001instructions for accessing subtitles in a language other than English are included on our board meetings web page as well as in the description below descrip a Contin all right good evening and welcome to the Ross Valley School District Board of trusty regular meeting today is January 29th 2025 and I am calling our meeting to order at 6:02 uh we have four trustees present in person at the Ross Valley School District office at 100 Shaw Drive in Sano myself Rachel lwac Daniel Cassidy Brian O'Neal and Chris L cob trusty Hamilton is not in attendance tonight we also have cabinet members present we have uh superintendent Tyler CRA Eric seel and Chris Carson our meetings being live streamed via YouTube and the links on our website and on the agenda there is a 60-second delay between the
002meeting and the YouTube live stream an audio recording of the meeting will be made available to the public on our district website within 72 hours of the meeting um and so with that I will move along with our agenda the first item is closed session um I'm going to identify the items on our closed session um we have conference with legal council anticipated litigation significant exposure to litigation pursuing to government code 549 569 subdivision D2 or3 special education program dispute one case student SSID 178 756 3438 um next item is public comment regarding items on the close session agenda we have no public here to comment and so I will recess as to close session at 6:03 e e e five and we are reconvening from Clos session at 6:33 um we are report out
003from close session is that um 4 to0 we approved the staff recommendation on special education program dispute case uh SSID 3438 and moving on procedural items we have the Pledge of Allegiance and Democratic reflection I don't have a democratic reflection today but I did just want to ackn the fact that it is um the start of Lunar New Year so I wanted to say um happy New Year to everyone who celebrates that and with that I will stand up and we can do our pledge if you would like to join me please feel free toag United States of America to the stand na indivisible andice for all um next item is adopting the agenda and time allocations did we have any changes to this any motions if not don't entertain a motion to adopt the
004agenda I will make a motion to adopt the agenda and time allocations as noted yeah I'll second it all right motion a second Chris hi Daniel hi Ryan hi and Rachel I all right we have our agenda approved moving on communication uh we have public comment regarding items not on the Open Session agenda do we have any comment cards for that no all right so we have no public comment for that um and then correspondence and communication to the board we do have some exchanges that are posted there hopefully everyone got a chance to see those um and the next item is e presentation Andor action items the first item there is the recommended approval of resolution 08 2425 declaring the district a sanctuary district and Tyler hand us over to you yeah great so
005this is a resolution declaring rvsd as a sanctuary district and this is um a very similar resolution that many uh boards are doing across Marin County we think this is really important um just to note that we have processes in place to support our families our undocumented families um across the district and there's support at our school sites with our principles and admin assistance if you need it and really um I see this one of our biggest roles as Educators is to protect students right to free public education and that goes for undocumented students as well so this resolution is just doubling down and reaffirming that um along with other boards in the county do we have any questions for Tyler do we have any public comment on this item no all right no questions
006no public comment um any other discussion on this item okay just just makes sense where we are today in other districts in Moran County doing the same so agre U I hope that we continue to get the state support behind this as I've seen other states starting to move in a very terrible Direction um and whatever we can do to make sure that our families are you know f safe and even have the ability to get resources from us U it's a no-brainer yeah I want to shout out nurse Megan and Emilia elari whove helped me put together one pager that gives um step-by-step support for our admin assistants and principles um and there's uh we have red cards that allow parents to understand their legal rights in these situations um that are available at
007our our off front offices um and there's also support at the school sites for Emergency Family Planning as well so um if anyone out there needs the support and just need to go to your school and it's there for you okay I'm going to go out the limb here and raise a very touchy question what are where do we stand and what can we do if by chance in the worst case scenarios um there's an infiltration of ice in our schools like what what are do we have do we have plans do we have an ability to react to that um have we thought about that as we put this could you talk a little bit about that absolutely so um if ice um and this is a similar procedure many districts are taking across
008the county if ice comes on campus the first step that any teacher principal or admin assistant has is call me directly um and then gather badge number information um all the information from the team at ice and then I would come I would have legal counsel on the phone we would discuss the issues with ice um if there weren't a warrant or exent circumstances um that'd be turned away if there was a warrant or exent circumstances by law we would um allow them to to do their job well I appreciate this being prepared so thank you thank you I think it's important that the children are and their families are feel safe coming to school absolutely that's the whole thing right schools should be safe places for all of our students if there's no further
009discussion I will entertain a motion on this resolution so I'll make a motion to recommend that the Board of Trustees approve resolution 08 24 25 declaring District as a sanctuary District have a motion a second a second all right Danel all Chris I I and Rachel I all right so thank you for br that together the next item is Staff presentation on reading instruction in rbsd great and we're going to have a wonderful instructional coach and rvta member um present about a reading program Molina olenberger hi is it do we is it do we stand do we sit what happens whever you you're comfortable I'm more comfortable standing okay so hi I'm Molina olenberger I'm the instructional coach um across the four Elementary sites and before that I taught for second third grade at White
010Thomas for 13 years um so today we're going to be talking a little bit about Ela uh and rvsd basically where we've been and where we're heading okay am I using the right thing might need to be turned on I love it when it's not just me did you do that I did could you just explain in relation how you are related to Julia in in the instructional yes so Julia wott is also the director of curriculum along with assistant superintendent so I work directly under Julia wot um so I'll be presenting the first portion of well the majority of this presentation and then she'll be coming in at the end to talk a little bit about reading screeners so before we get started into Ela and where Ross Valley has been and where we're
011going I wanted to thank you we just changed that no I didn't I think you made it oh I didn't touch anything was it AI great okay at any rate I think it's important to ground ourselves in the research because this is what has uh driven hi this is what has driven the changes and the shifts that we have made in Reading instruction so first and foremost I'd like to nerd out on this okay so our brain is hardwired for oral language So speaking is a natural occurr in the brain reading is not in order to learn to read you have to rewire the brain so your frontal loobe is that's your phonological processor that's where that's located so that's what um where the oral speaking listening comes from all the way in the back
012the cital Lo that's your orthographic processor that's your print where ability to print so you literally have to connect both sides of the brain in order to learn to read okay so it's not a natural process um next slide they took away my okay um so leading into the simple view of reading so taking all of this brain research and on reading and Distilling it down in its simplest form right so we have word recognition and language comprehension and the two of those make up reading comprehension and reading comprehension is the ultimate goal of reading right next slide okay so just to illustrate this point okay if you have notice that there is a multiplication symbol and not an addition symbol in between word recognition and language comprehension so if you have no word recognition
013but you do have language comprehension we're not reading the result is not reading vice versa if you have word recognition but no language comprehension the result is also so not reading if there are impairments in word recognition so that's what that 0 five stands for and language but you do have language comprehension there are impairments in overall reading and if there are impairments in both there are impairments in reading comprehension so we must have word recognition combined with language comprehension in order to get the result of reading comprehension the ultimate goal of reading so to take that simple view of reading and really draw it out we have if you think of reading happening in the brain you can think of the language comprehension and word recognition being two strands of a rope that twist
014and combined um to make one rope which is reading okay um so as word recognition which includes phonological awareness decoding sight Rec site word recognition as that becomes increasingly automatic you're moving more towards skilled reading and at the same time as language comprehension becomes increasingly strategic um you these two strands of the Rope combine to get skilled reading next slide and something that I wanted to really put a fine point on is that in order for reading to be fluid and ultimately to get reading comprehension as I said before that is the ultimate goal decoding the decoding process has to be so automatic that the reader can devote most of their attention to comprehension so all of this research um our teachers are very familiar with um the last few years we've spent doing providing
015PD in the science of reading um and just to backpedal a little bit um if you've heard of the science of reading what that really refers to is a body of research that has existed for decades and continues to evolve to um to emphasize the best practices in teaching reading and so in the last few years and for some teachers even more than that um but as a Ross Valley School District the last few years we've been really focusing on building background with the science of reading and how people learn to read next slide so with all that being said here are some specific steps that we have taken towards um in Ross Valley towards alignment with the science of reading research one thing I want to point out is that we have always had
016a skills-based uh structured skills-based approach through for phonics through our foundations program and in the recent years we have amped up our um professional development around the usage of foundations for our um skills we've also increased an emphasis on bmic awareness uh we have the program called hegerty um as I said before we've retrained teachers on our pH phonics program foundations we've transitioned to using decodable books in the primary grades um as opposed to leveled readers and we've also begun to implement common assessments that are better targeted to instruction to individual students needs and the examples are um esgi in the primary grades dibles reading screener in kindergarten through second grade and I ready k through 5 um so this is a little timeline about where we've been right um so in the spring of
0172023 we gathered a working group that consisted of teachers uh classroom teachers uh special ed teachers um interventionists and administrators uh and this working group worked to establish our core beliefs um these became our guiding principles for ELA instruction and they also um gave us our lens for every step that we've taken along the way since so from there in the spring of 2024 we engaged in a curriculum review we actually reviewed six curriculum with our six curricula with our uh pilot team um and from that six we whittel it down to four that we were interested in really looking into and hearing from the Reps from those companies and from those we selected two programs to Pilot this school year in the fall our pilot teachers um some of who are here in this
018room our pilot teachers uh piloted The Benchmark Advance program um and this involved um training watching demo lessons of the program we conducted classroom observations um and completed at the end of our pilot a thorough evaluation and review that connects back to our core beliefs in the spring we are going to Pilot El education we'll follow a very similar process where we will have our training um it's coming up in the next coming weeks um we will be actually the difference here is that we are going to be piloting alongside larksburg qua Madera who has selected elel also for their pilot and so we're kind of harnessing the power of the two school districts to um pilot this program um and we will conduct a curriculum review at the end of this pilot in the
019spring April end of April early May um just as we did before using the same lens that we used uh to review The Benchmark Advance um curriculum next slide who has this remote thank you for the best just like shouting into the okay um so a little overview overview about the Benchmark Advan curriculum um what the our pilot team determined as the standouts when we reviewed and decided ultimately to select it to Pilot um is that it is science of reading aligned um it's based in current research on how children learn to read um it emphasizes critical components like phonological awareness phonics fluency and vocabulary development there's a Content Rich it is a content-rich curriculum um it allows um the units build upon each other um in order to build knowledge that spans across various
020subjects there's also vertical alignment from kindergarten up to uh fifth grade will actually be on because the curriculum goes beyond fifth grade but we only are implementing it through fifth grade um and so there's vertical alignment of Concepts and skills that are progressively taught across grade levels um ensuring that students build upon prior knowledge um it's also a multi-sensory approach um there is embedded differentiation support and um the assessment is data driven um and drives instruction so um after reviewing after our pilot team reviewed the Benchmark Advance program I just wanted to kind of point out some key takeaways it was actually a quite lengthy evaluation um but I didn't want to go over every single detail so here's some key points from our pilot team about the strengths and weaknesses of the program so
021some strengths was the text centered reading that um the how it build the knowledge builds upon itself across grades um and then also the response to text was very strong in supporting students and teaching students how to respond to text some weaknesses on the program uh were the writing instruction um our teachers found lacking and Scaffolding they really needed to supplement it quite a bit in order for students to feel successful and there was also a lack in uh teaching of craft of writing as well as choice of topics and then overall teacher usability was um was marked low for this program next slide so next up is elel education we're going to start our launch training in a couple weeks and then teachers are going to officially start teaching it in the classroom the
022week after um Mid Winter Break um so some standouts of the program um as far as we see so far is the the content-rich texts um El education uses um authentic trade books as their Mentor texts so that was a standout for us um and there are real world texts across various subjects like social studies science um to and they build substantial knowledge and engage students it is also science of reading based um I don't think you're going to see any curriculum these days that doesn't say it's science of reading based right um it has a focus on Collaborative Learning giving students opportunities to collaborate with each other engage in discussions and engage in group projects thank you or hey to the rescue always um there are performance tasks tied to every unit of study
023every unit um that the students work towards um there is character development embedded as a matter of fact some schools um well as a matter of fact Manor School um implemented uh the El education character development um portion so some schools actually just use it just for the character development there's differentiation embedded and a strong focus on family engagement connecting what is being learned in the classroom to home I kind of likeed saying next slide honestly um so how does coaching fit in with all of this work um so as a coach must much like any of us in our professions right I wear many hats one is supporting of the ELA pilot and facilitating pilot meetings um and as well as assisting teachers with the implementation and the planning of um how to implement
024the program I also um am quite involved in assessment support as you saw we are implementing new assessment system such as I ready and dibles and I have a heavy hand in supporting with those both in administration but also in guidance and analyzing the data to inform instruction um also probably the most gratifying part of my job is the facilitation of our mtss and ELD team um since the since I started in this role Julia and I have worked to create a group of interventionists who are also ELD teachers at each site and create a group where we collaborate to focus on to lead intervention and support processes across the sites that are um consistent across sites uh we collab we meet monthly and collaborate on strategies to address um diverse student needs um and
025then also partnering with teachers oh yeah I'm also an instructional coach so um engaging with teachers um also differentiating how what based on what teachers need we uh it may look like co-planning lessons with teachers modeling structured literacy strategies um and delivering targeted professional development among other things so now I'm going to pass it off to Julia who is going to talk a little bit more about another next step I talked about our pilot next steps but there's also some next steps involving reading screener implementation thank you Molina and just before I talk about the reading screener just need to say I don't know where we would be in Ross Valley without Molina like her work you can tell she is such an extraordinary expert and worked so closely with teachers and um really is
026kind of like the glue that is holding a lot of things together um definitely many many hats and really having an impact really incredible thank you appreciate that yeah um so just the reading screener boss Valley is ahead of the game next year is the first year that um all districts in in California need to have a reading screener in place it's really a reading difficulty screener in place for grades K through two we're in our I guess it's our first year of K2 we started piloting last year but now we're we're in a full pilot of um mclass which is um a collaboration with amplify and dibles 8 um and uh May maybe 16 different screeners were brought to the state all wanting to be approved and only four were approved and one of
027those is the one that we're currently using the only other one we're really considering is the one there at the bottom multitudes we actually had Eric was super involved in some piloting with a couple of our sites of multitudes um one of the big differences between the two screeners is that multitudes is free um and so that's one reason to consider it it's also it takes about 15ish minutes per kid whereas the um amplify uh M class is more like sevenish minutes so that's a little bit of a drawback and the um M Class screener is something that we administer three times a year which we like because we're seeing the progress that students are making um and multitudes is at at least for right now once a year but we will this year be
028adopting a raing screener there's a um kind of openhouse at mcoe coming up in March where we're going to have a team Molina included in some of our intervention teachers going taking a little bit of a deeper look and making some decisions around there there are some new requirements um we will in future need to notify parents that we will be screening kids and then within I think it's 45 days we need to provide parents with the assessment results um so just kind of super proud that we're ahead of the game and that's due to our amazing teachers our intervention teachers who were like really on top of it and with Molina's support so yeah that's a lot of information about reading instruction I mean it's it's been a big shift for a lot of
029districts and a heavy lift for a lot of districts and I'm really really proud of where we are right now in our district with this we're actually as I have these meetings know with all the folks that do my job in the county um we're kind of ahead of the game and we have amazing teachers who are piloting um and really helping us figure this out a couple things I want to pinpoint first of all I want to thank Julia for her leadership with this I think this is one of the Str strength areas of the district is our teaching and learning um and this probably the most important thing in our district is the teaching learning so big kudos to you and your leadership also want to note that Molina is a prime example
030of the quality of the teachers that we have across the district so when we're talking about things like a parcel tax and other issues Molina olenberger is a representation of the quality of the the teachers that we have across the district and I thank you for your leadership with with our teachers and then the other thing I want to talk about is a lot of this work that you're seeing this transition is a way to better support dyslexic students so I know in our some of our special education conversations that we've had um dyslexia is a topic of conversation and a topic of Need for um better support for our students and the more structured reading program the universal screeners the professional development the work that our teachers are doing is all kind of targeted
031at making sure students who do struggle with reading have a little bit more structure around how they're taught um and that we identify as a as a system when students are struggling so we can get them additional support can I ask a question yeah is dyslexia increasing across this age group like are we just more aware of it now and so we're we're trying to combat it sooner yeah I don't think it's I don't think it's increasing I think it's a greater awareness and and that's why the state is really adamant about having these screeners and because you can really remediate early on and and move kids forward and then how does I ready play in or is I ready just another so I ready is a diagnostic assessment tool it gives a different kind
032of information actually goes deeper than um mass does in a lot of ways but it gives you just different information it's more comprehensive in terms of reading and math it's it's for math as well I noticed the parents can opt out is that something that is always going to be option once this mandate is rolled out or it's likely they parents can opt out of cast yeah they can opt out of the physical fitness assessment okay another question on The Benchmark Advance um the weaknesses that were noted is is there any way to help navigate those weaknesses and what you've done to sort of address those so that this becomes a really great like for everybody right right um and it should be noted that there's no am right um so um certainly any program
033that we adopt there may be areas that for example Benchmark Advance maybe may have an area so we may need to look into if Benchmark was the program that we decided to adopt how would we supplement writing right right yeah and so that would be a big question so you would look to probably supplement those areas where it would okay that's great yeah once you um once you guys have Tri both of them I guess um what what's the process for choosing how is that going to come about so after the piloted Benchmark Molina took the team through a really comprehensive and indepth process where using um criteria that comes from the state and that comes from the reading league and that comes from our own um criteria for a reading program we did a
034whole analysis we actually have quantitative data around that and then we'll go through the same process with El education and at that point we'll start talking about you know the relative Merit merits of each program and at the end of this year we may decide to move forward with one of those programs or we may decide that we want to continue piloting we we're very much um we don't want to move forward with the program until we know that it's the right program for us and so we are going to take our time because it's super important you tend to stay with one of these programs for you know a decade or so and um we want to make sure we get it right formally the committee would make a recommendation to the board and
035the board would vote um at the end of the year to adopt or reject the um recommendation of the committee so you had initially selecting four of these to look at closer so would you if you didn't weren't satisfied with both of these at the end of all year assessments would you go to another one to try those or most likely and what's happening at the same time is that districts all over the state but particularly our our local Marin colleagues are also piloting and so we're learning about what's working what's not working hey you know maybe this program is worth the pr try you know I will say no one is is landing yet on a program and saying it has it takes all the boxes it's really not going to happen and so
036a lot of it is knowing who we are as a district and where our strengths lie and what we need I mean we've got really talented teachers um and so it's figuring out that's why you want that kind of District lens that we co-developed of here's how we find the program that we need it's a lot of work our pilot team is amazing and learning a brand new program on top of everything else that they're doing and then doing that twice in one year is a huge and heavy so big big big thank you to that do we have any more questions if not I was going to go to public comment on this topic do we have any public comment on this item all right seeing public comment do we have any further discussion
037from the board here great yeah I love these presentations yeah thank you for your hard work and the teachers too because I know that's not easy so thank you all right moving on um the next item we have is um recommended approval of the annual audit report for the 20123 24 school year and I'm going to invite up Steven roach who is the CPA Steven roach it's actually his firm and so um Mr roach is gonna talk about the audit report this even good evening I'm going to go through here rather quickly but I'll I'll be happy to stick around as long as you like to talk about the audit report tonight uh page one of the audit report is the independent Auditor's opinion on the financial statements and just as you've had in the
038prior year you had an unmodified opinion on the primary government which is the Ross Valley School District and an adverse opinion on the component unit which deals with the fact that we do not disclose information regarding your foundation uh basically a lot of your districts in the county have the same same exact opinion because they don't present their foundations the reports as well well has no significant impact on anything as far as Bond ratings or anything like that so it's nothing to worry about uh I'm going to skip over all of the financial information and the reason why I'm going to do that is that there were no significant audit adjustments that were made to any of your books so it's basically the same information that you approved back in September as part of your
039un audited actuals if you go back to page 73 just point out a few items and that's in the actual hard copy I don't know if that corresponds to your uh your PDF copy this on your computer or not but page 73 is the schedule of financial Trends and Analysis and this shows um combined financial information of the cafeteria fund deferred maintenance fund and general fund which are combined for financial reporting purposes in accordance with gby statement 54 so this shows it for the financial information for the past three fiscal years as well as the 2425 budget uh just a few items I'm going to point out if you go down five rows from the top you'll see that uh the change in fund balance in the two previous years uh you had uh increases
040or operating surpluses in excess of $2 million in each of those years and this past year there was a operating deficit of 631 th000 and a lot of that's dealing with the fact that in the previous couple years you've had a significant amount of money uh from the federal programs that came out about with covid at this point most of that money is going away so you're not going to have that big buffer of money that you can charge to Federal programs uh next year it looks like there's a decrease also in I fully expect that to be the casee cuz now you don't have those funds uh one thing you'll want to do going forward is you want to be very conservative on your budgeting because you do have kind of a different scenario
041going on uh I also have some concerns I'm not sure how how things will be affected you guys are basic Aid currently but you guys kind of go in and out of basic Aid and uh with all the fires and everything else going on down in the state that's going to reduce a lot of the lcff funding that's taken care of by property taxes in certain areas so that difference is going to be made up with State contributions and the states already not in the best fiscal shape as well so I would just uh recommend that you're very very conservative in your budgeting at least for the next year see until we kind of see where things pan out uh if you go down the center of the page you'll see total longterm liabilities for
042the 23 24 year the district ended with $62.8 million of that amount that consist of about $41 million of General obligation Bond debt which is basically financed by the property taxpayers within the the district and the other portion is predominantly $20 million of net pension liability and that debt is service by the sturge and Purge contributions on an annual basis it's not something you can pay down in advance it's just going to be your ongoing contributions so overall you don't really have a substantial amount of debt at all in the general fund and that's that's very good for a district especially with the the budget being affected by all the different things going on currently uh next I'm going to have you jump all the way back to page 92 uh this is the findings
043and question cost section and uh basically a number of districts especially in maren County did not actually uh implement this program during the past fiscal year so if you did not implement it we had to include a finding in there as a as a means of triggering the takeback of those funds back to the state uh this year you guys do have the program operating so this should go away um there's not anything specific other than the fact that you did not operate the program is why you have a finding in this report uh last year there was one comment that we had and uh it was fully implemented so overall that's what you want to see if we bring something to your attention you want to see that it's being implemented that's all we
044can really hope for so other than that I'd say it's a a positive report but uh you do need to really look at the budget going forward and just be very conservative in all your budgeting and your financial decisions until we kind of see what's going on any questions about anything in particular I just had when I read this I had a quick question the non-compliance material to finance statements noted is Mark yes yes and that deals with this finding here uh because you have an amount of $268,000 that's going back to the stage we have to identify that in that because it's material to the financial statements I see so that that's the only reason why that's in there okay thank you any other questions that was my only question from reviewing it can
045me just say again thank you to Stephen for all of his hard work on this because putting together these audit reports and working with districts it's it can be challenging especially with smaller districts and so thank you I appreciate it I like say the audit once again went very smooth everyone in their staff was very helpful and just as they have been in PRI years so can you give me just a quick um like when you say budget conservatively M can you talk me through what that might mean well I I wouldn't include anything in the budget as far as being too optimistic about growing Ada it sounds like you guys have uh some declining so that's one of the key things for a district is uh if you budget too high on your Ada
046let's say you might budget an additional teacher in in anticipation that you're going to have that and if you don't actually get that teacher then you know that's money that's going out and you're not getting funding currently you guys are basic a you're going to get the same amount regardless so you just want to be careful on that everything you do just you just need to look at it I mean before obligating yourself to some something that's going to be a long-term debt item that you have to make annual payments each year going forward you know you shouldn't be doing it optimistically hoping that there's going to be a large influx of ADA or something coming on the right appreciate that do any other questions um do we have any public comment on this agenda
047item all right so um if you would like to come up and take a seat here and then let us know your name and affiliation so people listening know who's talking sure sure and then you have three minutes um you'll get an warning when you have 30 seconds left oh perfect don't take that long just just so everybody understands um public comment you're allowed to speak to us but we not we are not allowed to interact or respond so uh Kevin Curtis from San atelo and uh thank you all of you for for working so hard on this and thank you to uh stepen roach for all many years many years of service uh well and it sounds like you just gave a an additional positive uh uh certification to the budget school budget which
048also seems to have had a certification as a positive from the Marine County Board of Education that if I understood Rachel has uh received from the county uh and so what I would imagine that means is that the certified budget means that this year as well as the next two years are comfortable with the ideas of which uh we are spending going forward so that would mean in my mind that a parcel tax would then have some additional considerations as I've mentioned online if you follow next door in the realm uh which follows and of course this is a problem with local government versus educational government where there really are a lot of State separations you don't really have too many ways in which you can work together however you should be able to understand
049which uh the either or other is doing in uh in town in Sano as well as faira you have currently uh 990 in s SoMo and 490 or so in Fairfax units coming in uh those housing units each one of them would participate in the partial tax as well as any new students as part of those families moving into those housing units so i' would ask that when you are considering I may have missed this portion of the meeting of the parcel tax information but uh I would ask that you uh consider a calculation in decisions for the partial tax that include the new housing that may be coming into the area into the district borders um if you have currently a a a fiscal year positive general fund balance as Steve Rich has recommended
050and then also uh perhaps even with the teachers uh requiring an up to 1 million perhaps uh salary raise this year next year they out of the budget then uh it sounds like you have that already in the unrestricted funds thank you 30 30 seconds 30 seconds uh and I would just ask that you calculate that into your discussions when you have them thank you thank you and just a reminder right now we're talking about the uh audit findings so if your comment is about audit findings um feel free to make your public comments now if your comments are regarding the partial tax that's coming up in a couple items so feel free to take stand if you like hi good evening Todd Greenberg here from Fairfax nice to be with all of you I
051um appreciate how uh well done the meeting minutes AR in comparison to it's easy to follow along to uh was said and what was done oh thank you U that that being said um uh I also appreciate a more detailed audit report than we get uh in Fairfax uh and I just want to ask uh this may be out of the realm of what his engagement is but um uh are you able or has anyone here considered having Mr roach if I've got his name correct um interact with Chris Carson your Chief business official to look at ways to optimize uh not present to you what the scenarios are not just in a group of numbers but graphically for hey this is the range of where we could be so that you could easily along
052the lines of uh data presentation Edmond tufty is the Guru at this so you could easily see not just in a bunch of numbers where your decisions would lead and have some probability Factor rather than just receiving a report we received the report and some people are better at numbers than others some people are more visual I I I don't know if he's able to interact with if Chris does that on his own but that's my suggestion related to this I think might pull out a little bit more value from the knowledge that he likely has from interacting with so many different jurisdictions that might be helpful here thank you I would say one thing about that is we deal typically historically based on the items of the past that have already transpired uh if
053you are interested in something like that there's probably different organizations that would be better suited as far as going budget projections uh there's a lot of Consultants throughout California uh School services or different different type of depending what you're looking at but there are different people that would be more in tune with budgeting give forecasting different things like that than I all right do we have any additional public comments hey uh PJ Feer Manor parent um like the audit report as well um as well put together gone through uh many years of them so it's not surprising to get the advice of budget conservatively which is a consistent theme and not surprising um accountants I'm a lawyer I also tell everybody to be um risk averse but you know just want to give the perspective
054that this is the same advice understandably given to the school district during the years where it was accumulating a large reserve and consistently having budget surpluses and I know Chris is presenting on the governor's uh January uh budget update but the budget for B on my review and and the and that report was we should be cautiously optimistic specifically for K12 education funding uh B improving so just don't you know I would also be curious if Mr roach thinks that the budgeting process has been consistently conservative in a way that he would recommend given that we are having good reports and this isn't necessarily A Cause to budget more conservatively as opposed to um more aggressively or optimistically thank you do we have any additional public comments all right see n I'll bring it back
055to the board for discussion do we have any other comments up here or I to mention about this topic I think the public comments are you know very interesting you know we can always wrap our heads around how to look at things differently and open our minds about how to capture the full picture right and how to present it how to present it um always looking for ways to better ourselves right um just want to put that out there um I'm a former eny person and to have an audit that is so easily readable is a is a is a feat so I commend you on that I appreciate it when I when I opened it up I had that dread that came back over me and I started to read it and thought wow
056this is pretty straightforward so thank you I'm pretty simp uh it was not easy for me to read just for the record this is foreign so thank you for well my day job is working for Auditors so I'm really familiar with seeing audit reports I don't usually see school district ones we do other government agencies but um I I appreciate how easy and straightforward it is it's very familiar um but I do appreciate um and in the information about the parts where like the El funding and how that has to be returned so that I I appreciate it having that extra background for that so thank you for that as well um and then thank you to Chris and all the staff who helped with the audit because I know that that's also a big
057lift to get all that information together every year absolutely um other than that I have nothing for them as one does anybody else want to say anything if not I will move to the next item we have to on this oh yeah sorry yeah skipped that part sorry um so uh it's recommended that the Board review and approve the annual District audit report for the 2023 24 school year do I have a motion on this item I will make a motion to recommend the approval of the annual audit report for the 20 324 school year okay so you're moving to approve it then okay all right do have a second yeah I'll second it right Motion in a second Chris I Daniel hi Ryan hi and Rachel I thank you for that thank you for
058noticing that I thank you very much all right thank you Stephen thanks Stephen right yeah so just I wanted a quick reminder we have comment cards in the hall if you want to make public comment it's easiest if you get those ahead of us ahead in time so we can get him submitted to Teresa so we have a flow going may' be a lot smoother and faster yellow if it's a about the public heing parcel tax and blue if it's anything else okay thank you Joseph the yeah right out the if you want to make a public comment during the public hearing section on the paral tax and blue if it's anything else thank you no no okay uh our next item is the governor's proposed 2526 budget update and so thank you for the
059opportunity to discuss the uh Governor's January budget proposal and as part of the uh Governor's as part of the state budget the governor is obligated to provide a proposed budget for the coming fiscal year in January and he would do that again in May and then there would be a budget adoption by the state in June and so this is the very first um budget proposal that his has provided and so what we'll be doing tonight is just going through the overall uh state and federal budget very quickly very high level overview uh and then uh lcff um revenues and programs that are coming in and just kind of what our next steps are um so when looking at the the governor's budget he released the budget at one of the most difficult times in
060in the state and that has to do with all of the fires in Southern California and what has happened is that they have also delayed the implementation or delayed the requirement for the um filing of taxes by April 15th which is what they did several years ago and that then created a fiscal crisis at the state level last year and so we're kind of entering that type of phase again and so it's this is one of those um f um difficult times that we have to deal with uh another natural disaster um when looking at the the state budget the other thing that's of of note that's really important is that when looking at the current year lcf revenues they've actually under appropriated the current year lcff revenues and under proposition 98 they're supposed to
061provide the full amount and so that they are providing some of those dollars so it's that's just something to keep an eye on as we move forward um and and then as we look um the the governor is really looking to um provide uh lots of dollars under proposition 98 for other highquality education programs and so we'll get into that as we move forward um as we looked at the the California um situation and also at the federal level what we're seeing is that the housing market has slowed down a lot in many areas in Marine County it may not be quite as bad as other areas but we have the the risks related to the Federal Reserve and I believe that the the Federal Reserve um did not drop those rates again today so
062that that does impact us um and so that helps lead to further economic uncertainty what is of what is good in looking at the governor's budget proposal is he is projecting his budget plus of $177 billion and so that is currently before anything happens at the federal level and that allows him to be able to put dollars back into that rainy day fund for education and that rainy day fund that for Education was set up many years ago and slowly built up and last year it we really felt the impact of it because what it did is it allowed the state to not make as drastic a Cuts in education as they would have needed so that that's really important and so those are just some things to really keep an eye on and of
063course we also have um some issues with the tariffs uh that could potentially negatively impact California and obviously the immigration policy when looking at our lcff uh and all of our programs um our lcff dollars those are the dollars that we receive for our attendance and for the students coming to school school every day in the current year we are going to be paid based upon our property taxes but next year we'll flip right back into lcff so everything we're talking about is really critical and will impact our revenues and what is of note if you look towards the left you'll see the lcff base Grant we're seeing a 2.43% increase in the estimated Cola um that is a drop from our first interim uh when we were looking at a 2 93% col so
064there's roughly a half a percent drop and the other thing that is is critical is that this is an increase in per student funding and not in total revenues so because we're flipping from Community funding to state aid we do expect a drop in our total lcff revenues again so we won't feel a 2.43% increase but we will see it in our per student funding so I just want to point that out um another really important thing that is being implemented fully next year is the universal transitional kindergarten so what that means is that it will be a completely um full grade level just as every other grade in in education and so with that comes some additional requirements for Teacher credentialing uh and also some um class siiz ratios for adults to students and
065what that means is that we can have an average class size of 24 to1 but we can only have an average adult to to student ratio of 10:1 so really that's pushing your uh student to teach a ratio down to 20 to1 likely because what you would do is have a um an instructional Aid in the classroom at that time there is some question whether it will be fully funded um I was looking at the lcff calculator that was just put out by fmat and they did not put in the additional dollars for funding the the full implementation of TK and so that that's um one of those things that we just really need to keep an eye on because it's been although they've they've put it in as a proposal we're not certain full
066that it will be fully funded um there is a new um I'm sorry this is the learning recovery emergency block grant we currently have that and it was scheduled to be um fully spent out at the end of this year but they're also projecting to put in some additional dollars so these are onetime dollars that would come in um for pretty much any type of expense that you would need for learning recovery to help um uh instructional needs as a result of the covid shutdown I I don't know what those dollars are at this particular point there will be a a um a trailer Bill coming out in February and we'll start to understand the dollar amount another thing is that's coming out as a student support and professional development discretionary block grant and um
067this is something that I know that I I think Tyler and and uh Julia are excited about uh because it will provide some additional dollars that we can use um for supports for our our um teachers um and it's 1.8 uh billion dollars I'm not sure what it means all of these are proposals we don't know what they mean to the district just yet those will come out in the coming days uh another thing is again kind of going back to one of those earlier slides the governor is really trying to invest in literacy so he's also providing dollars for TK literacy and Mathematics coaches and um so those are again some things that I think Tyler and and Julia are excited about and so with that um and Oh I thought I had one
068additional slide there is an additional block gr that is being proposed um and that is also something that we don't know what the total dollar amount is and it's supposed to be something similar to the instructional materials and uh art and music block grant that we received several years ago so um that will be exciting to hear what those dollars look look like as they come out and in terms of our next steps what we'll be doing is um at our next board meeting I'm sorry at our meeting in March not our next one um we will be pres presenting our second interim budget and we'll be starting to implement some of these changes that we just talked about for example like the 2.43% cola Will Roll in and if we have information on some
069of those other programs we'll start to roll them into our um adopted or our second year of our multi-year projections and so we'll we'll deal with that uh and then in May the governor will be releasing his May uh revise and that generally comes out in miday and then the only problem with miday is that we have our our adopted budget hearing on June 4th so there's not a whole lot of time between that miday date and June 4th so what we'll be doing is just changes that are considered to be material within our budget um and then again our our board would adopt the budget on June 25th um and hopefully by June 30th or July 1st we would have a state adopted budget so that's really the next steps in terms of the
070state budget but overall it's good it's a good state budget it's optimistic but there's a lot of caution there because of the unknowns related to the fires and the federal government so those are things to just kind of wait and see and so with that I send it back to you for questions you might have I hate to sound like eore up here but the impact of the fires is dramatic to say the least um and the questioning around California being able to get the funding from the federal government that it needs to at least put a dent in some of the recovery efforts that they want to do is questionable right then you top that with the freeze that has currently been held up in federal court but it's going to be fought and
071that freeze will eventually affect school children so I'm trying to I'm trying to wrap my head around where's the optimism um I'm just so conservative when it comes to living daily what I'm getting in my own job and seeing what can happen and what actually is going to happen and I just want to make sure that we're prepared for that um and I just want to get your take you know as someone who really gets into these numbers year after year do you think this is a game Cher this new Administration um for our governor um I think for example related to the the fires the fires are going to have a tremendous impact upon California's overall state budget LA county is the single largest county in terms of population in the entire country and
072they lost tens of thousands of homes y so and you heard it tonight from our auditor be conservative budgeting and you're also seeing it again um when I was looking at the figat calculator this this afternoon where I didn't see the additional TK dollars exactly so you're seeing that level of conservativism and I think it has to be there because there there are many many risks to the state budget and the governor when he presented it to the uh publicly he talked about that $ 17 billion um net uh excess that they have but also cautioned because of the federal government and I think we need to take that seriously okay that's good to hear from your perspective thank you the um the tax extension deadline that they've done because of the fires is that
073that's specific to those counties correct yes it's it's specific to those areas but it affects the overall state budget yes does it affect our funding from the state or it can because for example two years ago Northern California had the same issue where we had lots of rain and flooding and so they delayed Northern California including the Bay Area in Marine County so we could have delayed our tax returns and many people and companies did what happened is the state went into the next year budget the 2013 24 budget year assuming certain things because um they didn't have the final numbers and what ended up happening is the tax revenues came in less than their assumptions and that's when they had to make midyear cuts and that's that's where that rainy day fund really helped
074uh school districts and so I anticipate that type of thing potentially being there again I hope and pray that that the county I'm sorry that the the state is more conservative this time um because LA County again is that it is the economic engine of of the state really other than the Bay Area um and so it can have a tremendous impact upon our our state resources and state revenues do we have any more questions for all right so I will um go out to public comment on this item agenda agenda item do I have any public comment on this specific one do you have any cards for this so no public coming on thank you Chris thank you Chris yeah just please state your name again just so people listening can hear thank you
075Kevin Curtis Sano yes yeah I think you just on great uh it's always tough when the budgets uh decision making timelines are not aligned with the state I completely understand if you're in a 25th of June and and there a May release and you're trying to decide in January EXC what to do turn up the volume there's no Amplified sound in here oh yeah sorry there's noi I'll speak up a little bit have speakers you know the problem is is that uh the the solution is that we don't really know as Chris had certainly mentioned but but the history may tell us that Gavin Nome has not diminished anything that he sent out in January by his May release and and and that's good news that's particularly for the question that you posed Chris which
076is a very valid question which is what may happen between now and then uh so uh the radiation find certainly as Chris had mentioned uh supplementing in the past but uh the the current release the the the the pre-release of the the budget has looked very good and uh it looks like full funding for TK up through uh 8th grade which is very good for Ross Valle schol district and uh that's all I have to say thanks thank you any additional public comment all right let's see this was just discussing information and a report so I will move on thank you Chris thanks Chris and the next item is uh H recommended acceptance of the prioritized budget cuts list from the budget advisory committee and District administration and that is going to be me as
077well and so um when we were looking at potential budget reductions one of the things that we implemented was a budget advisory committee and so what we'll be talking about this evening is is about the budget advisory committee the process that we uh took this year and and what we looked at and also what the cuts and priority order R um and so what I'd like to do is if you are a member of the budget committee and we have the list of parents trustees District staff partners whether you were certificated classified or Administration if you're in the room would you mind standing up I think it's really important and one that we recognize them but to understand the heavy lift that they were looking at in dealing with and so I want to say
078truly thank you to each and every one of them I know we've said it uh several times but we can't say it enough and so um again thank you to each and every one of them and what we did is we involved the entire Community we we looked at parents we tried to ensure and I'll go back to one slide we tried to ensure that we had parents at every single School site represented we tried to make sure we had trustees represented um and when talking about our district Partners you see that we have our Ross Valley Teachers Association and our California School Employees Association and we also had one unrepresented staff member of Teresa that was presentent along with our administrators um and so that all of the work that they did was really
079critical to the process um and so what we did last year we took a look at expenses Solly this year we started looking at revenues and there was kind of this Epiphany moment when looking at revenues I I've long talked about um districts and and where they're at in terms of um on a per student funding level and Tyler came in fresh set of eyes learning it listening to me and learning it on his own as well came up with this graph and I think it does Justice to um where we are are in terms of the districts in the county and it's not every District mind you but what it does show is that you there's this distinct line between basic Aid or Community funded districts and lcff districts and so um districts that
080are have high UND duplicated pupil counts are going to be higher on that lcff uh side in districts that have high property taxes are going to be high on the other side and then you have um four districts that are kind of going back and forth and we we happen to be one of those districts now we had never been a community funded District until the current year and um so that's important to note and when talking to the budget advisory committee what they were able to determine is that it's kind of a a r not kind of it is really a revenue issue but with that we still needed to look at expenses and so what we did is we took a look at where is it that we can cut and so we
081set a target for cutting of $500,000 um and and then what we started doing is providing a list to uh the committee for them to actually take a look at and that that list was put together by uh the administration all of the administrators including the the principles uh then we uh provided it to the budget advisory committee and asked them is there anything that you can think of related to this in addition and then we had what you call table talks over the course of the two um days and the the second one we really got into where we had a site administrator we made sure that we had certificated and classified staff and parents represented at every single table so that as they're talking they're hearing how these uh Cuts would impact the
082school sites because that's really important in making your decision at least how how you think that it um what you could would support more than others and then finally what we did is we provide the last day what we call a DOT exercise and what that did is allowed um the the U members of the committee to provide up to three different dots on the ones it it's kind of a bad thing thing you're selecting the ones that you think would be you could cut more than the others and so really that's what we were asking them to do is just give us their priority listing and so with that we did get a priority listing the one thing that is important to note that before we go on to the list and showing the
083the dots um is that when we when they Administration got the the votes we took a look at everything and we realized that some of the the bulk of the cuts were going to be in one School site so we took a look and had conversations with that site and so we did reprioritize just ever so slightly and you'll see that in our list and so as we as we go through um everything that's in green are things that we think that we could do um Within in the first year potentially and so those are your highest priorities and what you'll note is that for example guest support teachers received 32 dots um and even though we show PE teachers Elementary it was really PE Specialists they they received 12 dots and the reason that
084one is just the PE specialist is because that's a negotiated uh topic with rvta so we couldn't make that cut without going to the table to discuss it with rvta um in in terms of uh Tech platforms we didn't ask them to vote on that one because we were going to make those cuts already um and we have guiding Coalition up there with 10 dots and white Hill schedule reductions at three dots and this is kind of where we rep prioritized just a little bit so that we could get um up to the number you'll see the seventh seven period day had 18 dots and and we thought that that would have more of an impact on children in talking with the uh the principles at the site and so they they thought that they
085could do schedule reductions so was that given take and so as we move into the red those are kind of the the next line of cuts that we would potentially make if we have to make additional cuts and you see um things on there like um reductions in in the amount of dlight stip stiens the fifth grade instrumental music potentially up there with four dots um counseling services received only three um food and meetings too uh and then we get into the the ones that didn't receive too much um or any votes at all and so you'll see those uh moving forward and so just in the interest of transparency that was the the way the dot exercise came out we wanted to make sure that the input from the the entire Community Was Heard
086as we were presenting it this evening um and and so as we go forward um in terms of our proposed 25 26 cuts um we without a parcel tax we will likely have to make um the cuts that are in that green section and so they would impact our 25 26 um fiscal year and so that that's really important to know and as we move forward into 26 27 we would start looking at those others and you see those cuts there um and a lot of it has to do with um During the covid period we had the 275 student drop uh in enrollment at the impact on attendance and what what really masked that drop we would have felt it the second year under normal circumstances but the state um went and did the
087three-year averaging and so that really masked that drop of 275 children but we're we are at that point now where we're going to be impacted by those dollars um and and that drop in student attendance and so as we move forward they're they our needs to to impact directly programs if we don't if we're not able to get um uh additional dollars so and one thing I want to note on this is this is really to address the structure deficit this is not including any raises to CCA rbta or administrators so the working assumption in the budget and the working assumption with these Cuts is 0% yeah and so really what we're asking you tonight is just to accept the plan it doesn't mean that that we'll you're accepting the cuts at this point all
088of the cuts that we would be making we would be bringing back to you if we impacting people that type of thing and so it it's not accepting um the actual cuts at this time and so we'll continue with our budget process and um again the hope is that that we're able to um you know that the that the state budget is where they say and that we continue to receive increases both in our uh property taxes um as well as our colas with that said we are having a reduction in our overall revenue for next year is is the projection not an increase even with the 2.4% uh Cola there's going to be less Revenue next year than there is this year and it's approximately $400,000 so quick question on this list that we're
089looking at today and that we're um potentially accepting so if we accept this now you don't necessarily have to make these now but does this give you authorization to make them as needed in the future or how how does this work just technically I so what we would do is if we're if we have to actually lay people off there'll be agenda items where we would have to actually physically do that um and um we would be able to make some of these Cuts right now for example um we're already in the process of eliminating dollars in our budget related to the Tech um tech programs and so those are the types of things that you know we would just do on on the natural anyway so anything we can do um without having to
090come to the board we would actually do and then the items that we would formally need recognition from the board we would bring that like the seven period day in the 26 27 school year would be one that we would need to bring back as Personnel reductions yeah yeah CU I don't I want people to be able to weigh in on these things before and that's a big one that's a really big one especially like the music program in fifth grade those go back a couple sides those are really important no the other way sorry one more it's still this one right no the other the one there the two two dates one more there you go so this is kind of our plan of action um reducing class sections could be a natural attrition
091if someone retires um goes to another dist District we may not have to bring a personel action to the board on that one guest support teachers are essentially substitute teachers we can make that decision without bringing any any additional authorization to the board um where we start having a need for additional authorization from the board is in that 26 27 school year where we're talking about laying teachers off who are elective teachers um laying counselors off laying uh PE teachers off potentially that one there should be asteris next to next to because we would need to negotiate that with the Union um and then fifth grade instrumental music so the $500,000 in the potential in the 2526 is really kind of the easier ones to to do um and the 2627 would be more significant
092and we'd bring Personnel actions to the board to vote home from there thank you good question do we have any other questions up here CH or Tyler no okay um I will open it up for public comment on this specific agenda item only which is the list of the budget cuts so if you would like to make a public comment you have you can come over um have cards okay just state your name so people listening can hear I hope that's my name called um really couldn't hear um I was curious in looking at the Cuts if there could be a comparison to the administrative staff as opposed to our teachers because I always see the teachers that are paid the least to be the first ones cut and looking through the budget which I'll
093bring up later if the teachers are receiving approximately $10 million in your proposed budget and the administrative staff is receiving approximately $5 million in your proposed budget I think before any teachers are cut there should certainly be a cut in the over head which if a larger salary person lost 10% that could possibly save one teacher's position so I would like to see a comparative basis so we could actually make that comparison I don't think the teachers should be the ones to be cut thank you one thing that I'd like to remind the board of is can I sure we still go ahead I mean um is that this is kind of the uh last series of cuts uh our former superintendent Marcy Tran and Chris Carson have been cutting the budget since 2020 um
094slowly reducing things like uh HR administrators and other Personnel at the district office um so this really is not the first set of cuts we're bringing to the board this is kind of the final set of cuts that we're bringing to the board and that topic was something that we really discussed at length in the budget advisory committee the conversation around administrator Cuts great thank you hi Todd Greenberg again is this on is this on now on this way okay all right um along lines parallel to what Mr McIntosh just said um um uh I I have a comment but first I'd like to compliment everybody for actually considering Cuts because that's where things are going there's def it'ss around and the funding is uncertain I'm less optimistic than some people are about what kind
095of funding this state is going to have so that as I was indicating previously there need to be a range of plans not just one plan what are we going to do have a plan that contemplates multiple scenarios next Mr Macintosh was saying that administrators need to share in this too I I understand there's many complications of labor law and uh unions and different concerns but we're all in this together as a community and as a team and we're all here because of kids I don't know what the proper way is to explore this but I I would suggest that in addition to what Mr McIntosh commented on that administrators um are asked to participate and plan for any cuts in a way that they are comfortable with uh to the extent that that can
096happen but also I haven't heard any discussion of Merit that should be driving a lot of the decisions on what does and doesn't get cut both in terms of who is performing I understand there's Union considerations but who is actually providing the excellent teaching outcomes that the funding is going for why shouldn't we be allocating Capital based upon who is actually providing excellent teaching here rather than just looking at particular programs and then I don't know the answer to this one last question but since I was young music always was on The Chopping board now I'm not an accomplished musician but I would uh ask you why music should get cut thank you all right go ahead and come on um Kevin Sano uh I just urge the board to consider this uh Steven roach
097just certified you with a 20% 22% budget surplus and uh Chris Carson just mentioned that the state had provided funds from roughly 2020 to 2021 based on Ada at kind of a surplus based on whatever happens uh decrease or increase with your Ada and so that was great news so we've had great funding for a couple years and I think what he's saying is that uh things get hectic going forward based on the the current Ada but we got 60-ish 65 is Ada that we weren't expecting this year in pupils 10 NK this here or not as Chris is nodding and uh so so I would just say this that uh if we have a $ 30 million budget and or $30 million doish in revenues that 10% with the state limits being 3% 10%
098still puts us in a great position if we had a 22% budget current historically if we've had a 15 to 19% comfortable living in Ross Valley School District uh of of unrestricted funds in the in the reserve that you have plenty of room right now to move forward with at least a year and or two years in supplementing both the current you know no cuts of $500,000 and supporting that through the reserves as well as uh an additional two or 3% to teacher salaries if you're paying 2.51 now or 1.35 whatever it may be so I'd just like to say that it seems like it's there 3% should be the the point in which you start to to worry about and certainly Marine County Board of uh education is going to tell you with a
099two-year out uh you know uh report next year whether or not you're you're coming into that status or not we all have the understanding that there are many new homes and many new students coming into the district with the current sixth housing element with the uh State's housing El mandates down to sen onare facts so thank you good luck tough decisions do you have any other public comment so I will bring it back to the board for discussion comments or feedback and the many of the people are here the budget advisory committee it was a a wonderfully challenging experience right it was uh as soon as somebody one table is like yeah this is what we should do another table's like that's the worst idea ever we're like they're right um so it was a
100really challenging thing so thanks for everybody here and whoever is listening for participating in that um it's not easy everybody cares that's the wonderful thing about education in this community um so the the things that Chris outlined are the ones that the committee spoke on all right I was wondering I was wondering where you were going when you said it was wonderful because I was like that was one of the worst things I've had but it was a great Democratic you know the process Mr santui stands up like we can't get rid of zero period because it'll Crush our music department like oh we thought we solved it so I mean it was it was just great to have everybody's opinions in the room because it was it was important and you guys did a
101really good job from the first meeting the second meeting to get more people in the room right so it was um wonderfully challeng in experience it's definitely challenging yeah yeah I think I think most of the people I sat with at those tables the general feeling was none of these Cuts feel good we don't want to make any of these cuts for every single thing it was like well that one's terrible too we can't cut that so every single thing we were looking at felt like that and so I feel like at least these things are the least unpalatable I don't know just I don't like any of these Cuts but I know that that we have to do this this is part of our job as trustees is to look at these really terrible
102decisions and figure out what needs to to go if that's the case um this is I look at this and I I tell everybody I'm eating my own cooking my kids go here I I love our teachers our administrators it's like for me it's a perfect pot of soup and take the chicken out is it still chicken soup no someone's going to so anything you take out we're affecting the recipe and I think that leads into the next chapter of our meeting which is the things we've got to do to make sure that we don't see this I'm just kind of I think that's what stood out to me in the budget advisory committee process was that when we started looking at all of the options starting as far away from students as possible we
103found that really Marcy Tran and Chris Carson had done a phenomenal job really reducing far away from the classroom Unfortunately they did such a good job the rest of the things that we have to cut now are student facing um which makes Rachel's Point really cogent none of these cuts are ones that are palatable none of them are ones that we want to move forward with and in order to give our teachers raises we either need to increase revenues or we need to cut these first programs and I think the public comments about cutting going to the administrative side I think the transparency of what's already been done is very important that you've raised here tonight that there have been tremendous cuts on the administrative side um and yeah at some point you come for
104the bigger limbs unfortunately I think the process here is the most important part of this um this is my seventh year here and I've really had to watch these possible Cliffs coming and um I know you have probably the most difficult job in the entire Community when it comes to the moving Target it's like throwing darts at a at a swinging dart board um you know you can understand kind of where it's going to be but in actuality I can't count the number of meetings that we've had with one set of data only to come back two weeks later with an entirely new set of data and we're expecting you to actually prioritize put these things in in a form where we can eat it up and understand it in order to now look at
105the new menu when we come back two weeks later so I I I can't imagine how difficult that is I do thank you for actually being able to put it in bite-sized pieces for us to take at the moment um and this type of thing is most important to me because I always preach community and and truly you know most parents and most teachers and most community members they don't want to have anything to do with this because it's not a problem to them until it's a problem for them and so at that stage is when is when this type of community event Community event truly has to come and say it's kind of like I tell my kids if you don't vote you know you can't complain right that's what this is right it's
106not like we're hiding numbers in math it's math so bring it everybody in that wants to complain about it and have them sit down at these tables you're talking about and have them hear the other side of the arguments and then it starts to make sense and then they start to understand the weight of what's going on and then they start to be a community outreach in regard to the importance and so from a process standpoint I'm extremely proud of the turnout that we were able to get because we called it out hey this is coming either get involved or get out of the way because we're going to have to make decisions up here eventually and I also like it that this is not a decision this is a recommendation acceptance of priorities this
107is not anything that we're doing this is just you know this is getting your gear ready to go on on a trip you know it might rain so get your gear ready doesn't mean that you're going to need it and we don't know exactly where it's going to go but I I applaud the process I'm very proud of the work that you guys all did and that the community did to make that um happen yeah I really appreciated the people who are on the the budget advisory Comm committee I mean it was four meetings and it was a lot of hard work getting through all that like to understand the budget in the beginning and then to like look at the list and really go deep onto the impact that it would have to our
108teachers our students to the schools so um it was a lot of work and I'm very grateful that people were able to step in um and yes uh looks like we do have to vote on this one so I don't know if you guys are done discussing or having any further comments not I will entertain a motion on this yeah I'll recommend that um we accept the prioritized budget cuts list from the budget advisory committee and the District administration I will second it so Dani I Rachel I Chris I and Ryan I all right so we have approv that are accepted to list we take a break H we take a break yeah you want to take a break okay so we will take a quick pause for the public hearing okay just remind if
109you're going to make public comment fill out a yellow card and give it to Teresa there's yellow cards right out front if you'd like to make e e e all okay so thank you we are back from our quick Break um our next item on the agenda is public hearing regarding proposed education parcel tax on the May 6 2025 meil ballot election so for this I have to read a script so bear with me um pursuant to government code section 50077 notice is hereby given this public hearing has been called for the adoption of resolution 0924 25 a resolution of the Board of Trustees of the Ross Valley School District of the county of Marin State of California calling a mailed ballot special election for approval of an educational partial tax establishing specifications of the
110election order and requesting consolidation with other elections occurring on May 6th 2025 I now call our public hearing open it's 8:17 so um I have have a list of comment cards here so I'll go through these and if at the end there's people who would like to give public comment and we do not have time you may come up at the end just raise your hand um and then I have four seats here so each of you can come and sit I'll call up four people at a time so we can get through it faster um we have 16 here is everyone okay if we did three minutes a card okay so it's a little bit over 45 minutes which is what we have allotted for this thing so everyone will get three minutes you
111will have a 30 second warning when your time is almost up um and it needs to be on this specific topic then yeah was just Chris are you going to be taking time okay thank you thank you Chris and then um is there anything I'm forgetting okay so I think that's everything so I've got um Meredith Woodward Autumn arry and Alicia ciz too and then I've got uh Michael yes thank you work my handwriting am I going first y sorry I called you first hi my name is Meredith wward and I work in student services I know tonight that you're going to hear a great deal about our District's in ability to attract and retain staff in general but I'd like to speak more specifically about our challenge to fill special education for positions for
112our students with the highest needs over the past few years years we've had numerous open positions in special education ranging from teachers to 1 to one8 because we have the lowest funding formula in the county we are unable to attract and retain staff for our most vulnerable students these These are students that need consistency but face a revolving door of agency hires that often do not last a full school year added to this is a nationwide shortage of special education teachers without an increase in PayPal packages we simply cannot compete most importantly for taxpayers this is investment in their property the state budget cuts to programs and staff that we are facing should the proposed parcel tax not pass will create even more losses in staff and enrollment leading to less value placed in our
113schools and diminished property values down the line this tax does not have an impact on senior citizens and a is a fair progressive tax based on property size our community needs Ross Valley Schools to be the best they can be thank you for your time and consideration thank you thank you thank you um for allowing me to speak twice Michael McIntosh and on this issue I do want to bring a couple figures so what I see from your budget you have revenue of approximately $29 million you have expenditures of approximately 31 you're looking at an operational deficit of 1.4 the teacher salaries on your proposed budget come in at $1,331 th000 and the supervisors and administrators come in at 5, 375,000 so basically the teachers are getting onethird of the general budget and the administration
114and supervisors are getting one sixth of the budget which I think is proportionally incorrect but the tax that you presented here here will fail not only is it a heavy lift at your 2/3 but the reason it will fail is because you've left it to be subjective you have not said the square footage by plat map you've not covered which buildings so will the square footage be for each floor of a building to the square footage of the Interior Space will it include an Adu will it include any sort of outst structure or garage and have you considered that disproportionately this will affect renters probably the most because this is going to burden their small little rents that they're going to have to pay it would be much more fair if this was done either
115by a square footage on a plat map so you could say the building's footprint or by the size of the parcel so as somebody who has a large piece of property I think it would certainly be more fair to the community to charge me by the size of the property and not by the square footage nor would I want the school district to now waste all kinds of money to start figuring out well should we include this little building should it be over 100 square ft should be under 200 square ft should we include an Adu or what about deed restricted properties so things that are supposed to be affordable how will that be included so again I think this is premature and if you do want to go for a square footage tax I
116encourage you to be very transparent not that this is opaque but to really help people understand so you can even budget a correct number of what buildings will include and then is there a peels process what if a building is later torn down and rebuilt or a building is removed okay or there's a fire so how is this going to affect the budget again if you stick with either a plat or if you stick with a parcel I think you'll have a better opportunity thank you hello I'm autum M I'm one of the counselors at whill middle and I'm actually here today to speak on behalf of our Educators at whill so we the educators of whill Middle School are writing to express our strong support and a parcel tax increase as Educators we witness
117firsthand the critical role that adequate funding plays in supporting our students success and wellbeing this increased parcel tax will enable us to continue offering essential resources including a vibrant Arts and Music program additional classroom support and Mental Health Services these services are vital in helping our students navigate the the pressures of adolescence manage academic stress and promote their social and emotional development combined with rigorous academic instruction from our highly qualified teachers these resources help us maintain the high standards of Education that have earned we till middle school the distinction of being a school to watch however if this parcel tax does not pass these vital programs will be at risk of being cut additionally we will continue to face the detrimental effects of high turnover rates among staff and the negative impact this has on
118our students mental health as well as our Educators these challenges not only affect our staff but they directly hinder our students ability to thrive in a stable and supportive learning environment we as the Educators at White Hill are committed to advocating for the passage of this tax and are eager to collaborate with students families and neighbors to ensure they understand how funding will directly benefit our students and the broader School Community we look forward to working together to secure a positive future for our students and you'll find that this letter is signed by all the teachers that window thank [Applause] you I have a request so for people in the audience if we could refrain from clapping I I appreciate the support but we're trying if we want to get everyone to get a chance
119to speak and would like to keep it just tight timing wise so I understand the support we can do it all at the end I think that would be great but I just want to make sure that we're respecting everyone's time because I know you're all here and you have school tomorrow a lot of you so just gonna put that request out there my name is Alisia Solis and I'm the school psychologist at White Hill and I'm also um really close colleagues with Autumn so we came up here together as a pair um so I wanted to share more about the vital importance of having a strong counseling support team at the Middle School counseling services are listed as something that could be cut in the second round if the parcel tax does not pass
120not only does white Hill provide excellent academic experiences but is because of the direct intentional support of our counseling team Autumn Arbury and Michelle Pelton that our students also are able to call White Hill a second home our Counseling Center is not just for oneon-one counseling as people may think it also serves as a community place for students of diverse identities and backgrounds to find refuge and compassion where they can build skills rest connect and express their most authentic selves which is so important especially in this current climate students can access the care closet finding clothes and other Essentials with the help of our counselors Michelle and Autumn also lead many programs through the Counseling Center that build leadership skills for our students which as you know also serve as preventative strategies and build resilience
121in many of our most vulnerable groups there is a direct link between what they provide and the students academic success in constructive choices outside of school and beyond all of that and most critically I have witnessed firsthand on many occasions our Council at the front lines of saving our students lives they they save lives and when there are significant mental health concerns or other issues that may put our students In Harm's Way they are the first Personnel that are notified and they fearlessly and with Incredible talent that comes with deep commitment and experience lead our team including myself and our principles on crucial next steps in these moments of crises we cannot cut counseling services that can never be something that happens I can't fathom a school setting being successful without the most important services
122that our mental health Team provides at White hill we really need the parcel tax to continue to fund these life-changing and life-saving programs I strongly urge our community to spread the word and help get this passed so that we can keep doing the best we can for our students academically socially and emotionally and in all the ways thank you thank you all right Michael McIntosh did you put two in you're naming her in here twice oh no I submitted one to speak on a prior ISS you also gotcha okay thanks all right so I have uh sorry Jenny Wright um Kevin Curtis Heather Selby and Todd Greenberg I think Kevin left Kevin leave okay okay no here all right so we'll put aside and then Arena kabich kort sorry my name is Jenny Wright I'll
123be speaking on behalf of lindsy Crawford our Union president I am the union secretary uh for classified hi my name is Lindsay Crawford I have worked for the district for 22 years and I am CA president I would like to thank the board and the superintendent for your proactive approach to our impending budget issues bringing bringing forth a solution as one of the lowest funded school districts in Marin without having to make drastic cuts to programs and staff is why the community needs to vote Yes for this new educational parcel tax Ross Val is committed to providing a quality education to all students for which certificated and classified employees are essential for that to happen we need to be more competitive in attracting staff to our open positions working in the business department processing payroll
124and accounts payable I can attest to the large number of open positions and turnover of Staff we have had for several years now we currently have 28 open classified positions some of these positions are are currently being filled by outside agencies while other vital positions remain open with no interest from potential candidates because other districts are able to offer better compensation than we can with our current budget it is imperative that we move forward this with this special election so that we can retain our current staff a delay would provide potential for continued loss of teachers and staff to other districts who pay more by voting yes for this partial tax you are allowing Ross Valley to maintain the highest level of education at your neighborhood schools ensuring that your children receive the best teachers
125and staff to help guide them through their elementary and middle school education allowing them to learn and grow in a safe environment with the necessary resources to succeed thank you for your time okay um good evening members of the board fellow community members and stakeholders my name is Heather Selby and I'm here tonight speaking as a district teacher a homeowner and most importantly as a parent of two children within the district one in first grade at Hidden Valley and another at in sixth grade at White Hill I wear multiple hats in this community and because of that I have a unique and varied perspective on what is at stake with this proposed parcel tax as a teacher I see firsthand the dedication hard work and passion of my colleagues I also see the the challenges
126we Face particularly at the junior high level when it comes to teacher retention in maintaining the quality of Education our students deserve our current salary scale lacks the ability to maintain or attract Educators especially those with single subjects when we lose these teachers we lose the stability instructional knowledge and the ability to prepare our students effectively for high school and Beyond as a parent I want my children and all those in our community to receive an ed ucation that prepares them for Success white Hills should not be a revolving door of Educators a strong Middle School is the bridge between Elementary in high school a crucial time when students need consistency mentorship and high quality instruction without competitive salaries we cannot retain the experienced teachers who can make this possible as a homeowner I recognize
127that this parcel tax means an additional cost for me and my family but I also know that strong schools are the backbone of a strong Community good schools increase property values attract families and ensure that our town remains a desirable place to live I believe our community would rather invest in our schools now than pay the price later in the form of declining School quality and a weakened Community above all this partial tax is truly not optional if we want to keep Ross Valley the district that it is today as you all know white Hill has just been given a national recognition test scores have come up to or surpassed preco levels and our schools are integrating many new curriculums across grade levels and subject matters this is not a time to step back but
128instead a time to step up without the parcel task we risk dismantling the programs services and Staffing that make our schools what they are this is not just about one part of our school system it is about the people who make all the dynamic parts of it work as it is all connected and stepping up starts with the decision you make today I thank you for putting this parcel tax on the ballot giving our community the chance to show that we value education that we are willing to invest in our teachers and our children and that we refuse to accept anything less than the best for our schools thank you hi Todd Greenberg once again uh I'm for high quality education in our district but I'm for putting forth a really well thought out good
129plan and I believe there are some errors or areas of improvement that I'd like to point out here and I I'd like you to consider learning from some of Fairfax town council's mistakes there's not adequate notification that's gone on we had a huge fight for two years in Fairfax related to local rent controls where there wasn't adequate notification to all stakeholders I know one person in Fairfax who has receiv received received a mailer talking about this one one person who's up on their politics he brought it to my attention I have not personally received a mailer why not also having a mail in election midterm there's going to be a poor turnout the intention is that two-thirds of the voters would approve if we really wanted to be transparent doing this if we really wanted
130community buy in for what was best for our students and for the district we would do it so that we would have a big turnout and everybody would be noticed adequately it's a big mistake not to make everybody buy into this the amount of building square footage on Parcels is listed on page three is this going to create a poli Poli action and who's going to bear the cost of those actions and the inspections and the tax increases that result from somebody coming into someone's property and Fairfax a family by the name of sorens were on the calendar for a year or two and uh had quite a issue come up where their property is now impaired uh based on an ultimate find and it costs them a lot of money with attorneys and in
131Fairfax I don't know about Senate suo but other places may have this situation too a lot of records were lost in a flood sen some had a flood uh there may not be clear records about what exists here um also I would suggest you consider having this only take effect if revenues fell below a certain amount so you got what you need if the state doesn't deliver for you that would be a lot more palatable where the funding would be there if you need it but otherwise it wouldn't be an added tax that increases people's cost of living then there's an error here on page four pardon me to point this out C exemptions one says principal residence two says primary your time's up thank you thank you first I'd like to thank you all
132for your consideration Tyler when you said you were going to hit the ground running um you certainly did that thank you for your your time and your efforts of educating and informing us um my name is Marina kennel vort I have been the AA at way Thomas for nearly 18 years I love my job for many reasons and wouldn't want to work anywhere else but more importantly I have had the great privilege and honor of being a Community member for over 35 years I attended Manor School my husband attended Brookside school together we raised our three boys now successful men in San andelo in the home where my husband grew up many factors fell into place for our Bo's success but their story began on the shoulders of the amazing teachers and support staff in
133the Ross Valley School District several of whom are still working here it was here the foundation to their success was built starting with an enriched education we must continue to enrich the children and families in our community so they can create their own success story we must continue to build their Foundation every day in the classrooms in the art room in the music room in the school library in PE in the school office on the schoolyard and right here at the district office please show your support of the parcel tax our dedicated teachers and support staff deserve to earn a fair living wage so we can continue our mission of building a foundation with an enriched education our children and Community deserve it and our future depends on it thank you thank you so uh
134Cindy crto Mimi Willard Christina Workman and Pascal good evening Cindy CTO TK teacher and co-president of rbta I'm in report of the parcel tax to maintain the exceptional Educators and quality program that make Ross Valley School District the amazing place to teach a parcel tax ensures that we all Educators classified and certificated stay and get paid a limal w thank you for your time consideration good evening Christina Workman H third and fourth grade combination teacher at Hidden Valley and rbta Co vice president uh I'd like to say to anyone who's currently questioning the partiel tax I encourage you to be open-minded and to listen to the last two years worth of board meetings where Ross Valley Educators have shared their hardships and circumstances many of us are struggling dayto day to make ends meet we
135are passionate professionals who go above and beyond for our students because they deserve it and we deserve to make a living wage and yet we continue to be the lowest pay District in the county you've heard tonight how dire the future of the budget is the parcel tax will allow Educators to make a living wage continue to give our students the best our students are the future we need this parcel tax and we need to educate our community members on the importance of passing this parcel tax I am committed with my colleagues to reach out to our community and rally together to make a positive change for our schools our community and our children thank you good evening uh thanks for having this meeting I almost didn't come here because I didn't know about it
136uh two days ago I got one PR piece and then today at 4:00 in my mail I got your public notice I don't follow your board activities on your website where it was posted and if this is an attempt to create you know acceptance of your proposal you're starting off on the wrong foot excuse me can you give me your name please Pascal cich thank you um don't follow the footsteps of Tam Union which blew it big time in trying to get community support they were they also arrogant I'm not picking that up from you folks but it's like if you want to build support for an extension of the existing parcel tax you're not going to do it by telling people about a meeting three hours before the meeting so you spent a lot
137of money on this and instead of having the room packed with supporters that work for the district you could have had more people that are actually going to be paying the tax so this is really disappointing it's not a good way to start um couple of things about in particular about the tax um you you've you know you kind of changed the methodology here you've gone to a per square foot you've already had comments about how's that calculated are garages and adus and sheds included or is it probably I imagine it's strictly from the property tax rule that's what what you'll take um if you have a 2500 foot house your tax is going to double from 650 bucks uh a year you're going to go to over $1,300 a year so I think you're
138kind of doing smoking mirrors here because you're you're kind of pretending like it's an extension but it's not it's a big increase um the one thing you're doing good is you're going to extend the senior exemption that's good seniors will actually be supportive of you if you do that and a lot of seniors are struggling to stay in their homes so that's a good thing but from the Optics of the public that are paying these taxes you know we're just burned out we're sick of paying taxes and the first thing I look at at this district and all the other districts is why aren't you consolidating I see 1600 students in your District I see a really nice office I hear conversation about $5 million for administrator salaries why aren't you combining with other districts
139I don't understand Morin why we have so many you know I don't know how schools are operated so I don't have that expertise but from the Optics of it it's super inefficient and so I really encourage you before you ask for more money pull your pull your act together and start consolidating so those my comments thank you hi um I'm Mimi Willard uh president of the Coalition of sensible taxpayers you face a a really important and difficult decision tonight um it's clear that the Ross Valley School District is committed to hiring and retaining quality teachers and who um providing the best education that they can to the district students and uh obviously you need to to pay appropriately and accordingly uh the community also wants good schools but as Pascal mentioned um some in the
140community are struggling to pay more particularly with the flood of additional taxes so against this backdrop in the spring you developed a parcel tax proposal it pulled in June and the support was weak um and the decision was made to postpone to a special election in 25 or for an um a regular election in 2026 the current proposal has some tweaks but I'd say overall it's kind of similar to what you were looking at in June um and the main difference is that it's a special election which is lower turnout and as was described by your consultant at your last board meeting uh in some detail it offers the opportunity to Target to make sure that the ones who you think are your voters actually come and vote so um because the um the overall
141uh result of a of a special election isn't representative our organization almost always opposes taxes that are on a special election ballot um and it hasn't it it is it's not in any sense targeted against you it's a policy that we develop and for a good reason we haven't decided yet whether to oppose this tax we know that there is some need and we like the squarefoot approach but again we usually oppose special elections even if we don't oppose take us out of the equation I think this tax could fail and I think it's because it's similar to the one that didn't poll well in June and because in the interim The Tam Union uh reduced parcel tax passed Bond measure I'm sorry passed adding to the um tax fatigue an election is costly to
142the district to the volunteers who put in their time to the foundations and the donors so if this fails what happens does oh uh does that force you to cut the proposal severely uh to worse than what you would have uh put forward had you just waited another year we think that you have adequate reserves to wait out that year and it might make more sense that's up to you I think it's important that you make sure that whatever proposal you advance has the support of the broad Community Coalition and that it will pass readily our organization has a history of partnering with sensible Solutions and supporting taxes that are necessary and fair and we would look forward to the opportunity to work with you thank you Pete suuchi Sarah fori Kathleen wolf and Eric
143Brandt hello my name is Pete santui I'm a music teacher in the district and I've been teaching here for 20 years and my son also went through Manor School and white Hill and um so the district has a funding Pro problem part of that part of that Revenue problem is I should say a revenue problem part of the problem is funding another part of that Revenue problem is attendance and um I feel like the district can't wait on this I feel like they need to move forward with this paral tax proposal and and because if not you're going to have to start making cuts that really affect the programs that are offered to kids and families and then that will create a negative spiral that will increase your Revenue problem because when you start cutting
144those programs you're decreasing the quality of your schools and then you'll have more of an attendance problem as it'll be harder to attract families to the district and and keep families here I have noticed just this year several families coming to our district mid year and um when I've been talking to the kids asking them about oh what was your music what was the music class like at your old school They said our music program was cut we didn't have music at our old school and so now we're so happy to be here where we have music classes and um so if we have to start cutting electives at the middle school if we have to cut St start cutting part of our music program at the elementary school we're going to be one of
145those districts that are losing attendance and losing families because we're not offering the programs that they want um so I I I'm really worried about that also just from a point of view of the lead music teacher um we already have Consolidated the music team over the last 10 years we used to have five music teachers now we have four but our four music teachers now are full-time and um that's working out well for us and retaining a great music faculty if we have to start cutting some music classes what it means is that some of our music teachers again will not be full-time and we're not going to be able to retain that excellent faculty and so uh I just I think that I think the district needs to go forward with it and
146um retain the quality of our district and the quality of the education that the students are getting thank you hello good evening uh my name is Sarah hori I'm a teacher at Hidden Valley and also co-president of LTA good evening I'm Kathleen wolf I'm a teacher at Hidden Valley also and we here uh to support the parcel tax both as Educators taxpaying residents and parents of previous students of the district our children were lucky enough to go through the Ross Valley School District and it successfully prepared them for both high school and college even though both of our own children no longer in the district we believe strongly that all children should benefit from the many superb programs rbsd offers as well as receive an excellent education from the highly qualified teachers that District employs
147thank you thank you hi I'm Eric brand I've been teaching in Ross Valley for 25 years and all three of my children have gone through here as well um I want to applaud my friend uh and colleague Heather for her great speech mine is not quite as eloquent as hers um but I'm here to voice my support for this proposed tax um being here a long time I've seen how our low pay equals High turnover I've supported mentored many many teachers who've gone on to work in great districts down the road um so they've moved all over or they moved to Petaluma where they can afford to to um buy you know buy homes and live on the salary there um I think when we get new turnover as an experienced teacher we have a
148lot more we spend a lot more money on training and having to support these new people and I've done a lot of that and I do love it but you know when you train someone to move somewhere else it's not a real good use of resources um I think bringing if we can bring our salaries a little closer to the matching districts we'll be able to retain quality teachers um and although I'll never match the salary of my friends who work at Rie Williams um and I would love to have our district merge with someone else but they would be taking the poor neighbors on board because their district is not better their budgets are not better taking us on so um as much as it would be awesome like the fire departments have merged
149that really doesn't work that well for schools um Although our district did merge Ross Valley and Fairfax 30 years ago I think we one of the few districts in we in that did that um I think if we are paid at a comparable rate I mean I I am a homeowner here in San Ando and we're living on a Sho string but when you do do that I think putting money into schools is always a good way I I don't feel bad voting for local school taxes um and I do love working with students that live right here in my town and seeing what they're doing and I think it is a better Community when um you can have teachers that can afford to live in the town where they work thank you all right
150those were all the cards I had but do I have anybody in the audience who do not fill out a card but would like to come up and speak you're welcome to come and take up a chair just let us know who your name is so people listening can know who you're listening to thank hi thanks uh PJ fer uh Manor parent and barefax homeowner whose taxes would be um increased by this measure uh just want to start out saying I strongly support any part tax increase um you know the the district really does very much need this money it's you all have heard before I've been uh plenty critical of the budget allocations but it's always from how can we make the most of the wul small amount of funding that the district has
151to meet all of its demands there just isn't enough money to allocate um the way that the district um should be spending uh and so this partial tax is completely necessary um my one issue with it is that we are just giving a big tax cut to unimproved Parcels who would otherwise be spending $700 per Parcel Plus 3% increase over the next three years that was already pass and approved by voters um they're going to end up over the next 9 years years should this pass pay less than half the amount that they were otherwise going to pay over the next three years it's like roughly $500,000 that could go to um supporting the district's ongoing budget needs so I think that the unimproved parcels should go just leave it unchanged just have this parcel
152tax renewal extension be just changing how improved Parcels are taxed by switching them to the person square footage population um 52 cents obviously I understand um you've got a lot of criticism on taxes in general unfortunately um while we get a lot of uninformed Bluster we are not hearing uh criticism explain why teachers should have to work in the district five years before they make even 50% of the area of median income and just then qualify as very low income for federal housing um requirements uh it would take an 11% increase to get our highest paid teacher to be paid just area median income uh we need a much bigger increase for Teacher educator staff salaries then this partial tax would afford but it's a necessary Head Start and I hope we get something on
153the ballot thank you thank you great last call for public comments anybody okay all right seeing no one wanting to step forward um I now call the public hearing closed all right so moving on thank you to all of our commenters um the next item is recommended board approval of resolution 092 425 calling a mailed ballot election establishing specifications of the election order and requesting cons solidation with other elections occurring on May 6 202 all right great so um I just want to kind of remind myself and those folks in the room that uh I'm new here uh still and one of the first orders of operation for me as a new superintendent was to point of order are we moving on from the last presentation and moving on to number seven without bringing it
154back to the board oh my apologies uh yes sorry just sorry it's okay long night sorry Ty it's okay backing up to number six um yes so we're bringing it back to the what is do we do it for the public hearings sure all right I mean this is our only chance disc discussion all right yes go ahead go ahead I got a lot to say I bet you too let us hear it okay uh told you so I mean seven years ago I ran for this position knowing this day was coming so Told You So Right U I'm really big on not blaming I'm really big on not guilting people because I don't accept guilt and I don't accept blame in my life when I know that I really try to go out and
155do the best for for the people in my community and my family my friends 7 years ago I ran for this position because I was watching what was coming down the lane and and I and I'm I'm not trying to say Told You So to be right I'm trying to say here we are welcome to the show some people recognize and see what's coming uh in the future and some people pretend it's not here until it's here um first of all I'd like to say to all of the passion within teachers is I don't think there's a person up here in the last three boards or four boards that I've sat with that would disagree with your passion and disagree with the importance of getting you everything that you need I have never one time
156sat in closed session or open session with anyone that I have worked with in this position for the last seven years that didn't believe in the teachers did not believe in the mission did not believe in how important the children is for the community did not believe how important it is to amazing property rights not one time have I ever heard anything disparaging said about teachers and the need and this importance I have the luxury of um being an elected official as a Fairfax town councilman over 12 years ago 10 years ago I learned a lot more about the bigger picture I recently lost an election from R County Supervisor where I dug in really deep to put my best hat out there because I believe in my community and the importance of all of
157us I also believe in winning and uh I coached I played competitive baseball for 40 years I've coached baseball for many years and I in my professional career as um a realtor I teach my clients and my children and my friends how to win to play a game to not to win to me is is a waste of time and I'd be honest to tell you that I am concerned about this partial tax do I believe in its importance 100% will I advocate for its importance absolutely do I believe it can pass right now no not sure right and and that's because in everything I've ever done in my life I try to outline a plan or a path to yes because to failure to plan for a path to yes just puts it out
158there as hope and hope is not a plan right your need as teachers and our need as a community to have this pass is dire it's not a plan that's a hope right um if you look at the amount of things that our board has had to deal with in the past seven years um for me the the three biggest things that we dealt with were covid not not part of our plan but how to deal with that uh the charter school not part of our plan how to deal with that Children's Center not part of our plan how to deal with that right and recently teacher pay is part of our plan we got to deal with that right but the amount of minutes that our board and our volunteers because we don't get
159paid for this by the way in case people think that this is a paid position this is a volunteer position for our community for the amount of time that we put in on things that were not important for the direct impact on the children which ended up being a massive amount of effort and time um we now face probably the most important thing that I have ever had to sit down and deal with as a Schoolboard and elected official for this community and when when we talked about these other processes when we talked about the and heard and and I saw as many seats that are filled right now with red shirts and teachers all telling us what we needed and I if you go back and listen to tapes I told you this then
160that it is not a US versus you problem what I said and you can listen to it this is a we problem right this is a this is not just our board and the teachers this is a community of everyone that is going to have to make this work so here we are with a community right but let me tell you our board has been beaten up we were beaten up at covid we got beat up by the charter school and the whole battle Within that from members of the community we got crushed ran yeah so it's a discussion between the boards yes I'll I'll turn this way thank you we got crushed from the way that we were being dealt with in regards to um the children's center and I believe that we have
161a PR problem as a board now we're going to go out and ask for a massive community outreach to get funding for probably one of the most important things we're going to do and I am very intimidated that if we do not have a plan not only for this partial tax but to to educate talk about how we need butts and seats how attendance is a massive resource just as important as this partial tax how we need to go and um be in competition and acknowledge competition between the charter schools for those children that could bring a million dollars that's also Revenue gain for us right attendance competition our marketing which we're spending money on and this partial tax now this partial tax is here an important but it's no more important than any of
162those other items that we deal with and I think that to just look at this one thing really quickly right now is a shortsighted importance without a plan of how we're going to do all of these things at once and I'm very concerned at the end of the day that if we push this for timing and importance we may we may lose and if we do lose what is the bigger ramification for that down in the future so I've I I heard from the public I've heard from you about planning and I want to be very clear that this isn't something that we just decided let's put on a show this is something that we went through Consultants we had it pulled as some of you know we came back with that polling information we
163thought about what does it mean to probably look at why it failed in the polls we looked at as a board as to why it failed in the polls we took out the things that triggered the failures the forever taxes won the lack of an of a of of an option for the seniors to opt out those were the things that weighed it down that was the feedback that we actually got from people that were actually pulled so we have been sitting here and planning all of this now for those of you who say I didn't hear about this until whatever day I get that but the way that that a parcel tax campaign works is is that we can't start campaigning for it until it's on the ballot and that is the law okay
164I would have started knocking on doors personally three months ago telling people that I think we need a parcel tax but I can't do that because the laws say that once it's on the ballot which is a time frame you have that amount of time from the time frame to the vote to make it happen we can sit around and we can pick this apart okay you can I know people who could criticize God for resting on the seventh day okay but the reality is is that if we go out with the passion and fervor which I know we have it's not about hope it's about educating as we knock on doors it's about educating with the information we have it's about simplifying why we're doing it this way because there is a reason why
165we've chosen this approach to go this way there is a reason why why why why racial and I have set down for hours and hours outside of our everyday jobs and sat down with parents and volunteers who are ready to jump on the horses they're just looking for the Mel Gibson with the painted face to lead them okay and that's all we need is to get these things moved forward we have been planning if we fail and this is where I'm coming from if we fail my ass is getting back up and trying again okay because I owe it to every educator in this room that if I get if I don't get elected again I know I did the right thing okay so if we don't put it on the ballot right where are
166we we are exactly where we're going to be at the major election if we do put on a ballot and we fail we'll go back and do it again will we be burned out will there'll be resources we've used absolutely but we have to keep this momentum going because as one of the teachers said strong schools are the backbone of a strong Community when I first moved here I I didn't have kids yet when I got a ballot I saw something for a a school I was like yes yes yes because I was part of the community and I bought into being a part of community without kids yet I know my kids are going to grow up quickly and I'll still live here and I'll still say yes yes yes because the parcel tax
167is the blood that keeps the heartbeat of the schools moving and I and I don't want to underestimate how much planning and work is going into this we are working so hard and guess what we can't do this work once it's on the ballot we can't use District resources once it's on the ballot so it'll look like what's the district doing they're not doing a damn thing where are they because we can't do we can't be the face of this it's up to the community and I am begging you begging you to take this seriously we are on the precipice of soaring or falling and I know it sounds like like dramatic but it is absolutely right you're right you saw it coming great we're here so what are we going to do about it
168well if I can if I can I hear you and I don't I don't think it's if we're going to the ballot I I would I would totally agree that this is a no-brainer to go to the ballot when and how we go on that ballot is is my biggest point of contention well you know the feedback that we're getting from the community the information that we think we can still add to making sure that things are the Right Way Forward educating people as we knock on doors as we get the information out there that's what we have to do that's what we have to do but where actually talking about moving now like right now yeah right and and I don't believe that in and when we first brought up the concept of partial
169tax the very first thing I said is we need to get community Buy in in the beginning and from four out of the 16 people I heard right here right what I'm hearing is that con constituency is not 100% on board there are questions on how many years and how we got to that which is fair there are questions on how long it's going to be right there are questions about how this square footage which I think is a brilliant idea and it and it came to us from people who were thinking ahead how well we built this this community to find a path to yes is what I'm questioning I'm not questioning is should we have a partial tax you know I think we definitely have to have a part I think that's a
170no-brainer but I think that the community is over taxed and if you did follow the Tam District right that that was a big deal I mean and and we brought this up in our meetings we talked about this we talked about the the danger of putting this out here too quickly I would also I would also bring up the one point that I do have concerns with is we hire a consultant to win right and that's why we pay something how do we get this done how do we win for our teachers and this community the problem with that in the special election is we're targeting a win over community and I know that sounds awkward but think about it if if our consultant says the best way to do this is to have it
171on a special election because our people are more likely to vote for what we want that's good for us right that's good for our win that's good for the teachers win is that really building Community or is that disenfranchising people because we know they're not going to vote in May right and if we lose I don't think you can make that comeback so you're saying that people who don't take advantage of their civic duty we have to cater to them well no I'm no well I'm what I'm saying is is that I would rather not disenfranchise an entire community and I mean as much as I think the win is I think the win-win scenario is and and I'd like to figure out this to find out do we have to move forward with this
172now I mean what is the risk of putting it off a year what is the financial impact if we waited a year do we have enough reserves to weather the storm to bring in um opponents of this tax to get them on board if if we don't do this now now as in as in May because the other option is June of 2026 we will go one more year and we'll give 0% raise to CSEA and rvta My worry is that with a 0% raise because we have less Revenue next year than we have this year that we're going to lose exceptional teachers and I think one of the things that I've learned in this district is that we have some of the best Educators in the state of California they are dedicated to our
173community they could go other places for more money and they don't and they are always curious to learn and Implement new strategies for our students um like you heard some of our counselors say they're saving Liv they're literally saving lives when it comes to some social emotional health issues um and I'm really afraid that a 0% raise to our custodians our front office admin to our teachers is going to be really detrimental to the long-term health of our schools and our community well there's risk agreed that's the risk I think agree I I mean there's risk both ways we have to look at risk both ways right I mean we could lose an election and then have even a harder chance or we could really try to push it and really get it are we
174locked into that may date is there do we arbitrarily pick the May date the the county has a series of special election dates that are posted and then if a ballot measure comes up they run that election if there isn't they just don't run the election are you saying that the only date is May and then June 26 or is there another special election date in November there's an there I think there are other special election dates between May 6th and the June the following so we're not necessarily talking about a full year risk of this there is an option to pull back and try to get more onboarding get more yes I mean the path to yes is crucial for me right and I would i' rather not hurry and lose or I would
175rather not disenfranchise part of the electorate because we can I'd rather find a when we're and and this is exactly what I brought up to this board when we first brought up the partial tax when the teachers were asking for money is that we better get buying it doesn't sound like we have all the buying it sounds like we have teachers and um Union and um people that are ready to get out there and knock on the doors it sounds like we've got a we've got a call to to action ready to go that's good that's going to take take that to win 66% is a lot you know and we saw it fail and also like I said for the reasons I discussed earlier our the perception I mean I know how amazing you
176guys are I mean I know and I know how amazing the group before this board was right so I don't have any illusions of the amazing intent that these boards have but the other people that were kind of beating us around over the last few years did a number and we didn't have the best reputation whether it was perceived or reality you know there were a lot of people coming in here not trusting this board right for reasons that were absolutely untrue and proven to be untrue by the way but that doesn't mean that the perception of our board is exceptional right now and I do believe that the need for this partial tax is exceptional and it's important but I think I think I think we need more buyin are you implying that when
177people decide to vote for this parcel tax they're going be thinking about the board absolutely or thinking about the community and the taxes that are needed to pay the teachers I think that I think they absolutely would think of the board and that's actually the feedback that I've had out there in the community as I ran a campaign right for last March and I was out there talking to people every day I was constantly having to to to to to inform of a real narrative to people because most people don't read most people don't listen they hear one person and that is their reality right I don't know I was just more recently on the campaign Trail Daniel as well um my my impression from talking to people in the general public who didn't have
178children in our schools and I I specifically went and sought out seniors and people who did not have children in our schools to campaign because I figured they don't know who I am and sure enough nobody was nobody knew who I was when I was knocking on a door um and they just had no idea what was going on in our schools and a lot of them asked me about the teachers a lot of them asked if they were happy a lot of them asked about the programs in special education they asked about the art and music programs not a single person asked about the board members like if I hadn't told them who I was they would have been no so I don't think that was what was coming to people's minds and I
179talked to a lot of people I think I had a thousand houses in the time that I was campaigning personally me and on top of tablein and I actually I think I met Heather one of those with her children but I'm just saying like we were not the people that they were talking about they were they want to know how our kids were doing they wanted to know how special ed services were they wanted to know how um how the teachers were those are the main things that people were talking to me about and that was recent that was like October November so I don't necessarily think that we're the focus um and I think that there was a lot of positive feedback about our schools I talked to a lot of retired teachers and
180people who are retired who were like I always support the teachers and every time there's like stuff that comes up for school it's kind of like Chris they will always vote for it this is this is about teacher pay it's not about our reputation it's not about us I totally agree with you but I I have to totally disagree with you Rachel when when when public speakers come up here and talk I write everyone's name down and I write some notes and I write a positive if they were in a positive favor of of the issue that I was thinking about or negative and I can go back and look at the notes I can remember many meetings I can remember the meetings where the teachers were up here very upset with us I'm not
181saying they don't like us personally right I'm saying that they didn't trust that we were giving them real information in real time proven otherwise right I have notes where 50 people at Wade Thomas came up and spoke for that children center and three people gave us a neutral rating about what our decisions were right and we and we get back here and and we we ride out in front of the White Horse because we can take some shots right most people could never sit up here and take that but 46 out of 50 people coming up thinking that we're making a horrible decision about the Children's Center that that that that is stuff that those are people that are showing up and having an opinion about what we are doing right and I agree that
182the teachers this could not be the more important and most righteous thing that we need to do for our community right I believe that that is but I also don't think that everybody thinks that we've done a great job over the last few years I don't believe that we have the Stellar um backing that we used to have I don't necessarily know that to do a part taex we need to have people buy in on us like I'm not looking for people to approve of me I'm looking for them to approve of me trying to help our teachers get paid and that's what I want their approval for and I think that is an easier buy than trying to get them like I don't want a popularity contest it's not for me it's not about
183me I want to make sure that teachers can get paid I'm not saying it's about us what I'm saying is it's about just did no I'm saying it's about the Judgment that they feel as though we have had in past issues yeah then no then those those people are never going to see what the true issue is which is to get better pay for our teachers and so we're not going to be the ones knocking on the doors we can't it'll be the parents who've stepped up it will be the volunteers it will be even the kids who know that this is a very important thing that we've got to move forward I personally think that time is of the essence and um you know i' I've been there I've been on both sides you
184know samesex marriage wait wait till people feel good about it don't push it forward you know you can still sit in the back of the bus people aren't ready to see you sitting in the front of the bus you can go through every single thing and I will tell you you put on your boots and you walk into the storm head on and I think we should do this I think we should I think we should do this yeah and there may be ways of capitalizing the other districts are making Cuts right so it goes back to the reputation of our district That We're Not Making Cuts but as soon as this gets out there it is a little bit of a reputation like Pete said like oh man this is going away let's look
185somewhere else right so the fact that the plan to your like what's the plan well you guys have been planning and we can't do anything until somebody says we can do something okay I feel good about that how do we mobilize how do we get everybody involved um and it's going to be a big lift to your point right it's we we got to go out to everybody the gentleman who just got the mail right we got to communicate with everybody deciding not to do something out of fear or failure to me is not an option that's I'm not I'm not saying it's a fear failure Chris what I'm saying is that there are recent plans that were grade on paper that failed in regards to taxes and also the point of a of a
186of a tax burden at a time of high inflation is a real consideration I'm not saying this is a bad idea please don't think that I in any way am am against the plan for this partial tax because I think it is an absolute necessary tax to pass okay I'm trying to determine how we can make sure we get it right and I don't think hurrying to be first to get it out there supersedes the plan to yes yes I think part of the urgency is not the fact that like we're trying to rush anybody it's the fact that looking at our reserves and our balances three years out we're we are like one or two budget certifications away from having a qualified budget yes do you want to vote on that I don't want
187to vote on that but also if you're saying that we're taking our time I don't like the idea of having our first discussion on a lot of this with public input and then to be the next item on the agenda is to be voting on how are we supposed to take input from the community right and get real feedback from people who have concerns and talk about it with four out of the five of us and then on the very next item exact something and put it into play I I just don't like the Optics we did it once before this is the third no no I'm well I'm talking about with opposition feedback and I'm not saying it's it's not important what I'm saying is that it is the special election date the only
188option did do can we look at pushing something out there what's the next date the next date is and thank you to uh Teresa for getting these dates for me is August 25th the challenge with this is you have to get so you host a vote you hold a vote you get the results the the results are certified and then we need to talk to the county to get the the tax funds into our coffers so we can pay teachers the only one where we can get money to actually have in the 25 26 budget is the May election so any other election there's August November April and May five months right then we would have to wait you know until the next school year there is an option that we've talked with Mimi about
189of getting a a loan from the county but that would be um there would be a penalty associated with that uh with that I mean from what I heard from cost is they're not going to support this in its current state and to me that's a pretty powerful non-endorsement of something that we know is very important obviously I don't think they're here to penalize the community but that's what I'm hearing and I would much rather I would much rather think about the idea of waiting four months and getting getting getting opponents on board so we guarantee this thing passes I'd rather to take a five-month financial hit and have a 9month tax I'm a nine-year tax that's really solid then I would maybe getting defeated by one or two% and really having nothing hold on
190Mimi Mimi said that it could fail tax fatigue um but they haven't decided their opinion yet and she also said we think you have adequate reserves and that's going to be a misconception that we have to let everybody know that we've been doing through these budget advisory committees that we do not have adequate reserves one thing just to put on record is right now our third year out is at 5.4% right with two 2% away from the state minimum and Chris shut his door today and dug his heels into the second interim budget that number of 5.4 will be lower when we come back in March and how much of that includes teacher raises in the next couple years the Assumption the working assumption is a 0% raise for that's a non-star so again it's
191how do we over the next handful of weeks make sure we clearly communicate with the community and this is everybody involved that these reserves that this magical money tree that we have it doesn't exist right we've been saying that you've been saying that for years get your math people in the room we'll get like we know that but we have to communicate and clearly articulate that to everybody in the community just because we know it to be true doesn't mean everybody knows that to be true so that's how we all have to get on the same page that we do not have adequate reserves we do if we don't want to pay our teachers anymore great but that's not what we're that's not why we're here I mean right since I've been on this board
192every meeting has been teacher teach like we need more yes so we have two years I just have two years of this you've got a lot more baggage um like we have history of people I get everybody on board we have names we have the teachers in the room we have parents um with the senior opt out that's a great and it's not a forever tax that's the feedback that we heard great but the we talked we really analyed there used to be the flat parcel just based on everyone has a parcel being ped with everything right and the way that's going forward that we've been educated about and correct me if I'm wrong is that the more Equitable way to do it is the way that this parcel tax is drafted to look at
193buildings which as one person raised the empty Parcels wouldn't apply because we have to have the structures but in our conversations with consult and other people we've had to come in here to talk through these things this is the future of what partial taxes are going to look like am I correct in remembering that correctly yes and that when that type of formula is out there it's actually more well received because of it it's more Equitable for people that might have a small house but they're paying as much as someone with a big house and the ones that are going to pay more correct me if I'm wrong at places like Red Hill shopping center for example um they're going to pay more because of the property size that's paid there right and passing down
194that tax through renters will probably filter down to a granular size am I correct we talked about those things as well it's hard to decide what a landlord will do but there is a there's a potential where a landlord assumes a larger tax bill and passes that on to renters but not all landlords will do that some will yeah you have to assume yeah I mean you have to assume they will yeah but that's valid I I love the idea of the P the square foot I listen I think we're on the right page and I'm not saying no I'm just saying are we thinking this through mean I want to poke holes in it and I want to play Devil's Advocate to make sure that everybody understands like we're trying to think of this
195all through and it is going to take a Community to get it through it's no doubt the most important thing that I have ever done in seven years and right and I also want to ask this and Chris you would know this as well we push this out we're backing up more into a corner because we have another a parcel tax that we've paid for 30 years that's going to be coming up for soon or our current parcel tax ends in 28 that's right so and we're going to be asking for that again too replace it But but so you're paying double for those last three two years or is it's going to take the two to replace if this moves forward rep the current one is Suns and new is so so people will
196benefit and people will so people who are paying for that old one help me if I'm wrong will actually benefit more with this new one because they might even be paying less than what they were paying with the old one if if your square footage is 1384 square feet you will be paying the same amount or lower depend if you have a smaller uh house that if your house is larger than 848 be more the average home in the district is 1901 Square ft which is about a $268 increase from next year's partial tax so when you think about the average home owner paying $268 more for $3 million Revenue to pay our teachers it's an it's an investment in their property value and the community of $268 on average thank you that's what I
197just want to make sure that you know this is the stuff we need to really be articulated in as we start to move this forward yeah thank you and that is in um a presentation that I've given at almost every PTA meeting up up into this point I'm going to the uh Sleepy Hollow homeowners association next week along with the Brookside uh PTA meeting I also have a video set and ready to go out based on whatever the board votes on today I will send that out to all of parents square and I would encourage any person that gets that to forward it on we'll post it on next door um and I will I can't do advocacy once this is on the ballot but I will this will be a number one priority for
198me in terms of information sharing and we will send informational Flyers out we'll make sure every person in this community knows what this tax is and is clear on it and my you know I'm happy to meet with anybody who needs to talk through the details oh I hear you we're we're in the same boat we can't do that as well as trustees but we do have a selection of parents from all of the schools that are willing to step up and be on committees and start to move this forward so the education and the information will be out there and be flowing so that's good to know what happens if it doesn't pass so that I I think that's a really good question so we've got two options to to think about today and
199this is really once Charles comes up he'll have a little bit of a presentation for us we can elect to move forward with this may or hold it off next June would be maybe another option that we might be able to get Excuse Me Maybe I didn't understand maybe you didn't my question I was asking what if we decide to put it on y to the may we move forward with this partial tax and it doesn't pass yep that's what I was say not like this vote but what what if the major vote it's taking a long long route to get there apologize if it doesn't get pass in may we can go back out in next June and go for it again we might learn some lessons if we go out and don't get
200it like what needs to be adjusted does the 52 Cent need to be 50 cents do we need to go back to square footage so I think there could be learning the the part that worries me is that if we don't get it in 26 we almost have no Runway before the current paralex runs out and then so I that's where the urgency starts ramping up for me and where this may Mak more sense for me personally but I'm not voting on this this is a decision that you w get to make my concern is in the meantime if we don't get it passed we're GNA have to make the cuts yeah right proba in the next two years and then they won't get raises for the teachers so that's concerning because we're going to
201be hamers from teachers and then on top of that we're gonna have to go out and do this again and try and get the support Meanwhile we're trying to like get people into our classrooms and they're not going to want to come and we don't have necessarily the robust programs we have now so it's like you're talking about butts and seats but if we're getting rid of the programs that bring those butts in yeah just imagine that budget um committee you know imagine that one that's that's and I I think you raised a really good question earlier um Ryan about like holistically looking at attendance and I would give our our principles and teachers a lot credit for the campaign they've done on messaging around attendance this year I think some of the parents in
202the room might say maybe a little too good we've sent a lot of messages around attendance um we are working really hard on enrollment we've got a new champion of enrollment in Teresa and we're seeing some positive numbers with enrollment right now um we're also working on our marketing campaign we canceled the $25,000 marketing budget last year and we kind of created our own thing between Teresa and and Rachel and a few other people we put together the informational pamphlet that the gentleman shared we'll be doing that two times a year for marketing purposes we're also working with a family uh at Hidden Valley to put out a video on TK and our Middle School to get marketing out and that will be that cost will be about half of what the $25,000 in the
203past so talking about enrollment talking about attendance um and then information around the budget and so we've got a plan a partial tax and we have a plan B budet Cuts so we're we have a a pretty thorough plan around increasing Revenue um for the long term here and I think one thing Chris and I have talked about is as we flip in and out of community funded and um state fund we'll start moving deeper into basic Aid and I think as homes start turning over in the in the community we'll move deeper into basic Aid so this when we start looking eight and nine years out the the prospectus looks better for us because the property tax basis will be higher for us and hopefully based on what we're doing the quality teachers the
204marketing that we're doing that enrollment will be higher as well do any there thank you it's good discussion good discussion than I'm sorry I missed this earlier so would you like is it okay did I miss anything were you ready to move on to the next item yeah now that we had discussion that I mean the important part for the public is we're not allowed to talk about any of these things things when we're not here so you might hear a lot of the discussion it's because this is the first time we've had this discussion we we're able to share ideas because we have to do all that in the open so thanks for bearing with that all right so the next item is recommended board approval of resolution 09245 calling a mailed ballot election
205establishing specifications of the election order and requesting consolidation with other elections occurring on May 6 2025 great so I'll make this really quick um in the first six months of my tenure here there was uh my my main thing was to listen and learn and get to know the community and two really clear things emerged when I talked to parents and teachers and administrators one we have amazing teachers two figure out how to pay our teachers that was like the marching order I asked a couple of questions to everybody what's working in our district what not working in our district and what do you want to see from your next superintendent what's working in the district was we have great staff and what you want to see from your next superintendent was find a way
206to pay our teachers and we Chris did an excellent job with the budget advisory committee meeting this year which helped us establish a plan B for budget cuts and then the plan a when we looked at the budget it was really a revenue issue so that's kind of why we're here tonight having this discussion um and I'm happy to turn this over to Charles Heath who is our consultant with Team Civics who's helping us along with our STS Charles thanks thank you good evening on now yes okay great thank you um so Charles Heath team Civics I'm the uh uh consultant that's working with you on the partial tax measure um I've been biting my tongue in the back of the room because a lot of questions and issues have come up that I think
207I can answer um so I'm going to walk through uh the presentation that I prepared that will sort of uh set the context for the uh resolution that you'll be considering uh and as I go I'll try to uh answer some of the issues that uh uh came up during your discussion um so at your last board meeting earlier in January um we uh walked through a set of recommendations that we had for what you might consider placing on the ballot um this year um and uh one probably the biggest uh consideration in that set of recommendations is the tax rate to pursue and what we're trying to accomplish with this measure is two things one is you do have the expiring parcel tax in 2028 um if we're going to go to the ballot
208with a new parcel tax the idea is we would also want to renew that funding as well so that we don't have this quick succession of multiple parcel tax selections that would also by renewing the existing parcel tax now provide some but budget certainty for the district going forward so you're not again facing this fiscal cliff just a few fiscal years away um So within that 52 2 uh cents per square foot uh that we're recommending we can kind of break that into two pieces there's the first 32 cents which simply replaces the roughly $4.8 million in Revenue you're currently collecting from your parcel tax right um and uh then in addition to that um the direction we receive from the district is that your desire is to realize an additional $3 million in new
209Revenue to address your um flagging uh uh competitive salaries uh with your employees so that 20% is or that 20 cents uh per building square foot is what would generate that $3 million annually um when you move from a per parcel methodology like you currently have with your parcel tax to a building square footage methodology and many school districts are doing that around California for equity and fairness reasons uh the question becomes how do you treat those vacant Parcels that you know have taxable land but no building square footage the approach most school districts use is they set a flat rate that is typically lower than what uh you know a developed parcel would pay uh under the thinking that you know building square footage generates students and um contributes to the the needs of
210the school district whereas raw land doesn't um so we're recommending here a $95 per parcel rate for unimproved Parcels um I think that that sort of makes sense on the uh the fairness level so when we um sort of analyzed that and uh superintendent graph shared some of this information um and compare what the impact of this new structure would be compared to your existing structure um the average single family home within your district is about 1,00 Square fet so this 52 Cent per partial tax would result in about a $988 a year uh tax for that average home um if we were to try to generate the same $7.8 million through a per parcel methodology like you currently have that would require a tax of uh $1,165 so to generate the same Revenue using
211this methodology that average home in uh in your District pays less other key consideration is the duration of this uh in your polling that was conducted last year you considered a potential imp perpetuity tax that would have no set in date we often find that that's sort of a concerning concept for voters they like to have the opportunity to revisit the concept of this in the not too distant future we've typically found that something under 10 years is sort of The Sweet Spot it gives voters that opportunity to reassess the need for the measure but also gives you enough Runway to be able to do budget planning deliver on your promises before uh you're back out there getting the tax renewed um because the cost of delivering Services goes up every year many parcel taxes
212also include a cost of living adjustment your current parcel tax is 3% annually we're recommending continuing that at 3% again that's a pretty common number uh among parcel taxes here in maren and elsewhere in the Bay Area um state law allows you to offer three exemptions from your tax uh one based on age which is typically Ally um homeowners over the age of 65 uh and also recipients of uh SSI social security income and SSDI supplemental Security disability income um and uh the federal government has qualification thresholds based on income and disability um we are recommending that you include all three of those legally available exemptions that way folks that uh you know have a a hardship uh have that option to opt out optionally from the uh from the tax it's not an automatic
213exemption they have to apply for it and qualify for it um lastly accountability Provisions you're not required in a partial tax measure to have an independent oversight committee like you have to do in a bond or to have annual audits or um to preclude the use of funds for administration uh we are recommending that you do include those those are typically important accountability Provisions for voters um and I believe your existing parcel tax uh uh includes those Provisions as well so that will uh continue uh that that General approach um I wanted to answer the question related to well how do you actually figure out the building square footage of homes and how is that assessed so on the county assessor's property tax records uh there's a square footage for every single property within the
214uh uh the district um that is the number that would be used to calculate the tax for each property on an annual basis um any of you that have done major construction on your home have probably received a reassessment notice from the county assessor's office anytime P permits are pulled to change the build building footprint or the square footage the county assessor updates those roles so they're fairly accurate update but the county also has an appeals process if you get that tax and you feel like it doesn't accurately represent the square footage of your property there's a mechanism to uh to address that um also wanted to address the election date question so yes may 2025 is your next opportunity to put a parcel tax on the ballot there are other established election dates throughout
215the year as was mentioned August and November of 2025 are are options uh but here's the r there is a July deadline every year for getting um taxes on the next year's property tax bills so may 20125 is your last opportunity to get this tax on the 2526 tax roles after that the soonest the measure the the tax could go on the roles and you start generating revenue is the 2627 uh fiscal year so you know you all know the urgency of the issue better than I do and can consider you know what a year delay in receiving those revenues but there's no option in between that it's either this next fiscal year requiring a May election or a whole year later um so let me keep going here um in the uh resolution that
216you'll be considering tonight um there's a number of different components um there's the full text of the measure that will be reprinted in the ballot pamphlet that contains all the details on the recommendations that I just walked through um that's reprinted in the ballot pamphlet that's mailed to all voters along with their ballots in a mail ballot election um in the resolution you'll also see exhibit a which is the ballot question so we took the components of the uh measure that we've talked about um looked back at your polling and drafted working with your legal counsel this ballot question this is what will actually be appear will appear on ballots it's uh formed as a question this is what voters answer yes or no to when they cast their their ballot this is legally limited
217to 75 words this draft is 75 words on the nose so the vote will just be yes or no the voters vote yes or no to this question yes shall the Ross Valley School District's measure be adopted that's essentially the question and then the rest of the language describes the measure yeah um there have been uh quite a few comments tonight related to voter turnout in a special election this may um there has sort of been an assertion that you know you see dramatically lower turnout in special elections um I pulled the data so we could kind of validate that assertion uh it turns out to be not really true um so uh there has been sort of an assumption that you know if if we put the measure on a single issue special election
218ballot you're going to see much lower voter turnout than if we did a Statewide election next year the next opportunity to do that uh and the only Statewide election that would get you on the 26 27 uh tax roles would be the June primary so I compared here some recent uh special parcel tax elections in Marin County and a couple other examples from other parts of the Bay Area and the voter turn out that they had in those elections compared to the turnout in the same districts in the last gubinatorial primary election which is analogous to what we have in June of 2026 and as you can see here there's marginal differences in voter turnout but not dramatic differences in Nado they had a March 2023 special election exactly like you're considering here tonight compared
219to the June primary election in 2022 you know a few percentage points difference and a couple thousand votes difference but not dramatically different when we see 70 80% turnout that's general election turnout in November so your next opportunity to do that would be November 2026 which is going to delay your receipt of funds by a whole another year right because now you've tripped over two July deadlines to get your tax on the rolles so now you're not receiving Revenue until 26 I'm sorry 2728 um so a pretty significant timing consideration there um you know are are these elections manipulative are they trying to sneak issues past voters I I think that's a hard case to make in an era where every single Min voter getss a ballot in the mail and has an opportunity to
220vote um and as you can see they turn out at similar rates than they do in regularly scheduled Statewide elections there's even an example on there at the bottom Ora Union School District that's where my kids to go to school we had a special partial tax election where voter turnout was higher than in the Statewide primary election so um I would also argue that when you have a single issue on the ballot and not dozens of issues like we do in the Statewide elections there's more focus on the issue and in some ways it's more transparent so um I don't put a lot of stake in those arguments that special elections are somehow anti-democratic or manipulative um lastly I'll just talk you through the uh the timeline uh that we're looking at here so the
221first step in the parcel tax process is assessing the feasibility that's really uh the process you went through last summer when you worked with Godby research to conduct a poll um based on that we gleaned a lot of information that's gone into um developing this measure um as has been discussed tonight there the school district has a limited opportunity to provide impartial information to the public the mailing that was described as part of that effort it can't advocate for the measure but it just educates and informs people about your budget uh where you stand in terms of uh teacher compensation and other related issues but it has to stop short of any advocacy um Tyler's presentations to the ptas and other community groups are part of that awareness building effort so that's been ongoing concurrent
222to the development of the measure so here tonight the resolution that you're considering uh is really the culmination of the district's plan effort to prepare a measure for the ballot um and if you uh vote to adopt the resolution that moves us into a separate phase in the process which is the independent advocacy campaign so as we've discussed by law no public resources no District resources can be used to advocate for the passage of the measure so tonight if you adopt the resolution we hand this process off to a community campaign group that takes the process forward and any advocacy in favor of the measure has to be privately funded and and coordinated using volunteers no District staff time no District facilities no District resources of of any kind um the timeliness of this decision
223is really being driven by the fact that um the resolution calling this election has to be delivered to the county elections office at least 88 days prior to election day so for this may election February 7th is that deadline so this is uh your last board meeting to uh consider the resolution before that deadline passes so that's why we're uh here having this conversation tonight so um that's what I have to share and happy to answer any other questions you have I have a question um if we do if we stck I understand that may that the reason for this may date is so that we get funds faster if it if it's proved right if we did go to August or we pushed it back or even even in the example of where you
224pushed it back to 2027 or 2028 you start collecting tax though like we would we would receive the money from the May to August or the from that time where the vote passed we just might not get the funds for a certain period of time is that correct no so um once the voters approve the tax then it goes on the subsequent years's property tax bills um so you can't retroactively assess that tax if you're in the middle of one of those property tax years so for example if we if the voters adopt this tax in May of 2025 then it's starts being collected in the property tax bills that go out in October of 201 so it's almost like a penalty if you don't get it in it's not like you can you can
225retr grab this to that date and we can borrow against the the future nope you cannot there are borrowing mechanisms where you can borrow against future anticipated revenues but you're not going to receive those until that next Property Tax Bill one year yeah one year makes sense so um we heard a public comment tonight um and also received a email communication about this but we have a flat rate in there of $95 for unimproved Parcels so Parcels that don't have any buildings on them and you're saying that's because they're not sending children to school since there's nobody living in empty lots basically um so my question is is um I know our attorneys had uh opinion on this as well but um I know it doesn't have to be $5 that was a number that
226we picked it needs to be lower according to our attorneys it needs to be lower than um it just has to be lower I guess but it doesn't there's it's it's kind of a gray area but um what what is the reasoning for picking just 95 or landing on 95 because I did some research on this um and I just like pulled different I pulled different um school districts and what they were doing when they had the per square footage and what they were charging for their their flat rates for them and so some didn't charge anything at all like there were a couple school districts that don't charge anything um several of them charged $25 the highest one I found was Alama Unified School District who charges 299 a flat rate so I was
227just wondering like what 299 299 20 flat rate yeah but my concern was like Hey if you have a house that's like 900 square fet you'd be paying less than if we were keeping it at our I mean if we charge the people who have unimproved Parcels the same rate they're paying now a house that is like 700 square feet would be paying less than they would be paying in their rate right and so there's legality issues with that but my question is is okay so maybe it's not 700 with their currently pay but could it be more than the 95 and what are your recommendations on maybe adjusting that number up because that does that does bring like $236,000 cut to what those Parcels have been previously paying y so um you you have
228487 unimproved Parcels in your District right so if we want to do the math that's how you can uh figure out the the revenue um so state law requires that parcel taxes be applied uniformly across all Parcels right and so a square footage tax rate that is applied uniformly across all square footage that's uniform obviously per parcel is uniform because it's an equal rate that's applied uh uniformally um the the question becomes how do you deal with unimproved Parcels there's no perfect methodology to to to deal with it um you know you you've cited some examples about how other districts have done done it some are just silent on the topic and just don't assess those Parcels that that certainly would be an option I think assessing those undeveloped Parcels at a rate you know
229similar or greater to what a built out parcel is paying sort of breaks with the uniformity of just the logic and the structure of the measure so I think that's why setting it at a lower amount um but there is no magic to $95 um I mean one consideration I have and I'll back up here and look at our our ballot question you know for a lot of Voters this is probably the most important thing they're going to read as they determine how to vote and there's a lot of numbers in here already in terms of the cents per square foot total proceeds rais the 3% annual adjustments I become concerned that if we have a number in there that's $500 or even $299 or something like that it's it's an opportunity for confusion where
230voters say well is that 299 on top of the 52 cents and you can see how that could kind of go sideways quickly um so I I prefer something that's more of a you know nominal number just because I think it's simpler for people to get their heads around and becomes less of a point of concern um but you can set that rate any amount that you feel is comfortable as long as it needs that uniformity standard which just a little bit like not set down not black and white okay yeah but if you start pushing it to where you have like a tiny condo and they're kind of on par with the same fees then you're running into those issues I think so okay yeah so an 1100 square foot would house would pay
231um just over $500 in this scenario okay um and if you set the the unproved parcel at next year's current parcel tax rate it' be 720 so you'd be paying almost $200 more at an unimproved parcel than a an 1100t home is and certainly there are some homes in s s on Fairfax that are even smaller than that um so when we reached out to the lawyers they did say that they're could be a legal challenge if that you know discrepancy starts to come into to focus so I just wanted to bring it up since I heard I got emailed about it so I to have any other questions for us or for him for questions for William and I'm going to go out to public comment after that no Charles um a lot of
232people that talked uh in opposition to this talked about tax fatigue um was that something you saw in maybe those polling numbers previously um I I I mean it's yes there there there certainly is an element of tax fatigue and we saw that in in your your polling um you know your numbers were sort of in the high 50% range to low to mid 60% range so a campaign is going to have to try to um generate additional support on top of that to get the the measure over the top you know how much of that is tax fatigue or or other issues is impossible to know specifically um although I will say that the the passage rate for parcel taxes in the November 2024 election was uh over 90% Statewide um and uh the
233vast majority of taxes that were on the ballot here in Marine County were approved despite the warnings of a tax tsunami and that they were all going to go down and defeat um so uh you know I mean I think there's there's always an impact with the cumul of taxes that people are asked to vote on um but I haven't seen any indication that voters have just turned off to taxes and what we typically see if there's anything that voters are willing to tax themselves for it's usually public education or Public Safety right and so you have excellent schools here they produce tremendous property values and so I think that if they're going to vote for any tax it's this type of tax and I guess it would it would we'd have to rely on
234our campaign to educate the voters that this eventually will replace the current partiel tax that isn't as Equitable as this one right yeah that's part of the message because that really can't go in there that's a little too much of a b but yeah limited by 75 words there's only so much you can say I will say in the if you look at the resolution you're adopting tonight um there is a part of exhibit B which is the full text that is mailed to all voters yeah um it's actually at the end of section B um it describes how if this measure is approved it will replace measure E from 2018 um starting June 30th 2025 and continuing into for nine years great have any more questions for Charles okay um with that I'm going
235to go out to public comment so if you would like to comment um comment cards for that com no okay if you would like to make com yes thank you Charles you would like to make public comment just raise your hand and come on up and let us know who's talking to Michael McIntosh um one happy T so I'll be running out of here afterwards like is vietnames um what I want to bring up in listening to this discussion I agree kind of what Ryan said there is no being your District that does not want to see the teachers better compensated our concerns is really to administrated overb in half so I mean I would love to have a disclosure to the public how many teachers do you have and how many people do you
236have in support administrative staff if they're receiving half the money the teachers are receiving there might be a matrix of proportionality that would be very disclosing additional thing if you need the tax right now and you're fearful of waiting okay I agree too if you get a better buy and you have a better chance and I think there's a lot of problems until you define how and what you're going to be um taxing for this 52 Square ft split it go for right now increase your vacant parcel tax and I have one and get that on the ballot right now just agree to get that done I think you get a Buy in from everybody but refine your square footage and really in an overall picture if this board told me that all these funds
237were going to be allocated to the teachers not just thrown into the general fund so they get this increase but everybody gets this increase or say like oh we need this money for the teachers and this really happen s when funds are taken out of the general fund for fire police school or anything else we have a shortfall because really it's supporting the pensions the pre existing pensions which is the greatest burden for your administrative staff so if instead you made sure that these funds didn't allow you to say oh we've got this now covered for the peachers so we have more room to take up more things because remember when you have a balanced budget you have to provide this for all your pensions at your full rate and last but not least I
238do question and I'm sure Charles could articulate this better but it is my impression that when you use public purpose bonds and we're all talking about building affordable housing that you are exempt from these School measures and different impact fees so again you're actually benefiting the developers that are making very large buildings because we're talking about building more or needed more and more affordable housing so if you would look at splitting your parcel tax push the vacancy right now you know a fixed amount that you can balance your budget with you can then refine your language on how your taxing and get your community buying you could look to make sure that these funds now and in the future are not thrown into your general funds that they're always allocated for the increase of the
239teachers and protected by the teachers and not used to support pensions which disproportionately favor your administrative staff the third one do look into what is EXA deed restricted properties I believe are exempt so again you're profiting the developers that least needed thank you thank you hi Todd Greenberg so here you have uh as one of your colleagues pointed out uh on the heels of the first public hearing a push we've got to vote on this otherwise we're not going to have this so we've got to make maybe a bad decision because and and and then and no offense I mean everyone's trying their best but what hasn't been brought up here is what the costs of defeat are I I think U one of your colleagues did bring up um Community perception but what is
240the monetary cost of this consultant how much have they charged you and how much will they charge you and how much is the bond disclos the the tax attorney how much are you spending if you do this and you lose and then you handicap the ability to actually pass it going forward by getting the community Buy in how much how many teachers could be funded the public deserves to know how much you're spending in Fairfax they wouldn't tell us we asked there were multiple inquiries and they wouldn't tell us what the bond disclosure attorney or what the bond consulting firm was charging I suggest that you weigh what these costs are and think about how you could bridge I heard you loud and clear that hey you know what we really could use this money
241now well I could really use the money for other things too but I don't get to make that decision it sounds like you've got a two or threee possibility and maybe there's other Alternatives where you could get private donations kiddo things like that where you could save the music program I I think if you want to make it pass you need to defer this tonight and get the best ideas in the community so you're not just trying to get it passed because I think you're going to get opposition to what's being put forth right now I understand it's the easy quick fix but it there's a cost to this and maybe a big big cost by disenfranchising the community and getting opposition to it thank you please you have to say say your name so
242people listening know who's speaking thank you hi I am Daren Matson and um I was not planning on speaking tonight at all my heart is racing I'm feeling super emotional and nervous to be up here um but I just feel so compelled to speak to all of you guys and look you in the eye and have the teachers I'm going to get emotional but um these teach teachers that are going to all get up in the morning and teach my kids and it's 10:00 at night and I just we didn't get here overnight it's been a long road to get here these conversations have been going on and some of the questions that have been brought up why can't we do this why can't we do that maybe maybe there's more than one way to
243skin a cat but here we are here and it's time to move forward and I hope hearing that presentation Ryan kind of settled you or made you feel more comfortable with the decision to move forward with the May ballot I I've just been taking notes it it's all making sense to me and as a mom and part of this community and someone who moved here a few years ago targeted San andelo because of the schools we were living in San Rafel and we moved to San anelo when my oldest was about to turn six and go into um the public school district and that's why I'm here and um there's a lot of moms in this district and we can't or parents I should say and we can't just have a district full of parents
244who live here and have kids and that's why they're here and I just feel like the time is now and it's it's time to move forward I'm I'm so fearful of what's to come if this doesn't happen so that's what I want to say thank you thank you um I am an I have two kids at Menor I also volunteer from any foring from school lunch Garden budget advisory committee parel tax committee um I know 10:00 but I sh I'm going to take one more minute and say we have been playing right there is a paral tax Committee of parents that ready to go this is not like it's came out of nowhere it's really absolutely needs to happen we can't just not pay teachers comparable to what neighbors are paying we just cannot we
245cannot PR August have teachers positions that we can't feel because they going to other districts it's not a thing that we can wait a year or two or year and a half we are here at the point where we need to be able to pay teachers comparably at least we are no over close to have like a some reasonable salary we're not even talking about that we're talking about being able to hire teachers we have been talking about it we have been planning about it we are ready to go and because of all these like rules and regulations when we can't talk about we can start start doing things but we are ready and the people are ready parents are ready and you know I pay more taxes on my Fairfax house than several of
246my neighbors combined it will be paining me that I have to pay even more but kids deserve this kids need to have teachers that could you know should be able to leave and pay their bills there is no other way around it there is no magic extra money that's going to maybe come from the buildings that might be built in 2027 2029 we don't have a luxury of waiting till 2027 to find out if we're going to have more revenues from maybe the kids that may or may not come the building that may may not get built I mean it's just time is now like right now so then we all go to sleep and go to thank you thanks for another opportunity Pascal cich appreciate the conversation really good points uh I was really
247drawn by what you said Ryan about is this the time and how do you bring this forward it's not about the teachers not getting paid and recognized and I speak from a place of of just burnout and that's the tax fatigue that everybody's been talking about keep in mind we're all about to get multiple uh several time increases in our homeowners insurance if not canceled out right when I look at my tax budget my home home ownership budget you know my my home owner's insurance now is maybe $1,400 a year which I understand is really good have a small house it's going to go I have no doubt it's going to go to 5,000 or more if it's even available so I'm going to look at that and I'm going to go if if that
248happens by May when my tax bill on my my insurance gets renewed I'm going to be even more in a position of saying I can't pay anything more um but the thing that that I think if you pass this tonight and I think you will um is you really should not ignore this this concept of administrative burden you know if your superintendent's making 250,000 a year I look at that and go great High three years of pension that's going to be a lifetime amount of money for a district that is Tiny so do not sweep this under the rug this idea that oh you know we're going to ignore criticism about why are not all these districts combining because that's the first thing my letter to the editor is going to say is why is
249a 1600 student District have all this administrative burden why aren't you talking to the district over tell us educate me as to why you can't do that and if you can do that I might support it but if you can't make that argument where you sweep it under the rug you're not going to get the vote it's not about not supporting this the students uh and the teachers it's about getting rid of inefficiency and that's what I really encourage you to do if you if you bring this forward thank you uh djer again uh Manor parent and homeowners uh taxes would be increased um I appreciate the question question um to Charles about the unimproved parcel rate in the explanation um and I it still doesn't make sense to me for why the the the
250whole premise of an unimproved parcel shouldn't have to pay why not you know that it's still a sellable piece of land they're still getting the increase in their home and and property values that's uh associated with being in a school district that uh is well staffed and pays its teachers their property will be worth more if everybody else is paying more in taxes and improving the schools why are they you know suddenly exempt from this that I don't know why that sort of thinking wouldn't apply to you know why is a parent with four kids in the district but in a 2000t home paying less than somebody with no kids in The District in a 2500t home you know you could just keep going back and forth that way I think the per square foot
251is the best shot we have at getting something Equitable but I don't think that means we should exempt unimproved Parcels as if they're not getting a benefit um specifically on the point about confusing people with numbers I looked at the 2018 ballot and uh with it you get the county council's impartial analysis of the measure and in it there's a section that says should this measure not pass the current annual partial tax of $458 authorized back in the 2012 uh will expire on X date so it specifically says the old rate so people are going to see oh if we don't pass this people will just be paying this old rate of $700 instead of 95 I I think that's confusing as well um going back and having that in there um and and just
252said it's not about the teachers but it absolutely is if we pass this and all the money goes to the teachers which it is year mark you could just read um for the teachers they're still going to be underpaid they're still going to be burden people are talking about a tax burden and all the examples we're hearing are not taxes prices have increased across the board not taxes they're prices that everybody has to pay including the teachers who are making less than half of the area median income um it it's really bizarre and you know you can't affect how this is going to uh you can't predict how this is going to affect renters but I just want to point out landlords have it both ways when they say oh no we should be able
253to set our prices based on the market rate what what a buyer what a renter is willing to pay but also our price is set based off every incremental cost uh which one is it thank you right you have any additional public comment okay I wasn't going to speak either but I feel compelled also like uh my name is Anna Marsh I'm a parent at way Thomas um I I feel excited that we're here because I also have been a part of the process I was on the budget advisory committee and it's just all it's like I feel like it's happening and it all of the work that we've that everybody has done but also I've talked to people so many parents at school and they are just like ready to go like let's do
254it like get me the information give me a script to go to my neighbor's house like people are ready like they know we haven't received very much information yet because it's it has not been approved by the board yet but have everybody I know like all the parents they know that I come to these my friends they know I come to these meetings they know I'm involved they ask me and people are ready like so many parents are just I mean they know they they want it we're ready to go so I think with that energy the momentum I don't think waiting I don't think it would do anything I mean in from my opinion because I know people they want it now like we're ready to support the teachers we don't want to be
255any like lull in it it's like let's let's just do it like everybody get let's get everybody the information and educate parents and community members on you know how best to go talk to your neighbors and how best like what we can do but I mean if there's there's going to be a lot of support I have no doubt of that and then it's going to be finding ways to support to communicate it I mean that's that's going to be really like where we should be focusing our energy like let's get this done and then move on to get it past anyway thank you thank you last call for public comments all right seeing none um I will bring it back to the board for discussion I have nothing further to say can I share
256one thought about something I heard a couple of times today is the idea of District consolidation I know this is a conversation that's been going on particularly with Southern Marin for quite some time um and I'd like to put on record that districts can't make that decision it actually has to be started by community members and led through a vote so um there is no option for me or the board to start a campaign to combine us with Miller Creek and Larks cord that actually has to come from um citizens and there have been efforts in the past to to get that started and hasn't gone anywhere so um there is the E2 collaborative which talks about this and I sit on the committee too so this is a countywide thing that's already been in
257discussion of right consolidating the 17 districts and we talk about the the uh the things that you're talking about is it already is in play people recognize the duplication of Services um it's the same argument against the charter schools it's a duplication of services so it's an over tax so that that's already in the way at the county level it's called the E2 collaborative if you want to look it up thanks R say not only that but um a lot of times there's Community push back and they don't want to consolidate because there are other ones that have higher parcel taxes they have far higher property tax bases yeah and it's not in their best interest financially to combine with other districts that are lower than them and it's almost there's almost never like districts
258that are on par financially as far as tax bases and far as personal taxes that's right and on top of that when I was at the school Services of California um Summit last week with Chris and Tyler um we learned that Marin County actually did a study on this I knew this from prior um they did a study and decided it wasn't really going to be that efficient and save that much money to combined districts however we also realized when we were watching these slides that Marin County Office of Education receives a fair amount of money for every single District they have so they are disincentivized to combine districts at the county level because they get more money for every single District they have they have more districts they get more money so for us
259to consolidate it's not in their best interest and they're also the ones who put out the study so if you're interested in it and you're a Community member who's particularly driven you might want to look into which ones are more aligned which districts are interested in that and then find the community members and then come to us because I mean we're open to it I have no problem it means like hey I may not have to serve up here I mean I like being here at 10:20 at night so you know there's there are other ways but it can't come from us for that and I'm not opposed to it and I have no problem with that and I see that the logic in it but it's also not our role so just wanted to
260clarify that and I want to say one more thing I want to really say that seniors can opt out of paying this tax when I hear of the burden to our older citizens the fear of paying more taxes remember you can vote in favor of it and it won't impact you financially if you choose to opt out um some don't you know which is great um but just wanted to put that out there oh my thoughts were pretty much voiced um I really you know I really want to pound in the concept that I can't stress how important this is that doesn't mean that my attitudes and my questions are not trying to align with your passion it's trying to awaken the importance of doing this properly um I don't like to hurry and do
261something wrong but I think my objections in discussing this and bringing this out to our Forum can also show the level of work that other people have put forward to get us to this point um I would prefer I would prefer to push it off to get more Community Buy in um because when we first brought this up that was the first thing I said is we need to bring all the stakeholders in but then you know the one thing that hits me at some point you got to let your kid ride the bike you know you walk them you talk them you you put on the knee pads you put them on the bike and you hold the back and you run in this awkward thing eventually you got to let the kid ride
262the bike and you know um I think that if there's passion and that's the community and the teachers um you know in the in the famous words of Anna Marsh you know ready to go you know let let's do it that's kind of it's kind of where I sit great Segway all right and with that do we have any further discussions if not I will entertain a motion on this item I'll make a motion to recommend that we approve 0924 25 calling for a mailed ballot election establishing the specifications of the election order and requesting consolidation with other election occurring on May 6 2025 I will second first and second Ryan hi Chris hi Daniel hi Rachel hi thank you thank you go get it let's do this hopefully everybody sticks around for our next
263topic the school launch program School launch breakfast where you going we'll be here that's amazing thank you all right all right do you guys need to stop go to the bathroom no pum ready go push through okay all right we promise okay so the next item is authorization to go out to bid for national school lunch program and school program so this item is actually in recognition of um of everything that has been happening with our school lunch program and you know just the the level of um meals that are being served uh clearly the kids don't like them as much as they should and also parents may not like them as much as they should as well and so we are looking to see if there is another vendor that would be willing to
264provide meal service to our children and so that's what this is doing it allows us to go out for that all right do we have any questions for Chris my understanding is that the the pool is so limited that you know like are we doing the same thing we did last year and we wind up still with the same vendor you know that that may very well happen just but it's great that you know I I will be looking to see if there are others out there and we actively sent it out to previous vendors in the area and we'll do the same thing to see if there are any takers um that would be willing to provide a a proposal to us do you need approval for that yes we're seeking Pur we have
265to go com do have more questions on the school lunch do have more question we're be 1 a.m bringing breakfast right now vas has F to school lunches starting this year and the difference for the kids is unbelievable they all line up to get lunch they eat the teachers say how the kids come not grumpy they're ready to go they're learning versus hungry hungry kids can't learn they went they got a grant from Kitchen facilities improvement from the California state they got a grant for measure from Martin County they made it happen without any bond money or any those big things that we have to get us parents for and Community for and I would love for us to consider not just sending it out to the same vendor lunch master has been so terrible
266we're teaching kids how we need to have bzero waste and then we bring them lunch where every slice of apple is packaged in cellophan every single slice it's it's garbage the food is like when I volunteer for lunch kids come to here like this pizza is rotten and I'm like I'm sorry I probably wouldn't either and I'm sorry and that kid is going to classroom back the classroom hungry they have nothing else to eat they're hungry and hungry kids can't learn and so what I really want to encourage Chris and and everyone is that no we're not just sending it back to the same vendor we need to see other ways to do it and likeon District shows us a perfect example how this could be done much better without any B Money and I
267do want to us start thinking and looking more into are we leaving money on the tables by not applying to any grants last year for example there was 565 million California Department of Education had grants just for improving kitchens in schools did we apply no there were 117 millions of funding for Greening schoolyards did we apply no I'm not saying all grants get approved I ran I wrote lots of grants in my life as a scientist but if we never apply for anything we're sure not going to get any of that money yes it's one time money but we need that that's the money we need to make those kind of improvements like even if the state recognizes that you know we need to do better feeding and have all these GRS why are we
268not participating in any of this like none of them like we son Elementary got $200 million Grand just so they can teach kids about importance of eating vegetables and adding more vegetables to the die $200,000 like we did not put any of that zero and so I would encourage you to see what are other ways for us to improve how we can feed the kids this especially goes for the poor kids that otherwise have zero food to eat they're going back to classroom hungry lunch Master food is is really really bad we got to do better we could do better if we we put effort and focus on it rather than just you know sending it out again Master thank you um one of the things that do we have any additional public comment no
269I agree thank you all right I see another headling as well thank you all right go ahead one of the things that that Tyler and I did is we went and we visited saso Marin School District who also has conscious kitchen and I visited also by myself um Lanas school district and I the intent was to look at their food service program under conscious kitchen and unfortunately um with those programs our kitchens are not um large enough we don't have we don't have the facilities to be able to provide that those types of meals um having been in a district where I was the um CBO for a number of years with 10 schools where we provided meals at every school uh we had a robust breakfast and and lunch program I know what the
270sizes of the kitchens are and I was looking also at the sizes of the kitchens that um both lanus and saso Marin School District use and for example um our kitchen at um white Hill was about the size roughly the size of the um the the storage space at souo Marine didn't even include the actual kitchen so that's just an example we would need to to have um Refrigeration we need to have freezer space um it just there's a lot of things that we don't have the facilities for that we would have to actually build up that infrastructure what did there's a happy medium between having facilities to accommodate chefs to having meals like this prepared you know um green and available in fresh you know um they they they make great Foods I I
271actually and I'm very familiar with the program and you know water is just behind it and everyone but is there way to that they could package the foods like they they've done on airplanes you know like they took the the concept of the high the chef in the sky to a new level um you know it's it's hard I mean we we've we've tried to to do school lunches ourselves and push for that but I can't I can't advocate for my kid to eat white flour all day you know um let's keep looking let's keep trying I think that these These are great ideas that we've obviously explored but I think some of the feedback that I think I've because this I mean when I went out earlier in the year said what is the
272district not doing well this was like one of the top top concerns that I heard from from families and with kids I do think we have the opportunity to think a little more creatively and go find grants and see if there's something else we can do um I think I've heard loud and clear from students and parents that lunch Master is really an option we should move away from and we'll do everything we can to to move on that um we just have to find the narrow window on something we can actually do and we can laugh about I laugh about it but the reality is sometimes it's the only true meal some kids are getting in the day and I think we have to really understand that we have a population of children that
273are relying on these free lunches to really be meaningful for them so I think that would be a great idea I would support that so you have any further discussion among the board members if not I'll entertain a motion on this item so moved great do have a second hi all right Ryan hi Chris hi Daniel hi Rachel I thank you Chris and moving on recommended approval of the agreement with order I think we have to yeah can you make a motion to continue the meeting past time yes thank you for catching that um I have a motion do you have a second yes second all right Ryan no no Chris um I Daniel it's gonna be quick it's gonna be quick all all right Rachel I ran okay so I told you I was
274gonna vote on that I know I know let's go I did think about that one tonight all recomend approval of the agreement with the sard Val City schools to provide services to ensure compliance under the Extended Learning opportunities elop program at Ross Valley School District and this is me again um super quick yeah I will make it quick so as you heard within the audit there's lots of requirements related to the elop program um we we have implemented the program and what we're going to do is ensure that the compliance because it is a very complex beast and um the San raell City schools has a robust Asis program prior to having the elop program which is how it's run it's the same and so what they'll be able to do is provide those same
275mechanisms working with the YMCA to ensure that um we meet all of the criteria that we need and um so that's what we're asking is just to to allow for that and it is um an amount not to exceed uh did I not put that in there 15,000 15,000 so the the the long and short of this is this is a support from santaf fell to help us get more lowincome students into exad of learning before and after school programs do you have any questions no all right do have any public comment nope okay that for board discussion any comments on this one I think it's a good idea yeah after reading the audit report is this is the one that we were ding before so okay um I will entertain a motion on this
276item uh i' recommend that we approve the agreement with the sanfl city schools to provide services to ensure compliance under of the Extended Learning opportunities program at Ross Valley School District I second that so Daniel I Rachel I Ryan I Chris all right moving on recommended approval of the 2025 26 and 2026 27 school calendars that fine um yeah super happy to be bringing two years of calendars to the board and both of these calendars are what I would effectively call a rollover calendar they're very similar to this year's calendars the only thing that really changes is the place them to the fall PD day which we are placing um with absenteeism in mind and so just trying to find an um on the first one it's it's next to the local holiday in that
277one and so um so that there won't be a gap day where like a Thursday is a holiday and then a Friday you're back in school again there were a lot of absences on that day this year not surprisingly um so um the calendar is built by our um teacher leadership team like they give input admin gives input um it's already gone out um just to be shared and and give knowledge for our um classified and certificated staff and we recommend approval of of the calendars after which we will translate them into Spanish and um send them out to the community am I missing rashash Shana or what was it was it yapor Y kapor is it still on our calendar yes I don't see it it's not named as the actual holiday we call
278it a local holiday we we don't put any you know religious holiday I'm just making sure that what I'm looking at is I see veterans day and stuff like that we make sure that it's yeah because that's a um federal holiday national holiday yeah I was going to ask about different the veteran day because it falls on a Tuesday next year and a Wednesday the next year and and I know a lot of businesses don't it's an burden on parents if businesses aren't closed and their kids are just out on a Tuesday or a Wednesday so is there any way of recognizing that on a Monday or Friday the veterans are very clear that they want to be recognized on Veterans Day and federal services are closed that day yeah okay so I can be
279sa kids because I'm all no but otherwise a good job like just looking at that a little more closely going yeah and and it's in alignment with the Tam calendar question that's really how we're choosing it and and before we started taking that as a holiday there were really high rates of absenteeism on that day so we're still at 80 student days we still have three professional development days teacher work days days at the end um that are kind of held in place in the event that we have a school closure all right great do you have any public comments on the school calendars nope okay see we make a motion to approve the 25 26 and 2627 school calendar fantastic do we have any discussion that we had further no okay just check it
280okay then I will I have a first do I have a second yeah I'll second it great all right Ryan Daniel hi Chris hi Rachel I and we have two skill calendars thank you and moving on recommended approval of resolution 07242 and the annual accounting of the 20232 24 developer fees in fund 25 government code section 661 D and 666 666 D here you go go ahead think it's CL so this was a information item on the December board meeting and it's up for approval this even as a resolution so it's the exact same item just with an approval and and this is something that has to be done anually any questions for Chris there any public comment no all right any discussion all right I will entertain a motion on this item motion that
281we uh approve resolution 07 2425 and the annual accounting 23 24 developers fee great second fantastic Daniel hi Chris hi Ryan Rachel I all right so we have approved that thank you Chris and we have consent actions did anybody have anything they wanted to pull out of here or if not I will um um actually do we have any questions no comments do we have any public comment no okay on the consent comment on the okay just because it um includes all the financial and budget reports uh that for again for recording uh just quickly um was hoping that um in the reports um we could see if the um children center money is going to start being spent and what and what the plans are for that um you know it's not doing anybody
282any good for it to just sit in an account unspent um and just given the previous item about the lunch Masters um I would expect kitchen expansion would be a capital Improvement that would qualify for the use of that funds I know it wasn't on the survey um done later but if we're looking for projects that could be done quicker and integrate with other things that the schools are spending money on great thank you thank you how was that conent I don't yeah um yeah um consent actions so no more public you have no public comments on consent okay so I will entertain a motion on the consent items so moved I will second Ryan I Rachel I Daniel hi Chris hi okay so consent is approved board business committee updates reports from an announcements
283by trustees I'll just say I've been really busy I've been doing a lot of this school events and a lot of uh parent club events I'll leave it at that um I also went to the school Services um budget workshop on Tuesday last week thanks pet good night which was informative and also I was surprised at how much I actually knew I was like Oh I thought I'd be in over my head I was like actually I knew exactly what was going on so that was um refreshing thank you Chris for um my education over the last five years and I will get that I have not I missed the joint save School save rout to schools because I was on an airplane um but for my understanding um I followed up afterwards and there
284was not a lot of there there but um to discuss but uh um hopefully the next even I'll be able to make and I'll also report but just everybody know and they in spirit oh I forgot I was at the yes board meeting and there is a Fairfax art show going on now with students don't worry about it anyone else no okay I will move on um to approval of regular meeting minutes for December 18th 2024 if we look fine to me yeah that good to me too I will make a motion that we approve the board meeting minutes for December 18th 202 for moved great Rachel I Chris hi Daniel hi and Ryan okay and next item is approval of the special meeting minutes for January 8th 2025 yeah again not no changes for
285me me neither okay so I'll make a motion that we approve the January 8th 2025 special board meeting minutes do have a second no second it great Rachel I Daniel yeah I EXC me chis hi Ryan I'm stay all right so that passed too and then uh superintendent cabinet report updates I'll just say that uh I've been exceptionally busy and last week the highlight of maybe my year so far was subbing over at Hidden Valley getting to interact with kids and staff and parents and it was just uh really really wonderful I'm looking forward stopping all the other schools and then the next two days I'll be down in montere for superintendent's uh uh Summit which I'm really excited to go learn from other superintendents cabinet members any updates nothing interest all right then all
286right with that um meeing review future board topics and board Direction anything we wanted to direct anybody on all right so I move on to meeting debrief any feedback comments thank you for catching me on my mistakes I'm very tired today so I appreciate all the help running the meeting Ryan I just love just having a discussion and really talking about these things I you know I love I love those cop talks on well I mean literally on the record there is nothing more important than actually doing the business of the people in front of the people absolutely as and one of the biggest cuts that I've received in the past is we' have had a lot of unanimous votes and when people see unanimous votes without discussion they just have to assume that we're
287not doing independent research and we're not coming to you know decisions in public so public disagreement and the Airing of Grievances of others is equally as important to bring them out whether you feel as though they're valid or not in order to gain the Public's trust and we need it for this that's what I did it well I appreciate it it was helpful to have a lot of dialogue and I love the fact that we can all talk and maybe very much disagree on things and still be sole I appreciate that we're not that far off on almost anything let we can't we can't just be so greed with it just we lose credibility well and generally we can have different opinions it's totally fine I make get that all the time um you're wrong
288though all right um with that I am going to adjourn our meeting at 10:44 thank you all so much thank you e