CorpusRecord 46

OCPS | 2025-02-13 School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / OCPS Boardmeetings
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Orange County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
44,615 words · about 248 min
Collected
2026-03-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon and welcome to the Orange County school board's work session which has been scheduled today Thursday February 13 2025 for the purpose of discussing kce ethics and lobbying policy advanced studies and bedh public input at Schoolboard meetings the public will not have an opportunity to participate in this work session to provide public comment because this is not a regularly scheduled Schoolboard meeting no action will will be taken and there will be no open comment period in which the public normally addresses the school board on relevant topics that are related to the work of the board thank you so much for being here this afternoon with us I'm going to do a quick roll call I believe we have chair Jacobs on the line with us chair Jacobs I am here thank you good we

002have member Salam Mona that is also I believe calling in okay okay so she's coming on her way she'll be here soon member forant good afternoon member Douglas member Vanos here member Gallow good afternoon member Felder good afternoon and I am Vice chair bird standing in for the chair today as a reminder board members will not be engaging in outside electronic or digital Communications during the meeting so that we can focus on the matters immediately before us to my fellow board members and District staff when speaking please make sure that your microphone is turned on and speak directly into it so that our YouTube and orange TV viewers can hear you clearly again thank you so much for participating in or attending today's meeting we're going to start with a moment of silence and the

003Pledge of Allegiance and now for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay before before I turn it over I just want to hand over the trophy that I finally brought for for our winner over here of our reading competition this is our the read around the city reading Champion trophy from reimagine communities that we use for our reading competition so we are going to use it for our current let's read ocps competition and member Douglas is the current winner so she gets hold on to it so much thank you are welcome and thank you member bird for this great idea that you had I'm sure you like it

004because you're the big winner uhhuh no thank you I appreciate it all right so I am going to turn it over to doc Dr Vasquez right now so that we can work on policy kce ethics and lobbying thank you Madam co-chair the board is addressing the polic kce it was originally scheduled for discussion Tuesday but time did not permit and so we will be looking at revisions to the policy we've had several board members that have asked us to revisit some of the language we have Mr palmerini our general counsel as well as Vivien cotas who will be going through the policy and engaging in conversation about what's currently in there and any suggested revisions Mr Paul Marini thank you madam superintendent members of the board can you hear me okay so we had this

005policy back before you in a work session on September 19th last year and it was on a discrete issue so I think what I want to do is just go over the discreet issue first and then go over into the more General overview as to what the policy was so if the first the discret issue we had was product testimonials and I have you all have been given copies of the red line you should be in the red line and before I start let me tell you have the copy of the red line and a copy of the clean version when we go into the more broad overview you're going to want to pull up the clean version my staff is in the middle of doing a renumbering project on some of these policies clar

006ifying them making them look better in outline form so the red line is a revised you know version that has different numbering and lettering my chart that I gave you on the differences between state law and the ethics policy is the old clean version of the policy so for right now just look at the red line but then I will when we go into the more broad overview I'll have you switch to the clean version product testimonials we discussed this in depth at our September 19th work session there was a couple minor changes coming out of it but to remind you all of the issue and for members Douglas and Vanos who are new to the board what the issue actually was is there was a discussion about folks who are vendors of ours but

007who also provide us complimentary good and services and they're registered as a 501c3 under the Internal Revenue code charitable organization there was an issue with respect to testimonial videos and we wanted to put parameters in place as to in what circumstances a testimonial video could normally be done and under the version of the policy as it exists today absent the unless it's in a contract unless we put in a contract with a vendor that you can do a testimonial we our employees can't do testimonials for our vendors absent the consent of the ethics compliance officer so that is the current version here's the proposed change you'll see in paragraph one the testimonial of an ocps employee for a vendor can't be done without the written consent of the ethics compliance officer Vivian cotus who's sitting

008next to me is our associate general counsel but she's also the ethics compliance officer the board designated her as that when she got here in 2017 in practice this policy had this Miss cotas order superintendent approving of these testimonial videos so what we did is we added the superintendent in here as one of the as a person who can also authorize a test testimonial it this Pol this policy changes just to conform with the practice and then we also said the Restriction concludes testimonials in any form including written oral electronic and in any form including but not limited to websites or emails so testimonial videos we've had in the past go up on internet sites and we wanted to ensure that those videos going up on Internet sites are have the approval of either the

009ethics compliance officer or the superintendent as the case may be we also added a new paragraph three with respect to those 501c3 organizations and what happens what it now says is an ocps employee May provide a testimonial for any vendor who is a charitable Foundation organized under under Section 501c3 of the Internal Revenue code which provides the district complimentary goods or services the following criteria will be utilized for such testimonials first it says an ocps staff member's decision to participate in and provide a testimonial is entirely voluntary and then after the comma this is new language from September 19th and shall be based upon the employees personal experience we wanted to avoid the situation where an employee is relaying the experience that he or she did not actually have in a testimonial video we wanted

010to make sure the employee was the one who had that experience two ocps will not be identified by name and any testimonial no filming will take place on ocps property no individual ocps school will be identified by name or likeness no use of ocps District logos or individual School logos staff members who provide testimonials will be identified by first name position and type of school so instead of saying it's John pomerini school counselor a popka high school it would actually say as the example Susan interventionist elementary school so you would not be able to identify that Susan is working for an ocps school as part of the testimonial no qualit let me try that again in English no quantitative data will be included in any testimonial unless the data is approved by the district's research

011management and strategy give me a second that's my sign I've been talking entirely too much this week the vendor shall submit all testimonials secure from an ocps staff member to the superintendent or design the design would be Miss cotus for review prior to use or publication in any form such review shall be limited to ensuring compliance with the requirements listed above and then the last bullet here is new the vendor shall include in their video that The Views expressed by the teacher or employees in the video are those of the individual teacher or employee and not necessarily reflective of the views of their employer so these were two minor additions from last time but other and we went through and re-reviewed the board's discussion on this and we' made those changes in conformance with the

012board's Direction but we are happy to open it up for any questions thank you Mr palmerini Angie Gallow sorry member Gallow thank you madam chair I have a couple of things so didn't we approve isn't part of this already approved did I know that we made the recommendations did it not go through the full process to get approved and put in policy so there were some changes that needed to come back we did not actually bring it all the way through the process because part of the direction that weed the last time was hey we wanted to have a wider discussion about the policy so we wanted to see the side by side sure okay so in number two an ocps employee who provides a testimony to a vendor without the written consent of the

013e e ethics compliance officer is subject to Deary disciplinary action I would ask that we put in ethics compliant officer or the superintendent yes to match with the verbiage that we have in one yes ma'am and then if we're going to be consistent down at bullet number 8 it says the vendor shall submit all testimonials secured from Ops staff to the superintendent or design so for adding design there I would request that in number one we put or superint the superintendent design KN and also add it to number two just to be consistent through Out product testimonials so I understand the consistency I'm just thinking through this as I'm sharing it superintendent or design for review you know design I meant to be I think it's meant to be the ethics compliance officer I you

014know I could make that change in that bullet number eight to say ethics compliance officer to make it consistent and I'm fine with that but in most cases where the superintendent is tasked with something in policy we usually say the superintendent or the superintendent's designate in case she would prefer Dr arrer or Dr Williams to take the lead on that just I'm at the if that's the board's Direction then I'm at the board's pleasure there because the superintendent would have to designate so if she wanted to still have she could or she could especially if she's out of town I mean she's a very very busy superintendent okay okay okay so that was all that I had on the section just those minor changes all right we'll make the we'll make the changes and when

015we bring it back for a rural development Workshop you'll see the changes in there and then and number eight are you going to add the superintendent or design and or the compliance officer because I feel like it should be there too okay yes all right that was all I had thank you thank you member Fant thank you okay so my questions are just kind of clarifying bullet point two more more or less are they able to state that they work at a local public school like say I'd say you know Miss Fant I'm a teacher at a local elementary school or a local public elementary school because you're not stating that it's the it could be a charter school as well I think just so people understand you know people who would be VI viewing

016the video okay like what type of school is this so and I'll I may let Vivien and the superintendent jump in on this too depending on where the vendor located and let's say hey we're here and we're based in Orlando Florida and we want you to hear from a local elementary school teacher that may identify that teacher as an ocps teacher more readily than if it was a company who was located outside of of Central Florida that's the only concern that I can think of but Madam superintendent or Miss cotus is there anything you all would want to add there member foron I believe that the language was put in there because most of the times when an employee is asked to give a testimonial the reason the employee is being asked is not necessarily

017because of that individual employee it's because of their affiliation with the district and so the vendor is attempting to to use the testimonial to expand their program if they're a business vendor they're trying to Market their program using the district as the means of expanding their work and so the goal was to allow the employee to sit for the testimonial but not have the descriptor of ocps principal ocps teacher and so what we came up with was a generic my name is Jane Smith I'm an elementary school teacher they can say they teach fifth grade but not to identify the school in such a way that ties them to ocps okay okay next question would be on maybe number seven I'd have to count them out what would when we talk about quantitative data what

018exactly could you describe that for me we have had a situation in the past where someone has given a testimonial and has given statistical data in that testimonial saying that something improved by a certain percentage and when we went back and we looked at that information we believed it to be inaccurate and so if someone wants to give a testimonial and give data the preferen is that it be reviewed by the district to make sure that data is accurate it we're not talking about you know I'm a teacher and I've seen a vast Improvement in my students by using this program or this product this was very specific we've seen this level of improvement from this level of improvement and it was not accurate so the goal is to not really elicit that kind of

019information from the employee but if the employee feels that they want to give a testimonial that includes some sort of Statistics we would ask that there be reviewed by our research team before they're used okay okay that makes sense all right that was all for now thank you thank you member Fant chair Jacobs I'm sorry no comment at this point no questions oh my gosh yes it was me I'm sorry I have a headache and I'm not thinking very clearly yes that was me I'm in chair Jacob's SE right now all right do you have anything to say yes I do thank you okay so I want to just clarify a few things because when we talk about product testimonials we're only talking about like can can we maybe have a I feel like there

020needs to be some definition here and my concern here is we've got many nonprofits that work with our schools not with a product but just work with our schools and maybe have had programs in our schools that have been really successful programs but they do it on a nonprofit basis and many of these things we do you know and those you know we have I can I can think off the top of my head a good handful of times where we've done videos where you know highlighting that this vendor is in the school and did this today and the school's there the name of the schools there our logos in it all of that so is there a difference here are we just talking about a product or are we talking about anything that a

021nonprofit is doing in any of our schools can no one do any kind of testimonial that I just need to I feel like we need to be a little clearer about that here member bird when the policy was written it applied to a vendor so I believe that's why the term product was used because typically with a vendor we're buying a service or we're buying a curriculum material or a book or a bus or something of that nature okay we regularly get requests from nonprofit organizations s that want a testimonial and what happens is when that comes through me I don't know the program and so I will ask who's requesting the testimonial what is our nature of our relationship with the entity why are they requesting the testimonial I don't have I'm not boots

022on the ground so I don't know the value of the program to the district so at that point I would go to the superintendent and say say superintendent do you want to do this is what they're asking if she says yes then my the next phase of my role is every time our employee is asked to provide a testimonial they're presented with a release and the release says that the employee authorizes the use of their name likeness voice for any purpose that the entity deems appropriate from the beginning of time to the end of time the second sentence is usually that the employee has the authority to speak on behalf of the district and so then I have to reach out to the entity and say what are you using this for and see why

023they want to use it and what parameters I can put on it and also make clear to the employee that they understand what this release means because it is a broad release for The Entity to use that person's image for as long as they want and for whatever purpose they want and usually we work this out if it comes through the process as it's intended if it doesn't then the employee ordinarily will sign the release sits for the testimonial and then once we find out about it if it's something that we want to take down we have to reach out to the entity and say will you please take this down and my history has been that they cooperate with us but that is the process often times our employees are invited to sit on

024panels to present about a particular topic which inherently includes a product testimonial of some kind but that's really secondary to the professional development opportunity so in that case I will ask the entity look we are happy to have our employee participate on the panel would you agree that they presentation that you're going to record is not going to be used for marketing purposes and they always agree because they want the benefit of our employee to participate in the panel and it allows the employee to have the professional development opportunity with a nonprofit We Know going into it if we approve the testimonial that the nonprofit is using it to expand the reach of their program and if the nonprofit knows that it's part of their Grant process they need to secure feedback on their program

025they will tell us as part of our agreement that we sign with them we need surveys and we need the surveys to be completed to evaluate the program if there's student surveys we ask that they be completed anonymously unless the parent has consented to the students name being used if it is teacher surveys we also ask Anonymous I will always counsel the program directors that usually at the bottom of that survey and the fine print it says your survey feedback can be used by The Entity for that purpose I think it's important in this day and age of social media and the internet for our employees to understand the broadness of what they're signing on to but that is usually how the process works so product in this context was really written in conjunction with

026buying something from a vendor right and I totally understand that it was just when we add the 501c3 that you know makes me just want to make sure that we're still cooperating fully with our great nonprofits that help our schools and work with our schools and many of them that are applying for grants that really do have to have data to show up you know our testimonials to be able to get that money to continue their work so okay well so then you're what you're saying basically basically is we could we can usually work through the process and they can still have all of those things usually that they need once they work through it I have found that entities are very Cooperative with us and they understand the constraints and it gives me an

027opportunity to understand what they're looking for also counsel the employee at the same time and have some continuity in how we treat the entities that we deal with and in terms of the language perhaps we just delete the word product and just have testimonials and that might cure the section that might be a good idea I if if we are applying it to all of the situations with testimonials then yeah then maybe we do need to take out product because many times it's not a specific product and now that this does include our nonprofits I'm assuming that there's some way to sh we have a plan for how to sh once we approve all this to share it out with all of our existing nonprofits that you know that this is the new policy and

028that I mean I'm sure that's been thought of we will yeah we will assure that once it gets passed in final form that we make sure we get with our folks to make sure it's shared shared with them wonderful okay I think that's it for me member Vanos thank you madam Vice chair and I actually I probably was at the original meeting but not in the same position so I'm sorry if I'm a little behind trying to catch up for the for section three and I think member bird clarified this but what you're saying is it does not just apply to a charitable Foundation but also for nonprofits as well correct okay what about if there was a for-profit company that was providing services to the district through a grant so yeah essentially the way

029this has worked in practice is that whether the entity is a vendor or a nonprofit or a grant-funded program if the ask is made we would like a testimon the question becomes does the district want to authorize the testimonial if the answer is yes then it has happened regardless of the status of the entity okay okay perfect and then also under section three I mean I assume that if this a charitable Foundation or or whatever wanted testimonial of a student that a student could provide it we never if the request is of students there is absolutely no circumstance in which the student is recorded without parental consent right okay but that's through the parents really correct okay okay and then my last question about this is on the quantitative data that will will be included

030unless it's approved it will not be included unless it's approved through the district do we does the district share data that they have in relation to the program with the let's say just say charitable Foundation or organization most of our nonprofit charitable grant-funded organizations when they come to us with a program the question is what data are you going to need they need that data to support the efficacy of their program so usually going into it we know data elements that they're going to ask for and we report that data and an agreed upon cycle depending on their needs and if if their aggregate data is going to say something about the program all we're asking is will they let us know what they want to say before they say it so we can verify

031that we agree with the analysis okay thank you member Douglas oh okay I just want to make sure that I understand I just had coffee this morning with a nonprofit so I just want to make sure that I'm in the right side of the law and I'm not doing anything crazy so I just had coffee with a nonprofit and they provide scholarship for student and all that so if I attend one of the events and they take pictures and things like that what what what that what is the problem is it a problem for us to do that how do we cover ourselves when they use our pictures over and over and over can they do that do we have a form that we can they can fill out say no we not you know

032you're not supposed to be you know using this picture over and over to kind of you know you know promote your event and I want to make sure you understood my question I do I think the concern is if you're at a public event you don't necessarily have the right to privacy and to not be photographed in that you would have in a private setting so if you're at a group event and there is a group picture taken and your photo is used I think it becomes the context that your photograph is used that is the issue if it's a private setting where you don't expect to be photographed and you are photographed that is a different set of circumstances but this particular section is dealing with if if the entity that you were meeting

033with asked for you to give an interview and in that interview you made comments about the program and how wonderful it was and that you know the program is an asset to Orange County Public Schools usually if that was going to be done you would be presented with a release because the organization wants to be able to use your statement and they don't want you to come back and say I didn't authorize this and so that's what this section is dealing with in terms of being photographed that depends on on the context I mean when you go to events usually they put you know you have a lot of kids you know take a picture they come to you what do you think of the event oh it was a great event I think you

034know and you don't realize you actually saying maybe something you shouldn't say so that's not what this section is trying to capture this section is trying to capture a packaged presentation that supports an entity whether it's a nonprofit or it's a vendor and it's you sitting down specifically to talk about specifically something in a positive light and if it's a nonprofit they're going to use that to expand their program to expand their funding if it's a vendor they're usually going to use it for marketing purposes ocps likes this product or this service so we think you'll like it too I mean there's a very fine line you know I'm just saying very fine line because if I go to an event and they ask me a question what do you think of the event I

035think it was a great event is the it really helped the kids and I'm a board member so that tell them that as a board member of ocps I agree and I actually put my stamp of approval on this and I don't know this is critical to me I how do I protect myself when how do we protect ourself when we go to events like that this policy is not trying to censor your comments if you go to an event you think it's a great event and it's for a good cause you're free to say that okay that's what I wanted to hear this is a different situation okay this particular portion applies to employees as you'll see throughout the policy kce there is different between how board members are treated under this policy versus

036employees there's separate sets of rules for you all so and we'll go over more of that as we go through the policy that would be great thank you because we get invited to a lot of things of yeah and there's a difference between saying this is a great event you know I had a wonderful time and I think it was wonderful thing versus you getting up there saying you know vendor ABC is in our schools and I think have done this and this and they've had this data and they've improved this achievement that's that's those are two separate and distinct conversations all thank you thank you for clarifying thank you member Douglas good points member Gallow thank you madam chair some of the stuff that I wanted to cover has been covered especially in reference

037to nonprofits I just want to Ure that when we're working with nonprofits or charitable organizations that we make every good faith attempt to be good partners to them because as member bird mentioned they're in our schools for free they're doing really really good work and without their partnership we won't be successful I mean they really lend that much to the mission and the purpose of ocps and what we're sent out to do so I know that we have to have some of these things defined in here for the sake of clarity on what we will and won't allow but I'm just hoping that when it comes down to it and we're looking at it that we're really looking at it through the lens of a partnership and the understanding that nonprofits as you mentioned earlier

038rely on the benefit of their product to expand Their audience or to even to get the fundraising they need to continue that support right they need to provide to the people that hold them accountable by donating to that charitable organization that what they're doing is working so I'm just hoping that we would we would keep that in mind and then to member Douglas's part this product testimonials has it doesn't apply to us not not at all anywhere in here does to say board member it only says employee we're not an ocps employee so the product testimonials don't apply to any board member unless this board chooses to add board member into the list of people people that are subject to this policy correct yes yes John's just so happy that I pointed that out listen

039there's a whole host of issues with respect to board members and their right to Advocate and that you know is different than an employee so I understand where you're coming from thank you thank you member Gallow you done okay member Fant thank you so continuing on that page 13 number two just reading through that again I know this isn't redlined but it says that if an any ocps employee who provides a testimonial is subject to discipline like without getting written consent from an Ethics compliance officer is subject to disciplinary action but not limited to dismissal from employment so my issue with this is you've got sweet little kindergarten teacher who is using a product or working with a vendor and the vendor says wow how is this working for you and they go oh my

040gosh I've seen such a difference in my class they went from getting FS all year so they're getting A's now and it's 100% because I've been using this product and they want to just share that I'm little kindergarten teacher I'm not going to go and think in my mind oh I need to go talk with a ethics compliance officer and then when you find out hey it's written right here it's in a policy that there's like how many policies and why didn't you read through all you know how many policies that we have and then it's well we could actually fire you so that I just feel like it's I mean I see other things that go on around here and people aren't getting fired for those and but for something like this I that

041just seems a little like I would never want to say anything ever like I feel like we're putting a muzzle on our teachers and our staff member for my response to that would be that Casey is a lengthy policy I understand that's 22 pages long every year when employees get reappointed they affirm that they have read kce even setting aside all of that if someone comes to you says we're so happy that you like our program and that you want to talk about it positively will you sign this release that release should Garner somebody's attention specifically if there's language in there that says the person's authorized to speak on behalf of the district even if that doesn't the individ the employee doesn't read it they don't necessarily appreciate what they're reading I in my tenure

042here which is almost eight years I've only had to send less than a handful of people to Professional Standards I don't handle the Professional Standards process but my understanding is that they were just told be aware of kce kce does not authorize this and that is what has happened there is not a flagrant intent on the part of employees to violate this policy but I think that is why the language is in there just so that there has to be some personal responsibility on the part of the employee that they are speaking on behalf of the district if the employee wants to put on their social media I have a great program that I worked with I love it I can't stop an employee from their right to free speech but ordinarily this request is

043because of the entity wanting to capture that person's affili with the district can I add here so like I've been the labor and employment lawyer before I became to this position for the entirety of this policy I don't remember anybody getting disciplined much less fired over it as as Miss Cota said it's normally a we have things called written directives which are statements of performance expectations that aren't disciplinary we don't even do that when somebody comes and violates this policy we just say hey we give them what's known as verbal verbal coaching which is hey there's this policy you have you know technically violated it you have to be aware of it going forward please follow it in the future now the reason why that language is subject to including but not limited to dismissal

044say you have somebody who went in you know asked the question hey can I do this testimonial they say no and they're like well I don't like the answer I'm therefore going to do it anyways that's going to be treated in a different Manner and it may be disciplinary and it may be up to an including dismissal depending on how egregious it is or not this language allows us to have some wiggle room to deal with the extremely egregious cases none of which we've seen in the 12 years that we've been doing this having this policy yes superintendent so additionally the that teacher could use students as part of the testimonial they could allow them to take pictures of students without parents' permission to be part of the testimonial and so this allows us to

045be able to if there were a situation to move forward with discipline and as Mr palmerini said even the most recent case that we had there were they were just told you need to be aware that this policy exists and nothing happened to them but it does allow for us in extreme situations to be able to do to deal with discipline as we do with anyone who violates one of our policies okay and member front the other aspect to this is that at least with our vendors when we solicit for services or for products anything over $50,000 is supposed to go through our procurement process unless it falls in an exception when we staff those selection committees we staff them both from school-based personnel and from District Personnel so the teacher you mentioned that gives

046the testimonial innocently if we pick that teacher to be on a panel and we don't know that she's given a testimonial and all of a sudden we solicit for bids and those respondents submit bids and say that Committee Member should be disqualified because they gave a testimonial talking about how great company a is and now company a is bidding for the work that compromises the district's ability to staff our committees with people that have subject matter expertise and our stakeholders in the item that we're buying so knowing who's out there giving a testimonial helps us because we don't want want stakeholders to get disqualified when those are the very Services we're going out to procure and we've had it happen we had a person who innocently wrote a reference letter for a staffing agency thinking

047the staffing agency was going to use it in another County the staffing agency turned around and put that letter as part of their response to the district's bid for those Staffing services and we had to remove that person was a very important Point person for those very services from the committee because there was a reference letter in that person's packet with this individual saying how great the staffing company was and so the other submittals were like well how do we how can this person be fair if they've written such a glowing reference letter to for this other agency so that is the other element here it's not just trying to maintain the narrative and how the district's name is used as a public entity we have a procurement process because we're spending public dollars and

048it does impact our ability to staff these committees with the appropriate people okay so just clarifying when so say this kindergarten teacher she goes on social media and she says I love this product it's been amazing she's allowed to say that that's her social media we don't control it and even if she were to say I work at and such a school and so now you can't control it so that's free speech but but I will tell you video is not Free Speech but that's not the VA that there's no value in that teacher social media the Entity wants something that they can use to get to send to their Grant funders to another District that they're trying to sell they're not going to mine somebody's social media for a a glowing report from a

049ocps teacher that said I had a great experience teaching my kids using X product or X curriculum screen recording screen sharing I mean there's great ways to share people's Social Media stuff I get it so I guess I think that's where I'm it feels like a fine line between free speech and censoring people's speech I 100% I get it where you can't maybe you know you don't want to say maybe the school whatnot but to tell a teacher like we you could be dismissed I know in the situation that happened all those teachers were like oh my gosh like what we were just so excited for how amazing this product was and now we're being told you this is absolutely unacceptable you can't do this you're breaking the ethics policy those teachers are like wait

050do you guys not care about kids learning or do you care I think that's the part where I think it's just frustrating I don't know I have I have an issue with it but we'll keep going okay superintendent I have you queued in did you have anything more you wanted to add I don't it was it was a while ago and so I apologize I honestly oh I do remember remember there was two points I'm sorry so one is I would caution any board member that you make statements about any type of program without having data if you are interested if you're going to an event and you think you might be asked we'd be happy to share with you information about where it's being used or you know the partnership that we have with

051the organization but just if you make a statement and it's not accurate then you know then we have the problem of having to backtrack so we'll be more than happy to assist in any way if you are going to an event and then second you I want to reassure everyone that we you know we love our nonprofits and we love working with them and as long as they're aligned with our vision and our mission and it doesn't contradict what we are what we're doing and what we're saying we will always partner with them thank you superintendent I wanted I'm queued up next I just wanted to touch one more time on the social media if I agree with member font that it is really easy to use social media now for advertising and I've seen

052a lot of companies where they have like we have you know this many likes on Facebook or this many or they'll put you know like she said like a screenshot of something a teacher says so in that case if we had a vendor or a nonprofit that said without our permission in a mailer out to Neighborhood schools one of our teachers a ocps teacher blah blah blah blah blah MH says you know and has like a screenshot of there would would we have grounds then to come back to them for not getting permission to do that or is it just like it's out on the social media so it's fair game so we had a recent example where we had a teacher who used a program and it was a Civics program and did sort

053of a mock election in her classroom and then put on social media you know I had a great day with my students we had a mock election and I didn't see the social media post so I do not know if the teacher specifically referenced the curriculum but there was a product manager that apparently was monitoring social media from the company and saw the teachers post and basically said to the teacher we would love to turn this into a newsletter story would you be willing to sit for the story so the social media post was nice but the vendor wanted something more that teacher basically reached out to the principal principal reached out to their District leadership and said can we do this now this is a vendor that we pay for curriculum materials So my

054answer was no because it violates kce but that teacher's post is still out there so to the extent that teacher's post benefits the district it I mean that benefits that vendor it is what it is I can't ask her to take it down that's her social media account she controls it she has the ability to say what she wants to say on it and I did not refer it to Professional Standards for a disciplinary matter because I felt that she was using her social media in what in a way that she deems appropriate okay thank you for clarifying that I believe chair Jacobs does now want to speak chair Jacobs yes thank you actually on on the same subject line so to member Bird's scenario I understand that we can't restrict our employees right to

055free speech on their social media sites but it does seem to me that we could as part of our contract with our vendors restrict their ability to use those as any kind of indorsement so I mean there's a difference between our right to restrict a vendor as part of our contract and free speech so isn't that a way that we could address this because I do see I know it probably isn't going to happen something s but chair we create our policies go ahead chair we build into our agreements that our vendors will abide by kce and so in a scenario like the one I mentioned I can go back to the vendor and say hey I want you to remind I want to remind you of kce but in this instance I think the

056vendor is going to turn around and tell me well this is this teacher's personal social media and we're not violating your policy now the solic that's why I'm suggesting that's that's exactly why I'm suggesting that our policy could be written so that we don't want a back Channel way to get an endorsement or give an endorsement and we could change our contract to prohibit them from using material from our employees social media sites to their advantage can't we legally do that chair I would like to or Madam chair I would like to be able to research the law a little bit more about utiliz prohibiting folks from utilizing stuff in the public domain I understand exactly where you're trying to get I just want to make sure that we can legally do what you're suggesting

057and I that's going to take some research on our part no no no problem John I yeah I would definitely like for you to do that I don't remember the scenario that I'm thinking of but I remember something similar to this and the control that we have when we enter into contract so by all means if you'll look at that and then if that means that we have to change our policy to speak to that then we'd have an opportunity to come back and look at it if the board feels it that's worthwhile okay thank you guys thank you thank you chair superintendent I have you up again did you not okay okay it looks like we are at the end of our comments on this policy I did also want to just acknowledge for

058the record that member Salam monka did arrive while we were having those discussions so she is here in person all right so for the next portion of the discussion I was tasked back in September to bring the board a comparison with regard to our current policy and what is required by State law versus what is not required by state law Miss cotus and I have gone through this process as I said it's a it was a painstaking process and I do emphasize the pain portion of that process U but I wanted to give you a sort of a an update first before we go into this what does state law generally cover with respect and this is mostly having to do with gifts first thing with respect to you all as school board members there's

059a gift statute and it is explicit and here's what it says notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary a district Schoolboard member and their relatives and there's a whole Litany of relatives that are defined may not directly or indirectly solicit any gift or directly or indirectly accept any gift in excess of $50 from any person vendor potential vendor or other entity doing business with the school district and the term gift has the same meaning is as another statute and it includes things like meals tickets to events etc etc that is a very broad prohibition with respect to you all as school board members it covers there's I will tell you that there certain lawyers interpret this law in different ways certain lawyers interpret it to talk about you can't accept it from vendors

060or potential vendors I always get queasy because it says you can't accept it from any person which is a very very very broad definition that includes everybody as far as I'm concerned so I will tell you I have tendency to be not in the political sense but just in in more conservative when it comes to adhering to the gift law because I never want to run any of you a foul by saying well if it's not a vendor and it's it's a person you can accept something over $50 or solicit something over $50 that would concern me with respect to you all but that is the gift statute with respect to Schoolboard members and then there are other gift statutes which cover other the district's employees and the first one is that any employee cannot

061promise their action in exchange for a gift from anyone of any value so you can't say you know what I'm going to recommend you for this contract if you buy me you know dinner at a fancy restaurant that is prohibited or even if it's you know Burger King quite frankly $5 you can't it's prom an action for a $5 meal for all employees they cannot accept gifts from anyone of any value when that employee knows or with the exercise of reasonable care should know that's given to influence their actions even if it doesn't in fact influence you so if you know that somebody's coming to you saying hey my child is could be up for an expulsion and if I want you to put in a good word for my child and if you do

062I'm going to give you a $50 gift card a $100 gift whatever it is you cannot accept that because you know it's meant to influence your decision now you might have said I would be willing to put in a good word for your child anyways but that doesn't matter under that portion of the gift statute if you know it's being given to you to influence your decision no matter how much it is you can't accept it and then there is a discussion of what we know in in the gift statutes as rpes reporting individuals and procurement employees a reporting individual is somebody who has contractual authority to expend certain amounts of money and I think it's $35,000 in the statute but don't quote me on that Miss cotus just confirming that it is 35,000 so

063thank you any any employee that has that kind of authority they cannot accept gifts of over $100 from a vendor or a lobbyist so that is the statutory prohibition for gifts on reporting individuals and procurement employees reporting individuals and procurement employees cannot solicit a gift of any value from a vendor or a lobbyist which means I can't ask them for a $5 cup of coffee at Starbucks I don't even know if you can do $5 at Starbucks anymore it's probably inflated past that but I can't even ask for that reporting individuals and procurement employees cannot accept or solicit any gift of any value from a political committee reporting individuals and procurement employees have to file quarterly gift reports for gifts over $100 from non vendors lobbyists or political committee donors and they have to submit

064annual gift reports for of over $100 for other specific donors so there's a whole for those reporting individuals and procurement employees if they accept certain gifts over that threshold from non- lobbyist vendors and political committees they have to do quarterly reports and then you reporting individuals and procurement employees cannot solicit or accept honoraria under under certain circumstances but can accept reasonable and actual expenses of attendances at conferences and that kind of stuff an honoraria is defined in the law as payment of money of or anything of value directly or indirectly to a reporting individual or procurement employee or to any person on their behalf as consideration for a speech presentation writing or other similar C task so hey we're going to pay you a sum of money to come speak at our conference under the

065honor area law reporting individuals and procurement employees can't do that especially as part of their job duties so those are the general broad categories of gift laws so now I'm going to turn you to this 14-page chart do we want to stop and take some questions now or do you want to go through your chart first I am no no no I am at the board's pleasure okay member Felder thank you so much chair I just wanted to get some clarification two things family members I can understand maybe if it's we're on the board and our spouse maybe owns a contracting company or business or what have you how can we control their decision to go out to dinner with somebody unless it's a person that's trying to do business with us as a district

066and I can understand why how that needs to be prohibited they're trying to do business with us and they take our spouse out or whatever but I it just you say any relatives cousins I mean what what you mean husbands wives what how can you control that husbands you can wives you can but like a distant cousin how what how was that I don't think it gets down that far to distant cousins it's you know spouses children honest in you know daughters-in-law those those kinds of those kinds of folks parents does grandparents too I can't remember if it does grandparents well if it's business I can I can you I can understand it the second concern I have I remember some time ago when Dr Jenkins was our superintendent and before I got on the

067board I was always speaking you know different venues and I did receive an honorarium now she said to me now I think I'm understanding it correctly if somebody wanted me to speak as regarding Schoolboard stuff I don't receive honorarium for that because I should that's part of my not not my job but that's part of the responsibilities that we have as Schoolboard members schools and different places where may ask us to come in and speak you don't get honorariums for that's correct but if I'm preaching a sermon for my church I'm going get an honorarium I'm not doing it for the school I need to be corrected I just happen to be a school board member but I'm also a licensed Minister see what I'm saying yes so the thing that I would be careful

068of there is if they're inviting you in your capacity as a pastor minister they use a minister but but they're doing it because they could underlying think that you know hey if we throw ask her to do this as a minister because we could be coming to to have some business before the board I will stop that I understand how that goes I just want to make sure because I have had you know your school board M I said why do you want me to come you want me to share the gospel or do what because I'm not no you're not going I'm not doing it for that but I just wanted to make I just want to get clarity because many of us do speak at different occasions you know and it's not school

069related but I do want to get clarity because I do understand people sometimes will use the fact that you are on the board but you are doing other things so I just want I think I do understand it the way I did understand I just want to make sure I had it right member Felder my understanding is it's a matter of context so okay if the board member has a profession outside of their service as a board member and you're being asked to speak in that capacity then you can accept payment for your presentation or your service or or separ this separate I got you if you're being invited in Your Capacity as a school board member then you should not accept an honorarium for your attendance at the event thank you and I have

070a not when I've been asked it's been in the because of my ministerial connection right and being a a licensed Minister but I did want to clear that because people know you because I know of this but certainly it needs to be clear and I have made it clear as as as much as I possibly could that if you're inviting me this is what I'm going to do I'm going to preach the gospel I'm not going to talk about school stuff and I do expect honorarium but okay thank you all right thank you member Felder member Gallo thank you madam chair so I have a comment and then a suggestion to M member felder's Point one of the issues that I've had historically with this policy and at times when we try to add to

071the policy is that my line of work puts me in front of lobbyist on The Daily I'm asking for campaign contributions on The Daily for clients of mine due to the nature of the company that I own my own own daughter is a registered lobbyist for different firms and so for me it gets extremely murky because does that mean my daughter can't buy me dinner or she can't buy me a gift at Christmas no no no no no that the gift law is exempt out gifts from relatives okay so yes your daughter can in fact buy you a Christmas gift and if she doesn't then you got other issues okay and but she could take me out to dinner yeah okay so my suggestion if if if the board pleases is this current legal requirements

072under Florida law this very nice chart that you gave to us my recommendation would be that we only take up the items where we are more stringent than state law because clearly where we're not we're not going to change any of that language because we have to adhere to state law and so just for expediency and we do have I think two other policy we need to get through today so maybe if we just look at the areas where our policy outweighs or is more stringent than state law requires that might H that might speed us up and get us through this quicker can can I would had no intention of going over this 14-page policy on everyone no no no I was going to point out certain sections that I thought were more stringent

073than law and just tee that up for discussion this is what you all decide to do with it I'm just bringing it to you I want you all want to have the information side by side so there's a couple areas where I'm going to point out where I think it is more stringent than state law just to tee it up for discussion thank you Mr palmerini that's a good idea I real quick before we jump into that I just want to go back to one thing that you said that I think I just want to get double down clarification on you said that gifts that you consider it gifts from any person as opposed to some districts or general councils that might advise that it's just gifts from potential vendors I think that really has

074to be I really want to just hear you say that again I want to make sure because there's a that's a big difference right let me reread the statute yeah reread it again for me and I just want to clarify that one a little more notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary district school board members and their relatives as defined in 112 3112 subsection 21 may not directly or indirectly solicit any gift or directly or indirectly accept any gift in excess of $50 from any person comma vendor comma potential vendor comma or other entity doing business with the school district the term gift has the same meaning as in section 112 3112 subsection 12 so when you have a whole list of things like that you have to take each one individually right

075so if they when I read it just from the plain language of it if it says persons associated with a vendor that would be one thing but it said person comma vendor comma potential vendor comma so those are three separate classes of people and so that's where I get in there yes but or other entity doing business so the or in this case means you can't accept G from any of these classes of people person vendor potential vendor or other entity doing business with the school district so it's all four of those but yeah because I think we're going to ask the same thing or or vendor doing or doing what was the last part doing business other entity doing business with the school district right so that does not apply doing business or other

076entity mhm it's not saying those for doing business with the district does not apply to all those you don't think I don't think so Vivian if you have a different opinion she does not have a different opinion than me those are four distinct categories I'm just trying to understand the ethical reasoning behind that it doesn't really make any sense that you're saying saying that a family member or a board member cannot accept a gift from anyone over $50 regardless of if they do and think about that's yes well because they quite frankly when they passed this law back in 2012 it was meant to make things more onerous on Schoolboard members than it had been in the past they were they it was really this gift law was is not designed to be friendly towards

077board members yeah and I and I understand that and I that's why I feel like the whole potential vendor it does I mean that is diff I mean that is a real good guard rail you if if there's any opportunity for this person to be a vendor with ocps then absolutely not you should not be accepting anything from them so here any person is just I mean that's like a neighbor a neighbor who's a garbage man I can't listen I'm not I clearly we're all trained as lawyers to look at the words in the statute and the statutory construction says you are to give effect to every word that is in the statute right and person's actually defined in 1.01 Florida statute and it talks about any natural person so when I look at that

078I have to apply those rules of statutory construction but here's what I will commit to do I will commit to see if there's any law that has interpreted this one way or the other the last time I have looked at it I don't think that there's any law that's interpreted one way or the other on this but I will go ahead and make sure that I feel comfortable coming back to you saying yes I've looked at it there's no law it's still my opinion or I've looked at it here's the law and here's what it actually says I've looked at this before I haven't seen anything that goes to this level of of granularity but I'll do it again thank you Mr palmerini member Gallow thank you madam chair why you're doing you're little lookie

079can you Can can you check and see if other districts have interpreted it differently cuz based on what you just to me I don't know how a family would my a family member would be excluded from that gift cuz you said any person there nothing in what you read to me Exempted family and yet you just told me that family is there's other sections in the gift because it interprets it in accordance with the gift law and there's other sections within the gift law that says hey this prohibition on giving gifts doesn't apply to family members oh it doesn't it does the there anything that says it doesn't apply to people not entering in a contract not that not that I've seen I will relook at it again but to to member Felder may have

080expressed something the gift law says hey you're prohibited from receiving or soliciting gifts but this doesn't apply if it's relatives giving gifts to each other like you know a birthday gift holiday gift something like that but it would be to if my best friend gives me a gift for my birthday that has nothing to do with anything in politics I think the context of that is different right if your best friend's giving you a birthday gift they're not necessarily doing it to influence your decision making I will look just as you said as I'm doing my look see I'll make sure that I take care of that but I but I wouldn't tell you hey you know here here's what I would tell you if your best friend's giving you a birthday gift and you

081know there's nothing that your best friend has coming before you that's has coming in here there that has any business before you yeah you're going to take the birthday gift however if your best friend is knows is like you know has a kid who has an issue coming before you and all of a sudden they give you a birthday gift two weeks before that issue is coming up that may be something that would may be something that would give you pause so no that makes sense as as Mota says sometimes context is key here so yeah and while why we're we're doing a deeper dive it was just so there was a law that passed that basically said that sitting electeds cannnot Lobby that was since overturned by Court I don't know that anybody that

082sits up here is a registered lobbyist I'm certainly not a registered lobbyist but we are allowed to be registered lobbyist so as a registered lobbyist like what like should there be something in this policy that speaks of a school board member as a lobbyist and the dues and the don'ts because you're kind of impeding their they're getting paid to Lobby the policy could impede their ability to do their job and still follow this policy so we might want to take a little look see on that as as well because under state law we are allowed to be registered lobbyists now we cannot we cannot Lobby ourselves right but I could as a registered lobbyist go up and Lobby Tallahassee for any Baker like like for any company that I wanted to under state law so

083I think one of the things that so then am I prohibited from giving myself anything I think the answer is no there I so I'm not necessarily sure we need to put it in policy that may be a situation where we have a one-off like that you know you all as board members if you all did become registered lobbyist you would come to me and we would talk through the Contour of it I'm not necessarily sure we need to put it in there I don't you know I don't think that the law would prohibit you from being a registered lobbyist up in Tallahassee from from doing that like you said you couldn't obviously Lobby here your own board members that way and nor would that would be silly it just boggles the mind to even

084think about you know with respect to that and I was never suggesting that just to be on right no no no no no no no remember that court case overturned the prohibition against folks being sitting members being lobbyist now with respect to xboard members the court case did not address that ex ex members government officials the court case did not address that only that means if I left at the end of my term I can't lobby ocps but I can still be become a registered lobbyist for in if I'm for federal or Statewide it's just for the entity to which you came from that's right it would prohibit you for six years yeah from lobbying for them on their behalf no lobbying the entity from which you came ocps got it thank you but lobbying

085is different than advocating because if you don't get paid you know if I had hair you would have pulled it all out by now right I would pulled it out it would and it would have fallen out on its own I wouldn't have needed to pull it come on you love it we keep you on your toes yeah all right remember Gallow is that it for you that's I've annoyed John enough I'm good okay okay chair Jacobs chair Jacobs hey sorry about that guys give me just let me try to get right back to that section of the statute so John this issue of of $50 in the gift here's here's why I disagree with your interpretation and why I think other attorne some other attorneys see this differently I think the burant word is

086other so if it was intended to say that the doing business with the school district applied to all of these didn't apply to all of these okay so that or means that it's any person period any VOR period any potential vendor Peri period any entity doing business with the school period but it says other entity and so when you put the word other rather than an entity in it I think it changes and clarifies that all of these apply to doing business with the school district so if again if it said that you can't solicit a gift directly or IND indirectly in excess of $50 from any person vendor potential vendor or an entity doing business with the school district rather than other entity I I think there's a difference in the meaning of those

087two when you put the word other in that am I at all clear no I understand your position I and that is a plausible way of reading it I'm not sure it's the way I read it but it is a plausible way to read it so again this is where I think I need to go ahead and make sure that my research is 100% certain I am 98% certain but I will make sure it's 100% certain and at the end of the day folks again I can give advice and you could say Thank you Mr pomerini I appreciate it but you know I think I read it the other way and so I'm going to govern myself that way that is up to you all as elected officials to if how you feel comfortable with

088doing that so I look this won't be the first time that I've given some advice and you all have disagreed with it and gone the other way doesn't hurt my feelings it's what it is I no so John I know you I think you said you might disagree I know you disagree with it that the word other is very significant and was put in there for a reason rather than an entity but going back to I don't remember I think it might have been bird or no I think it was Gallow talking about how extreme that interpretation is so that would mean that none of my kids my cousins my grandmother my mother could go out to dinner with somebody if the other person picked up $60 worth of the meal and I think that's

089honestly such a bizarre interpretation that would have been the intent and the fact that there was no reason to put the word other if they meant and so I don't think you're going to find a case on point in all likelihood but I think that's the justification that others and myself would find if any if I do this or family member does and I'm ever brought up on an Ethics charge that's going to be the leg that I stand on and I think it's pretty strong I do appreciate you trying to do some research on it yeah no I listen I will do the research on it and I will come back to you and I'll let you know what I find or or if I don't find and if there's a like I said

090if there's a disagreement then it wouldn't be the first time it certainly won't be the last time and you all have to do what you feel comfortable with and what you think it is so yeah I appreciate that could you do one other thing because I know you're really plugged in with the I don't know what the term is it the school board law association yeah I think are you still president I am yeah so I'm pretty sure some attorneys see this $50 as only applying to entities doing business or people doing business if you have if you know some of those folks would you ask them for their justification of of reading it differently yeah that's not a problem okay yeah I know and I and I began this by saying that other attorneys

091differ in their interpretation than than what mine is so and yeah yeah I'm just curious about their yeah their reasoning and I have a feeling it's going to come down I've I've had this debate with attorneys for a while over when other gets used and what its meaning is and so I'd be interested in what those attorneys base their their opinion on all right thanks guys sorry for taking up so much time on this that's okay thank you chair Jacobs member Fant so I think chair Jacob's kind of covered what I was going to say because I had pulled up the statute here but really I mean the way I read it is that if you're meeting with somebody and they're giving you a gift to sway your views or your belief or anything like

092that because they are or want to do business with the school district that is what I see for that if you're going and you get a gift from a friend and you have no idea that they even are a vendor with the district like you just have no idea maybe they're the an AC contractor or they work for an AC contracting business that does stuff with the district and they're your neighbor and they gave you know a $100 gift card to eat somewhere and you didn't realize like I think it's when you're willingly receiving gifts MH because they're trying to sway weigh your views that is how I mean I'm not a lawyer but that's kind of how I interpret it so I think in the same way we're it's like I feel like I

093wouldn't go around like being freaked out to receive gifts but like if I don't know the person and they're just like randomly I would obviously want to figure out why they're doing that but I think I don't know that's the way I feel like it was written for just my two cents listen I I understand that I've just given unpopular opinion and I will research it I will see if I think other people have different reasoning and if I am open to being persuaded well and to you said something interesting when you said you know you can give advice but ultimately you know we're elected officials and we have to govern ourselves right so I kind of along that same line I kind of would wonder why we have certain policies in place with board

094members because there really isn't any disciplinary action that can be taken on board members for certain policies which I would which is some of the reason for policies but but I do think that the you know like with lobbying and different areas like that and some of and I guess the gifts it's good to let other people know what they can and can't do with board members but you know it's just I don't know it's an interesting take member Gallow did you buzz in again yeah just a quick question and I'm sure you have Mr pomerini but have you reviewed the staff analysis from 2012 when this bill was implemented for Schoolboard members I did it was a long time ago so I so I'm just curious if there's something in there that might help

095clarify I will intent I will relook at it but what I almost remember and this happens more times and you and you know this happens more times what the staff analysis will do is repeat the statutory language and do nothing more and which is sometimes there's misinformation and staff analysis well I wasn't going to say that however many times it just repeats the statutory language which makes it not helpful at all I seem to remember that on this one but I'll relook thank you okay do you want to go ahead and cover what you want to cover in the chart sure so going down on page one was that sorry I just had a knat run across my paper that was great when you look down at the last two columns gifts and gratuitous meals

096the policy itself limits gifts and gratuitous meals to $5 instead of the board member limit of 50 and the ripe limit of $100 so that is an obvious difference between state law and what your policy has and then one time make decisions on that page and move forward so we don't have to at the end go all the way back through that's a great idea member Gallow would you mind Mr pomerini no okay we have member chair or the chair actually that wants to speak thank you I don't know I just lost audio a minute ago can youall hear me yes we can hear you okay just very briefly John I know this gift interpretation isn't popular but just for the record my reason for disagreement isn't about whether I like it or don't like

097it I just sincerely don't think it's correct with all due respect thank you chair Jacobs you're welcome okay member Gallow thank you madam chair so in this particular on this particular page the last two which is what we're discussing I would recommend that we utilize the legislative intent on oversight over the board only because no one's going to be swayed for $5 I there Ain no board member up here that's going to be swayed for $50 but if if there was an Ethics violation it would go to the it would go to the Ethics Committee it would get it would get sent to there would have to be an accus and then someone would have to send it to the Ethics Committee and the ethics commission would have oversight over if they would take it

098up and if we were in they're wrong or not if someone sends them something that a board member took something for $5 the ethics commission doesn't care and so to member Bird's point there is no teeth in this policy so to hold board members or others to $5 when board members are already at 50 versus everybody else is at 100 we already have we'll just take a reduced amount I think we should just follow state law and follow the guidelines given to us that is in statute so me Miss cotus points out on page eight we have an actual provision that says gifts to board members board members shall comply with applicable provisions of Florida law regarding the solicitation acceptance and disclosure of any gifts so the gift provision would not apply to you all

099because the more specific provision dealing with gifts that says we'll comply with Florida law we be what's there I think gratuitous meals at some point do apply to board members in in the policy so what we can do with respect to gratuitous meals is we can eliminate board member from that provision okay so you would really want to eliminate both of these because one's contradicting the other anyways well remember this is also applying to your employees as well but it says for board member oh cuz you're just yeah I'm just reting people so we could just take do we want to talk about that for employees that's huh okay okay wait a minute wait a member gallow the language is on page eight it should be subsection five that says gifts to board members and

100so that is basically saying board members are subject to applicable Florida law I think the appropriate action is under the section on gratuitous meals which is page five just eliminate the board the reference to board members and just have it read a procurement official the ethics compliance officer or any staff member with Contracting Authority there hold on hold on hold on go remember I told you earlier that we had the non the non- redline version of the policy you got to look at the non Redline the non- redline version of the policy is what you need to be looking at cuz that's where the page reference or right okay so for clarification the First Column is referring to page two where the policy has the definitions correct okay so in our policy we Define gifts

101as anything of value exceeding $5 but does not include blah blah blah blah blah gratuitous meals is anything in excess of $5 and then then in the policy is where page five and page eight is where it's talking about how much board members May accept or how much employees May accept the 50 and the 100 it's not saying that we can't accept $5 anything over $5 it's just describing giving a definition to what a gift is in this policy and what a meal is in this policy correct but I think for the sake of consist y since most of the policy does not apply to board members if we're going to say on page eight in subsection 5 that board members shall comply with all appicable provisions of Florida law regarding a gift a meal

102could constitute a gift if you're invited to an event and there is a meal that is part of attending that event so rather than create confusion if you just eliminate the reference to board member in this section on page five that begins gratuitous meals gifts and certain travel restrictions you'll eliminate any confusion between that language and the general reference to complying with Florida Statutes we would also it's also in the definition of gratuitous meal as well it says to any board member so we would have to remove it from that definition as well right so Madam member Gallow I guess the issue so on page five under under gratuitous meals and certain travel restrictions when it defines gratuitous meals but when you when you go back to the beginning of the policy under gifs and

103gratuitous Mills number N9 and 10 on page two it clearly states in both of those that the no value exceeding $5 so in one area it's defined one way and another area it's defined with that amount limit in it right but I think the gratuitous meal section is talking about generally you shouldn't accept anything over $5 however if you attend a conference and a meal is given at a conference there's flexibility in the value of that meal if the conference is put on by a nonprofit versus a conference that's put on for a vendor and the point of that is if you go to a conference and the vendor invites you to a special dinner the theory is that you shouldn't be accepting that any meal that exceeds the $25 I thought it was it

104says 25 for food and then 50 for gifts is that what it is for board members what what is the LW state for gtus Mills for board members is it $25 per state law or 50 I it's just the 50 it's just the 50 then where's the 25 coming from your policy okay so maybe to be consistent I would suggest that we adhere to state law just because I think that's the easy and cleanest way to do it we're already held at a much higher standard than other elected officials and I feel like it would be easier and clearer for everybody involved including our employees if what we set forth is just very consistent with law that would be my recommendation because when we go to our conferences the majority of time when we're at

105those conferences even if the company is nonprofit the people paying for that are vendors they're there because they want our time they're there because they want to have access to us and what they do is they just they will you know they'll have like six or seven vendors and then that way it's it's $50 per vendor and so I want I mean I want to make sure that we're transparent and we're accountable and I don't want improprieties to happen and I know that we have guard rails in place so that bad actors get caught but it shouldn't be so stringent that it creates an undue burden on our employees or on the board members and based on what I do for a job and some parts of this policy I would do nothing but fill

106out forms all day long but but but kce the way it's written with the language on page8 it is exempting the board from the gift definition and it's as basically applying existing floral law to board members and gifts so the rest of this policy would apply to District employees other than the board members and so what that gratuit is meal section should be revised to say is that if select employees whether they're procurement people or myself as the ethics compliance officer or staff attorneys with Contracting Authority we generally don't accept anything above $5 but if we attend an event and a meal is given then we can accept a meal within certain parameters depending on who's sponsoring the event so the so the goal would be to eliminate the reference to board member in the

107gratuitous meal section and in the definition of gratuitous meals that I think is at the bottom of page two and then that way you have the consistency of a gift is whatever Florida law defines it to be as to a board member okay I just I'm I'm fine with that but going back to our like the $5 like so in my mind why do why even have an amount there why just not say you can't accept anything from anybody at any time because to put a dollar amount in there at $5 is ridiculous I don't even know that you can get a pack of gum anymore for $5 as I understand it that was meant to cover sort of trinkets that sometimes vendors send that you know are Bost with a vendor's logo and the

108employees can take it and not necessarily have to worry about whether they have violated the gift provision there are other Provisions in here if we get to them which talks about you know Gifts of food that are given to employees as long as the gift is to 10 or more employees a vendor can make that gift a nonprofit can make that gift and the reason the 10 or more was selected is that you know a vendor who do decides to send send breakfast to a department is not going to endear themselves in a way that taking one employee out for an expensive meal or buying one employee a gift card May produce a more targeted result if a vendor is trying to endear themselves to someone that has Contracting Authority or can influence whether or

109not they get a contract or they continue a contract okay thank that and that makes sense I just I think of scenarios especially like at the school based level where for example Chick-fil-A is a vendor sure but yet Chick-fil-A will bring free food in all the time for teachers and staff right that would be over $5 in some cases it could be over $25 especially if you eat two sandwiches and two fries right so it's just so in those instances is this some things in this policy just don't make sense I understand the intent when it comes to procurement I understand the intent especially we're in that blackout period and what not we want to make sure that we uphold very stringent guidelines for our employees so that in Prior something improper doesn't happen because

110we don't ever want to be accused of being dishonest in our negotiations with our vendors but I think that there needs to be some flexibility within that so that it makes sense and member Gallow there is I mean during the holidays when when departments are being sent gift baskets and boxes of chocolate if they're sent to one person and we get the call and it says well can I can I accept this it came from vendor so and so the advice is always put it out for the Department to share and you're free to accept it because the policy does allow now those types of things like a pizza party if a if a local pizza entity wants to send pizzas to a school and they happen to be a vendor if if they're sending

111it to one person that creates a different outcome than if they're sending it to the whole school and so the policy does allow for that this is the policy as I understand it is intended to eliminate a targeted gift of some that will impress upon an individual who may lean positively in favor of an entity because of that gift thank you I appreciate that I appreciate that explanation all right I'm gonna let's hear from other board members Madam chair can we take a few minutes because my day can't get any better I'm getting security alerts from my bank account okay we're going to take a 10-minute reset yes and we'll be back he oh oh no o hey n n n n n n a n okay board members are we ready y okay we're

112going to get back started again Mr pomerini do you want to continue we don't have any more speakers on the page one okay I think just for ease for the board to the extent that these rules apply to board members with regard to gifts gratuitous meals all of it I think what I've heard is just for us to have direction to go back and make revisions to all of that throughout the policy so instead of going through all of that here we'll just go ahead and do that and bring back those changes to you all is that acceptable board yes I think everybody thinks that would be just fine okay and with respect to limits on employees is it the board's will to apply limits on employees consistent with state law or do you want

113the more stringent definitions here I would propose that we stick with state law does everyone agree on that I I would agree to that I would love to hear if the superintendent would like to weigh in I just want to make sure she has no heartburn with us just keeping it with state law no I think it would make it easier on all parties if we have the law to just fall back on and not have to worry about any challenges to it so I definitely am agreement wonderful hold on Mr pommer one second I have you queued in was that just to comment on that okay go ahead okay the next thing I wanted to go to is actually I think that's going to what we've just done is going to clean up a

114lot of what we needed to do here but there's just a couple other things I wanted to to address then if you go to page four of the chart where it says registration of lobbyists I just wanted to point out that there is a you know especially with with certain procurements and other events we've had lately with respect to how lobbyists are registered and all of that there is a standard in state law that talks about you know how lobbyists can give gifts there's not necessarily a registration standard with respect to school boards and state law but you all also tasked us to look around the state to see what we had versus what there was with regard to registration of lobbyist we've looked and by we I mean Miss cotus looked Broward Hillsboro Miami

115Dade Palm Beach all have lobbyist registration policies that they have so it would be consistent with the other large districts to have a lobus registration policy it isn't technically required by state law but wanted to get the board's Direction one way or the other thank you Mr pomerini I'm was actually queued into to speak to page 4 so I appreciate the research finding out what other districts do I think that it's totally appropriate to have a registration of lobbyists I think it's beneficial for everybody to be able to look up and see if someone is a registered lobbyist I do have just some and I don't even know if I have a preference either way but I do think that you know maybe the registration process could be looked at I don't know if you've

116looked at if feather boards do every year that they have to register because I'm wondering are we doing that are we checking in do we go through that whole list every year and make sure that they've all re-registered or like how is that even monitored that one we do mic sorry the registration process is driven by the individual not the entity so there is an annual process because sometimes people cycle out okay so a company May hire ABC group to represent them as lobbyist but if the individual who's going to Lobby on behalf of that group before the board changes then that individual will register through Le services and the forms that we have online okay so but it's up to them to be to do that because my only concern is you know I

117don't as a board member I don't know if someone has registered unless I guess I could check with you if someone's trying to have a meeting with me I would check with you to make sure they're registered Lobby I would assume most all lobbyists know that they have to be registered lobbyists but you know I just don't know like what the checks and balances is for us on not that part the gray area Falls when you have a business because parents are Exempted government officials are Exempted representatives of nonprofits are Exempted school-based organizations like ptas things of that nature they're Exempted so and even an attorney who's representing a client or a legal guardian who's representing a student they're all Exempted from the definition of l obious so it's really only when someone is going

118to approach you on behalf of a business entity that you have to wonder if they're a lobbyist and again it becomes a question of are they meeting with you to try and sway you on something that may come before the board if they're meeting with you to have a general discussion about some topic that may be pressing in your District but it's not something that you can foresee will be an issue before the board they don't have to be registered as a lobbyist it again I mean I hate to say this but it's context and out of an abundance of caution if someone is going to solicit you or other members of the board they should be registered as a lobbyist sometimes I do get calls from individuals that say I'm going to reach out

119to the board this is what I want to talk about do you think I need to register and based on what they tell me I say yes or I say no that's an Ideal World sometimes it doesn't happen that way but out of an abundance of caution we do ask folks to register if they believe that they will be representing a business's interest with you as a board member okay thank you that's that's helpful the no that's okay I'm not going to do that reports the reports that's not on page four though you haven't gotten there yet but I wanted to whenever we get to it when we're talking about lobbying I want to talk I would like to bring up the reports that we have to sign when we when people Lobby us has

120board members I think employees it might be a little different but with the board members it's extremely difficult to be able to do remember Gallow kind of referred to it a little bit earlier in her line of work but we are as board members you know we I sit on numerous boards in the community we are in the business Community constantly I there are numerous business owners that come and talk to me all the time when we go to conferences we talk to 20 different vendors within a week at a conference so I feel like there I just have a little bit of concerns about our requirements around the reports I do feel like there needs to be reports I understand the reasoning behind it I just I just kind of wanted to have a

121little discussion about that and if you could help help facilitate that discussion or if any other board board members have any other input on that I don't really know what the answer is I just know that it's very challenging as an elected official to document every single interaction we have with someone that is a you know a business owner or has a product or whatever and I also and I understand that needs to be public record I would also argue that our schedules are public record our emails are public record our even cell phone records are public record so I'm just wondering about that and I would also like to know you know what the statute says about that and how this differs maybe from what like other elected officials like Orange County government what

122they what those Commissioners have to do they fill out forms every time they speak to someone I'm I just want to see if we're doing things unnecessarily too stringent or if we're right where we should be just want to have a little discussion about that thank you member bird most of these lobbying policies the purpose of them is to create transparency in terms of who is trying to influence the business of the public entity in preparation for the September meeting discuss discussion regarding KC I went back and listened to the 2012 presentation to the board when KC was first brought up and it was a presentation given by then general counsel Woody Rodriguez and the chair at the time Bill sablet and they indicated that this policy was an attempt by the district to create

123an Ethics policy it was modeled off of Orange County's policy which was implemented in 2008 orange policies Orange County's policy has not changed since 2008 in a similar fashion our policy has not been revised since 2012 Orange County has a lobbying policy they require the registration of lobbyist and they do require the lobbyist to complete a form of who they met with as far as I can tell there is not a corresponding requirement for the public official to fill out a form the way this policy is written ideally there should be a match there should be two forms there should be the form from the lobbyist and the form from the board member that sat in the meeting and each form essentially dovetails we had a meeting on the same day these are the people

124we met with and generally what was discussed I understand it can be overwhelming when you interact with folks who are lobbyists to to fill out these forms but I would suggest that we focus on the definition of lobbying and lobbying is an action that is meant to influence a foreseeable action of the school board it's so it's meant to influence a foreseeable event before the school board so I think the extent of the reporting is based on the conversation you're having so if you're going to event and you're mingling with people I don't think you're having the kind of conversation where someone is trying to influence a position that you may take on a foreseeable action of the board maybe maybe not I mean I I just don't know and really that is the standard

125here again if it's a parent if it's someone from a PTA if it's another government official that you're having the conversation with they're not lobbyists and so you wouldn't have to report that communication but this can be changed as I said orange counties requires reporting from the lobbyist side it doesn't require reporting from the public official side and maybe that is because of what you're saying that your calendars are public you know your meetings are recorded in in such a way I don't have background as to why orange counties was written that way I know that our policy was modeled off of orange counties thank you I appreciate the facilitation of that discussion a little bit that helped a lot I'm going to he I would like to hear from my other board members on

126this we've got member Gallow thank you madam chair so I don't I'm fine with the lobbyist registering have to register with us so we know who the lobbyist is I do think that's that's helpful and the House of Representative actually it's not a law but they do have a rule that anybody who is a registered lobbyist has to register as a lobbyist and even register the topic that they will be lobbying on so you'll see like a lobbyist name and all the various entities that they represent and they have to do that before they can go in and speak to anybody in the House of Representatives Senate has different different rules I think that it would be great if and I don't know if this is possible if once the lobbyist registers if it could

127be in a searchable database attached somewhere so as a board member I can see who's registered and who's not just for like as Melissa mentioned we meet a lot of different people that with a lot of different products when we're at different conferences and it could be any conference it could be Excel and Ed which is a fabulous conference you're going to have vendors there who want to tell you about their product they may not be registered because that I was we were in Oklahoma City they may be the Oklahoma City people but it would be it would be good for for me to be able to go online and be okay well the Oklahoma people may not be registered but there is somebody registered from this company with Orange County and then it would

128be it would also be a reminder to me to say hey are you registered if you're going to have a conversation with me I need you to register I'm with member bird on the forms because it gets a little bit murky like some of them are slam dunks I had two meetings this past week and a half with vendors it was very I knew what they wanted to speak to me about it was very there was no doubt in my mind that I needed to fill out the forms I filled out the forms I gave them to Vivian others are little like people that we've never done business with or they just tell me about their product wouldn't necessarily fill out a form on that because they're just letting me know that they have a

129product available there's been other times that I've gotten emails or I've talked to somebody I'm like hey shoot me an email I will forward it to the people that might apply to and if they think that's relevant they'll talk to you and all I am is a conduit for that information I don't usually fill out forms for that because in my mind they came to me I don't even know if we have a use I don't know if we have a need I'm giving it to the people that would have that information and they could take it from there and that's usually the extent of the conversation that I had so because it's just kind of murky I'm wondering if we do just put the onus on on the lobbyist and maybe add some oversight

130to ensure that everybody we talk to is an actual lobbyist because now I'm going through things in my mind of people that I've spoken to and it's been no secret because I've had conversations with Mr pomerini with the superintendent so you all will know who I'm talking about that they that the same person has multiple conversations with the board so it's not like I'm hiding anything you know I'm having conversations but like in that instance I couldn't even tell you right now if they're registered lobbyists with lch County okay good thank you but it would be nice that I would be able to check that myself I just want to make sure that I'm following the law and then I have a question about the first the first item on four where it talks about

131the provision to prohibit vendors from paying for ocps employees travel or attendance at conferences or meetings I know that sometimes we are able to get scholarships especially if it's a really great conference like maybe it's an IT conference that it's really important that we want to send people to but it's expensive like we get scholarships and we get grants would they be allowed to attend if the scholarship or the grants came from a vendor to go to a conference that there would be it would be more of an informational conference and there'll be a lot more like vendors there would that be allowed under this policy so generally when we are when we have an agreement if the department anticipates that there is a conference that will help them administer the contract we build it

132into the contract that our staff can attend whatever the conference is and it happens across the board we have transportation folks that attend conferences the you know particularly about electric buses or things of that nature we build it into curriculum materials we can certainly build it into processes if we know in advance most of the time the vendors will invite an employee to a conference if it's part of a presentation opportunity for the employee if they call me and they say am I able to go my question is always are you going to be recorded and if you are going to be recorded what's the recording going to be used for the vendor will always agree that whatever recording is done is only used for their internal purposes and many of these vendors require a

133letter from me authorizing the employee to accept the offer of travel or attendance at a conference because they want to make sure that they are not barred from a future procurement because they have made that offer to the employee and so the goal is always to allow it particularly if it is directly associated with a program that employee is administering on behalf of the district okay that's helpful information and then my last question I saw that there is I guess a $25 lobbying fee that lobbyists have to fill out to be a lobbyist is that per entity that they're representing or just hey I'm a lobbyist here's my $25 I can talk to youall about anything I want it's per individual okay and it is not limited to a subject matter so if they send

134the form in and they say here's my $25 and I am lobbying on behalf of a corporation B Corporation C corporation that is all in the form they submit it's $125 fee and that's the end of it that's why we require the annual renewal because if we did it by institution we wouldn't necessarily track who the individual is that's actually doing the lobbying sure that Mak sense and what does the $25 go tool $25 is paid into is paid paid into the district's general fund and it's the fee that was established to process the paperwork okay okay thank you thank you member Gallow member Vanos thank you madam Vice chair I just wanted to going along with what member bird said you know also just wanted to agree with her on the meetings with vendors

135because for me sometimes I reach out or sometimes a vendor might reach out to me and maybe their intent is to Lobby me but my intent is to find out as much information about what they're doing as possible so you know I think some so sometimes that's just for me that's the purpose of the meeting is there the expert on you know some particular issue that I have really no idea about so I'm going for me it's a learning meeting and I'm asking them questions about their industry and I'm asking them well why this and why that as as you would probably expect of me and so you know I don't so I would just like to Echo that I don't know that's lobbing I love the idea of having some kind of requirement with

136an ocps that lobbyists have to register and you know wonder if maybe it's part of that registration I mean can we just require them if they meet with a Schoolboard member to include that that they put that in there they the lobbyist is already required to complete the form okay it in your example if you're meeting with a vendor the vendor already has a business relationship with the district so if the vendor is meeting with you to explain what they do with the district they're not really trying to influence you unless somewhere in that conversation it's we also can provide you other services and so foreseeably maybe you will be voting on those other services at some point in your role as a board member so it's a it's a gray area but a vendor

137wouldn't have to register as a lobbyist if their attitude is I already have a business relationship and I'm talking to the board member about my existing business relationship okay and I guess but sometimes applies to to someone who isn't a vendor I think yeah because maybe it's maybe it's for something that we don't we haven't hired someone maybe in the future we're thinking about it's something new and I don't understand it so I want to learn more about it they approach me but I'm you know asking the questions and I think the searchable database will solve some of these issues because if if you are regularly being approached by folks that are not registered as a lobbyist and you let me know I am able to reach out to that person and say you may

138not be aware we have a lobbying policy would you please register as a lobbyist I'm happy to walk you through the process here because you're meeting with board members whether you're intending or you're not intending to try and influence them it would be appropriate given my understanding of your Communications that you register as a lobbyist okay that's great and then just one other question I just want to clarify something that you said when you were talking about the definition of a lobbyist did you say something about attorneys were not included in that I said if an attorney is approaching you on behalf of a student or a parent they are not considered a lobbyist okay they are representing their client and they would not fall under the definition of a lobbyist got it okay and

139then are we just kind of sticking to this area now or we is the whole policy open for questions just a page okay got it thank you thank you member Salam Mona yeah I was I was just going to back up to what the previous member said on on the form that it really is I have some our meetings who member of ano said where I reach out because I want to learn not to be influenced even if like that's their intention truly and so if there's a database that's great but I do think that the current form as it stands is a pretty heavy burden and hard to consistently and uniformly abide by cuz I think we all have perhaps different definitions on that and so I think generally my approach to this whole

140policy is if there's not a lot of teeth to something and we are very we defer from what the state statute is then I rather us not have it because it just means more overhead on us individually and so I understand the reason behind why we did it I get that I also think that in future boards are probably going to encounter this even more we just especially as Orange County we're such a large district and we have so many public private Partnerships and so many nonprofit like we just are like we have conversations with a lot of different people and I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing but it I don't want to discouraged having those conversations because there's all overhead associated with it that doesn't have a lot of teeth either well

141and I don't think that the policy was created to create teeth as to a board member I think the policy was to allow staff to be informed if a vendor for example if a vendor is reaching out to you during the new contact period the vendors aware they're in the middle of the no contact period you may not be aware of it so if I were to get a form and I know that we're in the middle of a no contact period I reach out to that vendor and say you know you're not supposed to be talking to a board member yes if if that is repeated conduct the policy builds in the opportunity for me to come before the board and to ask that some sort of a disciplinary action be applied to a

142vendor depending on the circumstance so I think part of this was intended to inform staff who may be approaching you if someone is violating a no contact I think the no like the no contact example makes sense in this context but this is yeah it just the other we're talking about the form particularly I understand that one doesn't really serve that purpose either because you know my team who's scheduling stuff they don't know the intention behind it I'm not update like or if they see something on my calendar I prefer we just put the burden on them rather than us there's a lot more of them with a lot more staff than there of us sometimes great is there any are we good any response to that or no okay member Douglas I just want

143to say that I mean this is the first time for me and it's really a lot and a lot of great areas I don't even know where to start thinking but I just would like to think about that talk about again about the report that we're talking about is that the form that you're referring to that the report the form are they the same thing the form that yeah when we have to fill out forms if we're at a conference and we talk to V I mean that's a lot and and member dougas I believe the recommendation of the board is to eliminate the form at least for the board members to complete we're still going to maintain that the lobbyists complete the form okay thank you that's thank you member Douglas on that same

144note is it possible possibly to do what like Orange County does when you go to speak when you go register when you go to speak to a commissioner you sign in on the computer putting your name who you are who you're with who you're going to speak to and why you're going to speak to them and that's all done digitally right on the computer I would love to see that because actually as a board member it might be helpful for me to see which lobbyist who the lobbyists are meeting with if I could look up hey this lobbyist has met with every board member and now they're asking to meet with me about XYZ that's that's sometime informative to me before I have a meeting with someone so if there's any way we could do

145that registration electronically and the reason for the meeting that might be great I will have to check on that okay superintendent wants to speak just one comment on that board members don't always meet with the lobbyist here so I think there needs to be I mean I think that's a great idea because if they're here it's much easier because they have to sign in anyway certainly but just to keep in mind that it doesn't always happen here good point yes that's true okay the board is clear go take your chance so there's other I think most of honestly when I'm going through this list there's I think I've got the direction that you all want to go I'm not going to to belabor it there's a se you know obviously we have this whole section

146delineated for the ethics compliance officer that does not isn't required by law but I don't recommend removing that in any way shape or form because Vivian's here to keep you all out of out of any issues with respect to that so I would recommend keeping it quite frankly though but I think the rest of it I understand where you all are coming from and we can do a red line to get you all where you want to go so it that will take some time obviously she and I will have to sit down and go through it unless yeah unless there's any other yeah I was getting there okay all right sorry that's all right unless there are any other sections you all want to cover in this list I think we're good I would

147agree with that I'd like to see what you guys bring back and then we can dig in more but member Gallow did but in so go ahead thank you madam chair so earlier Mr primary and I discussed something that was of concern to me because it would hurt the vendor so under what you just said we that would just revert to state law correct that's that's the direct the direction I understand is everywhere where it needs to revert to state law it reverts to state law okay perfect that's all I that's I would make sure understood that thank you great and thank you Mr pomerini for wrapping us up quickly on this one quicker than it needed to be I see that Mr Russo here has moved up towards the front but I did just

148get a note that if the board is interested in taking a break there is some food in the back if you feel like you need that do we want to do that or do we want to just keep moving on because we do still have two more things to do great okay let's do a short one guys 15 minutes thank Youk you n oh n you oh oh a oh n a n n n n n he oh okay yeah oh oh oh a okay I think we're ready to begin again hello thank you for everyone that has joined us I'm going to turn it over to Dr Vasquez M I'm so excited that we have Dr Russo here to help present the information on the progress and successes of our students in our comprehensive

149Advanced Studies program what you're going to see is that we've made some incredible strides we still have areas where we want to grow but overall I can say I'm extremely proud of the work of our teachers our students and our staff to bring about the supports necessary so our students are successful in the advanced programming so Dr Russo turning it over to you all right thank you just want to make sure the presentation is showing on the screen oh there we go perfect all right Dr Russo I don't know that your mic's on because I think I turned it off when I left you got it yeah there you go there we go all right good afternoon Vice chair bird board members and superintendent Vasquez today we are here to provide a strategic Plan update

150for advanced studies participation and performance for the 2023 2024 school year the advanced studies Department within curriculum and digital learning directly supports the ocps 2025 strategic plan objective of high expectations for student learning by supporting students and teachers through increasing participation and performance in meaningful accelerated Pathways shown on this slide are the advanced studies programs offered throughout ocps during this presentation we will discuss advanced placement or AP Cambridge assessment International Education or Cambridge the international Balor or IB while the majority of our programs can be found at high schools we have expanded program access to include both elementary and middle schools through the consideration of community needs and feeder patterns additionally to help clarify terms we will be using throughout the presentation we have created an FAQ document that was provided to you and can

151also be access by clicking on the slide header does everybody have an FAQ document yeah okay to provide further insights I would like to introduce Dr Rebecca hunt director of advanced studies who will share additional key highlights and data thank you Dr Russo thank you Dr Russo to begin we will highlight districtwide Trends and individual core successes for AP Cambridge and IB let's delve into the impressive achiev of our AP students in the 2023 2024 school year a remarkable 48441 students earned the prestigious AP scholar award recognizing their dedication and success and achieving scores of three or higher on three or more AP exams this represents a significant increase of 720 AP Scholars compared to the 2022 2023 school year showcasing the growing success of our students challenging themselves with rigorous coursework additionally 192 students

152earned the coveted AP Capstone diploma signifying their completion of rigorous coursework in AP seminar AP research and four additional AP exams of their choice this represents a slight increase from the 190 AP Capstone diplomas earned in the 2022 2023 school year our students who took the new AP pre-calculus course demonstrated exceptional performance achieving a district passing rate of 72% among the senior students who took and passed this course as their highest level Math course an impressive 48% earned their first college credits the 2024 AP exam pass rate for ocps was 59% marking the highest rate since 2016 and a significant 6% increase compared to the 2023 AP exam series our newest program Cambridge Advanced achieved remarkable success in the 2023 2024 school year a total of 336 students earn the Cambridge Advanced international certificate of

153Education or Ace diploma compared to 251 Ace diplomas earned in the 2022 2023 school year this accomplishment allows students to qualify for the Florida academic Scholars 100% scholarship award through the Florida bright future scholarship program without meeting the act or sat requirement furthermore 93% of Cambridge Ace diploma students who would not have otherwise qualified were able to achieve the prestigious Florida academic Scholars award through the successful completion of their Ace diploma ocps Cambridge students outperform students nationally in a variety of courses including literature and English as level with a district pass rate of 63% compared to the National pass rate of 61% our students also surpass the national pass rate and the English General Paper as level course with a district-wide pass rate of 7 7% compared to the National pass rate of 73% the

154high success rate in this introductory course sets students up for Success on their path to achieving the ace diploma with the expansion of Cambridge offerings at our Traditional High Schools ocps was awarded Cambridge large District of the year for its increased access to rigorous Cambridge curriculum and strong student performance on Cambridge exams over the last three years our long tradition of success with the international aalor or IB program has continued with 170 students earning the prestigious IB diploma building upon the success of the 2022 2023 school year which saw 164 students achieve this distinction this accomplishment allows students to qualify for the Florida academic Scholars 100% scholarship award through the Florida bright future scholarship program without meeting the act or sat requirement 58% of IB diploma students who would not have otherwise qualified were able

155to achieve the prestigious Florida academic Scholars award through the successful completion of their IB diploma furthermore the theory of knowledge course which is essential for students to earn the IB diploma had a district passing rate of 83% ocps IB students outperform students globally in the following subjects history HL or higher level with a district pass rate of 81% compared to the global pass rate of 71% business management SL or standard level with a district pass rate of 74% compared to the global pass rate of 72% it's important to note that HL courses require at least 240 hours of study typically spanning two school years while SL courses require at least 150 hours of study typically completed in one school year let's take a look at the growth of advanced studies exam participation over the past

1563 years analysis of advanced studies exam participation reveals a significant upward Trend as Illustrated in the bar graph participation has St increased with 37,8 5 exams taken in the 21 2022 school year 44893 in the 2022 2023 school year and 54419 in the 2023 2024 school year this represents a notable 41% increase from the 2021 2022 school year to the 2023 2024 school year indicating growing student engagement in advanced coursework further looking at individual programs the number of AP exams increased to 36497 in the 2023 2024 school year the expansion of the Cambridge Advanced program across all Traditional ocps High Schools led to a substantial increase in Cambridge exams reaching 15,980 additionally IB exam participation Rose to 1,938 we will now transition to a discussion of performance on Advanced study spring 2024 exams Orange County

157Public School's advanced placement exam performance was similar to other large districts within the State of Florida ocps students passed 21546 AP exams during the May 2024 exam Administration equating to 59% of students receiving a qualifying score of 3 four or five this is a 6% increase when compared to the May 2023 exam pass rate of 53% in the 2023 2024 exam Administration these 21546 passing scores led to 11 18,24 college credits saving ocus families approximately $23.6 million in college tuition this is based on the State University's average cost of $200 and8 cents per credit hour and the maximum number of credit hours students are eligible to receive according to the FD credit by exam equivalencies ocps Cambridge students took their examin in April May and June of the 2023 2024 school year districtwide Cambridge Advanced

158exam performance has increased from 5,121 exams passed to 9,441 exams passed showing an 84% increase from the 2022 2023 school year as a result ocps Cambridge students earned 29,6 college credits saving ocps families approximately $5.8 million in college tuition based on the State University Systems average cost per credit hour IB performance in the 2023 2024 school year remains steud with national exam performance ocps IB students successfully passed 1,755 exams in the spring 2024 exam series compared to 1593 exams in the spring 2023 exam series Ivy students earned 7,440 college credits saving ocps families approximately $1.5 million in college tuition based on the State University Systems average cost per credit hour let's now take a look at enrollment and participation in advanced studies courses which includes advanced placement Cambridge Advanced and the international Balor ocps has

159remained overall steady in providing College equivalent coursework options showing a 21% increase in student enrollments to further clarify the substantial increase is a result of advanced stud's program expansions and Department structures focusing on our goal to make it day's course is more accessible to any student willing to take on the challenge of these rigorous programs ocps offerings to students with Advanced Studies Pathways have continued to grow in the last year we have added 13 new Advanced Studies programs at our Traditional High Schools increasing participation and providing students diverse Pathways to success Advanced Studies programs offer at the elementary and middle school levels prepare students for rigorous coursework through the development of outstanding transferable skills skills that include critical thinking research and collaboration in our high schools we've continued to focus on providing diverse Pathways to

160success for students for example allowing students to be a Cambridge Advanced Ace diploma seeking student IB diploma seeking student or take individual courses that best fit their post-secondary plans additionally through the ocps.net homepage by selecting current families then selecting academic pass under the quick link section ocps families can access the ocps academic pass web page to explore Advanced days options available to their students our Advanced Studies supports to continue to focus on student needs and the premise that high school students many of who will be first generation college students need experiences in high school that are well aligned with higher education practices to ensure that Student Success translates to their post-secondary path holistically the research has indicated that the skills gained through these types of support can impact students personal growth and success in college

161and included in the support we offer to students is AP tutoring which is offered all year at ocps high schools for each AP subject Club testing sessions are offered three times throughout the school year or students have the option of participating in a week-long summer camp that prepares students for the culminating KP exam at the end of the summer our Advanced Studies Symposium is designed to empower Rising Juniors connecting them with colleges and universities student organizations and financial aid experts where students can begin to build their post-secondary portfolios addition Ally they can learn about Advanced course options to enhance their High School experience furthermore our active participation in parent nights at our high schools help us provide valuable information regarding Advanced St Pathways available to students to ensure that students are set up for Success

162we provide a multitude of teacher professional learning opportunities with ap Cambridge and IB that include topics such as data available resources program development and subject specific content teachers can participate in AP Cambridge and IB professional learning throughout the school year and summer ocps also offers district-wide plc's to advance days teachers plcs are offered three times per school year to support collaboration and growth in a variety of subject areas additionally we provide support to program coordinators with quarterly meetings School support visits and examination support thank you and I will now turn this presentation back over to superintendent Vasquez for any additional comments thank you Dr Hunt and Dr Russo board members as you can see we've really made some wonderful strides across subgroups across the various offerings within our Advanced Studies program we know we have

163we still have room to grow but I really am extremely proud of the impact the collaboration between the district and the schools has had on our students and so we're ready to take take any questions or comments thank you superintendent we have a few board members that have some comments member salaman thank you chair and I agree this is these are some very great numbers and how much progress we've done on increasing just the access and the opportunity for our students to be in these rigorous programs really okay a couple of questions so one on on for the IB diploma do they need to pass all six class exams is that how it works yes they have to pass all the exams they also have to complete a course called to where they write an

164extended essay and the essay is graded by the IB as well and they also have to complete a Cass which is like a community service project got it okay so I was doing a bit of numbers here and so when you do one in the future would be helpful to also understand Pass rates because it's great that folks are taking these exams but it's also important to know if they're passing them and I know we track them and I got some of the numbers by doing the pass exams divided by the amount of people taking it right so what I was curious was comparing the AP pass rates seems to be about 60% % the cambage Pass rates are 60% and then the IB ones are 91% is that about right and I would have

165to look at my data real quick to to confirm that the IB tends to be a little bit higher because it's a smaller number of students it's also a different type of student often IB doesn't Target that middle of the road student and Cambridge and AP do a better job at targeting that specific student and we also have seen a change in how what students want take postco so the IB requires a lot of commitment on the students part right we've seen a lot of them say well I'd rather take Cambridge and get a Cambridge diploma because it provides me with like additional electives I can take or or I can take other AP courses and the same with ap being more of an allart model minus the Capstone diploma no it makes sense I

166think so I think one of the things we're definitely doing well is to provide more options and choices one of my biggest areas of concern though is one these choices can be overwhelming and also each of these programs have call it their own Pathways right so AP you have you could take any AP class get some credit call it a day then there is the AP scholar right which is you pass at least three exams with a score of three that pass rate drops from 60% of our students passing some of these exams taken to only 13% of all our students doing M AP scholar then there's an even smaller path which is the next pathway in AP is you do AP seminar AP research and then you do four AP classes in some combination

167that gives you the AP Capstone diploma that number students if my math is right tell me if I'm wrong it's 192 divided by the 36,000 so that's less than 1% of our students are getting the AP Capstone diploma that drop in The Funnel of percentages is the same across all of them so Cambridge the pass rate is about 60% of our students but Cambridge diploma is only 2% of our students and then with IB we have 91% pass Ray it is a much smaller number they're doing great but the IB diploma is only 8% and so my question is what are we doing to work with our schools to make sure that the students have access to reaching all parts of the pathway because what I worry and when I talk to some of our

168students it's like great my high school offers five of these Ace classes and then four of these APS and maybe two of these IBS unless I'm like a guro in like my master schedule I can't reach call it Mastery or Peak pathway with any of them I have to do this combination of buffet of some ACE classes some AP classes some do en ret and what ends up happening is their diploma looks all over the place and colleges one of the things they're looking for is Mastery commitment ability to like figure out and go deep with some of these Pathways so I'm all for having more options more choices more classes in advanced placement but I from what I've understood from our students they're feeling a little confused as well as it's really frustrating for

169them to create their own schedule when they can be in one or another path back in the day it used to be one school was just IB one school was just Cambridge one school was just AP and as long as you took enough of those advanced classes you would just like automatically meet that pathway to that diploma or to that Capstone because that was all there was and so you had probably many more students in that opportunity now I think they're missing the Mark at like that percentage and so I'm just curious how are we working with our principles and our schools to help them determine the question how many of these programs do you offer or are we saying you have to offer all you know all two or three just wondering though yeah

170so we meet with princip principles individually every year we actually go through and that's something I think that's impacted our participation as well because we create course progressions for every school because we found out years ago that it's not a one- siiz fits-all approach we can't you know we used to have a practice of putting majority of our students in AP Human Geography in 9th grade but we found out students have other interests they're interested in stem Fields they're interested maybe more in ela they're interested more in some are interested in social studies and want to take that path so the with the diploma is dropping off we've really veered away from telling students that you have you're locked in this specific pathway once you start high school so maybe you take English General Paper

171is a common Cambridge course you take that course and you realize you know what I actually don't think Cambridge is for me that's okay then my 10th grade year I can take some AP courses I can take some dual enrollment maybe I decide that an AP Capstone diploma is now my path because that begins in 10th Grade so we've been giving students more options in in that way and I also think it depends on how the where the student wants to attend college this been a conversation we've had also training guidance counselors the past two years to really talk about if you want to go out of state what is the best program for you to be in what's the path that you want to select so we build those progressions for principles we give

172them options for every type of student student so that we've created more individualized it's not perfect we're still working on it but it is something that we've been addressing because we know that is a need and I think there's been some miscommunication that have gone you know every way in regarding to the programs and how they can be used but what we don't what we've tried not to do is really not say you have to stick with this one path you have to stick with this one thing and a lot of students with IB it dropping off is essentially that you know if you if you fail one exam you don't have the opportunity to to reach take that exam or try to get that diploma again yeah I think may maybe what I'm talking

173about is a little bit more of that Cambridge and AP Choice like it's really hard to reach that diploma level with Cambridge or AP if you are doing both and I agree it's fine for us to have choice but I'm not sure how many of our students know so the programs don't technically compete with each other so the way that we build course progressions especially with Cambridge offers some courses that AP doesn't like for example they offer travel and tourism they offer drama which which AP doesn't offers they offer some electives that students get that are that are at that Sixpoint waiting they're more rigorous courses than they get with ap so we build out a progression we essentially build Cambridge and AP together but it doesn't mean that every student's going to take a

174diploma path maybe they don't want to earn that diploma and a lot of students with Capstone it's more of the honor of earning this capson diploma because it doesn't equate Bright Futures as as Cambridge does yes it's not by Futures but it like if you get any of these diplomas because that like that's a real way to show as we talked about like the depth and breadth and Mastery of one of these paths right like all college board has their point of view and thesis on why that path is great cambrid us too they view themselves as full packages I'm not saying that we have to view them that way but I want they want say I'm not sure that aside from our counselor and principles understanding how they're all different and maybe it's a

175buffet that our families and students are as aware of the fact that yes you can do the buffet and that's available to everyone but if you don't want the buffet like here's the way that you can kind of Excel and commit as well because before a lot of the students would just have that just because one school would just be IB or one school would just be Cambridge and that's something we've been working on because we do we do realize that there is more education we can do for parents and students we were doing parenty but often we would get you know Elementary and Middle School parents that maybe weren't to that to that level yet so we tried to focus more on parent nights curriculum nights a lot of our high schools host Advanced

176Studies nights which we help them with and build information for parents in that way so it's more customized to the school we also working with student services to to look at a various communication platforms that we can build something out for parents to have that information but I will say we're we're still working on that parent communication side no I appreciate it and I think a lot of it a lot of the inperson events are great for answering those questions but even just having like graphics on our website that say this is it like just Vis I worry when we have a lot of dependency on the right people telling the right people the right thing rather than potentially having one or two resources to go to the ha that and so when I went

177on our website to the new current families and then going to the pathways and I go to high school school and I click in AP it gives me a list of every high school that offers AP if I'm a parent I don't know what AP is I don't know the difference between AP or Cambridge or Magnum programs if I'm looking at just all the schools that have it I also don't know anything about AP as a program like I don't know what AP scholar is I don't know what AP diploma is so we're it's like we're doing a little bit but if I don't know that as a parent I would go on this website and get that much helpful here all I'm getting is here's a high school path it's called advanced placement and

178here's all the schools that have it I don't know how many parents would be like that's like I know so much now from that and so I think if we do have this place on our website that has these Pathways then let's actually show the pathways would be my preference and so and we have it like you said you're talking to principles about this and guidance counselors about this I'm sure there's a couple Graphics if we could just bring that into the website I think it would make a huge difference because I think it's great for us to have more numbers of more students taking AP classes but if we're talking about some of the stuff in the portrait of a graduate that we talked about I think that's there's some numbers on who reaches

179kind of the AP like in AP Scholars you know we have good numbers in AP scholar because if you go to a school that has a lot of AP classes chances are that you're going to go to your three and three classes and you got that and some students get to that point and they're like I didn't even know this was like a thing to get AP scholar or AP diploma right so I just I want to avoid that based on what I've heard from students and we also and that's one of the things that we've been working on and we plan to work on this summer is that our Advanced St information is also housed in the curriculum and digital learning tab on the web page where there's detailed information about each program so

180we been working on how we can kind of streamline that information so that it's all there for families and then high schools also house that information on their web pages as well well yeah the pathways are there that's what I was saying I'm when I go on there and then it says High School Middle or which one's this one so we've been having those same discussions of how to streamline it how to make it easy we've talked about student testimonials what does the course look like and that's why we've kind of expanded what the student contact so just to to kind of describe a little bit about and I think Becky's being modest the meetings that she's been having with principles over the last two years with her teams and with Mr Martinez there they

181meet with each of the principles they look at AP potential report which not just for AP but shows what students are showing an aptitude from looks at demographic information looks at exactly what board member Salam Mona's referring to is you know are the right courses being offered at the right Community are we looking at Pass rates overall making sure that if they are on a Cambridge track there is a diploma track and schools are adding that diploma Cambridge was a new addition a few years ago we offer it at all of the schools all the schools don't offer the diploma track but those that are building that out to make sure they have the right courses and this happened even when we build new high schools because that came up as a concern also the

182guidance counselor is making sure that they're helping the students pick the right courses so that is noted and we appreciate the feedback and I would say something else we added just this last summer so it was like our inaugural year of doing it we had an advanced day Symposium and during that Symposium we had we basically wanted students to be able to build their their portfolio for college so if I'm a rising Junior how am I getting some of this information to be able to prepare for that so we had student organizations there we had like the honors societies at the schools we had clubs we had SGA we also had some Q&A time for our College and Career Department here at the district where parents and their families and could come and ask questions

183and then we also had representatives from all our Advanced programs we had AP Cambridge we also had representative from college board's big future program that helps provide scholarship money for students we also had a representative from K as well and we also had a representative from Bright Futures and then we had a number of colleges and universities so students could kind of get the full picture we were actually close to public transportation we had 350 students attend with their parents so they're able to get program information that way and we've working on trying to grow it for this year and add additional items so I think that'll also help with parents and students getting the correct information wonderful thank you member Salam monka that was a lot of good information member Felder first of all

184thank you for your extensive and very thorough report and tues say I had an opportunity to share with the board when I went to one of my schools oage who had installation of the Cambridge Scholars club and looking at I like this when I was in high school some eons years ago I'm I was not a good test taker standardized test taker but this kind of program would have been wonderful for me even though I graduating top 10 of my class and I was in all of these clubs and whe where they look at diplomas may now look at IB or cambrid back then they looked at your time in public service community service in addition to how well you were doing in school and your leadership in clubs and so forth but when I

185went to Oakridge and well while at Edgewater they had the Cambridge program bought at Edgewater back in before I left and you know this gives the middle of the row student who may not be totally AP but they're very cautious interest about their study it does something for their self-esteem and I gave them the history of the Cambridge and where it came from and how proud they should be I'm really excited even though you know looking at on when you talked about the percentage where we went from 53 to 59 or something that percentage I'm I'm happy that there are more choices and just as board member salom Monica brought out I think that's something to consider some of the suggest she gave she's much younger than most of us she probably close to remembering

186those kinds of things taking AB classes and so forth but I think that's important but what I want to commend you on is the fact this district has offered the students a variety of of ways to become scholarly and to see the success rate I am just so happy that we have this and then one of the things I think you mentioned about the drop well I think when they you when Oakridge chose to do have the Cambridge Scholars but also the Cambridge club that will also improve participation from students to it makes them excited about being academic and doing well so I like the program I'm I'm I'm so excited that there's a fresh alternative to students to for children that want to be smart want to be considered as smart you have this

187cambage program so I am so excited the fact that we offer more IB programs at more of our high schools and I just think that this is a very unique way to encourage students to want to be smart it makes it popular for them to want to be smart again you know it is a work in progress as I realized that and I don't want us to ever limit ourselves because it's a working process but be prepared to go through the process you know be prepared for the progression cuz it's going to you're not going to Hur up in do it right away we going to be some drops and stuff but just stick with programs like this keep it in our schools as much as possible because children need choices they need choices and

188we cannot relinquish the Drive Academia we cannot we have to always keep that first and foremost so I'm excited about the Advan study Symposium that you do for the students and I'm I'm I'm really excited about Oakridge their participation with the Cambridge Club you know I was so excited and they seemed so happy and felt the self-esteem they were just so happy that they could be named as a part of that so I appreciate that so I just wanted to you know put that out and I'm hoping that we can consider some of the things that board member salom Monica said take that in serious consideration so that we can improve what we're doing Salam Mona thank you baby Salam Mona all right thank you so much thank you I know my name Vicky Felder

189thank you member Felder member Gallow thank you madam chair I'm going to commend you not only for this great presentation but for the fact that I've been you've been in here for a very long time so you're patience with us as we get through ethics and the fact that you're looking at us straighten eye without yawning at this point when I can I can barely keep my eyes on a piece of paper for more than two seconds I'm just in allwe of so I have just a couple of questions when we look when we did the Deep dive in into some of our Advanced Studies did we look at did we break it down by demographics like do we have a demographic breakdown on who who is really excelling the increases that we saw in

190the percentages amongst what de demographics were we seeing those increases and then did we take a larger look like by schools are some schools doing it very well where other schools may maybe are seeing less of an increase that are kind of below the mark of the numbers that you just gave us versus at them because these are all averages yes so we've noticed that so with demographics we Pro report with princi and we have our individual principal meetings we look at all of advanced study enrollment compared to their whole school enrollment and then we also look at the AP program and we look at courses that have a wider access so we'll look at like AP seminar which is a more accessible course to students and see what the demographics look like in that

191course compared to whole school enrollment and then we'll also look at the demographics of earning the Capstone diploma for Cambridge we look at the English General Paper course because it's the entry level course comparing the enrollment to that to the demographic of the of the whole school and then we do the same with IB along with their diploma we don't look at the performance but we could look at the performance what we've been really focused on is the enrollment side because there's a lot of research that says that the experience of being in that class is what helps you know to that next level to that college level it's not necessarily about the exam score but it's definitely something we could we could have another piece is really we realize that the programs are meeting

192two different types of students so often with AP we see more of a student that's good at taking standardized tests they're more good at multiple choice they can do those little frq sections of the exam when we look at Cambridge it's Cambridge has no multiple choice it's tell me what you know right about it and so it really meets two different types of students when we when we look at their achievement so we see some of the schools where maybe their scores are higher in Cambridge than they are in AP or higher in AP than they are in Cambridge it really just depends on what best fits the student okay thank you I appreciate that and my next question is I know that we're tracking and our we're seeing increases in advanced studies which is

193fabulous what about dual enrollment are those applicable like are you seeing more of an increase in dual enrollment and I'll tell you why I'm asking a minute or more of an increase in AP because I see that for a lot of the definitions of of like being an AP scholar and even the AP Capstone which I'm going to talk about in a second you get a level three and it you you can get that type of designation but most colleges won't accept a level three as a pass rate don't most of them it has to be like a four or a five or a six to really for them to CLP that class and give you Class Credit it depends on the course they're credit by exam equivalencies for the all public universities in Florida

194for example AP English Language if you score a three in that exam you get credit for ENC 1101 which is college composition if you were to score a four or five you get an ENC 1101 and 1102 credit so it really just depends on the course typically threes will will grant introduct introductory level courses and then fours or five will give you additional credit okay and are we seeing an increase in dual enrollment dual enrollment is not my area it's not your area okay that's fine that's and the reason like my I had two daughters and one of them did dual enrollment senior year was she would have done it both Junior and senior cuz it just it fit her personality she did not like she didn't like being told what to do I'm trying

195to think of a better way to say it but she didn't like the like she didn't like to have to be told when to go to class and when to leave class and to be in class like she just didn't do well in that environment where it was just so done for her I'm trying I want to say regiment and I know that's not the correct word but she just didn't like that and she didn't do particularly well in high school she did went to Valencia and did dual enrollment and she flourished she did well and she made good grades and it was because she got to choose her classes she got to choose when she went to her classes and it was just the freedom that she craved that she didn't get in high

196school my other one wanted no part of dual enrollment she loved her High School loved her friends she wanted to be involved she took AP my all the way my older daughter took away a lot more credits that could be applied to college than my one that did the AP because of the schooling and she actually she went through her high school at the time had AP Capstone and so I always remember was actually a former board member that used to be on this board before I was ever on the board told me if you want like the high school experience and absolutely you got to go in the advanced studies and you do that route but if you're really just looking to get college credit college credit that you know you're going to get

197duel and rment is easier to pass and as long as you get a see above you get college credit for it yeah so I guess the point I'm trying to make here which has nothing to do with y'all so again thank you for indulging me but this is great nudes and I want more of our student to really be in the AP so they can stay in school and experience at high school cuz you only get high school once in your life like you don't ever get to go back and just the whole experience of the football games and the basketball games and the rallies and the dress up days and all that you get to do at schools is what makes it so much fun when you do dual enroll even part-time you're disengaging

198from the school and you're not likely to be as involved however when we do graduation for those who would like to be a Val Victorian or solidor torian unless you are in dual enrollment it's very hard to compete some of it is due to what member Salam Mona brought up about just there being enough classes available to get to where you need to be and if you're in well if you're in two different programs it wouldn't matter because of the way they're weighted but it seems like year after year after year when I'm at graduations it's more and more dual enrollment students that are getting that valid Victorian and other students would like to have it but they just can't do it if they get if they're in the traditional sense of high school and

199what bothers me is that we want kids in our schools like we want to retain them and it's almost like we're encouraging them to leave and go into dual enrollment if they do want to be in the top 10% of their class or they do have a goal of being Val Victorian so for years I've been like can we do one for dual enrollment one for like advanced studies for those that stayed in classes or can we figure out a way to wait them and I know that they're waited because the superintendent is looking at me and she's going to chime in that they're waited but you have certain courses that count as one class in high school but count as two in in dual enrollment so that's how they get those extra points in

200that higher GPA average so I just wanted to go on my soap box and for that because I've been saying it for years again I know it has nothing to do with you I'm going to let the superintendent chime in and then I do have a question about Capstone thank you member Gallow superintendent thank you so we have tried to expand the virtual options for dual enrollment right and so I think our latest and I'm looking at T sh Bron can Dr BR I believe is with Barry University that's going to be offered at several of our schools we have some with the University of Florida and so they are available the I mean Lake Nona High School is the except because the campus is right next to it but we have been looking for

201opportunities to expand that but it would be virtually and then they are able to take a year-long course in one semester so that they are more equal footing so it's coming oh that's great news thank you and then in reference to the AP Capstone diploma my daughter as I mentioned earlier went to East River I think it was the first year that they offered AP Capstone and so she took AP research and AP seminar it was by far the best two classes that she could have taken that prepared her for college Bar None end of story like she had such an easier time especially with research papers and things that she needed to do especially in her master's level classes like those two classes I just can't speak highly enough of them on what they

202teach that critical thinking and the ability to research all that you don't typically get I noticed that it says that we have that the AP Capstone I think is only offered in 15 of our high schools yes do we have any plans to expand that cuz I think I think every high school should have an AP seminar and AP research class available for those students I think every high school I just yeah I really and yeah the kids that want to go to college would be the kids that would be participating in those classes but I just think that all 23 high schools should have that available to their students and my next question would be the AP research and seminar if it's not at their school are they able to take that online is

203that class available virtually if they wanted to do so or no I'm not sure about the online option I do know that they do have cohort models for FLVS and I think ocvs does as well but I'm not sure if they're offered to students on a on a allart basis if they're if they're a student out of school and that's their main home I will say that when it comes to Capon the schools that don't offer it are most of them are IB schools because they offer more of an extensive IB diploma program and then the other ones they offer more of an extensive Cambridge diploma program where they're offering more than the seven classes required for the diploma there may be offering anywhere from 10 to 16 so it really just depends one of

204the things we've really been focused on is college board East to be a requirement that you had to be on the path to the caps and diploma to be able to take AP seminar so you had to take seminar and research together now Seminar can be offered by itself so you can take it as a as just an English elective essentially so we've really been promoting that with the schools because college board has shown a lot of data where students that were successful in AP seminar they gained a lot of research and writing skills that actually increase their scores in other exam areas so we've really been focusing on the students that have AP potential for that course and then maybe from there the schools might grow some some Capstone diplomas from that from that

205point if there student interest but been focusing on adding AP seminar and getting students there for that's wonderful I will say that my youngest daughter is one of the best writers in our family she often writes my speeches well now now ai is kind of taken over she's gotten busy but I mean she I would literally be like I need this is a topic I want to discuss at graduation I need a speech and during a car ride she would write it for me and it would be the most fabulous speech I've ever heard in my life so I'm going to Tribute that to AP seminar so thank you than thank you member Gallow thank you for being so honest about who's really writing your speeches that was very interesting I am queued in next

206and I think this is really a great discussion we met earlier in the year because I had so many questions about this as well that were brought to me by one of my schools and you did such a good job of explaining it all to me and once I understood that we were looking at a more of like a all aart type thing and a more of diverse Pathways and they can pick and choose what they're doing and that wasn't really what was being communicated in the schools and you were working to correct that and make sure that everybody understood that what the goal was then it all kind of made more sense to me and what what member Salam Mona was talking about though is kind of the opposite side to that coin right

207to what you and I in that conversation we had when we talked about this and about having really well-rounded kids that were had exposure to so many different things she's talking about those select few and this is her world too because that was the kind of kid she was and I know she's left so now I don't want to talk about her while she's not here but she's brilliant right so she was that kind of kid that wanted this kind of that Capstone diploma and there are those kids that th those are the kids that are going to Target that kind of path but when we're looking at like what we're seeing now with colleges a lot of them though she's saying that some of them want to see that really indepth study a lot

208of them are really looking for kids that is not the AP Capstone diploma was not the only thing they accomplished in high school you know we're having kids that have those AP Capstone diplomas and the all those other you know 5.2 gpas that are not getting the college acceptances that they should be getting that are in the top 10 of the class at the high school and when I've talked to Mr Martinez about that when he's talked to admissions counselors It's because they say well we're not looking at just that anymore because those kids couldn't carry on a conversation which was the same thing we heard from our business people in the community when we looked at Portrait of a graduate that we need kids to not always be so focused on on this on

209the core on the curriculum so much that they're not living the rest of their life right and not getting a well-rounded education and not experiencing all the things like what member Gallow was talking about because I know a lot of kids that are coming home from high school that are in like Ace Program or trying for that AP cap on diploma that are doing six and seven hours of homework at night and my daughter has some friends that she K every time I say call so and so she's like she can't do anything she's at home doing homework and the child never goes out I'm not kidding never goes out this one child so there's so many of them that are living like that and then on top of all of that we have the

210whole Mental Health crisis that our teenagers have gone through for the past 20 years that we've been pushing pushing pushing these Advanced Studies not that it's not I'm totally no not trying to come down on Advanced Studies because I think they are wonderful and they have a place but my whole point to this conversation is I feel like we are in the right direction in the what the conversation that we had where we're looking at you can do this you can do some ACE you can try some C you know you can try some I AP you know find something that fits for you and let's look at whole experience and the whole child and where you want to go and I love having the conversation with what school do you want to go to

211and let's try to figure out how you get there because it's not always with like it used to be you know anymore the schools are noticing I think where we went wrong in some ways pushing some of these kids so far that they were missing so many of the other important skills that they needed so that was a lot to just say that I think we are on the right path but it was interesting to me that she brought up the other side of that where you know if we're offering all these options are we still offering that real def definitive path for those few children that you know are trying for the Ivy Leagues that really want to you know get those things so I thought that was an interesting discussion that we still

212try to make sure those options are open for those kids but for the majority of the kids that were trying to just have a good high school experience hopefully and also get to college and especially the ones that we see that you know we had this conversation about my high schools because I was asking I was concerned about if the kids were the ones getting the ace diploma or that weren't able to pass the act or the SAT requirement for right Futures right how many of those that actually is like cuz my thinking was well if you're passing getting the ace diploma then you're probably getting the score in ACT SAT act for Bright Futures and what we found out is it wasn't true yes that this really was a big advantage and that is

213a huge and I just met with students at Waka yesterday and so many of them were that I've known for so long and I asked them how their college thing is going they're like great I'm getting 100% by Futures because I got my Ace my Ace diploma and you know they're excited because they wouldn't be able to go to college otherwise and so that kind of opportunity I'm I just I love that we are we have it there for those kids that need it and the only other thing I wanted to comment was to talk a little bit more about what member salamano was talking about about it all being easy easy access for parents and you know I talk about this all the time and we talked about it when we were talking about

214zel about that there was an option to put in Pathways and we're student yeah we're working on that right so that's what I've always envisioned where a parent can log into their child's whatever program and see in eighth grade oh look look at this class over here you could take here and then you could take this and then you get this diploma that does this or or you can do this you know if they could see it like in a little virtual world with things they can click on with explanations and I think that is the end goal right that One-Stop shop Dr AR Brewster that we talked about several years ago that's it for me mine was more of a commentary but I think our next board member to speak is member Vanos thank

215you so much my first question is first of all thank you and I'm so happy to see this I love that we have more advanced options for students it's maybe not for everyone but I'm so glad that for people who want it they can you know we're seeing more kids go into AP we're seeing more kids go into other programs too first I just wanted to ask about the AP so I see for Ace and for IB students can qualify for the Bright Futures but is that's not true for AP no the Caps diploma is not written in statute that way only the Cambridge Ace diploma and the IB diploma okay thank you I also wanted to so I also wanted I just notes that are kind of all over the place but I did

216want to EO what member Gallow said about the AP research and seminar and whether or not a student decides to go for the Capstone I think those two classes are so critical for and my daughter's also in them just for critical thinking and for understanding how to use sources and the value of sources and I just I think in the society that we're living in now that class in particular those two classes are so important so I would love to see again I'm not saying we have to push everyone to get the Capstone but but even just to participate in those two classes and I do think I would love to see that option as well in all of our high schools and I would hate to see just because they have an Ace Program

217that they also just don't have an option to take those too so that's that's one point I wanted to make oh I also wanted to say okay unrelated that your building portfolio that you had for for I guess students who were going to be Juniors I think it was this past summer yes for Rising Juniors yes okay my daughter overslept so she did not make it but I've heard from many people that it was an amazing event and so I just wanted to say many many students and parents just had really great things to say about it so thank you for doing that and hopefully you'll do it again and maybe my second daughter will be will set her alarm and we'll make it okay also wanted to speak to member salamas when she was

218talking about just the choices and and again I do think it's really great for our students to explore but I I I would like to see just a clearer pathway I think it is very confusing you know and I just so this is my third year in high school at open house was the first time I learned that Ace could be used for Bright Futures like I didn't even know that and I was wondering why we even honestly had it but like so I didn't even know that so maybe just making that a little bit clearer and going along with the communication piece you know and I guess I can ask you this question when it when someone graduates with one of the AP diplomas or one of the ace diplomas is one of them

219like better received by colleges so it really just depends on where the student wants to go to school so those are some of the conversations that we're having with parents so if I want to attend college out of state AP and earning an AP capson diploma is probably going to be a better fit for me and it's going to equal more college credit we often get questions about Ivy League schools and typically they don't offer credit for any courses they will offer Honors College standing if if anything if a student wants to go to school in the state of Florida Cambridge diploma would be a great route or an IB diploma because it does yield the Bright Futures if you're concerned about sat or act but those have been the conversations that we've been having

220one's really not better than the other it's just kind of like what best fits what you are wanting to do in postsecondary and I think that's kind of like we talk with parents about researching schools what school is your child interested and attending you know what what are they what are they wanting like I could say Columbia University if you're a computer science major they want you to have taken AP Psychology not dual enrollment psychology not Cambridge not IB psychology they want APS ology so it really just depends on what the school is looking for and that's what we encourage families to do I will say that they all yield college credit Cambridge is a program that's actually existed since the late 1800s it's actually what IB was built upon so if we get actually

221a lot of students that come from other countries and they'll bring their transcripts we're able to accommodate those students now as we weren't previously so a lot of families that come here globally actually are like oh I'm very familiar with this is great that this is offered at the school so they actually have a higher ed team in the United States Cambridge does where if a college is not willing to accept the credit they work with the school to accept the credit and we've had 100% success rate in doing that but as the program grows it's more known throughout the United States but that's sort of our recommendation for now in terms of what your you know what your student is looking for After High School okay I appreciate that answer I don't think that

222makes it easier for parents or students to deci what to choose so I I don't know I don't know what we can do about that but I it is it's yeah it just doesn't give a lot of guidance to to parents and students and it can just lead to I think more stressed out students and just more anxious because they're just not sure am I making the right choice am I not making the right choice I don't know I don't know if there's an answer but maybe we could just think about if there's you know some kind of I don't know database or or spreadsheet or just information where it's kind of all in one place where they can see like the schools they interested in like what would be the better path for you

223to choose I don't know oh also just going along with the communication piece the AP tutoring in all high schools is also something that I just discovered this year three years into high school that's amazing and I hope that you know we can spread that make sure parents and students know that is available every high school for every AP subject I think that's really incredible that we offer that so just would want to make sure that you know all parents and students know about that something member Gallow mentioned I think there was a lot there can we get information about the breakdown of Passage rates by school by high school can we provide P rate data by school demographic broken down by demographic that would that would take a little bit but we could get

224that information it just might take a little while to to have that by demographic byass rate okay so do so you're saying we already have it by school so I could like compare pass rate to Ed pass okay cor Park okay okay got it thank you I just I have heard concerns from some people who work in different schools and they have shared that they feel like sometimes like a program in one school maybe an IB program or whatever is not really the same thing that's happening in another school even though it's still IB so I just want to make sure that all the schools are kind of getting the same level of instruction and maybe it's just sharing you know best practices among different schools okay and I think this is my last question

225somewhere I think we read I read that you have advanced studies in elementary school we do so we have two Cambridge Elementary programs what those programs essentially are is for the Cambridge diploma there is a course called Global perspectives it's actually at one point Cambridge and AP were Partners and that's where Global perspectives was part of AP research and seminar so essentially now it's a it's AP and seminar and research together into into one course at the elementary level they do almost like their version of research so they may look into like water usage and how many times do I you know how long do I run this sink when I'm brushing my teeth things like that they do at home or they might explore different vegetables and where they're grown so it kind of

226develops those inquiry skills at a young age and then for Middle School it actually focuses again on global perspectives as a course by itself and students can also research similar topics at the middle school level and then it builds up to them taking the global perspectives course in high school okay I love anything that encourages research and just curiosity and I just think that's really important to start an elementary and middle school are we looking to expand those programs into more schools or we haven't recently looked into any more Elementary programs that those programs do come at a cost so that's part of what kind of inhibits them from going to more at the elementary level at the middle and high school level Cambridge provides us with almost like a voucher program where if we're

227spending a certain amount of money on exams it covers the cost of the program's annual fee so we don't have to pay annual fees with the middle or high school programs got it okay and just a question does for that cost issue is that true of AP as well no AP does not have an annual fee okay they don't have a fee okay but there are not any Elementary programs for for AP no no I know that I just that just got me on a different Rabbit Hole so okay thank you thank you member Douglas thank you so much for you the presentation about APS and Ace and we have great programs in ocps thank you so much for doing that for our kids again I want to talk about the communication piece I think

228a lot of the parents do not know all these programs that we have I really believe it especially Second Language parents do not know the options that their kids have they have very SM kids that absolutely do not know some of them about all that you have for them and we need to really push that communication piece so all students are aware of what they you know Equity that all of them know what they have on the table so they can make a choice my second one is that just like any statistics that we have in reading math and everything I would like to know a little bit you know those the statistics the numbers that you gave how many of them are minority students how how do you determine I just want to see

229a holistic image of all our students in numbers different colors different I just want to see it so we can see where we can make it better for one you know to the other makes it a little bit more challenging for all of them and I think it's very important to to make sure that all our children are Tre it the same way and they have the same opportunity and they can go further you know and the 59% or whatever I really would like to see a better image of what they represent in each category in our minorities I just would like to see a holistic portrait of The Graduate and our ocps is composed to so many Lang languages and and I would like to see to see that if possible one thing that

230makes Cambridge a little more accessible to English language Learners is there are different categories that students take seven courses in four different subject groups and one of the subject groups is languages and it's more of language acquisition versus thinking we typically think English language so students can actually take a couple of our schools offer Portuguese they offer French they offer Spanish so they can actually meet that requirement for the diploma through their own native language which helps a lot of students achieve those diplomas and gives them a little more access so that's something that we do as well as regard to the demographic data we definitely have that data of what our enrollment looks like for those courses and who we're offering access to and we review that data with principles to say you know

231look at looking at your whole school is there representation in these courses yes demographic is representation as as a teacher there are a lot of those programs that I didn't know about I'm I'm telling you I've been teaching nine years in in high school and I know some of them are taking AP French and AP but what does that mean is that all they need to graduate and to have or do they is that a composition of six or seven you know programs that they need to have in order to to pass is that only that French AP that allow them to go further or is that a whole do do you know what you know what I mean okay because I heard you say that in order to pass the IB I think you

232needed to take six yes so for Cambridge you have to take seven courses seven courses yeah okay so it's different requirements for different diplomas IB has a has a number of requirements coursework and community service and an essay so it's a little bit different for AP it's four exams you have to pass and AP seminar and research so six so it's different for for every program if you are earning their diploma okay so yeah so you got my point yes thank you so much I appreciate you thank you thank you member Douglas superintendent thank you madam chair just a couple of things so number one we actually do have a more defined definition and pathway it's not on the parent portal and so I've been communicating with our chief academic officer and they're going to

233move it's under advanced studies and so it gives the delineation and much more information I cannot access it on the phone though so that's another piece that we need to work out with our it folks because if you're a parent you're probably going to be using your phone to access the information and we can't through the parent I can't so I can't even access the other one second during the Town Halls that I've been having with the students this really has been like a big topic of conversation College and Career Readiness and so they've actually suggested that we put together a canvas course for them it's also something that could be provided to parents so we can translate it in the at least the six major languages so that they can refer to it often

234many times they say that even though they have great counselors it's difficult to get to them so having this canvas course that would have the various Pathways the courses the continuum the sequence so that is that's something that's come out and second we do have the subgroup data and can give it to you some schools are doing better with some of our subgroups than others but even within that we saw increases in participation and pass rate for for some of the subgroups so we'll definitely get that information to you thank you so much superintendent and thank you both Dr Hunt Dr Russo this was such great information very encouraging and it was wonderful and thank you for being so patient with us as you waited today all right we have one policy left and we

235are going to go right through and get it done quickly right Mr pomerini or should I say right board it is usually not the presenter yeah it's usually not the presenter it's policy BH public input as at at Schoolboard meetings I'm going to turn it back over to Dr Vasquez thank you madam chair our last policy for the evening deals with public comment there's been recent court case that is going to require the board to amend at least one portion of the policy and I'll turn it over to our general counsel Mr pal Marini to give us further details on that thank you madam chair members of the board I'm going to go through the red line first and then I'll get to the PowerPoint just so it's just easier that way I think it'll

236flow better what I've done is I've Tak the pilot program that we instituted oh I think it's going back close to a year if not more now and updated our policy to reflect it so you'll see in many places where we had a public input period we've changed it to open public comment I'm not going to go through every place where I do that obviously so you're going to see that being changed over and over again in subsection B here the open public comment period shall start approximately 1 hour prior to the regularly scheduled board meeting that's what we've been doing it starts at 4: our board meeting starts at 5: so just wanted to codify that it says the schedu at 1 hour prior to regularly scheduled board meeting board meeting and conclude no

237later than 45 minutes after commencing you all have put 45 minutes for public comment so I'm just codifying that into the policy itself down to C this is for folks who want to email in public comment you all will get that the morning of the meeting I think the cut off is 5:00 the day before so they can the folks can email public comment at ocps.net prior by 5:00 p.m. prior to the regularly scheduled meeting and you all will get the email public comments from those folks who do so and then on D the open public comment period only occurs prior during a pre- agenda meeting before regularly scheduled board meeting of course we don't do open public comment before any other meeting other than a regularly scheduled board meeting and the at the bottom

238in the event there are no members of the public that wish to address the board during an open public comment period the board May immediately conclude the open public comment period so that just gives you all the authority if there's nobody here to say okay meeting adjourned agenda public comment again this is comment that occurs during our regularly scheduled board meetings so this is just changing the name from the public comment period which is what it was in the policy to the agenda public comment you'll see that repeatedly throughout the policy C is the section where you all as part of your pilot allow CTA OA and okasa to have along with the superintendent stor advisory Council to be a lot of three minutes each to each to report to the board on relevant topics

239on public education within the District of course we leave we have the statement in there that says issues that have been or could be raised at the bargaining table as mandatory permissive subjects of bargaining may not be addressed during the district Association reports pursuant to 44 7309 that's the they shouldn't be bargaining directly with you all it should be done at the bargaining table provision and that comes from our pilot program I've just put a note in there that the board will have to make the decision whether you all want to continue that or not continue that this was a pilot program so it's up to you all to decide whether or not to continue it or not I've put it in here just for your discussion a lot of times for speakers during the

240open public comment period again it's 45 minutes we change that to conform with the pilot program in order to accommodate more speakers the chair May reduce the amount of time for each speaker so subsection B then goes into what we did during the pilot which was it used to be if we had between one and 20 speakers they would get three minutes and now we're switching that from to 1 to 10 speakers if we have 1 to 10 speakers they'll get 3 minutes if we have 11 to 20 speakers they would get two minutes as you remember Tuesday night we had 13 speakers so we cut them down to 2 minutes a piece if we have 21 Plus speakers they would get one minute to speak so and then we have the priority categories again

241parents legal Guardians students and employees priority two Orange County residents priority three everybody else once again that's just changing the name we had a subsection e is we had a telephonic option during covid obviously we don't do that anymore so I've eliminated that or S proposed eliminating that again changing the name open public comment going down here it says the order of speakers will be based on the order of issuance and subsequent submitt completed cards to the board Clerk we don't complete cards anymore with the board clerk what we do is we have an electronic system and under your policy it says the superintendent is authorized to establish reasonable time frames and procedures governing the signup process within the parameters of this policy so we used to have blue cards and yellow cards so the

242blue cards were I'm going to flip this I know I am the blue cards were pre agenda and the yellow cards were the regular agenda I may have flipped that but you all know what I mean now it's all done electronically so any reference to filling out cards and speaking in the order in which you're received that goes away you're going to speak in the order the priority order which is parents legal Guardians students employees Orange County residents and then non- Orange County residents relevant topics that's basically just making changes to the name to reflect what was in the pilot program we had certain topics that were off limits during the pre- agenda the open public comment period what we added in was pending litigation for as long as I can remember when we had

243open public comment we I've always said and it's part of the chair's remarks that we do not allow discussions of pending litigation I mean and so that has been the long-standing practice the pending litigation wasn't in the actual language of the policy it needed to be added in there to conform to our practice so we've added that in and number six is the big change that is going to be made and then I'll explain why board has adopted a code of Civility which requires all participants to engage in meaningful but civil Communications speakers addressing the board during open public comment or agenda public comment shall abide by the code of Civility and here's the language change to the extent it does not conflict with with the right of speakers to State his or her viewpoint

244consistent with current federal law now I'm going to the PowerPoint to explain why so first slide here in policy bedh again we incorporate the code of Civility this is the current language that was in the code prohibited from using loud or offensive language inappropriate gestures profanity or other language at the discretion of the board chair or designate is intended to bully belittle tease demain another individual or is otherwise abusive or obscene board chair designate an effort to maintain orderly conduct and proper decorum and a meeting May remove a speaker so we in incorporate the code of Civility the chair says in the meeting first we ask that you comply with our code of Civility which means the specific names of individuals or specific positions of individuals are not to be referenced so that's also something

245we do hey don't say it's Mr Smith the third grade teacher at Maxi Elementary School just say it's my kids elementary teacher the management directive B12 our code of Civility we shall share our opinions and concerns without loud and offensive language gestures or profanity we treat each other as we would like to be treated we don't threaten or cause physical body har bodily harm we don't threaten or cause damage to of property of anothers we don't bully belittle or tease one another and we don't allow others to do so in our presence so our general code of Civility is you know you're going to act appropriately and with theorum and not be offensive not be profane not be obscene and that's what we expect from speakers this is just the rest of the Pol the

246code of Civility it really doesn't have much to do with the policy of the issue but I want wanted to include it just for completeness so now the reason for the change there was a case that just came out of the 11th circuit moms for Liberty versus Bard County School Board the moms or the moms for Liberty challenged The Bard County school board's policy regarding abusive speech personally directed speech and obscene speech and in each instance the Court ruled that the bravar county school board's policy violated the First Amendment because it engaged an unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination and so this is how it plays out here's what the court says there is under the First Amendment you can't discriminate against somebody on the basis of their Viewpoint that is quintessential speech that's protected under the First

247Amendment and you can't prohibit somebody from coming up there and making spe and making speech and except in very very limited circumstances so with respect to to abusive speech the court looked at a couple instances one when there were there's a challenge to the covid-19 mask policy and one of the speakers says the masking policy was a simple ploy to silence our opposition to this evil lgbtq agenda and the chair in that case said U prohibited the speaker from speaking further because she determined evil was quote abusive and the court said the speaker hadn't screamed yelled or otherwise caused A disruption and the chair also stopped the speaker for abusive name calling when a speaker referenced the liberal left the court said as follows no one likes to be called evil but it is not

248abusive to use that term restrictions that bar offensive or otherwise unwelcome speech are impermissible regardless of the form in which the government seeks to impose them a Prohibition on offensive or unacceptable as the chair put at speech may appear neutral after all it prohibits a speaker from saying another offensive anything offensive about another person or topic and this next line is the one that is the most important coming out of the case but giving of offense is a Viewpoint in restrictions barring Viewpoint effectively requires Happy Talk permitting a speaker to give positive or benign comments but not negative or even challenging ones and if the only ideas that can be communicated are views that everyone already finds acceptable why have the school board meetings in the first place State can't prevent both willing and unwilling

249listeners from hearing certain perspectives because for every one person who finds these viewpoints offensive there may be others who welcome them so coming out of this case if somebody refers to somebody as evil we would have to allow it and if somebody and it's not not just for you all sitting on the dis for parents in the audience for teachers at schools for staff members at schools we would have to permit it so I'm going to go on a little bit further this I put this quote in here to be sure a different policy one prohibiting Viewpoint neutral characteristics of speech for example or explicitly or narrowly defining abusive could be constitutional but here the ban on abuse of speech is an undercover prohibition on offensive speech because the government may not burden the speech

250of others in order to tilt public debate and a preferred Direction the board's policy on abusive speech is facially unconstitutional facially means it's unconstitutional in any instance whatsoever there is no actual way you could constitutionally apply the prohibition against abuse of speech so they ruled that the abuse of speech prohibition was unconstitutional and could never be applied next is personally directed speech so the issue in this case was it was sometimes inconsistently applied so at some meetings speak speakers were allowed to address board members by name and give them thanks and praise offering thanks however was not always a shield one speaker was interrupted when she tried to thank a board member for positive impact on her daughter and at another meeting the chair cut off a mom's for Liberty member who tried to personally

251thank a board me personally thank a board member on yet another occasion the chair said nothing when a local high school student addressed one board member by name while advocating for her theater group to rehearse in the school's indoor facilities but when a mom's her Liberty member question he as a parent could stand up for district 2 without while having to watch a board member from the district behind a plastic prison that was the plexiglass the chair and another board member interrupted the him for calling out one of the board members informed him that he could not talk to or about his specific representative the court says then went on to say you have to allow speakers to reference an employee by name and this is the most concerning one to me going forward not

252only does this policy against personally directed speech not Advance the goals the board claims it serves it actually obstructs the core purpose of the board's meetings educating the community and the community about the community members concerns if a parent has a grievance about say a math teacher's teaching style it would be challenging to adequately explain the problem without referring to that math teacher or principal or coach and so on likewise when a parent wishes to praise a teacher or administrator such Communications are at the heart of the school board's business and the ill-defined and inconsistently enforced policy barring personally directed speech fundamentally impedes it without any coherent justification to be sure some meetings can get tense can be tense no one enjoys being called out negatively and some may even dislike public praise but that

253is the price of admission under the First Amendment so a parent can come up to the board now and say I think Mrs Smith my third grade teacher at Maxi Elementary is demeaning belittling abusive to my kid and we would otherwise prohibit that and say we're not calling out people individually in the meeting we cannot do that now we would have to allow that speech against that teacher that administrator anybody if a parent or any member of the public wants to come up here and say Beyond people on this dis that they're evil incompetent you know abusive that speech has to be allowed we cannot shut a speaker down from making it then there was the finally the abusive or the obscene portion so this dealt with members of the community coming to challenge books

254and so they started to read out of the books and as you can see in here that there was a speech about how a boy's pants were around his ankles and there was leg straddling and then the door swung open and then one of the kids said an explo if I've got it written there I'm not going to say it the chair interrupted quickly interrupted the speaker when she got to the expletive the court said well the word though while not polite is also not obscene nor the book's other content no matter how objection well it may be his early childhood reading material moreover the content of books in school libraries is a matter of serious Community interest it would be difficult if not impossible for speakers to adequately air their concerns about a particular

255book without informing both the board and the community about what the book says describing the content of a book is not as potent as reading its words nor is it in nor is it as informative now we already had a statute that said if a book is subject to being challenged and somebody starts to read it and we cut them off the book then has to be removed from the Shelf now if we do it not only does the book have to be removed from the Shelf but if we cut off the speaker from speaking it's a First Amendment violation under this case we're going to have to let him read it so that is why I modified the language as proposed here to say shall abide by the code of Civility to the extent

256it does not conflict with the speaker the right of a speaker to State his or her viewpoint consistent with current federal law I am extremely concerned about what could come I extremely concerned about folks being able to come up here not necessarily calling me out calling superintendent out calling any of you out but calling employees out by name and saying very negative things about them in public in the past we would be able to have prohibited that we will not be able to prohibit that going forward so I have to give you this information so you all can make a decision I think in order to comply with this case the language that I've suggested consistent with current federal law U will allow you to keep the public comment period while still complying with our

257responsibilities under the First Amendment as the court has interpreted it and I think the rest of the changes in the policy actually are just open changing the name consistent with our pilot program so that is it for going through it I will certainly open it for questions thank you Mr pomerini I'm CED in first on this same note while we're here on this section before I go back what does this or how does this play along with the law about not disrupting Schoolboard meetings so if a speaker got up there and let's just say somebody really wanted to stretch this and test it and just went crazy up there right with their speech in such a way that the crowd started getting crazy and the whole thing is a mess if the board if the

258chair had to stop could we still have that person removed based on the law that says it's a misdemeanor to disrupt a Schoolboard meeting so what I would suggest in that case is instead of stopping we would at that point recess the meeting to first of all we would see if the if the crowd was starting to get riled up if we had people standing if we had people going towards the the speaker if something like that was starting to happen I would suggest we recess immediately so we could get crowd control coming out of it I would suggest to the chair who was running the meeting at that point that the speaker needed to be you know admonished to the extent we can so if they were calling them all sorts of vile names

259like you know you all can imagine what that would be we would we would suggest that look there's a way to criticize whoever it is that you're criticizing without going to that extent of language so we're I would ask you to refrain from making comments profane obscene comments you know personally like that towards somebody But ultimately I don't think we would kick them out at the first instance of it we would ask them to refrain from using those types of words and then allow them to finish speaking now if they continue to just you know use that kind of language and incite the crowd again at that point I would say okay you can remove the speaker that could be a potential claim against us but you know there comes a point in time where

260you have the right to vindicate your right to to run a meeting without that kind of disruption but it would be a much more careful analysis than what we have done in the past gotcha thank you the other note that I had is back at the beginning of the policy about the allowing of email public comments up until 5:00 p.m the day before a regularly scheduled meeting is there a reason that we have to do that because I feel like really checking that email for public comment emails and sending them to board members is not a very laborous task it could be done up to almost up to board time but let's even say like 3:00 or 2:00 in the afternoon because a lot of people you know especially if there's something controversial that has

261now gotten news coverage the night before the board meeting which is typically when it happens or the morning of the board meeting we're we going to get emails the day of a board meeting for public comments so I'm I'm not I don't love that 5:00 the day before for a deadline and then us not being able to see these emails if they come in to that mailbox so I think the rationale behind it was to get them early enough then to get it to you all so you would have time to actually read it so there was you know if we did it at 2: or 3 in the afternoon we could get it to you all but you all may have set meetings with staff you may have you may not have time to

262read it so I think that was the rationale behind it there's listen whatever the board's pleasure is at what time they want to cut it off that's the board's pleasure they can make that change but I think that was the rationale get it early enough so they can get it to you at 10:00 in the morning to give you time to read it before you came in here gotcha okay I understand that yeah and then other than that I just did checks on the different changes you made meaning I don't have any problem with any of the other changes other than the obvious but just that time was the only thing I had a question on the next to to speak is member front thank you madam chair okay I would like to just chime

263in on so it's page two number two B where you asked what our thoughts were on continuing having the different associations and Council reports personally I've loved them I think they've been super beneficial I especially love hearing from the superintendent advisory Council students who come in and the information that they share is pertinent and very very helpful I love hearing from the different associations okasa has been one that I really have enjoyed I feel like we hear a lot about the other two and okasa coming in has really kind of helped me understand their role and what they do so personally I would like to continue that on page three are the practice of like not having any more cards and we've gone completely to electronic like huge Applause to whoever made that happen that

264is truly truly life-saving so Dr Williams is shaking her head at me okay sorry well either way I just I'm very thankful I know as a parent coming in it was definitely frustrating to weit in lines and it was during the co drama and you know dozens if not hundreds of people that would come at times and trying to wait in line and figuring that process out so I think having it online creates a more like friendly environment and you just sign up nicely and I feel like it's really worked well for us and my other thoughts the new federal law I understand it could be a little frustrating I think in some ways I mean I think we all know how I feel I would rather that our public comment time be videoed just

265because I feel like it's it should be available to the public but at the same point if people are going to be able to come in and U maybe share their thoughts on a teacher that they are disgruntled with and maybe that teacher is absolutely phenomenal they're a fabulous teacher and this person's just frustrated with them and they come in and they say things that aren't true or whatnot so in some ways I mean I guess it's a give some and take some on there but I mean I definitely agree with everything that the court said I think it's as frustrating as it is I mean I've sat here I think we all remember those days of just sitting here and I was kind of the brunt of a lot of the speakers that would

266come in and whether they said my name or not I'm just saying District 3 we all know who they were talking about and so you know some of those things you just got to sit and take it and if it is for a teacher or whatnot if you know that you're doing a great job those words you know kind of go over your head in some sense so I think it will just be a matter of kind of getting used to and helping the chair or whoever is guiding the meeting to know how we're going to continue forward my only last thought I know it's not in here but I know we had discussed at one point changing the arrangement for speakers during that open public comment time and to come to just a Podium

267like a just a mic stand and I don't know if that'll happen in the future or superintendent yes our staff is working on the Arrangement that will have barriers and then they'll be able to speak similar to what we had done previously so that's that's in the works wonderful thank you member frat superintendent I have you queued in to speak as well yes I am speaking for Dr Williams and while I'm sure we will use the technology for 99% of the time she would and I agree if technology is down then we will have to use cards so I don't know if we need to you know put anything in the policy or if we're we're fine no because the policy itself says the superintendent is authorized to establish reasonable time frames and procedures governing

268so you can set a procedure that says in the event that the technology is failed yes thank you wonderful thank you member Felder some clarification on page four with pending litigation student or employee Discipline matters speakers may not address the board on any issues or items pertaining to student or employee discipline or any other pending or ongoing investigation till all possible appeals have been exhausted and the matter is deemed concluded to a certain extent I do understand because sometimes Discipline matters you know we meet like we don't meet every week we meet what every two weeks or whatever twice and sometimes the situation sometimes changes you get more information and then the person is offered whatever is said what is happening you all get more information and it things change however I guess because of

269some situations that I've gotten some calls about and we still like Jose they're working on some situations but I'm and I'm other sure other board members get calls and emails too that sometimes things happen and the board we have to wait two weeks later sometimes we don't get the information because we have a lot of stuff that we don't just deal with disciplinary problems we deal with a lot of things on the board and I just I don't know how because I don't want people to to get totally embarrassed and you know and some of that stuff that's said or what they think and sometimes when you do the research is not true you know and everything but then I don't know if I'm just frustrated I guess I don't know whether or not how

270we can determine whether issue is immediate like I know for a fact when we have situations where employees have done some egregious thing like sex texting or something like that we you know this District I tell people I say you have to do something really really really really really bad for this District to just get rid of you cuz if you on drugs they have a plan for you to put to help you out and you know we do the same thing when we have kids we don't just OU them out we give them opportunity to get better to rehab I tell people I say this District do the same thing for employees but however sometimes things come up that seem immediate like if somebody there's a a ugly thing said to a student or

271an employee by another employee and they have to wait two more weeks you know or whenever to to to bring it to the board sometimes I don't know it just seems like they feel help it's like I there have been people here like there may be situations right here from people who work at the district they may feel like they've been mistreated and they want to say something but then they're afraid because of the time and a lot of times if so much time is gone we either not necessarily forgotten it but it's so many other things that we're trying to deal with and this something that happened in October and we just get to it what in December because you have to wait is there any way I just I have an issue with

272this because maybe because I've been in the last since I've been on the board like I got on the board 2020 like around 2022 people started telling me a lot of things that was happening and going on and I tell them come to the board you know if you want to express share with the board you have a 4 to 4:30 time to express yourself and then some of the stuff has been they couldn't do it because again it's pending and we can't hear it and a lot of times I think if the some of the stuff we I mean we not I mean some of the stuff that people want to tell us is you know it's clear that what you're telling us you were in the wrong I mean you were clearly in

273the wrong and it's really it will may do you better Justice to go through the litigation period cuz maybe if we don't hear it we don't have to give you a verdict cuz once we get a verdict that's it but then again I think sometimes we just are not aware of how people are treated and we don't know that they are being mistreated and sometimes when you wait a while you don't get the information and it's skewed so I guess what I'm I'm saying maybe I should just wait and see but I I just wanted to go on record that I have a issue bman Feld has an issue page four with the pinning litigation about student or employee Discipline matters because just this week someone I don't know I didn't really knew know knew

274me you know they kind of share some things with me I said well do you want to come to the board and you know share your concerns no I'm I'm just cuz I talked about it two years ago and nobody did anything about it so I'm just you know going to resign and I was like I felt bad for them so I don't really know John and because I I'm I'm on both side I feel like we don't need to be plastered with a lot of that stuff because we have other things we have to be concerned with but at the same time I do want to be sensitive to what people are feeling and I don't want them to feel feel like well nobody's going to do anything about I'm just going to resign

275or I'm just going to leave and that has happened you know people leave for whatever reasons they leave but I just want you to know that I do have some issues and I guess I think that a lot of things we don't know as a board and I think some of the things that we were told we would be a gas we would we' go what that what but by the time they go through all of that the litigation and all of that we don't it's fixed and we don't not necessarily fixed but it's a decision has been made and then why why tell the board I mean decision has been made so I do I don't know whether there's some way we can kind of look at what's necessary to tell us before litigation

276or whether we should still go with this because there's some things happening and it's not in people's imagination it's happening and Maria has our superintendent that even has a lot to deal with as a as a superintendent a lot of stuff come through because I talked to her the other day and she was like the day is finally over I so a lot of things were coming at her you know what I'm saying and so I just don't I don't know I just have some concerns and maybe I have not been involved D long enough to hear other complaints from people you know who talk about that they feel like they've being mistreated and the board never knows about it cuz I would say I say if you got an issue why don't you know

277share with the board and then they don't they're not able to and then I guess you guys do the best you can to let us all know what's going on with schools I think that of us should ever be in the dark about any any school we don't it doesn't have to be our school cuz if something comes up and we have to vote on a hiring or somebody or dismissal we got to be in on it so you might as well tell us everything so I just want you to know I just have an issue with that I don't know how to fix it I don't know what we can do but I don't know so thank you may I say a couple things on that sure so employee and student dis Discipline matters

278are especially hard and there's a process that we have a due process that we have for both of those and there are times when allegations are made against folks students or employees and they have a right to hear the evidence against them they have the right to to contest the evidence against them offer their own statements offer their own evidence and a lot of times a great number of times these situations resolve themselves satisfactorily just by going through that process and so if folks can come in here at the beginning of the process and come to you all without going through it may shortcircuit that process because there have been times when folks have come up here and said to this board whatever their situation was and the board members will say you know what

279that's absolutely horrible that's happened to you I'm very sorry and that may or may not have been true but now what staff hears is the board member saying that's absolutely horrible that's happened to you and we're really sorry so now the staff member who has to investigate that is in a situation like oh is the board saying that what our investigation is isn't true that's why we don't have these things we let the investigatory process process play out because we do have due process for our employees and we do have due process for our students and we allow that process to go through and let's say that process goes through and the employees still not happy or the student still not happy they have the right to appeal it could either be if it's a

280student discipline case it's an expulsion it's coming to you all to decide and you all will have the final decision right and if it's you know an employee decision if it's determination it's coming to you all for a decision so there is Avenues to get to you all at eventually but I would say if you all make statements during the pendency of it too depending on what the statements are you it could be a situation like I think that diva is guilty right and if you say that then the that without having all the evidence the employee or the students representative can get up and say member Felder I think you've prejudged this case I'd like to rec I'd like like you to recuse yourself and you would have to do it so having these

281things go through the process eliminates the vast vast majority of these cases and most of the time it resolves everybody not may not be perfectly happy but that it comes to a resolution that's acceptable to everybody and on the few cases that don't you all will get to have your say but if you say it early without having all the evidence it causes it could cause issues and I appreciate you I'm sorry yes ma' I appreciate you're responding to me as honestly you know as you can about the situation because I told you on the onset that I'm I'm kind of on the fence about it because I remember a situation when I first got on the board a student at one of the high schools out east they did some stuff that was really

282really bad and we tried to get them they never made a statement they refused to make a statement but then was football season and the mother wanted to come and for us and wanted we said why didn't you make make a statement I remember saying to the student when I approached him I said baby hold your head up tell us let us hear but see that they refus to make the statement so say what happened you know so it it I guess it's a maybe sort of like a catch 22 and sometimes people are not honest as adults some of us are not honest you know for whatever reason that we're not so again and I appreciate you responding to me and I still want you to know that I still have issues but I

283do totally understand if you don't sometimes let the case finish out people do lie cuz I had people I found out some things and they lied I remember Bridget said to one of the people why you lied to the board member why you didn't tell the whole truth now ask why you tell me the old truth well I didn't think it really mattered I said but you put me out on the limb like that so I understand I just still I just want to talk about that I still got issues thank you thank you member Felder I think the superintendent did you have something to say on this as well I do and board member Felder I appreciate you being concerned about the amount of of what comes on me but I do want to

284remind the board that before something is publicly aired I'm supposed to be made aware of it so now this is the second time there's been an allegation that something has happened one was done Tuesday and now another one today that I was not made aware of it and on Tuesday you and just now you stated that you were made aware of a s somebody came to you and spoke to you that there had been they were treated inappropriately so I really am urging the board that if there's a concern that you remember that it's supposed to come to me before it's aired publicly so I have the opportunity to address it thank you thank you superintendent member Gallow thank you madam chair so first things kind of in regards to this will not be a

285helpful at all but I'm throwing it out there anyways in simol County the board members attend every disciplinary hearing we don't do that in Orange County I'm not saying it's it's it's a smaller County I mean we could do it by District if we wanted just food for thought I want to backtrack on just CU I zoned out for a minute are we not doing cards at all like if someone comes and they didn't sign up previously can they sign up on the computer here or they just out of lot yes they no they sign up on the computer here okay I just want to make sure I heard that correctly cuz my the wires got crossed I want to discuss briefly about something that's not in this policy okay that I think as a

286board we should discuss not all the time but there have been times when pre- agenda during pre- agenda we have speakers there's time left over so the board will take up maybe some of the issues that we heard during pre- agenda and this leads to us delaying our board meeting it's happening a little bit more frequently now and so I and I think that this might be a policy to put it in but I really believe that if we state that our board meeting is going to start at 5: our board meeting should start at 5: and if we have if as a board we would like to discuss it in older times we would bring it up at the end of our meeting during our thought conversation and we would say a speaker said

287this and I would like to respond to it or reply or do that and I think that's a better forum because starting the meeting at 5:30 5:05 5:15 I think is disrespectful to the public it's disrespectful to those in the audience it's disrespectful to those who are waiting to come in to be recognized and it's disrespectful to our staff and and it is nobody's fault I've contributed to it I've been the reason why we've been late before I've felt like I needed to share something which is why I'm suggesting maybe we to put something in policy that says 445 that's it no more comment no more board comment if the board would like to respond then they could respond at the end of the regularly scheduled meeting during their time Mr pomerini so I've switched

288to section 1B what it says is as follows the open public comment period shall begin approximately 1 hour prior to regularly scheduled board meeting and include no later than 45 minutes after commencing unless otherwise extended by a vote of the board provided that the extended period of time concludes prior to the beginning of the regularly scheduled board meeting so in other words Mr Pini is saying it's in it's already in there we're not following our policy can I ask that the next time that we're not following our policy that as our general counsel you push your button and say excuse me Madam chair but our policy dictates this and we've got to no more discussion can happen we've got to immediately go into our board meeting sure I will be more than happy to do

289so I you know you all know that I don't hesitate to speak up when I see that there's an issue coming down the pike but I also want to be respectful to you all in your discussions so that's why I have not done that in the past if the board desires me to do so I will most certainly remind the board that this policy says that we have to conclude prior to the start of our regularly scheduled board meeting I have no issue doing that and again I'm not because I have been part of the problem I'm going to freely admit that I'm the one who clicks my button and our chair is very gracious and she will allow us to speak because she's a big believer that all board members should be heard so

290even I need that reminder at times and I know and so that's why I'm just saying since we do have it policy maybe just a gentle at 4:45 a gentle reminder that if anybody would like a quick break before the 5:00 session we have in right now otherwise we're going straight into that 5:00 we're not taking a break if we continue a conversation and it's 5:00 and we need to start the board meeting we're going to go straight into it so I will make it as a matter of of my what I do I will look and see when it's 4:45 and then I will remind the board members of the board that this period is supposed to end no later than 45 minutes after it commences and you all have to I believe it

291says unless otherwise extended by a vote of the board so I will have to remind you all that a vote of the board is required to go beyond 4 that would require a motion and a second and then a vote correct yes ma'am what I'm not done so the next thing I want to I agree about continuing what member front said on number two section B that we continue having those meetings I find them to be very informative on the top of page four I have one question I know that the amendment rights and I don't agree with it I do I used to be a supporter of broadcasting our pre- agenda I'm now not and now I'm really not if they can mention names we're all fair game I ran for office our teachers

292and our administrators are under a lot of stress so for people to be able to come up here and vent about one of our employee whether it's true or not is to baring like that's defamation and I don't know how we can allow I don't know how First Amendment Trump's defamation rights so there is in the law privileges for folks who testify in public hearings that they don't there's the principle of they have the right to petition the government for redress of their Grievances and they should be able to do that and a lot of times they get a privilege against in the claim of defamation because they're doing it in a public for in the place where they're supposed to be doing it now there are sometimes when it's so egregious that it clicks

293over and maybe the privilege goes away or there it gets waved but they get wide latitude just like you all get wide latitude you all have an absolute privilege from what you say up at the dis on a claim from defamation so you all get wide latitude but people coming in to to redress grievances directly to the government get wide latitude as well thank you for that Mr pomini what about students will they be allowed to mention students names if a parent comes up and another student's bullying their student will they be able to come up and say I go to ABC Elementary and little Johnny has been pushing Sally around and hurting her what are you going to do about it I fear that if we were to prohibit it we could be in

294potentially in liability so what about pending litigation or discipline matters I mean doesn't it throw all this stuff out so no that doesn't do that what you cannot engage in Viewpoint discrimination under the law but what you can do is say there are certain topics and content that are off limits in a particular form you all have the right to set up what kinds of speech what categories of speech you're entitled to hear what you can't do is say I'm gonna allow you to talk about you know topic X but I can't let you offend somebody but I can say pending litigation and pending employee Discipline matters those entire topics regardless of whether you're for or against something are off limits so we get to set the Forum but once we open the form we

295can't prohibit somebody's Viewpoint so somebody can get up to the microphone and just start throwing down F bombs and there's nothing we can do about it you know I think if it's if it's F bombs you know I think a general reminder that this is a public forum and that it probably would be better if we could say things more civy would be appropriate but if they continue to drop the f bomb you know probably could that we probably would have an issue if we pre prevented it now if they started calling you the BW the c-word you know all of those types of things I think that's probably the place where you could say you know what it's harassment that's that's enough that's that you don't have a right you have the right to

296give offense but that's too far that would be the place where I would say let's draw the line okay so thank you for that at the top of page four under relevant topics under a it says except as otherwise indicated in this policy speakers may only address the board on topics that are related to work of the board if they come up here and they start discussing employee relations or an employee problem can't we say I'm so sorry that's not the work of the board that falls under operation falls under the superintendent that's not that's what's the word that you use not Germaine to the topic at hand or you're out of order so ultimately the work of the board also includes overseeing the performance of the superintendent and so she's operation I don't disagree

297with that I if you look remember look at the bravard County case and what they said which is you know if you want to come in and criticize the math teacher you can do that right that is operational quintessentially but they said the board has to listen to that and so I would be very leery I understand the distinction you're trying to draw I don't think the court would buy that distinction but we'd have to get sued first we would have to get why thank you for giving me extra work I appreciate that yes we would have to get sued well I my point is I'm I'm wondering and I think I know the answer is going to be no if we could add a little bit more teeth to the relevant topics to preclude

298people from really speaking harshly of our employees or our students I think as a board it's Paramount that we protect their privacy and their rights and I'm extremely concerned with the burden and the harm that could cause to our teachers are under so much right now to have somebody come up and then hear it from everybody else oh so and so was at the mic and saying this and this is out about you it's so unfair and so I mean if there's anything we could do to give this teeth to stop that from happening I get we don't want to get sued but I'd rather stand up for the rights of of our employees and their privacy and take that shot versus have them decimated at a Podium because some disgruntled person or it could

299even be somebody that's not even in this community I they can attack us all they want I don't care bring Bring it on I elected to do this but our employees at the end of the day are just trying to teach kids they're doing the best that they can their pay stinks there's a lot of pressure on them and then for them to be in that kind of Limelight when they didn't ask for it I believe it's unfair that's all I have thank you thank you member Gallow so can we do that can you legally look and see if there's anything we can do with that I I will I will look and see what kind of language I could craft there's always another option eliminate the period Al together you know this board's not

300going to do that I no well maybe that's that's I am you asked what options there are and that is an option I will look to see if there are other options the problem is that case was so broadly decided that in theory you can write language that would potentially pass constitutional muster but in practice I don't know how to do it but it is it is from a lawsuit and I know that in a court of law it would be like the case versus Bard County Schools blah blah blah but it's not in statute we wouldn't be breaking the law we could just if someone disagree with what we're doing they could sue us but I'm just wondering if we could put language in here that we could say well our interpretation is this

301doesn't come under the purview of the board the superintend yes reports to the board but operationally she gets to make her own decisions and unless an employee comes and gets terminated and finds fault with that we never hear about it people I mean we approve the hires but we don't that's more of a like administrative deed that we do versus really have an input on what happens and nor should we have input on who the superintendent hires I mean there's a reason why there's the governing body and the operational body and so I'm just thinking that if we could say hey I'm sorry that is not within the purview of the board then we could we can kind of stop them from harming you know our employees our students again it does not and should

302not pertain to us but it should pertain to our employees so I'm thinking this is just on the Fly and I'm going to look at it so of that in see where you have the various things that you don't disc us I could do something to the effect of criticisms of employees that have not been raised with Administration in the first instance that could be that could be a category you know cuz I would be leery of banning it Al together but I think if you say you have to raise it with the administrator and go through the ad the administrative process first and go through the superintendent and her staff first and get that fully resolved one way or the other before you come here that's going to stop 99.9% of your issues we

303can attempt to do that you know obviously I can't guarantee if somebody were to sue us over it what a court would do with it but I think that would put a guard rail in place first to maybe prevent most of these things from from getting to you where teacher's getting criticized that may be some language I can add and the superintendent's looking at me like superintendent I really like that where U board member Gallow is taking us and I'm just wondering if it was bravard right the case if bravard had anything in policy similar to this that didn't cover them versus that statement in our policy that would and I am in 100% agreement you know they can attack they can say whatever they want about us but first of all when they're coming

304and they're making those statements about our staff we don't know that it's true right and the I am not a fan of broadcasting because if they say something we may not have the information at at the table to be able to say you're right or you're wrong but that's already out there and there's no guarantee that when we do find out the correct answer they're going to be listening to it so I would I would want us to take a look if Bard had that in their policy and if this has a potential to cover us because I think we're not violating our policy and we're letting them speak just to only topics that are related to the work of the board I will attempt to craft something as best I can you know remember

305bra what Bard had is you couldn't have any personally directed speech and the court said that was unconstitutional so you know I think if maybe they didn't foreclose the entire field on that we can try it I can try to craft language and bring it back thank you Mr pomerini member Vanos thank you that's actually what I was going to suggest was just to put the employees under you know the pending litigation just make ocps employees under that I do wonder when you said the language criticism I feel like maybe you'd have to say anything any comment on employee yes no I was thinking on the fly yes yeah yeah but yeah I was going to suggest the same thing and I guess I also want to clarify too if someone were to come up

306and say you know math teacher is stealing candy from children on Saturdays like is that allowed or does it have to be related to what we're doing on this or you know is it related to what he does in the classroom or is can they say anything about well I think their privilege to petition a government to redress grievances would have to be with respect to the work that is done for the government that you all could potentially have the ability to remedy when they come up here if he's out there stealing candy from children on Saturdays I mean that may be Criminal activity but that's not anything that we would deal with in the first instance we may deal with the arrest Fallout from an employment standard or standpoint after that but yeah I

307you know math teacher goes out on Saturday night and does XYZ and post on social media yeah yeah I think it's just important that we know that so that if you know if a speaker starts to go down that lane we know that okay that is actually not allowed that they can't just say anything about anyone so what I would anticipate is as this is going on I will be the first line of defense to chime in to say hey I think this is going beyond the parameters that they're allowed to address okay so I I have a pretty Keen ear when it comes to that and I'm very attuned to what these standards are okay so if if I think it's getting to that point it'll probably be my job to address in the

308first instance so Madam chair we stop here and then speak through the issue and do it that way okay just wanted to clarify that this lawsuit didn't change that also wanted to say that I do agree with continuing the CTA okasa and OA comments and then the other issue is just to the extent something comes up I mean maybe we can kind of exclude the employee conversations but if you know if something were to come up and a speaker's talking about something that we need to rip up because it's not true I think and I think the superintendent makes a really good point that we're just not going to capture the same audience but I think we should think about what we have to do something so like what would be the best way to

309respond when someone comes up and just you know has their First Amendment right to say whatever but it's misrepresentations it's untruths it's things that aren't happening it's not in the district you know what is the best way for us to respond I think we just need to think about that and be prepared because it's going to happen yeah yeah that I mean in the past you know what we've done is folks have said stuff at pre- Agenda it's clearly not true staff will gather the information superintendent or board member during the regular meeting we've done it at the end of the meeting say you know earlier today we heard people make XY YZ statement that's not true we heck it happened Tuesday night when we had a speaker get up here and say I know

310for a fact is has been in school two different schools and the superintendent immediately corrected it so you know I think we have in the past done things that to correct blatant misrepresentations and I think we'll be prepared to do it in the future it just depends on like how long it's gone and and what instance it happens so okay and then one other with member sorry fairly fairly bacing it still with member Gallo's comment about the board responding during the public comment period I would suggest that it's not just that we don't allow it to go to 4:45 but that we don't even start because what happened in a previous meeting was some people had time to respond right after and then other people had to wait go through the whole meeting and then

311they were responding and then it wasn't clear that some people you know what I mean it wasn't a cohesive conversation so I really think we should try hard to not say anything even if we have time so there is so there's one of two ways to do that one I can put in formal language two you all can police yourselves now I will leave that we are not good at that so I we passionate yeah you are listen I'm trying to be extremely differential to you all and what you all want to do so I'm making suggest so I can bring language back that says any response to speakers Can we'll wait till you know board member comments at the end of of the board meeting now there will be times when for example the

312person says ice wasn't here right and if you all all are saying if you all don't if it's in policy that you all don't respond then that sits there for a room full of people and it doesn't get rebutted so there's there's pluses and minuses there well maybe we could allow the superintendent to respond because she's more responsible so if she needs to to correct something she could respond in that moment but I feel like what because what happens is it's different I think when one board member chimes in then other people feel like they need to as well but if the superintendent can correct something that is clearly inaccurate I think that's that is different all right I will craft language to reflect that if that's the will of all of you sitting up

313there yes superintendent and what we thank you madam chair what we used to do is they would speak and you know they've come here and if they have a concern I think we need need to at least try and have staff respond to them so what we used to do board did not comment like they we you just go through and then at the end the chair you know would recognize the superintendent and you know we would say there and staff like I'm I'm when someone's up there I'm already texting to say please make sure you talk to so talk to that speaker so I can actually say we have staff that is prepared to to meet with you right after the pre- agenda and that way they at least have someone that they've contact

314with and I think the other piece and it's I don't know if it needs to be in policy but I think it's something we need to do in practice for sure is that we provide a response to the board about any action that's taken based on the people who have come right so if it's you know if the parent that has had issues with the IEP not being followed then we can give you an initial response you know we had the School leader principal leader meet with the parent they're going to schedule a meeting and at least you know what has been done with any person that's come to speak that had a concern so we can do that and you may I mean I don't know if it needs to be in policy but

315I think that's something we can definitely do to at least assure the board that someone has made an attempt to address the issues and concern from the I think that's a practice matter superintendent and then just one more piece just because this lawsuit is relevant to what we're talking about today I for one wanted to say that there is some language in this lawsuit that I personally in this moms for Liberty lawsuit that I personally appreciate so I just wanted to read two sentences one is indeed it is firmly settled under our constit tion that the public expression of ideas may not be prohibited merely because the ideas are themselves offensive to some of their hearers and then it goes on to say the government is ill equipped in any event to decide what is

316or is not offensive that's it that's a good place for we the only thing I was just going to add I had buzzed in was is it possible for us to just in one of our categories that we will not allow is the names or names of miners I can we prohibit that at least I'm going to try to craft language for okay for for anything having to do with specific employees or students thank you and we will hope that it stands and we'll fight it if it we get challenged then we'll see where it goes okay and I'm going to let member Felder close us out so we can go home all right yes I just have a concern sometimes even if a complaint has been made not all people in charge are going

317to be honest I know that from my own personal experience before I got on this board sometimes administrators or whoever the persons that be they're not honest and what they say so in the event I do have concerns about calling people's names and attacking teachers and all that's I'm really not with that at all but sometimes when parents come and employes come when they try to if when you said that before they can come to us they go through Administration I'm hoping that we have a vetting process in place or we know in fact that the administrator is going to treat them fairly sometimes they don't and so in that event if the admin no that didn't happen this didn't happen and then they are not able to come and then later on down the

318line we would get a lawsuit because a lawsuit may come out we realize that if they had been allowed to say what it really happened then as a board and a superintendent we could look at and realize that the administrator or who whoever the persons the powers that be that were in control they were wrong sometimes it happen not all the time sometimes there are lies and we find out later on that the person who was accusatory that they were not telling the truth and that's why this policy may be good because sometimes they do lie but sometimes they're not lying they're not lying and so I'm just hoping that when we revamp we look at this wording and that we deal with both sides of the question because everybody's not truthful we give everybody

319the benefit of the doubt that you're going to do the right thing that's the best way to see people in a good light but sometimes they are not in a good light right thank you thank you member Felder I believe that concludes all of our business today we got through all three items and it only took us free at last a ton of hours but this was a lot of work this week thank you U Mr pomerini for all your work have a good night everyone have a good night a

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.