001oh he oh l the he oh I oh call this meeting to order if we could all please face the flag and recite the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all right roll call trusty Blake King we're here trusty Ellis I'm here trusty Candelaria president and trusty Murphy is all present let the record reflect four trustees are present Dr Wilson okay the next uh part on the agenda would be the financial presentation by our CFO Eric kurs all right good evening uh board or uh Dr Wilson uh here is the financial report for the period ending November 30th on the cover page next slide uh so when we
002look at our balances without the tax anticipation warrants um the current education fund is at 7.7 million our uh operating referendum fund is at 2 million uh The Debt Service fund is a negative 1.2 million the uh referendum Debt Service fund is at 2.3 million our operations fund is at 14 million the rainy day fund is at 3.3 almost 3.4 million and the Self Insurance Fund is at 2.3 million um next slide if we look at our targeted cash balances uh the education fund still is about uh 6.7 million below the board policy for uh targeted cash balances um the operating referendum fund is about 7.2 7.3 below the target uh the operations fund is uh to the good 5 million the rainy day fund doesn't really have a Target it helps offset those other
003deficits and our self Insurance Fund has a targeted balance of 4.7 million and we're uh under that by about 50% about 2.3 or 2.4 million short next uh we have concluded um really having access to the eser fund we are in the liquidation phase um the liquidation of the eser3 funds has to be completed here in December uh that process is complete and we're waiting for our final reimbursement from the Indiana Department of Education any questions on on this first slide trustees I guess not all right uh next uh this is just the detail month by month line item by line item of the education fund uh if you'll notice the highlighted number in the lower right hand corner uh that is the number uh after we pay back the tax anticipation warrant or in
004this case it's a tuition advancement warrant or a tuition anticipation warrant uh those are paid back here in December next um this is our uh the referendum operating fund really the same information in the in the lower right uh that gives you the balance without uh the repayment next uh this is two more funds uh Debt Service funds uh again uh one of them has the uh negative bounce uh and this this fund pays our debt service which is what was used to build buildings do major building renovations uh it has a pay repayment timing that occurs in January and in July right after the property tax settlement so we'll get the final distribution from the Lake County uh treasur and the Lake County Auditor's office at the very end of December we'll have that
005money for a week and then we pay it on to uh the people that loan School City of ham city of ham money uh the last page this is uh next slide this is our operations fund and the details there um next slide this is the graphical uh representation of of our funds I think as I pointed out last month uh both the uh each trend line one trend line shows our balances without the borrowing or without the tax anticipation or tuition anticipation warrants and one shows it with the reason those lines come together in December is because that short-term borrowing that we do and it has to all be paid back in December it can't roll into the next year next item uh this looks at each of the fund balances and it's really
006kind of the same thing the lower trend line is without the borrowing uh the the higher trend line is with the borrowing and they come together in December next so this is the repayment of our tax anticipation warrants and our tuition advancements uh we have have a principle that will be repaying here in December of $6 million from the education fund I did get the actual bill on the interest so our interest payment uh we had asked for an additional appropriation of 300,000 we really only needed about 200,000 once we got the invoice and they looked at the timing of when we received the money and when we're paying it back um so the principle and interest number is there we had borrowed 3.1 million into the operating referendum fund for million Into The Debt
007Service fund and 2.9 Million into the um into the operations fund so we had for this year we borrowed $16 million to ensure liquidity throughout the year uh we'll be paying back $726,500 uh tax anticipation or tuition anticipation warrants for 2025 uh the plan is to use our our funds internally to deal with the EB and flow of the settlement of the property tax payments next so the other year end activities are really focusing on closing out some federal grants the sr3 uh grant that I had previously mentioned and there are multiple years of federal title grants so um those grants typically have consistent Cycles year after year uh but as a result of covid uh the US Department of Education extended those deadlines so we have multiple title grants that are ending simultaneously here
008in December so uh we're working on those Closeouts those liquidations and those uh final expenditure reports so that concludes my financial report for the board trustees any questions madam presid president trusty Blake King thank you uh moving forward uh when we talk about Federal title grant funding could we could it be part of our reporting you know title one for you know whatever the you know the grant individuals are specifically and and then we can know uh the beginning and the ending amount on a monthly basis is is that doable uh superintendent oh yeah I mean there's lot just takes more time the only time we see is when we actually you know we use it as a grant when someone's requesting x amount of dollars to use for title this or title that if
009we saw it on a monthly basis the beginning of the title and the end so you know we can see how the money is uh yeah I mean for title one I think that that makes sense we can do that for sure that's the only title one's the title one and maybe some of the the federal special ed grants those are the material grants other ones are probably too small okay what's the average amount of Title One funding do we get Average I I'll have to get that number I mean again it like I know we took a $530,000 title one reduction this year um so I I I'm thinking we're at four four to five million in title one but that is off the top of my head number okay so in in January
010perhaps we can get those numbers okay thank you thank you for the larger paper yes thank you I can that was Miss Lopez she uh is concerned about our vision thank you Mrs Lopez and also you know congratulations School City of Hammond on I I've been going to board meetings since the end of 97 this might be the first year of no tax anticipation warrants um job well done everybody on getting this District back on the fiscal that it needed to get to there were some tough Cuts but it's getting us to where we need it to be all right next item Trustee Candelaria public expression first period limited to items on the agenda first member is going to be Reena Horan good evening as an HTF representative I'd like to urge this board to
011vote no on the wellness incentive program at this time as it was created outside outside our negotiation window we urge School City of Hammond to go back to our original agreed upon contract with settled insurance premiums back since September 2024 HTF would love to discuss a wellness program and incentives for our members during our negotiation window changing contracts outside of our negotiation window is both illegal and and unethical your employees deserve better because they do matter or so we've been told thank you next member Dr Mich good evening um I am curious to know uh well first of all I'd like to say um yes like I'm confused about why this Wellness incentive is back on the agenda because I thought that was something that had already been voted upon unless now this is a
012second one A different one A later one something else it does seem weird that we're doing them back to back if so um but it is absolutely illegal and it makes absolutely no sense to do um and there's been no clear demonstration of why it's being pursued in this way um I also find like a it to be slightly strange to talk about tax anticipation warrants or tuition anticipation warrants or however we're framing it depending on what fund we which type of municipality whatever um because so it's like we're going into this year we're seeing kind of low cash balance with no numbers reported in terms of cash balance apparently um and then we're saying well we're not doing anything new but then we just got done doing all of these and presumably they're going
013to be paid off maybe some of them um at the end of this year uh strongly encourage people to keep an eye on that and strongly encourage people to think critically about okay is it really that the plan going forward is to not use tax anticipation warrants or is it really that the plan going forward is to that there is no plan going forward that um now that people maybe didn't get their way or don't whatever it is uh didn't get an outcome they wanted however that is don't think that they're going to be the ones making decisions in certain ways that that now it's just like okay let's just kind of leave it up to God um which I mean I trust God more than most boards um but God requires us to engage
014in correct action and encourage that and other people so whatever is going on I hope that we go into this new year with the right intent and the right action and making sure we're following the right procedures and that there is some kind of plan and not just a hey we're trying to set the next group of folks up for failure here because that would be really uncharitable and unfortunate especially this time of year um and I hope very soon we will be able to talk about transport again and our students especially this time of year it is very cold outside thank you next member leet onz oh okay so you want me to switch you from the first to the second no it's fine next Community member Wanda Pucket I'm on the Pucket I
015would like to know y'all talking about we in the red what is we going to do about them buses it's cold out s kids walking to school do we have enough money to get those children buses for the wi you ain't got got to give it to them the all year you can just give it to them for the 6 months that we out there in the cold walking the school that's all I'm asking for cuz it's going to be sleep ice on that ground we got too many strange folk walking around here now kids coming up missing I hate to see one of our come up missing cuz it's going to be a problem then cuz y'all could have gave them them buses for that 6 months where the money at let's bring it
016out and get them kids to buses for 6 months because you got the middle in the high school walking the elementary kids to school the middle kids is being late getting to school high school kids is being late getting the class too cuz they got to walk the elementary kids to school well met they walking into Irving and Lincoln the older siblings going to Edgar and Hammond Central parents at work they got to take time to walk their brothers and sisters to Irving and Lincoln try to get the school on time for they s and won't make it we got to come up with a better solution than this cuz you call these parents house talking about they kids that missing x y z classes yeah they missing cuz they walking their youngest sibling to
017school and getting to their school late can we do something about it that's all I got to say I will be back there includes everyone written in for first session of public expression Dr Wilson hey next uh thing on the agenda unfinished business um I'm asking for approval of the wellness incentive program I think it's important that we have a pro program in place that we can offer our employees uh definitely have something in place that we can get out before the first of the year before the full premium increase would take place so I'm asking for your approval uh your approval of the wellness incentive program do I have a motion do I have a motion make a motion I'm sorry can I ask questions or no okay I'll make a motion second I
018have a motion and a second trusty Ellis yeah I just a few questions and just kind of um trying to understand um there was a comment me that um this wellness program sorry yep that the wellness program was um after the contract negotiations and so I just want to understand was this ever brought up during the insurance um committee um as a concept the wellness program uh yes the wellness program was brought up during multiple Insurance committee meetings all right and then um cuz then I also heard that it was created ated out of the negotiation window so I'm assuming if you're saying that it wasn't that it was brought up multiple times not outside the negotiation window no it was not brought up uh during the negotiating window it was brought up really once
019we saw the premium increases uh that came on October 3rd um so since it's outside of the negotiating window after checking with I mean we really wanted to figure out a way to mitigate some of the premium increases but do it in a way that's an investment in people's health and wellness uh so after checking with uh basically all three of our labor and general counil attorneys negotiating attorneys uh they indicated that the wellness incentive program with respect to teachers uh can be done under the concept of a supplemental payment uh so that can occur outside of the bargaining window and any time that the board wishes to approve such a supplemental payment and I like to ask this question every time so what happens if we do not vote on this wellness program as
020it relates to the cost of um premiums and um really the possibility of kind of reducing costs so so the off the offset of the premium increase went occur um and the premiums would go in effect as they um are in the contract so essentially the pattern for the other groups uh beyond the HTF uh unit follows the pattern of of of what HTF has agreed to um so those increases in the premium would go into effect as as as early as the first pay in Jan January uh the wellness incentive would offset those if it's not approved they would just go in effect as scheduled with no discounts uh for those employees that participate in the wellness um the the wellness incentive impact on um a single a single employee means that their increase
021would be right around $100 um the increase with the wellness incentives in place for a employee on family the increase is about ,000 depending on which of the two plans they're on um without without that the family increases closer to $3,000 so the wellness really does a nice job of offsetting some of those increases the specific details were in the packet that we had circulated to the board um early or really at the end of October right and just to be clear if we don't vote on this Wellness Plan we're operating on these premiums until the next contract year that's that's the way I would understand it so there will be no um relief for anyone who's under our um Health Plan that's so I understand that I'd probably kick it over to attorney Conrad
022to see if she concurs with that well in terms of when you say relief relief from well I mean guess a lot of the um in is that the premium is rising and then obviously uh mean more deduction off of um staff checks so I guess for me is if we don't vote on this wellness program they won't get any type of relief and there's no we can't there's no cause they can't renegotiate contract just to be very clear about around Healthcare so right now bargaining window is from September 15th to November 15th that's your bargaining window and the the union had filed with herb who is the body who oversees bargaining in the state of Indiana and asked that there would be a stay put on on the contract basically and they had made
023the argument that this really hadn't been negotiated during the bargaining window and Herb made a ruling on that and said no just you guys finalized a contract during the bargaining window and in that contract it addressed the insurance and they had a quote in there I could pull it up if you want but basically saying just because you now don't like the bargain that you struck doesn't mean that you go back to it so Herb's position on that was it is your collector bargaining agreement that you've got right now and then the bargaining window will open up again September 15th of 2025 and then it will end in 20 November 15 of 2025 now the I think what's contemplated here is called a supplemental payment and supplemental payments do not have to be bargained um
024supplemental payments can be provided outside of outside of the bargaining window and they're not there's nothing that requires them to be negotiated okay thank you okay do we have any other questions on this item Madame President trusty Blake King my unreadiness to support um this wellness program is based on several issues first of all I um at the last board meeting when it was voted down I presented several questions and today none of those questions have been addressed not one of them so if they have not been addressed in my mind obviously I was correct I would like to read into record once again as I understand it since everything is as I understand it as Mr kurts as I understand it attorney Conrad not really definitive so this is how I see it herb
025guidelines mandatory subjects of bargaining the parties are required to bargain salary wages and salary and wage related fringe benefits Indiana code 20- 29- 6-4 all agreements on these subjects must be included in the CBA Wellness programs are considered a fringe benefit on page 12 of this document salary and wage related friends benefits accident sickness and it goes on Wellness plans it's a negotiable item you can't put a negotiable item in front of me as a board member and you have negotiated outside your window you know outside your window knowing if everybody knew a wellness program was the went all thing to bring down the cost why wasn't it negotiated in the contract during the window of opportunity again the wellness program as we saw it was not presented to this board member or the entire
026board with data with numbers whatever to this board until after the contract was signed outside of the window of opportunity to negotiate then it was stated that what we're doing is illegal no one has confronted that one word illegal until you can tell this board member supporting this program today is illegal I can't I can't support it I am not dismissing or undermining the superintendent's request is just that I'm not ready it was voted down down at the last board meeting so if it's voted down at this board meeting it tells me you can bring it back when the union is comfortable when they have read and seen the entire program as presented to us and explain to them in detail because I'm still not convinced this this increase this decrease in the premiums you
027haven't showed that to me and again state statute vote it down it just if if when I say no to something you bring it back it sort of undermines me as a board member until you have answered my questions then there's another issue Hippa under this wellness program if I admit I'm an alcoholic you know that's my business and I want some help you know who's going to know this who's going to monitor this is This Confidential you know I have a drink problem I have a crack problem I'm on drugs where is the confidentiality and that and that is not expressed anywhere in the program that was presented to me or if it has I just haven't seen it we are not prepared to support this we can come back if we voted it
028down last month we vote it down again and and these questions are answered to my benefit where I can feel comfortable then I could support it I understand willness programs what they do but it's not immediate it's a progressive the impact is not immediate as I am as it has been presented to me even the call savings is not immediate unless the person participates in the program period so that's my unreadiness uh is is nothing against the super dependant it's because my questions have not been answered I can read to understand myself and again this program was presented after the fact was not presented in the negotiate in that window of opportunity you had every opportunity and furthermore truste Murphy if you recall you have been requesting the report for months prior to us getting
029it how many times did you say Mr Curts where's the wellness program Mr Curts wears the wellness program we did not get it during the contract negotiation we got it after the fact so perhaps had this document been present I disagree with that statement I am not finished come on trusty M let's go out with a bang now let's go out let's go out let's speaking point of order please do not say things that I did not say you may continue thank you but I stand you might well anyway if you want to sit there and go on record and say that that's on you but again uh my unreadiness will remain here until if you're not jotting down my questions if you don't respect me enough as a board member to at least answer
030my questions I will not support this until I get some answers it's illegal you you didn't do it outside the contract window you you did it outside the window of opportunity and according into the documents that I'm reading it is a negotiable item not a board member to decide if that's the case you all can walk out of contract negotiate and say okay board we forgot to do this uh I want you to vote support this it doesn't work that way there's a process there's a process and we're going to be consistent that's how I see it we have to be consistent thank you very much Madam president all right um from other board members is there anything else all right so since we're dealing with facts I want to point out the minutes from
031the last board meeting the minutes of November 19th which are up for approval tonight item 8A approval of the 2025 School City of H and wellness and Senate program motion to table oh it didn't get a second so the final resolution it dies for lack of a second so at no time was this voted down so that was a big problem problem with the last meeting um I had to keep going on with item after item because we couldn't get any motions that night because we couldn't even get a motion or we couldn't get a second so at no time was this item voted down now dealing with more facts any questions that were at I I'm sorry I've got the floor go ahead so at any time I have asked you and I reiterated
032what the questions are and sent them on so it's been almost let's call it 28 days since that meeting and questions could have been sent to the superintendent we had a consultant tonight that people asked numerous questions on so there was no way any board member didn't have the time to ask questions um I see none that had been submitted by email that haven't been answered so I'm not sure where that is so why is this back on the thing as has been stated by um the administration it is going to give relief to our classified staff uh that's a reason to vote Yes on this we a classified staff the people who make so little money they're going to have to make decisions on am I going to do health care or am I
033going to feed my family you should say yes for the custodians they don't make as much money as people think they do especially the floaters and the staff they need this relief until we can figure out what we're going to do with insurance for the following year say yes for the teachers this also gives them relief from The increased costs so this is a thing that is good for our um people that work for us it's going to give them the relief they need on the insurance cost increases and it gives time for the units to come back to the district and work on what's needed because as our pool has been shrinking over the years I was here at a time that the school city of Hamond insurance if you got pregnant you didn't
034pay one penny until that baby was born but over the years years the premiums went up so benefits had to come down and there's just no way let's left anymore this we can't cut any more benefits it's hard anything left so this is the Band-Aid that we can put on for employees right now to give them Financial relief from The increased Insurance costs so I urge my fellow board members to vote Yes on this for the employees that need it the most trusty Blake King thank you madam president may I add we have had several teachers to come before this Podium and not one of them not one of them have indicated that they wanted to vote Yes on this Wellness prog so evidently they know something we don't know and you you in your
035presentation you more or less say uh the teachers needed this well I don't know what teachers you're talking to then secondly the custodians um they can make up their own mind I don't I don't see them coming to the microphone um pressuring us to support this so if so obviously again we have not done our due diligence as a board as a district to provide the correct information to make a conservative uh decision it's all Helter Skelter it's up in the ear it's if it's maybe I don't you know that's how I understand it there is no clear understanding on this um motion and again if someone tells me it's something illegal and no one refutes it is it illegal we have an attorney we we have staff if it if if someone says and
036say trusty King it's illegal and I don't hear the staff or the legal council say differently you're you're you're not doing we're not doing our due diligence I think we have plenty of time just like if we voted down today this you need to get back to that negotiating table and and and and Slug It Out explain it to them because obviously you have done a poor job negotiation is two-sided not one-sided you don't walk away well they don't get it they just don't get it it's not that kind it's it's negotiating in good faith those two words are powerful good faith have we done this I don't think so otherwise we wouldn't have this this struggle we'd have every teacher lined up all around this we M trusty King please we want it I
037have not received one email normally when when teachers or staff want something we are bombarding with emails not one so again it must be illegal according to the state statute it is a negotiable item it's I can't go over that I can't go beyond that I am subject to that state statute I cannot negotiate a negotiable item thank you attorney Conrad yes is this payment illegal and and if you could break it down because we have classified we have the custodians we have the certified staff is it illegal for any of them it is not illegal because it's a supplemental payment supplemental payments do not need to be negotiated in addition as I stated and if you want the citation I'll give it to you in just a moment you're not permitted to go back
038to the bargaining table until September 15th 20 2025 there is the the state statute is very explicit bargaining starts September 15th it ends November 15th um what BB had said go back to the order that we got from herb was that after the collective bargaining agreement is ratified and signed there is currently no mechanism in the law for a party to then declare they at impass because they're not happy with the terms they bargained and wish to go back to the bargaining table those aren't my words that's from the Indiana education employment labor relation board that's their order to all of you that's out of mad right but but again we also have classified is it illegal for them no it is not how about the custodians I'm sorry I can't hear you because there's
039too much going on Mr Suarez if you could let people know um so you're talking about the teachers and I know that's I'm the teachers are heavily regulated by the state that is correct right so I know going to Statue we can go through that but we also have the custodians we also have the classified staff and it is not illegal for them either correct that is correct it is not illegal for this to be done for any portion of your employees okay and this is not to you but to my future board members up here we belong to the Indiana school boards Association they have attorneys on staff there at any time you can contact them and you can ask them for a written opinion so a question is is this illegal actually could
040have been sent after the last board meeting and they already would have replied to you whether or not it was so do we have any more discussion on this item Madame President truste Blake King Thank you regarding the Indiana schoot Association we can accept or reject their recommendations it's not a mandate they're just an association they're not a legal uh Association and uh regarding to this again window of we went beyond that the the negotiation it took almost two what over a year and a half to negotiate this contract so if that was the case we we couldn't even extend it the contract so so you want everybody to believe that at any given time when you when say look we we want to get past this impass we want to get past this unfair
041Labor uh practice that's been presented to the board to the board not the district the the board to prevent that you me to tell me you can well let's get let's go back to the table let's go back to the table and and discuss what needs to be discussed what has what was obviously left off if the district they have to have Tak some onus in this in this whole scheme of things and they're they refuse to they they want to put it all on the union it's a two-way negotiations The Wellness Plan which was requested time and a time and again where is the wellness PR Mr kurts where is the wellness PR and finally we got one past the window of opportunity to negotiate so how can a how can a union be
042subject to or forced to accept something that was never negotiated I mean one law supersedes another fine you know if if I had a book of laws I probably could find one too but I'm not doing that it says it's a negotiable item period you can't change that it's not a now you want to play sematics you know we're GNA play a word game supplement versus friends benefit it's a friends benef we can't negotiate this we're out of order I want to be consistent moving into 20125 I don't want to set a president that's going to hurt us down the road and can very well do that period bargaining in good faith we have not done that and and what's so frightening this contract it says the board not the administration the board so that
043unfair lab Labor practice was filed against this board and I for something I wasn't even privy too according to our B our bylaws our board policy we designate our superintendent to speak on our behalf at these negotiating teams so moving forward perhaps we're going to need a union person at that table as well so I will clearly understand what is going on and as far as the custodians why did someone meet with them on December 6 trying to persuade them to accept this policy so that's out of order way out of order so I'm not going to be subject to something that could be as far as I'm concerned illegal according to the state statute it is a French prefit period and and and those who did not support the the contract the Union contract
044before I I can't see how they can accept this as well because it is supposed to be an extension of the previous the contract that was ratified by this board on October 1st after the fact period thank you attorney condr I'm going to ask you a two-pointed question because I think we've got some confusion here the first question is has the wellness program already been negotiated been in past contracts and the second question is sort of corollary to this how is this different it's just an incentive on top of the program already in the contract sure your current contract that has been agreed upon and filed with herb States the School City of Hammond will provide teachers and their spouses with an opportunity to participate in the school City of Hammond wellness program this is
045consistent with your current contract language the only thing that's different here is that you are providing a supplemental payment to help offset premiums and you can do that and I'm going to read the code to you the code under Indiana code 20-28 9-15 a says a supplemental payment provided under this subject sub subsection is not subject to collective bargaining I I don't know how to make it any simpler okay so to reiterate the wellness program is in the current contract it's been in Prior contract what we have today is to provide an incentive for employees that currently not in it to get involved in it and also the ones because I believe we got numbers earlier tonight um we want to reach a goal of 90% of people to be part of the wellness program
046but only 30% of employees so it is negotiated but this is just an incentive that we're being asked to approved tonight well I'm going to back up no it's not the language that I read to you was in the contract in the 2223 contract it was also in the 2324 contract it's it's a part of your obligation under your contract okay um the there is an incentive program that's being provided as a supplemental payment that is being done under the section under the statute with regard to supplemental payments for teachers for teachers yes okay now and and that's all teachers because there is nothing in State Statute that regulates you know there's nothing that limits you from being able to do supplemental payments for non- teing staff so that kind of goes back to home
047rule that yes you can do supplemental payments for other staff if you if the board desired that too all right I I'm clear on that is there any more questions on that matter yes because it's again it's a word game how can you separate the two you is it's as though you could put in a contract um every teacher get an automobile we explain it later on and then later on you explain it I mean it's you're just you're playing on Words you got to have you're not making people hold I mean you're you're you're putting you just literally playing word games and it's unfortunate and we're taking all this time to explain something that could have been explained between the last board meeting and now don't tell me I had to write questions somebody
048knew what I said so you didn't care enough you didn't care enough to listen to me and then able to explain to me during executive session or just before now you want to play word games you want to dig down and and and it it's not working for me and I hope it's not working for the other board members it's just not right if you voted down today you can bring it back next month when when all the air has been cleared and what is wrong with that and furthermore we got a new board coming in this should be in the hands of a new board anyway and that was the the initial agreement but I won't say agreement it was the initial thought process you want going to hamstring a new superintendent and a
049new board with something that we still don't know what it's about you can't put something in a contract without supporting data and without everybody understanding explicitly what they're getting period so let's start playing these word games if anything it should have been anou since you want to play a Gams were supplemental we could have done you could have done anou with this and not and not forcing the board to do this well Atty Conrad you you feel you have the upper hand you've always been complicit with this Administration to give them what they want so just keep on digging and and let's hear what you got to say yeah you cannot do anou because it's outside the bargaining window with the teachers now the board could the new if this board made the decision to
050go ahead and proceed tonight because it's a supplemental payment the new board could come along and undo the supplemental payment feel better about that well that's doesn't make it right so you want to put us in a position to force them to do do something that we shouldn't even be bogged down with we want to move forward we want to get past this if this is something they want to do let them come up and do it let them decide and by then hopefully we'd have more information because I'm tired of these word games uh that we're playing tonight and uh you're just trying to convince people to vote and it it's not convincing me because you should have done all of this PRI you anticipated this push back from me and uh and you
051didn't care you didn't care enough to answer my questions prior to this meeting I am a board member elected by the people I'm not appointed I'm not a figurehead I'm not a rubber stamp and I'm tired of being treated like one so are we ready to call the question or does I move that we remove it from the agenda I'll make a motion that this agenda might have be removed from this agenda at at this point in time you can't make another motion you can offer an amendment to the existing motion if the person who made the motion is willing to accept the amendment well I make a motion that we me no that that's not how she's she just explained what you needed to do so up there we show who made the motion
052so you have to ask that person if they're willing to change their motion and it's not to remove it from the agenda I believe only tabling it's to amend if she wants to amend the pending motion she can make an amendment to the pending motion but what would the amendment be if if I'm at I make Madam I mean trustee Ellis are you willing to amend your motion is that the question no not at this time okay so I believe we've I'm calling the question so we have a motion to approve the 2025 School City of Hammond wellness and Senate program along with the uh second we've had numerous minutes of discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I roll call vote please I roll call vote I I already called a roll
053call all right this this constitutes a roll call vote you may do what you want next month I have called for the vote all those in favor please signify by saying I I all those opposed no and it will be shown up in the minutes how everybody did we didn't need to do a roll call all right next item on the agenda is minutes I have the executive session minutes of November 12th and then approval of the executive session minutes for November 19th do I have a motion Madam president trusty candle Ario I move for the approval of the executive session minutes November 12th 2024 and November 19th 2024 as presented uh please no discussion out there so we can hear each other um do I have a second I'll second the motion repeat the
054whole thing officer Suarez uh our secretary couldn't hear what he said because of the comments so if you could talk to people in the back please I move for the approval of the executive sessions minutes November 12th 2024 item a Item B the approval of the executive session minutes November 19th 2024 is presented and we had a second by trusty Ellis all right do we have any discussion just one question me see no this is November trusty ERS were you there no but I read the minutes yeah were you present at the meeting I wasn't but I can read the minutes and okay I feel like there's been other minutes meetings where people weren't there and it was approved I don't think so but go ahead uh well most board meetings if people were not
055there you can read the minutes that's why they send the minutes I I understand that but okay all right so do we have I have a motion and a second all those in favor signify by saying I I all opposed oppos passes 31 all right I look for a motion for the approval of the school board meeting minutes for November 19th 2024 Madame President trusty Candelaria I move for the approval of the school board meeting minutes November 19th 2024 as presented do I have a second I'll second the motion I have a motion and a second do we have any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I all those opposed so that that was 40 okay uh consent agenda Dr Wilson okay just asking for your approval of the consent
056agenda that would be the accounts payable donations extracurricular purchases payroll schedule and voucher Personnel report overnight field trips and the overnight field trips right do I have a motion Madam president trusty candalaria I move to approve all consent agendas items a through f as presented do I have a second I'll second it thank you trusty Ellis is there any discussion Madame President discussion trusty Blake King excuse me thank you I would like to read into records our accounts payable docet register for December 17 2024 our claims total 5,486 92135 our payroll totaled 4 million 888,246 I would like to um raise some questions or just comments on our Personnel report if I may um for those who who don't again we have an AM my a staggering amount of uh resignations and key jobs uh
057key position uh if you have privy to that I would hope that you review it um additionally I'll just go to our Executives summary to sort of give us an overview excuse me uh two terminations 11 resignations certified no classified and seven resignations certified uh transfers reassignments uh recommended for higher uh 17 classified and and two hired and approv leave absences and when I and many of our um excuse me my voice is just my question regarding our Personnel report uh whoever can answer it realizing that we've had so many uh resignations and uh and some terminations and then our our expected retirements uh and many of these jobs have not been filled and when we look at our R report of all the hundreds of jobs that have not been filled is there can
058a report be provided to show the cost savings if any cost savings to these resignations these terminations uh these retirements in areas of salaries uh benefits uh some professional development cost uh because if those cost savings are there that's additional dollars in my mind I could be wrong but superintendent can that report since I mean from Janu well I would say from J July since the corrective action plan was approved when we actually put it into action where folks were rifted and you know the movement of folks U it's just a ton of and if if we if these people aren't on staff we're not hiring they're not working so that's a cost savings so at some point I would like to see a reporting reflected somewhere somehow to this board especially the new board
059coming in and to our constituents uh the actual cost savings uh if any you know maybe it balances out I don't know but I'm certain this is a report that needs to be generated so that we can see the benefit of all of this and um oh my God and then one other point I want to make under our uh oh let me go back to it give me a second here let me blow this up I can appreciate our our staffing summary because it actually shows us um who's in the building and again this this report alone uh in conjunction with and I just request it would certainly help us put that report together because we don't have the number of folks in the buildings it seems that um Kelly Services is providing uh
060more of that than than our certified staff should and uh and that's quite a difference so again uh Dr Wilson is this report feasible I'll talk with uh B Vera and see what I mean I I guess the savings would be if the positions weren't fil exactly and you look at our on our website there's hundreds of positions that haven't been filled and we know we're losing a lot of good certified and those are high cost special skilled people that make quite a bit of that make a decent salary and they're going somewhere else so I think we need to see that board that report moving forward because if it shows that we have additional dollars to work with uh perhaps uh that could be the funding to get every child that every Elementary child
061in in this District that needs uh Transportation uh that's my real purpose of this it's money there money out there it has to be and uh our enrollment is low so it's I guess if if that's the argument why we haven't F these positions it's a cost savings it has to be so um that's the conclusion of my uh observations for Center J thank you madam president all right do we have any further discussion on this item all right hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I all those opposed carries 4 z uh we have no new business for tonight and the calendar for January at this time on Tuesday January the 7th an executive session at 5:30 and board meeting 6:30 has been scheduled at Tuesday January the 21th is 5:30
062in executive session and a school board meeting at 6:30 all righty Madame President trusty Blake King uh may I I'm just getting your permission at this point or or before the meeting adjourn I would would like to make uh an announcement regarding our Indiana learn.org program there's a deadline coming and uh I know superintendent has done a great job in getting it out there but since we do have an audience here may I have permission make good go ahead thank you very much as many of you might know uh indan Indiana learn.org uh through the Indiana Department of Education is offering an tremendous tutoring program it's especially for our third graders that had trouble passing our uh assessment test and as you know Senate Bill won is I understand it is going to effect this
063year meaning your our children will be automatically maintained up to two years if they don't pass these tests this is a great opportunity for parents the deadline for parents to apply for this grant up to $1,000 is the 20th which is Friday so I know we only have a couple more days left in school and I'm asking the teachers and administrators to just let's get this information out to our teachers and PTA uh that's a good sounding board of information to get out so I I feel that's very important thank you that's Friday the deadline okay all right next item public expression second period trusty candalaria public expression second period first member is going to be Reena Horgan good evening I stand before you tonight to address a critical issue that affects not only our
064students but also the dedicated staff who support them every day secretaries teachers and support staff are often put in a position where due to the absence of a nurse they are forced to take on responsibility far outside their job descriptions specifically secretaries who are essential to the smooth smooth operation of the school are being asked to act as medical responders dealing with sick or injured students multiple times a week these staff members are not trained medical professionals they should not be expected to make life or death decisions or provide medical care and yet when there is no nurse on site they are left to manage situations that required specific knowledge and experience with over 700 students in some of our buildings this responsibility is overwhelming and undermines their ability to perform their primary duties it
065is concerning that some staff are being asked to sign waivers that dissolve the district responsibility in case of Errors these waivers raise serious legal and ethical questions we cannot expect secretaries to operate in this role without necessarily training them or support nor should they be made to Bear the weight of the potential mistake The Strain on these staff members is pable it is causing undue stress anxiety and burnout all of which Ripple out and affect the entire School Community the well-being of our students and staff should be a priority and we must find a solution I urge this board to prioritize funding for the return of School nurses to all buildings on a daily basis our students deserve access to trained medical professionals and our staff deserves the support they need to carry out their
066important roles effectively thank you next member Dr Michaela I'm good evening again um I would expect I want to express appreciation for trustees on this board that have like consistently advocated for people teachers the community students Etc uh despite the uh vigorous attempts of other members of the board and the administration to do things that don't seemingly have any Rhyme or Reason but that they seem very intent upon um it's interesting when we talk about supplemental payments right because we're talking about supplemental payments the way the statute reads in excess of the salary the compensation so how much of this the teacher salary gets paid to somebody else or anything like that I mean it starts to get weird what's very weird to me though is that apparently there was an order or decision that
067was given to somebody at some point that I don't have the impression was given to these board members um and that we're just hearing Snippets of that even to my ears I can tell is completely out of context because the wording makes no sense and anybody listening to the recording of the meeting tonight um will come to the same conclusion um because it just it's mindboggling you have people making a concerted effort to convince various unions to get on board with something that according to them and according to their members makes no sense the unions don't want to do it the members don't want to do it the teachers don't want to do it apparently the custodians don't want to do it and then there's this paternalistic well we're doing it for them somehow that
068just doesn't read as genuine especially with the desire to bring this up again and again which by the way um apparently you're governed by parliamentary procedure specific to revised Roberts ruled and newly revised I don't think I've ever seen you guys approve an agenda at the beginning of a meeting which I've always thought to be incredibly odd but it's because you're also structuring your meetings around nea's suggestion from 2000 which is also incredibly odd um one of those supersedes the other um and I think that's a a workaround right because in most other boards I've never sat on a board where we weren't approving the the agenda at the beginning of the meeting that's standard practice and it shocks me to ever see and I've sat on several boards it shocks me to see that
069in practice here uh that's absolutely one thing that we need to do in the coming year uh as a new board policy because clearly it's being used as a workaround to put things that on the agenda that are completely inappropriate thank you next member Wanda Pucket now I got a question what is y'all going to do to try to keep our teachers our staff in these schools for our kids y'all sitting up there going back and forth more yel what about the teachers what about the par professional y'all running them away every last one of them great teachers we had is leaving our kid deserve a education too but y'all board members that sit up there thinking about yel y'all ain't thinking about these kids quote quote y'all think y'all Big Shot sitting up there
070election coming up the community vot y'all in the community can get together and vote y'all out it's time to put these teachers those prayer professionals first for our kids quit worrying about yourself I'm not going to tell you again and this going to be my last time telling you like I said election coming up a lot of y'all want them seats back Community going to come together cuz y'all is not putting our kids first y'all putting y yourself first y'all forget about the teachers and y'all forgetting about them PA professionals let's work with them they come first before any one of us come first y'all playing I got nothing but air now and time since I don't sit back and retired I'm an advocate for these kids and these teachers and these parents I hate
071to see good teachers good prayer professional leaving our district and the way we acting we running them away sit back and look how many good teachers don't left already how many prayer profession don't left let's get them back come on with a resolution to keep them here not run them away yeah everybody sitting around looking talking about what I'm saying y'all know what I'm saying is the truth think about them first y'all want to lose all our best teachers that we got left now you need to try to bring the ones that y'all ran away back cuz y'all overcrowd in the classroom we need no par of professionals back and we need our teachers back cuz our kid deserve education just like everybody else don't forget election coming up bye next member leet monz good
072evening um I really wish you would have waited to vote on that um because the union the teachers the custodians they spoke on what they wanted I high doubt that they emailed anyone and said that they wanted this to go they're here today and that's not good negotiations that's not how you negotiate with unions and I would hope that you consider negotiating better with them they don't have a raise that balances out that Health Care uh unfortunately we can't use that out of the rainy day fund but the transportation could be written up in a resolution from the rainy day fund that could be something you could think about um I want to say goodbye I think we're losing a couple people here I'm excited I'm excited about next year and other decisions that will
073be made because there's going to be a lot of changes there's going to be a lot of changes and I'm optimistic about that um as far as these reports oh thank you so much you're on fire tonight with that cost savings love it okay let's get some cost savings uh announced for next month I Ted that too and there are car call Savings in that Personnel report oh and it's so vague I can't wait to see the reports looking a little bit better I was disappointed not to see those documents um to the accounts payable what is it like 245 pages I was hoping to see those pages today but all in all um you're doing a great job I want to say I am excited happy H Merry Christmas and happy New Year because
074next year there's going to be so many great changes I'm hoping to see uh many changes and many jobs being posted to replace some of these people maybe some evaluations um are hopefully on are due and maybe some positions we could do without to help um as far as uh the children real quick I got 50 seconds with everything going on yes um the kids transportation that could be resolved as far as plans and things why not prioritize the you know single dig uh cold advisory plans put one up there school districts usually do that they accommodate and put that responsibility on the principles because I'm tired of seeing everything placed on the teachers and them bickering online the teachers are doing their job but the administration in those buildings are responsible for those childrens
075if you put a plan up there it'll be easier the parents don't need to be called names the teachers don't need to be it it works both ways we want to keep parents engaged and so let's let's you know keep it professional there all right thank you so much thank you Carla today was great that concludes everyone written in for second session of public expression Madam president trusty Blake King I think it would be proper for all of us to wish our constituents happy merry Christmas and happy New Year next time you see us we'll we'll see me we'll be 2025 um and we wish you all the best be careful take care of your family hug your children love on them and let's love on each other thank you for your service Dr Wilson
076just a few quick announcement uh the superintendent search is ongoing uh right now the applications are accepted through December 31st so we definitely want to encourage more people to apply I also wanted to thank truste Murphy for her service on the board and her dedication to children and I would also like to thank truste Ellis for her service uh it was just for a few months but it's very much appreciated so do you mind if I say something as we go ahead point of privilege um yeah so I I took this on because I am a parent of a child in h in public schools and um this is a very challenging position and so I feel like so many times people sit and judge just let's be clear I'm not knowing the full story
077right and I um I think sometimes uh trusty King says that that we don't have the full story and sometimes um we are put in positions to make decisions that um sometimes it may not feel like we're doing the best for a kid CU When I make a decision the first thing that pops in my head is my third grader she is going to be in him and I own a home she's going to be in him and public school for a very long time so yes there will be transition just remember change takes time is not going to happen overnight just because we get a new superintendent just because a new board comes don't think things are going to change in 6 months and you have to be patient and we have to work
078together not just the board and the administration it really takes community and what I I've seen in the last couple of months is that it's the same people that show up we need more people in the seats and even if you're watching on the video I think you need to pour in and uh create comments cuz yes we want people to ultimately it's us as a community moving forward it can't just be the same 10 20 people having this conversation it has to be more people so I I say this because I I feel like this was an experience that I will be involved whether you see me in the seats or whether you see me on the camera but just know that um we app I appre let me speak for me I app
079appreciate every board member here I appreciate everyone's opinion and um at the end of the day I know it's not a selfish decision why people make the decision that they make is because they feel like they're making doing the greater good knowing the full set of the picture that happens behind doors and so um I I'm going to congratulate the new two two board members that are coming on I wish you guys the best of luck and honestly I think you should make these decisions based off of facts do your own research and it's going to take time you're not going to get it because it took me almost three months and I feel like H I still kind of need more information so just do your own research sit with PE sit with people
080um sit with Finance sit with Administration um and really kind of get to know the full story so that's how I'm going to leave this and I'm going wish you guys the best of Lu in 2025 I will be in the audience rooting you guys on thank you and I'm going to do some academic news I want to do a shout out to the Hammond's Lego robotics team so this past weekend it was the bionic Bulldogs from Barnes Hicks at the regional they got the champion award the robot performance award and advancing on to semi State this past weekend also the Lincoln smart Barts smart Bots sorry it's late Innovative design advancing onto semi-state and the hesel Bots from Morton Elementary core values award I hope to see them at a public um presentation sometime
081next year I also want to invite everybody January 4th 2025 before school gets back together we'll have our first chess tournament of the year that will be the individual region at Hammond Central they always welcome us over there and we'll have kids from across the state uh coming in there to go and play their best chess um and that concludes it for this year is there's nothing further business before this board president this me I'm sorry trusty Blake King one other since you were acknowledging our students we were able to attend the uh PTA Hoppa program at at Central thank you trusty and uh it was uh very exciting I invited Mrs schy and uh Missy goera to have a presentation next year sometime with kids and then one awesome thing three of our young
082men from Morton High School were signed I can't find information there was an incredible signing uh uh event for them at Morton High School and they will be bringing these young men to to present these young they got one got signed at Vanderbilt and I can't remember at all but it was so exciting and I invited those young people to come so next year as truste Murphy indicated we're going to have some extraordinary recognitions of our young folks doing something that withraw other folks to our district thank you m thank you all right as there's no further business for this board this meeting is now adjourned e