001e e e 7 o' we'll call to order the regular meeting of the Clarkston Community Schools Board of Education if you would all please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I PL allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all our first order of business tonight we have a new board member who is joining us Mr Mike Clark who was elected last November and it is my great pleasure at this time to ad Minister the oath of office to him so Mr Clark if you could please rise and repeat after me please I do solemnly swear I do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the
002Constitution of the United States and the constitution of this state and the constitution of this state and that I will Faithfully discharge the duties and then I will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of member of the board of education of the office of member of the Board of Education of Clarkston Community Schools of clarkon Community Schools according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability congratulations than welcome to [Applause] board item 1.6 is our roll call Mrs McLean can you please call the role Mrs mcginness here Mr H here Mrs love here Mr Clark here Mrs Egan here Mrs crane here Mr NE here we all here and we will proceed this meeting is a meeting of the board of ucation in public for the purpose of conducting
003the school district's business it is not to be considered a public Community hearing there is a time for public participation during the meeting as indicated in agenda items three and nine item is approval of the consent agenda may I have a motion please I move to approve the consent agenda as presented support motions made and supported Mrs mlan can you please call the role Mr H yes Mrs crane yes Mr Clark yes Mrs Ean yes Mrs mcginness yes Mrs love yes Mr NE yes motion carried thank you item three is the first opportunity for citizens to address the board again under this item item 3.1 you can address the board on any topic that is on tonight's agenda which is being displayed behind me and then under item nine you're welcome to address the board
004on any topic when making comments please state your name and address direct your com comments here to the board president each person may speak for up to two minutes and per our established procedures the board will not respond to questions or interact with the speaker during public comment although we may refer the matter to our Administration for followup um Mrs Mahoney has told me there is no one that has signed up to address the board on an agenda topic and again under item nine you'll have the opportunity to address the board on any topic item four is our superintendent update Dr Ryan thank you president need uh first order of business is to welcome Mr Mike Clark uh on behalf of our school district our Administration and our staff uh I know I can speak
005for everyone we're excited to have you aboard and uh looking forward to working with you so congratulations welcome aboard uh next piece a big week for welcoming in our new kindergarteners and young fives in the school district and their families on Wednesday night uh as it's set right now on February 12th it's 6:30 at Clarkson High School uh we're hoping to have a big uh show up we've been doing our best to broadcast it out but again if you're listening to this broadcast you know somebody in our community that is of kindergarten age and their families please please come on Wednesday night it's it's a great night not only of information but you really get a feel and a sense of the vibe that is Clarks in Community Schools so thank you uh next this
006Friday uh excuse me the starting this Thursday uh the CHS drama club production of Hello Dolly begins it's going to go through the weekend I want to invite everybody out and I just want to say a quick piece for the students that are involved we do a lot of celebrations for our students that are on the athletic fields in robotics and so many different ways that Clarks and kids show they're smart I encourage everyone in the community for a nice night of entertainment with their families to show up so much talent we're talking students obviously that you see on stage the singing the acting um the stage presence the pit with our musicians in it the live music that accompanies the musical is incredible and then I write down to the back uh stage hands
007and uh your tru's daughter my senior uh who is a seamstress in SE I had the opportunity even work on on a lot of the costumes uh for this musical uh what I'm trying to say is there's so many different ways that our students show competency and how they're smart and uh what they're capable of and for all the students first of all that are involved and have worked so hard for this performance that's going to be coming up on Thursday I want to say great job we're proud of you and for everyone else in the community take a night come out for the show it's great Clarkson entertainment so thank you uh next it's my pleasure to recognize one of the my own in terms our administrative team here at central office I'd like
008Miss Kelly Allen to stand up please know how it is to be able to have the spotlight on you our director of uh marketing and community relations Kelly Allen on her achievement of an incred in public relations Kelly's had to complete a rigorous panel of presentations and pass a complex series of exams to attain this special designation she's not a leader in communication here in Clarkston you should know that she's a leader in Oakland County Southeast Michigan and people nowhere across the country so it's kind of nice to know that we have that kind of power in terms of communication and getting the message out of about clar's schools congratulations [Applause] Kelly finally uh just an announcement that for next Monday and Tuesday there'll be no school for staff's or students this midwinter break and
009I wish everybody a safe and restful couple days thank you Mr NE thank you Dr Ryan we have no presentation items tonight we'll move along to our action items item 6.1 approval of personnel changes may I have a motion please I move that the Board of Education approves the Personnel changes as listed on the attach attached sheets support motions made supported anybody have any questions for Mr Lucio hearing none all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I any opposed motion carried thank you item 6.2 is the approval of our District's vote for the masb board of directors uh the board has received some information in the packet as well as some emails from candidates for the Region 8 one of the Region 8 uh membership on the board of directors
010which is is the Tri County Area of Wayne Oakland and mccom County we need to address this uh at this meeting to meet the deadline so do I have a motion please I move that the Clarkston Board of Education votes for Mr rodri Means of Westwood Community School District in Wayne County for the Region 8 three-year term support motions made and supported Mr scen do you want to give any uh additional comments for your motion knowing that the inter that the nominees are being interviewed right now as we speak and that we had to do this at this meeting uh I tried to dig in and do a little bit of research as best we could Mrs love and I actually met with Mr Means at the DC advocacy Institute um over the weekend and
011then I also had another chance to talk to him during the winter Institute just this past weekend um and that coupled with uh just my research I just think that he would be a good choice thank you any other comments or questions seeing none all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I any opposed motion carried thank you item 6.3 is the approval of some contracts regarding our construction of our new Junior High School may I have a motion please I move the Board of Education approve the contract for complete interactive Technologies Incorporated in the amount of $292,900 construction contingency in the amount of $29,990 as presented support motions made and supported any comments or questions hearing none all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I
012I any opposed motion carried thank you item 6.4 is the approval of change orders for some electrical and foundation work May I have a motion please I move the Board of Education approve the construction change orders for Metro Electric bulletin number four in the amount of $ 71,72 and for JJ Barney's additional helical peel peer work in the amount of $503 72 support motions made supported and again this work is for the new Junior High School construction any comments or questions seeing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any oppose motion carried thank you item 6.5 is the approval of some playround upgrades for the Early Childhood Center and the funshine program at the high school may I have a motion please I move at the Board of Education appr playground ands
013at the Early Childhood Center and the high school funshine program to rebuild fund Incorporated in the amount of $13,000 and to albanelli for concrete sidewalks in the amount of $339,800 we have also set a contingency and allowance in the amount of $96,700 for a total recommendation of $2 $39,586 have outlived their useful life in uh but both schools uh that's the original playground at the funshine at the high school so it's uh again that one's more than outlived its a useful life and then the um believe it or not this Early Childhood Center is now 20 years old and um that's about what we try to start to make updates a lot of things U become obsolete where we can't buy parts to to complete uh repairs and things like that for it president need
014I just want to make a comment that I'm I'm real appreciative that the district is keeping an eye on our playground equipment because there was a day in this District when we had extremely Obsolete and even dangerous playground equipment some 20 years ago and um to see the district is keeping an eye on the playground equipment and its availability to be maintained and be safe for our children I really appreciate it thank you I'm just going to add that this is 100% covered by grants it's covered by our uh gsrp startup grants that have to be spent by June 30th thank you Mrs Rogers and this Mrs love yeah just to clarify for the contingency of $96,000 that is that includes the removal disposal and The Mulch and fence work as well yes yeah so
015we we don't have those contracts so we're carrying an allowance to get those uh as we start the work um the big thing to get to tonight was the playground equipment has a long lead time and because it's funded with grants we have to have it installed and uh invoiced before June 30th um so this allows us to get the parts ordered and we'll continue to uh find vendors to uh and contractors to do the rest of the work but okay so that's why it's all lumped in together yeah so those pieces we don't have actual prices for but we feel we can do it all within that allowance okay yeah any other comments or questions thank you very much Mr Goodman all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I
016any opposed motion carried thank you we have no report items tonight we have two discussion items the first one item 8.1 discussion on the school resource officer partnership and funding Dr Ryan okay thank you president need and the reference to the Partnerships I'm referring to is the current um Arrangements that Clarkson school has worked with both Springfield and Independence Township um to help have the support for the resource officers that we have in clarson schools currently we have um one officer assigned to each one of our secondary buildings just as a reminder of our community knows uh in tune tuning in tonight and we have one uh officer that's spread across our seven elementary schools um so with that we are currently in the process of evaluating and negotiating with our our townships and our
017ability to continue the support of the services of these resources in our buildings and I should before I get too far into into my monologue here be able to at least give a shout out to the crowd Mr Chuck file who is here at our board meeting tonight W for our board uh who is our independent Township supervisor um which is always interesting when you talk about U public entities when it comes to you know intergovernmental and other relationships that require uh negoti iations or approvals or collaboration uh entities like us have to do a majority of this in public under the public eye as part of the open meetings act um I have informed our Board of Education some of the preliminary uh proposals and things that uh that we've been working with both
018townships uh it should be a note that why we're having this conversation at all this evening is because Oakland County the Commissioners and our executive have found it within their need to to Levy what I view is an enormous and as far as I my understanding of it right now a very unfair level of increase for overall protection police uh Services of Oakland County Sheriff across the entire County uh this increase I'll say publicly has not been given any any rationale uh in any type of uh you know explanation to why we could understand to why this increase has occurred uh it was done unilaterally and um to be fair to our Partners at both townships that we cooperate with in in Clarkson with very much uh last minute uh it was after the election
019in a very short period of time for both of our supervisors both of our supervisors in both uh townships Independence and Springfield both being new um coming into their roles we're immediately met with uh between 15 and 18% uh increases and again this is my understanding at least uh for the resource officers that being even a higher towards an 18% um but further all the officers that are assigned to the township that Independence Township supports were increased greatly um this obviously creates a financial strain to our partners both in Independence and Springfield townships and is worthy of a conversation of how we can uh work together to solutioning to keep these this critical Service as which has been put forth by our school Community our staff uh and myself uh into the future so to
020look at uh you know the relative costs our initial conversations with with uh Springfield Township is more along the lines and how we structure that yearly cost um but we're again we're still in in conversations with them uh as far as independ Township and and myself and Mr Leo and meeting with M Mr file and really trying to sharpen our pencils to to get some some preliminary uh positioning on the school district and again I did not have authorization to make deal but at least looking to get a conversation going so that would bring a constructive conversation back to this group was along the lines of splitting that that large increase uh between us in the township even though that we don't have a complete split in the proportion of our current uh coverage for
021those resource officers uh Mr file at least from my our Recollections and and looking at that um thinks this is much more dramatic impact for the township and is interested in continuing to talk about how we could possibly fund these uh but but initial one possibility it was floated by him and again I'm not sure that that was you know the extent he's had conversations with his board U but looking at transferring the total cost of the funding to the school district for the resource officers and increasing possibly um other police support within the township so what I'm coming tonight with the board and I'm glad uh Mr file could be present too is to kind of do a historical perspective of our arrangement with Independence Township right now focused uh because Springfield Township actually
022just began this this uh relationship with us this past school year this is the first year so there's no history that way like we have with the great history of the Independence Township uh we also want to look at to the best of our knowledge again we're almost third party contractors in a way that this is coming from the county onto the backs of the township and then the relationship for us to be able to help support that here at the school district um so what you'll hear secondly after that first the history will come from from uh M Rogers uh Mr Le will then provide kind of a little bit of a financial look at you know what's in play and uh I'm suggesting a great public conversation with our board members and what
023we can do as good partners moving forward together on this critical element of our operations and some directions so that once uh the lights are off and Mr lto can go to work with Mr file and with Springfield Township we can have some directions so I can speak with some Authority um when I'm in those meetings and then obviously at the end I'll report back so this time I would turn to miss Rogers to give us a report of the last several years and what that relationship just kind of in summary has been in terms of the funding of the resource officers and then we'll turn to Mr lcio to dig in a little deeper so this will be quick prior to 2015 16 school year we didn't contribute anything it was 100% funded by
024the township so that was Zero cost to us back in 20145 so the years prior to that and then starting the year of 20156 we started contributing $330,000 a year towards s so mind you we didn't we only we didn't have as many sorr officers back then but we paid 30,000 and I figured it out it was around 15% at that time of the cost is what we contributed and we continued to pay the 30,000 in 201617 we also paid 30,000 to the Township in 20178 and then we started the 50% relationship for the school year month we only pay the school year months we don't pay the summer months and we started that with 50% at 201819 and that is continued until now the 50% okay thank you Mr Rogers so the new salary
025scale for SRO to include the vehicle based on the bill that we had from 23 24 from Independence Township and what we used with the Springfield it's up about 30,00 000 an officer so for our forly aison it's it's roughly 120 Grand if my data is my comparison is accurate the bill that we got is our based off our fiscal year so it's school year and the rate change is our calendar so I'm I'm sure that's off a few thousand in either direction based on how they calculate it there's another caveat that is in these contracts that the county is is um entering into with the townships and it's a dollar per pupil to fund uh a special fund for resources for school so that would be another 6,500 so that's what I anticipate is
026roughly like 125,000 increase that's for our total program so our total program right now is is about 630,000 this is going to put it roughly at 750 is what I estimate there's another and they're doing a three-year contract um is what the the county is proposing with the townships and it's another 6% and then for 2027 it's 6% plus CPI so I I'd imagine that's that's going to be around 10 10% probably with with the way inflation's tracking right now so those are the increased costs it is a significant increase cost to both of our townships that we're partnering with right now any questions for Mr luo I have a couple questions president need um based on the numbers you just presented to us what type of budget cut or elimination do you feel we
027might have to incur to support the payment that is being pushed over to us well we're currently the state is currently looking at what kind of funding we're going to get next year per pupil but I think our original board parameters had 2 million cut per per year per cut for the next next two years to get our budget where we're not deficit spending but we're going to have to to re relook at our model based on what's being proposed by the governor at this point am I'm also correct to believe and understand that there is no one direct line item in the state school aid budget to provide for safety in our school buildings is that correct is correct therefore any any cost for safety is directly affecting the general fund and the programs
028that we provide for our students correct that is correct thank you um when these officers are in our building and and there should be a CommunityWide emergency call are they part of the police force that could answer a CommunityWide call or do they stay solely at our school buildings at that time they stay solely at our buildings I think that's all my questions for right this minute thank you it might be uh important information relative to that to look at and feedback that we have from our um substation and again this is the best information I have is that roughly of the current four officers that we have in the schools if it was just down to to Fielding calls just to be fair Fielding calls that were coming inside the school because regardless that
029that schools exist in the Township in in this part of the county so there will be a response uh from police that would be roughly correct me Mr L one officer that was kind of we were led to kind of think that that would be the requirement in and itself you know so looking at you know total of police presence that we have and it should be also to me noted that it's not just about security you know these individuals are not just security guards right so they're as we spoke publicly before and and within their job descriptions with our safety director they're involved in promoting positive behavior and interactions with the police in our community they're involved in direct investigations at different levels um and they to support uh the school on a lot
030of different levels relate to um not only criminal system but overall you know the youth in our community and and how we're trying to provide that kind of um culture and and presence that I believe is the um the piece that this community is built on you know there's a strong semblance of a respect for Law and Order and one that we want to kind of build and one in understanding not in fear or misunderstanding so all that kind of comes together in terms of that support piece thank you Dr Ryan Mrs z um yeah did I hear you correctly that Independence Township wants us to take on 100% of the increase no I don't know if that'd be 100% or what I would say right now where we are in in in the conversation
031um is that uh Mr file put forth that he would prefer if this was to be moved those officers um to clarson community schools for full support um this is conversations in our in our our preliminary uh um call negotiations or discussions uh this wasn't a board action or anything by Independence Township um but a place where we're starting from that we're going to get direction from the our board tonight to proceed forward okay well I can say for me personally I think it makes sense to share the cost how we currently are sharing it and I think it would be really absurd for us to pay for the 3 months a year that we're not even using it I don't see why we would pay any of that uh increase at all and I
032wouldn't support that at all as a board member to increase that Dr Ryan can you remind me does a school district have a local millage to support police we do not and uh another point that we make in our conversation with Mr f is at some point be able to potentially collaborate on on on some sort of uh police millage that would also affect the schools and and can you remind the board um as we have some newer board members would it be legal for us to go to the community and ask for such a millage ourselves ourselves I believe that would not be within our ability to bond directly because that would be a indirect contractor cost of school district and I believe the township has a police millage for such a purpose is
033that your understanding as well that's my understanding as well yes and so as I look at this and having lived through the history of who pays for what when um it's all tax dollars right we're all serving the same people in our community and so shifting responsibility from one set of tax dollars to another is a is certainly a curious thing when the when the uh Services of these officers are serving the same Community either way and the same people are paying these tax dollars and so certainly a cost sharing as we have been doing the last few years I think makes some sense I think our primary purpose in existing is to make sure our kids are being educated and our kids are prepared when they leave our doors they can be successful for
034whatever future um is before them and so I think our our mission certainly when our parents entrust their students to us is first and foremost we want to follow the law and secondly I think we want to be as safe as possible in our delivery of our program and I think that's something that I don't know anybody could really be against you know we have made significant investments in our physical plant safety you know in auditing our safety you know um attributes of our buildings and our programs um and we've we've gone so far as to look to expand our police presence um within the district but the police are still coming through a municipality because the municipality provides the police force for a community and so the needs that we have are not school
035district specific needs the community needs and so I think you know figuring out how to split whatever cost this is or find a way to fund this cost makes a lot of sense but I'd be hard hard pressed to go to my constituency here in the district and say I'm sorry we have to raise class sizes because we we don't have a way to pay for these police officers that we need to keep your kids safe you know that that's not a choice as a board member you know I'm really willing to make I'm not putting safety or education one before the other you know I think we need to look at you know as a community this is an issue that we need to solve and it needs to be solved in a more
036Global um respect to how do we fund police and protection in our community and what does that look like and certainly I think we're we're limited and what we could do as a school district District CU we can't go for a local millage to fund these kinds of things you know we're provided our state funding and that's all that we are allowed to collect locally I hear you Mr hon I just want to reemphasize you know from the conversations I had with Mr file that he is open to be creative you know whether it was through an election through the township or others U I think it was a point where just for him to say you know we're here and it's together we have to be creative to figure this out so where we
037land you know that's a whole other story Mr Clark I do have one question on this it mentions that there's a a vehicle involved is that vehicle cost going to be a singular cost would that be spread out um any in and I know that that was a a area it's factored into the salary so they charge us per office it's like officer with a car based on the rank that we that we get at least that's my understanding I have like a pay scale okay president need I I would also add just to keep our community informed that Clarkson is a base funded School District in this state it means we're at the lowest funded level of per pupil allocation across the entire State now I'm proud to say there's very few people in
038this community that know that because we have a premier School District we work very very hard to provide the programming and the buildings and the environment for our students that makes them think that they're in the richest District in the world in this community and we're not we're base funded that means that three4 of the school districts in Oakland County get thousands of dollars more per pupil since 1994 than Clarkson Community Schools gets so to take our precious School dollars away from our students education and put it towards a greater resource than we have had to do in the past is a really painful exercise this board would have to take to do that and I would have a very very hard time funding more money to safety even though of course it is Paramount
039to our students education and to them for them to know that they are safe in this school and that they can learn in this school building without being impacted by what might be going on in the environment outside of them but it'd be very very hard for me to Challen and challenging for me to decide I'm going to pay more for a school resource officer than I'm going to pay more to educate my student and that's the bottom line for me thank you Mr mckinon Mrs Green I don't have much to add other than I completely agree with my colleagues who've already spoken and have said it very eloquently but I would just like to remind people that these SRO officers not only communicate with their the students the public school students that attend their
040school but they communicate with their families they communicate I know they've made calls out I know that that they have just fostered those good relationships and they have done immeasurable good since we've put them into place and so I agree with everything you said that I I don't want to take them away but I don't want to keep them at the at the cost of higher class sizes or losing programs or anything like that thank you Mr scen I would just add that I think um I think the community is aware we've done a good job communicating this but just to tie it into this particular conversation we Face an inordinate number of threats that many which seem to come on Sunday night um and our officers uh that we work with are the ones
041that are going to these families houses that are helping us track these things down to make sure that we know the origin of every single one of these threats and I know our Administration works tirelessly um Around the Clock dealing with these things to make sure that we are as safe as we possibly can be every morning when kids come to school and I think that aspect of how do we provide that level of service would be very difficult if we didn't have the SRO program but it it's not something we can possibly do without you know we we absolutely have to track down every single one one of these things and there are a lot of these things unfortunately at this point and you know I think that is Paramount to this conversation of
042that's the level of safety that I'll say our community demands and needs to feel safe in in how we operate a program for their children thank you Mr Hyer I would only add that I go into a lot of school buildings just with my day job and I've been presid in probably um already two lockdowns this school year this is this is just the sad state of things that you know we cannot live without these school resource officers it's just a standard now in our you know in our school buildings um so I would concur with um Mr hire's comments about the need we can't consider not having you know their presence there I would also say that um I think the kids the students build a relationship with these these officers and they have
043a real sense of um Safety and Security um so I I um I hope we can just work something out in terms of the dollar um commitment that we're going to make without impacting our kids in our in our classroom um but I agree we can't we just can't we can't be in an environment without these officers thank thank you Mrs Ean further comment Dr Ryan do you have the feedback that you were looking for from I have some of it but I I want to dig in a little bit deeper with the board tonight and what I would like to have because I hear the board you when you speak in a voice of you know not wanting to trade what we have in the classroom but feeling absolutely necessary and the urge and
044it's not negotiable that we don't have these type of um supports in our schools that being said looking at the financial realities that are facing Township sh across this County currently I would like the board to give me just a little bit of of room to be able to see what we can do Mr Lei Miss Miss Rogers financially to try to help uh support the burden that's been placed on on our on our townships this year both Springfield Independence to be good partners in good times and bad that's why I publicly wanted you know the not only to hear everybody out but with 100% transparency to be able to tomorrow to reach out uh to Mr fou to you know schedule another appointment for us to be able to talk and hopefully at some
045point very soon here how the both The Independents and Springfield Township boards are leaning in their concerns directly in hopefully a public dialogue um that we can eventually sharpen the pencils and get down to what we need to do to get this solv I think we can um but I do believe clarson schools needs to step up to some degree on this offset of this enormous increase that's been put on the townships you know I need a little room to maneuver and be able to work with that and again it's always kind of interesting in a at the same time to be publicly having a conversation with the individual I have to negotiate that's um sitting six seven rows back for me uh but you know God love America so we'll we'll get down and
046get after it and and I would like to hear back that I'm I'm given that Latitude to to work within that and I'll come back with a another you know we'll see where we can where we can go from here and I just want to say I have a lot of confidence in working with Mr file that we'll be able to figure something out Dr Ryan I guess you know um first and foremost I would say I I don't look I mean this increase is not coming from the township they're sort of the messenger in this case um you know I think our um dismay and displeasure at the way this was handled you know with a very short turnaround time and a very huge increase over a three-year period we should absolutely register that
047with the County police sheriff's department um I don't know Stephanie has a good relationship with the sheriff um we could definitely um you know send our I don't know send our feelings that way concerns to let them know like this is not acceptable like this is such an essential service you can't pull the rug out from under us you know and and give us you know 30 60 days notice for a three-year um increase you know that that's just not going to work for us I would say that first and foremost you know because we're on such a tight timeline and in a larger uh uh if we had time to plan I would say let's do a community survey and let's see what the community has to say about where these funds should come
048from and what the value of the service is um you know absent of that given kind of a maybe a tighter timeline here with what we're dealing with you know I think um I'm not an expert in Municipal finance and and I'm certainly not an expert in another entity's finances but you know given that the community has police millages in place I think we need to look at you know what can that really fund and and how do we fit into that with these school resource officers and you know what's really changed over the last you know eight eight years or so that it it has changed you know from where we used to be um and and I look at that as kind of a base a base place you know from where to
049start I think I think we absolutely want to do our part we understand costs are increasing um we understand inflation you know has certainly been an issue the last 3 or 4 years um and I would say um you know if there's something small that we can pay to share in the increase in cost i' I'd certainly be okay with that um but you know I think we have to look bigger picture here as well and and we all work for the community you know we're not here to you know come up with our own ideas necessarily we represent the community sitting on the school board I mean municipalities represent that same Community you know we should be working together to meet the needs I think of that community you know shifting things back and
050forth I mean there are a lot of things that we do for the township you know because it's the same Community you know relative to programs that we house or we have special rental agreements and rates and things you know because it it doesn't make sense to just trade tax dollars back and forth you know I mean our facilities on both sides are paid for by our our community by our taxpayers and so I think we need to be good stewards of that so long-winded way of saying I think on the big picture the the entire calculus of where those funds come from we need to look at um on the short term picture I think you know some kind of cost share I would be open to I think the board would be open
051to um but I think we need to look long term at this too and that may include some kind of survey component or engaging our community jointly as well well I agree with that Mr Hyer and Mrs Crane and I is board leadership we've had a little more time to look at this uh it was our suggestion that we do give Dr Ryan some latitude to share so this increased cost recognizing that it all came as a shock and surprise to all of us um given the political realities I don't think that increase is going away is as upset as we are as to how it came down and we believe that the board is best served by giving Dr Ryan some latitude to discuss this with the township and then come back to us
052I don't want to speak for you but no that's exactly what I was going to say I just want to I mean you said it longer but I do want to remind people that that they are serving the community it's not just that they're in the public school system they are Clarkston Community SRO so regardless of where kids may go to school if something happens to your neighbor who goes to Clarkson Community Schools it's those SRO that are going to be there so I think that yeah that's exactly I agree okay thank you Mr file um if you would like to come up to the podium we usually uh require people to sign in ahead of time but given the nature of the topic and the fact that you're here I we would welcome to
053hear whatever thoughts you have on the subject and I'm new and you're new that's my favorite saying right now you know when people throw stuff at me like this uh I I do want want to appreciate the fact that you're having this conversation it's uh it's a very disturbing one I think I think everything that the way they handled it was very politically motivated I'm not really going to speak much to what I think is the the resolution to the issue but I just do want to bring some additional Clarity to how we got here in our position from the township to this point um you know I did have the meeting as Dr Ryan was saying I believe that we can work out a solution but this is a major hit I got the
054notice they the township or I'm sorry the county said they did a study 18 months ago on how we were not we there are 12 municipalities in Oakland County out of 60 that contract with Oakland County Sheriff all the rest of them are either going with Michigan State Police which is a couple of them north of us which they are now being dropped so they're going to have to look at an option or they have their own police force so from that standpoint there's not a lot of us that actually contract through the the county matter of fact we're one of the only ones that have kind of a an unusual situation where not only do we subcontract out to the schools we also subcontract to the Village um and so we've got kind of
055a a weird little unique situation going on there 18 months ago the commissioner said they did a study kind of an activity based costing study I don't know if anybody's financed that really means they look at every single possible cost they're incurring and transferring it into a pot to come up with a total amount they went through and did this and then they took that dollar those dollars amount and said okay how many police officers do we have what's their ranks and came up with this very bizarre formula to allocate the cost to so in their calculations they went through everything from the number of bullets that they would dispense whether it's through there just what they carry through practice rounds because they're required to do certain amount of practice rounds to the cars to
056any of the maintenance on the cars um into to any training you name it you can think about it it's in there and then it's even outside of that would be any support administrative support whether it's directly through Oakland County Sheriff's or not now when we ask when I say we a bunch of the other uh 10 of the other supervisors we went down there and talked to him and said please let us see the map because even the union for the sheriff's were against this just so you know this is turned out to be a 15.2% overall increase for the Township in year one okay so that amounts to just about a million dollar so this is a million dollar that was not budgeted so I did hear the conversation about the police millage
057that we did did do one and at this rate it will be negative in 3 years and we can't go back and raise it we would have to come up with a new alternative to that so that amount that was budgeted was not even the only saving grace why there's going to be any sort in the first year and a half is because we were trying to uh go through and save for a new substation right now the 34 officers are working out of a space about like this um so it was Tiny so again Oakland County does not pay for the substations the township has to pay for it so from that standpoint that's where the additional was coming from they did not tell us about this increase until uh mid December so there's
058clearly something wrong there with all this and they also told me that I had to give them a response back in 14 days clearly I did not make that Mark um so I called down there and said that's impossible I'm new I don't know what's going on you can't ask me to do this yet so I've been dragging and dragging and dragging our feet I will tell you this is that on Tuesday this was presented to the board the Township board and the board did approve the contract without the SRO now that does not mean that the SRO is off the table it was just because we didn't know where we were at yet there's obviously a lengthy process between going through your board our board The Village their board trying to figure out all
059these different moving pieces but we did have to get a contract signed to them otherwise he said they're going to pull them all now they oops I know they wouldn't have actually pulled them all my board gave me the latitude to be able to deal with the SRO so I think the same thing that Sean is Dr Sean Ryan is asking for is the same thing my board gave me to be able to go through and sit down and try to figure this out I firmly believe that there is two things we're going to going to have to look at there is going to be a short term and I would say shortterm is over the next 12 months what are we going to do I think that next 12 months is going to be
060challenging at best painful most likely from there on we have to look at alternative options this movement I almost call it a movement because it is really more of a political social movement than it is a financial one um is that the township I have been engaging with some other townships that have police forces and when I sat back and the option used to be that it would make sense it would be would not sorry would not make sense to pull the police force internally to the township the reason being is the liability the insurance costs and all that just made it too steep to do something like that with the new way they're counting they're including all the premiums for the insurance and everything else in that number so when I talk to Waterford
061which I don't know if you guys know there not but they have their own Police Department their own dispatch so I was over there talking to them and based on their total pool and their total cost and we started breaking it down it would cost a Township about 350,000 on the back of a napkin so put an aster on it compared to what we're paying for the uh County so now the Delta is about 350,000 plus or minus so we're looking at a longer term solution as well which ultimately probably means migrating away from Oakland County uh it's just they they have their own agendas matter of fact for the first time in the history of the contract they actually called the sros out separately before it was just another line item in there now
062there's a completely separate different contract now why are they doing that I'm not 100% sure I think I have some ideas I think the ideas there is directionally is that they're going to it's a very toxic conversation to say that we don't want to protect our children so at the same token with some of the things they're doing and the way they're costing things out it almost looks like and it was point blank asked to Woodward I asked him point blank is this a defund the police move and he got very upset very quickly uh and said absolutely not da d da da da but yet everything he kept on talking to me seems like that's the direction was going and that was kind of the perception of the other supervisors that were there uh
063given that Oakland County that is moving more in that direction every year in the voting Trend I don't see it going away and therefore I believe that we're going to probably have to come up with our own Police Department or some sort of Regional Police Department option much like we do with fire so you know we there's a couple of us the North Oakland fire North Oakland County Fire I forget what the C stands for um that goes through and says okay you know grow and Brandon and Holly and all those guys can't afford their own fire department so they join together we're prob I'm looking at that probably directionally as a an option to help fund this situation I believe it's something we just have to start bringing on I don't remember which one
064of you said it but I think it was one of you two ladies said that it's just now part of the the day-to-day operation cost and that needs to start getting factored into it whether it's on your balance sheet or ours or I should income statement and expenses it's it's one or the other the bottom line I'm a resident here and so I pay taxes some goes to you guys some goes to us a lot goes to the county right at the end of the day we have a responsibility I believe to all the residents whether you're sitting on this board or our board to make sure that we're taking care of the kids okay unequivocally that's not even in question it's just now a matter of the math because all over the next 3
065years it is going to be about a 36 to almost 37% increase over what was budgeted for the three years already and we already figured there was going to be an increase so we bumped up our budget but this is on top of it I do again I I kind of moved off it real quick I do want to point out that of that 15.2 36 37% um aggre over the 3 years that the police are only looking at A8 to .9% pay raise so the money's not going to them that's why the union themselves are very upset matter of fact they wrote a letter and all of us uh municipalities except for uh Pontiac signed a letter stating their frustrations with how this was handled as well just to give you an idea real
066quick that how egregious this is a resource officer this year in 20 25 will cost $1 187,188 48 next year that number goes to $612,000 the next year after that goes to 670,000 we're looking at basically a 1.5 1.8 uh million dollar cost on the SRO it's huge it's huge across the board you know we didn't have the funds we didn't anticipate it we tried very very hard to get them to go through and take that 15.2 CU that's really that's the big hit right that's the big hit half of it is coming up front so we tried to get them to say look just take it and average it out over the three years don't get us all don't give us 50% in the first year and they wouldn't budge you they said no
067too bad you guys have had too easy for too long so that's kind of a little bit of of the backstory and the things that we're doing over the township um I do believe that there are some creative options you know I I come from the private sector this is now I maybe week eight or 9 or 10 or 12 or something like that for me um you know in the in the private sector and and I don't want anybody here to be insulted um but we always figure we were smarter than the government so we can let them come up with whatever they want to we'll figure a way around it and so on and so forth so I come with that mentality um I think there's some ways we can think outside of
068the box to get this resolved in a way again first year is just going to be painful but I think year two three and on that we can look back and say okay this was the moment in the time where we decided that we were going to take control of our own future and our own kids safety and take the full responsibility for it and not be at the mercy of some other entity that may have a different agenda okay um and that's that's really all I want to do I wanted to give that a little bit of a backstory to so and also so as you're sitting there thinking about it you know I I I talk with my hands a lot apparently um I fully believe that there are a ways to solve
069this problem the problem is is that I don't know if they can be because government moves really slow that I don't know if we can get it all resolved in the first year but I think for the years going forward we're going to be able to come up with a solution M Mr Mr F can you just clarify I have no idea what the chain of command or the process is but is this a decision that's made at the county commissioner yes level it's not a police department no decision no so it's uh it's the County Commissioners which is kind of the equivalent of your board my board yeah group there right uh they sat down and they sat down with the CFO of Oakland County and they came back with a number in all
070actuality the first round of numbers were much smaller uh they came to the the to a subcommittee of the Commissioners and they went through it and it looked directionally like everything was going to go through you know the interesting thing is that they said okay we're going to use the cost of living published by the state of Michigan so that's a very clear easy number we can all live with right I mean it's a published number hopefully really smart people behind it are come up with it drive it then all of a sudden they said well we're going to need to add had 3% on top of that and then when asked why they said well because the health insurance costs but anybody who knows how you calculate CPI health insurance is a factor in
071that calculation now Oakland county is self-funded so they have some maybe unusual costs I don't know but this is some of the problems we ran into when we were trying to dig in to figure out how they did this calculation so Oakland County Sheriff's Department came back and said well 3 seems high we don't quite understand it but okay we know that you're adding a bunch of stuff in there that has not historically been in there maybe it's not part of the CPI okay whatever whatever at the last minute one of the Commissioners came back and said No it should be 6% when asked for further justification of why 6% this particular commissioner could not come back with an explanation just said because that's the way it looks like and we talked to the CFO
072and the I don't know Deputy CFO or whatever and they uh said yeah you know it's probably safer well of course it's always safer if you raise the number that doesn't mean it's accurate or right but yes it was definitely safer to go with six the union itself at that point in time said that's not right and they've been in up in arms pretty much ever since because in all reality the problem is is they knew that this increase was going to be huge for any Township to absorb and obviously that meant that the way that you're going to deal with something like this that comes at you so hard and so fast is going to be by making cuts and they were concerned about the fact that you know over the if you look
073at it you I heard you say that you're not great at ter parting financials if you look over the last you know five six years that the co money right all the co money that came in the governments raised a bunch of taxes across the board and gave a bunch of money to a bunch of entities um most counties funded gave a portion of that to their Police Department the county sheriff's not a penny went to our County Sheriff's and so from there they've been all along been in bishard which is God bless him you know he he's a kind of a a lone wolf in that pack and uh which doesn't really make sense now that I just said it but you know what I mean uh and so been fighting the fight every
074day about how we going to get the money to start paying for this stuff you know we have a single helicopter that is constantly under repair and so if there's any need to do anything we have problems potential issues there and he's like we just can't get the funding anywhere so the the county is still taking all the same amount of money that it was it's just reallocating it to I think somebody brought up the fact that I think you brought the fact that in the SRO and I think this is part of the reason why they carved that contract out there is now this social fund that hasn't been defined what it is what its objectives are how much it's going to raise where it's going to go who's going to manage it none
075of that has even been defined but they're carving it out to make sure that there's funds going into it and so there's there's problems there there's problems there and so that's why the the deputy Union is like no this doesn't make any sense and then that obviously carried forward where it was supposed to be CPI plus three now it's CPI plus 6 and as pointed out that's going to be somewhere around 9 10% a year increase it's brutal it's brutal Mr F thank you very much for coming out tonight and sharing all your thoughts in the background very very helpful I look forward to working with you guys thank you any other discussion from board members uh Mr I just wanted to say that you know in the past we've had a pretty strong history
076with working with the township we we share athletic fields um Community Ed ITV you know we've done a lot of work collaboratively I'm very optimistic that we will continue to be able to move forward you know solving this together it's just not an it's there is not an easy solution at this point in time um but do like Mr hire's idea of perhaps reaching out to the public and finding out you know what do they think you know what's you know how do we want to fund this how do we want to take care of this I mean it we're not going to sit here and accomplish anything by like trading tax dollars right increasing our fees for something that the township helps pay you know that we the township use it just doesn't make
077sense so I do like the idea of maybe reaching out to the community in some way maybe having a public forum something um where we can you know address this head on and see what kind of ideas come in from the public thank you Mrs Ean Dr yeah I just say I think I'm confident looking that really as you hear from Mr file that there's so much more that binds us together in this part of the county and within Clarkston and we stand together we're stronger we push together with our values we'll carry the day if we let them divide us and and conquer us uh peace meal then that's what'll happen so I have full intent know already from working Mr file that we're going to we're going to solve this Mr beginners president
078need my quick Google search of the 2526 budget for Oakland County on page 125 would seem to indicate that their 24 budget was 164 894 and their 25 budget is 14063 so I'd like to look into that a little bit and I think it would be a very good thing for us board members who are very good at advocating for our district for us to uh confirm these numbers and write to our commissioners appropriately and ask the questions that need to be asked thank you Mrs love I I believe there's a County board meeting tomorrow if we wanted to Advocate thank you thank you all right if there's nothing further thank you all very much again thank you Mr file uh Mr lucido did you have something you wanted to add oh no I'm just
079getting ready for the next okay all right moving on then item 8.2 is our discussion on schools of choice programs for the next school year Mr Dr R as promised uh a year ago I said that when it came time review we're in that revieww period for our school choice program we're going to focus on the Open Enrollment one uh specifically tonight we want to be able to share some information broadly on all the all the elements but kind of dig into that and give uh a little bit of reflection of what that cohort looks like and to get some dialogue and some direction from the board as as we proceed forward uh on the whole I feel like we were successful in our Endeavor this year and to re reiterate from Mr Leo's presentation
080um earlier well actually it was in the fall bu the pupil accounting that we managed for the first time in a long time to be flat which was considered a major success uh in terms of overall program integrity and long-term health of our school district that way M SE will kind of give us the tail of the tape yep um so this is our our analysis of last year and where we're at with our um school choice so these are all the programs that we're currently offering we have our IB Program Clarkston virtual virtual career imion that's all of our CTE construction Tech CSM Tech the young fives in kindergart and that's what we did 75 then last year the employee non-resident that's that's any staff member who's getting a paycheck from Clarkson that's full
081time allowed to send their students there uh project search that's our new special ed program at the hospitals and prior program participant those are students who enrolled in in a program and are currently still attending school here um we so we currently from Fall to 24 450 students is what we have so we did we studied attendance Behavior referrals and academic success in math and reading for our young fives program our attendance this is the average number of absences for our School of Choice versus non-school of choice with our School of Choice students there was one student that had 146 absences and two that had um in the 40s so it is skewed a little bit but it's it was pretty close here for Behavior we're basically looking at 1% of the population had a
082behavior referral in our young fives kindergarten program so it's it's accurate based on the population 1% of each and then this is something that um was actually anticipated because there is a lot of thought that the parents who are driving their students here and don't have the transportation that they're very committed um to their students academic success and we did see that so um our School of Choice um outperformed our our non-school of choice students in both reading and math and then this is the slide that I showed you last in my presentation in November I want you to focus at the bottom so where it says 2004 25 2024 and so in 2024 plant Moran had us to be up four students and our birth rate capture had us up to be 30 students
083okay we ended up being up two students and we took 74 through young F kindergarten school of choice so we would have been down 72 students had we not run the program as we did last year so Dr Ryan and I and Mr Mahoney and our team we were currently looking at this and um this year having the students to be able to place young thives through fifth grade it helped us to have balanced class sizes not collapse sections um and we did follow the board's directive in place most of those students in young fives and kindergarten but now that we're looking that we have to start setting dates for next year we wanted to look at this so being down 72 when plant Moran and our birth rates would project us to being up
084next year we're projected to being being down so this is what we're kind of looking at now we wanted to get some feedback from the board um in this next slide here this is the recommendations that we have we want to continue our Secondary School of Choice programs as unlimited 105 and and 105c programs and we're looking at a window we're still establishing that but we're looking it'll be sometime in April through August 9th is really what we're looking for to capture students into those programs and then our Elementary School of Choice um we would like to continue that we did like it that it went through fifth grade it was really helpful to balance out some class sizes and um have some parity across our school district so we're looking at doing that and
085in a limited program like we did last year but we wanted to collect some feedback from the board I know that that you've asked for this data before to see how those students are performing in the areas that we shared so we'd like to just hear your thoughts so we can come back to the proposal at the next board meeting for the secondary programs as well as our y FES through fifth grade program thank you m Mr Lucio uh questions from Mrs Lucio before we get to comments okay then uh comments reactions so M Mr H in Mr luo in terms of um kind of filling the grades and you know rounding out class size right that was part of the goal and the flexibility that allows us to essentially add the students and the
086revenue for the students without increasing any costs right under that umbrella um how do you see this going forward where we're continuing to round out so like if we round out class size this year obviously we have a little bit of movement of parents moving away and families moving away and we have new students to move into the community and so we've got those in there H how does that rounding out sort of feature change now that we've already done it one year that's a that's a good question we still have some holes like I I was looking at one of our elementaries they're headed into having 33 in fifth grade right now so if we run if we run with that that that's that's way too high we've never we haven't run with that
087even so like I in in that scenario we would probably move sections around move a student up there but we have holes where we could have taken I could have probably taken another 75 and leveled out class sizes even more I I don't know that I think I I think I continue to will be able to do that it was really nice doing it it wasn't we've never done it before we also worked with a different window we had it all set up for July 1st but we did not have a ton of teachers changing class sizes packing stuff up we've been able to continue to run the same young fives programs kindergarten numbers at our at our schools without collapsing so it and not only like helped to level out class sizes it helped
088to keep teachers in their grade levels and and not not move them around you know and and I remember we we looked at the numbers um I don't know six or six months ago I think um the spread was pretty even in terms of uh young fives through fifth grade if memory serves me yes we we have pretty even class sizes it's we actually put it up at an element I think I shared with you before just to celebrate how low we are in our classes and um you know we probably could do a better job sharing that with our teaching staff because you know when you say you know and I've gotten feedback before like is everyone like School of Choice well no but they don't know that instead of having School of Choice
089kids in a class size of 19 you would have been at 24 or 25 with residents it's kind of so um it's worked out very well balancing it out that's why we'd like to run it back we did put young fives in kindergarten as our our primary cuz I don't think we have enough kids coming in to run the number of sections we do in young F's kindergarten so we've been using this but it's kept the same class size it's kept those teachers in their classrooms yeah that that was kind of my followup where I was going with that is you would expect I think based on what you just said that we would have more Choice openings in young fives in kindergarten than we we would in say first second third fourth or fifth
090that's very true okay cuz we've been using that Steve back to your original point like we've been using that to funnel this many sections in those younger grades so we kind of need it or we'd reduce I would have reduced the number of teachers without it last last year maybe maybe one one or two and then we would have had some sections that were were off you know especially in our smaller schools like Clarkson Elementary Andersonville if you're only running two in a grade level it's very hard to have they have you know some some standard class sizes they're close to it yeah I I guess I I would be uh I would be okay if we kept the the status quo on this but I would want to look at the data again next
091year because I I think there's a point where we do want to ratchet this down um you know but I think we need to continue to look at the data as we roll forward here because I I'm not sure that I want to continue to do the 75 every year would agree but if there's still room to round out class sizes and maintain our program then I I'm open to looking at it another year thank you Mr I would even say it's getting better over time being that we're losing students out of our ranks so the students that we're back filling in hopefully you know although it's going to be more heavy in the elementary side of it the overall population has been going down um homegrown that way being able to even it out
092will continue to hopefully be able to add I want to say stability I'll let Mr L respond directly to that but stability that we build Elementary should translate stability that we see in the Middle School junior high and high school yeah like I shared last time our Middle School numbers are very low Junior High we have some small class sizes coming coming through we I was with the number of Elementary principles today there's like there's literally no space left in the elementaries which which is a good thing that means we're using every inch of our of our of our square footage to educate kids with our support positions and turning we've turned closets into offices and unfortunately we have some co-curricular teachers teaching on carts which is not what we want but um having our
093buildings this full is is is ideal and we hit it right you know like with being up two kids that's exactly what we wanted we wanted to stop losing kids and this is the first time in 12 years that that's been the case for that I've seen my my tenure here thank you Mr luo your capture rate analysis I think it's it's telling because in 2000 we had 16,000 bur in the county and now we're down to 13 ,000 so there's going to be a decline even if you increase your capture rate a little you're still going to have a significant Decline and following up from Mr H's comment for the benefit of the public this is a discussion we have every year so whatever we do for this year you know we will revisit
094it again in 2026 other comments Mrs crane uh yeah I would just like to make sure that we know next year how many of the original 75 came on in year two I just think that's I know we will but that's just just an important number I'd like to kind of kind of the the attrition number for the school choice yeah I mean are we keeping half are we keeping 95% I mean we don't I don't know yet the the the we do have that I I'll bring it we just looked at this we put that in the we can review this I don't want to I don't want to high I wouldn't want to prom it was very high but I don't want to missp speake we will share that with you then we
095can review okay thank you and and that's a great Point Mrs scan because that that was a concern we talked about the potential volatility MH and so I wouldn't really expect that in year one that's definitely a number I want to continue to look at I think the data you brought to us tonight is is a great start of the kind of things we want to look at I think it gives us a good Baseline mean I'd want continue to look at that see I mean so that that 104 absence that was included in that average that you showed us yeah so I mean that's almost an anomaly that we can't because that can happen with any kid something yes you know that but in absences of that many so I have one kid with
096140 and I think the other two were in the 40s that with that small of a number of students that that really shot it up excuse that up yeah M love I would just like to with the data that we're getting now I appreciate it I would also like to hear from the teachers who've had to experience this um the feedback I've heard hasn't been the best um so you're you're not asking for any more more you're just asking for the same amount as last year I'm asking for the same I will I will say and I and I wish there was a better way to do this but when it's in the middle of July and August first is coming around we're deciding are we adding another section to kindergarten adding 10 kids from
097school of choice or are we running with the numbers I have I will tell you this has significantly lowered class sizes now do I go back I'm making this up completely have I ever gone to the a kindergarten team at Bailey Lake and said hey guys do you want three sections of 24 four sections of 18 I I've never there's no time for us to have that communication we barely have time to even communicate with the principal on that but I will tell you that's what's happening it's not more kids getting put in or it's or it's we would have taken a teacher away but now that we're we have eight kids to place in second grade we're now able to run um three two three sections instead of cutting it down to two where
098they'd have a I can't think of one time that we have had that a teacher has had an increased class size because of this and I I almost don't think it's fair cuz I I haven't done a good job of educating them but I don't even know if that's feasible with the intensity of placing 75 students over seven Elementary buildings in such a such a time crunch that I can have that dialogue with the teachers but I don't know that they have all the data to even answer that question okay for their grade level if that if that makes sense okay and I would just like to kind of reiterate what Steve was saying about dialing it back I would like to I don't want to keep depending on this and I definitely don't want
099to increase it in the future I'd like us to focus more on bringing in these Clarkson virtual construction Tech kids CSM Tech kids um and also just having Innovative programs that are bringing kids to Clarkston and gaining our enrollment that way instead of relying on School of Choice I just don't think School of Choice in general in our community is wanted mhm yep and we can look our intent was really to look at bringing it back and then we started looking at the projections so I mean our goal is to be flat we we like where we're at we like our number of sections I mean that that is really that is the intent of this program not to increase increase our enrollment it's the stop stop losing the enrollment so we can keep the
100programs the IV the CSM Tech the band all of these programs so we have enough students to take all the different languages we offer and so forth because that that is becoming challenging when you got a middle school that used to have 1300 kids that's now at 900 president nean I would wholeheartedly like to express how much these School of Choice children help benefit the rest of the students in this District by expanding the offerings of the programs you just spoke of because the likelihood is if all these School of Choice children were not in our district many of these programs would no longer longer exist and I think that's an important thing that our community needs to be educated about I'm extremely proud to see that their achievement numbers are what they are because
101that is not the perception in this community we need to do a much better job of telling the story My Own grandchild is one of those students and I can tell you her achievement is above the average in her class so I think that we need to educate our teaching staff better about what these children bring to our school district and our community because these numbers help provide the services and opportunities we give to our students that they would not get otherwise and I think that's a very important story that we need to make sure we start telling thank you Mrs mcginness just one more thing to add Mr need I I guess I would I would challenge uh Dr Ryan and Mr luo when we're sitting here in January or February a year from
102now and we're having a similar kind of conversation you know I I would pose like what else is there right like as I look at the the numbers and the environment that we're in you know H how do we you know is it maintaining more of our students you know my sense is they probably move out of the community and that's probably a hard thing to do you know do we increase our birth capture rate like how do we do that what does that look like I'm not sure we could increase the number of births um you know we'd have to have to rewind 5 years or so but there's there's only so many ways we can affect these numbers and my my challenge would be like what else is there right like we we
103have this we don't love it we understand the function it's doing what we said it was going to do I don't you know I worry about the long-term effects as we go through the whole piece but are there other ways where we can pick up you know hey if we just do this thing over here we can get five more kids here five more kids you know that our own kids back in our buildings what does that look like you know and so if we've got a year to think about that i' to explore you know some of those other options that might be out there whether that's marketing you know Communications like H how do we let people know what we have going on here and and why this might be a good fit
104for their kid if their kit is you know is in any of these programs that we have you know let's let's look look at some of those things as well than you have we noticed any loss of students based on people pulling them out of the school district not just the lower birth rate cuz I know out there there's a lot of people that are pulling their kids and doing home schools I know it's a growing uh it's a growing Trend and are we losing any from that and and and what could we do to possibly pull those kids back in and that could be something that maybe we're maybe the school's heading in a direction that a lot of the parents some of the parents don't want it to go and that's probably why
105they're doing it have we looked into any of that research at all Mr Lucio can you address that we do I don't have it with me to pull up for you I can certainly share that with you we we have graphed that out for the last 10 years co co is you'll see some big spikes but other than that it's pretty okay yeah we'll take it off we got great data for that we present it every year as a ongoing story to the board it's a great question we can part of orientation piece we'll pull that all in there we'll just share that presentation yeah thank you you know another little fun you know looking at the fact sorry just you know of programming seeing that these are highly able Learners that are going to
106back fill into our CSM Tech our marching band and all of our other programs that keep them vibrant Mr Nito I think it was in the fall we were kicking around looking at our loss students and and just for our own you know bizarre interest of of charting if we wouldn't have done if we would have done this instead of that and if we wouldn't have been trying to augment and try to bring a stabilization enrollment I think we were looking at next year the year after closing one of our elementaries so then it's real you know look at the cost there because those are the students that been back filled the middle school and everything else it's not a fear thing it's more of just the reality of our situation when we at Point
107not too long ago we're at 88,200 and then based on birth rate the entire County uh you know scooting down that piece and and having the privilege of being a midcap school district in the state of Michigan you know we have power of numbers and that means that you know that that offerings that we can have that you don't see in a lot of schools and it's it's funny one I'm glad that our community takes that I'm going to say they take it for granted it's an expectation that we have all these offerings that we have the most AP classes in Oakland County we do that because we need actual kids in those classes taking them kids that learn that are capable and and can kind of carry the bar and add you know add
108to the fabric of the school district and and I think that's our goal but I really appreciate you know that look uh that it has to be under scrutiny and you had to look at the idea the other conversation you had is we were looking at if we were going to be this much up then we were going to back off this much it's almost like falling in numbers from your year to get that balance um we'll continue to look at those programs like Miss love suggested in a broader way to look for attraction um that's been a tough sell over the last 20 years I can remember when two superintendents ago that we actually brought CSM Tech from the county and it was going to be the big thing that we attracted in thousands
109of kids and it was a nice move for for Clarkson students but you know for whatever reason a lot of people whether it's because they're friends their their neighborhood however tend to like to stay closer to home um so that being said and I'm sorry anything else you want to add in there nope anybody else going once going twice okay thank you that it's really suit I appreciate all the information and thank you everybody for your comments item nine is the second opportunity for citizens to address the board on any topic is there anyone in the audience who would like to address the board please come to the podium and give us your name and address and you all up 2 minutes hello my name is Jackson MCN um regarding the um school resource officers
110I think that it's important to notice that there's only a limited amount of money between the the school district and the um the independent Township and if one of those organizations is going to have to pay more for something that means some part of those budgets is going to be reduced for some other for some other use so I think that the discussion should be based around are we going to reduce what we have within the schools or we going to reduce what we have within the functions of independent Township because the fact of the matter is it's would be very difficult to to limit those those increases in in prices but those costs have to go somewhere and that I guess in that context is how it would look at a portioning the the
111increas in costs between the school district and the Independence Township um thank you thank you Mr MCM I appreciate that any other citizens yes Rogers welcome uh Beth Rogers 7165 Hogback Lake Road Davisburg um also the president of the cea welcome we're glad to have you here uh I just wanted to address teachers and their feelings towards School of Choice students I will tell you that most of your staff don't know who your School of Choice students are I don't look at my students addresses they're just my students and all of the students that walk through our doors are Clarkson students we love them equally we educate them equally I know from time to time it comes up where teachers will will make that commentary but the vast majority of us love and educate our
112students because they're all Clarkson students we thank you we thank you Mr Leo for the work that you've done to help stabilize our district and we will always be here to support you and our students thank you thank you Mr Rogers appreciate that any other comments from the public okay item 10 we'll move on to information items uh we had three of our board members attend an education conference in Washington DC this last weekend and I would ask Mrs crane to give us a brief summary of what they did and what they learned yes thank you uh Mrs love Mr hire and I were in Washington DC for almost a week um we attended a conference uh an advocacy conference where we had keynote speakers breakout Clinic sessions uh we were busy from morning till
113night at night we met to talk over our key talking points that we would use to go onto the hill which we did for two days days um and during that time we met with Senators congressmen people on both sides of the aisle the majority the minority um we advocated for public education uh I think Mr hire has uh he said that this he has been to Washington DC I think between this and is it Student Association for stem advocacy is this was his 51st trip for advocating washhington DC uh so he is an amazing guide and he works tirelessly to set up meetings which he then sent me the uh Mrs love and I the itinerary for and it was exhausting just reading it um however we made it through and uh it was
114it was just it's a my point in that is that he said that this this was my third time going the first was right after covid which was very strange couldn't get close to people you were wearing masks the second year was a little better this year I think Mr hire you said felt like normal and and I would say I mean it felt like you were just talking to people no matter who you were sitting in front of you were just talking to people so I will say that that that both sides of the aisle both said yes things are chaotic right now we know that they they gave us all the assurances that they could that they felt like funding formulas were safe uh in our Arena so that was kind of what
115we took out of it and I think that we'll keep keep trying keep advocating so thank you Mrs crane anybody you want to add from I would just did we start at 7:30 in the morning just you said we started early in the morning was that the time some days yes um just a point of clarification that I would add is my primary responsibility on this trip was representing Michigan Association at school boards um happy to collaborate and support our Clarkston board as well and certainly speak on behalf of Clarkston there but that was my primary role on this trip thank you thank you Mr P and I think most of those 51 trips were through the Michigan Association of school boards correct a lot of them yeah did anybody get a check for idea
116yes they they gave it they you know they just post or like 20 years in the future okay some upcoming items uh this Wednesday February 12th of the high school performing arts center is the young fives in kindergarten information night as Dr Ryan mentioned our midwinter break is Monday next Monday and Tuesday no school for students and staff School resumes Wednesday the 19th our next Board of Education meeting is Monday February 24th we are going to have a workshop on secondary math initiatives and then our regular board meeting is Monday March March 10th at 700 p.m. item 11 is adjournment May I have a motion please move to adjourn support motion made and supported all those in favor please say I I any opposed motion Carri thank you we are adjourned thanks everybody