CorpusRecord 42375

Kuna School District Board of Trustees Regular Meeting - February 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Kuna School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Ada County, ID
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,872 words · about 122 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Happy Valentine's Day some treats for all of you since we're putting in some extra time and I'm Journal work to Phil here uh who comes from isba and I've set in on some of his workshops does a great job so I'm anxious to see what we can learn tonight thanks for having me cim I hope JD makes it soon that this is actually part one of two pieces that would will not only satisfy your literacy and continuous Improvement training requirement by the state but hopefully do more um we really want to dig into I've got my colleague Jason I I want to introduce him before I'm remiss and fail to Jason Lloyd is a school board member in Twin Falls just had a board meeting last night uh came to work for

002isba in October yep and what else should they know about you been in education my whole life um my mother's a teacher my wife's a teacher teacher and I love education he weren't you a teacher also our college professor yes yes I post secondary yes both and so he'll engage here in the workshop too at some point we have not rehearsed together so don't but we're just going to with it um in in fact I have no intention I know there's a lot of slides I'll probably click through them but I think the most effective learning opportunity is a conversation together and every where I go there's a conversation that needs to be had by a board board superintendent administrative team um but it's not always being had so uh a lot of times my

003thinking and as a facilitator and I've been doing this a long time is what do people really need to talk about like what can I say ask suggest do that prompts sort of those ahas that come and with that is this question about you know what is good governance anyway what what does it mean to govern effectively govern and oversee a school system uh I write and talk about these things a lot but I think it means different things different places I any of the trustees what does it mean to you what what does good governance look like feel like what do you do what do you not do I I think it's working together for the best of the district working with Administration um together to come up to what we can do for

004the students and for our community together is a key word together uhuh and um yeah what we bring to the table and how we bring that there's a great old book by um Jamie vmer called schools can't do it alone Jamie wmer uh was an ice cream manufacturer who had his own business and did a lot of speaking about how messed up public schools were and then he investigated dug in a little bit more gave a little more thinking slept on it got confronted blah blah blah like it's it's quite an amazing story if you've ever had a chance to hear him speak or read his book um schools can't do it alone one of his realizations was you when he was making ice cream you know the big Factory if they had bad blueberries

005they could call them like they could toss them away way and it dawned on him one day it's like wait a minute in public education we don't we don't get to pick the bad ones out we've got to work with what we have it's sort of a fascinating mindset and shift um he's on my mind uh had his book in my hand yesterday but so just thinking about that like what are we trying to do here anyway what are our limitations and very importantly that concept how do we do it together one of the essential pieces as I talk and share is is how do we work trustees Administration teachers and staff Community um some of you that might have been in workshops with me a couple of years ago we were talking about a

006book called The governance core and Michael Fen who's a education leader researcher out of Canada he put together a book with a guy by the name of Davis Campbell who had had worked in public education for more than 50 years uh and so they put this book together called the governance core and one of the big pieces was this idea that uh what what teachers are doing in a classroom does that make any sense with what administrators are doing wherever they are and whatever it is they're doing no offense FKS um like is it does it even make sense and they use the word coherent and when they put that book together the the governance core they put in this third circle does what the board does does it make any sense with what is

007actually happening with teachers and with admin like is it disconnected is it fragmented is it how does it fit together and as I think about that I think of a fourth circle that I think is really critical and maybe the most important missing element right is how do we as board members engage the community not just our friends not just people that think Like Us come from our background go to our church whatever the our circle is but but the broader Community how do we not just the customers so not just parents and families or students but the elderly folks the people that don't have children um the married the unmarried every Walk of Life in the community how do we get them invested in what the board is doing what the administration is doing

008and what's happening in the classroom so I'm going to ask you to indulge me in this question here sorry it's green instead of the traditional yellow I'd like you to pick a number and answer that question for us and Jason will pick these up so it's quasi Anonymous I I I'm going to say you know usually I would say we have a superintendent do this but I I want the the B Team superintendent here to agree on an answer you two come to consensus on one and so that way it'll give us at least five up there I feel like je pry what what percentage of C students are currently reading at or above grade level and then there is a follow-up question Jas you want to stick those on the left for me now

009here's the trickier one I'll Advance the slide but with the right support what percentage of students could be performing at or above grade level so you have to interpret that Define it did you guys do well on the first one did you you collaborated thank you thank you with the right support what percentage of students could be reading specifically reading at or above grade l% any help they got cond do decision they' got agree so that's super tricky so sorry that B Team term that was one of their yeah just just saying I didn't just call them that um propo one of them said it for both of them but uh so with data one of the very first questions we should always ask about any data any information just what do we see when

010you look up here on the left on the right what what do you see there I see where we're at and where we need to be or where we think we need to be two different kind of ranges definitely okay someone else guest really low something is that is that Hillary low no it's not me somebody guess low I assume we're yeah low low somebody else I put that in your own words what do you see on the left versus the right I that there should be Improvement there there should be Improv Improvement we're not performing where we need to be I'm going to say that just to write this up here this one's at 45% and the top one is at 78% and the range here is 85 that's kind of like an eight

011uh to 95 so wherever you were at on here you probably put something higher up there in fact I think there's 100% chance of that anything else what what was in your mind when you picked a number for the percentage of students that are currently reading at or above grade level this is a great timing because you're going to see a report on this tonight um that it's lower than it that it would like to be was that what was in your mind that you know it's lower than what the board would like to see I think anybody in the anyone the community anything else like what was on your mind had was there a report was there a guest was there mine was a wild guest okay thank you for that know yeah no

012no thank you I know we've discussed it and so I don't I might have picked the wrong number but I was thinking we've talked about this before but what what was in your mind here this 85 to 95% range just that's where I want it to be what's that that's where I want it to be you want it to my vision my vision is that yeah we can get to that well and with the right support kind of subjective but if we had whatever it is that it takes to move from this range which the median here would be about 60% to the median here which is 90% U what what would it take to go from 60% of students reading at or above grade level and this was intentionally just left wide open K12

013right as we we think about that one of the most important important things that a school board can do coming down behind you okay and I got more backup magnets so thanks to somebody Dean thinks of everything actually it was Kevin thanks him too one of the most important things a school board can do is focus one of the most difficult things the school board has to do is focus there 's just no end pick your term for it tyranny the moment there there is no end of stuff coming at us and one of the hard things particularly when we're new one of the hard things is to differentiate between a customer complaint and a community concern that's right because and I'm reflecting when I was a new school board member I was the people

014people came to and once they knew I would listen they told their friends talk to Phil didn't matter whether it was parents or whether it was staff or just a Community member and and it was really hard to get it it takes most of us about two years to get to a place it's like oh that's why we shouldn't do that like right it it's we don't know until we know and people can tell us but it's not the same until we experience it we really don't understand something until we've experienced it and then most of us once we get it we get it but that distinction between being micr focused on what's happening in an individual classroom not yet dare I say library lunchroom playground ball field like that that Micro Focus versus the

015macro focus of the longterm Vision I would say for me as a board member that didn't sink in until the night that I was signing a contract that gave an easement to a utility company to go through uh one of our middle schools property and the words were into perpetuity I don't think I'd ever signed anything before that with those words in it like I was I was g i was the board chair signing what the board had approved to give away property where we could never have a ball field never build another building never put a parking lot never put in a fire lanane you know like that that was no longer and those words into perpetuity were pretty pretty daunting I I think it was that night that for me I realized oh

016this is really big picture like right it was we we'd had all the other kinds of stuff of the school year and the things that come and go and conflicts and challenges and budgets and bonds and all the all the Killer Bees the buses ball games buildings everything that you have to do you know that that is not helping focus on this it's not like buildings and buses and bonds and all the things are not important they're just not the main thing so I I would encourage you tonight just to kind of reflect on but what is our main thing and maybe that's a rhetorical individual question and maybe it's a conversation as a board in the near future like for us as the ca School Board what is the main thing that we can

017agree to is is our big one and we've been rolling out something slowly across the state of Idaho we call Gem State governance it comes from the research on how School boards can affect student achievement and it's really primarily focused in three areas what what what are the beliefs about about what is possible does a person have kind of a growth mindset where they have high expectations for kids for for staff for themselves there's a lot that goes into perspectives do we have the knowledge the understanding the wisdom I would even add sometimes to do the actions that we can statistically correlate with improving student achievement nobody credible can say if the board does this this and this student achievement will improve what we can say is where student achievement is improving boards tend to

018do this this and this let's let's unpack some of that a little bit I I apologize the slides like they went from PowerPoint to PDF to Google slides to squirly um we talked about what is governance I think just whatever it's word I think one of the essential pieces of governance perhaps the biggest power we have as a trustee is the power of the question and I think for what again whatever that what are Phil's thinking is worth I I I think that the better the questions we ask the better the school board governs so what does that look like what well for one it it's asking informed questions because if we're going to get to the balance between being too micr focused and maybe not being micr focused enough that balance is somewhere in

019the words of informed oversight we know enough to ask the good questions right so I think good governance is asking good questions informed questions informed oversight one of the things we know from the research and there was a a project uh started in 1998 it ended about 2015 idah hope was a part of it in fact U board chair that was iny at the time she's since deceased but her name is Janet she was a librarian Boye and she was a part of this National research study as were several people from Idaho at the time uh one of the things that we found was there's no substitute for high expectations like interviewing boards where students were improving and achievement the board and the system had high expectations for kids you you just can't emphasize how

020important that is like the piece here that the board can have is to have high expectations which translate into a powerful Vision with high goals and high expectations for students and staff like that's that's probably the key perspective that it takes to move the needle but we know from ongoing research as well in fact um Brian brought in this book I think he wanted me to sign it U actually he told me he bought it and didn't have any idea had a connection with me but chapter four in the book these two guys that wrote chapter 4 they did a very quantitative study in the state of Montana 2013 it was built on that foundations of the lighthouse project and they did a Statewide study that correlated what boards said they did with how they

021were doing on state standardized test and the strongest correlations they had was number one goals for the superintendent related to improving student achievement it was off the charts like it the Pearson r value 71 highly statistically significant if a board has goals for the superintendent that relate to improve student achievement almost always is improved very statistically significant the second most statistically significant was communicating those expectations to the community having goals for the superintendent that are on the website that are on school newsletters that are talked about in board meetings part of this is the power of alignment um or this same idea here coherence what we say is important and what we're wanting to do is that what we as a board are holding the system accountable for look at this one the third most

022statistically significant was making contract decisions about the superintendent based on how the students are doing having that be a big part of the basis which in Idaho it's required by law but I don't it the law just says you have to consider it whatever that means like you have to consider student achievement when you evaluate a superintendent the board has to decide with a superintendent this this is what this means to us in CA this is how this alignment this Improvement effort goes but collaborating with staff and community staff is an essential part of the community on a plan for the district whether you call it a strategic plan or you call it something else boards and systems that are improving in achievement they have a plan you just see how that all fits together

023so that the board's work is also tied of the plan it in higher achieving districts and I mean districts that are actually improving in achievement right that's that's the secret it's not where to just start but what are you doing with what you have that the board is aligning its work to the same goals they're holding the system and the superintendent accountable for this this is all flowing in the same direction and they're monitoring progress the simple Act of monitoring progress on student achievement is likely to drive Improvement in achiev achievement when the whole system knows the board is paying attention to how the students are doing and they're going to be talking at their February board meeting on the latest iri data everybody wants to look good not just the superintendents not just the

024central office staff principes teachers everybody wants to look good just the act of monitoring achievement I believe it can be a powerful lever for improving achievement indulge me just a minut minute four pictures together I don't know did you see these in the packet already or these okay sorry what what's the theme in those four photos to you what is it family family thank you achievement yeah just go ahead and name them all right go for K you're on a roll now girl I'll was the Whiteboard instead of the paper there family achievement I can almost read that somebody else what do you see Hillary um trust trust huge right Kim I I I'm going to go with achievement I I'm trying to think cuz you're achieving all of those things you're exploring you're trying

025new things maybe how expl yeah Discovery discover sorry that's kind of close to the one yeah what if that was a little boy in a picture with a magnifying glass what would you say he's trying to start a fire bugs yeah Michael do what did you say Michael burning bugs I say train St fire yeah n boys boys know it's burning bugs investigating yeah it's this exploring Discovery I I love the word curiosity I I won't spend a lot of time but now that that's a little larger do you see anything different happening or trust we got trust we got family they're laughing they're playing they're together laughing together one of the most important signs of a healthy group is laughter it doesn't matter what the group is like the board can laugh with each

026other at each other with the board as a whole it's help right um anything else I'm writing that down laughter together is healthy I learned that in church work one of the biggest factors of a healthy church is their laughter anything else on that one enjoyment enjoyment I write sloppy enough but at least I can hold in right we got that one this is a really intriguing picture there's a lot going on there what do you what do you see a little bit more enlarged kind of look at it like the big picture going forward yeah there's a big picture going forward small picture behind you but you're focused on that's good big picture focused on the road ahead what's that focusing on the road ahead focusing on the road ahead sometimes driving is relaxing

027sometimes um I it's red line or right at it yeah I'm thinking speeding yeah there's some there's some speeding I'm thinking there should be a policeman in the reew there somewhere take a good look at the rearview mirror the the road behind yeah it seems clearer than the road ahead the rearview mirror is a lot clearer almost like totally clear compared to the fuzzy future I heard a guy speak at a school boards conference 20 years ago in Spokane um the coach for Remember the Titans not Denzel Washington for the women but the real one coach Boon he he was the first person I ever heard say these words we need to stop trying to prepare students for our past and prepare them for their future it's been kind of Haunting as a father my

028kids are all grown um the youngest one lives here in the area went to boisey state has a degree in computer science he does work I didn't even know existed when he was born and gets paid a whole lot more money than I do and even if he loses his job he still makes more money like he makes extra money when he loses the job I'm serious as it all get up like it it's the most foreign thing to me the tech industry how how it works all three of my kids do things that I I would have never imagined them doing as adults those words have been kind of constantly resounding with me H how do we not try to prepare kids for our past which is kind of clear to us we you

029know we needed cursive writing I I hope I'm not stepping on anything here my 88-year-old mother is just convinced that the death of public schools is not teaching more cursive writing I said mom if they apply for a job if they want to go to college if they want to learn how to fix something do something be a mechanic they do that on a computer there's other advantages to handwriting achievement I like the idea in this photo possibilities and I just reinforce that other idea that their possibilities their future their Vision not necessarily what we would have thought all of these things can be correlated and are in research with school systems that are improving in achievement there's Clear Vision and vision is important but Clear Vision is probably more important that and I said

030it earlier but it has to be a shared Vision with the community it's not sustainable for five trustees to sit in a room and come up with a vision for the district so it's a nice exercise good conversation but the reality is if the community is not involved not bought in not participating students staff parents families other community members it just doesn't get sustained specific goal setting that's a little different goals are important but fuzzy goals get fuzzy results the more specific the goal the more likely achievement is be to be improving and for a school board this is sometimes counterintuitive in fact if we had a room full of teachers we would have all different ideas no offense cim we'd have all different ideas about what the main goals should be right because the

031art teacher thinks it should be art and the science teacher thinks it should be science and the math teacher thinks it should be math but they can't all be right I was working with the Austin School District 10 years ago on a superintendent evaluation instrument and we were just moving right along we'd had two three workshops everything was making progress and the system came up with this scorec card that they wanted to use as the foundation for the superintendent evaluation instrument it had 65 different things to measure I said folks if you're measuring 65 things y'all aren't measuring anything wait if the goal is 6 five different goals there is no goal all to say the important piece of that is the power of a narrow Focus what we want to see is is highly

032performing school boards with highly performing instructional teams administrators and teachers it the teachers can't do it alone administrators can't do it alone the board can't do it along it's everybody doing their piece to work together toward the same objective and and a piece of this that may be inherently here is in order for there to be Improvement the system has to be learning the board has to be learning and boardsmy improving haven't seen a gender inclusive word for boardsmarch that anyway sorry U the instructional team has to be improving if we do what we've always done we're going to get less than we always have we hear it said that if we do what we've always done we'll get what we've always had but that's really not true if we do the same thing over

033and over and over over time whether it's a machine or a person or a system we actually get less out of it so somebody has to be able to step out and have the Curiosity the discovery that that idea of exploring to be able to develop new techniques there's a lot of different things did I prompt any questions I'm playing Jason you want to jump in and add anything to what I've been saying you're so you don't have to I mean I I wanted to but you were on a role I I wanted to just reiterate the the belief in your students and your systems high expectations and belief they can perform it reminds me of one of my favorite academic studies done in the 70s have you heard of the big million effect where

034they researchers I don't know how they got away with this but they did at the time researchers gave kindergarten teachers 20 students they said here here are the 10 gifted students and here are the 10 non-gifted students and then they let them teach the kids throughout the year and then they went back and sure enough the 10 gifted students did well and the 10 non-gifted students struggled but the key was they had randomized the students so there was no difference between those two groups but was the effect of belief um that is really powerful it was their expectation yeah usually he'll ask questions I'm just wondering if you have any questions I will let you know but I don't thank you all right so I so I like to draw a pyramid or triangle and

035just to illustrate there's it's a system with different roles there's the often we call it the 50,000 F foot level right that's the Strategic there's the 10,000 ft level we call that the Tactical I'll get anward for this picture I can tell already and and then there's the ground level and the ground level is where the eil falls [Applause] over I should just [Applause] that was not on purpose for [Music] dramatic the Strategic the Tactical and then the operations this year teachers and staff these are the people that are day in and day out Hands-On with kids right these are the supervisors these are um the administrators the the people that are determining how things are done and the Board needs to be determining what is done that's strategic is your why why you do

036what you do your vision and your mission and the work of goals overlaps between the board and the administration and then the administration comes up with objectives operations has activities they do and individual tasks and all this somehow needs to to make sense top to bottom at the bottom is the outcomes this is the result of all the work that needs to happen a very important problem exists when board members try to do the work of Administrators and teachers and staff what's the biggest problem with that in your thinking if board members are trying to prescribe how how administrators manage how teachers teach how staff does their day job what's the big problem with that for me they're micromanaging something that they really don't have they know about as much as they should you know

037they're they're micromanaging things that they don't understand I've worked with boards all over the country and last night I was with a district with 180 some kids worked with Clark County board members in Vegas with 330 some thousand and Houston with 220 some thousand and it's it's always the same it's not it's not different little District mediumsized district large District good governance is good governance I spent hours with the Houston School Board nine caring women on the board passionate they were trying to figure out what they could possibly do to improve the academic performance of of one of their School feeder patterns eight out of nine people said either they could tutor students on Saturdays or they could coach Math teachers or they could volunteer in classrooms there is nothing wrong with a board member

038tutoring kids on Saturdays or volunteering in classrooms or being a a coach if that's your expertise right there's nothing wrong with that as a volunteer but the problem is who's doing the board's job if the board doesn't do the board's job that board got taken over by the state like because there's business up here at the top in the Strategic end that the board has to mind the vision the mission and very very vitally holding the system accountable for results only the board can hold the district accountable for results now you serve on a dual grant of authority you're elected by the citizens of the school district and you exist as a board and District because the state says you do we don't really like that as board members we love the concept of local

039control I wrote a master's thesis on it a long time ago how important local control is well the reality is and I said this to Senator lent three weeks ago in his office the reality is boards get all the local control that the legislature gives to them that's true right but the question becomes for us we can kick kick against the wall or the ice outside or whatever about that we can scream and holler as people do every day over at the capital every now and then I do but but it's like the the reality is we work with what we get within the parameters and and then the question becomes what are we doing with what we were given if if the board doesn't do its job again the administration's not going to do

040it they're not going to go out to the community and set a collaboratively developed vision for Student Success the administration's not going to really hold the whole system accountable you're the elected representatives of the community only you have the authority to hold the district accountable so as as you think about that I don't I don't mean this to be too heavy I'm just trying to go fast right like how does the board do this work and if there's plenty of time left over volunteer to do some other stuff like right but I mean I was on a school board I was a parent I I was a pastor in the school district I had all kinds of conflicts and role confusion and you know which hat am I putting on now is it is it

041an advocate is it a representative of this group is am I here on behalf of my kid am I here on behalf of the school board like was confusing for me much less of the teachers like but how do we navigate that and make sure we do the big stuff what Stephen cvy would call the big rocks right how how do we make sure we have that rock of vision and the big rock of accountability in place with Community Connection that if if there is a secret sauce that's missing in public school systems with improving achievement it is that Community Connection and and I had those same guys that did the research study 12 years ago in Montana do a report for me in Texas just a few years ago they showed a strong relationship

042between the boards involving the community in the board's work not sitting in a room like this and developing a vision and goals and plan and you know policies and all the work of the board but actually bringing the community in to help the board with that work making sure that all voices were heard and included that the greater extent to which boards do that the more likely the district is improving in achievement overall and closing gaps at the same time it really is sort of this elusive magical element that's been and missing when we talk about Community engagement it can't just be parents and teachers in classrooms it it can't just be back to school night it can't just be chaperon and field trips it that that's all good but that's down here at the

043operations level we need to figure out how do we involve the community in our work as a board and I would encourage you to think about that as you think about how do we improve reading right um was Kevin right yeah he he he let me know that he he taught only the upper grades of Elementary School something about not having the skills to teach kids to read but uh helping them read to learn that transition that we know happens about third grade you might ask your Administration for the data on student math sometime particularly look at Hispanic students English language Learners look at their math scores in second grade and look at them in fifth grade and I I'd almost be certain I should have looked before I said this but I'd almost be

044certain that those kiddos are doing pretty well in second grade on math and they're grossly underperforming in fifth grade why is that they're not reading and understanding the English words fast enough to do the word problems to get it worked out and they're frustrated and almost everywhere I've seen in the country those Trends are the same the Hispanic students come in doing great at math but they don't quite Master the English language skills to comprehend math quickly enough with understanding to do word problems in fifth grade talk with your Educators talk with others verify that what I'm saying is true or ridiculous but look at that data how are how is that group of students doing in math in the lower grades and Kevin's going to pull it up and then how are they doing

045in the upper elementary school because then it becomes all about reading right math is math is all about reading I'm going to suggest to you that the state Governor little like whatever anybody thinks of other initiatives things happening in the state or the governor or uh the superintendent of Public Instruction they're on the right track with how do we improve Pro reading comprehension in the early grades that's the key to every single thing else in life whether you're a business person whether you're uh a college professor whether you're a car mechanic or a plumber being able to read with understanding may be the ticket for success or at least the best import most important ticket we have being able to read with understanding so the laws exists we have to have this continuous Improvement plan

046do you all know anything about yours do you look at it do you think about it do you it you have to adopt one about every October it's tighter strategic you've got you've got the goals aligned consistent strategic plant yeah in most school systems in Idaho it's just a rope thing somebody fills it out board says yes approves it it's done like how might that be used in a way that actually gets what Kim's talking about embedded in the goals for the superintendent and the system there are these specific requirements in the Strategic plan I'm sure that yours like everybody else's has checked all the boxes what I what I don't know is if it's helping anything right or it's just sort of a thing that has to be done and it is it active

047Is it alive do your board meeting agendas relate to anything in the continuous Improvement plan do your goals for the superintendent relate to what's in the continuous Improvement plan you'll notice I'm talking about the same things over and over I'm talking about alignment coherence like is there a plan and is it focused if we're going to improve reading in the state of Idaho it will be because school systems focused on improving reading and I would even suggest as I do everywhere I go reading reading is this big complex thing reading is not simple most of those slides are for part two but reading is not simple you you can read fast you can read slow you can read fluently you can read with expression but I believe the most important piece is can we read

048and comprehend did we understand what we read so that we can put it into our own words or apply it in whatever way that we need to the pieces that have to be in the continuous Improvement plan the the idea was accountability the reality is it's just it's a lot of extra stuff and and a board would have to be maybe more committed and maybe less words like maybe more like granular to we're we're going to zero in on improving third grades seems to be sort of that magic grade where where kids are learning to read and then reading to learn and if they're not then the system is paying to remediate them or struggling to remediate them or passing them on without remediating them I i' I've seen it in like internet forwards and

049before we even use the word fake news fake news stuff you know it was reported in certain circles that the State of Florida was building prisons based on on um children's undiagnosed or un am I trying to say un unfixed eyesight problems it's the wrong word you I think you know what I mean uncorrected eyesight like right that they could they knew if a CH if a child couldn't see well to read well that now it's not true but it was an interesting thing it really got a lot of traction 20 years ago or so this idea that Florida was building in their state in fact if you Google it I think you can still find it as not true but that idea that you could predict who's going to go to prison by who

050can see to read or not I I still think there's something really powerful in that like and and I'm somebody that had really bad eyesight as a little kid that wasn't diagnosed by the optometrist um was the first grade teacher and then the school nurse that said you need to get him to an opthalmologist and I had the lazy eye with the the patch the whole bit but it was because the teacher saw that I don't think he can see well you know squinting at the board or whatever it was at six years old I don't know but but I think about that sometimes like where would my life be today if I hadn't have had my eyes corrected Vision corrected glasses contacts surgery like what what would I be doing today if I couldn't

051have read and learned to read and write and do math and every other thing like it is the Gateway like right yeah science is important music's important Art's important social science is important it's all important but if we can't read well we're not going to succeed in those other academic Pursuits or anything else we try to do in life the idea is accountability though and and so here the state's requiring that you have a session like this at some point where you learn and talk about literacy intervention and improvements here's what I want to say before we head toward part two you don't need to be reading Specialists to be an amazing board member in fact most your administrators don't need to be reading Specialists a few people in the system need to be reading

052Specialists what we've learned and know from the research board members need to know enough in this case about the science of reading to be able to understand when administrators come and they bring a recommendation whether it's for curriculum new books professional development whether it's budget that might be assigned to instructional coaches to improve reading or it's it's something specific that they've diagnosed and that the kids need phonics or site recognition all the different components of what it takes to read like when the administrators are talking with the board board members we need to know enough to be able to support good recommendations and to ask good questions there are three fundamental questions maybe four by the time I get done with the three but there are three fundamental questions we should ask every single time

053the administration makes a recommendation number one what does the research say research might be data what does our data suggest or what does the research say if if they were proposing a new curriculum what does the research suggest what are our peers doing what are other districts around us or districts like us across Idaho what are they doing with that particular curriculum the third one is yeah there is going to be four the the third one is how how does that apply to our setting what do we need to do in Cuna to make it successful here right just because it's working well in Melba or Meridian we're CA so what do we need to do maybe you could quote me on this but maybe not what do we need to do to cize it

054like what how do we our teachers our administrators our school school system really what is a research say about this suggestion what are our peers doing and how do we need to adjust it to fit Huna the fourth one is really probably the most powerful how will we know if it's successful I I would suggest every single recommendation that comes from Administration what does the data show us what are others doing with with this how do we need to modify it to work well in Cuna and how will we know if it's successful that's the board taking responsibility for the outcomes the accountability so in the state literacy literacy is a big broad term literacy includes all the things about reading it also includes things about writing generally and correct me if I'm wrong anybody

055in the room I think it also in includes things about speech about communication literacy is Big it's it's very big even reading by itself like I say is very big so what is it about reading if you can't pay attention to 12 different things what about reading might the board want to make sure they pay specific attention to to know that the system is improving well will that look like and that's that's questions ongoing conversations um a lot of different resources that are available again they didn't come through here but I'm going to send Deana uh just another version in case people want like the URLs to websites that were hyperlink here um we think about literacy what is literacy we've talked about that a little bit textbook definition it's the ability to identify understand

056interpret create compute and communicate using visual Audible and digital materials across disciplines and in any context the whole committee got their favorite word in mouth literacy it's huge reading itself it's a process of at the same time extracting and constructing meaning through interaction and involvement with written language and there's a reference for that that I'll get you the science of reading is a term that we've heard what the last five six years especially in Idaho especially like the last three years it's really become the last three in Idaho has been a lot about the science of reading there is literally new science about how kids read how they learn to read how they decode in their mind what the symbols mean to form not only words but ideas and Concepts and string it together to

057be able to communicate whether it's digitally audibly visually across different types of academic disciplines or situations to be able to apply what they read right that science of reading is relatively new I started to hear about it nationally maybe as far back as about eight years ago but it's it's really continued to gain some steam and support as people realize there are specific components like sight recognition of words like phonics like the fluency of being able to move across the words and the speed then with which you can move across the words that all contribute to whether a student can read well or not questions comments questions that Kevin can answer I'd love it there's essential components of reading instruction and I've been talking around some of these vocabulary comprehension we could definitely put spelling

058in the mix right the ability to spell words there's a connection there with the ability to read and understand the words like it or not phic awareness do we hear it when we hear it are we able to recognize it a lot of times we think of that more like preschool kindergarten first grade that recognition of sounds do the do the sounds then connect between what we hear and what the words actually represent um can we do this quickly with expression with inflection and with comprehension I think comprehensions again the big one do the kids have an ability to understand and gain meaning from the text does it mean anything to them or is it just words so we think about that there is this Idaho comprehensive literacy plan I have big hope that Idaho

059might ratchet this up as a bigger initiative and we call it Idaho reads and we get all in on it as a Statewide Community instead of just around the edges like but that the state sort of gets all in on reading and reading for understanding um so that we can comprehend we can grow we can develop we can improve economically and civically as a state through Reading students and adults your system needs to be able to do interventions part of the requirement again with the state with this training is that board members have some understanding that it's just not all that simple like we can't do what we've always done and expect anything to improve we've going to have to do something different that may be instructional coaches it may be professional development for staff

060it may be a different curriculum I I don't begin to pretend to know what cin needs like what would improve whatever the right number is and Kevin's going to give you that here in less than an hour probably whatever would improve from where your students are to where you really believe they could be what will move the needle on that maybe different in CA than it would be anywhere else or even in the charter schools within C like right that could could very students that don't score proficient on the fall iri it's important for board members to know they they must receive this is law this is not an option they must receive 30 to 60 hours of literacy intervention we call this tier three or tier two uh tier well it's both two and

061three can count towards it here here's the the pieces where it gets triggered right uh well this is the number percentage of students but 30 to 60 hours tier 2 or tier three so tier one is the students everyone gets that same instruction everybody gets the tier one instruction and if they're falling slightly below then they get this is about 18 to 20% of students yeah they get some supplemental instruction they just get more of what we were doing in tier one is that accurate they're just getting more provide students with more frequent that's what we call our wind T that we've talked about perfect glad you're here then tier three these are the ones that are really struggling yes and there skill gaps there where we target specific skills that they don't have yet

062this is where you have to do like a pull out or something specific right or yeah within the classroom perhaps but this is the kids that they need a lot of extra help like you said skill gaps if they're in second grade there was there were things in first grade in kindergarten that they just missed or if they came to kindergarten and they're at this level they're just not coming equipped to be successful in kindergarten this this cost you some money but money is allotted right to help with this yeah lots of money not enough do but these are requirements that that the the kids with the skill gaps are getting specific targeted to their individualized needs the tier two they're just getting more more time on task if you will and you might even

063think and talk as a system at some point what else would you need to do to move these kids up to tier one a variety of effect we're probably goingon to have to stop there Phil okay good because we need to get going but I I just want to make sure I one question for you that I hope I'm getting out of this that good governance to all of these interventions and the reading and where we want to be uh is knowing the why our why as a board and and helping our district achieve these goals and working together is that kind of what you're saying when you have that over there there a lot I try to put three hours into one you did yeah I'm just trying to sum up kind of what

064I got out of it and then I love the questions that you gave us to ask our administrators I think with I think those are really good questions that we can take a look as we go through um our evaluations of our superintendent and just questions when we have to ask about different programs so that that's kind of what I got out of it today and I don't know if anybody else has anything before we move on to Executive Board questions that you have for Phil I'm excited to see part two to see maybe more that we can do in helping our school district bring up these scores and and working together together with good government so does anybody else have anything I guess I'm just curious to see what the data is now yeah

065it's so fortuitous that you're going to see it in just a few minutes I mean that's really cool um I would love to be a resource if I you know I live about seven or eight miles from right here so um I know where most of the coffee shops are and if you don't drink coffee we can meet somewhere else um or whatever but uh any way I can be of assistance to you in the future please let thank you thank you appreciate it thank you very much and with that do I have a motion to go into executive session thank you Phil yes I can make a motion to go into executive session in aordance of Idaho code section 74 206 theard the elect to hold an executive session to consider the evaluation dismissal

066or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against the public officer employe staff member or individual agent or public school student that a second 5 Second all right call favor KY I Michael I and I for me for those of you that came thank you and we will be right back e e e of executive session and could I get you to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance all right ready begin I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice all I just have to say I'm so happy the Eagles wi yesterday okay after well after you say the Pledge of Allegiance sometimes I like go you know whatever it's like Yay Eagles

067I'm sorry Fly Eagles Fly that was my thing yesterday or I guess two days ago all right um do I have a motion to approve the agenda a motion that we approve the agenda do I have a second second all in favor Kirsty I uh Michael I JB I uh Hillary I and I'm I also all right we're going to start with some celebrations we just had a nice inservice I'll call call it in service this education part um ready to tell us about our Benchmark data see if we were even close to there's pressure now yeah no um tonight I'm going to share with you our winter bench work data comparison from beginning of the year until now but I'm only going to show you L entry tonight and then in March I'll come

068back and bring you the secondary data with the exception of Middle School some of the middle school math because they use I already as well um partly because it would have been super long it's already going to f along because there's a lot of slides but I promise I won't talk about every slide um but also so that we could then dive in a little bit deeper if you want so uh and by the way I did look up we were 74% K5 in our reading uh proficiency at the end of last year in May that's what I guessed very good I I said2 I was off by two the data I'm going to show you tonight is winter Benchmark data so it won't be quite that level yet um uh so this this gives

069you as a district where we were at in the beginning of the year in September the green represents our tier one then yellow is tier two red is tier three so that tier one are the students who at the beginning of the year were already at grade level at kindergarten first second third fourth fifth grade um yellow are those that are that are below grade level but red is two or more years below grade level kindergarten is a little bit tricky though because there's not really two years Below in right so this is where we're at at the beginning of the year anywhere from 50 to 62% in the proficient range here's where we were at in January so we've jumped uh from anywhere between 63 and 73% proficient but to give you a better

070idea just kind of done some simple calculations for you what you hope to see with this kind of data is that tier one that green you always want your biggest in increases here because that means you these are the percentage of kids that we've moved to grade level proficiency tier three which is that lowest level you always want to see a decrease there because that means there's fewer kids that are two or more below grade level the tier two in the middle is always a little bit hard to read because you have Movement Like if you move a student out of that tier three group into tier two that should be celebrated but if you move it it's even better to move them from here up to here so tier two you'll often times see

071a decrease but sometimes you see an increase and it's hard to know what's good and bad in tier two because there's movement both ways both ways but overall you can see from the beginning of the year till now second grade did not have a huge increase in their proficiency uh most of the other grades had pretty good growth wow in that time period any questions to this point on that okay so I'm going to show you now by building level I was going to have question so are those second graders did they have a slow increase in first grade so we don't know I I I mean is this something that happens to yeah that that would be that's one of those great questions we would ask at a building level like hey let's look

072at your data and what did happen let's go back to the previous year yeah um it is a really good question that's the kind of question he was talking about earlier tonight that's a great question to ask us so but we don't have any answer I don't well I can get you the answer so like in fourth grade the decrease in tier 3 is 5% but then the tier two is SE increase by 7% so yes this is 2% some of your tier one may have dropped down but then these five% moved up yeah that's what I'm talking it's kind of hard to tell if it's good or bad I mean obviously a decrease is usually a good sign unless that decrease meant they went this way so big picture data is what we're looking

073at teachers they'll look at this student by student they'll if there's a student that dropped from tier two to tier three that will be a huge red flog to that teacher okay what happened with this kid let's go find out let's look at our tier two our tier three interventions what's going on with that kid okay so now it's by school so again this was back in September and this is the state average our district average and then these are the school averages in September and then compar that to here we are in January everyone is close to that 60% or higher range couple that are below it and then I did the same thing for you so you don't have to do the maap in your head here's that increase in our tier one

074which you want to see as much increase as possible here a decrease in all of our tier three and then we see one that increased here kind of that mix in the middle again can you send us these slides what's that these weren't linked I don't think they can you send these they weren't linked but yes they were okay yeah and there's there's a lot of slides in here and I won't spend a lot of time on but I wanted you to have them because yeah you can go that way so are they all using Ice Station reading is that from and do they all are they all using the same programs or are different schools using different things to make that increase you're stealing my thunder no just kidding um yes the schools we

075currently have National Geographics reached for reading okay is our curriculum but we've also had to supplement as we talked about earlier uh science of reading the way we look at it now has evolved over the last few years and when we uh mat Geo was 2017 when it was published the version that we're using the science of reading wasn't quite there so for example hegerty is a product that all of our elementaries at least in K2 k through2 are using to help fill some of those holes in the phonics that aren't as strong in National Geographics resources okay so yes we use the same things but we've also had to supplement okay this is an interesting report that I station has started providing for us I think they took it from curriculum associ it's the

076general idea um about rate of improvement uh they've given different levels of it so a high high and moderate and low moderate is what you would expect to see so like in I ready I'll show you in just a minute we talk about typical growth I think moderate is a pretty similar comparison to that it's what you would expect to see in a year high growth High rate of improvement would be more like that stretch growth and I already calls it so a high level of rate of improvement means that they're going to more than one year is worth of growth in that year so our tier one remember these are our kids that are at grade level so we've got the expected growth you would want to see this is all overall right and

077that tier three group you got that expected growth this is kind of good news that tier 2 Group which is just slightly below grade level we've got high growth there if we're able to maintain that we would expect back at the end of the year then that we would have much higher proficiency overall um and but that kind of gives you an idea of where we're at sorry um is it what's the rate based on like what's the average based on like nationally by state like uh this is this is their normed this is normed nationally for them this is where they get it from so the moderate is that increase of 2 and eight uh I think it's scale points not percentage no it's percentile yeah but it is normed nationally normed for that

078so basically what this is telling us is that we've got we've got good growth within the year right but I remember last time we talked about this data I you asked for some historical data and I'm also preparing for um a curriculum adoption process for K5 because our National Geographic is old and outdated and it's time to renew so what I did on this one it's a little bit confusing but I'll show you kind of the trend tier one was all the on grade level tier 2 was slightly below and tier three was two or more below and this is by grade level and it's 3 years worth of where we were at this is all winter Benchmark data so this wasn't end of the year this is winter but what this shows me is

079that we're kind we're we're either trending down a little bit or up a little bit or flat we're not really seeing much movement anywhere down a little bit up a little bit mixed down a little bit so over the last three years from beginning to the end of the year we're making good growth but year over year our system hasn't improved in terms of getting more people at a higher level by the end of the year does that make sense yeah so just so I make sure I understand like blue in 2023 would be the same students as red in the next year am I right like like kindergarteners these are different kindergart but she's saying the blue goes to Red in first grade are to be the second so they oh yes this would

080be kinder then that would be okay first that would be second okay yeah good yes um but so what this tells me is even though we're getting good growth we're not moving the needle on overall Improvement as a system and so I'm excited then to have the opportunity to do a curriculum process because as was pointed out the science of reading has come a long way in the last few years and so even our curriculum um Partners out in the world they've all adjusted their curriculum to include better science of reading strategies within so we'll be going through that process and it also forces every it forces us to look at our instructional practices too because when you bring in a new curriculum resource you have to adjust your practices so I think this data

081shows that it is a good time to look at that and whatever we bring in we need to make sure that our practices lead to moving the system upward not just kids within the same year are we looking at other districts and and what they're using also and how they've improved and and not and I agree with what was said prior to this that we have to make it our own in our way but we do really makes sense to look at some of those districts that have made huge oh yes I I have yes I'm talking with several of them uh we're getting our we're getting a working group ready right now that will start to start collect some of that information and bring in the information and then we'll come you to get

082an actual adoption Committee in place so that we make sure that we have our 50% parent representation and all that on the on the adoption committee itself so that we can move forward and uh determine what's next so would it be good to have a board member on that adoption committee yeah we'd love to have one of you think about it whoever wants to learn the most about science of reading it won't be me teaching it though I understand it but to teach it and articulate it well that's why we have a reading specialist instructional coaches so I just have another question it look like um like four out of the five or or five out of the six kind of graphs there um in 2025 the tier one is lower on all but fourth

083grade do you feel like you know any I think we're just stag I think we're stagnant um you know there's been a lot of this is all postco too so you would think that that would you know things would improve but there's also I don't know there's a lot of factors I don't want to make it sound like we're just making excuses but regardless we' we're stagnant right yeah again we're making growth from beginning to end of the year which is great that's the goal but we also want to improve our system and I don't see that happening so okay let's go on to the math data uh one of the things I love about our math curriculum is that our partnership with them isn't just they sell us a product and good luck with

084it they come and meet with us regularly they meet with us three times a year they bring data to us to look at and they analyze their own data Trends and help us to know what it's saying to us and how to what how to address um our instruction with that so this is fall sorry I got the fall on the bottom fall the winter for all K8 this is by percentages so and again green is they break it into five levels instead of just three but these combin are kind of like the other graphs so we had an overall increase of 9% in our proficiency which may not sound like a lot but that's almost 700 students so sometimes percentages look good and sometimes they don't numbers of so that's why this is up

085here so you can see you know we've got this is our number of students down at the lower levels this is how many moved up in our proficiency level so again pretty solid growth from beginning to middle of the year and now this breaks it down by schools so you can see the from here I'm sorry from here to here this shows you the overall increase for each School in levels four and five which is the on grade level and this shows you numbers of students so that you can see what that percentage really talks about and then it does the same thing for our Middle School level percentages of increase from fall to winter fall to winter and then numbers of students at each of those grade levels and then essentially I have the

086same thing for you by grade level but I won't spend a lot of time on this but we'll make sure you get the slide so you can go in so this shows you each School's grade level growth so that's kindergarten oh when you notice kindergarten there's no red because there's no two grade levels below in kind first grade and you can see the increase in level four and five or grade level proficiency wow so we've got some really good growth in but it's it's not consistent necessarily across every grade level but it's pretty good growth that's third grade fourth grade fifth grade then we get into Middle School School sixth 7th and eighth grade um I want to show you this these next two graphs this is what I was talking about earlier the typical

087growth versus the stretch growth typical means they're they're going to achieve what you would expect in a year's time so this was about Midway through when we did this testing so this is the percentage of students that were at least halfway to their typical goal by then so you know a large number of our it's kind of interesting this little dip and I don't know I want to do some studying on that to figure out what that dip means why why is it so seem why does it seem so hard for our fourth and fifth graders compared to the other grines and then this is the stretch what's amazing about this um again high in here High over here these are the kiddos that are going to close whatever Gap they have in two years

088time and what I love about curriculum associates they come and they bring this data to us and they help us identify those students so that we can keep eyes on those kids and focus intentionally on them because if we can get them as stretch growth twice they're at grade level now so if they were already low but this is my favorite part um I'm not sure how familiar are with a quadrant CFT but on this axis here the ex of the Y AIS it shows growth so the higher up here you are the more growth you had and this is the median line right here on this Y axis here this is the uh performance level you have proficiency levels and your median is right here on this line so you can see our schools

089are kind of clustered right where you know median growth median sorry median growth median performance we're kind of clustered right there this was last year's winter data and now if you kind of keep your eye right there as we switch to the next graph you can see that is Shifting and it's shifting this direction which is what you want a higher growth and a higher performance level so good job CA middle schoolgy yes they're killing it um this is good news for me because this says that what we are doing is moving the system it's as long as we continue to see this movement over the next few years then what we're doing is working so that's kind of the difference between where we're at reading and where we're at math reading we're having good

090growth from uh beginning to end of the year but we're not really moving the system much in math now we're moving the system as well so that was an exciting thing to see um what questions do you have I I don't have any disne so high performance low growth is that like they already were doing well is that okay just to make sure right and then high performance low growth are students that uh they don't really need a teacher I shouldn't say it that way but yeah they're going to perform well no matter how good or bad the instruction is and then the low performance low growth they need they need they're not growing and they're not performing where they should be this is the quadrant part of the quadrant you don't want to be

091in if you just kind of draw a diagonal line through the middle here that's kind of that progression of of a of moving the system in the right direction so how do we help them move what's that how do we help them move good question um again with curriculum Associates they're helping us to focus on the right all kids are the right kids but they're helping us to focus on the kids that haven't historically moved very well so that we can give them the right interventions so that they can move I think we need to ask some questions about what CA Middle School is doing Center g& and Creek and hover we need to see kind of what they're doing we do H and see what we need to do and this is new because

092because they're a separate um group now I'm curious to see what they're doing too I don't know much about that one oneon-one help also because it's Synergy could be yeah but definitely we got to find out what's going on and I know I know a lot of what's going on here and also here I mean these schools right here and that's part of that PLC work we've been doing is we really want people we want our teams to uh work together to look at data and use it it it doesn't need to be me going to them and say Here's your data what are you going to do they should be excited to look at this data and if I'm teaching at Reed I'm going to go to Indian Creek say what did you guys

093do how did you get so much more movement than we did we moved but let's how did you move more than us I was going to say I went to K Middle School they have like an actual war room kind of like and I was really impressed with yeah I was really impressed with it I call it the War Room the data wall and I was just really impressed with what I I saw Michael was with it when we went there and it was very impressive and a lot of schools have some form of that um like at Reed they don't have a room so we have a digital data wall that it's not as effective though CU having that up and visible is a it was amazing it's a culture building thing it was

094amazing have something like that is what does Fremont have something like that I haven't seen that in three months do you guys have a big data wall we've got a digital one with the team yeah so that's the data I wanted to share with you tonight uh thank you for the good questions that's twoo I will come next month like I said with secondary data it'll be the uh shortened interim comprehensive assessments the Seas so it'll be like like the shorter version of the isets so I'll have language arts and math data for you for both of those um and then we'll talk about that too so all right sounds good thank you Kevin Mr Reno is here I think he's next right he is I jumped ahead sorry we're going to talk about graduation

095y Chevon board members welcome to graduation R so one of the key figures that we are judged on is our graduation rates um you can see we have a 10year data set here and it really shows the effects of the pandemic no kidding here's here's the pmic four years 1 2 3 42 so it's going to take a full system to come out our current four our current fifth graders are the co kindergarteners so how is that going to affect as we come on but but yeah so 90% has been our our school goal so you can see we we reached it pre pandemic and then it just fall now we're on our way back up Robbie what's the state rate the I'm coming up sorry so the state this is a state uh graph

096so the state set a goal like 86 90 92 99 95 the state goal is 95% well they came back well the state actual has been this across the state okay so this year the State Board reset goals so the goal for 2023 was 88.8 this is the new goal for last year this current graduation will be 45 then 86 by 2029 is the expected State goal to get the state average up there well yeah well I was just um in your leadership um meeting that you had and talked about attendance and you were wondering how that would affect our graduation rate so have you examined that at all like how is attendance affecting this yeah we're still analyz because it's it's because with the semester ending and that that's where we can really dig

097deep and do that um so if you if you put us against the state actual and the state goal you can see we're already we're where we're where we should be according to the state goal of course that's not good enough for us because if you look at you know an 86% that means 14% of our kids and we have 425 graduates average for the next four years that's you know 50 kids that are not going to graduate and that's we put it like that like Mr gier did the numbers you know so that's still yeah that's a great that's a 86 or 90 is great but we put in numbers of kids that's still not not good U so comparison to the state so we'll see um because the state has not come out

098could get the state number they have that published yet but then we also have to track we're tracking our fiveyear coworker so the kids that do not gra so you enter high school as a freshman you're expected to graduate in four years or we're judg on all those kids so if we have 600 kids start and they they have move to another school or if they drop out we're accountable for that if they move to another school that school then becomes accountable for it but if they drop out that counts against us as we go but then there's some kids that don't graduate on time and so those kids who come after summer grads or the next year this is where that comes in this is really promising you know right here the 92% of

099our fiveyear cohort kids get that but geds don't count towards that right correct GED counts doesn't counts against us an initial Point graduates don't count on this correct this is not initial Point any questions and this is one of the metrics on our strategic plan that we that's part part I mean High School mon that anyway but that is part of our strategic plan is to to monitor our graduation rate so you'll have these that 22 23 number this year yes it's I okay well we'll make sure it's in the slide okay there it's in the 90s so thank you Robbie can we also link this because it wasn't on the agenda all right um other reports we'll start off with a board theme um so kind of just kind of wanted you guys to

100see um one of the things I wanted to do this year as chairman of the board is to kind of have a board theme and uh our board theme is supportive learning environment what we can do as a board to support the learning environment in our district um so we have four pillars in our strategic plan and the Strategic plan is 2022 to 2027 and we we decide to do pillars we have a student learning pillar and we have little subcategories after that under that safe schools pillar organizational strength pillar and strong relationships pillar so that's what the school district as a whole has um so the reason why I wanted to come up with a board theme this year was um after doing some uh going to different schools and seeing some needs um

101I think it's important that we F Focus the board's work and board meeting on priorities for the year I think that if we had a theme it provides a road map to align resources to support our parents students teachers and community and I think it sets a vision of how the board can help the district prepare for the future kind of interesting because this kind of ties along with what we were talking about earlier here in our um in service type thing so the how so I was looking at priority areas supportive learn that support learning environment one of the things is uh as we've kind of been through I think all of us as we went out on our trips and just talking together as a board uh we know that there's some behavior

102issues in our district and some of the things that we I I think that I'm hoping the board would like to do is concentrate on Elementary provide staff professional development around behaviors in the classroom whatever we can do as a board to help our administrators our teachers our staff in the behavior issues that they're seeing especially at the elementary level then also I think um another how uh to help support would be special services educating about and supporting programs such as TLC SLC GT eer ER El Etc some of those special services um and just educating ourselves about those programs and what we can do to help then parents um and I think one of the things that we talked about and come up with is providing parent universities Pol policy engagement transparency as a

103board I think it's important that we give our parents um some ins service some things to talk about to educate um to make sure we're doing good policy engagement and bringing them in and also I think it's important as a board that we stay transparent to our parents then student well-being some of the things I think that we can do in supporting learning environment is instructional time how can we increase instructional time for our teachers and what are some things we can do to and prevention in student well-being and what kind of coping skills can we give some of our students and then I think it's really important also in supporting our learning environment we've talked about this tonight is the data educating the board on how our schools and students students are doing to

104support improve and celebrate them so that's kind of the how of what I'd like to see us as a board um focus on for this coming year and then the next one so how we would do this is by monitoring so in our board meetings we we would encourage reports on these priority areas we want to review data uh we want to monitor those budgets and resources to help with this supportive learning and environment for the year and then of course I think we want to celebrate the successes that we will be seeing in our district okay and anybody have any questions I know I sent this out to the board earlier a couple weeks ago do you guys have any questions I I just thought it would be kind of nice to have a

105theme and kind of give us a road map to see the different things that we can do as a board to help our district yeah I think um my question is what do we do like what's the next step um so like I think some some data on what the behavior issues are what kinds of things they're seeing what you know like maybe Gathering some of that information from elementary schools I yeah I think that's right on I think that that would be what we would need to do and follow up on and then also you know our we're working on the phone policy we the parent universities are in progress I think all those things are y so I just and then the policy engagement all those things are kind progress I think it

106really gives us the why the vision and the mission can I say that that we learned tonight um and it lines up with a strategic plan that our school district has also so yeah those are that's exactly what I think we'd be looking at those are things that we need to look at it kind of gives us a a place to start any other questions anything from the administrators or well good we'll just move right on then okay thanks Kim yeah update from parent University and I know um trusty L you were able to go to that would you like to give us a small report on how that went with the parents and what went on uh sure I mean just from my perspective um I know there was one previous to this one

107right and this so this is the second one but um I was only able to attend this one and I thought it was well done I enjoyed the idea of having the panel of people to talk and then um it was really it was really great to be able to have there were QR codes on the tables that if you thought of questions um throughout the evening you could submit those questions and they were they were responded to that evening so it was kind of a good feedback in a real time situation I thought there was good interaction I think you know there were there's lots of strong feelings about all these um issues going on but I thought that everyone was pretty respectful in being able to present what their thoughts and feelings were

108from all the sides and um at least that was my so what was the overall questions that the parents had like what was the most I I if you could say that we're that the community is looking at I think that the community many of the parents there were parents of children within the TLC and and err um type programs um but then there were some parents there that were that were there not um that were not they were just like general education I don't know what you call it but yeah um anyway so they were communicating with one another and trying to balance the needs of all students and I think that that's the main concern that was happening and so good conversation so I thought I think good conversation to be able to

109understand how things are from other perspectives and kind of some of the needs that need to be met on for for different types of students within the program or within the school system I think the main frustration that I think came out from some of the parents was just that um there's a lot of disruption in the classroom from behaviors and and I don't think that that's all from from students that are in you know TLC or ER that's behaviors like we've talked about throughout the throughout the school system and and what came out was really it's it's elementary schools it's the middle school and high school students I mean at least what was represented to me at this University parent University was that it's really just was the the disruptions are in elementary school

110and so large class sizes are a big problem that Al that came out for sure we need to I think that's an issue that needs Focus um but yeah that's kind of the I don't have the solutions but those were those conversations were certainly good and I think it kind of helped people feel like they had a forum for coming and and handling a frustration um and answering getting their questions answered so well thank a big thank you to the administration for putting that together and uh Kevin and U I felt bad I was sick that night oh you were yes sois thank did a great Kelly thank you to so and do we have another one already scheduled that's what I was good we don't have it scheduled yet but we're that's one of

111my next projects to get that next one going do you have feedback for us you would like it to be on um if you have ideas I'd love to hear them we can bring some ideas to you too if you yeah bring us some ideas let me think on that yeah um okay uh last meeting we talked about some committees but I would like to report on some um board Liaisons and um kind of have talked to these board members um and so when I say Liaisons it's not a committee a group of people but it's the board members um being kind of liaison to that group and being able to report back to us if something is coming up and kind of give us more information so um with the city and mitigation and

112whatever goes on with the city um JD Grant and Michael Thorton have stepped up and said they would kind of like to to work with that and to work with them to also work with Tim and Jason and and working with some of that so that um we can see how that looks then uh policy Hillary uh loves policy so I'm like you go girl can I can oh sure sure sure can I talk about our um oh we're trying to be unified with the city and development and all that I just want to make sure um that we're all on the same page as far as that goes I mean we've been working with them for a long time and I feel like we have swung the pendulum a little bit um to help

113the education our community I feel like the city has compared to other cities the city has helped us quite a bit and um the tone has changed a little bit but um I mean with Danielle not doing that job anymore I think uh Tim is mainly responsible for that now is that right Tim and Jason okay okay so um just so that would talk about that I mean we were asking for some mitigation fees when there's developers coming so um I know in the past um they had the pre-planning meeting the Planning and Zoning meeting the city council meeting it's a lot of meetings for you guys to go to um I mean is that consistent the pre-planning meeting and the planning zoning meeting they have it every month or did they have it every

114week they have it every week okay so and we we go cuz we're mainly tied in with obviously kuna and Meridian are the two main ones that we have and like we just got an application that is in our boundaries that's from Ada County and so when that one processes through we'll you know as those meetings start we'll have to attend you know with Ada County but I've been to meetings in calwell for Canyon County and so it just it's it's all over but Cuna and M are the most two consistent CA has a meeting every Tuesday alternating city council one week planning zoning Rian has a meeting every Tuesday and Thursday um city council and planning zoning going back forth and so we just have to watch those agendas and if there are developments

115that are in our boundaries then you know we have to go make a presence at at those meetings so we appreciate the efforts that you guys made I know L's made a lot of um those meetings as well um one thing that I know that we talked about before is just making sure I mean every time correct me if anyone has any different opinion about this but whenever there's a development that's in our school district um it is going to feed into one it's going to feed into one school that's at capacity either high school elementary or Elementary or middle school so our I mean our thought process or or ask when we go to the developers is like if you develop this is going to affect this is going to affect us and we

116need some help um and so that's what we're asking them for do we we do have kind of a platform for those mitigation fees that we can ask for um I think I just hope we don't sell ourselves short um with with some of these big companies that come out here and um ask for a little bit more I mean it doesn't ever hurt to ask but I just want to make sure as a board we're all on that same page that that's what that's the process that we're taking and that's what we want to have happen I I I think that is and I think it's good that you're on it because you've been on it or you understand the history of when we started this and I think with Michael too it will

117help um with that I know uh Tim I talked with Tim a little bit about the difference between C Meridian which is something I think is a something that you guys will have to probably pick up on meridian's not quite they haven't swung the pendulum no right so there's they're not going they fight back they're not going but we're not going to quit either yeah so that I I think that's something that you need to probably work on too but definitely uh we've been here and and we know that um we need something we're growing and there's not a lot of money coming in so and I know one thing we talked about is land as far as like how many acres is okay to say yes and how many acres is okay to say

118no and making sure that we stick with that too so I think we said we want to see every request and take it individually right based on like the needs yeah and where it's at I know they to do the feeds into's infrastructure for that anyway I I didn't hear what you said I'm sorry there's an apartment complex that they're trying to do and that's I think it's important we know where our schools are at too and what what it feeds into and that number and um and I'm I'm happy that we've got two board members that will help take some time to to look into that more so if if you guys need any help or um please reach out to me okay I'd love to help as much as I can thank appreciate

119it we will we will do that we have been stewing on a few questions that we could probably use your guidance and some um you know where we want to go as a board yeah and I think just helping clarify things sometimes for the community it can be confusing um so making sure that we always have a letter in the packet too because sometimes we don't yeah that's been an issue and if we don't have a letter then the city is confused as to why we we don't have a letter in the packet I know I have I we have some patrons that sometimes like get after me because so we'll go to a developer and we'll say hey we we can't support this development and then they give us the mitigation fees per unit

120that we've asked and we're like okay we can support this development so I mean it we're caught between a rock and a hard that's the wishy-washy place that's what I was going to ask cuz that's what I hear the most too like what is how do we handle that how are you handling that I think I think we all have to I mean we can't completely stop growth and development that hurts us in our our local local economy a little bit too I mean we have to have a little bit of growth to sustain our economy and then you get back to some legal ramifications too about if you completely stop growth and development then people that are selling the properties do have a leg stand on as far as that goes as well so

121so I I I like the way that we're doing this I know when people don't see the big picture that they don't agree with with it but um I mean I don't I don't want to see a big boom and all in that unless they're helping the schools in education so do you think it's just it's not that we don't support the growth and development it's that we we are asking for them to partner so it's not that we are a no and then we get money and then we're a yes it's just that we are we're asking for their support you know as part of the community it's not that we're changing our mind it's just that we know we can't stop the growth and development based on private property rights and all sorts

122of laws but but we're asking them to be a partner so it's not really a flip flop it's what I kind of feel like well I had a commun Community member come to me with that same scenario and I had to think about it for a while but if I'm on the school board who am I representing I'm representing the school and the kids and I get it that there's some you know kind of a fine line somewhere sometimes but if that's what I'm representing representing then that's who I want to make sure it's a piece and I guess that's one way I looked at it um because I could understand what they were saying it is a fine line between well we're granting this one but we're not graning this one or whatever but

123if I'm a member of the school board I'm here to represent kids and what we can do to help kids in our community and I guess that's the way I look at it JD yeah I like what yeah um try loow said it's it's a partnership it's a partnership they're going to partnership and help us with the education of the kids in our community then we can you know partner with them as well yeah well we do I mean it really benef we we represent the kids and the students but we also represent those that are paying taxes and it is beneficial really for taxpayers and those that we're going to go ask money you know of later for bonds it helps us it helps offset so so it's really beneficial to all the people

124that were representing yeah definitely well thank you thank you for uh those words and then Hillary uh has agreed to kind of be our liaison uh with Brian on any policy that we have so if there have community members who have questions or whatever um of course they can go to any but um Hillary would kind of be the person who would kind of fall through with that so um any questions about that I just wanted to say that since this we switched from having like a policy meeting I still feel like we're getting a lot of good Community involvement for the policy I don't know if you feel like that um Brian but yeah sh lots of emails I think we've all received and and I think we're people are are seeing those policies

125that we're reviewing and and engaging with us on it they have a really good opportunity to do that and so I feel like it actually has been beneficial to open it up to more than just a few people yeah I think the biggest feedback I think chairman Nixon gave it to me as well and you've said it multiple times can we just link everything we're like we do PDFs but it's time for us probably to get out of the 80s and and look at some kind of program be nice to link some of those policies with I think we should look at that seriously because I think people would be able to navigate our our policies so much easier yeah I agree I know it would be a lot less frustrating for people looking for

126something or trying to find you know what the laws are compared to the policy and imagine that time that thean can SP with her family insteading up Poli yes pH all right um let's move right along um CFO Brad stman is going to talk to us about Levy timing and a date to the board okay so this is a quick informational slide I'll share with you so we we thought it would be a great idea to remind ourselves on the timing of Levy funds and when they're coming in and when we need to plan uh for making sure we don't have an interruption in our Le Le fund supplemental levies and for planning for Capital planning committee having Bond Levy money as well so the first one is the emergency Levy that happened last year

127where it was certified and we're having funds that get us through calendar year 2025 along with the general fund now for calendar year 26 and 27 that's where the supplemental Levy comes in that was voted for last November and then it will be certified this year so that Jason wants to know it'll cover us now through the end of 202 7 calendar year now to ensure we don't have a break we need to plan for the next supplemental Levy which you would Jason and team would want to we'd want to push for that by the end of next calendar year or beginning of 2027 at the latest so that it gets certified in 27 and then you would have no break and funding at the end of calendar 27 you would then have another two

128years of calendar 28 and 29 that take us through 29 so that you don't have a break now you you may notice there's calendar there's a timing difference between when you get the funds as the calendar year versus the school year when when you budget for fiscal year is a little bit early so that timing difference we plan for that by getting through that through the using the general fund in the inter term just like we're doing this year and then it catches up in in the end so we would budget the expenses ahead and then you have the funds come in and on at the very end on the back end you're you're whole again but the key there would be not to do what we've done the last few years where you have

129a break in funding and then you you dip more into the general fund luckily we had a sufficient general fund now if you do that too many times then you don't have a general fund to get you through and that's why it's important to not have a break in the supplemental funding and also with the unknown of state and federal funding in the future and then the last one Bond Levy vote we would want to have even prior to the next supplemental Levy vote if we wanted to have facilities because because you wouldn't start getting that money to start building for for two years from now um and then it takes time to build and you wouldn't be able to enjoy the new facilities or updated facilities until 5 years from now so if you

130delay that one year then you're now under 2031 and we know that that failed a couple years ago so that's already put us a couple years behind and we we were just talking about growth and needing to have those so it's just a reminder on that as we plan to make sure that we've we don't have a break in funing that puts us in trouble that makes us you know need to let go of teachers or not have the funding for our facilities and and then it helps with the capital planning committee so this is informational only so now at this point you uh Capital planning committee just decides what to do going forward I didn't realize that um our vote November of 2024 we don't get the money till January of 2026 and January

1312020 so that's the difference too between the May and November vote because the certification is in September and it delays you that much further on each of these I didn't realize that live and learn that's that's that's the tradeoff so many but that's why knowing this we can plan ahead a little bit better to make sure we don't have gaps well it's only planning ahead it's hopefully getting the people to but yeah and then every the community can understand how important this is so well I think it's just important always when we're talking about a levy that everyone Rec recognizes that a levy is for our operating expenses and it's for the curriculum and teachers and things like that everything we're operating and it's not for schools and that's something that I see pretty frequently

132mistaken so I just want to make sure that we say that all the time and the bond is would be for new facilities and improvements that be a broken record yeah well I just think it shows how much we're underfunded because we have to keep going for levies that's the other thing to mention is that this is the system in place in our state for funding schools and so this isn't a the fault of Cuna or that we're overspending it is the funding mechanism for schools districts yeah it's been like that for a long time it was only recently where we had a little break yeah and now we need to get back to back right that was the nice thing that Co did for us it gave us a lot some monies that we

133didn't have so if you could say something nice about that thank you thank you thanks I guess where are we at on the B the capital planning that's what we're going to talk about yeah um so Capital planning committee I um talked with Kim bead all before she went on her wonderful cruise and what we want to do is we want to make sure that people understand that we are right now in the process of putting together that committee so we can start as soon as possible so we are looking for people that would like to serve on it and anybody that you know that would like to serve on it also I know we're going to need one or two board members on that correct on the capital planning improve I don't know is

134there a policy requirement for the number or is it just I think it's I think it's important that we have at least one if not two absolutely so um and so basically we want to make sure that anybody that wants to be a part of that planning um need to talk with Jason and Allison um it it's important because we as a school board need to know what the community wants and what they're thinking and uh taking to look at that so uh we need to start that right now and so hopefully I think next month you're going to be hopefully putting that together I I have the email ready to go I just didn't want to get that's what I want to how many people do you want on that committee roughly you know

135as many as we can get honestly I think the more feedback the more voice we have the better decision we're going to make like community members I know when I was on it like the mayor yeah um counil we have a pretty good list um we Allison put together a survey uh back in I think early August asking for um community members that were interested in serving um obviously you guys helped us make the decision to kind of shift the focus of that Capital Planning Group to see if those folks wanted to help with the levy and we did that so we still have that same list of of people um that expressed interest we also have previous um names that were on the capital planning uh that we did what was that night finished

136in 2020 I think 2019 is it that long ago no we had we just had one not too long ago one with the bond before the bond that went down yeah a couple years ago was right when David it's going to say a couple years ago can we can we as board members um what if we all find at least one or two people each of us ask if they'll be on that Capital planning committee that would be amazing I know I I sent him one I got one from you today sent him one I think that's a great idea and then I just want to open it up anybody listening anybody here uh this is your time to step up and help our community um take a look at where we need to go

137and how we need to do that yeah so I think it's important okay any other comments or questions all right do we have any patrons who have signed up to address the board tonight no all right let's all right CFO stemman you're up again on the update on the appraisal for thanks guys for coming tonight thank you okay so this is another informational slide where there no action is needed but few months ago you approved to get an appraisal for the Fourth Street location the gym and other buildings and the company uh was able to give us an appraisal and they they did two different approaches a cost compar or a cost replacement and a sales comparison approach they recommended the latter the sales comparison they're both pretty similar if you round up and down

138about 1.7 million in here if you wanted to get into a lot of details of 63 page appraisal but what they did uh was come up with the price per square foot and and came up with the price now uh again this is informational you you use this at this point with the capital planning committee to decide do we continue to use it for what we use it now do we make adjustments do we sell it and use the funds Elsewhere for the district that's that's really the next steps the the next slide I'll just show very briefly just shows how they came up with the the 1.7 using the sales method they just do simply what you always do in real estate right you compared with the comparables of the other commercial properties they

139surveyed real estate professionals what they thought it might be per square foot and they came up with with the amount here um the the actual value of the land is 600,000 that's within the total 1.7 million uh in either method it's also within the cost approach I won't go over it here but if you wanted to in the appendix you could see how they came up with the the cost replacement approach um and then then one other piece of information is just right here just saying if you demolish all the buildings wiped them out what's the value of the land because you would have to pay to to for the demolition costs you'd only get about half a million being able to sell it at that point so selling it as is would make more

140sense because it's a one point it's worth 1.2 million more leaving as is a 1.7 U but now at this point you just decide what's the value to to the district is it is better to keep it for what we use it for or should we sell that's the next steps so this is just informational only just to give you an update on the appraisal you can dig into the details and the appendix and the actual appraisal itself any questions do we know how much we were leasing it out to Boys and Girls Club when they were in there boys and girls CL was think was not pain they W they weren't paying anything partnership okay they paid for the custodian um okay so the lights already that was they helped paint it I think

141didn't they they did they did some upkeep outside they did some upkeep inside but they and have we had some interest in purchasing any formal interest like people saying how she put the word formal how do you I just have heard about it and sent them your way any that I have heard yeah we've G tours we've talked different people do we know do you know do we know how much like utilities cost just a monthly cost breakdown what we have to pay to turn the lights on and remember we still use it as a warehouse we still use it as office space yeah um we do some use rental absolutely it's a so that we would have to if we sold we would have to find a solution for a warehouse solution for storage

142solution for our Sports renting out to eight offices there are yeah we use it a little bit for rental we use it for overflow um does the Middle School still use the gym for practice at all uh they with the decrease of c teams um we just we don't use it as much I know Indian Creek will use it as an auditorium a little bit um Ross hasn't come back to using it yet um but Indian Creek has returned to use it as an auditorium okay and this is just one appraisal you could also decide just like like a doctor maybe want a second opinion or there's supposedly a historical appraisal that the city really would like us to do um the city would really like to control who who buys and who we sell

143to do I think they can buy it they offer to buy it they offer partnership again that partnership we're partnering if if somebody comes to rent it like are we because I know there's like there's a roller derby Club in there there's lacrosse they have all that stuff our soccer soccer team uses it quite a bit for indoor stuff our our high school soccer team does lacrosse uses it absolutely so it's being used as a gym then somewh City uses it for like the Down Home Country Christmas there's another event that do there the breakfast whatever that is oh okay prayer breakfast well they they had that at the church this last time instead of down there so like how much how much are we charging like for the these clubs that are coming in

144there right now we probably should like we do have a policy in place for charging so we should yeah and it'll and and then I know that with youve you've got some suggestions so it'll come back in May for some an some amendments to um again that that's like I feel like that's a pretty commonly updated um that that gym is charged like the same as we charged Crimson Point same that we charge read now that it has an actual the Kevin gford not Memorial floor because we don't want to stay memoral but it's not really covering much of the cost yeah we don't rent it the same as we do like the middle schools or high schools because you don't have the scoreboard you don't have the speakers you don't have the bleach your

145capacity like but it's it's charged the same as Crimson Silver Trail and Reed and then what's do we know at all like what the future costs that are going to be needed because like I noticed somewhere on here that it's not in great shape it needs it needs a really good bathroom renovation if we truly we it probably should be sooner than later um and there really is no ba I mean there's just a one male and one female bathroom but it's maybe two toilets each so it's a really small bathroom capacity for like if you were to truly have an event there of 100 people the it' be the bathroom really needs some work the HVAC got some work the ceiling got some work um and is all of that factored into what the

146sales appraisal is like the future work that needs to be done like for someone also to take it over like is it they're going to have to bring some stuff up to code right fire sprinkler and so is that kind of factored in this sales yeah and my question to him that's what he hinted at that included into it okay but um good financial analysis would be what you're saying is what would it be to make continue to maintain this and if you sell it sooner and you get more out of it yeah that's what I'm kind of wondering is like if we're headed down the road of like needing to put a lot of money into it like what's the what's the analysis I guess yeah but maybe the next step was that number

147low to you guys or is that high or about what you thought it would be I had no idea to be honest with you I thought it was high it seems I as how old it is and how much work it's going to need for somebody just trying to think of what a what a potential buyer would use it for and and what their like return on that purchase would be and what the investment will be to bring it to code so that's why it seemed High to me but I I mean my opinion really is not educated so I don't know I know we have we have someone in the community right now that just um took over the force club and they they would like to rent it I I don't know what

148that would look like we can we maybe get some answers like how much it costs us to upkeep and run like utilities just on a monthly basis what what is the cost to the district to just have it and then I guess also helpful to know like what a plan would be to relocate those things that are going to like do we have resources within the district to relocate that or not you know where would we put Tech where would we put the warehouse where would we put storage maybe a good brainstorm on that well the kids don't have a place to practice sure that with that one less gym what would be our plan for yeah I think I think I mean my two senses I think some type of rental option that covers

149the fees as long as we can still be able to have it from our three to five so that our kids can use it when we need it right okay all right okay any other questions or concerns or comments all right let's move on to new business uh March regular meeting um trusty low won't be able to attend our meeting March 11th and so she um is asking if we can move it to the first Tuesday which is March 4th 2025 uh did you want to say anything else about um I may be able to join remotely but I just thought if if it was POS possible with everyone's schedule I would just throw it out there to see if that would some be something everyone can accommodate and I did talk with Phil um

150and I and he's willing he can't come March 4th if we change it to that he's got a conference but he will come in April so we don't have to worry about not having our second um in service so I I I personally don't have have a problem with it I just don't know if it sets a precedent that you know I don't want everyone to think every time they can't come that sure myself included that hey can we change the the date that's my my only issue but I personally don't have a problem with changing it and I would love I think you're an important piece and I'd like to have you here so that that's my only concern so anybody else I don't have a problem with you yeah do I have a

151motion then I'd rather not I can make the motion but I'll make a motion that we change the meeting from March 11th to March 4th okay do I have a second a second okay and in favor um Kirsty hi Michael hi JD hi Hillary hi and I and I okay so that passes all right second reading of policy and for superintendent grade to go through that with us and just real fast CFO 7 didn't leave angry his son gets his um Miss Mission column I'm sure you can relate to that yeah he said we had to be down to eight and we said his part's down snuck out we totally understand yes um just remember when a policy from first read secretary changes significantly I bring it back so you guys get opportunity and I

152promise my the nurses that I meet with won't do this every time they got really excited and they felt like this part policy was too wordy so they came back with significant changes so that's why it's here um they really just shortened it and condensed it um they stole a lot of it from valview school district of how they shortened it and took some things out but that's why it came back in for secondly do I have any um do I have a motion I'll make a motion that we accept um policy 990 bloodborne pathogens okay Dar a second second do I have any um discussion all right uh Kirsty hi Michael hi JD hi Hillary hi and I'm an I also so all right and now we are on amending the following yeah so

153these are there's we group these policies into four different categories for you um this is just first read so there's two Amendment ones and we just put the cell phone one at the bottom we fig out the most disced I just have one on 678 and it's just wording um like there's a change um already from this to the in um on number five and so I figured it would be good to do that also on 12 and 13 and I I had a I had a statement um to make it not a change on the same one on the same one 678 but just to make it more organized uh if you take a look at um some of the the numbers they talk about religion and religion and then they add something else

154into it then they go back to religion I'd like to see all of them kind of organized yeah in the same yeah um which is not a change but just that organization so it makes it easier for our patrons to to follow follow along mhm I was slow at the pencil you said this to the um what well so it changed it on on5 and then but the same wording should be used on 12 and 13 from this to the the district instead of this District do you guys want this one to come back as a standal in second or you're make those changes for well I think if we're going to combine a bunch of them we should see it again okay yeah I don't know if combining it she just said reorder reordering

155it it's not com just be reordering it put all the release time ones together all right and why they're releasing just kind of organize it a little bit better in the numbers so yeah that makes sense I also I had a question with policy 504 or 502 sorry yeah it's one of those that her number is different than our number so there's two yeah so sorry um so the student publication one and I I kind of went over this with you if you take a look at that I don't know bringing that out there's a portion where it tells you what what it can't like what it can't have for a student material and then what it can have for advertisement right and um I'll let you explain it first Jer nion just wanted to

156why there's some that are repeated like obscene your advertisement can't be obscene and your student article couldn't be obscene but there's some that it just seems like all of those um stipulations should be if you scroll down should be used for both so this list of what you can't do isn't exactly the same as the list on number three number three so and then three has one that number two doesn't which I'm like going okay what's the difference what student Publications do we have uh we used to have student newspapers right now currently none of our schools do anymore um we do have an advertising policy too they all have a yearbook so the yearbook there are advertisements in the yearbook so this now like if Kevin wanted to advertise for his um Painting Company

157he could he couldn't do it if it was SE try to refrain do your best yeah I just kind of that way you don't choose Kevin's painting company over Robbie's painting company and you've got a reason why because of the scene but we could what my suggestion was I'll take these combine them with what is Missy from one and I'll do the same and then I'll run it by our because right now student Publications not it's a dinosaur we do have yearbooks and at the high school we do have some social media that's run by students so we kind of said that's the new version of the student newspaper well yeah and let's say Middle School decides they want to do a newspaper sometime or whatever then we have the policy to go with it

158absolutely but I I can easily so we'll combine those I'll run them by the principles and then I'll bring it back and I like that idea so I think that'd be great and then um the other one was policy hold on here with the principal which one was the principal 308 thank you thank you so much policy 308 um there was one that I wanted you to take a look at and uh change some wording and I think I gave that to you Brian you asked about the Charlotte Danielson training um no it was hold on I wrote it in my other notebook um go back up go back up sorry it had to do keep going up the second sentence on the first paragraph thank you s I had I don't know I just

159that one didn't read right to me there's like Miss of their assigned School management of of their sign school or something but I'm not the language arts the second sentence of what of the first paragraph the first see did not read right to so it says principles are the chief administrator at each School whose primary responsibility is to supervise the operation and management their assigned school second sentence and what do you want to change about it second line starts yeah starts on the second line principles just it didn't read right to me show you of there sign school that's all that what you're talking about I think it looks good now I can't find out where it was I think it looks like it's been changed so I'm happy with the way it is so

160on that end so and I think that was my only questions and changes well amendments a we put Amendment B on the bottom all right do I have is there any other not on this section anything else on this section that you'd like to take a look at do I have a motion to accept um the first reading of I guess I can say 202 308 310 47.5 410 47502 and 678 I still move okay and is there any other discussion K hi Michael hi uh JD hi Hillary hi and I'm I okay the next group is a group of removals I know I think there's six oh I'm sorry adopt first I have a few things um via some feedback from the community and that I also agree with in 39.1 um it's got

161a the pupil Personnel is defined but then never used within the policy so I don't know if that was in intended um to maybe replace some of the yeah like where it says principal school counselor and like design or if we just need to remove the pupil Personnel it said counselors it would be first so this was a change that we made because it it called counselor and then counselor was listed as part of the as one of the many like so then we thought it was better as people Personnel but I think later it kept repeating counselors so maybe we didn't replace where they said counsel should because it it lumped social worker all in and we're like ah counselor isn't really a social worker so maybe we just need to replace all those

162designations personel thank you so we we fixed one but not fixed all would that be a reason because they refer to it as school counselor but they listed like four different jobs that would that be an okay to switch it out so then just to yeah yeah um I did under the exceptions um to disclosure to parents it talks about um a violation it's it's except when there's a VI violation of professional code of ethics and I wonder if we can um refer to what those code of ethics would be because it just kind of like what code of ethics are we talking about it's kind of like a ABC or like give a bulleted list of like some examples cuz I think it's just a little too open-ended for that exception to defining code

163of ethics yeah like what code of ethics are we talking about so if there's a specific professional code of ethics then we can reference it there or otherwise we can just list that out okay okay um I don't know specifically what they're talking about when they say professional code of ethics I it just makes it easier if parents reading it they know how have to try to go yeah I I'm sure we have it somewhere but it's not linked yeah or um and what that means I mean I agree yeah code of ethics everyone it'll be super easy to to B that out okay and then if everybody's ready to move on yeah okay 6393 sorry Brian I can wait no you're to fine okay um 6 39.3 it talks about um a member of

164the school will always accompany um a parent visiting a classroom and I think it might be nicer to like it's right there where it says will always accompany visitors I think it could change to May because I just think like if a parent is a if they if we've got a comfort level if an administrator or something has a comfort level with a parent then maybe they don't always need to just be sitting there with them if they want to visit lots of classrooms then maybe they don't need to be with them the entire time maybe they can come and introduce them in the class and then leave them at the you know yeah the only thing I see I hav played devil's advocate here the only thing I see is if a teacher says

165the parent did this and there's not that third person in there or if the parent says the teacher did this and there's not that third person in there um that's the only thing I see that it would be nice to have it doesn't have to be an administrator maybe but just somebody to make sure that whatever is occurring is there's a third person there to make sure that that's what's happening that's the only reason I'm playing Devil's Advocate that I would like to have it as is instead of I mean there's probably a whole classroom of students as well so you can't rely on the student and that has happened where there has been a parent in there and they said that something happened and it and the teacher said that didn't happen and then

166I don't want to bring the kids into it I guess is the thing is because you're going to have kids say yeah no yeah I I just like the idea of having that parent but that's just I mean um I think it's a safety issue for everybody including us as a school board well and I do think that the this particular policy is as a result of some legislation that wanted to make it feel like parents were invited to the classroom and and in my opinion this policy just doesn't do that I don't think it fits the intent of the law and so I thought that this would loosen that up just a little bit um and leave it up to the administrator in their comfort level um that's just my thought um another part

167um is in number four um on the classroom visit procedures let's see maybe that's not where it's at once clear by the background check proced there something um I just feel like maybe there isn't a pre- meeting necessarily involved or necessary because I think if a parent wants to visit a class it may be just because they are curious about their student you know what their students's learning about or or the environment of the classroom or for any reason and I don't necessarily think that we need a pre meeting to talk about maybe not necessarily only just a problem that they're coming for so does the teacher need to have a meeting prior to I think that that's also a barrier to you know opening the classroom to parents and I think we need to

168try to do that is that number where you it's number four one one's cleared by the background chair oh preet with parent teacher yeah read on himim speaking comprehension go you can say pre meet with parent or teacher or just like an an email to make sure that the teacher the parent knows the expectations of the classroom like it does do we need a schedule like I think we're just making a visit to the classroom a big deal yeah where I think maybe it just shouldn't be such a big deal well I wish things were like it used to be like people would just Dro in say I'd like to go visit a classroom but things have changed so much um I you know the pre-meet is kind of nice just to set up so

169the teacher understands maybe what you're coming to look for but I don't think that has to be in a meeting that could be like an email or an email or a phone call I I I don't think that's a problem I just like to see it simplified to an email or a phone call or something another way to yeah or if they want to meet I I mean yeah pre meet via email or phone or if they want to come in I mean it depends on the parent and the teacher want me via phone call or email or meeting yeah if the administ text parents Square yeah ex par Square Works square square yeah um in number six there's kind of some verbage here that says can we also provide some tips about curious kids

170I don't know is that part supposed to be part of the policy or is that somebody's questions that got added as policy my experience has been kids always want to ask me questions especially when it's their friend's mom I that doesn't seem like policy LED with me so I think we could probably delete that all I don't any problem with I mean I think that they're just trying to set out as uh from the classroom if you come in you know when teach when parents come in I don't care how many times I've taught or administrators it's disruptive and everybody goes you know and then you have to and then well we've been there as we've gone into some of the classrooms what are they here for how come you're here what's going on and

171I I don't think that's the whole purpose of why you're going and so I think they're just trying to set that up um so that you would understand that there may be some Curious Kids but I guess it shouldn't be a question if it's a policy so I guess no say what we're going to do yes so you know we can provide tips of what it would look like maybe for parents going in and then again number seven I just feel like we don't necessarily need that second adult to support the visitor I think expectations for the visitors should be made clear like they're not to interrupt they need to not interrup engage with the teacher or the students they're there as a silent Observer and then we I guess I don't to me it's

172a safety issue so my and I'm playing Devil's Advocate it's a safety issue as in like I want to make sure that whatever happens happens and that people don't feel like this happened and then we get into more issues um and I who that person is I don't think it has yeah just another staff member just someone to be in there and once they get in there if things are going fine then I think that's okay that's not what it says though they said that it has to be there with them the entire time well and I believe administrated and staff already have enough stuff going on that they don't need to it feel like addition parent it I don't see where it says they have to be in there the whole time well it

173says up above and so this is just in up above where it says it will anation just sitting in the classroom and taking notes I've done it before an administrator did not sit with me and I sat in the classroom quietly and I just wrote down what I was observing I didn't interact with anyone I didn't talk to the teacher I didn't with the kids like I just sat there and did what I supposed to and moved on like parents should be just trusted to do the observation and move on well we're background checking um we're having we're we're setting out the expectations I feel like and that's putting a lot on a staff member administrators have to observe when a parent wants to go into a classroom do you want me to bring feedback

174from the administrators I'd like to hear what the I I know as a teacher sometimes I always like to have I would just think it'd be a safety issue I can come back with their feedback yeah I I don't have a problem I'm just kind of Playing devil's advocate to make sure that we don't find ourselves in the issue someday well we have well they're following protocol there's already protocol set up the parent is already following it I mean I did all protocol I followed it and did I was supposed to yeah I think when we I think this did we change this a couple years ago just recently actually yeah Bas and and after a little bit of time and looking through it I feel like it's it doesn't really support what the intention

175of the code that was or the the legislature that was or the legislative what whatever you call it the Pol or the law that was put into place yeah and we're bringing remember this was the movement of trying to bring our procedures yeah into policy that's so we there was no changes to this it just went from that the handbook basically to to policy policy that's why it's got trusty low loves the point ones and the point tws and that's weird number well I guess I'm just curious why that would offend a parent if there was a third person in there I don't think it's offensive I just think that it's un it is difficult it makes it more difficult for scheduling it makes it more difficult to to allow a parent to just be

176in there and observe kind of makes a big deal out of a parent being there like they're being watched where really a parent just wants to come and be a part of the classroom and I think we want to have that feeling of of an open invitation for I totally agree with that and not the feeling I think happening right now you don't trust them in the classroom well it's because it it's because it disrupts education I mean I don't I don't think we need to have an open invitation for just anyone go watch a classroom I don't think that's a good idea in the Idaho code 3361 I I guess what I'd like to hear is what the administrators teachers feel about it and see what they think um that's my personal feeling yeah

177I can come back with that feedback so and we'll leave at that the suggestion or I'm not trying to be mean to the parent I I'm trying to be as transparent as possible but I want to keep them safe along with the teacher and to me it's a safety issue cuz I understand what could possibly happen and what's happened in and that's why the system of you guys having a first second three we've got the time I can totally bring that back and we can and I guess I just feel like the overall feel of the policy should be in keeping with that Idaho code and then also just to make it feel like we aren't hiding anything and that we're being very transparent not trying to keep parents out of the classroom feel and

178that's not the way it reads to me so see to me it reads like it's okay I mean I'm not asking parents not to go in and be transparent it's just part of the policy to go in and make everybody safe that's the way I look at it but I I'd like to hear what they have to say Okay anything else on this policy did you have another one Hillary um not on this section okay so um do I have so we're going to take 69 one and3 and I'll come back and those will be this we're just going to take that one out second read part and I'll give you guys point four will go it might affect the point four based on what happens okay okay so how do we want to say

179this do we want to wait and put I would make a motion that we make some revisions to this and bring it back for new business again at the next me first or second reading first first first stay first for both of them for 6391 6393 and 6394 okay okay so that is our motion do I have a second all right we'll start with kiry Michael I and Hillary and I'm an i okay and then removal of the following policies I get it super excited for the removal I know let's just go do we have a motion I'll make a motion to remove 20 7 417 453 471 472 473 477 478 and 480 do I have a second second any discussion no all right and thank you Hillary hi and JD and Michael and

180kiry I'm and I also all right and now for the student use of personal communication devices policy 518 take notes you're going to want to click on it right work and I think um trusty L you had a concern um well I have a few details um I guess I think that where it says under elementary schools I think that well I guess I think that the um let's start with consequence quences and go backward I guess if we if that's okay um I think the consequences for the violations at the elementary middle and high school should be the same I don't I don't care for the um the word confiscation of the device and in elementary or middle and I think that that we should use the same process of of um what that

181what it states in the high school as taking the student with the device to the front office putting it in an envelope you know so that it's so that there's no um I guess question about who broke the screen on the phone or a loss of the phone or or device or somebody lost my I airpods or whatever I think it's just is a protection for both it seems like a like what you see on the cops shows is a chain of evidence and so I think that protects everyone it protects the teacher from accusations I think it is a good opportunity to just train the students from elementary to Middle High School in a uniform policy throughout their entire process I guess my feelings on that is you're dealing with different um ages and

182uh different ways to have that phone policy because there are are different ages um I don't think elementary kids are going to understand okay today you put it in this little package and then next time mom picks it up or whatever I think that it's important to give them more um freedom to do what's right for that elementary student and they know that process better um kids aren't going to little elementary kids aren't going to understand I put it in this folder or or write it the middle schools when I've talked to both principals and some of the teachers they do like the word confiscation that's the word they've been using and that's the word that they the kids are used to um and it's been working for them and there hasn't been as many

183issues that's what I've heard when I when I've asked them and so they they like that reading and I think that the parents that purchased the device and send it with their kid don't like that so what word would they like to see I think they'd like to not have a teacher take the phone and put it in their desk somewhere where it could be stolen and that they can put it in a safe place for them so uh what What's occurring now Brian on that so what we did is we dropped what's in the handbook at the elementary this is the language is in the handbook and what was their practice I maybe Mr gford can tell us I don't know how long that's been the elementary procedure and since you guys have where

184they put the device when they confiscate it it goes to the office like a teacher at elementary school goes straight to the office with it no my experience typically is a teacher would hold on to it till the end of the day you get take it home the next time they would send it the officy your prepar has to come get it but it it hasn't been a huge issue at with cell phones cuz most of the time we just a we put that in your backpack that's where it's supposed to be and they do it usually most and until they get to fifth grade un but that's different than a confiscation right like that's just having them put it in the backpack well I think it gives them Freedom as teachers and principles to

185what's best for their school I mean you could change it to putting it away and they backpack as OPP to confiscation yeah may result in a confiscation so like I guess they that's up to the teacher and then middle school should be the same as high school the teacher shouldn't be taking the device the student should be es qued to the office and there it goes and then It prepares them for high school because the teacher will get blamed with something happens to it is this your first year or second year second second year no so this was the the wording in the handbook for the last two years and and you guys are fine with that wording and it's been working well or do you feel like there's an issue and we do send

186it directly to the office it doesn't stay in teachers will will call a safety Aid or um teacher will send the student to the office with the phone and notify the office students on their way down with phone so it sounds like they're already following that so we might as well put it in you can just reord it in that well it's still the same as high school well and so then while we're talking about the consequences um apparent feedback that I thought was valid um emailed about you know so the second and third offense is where the parents will be notified and have to pick up the device so what that means is that it's it's likely that a student will be sent home on a bus or walking and maybe at home without

187any way to communicate for till their parents get home if they're not able to come pick it up so I mean a concern about a safety issue was brought up there like and I think that's very valid and I think that we can do some rewarding in in that that and that um let's say the child contacts the parent parent says I can't get there in time then it's released to the student I don't have a problem with that if we word that in there um same with the third because I agree that there's an issue if your kid's coming home and it doesn't have a phone and you need that phone so I think we could add that yeah and and so that's the same with the elementary one like it says that they're

188notified that they have to pick it up in the front office at the elementary school so I mean that's just the way that kids tell their parents they're home it's the way their parents track them and just because they used it in class I don't know if we want to open it up to a safety issue and them you know being at home and having an emergency and not being able to contact an adult or call 911 or whatever needs to happen so yeah so do we want to say that parents don't have to pick it up like no I think you can do what she said and reward it and if parent can't come then the student can pick it up then the student can pick it up but there's a long as the

189parent is notified parent is notified and then knows it that's that's how I think I mean if you've got a third or fourth offense no your parent needs to be notified well and I when I've talked with the middle schools one of the things they do if there third or fourth is they check their phone in at the office and then they pick it up at the end of the day until it resets and I I like that idea and that's what they've been doing too so I wondered if we want to get rid of the second offense and just go first um um and then second third and only have three so that because really the second offense just says that the only difference is that the parent has to pick it up instead

190of the student and if we just do the third offense where they go straight to a lunch detention for a second offense instead I like the fourth offense though the four off thank but just like maybe make it three offenses instead of the second the in instead of four but get rid of the second book um let me think about that the only thing that I can think of is when a parent has to come and pick up that phone it does make a difference but they don't if they can't make it all they have to do is say they can't make it and that's true but that to me that's an exception and not the rule but maybe I'm looking at that I feel like most parents can't get to school at 2:30 to

191pick up their kids' phone well the second one says that the student can be pick it well the second one is the parents are required to pick it up but we're saying that the parents are required to pick it up unless they say I can't make it then we go home with the student how Mr Reno what what are your thoughts on that do you have any thoughts well it's just hard because like you said If the parents who are involved well yes there are some parents who can't pick it up there are some parents that are involved that will sayy yeah keep the phone Consequence the parents that want haveone never going to Pi up and those kids we deal with and so the policy you know we work with exceptions you know if

192it's truly emergency yes we get back we're not right that's not our process suggest couldn't say parent Guardians will be notified can you scroll up to the top CU I I see so the third offense says they have to serve a lunch to right yeah okay and remember the offenses are just broken out by High School you guys had a wondering up here could it say that student parent Guardian will be notified and a plan to pick up the device will be created that way Tim can call parent and he makes the plan cuz he calls me I'm going to say you keep that phone on are you talking about elementary or middle when you're saying that you guys were worried about the will but just the plan cuz well but the way the middle

193school is worded it doesn't that's not even the way he described it right should be the way he's describing you the middle school should be like the high school in like in Tim said like it goes immediately up to the office like that should be in the policy so parents know like it's immediately escorted to the office what the confiscation correct yeah thing is that's not even and then you know then the second offense is yes it has to stay in the office so it needs to be detailed like like the way they break it down at the middle school in the high school you mean the way they break it down well I mean the way he's doing it is kind of like the high school so I mean it doesn't really matter you

194can still word it the same Cuz Mr Jensen said they're doing it exactly the same way it goes in envelope it's escorted to the office that's the same thing as the high school second offenses it goes straight to the office third offenses they lock it in office so it should be exactly the way the process is I agree so Mr Jensen if you feel that we're going to do high school for Middle School you're okay with that proc the same proc the process you're doing what were you asking trusty so if we change so we're going to make the middle school be the same as the high school is that something you're okay with since you've been using this for a while because it sounds like what you're doing is pretty close it's not you're

195not just taking the phone and putting it on a student's on a teacher's desk till the end of the day right they're taking you to the office I I feel like we would be taking a step back a little bit just because everybody's used to the parents and we very rarely do we have an incident like I'm there most nights till 5 5:30 and I tell parents 6 and I say hey I'll be here I'll make I'll set up a time with you we've done that to have them come pick it up what you end up with um what from our experience and Mr REO was kind of saying it was when you give it back to kids they your parent calls in and says I can't make it and they call in again the

196next day kid violates oh I can't make it just give it to my kid the next you and it just becomes an ongoing and so then it creates you know that issue for and it's just it's not a bunch of kids but it's enough kids that you're you're doing that so um and it's a tracking thing when you go to like First Defense second defense third offense like you guys have got 1,900 kids who's cracking the first offense the second offense the third offense it's a tracking because most of the time that you know those phones get taken um not most of the time all the time they get taken to the ladies in the office and sort of now are we put that on them to track okay it's it's Tim Jensen's first offense

197or second offense third offense you know we've only got 5 you know 60 kids they've got well this process was suggested by the high school and but the high school hasn't hasn't been using a policy before and I I'm speaking from experience of having had a policy for a couple years that has work eff and that's my fear is yeah we put this in it's not manageable then we have come back to you to say okay how can we amend this to may fit we're just trying this so this is what was suggested and so that's the hard part about putting a policy is that it'll we'll have to live it and then kind of see what is the volume because we've heard there's been success if you have clear expectations there Suess but how

198are school because they guys got huge well and when we looked at our policy we reached out to multiple other schools that were already that already had a cell phone policy and this is actually just following what other schools and districts had in place so am I hearing you say that you're okay with this and it's not broken so you want to keep it that way is that and I'm good with rewarding things I like what Mr grave was saying you know contact to make a plan you know have a plan with parents and stuff for elementary middle it's not going to be a hill we die on I just we know from experience the tracking side of it is it becomes multiple but then you get parents unfortunately that abused the well I can't

199make it just give it to my kid at the end of the day and that happens multiple times and more of like what you just said like we put in an envelope so just maybe you write out like a reset process that you do and then that's the policy not necessarily changing what you do just rewarding it so that it matches what you do right that's and I'm I'm good with that okay and really I think if we remove like having so many offenses like if we only make it three offenses and I to track and then you don't have to like by the third offense really they and and you're saying you want to reset it every quarter like possible I mean well but I like the third offense cu make them do detention

200because if a parent if a parent is I think she's saying take out the second offense is I take out the second offense only have it go to three offenses because on the third offense you're checking it in before school and you won't have the problem like you're everyone's checking it in you you've lost the privilege then to have it throughout the day and you have to pick it up at the end of the day but they also have toer detention so the second offense doesn't make them to do that but I would like to do that I'm saying I don't care I like all four so it doesn't really bother okay um and I'm fine with changing that and taking the second offense out if that's okay with Mr Reno and and I think

201that the and the teachers CU they're the ones that are yeah upholding this then I don't have a problem with that and I think the main concern of the the feedback from parents is having kids go home without a phone so you're arranging like a 6 p.m. pickup as long as their parents know they're not going to have a phone when they leave school and that plan is made ahead of time like that seems like the concern is that they don't have any way to nobody has a home phone anymore they walk home it's just a different world than we used to live in people have an expectation of being able to communicate with their students and that's one of the things having parents score now is beautiful because to be able to send them

202a direct message that you know they might be at work and can't answer their phone but it PS a text to them that they see you know so we that's just been a practice that we started here to sure that communication gets made you know one way or another in a way that a parent can get the information okay good discussion but I want to make sure I understand what I'm saying are we keeping Elementary in Middle the same but putting in some verbiage that you had I wrote down in my notes I'm going to work with Tim on on maybe like a little bit more of a steps on the ver for Middle School yes okay and work with Robbie if he wants to change any of the steps Elementary one we just don't

203we just keep it I don't know we don't have that person get to be or what's the ver D I think it would just be nice if in the policy it said that a student won't be sent home without a way to communicate without having first communicated with their parents like then it can be on a case-by Case basis but just so a parent doesn't believe their child has a phone they can't contact them they're stuck at work they don't know that their phone has been taken away no I agree with that like like in that first paragraph somewhere or maybe the end State something like about and these guys will help me with that I'm good with that that's our standard practice anyway and so what I think I I he and most of

204the feedback I think that I heard and that I sent on was like what happens if there's a catastrophe will our kids have a chance to have their phones yes they will in the book bags they still have access yeah they'll just turn them on that's that's the main thing that and I want people to understand that um that's the main thing I heard back and then also what Hillary said like um I don't want my kid without a phone after school if especially if they're like I'll call latch key type kid they want to make sure they have that phone and I totally agree with that can stop getting in trouble put your phone away you have I don't think there's a lot of I don't think there's a lot of elementary school kids

205that they're confiscating phones I'll just be honest with you high school it's mainly uh and I think the middle school has really worked it out where they're not really having issues they said we don't have that many not compared to what we used to I mean we used to have shoot there' be some days we have 20 or more of them and now maybe one or two some lot of and then I I'm fine with taking out that second offense and making the third the second and the fourth the third I I agree with that I think just redu it'll reduce tracking the only difference between the first and second is that the parents have to pick it up and so it just seems like just going to make the third third the second yeah

206and then the fourth the third and then just a like one detail under non-instructional time PCD prohibitions for elementary schools like don't we need an and slash or in order to make it make sense you said it's in pink right there and slash or oh way to go that's good grammar cutch and then I guess one thing that I heard also and it if we could spell out that um substitute teachers will be have this communicated um because what I'm hearing from both students and parents is that substitute teachers are heavily on their phones so that's something we discussed all it so I think if that could be spelled out here and maybe put in whatever contract they sign that would be great or even if they yeah when they come in to pii orientation

207about that I make a motion that we um adopt that with the first reading of policy 518 and make those um changes and move on to the second the second policy or the second reading I mean so bringing back second read with with changes yes talk more okay any more discussion moving along Hillary hi um JD hi Michael kiry hi I for me all right get you home Michael let's take a look at the consent agenda eventually um do I have a motion question I'm sorry ahead um on the trip requests it's I it's not necessarily super important for this particular approval but I think it would be nice if they could include what they're attending or what they're doing I'm working on I talk with and we're trying to get all of the questions

208answered my understanding this this right and I talked with her about that if we had more of an idea where they're going and then also there were some corrections that need to be made there were four shaon and three stated so um and then also there's two different forms that are are being used is there one of them is a go ahead and tell like I said we're trying to get everything put together it's been a process are people still using the old form and they're not if that old form is completely gone and I would like it back but I would like it back too whatever know it just says they're going some to Florida to Florida I don't know where they're going what why are they doing that that's exactly what I said

209to her it' be nice if they had more wrest I motion that we approve the consent agenda do I have a second second and all in favor K hi Michael hi JD hi and Hillary hi and I for me all right we are on the good of the order and I just wanted to let you know down theill thank you day on the hill is February 17th through the 18th and then we're having our third annual College and Career Fair February 26 and where's that located at the high school high school know oh it's gasum now it's a gym oh wow has it gotten too big for the they gym last year wow so just wanted to make sure we understood that and then April 8th will be our part two to our inservice that

210we're getting for our literacy training and then the good of the order I hope Kim Beck doll is having a great time on her her ship and um Michael good luck on your vacation for the good of the order and you know with that we'll adjourn all in favorite moving right along how's that the I don't know what

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.