001e instructions for accessing subtitles in a language other than English are included on our board meetings web page as well as in the description below e e good evening and thank you for joining us um it is January 8 2025 at 5:47 I'm calling the Ross Valley School District Board of Tristy special meeting to order um at this time we have four trustees present we have Daniel Cassidy Shelley Hamilton Chris L cob and myself Rachel lwak we also have our um superintendent uh Tyler gr here tonight um this meeting is here at the Ross Valley School District office it shall drive and um with our meeting called to order I will move on to our procedural items the first one there is the Pledge of Allegiance so like to please do I to flag of
002the United States of America and to the repu for which it stands one nation under God invisible with li Justice all thank you and next item is to adopt the agenda and time allocations did we have any board members who would like to make deorations changes if not I'll entertain the motion I will make a motion to adopt the agenda and time allocations as noted second second Chris I shell hi Daniel hi and Rachel I we have an agenda for this evening the next item is presentation and action items our first item under this is public comment regarding items on the Open Session agenda um we are only taking comments on our special meeting um agenda items tonight so they need to be focused on the item as listed in number two which is uh
003for discussion for the purpose of giving direction to the superintendent regarding parcel tax renewal so I have one comic card if anybody would like to add one um I'm happy to take him just pass one over to do a trees over here um but right now I have [Applause] Christina hello happy New Year so I'm Christina Workman uh our VTA Co VP and third and fourth grade teacher at Hidden Valley I'd like to thank superintendent graph for his presentation Monday morning with the staff um really laying out with the parcel tax like the needs of the why we need the parcel tax and why it's important just your continued transparency speaks volumes and it means so much to all of us so thank you very very much rvta supports the parcel tax we are behind
004the board and our superintendent we're on board and United and working together we realize how vital it is that this parcel tax passes and we want to make sure that we're working together to make it clear to our community how vital and critical is that we do pass this parcel tax we understand that the parcel tax doesn't pass then major Cuts will happen and our amazing qualified teachers will be forced to look for other jobs we need to pay qualified teachers our current qualified teachers we need to be able to pay people rolling out new curriculum we need teacher leadership we need to be able to retain the um the teachers that we have and our teachers as we've been seeing for the last few years now we need to be paid a livable wage
005and we know the parcel tax is really our or only answer for that um it's imperative that this parcel tax passes and we're ready to work together thank you thank you Christin Last Chance anybody else all right so moving on um is the next item which is board discussion for the purpose of giving direction to the superintendent regarding personal tax renewal great turn over you yeah so tonight we have Charles Heath um with Team Civics who's going to talk to us a little bit about uh some of the conversation we had the December board meeting around uh making decisions around per parcel or per square foot senior exemption inflation rate all those questions that we had at the end of that presentation um Charles will bring his expertise into the room um share his perspective
006and we can ask and answer questions uh from from Charles on that so welcome Charles sure thank you good evening I am uh Charles Heath I'm a partner with Team Civics uh we are Consulting that work with uh most of the school districts here in Ming County and many school districts around the state uh to design and pass Revenue measures we work on a lot of bond measures and parcel taxes we've worked for uh Tam Union High School Districts here and most of the other feeder districts that feed into Tam and um the other districts here in Marin as well um we've uh uh been working on this for a little less than a month now I think we were brought on board in mid December so um Tyler was gracious enough to spend some
007time with us to to kind of get us up to speed on some of the conversations that the board has been having to date some of the decision points that you all are wrestling with uh and the potential timelines if we want to have a measure U on the ballot as soon as the May 2025 uh special mail in ballot election so um I've put together some some thoughts that I'm happy to share with you based on my perspective as I've kind of looked at the the options um I've also had conversations with Brian Godby about the survey research that he conducted last summer when you were thinking about potentially putting something on the November 2024 ballot so I have the benefit of of all of that data and Brian's conclusions um and uh also
008happy to talk to you about just timeline and process from here right so most immediately I think what we need to do is come out of tonight's meeting with some direction from you all in terms of um what are the key components of the parcel tax that you want us to bring back to you in the form of a resolution at your January ticking away on us here um so we want to be able to work on that and bring back something that hopefully we have a consensus on um as part of that I thought I would kind of walk you through what I see as the key decision points around tax rate uh duration um the um potential uses of funds uh whether or not to include a cost of living adjustment and if
009so how much um kind of each of those key decision points that would uh then uh help inform the uh the creation of the resolution and then beyond that we can also talk about communication strategy and the transition to an independent advocacy campaign if you were to put the uh the measure on the ballot so that's sort of the framing um anything else you all want to make sure that I cover this evening or should we start there sounds the only other only other point which I'm sure you'll cover is the per parcel versus per square foot um decision yep yep we we'll definitely and why don't we actually start there because I think probably the most challenging decision in front of you here is uh how do you choose an appropriate rate right and
010as you might imagine for a parcel tax that requires a 2third vote to to pass um choosing a rate that the community generally perceives as affordable and appropriate is is probably the most important decision you'll you'll make in in all this as you probably know the vast majority of of school parcel taxes both in Marin County and throughout the state are like your current parcel tax just a simple per parcel methodology um increasingly we've seen some school districts moving away from that there was a state supreme court decision uh last year in 2024 that sort of opened the door for allowing more latitude and how you can structure parcel taxes um using different methodologies including the per square foot option um the primary benefit of the per square foot approach is that um it means
011that the um larger larger properties within your District that have greater square footage that may beond you know um a single parcel or a few Parcels they end up paying proportionately more under that methodology than they would under the uh the per parcel rate and when we run the numbers I'll go through these with you in a minute we definitely see that when you move from a uh per parcel approach to a per square foot approach it brings the cost for the average single family home down because a greater portion of the burden is being borne by those non-residential Parcels so that's the primary benefit I think there's good arguments to to be made that it's a more Equitable um approach to to assessing the tax the downside of the per square foot approach is
012that it's more complicated right when on a per parcel basis it's really easy for me to understand as a homeowner how much it's going to cost me every year um on the per square foot approach I got to do some math and I also have to know how big my property is and some of those factors to to to get at the numbers Charles is it the property size or square footage of the house so you can do it either way legally um what we uh find in virtually all cases is that it's based on the building square footage so the improvements that are on that parcel not the lot size as a whole and the reason for that is is that um you know there's some correspondence between the size of the building and
013student generation and factors like that lot sizes are all over the map and you can have some very small homes on a very big Hillside property and it's just hard to rationalize why that should drive the cost I just think people know their square footage the house I don't know how big my personal lot is so I think that's almost easier even though it's more complicated than per parcel knowing the square footage the house is easier yeah it's the number that comes to mind more easily than your lot size for sure yep um so so let me just kind of walk you through our thinking as we've looked at the numbers so um my understanding is we're trying to do two things with this parcel tax one is we want to renew the funding that
014you receive under your current parcel tax which this year I believe is about uh $4.7 million um and what we're looking at here for a measure that we would place on the May 2025 ballot it would actually take effect in the 2526 fiscal year right on the property tax bills for that year so we actually need to look ahead at what would your parcel tax generate in that 25 26 year because that's what we're asking voters to consider and by my estimation with that 3% increase it would be about 4.85 million next year okay so just to keep you whole um to generate 4.85 million we also need to account for the fact that you currently offer a senior exemption and it looks like about 20 5% of the single family residential Parcels in your
015District are currently qualifying for the exemption so we need to account for that when we when we do our math um so um next year the per parcel rate that would be required to generate that 4.85 million is about $720 per parcel okay if we were to shift that to a square footage methodology and account for those exemptions I estimate that we would need a tax rate of 32 cents per square foot to uh generate that same amount of money after exemptions if we apply that 32 cents uh per square foot to the average single family residential square footage in your District which is 191 square feet that results in a tax rate for the average property of $68 per year so you can see 68 compared to 720 we're seeing that benefit of moving
016to the square footage approach for that typical um single family residence um so 32 cents is what would be required just to keep you whole um and then that could continue to adjust by 3% or whatever Factor we choose um going into the future I also understand that in order to address your budget need you're trying to generate an additional approximately $3 million right so um $3 million applied to your taxable square footage accounting for exemptions requires an additional tax rate of 20 cents per square foot okay so that would be a total of 52 cents per square foot that additional 20 cents applied to that $1900 average square foot is an additional $380 right for a total of uh 988 would be the total tax rate under the 52 cents per square foot for
017that average uh single family home by comparison if we were doing this on a per parcel basis the additional $3 million would require an increase in the tax rate of $445 to a total of $1,165 okay so 16 one 1,165 compared to 988 that's the differential that we see when we move to square footage compared to um per parcel so on the whole I think just just thinking about the um sort of how do we optimize this measure politically um to to maximize support I think the square footage approach likely is is beneficial to you um even though it is more complicated and I agree it sounds it sounds it's the complication part that worries me the most that could be the killer for voters to actually vote Yes or no right and so in
018your experience and what you've seen districts move to can you provide us any type of guidance on on what other districts have done to really simplify uh the voter experience to be able to see clearly that this makes sense on so many levels sure um per square foot yeah it just it requires as as part of your messaging part of your messaging is going to be why do you need this Revenue right and you know you're the lowest funded District in R County on a per student basis and you have a lot of good messages that you can use to to make the case and the need to stay competitive on salaries for attracting and retaining teachers and other staff um but you have to add to that the messaging around why this methodology makes
019sense because we're changing methodology right and why are we doing that and that's where I think the equity argument this is more Equitable structure um it reduces the cost for the average homeowner in the community um and I I would really use those those numbers um focused on the average square footage in the community to kind of ground people in some real numbers now some people I mean averages are averages because half are above and half are below right so um we'll ALS the the square footage of every property in your district is public record so as part of the campaign we can access that data answer questions for people so that they know concretely how much this is going to cost them and take some of the mystery out of it that second part
020that sorry that last sentence do you think it might be beneficial to have some type of resource in place for people to call and have that calculation given to them just I mean do we app something yeah I mean it's it's basically it's a spreadsheet so a couple things we could do is one we could make that available to District staff to be able to answer that question if it comes up um because that's factual information the district can always provide factual information just can't Advocate once the measures on valid right um we've also in some instances created a calculator that you know we can put on your your District website or the campaign website where people can go in and we'll do the math Forum you plug in your address and it tells you
021here something it's going to cost you so some tools there so we could tie it in with that County data about not just my home is 2200 feet let me just multiply that by 52 okay yeah yeah you can tie it to the address and we could also I mean you could also do the reverse re-engineered math and say you know if if it if this was done on a per parcel basis it would cost $1,165 which would be equivalent to a homeowner of whatever turns out to be anything anyone who owns homes larger than that would pay a bit more and if you own if your house wasow less than that it's a simplified kind of way of saying a cut off line and the equity argument that as well is there a cap
022that you'd recommend like not over it just doubled that to like a 3,800 square foot house and I don't know what the the the house sizes go but I know down Butterfield there's some large presumably large houses um yeah so so we we looked at the cap and in the polling that you did it assumed that there was a cap I think it was around 10,000 square fet um and as and we had um we had someone run the data on how many Parcels in your District would actually that cap would apply to and there were only 30 Parcels in the whole you have 9,000 taxable Parcels only 30 would qualify under the cap over 10,000 foot homes uh yeah well there one residential property the rest were all non-residential so commercial or like larger
023apartment or condo complexes um so my advice you one of the challenges with the cap is that now all of a sudden you have this other number that's in the the ballot question right you can either phrase it in terms of a square footage cap or a dollar cap you know is the equivalent either way um but it complicates the bot question and we've tested this in polling side by side and when you add that cap that additional complexity people start start asking El well this is going to cost somebody a couple thousand dollars a year not you know the whatever N9 $988 they're telling me and doubt is not your friend in in these elections so given that it only applies to 30 parcels and one residence just let it I would simplify it
024and just remove the cap yeah and then how does it work with apartment complex like they they would have to pay that large amount potentially if it went through they would pay the larger amount yes uh just simply based on their square footage um but you know if you assume that apartment complex as whatever 15 units then they're going to take that amount divide it by 15 then divide it again by 12 months and pass that through in in rent to the extent that uh they're able to the market will bear it and again it sounds like the other the other piece of the message is that it's really the size of the building the number of bedrooms that drives the impact on the school district in terms of the number of potential amilies and
025students who live in them so from an explanation perspective that's whether it's an apartment or a house right so would somebody in an apartment in that case pay less than they're paying today well if you're in an apartment and you don't pay property taxes you don't currently pay for a parcel tax and you wouldn't in the future so it would just be a pass but it get passed through so what's the Assumption for people want apartments that pass through it's it's really hard to figure it out because I mean ultimately rents are arget driven more so than you know just pass through of cost so um but you know under this methodology it is going to cost those apartment buildings more to the landlord and to the extent that they pass it through is you
026know it's hard for us to estimate that in any Accurate Way are there any I'm sorry go ahead it is done on a per square foot basis so it shouldn't really matter if it if if a landlord passes through an expense an actual expense then they're passing through the exact per square foot cost to a renter that a homeowner would be absorbing as well from an equ like from everybody getting the same and maybe I'm splitting hairs here or not but I think about the affordable housing units individuals who really don't have a lot of uh Delta to have a rental raise what have other districts done for those buildings and we're looking at a parcel you know do those landlords get get capped so that those tenants that are getting a break and rent
027aren't hurt yeah there's no way to offer an exemption for low-income properties or something to that effect the only exemptions that are allowed are for the property owner not not for a tenant um because the tenants aren't paying property taxes uh and they can only only be offered based on age or um if the property owner qualifies for low-income disability benefits that's all the state law allows so we don't have many tools there you could potentially you know look at your profile of parcels and say okay of our multif family um dwellings you know how do we isolate a category of those where we do want to apply a cap to try to mitigate this but I I think it again we're talking about 30 Parcels total that we even qualify yeah so we're really
028trying to thread the needle to develop something that achieves that outcome yeah okay of those 30 how many of them are like commercial versus like rental space um I have that database I don't know off the top of my head but I can I get you that information I'm thinking maybe there's a way to do it like number of living units per parcel then you can kind of get it that way because I think the ones are probably over 100 would likely have low income and you can maybe cap it for those FS could you do that do something like that or just cap it in general for a living number units I mean we couldn't tie the tax methodology to to dwelling units it would have to be based on either square footage or
029Parcels yeah so that's very limited have you ever seen it done on for bedroom I know some planning departments do certain regulations based on number of bedrooms in a yeah I mean state law for school district parcel taxes it has to be based either on square footage or Parcels we don't really have another way to assess the tax yeah so it's not perfect because we only have so many tools yeah yeah um the other thing to think about related to um the square footage option is that you do have uh I think it's about 900 Parcels in your District um that are unimproved so they're vacant Parcels um under your current parcel tax they're assessed the same rate as everybody else um in the square footage methodology you have some flexibility because how do you
030apply a square footed parcel tax to a parcel that has no um uh no square footage so typically what's done is you have a separate rate category for unimproved Parcels um in your polling you tested a $199 rate for those unimproved Parcels to me that feels High um for these properties that aren't generating so I think a number that would be more in the you know 75 to $95 rate range would probably be more palatable and again if you think about the voter that's just quickly reading through this ballot proposal they're trying to EST multiple numbers and the more you can keep those numbers in a palatable range the better reaction you're going to get and what are those vacant Parcels paying today they're just the same rate as everybody else because it's just purely
031based on per parcel rate every parcel is treated equally it's a 698 and means nobody lives there the house is for sale or just or that's just a term that there's no no improvements on the property so it's just raw land yeah oh just land just land yeah okay and sometimes you'll have situations where there's a home that's been divided into two Parcels but that other parcel doesn't have anything built on it so that's counting as one of those vacant Parcels right so the number that we got for the um square foot the 52 cents square foot that's backed in with the the 900 ones pulled out obviously we change that rate or yeah so I for the numbers I gave you earlier I assume $95 per vacant parcel just to get to those numbers
032but again because there's not many and the rat's relatively low it doesn't move the needle a lot in terms of the overall revenue and this includes the 25% senior opt out uh it does yeah all these numbers factor in the exemption and these exemptions seem to me not to have that much of an impact on our overall goal 4.85 right um well it's 25% of your residential Parcels so I mean it does have some it's several hundred, a year in in Revenue um and it just means that when you factor in those exemptions you have to raise the rate to generate the same amount of Revenue okay all right yeah and talking to neighbors who would be interested in that exemption how do we promote that how do we because I from people I've talked
033to sometimes it's complicated and I think it just goes through the the tax assessor's office but is there a way making that easier for our exemption population to know that they can still vote Yes because it's easy to exempt or everybody's just automatically qualified out want to do so it's actually the school district that administers the exemption um and I don't know how you currently promote the senior exemption or if you do um by law if seniors um apply for the exemption once it has to be carried forward each year for the life of the tax so you can't make them reapply every year okay that's easier yep um and you know I often see that you know in the course of pro promoting attacks like this and going through the campaign process a big
034portion of that will be focused messaging to senior citizens about the availability of the exemption now it's a double-edged sword because that's probably going to result in more exemptions which is going to cost you Revenue but those are also important votes to get to uh the thirds Mark yeah um but you know many school districts on an ongoing basis will have you know an annual communication to senior homeowners to say you know the deadline's coming up to apply for this exemption um typically there's a deadline in kind of the May time frame so that you can receive those and process the exemptions before the property tax bills go out in the fall but the district is responsible for preparing the levy role that gets provided to the county assessor to then add to the property
035tax bills okay um and that's going to get a lot more complicated if you're run a square footage methodology because it's no longer just you know taking $720 and applying it to all the parcels except the exemptions you have to calculate it for each one so most school districts that have a square footage based parcel tax they have a third party professional administrator that prepares those tax rules for them and that's just an additional cost who we'd have to do every year or just the one time it um you need to do it annual because potentially there could be changes in square footage from year to year your exemptions will change from year to year so it needs to be updated annually and I I can uh refer you to firms that do that kind
036of work for other districts in the area just curious what does that cost a district per year I don't have a good sense of that to be honest I can find out for you um and it's going to scale with the number of you know with the size of the district and the number of parcels but we can we can get you for that less than $3 million that's good um so so those are some some thoughts on the rate the the other I think considerations are the duration of the measure so in the polling that you conducted last summer it assumed a measure that would continue until ended by voters so essentially in perpetuity parcel tax um it's interesting because in your polling when negative messages were tested the number one negative netive it
037was this is a forever tax that is going to go on and we kind of as voters we lose control over it um given that you're looking to increase the rate fairly substantially here I would advise not going for a permanent tax and putting a duration on it um I know I think there's been some discussion around 10 years if you were looking at 10 years I would advise you to go for nine just because there're these psychological thresholds and when you take over from a single digit number to a double digit number it's perceived differently uh that would also align you you know nine years put you um on schedule to have a renewal come back in either 2032 or 2034 which would be regularly scheduled elections less expensive than the the special elections
038so that that would be my recommendation on the duration um and then there's the cost of living adjustment your current measure is 3% um I know I've heard some talk of uh increasing that to 3.5 just to kind of keep up with uh inflation um I I mean the more you change in a measure the more scrutiny is going to attract right and we're already changing a lot especially with the methodology change on the tax rate I would advise you know that half% isn't going to be a ton of money if we're only talking about a nine-year measure If This Were an in perpetuity measure then yeah that makes a big difference 30 years from now um but I would say that you know keep that at 3% for a little more continuity with your
039current measure and if you look at most partial taxes in in Marin County 3% is the the cost of living adjustment and so it's sort of within the norm and I think for that reason we'll probably meet with less uh resistance um and then lastly the the potential uses of funding um the polling says pretty clearly that attracting and retaining teaches is the top priority for the community as I understand it that's how you're almost exclusively using your current partial tax revenue and how you would use this going forward so attracting and retaining teachers and how that relates to supporting quality educational programming I think that's kind of the intent and the the focus of this measure that's super verbiage the attracting and retaining teachers I understand what we're saying here but it makes it
040seem like we're trying to recruit rather than you know we want to pay our teachers more they deserve more money so I just I'm just kind of hoping that we can say it's about salaries so making it competitive salaries to keep our teachers I don't know just keep hearing that same verbiage over again I just hope we can massage that very standard for like school really standard but I mean that's the interesting thing about the messaging we can do whatever we want with the messaging yeah and make it clear to people and explain this is so we can pay our teachers a livable wage exactly that's this is what we've been listening to for the last two years in our board meetings and we're hearing them and we're trying to help that's what I I
041was hope we could sort of give back like this is what we want to give you back that's all that's I'm thinking I agree have to be very clear what do you think in that all of this I've sort of taken a lot of notes Here what what do you think is going to be the biggest bullet point of scrutiny in this whole mix um I I honestly I think it's justifying the tax rate and I mean you're you're asking the community here for to you know jump the revenue from 4.5 million to 7.5 million you know and I think you have to have to justify that um I I've seen the budget Road show that Tyler's been doing and I think he makes a great case for it you know you are the lowest
042funded District in the county your um compensation for your employees is becoming less competitive with every year uh and that has consequences right at some point you start losing your talent um and that has an impact on the quality of education so I think you have the story you need to to make that case um but you know it's not an insignificant jump in the in the tax rate I think that might be one of the challenges in the messaging is it is an increase in the rate and it's a decrease in tax for you know 50% of our community as well um so like when you think about an unimproved parcel that's a tax reduction for that person person if you talk about a person with a or family living in a place that's
043less than 1,800 ft I think was the average that tax rate is actually the the bill that they get is going to go down it's not going to go down because it's inclusive of the additional 3 million it's still going to go up it's going to go up to 998 it's going to go down relative to what they would if it was the same proposal on a per paral bis but it's still there the number is still going up to everybody unless I mean not to everybody there will be some homes my guess on the lower square footage like if you have a one of those 1100 squ foot Bungalows your tax rate might go down I would have to run the numbers to find out exactly what the square footage would be and I
044think it's an important bullet point to share with some of the folks and there's a there's a lot of smaller homes in our area and I think you know we're asking in terms of how you simplify the the messaging I think having some kind of um case examples of you know somebody who lives in a very small Bungalow less than x number of square feet here's what it would look like for them somebody who lives in an average size two-bedroom apart you two-bedroom house or apartment with kids here's what it look like three scen like three kinds of yeah just three not 119 no just a few kind of exam examples of what this might look like I think would be graspable and understandable for people um and tangible you know rather than just a
045bunch of numbers pictures of these houses or whatever you know so I think that simplifying that way and I think that can I mean there's communication on a flyer and then there's you know Road Show 2.0 that has a slide that has those examples what do you think if we did promote hey seniors the senior EX extion do you think have you seen that number going from X to Y if people do promote that the exemption is possible well um I mean seniors given that most of them don't have children in the schools tend to be you know one of the more resistant demographic groups um and you know the the message that you know you you are eligible for an optional exemption and it's I think it's important to explain it as optional so
046that people feel like that's their choice and they can contribute if they want to um I I I mean I I've seen that the dramatic impact it's hard to quantify but it'll turn a lot of votes in your favor that otherwise would be knows M so I would I mean virtually all school districts offer a senior exemption for this reason and I wouldn't consider taking that off the no I I'm just trying to figure out ways of making it easier for the people that are exempt and so the one time opt out is great for the next nine years they don't have to do something each here some of my neighbors said that's really confusing and they have to pay attention to that so the easier we can make that I don't know how we
047message that but maybe do the road shows and just conversations yeah and uh I mean we we have the names and addresses of every voter that's over the age of 65 so we can send them information I there's there's ways that we can communicate directly to that population so you can have targeted Communications based on the interests of particular voter populations do we know was that % of that opt out do we know what was for the Tam Union Bond what opted out you can't opt out yeah bonds don't have exemptions um but I I could find out um what what Tam senior exemption rate is for their partiel tax I would assume it's similar do do you know so the 25% was 25% of uh 25% of eligible voters 25% What's the total number
048of potential is it 25% of the total potential population that could opt out like yeah 25% of your residential Parcels are currently qualified for the exemption qualif now I don't know off the top of my head what percentage of your residential Parcels are age 65 plus that would potentially be eligible um that 25% is already fairly high so I would think you probably have a pretty high exemption rate already um and it's important the the senior exemption only appli applies to a principal residence so if I'm a landlord I can't apply for the senior exemption for my you know multif family rental property um so 25% are eligible or 25% are availing themselves of the exemption 25% of your residential Parcels are currently exempt okay currently availing themselves of that exemption and how many more
049are qualified but are not availing themselves do we know that I I don't know that we could approximate it though okay because I'm just thinking if we because that like you said there's a there's a little bit of a catch 22 of yes you want to let everybody know about it but that 25% could theoretically increase and to know what the potential total incre what's the maximum that it could go up to based on how many Parcels are occupied by people who could Avail themselves of that might be I would imagine I think doing a couple simple like a mailer and a link on our website that has the the form and to contact is enough um and then you know before the vote making sure everybody knows that there is an opt out and
050here's how you do it right is key I and you know even if it's an extra 5% that's not going to we're still going to have million a couple million dollars more you know 1.5 1.7 or 2.5 2.7 million more to pay our teachers so I don't think that's the like Lynch pin okay um but we can definitely make it really clear for folks where to do it and who to contact I just want to make sure that we know what that is like if if it's like 25% R but it could be 50% and we don't calculate that into the rate that we go for and then all of a sudden we're not getting the amount that we thought we were going to get because we didn't because all of a sudden that bumped
051way up would be helpful to make sure that we know you know what the potential increase is for the Outreach that we're going to be doing sure yeah we can run those numbers I think we need just make sure that our Communications are very clear and they're very comprehensive to like our entire Community because when I was campaigning I met a lot of people who were seniors who were like oh why do they why do you guys need more money and I had a lot of conversations to try and explain why we probably were looking at doing something like this in the future and most of them were like very supportive of it once you explained and I think every single person who was a little bit critical of having another tax once you talked
052to them they understood but they just had to understand why we were asking for it and what it was be used for so I think as long as we get The Upfront messaging very clear and very open transparent I think we're going to run into fewer problems um and most of the ones I said you know we always support our schools we just want to know why and I I think that's the Crux of it just if we can be very clear this is what it's going for I think they'll be supported and the 52 cents versus like 57 cents 15 9 cents does that and that gets US 52 Cents gets us the additional 3 million I think one of the things we talked about you know last time well if we just went
053for 3.5 million or something is there similar to your recommendation of going for nine years instead of 10 is there any other kind of strategy or thinking around going for 50 one cents or 54 cents or 5 like that I actual language that you use on the ble changing from you know 52 to 51 or 52 to 54 probably isn't going to move the needle a lot in support it's when you tip over those thresholds that it starts to make a difference so you know would 49 or 48 cents improve support probably marginally um but anything within that low 50 category I don't think is going to change support we we typically find that with square footage parcel taxes you see less rate sensitivity the rate can change more before you see corresponding changes in
054support that's not the case in per parcel rates right because when I go from 100 bucks to 150 bucks that's a very you know tangible difference that people can rationalize so um it's just it's it's one of the impacts of the square footage is that the cost is a little less obvious I've done some back of the napkin math um and I've shared this in the parcel tax uh slide deck that I have if you can remember back to where I shared the comparables between Kentfield lks record Madera and uh did I see Miller Creek and where we stand on a couple different parts of the salary schedule and there was some of it was the about half of it was green half of it was red I've run the projections for this year MO
055is turning red and I have data for larksburg corter Madera and uh Kentfield for next year because they've already settled with their unions and even more of that image turns red so what that articulates is that we are losing ground in the way that we're paying teachers and $3 million would give me enough to go to the bargain bargaining table to turn more of that image green not all of it green but more of it green and I think for me that's the rational rationalization for the $3 million Mark is to be competitive it doesn't mean we're way out in front of everybody else in terms of pay it doesn't mean we're paying the same as Reed or Ross with you know they're so deep into basic aid but we're competitive with our comparable districts
056and I think that number gets us in that ballpark yeah and do do we know if those were all partial versus square footage those um parcel taxs I I believe and you might know better than I that uh I think every par every parcel tax in the county is per parcel except for S Rin City just passed per square foot correct and in and in your um calculations with what you just explained about being competitive and what you know of the um agreements that were recently made are they were they were they and have they been in the past such that the 3 million the additional will not only allow us to be competitive now but will allow us to be competitive moving forward such that we're not going to immediately not be able to
057keep up with the Joneses with you know to be able to does that do you feel comfortable that this is I think we can I think I can project relatively confidently that over the next two years if we do a twoe settlement we can turn more of that image that I was talking about Green um it's hard to tell it it feels like there's a little bit of an arms race in Marin County and that's what I was getting at and I think they're districts are going to start having to have a long look in the mirror about what they're doing um you're seeing districts put submit qualified budgets you're seeing other districts cut the seven period day at middle school and I think one thing I've heard loud and clear from our communities that
058we want to keep our excellent student programs that we have in addition to paying our teachers a livable wage and I think this number gets us there for the time being but I don't know what superintendents are going to do around the county mhm over the next four years and if they're going to slash programs in order to do this because they want to attract and retain so I think it's a it's a sticky situation I think um you know there was J article recently about a district that's submitting a qualified budget in part because of what they're which which is where where I was getting at was this conversation of I mean The Sweet Spot that we're trying to find obviously is how much can we ask that we get past not too much
059not too little that we're going to you know yes we'll be whole for a while but are we going to be back in a hot seat again in a short period so it's really that Balancing Act of how much is reasonable that does not jeopardize our ability to pass it because ultimately that it needs to pass so yeah I mean we it's going to provide firmer scaffolding at least around our budgeting right and we don't know what State budget's going to look like I mean we have so many variables coming into play here right but at least if we can Elevate our own scaffolding to put us in a better position I think you know I think we might be we might be we're going to provide better pay again not you know out of
060the park but at least competitive pay for our teachers and then hopefully the other factors that go into our budgeting for our pay for our teachers will who knows where the wind will blow but this gives us a little more yeah yeah and I think one thing that I've talked with our Union Partners about is historically over the last 15 20 25 years compensation increases have typically closely mirrored the cost of living adjustment not always spoton sometimes a little lower sometimes a little higher and not until the inflationary period that we just hit recently and the co dollars that have hit school districts in which has been wonderful to support student learning have we seen these like eight n 10% uh salary agreements and I think I'm interested to see where superintendant across the state
061start going if we start moving back to that more traditional close to Cola agreement or if we keep doing this you know I'm going to offer eight and okay I'm gonna offer nine and I'm going to offer 15 um it's just not sustainable to be in that place where we've been in over the last few years all that to say I'd love to pay our teachers you know yeah as much as they like you know one important Point related to this conversation of the rate if we tick up much above 52 cents per square foot when you apply that to the average square footage it's going to take it to a number North of ,000 doll right and I do think there's some Advantage just again based on perceptions that you know this going to
062cost the average homeowner less than $ thousand doar less than a thousand is more Target yeah I agree I agree so I think that that feels like we're striking the balance between being aggressive and getting the revenue that we need to support the salary increases that we think are fair and not burdening our our taxpayers with you know excess tax we're really trying to make this a reasonable tax yeah um for for our community members yeah and it's only going to be under ,000 this first year year two at 3% you so it's again messaging but that's not a change no no I agree but you know just getting it approved that's a big deal um yeah I just don't yeah it's that balance of how do we I don't want to be here in
063four years we need another $2 million but it sounds like this is that you all and I very much appreciate the work and the thoughtfulness and the you know attention to all of these calculations to to try and thread that and what I'm hearing is that this is this feels like what we can do aggressively and meet what we need and there are other factors down the road right we're going to do new demographic study to see how many you know little two and three year olds we have run around our Our Two Towns um homes are going to continue to turn over which will increase our tax basis which should help us be more competitive in the future right I think the the state outlook on the budget at least recently is a little
064better than I think we had assumed which is good news um and then one of my big hopes is if we continue to flip in and out of basic Aid and lcff um Community funded and and state funded that we're increasing enrollment I mean I I want to increase enrollment I want this community to understand how great our teachers are how fantastic our school programs are and I want to have all of the kids that that live in our Two Towns come to our schools so I think those those other factors can help us stay competitive without having to come back and ask for more partial tax um you know that's helpful before this one expires I think that's yeah you know the nine-year term seems Seems Fair yep so I I want to do
065quick recap what I'm hearing Charles say is not having a cap because there's really only 30 Parcels that qualify anyways and only one of them is residential for a single family homeowner continue to keep the exemption seems like the right the right move simplifying not changing as much as as we can we want to make sure our seniors are here in support of this um a nine-year term feels like the right balance between having a good long term yet something that's you know that's nine years from 2025 26 tax year yeah from the year it goes into effect which be the coming fiscal year great a 3% um inflation cost of living adjustment and I think those are the the main factors is that did I cap paral versus square foot and I think you
066I mean that was what we had wrestled with last time that we were having a difficulty and mainly I think it was around can we simplify the messaging not conceptually I think it makes sense yeah um from from all of the arguments in terms of equity and use purpose of the money is based on any uh so I think it's been really helpful to hear kind of how this pans out and I feel optimistic about being able to have a simplified messaging in that area and that the calculations that you've made uh mean that it will still generate the kind of Revenue because that was the other question we had was if we go here you know we'll be will we be able to generate the revenue that we are assuming we need so yeah
067just listening to you Charles I think I think if we're looking at something for nine years and the wave of the future is to go to uh square footage we're going to look pretty archaic In Time by having this parcel per parcel so it seems to me that we just have to make sure that it's simplified doesn't confuse and honestly you know the population it really gets confused you know or the people or people that don't have kids in the system are older right and if we exempt them anyway we might be taking that population that's like doesn't want to think about it out of the you know I'm just going to say it um so you know I I really fought against it at first I was like make it simple make it flat
068but the Equitable argument I think is going to help us help us a lot I know as a homeowner here I feel that way um you know that's where I stand I wonder what the and again this could just be on the margin like how many over 65 are currently paying the parcel tax that have a house greater than 19900 ft so they even though they're paying today they might opt out because oh I've got a 2400t house it's optional I don't have to pay that was my only other that was a question that I was addressing earlier I think that's the only other variable that I would like to make sure that we look into before we actually nail down because if it's because if if you know it's all assumptions that you have
069to do in the calculations to put this on the bance so if we if we're going to have to make some sort of of assumption that says 25% now through this campaign we might expect that to increase by X for new people or if a large percentage of people that are over 65 who are currently opting out have a house smaller than 1900 sare feet because they've been here for 30 years maybe they might be in oh maybe right like I again it's margin doesn't really just thinking about the demographics of the community you already have 25% of your Residential Properties opting out I can't imagine that more than like 40% of your total residential partials are over the age of 65 that's probably a really high estimate so you know I I I and
070you're never going to have 100% participation in the exemption right so I think that the you know it will change around the margins but I don't think it's going to be and then the 3% cost of living adjustment each year is that on the 52 Cent per square foot or how do you apply that because in year two then it's like one and a half cents so then am I paying 503 and a half cents per square foot yeah we we can write the language of the measure I mean one you can't assess it you know based on a fraction of a scent or we can write into the language of the measure that it's going to be the you know rounded to the nearest cent or something to that effect like your current rate
071yeah but it's just the the way it works it's 3% applied to the tax rate then applied to all that taxable square footage um plus the exemptions does that matter do like does that 3% is 3% if it's per partial versus per square fo you're still paying the same thing cost you the same and I think I think one of the decisions I'm hearing the board make is that our this partial tax has been voted on I think four or five times so it's been upheld in this in this community for 30 years and I think that's important to note that that our seniors our young families have voted yes on this for 30 years um and I think that's really important to note um and I just lost the other point that I was
072trying to make maybe it'll come back to me I I also I mean I also feel very optimistic I mean I think the solidarity that I'm hearing among all different types of constituents really appreciate the statements that we've heard the past couple meetings from the teachers union and from other employees and Educators and community members and you know the feedback and the sense of the sense of unity and everyone coming together to make this happen feels like a ground swell of positiveness um that's giving me a lot of Hope energy optimism so I really I appreciate that and I think it's just going to continue to carry us forward um so the other point I was trying to make it's been voted on and upheld for 30 years Mo the most recent one we took
073from a 4% cost of living adjustment and moved it down to a 3% and this board is recommending maintaining that reduction not moving back to that old 4% rate and I think that that's you know another sign that we're trying to be really reasonable with this this tax and not just go out and get as much as we can we're trying to be really thoughtful and reasonable here yeah and you know maybe I'm bringing um a blanket to auna but I just want to understand what type of guidance of Charles if from you how we're going to Soldier this you know um I know that everyone wants to to to be involved in you know is it is it so Grassroots that we're knocking on doors is there an opportunity to perhaps have even um
074a a um an internet presence to talk about this you know what type of what type of you know messaging are we going to be able to use to get this this momentum going sure um so there's two pieces to that answer one is what the school district can do in the runup to the election and then what you need in terms of a community campaign so um you have a window of time from now until shortly after you actually put the measure on the ballot when the district can use public funds and public resources to communicate factually you know here's our budget situation here's why we need an extra3 million here are the consequences if we don't have it and we can work with Tyler to put together some messaging and I would encourage
075the district to do everything it can to get that message out because that kind of lays the foundation of knowledge for why we're even asking for this um then beyond that you know I don't want to underestimate this is a significant undertaking any measure that requires a two-thirds vote and the fact that this this is you know you're looking to place this on the ballot in a special election means that you also have to think about voter turnout right because voter turnout on the natural in any special election is going to be quite low it's usually in the 30 to 40% right uh participation rate range the key to being successful in these special elections is communicate to those people that are likely to vote make sure you persuade as many of them to vote
076Yes but also influence turnout to your advantage by mobilizing supporters to make sure they get their ballots in and that's where the knocking on door and having the face to-face conversations is important to identify who your supporters are and then follow up and make sure they actually cast their their ballot um but campaigns these days are typically a combination of that type of Grassroots Outreach and that's where leaning on your parent groups and your employee associations is really important because they're the boots on the ground that help you get that done but in addition to that um direct mail um signage in the community um targeted digital advertising you know usually the various social media platforms campaign should have a website you know you can have that information about the cost and and whatnot readily
077available to voters um so you know and that's part of what we can do is is help you put together that strategy for from the point we put this on the ballot through to election day how do we both persuade voters but also mobilize our our supporters to make sure they vote in a low turnout election and I don't know what the laws are but regarding signage in the community are we allowed to have signage on school campuses for this we're not not if it Advocates okay not if it advocates for the passage of the measure yeah we can't use a public resource in any way to advocate for the measure I thought so I just wanted to make sure because I know a lot of teachers want to promote this but I don't was
078just wondering what our paramet were does the clock start ticking on that limitation uh from the approval like this tonight is just a conversation and providing direction does the clock start on that from the day that we make an actual decision or from the when it goes on the ballot which I think you said was like a February February 6 deadline yeah I think but January 29th is when you would actually adopt the resolution and that's where we're we're official we have something on the ballot so you can never use public resources to advocate for any ballot measure right um however you know when we're in this period where we don't we we only have a hypothetical measure at this point right there's more latitude in terms of of what you can do and what
079you can say once that measure is on the ballot that's where the scrutiny increases right and that's where you want to be very careful that you know District staff when they're on the job you know they can provide information they can't Advocate anyway that goes for you know your teachers as well so they have to be very careful to the extent they're going to be involved in the campaign they're doing this on their own time not on District Time same goes for facilities District dollars obviously we just have to be real careful that any advocacy is privately funded and done so by vol unteers that aren't a district resource so but the parents can do whatever we want we don't run into that restriction with parents they can't bring signs onto campus though and wave
080them there what they can do is they can like on the street have a table out front at the entrance of the school perhaps okay just just you know stand you know table what is it that come that what um what format does our decision Mak take on February when we have to make the decision do we have is it all of the f is it a formal resolution with all of the formal ballot language that we are approving is it terms that then get translated what does that tell us a little bit about what that looks like yeah so so if we leave here tonight with agreement on what we've talked about you know the tax rate the duration the cost of judgment um Tyler and I will go back and work with the
081district's legal council to put all that into the form of a resolution that basically you know puts that on the before the voters um and it also includes all the language instructing the county regist voters to conduct this election on you know in May 2025 and and why not so that's what you would be considering and approving on the on January 29th okay so substantive you know input is really important tonight where when we come back in January 29th it's really going to be you know a little bit more discussion maybe some clarifying um but if we're if there's going to be a substantive change on the 29th would have to have a special board meeting really soon after that in order to meet that February deadline we could make minor changes to the resolution
082on the night but okay yeah great the more we can have this sort of set going into the meeting the smoo will be yeah is there any push back so I'm looking at the current one the measure e and we uh went into effect 2020 and it was for eight years so 5 years later we're asking for more money and to is there any meant like oh why don't you guys ask for more then or why are we doing this sooner does that and that was Co so everything's foggy does that have any impact in people's perception well this measure would be written to replace the old measure so the old one would go away this one would take effect and I think that you know given what's happened with salary increases and changes in
083the state budget and Co dollars going away and enough has changed that it's reasonable to think that we need to rethink this proposal now and maybe that's a good way of some type of communication around I think that for for me there is so much that has changed between 2020 and now in like you mentioned I mean the co the economy politically I mean there's just so many changes just to say so much has changed since this was implemented it makes sense to create a new one without having to get too complicated into the details and I think that will resonate with all of us who've experienced all that change also it was 2018 when we did maure taxable real property beginning July 1st 2020 it was 2018 when it worked on that one it
084was to renew to 2028 so I don't know if that's a t or not but working on that one I mean I'm you're you need you need direction right Tyler tonight um I think your recap accurately reflects I think the one thing I didn't capture was what I'm hearing Charles suggest is per square foot and I think most of the board is in alignment with that suggestion yes okay yeah and having that standard I just did the map 1100 foot would pay 572 that's a win for X percentage of property owners whatever those percentages are 1900 is under a thousand okay that's still a lot that's 30% more than I'm paying today but okay but less than if it was on a per yeah so I don't know how we promote that and 2400 foot
085would be twice as much as they're paying today and you know whatever 3,000 ft is almost 2 and a half times as they're paying today loose numbers so that's that's a big difference right for a 24 foot home they're paying twice as much than they are today and again it's not majority right that's where and it is Equitable um that's where that's where the messaging around what is this why do we need this and what is it going to comes into play so I think the messaging of why do we need this in terms of paying you know paying a living wage attract and retain if we don't what happens comes into play when you're just looking at the what are you paying today what might you be paying tomorrow and then there's different messaging
086for people who are asking like why are you you know it's like the EIC why are you changing it from per parcel then that's a different set of messaging and explanations for that um why is that changing question which is different than why is it going up so it's just I mean that's part of the polling you know we tested a a big set of potential arguments in favor the most persuasive argument to your voters was having a great teacher in the classroom is the most important element of providing quality education this measure will help Ross Valley School District attract and recruit the best teachers to our classrooms so if we want to make it simple it's all about having a great teacher in the classroom that's what this allows us to do yeah when
087we have hundreds and hundreds of emails we've received over the last two years to that effect I mean what we need to do is find those people and be like hey come help us because we're ready for it send them my way have you heard of um in terms of the Outreach campaign and everything um we had you know just really heartfelt and important uh public comment for two years that we have recordings of for all of those meetings that I think uh are also very important messaging for the community directly in the voice of teachers who are here so I think that we have all of that as well um which is what we're what we're responding to so um we haven't talked about transition for communication to like a community Le campaign so
088I don't know are we ready to move on do we have any more terms that you needed to get nail down or I think we're good think we got it um so the transition to the community Le campaign you know again the district can't be involved in that process it has to be separate but you know through all the conversation you all have had over the last couple years I'm sure there are folks that have emerged that are passionate about this issue and so what I would encourage is over the next you know few weeks as we're finalizing the measure qualifying for the ballot that that group start to form and get together and have conversations it sounds like you have some folks that have been involved in past campaigns um I I'm happy to
089share some recommended sort of organizational structures for how you divide and conquer the different tasks of the campaign um you have to do private fundraising um your schools foundation and your parent organizations uh as independent 501c3 organizations can contribute to that campaign so that's a potential source of funds uh your employee associations other community donors that's typically how you raise the dollars to fund the advertising and the signs and the direct mail um but uh yeah between now and the end of the month start getting that organization pulled together um come February um there's going to be some deadlines once the measures on the ballot for submitting the official argument in favor of the measure that gets published in the ballot pamphlet so that ADV group will need to um draft an argument and you
090can have up to five people sign on to that with their names and titles that's an important group to show broad-based support for the measure um and then start working to put together a campaign plan so you know does did you just say that the official argument in favor also need has a deadline of February 6th it's not February 6th I don't know the date off the top of my head it's going to be in about mid-February and how how generally how important is I'm just thinking the last campaign and you know you read through your booklet and you see what you're voting on and then you see the for and against and that's what you're talking about is those statements exactly it's actually in the voter pet yeah how how much influence do you
091think that has on success um I mean I think it's important every single registered voter is going to receive that booklet and in this special election it's going to have one issue in it right so it's not like the big thick booklet we get before the general election you know it's going to have one issue um and there's an opportunity for opponents to have a statement in there so at the very least you want to make sure you've countered that um I mean it's it's free to the campaign they don't charge you anything to be able to send something to every registered voter so i' take advantage of it so what is is that date set I'm looking for that online is there a special election date well yeah um I don't I don't think
092the county has released a calendar for this May's election it's a county decision yeah yeah County Register voters is what uh administer do we know else is going to be on that nothing that I know of I think this would be the only item on the P for our for our jurisdiction yeah okay what are the potential oppos opposition things that we would need to be thinking about or be mindful of either groups or whatever that would possibly create one of those opposition things or just be out there in the community sure um I mean usually opposition to measures like this is just so anti-tax and people may make the argument that we're already taxed to death with all these other taxes that have been proposed um so I think that's where you just need
093to be prepared to justify why we need this funding and you know without it what the consequences would be um you know there's a fairly active anti-tax group in in Marine County that you know you might want to meet with if you haven't done so already and have some conversations with them and they they tend to like these square footage um tight partial taxes so you're structuring something that I think they could probably live with um but that's just going to require some conversation to hopefully reduce their motivation to oppose you Rachel you've been involved in a lot of these do you have anything that we're not thinking about that we should be thinking about with respect to this segment of the campaign I mean mostly just thinking of like getting that community group formed
094and having them ready to take the the Reigns and kind of run with it um but for me that seems to be like the lead priority I think the terms we've agreed on are pretty much everything I would have requested um I think that that's going to be really key what once that group is formed what can board members do and not do with respect to that group in terms of yes or no leadership positions only attend things in the evening like what are the what are those kind of things that need to be thought about in terms of yeah so so you all as board members have more flexibility than Tyler for example right because you're not full-time employees of the district so you have more time flexibility so you can you can be
095involved in the campaign as long as you're not using a district resource so you know if you have a district issued uh email address don't use that for campaign communication use your personal email address um you know don't hold campaign meetings in a School District owned office do that at somebody's home or you know some private facility um so it's really just making sure that you're not using a public resource um you know I've heard concern about well can five board members attend a campaign meeting or is that a brown act violation I mean technically the brown Act only applies to to business that would come before the board and campaign business obviously can't because districts can't campaign but with that said you probably want to be careful that you're not creating perceptions of impropriety
096so you know maybe have two board members that are to attend those meetings even if all five are involved in the campaign in some fashion that is what they did in 2018 there were two designated board members who were part of the campaign but they were not the leads on the campaign that they were there that they did a fair amount so is there strategies on people that have kids in high school or college so in our district but they're no longer in our district versus T you know everybody's eventually going there so okay I can get behind that is there some yeah um so I think you know leading on some of your sort of alumni parents can be helpful you know that's a population that you would hope would be supportive of this
097to kind of you know pay it back um and then um you know I would also think about having Representatives on that Campaign Committee that are part of the senior population so you're kind of reaching outside of that you know obvious parent group to find tentacles into those you know groups and create relationships there to communicate with those populations you know the more you can have representation on your Campaign Committee for kind of all the key factions of the community you know business Community representation on some level maybe even you know folks that you know own rental properties or something like that you know then your your opening lines of communications to the full community um what is or isn't the role of other Municipal agencies in our community in something like this to be
098kind of in solidarity and showing Like We Are One Community the whether were the fire department the police department the town the county you know that we are all in this together for all of our kids um or is that something that is not typically some done so so they can't use public resources to advocate for your measure either um what they can do though is their elected boards or councils can adopt resolutions of support just taking an official position of support so I don't know if you did that for tamel pas' Bond measure last year but you could have and they could adopt a resolution supporting your parcel tax just going on record is supporting this that's that's about the only way as public agencies they can support your efforts but the Tam Union
099PTA could could promote or Advocate they can their schools foundations can as well yeah CU those are are independent organizations it's not part of the school district okay that's helpful thank you you can seek endorsements from their board members you know other leaders within the district you know endorsements are key having a broad list of people that support this you know it just creates a sense that okay people that I know and respect are supporting this measure um mail in votes versus in person day of is there like one so it's a special it's mail and only mail and only so that could be whatever time those mailers are sent so we just would have to work back from that date the the ballots are mailed to all voters 29 days before election day so
100basically back up a month so will be beginning of April um and um what we find typically is the vast majority of the ballots they're returned by mail but they're returned by mail at the end of the voting period people just tend to procrastinate in that way so um strategically the campaign will need think about the timing of its communication so you know but throughout that roughly 30-day voting period That's when most of your key messaging is going out also strategically for the campaign um it's a public record as to whether each and every registered voter in your district has returned to Ballot or not so if you're smart as a campaign and you've built a good database if who your supporters are you could track and see if they've returned their ballot and follow
101up with them if they haven't until you see that ballot come in so there's some strategies in these special elections that help you influence turnout that's harder to do in the big general elections that's good still any other questions response and then since we can't use District resources obviously when do your your services stop when we put the resolution on or when like when or when we approve the resolution when we put it on on February 6th or when does that happen I know when it transitions over my contract is scheduled to run for two weeks after the qualific qualification deadline so we can kind of get you on the ballot do the wrapup communication related to that so the community knows what's been placed on the ballot uh but then that's when my relationship
102with the school district ends and so if the community Campaign Committee were to want us to help advise the campaign we're available to do that as soon as our district contract is ended well I really appreciate your Insight this was wildly supportive for me tonight I think we've had some really good discussions um about this and this just really crystallized and clarified things for for me so thank you over yes thank you have to do public comment before we oh we do public comment before we did that thank you all right so do we have any other questions do you need anything else from us all right thank you very much yes sure thing my pleasure okay so moving on agenda um with that it is 7:05 and I will adjourn our meeting