CorpusRecord 50349

Public Hearing: Chapter 505 Rulemaking Proposal

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Maine Department of the Secretary of State
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Kennebec County, ME
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,899 words · about 22 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001welcome to the public hearing today I'm Secretary of State Shan Bellos and I'm pleased to welcome all of you to today's public hearing January 16 2025 which is beginning now and it is precisely 1:08 pm and so we will extend the hearing time to 3:08 PM should it be required uh this is on the proposed repeal and replacement of chapter 505 voter list maintenance proced procur submitted through citizen petition this hearing was noticed on December 25th 2024 and advertised uh on December 26 2024 in major newspapers in the state notice was also provided by email to stakeholders and interested parties ins sufficient time to allow for participation in this hearing and the written comment this hearing is being reported my name is shanana Bellow uh main secretary of state with me are the senior policy

002director Emily cook Assistant Attorney General John Bolton communications director Claire davit and our technology Aid and uh extraordinaire executive assistant Mary Mary KES the proposed real repeal and replacement of chapter 505 was proposed by private citizens in a petition signed by 150 or more registered voters under tile by section 8055 of the main revine statutes the department of secretary of state is required to initiate rule making proceedings and invite public comment on the proposed rule the proposed rule would repeal and replace the current rule governing maintenance of voter registration records under the national voter registration Act of 1993 the proposed rule would also impose on Municipal regist new and modified requirements relating to voter list maintenance and the cancellation of and eligible voters the rule would also create new standards for regist to determine whether

003people seeking to register to vote or qualified voters the procedure for today's hearing is simple anyone wishing to provide public comments must sign an advance the hearing is scheduled from 1: to 3M all those who have signed in by 3M will have the opportunity to be heard as the hearing officer I will call people forward to the seat uh you pass by or speak standing or sitting in this chair in the order that you have signed in when your name is call please step forward for purposes of viewers at home and for the official record of the proceeding please state your name your town or city of residents uh if you're here on behalf of an organization that organization that you represent and then present your comment in keeping with the rules of the legislature

004each person will have a Max maximum of three minutes to speak but you may provide written comments that are as in detailed length as you choose I will be indicating when you have one minute left uh and I will also indicate when your time has expired uh this isn't a discussion or debate so it's not a Q&A and if you have questions that you'd like to submit in your written comment we may we may answer those at that time but this is your opportunity it's the Public's opportunity to tell the department of Secretary of State what your views are and what uh changes uh whether you agree with this proposed rule or disagree with this proposed Rule and uh what you would like to see have happen in the interest of fairness we will alternate

005between proponents and opponents of the rule during this hearing we'll begin with the first person on the signin sheet who supports the proposed rule uh or provision of the proposed rule if there's part of it that you like we'll hear from the first person who opposes the proposed rule uh then um I don't see that any have signed up yet but if there is anyone that is neither for nor against the proposed rule they would then have an opportunity to speak in the order that they have signed up we will continue to rotate in that order a proponent an opponent and either for or against and so on uh this is not um you don't have to stay for the whole thing uh till 308 um if you've spoken your piece and you want to

006exit the room or if you have business outside or you want to switch seats with someone check on something whatever you can get up at any time it is 100% permissible and just exitting the door behind you just try to be as quiet as possible no eating in this room you know no no gum no loud Applause or commentary because each person that speaks it is their opportunity to be heard without comment or reaction either favorable or unfavorable from those ass um and as I already mentioned if you have written testimony or comments you'd like to share um and prefer to do that instead of speaking publicly or in addition to speaking publicly feel free to do so if those written comments are with you today um uh my communications director Claire davit will be

007accepting those when you when you step forward um if you prefer to submit them after the fact uh you may submit them to Melissa Packer she's a designated uh person and the notice of hearing to receive comments her email is melissa. me.gov uh you could also mail them to the Bureau of Corporations elections and commissions that is 184 State House station Augusta Main d184 and that uh email address and uh regular address can be provided to you after the conclusion of the hearing if you didn't get that in that quick reading the deadline for written comments on the proposed rule is January 31st 2025 that's close of business it's 5:00 pm here of the division of Elections must be received by that date not postmarked received um with that being said thank you all for

008coming out um we always love it to hear the citizens views about elections we love citizen engagement in our elections that what's makes our democracy work um so welcome and we will proce uh and we will start uh with a proponent of the rule testifying in favor Sandra Mason of a guesta please uh join us thank you I'd rather stand up because I'm kind of sure totally fine um I speak in favor of this because I live on Young Road and this in austo and my name is Sandra Mason I live there for 60 years so I know everybody on the road put a dead and Bo around the lake and there only 43 suppos there um I got the voter registration list from the city cour and since I know everybody and I've known

009them for many years I know who has left I know who still lives there many of these on this list 21% of the people on on this list do not with there if their children who grew up with my children and moved away decades over why are they still there well unfortunately in the towns the city CL get gained why aren't they there well the city clerks don't have the ability to update the list however there's deadly opportunity for people who are not necessarily following the law to easily find out who's not living there and to go in and get an L that creates a situation of mistrust within the voting public because we know this can be done and it affects elections and that's why people get upset but they're upset with the RO

010people they're upset with the city clerks City CLS have no way to update this list until the state of allows them to do it so what are you all waiting for decades old lists of people on here who don't exist anymore there who live out of stain who moved away but they're still on the list and the fail people can take them Lo in and say I want Ann ballot by name of so and so I live at such and such they get the ballot and they have the ability to it that how elections are often lost so it's pretty upsetting to be in this kind of situation and people are not happy about it but they're unhappy with the B people it's not the town fo it is state of give them the ability

011to update their way thank you have thank you U we will now hear from first opponent to the proposed Ro P Boon sure to but I'll [Laughter] it good afternoon secretary bow my name is Patty Duo I am uh the chairperson for the legislative policy committee for the many towns and City Clerks Association uh we are opposed to the proposed rule p292 and we thank you for the opportunity to speak on this um today committee members expressed concern about the costs that municipalities were would incur for the required mailing every five years mailing cost for postcards would be approximately 50 cents per unit plus labor costs if done in house uh if the third party is used those costs would be even higher many of these ma mailers could be returned as a deliverable which

012makes the process somewhat inefficient in addition uh Municipal clerks already have a Myriad of Duties um that are required to do and this would just add to the workload course uh due to the recent High turnover in the clerk and regist professions members pointed out that a lack of training and experience with new clerks and registrars could result in an inconsistent administration of this process over the five voting jurisdictions clerks noted that the additional recordkeeping requirements along with a longer retention period for certain records is an additional Garnet for into clerks and registers collecting and retaining certain documents regarding canceled voters for a longer period than the designated retention time for canceled phot registration cards seems illogical and cumbersome our members suggested that allowing registrars the option to perform phot list maintenance might be helpful

013rather than making it mandatory so long as that process is detailed it doesn't result in any violations of federal law members noted that the Secretary of State's office is well versed in state and federal laws and has membership in the Eric system which is a paid subscription that works with several other states to compare data and help identify voters who have registered elsewhere M clerks do not have access to the Eric system in addition the Secretary of State's office can manipulate the central vo registration system to help automate the voter list maintenance process if they desire to do so so we thank you for the opportunity to speak on this and U having to answer questions thank you very much appreciate that um our next we're going to go switch back to proponents um B

014Corbin A yeah and I think there was somebody else who was trying to get in that individual does not want to testify okay um that brings us to Olivia ground and if any of folks in the other room we now have two seats hello SEC are registered to it is important to make sure that people College temporary work not have thank you um we will next hear from Alicia Ray of Le Justin yes [Laughter] good afternoon secretarys and members of the department at the Secretary of State my name is Alicia Ray and I am a Talis Alli for the American civil liberties Union with me for more than 50 years the ACLU of me has worked to defend and preserve the constitutional rights of all people in our state including preserving to voting I'm here

015today to express some of the ACL world's concerns about the proposed changes to Main's voter list maintenance procedures while we recognize that there may be room for improvement in how those voter lists are maintained we believe that these particular changes would ween main voting LS they will these changes would create significant barriers for voters and registers alike we urge you to reject them first the proposed changes to the National change of address program remove the requirement from last confirmation mailing to to verify those address changes without that step participation in this program generally will have little value second the proposals to Define how a voter becomes vote inactive the current rule provides clear guidance on this but with removing that critical section this inactive status becomes fairly meaningless it also risks voter and register condution

016The Proposal also removes the requirement for vs to update voter records when someone moves within the same municipality this could lead to complications out of elections are administered by municipality but we have many Geographic delineations for host districts Senate districts County Wards Municipal Wards and this lack of instruction for those moving within the same town or city will make a harder for Bo Sy well we have concerns with the proposed changes in section five would would Place additional burden on voters to present what is noted as a current identification by requiring voters to update expired IDs we are creating an unnecessary economic barrier for low-income voters who may not have the means to renew their identification this would restrict access to the voter list and hinder those voters ability to exercise their vote finally the

017proposed changes in Section 8 require the National voting uh the NB data reports um those are unnecessary and won't work to improve current practices we Rec excuse me rejecting those changes as well in conclusion the ACLU of believes strongly that the proposed changes would undermine me already strong commitment to accessible fair and transparent elections and we respectfully request that the department reject those changes thank you um William I am the leader of this proposal before I start I would like to say I know there are some tyos that g into the proposed discuss those at later time if you want won't close any reasonable changes on that that's I the current version of chapter 505 was adopt in 1995 and hasn't been touched since last century um instead the accepted practice seems to be functionally

018repealing this regulation By ignoring it and setting the bar and not violating federal law for a department usted with making sure main agencies take their regulations seriously that seems a darn AR bad example to set main statutes require agencies to adopt rules of practice governing the conduct of the judicary proceedings the rendering of advisory rulings and Define a judicary proceeding anything in in any proceeding in which the legal rights duties or privileges specific persons are determined there are few rights more fundamental than right to vote even setting aside the questions raised by a state agency ignoring its own rules failing to regulate M's photo registration process this inevitably undermines The credibility of our elections by fueling doubts about who is and is not a legitimate voter for years we've listened to State officials concerned only

019with streamlining voter Administration and being publicly disdainful of concerns about unqualified voters long- departed voters and voters getting registered in towns other than moved than their Hometown we need to remind registar that registering voters in the correct municipality is just as important as ra Comm in the first place main thought clearly states that residence for voting purposes is something more permanent than wherever a would be voter lays their head many voters who are longtime residents their towns resent seeing their votes in local elections deluded by officials temp encouraging temporary residents and visitors to vote in those same elections even citizens who aren't worried about which town voters registering should be alarmed about the overgo number of registered voters according to your uh report to the legislature last year the CBR had 1.15 million registered voters

020on January 17th another 3,400 registered in time of June primary and another 32,000 registered online that's more than 47,000 4.1% more registered voters than the official voting population of 1.14 million as a point of comparison those 47,000 ghost voters outnumber the almost 40,000 that you reported mooved from the CPR last last year in fact they almost equal the double of 49,000 IFI duplicates you reported as having been unregistered since theem of 2007 those overages are echoed throughout the local voter roles and you can't have an accurate election if you don't know how many voters you're actually starting with especially when we're having elections and bond issues decided by the beest handful of votes bottom line if you want to dispill this trust in our elections there's no better place to start in adopting this regulation

021of the first step in transparency so people can see how the system is supposed to work and judge by what they see how well it is worth thank you I aop our next uh person to speak is Al Cleveland of Port I love sh Shar um my name is Al Cleveland I'm the director for the wom voters the league open voter to m is a nonpartisan political organization that's been working for over a hundred years to encourage informed and active participation in government to increase understanding of major public policy issues and to influence public policy through education democracy we neither support or oppose any political party or campaign the Wom sub names here ask the Secretary of State to Define this SCH of proposal this propos rule is unnecessary the in of toties it contains

022Provisions that are duplicated in or in contradiction with st law and it transfers the cost and responsibility for nna compliance and other functions which are now centralized and coordinated at the state level down to municipalities creating rundes inefficiencies and duplication of efforts as well as introducing more opportunities for ER opens up municipalities to litigation when mistakes are made and it offers no promise that voters will be better served or the vo Ro maintain at a higher standard for the last four years the leag of wom voters has run a broad election observation program for hundreds of volunteers across the state monitoring home places to observe the conduct of our elections and our volunteers have consistently witnessed to many elections to be fair secure and safe support efforts to make our election are secure but this

023measure would not achieve those goals this proposed rule would not support strengthening election system you should be reected thank you the next speaker is suzan from last well r that family tells me um I take it Ro Rob Rob whatever um nice to meet you all thank you for minutes here um I uh took note of this um proposal and jumped kind of right on it I'm a voter in b b and I've um done a lot of like helping with campaigns and I work on PO work Etc and I just uh wanted to come today to say I support upgrading the voter um list maintenance procedures and um because the in my experience um the current inaccuracies of eligible voters is pretty astounding and I think pretty detrimental to all of our political parties

024during our election process um and ignoring this chaos to me it's not really a strategy of winning elections for any party but it really shows on organization and incompetence and state and um so in a general overall I think would be often better that we take note on it and try to improve on the maintenance procedures um attentions to details I thought would benefit Everyone by delivering our confidence and Assurance in our elections and we results um I've been directly involved in elections through po working I support candidates um and I work off the voter roles and it they give me to call to follow up on meeting and who they've met as voters and whatnot and um I have just found unbelievable nobody lives where they're supposed to live or they're not even in

025the town and it's not even their name and and it's just a a disaster um and uh I kind of been disgusted at all the the fake the fakeness that I come across the addes are wrong numbers are wrong I get answering machines and they not the people that are supposed to be there um so uh I took did a little look through and I saw that in 2006 which about 19 years ago the doj reached an agreement with me to ensure the accuracy Integrity of the young maners f in accordance with help America vote act and National voter registration act and I read on that said the agreement set a plan to put a computerized registration database at this Mr D who was in office um and the doj investigation found that M main

026ver rols contained significant number of inable Voters and the agreement asked um for me to conduct a program maintenance and I just don't see that there's any maintenance um I live in Bor which is home of USM college and my daughter she's her home and I'm running out yeah okay um so I had the uh some firsthand knowledge I know that I wanted to hone in the propos changes especially for that they'd be a fixed R to them because I've I've had experience going through some of the names the their dorms and Then followed by the phone numbers which are out of state 719 508 408 area and um one real quick uh last year we I did a recount I initiated a recount we so close in elections on a budget and uh it

027was quite an experience it was wonderful experience um in all we did not come out ahead we're still very close but I got to look at the list the voter list and then I'm I'm done here but right here I have found when I got that opportunity there was eight people born in 1910 1921 1918 and U obviously not around that any and so real quick uh that was only three hours of my time and I think that I know this cost all this mailings and I mean I can do if want me to clean up the V I can just go through and pick out who's not around anymore I can start there they didn't show just didn't show that they voted good thank you thank you thanks um there are no more proponents

028in the room that have signed up on the signing sheet um I'm gonna ask mared to see if there's anybody outside that's on the sign up sheet uh there is a call in number um I'm not sure that individual just listening there are four people on the zoom who um indicated that they are opposed to the rule but they're not sure if they'd like to testify so I'm assuming that that means um yeah if you can they raise their hand in the webinar not sure the person who was called in do that but the person who was called in I'm going to you to a panelist okay if they would like to um say your name your town or city whether your Pro whether you're in favor or opposed in any organization failure to say

029your name in town will be immediate disconnection okay so the person on the phone wishes to speak you your name and all right I um and no one else has raised their hand in Ling um then that concludes the formal um hearing for the school um I'm just going to restate the deadlines because I do really appreciate everyone that brought written comment um we'll be accepting comment until January 31st 2025 at Clos of business rules then require uh they provide 120 days for me to review the proposed rule review all of the comments that I received and make it deter um about whether to adopt the rule in full or in part or to make some sort of amendments to current rules um or take new action uh and um I do really appreciate everyone's

030engagement and participation today I think it's really really exciting to see this level of commitment um and engagement in our elections it really means a lot I I do want to share with you and for those watching uh on Zoom we uh yesterday submitted a required report that must be Mr Clardy alluded to the 2023 report we submit a report on the central voter registration system and voter registration I through all aspects of voter registration whether that's coming from our clerks in in same day voter registration whether it's coming from The Bureau Motor Vehicles automatic voter registration program or whether it's coming from our newest program online voter registration so yesterday we did submit that report to the legislature we are uh planning to post that on our Facebook page and it is posted onl

031legis it's on the legislator's website um at the veteran legal Affairs committee if you're interested in that I'm just gonna share because I know this group is so interested um and because I'm gonna formally I'm gonna sit here until three o'clock right again if you want to make sure okay um although we may close the zoom because I don't think anybody needs to watch a an empty room but um but I but I but so not as a portion of the hearing but just to share this report I think because all of you are interested in this report um we did share a statistic that may not mean much to someone who's not a clerk or in elections but that is that there are 182 583 inactive voters as of January 1st 2025 that is

032because um two years ago uh we sent out a national voter registration act compliant mailing uh to just over a quarter million uh people who were on the voter roles but not voted in the previous two Federal elections so that's what the national voter registration act requires that you have to wait for two Federal elections before you can uh reach out to someone in this way so we sent a postcard to all of those people to give them an opportunity to make their registration active um they also had the opportunity to make their registration active by voting in the success of two Federal elections and the gorial in 2022 so we sent this this letter this postcard in the summer of 2022 they could have voted in the gubernatorial election of 2022 or in this

033most recent presidential election and we do know that more voters turned out in this most recent presidential election than ever before in me's history um so from that quarter million roughly um 182 583 did not appear to have done that Tuesday was the deadline for voter participation history by the clerks to be entered into the central voter registration system so that means our clerks were reporting whether someone voted in 2024 many do it ahead of time some you know vacations are really busy and do it right on the deadline we're reviewing all of that data to um ensure its accuracy once we've reviewed the voter participation history from the 2024 election we will be removing 180 presumably unless any of those 18258 people had in fact voted in November we will be removing all of

034them for the rules so that is going to happen regardless of whether the rule changes or doesn't change I want folks to know that because I think uh um again we'll be reviewing all the testimony in detail but certainly um it is unlikely that someone born in 1910 was still living so um uh we also in that report you will find the regular list maintenance that happen so um death records that are removed um we did recently join the electronic registration information center program that exchanges data with other states so if someone's deceased in another state gives us another mechanism to um see that they have passed and be able to remove them um so this data there were 22611 records um cancelled um either through voters deceased U identified duplicates uh moves where voters

035self identified as having moved um and uh 10 register our hearings determining voters eligible so I share that because this this report is something that is required we do it every year you can look at the data you can look at the trends and make your own evaluation about what is or isn't happening but there is it is a report of what list maintenance has occurred in this so people are just aware of that that the question how do we access the ones you've done in the past reports uh the reports you can certainly ask our office for it so SOS office.gov if you make a request for prior your reports I'm sure we could could pull those together for you as it's a free you know it's public record under the Public Public also

036legl documents online great that's so legislator website or or our office so happy to share this with you well thanks everyone have a great rest of your afternoon really appreciate it um we're going to close down the zoom for all of you watching um particularly the clerks we've heard from a number of Clerks uh and I just deeply appreciate the testimony that that expressed um such high regard for how hard our Municipal clerks are working they do an excellent job with very little resources sometimes so for all the clerks watching online thank you and uh please take advantage of the comment period and we look forward to reading your comments and considering um yeah considering everyone's points of view thank you may I make a suggestion that when 250 people sign a petition that you

037have more than 12 people available to hear what the testimony is you have a screen out there and they could not access this video here out failing so we were sitting in that room final was on a phone so when that clearly the interest is there I think more than 12 people been a do what's T got the setup just nobody knew how we we we did try to use the legislature and we just weren't able to so one of the space constraints it's the largest firm that we had access to you do have you have a you have a television screen out there so you could have taken this and put it out there if somebody have access it thanks very much well have a great day everyone and we're concluding the zoom meeting

038uh so for all of those watching at home

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.