001e e e welcome to the bo of educations January 9th 2025 regular session meeting please stand as we observe a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance led by Miss Moran I flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all just a few announcements before we begin um as announced at Monday's work session the clothing Center committee was scheduled to meet tomorrow January 10th at 11: but due to the weather and canceling school tomorrow that meeting will also be rescheduled and board members hopefully you have seen your calendar in invitation confirming the meeting with our state legislators on Wednesday January 22nd but I wanted to announce publicly that that meeting has been confirmed and will take
002place at Bridgewater Place located on Bridgewater Road at 9:00 a.m. I also wanted to let you know as soon as possible that superintendent risewick and I made the decision to cancel our January 24th quarterly work session there are multiple meeting meeting scheduled for the evening hours over the coming weeks including several Community meetings so we wanted to offer everyone some relief um on their busy schedules any items that may have been submitted for that meeting will be moved to our Monday February 3rd work session and Knox County Schools will be closed well tomorrow but also on Martin Luther King holiday uh Junior holiday on Monday January 12th or I'm sorry January 20th are there any requested changes to the agenda move to approve motion by Mr triplet second by Miss Christie all those in favor
003I any opposed all right Miss Cy item five item five consent agenda second a motion by Miss Christie a second by Mr triplet any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries item 6A approve second reading of Knox County Board of educ ation policy d190 payroll as amended second a motion by Miss Christie a second by Mr triplet do we have any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries item 6B approve second reading of Knox County Board of Education policy D200 expenses and reimbursements as amended second a motion by Miss Christie a second by Mr triplet do we have any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 6 C approv second reading
004of knots County Board of Education policy d233 technology purchases as amended a motion by Miss Christie second by Mr triplet any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 6D approved second reading of knots County Board of Education policy d241 internal School funds as amended second motion by Miss Christie second by Mr triplet any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 6E approv second reading of KN County Board of Education policy d280 fundraising activities as amended second motion by Miss Christie second by Mr triplet any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 7A approve memorandum of understanding with Knox Education Foundation for receipt of grant funding up to $75,000 to fund
005the completion of the literacy specialist cohort for 14 Knox County Schools Employees a motion by Reverend Butler a second by Miss Christie any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion car 7B approved Batel education TSI n stemx stem classroom Grant sponsored by TVA and BVI in the total amount of $68,500 for Al Lots bricky McLoud Cedar Bluff Gibbs and lale elementary schools Carter Gibbs Gresham and Harden valley middle schools and Farragut Halls KS pal and West high schools second a motion by Miss bike a second by Mr triple any discussion it's a lot of schools seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 7 C approved Knoxville TVA Credit Union simply smart educator grants and the total amount of $228 59 for
006Austin East Bearden Carter Central faragate Fulton Gibbs Halls Carns pal South D and West high schools career Magnet Academy Harden Valley Academy Dr Paul l Kelly volunteer Academy and the elen inem academy motion by Miss spike a second by Miss Christie any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 70 approved Grant agreement with National Education Association foundation for receipt of a Student Success Grant in the amount of $5,000 for Gibbs Middle School motion by Mr R second by Miss Christie any discussion saying there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 7 e approved Delta Capa Society International early educator Grant through the Tennessee State organization Zeta chapter in the amount of $250 from Morland Heights Elementary School motion by Miss Christie second
007by Mr triplet any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries item 8A approve superintendent's annual evaluation a motion by Reverend Butler second by Miss Christie any discussion seeing there is none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries yes rever Butler uh I would like to uh say that as a board we just assessed our superintendent performance as as above expectations that's a four and uh we still have work to do we know we haven't achieved all of our goals but I believe that the comment ments from the assessments are saying that we're headed in the right direction and we are in the middle of creating a new strategic plan I'm reading from my script so I get this right consistent leadership will
008be important for us to achieve our goals for every student moving forward next year the superintendent will enter the final year of his his current contract and I believe going forward we need to have that uh confidence that we're going to have the person in in place that's going to move us forward so I'd like to ask the superintendent to bring us a new contract for consideration in February and if it's appropriate I'd like to put that in the form of a motion okay so I move that uh the board ask the superintendent to bring us a new contract four-year contract for consideration in February second all right the motion was made by Reverend Butler the second by is Christie Miss Christie any discussion um I I agree with you Dr Butler I do think
009that um it takes a long time and to when you start initiatives things don't happen overnight and I also know that there are a lot of school districts looking for superintendent right now so um you know I I do appreciate that suggestion yeah thank you for suggesting that I'm also in support of that is there any more discussion on this motion all right well let's go ahead and vote all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries thank you Reverend Butler item 8 C 8 B approved tenure for eligible teachers motion by Miss font Ridley second by Reverend Butler any discussion yes Miss font Ridley I said this on Monday thank you for allowing me to speak by the way um said this on Monday in case people didn't hear it but I
010am so proud to be able to be on this end of somebody getting their tenure and not the one trying to get the tenure so um I want to congratulate all 240 240 teachers who have worked their tails off and um shown that they have worked their tails off so um congratulations to you all and I appreciate all their hard work yeah awesome thank you for that all right all those in favor I any opposed motion carries item 8 C approve recognition of international borate economics at both the standard level and higher level as substitutions for the economics graduation requirement motion by Miss bike is second by Reverend Butler any discussion seeing there's none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 8 D consideration of resolutions regarding the emerald Academy Emerald
011Charter Schools renewal application motion by Miss Christie a second by Mr tripet any discussion we need to make a motion on which one I would make oh that's true yeah yeah I would make a motion to um approve the emerald Charter School renewal application okay second okay so the motion is to approve the renewal motion made by Miss Christie second Mr triplet do we have any discussion on that okay why don't we do want to do a call all right why don't we do a roll call bit on this one Dr Butler yes Miss Templeton yes Miss F Ridley no Miss bike yes Miss Morgan yes Mr triplet yes Mr Wright yes Miss Christie yes Miss Henderson yes Dr Butler would you like to change your pass vote Miss Templeton Miss bike okay that is
012five yes votes one no vote and three pass all right motion carries item 8 e discussion and possible action on revised 2025 2026 school year calendar so Move Motion by Miss bike a second by Miss Christie we have any discussion Miss bike um kind of just echoing uh you know what we said on Monday I'm so glad we have these opportunities to change the calendar to make more people happy I know we can't always make everyone happy and that I really appreciate uh Miss lner and Mr Wilson's um hard work and their team's work on this calendar as well as everyone else that works on the calendar um and um I would like to make my motion to go with option D um is there anything specific that I need to do to do that
013okay no I think because it's being revised and I think that was the revised option so I think we're good there yeah okay yeah I really appreciated option D and I think that you know um I did hear some feedback and I talked to some of my principles and I think I said this on Monday that a lot of people really wanted that um two weeks for winter break both for students and teachers to kind of feel refreshed and come back and I know we talked about that and um having that Memorial Day just so soon really crunched things but I guess um I would also ask that maybe for the year after that which would be 26 27 that we really try to work on that and it sounds like that's potentially possible speak
014to that if you yes pleas so thank you Miss bike I and obviously I can't speak to what the 267 calendar will hold yet but there is there is a little more flexibility I I would say in that and I actually went back and looked at some historical U calendars all the way back to like 20134 um and just kind of how they've changed over time and and maybe what some of those factors were and I can't remember the exact year but there's you know I think around 2015 16 or 1617 we started to do the week-long fall break uh which had been two days prior to that um so for folks who've been around a while um that was that was probably a place where we had a shift to where we started coming
015back a little bit earlier um more towards like August 1st rather than August third or fourth uh there was actually um including this this calendar adjustment that you guys are making uh two other times that we came back prior to August 1st um but again that had not historically been the pattern um I would say the most common to your point the most common number of vacation days at that winter break has been 10 for for teachers as well as the students or actually extends the students by day um and so that is something you know if we if we look at these tough years and we start to consider that July date that that that is or starting in July um and obviously we don't want to get early in July but um but
016looking at that in these tough years that may be the way to try to preserve more of the the winter break um when you look at that so each year brings its own set of nuance uh in terms of trying to to come up with a final plan but we we we do look forward to having a couple of years uh in the person making the calendar having a little more flexibility in the next couple of years around how we uh bring options for that do the early release days affect that very much not really um and and just as a without trying to go too far down happy to explain that uh in Greater detail um but when you think about your early release days they're they come from the same method that by
017which we get our inclement weather days so um those are earned through additional time that we attend school every day um so you're allowed by the state to go to school longer each day which we do by 30 minutes than required and then that you can Bank up to 13 instructional days through that acquired time but you're only allowed to use those days for certain things so that instructional time you build can be used for additional opportunities for PD it can be used for inclement weather or illness related things where you may have to have a school closure but to start to try to repurpose that time for uh days that are designated as instruction and or to extend a holiday or something like that you're not allowed to do that with that time so
018um there's a little bit of weird state math in all of that uh where where sometimes a half day counts as a whole day and and and that those sorts of things that can be kind of hard to track uh quite honestly if you're not in it really deeply but uh it does become different when you start trying to repurpose like some of what we've done through early release and professional development and stuff like that that makes a lot of sense thank you and then I think um maybe Corey is I don't know if this is the time that you want to talk about oh is that the early release document yeah does it have impact on on this or you want to just kind of go over it a little bit Madam chair yeah
019no I don't think it would have an impact on the calendar itself it's just a question of I know Miss Morgan you had asked um to see kind of a preliminary uh like sneak peek at what's coming in the early release day survey and so that's what you all have in front of you gotcha okay thank you thank you thanks is there any more discussion on this item all right well all those in favor say I I any opposed all right motion carries and I just before Miss cotney goes on to the next item when I want to thank the emerald families for being here this evening uh since we have voted for the renewal if you guys want to head out you are welcome to leave and enjoy your three-day weekend I didn't want
020you guys to to get stuck here for the rest of our meeting so we all enjoy your evening and thank you for being here Madam chair can I just also recognize and thank Mr Diggs while he's here because please yes because they do a lot for our children in Knox County Schools as well so I do appreciate that yes thank you Mr Diggs I don't see you but I know you're here he's enjoying that snow day all right Miss Cy rolling on item 8 F approved 2025 legislative priorities and believe we do have some public forum we do we have five speakers so we'll start Paula Hancock Paul you know the routine but if you'll state your name and County residence you'll have three minutes thank you you so much Mr triplet Paula Hancock Knox
021County Madam chair members of the board and superintendent rosick as an immensely proud K through2 Public School educated individual and educator with 20 years experience as a corporate professional a public school educator of 28 years a wife mother grandmother member of a gold star family and member of the Knox County Community I stand before you speaking to Advocate and to protect our students Educators and the education professional to create great public schools that prepare everyone for success in a global Society by investing in our profession and fully funding us County students and schools funding is the key ensuring our students succeed starts and ends with the resources and opportunities we give them no matter where we live or what we believe our Public School Educators want all children to succeed our NS County School Educators
022follow an education Great Commission and they go forth teaching all children regardless of race ethnicity religion sex or sexual orientation we want all of our students to have the funding they need to learn Without Limits and unlock their dreams but many students will be denied opportunities because their schools and communities will be underfunded and underresourced because of current voucher and school choice legislative initiatives on all counts vouchers and school choice harm Public Schools education and students vouchers Ste still scarce funding from public schools and give it to private schools that are unaccountable to taxpayers they do not reduce public education costs they increase costs by requiring taxpayers to fund two school systems and one public and one private the result is that public schools which educate 90% of students wind up with less funding this
023leads to larger class sizes and fewer resources such as Educators textbooks School nurses counselors technology lab equipment as well as music and athletic programs to name a few let us be reminded of Abraham Lincoln's famous line from his house divided speech which states A house divided against itself cannot stand for we know the foundation for which he derived the words in this speech Lincoln used this tring to explain that the United States could not remain divided forever he believed that the country would eventually only be able to sustain one system for he and we know that no one can serve two masters for either he will hate the one and love the other or else he will be loyal to the one and despise the other furthermore there is no conclusive evidence that voucher programs
024improve overall student achievement nor is there any validity to claims that by creating a create a competitive Marketplace for students students vouchers forced public schools to improve while these programs continue to discriminate against students with disabilities strip away students human and civil rights as well as exacerbate segregation through a selective process we should also not forget the importance for which the founding fathers viewed public education in the preservation of American democracy John Adams this nation's first vice president and second president of the United States was among the first great champions of organized education and wrote about the vital need for Quality education to be accessible to all citizens Adams is quoted saying laws for Liberal education of Youth especially of the lower class of people are so extremely wise and useful that to Humane and
025generous mind no expense for this purpose would be thought extravagant he saw a clear link between a strong public education system and the health and strength of the American democracy he also saw education as a vehicle for previous generations to empower future generations with the ability to learn and prosper Adams made his strongest argument for the value of a strong system of public education in a letter to British reformer John jet when he wrote the whole people must take upon themselves the education of the whole people if we are serious about doing what's right for for every child's Future Let's do what works support legislation and legislative priorities that provide every Knox County student with a public school education that inspires them encourages their curiosity and prepares them for Success support legislation and legislative priorities
026that provides Public School Educators with the support resources and time to do their jobs well and the security to retire with messed up on the timer but it's been all right I let it go a little longer than 3 minutes just the timer wasn't on that was our fault but no that's fine so thank you for your time I appreciate you all thank you got a little bonus time Arin krer Erin if you'll state your name and County resident you'll have three minutes thank you board for having me uh my name is Aaron Christ Knox County uh currently residing in District 5 um so I'm here before you uh just just like Miss Hancock spoke to you uh about the education freedom app I also here to talk about that I'm a father of Two
027And so um my daughters are about to start school and I want to stand here in front of you all just to let you know that um I also think that when the time comes you also consider the impact of this legislation and that what it will do to the public school system that my daughters are going to attend um this this type of uh initiative around the country is wildly unpopular among voters 65% of Voters in Kentucky every single County in Kentucky voted against this in Nebraska the program wasn't even around for an entire year and they voted to repeal it Colorado also rejected School vouchers uh in South Carolina their program was Den deemed unconstitutional okay the only way that these systems get passed is through legislation but I want you all to
028to realize that um you know this this type of method this type of approach to educating our children and our nation's future is not the correct way and what governor leag has proposed and the idea of withholding Hurricane Relief funding and for for get trying to Garner support for this type of legislation is not the right way and is not very popular um to tr try to get this past m hanc talked about um John Adams one of our founding fathers our founding fathers said that uh separation of church and state was Paramount and I think that our tax dollars need to be going to any religious uh religious backed institutions for schooling so um just that when the time comes I hope that this board um considers that and and and votes against supporting
029this type of legislation thank you very much thank you Brandy Jenkins Brandy if you'll state your name and County of residence you'll have three minutes hi I'm Brandy Jenkins Knox County uh good evening everyone I have a letter from State Representative Sam McKenzie I would like to read to you I believe you each have copies as well um I want he says I want to respond to the priorities introduced recently by board member triplet first it's nice to have areas of Common Ground funding preschool special needs is vitally important last year we the general assembly appropriated $16 million and the federal government provided 1.3 million for special education services if we adopt this strategy of creating Tia funding for the preschool it will cost an additional 92 million each year and a funding source needs
030to be determined state or local having individual lotteries for each Lea would be problematic and take a change to the State Constitution which can be up to a six-year process we have proper funding mechanisms in place and honestly Knox County uh not raising taxes this century is a dereliction of our duty as it relates to expanding charter school funding at the state level charter schools have more flexibility than public schools the local school district controls public education Charter Schools can dictate their own curriculum and standards to an extent they have the ability to try new things which vary in results there's no recurring investment for public schools why should charter schools be treated differently if they are a public school States generally have three ways to assist in funding K through 12 in infrastructure needs
031Appropriations financing assistance and dedicated revenues Tennessee leverages Appropriations and financing assistance but does not specifically dedicate revenues to K through 12 Capital expedent according to the comp trer office the Statewide cost of school infrastructure needs over the next 5 years is 9.8 billion on vouchers the data tells the story students do better in public schools in general and imagine if the state fully funds Knox County Schools the improvements we could make and lives that would be changed would be dramatic vouchers will be unlikely to help low income students to attend a high performing private school without some kind of scholarship from the school as tuition exceeds the voucher for nearly every private school in Knoxville the Board of Education wants disabled students to be allowed to participate in vouchers as seen in previous legislation the
032private schools seem hesitant or unwilling to provide this service Additionally the private schools are unwilling to have their students go through the same rigorous testing that you require as a school board and us at the state level lastly the only true positive that the Tennessee Department of Education uh uh States is that parents despite them not doing as well like having their children in private schools this cannot be the deciding factor thank you all thank you Ryan [Applause] batty Ryan if you'll state your name and County of residence you'll have three minutes hi there my name is Ryan Bey not batty but thank you Sor no it's okay apologize Ned batty whoever um and I am a few things I am a resident of Knox County and an templeton's District I am a proud product
033of Tennessee public school system and I am also a taxpayer I am really proud to call myself a product of the Tennessee public school system and as someone who is educated in the Tennessee Public Schools I know that they deserve more than policies that divert money from those schools and that's why I think this addition of support for school choice to the board's legislative priorities is odd as members of a board of education you are elected to represent and make decisions for the Knox County Public School System I must question why a board of education of a public school system thinks any public funds should be siphoned away from public schools that's where my taxes come in simply put as a taxpayer I don't always have a say in where my taxes go but I
034know that at least here in this meeting I have a chance to tell you all elected officials on a legislative body to please not endorse a policy that means my tax money could end up benefiting a private school school choice already exists we already have Charter and magnet schools and families who want to homeschool or private school their kids will continue to do so no matter what to call this school choice rather than what it really is diverting money from diverting public money from public schools is a dishonest scam thank you thank you Christiana Anton Chris if you'll state your name and County residence you'll have three minutes as well hi Christiana Anton 37917 I live in Reverend Butler's District I to and am several things I'm a Knoxville resident a secondary English educator Master
035student angry taxpayer and member of public school strong um your behavior tonight or what I perceive to be your behavior tonight seeing that we haven't seen the amendment yet that everybody came up here to talk about has revealed to me that you are incredibly similar to your politi and city council counterparts as public servants your legislative priorities should not include advocating for the disinvestment of our public schools by supporting voucher schemes like the so-called education Freedom scholarship act or expansion of Charter funding in my opinion private school vouchers and Charter Schools as we've already heard have no proven efficacy in raising Student Success on benchmarks nor do they improve student overall experience as a taxpayer I do not feel comfortable giving my support to exclusive private schools to the neglect of every public school student
036in Knox County yall have heard about Governor lead's voucher scam I'll skip down a little bit um we know that this money that they're allegedly going to give to working class families to send their kids to private schools is not enough to send them there we know who this is really going to benefit and as public servants you have a duty to Public Schools not private interest schools or otherwise instead of giving away public dollars to subsidize private schools why don't we use Public Funding to provide truly free public schools ones with without excessive fees or barriers to extracurricular programming can our board advocate for better and more counselors and student psych sorry School psychologists to help serve the students in District 9 who just lost one of their classmates to police violence can our
037legislative priorities Center the students who come to school every day afraid they are going to be shot and killed can we actually support special education students not advocate for them to take a voucher that strips them of their Federal rights speaking as an educator these are the priorities that are on teachers families and students Minds nearly every educator goes into educating because they want to help all children which is who Public Schools serve all children as our school board that is charged with managing and sorting Public Schools all children should be who you are serving not private interests like I said we know they don't serve all children private schools or any non-public schools they since their beginning have been built to be exclusionary to separate the US and the them and I thought we
038learned our lesson that separate and equal was not true nor constitutional but I'm just here to remind you that that does not work um and it's not what I believe a strong multi-racial democracy looks like nor the rest of my public school strong counterparts we believe that investing in students our public school students giving the dollars that you're oh so willing to take away from them to private schools is what a strong democracy looks like and to any KCs students here or listening know that you are worth more than every dollar they are fixing to take away from you to give to somebody else your future is bright and we are here to fight with you for your right to equality education thank you madam chair that concludes public four on this topic thank you
039Mr triplet Miss Cy can you read the item well we're doing legislative priorities but we do need a motion in a second we jumped into uh into our public form speakers first so Move Motion by Mr triplet have a second second m is Christie we will now move on to discussion Reverend Butler I had my light on before Mr triplet oh I'm so sorry rever Butler was that for a motion yes all right motion then I apologize thank you we some people just jumping in motion by Reverend Butler I move that we approve the Knox County Board of Education 25 2025 legislative policies as printed on the sheet without the addition optional additions from for Border consideration okay so we have a motion to adopt these without any addition about this okay in a second
040so that motion is by rever Butler second by Miss bik so we will discuss this motion okay okay Miss font Ridley okay so I've provided an outline but um to be honest I haven't written an outline since I was in college so and I definitely haven't written one since I was um having to type on a word processor um if you can even call it that anymore um I have Prett Ed a sheet and I've given it to each one of you um uh and I believe and I don't want to um disrespect anybody here on the board um but I believe that we are here as public school Representatives not private school advocates um some concerns that I have have already been brought up by our speakers and I appreciate you all's um willingness
041to get up in front of of the body um it they um by Design vouchers are exclusionary um students with IEPs give up the guarantee of services private schools do not have to admit students have to admit students who apply vouchers are not available to undocumented immigrants transportation is not available private schools May expel students for any reason and private private schools are not affordable for most even with the voucher um a few things another concern um lack of over oversight on how funds are spent opening the system up opens it up for fraud and just in in in pretty much every state that has them have reported fraud in Arizona and this was just this just happened in December a couple out of Colorado was indicted for defrauding the State of Arizona for applicant
042applications for 50 students 43 of which did not exist in Texas forgeries on birth certificates led to approved applications totaling in over $600,000 in lost money um negative or insignificant outcomes um this is from the Tennessee Department of Education data uh math proficiency Public Schools outperformed private schools um in E Ela English language arts Public School outperform private schools um not sure exactly apples to oranges because uh private schools don't have to take the teap but um that was what was provided on the website um by the Numbers a comparison of Public School enrollment and students already in private schools receiving vouchers in Arizona 90% of the students in Arizona go to public schools and 82 of the students receiving vouchers were already in private schools when they applied um New Hampshire is similar 89%
043of their students go to public school 89% of them were already in um Public Schools Texas 89% go to public school already in private school when when granted voucher 75% public schools in Wisconsin 85 % um go to public schools and already in private schools when we're granted vouchers 76% um as was mentioned before voucher systems were designed to help people who were already in private schools not to help people get a leg up um because it it doesn't happen um the tax argument I've had I've heard a lot of people say that they don't want their tax money going to um Public Schools if their kids go to private schools and I did some math I am I was an educator but I was not a math teacher um 3.26% of an average person
044or of everybody's income generally goes to Tennessee goes to education um the vouchers are $775 and I've put a few um examples of an income of $ 35,000 which is a state median pays $1,141 in taxes that go to education um a income of 60,000 only 1,956 goes to education and at an income of 100,000 only 300 or $3,260 go to taxes um the nowhere near the 7,075 that they would be getting for a voucher n not to mention if they have more than one student um and I'm almost done so 39% of T Tennessee schools receive less per student spending than vouchers promise and Knox Knox County receives $3,678 121 from the state per student the rest is local and federal monies um I also want to say something about the teacher bonus that
045is in the legislation um for one thing teachers are not ignorant and um a writer that has nothing to do with the subject matter of the bill is an insult um teachers are not upon in this legislatur in this legislation and teachers are offended um I had a couple of questions that I wasn't sure what the answers were so I don't know if somebody can answer it um what happens if an application is made awarded and accepted but the student is not accepted to the school is it only if the student's already accepted to the school or does that happen before so that they can decide whether they can go to the school and also what happens to the voucher money if a student is admitted and then expelled for any reason during the year
046um those were just kind of thoughts that I had today um and did a little homework and um I hope that you all find the information on that sheet that I gave you um informative so thank you thank you Miss bike thank you um I think when we're talking about students um of lower socioeconomic status and ones that need access or have barriers in place um I do really look to um Representative Sam McKenzie's guidance as the 15th uh legislative district does generally have more um disadvantaged families and students and people I also look to Reverend Butler and his guidance and um how he represents district one but also District 4 has um it's also fair share of families that have bar barers to private school without a voucher and the voucher will not help
047them um students that have ADHD to a certain extent if they have high support needs um they can't even pay to go to a private school in their out of their own money it doesn't matter how much money they have or how much money they want to pay that school won't accept them and um you know if you have a student that's in a wheelchair if you have a student that is deaf all of those schools have the freedom to not accept that student even if you want to pay out of your own dollars not necessarily a voucher and that is really problematic to me because I don't think a voucher is suddenly going to make these schools that are supposedly better than our school schools um except these students and I think so that
048argument doesn't really doesn't really work for me as far as um school choice and um and things like that um and so I just I really truly cannot be in favor of that in in favor of these other ones um and that's why I'm in favor of this amended version um from the 2024 which um Reverend Butler motion for thank you thank you Miss bike um I will be voting no on this motion because I do want to in I do want to one vote on the two additional um suggestions um and you know this debate around school choice seems to put people in two camps you're either for public school or you're against public school and I completely firmly reject that uh my biggest privilege is being a mom I'm in the schools all
049the time I've seen first hand how children can Thrive when given opportunity I've seen outstanding Educators pour into our children I believe in our public school system I send my own children to KCs schools but I also believe in school choice I believe parents should be empowered to make decisions that are right for their child's education and there is not a one-size fits-all solution I think that these two things are not in Conflict I think these beliefs are centered around the same thing what is best for the child not the system families across Tennessee have flexibility they do have choice if they have means education is the great equalizer no matter your background or income and it is the most powerful tool for achieving the American dream we've heard from opponents I hear from folks
050all the time um that school choice claims to take out funding defunds uh Public Schools but in just the last four years in Ox County alone our budget has increased by 35% in the past five again in the past 5 years uh that does not include the federal uh pandemic relief money that we had that was more than $150 million and all while during the pandemic our our student numbers actually decreased so why our student numbers decreased our funding increased we have voted to increase teacher pay improve security increase funding for high quality instruction and I think that competition makes everybody stronger and families deserve opportunities no matter their zip code and I know there's several um school board members who are in favor of school choice and I think that speaks volumes as well
051so I will be voting no on this motion and hopefully voting um yes if that comes to it on Mr triplets uh suggested recommendations Miss Templeton thank you appreciate it um so many things have been said tonight um I want to thank those of you who um stood up and spoke um those were eloquent words um and I appreciate it Miss hanok thank you um for the time you put into that um speech that you made and everybody else who did as well thank you for your time um I whole thing written about why I don't agree with vouchers um I'm not going to read it right now um and I hope I won't have to because I truly believe that this conversation is about this board looking past our partisan differences when it comes
052to communicating with our state legislators I think that we can come up with a list of legisla priorities that we all agree on and submit those in unity so that if any of our state legislators call us and say hey how's it going in your District regarding a b c d or E we can speak to that with honesty and with Integrity when we send this off to Nashville to say this is the Knox County school board's legislative priorities that means that we've all signed off on it more than any policy quite frankly when we send a off it means we all agree that's what it should be this should be a document of Unity on the issues that we can all stand behind so I would what while I'm on one side and maybe
053somebody else is on the other side I don't think that that's what this conversation right now was about is about what can we disseminate to and agree thank you Miss Chris we have our lights on I had to make sure going order there um as I said earlier in the week I honestly think that this decision is beyond our control either way I think that uh those at the state level have made their positions known on this one way or the other in their campaign PL platforms and typically if somebody makes something a campaign platform another body is not going to be able to to change that and I am curious Mr triplet how you would feel about adding something urging them to [Music] um have schools receiving public funds meet similar accountability measures that
054our Public Schools meet and be transparent in reporting um those achievement scores and and that would just be in the same manner Public Schools do and that would just be so parents can make informed decisions based on um that transparency and Reporting just encouraging them to look at those measures um moving forward I mean do you have strong feelings about that I'd be okay if you want to come up if you have some good wording you want to put in there than that um I'm trying to think on the flaw exactly how that wording would go but um we can let Lauren speak and think through it and yeah well I I have some some tentative wording here where um it says we Advocate that all in institutions receiving public funds to educate Tennessee students
055meet the same accountability standards and emphasize the importance of transparency in reporting student achievement data enabling all Tennessee parents to make informed decisions regarding the education of their children can you say that one more time CU that was a lot to read and I will I was going to say I need to hear that again okay um we ask that all institutions receiving public funds to educate Tennessee students meet the same accountability standards as public schools furthermore we emphasize the importance of transparency in reporting student achievement data enabling all Tennessee parents to make informed decisions regarding their children's education thinking through that I do like the portion about um achievement data so we can kind of figure out where they land um and this is I mean this is just encouraging them to to take
056that in mind as they are looking at the I mean I know there's multiple uh proposals in front of them and it is something that I would like for them to consider because I do think it's important for parents to have that information and for the public to have that information if for using tax dollars defend it okay let me think through that Miss Morgan thank you madam chair while I believe in school choice and the right for parents to choose what is best for their children and I am a a proponent of charter schools I'm thrilled that we were able to pass uh the renewal of emerald tonight and I'm I'm happy for the great work that they're doing there um I also don't believe that being pro- school choice means you're against public
057schools I am very much for public schools I choose to send my three children to public schools and I serve in the seat on the school board um as a fan of public schools I believe you can be both for public schools and believe that parents have the right to choose what is the best school option for their children um however I don't believe that it is in this board's realm of Duties to make vouchers a legislative priority as we don't have control over what the legislature does I think it's our job here on this board to make to make Knox County Schools the best that they can possibly be and be the place for our um where our students and our families want to get an education and choose to go to school and
058I believe that we need to continue to be focusing on that I think our effort should be focused on things that will support our teachers and help our students in KNX County Schools right now [Music] thank you Miss bike thank you um um I I think I can agree with um maybe adding in some requirements um for schools that uh might accept um esas and the school choice I'd like to add um that they have to background check all of their staff that they have to have certified teachers they need to be ADA Compliant that they also do teaps and then also abide by third grade retention I think that that is only fair if they're going to accept our money seems reasonable to me thank you Reverend Butler um I'm going to cut my
059light off because I want to make sure everybody had a chance to speak before I call for the question yes sir okay okay so there's a lot of discussion so we're voting right now strictly on this document and no other suggested changes or no other suggested additions correct so if this vote passes this is it but if this vote happens to fail then we would go back to this you know I was thinking maybe this could be our base and then vote on each addition additional consideration separately does that make sense to everybody I know this can kind of get a little a little wonky yes miss fley you have a question um by when you held it up um does this mean the 20 wait so the the one that's yeah so the 2025
060it looks like this yeah that so what Miss cotney did with this was she took all of the um discussion from Monday night and compiled it into this document so it's actually two pages no no it's just one page the second page are Steve's considerations yeah thank you okay all right so now that we got procedure oh Mr dupler well so so you all do need to clarify because we what I heard you say Madam chair is and the way I understand Reverend Butler's uh motion is to to approve the 2025 legislative priorities as written and as is before you correct but to exclude the additional the the optional additions for board consideration Reverend Butler is that correct okay so if that motion is approved then these options are out correct okay correct and then
061you said you may want to look at some additional so some additional that aren't these options you all could make motions on she said that if fails then we would go back to you know passing this you know as another vote just to pass this and then separate votes uh but I just wanted to make it clear as well so so if that if that motion passes then you all could somebody could make a motion on some some additional considerations but not the ones that are attached okay yeah okay gotcha okay all right Miss Cy will you please do a roll call thank you madam thank you madam chair Dr Butler yes Miss Templeton yes Miss mono Ridley yes Miss bike yes Miss Morgan yes Mr triplet no Mr Wright no Miss Christie um I'll
062pass and Miss Henderson no Miss Christie would you like to change your pass vote so that that's five yes votes three no votes and one pass all right motion carries oh miss miss Christie you on oh okay okay all right all right M do we have speak I'm sorry Sor no here here thank you thank you Adam chair 8 G consideration of student number 20241 disciplinary appeal I move to not have a hearing and I'm not sure how I want to term that Mr dupler but I make a motion I make a motion not to have a hearing or to uphold the to uphold make a motion upold the decision that was already the decision of the superintendent that's correct and I'll second all right if I may Madam chair yes please there's a lot
063of lights on yeah I mean and you all can have your discussion uh you know but but again I would I would I would caution you to not discuss the facts because those are confidential uh but but I did want to clarify what the vote would be and I think I think you've already clarified that so so a yes vote at this point uh upholds the superintendent the superintendent's decision on the record that that you all have reviewed um and then and then this this case would then end a no vote U would be to have a hearing and it would be a confidential hearing on the facts thank you okay thank you Mr dupler for that clarification Reverend Butler thank you madam chair and I uh support uh the nox County Schools administration and
064all the work that they've done to this point uh this is the first time that I have been involved with this process and um I think for most of us it may be our first time and I think when we would I'm not sure if I don't remember as for the last 15 years I've been attending board me meetings that this has happened so this is the first time and uh not getting into the facts but more about procedure uh i' rather air on on the side of having a hearing and not needing it then needing a hearing and not having it and so and I talked with uh some folk who have done this in other communities um other other districts uh and the board may want to go through this process so we
065can know we've gone through it and know what's required for the record so that we can surely say yeah okay the record was what we needed to have so um and I've come to this conclusion arguing with myself both sides but um and a feel and if if and and I have I came here really thinking I was going to automatically you know vote to up to uphold administration's decision but at this point I think it may be the board's best in the board's best interest for the district for us to take a look that's that's the best I can say if I'm getting into thank you Reverend Butler Miss F Ridley I have a brief statement to make um as a former teacher of the student involved I feel I can't approach the situation
066without bias therefore I have to recuse myself from consideration of this appeal okay thank you for that thank you any more discussion on procedures all right we seeing there is none Miss cotney can you please your I'll call Dr Butler I think I'm saying no because I'm saying we need to have a hearing correct so the yes so what we are voting on is to uphold the current uh decision made by KCs Administration so you're correct in that vote Reverend Butler Miss Templeton yes yeah this SS backwards you have to think about it Miss B pass Miss Morgan yes Mr triplet yes Mr Wright yes Miss Christie yes Miss Henderson yes Miss bike would you like to change your path vote that is six yes votes one no vote and one pass and then miss
067font readily recused herself motion carries all right we do have some public forum speakers thank you madam chair Candace pan Candace if you state your name and County residence you have three minutes CIS banister KN County resident after will died his employer reached out to us to offer food for our family and friends the day of will service I thanked them but told them there'd be quite a crowd they say they didn't care how many they wanted to make that day easier if they could they came and set up and fed nearly a 100 people the day of will service his manager told me that Will was she called will the top knot because he always pulled his hair on top of his head but also because he was their hardest worker the only one
068they allowed to clock in early because he went straight to work and never complained she said they missed him and wanted to do this for our family my older son worked at the theater they gave him the week off paid for it paid him for it and then had a fundraiser for you suicide my husband's employer matched donations given in memory of will to will Scout Tre my employer intimidated Will's friends sent someone to my house to intimidate Us by asking if we knew our son was a drug dealer and reported untruths about me because I told them the executive administrator had bullied my son when the superintendent ordered my son back to school sadly Knox County Schools has a long history and culture of intimidation harassment and bullying which will and our family have
069experienced and suffered through over the last eight years on December 5ifth I watched as Miss Owen spoke of 43 complaints from staff and parents from my son's school regarding the behavior of the executive administrator have vanished and that a lead person in HR said that no formal complaint process was ever initiated one of the current assistant superintendant took extensive notes from many of these employees in her previous position where are those notes where are the 43 written complaints why didn't HR invest initiate the investigation the admin was moved to HR as a secondary supervisor on the Friday before students return for the 1920 school year what were his duties the Optics on him being placed in HR and 43 written complaints about him disappearing from his fer pretty bad you have the power to insist
070that this culture of bullying intimidation and harassment come to an end you have one employee tell him to do this investigation tell him to find out one none of these complaints are available tell them you don't want a bully put in charge of the five regional directors and by extension every building level administrator across the county Sunday will be Will's 24th birthday I don't think I can convey to you what it feels like to face his birthday when he's no longer here on Earth I have not seen will since he was 16 years old I have not hugged him heard his voice seen him walk into a room heard his laugh or seen his smile I have not touched his beautiful red hair I have not set our table for four I have not bought
071him a gift or taking him shopping and he loved to shop I have not had the joy of making his favorite meal or watching him fall asleep on the couch after a long day I really don't even know what will would look like at age 24 I have endured seven birthdays without him in Sunday January 12th I will endure another one in all of these almost eight years Knox County Schools never invested and even investigated the who bullied our son even with 43 written complaints instead they tucked him into a desk in HR starting in 2019 and then moved him to a new very high-profile administrative position in May of 2024 do better in honor of Will's 24th birthday and all of the students in KN County Schools please do better thank you thank you
072madam chair that concludes public for thank you everybody enjoy your long weekend and we are adjourned for