001good evening it's 6:46 and I will call the November 11th 2024 Cedar Springs public school board meeting to order and if you would rise for me for the Pledge of Allegiance and we'll go to the center flag right here flag i al to the flag of the United States of America theic for it stands Nation indivisible thank you and if we could have a roll call please secretary slager yes truste Bowser here trusty Patton here trusty vanderhyde here treasure Gilmore absent secretary slager here vice president schner here president Reed here thank you and we've established a quum for tonight's meeting and next up we have the adoption of the agenda and I would entertain a motion for as presented as it's of public record so moved any discussion having none vice president shner yes secretary
002slagger yes trusty vandery yes trusty Patton yes trusty Bowser yes president Reed yes the agenda is adopted that brings us to gratitudes and I'd like to start off by giving thanks for the reelection of Matt and Trent and then we'll have Jason joining us in January and grateful for she service but we will be missing her but it's not our last meeting yet no you're stuck with me one more time there you go um I want to say that as usual I'm grateful for the Arts programs that we have here last weekend I start not just a couple days ago but a week ago um I spent in Detroit watching the band uh go to their state competition which was wonderful and then this past weekend went to the play which I see one of
003our high school students was in and that was so much fun to watch and to we went my husband and I went to all of the performances so we got to see the little nuances between each one and it was it was a lot of fun and so I'm so grateful that um all of my kids and so many other students at our schools can participate in band and choir and theater and and all those things because they're important what I'm grateful for yeah piggybacking on that I was in a at a river City's Alliance superintendent meeting on Friday morning and one of the things that we were really emphasizing is how to get other programs involved within the alliance and uh one of the ideas that came to the the table was doing sometime
004something like a theater Carousel where um we promote the other schools performances and also um you know set up a a kind of a fan bus from Cedar Springs to go to Sparta to watch their show and for them to send kids to our show so just a way to get those programs more connected and theater is amazing you can always Le something so we just see that as a neat opportunity for us to really be intentional and promote that that shared opportunity um but to do so in such a way that it helps tighten the the bonds of our individual programs but also to unify the northern part of the the county the region across multiple things other than just Athletics so I'm excited and thankful for that outside the box thinking I'm also
005thankful for the continued progress that's being made on various construction projects uh around the campus the lean to roofs are on the cold storage uh building and I was up there today and checking that out so those uh extra little attachments look great now that we've got the green light find me through the state for the building permits and approvals um yeah and just thankful for our veterans who were both our on staff and who live in the community and you know acknowledge their service we wouldn't have what we have it if it had not been for those sacrifices for veterans that had come before us and those who are currently serving in the Mard hey move on do we have high school Representatives here I don't I see high oh okay if you'd like
006to come to the podium and tell us who you are I don't I am William uch Vincent K and we're here just to give you update on what's happening in Cedar From perspective of uh we about month ago we had our blood dve we raised quite a bit we raised about 407 Pains of blood which with a few more blood drives that will give us quite a big chunk of money forc in general uh we had about 135 Midwest Michigan patients come in and donate about 145 people receive received the help they needed we also have the Harvest vest um for the Harvest West it was a good outcome we raised $500 and families enjoyed it a lot they had a lot of time we are currently planning a gratitude wall where the big red
007hwk is in the hallway of it's going to be a turkey with the feathers being um things students are thankful for we started that into a motion today um we're prepping for that right now and we hope to have that up soon in the weeks um and then we have snow cing which is coming up on February 8th um the theme is frozen and we're trying to work that out the sophore the main lead of the snow coming a few things we've decided are set up hallway decorating so we don't take away from homecoming especially is we will do we're thinking a foam a foam snowman with those foam balls and decorating those each year so it's reusable uh we're also planning a Santa event just in general at December 3rd from 6:30 to 8:30
008p.m. uh cookies letters Santa crafts Stu for kids in general and we have winter week where it's going to be December 9th through the 13 where it's going to be a spirit week and then we're going be doing like a door deing contest and we're still trying to decide on what we should get the winner the winners class of that and what class hour would be the winners that's all we have for lot thank you to know thank you for okay moving on to our consent items the normal business of the district I would entertain a motion for as presented so moov support vice president president shner yes secretary slager yes trusty vanderhey yes trusty Patton yes trusty Bowser yes president Reed yes motion carries brings us to discussion items and first up we have
009high school New course proposal AP comparative government and politics with Mr Baron W present yes well thank you um we are at that time of year where if we want to make any changes or adjustments uh or add new courses to our course catalog we need to bring them to forth to you to the board so the high school administration along with the building leadership team the socializes department and some very interested students have uh developed a new course here you may want to get into the new course proposal that's linked there for you um it is AP comparative government and politics and I just happened to notice today on the proposal the N politics got left off and so we do want to make sure that that is on there obviously it's on your
010agenda as well but that'll be important um that we're calling it the proper course title because it is an AP course and uh needs to show up on their transcripts uh correctly as well but um as we look through the proposal this is a course that will be a ful year course typically Juniors and seniors will be taking it um it will have its AP weighted grade and designation uh it is listed as a core course because our students who uh choose to take this may uh choose to take government or they may take government and then take this course but because it would meet the government Civics requirements for Michigan May curriculum we do want you to understand that it is uh able to be listed as academic Court um turning to item two
011you have your course description uh there for this which is what would appear in a course catalog uh the rationale behind this as you might be wondering a little more as I hit on a little bit first is that there was a strong student desire to offer this course we have several several dozen students um who are interested in having an AP government uh comparative government politics course um it does expand on our curriculum here uh offerings at the high school which is always something we want to look at as we look at School of Choice um opportunities for students who might have went through a different K8 system to be attracted to or families moving into our area to see a very broad cor group of courses that we're offering in our catalog um
012it also allows for um the fact that in our social studies Department every one of our core courses has an a attach that goes with it as far as an AP course except for government and Civics as it currently stands and so this would allow for that opportunity as well so that all of the cores and social studies um have an AP option which as you probably know from being on the board here does make a difference for some of our students as well who might be listed as AP Scholars or more from some of their designations from AP um it allow our students to also increase their civic engagement and uh be more actively involved in uh our local governments on the way all the way up to our national governments in that so
013that's a few of the items there um we have noted as well that our early medle early mdle college students sorry I'm stting a little bit here um could use this as a double dip in other words if they take this course it would meet the the Civics requirement under early midle college for their associates degree that they choose there if they need to do that maybe open up another option of another course for them to take uh during their their credit time there um it does overlap with the regular government and a little bit of our AP World History um they go into the different typ of governments that there are but not into nearly the depth that this um course would especially looking at all the different current governments around the world our
014projected enrollment is about 30 students um for the first year um we have capped it out potentially at about 60 students um if we have more interest than that we would take a look at it by typically looking at be a course that run um at most two sections of that um there will be no prerequisites um that is this course would be introduced that they would have to have other than um or wouldn't require any prerequisites for that piece um we would want them to go at make sure that they've had um US History um before that so for that being said as we look at the textbook piece under item six um the comparative government uh stories of the world for the AP course um is listed there it's about $113 in change
015for the book and another $41 for a sixe digital license if we should choose to go forth for that I'm just including that along with the proposal uh that I received on that in with this um however we would wait until we get the actual um enrollment projections for that course um see how that would fit in with our master schedule and our FTE that we have uh for teachers for that so really with our current um teaching staff of of AP teachers in the social studies Department probably all but Mr Cooper who teaches the econ course would be able to potentially teach this but we don't like to make those decisions until uh we look at the full master schedule FTE available so I have included if we were to have another certified teacher
016who hasn't had the at training uh need to take that the cost that're associated with that um the book we would bring forth to you later um again once we have actual enrollments we'd have to do we have to put that like a regular curriculum before bu yeah we'd have to do that and then it'd have to what sit for 30 days and that for that component of it so I'm just including those figure so you kind of have a good idea what it would be the total cost um if we look to approve this this course um we have listed um a number of links there for you to take a look at the actual scope and sequence of the course um that is listed there we do have Mr Stewart here tonight from
017the social studies Department if um you have any questions on this um and obviously we'll have here at the next meeting as well um for that component the last item that I included and working with um social saes Department specifically Mr Stewart is just kind of an overall flow chart because sometimes as board members I'm sure you'd like to know how is this going to fit in what kind of effects that would have and everything and even though it was noted U from the building leadership team and they don't see this encroaching on any of their other department um it is nice to least see a visual that um in this graphic you'll see on the left hand side it's kind of your traditional uh course sequencing for a student as far as their social
018studies classes go so as a freshman they can go U directly into world history or AP World History um on the world history side it's pretty straightforward uh there as far as the cour word uh for a more ADV Advanced um learning scenario you have the AP track which would be the extreme um there for a student who would be taking all AP courses throughout their social stud time and then the section in the middle shows you some options of how students may make choices in their sophomore and junior year leading up to their senior year and how AP comparative government and politics could fit into their fouryear plan I appreciate the that very much I know if Mr Stewart had anything to add or to share or I think that's super comprehensive like Ron
019said I mean the instigating event was the students coming forward not one time multiple times asking if this could be possible um that's the research that we put into it this this is a I think a course that would set Cedar Springs a bit apart it's a less common AP offering um it's more common to offer AP uh government and politics just focused on United States uh but these students did request this one specifically and um and and I think that that's interesting so as you noted in The Proposal I'm going to there is going to be the United States we be put in the United States alongside uh the governments of Iran China Mexico Nigeria Russia and the United Kingdom those are the six governments that the students are responsible for knowing about it
020in addition to the United States I didn't know existed until the students brought it then so I I got a question the students primarily who were interested in this are they ones that took apus history already or are in it and then they would want to take this in addition this was predominantly a group of sophomores last year that came forward but this um College Board is big on Open Access so the goal here would be that if you've never taken an AP class this could be your first one um or if you takeen in add to that help you get toward your AP scholar but AP US History would be helpful you learn a lot about government on the way side as you learn history but that won't be required questions yeah as long
021as there any other all right thank you for joining us thank you Ron High School choir course name change request and Ryan you're still up to B still love to that yes so uh bringing forth a request here for two name changes uh and two of our chir courses uh we're going to be changing Chang singers to B Voice v um which means beautiful voice this request is coming forth as we've had a few changes um in how we are offering this course in the sense that it's no longer a prerequisite for to be an auditions group of students and the voices are changing so this would only have subal in alos within this course and you might wonder you know a little bit why this kind of Change is Going forth within the in
022the vocal music field and competitive circuit um names mean something to the judges as they're coming forward as well as just um individuals out there suing as groups and so we want make sure that those match up so the first change is chamber singers to B Bo and then uh the second one is concert choir still going along the same kind of idea uh that the the voices here would be teners and bass voices um generally in in the concert world or in the choir World concert means that it is typically a little less Advanced ensemble um we want to move away from that idea that these could be very Advanced students um and it's just a change in human voice types that we're having here so um we're going to be making a change
023from concert choir to Red Haw singers that your course neither one of these have any curricular adjustments other than the change in the voices there's still the AL the same course objectives and sequence of learning in there no budgetary requests have been made or any kind of special profession so not being in I just wonder about the will the kids know what b means or we are we GNA lose students is that a marketing thing um or does yeah I don't what overcomes that well the course curriculum guide helps overcome that so we can have the description in there so that it would um show them what kind of of voices they going to be in this area plus keep in mind many of our students are taking music and Choir midle School feeding into
024this area so there is opportunities for the do you know what we call everybody all together the different all right there anybody else have any questions move on thank you again Financial update we have Scott Smith presenting in L all right so I'm subbing in for miti who is a spending some time with family right now which is a blessing really grateful for that um so so mty prepared for you three documents for tonight's board meeting they're all included as artifacts the first is just an overall Finance report um and there are several items that I want to just highlight for you uh and then clarify any questions that you may have first is the state aid membership we had our count day we submitted uh our fall count um the certified count came in
025at 2999.99 um that's uh slightly um the our state aid uh projected membership was uh 36 students. 43 FTE uh the the state aid membership count is that Blended number so it's our actual uh with then a blend of last year's count and this year's count so um the our projected uh or the excuse me the state a membership count of 36.4 3 students is 94 students 94.8 less than our uh uh membership from last year uh but is actually 2.43 FTE higher than what we budgeted um so the budgeted number that mty put forward last year was really spot on fortunately we're not below that if our actual comes in significantly below budget then we have to make adjustments you know it's still we have to be still mindful of the fact that our
026numbers are down 600 students from where they were uh on November 11th 2019 um and so that's just something we need to continue to watch uh continue to be mindful of as we move work more work forward uh with our programming um part of that State uh Aid membership count is that the state offsets that reduction in your budget um and so the state sets aside um $71 million to be shared across districts throughout the state so any District that lost enrollment from last year will get a share of that $71 million our projection is that we would get roughly $452,000 to offset that decline in enrollment um now the that number is a moving Target because uh it's all relative to how many other districts lost students as well so um they've got to
027they've got to set aside amount of money um everyone that lost students will kind of lay a stake to that money and then they'll distribute that out equitably across across the state so just to give you a sense um last year um the state was not able to fully pay uh the requests they paid those requests out at 77.4% so basically 77 cents on the dollar requested uh they were able to pay out of the stide that they that they had made so at least it's it's not um it's better than nothing uh it definitely helps you know every dollar helps for us as we Contin move forward um open enrollment um for benefits this year um is uh we're in the process of of doing that work right now and our employees are in
028the process of uh taking a look at their benefit packages um we're in a unique situation uh because we're a hardc cap district and so the state sets aside a limit as to how much a public school district can pay for for health benefits um like other districts in the State uh that cap increases annually at a rate that is uh linked to inflation so this year the cap the hard cap Rose by a very small amount 0 2% so the the hard cap from 203 2023 20 2022 23 excuse me the the hard gap for 24 uh increased by 2% uh for this year the problem is that our rates included or our rates for insurance increased significantly more than 02 percentage points uh and that predominantly is linked to uh increases in cost
029of prescription medication um and uh significant increases to the demands and costs for the um the inhibitor medication the oics uh some of those medications that are being used for weight loss um those uh prescription uh requests to put a significant toll on the health insurance um world and thus they're passing those costs along to their uh their clients that's how Insurance works if claims go up um members pay more it's they don't they're not doing this for us they're doing this for them um I'm part of the West Michigan Health Insurance Pool uh value ad committee and I'm part of their um their board of directors um so I sit in on monthly meetings where we talk about things like prescription medication costs of those medications and we really uh we're in a little
030bit of a different situation because um as being part of the pool our rates increase uh relative to the claims of of districts like us like our size organizations so our rates uh increased this year by 7.95% the average increase across the pool was 88.7% and there were some organizations some school districts that had rate increases of you know higher than 12% based on their claims data so while it's unfortunate that our members are going to be paying more for the same plans next year um it could be much worse uh there are options for members they can choose a different plan uh they can choose um different options with within their within the plan uh option group we have added another plan that that our families could consider that would be basically a no
031out-of-pocket cost plan but there would be a higher deductible so people do have options Beyond just spending more money on a pocket um and so I guess that's that's a good thing you know the important thing is and and we're working hard to share that information out through the business office and through uh Human Services um but what we're mindful of is there may be individuals who haven't read the emails have not been paying attention and so they're going to miss out on the uh open enrollment window and come January 1 they're going to see a rate increase that they weren't expecting um so we're going to continue to share the messaging as frequently and as um proactively as we can uh through individual emails through through to staff members through every Monday morning uh
032we send out a a districtwide newsletter um that's filled with different types of information so we're going to continue to run hey don't forget open enrollment uh in that newsletter uh so we're really going to try and get the word out uh we're having principles talk about it during their monthly staff meetings um but there may be individuals who missed the memo uh and they're going to find themselves in the situation where they're be paying more out of pocket than what they did this year does it is there examples with it that show plan a is this plan B is this see this or isn't able to do it that way yeah there's I mean the document yeah and and we've got um uh Carrie um dles and um and Kelly out of the HR
033Group they're doing uh meetings throughout the district in different buildings U trying to help just get the word out to people so we're really putting forth a significant effort but sometimes people just don't read the things that are in front of them because they're busy you know we're all busy so hopefully that will not be something that U you know puts people in a difficult situation but um we'll we'll continue to try and work to drive that number down and see what we can do to yeah yeah um flipping over on page two of that the threshold for competitive bids was set on October 10 that new number is $3,512 so we'll continue to use that as a a bell ringer for us when we have to get competitive bids for numbers less or for
034pricing on items less than $30,512 we'll still get quotes uh to be able to compare quotes just to be good stewards of our money and to help uh us be well informed as we're making big decisions but that uh that number did increase slightly and then planting a seed for you in terms of future considerations um you know we have had a sinking fund um that uh was approved by our voters in 2012 it expired in 2022 uh so we've gone two cycles now where we've not collected uh that Mill for uh sinking fund um there's still dollars left in that pool of money U but there are going to be continued projects that come up where we're going to need some additional dollars um that that will be sizable so for example you know
035the turf at the football field is um going to need replacement at some point in time in the next seven to 10 years uh if not sooner so uh one of the ways the districts that don't have a sinking fund like we do or we don't um one of the ways that they help offset the costs of some of those larger capital projects is to set aside a capital project fund um so we're in in doing that we would take a portion of our fund balance and uh the with the board's action set that move that into a capital projects fund to kind of set those dollars aside for future uh large scale capital projects um and so that's something that mty is going to be bringing uh to your attention in the months coming
036um with the potential of us moving in that direction at some point in time in the near future just to give us some safeguards moving forward a lot of the core infrastructure will be you know be taken care of um by the bond work that we'll be completing driveway uh Drive repayment um concrete those types of things so the the district will be in good shape at the conclusion of the bond uh but it's always nice to have that savings uh account set aside for those unexpected uh things that come up so that's uh something that M will be talking to you about in Greater length greater detail uh in the near future uh he also included then the general fund report from um uh through October 2024 um and then he also included a
037bond budget spreadsheet through October 31 2024 um I'll gladly do my best to answer any questions that you have over any of the three artifacts that M shared otherwise if there are questions from the board table we can email those um and M can get a communication back to us and we can share that information back out electronically questions no than um all right okay we roll into the quote for 62 intervention support so this is the second read on the ISL proposal um that was shared with you at our board meeting um in October uh at the work session um really that's a tool that we're looking to utilize uh at the secondary level um for students to use for intervention support um there's a lot of excitement and enthusiasm uh in certain Pockets
038uh particularly uh Ela and uh mathematics not so much yet uh in the areas of science and social studies uh just because ISL has not fully developed those branches of their support uh tree yet uh but they do look to be adding some of those Dimensions as we move forward but the bulk of interventions that our students need are not in science they're not in social studies they're in Reading uh writing and in MTH and so really the ISL program really hits the mark in terms of being able to support those two areas um Ron did you have any other thoughts or anything well just just to end to that that is true for the high school level the Middle School level does have developed science and social St so I just misunder understand that
039we would be purchasing that for the sixth through eth grade thank any questions we'll see that in a little bit or actually thank you next new will fall 2024 policy updates okay so um this is a big body of work as our our practice has in the past uh we take this little nibble sort of time um so I included the updates the overview uh the particular items that were looking at are really all um recommended uh adjustments recommended revisions that are based on um either grammatical errors or to help us become more compliant with uh legislative changes that have come through um the only uh significant difference that would not uh fall into one of those those two categories um would be the PO 5500 under student contact student conduct um that's a recommendation
040that they're uh that they've made to um bring in elements of um the uh academic honesty um thinking uh integrity and thinking um and then there's a subsequent uh policy recommendation 754 40 uh .09 and that's under artificial intelligence so you know giving us some guidelines around which uh students and staff can utilize AI in their work so again this is on Just for review to see if there are any questions uh since we met last um and this is something that we would if the board is comfortable likely move forward with u taking action on in December any questions concerns not just a comment that I I hope that the the high school teachers are trying to incorporate good use of artificial intelligence and teaching the students how they can use it but also
041where its flaws are yeah I hope that that's happening yeah I had a great conversation with Eddie Johns this morning about that very thing yeah using it the right way you know if you think about it you know we've they've been using technology for hundreds of years thousands of years the Abacus just counting Stones was technology the advocus the um the calculator slide rule you know those are all things that those are all technologies that we've used um the computer then a personal device uh tablet U our phones those are all things that we've had to learn um and think different ly around and this is really this it's a tool you know can either use for good or or not so much yeah so it's it's it's interesting this just seems like it's so
042much more powerful than anything else we've ever encountered but it just it will just make stuff up so students need to know that yeah yeah we'll see that again um our last discussion item is 2025 nsba scholarship opportunity through K ISD did I see April yeah the last last call um so the scholarship applications are due on the 15th um so you still have time if that's something that you would like to um participate in uh April did apply we got that submitted um but there's always room for more and if you apply and we don't if you didn't get the scholarship the district would just pay the membership or pay the participation so you at least be able to go that's so you're going regardless that's a worthwhile Adventure yeah no I had considered
043it I mean and talk briefly about it but I very happy that you applied and I wasn't 100% sure it was going to work for me so so I'm excited that I'm foring my husbandly down I don't want to go alone and think I'm gonna be the only one that' be good be happy to hear about it back yeah all right that brings us to public comments and this will be the time that the board hears from the public and we won't be responding but we would have Administration followup so do we have any takers for public comment this evening going once keep going twice Mrs Gus we have done correct all right then public comment will stand closed so for our action item this evening we have one item and it is the ISL
044quote for 6 through 12 intervention supports in the amount of 10,820 somebody check me on that and I will entertain a motion for as presented so moved as long as the numbers right any discussion having none vice president shner check number I am check was a 1590 extra charge I thought I'm looking at the Grand to okay so could 109 sorry a little n820 okay good I'm happy for the double check no worries yes okay here we go president sh yes secretary sler yes trusty vandery yes truste Patton yes trusty Bowser yes president read yes motion carries that brings us to the Clos session portion of our meeting tonight pursuant to op meeting act section 8C contract negotiations update and the um reasons are listed on the agenda Esa contract negotiations and superintendent contract exension
045so I would entertain a motion to move into close session at this time someone any discussion having none vice president Cher yes secretary slager yes presy Vader High yes pres Patton yes pres Bowser yes president Reed yes motion carot and see you in the post session for I'll leave it up to you we can have any audience sorry sorry Ron Barb that's we were gonna clean up but now thank you it won't be long good good the recording is back so stop cussing man sh THS out hey we can love the record show that at 7:59 we are rolling back into Open Session and we're moving into communication and for the Board of Education um you have any emails or anything that I've received and we just need to get on our calendars we're going
046to do a whole orientation together um for bsmh and how we work together on January 6th and then our we'll have our or um organizational meeting on January 11th so I have to get my new I know everyone else uses their phone but I have my little paper datebook I need so there you go okay else you have for us I do not have anything under communication um to share okay all right planning I kind of just did that communication um we have our December meeting and OB Shannon's last meeting with us oh I was going to ask a question is it I don't know if this is necessary but can we put on the next agenda to to vote on whether or not I can sit it graduation with y'all because if we pass
047it then it's done he can do that but I don't know that it's necessary I so I can just show up yeah the graduation in here we'll be good yeah until security calls you away inappropriate attire nothing crazy on the board for half of the academic school year true true oh that's a good point Chase yeah yeah we'll just have room we'll be fine all right yeah yeah yeah the only other thing for planning is I included that uh list of District events that was updated as of today it's unbelievable to look at that list and look at all the things that have already been crossed out exact what in the world time flies make sure you go to the musical because I won't be here to tell you to go okay so comes go
048to it Little Women all right okay having no more business before the board we will stand adjourned at 802