CorpusRecord 50

OCPS | 2025-01-16 School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / OCPS Boardmeetings
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Orange County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,970 words · about 100 min
Collected
2026-03-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon everyone and welcome to the Orange County school board's work session which has been scheduled for today Thursday January 16th 202 5 for the purpose of discussing the ocps 2025 strategic plan midyear update the public will not have an opportunity to participate in this work session and by that I mean provide public comment because it's not a regularly scheduled Schoolboard meeting no action will be taken and there'll be no open public comment period in which the public would normally address the school board on relevant topics with that said for those of you who are in the room thanks for joining us I know you're all here to present I think most of you we look forward to hearing from you and those who of you who might be tuning in we appreciate your interest

002in Orange County Public Schools with that Dr Vasquez superintendent you are recognized oh I should do a roll call sorry about that let me do a quick huh no you do after roll call yeah it's the page thank you thank you I think it's only pre pre- agenda that we don't all right let's do a quick roll call starting with member Felder I'm here member Gallow I believe may be joining us member Gallow are you online with USO just dropped okay if you can let me know Mr pom pomerini when she logs in member of Vanos here no problem member Vice chair good afternoon good afternoon member Douglas member Fant here and member Salamon hello how about that just a few minutes ago we were just about nobody here and we're all here that's wonderful

003okay we will begin our meeting with the moment of silence followed by Pledge of Allegiance alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right member Gallow have you joined us or rejoined us yes Madam chair I'm here all right thank you let the minutes reflect that member Gallow is with us all right with that Dr vquez you're recognized thank you madam chair we are delighted this afternoon to be able to present to you a midpoint a midpoint review of our Strate of our strategic plan I'm sorry can't seem to be speaking this morning and you will will see data being presented to you by Dr border and his team all of the Chiefs

004are going to be available to answer any specific questions you may have regarding their specific metrics on the various goals that we are hoping to be able to achieve by the end of this year I do want to say thank you so much to the team they have been working not just with the Chiefs but with the various departments in order to be able to not just compile the information but to ensure that the data that we're using is accurately measuring what we're trying to achieve so with that I am going to turn it over to Dr border oh excuse me one more when we have done this in the past we have not been able to achieve the entire presentation in one session and so we are going to try something a little different

005we did send out the presentation to the board I believe about a week ago so that you had a chance to review it we are going to present in sections and then at the end of that section we'll pause and give you an opportunity to ask any question you may have for that particular section so if a question pops up if you'll write it down I think this strategy may help us get through the entire presentation in one setting Dr border I turn it over to you thanks Dr Vasquez good afternoon chair Jacobs members of the board doesn't sound like your mic is on or we always say they're very sensitive testing good afternoon test doesn't sound like it but it doesn't sound like mine so on either and until I get like super close

006so testing there you go all right very good good afternoon chair Jacobs members of the board looking forward to presenting our midpoint on our ocps 2025 strategic plan today joining me at the table is our senior administrator in research measurement and strategy Mr Ben Allen and also joining me this afternoon as well is our senior executive director Dr Jennifer Sasser and also our newly anointed doctorate director of accountability Dr Michelle Paul so congratulations to Michelle we'll begin today with a review of our current state assessment data followed by strategy progress for each key performance indicator closing with Schoolboard discussion we're going to begin with the review of our state data it's important to note that the data that is being shared is from our vendor files as the official state file data is not yet

007available we're going to begin with star early literacy assessment outcomes for Progress monitoring 2 32% of our kindergarten students scored at level three or higher which is compared to 30% this time last year our first graders remain at 25% three and above as the same as it was at this time last year moving to Star reading 71% of our kindergarten students are scoring on grade level and above compared to 70% this time on pm2 year prior I'll pause for a moment for you to review the outcomes for first and second grade for star mathematics 29% of our kindergarten students scored at level three and above compared to 26% this time year prior I'll pause now for a moment for you to review the first and second grade mathematics outcomes now we're going to move to

008English language arts reading on the Florida assessment of student Thinking Fast 45% of our third graders scored three and above compared to 41% this time year prior whereas the state scored at 40% which is the same as year prior I'll pause now for a moment for you to review our fourth and fifth grade outcomes Vasquez Ember Fant wants to ask a clarifying question okay I just want to double check when you're saying when when you're explaining everything so the 20 2024 the pm3 that's like the last like in May they're taking that the pm2 is what it was halfway through the year and then the 2024 is right now halfway through the year so the last two slides are the comparable ones or the rows and the first one is just like end of the

009year data correct thanks board member for for the question the First Column that's where we finished last year on pm3 and then column two is where we were at this point last year and column three is where we currently are at this year all right now we're going to talk about Ela reading on fast for our middle school students 52% of our sixth graders scored at three and above compared to 40 on pm2 compared to 46% year prior the state scored at 50% compared to 47% year prior I'll now pause for a moment for you to review the outcomes for seventh and eighth grade can we go I'm sorry can we go back absolutely thank you okay I do think questions like the one member Fant asked are important so that everybody understands what we're

010looking at I have a specific question on this and those types of questions I'm going to write down and we can for them to the staff correct okay I'm sorry I didn't explain clearly we're going to stop I listen clearly we're going to stop in just a few slides and then any questions you have on the slides up to that point we'll answer and then we'll move on to the next set of slides so you'll get you will have all of your questions answers but what's happened in the past is that we are our Rhythm wasn't in sync with the time that we allocated so we're going to try this strategy to see if it's makes better sense thank you next we're going to share our Ela English language arts fast data for high school

011as of pm2 42% of our nth graders are scoring three and above which is compared to 41% this time year prior the state performed at 44% compared to 43% year prior I'll now pause and allow you to review the outcomes for 10th grade now we're going to move to mathematics you're you're you're a little faster okay at least my apologies chair I'll go back yeah but like it just takes a minute longer may I may I make one more comment Dr border before you move on maybe just ask can we move on to the next slide that way everybody has enough very good or even better if board members would just look up well I don't mean better there's two ways of doing it but if the board members everybody when you just look at

012Herold and then he will know he can go on that works too thank you chair thanks superintendent moving to elementary mathematics for mathematics on the Florida assessment of student thinking 34% of our third grade students on pm2 scored three and above which is compared to 33% year prior the state performed at 28% on pm2 which is compared to 31% year prior I'll pause for a moment for you to review our fourth and fifth grade outcomes okay moving to our Middle School mathematics for fast 40% of our sixth graders are currently scoring three and above which at this time last year was at 38% the state is currently at 39% which at this time last year was at 37% I'll now pause for a moment for you to review seventh and 8th grade mathematics okay and

013finally our last slide on Data before we open it up up for questions is algebra and geometry we do not have our pma2 data yet that is still being worked on it'll be finalized momentarily but PMA data which progress monitoring activity those are assessments that we use to help inform our teachers and administrators on how the students are progressing in algebra and geometry so that's different than the PM State assessment and so those on those assessments during the PMA 1 which covers just the material covered for that nine weeks not the whole the whole year as PM does we were at 53% in Algebra 1 and we finished last year at 53% as a comparison for the year for geometry for the first grading period we were at 54% and that is where we concluded

014last year so we will share with the board pma2 data for algebra and geometry as it becomes available so I'll pause there and open it up for questions on our current State assessment data all right thank you let's start with member Fant thank you madam chair just a couple questions just to kind of clarify I know if we can go back to the star reading I should have written down which SL they it was the second grade star reading yes ma'am can you remind me again is this the one where if if a child is in kindergarten and they don't pass it then they try again in first grade then they would try again in second grade so the state has a recommended score for transitioning from Star early literacy to Star reading we follow

015that as a district and so you have students transitioning to Star reading throughout the year so in kindergarten you have larger numbers of students that are taking star ear early literacy that have not moved yet to Star reading and then in first grade not quite the same numbers as in kindergarten but more kids are transitioning the students in second grade in in Star reading this encompasses all second graders which is different than for kindergarten in first grade where you have partial student populations in Star reading and then the other in Star early literacy which is what causes that difference in numbers yes ma'am which the 41% still is concerning but or 40% whatever okay so then the other one would be for math it must have been for the yeah that next I should have

016been a little more specific but it was it looks like it's everything is I don't know where I was let's move on to another one because I don't know what my notes Here what I'm thinking here but let's see for fourth and fifth grade math we are lower than last year so when we look at that kind of data what is being done at the school level to make sure that students are increasing and understanding the math so I can share Miss Fant that soon we'll be sharing with the board an interactive accountability denominator report that our team has worked on which allows teachers to drill down to the student level and utilize data to inform instruction and our administrators can also utilize that we are currently also I know corrective programs and the Cadre

017leaders are immersed in looking at the data and supporting schools on supports and needs and adjustments that may may need to be made based upon pm2 data okay perfect it's just some of the higher level things that are happening with the data superintendent additionally Dr Brown Canon and her team her team have analyzed the areas where there needs to be remediation they've gone back into the curriculum resource materials and have revised those and that information is being pushed out through the principles and to our teachers so that they know some additional things they may be able to do for the areas that are below what we expected them to be okay perfect perfect perfect and then one just final question it was on the seventh grade math and I just want to clarify this is

018be it's real low here and this is correct me if I'm wrong but it's because most of a lot of kids move up to like an eighth grade math and so they're taking that eighth grade thanks Miss FR for the question so the math progressions across districts in the state there's variance there and so we wward our students the opportunity to take algebra when they're ready in seventh grade and then move to geometry in eth grade we tend to have more students that are doing that which allows them to get to calculus AB and BC in high school and then other higher level math courses so those numbers do reflect here when you're trying to compare to the state it's a little more difficult since the math progression is not comparable across school districts superintendent

019thank you add additionally I asked the team to put together information so the board could see the total number of seventh graders that we have and then how many of them are taking algebra how many of them are taking geometry how many are taking pre-algebra and then how many are in seventh grade math so that you can then see the number of students that represent the 19% they will tell you that we're going to see that there are gains because this represents such a small percentage of the of the total mathematics but specifically in the in the seventh grade so that as soon as that has been compiled we will they're going to send it to the board all right thank you member bird thank you I'm GNA I have a few positive things to

020say I'm actually I saw a lot of really good data here I saw several categories that were higher than where we were last year in fact some of them many were where we were at the end of last year here at the midpoint so kudos to superintendent for your leadership and for our teachers and everybody that's working so hard to make these gains and I want to look at the star reading one more time because I think while the 40% is concerning I think there's a huge win here and that's at the first grade level and the fact that 83% of our first graders at the midpoint are scoring three or higher that's a huge gain first of all it's almost 10 points 10 percentage points than where we were last year but not only

021that's saying that 83% of our first graders are we're saying proficient right proficient where they need to be for reading in first grade right that's what that's telling us so thanks Miss bird for that just to add some clarifying points I think that you are correct that this is a very good sign I would say it's a very good sign because on pm2 last year we were at 74% and pm2 this year we're at 83% and we haven't changed our practices meaning we're following the state recommendation for when a first grader should transition from Star early literacy to Star reading so this is not all first graders okay but the first graders who have transitioned from Star early literacy because they've gotten the high enough score to move to Star reading those students are performing

0229 % higher than they were last year and I will tell you we were following that recommendation last year on the score so to me to your point that 9% uptick is a great sign okay so forgive me then it's not 83% of all of our first graders it's 83% of the student the first graders that are doing star reading so there are still students that are in the early literacy there are so this might be another area that would be beneficial to be able to see sure how that compares to our total number of first graders absolutely thanks Miss bur and be I just one more thing that you spoke about just wanted to add to that so second grade there are a few students still in Star early literacy certainly not near the

023numbers in first grade or kindergarten and then I also wanted to add that the three and above for the state language now is means on grade level or above so they're on grade level standard proficiency is referred to once they get to level four okay so they are on grade level just so encouraged is because we know we've got this focus on we know we've got this focus on on our on our science of reading and this is a good sign if our youngest readers are seeing these kinds of gains then I would expect that our second grade numbers our third grade numbers everything will start each year to keep moving up as these early readers who are so successful now at this age as they age so I'm I'm I'm excited about what I'm

024seeing thank you thanks Miss B all right thank you Vice chair a couple of questions several of them have been answered math 7eventh grade kind of like everybody else I'm like what do my notes mean drop the drop from PM 3 to where we are is does this go back to the question I think that member FR asked in terms of the what looks like a disparity in the data it and this goes back to Dr Vasquez in terms of how you've asked staff to break out this information will we will we be able to see that cohort of the students that match the state's cohort of students the ones that have not Advanced into okay I might be on the algebra go ahead you are so every district has the ability to group or

025provide access to courses to the different students we have been committed for over a decade to really Advance our students if they are able especially in mathematics at the middle school because we know how vital algebra Mastery is as they are pursuing many of the careers and Pathways in high school not all districts have the resources to do that they may not have the teachers that have the certifications to be able to teach the algebra the geometry in middle school because that does require a different certification than the middle grade certification what the data will'll show you is and I'll going to try and make a simplistic example let's say that we have a th000 students in seventh grade in our district and out of those 1,000 there are 200 that are in 7th grade

026regular math or they're taking the seventh grade assessment then we will show you there may be 500 that are taking algebra so they are not included in this number and maybe there's 200 forgot my math I think I have one now that are in Geometry those students are not included in this number so that's what that will allow you to see and the algebra and geometry are not are not captured in this data okay so you're going to show us the numbers but I'm assuming you're also going to show us within those numbers what the percentages of the 200 no the 500 that are in regular math that of those which percent of those are proficient they can do that yes I that's that's a great point because that this only shows us out of

027the students that are taking the seventh grade math fast assessment how many are on grade level so yes we'll be able to to do that and just to give you an idea not all certainly but the majority of the students that are taking seventh grade math struggle with very basic math concepts such as their times table they may not have a grasp on how to work with fractions with de with decimals and so some of those Concepts that are taught in 7th grade that require a Mastery of those basic numeracy skills they struggle because they don't know them and so you'll that's certainly again not for all students but I would venture to say that for many if not the vast majority of students that are taking seventh grade math they struggle right so we

028can expect those numbers to be lower than if we had all of our students taking seventh grade math and by encouraging them all to push themselves we can also expect all of their numbers to be on the Lower Side than the average for the state unless everybody is equally pushing our kids to try their best okay got it I did have and I think it was probably answered going back to slide number four back to Vice chair's Point can can you look back at say last year and see the correlation between the change from the level 3 pm2 from the previous year to the level 3 pm so this same data that we have but looking at the previous year and seeing if we had right now we have that ninepoint gain and we're anticipating

029that is going to have a positive impact on next year can we look at last year to see what kind of a game we had and is there in fact a correlation there I would think so but3 so I'm I'll allow the team to add chair but when it comes to Star reading there's also variances in that data across the state students can test multiple times within the platform it's also part I think now they've divided out but Accelerated Reader has been in there in the past Ben any additional the other is this on it's hard I can't hear you but I don't know if it means it's not close enough or it's not on I can't tell you how close you have to get but very close I'm I'm feeling very comfortable with the

030microphone right now here we go I don't blame you so the other complexity with that is some of the scales have changed between the first year that the test was administered there are multiple scales that we'll have to look at so we might have to do some analysis to get the numbers to work so we'll we'll take a look at what's available and what we can provide okay I had one other question and I'm not sure from my notes if I can tell what it pertained to but it was an area where we had a drop that it might have been ma it was an area where we had a significant drop and what I was curious about so we're looking at the entire district and unfortunately you can look school by school and student

031by student when you look at some of the data especially where we are not seeing the progress that we want or would hope for when you look at it school by school are there distinct differences or all schools kind of at least progressing at the same rate or do you see some that AR they might be lower but they're not the same lower as the previous year boy I am not very articulate today Miss Sasser Dr Sasser knows what I'm talking about though thanks chair Jacobs yes we there's variances across the schools so this is you know the district cumulative averages but we do the superintendent has conversations with us about trends that we're seeing we provide information to the superintendent and Dr arm Brewster that then is triangulated with other pieces of data including

032you know what we see at the schools on a day in and day out basis which is a big part of what we're looking at in those discussions so that then we can provide supports and adjustments as as needed so there's you know those are variances from from school to school we indicate where we see the largest drops and also the largest gains and then that information is taken from there and correlated to what the other data pieces and also what what is being seen at the school and then from there plans are worked on is there this is going to be a really broad question I think you're going to just tell me no but when you see a school that's kind of an outlier it may have been lower last year than other

033schools but it's it's not making the same gains are there certain factors that you find to be commonalities leadership in the school training of our Educators and any specific things that you can tie back to the root cause Dr Vasquez I'll give a response and then by all means if you have been able to find anything within the data I can tell you that several years ago there was an attempt to take a look at various factors that impact the school grade we looked at the number of years the principal had been there we looked at the number of years the principal had been a principal we looked at the number of teachers that I forgot the range but were new teachers or teachers in their first 2 to three years we looked at the

034number of students with Title One there were several factors and that then gave us a way to use more than one data point to identify schools of need or schools of concern that would need the support my recollection and I don't want to be held to it is because it was I mean I was a CAO back then but the leadership component was a huge factor which is why we then at that time started to take a look at instructional leadership preparation for our prein and then those that were already principles and it's a reason why we added the classroom walkthroughs that we would be able to start to see the practices in the in the classroom if there was transfer from the professional development from what the principles we were sharing with them on

035a monthly basis if all of that was transferring if the principal was able to give appropriate feedback and understood how they could assist the teacher or provide intervention support based on what was at the school Jenifer I know you were in a different role at that time but I don't know if there's anything else that you remember as it relates to to the factors that may contribute to schools that may not be performing as well so thanks again for the question chair Dr J Sasser just pointed out the importance of the teacher in the classroom you know and when we have vacancies making sure that we have the supports that are in place in those cases because sometimes that is a indicator where we see drops the empirical data does support the impact of the

036teacher in the classroom as being the number one impact and then the leadership at the school following that so you know we're blessed to have amazing teachers and leaders across the district and those are the two largest impacts upon our students okay and then even even when you're looking at the teacher there's probably components of what you're looking at there in the in the transportation Arena they have what's called a crash data well some companies offer a crash data management analysis and it will look at not just crashes at a particular area area but weather conditions the skid marks time of day all different factors and looking for are there commonalities that would indicate what exactly do we need to fix and so I was thinking that the same would apply and it sounds like

037it does but is this something that you do every year so we have conducted risk factor analysis in the past that Dr Vasquez was referring to that has not been something that we've we've utilized with The Changing State assessment being part of that but certainly we'll have additional conversations with Dr Vasquez and see if that is something that we want to look at in the in the future but it is something that we've looked at in the past I you know from my experiences I will say that there there's expences within that I mean there are you know and even as a prior principal there are teachers in the first year that you know the results are amazing and then you know others it continues to progress as they go and then and also there

038are teachers that have been with us for 20 years who have amazing results so yeah you know there's there's certainly different different factors in there there's always going to be outliers but I know this board has been really interested in promoting training education for our Educators beyond what is required and so it also would be interesting for us to see does that translate and how well does that translate in student performance I think we all think it would but it would be nice to validate that with data and I started out this meeting by talking about how data brid OST PES and the ability to access and draw con clusions from it is really pretty impressive so thank you yeah thanks chair and you know now that we're in you know the state's progress modering

039system has been in place for a couple years it gives us you know more longitudinal reliable data as long as the scale scores kind of stay similar for us to begin having this discussion again yeah thank you member Vanos thank you madam chair I just wanted to follow up real quick with actually just something you just said about the progress ing data coming from the state being able to give you continuous information do you feel confident that the progress monitoring tests from the state actually are valid so I will see if my team wants to add anything board member van Vanos but I mean we are confident that the progress monitoring assessments are aligned to the standards of the course and give us an indicator along the way of how our students are doing which

040allows you know for adjustments to be continually happening along the way parents are informed of how their students are doing as well and what they're expected to learn the PM assessments do cover the content for the entire year and so you know we have a lot of pieces in place that help with that across the district with scope and sequences and those kind of pieces to ensure that we're covering all of the standards that are expected to be covered with in a course that are going to be assessed and the other piece that I would add on to that is that part of the law when the assessment system changed from FSA to fast was that the State Department of Education would conduct a study from pm1 to pm2 to pm3 so the beginning of

041year middle of year end of year about the validity and predictive measures that are associated with the assessment so they're currently doing that study now they needed to build up their own data sets before they could conduct that study and it's it's underway we haven't heard from the any outcomes of that but it's it's an issue that they're still looking into as part of kind of the long-term implementation of the new assessment system thank you and then that was really my question because I know they passed the you know they passed a law requiring it and just like that the test was out there so I was just curious what what studies were actually done to make sure that it was you know measuring what it's supposed to measure but it sounds like we don't

042really know but they're working on coming up with that information now okay thank you so I had a question on the I was looking at the fast Ela reading in fifth grade and then to the next page in sixth grade and seventh and eighth grade and I just see there's just a big drop in performance on the ELA test in middle school and I was just curious why you thought that was board member vonas just asking a clarifying question So when you say the big drop in Middle School I'm looking at the can you can you provide more cont so I'm looking at the fifth grade you know they're the district is at 58% I'm looking at the end of the year is at 58% and then okay sixth grade is 52 7th grade's 47

043e8th grade's 49 and so I'm just curious your thoughts on you know just I have Middle School is my soft spot and I have some I think we have some work to do in middle school so just curious why you thought that was the case yeah thanks board member vonos Ben yeah so in mathematics it's a little different than reading so in math the students get exposed to different content throughout the year so it's new ideas that they've never seen before so in the middle of the year they're being tested on end of year standards and so substantial amount of topics they just haven't learned yet so we tend to see bigger I would I don't even want to call them drops but differences between pm2 and pm3 and pm1 pm2 pm3 in mathematics as

044opposed to reading where it's a similar set of skills they're just being assessed at a higher level so students who are strong readers will be able to apply those same skills to more complex tests or texts at the higher grade levels and so we generally don't see as much difference between pm1 to pm3 in Reading as we do in mathematics so it's really a Content exposure thing they just haven't seen the content yet so you're saying in Middle School reading they haven't seen the content yet that they're in mathematics they haven't seen the content no no I understand that yeah I was actually talking about the reading portion that you know we're it just seems to decrease or just get pretty low in middle school and I was just curious as to why and one

045of the reasons I'm asking is because I'm wondering when you talk about the math and you're talking about the different sets of students who are taking the tests I'm wondering if in Middle School part of the reason we're seeing a decrease is because and I'm just asking the question are we losing students for middle school and is it just a different group of students taking the test so that's really what I'm asking got it and board member of honors are you like are you referring to the fifth grade State and District reading outcomes compared to like sixth grade is that what you're yeah so I'm looking at slide six fifth grade it's showing the district for level three level three is 58% and then I'm turning the page and I'm seeing sixth grade now we're

046at 52% and seventh grade now we're at 47% eighth grade we're at 49% yeah yeah we'll we'll we'll follow up board member vonos and provide additional information I mean the this the rigor of the standards of course continues to increase as students go up but to your point we'll we'll take a further look at that and provide additional information all right Dr Vasquez and Dr Vasquez for the sake of this work session if if I'm not recognizing you jump in and take ownership okay thank you apologize no no apologies superintendent is pushing her button to be recognized which given the fact that she has all the answers to everything I just would rather you feel like you no no I I do not just a couple of points that you know cohorts are different right

047and so when we're comparing the data and I what you're saying is true but comparing last year to the current year it's a whole different group of kids so we a better analysis is to look at the cohort group before so where we were at the end of the year let's say with fifth grade or sixth grade and then where seventh grade is this year because that's the cohort that represents last year's assessment so on this slide last year the sixth graders were at 52% at the end of the year in reading this year that group or most of them because you're right some students move out they're not right they're not the exact same group but now that group that was at 52 the middle of the year is at 46 does that make

048sense so when we're looking at the data let's try and do it by cohort as well that gives a better picture and I'm also not sure how much the score the scale scores change from one grade to another and so a student it's it's like saying that the our grading scale would change to make it simple so in let's say in sixth grade an a may be a 90 to a 100 but when they get to seventh grade and I'm asking I don't know if the band numbers change from one grade to the next that would be something else for us to look at because it may be that 90 to 100 was proficient in sixth grade but when they got into seventh grade it's 95 to 100 and I know it's yeah and that's

049yes the bands do vary by grade level but there's a standard setting process that happened after the new test happened to kind of establish those cuts so the levels the range of the levels might look different when we're looking at the numbers however it's gone through a standard setting process at the state one thing if I could just jump back quickly to the validity question because I don't think I answered that completely fully the pm3 results are valid so those have gone through multiple process is for vetting those it's the pm1 to pm2 to pm3 that the state's doing the validity study on and that's part of that ongoing process got it okay thank you I'm almost done I'm looking at slide 10 and member for as a great question about the district scores in

050seventh grade and you had mentioned that one of the reasons that the score looks lower for seventh grade is because students are advancing into algebra and geometry so that they can be on track to take Calculus AB and Calculus BC I would just be curious well I would be I would be curious to know how many how many students are actually taking BC first s stats their senior year just I'm just I'm I just have questions about that progression in general and if if we're doing students of service and pushing them ahead in math thanks board member vas appreciate it and then I have just one last question and it's on slide nine member front had also asked about the numbers in fifth grade math I believe and you had indicated that the teachers were

051you were sort of drilling down to find out what needed to be done to address some of the lower scores and I was just wondering how are you determining that is that how are you drilling down to to determine kind of what the students are lacking in that area so board member Venice one thing I would add here is when we start looking at our achievement gaps one of the strategies that's being looked at this year is how fourth and fifth graders are doing on number sense with whole numbers because that was an area where students had struggled in year prior so that's an example of how we can drill down to see which skills and content students are struggling on and then if there needs to be additional intervention or remediation of skills you

052know especially in mathematics closing holes and gaps so that students can can further along the continual okay and I guess I was just wondering is that just more teacher time kind of one-on-one time spent with a student or is it just giving them more tests May so when the we receive scores back it's more than just the number so the school and the district level are able to disaggregate the results of the assessment by strand by grade level by teacher and those conversations take place some at the district level as they're talking with principal leaders and leaders let's say about specific schools of concern and specific grade levels and then at the school level teachers were expecting are looking at their data they're making adjustments they're looking to see I have five students that really

053did not master this particular strand so I need to go back and retach and that's where our CAO department has or is I think they finished but they were going into the curriculum resource materials and adding additional resources for that reteaching and so teachers and principals and the district have the data that disaggregates where the students were so they can then make decisions about who's going in intervention who needs reteaching who may u benefit from additional tutoring if they're offering tutoring after school to be able to address the concepts primarily the concept that haven't been taught because in some cases there schools may be two weeks behind or scope and sequence and they took the test so it may show well they did not grasp this particular strand and when they talked to the teacher

054yes we were behind we didn't teach it and so that's why the students didn't show that they demonstrated it thank you okay Vice chair thank you I just have a quick followup on the algebra and geometry and it kind of goes along with what member Thanos was saying do we have do we have data on when we look at that data it's all students taking the algebra and geometry testing do we is it possible to pull out the ones that are seventh and eighth graders so that we can see and I'm sure you guys already do this actually but how success uccessful the seventh and eighth graders obviously are because I think that would be really interesting to see if it's either they're boosting our algebra and geometry scores because they're such bra kids or

055is it are they not being as successful because they're so young so I would love to see that data if you have it or you could pull it I've always been interested in that whole concept of pushing them into algebra geometry and I'd like to know if that how that affects them thanks board member B we can pull that and share that but it definitely boosts the scores you'll see some internal measures of success later that are looking at the algebra percentages in in high school specifically good thank you and so we talked you talked or the superintendent just talked about when they teachers look at data and they see you know like a specific strand that maybe students didn't grasp when we look at this data where it's you know 50 3% at level

056three or above so that means that 47% are not on grade level that's a that's a big chunk that's not just a little piece so what happens when that comes in and we look at that and we say okay well right now we've got 47% of the kids that are not on grade level how does how do they how can they possibly catch up because they've got the scope and sequence they've got to get through they don't have time to go back and retach all that I mean I would imagine that this is a huge struggle and this is why we're obviously trying to make changes early so that they don't get to this point but what kind of is the what are the strategies when when we look at that and that huge chunk

057of kids that are not where they need to be already like here in the middle of the year and now we've got the rest only the rest of the year to get through the new material and make sure that they've we've catched all those other kids up could you help me understand that a little bit I'll try a little bit and I'll some of this or a lot of this is possible because our incredible data team has been able to put together a platform where the data is accessible where it was not last year for them to more easily manipulate the information so there's a variety of strategies that can be used varies by school obviously you identify who the students are some of the students may be pulled by a resource teacher or an

058inventionist for part of their day so that they are remediated in a specific area some may choose to regroup students and so one teacher may take a group and work on a certain concept until they've mastered that especially during intervention time or at some point during the day some of the schools offer the tutoring and that is the focus of the tutoring some take advantage of some online tools where they can have the student specifically work on the areas of of need in some cases in some of are more fragile schools we actually have District staff that goes in and actually works with some of those students to try and get them up we also have strategies where they will look at let's say the number of questions if they get into a pinch and

059it's like okay we only have eight weeks before the test we know we're not going to be able to get through all of this and then they identify which ones would maybe take priority maybe that's based on the number of students it may be based on how close they are because on grade level me it could be a student that's at a level two and so level two child may just have a small misconception and they're able to remediate in a much easier fashion that someone that is at a level one so there's various strategies and then of course we also looked at the summer to help do some more remediation for some of those students that we may not have caught up all right member Douglas I'm an optimist and the numbers are going

060upward not downward so it's pretty good appreciate that and I'm also visual person and I would like to know can we see the variance between the schools okay and how they perform in each category okay and I think that will better explain the numbers to us when we see the data between the schools and my second question is can those successful schools in math or reading or both share best practices with other schools that's struggling in that are in those areas so that's what I had to say thanks board member Douglas so starting with your second point I mean that's that's an emphasis for us us as a district we're really want the professional Learning Community model to continue to flourish and grow which allows for the sharing of practices within schools and across schools

061our reorganization to the Cadre model also allows for schools to share with each other across the district versus just within a geographical area which was kind of the prior alignment so it allows for more more advanced sharing across different schools across the district to the first point Dr Vasquez do you want me to speak to the first point we do have data by school board member Douglas that we that we share we have trackers that we put out the schools as they're developed I mean that we put out to that is shared amongst the schools and so we certainly can look to share that with the board yeah the board received the scores maybe our new board members did not receive that so we need to go back and make sure that they get they

062get the scores back to you member Douglas okay yeah to the question of being able to visualize Mr border on the question of being able to visualize there I was when the when member Douglas asked as the question I was envisioning it as a graph of some type although I know how many schools that we have so I wasn't quite sure other than a spreadsheet of some sort if there is any other way of viewing that data yes so thanks chair thanks board member Douglas so the we currently have Excel spreadsheets that we sent those out to the board prior we'll send those out again when those are are final however what's coming to the board as a strategic Plan update on February 11th is an overview of our interactive accountability denominator report that the

063team just developed and we are currently training principles on the utilization of that tool and transitioning to assistant principles as well and so once the board sees that preview we're certainly happy to provide any additional assistance and support but you'll be able to have visuals on each one of your schools with different graphs and pieces of information on how they're progressing relative to the state assessments Rel perfect yeah I was thinking if you compared each one relative to the average of all of them that would be probably the best visual tool when you present that to the board I'm assuming at that point you're going to share with us the methodology yes we that'll all be part of the presentation chair I mean it's it's the state data yeah that we've put into a powerbi

064tool which would which allows schools to interact with it in a much more userfriendly manner it's also part of our goal of taking off of the plate of our administrators and teachers so that they have a tool that they can interact with instead of having to compile information and put it into other places all right thank you thank you member Felder thank you a lot of the questions that I had I think with the rest of the board members and the superintendent answering the questions some of them have been answered especially when member Douglas talked about the variance if we could have some kind of I guess visual to see what that was about but initially when board member Vanos talked about asked a question about why was there such a drop as as the

065children progressed and I was just kind of going to sort of offer my opinion about that Middle School is difficult and I I and I don't mean to say it like we don't have an answer but it is difficult because of the competitiveness of the world and things that children are attracted to as they get through their Adolescent and puberty in elementary everybody the children you know everybody excited they love school but something happens between six well sixth and seventh grade fifth and sixth something happens I don't they the distractions are far more so I'm wondering if we can because I don't believe that the teachers are not working hard I know that they are cuz I was a teacher and I know they are but I'm wondering if we could somehow not necessarily revamp

066but those persons that are coming in like and I know we don't have money for tutoring and all that but people that are kind of coming and we could kind of revamp their job description in terms of assisting with the teachers with the work because reading I'm excited that we're higher than the state in terms of our centage that means the people tell I wanted to read all of this we doing something right down here but if we could F find a way to maybe assist because I am concerned and I know certain schools are always having a struggle certain schools in certain districts are having the same type of struggles as opposed to schools in other districts so again as it was suggest one of the board members to see like not the template

067but what like what what are they do what are they doing to to make this happen if there's some kind of way we can share I know years and years ago sometimes we would do something like team teaching teachers would go into other teachers classrooms and they would watch and they would you know they would go and kind of see what the teacher was doing that was working I don't know if we have that kind of time because days seem to be shorter and students are more in the classroom we have more students than we used to have in classes even though we are seventh periods out the day but still not enough time but I am concerned that we are at that point where it seems like it's dropping if you look on page

06810 at the mathematics I'm not a math person I'm I'm Ela but you look at 7th grade 2023 4 you were the district is at 36% and then 2023 I'm on page 10 24 level three is dropped and it's pm2 down to 16% so I don't I'm sure you all are trying to find out it's on page 10 that's where I'm looking what happened and I used to think that in the past we've done very well with math much better than we were with Ela so I don't know what what are we doing to to kind of fix that Dr border thanks board member Felder so just wanted to talk on seventh grade for a moment so 36 is where we finished last year at pm two last year we were at 16% so okay

069so we got better we went up from 16 to 36 oh I looked at it wrong I'm sorry no that's okay I'm glad you asked and we're currently at 19% so if we go up 20% again we'll actually have made a 3% increase okay so we're at 36 and then 2425 we down at 19 right yes but if you compare that to where we were Miss Felder at this time last year we were at 16% oh I see so we were okay we are going up okay I looked at it wrong I see it now I understand thanks for asking Dr did you want to chime in and so and I was waiting for board member bird to come back because really she's the one that alerted it or brought it to my attention so

070first I need to apologize to the board we met last week reviewed the presentation it might have been the week no it was last week because we were on vacation the week before and when we decided to shunet I said I want the board to receive the presentation ahead of time that responsibility came to me and I blew it I didn't send it to you ahead of time so this is the first time that they are seeing it is my apologies I was the one that was supposed to send it along with the preview that we were going to chunk it and so we're going to take a little bit more time to answer their question because it's the first time they're seeing so my apologies to to the board I believe leave we did

071do a one-onone with the brand new board members just because we wanted you to have history so but everybody else this is the first time and we'll we'll hopefully be able to get through all of this today and we will like I said we will go through the data with disaggregating it so that you're able to see it but everything you're seeing right now is midpoint so if we've gone up from last this time last year that's a good thing and we may be far away from where we were but we this was done in December so we have several months for us you know and our teachers are amazing and so they got us there last year so I have no doubt that they'll get us this year thank you madam chair I am

072I am absolutely delighted to hear that you didn't send it to us cuz I've been sitting here beating myself up I don't have time to go back and look at it but there's been a lot of stuff coming our way and I was just thinking I missed this one of the things that I'm going to go to member Vanos in a minute but in terms of the way we're presenting this material it makes sense to us but intuitively when you look at it you expect 56 to be the first the first thing that happened then the 37 here would be the next thing and then you would be at 39 so for the public when they see it they're going to see 56 dropping to 37 up to 39 and that's not really what it

073is because pm2 comes before pm3 but I understand why you did it because for the board's benefit having them side by side is easier for us it took me a little while to understand why we displayed information again CU I think some people could look at it and think we're jumping around more than we are I don't know what the answer is to that but just probably if I had gotten this ahead of time I would have at least asked that question but again I don't know what the answer is but I do like for the public if they tune in for them to get it well I'm I'm hoping that if they see the dates that might help yeah but the problem is there's 23 24 and most people are not going to have

074any idea what pm2 and pm3 mean that's where again there's us we'll go back and take that Fe because you're right we'll try and make it better yeah have a couple thoughts but we'll talk about that later okay let's go to member Vanos I just have one last question and I don't know if it's for superintendent or for you Dr border but first of all thank you and thank you for coming to my office and walking through this with me and I still had all the questions even though did get briefed on it for so but my question when we talked about just the factors that impact the school grade because I just think it's important to talk about about all of that either either you or Dr vasus mentioned that teachers in the classroom

075had the number one impact and the leadership in the schools had number two impact is that even more impactful or influential on the testing in the school grades than just the socioeconomic status of the students is that what you meant by that or thanks board member vanas no I was referring to two of the highest impacts from some of the Empirical research that's out there there is additional Empirical research that I just personally refuse to support or believe in because I've seen it too many times where it can be refuted but there is there is Empirical research that speaks to socioeconomic status related to student outcomes well I think that you know the two things I was mentioning have an ability to refute that research that is out there on that okay I appreciate that

076and I guess my my question wasn't it was on outcomes as much as it was on testing performance so I appreciate that understood there's certainly much more to outcomes than the test and we're hoping to capture that in our next strategic plan which is coming to the board soon because we agree there's a lot more to outcomes than the test scores and so we're hoping to capture that in our next strategic plan as well perfect thank you all right member Felder I'm sorry okay all right thank you all right there's nobody else on the board thank you're up thanks chair thanks board for the discussion I appreciate it so now we are going to hope to move move through our 18 key performance indicators of our strategic plan efficiently as I can and so I'll

077I'll do my best I'm going to move quickly through the first slide of each key performance indicator because those are the targets that the board had approved years prior and so it's just kind of setting the stage for what we're working on this year to try to reach those targets so if I need to slow down just let me know but my plan for each kpi is the first slide move quick the second slide get into where we're at so on slide 12 our first key performance indicator is narrowing or eliminating our English language arts achievement Gap as measured on the Florida assessment of student thinking and so you can see where our gaps were last year in that final in the third column for 2324 and So based upon if you look at our

078white to black Gap last year being 29% based upon the overall 70 and 41 we want to reduce that Target by 3% this year to 26% and so to to accomplish U narrowing and eliminating our achievement gaps on the next slide are the strategies that we are that have risen to the top that we're focusing on in our strategic plan this year so first we want to increase the percent of ela standards aligned instruction and this is being measured via classroom visits and we are currently at 71% of what we're observing is standards based instruction which is up from 68 with a target of 75 our next strategy is to increase the student achievement in in ela on the fast for each of our student groups you can see our Targets in the final column

079we will not have data by student group until we get official state files so we can certainly share that with the board when those when those come out and then the next one is decreasing the achievement Gap in ela as measured on fast and so similarly for white to black at the first quarter which is the third column over we were at 25% with a target of 26 so we already were below our Target and so certainly if we maintain that pace we are on track to do so we will have the official state file data and be able to share out with the board our Point as of the second quarter but you can see for the first quarter where we were at relative to our targets I want to cover our next key

080performance indicator and then pause for the next two actually and then pause for any questions on those three our next key performance indicator is narrowing our achievement Gap when it comes to mathematics on the state assessment and here respectively you can see white to black for 2324 we finished at 31 % which is based upon the overall 7241 we have a goal to reduce that by 3% and that's similar as you look at our other gaps that we have across the district but we want to reduce by 3% and so on the next slide what we're working on this year the first one is we're looking at our level one and two students in fourth and fifth grade specifically in the areas of number sents and operations with whole numbers category and you can see

081see at the first quarter our fourth graders in that c in that category were at 133% they've now moved up to 30% with a target of where we want to reach of 58% but also looking at the 2324 outcomes which is your third column over we finished last year at 42 so we certainly are on a trajectory to surpass for fifth grade we are currently at 38% which is our second quarter outcome up from 19 the first quarter so we doubled it so again certainly looking on track to surpass the goal the target the or to reach the target of 58% which exceeds last year's outcome of 49% by 9% our next area measure of success is looking at our seventh grade students that are taking our regular math classes and seeing how they are

082come doing on fast so this was kind of talked about earlier and we were at 10% the first quarter three and above we are currently at 15% we have a Target set for 47% here our next measure of success is increasing the percentage of traditional high school students that are on grade level for Algebra 1 being three and above and we were at 39% first quarter currently at 36% and we have a target of 45% in this area keep in mind that this one is measured by by the content for that grading period that is different than the other areas which are on assessment covering the content for an entire year when it comes to mathematics that's our internal measurement and that covers the content for the nine weeks so comparing to a prior quarter

083may not be applicable in those cases so I'll pause after our next kpi which is to increase the percent of third grade students achieving at grade level and above on the fast our Target this year 60% an increase of 3% over a year prior to reach that we're looking to increase the percentage of third grade students that are performing at that level on pm3 first quarter was 31 we moved up to 45 and so that puts us on a trajectory to pass the 57% of last year and also be aligned with the 60% Target we want our elementary administrators to participate in the instructional Leadership Institute this year which is our second year and we are on track for 100% participation we also want our elementary schools to offer seven sessions of the science of

084reading training and 100% of our schools have offered four sessions as of the second quarter and so on track to reach seven sessions this year so I'll pause there and see if there are questions on those three key performance indicators okay I have a question on slide 13 I'm doing this again I'm like what was my question I have down why not all H oh I know it's under increased percent of ela standards aligned classroom in so they're increasing but I'm not sure I understand why it's not higher even though it's definitely increasing are you talking chair for the first measure the increasing percentage of aligned instruction yeah yeah because I mean this is not this is not student performance that we have less control over but correct so what does that mean that so

085we're looking when we visit classrooms to see if the instruction is aligned to the rigor of the standard and it's a walkthrough tool that our school supervisors utilize when they walk through and so it's collected that way but we had we're seeing 71% of the instruction aligned to the rigor of the standard which was up from 68% first quarter so we're seeing we're seeing it continue to move okay so when you use the term rigor that helps me a little because it when I saw this I thought you're just saying they're just teaching something else so if they have a class that isn't up to that standard they're not going to be at that level because they need to meet the kids where they are okay correct and there you know and there are times

086where adjustments are made based upon how a class is performing and things that may need to be done and so you know the walkthrough tool is just one piece yeah of this okay page slide so my concern here you know it looks like grade four we went from 133% to 30% it's reasonable we'll get to 58% we're seeing you know huge jump grade five seven it may come back to the same answer you've you've given us before but we only went up 5 percentage points and if I'm understanding this we have a goal of so the rest of them I think are reasonable goals I don't I remember we spent a lot of time on what these targets would be but obviously not only are we not going to hit it but was it reasonable

087to begin with and why was it 33 last year and 10 15 just again it may come down to the same answer but you'll just have to tell me the same thing again chair I can we'll follow up and get more we'll follow up with staff and get more information but we finished last year at 33 and so we certainly you know a lot of there's a lot of intervention and other pieces that take place now between now and the state assessment and so I you know I do believe that we can make that jump to be where we were at last year and hopefully move towards our Target of 47% but I'll follow up with st let me ask one other question yeah you're right if if we were at 33 and you we

088were thinking 30 or 47 that's kind of in in line oh it's a little yeah kind of in line with the other increases what I'm what I'm not sure of is were we looking at these same percentage increases the previous year and did we make it but you'll follow up I'm glad and I'm glad you asked that question chair I was thinking the same thing as I was sitting here so we'll we'll oh well I'm so glad we'll look and see what our data was in that area last year and it may it may cause us reason to say okay or we may need to have a further look Dr vas I feel validated but you also might just be appeasing me I don't know but whatever it is thanks I was I was thinking

089the same thing CH Dr Vasquez did you want to speak okay thank you thanks chair okay so we're going to move on to our next set of key performance indicators our first one is looking to increase our participation and performance in meaningful accelerated Pathways again this is measured by how acceleration is measured at from the state assessment system so in Middle School last year we finished at 76 we have a target of 84 and high school we finished at 64 we have a target of 71 so what we're working on this year is five different metrics the first one is we want District performance to reach 71 overall for our high schools which is what you saw on the last slide we're currently at 53% it's important to keep keep in mind that a lot

090of students earn their industry certifications as the year goes on later in the year they also may pass advanced placement IB Cambridge exams which all fall into this past do enrollment courses so this number will continue to grow up and pretty exponentially throughout the rest of the year next 75% of our Traditional High Schools will reach 71 so that's looking at each individual high school and are they currently at 71 again there's a lot more to happen between now and the end of the year and so that's as of today two of the high schools are already at 71 so I don't feel any angst there given that a lot of that comes in much later in the year our next one is to dis the district performance we reach 84% overall for Middle School

091we'll share that with the board soon again there's pending PMA data there that ties in with algebra and geometry in middle school because that counsil in their acceleration in middle school and so we will provide that to the board as we are able to to have a closer look at that information we want half of the middle schools to be at 84% or higher we were at 14% first quarter we'll be much higher now we'll well we'll be higher now I don't know the percentage higher but we'll we'll have a look at that and share that with the board based upon PMA to and finally we want to provide opportunities for middle school students to get College and Career exploration through our co Career and Technical education centers and we've had 20 events so far

092with a target of 27 the next kpi want to discuss is our teacher self-reported student resiliency so this is something that teachers respond to on our survey we were at 86% last year and our Target this year is 90 89% which is Teachers indicating that they are confident in their ability to support student resiliency to reach that we want all of our schools participating in resiliency events We are continuing at 100% we want our school staff to be confident after completing the resiliency course so we survey them we're at 77% as of the second quarter our goal is we want 100% we want School administrators to participate in resiliency training we have a target of 100% for that we'll continue to work towards we have want our school-based student services teams to to also be

093confident after their professional learning sessions and we're at 88% confidence among those student services teams we want our to embed resiliency strategies into the district new teacher induction program and we're at 100 % for doing that so we already exceeded the plan that we had for that our next key performance indicator is that all of our traditional schools will be rated SE higher we currently had all but four schools there at 98% we want to get to 100% this year to do that we're looking to increase the communication with our teachers and families via talking points you can see the breakdown as of the second quarter we have not been able to disaggregate that specifically to teacher but for all staff at the schools we're at 66% and it's the same for our families communicating

094back with us at 66% on talking points we have goals 75 and 60% respectively so we're already exceeding the planned goal for families we want to improve the percent of students scoring at or above grade level on the corresponding Ela State assessment by 3% at Eagles Nest our academic center for excellence College Park and Memorial you can see that we are we moved up 133% at Eagles Nest 8% at academic center for excellence 13% at College Park and we've moved up 9% at Memorial so they all are continuing to move forward we want to achieve retention rate of 65% of our instructional staff in our in in the schools I just mentioned and we are on Pace for that as of the end of the second quarter we were at 65% so I will pause

095there on those three key performance indicators and see if there are questions I have a couple of questions for you slide 19 row two yeah okay so I'm I'm I've got to be misunderstanding something so the target is 75% and I'm looking at 4 and a half and %. what am I misunderstanding here no thanks chair this one is you know we're obviously in the final year of this strategic plan but as we move into Futures if this becomes a measure of success we'll we'll look at how maybe we word it but the intent here is that 75% of our traditional high schools so there's 23 of them so 75% of those 16 will reach a level of 71% or higher on their acceleration rate and so as of today there's two of them which

096is tremendous because a lot of this is going to come in later in the year when students complete industry certif ifications they take their AP exams IB exams Cambridge exams and pass them they pass St enrollment courses with C or higher all of that will factor in and so these numbers move up really exponentially throughout the rest of the year so that's as of today two schools are already at that percentage did we have something similar to this last year because that answer I've heard before so actually last year for this our measures of success actually just mirrored our scorecard and so we wanted to try to take it a little bit deeper this year but it's been a similar discussion but what I remember was that I'm looking at this thinking it's it's going

097to gradually increase and you explaining that completion Factor happens at the end of the year so this is one especially at the high school level you can look for exponential increases and even middle school because there are C if they're taking a high school course and they pass it successfully some of those courses count in this component and so that you know those won't count until they've completed it at the end of the year slide 21 I'm sure there's an equal explanation for this but the school administrators being at 30% that really that surprised me so I would just add chair that I mean there's a lot on the plates of our administrators and a lot coming and so you know we'll we'll certainly continue to offer sessions and encourage attendance but you know we're

098at 30% now and this will there will probably be exponential gain here as well but it's not a required man you know training but it's one that we put out there and offer and so we'll we'll continue to to do that and Market the opportunities and the last slide 23 I know you covered this but that's really exciting to see that grow grow in those schools so I know you covered it but rather than just focusing on the areas of concern or question I just wanted to take a minute to just wow thanks CH is wow thank you okay member salamona thank you chair so one of the questions I had was around the middle school accelerator options so no it's not this one it's the one where it's like how many of our students

099are participating in some of the accelerated Pathways yeah I think it's that second to last 51 so what what are we counting here in terms of acceleration components thanks board member Salam MOA so this is how the state measures us on acceleration and so Ben if I leave anything out feel free to jump in but it's our the denominator is different so at high school the denominator here is the entire senior class that is on a standard diploma track in Middle School these are the students who are level three or higher on their fast assessment so that is the denominator and then to to satisfy being considered accelerated for this component if they pass Algebra 1 or geometry if they pass a high school course if they obain an industry certification then am I leaving

100anything out yeah so just in in the Middle School it's really the majority of our students in that Middle School acceleration pathway are in algebra one or geometry it's also any of the other courses with an EOC associated with it so that would be biology US History or well Civics is a middle school eocc so that doesn't count but any of those courses if they pass the EOC level three or higher they countor as being that's the numerator that's how they get their acceleration there's another component of that actually lags by a year which is industry certification at the middle school level so students last year who took an industry certification test and passed it would also count towards that Middle School acceleration component got it okay that makes sense to me now all right

101I just wanted to know what those definitions were thank you thanks board member salaka all right moving forward okay moving on to our next set of key performance indicators our first one is increasing students positive perceptions of classroom and schoolwide culture last year respectively in middle school we were at 30 and high school we were at 34 we have resp targets of 39 here on the next slide you'll see what we're working on this year I would also be remiss if I did not remind the board that we transitioned our survey inhouse at a half a million dollars cost that it was Prior and we transitioned that in-house we also looked at the number of questions on the survey last year we had committees with staff we have greatly reduced the number of questions this

102year which has led to in most cases higher participation this year and so I don't think I can say scientifically but I think more reliable data because people may be reading the questions more and answering them with them being fewer so I use that as a preview to say we're looking at the schools that are part of our Stetson University pilot which was a set of schools in this area that had some of our lower schoolers before Stetson is supporting us and so we don't the fall survey 100% of those schools were above 39% you're going to see that similarly because with the new survey we are looking much better but I think also much more reliable information in my opinion that's anecdotal but I believe so our Target is 100% of those schools continuing

103on that track for middle schools that fell below 39% last year we were asking them to do a secondary dive survey after the fall survey where they could go deeper into a specific area that they wanted to find out more about we all exceeded that however the superintendent asked that we still look at our schools in the lower ctiw as part of continuous Improvement and still work with them on a secondary survey and so that's currently in place and happening but all of our middle schools scored above the target of 39% on the fall survey and the similarly at the high school all scoring above it matter of fact 86 % there was the scores in that category and I'm sorry I remiss on this so let me reset 69% of our middle schools scored

104above it overall it has certainly gone up which you'll see in other slides 86% at the high school level but we are working with the lowest quartile of our schools to take a deeper look on where we're at with that I'm going reset on this one one more time that was the number of schools last year that were below those numbers the reason it's na this year is all schools are above it my apologies for that happy to answer questions though when they when we get to that clarify we're good student sense of belonging similarly last year our middle schools were 38 and our high schools 35 respectively Target this year 41 and 38 which are 3% increases so again here you can see the number of schools last year that were below those numbers

105numb this year on the fall survey all of our schools are outperforming those numbers and we are still though going to do a secondary dive with the lower CTI schools to continue to move forward for sense of belonging at safe meetings we want safe and school-based social worker meetings that topic to be covered at all those meetings and that has been covered at all of those meetings next key performance indicator is increasing the efficiency and of recruitment efforts by what we call touch points which is when we're interacting with employees that we are recruiting and we had a target of 812 which is for the end of the year we are already at 788 so well on Pace for that Target to reach that we want to attain at least an 88% response on our

106Junior and senior intern survey satisfaction we're at 94% exceeding our Target of 90 for our students who go our UCF students go on our Title One tours to see the great things at our schools we're to 93% satisfaction with a goal there of 85% and we want to increase the number of events attended to recruit instructional staff by 3% we are have a target of 170 we were already at 103 as of second quarter next we want to increase the retention rate of instructional and non-instructional Personnel we have a Target here of 89% which is a bump up from last year it's important to note that is exceeding the national retention rate average we want to increase the retention to do that we're looking at our resignation rate for all non hourly positions as of

107second quarter we were at 3.25% that we want to be under 8.29% by the end of the year for retirement rate for non- hourly we 65% we want to be under 1.6% at year end and for communication with all employees in year five of drop because they can go for three more years we've done that with all of those employees our next key performance indicator is looking to increase the amount of available resources through Innovation and collaboration we measure this through our rebates we had a target of $18,350 this year to reach that we're looking to increase the number of rebate resources to two this year we also are looking to or to have two of those this year we want to increase the number of contracts with rebate options so we're looking to have

108one of those this year and we also want to increase awareness through targeted monthly communication on contracts and initiatives with rebate options and we have a target of 12 for that area cover one more kpi key performance indicator and then see if there are any questions next is reducing the number of classroom Portables we have a target of 831 we finished at 1,031 as of or I'm sorry we our outcome last year was 1,31 We have a Target to be down to 831 this school year at the end to do that we want our new schools to open on time we are one of two on schedule we want to remove unneeded Portables We've have 21 lease Portables removed we have a target of 230 to be removed and a lot of that of course

109happens through the end of the year and in the summer Master schedules reviewed to ensure that our Portables that are at our schools are needed and so that's part of the budgeting process in the spring with waiting enrollment projection figures and we want functional Equity of classroom addition projects open on time so all of our additional construction projects at our schools and we have three of six projects on time so I will pause there and see if there are any questions before we continue thank you member Fant thank you I just had a quick question regarding the Stetson University pilot on school climate and culture do we know how many students actually participate in that I will follow up Miss FR and get you additional information on that perfect and then the other thing I'd

110love to see is what does that survey look like like what kind of questions are we asking how many questions are there I do know that the longer the survey is the more kids tend to just click whatever they want to get done with the survey and so just to clarify Miss fron are you talking about the survey we use as a district I because I'll need to find out more details on the stats and support I don't know that they're doing a survey or if it's training and professional learning with our staff so when you say survey do you mean our staff survey or whatever survey we're giving the students that came from ston or if that's something that we're providing I'll share with you our district survey that we're that we're giving and

111keep in mind that we just survey our secondary students so perfect okay perfect okay thank you okay that's all we have excellent thank you all right our next key performance indicator is our use of District Wellness Resources and so you will see our targets respectively this year for our physical exams our well visits our breast cancer cervical cancer and colon cancer screenings to reach those targets we want ocps positive news stories during awareness months on cancer screening and those are slated to be occurring in the months respectively of January March and may we want to communicate to employees that have not had their cancer screenings but should be according to recommendations from the CDC or American Cancer Society and so far cumulatively we've had four of those so we are on Pace to reach our

112Target of seven we want our employee Wellness representatives to provide bimonthly communication on screenings and other Wellness activities and cun cumulatively we are already at 43 of those events next we want to increase a high quality responsive and customer service experience this is specifically related to information technology and Heat tickets that are completed and we have a target of 98% satisfaction to reach our Target our CIO team has a target of 91 visits with school administrators and staff next we aim to increase efficiency improvements for common issues and we have a target of 27 for that by end of year next we want to establish a self-help program to assist users in to select the proper entry for tickets or assistance an average of at least five times per month with a target of 20

113so that chatbot has been built it's in the final phases of quality assurances and we want to just make sure it's expansive enough and it the plan is for a February rollout next we want to increase the number of volunteers and Partnerships you can see our Target respectively for volunteers of 79,3 and 5,36 for Partnerships to reach our Target we aim to increase the number of read to succeed volunteer tutors by 30% which would take us to 604 currently at 311 next we want to increase the ocps employees who volunteer to 5,620 or more we already have 5,130 next we want to increase our current current corporate projects by 3% to 88 and we're currently at 56 and finally we want to document the number of businesses targeted and registered based on Prospect research and

114our collaboration groups with a target of 42 and we have reached that Target our next kpi is to increase the total dollars raised by the foundation for Orange County Public Schools we have a target of 5,455 644 to reach that Target we want to increase the number of new donors to at least 3,000 currently at 977 we want to increase the retention rate of donors to 25% or higher we're at 17.15 we want our individual donors to increase to 4,000 or more and we're currently just under 2,000 we want to increase our followers on Facebook and Linkedin we're at 4542 and we want to increase donors to to our ocps gives campaign to 500 and we are already at 440 next we want to increase opportunities for stakeholders to provide feedback across Orange County Public

115Schools and we have a target of 1,454 opportunities so our Chiefs and deputies have a target of 948 School visits this year our superintendent had a focus group in town hall goal of 90 this year and our thought exchange across divisions with stakeholders we had a target of 46 and we're already at 690 in that category and so all these will feed into that overall key performance indicator and finally or not finally next we want to increase the District's internal and external satisfaction rating and it is finally across the district and known as our net promoter score and we were at 34% detractors last year we want to decrease that to 28% detractors to reach that our district divisions are going to have a goal to decrease detractors by 3% on the fall survey and

11620 almost 27% of our divisions did that we want to decrease detractors by 3% on the fall survey compared to last year all of our schools and 26% of our schools did that and we also want our schools to decrease detractors by 3% from the fall to Spring survey and we'll be able to see that when the spring survey is administered so that is our final key performance indicator and so I will look forward to questions from the board and discussion Dr Vasquez again thank you so much to the team and to all of our Chiefs that have really helped Drive the work in our strategic plan board members we greatly appreciate the feedback that you have given us today as we move to close out the 2025 strategic plan and move into our new

117strategic plan any other changes you would like to see to the reporting of the data that would make it more helpful we would love to know as soon as you're able to as we are already anxiously finalizing our new strategic plan so thank you again thank you superintendent we have three board members queued up with comments or questions and I am first so I have a quick question about the customer service indicator and you had said that this relates to our Heat tickets and IT department so my question is and this might be something we can look at for our coming strategic plan but is it possible for us to also look at in the future our customer service experience of parents for the schools because that's probably one of the biggest complaints I get

118is either phones not being answered at schools when they call the school or phone calls not being returned those are two of the biggest complaints I get from parents about schools and I think that has a huge impact on the perception of our schools and how you know helpful and willing they are and really a lot of times is just everyone's busy and or some's going on and but I always feel like there should be somebody at a desk answering a phone at a school but but anyway so is there could we add that at somewhere in our indicators because I think that's is a really at least that's my opinion that's a really important thing that we need to really work on make sure our schools are provided especially in this in this world

119of choice we need to be treating our parents with that kind of responsiveness so I would love to see that added at some point so thanks board member bird so I think that we have an opportunity in in the next strategic plan and even currently with the spring survey with the secondary dive surveys our schools that score in the lower quartile have an opportunity to follow up with additional questions and so with our schools that are in the lower quartile with their families will work with the team to add in questions specifically about cust customer service and the examples you gave so that way we can see if if that like you're saying you're getting communication on that is a contributing that we can then address perfect thank you next is member Vanos thank you

120Vice chair I also just wanted to elevate what member bird said in fact I was at a middle school today and the principal was telling me that he'd read for every one negative experience a parent has you have to have 10 positive experiences to make up for it so I just think that's such an important Point the question I had and I'm sorry this was actually in the Chunk we did before this on on slide 29 I just have one question and it's in and we had talked about it when you came into my office about the interns in ocps and I really appreciate the follow-up that you provided me I had asked how many interns we had and how many were hired and you had shared that there were 292 interns that we had

121an ocps we' hired 149 of them my question is what percent you know what percentage did we make offers to and what percentage accepted the offer and I know you probably don't have that right now but if you could follow up with that I'm just curious about you know love the positive survey feedback my question is just is this does this ultimately a place that they would want to work and I know there are other factors there but I'd be interested in that thanks board member Vanos we'll follow up thank you thank you member Fant perfect thank you so mine is not really a question on the data but more what Dr Vasquez was saying like how can we improve for the 2030 plan and I think for me and it sounds like a lot

122of us up here just breaking down the data a little bit more even if it was something where we can click on it and it would just come up with a little more information especially for that Ela and math because a lot of that can be confusing or misconstrued especially that seventh grade when you're you're seeing okay maybe this test we only actually tested 200 students because 800 of them were taking the pre-algebra test or algebra one or whatever it might be and so I think for us to kind of understand that it would be really helpful again with the star reading and the star early literacy those types of components I think would be really helpful thank you thanks board member front appreciate that feedback and excited to share the tool with you on

123February 11th we're getting a lot of positive feedback so far and there'll be opportunities for us moving forward to continue to look at that tool and see how we can continue to take it to the next level wonderful thank you does anyone have anything else to share okay no further oh one more thing M Sal just to say thank you I know the team has been doing so much work between preparing this and also what will be the future strategic plan and the data so I definitely appreciate that you've had a lot of of parallel work and I'm very excited for the for the new numbers and I think we're being very thoughtful about the new categories and what makes sense to measure and what doesn't and so just props to the team thank you

124so much thanks board memb salamak and thanks to the board for all of your collaboration I'm excited for ocps 2030 to come to you soon and looking forward to what that can bring to the district and also thanks to the working group leaders as well as the Chiefs for all their continued support of the Strategic plan they do a tremendous job helping to move everything forward and providing information for this presentation today so thanks to to them and their team teams as well Cu the working group leaders do a great job thank you thank you member Felder yes I I too along with member Salam Monica I know this is a lot of work and you didn't just do it overnight it took a lot of effort and anytime you come into my office you

125allow me to ask all kinds of questions and you answer all of you when when I'm meeting with you and I just want to tell you thank you and I believe as a super attendent suggested some things some more things are going to happen so that we can get some clarity cuz I specifically and I'm sure other board members may have the same sentiment I'd like to know within my district some of the schools and what you know I see that there was some a great deal of success with a lot of my schools and I'm so grateful because my principles all of them they work very very hard and the teachers and I'm just so incredibly grateful for what they do and they do it like they love it so I'm I'm I'm so

126happy and the cabinet members who come they're always in my schools doing things so I'm happy but I would like to know because if there's some specific kinds of issues that we need to zero in on to help our students become more successful then I am all for that because we don't know the climate that's going to come when ensuing year and how many children you we just don't know what's going to happen to their ability to be able to stay in school and learn how to read and read and do mathematical computations with success we don't know you know so while we're on this road of upward you know Mobility I want us and I'm so proud of this District in terms of what we do because we are the fourth largest and eighth

127in the nation so to me that speaks volumes we have what 22 high schools about to be 23 that'll be graduating next year 25 26 so I just want to tell you thank you for your effort I appreciate it thank you thank you board member Felder thank you the superintendent thank you go ahead thank you Madame Vice chair so two points first I know that we have a training coming up I'm wondering if we could take maybe a 10-minute break and second those that are not involved with the training that would be anyone that is not a board member anyone that is not that does not sit on the DI or on the two sides or the individuals that are going to do the training do need to leave because it's a confidential training and

128then third board member bur did you hear my comments apologizing yes I did because I had on the TV in the back I turned it on back there yes all right thank you that those were that's it thank you I real fast right before I adjourn I just wanted to comment again because I was in the back when we were talking about the board members getting individual data for your schools I do want to definitely agree with that because we as board members are often asked either by our Chambers or you know other elected officials or in our constituents you know they want to know hey what what's going on with so and so School how's it doing and I would love to be able to share some of this great data wow you would

129not believe the good things that are happening and you know this school or that school so yeah I definitely feel like that's going to be so beneficial for us board members thanks shur thank you okay if there's no further business this meeting is adjourned thank you all oh

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.