001good afternoon no good morning and welcome welcome to Orange County's work session which has been scheduled for today Tuesday February 11th 2025 for the purpose of discussing jca assignment of scho students to school and kce ethics and lobbying policy the public will not have an opportunity to participate in this work session to provide public comments because it's not a regularly scheduled Schoolboard meeting no action will be taken there'll be no open public comment period in which the public would normally address the board on topics that are relevant to the board's work so with that in spite of that for those of you who are joining us that are not members of Orange County Public School staff thank you for being here do a quick roll call Vice chair bird member salaman good morning good morning
002member Fant I'm here chair thank you member Douglas good morning good morning member Vanos good morning good morning member Gallow good morning and member Felder is not with us Madame superintendent do you happen to know if she's going to be joining us we believe so yes Madam chair she will be joining us in Yes she'll be joining in person thank you so the minutes will ref reflect that when she joins us as a reminder board members will not be engaging in outside Electronics or digital communication during the meeting so that we can focus on the matters immediately before us to my fellow board members and District staff when speaking please make sure your microphone is turned on speak directly into it very close to it so that our YouTube and orange TV viewers can hear
003you clearly with that we will now pause for a moment of silence and I invite you to joined us in the Pledge of Allegiance and now for the pledge IED Ali to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right first item on our agenda is jca assignment of students to school and I will turn the floor over to Dr vascas thank you madam chair we this morning will have our general counsel John palmerini walk us through both policies Greg Mr Greg Moody is involved in I believe in arbitration this morning and but we do have members of his team here you're all familiar with them and so with that I will turn it over
004to Mr palini thank you madam superintendent members of the board can you hear me is the mic on it may be but if it is you're not close enough to it do you think how about now yes I wasn't kidding I mean you really have to practically be touching the mic here that's always good for Hygiene so absolutely members of the board we are here today on jca policy jca assignment of students to schools there is no red line here for the policy there's been a couple board members that have have approached me saying they would like to discuss school choice matters and you know expanding choice and in areas where students can go to schools and what ways we would allow transfers so what the purpose of today's work session is to get board
005member feedback on potential changes you would like to see in our transfer policy assignment of students to schools you know there's Mr pom if I can interrupt you for just a minute I'm being told that the policy is not up on board dos at this time to see it's there's no red line of it so it's the standard it's the it's the just the policy itself if they went to our policy website they could see it we can have our folks put in just the policy itself into board dos oh if they can do that while we're working through that it would be helpful I hear what you're saying I just you know on behalf of members of the public I think it's easier for them if they're following our agenda not to have to
006find our policies I completely understand but I understand why it wasn't required okay so we'll work on getting that up as you go forward thank you yes yes ma'am sorry so the purpose of this is to turn the discussion over to the board so you all can have a discussion about what kinds of changes you would like to see with respect to Choice options transfers I know one board member had an issue had a question or a concern about magnets and that would also be something that we could discuss here and then if we need to bring back the magnet policy separately along with policy jca after we've gotten your thoughts we can most certainly do that but the purpose was to allow you all to give ideas to staff about whether you want what
007kinds of changes you want to see with respect to choice so I essentially want to turn it over to the board we will listen to the discussion we myself along with Stacy Neil and her staff will be here to answer any questions you may have about particular provisions of the policy but I wanted to turn it over the board for discussion all righty thank you member g i'm not sure if you pushed your button to speak to this if it was to note that it wasn't on board Ducks but you're recognized thank you and I did I was pushing my button about the board docs but I can go ahead and kick us off so I was one of the board members that asked us to review this policy and the reason that I wanted
008to review the policy is in light of our declining enrollment and in light of the competition that we're experiencing with the feses scholarships I think it's important now more than ever to review this policy and make sure that we're doing everything that we can to recruit and retain as many students as we can and sometimes the parameters within this policy make it difficult for us to do that we often times in my experience in conversations that I've had with constituents and residents of Orange County they have to jump through multiple hoops and when I was having a conversation with Dr Su U Dr Vasquez I said you know we need to make it easier we need to make it easier for kids to enroll especially in those schools that are under capacity we need to
009look at it maybe in a case-by casee basis versus a fast Rule and I think that we need to I would love to see open enrollment I know other districts have Incorporated enrollment where they're really let any child go to any school that they want it's a smaller County and I understand that creates more challenges is for us because we are a larger County but I think moving forward we're going to have to have really thorough and deep conversations about this policy and how we can accommodate our students and provide the best customer service that we can because we're no longer in the area where you know you're in a Zone and you go to that school you have choices you have lots of choices and we always want ocps to be the best choice
010for our students and in doing so we need to be a little bit more accommodating on what that looks like and how we do it so I just wanted to review this policy and look at a few things that I think off the bat we can change the larger conversation would be about like open enrollment because that has that makes it extremely difficult for our student enrollment to actually do projections and opening schools but as a district we're going to have to start having tough conversations about schools that are under enrolled and what what does that look like and does that look like targeted rezoning does that look like we need to maybe consolidate schools and those are all scary conversations that it's our responsibility to look at because we need everybody going to the
011best learning environment with the best teachers and in order for us to provide that we really got to look at the cost of some of these smaller schools being open so this is to start that conversation and to make changes right now that we can that makes sense that'll make easier for students to choose to go other to other schools other than their zon schools all right thank you member Gallow member forant thank you madam chair oh this thing is stuck okay so my big thing that I've seen just in my area and I just want to make sure that this policy does State this already but siblings of students who let's say a student goes to a school they want to enroll in a school they're in kindergarten they sign up to get in
012and they are able to get into that School say it's a open enrolled school and so they get in and now the school closes that enrollment and they don't ever open enroll again it's now close I had the situation now this kindergartener is now in first second grade now their younger sibling comes up and they also want to go to the same school just correct me if I'm wrong but this policy does not did we ever fix that where the policy now has the option for that younger sibling to automatically enroll in that school not automatically but yes it's on all our policies or all our transfers that siblings May apply for the transfer if there's capacity at that school if there's capacity so that's where I would like to eliminate that part if we
013allow one sibling in if we allow one F we allow the whole family and that's just as if they live in that zoned area that's would that would be my request because we can't expect families now their kid is in second third grade and the you know younger sibling is coming up and now the family has to decide do we remove our child from this amazing school that we love that we've grown to really be a part of and put them into our Zone school or do we pull them all together so now you have parents starting to question and then they get frustrated with the district when the younger sibling can't just automatically go in so I would like to propose that we if if a one sibling is able to go into a
014school for like an open enrollment I maybe can understand the magnet program if it's something where you're getting in based on your ability Boon high school for instance with their the oh my word I'm losing my train of thought yes law magnet any of those magnets that they have Finance magnet is the one I'm thinking of so if you don't have the maybe the academic rigor to get into that I can understand that then like the next sibling if they don't have that what it takes to get in but when it's an open enrolled case I would like to see that the whole family gets right in there so the wording says may however we do accommodate siblings so but only if there's if there's capacity the wording says but we do accommodate siblings so
015then I think we need to say that because otherwise the schools say well no this is and they push back and now the parent has to reach out and it just makes it a little more Comfort two things I'm going to call on the superintendent but could we bring bring back the sibling language that I just saw that portion cuz I I do think that give me a second okay you had it up a second ago and it was really helpful siblings of a student granted trans medical transfer may be eligible as long as it's so this language on siblings is in replicated in numerous other sections like ESC 504 transfers so it repeats itself over and over right so it says siblings of a student granted and whatever the transfer is may be eligible
016for transfer same school so long as school has an available seat for The Sibling is not is not over capacity okay right Dr Vasquez I'm sorry did you want to be recognized it look like okay thank you thank you madam chair we certainly can look at the verbiage and maybe outline more specifically what how we make that accommodation I am very cautious of saying all there may be some circumstances where a sibling may have very specific needs may require intensive services that are not available at the school and so in those particular cases we may not be able to accommodate because the units that serve them are not there even with the magnets you mentioned a boon Finance magnet we could make an accommodation where they're not they're not going to the magnet but they
017could been go to Boon as a student and not be part of that magnet of course that we have a few select schools that it's District that it's the school in and of itself is a magnet across all grade levels in those cases we would not be able to do that but I think that's a great idea that we take a look at the verbiage and make it a little bit more clearer while still maintaining a word that doesn't say every single child will be automatically part of that transfer and just to recap magnet did Institute or oh is that a good word they did Implement siblings in their policy that is processed through our office so maybe we could just put something like some exceptions May apply and then that way we have kind
018of the out and it helps because I totally agree like if you have a a child with critical needs that can't be serviced at the school then we would say we would love to accommodate you however this school will not help your child in that aspect but we have this school that could I think that would be great thank you all right thank you member for member BD Vice chair thank you the superintendent hit on the magnet Choice with you know allowing a student that maybe is not wouldn't qualify for the magnet to go in and maybe some verbiage like provided any specific needs that sibling has can be met at that school then they could be you know something to that effect and I appreciate the S this The Sibling brought up by member
019foron I think that's a definitely an area that we could make it just easier so it's not in question and I agree with member Gallow that you know we the issue of customer service I think is a big issue and I think that when especially when it comes to registration issues when a parent is new to ocps and this is their first interaction with ocps and it's challenging or difficult or way more way more challenging than it really should be that's that puts a bad taste in their mouth for the entire experience with ocps which is not typically what they would probably experience maybe at the school so I do think that the that as far as that goes that needs to be addressed for sure and I'm all in favor of doing whatever we
020can to make all those processes easier however I do have some concerns when we get into a bigger conversation of you know open enrollment or more Choice while I agree with more choice and I think that there definitely needs to be a case-by casee basis and it needs to be a lot easier I have you know School that parents choose not to put their kids in those schools not necessarily for reasons that you know are academic needs or that school wouldn't serve the needs of their kids but for reasons that we worked really hard to overcome in this district and in districts all across the country so I think we have to be really really careful because I think what could happen is it could just make some of these lower enrolled schools make it
021even worse and I think a lot of that has to do with you know we talk about I talk about this a lot with Mr Martinez as well you know the marketing of schools and how we share what our and we've talked about this a lot how we share what our schools are doing parents need to know that but I just I have some real hesitation with allowing parents to just choose anywhere to go because of that so I don't know if that was real clear but but yeah okay thank you that's kind of what I want to share on that as as far as specifics within the policy I'm not really there yet but I just kind of wanted to get that thought out first thank you all right thank you Vice chair so
022let me I agree but maybe this will make it more clear more clear without be being too offensive in my language so I personally it was extremely important to me that my kids went to Public Schools not not about academics but about the diversity in our schools I wanted my kids in a diverse school I'm from a different generation than most of you and I saw too many people my age that did not have the ability well they had the ability they just didn't know how to interact with people that were different from them and I mean I would I would hear this we had African-American principal I love her she's still today a dear friend and one of my neighbors who was also a dear friend told me she had a problem and she
023didn't know how to talk to people like that I this really happened when my kids were little and I didn't even understand what that meant cuz we're all speaking English so I didn't get it but that further reinforced how valuable it is for our kids to grow up in not just racially diverse but diverse in thought diversity is such a strength to our youth and to our society and I so I appreciate what you're saying that we might have some families who don't see that as a strength what they see as a strength is a school that where their student is the majority and where they feel comfortable so for that reason I entirely agree with you fortunately we're not talking about wholescale Open Enrollment but that would be a concern and equity in our
024schools continues to be a concern it was one of my concerns when I learned that ocps was I'm trying to remember what the term is desegregation yeah when you're not under the desegregation part what is it called unary yeah unitary that sounds so good but in Middle School Junior High School our it was the first time that desegregation was in place in my school district when I was in junior high school and because that shaped my life moving forward and enriched it in so much in so many ways I was concerned about the unification and how much we might lose diversity in our own schools so I want to double down and agree with you I think it is a potential issue and while it may help us compete with private schools there's a point
025at which I don't think we sacrifice the values we believe in to compete so I think we just have to prove ourselves on on other grounds as much as we can I definitely appreciate where member font is coming from I want to see the language so when I read that particular language it doesn't it says they may if there's capacity I mean it's really clear-cut and I don't want a situation where we have a parent standing here and saying you're violating your policy with that family they're in my school and you're violating your policy so I want it to be clear we're not violating our policy I think there's easy ways to and I think it was either one of my fellow board members suggested some language I think we can get to that real
026easily and the other thing that's obvious that in there in that particular section is it's only for one year or on a yearly basis so oh okay I don't know what I saw but it was like the sibling I saw yeah something about the sibling being eligible for only one year can you it was only for certain transfers like the grandfather because if I'm there for my final year we would allow that sibling to remain after rezoning with that grandfathered sibling or an Rising transfer the child is in their last year of school there so their sibling can stay but that's the only reference to a year otherwise they're there the duration okay who's working the t is that can you pull back up that section that you had referenced for us I want to
027do so give me yeah it wasn't that one I mean it was up for a second but bottom line let's just you know we'll bring We'll rely on yall to just you know make it consistent with whatever the board ultimately decides we'll find it in all places and make it consistent ex okay all right next up is member Vanos and I'm going to ask that you run the meeting for just a minute or two member Vanos you're recognized thank you madam chair also just wanted to quickly say I appreciate what was said about siblings I think that's been a huge gap and I think it's really important that we help our families by keeping siblings together and I appreciate what's been done with the middle schools this year so and the magnet so thank you
028also wanted to touch on there have been a couple of comments about when it comes to transfers you know having transfers be done on a case-by casee basis this makes me nervous I don't like case-by case basis I think people need to know what the policy is and I think we need to follow it because I think it sets up a situation where you know if you have a a you know an act Advocate mom or an advocate dad you know you're you're maybe you know more likely to to get something I think we need to think of all kids equally and I just having case-by case basis just makes nervous so I just wanted to to make that point and then kind of the third Point talking about magnet schools this is and I
029it kind of bleeds into open enrollment a little bit too you know a line that I have said when I've been talking to you know State lawmakers and it is public school parents like public school choices and I firmly believe that I am a magnet school mom I think our magnet schools provide some really great opportunities for our students and I also think that there's there's a there's a danger with magnet schools and this is hitting a little bit on what member bird said that they're not really accessible to everybody our magnet schools don't provide transportation and so the only people who can really go to magnet schools are people whose parents can drop them off in the morning parents who you know can pick them up after school if you want to do a
030sport in middle school and you're in a magnet school you also have have a parent come pick you up at 4:00 then take there's no bus to take you to an after school activity so to me the way that it's happening now is not fair and I support magnet schools and I want I believe in magnet schools I actually think we need more but I just want to open up the conversation to ways that we can make magnet schools work maybe it is by having more like Regional magnet schools using templates of magnet schools that have worked in one area and doing them in another area maybe it's I think Transportation I know is I think we just need to relook a transportation period I don't think we can have schools where we are not
031offering transportation to our students maybe we have Depot where you know buses can pick students up in certain places to take them to schools maybe we have passenger vans I'm just throwing ideas out there of possible solutions and ways to make it more fair I'd love to hear from other other you all and other members as well and then I think the third point is you know the other concern I have with magnets is and I think this transportation is an issue but I think it's also awareness of the magnet program and again in order for a student to participate in a magnet school you have to have a parent that knows what the process is paying attention applies to the magnet and so I would like to see more efforts to go and recruit
032students to be in our magnet schools to go out into areas where we typically don't have as many students applying to magnet schools and you know if that means for some period of time that there is a minimum percentage of our magnet schools that you know have you know kids from a certain area or kids from certain socioeconomic demographic maybe that needs to happen I just think we need to do a better job of making sure that our magnet schools truly are open to everyone thank you all right thank thank you member Vanos member Gallow thank you madam chair so a couple of things I get the concern about some schools being under enrolled While others are full I understand that argument but if parents don't want to go there they're not going to go
033to that school and they're that school still going to be under enrolled and they're either going to choose to go to a school outside the county or they're going to choose to go to a charter school or they're going to choose to go to private school using FES so I think the days of us being able to control what a parent or a student decides to do is gone and I think we need to shift our mindset to how do we keep students in Orange County Public Schools what does that look like and if a school is under enrolled then we need to look at why is that school Under enrolled and why are students and parents choosing not to send their kids there and what can we do to maybe lift that school up
034and if we can't lift that school up then that's another conversation that we need to have which is going to be uncomfortable and awkward but we have to do what's right by all students and spending money on schools that are under enrolled when we could place students in a newer better school and offer more money to our teachers those are the hard decisions that we're going to have to make that we promised we promised our teachers we would that we would look at and this is a first step into really looking at that process and how we do it and I often say we can either be Blockbuster or Netflix which one do you which one do we choose to be because we can be Blockbuster and we can keep doing what we've been doing
035and we can see if it works out for us or we can right now start having those conversations and be Innovative and be Forward Thinking on what we want ocps to look like and how we ensure that every student chooses ocps and gets the best high quality education that we can offer so that's kind of where my mind is coming from and to m vos's point about magnet schools and busing I agree we need to look at busing anything that we can do that Innovative Depot smaller buses that's fine but we also don't we don't bus for dual enrollment there's a lot of things that are inequitable if you look within the makeup or the scope of the decisions or the policies that we have like dual enrollment is a great program but unless you
036have access to a car you can't do dual enrollment because not every school has classes on campus for dual enrollment most of them don't like East River maybe has one or two and I understand why we don't it's difficult with the calendar their calendar is different than us and they can just choose not to show up I get the issues with it but that's still another inequity and that's a huge one because that's free college that's free college so those are just some of my thoughts about that but I do want to kind of just go through this quickly with some of the things that I've highlighted that I would like us to look at the first is a number two change of address it says any application containing erroneous or false information be be
037grounds for denial of a requested transfer or the immediate revoke the they revoking the transfer so I guess my point is I don't know if maybe we can be a little bit more detailed than that but if if they're in open enrollment and they move and they're in a school that they're open enrollment for yes we need to have their information so we can contact them but I don't know that we should be revoking their transfer if they're in an open enrollment school that we've already said has capacity they can attend for the duration of of that school why if their information is incorrect we're just we're just going to we're going to revoke their transfer like that makes no sense to me it needs to be more specific maybe to zoned areas and maybe
038we just need to kind of dial into that a little bit applications so this one is one that I've gotten a lot of calls on and so I'm trying to discern which is our policy and which is the that we have to abide by so it says Guardians who wish to apply for transfer to a school other than the assigned school for their child for one of the reason set forth Below in section six must submit a completed application based on the criteria listed in each individual subsection and then it says a Guardians must attach appropriate proof of legal guardianship okay that's fine a parenting plan is do we is it by law that we have to require a parenting plan an affidavit is at a law an educational guardianship for the firsttime students to
039ocps do we need that and a birth certificate like what the birth certificate kind of provide that information I guess the point I'm trying to make is that I want us to make it as easy as possible on parents who are just trying to get their child into one of our schools and so if there's anything within the application process that we can remove to make it easier on our parents that would be appreciated cuz right now they have to go down to dual enrollment I mean to student enrollment and if you're on my side of town that's not very close and you're missing work and you're doing this to go all the way down there and then not have the information that you thought you had and then to be told you have to
040come back like it's a laborous process so if we could streamline that or make that easier that would be great and I'm just going to go through all my things in every single one of these things it says oh hang on there's a lot to unpack in that hang on Dr No but can we sorry can we clarify because that's not you have to add everything it's one of those items and so maybe it's our verbage because you don't have to provide and clar I mean please correct me if I'm wrong but you must provide either and maybe that's the word we need there proof of legal guardianship or a parenting plan or affid it's not that you provide all of those things it's not that that's not the way it's worded yeah and actually
041before we it is the way it's word it's just being misinterpreted we don't have the word either in there but that I mean that's how I understood it yeah so we can rechange it's not that we're requiring all of those things so just legally when you see the word or it means a choice of any of that list if it had said and then it would mean everything in that list but we can certainly clarify it say any of the following to something like that yeah in this case the or is after affidavit and before education I was scanning it really Qui but the parenting plan is necessary yeah the or is just between affidavit it's just the grammar appropriate grammar being misunderstood we have to form prr not friendly to those yeah well great
042and then then I guess all we really need to do is reformat that paragraph okay before we go forward can we pause just for a minute on the erroneous information question you had about booting our students out cuz I don't think that's what it says either but can we go back to that language maybe you could do a search on erroneous what say maybe grounds for denial or requested transfer or immediate it may be May so to I think to your point if somebody has moved and they haven't updated the information it's not a there automatically but theat the threat of it is there so I was just recommending that maybe we reward that into a more friendly tone and it applies to an application so I read it as not a change to somebody
043who already there but an application so you're asking to be you presented your add your application you know where you live today once you get in if you move I don't think that b applies but I just there was these are really great issues and I think this is a great conversation it's exactly why we have work sessions and I'm really the different perspectives but at the same time what I also hear is kind of a common goal so I just wanted to bridge the gap on that for anybody who might be tuning in so but I have had an issue with somebody applied the reason that this got brought back a few months ago was there was so I just want it to be clear and so if the application I mean if I
044don't know maybe we need to look at what what erroneous or false information would be on that application that would be that would be a cause for the transfer to be revoked so we have parents who will put a use a address and they're not residing at that address or we have situations such as where we ask for the Le proof of legal Guardianship and parents will say they have separated and are living somewhere and they are not or we will have someone who is not the legal parent or Guardian provide a application and they're not the ones who should be providing information and what happens is when something is approved from the district they take it to the school and the school thinks well because the district office approved it then it is okay
045and then we end up having further legal situations with who's there to register and the information they're providing is not the same information that they would have provided to our office so we try to streamline it as much as as we possibly can by obtaining the correct information from the parents there was the one situation where the mom and dad had an active lease in one area with lights water cable IDs everything matching and then they were separating and the other parent had a handwritten lease to another address to get into the school zone that they wanted and could not provide that they were actually residing at the address that they wanted their child to go to the school and one parent when you're married has no more rights over the other one and we've
046had situations where we've had a parent say they're separated and will move a child to one school using information that may not be accurate or correct and then that parent will come the other parent will come withdraw the child and then we have a pingpong of a child back and forth so a lot of situations or wording that we try to put into the policies to help alleviate certain real life situations we've had and not always are we able to maybe accurately word it but we try to get the intent so we will work on it but that se ction is we need to see who the legal guardian is we've had parents who are separated shouldn't even have contact with their kids and we'll do an application and take the approval to the school
047and we don't know so we try to help the schools out as much as we possibly can so what looks and sounds like difficulties at time it probably is because if you have everything you need think about a 200 200,000 students if you have everything you need to register you have no difficulty it's only parents who have situations that have the difficulties and those are the ones you hear about and sometimes they bypass my office because they want to go above and beyond to get you know in and if they start which I know you're saying is difficult for some parents to get to us but if they start with us sometimes we can Rectify it and get it handled a lot of those calls and emails that you receive they haven't even talked to
048us I and I understand that and I appreciate that I guess what I'm asking for is if they're going to a school that is under capacity that we would probably give them an open enrollment to anyways then I don't know that they need to jump through all these hoops and I would also and I'm I am sure that student enrollment is but us to be cognizant that when a family is going through a separation or divorce that's already really difficult it's really difficult on the kids and so I just don't ever want to do anything to add to an already difficult situation so anytime we can make the process smooth and it could be that they're and they may not be doing it on purpose they may not know that they need to go to
049student enrollment they I mean I would have just show I if I was switching schools for my kids I would have just taken all the information based on my new address to the new school to the Reg I would never it would never have occurred to me that I needed to go to student enrollment first before I enrolled my kids into a school I just would have gone to the new school so that could just be parents not understanding what they need to do and we live in a society where you know a lot of these parents are working two or three jobs have multiple kids that are in multiple events it's it's they're already extremely probably busy and underwater so in looking through this policy and I know that member front broke brought it
050up earlier but it does say in in any any time that we offer a transfer and it refers to the siblings it does say May and it does say if there's capacity so if that really doesn't apply then yeah if we could kind of change that verbage throughout this whole policy that would be really great and then on C under can we I'm so sorry to interrupt you can we pause and I'm just seeking clarification if I may okay so is the board wanting us to do transfers if the school is over capacity because removing that verbage is what you would be saying and I thought what we wanted to do is clarify that there are some situations that may qualify for the transfer based on extenda circumstances so I'm sorry I what I heard
051Stacy say was that they do accommodate transfers and maybe I miss a part she said unless there's a capacity issue but all I heard was that we do accommodate siblings for those transfers correct but I understood your statement when you said based on capacity to change that and that I just want to clarify what you're as what the board is asking us to change process I'm going to I'm going to let well the chair can recognize member front in one minute I was under the impression that regardless of capacity that I thought that this is what we were already doing and I was just suggesting if this is what we're already doing then the verbage should mimic what we're doing but if I misunderstood what Miss O'Neal said then I so if I can just
052because this is getting complicated first of all to Dr vasquez's question we've had some Dialogue on this the board has not rendered an opinion or a suggestion I am trying to keep notes of what the issues are so at the end we can Circle back to see if there's consensus thank you for bringing that up to member Galla's point I think I also understood that capacity was not a deciding factor for siblings even though and this is where I had concern that language told me that they may be considered if there's capacity so I read that language that if there's not capacity and I hear you saying is capacity going to be a determining Factor so if there's capacity we are not automatically accepting every sibling if there are special circumstances where a child has
053specific needs that cannot be met at that school we would not approve that transfer am I incorrect on that the so it's the flip side of the issue if there is not capacity would we accept a sibling I read this as no like General sibling and I hear you saying is the board wanting to change that and I heard Miss Neil say that we don't prohibit a student based on capacity so can we get clarity on that okay so and you're correct and maybe I it's my clarification so for the most part most siblings are for younger grade levels such as your Elementary so it might be a r a kindergarten or first grade you know something to that effect so we usually do not have issues because those schools if we if they have
054we use capacity as 90% right so we say we're not going to do transfers to schools if it is already at 90% however if the school is at 90% And we can look at 95% or 100% then we will allow and there's conversation with the principles because this is also an issue sometimes they may not have seats in the grade levels that they're requesting for siblings but for the most part we have tried to be accommodating but no if it's a Timber Timber Creek if it's a Timber Creek or one of those over Capac like over capacity schools then it's we do not we cannot however we do take and I know you said you don't like Case by case because we should be doing it generally but that is a situation where we would
055be doing a great and service and not fiduciary to put a student or students into Timber Creek for example but for elementary age students and maybe even some middle schools that's where you get a lot of your sibling transfers we're able to accommodate a little more but yes we'll change the verbiage to reflect but it still is a May if the school is over capacity so Dr Vasquez back to to your point I think you know you have a really valid question I want an answer too from the board how do we feel about overcapacity and are we still going to bring siblings in but I'm still confused by how we're actually doing this that's why it says may because it is on a caseby casee basis so number one if a school is over
056capacity and I will use Lake Nona high school that was at 4500 before we were relieving it with the new high school if a parent had a sibling that a student that was already there on a special transfer and they asked for another for a sibling to then also go to Lake Nona high school we probably would deny it because it was already severely overc capacity now there may be a situation at a school that is not as overcrowded but is still over that 90% threshold that they said we have seats in the second grade yes we will approve it one that applies to regardless whatever grade level is a student that has unique needs if that child has specific needs and resources that are not found at the school regardless of capacity we would
057not approve it because those Services would not be there and in order for us to provide them we would have to incur Incredible cost to replicate the services that they would get let's say at the Center school or at the Zone school that has those Services provided so that's why I was commenting about the capacity issue and in May that we could add a statement that there are extenuating circumstances that could result in a sibling being accepted to a school that was overcapacity and that would take into account extenuating circumstances just as another clar point of clarification Stacy you brought this up we currently are using 90% we were having conversations yesterday at cabinet about raising that threshold so that automatically would in some cases because the school that is newly opened that maybe is
058at 90% capacity and you see that there's growth we probably would be very cautious in allowing more transfers but we are looking at changing that cap that would allow for more families to be able to be accepted okay before we move forward because the use of the term May here I still hear different things so John if you could help us we are on I am on Page I think it's page three my laptop just froze up it's C hang on is some page three and it's the first C on page three go back up Okay C siblings may be eligible to transfer with the student who is granted the scholarship as long as the school has available seat for The Sibling so in this case that may doesn't apply to being able to override
059the capacity issue it is you may if there's capacity so capacity is at this point the determining Factor Hardline based on that why can't we change the May to sh since you've already put in the paragraph the criter for it happening all I'm trying to get clarification on right this minute because I'm hearing that may means we don't always comply with capacity and the policy doesn't say that to me the policy says the May doesn't apply if there's not capacity there's not capacity in it a no right that's the way I the way I'm reading it is how you're how you just said it is if they if we do have the capacity that we may we may allow that so and if we don't if we don't we will not yes member Gallow I'm
060not saying that this is how we should be I'm just saying this Lang this particular language in this section is pretty clear Hardline capacity you can't go forward so if the board wants to go in a different direction yes we needed to change that language frankly we can just take the capacity part out and it's a may but to the superintendent's point of view I think we need to have a serious conversation about is that something we agree with what are the potential ramifications is this a rather immaterial number of people or could it be large enough to be a problem for the district all those discussions need to take place Mr pomerini Madam chair so to Encompass the situation that the superintendent has referenced let's say it this is a family empowerment scholarship and
061Maybe not maybe not this particular one but let's say it is a situation where student may be eligible to transfer you take out the capacity but the receiving school doesn't have the services to provide for that student so if you say shall in that instance then you transfer then you're required to transfer them without having the services so I think leaving the May in there is going to be necessary to handle those oneoff situations yeah yeah I agree but we could modify this language of capacity doesn't count by just striking that last part okay I think we're reasonably member front did you want to respond to this specific issue because member Gallow has the floor unless okay think we're good at this point okay member Gallow back to you thank you and thank you John
062I appreciate that clarification I will just state that in in every section it references the IEP and that if there is not available resources for that IEP at the school obviously we're not going to allow that transfer so I don't think that would be a reason enough not to change the Pol like change the verbiage cuz we're not messing with the IEP verbiage I mean that has to be we can't send a child to a school that can't provide the resources that child needs to thrive I'm happy to hear that we're looking at the capacity because that was one of my questions with sibling transfers and whatnot can we raise that capacity does that make sense so that we can keep families together so I'm I'm happy to hear that my next thing that I
063wanted to look at was number five revoking a transfer so and I get that I'm that this is a mindset shift that we're we're going to have to make as a district and that takes time and that we're not going to do all these changes immediately we've kind of got to move in that direction but my thinking on this part especially a where it says it'll be reviewed throughout the year upon the review if there's incidences of excessive tardiness absentee is in referrals disciplinary action blah blah blah that we can they the transfers may be revoked we wouldn't ever revoke somebody from their Zone School we're not allowed to so if they're in one of Orange County Public Schools and we've allowed that transfer I don't think that this should be a criteria for a
064student to be removed from that school I think that this is something that should be handled like it would be in any Zone school that we have like if disciplinary action needs to be taken then disciplinary action needs to be taken if they need to go on an absentees in plan or the truy officers need to be involved then we involve the truy officers but I believe that this student should be treated at this school as any other student is treated at any Zone school because it's still our school they're still a student of Orange County Public Schools that's my personal opinion I don't I just I think that just makes sense to me I don't know how the board feels about it but that's how I feel and then we've already talked about all
065the Maze and the overc capacities and then on the academic transfer so I'm on page four at e it says transfer timeline submitted February 1st through April 30th of each year I hate to interrupt you just give me the previous one just give me the location of it oh the one yeah oh on the one on the transfers that was page two number five okay thank you is that time frame written in stone is that something that we would be able to work with or no that is something that's not law based that's something that we've done policy-wise on that time frame but I but I would turn it over to Stacy on logistical issues that it may cause so academic transfers are based on a continuation of certain courses from middle school to high
066school so what happens is if you were in if you're in an Orange County Public School trying to continue whatever is not offered at your Zone school and you get a transfer to a school that's offering Mandarin right so to transfer a student mid year after school is started in Mandarin would not be academically sound I guess but if you're coming from another state another County another country and you were in Mandarin and now you're transferring yes we would we would we would allow that exception is but that exception is not listed in the policy unless I missed it so maybe we could add that exception to people coming from other districts or outside the state if they want to do midyear academic transfers that we wouldn't hold them to that date and the when
067we look at consistency I only brought that up because open enrollment is open year round for for any school underc capacity so just for the stake of being consistent I don't want to create a hardship for student enrollment but is that something we can look at maybe the answer is no but I would like us to at least have that conversation or look at it and then in that same area it says you have to have a SE better and if you don't have a SE better then you're you can get you can lose your academic transfer and again we wouldn't kick a student out of their Zone school if they have a Seer better we're going to work with them we're going to help them we're going to get them tutoring we're going to
068try to lift the student up we're not going to discipline them by removing them from the school so I don't think we should be doing that for transfers I don't think that students on a transfer should have different rules apply to them than students that are zoned I get at one time we looked at this was a privilege we were this was a privilege for you to go to the school but I just don't think we're any longer in a place where we can look at a student and say well this is a privilege it's a it's it's something that we just need to do in my opinion may I Madam chair please well I will tell you that the two that you've just recently brought up are ones that our principles and our teachers
069would have grave concerns with a teacher who has a child that is failing not turning in assignments not coming to school now you're asking her or him for a child that has chosen to come to that school has asked to come to that school to exert additional energy not that they already aren't doing it but they're there on a transfer and so I know from from years of being not even just a principal but a principal supervisor the acade chief academic officer and Deputy superintendent this is one and Stacy you could probably chime in that's one that they use to be able to get the children to come to school to help to get the children to take advantage of tutoring Services and so I know that would be one th those two would be
070ones of grave concern to principes and teachers and may I just chime in with the attendance and discipline so what we've observed is when we give the transfer and parents choose schools that they're not able to get them to what happens is they have excessive absenteeism or excessive tardiness and that causes A disruption to the classroom when they're coming in late and they've missed a lot of work so it's kind of what's the word I'm looking for a chain effect if I'm if I'm missing first period or and coming in for second then I'm going to start failing first period so if they're at their Zone school which they could get to either by bus or because it's within the proximity of their home then they're on time they're choosing to escape sometimes and I
071probably shouldn't say that word discipline that's going on at their Zone school so that's why that was put in for a lot of reasons thank you and if I may if they're not coming to school they're absent or they're tardy they're missing instruction which is the whole point of why they're coming to school we exist to be able to educate our children so if they have excessive absences or tardies because they cannot get their child to school then that defeats the purpose of why we're here now board member Vos brought up the whole Transportation issue I think that if Transportation Were Somehow fit into the equation that would be different thank you Dr Vasquez and Miss Neil and I do I understand what you're saying and I think that's fair and I think it goes
072back to what I said earlier about a mind shift and I want to be very clear that I'm not here to create more burdens for principles or for teachers but if we had an attendance problems at the Zone school we would handle those attendance problems we have a lot of attendance problems from school from students that go to that school and we have to deal with it or they face the consequences whatever those consequences are I just don't I guess in my mind I don't see why it's different and I'm not so certain that if we revoked the academic transfer that child would go back to their Zone school there's no guarantee that they would go back to their Zone school they have so many other choices and so many options to do and so
073we could lose that child altogether again this is CH I'm not saying everything changes at once I'm just saying maybe we just start having that conversation and maybe we start and see how we can get to a place that we're servicing children well no matter where they are because you have teachers every day that have students that aren't showing up that you have students that are discipline problem that you they have students that are struggling and they still have to figure out to teach that student without any recourse of that student being moved somewhere other than there if there is a disciplinary issue and then they're they're expelled or suspended or whatnot so I'm not saying we have to get there today or this week I'm just saying these this is what I would like
074to see us discuss as as we move forward it can I just also add and I apologize before a revocation happens there's a process or there are processes that have to happen so it's not just oh Johnny or su's late you know and we're going to revoke it's a process before a transfer is revoked so all the steps that are taken at their Zone school where they're put on the plan and they have the attendance meetings and things all of that happens and has to happen and the principles and administrators have to show you know that they've done this and put the family on a contract before a you know a transfer is so we put forth every effort to yes ma'am okay awesome thank you can I just I'm in trying to figure out
075the best way to run this meeting you've brought up a lot of issues I really like for us to be able to focus on them one at a time okay while they're fresh in everybody's mind and see where the board is what I fear is going to happen is member bird is next she might respond to some she might have some new ones at least from the standpoint of chairing this meeting it is going to be very difficult to land the plane I think I think member Gallow you mentioned I don't think we're going to be honest I don't think we're going to land the plane on anything today from the standpoint obviously it's a work session we're not going to make a final decision but I don't think given the amount of time we
076have left that we're going to even have a chance to really come to consensus so I just have two things at left and then I can be done and then okay okay however you choose to go forward sh okay and you have notes down I'm working really hard to keep up with you but okay good so Academic Year completion transfer it says that I'm sorry page and nine okay thanks I think that's a j and it talks about number three eligibility and about Academic Year completion transfer and it says the transfer a says the transfer is only their duration of their current school year so I was just curious if there is capacity at that school why why is it only one school year and could we allow that student to stay if it's not
077an over capacity school and then finally my last one is the Hope Scholarship do we it's in our policy does a Hope Scholarship still exist or did the hope get put in with the FES there is still a Hope Scholarship statute that is on the books I think it has been folded within the FES program for administration funding and all that but yes Hope Scholarship for you know students who are bullied and who have made or who have made allegations of bullying harassment is still statutorily there thank you thank you that's all chair thank you so much for indulge me for that's all that and can I just address the Academic Year so the Academic Year completion we came up with a name it used to be the midyear transfer but that was confusing so
078what happens is the parent has moved out of the Zone in and they may have moved out of County or whatever the situation is it's a code in Skyward where we can update the address to allow the student to remain at that school until the end of the school year and then if the school is on the controlled open enrollment or they're Rising you know cuz they're completing they can apply for the next year's transfer to remain but it's only at that time of the year that we're able to do this code in Skyward so it's a little method behind the madness thank you that makes s thank you so much okay let's let's do this I'm going to take you all in the order that you're here to the extent that you responding to
079one of the issues brought up by member Gallow kind of flagged that for me so I can keep track of it to the extent it's a new issue let me know that as well when we start okay and okay let's start with Vice chair thank you chair yeah I'm going to comment on something one thing that yeah she talked about but also something that was brought up about magnet schools okay and I also do agree that there we'll never lay on the plane on this but I think that this is a great starting point of this conversation going have to have multiple conversations about this for sure and I think somebody's going to have to watch this video or transcribe it okay so as far as the magnet schools I completely agree with you and
080I've been talking about this since I got on the board actually six years ago that I have always felt like our magnet programs are while they are wonderful and my child took advantage of a great one at the Boon law magnet but again I was able to drive her 45 minutes every morning that being said I think that what one thing that I've always that I've talked to even the superintendent about is that I believe that we really do need to look at our magnet programs assess which ones are successful which ones are doing really well and then look at replicating those ones that are good I also really feel like magnet programs need to be run through the district and not at a school by school basis because the concern there is when that
081teacher who's running that program leaves the school then the magnet program falls apart if the magnet program is not a program that has you know real strong like curriculum guidelines and you know hard rails and everything else that's really monitored then I think that's a real issue what I would like to see happen is the most successful ones be replicated and then put in regionally and then I agree with you that we have to provide some kind of Depot pickup or you know whatever we can do because otherwise it is just one more area that the halves and haves Nots get to participate in and I think they're really great and I would love to see more of our kids be able to do that so I agree with you on that as far as
082the overc capacity with the mag with with the schools and transfers my question to that is you know why some of these really overc capacity schools have magnet programs and have allowed transfers in for some reason so if we do that then why would we not allow The Sibling would be my question and you know like when my daughter went to the Boon magnet I didn't my other child was not in high school they were too far separated but had she been I don't know how I would have done you know two separate across towns I wouldn't have I would have either pulled or I would have I don't know want I would have wanted to get her in that school as well but if you know they are not on the open capacity list
083that's an issue so my question to that is why would we approve any transfer into an overc capacity School period in of story like why would we even do why are we even doing magnet programs into a school that is severely overcrowded if we're not willing to at least allow the siblings to continue in that school so that's my question about that I am also very concerned about the revoc revoca re revocation yeah yes thank you revoking transfers because my concern with that is that they can be a little selective and I don't know that they are I'm just saying they could be and while I understand that you know there's this concern with you know maybe a child that's not putting forth any effort causing dis major discipline issues and all of those things
084and they're but they're there by choice I don't I agree with member Galla that I'm not really understanding how that's any different then we pull that child out of that transfer and put them back in his own school and now that school has to deal with the same child that is not putting forth effort and causing all kinds of discipline problems we I think we have two revocations so I want to be are we talking about revocation for Behavior are we talking about revocation for not meeting well I or both no the r it says in there that it can revoke based on excessive tardies okay okay that one referrals for disciplinary action and I know I've had one that there was a lot of discipline issues so I don't I don't like the idea
085of schools picking and choosing which students they serve I guess is kind of based on discipline or attendance I do understand them you know not being able to provide the transportation to get there and I think that's where you know a lot of counseling and conversations happen maybe this isn't the best choice for your child to be here if you know that kind of thing and I get that we try to do that but I just have a little bit of concerns about it being used not always in the best interest of the child but maybe the best interest of the school and so that's where that concern comes from for me and that's it for me thank okay perfect thank you member Salam monka thank you chair okay a couple of things one Stacy
086I've worked with you I did have like n a high school and the beauty of a lot of overedit school so I just want to say thank you because you have it's been great to work with you I know that there's Nuance in the process and you've always shown up in a way that at least in my cases thinks about the full family and the full student so thank you for that and your team and I know that there's a lot coming and every case is interesting the part where we talk about the denial of an application and it talks about being false and erroneous I treat those a little bit different and I want us to treat them maybe more explicitly different right there is an application that is false and I've had parents
087that do change addresses and do kind of not they're not transparent and it's clear that they just want to stay in these schools and this is kind of false information but there are a lot of parents that are overwhelmed by the process and just create errors in the application and when we deny such application sometimes it can't can be really confusing and I found that there's a lot of back and forth with the errors like they provided the wrong document or the wrong thing and so one I think being more explicit about the list of documents being explicit about what's an and or an or any of is really important and that's just like communication of this and the policy and then the material we have but when there are errors that are not perceived
088to be just falsehoods I think there is a place where and I know say you work on it Case by case on like this is what it is but in general if we know what are the most common errors on these applications I think providing some more tips or advice or understanding of like hey we see these common errors all the time and we could save on rollan team a lot of time if we just tell parents these are the most common errors in applications make sure you address them that's not a policy thing but I think it could go a long way in saving us time and I do want us to separate falsehoods from aonia mistakes in these applications so that's one I agree with member Gallow that because we have all this
089IP language there is it's it's clear that if it is IP or other accommodations it's pretty clear so I think in the other areas we can be a little bit more explicit in terms of revoking so one of the issues I have with that one if we can go to number five on revoke page five yep right there thank you disciplinary action I think here I'm fine with keeping it in terms of of course if a student's having a lot of this if we keep it I just want us to be more explicit we have levels of discipline and I think there are levels that perhaps we can come back from and levels that we can't right I don't want a student being revoked over level one or level two and then having selective enforcement
090of what we revoke or not not saying that it's happening but I would appreciate if we do keep this disciplinary action component let's be clear about level 3es or level fours like we've done some thoughtful thinking on discipline it for a reason so I'm all for making it more clear when it comes to tardiness an absentismo program that was only AA available at Lake George Elementary but it wasn't at McCoy Elementary at the time and I had to like ride my bike instead of like I didn't have transportation because I wasn't zoned for it but the reason I was going was because McCoy didn't have the English language component that I needed for like full immersion to like learn English and I really wanted to learn English but I was in second third grade and
091what I do remember was I had to ride my bike one time my bike got stolen like I didn't live in a great place my back was stolen and I was tardy like multiple days cuz instead of bike I had to like walk to school there were times when things just happened and I had to be absent but one of the things that I always thought as a student was like as long as my grades are up to par I hope my tardiness and absentismo wouldn't hurt me and so like I do like when it comes to equity here what I want to maybe just make sure we're not doing as as long as a students's performance academic performance is up to par in some way and I know we have like C or above
092as maybe the threshold based on some other place in this document I'm I'm I don't want tardin as an absentismo a transfer I understand disciplinary action especially if we're talking like a magnet school or some reason where like you are taking the seat of another student that you know isn't getting Level threes and level four so like I'm okay with keeping disciplinary action but I do want to be very mindful tardiness and absenteeism because I understand it can be a burden on staff and catching up but some of these students are they're just they're just trying their best on academically and if they're providing their own transportation like it's just it's hard that's my point on that one let's see what else to to to clarify on that one this language though doesn't say that'll
093be revoked as says it may which encompasses it may not be as clear as you like but it does encompass the discretion of the school yeah I have concerns with discretion that you could override academic performance with absentismo over writing academic performance got it okay that's my preference yeah no I understand the other one is so on the academics of see or better like I'm I think I'm I'm with Gallow in that privilege is a little bit out the door as we try to be competitive but if a student is taking the seat of another student that is in that zone for a magnum program or Academic Program I'm okay with having that academic standard I don't know if it's C I don't know like I don't know what that GPA component is I definitely
094defer to staff and teachers and principles on that but yeah I I believe that if a student is doing well regardless they should be given the benefit of the doubt in some of this other stuff and that's just maybe from my own experience why I thought about it that way because live happens and some of this stuff goes down but as long as you're kind of trying your best and working at it I believe we should not be so harsh on that let's see what else do I have Okay so this goes to the broader conversation ju thank you member Gallo for bringing this conversation up because I also worry a lot about our competitiveness and I believe that the enrollment office is mostly just the referee on the policy but they're not really kind
095of it's our job to be thinking big about what we're doing to stay competitive and I'm almost curious in our ways of getting creative and I know member V has mentioned a few things that we could do like what if we start having more of like an enrollment marketplace where it's like not this year but one or two years out parents know that they want to go to Boon legal or Boon finance and they kind of put a bid in this arbitrary enrollment Marketplace and another parents wants to go get out of Boon to go to wiip park and we start having a little bit more of a predict approach to enrollment but it's kind of swapping of the seats of parents that are both kind of opting in to do this that allows the
096data to be cleaner predictive I don't know if other districts have done it but I can imagine there's some world where we have a year or two head start on a enrollment Marketplace so that would be one of the things I would consider there could be a world with attached with this enrollment Marketplace we also speak to transportation and you know if there's enough people from this one school or some service that we can attach to this enrollment Marketplace I think my priority would be to keep these dollars in the district and so I'm sure that if we can keep these folks who would otherwise go outside of Orange County maybe there's some Transportation leeway we have on providing it for this call it enrollment Marketplace but that's just me being a little creative and
097Innovative here and we'll let the folks that know how that would be implemented thank you perfect member front thank you this really has been a great conversation and I think there's a lot to unpack you know we've been talking about a lot of different things The Sibling transfer definitely is like top on my list I think if we're allowing a sibling in if we're if we're if there's open enrollment M or a student is allowed to go to a school because they've transferred they meet all the criteria any sibling attached to that whether they're a step but I to me they would need to like live in their home or be a part of their family like I know some are like they're there for the week and then they're with another parent for the
098week but somehow they're very integrated with the family they should just be allowed to go in as if they're zoned for that School the same way we wouldn't say hey we're at capacity now I'm sorry I know you're zoned for our school but our school is at capacity we just now are over capacity so to me once we I hope that makes sense but once a student is we've deemed them like okay yes you're eligible to transfer you've got all the stuff any sibling coming up should be allowed to as long as that child is in that school I feel like The Sibling should be allowed to attend as long as they have I don't know if there's some you know crazy something where they don't have what they need like what member salaman was
099saying with the esol like if there's something like that where hey this I know you want to come here but I think this school over here might be a better fit for your family something we could discuss one question I do have is do all parents have to go through your department in order to enroll their child in school no one comes to the office to enroll okay that goes enrollment happens directly at the schools okay that's what I thought and transfers come through our office yes okay so I think that's maybe where some of the confusion could come from then if there's a parent that's like I want to transfer I don't know if that ever happens where now they're going to the school if they go to the school and say I want
100to transfer the school then directs them to your office correct yes okay that's all I mean hence the name student enrollment well no no I get you but I think there was some questions here that there was some confusion and parents weren't understanding where to go so I think that makes sense and I think as long as the schools are because that's really the touch point for our parents they're going to go to their local school talk with them and as long as the school is directing them to your office there should not be an issue let me see what else I have put here okay the change of address one question I do have I've noticed this year I had this issue but I've had it before but so Midway through the year there's
101almost like an address check is that correct or no so we're currently doing audits at certain schools I mean we're going to do them all but we're you know systematically doing audits so yes parents do have to provide updated proof of an address and the rising fifth graders going into middle school and the rising eighth graders going into High School have to provide proof of their updated residents and that's only because our system allows parents to just roll you know once students in roll they just roll from grade to grade school to school so we're doing the checks now and we started with fifth grade you know the rising grades would it be helpful at all where every year a parent has to just submit one proof of address every year before you can continue
102with the year you would just provide that is what is supposed to happen however we have have a registar turnover and it gets hard for them to keep up with who they have so we said this would be a way to start working at getting it's a culture change it is I think Gallow said it and what we're doing is we set with a lot of this is we set a bar and it's the hopes that people will rise to it not saying it is going to make it you know but we don't want to give that out to parents so easily so yes it is what is required or should be done and the parents are supposed to do it every year but they do not MH okay is there a way so I
103had and maybe we this is something we could discuss but I had a student this year was in the middle of her senior year parents moved out of you probably remember this one so moved out of County and she wanted to remain at her school to graduate with the school that she had gone to for the last three and a half years that is a decision that the parents made to move out of County however is there a way for us to do some sort of exception we make the exceptions the problem is once again we have policies and procedures in place and we try to have hold parents accountable and the reason is during Co a lot of families bought houses out of County so we're talking about 2021 2020 and they have not
104been in the county for four or five years and so when it is finally brought to our attention we address it we work with them as much as we possibly can right especially for seniors but the problem is the parents are not forthcoming with the information and they get mad because they get caught so but we have we have things in place that we try to work with parents but we have to have it in writing no I get you I get you and I think we do have to have rules and otherwise people would just run all over us and take advantage of every situation so I'm all about having the rules just curious about that one and then I just wanted to say I do agree with member Salam monka that I think
105we should really focus on that the academic performance over a tardiness or absenteeism I think having your own personal experience that's really helpful because it helps us kind of put it into the perspective of a like a lens of a child so it's not necessarily that they're just not wanting to show up or or whatnot sometimes there really is those circumstances and I think when you're looking at a kid so let's say your mom were able to drive you but she was had to get another sibling to a different school and then by the time she got you to your school you're a little late every day well it's not your fault and it's you know in that sense so I do think as long as the student is achieving those High academic standards that
106we're looking for at least to see I don't know if that's really high but that whatever the standard is set that we've got I think that would be great but I think my biggest thing for me on this is just that the siblings of students that they would be allowed to come in just can I add this so two things a c is a 2.0 GPA right you need a 2.0 GPA to graduate anything below that Miss Neil I'm sorry I I don't I apologize for here's my concern we have 14 minutes we have a hard stop at noon cuz we have a lot on our plate we have two more board members who haven't been heard at all so and we're not going to land the plane so I really want to hear from
107these two board members if we could and I'm going to ask both more board members member Fel Felder member Douglas to be as concise as possible in your comments so we can hear from each of you member Felder you recognized thank you first of all I'd like to thank Miss Neil and her team cuz I have been in and out of their office regarding some constituents within my district and some who are not in my district regarding the transferring of students and going to schools let me just say this there was a situation that they attended to the need of a family that I was so happy about because the the English was null and void and Miss Neil it was 4:30 5:00 in the evening on a Friday and she was able to get
108a get a translator like through her phone or whatever to try to find out what the situation is she and Mr Moody nevertheless it was attended to so listen to other board members talking about siblings especially when remember gallow the fact that having the opportunity for siblings to to be at school and Miss Neil explicitly said that usually in elementary years if you have a sibling that's like 5 years old and the other sibling is like 12 or 11 and it's a k through eight school they made availability for that family for those children to be together and I just want to just tell you thank you it does happen we we are able to kind of get them together and in relation to what excuse in regards to what member salom Monica talked about
109with the magnet program and some of the other board members and member bird I do have some issues because I taught at a magnet school when Dr Phillips first opened was Performing Arts Magnet School in 1987 and there were some issues about threats to students who if they did not keep the GPA up or you know they were going to be put out that is a concern and I guess at this time at 2025 we might want to revisit that thought process of putting people out because of disciplinary action but then again if it's a magnet program and you have a limit to the students and then you have somebody who's there taking up seats and they're not doing what's required what is what what can you do about that you have to deal with
110that so I have mixed and you say we might not land the plane and we probably won't I do have some mixed feelings about that because I worked at a magnet school that it was a coveted school people all over the district was trying to go so I do have some issues and we probably need to revisit and probably redo policy as it relates to that and thirdly I do want to and we didn't I haven't heard any board members kind of talk about it yet but maybe this is something they can go somewhere else chair Jacobs but we do have schools in this District who will reject students I don't know what their reasoning is but they tell the parents that this might not you might not fit in this body the student body
111you might need to be somewhere else and I know that's hear say but as we are nitpicking and addressing the issues our schools deal with our children we have to remember our first business business is to educate children and not to determine whether or not you fit in this environment if I ever hear of it none of my schools in my district I have had that kind of situation thank God but if I have if I ever get in a position and I'm seeing and I hear that well I don't know I guess John pal Marine whoever the lawyers are may have to come do something with me cuz I'm not going to take that I'm telling you I will not at all so maybe that could be something chair Jacobs that I don't know
112whether anybody else have felt that in the district you board members have heard those kinds of inform I think I think that's encapsulated in a lot of what I heard so when I recap I think one of the things a lot of board members have alluded to okay thank you and lastly thank you so much chair Jacobs I about the transfers I know exactly what Miss Neil I had an issue it wasn't in my district but because the person knew me were parents they weren't separated but they were saying they were separated CU they wanted their the child to go to a particular school and their office I mean I didn't realize the magnitude of the kind of work that they do and people assignment and I'm wondering if they need guards up there but
113I'm just saying it's it's really something and a lot of times as board members we really don't get the ends and outs of really how these people manipulate and maneuver to try to get and I get it you want your child that's your baby you want your child to go to what you think is the best possible school but then sometimes by any means necessary you do stuff and then the pupil assignment people and the district we're left vulnerable to kind of come behind and fix this foolishness so again CH Jacobs we're not going to land this plane and this has been a very healthy conversation I listen to my fellow board members we are going to have to come back and revisit this and deal with policies intricately as we deal with what is
114the right thing to do in terms of us as a district and a board in of a district and also working with our pupil assignment people because it's a lot so those are my points thank much thank you thank you member Douglas yes oh wow okay member G has impa a lot of issues and they all very valid I appreciate you for this conversation is really u a propo and it's supposed to happen however I really believe that this conversation should be brought to the principal and the teachers because they are personally involved in this decision making that we're making at the moment and I really believe that as our superintendent is doing a town hall maybe we should bring one or two of these issues to the teachers and the principal at that time
115and get a little bit and pick their brain and get a little bit of their ideas about what could happen and what would be the solution to some of those questions that we have right now also I agree with the sibling to put less burden on parents okay let's have all the kids be in same schools I have traveled with my kids I have three kids one was in a popka the other was in a the other one was in Citrus Elementary and the other one was in aoy it was like I had to travel I mean it was way too much for me okay so allowing the siblings to stay in the same school is a great idea I mean if we can okay and thank you so much Stacy for clarifying the enrollment
116because I thought so that parents should go to schools to enroll their kids it's just for transferring that they come to you is all right well other things yes and among other things okay thank you so much and somebody I don't know I don't remember who said that thank you for the sibling ones was good talking about all the kids can go to all the parents can choose the school they want for this student I think there's a little we should reconsider that we should there's a reservation because that could impact or influence other aspect and factors just like Transportation for for you know letting those parents choose which school they want to go to all right so let's I mean it's a lot of issues and truly I think the principal and the teacher
117should be aware of it and give their feed back on that thank you all right thank you all right so we're going to land well we're not going to land the plane but we're going to finish this meeting by 12:00 John had a strong request of me last night to try to to conclude this meeting by noon so I'm going to just touch on what I think are some overarching issues and a theme that I've heard most board members speak to is whatever we do the language in this policy needs to be more clear and more specific there's a lot of latitude and flexibility that is buil built into it and I think it was intentional and I think there's valid reason for having that but I also agree with the board that also that
118increases discretion and that discretion may not be used in the appropriate manner so work to do there second thing I think there's large agreement and I this is a non this is so obvious but we're in a very competitive environment and we need to look as we move forward with this in the lens of how do we remain competitive and how do we best tell our story some great suggestions along the line I loved Salam Mona's suggestion each one of you have offered really I think key things that we need to consider in how we do that with still recognizing that diversity and Equity are extremely important Transportation has come up over and over again going to be a tough one to deal with but I think and I agree I think it's a very
119important part of equity in turn my one thought that I have I use a search engine a lot and it's not a real great search engine because I often don't find what I'm looking for or I find 25 references and I have to figure out which one is the latest and how is it Germaine specifically I put in transfer and I don't I didn't get anything so I think we have some work to do when we talk about promoting our schools and communicating that is a place that's essential eligibility has been raised frequently the issue of what qualifications you have to have to stay in the school siblings open enrollment all of these have been topics of conversation So the plan is I think is for the superintendent and her team to have a chance
120to look at all these suggestions evaluate what what is feasible from an operational standpoint what their recommendation is on different issues and the basis for that recommendation come back for another work session with very organized issues that you all brought up and I like I said I tried to take really good notes all the subjects were important but allow us to get a little bit more organized and then how we approach that so I think with the value of the superintendent and her team being able to consider everything that's brought up we will come back won't probably land the plane that time but we'll get closer to understanding where the as a whole is so I'm going to wrap this up with one last comment and that is I do think this is one of
121the best work sessions that we've had from the standpoint of the engagement of the board and the serious thought of each one of you and I appreciate I always enjoy working with each one of you but I appreciate the way everybody comes to the table with I want to say a pure heart and the best intentions with that member bird Vice chair only because oh my God I have two members you guys are going to have to keep it to 30 seconds okay Gall thank you madam chair I recognize we have to go into close session at noon we do have another item on the agenda that we're obviously not going to get to today which disappoints me I know this happens far too often so I'm a little aggravated because far too often we
122have stuff on our agenda and we schedule stuff right around it and we're not able to get through the work of this board in one session and we've complained about it and we've complained about it and we've complained about it and here we are today and we're going to have to revisit the ethics policy which I was hoping to get to today because something else was scheduled so and I wasn't as a board member I wasn't told that we were going to cut this work session short to attend that Clos session so I'd like to a know when we're going to revisit the ethics and how in the future we can stop this from happening okay one thing I do want to say that this is unusual where we had a situation that is time
123sensitive not not where we have an unexpected item that comes up that we need to address our board our work sessions do go longer than is budgeted consistently absolutely today's situation wouldn't have been enough time probably to handle both of them even if we didn't have an issue that needs to be addressed right now still probably wouldn't have been enough time so I hear you on that superintendent you want to be recognized before I I do and so first of all I do understand board member gall's frustration however I do need the board to recognize that there are going to be times when there is an emergency meeting that has to be called and second it's very difficult ult to coordinate eight schedules even when we've asked that certain days be blocked off there's things
124that come up for each of the board members that don't allow us them to take the entire day so we've committed to Tuesdays and if that's not the best day for the board members then we need to know and then we will adjust but that was the intent about two years ago where I ask can we just slate Tuesdays and we have yet to have that situation where we've been able to start early be or stick to it because people have things that are scheduled in between I have a question for Mr pomerini is there a reason that we have to start right at 12 or can they continue discussions are there individuals that are here that are attending that Clos session that can't wait they're there's not individuals that couldn't wait I have a
125tendency to think that there there is going to be a large range of discussion in the next meeting correct and it's going to take some time to get through correct but we don't have our public agenda until 4 o' that's correct so I leave it to the board I mean you have we have until 4 o' before you have that hard hard stop you could take some time to talk about the ethics policy or or not I leave it to you if I my personal opinion on this the ethics policy is extremely important if we this took two hours and we didn't get we got I think most of the issues on the table if we open the door to ethics I don't think we're going to get anywhere close to even getting the issues
126on the table most likely so will be short even if we had two hours for ethics I have no idea how this next meeting is going to go this meeting went 2 hours we didn't finish it and it isn't time sensitive we don't have to land the plane we have to land the plane at the next one so my strong suggestion I'm I will defer to the board is that we adjourn this meeting we come back on ethics set aside 3 hours instead of 2 hours for ethics and move on with the next meeting thank you madam chair I'm I'm fine with that I just do we have a date when ethics is going to come back before the board because we've waited several months to discuss ethics I get the nature of the importance
127of of the next meeting it is it is frustrating as a board member that it we're just never allotted we take a long time to discuss things and it just feels like we're always running out of time because we've got to get to the next thing right I hear you I also hear the superintendent that we are likewise a part of the problem because of scheduling no one individual I'm going to have a problem with Thursday I my understanding was We were supposed to set aside Tuesdays and Thursdays and best laid plans doesn't always happen so I think I hear you Madam superintendent I think it's a valid point I certainly hear you I'm always myself in the same situation never have enough time but we have to make the time member bird Vice chair
128you're going to close us out and then we're going to adjourn is we have to advertise specifically what we're talking about at a work session like could we add ethics to our Thursday session which is already scheduled for three hours we could Madam chair man please absolutely you recogniz we could absolutely say that we could say we're Contin continuing the discussion on the lobing and ethics until Thursday if the board desires to do that right I have no issue with that I mean we're already here it's scheduled for three we could even add an extra hour make it a 4our session if if we need to and then also the reason I buzz in because I was just going to ask if we could before our next session when we talk about the student assignments
129if we could maybe get a few policies from other districts on Student Assignment I think it would be really informative to be able to see what other districts are doing great suggestions that's it I procedurally I am supposed to call for a motion to adjourn the meeting you all know I have never done that but I should do it so I have a motion to adjourn the meeting do we have a second hold hold on hold on Pardon Me is the direction I'm sorry no is the direction from the board I would ask that if we're going to do it on Thursday that the board move and approve or give consensus at least to moving policy KC to Thursday to add it on to the agenda we canj okay all right so does the board
130agree that we should adjourn this meeting but carry over the ethics policy to Thursday motion to to accept okay all right this Thursday we have have a work session on Thursday okay we have a motion from Vice chair do we have a second you can't motion second it he said vice chair I thought viair you Vice chair you were the one who sat in this chair earlier okay how are we doing that's okay all right we have a second by I think that was member Vanos all in favor please say I oppose meeting is adjourned you made me feel good oh I just I oh oh