001e e e on policy analytics from Mr Barry Gardner so if you'd be willing to come up to the microphone and get us uh kick off our meeting so thank you so much for coming tonight and be willing to meet with us right thank you I need to you should be all set okay awesome thank you well uh appreciate the opportunity to to be here tonight with the the board uh so so very garden with policy analytics uh so a little bit about us so policy analytics is a firm based out of Indianapolis uh we've been around for about 20 years uh really specializing in the property tax space understanding assessed value understanding tax rates and what those implcations are for government units so we work with cities towns the state of Indiana uh and
002obviously school districts uh and so I joined policy analytics about 18 months ago um previously I was spent 23 years in public education um taught as an administrator I spent my last 10 years in school Finance U in a couple different districts as a CFO and as assistant superintendent for finance and so have a background kind of uh within this work um and so tonight tonight we um are here just to talk a little bit about the tax base uh that the school district has here in Tipton uh what that means uh when it comes to your property tax revenues which then also can impact your education fund revenues in terms of the transfer from education to operations fund and what we may see in terms of some things moving forward or some things being
003aware of uh as we start to get closer and closer to a legislative session that I think is going to be really interesting uh because if you paying attention uh there's been a lot of talk about property tax reform um all three gor too candidates came out with some sort of platform on property tax reform Governor Le Ron has put out multiple plans when it comes to property tax reform and the easiest way to kind of think about that right is if I'm reforming property taxes and I say I want homeowners to pay less that typically means less Revenue coming for the school district potentially right and so what's that mean what's that look like so uh no crystal ball here tonight I don't have all any of those answers yet because there uh we'll
004see what the legislative process will bring but just a little bit maybe for the district to understand of things to be aware of right and what that might uh look like uh in terms of some things at least we know they're talking about tonight so um feel free please uh as we go through this uh to ask any questions ask me to pause to go through anything um I want this to be uh helpful for all of you so uh dialogue you want to have about any of this don't hesitate to to interrupt and ask so um way we'll kind of move forward so one of the first pieces that we do with our analysis at Pro policy analytics is start to understand the makeup of the school district and so what this first slide
005really shows us uh the map there on the leand side uh the outline is Tipton School District so that is the Tipton School District boundary and then within it you see multiple colors that represent different taxing districts uh because there are unique taxing districts uh within each um of these areas of the community that also set their own po potential tax rates um those are listed there on the right uh and so you can see the different um units uh so we have the county has a tax rate uh the schools tax rate a Township tax rate we often refer to those you may sometimes if you're hear the term overlapping tax districts right because they stack on top of each other because at the end of the day the homeowner is taxed at that
006total number at the very top and the school districts rate is a part of that uh and inside of that we have what we call Incorporated and unincorporated unincorporated are areas that don't have a municipal tax they don't have a city or town associated with them and typically what we find happening is when we have extra units of government stacked like we see in some of those cases we see higher tax rates which then contributes to a term you may have heard called circuit breaker right and circuit breaker if you're not familiar with it is dollars that the district doesn't collect because a homeowner can only pay so much in in property taxes you've heard of the one two and 3% caps right so if my tax bill is um $2,200 but my home is
007worth $200,000 I can only pay $2,000 in taxes that $200 is what we call circuit breaker loss that's not collected and that happens when you have rates that start to get above $2 in totality so you have a few districts that have tax rates over $2 which means you're going to have some circuit breaker here in the district that that impacts um kind of the overall operations fund how much money you receive at the end of the day right so then the next piece is we start to look um at a couple of things here within this chart one where does your assessed value sit within your community uh and as you see on here it's spread out kind of through some different townships it's not all centrally located in in one particular um taxing
008district um and on the right hand side where you see the parcel count and the parcel count at the cap that shows us how many units are at what we would say that cap they reached the the limit of what they can can pay and when we say Parcels just so we understand the definition that's any piece of properties that could be a home could be Farmland it could be a business all of those count as as Parcels the first ones that are going to hit the cap or homes um because the 1% hit the cap first then the 2% and so you can see the majority of what we see districts at the cap is Tipton taxing district and if you were to flip back uh in the presentation break you would see it
009has over a $3 tax we would expect that we have that higher tax rate we're to have more Parcels hitting the cap and then it's just shown graphically there within the community and the reason we look at this is because districts when we talk about your tax rate and the school's tax rate that 901 Cent rate right whether you move that up or down has different impact in each of these areas because if homes are at the cap it doesn't matter if you raise your rate up or down that taxpayer is not going to notice a difference on the bill but if then there areas where they're not at the cap in some of the township areas and that rate moves up and down they may see relief or see additional liability in their tax
010bill based on that rate right so we have call that tax rate sensitivity and it's really different in each of these areas depending on what homeowners are so that makes it a really complicated um proposal to go out and talk about tax rates and what people are paying because where they live and what their tax rate is could look really different even though they're all in the Tipton School District right yes the lwood Civic set is that considered West lwood if you go back to the map within that piece it's outlined there um in the red and I think it's just a small tin yeah it's just a small sliver there off to to that so yes okay so as a farmer a few years ago I was encouraged to combine my parcels and so
011where I might have one what I call a farm might have been in three parcels and I combined them okay because I don't need my list be this long because I'm not trying to impress anybody with how much Farm gra we have or don't have okay so uh what effect did that have so given that it's uh the Unique Piece when when things are assessed okay when properties are assessed is within let's call it let's use this kind of here as this map right of this pedestal I can be on the same piece of property and I can have different taxing rates on I can have a 1% residential I can have a 2% farmland and I can have a 3% uh commercial all on the same piece of property so Parcels I'm sorry they
012would be different parcel well then each each parcel is individually evaluated in that manner for what is sitting on that piece of property so what they would look at is is it Farmland so if you combine your parcels and it's all Farmland it really doesn't change changed the math it's still all Farmland it's really what the component that's sitting on that parcel is comprised of whether it's residential whether it's farmland or whether it's a business or commercial is that that helps makes sense I know it's it can be complicated in those pieces oh okay sorry thank you so then one of the things that we um look at for the school district is what what changes in assess value so each year um the way our assessment system works is the county assessor goes out
013and assesses all the the properties determines the new values within those properties and then assigns an assess new assess value and that's we call the growth right how much how much did my home increase in value so if my home was worth 200,000 last year now it's worth 210,000 that's the assess value growth within that and so this is the year-over change in what we call Gross assess value and gross assess value is before any kind of deduction so if you've ever looked at your home Bill uh there's a standard deduction of $48,000 and there's a supplemental deduction that's in most years been 35% so you're not taxed on the 200,000 you're taxed on a lesser amount after uh what we call Net assessed value but we look at gross uh to start and you
014can see the district had a grow sucess value of for 2025 is budget of about 5.6% and we can look to see where that growth came from um you the chart excuse me the column on the left breaks down what percentage each of the categories makes up of your overall assess value so you're about 57% residential so about 57% of your assessed value base is in homes you can see Apartments make up a very small part your commercial makes up a small part and then you've got about again 34% that's agricultural or personal property right and so then we look at what those changeovers were all right so residential has grown and we'll talk about that in a little bit more in just a minute but big home prices prices have grown we've continued to
015see that uh that's reflecting the value um agriculture agriculture has grown because Farmland is determined by state calculation so the state has a particular calculation they put on the assess value for Farmland um and it is just right now on a trajectory that that calculation is continuing to increase so it's increasing the ba what we call the base rate right now it's around 2250 an acre um that that Farmland is taxed at uh in terms of that assessed value and that's expected to continue to grow we'll show that here in a second so why did agricultural grow So Much is That Base rate went from about 1900 to 2250 it had a a large increase um calculation is based on what Farmland can be rented at and revenue and Farms it's a it's a calculation
016put out by the Purdue Extension Office um and it's a six-year rolling average with it's kind of saying what kind of Revenue are farms generating and it's theoretically the more Revenue they're generating the more they can pay in in property taxes um you had a decline in indust your industrial and your personal property and what we're able to really deduce out of that uh it looks like it's a couple of um Parcels within uh Chrysler parcel um so it looks like one they closed a little bit of a physical plant and associated with that is personal property is the equipment inside of it so any piece of equipment well as that piece of property cut decreased in size so did that personal property equipment inside and so that's what really drove those two declines was
017the the change in those Parcels this year um so again sometimes you have those unique pieces um within that uh Dr L the next slide so we look at this as a visual right and so we we talk about this piece of pie so to speak in terms of your breakout so again looking at the the chart on the right you're about 57% residential the personal property and the agriculture um this is what we call a diverse tax base okay if a district is 70% residential or more it's not a very diverse space and has a chance to have a lot more circuit breaker impact not generate as much dollars in Revenue you've got a nice base which helps the district overall in terms of your your Revenue the piece we'll talk a little bit
018here legislatively I would tell you as we kind of go into that this pie now starts to concern me a little bit for two reasons um if you I don't know how familiar you were there was what was called the Stalter committee which is state and local tax Review Committee uh that has been meeting for the last couple of years they just put out their report didn't really tell us a whole lot um what it did tell us is they're looking at a few areas and when they talk about property tax reform um two of those that were listed one was a change in the personal property taxes for businesses um right now businesses can depreciate the value of their equipment down to 30% and then they still have to be taxed on that 30%
019they've talked about eliminating that 30% which would allow them to depreciate that down to zero which would decrease the assess value in the district they've also talked about right now you can you're Exempted actually on uh personal property up to $80,000 they've talked about moving that exemption up to several million dollars so that would I wouldn't have to report my personal property if it was under two or three million which again would decline that so um when we think about that what would happen in this situation is that piece of the pie would get smaller right but at the end of the day you still have to generate the same amount of Levy or revenue for your school district so we talk about is then who pays well if the blue gets smaller the others
020have to get larger and that may cause taxpayers to pay a higher tax bill to pay a higher liability depending on what particular class and so that's one of the things we're watching um is what happens with personal property same with agriculture there's talk with the other recommendation was to make changes to the current Farmland calculation if they were to do that does that diminish how much assess value comes from Farmland so those pieces of the pi gets smaller again it means the others have to get larger which could mean tax rates Rising so one of the things we talked about districts is just being ready to be flexible when it comes to um some of the things you may have been used Tax a pretty steady one of the mechanisms um that may happen
021is if that in that situation is it could cause tax rates to rise and it's nothing you've done differently you may not change anything in your um your funding structure but just the mechanics of it is it would cause tax rates to to rise to generate the necessary Revenue uh for the local units so that's one piece um the other is if they put some sort of cap on this legislatively it could limit the revenue growth for the school district uh from what you've been used to so while this in the past has been a really beneficial I'd say kind of tax base this year could be an interesting piece for it just because you have some heavy Reliance in a couple of areas that they're talking about giving relief to and oh by the
022way they still are also talking about giving relief to all homeowners right and so what does that mean if they give relief to homeowners and say homeowners have to bring less to the table right I think the worry overall is there's going to be less Revenue maybe coming to the table um potentially in the future when it comes to your property tax related funds so I know that's a lot I know I talked that piece is that questions with that that movement it's a big piece your assessed value and how it's made up is a big piece that drives your Revenue so that's what some time to understand that and what again if you hear things legislatively what that might mean for you as a school district some poal changes for you they won't change
023in 24 or excuse me 25 so um that question has been raised right because typically any law that's passed is enacted July one County Assessors are supposed to put out their assessments for the following year August one that doesn't leave a whole lot of CH time to change so more than likely this would not impact the 26 budget it would more than likely probably start in the 27 budget um but I just you never know what the state legislators right and how quick they may look to make some changes um but more than likely we're we're anticipating this starting to impact the 27 budget given the timeline y great question uh this is just a historical piece um within this uh in terms of your C value broken out in these areas I want to
024point something out that kind of lead in for the next piece this whole Farmland calculation because it's changed over time and if you look on the leand side of the chart the Farmland value in The District in 2025 or excuse me 2015 was about 221 million at that point they changed the Farmland calculation and you can see if you look at that green span hell continue to decline over the next few years because the rate of the farmland calculation declined over those years now as we look from 2022 look how much it's grown back here recently we're going to show a chart that's a big swing in terms of this and all driven by this rolling six-year average which a lot of ways is tied to commodity prices uh and what you know Farms are
025able to generate in Revenue so it's just an interesting I think piece that you're a little bit uh sensitive to because of the amount of farm land that's made up in the district the other piece one of the other pieces we look at is values of homes inside the district um because again the value of a home uh is going to be a part of what the district is able to generate in Revenue uh so the median home value there the district is in Orange is $161,000 um of gross assess value right and our assessment system is what we call market-based so it's going to correlate with with what you start to see in home prices um really happening in the market so this runup you see to the right hand side of the chart
026if you think of the last few years and what's been happening with home prices across the state across the country that's kind of why we're seeing that piece home prices have gone up so they become assessed at a higher level and that also increases what a homeowner can pay in taxes because that's the way our system works the value of my home really determines again what I can pay in property taxes and that's been a little bit of this rub right because it's gone up pretty quickly and so it's it's increased what homeowners can pay or their tax liability would say so theoretically right if I'm the one% I can only pay 1% so in 2022 it says I could only pay roughly $1,200 in property taxes now in 2025 it's saying I can pay
027$1,600 in property taxes that's a $400 increase in a pretty short order right so that's a little bit what's kind of been playing behind the scenes in terms of of property taxes oh yeahor should give me one no it's okay I just thought you were just gonna just let me die on the vine up here my goal so okay so governor elect Braun gets his way and we return to 2021 tax bills we provide relief to seniors and lower priced homes um that is a recipe for disaster according to our numbers yeah okay across the state but that's if they don't change how they provide money to schools right I mean there's got to like all I'm hearing the word no offense I'm hearing could and may because we don't know he's not Governor yet
028right Could Happen may happen um there's there's no like they haven't done anything yet right I mean I can't like Rob I have the same fear but they have to know what that's going to do to the revenue not just of us but every school is going to be desperately low provide Universal vouchers and they're going to let you compete for the students I I think so I mean he not lying about it it's all out there in the I'm sorry go ahead he's not an emperor either There's A legislature that could okay okay so here's what I try to be politically correct here a little bit to right an open space Here's here's what piece um yes Governor BR has put out a plan I think there is some real concern on how that
029plan actually plays out in reality um not just by people running the analysis but also by legislators at this piece um I'm not sure how on board legislators are with his plan but at the end of the day I still think there's going to be some sort of property tax reform the question is if they limit Revenue do they allow schools like other government units something like a local income tax to replace some of that Revenue that has been floated around chairman Thompson represent Thompson who's chairman of house ways means has floated that in previous years um the Salter committee threw out that there is supposedly $4 billion dollar in local income tax revenue state is not tapping into so does this become a shift as part of their plan that okay we're going to
030lower property taxes because we get a win but we're going to provide some that Revenue um you know through a local income tax I think the thing also to remember is this just doesn't impact schools this impacts cities towns police fire all of those kind of agencies so I think you're going to see a coalition um that's going to push back a little bit but I I hate now I'm saying like oh we're going to figure this out right I'm still worried too I mean I think there's a definite reason to be worried about what the revenues may look like after that and I think having this conversation proactively and starting to prepare for it is an important step so I'm trying to find out what they're doing behind the side so I can go
031out and sell it and you know steal it and sell at that piece right and have the answers right kidding kidding um okay so how we one of the other pieces we help the district start to understand is what's your assess value look like in the future because again as assess value grows it has impact on your tax rates it has impact on your capacity in terms of maybe Debt Service um on your revenues so as your assessed value goes so does really your your dollars at the end of the day so what's it going to look like right well one of the things that we look at um are home values and home prices and what homes are selling for so this is a a chart for for Tipton County um it's not localized
032to the school district but it gives us a somewhat localized data set and what we're looking at is to say okay what have home prices done over the last few years in terms of change so this is a median sales price year-over-year um so you can see from 20 to 21 they went up by almost 16% 21 to 22 almost 9% now we've seen a little bit of a lull in 23 it dropped down a little bit um the interesting part so part of that 2122 is what's Driven some of the assess value growth the last couple of years prices home prices are up and so your assess values going up the this is a data point we use to start to project because the way our assess value system works is sales activity in
0332024 is assessed in 2025 and will be a part of your 26 budget so when we see a 14% change countywide in sales price what we're seeing is and we're seeing this across the state we thought for sure home price were going to start to Plateau right they skyrocketed they moved up mortgage or interest rates you know in the seven and 8% it was going to Plateau home prices it just hasn't done it yet so our trending analysis in the residential sector is that we're continuing to see growth in home prices which is growth and assess value so that's a a positive piece for the district and this is just a data point that starts to speak to that a little bit so the the 24 real estate affects the 25 assess value which affects
034the budget is that what you said okay it works yep the other piece obviously for the district that we look at is the Farmland calculation and this is that Farmland calculation um and kind of break this down again so in in 2025 we're sitting at the 2280 um you can see the growth the last couple of years this has been also a key contributor in the district's assessed value growth because the Farmland calculation has gone up and you're have a large component of your AV that is Farmland uh and you can see where it looks like it's going to continue to go which is just a continued climb over the next few years um I bring this up because when I came into the the school Finance world it was 2015 and that that incline
035you see on the leand side of the chart from 2012 to 2015 that got Farm Bureau activated enough that they changed the Farmland calculation because it was increasing too quickly and they made a change now look at the um the timeline on the right and how fast it's increasing Farm Bureau is actively lobbying to change the calculation to make some modifications again uh what that looks like I I don't know um you know their their argument in this piece which can understand um is it's not a timely calculation because a lot of the runup and commodity prices happened three or four years ago are captured in this and now commodity prices have gone down so my revenue is going down but my taxes are going up so it's not a timely system that interacts with
036those pieces and I so I think there's some some pieces there that'll be considered by the the legislative body within that um but I think the reason we bring this up is it makes us worried to project that the district's going to consider continue to see Farmland grow at this level because I just think they're going to come in and try probably make some modifications to how that that looks um within that and so we'll talk about how we're factoring that in here in just a second uh so lot of numbers here this is assess value uh the change in assess value on an annual basis for the school district so the blue lines are your historic changes uh the orange are some of our projections for moving forward and we'll talk about the other
037colors here a little bit in between so uh the teal 12.6 was the 2025 so the district's value grew by 12.6% for the 25 budget driven by home price Farmland uh really driving those those pieces right um if you go back and you think back to those charts that I showed you a little bit ago um we saw the run up in 23 well we saw the change in home prices in 21 and in 22 right the the purplish bar is a a legislative change that happened okay so in 2023 they passed House Bill 1499 and what it did is changed the supplemental deduction on a home so if you've ever looked at your uh home you get a 35% supplemental deduction reducing what you pay in in taxes right so they changed that in
0382024 they increased that deduction to 40% to give homeowners relief okay and the way the legislation was written is in 2024 it was 40% and then they would reduce back to 37 half% in 25 and then back to the original 35% in calendar year 26 so a little bit of a roller coaster what did it do well if you look at the 2024 the district grew by 7.7% in assess value that year what our numbers would say is if they had not passed that bill you actually would have grown by 10.7% it took assess value from the homeowner sector kind of pulled it off to the side with that extra deduction right now it wasn't lost because now if you look at 2025 you grew by 12.6 and we're saying if they had not passed
039that you would have only grown by 11.1 what's that difference it's that 3% almost cut in half coming back on and then when you look at 2026 you can see there's we're projecting to grow by 7.1% instead of 5.7 it's that last roll off of House Bill 1499 so that's created a little bit of roller coaster but it also gives us a little insight if they give some homeowner deductions what might it mean for assessed value it could put a drag a little bit on some of your assessed value growth as as well depending on what they they do um moving forward in the future again the next couple of years we still show some decent growth um you can see in the 5.8 and um 3.5 the reason it drops so low in 2030
040and 2031 is if you go back to the Farmland calculation that's a year it actually comes down and when that comes down it creates a drag on your assessed value and your assess value growth isn't as as strong so all these things are kind of working kind of interconnected um Dr want next so the other piece that we wanted to do for the school district um was to give a sense of what would a conservative AV look like growth look like because you are very heavy Agriculture and your very heavy personal property and those are two things that they are considering what would it look like if we gave a little bit of a conservative growth model and that's what the green represents um in that model it's a very simple piece we just took
041the 2025 Farmland value of 2250 and just held it constant we didn't allowed to grow like the the chart says it's going to we we held it constant so you can see the difference there in those years um is it is a lower growth it does create drag on the assessed value if they change that Farmland calculation could be further if they change the business personal property right within those pieces so again we're in this weird world right where we don't know what's going to happen that you could have some really strong AV growth or they could really pull back on those pieces and that can have some impact obviously on your debt capacity or what you're trying to do with some of your tax rates and those pieces because let me in the leads
042just for a second tax rate specific you have an operations fund tax rate that makes up part of that 91 cents right if you look at that 4% line and you go follow that white line across the math the way the system works with the operations fund tax rate is this if aess value is above that 4% because that's where currently what we call the maximum growth quotient is if it's above 4% your operations rate goes down you don't you don't do anything it's just the the the function of the system because you're only allowed to grow your right now your operations fund Revenue by 4% so if AV comes in higher than that your rate goes down if it comes in at the 3.2% or the 2% less than that MLG q line your
043rate goes up and there's nothing you're doing with that right that's just a function of however assess value comes in moves that operations fund rate up and down so as you think about you know whether the district chooses to manage to a total tax rate or the tax rate Sensi ity right you don't control that operations fund rate it moves up and down as a function of where assess value comes in U that there's aers to that we'll show it a little bit I think here in just a minute um but it I think just if you're thinking around tax rate it's an important component to understand all right so a lot of numbers here in this piece but this is a big part of the analysis so what we attempt to help the district
044do is understand what happens to your tax rates what happens to your Revenue if you pick a couple of different scenarios around your debt service fund and and two that we're going to cover tonight uh and we can always run additional scenarios for the district it's part of the work we do one of those is we call here is a fixed Debt Service Levy so your Levy is your Revenue right so if you look at that very top line under certified Levy and you notice the debt service number it stays exactly the same from 2024 on doesn't change right because we're keeping that constant okay what happens when you do that as aess value grows if you look at the bottom of the page your overall tax rate goes down all right so it's going
045to go from this case we go from 90 cents to 82 to 78 we continue to to decrease that could be a positive for the district couple of I think school Finance thoughts to think about when you talk about a a levy scenario if I keep the levy the same right that is how much I can pay in and really in bond payments on a on an annual basis right so it determines the capacity of my my bonds when that number stays flat so does my ability the amount of dollars I can issu in bond toll so if I am able to issue $10 million now that's how much I can make in payments in order to those $10 million the long range part of that is as construction costs go up and projects cost
046more and more to do which they've almost doubled in cost over the last four years um steel is up about 68% uh asphalt's up about 94% over the last four years right so as those costs go up that 30 286 becomes worth less and less because it doesn't get you any additional really dollars um in that piece so that's one of the drawbacks a little bit of a levy base piece is you can sometimes get behind in terms of maintaining your your buildings depending on where you're at so it's a it's a consideration to to have um the positive is it lowers your tax rate right as you keep that system it does bring your tax rate down I think the thing to consider within that is if you go back to one of those
047original charts some of those residents in your um taxing districts that have the $3 rates or higher may not feel a difference as you lower your rate they may not see a difference in your tax bill all that will happen is that Revenue that you give up may go to the other local units so to the the town to the county and to some of those other areas do the home that's a I have a problem with that argument May so you're saying if our rate goes lower the mayor is going to see that and borrow more money for the police department that's correct it's not the same money our this has been confusing among the board okay our debt service rate and our debt service money and all that is completely unrelated to any
048other entity in this town completely they are not tied together only in theory where they would see our rate go down and they would take advantage of it but they are not tied together correct they are tied together in what way so property tax revenue as a whole there's a property tax capacity that's out there that again when when homeowners are taxed right they're our our 39 cents per $100 has no effect on that it does so let me can I walk through this piece but not automatically it doesn't mean that we go to 30 5 cents and their rate goes up and not say their rate may not change their revenue their circuit breaker will change so but whether they borrow money and increase their rate or not is completely unrelated to whether or
049not we borrow money well those those are two different pieces right okay so them choosing to take out Bond issues or you choosing to take out Bond issues or two is is right those are unrelated those are that's what I'm talking those are administrative decisions that's what I'm talking about those are completely decisions around the rate and their decisions around the rate impact each other for example if the town were choose to choose to raise their tax rate by 10 cents the circuit breaker line that you see the circuit breaker loss there in the that line that calculation would go up for the school district and you would collect less dollars you being the taxpayer or you being sorry the school district sorry I pointed you scho dist that piece the school district would collect
050less Revenue yep so if the town or the county or any other unit increases their tax rate specifically like in the Tipton area right where those we have a $3 rate right if they increase their rate it's going to increase the circuit breaker loss for all units which means the net Levy or the revenue that the school district would collect at the end of the day would be less the same for the town or the county if you raise your rate it would cause them to collect less dollars potentially in those funds because of additional circuit breaker that happens so that is how you are are interrelated now you go out to a Township where a homeowner is not at the property tax cap then yes then there's not the interconnection with within that piece
051but that's where you have the uniqueness where you have these $ rates and you have homeowners at the cap what ha the way it works right if if I can only pay $1,600 and I'm at the cap and I'm paying $1,600 that $1600 is then broken out proportionally by the tax rates of each of those units so if the school is 25% of the overall rate you're going to get 25% of those $1600 right if you raise your rate that you become 50% of the overall rate you're now going to get 50% of the dollars but there's still only 6 $100 so if you get now 800 instead of 400 it means everyone else gets less that's how you're interconnected when it comes to the property tax world so if we raised our rate that
052would cause more circuit break breaker dollars to be lost for both the school district and the other governmental units in tipon in some of these areas if you go to the township so we could raise the rate and not actually generate the money the revenue that we would think we would generate because of circuit break cor and I apologize there's a chart and and Dr glaze I'll share this with you we do a chart and I didn't put it in here tonight um but I can share it the district so there's a calculation and what it says is for every dollar that you raise in your debt service Levy how much do you actually keep and so it might be 60 cents right and the reason for that is you're going to create additional circuit
053breaker on the school district so you're going to have to give up 40 cents and then what we also look at is that dollar comes from both the school district it may come from taxpayers and it may come from the other units because they have additional circuit breaker as well thank you for explaining it that way because that is not how we understood it right Jen from two years ago I'm gonna be honest I'm a get a call I love talking about this stuff so please my first was the initial what you just said this is why School Finance local finan is really complicated right because again if we went back to that original chart with the different tax rates depending on which township or Which tax unit we have a different scenario because again
054if a homeowner is not at the tax caps like in one of those townships we're not talking about the sharing of Revenue like we are inside of their rate increase would generate more revenue for for everybody within the township not within you know so when the city issues $2.6 million for a baseball field and then they issue a statutory Park Board to raise money for Park enhancements all those rates drive up we get less money coming into the school correct that's correct you you see essentially essentially they are dictating less money flowing to the school that way correct thank you so why don't why aren't we at the same table with the Commissioners and the mayor because the way Indiana currently works is each unit is allowed to set their own rates just like the
055library set their own rates you as the board choose to set the score good you could choose to raise your debt service rate by a dollar and cause lots of impact on some of the other units uh within those pieces there's nothing that that really stops you know with it there I mean there's obviously some legal steps in terms if you guys are familiar with and you do projects right you have to have some those pieces so I don't say there's not any piece within that from a tax standpoint it's really driven by each individual unit to my point though they they can continue to borrow money and we can continue to borrow money but because of the circuit breaker none of us are going to get the revenue we think we're going to get
056because we've just borrowed too much money right I live in Cicero Township I'm fine did you see that I'm a mile away from the circuit breaker you it's you guys out there on Green Street and stuff doesn't bother me you can double it I got loads of room on the chart so I don't care that's that's why we're all that's why we're elected from different districts right I represent 42% of the tax Bas and we aren't at the cap so it's really just screwing you guys over so it's okay let me clarify you're still going to this again the new right if you raise your rate and they raise their rate you're still going to get the money you need in The Debt Service fund to make those Bond it's the operations you're going to
057lose money in the operations so that's the push poll within this right and that's so that's the piece of you're still going to get those money for your bonds because they make sure you pay pay your bonds first but you're going to take the hit in the operations fund within that and that's the that's the catch and again that's when other units raise their rates they have impact on you potentially in some these particular areas in terms of your your circuit breakers so mean we make assumptions just to May of also TI when we do this analysis for you as a school district and we say here's where we project your circuit breaker to be we make assumptions about the other taxing units because they have impact on that calculation we typically hold their rates
058steady not making assumptions they're going to raise or lower them they're going to follow the natural flow of the of the assess value system because they impact this these figures at the end of the day if they move one way or the other I throw another Ranch you sure can okay so uh what fun know what if um someone wants to set up a tiff yeah so yeah tips are an interesting pie right yeah um they don't help anyone no particularly so let me let me start here uh government no everyone know to tip is we're familiar with the term tax financing that right so we're going to carve out a particular piece of of area and we're going to begin to to capture the assess value first and foremost I will tell you we
059at policy because we represent schools cities and towns both sides we often talk about a butt for test and what that means is would the development have happened if they had if they had not tiffed that area because the idea behind a tiff is I Tiff that area I'm going to redevelop I'm put infrastructure in to try to drive Business Development and create new Revenue coming in so the question is would it have happened had they not TI if it would have happened organically then a Tiff's not a good idea but if it it's a space where you don't have any commercial development and you're trying to generate it it can be a source of that we've seen great examples uh if you've ever uh Indianapolis Motor Speedway we live in the town of Speedway
060about a mile from the track there's a main street in Speedway that was Barren and deserted for my first 10 years living in the community they Tiff it they redid the infrastructure and if you go down there it's got about 10 new restaurants it's a thriving place that probably would not have happened had the infrastructure was so old right so there are positives there are also negatives at times when tips are misused didn't the legislature change didn't the school board used to have the power to reject tips residential tips residential tip resal tip commercial that power has been taken away on the Tiff topic I want to go back real quick because I haven't Liv here as long as these folks um the Chrysler Building that's now closed and hopefully reopening is that in a
061tiff it is in a chryler so that's affecting I mean it it does so it's this interesting piece right so years ago when they established the Tiff they set a b B assess value so let's say that land was worth $100,000 right you were collecting tax on that $100,000 it's Tiff for the next 20 to 25 years right you as that assess value grows you don't as a school district get to collect in growth you still get $100,000 when it expires even if they establish a new tip the base is reset to whatever that value is so it's a long range piece that eventually you do see the assess value inside that Tiff it's just over a long period of of time um so they are they tend to be a little bit of a
062controversial the the residential tip the money flows very quickly to the schools the the commercial tips not so much because they spend 20 years paying off the infrastructure say the first part about the residential residential so our tips right the houses get up the assessed value starts they're collecting taxes infrastructures paid for and the School receives their portion of the Tiff in under 20 years not necessarily uh depends on the how the Redevelopment commission handles a tiff because technically those dollars would be captured and inside those tiffs for the 20 years so school districts have typically um most cases been opposed to residential tiffs because it creates new homes which typically brings new students which requires additional services but you don't get the prop prop tax revenue from those homes because it's captured inside the
063the Tiff right now some communities have looked at it and some school boards have gotten um kind of in line with it because they're they don't have housing and they're trying to develop housing right that was the original intent uh Senator RS from Richmond passed the the residential Tiff Bill uh it was because they were having trouble um for a hospital didn't couldn't police couldn't find homes and that over in the Richmond area so this was that was kind of the Genesis of it school boards used to have a vote they could approve or deny that that has been taken away that's technically supposed to sunset in 277 um we'll see you know what they uh Sunset that or not but um that's been I would say districts can sometimes get a little bit more
064on board with commercial tiffs because again if it's generating development an area that wouldn't have had it it might be good for the overall Community residential tiffs are sometimes a little tougher to get on board with because of providing services without the revenue right so yeah great questions um within this um I think the last slide I have is the other scenario that we run within this piece is then The Debt Service holding The Debt Service rate steady okay so now I'm going to start at the bottom of the chart and if you look at the rates we're keeping The Debt Service rate at the 4177 and holding that steady the operations fund rate in this scenario is going down because a is is higher than the 4% MLG Q so that drives the operations
065rate down so overall the tax rates going down right when you look up then to the levy at the top you can see the increasing certified Levy um for The Debt Service fund creating additional dollars in Revenue in The Debt Service fund okay so now again if we go back to some big picture School Finance kind of topics why do some districts choose to do a uh a constant Debt Service rate right well it's because they know they're going to have additional projects coming and they need to have some capacity to fund those construction costs are going up and if I keep my Levy steady I have a more difficult time being able to maybe do those projects um and to to take care of the district in the way that I need um there's
066a stat that's out there by the American physical plant Association long word apaa they go by um they are facilities group around k12 and higher ed uh they recommend a district spend a K12 District spend 2% of your building values back in ongoing maintenance on an annual basis um so one of the easy ways we would always do that was find our insurance value because it's typically conservative right because we don't want to pay too high on premiums but whatever that was take 2% that gives us a rough number of what we should be doing in projects every year now whether you do two million every other year something like that right but your the whole idea is if I don't reinvest in my buildings just like if I don't upkeep my home I'm going
067to start to have wear and tear and all a sudden that number becomes really large right and we have some districts right now that we work with that have seen some have have been forced to do some very high Debt Service rate increases because they've had to replace $10 million in HVAC systems and major projects because they weren't taking care of them an ongoing basis right so I I'm not trying to um be a proponent one way or other for these strategies I'm just trying to talk kind of high level School Finance pieces that's why school districts would often look at a fixed debt rate kind of back to our overall um conversation right about this interconnectedness of the the rate and the circuit breaker is again um some districts choose not to let their
068rate fall because if I let my rate fall like in the Tipton area I'm not helping my homeowner I'm just helping the other units of government so that was a strategy honestly we had um one districts I worked with 90% of our homeowners were at the tax I could have lowered my debt service rate by 30 cents and none of them would have seen a difference so it just would have went to the county to the town to the city of Indianapolis and those places we said we need to invest in our buildings we need to invest in our district so we chose to do a a rate management piece so we can continue to invest in those areas so again theoretical pieces I for the board to consider and and talk with Dr glaz
069but we wanted to provide at least those two to give you some sense it really doesn't have an impact one way or the other on circuit breaker um that's one of the other things we look at because sometimes if you keep your debt service rate higher you might see some additional circuit breaker you don't see a whole lot of it here right now in the analysis so I have a question please how do you make the rate fixed because I thought the rate was dependent on the payments we had so can we fix it and then put extra money in our debt service account or make extra payments on the bonds we have how do you fix the rate I thought it fluctuated based on what you owe this year awesome question so two kind
070of ways to to do that um is one honestly is working with your financial advisor I think you guys work with Baker Tilly I believe that piece right to plan out over multiple years because then what they work to do is to structure your payments so you can do a bond issue either maybe not every year but every other year and they structure it so the payments keep that rate flat so that's that's one way is the way you structure your payments the other way you kind of fill in the Gap is there is a there's a line in the budget called operating balance you're allowed to keep up to depends on the bond but 50 to 15% of the payment you can keep in cash so that's a way districts will sometimes just maneuver
071that and keep a little more cash for the following year it's all part of the state guidelines part of the it's all appropriate to then fine tune to keep that number until the next year when the debt falls off or they have some additional AV and they can do another bond issue so those are the really the two ways that Dr GL it would work with your financial advisor to try to manage that rate that cash you just talked about can only be used for the debt that's right it's calculators of part as your next year's budget I know I've asked AR for glaz I'm not this is not a got you I I want to hear him answer this question too we can't make extra payments if if we owe $3.2 million but keeping
072our rate steady brings in 3.5 million can we pay $300,000 towards our debt so your only your rate is going to be set based upon your payments for that year and then what you're keeping in cash that's the way it's kind of structured um so you'd have to up what you're going to keep in cash in order to keep that money and could you if you had enough cash I think I think one time career and I gosh speak this is a legal question I think we use some to pay off a little bit of a bond at one point if you had extra cash but in a given year it's your payments plus what you're keeping in cash and you can't build up a whole lot because what they take for next year's budget
073is they say okay you have all this in cash you can use that to make some of your payments so they count that as a part of your payments for the following year so it's really hard to build up a whole lot of cash in The Debt Service fund to do things like that okay so so still learning that schools do money different that's for sure yeah so I think that was my last SL do play is within this P so any questions or anything that I can well thank you I appreciate I appreciate the dialogue comes up do this please let me know and I'll get you that slide I said we got the mar it's called the marginal chart slide of the terms of for every dollar you raise where it kind of
074go I'll get that to and you can share that out so yeah any questions you have I very is quick I mean he responds very quickly so um he you know let me know and we'll we'll send those to him and he's uh said he's pretty quick and has has a lot of good information yeah thank you so much for coming in yes thank you all appreciate it thank you thank you see uh real quick did anybody have any questions about the board agenda where's Andre she's coming okay I thought she was be I don't think we have any comments from the community so at this time we'll adjourn the work session and begin our regular school board meeting in about one minute she is e e e welcome to the Tipton Community School Corporation
075regular school board meeting I'd like to call the meeting to order um this evening we'll begin with our Pledge of Allegiance and we will recite our vision statement led by Eric Underwood pledge alance to the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all going EMP power fut W students who are prepared for a lifetime of opportunity and success okay thank you uh tonight we have the exciting opportunity to appoint a new school board member the board received three applications for the vacant School Board seat and interviewed three applicants in an open meeting on Monday December 2nd 2024 the board would like to thank all the applicants for their time and consideration to serve on this role the board would like
076to recommend Kimberly fake for appointment to the school board for the remaining term of Amber rabah ending December 31st 2024 do we have a motion and a second um to approve the new board member move to app Point new board member second it does anyone have any comments or questions okay all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed okay so at this time then we would invite um Julia I'm sorry Julia I'm not going to say your last name Kiki thank you from church church hle and inum um she's going to administer the oath of office to um Kimberly please join us in the front join me at pod all right well raise your right hand and repeat after me I solemnly swear or affirm I swear orir that I will support
077the Constitution that I will support the Constitution of the United States of America the constitution theti of the state of Indiana and the laws of the United States the law of the United States and the state of Indiana and the St Indi I will Faithfully execute I will Faithfully ex the duties of my office as a member of this governing body so help me God congratulations thank you [Applause] get to sit back me board okay at this time in our board meeting we like to take an opportunity to have the board talk a little bit about um tell me something good that you've seen in our community or in our school system um since we last met I will tell you we were at the Christmas concert last night between the middle school and high
078school and the very end of the concert was the combined choir I've lived here 10 years I don't think I've ever seen that many students in our combined choir it was very encouraging uh to see Miss swallen and Jenny and all the people that are contributing to that and see those numbers grow so it was I had the songs in my head all day which I didn't appreciate but it was fantastic to see that many um Middle School um and and High School choir kids so I thought that was great last night I would just like to say I had one of my first opportunities to be in The Inferno with the men's basketball or boys basketball on over the weekend and just to see all the displays up the community um participation so many
079of the sponsors it was just such a neat incredible night I've heard even my own kids say wow it's so cool to be able to play in such a neat looking place but just to see the community rally around was was just a fun kind of electric night okay then at this time um we'll move on to I don't believe we had any comments from the community so we will approve the consent agenda items tonight on the agenda we have um on the consent agenda sorry we have approval of the agenda approval of minutes from the work session of and the regular session session from November 12th and the special session on December 2nd approval of claims for payroll from November 15th November 22nd and December 6th the approval of the Personnel report from uh
080for December 2024 we do not have any um uh field trips to approve and in your packet included all of the donations from September 1st to November 30th so I need a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda items I that agenda I'll second that okay there any questions or comments okay all those in favor signify by saying I I post the Personnel report for December 10th 2024 we did not have any um for the certified staff for classified staff we have the resignation of Cindy McClay as a cafeteria employee at the high school Alyssa Phillips as the special education par educator at the element School uh by way of recommendation for classified staff we have Lily Heaton as and Nikki Perez both as special education par Educators at the elementary school and
081Heather goodnight as a cafeteria employee at the elementary school Under ECA staff we have the resignations of Tony Richard and dioney as track coaches at the high school Boyce Nichols resigned as the varsity girl soccer coach at the high school Nate Slack resigned as the freshman basketball coach at the high school Matthew Riley resigned as the sixth grade boys basketball coach at the Middle School uh we have recommendations for Ryan bergham as the sixth grade boys basketball coach at the middle school Corbin Nelson is the assistant swim coach at the high school and milin Swan as the boys freshman basketball coach at the high school um and then uh as a volunteer for BCA staff Matt Quigley as the boys basketball volunteer at the high school okay at this time we'll move into the superintendent
082report thank you very much I just wanted to do I didn't really do a PowerPoint this time because I just thought I would just kind of talk about a couple of things uh Mr dorski and I had the the great privilege of uh judging door contests in the elementary and it was very intense I have to say uh the effort put into these doors was just pretty unbelievable even like I we started probably about 3:15 and there were still people out getting the last touch on their door uh so anyway it was a it was a lot of fun uh some really hard work went into that and uh we certainly appreciate uh the fun things that uh happen this time of year and the one thing that I love as well um each one
083of our buildings is is uh decked out for the holidays and uh it's just nice to be in a place where uh you know we can kind of deck things out and and celebrate the season so it's always fun I I did want want to take the opportunity to thank the Campbell Family Foundation uh they've um they're they've uh told us that they are are willing to help us with our um playground project uh through a matching Grant and uh again I just want to thank them for their generosity and uh and what they're willing to do for our schools and uh we're looking forward to that uh the uh playground project is going to be delayed a little bit uh probably looking at a summer of 26 to give us some opportunity to raise
084some money uh in order to as I as I hear all the time do it right which is what we want to do and so uh I'm very excited about that and uh and again I want to thank the Campbell family for for doing that uh along the lines of our our new and improved Inferno I did want to thank John Robertson uh for the digital display boards and his all of his work that he's doing with those digital display boards um they uh I think they're adding to the game I think there's a lot more that we can do but uh I appreciate all the time that he's taken to uh write the uh the the programs and to uh and to really try to do some Innovative things with those displays and I
085just wanted to make sure that we said something about him uh in today's meeting uh so future meetings uh January is always a very interesting meeting it's a long meeting so I will apologize in advance uh we always do a summary of transfers um Brooke will talk about that and that's something you're going to prove a little bit later here in the uh in the meeting and uh she'll talk about how we had to uh move in order to make sure all of our um that we have no negative balances anywhere um and then we have a board of Finance meeting we also set the mileage rate we have a financial report and then we have our annual doab report and again this is the uh distress district report um we are not distress District
086but we still have to go through the report and tell everybody that we're not a distressed District uh so that's an annual report that we do we also have board um reorganization a conflict of interest statement and then uh there will be an appointment of a new uh Tipton uh Library board um uh appoint there there'll be a new appointee for that uh so that will happen also in January and uh and then we also permission to advertise geob bonds if we decide to go that direction uh in February um we are going to share our survey data in February um we get we have a lot of data in uh just have to kind of sort through it and present that out to everybody and then we also will avoid outstanding checks and then
087uh as always uh we're starting to look toward the spring and uh we'll ask for permission to advertise for bids for our spraying and trimming and uh those are that's a two-year contract um that we will award uh most likely in in the March meeting or maybe even the February meeting depending on if we get everything ready to roll so that's all I got I have a question yes um who is John Robertson he is an English teacher at the high school okay and uh John is um he does also has our Publications class so our Publications class has kind of taken over some of our that digital display work that we're doing and uh so John's a a graduate of Tipton and an allaround great guy so if you'd come to the brand marketing
088meeting yeah there you go you were invited to sorry about that you could have SP a couple of hours with him like that's right GL that's right little joke y Tammy was invited but wasn't supposed to be there I know showed up she showed up yes and I appreciate that and I am so sorry about that okay but anyway yeah that's John is good thank you yeah next we'll move into our blue future Awards yeah um neither Susan or Amber could be here tonight um but I did want to take the opportunity to to say something about them um I uh the the four ladies joined the board um when uh when I uh was first hired and uh and I I just wanted to you know kind of reflect on really how far we've
089come um and what all we've done it's it's been pretty amazing and uh just wanted to take the opportunity to thank Susan Sloan and Amber rall for for contributing to to all of that work and I'm I'm thrilled that the the two of you are still hanging on and and I think that um it just again I I I just appreciate the fact that you had a very green superintendent who uh was trying to figure it out and and you were all very nice to me as I was trying to figure it out so I appreciate that thank you uh we will have our elementary come up so the first person that El Sherry has worked at tips and Community Schools for 38 so we are very appreciative of her knowledge um she's held many
090positions but she currently teaches fourth grade um and she was one of our November shining staff members and um she is always putting students first um each year Mrs C has students in her class for Indiana State essay contest and students in their class have been selected to be finalists each of the three years the last three years and and we just want to recognize her for her hard work and Elementary and then we would also like to recognize her student so miss emry would you join us this is emry Freeman and she deserves a blue future award for being named as one of the finalists in The and EM is a student who puts forth a 100% effort into everything she does in and out of the classroom and she's a hard worker and
091she's just an all around wonderful kidul [Applause] I wanted to Mrs sh has been volunteering at her school for 14 years she volunteers every day she all the teach laminating and and Beyond whatever um recognize but I see every other Friday in the hallway I come in um for the mentoring program at elementary and um she is there at 8 a. greeting all the kids with open arms and smile and as a non hugger um feel every day so you can a non hugger into a hugger I think you're doing a great job so we appreciate all that you do and that's right [Applause] oh thank you so much to our award recipients at this time um I would like to say if you received a re uh an award tonight do not feel like
092you need to stay for the rest of our meeting if you would like to leave and head out um don't yeah don't be embarrassed feel free um okay next on our agenda is our Spotlight on schools with Mr jorski I'm trying to deep breath well for some reason it's not letting me close out I don't know why it won't disconnect oh do that make any sense it won't load because there's too many numbers the time she was there there were two of them but I think one of them mov to the middle school I know your presentations charts and colors and hey Kyle see I'm having a little trouble relinquishing the screen any secrets I can just I can just shut it off I know you guys frown on that but okay I I've got
093it up there but just won't stop absolutely okay awesome thank you you're magical thank you all right very you good I'm just GNA shut it go what I could do is I've shared this you guys anyways let me jump so uh my presentation I is simply just calendar considerations um so again we've got a uh we've been doing a little bit of a little bit of collection this year on um attendance as you are probably well aware at this point um just kind of St really good job of uh doing a great job of sharing um sharing data not just for us but also for all districts across the state so we can kind of see where we fall among others um I'm not going to get into that so much tonight as I am
094just looking at our own data so uh just a few notes uh where I'm about to share with you just a review of the last four school years 21 to 25 um just the first semester uh a quick explanation once again on EXC un excus Anis and how we're kind of monitoring that essentially excuses anytime we have a documented evidence that we know where our student is at whether they're homesick or the family had to take them out or something like we know that kid is safe and well um the unexcused is when there are no call no shows and then it's the job of our uh Administration kind of track down where are your kids why are they not here um just you know communication wise uh so that's going to give a little
095bit of explanations what I talk about on saying excuse vers excuse um our Focus uh on this kind of Da analysis is on attendance during fall break and Thanksgiving week those are two weeks that we have just two days of attendance Monday and Tuesday on each of those um and we wanted to compare that to the average weekly absence R so how does uh School attendance for students go you know on those short weeks compared to a regular school um before I get too far into that I do want to just bring this up because when I was going through this I knew wow 2021 what's happening there um this is a comparison of you can see the scale is the same of 2021 2022 school year to this school year um for first semester
096um that's a huge difference so we have come a long way since you know that just you know Co postco times um and all the last three years are pretty similar to what we have on 24 25 years so again perspective right perspective in context on we're saying like good and bad attendant it's it's nothing like what we saw in those couple years of Co so um again just want to keep that in mind as we look at the rest of these uh graphs again these are kind of does that include um when you say like Co years does that include when we would have to quarantine yes okay yes that's what this so a lot of these like when you have upwards of one week 40% of your students absent yeah that's uh that's
097pretty pretty dramatic especially early in that school year so uh when I look at this again I know the craft jum up I changed the scale so you can actually see uh the the jumps a little bit easier than you could with that outlier year um so to put these in perspective the top left is 22 23 top right is 23 24 the bottom left is this current school year 24 25 again this is just the semester of each of these school years and we're looking at fall break and Thanksgiving break that's what the green arrows are pointing to each of these graphs the first one's fall break the second arrow in each of the graphs is Thanksgiving break um so again putting these in perspective I calculated the average weekly absence from first semester
098for each of these three years um so on a regular school week over the past three years our average absence rate was about 5.5% all right that's about 75 students a day on average or out in the school district um during fall break week that was nearly 10% right it's 140 students um Thanksgiving week it was about 9% 125 is students um other data I found particularly interesting October 14th and 15th um are the two least attended days so far 24 25 school year that's fall break by far those were the two uh worst as far as attendance goes um Thanksgiving week actually has the attendance for Thanksgiving week has improved over the past uh through four years really um with an average uh absence rate of about 5.7% this year compared to 10.5% last
099year so Thanksgiving week this year was really great for School attendance um again thanks given week attendance has like I said improved over those last four years um from 11.2% compared to 7.8% uh just this past year so again those are the two that stand up the most as far as we you're looking at the graphs go um and then um Thanksgiving a little bit better or is improving and U fall break is is just not great for attendance wise as I'm sure our teachers question do you think fall break is affected by the fact that tric Central has the whole week off potentially yeah I mean I'm not to see I think I mean because we have people teaching there and kids here or vice versa and I just wonder we also know that
100Tuesday is our worst day we don't know why and I want to know if Adam's working on Taco Tuesday to uh we talked about this this Elementary actually this out in one of our ad um one of our best attendance our actually our best attendance day in the elementary Halloween yeah costumes come in for those are fun little pieces of nuggets of information it's like I wouldn't think that Halloween be a big attendance day for school but it is um I don't know how we leverage that I think we talked about having more dress updates um but again that's the kind of data that we're starting to get that we can see compared to this year the previous couple years what are the trends we're seeing so this is one of those trends that Dr
101wanted to wait until after Thanksgiving break kind of see okay that maybe that's just a one time thing what how does it look at Thanksgiving how do we compare to the last few years so again things for us to consider or for you to consider I should say as a board um is uh the purpose of the data again is to analyze find ways for the school board to directly impact student attendance right by making small adjustments or our calendar uh for example we're already planning to move our fall District PD day to that Thursday pork Festival which was our third worst attended uh day of the year so far um this is the first time like I said we've really had this uh data to analyze it well and we also can compare it
102to other districts um while adding dat to the end of the school year is a choice we could do that we could say hey let's just go ahead and get the whole fall break or U or all Thanksgiving week off just tack those on at the end of the year um if you're looking to impact student performance on uh our accountability assessments your ey learns your SATs um the IRS which now come along with a uh retention uh piece in the law as far as kids do not pass that there is an opportunity to retain them um that just by adding those to the end of the year those those days can't be used for instruction prior to those assessments um and so again while we can still we would still have those days post
103those assessments it's less you know obviously effective for those assessment uh days so again kind of defeats purpose there uh that's why again we apply our flex days our e-learning days prior to those U uh end of the year addon days so that way we make sure we get as much time before those accountability assessments as we can again just a quick reminder um March 3rd is where sat and I starts that's 122 instructional days um prior to that and then for I learn uh it's 146 days we start April 14 so again as much as we can kind of save on the front end that instructional day those instructional days the better um again I I I know that you know asking to move days from October to August is a big ass totally
104understand I'm glad I don't have to make that decision um I just have to present this information to you guys um so that is something for you to consider uh any questions related to that very short it is a good question though one thing that um as far as like like other school districts in the area affect our students attendance um I I need to go through it it'll be a bit of a pain but I can go through and look at when other schools if they have fall break they fall break and then how they all do the thanks breaks and compare their data over the last few years um if you're interested taking a guys need that to help to make a decision yeah I mean the tric central data won't help because
105they don't have school that week but I mean I I think that that's potentially the the problem maybe I don't know I don't know that it's all surrounding districts it's just within the county specifically we have it seems like some shared things but maybe I don't think you need do that yet Scott we'll let you know also on your Halloween thing I'm thinking maybe so we have school on Thanksgiving and on Christmas and New Year's Day those will be really well attended right I'm just following the data here excent idea excellent idea I think that's great you won't be I'll you present you w be here I'm eager to see I'm eager to see Fourth of July attendance well one of the things that I would like to say is we are a small community
106okay so one of the other things that you could look at is what groups are traveling together okay and so you can have couple families that are going on vacation together and that can add up to a large number of students okay one of the things we used to do in um the operating room is we would find out when the doctor's uh vacations were and then I could could cut back on Staffing when I knew some of those surgeons were gone vice versa in OB OB over staff always in September lots of babies were born in September okay so and I think groups of people should stay together that's how they're friends that what's makes our community strong and uh look at that pce or we should think about that piece you know we
107traveled with the same group of families when we took vacation so well I think by creating this especially giving us a week so my family always travels for a week over my kids always went to school since this I've changed my plans and we're going over fall break my kids don't miss so maybe it will help people plan to take vacations in October thanks saing break thank you okay uh next in your packet were the department reports that we received are there any questions from those okay and then brick would you please give us the financial report would you mind moving your mic turn it back on it's okay thank um for month in November we finished in the education fund with 9787 390 and operations $137,600 186 Debt Service 78129 289 and rainy day
1082 milion um 3,833 41 um the education fund revenues total 94241 19 and Dr glaz and and I were surprised that our summer school reimbursement came in at 71,3 A3 the year before it was more in the 42,000 range I don't know if that's a focus on reading or or what that was from but anyway we're happy with that yes it say we focus on read yeah and then um do that in November and December in January the payment will bump back up to the $913,000 range I called the auditor's office today to check on our property tax settlement and for the operations and Debt Service funds and they said that they had submitted that to the state for churning and checking so as soon as they get the approval then they're going to print
109the checks they expect that to be by this Friday and then after reviewing education operations fund appropriation balances remaining along with expenses to be paid through the end of the year we didn't see any need to request an additional this year and then as Dr glaze mentioned the urine transfer process of appropriation is a little different you're just taking um positive appropriation within a fund and shifting it to cover any negative lines so that they all come out in the positive so I will do that and then report in January on that and year-to date interest so far is 548 27698 thank you does anyone have any questions just yeah I maybe I missed it so we're getting a check for Debt Service because we'll probably have do we have December Debt Service payments we
110do and I have those all set up Dr Blaze just signed for them so I I told them when we got to get the money when right when they're making the determination on when they're going to send us a payment I have to have time to make the payment I say it seems like we're getting kind of late to not have that money okay that's I mean yeah I usually check with the um US Bank who's our trustee that turns around then makes other payments with that say if I get this to you by this date you have time to do what you need to do so that those are the things that keep me up at night yeah I was thinking we requested an early draw but we didn't get we didn't get it
111early draw right so yeah any other questions okay we don't have any old business so we will move on to our new business tonight we need to approve the transfer of Appropriations to close out the budget for 2024 in order to close out the budget all major budget accounts must not not show a deficit inter and intra fund transfers of Appropriations allow schools to transfer Surplus Appropriations to accounts needing additional appropriation it is recommended that the board approve the transfer of Appropriations to close the 2024 budget the summer will be made available to the board at the January meeting I'm I need a motion and a second to approve the transfer of Appropriations I move to approve the transfer of Appropriations to close out the 2024 budget I have a second I'll second thank you
112okay does anyone have any questions or comments okay you really look at this before you do budgets for next year I'm sorry what the year in changes that you're making to make every account positive are you really looking at that before you budget for the next year which helps which helps our 2025 budget so that is something that we are considering yes so revenue streams how much we're going to come in under budget and how that's going to impact our 2025 budget we have to post our um budget documents and Gateway we get that done in September and then the public hearing for that is in October and there are deadlines that Gateway or the dgf gives us that we have to post those documents in there and get approval or we get stuck with
113last year's rates and budgets so do you ever look at any trends at any accounts that specifically you're always around I spend a lot of time trying to build the most perfect budget ever and then some emergency or some something out of the blue arises and any account can go negative quickly um sometimes the state will come along I can build my budget in August or September and the state will come along and change benefit codes for example I could build a budget with old benefit codes and then the doe comes through and says oh by the way we're changing all of these short-term disabilities is now going under this and you have to add subcategories to all the ends of your benefit codes to account for who's a teacher who who's a counselor who's
114a oh my goodness other collective bargaining member and suddenly my budget is no longer I can't just press a button and make it happen I have to make changes all the time so I really try to build the Great budget but things change continuously maybe I don't know maybe this is a still a rookie question that we don't know what those numbers will be but we have to approve the mov moving of the money it just seems a little well we don't even know what our curricular material reimbursements going to be right like they're going to tell us in December and you guys are going to be discussing it tonight right right I just I guess I'm sort of asking that more for them that it's like we have to approve it now but you
115won't have all the money and the balances until the end of the year we don't even know what but you have to have it done in January so it's well just like our October ADM count we're building a budget based on what we think it'll be and then the count day comes and you just have so do you know right now which accounts are negative I could probably run a report to show you I mean I'll report that in January you'll see the ins and outs of every line but your appropriation report that I put in the board documents would have all of those lines that are negative or overextended and other things that can change or you may be maybe you miscoded someone like we have a calculation we do for maintenance of effort
116with related to special education maybe you found that a teacher was being paid out of a general High School line but they're really teaching a special education class we've had to do some cleanup of those things and make sure their benefits were coded right so that we can simply generate a report and you know have the info readily available in our fingertips so usually there's there's clean up throughout the year you just find something that was maybe paid out of the wrong line and you have to reverse it or whatever are there any other questions or comments okay all right all those in favor to approve the transfer of Appropriations signify by saying I I opposed okay next we need to approve a resolution allowing the use of Debt Service operating balance to reduce the
117tax rate last month the high school executive plan for roofing systems was presented to the board in order to issue a general obligation bond for the roof project the 2025 Debt Service tax rate must be below 40 cents by using the operating balance and Debt Service we can lower the tax rate to 39 cents in your packet is a resolution allowing the superintendent to use operating balance to lower the tax rate it is recommended the board approve the resolution as written need a motion in a second to approve the resolution I move to approve the resolution allowing the use of Debt Service operating balance to reduce the tax I need a second okay thank you are there any questions or comments why do we want to reduce um part of what what Barry was talking
118about was House Bill 1499 if we want to issue a Geo bond in 25 we would have to have a rate under 40 cents so it would take approximately we have to work with a dgf GF on exactly what that number is um but we're thinking around 150,000 of our operating balance in debt service in order to bring down the rate to 39 cents uh currently the rate is around 41 cents but we don't know that we're going to need that are you sure we're going to need $150,000 we're not U if that would be we would only use that operating balance if we would have an issue with tax draw uh but there's a stronger likelihood that that will not be an issue because of our our U the rate in which that we
119are we normally get our tax uh dollars we have over 100% of our tax money that comes in in some cases particularly in whenever they're paying they a lot of people just pay their tax bill all at one time so occasionally we get more than what we're expecting what happens if we would approve this tonight and then decide as a board we don't want to issue a goine nothing nothing but if we want to we would have to do it so yeah but if you don't if if we decide not to it's just going to be 30 it'll be 39 cents and that won't have any impact so I'm going to abstain from the vote um November 27th I had asked for some information Baker Tilly around our other funding options there's some confusing proposals
120from um H there's one from Baker Tilly that that issues the the bond in uh 25 there's another one that that Andrew Manor reviewed that that issues it in 26 and um so I'm just going to recuse myself because I don't have enough data to to make the vote um and so I'm not opposed to the debt and all that other stuff um but I'm I'm not comfortable with the um I I asked for that information on the 27th of November and I I don't have the answer to those questions tonight so I can't quote on this in good conscience I I would say I read the resolution like 19 times and I I it doesn't seem specific to me that this that that's what it's for it seems very open-ended that operations it mentions
121all like your ability to move money around with no dollar amounts and no it doesn't mention that it's for this specific purpose I I think that's just the way that that resolution was written really all of this is going to do is impact the dep service but that's not you understand that's not what it says and so for me to sign off on it it needs to say what we're talking about it it's very open-ended sure um and I'm not I'm not comfortable with that it's not a distrusting of you it's signing onto a document that doesn't say what I understand it's supposed to do it um the two I the two don't seem to match I mean I read all the emails 150,000 we've talked about this for a long time I understand what
122we're trying to do I understand why we're trying to do it but that is not what the resolution says specifically okay would would it accomplish this yes but I think it opens the door to it doesn't say a dollar amount and so it's concerning to me yeah it's probably not going to say a dollar amount because because we don't know what the dollar amount is but it's also not specific to what we're trying to accomplish it doesn't just say we're trying to move money from debt service for this it doesn't give a purpose okay does that make sense I'm not accusing anyone of anything I'm just reading that and I know what we're talking about and I don't think right the words on the paper match what we're trying to do and they're not specific
123enough for my comfort level would the board one to table this and we could potentially have a special meeting once we get more information and maybe a better resolution more specific that would be the question that would be worth asking I I'm just I'm not voting for it the way it's written and Rob's not voting for it the way because he hasn't had his questions answered which I completely understand so if we have time to do that I would prefer because I mean we can just we would just have a special meeting and we can do that okay I appreciate that I just um well I mean this is a this is an unusual thing to do for one thing I mean and this is all kind of part of this uh of House Bill
1241499 and um so it's it's one of those it's just kind of different territory than what most schools have had to go through in order to do this so I understand but I hope you understand my no I do no I absolutely do and there just there there's a lot of legal ease in that resolution I get that and the question to Baker Tilly is is that it's 41 cents this year if you look at every chart we've been given it's 41 cents the next year and the following year and so my question to them is every year are we going to be appropriating $150,000 to bring that under so we can borrow more money and so I I I don't think I can vote on this until I understand um that that that fund
125does not make1 50,000 a year So eventually you run out other people's money right I'll be really honest I just got that from Belia and I just didn't have time to get it out but I will send that out tonight that's fine uh but it's uh it um again I think that what Belia writes will clarify that because we don't have any bonds falling off the books for three years or four three or four years right we're paying off the Geo Bond the 2017 but that's December that's December right but for the next three years we're we're at Red nothing nothing is nothing's coming off correct yes then I think that's the 2017 um series series yes yeah okay yeah there's four 2017 yeah yeah the last payment is sometime in 28 I think probably
126December right BR probably half and half do we need to do that we have a laer in room table vot to table M that's a 25 and then and then it's four years until and then in 20 or 28 and then 28 and then 29 we lose another geobond from 23 which is probably the transportation yes okay I think then at this time I need a motion in a second to table our agenda item 11.2 the approval of a resolution allowing the use of Debt Service operating balance to reduce the tax rate I move to table the resolution allowing the use of Debt Service operating balance to reduce the tax rate second thank you all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed okay right we will table that okay um for our next
127conversation and decision is the proposed calendar update for 2025 2026 this fall Western School Corporation KC Lea passed their 2025 2026 calendar with fall break on the third full week of October and the alignment of spring break with the week of April 1st this has been the traditional breaks for all the kex schools with the exception of this year for this reason we are requesting the board amend the 2025 2026 calendar to align the corporation breaks with the rest of Kix schools in addition we are requesting the corporation move to a full week of fall break to avoid two two-day weeks currently fall break and Thanksgiving break weeks the two days before the current fall break would be added to the beginning of the school year an option two is added that eliminates a snow
128makeup day and adds one day to end the to end to the end of the year sorry in the future we will move our calendar discussions from Spring to the fall of the year to ensure our breaks align with other k6 schools so at this time I need a motion in a second um to approve the proposed calendar update and we can have a discussion on which um option we prefer to have I moveed to approve the proposed calendar update for the 2025 2026 school years a second thank you okay so I think you probably had an opportunity to review the calendars that were in our pack it um the first one was the one that was proposed and had us beginning school on August 6 and ending um on May 20 yep and May
12928th um another option on the SEC so I think the only difference if I'm correct Mr torsky Dr glaze is that instead we would begin the we would move our date to start a little bit later in August and get out a little bit later in May some people I mean yeah lots of reasons for that either yeah either adding to the end or adding to the beginning so either way so it's really just a preference at this point well does change I like Scott's point about the number of school days prior to the testing and is that option two one that's option one will we start earlier Yeah by by two days one day yeah is it just one cuz we added it would be two days the six the eight yeah but if
130you wanted if you wanted to go ahead and eliminate a snow makeup day we could just add one day and then go ahead and eliminate the snow make I don't like starting earlier I know I agree I agree I agree and that would mean we would have our teacher day on the sixth our student day would be the seven if we just added a day to the beginning of the year and then we just didn't we would just exclude a snow makeup day after uh spring break so that way it's not putting two days at the beginning we're just adding one day one I'm all for adding at the end of the year versus the beginning um I think kids are still working in August I don't like starting give them another day make money
131and enjoy the what if we kept October break and we told them Halloween was on that Tu I like that thinking look I'm trying to use provides I like that thinking Eric I think that's great we just move Halloween that's right how hard can that be so with the draft two we start on the 8th August and then we get out on a Friday the 29th okay and then we still have we took away the flex day at the end of spring break correct okay yes which honestly is not usually we don't have a lot of trouble with kids coming back on that Monday right we always have trouble with kids leaving early yeah so so that wasn't a big deal at all I mean if we took away a snow makeup day would we
132take away February 13 you you could that one too I mean we can just eliminate a snow makeup day I and you can the concern would be then if we needed the snow days to get in our days before testing and right yeah that's true yeah which I had I remember having an elementary teacher talk to me about wanting those days be when they were concerned when we were going to do a two we sure spring break with all those flex days the concern for them was having enough days to do instruction right right prior to you know spring break time and April and so so right now on the second one February 13th that Friday is a that's that's a flex day we would have the day off unless there' been a snow day
133prior to that day Andre we would go or we would have a e-learning day we would go because we only can have three e-learning days and so this would be after we we've missed three days well actually four days because um President's Day would be in there right and then so we would have to have missed four days and then we would have to make up that day on the 13th well I families are probably going a plan that weekend to go somewhere we have present day and a flex day yeah um am I wrong between option one and option two we're only ending one day later yes because we eliminated a flex day and starting two days later right actually starting the same time that we already planned which is Thursday yeah Thursday work
134day Friday or student day Friday for student day that's what that was my question too yeah they Thursday our teachers love Friday and and I taught I love to just like a tway or whatever first week it really helps us on the transportation side I'll be really honest because it gives us the weekend to figure some things out and Monday goes a whole lot better um I mean I I guess I would support option two especially because hopefully with um having full weeks in October now um that would get give a good consistent timeline to education um and allow our kids to work longer in the summer I agree I'm moved to approve the second option for the calendar second any other questions or comments oh do we I heard we used to have a
135kind of a calendar committee you think it would be beneficial to have different people from different School looking at this S I hear a volunteer that's what they do to me careful on the committee we can do that um yeah but really yeah input to it yeah and and typically what I will do is we'll kind of give drafts to the Association and have them go ahead and take a look at it and then we talk about it during our meet and discuss time um and uh so we we do do that um but um yeah I mean and that's something we can continue to do um is the not part of the contract contract no it used to be it did yeah okay it did you can tell I have a little Gap in
136my yeah it did yeah it was a it was they had it was negotiated by the featur right right it was part of the that all changed in you remember that 2008 I believe yeah Eric had a chalkboard in his room can outdated Maps because the wall had come down okay at this time all those in favor of approving the option two for the proposed calendar signify by saying I I opposed you think thank you uh lastly we need to approve the adoption of supplemental curricular materials for the spring semester of 2025 and Beyond earlier Mr jorski actually did not right no proposal but anyways it is included in your packet the list of supplemental curcular materials um and so I just need a motion in a second to approve that adoption you will answer
137any questions by the way that was the whole committee that yes did I moveed to approve uh the adoption of supplemental curricular materials for the spring semester 2025 and Beyond second that okay are there any questions or comments for Mr jsk so what does this mean so so like so I mean so Mrs Cole She whatever you or her wrote this and it's great very informative the total cost is there um but what does this mean this means something in addition to are giving permission to use public dollars to pay for these things now I will say more I think I'm not 100% sure if we need yeah we probably do because they're books um for Miss Neely and uh Miss Miller um those are being paid out of a high ability Grant so I
138don't need we don't need approval for that like that that goes through me however um uh because they books reviews that recommends hey these books are okay people looked at this for Miss Kohl's um it's a nonc consumable subal curricular material basically it's something that is relates to content and pretty much everything that's related to content that's being paid with State dollars which we scrip it from collecting money from families to pay for these things now State money is paying for these things if State money is paying for these things now the governing body is responsible for what is going hands um even more so uh so in this case here simply we're saying yes we are okay with our students having access to this particular thing being paid for out State dollars okay so
139that's it's it's going to happen every semester the way we kind of worked it out is we do one in the spring one in the fall we did this last spring if you recall um those on the board who were there um where we had it was the first time right we had all those Ty materials that are like hey our teacher want to use this but it's the core cric that's part of the adoptive that's the core this is the supplemental piece this is all that's all the extra things I'm teach like really would like to have this added to our curricul so that we can better support our students whether that's um through interventions which is what example for and type stuff um but yeah it's it's something that we just will will
140do for spring every all until um change again but yeah it's it's a bit tedious because again and I I'll be transparent about it like it's hard to get people to join these committees it's one unpaid two it's really inconvenient time and it's just something where it's like we need to get it done so we get a team together as best we can we make a recommendation present to you guys it's it's very much bureaucratic stuff that it's just it just feels like a lot of spinning wheels but it's technically by the book and then finally all this is through for Mr SS and middle school this is open to any teacher in any building to be able to to request I believe it's just for her class um and then the books for Mrs
141ne's honors class and Miss Miller's honors class um for just just for high bu because of where it's coming from ability funds can only go only ability resour got com about that okay but and I was asked a terrible question so I apologize that my my question is this is open to anybody the fact that it's all middle school is only Middle School requested I think everyone else got their stuff back in the spring okay um and because we we I did really I went to every team meeting to explain this whole process then because it is complicated it's tedious and it's just to be honest a bit of a nightmare to manage um so when we did this fall one I sent out a message to all staff I only had the three uh
142Middle School I was thankful for that but again um we'll have another one these this spring thank you real quick speaking of books and money with the change in we couldn't charge a book rental and the state was going to reimburse us we never knew how that was going to work out Dr glaz did it was it close well we'll know here in a couple of days um it's a I'd never heard a followup we were very concerned about well it a little more concerned this year because we thought we would would have that money and we don't have it yet so oh and we haven't heard exactly what the per pupil that's true across the state not just us not just yeah it's everybody okay that's why I haven't heard how it went correct
143so we're playing the game on that one which is one of the reasons why we don't know what to do with negative balances and different things right that if they don't give us the money we have to balance the books right anything else okay all those in favor of approving the adoption of supplemental curricular materials um signify by saying I I opposed okay lastly um a couple matters to come before the board first I'll ask does anyone have any other matters to bring before the board this time okay um tonight we would would I know Dr glaze mentioned this but we would like to honor our departing board members who are not here but um still give them minute to just talk about them we'd like to honor Amber rabah and Susan Sloan for their
144service as members of the Tipton Community School Corporation Board of school trustees we're so appreciative of their time and commitment to our schools and community over the last four years the board um has a small presentent um that we will get to them in time but we just want to honor them and thank them so much for their time um lastly um we don't have any advisory committees this month our schedule events uh December 11th is um the middle school and high school band Christmas CC ERT um December 17th is the Y Family Night concert 7 our last day of the second um grading period in semester 1 is December 20th and then December 21st through January 6th is the winter break January 7th is the first day of the third grading period in semester
1452 and January 14th is our next board meeting so at this time I need a motion and a second to adjourn the December board meeting so moved okay all those in favor signify by saying I I post all right thank you so much for joining us this evening have a merry Christmas thank you you too don't leave