001e e e no so no it's yeah that's [Music] well let's give another round of applause for the her e for e e for thank you and thank all the students what a fantastic job we are so proud of you keep up the great work have a great holiday season but [Music] scho are are you here with youres thank you look great too thank you have a great night [Music] thank um my team for all the all the work that put into planning the state of the district events we had more than 300 people that [Music] and got addition students we 350 people the so I want to thank all of our partners who helps sponsor yesterday District address and I'm just really appreciative of all the work that has happen Dr thank Theo and
002the energy in that room was quite mass and so again it took a lot of hard work inide the house truly want to just emphasize thanking our supporters who hadu from all sectors from the nonprofit sector to the private sector as well as the religious community some of our families and let me tell you our students did a sensational job I was so for our school district I want to thank the Allan team for a phenomenal job well done to De High School's Jazz Ensemble and I really want to thank all the leadership because when we came to them about two months ago and said well that season for jazz they really did a sensational job I want to thank all our student uh our student panelists my friend Ricky and pyden michaa and Isaac
003the mayor of so I thank them that many of our colleagues and partners throughout the city was so moved by their presentations s we left off in the hi about continuing to shine the light and shine our lights brightly for the children of Valentine and I want to thank who made commitments um to commments and some verbal commment so please know in our practice R and we will follow up with you and I truly believe that together as a collective Community we can continue to move out Town schol district and have continu Improvement so again I'm so honored to serve additionally we have some great updates we're really happy that we learned yesterday afternoon um that we are bondra now and so standards and pores recently conducted an evaluation of the district's finances and we
004received approv Bond rating so we went from Double B plus to Triple B and this is something that I want to thank the finance team of course my overall cabinet extend cabinet leaders and all everyone our school board directors thank you so much for your hard work and ensuring that we are utilizing our fiscal resources efficiently within our strategic plan we've identified that we're going to focus on one area priorities organizational efficiencies and what that Cas and see when the team comes together and we actually I want to commend truly the finance team for finding dollars of finding resources that we were able to capture and last year when I uh provided an overview to the board and even yesterday um we were able to secure uh additional funding and of course our Like official
005I think you the ones that are listening tonight addition $5 million in gr funding we were able to generate some revenue or find some Revenue that we weren't capturing efficiently before previously over more than7 million and then of course again I want to thank our state delegation for securing another 3435 million on top of our typical funding that we were going to receive from this education so and again I'm truly happy because we had many projects under way our our new school design project our family community family and community resource center and other efforts that we need St to find so again I want to thank my team for moving along with me understanding that we there sometimes we can't buy that or we can't do that and it's been and being just more prudent
006with our spending with l i job done I'm going to clap for you you clap for yourself [Music] that those are my remarks before the reor meeting so thank you good evening I'd like to call to order the meeting of the alltown School District Board of Directors for today December 5th 2024 I will now read the hold over names of the board Miss Conor term expiring 2025 Miss Harris term expiring 2025 Miss Brown term expiring 2025 Miss Ortiz term expiring 2025 Miss Noel term expiring 2027 Miss mson term expiring 2027 Miss Sierra term expiring 20127 mersia term expiring 2027 Mr term expiring 2027 please rise for the pleasant Allegiance followed by a Moment of Silence e need to check I think uh Mr Nicola's term because it was appointed before the municipal election would only
007go until December of 20 [Music] 25 because uh even though the term that he was filling was uh some of was just elected so we're going to need to check into that but it doesn't change the process year but I just want to note that for the purpos of the record and we'll have clarify that [Music] yes in accordance with the school laws of Pennsylvania article 4 section 401b 402 404 as amended by act 363 the board of school directors of the school district of the city of alltown will convene its reorganization meeting Thursday December 5th 2024 4 at 600 p.m. Administration Building located at 31 South Pence Street Allentown Pennsylvania at this time we're taking public comments on agenda item villing do we have any cards not on agenda items and I now have
008a nomination for the president of position of temporary president I'll nominate nikoloff I second that oh yeah I didn't know I was here yes I'm here hello it's okay I hear you guys we can hear but it's in and out and it sounds very any other nominations for the temporary president it was three nom for temporary presidents are closed as the nominations are closed and M nikof is the only candidate nominated there needs to be a motion to close the nominations so move second all in favor say I I now you can [Music] say the nominations for temporary presidents are now closed as the nomin are closed and Mr ncof is the only candidate nominated I move from Mr ncof election by acclamation for the position of temporary presence all in favor say I we're
009good before we move forward can someone fix the camera please I can't see anything but miss Ortiz I can't see anything either can everyone hear me okay I hear you it's Sally I can only hear you because I'm right here and the mics are also muffled yes they are MERS give it a second because there's two board members on the laptop they're not able to they still not hearing yeah they said the microphones are muffled and I just had to fix their camera that's it I still only see Miss Ortiz she's the only I can see the screen is black with her picture right that's that's what I see all I see is Miss Brown's name and I can hear but it's very muffled and it's in and out can you guys please use your
010microphones if possible which also means the public probably only so do we I guess we're trying to work through so can they hear now I'm using the microphone so maybe we're speaking Cloud loudly into the microphones can you hear me I can hear you you just sound muffled hear us it just sounds muffled oh they can hear us but yeah but we cannot see the video only shows me Mrs Ortiz photo I can't see anything else previously showing on our part that the camera's on I don't know does somebody else want to come right but if you guys aren't able to hear us that's a problem right we can hear you we can hear you so they can only see right here this doesn't well you need your microphone anyway well it still should be
011fixed because we don't know what the public can see or hear working I think you said you working thank you I move I think they can see everybody so in the meantime how should we let you guys know if we're speaking or we want to say something the the folks on Zoom me and Miss Brown the volume's up higher now can you guys try talking again really quick can you hear me yeah we can hear you everybody can hear me speaking yes okay thank you how about me okay thank you I still can't can't see though I just see Miss Ortiz the camera's on think I get Miss Brown if you can see the um the screen that says um there should be a screen there I can see everybody at at the uh deis
012if you pin that screen you should be able to only see that seems to be some things work check if we can find some temporary some smaller speakers too maybe that might help colle that we can screen so that can see that and they must use speaker connection yeah I think we can Sol the speakers I'm just thinking for them to see better [Music] so I can see now [Music] soard okay with [Music] proceeding the honor of being temporary president I'd like to take the time now to ask if there are any nominations for the position of President the school board directors I nominate nikoloff is President Noel Brown I nominate andreen Noel Brown not sure if y'all heard but I did nominate nikoloff did you guys hear me yes yes we heard you any
013other nominations I nominate and no BR I nominate Andre Noel Brown okay heard no well you didn't hear the Nom I know even though there was majority so far for Andre no brown but you said there was no other nominations did you hear when I made the nomination for you I did thank you okay all right thank you the nominees are Miss Noel and Mr nich second second all those in favor hi so first candidate will be um do a roll [Music] call what nomination is on the table I couldn't hear Miss Brown the nomination is for who I didn't hear I'm sorry you repeat that for her did she hear that I did not it sound like more than one person was talking at a time they say State the name of the person
014you nominated for voting we're not nominating anymore there's two nominees uh the first nominee is Andrea new Brown and Mr nicoloff are both the nominees so we're going to go to each person and you going to say who you're voting for okay so he said Miss Brown so I'm voting for Mr nikoloff Miss over Brown Noel Brown Miss Harris Miss andreen Miss Manon andreen Miss Noel no Miss Ortiz andreen Mr ncol and Miss Sierra and Mr Vero Andre Miss Noel has it 8 to one e thank you everyone and thank you to my board of directors for your V of confidence um May I not have a nomination for the vice I nominate Mr nicholoff I nominate Audrey mat I nominate myself Miss spe I nominate Audrey M I nominate a m you don't need
015to repeat if somebody's name is in nomination okay so it's just different names so we have Miss [Music] Madison Mr nicolov and Miss Harris any other nominations okay the nominations are now closed no need a motion to close a motion to close the nomination you have a second a second all in favor say I I can we do the Miss Brown Mr nicholoff Miss con over AUD M Miss Harris Harris Miss mat myself Miss Noel Miss [Music] Madison Miss Ortiz Audrey mat Mr Nichola Miss mat m Miss Sierra Miss mat Mr Verio Miss mat Miss meth has a vice president by congratulations congratulations Miss mat plus there's no change in officers there's no need to take the next motion to change the signature plate we save money and doing that ex ex the existing committees
016will stay as is for now okay any comments from the board I'm just I'm gonna back I'm just going to make a small comment that I know this year has been a challenging year for us as a board there's been a lot of winds and just a roller coaster ride for us but I'm hoping and I'm going to use the word I am prayerful that as we go into this new year as a board that we will be more united and understand that we don't have to agree we we do not have to agree to be to be very honest even when board members vote Yes we have different reasons why we vote Yes on something so we don't have to agree but I just want us all to respect each other and just understand
017that we're all here for the same reason and it is for the students um so I'm looking forward to having a very good year as we move into you know executing our strategic plan that's that's um any comments on the [Music] superintendent just want to say congratulations to miss m and to missell I'm looking forward to continue work very closely with both of you and of course the full board Contin move by looking for it as we said going to take like the strengths of all of us the team our families and our staff at the Forefront of our grou so thank you I'm so excited about continuing stream thank you Dr burs any comments from the public shenik good even everyone my name I'm president of organization called hard work and dedication Youth Association
018I'm here to speak about policy M sorry my organization has tried to rent Three Gems we've been renting these gems for the past I believe four years was doing it under the um light on program with the city of out toown which is no longer with you guys so we try to do it by ourselves we was told that we were a tier one or tier two at the beginning where we wouldn't have to pay anything now we're being told that the rent be GS we have to pay $200 a night just to practice so my organization has we start at age four with basketball and flag football we've been an organization since 2020 and between them we've been playing basketball with City alltown for eight seasons and all eight seasons my team on every
019level went the champ ship and those teams are made up of 95% of outt school district students so I'm not understanding why we have to pay $2 a night when we're doing a service for the community I cannot ask these parents to pay no more than what I'm already asking them I sponsor most of the children I ask to pay for them to pay $100 that's with the uniform included um water included Transportation if they don't have transportation my organization makes no money at all in fact we're losing money because we sponsor so many children practice are usually every day from 6 to 6 or 6:30 to 8:00 so we're keeping maybe 60 kids off the street for two hours for five nights a week and I think that's something big for the city where
020they're not out running the street so if we have to pay $200 a night we won't be able to do that anymore and I don't want to let the kids down like I there's no reason why an organization that's primar made up of outt school distri should have to a gym owned by School District that makes no sense to me and I don't want to have to tell my parents oh I'll give you guys the money back because we don't have a gym so your kids can't play and not only are we doing a service by keeping them off the street we're building up their St We R them up to be student athletes so these children are eventually goingon to play for t with South Mountain Island or they dof so with them having
021these extra practice hours they eventually gonna be better that's all I have to say thank you can you repeat the name of your organization hardwork and dedication Association thank you thank you so I have a question who we are we collecting money from people I didn't know un can I mean he said that was been happening all over the years throughout the years I've never had any knowledge I actually you rent and how's the money how was that documented we vote on all these Financial um things like getting money in we get money in from taxes and things like that I've never seen it as a line item and I remember when again I to go back into my memory but I remember when Johns Watson was on the board and she was talking about
022how we can get money from um you know different organizations of different people and we never really if we never did anything we never nobody came in hung a banner or things that's Happ now so but this woman said tonight and I can't I didn't hear it that she's been doing it for years so I'm just questioning that because this is my first time hearing I'm questioning that hold on I'm questioning that too because there's another organization a nonprofit is being charged that have never been charged before I know we changed I know 10 tier one tier two whatever however our nonprofits that that take care of our children I don't understand why they have to when they're not making money why they got to pay for to the rental of the of the gym
023or the school whatever the custodian you got to pay for you got to pay for the um the U security we've never done that before I know there's other people who just been taking advantage of us but when it comes to the nonprofit who do not make a profit and they're taking care of our students I think those weigh those fees should be weighed so are we reporting this income yes and how long have we been reporting so that's what I wanted to mention I know the policy was changed so so policy 707 was revised in June of 2023 prior to that I'm not sure exactly where it was so we went through we we reviewed the policy we started enforcing what the policy says so there is a charge so tier one are the
024booster clubs and the program that the district runs those are the ones that are free of charge for tier one tier two and tier three on down they receive a charge for usage but there's also a charge which we have which hasn't done before which is a cost that the district has been absorbing for custodial costs as well as security costs so we're enforcing what the policy says but then I have a question because we talk about sorry let me cut you off no no no we talk about Partners we talking about Partners where money we talk about sorry about that we talk about partners and where Partners money is longer than other peopley well let me not say long that's Street word right but they have more money than um The Little People Like
025Us like our kids right so this or and normally we don't speak out but I'm speaking about this because we're we're in business for kids right yes so my question is why I mean I've been to several events where people are occupying our spaces and we're treating them wonderfully but now we have a nonprofit organization where these people are Ground Zero with our students you know making sure that they're out of trouble or they've been um engaged and then we put that cost on them because we got to pay a custodian or keep the life on I think that I again once again I'm remaining optimistic but I think that our our priorities a little bit mixed up because I don't see how and why the little people which is me because I would be
026that parent right that would have to sit at this on this desk um at least twice a month and then I have to go figure out after spending 20 hours here free of charge where I'm going to find the money right to allow my kid to be in this program I think that we need to rethink that yeah because with the all time a is they are they don't really charge that much just for their uniform and they are having their banquet this Saturday and they have to pay and that's a lot of children that that's 200 children that we and plus kid leaders football that we kep off the streets we're in business for our students and again I'm I'm a lot older than I was in 2017 when I sat here and I've
027sat here long enough to see what works and what doesn't work and charging our students who the narrative when we first got here was our kids didn't learn our kids didn't want to learn the parents didn't want anything and it was a charter school that was holding us back now we're put in position where state has given us some money and we appear to be doing a lot better and now we're going to make our kids pay for it I remember when our kids would go from to different schools and they didn't have uniforms and they looked the mess and when I would asked the question like what's the problem and they would say well we don't have money and I'm like nobody asked now we moved past that I think that if we're really
028being intentional and I'm still just as passionate as I was in 2017 I'm just a little over if we're really intentional then we need to put our money where our mouth is and we need to invest in our students I don't see where we're benefiting when if we're charging our students and so we have to do that's just that's I'm one of nine but that's just my AR make a suggestion we're going to be going into our regular meeting where this policy is this policy is not on the agenda agenda but it should be addressed through the policy committee because technically this board voted on approving the policy and your Administration is enforcing the policy as it should be in accordance with uh the uh directive uh and it should be addressed through your policy
029committee if you want to make changes to policy 707 well well if if I may Dr B good point and that's why when we get to our policy this is why I push so much I have so much push back because when these policies come across to us it comes to us it's the first reading then we have a one we look through it and then it comes back for the approval we don't get a chance to really discuss things like this unless someone comes from the public and says hey this is the real problem you guys voted on this and this is the problem doesn't work for us so this is my reasoning when we ask things like what are the regulations you know how are these things going to be played out at
030the building level you know these are the problems that we have yes we want policy I you think I I like not voting no I vote no because I know that we're going to get days like this where again who's not benefiting our kids I just need to reemphasize under state law the reorganization meeting is solely for the reorganization purposes if you want to address this in board comment it would be appropriate to do so in our regular meeting and then it should be referred to the policy committee for dis position thank you very much Point well taken I receive [Music] that'll pick that up old business policy um may have a motion tojoin this meeting that all in favor say I [Music] I'd like to call to order the finance committee of the whole
031meeting of the board of directors of the school district of the city of Allentown for today December 5th 2024 the board welcomes and invites public comment you may address the board on agenda or non-agenda items the first opportunity for comment is at the beginning of the meeting and is limited to agenda items only comment cards must be received by the start of the meeting which is now once recognized please come to the podium state your name and address for the record and time we limit the remarks to 3 minutes are there any [Music] cards thank you madam chair again with the new meeting um I want to commend the board president M Rell and M mson looking forward to working closely with you again I want to underscore since we are talking about finances I
032want to commend the finance team to do thisly responsible we're ensuring that the district is capturing its resources so that we can fund the overall organization as we po mission is to educate the children who attend the alltown school district and support staff and such and I want to thank you again for your work you and that that concludes my remarks those are my remarks for this second of thank [Music] you we have just one action item on the Finance agenda this evening we are requesting the approval to purchase 100 Lenovo laptops for school district faculty and staff do we have some background on that on that item doph um so the 100 laptops are for the uh teachers the staff of the El school district and this is in regards to the laps that
033we have from back order from last year so last year when we got the new staff and the new faculty we gave all the one that we had St so this is to come back to normal levels for is there any comment or question seeing none may I have a motion to move this item forward to the December 19th 2024 meeting second all in favor I any oppos and the motion carries uh we are taking public comments on non-agenda items do we have any cards no cards is there any old business to come before the finance committee any new business to come may I have a motion to adour second second second all in favor I nobody I'd like to call order of the policy Committee of the whole meeting of the uh Board of
034director of the school district of the city of Valen for December 5th 2024 the board welcomes and invites public comment we may address on agenda or non agenda items this first opportunity for comment is the of the meeting and to comment cards must be received by the start of the meeting is now we will not be receiving public cards once the Mee begins a copy of the public Comm common houses located on the table next to the common card oh no don't per our board's policy any person may address the board in accordance with the procedures and limitations of this policy either on issues presented in resolutions being considered or on other matters affecting the Administration Management or operation of thean remarks of a personal nature directed against any individual ruled out of order if
035you choose to address the board pleas comic card Mard Mr s any comic cards not on agenda okay superintendent thank you missis um as our ongoing commitment to create an organization that works efficiently and fact the grou we are committed to updating our policies last year the board set a goal to update 10% of its policies and that's how we govern the organization and we exceeded that goal 26% this year we've added an additional 20% so that 46% of our policies can be updated so tonight we're presenting to you 13 policies and one of which is to uh pass our artificial intelligence policy with our first reading of our artificial intelligence policy as an organization and in effort to be closely aligned with coherent thinking to what have our district become more efficiently run as
036well as forward thinking we have been working very diligently um our team has been working very diligently to take policies that are Innovative in nature and thinking and I want to that team who's working really hard on ensuring that weing schools for the future so that our students the sport thinking um resources as well as Innovations so we're excited that the artificial intelligence policy is on this agenda amongst others but we want to bring that uh to attention because it's very closely line with our strategic plan incl schools for for our children thank you please present if my colleagues do not object I'd like to request we vote on all our policies together after Administration completes presentation if that's okay with everyone I okay can you pull policy 827 please 827 you want to do
037yes that's the conflict of interest yes or you just want to do it by I want to do it vote on it separ vote on it separately we still have time for that um the AI one cuz we made very will have to come back to put record just pull 827 for now okay you just want it done by itself and we vote that's correct okay enough thank you uh m caner i good evening members of the board I am presenting to you policy 150 which is on title on comparability of services the purpose of this policy is to ensure compliance that of the requirement that schools who receive fedal funds such as Title One do not receive less state and local funds we ensure this through our budget formula and we are monitored every
038November and we were found to be compliant for the 2425 school year fedal funds include not just title one which we provide money to schools for Staffing and academic Improvement resources we also have title two which we've transferred into title four title four includes well-rounded safe and healthy schools and Technology all the resources to support those initiatives and title three as well for English language learner supports there any questions okay thank you very much Mr C he will be sharing the next two policy well no just 628 good evening um our new policy um being pushed being read through tonight would be the post isurance tax compliance procedure for tax ex and bonds purpose of these potis tax compliance procedures is to establish policies and procedures in connection with the tax exempt bonds or notes
039issued by the school district of the city of Allentown so as to maximize the likelihood that all applicable post inssurance requirements of the federal tax laws the federal tax law needed to preserve the taxes and status on the bonds are met so in essence what that means is that is we're going to make sure that all the money we get that we handle properly to complete all the Arbitrage all the filings so that we can keep our tax and status for the money that we borrow this is particularly with the new money that we're Bor in any questions all right thank you very much Mr C we will go to Mr s you will present the next five policies for the first reading good evening super Brooks and our Este board members we have five
040uh policies to bring forward today uh it's important to note that the 300 series is combining what we have now from a 300 400 and 500 Series so previously it was recommended that these were broken down into a 300 series for employees 400 for professional employees and 500 for classified uh the new suggestions from psba put all of those policies together in the three 00 Series so for 301 we do have currently a 301 a 401 and a 501 but they're all being combined here into policy 301 for creating a new position and that is given um knowing the need for creating new position shall be determined by the board based on the recommendation of the superintendent and in the exercise of its authority to create a new position the board shall give primary consideration
041to the following effective management of District programs number of students enroll special needs of students operational needs of the district and the financial resources of the school Community uh another addition from prior versions is that the superintendent or J me shall be responsible to maintain a comprehensive and upto-date job description for all positions in the district any questions thank you can go on to the next one the next one is 304 employment in District staff again this unites policies 304 404 and 504 under the 300 series it speaks to our pre-employment requirements including the employment history review in compliance with state law it includes the background checks we do on all our employee perspective employees and again it unites um professional employees and classified employees there any questions next one please 305 is a new
042policy it is employment of substitutes U many of our Collective borrowing agreements do speak to this uh but this does put into policy preemployment requirements for uh substitutes that we would employ in the district I have a question on that one yes so um if you look in think it's the fourth paragraph it says an employee shall not be recommended for employment unless they show proof of certification is this the same certification that we do for teachers and when you say fourth paragraph under Authority yes let me approval shall not normally be given to candidates for employment record Ms hold on one [Music] second preemployment requirements okay so then if you go to the fourth paragraph it says a candidate for employment in the district shall not receive a recommendation for employment without evidence of
043his or her certification when such certification is required corre so is this the same as the teacher certification or uh it could be because salary substitutes are mentioned there so it could have to do with um a professional employee being approved as a salaried substitute which is a substitute position we do contract with ESS for teacher uh substitutes for the day-to-day okay I know there's been some instances where we have employed teachers that are like pending certification but they have to get a certification within a certain amount of time is that still open or does this policy shut it down so we we do the state of Pennsylvania pennsylv Department of does have an Emer certification process uh that allows individuals to apply and acquire an emergency permit to work as a teacher and there's
044different types of those emergency certifications as well so okay so that was my question can you say that out loud policy doesn't cont D having work for a very long time what okay thank you so what I'm thinking is if our policy says that you have to have certifications then that leaves the power in the hands of administration pretty much even if the department PBA says that you can get or does it have to have some clarity in that language yeah that's yeah that's what I was kind of iffy about when I read it I I get based on my career I read it as the certification that is appropriate for the individual so that if that person is in the situation where emergency certification is required them that's what the individual has to have
045if the person is in the position where professional certification is required then that's what the person has to have if there you no certification available for that position then that's also correct so since we're doing policy it needs to read that I understand what you're saying but it needs to be clear if it's not written it didn't happen this policy is consistent with State regulation uh and you you can't and you you're going to get an audit citation if you hire somebody who's not appropriately certificed ific at for the position because it says as required by law and it could be if somebody doesn't have appropriate certification they can receive an emergency certification which the Department of Education would approve so that process is extensively set forth in Pennsylvania regulation so I do not believe
046it needs to be in your policy and it can change from time to time but the footnotes that you see 3 9 10 and 11 they refer to sections of the school code or the state regulations that govern certification of employees so SP in the footnotes yes yeah I wasn't saying I want us to hire people that are not served it just didn't seem clear to me because I know in the past we've done that where people have gotten time to get their C certification but this is clearly say saying like no you need to come in but it spelled out that's what we didn't hear heard that part but it didn't say that it was spelled out in the footnote so if it's referencing in that in the policy in the footnotes then we're
047fine it's a good question thank you very muchy 306 is also a new policy for employment of Summer Staff um this gives the um board the authorization to approve the employment set the compensation and establish the period of employment for each individual employed in the district summer school program so a slight change for our proceedings you had previously voted on the summer programming on the compensation rate this would have us have uh as we approach summer the individuals that we going to work also be approved by the board and something that will be akin to a Personnel agenda so we'll have on the Personnel agenda each person that's hired and they're saddled with something you've never done before Ty typically you e we either go by what's already existing in the collective bargaining agreements for
048the hourly rate or you've approved other rates that are specific to that summer so would be you know if you're approving that rate then we would also have a Personnel agenda that approves the individuals that are working at that rate things could change I said I would look at it specific to the summer because things could change Always then we don't have to go back on all stuffff I just um Mr ver yes just for clarity we want to make sure we're capturing we thinking on that summer kind you said okay he stated we could look at the regular hourly pay or we look into it specific to the summer that for the at different points at least for my time well standing with the scholership we've paid uh professionals and classified employees a certain
049wage either based what's already in their contract or uh a wage approved by the school board in advance of the summer whether through essers or whether through recruiting uh needs thank you any other questions next one please uh and the last policy is policy 307 student teachers and interns uh this is very similar to the policy that already exists 407 but again taking the 300 400 500 series and putting them into the 300 series so can you explain that a little more about the school in term so this uh establishes the that district schools will accept student teachers and interns from accredited institutions in which the district has a Cooperative agreement approved by the board any questions all right thank you very much thank you polic evening again so the first policy is policy 224
050this is a new policy take care of a school property and this is to um give the power to the schools sh help to help the students to learn to respect property and develop feeling of right in community institutions and this policy what is doing is this is this policies across the board in different public schools in Pennsylvania and it gives the power to the to the to the faculty specifically to the principles to be able to uh hold or hold accountable the student the students accountable for damage of property for the school district so are we talking about the devices we're talking about devices we're talking about uh in general uh we about all kinds of this is property property that belongs to the Alon School District but in addition I specifically to it
051just devices so we have devices we have computers we have laptops that we provide to the students and in some cases several cases we have these laptops being damaged by the students so we with this policy we will be hold accountable the students for this for the damage of the computers right because we no longer even have the um ability um it is on the device but we do not we have not activated it for where to find out where the device is um many kids are coming back containing our device but then if we had that we could say it's you know if we had that on their device where we could track it we can say it you know it's in your house it's under your bed it's um because they okay it's
052an echo now um because the students do are not being held accountable in that that specifically to that point so the school district has lost almost one and half almost one and a half million dollars on on devices that we're not able to to locate because we do not have the capability to to for these devices so our call last year we sat into a very long meeting and we learned in that meeting that we're able to track the devices replace the devices there was a lot of things that happened and we left that meeting under the impression that we would get those things activated so we won't lose any so has right now there there's an the application that locates the devices is currently deactivated for last year and one of the requests uh
053so tonight we do to enable that device application so we could so we could find these devices yeah it was It was kind of crazy yeah pause for a second during that meeting they requested additional money I remember that we had to pay more for a specific function that was tied to that and we paid more so we paid the money and we didn't activate so we have the devices come with the application so every time we purchase a Chromebook it comes with the application we have it turn off because of last last year's new so my request tonight is to turn on the application so we can locate all these devices that that are currently in loss status okay so we're we're what we're paying for tonight is the activation of the new ones
054but I'm still concerned about the old ones if you're saying that you just gave me a huge loss number so just for clarity so last year or [Music] and so and it was said that some of the laptops that we purchased automatically had a tracking device but prior to that there was a presentation presented to the board by a vendor and the vendor um quoted and then the board some board members didn't feel comfortable so that was taken off the agenda and we've never Revisited but in the meantime some of the laptops that we bres they have and correct me I'm wrong but I I remember this a lot of conversation about this and they already had a tracking device inside of them but right now because we want to be good stewards and we
055have ways to do this so that we can and this is not I want to say this because I don't want it reported that this is not un to have school districts across the country we trying to solve this because sometimes boards don't want children to pay and families andur so we're trying to make sure we're safeguarding our lap so we don't have to continue or technology come back to you and ask to replenish that so that's what's happened did did I capture that is correct and in addition just to give you a couple of examples we have found devices in I can say e e e thank you I cofman director of stem the use of artificial intelligence and education this policy aims to ensure the safe ethical and responsible use of artificial intelligence
056Technologies in the Allentown School District it recognizes AI as a critical component of what our students need to be future ready and is aligned with the district's strategic plan policy 85.1 the use of artificial intelligence and education is shaped around three key areas first safety both for students and staff along with data security second AI Literacy for students and staff and then third Equity of access uh and outcomes the policy will inform the development of regulations procedures and guidance documents that will ensure best practices are utilized across the district to maximize the learning potential of artificial intelligence while keeping people safe and data secure we also require that our approach to AI is grounded in equity of both access and outcomes adhering to the policy and Associated procedures will Foster a learning culture of responsible
057and informed use of AI so that students will be better equipped to navigate AI tools effectively while understanding the limitations and ethical implications of artificial intelligence any questions that I can answer I yes go ahead superintendent before I add okay just want to underscore the importance of this policy as an organization of course we are trying to a forward thinking and it's imperative that we establish well the board um passes a policy that we have safeguards in place to protect our children we AI as we know like everything can be great if we have the right safeguards in place but right now we want to establish as an overall Learning Community our approach just like our you know other policies and Facilities usage and everything else and um our technology policies so that we are
058regulating what's being exposed in our CH what our children are experiencing in our classrooms AI can be great when we can use it to support our students with exceptionalities as well as our English learners but right now we want to establish a common vision and approach to how we collectively across the entire School District use AI in our classrooms so that's why we are presenting that policy this policy to the school board of directors we also uh when we met with um we we attended the psba conference um we saw a presentation we contacted the psba as well as uh attorney Waltz who is a expert in and AI technology he's one of our uh actually attorneys from sweet Stevenson Stevens I'm sorry sweet Stevens and so he is an expert leading around the C
059around the state of Pennsylvania how we look at Ai and how school districts approach approach this we had him come into the district and meet with our leadership team uh School leaders and above ensure that we understood the regulations that need to be in place as it relates to fura Hippa and everything else to safeguard our children and our staff uh we don't want our students to be in a situation that they use technology and then they're punished unduly punished because we have not established as a district how AI can be utilized in the classroom and we have various other opportunities to enhance personalized learning but absent of the policy we're not able to move forward so that's why we are presenting this and actually as a district we we want to move forward a
060little bit more on this because people are using things within the district and also with our tech technology team is saying to our staff you can't use certain tools and apps and they're getting upset because they're like why not because we don't have safeguards in place for people to use them in the district so I want to share that with the board wide the importance of this policy you you touched on something Dr B which is the only comment that I have just making sure that the information once we pass this policy is really disseminated to the students and families and parents so they actually know what they can do and can't do because the worst thing is to hold someone accountable to something that they don't know and AI is so new and fresh
061and but the it's new to really new to us but the kids really been on it for a while and so they have they have learned how to navigate that world really well so we want to make sure that you know they're very well aware of what they can and cannot do yes um Miss Brown no well and thank you for sharing that um as a district we established a um an innovation committee and I want to thank Mr coffin Mr yurch and Mr Weiss they lead that committee and they have been working very diligently since April and establishing we they've we've sent them to professional learning some of our partners have even funded them going to learn more about AI so that we're um current in the best best practices and we have surveyed
062our school leaders to assess their knowledge base of of immersive Technologies there is a survey that did it go out today we also disseminated a survey to all of our teachers and staff um throughout the district there's a survey going out tomorrow um Miss uh Smith is responsible for that a survey going out tomorrow for families so we can assess their knowledge base of where we are as an organization we are uh partnering with our friends uh at Google so they will come in on next week and they're going to provide professional learning to uh they actually afford awarded us a grant so they are going to fund professional learning uh for all all leaders assistant principles and above they also will spend time with our it team in a as well as our clerical
063support team so that we are all Ted up on immersive technology so we have a common thinking and vision and we've asked them to come back in January to um offer sessions to our faculty and staff so we do have a robust plan and we did a survey I'm sorry my student uh advisory counsel and we assessed their knowledge base of where they thought we are in the next direction we should go and we will now once we all have a common thinking about our Pro to using AI in the district and we have a board policy we will also ensure that we roll it out and it becomes embedded in our uh family family and student handbook as well so when we bring that forward to our school board of directors so we have
064everything all coherently aligned so one of our student reps have a question goe I just have a question on how AI like what can teachers do and can't do with AI because me personally when I think of the use of AI obviously there's students that take advantage of that I'm not going to lie about it there are people that take advantage of it but there's also students that work really hard on like papers and some teachers use AI to see if they can flag it as AI use and there have been students that have lost scholarships and gotten bad grades on things because the use of like AI was used to grade their paper to check if they have ai and I just feel like it isn't really fair because as a student myself like
065I write three-page paper four page papers six page 10 page papers and I don't want to get a bad grade or get told oh well you used AI to write this when I like worked really hard on it so that's just like my only concern you know and thank you for raising that question and so that's why we have a committee because for this very reason because there are organizations their districts their universities that you can use 50% of your paper can be AI if you site it but we don't have a policy or common understanding right now regulations in the district that speak to what you just said and I thank you for working really hard on your papers and wri so so yes so that's why we want to make sure we don't
066have so much variability of thinking about our approach to how we have students use AI um in in their school work cuz people use it every day in their jobs right especially for grammar check so if is using it for grammar to correct the grammar if if there's something wrong I don't think they should be penalized for that when us adults are so popping it in there so that thank you Mr that's the part that I have I'm speaking on behalf of the students like her because we have this policy in place we have to have something and then we have got we got our our response from legal and it's almost as if I'm feeling like the kids that we serve are going to be the last to pretty much know it's already going
067to be in place they're already going to be held the policy in place and then it's going to get rolled out we have people from Google I heard you right from different places that are going to come in and and and they're going to start but I wanted to my question I guess would be even though we had that advisory student advisory that that's comprised of how many students 40 they're the representation of the schools middle and high schol so 40 students out of all middle schools Middle and High School Middle High School yes and they were selected by their so and then I guess I would asked the question how engaged are they with their peers like are there student councils at that I mean how engaged because I don't want 40 kids speaking
068for 5,000 10,000 so and I understand your point however that's not the expectations we can survey the students so we Al and here they're thinking about how they use AI because that's the questions that are being asked however we will also have the teachers put in their policies their classroom their curriculum their uh syllabi and stuff how students based on our regulations but how they can use it and that's what we we are closing this because right now there's so much variability it's people's perspect um perspectives on how technology should be used and that should not be for the students given what you just said right now it's if I'm a teacher it was okay in my class but it's not in my class that's not fair to the students this young lady was still
069speaking you you have more no I thought you were finished I'm sorry I don't know her name and the hat and the glasses yeah I just wanted to agree with her I feel like me personally I don't want 40 students speaking on my behalf like me personally that's just me um my opinion on AI I feel like it could be used like good with safe blockers that that's good but that doesn't stop like a student using AI on another device like it's not going to stop like you could tell a kid don't do this and they're going to do the complete opposite it doesn't matter need a policy that's just why we need a policy yeah and we need regulations because if we don't have that it's going to be variability and it won't be
070fair for all students if we have a common expectation for everyone and then we can Safeguard just what you share and I just wanted to share um I take an English class and my English teacher she um is against AI use obviously um but I just want to say a point that she made she doesn't like AI because it doesn't actually help a student like with their grammar I feel like and I could say this right now there's like a lot of students at least at my school at Allen that do not have great grammar students that are even older than me because they just use like anything to make them sound smarter and they just use whatever the internet tells them it's not going to help them learn like my teacher she doesn't even
071want us like writing things on the computer because it'll just give us like these big words that we don't even know how to use and what they really mean and so she could tell right away that's not how you write and she even told us I can tell if you wrote it or not because I know the way you speak and I know the way you write so I feel like with AI use I feel like it can like impact like how can I say this it impacts like the education like how much education kids are getting in school like and that's what worries me cuz like I'm seeing like little kids middle schoolers who can't even read like a grade level book and it makes no sense cuz to me in middle school and
072Elementary School I was reading above level cuz there wasn't like like so much technology like I didn't even have a Chromebook when I was in elementary school well not until later at least or iPads or anything like that so I feel like it really does impact education it can impact it positively but it can impact it negatively and that might impact um like adult life situations if they need to like um apply for a job or um speak in front of the public it's just not going to help them out as much as they think in the run so you saying that you're they're learning things but they're not comprehending it they're not comprehending okay like you can search up anything on AI oh help me with this help me with that but if you're
073not actually learning and taking it in you're just doing it to do it I I won't get into research but Google Siri all those things are AI as well so I just want to let you know you're already using um AI but I won't get into the research around that right now but did you yeah I I would like one additional Point uh from what our student representative originally said research has shown that neurod Divergent individuals are more likely to flag as using AI when they're not so I would like that note to be taken into account when we develop policy for how teachers grade their students if they have somebody in their class with autism spectrum disorder or add or ADHD thank you thank you yeah that's very true and honesty assignments have to
074be developed around AI and I'm already schaming is that it any any other comments all right thank you Mr cofin thank you next we will have policy 239 good evening superintendent Burks and Schoolboard the updates to policy number 239 foreign exchange students that allows International exchange students to be tested for English language learner needs and provided appropriate instruction in accordance with District's language instructional education plan any questions comments was Qui all right then we can go to policy 121.1mi trips policy 121.1mi alignment with educational goals student safety and Equitable access some key elements include the purpose which recognizes that international travel is a valuable educational tool that enriches learning and promotes cultural competency closely tied to curricular objectives an approval process which requires formal approval by the superintendent school board at least six months in
075advance and exceptions may be made for special circumstances and trips must include a detailed itinerary safety protocols and vendor qualifications equity and access it encourages optional fundraising and business sponsorships to reduce the costs and provide opportunities for students of all economic backgrounds safety and emergency preparedness trips are subject to the Department of Homeland Security advisories and may be adjusted or canceled if safety concerns arise and emergency plans and pre-trip training are required for all participants eligibility eligibility and participation it's open to District students and good academic standing with priority given to Rising seniors parents and Guardians May participate if they meet the district background check requirements clear guidelines for chaperon ensure adequate supervision and finally vendor and financial transparency trips must be organized through a certified travel vendor with proof of insurance and performance bonds
076and financial accountability is mandated with clear cost outlines and post-trip Reporting I have a clarification question um in par paragraph five under guidelines it says that um trips um must be sponsored by a travel organization is that due to safety yeah due to safety and so that they are the ones organizing all the things they have the contacts within the countries of where to stay and they they're the organizing umbrella for it so if if like ASD itself wanted to plan something we would as an organization we would want to engage a tour company because they also assume the liability for the trip okay even with adults I had to do that nice only thing I can think of with this is when I I was in high school and you were in a foreign
077language like French German um Spanish um in whatever classes you were in you would take a trip to particular country that spoke that language so that that's what I'm thinking this is pretty much covering yeah I was just wondering why a travel organization because I do know like usually you can plan a trip no it be so yes so understanding what you're saying the liability that's important and they also have already vetted all the places of the hotels or accommodations food everything so to ensure that safety safy advisory or something and they would not allow us to take that trip okay well we would not propose that to you okay and they wouldn't take students on the trip anyway yeah thank you for clarifying that anything else all right thank you very much thank you
078okay may I have a motion to move these policies forward to the December 19th 2004 2024 board meeting so Mo second first second and a and a first in a second thank you um is there any discussion one of those all in favor say I I I any oppos yeah she's doing the conflict of interest after no we're gnao the conflict of interest okay something that wanted to go to the next meeting she's join us separately be forthcoming with the public there was something well which policy was it 707 the policy that Mr cuff presented on the the B Bond issuance there was a request for that to go to the next special meeting tonight tonight so let's separate that one okay we separ which one 707 no no no no right you can tell
079me when you get up there okay all right then um no n oppose uh motion here he did it already so we need we just need to what do we need vote on that one separately and group the other ones okay hold on we're voting on H 27 by itself what was it number 827 is something totally different right so what are we voting we what are we add he's talking about something Dr Brooks could you just let her know which policy you think we're talking about the bond ins is that the bond policy let me just try to clarify what happened here uh I believe the board moved as a whole all of the policies to go to your December 19th 19th meeting um however the bond compliance policy we would it's already on
080the agenda for Action in our special meeting which follows good so so we advertise that appropriately we just want to get authorization to move that forward so we can be compliant with the Internal Revenue Service requirements and uh the requirements to have such a policy for post2 2014 Bond issuances policy 628 policy 628 so we could have uh could we have a motion uh directing that policy 628 be brought forward uh to our special meeting this evening I make that motion second any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed I have it motion carried we're good okay let's go back to policy 827 conflict of interest Mr cuff good evening again so this is the first reading for policy 8 27 is the conflict of interests this also is being requested to move
081forward to the special meeting later this evening this policy should affirm the standards of conduct established to ensure the that board members and employees avoid potential acts of conflict of interests as well as the perception of a conflict of interests uh any discussion yes go right ahead so it's my recommendation that this policy be SE separated cuz in my opinion I feel like um in my opinion factually board members govern Administration and I don't think that they should be in the same policy and then if you go through this policy which I did there was some things um that I would consider having my own personal legal look at because without disclosing but through my experiences I would not want to have a policy that's laid out here that would put any of us board
082members in a precarious situation as it relates to our responsibility if a legal situation should occur um but again having it as one policy board members are not the same as administrators and I don't see where it should be together and we should be so quick to rush to making these changes cuz you know if we vote on it tonight then that means if somebody or anybody here is not in compliance with this it may very well become an issue it may be an issue that we cannot financially afford personally if I may uh once again the devil was in the details and I suggest that you look on the last page of the document and including the footnotes and this is how PBA sets up its policy service what this document is is a
083compilation of all the legal requirements in Pennsylvania governing conflicts of interest uh whether you approved this policy or not and I'm going to say why you should approve this policy uh you are still subject to these requirements as a board member elected in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to serve on a board I do not believe believe that there is anything in this policy that creates an additional legal obligation on any board member over what already exists in state law and regulation which are all compiled in uh at least the first seven items of the footnote uh the reason we're adopting this as we've indicated is that the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is requiring this as part of uh a review of districts and have cited districts who have not adopted such a policy as part of
084their Esser funding Pro uh process so we are strongly recommending that you do this as quickly as possible I will tell you very confidently if I thought that this policy was creating an additional legal obligation for any of your boards I wouldn't be doing my duty as Council for the school district in advising you regarding the situation this is not creating any additional obligations and is candidly a recitation of state law and regulation as it currently exists obviously you have the right if you're uncomfortable to not vote for this but it is my firm strong recommendation and the strong recommendation of the administration to approve the policy as presented and what is your position in terms of separating the two why does the administrative why does it have to be um board members as well
085as the administration because the way the state laws are drafted is that both board members and those administrators who have authority to make decisions regarding procurement and other related issues are treated the same um so uh if for example Dr Burks Mr cuff Miss Ramos they're held to the same standard of conflicts of interests as you as a board so having a separate policy in my opinion doesn't necessarily uh make sense because the statutes themselves don't distinguish between board members and administrators it just uh it it they consider public officials so you're a public official the same way as Dr Burks same way as Mr Mr cuff same same way as Miss Ramos under the circumstances so it doesn't make sense to have a separate set of rules so my next question is I know
086we at the last board meeting we talked about um I think it was the board president and the superintendent made specific um decisions pretty much without us you get to say that you get to set the agenda I think that's what that was yeah I don't make any decisions with so so but the what I'm getting at is in the event you have a board member who has not complied with some of the stuff that's written here who has the authority to actually um exercise um a sanction who has that Authority is it the board president and the superintendent I mean no uh so it depends on the issue as a general principle the board president president the superintendent they don't have the power of punishment to you as a board member in the event
087that you engage in a conflict of interest a member of the public can file a complaint with the state ethics commission uh if indeed you engage in a criminal offense under state law uh the district attorney can take action the only way you can be ultimately penalized under the circumstances by the district as the result of a purported conflict of interest is that the board president has the authority to remove a uh board member who is acting inappropriately or not in accordance with law from uh a committee leadership position but absent that uh that's the extent of authority that can be exercised by The District in dealing with a conflict of interest external sources such as the state ethics commission can f a complaint a member of the community can file a complaint and the
088Lehi County district attorney can bring in action if you engage in a uh what they call a high crime that's related to ethical responsibilities and remove you as a board member those are really the major elements say that the board president could remove under certain circumstances or no the board president the board president a majority of the board as well as any officer during the course of the year can remove a board president for any reason not including but not limited to uh a president you said president no she is she is saying what what he's saying Miss Conover like if I find if the board president finds that someone is moving has a conflict of interest the only power that the president has is to remove them from a committee like the education policy
089Finance but outside of that there is no I mean the president can and a board member can report the individual to an an agency but the board president doesn't have any special Authority Beyond her appointive Authority for putting people on committees she can remove people from committees so this is year number seven so this is new power to remove no that's been the whole time no that's under state law it's nothing new that's been the case for for years the board president ha has the authority to make committee appointments not appointments to uh lcti or the community college or the IU but for your policy committee chair the education committee chair the finance committee chair uh the buildings and grounds committee the board president has the uh unilateral authority to pick a committee chair and
090remove a committee chair at her will so I will say this is this is new to me because I've been here and we've had some issues on this board over the seven years and um and at once upon the time I was a I had a title was vice president and we did not have Thor Authority and it was communicated from legal that we we that that the um board leadership the president did not have the authority to remove one from a committee or from its position so this is new to me tonight this is new to me but you're saying to me now it may be new to your understanding or new to the understanding of the the board but that's been the law for quite some time yeah I was aware of it
091I was aware of it when you got here right okay I became aware of that when someone asked me before I became president but I I I've been aware of it because I was asked at one point and by other board members and um the president did not did not go through with it that's been the law for as long as I've been practicing and that's 45 years so I'm not questioning the law I'm questioning my knowledge of it and I'm questioning the the actions that have occurred that we won't discuss in this space um but I'm just I just had a aha moment so fine thank you learn something every day any other discussion all right as a reminder this is requested to move forward to the special meeting as well we're not I
092made them make a motion to split it so so we have to vote on this one separately okay this is only only one are we moving it forward to tonight yeah it's it's being voted it's an action item yeah okay Jeff hold on because she want she um Miss Conor wants to split it do do we do a separate motion for that to see if we do that or we just no she was talking split it from the the voting I thought she made a motion but there was no second okay so it fails okay did anybody recognize that that was a motion to split it instead of having it as a um administrative and Mis um oh I misunderstood that and a school board director um conflict of interest that we split it and
093it be separate whatever applies to us applies to us and whatever applies to them that would require a a rewrite obviously of the Poli I'm not confused but you also said so because now I'm I'm unclear you also said that it was state law like this is yes state law treat board members and public officials the same they don't create two different classes board members and administrators not public officials right board members and administrators are considered public officials under the state ethics act and that's why I use the term they don't distinguish between the two District employees not all District employees a teacher for example would not be subject to all of these same requirements this says conflict or conflict of interest shall mean use by a board member or District employee it should be
094um I get zero dollars you're right you're right um but it would be a district employee that would under state law qualify as a public official who makes a decision so for example if a teacher in this school district would want to use a particular vendor for a curriculum program but the teacher really doesn't have any authority to make that recommendation just merely expresses I would rather use XYZ curriculum under the circumstances and she may be related to somebody who sells that curriculum that probably wouldn't rise to a conflict of interest because that teacher doesn't have the authority to make that kind of decision on the other hand you as a board member the superintendent has the authority to make a recommendation uh you know uh Mr cuff has the authority to make a recommendation
095it won't but this is this is the way this is technically worded under state law I'm not so but I'm only one n understood so you made that motion correct yes is there anyone to second I second it all right any discussion so this is a motion to se to to separate it so what yeah this is the discussion so what disc time so what so what does it look like does it look like we're just in our policy is just going to remove Administration but it's the same verbiage the answer I I don't know how it would look like to do that I'm just suggesting this is in what section of the policies this it's going to be in 827 so we apply to all employees it's going to look like this so so
096that's what I'm saying it's going to look the same but it's just gonna be one that just says Administration and then another one that says I'm not suggesting that we do that we have a board member suggesting that no I'm asking if if if we if we go forward with that it's the same thing it's just on it's just administ is removed from one and then the other one has for I have to look at it carefully to see if by breaking that together you know separating it would change some of the defined terms it would would require some rewrite Mr nikoloff this is your expertise talk to me um it's my personal opinion that if the district or an individual were to become subject of an investigation that based on the legal opinion of
097Mr alanic they would not differentiate between our personal policies and the law if this policy covers all of the law that's what they would follow and we would be subject to that regardless of whether we made a separate document or not okay we're gonna take a vote vote on it do we want to do roll call or do we want to do I in so just to be clear we're we're voting on doing the separation that's what we're is that yes apparently I didn't hear the I'm Sor we had a second second we did have a second M okay so we're voting on the separation okay so a so that would be a motion to amend the current policy and break it up between board member uh compliance and other employee uh compliance and just
098for the record breaking it up he said that he would have to look at it he would have to review it so that does not necessarily mean that it would come back the same right it it will look very much the same but there it would have to take some work for him to be able to look at it to see but what does that do to what needs to happen for it delays what needs to happen what's the timeline on what needs to happen yesterday oh wow seriously uh it depends when we get scheduled with the state correct next week we need we need to have this policy in place for next week okay we're still going to go along with the for the vote um do we want to do roll call I
099would on this issue so this is a motion to to split it yes which means that it may not be ready for next week that's okay we have it's already been put on the floor um attorney Sanic or Mr cuff can you just explain the potential implications for the school district if we don't pass this policy that's aligned with the state law um so next ask you apologize so next week we're set for a review through Esser and what we've found in other districts who have had their Essa review they've looked for the conflict of interest and that has been a sighting in other districts um so that's what we're trying to avoid to have that sighting for the Allentown School District they could translation they could disallow certain of our uh Esser funding that
100we've received already and we received a lot of Esser funding yes without question that's a translation yes okay okay may and we once we learned about this we brought it to the board's attention because of the seriousness of this is immediately so it's not like this was something that we delayed our colleagues shared this with us we've been through extensive monitoring and as I mentioned in the beginning that we've we're in a very good position the way we look as it rates fiscally so we don't want to we don't want to uh have the district have any type of negativity or citation around its finances because we worked really hard to ensure that we used our resources in the manner in which we should have for the benefit of the children and there's some other
101organ districts who did not do that but we worked very diligently and so I just want to make sure that we had the full scope because it's my responsibility to share the implications and why this is so important so I have a go ahead question slash option is it possible to vote on this tonight I don't know what everyone's vote's going to be and if it does pass can we go and ratify this in two weeks a couple of weeks and make a decision to do a split recommend it because you're going to be asked to produce this right away and the fact that you have a motion that passes it doesn't necessarily shows that show it's in force I just think the we could I'm just saying the better course of action if the
102board really wanted to divide it in half and that's a majority of the board adopt the policy in its current form right now and you could refer it back to the policy committee and talk about this more and amend it we we should be that's that could be true for any policy that we adopt like this evening we heard issues relating to policy 707 that the board had concerns with and I suspect that the board's going to be looking at policy 707 again potentially in policy committee we could do that too but I just think for next week's meeting we would be best served by approving the policy in its current format and if we um want to split it up in a different format uh we can talk about it I'll be candid with
103you I'm kind of at a loss to understand why there is a desire to have a different set of rules for the board versus the employees who would uh under the state ethics act be deemed to be public officials uh I'm still at a loss to understand why that distinction needs to be made okay point of order let's go ahead and do the vote I know that I'm going to vote no because I want to continue the way we have the policy so M Mr sson please uh call Ro and I also want to say I want to withdraw my motion because I don't want District to be cited okay so now what happened with the okay so you have you have a motion right now and a second so a vote of yes to
104the motion that she just said she wants to with oh you asked to withdraw it then that's fine I'll be here she did me did you made you made the motion you made the second she made the the second okay so there's no second okay so is there a second okay now that's been if there's no second then the motion fails okay so let's go to the voting of the policy 2 827 can I get a motion I make the motion I have a second second any discussion okay do we just do all in favor yes because that's that's what we did before all in favor say I I any opposed I the um eyes have it and the motion is carried do we have any um public comments on the non-agenda item shenik wiik
105do we have zoom members make sure you get that count right Jen is off is Miss Brown on how many did you get Mr Simson no I'm not sure miss Brown is no Brown is off and miss miss they're both off so the count is minus two people so it's 9 - 2 7 so 61 MH still on no so we had two board members off yes yes so it's 61 for the last vote thank you all right ma'am good evening again I'm just up here to ask when can 707 be brought up and be um either revised or talked about so we can actually give our children a chance to have somewhere to play the practice and be between the hours of 6 and8 instead on the streets so I just want to know
106um if we can look at that again thank you very much thank you is there any old business I don't delete anything yes go right ahead can we uh revisit 707 and consider Amendment go ahead I I just want to request for the board that we provide you with a full scope of the direction that we're going and this is separate from a one request but holistically we will share with you our thinking about why we've put rules in place that we presented to the board back in 2023 um regarding how we use our fil facilities in the district so the administration if it's the board's request we will share with you are thinking why we've come to the way we have as it as it relates to our facilities I I don't want to
107get into lots of sites ation right now I can think of a few examples of why we put these policies in place and as we know as an organization we probably have more than $250 million of deferred maintenance in the district so when people use our facilities we have to have a way of capturing how we repair them we also have several we've made several uh appeals to organizations to partner with us we have several ways in which people are true partners in a sense with our schools and which people don't pay so the board would let us do that so we make an objective decision about whether we need to violate the that's I'm resp respectfully requesting that you give the administration an opportunity to give you objectively why these decisions were made so
108objectively as a elected official who represent the families and the children of alltown we have to remember were 100% free lunch and the nonprofits especially those who are on the ground grassroot they are not making money they're not so when they ask to use our schools we're charging them fees where they're keeping they're doing something extra we're educating the children but they're doing these after school things keeping and weekend things and keeping them out of trouble but yet to me we feel like I feel like we're penalizing them because the little that they get they put on our give it to our students so then they got to raise money just to use our facilities and I think it should be done on a on an individual basis I know for a fact that you
109know one group took forever for our um system took two months for our system to finally look at their application look at it and they were going at it and they were calling me and everything else and that's not that's not the first time this happened so I'm asking as the board as a board we are elected by our people why are we charging especially these you know the boosters yes and all that stuff like that because of what tier one or whatever they're they're raising money however these the smaller nonprofits are doing the things for our students that nobody else is doing if I may if I make a suggestion on on this issue um not all nonprofits are created equal I'm that's what I'm saying smaller yeah yeah I understand and if you're
110going to try to distinguish between because not all nonprofits are not profitable that's double that's d That's a double negative uh there are some very very large nonprofits in this country that raise billions of dollars per year and uh there are also a lot of nonprofits as you apply point out uh using the word smaller nonprofits that are edging by in the process uh I just don't think it's a simple solution I think you do need to talk about it and I do strongly recommend that when the board considers this issue that it considers what this might mean organizationally and I think you may want to see some of the data from the administration before you make a decision I I can guarantee you that there are a number of nonprofits perhaps very similar to
111the nonprofit who is here that are eeking by and this will impose a great hardship on their operation on the other hand there are many other nonprofits that we do business with that can very easily afford to do this and in fact may have larger budgets than we have as the Allentown School District I'm just suggesting that as you change the definitions of a policy that we look at that carefully and give some thoughtful consideration on this because um a snap judgment may impact you significantly and I interrupted you uh no honestly my suggestion was going to be Miss Phoebe that you added to the agenda for for review for the next one because I like to see things in front of me so if we're going to dissect it I want to dissect all
112of it and that will give the administration some time to bring the data and the information that they have and then we can make an informed decision um then about that policy but it needs to go on your your upcoming and by the way Mr cuff just reminded me just is another factor that goes into this is liability insurance so if God forbid something happens through an organization uh and it happens on school property but that's not the piece that we're discussing we're me that's not the but it but but it's part of the issue because that's one of the requirements but I thought that was always a requirement so that's why I wanted in front because I that's that's why I'm just I'm just saying that uh you know you heard a difficult story
113today admittedly we all did well but and and but we have to look at a broader picture of what this is going to mean to the district and its overall rules that's all I'm suggesting that we have a cerebral review of this and make the best decision for the community however I with any use of our schools the nonprofits have to have the liability insurance right or else you can't use our school right right what I wanted to add because that's and and I want to hear more of how we can get it done instead of how we can't get it done cuz I've been too many places in this little 20 years that I've been living in this world um 20 years old you're right um I've been too many places to know and
114understand that districts are doing it how many play times we've walked into places and they're really doing it they're make they're reaching out I'm I heard um the woman story tonight but my request has really just nothing to do with her single issue it has everything to do with what I've been why I've been sitting here for these seven years you know we can't look good and not be good and start talking about we so corporate that we can't get stuff done for our kids that's not going to happen on my watch or I'm going to be the bad guy you know what I mean because I'm going to keep pushing the same envelope we're here for our kids our kids are not rich we don't have the same things that everybody else has but
115if we all unite and pull together we can give our kids what our kids need because whether they're up on the hill or here in the valley what goes in them is what comes out and we keep talking about how successful we're going to be but then we get around this table and we talk about oh well I don't know if they have liability or we try to figure out we name a thousand reasons why we can't we are and we will we just got to figure it out yes and we do currently but we have structures for it and that's why I'd like for the board to see because there's several nonprofits that we partner with that use our facilities we have extended programs we have we've each uh and we've shared this with
116the board and some of the board members have come we have this room full of 75 different nonprofits at times we've had and we've engaged with people so there are ways that within our current structure that people engage with us but as we said some nonprofits like attorney satanic said are they're not all equal and when people say they're not making money we're finding that they are making money and so and they're getting benefits and then we're incurring costs and we have to clean our schools pay our staff and maintain things so if we open it up from one I just want to share this with the board and if you can tell me to be quiet but if we open up an opportunity for on one group and this has nothing to do with
117the young ladies who's here this evening we have to be Equitable and fair to all groups so when we make decisions we have to think about holistically the entire organization and the fiscal impact operationally and what it does for the children that we're responsible during the daytime if we spend resources and not buying things so I just wanted to say that because I thought was very important to underscore that we do support nonprofits so I don't want a news article saying we don't because we have tons of nonprofit Partners tons of them so I want to go don't pass I I think we are discussing Equity because when you think about Equity we're we're talking about everything is not created equal correct right as you're saying so for the smaller nonprofits that's trying to do
118work in the district it it it is challenging like she said so if we want to create it and make it Equitable Equity means that the larger nonprofits that can afford it would be able to pay and then but we have I don't want to get into this but I have to because I I don't want it walked away what the Administrations not partner with people we have extended day partner uh programs they work with local nonprofits the school select the nonprofits that they want to work with and we should we've given principles power and authority over their schools they survey some of them survey some people talk with and they partner with individual groups and they don't pay us because they're working with schools so we do that do that but again we have
119lots of requests tons Saturdays weekends all these things we have to staff it so we say everyone can use the schools at will regard as a group we don't have people that even want to work those opportunities all the time so we have to manage the organization because we have to think about the larger organ organization in service to the children during the daytime first all right I understand that um but one of the things that Jeff said was the business okay so these nonprofits are business business the bigger ones who are you know who are using our facilities who are making the money who are getting these bigger grants you know from United Way and everyone else who give them the grants to do these things with our school district even from the state
120you know because Valley youth house got a almost a million which I'm still mad about when we didn't really want them however um that's the business part but then again we have our nonprofits that don't have a business part who are just doing what they need to do for our students because they love it and they're doing it with their whole heart and they're not making money even though a mod like you said a modit nonprofit who's making a who's made a business of it is making money where upon these smaller ones who are doing the grassroot who are in there with our students are not and so I I really want us to look at that anyone else yeah if I could step in and make a comment here in the interest of time
121um we're likely is not to not vote on this tonight and I think there's a difference between reaction and Action Reaction being quick and without thinking um I'd like to ask Dr brks how long you think it would take the administration to adequately provide a contextual update on this information we can have that information I want to just look over to the right because the people who have to do the work is it realistically that we can have it within the next two weeks or do we need the next policy meeting I'm just looking over here if you could just give me a high sign because they have to do the work for the January meeting of we can have the report of how many nonprofits I know we have that tonight in someone's computer
122but how many nonprofits that we're working with currently go back to our current policy also look at the fiscal implications I'm looking over here to my left in the back the fiscal implications of who's using our facilities how much money we are spending for our facilities and usage so that we have a full scope of what this looks like so before we make a decision to make my ifications we make aned decision and of whatever decision the we have to follow and I what you said time this it but we left out the most important part how can we engage our smaller but we do already so that's why I want us to see obviously we're leaving some little people out and so my goal is to present to this board that we figure out
123ways to engage the little nonprofits because obviously if we look at our data and we look at our numbers they figured it out they're in we don't want to leave anyone out we want the small people as well so what do you need what do we need to be able to gauge the little people so that we can figure out how we can get them in I think it just in terms of giving some help and direction on this issue uh I think defining the groups that you're looking at may be critical in this decision and just saying saying the word smaller doesn't mean anything until you define Define it what does it mean in terms of the amount of annual contributions what is their annual budget are they an organized 501c3 organization those are
124the kinds of questions that need to be asked in order to make a policy that can be administered effectively by the district so that the board doesn't have to on a regular basis look at these things on a case- by casee basis which you couldn't do you'd be meeting all the time so I I do think that getting that kind of information and trying to seek definition is going to be critical on that yeah and if we can get clarifications on the tiers yes when you're doing the presentation Dr Burks so everyone understands like what's a tier one what's the tier two absolutely so to the board can we can we wait till January yes please yeah okay we the for the record the administration will have a presentation of all the levels how many
125people were are using our facilities in the fiscal implications to date and as well as historic and people in the back give me if you can get this historical data as to how many people how much we spend or how much revenue we're generated as well because we need to understand the bigger picture before we make a decision understand the bigger picture I think you gave us that before I think I want to know who we're missing I want to know what nonprofits and to speak to what Jeff was saying about we wouldn't know that answer how do we find out I have no idea okay see then we figure out how we can figure that out cuz there's a lot of nonprofits I meet people every day they say have a nonprofit so I
126would not know that but if you have some direction as that you can give us we'll take it but I don't know and but we're willing to by January we can revisit 707 and we just have to work out work with the administration to figure out how we're going to find the nonprofits who are trying who are doing but they're not getting in because they can't afford it they have we have to make sure that they dotted their eyes and crossed their tees that they're real nonprofits and if they're working here we want to make sure that we're accommodating them so we can do that would you agree yes any other probably will know now after he made that Miss Anna did you have something no no okay go ahead sorry all right um is
127there any new business man motion to adjourn second all in favor we go now to the education do you guys want a two-minute break yeah five minutes minutes we'll be back in five minutes and then we and we don't have much for Education we'll go real quick so just go and come back when we get in these new chairs my back is hurting me yeah you only have let's vote on that let's vote on you on you e e e good evening everyone we're gonna get started we got two items and we gonna be out the door oh another one I'm sorry won't be out the door good night I'd like to call the order the Education meeting of Committee of the whole for the board of directors for the school district for the city
128of Allentown for today December 5th 2024 the board welcomes and invites public comments you may address the board on agenda and or non-agenda items the first opportunity for comment is at the beginning of the meeting and is limited to agenda items only comment cards must be received at by the start of the meeting which is now we will not be receiving public cards once the meeting begins a copy of the public comment policy is located on the table next to the comment cards per our board's policy any person may address the board in accordance with the procedures and limitations of this policy either on issues presented in resolutions being considered or on other matters affecting Administration Management or operations of the district remarks of a personal nature directed against any individual will be ruled out
129of order if you choose to address the board please fill out a comment card and hand it to board secretary Mr Simonson again comments cards are located at the podium near the door once recognized please come to the podium state your name and address for the record and kindly limit your remarks to minutes at this time we are taking public comment on agenda items only we don't have any cards thank you very much tonight we we have two agenda items the first item is a request for the approval for moraven University counselors and social workers internships and these items will be presented by Dr Malika seavoy good evening the thank you um the first item is the approval for the agreement between Allentown school district and Moravian University to provide clinical and filled education and
130experience to school counseling and Social Work students at Moravian University the Allentown school district is considering the agreement between Moravian University and the district to serve as an educational site for students pursuing degrees in School counseling and social work this agreement will allow students at Moravian University to fulfill their practical internship requirements at our in our schools under the supervision of qualified site Personnel this gives also gives them the opportunity of real life experiences and also give the district an opportunity for recruiting Talent would you like to present this second item too can vot on both yep did we just talk about the Moravian yes so just have one quick question so um is the is this for ASD students or is it Moravian students Moravian students supporting ASD through their filled experience in practicum
131gotcha and what's the age demographic for that for does it matter college students about to graduate from college so they will be senior um Juniors and seniors Juniors and seniors okay thank you any other questions okay the second agreement is for the school the Allentown school district and St Luke's University Health Network we're asking for approval to provide after school work for St Luke's to provide after school work-based experiences for seniors in Allentown School District this opportunity will allow our senior students the opportunity to work at two one of two St Luke's um locations um one at Sacred Heart in the other one St Luke's St Luke's okay here um this initiative aims to prepare students for post-graduation Success while addressing Workforce Development within the Lehigh Valley this is in alignment with our strategic Focus
132around College and Career Readiness and Workforce Development and I also want to say the other talked about talent but the other um agreement that we're asking for support for is aligned to our um strategic plan priority five developing Talent thank you very much do you have any questions on that yeah quick question why only like two to three students is it because it's a pilot this is one of our Partnerships with St Luke's University so we have other opportunities and workbase experiences and internships this specific one is around food service and nutrition so they have four opportunities for our students to be employed um from now during now and through through June so so it's four different opportunities but no it's four students four students two at each site two at each site okay and
133this is one opportunity in Partnership that we have with St Luke's we have about four would they be able to expand this though if like we wanted to get more students in it we have other St Luke's opportunities to have additional students okay like one has 18 in it right now gotcha but I'm just thinking like this sounds like a really good one what if other kids like and perhaps once the friend here is like you know if I go to my friend that could be an opportunity this is our first time doing this one so as our students experience and we work with them around the food service and nutrition area quite sure like even if it's opportunities not necessarily paid but externship wor experiences yes I think they're open to that that's what
134I'm thinking I'm thinking of treating this like a pilot but then maybe in the future we can expand of students yeah yeah thank you thank you okay thanks thanks I just want to say I'm really excited about the possibilities of these Partnerships uh both groups with Moravian um as we know we need to build our own Pipeline and this will give us an opportunity to have more one for the support of the students more counseling and Clinic clinicians in the schools supporting our students and our whole Child Development which is a primary focus of of ours and then St Luke's we're really happy that they're great partners of ours and this is just an additional opportunity for them to support our students and I want to say publicly I want to thank them for serving
135as Platinum SP sponsor yesterday for our state of the district address so I just thought it was important to note that so we're excited thank you very much is there any more other comments may I have a motion to move these two items forward to our regular board meeting scheduled for December 19 2024 so move second we already had discussion all in favor please let it be known by saying I I are there any that oppose hearing and seeing none this moves forward to our next regular board meeting at this time is there any old business to come before the board any new business any grass catches hearing and seeing none may I have a motion to adjourn Su motion all in favor please let it be know by saying I I any oppose this
136meeting is adjourned that right thank you all right so we're heading straight into our special meeting I'd like to quote to order the special meeting of the board of directors of the school district for the city of Allentown for today December 5th 2024 the board welcomes and invites public comment you may address the board on agenda and or non-agenda items the first opportunity for a comment is at the beginning of the meeting and is limited to agenda items only common cards must be received by the start of the meeting which is now we will not be receiving Public public cards once the meeting begins a copy of the public common policy is located on the table next to the common cards per our board's policy any person may address the board in accordance with procedures
137and limitations of this policy either on issues presented in resolutions being considered on other matters affecting the Administration Management or operation of the district remarks of a personal nature directed against any individual will be ruled out of order if you choose to address the board please out a common card and hand it to the board secretary Mr Simonson comment cards are located at the podium near the door once recognized please come to the podium state your name and address for the record and kindly limit your remarks to 3 minutes we will now have the roll call Mr secretary please call the rooll uh Miss Brown Miss Conover present Miss Harris here miss matis here Mr nikoloff here Mr uh Miss Noel here miss Ortiz Miss Sierra Miss uh terso here Mr uh solicitor Miss Sierra
138is in the building her belongs is still here do we count her she may be in the ladi's room or do we count her or not uh I think you wait to show her arriving until we get to the appropriate item on the agenda because if we have an agenda action she's not here she shouldn't be counted as present so don't count her yeah don't count her yet you can uh count her when she comes back uh to the thing you can just say she joined the meeting at that time okay so we we have six members present and we'll wait to see if your other counter partner she I'm sure she'll come back in the lady's room I don't oh she had home she come to she had a okay she had leave she
139had leave I don't think she's returning to the meeting yeah she left okay defitely time for The Pledge I'm sorry I just want to make sure she was okay please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance United States of America thank you and for our superintendence remarks so good evening again School Board directors everyone I'll just make this brief something I didn't mention that I did not uh previously on Tuesday December 10th we are launching our inaugural Su uh special education excuse me special education family advisory Council so if any families who are listening if you are interested and joining our advisory Council uh please email uh Dr Bo or Mr sick um if you want to learn more about the special education family advisory Council the meeting is at 5:45 yes five o'clock thank you
140at five o'clock in this room so we are really um excited about launching the special education family advisory Council and that's all I want to mention so families are listening we'd love to have you join us on Tuesday December 10th at 5:00 P p.m. thank you thank you at this time we are only taking public comments on agenda items once recognized please come to the podium state your name and address for the record and kindly limit your remarks to 3 minutes any public comments okay thank you may I have a motion of approval of the policy report can we you want to do a separation sear okay are we okay with the separation yeah okay can I have the policy numbers which one is that 827 827 and 88 827 okay thank you may I
141have a motion to approve policy number 628 I make the motion a second a second any discussion please call the rote Miss con over yes Miss Harris yes Miss mat yes Mr nicolov yes Miss Noel yes Mr terso yes motion passes 60 thank you may have a motion to approve policy number 827 I make the motion I'll second second any discussion please call the r Miss Harris yes Miss mat yes Mr nikolov yes Miss Noel yes Miss tabio yes Miss Conover no motion passes 51 thank you at this time we are only taking public comments on non-agenda items once recognized please come to the podium state your name and address for the record and kindly limit your remarks to 3 minutes Mr secretary do we have any no ma'am is there any old business to
142come before the board any new business may have a motion to adjourn this meeting some this meeting is adjourned have a good one