001e e e 25 work session please stand as we observe a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance led by Miss Morgan iedge Ali to the flag of the United States of America to Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all just have a few announcements before we get into our very robust agenda this evening first off the clothing Center committee will meet on Friday January 10th at 10:00 a.m. in summerplace boardroom and also the next policy review meeting will be held on Friday January 24th at 10:00 a.m. in the Summer Place boardroom are there any requested changes to this meeting agenda move to approve motion by Mr triplet second by Miss Christie all those in favor say I I any opposed all right motion
002carries Dr riswick start with your report all right let's do that put everybody to sleep to start out thank you madam chair members of the board we're just saying everything feels long tonight so including my report so uh just want to welcome everybody back from winter break uh hope everyone was able to enjoy some time away with their family and friends and recharging uh I hope that uh everybody's excited as I am to kick off this new semester uh it's always a neat time of year when you kind of think and reflect a little bit about what happened last semester but then uh can think about all the things there are to do to get back uh to do and and I'm really excited about the momentum we have right now so uh I'll start
003this report off with a fun update this past Saturday I had the honor of dropping the puck at the Ice Bears game uh I was thankful to to the partners in education and the Knoxville Ice Bears for hosting us it was a fantastic event nearly $1,000 was raised that evening with all proceeds benefiting KS so I want to thank everybody for coming out for that that really is it was sold out really has becomeing and they couped it with Star Wars night so I know some of you guys were able to be there and we might have been on the fan bony for a little while getting to ride that too on the ice which is always a neat experience but uh the The Ice Bears have been great and partners in that as well
004I'm also pleased to share with you uh that that you will receive a copy of the 23 24 annual report on Thursday uh this report reviews the progress that we've made last year and provides insight into the intentional strategies our schools are using to improve uh student outcomes uh the annual report will also be available for download on our website this Thursday uh really excited about that and this is the second one we've done ever uh but it is I've gotten to see a good draft of it and it looks really good so we haven't always taken the time to report on these results uh extensively and I want to thank our strategy division uh who's worked extremely hard trying to increase transparency and improving communication of our district so big shout out to those
005three departments that really headed that our creative Services Department led by Abby Harris our public affairs uh led by Miss Carly Harrington and our impact and analytics that is uh Steve Rudder he he manages that for so uh it really really has been a work that they've been working on all semester uh but I do think even last year we got a lot of positive uh impact just from from CEOs from commission from different people just the fact they could kind of see the whole story there of the work that's been done done by our uh by our teachers and principles and schools so excited about that as we begin the New Year it's important that we take time to look ahead uh tonight I'd like to share the preview of a few major initiatives
006that are on the horizon for Knox County Schools uh in just a few minutes you get the opportunity to hear from Dr Brown uh on our update on our continuous improvement work in the special education uh just for folks to remember a little over two years ago we launched a deep dive into our special education services and supports to identify opportunities to enhance our work commitment to success for every student um you know I think at that time it was people were said what are we doing we knew we wanted to be better um and so that was something that we asked for there was no political pressure to do that it was just something that we uh want to always have that continuous Improvement mindset uh and really moved into that work uh and
007excited to hear that today um so as you know we've secured a third party contract uh contractor to produce a three to 5e strategic plan at the end of this that's what we're looking to do uh and while we forward to the results of that study uh I also want to commend Dr Brown and his team for not waiting for that study to be finished before we start implementing change now uh his team is currently uh taking meaningful steps to enhance as you'll hear in a minute the IEP experience for families and focused decision- making as close to the student as possible uh Dr Brown and his team have been in schools performing Fidelity checks and working with our regional leaders to ensure Schools teachers and administrators have the supports they need to to provide
008high quality education for our students um I want to say this you know when you take these things on they're not easy uh and and uh trying to make sure that we're doing these things right um sometimes it is two steps forward and three steps back um and there's a lot of people who are impacted by these things but just because the works hard is not a reason for us not to do it so uh I appreciate the board being on this journey with us I think we're we'll celebrate some victories today but we'll also point out some areas that we need to get better at uh and that our students deserve that so uh our work is far from finished but I'm I'm I'm confident we're on the right track um and under Dr
009Brown's leadership I'm confident we'll not only celebrate our successes but Embrace with Courage the changes that need to be made to help our students succeed couple other things just to tell you are coming up in the spirit of continuous Improvement I've tasked the academics division Dr Wilson's team uh to contract with a third party vendor to evaluate our middle school programs and practices if you look at our data over over the years and this is not a reflection on our Middle School teachers or our Middle School principles but it's been inconsistent we'll have we'll have like Ste increases and then steep Dives uh over time what we want to do is try to level that out um and so part of that U we want to we want to take a deep look and have
010a third party come look at what are National best practices for middle schools we started that if you remember uh at the end of November with Dr fauler Who was on assignment for us to interview our current sitting Middle School principles and get some feedback from them about areas we might be able to improve you probably heard me say before is is Middle School and extension of elementary school or is it preh high school and our answer right now is yes uh and we need to be able to Define that a little better uh we've done a pretty good job in elementary defining F foundational skills and and a good job about the career exploration for our high schools but Middle School is a place we want to continue to do that um so looking
011forward to that uh last month I was also encouraged to hear feedback as as you all did as well from our stakeholders on the development of our District's uh next fiveyear strategic plan I think three strengths that the Milan Chicago uh group identified from their surveys Focus the focus groups were culture communication and understanding of our priorities as I went back and looked over those um if I were going to say what are three things that I would hope that they would find those were probably three things that are really important uh for what we need to do moving ahead so I've been with the district for a long time and we we usually don't talk about these strengths so I was pleased to hear that our community is already feeling the impact of our
012improvements in these areas uh especially around communication that feels like one transparency and communication we can we never stop working on that but it was good to know that they noted that that was something they felt like they understood so we'll continue to build on that as you know this is also the point of the year when we begin to plan for next year's budget um our divisions and our divisional leaders have already begun evaluating their needs and expenditures to ensure that we're maximizing every dollar and prioritizing student impact last year we were able to make historic investments in our people and I want to thank our board again for you making that investment last year uh just as a reminder to the public 86% of our budget it's a big budget but 86% of
013our budget uh goes to Staffing and while this is a major investment it illustrates the CR critical and important role our staff play in improving outcomes for students uh and I want you to know on the record in January my commitment as superintendent this year will be to put us in a position to continue to invest in our people year after year I think uh you guys were part of the Evergreen study and you know we got in that hole because we weren't able to do that and market value we're there now and and that's going to take continuous investment as we move forward to do that but also understand 86% of our budget's in there so that's our commitment moving forward uh we'll continue to update you on that progress of where we are
014in the budget as we move forward uh and in closing before I wrap up I'd also like to take a moment to celebrate a significant milestone for many of our Educators this year 240 KCs teachers have earned tenure making a pivotal achievement in their careers and a testament to their dedication to our students uh I think it's really important to know tenure is not just a a mild recommendation that happens by chance it's a reflection of the Excellence resilience and unwavering commitment to education uh when we talk about great Educators in every school this is what we're talking about and to see these 240 achieve at that level that means they've been having an impact on students and their students are moving forward and these are the exact kind of folks that we want to
015stick around and really celebrate so uh they exemplify the very best of what it means to serve in a classroom and shape our students so I want to say congratulations to these Educators for their hard work uh and this well-deserved accomplishment and thank you for the opportunity on the long updates today it's all I have I meant to time that but I forgot to but it was all good stuff so all very meaningful work that is being done uh thank you Dr risle for that report next on the docket we have um Miss himl Garn our internal School funds audit report yes Madam chair members of the board our internal School funds audit report is part of an annual review of financial activity at the school level uh Mr Ted hotz from pcpa is here
016to highlight um the findings um as as he'll share uh we were pleased to see a reduction uh in findings in some areas um but you'll also see that we've still got some work to do and as you follow along in the report some of the steps that we have taken or are taking to get there are highlighted in our management responses um so I will turn it over to Mr hootz thank you it's good to see you again thank you good to be here again good to be here for start a new year um obviously our report is a really long report you see have the attachment it's 4133 Pages now there will be a corrective action plan added to it which is really the extension of the management responses that were discussed so
017it'll be even a few more pages longer than this obviously I'm not going to go over all the pages but I'm going to go over summary numbers and the finding section for reference say uh on PDF Pages two through four are your table contents the only reason I point that out is if you're interested in the balance sheet income statement and transfer schedules for an individual school that's that's where you would go look uh so um the particularly that's where we identify the balancing income statement for each school and later in the transfer section uh you'd have to go through uh find it in order but they're an alphabetical order elementary schools first middle schools then then high schools so if you're looking for information on a particular school for certain particular schools you can
018go to the page number in that rep use use the table of contents to find it um right after the table of contents on PDF Pages 7 through n will be the audit opinion and basically in the opinion section if if you read the opinions it looks a little odd because we are reporting under the the state manual Tennessee State manual for internal School funds so it has a different basis than Gap or generally accepted accounting principles so our report will show adverse opinion on us Gap but uh an unmodified opinion on the regulatory basis of accounting or the the the the state guidelines that we're required to use so that is don't be misled by that we are the report is exactly as it's supposed to be it's it's a clean opinion under the
019state man under the state manual that we're required to follow so don't be alarmed by the adverse opinion section there it's it's your regular report uh for for any school system in the state of Tennessee uh beyond that uh immediately after that are the summary numbers which on pages 11 through 15 um and here will the first two pages 11 and 12 will show summary numbers for your balance sheets uh of note on page 12 U and it's small print you won't be able to see it there but if you're also looking on your screen total cash held in in the internal School funds and I'll take a step back for a minute this audit is on the internal School fund so it's for the checking accounts basically or the activities that are at the
020individual schools it does not include Central office activity the only there is a central office account but it's an account which is tied in with the internal School funds so this is really only the internal School funds activity as opposed to central office activity but even at these uh the 90 plus schools total cash of the end of the year was 16.8 million so it's a lot a lot of money is held in these accounts also from a re on page 14 at the bottom you'll see total revenues and expenditures total revenues were 25.2 million for the year uh total expenses are 23.4 million so even though there are a lot of small transactions cuz primarily with there're small transactions in these accounts there's an awful lot of small transaction actions and and the dollars
021are significant so that's why the state requires this audit and that's that's why it's important to have controls because uh while many transactions are smaller in nature that they they can't certainly significant dollars are involved in these accounts uh after that follows the and I'm not going to go through these like uh the individual balance sheet and income statement for each school I'm going to skip all the way to the back and and the compliance section which is on pages first your compliance report is on pages 396 and 397 and this is the regular report on compliance two pages all it really does is is is refer to the findings that are that follow in the next Pages findings are predominantly internal control findings or or differences or exceptions to uh the state manual the
022guidelines for internal School funds um we have 12 findings listed here uh there were 12 findings a year ago U as Miss hgar noted that we do have a decrease in total number of exceptions in fact we had let me get my summary sheet here sorry um from the prior year of the 12 findings in the prior year two of them them were resolved uh six of the 12 had fewer instances so so eight either are fewer or or gone away two were about the same and two we had more instances so from a exception standpoint there there has been Improvement as auditor I want to continue to see Improvement and continue to see a lesser number of instances uh but but at least uh positive that ex number of exceptions has gone down and
023if you look at the individual findings and they do start on page um two more pages later page 400 yes you'll see okay I guess it was 3 that's fine that's a good example though you'll see that each section has have too many pages here um each section has a criteria or specific requirement a condition a cause and effect a recommend ation and then a management response the first four of those were written up by us the audit firm and the management response and later the corrective action plan which will mirror the management response is the school's response to the finding and and really what their plan is for the for the coming year to to correct or improve that that finding um and then the findings just quickly to to run down what they
024what they are where segregation of Duties uh which is difficult in an in a particularly in an elementary school where you have a very small office um negative fund balances um dispersement uh exceptions purchase order receipts exceptions and I'm really following the prior year finding summary on page 412 here uh these are the ones in the prior year and the column to the right will show whether they're repeated in which reference they are this year or whether they're corrected uh ticket reconciliation fundraising resale activities School support organizations approval of transfers uh travel policy uh the second to last one listed in third the last one listed were two that were resolved this year we did not have exceptions for so they were cleared and then two new ones and this year's report uh number uh
02511 which would be on uh up up a few pages but uh let's see yeah one more um deals with unauthorized credit card charges an external issue uh and then number the 12th one is supplemental salary payments so those are the two new ones um yeah again in summary uh there has been Improvement we want to continue to see Improvement in the number of exceptions um but we uh you know it's a it's a step in in the right direction and we certainly we get uh very good cooperation from the internal School funds team from from Garrett Raiden Heidi Murray and their their team and get communication from Ron mcferson and Jennifer hamar as well so we we appreciate their support um very open and and insisting in the process I have any questions does
026anyone have any questions no I will add I I realize you you don't know how long you've I think the report was released about a week ago but also it's over the holidays and so you may not have much time to to look at them if there's something you have a question on later certainly can either reach me directly at my firm pcpa or can go through Jennifer or Ron or or Garrett or or someone on staff to uh ask and then they can get get in touch with me as well yeah they're very accessible with with what they do and how they work with us which we appreciate awesome thank you so much for being here and and presenting that to us tonight all right thank you thanks happy New Year Happy New Year
027to you all right next up Steve Mr Triplet a legislative update sure um thank you madam chair uh thank you all board for responding to miss coty's email about figuring out a time to meet with our state legislators before session starts uh the date I know we we tried to accommodate lots of schedules obviously legislators and our own our own crew here and so uh we landed on Wednesday January 22nd at 9:00 a.m so if you want to plug that into your calendar um uh Miss cotney will send out an invitation uh shortly with some details and and all that but uh that date January 22nd at 9:00 a.m. we'll meet with our legislators and discuss you know the upcoming session and and things we'd like to see uh we will discuss our legislative priorities
028when we get to the uh the regular agenda for Thursday and that'll be kind of the Catalyst for our discussion with them on the 22nd thank you madam chair awesome thank you how long are we expecting that to last the breakfast yes yeah it's like an hour and a half Miss Christie do you have a strategic plan committee update that's a mouthful yeah thank you madam chair uh board members Milan Chicago provided us with their final report on stakeholder engagement surveys and also wrapped up their collaboration with Accenture regarding the student family staff and Community input Accenture is still in the early stages of their work toward drafting a plan for committee review and will be meeting with staff to review data next week um we will be meeting again the committee in the near
029future we do not have a date for that yet but as soon as that's been finalized we will of course share it with board members in the public awesome thank you does anyone have any questions right Dr Brown oh oh and board members the presentation is attached to the agenda so you can follow along you don't have to squint up at the TVs good thank you this is thank you madam chair members of the board uh as always I do appreciate the opportunity to come and share with you all I know that you receive information for lots of different places and articles and emails and all kinds of things and I do appreciate the opportunity to get to come and talk to you and share with you the work that we're doing um I gotta
030turn this s don't I Tri all right there we go um we're we're going to kind of stick to the same framework we did last time in uh really focusing on three major areas um as we reflected on this I know some of the um Miss Henderson you mentioned in the last meeting you know wanting a real update about some of the things that have been done um and so I'm going to go back and go through some historical things that we've accomplished and also look at some of the results that we're already seeing uh but uh as I reflected on that what I I think where we are is um we're doing some small things along the way that probably are unseen uh the big work of this year is more of a long-term
031goal of creating doing that analysis and and creating the three to five year strategic plan so I want to go back and kind of highlight some of the things that we have done uh in this update on the in these three areas um says there a lot going back talking about staff development um you know obviously the first thing that we did and and that came out of um the resolution you all passed in the fall of 23 was to develop a KCs way for special education and again this was just a framework that we provided to all schools one of the things that we know is when you have 91 schools there's 91 different ways to do things and we wanted to make sure that we provided some consistent Direction and advice on how
032to operate and make decisions as Dr RIS mentioned earlier closest to the student um so part of the work we've been doing this year is to go back and see are we doing it uh and so in the first quarter our our uh Regional support structure and our supervisors uh randomly visited schools dropped it on IEP meetings to see and at that time about 80% of the schools that they visited and that includes all five regions were following and doing the things they were having agendas they were they were meeting the the direction of that but 20% weren't um and so with that came corrective action plans and so our supervisors then follow up with that school leadership to make sure that they are using the KCs way for special education to provide that consistency
033um one of the other things that i' mentioned in the fall that we we did um we've provided some biweekly administrated training so every Wednesday or two times a month um we provide a Wednesday afternoon training that's open to all administrators in Knox County uh topics include manifestations eligibility the KCs way revisiting that data driven decision-making and how to be in Lea the the local um representative in an IEP meeting uh so again just trying to train principles uh because if we're honest when when Educators go to school there's very unless you're a special educator you don't get a lot of training in special education um I mean I can tell you I've got four degrees in education and I took one special education classes undergrad because I wasn't special a teacher so nowhere in
034administration nowhere do provide you that direction to really so our specialed department is really trying to help those people who don't have a background in special education know how to best handle uh those in in their school so a lot of a lot of those uh topics you'll see listed there um we've also done some additional trainings for other staff within the building all new special ed teachers go through a special education Institute this is a multi-day training that we do to help uh kind of bring in new teachers to the KCs way of doing things um and then also at at our district learning days we've had special trainings for our teaching assistants that's been focused on supporting students in the General Ed setting um as far as stakeholder engagement goes as I mentioned
035you all last time I think we talked about kind of our first meeting of the year I did bring on um three new members to the special ed Council so we had Regional representation across the district um we we met this year kind of did an intro and a review of of you know what we're doing in special education and where we are in that process and also just their role as the parent counsil just to be a sounding board for me uh and also help direct some of that work um I will say this the parent Council for me has proved to to be more than that uh I think one of the greatest things about it is it opened up another communication pathway so that parents feel like they've they've got a voice
036and they can have and and and I will say we have been able to address several issues that really aren't even in the realm of special education just concerns they had as parents but because they felt like they had somebody to talk to were able to address it one great story I I'll share with you um you know and this this one really upset me when this parent reached out to me told us about I think you all you all know we had the great initiative we had the partnership with KF where we uh provided new playgrounds which sounds really great and then one of my parents on the council reached out and said you know my son can't access that playground and even though they're supposed to be ADA Compliant they weren't really Ada
037functional and so because this child's in a wheelchair he was sitting on the side while he watched his friends play and if that doesn't bother you something's wrong and we can't stand for that so fortunately I have a great team of people that I work with I reached out to to Dr Adams and miss himar and they have people who are working on the playground stuff and we were able to come up they used ADA compliance money and we now have rubberized Pathways so that child can play with his aage peers cuz that's the way it should be um so so again that those are the things to me that's what matters and that's why we have special education Council and um you know I was really glad that we were able to work and
038and and get some things like that taken care of and that's not the only one you know there were several situations where parents on the council had issues something going on with their child um you know I reached out to Dr Wilson about something that had nothing to do with special education but it needed to be addressed and when I was made aware of it we were able to address that so um you know lots of good things coming out of the special ed Council um obviously they have participated in our in our analysis year this year they did a an individual kickoff to be able to ask questions to get an idea of what PCG had planned and then also they participated in their own focus group and then we had the uh the
039surveys and all that so there's been a whole lot of involvement with the special ed Council and our special ed parents this fall um I I kind of mentioned that the Strategic plan engagement we did F increase the number of focus groups because we had such and I believe I shared that with you all last time um as far as uh enhancing our engagement um you know part of my operational plan this year has been to look at getting more feedback and so um you know we produce a special ed parent newsletter and we added a feedback component for that which has been really helpful because uh I spoke with Sue o andb today and it really has helped to guide some of the things they've done specifically the October uh Family Resource fair so
040she really wanted to do like a conference where she could have these experts come in and share and parents said that's really not what we need we need to learn more about the resources and supports that are out there for special ed families um so they they were um we we used their feedback to to guide that um we've also had um the ability to partner with some um from some partnering organizations so we're having other people experts in the field to come in and share with our parents on subjects such as all things Behavior from the Tennessee voices the why and what and how of communication from step conservatorship and specialed planning from smoke Smokey Mountain Legacy and how to avoid conflict by the ark um so had a lot of a lot of
041good partners to come in and help us do this work and help uh engage and help parents know how to better support their child so here's the exciting part which means that 80% of our kids is we want to get to where 80% of our students with IEP spent 80% of their time in the General Ed setting currently our goal for this year and that's a multi-year goal to get to 80% but our goal for this year is 77.2 we are currently sitting across the district at 79.2 n and all five regions have met that Target um we have also exceeded our 2526 goal which is next year which is 78.3 4 uh so we are having more children included we are getting more kids in the general education setting more more often um all
042regions as I said met that Target um and 64 out of our 91 schools are above that so um not just are we meeting the average we're also individually you know the majority of our schools are are making that Target more exciting than that is the academic gains if you look at those trends at the bottom um we've seen an increase in ela proficiency uh over the past two years by 1.4% and in math by 3.5 uh so not only are kids spending more time in the general Ed setting it's showing results uh and we all know that to be true when kids are exposed to high quality instructional materials when they're in the tier one instruction they're going to get the material they're going to understand it better and they're going to perform better
043um so obviously inclusion is something that we all want and we are doing our best and striving to get kids included more often and spend more of their day in the General Ed setting all right so the final one is our strategic plan for education and and again just want to kind of circle back Dr risewick mentioned several these things a little while ago but basically our long-term what we're working on this year is to develop this 3 to five year strategic plan to improve achievement for all students we've seen an improvement but we can always do better you know we're always as Dr rise referenced we're always looking at continuous Improvement uh and so no matter how good we're doing we can always do better um we want again move more and more students
044into the general education setting we've meet and ex exceeded our goals uh for for LR but that it's not good enough we want to continue to do that uh and then finally obviously we want to improve special education supports to keep students in their Zone schools we don't want to have to move a child from place to place just to get the services they need we'd like to provide that Continuum of supports within the within the building uh a lot of this again is going to be kind of a refresh of what we've talked about before but if you'll remember in September we kicked off the project um October through December was really that analysis stage that's where they came out uh they sent out surveys got over 1,200 response we did 39 focus groups
045to get personto person input uh on the status and their feelings about special ed we also provided all the work that had been done by the acrian group uh prior to me coming into this role so the we gave them the recommendations from the task force we provided the acran report uh we gave them all the data and everything we have we continue to have weekly check-ins with PCG so just today we had a meeting to follow up on some data pieces that they wanted so we're continuing to pull data and get them the information they need um they did School visits so um visited every region in our district did over 60 schools uh all levels all different programmingsoftware did October through December so what's coming up next uh right now as I said
046we're we're continuing to engage with them give them the information they need provide it you know answers to any questions they have uh and then they will actually they're writing their report now they will present that to us uh and then the final after that report is issued we'll work with them uh over in April and May I'm hoping really it's sooner than that but really working with the council with their schools leadership uh special ed department and PCG to write that strateg IC plan which then we will bring to you I hope that is our next quarterly update uh we will be coming to you with that strategic plan to talk about here here's where we are here here's where we're doing well here's some areas we can improve in um and here's our
047plan to get there um so what are our next steps um in the staff development World we're going to continue to do principal trainings um some of those trainings are really what we're looking at is what are timely things that principles need to know what are the Hot Topics a lot of those are generated by principal questions and interest that they have uh but also just helping to prepare them for what's coming up for example you know in the spring one of the sessions we'll be doing is on uh grade transitions how to have a transition meeting and and who to include and you know how to how to navigate that process to make sure we may have a smooth transition from one grade or from one school to the next um one of the
048things that our specialed department is doing right now they're actually providing a monthly calendar to principal to let them know the things that they need to do on a monthly basis so these are timely reminders each month may have some similar things but also some specific things that they need to have in that month for example we're in January right now so what they're reminding principles of is we need to be looking at students IEPs and we need to be looking at their class schedules to make sure their hours of service are matching and they're getting what needs to be uh given to them in through their IEP um we also have uh are training all the assistants in our special day schools and other high need area schools so schools that have special programming
049like say uh autism Support Program uh but basically all of those assistants are going to receive a 40-hour training to become rbts which are registered Behavior technicians um they will complete that by Spring Break and at that point our own bcbas which are the board certified behavioral analysts will provide the supervision that's required um I Travis I always try to remember to give give the acronyms I know we've got a bunch of them um but they will provide the certification the the supervisions so those people can receive that RBT certification um again stakeholder engagement I'm actually meeting with the council again tomorrow I'm going to share a lot of this information they asked for an update and so um they felt like I'd have a good dry run today and tomorrow I'd be ready to
050go to give them the you know this is this is kind of the the warm-up session I guess and I'll give them the real one tomorrow um and and obviously we uh Sue O and B our on buds person has a special uh parent empowerment committee that she meets with uh again a lot of that's driven the topics and the things that she covers by the um um by the parents and the results of that survey that's that's in the newsletter that we send out um they um I lost that I had um her information but I've misplaced that so um another thing that's not in there uh and but I want to mention as far as we talk about what things are we doing to provide I know a lot of you like I
051mentioned you probably get lots of questions and I know a Hot Topic right now is modified content um modifying content for students is actually the the role of the regular educ education teacher uh however um what we did to help facilitate that is we've hired an inclusion coach and so now we have someone who's got a track record of being successful in supporting inclusion services within the classroom room um this is a special ed person who's going to be able to go into schools and help our regular Ed teachers modify that content so that we have you know appropriate materials that are aligned with the curriculum um and are high quality so that we can continue uh to to expose our students to that um additionally uh Dr L I spoke with today there's been
052lots of questions about where we are with a modified content Bank um her plan is to work with our Communications Department and the new website to have a uh a submission portal where parents community members Advocates whoever can upload information that we can make accessible to teachers um so again that's that's a that's a big work we've provided exemplars and trainings on how to do that uh but obviously there's um you know there there's still work to be done in that area um a couple other things I wanted to do um but I think that pretty wraps it up so uh do you all have any questions or anything I can H hopefully answer Miss bike thank you I have a few questions okay um first I would like to say thank you for this
053presentation it's been very helpful um and for all the work you're doing and that your team is doing I really appreciate that you've put that um feedback on the end of the newsletter I think that that is going to go really great um because definitely some feedback that I had heard previous viously from parents are that they felt like the newsletter wasn't quite hitting for them and sometimes felt a little condescending you know especially if you're a parent that's um been doing this your whole child's life with them there's a certain amount of skills you already have um and um and then of course the parents that are reading the newsletter are the parents that are already putting in that effort um but um some things that I know that you are already thinking about
054your team is already thinking about and stuff that I brought up in our um uh annual Workshop but I would love to see in some of this this reporting and data how you guys are kind of looking at um students that are falling kind of on both ends of the bell curve because I know that that still you know as you explained still SP Falls in special education with um giftedness and then the other end where you need heavy supports some amount of supports but that you know that there are students that do fall on both sides and to be intellectually gifted and be all the way on that side I think that there are some barriers to get to there if you you know twice exceptional students I know that I've I'm beating a
055dead horse to a certain extent here but there are quite a bit of students that you know maybe exceptional at math and I mean like very exceptional but are are not or maybe average or below average in Reading Ela and things like that that are not meeting that criteria to be classified as intellectually gifted and then we're seeing behavioral issues and other things that are happening and then those students are losing track and we're losing them um and then those parents are becoming frustrated so I'd really like to see kind of what we're doing to address that and have some sort of because as I understand it right now you it's an average of both and they're not looked at individually is that correct I am not a school psychologist okay so uh that's how
056I currently understand it but i' I'd love to see if there's a way to kind of separate it or have a rubric of like okay well if they're here but this then they still can kind of access those things and and I would say just aside from from because here's the thing I think too many times we're worried about all the pathways and it becomes complicated I I don't know the answers to you know how how School psychologists determine intellectual giftedness versus you know just providing Services the thing that I do know is that once a student receives an IEP I think that opens the doorway for services at any level and so I think through those IEP meetings like the parents need to voice their concerns and let's make sure that we're meeting with
057those um and if they don't get the answer they want from a school you know reach out to the supervisor reach you know like reach out to downtown and let let us support cuz that's what they're for I completely understand that but I think that that's sometimes where parents get frustrated is that they're kind of you know told not necessarily no but they're saying oh well your child doesn't qualify so too bad and then you know you've already done all of this work and then it's hard to continue pushing and continue pushing and sometimes you just don't have the time or know who to call where to call and all of that stuff so I think kind of making that easier and more accessible but also us KCs kind of modifying that to make it
058accessible for students and parents to access that because that's you know if you can't get the IEP if you can't get the 504 then that's kind of the barrier to that and that's kind of what I mean um because I think that there are many families that kind of fall in that Gap um and then with that is um when you are talking about special education I just want to ask this again um is ADHD and dyslexia classified under special education um it depends uh so we address dislexia through the ipds and usually that's addressed through a 504 plan um ADHD can sometimes be addressed through a 504 and sometimes does require an IEP um either way if the student has an IEP then Section 504 is covered under that it's kind of a an
059umbrella um so yes and no yeah um and I guess to expand on my question with that and where it's coming from is that I've heard a lot of parents especially with ADHD um that have been told that well you your student might you know you go through the tests and the and the questionnaires and the teachers do the questionnaires and there might be a mark of oh probably ADHD but then you're told well this is under medical and so you need a medical diagnosis and we don't do that for you there your student can't get and I could I could probably think of five families off the top of my head right now that are in that situation they're having to pay for private evaluations for ADHD that's my family included um in order
060to access those things and they're being told that you can't have access to those supports unless you have a medical diagnosis what is true we can't develop a 504 plan or give someone services without that diagnosis but I I do know that we also I think we offer screeners so that if if that's something that parents need you know we can have teachers and uh families do those screeners and then they can just take it to their pediatrician and and they can do that diagnosis yeah I guess um there are some pediatricians that are reluctant to give that diagnosis um and then that also requires you know families to have an appointment and to go through all that which does cost money and time and you know especially if you're already coming to school for
061the meetings and all of that stuff you know you essentially can't have a full-time job if you're doing this and that's really hard for families and so those families already have those barriers and I wonder how we're helping with those barrier to break down those barriers well I mean 504s and Ida are federal laws um so there there's certain restrictions and their requirements that we have to meet in order to provide services through those so um I I don't know that we have a good answer for that question I mean we're always willing to help um facilitate and to help any way we can like I said we can do screeners we can provide testing internally and even if they don't agree with our testing they can request an independent evaluation which we also pay
062for yeah if a if a screener is done though and the screener does show that oh yeah there's uh a tendency for this thenes we still have to have a doctor to give a medical diagnosis that's a okay yeah that's it's not and so there's no way around not having a doctor to have that medical diagnosis no because to get an IEP with ADHD it's falls under other health impairment and in order to have that you have to have a medical diagnosis of that impairment okay well I mean that's that's really unfortunate for a lot of families but I do think we have places like the vine clinic and other you know again I I understand it does require taking off and taking your child to the doctor um but again we can help facilitate
063that and even you know if they have problems our social workers can get them hooked up with a Vine clinic and it shouldn't cost them anything are those resources that are readily given to families yeah if if if we know that they're needed or if they're asked for yeah I guess there there are definitely some families that probably um don't want to say that they need that help yeah um and so I wonder if that's something that I would always if if you have a family that has a need and they don't feel like it can be met I would always encourage them to reach out to their school social worker the social workers literally have books full of resources and how they can help them get the help that they need and and help
064them navigate that those Pathways okay yeah um and then um next is kind of in the same vein of um you know I really love that we're working towards being uh a modeled district and I think we're getting there and we're going that direction um but I also want about kind of like um just the culture of of you know special education and it being this box that you kind of feels like you have to enter into in order to to get those things when like sometimes I've used the analogy before of that you know I participated in a thing where we had to build a ramp because we had someone that um had a needed access um to a stage and um found that actually everyone benefited from the ramp and so I wonder
065if there are ways in our classrooms and I know a lot of teachers are already doing it but it's not necessarily across the board that um you know a lot of students that don't yet have ADHD or an Autism diagnosis or are kind of on the edge of like is it or is it just a a you know some temporary behavioral things uh and auditory issues and and things like that that you know we're looking at like the lights and the different like things that could trigger a student to have those behavioral reactions uh and in our classrooms I think that that's definitely something that could get us there and and help a lot and I wonder if that's something that you looking at in this yeah I will say um modifications accommodations things that
066can be done for special education students benefit all students um however I don't I don't have any uh I'm not over general education that'd be Dr Wilson yeah uh so we can we can try our like we can share things and we can make suggestions and I think again that's what we're trying to do with this inclusion coach we're hiring people out of our budget and our funds to to try and support the general education uh classroom because I I do agree with you I mean I we we see great results from a lot of things I never never forget there as it's probably been 20 years ago but I went to a a Vanderbuilt training from the Triad group and we learned about you know things to do for children with autism in the
067classroom and I thought these aren't just good things you know for a child with autism these are good things for all children and so I I think you know yes I I think that's great and and I would love to do that and and I'm more than willing to partner with Dr Wilson and um we we we would provide trainings for General Ed teachers we we'd love to do things like that um I think that's great and that's something I'd really love to see I think lots of people I mean I've had that conversation with Dr ly and she said I'm I'm ready tomorrow if if you know if gen gened teachers want to come and talk about how to modify and how to do things and you know how to make a more inclusive
068classroom you know we're all for it that's what I'll say as far as you want me to address culture um there's not a single person that I work with on a daily basis that doesn't want to help every single child in a classroom and meet every ification and and and do all the things to help them be the best that they can be and to reach their Highest Potential um the the perception of special education being a place or this box or something that you have to get into you know those individual cultures are set at the building level and one thing that I will say you know this is you probably heard Dr riswick talk about this is the year of the principal and one of the things that we've tried really hard to
069do and he's tasked us to do is to get out in schools and I I can tell you personally in the first semester I visited 27 schools Middle High and Elementary I've got four more scheduled this week um and part of what I do is to go in and because the culture of a building is what's going to create that inclusive environment and as much as all the people in the central office that I work with in the special ed Department want that that 91 schools doing 91 different things you know what we've tried to do with the KCs way is to provide some of that consistency and then check up and make sure so hopefully again I I it never happens fast enough it doesn't happen fast enough for me I know it doesn't
070happen fast enough for parents um but we are we are doing our best to work on that culture to make sure that we provide that inclusive culture and that inclusive setting at every building where every child feels like they belong and aren't in a box somewhere because that's not okay um thank you so much I really appreciate your work and I know that this isn't easy so I do really appreciate it answering my questions yeah yeah and I and I will say that too you know somebody came up to me before the meeting and said I'd never take your job and I think I told you all when I first took this job I love this job I because every day what we do gets to impact kids and and and we get to impact
071kids who are at greatest risk for not being able to reach their potential for being marginalized and being disenfranchised and moved away from the norm so we get to find ways to get them into the classroom and to get them what they need so they can access their education and that's exciting work for me um I told Miss himar I hope she didn't take offense of this but I wouldn't want to be over the budget I don't want to deal with stuff in HR every day so she can keep her job I get to I get to make a difference for kids every day and and that's exciting yeah well thank you yeah I do want to piggy back on on that a little bit and I do appreciate all the work that's been done
072thank you for doing this presentation and all the work that's been put into it and I have heard from many parents who aren't feeling that change yet at you know at their level and so I do think that we need to supercharge this action we you know we need to take more action I would love to see our sped Department be the NV of all communities and communities coming to us and saying oh my gosh how are you guys doing that we want to model that um but I think we do have a long way to get there uh so what do you need from us how can we support how can we how can we I know fastpac yeah I I don't know how to change people's perceptions I will tell you when you
073say you want to to be a model for special education most of the districts around do come to us they do ask because what we are doing is Far and Away better than what they're able to do just simply because of our size we have 91 schools we have uh Mr mosan provided me some statistics today on on the increase that we have seen in the number of teachers and the assistance that we've provided and how that's cut down on the student to teacher ratio in our special classrooms and the support that we're providing um because of that we can provide services and programming that other school systems just don't have um I mean just last semester we had visitors from multiple surrounding counties come and visit several of our schools to look at our
074programming and how we're doing things um so I I you know again I think we're we're doing the right work I think where we struggle right now is what I mentioned a minute ago and we're trying I don't think that's just solitary to Special Ed I think if we asked Dr Wilson about the implementation of hqm in in the ELA classrooms he probably would say there's some St schools that do it really well and some schools are kind of being resistant dragging their feet um and we're seeing that as well and we're trying to Target our interventions on those schools that we think need support I had a conversation with Miss lner earlier this uh actually last week um about the school improvement process and we identify those schools uh you know talked to Dr
075ly today about providing a a menu of supports that if they identify that this is an area I've got to improve based on you know when we when they do all their analysis and they recognize that their special ed students aren't making the the gains everyone else is now how are we going to come in and support your school to make sure that you're providing that inclusive environment exposing those students to Ong grade level materials so that they can make the gains that they're capable of making thank you for that um I also wanted to ask so you said that the consultant that's coming to help with you know um with the Strategic plan they that person or that organization will be working with the special a counsel MH that's correct okay because I know
076the the reported back challenges to the to the system so I want to make sure that they're input and they're working alongside each other okay and then talk to me a little bit about the modified content you know I've heard from many parents about modified content um is that going to be part of the Strategic plan so that way it's just is there going to be a recommendation on that I know you said that there there's going to be a way to it on the website yeah so that's what we're hoping U Dr ly has received lots of emails and you know we're trying to figure out what is the best way um you part of the problem with modified content is that and not the problem it's the good thing is that it's individualized
077so each child yeah you know we modify the content for that individual to make sure it's still is aligned with those grade level standards that they're learning in that science class or that English class you know whatever it is um so the creation of a bank is is problematic because in my in my mind that's no better than just handing out worksheets to a student right um if we have all these pre-prepared things what what our special ed department has done is they've provided exemplars that show how we can modify that individual content to make sure that you are making that information that's standards align accessible to that student um without just handing them a worksheet here or there yeah yeah CU I don't want to see that yeah I've also encouraged those parents who
078have reached out to me i' I've encouraged them work with your school work with your teacher ultimately it's the gened teachers responsibility to provide content that's that's the role and we've recently received guidance from the special ed department at the state level to say that is the role of the general education teacher is to modif every child that comes into their building and and I try to remind people of this all the time every student is a general education student special ed just comes along to help them access that General education uh so again to to go back to miss bike's question about the Box everybody's in this box everybody's in the General Ed box and they are assigned to a teacher and that's who's responsible for their education what we've provided is that guidance
079and those exemplars to show them how to modify that content and now we've got an inclusion expert of our own who has done this for years uh and has proven has a proven track record of being successful who's now going to assist teachers in that so um you know again we want to open up for submissions to allow that to happen my encouragement to those parents would always be talk to your child's teacher if you want to provide materials to them they they may take them and use them it's the teacher's responsibility to make sure that it's aligned to the standard that they're teaching and appropriate for that child okay I guess that's where I'm I'm confused if it's aligned to the standards and you have parents and Community member submitting it and then the
080teacher takes that and then decides if it's aligned to the St standards or is this teacher submitting it so that other teachers can use it does that make sense if we open up the portal anyone could submit right now the onus of of modification falls on the General Ed classroom teacher and so yeah currently we have the exemplars that they can use to see how to modify um it is their responsibility to follow the standards that are set forth by the state for the the curriculum and for the grade level in the subject that they're teaching okay I guess I'm just confused if I'm a parent of a special ed child and I submit modified work but I'm not a teacher correct there there in lines the problem right yes so who's submitting it on
081the website the parents can because they're the ones who are wanting to submit it and like I said I would encourage them to talk to their teacher because the teacher can give them feedback like well actually we're studying this and it needs to look more like this and you know like uh but again we're trying to we're trying to open all Pathways like I said I I'm not opposed to it we we want to make life easier on everybody um and recognize that it's not easy work being a classroom teacher is tough oh absolutely when you're having to modify work and um I I I I feel like I'm getting a little amen section over here from my friend Paula Hancock uh because we meet with with Miss Hancock and some special ed teachers and
082on a monthly basis to talk about some of the thing and it's tough It's hard work um but we all get into this this field because we want to do what's right and we want to make a difference for kids yeah I appreciate that thank you FR for my questions yep Miss Templeton had to rethink some of my questions because you hit on several of them um actually most of them thank you Miss welcome Miss Templeton I'm here appreciate you reading my mind um first thank you true this is fantastic because as I get so many emails um ironically over the month of December a lot um probably as people are looking to the next semester and preparing and things like that so you answered quite a few of those it's very thorough and I
083appreciate the gains that you're making um and recognizing that each child has a special set of needs um and trying to meet those accordingly um thank you for that um I I also had a questions about this modifications Bank you you explained it very well um but you said something and I just need you to clarify it for me okay um because you said it early on about just Special Ed training in general and how that's lacking in the training for teachers right just with any teacher going through school true how much um knowledge do they have right in special and so if the onus is on the gened teacher to create these modifications that feels unfair M and um I believe you've recognized that and created the inclusion coach as someone a gened teacher
084can rely on um my concern is that we've got 91 schools and a lot of children sure Falling Up both sides of the belel Cur so um and then it goes back to how do we help you how do we help these teachers meet the needs of these individualized kids um meet their goals yeah and I would agree with you as I said we recognized and we would love to give more training but the problem is is on those District learning days when we have the opportunity schools have school plans they're working on goals they need time with teachers curriculum content people the social studies and science people and the English and the math people they want to pull everybody in and meet with them um and usually the special ed department is working with
085special ed teachers um so it's it it makes it difficult I mean time is a factor um there's just not a lot of great opportunity for experts in the area special education to train General Ed teachers and I'm absolutely not opposed to that but again that would would be a conversation Dr Wilson and I would need to have and and how do we how do we prioritize that um over you know making sure teachers are trained in presenting highly qual high quality instructional materials in their content um are the special ad teachers do this is going to somewhat show my ignorance so I'm just going to ask the question sure um I mean they are using the high quality content as well is correct and so are they being also utilized um in creating some
086of this modified content as resources obviously I understand the onus falls on the teacher sure and I would say that probably depends on the school and again going back to 91 schools everybody's staff differently their different programs their different services but yes a special education teacher in the building would work with can do that absolutely yes that they there are no hands tied there there's nothing that would hinder that their job is to make sure that we're meeting the needs of those children with IP in that school building okay yeah thank you Miss Christie thank you madam chair so my comments are short and relatively easy um I think I see where the disconnect is now with modified content but so I am thankful for this presentation um and um hopefully the Strategic plan can
087address some of these concerns as far as how we operate within the schools and and you know I'm very hopeful for that um I'm I'm a little curious as to how many IEPs we have because when you think about that that's a different plan for each child because they're all very different um so I appreciate the heavy lift that this is um and the work that has been done um again I think the Strategic plan might help guide some of that work but also just a shout out to you because we did have issues at one of my schools right before Christmas break and um you were there you personally came out like the next day or the the day after and I know the staff and principal everyone was very appreciative of that they
088felt heard um the problem wasn't easy to fix but they had a better understanding of um what needed to be done and the work that is being done so I am very appreciative of that and your team and this report well and M chrisy what I will say um to both of those things you know first and foremost I I mean I admitted here on record I'm not an expert in special education we have a director of special education who is that works for for me um I I would say that I'm an expert in kids because that's what I got into this job to do um and so I don't I don't care if the kid has an IEP if they don't have an IEP if they live in South Knoxville if they live
089in East Knoxville if they live in West Knoxville they're all our kids and they all deserve the ability to access their education uh on the modified content subject I will say I feel like the situation that you've probably been copied on emails and I've been copied on emails in your and your District um it seems to be going really well and I think the key to that is open communication uh it seems that the principal and the parent and the case manager and even our supervisors are all involved they're all in the team and that's the way it should work um and if it's not working like that in any of the schools that you all hear from please let me know I mean you all you all have my number you know how to
090email me um we want to know where it's not working well so that we can go and address that if communicate and I think the key to all that's communication they have an open line of communication and they're working together with that parent is it perfect probably not but they're working together and that's what this is about like in the end we all have the same goal the parent the teachers the principes the special Educators the general Educators we all want what's best for that child nobody got into education much less special education to mistreat a child or to not do what's best for them and to provide the best educational experience they possibly could good um and so I think you know what's happening right now in in your district is are glowing examples
091of of how it can work right that doesn't mean we're there everywhere like I said we've got 91 principles and 91 cultures you know and even in South Knoxville Bonnie Kate doesn't look like dogwood or South Knoxville or or new Hopewell they're all individual and they all have their own School culture and we rely on the leaders in those buildings so that that's if I could encourage anything it would be to have open communication and you don't have to be an expert in Special Ed but reach out to the people who are and they'll get you the supports and they'll find a way to make it work and if they don't explain it well enough reach out to somebody else and you know try to get the get the explanation that makes sense to you
092um so thank you m Morgan thank you for your presentation for all this information and for what you do I think I appreciate the passion that you have for kids and for seeing every kid as an individual and not checking a box of a diagnosis um that's really important to me and I'm glad that we have your perspective in that in this work I think that filters down into everything that we do and that's really important um I did want to brag on in the fall I sat down with um Mrs peram the principal at F Intermediate School and our sped students there had grown I wish wish had the numbers in front of me and I could be way off but tremendously in the data and from the year before and I asked her
093why what they did that did that and she said it was inclusion and it is um it's just it's exciting it's really great to see that and I our staff at at all of our schools all of my schools have been um they just do a fantastic job so I do want to brag on them um and then my um my one thing I would love to ask if we could reconsider um the mindset you you had said this to miss Henderson that you do think we are a model district for sped um as a parent of two students with IEPs uh and we've been doing this for I've been doing this for a long time now uh with my kiddos uh and from what I hear from other parents and from teachers in our
094district it feels like we have a disconnect um in general with maybe how families see it maybe how some of our teachers see it and maybe how it's been presented somewhat from what you said um while our staff is amazing my kids teachers are incredible I adore them I still as a parent of a special ed student would not say we're a model District uh first bed and I want us to be so badly so I would just love to ask if you would reconsider that perspective and maybe take that into the evaluation of what's going on because I do think we could do a lot better for our sped students 100% And and please don't I I did not mean that to sound like we've arrived by any stretch of the imagination I just
095we are a big District which means that we're under a big microscope um and so that also gives us the opportunity for a lot of variation from one school to the next and I think like I said there are places where we are really nailing it and there are places where honestly we probably aren't and I think that's the great thing about about you know the analysis that's being done is I think it's going to give us a really good 30,000 foot view of where we are and and the trends that they see in our district and some specific things that we can work on hopefully that includes trainings and other things that we will like I said we've tried to identify some of that on our own and provide some of those things in
096the interim to make sure we are moving in the right direction um you know no we're not perfect and and no I I did not mean that to say we're a model District like we're no we we've got room to do better but but we're doing good work and I and I'm like I know the people are doing their best um and that's why we want to have a third party to come in from the outside with fresh eyes to say hey I know this is what you've been doing here's some way you could do that better um and and we welcome that you know like Dr roswick said our goal is continuous Improvement we're going to continue to look at our practices and the things we're doing and see how we can get better
097each and every day yeah I love that and I'm so looking forward to the report from that and and I appreciate you guys diving into that and having a third party come in and look because I know from before I was on the board was when the resolution was passed and you all dove into this and um I appreciated the perspective of hey we have a lot of room to grow and and I think we still have a lot of room to grow so I just wanted to acknowledge that that we're eager to grow and excited for what's to come yeah absolutely and so again I I did not mean that to to sound like I've we've arrived or yes we are a model District um but I also know that historically like I said
098I our special ed teachers work really hard and I want to recognize that um and and I think I hope that they're all doing the best job that they think they can do um and that doesn't mean we can't get better um but I you know I I think sometimes those people who do the tough work sometimes feel like they're underneath it and just being beaten down all the time and so I I want to acknowledge that they are doing work and it is hard work um but they're doing the right work and but it doesn't mean we can't do the that work better Mr triplet Dr Brown thanks for presentation and sure putting yourself in the line of fire for a bunch of questions about a very Broad and difficult topic uh you talked
099about training bi-weekly administrative training staff training all that you also talked about some schools are doing it great some there's you know at times a measure of resistance to change that kind of thing um I guess my question is really around accountability you know um uh without accountability training really just becomes motion right just motion with no Rel action so what you know how are we holding people accountable to say all right you've been trained to do this I'm following following up to make sure you're falling through with what I've train that's a great great question a couple ways I mentioned that we're doing you know the the drop-ins and IEPs checking the cascs way making sure they're following that and then those supervisors are following back up with principles to to make sure do
100we see a pattern is it the same case manager is it a schoolwide problem you know so we can address that as needed uh I will also say one of the things that Dr Wilson I have thrown off to Dr Wilson several times but one thing that he has invited us so we meet my whole team goes and meets with the regional directors because they are the ones that hold principles accountable ultimately the principal is responsible for what happens in their school building and they answer to their Regional supervisors and directors we are kind of like the sidecar that provides support so the motorcycle doesn't fall over um but you know they're driving it and they're the wheel and steering it you know they're the they're the the the motorcycle itself so we uh we
101go to the regional director meetings periodically we share information we share trainings we give them things that they can look for excuse me um so there is a level of accountability and Dr Wilson has been great to open the doors and invite us in to make sure that we can follow up with what we are providing and what we are expecting from principles and schools in the world of special education good deal I I think that is you know as you talked to some of these that if experiences that are not up to the standard yeah that we sort of talk about and present in this room you know to me it seems like it's that aspect of accountability where some may not be following through with what you're presenting here if you present here
102sort of the ideal scenario of what we're trying to train people to do it doesn't always get translated all the way down to the classroom and that accountability piece I think is vitally important to ensure that that and students get what the needs I agree and I guess my thing is too because you know I do hear from parents that are frustrated and you know what do you need from us to make sure that all the kids all the families feel like they're being and all the teachers have the resources and you know supports that they need as well because I know it's a tough job um to make sure that we do become that model district and you know I know I sound like a broken record but you know we've we've been talking
103about this work um for two years which is 15% of a child's time with us you know it's a huge Chunk in their lives where two years in my life isn't that big of a deal but is in the life of a student sure and so you know I think that time is crucial um everyone on the board I know your staff has made it a priority so you know I would love to see fast changes um I look forward to the Strategic plan um and see what comes out of that and what recommendations or the recommendations are included in that so I look forward to that work as well y absolutely me too we're all excited yeah does anyone else have any questions all right well thank you so much thank you thank you
104Sophia you are next on the docket Sophia's going to do a presentation on free period uh products in the schools for us okay perfect hello everyone I hope you all have had an amazing break I'm presenting an update on the free per cre initiative that a and I started at the beginning of the school year unfortunately a cannot attend this meeting because she is returning home from visiting family over the holiday for those of you who don't who do not know what this initiative is I will give you a summary free period Knox is a student L initiative whose purpose is to make free period products easily accessible to every girl in high schools across Knox County in the in the bottom right of this slide you can see our logo I thought it was
105on CU he used it there you go there we go just takes a minute I'm thoroughly impressed by how well things have gone in the first semester of this program being implemented we have free period reps at 10 of the 15 Knox County high schools the schools represented are listed above these reps have truly carried out my vision in the schools by customizing it to fit each school's individual needs I would like to introduce Kaye Reid she is the representative of Central High School she will be talking about what it's like to be a free period rep hi so our main responsibility is to refill the baskets around our school with the free period products that we offer um and we kind of pertain it to our individual schools and what we need for each
106School along with that we communicate with sopia and ya in a group chat to give them updates on how things are going personally at Central I work with the nurse on the distributions around the school and unboxing everything that we receive so yeah these are pictures of our reps not all of the ones we have right now are pictured but these six subm photos for me to put in our slideshow so this is our poster this poster you might see in some of the photos that are about to come um I cre this idea the poster should be posted next to the baskets to help inform the Reps when a basket is running low it allows students to suggest improvements to our method of implementation and while we have only had 10 star reviews from
107this form we have also only had very few students interact with the QR code so that is something we are looking um to fix is interaction with our poster shown above are pictures the Reps have sent from their schools on how this is being implemented um like I said above some of the schools have made this project really unique to them Kaylee has made it very unique and she will talk about how Central has implemented this in their high school so in order to keep our period products from being misused we distribute them in a different way than a lot of the other schools are doing instead of putting them in the bathrooms around the school we keep them in various locations in the school and make students aware of those locations for example we
108keep them in our nurse's office and a lot of the female teachers in our schools have them when we run out I make sure to go around every couple one like weeks or so and make sure the teachers still have all the products that they need if they run out before I go and check they usually come find me or they go to the nurse and get them themselves um but yeah they make the female students aware that they have them in their rooms yeah I will say female teachers have been a very big driving force in this movement in informing all the students of the availability of this in our bathrooms and in our school so here are next steps our first goal is to fill the representative position at the remaining KCs high
109schools they are listed above um board members of these high schools if you could just set me up with someone to email or talk to um that would be amazing and our next goal is to figure out a way to collect data from the basket such as how much is being used how often it is used and how many students one baskets could service overall 2024 has been an amazing year for this project and I've been blessed to have the opportunity to work with it I cannot wait for what 2025 has to offer are there any questions Miss Templeton I beat you it was like a race well done well done way to take a project from idea to execution well done creating a plan finding people you found humans and how many high schools
110to do the things thank you and found and and they found teachers who were supportive and you are helping so many girls in the halls of those high schools and that is what is most important and well done to both of you and your entire team thank you for doing this um I did have a question though um I'm over here I tried to do the scan and I I think this is a different scan on here than the one you probably have but I'm curious how you are getting the word out at the high schools um to tell the ladies where to go to find products when they need them oh yeah that one doesn't work interesting um just word of mouth okay you oh it does work okay then user error it's on
111me yeah just Word of Mouth mainly but mainly Word of Mouth great then I'm really interested to hear um how many people are using them especially I would like to know that number myself we there's no real good way to count right but I do know that Halls has about 1300 students we have one basket in the upstairs freshman um Academy and Halls two levels and that's about it the basket is empty every week probably every week and there's about I think I fit 35 products Max in the basket so 35 a week not it's normally out in a week but not like I'm leaving it left out like Friday the last one's being taken so probably like 35 a week um the boxes that Knox County gets are full of 20 50 products uh
112we have not gone through an entire box but we went through I would say about 210 in a semester wow you're really meeting a need thank you and where where are they coming from where are the supplies coming from um Miss Wagner has ordered them for all Knox County high schools wow the nurses have them okay great well thank you thank you thank you both for doing this and um really uh just feeling a need thank you yeah correct me if I'm wrong uh someone on staff but there it is in the budget I believe that that the schools do receive these items which is yes so all the schools do receive them I think even middle schools as well they receive those Dr Brown thank you m chair yeah that that's me as well
113um other than Special Ed I also have all student Ser supports and uh help services and yes Miss as Sophia shared Miss Wagner does have that in her budget she does provide those um and as they need more her nurses put those orders in just like they would for Band-Aids or anything else and we s send those out of the schools yeah awesome thank you Miss bike thank you um yeah I think this is really awesome that this is I'm I think it's so cool that it's student Le and that the students are taking some responsibility in this and really getting involved honestly this is like a huge um demonstration of your leadership and I really appreciate that I think it's it's so cool to see you know the future generation taking hold of something
114and really going with it um and I'm curious kind of um what you need from us to keep going I know that you you listed the high schools that you need contacts with but are there other things that you all need to continue to be successful it's okay if you don't have answers right now but even if you want to think about it and maybe give us a report on what you need yeah um there's nothing I could think of right now and I would probably like to talk to a who's gone before I answer that question so yeah cool and I I'd love to hear at the end of the school year kind of like a how the school year went and everything that happen trials tribulations and then you know if you did
115find a way to kind of start tracking these and and other ways like um you know do you need uh supplies for Flyers to pass out or just anything like that um I think you know feel free to let us know and then I was also curious if I could ask if you wanted to share about any misuse issues I can as I say I would ask Kaye about that uh so our nurse we had originally had some in our bathrooms but they were running out in such a fast time that it seemed like they were just being taken and not like used so it was like we'd put a basket out that was completely full and it'd be empty the next day so we were just running out of products so fast and we've
116also had some issues like um students sticking certain products to the walls and ceilings of our B bathrooms which is not the point sobly perfect I love children yeah at Halls there's only been one one abuse so that's great um yeah I'd love to know you know if when you talk to the other student reps and at the end of the year kind of like what they've seen if they've seen any misuse and then you know I hope that you uh pass this on and that it continues next year and kind of see you know what happens there too from talking with the other reps um Central is the only place that's had problems so it's been really good and everyone that I've talked to in the bathrooms just in passing they've really appreciate everything
117and they're always like oh the board is just so nice for putting this in there and I'm like yeah they really are I think it's okay for you all to take the ownership of it and say that it's something that you're doing yeah thank you for sure Mr triplet great job um couple things one I just sent your representative from pal so you know Loop me in on the email and if they say no I'll I'll I'll put some pressure on but um and then the second thing is to follow with K I would find find a junior you know I don't know if all the reps are seniors or what but find a junior to kind of go ahead and start now taking on the project and then you can pass it on to
118somebody else and kind of perpetuate that beyond beyond the end of your senior year something MH yeah um currently right now we're partnering with the hostes of all the schools that have it and I would in in my personal opinion I'd like to work this project into the 865m the ones that have the medical um life sciences I feel like this goes right underneath that and that being a way that they can um serve and get an idea of something that they could be doing to help people I like to see that implemented sometime that's awesome Miss Christie thank you and thank you ladies I just want to brag on Sophia a little bit because I know that she would not get up there and say this but when we we talk about leadership now
119correct me if I'm wrong Sophia but I believe people from other parts other school districts in other areas have reached out to you about this project and how to um start a similar project in in their schools is that that correct yes and I know you have helped work with them as well so so thank you for that um obviously your reach is going far beyond n County Schools um so I'm I'm just really proud of you and in this initiative and your your leadership thank you else anyone else good job girls good job you should be proud of yourselves thank you thank you that work awesome thanks do we want to take a break y'all before we go into the yeah okay I was hoping other people did why don't we come back here
120at 6:40 it's currently 6:32 does that sound good all right e e e back hope everyone had a great break we will now go into our regular session agenda starting with item c one or two actually Dr Adams can you please uh kind of talk about the alternative Bell time analysis I know there was a blurb in it about in our uh board update but can you kind of go over that a little bit what that would entail certain certainly uh Madam share members of the board um so the btime analysis is basically we we look at this for several reasons one reason in particular is you look at the cost in living increase we have with our contractors uh being competitive in the market uh so it really identifies areas where we could have
121additional buses and save money and be able to keep up with our competitors it also gives an opportunity for the board to look at how it affects the district logistically um if it provides more transportation for students uh give students uh more opportunities to to Access Transportation so it it's it's a really good uh data study uh for you all to look at uh with all of our departments in the Operations Division uh we really challenged our executive directors to look at more efficient and effective operations and this is just one example of how Ryan and his team were doing that I'm really excited about this and I always appreciate your out of the box thinking on how to you know be creative U come Creative Solutions could this be used to help alleviate or
122eliminate a prz zone that is something that may be identified in the study I don't want to speak to the study um prior to them sharing that data with us but that is something that could definitely probably come out of that okay I would like I'm interested because I would like to see that so that way all students have access to buses so I'm excited about this study thank you so much for for giving a highlight absolutely thank you yes Miss F Ridley thank you um I had a couple of questions I was talking with my sister over the holidays and she lives up in Louisville and they did a study and totally revamped their busting system and it was a nightmare on the first day of school the last student got home at 10
123p.m. so there is a lot I don't know if it was because of the way they implemented it or what I think AI had a lot to do with it and the bus drivers were not on their regular routes and they couldn't use GPS so they were getting lost All Over Louisville so I'm hoping that we um take into account other systems possibly that have done this and kind of get some feedback from them because it sounds like a really great idea just want to make sure that we're heads up from the get-go so thank thank you Miss F really and what I will tell you is knoxx County school is very unique where we have over 50 contractors and I've been in large districts where we've had one contractor and when you do have
124one contractor it is very problematic uh because you have one uh contractor who has all of the routes um and when you look at multiple contractors that can divide up the routes it it makes those areas within your District a little easier um to to do a study on uh so uh we we certainly have reached out to other districts prior to even um looking at this study and and the we've got a pretty overwhelming response of of a positive response from those districts thank you thank you Dr Adams all right moving on item c three or four yep oh yeah Miss bike thank you um I for both um I just want to disclose for number three um that if that is the one that I think it is um I am both friends
125and have worked with them um but I think that I can vote on this um unbiasedly so I don't think that's going to be an issue but if I need to not that is okay too um and then uh number four I am so excited to see this on our agenda I know the alots PTO has been waiting for this for a long time and I am so excited to see it happen awesome I'm excited for them they work very hard Miss Templeton yeah I need to disclose as well that um I have worked with fork design and other in previous lives um and responsibilities with the maker City so just wanted to let you know okay thank you full disclosure okay I think Am I Wrong Mr dupler that they can vote on it
126because they are not benefiting financially is that correct yes that that was going to be thank you madam chair that was going to be one of my questions I mean do you all have a financial stake in Fork design at this point and if the yeah if the answer is no then and and I think you've both indicated that you feel like you can be unbiased then um then you've made your disclosure and you can move forward yeah I appreciate y'all bringing that up though thank you for that all right item five or six seven or eight or nine all right moving on then to board policies A or B C or D or E okay grants A or B C or D or E all right moving on then to regular agenda items A
127or B I would like to say for item a on the superintendent's um evaluation thank you for working so hard on your personal um or individual um evaluations I know it takes a lot of time and they were all very thoughtful and then is how I craft my memo is just taking all of that information from the individual um evaluation so thank you so much for putting the time into that okay C or D Mr triplet yeah I know Mr Diggs is here and I know he brought a whole crew of folks uh from Emerald Academy and they have sat through a very long meeting uh just to represent uh the school if if you're with Emerald academy uh just stand up for a moment that'd be great and uh appreciate you all coming and
128supporting your school and I know this is some parents and students and I think maybe some alumni Mr Diggs do you have anything to say and in support anything at all you're good good very good appreciate yall coming I just Echo that thank you for coming out tonight I know tonight was not a short meeting so thank you so much for uh supporting your school and your community um I know that Emerald Academy does amazing positive things for their students M Morgan thank you I I just wanted to Echo what you all said I'm so glad to see you guys here thank you for all the work that you do in our community and uh it was an absolute pleasure to get to visit the school and see the scholars last month and uh learn
129more about what Emerald does and I'm so thankful for the the work and all the students the scholars that you are helping in our community Miss Spike um did you say d and e yes yes um so oh wait no I think we were at D but we can talk about e too that's fine sorry are we done with C or c and d d c and d sorry I just also wanted to thank before we move on the Review Committee for their thorough work as well thank you so much all right moving on then to e thank you um this the next year's school calendar um I just want to thank um Corey and her team and everyone Keith that have done that constantly do the hard work of putting this together and your
130teams and working on the school calendar I know a lot of times people think that you know it's just maybe one or two people that are deciding this um and then not considering things um I also want to thank everyone for their feedback and contacting the board um I think that this is one of the reasons this this has happened I think this kind of came a little bit out of us looking at um the early release days and changing that and we did say that we would come back in January and look at this and you know it's been really great to talk to Keith about our calendar and really dig into how the calendar is made and you know all the decision and options that we have um I really like option D
131it seems like a lot of families and teachers also like option D I appreciate that you know uh potentially our kids and teachers wouldn't have to um do a half day before Christmas on a Monday um and then I also had one of my principles reach out today and say that you know her staff um really had appreciated having previously having you know a full two weeks um on a winter break before so that they can be refreshed and spend time with their families or just doing whatever they need to do to recharge to get back into the hard work of working with kids every single day um and so I I understand that option D doesn't change the um the coming back to spring semester on um and you know at the end of
132a week and kind of missing that extra weekend and I know that a lot of teachers will potentially take that day off um and then also wanted to ask if Keith had anything to say in regards to the calendar thank you Miss B and and I had an opportunity to talk to you for a moment this afternoon um you know the uh I will say just kind of in bringing this back we this was a discussion actually that got lifted up last April I believe um with some questions really around this same issue um and so this was actually an option that we went back and developed at that time and I shared with the board as you know potential if we wanted to bring it back up for for consideration so we're bringing this
133back at this point um and you know the the really the change that is significant and maybe different than what people I think are used to um is that we have tried to uh squeeze all that we are required to do uh in between that August 1st being the first day back for teachers um and then obviously the Memorial Day uh trying trying to get our last day for our teachers to be before that Memorial Day holiday um and some years are easier to do that than others and this was a particularly difficult year because uh with Memorial Day falling on that last Monday of the month of May um it's very early in the month uh comparatively if you look forward uh as we think about planning for the 2627 calendar which will be
134doing this spring um we're going to have four I think five more days to work with so um because it's like Monday the 30th or 31st that it falls on so that gives us a a little more wiggle room to do things like think about that holiday break and the comeback time and so um you know obviously we're always trying to account for a good solid break and good good timelines you know dividing lines for uh grading periods are another thing that were really challenging in this in this calendar um and so those are all things we have to consider and kind of deal with the the calendar that we have and so uh the the uh the change as I mentioned was that one of actually bring teach back on July 31st but it
135backs that day up allowing our students to end on a Friday rather than having that half day Monday and extending that break by a day for each uh each of our teacher and our staff group or staff and our student group I'm sorry yeah yeah thank you so much um for that option and I'll definitely be voting to move to option D thank you Miss funner Ridley I'm going to put my teacher hat on I um appreciate everything that you all did I have been on a team that has worked with schedules within our school it is not an easy thing um and you all are yall are awesome um also I want to thank cat for bringing it to the discussion um as a teacher it is difficult to teach a half day on
136the 22nd I'm just saying close to Christmas and then if even if you're not going anywhere getting Christmas together because from Thanksgiving to Christmas it's crazy and you don't have time to do anything so um I really appreciate you all doing this hard hard work to get it figured out thank you thank you Miss Morgan okay I just wanted to highlight what Dr Wilson said because I some one of the things that I was hearing from people is that that the schedule was you know not paid attention to or it wasn't n really looked at carefully and haphazardly done and that's not at all the case and you did bring it back up for consideration so I just want everyone to know that there is a lot of thought that does go into the schedule
137and um a lot of reasons behind it and I appreciate you being willing to discuss it again uh for however many times it is um also I would like to throw a curveball in we don't have to discuss it tonight I know we're um all probably pretty tired um um but I'm having a hard time focusing on one part of the schedule without having discussed the early release days and so I would love to either um have an idea on that for Thursday or I don't know if it's possible to PT this to the ne to next month's meeting and we discuss ity yeah the the only thing I would add to that I think our our commitment last year when we talked about the changes to the early releas is that we would do
138some additional surveying uh in the spring uh we actually talked at the end of the December meeting with Miss B about kind of that process and starting to do that and and thinking about kind of how we continue to gather input from our our principes our teachers our families around those early release days to your point if you look at the calendar um that has been adopted by the board for the 2526 school year it still reflects those early release days in the previous model that we did which was those six days at 2 hours early release a piece not the full not the half day that we moved to this year so that will be something that we'll have to consider because we are on a different model this year now than we are
139what we had to originally put into that calendar so it will have to come back in terms of looking at the early release and all that but we had we had said we would do that based on additional feedback having been collected and we haven't done that yet okay perfect so we will discuss that just in the future yes okay great thank you guys miss bike um you bring up a really great point and it makes me think um if we are um changing the calendar for next year is it too much of an issue to change it twice or is it not that big of a deal or so I will say I mean we do make an adjustment to that calendar uh and report that to the state in terms of which days
140and and different things like that so it would be an adjustment that we would report up to them I don't think that's a big lift to do that um it would be two pieces of action for guy resus he might not be happy that I'm asking him to do it twice um but uh he's usually pretty guy I think he'd be all right so I think we really and truly could do it either way it's it's at the board's discretion in terms of how how they would want to do that okay um then I guess to um ping off of Miss Morgan is is it possible to for Thursday or if we have any questions um to bring up kind of what you might include in some of that surveying I know I talked to
141Miss lner about kind of how you did the surveying last time and how you might modify that next time I'm not going to speak for Miss lner's workload between now and Thursday in terms of what that would entail so turn that over to you yeah Miss ler you're not doing anything are you at all I am now no um that that won't be difficult at all we can at least bring kind of the battery of questions and the methodology changes that we want to make I think there's a way we can get you slightly richer information than we were able to on the turnaround time last year okay cool thank you awesome I really do appreciate this being brought up in this discussion I heard from a lot of folks as well um so I'm
142excited for option D all right no more discussion on that one let's move on to F or G I think Mr triplet um do we want to talk about the legislative priorities I believe you had some uh couple things about legislative priorities these are the things that when you speak to a legislator you can say the Knox County school board as a whole agrees on right you can talk to your legislator about whatever you'd like to personally that you feel even if it's not a a legislative priority from the board but this is what we go into like a meeting and say all right the Knox County Schools this is what we' like to see done um so uh as we go through some of these I figur we'll just go through the 20 24
143list and yeah I figure because you know the past couple years I really appreciate what the board has done in the fact that we use this more of a work as a working document versus just passing the same thing every single year um so some things have gotten done and we have taken them off some things that you know have not gotten done and we put them on and so I do really appreciate the thought that has been put into this document every year so I think you know if we go through each category and if people have questions or discussion do we want to leave it do we want to take it off you know we can have have a thoughtful discussion around around each one so to begin local control that's been on
144there for a while I think has been a priority yeah and then who's who's up sh yeah Miss B oh um I mean of course I really like local control I I think that when I've seen Knox County be able to really do things and have the autonomy to do them that we do so well in that you know I think that looking at like third grade retention some of the things that we were able to do and um you know still work with legislators still work with what they wanted and um but still you know serve students and accomplish goals without putting more barriers in place I think we could improve a little bit more on that but not just that but um so many other things um so I I would love to
145see some element of local control still there because I think that that's important yeah I would actually like to I I think the academic retention decisions is a very specific version of local control and I feel like the term local control to a legislator we're not asking them to do anything you know we don't want them like we we passed those third and fourth grade all those laws this is something we want them to change and do for me the local control seem this that that paragraph seems too General so I would like to remove that and maybe local control on academic and retention decisions I don't know in my mind I look at these and I I feel like some of them are a little bit too general you know just for them to
146take into a meeting and go here's what Knox count schools wants to change about what we do it's sort of a general topic I would prefer them to be more specific in my in my opinion yeah I mean I I definitely understand what you're saying with that and I agree because you know things can get just get lost in the wording but what I do really like about this local control one is kind of like the last line that realistically that kind of encompasses everything that we're asking for and doing in the um you know to determine the full impact of leas before acting on proposed legislations regulations and guidelines to just really keep that in mind because I think sometimes um you know they have a lot of work to do and I think
147that sometimes that they forget that you know we have a lot of um educated professionals that are are also doing really hard work so if we could figure out some sort of way you know it doesn't have to be in a local control but just to have that line in there in something um I would appreciate that Miss bner Ridley um I've firsthand seen the impact of this third and fourth grade retention law and I do think it needs to be specific and it needs to be separate because um when you've got students in the third grade taking a test on the last half day of school to see if they can go to fourth grade that is um unexcusable um and I think that we need to specifically make a statement about the retention
148decisions because they are so um so important and the teachers are the best people to know the administrators the parents um are the best people to know whether their child needs to be retained or moved forward thanks Miss Templeton yeah um I I think there's a way to I I agree the reason my light went on was um to be to create a collaborative um kind of communications MH um to be accessible to our legislators and um not only as a board but also as the body that has direct communication with the people doing the work and doing the hard work um so as they make um decisions um that involve health care that involve education that involve all of these these different buckets um they have a resource um in US and making sure
149that they know that they have a resource in us and I do think that that becomes a priority um on our end to say we're here to be a resource for you um so that you can pick up the phone and we can have a conversation um and if we don't know the answer we can find it right um we could certainly um reach out um to get answers from the people who voted for them right um so I'm not hung up on having local control being a the header being local control um but I do think saying somewhere in there we urge them to seek import input from local boards I think that's important terminology right I will keep moving on through the document um is this the best way I'm I'm just trying
150to have like a very collaborative conversation on all of these yeah the challenge is how you GNA turn this into an actual working document by Thursday I mean you know we asked for Miss Cy asked for options I don't think anybody sent an email yeah except for myself so like we all really needed these in already written form so we could insert them or not insert them discuss them pull them out yeah and make changes so um you I don't know how we make that we can go one by one but it's almost like I don't know how we convert that to a document in this this setting yeah that's what's hard Miss Templeton I don't have an answer for that um but I do I'm fine leaving it the way it is too I
151just want to make sure that it's in there somewhere yeah because it's in there we can leave leave it yeah yeah yeah question about uh process okay yeah oh I'm sorry Reverend Butler question about process proc so um for example I don't have a problem with local control I do have a problem with the word control but uh but local input or but control works for me too but I don't have a problem with not using that uh but the the process question I have is is that uh and Mr tripler you use the board as a whole so the board as a whole uh may not have a consensus or and so does that mean that that does not go on on our priorities or is it majority rule or how does that work
152and let me just say what my what I prefer is that we have as a board we have a consensus because I may feel strongly about local control and five Others May do too but if you don't feel I don't think the board as a whole felt that way so I think that that's one of the questions I have is how do we decide if something goes on or not Min understand we have not always had a 100% you know unanimous opinion so we we have voted on individual ones in the past though right where we just went each one and took a vote on it yeah instead of as the document as a whole we have done that to put things on or off or leave it yeah so how are we doing it
153this time my my goal was to if we get some consensus and we have you know five or six of these that be agrees on and if there's something that people don't agree on it's fine you know then we vote on those individually which is what we've done in the past I like I don't mind leaving local control I just don't think it's Val a valuable paragraph Just because I don't think it's specific but if we want to leave it on there I'm not against leaving on there so I say we'll leave that one and move to the next one unless somebody's adamant about removing yeah so we can vote on each one on Thursday Miss bike um I just want to say I must have misread Miss coty's email um I thought when I
154saw this that I was looking at it to see oh is there anything I want to change and I really like our 2024 legislative priorities so that was my mistake and just thinking like yeah this one seems fine um and that's why I didn't send anything in because I like this one um my mistake well it was my mistake along with yours because I thought that this was that's what we were going to do is this was 2024 was it anything that we need to take out or put on and I thought all of these were still still something that we want to do and they they I mean they could be for sure I mean they could stay the same for this year it's just you know how depending how we vote on it
155but it could like totally just be this document again miss cotney was just getting suggestions if somebody wanted to add something that was important to them or they felt was important to the board um and then I thought we could go through all of these um I think Steve has some that he wants to kind of go over um but that's kind of how we it's hard in this setting to go over and come up with a document um but they absolutely could look like this again come Thursday so uh trying to be kind but looking at the 24 I like I like what we have there um and I'm looking at what Mr triplet has given us funding on special education preschool is new uh the the ability to conduct conduct lotteries is it's
156already on there so the other two increased child funding facility and support school choice those two those two are are new also so there three new ones so I see we we'd have to discuss those uh if if no one has a problem with the ones on 2024 and we would to move those forward then it'll be discussing those three Miss font Ridley um are we kind of jumping around I I think so okay I feel like you know it seems like people are pretty much on the same page with these so there was open conversation and I'm still on a learning curve so I get that there was I wasn't really confused I just didn't read this as closely as I should have on the teacher evaluation is the use of benchmark assessments as
157a an evaluation component state law or is that something we do locally miss himor Madam chair Miss font o Ridley as as I understand that the legislative priori is encourage encouraging the um General Assembly to broaden what can be used um as evaluation components so in addition to what what we opening it up to benchmark assessments other than I I believe am web is allowed now but opening up to um other benchmark assessments so at this point it's not a state law so what you're saying at at this point we can only allow options that state law prescribes okay yes okay because I um as a physical educator I didn't have benchmark assessments to do my evaluation I had to take the school scores and so I just don't know if benchmark assessments are fair
158to all teachers um even Jed teachers who get a student in with two weeks before the test is taken and they're counted by how that student does when they have nothing to do with the previous learning of that student and they could they could blow the scores through the roof or they could bottom the scores out so I think we need to make sure that when we evaluate the teachers that we are as Fair as we can be with how that assessment is done that's it thank you Miss bike no thank you um I guess going back to the 2024 you know I know it was mentioned that you know this is something we asked for last year and then moving forward um and I'm looking at it and thinking about you know were any
159of these achieved so you know because I know with like third grade retention that moved into a fourth grade thing and then you know some things were pulled back and is something to talk about and for us to discuss were any of these achieved in in these is there anyone on the board that feels like some of these were achieved and could roll off you know because I do think we try to have a one pager that is digestible and so if we're looking at or adding anything to this you know I think that there's a conflict there um or combining any of these you know like I guess I was looking at when we were going through talking I was thinking we were talking individual ones and I would make comments on individual but
160if we're going to kind of you know talk about all of it is there a way to combine some of these if we are going to fit other things in you know um I appreciate that local control is separate from academic retention and decisions but retention decisions but you know do we put that in there or is that I mean that is kind of a theme of like you know the teacher of evaluation and and all of this stuff [Music] um review and correct unnecessary requirements I mean that's that also you know there there's definitely a theme here um just thinking out loud if anyone has any ideas on combining some of this or whether we think that some of this was achieved I would argue that they're too General to to achieve like I
161and that that's been kind of my argument in the beginning but like the Tisa funding I think is pretty General but the last line talks about funding for preschool well they are specifically looking at funding I mean that's a that's a big one that they're being being pushed so I would like to take the priority I listed there funding for I would like to replace the that one with funding for it I mean that is falls under the category of Tisa funding but it's also a very specific goal that we want to see them achieve not just in general you know fund us for growth is kind of what it says now but I don't know that it I don't know that it gives something specific and I think the review and correct unnecessary requirements
162would be better suited if we went through and said all right here are some unnecessary requirements that we feel like need to be removed this is a goal I I think that some of these are so General that I don't know that we'll be able to have they'll never be removed because I don't know that they're specific enough yeah you ability to conduct lotteries would could be removed if that if that passes I think there's some potential that'll pass this round yeah I mean I I definitely agree with um some of what you said I definitely see that the funding for special education um preschools but um the only thing I would argue there is that um to do all prek just to fund prek um not just special education um prek but I don't
163know if there's some with that but I definitely think that um that could replace the Tisa slf funding and that the review andc correct um could either you know be moved into a a general statement like you know a lot of these things have kind of a a vision statement at the beginning um and that could go with kind of teacher evaluations reviewing correct unnecessary requirements and local control retention decisions kind of all these are good but somebody's got to rewrite all these make that's the problem you know so I I don't I don't know how we you know we're supposed to have this done by that meeting but like I would what I would say now like if we had the time I would say all right that's a great idea go back and
164write like a an open vision statement that covers all three of those or if you want to change something about the teacher valuation come back with that and then we can modify it's hard to write it from here yeah so I'm not sure that we will actually accomplish this in this meeting I know that's yeah you know yeah I mean I see that and um I get that I think that you know in previous years we've definitely seen where you know we've on Thursday or previous to Thursday have shown up with multiple versions and things like that I wouldn't mind trying to mish mash up something and if people liked it you vote for part of it I don't care you know right Reverend Butler thank you so um I've heard Mr triplet said for
165a second time and so I'm leaning in the direction that local control and uh and review and correct unnecessary requirements may be too general or vague and so we may want to take them out or be specific in saying what local control we want to have and what uh correction we might want to make and since we don't have time for that between now and Thursday we might want to eliminate those and so I offer that as a suggestion and then I offer a suggestion on funding for special education preschool students that it be funding for uh funding for all preschool students uh I don't know we want to put it specially special education or not uh but um but I think that that would be an area that would be an area that we
166would we we might want to see something about preschool funding in in place of Tissa and I'd offer those those two that that suggestion as well I know tsba has that on the preschool funding as a header there's a special ed too right yes and I think the reason is we're required to serve them but we're we're not given any funds traditional preschool I think there's some Grand options we have for for that so that's the reason for just specifically requesting special ed funding so funding for special education preschool students could go where Tissa funding is that would be a suggestion I and what I'm trying to do is move this alone so I would I support you I would suggest that I do support that as well so if we had that I think
167we need to leave academic retion decision there teacher evaluation there uh strengthen and support School Personnel I'm not sure um if that was fixed it is specific so it isic and in ability to conduct lotteries although it's may be may pass it still is something that's on the agenda so I think we need to leave that there so um I would not want increased child facility funding on there and I would not want support of school choice across District in District Char or private on there so I would disagree with those two but other things I've suggested I'll support okay Miss ky's trying to take all these notes so I I want to give like a little bit let's let's rewind a little bit because like Miss Miss bike said in the past what we've
168had is multiple suggestions or multiple copies from different board members um and we didn't really this time except for Mr triplets uh so what Miss cotney is going to do is take these notes work with either Steve or myself to then come up with a new document um a collaborative document here and we will then vote on that and then what we will do is vote on the the um like the ones that Steve has brought as individual ones does that make sense because at the end of the day we have to have a document to actually vote on so that's what we're trying to come up with take all these suggestions Madam chair I like I like that idea okay uh but uh I'm move very much to be candid and if there is
169a five4 vote I don't think that's the whole I think it has to be more than a 5-4 vote if it's a 54 vote it's not the whole board and I know that there are some fundamental differences that we may have with with anybody I don't think I agree with everybody 100% of the time I know that's true because I don't agree with myself 100% of the time but so I'm not saying I'm right anybody else is wrong I'm just simply saying if I felt positive about something going forward and we had a fire for a vote I would say it wasn't the whole board just because if we're going to say it's Knox County Board it should be Knox County board at least the majority of the bo a a Superior part of the
170board so that's that's just my feeling on it that if we vote it has to be more than Justus AI for Miss F Ridley thank you um I have a couple of different ones and I wanted to make sure that Miss cotney was able to get the notes um as far as local control I think that that is an important one um at this point the state is trying to take control away from us in a lot of different ways like with um uh charter schools and uh vouchers you know if we if we choose to not um approve a charter school it doesn't matter because they'll just take it to the state and the state will take it over so I think we need to keep as much local control as we can and
171um as far as it being a general statement um it's kind of like a teacher in a classroom um they're the best equipped and informed to make decisions concerning their classroom we are the heartbeat of this County every district and we need to make sure that we dig in our heels and make sure that the decisions are not being taken away from us for anything and then um the part on the suggestions that Steve that I'm sorry that Mr triplet made um about the school choice across the district um I am and just to be candid am diametrically opposed to any any kind of um school choice and Charter and private um schools so I I just feel like that's a slippery slope and it's going to cause um a lot of dissent among not
172just board members but our constituents so respectfully thank you Miss bike thank you um I agree with Miss Fontano Ridley on really all that she said and also Reverend Butler and you know um when I'm when I'm looking at what Mr triplet has suggested you know I do appreciate the special education preschool students funding um the ability to conduct lotteries I think think that that is huge um for our schools um because certainly we know they need money um and more money to pay for things and I think that that almost goes against the um Charter facility funding and the support of school choice um because the reason why our schools need more funding is that it's constantly being pulled away from them and that's left up to our PTO and our foundations to fill
173those gaps of the money that we don't have um and so I think that those are a little regressive um I definitely like it was something I ran on and representing District 4 I could never vote in favor of these and support these and I would have a really hard time because I know that you know I want to support the will of the board and if this is the will of the board that's going to be a huge Conflict for me um you know because I especially see um line two in the body of the support school choice across the district in District Charter and private um where it says prioritize Equitable access to high quality education I you know Knox County Schools is high quality education some people may not feel that way
174and some people are struggling but when we talk about being a model district and striving to be a model District I think we have to continue going for that and not looking for Community Partners to educate our children in a job that we're supposed to be doing um and so you know and I know that we have struggles with socioeconomic status but we have talked about this in children who you know have barriers with a socioeconomic status and their ability to get to a private school their ability to acclimate to a private school or even a charter school for that matter because you have to have parents that sign you up you have to have parents that are involved you have to be able to pay the fees you have to have the uniforms you
175have to have the clean clothes you have to have the no Behavior aval issues you have to have um you know not as many um student supports needs as other children and then you're kind of in this Echo chamber and if you get into that Echo chamber you have to acclimate and that is really hard to ask an eight nine 10 year-old to do especially on their own so if they are doing it successfully it's because they have parents involved or they have adults involved that help them get there and I think that one of the ways that we have been successful was um I think it's um was it Big Brothers Big Sisters that's doing the um what what is that called yeah the mentoring it was so cool to go to that and
176see and I think that that is one way that we are succeeding as a school district and inviting them into our schools to Mentor them hearing hearing them and those types of programs that's that's the direction that I want to go towards not necessarily relinquishing it to other places that may not be as successful as we are thank you Miss F Ridley thank you um I agree with Miss bike um we are I mean I'm a product of this school system I feel like I'm pretty pretty did a pretty good job um and like Miss bike said the financial responsibility above the the voucher so to speak would be practically impossible for the Target students that they are trying to focus on in the first part the the roll out um I've taught students in
177schools that have struggled and I've also had students who have gotten scholarships to private schools and I applaud them because they work their tails off to get there and um I'm concerned that supporting U things such as vouchers it and going back to the tsba conference I got the feeling that we were in the vast minority as far as supporting vouchers I felt like a lot of the school systems in the state and it showed through the resolutions that um we need to protect our public education we need to protect our schools and we need to protect um the teachers and the students and everything about it that's why we were elected for public schools and to support private schools with our funding is um is in opposition to that to in my opinion so
178um like uh Reverend Butler said the important things that we've had this this um school year so far that there's been contention on is always going has always gone five to four five to four five to four so it automatically you know it we could we could talk ourselves blue in the face um and talk about these priorities when if it's going to going to be the same vote we're wasting our breath so I'm I agree with Reverend Butler I think we need to have a threshold to actually come to agreement on some of these or all of these so um I don't know if there's any way to do that by Thursday but um it we would be remiss if we didn't try so thank you Mr triplet yeah I won't spend a much
179time arguing obviously I wrote the the priority so in my opinion it's pretty well stated there so there's no need to really argue that much other than to say I think that if we think that our this institution is going to be the answer for every student in Knox County I think I think that that's that's an unfair ask actually of Knox County Schools from a from a space in a classroom standpoint to a need of a student so I I do very much feel like it is essential for us to be able to partner with other people to help and assistance way I think Emerald Emerald Academy is one of those places and I'm sure there are others as well um and there are opportunities to help certain students that that is the better
180fit for I think that by and large we are the answer for most of Knox County but probably not all of Knox County and I do think these provide some opportunities for those that will find a better fit somewhere else um not the lack of our own effort I think but uh just because it's a better fit somewhere else and I think that's the case sometimes um to the I know the the pressure to to have a greater number of you know a larger percentage of the vote I don't even know how you would do that um Mr dup there is no we would just have to pass some policy or I don't even know how that would work based on Robert's Rules it's it's it's majority rule right majority rules I is that the
181way that works yeah thank you madam chair so I mean it's not just Robert's Rules it's state law St law says that uh the the Board of Education speaks through its members and a majority vote wins so whatever the majority is that's what can be passed now with that said I can tell you historically when it comes to legislative priorities uh there have been discussions in the past among board members that hey this should be unanimous or this should be you know a super majority or what have you but again legally uh majority rules Miss Christie well not to sound like a poly Anna here but let's face it this legislative priorities are a political exercise they always have been and you know honestly I think most of our state people have ran on a
182platform of either supporting school choice or not as well as many of these other things and I seriously doubt anything that we would put in here is going to change their minds if they have ran on that platform um I mean I get everybody's frustrations but I mean just just the title of the document it's legislative priorities I mean there will be a political divide there I mean that it's unfortunate that's just you know and I and I and I respect every body's feelings on that I just feel like when we talk around It ultimately I mean we could have this discussion all night but I don't know that it's going to change the outcome yeah I agree with that that's why at the end of the day we have you know we speak by
183votes and we uphold whatever majority vote that is madam chairman yes so um I'm not sure it was last year or the year before but when we had such a divide we just decided we wouldn't put that on there because it wasn't a Knox County Board decision but I hear loud and clear what the legal process is and so if that's what the majority feels like they want to do they do uh and I say they because you know I'm generally not part of the majority but one of things I would say is this is that if we're going to call that Knox County Board of Education legislative priorities and we're going to say this is what the whole board feels then we're not telling the truth so I would I would just uh I
184would just uh say that honestly either way side I felt on I would want it to be uh a Knox County Board this is what the board as a whole feels like these are the things we can send forward uh those things that we don't feel like we can see send forward as a whole you can talk with your legislators individually and uh I agree with uh Miss Christie is that uh that we uh have uh we we let them know what our priorities are as a whole but may not make a difference at the end of the day and how they vote I mean that's realistic so so we we've used a lot of time to share and and I and I respect uh you know Mr triplet and I don't agree on this
185issue but I respect him for his his his opinion his his reasoning and his reasoning does make sense from his perspective and so I respect him for that I'm not I'm not saying that I'm right and he's wrong I'm just simply saying we disagree and so if if we disagree we shouldn't say this is our legislative PR priorities this is It's only ours if we all are sending it forward as a body that's from my perspective I'm not asking anybody else to agree with me that's my perspective thank you Reverend Butler Miss fer Ridley thank you um and I'm and I'm going to be even more brief than Mr triplet and I respect everybody's um opin opions on things that's why that's the only way that we are going to be able to do anything
186is if we can talk to each other and share ideas um you talk about parents having an a choice or an opportunity they've always had a choice in where they send their students and again for us as public school funded entity if we give money to people to go to private school it's it's it's just it's the Parents Choice true but we should not be funding that choice so that's just not opinion of course Miss Templeton yeah I think that um every month we're going to agree and we're going to disagree on a Litany of things um that's how this is just is going to go um and it's not always going to be 54 and sometimes it's going to be a jumbled up 54 um it's not I don't think that um you after
187talking to each one of you just in passing over time I don't think anybody wants to see a politically divided board um I think this document more than any other says the board says this the entire it represents us as individuals um and because it is coming from one entity to another entity and for that reason I think we do need to agree we need to agree on each one of these things and um I think I I I very much agree with Mr triplet saying hey these need to be specific actionable items the same way that um you any organization decides whether or not they are effective or not we have to have you um actionable items to go back on to say last year was this effective was it not what do we
188me to do to change um so if we're going to speak to our legislators on specific items um I think it's very helpful to have that um have actual items underneath each one um but in the same vein the items that are under there need to reflect the entire body in this situation um I think it's Unique um and quite frankly it is at the discretion of those who disagree with me fundamentally to say you know you're right let's let's include the ones I think that's at the discretion of the board of how we're going to handle that um so that is my request that that we can include the items in the legislative um priorities that everybody supports because it reflects every single one of us um I think everybody knows where I stand
189on this last item um and I do feel like it is important that what we do send to the legislature um reflect us all and I do think it's important to try and to respect and to um respect each other um and to open and honest dialogue with our legislators to say Mr triple believes this way Miss Templeton believes something different let let talk about it and be available thank you Miss Mike thank you and I'll make this brief because I know it's getting late um you know I think being political is just something that we as human beings can't escape I think being partisan is another thing though and I think we all know kind of like where party lines are and that that's kind of what can stir up these things and I
190think that you know if something is not a part of our legislative priorities it does give us the freedom to still talk to our legislators about that that was you know that's been something that's been brought up about us not having a lobbyist is that like well we can contact our legislators and talk about what our priorities are but once this goes goes as you know the Knox County Board of Education legisl priorities that means we are to take on the will of the board and that it does look like that that is all of us being in favor of something like that and I think it's also a shame to think that we would send a piece of paper to our legislator and that they would vote how they wanted to vote anyway without
191considering it I think that's a huge breakdown and really unfortunate and probably someone we should be voting for um because they're they represent us they work for us we work for our people um and so I would really love you know I've definitely seen it from this board before and I would love some collaboration and camaraderie and you know even if it isn't a unanimous I'd like to see something close to that something that we could all feel proud of going into 2025 and our legislative session thank you thank you sorry I put all my papers away sorry was that the last oh yes moving on to G Mr dupler would you m this item yes I'll speak to it but uh I've already cautioned the board members and I'll caution you again about speaking
192much about this item uh this item is is uh comes under J1 1995 policy J 1995 um uh with student discipline you all have been provided materials uh individually uh reflecting the record in this case and it involves a student who uh has already had a disciplinary hearing at the school level uh already had one at the district level and then was um uh appealed to the superintendent and now it's been appealed healed to the board and under J1 195 um the board has been supplied this record um the board cannot discuss uh specifics uh the specific facts of this case under furpa and uh corresponding state law due to uh student uh confidentiality but uh in an effort to be as transparent as possible uh the board will have a vote on Thursday as
193to whether or not to to have a hearing and that vote will simply be uh whether or not the board feels that the uh record is um reflective of a situation that the board wants to adopt uh the most recent ruling of the superintendent or um go ahead and have a separate hearing so but again can't talk about the facts thanks thank you Mr dler all right moving on to public forum we do have one speaker Lance mold Lance if you'll state your name and County of residence and you'll have three minutes I think that mic's off see there we go they got it on thank you Lance MLL um Knox County um Madam chair members of the board um I want to talk to you about the the emerald Academy Charter School that's up
194for Renewal before you right now um Charter Schools were proposed some years back as like this is going to be the greatest thing they'll be do doing so much better than public schools do they'll bring new Innovations and all kinds of stuff um the history hasn't supported that claim um this ten state of Tennessee has uh abandoned their efforts with the uh achievement School District um Emerald Academy is par for the course they're um their achievements their students do no better than the one than the kids in our schools um I'm sure that it's it's a good school there were some people here who like the school obviously um but that's not really how you should decide whether you should approve this it's like because there are real costs associated with having a charter school
195in your midst that was planted basically by private entity for private purposes um it's using taxpayer Monies to pursue their private interests uh Knox County school board has virtually no meaningful influence control over what happens at Emerald Academy you rubber stamp the annual report that comes along but Emerald Academy has harms that it brings it's taking students from different schools which means that our schools are um are don't aren't as full as they should be you know it it disrupts our whole system the transportation system isn't is efficient it affects the efficiency of our schools and and Charter and emerald Academy has not accomplished anything in terms of achievement you know um the um and they've had 10 years to demonstrate that they can do better than Knox County Schools and the state has every
196year giving them more money per student the Knox County Schools gets for its students so I mean it seems pretty clear that it's time to say enough is enough you had your chance 10 years is mighty darn generous there's no need there's no I can see no justification unless you fall prey to political correctness to vote to keep Charter I mean Emerald Academy running because it's it's not doing anything it's not doing anything any better than Knox County Schools do so I urge you to vote no when it comes up for Renewal thank you madam chair that concludes public forum thank you we'll move on to board Forum sopia great job again thank you um I just wanted to wish all the teachers and students a happy new semester and I wanted to um touch
197on something Dr Brown said in his presentation I just wanted to say it's not only the special ed students that benefit from being in the classroom it's also us it's also um the normal students a couple um stories I have is in in choir we have non-verbal students come in and when we sound good they make noises and it's the most rewarding thing ever because even though they can't speak like us it's not like they're deaf they know when we sound good and we feel good when they make sounds like that and it's so much fun to be in the hallway and see um Karina she's a girl who's has a walker and we play Rock Paper Scissors shoe and we race each other and it's just so much fun to interact like that I'm
198proud to say that Halls has voted um Mr halls High and Miss halls High the past two years as special education students and I would just really like to complement the culture at halls High School that's awesome thank you for highlighting that Sophia Reverend Bor i' like the ELO um celebrating coming back to school for all of those who this is the first day I have a grandson who uh spent yesterday together and and I know he was really really excited about going to school today so I just want to say that that to all the students and also I want to say to miss Sophia awesome job awesome job Miss Templeton just the welcome back we are it's beginning of January and 2025 is going to be a great year so I want to
199thank you all for being here um I know it's your job um but um I appreciate the opportunity I appreciate the opportunity to be here and have good conversations and hear about the really great work that's been being done for my children um and so many other children um in this district and in this city so um thank you all um for the work that you do and for um just doing it day after day and um coming here and Reporting back to us it's appreciated Miss fter Ridley or my snowman earrings hoping yeah that things would be different um heart of a teacher um I I'm sorry I wanted to congratulate all of the how many teachers received tenure 200 240 wow because that is not an easy accomplishment um I know there are
200teachers who have worked for 10 years or more to achieve um tenure it was a lot easier when I started teaching because you basically just had to stick with it for so many years but um it is a hard process and I I uh applaud their hard work and perseverance um and thank you for everything that you do every day for your students and your schools so and also everybody welcome back it's been a long it's been a long break Mr triplet just want to ask when we're going to have a snow day that's all everybody wants to know so yeah Miss bike thank you um I'm trying to not make this too long but um all the board members have this uh print out in front of them um I want to highlight beard
201and Elementary and their hard work um and the principal Miss Harris's hard work and supporting Miss Melton the art teachers um support of her students and all the cool things that they're doing I'm not going to read this whole thing to you but um just wanted to highlight that um the Bearden Elementary students currently have an art display at kma um it opened on November 1st and um I think it closes at the end of January January 26th and um they did a whole program of uh for Buford Delaney and studying him and uh he is an artist that is from Knoxville that went to Paris and did all of these great things and um I think it's really great to um look at some of the things that have come from Knoxville and our
202local culture and what we can do outside of that and I really applaud these students for their hard work in artwork because that you know is something that my daughter has been able to use to express her emotions when she has anxiety and all of these different things and you know I know that our general education teachers our PE teachers and our art teachers and our music teachers often don't get highlighted and don't get the thanks that sometimes they deserve um in being so creative in getting our children to love learning and pulling in a little bit of History into art too so thank you so much to um Miss Harris and Miss Melton for your hard work thank you that's really cool thank you Miss Morgan Sophia thank you for what you said that
203was so that was just so touching I'm not going to lie I was fading but that perked me back up so thank you uh I think we've done a lot of good stuff tonight I'm excited about voting to make the calendar change I think that goes a long way towards you know we talk a lot about retaining and recruiting the best and I think that things like that making sure that we are protecting Christmas break for our students and our staff is a big deal towards retaining our great staff and so I appreciate that um and with the special EDS stuff you know it's really hard and if there was an easy button to fix it I know that Dr Brown would have fixed it the second he stepped into that position um and the
204only way through hard stuff is to trudge through it so Dr Brown thank you for being willing to do that and do the hard work of it and thank you to all of our special ed families and um everyone who's who's in it with us and welcome back and maybe we'll see some snow I don't know yes like that Mr Wright I just want to Echo what everybody said thank you Dr Brown for your presentation your team very good thank you for all that Miss Elkins also thank you to you and your your team for what you did uh and then also the tenure teachers I look forward to voting on that Thursday night that's that's awesome thanks awesome thank you Mr Right Miss Christie I don't think there's anything left to say so I'm
205good that's very good stuff um I want to welcome everybody back Dr RIS Lake my son said to me yesterday do you think the superintendent's goingon to call school off for snow I said I don't think so he's like do you think he would speak to me I'm sure he could he could have join the call um but I want to welcome everybody back back to school um I don't want to end this meeting on a sad note but we did have um quite a few hard hits in the Harden Valley area over the break there were two house fires two families lost their homes two fires over um The Christmas break um everybody was safe so that's what matters that's what matters but they were um some Harden Valley families with kiddos and I'm
206trying not to get emotional about this one because I do have a sophomore son but we did lose a student the other night in a car accident a sophomore at harden Valley Academy my son didn't know him and so to that family my heartbreaks for you and I'm so sorry for your loss so I welcome everybody back there were a few people who had some hard times this this break and let's just please remember those families in our prayers thank you with that we are adjourned