CorpusRecord 4675

2/6/25 KCS BOE Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / KCS TV
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Knox County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,804 words · about 49 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e welcome everybody to the Board of Education February 6 2025 regular session meeting please stand as we observe a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance led by Miss Elkins Al to the flag of the United States of America to the rep for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all just a few announcements Mr triplet will not be in attendance tonight and as was announced at Monday's work session several board members members will be attend attending the tsba legislative and legal Institute in Franklin Tennessee on Monday February 10th and Tuesday February 11th the naming facilities committee will be meeting on a Friday March 7th at 9:00 a.m. in this boardroom to consider a nomination to name the Gibbs High School baseball field in honor of alumni

002Morgan Wallen the 30-day required window prior to the meeting open today to allow time for public input so please share your feedback with the committee by email to board.of KN schools.org or by calling the board office our next policy review meeting is scheduled for Friday March 14th at 10: a.m. in the sportroom are there any requested changes to the agenda motion by Miss Christie second by Miss Templeton all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries okay moving on we have special recognition of some reward schools this evening so I'm going to pass that on to Dr Wilson There we go thank you madam chair members of the board um we are always excited to have a few moments to celebrate great achievement ments and tonight we get the chance to celebrate some

003of our schools and school leaders for the work that they do every day in November the State Department of Education announced the latest group of reward schools Based on data from the 2324 school year this is the state's highest designation and it recognizes schools that are making gains in terms of both achievement and growth for Stu students and all of our student groups tonight we're celebrating 18 schools that Reed the reward School designation and as you know we've had the chance over the course of this year at various times to highlight the positive gains and that we're seeing as a district in key areas like third and fourth grade reading and sixth and eth grade mathematics and we know results like these don't happen by chance I'm grateful for the hard work of all of

004our principles teachers and students that have contributed to the gains that we're seeing and I'm excited to get to recognize these schools for their part in that this evening we're going to ask each of them to come up and receive a poster and take a picture we're going to begin with region one and board members you're welcome as we get to the point of taking the pictures to join your schools as part of that so beginning with our principles in the audience we're going to start with region one and Al Lots Elementary and principal Tracy Marsh and first grade teacher Katie T [Applause] [Music] [Applause] tumens do individual pictures okay thank you [Music] next also from region one Bearden Elementary School represented by principal Porsche Harris [Applause] [Music] next is Bluegrass Elementary School who I

005believe is represented by M Jenkins uh Dr cutter couldn't do this come [Applause] out and Misty is the assistant principal I'm sorry I did not clarify that [Applause] next we welcome faragate Intermediate School represented by principal Susan [Applause] [Music] parum you all good [Applause] next we have norshore Elementary School principal Kimberly Harris and assistant principal Stacy Hillard next is Sequoya ele school and principal Shay Syer awesome and our last school from region one is West Valley Middle School principal Jennifer vasic and sixth grade science teacher Emily Rosco [Applause] all right from region two our first school is Harden Valley Elementary School principal Sarah fish and assistant principal Dr Karen [Applause] sharp good deal thank you next we have K's Elementary School principal Daniel champion and Whitney harness intervention teacher [Applause] [Music] all right and our

006final school from region two Pleasant Ridge Elementary School principal Jennifer Morel and assistant principal Jenny Scott two of our St MERS come on up yeah come on up guys [Applause] congratulations yes all right Region Three our first school will be Bonnie Kate Elementary School principal Rocky rally thank I know you're good [Applause] next career Magnet Academy principal Charlene Lewis and Janet aosta Academy coach [Music] taking oh goodness okay you a little thank you for doing that wait just a [Applause] [Music] second next we have Gap Creek Elementary School and principal Carl Whipple and actually James slay who was principal last year at Gap Creek is also joining us tonight so happy to have him [Music] thank you guys next Ellen n STEM Academy and principal Jim Allen [Applause] [Music] [Applause] next is Mount Olive Elementary

007principal Robert Angel and AA klie Pennington [Applause] [Music] [Applause] per and our final school from Region Three South Knox Elementary School principal tana nicle and assistant principal Reggie [Music] Mosley baby not here he's not here okay Tana reminded me that was back to back as she walked up here so [Applause] that's oh okay goodal all right next up our schools from Region 4 and first we're going to recognize Gibbs Elementary School our principal Joe Cameron sick tonight couldn't be with us so representing Gibbs is Michelle Nance assistant principal and Lisa moles their instructional coach [Applause] [Music] all right our last school this evening I I'll try not to be partial since they have a very handsome fifth grade boy there that may belong to me um is shannondell Elementary School principal Renee Rapa and assistant

008principal Terry [Applause] [Music] Fischer he's a handsome so just last thing I would be remiss if I didn't point out you guys saw as the schools came up um representation from the regional directors and the regional supervisors that work daily both in support uh and collaboration with these these School leaders and uh they do a phenomenal job uh getting out there working with our content and support teams and working with these principles and just uh the job they do is phenomenal so I wanted to make sure we recognize that tonight as well so for one final time please join me in congratulating all these schools that we're recognizing tonight [Music] I I was just about to say if y'all want to go ahead and head [Laughter] out yeah y'all go enjoy the weather a nice

009dinner congratulations again did I didn't to that I know well such a beautiful night they can go out and enjoy and celebrate thank you so all right we will go ahead and get into our regular agenda items Miss Cy thank you madam chair item six approved superintendent's Employment contract a motion by Miss Christie a second by was that you miss Templeton second by Miss Templeton any discussion yeah yes Miss font Ridley um coming in as a coming in as a new board member um and then the evaluation happening Bam Bam Bam even though I was in the classroom for so long I had no idea what some of this things meant so I would like to make a motion to um push the evaluation back to June so that when the new board comes in

010in two years they have an entire year to think about the evaluation and it will also line up with the fiscal year right are you talking about like June this year no or oh so June of 2026 starting 26 27 26 27 because we'll all still be here next year the contract or the evaluation the evaluation oh gotcha gotcha okay in okay okay I see um so that is in board policy that timeline so we would have to discuss that in policy review like changing the the entire timeline so make a motion then or or make a motion now or told you told you thank you madam chair uh so so miss font o rley uh I mean you know because it is a policy um you would have to make a motion to to

011change the policy and I know that this board has a habit of taking policies to policy review before making substantive changes so um so so because that's that's what you want to do and and believe me board members are free to make motions at meetings anytime they want but I mean because that's the particular substance of your motion um you know I would agree that you know probably best for you to bring it to policy review and then I mean there's there's time between now and and next June to do that so I mean that's you can do yeah that's good yeah but but if you have other concerns about the about the contract then you know Now's the Time to no I do not okay okay any more discussion seeing seeing there is none

012all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries item seven consent agenda motion by Miss Christie second by Reverend Butler any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries item 8A approved first reading of KN County Board of Education policy D100 fiscal management goals and objectives as amended Mo motion by Miss Christie second by Reverend Butler any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 8B approv first reading of knots County Board of Education policy e170 student transportation management as amended motion by Reverend Butler second by Miss Christie any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries eight C approved first reading of KN County Board of Education policy e173

013private vehicles for transporting students as amended motion by Miss Christie second by Reverend Butler any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 8 D approve first read of KN County Board of Education policy F-150 new project planning as amended motion by Reverend Butler second by second Miss Miss Christie any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 8 e approve first read of knots County Board of Education policy J1 191 misbehaviors and disciplinary options as amended motion by Miss Christie second by Reverend Butler do we have any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 9A approved Dollar General literacy Foundation Grant in the amount of $3,000 for B Morris Elementary School

014motion by Miss Christie a by Miss Templeton any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 9B approve keep Knoxville beautiful communication beautification grants in the total amount of $3,250 for Cedar Bluff and pal middle schools motion by Miss Christie second by Miss Templeton any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 10 a approve an increase to design contract with Sparkman and Associates architects Incorporated up to$ 6,296 to cover additional services for renovations to Lincoln Park Center for the newcomer Academy motion by Reverend Butler a second by Miss Christie any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 11a approved fiscal year 2025 General purpose budget line item transfers for October 1

015through December 31 2024 in the amount of $124,000 $124,800 by Sherman Carter Barnhart Architects motion by Miss Christie second by Mr Wright any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 11 C approve Mechanicsville lawdale Bowmont schools plan proposal motion by Reverend Butler a second by Miss Christy I see we have some discussion missley thank you V chair um there are a few things that I have a concern with um I was able to go over the survey that was given out but there was no mention that a merger was a possibility and I feel like that should be pretty transparent if we're talking about closing four schools or moving the students from four schools into one um as a public educator in in in in inner city

016schools for my entire career I know how important it is for Community Schools and I mentioned this on Monday um but best practices were mentioned in the proposal and I'm not exactly sure um where those best practices came from mainly because countless Studies have been done and um articles written about the import of small elementary schools especially in more disadvantaged communities each piece of information that I read has stressed the importance of relationships that schools that staff students and parents from form when they go to a small Elementary School I understand that larger schools in the county have performed well but to compare affluent School area schools with large populations and additional support from Foundation as other opportunities that enhance the experience experiences those schools to comparing them to schools in disadvantaged areas that do

017not benefit from all the extras is like comparing apples to oranges um West Ed which is a um information policy um company out of uh California um in an information analysis states that smaller School smaller is better When taking into account how disadvantaged the communities are um poor and minority students benefit most from smaller population sizes positive changes that smallness invites include the forming of strong personal bonds parent and Community involvement Simplicity and focus and improved instructional quality improved teacher working conditions and job satisfaction and built-in accountability um not to beat a dead horse about me teaching but going from teaching in a school with less than 500 100 kids in any given year to representing a larger School larger schools in District 3 has been a real eyeopener um while I've witnessed how great

018the larger schools are and feel of the smaller schools and the connections between children and pretty much every single adult in the building is so special every school has its own identity and to assume that a child who struggles sometimes to just get to school will rise to the challenge it's not something based in reality investment in the neighborhood schools could be something great um would it be wrong with using the funds allocated for the new school to bring the smaller schools up to the programming levels of the larger schools in the county and as for raising scores that money could be used for support such as tutoring after school opportunities for students who are struggling um I've seen firsthand how these supports have been helpful and brought big results um in addition I've heard

019from some parents of schools in the affected in the affected schools concerns lie with the fact that the current proposal is a building proposal only with no PR programming that will be offered to make a deal before any indication of the impact on the school communities involved is troubling I would like to see a concerted effort and promise that certain opportunities remain such as the arts program at bont I would like to suggest we table the vote if that's a possibility until more information um and input from all parts of the community and the school staff I know that there's at least one of the administrators involved in one of these schools whose doctorate is in urban education so um to not try to gather information and opinions from the administration I think we've missed

020an opportunity to actually see kind of how they feel Miss Mike thank you madam chair I have a few more questions about this but I really appreciate um everyone answering all the questions I've had over the last few days Corey Keith Garfield um and and I you know I know that this is you know building a new school is always um a big deal and comes with lots of questions um I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about how you came up with the total number of students that you would plan for this school I know you touched on it a little bit and some of it but just you don't have to go too in depth but just as I remember I think it was um a th Elementary School 500

021Middle School is that correct uh yes Madam chair uh Miss bike uh so yes we're looking at projected numbers uh and then working with Knox knoxv planning uh also um with the development in that area and and with the current population of students that's where we came up with the numbers of a th and approximately 600 middle school students uh that would bring those students back into their Community M um so it's the students that are at the current schools will or the zoned because I know that those students you know this this is going to take years um so we're not talking about those specific students but potentially the families that are zoned for those schools will some of them be end up being zoned for other schools or is it every family that's

022currently zoned for those plus more so the plus more would be the students that are currently bust out of their Community they would be coming back to their communities okay um but for the ones that are zoned for the and currently in those schools none of them would go back out to other schools that is correct those kuds would not be formed out of their communities okay okay thank you um next question is that um do you expect to have the same kind of number of trans for students that would want to go to this school and be able to um allow that space for them so the current numbers that we have does accommodate for the transfer students uh I can't speak to what that looks like in the next five years uh but

023I will say traditionally the numbers that we have with the projected numbers are are pretty sufficient to hold those students okay just to put it in perspective the school has 247,000 Square ft approximately yeah um and next question is I'm curious um if you've looked at the distance um from the three schools that we're talking about um to the rule High site so what when you I'm a little confused what question are you asking um I well I'll explain sorry it's been a long day no that's I just want to make sure I'm answering the right question um basically I'm curious about um with pulling these schol schools into one school plus having a middle school the distance that students will travel and be expected to travel and how many of those will it take

024out of their neighborhoods to get to this school so the communities that the school would will be serving it it it does like when you look at zoning it is within the Zone M so it it's not pulling them out of their Zone it's keeping them in their zone so it would it would accommodate the needs of a Zone I guess is what you're asking me um these students would if you were look at if you were to look at this uh on a zoning map then these students would be within their Zone they would not be out of their Zone okay I guess um sorry I'm trying to articulate the pictures in my mind um so like for the students that go to bont that are zoned for Bowmont and um you know like

025they're talking about a walking school bus and all of these other things and I know that to a certain extent the parental responsibility Zone if there will change but you know will these students then be expected to get on a bus and get to there is this I'm sorry that I have not looked on the map and Google ma to see how far they are but I'm curious if you guys have so one of the reasons we don't we don't do zoning until that that that comes after right so just like for instance far the the new school the elementary school in far experence milek right so we look at the zoning lines this is a little this is much more clean um because this school is serving in a particular Community uh and so

026this is a little different from other situations where we're busing students out of their Community this would be serving student in in the communities that that it serves so uh I guess it's just more of a clean P feeder pattern when you look at it uh and so it's very unique because because it's in a center city and because it's landord loed and because it's in a concentrated area um the zoning uh looks it it looks very clean when you when you when you look at actually doing the school zones okay um and then two more questions um if you were to have programming that had theater and things like that would there be a stage incorporated or would that be something that would come after it being built so that that's a part of

027the process of the actual design we would work very closely with academics we'd work very closely with the Arts programs we'd work very closely with the principal um or or or or the the director for those regions and and what was what would the school entail so yes if if if there was an art program we would design the school for an art program if there was a dance program we would design school for a stage so it it's just the programs would determine what the actual um uh schools look like okay I mean sorry you need unique areas within the school would look like yeah uh thank you um and my last question is is that the the title of this has lawdale in it but am I correct that we're not actually londsdale

028is not included in this plan they are included they are included there's there's a section of londsdale if you look at it now and and I will say every londsdale the two londsdale meetings I went the the the the families knew exactly where it was they're like yeah that doesn't really belong in that area so it's like on the Ridge and so that area would be included in the in a natural zone so lawdale Community but not school is that that is correct yeah la yes yes it's just it's just a portion of the community that's literally outside of the zone of lawdale it goes back to making clean feder patterns we would just clean that up okay so would any of any of the students that currently go to that are zone for Londale

029end up being zoned for this one or do we just not know that yet if you look at it now I'd say there would be a small portion that's why we included laale in the community meetings uh but it's not a large portion of students okay all right thank you yeah absolutely thank you a good questions Miss Templeton thank you madam chair sorry um yes so I I do have one question about just timeline at what point in this timeline is a principal decided upon that's a good question because I think that is a good education for folks to know how that works Dr R thank you madam chair Miss Templeton um so the way that works I think this is a this is three years out if I'm right Dr Adams uh we usually

030do that the end of the year before so they have a year that they work without the building because at that point um you know the design and the plan and all is there um they use that time to do community meetings lots of times there's picks on pick on things like color uh sometimes naming of the facility all those kinds of things and so uh when we do all of that then then that person's kind of the point for that they go out and do the community meeting so uh it is it's it's the year before the school would open okay two years out correct two years out if it's three years now it' be two years out before I name that person they have a full year to work basically without an operational

031building um and go from there I think uh we did that most recently with Dr scha knocker at mil Creek at the year before to work and I say it was a really cool process to see that because what she did was she you know she didn't didn't have a a building at that time but what she did was work out of the schools that it was pulling from so she really got to know those communities and so it really helped set the culture for mil Creek and she built her team it was really it was really cool to see from start to finish how it really kind of builds the community and then the community gets really excited about it right and I I appreciate that there's a process in place um and that

032um the community is a part of that conver ation and um led by the principal who's going to be doing the work doing the really hard work um yeah I absolutely appreciate that I I do believe however that we are in a very unique situation um with this property and with these particular schools that um and I you all heard everything I had to say on Monday and I don't feel the need to repeat all of it um and we've all received um a lot of emails from the community this week um which thank you to everyone who has sent an email I know this is somewhat anecdotal but it really is important for us to hear from our communities um on the impact of any of our decisions so um anecdotally thank you to

033everyone here who is going to speak on this and also um thank you to all of those who have reached out via phone and email so um that aside I want to take into account um the words that people took the time to reach out and say um this community is somewhat unique um because it does have the school um that receives the most transfer requests in it um because of its Arts integrated curriculum um and um that's something that I believe the community has already gotten behind due to the nope you're good um I thought it was myself talking back to me we all been there I was like I'm hearing voice I think everybody looked to see if it was their phone no it's good you're good we've all been there we've all

034been there um no but I do want to um recognize that this is a unique opportunity because Western Heights has had a lot of conversation about what their Community um can be and what they want to get behind and that is seen in the Western Heights transformation plan um in that transformation plan there are maker spaces there are opport unities for Arts creation and education there's an incubator for real good kitchen and um and I believe this is an opportunity for the board to set a vision for this school I do not think that we need to um set the curriculum for the school but it but setting a vision um with the um needs of the community that we already know um is important for all those who will be affected um so I

035would like to to um amend the motion and Miss cotney um I would like it to say I would like to approve the K through 9 Mechanicsville Lawnsdale Bowmont schools plan proposal to include comparable magnet type funding dedicated transfer seats Arts integrated curriculum and honors opportunities these are the things that we have learned from the Bowmont EXP experience the things that make that experience um positive for everyone that lives under its roof and um please understand that um this plan I recognize uh affects the West View families as well as the um mayard families and um I want to be sensitive to that because they are doing incredible work under their roofs as well so let that be on the record that I understand that um I am um at this moment focusing on um

036the magnet school that is bont and the and what has worked and the programming that has worked and I want to set a vision to allow for that in the future so I've amended the motion okay so an amended motion by Miss Templeton seconded by Miss bike do I want to do a is there any more discussion on Miss Christie oh okay so I just I have a couple questions I guess about the amended motion and first let me just say as far as the excitement and the Western Heights development and I think Miss Henderson you were probably the only other currently sitting board member on the board when this happened but um kcdc did a present for this board in in 2021 so I feel like this discussion has been ongoing for quite a

037while I mean I feel like even before Dr Adams came on I feel like we were having or Dr risewick um I know I had conversations with Mr Thomas and Mr Oaks about it so I do feel like this really isn't and it is exciting I mean all those things were in there that you talked about the maker spaces and the the food courts and all that um I guess my only question because we typically well first correct me if I'm wrong but the design phase still has to come back to the board for approval right the the school design still has to come back to this board for approval um which should entail all those things people are asking for right um I guess my question is and my hesitancy is to typically we

038do not get that far ahead as far as curriculum and things like that so I I kind of would like to know the associated costs with that I mean it's hard to vote on something without knowing what kind of fiscal impact it might have Miss Morgan thank you madam chair I wanted to just reiterate this was mentioned Monday uh but at hearing that the community wasn't given a chance to speak into this and that kind of thing there were eight Community meetings is that right Dr Adams eight when we did the faragate uh solution last year we had three and that was a lot I was at all of them three was a lot eight a lot of meetings they were made accessible in multiple languages they were um at different times of day so

039that people could attend them I do think that eight Community meetings is a lot of opportunity for people to ask questions and um and voice their concerns with things um so I couldn't in good I couldn't in good faith table this or anything like that I think all of the appropriate steps and measures have been taken um additionally this is Reverend Butler's District he knows this community he knows what this community needs he has spent years working on this with the KCs staff and with his constituents and his district and um I I think it's overstepping for a lot of us in different districts to say what we think another District would need and what would be best for their community so I Dr Butler said on Monday that he ships this as the kids

040say my kids will die that I just said that out loud um don't tell but that he fully supports this and um so I I defer to him you support it Dr Butler that's what you said Monday I could have used it totally wrong too I'm not I'm not a student clearly um so I go with what Dr Butler says again it's his community he knows and um I support him Miss Elkins may be like she is crazy I don't know what she just said but I I respect what Dr Butler has done in the work there so I think if he supports it and is on board it and that's the recommendation from our staff that I support this proposal do we have any more discussion on this Miss F Ridley thank you um

041so there's is there any chance of table in this and talking more to like school administrators and all that I mean procedurally you could make a motion to table it and then if you had a second then we would take a vote on it okay I would like to make a motion to table this until at least the next board meeting so that more information can be given out to the communities about what they're about to about they what they could expect okay motion by Miss fter Ridley is there a second okay seeing there's no second that motion fails so we're back then to the amended motion if there's no more discussion on this we do have a public forum speaker on this item that I'll bring up and we can oh Dr Dr Butler

042yeah speaker on well so on the voting items we take like the speakers on that item and then do a vote I should have called him before discussion but when it's on a voting item we take those specific speakers on that item speaker oh that is a good question I don't think we've ever had this before all right well so thank you madam chair to answer your question Reverend Butler this is this is something unique to the board that the board allows uh speakers to speak uh before the motion so uh and as U as the chair said I mean normally um when the when the motion is called on the on the on the docket then that's when the speaker is allowed to come up you know even before the discussion's had so uh

043you know as a matter of practice I think this board can allow the speaker now uh but I mean you know that that's we're a little we're a little out of order at this point anyway [Laughter] so Mr Jernigan would you like to come up you will have three minutes to state your name and County of residence and welcome again this week I appreciate the opportunity to speak thank you for giving me the opportunity the work that has been moved forward to create the opportunity for this new school is obviously been massive and as I mentioned on Monday night the the alternative location that I'm suggesting for this school is the Knoxville College property I sent an email out to all the board members early earlier today and then I've brought the copy of the

044uh email that I sent as a handout with a little map attached so you can see exactly where the properties are that I'm discussing the situation is that the debt owner of the uh $4.7 million First Mortgage on the Knoxville College property is offering it to the Knox County school system uh to be able to purchase that note that would give the school board the effective control of the 54 Acre Site of the 54 Acres approximately 11.5 acres is already zoned for 256 housing units uh it is there's no it does not appear that there's any kind of U difficulty or environmental condition with that 11 and a half acres it's generally flat to Rolling it has great Road access it is exactly the kind of rectangular property that is easy to develop for a

045school with uh playground facility uh or Sports fields in addition to that property being available there were a number of questions that I don't believe I have seen answered in the public for example what are the schools that are being traded what is mayard Elementary what is the value that's associated with that school in the public market Bowman has 76,000 Square fet in it on 6 and a half acres what is that land worth that's being traded to the Knox Knox County for the Rural High School site those properties have really significant ific value in the open market I feel and it doesn't seem exactly correct that that should be traded for the rural high school property which the county spent 30 years trying to give away so now we have a situation where there

046are real benefits to the city to the community to the betterment of Education in all of Knoxville for the school board to move forward with acquiring the Knox College debt and therefore the ownership of the property to be able to make things move forward in a positive way for the public education in Knoxville in the email you can see that I've detailed several other questions as to what is what is Knox County's obligation to use these buildings will mayard become UT housing I mean you talk about some place that you could put in 60 70 beds for UT housing mayard Elementary would be the perfect location are there going to be any requirements on what Knox County is going to be allowed to do so these are things that I think deserve further discussion a

047tabling of the issue as has been brought out which unfortunately didn't get a second would give the opportunity to have really robust conversations with the community because the fenin school was turned into a a permanent Supportive Housing and I'm not sure that anybody in the schools in these neighborhoods would want us permanent I think it's a wonderful thing fenan school has been a great asset but it's the kind of thing you need to have neighborhood involvement in let them see it coming I'm finished thank you very much thank you so much all right you want to talk yeah m is there anybody else anymore that's it for public forum do you want to do you want to speak yeah yeah I do y um I apologize I was caught off guard mid talk last time

048so I wanted to kind of go back to my thoughts yeah sorry um there's something important that I I believe is part of this amendment um this amended motion and what I want to reiterate are the set aside seats that the current school and the magnet schools provide um and that is very important in this community because it provides um opportunity for out of Zone kids to participate in the school as a whole um you know I these were my words on um Monday and I'm going to say them again because I want to make it very clear as to why I've put forth this motion both as a parent of a child that goes to Bowmont and somebody who has driven to that school for the last eight years and I'm very familiar with

049the community and um and I've joined arms with families that are um zoned for that school and um so I could speak personally about that experience um so these were my words uh for years this Arts integration magnet school has been the most sought-after magnet program in our district this designation allows teachers to weave the Arts into their curriculum making learning more engaging and fostering creativity it also encourages parent involvement through events like exhibit nights drawing families into the school and strengthening the community as a whole what's important to note about magnet schools is that they allocate a number of seats for transfers this offers fam's Choice within the public school system the structure not only promotes socioeconomic diversity but it fuels school Success engaged parents play a vital role in PTA organizing fundraisers and

050supporting staff needs I believe that this K through 8 school is a win for this community especially when it is set up correctly and with intention that is the purpose behind this amended motion thank you you miss bike thank thank you um really I just uh turned my light on because I wanted to officially apologize to miss Templeton I am so sorry and um uh I have learned my lesson on clicking on things that people have sent me so um but with that um I agree and I know that everyone has put a lot of hard work into this but um my nephew is at Bowmont and um um it it would be a shame to lose some of that and that is why I seconded this but I do also believe that through the

051conversations that I've had with um miss lner Mr Wilson and Mr Adams um that it seems like that um that that will be a part of it but I really like this as a guarantee that it will be a part of it and I know that you know from those conversations that it's hard to guarantee those things because that there's a whole process but um yeah so thank you and officially apologize I appreciate that Reverend Butler oh I'm so sorry Miss F Ridley you were I apologize that's okay thank you're just liing my line side there thank you I just want to go on record because I feel like this is going to happen um I have all faith in Knox County Schools in the administration in the supervisors in the teachers in the communities

052that they are going to make this work no matter what so I just want um to go on the record by saying that you know if it's going to happen and I support everything awesome thank you Reverend Butler uh first of all I want to just for clarification uh the the Middle School portion of the k28 would include the lale students or the students from lale uh but I know we when you were talking you're talking specifically about the elementary school but I just wanted to point that out and uh and in terms of the magnet program and all the programs that are at all the different schools uh we've talked about this um that we want to keep the best and add more of the rest of the best so uh and we do

053recognize uh the strength of the the magnet programs at bont and so that was part of the um region five uh priorities was part of the best practices so all of that is already there uh I think also the process that was defined somewhat a little bit more tonight is that as we go through this process of adding the design and programmatic items at that time we will have uh parental staff and Community Support as well this is the beginning of the process and so uh for me I I would like for us to continue the process that we use and that that way you have as much uh uh fairness and as much uh uh I think the more you stick to your process the better you are at making sure you do as

054much right as possible so I I I wish that we could guarantee but in my mind one one thing that I'm guaranteeing is that as the district one representative I'm going to fight and scratch for every program that we can get in that school for the in the best interest of all the kids in that community and also just make sure I I think that all of us are responsible for every school in Knox County so I don't have a problem with anyone suggesting that we do things that you think are best I welcome that but in with this particular case I think we should stick with the process and I think that process will work but I would say to everyone who care continue to be involved in the process continue to hold us

055accountable continue to demand what you need and what you want for your students that's what we're here to do but at this point I want to get it done I do I I appreciate your motion Ann and your heart because I agree I think that we have certain gems in our community Bowmont being one of them Lenn being another one like we just have these certain schools that are I just I love I have a heart for these schools and I reached out to a couple Bowmont parents this afternoon um to talk to them and so I do agree with you but I agree with Rend Butler of let's follow the process and I've seeing this process with mil Creek and with the solution I've seen um how Dr risewick and his team are so

056intentional and thoughtful through that whole process so I do have faith in that so while I love your heart and I love that you brought this I'm going to have to agree with Reverend Butler on the process on this because I do think that this will come I do think that this Vision will come and um it will include the community and the new principal and everything so I am am excited about that and I do want to make sure that we do hold ourselves accountable that that we do have these things included anybody else discussion okay all right I get we'll do roll call and this is on the amended motion Miss cotney Dr Bor I'll pass Miss Templeton yes Miss Fontano Ridley yes Miss bike yes Miss Morgan no M Mr Wright no

057Miss Christie no Miss Henderson no that is three yes votes and four no votes and one pass Dr Butler would you like to change your pass vote I will continue where I am okay thank you okay that motion fails so we will go back to the original motion that was made by Reverend Butler and seconded by Miss Christie which is the motion on the agenda so Dr batler yes Miss Templeton yes Miss font o Ridley i s i' never do this but I okay Miss bike yes Miss Morgan yes Mr Wright yes Miss Christie Miss Henderson yes that is seven yes votes and one pass Miss font o really would you like to change your pass no motion carries all right well thank you for all your work Reverend Butler it's a lot of meetings

058you went to yeah yeah there'll be more there'll be more this is just the beginning of the process all right moving on to public forum I will play Steve triplet this evening first up we have Angel Jones Miss James if you can just say your name and County of residence and welcome Angel Jones Knox County hi y'all I'm a mom of two kids who attend two public schools in Ox County and I'm here today to talk about a subject I brought up before which is Betsy Henderson backstory back in August 2022 Betsy Henderson went in front of the Knox County Commission to ask for permission to seek outside legal counsil for the school board my bad hold on I messed up a little bit bear with me well for whatever reason my thing is not

059playing but it is Betsy Henderson there at the county commission meeting admitting that she was there as the board even though the school board had already voted on seeking outside Council and they declined that so along with that she's done that again on misrepresenting herself on January 30th of 2025 she went to the Tennessee State Legislature and represented herself as our board chair and as a parent to advocate for vouchers our school board did not vote to support vouchers Miss Henderson used her position to push her own ideals otherwise she would have stated she was just there as a parent or she would have said My Views do not reflect the views of the board this won't be the last time that Betsy Henderson abuses her position her history shows that that's why I think

060she should be removed as chair and as D6 representative thank you for your time thank you next Aaron PE Aaron say your name County res presidence and you have three minutes Aaron kek Knox County good evening board members and invested community members that are here behind me I'm here tonight asking that board chair Betsy Henderson resign she has not been willing to be compliant with the vote this very board made regarding private school vouchers the majority of the people in this room work for other people and non-compliance in the workplace leads to termination you madam chair work for people you were elected by the people to be a voice for and an advocate for Knox County Public Schools you have abused and you have misused that power and that trust by going to Nashville and

061speaking in opposition to this very board's vote not only did you break the Public's trust but when you asked but when asked about this betrayal by the media you doubled down and responded with a politically divisive answer your response assumes that only leftists support Public Schools so then I wonder as a strong conservative why did you run for this position in the first place thank you Laura Bean Allen Laura welcome just state your name and County residence please Laura Bean Allen Knox County um my name is Laura Bean Allen and I am a a elll or English language learner teacher at Fulton High School I also live in the same neighborhood as fton and I'm neighbors with many of our schools families I'm here today to ask that Knox County Schools align and clarify our

062safety protocols given the recent executive order revoking the status of schools as sensitive spaces where ice cannot enter as well as laws passed by the Tennessee legislator's recent special session there are many students and families who do not currently feel safe in our schools we've already seen a drop in attendance in Fulton um as well as nationally there have already been rumors circulated false rumors circulated about ice raids that are going to happen at school warning students to stay home in the absence of clear information disinformation spreads students are scared to come to school and these are just kids it's not only immigrant students who are scared other um students born in America are also scared that officers are going to come into their classroom and detain their friends while they are trying to learn

063math this is affecting all students ability to learn and thrive in their own classrooms school is the place where students should feel safe student school is a place for learning um I'm requesting that KCs procedures on student safety be communicated clearly to students and families Dr risewick email to uh Knox County staff on January 30th reminded teachers that we do not allow access to students or Student Records without legal authorization this is not special protocol that's specific to undoc aded students this is in line with the constitutional right of all students in regards to the Fourth Amendment which protects against searches and seizures without a warrant the 14th amendment clarifies that this applies to people of all documentation statuses stating the government cannot deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the

064laws so in plain terms for schools we have never just let anyone walk in and have access to any of our kids or their information but not all uh students and families under understand what our safety Protocols are at this point in time that's only been communicated to staff and teachers are put in the position of trying to reassure students and families um of those protocols so I'm asking that we clearly can communicate that to families um additionally Dr Rick's email stated that we don't maintain in accordance to state and federal laws we don't maintain citizenship records on the citizenship status of our students there are um reports of Knox County Teachers questioning students on their documentation status not only does this scare and confuse students and families but it is not legal and opens

065Knox County Schools up to lawsuit lawsuits student safety does not have to and in fact should not be politicized against schools should be a place for teachers to teach and for kids to learn so let's make sure every family understands that um and I'm happy to meet with anyone after to discuss this further thank you for your time [Applause] thank you Laura next Colby Wayne Colby if you can just state your name and County residence and you have three minutes thank you welcome okay hi my name is Kobe Wayne and I live in L County I'm here today to talk about accountability and integrity within the board each of you are responsible for holding each other accountable and last week you failed um despite the majority of KN County and Tennessee residents being against Choice

066vouchers the chair of the board decided to go in front of the state senate and showed support for them this shows a huge lack of Integrity since your job on the board is to advocate for every child in public schools by showing support for the vouchers is clear that you do not have the best interest of public school students in mind the vouchers will only benefit The Wealthy by giving them a discount on their child's private school education students who live in a low-income household will not benefit from this since it doesn't cover the whole tuition for example tuition for ninth grade student at Christian Academy of Knoxville cost $8,885 says the voucher only covers $775 um the parents will be responsible for paying the remaining $1,810 this bill will cost the state of Tennessee

067over $1 billion do within the first five years taxpayer dollars should not be used to cover the tuition for a private school education and as a result of the actions that occurred last week I have created a petition to remove Betsy Henderson from the board as the chair the petition went live last Friday morning and as of right now the petition has over 1500 signatures that include former and current KNX County School staff while this is not an official petition that has been filed with the county this is a way for everyone in knxx County to make sure their voices are being heard thank you thank you Chad Brooks Mr Brooks welcome state your name and County residents um I'm Brooks I am Knox County resident um I am a teacher and a coach at

068uh West High School and uh I teach government and uh I'm just I'm just here to talk about you know how how I feel about the gun policy of Knox County um uh we were you know we were in class and we were talking about the Second Amendment and you know I asked my kids you know like if we have a gun in school cuz you know at West Side we've had a few you know kids have them or whatever um and I just asked him like what should be the consequences you know I got a bunch of different answers and you know I said you know what if if a kid brought a gun to school that they had to pay $100,000 and they got 20 years in prison you know my kids were

069kind of like that sounds that sounds crazy and I just asked him I was like is your life not worth 20 years is your life not worth $100,000 so whenever you think about it like that I just think that if a student does bring a gun to school I just feel like a public school environment is not the place for them to come back to um we've had several you know instances that are close to me or that I'm involved in and kids will come to school and have a gun in some form or fashion and they'll be back in a public school whether that be at West high school or at a different um school and I know we talk about zero like zero tolerance but if a kid is zero tolerance and get

070one year out or up to one year whenever we let them come back you know what what is that saying I mean I get that we care about our kids and every kid deserves some form of some form of education and during a covid time we figured out a lots of ways to teach kids and kids get educations and we wasn't there um so I'm just I'm just here to request that we look at that policy um I don't really know what it should be but I just feel an obligation because I told my students I'd be here so I came um but um my last thing I'll say is you know I coach so whenever I have parents come to me and they're wanting to come from a private school or wanting to come

071from middle school and they ask me or they bring up that we've had guns at West High School I want to be able to to tell them that you know if if a kid does have one he'll never be here like we are going to do something or this is this is our plan so just thank you thank you for listening thank you thanks for coming Caroline man did I pronounce your last name correctly yes okay and it is Caroline thank you uh Caroline man Lo County um I addressed the board on Monday and the voucher wrote was fresh I was a little bit upset and I didn't present my questions to you as clearly as I would have liked so I'd like to reframe them now and to ask you to follow up with

072me and your constituents in this forum and in other Communications in the future uh before I begin though I want to thank the board for taking a stand by keeping vouchers out of the 2025 legislative agenda um that was a necessary action and a responsible one and sadly a Courageous one in this time and in this state um I have three questions for you and I would appreciate your consideration in addressing them for as long as the current voucher and deportation regime stays in power first how is this board going to work with other leas across the state to overcome the damage to Public Schools caused by the super majority's decision to divert public funds into private Pockets how will you work with other eleas to overcome the genuine fear among students faculty staff and

073families now that Tennessee is part of this deportation regime especially here in Knox County with the sheriff's office in meshed in the 287g program second how will you as a board Monitor and report on the harms caus to Public Schools across the state in anox County as our tax dollars are diverted to public pocket private Pockets how will you as a board quote actively and consistently engage families through meaningful two-way communication as stated in the state's Board of Education policy to keep us informed of any disruptive deportation actions that take place in our schools as elected officials charged with the direction and oversight of public schools I expect you to be informed of these topics and to share this information with your constituents help us understand the consequences of this disastrous special session and third

074how will you as a board overcome the fact that members of this body have publicly advocated for legislation that undermines the institution you have been elected to direct how are you going to restore trust in the Knox County school board you were elected to support Public Schools your own legislative priorities for 2025 include a plea for lottery money for to fund educational programs and extracurricular activities how can you expect the people of Knox County to accept that your leadership testified in Nashville for a bill that hands over our tax dollars in instead of investing them in the essential institution of public education I hope to hear these answers from you as we all fight for public education in an increasingly hostile Administration thank you Shelly Higgins Shelly please state your name and County residence you

075have three minutes welcome my name is shy Higgins and I um live in Knox County and I'm in representative Henderson's district and I am here this evening speaking um in a personal capacity rather than as serving as a shrill cry for the leftist so I want to be really clear about that um I'm also speaking in capacity as someone who attended KNX County Schools my entire um School career and graduated from there I've been a parent of an ox County School student student and I am a trained um certified educator who has also worked in LX County and I've spent the past 30 plus years working and advocating for public education because that is the great equalizer so um I have some concerns which I think a lot of us have shared um and my

076main issues are number one although any member of this board is able to speak from their capacity regarding how they feel about vouchers and we're already down that road it's a done deal it is inherently a conflict of interest in public education for anyone who is elected to represent a public school district the students the families the Educators and the community that these um schools serve because if you are taking money from public education which has already been chronically underfunded for decades Tennessee currently rank 45th in funding for public school students and you're giving that to private schools that are only going to serve a small number of students and that's if they can get to the school or you know if the school stays in business when you have pop up schools that are

077going to pop up all of those things it's an inherent conflict of interest I think that one has to really look at that and think why am I supporting or why would anybody support that the other issue that I think is of a really a grave concern is the fact that we have an ethical issue because even if representative Henderson spoke in her personal capacity the other day she was introduced as the chair and board member of the third largest public school district in Lux County she did not clarify at any time that she was not there or that this board had struck down a motion to make this an vouchers an official legislative priority she had plenty of opportunity to do that she could have done that at any given time including when Governor

078Lee publicly tweeted to her and millions of people saw that and she she wasn't mentioned as a parent she was mentioned as the chair of Knox County she could have clarified that then and she chose not to either she knowingly did this with an intent to deceive or she made a very poor personal decision and either way this requires a no confidence vote in her moving forward thank you Miss Higgins Christiana Anton Christiana just state your name and County of residents welcome hi Christiana Anton Knox County I bet y'all can guess what I'm up here to talk about I don't have too much to say today because I stand before you Gob smacked and horrified at the assaults on public education from the federal level trickling down to this body so much for the party

079of small government I won't take up too much of the board's time because I'd mostly like to address the chair and the superintendent um I think all of you for the good work that you do I'm really excited about the new school um I would like to especially thank Reverend Butler Miss Templeton Miss fot Ridley Miss bike Miss Morgan and Miss Christie again for making the right choice last month and choosing not to include vouchers in the board's legislative priorities for 2025 in case Betsy missed that we choose not to include those I cannot express enough how thankful we are to have at least a handful of elected officials who truly seem to listen to their constituents if you think that we did not all see you go out of your way in a personal

080capacity but as a face of this body no less to advocate for the special session shenanigans that ripped fun from public schools while entangling this scam with the desperately needed relief for our neighbors you are sorely mistaken Not only was that disrespectful to everyone who came to speak to you last month and you apparently didn't listen to but your colleagues here on this board who had the gall who had the spine to stand up for public school kids like they took an oath took this job to do I have nothing to say but shame on you for calling yourself a public servant while truly serving private interests I fear we will all feel the horrible effects of this very soon next fiscal year at the latest Mr superintendent if you think people will stand for

081your staff pulling students out of instructional time to be interrogated about citizenship status without their parents or a lawyer present without at least bringing it to the public opinion um and attention you are also mistaken I have a feeling that this isn't in accordance with the district's policy or procedure and I sincerely hope that it's been remedied since I was made aware of it I would encourage you to ensure that the district's policies and procedures be reviewed and enforced diligently as we see students scared to come to school for a myriad of reasons guns immigration showing up they being questioned by the people who are supposed to stand up for them and educate them that's pathetic and any of you on your phones I also will reiterate what I said to the city council shame

082on you you're supposed to be listening to the people who come to participate in democracy school officials are meant to act in the place of parents when children are in their care I have siblings have babysat and am also an accredited educator who taught in public schools and so have been responsible for the lives of children even learned how to defend them against an armed Intruder before I knew my students names and faces so while I can only speak for myself I would like to imagine no caretaker or educator would absolutely ever turn a child over to anyone but their parents I have more you know what you're doing is wrong hold your colleagues accountable thank you Miss Anton that is Miss Christie yeah I just want to clarify something that one of the speakers

083said and I want to punt this to Mr dupler as far as children or students coming back after having a firearm in the building can you just speak to the state law and the the limit the 180 days I believe is the zero tolerance right is that the max because I do think there's some confusion out there as to what the law is and what what we can do as a district Mr dler thank you madam chair M Christie uh state law says a carrying a firearm on on a school campus is zero tolerance as has been mentioned zero tolerance means that a student is out for 180 days a full school year that that means that that student doesn't return to that school for that year what happens to that student after that uh

084the school system still has to educate that student uh free and appropriate public education as been mentioned in the uh Tennessee Constitution tonight so uh that that student still has to be educated so is there a chance that student could come back the answer is yes thank you thank you well with that board members Happy Valentine's month and we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.