0012025 of the debut Community District's board of education is called to order our mission is to develop world class Learners and citizens of character in a safe and inclusive Learning Community roll call please Bradley here Hamill here jacobitz Kaz here Jones here Parks here sansy here Whitman here we're going to start with the Pledge of Allegiance led by students from otan elementary school schol go ahead no say your name say your name in your grade I'm Ava and I'm in third grade I'm Cody Hodge and I'm in third grade I'm Sebastian B I'm in first grade I'm Mia and I'm in Kinder Garten I'm Prince and I am in second grade I to the flag of United States America and to theu for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice
002for all good J thank you I move the Board of Education approve the agenda as submitted second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education approved the agenda as submitted is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that motion carries I move that the Board of Education improve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 9th 2024 the special meeting of January 6th and the special meeting of January 8th 2025 as submitted second been moved and seconded that the Board of Education approved the minutes of the regular meeting of December 9th 2024 the special meeting of January 6th and the special meeting of January 8th 2025 as submitted is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I
003any opposed that motion carries all right so that brings us to board salutes and I believe there are two board salutes out there yeah I have one of the board salutes tonight and this one goes out to a few of our Hempstead High School students named Christiana aluri AI Patel and Brandon Zang these students earned a medal of excellence in the Congressional debate that was on Friday and Saturday in the Iowa high school speech Association State debate tournament all of these three students competed in the B chamber category and they did an out standing job as this not only takes a lot of hours in preparation but also challenges them to defend their position on a range of different topics so great job uh well done to Christiana Ai and brandan thank you I'm delighted
004to bring a board salute uh for the Prescott empty bows soup luncheon yeah I would had the privilege of serving on their their Advisory board when they were a charter school and that was when they started the the um yearly fundraiser which is a soup luncheon if you haven't participated I would really suggest you watch for mid December next year and take it in it it includes the family involvement Network and the Prescott school students and staff work together and it's an outstanding event it is their main fundraiser for the year and the students are trained in serving the guests who come to enjoy the luncheon and their artwork is on display they present musical numbers for the group while lunch is being served and uh there's a silent auction It's a Wonderful event beautifully
005done and uh we congratulate all uh those who made that possible great excellent it was a good event and the soup was delicious my son was very mad that he didn't get to be our waiter at our table but it's okay maybe next year maybe next year any other board salutes all right thank you thank you very much I move the Board of Education suspend The Rules of Order and go into open form second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education suspend The Rules of Order and go into open forum is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that motion carries so we're going to start the visitor and open Forum um with a report from Ed Glazer from otoman elementary school
006to hear about what's going well at Udan thanks for having me and inviting our students uh first and foremost uh the students at otan uh is what's going well our our families are are doing an excellent job um with attendance is the first thing um this year on our performance profile our growth in attendance um was uh double what the state average was and I predict if we fast forward a year we'll be at triple or quadruple in that growth and we're hovering just shy of that 95% and we're trying to get to 95% average daily attendance so that's the first thing that's going well um I've been principal for 12 or 13 years our behavioral data is the best it's been in 13 years and maybe Way Beyond that from when I was there
007as a teacher um so yeah kids are working hard and being safe and respectful it's a lot of fun uh going to work uh and then academically we have I ready data that comes through in the fall so our fall data we had 8% growth um over any of the previous three years in reading and in math so looking forward um they're starting to take that this week so we'll get our winner results but I'm hoping that that Trend continues and with kids showing up to school and being safe and respectful and working hard every day uh I'm predicting that we're going to continue to see that trend so thank you thank you anyone else wishing to address the board can do so at this time please know that following Iowa Code we can't engage
008with you but we do want to hear from you so if you would like to address the board and speak to tonight we'd ask that you come to the podium State your full name and your connection to the district and limit your remarks to 3 minutes using the timer that we have provided yep if you want to come up come on up where's the timer it's right there okay all right hi everybody um my name is Teresa Oliver my relation to the district is my son Cameron Oliver goes to Hoover and I am here because of an email that we received last Wednesday regarding your consideration for the closing of Hoover um I'm hoping this comes out a lot smoother than I as smooth as I it can considering we got the email last Wednesday
009and we had soccer tournaments this weekend and um it took a while to put this all together but what I'm concerned about with the email that we got on Wednesdays I'm I feel like I'm concerned about the lack of transparency that led to this recommendation I actually took a lot of time and I combed through the meeting minutes of the school board and the subcommittees and I could not find record of the data and the decision points that led us to the email that was kind of we felt uh many parents felt dropped in our laps last Wednesday um and I I just we I think we need a lot more transparency about where this um how this recommendation came about um you know it feels like the school board or or this recommendation went
0100 to 60 on us regarding this topic um to further that like travel analogy it feels like you're already 100 miles down the road and we're at sitting at the stop sign um it doesn't feel like we were brought along as you explored the various ways to save money we we weren't you know brought along with what the decision points were and what the data used to make those decisions were at each Crossroads as you travel down the way and now we're supposed to believe that that you know this is where we're at this is the decision but we don't know how you got there and we don't feel like we were brought along with it so we're just supposed to kind of trust that it's the right decision um you know we weren't informed
011that we looked into a we looked into B we looked into C we looked into D and this is why we crossed this one off and this is why we crossed this one off and that leads to the the entire premise is the entire premise accurate do we need to to close Hoover do we really need to save a million dollars as our teachers would say to us show your work how did you get here um you know and if Hoover has declining enrollment I only have 40 seconds left if Hoover has declining enrollment we have schools that are overcrowded nearby we actually have housing projects nearby in the immediate vicinity that are going to be going up on um arterial and Kerper and holy family just increased their uh tuition $4,000 it's no longer
012Apples to Apples for private education and public education and they're going to be coming back um I also want people to know that this is just not a Hoover concern this is a concern for table Mound Irving and Kennedy you if you are a parent there you should be concerned there too because you're going to get an influx of kids coming into your school and how are you going to hold on to your school's performance is it going to drop or is it going to stay the same I have more to say but I I really implore you um the last thing I would say is that Hoover is a a disadvantaged school um it has a it's a serves a high need area and yet they still manag to pull a commendable rating for
013their school and I don't think the school should be closed I think it needs to be modeled thank you hello um my name is Dan Hansen um I also am a parent of two children at uh Hoover School um I've been in this community for um almost five decades and um other than two years um I've been outside of the debuk area um I have been a lifelong deuker when I came back to debuk um after the couple years I was out um I picked my home in the area that I picked it because of the reputation that Hoover had as one of the the top schools um in the area um and it's it is very disappointing for as a parent just as you know the other lady stated that all of a sudden
014just surprise let's close the place without having you know heard any input whatsoever you know I I have kids from you know two ends of the spectrum I have one that is you know excelling up in the 99th percentile I have one that's you know in in the you know moderate area and um Hoover has taken care of both of my kids from both angles um very well we've had other um issues with other um children and some other and things and they have been extremely attentive to you know things that weren't even in the school um jurisdiction to be honest and they still took the bull by the horns to take care of these issues to teach my kids to help them learn to be the young adults that they you know are today
015um this is a great school and you know the other piece that I'll put to that is where I live um right now um if if you were to the the two places that I would probably be shifted to my kids would be um Irving or um Kennedy and one of those would double the distance my kids have to go to get to school the other one is more than double and the one that's double uh would force my kids to cross the busy street of J uh JFK which is you know um I you know that' honestly be the one from an academic area maybe I prefer although Irving I went to Irving myself um but you know it's it seems like we're just being left in the dark you know on these you
016know matters that you know and the school itself that it's it's not worth you know putting an extra strain on the other schools to take the kids when you have a very well run very well um oiled machine in that school to the way that they treat and and educate their kids and I implore you to reconsider and not close a school thank you [Applause] hello I'm Brandon Valentine I have two kids in the Hoover School District and I also am here to ask some questions about the closing of Hoover I was looking at the report and we were told that we were going to save a million dollars a year by closing down Hoover and I obviously we weren't shown how or why there wasn't a detailed like breakdown so I tried my best
017to try and figure out how exactly we would save that money we especially not getting rid of the school we wouldn't be getting any any money from selling the school so there's no no money there we wouldn't get any money from from those teachers because they would just be repositioned and throughout the rest of the the school district we would we would save a small amount of money on Heating and electricity because we'd still have to heat it keep electricity and maintain it have a maintenance guy there all times so that it wouldn't deteriorate like Nativity did when they left their building unused so I I wasn't able to see where this million doll figure came from especially I say especially after I was looking over the budgets for the past three years and we
018were 6 million 7971 188 off over just a two-year span on what our our projected budget should be on the low side so I mean I have a really hard time believing that we're going to save a million dollars on this when we can't even figure out where our budget is why the next question I got is Hoover has excellent south-facing property a lot of flat a lot of flat rooftops and I know we've looked into solar and and I was kind of wondering if at some point in time you guys could address why that wasn't viable cuz if we were rate code 600 under under Alliant then this is a pretty simple install save and take advantage of the benefits we can add AC which would improve our students learning habitat I mean everybody
019learns better when they're more comfortable we gain instruction hours because they wouldn't be getting sent home early and you could do this across the district now I get it if we are rate code 440 then that becomes far more difficult then it then it becomes an issue of the school sits down with not only the the Alliant but also this the um the city and the uh and the uh Solar Company and they and you work out a deal on on relief and and um School exemptions so that maybe there's an option there even under 440 where we save money the average School in Iowa saved over $23,000 a year going to solar but I'm just I just feel like there isn't enough inform information and there's other ways that we could save money throughout
020the district without closing down a school that has done my kids a ton of a ton of good especially you considering they have behavior problems and my and the teachers are excellent and they've done everything they can and I I just can't see it closing down especially when you look at at the metrics I mean they're not anywhere near the lowest scoring they're not anywhere near the they're not anywhere near the highest cost per pupil like I don't see I mean it doesn't make any sense to me why we close that school down and thank you for giving me time and also I sent an email with a further breakdown with with the numbers to each one of you thank you we did get your email thank you [Applause] I'm seeing no more um any
021is there anyone else wanting to speak okay thank you good evening I'm Steve vanv art educator at Hoover Elementary proud District employee of 24 years and um I couldn't be more prouder of my employer or the school than I've been gifted to be at for that amount of time um it'd be hard pressed to probably find anybody that has the experience or knowledge uh left in our district that might know a little bit more about Hoover and that so I would love and I encourage each board member to reach out to me I would love to tell you my stories about my travels through the district and um the great experiences that uh Hoover has brought to me enrich my life and uh yeah it'd be great so you know I was thinking about this
022I'm I'm not much to read off a page I like to shoot from the hip sometimes so um you know one of the things that um I thought about it kind got covered by some people and I know a lot of people in the community I've been born and raised here and you know a lot of people come to me and and they want to know the why and that's something that I work with with our students on is no one likes to be told what to do but if you explain the why you can hopefully um be able to take that in and be able to you know put it together in the sense that you can proceed forward forward and formulate the best plan for you in that moment of time and I
023think that's what I hear from the community and hearing from some people that have come forward is they're still not sure the why the work the stewardship that all of you have come to do and superintendent uh Hawkins you know is much appreciated and um the jobs that you have moving forward is not easy in a state that doesn't fund our public system so there are tough decisions but you know one of the things that kind of came up was you know why why if we can explain the why you know the 2019 data kind of struck me as an anomaly you know I think we're kind of a school and again I don't have the data but I think we're kind of a school that falls about 288 to 330 you know the Open
024Enrollment open enrollment out is kind of a wash and you know these decisions are tough we think about where these students come from uh their living areas are they you know are they more apt to move and that kind of stuff so you know as we go through as we look at this we you know ask ourselves is this the best flex space you know do we need to describe what efficiencies mean more to people in our community just to have that transparency to give the Optics because you know the children are listening they're watching they're our future for our public schools and the people that care for them are the ones that are going to vote on the issues that are so important to our schools so if anything can become of this let's
025reflect as ourselves as Educators as people that make decisions and let's do the best jobs we can of which I know we try every day to do thank you so much thank [Applause] you hello I'm Katie har I'm a fifth grade teacher at Hoover and I'm here representing myself and my fifth grade students and all of Hoover the Hoover community and all of the teachers back there um I just wrote something that myself and my students came up with so I'll just read from it good evening my name is Katie Harvey I'm a fifth grade teacher at Hoover Elementary I'm here today to express mine and my students deep concern regarding the proposed closure of our school which has been a vital part of our community for 57 years 3 years ago I came to
026Hoover and it welcomed me with open arms I've been teaching for 13 years but these past three years I have felt I have made more of an impact on student lives than ever before Hoover is a school where it's home it's home to students staff parents and community members it's a place where students feel valued respected and accepted without fear or judgment it's a place where students Thrive and feel emotionally secure it's a place where everyone feels included the people here the makeup of this school is what makes it special and unique I firmly believe there is no other school in the district like it closing our doors is like locking the door to our home like any plan there's option b I encourage you to consider it and this is just a paragraph from
027my fifth grade classroom this school is our Hive and we are all family we have so so many memories here the school was built for a reason and many teachers will be displaced throughout the district and no longer be together some may be left without jobs students Futures are unclear and they could be separated from friends and family our school supports our students needs and kids may not feel like they belong in their new school or accepted Hoover is a small tight-knit community it's easy to Navigate please consider keeping our doors open and letting our Hive thrive thank [Applause] you is there anyone else that wishes to approach and speak just one thing I'll share uh is that superintendent Hawkins is going to provide some more information during the Ed programs portion of this meeting
028which is happening in just a few minutes so if you're looking for more information and some of the information that you were asking about um if you could stick around it's coming with that I'll move the Board of Education reinstate The Rules of Order and return to regular session second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education reinstate The Rules of Order and return to regular session is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries I move that the Board of Education improve those items listed in the consent agenda second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education approved those items listed in the consent agenda is there anything a board member would like to have pulled seeing none all
029those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries that brings us to the facilities and support services committee report from Miss Woodman okay I will summarize our meeting we we have lots of conversations at our committee meetings this meeting was held on January 6th at 400 p.m. here at the same place um we had an update on District projects which we always do in our meetings Senior High School renovation 2 the construction is complete just odds and ends of cleanup work is left to finish sville Elementary solar project the project is complete we're just waiting for the rebate check for reimbursement Eisenhower gym addition project the plans for the project are almost complete and specs will be ready for bid next week March facility meeting we will have the results of
030the bids Irving mechanical remodel project the project is in the design phase and pl should be available um that I know it says February meeting so they're almost done with the plan so we'll get to see the final one in February the transportation siding replacement the project is on track and all siding has been replaced in waiting for the new new steel doors to arrive and the painting will be done in the spring when it's warmer the Rosevelt Bus Loop resurfacing project the bid opening for this project will be January 28th and public hearing will be held after the facilities and support service committee meeting in February and the Marshall um playground replacement project the project is currently in design phase this is the next school that we plan on replacing the playground equipment and
031will be presented at the facilities Support Services meeting in February and one more project that Donna was just brought to our attention Carver Elementary School shared with the committee about a new accessible play equipment for students with mobility issues was installed during the winter break at Carver the funds for the equipment were raised from the Carver fall fundraisers and the Carver parent teacher group Improvement cost for the equipment estimated at 37,500 so Carver is very proud and I know it's a newer school but it's how many years old now I think they said 18 18 yeah it's hard to believe but they've made the the equipment that is there in the space that there is more has more um access for mobility issues and it was all the funds were raised by the parents and
032the school so that was awesome um Center justics that's with our um efficiencies for um heating and air the Hoover there's always a contest on who has the most savings so Hoover Elementary won the energy saving contest over the winter break so congratulations to and this is the whole school it's not just one person that makes this happen it's everyone shedding off lights when they're supposed to turning down thermostats making sure things are turned down over the weekends when the school's not in use and I'm sure the students take part in all of this as well so congrats and 15 of our district buildings were aborted the energy star label which is an increase from last year two more buildings got the energy star label so we're very proud of the way our district is
033handling our buildings and trying to keep costs down and that is all I have thank you just the Motions oh sorry I do have some motions thank you I move the Board of Education approved the request to the school budget Review Committee for a modified to supplemental amount and supplemental aid for the 2025 2026 Dropout prevention program in the amount of 5 ,1 45,8 based on the formula and match for expenditures necessary to implement the 2025 and 2026 at risk and Dropout prevention programs second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education approv the request to the school budget Review Committee for modified supplemental amount and supplemental aid for the 2025 2026 Dropout prevention program in the amount of 5,145 $14 based on the formula and match for expend expenditures necessary to implement
034the 2025 2026 at risk and Dropout prevention program plans is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries I move the Board of Education tentatively tentatively approve the plans and specifications form of contract and estimate of total cost for ellan Middle School repaving storm water project and set the date time and location as February 3rd 2025 at 430 p.m. at the D Community School District at 2300 Cheney Road debuk Iowa for a hearing there on and further authorize the advertisement for competitive bids second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education tentatively approved the plans specifications form of contract and estimate of total cost for the Elanor Roosevelt Middle School repaving stormwater project and set the date time and location is February
0353rd 2025 at 430 p.m. at the debuk Community School District 2300 Cheney Road debuk Iowa for a hearing thereon and further authorize the advertisement for competitive bids is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries the next motion um we have Lisa Demmer that will present present the quarterly budget report second and I move the Board of Education approve the quarterly budget report but Lisa is going to speak good evening Schoolboard members and superintendent Hawkins I just have a few things I'd like to point out with the budget report um the general fund expenditures on page 51 um when I add the year-to-date expenditures to the encumbrance column the total is a little over 34 million this amount is comparable to the total expenditures
036we had at this time last year um we do know as we continue on with our year and the spring does we do tend to see more expenditures so we will continue to monitor these expenditures closely I would also like to talk about the pebble fund expenditures on 51 on page 51 the report does show a deficit of about two $2.7 million in the budget balance column the reasons for this are because of our FY 2324 bus replacement um were carried over from last year and going to be paid out this year and we also have encumbered all the funds for our safety grant that we will be getting reimbursement for but those um expenditures are in those budgets and then the last I would like to look at is the district revenues on pages
03753 through 59 the revenue report shows that through December 31st the district has received approximately 50% or more of the budgeted revenue for the for the year in all of the f except the nutrition and save fund the save fund is well over 50% due to the bond proceeds that we received for the Eisenhower and Irving projects the nutrition fund is only at 24% of the budgeted revenues and the reason for that is we implemented the um impotent campus Food Service module this year and we're still working on some reporting issues with that so we hope to have that completed at the end of this month does anybody have any other questions for me thank you thanks l okay I'll restate I move the Board of Education approve the quarterly budget report second it's been
038moved and seconded that the Board of Education approved the quarterly budget report thank you for that report all those in favor or is there any other discussion I guess all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries that's all I have Kate thank you Miss Whitman we're going to hand it over to superintendent Hawkins for Ed programs and policy report good evening everybody you know as I look out into this um into this room tonight I'm not surprised to see what I see you know we see lots of people here we have our staff here we have kiddos here we have parents here and we have community members here that are upset regarding a recommendation that um myself and our team made to the board this week and to be
039honest with you I would be really disappointed if you weren't here and upset about that we strive in our district so that our students feel welcome um they feel I heard the word SEC emotionally secure that they feel like they're part of a family and we strive for that in each and every one of our buildings each and every day so the fact that you feel that way I love that the culture feels that way and Kathleen thanks for all your work that you do to make that cult to [Applause] happen this is um this is a tough thing I mean nobody wants to wake up in morning and say you know we're going to go close a school today you know closing schools is something that is not a familiar thing that has happened
040in the debut Community School District it's a challenging thing and I know most of you probably don't care that I say this but it's got personal ties to me personally does well um I went to Hoover my children went to Hoover my mother and my grandmother worked there and my parents still live right across the street from Hoover Elementary School so this was not by any means an easy decision but as superintendent is also my job to make sure that we are fiscally responsible and looking at our budgets as we move forward each and every year and when we make those recommendations s those are because we've really vetted many different options that you know to see what option really makes most sense I apologize some of you have seen this presentation that I'm going
041to give it's going to be a repeat but for those of you that shared tonight I hope this gives you some answers to really what is the reason why we're looking at closing Hoover Elementary School okay so the first thing I'm going to talk about oh one other thing I wanted to say is I am so glad Mr V got up here this would not be complete without Mr V giving us a little speech so um Steve I'm thankful for you doing that tonight um you know if you remember last uh November we went through a bond referendum um in the with the Deb Community School District again something else that was very unfamiliar we hadn't done that before and part of that's because we are getting low funding from the state when we look
042at our SSA which is our state supplemental aid for years the state funded us at about 4% which is the exact same percentage of inflation that's what people were getting for their jobs all those things and over the last 10 to 15 years that number just keeps going down and going down I mean we've had years where the state has given us 1% new money well many people in this room besides the teaching staff um didn't get just a 1% raise in their jobs and so it's been difficult for us funding wise to keep things moving in the direction that we needed to move to make sure that our students are getting the best experience and the best education possible so we went for a bond referendum and in that Bond referendum we looked to
043move from three to two Middle School we know that efficiency comes from our our middle schools if we can get our middle schools from 3 to two and have feeder programs to the high school that needs to happen and that still will need to happen in our district after after you know whatever happens here in the near future secondly we've continued to look at ways that we can internally find efficiencies teaching staff and board members you'll remember last year we looked at teacher leadership and we said hey we know how important it is for us to have teacher leaders in this District but the state gave us some flexibility with some funding and we said hey do we need to look at teacher leadership so we can save teaching staff and the answer overwhelming was
044was yes we looked at teacher quality dollars those are dollars that we provide to our staff around professional development and other things that they may want to attend to better themselves as a teacher those are things that we've decided to cut back on okay not only have we gotten low State supplemental aid but our costs have increased everybody knows that postco inflation went way up way more than 1% so all everything that we do in the district cost more than it did four or five years ago okay so what do we do in internally we started looking at school facilities how can we be efficient in our facilities we started to look at enrollment because we know that Iowa in general has not grown in population and we also know that our enrollment has declined
045over the last 5 years I was actually at a meeting with the city last Friday and they did a p a projection of um of debutee and what do our current um why am I what am I thinking what I want to say population TR our population thanks Anderson and honestly when they showed our population today in 2024 because it was last year's data to 2025 2029 it showed that debuk is going to decrease in population so one of the things that I have found as the superintendent of schools is school Finance is the craziest thing you'll ever talk about it's really hard to understand and and we're really fortunate that we have a CFO Lisa Demmer that can kind of keep me filled in to how these things work but there's lots of different
046funding sources which we're going to talk about that make a difference if you can go back one more Mike the other thing we looked at is how can we retain staff we know that as a state we're having trouble filling some teaching positions we're having trouble filling par positions I mean if anybody tells me they're retiring and I don't ask them if they want to be a bus driver I mean cuz those are Ernie's laughing at me but yeah I mean those are things that we need to look at and be able to say hey we have a staff here how can we make this work in our openings that we currently have okay with that being said there are two money funds that I want to talk about tonight the first one is our
047general fund so our general fund is funding that we get from the state so when we talk about state State supplemental Aid we are talking about general fund we are funded by the state by how many students are in our schools so we get x amount of dollars per student that we have so when our enrollment is declining that means we get less money people say what can you spend out of the general fund we 85% of our general fund dollars are spent on staff salary and benefits so that is the majority of what we can spend in our general fund so when we talk today about we're looking at ways that we can save a million dollars we're talking about out of our general fund okay the next fund is what we can we
048call Save dollar or many of you will know it by 1 cent sales tax so every time you go to the store you buy Goods this is how we get money as a district this again save dollars is based on how many students we have in our district so when our numbers decline our save dollars decline as well okay what can we use Save dollars for Save dollars are really made for infrastructure so when we uh renovated Senior High School that was out of save dollars when we're talking about um Eisenhower project that was on the bond referendum or air conditioning of Irving we are talking about save dollars that we can bond for and we can bond for them down in future years okay we cannot you save dollars for staff um for Staffing
049okay so those two fun so when we talk about things you know people have said to me well wait a minute you just renovated senior why didn't you use that money to save Hoover and really we're talking about two different funds okay so when we start to look at at efficiency and what what are those considerations really the enrollment Trends pointed to the fact that we really can consolidate an elementary school so then you ask me well why why you why did you pick Hoover so first we looked at enrollment Trends over a sixe period of time we looked at how many of our students in District transfer so we have students that in District transfer to schools and kids that in District transfer to other schools it's a big process that we do each
050and every year it's Lisa Fel is's favorite thing to do um and then we looked at capacity in buildings that surrounded other buildings in our district okay so when we look at boundaries any buildings that are share and boundaries what does it look like for their capacity and then as I said earlier Staffing considerations what does it look like that we would have a spot because we we really do not in our I mean we're going to work super hard to not let any of our staff go because we've got a great staff so if you look at these numbers this is certified enrollment this is how many students were in seats the day that the state takes certified enrollment for us so you can look at we're going from 2019 all the way up
051to last or till 24 25 school year because we have our certified enrollment as of October 15th so if you look at this two schools that stand out for me are Prescott and Udan both of their numbers have increased and that mainly over time is because we Clos foled if you'll remember we closed Fulton a few years back and many of those students went to presat and Eisenhower okay but if you look at this closely the one school that is standing out to us is Hoover Elementary Hoover over a six-year period of time has decreased in enrollment by almost 23% okay and when we look at those numbers I want you to look at Irving and Kennedy so we've talked a little bit tonight about well is their capacity are we are we um you
052know shoving students into schools and there's no room if you look at Irving they're down 45 kids over the last six years and Kennedy has down 86 students over the last six years okay so we look at Hoover as a whole Hoover the students that live in the Hoover boundaries is 219 of our students we have 76 students that open enroll into Hoover so they're supposed to be in a different school and then we have 93 students that currently open and roll out of Hoover and go to other buildings okay so again we looked at boundaries and I don't love this map but if you look at it um you can see the Hoover boundaries are the yellow and then the ones that we really um share or or butt up against are Irving which
053is there on the right hand side and Kennedy which is there on that um the West End side and then table Mound comes down and that's that red area which is really um past Highway 20 okay so when we looked at our boundaries we really looked at to say okay is there a PL is since there's room at Irving and Kennedy what does that look like if we would we would possibly you know change the boundary line to go straight down that that red line straight down that's JFK so if we said anybody to the west of JFK would go to Kennedy anybody on the east side of JFK would go to Irving and then the bottom red line is really Highway 20 so that big yellow area let me think that that would turn
054into table Mount okay so currently we have 44 staff members at Hoover Elementary School and if you look there their total salary and benefit package is just a shy of $3 million okay so we're anticipating that if we if the board would um approve to close Hoover we would save approximately a million dollars annually each year so people say to me how does that happen right well number one um we're not going to if you look at the $3 million some of those staff are going to stay with are going to stay with us because we're going to have to add a few sections at Kennedy Irving and table Mount so that's not a savings right the savings comes from the staff that move into jobs that already exist that are going to be vacated
055by somebody who retires or possibly resigns our retirements are due on January 15 so as they come in we're able to be able to see that we have capacity for the staff that we currently have with the retirements and resignations as they come in this last week so the million dooll savings comes from not filling or comes yeah comes from not filling those Hoover positions does that make sense okay so the enrollment proposal changes I think these these next few slides are really critical for our families and our staff to look at if you look at current enrollment at Irving there's 413 students next year the projected enrollment is 53 now remember these numbers are approximate these are saying that every student that we know that that would be in those boundaries would choose to
056go to that school because we give Parents Choice for open enrollment so there might be some parents that choose not to go to Irving and open enroll to a different school does that make sense okay Kennedy um currently $99 if everybody goes in where they live currently it would go up to 580 table Mount is 427 and they would go up to 477 Irving and Kennedy have been much greater than that in the in the um in the past they're still not at Max Capacity this would be a um the highest student population we would have it table Mount if you look at Irving currently right now we have three sections across the board K through five at Irving Elementary next year you can see where we would propose a section change that would mean
057we would add a section at those schools um to make them four sections that would be in kindergarten first second and fourth grade and you can see what our projected classroom um numbers would be our section numbers so in kindergarten they would be 19 across those four sections you can see 19 and 20 and then our largest is fifth grade which if you look at our fifth grade across the whole District it's our it's one of our biggest classes we have besides the junior class we have right now our board policy states that in fourth and fifth grade our lar our largest capacity is 29 students so we still fit in our board policy okay um at Kennedy you can see where the section changes would be um and where they are currently with sections
058where those section changes would be and then what the Capac what would be the enrollment numbers at those buildings so I keep hearing from people that we're going to have we're going to be overcrowded in some of these schools and I just want to be clear that with the declining enrollment that really is not the case then lastly table Mound you can see um where we are in sections the number of sections we would add and then our section number and you know when we look at that kindergarten number that feels a little like it's kind of like can go either way so just remember as a district we look every year at section numbers we watch those from spring summer and sometimes I mean this year we added a section in September at Carver
059so we continually look at those numbers and if we need to add a section back to table Mound that is obviously something we would do and we would do that at any of our district buildings if the number got to a point where it didn't mean our board policy so my next question is so what are we going to do with Hoover because when we sold when we um closed folon Folton Elementary went up for sale and we sold that um to a community organization right now our plan is to not sell Hoover Elementary number one Hoover's on about 9.5 um Acres so there's a lot of acreage there and number two when we talk about efficiencies the things I just talked about our general Leed fund efficiencies having Hoover and using it at a
060flex space helps us on our save dollar efficiencies so the example I would give you if we were going to let's say we're going to reair condition Marshall okay I'll just throw a school out there that's not air condition if we do that project summer over summer over summer so that we don't have any disruption of our students it's going to cost us a lot more money than if we would just say we're going to do that air conditioning project over 14 months because we know each year that dollar amount is going to go up it's going to go up it's going to go up which is going to have us spend more Sav dollars which is going to have it so that we can't do the building and facility upgrades that we need to
061do so if we were going to put air conditioning at Marshall we could use Hoover as a flex space have Marshall go to Hoover while they do the construction of that and then the school would move back once that construction was finished as you know that's currently happening with our neighboring School District between resurrection and St com kills but you using that that space as a flex space can really help us in efficiencies on our save dollars okay so propose next steps so really um you know we sent out a letter to the to the families hopeful that people were going to attend tonight so you could hear more information we are doing a family um informational session on January 21st at 6:00 p.m. at that time we'll be um having a dinner for families
062we'll have daycare available for for students we'll have um interpreters there and we'll have um our district office staff there to come and facilitate a presentation and a question answer for all families and their students and staff we will then bring those U questions and answers back to the board at a subcommittee meeting also giving them a recommendation with boundary changes as well because again we want to listen to you we want to hear what you have to say and then the board would vote whether to close Hoover Elementary or not at the board meeting in February which is February 10th at that time staff alignment and notifications would hap would would start and Brian Co our chief human resource officer said a great job of being proactive with unions and talking about what that
063process look likees and making sure that our Hoover staff has the first choice in moving forward with openings that occur um here due to retirements and resignations after that time some things that we learned from folon was it's really important that we get students into their new schools so we'll be doing some fly up events those schools will be having open houses for families and their students to come in and and learn learn about the new school have conversations uh we pair them up with a buddy they do some activities at that school um and get them prepared to move into that new building for the next school year again it's our job we it's it's our job to make sure that transition goes smoothly we want students to feel this the way they feel
064at Hoover in in another building that they will attend as superintendent of schools it's my job job to want to make every building feel like you feel about Hoover because we want our kids to come to school every day we want them to have the best education we want everybody to be a high- performing school and we want our parents to be here fighting for their kids to say we love the debut Community School District so I know today is a sad day it is but just know that we're making making this decision so that we can continue to offer your kids the best education possible in our district so thank you for being here tonight thank you superintendent Hawkins that brings us to new business I move the Board of Education approve the 2024
065and 2025 board committees second it's been moved and seconded that the Board of Education approved the 2024 2025 board committees there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries I move the Board of Education approve the proclamation recognizing Martin Luther King day and authorize the president and secretary to sign on behalf of the board second it's been moved in seconded that the Board of Education approved the proclamation recognizing Martin Luther King day and authorized the president and secretary to sign on behalf of the board is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that motion carries and I will read the proclamation whereas on Sunday January 19th 2025 our community will celebrate the birthday of Dr Martin
066Luther King Jr beginning with a gathering at Jackson Park at 12:15 p.m. and a March to the Multicultural Family Center to witness the awards in the annual NAACP tribute contest and whereas on Monday January 20th the annual Martin Luther King Jor birthday celebration will be held at the q casino resort Reflections event spaces with breakfast beginning at 7:00 a.m. and the celebration beginning at 7:30 a.m. featuring keynote speaker Dr John Stewart presenting living as a called person MLK and you and me and whereas in honor of Dr Martin Luther King Jr the King Center is urging people to reject all forms of hatred bigotry and Prejudice while pledging to do everything in their capacity to make America and the world a place for equality and justice freedom and peace will grow and flourish and whereas
067we invite all citizens to join in keeping his dream Alive by joining in the celebrations dedicating their lives to creating the community of Dr King's dream and pledging a nonviolent way of life in their dealings with all people now therefore I Kate parks on behalf of the debut Community School District board of education do hereby Proclaim January 19th and 20th 2025 as days of great celebration in honor of Dr Martin Luther King Jr signed this 13th day of January 2025 hopefully everyone can make it to that event it's a great one is there any um board member or administrative issues not on the agenda to discuss I do have uh one comment just in my spirit you know I know there's no decision being made today and I appreciate all of the facts that the
068superintendent was able to provide all of us um I I do want to acknowledge the the emotions that are in the space right now that parents are feeling children are are uh experiencing District staff um the superintendent personally and the board member and and like I mentioned a few days ago no one in here wants to close any current or future buildings right um but with the the facts that you see in front of you with low numbers low State support um but increase in costs for me you know when I was with my wife yesterday a lot of questions you know even I was asking and trying to reflect on um like why is Iowa and our community's population going down why is it um that there's leaders that are not supporting um the
069buildings the way that we need it a lot of questions I'm just Contin uh to ask um and not a lot of answers um even this past week I believe yesterday we had one of our partners the th talked about how their model has to change a little bit because just demographics are changing and the industries is changing and in order to survive they have to do things differently what you are seeing and experiencing today the community as a whole is experiencing it as well it's interconnected and as a community um we have to reimagine just how to do things differently together um and that's important um but most importantly I want you to know that your pain is our pain right um what you're experiencing we we are experiencing right and you may not
070have all the facts um but we're hurting too right your pain is our pain and hopefully no matter what happens we move forward together I know we've done it before in other areas um but it's just in my experience I just want to acknowledge what we're all experiencing right now and hopefully we all can find ways to move forward together but thank you again for all the facts you well said Anderson thank you for bringing that making that point anology thank you we you know encourage folks to attend the feedback sessions that are coming up um we know that schools are important communities and it is truly heartening to see the support that you have for your school uh and these aren't easy decisions and not decisions that any of us want to have to
071be making but we do value your feedback and encourage you to please come to those sessions and share your thoughts anything else all right we're adjourned thank you everyone thank you [Music]