CorpusRecord 53649

2.03.2025 MDPS Regular Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Madison District Public Schools
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Oakland County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,043 words · about 73 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e meeting tonight is Monday February 3rd 2025 this is the regular Board of Education meeting we have first Pledge of Allegiance would trustee chamblas lead us please I to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all I'm going to try to do it out of that all righty next up is public fundamentals public input is fundamental to the operation District Moll call First oh my goodness thank you roll call please here here here here here here I apologize I put trustee chamblas the roll call was all right we'll start again public input is fundamental to the operation of medicine District Public Schools our public has an opportunity to speak at every Board of Education

002meeting a period of time known as public comment is set aside at each meeting to give parents and other citizens a chance to speak directly to the board about school related topics anyone who wishes to speak to the board must fill out a request form and give it to the board secretary before the meeting begins comments are limited to 3 minutes the Board of Education accepts comments made during public comment from anyone who follows these guidelines public comment is one of the many information sources the board uses before making a decision in the best interest of the children who attend Madison District Public Schools the board also works with the District staff to address citizens questions and concerns did we receive any requests we did not thank you anybody else no okay we're going to

003move on turn the floor over to the superintendent for our presentation of awards thank you we're going to start with our Early Childhood Center principal Lisa de Julio she's going to introduce our student of the month as well as our staff members of the month all right I have Miss suridge here who is going to introduce our first student good afternoon I would like to first um honor Harmony Harmony you want to come on [Applause] up are you ready swee turn look this way okay I'm going to say some good things about okay so Harmony is ready to learn when she comes to school every day she has sown so so much growth this year she listens to directions while on the carpet or at her seat when she doesn't understand something she kind of

004looks at you with like little puzzled look on her face and you can tell her mind is working trying to figure out what she should be doing or what's going on or why it's not making sense to her she has learned so much this year she' she has mastered almost all of her letters and sounds and is now busy working on putting those sounds together to read three letter words Harmony is always a bright light in her class she's not afraid to be herself I know those of you who are here saw her marching in with her little stuff she's ready she was leading the pack on the way into the building today right um Harmony is working hard every day and is continuing to work on her reading skills we're very proud of Harmony

005and everything she's doing to move forward this year and keeps working hard okay we're good all right so for them I hope they get better soon but I told them to sign in and watch so Axel always has a smile on his face he's always excited for the day he's eager to try new things and always tries his best no matter how hard it is when he is working really hard you might see him put his hands up on his forehead like this and his little hair starts poofing out it's so cute like that Axel is also very inquisitive and ask many questions about things he's curious about or things he does not understand Axel has been working so hard on reading this year he's now working on first grade phonic skills earlier this year

006when we had a book fair Axel and his family visited he eagerly picked out a book He's roaming all around looking Mr Julia was in there to do there too it was so much fun and he picked out his book and he was so excited the next day he came back to school just I read this last night I read this I mean I wish he was here because it would be so cute he's like I read this and it was adorable so he was just so enthusiastic and he has came so far this year and continues to work hard so we're so proud of him thank you Axel [Applause] and her is it working for our staff of the month we have chosen ECC has chosen Miss Gabrielle Curtis come on up come on

007up Gabrielle has been a valued member of our school Community previously serving as a guest teacher and Pa professional she is now our student teacher in Miss jabo's room and she has truly embraced her role with dedication and enthusiasm going above and beyond her school requirements Gabrielle has demonstrated exceptional commitment to her students and colleagues she has built strong relationships with both staff and students making a meaningful impact in our school and some of the comments from the teachers that she is a valued member of our school Community um she goes above and beyond her school requirements and has demonstrated exceptional commitment to her students and colleagues and she's just building strong relationships with staff and students so please join us in congratulating Miss Gabrielle Curtis is our St play of the month this one

008this one is for you thank you will have Madison Elementary School good evening uh we will be highlighting our self-contain classrooms this evening and I have one of our self-contained teachers to introduce those very special students oh use the microphone sorry just a minute um my class can I have Michael come up Michael come here hey [Music] [Applause] Michael that's okay I don't need it I got it um Michael is our chosen student of the month Michael is a wonderful student and role model to his classmates Michael comes in Every Day cheerfully greeting his teachers just like he just did it's always miss Rogers so he's very happy to see all of us he is help you want to help me read want to help me read come here come here what's that say he

009is helpful and kind to his classmates and peers Michael likes to build things and share his treasures with our class we are so glad to have Michael in class and as a friend keep up the great [Applause] work love what do you have turn around say hi Mr I is so good with these kids thank you all right next from is v v did's class she's off on maternity leave we have Lucas I'm not going to chop his name up so I'm [Music] Lucas I know how they marched out you're so proud I love my bad I'm just really messing this up no problem no there we go all right you turn the micophone is from Miss Bend class has been chosen as student of the month for his outstanding dedication kindness and hard work

010he consistently demonstrates a positive attitude respect for others and a strong commitment to learning his enthusiasm in the classroom willingness to help classmates and determination to do his best make him a role model for his peers we are proud to recognize L Lucas for his achievements and contributions to our school Community keep up the great work thank you Lucas [Applause] yes staff member of the month um couldn't be here microphone sorry our staff member of the month couldn't be here tonight but I would still um like to honor her for imp exemplifying perseverance our staff has chosen Katherine patrio according to to her colleagues Katherine has exemplified true perseverance throughout this year facing numerous personal challenges with unwavering dedication despite dealing with difficult family health issues her own health struggles and the heartbreaking loss of

011her beloved dog Rocky Catherine has continued to show up for her students and colleagues with resilience and strength her commitment to her role as an educator is inspiring she goes consistently Above and Beyond in her classroom creating a self- insecure and nurturing environment where her students feel valued loved and appreciated she takes steps she takes extra steps to recognize acts of kindness among her students fostering a positive and supportive classroom culture her passion for teaching shines through her daily interactions always greeting her students with a warm smile and genuine enthus enthusiasm Beyond her classroom she is a dedicated team player she actively contributes to literacy committee offering her time and support to enhance our school community Catherine's positive attitude motivates those around her and through every challenge she has remained committed to her students colleagues

012family and friends she truly embodies the spirit of resilience and serves as an inspiration to the entire M mes [Applause] family thank you now we will have Wilkinson Middle School principal Jones evening evening good evening um I'm going to start this with um our staff of the month um a little out of order maybe not I'll start with our staff of the month our staff of the month is unable to be here today but our staff of the month is Miss Laura Schultz um she embodies the word perseverance at all times times um Laura came to us in the spring of last year she's a returning Madison District employee and has just been on fire ever since it was an overwhelming um thing with our staff to give her the student of the staff of

013the month for the things that she does Laura basically never takes a lunch she's always moving to help the case load of our special needs students in our building but she still finds time to do um School Improvement just anything and everything that we need and she just pushes through no matter how difficult her load comes in she just helps us helps us helps us and Wilkinson is very proud to honor her as our staff of the month for the characteristic of perseverance and at this time we're going to have Mr Pera Mr Pera is going to come and talk about our two students of the month um and they are we had a makeup game today at our building this afternoon against Clon so it's currently going on and they're there oh thank you

014Miss Jones our first student of the month is eth grader D'Angelo Jones D'Angelo has long stood as a heart of his grade at mdps he has always been a model student showcasing good behavior and doing his best to maintain his grades in his interactions with others he always opts to lead with Grace and kindness towards others where he showcases perseverance is that regardless of any challenge whether it is learning new academic content or rehearsing band recital he always Rises to meet these challenges Because he believes in the power of holding himself to high standards D'Angelo's perseverance sets a standard for all students at Wilkinson and he will continue to set this standard in his high school career for our second student of the month Elsa in e8th grade Joselyn whitler Joselyn has always persevered to

015be a balanced well-rounded student her schedule has often included both band concert and extracurricular Sports despite these large obligations joshlin is always the first to check her grades every morning on myar and consistently is self-motivated to maintain good grades at all times she has worked tirelessly to improve as a student year after year and has emerged as a focused young woman who can achieve whatever she sets her mind to Jocelyn is more than prepared for the challenges of high school and whatever the next chapter of life brings her way thank [Applause] you last but not least we have Madison High School evening um if you haven't noticed a theme yet um the February theme is perseverance and achieving our goals remaining committed with the support of all of those around us so we are honoring

01610th graders this month around the theme of perseverance so if we could have as me Hannah fin up first come on up all right Esme your teachers had some very nice things to say about you Esme is absolutely amazing she always turns in thoughtful beautifully worded work she is a pleasure to have in class Esme is independent thoughtful creative and she doesn't shy away from any challenge don't mistake her softness for weakness pay attention to her work she doesn't try to show off but we be fools not to acknowledge and celebrate all of her potential she has challenged herself and is excelling this year she's taking two AP college level classes um AP US History here at the high school and AP environmental science over at um Casa our center for advanced studies and arts

017as well as Japanese uh her Casa instructors Shar shared this quote with us to embody the daily hard work and commitment that she exudes the difference between a try and a Triumph is just a little ump [Applause] congratulations all right our next 10th grader tamari Gentry come on [Applause] [Music] up all right tamari when tamari is on point he is a force to be reckoned with he will make sure he has the teachers attention and will get help until he completes the assignment uh his personality is infectious and so much fun I'm so glad to have tamari this year uh I really miss having Mari in my class he is so kind to everyone around him he's curious about the students he hasn't met and he's so refreshingly honest and open he wants to help

018more than he wants to play but if I'm being honest I'm glad he has balanced both also he has so worked so very hard to improve in all of his classes always asking questions if he didn't understand a thing and he is a committed young gentleman from his 9th to his 10th grade year especially tamari has continuously sought opportunities to grow knowing that true success comes from pushing beyond your comfort zone and he's applying to both otac and Casa next year because he's not sure which one wants to go with potentially um the engineering Robotics and mechatronics program um or Kasa some AP classes but no matter which one he chooses he'll be an amazing fit we're so proud very good they'd be very proud of all right and we are honored uh to have

019uh Mr prosi for our staff member of the month come up Mr PR all right Mr pre is a welcome addition to our staff he is knowledgeable and a great resource and he is inspiration to our students Mr pres is an amazing addition to the staff again um he truly cares about the staff the students love him trust him and have shared what a great support he is and Mr pres has been a great role model for our students he inspires and cares about our students and always make sure they are safe as a the first year teacher you would know it Mr pre has brought energy and excitement to his classroom with his experiences and strengths to connect with his students um he teaches two Preparatory classes for us and he has worked especially

020hard to tailor his lessons and his instruction to our students learning styles and needs uh he has recognized A Fire Within his Prep students that he continues to nurture each day we were so excited to bring back physics uh to our school with Mr pre um as well so they were uh they were just doing a lab the other morning on Friday morning the kids were so stoked it was amazing um Mr pre continually strives for excellence in every lesson he creates and concept he explains teaching is not always an easy job as we know especially in a subject as complex and challenging as math or physics uh but he approaches every day with a determination ready to break down any barriers and make the toughest material accessible and engaging [Applause] congratulations uh with that

021I guess I want to say thank you and congratulations we all the board members will say it at the end of the meeting you guys are gone so I'm sure they still will but the while you're here let's uh to the staff to the students congratulations and thank you we will take a 5 minute break for anybody that needs to go and we will resume at 6:27 with the rest of the meeting so e e e is 6:28 we are back in and we are going to start with the administration report thank you good evening so last week I went to the Oakland County School Board Associated meeting with um secretary Bush and I wanted to share with you guys some of the things that we received the back of the report there's a page

022that call that's called the keyw work of school boards and that was the kind of like the overview of the presentation and it just talks about what we need to do as a school board we need to make sure we we have relationships we maintain them one of the things that came up was a vision and Mission and I thought to myself do the board members or the new board members even know our mission and vision statement and our core values and it also talked about how we need to always make decisions around that mission and vision and our core values talk talks about holding us accountable creating policy as well as Community leadership so out of that Workshop I do want to eventually have like subcommittees where we can have policy because we have

023a ton of policy updates and I think sometimes it's just Pam and I working on them but if I can have a board member that's interested in it you guys will be more than appreciative if you guys can help us with creating policy so on the front I shared with you guys a especially for our new board members our mission and our vision and as a district we will use a rigorous curriculum that will engage all students regardless of their academic level in an environment that is safe supportive and nurturing and as our vision we will provide our students with the education that will prepare that will prepare them academically socially and emotionally for the next phases of their lives and Beyond we wanted to incorporate that not just college but we never know where

024our students are going they may go to trade school they may go to another District so whether they're going into they're graduating or if they're transferring schools our vision is to make sure that they are prepared for that next level and for our core values we like to spell out the word scope so we always put students first we make sure that we're courageous in our leadership in our everyday activities every day we strive to be 1% better we always want to make sure that we are persevering and we're ethical at all times so when we have our student of the month and our staff members of the month we try to go through each one of these core values and focus on that so for our new board members and our old board members

025who have not seen this in a while I'll make sure that this is visible on our report every month um just just as a point of um Vision Bush would you like I would I'm sorry president holder you um just as a point a vision is always first then the mission underneath that okay just thank you you also I do want to announce attention everyone we have received the summer Discovery learning Grant again this year woo last year we um were able to host a K8 program that was out of this world we host students not only from Madison but from any District um we only received like $330,000 last year but we were able to take the kids on five different field trips we had different events every week they learned math and English

026or literacy from 9 until 12 and then from 1 until 4 they learned different sports so they learned football one week we focused on football baseball basketball well this year we earned um the scholarship the Grant and we had $414,000 to host this program so we are so excited to the community please check out our website probably around March or April we will start advertising for it spaces are limited but we are are going to take as many kids as possible so please make sure you guys stay tuned for the details about our summer Discovery program um in the financial state that we are this gives us an opportunity to bring smiles to kids' faces and parents faces because not only are we teaching them how to be a kid again but we're also improving

027their literacy and math skills so we're so excited about that on the back I have to take this opportunity to give the city of Madison Heights a huge shout out prior to this year we were paying for fuel for our buses and we were driving the buses all the way to Mound and 696 and then bringing them back here and we had a credit card so we were getting interest charged so on and so forth we reached out to Madison Heights because we discovered that they were providing our district was sought and we said hey can you guys give us a deal with fuel this year we send our buses to the city of Madison Heights and we purchased fuel from the city thus far we have saved $8.37 from August until July on fuel

028so I want to sincerely thank the city of Madison Heights for their um partnership with us and it's really appreciated very [Applause] good for our food service and transportation department I want to give cat a shout out we received a $27,000 Grant and this is for safe routes to school program and basically it's a way to encourage and make sure our students are safe as they're walking back and forth to school so cat is going to use this funding to support different programs just to give them things that they need to make sure that they're safe going back and forth to school so great job Department of Transportation y Cham us I just want to say cat Vice is phenomenal at getting grants and money and I tell her this all the time and I'm

029going to say it every time it comes up she fights for every dollar and I think it's phenomenal I would honestly like to see a tally of how much in grant money she has actually been awarded in the past like 3 years because I can't believe you do an amazing job thank you so much for fighting for every penny for these [Applause] kids stakeholder I did mention that I will send you guys the presentation that secretary Bush and I received but I wanted your feedback because we have the Mich Association of school board Region 8 candidates and I sent out the list last week and we have to cast our vote before our next March meeting so if you guys had a chance to look at the candidates or does anyone want to recommend a

030candidate over or president holder I'll open the floor trusty Bush um I reviewed every candidate and the two that I know we're um selecting one but Paul Co and uh from Bloomfield Hill schools he's in Oakland County and I thought that he had the enough credentials that he would make a fine candidate the other one that I really liked was rodri means he's in Wayne County I believe but he's had 28 years of experience lots of um credentialing I really liked him as my primary but the other hand the what you know in the cost benefit analysis Oakland county is you know we'd like to have somebody representing Oakland County on that I was thinking do we have anybody else that would like to either confirm or make other suggestions I know I read through

031them all and I personally didn't have a preference I don't know any of them same here so do we want to cast our vote for Paul everyone fine with that usually there's one or two that stand out this year I think we have a lot of great talent so if you have a preference I'm okay with that all right okay thank you that is it for me rodri lived in Oakland County yeah all righty excuse me next up consent agenda all matters listed under the consent agenda are considered to be routine in nature by the Board of Education and will be acted upon by one motion there will be no separate discussion of these items if any member of the board or any citizen requests discussion of an item that item will be removed from

032the consent agenda and will become the first item of business under the Board of Education action items portion of the agenda uh first is approval of the minute of the board of education for the organizational meeting of January 6 2025 approval of the January 2025 financials as submitted in the amount of 1,174 99181 approval of the Personnel report submitted by human resources on February 3rd 2025 I need a maker and support please Madam president trusty Thompson I'd like to make a motion that the Board of Education approve the consent approve the consent agenda as presented I'll second truste bush is the support any discussion see none can we have a roll call vote please yes yes yes yes yes yes thank you next up is the study session for the sinking fund versus the bond

033funding and the mdps plans thank you we're going to have our district attorney come up and he can introduce your his himself to you guys because we have some new faces on the board well good evening board Jeremy Moz with law firm of Clark Hill um pleasure to be back and U the ability to assist the school district um through various legal issues uh tonight um I think everybody has a copy of the slides um not sure if you guys all see on the screen but that's the the pack is in front of you and I'm going to go through that and what we're here for today um is really uh there's a couple new board members on and it's always good every couple of years to go through all of the legal parameters uh

034that really Drive uh what has to be done for various construction projects there's various laws that you have to address in in ter of the whole process and uh if you skip some of those or you miss some of those there are some penalties so it's always good to have a good uh primer on that as we go on because you guys are uh working to complete your bond funds and those bond funds but you guys now have a sinking fund congratulations on that it's always tough to have and it's great to have those they do have some different differentiation between the two so that's a at the end we're going to go over some of that so you guys can understand that in understanding the legal parameters as what the role the board plays

035uh following behind you speak to the mic please following behind me um plant Moran real point will come uh and go through more of the process as well from the owner's representative standpoint um so let me see if I hit the arrows the correct way there we go so uh first we'll go through the six main topics that I've broken everything into um looks like they don't they all show up on the screen on that up there but you'll see on your uh your handout uh independent design and supervision of projects what um uh governing bodies have oversight over those uh we'll then look at engaging Professional Services and what the responsibilities of the school district there then moving into the competitive bidding with when we're dealing with actually getting contractors in place to do

036the construction then when we get into contractor selection and approval and then finally uh we'll go through allowable uses of syncing funds and bond funds and do a little bit of comparison to understand both sides of those so first on the design and supervision um looks like on the screen if you're seeing that it appears that when it was converted up to this one some of the formatting got messed up so um but we'll go from here uh so on the left side of the U this slide here you'll see under Section 1263 of the revised school code uh it states that the design and construction of all school buildings are under the sole and exclusive jurisdiction of the state superintendent of Public Instruction um very uh simply uh that means local control local ordinances

037local laws don't apply to school districts for the general construction of school buildings there are some exceptions to that but overall everything that you guys do with your design of school buildings all goes to the state it's the part Lara uh Licensing and Regulatory Affairs uh authorized is authorized and delegated to to do that they also use the Bureau of construction code Bureau fire safties other bureaus but they oversee so all your plans and specifications go to the state for approvals uh to the right side of the slide uh when you want to do your plans and specifications they have to be um designed by a licensed architect or engineer in the state of Michigan and there's a threshold there you see at $155,000 so any construction project that exceeds $155,000 the plans and specifications

038have to be um prepared by a licensed architector engineer um those are the ones that then go to the state for approval so you can do that so you cannot dispense of your architect um after they design they stay on board to the whole process they work with your other design professional and construction management team throughout the process there is H one brand new exception uh that's not even law yet uh it's not effective until April 1st of this year but it is something something that's out there and um just bringing it to your attention this could be an opportunity for some of the syncing fund projects um um as uh the previous slide I was talking about the design of all the specifications by an architect that has to be independent of any of

039the contractors that are actually engaged to do the construction that has been the law um since that that school building construction Act was enacted back in the 60s um but it is now changed to allow for what we call design build where the architect and the Constructor can be part of the same team be on the same side of the fence and work together now there is a specific uh process you have to engage if you would like to explore this opportunity but similarily you have to have a design criteria developer design the criteria at which you will then hold the design Builder architect and Constructor to design the project to submit bids you have to do a competitive process to engage a design Builder and then there has to be continued oversight um by

040the design criteria developer that assists you with this process so it really adds a different layer um because you're now combining the contractor and the architect together but you still have to have uh the design uh criteria developer which will similarly act as the independent architect if you're just doing the traditional construction um process so it is available it could provide usually look you look at sometimes if for specific projects there could be speed of delivery um there are some advantages to it but there are some things that you need to pay attention yes so since we're skipping this stuff or not really no there's no if you went with the design Builder y you would be skipping this step but both the designer and the Builder would both be um previously uh they vetted

041as part of the process yeah they're vetted as part of the competitive process to engage Your Design Builder but they're working together which under the traditional process that you guys have been accustomed to is the architect is independent from the contractor and there's no comingling of those two they stay separate yes so so to put it in um like really simple terms because I'm that simple rather than having an architect and then the contractor to to build my new bathroom I could have the architect from the contractor design and build and then the contractor would build it so they can work for the same company and we they don't have to be separated correct but they still have to be licensed correct correct they still have to be licensed and you still have to go

042through a competitive process to engage them okay thank you um that's just something like I said it could be a possibility for some syncing front projects so we wanted just to be aware of that one so engaging Professional Services if you are not going to do design build um there is no legal requirement to do competitive bidding as you mentioned if you're going to do a design build you have to competitively bid that that design build team um but otherwise the other members of your uh construction management group that could be your independent architect if you're going to under the traditional design in construction process your construction manager your owner's representative those other Professional Services um under state law do not need to be competitively bid um if you're using federal funds there are some

043requirements with competitive bidding for services under federal funds um but where we're moving to syncing funds right now which is state funded local funded uh it's a local funding so we're not really under the federal rules um so I just wanted to highlight there that there is no legal requirement for the Professional Services but if we switch over to now looking at we want to engage the actual contractors to do the construction that we need this is where we do have to have competitive bidding under uh state law so there's two laws here that really drive that there's 1267 of the revised school code and also 1274 and so I'll go through those in turn first year for any construction renovation or alteration of a school building um you have to obtain competitive bids for

044the materials and labor for any construction project that's going to cost over $30,512 so we'll break that down in a couple of different things here uh first the monetary amount that's 3,512 that's this current fiscal year um and that actually runs off the state's fiscal year on October 1 um and it and it is escalated every year by a formula so right now um until the state issues its next memorandum the beginning of this October $30,512 is the competitive bidding threshold then if we back up there is the material and labor it has to be for the construction project you cannot break up the material and the labor and look at them separately you have to you have to look at as a project as a whole um so you have to that that's the

045coming up with the whole project is when you're determining the $30,512 and then lastly here this is for any construction renovation or alteration of a school building except for repairs in emergency situations so if you're going to repair a school building in emergency a good example boilers go out in the middle of the winter we can't wait there are specific ific time frames you have to go posting you can't wait so you can go repair a school building if it's broke and it no longer works you have a leaking roof you can repair that without having a competitive bid um but it has to be a repair not um any other thing so there are specific bidding procedures you have to follow here so this is more of a timing issue you have to ad

046you have to post an advertisement for two weeks on the State website you also have to post that advertisement in the newspaper one time before bids are due um and then there is a competitive sealed bid process where bids are then submitted uh and that process goes and it lays out all the requirements you have there um at the bottom here there are some reservation of Rights and you can reject bids um in the like those are all statutory and you highlight at the very bottom there the Michigan based business preference that is if a local policy if you'd like to have that in place uh we can consider that if you'd like um yes trusty Bush on this I I noticed do you have places like uh State website is underlined does our finance

047person have this so that they can click and get to that website um that's not a hyperlink um but yeah the State website it's Sigma VSS yeah I can get them all that information I think they should actually our bylaws are less than the 30,000 that are required to be approved by the board this is the state and that's not the board board approval and competitive bidding are can be different plant Marine real point they usually lead us through that process so we make sure that we follow all their guidelines they've been great with training us on that I just wanted to be clear this is the law we have different guidelines on that particular Point perfect thank you justy Thompson is a question you mentioned like if the roof is leaking that would be

048an emergency situation but we still need to get bids correct if it's emergency repair you don't have to do competitive bids you can a best practice would be to maybe call a few different contractors and have them come out and give you quotes to make sure you're getting you know um a good but you don't have to go through the formal State competitive bidding process if it's an emergency repair okay um one thing that um I would just highlight is there's also a law that came into effect um about a year ago now um and that's Michigan State prevailing wage laws came back into effect um after they were abolished in 2018 um I only highlight this is just something that you guys are aware of um when we're um your bond uh funds and

049because that Bond was uh enacted prior to uh this law going into effect so those are exempt and those Bond projects do not to pay state prevailing wage and your syncing fund is actually a locally funded tax uh it's not a state um state project so uh for the most part prevailing wage isn't going to be applicable but it's something that is in the construction world now so depending on the funding source if we get going it's a good primary just to know about it as you work through construction projects um that maybe extend beyond um you know syncing fund projects and the finishing up the bond projects just so you're aware of that um the other competitive in law that I mentioned is under 1274 the school code this deals with procurement of supplies

050materials and equipment so this is your desks your furniture and things of that nature um this could be part of a construction project um and so this is things where we might be wanting to get a bunch of new desks um if they are an eligible expenditure of the bond uh you might still need to uh have competitive bids the state bidding threshold is still the same 3,512 it escalates at the same time as the construction um and you have to do um and the board obviously has to approve that purchase um there are a couple exceptions highlighted there um if you use the state's uh bulk purchasing program that's through my deal where the state does their own competitive bidding and then allows uh different governmental agencies to purchase off of that they've already

051done the competitive bidding so you don't have to redo it you can just purchase right from there and then also purchases of food in a single transaction if there the the competitive bidding threshold is $100,000 not 30,000 that number doesn't change it's been stagnant since it was enacted probably 10 years ago um but that's for food purchases that's for the actual food not uh any purchase in the food service department which could be milk coolers and that it's just for the actual food that you would consume uh the Michigan base business PR PR preference is also available under this statute as well if you guys want to consider that so moving now that we have bids in we want to look at what we have to do if we're going to select our contractors so

052uh when bids come in um and and maybe U there's a due diligence that's done um Michigan is not a low bid State uh we are not required just to take the automatic lowest monetary bid uh Michigan we are obligated under the Attorney General opinion to accept the lowest responsible bidder so the key word there is responsible um there's really um several different things you can do in your due diligence you can look at references uh maybe the contra trctor previously worked did work at the school district um Financial capacity uh supply chain issues there's a lot of things that you could look at to make sure they're the most responsible able to meet your timeline U and all of those things to who's the most responsible even though they might be the lowest so

053there may be recommendations that come in front of you that maybe in monetarily uh terms they're the second lowest bidder but they might be the most responsible because the one that was the lowest might not be able to meet other criteria that are deemed uh uh important and able to make sure the Project's done uh on time and on budget and within the specifications as required um hopefully we never get to this point um but we always highlight the bid protests um really all I just highlight here is there you have the violation of public trust in red uh in the middle of your slide there um uh courts uh will really they leave they don't want to act as a super school board and always second guess because then anytime a bidder that submitted

054a bid wasn't satisfied that they weren't selected they could just file a lawsuit and it would come up every we never get any construction done um so courts generally uh will not sit a super School boards and it is uh a contractor disgruntled contractor has no standing isua School District it have to be a taxpayer would have to bring that suit and they'd have to bring it under the basis of a violation of public trust which is any fraud abuse or illegality so we're here today to you know show you all the legal issues and explain those to you so we don't end up any of those situations um so that you don't have that bid Pro test but it's always good to understand you know at the end of the U the reasoning why

055a lot of these uh processes are in place so now at the end um really getting into our syncing funds and bond funds and the differences of those uh and highlighting some of the issues here um first we'll look at bond funds uh that's under Section 1351 a of the revised school code uh as you know bond funds are generally for Capital uh improvements and capital purchases um those um 1351 U really focuses on um all of the school building and Capital Improvements um and that's where it is there is the ability to um purchase uh certain equipment and Technology with bond funds uh the technology I'm I'm sure you are aware uh has to be instructional technology um the bond funds can also be used for the hardware and the initial purchase of the

056operating system software uh not subsequent upgrades but it's the initial purchase and also to design and install you know the allowable technology um bond funds can be used to purchase buses uh we'll get into that a little bit later why that's important when we get to um syncing funds later um but the most important part of this slide is what bonds cannot be used for um and they cannot be used for automobiles trucks and vans uh any lease payments uh employee salaries uh and then repairs and maintenance um those are not allowable Bond expenditures so if we get over to syncing funds here again as on the the the screen uh the formatting got a little bit messed up but if you noticed we have uh we have two in blue and one in red

057um the one in red is really what we're focused on because is that is when you guys enacted your syncing fund so the syncing fund um prior to 2017 um had a uh you could have a a larger syncing fund Mills five years and go into 20 years um but starting in 2017 they expanded it to shorten up the amount of the size and the the length of the the syncing fund but they expanded it into allow for school uh security improvements and also the acquisition and upgrading of Technology um and then also um that was one expansion those two two items um your syncing fund which was enacted after August 5th 2003 now has the new further expanded syncing fund rules so now in addition to school security improvements and the acquisition and upgrading

058technology and the uh original real estate uh construction repair of school buildings you can now use uh your syncing funds to purchase student transportation vehicles or buses um it doesn't there you can't can buy other vehicles and buses provided that they are deemed a school transportation vehicle which is generally a vehicle that has a seating capacity of 11 11 or more um or uh excuse me yes 11 more more um to um including the the driver um you can also use it to buy parts supplies and equipment that would service those Transportation vehicles and then the the last one is basically what I call maintenance Vehicles your trucks and vans for your maintenance department and then the parts and supplies that go with there um at the end with syncing funds the big thing is

059what you also like I finished before is what you cannot use it for and you see the the bottom of each of those uh you cannot purchase equipment um um for with syncing funds unless it is dealing with the the buses and the maintenance Vehicles those exceptions um or furnishings and you can't use it for maintenance it only can be for repair of the school building it's putting something that's broken back into working order not preventative maintenance just question so and under that caveat we cannot use it for instance for purchasing of paint to paint within the district paint within a building after we've done some construction um part of the typically painting would be specified as part of the you know construction project that you're doing if you're just going to use it to

060just paint a wall that's already existing that would typically be preventative maintenance and things like desks and school Furniture not cannot be used for the sinking fund okay great thank thank you um so here I won't go through every line of this oh s we do have a question yep when you were speaking about the things that we can use bus I mean seeking funds for you said to purchase is it not leasing is it only to purchase buses right to purchase the buses okay but not lease bus um you could use a lease if it was a finance lease to where at the end of the lease you would own the bus okay so a finance lease is uh it's like a dollar out lease where you you basically are buying it on terms

061um so you could use a syncing fund if you were going to have ownership of the bus at the end of the lease a true lease where you were to just maybe pay monthly payments and then the buses go back after three years that wouldn't that wouldn't be acquiring the ownership of the vehicle okay I'm going to push it just a little bit when you said supplies does fuel is that considered Supply for buses um well that the Parts and Equipment is to maintain the vehicle the supplies to maintain the vehicles um fuel I will want to double check but it's I not to maintain the vehicle so I will but if we send it to get like an oil change that can be charged to sinking fund yeah yeah you're you're getting that but

062what is that just to be clear I don't want to nit that only if we are leasing to own can those charges be um used here or even if we're justly seen we can use these I just don't I don't want the vernacular to have a stumble in any way yeah so you can use it to you know to maintain the vehicles that you're acquiring um is the way the statute is drafted there has not been any that I've seen any explanation on the differentiation if you're leasing the bus and whether you then can use the sinking fund to buy the parts to maintain it here so we don't do it wrong y i I will definitely look into get the clarification on that and get it back to superintendent Perry anybody else trusty Bush

063so if I'm understanding this if we're leasing a bus are we still responsible for maintaining it and doing oil changes and things like that so is that what your question is is that this money sying fund money could be used for that type of maintenance of a leasee bus so I'm getting cat is here we do not pay for oil changes yeah that's what I was wondering most true leases if it's through the major leasing companies everything's included in the lease for the bus but to bring this down to bring this down to something simpler for my simple head so if I bought a car and I'm buying it over time with a loan like the school district buying a bus and I have to pay to maintain it we could use the sinking fund

064for that and for making payments on the bus okay yeah if it's like if you're going to own the bus at the end of the lease okay great thank you hang on one second K is there something that you wanted to say no okay I couldn't tell if you were had hand on chin or if you wanted our attention no you are fine anybody else okay let's move Ahad thank you Jeremy uh and then here's just a chart it sort of breaks down you know you can see on the left these are a list of a lot of the major uh different projects or uses that are often asked about for bond funds and syncing funds um so we won't go through all of them you can see there some of them are allowed under

065both Bond and syncing fund uh you'll see on the syncing fund column there's several uh red asterisks so those are would be yes but or a no but so there's conditions that go on them so as we get to those things we would definitely want to have conversations um because there are conditions that apply to whether or not you can or cannot use them um um in terms of different types of of purchases and depending what funds you're using so um that's just more of a a highlevel uh uh chart to to look at that sometimes is helpful and then lastly here um you know here is obviously there there are several um consequences for violating the law um the school code in general has um different penalties if you violate the bidding for construction

066and we talked about in our 1267 that's a little bit more stiff a penalty with 10% of the cost of the project and up to one year in jail um obviously if we get into prevailing wage we said we're aren't going to really apply to that but if if you do that does the new law really put some teeth into it it was much different than the old law where third parties can bring um that are affected the contractors third party beneficiaries they can bring uh lawsuits against the district if it was failed to have prevailing wage paid on a project um and then if you misuse your syncing fund dollars is the big thing here if you misuse your syncing fund dollars you have to repay the misused funds from the general fund and

067you lose your ability to Levy the sinking fund so that's sort of the big big whammy that you have to make sure you're paying attention to and this applies to all of us that are sitting up here we we take a note of office saying we are going to be fiduciary responsible so that'll to the seven of us as well we're not I was think I'm just the president and Treasurer myself so I think that that was just a quick CH so if we Mis and we're not going to but I I'm curious if you were to misuse the bond funds and you repay it back to the general or from your general fund um you said we lose the ability to l a sinking fund again is that forever um yeah well that well

068you said bond funds and syncing funds so the bond funds you have to repay it back there could also be penalties under your bonds that you have because they're taxes and bonds there could be penalties there but the syncing fund if you misuse your syncing fund dollars because I think this year will be your first sort of construction season of the new syncing funds if you misuse those you then have to pay them back the general fund and then you lose your sinking fund and that's forever yeah okay yeah so president holder justy bush is is this one of the reasons why it pays to have a professional management company and pay for them to manage the competitive bids and things like that so that it's done correctly rather than trying to require our finance

069director to go through and do all that I think that is definitely a best practice to have you know um you know a management company involved to to help out especially if there is that I've seen it both ways if you know the the business office is able to handle all of it but when you get into the construction there's lots of different approvals so to make sure everything is going I think it's definitely helpful so it it doesn't pay to be Pennywise and pound foolish in a situation like this not only from a financial perspective from the district but also for each individual here on the board and in our Administration I okay that's what I wanted to know thank you I will turn it over to plantar and they can continue the discussion

070work back thanks do you have the couple slides I saw yep oh thanks um so appreciate the opportunity to be here and um I'm Paul with plant Maran real point I don't know that I've been in front of the board hand for this what's that do we have handouts for this part uh yeah actually I have uh copies of get them up here to us we you left the floor always and forever so while Ron's passing those out just to uh mention real quick uh again I'm Paul with plant Maran real Point I've actually been working on the bond project since we started just mostly behind the scenes so a lot of meetings with Patricia uh and Ebony as well and the rest rest of administration uh and I know I met a few of

071you so appreciate the opportunity to be here tonight um just to reiterate a lot of what Jeremy said you know I've been uh working on school bonds for 30 years and there are times when I'm not sure what the law says and what it doesn't say and how to follow uh all the statutes and things and that's when I pick up the phone and call Clark Hill and call Jeremy just to make sure that we keep our clients out of trouble so don't feel like you have to be the experts on all this you have Patricia you have abon you have the administration you have uh us over at pland real point you have your attorneys to help make sure that all these eyes get dotted and tees get crossed and that we're good stewards

072collectively of all the Public's money which is really what this is all about and that we improve the schools as much as we can for the students and the teachers uh to make the best use of them so again we we thought it was a good idea to give an overview with a couple new board members on board and with the bond wrapping up and the sinking fund starting but don't feel like you have to have all this stuff memorized again I've been doing it for 30 years I don't have it all memorized all the time either so um we thought we'd just kind of give a quick overview you know in your role as the board um kind of what your role is in some of these projects um there's a lot of different

073things that go on uh I see I had some formatting issues too with ipdf but essentially you know there's a lot of things that go into the design from hiring The Architects to overseeing the whole design process having a construction manager in to do some estimating making sure that everything um is on budget making sure we follow all the right bidding procedures and all the different things that that go on with that um really your role as the board is pretty simple um and as we get into the syncing fund it'll become very repetitive kind of on an annual cycle we'll be coming in the spring to let you know uh who we need to hire to do all the design work so we'll be bringing those contract recommendations or amendments to you for your

074approval um we'll be letting you know what's going to come up in the next year of what the projects are that are going to be under designed and then what's going to be constructed and then once we actually bid the projects out we'll work with Administration to make sure that we uh put everything on Sigma and we make sure we advertise in the newspaper and do all those things to make sure we stay in good standing with the state um but really Your Role is really just to approve those contracts um and then at the end of the project we'll be back uh in the fall to let you know how construction went maybe show some before and after pictures let you know what happened and let you know how the budget fared in the

075schedule so really um a lot of the work that gets done is by the design professionals by the construction professionals um and you as the board uh do have a big important role to play but it's not quite as bad as it may seem so um so that's kind of how the design process works and then the second slide is really just kind of that contractor uh bid and award process and if you flip to the back slide it really kind of breaks it down of um really there's five major things and I kind of went through them but just to say it again it's to approve the professional service contracts for all the designers and Engineers The Architects to get the work underway in designing and then to approve the hard construction bids uh

076and any contingency dollars that'll be allocated if we had a very large change order let's say we tore into a roof and found a bunch of things we didn't know about we'd come back to you with that and ask for your approval on a change order that's over the threshold um and then periodically we'll be back with uh reports on how the progress is going um and how the Project's going in general compared to the schedule and the budget and then at the end really just reconciling the project out and and then kind of starting the next round of projects after that so and that's I guess what I wanted you to talk about uh this is all kind of need least I know the first year is uh what is on our our punch

077list so to speak to start with and then um from every year thereafter it what do we need to apply the money to correct yeah and what we've I think a year or two ago we actually helped do a facility assessment of all your buildings so what we would typically do is we would take that assessment sit down with administration because to your point there's always things that change or needs that arise and the way uh teachers teach and students learn things like that so uh we would usually put together a 10-year plan but really it's more like a rolling three-year plan where we know what we're designing this year or what we're actually I should say what we're designing for next year what we're constructing this year and then constantly reevaluating that because the

078nice thing about a sinking fund is it's for 10 years so that's a long period of time and as you said priorities change needs change we want to make sure that we reflect that so anybody else great thank you thank you thank you Mr Ron are you up next welcome thank you it's very good to be back so you guys know we kind of vetted him kind of hard yeah he looks it he looks it oh come on we we seriously gave you the the the Shakedown they put ringer a few times but it's been my pleasure yeah very I don't even know what word to use I apologize to him in the hall after it was a very emotional I did I apologize that well we did due diligence is what we have you

079the questions back yes they were hard questions but you did very very well and you exceeded expectations for sure thank you Mar does so I'm here for your actually your uh next agenda item which is for GMP number two to Brawn and this is for the bond this is not for the syncing fund this is for the for brawn so we bring before you this evening a recommendation to uh approve GMP number two to braon construction for the bond work for the summer of 2025 the way that this came about is that if you recall this is the 20 21 Bond we did Construction in 23 and through some very um detailed scope alignment yeah he's a addressing 8B yeah he's telling us about it so we can vote on it when we to that

080point okay yes that's what I need to know thank you yes thank you so through um some very astute scope refinement and uh going out and finding really good Market rates for our Professional Services we were able to bring the entire construction project in with a savings of approximately $886,000 at the end so you have that much money to spend we got together with the district we sat with the administration and we came up with a new scope that scope is the 2025 year that scope consists primarily of flooring at the high school and it also is a portion of work at Wilkinson or Roofing at wison so those are the two things that we're asking for in the GMP now the GMP is going to going to Brawn and again the GMP is for

081a total to Brawn of $772,500 on top of that we are recommending a 5% owners contingency of 38,600 for a total GMP of $811,000 65 excuse me president holder just just for those of us like me who don't know please define GMP GMP is a guaranteed maximum price oh GMP GMP okay thank you um so we as outlined by Clark Hill we engaged an architect designed it put it out to bid received bids opened them publicly read them out loud we had post bid interviews to them to find the uh um lowest qualified biders once satisfied we put together our package and that is what is before you today it that's all you have that's okay I have a question uh I will let the superintendent go first I just want to bring everyone up

082to speed because we have some board members that were not here last year or when we did the construction project so um we received a bond and the bond was specific to just Safety and Security at the high school and roofing repair at all the other buildings so I know you you guys are thinking like well why are you guys just doing the flooring at the high school because of the bond funds we only can spend it for Safety and Security at the high school we completed the projects at the high school um we redid the HVAC system the boiler room so on and so forth then by us working with plantar in real point we were able to save the $800,000 but by that money also being in the account we also earned interest

083on the money so now we're in our next phase of what should we do next to stay in the parameter of the bond and based off of the parameters of the bond and the facil facility analysis the next thing that we can do is repair the floors at the high school and the roofing at Wilkinson Middle School and I know the next question is well why won't you guys just repair the whole roof at Wilkinson Middle School well according to the facility analysis the roofing at the middle school parts of it still had a longer lifespan and I can't remember if it was beyond like 10 years or something like that it was approximately 10 years and it wasn't just us taking a look at it we actually took core samples we sent them out

084we had uh analysis at a lab we had professional uh Roofing analysis um and Consultants come in and give us these evaluations so this is backed up with uh hard science so tonight the Brun construction firm is asking for approval to start the work and continue the work work at the high school with the remaining bond funds I hope that was clear trusty Bush so when I was coming in I noticed that the carpeting is loose at the front door there which can create a trip Hazard is that the kind of thing that's going to be taken care of or is it just like replacing the carpeting in here what do you mean by flooring so what we are doing is because we don't have a tremendous amount of money we focused on the student

085spaces so we're uh primarily primarily looking at classrooms corridors we've got some office in there as well um this carpet is not in there and so you you've got a mothballed area which is not in there either front door there the front door well not the front front door but the door where we come in oh yes that is part of it too that Scopes in there as well okay I just happen to see that coming in so I'm like timely yeah okay I'm done we're replacing it we're not repairing or fixing it I was going to ask anybody else you'll be back so oh I W I do remember sorry um so a lot some of this is going to take place the bond reparations um before that April 1 deadline it it has

086something something to do remind me again for clarity that April 1st changing of the design in the in the construction manager um we've been working with the the two of you very well I don't know that there would be a reason are you talking about the 85% no did that yeah so I just want to be clear yeah the design build law that's completely optional you don't have to change anything what you're doing right now it's a new Option I probably should have been a little more clear that is completely optional that you could pursue if a project fit nicely into that delivery model but you don't have to change anything that you're doing right now you can just continue on as you currently have and continue this process um so the board would have

087to make a motion not to or we would just ignore it for Content okay I just didn't want to do it wrong and have a problem April 2 yeah okay anybody else good all righty thank you sir I know we'll be seeing you soon you'll see me for the next item too oh okay go ahead were you going to vote on the um actually it's later on so go ahead and give us the background okay so this is the next item on the agenda which is the plant Moran real Point amendment number three and this amendment is for plant Moran real point to handle your 10year syncing fund it is item um 8 C so just like we provided guidance for the bond program we'll be providing guidance for the 10e syncing fund we won't

088be engaged for the full 10 years we're just taking the first three years at a time so it's it's it's not 10 years it's three should you can should you decide we would love to St on and help you for the other but right now we think our best value is just that upfront first three anybody else all righty I think those are the two that pertain to you yeah I know we have to go into close session president holder trusty Bush um so were you planning on waiting around for our decision or is that something that you can go ahead and go and they'll notify you tomorrow I would love to know what you are thinking this evening if I could yeah that's that's going to be a while that's the thing so okay

089unless we get a motion from one of the board members to move I would make that motion um 8 B and C to um 5B I would make the motion to move 8 a sorry 5 a I would make the motion to make 8 B and C uh move it up to under 5A second that 5 A and B and a discussion so we are only voting to move it up on the agenda right now we are not voting for the motion one way or the other that was eight okay roll call vote please April anelo yes Mary Bush yes Rebecca shambles yes Cindy holder yes Mark Kimble yes chera McAlpine Taylor yes Gloria Thompson yes motion pass okay um is so that would make the study session 5B instead of five and now we

090can address the um 5B approval of the Brun guaranteed maximum price amendment number two Madison District Public Schools there's requesting approval for the Brun guaranteed maximum price amendment number two this amendment will provide continued support for bronze leadership in managing and overseeing the summer projects funded through the 21 Bond these projects are essential to enhancing District facilities ensuring safe and modern learning environments for students and maintaining the Integrity of our infrastructure approval of this amendment will allow Brawn to effectively coordinate construction efforts atere to project timelines and maintain cost efficiency while delivering high quality improvements across the district this amendment includes the replacement of Select flooring areas at Madison High School including student spaces and Coors as well as a portion of the roofing at Wilkinson Middle School these projects were identified as priorities in

091the facility assessment conducted in December 2023 it is recommended the Board of Education approve the Brun guaranteed maximum price amendment number two to support the successful completion of the district summer projects funded by the 21 Bond I need a maker and support Madam president trustee Thompson I'd like to make a motion that the Board of Education approve the braon guaranteed maximum price or GMP amendment number two to support the successful completion of the district summer projects funded by the 2021 Bond thank you do we have support all support trusty Chambler support any discussion seeing none roll call vote please R anelo yes Mary Bush yes Rebecca shamas yes Cindy holder yes Mark Kimble yes chera McAlpine Taylor yes Gloria Thompson yes motion pass next up is um what is 8C under 5A uh approval of

092plant Moran Road Point change order medicon District Public Schools is requesting approval for the plant Maran real Point change order this change order reflects ongoing work related to the projects funded by the 21 Bond as well as future projects associated with the November 24 sinking fund in addition to the continuation of essential Project work plant Maran real point will play a key in safeguarding the district's financial interest The Firm will ensure that all Financial Obligations associated with both the 21 Bond and the 24 sinking fund are met in accordance with the contractual requirements and regul atory standards their expertise will help mitigate risks and guarantee the district remains fully compliant with all funding guidelines allowing us to maximize the impact of these critical investments in our facility it is recommended the Board of Education approve

093the plant Moran rail Point change order I need a maker and support please presid holder TR de Bush I make the motion that the Board of Education approve the plant morand real PR real Point change order I support trusty Cher supports any discussion none roll call vote please April anelo andelo yes Marie Bush yes Rebecca shambles yes Cindy holder yes Mark Kimble yes chera Mel Pine Taylor yes Loria Thompson yes motion passed congratulations sir I want to say thank you to the board and I want to say thank you for being considerate and moving our items up on the agenda that was very good of you thank you very much and I want to say Welcome to our two newest members thank you very much nice to meeting you around thank you okay with that

094study session sinking fund versus bond funding in MD no that was our study session sorry close session to will review attorney client privilege communication sections 8 B of the open meetings act I get so many notes I can't read my agenda anymore I apologize so we need a maker in support please president holder yes I make a motion that we go into to close uh session to review attorney client privileged communication SE section 8h of the open meetings Act support trusty Thompson support any discussion seeing none roll call vote please April anelo Ando Ando Ando yes Mary Bush yes Rebecca chamblas yes Cindy holder yes Mark Kimble yes CH chera Mel Pine Taylor yes Gloria Thompson yes motion passed all right it is 7:30 e e e we only have eight e e e let's

095do the um fiscal year 2425 budget amendment number one presentation and with that trust us Finance director Ebony Ebony Thompson you go you have the floor that's your last name thank you good evening I'll be presenting the fiscal year 25 budget amendment one for the general fund not yet okay okay this first slide is um this is the executive summary which Compares fiscal year 24 actual costs the original fiscal year 25 budget and the fiscal year 25 amendment in the last column highlights the variance from the original budget to the amendment budget so our beginning fund balance for the original budget is 1 million4 um our original B budget revenues are 16.78% but our Amendment one revenues are 18 point about 18.1 01 so our revenues were estimate will increase 1 point 1.23 million um

096that's due to State local and federal funding estimates for fiscal year 25 so our expenditures original budget was 17 um 17.46% ever our expenditures for Amendment one increased to 19.02 million this is due to some fiscal year 24 invoices paid against our fisc year 25 budget um and that's due to uh when we got the invoices probably in July and August September we weren't able to apply it back to the to the last fiscal year and then also we've receive some invoices later on in the in the year or in the fall so we had to apply those back to or we had to apply those to this fiscal year because it was too late for us to apply it back to the last fiscal year um so our operating Surplus uh negative 688,000 was

097our budgeted one but then with the additional expenditures we're at 1.01 million so that kind of that did impact our fund balance tremendously leaving us with um 73,000 estimated well original budget to now 389,000 so that leaves us 4.1% from 4.1% revenues to now a 2.2% revenue so we did see a decrease in our fund balance however um we're going to go back look through our budget to see what we can apply to the sing fund to relieve our um general fund next slide is just some of our revenues and expenditures from this year just comparison from last year and this year our section 31a at risk fun at risk Grant we received 978,000 last year this year we did get a increase of 105,000 um so we're using that that fund to cover salaries

098and benefits um for some of our staff next we have our 31n Mental Health Services and supports Grant This was um Grant through Oakland schools last year we got 128,000 this year we got 411,000 and this this grant is being used as uh for contracted social worker PT OT and um and licensed professional counselor and then also additional funding to provide mental health and mental health supplies and materials we have a new Grant Title One Regional assistant Grant this is at our Madison Elementary School so this year this new Grant provided 39,000 in funding which are going to which we use towards PD tutoring um math and scence math and reading material so that helps out the general budget as well our Metro program started this year um new program new startup program this year

099we get 50% funding back from Oakland schools so 136,000 we should receive the end of this year property tax we have a estimated increase of 228,000 um that's based on what estimate will we receive by by June and then now we have the loss of Grants to 310 mental health we lost 280,000 because it's not offered this year our 31aa mental health student safety Grant it was decreased this year by 999,000 and then our loss of sther 3 which is 1.3 million any question ask I have one quick one yes so the um tax ta es is that part of our sinking fund no this is a property taxes yeah that we get from the city pres holder truste yes hi um what is sr3 sr3 is the co Grant so yeah the C Grant

100so okay we had until 9:30 of this year to use all the funds so that was already allocated all right thank you trust CH when Crystal and I first came on the board we were given this like sheet that broke down like Esser and all the different like financing things do you have that I can get one for you just so we could give the new trustees to help them understand the budget it was Lifesaver yep okay yep I'll have one for you I can have it for you this week okay that'll make it it makes it so easy just email it to all of us okay yeah I used to have to get all the the I did ask and and it was provided all the breakdowns so you knew which building and what

101group it was going to cuz otherwise when you look at it it's like yeah yeah what you would asked for was real helpful only I can't quite get it on my screen and I can't print with my computer yet so we're working on that though okay Miss Perry and I are working on it all right thank you oh you have the um the accounts in your packet of the um all the Y okay okay thank you us go home my son is do here's our student enrollment a little revenues and expenditures let's continue I press the wrong button I'm sorry I think I pressed one of those the can just read our packs ebony were you going to go over any of the rest of this she's trying I just shut the screen off by

102accident okay so revenues and expenditures for fisc year 25 so this is um side by side comparison so most of our Revenue this year came from the state that include like all our the state aid our categorical grants um go back to this one which includes uh suar grants the 22A proposal bilingual education robotics section 99h are at risk Grant and um gr GS RP so that equals about 11.9 million that we received from the state so grants are very important to this District so we make sure that we apply to all of them as much as we can and then when it come up for us to be amend amended we can get more funding for it so we make sure we're Patricia and I are pretty much on uh Nexus trying to uh

103fill our applications to get more funding uh our other Revenue come from local which is our property taxes ear needs on investments our facilities rental income and then our DHS Learning Tree income and then also our athletic so that equates about 3.6 million we receive 4% Federal funding which is our Medicaid our title funds one through four and our Ida our special education um funding and then um that's for 782,000 then 9 % other which is our pa18 Oakland County Special Education tax and then our indirect cost and that's about 1.6 million our expenses so 75% of this year um is salaries and benefits and then the other 16% is purchase Services uh vendor contracts and things of that nature 4% supplies a capital outlay 1% and then 4% other which includes District dues and

104District dues and fees are um the high school Casa tuition payments special education tuition payments but this also included 125,000 that we had to apply to this year which was last year expenses so that's kind of inflated our expenses for this year our student enrollment I just want to do a uh a chart just to so you can get a visual of where we were about 10 years ago and then where we are now um of course prior to 2019 or 2020 you know our enrollment was higher then Co hit and our enrollment dropped but we're trying to get it back up where we did have an increase in enrollment this year or 60 to 60 students and that was probably due to the summer Discovery program so with that being repeated this summer hopefully

105we're going to get more students for next year so in that way we can increase our per pupil funding with the state yes I just want to make a comment that our enrollment dropped so much from those years because of the dropping of the source program it wasn't because of invisible yeah it wasn't because of Co invisible students yeah that that too yeah yeah well that's the main force behind it okay we dropped over 500 FTE okay yeah that definitely impacted our enrollment but we're we're trying to increase our rment for next year so we can move up um so the next slide is our budget challenges um start over again as you can see in our budget we did have a significant loss of state and federal funding compared to previous years because of

106Grants not being offered anymore excluding not just the Ester Grant but other grants that we had last year just um we did not get this year or they were not renewed um later on this month we have the governor's uh budget proposal so we're going to see if the per pup funding is going to be increased or not um hopefully and then that will impact our budget for next year with the state aid um and then also we got a where impact on federal funding for next year is is kind of unknown because of what's going on in the in the in the world right now so tomorrow I'll be attending a webinar to talk about the Federal Federal funding so so I should get more information tomorrow um enrollment Trends we have declining student

107enrollment which reduces funding which is tied to our student count so we're hopefully going to have more students next year so we're working on ways where we can um uh make it more attractive for the parents to enroll their students in Madison District um seeing if we have some recruitment retention Strate strategies promote programs and also increasing family engagement this year we also had an increase in healthcare and benefit costs we had a 3% increase um that hit us in January so we had to take that in consideration with the budget um and that's with us uh going through different um Healthcare companies we did we did uh compare the costs um inflation is also hitting everybody Nationwide supplies and are going up we have to make sure we get multiple quotes with vendors even

108though some vendors we may have used for years it's it's time for us to like get get get quotes and go through our um go through Oakland schools uh purchasing cooperatives such as open schools and my deal and then um just making sure that we're we're communic communicating that throughout our throughout the department to make sure that this is important that we get multiple qus so that we can get the best cost for our product and services um Union negotiations we have some coming up with the teachers union then this is is some more contracts that that are expiring this fiscal year so we have to keep that in consideration with our budget and see what we can do there and plan for next year um and then our infrastructure needs are which is the

109sinking fund CL came in to help so I want to thank the community for letting this past because it's going to help our district with our maintenance needs and our well maintenance and and um repairs and improvements throughout the district and then we're working with plant Moran and also getting legal advice to make sure that we're using these funds properly you have any questions good job thank you make a motion we're done with this yes yes perfect trustee um chamblis thank you do you want me to read the motion to begin with or do you want to do it no you can do it okay I'm just trying to help I you're yes I did a question oh okay I'm sorry I thought I heard [Music] somebody 66 so we're going to do the budget

110amend now thank you sorry you're fine uh approval of the 2425 budget amendment number one Madison District public schools to seeking approval for the 2425 budget amendment number one this amendment incorporates adjustments to revenues and expenditures fees based on actual Financial changes prior gear spending Trends and projections for the future District needs the revised budget ensures fiscal responsibility while aligning resources to support student learning District Operations and strategic priorities it has recommended the Board of Education approve the 2425 budget amendment number one I need a maker and support please president holder trusty Chamas I make a motion that the Board of Education approves the 2425 budget amendment number one I'll second trusty Bush support any discussion none roll call vote please April and Selmo yes Mary Bush yes Rebecca chamblas yes Cindy holder yes Mark

111Kimble yes chera McAlpine Taylor yes Gloria Thompson yes motion pass next up is committee reports GRC did we do that would be me Miss Miss Bush um trusty Bush go ahead so a couple of things right now we are um in somewhat of an a political upheaval when it comes to Federal funding um everything for federal funding was frozen but then there was a lawsuit so Medicaid funding should still be good for the school district for OT and PT and things like that when we attended the uh the Oakland County school board meeting we talked about uh things are a little fuzzy there were things were issued but not sure how procedures we're going to go the state uh there's some things that are being voted on and the governor signed some stuff but there's

112some stuff that wasn't signed and there so it's got to go back to see if it's signed so there's just a lot of that kind of stuff going on on right now um I've been reading the executive orders from the White House and one of the things that came down is the um elimination of all federal funding um ex let me rephrase that uh elimination of federal uh association with programs related to Dei and um specifically for uh the verbiage related to trans gender as it applies to the school districts so I'm sure at some particular point you know that'll be addressed but as of right now we're doing everything that we need to do based on what I saw in the white house um executive order the the last thing was the uh September

11317th I think it is we are now obligated to have a patriot education day in the school district per executive order so on the 17th there will be um the school districts are supposed to work out something where they have civic education information about patriotism and and things like that so is that going to be every year yes for right now under the executive order as it stands I will do a better uh job of more detail as things get fleshed out in both the state and local tget so yep federal and state par and rep I have nothing for that thank you a Jer C okay so it is February's so um it is African-American history month and the H also is doing Lunar New Year events um in Madison Heights if you go

114onto their Facebook page they have a whole list of all the events that are happening from January 29th all the way to February 12th um and they're working with um people in our community that celebrate Lunar New Year um and the Asian media DC R TV um which is based in Madison Heights so um just go to the human relations and Equity commission page on Facebook and you can see all the activities but it looks like a lot of fun um I wanted to add our city school on is very um spontaneous we don't we don't meet often sometimes we don't meet for years um however um I know myself trusty bush and trusty harp were on that now obviously trusty harp is gone and trusty bush had said thank you but no thank you

115she was busy with a lot of other things I was an alternate I was an alternate so I didn't know if anybody else other than myself was interested in sitting on the city schoon I'm sorry I was telling chero would be good for her and I said why oh I'm not entirely sure what it is so that I think that's the issue it actually is exactly kind of what it is if the city and the school have problems that we try to resolve together or maybe get the community involved as a group um that's why it doesn't meet it's not an emergency group it is um and it's not often I don't like whenever it's needed yeah if something comes up that needs to be addressed ad hoc kind of thing yes so for instance

116um would the city school Leons have been involved uh with the idea of using the city for gasoline purchases and seeing if that can be worked out could or could it be but our superintendent handled that what about like having a public based so what about like having a a um recruitment display at the juneth or any of the other school um School promotion at City events like the um when Santa Claus came in and stuff like that I know most of the last time and you were there trusty Bush we were talking about there was a problem with like Crossing safety y that was the issue schools those kind of back and forth how can we resolve it of course those things take money time and we got money we got money for that

117so it's more those kind of problem solving it's easy um you can yes TR uh Patricia oh I was just going to add it was kind of it's just kind of like an opportunity for Madison to come together with the city as well as lere whenever an issue comes up that they need both school districts to give an input then they will say hey we have this meeting taking place on can you attend it's not a regularly scheduled meeting it just happens sometimes okay perfect congratulations CHR is going to to help us and then um it was suggested that we have a finance um super deep committee whatever they call TK force and um we have three City members on our finance committee currently so can you decide what you need for this to look

118like as far as Union Representatives um admin and let us know how you want that to look yeah so what I thinking what can happen is that I can have the task force and I can report back to the to the board on our Wednesday meeting um but I think for the task force I was just going to invite all union leaders as well as administrators and if they cannot attend each Union president then offer it to someone that may be their fi their Treasurer some so on and so for I actually was going to send out an email tonight and then if you need or want um representation from the board for our input or ideas you'll let us know I'll bring it back to the window thank you okay just for clarity board

119comment oh trusty Bush yeah I I think it would be good for us to do a finance committee report since we did meet since our last board meeting go ahead and um it was Cindy Gloria and myself and I took copious notes and left them at home so the one thing that I do remember that we talked about was the uh standard operating procedures that Ebony and Miss Perry have put together so that we now have a regulated system of managing the finances within our district including things like uh request for bids purchase orders uh use of the credit cards all things like that that uh it's going very well and then that is what we accomplished we did however also encourage Miss Perry to stop using a personal credit card and requesting reimbursements but

120rather to use a school resource that was the finance committee Report with that we have board comment just D Thompson congratulations to all the staff members and students who got Awards tonight and that'll do it it's just been a long meeting let's close this down trustee chamblas um congratulations to all the students and staff that received Awards tonight um I just wanted to say the robotics team was given a very uh amazing Grant they received $10,000 so they're able to get 3D printers and start doing things so they created this giant whale for me and um they're doing just our robotics team has gone so far from where they started just two years ago so I just want to say great job they have a competition coming up um at the end of February at

121Troy Athens tomorrow student council is doing a bake sale to raise funds at um the basketball game um Miss Smiley is running that with the CH or the kids from student council um and they're going to be selling a wide assortment of goodies so if you're able to stop by and just run in and grab something and help the student council out if the money for these things go to things like their their Proms and their homecomings and things like that um and their teacher sponsors handle it so other than that thank you and have a good night trusty Bush um I just want to congratulate the students and the employees who were recognized for their outstanding achievements with our scope uh goals and orientation as we keep getting 1% better every day and yes

122it's been late so I'm going to shut up thank you that sound that was very sincere yeah it was very genuine she like the floor thank you so I just want to reiterate um the employees of the month uh Miss patrio I think Miss Curtis Miss lorell and Mr Perez that they were amazing also our students little Harmony who mastered her letters and sounds and had the cutest little star shirt you've ever seen um ax who's very inquisitive Michael whose ability to build things and has um greets his teacher daily he was adorable Lucas with his positive attitude and kindness um D'Angelo who leads with Grace and kindness Jocelyn with her self motivation Esme whose creativeness and all her AP classes good gracious and um tamari and who's helpful and seeks an opportunity to grow

123I just wanted to say their names one more time to show how incredibly proud we are of them good idea trusty April anmo Elmo Ando get it you got itmo vacuum cleaners please and Selmo vacuum cleaners Selmo the floor is yours congratulations to all the students in the staff they got their Awards and yeah it was a good thing I like to see the uh the student is getting the awards and the um emphasis on their uh on their learning and education I really appreciate that as a former substitute teacher trained as a teacher but you know but that's I like to see that education Kimble uh congratulations to students of the month employees of the month and uh I'll be looking forward to this meeting ending I second that I second that I'm going

124to get on the podium no um I I just want to say honest and truly uh thank you to all the recipients thank you to our fellow board members I know some days it looks like we're in a boat that's in a very hard Waters we really are trying to get to resolution I truly believe that um I don't think there's anybody sitting here that doesn't have um um a honest and true vision of how we get things better but when you have seven different Minds sometimes it's it's a little it's it's a little yeah consensus I I truly truly truly with all my heart feel that we are all trying to work in the same direction and we're going to have to get over these little bumps and we're going to have to move

125on so that's all I have to say it is 9 50 can we have the last motion president holder I'll make a motion I'll second to adjourn all in favor all oppos look at that trusty Thompson at the end okay N9 see that again uh 51 good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.