CorpusRecord 51082

School Board Workshop and Business Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Scarborough Maine Public Schools
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Cumberland County, ME
Material
Transcript
Extent
30,291 words · about 169 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e walked up second ago I like I don't know to here you go very confused in my life right now lot going on by this oh yeah and I we get back together on this in boundary six one boundary one two boundary two three don't ask any three of the ones in here were working the fourth one that I you have an Italian without three boundary three boundary three test one two boundary three [Music] boundary six boundary six [Music] boundary five boundary five boundary four boundary like e e e um can we call our attendance really quickly please yes Mr caler here Leon here miss LST here miss Peterson here Mr H Rocky here miss trinian here miss Trini Huff here miss Ledger uh she'll be joining us soon Mr Rina perfect thank you

002would everyone please join us for the Pledge of Allegiance of the United States of America and to the stands indice um agenda item 4.1 4.0 is new business 4.1 is uh the school building advisory committee phase two update so we're happy to welcome Charlie and um Larry to the meeting tonight we're just to hear an update about what you've been up to I know there's been a lot going on and I know you have a lot to cover so I won't take too much time but I'll pass to April I just want to thank members of the council for being here um those that aren't able to be here uh rest assured that they will watch and that they will um be available you know and and follow up with the committee if they have

003questions okay all right so we will pass over to the two of you all right great thank you um appreciate the opportunity to give you guys an update and um on the work that the committee doing we'll just jump right in next slide please oh sorry so just a agenda we'll do an overview kind of show you we're at seven options now kind of what those are we'll walk through those and then talk about next steps SL so this is um a slide you guys saw at the last update this is our macro um view of the project plan so to dat um we've held to our plan um that put together we haven't missed any deadlines or Milestones so we're right on track of where we want this is the schedule at a more

004granular level um you can see kind of the temple with which we're meeting um and working towards narrowing down our options uh next week's Forum should uh provide us with better insight into kind of how the community feels about all the options um that I'm about to step through and uh additionally Herman is nearing completion of um the r order magnitude budgeting so we don't have budget numbers yet those are coming um probably by the end of the week we'll present those to the committee um after so we'll have that data point we'll have feedback from um the community Forum next week and then we're working on getting the survey out as well and then that'll help us T really narrow down these uh these seven choices down in just a few but so currently

005um this is kind of uh January February phase what we're doing now is um schedule events again the focus of this phase is is really just developing a selection methodology engaging the community um through those surveys and those listing forums slide looking out towards March um this is a the objective in in March will will really be to get down to two options um so we're trying to find the the options that we think best solve the school's needs and represents the interests of of the community and so we need to get to mark we kind of need that time to gather all of that information to get us down to that uh next slide looking further ahead into the spring we'll be focused on refining those uh final two options um and ultimately selecting

006one option to move on to the Final Phase of project design um I do want to note that the current schedule has another Workshop um on plann for May 1 we'd like to propose moving that to May 15th um the timing of when we're going to get the survey out and get the survey back um we'll just need that extra two weeks to to get the survey results be able to have that to help us get to a decision point because the objective of that Workshop is to present to you guys um our our final option we want to um and then in June um once we get to a single supportive option uh June will focus on finalizing that Divine concept uh and engaging the community to keep them a as to what we're

007doing and continuously gain uh get their feedback next I'll move on to a quick review of those seven options um and before I move into these um I do want to highlight that um you'll see the benchmarking Matrix associated with each option no that's a snapshot in time so we're we're still in the data collection phase we have um there's you'll see some tbds you'll see some red xes some green check marks don't get too worked up on those that's where we're at today they're all incomplete still we're still Gathering data we won't have those finalized probably until towards the end around the 27th is when we can have that so um I I also want to explain why you're looking at seven options instead of four um so I presented four here in this

008in this forum last time um when we brought Herman on right the esac one had done a lot of great work to get to those four options um but we recognize we're lay persons we're not experts we're not Educators we're not school designers so once we brought the Consultants into phase two we left that open that we may not have the right solution in these four so use your expertise take a look at all the data that we we collected over phase one um and help us you know if there's a hybrid solution or a completely new thing that we hadn't thought of we're open to looking at those and so Herman did just that um and on January 6 they brought us three additional options um that seems like we're moving back backwards to

009go from 4 to 7 but um but the the committee did vote to at least keep those those additional three options um for review until we get through R order magnitude pricing so once we see some budgetary numbers we'll know are these options we want to continue to look at or not next slide so I'll start with the um the first four that we've that came through usack one um option A is maintaining the primary and middle schools so this consists of uh renovating the existing buildings no new buildings um and no uh rephasing of classes um this in this option where you're keeping three grades at the middle school it would have a two-story addition for the Middle School um next slide this is that oh gosh sorry it's okay here's the Matrix um

010as it is currently again still collecting information that's the tbds that are in in there next slide option b is the fourth Primary School um this um will add again a two-story addition so this adds a a fourth primary school and a two-story addition to the middle school next slide and this shows how this option is currently um aligned to the benchmarking elements can I just ask a logistic question right Qui when I see red does that mean like for example um playground field areas aligned to doe standards so the red means that even with Renovations blueo would not meet those standards is I reading that correctly right okay thank you but we we're still I these are living documents so as we look at you know creative ways that we maybe can do things

011in the field some of these might change yeah and you know in order to kind of um have a comparison between the seven projects were using the same Matrix in terms of here are the big things that the committee was planning for in terms of needs of the schools um and obviously each potential solution meets some needs more than others right there's no one solution that protects all the B right okay option C is the new um grades two through three School so this option converts the primaries to K through one Wentworth becomes a 46 school which leaves grades seven and8 at the middle school and that would be a one story Edition at the middle school um next slide and here's the how the Matrix Stacks up today for this option option D is

012the new k through3 Community School um so this would also convert Wentworth to 46 and the Middle School to seven and8 which again would be a a single story addition to the Middle School The Matrix for that one benchmarking elements slide and so these next three are the new options that uh we can spend some time asking questions about if you'd like um option e is a k is a second K through five elementary school and so um You' rephase Wentworth to be a K through five build a second K through five school and then um add the a single story addition at I'm sorry this one gets a two-story Edition at the middle school and here's how that looks on our benchmarking elements SL um option f is a new P through2 Community School

013um uh the difference between this one and option C which was the fourth primary is that um this one also moves grade six to Wentworth which um we would do a small addition to Wentworth and then um a single story addition so a a smaller scope addition to the middle school it's another way to look at that fourth Primary School The Matrix as it is today and option G is a new one through three school so in this option this is really creative um the current the three primary schools would become kindergarten only schools um part of that is the kindergarten classrooms need a th000 foot classrooms and so it's you have to do pretty extensive renovations to get get them there so this solves for that and then you do um a one through

014three school and rephase went worth in the Middle School just a different way of looking at it slide this is the Matrix for option G as it is today here's kind of a summary of all of those you can look at them together how they compare so what's next um as I mentioned next week we'll hold our first Community Forum um we're we've been communicating this internally as a listening um meeting so we're we're going to present those seven options to the community and then just listen to their feedback um we're not defending anyone or or other option we just want to get a feel for what the community um wants you know in in in their solution um so we're we're going to ask for for feedback good bad or ugly um again right

015our overarching goal is to select an option that the voters will get behind um and and we can't do that without voter feedback and so um we ask everybody if you if you can be there on Tuesday please come please invite your friends um and your neighbors um the more feedback we get the more informed we'll become as we start to narrow these down to a single option uh yeah thanks I did kind of skip over the survey so there's a um one of the the the other way for getting feedback is the the surveys so we're going to do two two surveys um one is being developed right now and it will go out in the next couple of weeks um and that will inform our first kind of trunch of um narrowing down

016the options and then we'll do a second survey um later on to get from two to to a single op so you'll see that coming out uman end of January early fig that should hit so that's all I've got I'll turn it back over and answer any questions or conversations awesome thank you for um there's a lot of information here and I know we have a lot of questions so I appreciate you allowing enough time for for our bodies to um to talk and deliberate so I think what we'll do is I can I was thinking we'll go back and forth so maybe I'll start over here at the council first do you have any questions up that anybody terms of the presentation could you and maybe facilitate discussion could you leave it up on

017the summary of all the different options this one because I know I have a hard time keeping I can't imagine you didn't commit all those to don't have all the T thank you sure any questions any no no questions with just the comment like again for for me you know I think you guys are doing an awesome job process-wise and I really really hope that like at The Forum will get engaged and I I I appreciate and I hope all of my counselors will do as you suggested and be there and invite people we know to come and show up because again I'm remember last time when we did this we we we did these and people didn't come I think it's a totally different time right now so I think that's there's not a

018big comparison but it's really important for people to go so I really hope they'll come um I'm just really interested to see kind of what comes in March as you guys work through this because again all of these seem like they have pros and cons all of them um seem like they could meet our needs and it's just we just got to figure out um you know how do you guys and I'm interested if you do have an idea like what are like the top three criteria or things that are going to help to get to that solution because yeah it's a it's a great question counselor and um you know so you you see the benchmarking Matrix that that's associated with each one um so that just sort of allowed Herman to know what

019are the key Design Elements to work for but those are benchmarking elements that the district has said these these are things we care about um from that uh the the leadership team is going to work over the next few weeks to try to build the tool right so how do we make the right you know how do we come to a conclusion on what are the right options um there's a lot of emotion tied up in these um it'll be a mix of some subjective things and objective things right we talked last time about know prioritizing the priorities um and that's kind of what we got to get to so how do we go through this in a way that's fair Equitable um unbiased and and allows us to make the right decisions that the

020town supports as well yeah I I just hope we don't go with the lowest cost solution per se because sometimes the lowest costs might be inferior in terms of other things that we might have to give up and so you know I'm not saying that it needs to be super expensive or the next one up but you know I I think like when I think of some of these like I personally like suspect some of these the public may like more conceptually but may be more expensive than others and again there's a a cost benefit that happens when we go with different Alternatives and so like to me it's not just the cheapest one that's the best one it's what's the best value for our community and some of the things that I felt like

021our Community Values is in conflict with cost and you know trying to find that balance is going to be a real challenge but I I totally think the committee has the right approach and I'm looking forward to see kind of where we land just to kind of spin off that for the community uh the committee um I do think Diane's doing a lot of work at looking at the operating costs on these as well because sometimes the lowest sticker price has the highest and sometimes the highest has lowest and all those things and um keeping that at the Forefront in order to see the kind of long-term picture as well as the shortterm as well yeah I that's a a great Point especially when we talk about cost with folks and again that is I

022know that's kind of what people are waiting for is like what is this like at the end of the day they're going to say how is this going to impact my taxes and that was something I felt like we struggled with a little bit in the last committee we tried to create too many messages to try and explain that thinking people wanted to understand it in different ways and I feel like keeping that simple but we do have to be transparent that what is that long-term impact not just for when we go to bond but how that could increase your taxes from an operating perspective in perpetuity once we make that choice and you notice there was no mention today capital or operating costs and that that's intentional um because you start to put numbers

023before you have true data right it gets a lot of emotion when maybe those aren't aren't factual so we're allowing Herman the time to put those numbers together so when we actually present them um to the committee and start making decisions they're they're fact-based and not opinion based I will say oh sorry can I just say one thing I I will say just to piggy back on everything all the great points have already been made the one thing because I have sat on three different versions of these committees now I will say that one thing that sets this committee apart at this phase not only is it the responsiveness to the community but it is that focus on budget first yeah and so in the past the community has told us that they felt like

024we created the best possible learning environment for our kids but we pushed the budget to the side and said well we'll worry about that later and the feedback that we got was we want the budget upfront and so as a committee we've all been aligned on that from the beginning um and we were very clear with the Consultants that that was one of our priorities going into this and so that's definitely a different approach this time from my perspective people to to follow up on that then that's helpful to me because this is sort of an all this is sort when all things being equal these are roughly the same budget requirements and so when I look at all of those dots and things um you know I've been paying attention and I get a

025little confused and I think it would be really helpful to be saying as you approach this with Community import here's the solution here's roughly its description here are its relative pros and cons not just the Matrix but this is what we think the strengths of this one are this is what we think the weaknesses were the tradeoffs and try to do that succinctly for each one of those options uh if you go out with this I think people's heads will spit yeah so maybe that was not your intent but that's definitely come up within the committee is uh and the communication of that as well a very concise clear somewhat truncated version of The Matrix that gives the pros and cons in simple terms here are Seven Hats you know they'll all keep your head

026warm they all cost about the same you know this 's pretty infancy this one's utilitarian you know this one doesn't look good on you at all Etc that's you know in the simplest terms I think that's really what you're what you're trying to say here is to say yeah within this box there are lots of different approaches to it here's what we came up with which one feels better to you because I think that's really what you're asking at this point is what feels better to you your neighborhood your kids Etc and order to have that gut reaction they have to have they have to be able to extend the Hat analogy to go and stand in front of there and put it on yeah I would um f I'm Gonna Come To You Right

027Next I just want to piggyback exactly what Don said I'm so sorry um uh I am really wanting I'm excited to hear that you're going down the pros and cons list because I would really like to hear the pros and cons for each solution I want to know the operating cost I want to know the upfront cost but in addition to that that I want to know what it means to families what it means to staff what it means to students so um I'm really interested in hearing in seeing you play out that part of this when when you start that work yeah I I I it's well said and and and received we'll work on that we've talked a lot about it in committee it's it's it's really easy to say to a pros

028and cons list and then when you start trying to do that it right what's a pro to one person is a con to another and so we've gotten into these debates of like well you know what what half the room thinks is a positive about an option the other half thinks is actually a negative about the option and so yeah we've struggled to actually put those and end up just and I think that's why we have that Matrix right so that we can say this solution provides for these things but it doesn't provide for these other items right and I'm not sure to your point counselor Cushing that they will all be within the same cost range right I I don't know that we know that yet right but certainly that may be a factor

029as the committee continues its work and decides what proposals to move forward because we are very committed to the um the financial piece but it's it's fair to say that what that the directive you gave was to shoot for this and I think it's reasonable to say this is what we applying to we're not going to know until the final analysis I think it's very important to be upfront with people about that I think that's a very good point today so we're looking in this range but over seven options with seven it's very hard to be precise right so it it could very well turn out that your favorite cost in that's yeah right because the first four options are coming straight from esac one and again you know having been on that committee myself

030none of us you know were experts in terms of um knowing whether those ideas fell within that range or not that's part of the work that we're engaging Herman with all right PR yeah I'm gonna bring the horse back around to beat it a couple more times um one of the things I'm really interested in and when my question is actually when you cost these have numbers like hard numbers which I'm very interested in um by the end of the month um are those including not just The Upfront build cost but also the operational cost because I'm Fair interested in both of those I on the finance committee and budget construction we'll have we'll have a an order of magnitude cost on the project on the capital cost um I don't the level of effort

031it takes to do a full operating cost model is pretty heavy so um I we're going to try to do some things but I don't I don't think we'll actually have operating costs by the end of the month we'll have Capital costs um and that'll help us inform and we'll build an operating cost model for a few the fewer options I I just I don't think it's realistic to to have that for all seven options that's my concern with the seven options over the four options yeah is that things that are really important to taxpayers which is their toay taxes every single year are going to be more heavily impacted by the operation cost than they are by the cost of the act and that's something that again I'm very mindful of being um I'm

032I'm on the committee so I apologize I hav been brought this to everyone's attention prior but kind of taking this step back has helped me realize that that Matrix a lot um some of these newer I guess the option oh no can you back that one oh back there yeah um there are changes being made to Wentworth specifically e is a pretty drastic change um and we we really haven't evaluated how Wentworth would be impacted by these changes on The Matrix so some of those things you know if we put those additions onto Wentworth are we impacting the field can you go back to the sorry Nick you know are we starting to lose some with the WW worth we currently have are we kind of lessening its ability to fulfill the Matrix and things

033so um I'm on the committee with you but just something to tag for ourselves in the future to kind of look again and and make sure that we're not um kind of taking from what we already have yeah and and I intentionally didn't didn't you know produce the the draft site plans and bubble bubble diagrams for this for this meeting because otherwise that that would be all we'd look at the whole time and not have this discussion um but I do know that you know in that one right you lose the fire land behind and there there's some there's some things that you know you have to do to make those things work so can I can I ask a question question um so I for I don't know if there's a bunch of committee

034members here but I'm just curious like with the timeline that you guys have set out how confident do you feel that that timeline allows you to do the quality work that's needed to get this right because I get concerned sometimes that sometimes the timeline is driving the work and then I'll speak for the last um committing myself my own personal perspective not spdc I got on was we did end up getting kind of really focused on needing to get it on the ballot by a certain date and I think we did a great job but we definitely needed more time probably to bring the public along and again the more complicated it is like even some of these if they do become the winners are just hard for people to understand and I remember there

035were so many times we were out in the public talking to people and things that we thought were so obvious it was like no they don't even understand that Wentworth is moving and this is happening and so again I just the the time to bring the public along I think is the most important part of this and do you feel confident that the timeline we have is going to set us up to bring the public along successfully so that it can pass into valid I think a great question and it it's obvious to me looking at the Timeline that there's challenges there I think what the the challenge is more immediate in that we need to uh down these choices then heram in and programming and the Boe and everything then we dive deeper into

036those fewer choices and that's where I think we get the quality of the data by not doing it for seven you know it's just and but because now it's grown to seven are the things we need to expedite are making the hard choices about what are the final couple of options and I think that's where we need to be very diligent about making those decisions well I I just I just want to say that for me personally if you guys feel like you need more time ask for it but also I'm also comfortable and I don't know if Tom's gonna like this or anybody say it I can already feel sh not liking I know well I'm just saying I'm just saying I this this this election this November one is a pretty small one

037there's not a lot happening and so I would have no problem doing another election a couple months later like I don't think we have to wait till June I would rather say if we need to have a special election on this because it's so important to our community this to me justifies it so I just want people to feel good about the quality of the work and that you feel like you're ready and if you're not just let us know and you can figure out a way to still go as fast as we can if we have to do that yeah I I appreciate that I think um I looking at the project plan that that we have in front of us and where we're at with it and where we're going I feel confident

038we're going to be okay um if if that changes and I we need to come in here and ask for an extension we will but I I feel pretty good about where we're at the other thing that I would add to what I heard you say John is that um I think there are some significant shifts in this particular project than in the last rendition right and you know I've been along for both of those rides as well um but I think that we are really paying a lot of attention to Communications um to really making sure that um we're blanketing the community in multiple ways um I think the addition of the two surveys to engage the public um are also things that that we didn't previously had so it's not you know I

039don't want to characterize it as a wash R repeat because this is a very different process that's a good point and and to your earlier point I think the community is in a different place um and just even if there's anything good that we can take away from the failed referendum it's that now the community understands that there's going to be a potential school question whereas people didn't we didn't have that last time right we were trying to even we were at a level where we were even trying to tell the community there's a school on the ballot like so and I and I think luckily we you know we've Advanced the community's knowledge and awareness beyond that point now yeah right right go back over to the school board I any questions here um

040okay so let me I have a couple so I just want to be sure we're not going to have costs by The Forum because I heard you say right we're not yeah okay so when you're looking at these seven and you're as a committee drilling down how if you don't have the the operating costs because that you're waiting on that how are you um how are you going to rank these and start letting go of them what are you going to be considering um so again I we as a leadership team we have work to do to build a tool that helps us make you know as unbiased decisions as we can and and be as objective as we can we all have kind of our favorites and things like that but we we want

041to be able to to develop the tools that help the committee get down to that so so that's not finalized yet so I can't answer completely um I will say you know the benchmarking elements that you see um on these slides is kind of our starting point does it meet the objectives right does it which you know which one's best solve for right the the problems that that have been so well defined by Diane and her team and then um and then we look at cost right um I wrote myself a note to and I I'll talk with um Lisa and see is is there a way we can do maybe a high level OP cost model for the first trunch and and get something more detailed for for TR to something like that right

042so I think even if we were able to provide a staffing cost right as a comparison you know not going into all of the other operating costs like you know um utilities right we could probably get that um you know at a sooner time right yeah that would be great because the staff is going to be your biggest cost with any of these right your ongoing operating cost and so if at least if you have an idea what that is I would think that would be helpful as you're trying to narrow it down even just a high level yeah I would be interested to know what how many disruptions we're going to be causing all this because there would be a lot of transitions for our kids also to get used to all this so

043I would personally as a parent I would like the least amount of transitions Poss um transitions in the final options or transitions through the construction through the construction through the construction right yeah yeah and um uh it's impossible for me to read on these slides but I do know there is a there is an element in there of know project timeline and things like that and how that how that will play out right so so yes 100% agree um that that's an element that that we'll look at and consider actually for me also um as part of your like larger analysis um sort of the need to District um because I think people have a right to know that um when they're evaluating these options because when you start whatever you do if you're going

044to need to redistrict that's a conversation where are you your districting is extremely uh traumatic I would even say for the community to go through if you're all your younger sibl have gone to one school and have this teacher and suddenly you're going to somewhere else as a again I have kids at the age of these schools we're talking about um you know my kids were separated as I testified not have um they were very angry that and if they were told that that arbitrarily they would be moved from one school to another which was something that we considered um that that was considered very detrimental they they would have been very by that yeah just just to be clear right I mean as you look at these options on the board um they all

045require some element of redistricting with the exception of a um b b doesn't necessarily redistrict it has a consolidation in the middle there a great earlier than we currently do with Wentworth but every if we add a fourth school we do any any of these other options there will be a redistricting element I just think that should Beed I know you're thinking about a million things but I think that's one because that's something that caus a lot of emotional reaction and I I do think it is important to be looking at the equality across the town um just because the child lives in one area of town they should be receiving the same education as the child in another part of town um and some of these options shake up a lot with Renovations and

046builds and all of these things so my hope would be um that no matter where you fell between a new school or a a renovation that you are provided the same environment and everything across Y and building on those those last two or three comments I was I was going to bring up the the the topic of construction impacts and disruptions and um I think that what that has in common with with some of these other comments is that as much as the focus rightfully has been on budget impacts and how critical that's going to be to the vote assuming that happens in November um and I'm sure you've talked about this in the committee but really seems to me looking back on some of the things that the town has grappled with related to

047the schools over the last several years even going back to you know early start and and flip-flopping the older kids with the younger kids I think there was a that to bring up topic but I think sometimes I think sometimes there it's just sort of a pattern sometimes where where a group works on something works really hard on something um thinks they've gotten good input and then they then it actually gets out to the commity and the public and some and there are things that turned out to have been blind spots so um to me those include things like construction related impacts how long how long would some of these scenarios take from start to finish um the busing impacts you know districting um and and Equity of education so I'll be interested to hear

048I agree with with Council Anderson I I hope that there is good participation at The Forum and Beyond and i' interested to hear how much of those sorts of things we hear obviously it's most likely to come from parents who have kids in the schools currently um they may be disproportionately focused on those things as opposed to some of the other factors yeah and you know anecdotally only right so so there's no this isn't from a survey or anything just my conversations with people I'll have I'll have a conversation with with you know somebody in the town that will say I don't care how much it costs don't care about cost I want Community Schools in the story you talk to somebody else and they'll say I don't want to pay taxes don't raise my

049taxes whatever you do so you know and I I'll take a moment to just kind of toot the horn of a committee to try to balance all of that feedback from the from the community as it comes in um you know and and and then we all have our own personal biases as well right and so the committee's done a really good job of trying to um kind of stay above The Fray take those inbound you know take take that that that input process it um you know and be as be as Fair as we can and try to try to come up with a solution that that the most people in town can get behind um without alienating any particular group within town it's it's frankly right it's it's a hard problem yeah that's

050why we're at our Comm just to add another problem for for thoughts because again like I think last time I think we you know and it came through the survey the location was a reason for a lot of people of why they voted no not all of these may require new locations at the next meeting when we have the nro list but we also have a sense of potential locations of where those could be because to me that's I think some people might look at this and be like well I can tell you which one I like but I want to know where it's going to go and that might actually change my mind if it's not so I I will say likely no um and and Tom you can jump in and correct me

051please but there there's a there's an element of confidentiality with with site selection um that we don't want to put the town in a in a bad place to negotiate from and so if we start to publicize the sites that we're looking at um right then those land owners become aware um that that that's the option and that's the only place that a school can go and things like that and so um we're we're being careful with that um at some point we have to kind of we will have to publish that and I'll work with the town and when when's the right time to do that kind of like with the operating cost like maybe not like a precise plot of land but a general area or neighborhood that we could say like again

052I I just want people to know we're not going to put something in west scarver or maybe we are and like that might change how people feel about again if we went with the new k32 one just the primary school option b and said that's going to go in West Scaro because that's that's what the decision is people might react to that differently than well we're going to put it try and put it near the campus and like be close because I know the big piece that um I think of like the parents and even some of the non-parents and just what we hear on the town side is traffic traffic traffic so if this is in a place where people perceive significant traffic or where there's significant traffic additional costs that are required to

053remediate the new traffic like we need to have an answer to that like that will be something that a lot of people sorry a lot of people will want to kind of understand to know before they vote yeah certainly before we vote I mean that's that's not a question right obviously I think I think um we we were our the initial answer was in response to by the next time we meet so certainly by the time we vote just to be clear um and then as a member of the site selection subcommittee there's a couple other committee members is here um so please you know feel free to jump in um but we are working in tandem with the larger group um we're meeting every week right now um to evaluate different sites and right

054now because we don't know what we're building um it's really hard to eliminate anything off the list and so really our primary focus has been to look at what all of our potential options are above a certain size acreage that is stipulated by the DOE and then when as we start to get towards what we're building we will have those options ready to you know launch with the committee and say okay if this is what we're building this is what the site selection committee has been working on for a building of that size you know that would have these certain phase levels add it etc etc and so just so the community is aware we are doing that kind of in tandem with the work of the committee so that when we get closer to

055knowing which options we're going to go you know to The Next Step that we have that that framework laid already because John knows better than anybody else in this room what site selection was like last time he was the chair of the council uh at the negotiating table with the downs and so now that I find myself in that chair seat I'm trying to avoid a similar fate of negotiating right down to the wire it was scary yeah it was actually want can I jump in yeah can say something Qui just on site just to give you a flavor uh we have about half of the the full committee is also the S selection a lot of folks are very interested in this and learning from last time those experiences we really need to started

056early so we have sit wi net this time in some respects smaller papage pursu some of these options um and we're kind of further appe so we're looking uh kind of you know further than just the immediate area here we fully expect that a lot of those will fall off for a number of good reasons uh in fact tomorrow we've asked our Consultants to come prepared with educating us on kind of the publicly available information Wetland hle pools um location utilities so I expect as soon as tomorrow at our meeting we'll start to eliminate some of those those properties right away uh but I just want to impress upon you we started in Earnest uh we're casting a wide that very thorough yeah I totally understand negotiating and the requirement for confidentiality has part of

057that process um uh I I just really want to Echo what council Anderson said um I and I want to move it even further which is what you talked about building consensus in the community which is sort of what you're doing on your committee which is sort of what there's a lot of variety of opinions on your committee which I think is a strength of your committee um as part of that process uh that you talked about within the committee of building consensus I think you need to think about how to distill the information points that you've used in order to spread that with a wider Community because you not only have to build consensus internally you have to create consensus a wide across a wide community of folks who are mostly disinterested um in

058what's going on until they have to be so most people are not all that dialed in to what's going on try to engage them um but then at the end they sort of come around and they have to make a decision real fast and there needs to be a way that they understand the process that you use to build consensus so that when they competing demands of I I I I like I want my small schools I mean that's the since that's true many people like small schools many people also want equity and education also people want a certain location and not that location and people want a certain price tag and not that price tag and people want all about operating costs as low as possible as well as the lowest price like like

059there's a lot of competiting desires and that's in one person's head um that's CommunityWide but you're talking about building consensus among yourselves I really urge you to to take the process you're using and figure out how to communicate that out so that on the day before the election whether it's November or another dat um we we have that answer for for constituents who are asking us you know why why would you take I mean why did you take away our community schools why would you put it there why would you ask for that much money why do we care about this why is the cafeteria back like there was all sorts of you know my kids did it for my kids fine all four of them went through eight corners and it was perfect we

060need to be able to say well they thought about that and here's what they said because I um in fast of the information last time although I followed it at a high level was I was overloaded trying to Fig follow it and when I looked at that Matrix it looked like a nutrition label on the back of the package of cookies and my kids want to PE and I'm just like oh not again and I understand the purpose of The Matrix and the and the need to be able to see all that information but we need to make information for people who want to find it accessible but for people who don't want to spend time and a lot of people don't have the capacity it's not intelligence it's time because they're busy with family

061and work and a million other demands that they need to be able to look at and say I understand why they came to this decision and I can get behind it because that's the only way we're going to get this I agree with that 100% And it's it's going to be one of the things really focus on and kind of going back to phase one the data we had that was really valuable was that survey that got done right after the failed referendum and we've really let that drive us because we're ultimately we need to put together something that will pass yeah and so we we're really we come back to it often to say um and people on the committee will quote you know 57% of the people said they this is what whatever

062the issue is so that's kind of what we have already but I think to your point um then as we're making those decisions making it very concise and clear is is going to be what brings people along see for the cell phone video thing people want soundes they don't read yeah it's great it's great feedback and our communication subcommittee does has been done doing a really good job um we'll give them that feedback to help us work to distill this down and I thought the first committee did a good job I don't want them to feel like their work is not like honored I I tried to follow along I read everything that was sent to me I did not read everything on the website I read as much as I could because it was

063under the Committees um but I I did I did my homework it was dense and I'm a good reader don't I already broke April's heart I told her the same thing as you know I I tried to consume this a month before the vote and I I felt uninformed so I just voted no yeah I think what I just fr's comment something special happened in the initial sbac committee right where you guys were able to have so many people with different perspectives come together however I will say you guys didn't get to one and so I still feel like like I'm I'm eager to see what happens yeah and I really encourage all committee members hopefully to have an open mind to stay on board to make some concessions where they feel because like the

064frightless point all of those things you mentioned are important like none of them are not important but we have to try and find as much consensus as we can know what our tradeoffs are and comfortable with it and you know I'm not going to be polanish to think we're gonna like 100% support for this like I I think that's just not realistic and I think people don't have to support it but you know to your point of like showing that debate being contradictory with each other I think is really important for the public to know happened and you know even as we go out to communicate like not trying to sell this as this is the best solution but to say hey we've had to make some cup choices and this solution is the one

065we chose and what we decided to give up because we had to give something up was this thing and we hated doing that we didn't want to do that but we had to make a choice and that's what we chose like I just think that level of honesty and authenticity and transpar Arcy will really help hopefully bring people along and see that we're making some concessions because I don't think we're going to get everything we want can I say can I say one more thing and then I I'll be G for today I promise um it's not going to be enough to hope that people come along with us on this ride yeah right like every single person in this room knows it's not enough to just hope people come to the forums that people

066we hope people will fill out the survey like one of the biggest things that we need to be doing is actively reaching out we need to leave this room and every single one of us needs to text 10 people and say there's this forum next Tuesday at six o'clock do you want me to pick you up can I bring you a coffee like it needs to be that active level of Engagement they saw it in cap Lisa has told us anecdotally that it was the people on the committee the elected officials the people the elected officials know the school staff coming and actively grabbing people and saying you you don't get to just wait until October 22nd to call me and be like which you know how should I vote like we can't do that

067this is too important it's too important yes so this is my call to everybody like like it's it's just not GNA be enough to and and we all work so hard and so the last thing I want is for us to work this hard again and have the community tell us in October that they just didn't get it like that would that will truly break my heart and so that's my Rah ra go team moment is we all have to be active participants in getting people to come along with us agreed and I would say just as a final um for myself and I'll be done um I mean we're coming on 7 o'clock but I will be done um I I will admit I I heard that there was three new Solutions and my

068heart sank a little bit um I I didn't expect I was one like John where I was like okay phase one you didn't come to a solution and so um when I heard there's three new I you know I I kind of was like oh but what I appreciate in seeing this is that um is is I think committee members are probably tied to the solution they like right but what I appreciate about this is that there's a step back and saying hey we might not have all the answers if you find something that is that you think is innovative and you think would work T and so when I'm looking at these when my initial hesitation was I don't want three new Solutions I want you to get to one I appreciate that there's

069a lot of out of the box thinking here and I appreciate that there are solutions that I wouldn't like I never would why I wouldn't have thought of this a K5 when that's what I attended in the school I don't know I do not know that never would have crossed my mind but that's what I attended and so the fact that you're you was committee and with carman's help are looking at these and saying okay let's look a little bit differently and deeper I really really appreciate that and so I think um I think as you kind of prioritize your priorities and you come up with the things these are what we're getting I don't want to put my thumb on the on the needle here and tell you what to do um and that's

070why I'm trying to be intentionally vague about the pros and cons but when you come up with your priority list and you're able to say solution a gives us a b and c we aren't going to get D and F solution B is going to give us one through five but not six that is going to be super super helpful for the community to try to digest this and understand it a little bit more and so I do think there's a lot of value in the fact that you've got a committee full of people with varying ideas varying opinions differing emotions about all of this and you all are all working together so to John's point I do hope everybody takes that step back and takes a look at the work you're doing and realizes

071you're really putting in a lot of effort to help get to a solution we need and it you know it did it took moment of of humility I think inac one where we were gonna we're going to get to one one one choice and then you know we have kind of had to go look none of us are experts we we we chose $600 a square foot for construction cost we have no idea if that's accurate or not it's not fair to let that be how we narrow this down to one choice and so then we kind of just been trying to carry that humility forward and allow the experts now to to inform us and and make real data driven decisions we have to wait till the tables get out of the way we

072will totally do a hand in a midle thank you both so much for coming we really thank e e e oh all right that was really something um good evening welcome to the school board um Scarboro Board of Education business meeting the date Thursday January 16 2025 um Ray can we call the attendance Please Mr kaher present Miss Leong here miss Lindstrom here miss Peterson here Mr rockenstein here M tarpinian here miss Trini Hoff here miss leder here M rasina perfect thank you so much would everyone please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge of to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands Nation indivisible with liy and justice for all perfect all right um agenda item 4.0 is approval of the December 19th 2024 workshop

073and business meeting minutes um without objection we can approve those um agenda item 5.0 is the consent agenda this is a non-action item um the December resignations retirements and new hires is um part of our meeting materials is there anything you wanted to nope no add perfect agenda item 6.0 are adjustments to the agenda are there any adjustments yes there's one adjustment to the agenda tonight um item 7.0 Spotlight award recognition uh that is going to be moved to the next meeting please thank you so our new agenda item 7.0 is the superintendance report correct all right so superintendent report for this evening um I know that we have a couple of uh bigger items on the agenda this evening so I really wanted to just keep this short um and I am providing you

074with the enrollment report as of December 31st um as you can see our enrollment is holding very consistent um with previous months um the other thing that I would just add as part of my report that I do not have a slide for is um just a reminder to the community that there is a lot of work going on with our building committee um we have a community Forum coming up on Tuesday today um there are seven options uh that the committee is looking at right now and um we really value feedback from the community to help us to know what are the things that uh people value um we are very committed to um uh setting really strong financial boundaries for this project so um the building committee uh has set some really hard

075parameters between 70 million and 130 million and so um you know we are not at the place right now where any of these seven options have financials um but um we are going out for this form really to kind of get some conceptual feedback about um what type of um phase level structures in schools that the community might be interested in um we will also in addition to having the Forum on Tuesday um surveying the community at the end of January everyone will get a postcard in the mail at their home um whether you're affiliated with a school system or not that'll go to Every Scaro citizen um and um with a QR code or a link and um if people would prefer to have a paper copy we'll have paper copies available here um

076at Town Hall we'll also have paper copies at the library and again that's another method for us to get feedback from the community about those seven options um and then as we drill down to fewer options um later this spring we will then conduct a second survey in a similar way to say here are the options that were the two options again I'm assuming two options but that'll be up to the committee but you know here are the more limited options that we're looking at and you know here's what this one provides here what this one provides these are all more details um because um the committee is very much interested um in making sure that we're continuing to take the temperature with the community and moving along with a project that um there will

077be strong support for thank you Diane are there any questions for Diane all right agenda item 8.0 is the chair's report I just also have a very brief one I know we have a pretty jam-packed agenda tonight um the first thing I wanted to talk about is the um annual comprehensive um audit was done between the town and the board um I think uh Jenna is going to speak about this a little bit more so I won't steal too much of her Thunder but I will say that the audit went very well um the report out was was very good this is the audit was actually done before Thanksgiving and so that was a really big uh thing for the town they actually reviewed the last few the last I think it was 12 years

078of audits and um I think there's less than a handful of times they've been done on time and then this one was actually done even earlier so the findings were all really really good um the fund balance uh for the town is well above the minimum right now it's at 14.5 and their aspirational goal is 16.6% so they they aren't to too far off um and 6 point just so you know 16.6% represents two months of expenses for the town so that's what their aspirational goal is to get to and so they're they're well above the minimum and Well on their way um so they um lots of good news that came out of the audit um I do know I'll put a plug for I don't I don't see Kate but um did she

079leave she makes you she has these beautiful books if anybody's interested in I'm really reading very interesting facts and figures about the audit report so that is that is that um the other thing I wanted to say is last week we held um a special meeting and this was I I'll talk a little bit more about this when we get to the um electronic devices policy but um this was a new a new thing for all of us we've never invited the public in on our process um in the way that we did last week and um I did uh ask around at the end I did hear some from some parents at night I received some emails afterward um and I did hear back from all the board members that um I think all

080in all everybody really considered it a successful evening um I really appreciated that we had um students and parents and teachers and that everybody seemed from what I could tell to be listening to each other and to be really respectful of each other I was bouncing back and forth between the two big conversations and at one point I went over and I heard a student ask a parent I want I want you to explain to me why you think we shouldn't have cell phones really want to understand where you're coming from and so that sort of respectful dialogue was really really important to me and I think really important to everybody up here so for those of you that are here that were that attended or that are listening and attended thank you so much

081you did um give everyone up here some really valuable feedback to consider and it's really important to us as we're making these decisions so thank you for making our very first um special meeting special so thank you for that all right agenda item nine .0 our committee reports so we will start with the building committee so Jillian and Alyssa all right well we just heard a whole bunch about uh about the committee so right now actually there are seven options I don't know why that still says four but um we heard about the seven options tonight uh we are going out with a survey in the near future but most importantly is the community Forum coming up on the 21st that's next Tuesday at 6: p.m. in the U Middle School cafeteria and so you'll

082see some signs have gone up around town tonight um and I think Diane covered the rest of it so any any questions please come please bring a friend to please tell all your friends you heard that earlier but uh it's really important that we get this community feedback or else we are making decisions in the absence of so and this is kind of the time to hear your voice and hear what what you guys want as a community for our children for our future kind of these are the long-term decisions that will be made for um you know our structures of our school system for a long time and we we're really asking for it now because when it comes to referendum we've already made a lot of choices so we're asking to please please

083show up give us feedback talk with us stay involved stay informed bring friends lots and lots of them um um so that we can we can use all that information use that data we saw all that engagement with the cell phones as it continues and you know we hope to carry all that excitement um and engagement along into the building committees excuse me are there any questions all right uh Jillian we stick with you all right so the communications committee met last on the 10th at 8:00 in the morning the next one is on February 6 8: a.m. we are really working uh towards finalizing some things for the senior citizen appreciation dinner this will be our second one it is planned right now for April 8th at 4M at the wentor cafeteria um all

084hands on deck with this one we have had a lot of people jumping in already and helping to uh make this happen um right now we're working on recruiting groups groups to participate um we will be sending out some information to staff we're working on advertising and other planning activities we were able to get it in the spring flyer for community services so that's really great um so that will go out to the whole Community this year it'll be locked to only uh Scaro residents um which is a little bit of a change we had it open last time but we wanted to focus on Scarboro residents um we are working on Spotlight award presentations we have two coming up um and we're requesting additional submissions um and we're still continuing to work on routine

085updates for the district and town newsletters establishing a pattern um but we are starting to look at budget communication which will be coming up soon thank you Jillian any question for questions for Jillian all right Jenna um so as you had mentioned Shannon um Kate reviewed the fy2 for audit process and it was great because the audit was complete in record time and normally we're still waiting on it at this point and we're excited we were excited to finally get the information so that giant book that Shannon was holding up before it's actually linked in here that's the town annual comprehensive financial report so if you wanted to click into that you can um but I know Kate also has paper copies probably and she'll happily share because she also likes flipping through pages um

086and then linked in there are also the other documents that we reviewed and we spent the most time on the financial report and the school Department financial statement there are a lot of acronyms and I can't remember any of them for the life of me um so if you actually go back to our last meeting to watch it you'll get more in-depth explanation of all these things that I can't do justice for um Kate does a beautiful job and I can listen to her speak all day about finances um and then coming up I want everyone to gear up because it's budget season again um so the two big dates that you want to Mark in your calendars now are March 18th and March 19th they are the Leadership Council and School Board budget Workshop

087days um the first one's going to be held at 4:30 7 at Wentworth and the second one's going to be 8:30 in the morning to 11:00 a.m. at Town council chambers here and I personally love these because you get to speak with building leaders we go line by line and discuss why things are in the budget um it's very informative to everybody to understand how we got these numbers and that's why we're proposing these numbers to the town um when it's time to vote so so def save those dates and then if you want to know more information on the budget process there's a link below but if you go to the main web page the school web page click on board and then go to budget and all of your information is there um

088and you can also go back to previous meetings from previous years uh about this whole process and our next meeting is January 27th at 6m awesome thank you so much Jenna are there any questions for Jenna all right um Alyssa long-term planning all right so we're going to be having our second long-term planning committee uh meeting on January 30th um zoom in in person uh we're going to be talking about the budgetary needs um for next year a little bit of a challenging conversation due to the fact that we don't know what's going on with our school buildings um but we'll be doing a review then all right perfect thank you you bless you any questions for Alissa all right frea negotiations I'd love to say they are off to a hot start um they're

089not but we have meetings scheduled which is great news and I look very forward to getting those started next week and our goal um I'm just want to add that last line our goal is to get this contract completed by the end of this school year that is always Our Hope and that is something that is extremely important to this group yeah any questions all right carry on policy committee where I spend all my time um uh this committee is moving along we are obviously uh reviewing the student use of cellular technology and other devices uh policies as I don't think is a surprise to anybody sitting in front of me um we've been reviewing it um since June obviously not exclusively but that's been our main focus for the last few meetings um and

090I am very excited to bring that to First reading tonight uh later on uh once we get to a place where we can look at focus on other items um we're looking at use of school facilities coming up next um in student transportation and then um once uh maybe at some point we'll get back to reviewing our old policies uh the goal that when I started uh on this committee a couple years ago at this point was to review all policies that haven't been reviewed since before 2020 um we are in a b of the alphabet so moving right along moving right along yes um but uh but my I am I am optimistic that once we get back on track we're going to roll into see soon so um that's my goal the next

091meeting date is February 4th from 4 to 5:30 that is a change to our usual schedule um so just note that it's not our normal uh th first Thursday of the month 6 to 7 or 5 to 6:30 meeting um it's it's a different day of the week um and we should go back to our normal schedule after that hybrid or what it's a Tuesday thank you that's it's a Tuesday I can remember it was Tuesday or Wednesday it's a Tuesday um and then I just wanted to say uh Shanna talked about it but we had what we considered a successful Round Table discussion special board meeting I'm not really sure I still I think we still don't know what to call it um on January 9th and I really thank everyone who came out

092to participate that was really helpful FR isn't the February 4th meeting here in town council chambers it might be maybe in the school conference yeah I'm looking I'm looking at Cheryl yeah so we can update the slide before we yeah publish it yeah and the agenda will be right we usually meet in the conference room we have been meeting in to allow space for everybody who wants to come yeah recently perfect thank you any questions all right um are there any leaz on reports before I get to you FR are there any other lays on reports all right so 11 Point 11.0 is our L reports 11.1 no 10.0 is our L on reports 10.1 is a summary results from the 2024 delegate assembly you've been waiting for this I would like you to picture

093me in my atct office on a beautiful beautiful sunny October Saturday on Zoom with 80 other Schoolboard members all of whom feel like they know Robert's Rules really well but do not agree on what Robert rules says so we went through the packet um which is available on the materials to know what the main School boards Association um which is an association we're a member of what their um proposed resolutions um deletions revisions and additions um which get voted on by a member of the school board who are members and so I was uh honored to be the one chosen to go to that um and so that so that Scarboro could participate and have a voice in what the main School Bo Association will be advocating for the legislative this season which is actually

094important because um when decisions get made in Augusta about what happens here at Scarboro we have to follow those rules whether we'd like them or not so having a voice at that table is really important um even more important than beautiful fall Saturday mornings um I am not going to go through all of them because there's a lot of them I'm going to hit the ones that were of hot topics to debate um and I have notes if anyone wants them all everything passed just you know everything that they propos passed usually by a large majority nothing passed unanimously um uh and so let me just hit the highlights which uh the first one was gunfree schools uh we talked about that here um they changed the language um uh with the msba supporting evidence-based

095Public Health interventions to ruse gun violence in schools um gunfree schools is the law like there's a leg there's a law actually me that says you can't have guns at school um and so it was a very spicy debate which kind of surprised me but shouldn't have should never be surprised um we ultimately passed the revision um there were lots of questions about what the language meant and then we went into yellow flag red flag bills for no reason because they have nothing to do with us um but we spent a lot of time there um then we came back to our job and uh the next place where we had a a long conversation was the legislative mandates I'm talking about how um we late we word Smith this to death and there were

096lots of amendments passed um but ultimately what passed really pushed that legislative mandates from Augusta need to include the input of residents from geographically diverse areas of Maine um and that anything mandatory that's passed in Augusta needs to be funded by Augusta so that if they're going to put uh requirements on our school district they need to adequately fund those changes which doesn't happen but we can ask for it um there was a really long long conversation um and a lot of argument over what Robert rules is and how to make a motion to amend and now and my notes myself that now we're running behind because now we're debating whether only people who are citizens should be included um so we were like hours behind at that point so we went back um to

097the regular program next place we had a big discussion was Equitable education opportunities I actually voted against this even though it passed um and they took out a statement saying um the last statement of that said by involving parents and other citizens in the process when appropriate local school boards can test results in positive and can use test results in positive and constructive ways um there was a big argument that we didn't need to put parents here because they're elsewhere but I don't agree that we should ever take parents out of the equation I think I said that at this meeting before we went down about that revision um and I didn't change my vote there I think that if um if the school boards are going to be passing something parents have a right

098and should Beed so that was what I advocated for and I lost um uh essential program and services was another big place um lots and lots of debate on that um and really we added in predictable and sustainable funding sources from the state trying to make the state um pay their fair share essentially of all the mandates they put on the school districts which relieves local burdens to taxpayers which is why it was so important to advocate for it um and then there were two new rule uh resolutions passed one on artificial intelligence in schools super extensive discussion very wide range of understanding of what AI is um and um but ultimately it did pass um and it just starts the conversation about using AI to promote literacy providing new learning opportunities um but not

099a substitute for original thought work not a substitute for students learning um and yeah so that that passed and then we uh Oro submitted something indicating that uh the 55% which I'm not going to get into today Kate does a better job of it but roughly the state provides 55% funding of what they think it cost to educate every student in Maine we do not get 55% of our budget funded from austa we do not get that very clearly we do not but they a portion a a proportion of that money pot the 55% that they they think is what it cost educate does get come to us um through various ways and as part of our budget offset um so um historically that 55% has not been funded at the full 55% which is

100the law that has recently changed which has been a very good thing for school districts it's made the state ex simply pay their fair share um the the idea was to make sure that 55% keeps Pace with inflation so that a portion of it doesn't get eroded um there was a long debate about whether we needed to do that whether it was internal no formula or not internal new formula there was no Kates there so nobody understood what they were talking about um but ultimately I think we all decided that we do want to make sure that whatever they're funding keeps fac with inflation because if it doesn't then what it does is it pushes um the burden onto the local taxpayers which is something that as an organization um we're against and as a

101school board obviously we are always looking for ways to to fund our district and and alleviate the the burden on taxpayers um in our Comm you missed a very exciting meeting and uh everybody needs rules Robert rules of orders uh the cheat she that sh hadn had made for us and no and my only takea away from that is people need new hobbies that are not related to Robert rules after that meeting I feel like you're selling this so that nobody else tries to take this volunteer opportunity from you next year I will I will I will bake you cookies oh are there any questions for frea all right thank you for attending and representing us and thank you for fighting the good fight and um even when you when you weren't successful you were

102still successful because you represented us well so thank you for that all right agenda item um 11.0 our student report so we'll turn this over to Grace and Abby so at the middle school during the month of January um middle schoolers were introduced to the mood meter um which is a tool used to identify how students are feeling in a given moment and how that affects them emotionally they practiced identifying their emotional reactions to music and they created a favorite playlist of songs and then grouped the songs based on how the song made them feel and then at the high school um the National Honor Society sponsored a candy gram Drive right before vacation um students and teachers were able to purchase small bags of candy and write special messages to other students or teachers

103which were then delivered by NHS members um we raised $175 which was donated to the Toys for TOS program um last week at Pleasant Hill volunteers from Unum coordinated by Junior Achievement came to teach second graders about our community students learned about government business and the roles and responsibilities of citizens it was a wonderful day of learning complete with engaging donut shop pza making and voting simulations and at blueo there was an hour of code event the hour of code was held in hopes of creating excitement and a basic understanding of coding within computer science awesome thank you both so much um very good job with the Toys for Tots that's really awesome that's exciting any questions for you there all right we're gonna Circle back to you in just a little bit um all

104right agenda item 12.0 is general public comment so I want to um set the stage a little for this evening um I know we have a lot of people here interested in talking the first um one uh General public comment is is for people who are interested in making comment for something that is not on the agenda so is there anybody here interested in making general public comment and would you mind checking the online if you're online and you're interested in making general public comment you can raise your your um hand and by raising your hand I mean your online Zoom hand uh if you want to come up yeah generally we we don't answer questions but let me hear Let me see if we can do it um so for the workshop regarding like

105the like k through eight schooling is that considered on this agenda item and if I wish to speak about that is that separate time to whatever else is on the agenda um that would actually be now so if you want to speak to the workshop now would be a great time and do I still get my time at okay yes yes it's per it's per so um yeah you're per per topic so this is going to be for anything not on our meeting agenda so your perfect timing um I am going to start a timer I'm going to hope it works so you see the three little this is for everyone's education actually I'll say it one time there's a three um colored dots in front of you uh green means you're good within your

106three minutes when you get to the yellow it means you have um I believe it's 10 or 15 seconds left um somewhere roughly in that range and then when you see the red flashing that means your 3 minutes is okay all right all right so if you just want to tell us your name really quickly okay hello my name is Alex W I'm a scarber high school senior I'm going to keep it brief because I know a lot of people are here for the phone policy um I've had like over 400 hours in volunteering with the Leal woman voters main students vote uh main citizens for clean elections uh my other job other than being a student is volunteering for civic engagement work and I've heard discussions regarding wanting to engage the community further seeing

107as referendum last year was difficult and did not have a lot of community understand in so what I'd like to offer is and this is something I can't offer for the next year but I can offer for these coming months as I will be graduating uh if people are interested in having student Outreach specifically to the high school and middle schools as far as Civic engagement goes showing up to community Forum events I'd love to do that through civil rights Club of which I am a co-president um I'd also like to make recommendations which I can bring up next week at the Forum regarding the accessibility in information uh with Civic engagement last year's referendum question for the Statewide elections had um or actually two years ago now sorry for 2023 at like eight different

108referendums and we see that as there's more and more choices of Voters to be made there is less and less engagement for each following one so I'd like to encourage whatever the team is doing there to reduce that to three or four options at most uh and then infographics really help a lot as well for civic engagement and that's all I have to say thank you thank you Jillian I think you got you get that for Jillian is our um liaison for the communic ation committee so for the for the um building committee so you can pass that on Perfect all right is there anyone else wishing to make General Public comment all right see none I will close um agenda item 13.0 is new business 13.1 is the Scarboro Wentworth school presentations for this

109we'll invite Kelly we're so excited to see that we were on the agenda with the cell phones because we knew we would get a great crowd and um we're really happy to be here and have this opportunity I'm Kelly Crosby I'm the principal at Wentworth school and I'm joined by Gabrielle perer she is our assistant principal and we're very grateful for this chance to kind of brag on our school for a little while and we've also noticed that you haven't had a chance to eat dinner and the camera is going to be on us so please enjoy your dinner sit back relax get comfortable sorry everybody who's here we've got a few things to share about Wentworth so um Ray if you could go to the next slide please alrighty so I am not going

110to read our Scarboro Public Schools Mission verbatim but I really want to kind of set the stage and emphasize how at Wentworth we're super intentional about aligning our actions and our priorities to that mission um and you know with that being said we really strive to oh time we're out of time John we really strive to model resiliency um and meaningfully teach the essential skills that are required to productively contribute to our school community and Beyond and we also really strive to cultivate that Curiosity that supports this notion of lifelong learning and we're going to kind of touch upon those things as we move through this presentation you skipped one there we go okay so we really give a lot of thought to what we were going to share this evening and what makes a

111high performing school and we feel like we have a lot of opportunities to share about our um you know test scores and proficiency I mean I did include those on there because they are impressive and you know our our students are outperforming at the state and District level and we're really proud of our Proficiency in both reading and in math and our a scores and our top rankings is um we're the number 11 Elementary School in the state of Maine that's out of uh 324 so it's like the top 2% so we're very proud of all of that but that's not what we're going to actually focus on today we're going to focus on some of the more intangible pieces that make Wentworth a really special school and we're sort of wrapping that into some

112Communications that we got early in this school year and so in 2021 Wentworth and I think the rest of the schools in the state of Maine were placed on this like tiered additional targeted support plan through um the Essa every student succeeds act um and we were placed on that tier for support because our students who were struggling with attendance so students who had like chronic absenteeism were not making adequate Pro ress let that sink in for a moment but that was why we were placed on this tiered support because students who were not attending school weren't making progress but in 2021 we still had massive quarantine requirements and kids were being placed out of school for um covid and covid like symptoms and close contacts and all of those things in 2024 just this

113fall I received this communication that we actually are no longer on that list that we Ed that tiered status and um according to Katie vitro our curriculum director she says that just rarely ever happens so we feel really proud about that um because as it says in this email all of our none of our student populations experienced challenges across any of the identified State indicators which is really something to be proud about so as a result of that somebody from this Coalition for attendance um count me and reached out and said through a public data request Quest like I'm blown away by this progress and your absenteeism rates what have you done I'd really like to talk to you about it and we had a conversation and talked a lot about you know we put

114a lot of systems in place as a district Communications monitoring looking at our data but really what we talked a lot about was making sure that we made School a place where students just really want to be and so that's what we're going to focus our presentation on what we do at Wentworth that makes it a school where kids want to want to be and we set out purposefully every single day to make sure it's a place that um every day matters and that we recognize that our students they're eight and nine and 10 and 11 years old they're children and childhood is fleeting and should be joyful and I just want to add as someone who's new to the Wentworth Community like that's really palpable like you can step in and just feel the

115energy shift and it's something that is quite unprecedented and I think speaks to a lot of the work and effort from not only leadership but also from our staff and community members so Shameless plug thank you everybody for that um and so with that being said I kind of want to transition us from the more like traditional conversational topics we have in meetings such as this our foundational commitments and have that segue into the concept of cultivating joy in a learning community and so as Kelly alluded to we do have a history of strong academic outcomes for for our Wentworth students which we believe is like largely attributed to a number of foundational commitments that I've enumerated in the little graphic so we have our student support systems SST and students of concern where we

116collaborate with like really um high impact stakeholders to talk about students and ongoing challenges they might be experiencing and how we can remove barriers or provide really meaningful supports to elevate their experience at school we have our classroom teachers and other um instructional staff who provide really high quality tier one instruction which we're super appreciative of um and of course that informs our students educational outcomes we also have our ruler implementation which Kelly's going to speak to in Greater depth later as well as a strong focus on social emotional learning and targeting the whole child providing a real um encompassing support um we also focus a lot on building capacity across staff really providing thorough PD that aligns to not only their needs but the needs that our students are reflecting and then that fifth

117commitment which is cultivating care and community and we really believe firmly at Wentworth that it's a symbiotic relationship advancing the learning and advancing the joy and um we pride ourselves in being really thoughtful about creating opportunities to cultivate that Joy contentment and community at onew worth so in the next slide I'm going to talk a little bit more about what Gabrielle began which is our ruler implementation and so you our our mission is welcoming and inclusive schools in a nutshell and for many years we've had the respect code at Wentworth and that's our framework and it's been successful for a really long time it's all about um explicit instruction on expected behavior um teaching pro-social um interactions however post pandemic um we were pretty anecdotally recognizing a shift in students ability to consistently demonstrate expected

118behavior um um and teachers were really consistently expressing those concerns around um students ability to regulate their emotions and so we set a course to um examine our data we used our Panorama survey data and uh figure out what was going on and do something about it and so we discovered through our Panorama survey data that while we had a really significant strength in relationships there was a gap in students abilities to um regulate their own emotions and self-efficacy and growth mindset so we selected a an seal um resource called ruler it comes from the Yale Center for emotional intelligence and we built an implementation team which you see the original part of the original implementation team on the top left here and we leveraged our Wednesday early release days that professional development time and

119we transition from the traditional PLT model to a more building-wide focus and we were all hands on deck learning about ruler learning about this seal implementation and um focusing on the adult aspect ofal so that the adults could gain those skills first before turn keying that knowledge for our students we used all of the tools on the right hand side of that slide you'll see our staff-wide Charter so this was a ruler signature tool to develop a charter um that's the charter that our staff created together and we worked hard to build a scope in sequence that everybody was committed to everybody contributed to for this school year we spent the whole year last year preparing for this year to do this work with kids always you know we were really on board with it

120everybody was excited about it but always the question in school is great yes we're on board but like when and how are we going to do this and what is it going to be in place of and so from that challenge um Community day was born and this year um Community Day has just been such a wild success it has been an absolute blast um I'm going to talk about it a little bit more on the next slide um Ray if you want to advance to that one so Community Day takes place on every single early release day and we have a completely different schedule on community day and it's a grade level schedule so for those of you who who are familiar with the organizational setup at Wentworth school we have vertical teams so

121third fourth and fifth graders together and they kind of travel throughout their day together on community day it's grade level team so they have lunch and recess and their Allied Arts with all of their grade level peers so you guys will remember you didn't have that opportunity much it went worth it was kind of a missing piece and so this has um met that need and so so much more so on every Community Day we begin all together in a whole school assembly and whatever the focus of the month is is kicked off so in the top leftand Corner you'll see that's all of our seven almost 700 precious little children sitting there at attention like really focused super expected behavior um and rolling out the mood meter which they talked about in the student

122report to our school and then following the whole school assembly there is a block of time that there's theal lesson you saw from the map earlier in the classroom every student in the school is experiencing the same learning just kind of adjusted for age um and there's an opportunity for Community time in addition to like I said grade level lunch and their Allied arts class each day so Community time has really developed into something super special we knew that we were going to be thrilled with this opportunity to really wholes scale Implement theal lessons and the signature tools but Community time has evolved into something so amazing and so we shared some highlights from just this week like Wednesday um at the end of our whole school assembly we had um a Native American drumming

123band called The I'm gonna do my very best here I have to look at the word Berna B sorry drummers they um represent so many um parts of the Native American community and they came and did a presentation and brought their daughter who was a third grader to do some um traditional dance and then one of our students who also has Native American culture and background joined her um if you click Ray on that little box up above yep that one there's a quick little video of that [Music] so please note how like wonderful our audience is of eight n and 10 year olds and also that the little girl who came with the group she's a third grader and she goes to to a teeny teeny tiny school on Indian Island and she was

124just blown away by our school and so she ended up participating in the entire day our kids just scooped her right up she went to gym class she went to lunch in recess with them she had the best day ever um so that was really awesome and just speaks to kind of the inclusive culture and like just kindness and heart of our kids it was just awesome um so after the whole school assembly the fifth graders had an additional um additional presentation by the drumming group while the fourth graders participated in Junior Achievement also connected to the Pleasant Hill um student report so volunteers came in and the pictures uh bottom middle and bottom right our fourth graders participating in Junior Achievement and they really customized the lesson for us and made it connected to

125our classroom CH Charters so um volunteers from the community came in and talked about how in their professional life um the charter the work of the charter really connects to even right through adulthood and so it was really awesome special connected made sense and then our third graders not to be left out actually had a presentation by two fabulous Scarboro high school students um Ali and Fiona came they are super passionate about sustainability so they came to teach our third graders about recycling um they first came and presented to me me I was blown away had them present to our leadership team they were blown away those two girls Scaro High School seniors came and presented to our entire faculty so a hundred teachers and then we we're bringing them back for the whole school

126they did such a great job if you click the little Earth on the bottom left it's a video of their original song Dropping on Spotify yes two one paper plastic [Music] you guys like the entire presentation was like very interactive there was s singing dancing so much engagement so um as you can see that's just a snapshot from this week's Community day and we do this every month amazing um Gabrielle's going to talk a little bit more about the classroom Charters that I alluded to because it's really we find it really guiding the work um across our school yeah I think you know Kelly mentioned earlier to the respect code and that really served as one of our primary reference points when we were supporting students as they were navigating some like socially nuanced circumstances

127or complex challenges at school and now I feel like we also have this classroom Charter which is really supportive of that work too so through ruler we emphasize the power of this Charter and this Collective agency to identify how we want to feel in our space and so every classroom put their heads together and they collaborated and identified some really powerful feeling words um such as confident creative respected strong loved and they not only identified these words that they want to feel and embrace every day at school and support their peers doing so but they also identified their Pathway to get there so what are those expectations how are we going to conduct ourselves so that we can Safeguard these feelings each other and it's really quite powerful and we see all these charters in

128the classrooms front and center on the bulletin board or on the the Whiteboard by the projector and it's really clear that it's become like the fabric of their classroom communities go to the next slide um this was the culmination of one of our uh spirit weeks yeah so I don't know if people can put their thinking hats on and reflect back to when they were in school and the week before winter vacation kind of is like frenetic energy and everyone's kind of just in the fields ready to go home do all the fun things with their family take a break from school and so we're like what better way to kind of ease that little energy and tension by cultivating a sense of calm and so we kind of put our heads together and try

129to think of how can we do this meaningfully and connect it to some broader values and we thought of Huga which if you're not familiar Huga is this Danish concept of contentment and joy and gratitude and we felt that aligned really nicely to some of our work with ruler as well um and so we brought it to our students at our December Community day and we played them a little video to get them hooked from Frozen sold Game Changer they were like ready to go they embraced it they were pumped they like oh thank you for coming up with this idea um and so we worked together within our ruler team and then also Kelly and I did some like conversation as well to think about how we can take this concept and put it

130into a spirit week and so we created a week of activities for students to engage in that focused on these Core Concepts of Joy contentment gratitude coziness and so some of the activities included like reading by a virtual fireplace um or um hot cocoa for students or writing um strips of on strips of paper like just something you're thankful for at onew worth in creating gratitude chains for a front entrance um just a lot of small things that bring those warm fuzzy feelings to our students but also really kind of ensure that we were having a peaceful um content transition into our winter vacation best week before break ever awesome yeah ever great and so here was the grand finale every I'm going to talk a little bit about the announcements on the next slide

131but there's a theme for each day on the morning announcements at Wentworth and on Friday we start the day with the dance party and it's the Friday jam and on the Thursday before I dropped into I was just kind of visiting some after school clubs which you're also going to hear about you guys didn't know you were just really in for this but thanks for hanging with us um and so the Thursday before I dropped into chorus club and they were singing this song and it means grant us peace in Latin and so I impulsively without talking to the adviser at all like you guys should be our Friday Jam tomorrow morning just and she was like what how how are we G and I was like just anybody who wants to just show up

132at the office and we'll do a live Friday jam and it'll be awesome and so I thought maybe like a few kids would show up and we'd figure something out because typically I just play a song off my cell phone into the microphone um for the announcements but um in this video clip you'll see how many of these little just cherubs showed up and sang this song that means grant us peace in Latin and it was like the sweetest end to our Huga so if you want to play that clip [Music] and I'm definitely crying in at the end of that because it was so cute and pure and I'm also wearing a snuggie um because it was pjj um but I just felt like that right there just sort of represents there's so much

133negativity about behavior in school and not everybody feels that way and not every school feels that way and that was just a really great representation of just like the joy and beauty that comes in public elementary schools every day or at least at Wentworth and so on the next slide um I mention that every day this is something that we really purposefully do to stay connected we're a large school um in four different learning communities so every morning we come together as one big school um with the daily morning announcements and it's not just the typical like oh it's this day of the week and let's do the Pledge of Allegiance but each day has a theme um and I mentioned about the Friday Jam but we have an accompanying slide deck that's projected in

134every classroom um and so we're really purposeful about coming together and we really highlight all of our students um diverse and unique strengths so each day there are at least two or three students who are sharing a greeting and the word or phrase of the day in their native language um we have a slide deck for Thursdays which are called thoughtful Thursday you can see one of them um students came because the theme this year is what you're proud of or what you're grateful for connected to ruler um and so in the first Thursday of December a couple of kids from Mrs Sullivan's class came down and shared that they were proud and grateful for their class Charter if you click on that link you will hear their wrap that they did about their class

135Charter accepted respected empowered included Charter is cool so cute it's just um joyful wonderful things like that what they bring to you is just you you can't you can't script it um this week a couple of students talked about why we have no school on Monday and the history behind Martin Luther King Jr and um how that connects to our ruler work uh twice monthly we have a bilingual breakfast as part of the morning part of um school and that's hosted by our multi lingual teacher and our world language teacher and they have a theme every time uh recently they talked about what's on your plate and it was all of our students I wrote down how many slides there were something like a 90 slide slide yeah 90 slides featuring each of our bilingual

136students and their Country Connection and what breakfast looks like in that country so they just do a different theme each time to just celebrate all of those um wonderful differences so those are some of the ways that we show our best selves starting in the morning and really purposefully throughout the day perfect thank you so we also really encourage the same concept of connectivity engagement and fun after school hours and WW worth is is really well situated to provide a whole host of offerings for our students to really connect to their interests and to also facilitate continued opportunities to engage with their peers and we just have an incredible system of clubs that I feel like we could just Rave and go on and on for I think Kelly Compares Club signups to what Taylor

137Swift concerts tickets trying to get tickets to the Taylor Swift concert we don't mean for it to be that way but it is yeah it's certainly intense but I mean c also rewarding simultaneously we have so many offerings I'll just name a few Lego Club chess club speed cubing coating fiber art so something that appeals to like a diverse array of interest and students and um most of our clubs have completely filled in spots have a weight list we're always having conversations about how we can expand our offerings so that students can um be kind of guaranteed these experiences which I actually believe they are this year right like everyone there's enough yeah slots for every student to participate in one Club um but a lot of kids sign up for more than one yeah

138which I can't blame them it's a great opportunity and so I think that we're only going to continue to grow this initiative and we're super appreciative for our club advisers and for Molly brenman who's kind of coordinating and doing a lot of the heavy lifting in this work oops there we go okay and so we really couldn't do all of this work without the community support and involvement that we are so fortunate to have um and we do want to thank the school board for continuing to support our bio appointment days that begin um our school year that way I feel like those By Appointment days just set the tone for engagement it sets the tone for like we are working together to support your child on this journey through Wentworth um and those examples

139just continue throughout the year of how our community shows up um in our school and really at everything that we ask for from just PT like our parent teach organization requesting donations to support a staff lunch in done um I put out on the top leftand side we had some signs in need of repair like they have the uh expectations for playground equipment they were in need of repair I put out a photo in our weekly um family news hey is anybody handy do you want to fix this and that's a picture of Parker one of our fourth graders um and he and his dad have like revamped all of them um um we have a quadre of volunteers who when they come for their kids activities they just are on rotation to organize our

140ridiculously always overflowing lost and found um Public Service Announcement please label your child's clothing Wentworth parents but they just come in and take care of that um bottom left is a connection with um wmtw we were at school at 5 a.m. doing weather at our school um and then in the middle and on the bottom right this is a really special one I recently accompanied um two classrooms who walk did a walking field trip up to the hardware store to deliver thank you cards because um Ace donated the paint for our students during Community time to repaint the map of the United States that you see on the bottom right hand side um and give that a little J on our playground and they walked up and they gave the um cards and apparently we

141really like to sing at Wentworth because they s ated them with the 50 Nifty United States song and it was just so cute and the the owners smiles were just ear to ear so really special and I feel like these connections to use Gabrielle's word from earlier are really symbiotic um and I feel like have just made Wentworth just one of the crown jewels of our community and ultimate excuse me ultimately it all goes back to supporting student achievement and so so we're at our last slide one more there we go okay um so again we could have shared with you about like guaranteed inviable curriculum test scores all of the academic pieces all of that is very solidly in place and I feel like we have a lot of opportunities to speak to that

142um but we wanted to take this path because um we expect a lot of these little babies at went wereth school we really do and nothing is a reminder of how little they really are until you have them come to school in their PJs and you just see like they are really little in their little footsy jams um and we recognize that childhood is fleeting and that Wentworth is purposefully joyful and it's a purposefully joyful learning environment for students and that joy in kids be gets joy in staff and it's just um all flows together and so we will um continue leading with heart because we believe that schools are just this really sacred place not because of the beautiful building though that helps because then you have space to learn and grow and do

143all of these wonderful things um but because of the people who are in the buildings and um there's just this really wonderful Synergy among our school Community this year in a climate that we are really incredibly proud of so thank you for this opportunity to share and thanks for sharing in our joy and thanks for hanging in there with us everybody thank you thanks do we do questions or not yeah is there any questions or comments for Kelly um I have comments oh sure thank you that was wonderful I love presentations for you guys um I wanted to just tell you that how much I appreciate the unstructuredness of some of these moments like your Friday jam and was the rap that the kids were doing um I think it's really important that even though

144there's a lot of structure during the day those unstructured moments are the ones that they're going to leave with and they're they're always going to remember those um and that's what's really meaningful in this kind of setting um because it's a lot it's a lot to control self-regulate when you don't have those opportunities to be unstructured um but I do have a question sure so with self-regulating in school I imagine there might be some difficulty with self-regulating at home not always but sometimes are there family resources that our families can access this ruler stuff I'm so glad you asked Jenna um in our weekly email um you could even look at the one this week there is a family connection resource to whatever our signature tool of the month is and so this month it's

145a focus on um like a little bit more information about our classroom Charters and how you could build a family Charter at home so there are um connected student Family Home Connection resources yeah thank you did you have something well I want to I'm gonna get the name of it wrong I think but I want to say congratulations for getting taken off that list the S Essa yes congratulations thank you um I just love the environment you've kind of made for these kids um they are still so little and it's easy to forget and I love that you've kind of made an environment where they have very high expectations and that's great and they're learning and all of those things but it also can be an environment where um it's not just educationally that they're

146growing so congratulations and thank you yeah go ahead thank you so much for everything you do every day for our kids um I love the fact that our schools are thriving I think first things first we're here to make sure that their academics are strong and kids are getting what they need so that they can be successful later in life um and we do get a lot of that here and it's something that's really important for us to keep our eyes on I am so happy though to see you go behind that and talk about the joy that you bring to our kids every day and how that Joy connects directly to their academic progress that if we want if kids want to be there and they're they're um nurtured there um that they're able

147to do what they need to do to gain access access to their to their academics and therefore Thrive um I also really want to say thank you for your celebration of all the different cultures and how you're able to elevate the differences in a way that's not divisive or separate but in a way that celebrates each individual child's unique um self and supporting that as something special because that is so important thank you thank you you thank you P anything else um I will just also say thank you very much um this was an amazing presentation so thank you um I I don't think it's a big secret I'm a huge lover of emotional intelligence I believe very much in it I I um I I find a lot of value in it and what's

148what I find a lot of value in particularly is that when you create an environment where people feel like they um can build confidence they can identify their emotions and they can lead from a place of high emotional intelligence that actually translates to um improve performance right so we know that in the business world but what's fascinating is that you're finding that in the kids world too right so the more you can create an environment where they are confident and they feel respected and they feel valued that engages them and wants them it makes them want to perform and want to succeed and want to do better and so it's no surprise to me that by increasing their um essentially emotional intelligence that's what I refer tocl as you're actually increasing your grades in your

149academics and you're able to come off of tier support as well so they go hand inand and they um it's really important that we recognize that so thank you and thank you for all you do this is really incredible you should be really proud well you're all invited any early release day if you want to come down and experience Community Day we start at 8:30 and the fun rolls on right till 1:45 and it's a really really special day so come join us thank you thank you all right okay um agenda item 13.2 is the first reading of policy JFK student use of privately owned electronic devices at school so before I turn this over to frea um I I just uh want to review where we've been and where we're going so that everybody

150is working from the same set of information um the policy any like generally speaking any policy process starts with the policy committee so when frla gave the policy committee update she mentioned that we're um we're looking back at Old policies and we are um we we've moved right through the bees almost almost through the bees um so that that's our process and so what happens is the policy committee which is fra myself and Julian we review policies the existing policies we review model policies we think of determine if any changes need to be made we discuss those changes um we write a recommended draft and then it comes to the full board for consideration so with these our current policies JFK and jfcr we started that process in June this policy impacts so many within

151our community I think we have had upwards of I don't know 300 emails we've received possibly I am looking at one um petition in front of me that is parents and teachers it is 240 signatures and I am looking at a student and teacher um petition that is 384 signatures um so that's on top of the letters we've received that's on top of the public comment we've received at every single policy meeting we've had since June that's on top of um phone calls that board members have received that is on top of other communication so um I think as a whole as I mentioned earlier when I was thanking everybody for our special meeting we recognize that this really really impacts a lot of people our goal as a policy Comm committee has always been

152to make thoughtful decisions to take our time and to do things in a way where we can bring forward the very best recommendation for this board to consider and when I say very best recommendation I mean a recommendation that works for our students that works for our parents and that works for our staff um so it takes us time we've never shied away from that um and that's that's why it's it's you know here we are in January just just bringing it Forward um so we held this special meeting we did receive a lot of feedback so um we have been intentionally intentional about that special meeting we placed it where we did because we wanted to have a draft policy but we wanted to hear from the community before we held this meeting and

153so um we asked people to come and they came I think we had about 50 people at that meeting um and it was really a really like I said a really really good opportunity to provide feedback so tonight what is in front of us is the first reading of the draft um we are going to go we're going to hear from fra we'll hear about the what changed and then from there um this is the boards and Public's opportunity to hear those changes for the first time it's also the board's opportunity to provide suggested changes that they want to see to the draft um it is time to hear from you and then it will go back to the policy committee for consideration so when the board votes on this a yes vote does not

154mean they are voting yes for the draft policy a yes vote means they are voting to push this to a second reading so I want to be very clear about this this is not the end all Beall this is our first reading the policy committee will then meet on um February 4th that was the time we heard earlier um it'll be here in town council chambers and that is the opportunity where the PO policy committee are going to consider the discussion tonight the recommendations from the board tonight all of the comments we've heard the petitions the the emails everything we've C we've heard and make any necessary adjustments at that time and then um as it stands on February 27th which is our uh regularly scheduled board meeting that's when it this policy will go

155to Second reading so at second reading any of the changes the policy committee has made will come forward in a new draft at that time after second reading if it is voted a yes vote at second reading would me by a board member would mean yes I support the policy as it's written and then it would move forward from there it would become our policy our district-wide policy at that time all right so on that note would you mind providing the update I would be happy to um this is the biggest like not reveal policy moment in my committee chairship since we released a draft ahead of time and we've debated it um not not amongst ourselves but at the last meeting we really heard a lot about it um it's I don't believe we've

156had that much preparation for any policy um since I've started um so the changes uh we've taken two separate policies jfcr and JFK combine them back into one um the reason we did that is because typically if you have two policies like that the first policy is the policy and the second policy is a procedure that is to be followed in order to kind of inact or implement the original policy jfcr is not a procedure it's a policy and so it didn't make sense to have two separate documents that put the policy out um and so we don't we don't have enough institutional memory to know why that decision was made or when that decision was made but um we did make a decision that when we put draft forward we were going to make

157one policy and one document so that was that's the biggest most obvious change um within the draft policy itself um it's fairly similar to the old policy but there are some important changes um first of all it has um it it it refers to privately owned electronic devices at schools um and indicates this is applicable to cellular telephones and other electronic devices um it talks about that between in case through eight all of these devices have to be turned off and stored um and cannot be used during school hours um it the first paragraph carves out the high school for an exception which permits that the devices to be used during passing periods only and no other school time um and then it indicates that you know the devices are should be used in a

158manner that doesn't disrupt the activities of others um there's some specific um Provisions regarding um electronic devices that include cameras videos or sound recording functions um it talks about how that's strictly prohibited in locker rooms restrooms buses classrooms and other school locations um there's permission required to be uh you have to get consent before taking any sort of recording of others that's not a change from the other policy our other policy did very much the same thing um obviously uh this is the same that if any of the devices are used in a way that violates uh the board policy administrative procedure school rules um and then specifies what might be if it's illegal use for illegal means or bullying harassing discrimination um that's prohibited uh you can't use the devices to break any rules

159um the there's a provision that we've heard a little bit about that are concerning people having with privacy rights um it indicates that these devices may be searched if there is a reasonable suspicion that a student is violating by any board policy procedure school rules or engaging in misconduct um related to that device and then um it disciplinary action can be taken to enact the policy which is pretty typical that isn't a change um so it's it's a short it's a short policy it's one page um and then there's some references in it but that's that is the policy that has been put forward uh to be considered tonight and I'm looking forward to hearing what you have to say at the next section all right um so for the board are there any questions

160on the changes not discussion time but any questions all right hearing none is there anyone wishing to make public comment if so if you just want to line up um or if you want to stay seated and just take your time time that that work whatever you want to do is fine but Ray would you also mind monitoring the online if you are online and wishing to make public comment if you could in the bottom of your Zoom um menu there's a raise hand function if you could raise your hand um I'm going to start with the inside and then we'll monitor the the zoom and just yep we can go ahead and get started and I'll just provide one set of instructions for everyone I won't repeat myself over and over um there are

161I've already mentioned the lights to you um if you just as you come up if you could introduce yourself with your name that's that's sufficient um you will have three minutes to provide public comment please address your comments to me is the chair um and we will um get this started oh yeah thank you um for asked me to just explain really quickly that for public comment purposes it's not a dialogue it's not a back and forth um this this is our um business meeting so it's more us listening to you um taking notes if there is something to follow up on um we can certainly do that at a later at a later date all right all right all right thanks everybody uh my name is Kristen Vero and I'm gonna read um part

162of the letter that Shannon had mentioned um that several of us put together Following last week's meeting um and that was signed by 240 parents and concerned community members um if I run out of time Kristen Richie is going to finish the note for me dear school board members first thank you for taking the time to review this policy we understand it is a difficult process with lots of competing interests we the undersigned parents teachers and community members strongly support a policy to create a personal electronic device and social media free environment in scarbo schools this initiative prioritizes student learning Focus Social Development and emotional well-being the US faces a youth Mental Health crisis with evidence linking social media and digital products to increase distraction cyber bullying anxiety depression suicide and self harm among teens

163the US Surgeon General Dr VC Murthy has empath emphasized the need for a device-free space including schools stating the risk of not acting could be someone's life Scarboro public schools have shown their commitment to address suicidal ideation by using go Guardian technology but together we can do more to tackle the root causes of this crisis and better support our children the primary goal of school is to educate and to create a learning environment that is both Equitable and effective numerous studies show that Simply Having a phone nearby increases cognitive load and reduces attention as the anticipation of notifications pains and other distractions takes away from the focus of learning this this is a feeling that we all recognize even as adults research has made it abundantly clear that bell-to-bell personal device free policies improves the

164school environment by increasing academic engagement improving learning outcomes and students social connection with their peers devices including but not limited to cellular phones SmartWatches and other are other wearables and gaming devices distract from learning and interrupted opportunities for students to engage in face-to-face interaction with each other while we acknowledge that smartphones can provide benefit such as immediate access to information and quick communication with peers and parents many of these needs can be addressed through Alternatives that do not compromise our children's social emotional and academic development we heard the concerns raised during the round table discussion on January 9th it is understandable that students feel strongly and push back against the idea of not having their devices further despite the stated opposition to a ban one or many students shared they commonly observe peers abusing their

165devices using apps like Instagram or Tik Tok which is distracting to others are subject to inconsistent policies due to teacher discretion respond immediately to Power School notifications on their personal devices illustrating the distraction and compulsive nature of phone notifications and want to be trusted but lack the school or parent provided formal education on how to use devices appropriately thank you I'm gonna let Kristen finish okay hi I'm Kristen Richie I'm a parent of two children in the school system okay students May May support maintaining access to their devices but share concerns on issues that the proposed policy is designed to address as adults it is our responsibility to prioritize evidence over emotion and make decisions in their best interest Guided by peer review data from reliable sources teachers also shared their views at the round

166table with many highlighting effective strategies for managing phones While others expressed a preference for having devices left at home additionally teachers highlighted that the current policy update which introduces a device-free lunch at the high school is difficult to enforce to address these challenges we advocate for the following one personal electronic device free school days from the first Bell to the last bell where devices are turned off securely locked away and inaccessible to students during the school hours while under the supervision of an employee of the school district for a school related program examples of storage devices include phone specific lockers pencil pouches or manila envelopes stored in a secure location and lockable pouches that students cannot unlock policy may allow use of personal laptops and calculators if necessary for educational purposes we acknowledge that technology

167evolves rapidly and not all scenarios may be captured or known so regular communication is essential to discuss progress and make necessary adjustments two exceptions should be made for children with documented medical needs or special educational plans requiring personal device use along with the transition period to allow parents and administrators to adjust before the policy is implemented three a Prohibition on using social media platforms for school to student communication including school-based Communications such as those for athletic teams after school activities and Career and Technical education we recognize that this change requires a cultural shift if a compromise is necessary we would support implementing a full rollout for the 2026 to 2027 school year the policy is vital for enhancing academic engagement learning outcomes and pure social connections if the board decides against a device in social

168media free policy we respectfully request access to the data supporting that position thank you for your dedication to this isue thank you both of you hi hi I am a junior I'm Henry I'm a junior at the high school and thank you for giving us all this opportunity to speak I'm here on behalf of the 384 students and some teachers who signed this petition opposing the current draft JFK and this has been emailed to the board um the propos proposed policy Banning the use of personal electronic devices at Scaro Public Schools introduces numerous logistical challenges undermines students educational opportunities restricts the choice of teachers and creates unnecessary conflict between students staff and administrators the ban on all personal devices extends Beyond phones to include devices like laptops and calculators this is unfeasible as the school

169cannot provide calculators for all students and many Advanced courses require personal devices for essential learning tools like programming software student in addition students applying to colleges need to use personal devices to log into portals and their applications with a personal email address which cannot be done on school managed devices most classrooms already manage phone use effectively there's already a policy in place that the teachers and administrators have said works well the new policy completely removes their discretion on use of personal electronics the decision to give a child a personal electronic device and how to manage it use should remain a personal choice for each family Guided by their own values and understanding of their child's maturity rather than being dictated by Schoolboard policies as families already have the tools and power to implement restrictions and

170monitor usage effectively study halls or invaluable time for students to catch up on schoolwork and other activities and many students may need to use a personal device to do this lunchtime supervision is already stretched thin with only two or three staff members managing hundreds of students and enforcing this policy would require significantly more staff Mak it impractical and it should be left to teacher discretion on whether a student uses one of these devices and parent discretion on whether student owns one of these devices and what they can do on said device the usage of these devices should not just be the school board's decision as a blanket ban harmens more than it does good thank you thank you Sor I'm just pulling it up um am I good yeah just with can you tell us

171your name first oh yeah um hi my name is Kaye q and I'm a senior at Scaro High School um in response to the new policy draft I would like to ask the board to consider um adding teacher discretion back into the policy and also providing more provisions and exceptions for personal personally owned electronic devices um the reason I do not want to complete phone ban at the high school level is because data from schools around the world shows mixed results regarding its Effectiveness for instance a British study um that tracked surveys regarding phone bans SL uh usages from 2001 to 2013 found that yes phone banss could be an effective way to increase student performance at the same time a Swedish study published in 2020 found no impact on mobile um phone bands in

172school and even dismiss their small size gains as a result their policy advice was that while introducing a mobile phone ban is tempting due to its lowcost nature such a ban should not be expected to produce substantial gains in student performance additionally the United Nations educational scientific and cultural organization recently released a report that did have finding ings on how phones as well as other technological devices can be distractions which hinder student engagement however at the same time the report doesn't actually advocate for total phone band instead it advises that schools develop curriculum that teaches students the risks and opportunities smartphones provide and encourages them to navigate the digital world effectively um so basically there are a multitude of factors that influence these studies including cultural ones as seen with like Swedish um Sweden and

173Britain and Al there's the pandemic that influences how students are behaving in schools as of right now but there isn't actually conclusive evidence which says that a strict phone uh ban policy is the most effective and so I think that having a blanket phone policy oversimplifies the issue and kind of feels disingenuous to us students um currently I don't see a lot of people advocating for Solutions which address the root causes of student engagement issues and Tech technology issues that they have um it's hard to see this kind of support and people coming out advocating for a better curriculum that um addresses device management or different teaching styles which keep students engaged and also um how to make resources more available to students who are neurod Divergent and have attention issues and phones just exacerbate

174that um and it kind of feels patronizing to us as students that we are being told that this is for our protection um when in reality we already understand the negative consequences of smart device usage but also get to experience their academic benefits every day which many adults keep dismissing um there's a generational disconnect happening here because it is silly to us that while us students face bigger issues um like environmental Devastation and gun violence parents seem the most focused on a piece of technology that grants most of us students information from all over the globe um right at the tips of our fingers that's thank you um hello my name is magdalina goal shop and I'm a sophomore at scar high school there are a few things that I've been thinking about that I

175just wanted to let everybody ruminate on the search and seizure clause in the draft lets there be with reasonable evidence searching and seasoning of a student's phones I have many conflictions with this and this is something that I would like to see revised when going over the draft other than that if us using phones is so problematic why don't we have more digital digital literacy and media classes to teach us how to use them properly if adults are expecting us to be able to go off without them and become adults we need to be taught how to use the technology that is by no means going away us as students are here to learn from adults and our parents so in t tandem with this phone policy I would like to see more proper tools

176to help us with that teacher discretion and Trust has between students and Educators has always worked in my experience and I think that that is the way right now that it should stay trust and respect from teachers and students makes the difference and putting this current draft into action would break some of that trust that we've been building at Scaro schools a closing question I have to end with for people to think about is that I've heard many people say that there are ways to get in quick contact with parents and I'd like to know what those ways are how can students not how can students get in contact with parents if not by calling or texting that's all I have thank you hi um I'm Jenny jubilus I'm a parent in the district um

177and so as a pediatrician um as well as a parent of us soon Tobe high schooler um I really appreciate the thoughtful emphasis that the school board has taken I know it's taken a long time and many many hours and I really do appreciate that this this draft that you have put forward I feel that it's evidence-based and in the best interest of all of our students um I am um I'm very much in support of this draft policy when I look at what the school board's mission is you know this is not a judgment on what choices we make within our own families this is a way of establishing the most effective learning environment for as many students as we possibly can and to do that we need to really look at the evidence

178um when we look at the evidence in pediatric medicine we we grade it um and we grade it on the basis of how well supported It Is by peer reviewed published literature that is generalizable to our settings so for example the Sweden study that was referenced one of the things that the American Academy of Pediatrics has acknowledged is that yes that study exists but Sweden already used um a lot of electronics in their classrooms be prior to that studying being published and so the difference wasn't as noticeable as it might be in other settings multiple peer-reviewed published Studies have shown that smartphone use and specifically social media use are associated with increased risks of anxiety and depression and a myriad of other mental health issues and that's particularly true for teen girls but also for

179boys cyber bullying is very real and I cannot say enough how grateful I am that the middle school has gone has really gone cell phone free this year um it's there have been so many times that I've been so glad that there it's a it's a safe space for these kids um there are studies in Spain and in Norway that um describe a very significant decrease in bullying after implementing a personal use ban of cell phones in schools and then there was a qualitative study in New Zealand that assessed the impact of cell phone restriction during school hours and they did this retroactively so after the ban was was put into place and they found that Educators and students actually agreed that the students um spent more time engaging in face-to-face interactions and they had

180much more positive influence on their mental effect after the cell phone restriction was in place um multiple school systems in Maine and nationally have successfully advocated for phone- free schools even through High School following peer review scientific data about what's best for our children and I'm really encouraging Scarboro to do the same continuing to follow the data rather than emotions scientists super important data show that students don't benefit from increased technology use in school in this in this fashion um and they actually may be harmed by it um and that's why I as a pediatrician support the draft policy I would again really encourage you to look at the fact that this is not 100% ban on cell phones all the time this is providing a safe space for our children to learn and as

181Shannon correctly stated if you provide them a safe space to learn where they feel safe they feel comfortable then the academics will follow thank you thank you how are we doing online right s can online hello I'm a parent of a junior at the high school and I'm concerned about the broad scope of the changes the board is making to JFK especially as it relates to the high school as currently written the board will enact bans and restrictions on the high school of all privately owned electronic devices that far exceeds those of neighboring high schools all high schools in the county but bath allow smartphone use during lunch and many allow it during study hall as well and all but bath allow for Teacher discretion during educational periods the current draft of jsck goes too

182far by removing allowances for lunchtime use and teacher permission at the high school according to the information collected by the board from the high school staff the majority of the staff wish to retain language about teacher discretion many suggest requiring phone trees in every classroom one of the teacher group reports quote phone trees should be mandatory for academic time and teacher discretion to allow usage for particular assignments or non-academic time and another says that quote phone trees work and teachers really like them those of us who use them find them very effective there is zero mention of phone trees or teacher discretion in the current revision of JFC and it is disappointing that the board appears to have requested input and decided to disregard it I urge the board to revisit the advice and request

183coming directly from the people at the high school who deal with these students in their devices the most additionally language in the draft as well as in the preceding policies is lacking in Clarity and specificity the high school teachers and students have requested you to provide clarity as well the board should seek to clarify and specify their policies and not continue to obfuscate and confuse I urge the board to fix this problem by using plain and specific language in the new policy State plainly and as specifically as possible what exactly exactly what devices you are Banning and how such bans will be implemented at each School today's high school students use electronic devices throughout their day to accomplish many diverse and important tasks they use these devices in ways inconceivable to a student from any

184previous generation today's technology is an inherent part of daily life for and for these students and expecting them to function as we all did during our youth is unreasonable thank you for your time thank you would you mind I'm sorry would you mind telling us your name just for the Amy Salo thank you so much just want how's your name really uh hello again my name is Alex woo I'm a high school senior uh may I begin yes okay so I'd like to start with some broad um recommendations that I believe are good regardless of somebody's position on the ban um I believe that this policy is for electronic devices as a whole but however I believe that instead of this it should enumerate uh other personal devices because it seems the intent of of

185uh regardless of whatever your position is to be a ban on cell phones but currently our policy is Broad and overreaching of all personal devices now currently um personal electronic devices that doesn't just include phones that also includes um personal computers calculators as we've heard before and a lot of other devices um we should enumerate these things specifically because there's a lot of academically um inclined devices such as calculators and laptops that uh are able to subsidize um classroom learning without the school having to pay for them and isn't able to pay for them because uh we don't have the necessary funding um without having to worry about that being paid for the school so I'd like to have specific Clauses naming phones and their bands and their restrictions as opposed to other personal devices

186that way we will help classroom environments be purposed for Learning and other things um I also believe in I APS and multi-tiered student support um again there should be exceptions for these for personal devices aside from just phones uh I've heard of smart watches and other things that are vital to things that our school psychiatrists don't currently have the resources to use under our overarching phone ban and just personal advice ban they can't be helping neurod divent and other disabled students with these devices because of the broad scope of our current uh policy um I want to sort of emphasize that bit about personal devices subsidizing things that the uh school system can't right now our Chromebooks are quite poor um for the last three laying classes that I've had um I take AP laying

187um we've been trying to take a test and because of the nature of our Chromebooks we have not been able to take them that is three wasted educational periods that we were not able to do anything effectively in because we were trying to do technological things um had we had personal devices and a lot of people who were able to use personal devices they were able to access college board and other things effectively so that also happens for cahoot where people don't have their Chromebooks working and because they have personal devices they're still able to engage in the classroom environment effectively um again it should be enumerated specifically what cell phones can be used for and other personal devices because those two things are very different if the policy team has time which I respect

188your time and I know there's other things um please amend this policy to include other personal device use that can be used regardless um I still advocate for personal cell phone usage and healthy responsible use and curriculum but all those other things I believe are important to whatever side thank you hello hi my name is l Lauren I'm a parent so I'm adding to the evidence-based discussion for not having cell phones um um but um I changed some of this wording in this write up to people from youth because I think it kind of it's all of us we're all kind of part of the problem but I think this is an excellent opportunity to create good habits so here goes um Dr Anna lmy a renowned psychiatrist and expert in addicted addiction medicine highlights

189the powerful role dopamine the brain's pleasure and reward chemical plays in addiction activities that trigger High dopamine surges such as excessive screen time social media use or gaming can rewire the brain's reward Pathways making it harder for individuals especially children and teens to experience pleasure from everyday activities this constant exposure to artificial dopamine spikes increases the risk of addiction like behaviors people create crave more stimulation to feel normal over time the brain compensates by reducing dopamine receptors leading to a state of dop dopamine deficit this deficit leaves people feeling irritable anxious or even depressed when they're not engaging in these high stimulation activities for youth this cycle creates a dangerous and people this cycle creates a dangerous feedback loop research shows has shown that such dopamine disregulation is linked to higher rates of impulsivity emotional

190disregulation and self Haring behaviors these behaviors often emerge as coping mechanisms for the distress caused by dopamine imbalances and the inability to tolerate discomfort or boredom Dr lmy emphasizes that mitigating these risks requires reducing access to addictive stimuli like constant phone use and teaching people how to find a balance through delayed gratification meaning connections and real world experiences by creating phone free environments in schools we hope to teach young people the risks of addiction and prevent its Downstream effects including self harm and Foster healthier more resilient communities so there's that but um so where I work we like to throw out wacky ideas and we kind of create a brainstorm so I'm like obviously I'm for the phone sit like moving away from phones in the high school and maybe there's a way that we

191can kind of embrace an opportunity for eighth graders going into ninth grade to Pioneer the change and like embrace it and then year over year there'll be more kids wanting to like obviously they'll have to because but anyways they're already not using phones let's like keep that going instead of letting them like obviously they already have phones they don't want to get rid of phones but maybe there's a way to have kins Embrace that that's all I don't know just an idea wacky idea thank you hi uh my name is Lauren Bornstein I'm an English teacher at the high school I was not planning on speaking so I've nothing written down but um my understanding is that this draft policy is not a phonefree environment it says that the students can use it during passing

192time so you know while these studies I think are very meaningful to the students um this phone policy is not guaranteeing that it is a phone-free environment and so um I'm quite nervous about the imple uh implementation of the policy so the students would have the phones on them because if they can use them during passing time that means they'd be in their backpacks so um someone mentioned earlier that I've used a phone tree for the first time this year and it's worked beautifully and I like the um flexibility that I have in um getting to the students level and interacting with them and having discussions about when it's appropriate to um if they need to check their phone or do something with it um I think if it were a true phone-free environment we

193could all work with that if that meant that the phones were not at school whether they were in those fancy magnetic bags or in a locker or left at home I don't think that could ever happen but um but obviously we don't have the budget for that I don't think so my concern is that this policy actually does not say that we will have a phone free environment which is what everyone it sounds like people really want but in supporting the draft policy it's actually not a phone free environment and I'm worried about the way that staff will have to you know I hate to use were disciplined but I worry that it will become um a battle knowing that these students will have their phones on them and that this passing time will sort

194of leak into other areas of the school um just because if the phone's in the backpack it is still a distraction um and so the I am not in support of the draft policy because I think it disallows the school to work with the students on where they are in their development and working toward understanding their use of their phones um expecting them to leave it in their backpacks for the entire day except for passing time again I've been a teacher now for 12 years that just does not feel realistic to me so that's what makes me a little bit wary about the draft policy itself thank you thank you hello I'm Joanna Wallace um and I am opposed to the draft policy as written um I'll share that um I have two students one

195in the Middle School one at Wentworth and we had Pur purchased smart watches for both of those students with the discussions with teachers and principles before we purchased those watches a couple years ago um with the uh now ban it was very difficult for um I have a child with an IEP and when we spoke um in the IEP meeting um the watch was purchased in part with the discussion with the IEP in in support of the I with the IEP teachers and um it wasn't written into our students IEP at the time because they were allowed at the time uh now that there is a a ban uh at the lower levels it was the IEP teachers were very very uh unwilling to write the watch into the IEP because of the ban um

196so there were several devices that were suggested that the school could purchase that would satisfy three different needs of my child um but why would we have the school spend money on those devices when the Watch Works does what it needs to do is free to the school and uh is it's locked down during the day too so there's no phone calls that can happen there's no texting that can happen from Bell to Bell um so I I'd really be in support of adding in teacher discretion excuse me into the back into the policy um I would also be in support of um adding device management into the policy because there is a difference between smart watches that can't access the internet and cell phones which can especially at the the younger levels so I'd

197like that to be considered as well um and I'd also just like to remind everybody that social media does not equal self phones um and devices so um Banning those devices does not my kids don't have social media that's my choice um but they do have devices which I consider a tool for them thanks thank you good evening good evening um my name is Denise Blain I am a teacher at scubber high school I also was not planning on speaking tonight but um he can never keep me in a seat too long um I am sorry um I'm standing in front of you in opposition to the draft policy um for I guess three reasons um the first one is I would like the board to consider putting teacher discretion back into the policy um

198it's no surprise I've been teaching here for 25 years a lot of our teachers have been teaching for many years and this is what we do we manage things um and taking that away to me feels like you don't trust me that that putting that in there and taking it away you don't trust me to to do my job um secondly the policy as drafted would definitely change the way I interact with my students um it is a part of their life I want them to be able to use it and use it correctly I don't want to police them all day long I don't want to do it I want to engage with them I want them to work with me and I think this policy as written would change that Dynamic lastly I've

199heard a lot about how it impacts education and I'm only speaking from the high school I don't have any fancy statistics or anything but I would ask the board while there is a bunch of data out there I'm not disregarding that National Data World data can we look at scarrow's data scarbro High School's data the Panorama survey our grades um compare those Statewide compare those nationally are we doing that badly I I would say no um I'm sure Mr Terio would love to come up here and do this amazing presentation on Panorama survey and watch me roll my eyes in the background but uh this is one time where I'm like yeah for the Panorama survey because sorry but I have watched that survey change that data change um especially in certain areas about feeling

200like we have a community feeling like they're supported so I would really like the board and the committee when you're re when you're looking at this draft policy again to kind of look really closely at scaros data and is this policy as written zero to 100 in my opinion going to be what's absolutely best for our students are we doing what's best for them in their education moving forward that's all I have thank you thank you how are we doing online okay is there anybody else wishing to make public oh we had a hand um if you allow her to talk okay Allison um online Allison you're um you have been permitted give him permitted Excuse me give him permission to talk um I'm going to start the timer I'll just um as it gets

201close as your time gets close I'll just um unfortunately have to interrupt you to let you know that all right okay thank you so much go ahead thank you um my name is Alison Avery I'm also teacher at the high school um I would just like to reiterate kind of what Miss Bornstein and Miss Blain are saying um currently the policy as drafted just states that they can use it during passing time and that means that students are still going to have all of these devices on them throughout the school day and my concern is that this is going to take the relationships that we have built with these students and now we are going to have to enforce yet another policy that in my opinion is already under management at the high school I

202think we do a very good job and our students are very respectful of instructional time um yes there is usage at lunch and in study halls but again I think that this is an opportunity for us as teachers to give the students the opportunity to have these devices on them before they get out into the real world when they get to College when they get into the job World they are not going to have a cell phone ban they're not going to have someone saying no you can't have that on you at all times like they're going to have to learn how to use these tools in their pockets they're going to have to learn how to put them ons silent to limit their distractions and I think at the high school level it is

203our job as Educators to make that happen like I personally have a cell phone tree and until it's a problem I don't need to use it if it is a problem for students then we do use it and I think for study halls if a student has their cell phone it's usually they're looking at class notes they're looking at their online textbooks they're looking uh other instructional things they're taking pictures for projects um I know in our stem classes we are constantly using them for taking pictures of their projects um taking videos of roof Goldberg machines we can't do these on their Chromebooks it's just not feasible so unless we can find funding to Prov IDE classrooms with cameras and videos and iPads and all of these other devices I just don't see that this

204is a reality that can be effectively managed at the high school without taking some of those learning opportunities away and in my experience the students who are distracted by social media or anything during a study hall on their phone if they don't have their phone they are just finding an alternative way to be distracted I think that's a conversation that parents need to have with students about their time management and the consequences of not using their time effectively and that's a growth opportunity that developmentally they need to have before they can leave high school they need to learn these skills these are soft skills that we need to be proactively teaching our students and I think that a complete ban on personal electronics takes that away those learning opportunities and it's not just about the

205academics it's also about these soft skills and the presentation at Wentworth was teaching these students soft skills so why are we not continuing these soft skills throughout their entire academic career thank you thank you Allison right is there anyone else wishing to make public comment either in person or yeah come um hi my name is vavi I'm a junior at Scarboro High School um while I understand the argument that these cell phones are distracting I believe that it is the responsibility of the school department to teach students what responsible usage truly looks like each step in a students education is pivotal and it teaches us crucial lesson crucial lessons and ways to navigate what comes next this does not include directly prohibiting phone usage as we enter the next stages of the digital age personal

206device usage is inevitable rather than carrying out a full restriction in personal devices like phones or personal laptops it is imperative that the school district encourages responsible usage via lesson plans and curricula that weave in technology and if anything it creates a bridge between Generations that allows teachers to engage with students in a language that they're more familiar with in this new era f f phones have the potential to provide social and emotional benefits which has been proven to be a goal of the school district as has been previously discussed personal electronic devices um personal electronic devices can be can act as emotional Regulators in addition to the difficulties involved in incor in incorporating school specific technology into plans like IEPs and 504s the lengthiness of the process taken to get these plans in the

207first place is one of is one that consists of many many steps and it takes time finally as much as it hurts to admit we live in a time of violence it is painful to say that the chances of an of a school emergency or threat are not 0% scarber has experienced some of these and I personally have experienced some of these on the second day of my sixth grade I had to endure a non a non-drill bomb evacuation in the sixth grade further in in another experience I had a close friend of mine send me frantic test texts in the middle of a code red these personal devices provide a feeling of comfort and it is the duty of the School Board to balance such comfort and education as we grow and enter the

208world in the digital era thank you thank you is there anyone else wishing to make public comment either in person or online would you mind checking for me one more time all right seeing none I will close public comment um I'm going to ask if we could take a five minute recess um just a stretch um uh with no objection we will just take a five minute recess come back at 906 do you have an objection okay e e e all right welcome back thank you everybody um looking at the time um it is 9 910 um I'm going to um ask if there is a motion to go ahead and suspend our our time rules to generally speaking we do not do business after 9:30 um I'm going to assume we're going to do

209business tonight Beyond 9:30 so before we get started into our part um I just want to see if there's a motion to ex to suspend our our time I'd like to make that motion second is there any discussion all in favor um all opposed were you was your hand raised I'm sorry okay so the motion is unanimous thank you okay so um we've had our um update we've heard our um public comment is there a motion to approve the first reading of policy JFK student use of privately owned electronic devices at school so moved second okay any discussion yeah go ahead Ellisa you first all right um so first thank you for all the public engagement and the emails and um staff response Student Response building leadership providing information District providing information um and thank

210you to the policy committee for kind of serving this up for our consideration um I do think the first thing that jumps out at me is the lack of um student discretion and I think um I would be in support of putting it back in there I think in general yeah that's isn't that what I just said teacher St oh God it's 9:15 I'm sorry sorry teacher discretion right I'm gonna get past that so um I think in general um the academic achievement data that we've seen coming out of Scarboro High School the um seal data everything coming kind of out of it has really been outstanding and remarkable and that's while the teachers have been able um to have a lot more flexibility with their own U management of cell phones with the students

211um I think kind of on top of that the teachers are asking to retain that responsibility it would be one thing if the teachers were asking us you know this is unmanageable I I need your help I I need a policy and things like that um but I think between the data that we're seeing and them requesting to keep that responsibility um I think it's really important that we kind of respect that um and allow them to have that discretion to um allow use when they see fit I'll just start there thank you yeah go ahead John um I agree with with those things um also I I I know we need to at least at some point address the different uses we heard from the robotics uh club with you know the computers that

212they use we've heard from I mean my daughter last year had uh you know some and or maybe she's doing it this year movie uh class where she used her phone for for for uh for projects that she was the whole actually class was pretty much on her phone um this takes that away from them I know it's would be costly to the school to provide for you know I'm sure we can for some but not for all um you know the the different different things we heard today about you know students with IPS you know there's just so many different things uh is a calculator a personal electronic device I I don't I don't know I mean I think it was one day but uh I don't know if it is still today um

213there's I mean there's there's so much to to look at with this and and and I I'll I'm sure I'll jump back in but I wanted to at least bring that up so that we you know somebody hit on it perfect thank you John I'm GNA go to Grace first and then Mitchell I'll come to you okay kind of echoing what Alyssa and John have said um I think we need to revise um the policy to include uh at the discretion of teachers like teachers can allow phones to be used I mean as a current student there are many situations where um using cell phones in class has been beneficial to my education um for example uh in the science class that I'm taking um we have we do a lot of labs and taking

214pictures of our labs and uploading them to classroom um allows our teacher to grade them um in addition I think the wording needs even things that sound obvious like calculators for example I think the policy needs to be very specific as to what is and what is not um like banned um it's very ambiguous where it says including but not limited to and I think if the policy is revised so that we say like a calculator would be considered an exception or a personal laptop would be considered an exception um I think that would be beneficial um I also am a little I guess concerned about students not being able to use their phones at lunch um as a couple teachers mentioned it would lead to it would be difficult for staff to police phone

215usage at lunch because there are so many students and there are only two or three staff that are like on lunch duty um and lastly I think a clause um needs to be added about medical exceptions and IEP exceptions and although this may seem obvious I think the wording of this policy really needs to be exact like although I know it would seem obvious that students who have medical exceptions can use their devices I think that needs to be added to the policy so that it's very clear for both students and teachers that um students with like medical or an IEP exception can use their personal device that's all thank you Grace Mitchell it sounds more like the issue that I keep hearing come up over and over again is separating social media from the

216devices and certain devices are being used in a very educational manner I know looking back at my recent experience in schools I use my phone a lot um to upload documents when I was remote or anything like scan them and turn them into a PDF so let's say we have one of those remote days and instead of a snow day could be useful for at home work in those situations so I think we really need to more focus on terminology like electronic devices and more folks say hey smart devices versus social media and what may be an issue if there was an issue but looking at our own Town's issue we don't seem to be having that issue with devices physically being like the main problem if there was a problem that did arise thank

217you Mel are you ready Jill oh oh Julian go ahead okay go ahead Jenna um I don't think it's a secret that I'm usually not for controlling things within our family choices um and that also carries to teacher choices as a teacher myself I would like to see teacher discretion be put back in I can definitely see this becoming some sort of power struggle that our teachers were not meant to be in school therefore um you know that being said I I am all for all this data about social media and all the effects that it has but it is also that family's choice to allow their child to have a phone to begin with so if there's a movement for younger kids to not have it it might translate to the older kids but

218as was pointed out it's already kind of too late for our current high school students um so things like restricting it during lunch and stuff like that I don't actually see it being a useful policy to be written in I think that would make it would do more harm than good um not to mention we do have have students that are translating for their families so they use their devices for translations and I'm sure teachers use it to translate for their non-english-speaking students um and we have working children and if these kids are responsible for getting work permits and stuff like that I feel like they should have access during these downtimes because they may actually need to check in with uh employers families and such so yes I would like to add teacher discretion

219and and not limiting their use as strictly in the policy can I ask a clarifying question you mean in the high school or do you mean all the whole thingol in the high school okay um I think as it as it is now I see that there aren't many complaints about the use of personal devices in the lower grades but more so in the high school so I think a tiered approach might be effective can I what what is your idea of it can I also ask a f question what's your idea of a tiered well so I mean if you look but someone had mentioned a distraction they're gonna find another way to distract themselves and if you're looking at kindergarteners it may not be a cell phone it might not be a personal

220device it could be Pokemon cards you know it could be the latest Taylor Swift cute t-shirt I don't know what you know that age group might be into at that time but they will find something but I think when they're really little they're probably still learning how to use these devices they probably don't have access to these devices because they're expensive their parents aren't giving it to them um with the exception of some watches um I know a lot of families that have had watches for location given that the world that we're living in right now you see a lot of things in the media um that we don't want to deal with but unfortunately we do um but what I mean by tiered approach is you know let's clarify what these personal devices are

221because it seems like in this policy like many of the students have pointed out this this is a a controlling all personal electronic devices it makes sense that now that we're including calculators um personal laptops even though they're more effective than our Google Chromebooks and I can attest because I use a school issued it's not the most effective um so I think we need to really really clarify what we mean because a lot of the discussion is a cell phone ban versus what's actually written here which as a personal device um personal electronic privately owned electronic device yeah um okay before I go to the three of you let me um fra and Jillian first no F anything just so it has a chance before I Circle back um yeah I'll just I'll just on

222what the notes that I just kind of have jotted down um so I think the things that strike me about the current draft policy that we floated um that I think we need to needs more um conversation not conversation needs more um development in the policy itself um I don't like the fact that it seems to be setting up this conflict between students and staff and the schools I think um we had a really great example of community building at winworth today and sort of the benefits of creating really good relationships and how that helps the school environment Thrive and putting in a con creating a conflict where there this Pro this is not a policy that emerged from the school as a problem that we're trying to address but rather emerge as a concern

223from the community about our current culture um we it looks to me like we're going to go in there and create conflict I've heard we're going to take away from relationships were going to create distress um I had somebody ask me was I willing to have a student suspended for checking their phone at lunch and I can unequivocally tell you no I will never support suspending a student for having them checking a phone at lunch and so if we write a policy that we say is very important and then we expect it to be upheld in schools we have to be willing to suspend students for violating that policy not the first time obviously it would there's a long road and a lot of diversion and multi levels of support to prevent said suspensions um

224that are effective but why are we going into an environment where the teachers are telling us that things are good and the students are um doing performing well on objective measures not their feelings although their feelings are important but objectively in in in um statistically they are doing well and generating a problem for teachers to police I've heard police search um know anti-c Community these are not words that I support in a school environment um I worry about the implementation of a policy and adding that to teachers that that adds to the policing I don't want policing in our lunchrooms to go hand inand that is something that makes me very concerned if that's the feelings it's going to create we're going to change the environment that we've try strived really hard to create in

225our schools and that's not something that I support um I want to make sure we clarify we need specification of the devices it's very very clear to me that nobody that I certainly do not intend to prevent robotics team that has won awards from performing their robotics Feats on the whatever computers are able to support that clearly not our phone books the um but also calcul like calculators like I'm old I had a graphing calculator at one point when I did math at some point in my life um it's a it's a p it's painful let's not go back there but I did math at one point um and and obviously we're not trying to prevent students from learning calculus and upper levels of math I mean that there's this an educational environment we're trying

226to support that I think we need to look at I think Mitch what you said is Mitchell I'm sorry what you said is very apropo which is that are we trying to prevent students from accessing social media during the school day or are we trying to prevent students from accessing smartphones during the school day because they are not the same thing they are different and so if our policy is we don't want people on a social media site we should look to that although with the same eye as how are we going to implement that and are we going to police if somebody is on fill in the your favorite or at least favorite social media app at the moment whatever people are on today are we going to suspend a student if their phone

227is on Snapchat are we going to do that are we willing to do that as a school do we want to set that as a priority for the school district um and then the curriculum and educational piece I heard student after student after student come up here and ask for Education about how to appropriately manage their their devices I've heard teachers tell us that they know how to do that that they're teaching that and that and and I had students ask for more education that is a call I think we should heed that's what struck me from today's conversation and all the other conversations that we've been having over the last several months but um that's kind of where I'm at at the moment I I would Echo that you know I was really interested

228to hear about the calls for education I mean we we do know that the devices are addictive and we know that they're um in some cases dangerous the the the platforms are designed to keep kids engaged um they collect personal data they they target us they they influence our Behavior like we're we're all addicts I would say well some of us but um um anyway uh you know I I but I really hear the teachers saying we've been doing this and and more so over the past decade we've been integrating this consistently into our day-to-day lives and and actually come to rely on them in some cases that the cameras are more powerful and and so on and I don't think anybody has any interest or intention in stripping that those pieces away um and

229so I think it's really good feedback for for us in in regards to the language and the wording um and so um I think that those are those that are concerned would hopefully uh support a well balanced bone policy that you know balances overuse and uh also promotes education especially for the 9 to 12 grades they um are about to be adults and out through the real world and um hopefully we could really hunker down on some appropriate use and not every kid has that problem some kids have significant problems with it um so anyway I I really I think that we got some really great feedback and I have I think we have a lot to work with but I understand that many members of this board went and observed lunch um I did

230not get that opportunity this week and so I was hoping that people would share that experience um I'll go ahead and speak and then I'll go back to the the three of you that raise your hands um uh I am really struck by something that um also the kids saying they wanted education I've been saying since June that to me this is a very much a two- Road problem you have a distraction Road and then you have what I'm going to lump on one road which is addiction cyberbulling social media all the things that we worry about with our kids and so what are we trying to solve with this policy I am I am absolutely not interested in creating a policy um to your point are we willing to suspend kids if our answer

231is no then we've done something wrong with this policy so I'm not interested in creating a policy where I'm then going to ask our administrators to go back and figure out the car vs and figure out how you are gonna get around this and it's not going to work and how are you g to keep an athlete on the field and how you to keep the robot robotics kid going to the school because then we're not doing our job so I'm interested in creating a policy that is going to work for everyone just like we've done with all of our other processes um if we are trying to solve for um the second road which is where I'm lumping everything else that I don't think the cell phone ban is getting us there I think

232that's where the education comes in um I am really interested in hearing how we can potentially use our advisory time our AES time and really ramping up education around um cell phone addiction and and social media um presence D digital citizenship what does it mean when you um sign into social media platforms and what information are you sharing right that's what I'm interested in getting at I'm interested in how we can create opportunities for parents to learn about um tools and strategies available to them and how do we bring our kids and our parents together together almost like what we did last week where they talked to each other about what it looks like to be addicted and why is it that um we as parents are really concerned about what our CH children's digital

233footprint looks like so I um I would love for to see us take that educational Road um for the distraction piece um it's really interesting to me because I don't I mean I guess I should only speak for myself sitting in the policy committee room um I looked at all of this from other districts these are policies from other districts and almost every single one of them says phones and cell phones and personal devices not limited um too and then it lists the same thing we did so it didn't dawn on me that a computer would be considered it didn't dawn on me that a calculator would be considered but now when I'm hearing this feedback I understand we need to be a little bit clearer so even though districts 1 through 50 or whatever

234it's sitting right here we've all done the same thing it the feedback I've received means we need to be we need to be a little bit more clear um I did attend uh three lunch break three a andc lunch so I attended all three um at the high school um I'm I guess if I'm really transparent and honest um I walked I walked in from what we've heard I expected to see almost everyone on their phones that was my full-on expectation walking into the high school lunch a was um I think it was around 360 kids is that right okay so 360 kids I did three laps around the cafeteria I um witnessed three children three kids on their phone and I'm going to shamefully admit that I looked over their shoulders to see what

235they were doing um sorry to the three of you one was on Power School checking their grades one was on their cell phone at the table looking at their just flip into their text and I watched to see what they were doing and what they were doing they were sitting by themselves and so they were on their phone flipping through their text but they were waiting for their friends to come out of the food line and as soon as their friends came out of the food line they put their phone away and were busy socializing just like regular the third kid was on his phone looking at a picture and but um was like looking on his phone at his phone pictures and was showing the whole table his photo and they were kind of

236talking about it together so again still social interactions um everybody else was talking I did observe one child who was doing pen and paper homework and I observed a second child on his computer doing homework but other than that all 360 kids were talking and it was loud and it was boisterous and somehow even though all that was going on all of those kids stood up like five minutes before lunch ended before any Bell had even rung and knew they needed to leave so there was no distraction at all it was I'm shocking the bee lunch was smaller um that is a the that's the lunch that um breaks up the study hall so it's like they go to study hall a little bit they go to lunch they go to study hall um that

237one was smaller that one had more kids sitting on their on their own um by choice uh at their own table um there was I would say more cell phone use there but I think it was a result of them wanting to sit by themselves and so it was more watching movies um listening to music that reading books that kind of thing was happening during the bee lunch and then C lunch just as big as A- lunch I saw a few kids on the phone but again same type of situation where they're on the phone looking at something um with their friends and so while I can appreciate and I do appreciate all of the data that has been sent to us all the data I've read about distractions and about social media use I

238absolutely agree it is addictive I absolutely agree there's a problem um with cell phones I think that we all know when we um or have our cell phones near us and we talk about I don't know purses suddenly your Instagram feed is filled with purse links to buy things there's a there's a situation unfolding right I resonate personally very much with the book my child was one that was raisu puberty with a cell phone and I resonate very much with a lot of the things I read in there um but I also have to balance that with what's happening in Scarboro specifically and I don't know um when I try to think because I would like us to measure something but but when I think about what are we going to measure we have a

239high school senior class that has a 93.4 grade point average what are we expecting them to increase to yeah that's I mean where do you go from yeah on a bell curve yes on a bell curve yeah or um and this is in 2000 going back to 2021 their grade point average was a 92.3 that was during covid so I'm not I I don't know if we can expect the grades to drastically improve what I would hope we would see perhaps is if we Implement something about AC academic time what I hope we see is less distraction less uh more focus on class as it is um but I I don't know I want us to be reasonable and what we what our expectations are as well so I think I'll leave it there for

240now yeah go ahead John I wanted to piggy back on the lunch thing uh I was able to uh to to go to lunch a couple periods uh and I think that uh my daughter told me braa was there I said which one is she she goes the one with the orange hair I go and that's um so uh I found out then when I went to lunch my kids don't like talking to me much because they're always on their phone when I'm around but uh at school at lunch there was very much the same and uh one thing I'm concerned about is tell kids they can't do something then they're going to want want to do it and then lunch was going to be when they're going to do it and I saw the

241the Skeleton Crew that they had um who's going to do it and then now how are you g to keep track of it and okay Timmy's ninth time and Johnny's third time and and and I mean I want to think about that and I'm sure you guys probably don't want to either um I was surprised honestly to to see that uh and when they did have the phone out it was and I was actually happy see it that they were all engaged in oh look at this video or look at this picture and and I'm like oh kids do actually talk to each other and it's not like it was when you know that's all we had to do I mean I guess we didn't have cell phones we passed notes and there I mean

242we could bring notes back I guess I could uh we could do that that'd be fun uh and maybe we get those uh uh fortune tellers get those back again I still know how to make them so see me if you need one um but I just I mean I don't want to cause problems where I don't think there is one and I think if we Ian we should at least consider it because I think that would put a problem where it wasn't before I just want to share that thanks John all right M Alissa um I had an opportunity to kind of view a lunch um I went to B and C B was the smaller lunch that Shannon had kind of reviewed and there were kids on their phone but similar to what

243John kind of said they were on it and then kind of had my eye on them and to see what would happened some friends came over and they just put it down and engaged right away with kind of what was going on in the table and um similar kind of experience they might pick it up and show show a photo or all of this I never saw anyone taking any photos it was very much like sharing something that was already there um and then sea Lun similar um one of the more boisterous 360 is student lunches um there were certainly phones present but it it was very social environment um I also um kind of on this kind of narrative of like you know okay so what happens if we pull the phones you know

244there these kids are sitting alone they could be engaging with other people and this kind of the narrative that we keep oh there'll be more of a social but you know that that child may just be introverted and may need time to recharge and that's their way of kind of turning inwards and having a few minutes to themselves um you don't always necessarily know what's on the phone they could be reading a book like I have my Kindle app right on my phone I can be on it at any time um just because they're necessarily on a phone it doesn't necessarily mean they're on social media and that's what I think has really fused this in this kind of debate that's gone forward where we've gone from kind of talking about cell phones and social

245media synonymously and they're not um if if a student is looking me and saying part of my academic success is Paramount on being able to check power school or do these types of things when you have a level of academic success that Scarboro has been putting forward I have a really hard time being okay with potentially um disrupting that um and I I feel like in a lot of ways lunch can be kind of a free time that kids can turn off for a little while it's only 20 25 minutes 25 minutes long it's really not you know they they put so much forward for so long um that I feel like taking away the phones it's you know sure they may carry a paperback book now like but it isn't necessarily going to translate

246to some of the narrative that we've heard where it's like you know they're going to suddenly turn and and befriend people they wouldn't have already ready like if they wanted to they would be ready um so that's um that was kind of my experience with lunch and um I wouldn't necessarily be opposed to seeing lunch being added into an area along with passing time where students are allowed to um utilize it of course still follow all the other rules within our handbook that you know ban other inappropriate behaviors but um you know I I will put that openly forward for that um echoing kind of on other topics echoing kind of what other people have said the idea of putting phone use curriculum forward I think is so imperative I would love to see that

247coming up for the curriculum committee sorry guys I'm not on it making work for other people um but I I think it's huge because you know as we've heard time and time again these devices aren't going anywhere this is lifelong you know the things that you post at 14 you know can you truly delete anything off the internet can you truly take anything away are you truly able to and you know you um being able to help kids understand that um and kind of what they're putting forward how they're presenting themselves and and moving forward in that way along with the ramifications of addiction to devices and all of those things it's very real um I think is really important um speaking specific um so health and and medical things have a near and dear

248place to my heart as a nurse um so I don't know if it's necessarily language that needs to be changed within the device I I do appreciate that K to8 is um a device ban but any any sort of IEP or health use I think need I don't know if that was just um a clarification that's needed within the district vers um change of policy wording um but if things are being used specifically for medical or health uses within the confines of an IEP I do think it's important that we respect that um and then the other issue I was going to bring up that I'm worried about and would like to kind of discuss a little bit out is this idea of banning smart watches because technology develops so fast um that are we

249gonna expect our building administrators administrators excuse me and teachers to identify what's a smartwatch what's not or fitbits allou or or Smart Apple watch is allow or you know what happens when a new one comes out how does that work does that one gets text messages that one gets calls is that one just counting your stat and all of these things suddenly develop and we've we put it forward we said no smart watches but what are we what are we trying to ban are we trying to ban the text message being received are we trying to you know ban the podometer podometer ban you know checking how many steps someone's taking throughout a day or you know so I think um we have to consider that before we and you know I don't know the

250answer to that as a board what our feelings are on that but I think that is something that our B building um teams will come up against um if we put forth a blanket smart watches um so even to Define within that a little bit more clearly what our goal is in that I think that's it let me go to Mitchell first and I come to you Jullian would we think about using language like disruptive devices like adding on to that point of smart watches you can ban smart watches but what is it are you trying to ban are you trying to disrupt the fact that it has a pedometer or just tells you the time with a bunch of other things or are you trying to ban the fact that someone could play music

251off their Smartwatch and be annoying a or not disturbing a whole class and learning time so maybe trying to find language that way and then another thing this is really running backwards in the conversation but um we were talking about like calculators and everything calculators are a lot more powerful than they used to be like you can upload and play a game in a 3D space on a modern graphing calcul so it still should probably be considered a personal electronic device but that's where verbiage like a disruptive device could come into play Jan I just had a question just on the the same vean a question that I I've had is I mean one of the things that has come up is that this policy was last reviewed what seven years ago7 eight years ago

252now um the technology does change so rapidly I think it would I don't know if you can have a a policy that has an you know a required review point I don't know um I would advocate for that because the tech I mean like you just said like asking people to catch every little thing I mean I don't I don't think smart watches were a thing for schoolage kids up until recently so um it might be something worth really promoting for future boards to look at this more frequently yeah and as a point of information we have other policies that have um specific timelines in there where they have to be reviewed so that's as simple as adding a sentence here at the end that says this policy will be reviewed annually by the board

253been eight months yeah yeah it might take eight months or a year to look through it but you know yeah or whatever we're gonna put in right whatever time frame we're gonna put in yeah all right um where are we you you I just wanted to add I would support language to review this not every year because I think that would be too soon um once it's implemented and then but you know more frequently than it would have like like you said this was last looked at in 2017 so um I agree I think technology is Ever Changing devices whatever these kids get access to it's ever changing we just we move that fast um so yeah I wouldn't support adding that language in there um did you want yeah go ahead just two more

254two more points one of which is I think another conversation I had that really sort of impacted me in this thought process was um that someone sing me uh parents sent smartphones in the schools 15 years ago and teachers have adapted to them being in their environment and so they've come to a place where it they've learned to manage situation and I think um you know I think someone else asked me like would you give your kid a smartphone in high school and I don't think I'm uh going to May answer that today because my kids are not at the age where we have to have that conversation yet I'm sure there's going to be lots of big feelings about that on all sides but um I want my kids to adapt to the environment

255they find themselves in today not the environment that I was raised in not the environment that came 10 years ago but I want to prepare them for the world they're entering now and that they will enter which will look different my kids enter it in 10 years and so I want my kids to adapt to the environment as well which I'm concerned that um trying to again I've heard like I think one student said it was like this Nostalgia of going back to a simpler time or to a different time is really uh it's like attractive I mean like it's like it's it's like you kind of keen for that Nostalgia um but I remember back to my and I'm looking back nostalgic and at my age um in my mid-40s it was video games

256were the end all and was going to end the we're going to end the world and people were like you know torching Nintendos the old ones the gry ones that don't work that well those because those were going to be the end of the world and I don't think that smartphones and Nintendos are the same but I don't think I think that impetus for parents to worry about if they're raising their children well is the same I think technology is causitive anxiety and that's hasn't changed um and I think this is what our generation of parents and our students are facing and so I do think that we need to prepare them to adopt to this world and cell phones are you know until they can be implanted directly in your brain inextricably linked to

257how we function um so I think by I want to protect children from the harms of the things that are that smartphones are capable of and I'm very concerned about of those things but I don't necessarily think that pretending like they don't exist and not preparing children as they become adults about how to handle them is the most is the wisest way to manage that risk so that's that's my one thing other thing is I'd like to see um I know there's periodic surveys of teachers I don't want to survey teachers on cell phones every single year but I think we should regularly gather data about um the is is this an ISS issue in classrooms like are teachers you know fighting with technology are we creating problems via this policy but also on the

258ground I know that you know I have a lot of trust in our Administration and they're um they're very hooked into the way they' the way they've designed the administration um there's a lot of good communication throughout but just sort of urging um them to be thoughtful about making sure we're we're asking teachers if there's a problem so that if there is one we're identifying it when there are problems we want to identify them bit of Technology if parents are concerned that technology is a problem distracting their children interfering with education we should be asking our teachers because they are the experts of what is happening in their classrooms um okay so um oh I'm sorry Grace pardon me of course so at I know uh cell phones at lunch was previously discussed and honestly

259a lot of St students the only time where they can socialize with their friends is at lunch so if they have the option between choosing to sit silently on their phone and talking with their friends like I'd say a vast majority of students are going to choose to socialize with their friends um there's a psychological theory reactance theory that basically States if someone is told not to do something they're going to want to do it more because they believe that their freedom is being threatened so if students are told not to use their pH at lunch they're going to want to use them more and the I don't believe that there currently is a problem with lunch I mean students I think really would rather socialize with their friends rather than be on their phone

260so I don't think it's necessary to restrict cell phones at lunch when they're really not a problem so thank you Grace um okay so I think I'm [Music] hearing uh I I I think I have a lot of thoughts I think I want to U maybe take it in groups but I do want to ask really quick just so I don't forget because I've already forgotten once can we please post um the information that um came from the high school um it was the 10-page report with our specific Scarboro data because I do think that this is pretty insightful information for the public to be able to see um it does include information about our graduation rates our uh the GPA that I mentioned to you for the last four years is in there um

261advanced placement courses uh sat means it also includes incidences of cyber bullying and I think it's interesting to note that in 2021 2022 um which would have been in Co during Co there was six incidents last year there was one so it's gone from 0 to six to three to one um these are all numbers this report is something I would be interested in us continuing to receive every year or every whatever we decide on for the the time for in between um because I think this is valuable information um for us to this is data that we can ground ourselves in that's specific for scarbo and I would like the community to be able to see that as well um the rest of the report is the um uh educational impacts to this draft

262policy what it would mean to the school so um if we could post that I would I would really appreciate that um so if we go to the policy if I'm hearing I I think maybe I'm just trying to think through the best way to go about this maybe we just look at one through five individually and see where we're at what feedback we have just so we know what to talk about in our policy committee meeting I have really detailed notes of what every single board member said okay so you feel like you could like I'm pretty comfortable but I have like 10 pages of notes from okay so you but you feel like you could rewrite something based on what you've heard today yeah okay John yeah go ahead and I know people

263brought up studies um talking about what what what they've said you know talk about excessive screen time and you know the impact do people think that kids are getting their excessive screen time at school is this something that's happening is I mean I mean I don't think excessive screen time gives you a 93 Point whatever GPA if every kid is just on their phone all time I know my daughter wouldn't be doing as well as she is in in her classes I mean I don't I think that I've heard that the teachers address it if it becomes an issue I'm wondering you do these studies even I'm sure people are going to come back and and have more information because we're going to do this again uh so I would be interested if somebody came

264back with telling us that okay yes it is happening at school because and where are they getting that information I just don't believe that we're allowing that to happen at as a community as a you know as as a district that it's happening anywhere and I I don't want people to think that that I'm here saying yes we should every kid should have a phone and they should have you know I'll buy them for myself no it's I don't want you know I want it I don't want them to be disruptive and I think I don't think that they are and I just want people to understand that we're just what we're doing here or at least what I'm doing is is yes I'm taking into consideration families but I'm also taking into consideration the

265students but also the staff and the administrators and what they all have to do and and and I've talked to different people and they've told me what and what common sense will tell you is GNA could happen and I know you know bath is an outlier but also bath is nowhere near the size of Scar brro and I don't think they have to deal with what we would have to deal with and and I just I just wanted to throw that out there because I don't know if anybody's ever brought it up but I I just don't think that kids are on their phones all day at school I I think that happens pretty much I've see my kids I'm pretty sure it happens when they get home and and I think we're all guilty

266of not stepping in and saying hey put away but that's just my thought yeah um I don't know to answer your question I don't know of research that talks about um or data that talks about um school school use um I did hear our kids at the last week um indicate that they use their phones to check power school I think Grace has told us she uses her phone to check power school I don't know that I can make the correlation that that's indicative of um overuse at school I think it's more indicative of the high performers we have at our school that seems like the properties of a device at school yeah to me go ahead well that and I think that's where some of like the Nuance of cell phones comes in because

267um a cell phone can be used for so many things sure if you're sitting on social media during English class like please put it away um but if you're tracking your homework assignments checking Power School um kind of doing you know being on your phone at school isn't necessarily inherently a problem in and of itself it's what you're doing on the cell phone um you know are you filling out College apps and you have to log in through I don't fully understand it's been a while since I P a college uh you know are you utilizing your phone to get into a college app so that you can you know further your education you know it's not just the inherent presence of a a cell phone so that I feel like that data would be

268really hard to obtain because you'd have to really look at not just how often are you on the phone but how often are you on the phone doing something unproductive um I think you a data point that like kind of came to mind as you were saying that um would be like how often were our students disciplined for phones um and I can't remember the exact number but I remember it was very low um and again it sounds like from teacher reports it was you know put it away and they did and um you know the number of cases that made its way to the assistant principles or principles was the very low number that I had kind of mentioned so um just a data point that popped in my head I do think that

269would be a good data point to add to this report going forward is how many phone instances are there it would be too much like no no no I think it would be yeah I think it would be interesting I I um I do think for me um I don't know that I said what I would support in so I just want to make sure you have some notes on what what I would want um um I am interested in a few things um I am interested in limiting the phone use during academic time I don't I think that to me study hall is an academic time and I know that's an unpopular opinion and I I own that um I do think providing teacher the teacher um I'm interested in putting back the teacher

270language um giving them back their discretion um but I do I I want to be clear on what I'm trying to accomplish I'm trying to stick on this distraction road so um I while I want to give teachers the the discretion back um and I I hear their feedback and I agree with their feedback um I'm really was moved by the very specific examples we had like the science lab where you can take a slow motion video of a reaction that to me is a very valuable use of a cell phone um so I do want to include that back what I'm not interested in and this is going to be really nuanced and I don't think we get to this but I'm not interested in okay there's 5 minutes left at the end of

271class why don't you go ahead and get on your cell phones because you've got five extra minutes I'm not interested in that piece I'm interested in the um academic piece um I'm in I would be uh good with putting lunch back on um allowing them use lunch I think we have to clarify passing time um although I want to go on record telling the two of you I told you so an you I told you so on the passing time the uh that it was not clear that that means between between hallways between classes so yes we will can put that one back um and then I'm also interested in two more things um I'm interested in trying to figure out the Athletics piece I know we've heard um there is concern around using um

272texting and using apps for athletic teams to correspond and so I'm interested in kind of figuring that piece out a little bit more and then the last one is um and this is more a budgetary piece um we heard from the art Department that um their I think for their classes Alone um the equipment that they would need would be um a roughly a $50,000 investment um for the equipment that they would need that right now cell phon fill that that gap for us so I am interested in kind of understanding how do we start um providing some of these and is it is it a good idea to provide these things for our students a little bit more than we do and start budgeting for them um off of that um the communication from

273school clubs and sports I don't think anyone's spoken at length on it um but I we have heard that like practice schedules were changed on social media you have to have social media to hear about these changes I also now have a daughter in sport so I know there's like specific apps that are used so I don't know if some of that got lost in communication with us but I I would say that I can respect a family's desire to not have their child on social media um so I think H um I would not want that family's choice to hinder their child's ability to show up to practice on time or at the right place and things like that so um again we haven't really heard from the athletic department or anything like that

274to truly hear that out but um if if um Sports and clubs and things are communicating on social media I I would be interested in not having that be an opport I would I would look for other opportun yeah and I think there is a difference um at I mean I can from personal experience last year I think there's a difference between athletic clubs uh coaches and instructors communicating with their kids and kid group groups that are friends making social media groups on social media right and so what I don't think we can do is we can't regulate that kids go out and create a social Media Group and in that sense if a group of kids is talking with each other and they're like hey practice was cancelled today our practice was moved I

275it's not that's not the same as official communication and so that that's it's like an interesting Dynamic there to try to work through but as long as like official communication is coming through EMA the school email yeah that would suffice all we can regulate is official I I can't expect the school board to regulate right children discussing things but if official communication I mean all practice cancelling should be come out in an official manner yeah I assume yeah um so I would say any official announcements like these things would hopefully come not on a social media platform would would that be part of what oh hold on one second Abby let me get to Jillian go ahead Jillian would that be part I mean that may be like a Nuance thing that would be part

276of the athletic Department's stuff I maybe Nate can add it to his report I don't know we really have enjoyed your report Nate that's what that's the lesson but but I like I don't I almost feel like we're that to not I think it's important like but I also think like kind of getting into the weeds in terms of of like all these little nuanced things like yeah like official yeah thank you those were the words I was looking go ahead evby so regarding like Athletics and so social media honest if I'm being honest the reason I got like Snapchat and Instagram was because like I got it freshman year like at the start of soccer season and it's not because like to find out like uh practice schedules but more so to like um

277about like team dinners or like team like outside of practice Team B like your social events yeah so it wasn't as much of like practice schedules but one thing I would say like I use my phone for is during soccer our coach would email us by like our personal emails not school emails so like we would be able to check our personal emails to see if practice got moved later or earlier like ending earlier I'd say that's like the use of social media like emails like on the phone and then also with like clubs like I also do Robotics and like other clubs so sometimes robotics like will end earlyer and have to like text my parents like hey can you pick me up a little earlier today cuz robotics will end earlier something like

278that yeah but regarding like social media it's not like team communication like as off practice is like and to be clear you're talking about social events that the team players are organizing yeah not not the coach Andor boosters or school or anything of that nature you're talking about the kids organizing amongst themselves like as of now like all of like the coach scheduled things aren't on social media like they reach out via like email or Google Classroom thank you for that yeah and you said your personal email are you saying like your personal school email or so for soccer it was my like home email like my personal email not school and that was from the coach yeah all right and they like I suppose you could have the option of putting your school email

279as well but most would put their personal email and like their parents email I might to through that one a little bit all right all right is there any other any other discussion all right yeah yeah and um I meant to Jenna had asked me to do this before I got started and I failed to do so so thank you for reminding me um a yes vote for this is not a vote on the language it's a vote to move this policy to Second reading so as a reminder um after this meeting should this path first reading and uh we vote Yes to move it to Second reading the policy committee is meeting to discuss the changes we' we've talked about tonight and to adapt the draft policy accordingly and then we will bring it

280back to the full board for a second reading yes yes all right all right so we have a first and second all in favor of approving the first reading of policy JFK student use of privately owned electronic devices at school all right that is unanimous thank you so policy Committee just for those that are watching are still here um oh I've delet I put my schedule down when is our meet February 4th February 4th all right thank you agenda item 13.3 is the student Spotlight award presentation so I'm going to turn this over to um Grace and Abby all right so Abby and I have been working on creating a student Spotlight award which is going to run um like in sync with the uh teacher Spotlight award um and the student Spotlight award is

281designed to recognize uh students grades 3 through 12 um for their exemplary performance in school um submissions will be collected via a Google form uh that will be sent to All faculty um once Abby and I have like solidified um all the details about the student Spotlight award we're going to send out the Google form to the principles at each school and then the principles are going to send the Google form to the teachers just so it gets like more attention I guess and it's not like discarded um and Abby and I are going to review responses from teachers um along with Miss vasnik who um is aby's Elo coordinator coordinator and then any um Communications Committee Member that's interested in also reviewing those responses and that's just so it's more of like a holistic

282approach and there isn't any bias coming from Abby and I as students um and depending how many responses we receive it will either be a monthly quarterly or semesterly nomination um we're hoping that it will be monthly um and we receive a high volume of responses and any faculty in grades 3 through 12 can nominate a student for this award so we created a Google form it's basically the same like questions as like the teacher Google form to nominate students it's just asking like what's your name who would you like to nominate and like provide like reasons why and then after uh like choosing a student we would reach out to them saying can you like provide us with any material that we could use to present at like the board meeting when recognizing the

283student and we hope to start this like as soon as we as possible we've met with like the high school and principal middle schools uh teacher principls and so we're hoping to start maybe like February so like yeah and we're meeting with Miss Crosby the Wentworth principal tomorrow can you I'm sorry can you repeat what you said um about the committee that's going to select I I I think I missed part of what you said oh yeah um so Abby and I like as part of the people that review the responses and select the winner um Abby and I miss vasnik who's aby's ELO coordinator and then any members of the communication committee that are interested in reviewing those responses also Kim and then like as a group come to a decision about who should

284receive that month's award oh very yeah all right um are there any questions for grace and Abby on this um okay uh do I have a motion to approve the student Spotlight award uh as presented so moved second okay is there any discussion I just I just want to say that this is great work and I'm really proud of you guys and I'm super excited to see how this rolls out and uh I just am so impressed so thank you so much yeah this has been um uh I think everybody here well I know everybody here knows but for those that don't know it but I Mentor Abby um as part of her ELO program and I know that the two of you have put a ton of work into this a ton of work

285and um it it seems like an easy thing on the surface but it it ends up when you actually get into it it's a lot and you have met with principles so you've met with your leaders and in your school and at the middle school and you're meeting with the leader at Wentworth school and those are big-time meetings right and some adults have struggled to do that and so the fact that you're doing it and you're thinking ahead and you're thinking about potential conflicts of interest and you're thinking about um how do we make this work is really really impressive and you should both be so proud of yourselves this is an awesome program I I sincerely hope you get a ton of applications I appreciate that you're thinking through how to make this fair

286and how to make this Equitable for everyone um so thank you thank you for all of your hard work both of you very very much thank you all right all right um all those in favor of approving the student Spotlight award as presented and that is unanimous thank you so much you two um I'm going to go ahead and release the two of them because I know they have homework assignment so if you two go ahead go on yes thank you all right agenda item 13.4 is the high school and middle school Unified sports club donation acceptance Diane sure so in your packet you'll see a letter from Kate Bolton um with the donation approval requested uh here's the letter on December 20th 202 24 the high school and middle school each received a donation

287check in the amount of $1,125 from a neighborhood event in the Winward Heights neighborhood Stacy white the high school stem engineering teacher organized a neighborhood event in Winward Heights neighborhood they donated a total of $2,250 to Unified sports each December uh these Neighbors illumin the streets around their neighborhood and they host a nighttime walk they collect donations for different charities and this year they chose Scaro Unified sports the money will be split between the high school unified basketball program and the Middle School unified club we respectfully request that the school board approve acceptance of this donation on behalf of the Scarboro High School's unified basketball program and the Middle School's unified club with many things perfect thank you do I I have a motion to approve the high school and middle school unified Sport Club

288donation acceptance as presented so moved second is there any discussion I live in this neighborhood and it's a beautiful event it's luminary night and the neighborhood looks forward to it every year everyone um orders candles and bags and sand and lights them up and then everyone just goes for a walk at night and it's a beautiful family event so thank you Stacy for organizing it every year um and I'm so happy that it's coming to the school this time oh that's really very cool um uh I forgot to ask if there is any public comment is there anybody wishing to make public comment seeing none all right um uh and my my um my conversation will be my discussion will be thank you very much this is very generous um all right all in favor

289of approving the high school and middle school unified Sport Club donation acceptance and we show that is unanimous thank you so much agenda item 13.5 is the EO ESO newcomers Grant donation acceptance yes so um in December uh Jane kenry who is a high school and middle school um esol esol teacher applied for a grant through the main Alpha Delta Kappa Organization for Women Educators the grant is for $500 and will be used to purchase a new cumber a newcomers kit this newcomers kit features a workbook series to help students newly arrive to the United States build essential language skills giving them confidence as communicators and readers so we respectfully request that the school board approve acceptance of this donation on behalf of our grade 6 through 12 esol students with many thanks all right

290there any questions any public comment do I have a motion to approve the eso newcomer Grant donation acceptance so second is there any discussion many thanks again all right all in favor it's shows unanimous thank you so much agenda item 13.6 are appointments 13.6 one is the Middle School winter two coaches as presented in your packet as presented in our packet all right do I um any questions for Diane anybody wishing to make public comment all right do I have a motion to approve the Middle School winter to coaches so second is there any discussion I'll in favor that shows as unanimous thank you agenda item 13.6 point2 is is a high school strength and conditioning coach as presented again in yes presented in packet thank you any questions any public comment I do I

291have a motion to approve the high school strength and conditioning coach so mov second is there any discussion all in favor that shows is unanimous um and without any objection we will adjourn at 10:18 p.m. thank you so much e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.