001good afternoon everyone and welcome to the Orange County School Board work session this afternoon Tuesday December 20 December 10 2024 thank goodness we're not in 208 and we're here for the purpose of discussing the potential for Guardians in our schools the public will not have a opportunity to participate in this work session to provide public comment because there is not a regularly scheduled meeting and because the school board will be taking no action and there will be no public comment period before this meeting I do I want to stress that again the school board will be taking no official action today if we were we would definitely be taking public input again thank you all for joining us this morning also as a reminder to the board and to the public board members will not
002be engaging in outside digital communication during the meeting so that we can focus our full attention on the issue before us and to my fellow board members staff and members of the public and myself remember when speaking please make sure your microphone is turned on and that you're speaking directly into it so that our YouTube and orang TV viewers can hear you clearly now we will begin with a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance and now for the pledge I pledge Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation indivisible with liy and justice for all all right right we're going to begin in just a minute I'll turn the floor over to Dr Vasquez but I do want to take
003this opportunity this is our first work session where we have our two new board members so I want to take this opportunity to welcome board member Vanos welcome she's been a regular inour meetings in terms of being in the audience I think for almost every meeting that I can remember for many years now so welcome and we are excited to have your participation in this role and another new member of our board but not new to Orange County Public Schools is member Douglas and member Douglas has spent years teaching in Orange County Public Schools and she joins us on the board with her wealth of experience which is invaluable to the decisions that we make here with that I will turn the floor over to Dr Basquez thank you madam chair this afternoon you will
004hear from our chief operations officer Mr Roberto Pacho and chief Holmes on the guardian program as you know we have benefited greatly from having SRO in our schools I am so thankful for the partnership that we have had for so many years in ensuring that our schools are safe places is of for our students to learn and for our employees to work we engaged in negotiations starting in February of this year hoping to secure a three-year contract with the various agencies that support our schools we were able to reach a three-year agreement with agencies with all but five of the agencies impacting 30 schools you will hear here today information about the guardian program you will hear about the costs associated with the program and the contract that we currently have in place and we
005you will also hear that we need to make a decision about our next steps by the end of January as it will take us approximately 6 months to stand up the guardian program you will also have an opportunity to ask questions of both Mr Pacho and chief Holmes after the presentation and I am now going to turn it over to Mr Pacho thank you superintendent good afternoon chair superintendent board members ensuring our staff and student Safety and Security remains our utmost priority before the commence of the school year as stated by the superintendent we negotiated with nine local law enforcement agencies to secure safe School officers for all our traditional schools this negotiation process resulted in a three-year agreement with four agencies and a one-year agreement with the remaining five these agreements detail the roles
006and responsibilities of each party including the reimbursement rates for services rendered by law enforcement agencies and their officers while we will continue to negotiate however it is imperative that we consider alternative options to ensure Readiness for any potential outcome today we will discuss some strategies to maintain a safe and secure environment in our schools independent of the results of the ongoing negotiations with the five remaining law enforcement agencies these five remaining law enforcement agencies cover 30 over our 213 schools our goal today is to provide a comprehensive overview regarding these Alternatives particularly the application of the Guardian program and to discuss how we can best serve our school district with that goal in mind our agenda for today will be the following we will remind you about the safe School officer mandate tell you a
007little bit of background about that we will present information on the guardian prog program including background information on the creation of the program the application of the program training screening and re recertification requirements for the program and those participating on it programming implementation considerations we will compare the different types of school of safe School officers and we will provide you details on funding information reimbursement rates historical data and comparative analysis and lastly as stated by the superintendent we will have some time to answer any questions that you might have today beside me is the chief our district police and also our school safety specialist Brian Holmes that he will continue with the presentation at this time good afternoon chair members of the board superintendent section 1000 decimal one2 Florida Statutes states that each district school
008board and superintendent shall partner with law enforcement or security agencies to assign one or more safe School officers ERS at each school facility within the district including charter schools these could be done by using a combination of school resource officers these are warn certified Law Enforcement Officers employed by a local law enforcement agency school safety officers that's what the district police currently is these are law enforcement officer certifies the law enforcement agency or the district school board a school safety officer has has the power to arrest persons under the same conditions as a deputy sheriff are authorized to make arrest on board property School Guardians a school district and there's three different types of Guardians so let me be clear a school district or Charter School employeer Personnel including teachers who volunteers to serve as
009a school Guardian in addition to his or her official duties an employee a school district or a charter school who is hired for the specific purpose of serving as a school guardian and then there's the school security guard a school district or Charter School governing board May contract with a private security agency to employ an individual who holds a Class D and class G license provided to the security guard has also completed the guardian training program and I'll go into specifics about that in a bit so I'm going to give you a little background on how the guardian program got started in the State of Florida on February 14 2018 a gunman took 17 lives and injured 17 others at margerie stowman Douglas High School in Parkland Florida as a result the legislature passed a
010bill creating that Chris Hixon coach Aon feice and Coach Scott bigel Guardian program in honor of those who gave their Liv lives during this tragedy why the guardian program was created well the margorie stowman Douglas High School Public Safety commission found that having Guardians in schools is an option to ensure highly trained Personnel are in place to respond immediately in the event of a school shooting also the cost of law enforcement Services continues to escalate something we're experiencing here and the funding received by the districts from the state is not sufficient to pay for all the School Safety and Security expenditures next slide so I'm going to go over this real quick just so you're clear about what a guardian program and how it applies again a school district employee who volunteers to serve as
011a school Guardian in addition to his or her official job duties a school district employee who is hired for the specific purpose of serving as a school guardian and then the third option security Guardians contracted by the school district through a security agency so what type of training do they have to have each Guardian candidate must complete a 144-hour training program this consists of 12 hours of a certified nationally recognized diversity training and 132 toal total hours of comprehensive firearm safety and proficiency training conducted by a criminal justice standards and training commission certified instructor that's a law enforcement firearms instructor though these are minimum requirements some Sheriff's offices Also may choose to require additional hours training exceeds the requirement actually for a police academy Train E for the 144 hours total when it comes to
012you combine the diversity and the firearms and the other training a sheriff's office shall provide training once the district school board and Sheriff's Office approve implementing the guardian trading the sheriff shall issue a school Guardian certificate to individuals who meet the statutory requirements the sheriff shall maintain documentation of weapon and Equipment inspections as well as the training certification inspection and qualification records of each School Guardian appointed by the sheriff what are some of the other requirements well they have to pass a psych psychological evaluation administered by a licensed psychologist designated by the Department of Law Enforcement and submit the eval evaluation results to the Sheriff's Office they must submit to and pass an initial drug test and subsequent random drug test in accordance with statutory requirements and that of the Sheriff's Office and lastly successfully
013complete an ongoing training weapons inspection and Firearms qualification on at least an annual basis and again back to that recertification requirement Guardian must be recertified on an annual basis any of the expenses incurred by the Sheriff's Office to facilitate the recertification are eligible for reimbursement by the state of Florida Department of Education using Guardian program Grant funds so the sheriff gets paid back for these services that he's providing in the training recertification requirements are determined by the Sheriff's Office responsible for initial certification in conjunction with the depart Florida Department of Law Enforcement next slide again funds are provided to the Sheriff's Office for screening related and training related cost as well as a onetime stien of $500 to district and charger School Employees at personnel and teachers who volunteer to serve as Guardians any expenses
014incurred by the Sheriff's Office related to screening training or stiens again are eligible to be submitted to the Department of Education for reimbursement so what are some of the things you ought to consider if you're considering a guardian program next slide let's talk about threat management all traditional and charter schools are required to have a school Bas threat management team the team requires a sworn law enforcement officer to be on the team Guardians did do guardians do not meet this requirement as a sworn law enforcement officer the school Bas thre man management team must meet at least monthly once monthly and in the event there's a threat at the school they have to meet to ass set assess any one of the threats or concerning behaviors that happen to go to the team itself let's
015talk about shared risk and responsibilities because any person certified as a school Guardian has no authority to act at any law enforcement capacity except to the extent necessary to prevent or Abate an active as salent incident on our campuses they're not standing in the place of a cop they can't make an arrest the current s model shares the risk and responsibility between the dis the district and our local law enforcement agencies that provide these Services it's shared risk shared responsibilities the SRO model increases the force multiplier effect that we get by having a local law enforcement agency as serving in that capacity in our school the sro's can contact their detectives to share information their Intel analysts will be involved in their investigations they have additional Personnel that can be called at a moment's notice
016on their radio and here comes the calvary in the event they need support or help next slide other things that we need to consider or you need to consider as the board are Community concerns utilizing a guardian model May diminish the perception of security across the entire District some schools don't have an SRO they have a guardian instead the diminished response capability to emergency is at schools because typically the Guardians are not carrying that agency's radio they don't have that's something we might be able to mitigate but those agencies would have to agree to that and then a perception of inequity of service as well why do these schools have a guardian why do these schools have an SRO those are questions that we'd have to address let's talk a little bit more about these
017the services that are brought by an SRO model well presence there's a cop there in a uniform that can act they have Mark patrol cars they have both offensive and defensive weapons capabilities rifles helmets Shields chem agent tasers expandable batons handcuffs all the officers in this County Carry Nar naren in the event we have an OD on our campus now some of these things I can mitigate that's something I may be able to mitigate with a with a program using the guardians but we'd have to work on on that Crisis Intervention training again another item I can mitigate but all the officers that serve as SRO in our schools already have Crisis Intervention training and that's a special emphasis on students with special needs that's what that training is mostly all about again law enforcement
018Communications call right to the dispatch here comes the calvary enhanced active asant training threat management and the cops can Baker Act a student that's in need of Baker Act services mental health support on any given day next slide so let's take a look at what some other districts are doing we use utilize these I'd like to start with Hillsboro Hill Hillsboro has what I like to refer to as a hybrid model they have Guardians in their Elementary they have sros in all their middle schools and then if their high schools they have two but one is an SRO and the other's a guardian P County Guardians in their Elementary sros in the middle schools again that hybrid model Sone and Guardians and Sheriff Jud you know he can't have enough people arms so he is
019actually adding administrators to his schools as well that have Guardian training Bard they have the same model Guardians in Elementary middle schools sros and then s Guardian in their High School Oola SOS in their traditional schools Guardians only in their Charters Lake County srose with guardians as a second layer uniformed administrators or professional managerial Personnel are concealed carry seminal sro's only and then last but not least dedicated Guardians at valua in nearly every school schools without a guardian have an SRO next slide so we did some estimated cost for you mind you these are estimates we'll start with the SRO program this year we're paying 72,000 we factored in some things that we pay additional for and not all of it but most of it pre-planning spring break Camps summer camps and summer school we
020pay $55 an hour for additional services for any of the SRO and those particular C capacities you got a total salary of 87,8 40 and that's a grand total for the SRO security guards all right we got a company to give us a bill rate and we factored in 180 day school year additional for the other things I just mentioned and then of course total salary is 74 304 and then if we were to hire Guardians here that work for district police and put them in the schools the actual salary itself would start lower and then some of the additional costs would be a bit lower but when you add the equipment I'd have to provide enough firearm belts uniforms a vest and things of that nature a radio a school radio and a radio
021most likely to be able to talk directly to District police we get up to 74,000 which is very comparative comparative when it comes to the security guard model so here are just some summary of of considerations if we had a guardian model it would require the district police to provide oversight for the guardian program a lot closer threat management teams we would have to cover that and step in there and then incident response and Reporting the schools that have Guardians most likely you know if there was an emergency in the school they would be calling the local agency but if there was a need to take a police report possibly some sort of disruption there's a chance that we would have to do that and respond to the school other considerations risk to the consistency
022and responsible to our security protocols onboarding process hey it takes time and resources to do that and we would have to hire probably if it was us 34 Personnel if it was a security guard agency that was doing that they do a lot of that on boarding people and they would have those responsibilities it wouldn't be us general liability you know where would the those be shifted to and then again that whole idea of public perception of the inconsistency of services and I'll turn it back over to Mr Pacho to talk about safe schools funding thank you Brian the following slides slide outlines the funds allocated by the state to enhance the saf and security of our students and staff while These funds are essential they unfortunately fall short of covering all the necessary expenses
023associated with our Safety and Security initiatives as a result the district will need to seek additional funding sources to to implement comprehensive security measures the slides detail the amount designated for Charter Schools we have to chare that the funds that we get our district police safe coordinators and all related cost associated with the school research officer program as as shown the estimated additional funding required for fiscal year 25 this year will exce $16.8 million this slide shows the steady increase in SRO reimbursement rates over the past 10 years these increases have been crucial in ensuring that our schools have adequate safety officer coverage notably the rate for the current school year reflects a 20% increase from the previous rate Additionally the rates negotiated for the next two years with the four out of the nine
024law enforcement agencies will result in a final increase of 25% from last school year this demonstrates our District's commitment and collaborative efforts regarding the SRO program these final slides compares the average teacher salary and the SRO reimbursement rate over the past 10 years this illustrates that the SRO reimbursement rate has exceeded the increase in teacher salaries from fiscal year 2021 to fiscal year 2025 the increase on the average teacher salary has grown by 14% while the cost to the district for SRO has grown by 44% so this completes the information that we have for you this afternoon now I hand it over to the superintendent for comments to address any questions you might have thank you B for the informative presentation one last note before we take questions from the board that I don't believe
025was mentioned in the presentation while the increases that while we were not able to reach a three-year agreement with the five agencies because of the requested increases the contract for the other agencies stipulate that if we pay any agency more money than has been agreed to in their contract that they are entitled to that amount hence why for the district it is almost a $2 million additional ask it's not just for the these 30 schools it would impact all all 213 of our schools and Madam chair we will now take U questions from the board all right thank you one question I have in I read over the presentation over the weekend and we met on it do what is the amount that they're actually asking for per officer chair at this point we have
026had a preliminary com discussions with mainly one agency we yet to confirm how much they will be asking for over all those five but the latest number that we have Again unconfirmed by all the other agencies is let me make sure I just I haven't I just haven't found that information and so when we're saying how much more it's going to cost it has to be based on on something here is 755 for fiscal year 26 and 79,000 for fiscal year 27 and that's if you if you use that interpolate that's what the number comes from from the superintendent so that will be for all the agencies close to 3/4 of a million dollar for next year and then about 1.2 million for the following year for the third year that brings us close to
027the $2 million Mark again that number has not been finalized I know that we have one one agency that has said that could be a number that might make them comfortable but all the other four agencies going to have confirmation that will be a sufficient number for them okay I'm going to go through most of the board members do have questions or comments when we Circle back around if you would be able to put up on the screen what we are currently what we would be paying based on our current contract for the next year and the following year not I mean just have that ready so we can compare that to the 75 and the 79 okay does that make sense I do not have a slide reflecting that chair maybe I can that's
028what I'm I'm reading it but I can definitely make that available to all board members you have that information just pull it up and we come back around to me if you can share that with us because that was the other thing that I was missing in this okay okay so what we would be paying for the contracts that we currently have locked in versus what you think they might be asking for the 75.5 and the 79 okay thank you okay let me start with member Gallow thank you madam chair there's a lot to unpack here is anybody else a little sick at their stomach that we have to have this conversation yeah I thought so first off I do have a couple comments I want to thank Orlando PD the Orange County Sheriff Eatonville
029and maand for agreeing to sign this three-year contract we so appreciate them in their efforts to provide the safe safest option for our schools which is a school resource officer and their budgets are tight just like our budgets are tight just like the other five municipalities budgets are tight and yet they found the dollars because they prioritize the safety of our schools and the safety of our students so I want to be very clear on that this is this is we're either going to prioritize their safety or we're not my personal opinion as a Schoolboard member and I don't I think every law enforcement agency in Orange County would agree that the safest option in fact they've said it publicly the safest option for our schools is one that has a school resource officer so
030to speak to the inequity how unfair is it that my district district one is unincorporated I will have SRO at every single one of my schools but I butt up against two member Vanos District which is Winter Park and they may be forced to have Guardians so my children my students in my district will have the opportunity for that safest option and yet Winter Park windir Winter Garden aoi and a poka will not so just that inequity bothers me and it concerns me greatly but I do have a couple of questions I know when you first on one of the first slides we were talking about security guards the guardian program school safety specialist and then of course school resource officers so just for the public's consumption really there's really only two options we got
031a school resource officers which are sworn law enforcement our district police which are school safety Specialists which again are sworn Law Enforcement Officers with arrest Authority and can intervene on any situation that happens on our C campus has been trained to deescalate students students with disabilities and students that have mental challenge they have been trained in that the only people that we allow to bakera kids and I'm not a fan of Baker acts I don't like them but the only people that can on our campuses are Law Enforcement Officers that's it that's the only only people that we will allow to actually bakera on our campuses so when we talk about it our two options are SRO or Guardians because security guards have to be Guardian trained so there's just another fancy term for Guardians
032that we just Outsource versus doing in house correct well the security guards and if we had in-house Guardians administrators whatever may they all have to go through the 144h hour training all of them right and I and I don't think even for today's purpose we're even talking about administrators or teachers because I don't think there's any appetite on this board whatsoever for that but when we do talk about the inequities we will have students that are in those five municipalities that will not want to go to those schools because they don't believe that the guardian is the safest option we also have staff that will want to transfer because they don't believe that Guardians are the safest option for our schools so the ongoing training that's for the Sheriff's Office to look like so you
033can't even tell me here today past that 144 hours what that ongoing training will look like is that correct well that's up to the sheriff the sheriff any additional hours the sheriff would make a decision to do that the annual training is always going to be a Firearms recertification and any additional new information they have about the Guardians and what they would need to know would be part of that for sure so you talked briefly about the difference in an SRO and a guardian and you highlighted some of the points that we've been discussing which is what an SRO has at their disposal versus a guardian because a guardian's only function only function on our campus is to stop an intruder and if someone were to intrude the only way they can stop that Intruder
034is to shoot and kill them because they can't arrest them they can't like they can't even stop like right they've got to shoot them that's all they can do is that correct prevent and Abate okay oh Lordy so if you could just go over a little bit more of what the equipment that an SRO would have versus what a guardian would have because I know we talked about a radio that would be up to each agency if they would afford US or the Guardians allow them to have a radio I know that they don't there's different weapons you spoke about Naran can you just go into a little bit more detail about that please yeah I you know M law enforcement in this County M I want to be real careful about what we disclose
035about capabilities of our Law Enforcement Officers with respect to what they have and what tools are at their disposal I don't want to give that advantage to anybody out there who could be coming on to our campus to know what we have I the stuff that he's discussed but I just want to be real careful about what we disclose publicly I appreciate that I do want to just if I could just a minute I think carrying Naran is fine because that's yeah that is not a danger issue so I'll ask this I'll ask it I'll thank you John I'll ask a genetic not a genetic a generic a generic question school resource officers have more equipment or more Firepower at their disposal than we would allow a guardian to have is that correct correct thank
036you and the new law there's a law that basically says that every district has to have Guardians correct not necessarily guard Guardians you have to have an so a s safe school officer in all of those that I mentioned before fall underneath that category so yes if you don't have the SRO you don't have a school safety officer which I'm a school safety officer then you would have to provide a guardian and one of the options that I discussed earlier I sorry just want to interrupt for a minute Chief Holmes I know it is these mics are very frustrating put that in right in front of you because I do want to make sure were picking up we can hear you in this room but I'm not sure that the mic's picking up go ahead
037thank you thank you madam chair I was referring to I thought there was a law that passed that it was still up to the school board on what they wanted our schools but every District needed to have a guardian and we met that because we have Charters that have Guardians did I Mis that's correct we have met that because we do have Guardians in our charter schools so I'm only pointing that out because I've read a lot of Articles and a lot of comments where they're like the legislature needs to fund the sros the legislature needs to fund the SR and while I agree with that they're really encouraging more Guardians and they've actually mandated that every District have at least one Guardian so I'm not certain that we will get the money that we
038need from Tallahassee because I think Tallahasse has been perfectly clear that they feel that Guardians serve the purpose that they need to serve and prioritize those a as they do sro's on the same like level play field all right let me acknowledge the superintendent for response thank you madam chair and if I am not mistaken if you are choosing to use your own employees as Guardians there's actually grant money to pay the stipan and to offset the cost of the training and so the the state does believe that Guardians is a viable option and there are several districts that employ Guardians and agree with that we have been fortunate to have our SRO and all of our schools which gives more more of a sense of security because of the ability to act in the
039way that they do the training that they have received and for the reasons that Chief Hol has mentioned there's so many other things that they are able to do for us thank you superintendent so we're districts are actually incentivized to use a guardian program okay that's that's all I have for now I want to hear from my cell fellow school board members regarding this thank you thank you member Gallow member Felder you're recognized yes thank you chair first of all i' like to thank officer Holmes and Chief Holmes and Roberto for the detailed report regarding our conversation about Guardians as a former teacher in this District nearly 40 years or more I appreciate knowing an SRO was on the campus I appreciate this time type of camaraderie that they developed with students and so when
040students left the campus were out in the community they recognized the SRO and a lot of crimes were prevented and there was discussion with regards to Guardians even though they're hybrids at work I don't know who the guardian may be it could be a parent or it could be anybody that may not be in the same Community or know the child or know the community and board member Gallow asked again and it struck me again when she asked the question the only equipment they would have would be to just shoot SRO have the ability to arrest to talk to scale down we're living in a season and in a climate where people have no fear about walking on our campuses with AR15s and harming our children and SRO has not gone to a 14we train
041he's gone to an academy or she's gone to an academy and has been trained and received a diploma certificate to express that wide a merit of training that they would have had to know how to handle all the weapons that they have and when officer Chief Holmes mentioned that I think this is on page I can't remember the page but said Guardians don't need they don't meet the sworn law enforcement officers that our officers would have that concerns me also the fact that my schools have Sr either with OPD or with the Orange County Chef's department but my other fellow board members some of them they won't have if this if we can't come to an agreement they won't have access to sros that's unfair that is not right and as a parent or a
042legal guardian that would draw some real concerns for me and thirdly when I look at the salary of teachers 7 and a half hours out a day and the salary that the sro's are requiring the teachers 14% And s has grown by 20% that concerns me I'm not going to Bel label this any longer because I'm sure we'll come back around with some other stuff but I need you to know I want it on record Schoolboard Vicky Felder I have a concern that there's a difference in our schools where one some schools would have trained trained police officers above a 14-week training but trained as opposed to some of the schools in our district not having that access I that draws great concern for me and I'm not in favor at all thank you thank
043you member Felder thank you member bird you recognized Vice chair thank you chair okay yeah there's there is so much here to unpack as member Gallow said first I think as Chief Holmes shared and my fellow board members have shared we all I believe see the numerous advantages to having our sros in our schools I have some of the would I believe to be the best sro's in our district in my schools that go so far and above Beyond above and beyond what they even have to do even traveling with our football team to go to a away games just to make sure that students and football players are safe the advantages are numerous and cannot be under overs ated one of the biggest advantages too that we haven't even talked about that goes even
044Beyond of course the obvious of keeping our kids safe is the relationships that these SRO build with our students and when our students see these police officers in this light of that they care about them and that they Mentor them they have conversations with them every day they are part of their school Community it changes their perception of what they may think of law enforcement right the negative stories that sometimes you hear about law enforcement it's important for that relationship building for our law enforcement and I've heard that from my Chiefs in my area and from my police officers in my area that they value those relationships and being in the schools and how important they feel that it is to be in the schools that's why I'm so incredibly disappointed by where we're at
045today with all of that being said we have to have coverage in our schools as a school district we do not have a choice we have to have someone in our schools bell to Bell that's the law and we I honestly believe in my heart that we made a very good faith effort in our negotiations as is evidenced by our largest partner the Orange County Sheriff Department accepting the 3year deal they wouldn't have accepted if it wasn't a good deal that was a we increased by 20% in the next three years we will have increased by a 25% increase that is as you said evidence of our commitment to keeping our SRS in our school that's how important it is to us as at the school district despite not being funded properly by the state
046which is not anything new for us here at the school district the safe school funding is just one more allocation that we are underfunded in and I understand as member Gallow said the stresses about not being able to fully staff their Police Department because they needed to raise their rates so that they can hire police officers believe me as a school board member I understand that I've got vacant classrooms with no teacher in it I've got school buses that aren't picked up on time because I don't have enough bus drivers because we cannot offer a salary that is competitive so I understand their conc concern and I understand why they need to raise their salaries I also understand that the municipalities have a little more flexibility with their funding they can raise their taxes which
047I know some of them have recently done but this safe School allocation that we get is the money that we're given period end of story the fact that we are overspending that budget this year by 16.8 actually almost $16.9 million is evidence of our commitment to keep our kids safe is also sad that we are not funded properly the fact that our transportation budget which I know I H on this a lot is only funded at like 50% I think it's even less than that dorine who's in the back but every one of our Cate or categoricals is underfunded so the fact that we have some of our law our law enforcement partners that don't recognize that we are this is what we're given we don't have flexibility we are really stuck between a rock
048and a hard place because we have no other option than a guardian if we if they do not settle this contract with us is disappointing and for me the big question is you know the these are our these school children that attend these schools every day the staff that work in those schools the parents who drop those kids off at their school every day are community members inside of these communities and these municipalities that are arguing about this contract so I personally do not understand where this this attitude of these this is these are your group of people to find the money to protect as opposed to this is not all of our this is these are not all of our community members to protect so I'm extremely disappointed that we are where we're at
049but with all of that being said I appreciate you doing the research on this the guardian program I understand that it does not mean that we are arming teachers and administrators that there are other options to hopefully make it as safe as it possibly can be but those are just my initial thoughts I have some questions but I'm going to leave it there for now thank you thank you member bird let me call on member Fant thank you madam chair hold on let me get used to this mic here over here so I agree with u member bird it is disappointing to see that you know we take great pride here at ocps in making sure that safety of our students is top priority I think every one of us that's one of our biggest
050things is making sure that our kids are safe and it so is disappointing that the I mean what I feel is a incredible raise to the SRO couldn't have been received well by the five different municipalities and so I hope to see in January when things you know the talks and all that get back up that they have a change of heart and see that it is important for them to be in our schools however I do have a few questions and I have talked with other Schoolboard members in different areas throughout Florida just ask them do you have SRO do you have Guardians how is it and I will say I was put at quite at ease the majority of the ones that I spoke to said that they have Guardians in their schools
051and I do see some shaking heads I know that is not what everybody wants and I will be I'm here to as a voice for the community so if the community wants SRO I'm all for SRO but I do want to just share what I heard and so from the other school board members they said that they have Guardians in their schools they feel the majority of those Guardians if not all are former law enforcement and former military which shows that I would never ever want a teacher I would never want a staff member I wouldn't want just a regular Joe from the community to be a guardian but if it is a former U law enforcement somebody who's retired who has the training that's something I would consider if that is where we're at
052and we were literally stuck in between a rock and a hard place I would be willing to look into it further if we don't have the money and that's what we have to do I do want people to understand that in those those school board members all told me that they feel their schools are incredibly safe and they feel that it is they don't feel that there's a difference however I do think when we look at the sro's this is like if if I could have it perfect and have it my way I would love an SRO and continue to have an SRO in every one of our schools so I really hope that we can see a change of heart in our community with the with these different municipalities who are kind of giving
053a push back so with that said couple questions for you with the Guardians I don't remember what page it was on but it was about the 144 hours of training when it talks about the different training so 132 hours would beun gun safety training so they would just have to go through basically how to shoot the gun and if they're already former military and former law enforcements I'm assuming they would know what they're doing they would and I'm pretty confident there'll be some deescalation in there as well that was one of my other questions is with the deescalation because I know some were saying that they would have to just shoot when they see somebody I do not believe that is what would happen that's like a last resort for anyone go ahead not necessarily
054prevent or obate I mean if somebody's a threat to you know our school that's their responsibility okay that's good to know okay the 12 hours of a diversity training what what would that look like you know it's diversity training to make sure you understand the rules of the workplace and treat everybody with respect and so just understanding human diversity training overall yeah guess I don't I'm not a law enforcement so I don't understand what it would be okay it's essentially to make sure you're not stepping on racial religious and you know preferences that people may have when you're working in the workplace so you're not you know insulting people and causing a problem okay okay and then my other question the part of the SRO Services one of them was enhanced activity or excuse me
055enhanced active asent training is that not something that we would have the Guardians go through they would go to active asant training it all depends on what the sheriff decides he would have them do annually all law enforcement agencies in the State of Florida including your District police are required to have active as salent training so I know in the past the Sheriff's Office and OPD and some of the other agencies have asked us over the summer to allow them or of times to allow us to utilize our school and they'll go in there and they'll play they'll run off some active as salent scenarios and okay so if we did have Guardians they would be allowed to attend those that would be up to the sheriff they would have to have some active ass
056salent training we call it in the law enforcement site single officer response to a active shooter and look these things happen very quickly so we've learned that there's no time to wait there's no standing at the door waiting for somebody else to show up you're going to go in and you're going to stop the shooting okay okay those are a good question just things to consider but I did want to just share that with what the other school board members had shared with me U but I do hope that our community and our different municipalities can kind of rally up and see that we do want to make sure that we have the best of the best security here in Orange County thank you thank you member Frant okay I have a couple of questions
057and we'll come back to the cost so obviously board members most board members have touched on the concern about Guardians and I want to start by being very clear that I agree that Guardians are that is not the option that I would ever choose for our schools and I do think that there's a very legitimate Equity issue and that concerns me enormously and we've talked about funding and it troubles me that so many of our categoricals are underfunded we have what was it a $16 million deficit if you will that we cover out of our general fund currently one question I have and you do not want to be misunderstood by anybody either in the room watching this or the media that's covering this I don't want anybody to misinterpret my question but if you're
058able to tell me if we did what I think the state would prefer and had nothing but Guardians would the budget that they provide us cover that CU we know that the budget that they're providing us the funding that they're providing for law enforcement is not adequate would it be adequate for Guardians do you know we have a $16 million deficit if we were paying the rate of a guardian would that go away or would we still have a deficit don't know that's okay that's okay the answer is don't know we'd have to evaluate it Dr Basquez so I just want to make sure for the those listening understand that the deficit that we have is not strictly due to the salary from the sro's our safe school budget funds other enhancements and security measures
059within our schools so it's not just the SRO superintendent thank you very much for clarification I think the path I was going down was that I'm not even well I'm not even sure if we did just go Guardian across the district which I would never in a million years support are we getting enough funding for that and I suspect that's not the case so a couple of other questions and this may have been covered tasers I don't know if U if anybody asked that question are Guardians allowed to use tasers Guardians typically do not carry tasers they're not issued by districts to carry tasers okay and one of the reasons I asked that is it wasn't that long ago or maybe it was a long time ago and I've just I'm just older than I
060like to admit but in my time in office there was a point where Law Enforcement Officers couldn't use tasers they if they needed to use Force they needed to use deadly force and tasers are a very valuable tool for I think for law enforcement officers to have and the idea that we could have have somebody in our school that is faced with the choice of a gun or or nothing is not a good choice nor do I think that the limited amount of training that they have could in any way prepare them for those Split Second decisions that law enforcement has to make and we see this time and time again where we get you know with videos and everything else the whole country gets to look back and say did that law enforcement officer
061make that right decision at that moment and we constantly are second guessing that law enforcement officer and that's somebody who most of the time has had years years in the field and we're talking about putting somebody who has had nothing really but training and learning how to shoot a gun and having diversity training does in no way equip a person to be able to make those life or death decisions in an instant so it frightens me Beyond Comprehension that would be an option that the state would even give us to be quite Frank but it is so since I think most of us are all on the same page we are still faced with a significant problem and a significant funding problem and a significant Equity problem when it comes to that so A couple
062of questions oh and also want to double down on what Vice chair said and I think it's important to recognize that Orange County Public Schools other school districts across the state do not have the ability to raise our tax rates our millage rate sales tax we the only thing that we can do we have two taxes that the legislature allows us to go out to the public and ask for permission with a time limit associated with them to raise taxes municipalities and counties are very different from that they do have unilateral authority to raise their taxes and that's an important distinction in this equation because I think if I'm a city I'm thinking well I don't I can't afford it the county can't afford it but I can't afford it but they do have a
063tool no most politicians don't like to raise taxes but I don't know very many politicians that like to have anything less than the safest environment in their schools there is one aspect of this that over the weekend I keep thinking that why is it that five municipalities need more money for their sros than the other four and I do wonder if we're looking at that fairly from the municipality's perspective so those 30 schools that we're talking about Winter Park for instance Winter Park pays High School Winter Park pays for or provides the SRO for the high school is that correct yes okay and do we know what percent of the attendance zone for Winter Park High School is actually in Winter Park I don't have that information so I was I don't have it either
064I was just trying to look it up and it's a little difficult but I know for instance windir elementary school because I used to represent district one I'm pretty sure that W windir Elementary School covers a large amount of unincorporated Orange County so when I think about the Tiny Town and I'm not trying to be preferential to windamir I just happen to know windamir better when they're asked to allocate Law Enforcement Officers to a school where maybe 50% of the students are actually in their jurisdiction then the proportion of their law enforcement budget that's going to schools is going to be much greater than say the sheriff's office or OPD and I think that factors into why some of these municipalities are struggling to fund this because of the percent of their budget that they're
065spending on a constituency and an attendance Zone that's not theirs so the is that making sense to everybody just because the school is located it could be located on The Fringe of a city with maybe I mean theoretically only 5 or 10% of the kids living in there but that City by virtue of the location of the school is responsible for all the law enforcement officers so looking at it through that lens I think as we're having these negotiations and obviously I'm not at the table and maybe this is something that's been looked at I think we need to rethink how we are asking how we're what we're expecting out of each jurisdiction kind of like we have done with links where we divide up the cost of funding links based on the ridership in
066each jurisdiction so I do think it would be valuable for us to go back and take a look at that I realize that we got one Stu one SRO in an elementary school so it's not like you can divide up and have you know a quarter of an SRO paid by this one a quarter by that one I know that doesn't work but perhaps from a financial standpoint there's a different way of addressing this that allows us to keep the overall rate lower but support and subsidize those jurisdictions that are covering an area outside of theirs with the funds that we give to those jurisdictions who are relieved of the responsibility that they would have if our attendance zones matched the jurisdictions in a lot of States that's the case in a lot of states
067the city runs its old School District Florida is not like that so I would like for us to do that evaluation and maybe start these conversations over looking through their lens as well as our needs Dr vascas you're you didn't you look like you want to speak so I would love your input no I think that's a great idea I do believe and I don't have the exact numbers but I do believe that goes in into who is covering what schools so for example you mentioned windamir windir police only covers one school the Sheriff's Office and I believe the yeah it's a sheriff's covers all the others but we certainly can go back and work with our team to see what percent of the students live within this the town of windamir and these other
068jurisdictions but I do want to remind the board again we have to make a decision in January so we as far I know that there is a meeting coming up I believe next week am I January 14th January 14 I'm Sor in January and that probably will be the time when we have to make a decision about which direction we go because we don't have the dollars to continue negotiating and also secure a contract for the Guardians but we will work on that date and if we are able to get it prior to the break we'll make sure to share it with the board okay and I don't know again it's very very hard to try to put these Maps together this way it we really need it done through a GIS and our demographer
069U Mr Moore would probably be able to spit this out in five minutes he may be doing it as we speak yeah he probably is but like for instance windir High School I was like okay what percentage of the zone and then I'm like wait a minute windir high school isn't it's not in windamir it's just not in windamir so that would not be a good example windir Elementary School is but I'm not sure that there are any middle schools that are in windir that are in the city limit so the fact that windir is only providing one SRO I think is by virtue of the fact that windamir Elementary School happens to be in windir and so I don't know how much that plays into this difference and I think but I think we
070can get to that data pretty quickly and I do think from an equity standpoint from the funding Partners it is very legitimate and fair for us to re-evaluate how the dollars that we have are appropriated and to restart that conversation and like I said with Mr Moore's help I think we can get there pretty quick it's not actually the number of students as much as it is because some students might be in private school or Charter Schools or whatever it has more to do with the ATT tenant's own potential Mr Pacho I think you are ready and then I have that other question for you CH just as you're having as you're having the discussion one thing that we probably need to consider is the the other side which is those agencies that have already
071concluded negotiations so like wind for example if we would look at their coverage some of those kids are coming from the windir area so that rate that was already established for for the sheriff to cover windir probably will have to be modified if we are using the same rationale that we would like to use for Wind Elementary so it just one of the things that I would like to point out it will be the same for anybody any other of those law enforcement agencies that might be serving kids that are coming from these five municipalities so and again if we change those rates then we have to change the other rates as well so just something yeah I mean what I'm suggesting doesn't guarantee that we keep that we're able to keep the same rate
072that we have for the jurisdictions that have agreed to because they've agreed based on the number of Law Enforcement Officers they're dedicating to this and by revisiting how what our expectations are of each that may change I recognize that I just the other thing to recognize is that some of the larger J jurisdictions their overall budget the law the SRO portion not just their law enforcement budget but their overall budget is probably much smaller than a smaller town or city and that matters just like it matters to us when we're looking at our t-shirt population I mean it's a huge part of our budget so every small increase amounts to a very large increase districtwide and if you're looking at a small portion of your employees maybe it's 5% you know the same percentage increase
073for 5% of our employees is less of a hit to our budget and that may be also part of what's factoring into the distinction between the jurisdictions so again I'm I'm not okay with where we are but I do think it behooves us to as much as possible understand where they're coming from and it may there may be some more legitimate reasons than we realize that may cause us to take a different more holistic approach and I would like for us to pursue that thank you so let me go now to anything further I'm sorry oh no I do want to know the answer to my initial question if you could yes I don't I don't want to make our team members into the back nervous but I'm about to disconnect this device to connect
074my device no problem I know that so that I can show you the numbers you requested and while we're doing that just a show of hands in the audience because sometimes I I think I'm communicating and I'm speaking Greek and be honest how many of you in the room have any idea what I was just talking about Oh yay okay oh that makes you feel good I know that our two Commissioners in the audience and I do want to recognize them have completely understand what I'm talking about so thank you all for being here absolutely I justn you can do it extend you want or DLI see extend it's not it's not extending it's not do I wonder why maybe try twist it here there it goes okay I got it we got it to
075work so just to just to show you a couple of notes as the information that you're looking at at the top just to as a point of reference is the rate that we have negotiated for last year so as you can see the last year fisal year 24 we had a agreed upon rate of $60,000 and then the total that equates based on all the total officers that we have the table below what it summarizes is the rates that were agreed upon by the sheriff OPD mland and Eatonville you can see the three rates for each of the three years 25 26 and 27 you can see the totals and I'm going to try to use my to kind of high like what I'm what I'm talking about every time I mention something so these
076will be the total for for the year that the increase is close to $4.3 million and I think that was the number that he wanted to get to that represents the number that we have been talking about the 20% increase for the year then between year two and three on the already agreed upon agreement with all the four out of the five agencies for the second year year will be close to $300,000 which will represent 1.4 % increase from year to year and then the final year will be 600 close to $600,000 we will represent 2.7 % increase from year to year so now if you go to the to the third table that is the number that we have derived again just wanted to clarify that these numbers have not been completely confirmed by
077four out of the five agencies just one said that this is a number that they probably could could entertain so we have the 72 which all I have agreed upon so that we're talking about the 20% increase then we go to year number two this is the number that they probably oh sorry let me make sure that I don't confuse anybody so these is number they have there were with disc C is the 755 what that represents is a 5% increase from the year before you can see the percentages so the idea is that the after the that increase of 20% they're looking at about 5% increase per year then we go to the year three which is 79,000 and you can see on this column the totals oh again I'm trying to highlight too
078much but you can see what the difference is the additional funds to cover the increase that's what we were talking about and the superintendent mentioned as an example once we do it for all these five a agencies we have to make all the other ones whole so the first for fiscal year 26 that will be close to 3/4 of a million dollars that mean not is not only for these five agencies but going back to the other four that I already agreed upon on the previous rate and the third year will be about a million to which bring us to the total that we use as an example close to $2 million so that's hopefully that gives you a better sense and I can zoom in a little bit more so that he a little
079bit clear so this is the these are the numbers that we have been using in order to analyze all the progression through the negotiation process and what we will need to make sure if we get to agreed upon A good rule of thought not a good something that can help you just kind of visualize this in your minds is that we have close to 300,000 300 officers in our in our facilities so every th000 is approximately $300,000 for every th000 that we agreed upon to increase on the rate of SRO is close to $300,000 just to kind of keep that in mind when we talk about increases all right thank you and you know the difference between 1.4 and 5% is a huge difference not just in dollars but and the difference between whatever I
080mean there's like three times as large an increase percentage wise and then twice large Dr Vasquez thank you madam I want to go back to the data that you asked for and I just want to clarify so the data that you're asking for would also then include for example windamir High School where the sheriff pays for the SRO there but there are students that live in the town of windamir yes absolutely yeah no I mean I think the same for the middle schools yeah absolutely it's going to it's going to cut both ways but I think it's helpful for us to understand that again as a percentage I think windamir with regard to the elementary school is going to be a net real negative I think when again middle and high school it's a positive
081to them I don't know how it all washes out but I think it makes sense for us to understand that and look at that again holistically and see what seems fair and Equitable to make sure that we are not going to make a decision that we have to make to satisfy five jurisdictions that cost us this much money when if we had done that analysis we might say okay it's it's not Equitable maybe we have to pay a little bit more but not that much more I don't know but again I think not doing that puts us at a disadvantage with not having access to all the information so I just think it's when you look at the students that live in the town of windir and the windir police only pay for one SRO
082and you take into account that they attend other middle you know middle and high school I think it's in Wind demir's favor but yes well I wanted to make sure we got your request correct and I think oh I do want to take I I did mention we have I think we had two Commissioners we have commissioner Nels Wilson is no commissioner Wilson's here with us yeah thank you is commissioner yure still with us or rbe okay and she was here as well and I think I appreciate both of you all understanding how important this is to our mutual constituents so thank you and congratulations on your Victory glad to have you back at the seat all right member Vanos you're recognized thank you so much Madam chair first of all thank you Chief Holmes
083Mr Poo for this presentation it was really helpful and thank you for answering all of my questions that took a really long time last week so thank you so much for that and also just want to Echo and thank the SRO who I've personally interacted with at my Children's Schools they're just such an amazing part of the community and I'm so glad that they will continue to at least be in those schools I wanted to also I think chair Jacob's brought up a really really excellent point about the funding so I want to ask a few questions about that and also I want to to to start well the funding in that our the funding for ocps is just so limited coming from one stream from the state from the state that as as member
084Galla pointed out is probably not going to increase funding for us even for SRO my question is I know that the safety this the money that we pay for SRO that comes from sort of the Safety and Security allocation will we be advocating for more money to that generally which I know we is used for other things too but is that on our legislative agenda for this year do you know I based on our discussion with Scott Howard I believe it is part of the legislative platform for this year and in order to request more funds for those specific initiatives of security related items that we have to cover from our budget okay thank you I also wanted to know on the slide where you show the SRO funding just in case it's not clear
085to the public I know we talked about this in our meeting but this these the rates that are shown that's not an sro's salary that's just the reimbursement that we're paying and then the remaining part of their salary is paid by the law enforcement agency is that is that right that's correct the one thing to note in regards to the rates is that all the rates are different you know the salaries that are necess s could get paid is dependent of course what agency they work for and also the time that they have been serve serve as an officer so of course based on the lent of Tangers like simul like teachers you have somebody that has been longer serving as a as a police officer that could have a higher rate than somebody that
086had just initiated his career as a law enforcement officer okay thank you kind of going back to what what chair Jacobs mentioned is I have a is this is this hypothetical is this possible let's would it be possible for one of the four agencies that we've reached an agreement with if they had officers that had capacity to serve at one of our other schools that might have to have a guardian or with another one of the 31 schools basically that we're talking about or 30 schools we're talking about if they had the capacity could we use one of the one of the officers from those agencies in one of the schools like in the in a Winter Park School could we use an officer from matland who maybe had capacity in a Winter Park School
087that would be an agreement between those two agencies for that to happen under anou that's not specifically addressed in the M that we currently have here in Orange County Law Enforcement that would be between those two agencies to make that decision sheriff's office has the ability to serve anywhere in the county because they have overall jurisdiction for the county but again typically my experience with the sheriff's office is they're going to respect the other agency's jurisdiction unless they're asked to come in or they have to come in because the agency's overwhelmed for whatever reason for an incident so that's how that typically works okay so it would be possible for ocps to ask let's say Orange County if they had officers that had extra capacity to serve in one of our schools that might not
088have an SRO it's possible we could pose that question to the Sheriff yes okay thank you I have a couple more questions I know you mentioned that the sheriff's office would be doing the training for the Guardians have they expressed that they're that of the agencies that we haven't agreed agreed with yet have they expressed that they are interested and able to do those trainings yeah we briefly had that conversation and they're capable of conducting that training yes all right now and the next question has to do with the threat management team and member bird and member Felder talked a lot about the relationships that the SRO have with the students in the school and I think that there's so many great great benefits of that for students and that they both mentioned but one
089thing that we didn't talk about was the threat management team and how these SRO serve on these these threat management teams in the schools is that right they do yes okay so if and I know you mentioned that Guardians are not able to serve that role not as a law enforcement it's required again it's a core four they're one of the core four that have to be on the team and a guardian cannot sit in their place okay so two questions about that one is so that would mean that you know someone who has that relationship with students and who's built that relationship would then not be serving on the threat team who could really provide insight to their experiences and interactions with the student so we'd be missing out on that if we had
090a guardian in the school yes okay and then the second question is who who would sit who would then have to fill that role Well we'd have to utilize somebody from our district police now if you have multiple schools it'd be very difficult to be there to have these type of relationships as you describe but they could serve on the team and H and can you remind me how many district police we have currently in our employee this includes me 15 okay so we have a lot of roles and responsibilities we currently have five that are covering schools okay so we only have 15 five are covering schools and then we would now have to find they would now also have to serve on these other threat management teams yes okay thank you I know
091well actually question do SRO monitor threats on social media in our Intel analysts monitor social media but I don't want to go into too much detail about what everybody does but Guardians would not be doing that at all correct typically that would not be their role or function no okay what happens if a guardian because i' I've read some studies on you know arming you know people that aren't law enforcement officers in schools what happens if a guardian you know drops a firearm or leaves it on a desk and a child gets a hold of it or some mishap happens who's liable well it depends on who's who's responsible you know who they're employed by so if it's our Guardian it would be my headache to deal with and then needless to say there's a
092couple of things if they are in any way subject Guardians to discipline then we have to notify the office safe schools so if they discharge their firearm in the line of duty and or are subjected to any type of discipline in this in in a case like as you described that would that would result in discipline then we'd have to notify the office safe schools are is there any kind do guardians have any kind of immunity from no they do not enjoy qualified immunity that law enforcement has they are you know going to be subject to the possibility of some sort of Li ability personally and needless to say if they were part of a guardian a security guard company then that company would be subject to that liability as well right is there any
093cap on it not that I know of but that's kind of out of my scope okay sorry okay jumping to another area when you were talking about the I guess the background checks that are required for Guardians I know you said there was a psychological test and a couple other things one thing I didn't see on there but maybe this is included if they have some kind of criminal background are they prevented from becoming a guardian yes okay this wasn't clear you touched on this but I just wanted to go back to to get more information I know you mentioned that Guardians would have 12 hours of diversity training are they are they trained with respect to ESC students I'm I'm not familiar if they are that's why I pointed out CIT training now that's
094something that can we've sent my security officers here at the district to CIT training just because we think it's that important if you're dealing with students you have that training all of our law enforcement have and again all the sworn officers in Orange County that serve in our schools have received CIT training and I know the sheriff it was personal personally a big big supporter of it I've seen him at the graduations and he I think is endeavoring to have all of his deputies attend the CIT training as well okay thank you just a couple more questions what kind of firearm would Guardians carry it depends on what type of Guardian they are sometimes and I don't really want to get in a lot of detail but it's typically a semi-automatic handgun and I'll just
095I'll just kind of End by saying I have obviously a lot of I have many concerns about this program you know some of the research that I did just talked about you know in chaotic situations in school and active shooter situations just the hit rate of trained law enforcement officers which is really really important anytime but particularly when you're in classrooms with students in kind of these situations is between 23 and 52% and that's for a trained law enforcement officer so I have real concerns for how a guardian with much less training would respond I think you mentioned our Guardians get or that Guardians would get 144 hours of training I and correct me if I'm wrong I think law enforcement officers get closer to 1,000 hours of training they do actually it's correct and
096the training is you know much more than just firearms and firearm safety and then of course when you are hired by an agency they're going to put you through their training as well they're going to put you through qualifications they're going to make sure you're you know well versed on how to handle a handgun safely and needless to say use of force the use of force continuum in all those areas now they're getting that in their 144 hours but it's just a snapshot are they going to get it when they leave there well it depends on the sheriff the sheriff could bring it back in say I'm going to have more training with them but here in Orange county is 44 hours okay thank you and then just my last point I know member Felder
097had on this but have a real concern with the equity issue in schools some having SRO some having Guardians and on the impact that will have for parents who care a lot about safety it's probably the number one thing I know I heard throughout my entire campaign and continue to hear about and parents who are now learning that there will just be a guardian or potentially a guardian in their school you know parents kind of making that option to pursue other choices outside of the public school system and when they do that not only is that hurting children but it's also when you have declining enrollment in schools it's also hurting the school too because there's fewer resources as as children leave so I have many many problems with this but thank you for your
098time and thank you for your answers all right thank you member vanis member Salamanca and then member Douglas thank you chair and thank you both for spending time walking us through all of this and also as member G and another members said you know thank you to those agencies that have worked with us and understand and appreciate the importance of safety of our students and also just the limited budget that we have right so one of the questions I had was around cost you showed up how much we get in terms of revenue from the state I think that's one of the slides if we can go back to that I'll just go off the number so if we were to go with that high number that they requested by year three that was the
09970k 79k number that you brought up that would put us at just salaries alone because I'm roughly going to say we have 300 officers my area District 2 is growing very rapidly I add to school all the time so I'm going to go with the 300 number to make our math easy I mean that would be almost $24 million just on salaries right we just talked about how this budget is not just salaries this budget includes all types of safe school funding and safety but when we look at that 79k number per at each those 300 I'm looking at a really high number I don't when I look at the budget it's just it doesn't quite add up and I see that number of 16 million going up significantly as well so it is a
100really really hard place to be put in because as we know with the kind of budget that we have and not much control over Revenue it ends of coming from the same pool of capital that we then have to have the continuous conversation and I have such a hard time stomaching you know I know you mentioned the numbers of the salary increases from 2021 onward but I went all the way back to 2015 and 2015 you to now our teachers average teacher salar is all teachers is about 25% increase but if I look at from 2015 and we all the way to 79k if we were to go there in 3 years for them that's that's over 125% increase for this role and it just it's really difficult because yes I know our SRO keep
101safe I am AB absolutely in support of having sro's in our schools but you know when things go south our teachers lines are also on the line and their safey is on the line and they keep our students safe from all sorts of things as well so it's just when I think budget when I think percentages when I do that comparison it is it is very difficult so when we look at the these costs as well we talked about that ratio and member vanas brought this up we currently have 15 at the district level that cover five schools we now are going to know that okay if we do a guardian program we're going to probably need to increase that number at the district to support things such as threat management teams right do we
102have a sense of how much more the district police budget increase would be to support some of these Guardian programs that are I guess I just didn't see that in the budget anywhere that would be a decision by the superintendent but that said I have eight open positions right now that we're currently recruiting for so you know we'd be in a situation where I am not concerned that we couldn't pick that up all right I think we could take on that role and pick up the threat management piece of this if we have to it's not preferred obviously because you mentioned the issue U ma Madam sanos says you know they're not there in that school they're not there they don't know U you know these students per se and they don't have a relationship
103but we can fulfill the role a threat or a concerning behavior for law enforcement is something we deal with on a day day and day out basis and we're very familiar with the types of things that happen in our schools so we could pick that up got it yeah I think I think I just kept seeing different buckets of things that maybe aren't accounted yet and the numbers that would increase the cost even further from that number in my district you know some schools are in City some schools are in County one of the things I've noticed that happens a lot sometimes is if something happens around the neighborhood God forbid there's someone that's unsafe that's walking around there is always this instant communication between city and county in my district of hey this school
104we're shutting down we're not letting buses out until this is cleared they communicate with the other folks and say you know some of these elementary schools are within a mile right like walking distance from each other and that communication happens quickly parents always notice and now get emails if we even delay 5 minutes of like why did my kid get dropped off when across the street County city lines you know that school was closed right and we are always trying to do it as quick as possible in the case of Guardians how would that work right so are they going to have radios that they can know when Cross County Cross City Line something shut down like how how how would that operate well that would be a challenge because they're going to be in
105different municipalities those would have to agree to give them radios and if that wasn't the case then the district police would have to provide the radios radios are approximately $5,000 a piece for a law enforcement radio and they would be communicating with us and we would have to share that information with our from our district police Communication Center they wouldn't be communicating directly with the agency with jurisdiction now if the Chiefs allowed for it and said yeah you can be on our radio system and here's the channel we want you to call in on that'd be another matter yeah yeah I think maybe because I live this every day in my district with County and City being split like you know nusi is one to the right one to the left I the amount of
106of that rapid communication that is required for district 2 to function in a healthy and safe way I see it all the time and I have huge concerns about some of the in the details implications and executions of something like the Guardians and the radios and the how many middle men are in the communication when something is serious so definitely thinking from from District 2 and how that would be impacted and thankfully I have very supportive agencies and and I'm I'm very grateful for that but I definitely have a lot of hesitations in our Guardians I also have a lot of hesitations on this budget this is just brutal when I think about the numbers and the percentages and I'm looking at this $22.5 million $23.7 million budget for that 79k and I don't know
107where that's just salaries and so I you know I urge us to continue having these conversations with these agencies and try to get them to understand just the volume that we're working with here I definitely urge them and I urge the public and folks to understand kind of how our hands are tied Revenue wise and we just don't have the tool kid to be able to do this even though we all up here really are supportive of the SRO program and want Sr in each of our schools I have the same concerns that I think parents really and and I hear from teachers as well just peace of mind I having an SRO and the car up front those are my questions I also I think to the last point on CIT training for ESC
108students I'm aan huge concern like how we work with these students what is expected of us on how we address the ESC students it's so important and I it's hard for us as a district to kind of hand this off on training and priorities it just it's it's difficult and I think this population would be unfortunately impacted for sure but thank you for this work thank you for the presentation and I think we'll continue doing our work and informing and talking to the public about the importance of this thank you member Salam monka member Douglas you're recognized well thank you so much U Jacobs and thank you Chief homes and Mr Pacho for your presentation it's been great however I'm really deeply saddened and disappointed that the safety of our kids are compromised is compromised
109because of salaries you know and these are our children they deserve the best they deserve to have the best safety sa safe environment to learn and not to have an SRO in in school just like member salanka just you know spoke about it's it's for teachers it's very important to see that children are safe there's a police officer's car in front it's it giv you a sense of you know safety and you know wanted to make sure that our building feel free to to be able to teach and do the things that we need to do and not worry about other issues you know and I agree with chair Jacob's Guardian program the more I listen to it the more I just really it's very unsettling it's not it's it's not solid at all you
110know I don't feel like it's something that can help with safety of our kids we really need people that are trained you know are trained for this job not the teachers okay and not the people that just come in for how many hours of training 144 no okay our children deserve the best and they deserve to be safe all right and I also think that the problem U is you know is applying to 30 schools right 30 schools and we really need to talk to those schools and make sure that you know they understand that it's not only the children of wind M it's our community it's our children they all belong to us okay and I'm looking forward to January 14th when they would have the negotiations to be able to you know with
111a lot of prayers that they will understand that you know this is our community and in order for us to have a great Community we need to have safety and let's put other things aside and think about our children first just so that's it thank you member Douglas member Fant thank you madam chair I think this has been an a really great discussion and I think it's been good to just be able to go over the details and discuss it is very conc con erning I think for all of us and I know especially for me I really am like we really want to make sure that our kids are safe everybody in our schools are safe that parents feel confident when they drop their children off some of the things that I'm thinking of
112just from a parent standpoint when you drop your kid off at school seeing the car the vehicle of a patrol car in the front of your child's school really does give you a sense of security and with the Guardian program we wouldn't have that not to say maybe our schools wouldn't be as safe but as a parent when I drive in and I don't see that patrol car it gives the sense that it's not safe and I think that whole in your presentation how you kept saying that the perception and I think that is a huge thing that I want the public I want parents I want new parents who are coming in and dropping off their kindergartener to feel that their child is safe at school and so it really is concerning when you
113crunch the numbers we're looking at all of our numbers we're really we're over budget as is it honestly feels like a slap in the face that they want such a incredibly high percent raise just in the last four years it was a 32% raise is that correct or more than that whatever it is it is incredibly High the fact that we we can't even give that kind of raise to our teachers administrators as much as we understand law enforcement is putting their life on the line to keep our school safe that it's really we don't have that kind of money and they I mean I feel like most everybody understands that the public schools don't have that kind of money to to provide that kind of raise and so I really again I want to
114urge urge our community I want to urge those municipalities who are holding out and kind of pushing back to consider every child and every teacher every parent who is dropping their child off we want the very best and for us I think it's very clear all of us want to have our SRO want to continue with SRO they've been incredible it's one of my favorite things to do when we walk into a school and visit visit our school to be able to see our SRO chat with them see how things are going our sro's really are incredible and a shout out to again to the municipalities and to our Sheriff's Office Orlando PD for for stepping up and continuing with providing those SRO it's been it is huge so for my area it is not
115impacted however with the areas that are that is it's a huge concern so we want to continue to provide those SRO so I would continue to urge the public write your write your local office your local sheriff's office or city office your Commissioners whoever it might be that you need to speak to and urge them and say this is a safety really is number one for each of us but thank you thank you member front member bird Vice chair thank you I I want to go back real quick to the threats because I think that's something that's really important to again reiterate that law requires that a police officer serves on the threat ma management team at every school so every time a threat comes into a school which we all know we have seen
116a huge increase in threats this year at all of our schools every time a threat comes in every threat is worked through the threat management team as is required so that means every time that happens at every one of these 30 schools that won't have a police officer that your department will have to send someone to that school to sit on that threat management team and to work through that threat with the school correct correct okay I want to talk a little bit just for a minute about our police force because over the weekend those are some things comments that I heard a lot you know we have a police force why not just have our police force fill in these schools so can you kind of speak on that for a minute first of
117all I want you to discuss I think there's a misunderstanding about what what our police force already does the size of it which you've already talked about is not as large as people might think that it is but the vast responsibility that you already are covering in our school district could you spend a few minutes talking about that to clarify that for the public sure I'm glad you asked this is a complex School Safety and Security program that we manage here the law enforcement agency you currently have overseas the entire program these things include an intelligence unit that interfaces with local law enforcement providing information about possibly a student that was involved in the threat and vice versa they provide us information things that we need to know in event to Abate the threat whatever
118it may be and address it's busy but we have a lot of things going on U those particular Intel that Intel unit sits on threat management teams as well to provide support to them information they may need in dealing with that particular situation we have a Communications law enforcement Communications team okay so our District police communication puts out every security notification associated with a whole host of things that happens at schools 247 365 they're here during Hurricane operations they never shut down so it's really busy there's a lot of things that go on they handle over a thousand calls per month in our in in our Communications unit so we have a lot going on there we oversee what's called I call it electronic security systems unit we are required by the state of Florida
119to test all the Emergency Equipment that's in our schools that they utilize an example would be duress buttons we do testing of the Alysa alert that we have our safer watch application we have to test every school including our Charter Schools mind you because I'm responsible as your school of safety specialist for the Safety and Security that goes on in the charter schools so we oversee that I have a Compliance Unit we have six people that are engaged in compliance we have clarc compliance with our technical colleges and we have maror stman high school public safety compliance in all of our schools we have to go out and visit every school every year and make sure that we check every door make sure we have a safer area designated in every single classroom make sure
120that all of their required trainings and training certificates are in place that the threat management teams are meeting like they're supposed to monthly in for every threat so should I keep going we have our Protective Services Unit I have my security officers they don't just provide security here at RBC and over here at the tech college we also provide security in Magnolia School and Silver Pines academy so they provide support for those schools sometimes we have students from those schools elope and they're there to help keep that from happening so there's just we're involved and engaged in a lot of things my Law Enforcement Officers oversee those units they're the supervisors for those units and then also when there's a threat at a school and we're concerned that there's a possibility that threat could come
121to the campus I send my officers out to those particular schools and provide additional Services if we have the threat of a active shooter come like IM imminent at a campus we respond immediately all hands on deck we go there I personally serve if I'm available on the incident command post as a representative for the district and if I'm not available it would be one of my one of my cap my Deputy Chief or one of my captains and this isn't just during normal school hours as you might think because there are kids on campus from 6:00 in the morning until 10:00 at night so a lot of these things happen after our regular school hours so if a high school is getting out you know at 2:20 something could happen 5:00 or there can
122be after care at a school at winmill elementary for example and there could be some sort of threat to the campus and the concern that some some threat May migrate on the campus Because of police activity in the area next thing you know we've going out and doing that I keep officers on till 6:00 in the evening and if anything happens coming up to that you're staying until it's done all right so and of course I'm on call 247365 for the 4 to5 Florida that come through so we to make sure that if we do have a threat and say it's Saturday and I promise you your favorite team's going to be playing when this comes through or on Sunday and we'll be managing that threat our Intel analysts are on call I have an
123on call Commander I'm on call and we're going to try to make sure that threat is addressed before that threat comes to school on Monday morning right we also do weapon screening we have randomized weapon screening programs that be do I don't want to go through a lot of detail oh we have canine also you've met Kine Coco and she's part of our screening program I have six screeners that's screen our schools to make sure that the students know they're not to bring weapons and unauthorized item including a whole host of things thank you Chief and so and you also fill in for schools for our municipalities or Sheriff office if there happens to be like or I'm glad you brought that back up I might have misspoke I have we cover three schools and
124currently we covering four because one of our municipalities their officer left the agency and they didn't have anybody to backfill it so I have my officer chief called me can you cover this for us and I've put my officer in there until he can be relieved by one of their officers at that agency same for the charters as well if a charter school their SRO or or their Guardian doesn't show up maybe they're sick and they can't come to work that particular day we'll be getting getting a call in the morning we're scrambling if the agency of jurisdiction can't backfill it we go there and we backfill it for that particular day until it can they can have somebody there so as you can see there's a lot of complexity to that a lot of
125movement parts and pieces and it's not a bunch of cops just doing all this work it's overseen it we're managing it back filling and making sure that we have a coordinated effort for our Safety and Security programming here at Orange County not just some haphazard not thought through oh and by the way we have over 14,000 cameras my essu unit unit oversees the camera system here and they make sure every one of the cameras when schools come online and every year that the cameras are configured so they operate properly so your badge that you have your badge reader we manage that system as well and so we give access to the higher level employees here in the district so they can get to the appropriate places the district needless to say I'm sorry there's a
126lot going on with that I think you I think you did a good job I think I covered it you could go on and on there probably a few things I didn't go into but there's a lot more that didn't even cover but needless to say it is a vast job coordinating and covering security and safety for this entire talking about it okay so not to mention the fact that much of this is required in state law it is it's required for us to do most of these things some of it though we go over and above and beyond you're in the district that's why I'm so proud of serving here as your Chief and your school safety specialist because we're not just trying to meet the bar we're trying to meet or exceed it
127and we do it in a lot of ways okay so you mentioned that you have 15 officers currently on your Force but you have an opening for 23 I do but you're having trouble filling we are we have to compete with these other agencies as well a lot of the ones we get are retired and recently coming down from New York New Jersey places like that they moved to Florida and they're not quite done with the career and they're looking for good hours I think we have a you know a great program here that good hours they can serve in the school when they first get here because I love training them as an SRO in the school before they move on to doing other things here for the district so they get a sense
128of what it means to be an SRO in a school and what it means to the schools themselves so yeah it's so the point is though that you are having trouble filling your open positions now just because of what we are experiencing districtwide where we cannot compete and offer competitive salaries because our funding is so limited so that kind of puts to sleep the idea that we could just snap our fingers and suddenly be able to hire 30 more officers to cover these schools if we needed to in August a that's one thing where would we find where how would we be able to fill those positions secondly is the cost would not when I look at you the program Guardian program cost that you outlined in the presentation what I'm seeing as the advantage
129to the guardian program cost-wise is just that it would be a kind of set cost it's not that it would save us any money because it's you have estimated here 74,000 is what you're estimating if we hired if we hired additional police officers I believe you've quoted us that a salary including like a vehicle cuz they have to have a vehicle they have to have all their equipment and everything is actually up over 100,000 a year with quite a bit more I mean just a police patrol vehicle outfitted is over $50,000 right so we wouldn't be able to afford that right we can't even reimburse our Municipal municipalities for more than what we're offering them now 72 so my point to that is that's not an option either and I wanted to make sure that
130was very clear that it's not that was something I was hearing a lot this weekend was that would be an easier solution and it really isn't so I wanted to get that out there and then finally I just want to chair could I just one more comment I know that you're proceeding to another question but the one thing that I think the public needs to know based on everything that Brian commented regarding what they bring to the table is that they are the coordinating body that help us coordinate all these SRO that we have with nine different agencies you know they talk the same language they understand the terms they understand what some of the things that the law enforcement need from us and they help translate what we need from them as well so
131I because I like you said you had a couple of questions like why does the District police exist why why they have it if they're not cover or our school TOS is because the intent of creating District police was to help us coordinate and of course they do have a portfolio of other functions that they do but that is one of the functions that I think that is very valuable to us because they help us coordinate with those all those nine agencies that we that we get to work with on a daily basis yeah exactly and if if we did not have a ocps police force we would have to go out and hire someone to stand in as our school safety off is that what it's called what your title school safety specialist school
132safety specialist because that's required by law we'd have to have someone to do all of those things we'd have to hire a whole whole another department like what his department does but this way at least they are sworn Law Officers like you said and they understand the language and can do it in a better way basically they're fulfilling all of the things we would have had to fulfill anyway right so thank you for that was a good point to bring up as well so I just I just want to kind of reiterate I member Vanos covered a few concerns that people have about the Guardians and yes there are numerous concerns I will tell you though that you know this has forced me to have to do a lot of research and there are Technologies
133there are Technologies out there that can protect against some of those things I will just say that I have found there is actually a local company that's that has technology for things to protect against some of those concerns safety concerns I certainly hope that we would never have to get there as I said earlier but again we are required by law to have coverage in our schools so I just want to my last statement on this is going to be that we will never have enough money to fully reimburse these these police forces any of them for the cost of these officers in our schools I think everybody knows that therefore it is really the decision of these municipalities to go back and discuss if as member Gallow said prioritize the safety of the kids
134in those schools the staff in those schools and to make the decision to accept that they have this is just part part of it this is just part of policing the community part of their Community is the schools just like it is the streets in this neighborhood the streets in that neighborhood if there's an area of a neighborhood that happens to be higher crime or there's a crime spree going on they don't go to the HOA and say you guys need to Buck up some more money we have to put more officers over here it's just part of keeping the community safe so this is part of the community so I'm hopeful that every municipality will find a way to to do this and I wouldn't be saying this if I didn't feel like we
135did not do our part because I certainly have heard for years the concern about the cost and the reimbursement rate of the SRO and I have advocated many times that we need to reimburse more we need to reimburse more and this year I honestly feel as though we did I feel like we really came in strong that was a this was a great way to I thought show them how much we appreciate them and you know we are sacrificing different areas and that's another thing we don't talk about a lot you know like where does this money come from there are cuts that are made and we have we have tried really hard this the past two three years preparing for you know the loss of our Esser funds and finding places to consolidate and
136make our budget tighter everywhere we can we had to even cut some summer school programs this past summer to pay for some other things so you know our superintendent has cut the cabinet positions and so you know every area has cut we've cut programs that are not don't have return on investment so I really felt like at this point that we had that we did our part to do what we can so hopefully they will feel the same way and they will do their part thank you thank you Vice chair and member Gallow you recognized thank you madam chair I have just a couple of questions the first one is can you walk me through a scenario the best that you can if we have a guardian on our campus and someone comes up and
137says so and so has a gun in their backpack how how would we proceed with a guardian versus an Sr well it would be they didn't reach out to an admin administrator they would go and meet that student if there was a gun in the backpack the administrator would be in a position to conduct a search of that backpack so they would make sure they were standing by to stand by in the event something were to happen right then and they would separate the backpack from the student they usually take them to someplace where they can you know talk to the student and hopefully use some of the equipment that we have given them I'm not going to go into detail but make sure they don't have anything on their in their on their person
138themselves and then search the backpack the administrator would conduct the search the administrator search they have search training and they do that would schools so really it's would they take the guardian with them yes if a gun was found on a student and the student it became an issue what what could The Guardian do like if they if they were wrestling with a gun something like that happened with a student that had in his backpack like the administrator can only do so much right because there wouldn't be an SRO on campus so other than call the police law enforcements which I'm sure they would immediately do they should yes we I mean even if they got there at the fastest it would take a couple of minutes so in in the meantime before we got
139law enforcement officers on our campus what would the guardian be able to do to deescalate the situation and get the gun away from that student they are required to have some deescalation training as part of their training in the 144 hours we mentioned earlier you know what would they be required to do well prevent an evate that if they're fighting over a gun they should be be engaged in that situation and help disarm the student that situation so that is their sole responsibility to manage that situation right there all the way up to the use of deadly force so they in that instance they would be able to put their hands on a student they would yes to prevent orate yes okay do our Guardians do they have immunity if they were if someone were
140to get on our campuses and they would shoot and killed an as salent do they have immunity against being sued or can they be sued by the family John do you want to address that yeah so there's complex layers of different laws that cover here right so state law would be it would be a wrongful death action there would be some ways that we would assert I would the district would get sued in that case if it was our Guardian the guardian may get sued individually state law says somebody acting within the course and scope of their employment on and not exhibiting a willful or wanting disregard for human life is immune from suit so the liability would come to us we have a $200,000 per person 300,000 total cap on some on the claims
141there now of course if if a judgment was rendered against us and somebody got a claims bill they would have to go up in the legislature and get a claims bill for any amount above $300,000 there's also section 1983 under federal law that would be a deprivation of somebody's life liberty without due process of law and wrongful death Claims can get turned into 1983 claims there are no caps under 1983 under federal law against government entities or individuals found liable so that's there's a whole bunch of factual scenarios that would have to be looked at and there's a bunch of laws that could be applied there but it's there's liability to go around and let's just be clear we'll we'll be litigating that for a long time if we were ever in that scenario and
142isn't it true that the legislature keeps trying to raise that immunity amount every year they do try to raise that immunity amount every year the smaller districts especially band together against that because that higher limit would devastate them it would not be good for us let let be clear it would be very deletar is to us if we had higher caps however those smaller districts and smaller counties and municipalities would be especially devastated if that calf was lifted up thank you and if we hired Guardians they would report to you Chief homes well if they were a security guard agency they report to them but in yes there would be a dotted line directly to me so and my team so I guess my next question we would manage the guardian program if there was
143a security guard program yes we would manage it okay and I know as our school safety specialist you don't have immunity either I'm sorry you don't have immunity as our school well I do as your as your Chief okay I have qualified immunity as your as youram as police officer for the district I have qualified immunity and I just want to make that point because as a board we've made a priority to ensure and I even think we put it in policy that our school safety specialist is a trained law enforcement officer a for that reason and be if you're our school safety specialist you need that type of training and you need that type of knowledge and you need lingo all the stuff that my fellow board members discussed up here but in other
144districts where it's not they don't have immunity because we were just discussing that at the fsba conference so it's good to know that you have immunity so they you cannot get sued however the rest of us up here are not so lucky so I just want to I want to point out again that I just I was just Googling things that have happened across the country and here in Florida with guardians I Googled the same thing with school resource officers nothing came up but a whole slew of things where there's been errors on the parts of Guardians we had Guardians walk out in Hillsboro just left their shift we've had we've had Guardians in Pasco and one of Lake County I think one of the two that left their service weapon in a bathroom or
145laying around and I believe the law that we have to report to save schools initially wasn't in their very first Marjorie stowman Douglas requirements it came after some of these things transpired not here just here in Florida but across the country that there's a reason that the law was enacted that we have to report to the office of safe schools any any type of altercation that happens on our campuses between our SRO I'm never going to support Guardians I'm just going to throw it out there and be very very transparent I will not support them I will not vote for them I don't believe that is the safest option for our schools I'm going to beg those five municipalities to take a long look at what they value and how they value it and I'm
146and I'm sincerely praying that they decide to do the right thing and put school resource officers in our buildings because if they don't the decisions that we have to make up here are not fair it's not fair to any of us up here it's especially not fair to our superintendent and our District staff because I will be a board member that will say no and we're goingon to have to find the money and so where does it come that is and I understand that puts my superintendent in such a difficult position and that's not fair to her but i' I've been on the other side of this for too long with the Florida to prevent the Florida Coalition prevent gun violence I've been up in Tallahassee I've given too many speeches I've seen too many
147things happened I've been on the side of gun reform to keep our kids safe I pushed out child locks I just in good conscious I can't put those 30 schools and those students and our staff at what I believe to be a high risk by putting a guardian in there it's never been tested we've never had a situation where we had thank you Lord that we've had a gunman or a seent come on campus where there's Guardians to see what would happen What in real time would happen if we have a guardian we just we haven't experienced that in Florida and I don't want Orange County be to be the first one that does so thank you oh yes Madam chair if I may on with respect to liability for you all as board members
148just want to make it clear the decision about Guardians versus SRO that is what's known as a planning and discretionary event and under state law you all are completely immune from being sued on discretionary and planning level decisions like that so that is not something that you all would be on the hook for liability for I don't think you would be on the hook for liability under state law negligence individually I don't think you're going to be on the hook for liability under a 1983 claim unless you made some sort of decision that evidenced such willful and wanting disregard for human life that you all would be subject to that type of liability so I don't want you all to worry about that from a liability standpoint against you all individually the board collectively is
149the entity that's going to get sued and that's going to be it but you all are not going to be individually in liability in those cases thank you John although there is a lawsuit where we've been named individually yes so just because it may not have standing does it mean it can't be done you've been sued in your individual names but in your official capacities there they have not sued you individually which is a different I'm trying thank you member Gallow couple of last questions I have so we have 30 schools how many total Sr I don't high schools are a different number so what's the total number SRO be 34 34 Sr we would we are short if we can't negotiate that contract so I my closing thoughts on this I agree with everything
150that most of my fellow board members have said I'll just Echo everything that member Gallo said I think I think it's very obvious to most of us to our community to our faculty to all of our employees all of our parents that this is not the highest and quality of safety we can have and we shouldn't be in that position where we have to make that decision I agree with I don't I don't want to be the first to experience how a situation a tragic situation unfolds because of the lack of experienced trained law enforcement officer having said that I just I want to focus as much as we can on what's the solution with 34 officers that's I don't I think I think the sheriff's office has I want to say yeah almost 3,000
1512700 at least as reported on Google but in that ballpark and OPD I'm not sure what that is it's probably maybe 25 30% of it I'm guessing just by virtue of their size population wise maybe it's 25% those numbers are a lot higher than a lot of these smaller jurisdictions last I knew with windir they had maybe Chief you might know how many on about how many windir has Law Enforcement Officers I believe it's 14 okay okay I was I was going to guess like 40 but so somewhere between 14 and 40 that's a whole lot less I'm going to go back to wind just because I'm more familiar with it but less than 30% of the students at windir elementary school are actually from the town of windamir about 3% of the high school
152students in windamir high school about 3% would be coming from windir I'm on average they're generating about 5% of the population of a elementary school you add that together and their contribution from an equitable standpoint is less than a half of an SRO so I think I'm I'm I'm going to I know I'm going to beat this horse to death but we want equity in our schools when it comes to safety I'm all in and I think we're all we're all all in that every school should have the same level of expertise when it comes to protecting our schools and again I think we just need to go back and look and make sure that we are treating all of our jurisdictions equitably look at the funding formula it maybe a total different way of
153as as member venos mentioned it it could be that the sheriff or OPD takes over a larger portion but they obviously get the funding for that so there's other ways that we can look at this the main goal is to find a way to avoid Guardians and to find it in the fairest fashion that we can with that let me call on member Vanos thank you madam chair I just have one question with the agencies who we haven't reached an agreement with if we do not reach an agreement with them on the SRO what would you expect would happen to that to their current SRO they'd be absorbed backed into their patrol operations most likely in other areas they you know maybe short okay so basically let's say if a law enforcement agency was providing
154four sro's now they're getting $72,000 time 4 less money from op ocps to pay their officer so they'd be paying an additional $288,000 let's just say based on four to cover their officers whereas if they agree to the current three-year contract where they want 79,000 and we're offering 75,000 they would really only be having to pay an extra 16,000 for for officers yes okay thank you member Gallow thank you madam chair can we talk about next steps so if we can't reach an agreement with the five municipalities what are the next steps does this go to rural development does this go towards a vote what does that look like it's an operational decision that will be made by me the information that I've heard today will help guide that decision but it is an operational
155decision what so the okay I have I'm I'd have to go I was under the impression that per state statute that it had to be approved up by the board to to do Guardians in in a district cuz I know other school boards have it has gone before the board for approval so I'm I would be very concerned if we'd be making a decision like this that was just strictly an operational decision without it going before the board and without taking public comment in a rural development and on an agenda item that concerns me so legal is verifying information that they had shared with me so we my understanding can we from speaking to to him was that it was an operational decision so it is an operational decision the statute makes responsibility joint for
156both the school board here's what it says for the protection and safety of school Personnel property students and visitors each district school board and school district superintendent shall partner with law enforcement agencies or security agencies to establish or assign one or more safe School officers at each school facility within the district including charter schools so it does this is typically a joint this is typically an operational decision it does make responsibility to you all to say to the superintendent for example hey I noticed there's not a safe school officer at certain schools that would be a responsibility that would be on you all but as for what type of Officer safe school officer we would have there that is typically an operational decision that the superintendent would handle thank you John I appreciate that I
157know other districts have handled it differently so I would urge us to talk to some of the other legal counsel and other districts as I just said I'm I really don't want this decision to made without input from the public I just I don't think our community wants Guardians I don't think our community will put up with guardians and not to vet that more thoroughly in a public atmosphere I just I don't support I don't support at all I don't support Guardians I wouldn't support the superintendent's decision to put Guardians on our campus all right Dr VC you're recognized so if it's the will of the board that we pay the additional two $1.9 million then we will go back and look at what cuts need to be made I thought that was that's been
158part of the conversations so if the will of the board board is that we find the 1.9 million our team will go back and see where we cut okay all right thank you I was going to ask John to read that again but we don't need to and to be honest with you our superintendent has been extremely responsive to this board so you might I understand that you may very much disagree with us from you know on on a particular issue and this might be one of them but I also appreciate that no no please make no no no I do not want Guardians in our schools oh no absolutely not I am I want an SRO in every one of our schools but we don't have the money and every dollar that we are
159looking to cut is going towards salaries for next year because we know that is a priority for our board and so finding the $19 million would mean that's $1.9 million that won't be able to go to WS salaries for next year and superintendent thank you for making sure that was clear I did not mean to suggest that you're in favor of this I just know that you understand there's a cost to every decision and if we have to come up with 1.9 million there aren't good choices for us under this situation and you'll share with us the cost of that hopefully we come up with a solution that doesn't cost us that much and hopefully all of our jurisdictions in in involved in this have an opportunity to hear from the public before we would
160make that kind of decision hopefully they're hearing from the public already so we're talking about talking about 34 positions to follow up on member vos's questions what which jurisdiction was it that has four is that was that wter Park who was that you were just yeah okay yeah so if if a jurisdiction had four say sro's and on that jurisdiction we were to switch to Guardians then that would not only be that much money that they would have to absorb without our support but that might very well be for people that don't want to work in that jurisdiction anymore because I'd like to think that a lot of the law enforcement offic officers who have said sign me up that's where I want to be that's where they want to be so it could be
161that we end up hiring those people bringing them onto our Force paying them what we can pay and not necessarily what those jurisdictions are paying them because they're part of a team they want to be part of so that's also a possibility that's worth considering and I don't know I I just I don't know these individuals but some of these smaller jurisdictions to have to take on that additional obligation is you know just might not be affordable I've poor windir they're going to watch this say why does she keep bringing up windir but if Chief's numbers are right and they have one officer that we're paying for it may be one more than they should have to pay for but that's also one person that they're not going to have funding to pay for if
162we were to with the guardian option so anyway I think I think all of this is a really good conversation to be having I think it's really helpful that our parents and our employees understand where we stand on this and I'm going to cross my fingers and hope that we reach a good not much of a compromise a good solution and I'm more optimistic than I was last week I will say that so with that U member Felder at this point I think you're closing us out I just wanted to first of all to say and to reiterate this discussion was very much needed I'm so glad every board member had an opportunity to discuss every aspect of this and I certainly will not want and I know we're going to look into this our
163super intended to be put out there to make an operational decision and then not having opportunity to have the public the input from constituency and again another discussion with the board because if it the worst case scenario and I pray to God that will not occur but I know that we probably going to have to go back to the board and look at this and but I am certainly in favor before a decision has to be made I would like to have not only input from parents but teachers administrators people who are in the schools that have to accept the decision that this district is going to make and I know we talked about it the hybrid example where some that may work but again sro's in the school is something that I prefer from
164my own personal experience as a teacher and knowing what it did for some of the children that I taught who got in trouble and they saw an SRO who saw them about to do something bad and they were able to deescalate that outside of the school so again I just wanted to say that if we and we are obviously going have to go back I really would welcome input from the public I they need to hear then we need to hear and let them discuss it with us about this thank you chairperson absolutely thank you all right that ends our work session on I don't even want to call it the guardian program on law enforcement options SRO options for our schools and we will reconvene and in about 20 minutes not reconvene but we
165will convene for our public open comments session at 4 o'clock with that meeting is now adjourned thank you all for being here thank you okay