001e instructions for accessing subtitles in a language other than English are included on our board meetings web page as well as in the description below inst Des e hi good evening and welcome to the belly School District Board of trist's regular meeting today is December 18th 2024 and I am calling our meeting to order at 602 uh we have the following trustees present in person here at the Ross Valley School District office myself Rachel lwak Daniel Cassidy and Shelley Hamilton um trust Ryan O'Neal and truste Chris land's cob are not in attendance tonight um we also have cabinet members president uh present superintendent graph um Eric Sable and Chris Carson uh the meeting is being live streamed via YouTube and the links on our website and on the agenda there will be a 60-second delay
002between the meeting and the YouTube live stream an audio recording of the meeting will be made available to the public on our district website within 72 hours following the meeting um and with that I will um go over to our agenda the first item we have is closed session um I'm going to identify the items in closed session our topics are conference with legal council anticipated litigation significant significant exposure to litigation pursuant to government code 54956.9 subdivision D2 or three special education program dispute three cases student SSID 33673 02355 number 521 737 7477 and number 645 966 2261 the other item under this agenda for close session is liability claims significant exposure to litigation pursuant to government code 54956.9 section d23 when case claim number 25001 um and with that there is no public here
003for public comment so at 604 I will recess us to closed session e e e by all right thank you and we are reconvening at 7:01 for the closed session um our report out from close session is um there was approval of the special education program dispute all three cases um SS ID number 33673 02355 uh number 521 737 7477 and case number 645 966 2261 um the other item of the liability claim was denied um and that was uh significant exposure to litigation pursuant to government code 54956.9 d231 case claim 25001 and with that I'm moving on our procedural items the first which is the Pledge of Allegiance um so if you'd like to S with me to of the United States of America TOS One Nation God indivisible withy and justice for allk
004you and item is to adopt the agenda and time allocations and um we would like to actually revise the order of the items so we would like to move item number two to the item number five spot and just flipflop number five and two if that's all right with everybody sure so if that is okay then I will entertain a motion to adopt our agenda as modified there oh and uh just for the record Chris land's cob our trustee has just entered the room at 72 hell we were um just discussing adopting the agenda and moving item number two to item number five spot and just put flopping them on the agenda so I will entertain your that shift I would make a motion with the amendment to adopt the agenda thank you do have
005a second I'll second it sh hi Daniel hi Chris hi Rachel hi all right so we have adopted our agenda and the next item is communication which is a public comment regarding items not on the Open Session agenda um anybody has any open comments open public comments not on the agenda seeing none I will move on the next item is correspondence and communication to the board um we had one item listed there um the next item is uh presentation and or action items the first one there is the Board of Trustees terms of office both of office swearing and ceremony recognition and reception of reelected trustees so with that we have a guest here today hi everybody hi ready to get started um I was mentioning as I came in I think I I'm not
006sure I know everybody but I'm John Carol County Superintendent of Schools and I get the uh the honor of of circulating throughout the county um last week and this week administering the oath of office to um I don't think I hit every single School District but really close and it's really nice to check in with people and I was mentioning this is the least awkward of my um swearing in ceremonies because I had endorsed all three candidates that are back on the board and that wasn't the case everywhere so there are some places is I to swear people and they were nice and polite but um maybe a little bit different than here I also feel a special kinship with the Ross Valley School District having um worked here at one time and having a
007couple of colleagues who had worked with in varying roles uh over the years um so my pleasure to be here tonight and I will um if I could get our the three candidates candidates not candidates anymore the three um trustees who've been reelected to stand and raise your right hand and uh the way this will work is um I'll say I and then there's a blank and I'll pause and you say your name and then just repeat after me and I think I have it down now where I do it in a Cadence that you can keep up with and that took some doing there's some people I get you know like too many words we got we got this but you do have to listen carefully okay I I shamilton City do solemnly swear
008do solemnly swear or affirm or that I will support and defend the Constitution that I will support and defend the Conti of the United States of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies all enemies foreign and domestic foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear true faith and aliance to the Constitution of the United States to the constition of the United States states and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely take this obligation freely without any mental reservation any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully I will well and
009Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter upon congratulations I just want to take a moment to express my gratitude as I do for trustees everywhere um stepping into a job and you're all veterans at this point so you know what it's like and yet you come back the I think the most one of the most thankless elected jobs you can have it's unpaid it's a lot of work when things go smoothly no one knows who you are when things go bad everyone points their fingers at you so it's not one of these places where you can find a lot of Glory um some people use it it as a stepping stone to hire political office I don't think that's the case as far as I can tell it also
010doesn't work very well for those people who do once in a while it does there few people who um used as a stepping stone but I think you are all here and I have some personal experience in observing your work over the last several months um and I'm I'm convinced that you're you're here for all the right reasons that you're here to serve kids to make sure that students students learn and grow emotionally every day so um my gratitude and I I think I Express gratitude from your community as well and on on behalf of the county of Maron for the work that you do so thanks very much for being here I just want to reaffirm what John said here part of the reason I applied for this job was the strength and stability
011of this board so having that strength and stability continue on is something I know I'm really excited about our community is excited about and our staff is really excited about so I'm personally looking forward to the work that we have ahead of ourselves and I know that this board will will do the right thing by kids congratulations E3 thank you thanks good luck wait to wait to leave the room thank you all right so we can have a short reception here uh we do want to move on with the agenda we've got a pretty packed one but we do have refreshments and cookies we do have some family members here so um feel free to stand upot have have some refreshments uh and we'll we'll get started maybe in about 10 minutes does that sound
012good yeah great e e e all right welcome back thank you for that small reception um our next item on our agenda is the annual Board of Trustees organizational weights this is number two we switched around right yep sorry my bad um our next item is the board discussion for the purpose of giving direction to the superintendent regarding partial tax renew all so that was item two or yeah two there was five and is now two okay so this is Tyler sorry about that great well I'm excited to bring this presentation to you um tonight uh some of the slides that I'm about to show many of you have already seen so I'll move through some of them pretty quickly um but essentially we are uh asking the board for some direction around details around
013continuing a partial tax that we currently have um and adjusting some of the terms and the amount this is a partial tax that uh community of Ross Valley has supported for over 30 years um so we expect that uh that that support will continue so why are we considering increasing the partial tax and I think uh this really starts with what I've heard loud and clear from the community is the quality of our teachers classified staff and administrators is exceptional here we want to continue to retain and uh you know attract new teachers diverse teachers and and staff um to support our students and one of the problems is we have the lowest per pupil Revenue in in the county which makes it very difficult to compete with surrounding districts or even uh similar districts
014with similar funding uh structures that we do so in order to solve that problem we've got two options we can go through budget cuts uh we've had the budget advisory committee this year um bring us a list of cuts which we'll bring to the next board meeting for you to consider um or we can go out and try to increase Revenue through adjusting the current partial tax that we have um moving forward you've seen this one before it's just an articulation of uh districts on the left side our state state funded and the more lowincome uh English language learner homeless and Foster youth students drive more funding so a district like santaf fell gets $12 million above the state minimum um and then other school districts that have larger property tax revenues uh can generate
015you know six8 1020 million above the state minimum we're right down there with Miller Creek Kent field and larksburg Court of Dara kind of right at the bottom and we along with Miller Creek kind of flip-flop between state funded and Community funded um this is a really good articulation of exactly how that looks in practice um there we are at the top of this but really the lowest funded in the county U Miller Creek has $600 per student more than we do and then uh you can see Nado Kentfield Larks Corda over $1,000 uh more than than we have um having $1,000 more per student would really help solve a lot of our budget problems s so we have to augment this Revenue through a partial tax um and when you compare our partial tax
016to partial taxes of our comparison districts at least the ones we're considering comparison districts this year uh were on the low end so not only our revenues low but our partial tax is relatively low uh in comparison this year we're at uh just under $700 $699 next year we'll bump up to $720 and when you compare that to Larks cord Mader and Kentfield you know we're 300 to $1,100 behind them you also notice that our inflation rate is lower we're at 3% lar cord Madera is at 5% and you can see Miller Creek at 5% as well we also have the shortest term um eight years where you see other districts at 10 and 12 years so when we're talking about you know reorganizing uh the current partiel tax these are some things for for
017us to consider uh the conversations I've had with folks were not recommending getting as high as Kentfield we think that's a pretty high parcel tax um we're looking for something closer in that larksburg cour of Madera um range and I think that would get us to a place where we could offer competitive salaries for all of our staff you've seen this before you'll see this again with Chris's presentation later tonight the yellow line there you can see the revenues uh starting in 2122 was at 27 million went to 30 million then went down a little bit still basically 30 million uh this year 2425 went down under 30 million uh and it's going to kind of stay in that range next year and then bump up to 31 million you can see our revenues really
018are pretty darn flat over the last handful of years and we all know that the prices of everything is going up um we're giving r raises to our our teachers so it's becoming more and more challenging to meet the needs of the district with relatively flat revenues uh the the scary thing for me is really the red line there you'll see in the last four years from 23 24 all the way through 26 27 we're going to be deficit of spending um the real numbers are the first three you see we put $2 million into the reserves in 2122 that's a real number um we put $2 million into the reserves in 2223 last year we spent down the revenue the reserves by over half a million and then the last three numbers are projections
019uh right now we're projected to deficit spend by $2.6 million it probably won't be that but it'll be in the high 1 million very close to 2 million um when we come back to in October and then you've got a $3 million deficit and a $1.2 million deficit in that 26 27 years so we need to fix the structural deficit and we need to do a better job paying our staff uh you can see the projection for revenues is going down here reserves reserves thanks I appreciate that um the first three numbers are real numbers 26.6 25.7 and 23.1 um and then the following three numbers are projections at 16.4% 8.7 and 5.7 uh this again the state requirement is a 3% reserve the boards ask is a 10% reserve and an Elementary District average
020across the state is 25% you've seen this before um this is a comparison of a couple different places in the salary schedule with these comparison districts what you see in green is us paying better than the the comparison district and what you see in red is them paying more so when I came to you earlier in the year I felt confident that we were kind of in the ballpark we're we're right there we got some higher some lower we we're competitive there have been settlements across the the districts everything but Miller Creek has had a settlement so we've had a settlement Kentfield Marksburg cord and have a settlement you can see there's more red this year than there was last year so we're getting less competitive fewer green boxes and those green boxes we have
021are just you know a percentage or two above the comparison districts and then when we start looking out to next year obviously we haven't settled for next year those numbers may increase if we get a parcel tax they will likely not increase if we don't get a parcel tax so those numbers may stay stagnant if we don't um get a parcel tax a lot of red here and you look at the percentages that we've put there these are much higher percentages so when you compare the first starting sell k field you'd get paid almost 133% more than you get paid here almost 4% Larks cord of Madera and without a settlement 3.7% higher at Miller Creek so this is an increasingly urgent issue for us um to make adjustments here and increase the revenue so
022we can pay our teachers an appropriate salary um I extended this uh as well this used to be a three-year total I've added this year's in there as well so you can see Miller Creek has a TBD if they settle for more than a a third of a percent they'll bump in front of us and we'll fall back um here so I came to you earlier this year saying we've been aggressive we're in the ballpark and now we're kind of sliding behind as we move forward um we we gave 1.35% this year we felt like that's what we could afford um it increased our deficit spending just giving that small percentage um so in order to continue to give raises we're going to need to have an increase in the parcel tax um so the
023parcel tax would be used to pay teacher salaries that's what we'd use it for um because we could pay more for more teacher salaries it would also alleviate some of the strain on our unrestricted budget which would allow us to have salary increases for our counselors um our support staff our custodial staff everyone else that works across the district um it could could help us increase some program improvements I'm thinking specifically for uh tier 2 intervention for our students or special ed services um and it could give us a little bit more breathing room for facilities maintenance however the parcel tax will not be used for administrate of salaries facilities improvements or pension obligations explicitly so it's kind of an implicit um dance here uh so what happens if the ballot measure doesn't pass we'll
024have to implement the list of budget cuts uh up to $500,000 to the budget advisory committee forwarded to us and that means a guest support teacher and this is kind of like a roving substitute that helps with uh alleviating you know unfilled subs or supporting with um you know a teacher need to leave their classroom to attend an IEP meeting um they're pretty important our principles really enjoy that support a few Tech platforms teacher leadership positions at White Hill and reducing uh class SE is in increasing class size at White Hill salary increases will also stagnate um with a three with a projected 3 million dollar deficit next year it's very unlikely we'll be able to give a single percent next year um very very difficult next year and then potentially we'll need to consider
025deeper Cuts in the out years and this would be the seven period day where our kids get to electives um Counseling Services certificated PE teachers at the elementary school teacher at the elementary school level kids would still get PE but teachers would need to do the the teaching we wouldn't have certificated PE to allow teachers to have prep time and that would need to be negotiated with their Union Partners um and then fifth grade instrumental music so you can see it's pretty significant if we did not get the the measure passed and here's what happens if it does pass we can negotiate meaningful salary increases with our Union Partners potentially do multi year settlement we haven't done one of those in in a while and it would be a nice thing to have us focus
026on other things than um salary increases it help us attract and retain high quality diverse staff members um and would make our salary schedule more competitive with our comparative districts would also be able to maintain our excellent student programs we have fantastic programs here our elective programs are amazing our band our music our art programs are fantastic we have good tier two interventions for our students I'd love to see those increase um with a partial tax we'll still have a little bit of movement in the budget uh to allow us to do that um we can also examine our systems of of student support maybe keep some students from getting IEPs because we give them support before they need it need an IEP um and we'll be able to minimize or eliminate the structural deficit
027so some questions for the board to consider tonight should the tax be a per parcel tax which is what the current structure is or should we go to a per square foot parcel tax which would mean a smaller home would pay less tax and a larger home would pay a larger tax um what should the annual inflation rate be right now we're at 3% um what should the term of the partiel tax be it ends in 2028 but we could reup now and do an eight a 10 or a 12E term um should we consider a senior exemption senior exemptions are not allowed in a bond which is for facilities but they are allowed in a parcel tax which usually is used for programs and salaries um right now we're recommending about a three $3
028million increase to the overall partial tax if you'd like to see an adjustment for that please let us know um and should we hire a consultant to support us with that informational campaign so those are some of the questions to consider happy to take direction from the board or answer any questions you might have you know Tyler you and I had a moment to talk about this because I didn't think I was going to make this meeting today and you know one of the things that concerns me about a per parcel or per square foot is the confusion that it can cause and I think that anytime you confuse taxpayers to vote on something it dismantles our ability to pass it so I am in favor of not having a um per square foot but
029just per parcel and I know that in some cases you can say well what about the bigger properties we're losing out but you also have a population of individuals here that can opt out of that parcel tax so that I think sort of fills the glass and empties it at the same time and I think that the the one thing that I want to make sure we do is that we pass this right um that's that's my biggest concern in terms of the annual inflation rate we' also talked about that as well in 2022 believe it or not the inflation rate was 99.6% it's crazy okay um the Federal Reserve is projecting an annual inflation rate of 2.1% in 2026 and the bringing in Trump's proposed tariffs will be at 2.3 I think if we
030have a shorter tail of an 8-year parcel tax we can we can safely stay at 3% unless there's an anomaly like the 9.6 but I think that given the administration's goals to do the things they want to do uh for Tech and corporations they are incentivized to keep that inflation rate low as well as the individual who's been hired to head treasury who is a te- Bel expert so I believe that we we will at least buy ourselves four years so we don't have to up that 5% and I think that's another scary turnoff as well for voters so I think staying at that 3% and and and I have some other things in there but I wanted to just throw those two strong comments out for us to think about um just making sure
031that we provide a red carpet for our taxpayers to understand I think the what could happen if we don't pass it and what could happen what will happen if we don't and the ease of understanding that it's just very clear and very clean for taxpayers that's my two SS I appreciate that yeah I like the eight eighty year I mean I'm not a financial expert but we can it's doesn't seem like you're as locked in right things may change and you can always renew sooner kind of like what we're proposing now so I kind of like that and I would follow Chris's lead on the inflation numbers right if that's a if that feels right to our community which we know it's very cost sensitive again it lowers that barrier of of rejection so I
032just want to say on the eight-year renewal it's traditional like it maybe at two to three years out you always are starting to prepare to renew it ahead of time like you know like in 2020 when our expired we started in 2018 to renew it so it's like it's this so eight years is not a very long run time for another one 10 years I mean and that's a big it's a big lift from the community community has to do it can't be District funds right so it's like I can see the appeal of having maybe 10 years because it's it's a constant like you have to find the people you have to get experience and it's like then you're waiting to see if things are going to be renewed or not and then you
033need to have enough lead time if it fails to do it again to get a smaller amount like they did at T Bond so I think having the extra two years for me somebody who's worked on partial taxes in bond having the extra time I appreciate it I do see like you know I'm going to have to pay on my tax bill as well so I mean for that the 3% I could see why you'd be more appeeling as well but I don't know that we want to stick with eight when if we're looking at the other three comparable districts they all have 10 or 12 but if you go 10 years would you stay at an inflationary rate of three or would you up it to five I guess what I'm hear is the
034longer you go out the more variability and unpredictability do you have it's only two years only two years but but you're looking at you're looking at different administrations on a federal level that can come in and dismantle any type of inflationary precautions that are in place right and it can it can it can go south within six months but you'll have that in four years maybe you could also consider I know the examples here were 3 and 5% but if you all wanted to move to 3 and half% or 4% like there's no hard number three or five you oh really yeah that's that's oh yeah because what does that do I mean what I'm thinking I mean we've we're already already far behind in allowing our teachers to live here and be able to
035afford it whether you know this happens or not what is what ises that massaging of those numbers at at a half percent do because that would be interesting to see right yeah I was going to say I think some of this for me I I'm I'm doing scenario turning my head of like you know 3% over 10 years on a square foot I me you've got obviously you've got a you've got a bunch of variables here so you kind of have to and I'm thinking of scenarios and then what you're saying is then that's the revenue side of the scenario but then I'm also thinking of the expense side of the scenario which is what actual inflationary rates are plus what actual potential you know escalation and salaries are to keep up with the rest
036of the districts who are going to be continuing to do like I don't want to be back in this seat again in six years because we can't keep up with that and we underpin what we need what we need which I think is what I'm hearing saying which I agree with I don't want to undershoot it such that we're right back here in five years and I think the last time the district uh renewed a parcel tax we kept everything status quo so we didn't up the amount we didn't up the we dropped the inflator from 4 to three last in 2018 so we went down so we would what was that based on that decision to go from four to three then they didn't want it to fail right okay and I think that's
037something for the board to consider is which of the toggles do you want to move up or down in order to get the yes because the ultimate thing is we want the yes so we're not inac the cuts that we talked about and we have to be careful are we toggling it because it looks good or we toggling it because it's going to have an effective impact on what we can offer our teachers because 3% three and a half go for you know that's what the scenario things you have to do are because again you don't want to toggle it down so low that you're not actually going to be able to achieve the goals that living in County the difference between 3 and 4% would be about $74,000 at a cost of 1% to
038the whole district is $200,000 so it's less than a percent to teachers right if we did it from 3 to 4% so it's not like a huge impact but it's but each year you get that that's right that guaranteed so but if you push it to four you get that fear from taxpayers and that's the thing is if you dial all the dials down what in one individual dial might be not significant but if you I I have no idea what the fiscal impact of per per parcel or per square foot is I'm sure there's some sort of mathematical where you take the per square footage in the district and figure that out on a per part like but if you say we're going to choose the one that's going to get us less revenue
039and then we're going to choose the inflationary rate that's the lowest and we're going to choose a timeline that's like if you dial all those dials down that might have a yeah a a detrimental impact so I think it's a matter of figuring out a which tiles have the most voting impact and then how is the combination of you know the per square foot versus the per parcel shouldn't have any impact on the revenues because we can back if we say we want a $3 million Target we can just increase the cents per square foot or increase the dollar per parcel to get to the $3 million money the number um but you may have a taxpayer who says I'm voting yes on this because it's Equitable I have a smaller place I'm paying less
040but you might have someone say I'm paying way more than I used to pay because my house is large to which I would then want to know what's your stock and inventory of housing units in the voting public to be able to understand from a voter perspective of 80% of our housing units are gonna be smaller but then you have to so the average the average home size in our two towns if we did 16.5 cents more than what we currently have which would be 42.3% per square foot the average home gets you at 1146 which is right around where Kentfield right right where lar that's a $450 increase year-over-year that's right and is that kind of the target we're looking for somewhere in that zone I think if we could get somewhere between you
041know a th and 1150 I think that would get us that would get us to the because isn't that one of the arguments we're going to have to make is in addition to Rene it you guys are going to need to pay 50% more so how is that perceived reason no 100% yes yes um that's a big number I live around a lot of old neighbors that have been there a long time I'm already having a conversation with that that when I ran the numbers at 42.3 cents per square foot a 1700 SQ foot home would essentially pay the projected $700 720 that we would if we didn't do anything so if you had a 1,700 foot home or smaller you'd pay the same amount or less so no ch essentially no change it may
042actually have a tax reduction oh if you have a little 1100 foot Bungalow interesting and then on the the larger size it could go up to $2,500 and we could set a cap to say no one's paying more than 2,000 or 3,000 or whatever the cap is how do you convey that to the public to vote on it without them the challenge this is where it gets is that why people do the parel just and backing into the lazy persons what but I've just seen the confusion the low information voting my own marriage was voted against because they rewarded it wrong right so it's like really getting it simplified to where um it doesn't get but that's just me I mean um I I just want to get this thing passed yeah but to to
043shelle's point if we have a higher percentage of people with sub 1700 foot houses better voting that that's not a bad right they may be more in favor of that again if it gets us to the number I I don't know I'm not a politic like you know there's a lot of Ls here that's what so this is we're just starting this we're not saying this is what we're doing right tonight tonight is a conversation to give Chris and I some direction on what we can bring back to you in on January 29th on January 29th what I'm hearing from the board at this moment in time is is maybe bringing a couple different proposals and you can vote on you know a b or c whichever one you all think um might get the
044most yes votes and we will work with our consultants if the board approves the consultant to kind of dial in exactly what language might work best for voter population do we have and and if there are some examples because it my understanding from a presentation we had last year is that actually more parcel tax campaigns are going towards a square footage than like the there is there is a a foot in general and some um advocacy support for that that we might be able to leverage and that we also might have yeah my understanding is it not that it would be so much support that we' be getting rather not receiving opposition if we went with the support but tax groups which is significant information to consider and and and with that in mind I'd
045say number four we should definitely have a senior exemption we have one now and I think that we have a large population of seniors and if we need their votes we need to make sure that they can po out and does that so how does that change then the numbers with a higher a large percentage over 65 then do we have to raise or ask more knowing that they may opt out you just we currently have that now yes okay so it's kind of baked into this okay and we have about 30% of our uh our population opt out right now I think you may rais a good point though that are you saying that we should understand the demographics of people with larger plots are they younger do they have kids in the district
046yeah I mean is there a way to do that within the time frame that you're talking about you should understand the demographics of the voter I mean I don't know how much we've done in the prior I know we did the survey thing but I think having an understanding of the demographics of the of the voting jurisdiction that we're in both in terms of parcels age likely voters what kind of what what's the impact on the variety of people who are likely to be voting on this will should be partially what informs how it gets talked about and who who who we go and talk to and how we talk to them um and understand like I said understanding how many Parcels in our jurisdiction are this size or that size and are those the
047likely voters or the not likely voters are those the seniors or not the seniors I think would be really helpful to understand how to craft this to meet our financial needs while at the same time making sure it gets back yeah one thing Rachel and I have found in talking to some surrounding districts and I believe this is true here as well that somewhere between 70 to 80% of the homeowners are not they they're not sending kids to our schools they're seniors they're young couples their kids are off to college and they're not deeply connected to our schools they're kind of T tangentially connected and 30% based on the exemption rate about 30% of those people our seniors that are opting out anyway so there's a large proportion of the people that vote that aren't
048you know setting their kids to our our teachers classrooms that's something to consider so wait I mean we can pull we can pull demographic data for our district and like the ages groups and whatever and then cross reference probably with some information we have about the parcel sizes because I know Chris was doing some investigating the parcels the number of parcels we have we we know the number of parcels we have yeah we don't know the breakdown of them that might be a little more difficult because getting the the square footages was pretty difficult to begin with the the parcel sizes yeah which you again me it speaks to the it speaks to then the um conversation on the messaging which I'm all in favor of in general which is public education is a benefit
049to us all that this is not a transactional fee for service kind of deal pay your taxes get your service this is a public benefit for everyone who lives here and there are lots of different reasons why there's home I mean if you want to just go economically there's home value prices but even bigger than that this is our public responsibility for the last generation for the next generation and for many more generations to come and this is what we do as a civil Society who cares about children so that would come into number six about a consultant suppor us with an informational campaign they have that kind of messaging right but I think it also tees into to the who are the people that are voting if they're not my kids are going to
050school next year and I want great teacher for my kids kids we want great teachers for our children for our children in general and for years to come even after your kidss have um so and that's one of the really great things about our community is that I mean I think we had like a 77 or 74% passage rate of measure e in 2018 for our current personal tax and it's the same demographics as it was it is as it is now so I mean the people do support our our schools and our teachers a couple months ago we had the consultant hey what would you do it was a it was a whatever I'm going to make this up only 65% said they were or whatever it was it was 54% we had to
051get to maybe 65 and we're like oh 54 that's not bad but they said that's like a massive Gulf so how do how does that how do we change that outcome how do we is that through this consultant more everybody's on board everybody's going in the same direction I think a huge part of the problems the last time when we did the the polling was one we had no information out there in the public none we Tyler has come on board and he's you know gone around done his budget his budget Road Show tour um and he's talked to several stakeholder groups but we didn't have that before and we just kind of like hey let's just bring this on our community at a time when there were already bonds going up for multiple municipalities
052around our area so there was you know talks about talk about a tech tsunami and things like that and so I think people were already kind of ready to say no to anything at that point and I think the fact that there was already the trepidation about the other things were possibly coming up as taxes coupled with the fact that we had no informational campaign and one of the terms that was listed on the the survey was that it was um until until it was repealed by voters which basically was spun as a forever tax and people do not want that they need a term on it so I think we absolutely have to have a term because that I think that was what tanked it everyone I've talked to when I've been out and
053about has said that was why they said no including my husband so I think that there are things in that that aren't really reflective of this I think we'll be able to get if we have information if we're out there and if we have the people in our community who are willing to help us and then it's the community going out to all of your neighbors who don't have kids at Archie have kids wherever private schools don't have kids any it's getting that and that's the community that takes all of us that's the and to if you have great teachers with great quality schools your property values are going to be outstanding we all agree with that we need the people that don't agree with that like who doesn't want their property value to go
054up I can't afford I can't afford $300 more dollars a a month who doesn't want a high quality Community I know right who who doesn't want you know um kids practicing your practicing your door knockings but we would need so we would need that message because I remember going door too for I think something at Memorial Park measure or something go the first person I knocked on he goes I get it I get it you guys all bought million dollar houses you got high taxes I've been here 40 years I can't I can't afford anymore no senior exemption I know but it was like I was like that's the first guy I knock on like what do we do okay let's go back to the Dugout and get here go to the next door keep
055keep one thing just back to your original question of like hey it was 55% when we pulled last we need to get to 65% the Consultants say that's a Chasm every teacher I've talked to and I spoke to a handful of counselors today about this and they asked me what can we do and I said we can come on our non-paid time on the weekend and knock doors and they're all willing to do it I talked with our Union Partners they're willing to do it I'm willing to do it I know you all are willing to do it in our non-pa time so I have a lot of confidence in this community that we're going to get out there and we're going to get to the Town Council meetings we're going to go to the
056PTA meetings we're going to knock doors and everyone's going to have all the information that they'll need to make the informed decision that they need to make and to that to that point Chris I I definitely hear what you were saying about um making choices on these factors so that it passes and and the L the length the appropriate language so that it passes for and you were talking about like lwi information voters or voters who maybe don't who aren't going to spend time really understanding this and my feeling from what Tyler just said is that I think there is going to be so much Outreach that that will kind of bring up the informedness which might allow us to maybe make some assumptions that we might not make if we were assuming a lot
057more uninformed blanket whatevers so that's for me when I'm weighing like am I willing to maybe push it a little bit harder on the percentage rate or maybe think about the per square foot instead of like maybe not making it just super super super easy and dumb it down all the way because I think we're going to have a campaign that will bring up the information awareness on our current tax I think we're going have to yeah we have on our current tax bill do we know if it's per parcel or per square foot parcel no no our school district but what about Library the mosquitoes um everything else that we're paying for does that matter does like like if you get like do people know I'm just trying to be an expert on the
058schools so I don't know we can I think there's a local one that tried like the emergency services or something I don't I guess this is what our consultant would tell us hey this is we're the smartest people in the room this is what we recommend you do so great let's do that so I want to be cognizant of time tonight and I have a feeling we could talk about this in depth for another hour I'm hearing loud and clear from the board that a senior exemption is a yes and we should definitely design around that yes is there any direction for the board around the term or inflation rate that you'd like us to consider more than eight less than 14 years years years you do 10 if that's to I would say 10
059at the very most because you know we might have another pandemic and that like threw the finances all over the place an eight Too Short eight Too Short an A too short I think if this helps I read the Coalition of sensible taxpayers guidelines on partial taxes this this morning and they recommend between eight and 10 years okay 10 and inflation I'm I only know what I know today and the Nerds that crunch the numbers but you know um I think I think I think that if we chose three I wouldn't feel like we're putting ourselves in Peril but 10 years out we talked about this I might creep it up a little bit like three and a half like a half and then is that negotiation with like all right if we go down
060to three but then we're going to do eight yeah once once we there's no like this is what we're petitioning for my hope is that when we come to you on January 29th we have a pretty concrete plan and then the next day I start sending out information I publish a video we start knocking doors and we get because these are all the questions that the folks in the room are asking what's what are the details and once we're on that we're going to have some talking points and then we've got a few months Runway to make and I think CH racist but if we do do this are we still in the Tailwind of Kentfield in cor Madera which my question on number five which was where you came up with the 3 million
061were there what were there assumptions baked into it based on the context and Landscape that were in and that's how you got there and if that's fine then I would say okay great yep so I think that if you look at the 2526 here yeah we could turn most of this green we're not going to turn all of it green in one year but if we do two-year deal we can get close to Turning most of this green and be very competitive with these similar districts four for how long for how long yeah so say with three and a half keep us competitive it's it's really hard to tell it is um because the as you see districts make decisions on teacher pay you'll you you've seen some districts in the area say we're actually
062going to reduce student programs to pay our teachers and I think our community is at this inflection point where we're really proud of the programs we offer our students and we want to maintain those programs yet we also want to pay our teachers so that's I think the I can can the challenge we're in can can do can we get any um Intel on their budgets and their when their their when do their partial taxes end have they been aggressive for the past four years to the point where they're going to have to taper off I mean there's some kind of not quite a crystal ball but maybe some informed projecting of like hey they went this and they're going to flatten out or something that t no I just think it's a crystal ball
063you start cutting things you're dealing you start you start cutting them around too at the schools and that I mean but you're saying some of these have already started doing cuts to be able yeah lur cour of Madera no longer offers a seven period day at the middle school yeah and Kent field is cutting it as we speak ah okay so that's helpful information from to me kind of says okay they're they're not they're going to maybe flatten out or something what do the what does the teacher leadership say to you like what what have they communicated about what they think we should do as well other than I know there's a lot of help and stuff but have you spoken to the leadership to say I think having a two-year deal is something that
064at least rvta is very interested in my guess is CA would be interested in that as well okay um I mean I know that rvta would love for us to light this thing up completely bright green um and we have to make sure we're financially solvent we're not structurally deficit spending so it's it's and that's where and we have to make sure it pass it's tough for me to say right here well I want to turn everything green which means I have to give a 15% oneyear raise but I I need to go to the bargaining table with the Union to to talk about that um so I could be aggressive and turn it all green next year but that's going to have all kinds of cascading impacts down the road but I I I
065think I'm I'm asking more along the lines of you know the goal is we want this to pass yes and has there been a push to take risk and getting it pass that's what I'm just sort of wondering the like the risk analysis and tolerance for risk and not getting passed in order for to have higher I haven't had that conversation with you I I I don't like participation trophies I like to win and so you know nice try yeah look what we did tried then I I can't play with that I think everyone I'm talking to is going for the W okay it it it needs to be W because when you go back to this and you're projecting a $3 million deficit in 2020 25 26 which means there's no way we can
066offer a raise right well Union leadership is crystal clear about not wanting that option that's right okay so the only other option is a w okay yeah so I think I I I think going into this we I think we should really balance the optics for for voters I think the exemption is a smart idea for seniors um I don't know I mean I'm willing to hear the arguments around a parcel per foot and flat maybe based on some underlying data which was what I think you know Daniel and and Shel are interested in and then I think when we come back we can take a look at all that stuff and determine from there Y and I think we're all on board for 10 based on the turnaround the turn rate on this good
067summer um get do do you think it would be helpful to have like a special me so we could tweak this because there's a really short Runway to put a ballot measure on decision we have to make a decision our next for me is January 29th so we have to make a decision then is there a possibility to have a special meeting with a consultant if we decide to go that route as well so that we can ensure that and Community the special meetings that we had in a fall I think I would like to go to the community with an answer okay so once we decide on these things and that we have the information I'm happy to host a town hall where it's an informational campaign and I share exactly what the cost
068is and you know all the details okay could you say something more about the consultant then or go ahead yeah we'll talk about the consultant it's another agenda item just just for clarity I'm hearing direction from the board at a 3.5% inflation rate initially a senior exemption absolutely a 10-year term and more conversation on the per parcel vers per uh square foot is that accurate yep I think so yeah sounds good all right that's all I mean yeah Rachel you're the parcel tax expert here I mean the only thing I can say on the per parcel versus per square foot is we will get less push back on the per square foot but I think it might be harder to pass because of the understanding we have to get out and explain that to everybody
069what that means and how because it is harder to like okay then I have to look and actually for me it would cost me less but it's like you have to go and do the calculation and trying to tell people that is really a tricky thing so it's like would people vote no because it's too complicated so that is something I think we do need to discuss more yeah just because that you know I'd like people to have a chance to weigh in on that think the other thing is is would it be possible for us to do a survey and send it people like here are three various options and here's how it would affect you so they can vote on it that way I mean it might give us more feedback from the
070community like we did when um we were asking what people wanted us to do with the money from the sale of Deer Park yeah that's that was just going to our district I put that all over social media so people who weren't in our schools doing that but I mean it's just to give people a chance to like provide feedback right because I would like to hear what other people have to say with this information I could put a short survey together that we could gather some data that might help us make decision just to see if people understand the concept of per square foot or whatever just I know I feel like I don't have enough information to say one way or another I know how I personally feel about it but yeah I'm
071representing a bunch of people so yeah and and I you know again you know I just I've seen bot measures confuse people and they just yeah that okay okay thank you so um with that we have to go for public comment sorry so um public comment um I have cards here if anybody else would like to add one or at the end if you haven't turned one in you just let me know um but um I have di so you love to come up you don't want to you sorry you're noise on the top there you have a green card so you can come up yeah I just what is the percentage it needs to pass 65 66 666 yeah second grade teacher and also one of Co oh thank you Teresa thank you um
072I just want to thank you all for this conversation and for everything that all the collaboration you do um feels like a really positive partnership um looking forward to working with you I want to um just tell you all please reach out to any of us and tell us how we can help as we're moving forward because we really want to work together um and we just want to continue to build trust um you know we obviously represent all of our members and uh there's still some trust that needs to be continued to be built up so we want to continue um working on that and um agree totally that the messaging and the language that goes out to to a community um is really important and what else did I want to say that's
073basically it um oh I would specifically um we want to make sure that you know like one of the language things is that we're saying teachers a lot we just want to make sure that um that all educators are included when we use the term teacher that we also mean the counselors and the speech therapists and the school psychologists um and I really appreciate the really specific uh you know questions about the uh the M the amounts here um when I was voting for The Measure B I know it's a different thing but you know I actually read in the ballot um book and um there was a little formula you could do because I was like well I want to know like how much is my tax actually going to be different like what's
074the amount going to be and you know I was able to do it really quick and it was like I forget it was $200 or $300 and you know I was like okay no-brainer you know um of course and but you know my husband was like that's a lot of money so it it um I feel like people do really need to know the specifics it would be helpful to know but um again please reach out to let us know how we can help and looking forward to working together I know we have um a lot of people that really want to work together and amazing community of parents that um you know in my 17 years have I've always felt are really with us and ready to support and um lots of really smart
075caring people that um really love our schools thank you D Daniel um I'm a parent of two Hidden Valley children um I have a house in San andelo I grew up in San andelo all my mom and dad's friends are in Sano in Fairfax um they're the seniors you're talking about that exemptions very smart cuz they all vote but they're on fixed incomes and they made a lot less than people make now and they bought their house one of them bought their house for like $16,000 on on uh Meadow cof so just to like put it in perspective her neighbors are definitely bringing home more than she is she's a librarian still so um that said I think that's all smart but I I'm in support of the parcel tax I think it's really important
076I think everyone here knows that without our teachers our schools are just lipstick on a pig I'm in this my uh son was in the same class that I would took I was in sixth grade in the same class that my son's kindergarten class was in and it still has the water stained you know pool sealing tile that it had when Mr cook was there so that said our teachers are amazing they are the ones who kiss our kids give them hugs when they fall dry their tears tell us if they're having a hard time see things that we don't see because we love them too much to notice it and really teach our kids how be good people and they're ultimately are going to make them healthier adults and help with their mental health
077and all those other things that are really important and I'd really like this whole Community to be kind and sweet in 20 years and not you know riddled with people that didn't get hugged enough as kids so that said I think the parcel tax is really important regardless of anything else they and our teachers deserve it they're really amazing people and they work really hard and they do it because they love our kids so they deserve it more than anyone so thank you Sandra hi I'm Sandra Mera I've got two kids at Hidden Valley and um I am part of the parent support group here letting you guys know that we're here and we're ready um to support this and I would just ask that um you know I want to make sure it's enough
078our teachers give everything to our children um I want them to live in our community I've heard way too many heart ship stories about the things that they need to pay for and the things that they can't pay for and it breaks my heart and they come to school every day and they give it all to our children and I just want to make sure it's enough and that we I know we need to get this past but um I you've got our support um and I mean there's 25 50 people that couldn't be here tonight that that want to be here and are ready to go out there and get the support so thank you Danny C hi everyone um first let me thank you for having this meeting um and I also having
079been at many of the board meetings over the finances last year just really appreciate the tone of this meeting in comparison to what it was um a year ago and and especially in the spring so hopefully the community and the parents and the board and the teachers and rvta can continue to work um as humans and it doesn't get to that contentious point that it really fell last year so thank you for starting almost 2025 out with this um I'm a parent of two children at hin Valley a lot of you think already know this now I am a teacher in t uhsd I'm in my year in the district I was at Redwood I'm now at tamascal I'm also on the budget committee here um so just thinking about um the experience we just
080went through with measure a which didn't pass measure B which did and actually rethinking some things that we've been talking about in our budget committee teams to point number one um I know it is not Apples to Apples but sat in lots of meetings where it was pointed out over and over again that measure a the half a billion dollar Bond did not pass by 2% because of our community um and the idea that Archie was not getting what the other schools were getting in an absence of understanding that Archie wasn't getting it because Archie didn't need it there was I mean and don't need to go into the details so I know it's not the same situation at all but talking about tax per personal versus tax per square foot just wanting to make
081sure it is abundantly clear that it is not then an equity issue and they're paying less and we're paying more and we're not getting the same thing and just reminding a reminder that that was a really a big reason that Bond Aid did not pass with because of that view in in our community um and to that Tyler and Rachel if you are going to send out a survey of hearing you talk about it I honestly think a one question survey with an explanation definition of the difference if you were voting today yes or like which would you vote Yes on right not even would you vote yes or no on a parcel and I think then that information would be really great because I don't want it to be like it doesn't pass by
0822% because of people being like well they're going to pay more they're going anyway I don't need to go on on that and to point number six in the budget Committee in my small group um oh shoot give 30 seconds oh 30 seconds um I think we were like initially because of the cost of it like very anti hiring a consultant but seeing the power of the consultant with measure B and knowing how important social media was for our federal elections and where there was a strong very strong social media presence we've all read the news that I think I mean magnets and signs matter but we have to have a very strong social media campaign and that cannot be ignored and I don't know if that can be accomplished without a consultant okay I
083had one more point you're too much of a rule follower okay my last point is again you've already spoken about it tonight um if you need a play to pocketbooks which again we saw with this 2024 election some would say came down to but I that's a whole another issue um we have some of the most prominent real estate agents children's in our schools um at least I know at Hidden Valley and how do we partner with them again talking about this media campaign I mean I I mean Eric Elman has two children at Hidden Valley you cannot go a block in this town without seeing his name and how does he communicate with his older clients like this matters for your pocketbook okay I'm done thank you thank you Danny Cindy Cindy crto TK
084teacher at Hidden Valley um I believe Educators play key role in the achievements of creating the highly desired schools in this District in spite of these efforts we rank near the lowest paid group of teachers or Educators um I recognize the financial dis uh position of the district uh being on the board the budget committee and without the partial tax substantial Cuts will need to be made each teacher in this district has their own special and unique story I'm here to share just a small portion of my life and why moving forward with the parcel tax is important to me in May of this year I actively interviewed for open positions and higher paying school districts and was extended offers I declined these offers however and chose to stay at Hidden Valley I could not
085have made it through 2023 the year of my husband's cancer Journey without my um Hidden Valley colleagues or families or students they were there for me and my family in one of our hardest yearses and that year reminded us that the mental and physical health of my family is a non-negotiable in days I happily celebrate my husband's first anniversary of being cancer-free his continued health is essential to me while the treatment portion is complete the maintenance portion has just begun we continue to pay for his regular trips to UCSF his blood work CT scans MRIs and his monthly medical needs his continued Health cannot be something that we as a family cut in our budget the last wage crease does not cover these costs knowing the current state of the district's budget the only way
086to change the cycle is to seek a partial tax to increase the wages of our Educators I'm here to make sure that the district and our schools are better because we can do better but not if we continue to spend our time focused on the small increases that perpetuate wages at the lowest end of the scale Marin my story is a small one in the multitude of our Educators each of us has our story of how our lives are affected by rising cost I continue to be at risk of losing my team members which are my family at Hidden Valley so I'm Here Wanting an action plan that will ensure the parcel tax passes thank you anybody else want to speak all that we move on can I make com comment discussion the teachers only
087language versus all the Educators like I thought it was good to say hey teachers need the money but everybody do so whatever the pros think about that language makes the most sense to me right that like like what will'll get yes vote what we'll get it passed we most considered about and then I think you guys were talking about this how do we know if it's enough but why not ask for like how is three million enough if and why could would the community support three and a half million I don't know how you figure that out but how do you don't go big or go go like with nothing but like how do we get to that and again maybe that's what the Consultants say so I just want those are really good comments
088I was thinking similarly I I it's not a compelling I think messaging isn't a compelling if we're just going to squeak into the green or if we're going to teer on the edge of the top of the bottom or something like like that so it's somewhere in between like being um irresponsible aggressive and being irresponsibly conservative too conservative that you're not making a compelling argument for like we don't want to be we don't want to be squeaking we don't want our teachers to be squeaking better but still squeaking along like we need to make it bold enough that we are moving solidly into a much better position and so I think that's both in terms of what we choose for the variables and and for the messaging so finding that sweet spot I think is
089going to be our key and the other thing that came to mind I'm thinking of with respect to the parcel versus square footage is the concept of fairness that this tax is fair so there could be arguments pro and con for each of them in terms of fair but I think we need to understand what our definition of fair is and that's what we're going to go with with cuz I think that's in thinking about this last election in general the idea of fairness I think is a going to be key in board so those are two things that came to mind I I want to say that I think the power of the message we have to send is that this is about people we are asking for money for our Educators we're not
090asking for money to put in a new lunchroom although I'm not negating why measure B and other measures are very important for facilities our kids are going to school you know with Archie Williams ate at the same chair but I mean if we really the comments have really made me realize these are individuals these are individual stories these are are Community these are our Educators these are our people so the equ and fairness of it it should even be a question when you put the human factor in you know we're not raising money for things we're raising money for the livelihoods of our Educators and I think we really have to push that and I think and and I think if we and if if if there's no compassion in our community to pass that
091we're in deep crap honestly so I think I think we've got to come out strong with that message and we'll work with our consultant I think hopefully to get that get that across that's it yeah Daniel you no good but I and I do like the idea of Us coming back for another conversation so that on the 20 we're not at the end having to stay here till 2: in the morning because we have to make a decision and we've got to like let me run out of the room we get my spread Chey whatever we we we don't want to do it at the last minute sorry that's right sorry a special meeting can just be this topic and this topic only and it can be relatively short um because we won't have a
092bunch of other things thank you so much I do we need to talk um and I wanted to say thank you to the people who came to speak I know it's late on an evening and it's during the middle of the week so I really appreciate the fact that people are coming here to you know give us some input because it's really appreciated and with that move on to the next item in our agenda which is uh number three Windows rbsd multilingual learning yeah I I'll introduce this topic and then hand it over um but I have to say that last Thursday last Wednesday Thursday last Thursday may have been the highlight of my career here at uh rvsd my very short career here at rvsd um we had probably 150 families 200 families uh
093at Manor Elementary celebrating the power of bilingualism and celebrating a good handful of our students who have uh reclassified as English proficient meaning they speak both their home language and English which as a monolingual speaker myself I wish I had the power of two two languages so I want to give a lot of credit to Eric Sable and Amelia alamari Amelia did a ton of work getting this together was calling people um on the phone and push pushing people to get as many people at this event so U without further Ado this is a great presentation about the power of multilingualism and some of the great students we have in our in our district thank you of course I'm losing my voice as I was coming here tonight literally so I'm not sick I think
094it's hi I'm Emilia lamari I'm the English language development coordinator for the district and intervention teacher at Manor Elementary School and also working with English Learners there director student services and uh it was a ton of fun to collaborate with Amilia on this though she did the vast majority of the work and a a lot of this information was also shared at least some of it I believe was shared at uh the um the the celebration um at least some of the information so amazing work and there a lot of information it's a community resource now so we're going to to try to run through it but definitely encourage you all to go back and sink into it some more yeah and a lot of picture pictures in here because I'm an ELD a teacher
095by for my life that's my passion and we pictures speak a thousand words so um we're going to quickly just go over the English language development team here at Ross Valley um specifically looking at who our multilingual Learners are and how we're supporting them Eric will present a bit of data and then we'll quickly talk about family engagement and share some great photos from last Thursday so this is our amazing Elementary um ELD team me from I represent Manor I'm there five days a week Alicia is at Brookside four days a week and Ellie and Angie are at way Thomas and Hidden Valley three days a week um and of course you know Lina our district coach who supports all of us and works with us through our mtss team meetings and then we have
096Lara um who is working um as the Spanish teacher at the middle school at White Hill and she's also supporting with elpac testing and reaching out to families she's bilingual and Amber wild who supports our newcomer is level one and two students at the middle school as well through English language development um we created this beautiful map last Thursday um we actually ran out of the little papers that were they were filling out we had so many families but you can just see the amazing diversity of our multilingual learner families um just at the top we have approximately 85 students right now districtwide that number fluctuates and I think um with the students that Tyler mentioned who were reclassified recently we're up to like 120 um and really diverse range of languages many of our
097families were transitioning from the term English language learner to multilingual learner because many of our families speak more than one language at home I was speaking to one of my U speaking families and the mom shared that Mom speaks um one dialect apart from Urdu dad speaks another dialect and they're teaching their kids Arabic so that's poor languages and English um so it's pretty amazing um we shared this um last Thursday as well but just really really firm Believers that um multilingualism is truly a superpower we know that it enhances cognitive abilities that kind of old school ideology that learning more than one language is going to prevent you from learning English totally not true we know um it really helps the brain develop in multiple ways um of course it promotes cultural awareness um
098it helps people and students understand people from different walks of life different perspectives and it improves communication you can communicate with double the people when you speak um double the languages okay so last year we adopted a new curriculum um specific for our English Learners or multilingual Learners called el achieve um this program is designed to be used in a pullout model or a self-contain model so there's two types of English language development when you're the classroom teacher is supporting students by providing scaffolds and differentiating the learning and using tools in the classroom and then a pullout model which is called designated English language development which is what this curriculum is used for um and it's really heavily focusing on oral language development through really um interesting age appropriate curriculum and content and the intention
099is to group kids by their proficiency level so you would have a group of newcomers you'd have a group of um level three students and they'd be working together to build their oral language really focusing on academic language and then that would transfer to their academic content areas okay I love all all the pictures of my munchkins um so this is our approach districtwide to supporting our English our multilingual Learners we really truly have the most amazing team um I feel so fortunate every time that we get to get together here at the district office um there's one teacher at every single School site who's both the English language development teacher and intervention teacher and that's really nice because many of us are pulling those students multiple times each day both in the reading intervention
100groups and for designated ELD and it allows us to provide the explicit phonics and the work needed to get them decoding and encoding and then also building their language skills and their vocabulary so you're kind of meeting them um at both ends of the spect spum so that they can really fully develop and access the curriculum and um just really quickly another big piece of this is the collaboration with classroom teachers that we're always meeting with them understanding what they're teaching in the classrooms making sure that our work is aligned to what they're teaching um oh sorry so uh these are just students at Brookside way Thomas and Hidden Valley um again most of uh Wade Thomas and hid valy they're there three times a week um so they're meeting with these students for the
101most part three times a week sometimes more than once a day and uh at Manor and Brookside where we have the majority of all our multilingual Learners we meeting with these students four times a week okay Amber wild she's phenomenal she is um working with all of the level one students those are students who we're going to talk a little bit about OPAC but scored a level one beginning to develop on the elpac newcomers and some of the level two students depending on their language proficiency and that's an alternative to their regular English class and it's really um an opportunity to provide targeted language instruction and also really support them in kind of scaffolding the instruction in their other in their other subjects so she really works very very closely with the content Area Teachers
102to make sure that she's building background knowledge and providing the vocabulary and the language that they need to be successful um and then we also have a special special advisory class where she works with students that were formally with her so she can continue having that relationship and making sure she's there as a support checking in to make sure that they're continuing to grow and thrive in their classrooms and of course like I mentioned before Lara is supporting at the school site as well with parent Outreach and elpac testing okay the data the fun part um this is going to be very brief because we know Julia did an amazing presentation on a lot of this data um at the last meeting but just in case um you're unfamiliar with the process of how an
103English language learn is identified and the official term is still English learner according to the CDE um so every single time that a student enrolls in a California school the parent has to complete something called the home language survey it's four questions and based on the answers to these questions um they are either eligible to take the elpac assessment which is a um a California state assessment of language or not um so basically if any language other than English is spoken at home there's a chance that this child might need additional support we give the lpac assessment um initially when they enter the school and then we get a result there's three levels from that initial lpac and based on their score they either are identified as initially fluent English proficient which means they don't
104receive services or they receive a level one two or three and based on that level they receive a varying amount of support um and then those students will continue taking the summit of Alek each spring until they reach a level four which is the highest level welldeveloped um and we'll go through that process a little bit it's pretty rigorous the assessment there are a lot of monolingual students that truthfully wouldn't pass it so it really is a true achievement to reach that that level of proficiency uh so just a couple um data representations here uh quickly so this is the uh the summit of lpac from Spring of 2024 and so uh sorry over on the right that is and then you'll see um the strands from previous years uh so the the purple up
105top um are are uh mlls who progressed at at least one level um so that's that's a solid number the and then the the blue band who maintained then and the sort of the teal um uh the those students who maintain levels one through three um and then down at the bottom students who decrease the level so um so we're seeing you know the vast majority of students that are maintaining uh or improving um so that's that's great and also understanding too that the cohorts are are shifting and changing year over-ear so um so that's uh just kind of showing a Continuum from um the past few years and another way to look at it uh also this is spring uh summative Alpac data you can see by grade level um the amount of children
106that are at level one two three or four and um uh and something to note is that um for kindergarten through second grade the the sumita of test is on paper and then it in third grade it changes to a computer U model so um that's kind of a a qualitative shift in in the student testing experience and um something that the team is definitely paying attention to in terms of um is that make it more challenging are the students able to access that better but um that's a sort of a a view of how our kiddos are doing from last spring uh on and those kiddos in the green those are the level fours we were talking about that are eligible for reclassification so many of those students were the students that were standing
107up and being honored at the event on Thursday so when we talk about reclassification we're really talking about changing a student status from an English learner to English fluent so they would no longer be receiving or need extra services and support in order to be successful in their content classes and so that first indicator is the Alpac assessment they have to score a level four unless they have an IEP in which case there's an alternate program that or um pathway we can take to reclassify the next step is getting teacher input and an evaluation looking at the report card and how they're doing across other subjects we consult with the parent or guardian and then we use other measures like Casp testing dibles testing other um standardized testing to compare and make sure they're also
108performing at high levels across all of it um and just to be clear the elpac is assessing four language areas of language the oral language component is listening and speaking and the written language is reading and writing and like I mentioned before the reading and writing component of that is pretty rigorous it's very similar to the Casp test okay these are all of our munchkins or the majority of them that were reclassified at the celebration on Thursday it was really exciting we had 20 students um between last spring and this year that were reclassified um you can see from all different language backgrounds Swedish erdu speaking arabic speaking Spanish speaking Japanese speaking um and they were just beyond proud the families were really proud it was pretty amazing to see um so very very excited
109about that and our last look is at family engagement um I want to take a quick look at the events that we've had this year and kind of what we're already doing to support our families and what I'm hoping we can keep building on um so this year um you can go to the next side if you want every um single School site was asked to have some sort of multilingual learner event um each site kind of did that in their own way we had an amazing Folklorico dance performance at Manor and we invited all families in a way Thomas had a breakfast um in a Hidden Valley I think as well so um I'm interested in seeing how we can further build out those events and make sure we get more families to attend
110and then also kind of go beyond the just socializing and really figure out how we can get more p parent voices and input into the decision- making this was our district celebration my amazing MC Jorge um in the back he was incredible um we had such an amazing turnout I don't even think this picture represents everyone some of them may have left by then um and then it's the back of their heads but I have Florencia and Denise there from the Fairfax Ando Children's Center um Tyler and I went and visited and we've built rebuilt an amazing relationship with them they've been at my school site I think six times since our visit we're talking on the phone daily Eric just emailed me about doing a TK presentation there to try to recruit families and
111bring them back to our district so that's a very exciting new development um I've got Shelly in the back of your head right there so thank you so much for coming that was amazing having you there interacting with our fames and participating um we did this really fun concentric circles would you rather discussion protocol it was a gamble but I think it worked out pretty well um we had families from all different language backgrounds um having conversations around whether or not they would prefer to never have to cook dinner again or never do laundry again giving them language scaffolds and really putting them in the shoes of their students and what it feels like to be in a class where you have students who are you know highly English proficient or English only students from
112various language backgrounds um and giving them you know that sense of discomfort but also that sense of success with the scaffolds and the language scaffolds and practicing so um they had a lot of fun and it was very successful I think okay so what we're currently doing um I think a lot of new and exciting things like I mentioned we're having um these very intentional events at the site level and the district level we're making um I think a much bigger effort to make sure that all of our communication and our Outreach is both in English and Spanish um and other languages when we use uh parents Square that's a really beautiful feature that automatically translates into the designated home language of each family um all of our schools and the district has uh diversity
113Equity inclusion of belonging committee that's looking at ways that we can be more inclusive of all of our families we have I worked with Teresa to um really think about how we can make Equitable Equitable and intentional Outreach to new families and how we're targeting our new families and where families of multilingual Learners might actually be able to see our Outreach um going Beyond parent Square thinking about grocery stores thinking about public libraries pediatrician off um offices and also just making the flyer a lot more um succinct and making sure that the most important and relevant information is there a lot of families don't don't know what TK is that concept doesn't exist outside of California um so making sure that it's not just a lot of information on one page and that it's it's
114really um easy for them to call and get more information Teresa worked with Sean to create a new Spanish hotline for registration so when families call they hear a Spanish speaking voice and they're able to leave a message in Spanish and have someone respond so it's a big step um my position in general is new and it's really exciting to have a district ELD coordinator and hopefully the bond thank you for that amazing conversation passes and we can think about more ways to invest in bringing more staff on our campuses who are bilingual and um whose Mo main focus is really including all families and making sure that they have Equitable access to education um and like I mentioned before I'm very excited that we established reestablished that partnership with the children center they are
115absolutely amazing the work they do they service a lot of our multilingual Learners both before they come to Ross Valley schools and in their after school program and summer programs they are just amazing human beings um they've been at parent conferences with us they're just incredible thought partners and a great resource and next steps my dreams hopes and dreams so uh we're really looking to like I said move those events kind of to the next level we um technically should be having something called the District English language advisory Council which means that um and it can be a subcommittee of an existing group so I'm hoping that the superintendent Council can include the family or families of multilingual Learners we can really make sure that their voices are included in important decisions um both at
116school sites and at the district level I want to continue to think about ways that we can reach out to families um I know that parent square is amazing because it's easy and it translates but from what I've seen so far it hasn't been the most effective tool in actually reaching our most vulnerable excuse me families and the families that we really want to attend these events like Tyler mentioned you know it really required Jorge and I calling every family me going out to dismissal every single day taking their phone out showing them where the message was helping them register calling again calling again so thinking about how can we make Outreach is a bilingual Community Leon an important member to bring on to the team possibly to make them that Outreach and make sure
117families feel like they really have a connected a person that they can connect to at at each School site um and then hiring recruitment I think making sure that we have as many bilingual bicultural teachers in front of our students as possible continuing to really think about our enrollment practices and making sure that we're digging deep and figuring out who the students are that are living in our district and making sure they know how amazing our community is and how much we want them here that's it so I want to give a huge thanks to Eric and Amelia for this work it may be obvious for some of us but this is what diversity Equity inclusion work looks like in practice this is what this is this is not something separate from the diversity or
118deib work that we're doing this is it um so I just want to be make that that uh connection explicit because I don't think everybody sees it that way um and just want to thank both of you for the work you you've done because that was a remarkable event that I think everybody left with ear to ear friends with so thank you any questions question from the board I just wanted to Echo that that was a fantastic event it was full it was food it was fun kids were running around it was it was Total Community I ran into my old neighbor who's now a grandparent whose daughter was at Manor who was there and that was a great just you know it's one of the things that happens in our community where it's you
119know you're in school whatever but it's your neighbors and your friends so it was fantastic and the energy level and I know I really appreciated you um taking the risk with having us stand up and it was a little bit like getting everybody to do it but the energy level to get us all engaged really made it that kind of it wasn't a meeting and it wasn't just you you squeeze the presentation stuff in there in between um you had the kids go into the so I just think the orchestration and the bringing together of just all the different ways of experiencing being together in community around this subject just was awesome so I really appreciate the thoughtfulness to how it was all put together um that event and I'm sure that reflects the thoughtfulness
120with which all of the work they're doing is so I really and I love the fact that we are holding up multilingual Learners and superpower and really it's so it's asset framed it's everything that like we talk about intellectually up here and to see it in practice is just fantastic yeah I I was on been on the parent Equity Guardian task force for many years when we first started we did the listening voices we actually pulled parents um in the community and asked them how they felt about being in the district and what was lacking and many said they didn't feel like they belonged something as simple as not having the ability to understand the technology on how to register online or or get the yellow school bus for example and there was this moment
121where we were like how are we going to get to this point and sitting here and seeing this because the one thing that a lot of us on the equity task force did didn't want to see was this almost parental approach to like let's help you as opposed to Let's Empower all of us right and and to me to sit here and to see the the inversion of the language that you know they're not being aided they're being empowered because you really do bring that power to the to our community in the classroom and I really thank you both for really doing this work because it brings to light where we need it to be and this is a great thing thank you so much happy to do it yeah I was um really impressed
122I love to see like the the really concrete actions that have been taken and that you're doing and that are ongoing like you know the the technology nights in different languages I that's wonderful because like how are people going to access these how their students are doing they can't understand how to register so just all those little changes and they're like they're small changes here and there but they're adding up over time and it's just it's great to see because we do want everyone to feel that they belong here and so I I appreciate all those actions that are being taken and it's not lip service and it's not you know it's not performative but it's actually like changes being made so it's it's nice to see that um the Spanish hotline I think is
123fantastic because that's a great way to reach out to people I mean how else if you can't communicate it's it's a huge barrier and it's on us not on them so I appreciate you taking the effort there I think one more shout out to vorge who has a lot to do with all of those evenings he's he's been at pretty much every Tech night there translating and supporting parents and then of course was there doing all the interpretation last week so orge thank you quick quick small question oh yeah um do are our phone trees at sites and District in those languages I don't know that we have I was talking with another District like push one to talk to so and so push to get a hold of the superintendent those kinds of things
124cuz I was talking to another District that was like oh yeah that would be like cuz that's the first thing you hear is you call the district you call your school and you hear in English or do you hear if you would like to hear information in Spanish press to I think this is the first step that we've taken and I want to appreciate Amilia and Teresa and Sean for their creativity and thinking outside the box when we're seeing we want we want to increase enrollment we're partnering with the children set more closely we're we're putting this hotline together so I think we're trying to find ways to be a little bit more creative and Nimble um and that's one example so we can consider doing that in in other areas as well just yeah
125I think the simplest things like calling the school to tell them that your child is sick that day or that has a doctor's appointment is a major barrier I have most of my families texting me as their way to report an absence which ideal I'm not at every school so I think really thinking that through and making sure that families really have a very comfortable easy way to access information and share information is huge thank you right do we have any more questions for our presenters thank you both get drop thank you and then we have any public comments the public is up bye public yes thank you no more okay um we have any F discussion thanks thanks guys thank you so we have a new vote on that so I'm going to move
126on to our enrollment update which looks like it is yeah great so I'll make this pretty quick um quick enrollment update Teresa can you there you go um so this is a where we're at currently we're at 1680 which is kind of flat from where we've been at the beginning of the year we were at 1683 we've kind of bumped up and down between 1683 and 1680 um we do have a year-to-year comparison to something the board wanted to see uh from last time if you compare the colors you can see the cohort change so if you look at the if you look at the table below you see the orange it says uh 165 and then if you look at the table above it says 164 so we only lost one kid from the
127transition from kindergarten to first grade um and then you can see that is mostly the case pretty stable in a lot of areas um if you do look at the uh numbers on the far right the total numbers Brookside and Hidden Valley have gone down a little bit since last year uh Manor has actually gone up which is great news Wade Thomas I think is pretty stable there and we've lost some students at uh at uh sorry see yeah now I just can't see anything sorry yeah so I think it's gone down uh at White Hill as well so um overall we're seeing you know some Trends one thing that was interest that the board was interested in last time is the transition between fifth grade and sixth grade and you can see that yellow
128fifth grade at 168 I believe and actually went up to 194 and that I think is partly because of students coming in from the charter school um and that means we're not losing a lot of kids in that transition either so that's that's pretty good news um and then I'll look at the the next one is the uh so this is just from the first month you see that 1683 to 1680 kind of pretty stable there um and then can you pull up the second document please thank you um I want to give a shout out to Brookside Brookside has the uh best uh attendance rate right now at 96.7 eight which is pretty solid I think our goal is really closer to 97 that's kind of the pre-pandemic average 97% um what Chris and
129I were talking about earlier this week is that we typically see these numbers kind of slowly decrease over the year um we see some attendance issues in the spring um you know winter due to sickness so you'll see these numbers kind of go down a a little bit uh they're not exactly where I'd love them to be um but they're not bad either so I was talking to our principal over at Brookside Amanda Wagner earlier today and she was kind of talking about um a lot of the work that her teachers are doing to make sure attendance stays high so it's not just Amanda messaging it it's not just me messaging it but it's all the way down to the classroom teacher level really pushing and supporting this um she did say that there's there's
130a few parents that are like a little okay that's enough of that messaging and then there's other parents who are like okay we're going to do our best to get there so um you're going to turn a few people off from time to time about that but uh big Kudos Brook side and overall our District's doing pretty pretty Dar well there any ability to correlate this to how it's doing what it's doing to our bottom line when we say we need butts and seats how's it how's it looking we would not normally make any adjustments to our budget just yet um it would be done as we get into the second inter room because what ends up happening is the numbers tend to Trail off the other thing to to remember is that we now
131are on a three-year averaging if we're in Decline and so that plays a part in that and we're also having that bounce where we're going between Community funded and state aid funded so that impacting us as well but um as we get into the second interim it will impact our our revenues potentially for the positive good if those numbers go up great okay so keeping that message ingrained is helpful okay yeah and I I have something that I'll send out in the beginning of 2025 just as another reminder that how important this is and I actually mentioned it in a parent Square that'll go out tomorrow morning right somebody say I'm a little wonky have you done run chart factor analysis to look for patterns like key places and patterns where like sometimes it's just
132when you look over time and you can see wave patterns or you can see like you can see these patterns and then you ask like wait what's going on here where where it's having a particular pattern so that you can really it's not just we need more messaging it's like oh this is happening every Thursday or this is happening on the the third Thursday of February every year because you're looking at patterns either over the whole year or year to year and then kind of inquiring around what's going on with these patterns because sometimes it's sometimes it could be a really simple thing yeah when you see a pattern as opposed to just more right it's just oh we need our message at 3:00 instead of 5:00 or whatever it is if you can look
133at those kind of patterns I don't know if data to be a patterns that I know are start start with great attendance and we slowly get worse over the year that's pretty standard um we've also seen that like the Thursday and Friday before Labor Day is a tougher day we saw that we had that uh Thursday off for Jewish holiday the Friday after that was a tough day for attendance so we're seeing some patterns there um what I will say is that the independent study is is helping we have families actually using that that which is helping some of these numbers go higher than we would there's also a challenge for our teachers that we're doing all these packets and it's a lot of extra work so it's it's not all clean um but I
134think I haven't done a the analysis that you described but we have looked at the the daily rate and noticed a few patterns here and there I remember one of our discussions there was this like well let's have the pizza parties on Friday or let's have instead of Wednesday welcome we're going to have Friday welcome or what you know those kind little Tweaky things to to make those adjustments to incentivize on campus um at just the right points in time like our principles are are doing actually I would consider a pretty darn good job doing exactly that okay noticing a calendar date trying to do an event on that date and then you can also see some parents going like oh that's an event like oh my kid really wants to be there and then
135other parents are like oh it's just an event day let's go ski so you can see it on both sides yeah interesting I think the more that we can get out sooner like to get the pressure on the kids like hey I don't want to miss this day it's yeah whatever the Christmas sing along I want to be there right and so if if we know it's butting up next to a holiday how do we get that information or have like a and it takes you you know like no we just know the Friday and Thursday before every whatever holiday the kids do this and so it's ingrained into the the culture um and then as we look at the calendar for next year we could be a little more critical on like hey do
136we really need that day off on a Thursday like can we push that to a Frid like I I wasn't critical in that last year when we were approving the Cal for this year but I will be more so this year like is that the right thing to do I it was tough especially if we're not we're trying to match up to the high school school calendar is having one kid who's in a district who has a day off and the other kid who doesn't is not a happy home that day yeah there's a lot of gloating from the one who doesn't have to go I'm just saying a lot all right well there's any other question and definitely appreciate all the thoughtful intentionality that's already gone into it so I think it more just
137kind of brainstorming and how we continue to improve we just want to make sure that kids are in school and learning and we'll bring another update to the board in I think February great thank you y and there is no public here to comment and we didn't have any further discussion up here I just want to say there's like what was the statistic if you miss two days of school a month from k through eight you've missed an entire year of Education yeah just that number it's like yes we're losing money but your child is losing it on their education is part thats yeah it keeps sticking in my head when hear that anyways okay Moving On We're actually finally jumping to number five that was reorganized oh wait no not that one the new
138number five which is number two which is the annual Board of Trustees organizational meeting to elect a board president Clerk and representative to serve on the ren County School boards Association mcba for the term of December 2024 through December 2025 all right so could to have a fun discussion we also ballot if you want to do it that way or discuss I think it's been working very I think it's been working very well personally I mean I so I'm just GNA say I think I think the way we have it has been working very well and I'm so I'm not GNA say not it okay so I'm not gonna say not it do I get to say I need I need somebody else to help with a partial tax situation that might happen future so
139I don't have to be doing that okay I mean I definitely want to be involved but if I'm going to um yes do this another year I think I think creating ad hoc duties for People based on things that need to get done is something that we can definitely you don't have to carry Madam president do you want to continue you for another year in this role given your Stellar performance this [Laughter] past you buttering me up there's no butter there's no butter you know I I everyone's like not it I'm but the reality is it's like you are you are in this to two kids in school like all all of us have these kids in school what is it that you would like to happen I ran for a re-election because I wanted
140to continue like the positive direction that we've been moving in um with Tyler coming on board and I see you like like praying like I say yes I wouldn't have done that if I didn't care and I still care that hasn't changed so I would serve another year with the understanding that I may not want to do it a third year I understand I understand but I do you want to keep I think we should keep you on because I think you have Tyler needs that continu you know he's big boy but you know I I think that I think it would really help with the continuity of how you two the three of us I me it's the clerk being there with the planning on the agenda it's working well and just kind of
141throw things at us to pick up the pieces your communication to the community is quite good it's something to study those of us who will be probably in this role in the future take a look and learn from the expert here just make sure we're not going to throw you to the woles because I think that you should continue for another year as well than you is there a nomination yeah I think technically you have to nominate Le that's how we've done it do we want to start with the role of the president do you think I think we should I would like to formul a nomination to have Rachel wck continue as the president of the Ross B School District board for the 2025 school year second third all right so Chris I I
142sh Danel yeah all right thank you I accept Madam president conratulations very much with that I'm going to nominate Chris be our clerk I heard I I mean Daniel I think you would make an excellent clerk as well but um I'm thinking that perhaps in the future we might transition some rules around and I think that would be if that feels like the right sequencing then I'm all for it yeah I think it would be a a good natural progression all right well then ially Nate Chris ly C to be our clerk to sign away my home every [Laughter] time she's have to sign all the paperwork with me do second second all second I'm gonna say I and Daniel I shell I chrisy I graciously accept this nomination to continue as the clerk of
143the Ross Valley School District board thank you thank you all right yay congrats all right and our last one is the Marine County School boards Association um representative and I believe that is Daniel Daniel that is you or has been you if you are yeah for doing that under thir turn yeah then I would nominate Daniel as in County School boards Association representative for the 252 for the next year another term perfect I will second that so shell I Rachel I Chris I Daniel do you accept accept Okay so there you go you've got your status quo yep and let's see um last year we did Nom do an an mcspa alternate oh okay I don't know if you want to do that again I would like to nominate Shelly Hamilton mcsp I'm I am
144willing to give a speech about it I do do no but given the time and the ability to insinuate that you are the perfect candidate for this I will just nominate you sure you up for it yeah all right I'll second you that all right Chris I Rachel I Daniel hi and shell I accept thank you thanks so Chile's our alternate all right so number six uh we have to approve the contract with Team Civics to provide consulting services and informational flyer for a parcel tax measure this is this is me so uh we kind of talked about this in the earlier presentation and I just wanted to uh in creating the agenda we were thinking about putting this on the consent agenda but we wanted to be transparent with the community that we're actually
145having an honest discussion about whether we should or shouldn't use a a contractor to help us with the informational campaign um which would essentially be from Once you approve this through uh mid-February and then it would transition to the the community to start working either with a contractor or on their own um districts do it both ways so this would really be for the next six weeks um Charles Heath would be the person we would be working directly with and he knows Marin really well he's helped a number of districts in the area with both a bond and partiel taxes so he kind of knows our constituents pretty pretty well um being a new superintendent with limited experience this would be helpful for me for sure um and we got the price down it was
146I think close to $6,500 a month and we got it down to I think 9500 for the two months total um so Charles Heath and the team at Civics was uh willing to work with us questions about this and then to Danny's Point around social media are they doing anything around that or that's they'll help us with uh talking points Flyers mail um all the informational campaign that we go through help us with the website um that we get put up so all that will they though create you know like on Instagram you need a 300 by 300 pixel blah blah blah that's different than what you would do for a flyer will they create the assets that you would use so there um as a district we can pay for them to do an
147informational campaign yes so they we can get the information out we can't do anything that's like a measure no no no I'm thinking of the assets for an informational campaign Beyond print things because there's a element of rescaling resizing shorter words for social media than for print is that included when I've worked not it wasn't team Civics it was another group that Charles worked with but I was we were given assets to work with for social media but it was I was on the other end like it was after it had been handed off to a committee a CA Campaign Committee and it wasn't with the district so I'm not sure which assets they were given before that okay and so we would reach out to people in the community that are experts in this
148as well to maybe be on that committee to then work okay great yeah so then in February it would transition to a parent Le community-led effort and that's where it would be a you know yes on C or whatever the the thing is and um Rachel I had some really good discussions with two parents um down in Ross this morning and they were talking about how they actually led the community they had some graphic designers that sent their kids to the schools and they actually just created their own assets so you could this is really just for our support at the district through February and then the the actual campaign can decide whether to continue with Charles and team civics or to kind of do it on their own so this is more the messaging
149in the materials is more about the district about our teachers and Educators about our budget not about the specifics of the parcel exactly because we can't advertise for right we can't do that we can't and which we won't have the decision made until formally January that was that was my next question was timing because I was like wait why is he going to be on in January if we're not making a decision until end of January but now that makes sense to me that it's a different which I think is totally important messaging but I'm it's a helpful clarification for that did you work with them at the SU I have not worked with them I I didn't really work on the uh bonds that santell did our business office did that completely um I
150did some like phone call phone banking but uh I didn't work directly with them but they did use consultants for sure okay I don't have any questions and I know that you all have been doing so much due diligence that I really appreciate in terms of like you said talking to other districts talking to other people looking at options and Alternatives so I appreciate that you're bringing this forward to us having done a lot of that leg work and due diligence so yeah well for me it was one of those things where like I've worked on these campaigns and I've done the social media for multiple campaigns like four of them now but the thing was is like I I think that for this and the fact that we didn't have enough information out when
151we did the polling like we need to make sure that the community understands where we're sitting at and I think that they might be able to help us get a broader reach and do it in a more effective manner than we'll be able to do it if we did it on our own um that and there's do big Stakes like we have teachers here that I want to get paid and I want this to pass so it's like we need to not I'd rather spend some money up front and make sure that it's you know this effort isn't Wast yes and just in for context this is Bally $99,000 of support plus a little over $99,000 for mailers which would have to do anyways and if we get the win on it it's a $30
152million win potentially so 9,000 for 30 million is sounds like a great trade sounds like a good return yeah yeah okay so um there's uh any more questions or g go up for the nonpublic comment oh all right so I'll bring it back to us to discuss them no I was going to ask you a question okaye question um so I don't really know this world and so when you look at Team civx it seems to be very very much tied into Marin County which is one of the things that I said was really important and understanding the nuances of each town I was just looking at the work that they've done they've done a lot of something San andelo though it looks like it's all San Rafel M Creek I just interesting animal s
153s Fairfax just they because they were working with Tam Union they were all over Fairfax and S as well so they they are familiar with our district and that was two campaigns that they worked on with them so they they are through T okay yeah through T yeah they've got I mean make sense they knew people in our community by name and familiar with things that we needed to be paying attention to so enough to impress me I was like okay so they know S I trust I trust you okay thanks so um what do you need from us uh looks like we need to a vote to the contract with Team to exi consulting services and an informational FL for parcel tax meure okay so um do you want to ask for a motion
154yes since we have no public for comment and we have no further discussion I will entertain a motion okay I will uh put forth a motion to approve the contract with Team s x to provide consulting services and informational flyer for paral tax measure great by by second I'll second it great Chris I Daniel hi Shell hi Rachel I all right so we have approved that cart thank you for bringing that forward um the next item is recommended approval of the 2024 25 first interim budget report for the opportunity to speak this evening this on should be down there we go okay so thank you for the opportunity to discuss the first interum this evening um this is just kind of an outline of what we'll be talking about um this evening and so did
155I just go too far okay so in terms of our demographics demographics are are the things that really Drive our revenues and so that's looking at our our students and so when looking at this this is our um enrollment and our P2 attendance and the one thing I want to point out is you'll see numbers that are different than what Tyler was sharing earlier this uh this evening uh in terms of our enrollment and there's a reason for that uh when looking at uh the enrollment in the um School business world we talk about the the seabeds date and the seabeds is a certain date that we look at our enrollment and our staffing every year and that date is the first Wednesday in October every year so on that particular date we had an
156enrollment of 1693 and then the other thing that we look at is what is our uh P2 attendance and the reason for that is P2 attendance which is um our annual attendance as of the end of March each year that's what we generally get paid upon if you are an lcff district and so our numbers here are estimates based upon what we think our attendance will be in the current year and so you'll note that we're showing our attendance um rates in the 94.2 to 94.3% range um and that's important uh when talking about uh our total revenues our lcff revenues for the years that we are in lcff as opposed to community funded and one of the things that's really important is that we get those attendance uh rates up we did have a
157historical rate that was in the 96.2% range in in uh prior to to covid and so what you saw was them the state holding us constant for several years and then in 2223 that was the first year that we actually went back to our the true attendance rate and we had an attendance rate of 93.1% so our rates have gone up but again you do see an overall decrease in our enrollment the other thing that's important to note is our funded average daily attendance versus our P2 Ada this is really critical when looking at kind of what's happened to us of the last several years as well what you'll notice is that there is some large discrepancies um between our funded average daily attendance and our P2 Ada and the reason for that is um
158districts have traditionally had um been funded based upon the hire of your P your current year average daily attendance or your prior year average daily attendance uh and so during covid because of the all of the the drops in in enrollment and attendance that District saw they went back and they said okay the state we're not going to hold harmless uh for just the one year we're going to do a three-year average as well so now we still have those those other factors but we we also now have a three-year average that's in consideration and so that's why you see the large differences between funded daily attendance and our P2 uh average daily attendance but the one thing that is really critical you'll see a linear um kind of an average you see it going
159down and so this is really critical because this impacts our directly our revenues as as we are in lcf funded status and we're bouncing as well between the community funded and average daily attendance so can I if we're projecting that it's going to be the same 94.3% attendance how come the drop off is bigger this year next year and the 2627 uh it has to do with your enrollment we are seeing larger drops in our enrollment so if I go back a slide you'll see some pretty Ste starting with 80 6 683 637 okay yeah so that's that's what drives that if we get those attendance rates up um we might still only have an enrollment of 1683 next year but our average daily attendance would be higher than that 1587 but we know our
160enrollment this year is 1680 uh 1693 in 2425 it's 1693 again this is our seabed state so our date in the first Wednesday in October this is where it gets really Chris and I talked about this before this meeting was because I was basically giving you the real numbers as of like yesterday and Chris is giving you a snapshot time one day back in October so that's where I think if you're a Community member listening in you can start getting really confused about why is Chris using a different number than the number Tyler was talking about and so our budgets are always built on Snapshot data when we're talking our our attendance percentages it's it's a snapshot of our seabeds date which is that date in October as well as attendance as of our P2
161attendance which is as of the end of March so it it will fluctuate and be different than what Tyler was discussing and and does discuss every every month as he provides that data so again you see the the downward Trend in both enrollment and average daily attendance and Chris where are you getting these projections for the out years um in so these projections for the out years they're based upon um demographic studies that we've done so we use um the data that's there in present to kind of show what our declines are the other thing that we do is we look at what is called cohort um data and so what we do is we we move our students forward a year each year and then drop off a grade and just on the on
162the natural you're also seeing declines so it's a combination of those two things and uh we actually saw an increase in our enrollment if you go back to here you see an increase in our enrollment between 2223 and 2324 we went from 1724 to 1739 um and so we were a little more aggressive because we weren't ever projecting enrollment increases within our demographic studies in cohorts so we were a little more aggressive in our budget in the current current year and our our enrollment actually came in quite a bit less than what we had projected as well at budget adoption and earlier this year you may have remembered approving a new demographic study Chris is working with that team to Kickstart that so we can continue to use the most relevant demographic data to make
163these oute projections yeah are we fully tked meaning I know there was increasing the ages Are We Now up next we do go up again be fully implemented next year fully full implementation is 2526 2526 okay so within our cohorts we're having to increase our TK enrollment slightly each each year until 25 26 and then it's just W that's the number so in terms of our revenues and expenses I like to show the the percentages just because it it helps to kind of put things in perspective and I want to point to to two different numbers one is the local control funding formula which is 19.27% it's 64.4% then the other is the parcel tax uh in the current year we're estimating to receive $4.7 million to the generosity of the the tax pairs of
164our community and that's 15.8% of our total District budget when looking at that you combine those and and you're looking at over 80% of our total revenues so those are the the two largest sources of revenues that we have um and so it it's also important to note that our local control funding formula dollars are going to be um dropping next year as we look at multi-year projections um and we'll talk about that in just a few minutes as well uh due to flipping in and out of community funded status didn't did it go there we go okay so the when looking at our expenses we are a service oriented U business in essence and we are here to serve the community and and teach the children and as such you would expect our single
165largest source of expenses to be people and that's what you see within our general fund um 74.3% of our total general fund is salaries and benefits and and then we have other various sources of of expenses as you can see here is maintenance in of the properties that you have up there maintenance gets um included a large portion of it under the services and other because it's considered repairs and maintenance so that's one of the things that gets into that category um but then you also have books and supplies that some of the um things that they purchase go into that category as well and have we you youve PED in the sell of the center to help us offset some of the on the revenue right does that count in the revenue before that
166could you repeat I'm sorry Chris uh the sale of the Deer Park the sale of deer park is in a different fund altogether so this is the general fund so any expenses that would come out of that would not be included in this as well it would be in a separate fund altogether that's right in terms of our fund balance I know that's one of the things that we uh talk about a lot this is a slide that Tyler showed earlier this is our total general fund uh so it's both restricted and unrestricted and here's where you can really see the drop in our lcff revenues in 2425 we expect to have 9,275 if you look at 23 24 we actually had more dollars even though we went into Community funded status we have less
167dollars in the current year than we did last year and the reason for that is those threeyear averaging we're starting to lose some of those years that we had those large discrepancies between funded average daily attendance and our P2 attendance you see that we're losing the um the hold harmless that the state has given us for covid and so that's the start of that then in 25 26 we actually drop even more 18.9 million in essence and part of that is we flip back into state aid in 25 26 and then in 26 27 we're anticipating flipping back out of state aid and backing the community funded status so we're doing that dance going up and down and so it just becomes rather difficult from a budget standpoint and if you look from 2223 all
168the way to 26 27 that's a difference in in total revenue of less than a million dollars in five years um and you can imagine how inflation is impacting our own personal budgets you know as we're giving raises and increases in contracts um you know that is a that that amount of Revenue change really is not keeping Pace with the the costs that we have at the district so theind me what the significant decrease in state revenues was driving that so what happened under federal and state revenues we had a lot of covid funds that were coming in so that that's partly what's driving those to drop okay and then when you look at the local revenues your largest sources of local revenues are going to be your partiel tax um your um the yes
169foundation and then we we also receive uh some of our special ed funds under local revenues actually so as flow through dollars through the county with respect to inflation what's the what are the conversations happening right now about the state's um cost of living increases Cola um we'll have the final numbers um we have actually have the governor's January budget proposal comes out in the middle of January uh and then we have a school Services um conference the day after uh marttin Luther King so we'll know what those final numbers are they're not final at this particular point but they're they're not good so those cost of living adjustments keeping up with cost of living the colas that are coming in they're actually what they're saying is that our projections that we have based upon
170numbers that we get through the um common message that comes basically all of the county offices of Education come together and come up with estimates based upon the Department of Finance numbers and those are the numbers that districts around the state use those common messages are probably higher than what our Cola is going to be in January so we'll be dropping that you could see slightly lower lcff revenues in 25 26 if that happens how how many students are we talking in that flip like if we had five more students we would stay in in state aid funded or is it 80 student I mean 80 students like what's the ma order magnitude on the number of students on a funded on a per student basis that is causing this flip more or less not
171you have to be precise I'm just I'm just looking at orders of magnitude I think and correct me from wrong here Chris we're about $500,000 into Community funded this year so that would be about 50 students okay yeah that's just so I mean we're it's very close 50 out of 17 and just based upon our property tax values that we're estimating um the the increases in property taxes versus the cost of living adjustments in the lcff I I could see us staying permanently in community funded Maybe by 2031 so we're kind of in that range some property taxes and turn people selling houses exactly but obviously there's a lot of factors that go into that but we're getting into that that period where we need to to be thinking about that where we would permanently
172being St stay in so and I think I mentioned that to Tyler not too long ago as well so again this this is where we're at oh that was our total general fund when we talk about what is our Reserve percentage it the reserve percentage really is a measure of our unrestricted ending fund balance so I wanted to break apart the the ending balances that were on the previous page and just give you what those look like and I know Tyler mentioned earlier that um the the three numbers to the left in terms of Reserve percentages 26.6 25.7 and 23.1 those are our actual Reserve percentages anything after that are estimates at this particular Point um we expect them to be potentially higher than that when we close but you know and it if the
173uh cost of living adjustment on the lcff revenues changes for 2526 our revenues might drop and we could go the other way a little bit too so there's lots of variables that happen but the one thing that is certain is our ending fund balance is dropping and I think if if I was looking at the 25 26 number at 88.7% and we had been between 8 and 10% for the last few years I wouldn't be be that worried cuz we're kind of flat but when you see the number going from 26 down to five that I'm worried about yeah um so you know I think Chris and I have these conversations all the time about what number you comfortable with what makes you you know stay up at night um and to me I'm a
174little less worried about the number as the rate of decline the rate of decline scares me I'm fine if it was eight and stable but it's not that that so I think that's the piece that uh keeps me up at night and unfortunately the state when they did that three-year averaging that actually hurt a lot of districts because what that did is it artificially held our numbers higher it it made you appear that you had a lot more dollars for a long time than you really did um and so that that became one of those pressure points for districts up and down the State and and what you see is a lot of districts including in the Bay area right now going through similar issues so but we're out of the artificially inflated tale of
175the three years we are now back into the actual it's still great that it's averaged which I think is an improvement over a single year but we still have the three-year averaging but we just don't have the covid artificial hold harmless in those numbers so that's really what was driving it so this kind of that fiscal C we've been hearing about for the last four years and this why I'm hearing about other school districts closing schools and combining themely so there was always that fiscal cliff but what happened is the state changed how we calculate our revenues and they moved that Cliff out and so it's still there for districts that were in steep decline so this is something that does keep me up at night as well and so kind of going back to
176our process I I know I was mentioning that the uh Governor's uh going to be providing the January uh proposal and so that will impact our second interim budget and will inform our estimated actuals which is what's what's a little difficult to understand here is at the estimated actuals we're actually doing doing estimated actuals and adopted budget it's actually two budget years that we're looking at at that particular point but just you'll see that um all of the data that we get in January will start to inform those and and then in May we'll have the May revision which will be more or less something that's close to what ends up being approved at the state level um but then you have the by June 30th the state will approve their and adopt their budget
177so so all of those impact our budgets as we move forward and we have all of our um budgets as we shown here and so with that do we have any questions pretty much answered them along the way appreciate that um when do we start folding in budget assumptions or alternate scenario assumptions with partial tax without paral tax I imagine it's part of the communication stuff at some point but you probably don't build it in until it's passed I would not build it in until it's passed that's correct we have an idea of what we would cut based on the the task force so if it doesn't pass there's some things already that we're looking at yeah and so I I think what we'll be doing is we'll be bringing back uh at our December
178I'm sorry January board meeting a list of uh the budget advisory committee um cuts that they were talking about just to inform the board those would be something that would impact the budget not for 2526 but for 2627 and to answer your question directly I wouldn't build it into the budget until I know it passed and so if we were to move forward I don't want to assume that we're going to but if we were to move forward in um for the May election then we would have an idea if it passed and we could potentially add that to our adopted budget for the following year which was going to get my sequencing question too about like if the if we don't know about the partial tax before we have to have an adopted budget
179do we have to make budget cuts before we know whether we're going but if it's all happening around May back to tight time frame getting it on then we can make the decisions together in formed is what I'm hearing so that's helpful thank you I think the budget advisory committee the plan was to bring it to the board so we'd see the idea and give authorization for when they needed to make cuts that was the prioritized list with the amounts and how much they were you know cutting but it wouldn't have to exactly well and part of it was some of them require like a March 15th deadline for a release and so we would be hitting that in a few months and if we you know don't have time for that um which is
180why it would be an extra school year later so and we're planning to bring that list to you on January 29th big meaning okay thank you all right so we have uh no questions we're all done here all right no public for a comment do we have any discussion up here at the board no okay so um we do need to um approve uh the first interim budget report here so I recommend that we approve first interim budget report second motion there second Daniel hi Shelly hi Chris hi Rachel I okay and moving on um we have item mate which is present for public review or notice resolution number 07242 five and the annual accounting of the 20232 24 developer fees in fund 25 government code section 66001 D and 666b so this is Chris
181this is me again so this is um just an information item this evening we'll bring it back to the January uh board meeting for approval and what this does is it just provides information to the uh to the rate payers anytime you pull a permit uh to do any type of construction that you're adding to your property or building a building a home building a new business you have to pay a developer fee to the school district to help offset the cost of any additional children that might be um might happen as a result of that property that might come into the school district and create additional need for space and so what is required is that we it kind of going back to that if you if you build a new home you might
182have children that move into the home as well and so those those children might create the need for additional classrooms and so this developer fee offsets the cost of that to be able to then build those classrooms and so this is a requirement to just bring it to the governing board by the end of December each um each calendar year and so this is just our dollars that were received and expended expended out of that fund at the end of last year great thanks Chris do we have any questions for him all right we have no public for comment all right any further discussion all right thank you Chris all right moving on with agenda uh we have consent actions um unless we have to do we there's no vote on one okay all right
183there's no v um so consent actions um unless anybody wants to pull anything out I will entertain a motion to approve all six yeah I'll second okay wait I was just saying I will entertain I thought you said no no sorry excuse me no you want to make the I'll make a motion to approve all six okay thank you Daniel hi Chris hi Shell hi Rachel hi thank you and bringing that uh next one is board business so I have committee updates and reports from and trustees I intended we had a whole presentation on which is awful um and there to the superintendent's Council and the round table and um both of those I think have been going really well I've appreciated the small group discussion format super engaged tons of people you know people
184are definitely showing up and you said before like very engaged Community um and the um new new faces as there's new PTA president presidents and new site councils but they're there they're showing up um some great folks who have really good questions and lots of experience with finances and so it seems like a high level of employment question the last one I don't have any I mean interest of time a concert tonight at White Hill was quite wonderful um can't say anything better more heart was full great attendance wonderful sounds S I didn't get to go to that um how's the Winter Market oh so yeah the Winter Market Daniel and I both went to the Winter Market and he um he wrangled four of our mascots great thing is fifth graders now fit into
185costumes so we good for another couple years oh my gosh they were so adorable because they're all you know they're all the same height so it was really it was really cute how was your art project it was fun there were there was some Refreshers required for some of the adults because they were like I I know what they're supposed to look like so it was fun um and then we just talked to a ton of people who came by it was great and it was beautiful like it was really well done I'm glad that you know me and Kim reached out to us we were able to get something put together I would like to do something more next year now that I know what to expect and like how fun it was um
186I went to the way Thomas Harvest which was great I'd never been to one of those and I've been hearing about them so that was a lot of fun I went to the Dr Lorie Watson presentation at Valley she was it was really powerful hearing her speak I'm definitely going to the one in January um I went to the yes board meeting and they welcomed their new um their new executive director which is Lisa Ben cour um so she will be taking the Reigns now and kind of leading yes which is fantastic she's a manner parent she is a manner parent is she Charter yeah so she's on board now which is wonderful I know that their their steering committee their executive board is very happy that she's on staff now so that's been great
187um I know the yes leaders have been rolling out stuff um they did their white Hill play and then um like Manor and Wade Thomas are rolling right now I think H Valley just opened up their registration um and Brookside they're all kind of working on their things for the spring for their their stuff going on there um and then I guess this month has all been the sing Longs and the other things that they wanted me to mention um let's see other than that I think that was the main stuff oh I went to my first superintendent Council on accident I went to pick up some costumes and like drop drop off stuff but um Danel was sick that day so I ended up showing up and hanging out because I was like that's
188interesting so that was wonderful um it was it was really productive for me just to see what goes on at that meeting since i' never been there in my four years here so that was all move on to the next item um which is the approval of regular meeting minutes for October 9th and oh so yeah we have a quorum to on this one there's three of us here three of us yeah uh I will make a motion that we approve the regular meeting minutes for October 9th 2024 okay all right so Rachel I hi Shel hi Daniel hi Chris upst and approval of regular meeting minutes for November 13th 2024 shell you were not here for that I was not here yeah so um I will make a motion that we approve the regular
189meeting minutes for November 13th 2024 second it great Rachel I Daniel I uh Shelly and Chris all great thank you and superintendent cabinet report updates yeah so uh I've been doing a ton of stuff since last month uh that we met uh paral tax conversations with Roser record Madera and Tam Rachel I really appreciate you meeting um with those folks to learn from them our elll celebration last week was a huge huge uh success really excited there parent Guardian Equity task force and Dr Watson um some two of our great Equity events um let's see a Fairfax Winter Market which was a lot of fun uh CA negotiations I also went to a white Hill share case which is where teachers talk about uh their professional learning and collaboration some of their focal students which
190is also more of our Equity work that we're doing um that was a big highlight for me as well um and then uh Eric and I met with someone last week to talk about a potential review of our special education programs excited to bring that to the board at some point as well Julie I think the um the only thing I would add is we had a um Ela adoption committee release day last week and um spent most of the day Molina led us through a evaluation of the program that the teachers have been piloting for I don't know maybe nine weeks now Benchmark advance and it was a fantastic process really really good conversation um um just really clear that you know the teachers are learning a lot about what they want and what
191they don't want by working with this program and we are going to be moving forward with the spring pilot of el education um which I'm really excited about um largely because a lot of what you're looking for in an Ela program right now has to do with this knowledge strand of the the big shift from balance literacy to kind of a more structured literacy program is anchoring the instruction in content and knowledge so you're not teaching skills and then layering on top of that it's kind of the reverse you're you're anchored in content and the content and topics that are offered by El education are fantastic a fifth grade unit on the 19th Amendment or kindergarten starts the year investigating toys um so they're really student appropriate they have a very very strong Equity lens
192um which of course we're really happy about as well so and then the other part of it that's really exciting is we're going to be piloting in partnership with roxburg cour of Madera um which I think will be really interesting so all good stuff there um uh November 19th we had our first Wellness committee meeting of the year and U it was uh really great um for uh White Hill students are student wellness ambassadors um were in the house and um they um along with uh the counseling staff at White Hill did a presentation on uh Wellness practices at White Hill so I was really exciting to have a board committee with student representation and you know it was um really cool for for them to be in a you know in a space where
193there's like this official committee and we're like and you know and they're able to share uh their work um they uh they've been you know at County trainings um for you know training up these these uh youth ambassadors on how to go out and you know be Educators to to other uh young kids um and also um you know they're kind of learning from the high school kids Redwood High School kids and Archie kids have have uh gone to White Hill to do different health related presentations and and um uh so that was really cool our next one's going to be in uh February and uh so that'll be that'll be really good nothing see thank you um and with that uh future board topics and board Direction you have any feedback here I want
194to talk a little bit about just wellness and safety on things around campus talk to Tyler um earlier in the week around just parent education around Internet safety drugs and alcohol dating just kind of almost like a a series for parents and students there was a recent incident where um a student was uh being groomed on social media and it's like yeah kids you can't go outside it's dangerous outside but here's un mitigated access to the internet at second grade whatever fourth grade I just had another conversation parents today at Brookside and so I just think we need to do more about educating parents and I don't know what our role is it's like smoking in the 60s was at the schools roll to say no we think smoking's bad we don't know yet the
195research no we know social media is really bad like we know that but yet we're still hey kids here's a phone keep yourself busy so I don't know I just think that we have to do some I don't know what we I want to do do something about that so future topic there there are parent um run uh Zoom calls that we often participate in most recent was understanding the teen brain for example and um they had a topic along those lines and perhaps we can leverage off of those to put in our newsletters instead of us probably and J so I'm in contact with the Department of Homeland Security guy out of San Francisco who um my cousin works with he' put me in touch with them for resources and support for families and
196so it there's something there that we should do at a larger level than a parent Zoom call hey I'm really you know like cuz it's again parents mean well yeah yeah but the social media is not good no it's not people are now slowly starting to come around to that but still they don't know what to do about it I mean I think the idea for future topics of parent education parent awareness the role of the school district the role of PT how how that like who who plays which roles in bringing people together around um those kinds of it could be series of things you know how dating has changed in the past 15 years right how intimate relationships are changing even at White Hill right sixth seventh e8th grade right stuff starts getting
197serious and you know but I remember what we did in middle school but it's a lot different now so how do we just educate parent you know just to got enough Direction I do okay thank you dude thank you I also didn't know if we um do we have to if we decide we want to form a subcommittee say to help with the partial tax do we need to have a meeting and like vote on that or don't know you can maybe look into how that gets established because it's like ad hoc is it yeah I mean standing committees are different from just ad hoc things so it's look how we do it yeah because I would like to figure out how we can like hey yes we'll all be involved but also like who
198are the people who are the key ones to go to on the board if we're like doing that okay kind of like we do with the search yeah like do we we kind of decided that in the meeting do we vote on that okay we should look that up okay yes it's a lighter lift than the other yeah all right and with that um meeting de brief any comments on this meeting other than the length which I don't think we really could have done anything about we needed to talk about a l of stuff is before 10 it is before 10 all right with that um I'm not going to make a motion to continue past 10:30 uh I will adjourn our meeting at 956