CorpusRecord 52918

DPS BOE Meeting 12/9/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / DeWitt Panthernet
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Clinton County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,601 words · about 26 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e J Li over this you are superintend and board members we're singing for today along with your families see them over there let's give them away let's say thank you so much for inviting us to S super excited let the show begin here we go we're do the sh song Happ sing again our words to keep us safe the pro any way list to what others say respons every sh each other respons [Applause] all right the next song is our positive Affirmation song repeat after me here we go I am sfe I am sfe I am kind I am kind I am responsible I am responsible that's not all that's not all I believe that I can change the world and singing like I that I change the world here some new signs

002we just learned say I am love I am I am bra I am brave I am a helpful friend I am a helpful friend that's not all but that's not all I believe that I can the world I I change [Music] World beautiful the next song we're seeing is called our boundary song show how do you boundary and sign with this boundary maybe some of you heard this one I feel like a lot of kids were home singing this one you ready get those signs going one two here we go please St one more time please I great song for anyone to use right this is the sing along what we practice are you guys ready for this one here we go we did practice it celebrate you some one two s i Cate you

003I [Music] Cate I Cate you I [Music] Cate sing this part you you are amazing just the way you are I am amazing just the way I am we come together just the way we are we stand together what are we strong together okay every going sing it I celebrate you I Cate me feel the joy feel the love can't hear [Music] you I feel yay all right we got the song next and I know you guys prob know this one to sing along if you know it here we go [Applause] we want to say thank you to the board members and to our superintendent for inviting us again we're going to get our b c real quick we go give [Music] okay let's all take a deep breath ready Brea bre [Music] yay let's

004give these [Music] [Applause] all right see thank you again you guys e e okay next on the agenda tonight is another presentation we're going to have D hold school's budget amendment with Rob spola our assistant superintendent finance and operations welcome thank you unfortunately I would not be nearly as acing what you just experienced in the auditorium but um go ahead and ask questions as I go through this the finance committee meet last week nothing has changed last week but we'll Dive Right In And like I said if you got questions along the way just shout them out as we're going through it so starting with our Revenue back in June the board had approved about $4.8 billion of of total revenue we're projecting with this budget amendment about $ 41.6 million which is an increase

005of $777,000 breaking that down we've got four primary sources of revenue it's local state federal and then kind of other category as we look at our local Revenue that's up about $174,000 primarily that's property tax revenue increases from the dollars that we we knew we had back in June compared to what we we do know that we have now as we go into the 24 25 year but keep in mind that $114,000 increase it's decreased on the state side because for every dollar we get in property cash Revenue the state takes away a dollar in state aid that we receive so the net sum is zero but we have to reflect proper cat revenue on local revenue and then we have to decrease it on CR state revenue our athletic gate receipts sport pass on

006participation fees are are pretty strong if we've gone through the fall season so we're looking at probably about an additional $114,000 of Revenue uh related to the Athletics area and then we've received some of the jewel settlement funds so if you'll recall we were part of that baking La SU and those funds started coming in so we've received about 32,000 to date uh we will have a corresponding expenditure increase the buildings right now are working on the ways uh in which that they wish to spend those funds and I Envision it being a combination of some purchases along with some education for the students and we've targeted herbison Woods the middle school and the high school for those dollars and then we have just some miscellaneous excuse me amounts as well within our local line

007state revenue is where you're going to see a lot of ups and downs the net decrease is 61,000 with our state revenue um first there's that decrease on the taxable value change to 114,000 we also have a decrease due to enrollment so we've projected our enrollment Blended will be 3122 for this year we're at 3109 so we have a loss of about 13 FTE in students and that's equating up to about $129,000 additionally we have a loss of about $749,000 because when we put our budget together we had assumed a foundation increase and we had assume $249 or $241 is what that increase would be when the state budget got finalized at the end of June they actually get a 0 Foundation increase they end up putting some additional dollars into the retirement side of

008the dollars that we received but our foundation allowance is flat you're over here one of the nice things that the state worked in last year was a categorical that addressed the fact that a lot of districts across the state are experiencing enrollment declines year-over-year and so if you are a district that happens to have a decline like we do there is a categorical that doesn't make you whole but does cover a portion of that loss last year they had to prate the amount there was not enough dollars available to fully fund that so I kind of put in an estimate of what I thought we received if there had to be a pration again I'm hoping that's a conservative number and maybe we'll get a little bit more than $34,000 that's that's estimated there but

009that's what I've calculated so far and then the next two lines relate to our retirement system so the first one is a true increase in dollars available uh we have what it's called a mier's cost offset um as well as some unfunded liability some dollars that we we get from a District's perspective help cover those costs that's projected to be about a million dollar increase year-over-year um however we do have a decrease for some flow through dollars so we also have some unfunded liability dollars that come in from the state that we then have to turn around and remit to the officer Retirement Services usually about 7 to 10 days after those funds come in um um so that's a decrease of $583,000 but we have a decrease on the expenditure side as well so

010that line item ends up being a net zero for the bottom line of our district but again we have to reflect that loss of Revenue and then you'll see on the expenditure side that we reduce the retirement expense that we're paying uh to coupable on side of that and then the last P Point here is our at risk categorical funding that's got about $67,000 will be budgeted in June and that's a combination of the fact that we have uh a new way that the state's calculating those funds to district and then we unfortunately have fewer students that are qualifying for those funds so we're seeing reduction in that categorical line we continue on with state revenue the next two B points uh c special life categorical and these are increases one is in essence an

011ongoing and the other one is a one time so when we close out our books we're required to submit a a report to the state that tracks our actual special categorical um expenditures and then what they do is they will true up our dollars for this year based on last year's actual but then they also Drew up in a one-time payment our last year of what our final numbers are so the $83,000 should be an ongoing we'll get that increase and it should be ongoing as long as the costs stay at least where they are this year and don't go down and if our composition General FTE students versus special FTE students kind of stays consistent as what and then the $25,000 truly is just a one time catches up from last year and we

012move on next bullet point encapsulates four categoricals that were new last year and or into this year uh so the first one is a reduction and it's the school uh mental health and school safety if you'll recall back in June the state had actually slashed that funding over 90% from dollars that we had received previous two years they did restore some of those funds in a supplemental but still to the tune of a reduction of about $261,000 for our indri the next is uh they call it section 35j it's a literacy professional development and curriculum supports categorical about $451,000 what we received most of those dollars went to the Wonders curriculum that was approved by the board this past spring so roughly 380,000 of that went towards that curriculum the remaining dollars went to professional

013development for the teachers for basically learning and and and understanding what that c was so again those are one time dollars that received and then for those adoptions as well as the training we also have a district transport Transportation cost categorical that's up about $29,000 from the initial allocation to the receipt uh and just as a reminder those funds are being used to purchase to cover in part the bus purchases that were approved by the board so roughly 950,000 that was approved in the spring for the bus we purchased in July 200 of that is going to to cover that cost and then the last bullet point here is a student loan repayment categor CL the state offered some dollars for staff members working in districts if they met certain criteria and were making Federal

014loan payments they could get some dollars help offset payments they had already made so the dollars came to the district we had to turn around and paay staff that uh qualified for this so again you've got revenue we go off expend those costs that's state revenue so there's a lot there I'll pause for just a minute to see if anyone had any questions on Lo State areas not a federal not much change in federal we're down about 4,000 W be projected in June so we got not a lot of change there and then our last bucket in revenue is transfers another and that's up about 69,000 first two are uh funds that we receive from the ISD so we've got our special ed fund you'll recall back this summer there was a millage that the

015ISP had on the ballot that if successful there was some dollars that would come to the local that was successful so that $158,000 that's reflected here are some additional dollars that are FL from CC res to the locals to help cover costs the second is related to vad funding not a lot of change there but there's about a $21,000 increase in funding coming for bad programming uh and most of that gets offset with some tuition ch changes that we had on on what we initially thought we would have and then the last two are things that you'll see on the expenditure side as well so we did an installment purchase agreement that was approved by the board in June I believe for $450,000 that was also being used to help fund the purchase of the

016buses uh so you'll see um the bus purchase on the expenditure side and that's what at 450 went and then last month the board approved the sale of two buses that cost or of Revenue of $40,000 we have an agenda item tonight for this approval of the Chevy Travers which will be using um these funds to recover that cost so that's Revenue we shift years in focus to the expenditure side about $4 41.6 million is the expenditures that were approved in June we're looking at about $ 43.2 million with the amendment which is an increase of about a million5 and as we look at the major adjustments in our expenditures the first two bullet points are items that we talked about on the revenue side of the retirement changes and there those categorical changes and

017then the next four are are are new exclusive expenditures so we were wrapping up negotiations with our our units in the spring and early summer so we've reflected all the contract changes related to that as well as some off schedule payments that we put into place when we we sell contracts we just wrapped up open enrollment in November so for all of our helping dental vision insurance changes we work those in previous Amendment now that open enrollment is closed we do have one fewer special ed era that we need versus what we thought that we need in June and then uh part of negotiations we also made some adjustments for our schedule within our teachers contract so we reflected those changes within this budget amendment continuing on we had some select departmental budget adjustments that

018we made our workers comp insurance is actually up year-over-year basically a mod Factor that's that's adjusted this year for that our substitute teacher cost training a little bit higher than I was thinking they would back in June so I collected some additional cost to cover that uh we approved I believe in July maybe June uh official and game work through changes in athletic so I work those into the budget uh and then the next year I think we talked about again on the revenue side so it was the purchase of the buses and some of the revenue sources to cover that the district vehicle and then the Jew fing and find uses for that and then the last budget line is um our 11 ke position so we originally had four Specialists it's now three

019specialists in being assistant principal of the high school and three Paras that we had worked into the budget um when we were receiving some of the federal dollars knowing that if nothing changed when the dollars we had related and kind of tied to those went away those positions might go away but also knowing that we were hopeful to be able to add those positions in over time this budget reflects adding one more position so we added one last year we're adding another here so we got two of those positions that now have formally been worked in the budget and you'll see in two slides kind of how the remaining positions look work and how they kind of the plal so that's expenditures anything on the expend when you say increase substitute teacher cost that keeps

020us competitive with surrounding districts so we made an yes it does um this is related more to to use um but we did do an increase in our sub rates when we had the initial budget approved and our hope is to be able to do some small incremental increases every year the St competitive or maybe slightly ahead of what other districts are are doing and part of that is we we four or five years ago we landed in a situation where kind of in the Tri County Area there was an agreement that we would all move together and you started having districts that were going off and setting their own rates and then there was a reluctance from those that weren't making changes to make any changes and we just got way behind in what

021the sub rate should be so we made a onetime adjustment and then the last couple years we've been doing these small increases so that's a good question but this cost here is more tied to just usage of sub costs any other questions so if not then we take everything that we talked about we put it into the format that the state requires if you look at the total revenue line You'll see that's 41.6 million look at the total expenditure line we're at 43.2 so we've got excess Revenue over expenditures of a negative almost $1.6 million we're talk about that on the next slide because that's not a structural imbalance that we have but we'll talk about that next uh then once we look at fund balance we started the year at 9.5 million we're projecting

022to be about 7.9 million which is a little bit over 18% and more importantly we'll V this slide breaks down what that looks like so starting with just the the revenue over expenditures so we have about a million 6 deficit however we have three line items within that budget that are not recurring costs so as I mentioned we have off schedu payments to all of our staff those one time pay them this year they come off of the expenditure side we've also been paying down or spending down our Equalization funds and then we've got those section 11t expenditures so we back those three line items out our structural balance if you go is about $132,000 but keep in mind that's on A3 is million budget so I would defend that structurally we basically b as

023we look at just the dollar side of things the second component of that is our assigned fund balance so the way that it worked with the federal dollars that weed is we kind of front loaded being able to claim the revenue but the expenditures we've been paying in smaller increments over time so when we closed the books in June we had a million $ 77,6 67 we assigned for those 11t positions we're projecting that we'll use up about $486,000 of that so as we close out this year we'll still have about a million2 in fund balance to pay those positions going forward which buys us some time to see if there's more of those positions we can formly work into the budget and that million two will give us roughly another 2 and A2 years

024to be able to figure that out then as we take that down even a little further and we look at our fund balance in total and you'll see the fund balance ass signed at that million2 our unreserved is at about $6.7 million probably more importantly what's that mean on a percentage basis right about 15.5% of unreserved fun balance right about 2.8% of ass signed fund balance that makes up at 18.3 we saw on the previous slide we're sitting about 15% which is really where we want to be on the unreserved side of things and then we still have that assign to figure out those positions so I think this is an important slide to really put some context to what you saw in the previous slide balance amount so with that that would conclude my

025presentation unless there's any last questions any of you might have questions for yeah Rob I know we talked at the finance committee a little bit of uh looking forward what you might expect I know flamed up right now in the the legislature and funny things can happen What do you expect this to look like over the next six months to a year yeah power in the house and yeah I think that the the legislator is going to try to do a lot of things here over the course the next couple of weeks I think the two things that we're going to have to watch is tax shifts uh so things that are currently going into the state aid fund that may be diverted into other areas which will impact our ability to get funding into

026the future and then the other one is if they make any adjustments to uh Insurance caps which could have an impact on us um over the course of the next couple of years so that's what I see kind of in the short term with lame dock longer term with uh the Republicans uh taking control of the house come January you're going to have a split legislature Senate with the Democrats house with Republicans and I unfortunately think we're going to be in a position where we were maybe a dozen years ago where budgets do not get settled in June we're looking probably at August September I even see going into October before a budget settled which was going to make our jobs more difficult as we are required by law to have our budgets passed in

027place by the end of June so that's kind of what I see on the horizon and then I I just don't know if the dollars clearly aren't going to be there like they have in the last few years but I don't know if if they don't play nice um it'll be interesting to see what what what happens here course the next 6 to9 months and then we have the federal side of things as well that could have some rle effects just what happens with the Department yeah with that fund balance is that unreserved number that we target for around 15% right correct am I remembering right okay app thank you all okay we'll move on to public Communications for items found on the agenda nothing we will close Public Communication we will move on to

028our student report please welcome Molly BR you please hi thank you um I really want to talk about our community outreach during the holidays um as we approach the holidays we obviously know that there are some people in the community and the surrounding communities who might struggle a little more than others so I wanted to recognize a club at the high school do it gives back they're running multiple events throughout this holiday time including a Giving Tree and gift bags these holiday gift bags allow students and community members to create a connection with young children at a partner school in order to give them a memorable holiday experience along with creating the gift bags gives back allows its members to to deliver the bags helping them helping to see the best impact they have on

029the surrounding communities and then additionally do it get back with the help of student government co-host to the F Drive um and this F Drive was unique because it wasn't the traditional related items we targeted cereal boxes and birthday cake mixes which allows certain communities to have access to maybe more luxury goods that they would normally have access to and then recognizing another club the business Professionals of America um they begin their competition season with a regional competition next Friday which allows many students at the high school to present about the business skills they've learned and study throughout their club and then and band programs additionally have been embracing the holiday spirit with various holiday events and concerts that are upcoming and then turning to the athletic side of things our successful fall season has

030come to an end and the start of our promising winter season has begun many student athletes jump straight from Winter sport to or fall sport to Winter sport which can be very difficult for them but we can see that it shows the dedication of all high school athletes and as to participate in this winter season we are excited to see what our teams can do additionally throughout this winter season we are choosing to prioritize class Unity with a senior class planning a senior class event that allows students to interact with peers that they may not normally interact with this event as well as many other school planned activities and staff appreciation events are essential in creating a positive school clment for all students and staff and then one final thing Board of trustee Miss carpenter

031has expressed interest in being a student for at high school so we're currently planning a date for that and we're excited to have I'm looking forward to it any questions M thank you m appreciate it okay move on to some action items first we'll start with the consent agenda it's recommendation by superintendent Kev robida Board of Education approved adopt and accept the following items for immediate implementation and appropriate action as presented approval of minutes from the regular meeting November 11th 2024 curricular and Improvement committee meeting November 11th 2024 policy committee November 21st 2024 and finance committee December 4th 24 the treasurer's reports and all the bills and checks and payments the treasur has reviewed those for November 24 out of state overnight student trip request for Middle School 8th grade students to koca City sha

032Japan January 23rd through 31st 2025 and the professional hiring of Jacob Hampton as dit's new director of technology and media service do have a motion supp support any discussion okay all those in favor please say I I I any post motion carries next to the budget amendment it's recommendation by assistant superintendent Rob sto and superintendent Kevin rid the Board of Education approved the following Amendment budget for the 2024 2025 fiscal year for D Public Schools General frund revenues of 41,600 205 564 expenditures exceeding Revenue by 1.58 a235 resulting in an estimated fund balances of June 10th 2025 of 7,934 229 as motion so moving for to any discussion all those in favor please say I I any post motion carries next we will move on to the purchase of a district vehicle it's a recommendation

033by R spago assistant superintendent for finance and operations at the Board of Education approve the purchase of a Chevy Traverse at a cost not to exceed wrestling at times uh that doesn't need a fullsize bus to be able to get to events we also have some transition programs up at the high school uh of some students within our special needs program that go off and do some work-based learning opportunities again we don't need a fullsize bus for them to to be able to to go off on on those uh work experiences so this gives us an opportunity to be a little more cost effective and how we provide that that over Transportation are others able to drive that vehicle too without having you know your commercial driver's license or whatever need to through an approval

034process through a transportation department and then they have an opportunity to drive the vehicle themselves great and we also will use it at times for personal development so if we've got a core team of five or six people may be going to an out of town uh PD they can also use that versus everyone taking their own Vehicles Great thank you any other questions for okay all those in favor please say I any clst okay we move on to technology presentation systems part of the bonds uh the recommendation by superintendent Kevin robic that the Board of Education approved the purchase of 160 short throw interactive projection systems from bond funds as presented you got a quote there from data image it's provided for your review motion okay moving for any discussion yeah so that one

035shared talk more to it but essentially we wanted to do this now in the first year because the prices are going to go up S Bond dollars are there so this is some the project we already plan with the bond right Sherry yes this is a portion of the project we will be purchasing a few other random projectors but this is the bulk of them that's going to be the piggy share of the purchase and so we tried to get that out of the way before the price increases um happen um these are essentially replacement projectors so they will go in classrooms in the same locations that currently have now what's the lead time on those Sher are things moving pretty quickly they're moving moving relatively quickly so we shouldn't have any delays the intent

036is to put them into place over the summer I noticed it sounds like shav's getting skipped out because they're going to be under construction do we plan to do shevy later or absolutely okay I was I just didn't want to pre- purchase for a 2year install because then you have warranty issues and things like that and then construction you always have issues okay and the other thing is is I just wanted to mention that I have been in discussion with our new tech director with Jacob and he's absolutely on board with the whole process and all that with it he would be here tonight except for um his school actually has board meetings on the same night and Sherry thank you for everything you've done to come back and serve an interim and keep the

037ship a flat we really appreciate it okay move been supported discussed any other discussion all those in favor please say I hi po motion carries next is early graduation requests is the recommendation by superintendent Kevin robc that the Board of Education approved three requests for early graduation as presented to a motion so move moveed in support to any discussion all those in favor please say I I any post motion carries next is the MB board of directors nomination recommendation by superintendent Kevin ridc that board of education support the nomination of Josh from monana to represent Region 4 on the MP board of directors this is a re-election appointment as I have served the two years or the partial this will be a three full year term so I will abstain from this ask but do

038we have a motion support support any discussion or questions all those in favor please say I I any oppos motion carries next we have our first reading of policies it's recommendation by superintendent Kevin ridc at the Board of Education approve the following policies for first reading as presented policy 53302 5340 5500 7230 8321 1130 3110 4110 6110 6111 6112 6114 6325 6550 7310 and 74 0 do we have a motion I think what you just what I just read some of them were some of them were correct but we did let's go with on the agenda so I'm going to read those one more time the agenda okay know we good here 31208 53 30.02 5340 7230 8321 1130 3110 4110 6110 6111 6112 6114 6325 7310 and corer that into the record we have

039a motion right move and supported any discussion I I will just say there are some of our technology related policies are under thorough review we'll just say right now the new tech director is going to take a close look at them over the next month or two come back to the board with some recommendations there's just some cleanup that needs to happen in terms of how things interact with one another and things like that so everybody should note that the other thing is I I want to say to Angelina and Hana it was a fun it was a fun committee meeting we we have a a really good robust discussion about these policies so I don't want anybody to think that we're passing however many policies this is these are with no discussion I think

040we had two and a half hours of discussion on these so thank you to to to both of you uh it was a lot of fun in a very nerdy way yeah we bring our our nerd s to the table in really different ways so no I agree I think we we had quite a few hours of really good conversation about these and I'll second the the Tech ones we kind of paused so that they could get a more thorough review before we finalize those and we talked about these ones at length and I feel good about them sounds like we have to write three or mbers on it thank you all for your service all right any other discussion okay all those in favor please say I I any oppose motion carries okay that

041will do it for Action items uh one form of disc discussion before we get to public Communications I just wanted to check in with everybody uh you know we' been the policy of this board to donate our our payments you know for our meetings and our service here back to the school we create two scholarships for at high school seniors you have your pay subs in front of you that have that donation going back and the foundation for that just kind of want to get some nods veral agreements we're all still okay proceeding with that policy yep yes okay and we will do that to two scholarships for this as okay we move on to public Communications for any items not found on the agenda time okay then we will close public Communications and we

042will move on to the superintendent report all right thank you I'm pleased to share that the board of education is recognizing the incredible dedication of our staff by providing s rals this week it's a small but heartfelt gesture to show our gratitude for all that they do to support our students and the community as we approach the holiday season I want to take this opportunity to wish all of our families a joyful and peaceful time with their loved ones this season is also a time of giving and kindness I'm inspired by the many holiday activities taking place across our schools our staff our students and our district families are coming together in remarkable ways to lift up those in need your generosity and compassion are making a meaningful differ in our community I extend my

043S thanks to the Board of Education our dedicated District staff our amazing families for your efforts act of kindness big and small bring Smiles STS and reminders the power of community is a great school and a great district and a great community and that's all I have today any questions for Mr anything else from anybody thank you um I just wanted to throw out there for the board in general that um I'd like us to consider an opportunity for board members during board meetings to have an opportunity to share back um a lot of us are hearing from consents in the you know Community we're dealing with issues we answering questions for people or being asked questions from people um and I would well for us to consider an opportunity for board members you don't

044have to use it every time but that we build somewhere in our agenda where we can um report that back out or talk about it um just the last couple weeks that the I've had opport to work on significant issues such as for our band director to have you know additional support in Staffing um the way we you know some of the language bylaws how we post our budget you know there's just lots of things that we're hearing from people and I think that might be beneficial if there's just a little of space for members to share that back out and I don't know what capacity that we build that in or talk about that and that yeah I'd second that entertain a motion for adjournment simple all those in favor please say I I

045okay we are adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.