CorpusRecord 5270

01-25-25 Board of Education Budget Workshop #1

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bristol Public Schools
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,819 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you very much chair Pond good morning everyone good to see you all thank you all for being here as chair Pond said this is budget Workshop number one for the superintendent's proposed budget I would like to begin my presentation by introducing my team from central office I'd like to start with Miss Lyn B who's our Director of Finance and operations Mrs Carly foron her Chief academic officer Amy Martino our director of people Personnel Services Dr Kimberly culen our chief of talent management was not able to join us today I want to welcome we have administrators um from Bristol Public Schools online and also in the audience like to thank them for participating today um like to thank mayor cajano and the city for allowing us to be here in the council chambers this morning

002um we moved today's Workshop to Saturday hoping more of the public could join but also as an effort as the mayor said to show the collaborative nature uh during the budgetary process so thank you very much for accommodating us and I want to say that based on feedback from the Board of Education and the board of Finance today's presentation you will View today will look different than past presentations as the focus will be on the process for how the recommended budget was developed as well as the major drivers responsible for um my proposed increase we hope that this presentation will provide all with the information necessary for responsible fiscal decision-making as well as advocacy at the state and local levels for Bristol Public Schools Community um I also want to say that um after the

003presentation uh members of my team we will open the um presentation up for questions members of my team will take note of those questions we'll record all of the questions and then we'll be prepared at our next workshop on February 4th from 6:00 to 8 at the Boe Auditorium to respond to all of those questions so I just wanted to let you know that ahead of time so Bristol Public Schools mission to teach and learn with passion and purpose along with the bristol board of education's goals to secure necessary funding through public and Community Partnerships narrow the achievement Gap hire a qualified and diverse staff and provide a safe learning environment affirms our commitment to support highly effective teaching and Leadership and every classroom school building and central office Department this budget is not just

004a financial document it is a reflection of our ongoing commitment to our mission ensuring that our resources continue to support our values it reflects the desire to provide our young people with relevant 21st Century Learning opportunities and recognizes the key role our education system plays in our community our mutual goal is to provide our students with the tools they need to Excel and ensure that our community remains a place where all individual uals can Thrive um in the budget book that the commissioner has received there is a list of highlights of Bristo Public Schools accompl accomplishments during the past school year I am confident with our Collective efforts and partnership Bristo Public Schools students will continue to experience growth and success so in laying the foundation for the budget we want to provide you with

005um data on enrollment so what you are viewing now is enrollment as of October 1st 2024 there are 7,713 students enrolled in Bristol Public Schools in our classrooms additionally it is important to note our fiscal responsibility towards other resident students which includes and you'll see these listed on the side on the slide 465 students attending magnet schools five students attending open choice schools6 State students attending vocational Agricultural foag and technical schools as well as 53 students attending parochial schools the next uh slide uh the charts you see on this screen were taken from the Connecticut State Department of Education public Ed site website and show our demographics through last school year we included this slide to show you the increases we have seen in the percentage of English multilingual Learners as well as students with

006disabilities this slide shows the percentage enrollment by race from 2021 and includes the 2425 school year data special education free and reduced and multilingual Learners as of uh October 1st so you'll see that current data listed on that slide although Bristol is a community eligibility program C District I believe it is important to clarify our current standing regarding this eligibility the C provides an alternative approach for offering School meals in local educational agencies and schools in lowincome areas instead of collecting individual household applicants for free and reduced price meals the C allows schools that predominantly serve low-income children to offer free nutritious School meals to all students through the national school lunch program and school Breakers program the C uses information from other programs including the supplemental nutritional assistance program commonly referred to as snap

007and temporary family assistance the TFA this includes students who are deemed categorically eligible based on criteria like Snap TF or homelessness the proposed 2025 26 budget of 146 m9498 reflects a 12.58% increase over last year's adjusted budget this proposal underscores the need for additional resources to address the team's best plans to except accelerate teaching and learning in the 2025 2026 school year the overall General budget request amounts to again 146 million 94951 this amount does not reflect the grant funding also used to support Bristol Public Schools we will provide more Grant data in this second workshop on February 4th this presentation is about the general fund not the grants however it's important to note that the share covered by City of Bristol taxpayers is significant Ally lower totaling 105 million I'm sorry y 15,292 267

008this reduction is made possible through a substantial contribution of 41 m657 314 or 28.35 per from the state of Connecticut which provides essential funding to support the city's educational financial needs so we wanted to um really emphasize the budget drivers these are the areas in which are we are that's really driving the increase that I'm proposing number one is human capital this is the most significant investment in our students learning 5865 per of the total budget is comprised of salaries and benefits the wage line items increased to 81,7 77,4 49 of the total budget of 146,147 581 or 34.3 2% of the 12.58% increase the information below represents a partial decrease description of this increase the second year of the contracts Union contracts were 2267 3351 and 818 amounts to an increase of 1,278 53

009or 8.73% in funding with Equity increases in Step movement the first year of the Bristol Federation of teachers three-year contract amount an increase of 3,252 a 6.32% increase with step movement increases related to special education tuition transportation and services amount to 6, 33,6 69 this equates to an increase of $594,000 for tuition 2,266 1864 for special trans EDS transportation and $2,253 221 for contracted professional Technical Services regular transportation and fuel costs Rise by 29 92,3 $35 or 6.58% the increase is due to contractual obligations and the loss of significant Federal arpa funding for housing insecure students these are beyond our control but necessary to ensure our students safe and efficient Transportation the Connecticut inter Scholastic Athletic Conference or the C Revis its bylaws allowing High School coaches to conduct summer coaching and training we will

010open summer coaching and training to continue equitably supporting our athletes as they compete with peers across the state has an anticipated budget impact of $3 36,3 41 this slide presents the same inter information as a previous slide rounded to the tens of thousands our district recently received a large maintenance of effort increase in our overall allocation for fiscal year 2025 which we strategically applied to our tradition line and our special education budget this gives a false appearance of a small smaller increase to our special education tuition request for the 2025 2026 fiscal year the rising costs of special education tuition which have been increasing year-over-year continue to present a significant challenge although we allocated additional funds to special education the substantial rise in tuition has reduced the apparent impact of this recent increase simply put

011the costs are growing faster than the funding can offset the funding request to the city for estimated excess cost reimbursement is based on the amount we received in excess cost in the previous year since this amount has been uh decreased by the state to an all-time low of 64% reimbursement we did not increase the estimated excess cost reimbursement for fiscal year 2026 so we wanted to provide you with a Time line and um details on the 2025 2026 budget process number one we updated contractual increases and those are applied to positions enrolled to the new year we forecast employee benefits based on current Staffing levels as in past years each building administrator and department head prepared a budget to present to myself and the central office team after budget meetings with administrators central office reviewed

012requests to streamline where appropriate worked we worked with vendors and staff to finalize salaries and benefits we reviewed current grants to see which items might be moved to those sources of funding based on the grant requirements and of course we prepared today's and next week's presentations in additions to these items we wanted to emphasize that Bristol Public Schools also engage in a fiscal audit with CLA um thanks to collaboration and funding with the city we've also had discussions with CLA regarding the development of a financial dashboard and um I should also add that based on the audit recommendations we've already started at central office to look at those recommendations and Implement those recommendations in terms of our current practices we've also engaged in advocacy efforts along with uh other groups such as the Connecticut Association

013of public school superintendant including communication with Bristol legislative delegation and other educational officials regarding the uncontrolled tuition costs charged by private schools who work with our needest students including specialized Transportation costs associated with outplacement services and the rising number of students in need of these Services I would like to Now call on my colleague Amy Martino director of people Personnel Services to provide us with more information about special education costs Mar thank you Miss White I'm excited to talk about pupil Personnel Services this morning as I'm sure many of you have seen both in our social media of the city uh highlights and newsletters from the city um but even across the state special education costs are of concern across the state and really across the country um for the start of the 2024 and

01425 school year you may have noticed a change from us using the title of special services to pupil Personnel Services we did so to more accurate accurately reflect the expenditures that are overseen within the department so beyond special education costs it is important to know that pupil Personnel Services oversees costs for any type of service that any child would need such as nursing services or related services for General and special education students in term ter of Section 504 those plans oversee programming and accommodation needs for general education students and that is overseen within this department too so that's just an important fact to be aware of so on the slides in front of you you'll see a couple of trajectories um the Bristol Public Schools does have a rob a robust Continuum of special education

015services in addition to co- teing which would be a special education teacher providing instruction alongside a general education teacher we support students who require one-on-one or small group instruction in smaller resource settings and for students who require a partial of full day self-contained program we have 32 program classrooms across the district serving students from prek through 22 I know that number might be surprising um and when we look at you know 15 years ago for example we had three lead classrooms whereas now we have eight and that's exponential itially growing in terms of our destinations Learning Centers and breakthrough programs 14 classes altoe we provide instruction to students who require intensive behavior and social emotional skills along with their academic instruction our Excel program eight classrooms in total provide functional academic and adaptive living skills

016and they have students with pretty significant um Health needs um we respond to students who have breathing equipment needs feeding tubes one-on-one nursing Etc in our lead programs we have eight classrooms in total and they support students on the autism spectrum but only those who require the most significant level of servicing including discrete trial instruction so as you can see on our slide our IND District programming has increased dramatically over the past 5 years in particular I can tell tell you there was some questions about the number of seats in each program and generally speaking uh both the state and Unions would say 10 is a general number that we look for 10 to 15 is about the enrollment I can share with you that every classroom with the exception of two Excel classrooms are

017overc capacity one of our Learning Centers in fact has 17 students where the cap would be 15 so when we look at this trajectory this does not include costs of Transportation including wheelchair vehicles does not include the nursing services or physical equipment that we require for students to eat breathe toilet nor the devices that students might need to communicate and that's just to name a few of the services in the December meeting we did want to highlight some changes that we've noted that we're just unexpected because I do think that's an important piece of this so as of December 1st of the 96 students that were newly enrolled into Bristol 76.7 of the newly enrolled students required either either an in District program outof District program physical equipment or communication device in addition we needed

018to add three onetoone pair Educators based on IEPs that we had received last year we spent approximately half a million dollars on onetoone services and just from July 1 to December one we have expended an additional half a million dollars for services that we just were not anticipating next slide please before I turn the presentation back over to miss white I do think it's also important to speak about the special special education budget and the three critical impacts one is the anticipated costs we heard a little bit about that so we can anticipate salaries the number of students gener generally speaking in magnets or private or in District programs the second would be anticipated versus actual grant funding and excess cost reimbursements that's another key um impact and then the third is the unanticipated student

019needs revision and contract Service delivery and then the state mandates that usually come out every July 1 when we look at this chart um and I'm sure miss um white will share in more detail but one of the question areas that you may have in the audience is that professional service line that's quite a large driver of the special education budget I think it is important to know that $3 million of that line is for related services or contracted service at outof District programs so while we might have a tuition that goes with uh a student that is there there's also additional services that are not combined with the tuition so $3 million right off the bat is for the additional services with that that also that line also takes into account the one-on-one Services

020hearing and vision services for students in District with hearing en Vision impairments and um equipment just to name some of the few uh big drivers of that line and now I will turn it back over to miss white thank you very much M Martino as you can see from the spreadsheet above Bristol specie Education costs have risen significantly but the amount of funding we receive from the state of Connecticut has not even though State reimbursement continues to drop Bristol strives to provide excellent special education programming and services to our students and their families the reimbursement percentage for all students within our adjusted equalized net Grand list per capita has dropped to 64.9% for for schol year 2025 substantially lower than last year and the year previous this unanticipated budgetary shortfall coupled with much higher costs

021unb burdens the City of Bristol and its taxpayers Bristol has spent approximately $1.4 million more than previous years through December 1st 2024 for special education and with the reduction of excess cost reimbursement we are already receiving $1 175,000 less than what was budgeted for excess cost reimbursement for the year we want to be transparent about our staff we have not previously presented all of our substitute and miscellaneous positions in the current school year we are regularly reviewing all positions in reconciliation with munis we have identified that vacant positions have not been reflected in total staff counts prior to this year we are rectifying the situation by ensuring that open positions are marked accordingly as pending within the system and are accounted for since these positions correspond to funding we will include all positions going forward

022you'll also notice sub supplemental and substitute positions are accounted for on this chart as they have a fiscal impact on operating and Grant budgets supplemental employees are examples of these employees are tutoring stiens coaches paid student interns adult education Family Resource Center employees learner engagement attendance program employees um also known as the LEAP program which is a grant we received from the csde to improve student attendance this slide provides a list of requested additional Staffing for the 2025 26 school year as you can see on the slide we are requesting a dean of discipline at each of our high schools Bristol Central and Bristol Eastern based on current administrative assignments when we look at per pupil cost of Administrators across the district we are spending the lease on our high school administrative teams indicating a

023higher student to admin ratio than we see at any other level and I know I've had conversations um with some of the board Commissioners regarding this and we'll have more information to share at our next uh budget Workshop we are also asking for uh behavioral support at Southside school business teacher at bames colonary teacher at Bristol Eastern and we're also looking at other positions such as tsol a junior Tech position and two security guards at the elementary school I should also note regarding the two security guards we are also actively seeking Grant funds to cover these positions this slide shows a proposed budget by character um we believe that this is the way that we've previously presented this information in uh past budget presentations this slide show shows a summary of our proposal I also

024want to point out um the new information here is the number of fulltime employees which is that middle column um I think there may have been a typo um in the books that show that as a dollar sign but that's actually the number of full-time employees as budgets are created well in advance of being spent many variables can affect a proposed budget I will go over the ones that can have the greatest impact the current medical insurance Co Insurance costs are a 13.3% increase a rise in these costs would directly increase the board of education budget expense resignations and retirements can also lead to unexpected costs and savings as new staff are anticipated to come in at a lower salary but retirees may receive Severance payments our budget is calculated based on student enrollment per

025people expense or PPE changes can affect funding levels increase enrollment may require additional resources while decrease enrollment could lead to budget cuts or reallocations students with biling or special education needs may require additional resources such as additional specialized teachers or support staff or student specific materials or programming regarding uh certified salaries this pertains the contractual increases included for two new positions um also in the latest uh approved teachers contract teachers received a general wage increase per step these figures do not include any salaries allocated to Grants and again contractual wage increases are 3,7 75,500 regarding salaries for non-certified um we've had increases um the number of par Educators because of students with one-on-one needs we've had Equity adjustment to bring up the industry standards for the 818 supervisors Union 3351 Union there was collapsing of

026the salary schedule in the latest negotiations reduced step one and changed the way secretaries reive stipend for bachelor degrees budgeted overtime increase to be closer to actual expenditures overall the non-certified staff will increased by 1,410 785 this slide shows salaries for all others others include tutors substitutes we no longer have the ARP eser money to supplement um our money that we are available available to pay for substitutes we also have additional coaches that we did not have in the past overall we will see an addition of $583 in all other salaries the salary increases for all Bristol Public School staff are 5,634 169 and here you see on this slide um the salary budget drivers are shown here on this slide employee benefits contractual obligations are the driver of the increases and employee benefits our

027Actuarial Consulting staff at Lockton in line with our commitment to transparency estimates our insurance costs to increase by 133% .3% over last year we want to keep you informed that we will receive no additional help from the insurance reserved this year increasing the amount the board must cover making the budget change percentage look larger than it would be if needed we would receive $750,000 from the reserve as an offset last year Social Security and Medicare increases as salaries increase Severance was increased to be closer to last year's actual overall we see a 3,993 759 increase and employee benefits professional Technical Services our budgetary increase is a reflection of the importance of professional Technical Services which cater to our outplaced student needs people Personnel Services expenses and athletic expenses increases are the driving forces Behind These

028increases other services include property and liability insurance where we have budgeted and anticipated annual increase software costs continue to increase due to the need for updated and more software more secure software Solutions staff travel and conferences has increased to reflect the current market conditions mainten maintenance supplies services and utilities this slide details our estimate of utilities including electricity water and gas based on the contracted amount of services for the City of Bristol it also includes the supplies necessary to maintain our building facilities such as cleaning products repair materials and office supplies we are pleased to report that the city's investment in solar generation has resulted in significant energy credits effectively keeping our electrical expenses at a minimal increase for the next next fiscal year overall utilities maintenance supplies and services show an increase of $

02948,49 student transportation as we approach the final year of the first student contract it's crucial to note that we will be going out to bid in the next fiscal year this transition May significantly impact our upcoming trans Transportation budget the special education bid we received for fiscal year 2025 had a substantial increase with some rides costing over 50% more this surge is primarily due to our preco contract ending on June 30th 2024 posing a significant budgetary challenge transportation services will see a significant increase of $2,737 in fiscal year 2026 this rise is primarily due to contractual increases and the rising fuel costs which are the main drivers of our transportation budget tuition to other facilities due to leg legislative changes that took place in July 2024 regular education tuitions have been maintained at fiscal year

0302025 levels special education tuition continues to increase faster than we were able to budget for it the amounts would have been much larger without the additional 1.4 million the city provided to the board of education and fiscal year 2025 for maintenance of effort overall we have increased the amount of funding and expenditures to other schools by $594,500 educational supplies and materials this slide presents the budget amounts for instructional supplies as requested by our principles and department leaders please note that posted rate Ates have increased while administrative Supply expenses have been reduced additionally funding for library books and periodicals have been decreased due to the availability of many educational materials now being available online overall the budget request has increased by $242,500 equipment and capital outlay we have tried to keep cost down and have no

031increased ability building and site improvements equipment and uniform costs have increased and the bism line was increased due to increased expenses in that area overall equipment Capital outlays have increased by $127,200 cost reimbursement funding by the state over the last three years we have been cautious in increasing the excess cost reimbursement line at this juncture it would be unwise to add additional credits without the certainty of receiving that funding it's a risk that we are very reluctant to take and this once again um it's a 2025 superintendent proposed budget this includes our budget presentation um as said earlier and also said by the mayor this is the first Workshop number one this is the first proposed budget presentation we will now invite you to ask questions which we will record and then be prepared to

032respond to during our second budget workshop on Tuesday February 4th from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. in the Boe Auditorium thank you sh oh are they asking questions or turn on your mic there we go okay thank you very much for this excellent trans uh presentation uh I was going to say Transportation but um it appears that after some considerable conversations we Year Marie can you just introduce yourself yes I'm Maria Brian I'm a member of the board of finance and I am the board of Finance Lees under the board of education so some of my comments have to do with conversations over this past year with regard to last year's budget present and some of the constructive comments that we have shared about how to better present um what uh at least I as a

033member of the board of Finance might need to understand about your budget so first of all uh thank you very much for listening uh superintendent white thank you very much to you and your team for presenting the information that I think is most important to us so to some questions that I have that um might be clarified by the next Workshop um having said that about the financial information that you've presented I do have a couple of academic education questions the first is what do you Board of Education rely upon as your top three metrics for the academic performance of students in our K to2 system in addition with respect to teacher professional development and I do understand that there were some high quality workshops or institutes that were presented to a select group of

034teachers this past summer can you report on that uh another question the two deans of discipline are those both academic and administrative positions and if they are not why could they not be offered at a different professional level and different salary position um another question non-certified staff is there any way to reduce the costs by being more creative or Innovative in how you manage your non-certified staff slide number 24 are the benefits that you present accurate with regard to the controller's office understanding about those benefits or anything that our insurance subcommittee of our Board of Finance is negotiating slide number 25 your software costs with uh some discussion this past year under the mayor's guidance of a collaborative it department and some of those technical costs being shared is there any way to reduce some

035of those software costs slide number 26 what do you mean by lease rentals and can that be reduced slide number 31 obviously a big Financial nut that we all will need to take uh a close or monitor closely as the legislature determines how they're going to deal with special education cost this year and that is what will be the percentage reimbursement for uh ECS will it in fact go up to what you we all deserve which I think is 91% thank you I appreciate that thank you uh through the chair are we going to be able to discuss as a board as well yes okay um so we will start with questions from the board um thank you Marie from the board of Finance uh and then we'll go back if anyone has questions um

036May I begin public absolutely okay um first I think uh I just wanted to thank everyone for taking the time out on a Saturday morning to join us to listen to this presentation um I know there was some concern um in the community as to why we would hold this on a a Saturday morning rather than a regularly scheduled meeting which is usually at 7 p.m. but I have to say this time works out a lot better for a lot of people because there's a lot more people than I've ever seen in my now four years on the board at this meeting and I think it's a testament to um what we want to do which is collaborate with the city so uh the mayor mentioned it at the beginning but this meeting came as

037a fruition from discussions about collaborating between the two boards um it was something they've done in the past and it's something I think the board should consider doing in the future especially its first Workshop which tends to be um its most informative one whereas the second Workshop we usually come back with Solutions changes and things like that um I wanted to kind of turn and weave throughout um the presentation um one of the things we keep hearing about is excess cost I don't know that many people in the community really understand what that means and I think it's an important story that we have to talk about um excess cost is essentially a formula that says the city should absorb up to four and a half times the average cost of a student before it

038receives a reimbursement from the state and so what you heard today was that for our excess cost we received 65% of that overage so for every dollar of four and a half times of what the city absorbs we receive 64 cents on the dollar as a reimbursement which puts us in a very precarious position as a city so when we start to budget the state automatically assumes that we should cover up to four and a half times per child what we actually spend per child that is not something that you could easily budget for and so when people look at special educa or pupil Personnel Services cost and they ask well why does it Skyrock every year why are there changes it's because there's such volatility and unpredictability and it actually puts the burden on

039taxpayers it's not something that anyone on this board looks to do to burden the city it's something in a reality that we actually are dealing with on a day-to-day basis the other thing that we find ourselves grappling with is that there's no cost on tuition cost when we send kids to other schools out of the city now uh Miss Martino presented programs lead breakthrough all the different types of classrooms that we have continued to increase to keep kids in our town but what you also heard from her is those are supposed to be Capp uh classrooms and they're busting at the seams meaning we need more of these classrooms in order to prevent outplacement but we also have no control on outplacement if people want to send their kids out of town to a different

040program they have that right we have a right to to dispute and fight it but ultimately in the state of Connecticut every child is guaranteed a quality education and under federal law idea and other laws they have a right to dispute whether they are actually getting that public quality education and so those types of costs become uncontrollable and unpredictable I wanted to point out in the budget 5.6 million and $3.9 million are fixed employee costs that's $9.6 million or almost 60% of the increase that we have presented today now we saw that there were some requests for um increases in full-time employees and I think as a board we want to talk about how we can be creative and getting those employees that our staff says are a high need for them um you know

041we opened with the Salvo unfortunately that we're seeing a 779 million loss um in motor vehicle valuations which is about a $2 million hit in total tax revenue for the city and so we I think on our end we completely understand the need to have these conversations I think from a board perspective we see an increase in emplo about 200 employees um from 2023 to 202 four in total FTE at 22 23 23 24 so I think as a board we have to talk about how we want to restructure our employee our total FTE so that we can meet the needs more creatively of the district but I also think we have to be real about what actual cost we have to meet which is that 9.6 million that's a that's a bottom line cost

042that has to be met regardless I also wanted to talk um in case people are worried about um those uh salary increases and changes this year we actually had a lot of uh uh open and strong Communications with our unions and came to final agreement threee agreements um when you are negotiating with a union you are also negotiating against a state settlement rate which you have to look at and so we came very very close to what the state settlement rate would have been if we go to arbitration now if we are below the state settlement rate and the union wants to go to arbitration they'll likely they'll likely win that scenario which is understandable because if across the state people settle at 3 and half% increase and we decided we were only going to

043give a 2% increase you better believe that in arbitration they're going to get closer to that three and a half per. and so these are all realities that we're dealing with and I think that as we uh as we look to present this budget from my perspective we obviously have to be under $16.4 million how we get there is really going to be a test and a question and it's also will be a stress for our district we have asked year-over-year for X more million dollars in the budget we do not get it and we understand that the city has to play a role in balancing its own needs with taxpayers but we also have to play a role I also wanted to point out something else in the news we it was shared that

044we have currently an $1 million deficit that $1 million deficit did not post about 6.4 million of revenues so our actual projected deficit for the current year is around $4.5 million we are already starting with a whole and that's another important piece is that we are already starting with a hole and now we're trying to C play catchup and so I think some of the numbers that you see here start to reflect what that catchup really is but I also think there's a lot of collaboration that can happen you know Maria O'Brien mentioned it with um Information Technology services and a couple of other things and so I think that's where we um we really need to start looking at um certain items and I think that's all I had in my notes so thank

045you thank you any other Commissioners have any questions no um I I I have a few good morning um so just a few things I um wanted to ask was this year we moved up the um school start time to um we were told it would give us a cost savings for transportation so I'm wondering if there was any cost savings to adjusting the school start time um last year first student was not getting our kids to school on time or home um almost daily it was a there was a big problem so our um Dr carboned said we were possibly going to um ask for for their contract for students contract if they weren't getting our kids home or to school within a certain time frame we didn't necessarily need to pay for that

046so we were going to recoup possibly um per the contract for their inability to bus our students so I don't know if we recouped any money uh in regards to that with for student and then with the alliance District um The Alliance Grant I know we're not covering that today is any part of this budget um going to be funded by Alliance or that's about $14 million last year the year before it was 11 so I'm just wondering if we're going to have more things presented to us as costs with the 14 million or if that's going to be part of this budget here and that's all I have for now thank you thank you refer to my notes so I apologize if it seems a little choppy I do have some questions around um

047why we may not have received assistance from insurance Reserve is there um an opportunity to explore whether or not that will be available to us um some of the questions that I had were addressed both by Maria O'Brien and some other Commissioners um specifically maybe as a followup looking at how we may be able to to redistribute Staffing or um be creative if we need to increase the Staffing compliment of how we might use um the skills of the staff that we have currently um I have I do have a question about how some of the vacancies uh may have changed over time I I like that we have included uh the impact of vacancies in our presentation because it it sometimes we need to hold spots and that is still part of the budget

048even if the staff compliment doesn't necessarily show that we have this Staffing number while we're um trying to refill positions um have we noticed Trends or changes in our staff vacancies um over time and I would hesitate to lose those staffing places um because we're having a hard time filling uh positions because of what's Happening throughout the state especially with certain certifications um so how can we maintain these vacancies um and have it be sort of understood that we need to keep those Place those placeholders in our budget um I did have a question about the behavioral supports at Southside but that was asked by Marie O'Brien um would be helpful to understand a little bit about the bid bidding process for transportation especially because it's been a topic um and pursuant to what uh

049commissioner van Gord asked if we received a return on um some of the contractual obligations with first student and I know that that can also be sensitive because we we want to be mindful that they have an operation to run and that we want to be able to continue to support their need for finding bus drivers and people to provide Safe Transportation to our students as well so I know that that is a a very delicate balance there um again my apologies because I'm referring to my notes here um I I heard that there was an increase to equipment increase to uniforms some of my questions might be any of the increases to uniforms and such was that a result of contractual obligations I know we it was a it was a very big year

050with our um Union negot iations so really from my understanding making sure that I know that some of these things may be out of our hands they contractual obligations and and I think the presentation did a good job with showing um where things were the result of contractual obligations but the question about the increase with equipment and uniforms were uniforms a result of contractual obligations with reimbursement in the contract um and equipment what are we seeing with our equipment needs is it maintenance equipment um you know what sort of equipment there are we noticing because obviously we want to make sure that we're keeping our schools safe and wellmaintained do we have I know that the anticipated Revenue was stable do we expect in any way that we might see an increase somewhere to that

051to that Revenue um to offset some costs if we know that that's going to be pretty static then certainly is is we can't expect we there's not going to be an increase in return there um but I also would like to say that I appreciate the collaboration I thought that this um the feedback that was provided to the district about how to make the presentation uh a little more user friendly and understandable and fill in some of the gaps I thought that this really hit that and it was really well done um and I I appreciate that I was able to understand it and then be able to formulate questions um based on an understanding rather than you know feeling there are some things that might have been a little bit nebulous so I think

052that's all I have for now and well done thank you okay anyone in the um gallery that would like to ask questions I I just want to First reiterate what Marie said very focused presentation excellent um I think we have good numbers of board of Finance members here myself like getting to the point and you're under an owl which is great and I don't want to keep us too much longer than that um but a couple areas I'd like to just bring up and have you focus on and give us a little bit more detail when we were speaking to commissioner Russell Tucker about the maintenance of effort uh issue that we had in the additional $1.4 million she had kind of directed us towards the grant dashboard not an expert on this but looking

053at that Grant dashboard um initial look and I'm not going to throw a number out at you and because I don't want that to get misconstrued anywhere but it looks like there were significant amounts of Grants mostly in adult education that expired in June of 2024 I know that the previous administration when we were going through budget negotiations at this time last year felt like we would be coming in at a much lower deficit than we did see and that we don't want that miscommunication to happen this year so I'd like to just get a better uh understanding of what grant funding goes to one place to the other and um as an example to that let me see if I have my notes here right yeah there were I think you took 25 positions

054in this this current budget year and pushed them over to grant funding whether it's new positions or others um you know we had $3.2 million New Alliance grant funding to cover that that comes out to about $128,000 per per position so it's pretty close in math you look like you're proposing five new positions I think all towards Grant this year um that would be an assumption that we're only going to get an additional $640,000 from Grant Revenue uh I don't want to chase Grant Revenue but I think that's a little disparity and I'd love to get a little more clarification on what's happening in that area um one other real interesting thing too that's kind of related to that is I the salary benefit portion of your budget is 58% I think you guys stated

055that was a little surprising to me that number used to be much higher and I know Transportation other things like this are probably creating that draw but typically we like to see 7 80% go to our people that are in front of our kids so there's got to be ways we look at that with Transportation I think people covered that just happened to be talking to um u x mayor Bouton now commissioner Bouton and CT built has a program that uh is on a 90-day pause unfortunately but it's kind of a green energy program where you can work with companies like first student and I'll try to connect you all to to look at this they want to bring in electric buses but when they do that first student gets the electric bus they still

056provide service but we get the rebate back um which is significant dollars she's told us so you know we we need to save on Transportation everybody agrees on that I'm looking for innovative ideas you have a lot of good questions that came there I'm an am in special education which is tough um we definitely uh see reduction in state funding there is good news here for all of you we're not the only one in the state you know the the 12 cities that are larger than us hit get even hit harder that's where our state legislators live that's where the power is on the state government I will personally be going to ask for more help on special education and to that end I don't want you to chase revenues on excess cost but I

057think a a more realistic look at the budget is helpful and I'll give you the Cityside kind of analogy you know we we've been doing very good in conveyance fees and interest income uh things where that's Revenue we don't attribute all of it there because we want to run ahead and you don't want to be too aggressive uh but you're going to have to be a little more aggressive you're just GNA have to I mean even just this past year you I think four and a half million is your running deficit but a lot of that is reduced by a significant increase even though the percentage comes down of the reimbursement rate you're still receiving money more of a year and I am confident that the state legislature knows this as a problem it's the

058number one priority and I will be up in the governor's office office and other places and state legislators uh fighting for you on that one as well um I think everything else was covered here just let me look one second I think that's it thanks thank you I didn't introduce myself either by the way mayor Jeff K I think they knew I think we know really had a major impact because you didn't even mention all the people online but we had quite a few people online yeah do we have anyone else who has any questions in the gallery okay well I would like to just again reiterate and thank uh superintendent White and her cabinet staff for an excellent job of putting together this presentation uh it was a very transparent presentation um that was

059easy to understand why we are where we are um as I listened to to all of the dollar signs I had other Knowledge from conversations uh you previous meetings uh about the data and how it drives these decisions and because of you know time and not wanting to go really deeply into these things um I just want to say that when this uh when these people come to us and explain things to us about how they're getting to these numbers it is important when they're looking at data um when they're looking at the number of Professionals in a building versus the number of students and then how it impacts the behaviors or the fights you know specifically for asking for more resources to address the behavior issues in the high schools we also look okay

060well when all of these fights happen does impact their educational outcomes and we see the trends going down at the same time as we see the data showing that we're experiencing more kids that can't self-regulate uh these are dangerous things right and so I want to say I personally appreciate that these decisions aren't made only because we have to right but they are made because it is the reality that we're in and we care about all students in this town and it's not good for anyone to be in an environment where we're not meeting the needs of every single student and we've seen nationally a lot of violence and crisises in schools we don't want to be those schools and so along with that I also you know to commissioner um van gor's Point want

061to recognize the work that Lynn does in forseeing and forecasting additional expenses that couldn't come last year when we had bames Transportation um issues it was because when we budgeted and preco and we looked at um how we were going to have a new school and the school was going to be based on a lottery it pulls kids from all over town that was the first time we had a bus that had to go to Every location in the whole city which offset all of the transportation in the city because it wasn't something that you know I think was totally foreseeable or maybe the bus company didn't say well when you add this it's going to change the whole landscape of everything so we had to go through the Growing Pains of that which was

062very inconvenient to our parents our children you know our community in changing that time it didn't reduce the cost of the buses but it didn't create an additional expense if we kept the time where it was we had to add I don't know if it was five or six more at least two more more buses and so we prohibited that expense because of the Forward Thinking of learning from our um previous experiences and looking at the data and so when I think about the grants that we writing right now and the resources and I know we don't want to um add a lot of Staff based on soft money that's not what we're trying to do but can those Grant fundings help us in areas so that monies that we have can then offset our

063deficit uh we also are having a lot of conversations about the current staff and how we can look at things differently sometimes instead of adding additional staff how can we take the staff we have and redistribute um the the infrastructure so that it can meet the needs of the changing School District the people that are making these decisions are coming prepared with their data they're explaining it to us in ways that we really feel confident about what's being presented to us uh and for that I'm very very grateful so I just want to really emphasize how thankful I am for that um and when you look at increases to to special education cost again this is across the country these are things that you know are our reality and we also understand that you know

064when funding isn't available and in a year like last year where we were we didn't have we didn't see any increase to the to the budget it was completely flatlined that as commissioner um Telo said has a compound impact right and so we were really grateful for the forensic audit that the mayor and uh the um Board of Finance had suggested it really gave us a a deep look at our accounting and how we're spending money and the outcomes were very very helpful because it helped reinforce what we knew our expenses are increasing but our budget is is not and so it's a predictable uh problem that we're having and so I think just being transparent and having these conversations up front and having preliminary conversations is going to take that surprise factor out of

065things for people and help us to really um look at this as a Comm Community issue and how do we work together to figure out the best solution and so I really want to thank everyone for coming today uh you know our information is on the website as well all of the board Commissioners how to contact us if you ever have questions we're more than happy to sit down with you and answer those questions um again we're all in this together and thank you very much so with no further Ado we will adjourn the meeting thank you thank you very much h

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.