001e e e good evening like to start our meeting if we could at this point I want to thank you for coming out tonight and I know that with Christmas Around the Corner everybody has you know three calendars going at the same time so I really appreciate you taking the time um to show your interest in our district okay um let's begin with the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all and one thing I wanted to mention is anyone interested in speaking um that when you get here so you're probably already here you need to fill out one of these things um and make sure that Michelle Oxley
002then the table gets it okay um roll call this foxley U Miss Hamilton present Mrs Brown Mr does Mrs Mitchell here miss Acton here miss hunt here and Mrs Fitzgerald here okay now I would like an approval of agenda how about a motion to approve the agenda so moved support any discussion about the agenda okay all those in favor I I opposed osed okay motion carries now I will turn over to our superintendent for the superintendent report thank you uh and uh my report's going to be brief because a lot of the stuff we're going to covers a little bit later but uh one thing that is um I don't know both happy and sad depending on on the moment um is we are going to Bid Farewell to some of our uh our friends
003who've been with us for for quite a few years those who've given their service and time to to Jackson Public Schools um you know uh I'm Angela I'll start with you you know you and I became close obviously through the bond process and and you're a constant cheerleader for the district since um well for for better part of a decade now but uh you've served as a trustee a vice president president and back to the trustee kind of Full Circle um and uh I am blessed to continue to be able to work with you in uh as a special head coordinator for the Jackson County Intermediate School District and I know that you'll continue to serve the students of Jackson Public Schools so we want to say thank you on behalf of the entire District
004um got it all right uh Libby your your NE 50 years with JPS um just a force to be reckoned with as a teacher I had the the pleasure to work with you uh in lots of different capacities to be in your classroom to see the work you did with students to work with you um settling contracts and and in your role as the uh as the president of the Jackson Education Association um it has been again a privilege and an honor and I guarantee I know you and I will continue to have opportunities to work together uh in the future but you have been trustee treasurer secretary vice president done it all we we couldn't say thank you enough um I know that many of the students uh you know still speak about you
005all the time because they remember you know the the experiences that they got in your classroom so on behalf of Jackson Public Schools and myself we want to say thank you very much um and Pam Fitzgerald uh all right so Pam since 1957 I think was when you came to the district but but uh you've been a a part of a professional part of Jackson Public Schools since 1987 I I it can because you've been to every one of our places I I remember that um so Pam I I can't say thank you enough for your service your commitment you've been secretary vice president president I don't know secretary every year for better part of a decade it feels like 12 years service on the board of education um and and that's not easy because
006you and I have lived uh ups and downs and so um you've seen you've seen JPS uh highs and lows and and you've had to deal with some of the hardest things that we we deal with so I I can't say thank you enough for your service and on behalf of Jackson Public Schools uh we are and have been blessed to work with with you and and the rest of our board so thank you very much uh ladies and gentlemen there are some um some light Refreshments in the back uh cupcakes cheesec crackers that kind of thing water lemonade please help yourself um uh on behalf of our celebration and recognition for for the dedication and service of our outgoing board members so yep um Libby can we come your way and we'll grab a
007picture uh just so we get an outgoing picture of our board and Pam if you'll join me real quick we'll e and that concludes the superintendent report for the month of December um at this point I would like to um entertain a motion for the consent agenda approval so moved second any discussion on the agenda no okay it passed oh I'm sorry let's do a vote would you do a roll call just okay all in favor I opposed thank you motion passes citizens requesting to address the board we have one Miss Cheryl cimetti good evening I also just wanted to take a moment to congratulate the three outgoing board members and to thank you for your service and your dedication um it's hard work there are a lot of rewards sometimes it's thankless but you
008guys have never stopped never hesitated to step up and and do the right thing so I just wanted to say thank you thank you Sher oh we do William Hastings okay okay so um I'm here tonight to go uh Back to the Future a little bit to to go back to the October meeting when the new uh di policy was adopted so this Dia policy which was written by two and only two board members was first introduced at the May meeting following that meeting when no action was taken there was approximately five months when the meeting excuse me when the when the proposed policy went to the back burner stayed on the back burner went in the fridge went in the freezer for a while eventually was brought out um was handed kind of uh
009back around to the administration to um move a few commas and and and fine-tune it and was brought up for a vote at the oo October meeting where it was passed uh I believe 4 to two so I consider this uh disconcerting I con consider it an an end around around the authority of of this board that two members of the board were able to write a policy keep the policy tuck it under their arm keep in their back pocket hand it off to the Friends of the administration who then brought it back out to be voted upon without the proper due diligence and input of the full board um just because you afraid of Kesha Hamilton whether you are not she's a duly elected member who is entitled to have her input on that
010policy so I consider the way this was essentially birthed in sin to be an end round of the fundamental authority of the elected members of the board the five members of the board who did not get a chance to participate this in any manner whatsoever and which means in turn it's an end it's an end run excuse me around the authority of the voters who elected the current members of the board to represent them and moreover I I just like to add there there's some other problems with it so you look at the language on the on the policy it's so deliberately vague you start throwing around terms like inclusive environment inclusive accepting cultural responses so forth and so on those terms might mean something different to every everyone in this room when terms can
011mean almost anything they effectively mean nothing um and it was called out at during the October meeting that there's no there's no goals and metrics to judge this by there there's a little c ofil in there that says the the board will determine boards and metrics but I haven't seen any boards in and metrics so I think it's just uh uh fundamentally unacceptable whether it's a good policy a bad policy or an indiffer policy it was it was done in a political manner around the backs of the majority of the board Bo with the consent of the administration um and I guess tonight we're also going to be discussing the um I think you've already discussed and determined the superintendent's valuation um but I just can't help uh but notice that um the metrics are
012very bad the metrics are very poor enrollment at JPS is down 23% since the 2013 14 school year um if you want to go back just five years uh your chronic absenteeism which is students missing more than 18 days a year is up almost 50% since the 201819 school year that's just five years ago most of you well many of you were on the board at that time not everyone and college readiness has declined 48.3% since 28 or 19 so if these results meet or exceed your expectations whether in determining the uh whether in uh uh grading the superintendent or grading yourselves or whatever kinds of glasses rosecolor glasses xray glasses whatever you use to view the district if if these are considered um acceptable or meeting or exceeding expectations I really would hate to
013see what in your mind would constitute missing expectations for student achievement JPS and um I don't know I if if you look around you look what's going on at the uh just down the street at the uh Jackson County Commission tonight um this is not a good environment to be to put it very nicely like calling a Minefield not a a good environment to be pushing for um another building millage in the year 2025 but um I guess we'll that will all be determined in the fullness of time thank you okay our first action item uh Neola update Jeff all right um so we've got our policies back you had these for first reading last month uh there is an update to the title 9 policy this brings us in line uh with Federal legislation
014uh you do also see uh policy updates with regards to Edgar and ug that's um how we spend federal dollars and again um law driven so you know I I share this kind of in that's most of these policies are all driven by changes in law across either at the state or or federal level so they've been through policy committee they were here for first reading it is my recommendation that we adopt the policies as presented and I want to say thank you uh to our policy committee for the work they put in uh reviewing these policies Madam president I'll move uh to approve the policies as presented support have a couple questions um so I'm looking at um policy um title volume 39 number one September 2024 new artificial intelligence um so for the
015audience I was in the very first meeting that we had around these policies and I had questions that I wanted our Neola representative to answer um she was not in that or they were not in that first meeting the second meeting that we was scheduled I was not able to be in that meeting um so I didn't get my questions answered so I just want him to kind of go over some of these uh a couple questions that I have for a couple of these um Jeff do you mind just um because this looks like the artificial intelligence this is a brand new policy all together for us you might just talking a little bit about it um is it uh code P 75409 is that the one that I'm okay thank you apologize I
016just have two just that one and one more okay I apologize I just my computer's not getting it open so give me a second while I grab the hard cop thank you and and just so you know um I'm just kind of curious you know one if you just talk about the policy a little bit and then I'm wondering what we're seeing in the class what we're kind of talking about in the class if you want to just kind of expound a little bit on that as well I appreciate it well let me start with with um AI in the classroom while Michelle grabs the policy and uh we see AI in a variety of different formats in our classroom from our assessments that are intuitive that that help move our students as they start
017to take a test and every question they get right it directs them and every and if they get the question wrong it tells us feeds us information about their thought process that goes into why they may have selected one answer or another uh we do see a variety of of opportunities for our students to access and use artificial intelligence and I get that there's a a a Brave New World coming and I will the the keynote speaker at the fall conference is all about artificial intelligence we can't find enough training about artificial intelligence and I say that tongue and cheek but everywhere we go that's what's in front of us uh because that is coming to a theater near us whether we want it to or not and to pretend like it doesn't exist um
018as much like you know bearing our head in the sand and hoping that the world will will somehow be different when we when we pull our head back up um but uh but policy 7549 deals with artificial intelligence it does recognize the positive impacts of AI uh it's a position statement from the beginning um and we do allow for the use of including but not limited to you know AI as long as it does not um discriminate or provide us an opportunity to discriminate based on any of the protected classes um so it's at this point very positional it's not a policy on yes you will use it no you won't use it and we're still again developing opportunities if if you're looking at making any sort of video or publishing it's probably going to
019be used you're probably going to be using AI um and so there's if again we need to teach our children the right way to use things and and I know there's a lot of fear in classrooms about well our kids will cheat and they're going to go to chat GTP and AI is going to get better and faster at some of these things but I will tell you um we need to be learning how to leverage AI not run from it if we're if if we're trying to get our kids to run from AI we are not preparing them for the future that I promise you will be here tomorrow because the whole world is is kind of Shifting in that direction absolutely thank you for that Jeff one more question about this policy or
020two um so cheating has been around for you know hundreds of years you know it's never going anywhere um we just have a new tool for it now with AI um this policy um so I'm reading I'm I guess I'm just wondering this it just like we just kind of want to put something on the books that yeah we're we're you know aware of AI and we're going to kind of cheat it I mean treat it like we do just regular cheating are we seeing now mind you I'm a suppor of you know the fact that AI is here and it's here to stay period you know and how do we use it and how do we use it well um and and how do we train our students to use it well um and
021I'm not against the policy I'm just trying to understand um I guess what it's saying aside from the fact that Poli that it's here and like what what are we kind of saying in this policy this is more of a placeholder because as you notice when you read this policy it reflects yeah a bunch of other policies a bunch of other policies including academic dishonesty including you know academic freedom within our teachers it it it right this this is a positional statement on artificial intelligence recognizing that the scope of what it may cover is probably also going to apply to to or policies from a variety of different places will will fall under this umbrella that answer your question that was helpful because I I noticed all the other ones in there and I'm like
022let me just ask a little bit about that this if you read the first paragraph it is just positional this is this is how where we stand as a board or as a district and then again what it's really saying is the rest of these policies that are kind of dovetailed in all kind of will apply as we move forward and academic dishonesty is is is something obviously that we we we're actively working against and our teachers are again I would still tell you every day we run into that challenge yeah so I think the better the better Avenue is how do we leverage and use AI appropriately rather than and like like let's teach them how to use it correctly rather than to to make it something that they have to hide so that
023then it becomes cheating and we've seen it I mean I Any teacher would tell you they' run into it um and it's like any new technology we're going to experience that um by those who would misuse it yeah that's my concern that we're not um you know like AI because like it's here so how do we so I'm glad that this is just simply that and not I was just like I don't I'm hoping that we're not putting something in place that's going to you know criminalize our students Behavior around this versus just you know like how do we teach you how to use it actually just about the opposite it's just about the opposite one more question for you yes please um I on P 1130 the copy of the conflict of interest yep
024and I kind of just want you just to um explain this I'm the green if I remember right that means that this was added in if it's highlighted in green is that is that what that mean it was added in yeah I I think green is new language you are thought okay and and do you mind just kind of explaining a little bit about this um the conflict of interest policy that we have in front of us yep bear with me for just one second and that's the last one I think I have no I have one more after that yeah I think I think this is strictly language cleanup so when you see um and I'll give you an example I'm just going to read the first paragraph So that we can kind of
025see where where some of this comes in so we'll just start with i i shouldn't say that the second paragraph to accomplish this the board of education has adopted the following guidelines which apply to All District employees officers notice the word and was crossed off officers comma agents and board members rather than including members of the board okay so it was always there yeah it's it it is strictly language cleanup and the reason that we see policy language cleanup from time to time um could be pronoun updates could be things along those lines or if uh policy was challenged someplace else and they saw that some of the language created some ambiguities or some questions they would then apply some language cleanup uniformly across so again you got you got several places that inform policy
026you got federal law state law local decisions obviously but case law um you know insurance companies lawsuits I mean the the lawyers that work for Neola help to advise us and so it's not it's not just one or it's not just Brendan our our attorney but but rather a whole host of people who do nothing but educational policy and that right there is repeated kind of multiple times right so if you were to look down um we'll we'll read number one as again as an example because that language is is the same throughout this policy and it it it follows over into other policies where this this one is mirrored but um again no employee officer or agent again you just got rid of the word agent the comma agent then you get comma or
027board member shall engage in or have Financial or other interests directly or indirectly in any activity that conflict that conflicts or raises a reasonable question of conflict with the employees officers agents or board members you you so they got rid of the his her and kind of spelled out that group like who who could be we be talking to and it's just language cleanup like that that that we see kind of throughout here and again as the policy continues duties responsibilities and school system when a staff member determines that the possibility of personal interest conflicts conflict exists the staff member again instead of he or she it's it it really kind of relates it back should prior to the matter be considered by the board or Administration disclose the staff member cross off his her
028interest and that's that's what this is there's there's a lot of that throughout these policies where it's just it's just language cleanup so perfect one more question for you Jeff on that actually twoo um the S the paragraph that you just read yeah I actually just had a question about that can you just kind of expound on that um as far as like you know Financial interests and and Etc that you were referring to um what exactly are how did the district uh interpret that um well I I'll try to give an example and we can kind of extrapolate it out from there but um let's pretend that Jackson Public Schools was going to contract mowing service right and and um a member of the board had a family who did mowing service or an
029employee or an administrator had owned a mowing company and they wanted to bid on it and they they did bid on it that would be a financial interest and they they would have to disclose that ahead of time it wouldn't necessarily prohibit or preclude the board from awarding that contract if they bid low but we would you know the board would have to know kind of upfront and it spells out their their obligation and does that mean also the board members themselves also could you know is that saying that as long as it's disclosed that you're participating in this uh you know process that you're allowed to and that you could be awarded am I reading that like that or no potentially yes um the board can't but if you had a um a significant
030other or or a familiar relation um that that was going to do work as an example then then yes the answer to that question and I've seen that actually happen uh in in in smaller kind of closed communities um where you know you don't have you don't have the variety of businesses everybody's related to everybody and somebody's brother is is going to be the guy mowing the lawn or doing the plowing or something like that and again kind of an example but but you could extrapolate out how that might apply but board members themselves cannot no okay no that I I knew that but I want to make sure sometime I ask questions too for the audience sake one last question will you remind me because I know MCL means what does c CFR mean
031I forgot what that one meant um the CFR you see it on the back of some of these uh yeah is Michigan compile law and yeah thank you very much I something legal but I not Derek but Marcus code of federal you say what code of code of federal regulations okay thank you and that that that right there will will hit us thank you very much Marcus but again kind of driven by federal law or federal changes and I just want again to remind the audience I don't always ask questions because I don't know um some sometimes I don't but then sometime I also ask questions because I like for our audience to hear a little bit more about what's going on thank you Jeff y you are welcome yeah um Jee I'm assuming that
032the cardiac response plan is the response the legislation that passed earlier this year do we have do we already have ads in res school all right so we just need to come up with a plan then okay putting it into ay gotta then the Drone amendments are because of what's happening in New Jersey drones are again one of those things that are going to be around so we bet have a policy for how they're used and we we run into this every year I don't want anybody to think we don't I promise you somebody's going to fly a drone over a football game without permission and those are pieces that'll happen and so we're going to have to we have to have a policy to address those pieces okay at this point we'll take a
033vote all in favor I I oppose the same he motion passes thank you Marcus budget amendment good evening as you know we amend our budget a few times throughout the year with December being the first of those um now that we have our fall counts in and the state budget that we did not have when we brought a budget back in the spring or summer um we went through this at our finance committee facility meeting um about a week and a half ago and again this is a look at the budget at the time when I did this some of these are already changed potentially um what it looks like is that um we would be using approximately $4 million of fund balance back in the spring we brought you a budget that looked like
034we would use about 4.1 million um a couple things that I would just um let the board be aware of is part of that is due to to um the Michigan clean School Bus grant that we applied for were awarded and have already received funding for that's a grant that um we have two years to decide if we want to move forward with it but that Revenue has been received so it's it's included in this budget amendment um and then you know a couple things to note that have changed since we brought the budget back in June we did not receive that Foundation increase that we had budgeted for um or realize some of the um budget cuts the retri that that we were anticipating as well at that time so as it stands today
035again it it shows that we're going to be using about $4 million if you take that clean School Bus grant money out of the picture because it is for a specific use the picture's a little different but that's the way it looks today um I think Jeff wants to say a few words on this as well so I'll turn it over to him thank you Marcus um and you'll see that if the the clean bus Grant gr um in the state sources under Revenue so you see that that line changed from um oh 51 to 53 right so that's where we get the Lion Share of our funding so 51 million to 53 million 492 um and that's a great thing it's it's nice because it provides us with some opportunity to replace buses if
036we need to or add to our Fleet over the next couple years without having to pull from general fund but you need to think of the that that money is money that's set aside with a very specific purpose you can't you can't use it for anything else so while our budget today shows us dipping that $4 million as Marcus said the reality is is it's it's actually closer to 5.7 or 5.6 um remember we were always planning to dip my goal you know I I had shared that I think the longterm plan would be to dip about 6 million over three years not 6 million in one year um and again to Marcus's point we had anticipated back when we adopted the budget at 4.1 that we were going to get about $241 per pupil
037we we were looking at some of the other grants that we were going to get that that didn't happen and and some of the attrition that didn't happen or or that we had to counter with with new hires because of changing student Dynamics or student populations um and in that regard uh you know we didn't see the cuts that were the the reductions that we need um I intend to and I need all the board members if you have questions on this specifically please call me Reach Out come visit with me come sit with me uh I'm going to be asking our our new board members um to set a target for where the board wants the budget to be for 2025 2026 I'm going to ask you to do this in January so you
038got about a month to kind of do some of this this thought this deep dive but the reality is um I'm going to have to go to war to to rightsize this budget we cannot if we if we dip in $5 million every year we're broke in a couple years that's that right there is not acceptable we have got to balance the budget and and right size our budget for next year now if the dip isn't as bad if if if we're able to come back a little bit if we were to see a a supplemental from the state and I've heard about this but I haven't actually seen it you know that that could change but at the same time there are some other factors that we're going to pay attention to um there's
039a a bill that is still being reworked but I believe it's going to be signed before the end of the year to rewrite um p152 which is our cost share of health insurance um much to our teachers relief it insurance cost uh it's it's expensive and our our teachers um bear everything above the hard cap and we bear everything below the hard cap uh that means we're picking up about 75% of the cost of health insurance today plus or minus the new law my understanding is would make 80% the the floor so we would see potentially a four to 5% increase in our share of the health care cost health care is the one is the single largest check to one vendor that we have we spend about $8 million uh to Blue Cross Blue
040Shield every year uh so if you can imagine four to five% of that we could be on the hook for four $500,000 so the budget that's that's worrisome if you're planning a budget to not have that known quantity and to to see that coming down the pipe that might be something that that we're going to have to address um and then we've heard conversations about what uh cuts at the federal level will will look like uh I am telling you I will anticipate or recommend that we anticipate reductions in title funding for the 2025 2026 school year I don't know to what degree um I've heard title two title $ three dollar could be at risk and that adds up to again another plus or minus half a million dollars so we've got work to
041do in the next six months and I intend to make this a a working project every month on the agenda and I'll kind of walk through my plan but in order to do that I need the board to set that Target formally for me in the month of of uh January and then I'll be back with kind of some of the steps and procedures in February back with some of the steps and procedures in March back with some of the steps and procedures in April and that way every month we're talking about it everybody knows what we're doing but then by June when we adopt our budget for 25 26 we we've a come closer to the reality of our income matching our expenses and or expenses matching our income um and we have a
042plan for how our fund balances going to be used by the district um moving forward so that's going to be my request my ask and it's it's a heavy topic and there's a lot there and I'll I'll take questions but just kind of giving you an opportunity to digest the amended budget Marcus is correct this is why this is one of this is the best practice Gang This Is Why We amend the budget in in December it's why we come back and amend the budget in March it's why we want this kind of eye on the prize all the time so that we never get to the end of the year and go oops we didn't know this was coming and so I'd much rather no today if I'm scrambling to do this in in
043June uh it it becomes very Draconian it becomes very you know something that that's not well conceived and so we want to be very intentional about about our actions um so that's what I got I would just share with you in the next 30 days um to our new board members to anybody in the public that wants to know about school budget or Finance reach out to me but but Bard if you've got questions you know i' I'd encourage you to reach out out and I'll be happy to sit down Marcus and his team can sit down and kind of show you kind of where the levers are at um for this and we'll talk more about it next month um Marcus I think the only thing you were going to say is it's your
044recommendation to adop adopt the amended budget exactly so this time we would recommend adopting the December budget amendment so moved all in favor discuss oh I'm sorry discussion just had a discussion you're discussing okay um so couple questions for you so set a Target um you mentioned that um say a little bit more about that if we're setting it and we need to be prepared to bring that back in January well so if today we're 5.7 in the red and I don't believe we'll end the year 5. seven in the red I believe we'll do better than that but if first of all you can't start if if I started cutting today let's just say that that I started cutting today half of the expenses for any given line item have already been been expensed
045out so the reality of seeing a whole lot of savings out of immediate Cuts is not real but I'm anticipating that we'll dip in the ballpark of five and it could be a little better than that but but that's that's where I'm anticipating today um even though Marcus has got us dipping a little bit more that's he's telling me worst case scenario which is what I need him to tell you um but we can't dip five again next year so I said we could do six over three years well if we dip five this year we could do a million next year we could but but again there's some unknown expenses coming down the road and I don't know how able I am saying we should dip a million next year is diping the general
046fund is that what you're referring to okay if if we dip it's it's spending our bank account yeah from the general f that's how I'm saying it from the fund balance okay is that the general fund sorry yes yeah everything that we're going to talk about is general fund okay thank um but as I said there's there's potentially a million dollars in new costs that could come our way between health insurance and whatever may happen at title so to say could could we dip a million next next year yeah and that would still kind of fit within that and it would still leave us with a 18% fund balance that would still feel pretty good but if if we saw unrealized if we said let's dip a million and then we saw another million in
047in unexpected expenses all of a sudden we're dipping two million and that becomes much more dangerous so so the setting the target is is just help me understand you saying like we only want to dip three million into the fund balance and so we got to figure out how to cut the 2.7 you know from the difference is that what you're trying to say by you're G I'm I'm gonna ask the board to tell me Jeff this is how far we want to dip in 25 26 and then that dipping means that we're going to be cutting things is that am I am I clear we will be we will have to right siiz our budget we will have to cut in order to be able to do that you are correct and cutting will
048generally looks like what it could look like a lot of things so um but I'll start with the the heavy it could look like layoffs all right and I won't pretend that it won't we' had this before and candidly i' I've every year since 2003 minus a handful we end up doing more with less um and we've seen specific periods where it's been heavier than others but it could be through attrition which is still our goal so um as as we have retirements the goal would be not to replace the retirements we won't be able to do that on a one for one basis the problem is is if I if a special education teacher reti were mandated by law to offer that special education programming I'm going to have to fill that special education
049spot you want to and that that could cause somebody else you again if you think about it in musical chairs that that means somebody else is going to get standing when the chair when the Music Stops um and there's a pro what's that programming I I don't know I'm just wondering what maybe um I I don't want to I I don't want to speculate yet because so where I'm at is I've got a road map in my head I've got a war board in my office that that only I talk about I met with the cabinet and I said I'm not going to share this with you yet I want you to come up with your ideas because I don't want the echo chamber effect I don't want everybody just going well this what Jeff
050said so let's go do it and and I want them working on their ideas guess what they've done with their staff they they they've gone to their administrators to say okay we got to find you know not just I don't want to say trim the fat we knew we we spent Esser dollars to prop us up to help us bridge that that that leap out of covid and that's exactly what it did and we've we've been saving those to be able to stretch that out even more we're just not going to be able to stretch it out as far as I was initially hoping because some of the variables have changed okay that's good um and you've been you've answered them I'm I'll probably get with you to get a meeting because I have lots
051more questions this is helpful though thank you and and and we're going to talk about this again like I said we'll talk about it in January I'm glad you're planning that we're talk about it in February every Mee yeah every month it's going to be a conversation piece the community is going to know where we're at what we're what we're doing but it so is our staff and our our board but I I need the board to tell me and the reason I say this is because when the board gives me the number if you guys say Jeff balance our budget that's what I will work towards if the board says Jeff dip 1 million that's what I will work work towards and I'll build the budget to to meet the board's expectation thank you
052yeah in your mind at this point are you looking at taking some three times as opposed to pretty much everything one time is that what you're looking at to cause the least amount of pain um I don't know that there's a least amount of pain okay I I I don't I I think that if we dip $5 million M I wouldn't I would balance the budget at that point I would just tell me to to bring a balanced budget for next year because again I don't want to see the unexpected consequences um of of of unexpected bills like whether it's health insurance or and health insurance went up 133% this year right I mean when I say this it's we need help where if you you know legislators help us bring down the cost of
053health insurance um you know it's it's there there's there's a lot of challenges that we're we're running into and you know Miss Hamilton you asked you know is thisam programmer people and the answer is probably yes I mean the hard part is is I would love to say we need to cut 12% of our budget but I can't cut 12% of the electric bill because I still got to turn the lights on and I can't cut 12% of the heating bill because I still got to heat the buildings right so there's are there areas that we'll try to keep the cuts you know to a minimum absolutely but there's also areas that I I I can't reduce the cost of of lighting so um that those are going to be the challenges we're going to
054face but I'll do this and I'll talk about the plan and the process I you guys set a budget goal in in January I'm hoping to be able to share a plan with you in February and start to enact that plan in March April May June so that when we hit the budget at the June meeting we're balanced that's what I hope sorry about the heavy news but it seems like that's the conversations I've been having with thank you okay no more discussion all right all in favor I oppose the same a motion passes thank you now we're going on to the superintendent evaluation um it was new this year and we had an extensive training on it um from masb and the difference uh is twofold first difference is that um they didn't split
055up effective into effective and highly effective either you're effective you're not so they're looking at it so there are three categories um needing support developing and effective and um superintendent Beal's overall score was 98.5 which identifies him as number three effective um and he was rated in five categories the board consensus uh score for category a which is the governance and board relations was 275 community relations 270 staff relations 3.0 business and finance which I believe is your strength then some uh three instructional leadership three so he obviously did very well um in his valuation this time we had a number of comments some from board members some from the public um staff comments we have a couple I'd like to read uh the first one is superintendent Jeff Beal has had another successful year
056at JPS he continues to responsibly lead JPS and positively impact Jack County which is displayed in the numerous improvements Community Partnerships and countywide Leadership activities he has spearheaded Jeff welcomes parents in the community to be involved in JPS and does whatever is necessary to make JPS an attractive District choice for students to attend of her faculty and staff to work GPS is a great place to be under Jeff's leadership another one I've been a teacher at Jackson Public Schools for over 10 years and have watched District grow and continually improve I recently switched my teaching assignment to another JPS building and I realized that the positivity I felt prior to the change is not confined to just one building well there are significant differences between my two schools the energy and excitement for learning resounds
057within the classrooms at both places uh then we had a new employee as a new employee I have been made to feel appreciated and respected for all I do for the staff and students Mr be made a point of checking in on me after the first week to see how things were going he made sure I knew who to contact for specific questions and explained how to access more general information on the JPS website um there was a comment that a board member would have preferred to know some um things that we had in place like the sexual education Advisory Board District Improvement um meetings and also felt that board members should not be refused attendance at National Association School boards conferences uh another one said I looked at the Benchmark conference statistics and it
058showed as of August 2024 our retention rate for teachers was 92% which is impressive and the primary reason I gave Mr Beal a high score in that category um Jeff does a good job at sharing important information in a timely manner across many platforms um he encourages and promotes autonomy from administrators to ensure the best practices are followed to support Student Success so overall uh well 98.5 you know overall obviously it was a very good evaluation and not as many comments as I would have liked um but I think you're kind of getting the gist from from what um I did at that point we get at that point Madam president I'll move to approve the superintendent evaluation document as presented as a effective rating for superintendent B support any discussion yes some discussion okay
059so um James Baldwin some of you all may know him he's deceased now but he says and I'm gonna uh do a play on his words he says I love JPS he said America but I'm going to just like I said play on it I love JPS more than any other District in the world and exactly for this reason I insist on the right to criticize it perpetually my comments on this current uh action item that were're on the state of Michigan as Pam mentioned updated their evaluation tool for this year's evaluation um while we inaccurately averaged um his scores uh previously it did allow all voices to be represented in those scores um the new tool that we're using says that you should use consensus and the definition that they use for consensus is
060um choosing the mode those of us who are math students and we understand that that is the most occurring number so there's no uh averaging it's just the most occurring number um as the score um so with these scores um so these scores they are less a reflection of the full board and more a reflection of the most occurring score for that reason I'm going be a no vote on uh this uh evaluation product that we're bringing to you tonight okay let's go ahead and vote all in favor I I opposed no okay motion passes thank you superintendent evaluation we now go on to superintendent employment agreement um this the same agreement that you've seen in previous years it extends it out one year um with the same uh 2% raise for the final year
061and a same increase in my board paid annuity there is one language change um in here and it does deal specifically with the board paid annuity this comes uh from our payroll department um who works with the office of Retirement services so um the board paid annuity is considered compensation and as such it's figured into um the the final average compensation for every school employee uh and so what was recommended and it's not just for the superintendent this is the same recommendation that you'll see anywhere that a board paid annuity is there is that you have to have the language or Os wants to see the language and and and I'm going to paraphrase here because Brendan wrote the language the attorney kind of dovetailed it in here but cash option available because they have
062to say it's compensation and as compensation you can't they don't want you to say it can only go in that pension account or in that IRA account it it it can be taken as cash and you're going to see this language again it's in mind because of the changes or in ORS and this is again language that um Nicole our payroll person brought to my attention uh in the fall and again language you will see in our contracts across the board wherever you see a board paid to do Marcus did I get that accurate all right and that's the only change there's no no substantive dollar change there's no no hidden raise in this it's the exact same raise I already have my my salary set for next year so it's really just adding one
063year which is all we ever do and then adding that the same salary changes to that final year mam president I'll move approval for discussion second you have a second support discussion gisha yes so um so the extra duty pay is still listed in this contract um there's also as Jeff just mentioned to you all an extension on the contract of one year um based on our district data the fact that we're a partnership school that's been forced to work with the state of Michigan to address our deficiencies the disparaging text message that was sent to board member Kesha Hamilton um and uh inappropriately handled um the uh ensuring horror that was experienced by our community and the lack of intention and authentic engagement of our Urban classified District um by this superintendent I'll also
064be a no vote on this one thank you okay any more discussion um Madam president this has been reviewed by our legal councel brot any more discussion okay all in favor I oppose the same no than you motion passes okay now the other thing that's me okay um the changes from the state are meant to be helpful meant to be more accurate um assessment of time before we had to evaluate the superintendent every year just like with teachers you have the thing to the teachers well all of those have been reduced so if fact let me get exactly the wording here for him yep mb's new time frame for superintensive valuation is no longer every year the new requirements are stated below if the superintendent is rated effective on three consecutive evaluations the board may
065choose to conduct an evaluation by an by anually instead of annually off years still report as effective in the RP if evaluation slips below effective or if the evaluator changes the evaluation must be conducted annually rated as developing or needing support the board must develop and require the superintendent to implement an improvement plan to correct deficiencies the Improvement plan must recommend professional development opportunities and other actions designed to improve the rating um so here is where we need to discuss this and take action on uh whether to take Jeff or any superintendent that's here at JPS as long as they've been effective for three consecutive years and remain effective on that midyear thing um they would get a formal evaluation every two years instead of every year do I have a motion to to do
066that do discuss come after that yeah I'll make that motion to discuss okay support he motion to discuss let's go ahead and discuss um I have a question on yeah where it says the um if the evaluator changes if we're the evaluators and we would you know have elections I believe a couple years does that mean that um the evaluation must be conducted actually I asked that very question lib um and it does not now if we decided that we were going to have a situation besides the board if we hire an outside person to do an evaluation if we feel we need um an expert from masb to come and an evaluation that would be your change in evaluator the board is like considered a Mr and Mrs Board you know and if there's
067board still doing the evaluation it's the same evaluator G um I'm not opposed to moving to a biannual evaluation um but I would make a motion to postpone this until the January 21st meeting um of next year so that uh we have three new board members coming on I think it's uh appropriate to uh see if they want to continue to have evaluations yearly or um move to a twoyear processen so I'm opposed um I've always worked in the private sector I've always been evaluated every year and I just think it holds um the superintendent more accountable to what his goals and um the agendas are going to be just for his goals so I'm I'm opposed to that I think we should do it annually I too I'm opposed for the B anual excuse
068me I'm a little horse um I think with our district recently just coming out of um some strict observ observation I think it would be um beneficial for us to have that annual period for us to to see what milestones we are meeting the goals that we are accomplishing within that I think if we go by annual that some things may get lost and the weeds and our district can't afford that any other comment I'll just say I'm in support of it if masb is recommending it and if it falls if his goals fall short of this you can still decide to do it and you still have that midterm evaluation the the less formal one but it would still identify any deficits or any problems along the way that's the rep that's in there
069um what I liked about it and I am in for uh in favor of it is that we every school year moves so quickly and if we want to attain certain goals that period is not enough to decide well I don't know he didn't do that or she didn't do that or I don't see it done and it might be a 12 14 month thing that takes that long I just don't like rushing it and I know when I was principal of this school I had a hard time with that many evaluations with teachers Jeremy didn't you too at that time um and it's not necessary and they're not doing that now as long as the evaluations up to that point and they must remain effective the rep itself kind of takes care of that
070intermediate stuff um I just think it gives both the board and the superintendent enough time to really reach a goal and it also gives us a little um safety net and and US looking at it with that midyear rep it's still there it's not as intensive and it's not all-inclusive like the annual evaluation but it hits the high points and you make sure that whoever is in here is hitting those along the way so you don't get um so they don't get sidetracked and you don't get blindsided at the end when you see two years have passed and you haven't done this that prevents that from happening so um so I'm also opposed to this as well um the tool that masb has that we've chosen to use because there are other tools out there
071we could use a different evaluation tool if we wanted to um this tool um it's generalized um and it's very limited in its ability to accurately assess what individual districts are doing because it is generalized to the state of Michigan and whoever in the district or in the state wants to use it so it's it's a you know it's not the best tool for one thing um but um our you know here at JPS you know while these evaluation conversations are very difficult um the final scoring each year does give us an opportunity as Shand mentioned to you know say hold on these are things that you know that are not that we need to look at at minimum like I said the tool is is limited and and insufficient um but it is an
072opportunity at least for us to look at it yearly which you know um you know there's we're doing M and all those different like it's all whack but um it is an opportunity for us to be able to look each year so we should the second thing um derck made a motion and Libby uh seconded it I know we didn't hear it but she did second that motion I'm not sure if that's still on the table or not but I do like the idea of allowing new board members that are incoming to have a say in um what happens with this so I'm I'm open to uh you know pushing it off to January so they can have some conversation around us as well Eric for purposes so just so Michelle can accurately reflect can
073I could you give me the wording on that motion to postpone to the January 21st meeting a second by Libby second thank you ask for discussion yeah any more discussion on that waiting until January support you support that okay I just want to add one more um comment while it says that the masb has changed this policy it says the board may choose so we have the autonomy to decide on that and I think it doesn't right so it doesn't and actually the state exactly so it doesn't put us in this box so I um I do support us waiting till our January 21st meeting organizational meeting when we have our new oncoming board members to um hear their perspective and and make a decision then I have one more question also um the if
074we were to vote yes in January to you know go to these biannual um evaluations when would that start when does the clock start to you know to say we have you know the last two years have been whatever or is it like 20 this one is one and then next year one you'd start whenever you approve it so the 25 evaluation would be the beginning of that and remember that even though this is just so just so I can understand what you're say Pam um in 25 if we said don't inter it I'm just wondering when did the um it says if we have at least two you know when when did that start can I take a stt so so first of all I'm I'm going to be candid with everybody I don't
075mind an evaluation every every year I I said it this year and I had some wonderful feedback I take the the comments I think I said Shar this with you the night that we had our evaluation Retreat that the comments that you provide me give me guidance on on where to go um this what what Miss Fitzgerald has brought before you is is changes in the law that were passed and that became effective July 1 uh we do this for our teaching staff and our administrators now so uh it's biannual or tri-annual for our teaching staff uh and our administrators and the it it Keisha to answer your question specific and I'll I'll use it with a teacher if a teacher was uh highly effective or effective the last two years they've got a rotation
076year where they would not be evaluated this coming year and this is a again kind of a one of those position conversations all right the board has the option to evaluate every year the board doesn't have to option every year and this uh I I'm I'm I'll speak for me I don't mind however you also have that you need to understand that I'm probably not going to be the superintendent of JPS forever so at some some point there'll be another superintendent in here so what position you make may be the conversation of the position for that person down the road Andor you may want to revert back so if you say yes Jee you've been effective or highly effective you may say I want to do evaluation every year for the next person because they
077don't have the the running clock on them so this is just positional and it it's just law and I'm I'm not going to say I'm for or against this because obviously it would be self-serving to say I am for it and at the same time I I'm not opposed to it because it is what we do with every other employee but uh I'm good with whatever the board decides but I think that answered your question Miss Hamilton please tell me if I did or didn't yes the past three years it kind of starts right away it just looks at the past couple years 2 thank you 25 would be your first and before we take this vote can you just clarify what we're voting on I think it's his motion just so we can clarify
078that yeah have to wait until January meeting yeah okay all in favor of waiting to tabling this until January meeting yes yes opposed okay motion passed thank you Okie do at this point we are down to board comments would anyone like to make a comment Isa yes so um I had opportunity to attend the Council of urban Boards of Education conference um accessible only through um nsba the National School Board Association so um we all attend masb which is the Michigan Association of school boards their conference is a Statewide Association that we are members of um the national you know clearly we're you know building out a little bit um they have their conferences as well we have chosen the board chose I did not choose the board chose about three years ago when I
079motioned for us to start attending those conferences to not go to those conferences well nsba offers a council on Urban Boards of Education they call it Cube um which is open only to Urban school districts but you can only access it through the National School Board Association anyways though I had opportunity um this year in I think it was October um yes it was in October to attend their conference on a scholarship they offer scholarships to um boards they I think they give every board I think they give each of them one scholarship if they want to anyways so I was able to to you know fagle and do the things that I do because I knew how important was for me to be there and get to that uh conference um it was enlightening
080and um affirmative and uh you know uh inspiring um in the information that was being shared um because again this is a it's for urban school districts only you all may or may not know but JPS is classified as an urban School District um and so a lot of the information that was being shared the all of the information that was being shared in the uh sessions and the um you know the the breakout sessions the uh Keynotes and Etc were again based around Urban school districts um masb um it caters to the general population here in Michigan um which makes sense because it's a Statewide Association which also makes sense where nasb would say we're going to have a separate conference that is specific to this group because even the National Conference it can't
081specifically address the concerns almost like you know all the moms we want to have a conference for you all the dads we want to have there are different things that's going to be discussed in those things so anyway so Cube like I said it's um for them um it was a it was a a great conference um like I said a lot of the suggestions and the questions and the uh things that I bring up um were affirmed in that meeting so that was good um I think we should still be going to those conferences um which is why I figured out a way to get there I don't know if I'll be able to do it next year but um anyways I wanted you all to know that that's where I was I've been
082missing a couple meetings because I've been traveling I travel for work sometimes as well um so um let me see one more thing um okay so the holiday holiday yes um happy holidays I wanted you all to know that I went to the conference and then I want to say happy Holidays happy holidays to our students our teachers our uh parents our staff um you know these years are just the work that we put in to educate our students understanding how important education is you know we rule the world they they talk about The Hand That Rocks the Cradle rules the world um our teachers and staff and folks you all are the people who help rule the world literally you know I mean we the education that we pour into our students is so
083important so thank you thank you thank you I'm trusting and hoping that you all will be able to have some time to relax with your family enjoy um those things are the most important to you um and then come back hopefully refreshed and rejuvenated for the next half of the year but um I I don't want it to um you to think that I don't recognize the importance of what we do um the sacrifices that we're making to raise basically folks kids by having them in you know in the education world so thank you thank you thank you and again Happy Holidays anybody else lib do you want to say something I just wanted to thank the community for allowing me to sit on this board for the last six years it's been quite an
084experience I've really enjoyed it and um I hope that the that the coming years prove to be very fruitful for our students and for the faculty and that's it um hope everyone uh that uh works for JPS can uh take some welld deserved time off uh during the holiday season to recoup and recharge heading into uh 2025 uh appreciate the work that is ahead of us on uh the budget and bringing that into um uh into balance uh I think that that presents us an enormous opportunity to uh explore some uh really bold growth opportunities uh to work strategically to uh with staff to figure out how we can uh reallocate uh some funds uh creatively to preserve staff um maybe incentivize uh some uh reasonable attrition and uh I know that Administration will uh
085do all of those things uh to ensure that uh cuts to those that uh put themselves out there uh come at the very last um even if they may be hard decisions so appreciate the work ahead on that uh and look forward to working with uh uh Cheryl Ela and subba in the new year um on some of those difficult decisions uh do want to give thanks to uh Libby Angela and Pam uh Libby actually um was probably one of the first uh kind of activists uh engaged uh citizens that I met when I first moved to Jackson uh with her and George uh in a different space but uh it has been a pleasure to uh work beside you and uh continue to uh make Jackson a better place uh working with you Libby
086uh Angela you are a delight um it has been great to sit next to you um and appreciate your service and getting to know you more um and look forward to continuing to uh hang out with you and Pam thank you for uh your leadership for uh your dedication for uh your Decades of service uh to uh the community and to JPS in particular so very much appreciated he wow I can't believe uh this is my last meeting uh when I first campaigned and became elected six years ago uh my daughter was in third grade and my son was in kindergarten at Shar Park Academy and now my daughter is a freshman here at Jackson high school and my son is at in sixth grade at Parkside which is hard to believe um this has
087been a great journey um that has definitely come with challenges um I've met many um staff parents and stakeholders I wouldn't have met otherwise I have made lifelong friendships because of the board the staff at JPS are simply amazing I'm very proud to have children in JPS District I love the JPS District when I got elected and I can say that I love it even more now after six years being on the board I would like to thank Mr Beal for his leadership during my six years on the board along with the cabinet's hard work and collaboration and I'd like to thank the community for allowing me this opportunity to serve in the board it's been a true honor and I wish the new board um very well in 2025 thank youen so I wanted
088to thank Libby Angela and Pam also it's been an honor to serve with you really I have learned so much and I have a long history with Libby so my children are 36 and 3 before so Lippy would always call my one son schneid it was always schneid this and schneid that and he still uses that for his email and but my kids just loved her they just they they just thought she was the best and Angela when I first came on here I was really nervous and she was so kind and nice to me so she really is a really nice person and um pam pam was the principal when my kids were here too so we just have this long history and I went to school with her husband Dan so I have
089learned so much from all three of you thank you so much I just really appreciate every all the help you gave me as a new board member so I too want to thank Libby Angela and Pam liby has been my daughter's favorite teacher and so Libby is often you know asked how how was my daughter doing and just doing that touch point to see you know what success she's achieving but thank you Libby for being instrumental and um many of the tough decisions on this board Angela thank you for um meeting with me when I had this Brave idea to run for a school board we met and we talked and you were very transparent about your experience at that point and um we have had had many conversations that have been meaningful and so
090um each of you have been an asset to the team in so many different ways Pam appreciate your leadership I've had to nudge you a few times what and turn my microphone off turn your microphone off many different times but um I think collectively we've we've made it over these past few years and so thank you to each of you happy holidays everyone okay I'm last um JPS has been part of my life my entire life um I personally a fourth generation Jackson high school graduate um and my six kids were the fifth generation and now I have a little granddaughter at dible so that's our sixth generation this has been an interesting 12 years um I got to I I was pleased I think that I brought to the board a view of the
091district from a bunch of different angles as I mentioned before I was assistant director of federal programs when I was like 20 I don't know what I thought I was doing with that um and then I stayed home with my kids for quite a while then at about 32 I thought ah I don't know everything maybe I should go to college so I did and my goal at that point was to be the first female principal of Jackson high that was my focus and I was and we've had two more since then so I guess I didn't kill it for anybody um we've had some struggles we've been through during my tenure here we've been through um two bonds the pandemic school closing School openings um there have been challenges but there have been huge
092huge um JPS is just something so special I was a uh on the NCA board to um certify school districts so I get into a lot of school districts in Jackson or in Jackson in Michigan and there is just simply a difference when you walk into the door at Jackson high and when you walk into the door someplace else and there were big schools like ours um but there's just a Vibrance that's within the district that you just don't find any place else and that says nothing about the fact that we offer what other schools don't there's no other school in the county that has the AP programs or the other end at the students who need extra help that we have here um I have worked at JPS through 11 superintendence and I tell
093you you got a winner here you got his financing his ability to earn the trust of people in a very Earnest way um then there's Michelle who held my hand all the way through that she gives me this funny little you can see it this little agenda this is Pam's agenda's special agenda it says things like um motion to approve call for support just so I don't skip skip over any of those steps they're wonderful so Michelle has been a godsend um all the way through but the biggest thing I've had not as a board but just in general is the students I had students for years and years I was taught seniors and they've kept in contact all the way through and that is so important it's kind of funny if I'm at the
094fair or at the mall or whatever and someone yells missfitz I know they were in my class and if they say well hello Mrs Fitzgerald I know they were in my office for some reason or another but they're a delight everybody involved in JPS has a really quirky little part of them that appreciates diversity and appreciates um the opportunity ities I mean you are immersed in culture cultural diversity just walking down the hallway our kids leave 12th grade at Jackson high able to move in any Social Circle feeling comfortable in any new surroundings um and you just don't get that other places so thank you for my 800 years in JPS last 12 as as um a non-p paycheck person I don't know what that was about but the volunteerism I was hoping would give
095back a little bit of what I got from them so thank you very much and you guys have been so solid and so supportive and when I need you you showed up you're right there thank you if if you don't mind I'm going to just say thank you again to to Libby Angela Pam and and and really truly the whole board but we have a saying in Jackson uh once a viking always always a viking your family here and and I I need you to know that so thank you very much for your service everybody please have a a safe night safe drive home and a happy holidays we'll see you again in 2025 and all we have in our calar new um meeting in January the 21st same place motions move to aour all
096in favor