CorpusRecord 5271

01-08-25 Regular Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bristol Public Schools
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,479 words · about 120 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e five Board of Education meeting to the order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for stand One Nation God indivisible liberty and justice for all as a reminder please be sure to use your microphone when speaking and voting to ensure those online can hear you next we will have a moment of silence for Nancy clinch Kleinman I'm sorry executive assistant Boe 1960 to 1967 and 1978 to 2003 we will also have a moment of silence for Carson for Marlene Carson secretary Boe Green Hills Stafford o Connell 42886 to 12906 and we will also have a moment of silence for Timothy UST owski school resource officer Bristol Central High School 9824 through 9711 thank you the next item

002on on the agenda is staff and student recognition I will turn staff recognition over to Mrs White thank you chair Pond good evening everyone happy New Year um so it's my pleasure to announce the business Education Foundation mini Grant recipients just as a reminder the business Education Foundation through donations granted Partnerships is able to fund programs not normally included in the school or city budget the foundation also promotes Partnerships that enable Bristol Public Schools to benefit from corporate grants and matching gifts these Partners educate the community on the needs of Bristo public schools and deep in community support earlier this evening the minig grant reception was held and the following staff members received a mini grants so as I call your name and the title of your project if you will please stand so we

003could recognize you first um the first recipient was Erin rener from Baines her project was Wellness Fair she's not able to join us this evening but I wanted to make sure to recognize and congratulate her um the next recipient was Shannon Burton also from bames walls that talk unfortunately she also was not able to be here but I wanted to recognize her name next we have Crystal Russman from p Central High School her initiative was the ramal report congratulations Crystal next uh Gina Gallo from Bristol Central High School Gina received two grants let's see how I do the pronunciation again Gina po Italiano let's speak Italian practice makes perfect congratulations Gina next we have Steve from bril uh Central High School Union diversity a celebration of cultures congratulations Steve our next recipient was Britney marari

004from Bristol Eastern High School I believe britley just recently had a baby but some of her students uh were at the reception and talked about their project through Deca so those students would please stand unfortunately I don't have your name so if you could please keep what is it okay good maybe somebody's car um if you could please stand again I didn't have your names but I'd love to have each one of you say your name say Hello thank you very much thank you for representing Miss marcari next we have Justin mcdermit from Bristol Eastern High School friends in the Spanish speaking worlds congratulations next Katherine rck from Bristol Eastern High School Latin alive congratulations Catherine next Kimberly defusco from Bristol Eastern High School Color My World with positivity congratulations um the next recipient was

005Jessica EPS from Bristol Eastern High School destinations Academy she cannot be here but we wanted to recognize and congratulate her so congratulations Jessica next we have Steve Teran from chippin Hill Middle School PBIS school store congratulations to you uh next is Gina Weiss from brist um I'm sorry greenh Hill school and West Bristol School creating a century Library congratulations to next Terry Grant from greenh Hill School Quail in the courtyard conations Terry and I just started our last recipient also couldn't be here tonight Marcy Des Shan from Mountain View and her um Grant was our knowledge is for us so congratulations to Mars thank you next we will have next item on the agenda is the December 4 2024 regular meeting minutes you have all received a copy of the minutes in your packet are

006there any corrections or extensions motion to accept second motion has been made and accepted all in favor I I I opposed motion passes the next item is the through the chair we're having a problem with the uh video right now oh okay okay we need to take a brief pause just a minute okay they don't want to look at Lynn the whole time no and I'd rather not be on camera like that so thank you right yeah do what it was on Susan for a while in the beginning but then it yeah I know we did differently got it okay next item on the agenda is the December 18th 2024 special meeting minutes you have all received a copy of the minutes in your packet are there any corrections or extensions motion to accept second

007second motion has been made and accepted in second all in favor I I hi any opposed motion passes the next item on the agenda is committee reports the first committee report is finance and operations Mr tago thank you very much I will be delivering uh tonight's report on behalf of chair Carlson who um I think it's online but uh was late we're unable to attend our last meeting um our last meeting was actually held at 5:30 today um I think some of the important items uh to go over are um our current operating deficit which is at $1 million I think for context for the public um and for board Commissioners who haven't um gone into our finances typically uh were still in a positive uh position at this time of year um historically we

008usually end up in a deficit around February while we wait for our excess cost Grant to come through um and that number usually ranges between four to $6 million and that allows us throughout the end of the year to close out open purchase orders which usually balances our budget or leads us to a surplus unfortunately um given the nature of our deficit and given the fact that we uh haven't received significant funding from the city year-over-year I don't foresee and I don't think the staff will foresee that will'll end up um in a positive position by uh the end of the year just to give um an overview in our transportation cost we will continue to accumulate a deficit month over month due to contractual obligations we're currently over our transportation line by 329,000 $67

009but if you look at the numbers more deeply our biggest cost at the moment is our special education total which sits at $8.1 million deficit the uh issue that we talk about in our finance committee usually month over month is both the rising cost of transportation and special education that is uncontrollable as well as private and public tuitions for outplaced students unfortunately even though we budget for these tuitions in July or by July where our fiscal year starts we usually get bills around the fall and those bills can be more than what we budgeted for so if someone gives us an estimate of what they think they're contractual costs are going to be unfortunately those continue to rise year-over-year at the same time when we're trying to fund special education last year we are funded

010in the mid 70 range for excess costs which means if we spend x times over the amount of what we're expected per people we only get reimbursement 72 cents on the dollar that is an egregious amount of reimbursement and actually puts a lot of strain on taxpayers in Bristol recently over the fall we were alerted by the State Department of Education that the City of Bristol actually underfunded our minimum budget requirement by the amount of $1.2 million in December the board of Finance finally rectified that number and provided us with the additional appropriation I think it's just important that as people continue um to look to the next year and look get our Municipal finances they should be really concerned about funding education in this town and when we have our workshops at the end

011of January people should come to those workshops and see what's in our budget what we're paying for how we're trying to realize savings how our staff can be uh multifaceted but also strained I also think it's important that people reach out to their city council members and talk to them about why funding education is important because when we go into to uh the board of finance and we ask them for 5% or 6% or 11% we'll likely get 2% which means we will be in a deficit situation again in the next fisal year if that is a reality the other item that we talked about that was of import that I think is of importance to our community is our Capital Improvement plan is a five-year plan that we submit to the city um on

012an annual basis just wanted to point out some items that are on this plan so people are aware in the next fiscal year we'll be asking for $9.8 million and these include theater alterations at both high schools as well as the beginning phase of a project for roof Mechanicals at Bristol Central High School these are necessary because the roof Mechanicals are way out of date and some of the Mechanicals are double past their lifetime 2627 will be asking for $3.2 million in capital Improvement to continue the roof project and start the same at veral Eastern 2728 will ask for the total amount for Bristol Eastern roof Mechanicals and here's where it gets interesting we'll be looking to renovate some uh Stafford school which has not been touched in several years for $50 million in the

013next fiscal year following that we need to make HVAC upgrades at chippens Hill and targeted HVAC upgrades at Hubble School the total will be $3.5 million and lastly in future years we'll be looking to renovate Southside school as new for $43 million those are based on cost today not future costs and I think those are important uh for the public to know I think it's also important for the public to know that this is a continuous improvement process for our district we have a lot of buildings that are out to date we've done a lot of work um using our Sr art money to uh save the city dollars on targeted um mechanical and other upgrades but I also think it's important to know that in the year 27 through 29 the city will also

014be ballooning on its debt costs bonded costs and so these are all things that will play out in future years that will affect taxpayers and also I think what it does tell everybody and showcase tonight that education not only is a big cost to the city but it's an important one so as you look to Advocate as you look to elect people in the future these are the numbers that you should be looking at and knowing about uh we had no one from the public attending our finance meetings um I know was at 5:30 they're usually at 6 um but I would encourage people to start attending so they can learn more thank you thank you student achievement good evening uh student achievement committee we met on December 18th um we had the opportunity to

015learn about the Connecticut fitness assessment data as well as our high school program of studies um we discussed and approved our upcoming student achievement committee meeting dates for 2025 and there are four curriculum revisions that are on our agenda tonight under number 11 that we discussed in our committee meeting as well so we'll be learning more about those our next student achievement committee meeting is uh January 15th thank you uh the next item on the agenda is student representative reports we will start with Bristol Central Abigail Wasa good evening board members tonight I'll be reporting on Bristol Central High School for the month of December starting off with Universal Central Performing Arts BC Jazz Band concert band and percussion Ensemble performed at their annual holiday concert this pest month we also had performances from our

016concert choir madreal and BC Flats the Bristol Central drama club has also begun preparations for the spring musical they will perform Mama Mia this March and have been busy with workshops auditions and practices we can't wait to see the show turning to BC Athletics our winter sports are now in full swing and having great Seasons across the board we had one athlete from our volleyball team achieve first team class L all state so congratulations to her we love seeing our athletes being recognized for their hard work bchs students had lots of fun in December between spirit week that was set up by bchs student council and our annual FES of a celebration where students from all grades competed in games realized in Holiday trivia bchs is also proud to say that as a school we

017were able to raise a lot of money for the Connecticut Children's Medical Center by dressing in pajamas and donating now with the new year comes midterms right around the corner students and teachers alike have begun preparations for the upcoming test and even though this can be a stressful time we can't believe semester 2 is right around the corner I look forward to updating you on all future events thank you Abigail uh next we have Bristol Eastern Payton Troth hello and good evening ladies and gentlemen this January report will consist of the sporting events and activities as well as the updates on academics and extracurriculars at Bristol Eastern High School so this Sports season is in full swing and the athletes of Bristol Eastern have kicked off the year on a great note uh lots of

018students have been showing up to support our athletes as well as other teams coaches players and family and friends uh during winter break our boys basketball team defeated the bristel central Rams after a thrilling competition the game went to overtime and was a very exciting rivalry to watch uh as a senior and the boys basketball team manager I loved watching both Central and Eastern and battle it out through the love of basketball as it also was a great way to see the strength and enthusiasm of the community the girls team has also been doing well and has the record of three to three uh to keep up with sports this season you can look on all uh Eastern social media Pages uh the last month uh Bristol Eastern has had lots of activities for both

019students and teachers to be a part of uh the biggest event that we had this past month was our annual student teacher basketball game that happened right before break uh this event was filled with not only excitement but but festive Spirit the game was competitive yet friendly with students showing off their skills and teachers giving their best effort as well the crowd cheered enthusiastically enjoying every moment in the game but in the end the game ended with a tie and it was truly a memor uh a memorable event that brought everyone together to celebrate the holiday season with laughter and camaraderie uh as Christmas break rolled around both students and teachers eagerly embraced that much needed time off the break was the Perfect Blend of relaxation and celebration and recharging for the new year ahead

020so as school starts back up college visits have begun for seniors and all seniors have the chance to visit colleges of their choice like Sacred Heart uh Yukon and even Springfield College these visits are either in person or a representative from the school comes and talks to the students in guidance either way these college visits allow seniors to have options and explore colleges before deciding on their life post High School uh for the start of the school year the Lancers have been doing a really good job on getting adjusted to uh the new schedule and rules every Wednesday for 30 minutes we have blue crew which allows us for a home room to do activities last week we played a couple games and talked with our teachers but with these uh different activities that happen

021weekly we're able to really connect with one another and have fun with our teachers and peers so as always the Lancers uh and the student and staff have been working diligently this semester and we look forward to continuing the hard work thank you thank you Payton next item on the agenda is the chair report I'm pleased to share that the Bristol Federation of teachers overwhelmingly ratified their contract with 460 yes votes to only nine votes the bft president commented that this reflected the openness and collaborative nature of the negotiations this year we have also successfully ratified three additional Union contracts including 2267 818 and 3351 state law gives both Boards of education and unions representing teachers and other ized employees the duty to negotiate with each other over matters appropriate for collecting bargaining a common

022provision of collected bargaining laws requires employers and employees engaged in collective bargaining to negotiate in good faith this was my first experience on the employer side of the table and I am happy to share that while timec consuming the process was very informative and relational and accomplished in good faith I have a tremendous amount of respect for all of the BPS employees and felt that the unions did a great job working with the board to advocate for their members and negotiate and ratify Fair contracts the city contracted CLA an independent auditing firm to conduct fiscal auditing that aims to evaluate our financial data and Implement business intelligence by creating a dashboard the dashboard will allow the Boe and the city to better track analyze and display our financial data they have completed their draft report

023for the board's review one of the areas the report examined was BPS budget growth for the past three years relative to special education expenses and found that expenses grew 20% from 2021 to 2024 however the BPS budget has only been increased by 5% creating an imminent budget shortfall the review also found that I'm sorry total tuition for special education loan has increased approximately 15% over the last 2 years while expenses grew 20% from 2021 to 2024 this explains the predictable deficit mainly due to Rising costs in special education tuition tuition expenditures have been increasing 14 to 16% over recent years while the overall BPS budget is only incrementally increasing anywhere between 2 and 3% this report will be instrumental when presenting the budget to the board of Finance at the budget workshop on January 21st

024at 6m and we are very grateful for the city's investment in the audit and the dashboard jod goler from cab updated the model school safety policy he shared with the board his intention was with this latest version was to emphasize the district and school security and safety committees and the district and school security and safety plans he he will continue to draft a model administrative regulation that provides greater detail related to plan components response strategies and assessment the next school safety meeting is scheduled to meet on January 29th at 6 pm. the board has also contracted cab to conduct an audit of BPS policies and bylaws the audit is on schedule and the review will will begin this month cab anticipates the completion of the audit by mid-march the board will then receive a narrative

025report on the strengths and weaknesses of the policy manual and a chart of incomplete and out-of-date policies including suggestions and recommendations for our policy work lastly superintendent white was informed that the Connecticut state department education had received two Charter School applications for Bristol one from Kings Academy and another from Reach Academy the superintendent was notified on December 18th that the Connecticut State Department of Ed Charter School office assessed both applications determining that King's Academy submission did not meet the necessary score to justify a public hearing as a result the board was not required to conduct a public hearing for King's Academy in contrast reach Academy's applications scored sufficiently to necessitate a public hearing however the superintendent and District were initially unaware of reach Academy's application because they did not submit their application to the superintendent's

026office or the Bristol Public Schools grants office instead they emailed Ed commissioner perro Simmons and I and included a link to their application along with a message indicating that they had submitted their application to the state we were both unaware that Reach Academy regarded their email as an official submission of their proposal to Bristol Public Schools nor did we realize that they had not officially submitted their Grant to Bristol Public Schools the uncertainty surrounding their submission led us to question whether the hearing would proceed as scheduled on December 19th this confusion contributed to a lower turnout at the hearing due to the short notice provided I was present along with a few other Commissioners and central office staff to listen to reach Academy's presentation and to offer public testimony remaining neutral regarding their application while

027I support the concept of school choice and recognized the potential benefits that Reach Academy could bring I felt that there had been at there had not been adequate communication with the superintendent in school district this dialogue is essential to address the needs of our community including considerations for school space Transportation costs and other critical factors that should have been evaluated prior to reach application submission consequently we will be voting on their application this evening I have encouraged Reach Academy to engage with the superintendent and the district in the future if they should wish to reapply as the current application lacks several key details necessary for assessing the additional costs especially in light of our existing budget deficit based on the timing of the first public hearing for reach Academy's Charter School proposal and the low

028public attendance the Connecticut state department of education has scheduled a second public hearing for Thursday which is tomorrow January 9th at 6m at the board at the Board of Education in this room and although the board will have already voted our vote is only part of the process the second hearing will give the public and the board commiss and board Commissioners more time to review the application and share their feedback to the State Board of educ a this concludes my report next item on the agenda is the superintendent report thank you Sher P didn't steal all your stuff no no I must have known because I only had one item on the agenda which is redistricting which will be um a standing item um for my updates future board EV ENT meetings but I wanted

029to let the board know um that we were able to reconnect with Mike zuba and Pete Gallagher from slam collaborative who um worked on support of the district on phase one of the reging plan and they submitted a proposal to us today to work with us on the next phase oh oh sorry yeah I understand I'll move the microphone closer thank you um so MP Planning Group which is the name that uh zuba and gallager now work for they actually have their own firm now as I said submitted a proposal to assist us with the next phase of the redistricting um the scope of services is really designed to complement our technical proposals and provide uh coverage at public meetings as well as develop an interactive map of the recommended R districting scenario very similar

030to what they did during phase one so in their proposal thank you um they broke the project into three interrelated phases which I'm going to provide a summary of each phase but of course I can share the full proposal um with the board phase one is the Baseline conditions this is really focused on updating enrollment projections and capacities and this will inform our Baseline to um inform our reg districting options at both the elementary school and middle school level and NPS anticipates that much of this work will be completed this winter and spring with projections being refreshed with next Falls student enrollment phase two redistricting and swing space scenarios this focuses on grade reconfiguration um they will be looking at the swing space opportunities to support the Edgewood renovation and identify space for special program

031expansion they anticipate this phase of the work will occur this spring into the summer with final twins made to the preferred scenario once they again receive the full 2025 student enrollment and phase 2.3 covers coordination meetings and online map viewer this covers time for internal meetings um meetings with the Board of Education Community meetings and the online map view were similar to what was put together for phase one I should also add that um as part of the process they certainly want to start by meeting with the Board of Education meeting with BPS Administration to confirm data sources discuss methodologies and assumptions and agree on the final schedules and deliverables the initial meeting uh will include their assessment of our project schedule communication procedures and project deliverables and so of course um the plan is

032to work very closely with the board of education on all of the phases um also additionally I did ask um the presence of both the Bristol Federation of teachers and the Bristol administrators Union uh to survey their members to see what specific questions or concerns they have regarding the registering process the next phase and any issues or things that we should be aware of before we begin the phase two process um they completed the surveys we have those survey results which I can certainly share with the Board of Education and we'll also um share with MP so ahead of time we're making sure that we are very thoughtful about the process and making sure that we're engaging the full community and that concludes my report thank you uh the next item on the agenda is

033the consent agenda can I have well before we have a motion to approve we have to pull item 81a administrative hire uh Courtney Decker due to an error that says School the names of the schools instead of districtwide we'll pull the we'll pull the item from the agenda before the vote and then we will vote on that specific item after I move to approve the consent agenda item 81b through 81f can I have a second second the motion's been made in seconded all in favor I I I I opposed motion passes unanimously I will make a motion to approve item 881a uh as districtwide higher can I have a second second motion's been made in seconded all in favor I I I I I opposed motion passes unanimously uh did you include 82 grants in

034this oh I'm sorry I meant to do that yes okay so we I I will need a motion move to approve 82 move to approve 82 can I have a second second motion's been made and seconded all in favor I I I I opposed motion passes unanimously next we will have public comment Miss Everett did you receive any public comment um submit a comment comment you all have it your place hold on okay so we have public comment so I will read the rules okay during a meeting everyone is required to address the chair for recognition each speaker must State his or her name and address all speakers must observe rules of common etiquette personalities are not to be injected anyone violating this rule will be denied the floor unless waved by the chairperson or

035a majority of the board each speaker shall limit his or her remarks to 3 minutes a speaker will not be recognized for a second time on the same topic written statements and materials may be made available in advance of comments for distribution to board members speakers shall State their positions on the subject being discussed board members will not respond directly to committee to comments during the board meeting the superintendent will direct the question to the appropriate staff member for followup uh the first person is Jennifer benevento can you hear me now oh hello good evening uh ladies and gentlemen of the Board of Education um my name is Jennifer benevent I live at 239 Grove Street here in Bristol I have a 16-year-old who goes to Bristol Eastern High School and has been a member

036of the community since he started and is a a special ed kiddo um so I stand before you today uh to hopefully impress upon you my concern as to why a charter school for the City of Bristol is an illogical and harmful idea uh first let's address the severe lack of transparency and engagement with the community the proposal for a charter school has been presented with little to no meaningful input from the very people it will impact the students parents and teachers when decisions are made in the dark without proper discussion they inevitably alienate the community and undermine the trust that is so crucial in the education system moreover the privatization of public education through Charter Schools only serves to siphon tax dollars away from already underfunded Public Schools instead of investing the money in

037the resources and supports our students need it is diverted into duplicative management structures such as charment Charter management companies this ises nothing but add another layer of bureaucracy and is the and the result is a wasteful use of taxpayer money that could have been better spent supporting our local schools um I started to read the 300 Page Charter School application which is clearly designed so that nobody looks at it um talk about not being uh very transparent but I read it because it's my job and I enjoy that kind of thing and let me just be clear with you the ideas that were presented are easily implemented in the existing public school if only our amazing Public School staff were given the resources and autonomy to do so our teachers are passionate dedicated and more

038than capable of leading the charge and improving education but they need the support not the distraction of an unnecessary Charter School structure furthermore a charter school would erode Democratic control the charter school board Is Not Elected by the people it is it isn't held accountable to taxpayers parents or the local community the same way that public schools are decisions would be made behind closed doors without direct recourse from the people most affected by them finally let's look at the track record of charter schools in the state many have seen High staff turnover continued issues with having uncertified teachers failure to provide proper support under the state's teacher and education Mentor program and this leads to instability and Staffing lack of continuity in the classroom and is a disservice to our students despite their Pro prif

039eration in our states charter schools have done very little to close the achievement Gap I implore all of you to do a five minute search of this Charter School look at one of its charter schools in New York look at its comparison of grades compared to the state average look at the amount of turnover look at The Chronic absenteeism take five minutes and do a little bit of research it is not your you are abdicating your responsibility by shuffling it off to a charter school for these reasons the charter school proposal is misguided and it's illogical for Bristol our public schools are the backbone of our community we must invest in them not divert precious resources to privatize Alternatives that will only harm our children's education and I will be at tomorrow's meeting thank you

040so much thank you um I just want to add uh an additional rule for public comment that wasn't on my print out but is on the agenda members of the public are invited to comment to the board on any topic related to the items on the agenda we want and you absolutely did that we're voting tonight oh no it was not in response to yours I just wanted to make sure that I made the rules clear we really want to hear from all our constituents and if it's an item that's not on the agenda our emails are on on the website and we always want to hear from everyone but during board meetings we really want to hear about what we're voting on and what we're discussing and so I appreciate you keeping it relevant

041to our agenda thank you the next person on the agenda is Sue Tyler thank you chair Pon um I am going to read a letter from a constituent of mine who was unable to attend tonight's meeting and asked me to read this dear board chair I am writing to express my support for Kristen G Antonio who has consistently demonstrated unwavering commitment to advocating for students with disabilities in our school district as an elected leader Christen has gone above and beyond to ensure that the voices of students with disabilities are heard and their needs are met I know this because I am one of those students through her eff efforts Kristen has worked diligently to provide inclusive educational opportunities that recognize the unique abilities and challenges of students with disabilities whether it has been championing Poli

042uh policy changes ensuring proper accommodations or fostering an environment where students feel safe and supported Kristen has been a tireless advocate for me and my family I remember when I was having an issue with school placement my parents reached out to Kristen who helped guide my parents through the process she was was able to give my parents the proper information on who to contact which improved my ability to actually get into all of my classrooms freshman year if Kristen didn't take that time out of her day to help with my issue I would not have been able to succeed and participate fully in the first day of high school additionally Kristen has fostered an environment of open communication creating spaces where students with disabilities and their families feel empowered to voice their concerns and contribute

043to the ongoing Improvement of the school system her leadership in this area has been valuable in building a school district that is truly inclusive and representative of all students needs I felt fully empowered while a student in the Bristol school system knowing that an elected official on the board of education was supporting all students I am confident that Kristen will continue to be a positive force for change in our community her dedication is ensuring that all students with disabilities have a voice and the resources they need is truly commendable thank you for your time and consideration sincerely Emma Goldsberry 176 Macintosh Drive Bristol thank you thank you next we have jennif Jennifer tago J sorry and possibly Alex my name is Jennifer tago for the record and I reside at 64 holberry Road good evening

044superintendent white Commissioners and chair Pond I would like to begin my remarks by stating that I am glad that the gross waste of taxpayer dollars and a failed ethics complaint found by the board CH found the board chair innocent of all imaginary claims from that my hope is that this attempt at smearing elected officials will will be the last the fact that the complaintant in the fabricated claims appears in a sitting Board of Education Commissioners failed campaign videos is just more proof that certain members of this board are unable to do the work that they were elected to do and also are unfit to hold public office this leads me to my main reason for being here I am addressing agenda item 14 performance of a board member I have served proudly on this board

045for almost a decade I have been in the Super majority as well as the super minority I have witnessed and regretfully participated in partisan Politics as was the culture of this board for many many years I have never seen or imagined anything like this current board I can say with certainty that no other board composition would ever have allowed for such a clear and disgraceful dereliction of Duties as I wish witnessed on November 6th for four Commissioners to willfully and unnecessarily choose to witness a friend of theirs purger themselves rather than to conduct the business of the board is repugnant at best all four should publicly apologize to the eagle scout who had to wait to have his final project approved to the Mountain View PTA who had to wait to get their playground approved

046to staff and administrators who had to wait to finalize negotiations and to the taxpayers who they disrespected by putting Petty and fruitless smear tactics above the business of the district my expectation for the remainder of the term is that all Commissioners will finally accept that Shelby is the board chair and work collaboratively for those who are bitter about it I would advise to learn how to build relationships rather than destroy them learn how to work together rather than working selfishly and lastly put the needs of the 8,000 students in the district above their own thank you I'm not going to be able to say the name because of the writing but I'm going to try really hard is it Blaze traza sorry okay good good evening I'm reading this uh from a constituit Linda magnifico

047of Stafford Avenue my address is 58 lkin Lane in Bristol board chair I am writing this letter to support Christian jantonio a member of the board I am a retired special education administrator and have worked in the private sector for over 25 years most most recently as a principal for the web School Of The Institute of living so I am highly experienced in the area of evaluation and supervision of employee in the educational field if Christian had applied for a position with my organization I would have hired her in an instant and I would have worked and supervised a knowledable employee now that's an endorsement the City of Bristol is lucky to have Christian J Antonio on the board of education there are too few true advocates for our students with special needs Christian is

048one of the best she has shown this over and over again she has a great understanding of special education laws as a parent of a beautiful a beautiful Mia she understands the needs of families and how to even with all my knowledge and experience I still ask Christian for advice with my grandchildren when they need help and she was helpful and responsive Christian is a trustworthy intelligent compassionate member of the board and Bristol is lucky to have her best Linder magnifico thank you next I have Maria with the same last name is that easy I know good evening I am here to read a letter from a constituent and support of um Chris G Antonio dear board chair I am writing to express my support for Christen GI Antonio member of our school district spard

049of Education I know Kristen from both a personal and professional standpoint as a parent of a Bristol student I had the privilege of working closely with Kristen during my child's senior year and I was deeply impressed by her leadership commitment and unwavering support during a challenging situation in particular Kristen stepped in to assist when there was an issue with graduation her immediate response empathy and thorough followup ensured that my family received the support and guidance necessary to navigate the process to get the results we were seeking without additional stress throughout the process Kristen stayed in constant contact with me until the situation was completely resolved Kristen is an outstanding individual who cares deeply about the well-being of all students in our town her actions have not only helped my family but have also undoubtedly had

050a positive impact on many others she has earned my respect and admiration and I strongly believe that her leadership on the board of education is a great benefit to our community thank you for considering my input and support of christen jantonio I wholeheartedly believe that Bristol and its students are better knowing Kristen is on their side sincerely Amy goldsbury 176 Macintosh drive thank you thank you next we have Mike ereno good evening for the record Mike ereno 40 Palmer Place um I initially wasn't going to speak uh yeah I don't know just this is Alex everyone knows him and you all see he clearly is one of the special needs children over at Edgewood and I appreciate commissioner tagel pointing out the importance of funding particularly special education funding mean you guys see it firsthand

051you witness how far behind he is he's five and a half years old and that is not normal five and a half year old Behavior he's getting there before he started Edgewood he really didn't speak he was non-verbal yeah and now he's speaking and talks back to me by the way which uh is nice the other night he told me to go to sleep and get out of the room which is yeah it's it means a lot that he's actually starting to talk I apologize tonight if his behavior of his be out has been interruptive there's not really much I can do about that I can tell him be quiet a thousand times and Alex will do what Alex wants to do that's just the way it is when you're dealing with special education and

052uh and I just want to end with this I I'm very glad that there are members from the Bristol Republican Town committee eboard here tonight who saw firstand my son and saw firsthand his disability maybe now don't understand why I wanted Rob on the board of ed thank you thank you thank you the next item on the agenda is deliberated items here oh is there anybody online oh I asked Susan I'm sorry okay I have an additional question um last month a written public comment was sent in and it was read into the record so um there were two additional submitted written comments that I was hoping could be read into the record um so last month um Vice chair Simmons ran the meeting and um made a decision outside of where what our practices

053are and a apologized later for that that was something that misin it was a misinterpretation on her part we we have uh listed the rules on the agenda and I just want to make sure we're not picking winners losers things that we want to read things we don't want to read if a constituent wants to submit something that they are all you know treated equally absolutely and I have not read any public comments into the record since I've been the chair since we've had this rule so I'm not picking winners or losers okay I'm not sure that we have or we haven't but that has been the practice and so we're going to proceed I just like them to be part of the record thank you the next item is deliberated items District leadership team

054reports uh 10.1 reach Charter School application uh and I will turn it over to superintendent white thank you chair p um chair pond in her um update uh did provide a summary of the uh process of our involvement with the reach Charter School application um I've had a number of communications with the board trying to keep um all the Commissioners updated on information I've received from the Department um there were a couple of things I wanted to say before discussion and and vote uh first of all I have not heard from the reach Charter School um they have not reached out to me um there was one initial phone call um that was made they called our office um before the first public hearing wanted information about logistics what AV Equipment would be available um

055I got on the phone and the person was very surprised uh I didn't think the superintendent um would have time to talk and this really was very evasive so I still have not heard from uh the reach Charter group um I want to thank um the members of the board the community and also of central office who were able to attend uh the first public hearing which I was not able to attend I know there a number of folks who spoke so I appreciate the attendance um and your speaking at the public hearing there's another another public hearing tomorrow night I will be present um and I will be able to represent the board and the district in my remarks um also after the public hearing um the district is supposed to submit written comment

056to the State Department of Education charter school office which I will do so on Friday in advancement of the State Board um voting on whether to move the charter school application forward um at their regular scheduled meeting next Wednesday night Wednesday morning I should say so thank you okay is there any discussion the chair yes um yes I guess I'll start the discussion um I too read the uh hundreds of pages and applications uh for reach um in the limited time that I actually have um and given the compressed time frame that I actually have to consider this um I'm not going to get into the philosophical discussion of whether we should have Charter Schools or we shouldn't um I think that you know the state has a mechanism for how it wants to go

057about approving these schools they're available in 45 States in DC um and what I really wanted to look at uh was one does the application and what's said in the application truly match the data that's available and even though they didn't really send data to us the New York State Department of Education does have their data available online that you can compare not only to um to the district but uh Statewide one of the themes in their application that they stressed upon was uh their introduction of uh literacy they really championed literacy and um they talked about how they um will theme classrooms to specific topics that students are expected to learn and give them an enriching vocabulary by having opportunities to um uh review the vocabulary as it's around the classroom and so one

058of the things that I wanted to look at was how are they scoring in English language arts compared to their peers because that's really important because if the biggest thing you champion and what you want to bring to our district where you feel there is a need how do you compare to your peers um New York State Department of Education um has groupings grades 3 through eight um and then you could disaggregate that 3 through seven I specifically looked at uh their buffalo elementary school and I also pulled scores from our schools that were just elementary schools to kind of take a look at a comparison but I wanted to compare apples to apples so I compared kids in the Buffalo Public School System to the students at the Reach Elementary School in Buffalo interestingly

059when you look at their Ela results uh let me just put context they grade these level one through proficient level one two 3 four five proficient um when you look at sort of how they're clustered by even by grade level and then on the aggregate they are underperforming Buffalo public schools in ela in every single grade C interestingly when you look at the math results they're overperforming which I thought was strange given that they didn't highly stress mathematics as part of their program um the other thing that I wanted to look at was I think there is a concern and this may be specific to Connecticut about cherry-picking students when you go on Ed site and try to look at the number of students with disabilities and you select a charter school all you see

060is na which makes it impossible for me as uh as a a policy maker to make a decision as to whether we're going to have a school that can pick and choose kids or take funding and send them back to our school because they cannot provide for them um in Buffalo is is a different story they do serve populations of students with disabilities however when you look at the relative as a percent of a population it's 6% less so that was a concern when it comes to uh multilingual learners 14% less what I did find interesting as part of their data is they do Champion that they target um students who were economically disadvantaged and as a percent of the population they were actually 10% higher of serving that population compared to their peers um

061in Buffalo so I I did find that interesting um my biggest concern however is not just the timeline that um we are under as a constraint but I have seen zero evidence of support in that this community for a charter school zero I've had no one reach out to me that they want a charter school we've had one person tonight who um eloquently said why they're opposed to it but I've been no one reach out and I think the fundamental piece that this board has to consider is if it is going to support a charter school then there has to be a need in the community because typically when you look at Charter Schools they tend to serve urban areas and they tend to serve students who are either um ethnically biracial Hispanic or Latino

062or black or African-American those are the populations they tend to serve more and so for me when I don't see a need in our community when I don't have any evidence that there is a need when they don't share data of a need I find it unconscionable to move forward I also find it unconscionable to move forward because of the situation that we are in we are in 11 million dollar deficit at this point that number will change I know that we have been underfunded by the city which has been made up I know that but it's not likely to go much higher the state formula for funding education still has not been resolved it is a topic of discussion though probably not going to get where we want it to be and those factors

063in addition to the fact that I cannot see what student populations are current charter schools in Connecticut are serving don't allow me in good conscious to make a decision that I would approve this different place different time better data may be a different story because I oppose things just for the sake of opposing I have to look at the data and dig deep I did that when I read the application and I looked at their data so I am a hard now on this application thank you thank you any other discussion yes um through the chair if I may yeah um so I actually share a lot of commissioner Tag's uh concerns I did uh uh similar um information scraping on the internet uh looking at like the scores and things like that and I

064I came away uh pretty much as unimpressed as as commissioner tago did um and I do share a lot of the same concerns as as you do too um in this um so I you know the lack of transparency um I looking at their application they don't even have a um a building site prepared yet or even identified I mean they seem woefully impr prepared to you know get off the ground running here and based on their scores compared to like what our scores are frankly it's it's my impression that they want to use the the the Bristol student body to boost their numbers that's what it seems like to me um and you know um I'm I'm I think I'm a hard no on this for a lot of the same reasons so um

065thank you okay any other discussion I'll just um quickly through the chair I agree with both Commissioners I too was unimpressed with their presentation um it was lackluster and while I um do support school choice um I wasn't woed so if another school maybe wants to come and woo us maybe but um I this one was a pass for me too you okay any other discussion through the chair um I won't mirror a lot of the points that I agree with that are made both by the public and other Commissioners tonight I was present at the first um at the first hearing I had mentioned a lot of the same things that have been mentioned tonight in addition to that I had concerns about the process and I was critical of the process admittedly um

066with the timing and that um not notice to the public means notice to the public and it has to be properly noticed and really you know a few days or a week or whatever it was in the middle of the holiday season really was grossly unfair to the district the community you know um I'm not here to just shut every you know thing down that comes before us but if you if you really wanted the input and I think I said this at the at the hearing if you really wanted the community's input this wasn't the way to do it um uh the I was concerned about the ECS formula funding because it was my understanding that the charter school was seeking um some State funding and I was critical about how uh we have

067not gotten full ECS um State funding that was originally promised in the what we thought would be in the beginning of the year which is not helping our um special education deficit at all um and if they were willing to fund a charter school that was going to serve this community why aren't they willing to fulfill ECS funding to the levels that we're requesting um the last item was also concern because they had a a public speaker from danburry and most recently in the news Danberry had gotten approval for a charter school I believe it's in its fifth year I didn't bring the article tonight um but you could probably find it yourself if you're interested and they are still waiting for their state funding even after getting approved and having it site so those

068are some of the additional items just from that evening and I agree with most of the comments on and sented I am also opposed okay thank you any further discussion okay without further discussion can I have a motion to approve the reach Charter School application we're gonna vote right so okay I'll make the motion to approve it knowing my objection well I'll second okay I have a motion and it has been seconded all in favor say seconded that motion Comm J Tony all in favor all opposed no oos no opposed okay it is unanimously opposed the next item on the agenda is the 2025 26 program of studies and we have Mr Peter Wier good evening Commissioners uh I'm here tonight to seek approval of the 2526 program of studies uh which was presented to

069the student achievement committee on Wednesday December 18th uh before I present information I want to thank the office of teaching and learning for the work updating the program they did an amazing job combing through a really big document uh providing changes where needed and Alignment to our curriculum documents uh special thanks to Karly foron Ken Bagley Sarah hail Laur Lanza and legic Ward for their review and updates I also want to thank Mel vatrano my program of studies counterpart at be for her contributions as well uh just to highlight um Bristol prep has a new program of studies uh which is linked on the right hand side thanks to Ashley Albert and Chris Irvin for their work on that it is separate from the high school program uh because as you know B prep operates

070on Hex semesters so despite their smaller enrollment numbers um their p uh program of studies reflects a wide variety of classes in their respective content areas as well as elective offerings to meet the needs of their students and their ring admission so if you have this uh presentation you can certainly page through their program of studies as well if you'd like the program is electronically available most of the information within the program is uh information that you at the Boe have already approved through curriculum approvals uh or policy with the exception of courses that are slated to be finished later on this year any changes from the 2425 program won't appear in the 25 26 program until the boa has approved them students will have access to this document in January after the board of

071ed meeting and then they can start uh their course selection so next just a few highlights uh as you can see up here there's a number of courses that uh are being offered some new some old uh theater for social justice and inota digital photography are bames courses that are articulated with the Southern Connecticut State University and are now available to students or will be available to students once approved uh which will allow them to earn college credit while in school uh music theory 1 and two are now articulated with Yukon as well as the history of American popular music uh our our CTE courses which uh have uh been articulated for a while are listed here uh many are are um articulated with tungus and again can earn college credit While others in Project

072Lead the Way are either with University of New Haven or RIT um again listed above two new courses uh that we're working on in the approval and social studies are border states and nation which is articulated with Central Connecticut and the model of the United Nations which has been a a a little baby of John stavens over at Bristol East for quite some time so now offering that as a course is uh is exciting opportunity for him and his students as well as the students at Bristol Central High School next slide um highlighting those courses because all students are eligible to take them and of course that will help uh in our school performance IND uh index for each of the high schools where indicators about post-secondary preparation and Readiness uh can be fulfilled by

073taking these courses so um we're hoping to get your approval tonight so we can start scheduling process for next school year thank you very much um does anybody have any questions okay can I have a motion to approve the 2025 26 program of study course updates as presented so moved second motion has been made and seconded all in favor I I opposed I oppos who opposed I oppos okay motion passes with eight yes and one opposition the next item on the agenda is Bristol Central High School Exchange program and we have leash Ward and Dr Gina Galla well it says it here so it must be true good evening Commissioners um so I'm here to ask permission for two study abroad programs but really I'm here to introduce uh Gina Gallow who is tit in

074her work to provide students the opportunities to both immerse themselves in Italian language and Italian culture um you recognized her earlier for the minig grants she's won for just that purpose so today she's coming to request permission to begin planning two separate trips uh and being planning and fundraising two separate trips to Italy um one in 2026 which would um see an exchange of students from Italy to come visit um us here in Bristol before our Bristol students go visit them in Italy and then a 2027 trip to Italy um to attend classes at a language school there so J will tell you more about it and she she's passionate and knowledgeable and can answer questions you have about either of those two trips um after um I really just thank her for all the

075work she does to make these trips a possibility for our students so G good evening everyone uh thank you for your time um as Dr Ward stated um we are looking to um request permission and approval for two programs and I want to just kind of explain why we're looking to do to to request to it takes a full year to plan these programs we really want to give our kids and our families o opportune time to plan to fundraise and to really have a moment to decide which trip is appropriate for them some students to both so uh we really want to give them opportunity to to have time to plan so the first is a Exchange program um for 16 years we had an exchange program with Foo in the marquet region in

076Italy and my counterpart retired ired and I was desperate um and Foo called us personally the the principal from Foo called our school and said we will do anything whatever you want we would love for you to come back to us we have people in place that would like to continue um and so they they they reached out to Bristol um and I think that that's a testament to our district and to you guys um because there this is not happening everywhere um exchange programs and study AB Brads are not happening everywhere in in the United States but let's talk just Connecticut so um the fact that they reached out to us I think is uh a testament to the hard work that we do here um that's the first program and it's it is

077a true exchange we host Italian students here and then we go and study abroad there um and we stay with families and it is um it is one of the greatest joys of my teaching career and my um my job here in Bristol it is is really one of my my most passionate pieces um I'm really excited to propose the second um we always do the exchange is every other year so because it takes a full year to plan we can't do that every year um it's a I don't want to use the word burden but it's a responsibility on families and we can't really ask that of every year but we also have to know what kind of families we have so to meet the needs of all of our students we also offer

078a study abroad and so we partner with a language School in Italy and we go and study abroad there from usually to about 8:30 to 11:00 then we have a break we go from 11: to 1 we take classes and I take classes with them so the kids are in one room and I'm in the room next door getting the best professional development you could ever imagine um and we are looking at a school in Sardinia and this is particularly interesting because there is a program at Bristol Central that teaches about culture um healthy living and Healthy Lifestyles and they start the program with talking about blue zones if you don't know what that it is really magical um uh areas in the world that have the highest um life expectancies in the world and

079Sardinia in Italy has one of those blue zones and we have a program at bristell Central that teaches this and the teacher came to me and said we need to collaborate we need to do something together and so the Italian program and the life studies programs are combining and we're actually proposing this together so we can bring that program with us and both sides so it's not just a language study but life study as well um I have included uh a lengthy document with lots of details um I'm happy to answer any questions um and I appreciate all of the support we've had so far every time you tell us about these things I have the same question can we come you you are on a list of a very long list of of those

080who would like to join yes okay does anybody have any uh questions or discussion for Miss Galla I think they're called I I don't mind um I did review the itinerary and the Blue Zone looks really exciting and um I'm glad we're able to give this opportunity to our students so thank you thank you okay without any further discussion and I have a motion to approve the Bristol Central Exchange program with G nuli classical Language School in Foo Italy with student travel to Italy in the spring of 2020 26 as presented so moved second motion's been made and seconded all in favor I any opposed motion passes unanimously I'm going to keep you here because now we have the Bristol Central trip to Italy in the spring of 2027 yes and that's the language school

081that's the the first gonna say is there any discussion because you already explained that yes yep no okay and I have a motion to approve the Bristol Central Study Abroad trip to Sardinia Italy in the spring of 2027 as presented so moved second motion's been made and seconded all in favor I I opposed motion passes unanimously thank you so much gra the next item on the agenda is the pupil Personnel Service leadership team report and we have Amy Martino good evening good evening um I just want to uh thank uh commissioner tag lello for kind of sharing some of the budget discussions we've had at our finance meeting I think it's going to align a little bit with some of the other highlights I'll mention today um as you'll see on the slide I am

082going to be reviewing both December 1st and January 1st data in terms of overall special education enrollment we did go from 1784 from on December 1st to 1803 on January 1st we continue to stay around that 22% Mark of students requiring special education services when you look um at the private place students you'll see that from December 1st to January we went from 113 to 118 it is important to know that in the month of January we did have three students that moved into District that required out of District programming at the time of enrollment um which is part of that uh increase magnet enrollment went from 83 to 84 and then you'll notice that in terms of risk Assessments in December they were 37 in January there were 23 um I will say that

083in uh sorry as of January 1st and um in terms of psychiatric evaluations independent evaluations those are there um 911 calls again by December 1st so for the month of November we had two and in the month of December we had six however there were two that were errors so just to keep that in mind in the December Finance meeting I did want to highlight some pretty drastic um trends that were noticing that our numbers don't show each month so this graphic here really highlights some of the programming that we have in the Bristol Public Schools so um I would say that in Bristol we have quite the robust Continuum of special education services many may not know that in addition to co- teing which is a special education teacher providing instruction alongside of general

084education teacher we do support students who require one-on-one instru instruction um in a group setting or one-on-one instruction but in addition to this we have 32 um different programs throughout our district those programs serveice students from prek through 22 and as you'll see here um I've highlighted just some of our programs not all um but destinations Learning Center and breakthrough programs we have 14 classes in total they do provide students instruction who require intensive behavioral and social emotional Services alongside academic instruction our Excel programs which we have eight of provide functional academic and adaptive living skills instruction and you'll notice that our lead instruction which supports students on the autism uh Spectrum we have grown exponentially in that regard with to a total of eight classrooms to date and I can tell you all seats

085are full and we're bursting at the seams one one important fact that we noticed from July 1 through the end of December was that of the 96 students who were enrolled in Bristol Public Schools newly enrolled 76.7% of those students required either in District programming physical equipment communication devices and there were a significant need for additional par Educators to be added for one-on-one Services we also highlighted the exponential costs of Nursing services equating to about half a million dollars that we had not um anticipated and we've seen other fiscal impacts such as tuition costs um that were noted earlier as well as Transportation needs um so in addition to just sharing with you numbers each month that really kind of show some stagnation between that 20 to 22% I think we thought it was important

086to show some other trends that are really um actualized within our district are there any questions chair yes thank you for presenting this I know you know you present this to an audience usually of three or and then staff who already know the composition so this is this is important and this is just enrollment in specific areas right and another piece that you had put together um at my request and I thank you for that was uh specific those hard costs like physical equipment and all that stuff and I think you know us showing the story story we've get a you know we get a very nice Excel sheet showing month over month and um from the beginning of the year Trends but that doesn't really showcase a story this starts the Showcase a story

087The chaired mentioned that um CLA is assisting The District in creating a dashboard and I know you're part of those meetings and I think that's going to be um really helpful because as we start to showcase our story and enrollment and cost visuals like this have a big impact on people who may not fully understand what we're going through so I do appreciate the work you have done I know I said it at the finance meeting but I wanted to say it with a larger audience so they do know that you guys are working really hard to try to get others to understand what the district is actually uh facing because it's it's Monumental thank you for that and I can share that we have submitted the highest amount of excess cost reimbursement that we

088have ever submitted in Bristol Public Schools so let's wait to see what the state does in terms of response any other question questions thank you thank you next item on the agenda curriculum revision uh Pottery 3 is a new course and we have Mr Ken Bagley good evening commissioner superintendent white um I have three curriculum before you tonight to be for full approval that were presented thanks to Sarah Hae my colleague and my absence at the student achievement last month um the first up is Pottery 3 um Pottery 3 allows the kids to continue their study of of one of the most ancient art forms that we as humans know um through and we are um working on Pottery 4 as well so that will be coming before you within the next year or so

089so I'd be happy to answer any questions or entertain a motion to approve uh to implement this curriculum okay and I have a motion to approve the new course Pottery 3 as presented motion to approve second any discussion I just would like to say my daughter's in Pottery too she's very much so enjoying the class she was home sick today with a fever meds kicked in and she said mom can you bring me to school I don't want to miss Pottery that's awesome sorry not allowed but she is thoroughly enjoying it so I'm sure she'll be signing up for pottery 3 my daughter she took uh she took P at Eastern and I got to say we have some beautiful pieces that we still have on our y on our on our shelves that's that's

090awesome okay so the motion has been made and seconded all in favor I I opposed motion passes unanimously thank you uh my next curriculum is in our theater pathway um improv comedy um this allows our students to develop the skills for improvisational theater both comedic and dramatic um I know it says improv comedy but part of it is also going to be the dramatic improvisation as well um be happy to answer any questions or entertain a motion to uh approve for implementation okay and I have a motion to approve the new course improv comedy as presented so moved second motion's been made and seconded is there any discussion uh I did have a a question uh with the uh with the with the Improv um you know uh things that you guys be doing uh

091any plans to uh to have like any kind of like uh like improv comedy things or anything like that like at at the beames I I believe so I think I think part of their design is to have a performance of some and the what a lot of people first go to is Whose Line Is It Anyway yeah that's one of the most common people see but what I I don't think a lot of people see with improv is the use in public speaking and the use uh a lot of corporate developers use I follow a u improv instructor they get called on a lot of corporate gigs to teach improv to the corporate uh area BEC because it allows for better speech I would be a better speaker in public if I had taken

092improv theater but uh yeah there is there is some idea and then with bames hopefully between the between the student body and the uh parks and wreck that that would be another great act to bring in as a Whose Line Is It Anyways type show I'm sure that' be well attended thank you okay motion's been made in seconded all in favor I I I opposed motion passes unanimously you have one more Mr B thank you um the the last one I have for this evening is found object art and um it is exactly that using found objects to produce art and and Bristol has an amazing example of that at the pool um across the street from Eastern the whole back wall was uh and I don't have the artist name on the tip of

093my tongue right now that did the artwork of stuff that was found at the dump and it's a beautiful piece of artwork if you haven't had a chance to get up there and see it um but this course will teach kids about that idea of collecting and producing artwork out of items that are found either around the house or searched for or um just happen stance so I would entertain any questions or a motion to approve motion to approve second motion's been made and seconded are there any discussions I do have question um this is a course my oldest would also enjoy um but did we have to hire any new staff for the class or will we able to have a teacher that's already staffed pick up this course as we're developing our bames

094Pathways um we staff according to student sign up and and I think Miss foron could speak more to this but as students sign up for courses we we staff the courses that are most required some years we run classes some years we don't and and some of them have gotten on a cycle of on and off that allows all these different courses to be taken um as of right now now I don't expect any staffing but if we if we get a lot of kids I would love to hire more teachers to teach more of our Fine Arts courses U but as of right now I don't I don't see that I would get permission to hire more teachers yet and I guess my only other question and I don't know if you could speak

095on this um anecdotally um I know students who have um wanted to take cources at beams were unable to because their preference would have than Tech and there was no opening um do we are we adding classes for Tech do we have like a space in there where um maybe a lot of students looking to enter into Tech and are and is there really a need for more openings in Tech yeah that I would not have the answer too but we can we can get that answer for you apprciate it okay so we if if I may through the chair uh I I had one other question as far as like uh finding the recycled materials uh how do you uh how do you go about that process what does that process look like a

096lot of it's going to be at home in the garbage or in the recycling bin um honestly and then what what we can find if there are specific items that a student might need we can take up collection I know already in our in our art classes they'll put out hey does anybody have egg cartons um does anybody have found found objects that we already use in some of our art projects um we'll put out a call if we need stuff and uh if I need to go to the dump I'll go to the dump yeah tag sales and um Goodwill are good spots too yes absolutely okay any further discussion well a motion has been made and seconded all in favor I I I opposed motion passes unanimously thank you for your continued support

097of the Art thank you next we have Wellness revision with Sarah hail good evening everybody um this curriculum revision was brought to the student achievement committee last month and it was voted to move to the full board tonight for approval um this revision um reflects new Connecticut state standards as well as new national state standards um national standards and um I would be more than happy to take any questions or move to approve motion to accept second the motion has been made made and seconded do we have any discussion with no discussion all in favor I opposed motion passes unanimously thank you so much do we have any new business okay with no new business we will move on chair something listed on the agenda Boe M oh I didn't have my glasses on definitely

098blind wait it just says new business yeah that's one eoe member appointment to Edgewood pre renovation building committee not on my agenda onine I'm on I'm on oh okay see it up there uh 12.1 Boe member appointment to the Edgewood prek renovation building committee is someone going to speak to this should we table this and who added this so I I just my suggestion for an appointment would be commissioner Carlson I second that I'm all right with it okay motion has been made and seconded for Eric Carlson to be the Edgewood pre- renovation building committee appointment any discussion with no further discussion can we have a vote all in favor I I opposed motion passes unanimously we have ourselves a Boe represent perfect the CIP okay next is the leaon report through the chair yes

099there was also um two additional things that should be brought forward the Capital Improvement plan that was presented to the finance committee and the donation okay so I'll uh yes correct I forgot about those items even though it just happened at 5:30 um I I would like to make a motion to add uh two items to new business one is the capit Improvement plan that I spoke about earlier um in my finance update and the second is a donation um that we received um I could read more about it um oh for the art yeah but I'll read once the motion is approved okay so I'm looking for a motion to approve the cap no I made a motion to add it to the agenda we need to vote to add it to the agenda

100and then we can I'm looking for a motion to add will Dante motion to add the two items to the agenda I'll second motion's been made and seconded all in favor i i two items have now been added to the agenda okay so I will make a motion uh actually what is Pete here okay do you want him to present the CIP or do you want to do it I mean I already did but I can uh present it uh commissioner without a problem I am remote but I have it in front of me yeah uh what I'll suggest is is does anyone have any questions on the items that I went through which included roof Mechanicals um the two new schools uh uh h two HVAC programs that were staggered through 2029 if not

101then I'll make a motion to accept CIP as proposed second okay motion's been made and seconded any discussion all in favor I I I opposed motion passes unanimously okay uh the second item is a donation uh from the estate of Richard Sant torsos so I you oh all right we have you weren't here at the other meeting so I didn't I was not okay it is on uh good evening Commissioners Liam M the principal at Bristol arts and Innovation magnet um I would like to ask for board approval for a donation of artwork from Mr Richard santorso senior and his estate uh Mr santorso uh would like to graciously donate his life's work uh this is comprised of roughly 80 paintings um 80 works of art that span his lifetime from aged 8 to aged

10270 1961 to to 2024 this artwork varies in size and composition taking inspiration from everyone from Picasso to Monae to Warhol unfortunately Mr santorso passed away at the end of 2024 his life work his life's work which he would so generously like to leave to Bristol arts and Innovation magnet School's art Department um is estimated at auction um at a value of up to $4,000 we roughly estimated about $50 per painting um so up to $4,000 he also donated the entirety of his art supplies that he had uh left with him uh roughly around $100 maybe $200 uh worth of art supplies um this art uh I would like to thank Miss uh Ryan Hill the high school art teacher at bames for her work with Mr santorso um as she gathered information through a

103series of emails and interviews with Mr santorso um as he was in hospice to Capt capture his love of Art and his hopes for his life work after his passing with the approval of this donation Miss Hill plans to host an art show at at the bames art gallery dedicated to Mr santorso entitled Richard santorso senior a lifetime of me 1961 to 2024 my soul my family life and you miss Hill and other bames art teachers will also use Mr Santoro's works for years to come to serve as demonstration pieces for bames arts classes grades 6 through 12 so I would very much like to ask for a motion uh to support the donation of of um Mr santorso and his estate uh and your support of local art and its impact on our students

104and the community at large once we um if uh this is approved uh we will get started on setting up that art show and we'll obviously invite you all to to the show uh I'm willing to take any questions um or anything like that thank you okay one the motion's been made a second second motion's been made and seconded any discussion without discussion all in favor I I hi hi thank you all very much opposed motion passes unanimously thank you I can't wait to go see that through the chair yes I had one other item potentially for new business I wanted to point out there's an agenda item on tonight's agenda in 14.2 um commissioner was provided the agenda item with the option to uh convene that item either in executive session or public session

105uh the commissioner chose public session so it's not appropriately listed here as executive session I don't know what you want to do with that but um well it's proposed for executive session but if the commissioner wants it in full session then we will have it in full full session that was the way we were told to put on the agenda so you'll have to make an adjustment to the agenda if you if it's your agenda item you would have to add it to new business I'm not sure but that's yeah I'm sorry what is the the items proposed for executive session the commissioner would like it to be in full session which is for options so so we'll have it in Open Session right so um I don't know why we would have to move

106it no you don't have to move it and you don't have to amend the item but anytime we do executive session it is a vote to go in however when it is discussing the performance of an individual they reserve the right to have that into Open Session therefore even if we voted to convene to Executive session because it is your right to be an open session that would nullify the vote The Proposal is for executive session because we have have to notify the public that we would be potentially an executive session so they have proper notice so we don't have to change anything we're not required to vote to go into executive session you've made it clear that you don't want that which is perfectly fine I didn't know if there had to be an

107an agenda adjustment um because it it is not going to be held in executive session it doesn't have to be it was just proposed okay so if you decide that you don't want it in executive session we're not going to we're not going to go into executive session for that okay and we can uh either vote to go into executive session for SUP for the superintendent's performance and then come back out for the discussion or we can do the discussion first and then go into executive session I don't have any preference do you have a preference weate to the agenda oh that's why I was bringing up a new business I you know the agenda is the chairs so I think you I'm asking you what you would prefer Kristen so we only have one

108other uh item on here the information leaz on reports prior to that so if you'd like to uh finish that off that would be fine um and then have the Open Session and then executive session last so that we can clear with that nobody has to come back here unless people are still here okay then we need a motion on the floor to vote to move up an agenda item well first we need what I said oh we were going to do liais on reports first I thought no but you still need the motion but whatever okay so first we'll do liaison information reports um are there any Commissioners who would like to share a liaison report I have always because I feel we should be always cheerleading the amazing work that's happening in our

109schools which is always about the students um as it should be so I will start with Southside um Dr Huber shares the following right before the holiday based on family feedback we held our first ever holidays across the world celebration we had 25 families sign up to bring food in from their culture share a book or activity and enjoy a dinner and night of activities together it was an amazing opportunity to learn about our individ individual cultures and how our differences can make us stronger and we all have more in common than we thought after dinner families had the chance to make a quilt SP ornaments listen to stories and participate and many other cultural activities which represent the diversity of our school thanks to Mrs pesi for coordinating this event last week we held

110our second in school learning day of the year and we are fortunate to welcome almost 200 guests into our classes for literacy Math and Science we still have one more in school learning day before the end of the year for any families who were unable to attend last week session lastly in an effort to continually teach self-awareness and velop outstanding relationships our climate team has planned a Super Bowl activity s o p- um Bowl activity to coincide with the Super Bowl our buddy classes meaning our kindergarten kids who are paired with grade five class um meet each month and we'll be learning about how our actions can impact others in the power of sharing and we will have a contest to see which class can collect the largest number of canned goods we will then

111donate these to a local food pantry as a means of giving back to our Southside in Bristol Community and um I would like to share that with the second in school learning day um my son who attend Southside school I couldn't neither my husband nor I could attend and my mom Nana Flo got to attend for the first time and I just want to say that it's really a testament to that true family engagement like it's you know that enveloping all of um what family engagement means to expand outside of that Mom Dad support I know that Southside welcomes trusted adults who are on the emergency contact list for the for those students and um the teacher M glette took a picture of my mom with my son and I mean it could really bring

112tears to my eyes it was really a beautiful opportunity for my mom to be engaged um in a way that she'd never been and she said there was a boy at the table who didn't have anyone there who asked her about a math example and she was just so proud to share and then she helped them with the answer and he hugged her and I just feel like this is what our community is and these are the examples of um School family Community Partnerships that we should be discussing each month so I thought that was a beautiful example onto Bristol Eastern on January 7th Bristol Eastern High School held its annual grade 8 open house for all incoming freshmen that will attend Bristol Eastern High School next year at the open house families were greeted

113by the administrative team with a brief presentation and then they were able to go by groups to several stations set up around the building to learn more about our school from teachers school counselors and students parents and eighth grade students receiv received a lot of information that will help them start to build their schedules for next year and to walk the building to familiarize themselves with be the day before the holiday vacation started Eastern was filled with holiday spirit as our chorus and band played two separate concerts for students they played a wide array of holiday songs ring from old classics to new pop songs students were invited to sing along as our performing artists led the way that same day we held our annual staff versus students basketball games the comp competition was friendly

114and competitive and to the Delight of the staff they were able to top the students uh letting the youngsters know that they can still hang with them on the basketball court shout out to that um Shameless brag which I think the staff earned uh midyear exams are fast approaching and are scheduled to take place at the end of January students are preparing for for exams and also getting ready to start making scheduling requests for the upcoming school year and while our seniors will not be returning next year they are now heading into scholarship season where they will be applying to numerous local state and National scholarships there's the scholarship Awards night is currently scheduled for June 5th but the scholarship application process starts now and will be in full swing for the next three months

115thank you thank you are there any other liaison reports I just have something quick sure all right this is from the School Readiness Council um Edwood prek academy uh received an additional 15 um part day slots starting this month um there are currently five openings as of today if anyone's interested call 860 584 7828 um then also the Early Childhood parent ambassadors are launching their next state survey from January 17th through February 14th with a focus on early literacy I'll let Donna koser know if you if you have an opportunity for us to provide the survey to your to your families with children between the ages of birth to six all families that complete the survey receive $10 gift certificate and will be entered into a local drawing for a $50 Amazon gift card uh

116it's decure atw West Central connecticut. org not that everybody's going to remember but there you go thank you thank you I think Lori was going to do I don't I don't have one oh you didn't have one okay any others okay with no further liaison reports we will move to the next agenda item um we will need a motion to move the discussion concerning the performance of a board member uh up one item on the agenda so moved second yes discussion uh through the chair yes um my suggestion would be to um convene into executive session discuss number one and then reconvene into public session um to discuss number two I feel that we would be able to have a more effective conversation for number one um having that conversation first okay just my suggestion

117through the chair yes your choice was left to me I did not know anyone had any different feelings so we'll have a vote on how this happens um sorry can someone clarify what the motion on the table is sorry so there is a motion on the table to move discussion concerning the performance of a board member uh out of out of order so make that number one and make the possible action concerning the superintendent's performance goals as the second agenda item the motion has been made in second got um and we are in discussion gotcha okay um I agree with my colleague I would like to keep the order so that way we can um get through the superintendent's presentation of her goals from a professional standpoint and then we can deal we need to

118deal with as a board separately the chair yes um I don't see how a discussion on an action item or any item that's spit for the board of edge would interfere with the discussion on the superintendent pools thank you for your comment any other discussion I agree I would never let one thing impact another we're prepared to discuss all items tonight um I'm just asking that if the chair deferred to my preference why is it being retracted now I had actually offered it to be even earlier but um so but you are the chair so you controlled the agenda and um I'm trying to listen to all n every every person at the table has equal voice here and so I would like to honor all voices so I appreciate and if no one had

119any opposition to it I would have absolutely no problem with have given you that so um any other comments before we vote I guess I do have a comment if you had no problem with having her do that I hope you support her moving the agenda item up thank you through the chair yeah I think that um I would be fine with moving the agenda item and I had not considered commissioner um f Simon bu's lens until she said that and I will say that I have seen emotions impede abilities for us to be objective in our work and I will be the first person to say that I probably have done that myself and to be fair to superintendent white so that we're all up there with hopefully a very neutral approach to the

120conversation about goals um I think we should consider the recommendation of doing the uh executive session with the superintendent schools first however I'm open to hearing why we would like to move the sequencing because just as it as just as I heard what commissioner fit Simon bua said maybe there's a reason to move it um that sort of is more compelling than the first recommendation so again can just share if you if you don't mind um when the commissioner request it in public session you know a lot of times we go into executive session last and you know U we do that at the convenience of the public for a lot of teams it doesn't preclude the public from staying on um but we did have a lot of agenda items tonight and so I

121feel that it defeats my um my my wishes and my intent for it to be in the public session we do still have people here in the gallery people online um and we might lose some of that if um you know we wait until executive session so to me the only reason why I'm saying that is because it mirrors more of what public session is for me in our in our past practice we do try to reserve executive session for last for a reason there was nothing in here that said there would be um any proposed action that doesn't mean there wouldn't be um so so that's why I'm saying so um a lot of times in those instances if we had executive session and there was not going to be a proposed action it

122is customary that most people leave when we go to Executive session so it defeats my request to have it in public session it would still be in public session technically yes but technically yes yes but the uh the impression would be not really okay so we have we've had a discussion and we have a motion on the floor to move agenda item two um before agenda item one so that we discuss um the performance of a board member before the superintendent's performance goals the motion has been made and seconded I think we should do a roll call vote because I think this is going to be not unanimously and I could start Lori do you want to start on your okay so to move the um executive yes to move it change it to first

123to the board member to First correct yes I vote Yes commissioner G Antonio votes yes I support the commissioner's wish and I vote Yes I vote no no no I vote no very respectfully I do think that um it's going to really impact our ability to have an effective conversation for number one commissioner Carlson I'm going to vote no motion did not pass so now I need a motion to convene into executive session for the purpose of possible action concerning the superintendent performance goals proposed for executive session so moved and just noting that we're inviting Iris white to join us inviting superintendent second to go into executive session motion has been moved and second all in favor I I no I don't okay so the motion passes 81 we are now going into a second

124session oh e e e I I opposed approve we are now in in it session uh can I have an OT a motion to um approve superintendent whites Bulls so moved second motion's been made and seconded all in favor I I any opposed no you voted no yes okay motion passes 81 okay the next agenda item is a discussion of a board members performance um I have an agenda for the discussion I will start with an overview of the Boe responsibilities communication protocols and bylaws um the second item on the agenda is an explanation of why the board is discussing the performance in a public session the third is a per is performance violations for discussion um and we will I will outline the violations the fourth is the review the documents the documentation of

125the specific violations and I will hand them out to the full board the fifth is the review the documentation of the responses to the violations which I will also provide to the full board um I included guidelines for discussion which is the discussion will be limited to the four or identified performance violations for board discussion I will facilitate the discussion ensuring that we maintain a respectful dialogue and stay on track with the specific performance topics I will encourage all Commissioners to focus on discussing the performance topics rather than the individual each commissioner will have five minutes to comment on the three performance topics please keep your comments limited to the three topics each commissioner will have one chance to speak any commissioner who does not wish to speak can pass at the conclusion of our

126discussion I will provide a summary and outline with potential next steps this is not a hearing there will be no vote tonight this is simply a discussion um seven performance discussion topics with the full board uh and I will go through those after when we get to number seven first I'm going to hand out the bylaws and communication protocols I printed them the ones that are highlighted are ones that we can speak to but any we any commissioner can speak to any of the communication protocols or bylaws okay first agenda item I'm going to get my classes you're the chair yes I have can I ask a question sure um I was just wondering I don't know what the process is but it why we weren't provided this agenda prior to this part of the

127meeting because we believed that this would be an executive session that there would be no reason to have an audience to discuss our our business of the board um and so this required a lot of work to put together and I have a full-time job so this just was finished um without time for me to share this ahead of time so that's the honest answer through the chair yes and just to clarify this isn't in a meeting official meeting agenda this is your version of control through the process so you can get it's just one item okay for discussion so that we keep to quorum so it's an outline for decorum just wanted to clarify thank you so maybe I should have called it the outline instead of the agenda okay the Board of Education

128serves as a volunteer representative body for local government elected by the registered voters of Bristol we are charged with overseeing the school district serving as leaders and advocates for public education each member represents the entrance of the entire District rather than a specific subgroup or area reflecting the diversity of the community we serve it is a serious commitment requiring a considerable amount of time and adherence to Legal guidelines the taxpayers rely on us to manage a budget exceeding 100 million responsibly ensuring quality education for all students the authority of the school board is granted by state laws and regulations the board can only take action as a collective body during official meetings where decisions are made through majority votes individual board members do not have the power to direct the superintendent or staff alter policies

129or procedures manage District Operations or make independent decisions we are not responsible for the day-to-day management of the school district that job is left to the professional Educators hired by the school board the school board delegates District administration and daily operations to the superintendent in compliance with state and federal laws school boards adopt policies and rules to serve as guidelines for the general management and administrative actions of the district the board is also responsible for hiring the superintendent and delegates authority to the superintendent to to determine how to achieve the district goals provide leadership to the staff and manage District Operations the board also adopts the school's District's budget which we will be doing shortly in January or this at the end of the month the board establishes policies and sets educational objectives for the

130district enabling the superintendent to act as the chief executive officer responsible for overseeing all District Operations the superintendent acts as the bridge between the board and the staff a successful School Board Fosters a collaborative partnership with the superintendent aiming for ongoing Improvement within the district and recognizes both the board and the superintendent as the district's leadership team additionally we are tasked with assessing the superintendent's performance against specific goals which we also just did tonight on our agenda to operate effectively it is essential to have a clear set of Ru rules and to follow them safeguarding District resources to provide every student with a high quality education while prioritizing their well-being in all decisions and actions the board's bylaws serve as our operational manual it is crucial for board members to adhere to the board's protocols

131and bylaws because they act as the foundational transparency in legal compliance preventing potential conflicts and protecting the board from legal issues if not adhered to properly essentially rules and guidelines for the board and District governance ensuring consistent decision-making accountability they provide a structured framework for Effective board operations our bylaws Define clear procedures for key aspects like voting meeting conduct conflict resolution and member responsibilities eliminating confusion and allowing for smooth operations adhering to the bylaws helps ensure the organization is operating with legal boundaries particularly regarding issues like financial management and decision and decision-making processing failure to follow bylaws can damage the board's reputation potentially leading to Al challenges or loss of public trust when a board member when all board members are aware of and follow the established protocols the board can function effectively and make

132informed decisions for the best interest of Bristol Public Schools for our students and families the established communication protocols hold board members accountable for their actions and decisions promoting transparency and ethical conduct our communication protocol stipulates that all communication related to board Matters from board Commissioners to the superintendent must be directed through the chair this includes inquiries requests for information updates or any other business of the board this allows the chair to serve as the intermediary between the superintendent and the board and protects the superintendent and the District staff from being inundated with requests for information from nine individuals it is incumbent of the chair to run effective meetings maintained Quorum of the board and to keep the board focused on the district Mission Vision and goals most members do a great job of following the

133rules which is instrumental to effective School governance that said I think it's common for every commissioner to accidentally slip up on a communication protocol or bylaw now and then when that happens it is not necessary to consult with the board attorney or have a big discussion about it the rules can be complex and since we're all volunteers it's easy to access accidentally break a bylaw or miss a communication protocol each chair has their own way of handling these situations my Approach has been to offer the opportunity to meet privately to have a conversation aimed at figuring out if there's any confusion about the rules and to Pro provide access to resources that can help clarify things I made several attempts over the past eight months to arrange a one-on-one meeting with commissioner G Antonio providing

134gentle reminders both in person and via email concerning the violations at the request of commissioner G Antonio superintendent White had no hesitation in honoring commissioner gano's special requests to include the superintendent on all of her emails to the chair I was also in agreement in hopes that this would help to Foster and rebuild trust regrettably the strategy did not prevent further and additional violations of the established protocols and bylaws therefore commissioner giantonio was asked asked to comply with the board's protocols and bylaws applicable to all board Commissioners when an attempt when all attempts proved unsuccessful and commissioner G Antonio recently called a state funer and identified herself as a board commissioner and violated our bylaws I saw advice from the board's attorney on how to address the persistent violations and the negative impact they are

135having on the board's ability to carry out our elected responsibilities the attorney recommend that we include a discussion of her performance in the agenda allowing the entire board to engage in the matter the second agenda item discusses why we're doing this an open session in an effort to use discretion about this sensitive matter commissioner giantonio was notified that she had the right to have the discussion take place in executive session and that her privacy would be maintained however she opted to wave her right to have the discussion in a closed meeting and requested that the board have the discussion during an open board meeting the next agenda item specific violations for discussion the first is representing the board in an official capacity the second is contacting board attorney the third is emailing District staff and

136the fourth is breaching confidentiality I'm going to pass these out the first example of representing the board in an official capacity the documentation is an email that informs me that in a call that commissioner G Antonio had with a state funer she represented herself as a board of aded member our bylaws clearly represent that each of the nine have no Authority outside of a board meeting when we're voting we don't represent ourselves as as Board of Education members to state funders to question um any type of board business the only person who can speak for the board is the chair of the board it is very difficult to have board members go outside of the protocols and rules and the board is responsible for the relationships we build with our funders and when you have

137someone that goes outside of the rules to call and ask questions and make comments that may not be in the best interest of the board it needs to be addressed um I have tried to do this in a way that wasn't public and I have tried to do this in a way that um we can hear handle these things by rebuilding relationships or um you know having a conversation those were not options so we are at the point now where we're looking at each of the violations and we are going to let the Commissioners look through these violations I'm not going to go one by one and name every violation but there are evidence through these emails of contacting the board attorney only the chair or the superintendent can incur a fee if everybody were

138to be able to just call the board attorney every time they had a question at almost $500 a pop we would not un we would not be able to keep up with those expensive the reasons why the rules are in place is because if I know that I have to talk to the attorney on Wednesday and three people have a question I can write down the question question and then ask all of the questions at once so we're only incurred one fee often times depending on how long you've been the chair the previous chair was the chair for four years I think yeah and so she had a lot of the answers so we didn't call the board attorney we knew we couldn't call the board attorney the rules were the rules so we would

139ask the chair she didn't know the answer it was incumbent upon her to get the answer for us calling the the board chair directly is incomplete violation of our bylaws um the next is emailing District staff it is unfair to District staff to re be put on emails with requests from nine different Commissioners the reason why the rules are there are to protect the staff the the the proper chain of command per our bylaws and per our communication protocol is to reach out to your to the chair whoever the chairman may be present your question the chair then in a in a manner that doesn't indate the person who's running the entire School District so if we check in on Friday mornings and someone has questions on Wednesday and it's not an emergency or a

140911 then we respect that other people have jobs to do and we don't have people feel like because we're on the board they have to jump for us we want to be respectful of the people who are doing the work and give them that respect by following our our bylaws and the last is breaching confidentiality there have been instances when we are in executive session and things have been shared what happens in executive session is supposed to be a closed meeting we have legal issues with people suing us because of things that were disclosed that weren't even true from executive session so they need to be addressed and the intent of this is not to shame or punish it is to change Behavior I would like us to work as a cohesive board I have

141been making that flea for eight months so next I will hand out my responses to the violations which I think I have 11 11 times I've reminded commissioner G anonio about the protocols specifically citing the violations and asking if we could work as a cohesive board for what's in the best interest of Children and Families in Bristol e e e with the chair yes the people online are asking that you speak into the microphones more clearly please I thought I was so loud but okay I will thank you I feel like I'm too loud sometimes yeah I know you feel that way too don't I e e do people need a few more minutes I can reread the guidelines for the discussion the discussion will be limited to the four identified performance topics for board

142discussion I will facilitate the discussion ensuring that we maintain a respectful dialogue and stay on track with the specific performance topics I encourage all Commissioners to focus on discussing the violation rather than the individual ual each commissioner will have 5 minutes to address the performance topics and must limit their comments to these topics this is not a hearing and there will be no voting or any action tonight each commissioner will have one chance to speak any commissioner who does not wish to speak can pass at the conclusion of our discussion I will provide a summary and outline of potential next steps the purpose of the discussion is for the board to review and discuss the violations of our communication protocols and bylaws I will ask all Commissioners who participate in the discussion to provide constructive

143feedback in a respectful and professional manner focus on specific actions behaviors or outcomes related to the board members performance avoiding personal attacks or subjective opinions the performance discussion topics include constructive feedback regarding the impact of breaching the board's communication protocol and bylaws highlighting the obstacles the violations present to operating as a cohesive board and the extra costs incurred to our budget the next one is suggestions on how to address any commissioner who violates the board's protocols and bylaws that will encourage person personal responsibility among members and the third is suggestions for strategies to prevent future violations including potential action items I will start on either end of the table and we can go from one end to the next until we hit the middle commissioner G anonio you reserve the right to speak last after

144hearing what everyone says Jill or Lori who would like to go first oh okay I don't know how they're more perer I I really don't we didn't get any of this until right now neither did they everyone just got this well I will first we're on most of these emails you're on these emails they're your emails okay Joe Gess taking a breath before a tough conversation um okay so this is tough I will be honest in a respectful manner um I'd like to begin first by stating that I I truly believe that having a highly functioning effective board um should be a top priority for us all as it's in the best interest of our community and most importantly the kids in our district yes I'm sorry I'm naturally soft spoken so I apologize I

145had expressed back in September to this group my concerns regarding our functioning and the need for us to do better I believe that our policies and procedures and bylaws are a critical tool that help guide our practice and essentially can lead to building healthy effective working relationships and I think most importantly acts as a framework for us to do better so a couple things stand out to me that I wanted to touch upon I feel that the materials before us tonight highlight that our communication protocol um has not been followed I totally understand that issues will arise from time to time I was not aware um until I saw these materials the extent to which um they were not being followed uh for example number two you know just number four number six nine 10

146I feel that they should have been directed to the chair as outlined in our protocol and I should and and should not have included superintendent and District staff I think that this is really important to follow because District staff and the superintendent need to know what to expect from us um and what that communication is like at I mean for example imagine if at any given time the superintendent received random emails from all of us it's not a good use of time and that's the role of the chair and I I believe that um when inquiry you know when these inquiries you know could be sent um they can be received and handled as outlined in our communication protocol um I was onboarded with this protocol I feel that I've respected it over the years

147um and it's my expectation that my colleagues would follow it as well um code of ethics 9271 states that board members and superintendent both recognize that they serve as a part of an educational team with mutual respect trust Civility and regard for each other's respective roles and responsibilities however I feel that all of the materials that we had received tonight indicate the opposite um in past meetings we have received feedback from the community um that this issue is apparent in our meetings um and I'm deeply concerned that it is still present and it still persists in addition bylaw 9273 code of Civility touches upon three points that really stand out to me first attend all board meetings as possible for those that have asked my perspective regarding board attendance on November 6 I have been

148transparent and honest I feel that our first priority is here at this table and not doing so impacts our ability to do the work that we were elected to do um and ultimately I feel that that impacts our kids second recognize the importance of an effective governance team I'm not sure even how to comment on that um My Hope Is that one day we can be a team but I I don't see it right now and I don't think that we've been functioning as a team and some of these emails highlight that um and third take no private action that will compromise the board and administration um to me email one states that there was you know a call with a representative from the state department of Ed um in my perspective um based on

149our guidelines the chair is our board's point of contact I am con I'm concerned and Confused um as to why there was this phone call um with someone other than the chair I'm concerned that it potentially could impact our relationships on the state level I'm concerned that it potentially could impact our funding um and honestly it's something I would never do so I'm really I'm concerned that it was felt that it was okay as far as suggestions go I think I need some time to think about that thank you commissioner oen Kowski um first point rust did point out on um the emails are these public record okay so in um in some of the emails there are safety information as far as the safety programs as far as um other information that probably should

150not be discussed with the public okay we're focusing on right I'm just asking as far as they are fiable so yes they're public information but no I didn't share them with the public I just shared them with the board okay um it's just a lot of information to respond to at this time do you have the agenda where it's specific oh yeah I have it number seven right with the ABC yes um suggestions I don't know we could go around and around and around with this being open being transparent being honest being respectful is really I think number one um a lot of nitpicking how do we move past that and focus what our M main priority is which is the students the staff of Bristol you know we're all adults here right right so

151we there's nine of us different personalities but come on this is ridiculous that's just my honest opinion I don't have suggestions um I don't know how we're going to work together but hey we're here I think you know it's a priority and we can zero in on a certain commissioner but it's not just one commissioner okay and I passed I'm done thank you commissioner tag to say it kind of feels like I'm in the Twilight Zone A little bit here um where to begin um first of the documents that you provided us brist Board of Education communication protocol that is a document that I wrote I wrote this document in conjunction with the former superintendent and I wrote this document in conjunction with the former superintendent because board members had continuously violated our communication protocol

152across the board and I have been a stickler of protocol throughout my tenure I actually have a record of being the often the lone no vote when I don't agree with the procedure on this board commissioner Anderson's getting up there with me and the record for no votes by himself but it's uh it's something that's that is deeply important to me and these rules were agreed upon and I know everyone doesn't have it in front of them but I think some of them are important to read because not only is it a protocol that I developed in conjunction with the former superintendent it strictly ties to our bylaws that we agree to follow as elected folks State Statute first is the in general section it is the first sentence all Communications related to board business

153from board Commissioners to staff including the superintendent shall be required to go through the chair not not a difficult not hard to interpret it then follows with this includes inquiries requests for information updates or any other pertinent information the former superintendent and I felt the need to be even more specific than that General sentence because people were bypassing it and I agree with commissioner ozen Kowski it is not necessarily limited to a single board member because I have emails to people saying they have violated it we have a bylaw 910 which dictates the legal status of the board and it talks about our Authority Del ated to us under the State Constitution State Statute but it specifically says that at no time unless delegated authority by this board may an individual act as a member

154of the board I.E if you are not sitting at this table if you have no business in front of you as a convened board you have no power you do not go out into the community and represent yourself as a board member and opine on matters you do not call people outside or inside this district and let them know that you're a board commissioner people may not understand why we have that rule but I'll give you an example what if I walk into a school and a person doesn't recognize me and I say oh I'm a board commissioner and I want you to do X Y and Z that's a very scary thing for a staff member to go through we had a board commissioner who did that previously we did it's not a laughing

155matter either because it's a very serious matter and there's a reason why we have these bylaws on top of that bylaw 9273 which is code disability which is also in here it states and reiterates that point recognize that a board member has no Authority as an individual and that decisions can only be made by a majority vote at a board meeting our bylaws delegate authority to the chair of the board and delegate some other duties to its officers that is an important concept I also think it's important to note that when people represent themselves as a commissioner there's no context to that so when you go to meetings and represent yourself to a commissioner those in the audience are ignorant of your position they may not know that the board stripped you of your leadership

156assignments and relegated you to one committee they don't know that they don't know that you don't speak for the board whatsoever and it bothers me profusely because what comes out of that person's mouth is represented as an opinion of a board of which I am a member I don't like when people go out in the community and give misleading statements about the certification of the superintendent or lack thereof I don't like when they talk about our proceedings and suggest that they lack transparency Shelby should be nicknamed the great communicator because I have never received more emails with as much detail and elongation in my entire life not in my professional career not on the other boards that I serve there was great detail that she provides us there's also a requirement in 9273 that dictates

157that we should strive for a good working relationship with the superintendent I believe that those have been violated in instances questioning the person's credibility asking why they lack certain bits of information without context there was an email in here can find it there 500 emails in here moment find it oh email number three email number three U is about our safety and I respect my other Commissioners and not wanting to talk about um the specifics of that email but email number three was an email sent to the superintendent and the board chair with respect to information we were supplied regarding safety information this email was then forwarded to all the other Commissioners in it there are questions about or there is a tone toward the superintendent's credibility and ability to lead now if this were

158a single instance I move on from those things I think people make mistakes but it is part of a pattern when a state employee informs the board that the superintendent and board chair were essentially badmouth over a phone call by a board commissioner that's concerning to me it's very concerning to me because again it's a pattern of behavior it doesn't respect the decisions of the board and selecting it superintendent it doesn't follow the protocols established every commissioner under our bylaws by the way has a right to criticize District Operations every right you're an elected person people bring you issues all the time we understand not everyone's satisfied with what's going on in the school district even people who love the school district have problems with the school district that's the way that board of educations

159work but our protocol dictates that in every one of those instances you were to have a direct conversation with the superintendent regarding those things you don't go out in the community and bash your school district that's a bad look by the way as an elected official and you don't go to other employees of different agencies and do the same I'm a big believer that if you have a problem you you speak up and you say it this is not at all by the way how I would have gone about this and the reason I said I feel like I'm in the Twilight Zone is because when I was elected chair I had a workshop with everyone in this very room to discuss how we can get along and then I get back oh I'm not

160not really sure how we can do that well that's weird because we had poster boards all around the room discussing things that were important to us what we could accomplish during the term so on and so forth now some people called me a joke for doing that person in question but the reality is that's what leadership requires it requires you to step up and work with people even if you don't really necessarily like them and if people could actually read the email responses that the chair has provided almost every instance is how can we solve this problem which begs the question as to where do you go next I mean it it's difficult to to to answer that question because I've I've voiced my concerns to the chair many times that I don't believe people

161are truly past whatever grievances they are holding on to on this board and I don't think they'll ever going to get past them and they're just waiting people out they're waiting till the next election they're waiting they're hoping for a power shift whatever it may be and so in terms of working together listen I'm on a I'm on a my committee is with two other Republicans finance committee goes fine we sometimes have disagreements we have different questions it remains respectful and it's strange to me that the discourse cannot be the same elsewhere and it's strange to me that a communication protocol that is front and back side cannot be followed it is strange to me and it's strange to be here at 10:26 at night having this conversation with people that I don't feel will

162move freaking inch so those are my public comments thank you thank you so um I would agree that there you know it there's a lot of uh a lot of strong personalities in this room and we're not always going to agree on things and I think it's through those disagreements that um sometimes the what's important does get lost and I think this is a perfect example of that um having said that though I'm I'll be honest with you I'm I'm you know I'm just kind of confused by some of the stuff that's on here but I'm going to try to work through this as best I can and provide constructive feedback um so representing the board at official capacity um I would you know uh when I guess you know when coming through the uh

163building um and talking to uh people um in uh in here you know maybe uh you know saying you know it's not the majority of the board um when uh you know things haven't been voted on yet um you know maybe uh like consider that you know there are nine other people here and um you know that everybody here has a vote before saying it's major majority of the board um contacting the board attorney um I would say you know uh you know something I could think of constructive there um instead of reaching out to the lawyer every time for certain things maybe we could contact c um for for things that are you know already a policy and maybe that would be a little less expensive for us um I've seen that time and

164time again um emailing District staff well sometimes if if uh if you're emailing District staff or or if you're emailing if you're emailing the uh um if you're emailing certain people and all you're getting is derision and you're getting you're getting um you're getting combative comments what is that commissioner left to do where is that commissioner left to go to get that information um you know maybe uh you know so I guess we we'll that breaching confidentiality um so you know um I don't know when maybe emailing school when emailing a dance school about a student's information maybe we should redact that before we email um somebody um because that's not what that's not what commissioner G anonio did that's what you did okay so um this whole thing is a farce okay and um

165it's it's a joke so I'm gonna yield the rest of my time commissioner G Antonio because that's what this is okay okay I'm I'm gonna move on from that hopefully we can stick to the rules of addressing in a constructive way yeah I think constructive I think I was constructive actually okay yeah okay commissioner Simmons both professionally and personally it is my practice to praise in public and deliver constructive feedback in private so something like this this forum goes against what I believe it's a skillful approach to building relationships and correcting Behavior year so and this again comes from my personal approach and my professional approach [Music] um so I think the best way for me to fulfill what I believe is my responsibility in front of you all as a commissioner is to look

166at this objectively to look at the data as the data um while removing personality removing any of that um scope so that's what I want to do earlier we we heard public comment um in support of commissioner G Antonio focusing on contributions focusing on um the impacts of her support on families and students those are the families and students that we serve and that was a reminder to me that everything we do is about the children and the families of this community it's about sweet Alex who was here before us and I welcome I say families bring in your children and if it makes a loud noise so be it we're adults let us celebrate the fact that we have children here because it's the children that we serve and it's a reminder that we

167as the adults need to demonstrate patience kindness understanding and it's just not to say that we didn't do that here tonight I think we did and I think we have to be reminded that what we do is about children and I mention the public comment because that is where our focus should be our focus should not be um discussing publicly the Grievances we have because I don't think that it is representative of how we want to treat one another in life and how we would expect our children to treat each other in school and how we would expect our staff to treat one another but that is what we're doing tonight and I'm I'm not going to regurgitate uh violations um were there violations yes um but I prefer to look at how we are

168going to work together as a functioning board and how we are going to repair uh fractured relationships or maybe areas where there haven't been established relationships healthy relationships at all um I do believe everything is repairable I have a relationship with Kristen I rather like Kristen I think she is smart I think she's a positive contributor to the work that we do um there she brings up things that I have in deep thought of and I've been in education for almost three decades um I appreciate the lens by which she looks at things I've had opportunity to um have conversations with her outside of the board and um and I like her and I respect the um approach that she has used with me we have a a space of transparency and openness and I

169appreciate that but I also have to say in the same lens that we have conflicts on this board and that those conflicts have taken us away from the work which means we are not serving families and that is not acceptable we need to find a way to move forward every single one of us now we all have bosses I had bosses I haven't liked and I've been a boss and I'm sure I haven't been liked as well but there is a proper chain of command and we must follow it there are protocols and we must follow those as well and when we don't and we misstep we apologize and we seek in a very growth driven forward moving manner to be better and that's what I think we are missing on this board and until

170we put those things behind us we will continue to fail in serving this community in the way it needs to be served so how are we going to do that I do have lots of suggestions but you would be here for a long time one thing that I will say is reflection every year we should be doing that board commissioner reflection and I've been on this board almost two years and we haven't done it once it needs to be open it needs to be honest and if there is any way that we can create a safe space to have conversations with one another then we need to do that I do try to do that I think I have with most but there we are politically polarized and that is also a disservice to this

171community we're liked or disliked by the de or the are by our name and politics has no place in education no place at all and I if I knew how politically polarized we would be I would have passed on this opportunity and I'd been home with my family right now because it actually is hurtful to to my spirit and I think this the spirit of the people in this community but I do believe everything is repairable and I know people don't always hold the optimism that I hold but if I don't believe that everything is repairable then I would have to accept how we operate on this board and I do not accept that and I will not accept that I think that in addition to reflection we have to develop our own personal goals

172about how we're going to be better board members maybe less underhanded comments publicly maybe more constructive um communication practices with one another there are multiple approaches that we could use but I ask us to consider what we what would we tell our children if they came home and they sh shared an experience similar to what we're dealing with here would we tell our children to do the things that we're doing on this board is that the approach we would take what would we tell our students what would we tell our staff how would we expect to Bristol Public School staff members to interact with one another if they were faith with some of the challenges that we're faced so we know they're faced with quite similar challenges would we say that this behavior is okay

173I don't think we would I think we would hold them to a higher standard the alliances the factions whether it's endorsed by us as Commissioners or staff however it is manifesting and developing we need to hold each other to have it stop Shelby is the chair she is my boss I am a chain of command girl if Shelby tells me that I need to do ABC and d and that is the protocol then I'm going to do ABC and D I've disagreed with approaches by the chairs on this board because I've been through three chairs and I haven't agreed with every approach Dante are you smirking I'll talk to you later however there is a practice and a protocol and an expectation and I do my best to carry that out with to the best

174of my ability with respect to the process knowing that it's bigger than me so I asked that that's what we do here I ask that we move through this put our grievances aside we don't have to love our boss I don't have to be loved but I hope to be respected and I hope that each person on this board would believe that I've given each of you respect that I don't throw out underhanded comments publicly that I do speak the truth about the things that I appreciate and respect and the contributions that you have made because I don't feel that that's what we're that's not the the the Spirit by which we're treating each other but I think that's what we do have to do and we have to speak to each other with patience

175and kindness if we don't feel that's what we're receiving so I think that's all I have to say and I'll end with I do believe everything is repairable thank you Jen I do feel like I am in a Twilight Zone um because this is really just something I never thought I believe I'd see um so we do have communication issues um number one problem is when we ask questions of the chair we get insults we get called divisive we don't get responses you guys might get glowing long formal emails filled with information we get nothing the last time we received an email with information was in the whole text message email letter of counsel right which are you reading your are you reading your emails because you just got one like three days ago to

176the full Board of all the information of the charter school well okay so we can talk about the charter school in a minute we can talk about the charter school in a minute but there was an email sent out we were asking why is it a Personnel issue Personnel issues don't come before us it's a superintendence unless it goes to the Personnel committee so question was asked why and then we were blamed by all of you and told that trust was broken because this email went around to IB dve students only to find out the Shelby sent the email to jod Carson before she sent it to us a dance studio before you sent it to usor no this is a facilitated discussion I'm sorry this is very frustrating if you are going to sash

177we're talking this what we're talking about there's no communication are there violations there violations she's she's responsible to the people of this town to the constituents is she can't call the State Department of Education and ask a question and say says no she can parent and she said and in full disclosure I I am AO by education M we wouldn't have had to have called there wouldn't have had to have been a call to the State Department of Education to ask about the charter school application if the information had been forwarded to us like it was received to the chair on November 5th the the conversation never would have happened now um there is no you even email dissonance it truly is no I that's what we think of you you I understand I understand

178I have plenty of emails if everybody would like to ask me to see some emails that we have going back and forth emailing District staff I too have emailed Iris Iris I appreciate when you take my calls I think you know they're fine I don't know why I'm not in trouble as well I don't think Iris has a problem taking phone calls um we don't bother you often do we no think so um let's see kind of unfair to put oh you're right you're right you're right I'm sorry breaching confidentiality okay right now it's okay what're what we're gonna do commissioner vorder is if you can stay to the topic and the discussion points this is this is the topic you're justifying breaking protocols because you don't like what protocol do you just because them

179have you read I've read them but have you read what you've written to us where we I asked you about a consent agenda item and instead of getting a response understanding instead of getting a response on a consent agenda item I got 75 paragraphs about how my question was divisive and I and and and it happens repeatedly and that is why we've asked you to communicate with us email with all due respect right now we are speaking about the violations in front of us and how we move forward without incurring additional costs which when you when you break protocols and when you accuse people and act divisive are our board stands to pay I think it was $10,000 for the um violation that you filed and then I didn't file any violation fed a foal

180complaint oh my my fo well I had you dropped at the last minute and then I did drop it I did drop it because I was told I wasn't going to get what I was looking for we care more about using the $10,000 to hire a attorney fees when Dante was chair we were getting $2,000 attorney fees question commissioner van anyway we ask all the time for information and we get stonewalled and I have one other example to give you we've asked the chair multiple times if Dr deer upon his on on his departure had left had done an exit interview did an exit survey left any anything in it you know to explain which she said he would and we were told no it doesn't exist no what I was what I told you

181was that I don't have that and I don't have that information and that information was not something that I could give you that is what I told you and it is clear commissioner van Gord that you are bringing that up it was already brought up in never answered in the Ethics Committee this is the games that are being played the political the Ethics Committee which you admitted to sending furpa violation information to your gossip friend girl groups just because you have some issue with the former administrator you admitted to that I'm going to call point of order I I just it's not insane anyone could go watch the um through the chair I'm gon to call point of order I just don't feel comfortable with anybody would like a copy thank you so commissioner vorder

182why are you asking for it if you have it these are the games you play We I had to go and ask for it in other ways because you don't give us the information we request I'm sorry for getting heated but this is very frustrating it's 10:30 at night I've never seen something so how Dr deer's exit interview has anything to do with the bylaws goals you want to control the narrative and because you can't control the Nar explain that to me commissioner vanu can you explain to me why you are focused on people who no longer work for the district instead of focused on because you want to control the narrative when you can't then you get mad and you do this in public I want to move forward and do the work thank

183you wow okay so uh commissioner G anonio Eric oh I'm sorry Eric I didn't know he was still on yeah I'm still on all right Eric what do you have to say well uh as far as protocols for you know discussing with uh central office staff or anything like that questions uh requests I mean we have the full board meetings to do that and we have subcommittee meetings that's our best interaction points uh subcommittees at least we've got three people there saying hey you know we'd like this information that that's helpful um without going directly through the chair at that point sometimes um so we do got to keep our protocols and our you know set right is we're not the boss we're not the boss of every individual person down at central office we're

184not the boss of the principles of the school um we're policy we have to stick to the overall and we have to act you know more like a full board um you know we can't we can't uh go off on our own search out every little problem and and tackle it head on all by ourselves we are we are a group of nine people or we're in a committee of three that's where we're supposed to do that that's all I've got to say thank you thank you good evening members of the Publican board lots to unpack here right um obviously a very um inopportune way to examine the issues in their entirety without context singling out only a uh an alleged violations of a single commissioner I can tell you uh I've been on this

185board since 2018 there have been um I've been on when it's a super minority when it's a majority and a super majority or something weird and in between um I can honestly tell the City of Bristol and the public that they can go back to 2018 review my behavior my performance you can look at any committees you can look at um things that I wrote and I feel that although not perfect because I am a la person here that I'm here for a reason I spend quite a bit of time like everyone else here volunteering to do the work if anybody in this room or in the public thinks that I honestly believe that every one of these assessments is accurate that you're being given full context that you're not being given just opinions some

186stronger than others I have my own I will not go into the minutia detail that could prove many of my points that I have not made these violations but I can tell you there are three sides to the story and some of what you're hearing tonight is only one of them with a gross misrepresentation of context I will address the four performance violations because they were given and they're spoken about as if they were true and accurate in its entirety and as if there was some type of legal assessment placed on them um I understand protocols I will address some of the other points later I don't know that I can address everything that's been um um shot at me with here but I can tell you that um had I really thought that I

187did something so detrimental to the community do you really think I would have asked this to be in public session every one of my emails are fiable um I honestly believe that although certain people have a delivery method that might not be comfortable or acceptable to others that is feelings it's not fact and although we have to agree to get along with everyone because somebody doesn't like my question or somebody doesn't like the way I wrote something or something somebody doesn't like or they make assumptions on hearsay or what they hear in the public and those just aren't facts so I'm going to try to clear up some of the most egregious claims here um I I could I am welcome to have discussions with the community uh or any other Board of Ed member

188that would like to have a one-on-one discussion about this um um with um with an asterisk right no I'm just saying to F to provide full clarity because everybody only saw this ibody didn't see anything in this no no no I me in this meeting I mean in this meeting what I'm saying all right question is why ex you want this excuse me talking excuse me excuse me um so representing the board in official capacity the the example that was cited in here and um I I I'm not sure why chair Pond call a state founder so recently there was a um the state department of Ed held a public hearing for this district for a charter school a state department of Ed public hearing is accessible to every taxpayer and resident of the city

189it is not the purview of this Board of Ed any person in the city of bristle could have called the state department of Ed that's not and question excuse me please I did not interrupt a single soul they were talking here today okay Kristen but we I'm trying to say representing the board in an an official capacity your claim was that I called the state department of Ed I'm trying to provide Clarity to that because you were it no that is incorrect you excuse me I really need the time and I I you can disagree with it but you weren't there you weren't there I'm trying to clarify the issue I would appreciate the time doing so the my phone call to the state department of Ed was critical of the process I think we

190can all agree there was probably bunch of criticism from the community about the process which is also why we are having another public hearing tomorrow when I called I definitely said I'm Kristen G Antonio I live in Bristol I'm a resident full disclosure I am also a commissioner it was not meant to intimidate whatever there's two sides to whether you want to be transparent or not right you either tell somebody full disclosure I'm also commissioner and I'm getting questions from constituents I was part of this process the last time the school came around for this application and none of this process was the same as the last time so I had legitimate questions regarding the process being undertaken at the State Department of Education public hearing which is not the purview of this board I

191do not need permission to call the State Department of Ed I was asking questions about the process You can disagree with that you weren't there it doesn't matter I can call the State Department of Ed about a public Hearing in the district that I live in that affects my community absolutely okay so I'm going to move on because there's a lot more to talk about contacting the board attorney I was notified on December 27th by an email that my that the a commissioner is going to be put on the agenda for performance I questioned why I can't go into all the details right now because I don't want to waste that kind of time so I was given a reminder on January 3rd that in that reminder I was asked that I get the option

192of public or um or executive session I was like I don't understand this came right after and you referred to my call to the state department Evette so in all honesty I'm like I did not do anything wrong I can call the State Department of Ed anybody anybody in this room can call the State Department of Ed and ask questions about a public hearing so I cannot I really not going to I'm not going to tolerate the interruptions okay you talked you gave me last facilita the discussion and ask okay so I'm trying to you can shut down the discussion all you want and I think this is part of why it's not going to get repaired because you don't let the opposing Viewpoint be debated it is unfair for you to present only your

193opinion your facts as you state them opinion or my fact to our board members you put these I don't want to argue back and forth I want to get through my points yesterday so on January 6 I was given an email that I I mean January 3rd I was given an email that I had to provide my answer I provided my answers three times on January 7th that I would prefer it be in a public setting so I could clear this up and not have to go through the scrutiny of their opinion versus my opinion I just want to State the facts on the January 3D email commissioner chair Pond CC in the the board attorney I did not initiate the contact with the board attorney regarding this issue the board attorney was CED on

194an email that's when the cost starts ticking they charge you for reading emails any logical reasonable person would who sits on a board who knows that they are represented by a board attorney the attorney represents all of us not just the chair okay you put the board attorney on an email which caused any reasonable person especially this reasonable person alarm what is this about I picked up the phone because I have in the six years I've been on this board spoken with our attorney uh in the past depending on who the chair is some of that some of those Protocols are stricter and some are not there have been varying procedures over the time that I have been on the board so I excuse me so I called the attorney I left a 7-second voicemail

195that said I received an email that you are on it and I don't understand could you give me an explanation why hung up the phone I did not receive a call back which means that the attorney was prevented from calling me back and that that's what this is about contacting the board attorney 7c voicemail I left because the chair put the attorney on an email that said I was going to be on an agenda and include the attorney I don't know what anybody reasonable commissioner G Antonio when you received the email and it and it informed you that you had had the decision did the email include and you can reach out to me if you have any questions uh it did unfortunately I can get um your refusal to communicate with me at all

196andate an email I communicate an email so what let me move on so that emailing District staff the other um I just want to address these four points that it's tired it's long uh you know it's going to be a he said she said thing throughout this entire thing um it's not a he said she said thing the bylaws were violated these are concrete bylaws that have been violate a bylaw by calling the state department event so I in representing yourself as a board commissioner you absolutely keep saying it Shelby it doesn't make it a fact so I need to move on because I want to address the other times there are emails in here that yes I include Iris Maria um well Maria's already included because you include Maria on every email that's your

197choice I'm not I'm just saying it's more than just Iris I included Iris we did have that that you told in the beginning of this meeting that I approached you I'm not going to tell everybody in this room why I told you and asked you if I could include Iris on my emails there was an agreement Iris was in agreement we're talking some of these you have 11 examples in here but some of them are on the same issue so over the span of of 10 months if there were some of these times were During the period that I was allowed allowed by you can you imagine a public official can't put the superintendent on things yes there are communication protocols it's a protocol there were reasons why I asked for Iris to be on

198my emails there was not multiple emails coming from all these Commissioners previously there was a communication with myself and when um uh commissioner tagel was chair that he would receive feedback from me as sort of the for of a better word the minority caucus leader right and I thought that was going well um there was a breakdown though in some of my emails being sent that weren't being addressed and they weren't being addressed and I didn't want my questions my interpretation the way somebody reads the things that I write to be Rewritten only to give to the superintendent the way they were uh the way the chair wanted them to go I asked if I could just keep my copy I have never made a demand that Iris contact me directly every email was directed

199to the chair but Iris was on copy uh I do not I do not consider that to be I'm making demands of Iris to answer me I for me it was efficiency of communication that we could that we wouldn't get down into that's not what I said I told you this no you told me that it was these are my direct words and I commissioner G anonio the discussion is about moving forward accepting that when you violate protocols and bylaws it has a negative impact on the board it doesn't root Us in the work that we need to do this discussion isn't about you defending the bylaws to defend herself okay uh commissioner I want this is not this is not I'm talking about the three performance violations I'm not allowed to respond on the

200three performance looking at number seven the last to talk about it this is I'm an elected official and if you're going to put me on the agenda I'm allow to speak my five minutes so you think you just spoke five minutes and and the breaching so breaching confidentiality is quite the claim I am not even going to address that that is so false absolutely false and if you want to have some kind of other discussion about that to claim that I breach confidentiality and to say it to this public without proof without it being vetted is so inappropriate I'm actually appalled that's on here I'm a I can explain it but I won't if you wanted to have a conversation about any of these things we would have had the conversation but it's clear commissioner

201J Antonio that you don't want to take accountability for the violations that you did you are not interested I'm sorry I am going to say we G argue about it we're not gonna argue it's I'm closing the discussion well I didn't get to the performance I'm not really thinking that you getting there is going to make any difference in rebuilding this isn't a platform for you to demonstrate that you have Justified that you can break bylaws so you can make accusations of me hand out emails with limited contacts to every person on here and I you wanted every person in here Kristen you were looking for this we wanted to have a constructive conversation with concrete intent of what is going on here I think you just proved it um I don't even understand if

202I were perform if for guidelines for improvement my comment would be this if we really wanted to repair a broad set of examples of all sorts of violations in a different mindset a mindset more like commissioner Simmons pero per Simmons sorry um that we could have had something like uh a workshop let's collectively bring what each one of our commissioners thinks is a violation let's ask others maybe other leaders in cab um to come in help facilitate those discussions and then have a third party say well maybe it's that but really if you look at it there's no statutory reference for that or there's others we all have different interpretations of um what we think who violated this who violated thaton I'm going to ask you a very concrete question the last time you asked

203me if you could speak to the board attorney um I every time you've asked me every twice and both times I have given you that privilege I've never talking about right now is because I left her a voicemail on an email that you that that is different I'm asking you the last time you spoke to the board attorney were you respectful for the to the board attorney or were you critical of the board Attorney and did you say things about the board attorney uh that were you are you are not a legal expert yet you were criticized ing her ability to conduct the law uh that is false um and we can go back and forth with that I'm not going to share what I said to the attorney because I think it it um

204it would not serve this discussion very well no matter what okay so what I'm going to do now is I'm going to close the discussion and we are going to move forward uh with understanding that we I did my best to try to hold a conversation around accountability how do we work together as a board how do we refocus this board the amount of time that I have to spend on things that are nonsense that have nothing to do with what's best point of order these are your opinions can we please motion to close the meeting second I don't even Kristen chair I'm just saying you close you close the discussion that's the end of the items of business on the agenda I closed the discussion and on the agenda it says that I will

205recap the discussion and talk about actionable items but you're silencing the commissioner so you speak no I'm ending the discussion because the discussion is not productive she's violating our bylaws by being divisive in front of the board as we're having a conversation about how to not be divisive this whole thing has been divisive it is not appropriate this whole thing has been inappropriate my goodness I apologize to the public I gave it my best shot to try to hold people accountable on this to have self-awareness of refocusing and not making things into a circus it's unfortunate it's unfortunate and this is unfortunate the board meeting is adjourned what is it it's just the the board attorney did not want this released until Iris released a response with it and I prepared a response as well

206at this point so the fact that you you this is this is actually slander and the fact that you're handing this out I don't even know yes you do I can't even see it what did Jen just hand out I don't know what she handed out you do know what she handed out No One Believes you you lie

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.