CorpusRecord 5052

Reunión del Consejo de Educación del BVSD - 11 de febrero

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Boulder Valley School District Board of Education Meetings
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Boulder County, CO
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,271 words · about 52 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I would like to call this meeting to order. Members may participate electronically. Regular meetings. Laura, could you please take attendance? Chávez present. Present. R present. S present. Present. Thank you, members. If you would like to join me in reading the Land Acknowledgment: The Bolder Valley School District resides and operates on lands that are the ancestral homeland and territory unjustly and illegally taken from the Yut, Arapajo, Shan, Apache, Navajo, and 40 other nations of this land since time immemorial. We acknowledge the atrocities committed here, including the painful history of genocide, forced assimilation, and efforts to alienate Indigenous peoples from their lands with the support of policies of the United States government. We are aware of the many Indigenous peoples, past and present, and their dignified nations and cultures who care for the lands with strength and

002resilience. We recognize the histories of the land in Colorado and the survival of many nations who carry their oral traditions into the present. It is our responsibility. We are committed to educating our communities and our students so that we can celebrate the wisdom and knowledge of Indigenous peoples and actively unite to address injustices. By offering this recognition of the Earth, we affirm and honor the history, wisdom, oral traditions, and resilience of Indigenous peoples and acknowledge our responsibility to care for and value that land together. I would like to remind everyone that the mission of the Berer Valley School District is to create meaningful, engaging, and challenging learning opportunities so that all children thrive and are prepared for a life of success and civic engagement. Good evening everyone, thank you for joining us electronically. [Name 22]

003and present at this moment there is a motion to approve the agenda moved by KY, second by Bet. The time, can you take attendance? Chávez yes, Mler yes, NN yes, with Noira yes, RP yes, Sant Anger yes. The motion passes and as you can see the way we are arranged, we are going to begin with study items tonight. Tonight we have a topic that we must study, which is the decline in RICE enrollment. Do you want to give an introduction? Yes, yes, I would like to. Good evening members Dear board members, Dr. Anderson, this working session is a follow-up to the session we had on September 17th, and I want to start by introducing you to some key people: Clen Sigiro, Clire Sims, and district staff who have been working diligently. I'm very proud of

004the work they're going to present to you tonight. I also want to say the long-term committee will be joining us in our seats tonight. Jeff Anderson and Yales will be discussing what we've done and fixed, the things we'll be working on directly from the board. You'll see pictures; we don't have a presentation for you, but what we're going to do is share four pages of notes from our September meeting. We're going to talk about what we 've heard and how we're going to address those comments. Some of the things we're going to mention at the end are enrollment data, which is why we didn't include that in this conversation about declining enrollment. I want to make that clear. I have about 20 different things we're going to be looking at, so keep that in mind.

005We want to wrap up within an hour, but Clire is going to start. Feel free to ask questions while we're going over the board, and if not... They have nothing, this continues, given all the data that will be shared, and in the time you suggested, there will be organic breaks, or there will be time at the end. If we're going to stop at each dashboard, we'll pause so you can ask questions, and then you'll decide how deeply you want to go into the dashboard. We can look at it at the district level, school level, within regions, or if you want to talk about other things, we can decide. Thank you, and with that, I'll give you time to clear. Very well, good night, everyone. Let me get everything ready here. I'm glad to be back

006with you tonight. First of all, I want to reiterate my thanks for your comments on the draft dashboard that I was able to present to you in the fall. We have kept all your comments in mind and followed up with the revisions on the dashboard, and we are happy to share these more recent drafts. And as a reminder, these dashboards are tools to help us monitor enrollment trends within the district. With that said, it is very important to consider different factors surrounding enrollment and not just internal data. I will also be sharing sources such as the Department of Education and other sources to provide more context. Something I want to mention is the time frame of the data. As you know, this is the day of the October count, and this is our most reliable

007source. We're also going to share more current data and projections, but keep in mind that these can change over time. Now, speaking about the dashboard, we have a new page again. I already gave the general overview, but speaking about the time frame of the data, we have two pages, ordered by color. You see the darker blue? Those are historical or past data, and the light blue pages are current data from this year. This is organized by tabs, and I'm going to give you a tour step by step. We're going to include relevant links to other resources and websites. Okay, let's start with the first tab. Well, each tab has additional information that we're planning to share, but I'm going to close this here because I'm going to give you the tour. This first part of

008the data we 're looking at is the annual trends from kindergarten to 12 by special programs. These bars are grouped by program. We have students who are learning English, those who receive free or reduced-price lunch, gifted and talented students, and special education or twice-exceptional students. And we have this organized by group and by year. We go up to 2017, and looking at what we have... We've noticed that the numbers of students in special programs have generally and recently increased year over year. Although our enrollment numbers have decreased, I also want to point out that we now have certain things that are more interactive within our dashboard. If I hover my mouse over one, other options appear. Another important part regarding annual trends and contextual factors is data surrounding births. These are the number of births

009within the areas we serve. What we look at here at the top is the trend over time, starting from 2006. The blue part here shows the overall number of babies, and you can see how it has changed and decreased over time. But here I want to take a moment to introduce the regions we 're using to divide the schools. As you can see, North Boulder is highlighted here. We can draw that trend, and below you can see the elementary schools that contribute to that region. I want to take a moment to talk about the regions. Typically, we divide them by geography. In some cases, we have to make decisions. We have some schools that come from different geographic areas. For example, when we're talking about South and North Boulder, we're typically looking at these... Schools

010that end at Fer High School or Boulder High School. So, I want to ask before we continue if you have any questions about the schools that are included in that region so that we're all on the same page. Okay, okay. Well, yes, we can select certain schools. And another thing is that we're highlighting the two years when the students were born, which would be this year's kindergarten class. Another thing, I know, is that we received feedback in October. We're highlighting this kindergarten class in particular, and notably, we're not trying to connect births with preschool enrollment. We do consider it, but we haven't gone into more detail because it's more difficult to capture the trend. Preschool admissions are much lower than other grades, so we're focusing on kindergarten. Okay, let's continue. Okay, the next dashboard is

011looking at elementary capacity and utilization. Those were the metrics that were developed by the long- term committee. These show current data for this year and the projection for the next five years. Here we have the five numbers for the schools that fall within those phases of the long-term advisory committee's metrics. Those are schools that are equal to or less than two rounds. Rounds are classrooms per grade level, equal to a capacity of 60 or less, and participation is equal to or less than half a round, which is equal to 50% capacity. We look at the numbers above, and then we can delve deeper by region, either in that chart or on a map. If we want to focus on a geographic region, we can do this on the map, and below, in this chart, we

012have the specific numbers listed by elementary, the total by region, and ultimately, the total for the Clara District. Go ahead. If you have a question, is the word "rounds" defined for the public? We know what it means, but yes, yes, yes, that comment came up earlier, and it's in the information we've included. I appreciate you putting the total for the region. Having a percentage of capacity helps us for each region. What I'm wondering is if the North Bolder area, which is Gold Health, is included, which is a 20% capacity with a total of 10 students. That's included in the average, and I'm wondering if this is lowering the average because we 're not considering the mountain schools. Right now I'm wondering if it was included or rationed, and having it available when some people look

013at the regions and have specific questions about these regions. Well, at least for Col, it seems that it is included in this. And if the percentage is high, and correct me if I'm wrong, but from the original data, this starting point is based on the numbers, not the average capacity. So yes, it can vary a little. Well, North Boulder, because we struggled with this a little. Originally, we have the Netherlands schools in North Boulder. We took those out, we separated them as the mountain schools, and we left Gold Hill with Jameson because they end up in the North Boulder schools. But to clarify, what Glen says is correct; it's the percentage of the total. Thanks for clarifying that. Yes, I'm going to show the totals for the other regions as well. That looks very good.

014Do we have a verbal explanation of why we think the 2029 estimates will be correct, or how we arrived at those 2029 estimates? Right now, we don't have it on the dashboard, but we can add it if that's what you want. What are you looking for? If we say these are projections where it says 2029, we say that, but we don't have a float where it says 2029. If it's just a small comment, very well, the last look within these annual trends is enrollments within the district, looking at the numbers of students that are in the neighborhood districts for a net number. So you understand what we're seeing here in this chart, we have the net numbers, and in the numbers above, we have the neighboring districts and organizations. And we have historical data by

015year as well. You can also float by the number and see the contributions of students who came in and out to see how we arrived at that net number. Our net gains come from Adams 12, and the losses come from Gilpen County. And I want to note that we have included charter school institutions and renowned education entities, but they don't contribute students. Those students are only students leaving our district. And here in the last row or the last column, we have the totals for Gilpen County, from which schools they come. This is information directly from the Department of Education. We don't have precise information, but I don't think we've lost students. But this information comes directly from the Department of Education, right? Yes. Well, at that point, I'd be interested in digging a little deeper

016into that and learning a little more. These are the same numbers that lead us to make financial decisions that also come from the state, right? Yes. So if we have questions, I think it's worth finding this out with the state. I think very well. Let's continue with our next tab, which is enrollment patterns. The issue we're looking at here is student movement within the system. I want to take a big note that this only includes students who are attending BBD schools or who live in BBD attendance areas. This is based on the open enrollment matrices, which are still available on our website. The type of questions we can answer here are: Where are students enrolling in connection with where they live within the Bolder Valley District boundaries? This first view is at the district level.

017We can look at it by level, and we can also filter by region. And again, you can hover over it if you need a reminder or want to clarify which schools are within each region, but they'll be summarized here on the left. What we're looking at here is all the total numbers. That's the total number of students residing within BBS neighborhoods. Are they attending their neighborhood schools or charter schools, or are they going to another focus school? We're going to see that for the current year, and below that is the historical data by year. And here on the other side, we're looking at the enrollment composition in BBS: the total number of students enrolled in BBS, how many are attending their neighborhood schools, how many are enrolled through open enrollment, and how many are enrolled

018through open enrollment coming from other districts. If we have some students who aren't connected with their addresses, again, current year and historical trends by year. Another element we've heard is that we wanted to improve the colors on this tab. We've tried to do this and make it a little easier to read. And in the end, we decided not to include census data. Excuse me, but I'm going to pause here to take questions. For this district-level look at charter schools—these are charter schools that are inside BBS or other schools outside—yes, correct, very good. Well, I'll say it again. I like the regional view because it takes time to go over all the different ways of searching and viewing things, but from the perspective of the school accountability committee, for the different users, it's going to be

019very helpful. Okay, we can continue and delve deeper into the census data. There's an opportunity to find out those who aren't in the BBD system because we know they're residents within BBD, but we compare them to residents who are in BBD but aren't attending BBD schools. If it's any of the work I did last year, we have a very small window that we can only use every 10 years, or if we're not working with ACS, the American Community Surveys, that kind of thing, and they have a very large range of errors, a very large margin of error, and we really can't use them. And what about those who are enrolled with open enrollment? It's a little more to delve into or be more specific because they give us a general number because it's from PRE

020to 12, and we're dividing it up. I'm going to show the regions, for example, we 're still in elementary school. But this would be in the North Boulder region, and how This is an example, and from there we can also do it school by school. We have different filters when we look at the level, but you can select any other school. For several different schools, you can select at the level as well. And if we have historical data on this, we are also trying to show, at least, what we were looking at in the previous slides. We see on the left in the attendance area, and I want to point out that right below, at the school level, are those students who enrolled, for example, in Sánchez, and which schools they are. And these were

021classified by neighborhood: focused schools and charter schools. And there you can see the numbers on the right, the composition of enrollments by school. And below, we see the other side of the coin: Alicia Sánchez enrolled in other schools, and which schools they are. And the net numbers are shown year by year, and you can see the historical trend. I just want to say thank you very much because you included a lot of information. This is very detailed and very clear. Well, I don't know, I wouldn't want to ask for more information, but please, could you include this information by school? I do n't know if it's a bit confusing, but anyway, this is very valuable. Well, Jorge, let me take note. We'll come back to you because at the moment we're struggling to get from

022one side of the board to the other in the database. But let me tell you what we can do about it. And well, I appreciate it. And to back this up, maybe we'll look at it later, but it would be helpful to discuss by region, like the high schools, or how they're aligned with our attendance policies. That's my question. Well, no, I didn't make them perfectly aligned, right? But for example, we're talking about South Bolder, Bolder High School, and Fairview. Well, yes, they get from several schools, but the others are more aligned. And well, Nuvista, you see attendance from the mountains, yes, depending on the basic population, and it depends on each region. We're going to continue now in the next section. The topic is enrollments, enrollment losses or increases, and what the trends are

023within a school year. We've seen a change in the count that's done every year in October in a given school year. And I note that we ca n't show this data broken down by school. The first graph shows the historical data of enrollment increases and decreases month by month over the course of the school year, once the year starts in September. In May, the increase is shown in blue and the reductions are shown in orange. We've been showing these trends for three years, from 2021 to 2024. This was updated through January, and you can see for more information. Once we see, that is, whether students are leaving neighborhood schools or if the number is increasing, and we're also keeping track of those students who dropped out, we see this same graph. And if we take

024a step back and look at the year-over-year trend, we see... There is an improvement per semester, with larger numbers on both sides from December to January. If we look more closely at the current year with these measurement indices focused on the current school year from October to January, we can compare recent trends. At the bottom of the bars, we can see changes per month, and the clearer line represents the references. These are net numbers from December to January. We see an upward trend. Compared to the previous three years, it's a positive trend. I'm curious how the three years are determined, since the average is longer than three years. Well, it was simply a convenient sample for study. Our next slide shows student groups by program. As I showed earlier, we are seeing increases and decreases

025in these programs, taking the same indicators. The stocks are in orange, and the gains are in blue. I simply rotated the graph to explain. As we look at this data, our net number for the current year, and this is still in progress, updated to January, shows how we are progressing with this trend. That's why these numbers are not yet paired, and we have the numbers of decreases and increases compared to the average of For the previous 3 years, this part of the graph shows how these bars approach or do not approach the reference lines for the entire year. Yes, it's worth noting that this year we 're looking at data up to January, but the numbers are shown for full years. But how could we name these graphs to determine what they represent? That's my

026recommendation. Yes, thank you. If you put the cursor over the gray lines, it says " average." Why wouldn't you have to add a name or label? When you hover the cursor over the number, it shows what it is. This is a different way of looking at the data. Oh, there's a question. Well, maybe that's for another time. But do we have any idea how many students might also be in orange and blue? I mean, are they leaving and returning later? Or is it because they are different data? And we have people who leave, but they are foreigners. If they return, it's a different way of interpreting. Or are there 15 foreign students that we are trying to retain? But well, it's a different way of interpreting. Well, Alex, at this moment I don't have an

027answer for that about duplicate students. But let's analyze the information on the dashboard using this data. Well, we have the students who... They dropped the losses or decreases in enrollment. These categories are those students who dropped out or transferred to a private school, a neighborhood school, or a different educational environment. Once we look at this, each column represents a year. We have the current year moving forward, and we have the reasons why they left. The main reason continues to be that they went to another type of educational environment. And well, both of these numbers on the right side are very close, and we're going to analyze how they're progressing over time. And these have consistently resulted in the lowest enrollments. You would say what the "other" category refers to. Well, there we would include near

028or far because we don't have many details. One way to look at it is what our sphere of influence is. We likely have a certain number of students who, for example, would be transferring to a closer school, or some who are leaving that school for reasons that are beyond our control. At some point, we did exit surveys to learn a little more about why they left the school, and of course, participation is optional. But what would the update be? Well, the enrollment office is collecting this information. And yes, we are definitely collecting this information. That was one of the recommendations of the long-term advisory committee. Yes, Kiri, we already know the participation rate in these surveys. No, I don't have the data, but I'll follow up and get back to you. Thank you. Well, I

029think working with ranges doesn't necessarily tell me how those names are behaving, or if they are increasing or decreasing. I mean, here it tells me that 350 fewer are leaving, but another way to present this would be to highlight it. Well, I don't know what the relevance by range is, and that's what I wanted to ask. We collect this information from the dropout codes, and that doesn't specify which school they're going to because that's a further step, and that's why we're leaving it at this point because they can go out of state, in state, or to a school closer to their home. I really don't know if we could collect this information within a certain number of miles. There's no way unless you do it hand in hand. Well, quickly, we do know if they're

030enrolling in another school. They are going out of state, out of the country, so we don't know how many. We want to know how many students are leaving BBSD. We can present a lot of data, but what's really important is understanding how many students are leaving. That seems more important to me than understanding if they just left the state or left the country. I think I could have that conversation another time. Well, competing with another state would n't make sense. But if they are going to another district, then that's why I'm asking about those almost 400 students. Where are they going? I know that would be difficult information to obtain. And the other question would be if they changed their address or not, just changed schools. Did they really move to another school district in

031Colorado, or did they leave the country? Could it be to another district? Could it be in Durango? Could it be in Bromfield? To get such granular data for each student, it would be very helpful to add "transfers to a different district" or "outside BBSD" to the title. And this is how we want to start understanding out-of- district enrollments on another screen. We were able to observe enrollments within the district. So I see that we are moving from one perspective to another, and that would be an obstacle for us. But simply changing the title would be clearer. And even if we look at the top and bottom, the code for when students drop out is static, but the numbers are not. So we have to analyze what the story is really saying. That is, the students

032are many, and that's what we see in the data analysis. Any of these boards is a very important point; the abilities are different. So here we are, kind of playing with the size of the points. The scale goes from 500 to 30; these are difficult scales to manage. Oh, thank you. And well, we have another section to explore. We're almost finished. In this last section, we see public schools compared to private schools. The data from the Ministry of Education, and I put the title in red, is for the data of public and private schools from kindergarten through 12th grade. We see the year- by- year historical trends that were reported by each school without verification by the Ministry of Education. And here are some blank cells; that means they are not... The data is sorted

033by the numbers higher than the one at the top, and you can see the largest participants in the bolded area. We have the data from the Department of Education broken down, and you can see it here. There is significant data because the schools are all in capital letters. Well, I just wanted to ask... well, it's simply a detail from the file provided by the Department of Education, and we can also see the number of students receiving their education at home. What we have here are the rates and the proportion of students at home. And if we put the cursor here... uh... so here I ask you, how do you expect us as a council to interact? We're going to bring in more... we're going to analyze data in a granular way. How do you expect

034the council to interact with these kinds of meetings, as typically happens? Well, we would have to analyze in more depth the trends, those that occur in a conservative way and those that present more questions. I do n't know if we have a manual yet on how this is going to guide us there, but by having the tools, we empower our community in a way that every school district has been able to manage in the country. We have to have this kind of analysis accessible at the level And that's very important for navigating this situation and for public confidence, knowing that we have this information and that we can see it, and the trends that school enrollments show in different categories. And we want to spend more time analyzing these kinds of things as we consider

035what options we have. And this gives us the tools not to just have a conversation without information, but because we don't want to stagnate, we want to have the data and the analysis. And Rob's team has done a great job increasing data transfer and collection. And we're in a very, very good position going forward. Yes, so we have the vice-chair of the committee here. What 's your opinion on these and on the discussions that have been happening? Well, we haven't put the dashboard into use yet. We've had working sessions, we've met with people before. And this is going to be very useful going forward. And one of the most important things from my point of view is to give the public a place to start. And I want to encourage the public. I'm not worried

036about the board, but more about the public. And Clara has done a great job in making this data quite... Obviously, because last year, well, we didn't have it, and there's always a danger when data is presented. When you see this data, we want to make sure that this data is understood, and I always analyze this data, and I'm always very conservative, but we're going to be very pleased, and this will be very helpful. Council members, any other questions or comments for the team? Alex, I want to say that I'm very impressed with all the work. I think it's extremely good, and with Rob, I was impressed by the district's commitment to transparency. The more we delve deeper, the more we talk, the more we're going to understand. So, thank you very much, and thank you

037to Dr. Anderson for his leadership. With that, Council members, no further questions. We're going to take a short break to reconfigure the room. Thank you to... and starting with the report from Superintendent Dr. Anderson. Good evening. Thank you, Chairman Rash. Board members, any comments for my remarks tonight? As you know, we have March Madness starting in a month, but we need to be monitoring the Monar High School basketball team, who dominated the Special Olympics and won the tournament in Colorado on March 7th. My final comment: I'm happy to announce that our academy will be back this summer, and we're looking for businesses and community members who want to help. You can be a career champion, a panelist, help students work on their resumes, give a tour of your work, or host a workshop. It's your

038opportunity to offer mentorship and work experience. And as a reminder, students who participate in the GR Plus Leadership Academy have the opportunity to earn college credit through exams. Club: For those who are interested and listening, you can go to bvsd.org. And that's all for my comments. Board members, do you have anything else for me? And with that, we have public speaking. The board respects the public's right to speak, and we remind the public that you are responsible for what you say. You have two minutes to speak, to see a yellow card when you have 30 seconds left and an orange card when you have 10 seconds left. If you run out of time, you can always email the board. With that, we'll talk to the student speakers. The first one This is Harley Proctor. Hello,

039I'm Harley Proctor. I'm a student at Louisville Elementary. I'm here to tell you that we think the district should have a no-idling policy, and you need to implement it right now. We're very grateful for the message you put in the school newspaper, but we need a policy and a way to enforce it. A car that isn't running for more than 10 seconds and isn't moving is polluting with toxins that can cause health problems and greenhouse gases that cause climate change. In 2023, the district passed this new Green Deal, and they need to comply with it. We need a policy that can be enforced. Our Panthers for Action club will be contacting you to see if there's a way to implement that policy. Thank you, Harley. This is Mimi St. Hello, I'm Mimi St. I'm a

040student at Louisville Elementary. I'm here to tell you that we believe the district should have a no-idling policy, and you need to implement it right now. We appreciate the message you put in the school newspaper. School, but we need this policy and a way to enforce it. If you leave your car running for more than seconds, it's bad because it damages the environment and releases toxins that can cause breathing problems. This is the third time we've come before the board this year. Clearly, it's important to us because we want a healthy future. The school Panthers club will be contacting each of you next week to talk about this policy. If you care about our future, please enforce this policy so we can breathe clean air. Thank you. Next speaker is K. Patrick, who joined virtually.

041Roll call: Rena. Hi, I'm Rena Patrick, and I'm a student at Luisville Elementary. I'm here to ask the board to create a district-wide no-running policy for all schools. It's important to make this rule and enforce it. Right now, we're grateful that you've already sent a message to all the families at the school, but it's time to have a clear policy to ensure everyone complies. This helps protect the environment and keep the air clean for everyone. Here are some ideas about how the policy can be enforced: one, official signs Around the school, we can put signs in the parking lot and student pick-up areas to remind people to turn off their cars. We need to send these reminders to students and drivers during drop-off and pick-up times. We need to have an incentive to follow the

042rules, like prizes or fines. If a driver doesn't turn off their car, we can have a warning system and then issue a small fine. Thank you for listening. I hope you can make sure my generation is the first to experience these changes together. Thank you for making our schools a healthier and happier place. Next speaker is Lilan Bran. Hi, I'm Lilan Bran. I'm here as a student from Louisville to tell you that we believe you shouldn't allow cars to be left running, and we need education. Right now, I've noticed that parents and adults at our school aren't following the signs. We need systemic change. We're also very grateful that you sent a message, but we need a policy and a way to enforce it. If we want to stop cars from being left running in

043the district, we need to leave a car... Leaving a car running but not driving burns more fuel. If you're going to leave your car running for more than 10 seconds, you should turn it off. Many people in the community don't realize that this harms the environment. It damages the environment because it releases pollution that harms students' lungs, and it releases greenhouse gases that contribute to climate change. In conclusion, we children are the ones who experience the effects of the decisions you make. Do your part. Thank you, thank you, Lilian. The next final speaker is Sarah Danford. Hello, I'm Danford. I have four children in the district; three are in Fairview. I wanted to talk to you about changing Fairview from having eight periods to seven. All my children participate in the International Baccalaureate program. And

044if we change to seven periods, the International Baccalaureate program works—I do n't know if you knew this—it works because it needs to have a certain number of classes and also an additional class. There are many things that will be affected by changing the day to seven periods. One of the most important is the clubs. There are 75 clubs in Fairview. We have a lunch hour that will be changed to two periods. I don't know how It's going to feed more than 10,000 to 1,900 children in two periods. Also, arts, choir, and the children take more than one of those classes at a time. They need to talk and try all of those things before making a decision to change it. The other thing I wanted to say is that three of the five high schools

045have eight periods. Why aren't we moving the other two to eight periods instead of hurting the high schools that are doing well? Thank you. That concludes this public participation for tonight. We're going to continue with the board communication. Board members, who would like to start? I wanted to thank the students in particular who came to speak, but everyone who participates publicly. The students, I'm very impressed that you have the courage to come and talk to us. It's hard for adults not to say, "Kids, I appreciate that you're working hard on this issue and that you care and how much you've learned about the impact of leaving your car running." And if we have this on the list of things to discuss in the future, the way we do these things at the board. Typically, these

046things do n't happen when someone thinks, "Ah, here's a good idea." We have to Schedule it along with other things that are also good ideas, and we also have to comply with the law. Oh, I'm looking forward to meeting you. I'd like to learn more about you, and I ask for your patience because yes, we have listened to you, and this board—yes, this board— cares about the environment; otherwise, we wouldn't have adopted the Green New Deal. So, I appreciate the work you 're doing. Thank you, Kiri. I'm going to continue, board members. One of the rules is typically not to talk to the speakers instead of modeling that. I want to talk to the last speaker tonight, Sara. I wish you had communicated with the board more beforehand. We've received many emails. Because of the

047email you sent, there's a lot of misinformation on the board. We're not going to participate in that dialogue. We haven't participated in the conversations. Part of the discussions between the union and district staff during the day. Many of the things we've talked about, we don't have the information. We have to act on the information. I wanted to make that clear, and it's very unfortunate the amount of anxiety and stress this conversation has caused families in Fairview, including my own, who are part of the International Baccalaureate program. I do n't normally speak with the speakers, but I wanted to share that with you. I'm going to talk about something else. I thank everyone who volunteered to judge the final projects and papers in high school. This requires many volunteers and is very difficult. Sorry. It was

048National History Day. Thank you to everyone who gave this artwork. It was excellent looking through the halls with the students' work, and it reaffirms why we are here. This makes me happy. It was very nice talking with the students about what they felt and the inspiration for their work. Board members, thank you, David, for inviting me to the BBSA union legislative meeting with Julia Meleky Brown and J. Marchman Smith. It was very nice to hear from the teachers and what they are advocating for. We are aligned in maintaining funding for the university. Funding for education, and thank you, David, for inviting me and keeping us up to date on the conversation. I wanted to see our legislative priorities, and we'd be happy to share them with you. Rob and I had the opportunity to attend

049the quarterly meeting with members from the County, the City, and the University of Colorado. We're working on the same issues. It's a difficult time being in government. It's good to have a space to share thoughts and frustrations. Some things that were mentioned that I wasn't aware of: There's a bill, which is Bill 25169, that allows housing construction on educational and religious properties. That's in the legislature, Bill 25169. If you want to see this bill... Beyond that, I wanted to tell you that I'll be at the DAC executive meeting. If you requested information about how you can improve your budgeting process, I've been brainstorming about that, about allocating certain dollars, or which parts of the strategic plan are most promising in terms of data sources. But if you have any ideas, I'd be happy to receive

050them so I can help deliver that information to that committee. And I think that's all for now. Comments from tonight: Alex, thank you. I want to say that I appreciate speaking with people from the community during my office hours last week. It worked out. I'm going to make an announcement for upcoming dates. It would be great if any of you could meet with me. Also, something worth sharing from a mother who was explaining her student's experience journey: how difficult it can be for a child with learning disabilities to go through the special education program, and the mental health issues that can arise later. How these things can lead to the young person not being happy. So, I like that we've adopted policies about neurodiversity, and this week we've been interacting with district staff about communicating

051with parents of children with disabilities who want to do open enrollment. But above all, it's the students' experience, so they feel like they belong and that they're going to succeed. When we can't deliver on that, we 're not serving the students as we should, and it's difficult for them. And we shouldn't lose sight of the human aspect of what happens when a student is dealing with social issues. That weighs on the children. It's important that our children succeed, and it's not simply about the social aspect. Emotional, I want to say we need attention and the experience of families and students. And that's what we 're trying to do. How do they know the district? We know we have large systems, we have tight resources, we have laws and policies, but the family has the experience

052through their child, and sometimes we can lose that, whether it's a board member or anyone else. So I encourage you to think about the user experience. I'm not saying people don't do that, but I am saying it is difficult, and people dealing with that can feel it as super intense, and we always need to put ourselves in the other person's shoes. And I want to share that this is very important, and I feel that those who are advocating for this, or are going to pay for cars, well, we need to have a jar and collect a dollar from each person who leaves their car running until we develop a policy. I don't think the police are going to come and write tickets for us, but with a jar, leaving the car running and paying a

053dollar, we can raise some money. While Alex and I attended the budget meeting, we thank Bill and his team for a great job. I'm letting the board know that we'll start looking at the dues on the 25th of this month. Alex and I started by putting some focus on this issue. Okay, Alex, again, that reminded me. I should say that the information about the budget— we're spending money at a rate that 's more in line with what was expected. And that 's a good thing because of the efficient changes in the last round. People on staff and in the community are very aware of that, and the spending is on track. Board members, any other comments for tonight? Seeing as there's nothing, let's continue with the informational items. The first is the Long-Term Committee update,

054including the annual enrollment report. Good evening, President, RP, and Board members. Tonight, I'm here with Ivet Solis and Jeff Andersen, Elra's little things, and we're giving an update. Tonight, Glen the planner will be giving a report on the annual trends. I want to start with this slide. This goes back to 2022, and it's a timeframe of all the work we've done with the decline in enrollment and everything we've accomplished in this timeframe. As you know, this work... At different levels, we're coming together to study this, and Jeff and Beth will be talking about it for the remainder of this year. We've had another baby event; it's where we need to be, and we've focused more energy on engagement. We've also started a new enrollment option program for those who commute here to BVSD. We'll also

055have a session in March where we'll present our dashboard. This is about attendance limits, and we'll continue that work in March and May. The work continues on the data we'll be presenting. We're trying to make it more transparent, involve the community in discussions, and with that, I'll give you the time for the update from the Long- Term Advisory Committee. Good evening, Dr. Andersen. Board members, the committee has met several times since the last update in October, and at our November meeting, we continued discussing the enrollment status at the secondary level. At the January meeting, we heard the enrollment update that was given to the board in December, and also the general discussion about attendance limits in anticipation of the annual trend report. Tonight, the staff will also explain the projections that were calculated, and in

056March the committee will continue to look at enrollment at the secondary level, focusing also on secondary schools from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade. We'll hear more of the discussion about attendance limits and how the information that will be presented tonight goes directly to the Council's recommendations. I want to remind you and the public about the specifics of those recommendations. The metric that was recommended by the ELRA includes three components: the annual report that the staff is presenting tonight, an enrollment counseling phase, and a community engagement phase. The data presented under this annual trend report will determine if schools meet the criteria to be in which phase they fit. When a primary school has fewer than two classes per grade level and enrollments less than 60 per capacity, the council and the community should be aware of

057the resource allocation. The allocation of resources will continue, including staff funds, and the funding formula will be used for whatever is needed for classes of different ages, the library, counseling, or... These special classes may be limited, or perhaps these part- time teachers are in the community engagement phase, and an elementary school continues to experience declining enrollment, falling to 50% or less capacity for at least the next 5 years. The staff will engage the community to develop possible solutions and seek educational resources for the student and staff environments. Other recommendations the committee has made to the board include studying the open enrollment policy, areas with attendance limits, and the motivations or interests parents are seeking. With that, I'll give the floor to Mr. Glen. Thank you very much. I want to begin with this slide, which

058is familiar to the board. This slide was presented in December and represents the trends the Institute has had over the last 10 years. These are also projections for the future, and as a reminder, we are finishing a period of growth that has leveled off over the last decade, and we have begun to decline since 2018. Of course, Cover accelerated this a lot, and we have been on a downward trend since then. However, this year has been better than we expected; we decreased by half a percent, and we expected 1.4 percent. We are decreasing, but our projections are a little better than last year. A little background on the project and the methodology surrounding this project: We use a group survival method, which is the norm in many school districts, especially in Colorado, and also in

059the country, I believe. This survival model takes the difference between—you can see the examples here; it's best explained with examples—for example, kindergarten students in 2017 and compare them to the same class in 2018. They take what is called a progression, which is a ratio (this is the red part), and they do this for all grades from kindergarten through 12th grade and across several years as well. And when they are ready to project for the following year, that is the fundamental basis. It's not everything, but they add up this ratio, this portion, based on various averages. They can use 3 or 4 years. When I do this, I base it on resident students, where they live, and then we add open enrollment and things like that to make it a good demographic model. And of course,

060with this type of projection, there are certain assumptions. For example... This, uh, the fluidity of open enrollment, migration, births, new construction, new homes. Oh, right, when we're trying to build based on the past, as long as we're in a stable condition, the projections can work. Although there are certain surprises that occur, and that's what causes a change in trends, as we saw with Cover. We've been working based on past events, but if we add births, new homes, births—those are things we add to the model to help us provide a little more clarity toward the future. This product of this year's projections—this is the chart we use, and I want to point out that the rack, the advisory conditions, and involvement, and those that Ivet mentioned, these projections for this year were a little higher than

061the previous year. The reason for that is that we had a good year of growth this year, and that's why those trends went up a little. A very large kindergarten class—that's going to take us toward the future and helps our projections toward the future. Also, last year we also had more schools that were entering the involvement phase for the next 5 years. Many of these schools were on the edge, and maybe this is a small A deviation in the projections can influence many of those schools. This year we're looking at fewer schools in the engagement phase. So when we look at this, the yellow boxes are areas where there's a trigger, where the engagement phase wasn't completed. What they need for that school to be included or considered in the engagement phase is to look

062at both boxes in any given year. And it's the same with the orange boxes, which are noted as being in the engagement phase. When we look here at Heatherwood, Heatherwood entered the engagement phase last year, and we've been monitoring under that designation going forward. Unfortunately, for 2024 and 2025, Heatherwood is the only school that appears to be entering that engagement phase. To clarify, the yellow boxes are in the advisory phase, and the orange boxes are in the engagement phase. So when it's orange and yellow, they're still advisory. Yes, advisory is orange with orange to be in the engagement phase. And a clarification as well: I think we talked about this in the session of I work, but the projections for 2025 and 2026 are based on the open enrollment methodology. Yes, that's correct. Thinking about

063this, looking at it by geographic region, we currently have eight schools in the advisory phase: five in Boulder, one in Louisville, one in Superior, and one in Bromfield. Heatherwood is the only one in the engagement phase at the moment. Through the next two years, we don't anticipate any changes to this, with others remaining in the advisory phase and one in engagement. Starting in 2027, we see one more school in the advisory phase in the Boulder area and another in Bronfield. And again in 2028, we see that the school in Co possibly enters the engagement phase. And in five years, in 2029, we project that eight schools will continue in the advisory phase, and we have added what appears to potentially enter the engagement phase at that time, with the result being three schools possibly in

064the engagement phase. So, to summarize, for the year 2024, there are eight schools that are in the advisory phase. Advisory Call Creek, Montessori, Eisenhauer, El Dorado, Flat Irons, Call Mesa, and Withier. So, to reiterate, those are equal to or less than two rounds each, or they are at capacity of 60 or less. There are no other schools that are in the community engagement phase in 2024. We continue to monitor them under that status. Projections indicate that enrollment will continue to decline in the district through the 2029 school year, but it appears that the trend or rate of decline is slowing down a little. Also, in 2029, we project having eight schools in the advisory phase and three in the community engagement phase. Those schools are distributed with seven in Boldridge, one in Louisville, one in

065Superior, and two in Bromfield. We continue to look at policy revisions and other tools to make adjustments around enrollment going forward. With that said, we are happy to take any questions you may have. Jason, one quick question. It's a little difficult to see the presentation. What are the three schools in 2029? Is Collier in the engagement phase? 2029 And hew the third with call And Heatherwood if 2029 let me open this slide 2029 hew school col school and weier school Kitty Well I'm a little confused So hew is already in the engagement phase and we anticipate that it will still be in this engagement phase Yes very good question because when you make projections I don't have a way of knowing if the effects of the measures we have taken with hew How will the

066results be in the future Right now we are doing information hew had a very good year this year and I think we have reason to be optimistic but for now we cannot include those improvements and assume that things will improve this is based on the performances of past years and the structure of the classes Ah okay I understand now Thank you Dr. Andersen Yes very good question I appreciate the application this metric and projections do not take into consideration the changes we are making that are [Music] Ah that are decreasing the decrease in enrollment and because there are several factors that can change the enrollment results for example We had a class We had a very large kindergarten enrollment this year, which was tremendous for us. We also included enrollments for people who work in

067our district but don't necessarily live here. 320 students applied for that preference, and 269 have already accepted spots in our schools for this coming year. That's tremendous. Besides that, I'll say that Heatherwood Elementary has been working with the community, and I think the community received the program we added. This STEAM environment program, and we didn't just throw something out there; it was the community. It was a design, workshops we worked on with the school. And in open enrollment, zero Heatherwood students who were enrolled at Heatherwood opted to go to another school that wasn't Heatherwood. These are things that break the trends that you won't see until next year. But what I will say is that we haven't finished our work yet. We still have to consider attendance limits and continue working with ALAC. But I

068will say that the efforts we've made based on the policies that this council has passed, the work that our team has done, we're going in the right direction. We started this in 2021, Alex. Yes, following the points you just mentioned, Doctor. And I live in the South Bold area where we have Montess in the preliminary role, and as a council, we've talked about what's within our control as a council. But I think the things that people are doing in the school... Okay, we're planning for the next 10 years, but there are people in the school who can figure out what they can do to continue making their schools good and attractive to their community. But I'm curious, what are the strategies for schools that are in the advisory stage, where we don't have a lot

069of money to pay for innovative things, but we have incredible people who are currently in the school who can do things? What can we do to facilitate those changes based on their local knowledge in their communities and their resources so that their schools continue to be attractive to the children in their neighborhood? Is there anything the council can do to support that effort to keep the children there? What I will mention is that at the school level, because we've developed this metric and because we've developed this level of transparency, the schools are paying attention. To say that we have involved schools more deeply, I think we don't have a playbook where the design of the mentoring can be transparent and say, "Hey, this is coming and nothing is happening, we're going to scold you." The

070design of mentoring versus involvement, so as not to surprise you, is a notification. But I will say that I have engaged with several parents, several schools, mentoring groups, whether it be parent- teacher organizations, school accountability committees, and other groups, and I think we do see individuals who are going to support their schools, and I know that the leaders are informed and involved in these efforts. Yes, I think the efforts... Beyond that, if we look at more stability, but still not enough, these changes aren't very big for children. There could be certain support, but right now the efforts have been at the local level. When I look at this image, it highlights how important these boards are, these images of being able to look at this at a regional level because there are certain groups of

071schools that are in the involvement phase or in the mentoring phase. So when you decide something, it is determined by who is around you, if the schools are in the involvement or mentoring phase. That's it. One important reason is why we need to get really into the data and delve deeper. Schools need to better understand how this works in different regions and communities because we have to consider that the decline in enrollment isn't going to disappear; we can only slow it down. How fast is it declining? Council members, any other questions for Glen? Just a comment: very, very well done. I'm always amazed by what you guys do. I think you're magicians. Thank you so much, Glen. Thank you for the informative article tonight. Council members, this is the legislative update, Dr. Andersen. I think

072you have several things you want to mention tonight. Thank you, Chairman Rusp. Council members, the legislative session is continuing. I have a conversation this week to provide more commentary on the accountability bill that will be out this week. So, hopefully, I'll be able to provide more commentary for Ur Annos. I hope this bill is in line with the work the workforce group is doing, and with that said, I hope you'll be open to revisions and adjustments when the bill comes out and be able to shape and mold it in the ways we want. And in terms of the 1448 financial act, from what I understand, there have been There's a lot of energy surrounding the language that could stop 1448 from taking effect. On several occasions, there were efforts within the legislature to remove that

073provocative language. And as I want to remind this council and the public, over the past year, one of the main options was trying to implement a school finance bill where they didn't have the money to implement it, and that wasn't true. So the issue here is eliminating the averaging, which negatively impacts 80% of the districts across Colorado. And as I've shared with you, we continue our involvement in 1448, and it's going to be active. It's going to take effect, or it won't. And we're going back to the 5-year formula averaging. One of the challenges school districts are going to have is which scenario they're better off in. When I've asked other superintendents, they look at me, and I think people don't know. And that's one of the concerns we've had when we're advocating against 1448

074and the changes that are going to happen. And if you're a large organization, you have ongoing projects, ongoing costs, trying to negotiate salaries, and the cost of living is rising. The governor's budget doesn't have enough. Money for schools for the District. I think we still have a lot to accomplish, but we're going to stay involved in these issues. I think one of the biggest issues is trying to figure out what's going to happen with the budget, the proposed budget, and what's going to happen with 1448. Thank you, Dr. Andersen, and for your advocacy. These two pieces of legislation are very important. Council members, two things I want to mention are Senate Bill 27, which deals with security rehearsals. This bill does not require a task force to develop best practices, use trauma or forms of

075practice, to maintain these security rehearsals. And the other thing is Bill 25, 1192, which requires students to fill out PSAs, which are the Federal Assistance forms. And I have a lot of concern that students are giving information to the Federal Government. I'm not very comfortable with this. I wanted to bring this to your attention. I have a question for Dr. Andersen. And excuse me, can you remind me what the provocative language is for 1448? I can't say specifically or exactly, but it says that if the money is n't there To implement 1448, then the school finance act reverts to what it was before 1448. This was the question. Some people are interpreting this differently, or changing the language so that 1448 can continue even though there isn't enough money. So this is what's at stake,

076and that's the challenge. Another thing, President Rash, what I will mention is that when we're talking with the delegation and the council members about the financial literacy bill, what I'm trying to say is, instead of that, why don't you go into school finances and try to figure that out? That seems more important to me, instead of adding new things, no matter how much lack of passion or lack of interest there is in the people, because that doesn't seem like a very responsible thing to do. I've been firm on this, and yes, they have good ideas for bills around education, and I've already told this to our delegation, and they want to hear opinions, but I want to save them trouble. I know we can't support this bill right now, Alex, and then Kery. Thank you.

077I just wanted to talk about the accountability bill. I looked at the draft yesterday, but I do agree. With what Dr. Andr says about the concerns regarding the recommendations coming out of the working group, my personal inclination is to try to support Colorado's accountability system. I believe the system has credibility and transparency, and I think the audit of the accountability system is working in many parts. We also have something that is more based on technical innovation, a system that values student growth and other measures, giving us the data we need. But things that aren't very well aligned with the current draft have created a debate. They've changed the accountability of the State Board of Education and the Colorado Department of Education, changing the authority over the details and micro-details of the measures. Then I'm reminded

078of states like Florida or Texas that have very, very weak, very poor systems. And we have a local control system that is reinforced by the State Board of Education, which keeps the legislature and the governor in check, making small decisions. If we let the technical experts do that, we have mechanisms to test this so that all of this can be addressed by the legislature and the education committee. I think it's a recipe for reducing what we need. They can change this if it looks good or bad. And I think that's mainly what doesn't align with the working group's recommendation that Dr. Andersen mentioned: they're politicizing the technical details. And then, well, you've said that the working group has been very good for the State of Colorado. Those people who have seen polarized positions have been

079able to collaborate and refine the details about the committees and the accountability system. The technical experts understand how to make proposals and take different measures. And that's linked to whether you can obtain the data reliably and consistently and then take action. For example, in 104 school districts, when the working group was developed, they had very little technical experience. It was a committee with many opinions, with individuals who had desires and dreams, but you can't achieve this until you have a robust data system. And we need a robust system that can analyze data from elementary or secondary and all levels because this is an aspiration, but we don't currently have this data. And this is just the feedback I wanted to give you without losing sight of the technical aspect of something like this, because every

080time something doesn't work, it's because... So, what is the overall validity of the system? I'm very excited to continue investigating, and there are people waiting, but we still need to know, even without the experts involved, who don't yet have the data to evaluate. And that's something I want to... Well, I want to give my opinion on the law, or rather, on your writing. I agree that [Music] uh, it's a very bad idea that students have to fill out the applications and forms themselves. I do know that it's a good idea to teach them how to do it and to give them fake financial information that isn't theirs so they know how to fill them out, so they learn how to fill out a form, but not with their own information. Do any Council members have

081questions or comments on the legislative update, since there isn't one yet? We are moving towards the approval of personnel articles 8.3. Funds for Uni Hill are accepted. 8.4. The donation is accepted. For B Creek 8.5, the donation to Lafayette 8.6 is accepted. The donation to Lusville 8.7 is accepted. The donation to Metalarc 8.8 is accepted. The donation to New Vista High School 8 is accepted. The Proof Point computer program is renewed. Are there any other topics to discuss? We need a motion to approve. It is proposed by Kiri, seconded by Jorge. Council members, any discussion since there isn't one. Could Laura please take attendance? Chávez sck Queen laera, the motion is approved. The agenda includes policies on study, distribution of materials, curriculum policy K. We have a policy to put the Council... but we only

082have this one item. But on the agenda for February 25th, we're going to have more policies. Do you remember when we were in elementary school, you got a folder every Friday with information about everything you could do in your neighborhood? And since then, well, this policy hasn't been reviewed since 1996, but with the arrival of the internet, we don't have to be the ones delivering this information since it's available through other channels, and this puts our leaders... Educational issues are in the midst of a problem. And for that reason, after discussing and speaking with all the principals, and we have different practices, we no longer have bulletins, so we unanimously agreed that this policy no longer needs to be in effect in the district. So we're going to maintain language so the community understands what

083we 've done, and it leaves us with the standards for a decision to be made. Thank you, Kath. Do any Council members have questions or comments about this? Yes, well, thank you for this. I have a small change that I haven't emailed you yet. It's something very small. Very good. Yes, Alex, this seems very reasonable to me. It's a strategy to solve problems we don't have to solve. Are there any other opinions from school leaders that we should consider, or is it something very clear? No, well, it was very clear when we proposed and explained that there were no legal requirements to implement this, nor was there a practical reason. It was a very brief discussion. Thank you. This policy, well, it's no longer useful in these times. We can bring this down to just

084one page. So we're reducing these policies, and thank you for your work on this. It seems there are no more comments. We'll continue to the agenda for the future in this section. Any Council members? Topic you want to include on upcoming agendas, it seems not, Council members. Um, the last item on our agenda, executive session, there is a motion. Yes, Jorge, I, Jorge, Chavez, propose, in accordance with CRC Standard 24 6402, to meet on the topic of Legal Councils. Could you please call roll, Chavez? Yes, Mler, yes. Yes, Agera, yes. Ros, yes. Yes, Serge, yes. Anger, yes. The motion is approved, Council members. We will meet in the Glacier Room, and since we don't have time, we need to vote to end our meeting. This is the end of our meeting. Thank you very much.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.