CorpusRecord 47857

WLCSC - Regular Board Meeting January 13, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WLCSC YouTube
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Tippecanoe County, IN
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,037 words · about 90 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I'd like to welcome you to our fancy new boardroom and to the uh West lafette Community School Corporation regular board meeting um we have a lot of uh procedural things to do this evening and the first thing I would like to do is approve the agenda for the January 13th organizational meeting which is what we're doing right now sorry I said regular a minute ago so um I need a motion so moved moved by Rachel I need a second to approve the agenda second seconded by DEA all those in favor I will start the look at this okay I will start all in favor please vote are we yeah I'm wondering are we going to have the public comments before the meeting before the organization because this uh there are some vote we are going

002to have this meeting so probably we can move this uh Communications from the audience uh before these things and then we can have has anyone signed up I forgot to grab the sheet I can have that for you that be great thank you I don't know any it' be the the blue one yeah the blue one yeah okay super well there you go yes you I I wonder whether the the CCH uh in voice is part of the consent agenda it's separate for this meeting this is the organizational meeting first so we're going to vote for our new officers and then that will be part of the regular meeting after we SE the new um executive yeah thank you for clarification you bet okay so if everybody could go ahead and vote on whether or

003not to accept the organizational meeting agenda put yes here right yep okay there you go look at that we're good at it already thank you very much that is everybody the next item of business is the elections and uh first we will discuss the president is there a motion motion to um do anything to um nominate someone for the president of the board okay daa don't make a motion of who to nominate yeah but turn on your button thank you okay so first um to make some clarifying comments no individual board member has the authority to direct the superintendent for a long long time this has been the tradition in our School District to have the board president directing the superintendent it's not appropriate and we need to change this tradition so there's two Indiana

004State statutes that specifically address the authority of the Schoolboard president the first is the Schoolboard president has the authority to call a special meeting the second is after the full schoolbd votes to approve a contract the board president and secretary has the authority to sign the contract on behalf of the school corporation our policies in addition give the school board president additional responsibilities including presiding at meetings acting as the official spokesman appointing committees and approving the agenda so that's the only things that um the school board president is authorized to do that's different than all the other board members they do not have the authority to direct the superintendent they don't have the authority to be the gatekeeper of information so we need a board president who's going to follow the Schoolboard policies ensure equal

005access to information to all Schoolboard members refrain from withholding information avoid actions that may cause or create additional liability for the school and treat all board members with respect and prioritize serving the board rather than seeking to control it so with that being said I would like to nominate Lawrence Wong he has a strong understanding of Robert's Rules and our policies and I believe he'll follow them consistently and accurately he also is a unifying voice he's respectful to everyone and he's committed to Crea an environment where all seven members can share their opinions and collaborate effectively okay Rachel um I would just like to weigh in on um from my perspective um much of what Mrs Mard has shared is speculative with regard to the nature of the operation between the board chair and the

006superintendent um uh so I don't I don't agree with the premise of her comments so I want to kind of make that be known my um hope for tonight uh as the most tenur person on the board and looking out at what I believe the Board needs in the future um is that we would uh as a board agree on someone who has completed a term someone who has midterm and someone who's brand new to the board I think that would give the most balance to the officer slate so for those reasons uh because there's so much difficult Y and transition um between board chair I would nominate you Amy as the board chair thank you George uh may I ask Mr mord do you have any examples of directions that you found inappropriate between

007the president and the I did actually just this week um if you notice on the website currently when you look under the board members it lists um Mrs Austin's email address and then for all other school board members it just has the general Schoolboard email so I had emailed the superintendent cced all the board members so they'd be aware of what I was sharing and just said I would like to have all board members have their emails included and then have the general email at the top and share that if you want to reach all board members at the same time Mrs Austin responded to the email that I sent to Dr Griner and told him no not to do that that she wants it left that way so that all board members um so

008the community doesn't have access to board members emails to email them directly so may I ask for a clarification then so you are asking her not to direct but in in so doing you were directing no so the difference is sharing an opinion so Mrs Austin can share with Dr Griner that she would like just her email shared and not other Schoolboard members and he can agree to follow that and it looked like that's where I don't I don't know behind the scenes if he came up with this on his own or with her recommendation but then I can step forward and share my opinion Dr Griner is the one that gets to make these decision and is held accountable by the seven of us so ask himine that's what I did is asked him

009ask him now in this for ask him to do it but that's not what we're talking about the topic we're talking about right now is the president and how they direct the superintendent and this actually happens quite frequently where one of us um will email the superintendent a question and the board president will intercede and direct him to hand a certain way which is act is not appropriate Rachel I feel like as someone leading because you have exhibited half of the email cor correspondence but not put in the last sentence of the email correspondence which was it would be appropriate for us to hold as it exists now and to discuss it in a public meeting so Mrs Austin was really pushing for a public conversation of what we would like to have in terms

010of an access point uh or information about our own um personal contact information in a public setting rather than privately directing our superintendent to do something so I I do think it's important if you're going to summarize that you would summarize the entire um concept of the email and not just the part that that suits your position David just a just a point of order just a point of order the motion there was first a motion to nominate La Mr Wong um we need a second on that we're not at a discussion point and then there was also another motion to nominate Miss Austin um we I think we need to address that before we move to any discussion or elaboration on reasons for what why somebody's nominating somebody y we did get derailed there

011thank you very much um would someone like to Second the nomination of Lawrence UA okay and would someone Rachel nominated me would someone like to second that I'll second great thank you George all right I would like to point out that on um the regular meeting agenda no the no exhibit item between 8 and nine is board training and communication agreement and this was a conversation I had intended to lead whether I'm president or not um at that time so I'd like to table this discussion and move forward with any further nominations for president there may be YES station I'd like to just to follow up so that it's clear as board members are considering who to vote for um that the I have the actual email in front of me so I had sent

012the email to Sean Amy's response was one sentence long we have deliberately left the individual School emails off the website to encourage patrons to address the entire board that was all that was shared in her email Dr Griner responded and said that he's willing to listen to um the request the opinion that I had shared at that point Amy said leave it off the website and then we'll discuss it on Monday so I just want to clarify that the conversation didn't quite happen like Mrs W and Monday's being the meeting but thank you for recapitulating the email does anyone else have any nominations for president okay super I think the way we're going to need to do this is to have a vote on Lawrence first so I'm going to start the vote if you

013would like to vote for Lawrence indicate with a yes abstain is the middle yellow button and no is the red yeah isn't it just a straight up vote on um you can't vote either or with the system though we're going to have to do Lawrence and then if he doesn't get the majority then we'll vote for me right isn't that correct no my my understanding is that this vote needs to be um laain okay yeah I mean so it could be um pick it alphabetically maybe one of you is yes one of you is no okay um I'm willing to do that or or we can just raise our hand yeah or or we can raise our hand I understand that we have the system but I we don't have the vote should be yes

014or or for one person or not not so we're voting Lawrence first because he was nominated first and there'll be a show of hands and then for me he wants to abandon he wants to abandon the technology all together and have a show up hands right for Lawrence and then a show hands for oh I or even just a uh roll call vote of who you're voting for in a specific order sure that that to me makes the most sense in terms of um that makes a lot of sense if we were independently voting for each person somebody could technically vote Yes for both of you that makes sense no that no I mean it it's and it wouldn't be wrong based off of the way that that vote would be handled I think um

015it should these are typically straight roll call votes sounds good I like it okay we'll start with UA yeah so are you going to make sure the nominees agree and that's one thing another thing so we're going to have some do you want to be president I do no no I mean no I'm what I'm saying that's kind of the procedures and then you have confirm the nominees accept the ntion and then we will have some discussions and then we go ahead okay sounds good Lawrence would you like to share whether or not you accept the nomination yes great another thing is is there any discussion for this or I guess no no need to discuss weren't we just discussing but okay yeah feel free if you would like each of them to take five

016minutes and run out a campaign platform can do that I'd be happy to I mean I'll I think if if you'd like to talk about Lawrence or myself or whatever we can discuss right now I second I just want to explain why sure I do so amazing so I I feel um I first of all I agree with what DEA said and uh so the president is not the boss over anyone so according to the policy actually the the president's main role is to preside the meeting and uh Lawrence has um um two years experience already and also he diligently study all the rules laws and and uh he's I think he is war fire and he will be a good unifier and plus I think it would be really nice for all the board

017members to take a turn to to take the lead the lead leadership role and uh first it can share the the burden because all the leaders need to take more time than other people and also it can we can better use the collective wisdom and to um you know each board member have their expertise and the different perspectives if we can take a turn to do that unless some people don't want to otherwise I think it's a healthy way to to do uh to do the leadership and those that's that's Rachel uh while I agree in principle to what um UA has explained there I'll also say that it's uh in my experience important to ease those transitions so as I described earlier it makes sense to have a person from each station so that

018there's a plan um for evolution in our leadership over time so that is a uh that is the reason why I nominated you um because I think you keep um uh you have worked with s Riner now for two years two years one year I can't keep track um and already have a relationship there and a two-year cycle for a board chair makes a lot of sense okay Lawrence would you like to say anything on your own behalf sure yeah I first of all I appreciate I have been here for two years and appreciate the first Mr wait as president and also last year uh Mr um uh Amy sir as president I'm very happy and it's my honor to work with two presidents so that's no problem and uh if I'm uh elected uh

019I think one things I'm going to do is uh I will try to build a more unified uh school board so we can work together for our um uh shared visions and also the goals and other things I think uh we can uh improve the efficiency and productivities of our meetings uh if we follow the rubber rule so that's um not only for the meeting also for the uh policy makings that's something we are uh working on and also I will uh promote advocate for more uh kind of coll collaboration collaborative decision makings so we make our uh School Board the more inclusive uh the decision making more inclusive decision makings and shared the leadership so that's U something if I'm delected so I'm trying to are working on that thank you David I would

020actually like both um candidates to speak a little bit not just about what they plan to do like bringing more Unity but how like what what are the ways that you do plan that you plan to to bring people together and to work collaboratively I think it's good practice for us to have whoever is up for election for this role um to be able to speak more clearly to that um Beyond what's on notes on paper and um and and really speak about how they're going to unify the board okay daa do you have anything to add to what you've already said um yes just even to piggyback what um Dr perer is saying is we have had a year of Miss A Mrs Austin as president and it has not been in a unifying

021experience and so we have seen from action what she's bringing and Lauren's action up to this point I um I believe he'll bring unification okay George I only just got here so I am not in a position to malign anyone I am going to listen to what the candidates have to say and uh vote my conscience okay um I don't feel like it'd be appropriate to say anything um about Lawrence's candidacy I think he would probably honestly have a better grasp of Robert's Rules than I do it's very discombobulating when you feel like people are um speaking negatively about you to also try to run the meeting so when I if I think if people were to go back and look when the times when I've gotten most out of order have been the times

022when someone has been disparaging me personally um as far as unification I feel like this last year has been a growth here in terms of um our ability to work together I don't know what direction daa thinks that I've been giving Dr Griner behind closed doors I haven't um 99% of the conversations we have our procedural you know what's going to be on the agenda what do we need to do for this what do we need to do for that um how can I help you do this that or the other and the times when I have given a dire like no let's talk about that on Monday has been in the pursuit of actual transparency and having that conversation in public um or in the pursuit of not getting people's feelings any more heated

023by email than they already are um I would love to talk through some training options and that was one of the things I planned for the discussion regarding communication and I think I think um that could be very unifying but I can't unify the board on my own and I've approached several members of this board and asked for their help in making this a less hostile and less contentious environment and I've been told flat out no so I have done everything I could think of to do to make this board function correctly but I'm only one of seven and I can't do it by myself and I would hope that whoever is elected to the presidency whether it's myself or Lawrence or anyone else that we all will put our axes down and stop grinding

024them and start working for the kids because that's why we're here so that's all I have to say about that George do you have anything to say about me as the seconder um oh yeah buttons I am in an interesting position because now I am a board member but previous to that I spoke just as a community member and as a community member uh we don't we don't have access to The Insider information and to the making of the sausage as it were uh for what went on in the school board but I can say from what I saw um sitting in the audience in the board meetings it was clear that there was tension and to me I think Mrs Austin dealt with attention as best she could uh she dealt with it as

025a lay person who was not originally trained in legal issues or School issues and she Rose to the occasion by taking the trainings by listening to the guidance from the superintendent and the professional staff and by doing her best to make sure that meetings didn't boil over uh sometimes that can't be helped depending on who you have to work with but I would be comfortable with Mrs Austin as president going forward okay thank you DEA more comments if you'd like to say anything about me what um I thought it was interesting the comment that you said of trying to help the board work together last year at the very beginning of the year one of the things I brought up in the meeting was the dysfunctionalism of communication between board the board president and the

026board and Dr grer and so you had asked me to put together a document that would address that so at the beginning of last year I shared that with you that would address some of these issues that we continue to have and then you chose just to ignore it and it's never addressed it last year so this is just to me more examples of um actions that have happened and so I would like to see a change in our instead I asked Dr grer if he would be willing to meet with each board member individually regularly so that those conversations could be had directly in person and I thought that was a good solution because he was willing to have those meetings so that everyone could feel heard and listen to and that he could

027um do his best to spin seven plates and serve seven Chiefs but I guess that wasn't liked David um since I had asked my original question before you went and you were able to share both um the what and how I'd like uh for uh Mr Wong to also share about how do you plan to do it Beyond you said several what you would like to do and I think that those are all things that all of us would like but how would you plan to do that that's what I'm trying to answer uh Dr pera's question I think the first things uh we should with school board should be collectively uh follow the the rules we have Schoolboard policies we can follow the policies for example if we run the policy committee we should

028follow the open door law to have that Open Door law and say for example if we want to make meeting agenda we have that open procedures so everybody can contribute so also the rubber rules so we have motions somebody motion second discussion and vote announce the result so we follow these procedures and uh so ens sure we everybody whole team can have some open and respective discussions for the key issues and this also improve the efficiency and productivities of our whole school board I mean if you look at the Indiana General Assembly they have over thousand bills several hundred people they can get the deal done very soon so we have seven people just a couple of policies we shouldn't take that long time if we follow the rubber rule so basically one thing I'm

029thinking we need to follow the all kind of rules the state rule our school policy and also rubber Rule and also another things uh I think we need U uh for the school leadership uh team with should more inclusive uh uh for that leadership team so maybe more people get involved and also we need more uh inclusive decision making uh process so everybody get involved everybody kind of ownership of the whole uh process so I think those two things after that probably we will get moving toward more unified board I mean but uh giv our history uh situation I don't think there's some sa bullet we can and you know get the the issue done very quickly but uh I believe if we work together uh later Bel later we can uh build up a

030more Unified School bar so together we can serve our school and the student and also the whole Community to better better in a better way and in a a professional way accountable way and also transparent thank you okay Rachel um I think that um Lawrence has raised some good points I think it is important to understand the interplay between U state law um Roberts rules and policy they actually or and um Schoolboard policy I think they carry very different um but hopefully compatible roles so I think knowing how those things fit together is very important um it is my intent uh should he not be elected for the president to nominate him for vice because I think a lot of these issues that uh Lawrence brings up are wonderful conversations that should be had among

031the officers and a balanced slate of officers so that they can have those conversations together and determine what is best for the board going forward but as a as someone who was board chair for two years I will say that it is highly unreasonable to um armchair quarterback uh the the board chair um it is a difficult role I certainly improved I believe through the course of two years in the seat and I would presume that Amy will also uh improve and I expect that um u in fact I would anticipate that she does thank you UA would you like to say anything else yeah I feel yeah I feel the a lot of things need to be streamlined and uh set up a clear policy and now we have hundreds of policies to to

032build reorganize and so yeah I I I I hope that the new leader can incorporate all the diverse perspectives and different opinions and um and so I think Lawrence will be ideal for that and also again he knows the rules very well and so in many occasions I I found that he knows the rules very well and so I I feel that would be very helpful for us to work together again I really don't think the the presid is the the boss and just somebody who organized the rest of us to work together okay we've all had two chances to speak on this issue does anyone have anything else to say what go ahead I'd like to make Mo I'd like to make a motion to call this to vote in a roll call vote

033okay sounds great we need a second we need a second Rachel oh okay R okay so moved by David and seconded by Rachel I initials are hard okay that means we go ahead and do it we don't have to talk about whether or not we're going to do it great I'm going to go backwards in alphabetical order UA can I have your vote for president president please uh Lawrence okay Rachel Amy thank you Lawrence La David Miss Austin DEA Mr Wong George Mrs Austin thank you and I will uh be happy to continue so that's um four votes in my favor and three in Mr Wongs so thank you very much I appreciate your confidence and um next we will move on to the vice president vote and now that I'm a little more combobulated

034here's what we're going to do we're going to um take nominations and once all the nominations have been seconded we nomination is second nomination is second nomination is second and so on and then we'll go down and back and talk about whatever we want to talk about in our time and then we'll do the roll call vote does that sound acceptable cool Rachel I would like to nominate Lawrence Wong as Vice um and I'd like to give a couple of good reasons for that uh that I think this is a great opportunity um to talk about his strengths um first he has actively sought out training opportunities in two years he has exceeded both uh of uh our other members our other new members and his points through the isba he's particularly focused on legal

035and financial matters and without prompting has provided those reports to the rest of the board for our own benefit um he always responds in a very timely manner to questions he honors the board bylaws such as holding executive sessions confidential avoiding politization of board matters on social media and those types of kind of softer skills um he has a strong pattern of attendance he arrives on time he's ready to go and I always uh have great confidence in his reliability um and he also um consistently seeks out information so he can vote a yes or no rather than abstaining so in general I really appreciate his professional kind of non-emotional language and participation in meetings and for these reasons I would nominate him as vice president I think he will be a great contributor to

036that kind of three-part conversation that should happen among our officers thank you all right I need a second for Lawrence George okay great thank you and are there any other nominations David I'd like to nominate Dr Yin are we doing comments now or were we going to wait till after the seconds you can go ahead and do comments now I think that she she has four years of service on the board has a really strong track record of engaging with the community and I think that there's a um there there's uh been a lot of work that she's done to help uh build towards um a stronger school board and I I would like to see her as our vice president okay thank you is there a second a second for Dr Yin well I

037don't know what if they want to serve I guess I'd love to hear that before the second happens um is my well that's the next question isn't it well in some ways when I'm making a second I'm kind of saying which I want and I don't even know if either of them would like to serve so I would like to hear that so that I'm not okay trying to Lawrence are you willing to serve as vice president yes thank you UA are you you will support Lawrence okay okay well are there any other nominations okay uh in that case do we need to vote or can we just okay um we'll do the same thing we did before only we'll start at this side and I will support Lawrence um for sorry I don't write

038fast enough um and then George yes okay DEA yes um David yes Lawrence yes Rachel yes UA yes okay well isn't that nice to have a uh unanimous vote lovely okay and now we're going to do the same thing we're going to move on to the secretary so first we need a nomination and so you would prefer to do nominations and then acceptances sure I'm super flexible all right I need a nomination please I would like to nominate U yeah okay um UA do you accept this nomination yes okay and is there a second no I'm in the second okay is there a second okay Lawrence let's go let's just go down the row it's easier to keep track of is that okay can we start with Rachel and loop back around to you I'd

039like to make nomination oh okay let's do that then I'd like to nominate George Lyle okay and um your RW George do you accept oh you need a second shoot I thought we were doing it the other way who seconds David thank you um yeah okay so is there anybody else super okay here's how we're going to do we're going to start with Rachel we're going to go down this way we're going to loop back to UA and then we'll do it again and so we'll each get two opportunities to speak Rachel go ahead um George brings unique Insight with his legal expertise and his demeanor and communication uh in particular I think that will be helpful in developing of um minutes and and consistency in that way I also think he is an excellent

040third person to the officer slate and would bring some much needed balance and wisdom to that those are the reasons I've nominated him great Lawrence yeah the reason why I'm second nomination secretary so my obervation is sorry of her first uh term four years uh she's dedicated service on the board she has cons consistently uh demonstrated a strong commitment to promote uh transparency and also a accountability of the whole school board so both of those values are essential for a successful school board and the major responsibilities of uh uh board secretary is to ensure that our meeting uh minutes are accurate reliable and uh through and I I appreciate the previous uh secretaries Mr Austin and also uh Tom shot Tom shot yeah they uh they both of them Ser in this Ro thank you

041for their leadership and also their dedications uh our meeting minutes is much better during the last two years uh but I think um there's still some some things we can make that uh uh that better so those minutes not just a record of our discussion and also decisions they are vital tour for maintaining uh transparen and also building trust with our school community and Dr yin's uh four years experience uh her education and education and also attend attendance to the details dedicated to the principles of open communication and uh gel's uh Comm Community engagement uh make her an idea U ideal candidate for this B secretary POS so I'm fully confident that Dr Ying uh will be is well suit for this role thank you thank you David I have nothing to add I would

042like to hear both candidates say why okay um we'll get there ASA um our policy states that the secretary's role is to keep the minutes sign documents and then assume responsibilities of the president if both the President and Vice President are absent so we need someone that's going to keep accurate neutral minutes that comply with Open Door law um last year at the beginning of the year when there was a lot of issues with the minutes Mrs Austin um had asked Dr Yin to put together a document that would put some clear procedures and a timeline in place because there's a lot of inconsistencies in the way the minutes are kept and shared so she did that but um that document was ignored so I think she has already demonstrated that she's put forth time

043and effort to make sure the minutes are comprehensive and inclusive so I I think she would do a nice job as secretary thank you George well I I appreciate the trust that Mrs Wht has uh placed in me and on that note um I would venture to Guess that most people in this community um don't attend these meetings and most people probably don't tune in to the live stream because it is 2 and 1 half hours of the worst television you will ever find and so the majority of what people know about what we do here usually comes from two places the gentleman with the bandage on his head in the audience and from the minutes that we publish and it is my uh honest intent to make the minutes as neutral useful and thorough

044as possible because uh if the board speaks with one voice the minutes and the other documents that we put out are usually the only voice that gets heard thanks um as for me I think your last sentence sums up why I would like to support you very well so we'll loop backg around to Dr Yan and over the past four years actually I think our minutes have improved a lot and become more and more informative and really appreciate the hard work of U Robata and the secretaries um I would like to continue to work closely with both robota and the board members to make the minutes sorrow informative and uh and neutral and to promote transparency and the efficiency and as Dasa said earlier last year I have proposed some procedures to uh to streamline

045the process in and of preparing minutes and uh I would continue to work with the board members to to do that and also I I have some other ideas I hope we can try out for example every um frequently we have recognitions for those students I every time I was so moved by the uh the recognition notes that the teachers and the principal uh principles share I hope those information can go into the minutes as well because that's a great record for both those students who are recognize and for others because they are role models and so and also I I will love to collaborate with all the board members to brainstorm ideas for how to make the Min more helpful for the community and uh be inclusive and yeah thanks thanks Rachel your second

046opportunity here I think that we all in this room recognize that the board could do a better job and it's collaboration and communication I I think that's been stated in many ways here tonight um we have established that there is someone experienced we have established that there is someone midterm experienced in different ways I believe that fresh eyes are a necessary piece to make that U best progress that we need and George's eyes in that uh officer slate uh are very um they're necessary they're going to see things that the rest of us have sitting in front of us as he learns through his onboarding so um i' just like to remind the board of um balance okay thanks Lawrence I just uh I forgot to appreciate the Roberta because she's a major workers on

047this meeting minutes I really appreciate that and I I still believe Dr Yin will be work with robot and all board members uh we can have a better uh meeting minutes a record uh for our school board thank you David okay DEA nothing George I spoken enough me too UA your last opportunity to speak before we take the roll call vote is there anything else you'd like to say great okay let me write everybody's initials down real quick um because they're new okay um UA you vote for no okay Rachel George and Lawrence uh Dr and David Mr Lyall and DEA Dr Yin and George George and I also would like to vote for George um for lots of reasons and welcome and good luck that's a big first day okay um the next item

048on the agenda is the seating of the board president which I'm already here yes ma'am I'm sorry can I ask procedural questions yes um there's been a lot of inconsistency tonight between uh Mr and first name uh I know in the past we've kind of designated one or the other would you mind giving us that direction tonight because I do not want to inadvertently offend anyone not using a title I have um received feedback that it feels less oppositional when we use each other's first names and I agree with that that it's more collegial so um that would be my preference if anyone objects to being addressed by their first name now is the time to say so cool fun okay first names it is great thank you um you're welcome I may have trouble

049remembering that though my my mom hit me if as long as you don't call me mister um is there a motion with this no I probably do dror Mr or Mrs that's fine yeah sure sure okay um so the only seating change that needs to happen is for Lawrence and DEA to switch places I believe if you would take a moment and do that um that'd be super and then yeah the name tags can move they're stuck but they'll come off do we can do it next meeting okay that's fine no problem does anybody know why seating of the board president has meet motion technical you're officially seated you're oh okay okay so do I need to no okay you could stand up and sit back down I could that sounds like a plan there

050we go okay I have been seated um holy smoke the next um item is C on here board appointments for 2025 and um it has been the tradition for a very long time for our CFO to serve as our Corporation Treasurer because no one else would dare and um so I would like to uh uh hear a motion for Michelle Kon to be appointed as our Treasurer please moved by Lawrence seconded by David um do we need any discussion on that one great all those in favor oops thank you Michelle for thank God Michelle and and for people whose brains work like yours no one else in this room was qualified to do it so definitely all right all those in favor of keeping Michelle exactly where she is please oh we're going to do

051this aren't we that's so fun there we go please hit yes wonderful thank you um the next item is to bond these positions and that is insurance that the school corporation obtains um against errors and omissions is that correct so um Mrs Kon is uh bonded $100,000 and so is Janelle Wade and our ECA Treasurer which is Leanne moner and athletic Secretary of Robin Beckham are each at 25,000 um could I have a motion please moved by Rachel second seconded by Lawrence um do we need to have any discussion on this one super let me reopen the voting all those in favor please indicate with a yes wonderful okay and uh the next item is our school corporation Physicians um they have seen us through some extremely difficult moments uh they share the position and

052that is a their request if I recall correctly they they like it that way um Dr Chester ho and Dr anarie ban kulie I would need a motion please moved by George second by David um okay and we'll reopen the vote oh I'm sorry sorry it's just procedural did it work out are these votes showing up online is it more I didn't know for the audio if it would be helpful to announce the final vote I believe they are showing up right Brandon they're showing up they're showing up there's a little like thought bubble above us it help the recording just to announce what the final vote is so that I can do that if those listening just can hear yeah that's fine because it's well it is behind us so okay yeah I'd be

053happy to but some people might just be listening sure Rachel yeah not related to that I just had to comment on this one since we're at first and second we're we're ready for discussion on this correct on the joers yes yeah I just wanted to add on to what Dr rer said he included his note to us but uh he always does a wonderful sorry always does a wonderful job in uh also Sol soliciting the opinions of our School nurses and they were also in agreement with this which is a compelling case for um renewing this appointment absolutely um okay we will go ahead and vote on the appointment of our school corporation Physicians now and that is a unanimous vote again thank you there's so many buttons okay [Music] um last we are going

054to appoint our our school attorneys um I will need a motion moved by Rachel a second by George okay any discussion Lawrence a quick question maybe update from Dr grer so regarding our school policies update are we going to h a contract with the CCH regarding uh the school policy update are we going to renew the contract no uh I think we don't have any as as far as I understand we don't have a contract details what responsibilities of each person how much u i mean their time effort they will put in what we should do that kind of things so I just wondering is there any update on that the transition uh contract remains in effect until it's finished but that include uh their uh the effort included their uh continuous contract the regular

055contct there's an annual fee I'd have what do you know what that is for the just to be our like retainer yes we have a retainer each month for but but isn't there an annual fee for the policies as what Mr Wong we can look that up and I'll put it in Friday notes but there is an annual fee to it but the original amount uh to the for the transition that that's in effect to get us transitioned uh fully to the new policies that's uh 16,000 uh fees for these things correct so are we going to have a new contract with them or just kind of add some clause on that it's not a new contract it's just a retainer okay yeah I think can I point of order yeah um we were discussing

056the renewal of or the appointment of the school attorney not other contracts right so that would be something for the regular meeting I agree and also I think that's two separate issues yeah the the um renewal or the the trans transfer to the new policies was a separate contract we had with them and this one is um for our general representation R my my concerns uh because I mean I need to make a decision whether or not renew that based on U that's pretty big effort we are working with st and I want more detailed information so I can make well informed decision on this motion so that's why I just uh ask Dr grer update so that is thank you with regard to the appointment of the school attorney um if the board uh

057were to initiate a change in attorneys we would not terminate the current attorney before we hired a new one um that would leave the school corporation vulnerable so um the because there's not been any work if we were for some reason to decide to uh switch um a vote against this tonight would leave our school corporation exposed so that's a greater conversation okay George I understand um David's point about this being slightly out of order but since we're on the subject I have to ask um why did we structure the business so that they have a retainer and a separate fee for some of the other work there's not a SE the separate fee the retainer is typical business a separate fee for uh Services could be an example of if um if there's a

058lawsuit and they're spending lots of hours um collecting information and protect um um representing the corporation yeah and I get that and that's pretty standard but so is there a retainer plus an hourly fee or are they charging basically per action item the retainer covers most things hey I'm going to turn my button back on any other um questions or comments before we go ahead and appoint the school attorneys okay I'm going to open up oh that's the wrong button there we go and that is seven out of seven in favor thank you um okay the next item is under other business and it concerns the board compensation um we receive $2,000 per year per board member plus $150 per meeting but if we stack meetings like we have tonight that's all one meeting so

059um there's also $75 per meeting um wait I'm sorry oh for executive sessions right that's 75 I never count it's about nickel an hour right um okay so I need a motion for that please moved by Lawrence SAR second George any discussion yeah just a clarification no nothing difficult I hope but those rates are uh written into Indiana code right yeah we're we're limited by what Indianapolis pays their school board and I think last year it was that they talked about raising it but um they didn't that I'm aware of so that's you know in in the um idea of transparency I just want to make it clear that this is not something that we are deciding to pay ourselves this is what we have been told we have to pay ourselves that's true right

060DEA my understanding is it's the max amount so we actually could pay ourselves less it's just they set what's the maximum am so we do have some control over that just to clarify okay anything else we need to talk about before we go ahead and do the vote Rachel I know that the West lafette schools Education Foundation would gladly take any um members compensation as a donation should we desire to um rid ourselves of it okay all right I'm going to start the vote all those in favor of the board compensation as it's listed please indicate with your buttons and my button there we go okay that's seven out of seven again one more time next we are going to appoint the education Foundation cannot overstate how much good they do Rachel I would like

061to request that appointment this year I've served previously on the Education Foundation I'm I'm familiar with the members and uh I think that it would be a good time for a change in board teacher discussion I've served there um several years at this point uh and so perhaps you might like to reassign that for this coming year okay so Rachel has nominated herself is there a second Lawrence Second Great uh any discussion I'm cool with that all right oh I got to do new buttons sorry there's so many oh okay there we go all those in favor of Rachel being appointed to the [Music] foundation wonderful that is seven out of seven again super oh that was so much we're going to stop that vote and I am going to adjourn this meeting and we

062will immediately switch to the regular board meeting I need a motion please David seconded by George all those in favor of adjourning the organizational meeting of stress please indicate with a raised hand or no with a button oh shoot I'm not used to buttons there we go goodness hey that's everybody again thank you all right now may we take a five minute recess I would love to take a five minute recess what a good idea thank you we're going to recess for five minutes e e e hi the button I'm going to call us back to order and um it is 703 and we don't have a school this evening but Dr Griner I understand there's something you'd like to talk us about absolutely so today the recognition is all about you uh as we

063celebrate isba board appreciation month our team would like to extend a heartfelt gratitude to the West layette Community School Corporation Board of Trustees your dedication your guidance and your service impact our students and our community we thank you for your leadership and your commitment to Excellence we'd also like to present you with a small token of our appreciation so thank you for all that you do for our schools thank you you're welcome that's very unexpected thank you haven't done anything yet not yet thank that's super I'll wait for them to finish before I go on there we go should we open them now or should we wait till we get it's like Christmas you can open them now but don't forget all right and next we will move on to communication from the audience of

064which we have none but I did remember to grab the paper um so following that is our consent agenda does anybody want to pull anything out of the consent agenda before I get all excited Mrs mford go ahead um I'd like to pull the Wonderland okay just because I have a coup questions is there a second to pull the Wonderland no we don't do a second for that Amy all right we'll move that down below the consent agenda is there anything else that we'd like to pull I I wonder whether the CCH invoices or in the consent agenda or not I don't believe so I believe they were in the board packet Just for information only but I don't see any motions about ccha on here if I have questions then I can still ask

065about it when we discuss that entry right um when would you like that to happen would that be accounts payable okay she would uh Dr y you would need the request to pull the accounts pay yeah that's what I let's do that um thank you we'll move that so we'll do one two three five and six as the consent agenda then we'll talk about the Wonderland lease which is number four and then we'll talk about accounts payable which is number seven so I need a motion for the rest of the consent agenda no what's the the the one I'm talking about is number nine the CCH invoice I'm not sure whether it's in the consent form not it's nine is Mrs cron on the it's a part of the cont payable count payable yeah we'll

066we'll talk about it there that'll work thanks okay so I need a motion concerning the rest of the consent agenda then moved by Rachel seconded by Lawrence is there any discussion no we don't do discussion all right we're going to do a vote with the buttons to approve the consent agenda there we go nice seven out of seven approve the consent agenda now um DEA would you like to talk about the Wonderland lease yes I think Wonderland's great and my question is I know community members have questions about Happy Hollow so I was wondering if Dr grer sense this involves the Happy Hollow building and committing us to a certain time period if you give the community and update of kind of where we're at with happy home I would be happy to do that

067Mrs mford so we are in the process now of putting together a plan to uh collect information uh from stakeholders and obviously we just sent an email to stakeholders so Wonderland received a an email Emil today uh explaining that we're working through this process now and we've all we will we plan to report to the board by December uh 2025 and with that we also want to collect uh Community input and so we're actually working with a couple of individuals to find out a good person to facilitate that dialogue for us uh and so we will collect Community input we want to maybe do a brief survey uh and then we want to engage in dialogue with the board and then we want to be prepared to present to uh the board and we're also

068the people that are using uh the facility now as well as our school leaders that use the building now um we're setting up individual meetings with school related folks and then we're welcoming um people that are leasing that would like to provide us with additional information too so all of those things will be cons considered uh and that's the process uh that we plan to work through um and we're developing that plan now that was everything thank you Rachel my pleasure I just want to clarify the one um thing that I didn't hear you mention was the Strategic plan so that would also weigh into the use of this facility as well wouldn't it so it's it's separate from what has been occurring now with strategic planning it will be tied into that because it

069is strategic planning but it's not the work right now that Mr Jones is doing with the surveys and so forth this will be additional on top of that but yes it is part of overall strategic planning because it's strategically planning where we're going with that building does that answer your question it does thank you for the clarification my pleasure okay um is there anything else we need to discuss with regard to item number four okay then I need a motion uh moved by D second by Lawrence all right buttons buttons all those in favor of renewing the Wonderland lease please indicate with your buttons okay we have point of information I'm abstaining because I'm on their board oh fa enough but I just want to make clear on that okay thank you um so we

070have six uh yeses and one exstension and we appreciate that okay 61 okay um next we need to talk about the accounts payable UA what would you like to talk about um I noticed that the the legal service ccha chargers $837 for Public Access request um so if if I'm not wrong that request was about the messages sent on the election day about the misinformation About Me by exponents so so I'm kind of confused by this charge first of all that none of those messages are kind of involve anybody else and in like involve privacy I wonder why do we have to consult them for for this public request and because 837 sounds a lot also there are about 17 messages among ours but only seven were shared to the public I wonder what's the

071rationale for the decision and then the third question will be can we learn their rational so in the future we don't need to hair them again for I feel is a quite a trivial thing but we spend a lot on this and I feel we have nothing to hide why don't we just share the information rather than Consulting them and pay them so much so the first question was whether or not our um cell phone records were subject to um Public Access requests because the school does not pay for this phone I do and um the second thing I'd like to address is I asked all the board members at that time to turn over any relevant texts that they had including yourself and the only texts that I received in reply were Rachel's which

072is why on the um document that we sent back to that Patron they were her comments were blue and the rest were gray um so if you felt there was more information to be shared I'm curious why you didn't send it to me when I requested that have missed that request okay and uh so so in general the procedure is just because you have the I saw you have the old the message you are in that group you have all the message so I thought the the you know the Community member ask for it then after you talk to the lawyer you will just share what you have I didn't realize that everybody has to share no it was requested that each board member contribute what they thought answered the request and Rachel turned over

073what she thought answered the request if you thought there were 17 messages then that should have come from you okay I I saw you have have them so you will just a share I didn't realize I feel like it was my words to turn over at that point um I felt like if a board member felt like their words needed to be made public in that way that they should initiate that just like if you and I were having a text conversation and there was a public access request about it I would ex I would turn over what I had said but I wouldn't necessarily turn over what you had said particularly after being accused of making unilateral decisions all night so um that was my feeling was each person who was involved should turn

074over what they felt was appropriate and Rachel did because she did most of the talking so the this will be a kind of general rule because what I'm trying to avoid is not spend the money on this unnecessary charge the money that was spent was the lawyer's time debating with um me mainly about whether or not it was an appropriate request and explaining to me how our phones that we pay for that actually the issue was largely because I'm a government contractor and my phone if if my phone gets stolen the first person I need to call is the FBI because my work email is on it and it's subject to um itar international trafficking and arms regulations so I was very concerned about the precedent of turning over anything from my phone to anyone

075and the compromise that she and I came up with was that we would ask individual board members to turn over their own information Rachel um I just want to say that the email request that you sent to the board was timely and was very clear and specific and gave a specific deadline for response which I met so thank you for that clear communication thanks anybody else need to say anything about this just to clarify in the future if the public request any public access to information and uh we should each of our even if you have all the emails communication each of our should share our own version I would say if I send a request for your Tex T regarding that public information request that you should send me what you think is appropriate

076if you had sent me 17 and Rachel had sent me seven I would have included 17 okay so it's not the lawyer who decide which one will be shared and I just want to in terms of email what happens is Mr Hamilton will run a search for key words in the email and turn over to Roberta I believe believe who then refer sends it out to the lawyers so every time do we have to send that to the lawyer because I just wonder whether we can make our own decisions sometimes only about your own phone because Mr Hamilton isn't going to go through my phone okay unless the FBI tells him to and so so for emails then for emails Mr Hamilton takes care of it and you don't have to control it but for

077texts it was different and that was largely what the conversation was concerning so when we share the tax communication and for example rual shared others as well does do other people need to give the permission to be shared or I just trying to figure out the procedures so in the future we can follow it better rather than well that actually flows nicely into what I want to talk about um in a couple of minutes about board training versus communication agreement so can we table this and have that conversation then yeah great thanks anything else okay I need a motion concerning the accounts payable and whether or not to approve it David and oh I just made you decious sorry DP and a second from Rachel thank you um all right buttons buttons there we go

078okay okay that's everybody thank you we don't have any unfinished business so the next item is uh Mrs cron with a transfer resolution okay if you remember during the 20 24 geobond process it was determined that the balance of the 17 lease construction account would be used to make Debt Service payments in 2025 the transfer from the 17 lease fund to The Debt Service fund was included as well as part of the 25 budget that was approved this past October the balance as of 12312 in the 17 lease fund was 2,853 36245 after posting acred interest we have included a transfer resolution for your approval in your board packets please approve that transfer as outlined I need a motion please moved by George second second by Lawrence thank you do we need any discussion about

079the transfer resolution both come up a particular example Amy um I don't think your microphone's on thank you very much um we've had several comments just tonight about communication and how we could improve that among the board um and also uh we have learned recently that our personal text messages are subject to the open um no the Freedom of Information Act but we will turn them over ourselves rather than having our phones searched um I think this is a good time as we have new board members um to come to some kind of agreement as to how we're going to communicate and um when and what information needs to be handled in what way um currently our practice is for Dr Griner and his team to send out Friday notes every Friday letting us know

080what he's been up to through the week um letting us know what's coming what might come up at the next board meeting what's been resolved from the last board meeting and so on um emergency communication used to come out via text but at this time um I will hear from Dr Griner that there is an emergency say there's fire trucks at the high school suddenly you'll start getting a lot of phone calls welcome to the board and um people will want to know hey what's going on at the high school and so Dr Griner will tell me you know somebody was smoking in the bathroom and it set off the fired alarm I'll give you more information as I have it and he'll go handle the problem sorry nobody's smoking I'm sorry okay fair they're

081just reenacting a scene from gree I didn't want to start a rumor that there was something terrible happening somewhere right now um so I will send an email or I'm sorry I will send a text out to the whole group that says check your email urgently and Dr Griner or ey depending on who is closer to a computer and has the bandwidth to do it at that moment will but it's mostly been Dr Griner will send out the information so that if you start getting calls from patrons you have an answer for them which is Handy particularly in emergency situations when everybody is worried about their kids um I would like to come up with an agreement that we can all adhere to and follow so that a year from now when we're having these

082discussions again in the organizational meeting we can say we came up with a plan and Amy followed it or we came up with a plan and Amy didn't follow it or somewhere in between so what I need to know is how would you like to communicate with me because I'm receiving very few phone calls questions requests for further information and I want to avoid the situation we got into with the website in particular because Mrs Julian and I had talked about a particular board member who didn't want their personal information published and so I said to her in the interest of transparency I think if a patron is going to email the board they should email all of us if there's something private why don't we leave mine on there so that they can just

083email me and I can anonymize it and then forward it but if someone has a concern I think it's reasonable and appropriate for all seven of us to get that simultaneously um so I guess we need to talk about communication from the Public Communication to the Public Communication by text communication by email communication by phone yes Rachel I would like to address the issue of communication from the community um and just share my perspective um we are not on the board to serve our friends we're on the board to serve the full community so if someone in the community has a concern or a question about the work of the board or our schools um it would seem to me to be very appropriate to communicate with the entire board uh anyone who is our

084friend and would like our opinion on a personal basis um would presumably already have our contact information so I am very comfortable with just using the single board email um for the interest of transparency and also Clarity you know we've had some vagueness over the past years over what a few patrons or a lot of patrons are and that kind of um subjective language and I would prefer that be more factual if we all receive it then we all see exactly the same things thanks George don't forget your button yeah um I hear that point and understand it um what I think might be a good idea is uh we've all been assigned email addresses from the school district correct yep and each one of those is centrally managed and it's subject to Discovery correct

085uh instead of putting any personal information like our personal email address or personal phone we have a board address and then we put each of our district addresses on there because there may be moments where a member of the public wants to address us all but there may be moments where a member of the public is only addressing one or two of us and even if that email only goes to one or two of us it's still in a publicly owned inbox that is subject to Discovery so you would prefer no texts and no phone calls and everything to be done by email I'm speaking specifically about communication from the Public Communication amongst us is an entirely different matter that we should discuss separately yep okay fair enough Rachel I I also would be comfortable

086with that approach George thank you for sharing your Insight okay David I agree that I think all of our emails should be on the website there maybe have a note at the top that we say we encourage you to um to express your concerns or thoughts to all of the board members and to do so in an easy way here's an email address that goes to all board members and that's where we put the uh all School Board member email okay DEA do you have thoughts um I agree with the ments that Mr L that George and David have both shared okay Lawrence uie anything to add I agree with George okay I think good to give the public options okay um can we make an agreement then just a second can we make an

087agreement then that if we get a if if someone sends a an email to me that is pertinent to an issue before the board if they just want to yell at me about the options that's fine but if it's if it's something that we're going to be voting on or that's going to come up in a meeting can we all agree that if we receive a patron email that we will anonymize it and then forward it to the rest of us I think that would be fair take out the names take out the identifying information if they say you know my daughter make it my child Etc and notate where you've done so but then that way all of us are singing from the same book rather than seven different books Rachel I just had

088a question uh what your preference would be for also including Dr grer and those Communications from us we we typically have always included Dr Grinder in those and I would assume you you mean us to do that absolutely absolutely and the the group border email actually included Dr grer correct yeah I remember we clarified that it's not just a bard of members right DEA did you I was going to say um from my understanding when we hear from community members the first thing that we're trying to do is encourage them to follow the chain of command so I know there has been times that if a someone has reached out the first step should be sending them to a principal or the superintendent and then as a board we're removed from it now correct um

089and I support that when it's something that a Community member would like shared with the board on a board topic that that's very appropriate to share with the board so right for things like that like you know I I need to talk to somebody about my child science grade and I send them back to the science teacher of course that would not need to be forwarded I don't want to inundate everyone with email but if it's something that we're going to be quoting during a meeting or saying I've received a ton of emails about pickle ball or whatever the issue is that's something that I think would be appropriate to send to everyone and anonymize is that fair you could even write the person back and say I'd like to forward your comments to the

090rest of the board would you like me to do that anonymously or can I put your name on it that's fair too but I think by the next meeting we should all have all the emails from all the patrons that everyone else has is that reasonable okay uh so from the public um all emails are going to be on the website we're going to encourage um use of the CC email and forward emails from patrons to the rest of the board and Dr Griner okay so let's talk about communicating to the public in the past when I first joined the board the president was the spokesperson for the board and if the if an individual board member were to desire to speak with the um press or public in any way that would be not

091necessarily approved by but run by the president so that the president could then say you know you're kind of walking right into a land mine you might want to walk that back before you have that conversation or so on just to put a second set of eyes on the information that was going out and I don't remember if it was David or George but one of you spoke about um speaking with one voice uh as a board I think it was you George and I do feel that that's very important and that's something we've very much gotten away from in the past four years so I would like to hear your thoughts on a communication agreement to the public does anyone have them DEA so we actually have two policies on this um the first

092policy is policy 014 3.1 on public expression and our policy states that the board president functions as the official spokes person for the board um isba clarifies that this communication be should be sanctioned by the entire board so when uh board president is determining that they want to share a message with the public from the board um the recommendation from isba is that this information is shared with the board ahead of time the board feels comfortable with that message being sent from the board uh it's not the board president's opinion or the board president wants to say this and only seeks leadership's input or only seeks a couple people's input um the comment of functioning as the official spokesperson um needs to be um involving the whole board and then the second one that was

093brought up was responding to emails from the entire Community um when the community emails the whole board email and as you shared um the president has been doing this the policy actually says the board secretary so policy 9130 says the board secretary will send an acknowledgement and what I have witnessed while I've served on the board is that the president's responding and not only sending an acknowledgement but stating their opinions to the Community member and this is where that gray area is not appropriate as anyone on the board is to State our own opinion and say it's representing the whole board and so our policy clearly helps us see that when someone shares a communication with us the board secretary which is what our policy says should send I guess this way should be sending

094an acknowledgement letting them know we have received your email with forward it to Dr Griner or I all board members are aware but that's where it stops it isn't then that board member's responsibility to share their own opinion um in their position as a board member okay George would you be amenable to sending out that communication from now on if we receive an email from the public just acknowledging it and saying we've taken whatever action are we aware I would yeah great thanks I have a question yeah so besides the the confirmation of receiving the email do we send a followups or we don't do we send what followups to the public if they have a inquiry or suggestion or whatever and we say oh we received your your email okay so after words will

095we follow up and or we will just uh let it go it looks like Rachel has something to say and I suddenly have the hiccups so go ahead well I was just going to give you a backstory um there is uh there's no historically speaking there's nothing nefarious happening there um generally speaking when a patron messages the board chair or the board um there is it's nine times out of 10 it's an explanation of things that have occurred that are factual and so in that case it's kind of uh the secretary in practice could sent an email said thank you we received your communication uh the board chair kind of has comboed those two things along with the explanation or sharing of information um and so I don't think that there's been that's been the

096case for 11 plus years that I've been on the board so uh I don't and that was definitely the approach that I took I agree with Mrs Mumford that sometimes it does get into gray area of sharing opinion um of the board chair to some degree we have to recognize when we vote for the board chair though we are um we are placing them in the role of spokesperson on behalf of the board and so to some degree um their opinion does uh or their method of responding to patrons is is appropriate so we we are electing them with confidence that they can do so but I'm not opposed to the idea of board members uh weighing in their thoughts on that but But ultimately it would come down to the chair to determine what

097would be said in response in detail anyway but I wanted to just offer you the historical perspective on that one thank you daa so as the board chair um there's no special Authority or power that you're given the board chair is given through that vote and so um when someone is responding for example to an email either the secretary or the president like I said it's our policy currently says secretary but we could put anyone in there they're representing the board and so there's not a lot of information unless the board together has sanctioned that as isba has stated how would you want that to be done so typically what happens is it's the superintendent any information that needs to be shared everything is going through the superintendent all of us have our opinions our

098you know thoughts on how he should handle things our job is to share that with him and then he makes the best decision that he can and it's not like one person has more Authority on this board to direct him or tell him what to do we all give him our opinion and then he makes his best decision and then the seven of us through our um evaluation that's when we can share you know I've had these strong feelings and you just ignore me that's where we have the opportunity to express if we don't agree with what he's doing but none of us I don't have a you know no matter what my um role is I don't have no one has the authority to respond to a community member their opinion and so we

099do have the option of community members are reaching out to us as board members to talk to them individually and share our own opinions as an individual but the line that we I've seen crossed is the board president sharing completely their opinion signing on off as representing the entire board and then that's where there's Rachel inacurate information um I would in in my time and training through the isba and and different programs uh I would say laterally it is a consensus that a collaboration between the board and the superintendent is better and more appropriate than um letting the uh or or telling the superintendent to respond and then annually either celebrating or uh castigating him for how he has done that so I would hope that we as a board would have a collaborative uh

100relationship with our superintendent that would not be um ripe with gotcha moments ASA and let me clarify just because I want to make sure Dr grer understands my point was not any gotcha moments um I believe that when the evaluation comes he should be full aware if there's something that a board member struggles with my point is that none of us have the power to direct him he's the one that's making these decisions sharing information answering questions none of us have that Authority would you be comfortable Dr R oh sorry go ahead sorry forgot so I don't mean this to sound flippant but I think that there is a potential solution to this issue it sounds like we need to have a group chat or a slack channel uh to talk about these issues in

101real time and then give real time approval to the superintendent and the board president for what we want said got be careful can't don't forget your buttons we can't have sidebar conversations in that way that's against our policy and isn't discoverable so well that's why I suggest a slack Channel because if it's managed by the organization then it is discoverable yep da so that's actually the purpose often of work sessions is anything that we want to discuss or we can do it in these public meeting um in a regular meeting but typically work sessions is bringing these topics having a discussion and then Dr Griner um making that decision but my understanding is and I I don't feel comfortable with email discussions text messages slack any of those things um open door policy says this

102needs to happen in a public um meeting would you feel comfortable with each individual like let's say we get a an email that has questions that need to be addressed would you feel comfortable with George writing the acknowledgement and then each individual board member gives their opinion to Dr grer and he respes on behalf of the district with his education and wisdom and knowledge are you comfortable with that first of all I guess I'd have to hear an example because I haven't seen my communication with the public to have an issue if I am responding to someone and I'll just make Mrs mford has shared with me before hey so and so said this I thought you'd want to know thank you then I communicate and I haven't seen an issue with that or or

103Dr Yen if she's given me information um so that would I I wouldn't want to have to go and communicate with each board member I would trust that if Dr mford gave me information I said thank you I'm going to reach out to that person that I could address that and we'd be good but maybe I'm not thinking of the right example that no that's okay that's good I think that that would require the rest of the board then to refrain from contacting that member of the public outside of the we've received your email thank you for contacting us we'll run it through the appropriate channels so that would mean that if Joe Cool sends us an email wanting Slurpees in the cafeteria we simply acknowledge it and we don't say yeah I really love

104Slurpees or Slurpees are going to turn your teeth blue or anything else we just acknowledge it and pass it on to Dr Grinder and he handles it could we all agree to that go ahead yeah I think uh most of time from my experience in last two years the the email we get from the communi most of time I mean 90% it's pretty much Administration related issues the either clarification or there some some day-to-day operations it's not really our school board issues I think in that case most of time 90% I mean the secretary for our policy secretary just acknowledge ay we get this new message and then we can forward that to our school administration they can handle that whatever I mean that's their authorities and there's maybe 10% 20% that's they have some

105things about our board I think any of our individual board member doesn't have any authorities we come here sit here and then we have we work together authorities so that's why I think it's not appropriate for any single board members rep to their um their message saying you can go ahead if you want to say something no I was just sorry oh okay yeah so I just in that case we can bring that to the meetings either work session or these kind of regular meetings if there's something serious we can talk about that over here and I think uh that that's what I'm thinking maybe Dr H Dr gr I don't know if you think that's good idea but I from what I can tell most of 90% of them and they for example the

106cafeteria things I can we can forward to Dr gr Dr gr can talk to somebody whoever take care of that and get that issue solved and reply to the Pat the parents whoever and get that issu maybe she can Dr gr can put in some notes in the Friday notes give us some update what's going on we have have this setle everybody happy something like that or he didn't give us any update from my point VI is it's okay that's their that's their authori their business it's not our B business thank you could I make a just a quick comment so the slurpie example well but it's an important point in that some earlier the dialogue you all were agreeing about the importance of the chain of command too and so it's sometimes more appropriate

107if the patron is comfortable and it also builds trust over time to suggest to the patron if they're comfortable to take their concern directly to Mrs Fitz Simmons and then that's examp ex Le or situation they would find that she's extremely um passionate about her work no no no it's just it was a good example for us to stress the importance of that chain chain of command building the trust someone used a teacher as an example earlier teachers want to serve their students they're in it because they love their kids um Mrs Simmons is in it because she values nutrition and the importance of students prepared to learn uh through through their their basic needs being met and so just remember that chain of command too I would encourage and in those situations where a

108patron is willing to communicate to the person through your direction uh where it should go that can be appropriate too because if and if not I'm happy to work with the patron to help them get to the position they need um but the more we all do that the more we build trust in our community with the leaders and teachers are leaders so if it's the classroom or the cafeteria that chain of command is so important because that's how we start to build the trust among our community and within our school Community boy have I seen when I get outside of it I make a big mess so I agree I'm hearing two things and I just before I let you guys talk I want to summarize I'm hearing that we have a lot of

109opinions about how communication should happen but there's more agreement than I actually thought there would be and I'm hearing that this conversation is going to take a little bit longer than I initially expected would it be appropriate at this point in the conversation for me to table this to a work session and call a work session where we can all discuss this with the public if they want to come hear it does that the two of you that have to something to say do you want to talk first and then we'll do that okay go ahead David um I just had what I thought might be a solution okay um general practice GE George provides a response and then um Dr grer makes a decision on if it's something that's a simple straightforward factual thing

110to respond to if it's something that needs to get sent off to um the appropriate area if it's food related um or he he makes a decision on if he wants some quick feedback since we're all using our district emails those are publicly accessible so those would having a discussion there shouldn't violate Public Access law as long as we don't as long as we're not making decisions decision we're providing our thoughts to brief thoughts to Dr Griner and or it's something that needs to be put into a work session and he makes that that decision communicates it to us and then then makes a decision because it does sound like 90% of at least Lawrence's estimate are quick factual things that we don't need to be bringing to these meetings or other work meetings great

111um I just think it Bears saying here in our public meeting because certainly um somebody listening to this conversation could um question if it's our if if when they bring questions or issues to us if we care about those and I think the answer that needs to be stated very clearly I believe that everybody in this group would agree that we definitely want to hear from the public um and we we are that is not problematic for us so we want their feedback we want to know and I think really what's at the heart of this conversation we're having is what is the best way to get them the best answer closest to the child and the resolution and so I just I felt like that needed to be said on this topic while we're

112here on it thank you I agree um I will ask Mrs Julian to get a work session scheduled for us with everybody available so that we can Duke this one out nicely and gently and politely and um we'll finish up that discussion but I think this was productive yeah so um forgive me if this was already covered in previous years because I'm new here but um have the attorneys ever had a discussion with us about what constitutes uh a vote or a decision yes we'll talk about that during the work session too I think yeah David no okay you and just a uh so many of us agree that that most of the email Communications actually U for ours we kind of Le the traffic right to the right direction and and people don't necessarily

113know who to contact for what issue so in that case I think to make it more efficient we can create uh some FAQ sure and uh give people for example it's a food service question or it's a transportation question and who to contact or principal and uh so I think we should uh try to avoid forward those emails to that that person because people will feel oh I didn't do my job that's why I got an email from you know Sean oh that's a fair point I I think yeah many times people I made that point before and many of our students actually families are the the parents that didn't grow up in this country they don't necessarily know how to solve some of those those problems and uh so they didn't know the chain

114of comment I didn't know until I become a board member so I think we should put that in mind and then make it very clear that way people have the right CH they can follow the right CH of command and they can go to the right channel to solve their problems okay I think that's reasonable I think um getting this scheduled and we'll have a less formal discussion about it um this wasn't a conversation that I was prepared to have when I was elected the first time and I appreciate everyone having it today and um I think that will further simmer things down as we move forward um where are we we're on number six Dr Griner do you have a report I do have a quick report as you're aware the Indiana Department of

115Education has approved the new diploma they approved that in December these new new requirements will be effective for all students beginning with the graduating class of 2029 so I want to begin by acknowledging and thanking Mr Rogers our counseling team and staff uh for the work that they have already begun to do uh with regard to unpacking uh what it means specifically for our course offer offerings uh per pathway and so they're just in the beginning stages of talking they haven't come together and talked but I know Mr Rogers is working with the counseling team on a plan and we're going to want to be inclusive in this approach now there's three primary Readiness seals you may recall those are the enrollment seal the employment seal and the enlistment and service seal each seal also

116has opportunity for an honors seal or an honors plus seal offering students flexibility to tailor their High School experience uh to meet their future goals again I just want to say because we're in the beginning stages of planning now thank you to Mr Rogers and to our counseling team and to each School staff member for their efforts in understanding and implementing the new diploma requirements Andor the work that they will do through dialogue and planning now their commitment to aligning our course offerings with these new Pathways ensures that we are well prepared to support our students for their individual aspirations dreams and goals upon graduation I'd also like to give a quick update on the strategic planning process uh it's progressing along nicely uh surveys are complete as you're aware and as I've reported before

117but I just want to reiterate uh that Mr Jones continues uh to look at that information and analyze it put it together in a way that he'll be able to report out uh to the board uh focus groups have occurred throughout December there were two virtual meetings and there was one inperson meeting there'll be another meeting uh that's virtual uh January 15th so Wednesday of this week at 1 pm and then we'll also have a graduates prepared to succeed Workshop uh that will be uh facilitated by Mr Jones and it will be with our administrators focusing on graduation requirements what does Preparation look like at each School level and then how does that information get linked into our strategic plan from there the next phase will be uh to move to goals and strategies and

118development and in March uh Mr Jones plans to present to you all the board um with regard to findings uh information that's been gathered from the surveys and from uh those focus groups and then Mr Jones will also explain and discuss next steps in the process to getting that final product uh the Strategic plan I finally want to celebrate one of our students student author Felicia shei uh she's published a book uh we celebrated her accomplishment by visiting Felicia at Willis she was very surprised it's a real book I'll pass it along yeah I I will pass it to each of you but I walked in with the book she was very excited uh this is what's exciting to me when I I asked Mrs uh Julian to order the book for me when I

119found out she'd published the book uh this and the process from fourth grade through sixth grade or where she's at today in sixth grade to get to this point is really really exciting she was excited to see it I am excited because this new Young author I've got a signed copy of her book I'll pass it out and let you each see it um I've invited her to come and talk with you guys she's going to come and speak with you uh next meeting and she'll talk about the process of publishing her book her mother has already agreed to allow her to come and do that she agreed with me first and looked pretty excited and very proud uh and then the board can ask any questions regarding the process um to get here here's

120what I said where I said I notice it says book one something tells me you're going to write more she getes you bet so she she's not done with this series to be of books she also something I'm very proud of recognize several students several uh her piano teacher different people in the book and if you want to peek at that when I send it around send it down to you you you can look but Mrs Su Stan one of our very own teachers Mrs Mara Brown and Mrs Celeste Fernandez uh were all acknowledged in this book as thank you for the support and inspiration and that is Westside teachers working with committed Westside students so there's RDP in the room today thank you you're so much better than stop aren't we though I feel

121like this is going to be worth money someday like this is like having a original JK rolling or something that's amazing um thank you very much for that that's exciting and uh next we've got Mrs prun and I'm gonna read and listen with half an ear yeah mine's not quite so exciting as that but um claims claims for the period of December 5th 2024 to January 8th 2025 total 8, 259,000 BN $ 4621 including regular Corporation expenses and the W bash Valley education center expenses of this amount 3,758 4156 were paid towards wages salaries and benefits um that's showing four payrolls and um three benefits from those payrolls I've provided the final fund report for November 2024 in your board packets total cash on hand in all funds was 21, 367,000 the education fund had

122a cash balance of $ 6,288 preliminary fund report for December has been included in your board packets but we have not yet finished reconciling the month nor the year in processes I'm hoping to finish that up this week um this week we are finishing up employee W2 those are going out to the buildings tomorrow to be delivered and we'll begin working on vendor 1099 forms as well as the December 31 form 9 thank you this is a real book another 3 years had passed brief like an uncontainable scent almost unbelievably gone the very moment you caught it she's in sixth grade she started it in fourth grade unbelievable that's amazing I'm so excited about that okay board reports first of all I um would like to say that I have a rough idea of what

123the board assignments will be that I've sketched out um just in case and it largely keeps people where they are but if you have opinions that you have not yet shared with me about your board assignment um I would like to hear those in the next couple few days so that I can solidify those and I'll email each person their assignment sometime in the next little while couple weeks um as far as my previous board assignment that was legislative and we are off to a rip roaring start um here St can probably tell me the exact number but there's a bill that would dissolve IPS and Gary and two other districts and make them into Charter Schools um um which we're real excited about um and of course they they change and evolve over time

124and I'm sure that the final version of that bill won't resemble altogether the initial version but um I will keep you all updated um about the things that we need to pay attention to a little bit later probably February and March are going to be um big months for contacting your elected representatives and um that is oh I'm sorry I thought I saw you pick up your hand um does anyone else I know Rachel has a statement from the foundation David did yeah sure um I was in a meeting earlier with some colleagues and one of the things that came up is regarding that that specific bill um raising it to folks in March is going to be too late is it too late if you want to have your voice heard you really need

125to do it soon um soon soon yeah okay um I will you all are getting the isba updates as well right and they're doing them as videos now which is um really fantastic because it's a lot easier to listen to a video while you fold laundry um so if um if anyone sees anything in there that they want me to carry to Indianapolis we're going to the isba legislative lunch and day what is that February something February February 18th 18th I knew you'd remember um and so I will be having lunch hopefully with um Chris Campbell and we'll invite Spencer Deary and we'll invite um Sheila clinker usually stops by the table as she you know circulates um so we'll see if we can uh make sure they understand where Westside is at as far

126as um the bills that are before the uh legislature so Rachel would you like to read the wi update for have aoup things one the teacher discussion was canel in December uh and so for a lack of agenda item so that was not held everiss on there um I did complete my isba board on boarding um you can look for the region board director no will be coming out the next week or so I am still going to try and make it to they've asked it to come all through that lunch I am trying to make my schedule so all those things are updates um but likewise um I think there's going to be some great overlap between am and I and those two roles and so we'll be of touching base there um the

127notes from uh Wendy iser she very graciously provided them uh as a reminder the deadline to apply for the foundation scholarships is quickly approaching that is Monday February the 3 I'm sorry that's not teacher please excuse me um that is seniors who are applying for scholar if you have anybody with seniors please um encourage them to apply um the 2025 scaring gr dinner and auction is Saturday March 1st so mark your calendars for that ultural Center again this year the event website is through the foundation website um and you can check the site for auction items and I'm certain also um the scarlet and bra committee is also seeking sponsors along with auction packages for this event so West Education Foundation board member so feel free to contact me that um oh your mic isn't

128on I just got a text sorry NAB it sorry sorry uh also um this is a really cool one founders day will take place on March the 2 7th and is being celebrated by um the Ed Foundation this is a day to celebrate philanthropy in our school community on March 27th 1855 the town of Kingston was platted at the corner of North and Salsbury streets 1/4 of the block was designated for school purposes donated by Jesse and Jane Lutz on March 27th 1855 Their donation of land and fourthought and planning laid the foundation for what would become the first school in the area later to be named westl and finally um she asked us to pass along uh gratitude to the many people and organizations who made the year end special for families enrolled in

129the backpack program uh the foundation received donations of snack foods kid kid-friendly easy to prep meals breakfast items and so much more from employees of Summers Plumbing Heating and Cooling each family also received multiple books to keep uh from the West Lafayette Public Library and alumni George carus and Kaia Harris provided gift cards for each family to use as needed I look forward to serving on that board that's all thank you and for anyone who couldn't hear you in the beginning it was that the seniors ought to apply for the grants and that the scarlet and gray is March the 1st right yes and the website is WL sf.org correct cool okay does anybody else have a committee report youa I see reaching for your button uh first a follow up and button so oh

130sorry you are um besides this announcement uh for the scholarship I wonder whether the high schoolers and the seniors and the their families receive that announcement as well they do the the Ed Foundation does an exceptional job of sending in that of information out so probably the seniors are sick of hearing about it to be honest with you okay yeah just to make sure because I not many people pH yeah when you have a senior you'll find that the counseling um team does an amazing job of sending out weekly or bi-weekly updates bi-weekly updates that tell you Now's the Time to apply for these Now's the Time to be looking at this we need your measurements for your Capp and gown yeah you get a lot of email to the cas and the students and

131their parents right okay because sometimes they may need a reminders and as for so the committee report uh glass meeting next one will be in Fe 18 to to o00 great thanks anything else from the Committees okay super but we're not really done uh the future meetings will have a possible work session on Monday February 10th that will be advertised if we decide to have it where's the um the um policy committee at have you met this year yet or you going to meet we are waiting on the board chair to direct that okay and so the intent was to get new members on and see if you wanted to shift the membership in that uh committee and figure out when the the timing would be gotcha okay we'll we'll discuss that in the email

132I will send about board assignments um yes Lawrence the you working on that I but I will work on that with your help if you're willing that'd be great the par just open great super yep I know we have a new member with a particular uh interest in the Parks what's that before you have any before you have any arrangement for the Committees I can still join the park meeting right the park when is their next meeting two weeks two weeks two weeks I'll make sure you know before then okay yeah okay but uh I think there's no rush I mean before you make any decision I can still continue on that and then whatever I'm flexible so okay Rachel I'm terribly sorry the December board teacher discussion meeting was canceled but I did receive

133a note from uh the discussion um rep and I forgot that I need to read that as well sure go ahead uh Mrs Hart asked um that we let the board know that the wlea appreciates the board approving the calendar for the 2027 26 27 school year awesome passing that along well thank you um okay the next uh board meeting will be February 10th at 6m and it'll be here we'll be here forever more because it's so beautiful um and uh upcoming dates of Interest there's no school on January 20th for Martin Luther King Day there's no school on February 14th for professional staff day which is going to really be a bummer no Valentine's oh oh that's okay I'm sure it's easier um and the snow makeup day number one uh is February 17th

134there's no school that day so that'll be a nice long weekend I guess that makes up for the Valentine's um next uh I'm going to adjourn this meeting at 8:05 and I'm going to reopen the board of Finance meeting you can't who's the who's the president of the finance board it's Dr Yin but she asked me to is that okay you to announce it we need to make a noral motion to adjourn shoot yes we do gosh darn it I got all excited I need a motion to adjourn George seconded by David uh can I get everybody to vote with your hands I'm sorry okay that's everybody thank you now we're adjourned at 805 still let's have a break let's have a f minute break and then we'll come back and do the finance thing

135real quick okay okay e e e um the first item of business on this agenda is selecting the president of the finance committee and this only meets once a year at the January meeting which means you forget everything you ever knew um in between um could I please have a nomination for president of the finance Comm Rachel nominate Lawrence okay Lawrence do you accept that nomination cool is there a second George seconds okay um does anyone else want to be the president of the finance committee okay sounds good um buttons all those in favor of Lawrence being the president of the finance committee please indicate with your buttons and that is seven out of seven so I will give this to you do you have a copy of this agenda yeah okay next item is

136the secretary so it's over to you next uh item on the agenda will be I will select the uh secretaries so I'm open for the nomination for Secretary of school Financial committee go ahead J I would nominate Desa so Desa uh do you yeah thank you for a second do you agree uh do you accept uh agree to sir yes thank you so any discussions uh for this nomination and um okay no then we can go ahead uh about yourself um I did it last year you sign the minutes and I have input on those minutes I made sure there was good information and then that's it so happy to do it okay thank you for Dasa to willing to S uh now it's time to vote we can go ahead vote so thank you

137707 so Desa was U elected the Secretary of our uh School Board Financial board and the next item will be the investment officer report and the investment the register so M thank you forgot it um so to start off with the investing officers report in our investment register the school district holds accounts with Huntington National Bank and had Investments through Huntington trust in 2024 interest earned on all accounts for the period December 1st 2023 through November 30 2024 totaled hold your horses probably not going to hear this again this is a good number $691,000 N3 C which was more than last year I don't think we're going to have that again for this year though so a breakdown of monthly interest in all accounts is included in your board packets currently the district has five

138certificates of deposit and two treasury bills that will mature over the next two years with interest rates ranging from 4.11% to 5.4% and we will continue to invest with the highest interest rates possible as CDs and bills mature there's nothing to approve um for this line item yes so that's uh now we can move on the next item which is uh physical indicators report and this is always something fun for new board members to get in January um it's a lot of information at once um but it's I think it's a good introduction to like what our numbers look like so um Brandon is going to be bringing up each um table as I talk about it and I will briefly explain what each one means but first of all this fiscal and qualitative indicators

139committee was a established under house enrolled act 1315 back in 2018 to develop indicators used to evaluate the financial condition of school corporations Indiana code 51378 requires Indiana school corporations to present the report on these indicators for review by the board at a public board meeting in January when the board of Finance convenes fiscal indicators I'm sharing this evening are located on the distressed unit of appeals board's website um under the fiscal indicator section you can bring those up for any School Corporation so if we're going to take a look at the first indicator graph that outlines the average daily membership or what we call ADM for the school corporation showing both the fall count and the spring count these counts are what our school tuition support funding from the state is actually based upon

140the graph shows data through the 2324 school year and as you can see the ADM increased slightly from the 1516 school year through the 1819 school year and is leveled off since for 2425 our funded ADM is currently 2,185 for the fall count down 23 students from last February mainly due to our kindergarten numbers which is the trend across the state most kindergarten classes are down basically across the United States at this point so uh please also remember that ADM does not include students receiving educational services at westl yet from other districts currently we have approximately 133 of those students from TSC we can go on to the next one addition stud yes the second indicator is new and uh from last year and shows the demographics of our ADM students broken down by free

141reduced lunch special education and English language learner percentages note that our free reduced lunch percent has increased over the past couple of years special education as a percent has decreased and eell has increased uh the third indicator graph shows year-end fund balances across all different types of funds and we have quite a few um notice the bright green and the light pink for f uh for federal funds typically run in the negative as they are reimbursement funds we have to expend money in those funds before we can get reimburse for those funds overall the school corporation maintains appropriate and healthy cash balances and its funds to maintain operations if there were ever an emergency the fourth indicator graph shows the annual deficit or Surplus for the district for all funds total revenue is indicated in

142the First Column green um total expense or sorry uh yeah screen um total total expenses are shown in the second column with the third column showing the difference between the two as a whole the school corporation ended 2023 with a surplus across all funds due in part to the healthy cash balances that we do maintain please remember this does include all funds including those federal funds that run in the negative so School corporations that have a lot of federal funds um they could actually run into the deficit because they have so many federal funds that run in the negative so Fifth and indicator graph shows the combination of budgeted fund cash balances and education operations referendum and rainy day funds as compared to total expenditures in those funds the absolute minimum percent for the industry

143is 8.3% or the equivalent of one month of expenses I wouldn't want to be a school corporation that only has one month of expenses as far as a cash balance um more acceptable industry standards call for three months to even six months worth of expenses as a cash balance our school corporation has historically done a great job conserving in cash as you can see we're in the 50% okay sixth indicator graph shows Revenue by type for each calendar year as can be seen total revenue has seen a slight increase over the years the largest section in blue is our state tuition support Revenue notice that even though our ADM has remained steady or even increased over the years our state tuition support has remained fairly steady and the last indicator graph shows our operating reference

144Revenue as a percent of the total revenue as of the end of 2023 our operating referendum amounted to 17.2% of total revenue across all funds for the school corporation notice the amount of Revenue has been increasing this is due to increased assess values being taxed at the same rate all else equal without the referendum we would have had approximately $6.2 million in educational and operational expenses that would not have been covered in 2023 so once again we appreciate our community and the fact that they support our refere random um without that um it would not be fun so okay any questions on that information as I said that's available on the doab website um you can pull up ours um I did do a combined um file so that uh it's on the public side

145as well as and your board packets but you can pull up any school corporation's um fiscal indicators information on that website thank you uh any discussions questions comments yeah I have a quick quick question so Bas I hope I can answer it basically I think uh uh at least I heard people's uh want to get better understanding of our monthly financial report also numbers tables so I just wondering uh maybe uh whenever Michelle whenever you get chance maybe we have some one hour two hour working sessions or maybe just the information sessions okay so you can expend the what kind of major expense because our I mean as our board member basically the major uh major duty is kind of overseeing the financial things and a lot of times we have to explain to the

146parents or community members how we use their monies right so if you can I mean I understand that our schools financial is U is uh more simple than I mean the public company there's More Much More Much more complicated but it's still kind of uh difficult and it's not easy to understand so we have two especially we have two new board members and when that it's not rush when that you get a chance maybe we have 1 hour two hour exp session information session so we can get better understand that will be I think so not a problem you know I love teaching about those things um I I would like some direction on exactly what you would like me to share or some questions to answer maybe because as you know it's a very

147wide um very a lot of information is included in that and that's right um we just cover just that little bit in our budget Workshop um but if there's something additional that you would like me to teach about give me some guidance because yeah like I said I can go in about 85 different directions so okay yeah we we'll think about it okay sorry go ahead George I just wanted to know if you've done any forecast casting about the incoming BR administration's potential property tax changes um we so we actually got some good news the other day um so have we done any forecasts about that no um the legislative Services Agency does do a lot of those calculations for the legislators um during the session so they could see what that impact would be

148um but we did get some news the other day that I don't know if you remember and so the two new board members this will be a little bit new to you but remember we had the apartment issue this past year um so apparently the dgf has updated those cost um models and we should not see the same impact going on this next year Eric Gman um is very positive about the changes that they have made for 25 pay 26 so okay okay so that's not an issue anymore huh um let's hope not okay we don't know exactly what that will look like yet um but he's very positive so okay I think the legislation is very hard to forecast because any because the whole property tax the system is very complicated you change anything

149and then the consequences will be very hard to estimate and what they're talking about in the legisl session right now it's very Broad and as we know what it ends up being is very different than what they start with uh but like I said the legislative Services Agency does put together reports for any of those or or analyses for any of those bills that come out that are financially related um for the legislators to see what the actual impact is going to be yeah I think the new governor they may have some things so yeah you want to have we're have a busy year so just a follow up and Michelle's question regarding what people want to learn and based on my personal experience and right now we have two new board members and I'm

150not sure about your background regard starting this school Finance but when I first started as a board member and I found it's very helpful to have that kind of Interactive Learning and uh at that time Karen was my um mentor and every month we we met before the board meeting I asked her questions about the account payable many other things and uh so I think we can start with the files that board members needed to R every month and including the the codes for for example we have a lot of acronyms and they mean different things and that you know first of all read those files second I think some general idea about um I'm talking about I already learned a lot in the past four years but I assume for new board members it'

151be helpful to know all the source of um finance and then all the major expenditures and the general regulations and so it'll be I do believe that we will be doing what we did similar to when Lawrence and Deja came on and um I did a binder I believe will we be doing that again we could do some of that but it's also if Mr Wong is suggesting that some of that occur for everybody for refresher I don't think that's a bad idea so we can certainly discuss it yeah also I think the those interactive session will be really helpful people read the file and ask a questions clarification questions and hear other people's questions and it's even I I believe even for relatively experienced uh board members will be helpful as well I I

152would love to join those meetings if I'm lowed yeah yeah just quick I think just some something for example for me my I spend several hours to understand at when I run campaigns so basically something like so what kind of uh funding Revenue sauce we have the local sauce we have state sauce we have federal government sauce how much we have and then what's the major expense we have so this some say for example the teachers compensation biggest one we have some dat Service uh we have some maintenance so each one roughly have how many three four Millions the teachers compensation maybe 20 Millions something like that so when we have something similar to what I do during the budget Workshop then something like that so we have just have bigger pictures so now when

153we have talk about when we voting for any Financial related things we can see oh this fall into which categories is for revenue or from expense and anything legal things for example the governor want to change the tax they change such such things and then we can understand oh this will be impact some our revenues from these revenues and how much consequenc we can you know that kind of thing so I think just highlight it's not details things so that's my understanding thank you Lawrence three people who want to talk Lawrence Lawrence you got three people who want to talk okay go ahead go ahead um why we all have one-on-one meeting scheduled with the three of you so it would probably be helpful just during those meetings to have some conversations about what it

154is that we know and what we should know and then from there maybe Michelle you make a decision on what you think would be most appropriate for all of us to have as a group and versus what some of us would need individually yep okay thank you uh May and the the training binder that um Dr Springer and I created is still on the box and should be available to everybody and um I have made myself available I'm sure any of your colleagues would be happy to answer any questions the two of you may have as you go forward thank you order com yeah go ahead um I was just going to suggest as well that the isba new board member Academy is very comprehensive and would um I would highly recommend it uh and

155it is um will give you an outside view in other words not a westoff yet flavored view but just a general view of what is a board members role and responsibility thank you any other comments could I make one one one comment that typically for the current board the board members that are that have been on um we will include Michelle in that next one but typically it's been Mrs Roth and me and I tell you that only so that you know that for this next one as per Dr per suggestion which I think is a great idea we'll include all three of us on that one-onone okay thank you any other comments so now we can our journey this uh West laf Community School Corporation Financial Board of Finance annual meeting at uh 8:30

156like to make do we need a I need a motion yeah second okay everybody agree raise your hand yes that's seven oh yes okay say 707 agree thank you which so journey journey the meeting thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.