CorpusRecord 54048

WLCSD Board of Education Meeting - December 5, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WalledLkSchools
Date
2024-12-06
Location
Oakland County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
24,302 words · about 136 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e we're going to call the meeting to order if we could please rise for the pledge of allegiance goed of aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you we're going to move on to our golden apple Awards Dr lws thank you very much and I will turn over to Mr scaling yes our first golden apple tonight is uh Sarah Greer Sarah if you could come on up [Applause] tonight's first golden apple recipient is Sarah GRE medical support pair professional at Wald Lake Elementary Sarah was nominated by Alysa labut first grade teacher at Wald Lake L because Sarah embodies the essence of dedication and support in every aspect of her work

002her interactions with students go beyond just assistance she Fosters genuine connections offers unwavering support and encouragement to each child she encounters her willingness to assist everyone from students to teachers grappling with classrooms challenges exemplifies her dedication to the school Community Sarah doesn't wait to be asked for help or to do something she takes the initiative within the classroom whether it's helping students do their best learning creating innovative ways for the classroom to run smoothly or helping to Foster positive learning environments Sarah takes it upon herself to engage in continuous learning Endeavors aimed at enhancing her ability to support and connect with students effectively Sarah's proactive approach demonstrates her innate self motivation as she consistently seeks out opportunities to improve and Excel in her role thank you Sarah for your dedication and support to the students

003and staff of Wal Lake L it's an honor to recognize you this evening hello working so I just want to say thank you so much to to Alysa and everybody at wake Elementary and that's helped me kind of find my way in my role and I am so honored today to get this and very humbled and I just want to say thank you so much so now my pleasure to turn over to Mrs quy yeah thank you Dr Lans our uh last but not least Golden Apple award winner is Brian blackney from W Lake Western High School come on up Brian there we go it's exciting almost as exciting as a lions and Packers match up at 8 o'clock tonight so all right tonight's Golden Apple award recipient in front of you is Brian blackney

004social studies teacher at Wald Lake western Brian was nominated by Terry sh I wlike Western parent because Brian is not only knowledgeable about his subject matter but he's also able to engage and Inspire students and I've witnessed this firsthand in his classroom at the high school level where students are often disengaged and unmotivated a history teacher who can make the Past come alive is a true asset Brian is not your typical history teacher his passion for history is evident in every lesson that he teaches and his enthusiasm is contagious he has a unique way of making even the most mundane historical facts come alive he uses interactive activities multiple presentation formats and real world examples to engage his students from time to time he can even be found wearing a pirate costume talking like a

005pirate and even using the harmonica to help history come alive for students uh Brian will let you perform for us later outside in the uh front uh he encourages critical thinking and Analysis challenging his students to think beyond the textbook and truly engages students respecting them for their opinions Brian's dedication to his students goes well beyond the classroom he helps students with their assignments encourages them when they're having a rough day offers guidance and support Brian takes the time to get to know each student individually understanding their strengths their weaknesses their interests and instructs them according to their needs patience and empathy are two additional qualities Brian possesses he remains calm and offers an empathetic ear during a students heightened level of emotions he shows kindness towards his students helping them build lasting connections with

006him and earning their trust the students feel comfortable being themselves encouraging them to be more active and participate in class Brian's a great role model for his students he demonstrates the importance uh the important value pardon me of hard work dedication and resilience he has a positive way of influencing students attitudes and beliefs Brian's not only a teacher but a mentor a role model and a supporter Brian thank you thank you for your dedication for your passion for your commitment to the students and we will miss you when you retire in January we wish you the best of luck on your new adventure and please come visit us it is our honor to recognize you tonight well uh I can say I all that I can say thank you ABS absolutely um wise man once

007said that uh you don't do anything on your own you often stand on the shoulders of giants and uh I thank you for the support of the board I thank you for the support of great administrators like Mr hamka great parents like shimansky and you know it it it it does take a village and I'm very thankful for my ability to serve this community for the years that I have and I just love the people here and I I will miss all of you thank you so much thank you and congratulations um before we move on I'm just going to welcome our two new board members to the table I will do it formally in board commentary but welcome Miss West and Mr Smith and we're going to move on to our textbook recommendation Dr

008L thank you madam president Mrs kensy thank you Dr Lance uh the current anatomy and physiology textbook and materials are now over 25 years old and the textbook no longer aligns with current science practices and standards So based on the results of the examination of available products it is the committee's recommendation to adopt Essentials of human anatomy and physiology Pearson 2022 which includes a textbook and online support the cost will not exceed $30,000 and includes student additions all teacher support materials online access technology and sh shpping the process has been endorsed by Administration and a motion for approval of the textbook adoption will be presented at the January 9th 2025 meeting thank you thank you Bond update Dr LS thank you very much it's my pleasure to introduce Mr Kevin Donnelly he's from plant brand

009real Point as community may remember at the beginning of the school year we engaged with plantman real Point as an owner's rep I've enjoyed working with them very much so far they've been an incredible asset to not only myself but to the district periodically throughout the school year miss johnley or someone from his team will be here to update the community about our bonds and where we are in the construction process and spending of the bonds he also had an opportunity to meet previously with the board subcommittee and that's part of the the commitment that we made as we entered into our agreement so Mr dling thank you Dr Lon uh happy to be here tonight and thank you for putting your confidence in plant Maran real point this is my uh first opportunity to

010present to the board looking forward to uh many future updates and presentations um tonight I'd like to cover NOP uh just some introductions uh of our team and who's going to be involved with the program uh a high level overview of our scope of services and what we're engaged to perform um related to the 19 and 24 Bond program uh a 90day action plan we uh we were hired I think late late August early September so we've been roughly working behind the scenes now for 90 days uh an update on Professional Services related to the bond uh then a bond update um for the projects that we wrapped up last summer and future projects to come in 2025 leaving a few minutes for any questions that the board may have I will be your um

011day-to-day Point person related to the bond program I think many of you know Mr Wills who will be presenting later tonight um he's done a lot of The Upfront work with closely with the district um Paul will be uh the partner in charge um I have a lot of support behind the scenes we do have some other folks that will be day-to-day working um alongside myself uh Lisa pit who hopefully you'll get a chance to meet here um in one of the upcoming meetings and we have a robust staff behind the scenes um handling a lot of the finances for the bond the project cost accounting and then any other um needs throughout the bond program we have folks that'll be coming in and out um to help support our group just a high level

012overview of of our services um coming in with the 19 program active we're kind of serving many roles right now um wrapping up the 19 program and kicking off the 24 program um right off the get-go one of one of my challenges and one of my tasks was to to validate all the details of what we're going to be doing in the 24 program so program validation and team assembly are really two key components that we're working on right now related to the 24 program and then as we're wrapping up uh the 19 program we're actively involved in design oversight construction oversight and close out of active projects in that same kind of sequence of our role at a high level will be uh will be the same for 2024 one of the things that

013that we're going to be implementing with the 24 Bond program that I don't believe the district has had to luxury to do in the past is we're going to have a what a pmis system stands for is a project management integration system uh we use a platform called e-builder that we're currently using in in 35 districts to help them manage their their programs and what e-builder is it's a realtime system that we predominantly use for cost control um and compliance management related to the bond so working closely with Julie and her team they'll have real-time information updated information related to budgets Finance Billings change orders everything related to the bond program will be at our fingertips um in the project team down the line um a construction uh TMP they'll also have um accessibility to

014that so all the players are really working from the same menu um it also provides a lot of um checks and balances and we can provide any type of customized reports for Julie and her team um as we move forward so we feel that this is going to be a a huge asset to the bond program moving forward uh one of the things that we want to pride ourselves on moving forward is just communicating U not only to day and day stakeholders but to the overall community and the constituents who have put their trust in um not only our organization but the entire project team um we're going to be coming to the board uh at least three or four times a year giving updates similar to what we're doing tonight uh we'll be working

015behind the scenes with Dr LW and his team giving monthly updates uh we'll be doing quarterly if not even more frequent Financial reconciliations on where we stand with the bond finances to make sure that everybody is talking from the same page related to the money um and then we'll provide provide quarterly dashboards as well um not only as part of our presentations moving forward but directly to um the finance and operations group uh we will work closely with Communications to make sure that the community um through the whole course of the bond program is up to date and they're getting real information and updates not only on what we're doing but what's yet to come um so we we want to make sure that we're we're reaching out to the community and utilizing the website

016to communicate so what has plant Mar and real Point been working on the last 90 days well at least from my perspective um just getting my arms around what we're doing uh being new to the program a lot of documents to review a lot of information to compile so I've been digesting a lot of that um over the last 90 days getting up to speed uh developing our our project management plan for the 24 program we've been having I just I kind of came in feet to the fire immediately um but we've been having regular meetings with Dr Lon um on a bi-weekly basis and in administration and then the extended project team um on a bi-weekly basis as well with with the uh with a and TMP uh working on Communications plans um part

017of what we're doing is communicating tonight so what is our communication plan moving forward and and how frequent and and what types of of mediums are we going to use to communicate and just figur getting getting my s uh acclimated to all the district buildings on the Finance and Accounting side I I mentioned e-builder earlier that is going to be uh the platform that we're going to utilize for the 24 program so getting budgets entered getting um governance um developed getting procedures and workflows developed on who's doing what um we'll talk a little bit further but identifying any design Prime opportunities and what design Prime is it's an owner direct approach for reent which we can talk a little bit about here in a moment uh and and setting up the cash flow for the

018for the uh four series Bond that's that's uh we've already sold series one but just setting up the overall cash flow for the program uh schedule and budget uh develop refine and coordinate the 24 program with the team we're going to be looking at that a little further in the presentation but um that schedule would be pretty fluid um we might make some modifications along the way but we have a pretty good game plan mov forward develop uh and update the budgets related to the 24 program as well and uh set up the e-builder budgets um in the systems Professional Services outside of plant Moran real Point there's there's obviously an extended team that that is required to execute the bonds um we've been working behind the scenes with District legal and administration and you'll

019be seeing it a little bit later in tonight's agenda um to get the architect on board for the 24 program we will be bringing forward in January a recommendation for construction management services and then in addition to that we've identified roughly a half a dozen other Professional Services that will be needed uh in that you know Geotech survey environmental security consultant and and testing um for the construction work so we are working right now on rfps that will be bringing Rec commendations forward in the coming months uh one of the things that we we feel that we're going to be able to provide and show to the district is a return on on the investment and plant we and real Point um there's a lot of different ways we feel that we can provide value

020um one of them is cost escalation avoidance we all know how the market has been and how the economy has gone the last four years if we're able collectively with the team just by one example to cut off six months to a year of the bond program which isn't unheard of that could mitigate an entire years of escalation an entire year of um fees from other Consultants so there's some real potential and savings there uh design approach I did mention the term design Prime and what that essentially means is if there is work in the bond program that is not necessarily very complex to give you an example Roofing projects parking lot projects we don't need to go through all the layers of Consultants which have fees to execute the work we can go directly

021to by example a roofing designer a civil engineer and cut the layer of of the main architect out and then go right to the contractor versus the CM um that could potentially save 6 to 8% maybe sometimes 10% and if there's 10 to 20 million in the program that adds to some real savings in that procurement approach so we're working closely with the team behind the scenes to identify what projects might be eligible for that and good candidates um procurement approach um we'll talk a little bit about that here in a moment but just negotiating with the other Consultants fair and reasonable market conditions um we'll provide an example here in a moment uh we feel pretty um we feel pretty good about where we arrived with TMP and the architect just holding the team

022accountable to the current market market conditions the appropriate terms and conditions um and and we'll see here in a moment that's realized some real savings and just quality review my background U I've been in construction management and program management close to 30 years um a lot of which was on the construction management side so I I I I do have a a pretty good background in in construction but just being that extra set of eyes and ears uh with the district and at the table um with the extended team will'll provide value obviously we're going to be part of all the design oversight just day-to-day with construction and just working closely with the team with with another extension of the district um again we're going to be bringing forward a recommendation of Dr Lon is

023here later tonight um we have gone through um and negotiated the terms with PMP on on their contract we're bringing a recommendation forward tonight um contingent upon legal review but we're going to be generating the contract um probably just before and after the holiday um we arrived at a a fixed number to start out with at 11.7 million the budget U that's in the PQ application is 15.4 so right off the get-go we've we've realized a savings of roughly 3.6 for that particular um Professional Service I had mentioned earlier that we are um negotiating similar um terms and conditions with the construction manager that we'll bring forward here in January and then there will be other required Professional Services as I had mentioned that we'll be bringing forward probably February March April time frame and

024that's with Geotech survey building commissioning potentially a security consultant testing and then any direct um Design Services that we might um apply to design Prim work so the pretty pictures the exciting things and and the real fruit of everyone's labor is the actual work that gets done um some of the projects that have been completed over the past year uh we did team buildings at all of the high schools this one is W Lake Central very similar if not identical building over at Wall Lake Northern and again and this this presentation will go on the website for the community to look at as well um a little different configuration as far as location but um identical building over at wal Lake western for the team building uh various Renovations over at Wall Lake Central uh

025improvements at the outdoor education center which have been completed wal Lake western addition and Renovations and that uh with the highlights from last summer now what do we have coming up for 2025 and you'll see a few of those recommendations tonight um we are going to be and this is to wrap up the 19 program we have roughly $30 million left to expend on the 19 program and that'll be contained in the projects that I have listed here uh Wall Lake Northern improvements and remodeling um we're going to be doing improvements to the W Lake Northern baseball and softball and that'll be funded through the syncing funds um turf fields new fencing improvements that we can do within budget uh maintenance and transportation improvements there'll be mechanical upgrades over at Wall Lake Central uh another

026recommendation being brought forward tonight is for districtwide security projects and and what I mean by that is we're going to be putting security film at all the vestibules for the majority of the buildings um and then Elementary gymnasium acoustic improvements at Keith Moon Lake Oakley Park and potentially Dublin so rolling into the 24 Bond program it's going to be split into four series we've already sold series one um this past spring um but real high level and this will continue to be refined as we move forward but the three main projects under series one are our Wall Lake Northern um Geisler um being repurposed and then the operations building um series two will be during years two and three and that will be the new Wixom Elementary um continuation of work over at Geisler in

027wal Lake Northern series three is where we're going to have some money to buy some buses as well and then we'll be doing improvements over at Western Twin Sun Commerce Elementary in glenary most of the elementary will be contained in years three and four and that's through series three the next page is a continuation of that and that's the remainder of the elementary buildings uh along with additional work over at the operations at oec and the ESC building series four projects which will be contained in years four through six will include Wall Lake Central the EC the middle school buildings and Dublin Elementary a lot to digest here but this I think will be helpful to the public as they look at the website look at this a little bit further just what are we

028doing at each building this is a high level summary um per building of what the scope is going to be not to say that might change a bit but if you're interested in what's going to happen in each building um these next three slides take a look at that when it hits the website all the elementaries were on page one the Middle School and high schools contained here and then all the miscellaneous buildings in the district um the scope of work that's going to be performed so I try to keep it as brief and uh as informative as I can um obviously if there's any questions I'm here to answer those but I'm looking forward to uh collaborating with the board as we move forward thank you Mrs Kaplan Mrs Cas Grande a couple of

029things so we um had an agenda item where we approved some pool work um because of code is this I assume from what we just heard here that Western and Central Pools are completed that code work is completed okay could I have an update on where we are with that yeah Central is completed and open Western the new gutter system has gone to the state the state has signed off on it it's gone to the fabricator it takes between six and eight month six and eight weeks to fabricate best case scenario we're still looking at a march/april availability hopefully we can get it done sooner but that right now is is the timeline because once they're actually removing almost three and 1 12 fet of tile from the top down and then about 2 and

0301/2 fet from what is a current Edge back to put this in and then rebuild all of that so but Central and Northern are operational right now okay perfect and then I just have a high Lev question I'm not even I I I don't think the board has seen any reports that have come out of the system that you're talking about um so I'm kind of wondering um if may I don't know if our committee has seen it yet or not so I'm just kind of asking out of out of kind of ignorance of that you mentioned dashboards um are they can we slice them by building um the board would probably like to see what are you going to show us and and and kind of get a feel and flavor for that so

031we talked in the subcommittee that we would have the subcommittee take a review of that first the reason why it's not available right now is we're finishing up to 2019 and to back fill that information would not be valuable use of our time and energy and so we're building into the 24 now and so it I would not anticipate that level of data being available until perhaps August or September just because that's when we start to really get into the 24 projects there's a couple small 24 projects that we're doing in bid pack8 that we'll talk about later the northern roof that's half 2019 half 2024 so they're tracking the 202 for stuff right now but it really wouldn't be much of a dashboard at this point I mean it sounds silly but it's only

032a couple million dollars I that's a lot of money to me but in a bond project is not going to show much at this time thank you that's all I have for now thank you um being part of the bond sub committee I had the opportunity to to review this presentation earlier and I I just want to say I appreciate that you guys took some feedback that we had in that meeting and and made some changes um one of the things that I hope that the community um very much appreciates is going to be the transparency um throughout the process that that we are hoping to make sure continues to happen um you know with the dashboard with knowing what's going on with trying to make it very clear um you know transparency has been

033something that's been a big deal the last couple years and so um one thing that I hope is if the community at any point feels that that transparency isn't there there's questions like please let us know because the the committee and um you know plant Moran the administration I feel is very responsive to that feedback and so we want to make sure that you know the community that supported this Bond also feels that we are supporting you back with the information that you need to feel comfortable with the decisions that we're making and that you are paying for so I just want to thank you guys for the work that you're doing and look forward to all the things that are going to happen Mr seigler uh echoing on what Mrs Levens said and uh

034and talking with Mrs craft and a lot of this information will be also available on the district website as as we're moving along uh when you talk about merging projects and cost savings you know it's a lot of money in the end when we put it all together a great deal of savings and I do want to thank everybody involved because when when we had our meeting we the subcommittee had some very specific thoughts or recommendations and suggestions and they were very well received uh you know we have been very fortunate to have the community support us as we are doing this in past Bond e Bond and millage efforts and I look forward to the end results because I think they will be spectacular and as Mrs Levens had said you know maybe we

035can dress down the buildings and look them a little bit more like school buildings I'm sure that will if it is if it's not a cost savings you will tell us that it's better off we're doing it this way and this is how you're going to save money versus going with straight cement walls but I appreciate it Mrs Fernandez I had two kind of highle questions I wanted to ask with the e-builder system that you're using um to track the bond funds will you also be tracking the syncing funds I noticed at least one of the projects was a syncing fund um syncing fund project and so will that tracking also happen through e-builder yeah any any syncing fund projects that are that are in play with the pro with the projects we're looking at

036regardless of funding source we'll be tracking that as well only the ones that are in play with the bonds we're not there's probably a lot of District direct initiatives that are that are being funded through the syncing fund we will not be tracking those but any projects that are part of the 24 program that have just have sinking fund funding we will be tracking but that's not to say we can't have that conversation with Julie and see how we can help okay I was going to say oh snap like sounds like that could be helpful um and my second question was just um uh I know you were brought in around late August and we had a bus purchase significant Siz bus purchase that happened I believe in October did you have any involvement or

037review or um insights and um into that I didn't have any involvement unfortunately so I wish I could help thank you Mr Smith uh thank you for that wonderful report and it's good to see the transparency is on there and to see the snapshot I think that's going to be wonderful ful for uh I myself as a parent as a taxpayer and everything to see actually what projects are there my my main question I have is just because it's in my my purview of I work from government when I see the cost savings that's wonderful of 3.6 are there contingencies built in in case there's any changes to anything like that is there 10% 20% I didn't see that in the motion so I just want to see if there's contingencies built into that that

038it's 11 million does that include 10% 15 caseing yeah we we we carry there's a lot of different contingencies that are carried right now but certainly for until we get all the contracts locked in for Professional Services there's a budget with contingency um set up um for all the construction projects when they're early um in conceptual design there's typically a 15 to 20% that'll get reduced as we get smarter and more definitive information with design and then we're going to recommend as we move forward with the bond program two contingency funds kind of holistically um there'll be construction contingency as projects come online of roughly 8 to 10% that the contractor will carry and then we'll hold back on our side roughly another 10% over the bond that we're calling owner contingency so there'll be

039plenty of contingencies built into the budget Miss Len and just one more I guess piece of clarification that was clear in the bond committee but maybe didn't make it up to this point is although there might be savings on something like Mr Smith is talking about that doesn't mean that something else might not cost more so we certainly aren't going to count our chickens before they're hatched so um that is just an important thing to point out Mr seagler one other thing that uh we forgot to mention was in regards to change orders of any sizable amounts that we would be notified as the part of the committee of those going through so very significant when we have any big changes that we you know that we need to know about and the board need

040don't all allow to inform the community thank you Mrs Fernandez notified or notified and approve clear as mud I can make a quick comment to that we we are we are working on um what we feel is best practice governance procedures with thresholds of who has authority to approve what and what goes to the board um there will be circumstances at least for our recommendation where change orders of a certain threshold will go to the board for approval uh but we're working those details out and finalizing the documents right now with Administration anybody else thank you very much we appreciate all your hard work and for sharing with us thank you your information okay we're moving on to District impr Improvement goals Dr Lans thank you very much I'll turn it over to Mrs kensky

041thank you Dr Lans if you give me just a moment to pull up our presentation on data thank you yeah you're right thank you Shaya it doesn't sound like it's on but I'm not sure with the new system how to get that yeah I mean I can use my teacher voice but this one thanks yeah yeah thanks Shane I couldn't hear that it wasn't on and sometimes it's a little low so we'll go we'll go solve that we'll solve that technical issue yeah they're testing it okay which one is the full screen this one is it that one yeah full screen there it is okay cool thank you thank you Mrs V all right testing anybody no still no Sor still no your teacher voice I can use my teacher voice which is totally totally

042fine can everybody in the back hear me yay all right thank you Mrs kensky all right some of you guys want to get home for the game so I get it I totally get it all right thank you um thank you uh to the board for allowing me an opportunity to talk a little bit about uh data and our data where we're at right now so all of you got this presentation last week uh so I I know that you've had some time to look this over and digest it one of the things that I wanted to do was to really keep the format really similar to a previous data presentation that I've shared and last year when we were talking about data one of the things that I wanted to make note of was

043that um and other board members have asked me about this 's lots of data like I got data we could sit here for a week and look at lots of different data sets and data points but the data pieces that we're really monitoring closely are those that are related to our district Improvement goals or our myip goals that's our Michigan integrated continuous improvement process goals we're obligated to have goals that align with our accreditation process that we use data multiple data points to support why we have those goals and that we closely monitor our progress on them and our implementation of strategies around those so what you're going to see tonight is exactly what we looked at last year but with some new updated data and information that talk about how we're doing with these

044two goals I'll also give you a quick balcony overview of our I ready diagnostic from this fall so that you can kind of get a sense as to what that data is showing in a in a very aggregate very overarching way so I'm going to give you some really drilled down data aligned with our goals and then I'm going to give you some broad balcony data just so that you can see where are we at with I ready this fall so again that purpose just what I stated we really want to look at those drill down data points around our district Improvement or our MIP goals and what are those MIP goals I was really really proud this summer when we were doing some teacher feedback uh and teacher professional development in working with a

045group in August uh a group of teachers from K12 they were actually able to say we know what our goals are I asked and they knew so what this shows is that we really are aligned with the work that we're doing and all the way down to the teacher classroom level our teachers are aware of and know what we're working on because this is what we work on this is our professional learning this is our Target so we want to enable all students to increase that Proficiency in reading and comprehending informational text that's the majority of texts that we ex that we experience as adults some of us read for pleasure but not all of us read uh uh um fictional text but informational text comes at us all the time so that's why we

046we chose as a as a broad committee looking at the data that we wanted to go with informational text also a second goal which is more of a systems goal but it supports the academic piece is Wald Lake having a successfully implemented multi-tiered system of support that supports the needs of all students so that's really taking a look at down to the individual level what does a student in this in any particular classroom need at any particular time all right so this is a a slide that's familiar from last year and in this slide is really where I kind of gave you that that comprehensive view of what data did we look at as a team and we spent months and months looking and digging into a v a variety of data to come up

047with those goals so again looking at the the I ready K through 8 this was spring 23 data we actually looked back at 2022 data to help us set the goal um but we also looked at mstep and really digging deep into some item analysis because remember those mstep D the mstep results come out and it really looks at grades three through eight um and you look at these big broad percentages and you think well what does that really mean so for our us and our team we really drilled down into an item analysis that's part of the presentation we'll talk about that and then you'll see our little Wald Lake logo because we also looked at grades we looked at benchmark assessments unit test tests tests that kids are taking every day in class

048and really digging into what are we asking kids to to do um on a day-to-day kind of basis right here in our classrooms so it's really looking at big state level data our Benchmark assessment system data down to the classroom level and and individual grades so this is just a repeat slide from last winter but this is our spring 2024 I ready diet agnostic for K8 so this was the end of the year this was May June kids were taking this final diagnostic we are making progress we are seeing those green bands expanding in the area of vocabulary and informational text comprehension so we're making gains it's kind of hard to tell when you look at these big broad uh uh barographs but we're going to take a look at some numbers to see how

049we're making some gains in in those two areas I gave you this whole snapshot because sometimes we ask about other elements of literacy and progress and I wanted you to be able to see where we're at also with regard to phological awareness which is the hearing and manipulated hearing of sounds and spoken sounds down to phonics which is mapping the sounds onto the reading of text or the writing of text but in this case it measures the reading of text those high frequency words so familiarity with those then we get down into the vocabulary and the comprehension just so that you can see comparatively yeah we have work to do in all of these areas but the biggest area of work to do is around vocabulary and comprehension so let's take a look at vocabulary

050you're going to see three data sets the first one that you're going to see is our entire District K through 8 on vocabulary on the left side you see where we started in October of 2022 looking at how our students were in this area of vocabulary and then taking a look at where Did We End the year in June this are these are all of our students who take I ready K8 so you can see we're making progress we're closing gaps this next slide looks exactly the same except at the top in yellow it says Elementary so this is K5 we felt it important to look at it by level as well so you can see in K5 our teachers are really focusing on strategies to improve vocabulary um and so this is this is

051showing some nice gains do we still have work to do absolutely we still have students below grade level but we're starting to close those gaps for for a lot of our students here's middle school so this is 6 through eight again making progress a little bit less progress in vocabulary at the middle school then spreads out across specific content areas and so we have content area kind of um Specialists if you will you know you have a science teacher that teaches science all day long K K5 you've got teachers that are teaching all subjects in one classroom so it's a little a little more compartmentalized in middle school but still focusing on disciplinary literacy strategies around vocabulary has been the focus of our professional learning we're making some gains and some progress so how does

052that translate into informational text so again the same types of data sets first looking at District K through 8 from our starting point until June so again as a as an aggregate uh uh look we're really making some gains still work to do like I said uh Elementary K5 again making nice gains but still work to do and then of course middle school again like we noted with vocabulary still gains maybe not quite as pronounced as we're seeing with some of our elementary students but we're still making progress in the area of informational text comprehension so woo and I'm on Wow all right that saves saves my voice so I can cheer for the Lions later when I get home okay all right so um so as you can see we're making some nice gains

053um one might say well shouldn't we be making more significant gains like you're you're throwing all in at this and really we are we are all in around these two areas of of uh goal work with our teachers uh one of the things I can tell you is that from experence erience of moving through numerous numerous cycles of District Improvement in other large districts uh typical District Improvement Cycles last about five years and this is just year two for us so I want you to think about we use 2022 23 data to formulate the goals 23 24 in implementing uh and so we've got we've got just a few years in on this so we've got a little bit of time to go as we're watching these gains so as I mentioned at the first

054slide we use a variety of data points I apologize to the audience this is very very tiny but board members I know you have a a a copy of this so you can enlarge it on your screens you can do what you need to with it but um we took a look in that initial 20 fall of 22 fall into winter of 22 kind of looking and digging deeply into Data um that we looked at our 2021 end ofe State assessment and we were were showing for informational text and vocabulary around 25 items um on those mstep uh State tests in third grade sixth grade and seventh grade that were showing up as relative areas of weakness that meant that we didn't even have uh 25% of the aggregate of students passing those items so

055if it was highlighted in red and yes that meant that that was a relative area of weakness when it came to informational text and vocab and you'll notice it says Ela so our English language arts exam as well as math and one might say well how does math factor into informational text comprehension anybody a fan of uh story problems remember when we were young right and you think I can do the math I can't figure out the story problem so really that's what we are trying to focus on I don't mean to make it make it trit or simplistic but really the language uh that's embedded in informational text in math has a really specific genre to it and we're really helping our kids to get better at understanding um informational text outside of an

056Ela or an English class so you can see third sixth and seventh grade uh as we took a look at those items we made a lot of gains within closing gaps on the uh M steps uh test we went from 25 areas of week weakness to seven now I caution you with that big jump because it might be like oh my gosh you solved the issue well we might have gotten kids a little over that threshold of of that 25% where we found a relative area of weakness for kids but um what we noticed is that uh then 2024 we only have six areas of weakness but if you look at the graphs some areas that last year moved off the the critical list kind of bumped back on so that leads us to believe

057um in learning services that those are areas that weren't really solid yet so as it says seven areas of weakness you know we make the we make this huge jump like woohoo and yes we're excited about it but we're really watching because I think some of these areas are tenative progress and we need to make sure that we've really got that solid for for some of our students and those a couple of those areas crop up in math so where's that connection right where's that connection to the work we're doing in learning Services if you remember we really uh are taking our time in rolling out that new middle school math program in we're starting this year with sixth grade next year it will roll up to seventh and then next the following year roll

058up to eth we really are addressing these weakness areas in really looking at what uh units and what lessons in math uh address these and really tightening that up so our math team and our math department are really well aware of it we're cautiously optimistic in terms of this type of um progress we're making but we know that some of it's tentative and we're really watching that carefully so that we can support our teachers in delivering the instruction and our Learners uh in the areas where they might be struggling all right so I'm going to move away from the district Improvement goals and the work that we're doing there and really just give you a that balcony overview of how's it going this fall with students incoming into for the new year and how are

059they doing on their reading and math Diagnostics so um again I'm going to start with the I ready placement level descriptors because this is important in terms of understanding what those color coding um systems mean especially when it comes to entering into the grade level for this year so if I'm a third grader and I took my assessment uh the second week of school which a lot of our students did you know right off the bat we're we're getting to do their diagnostic if I'm a third grader I'm being assessed on all the third grade standards but I just started third grade so I haven't yet had exposure to all of it yet so I want to caution you when you look at that yellow one grade below doesn't necessarily mean that a student is

060at risk yet so if you look at this descriptor it says that students who might Place yellow at their beginning of your diagnostic are performing consistent with students who have just begun that Academic Year so just cautiously think about that yellow and it basically curriculum Associates and their research share that if the students are still placing there in that midyear diagnostic which is January February and certainly by end of year diagnostic then those are students we need to really consider for additional intervention and that's where we look at students who fall into those categories as being recommended for some of our summer school programs tutoring opportunities other interventions that take place with the teacher in the classroom or with our intervention Specialists so just know that that's kind of how we watch and we use

061that if students at the beginning of the year are early on grade level or mid or above that means that these are students coming into third grade let's say who are well beyond where a third like they've learned their third grade standards in third grade so those are students we need to be looking at for enrichment for extra challenge for for other types of learning opportunities to help them grow and if students are two to three grade levels behind starting that grade that's definitely more a more intensive approach that we want to take and we want to make sure those students are definitely being provided supports with our mtss process so so how do we compare to our benchmarks this first graph you're seeing is reading so our I ready diagnostic was given like I

062said right when kids started uh in on school you can see uh the I'll go from left to right uh the national Norm that curriculum Associates is using is based on the fall 2022 23 National Data set in the Middle where it says National year to date those are the national fall scores in Reading k through eight by the way then you'll see Michigan district dists that utilize I ready K to8 you can see their fall Diagnostic and then you can see our district score is the the bar graph that's right there on the right next to the next to the key so as you can see based on this we continue to outperform National Norms from a few years ago we continue to outperform our national uh data from this fall as well as

063outperforming our Michigan counterparts who are also using IR as their Diagnostic in reading and remember that yellow doesn't necessarily mean everybody's way below there are students in that yellow range that are right on target where they need to be at this point in the year of course when we measure that in midyear and end of year is where we want to really be watching students in their progress um and this same exact graph in math so you can take a look at where Wald Lake is performing if you look at that far right uh vertical bar graph there and you can take a look again those National Norms from 2022 23 the national current data and then our Michigan counterparts so what are we doing about it right and this again is a familiar uh

064slide from last year but with some enhancements that I've added so what we continue to do as part of that five-year broad Improvement plan is the systems alignment piece we continue to work on our mtss processes one might think well you develop a process you show everybody what to do in monitoring student data and you'll let them do it um we have 12 elementaries we have four middle schools we have three high schools and the implementation of those processes we are continually refining checking in and monitoring and that's the work that my team and I continue to do with the principles and do with their teams at their building so aligning that uh system across our our district is of utmost importance and it's not a oneandone it's um continually inspecting what you expect and

065that's a a term that I like to use sometimes is inspect what you expect so we are keeping a close eye on that and continuing to work together our focused professional development so our professional development half days those times when our teachers come together aren't just times for them to do who whatever those are really focused professional learning opportunities where we're really keying in on strategies to teach vocabulary strategies to teach comprehension through small group instruction models and we're also focusing on that mtss process of digging deeply into the student data down to the individual student level and helping our classroom teachers know how to plan best for instruction next those close data reviews as I said that's part of our ongoing work uh with K8 and our buildings are doing a great job every

066building has data teams we have instructional Specialists and coaches that help look and dissect that data with our teachers and talk about action plans for students um so that we can continue to close those gaps in those areas of need continuous monitoring uh like I said we're looking at individual student growth through these processes uh the instructional work that we're doing again the PDS focus on techniques for small group work um the curriculum work that we're doing highlighting that middle school math and we continue to focus on using our district and board approved resources for helping our our teachers learn how to use those different tools effectively with kids other additional steps that partner School coaching model so having those high quality highly skilled facilitators in coaching right in classrooms alongside our teachers and helping

067our students they're also coaching and helping our coaches or our instructional Specialists that every building know how to support the teachers so they come in they coach they do that very intensive work and then they leave with homework if you will like when I come back here are some things that you know I want you to be working on and our fantastic instructional specialists at the building level continue to carry that work and along with the principles to work with our staff those grade level professional developments that are taking place um I do I I'm going to have a little bit during admin commentary Dr Lans and U board members to share about some fabulous work that took place at Keith yesterday um and then we also are my team and I are facilitating new

068teacher and new principal sessions we have a host of new administrators in the district and anytime you have that type of change over you want to make sure that we're all rowing the boat in the same direction and everybody's scaled up and have those same tools to help and support the system as a whole and we have a lot of new teachers which is exciting but it's also helping them know how to use those tools and to scale up those skills too and then we have training for our coaches as I mentioned those instructional Specialists continue to receive coaching uh supports through Oakland schools they continue to receive that through our coaching Network that we work with at the state level um and it's just it's very exciting to see everything very aligned so um

069that's what I have to share uh that's my final slide U I'm happy to entertain any questions or comments or thoughts um that I that you have at this time Mrs Mrs CA Grande um Dr Lance I don't know what this would look like I would think it would be in your perf you to kind of figure out what my one takeaway I took as Mrs kohanski was talking about those areas that are tentative progress it might be nice I don't know what it looks like or how it comes to us your decision but it might be nice to understand before we get the next presentation what we're doing on those areas of tenative progress okay so I would leave that to you though how how to do it thank you thank you Mrs Len

070thank you thank you Mrs kohy for the presentation um I've got two questions um kind of higher level questions um in your professional opinion how did we get to the point where vocabulary and informational text were the lower pieces of of our work yeah thank you for that that's a great question um I think that one of the things that I can speak to is what research tells us about why some of those areas might be might be weaker we know that students who maybe speak a different language at home as their home language come to us with a different set of vocabulary skills especially around English um we know that students um research shows us that students who our English Learners uh May uh Take 5 to 10 years to really acquire an academic

071vocabulary they may become very conversational speakers in a conversational way um but when it comes to academic vocab that becomes a much more difficult task to to help students with we know our our um students that speak a different language at home that that those numbers have increased over the years so we know that that's uh um one reason um why students May struggle in in the that particular area uh I I also know that research shows that students from economically disadvantaged households may talk less at home they may have less experiences outside of the home they may uh they may um be a little further from where some of our more um how shall I say um resourced families have opportunities to give their kids so students who come to us and and almost

072you can parallel some of these data charts if you look at economically disadvantaged population um you can look at it and it almost overlays in the exact same way that our um our data shows with vocabulary and comprehension so those are two areas um there could be a host of other areas students with speech and language uh difficulties or delays may also struggle in these types of areas too so helping our teachers have skills and strategies for helping not only English language learners but students who may be coming to us with a variety of of needs so that's really where we look at that's my professional opinion but it is based on on years of research and that's what we we tend to typically see so I would assume there's a way to break out

073those populations from the data so if we were to look at the the kids that don't fit in those boxes the English language Learners socioeconomically disadvantaged um special needs population just that average everyday learner is the data the same so the data is different um while that's not something that I've felt super comfortable sharing out in public I would be happy to share that with the board at uh at a at a separate time I don't want to I don't want to call anyone out for the data I don't want to call anybody you know I don't want to paint a negative picture or any of our subgroups or populations in any negative way but I'm happy to share that that data with you separately yeah and I totally understand just alternatively I want to

074paint a positive picture for when it is working absolutely you know and and and there may the data may not be as you know Grim as it might look sometimes if if we are you know if the populations are different I think it's it's healthy to look at when it is working well because I think it can look good and and be more positive um absolutely my second uh comment was on the the chart you know we went from 25 weaknesses to maybe seven or 10 to maybe six that's good that we're making progress what I'm wondering is what are the stretch goals that are not weaknesses but what are the things that we're looking at to maybe look at more advanced you know this is where we're doing really well maybe these are our

075Advanced students so we can start looking at more advanced work instead of the catch-up work it's what are we doing to push the top so I'm I'm wondering and and I don't expect you to answer this right now but something I'd be curious is what's the next step you know let's say we get that six down to you know two and one and then we have a party what's the other side of that so I'm very curious to know is there a current focus on the advanced piece of things and what does that look like yeah thank you I can speak to that a little bit when it comes to K5 so that small group instruction model that we talked about it's not just for our students who are below you know one two three

076grade levels below that small group instruction model is also for our higher achieving students so that expectation and when we coach and work with our teachers it's to look at all of their data yes we want them to focus as as Mrs CAG Grande said what are those actionable steps that we're taking when we're looking at mstep Trends or we're looking at that data on an individual student basis yes we want teachers to identify and use that data and say okay I know that this might be a group I've got to meet with every day or four out of the five days but where are those enriching groups right where are those groups that are already coming in high they're already scoring successfully on mstep they're already you know doing well and and and acing

077their Benchmark and their unit assessments and their class tests well those teachers are also in small group taking a look at what can I do to enrich so they might be reading books at higher levels they might be doing book club activities passion projects those are those kinds of things that we offer to those Advanced Learners to keep them growing um and while it's not part of this data presentation I'm I'm I'm going to write myself a note to talk um and share some data with you about the stretch growth numbers for students that fall in that early on and one or you know uh on and above I'd love to share with you the stretch growth because I don't want us to think that we we are neglecting any of our Learners actually the

078students and teaser they're growing and they're stretching uh uh really well above and beyond just an annual typical growth but I'll be happy to share those numbers with you I think that would be encouraging for you to see sure and that's good to hear and then you know if if they are growing you know faster great then what does the future look like for those kids as well yeah you bet thank you I'll get that for you Mrs West thank you Mr kensy yeah um so why I appreciate that like we are growing and improving um the information you sent to us I noticed was um in 2019 we are sign significantly higher than when we were in 2122 and I'm thinking part of that might be due to the online learning in Co um

079so I'm glad to see that we're starting to improve again but I was wondering if there's any Sr funds available to help these students that are at least two grades or more below behind um and if we have enough Staffing to even help those kids yeah thank you Mrs West that's a great question I know that um in looking at and i' I'd love to talk more with you about which pieces of the 2019 data yeah there I we didn't take a massive hit during covid but we definitely slid to a point where you know we we maintained in a lot of areas um in some areas we know that those kids came back to us and and it was time to grow again right and we're seeing some of that growth back but the

080the Esser dollars that came to us from covid are are done those were spent as of September of 24 so just within the last few months we spent them down we spent them on things like tutoring and summer school and all of those types of supports uh the state has come in with funding called uh 23g we also have um uh some we continue to use our 31a which is atrisk funding so funding that we receive from the state for students that are at risk for a variety of reasons and so we really are um very thoughtful and calculative about taking that money to kind of help to continue to support those same things that we were that we've been using them on um additional tutoring uh we I just went through with the principles

081in October a tutoring plan using that 23g money so our principles are like on it you know they're they're developing and designing a variety of types of things not just before and after school but some you know lunchtime drop in help tutoring to get ready for you know an upcoming assessment so our our principles are on it we we have teachers that are helping to staff that right now um we've been really fortunate to be able to have some funding streams that continue to support and so this 23g state level Grant uh is kind of doing that job for us and so we do have funding that's helping to support it um and continue to to plan along with our administrators and our teachers So yeah thank you um and then are we able to

082reach out are we reaching out to those families that need the extra help then so the families that it it looks it depends on what the programs are like at the individual building levels so I'm having them design programs around what their needs are they could be Invitation Only it's not a come one come all um just because of staffing needs it might be hard for us to do that uh as far as the communication piece and how parents are finding out about these things um I'm happy to Circle back to to our principles and get more information about how our teachers are reaching out to Families how they might uh or their or our counseling staff might be reaching out to families about opportunities for that okay thank you you bet Mr Smith thank

083you Mrs um thank you for answering that because some of the questions I had were what who resources are we using to help for intervention so thank you for also answer asking those what is the actual percentage of the threshold I think you mentioned something about 25% to be in the weakness what actually is your metric that you're using is it truly 25% for theep item analysis that I showed you with The Columns of red and green yes so if it was coded in red that meant that we did not yet have uh 25% or greater passing that with a proficiency um following up with that is to a personal and I'm sure many as well as uh how do you pull out the other outliers and help with uh the students that need other

084support structures or testing methods whether what other Diagnostics because we do have many kids out there uh that have test anxiety and other things like that and how do you pull out that data if you can uh measure that that you know we know that it's testing on one specific day or whatever it's that but we might hear from the teachers that we're working with our action plan with our teachers that our kids are doing amazing with you know reading and comprehension but then on the test it's not reflecting that so how do we adhere to that how do we how do we tease that out we were just having a a conversation about that in a planning meeting that I was in today uh really talking about how often times our instruction which tends

085to be paper pencil books in hand sometimes doesn't often translate to the digital world of kids reading uh you know the test is on a computer the SAT is completely digital right now right and that was a move that was made just within the last year so we've noticed some of that um and one of the things that I'm I'm working on with my team is how do we carefully provide more opportunities for our students to have access with digital print and and learning how to how to work that because some of it we wonder about is it the testing environment is it the test format um and the other thing too that we're looking at and kind of circling back to bringing this full circle and talking about vocabulary um our Michigan mstep has

086been assessed by the advancing literacy arm of teachers college to be the second hardest State assessment in the nation based on vocabulary and I'll give you an example of what I mean by that so in class we teach our kids we're going to learn about main ideas in details we're going to read about them we're going to highlight those we're going to write about main ideas in details so the teacher talks for months about main idea and details did you find the main idea look I found the main idea but when the student gets to the test the test language changes often times and so when the student looks at it on a test it's a the test question prompt which can't be read or explained by anyone student reads it and it says something

087along the lines of and I'm making this up but hypothesizing um read the following passage what is the essential focus and what are three evidence you know pieces of evidence that give you reason to to to know that and the kids's like I don't even know what that means right because my teachers called it you know they're not even thinking main idea in detail because it's called an essential focus and evidence right so what we're trying to do is to help our teachers to understand that the assessment sometimes doesn't often match our good instruction in the classroom and we want to make that more flexible so from a vocab standpoint that can also be but how do we tease that out you know we do a lot of hypothesizing about it um we do have

088digging deeper assessments so if we have a question about a student like gosh they didn't do so well on I but they're killing it killing it in class I know they're doing well we have some other um you know pull aside do do some digging deeper with some some other individualized assessments our instructional specialists at the elementary can can help support a teacher in doing that and there have been times where it's like you know they just didn't take the test well or they didn't feel well that day um and and so providing loads and loads of support to a student who just had a bad day doesn't seem to be you know effective so we do have ways of kind of teasing that out um but yeah I mean the test itself and the

089environment and and the vocabulary all of that can have a huge impact on how we perform thank you Mr seigler Mr kky one of the things that you and I had discussed I think probably six or eight months ago was the testing and the amount of students that we are testing percentage wise or who is being excluded and I think that would be very beneficial for you to reiterate that conversation if you don't mind with the audience yeah absolutely so um thanks Mr seagler so we we are obligated to test 95% of our student population when it comes to the state assessment and in that state assessment it's pretty much everybody unless there is a student that is has a significant cognitive impairment and might be in a um basic program classroom for which an

090alternative assessment might be the most appropriate for them and their exceptional needs so we test basically everyone if you're a student with a 504 plan if you're a student with ADHD if you're a student with uh that may have an IEP for uh accommodations if you're a student that is learning English as a new language we have to test all of it so when you look at that data it includes basically everybody except for a very very small fraction of students that might be taking something alternative so thank you for that any other questions thank you very much Mrs kohany thank you so we're going to move on to public commentary thank you thank you all for coming tonight and for your interest in addressing the board this is your opportunity to address the board

091the board will listen to your statements questions or concerns we will not have a conversation if followup is necessary a member of the superintendent staff or a board member will get back with you you have three minutes to address the board please keep an eye on the timer on the wall just over here if you come close to your time Mr seagler will let you know you're coming close and for you to begin to wrap up your comments we ask that all speakers remain professional and refrain from personal attacks thank you we're going to start with Mara FR I apologize it's not going to be on the wall so Mr seagler will give you a 30 second noce oh oh oh sorry I misspoke again it's okay good evening uh my name is Mara fre

092and I have a son who attends the adult transition program just for the um community members that are not familiar with this program uh they serve the young adults with special needs uh between 18 and 26 years old um I'm here to T today asking for the school board members to support the approval of the repurposing of gisler middle school this matter has a very important meaning to the adult transitions program considering the students would have a permanent space in that building the ATP program has been moved multiple times throughout the years and also according with the information from the Wall Lake School District um website they were part of the new uh Bild in um remodel project of the world Lake uh Western High School and somehow that just did not happen the mission

093of the ATP is to focus on increasing Independence through teaching functional academics vocational training daily living skills and communication skills in order to achieve that it is time for the ATP to have their own space just like any other students in the school district it is time for the ATP to have appropriate and properly equipped facilities with all the learning spaces tools and resources they deserve the students of the ATP work very hard every single day to maximize their full potential and to have a meaning meaningful life and be active members of our community today I invite you to do your to support their goals and their dreams thank you thank you Christine Titus good evening I'm Christine Titus I'm a proud instructional specialist at Hickory Woods Elementary I'm a 32ye Community member and all

094four of my kids went through Wild Lake school's K12 um and Mrs kohansi I'll apologize I promise I did not coordinate my comments with what happened tonight although it seems like that at times um first of all tonight I'd like to thank our learning Services team for the design of our last professional learning day on November 19th the feedback I heard from not only colleagues in my building but those colleagues I know from across the district was how relevant this learning was and is we had professionals learning from professionals their colleagues their their their Community Learning from our colleagues makes it real and practical when we can hear from those that are living in this curricula I had the pleasure of participating as a facilitator and I've never had a two-hour session fly by like

095this did it's gratifying to see Educators come together on behalf of your students and speaking of students um I get the fact that we have to look at a way of quantifying their learning through data and that helps with our instructional choices but what I'd like us all to remember is that behind the data is an individual student and that there are also qualitative ways of collecting information on that child's learning in addition to what we quantify I think sometimes we get so bogged down in what the data is telling us that we sometimes forget a child's learning isn't always a linear progression um and the learning can take take a lot of detours and even setbacks to success every child every day right so I'd like to leave you with that thought as I

096also wish you all a peaceful and happy holiday season thank you thank you chrisy Russ hello um it was holiday sweater day at my very very part-time job today so I just kept the outfit on um I wanted to talk about a couple things today there's a lot to talk about um one is I'm hoping later in the meeting when we talk about the um recommendations that we're going to hear good discussions about the changes in the feeder patterns um I feel like some of it is a little bit shortsighted and not really thinking through to the future and did we actually think it through when you're having 1/4th of the students get thrown to the Wolves when they go to high school when they're not with their peers that they've been with for three

097years because those Middle School years are really important for um students and developing friendships and it it is very difficult a to have a friend torn away to go to a different high school or to be that friend that's going away with all new people and I know we've heard it multiple times that kids are resilient well we know that they are but they don't necessarily there's so many other things that they are resilient for why are we segregating these two schools and and showing you know sending them off um where they have to kind of start over um another thing I wanted to talk about is the openings in the district so I think I started with I'm working an amazing very very part-time job and I get bored so now I sub because

098it's fabulous and I it is so a couple things I wanted to say number one is the secretaries are amazing in the district they are so welcoming I sub in wal Lake and in Farmington and in noi and I'll tell you one thing wal Lake needs to up their subay because the jobs sit there longer than I you can't get in a Novi job it's impossible it really is um so we are we pay the least amount in the surrounding area other than I think here on Bailey every other District pays more for Subs but the secretaries are amazing and everybody is so helpful and I'm loving it whatever District I'm in um but when you look at the job openings in Wald Lake there's 98 jobs open right now and 43 of them are

099par jobs which dates back to January of 23 so if you think about that I don't know how up to it is but think about it when you look at there's openings there's 38 in Troy and 58 in Rochester those are comparable districts why do we have so many and why are we not updating it think about when you're selling a house if the house has been on the market for months and months what's wrong with the house there's some of these job openings in W Lake that have been on the posting for two years some I don't know if they're if it's up to date or not but I think we need to figure out what we're doing because when you look at the Oakland County thing and you think wow 98 openings in

100Wild Lake what's wrong there that there's so many openings so I think that whether it's up toate or not something needs to be done um but like I said it's phenomenal to be working in the schools and the pair of professionals should be paid more and the subs but that's thank you Tim saw Miller good evening Tim Siller Commerce Township I'm assist gender male using pronouns he him and his last December this board considered a bid award for the purchase of 10 school buses intended to replace aging buses that will be passing the recommended replacement schedule of 10 years this was voted down four to three no good reasons were offered at that time for the no votes this brings us to last month when a bus purchase proposal was again presented to the board

101and passed 5-2 this proposal was essentially the same except for one additional 77 passenger vehicle comments were made such as not having enough time to get board questions answered do some buses really need to be replaced that weren't used during pandemic days and what happens if the district fails to follow its contract to maintain a set vehicle average age buses still age when sitting unused and it was pointed out that they travel the same number of miles whether full or not it's a good point that important agenda items should be announced further in advance of a board meeting to allow for board member research but for this one you had a year to get questions answered did the no voters stop asking once they voted The Proposal down if I was a board member who

102helped the wrote down something the administration proposed I would have kept asking questions and working with the administration to help resolve it by the next meeting instead of just letting it sit and why would anyone propose breaching a contract just to find out what would happen seriously compare that with the correct observation that the reproductive Health Board doesn't need to submit a report every two years following the law indeed all laws must be followed be they state or federal laws just as contracts need to be followed why the inconsistency now I'm quite familiar with Robert's Rules of Order but not as familiar with this board's meeting Customs do you allow for motions to postpone consideration to a specific time for instance the next board meeting if so that would be a proper way to ask

103for more time to consider an agenda item instead of just voting no that method demonstrates good faith intentions to understand an ISS isue more thoroughly rather than appearing to be obstructionist just a suggestion I wanted to pass along finally I would like to thank Peggy Casa Grande for her years of service for the wal School District I've only been acquainted with you for about two years but your passion for this district and its students became instantly apparent to me the district will miss you thank you thank you Mike wise Mike Y is 23-year resident of Commerce Township I'd like to comment on the repurposing of gisler middle school and the new feeder P pattern thank you to the board the entire Administration and their very experienced consultant expertise diligence and hard work and their transparency

104and the willingness to listen to the community these are difficult decisions that were necessary for moving forward with the repurposing of gisler everyone is entitled to their opinion everyone may be an expert everyone thinks their way might be the best the real reality is that it's not possible to make everybody happy all the time again thank you to the board the administration and plant Maran for working through this difficult and complicated process thank you for all you do I would also make would like to make a comment many thanks to piggy CA Grandy for her years and years of service guidance and steadfast support of the students parents teachers and administrators of the Wall Lake Consolidated School District thank you for your sacrifice and your generous giving of your time to make the Wall Lake

105School system a better place for all thank you thank you Britney Thompson um hello I'm a Wixom resident attending Lon Lake Elementary and we purchased our home based off of the local schools nearby nearby my children are Walkers to the elementary school a short bus ride to Sarah Banks middle school and with the IND District school of choice we were planning on sending them to Western because it is 4 minutes away from our house and half of our subdivision is already districted for Western we have created a village of support with the parents surrounding us while our kids all attend multiple elementary school elementary schools we are brought together in middle school at Sarah Banks we are there for one another when someone needs a ride when someone is sick and needs to be picked

106up when someone needs car pooling to sporting events after pract or sporting events after school we divide and conquer which I feel is very rare in the world we live in now it makes sense that middle schools should on toone mirror high schools and because the community that is formed what doesn't make sense is to rip apart the community that is already in place and has been in place for a long time I know many Lon Lake Elementary families already in District transfer to Western to keep that Bond and network in place which is why the original plan for September with Lon Lake going to Banks and then to Western makes the most sense and if busing was an option more for more families I believe even more would choose to go to Western as

107well there have been multiple surveys going around that I know were emailed to the board and it shows an overwhelming number of families that would prefer the lon Lake Banks Western route I really hope that with this re this new redistricting opportunity the board will listen to the community and focus on the incoming students for years to come and what makes sense for them instead of what has always been thank you thank you Melissa Cummings hello my name is Melissa Cummings thank you for taking the time for public comment tonight thank you for your service and this is my first board meeting but I'm speaking to you as a proud long-term Wixom resident I was born here raised here and just moved literally last year selected and purchased a home off of the same road

108where I grew up I'm a proud wake Western alumni my Dad ran the spare change school store at wake Western for over 30 years so it is a fabric of my community I selected a home to be in a feeder um home for the lon Lake Elementary School System the school where I went to elementary school my children will be going to Banks middle scho school and I was thrilled to see the original proposal where finally it would be corrected and be back to where I grew up off Lon Lake Road feeding into wal Lake Western High School it's the high school where we can walk it is at the end of our the road at the end of our subdivision is where wake Western resides it's The Logical closest solution for Lon Lake system

109school children so we were so relieved we have a group of 253 parents that are on daily threads that we're celebrating the day that that decision and proposal was announced to have it be Lon Lake Banks to Wal Lake western an equal frustration and confusion the day that that decision was reversed and the suggestion was made to be Lon Lake to Creek to Central and then relief we are glad that the pattern at least the most recent decision is to go Lon Lake to Banks but my request and plea to you as the board today is to consider that original proposed solution of Lon Lake to Banks to Wal Lake western it would allow my children children in our subdivision who are Walkers to Lon Lake today who would be bike riders to Banks to

110allow them to be bike riders to Wall Lake western instead of having to take a bus a long distance I have to frankly Google Map I don't even know where central is and I grew up in this area so far removed from the lon Lake Area I know it is important you put the priority on keep keeping the children that are in their current feeder patterns together I think we can work together as a community to come up with a short-term solution for the next three years for those students that want to continue in their current patterns while still preserving what is the best long-term solution for the community for homeowners like me that I elected to move my family last year from Bloomfield Hills Schools district to the Wall Lake school system because I

111believe so firmly in the success of this district and um a more logical solution for the logistics for the lon Lake um students is something I'm urging you to consider for those of us that will have students in the high school pattern for the next 10 or 15 years let's do what's right in the long term and work together on better short-term Solutions thank you Matt Hawkins Matt Matt Hawkins I'm a father of four in our school district and I live by Lon Lake Elementary I'm here to advocate in delay of the decision on the proposed rezoning same thing that other people are here for tonight I speak on behalf of many parents parents and Friends uh it's alarming how many issues are in the proposed plan and I hope to share with you tonight

112I also plead with you to reconsider the original September plan um in listen to the community that came here today so the proposed plan uh as it is currently has not followed the precedent of community involvement that has occurred in the past when performing splits the board has not explained why the initial September plan which reduce splits in align with community preferences was abandoned the proposed plan to reduce splits in imp will the proposed plan claims to reduce splits and impact fewer students however data shows the original plan in September would achieve these goals more effectively two recent surveys indicated that an overwhelming majority percent of families supported a plan like the one drafted in September the board's reasoning for the revision including reducing the number of school splits and affecting fewer students these claims

113are misleading as the original draft plan would have reduced splits even further and impacted fewer students in the future the rationale provided by the board so far is unsubstantiated separating children from peers have had have grown up NE will have negative impacts in the future on their well-being and sense of stability we should consider the whole District in this decision not just the 350 high school students the proximity of Central and Western is similar distance from metab Brook residents Lon Lake residents are mostly closer to Western the zoning does not make sense and will result in a huge increase in traffic and impact families work schedules and extracurricular activities the board has mentioned 350 students need Transportation has has a study been performed to to substantiate this data the high school parking lots are full

114if the board makes this decision the data should be provided to substantiate this 30 seconds the proposed plan does not ensure Equitable representation of demographics the parents would like to know why the proposed plan isolates students with subsidized housing and lunches the cost of logistics and transportation for the current high school students is unclear how many students would require Transportation because of their ability to drive carpool Etc what is the cost for this percentage the perception of The Wider Community is that this whole decision was made without consideration of anyone except for a group of 350 high school students thank you thank you I'm going to do my best here Melissa Clavin because I close I am Melissa clayben I have a third grader at L lake and a seventh grader at Sarah Banks so

115this decision on redistricting has a big impact on our family on the family sorry okay um what everyone said everything I've wanted to say what I'm looking for is a way to support you once this decision is has made how do I support you with my seventh grade how do I explain to him that you're looking out for his best interest when you are taking him away from his other friends I'm looking for more transparency and data and asking you to pause the decision if you don't have that information for prepared to share with us thank you thank you Susie [Applause] Crafton hi everyone um tonight I'm doing public comment uh because I'm not a board member tonight um I'd like to congratulate and welcome Lisa and Mike to to the board table this evening

116and to say goodbye to Peggy Casa Grande I'll be sitting in her chair starting in January with immense shoes to fill I'm grateful for your dedication to our district 16 long years I'm grateful for your commitment to public education that is just unwavering and you put a lot of hard work and heart into coming to the right decisions for kids I'm incredibly grateful for your mentorship for your leadership of this District during hard times and I hope I can spend a smidgen of the energy and the respect that I have for you on behalf of our community thank you so much truly that's all for tonight thank you Jackie gwin hi everyone I don't think I need to introduce myself to you guys but those of you in the audience who don't know me my

117name is Jackie Gerwin I'm a former wal Lake parent and the current director of the foundation for excellence as many of you know the purpose of the FF is to provide Grant funds to classrooms for additional tools and resources I wanted to take a couple minutes to give you an update as to what we've accomplished in the past year this past spring we were able to give back nearly $52,000 to classrooms across the district over half of those funds went to support literacy tools including decodable books magnetic letter trays and other reading materials we also were able to fund things like heart rate monitors drums and keyboards for music rooms maker space supplies light tables for art classes and printing costs for a school newspaper at Geer Middle School beyond our classroom grants we supported

11819 students in the district with scholarships for participation in marching band through the Schuman Performing Arts grants additionally we provided $2500 to assist the ATP adult special education program with supplies for their coffee cart business and nearly $1,500 to Title One elementary schools to ensure that all fifth graders get to experience fifth grade Camp so what's going on right now our 200 two 2025 Grant application is open now through January 6th and we're looking back at giving another $50,000 back this year we currently only have 21 submissions so if you're a teacher and you're listening please consider submitting we want to make sure we can give all that money out and right now we're kicking off our tuition Expedition raffle where we split the proceeds 5050 with the grand prize winner historically the winner has

119gotten over $10,000 in scholarship funds for postsecondary Education doesn't even have to be your kid it can a grandkid it can be a niece a nephew the nice neighbor down the street whoever you might want to give that money to and if you can't find somebody you can take that as a 40% lump sum of the proceeds I'm hoping that we can count on everybody sitting up at that table to purchase at least one ticket and support the ffe while you get a chance to win the grand prize tickets are $50 each and if you win and you have young kids will hold the money for 20 years so it'll still be there when they're ready to go to college in the new year you should also keep an eye out for our golf scramble

120registration the start of our kindergarten welcome kit sales and in April we'll be bringing back our Superstar staff Awards where you can give your favorite staff member a chance to win one of two $500 prizes from the W Lake Schools Federal Credit Union as you can see we have a lot of great things going on and that we like you are passionate about supporting our staff and students across the district we appreciate you and we thank you for doing the best for every child every day and a quick shout out thank you Peggy for all your your years and assisting me through so many things thank you thank you Andy classa hello um I'm here once again to talk about my friend Dakota um I'm going to tell you a story and this story is

121not my story this story came from five people who were very close to Dakota in her early years I can't Peg the actual year but this story either occurred in 2019 or 2020 but it's a true story and can be corroborated by said five people the gist of the story is that Dakota was at training and came back from training with burns on her neck of the five people they get different descriptions oh they're ugly Burns oh they were horrible Burns oh my gosh poor Dakota but the general consensus was that Dakota came back with burns on her neck okay we get into some various other conversations parts of it you know um but the conversations all ended in a very awkward way which was every all five of those folks all I know is

122I'm against the use of shock collars the manual says you use e-collars e-collars are shock collars I don't care what the dosage is my dad's a retired electrician I've been around it all my life okay um here you go Community I'm going to get you started why do we train with shot collars okay they're really not necessary and if you think about it shot collars are a negative training method these dogs are supposed to be positive they're supposed to be trained in a positive manner next question was Dakota the only one that this happened to because if you think about it Dakota is the only dog in the district where burn marks would really show up she's the only yellow white lab and this third one's been bugging me for a while you all know

123that in the first meeting I was here I said I had proof that on May 31st Dakota was diagnosed with a heart murmur potential heart conditions why would you send Dakota to refresh her training last July when she had these potential heart conditions I don't know anything about Dakota I haven't seen her up close in six months to this day 30 seconds okay that's the gist of what I wanted to kind of bring to light and through previous two meetings I've been here I've told you how overworked Dakota is I've also told you that the manual says should they planning on working this lab and all your labs in the district for 10 years average age of a lab is 10 years folks don't you think we might want to readdress what's going on with

124the therapy dog program just ask me I got ideas thank you thank you Gabby thiaga hello hi my name is Gabby tiaga thank you for allowing me to speak tonight I was at the last meeting and was able to listen to public comments about Dakota the dog and then board members speak about safety concerns and opportunities one spoke of their feelings and safety as a member of this board which I found a bit insulting considering they don't seem very concerned about the feelings and safety of the girls in our district a grown woman wants to pass policies to muzzle board members on social media which to remind you is a violation of the First Amendment instead of focusing on passing policies to protect our girls safety and spaces another member gave a very personal insight

125into how she became the woman she is she spoke of her mother's journey through school and having to take the path forced upon her because she was a girl I quote because at that time girls had to take this and boys took that when the time came for her to have her own children she wanted better she wanted more opportunities for her girls those opportunities exist because of the original title 9 ruling implemented in 1972 any woman who was before born before 1972 was born with fewer opportunities than this board member's mom wanted for her girls I was born after 1972 I won't say what year exactly and I was born with all the opportunities I could ever have I went my whole life knowing I could study and play any sport my daughter was

126born in 2008 with the same opportunity as me but in her lifetime she has to witness her space and safety be put in Jeopardy by boys who want what's hers now on to public comments about Dakota I won't lie I do love that dog my daughter has been out of this district for two years and still speaks highly of her that all being said it's very frustrating that this community seems more concerned about a dog than their daughters and sister safety and future opportunities in August of this year the United Nations issued a report called the violence against women and girls its causes and consequences according to the information received by March of 24 March of 2024 over 600 female athletes in more than 400 competitions have lost more than 890 medals in 29 different

127sports lots of numbers think about that those are just the numbers of medals not the opportunities taken from them not the scholarships lost and not the number of girls who gave up just because it was easier to be quiet so again I remind everyone science taught by this District teaches our children that women and girls have XX and men and boys have XY this District fought hard to follow the science when it came to mask and disregards it when it comes to the safety of our girls and young women our girls continue to be collateral damage in the social experiment I will end with a quick quote um we deserve a chance to compete and win so don't be nice don't be careful and be honest and be brave fight for women we've come too

128far to give up now and if you agree with that stand up and stand with us thank you thank you Karen Mitchell good evening my name is Cara Mitchell and my husband is Brian Mitchell we are parents of one alumni from 2024 and we currently have a seventh grader in the district I am here this evening to talk about our classroom sizes within the district recently we went to parent teacher conferences and that was when it really became an eyeopener for us our daughter is struggling with English she is currently two grade levels behind my husband and I were shocked to hear this we asked what can be done to help our out help our daughter get up to grade level maybe staying after school for help or during class time is there extra help

129available sadly her teacher has absolutely no extra time to help her she would love to help but her hands are tied she not only teaches seventh grade she also teaches eighth grade our classroom sizes reaching sometimes 35 children makes it impossible to focus on these children that are struggling how exactly are we going to get our children proficient on in these basic Common Core subjects I've gone to board meetings I've eem administrators and I've spoken to teachers in this District everyone agrees our classroom sizes are way too big yet no one has a plan of action to fix fix this all while my child who is in school 40 hours a week is still struggling struggling to be profession at her grade level please help me understand how to fight to fix this her teachers

130cannot help her in the free time because they have absolutely no free time we want to be the voice for our teacher teachers and children but need to know where to take this fight the teachers union the Department of Education how can we fix this I want to work with our teachers and the administration our children are suffering in this District this is a subject we have been battling for so many years we are open to any and all suggestions or collaborations so that our children and teachers can be heard I know we send board me members to conferences every year to support supposedly advocate for our kids but when do we start advocating to solve this problem and in the meantime when do we stop making excuses about funding and Staffing and everything else

131and just find a way to get it done you want our students and staff to be strong be resilient figure it out but we cannot keep failing at every turn I stand with our students our teachers and our families we need to solve this problem ASAP and I expect some type of response from somebody on this board thank you Nancy van [Applause] Len good evening um I'm here to Echo what has already been stated about Mrs kasag Grande who I shall call Peggy because I consider her a good friend we've served together in many capacities over the past years um and as I look at the board table with new members even some of you who have served many years um it's my real hope that you will all make a special attempt to emulate

132Mrs Casa Grande Peggy and the work she has done for this board um she's a consumate board member she through her leadership time was able to keep common peace she has had some extraordinary circumstances as a board president and was able to um muster her way through all of that with calm and dignity and patience she shows that same patience I believe in her dealings with all of the uh people that she deals with on a board level uh I have such admiration for her ability to recall even the minute details about things that have happened happened during her term as a board member um she can probably tell you the date of some of our hires or some of the conferences or some of the um issues that we've dealt with I I truly

133believe that she was there for the right reasons she cared about the staff she cared about the students she cared about the families in our district she cared about the Wald Lake School District as a whole whole her reason for being there was to give to help to influence for good um I can't think of a better board member and it is my hope that those of you who are new to the board those of you who have been there those of you who have been there forever that you will remind yourselves of that kind of dignity of that kind of ability of that kind of caring and bring that forth as you carry on so thank you Peggy thank you for being a friend thank you for your years of dedication to this school

134district thank you Ron lipet thank you madam president Thunder Steelers all of you uh allow me to welcome uh incoming board members Lisa West and Mike Smith and congratulate again uh Mr Sigler and Mrs Crafton uh next month uh what a moment to be part of this esteemed body given the important work to be handled in this session but uh before I get to that I would be remiss to pass up the opportunity to share a few words about Peggy kasag Grande uh on this her final appearance as a w Lake School Board member uh if I do this right uh this will be a delicate mix of both praise and humor uh I've gotten a nisca ground these past two years uh and to State the obvious she's incredibly gifted uh she is talented

135she is truly caring uh she is an asset to this body and we will miss her impact uh on this community greatly uh especially in the days to come uh Mrs Kasa Grande can be uh described in superlatives uh one of them I might use is prepared uh many of you don't know this but uh she holds on to every board document she's ever accured over her 16 years years uh of service and I I just assume she's got some kind of great vault in her basement uh for this very purpose uh I'm assuming some kind of whole cabinet or filing system devoted uh to some kind of organization uh I suspect this because uh she dumped uh many of these documents on me uh when I uh uh joined the board service last year

136saying something along the lines of here read this call me with questions uh and that's exactly what happened so to Mrs West uh to Mr Smith uh good luck be warned uh you got a little time still with her uh mostly I wanted to express a personal thanks to her for taking on this role uh she does it with absolute dedication and professionalism as has been uh shared at this Podium uh I've said this many times uh Miss Cas Grande Peggy you are a perfect template uh for board Service uh and I hope that generations to follow uh will see your example uh as how best to be an unflinching advocate for our students our staff uh and our community as a whole uh so as a parent of three daughters who benefited directly uh

137from your leadership uh please allow me to express my thanks while I still can uh may your basement be filled with travel and biking related materials uh in the future uh with my remaining time uh please allow me to express my thanks overall to the board uh for your professionalism uh your flexibility your transparency during the district repurposing process uh yes this is a necessary part of board service to sometimes make tough decisions uh using data and trending uh I particularly appreciate the board's attention to our community's feedback in listening carefully to concerns to have the willingness to Pivot based on input and to arrive at the best decision you can uh under the circumstances I know some conclusions are not fun uh I recognize there's never a perfect answer in tasks like this uh

138especially in cases where families are impact so uh thank you for your hard work and dedication and all that you do and towards strengthening uh our district for the future uh lastly I just would like to remind folks that at Wake Central this weekend uh Friday through Sunday is one block stories uh and it is a fantastic event I hope all of you have seen and will participate in and with that I say thank you very much thank you so we're going to move on to the consent agenda see on the consent agenda we have the approval of the minutes from November 7th 2024 from our regular meeting Personnel recommendations Financial reports um disbursements in the amount of 28,749 797 we have the Head Start director's report and we have bid Awards over $50,000 Dr

139Lans oh no we need to go back to oh I'm sorry I'm sorry Mrs C yes Mrs Grande sorry I'm jumping we're good the I move that the Board of Education approve the consent agenda as presented all those in favor I opposed motion carries 70 now we'll move on to Dr LW thank you I'm very excited about bid pack number eight the W Lake Consolidated School District solicit and receive bids for the wal Lake Northern High School operations and maintenance and renovations to Wild Lake Central mechanical upgrades identified to be funded through the 2019 Bond proceeds the bid process was facilitated through mutual effort of our Administration TMP PMR a and the whole team the recommendation from the team is to award the big bid package as Rec to the recommended contractor excuse me as

140the lowest responsive biders in an amount not to exceed 17,682 5623 I usually don't have to read the numbers has hard including all the recommended Alternatives just some highlights as to what this is going to what where the work is going to be done at Northern there's uh demo work in this and we'll put on some really great looking roofs we'll be working with the panels This will be really exciting we get new windows which will help us with our efficiencies Rel related to energy we'll be doing some new flooring we'll have some painting done the auditorium seating will be replaced uh both gyms will be air conditioned and there'll be some addition additional cameras and replacing of cameras uh the operations will'll be doing some demos some Roofing some windows painting the bathrooms will

141get renovated at operations and we'll have a significant amount of Paving where the buses are parked so we have a new Paving area in that particular location and at w Lake Central it's uh demoing doing the mechanical work and then painting afterwards this this Le now it's my turn to read the number sorry I moveed that the Board of Education approve the bid award for wlcsd 2019 Bond projects bid package number eight for wal Lake Northern operations and maintenance Renovations and Wald Lake Central mechanical upgrades for an amount not to exceed 17,682 5623 funded from Bond proceeds as recommended by the project team support any discussion all those in favor I opposed motion carries 70 contract for security glazing Services Dr L thank you madam president well Lake sality School District list and receive bids

142for security glazing for identified areas throughout the district to promote Safety and Security the bid was facilitated through the mutual efforts of administration TMP PMR and a construction the recommendation from the team is to award the contract to Michigan glass Coatings who is the lowest responsive bidder in an amount not to exceed $2 4,234 I move that the Board of Education authorized the superintendent to enter a contract with Michigan glass Coatings to provide security glazing services in an amount not to exceed $ 24,23461 audience as well what is the lifetime warranty on this is there a lifespan of use there's a warranty with it I I apologize I don't know whether it's 10e or lifetime but there is a warranty with that I can get that back to you okay thank you any other questions

143all those in favor I opposed motion carries 70 facility study recommendation Dr L thank you madam president at this point I'll turn it over to Mr Wills M pres and Dr lions and board members all right perfect thank you um so again tonight uh is taking a look at the repurpose of gisler uh Middle School relative to the um kind of a continuation of the 2018 2023 facility utilization planning study um at the end of the day um some of the goals and objectives again coming off the 2018 uh plan uh obviously you can see the decreased enrollment uh we were actually talking uh with several other districts who have similar experiences of of making some of these tough decisions but again a decrease of roughly 3,400 students over the last 12 years um predominately

144at the high school or I'm sorry at the middle school levels um again the purpose of this facility was really to truly identify which those four middle schools could potentially be repurposed um these goals were actually to look for spaces for adult transitions I believe you heard from an individual tonight about some of the benefits of of gisler being um recommended from that perspective um also in the bond program the 2024 Bond as Mr dony mentioned there are funds for all three remaining middle schools as well as for Geer being repurposed um going forward uh again at the end of the day um we took a look at the existing four um middle schools taking a look at the 12 elementary schools how ultimately they would go to a three Middle School to a three

145High School transition and this is really the work of about 60 people over two and a half months time period in September October with several updates to the board through that process um with really some of the goals is to reduce the number of splits um also to determine the new spaces for ATP so again um right now this is the current feeder pattern with the 12 elementary schools the four middle schools and three high schools um currently there are no splits of Elementary two school so it's pretty important as the committee looked at that and also taking a look at the splits currently in place potentially reducing from the current existing number so this is the existing boundaries of the elementary schools as it stands today and again the existing boundary Middle School at

146the high school um or I'm sorry at the middle school level going forward with the four middle schools in consideration so the original proposal um again took a look at keeping the elementary school SCH all together so that was one of the major concerns and also potentially looking at ultimately into the middle school into the high school theater patterns and here you can see one of the results um again does that in terms of um I'll call it the spatial relations if you will but some of the things we heard from that was what about Transportation what about breaking up the current feeder pattern of Elementary ultimately to uh to the high school level going forward so one of the things you're going to see tonight is the recommended proposal um again gisler is still

147being recommended fa facility for being repurposed uh the three I would main would be smart Walnut Creek and Banks uh with this proposal uh there is the opportunity to reduce the number of splits um but also maintain the current elementary to the high school pattern which we'll talk about here in a little bit I'm going forward um some of the other uh considerations that we took a look at uh was taking a look again dedicating that space uh at Geer for the new um ATP what changed from the original to the revised uh again was being the least disruptive and anytime you go from four middle schools to three there will be there will be some disruptions um again maintaining that current High School feeder pan is also very important uh transportation did look at

148both models and the model the revised model that you do see uh does actually um have less transportation and also the need to adjust bell times um because of the travel distances between the two going forward um taking a look um we took a look at Banks um the the revised does allow us for future growth so the good news is in each of these models going forward you're about 85 to 90% utilized which again does allow for some capacity of growth and as I mentioned the revised uh repurpose recommended proposal does maintain that current High School feeder pattern as it currently States some of the other considerations again we talk about keeping the elementary schools together um again this does recommended proposal does reduce those splits from three down to two and as mentioned

149uh the L Lake students uh they go to Banks and ultimately go to Wall Lake as it currently stands and then the same thing for um metal Bri in terms of leing Creek and then they'll go to Wal Lake western as they currently do so with that I'm going to turn it back over to um Madame President uh Dr L and the board for any questions thank you any questions Mr seet no no questions okay thank you thank you much Mrs Kaplan do you want who you want to read it go okay I move at the Board of Education approve the facility study recommendation as presented support discussion love since this motion is not Crystal Clear can somebody clarify exactly what that recommend is uh Mr will do you mind going back to a couple

150slides before magic so the motion is to repurpose gisler and to have that as a new feeder pattern thank you yes ma'am so I'll continue back to the discussion yep go ahead Miss L all right so um I prepared some comments so that I don't uh fall off track here um the community has spoken both tonight and through dozens and dozens of emails over the last several weeks um we can't say that the majority of the facilities committee agreed when barely half of the committee even responded and a very small majority of that barely half only 21 people were in support of the most recent map the map up here um the committee felt disenfranchised the community feels disenfranchised and for what what's the hurry why not get it right right now the presentation we

151just watched set a goal was three middle schools to three high schools now for people inside the ketchup bottle that might just mean literally three buildings and three buildings but for a parent who saw the presentation in September that meant the same three middle schools go to their three high schools and so up until November 7th the community thought the very first map was the map we received no feedback as board members that there was a problem with that map it wasn't until that map changed on November 7th that all of a sudden that was a problem and um you said in the presentation you wanted it to be the least disruptive but disruptive to whom as a parent of teenagers it doesn't take much to disrupt a teenager sometimes just saying good morning to

152a teenager is enough to set them off so I digress my own children have gone through what is being proposed tonight for us to vote on they're going to a different High School than their middle school classmate are going to sure this was by our choice we left the district and they're still with the kids that they went to elementary school with in the district but it has been difficult for them those friendships don't come back we can sit here and say all day that these kids will reconnect with their Elementary School classmates but that will not happen we can sit here all day and say that kids are resilient but how resilient do our kids kids need to be to keep dealing with the decisions of the wal Lake School Board and the administration

153we forced them to learn virtually during covid and then we forced them to wear masks when they went back to school and now we're trying to force a decision that the parents of the very children who will be affected by this don't support in a recent discussion with my kids high school princi le excuse me for one second I know you guys are all passionate but please keep your comments and let Miss Levan finish without inter Interruption thank you in a discussion that I recently had with my kids high school principal I was reminded of the mission statement of our district it starts our mission in partnership with parents and Community we should not take that lightly parents and the community matter more than what an auditing firm no offense Paul or numbers on a

154spreadsheet tell us numbers and money follow they do not lead we have a chance tonight to get this right and so I'm making an alternate motion I move that the Board of Education proceed with taking gisler offline repurposing it and with using the first map from September 26th as the redistricting plan a [Applause] second say I I appreciate you making the motion but we already have an motion on the table have to deal said you can have an amended motion it's been seconded and now we have to vote on it okay well let's vote and then we can move on from there no you have to open to discussion may may go ahead go ahead West um so I also have had concerns and I've expressed that to Dr LW and a few other board

155members so I also prepared a statement so I agree with the closure of Geisler due to space and enrollment compared to other middle schools um and to relocate the ESC and ATP I have concerns regarding the Middle School splits the original idea for the Bond as presented to the public was to have a feeder pattern from middle school to high school with no splits tax pairs voted on the bond and hopefully educated themselves in the vote with knowledge that changes would have to be made I understand that some people are concerned regarding changing high schools due to the no splits those already in high school can either attend the new school they are assigned to or do an in District transfer I have already been informed by been informed by Dr LW that current 9th

156through 11th graders would not be grandfathered into their current School even if Transportation was not provided by the district which I suggested I understand we cannot make everyone happy but not having splits in the feeding pattern makes the most long sense long term because I'm not looking at the shortterm when I look at the long-term goals families who are being affected by the change most are Geisler Meadowbrook and L link families so I was glad to see that the map was changed from November's meeting that sent Lon Lake students across the district to Walnut when Sarah Banks is in our backyard however I believe September's original map with no splits makes the most sense I would like to see Lon Lake's students feed into Sarah Banks then to Western with the rest of banks students

157also and metal Brook's students with should feed into wet Creek and then to Central with the rest of Creek students um with the exception of Clifford Smart the three other middle schools already encountered splits many students do transfers to avoid avoid splits whether at the start of middle school or or at high school to follow along with friends they made in middle school so my own family did this as a Glen Gary family we felt it was best to follow to CHS to Northern then Creek to Northern allowing my children to adapt better in the future as they already knew students from other schools they would be attending CHS so it's easy for them to transition other Glen Gary families who chose to follow the creek feeder pattern have then chose to transfer to Central

158as they made friends that they did not want to partner with in Middle School I believe that having no splits helps students who may deal with social anxiety since they know who they are already surrounded by Middle School years are essential to formulating relationships and I believe they are crucial to carry on to high school for a majority of children again taxpayers voted for this bond to close a middle school and to include no splits from middle school to high school so let's carry out what the taxpayers agreed to in their yes vote to the bond thank you any other discussion Mr seagler so as a as a parent of a child and I've I'm going to repeat myself for those of you who haven't heard this my daughter started kindergarten at Twin Sons grades

159one through four were at Maple grades five and six were at the school that we leased in Birmingham grade seven was in the Portables at Western or at at Wall Lake Middle grade eight in in the classroom and you're shaking your head so you remember all of this and then 9 through 12 was at Western I asked my daughter last week to interrupt here's where I need to interrupt according to Robert's rules once you have made a motion it has been seconded and we are discussing it needs to be finished I am on Page 5.5 and 5.4 of Robert's Rules we can not have the secondary motion we have to consider the first motion first was made on the floor right here so if I it's right here otherwise you would completely filibuster you have

160to finish the first motion so so anyways I asked my daughter you need to take the other motion off and go back to the other motion okay I asked look up and share the alternative because a couple of us have been through Robert so have I so have I so have I it's right here so anyway anyway anyway Mr SE Mr seagler can speak and then we will discuss which way we were going with the Motions so I asked my daughter who is now a young parent how she liked it she said Dad the adults were making a bigger issue of this than the children were she said as long as we were with our friends in within the neighborhood we were much happier than if we would have been split up now I realize

161what we're looking at right now is maintaining the split the way it is now the other thing we have to look at is this was not a redistricting effort this is a repurposing of a building where where we are going to have to make some modifications and unfort and I'm sorry because we are not looking at redistricting will we be looking at redistricting in 5 years maybe it's possible as we look as at enrollment changes it is very possible that we could be doing that but we have to we as parents you know when I've listened to the crowd tonight I hear Lon Lake you know maintain go to Banks go to Western and then but you still have a group of parents there that are doing Lon Lake that we'll be doing banks and

162then would be going to Central there's still a small pocket of of students that'll be up there so at this point I'm okay with making the modification for the facility study as it is presented with the mod with the changes that we have made and then looking at redistricting as we have to in probably 5 years thank you Mr zagler any other comments Mr Smith I just want to say maybe point of information can we take a recess to have the time to look up is that good yes thank you um before we go before we do that does anybody have any specific question comment Mr Wills did you no okay I had one that has nothing to do with how we resolve the motion go ahead go ahead Mrs Fernandez yeah so I just

163wanted to say that in my personal opinion and that matters little as the board because we operate as a group and um but in my personal opinion it would be nice to be able to ask for a delay and to sort this out but we have had conversations that indicate that there is some reasonable time expediency and this is the second board meeting in a row um that we have things that need to pass now or you know or things will go around and so I think I've spoken before about not being super excited about that um I would like the time so that when we have an item of great import to the community we actually can have an alternative that is to take a step back and make sure that we're either you

164know doing another bit of diligence or you know or figuring it out and the time between one meeting and another doesn't seem like too much to ask but um I I do want to mention that that question was asked and answered as we were talking about it um you know in some of our conversations and the information that's there so um you know either the either we ask to delay and then that causes some grave damage or we just look at which of the proposals are we about to vote on and you know in my opinion I would really like to make sure that we get things on agendas and I have really no role and making sure what gets on an agenda when um with enough time to be able to reasonably say I'd

165like to delay this to the next meeting and this is the second time that there's been a huge issue like that and um that is what I wanted to say about this um and I hope that people will start to understand in the community that we are asking for delays and um and that is a natural first step and if it seems like we're not we're just wanting to be you know like poop on the you know poop on the agenda thing that that's not what's happening behind the scenes so it would be great to be able to say can we have some more time and I feel like that's not an option thank you we're gonna follow Mr Smith we're going to take a 10-minute recess um and we will be back about 9:31

166thank you e e e sorry I'm a few minutes late so we're back in session at 9:36 um I'm going to give the floor to Dr Lon to share the attorney information thank you thank you madam president based on our attorney's recommendation we must deal with the first motion first unless and Mrs Byer who is the person that made the original motion Mrs C Grande you have the opportunity to accept the amendment as a friendly Amendment if you say yes to that then that now becomes what we vote on and the first motion does exist anymore if you do not accept that then we must deal with the first motion first before which means going through discussion and voting that's how the process has to play out and that was my understanding thank you for

167um confirming that and I do not accept the second motion and I want to consider the first motion that was on the table okay so now we're back to do we want to clarify the motion so that everybody understands while we go back to discussion yes no yes okay the motion that's on the um table is that the Board of Education approv the facility study recommended recommendations as presented which were what Mr Wills presented and to us with the feeder patterns the way they were that was the recommendation so now we're on to discussion with regards to furthering that yes go ahead Miss West um so to clarify it's the closed Geisler and the two elementary schools will be affected the major majorly will be Lon Lake and metal Brook with metal Brook going on

168from Creek to Western and then met Creek to Western and then Lon Lake to Banks and then Central is that correct okay that's what we are voting on okay I want to mic's off but that that is correct thank you yes that's correct go ahead Mrs Fernandez yeah I have this just the same comment that I had before I really think it would behoove us to have a little bit of extra time to socialize and get stakeholder engagement and while we've had the discussion I'm wondering if um if Dr L you might um Express what the timel what the time urgency is so that it's clear why we have to do this now and we can't wait if that is ined your recommendation sure we're following a timeline that we set out in August and

169the reason why the vote was set up the way that it was is that as if this is approved approved we then have to redistribute the current sixth and seventh graders from gisler they would then go to their respective new middle schools and during that time they would have the opportunity to register for courses so that we can build our course schedule so that we can place our teachers we have and not just teachers we have a number of staff that at gisler need to be placed moving into the 25 26 school year and to make sure that we can do that appropriately and efficiently we need the time to do that so po postponing this vote would not allow us the time to get the schedules to do the scheduling and to place the

170teachers in a fashion in which we're accustomed to in the district and if I can just clarify those activities that you mentioned that have to get done have to get done not immediately or not during this school year but in advance and in preparation to happen in the coming school year is that correct if we are to repurpose gisler we need to do it now if we are to continue students at gisler this would be we'd be in the same spot this time in 2025 okay okay so the the bit that um the bit that applies to gisler happens immediately what about um the bit that happens with the feeder patterns well the feeder patterns help toine how we build our transportation department okay and would and would also help that would also be part

171of our industri transfer if someone wanted to maintain or change their feeder pattern the industri transfer has to be done at the same time which is at the beginning of January because we need to know what students are going to what schools okay and that applies then that all of that Transportation stuff applies in the new school year correct yes ma'am thank you I thought that would be helpful to share for thank you for the questions Mrs Kaplan Mrs Cas Grande so I'd like us to think a little higher level and here's where I'm going with this we have a fiscal responsibility to this District we have a we looked at utilization the first part of this study was to look at what percent of utilization we had in our buildings and to see if

172there's any course correct that we potentially needed to look at and one of the things we then came to is that I believe we had about 60% is uh sometime utilization in uh the middle schools and so that's not fiscally responsible to have 60% typically you want to have around 80 to 90% right and we even have a goal that is set up for the superintendent around that and we have asked our employee the superintendent to go execute this for us so that's one two we have a special education program called adult transition program ATP the last time that we had a bond here we were not able to do everything that we wanted to do we had some changes those students students are looking and they're waiting for us to do something for them

173so that they can continue to succeed it's another piece that we need to be thinking about ultimately the reason we're doing this is because there's reduced number of students and it's not just here it's in other places absolutely these are difficult situations absolutely we are not going to make everybody happy but we have had a lot of people involved in this and we have asked our employee the superintendent he didn't do this on his own he talked with a lot of people he had a committee we heard from people who were not happy and we went back to the committee we followed the process and the protocol we need to be working at a higher level here I've been through this before this is repurposing I've been through redistricting this is repurposing this is different

174it also will allow us on down the line to no longer have this building again reducing our footprint being more fiscally responsible and putting the ESC inside the repurposed gisler building there are so many high level things that we need to be looking at as a board and I implore us to do that thank you go ahead Mrs so I just want to make sure it's Crystal Clear I have no problem repurposing Geisler and being fiscally responsible relocating ATP to its own home moving the ESC to a different building taking this building offline no problem the difference is I believe that the map from 926 is the map we should follow that's it if the costs are negligibly the same fiscally doesn't matter it matters to the parents it matters to the families it matters

175to the students for things that people aren't even thinking about right now that's it [Applause] so I agree with M Kasa Grande regarding the higher vision and I am looking at the higher Vision I agree with the guys are closing and that we are accommodating ATP and a more permanent solution I think that that's necessary um metal Brook and Loom Lake both have similar enrollments so that's why I'm thinking that being that the enrollment in itself is not going to change all that drastically since you're looking at maybe 10 20 students so I think that we need to consider that and make sure we're not having splits because it's really imp imperative for our middle school students to move on with their friends um to reduce that mental and social anxiety um and I think

176that once they already make those bonds especially whether they're acad academically um gifted or challenged they depend on those students already and um their friends and are able to develop that so they may go ahead and be more successful academically so I think this is something we really need to consider that we just make that switch to the September map thank you Mr Smith president uh I just have a couple I guess questions for Dr Lon uh what number of potential kids would become or would be offered potentially in District School of Choice if they're requested to move to their current feeder pattern high school are are you referring to the LOM Lake hiss students are currently TI being Central yeah we we'd have about 66 students as of today that would have to make

177it that would have to try to get back to Central if we change the feeder pattern to Western and can we handle everyone potentially if they did request that change yes it would be for metal Brook it would be 187 students that would have to request industry transfer would they get uh I don't know how the best to say it but the the front of you know the first for our high schools both both of our high schools have enough room that can accommodate any request for industry transfer now there's some other parts to that yes and the biggest part is for industry transfers we do not provide transportation so for someone to maintain their current high school they would have to figure out how to get there what would be the timeline for to

178measure this to see would it be you know on a year after the first year the metrics of how we're seeing what Transportation issues that might be arising with uh traffic whatever the the patterns might be are you going to come back to us within six months a year two years to potentially have to maybe relook at uh true redistricting I was part of redistricting as well uh over 12 years ago and I understand these decisions are tough uh you cannot please everyone uh you're doing what's best interest of the school so I'm just curious what what would be the measurable metrics at what points would we see moving forward so the plan that we're voting on at this particular moment would not affect traffic flow it would not affect number of cars any any

179more than any other year that it would the what I would recommend as a general concept and this is best practice is every 3 to five years in a district that's in decreasing enrollment which we still are that we would conduct another facility study the advantage that we have if we do it within that time frame is that plant Moran real Point that's part of the contract we already have with them so there' be no additional cost to do that and I I believe that that would be the most appropriate time to do it because that would give a complete cohort of middle school students to go through middle school and that would allow us to confirm where the students are going and what the current enrollment is in our high schools follow up with

180that uh you know as a parent as well uh what about the social emotional needs of the students handling these changes we know about resilience we know that not everyone handles things the same way uh what will we have in place for staff available for any potential issues that might arise so I'm I'm happy to say that we have Mrs gransky and Mr scaling are working with our Middle School principles right now and a a greater team to work on two parts of that one is is what additional programmingsoftware of this uh potential change I just of course want to make sure that's provided front and center to the district uh the first strength is it maintains the current High School feeder patterns and for our current high schoolers that is what's important for people

181that purchased homes in those areas when they actually to be clear for people that purchase homes in Lon lake that is a feeder pattern if they purchase in last 12 to 13 years that's one number two is it disrupts the least amount of students as of today so if this is implemented and implemented for 2526 it disrupts the least amount of students thank you Miss West um just another question regarding Staffing um those who have seniority in the district who we how will you guys determine who is um placed as far as Staffing goes would they have is it according to in District or versus in school I'm sorry when you say IND District in so if you so if a teacher has more seniority in Geisler versus a a first year teacher in say

182Creek who H who will be more likely like if you have to bump a teacher unfortunately I don't want to necessarily think this way but sure if this has to happen if we have to consider Staffing purposes will the teacher at Geisler with more seniority have the privilege of teaching or will the teacher with the first year because already at Creek have their position sure so Mr Hamp I'm gonna take a stab at this and then if I mess it up you can correct me okay uh I've had the opportunity to meet with the guer staff in person twice and Mr Hamin went over earlier this week I believe on Monday to to speak with them Mr hamka went over there to speak with them just on the topic that you you just asked about

183what the processes that we're using now in our contract with the wlea there's actual contract language when it comes to closing of building so it's a little bit different than typical restaffing that I've had the opportunity to do my predecessor now Mr Hamp has an opportunity to do and there's many factors that play into it in this particular case both times when I went to speak at Geisler and to the staff at gisler and when I say staff it's not just the teachers we're working with the secretaries we're working with food service working with all of our staff we do not see a situation in which anyone will be laid off so everyone that would like a job will have a job from every piece of data that we have right now so in your

184example who is placed at Creek there's a lot of variables that go into that but that first year teacher and you're I believe you said 25th year teacher yep I'm sorry just like an example 28th yeah they're both going to have jobs and so just like whenever we do placement there's a many variables that fall into that certification is one past experience is one evaluation is one seniority is a factor of that but it's not the only factor of that Mr amp did I do okay on that all right thank you I have a follow-up question then what about our more specialized teachers with certifications like uh in our music department PE things like that where that were're already covered throughout the district will they have an opportunity to have a job St yeah vocal

185music is a great example of that that right now we have two vocal music teachers for four middle schools when we go to three middle schools we will need three vocal music teachers because as we combine we can increase that programming again and so when it comes to the encore which are electives in the middle school I believe that we will have a spot for all of them now will it be the same spot that they're in right now and by that I mean the specific classes that they're teaching it might not be right that's just the reality but that's the same reality that they faced and that I faced as a teacher when I was teaching right and so we will do our very best we've committed to that I I'd like to applaud

186the associations because they've been working with us on this process we've we've been developing plans together to make sure that when we have unique situations like this that we're doing what's in the best interest of the district our students and our staff Mrs Fernandez I have a question um I think I heard it said more than once that um one of the different diff one of the differentiators is we won't necess we don't we could but we don't necessarily provide transportation to the to the families or the kids that want to choose to go to the other school right but it sounds like we could like you know maybe is that a decision yet to be made is it uh something that we can commit to do since we've got Spanky new buses and we

187have you know folks that voted on a $250 million Bond probably thinking that they were going to have that feeder pattern is that maybe something that we can commit to do so that um so that families don't have to worry about Transportation if they choose to go to the alternative feeder plan that is not what we're voting on tonight yeah so I think a point of clarification because I I did go through the bond presentations never was feeder pattern mentioned as a part of the bond presentation the part of the bond presentation related only to the middle school and were we closing a middle school or repurposing a middle school that was the only thing that we talked about during the bond presentation secondly we don't have enough drivers so even if we had enough

188buses we don't have enough drivers to do double bus runs for three years nor nor do I believe that that would be financially responsible for us to do that so we won't it's not it's not I just said we don't have enough drivers no well that's a hiring thing right I suppose everything's a hiring thing yes yeah okay but it's not that we have it and we're choosing not to do it it's that we don't have it and we we haven't had it for three years yeah okay um and I don't know if I understand what you're saying about guer being the focus but I think the one chart that um plant Moran showed us tonight pretty clearly had the schools mapped correct but that was not part of the bond presentation in May that's

189what you stated if I unless I misunderstood what you said I apologize no not in May then the September one right that had nothing to do with the bond passing oh yeah so if I misunderstood I apologize that's on me um that's it thank you very much okay we're gonna call for a vote all those in favor of the motion I I opposed motion carries 43 can you call so that we know sure sure we will Mrs vyer can you do a roll call please yeah of course Mrs C Grande yes Mrs Fernandez uh nay no Mrs Len n Mr seagler yes Mr Smith yes Mrs West Mrs Kaplan yes thank you thank you we're going to move on to I keep turning my mic off we're going to move on to the appointment of

190the architect um Dr Lon for more than 35 years TMP architecture Inc in Bloomfield Hills has provided architectural Design Services for new construction and Renovations across the district TMP has always a committed collaborative customer focused design process partner that results in attractive facilities that are functional and meet the instructional needs of the students and staff of w l Consolidated School District the administration recommends continuing use of TMP architecture and architectural services not to exceed 1,779 c0 for the 2024 Bond program on a personal note I I have enjoyed working with TMP and getting to know them better I appreciate the perspective that they have in our district and the history that they have in our district and I I look forward to continuing to work with them Mr I move that the Board of Education

191hire and appoint TMP architecture Inc to provide architectural services not to exceed 11,779 $130 for the 2024 Bond program support discussion okay all those in favor I opposed motion carries 7 Z resolution limited schools of choice Dr Lans turn over to Mr scaling thank you Dr Lans for many years wal Lake Consolidated Schools has been open to Section 105 schools of choice under the state school aid act under this section a pupil May enroll from one Oakland County School District to another the administration is requesting that the Board of Education approve wad Lake Consolidated Schools as a participant in Section 105 limited schools of choice for the 2526 school year with a designation of school openings not to exceed 5% of the most recent October count in any individual school and not to exceed 10%

192of the most recent October count for the 2526 school year specific to kindergarten Mrs Kaplan Mrs Mrs CAG Grande I move that the Board of Education approved administration's recommendation that the district participate in Section 105 limited schools of choice for the 2025 2026 school year and the school openings to be designated by Administration not to exceed 5% of the most recent October count in any individual School with the exception of increasing the kindergarten openings not to exceed 10% of the most recent October count in any individual School support discussion Mrs Kaplan Mrs Casa Grande a question are there any schools that would be closed to school of choice for kindergarten or would they all be open do we know I can give you the right now the historical perspective is that we do have a

193few schools that close even at the 10% Commerce is typically closed at some point and uh Dublin would also be closed even at the 10% all the rest of our schools historically have openings at the 10% level okay thank you any other discussion Mr Smith M president I just have a quick question what is the total that we have currently your school's Choice 93 is that showing historically that we've been consistent or is it dipped down or gone up or slightly down from last year uh slightly up from two previous years okay thank you any other questions Miss West um regarding School of choice for staff members um do they have do they take precedence as far as getting School of Choice which which school they want and um are they available to go to

194schools that may have it closed otherwise so staff members do have uh preference over non-staff School of Choice so when a staff member asks it it's not technically School of choice but when they our staff member do the the employee relationship they're allowed to bring their students to W Lake if we have room we can accommodate them at the school of their choice but for example as someone mentioned earlier today if we had 35 students in a class at sixth grade we wouldn't be able to put them in that particular building it's more likely than not we have room any other okay all those in favor I opposed motion carries 70 moving on to resolution Michigan Association of school boards masb board of directors group six nomination the Michigan Association of school boards director board

195of directors is comprised of 22 members 16 directors elected from the eight regions two elected from each one director from each groups five six and seven and three at large directors group and region director are elected by active members school boards and each year several seats are up for election article 8 section 7 of the masb bylaws permit local school districts to nominate masb board of directors candidates for open positions the wle School Board of Education will vote to nominate Mr Mark Zigler as a candidate to represent the masb board of directors group six school districts with a pupil membership of 11,1 to 40,000 for a three-year term I'm gonna give this one to miss West sorry she's new she gets preferential treatment um I moved at the Board of Education approved the nomination of

196Mr Mark seagler to represent the M Michigan Association of school boards director of group six and that the nomination be submitted by the January 8th 2025 deadline for consideration supp any discussion thank you for doing that Mark I would just like to say thank you Mr seagler for doing that all those in favor I opposed congratulations Mr seagler motion carry 70 moving on to administrative commentary Dr LW thank you madam president we'll jump around here today we'll start with Mr hampa good evening everyone I am excited to share with you that we are in full swing with the teacher of the year um celebration and and identifying our teachers of the year for the celebration in January I am I've had the opportunity to work the with the teacher of the year committee and we

197were so impressed by all the nominations and the dedication hard work and passion that our teachers bring to the our buildings every day and I'm just looking forward to celebrating them in January thank you sir Miss Mir thank you Dr Lans um just want to highlight um some of our work in special services with continuing to establish relationships with our parent community and also in supporting parent engagement and part of that this year is that we worked with our pack um our parent advisory committee to establish a four-part series where parents can come in and have um opportunities to do conferences before the parent advisory committee meetings and then we would do a workshop for the last hour and so that has been exciting we've had two meetings um thus far the school year one

198one in October um and then again in November our next one is going to be in January where we'll do conferences to start off and then there'll be some my able planning and um special needs planning opportunities learning opportunities for parents so we're really excited about continuing that partnership and increasing parent engagement and also providing some parent education and support thank you thank you very much Mrs ommer thank you Dr Lans um first of all I wanted to thank the board for in June the board at that time approved the purchase of informed K12 which is a workflow management system for those of you just as a reminder but essentially that is it's an electronic way to move the paper around the district in a more efficient way so that that way we're utilizing less

199time we're actually getting better information to be able to process those types of things inform K12 was brought forth by a collaboration of our our um several of our employees that looked at different options and was recommended at that time and the board was kind enough to approve that so I just wanted to little update you a little bit in regards to what the progress has been made since the end of June beginning of July we've done some collaboration on some business office forms we promised our leadership team that we try to start off slow give them the most Bay for their buck with some simple types of forms that would be easy for them to utilize and to get acclimated um we're we're looking forward to moving forward with more complex um types of

200procedures including some things of collaborating with HR for onboarding so that it makes it easier for not only our new employees but our current employees in terms of making some changes we've had some significant success with doing some extracurricular activities in terms of sending contracts out to employees which has expedited things and also will make sure that they get paid appropriately and have those contracts in place when the time comes so essentially we have about probably about 10 processes that are complete and in active currently um and about another 10 to 11 that are we're working on and then expecting a lot more to come in the future so we're very excited about that and appreciate the support that the board has provided for that process thank you very much Mr scaling thank you Dr

201Lon I have the privilege of uh working to help support Mr Brian swinhart uh uh lead's athletic department and I'd like to share a few highlights from our fall athletic uh teams and Seasons that they've just wrapped up their competitions first uh all three of our schools were able to field and compete in our uh the K unified soccer program six games for their season uh That season culminated with the klaa tournament that was held on October 29th at the leg Legacy Center in Brighton uh for Central some highlights from their athletic teams their Equestrian Team made it to Regionals uh for boys soccer we had five athletes make the academic All State one soccer athlete was selected to the boys soccer All State team uh for our Central football team 56% of the team

202was uh All lvc Conference academic and our tennis team we had one athlete uh from Central tennis team to make the All State team for w Lake Northern uh we had three of our football athletes make the academic All State our Equestrian Team for wal Lake Northern also made it to Regionals fining finishing fourth which was one step short of qualifying for the for the states uh we had one athlete State qualifier for boys boys cross country from Northern and our girls swim and dive we had one diver qualify for regionals three athletes qualify for state and individual events and the 200 freestyle team qualified for States as well uh girls golf from northern we had one golfer uh make the academic allate team from that sport boys tennis was LBC Champions our volleyball uh

203was academic team All State and individual academic all state had two athletes uh finally from Western uh our volleyball uh academic all state had six athletes uh we had a diver from the swim and dive team uh qualify for states the boys soccer team was um All State academic team five of those athletes individually academic All State and three individual Allstate honorable mention teams from the boy soccer team football uh for Western was LBC Champs District Champs they uh were first team academic All State and they had eight athletes that were individual academic All State as well so congratulations to all of our fall athletes coaches and parents on successful seasons and we wish our our winter seasons good luck as they get underway thanks you sir thank you sir Mr Durkin thank you Dr

204Lon and to certainly follow some of the athletic accolades it's been a very start to very busy start to the school year as everyone certainly knows uh that's still here with us tonight and uh just as with that being said it's been an equally busy month of November yeah and community relations getting ready for the next edition of learning uh that should be coming out uh later this month should be hitting a mailbox near you uh the digital Edition should be available as early as next week but I just want to give a special shout out to Pam Cole and Jason Lewis for all their hard work and really doing a great job summarizing the first third of the school year so thank you thank you Mr Drake Mrs quiny usually I'm first so I

205know I changed it up today you changed it up on me yeah so um as uh one of our public comments uh highlighted on the 19th we had some really excellent uh teacher-led professional developments so uh we had teachers teaching teachers which is always a great way uh to provide uh support for our staff um we gave them a variety of options so that staff had the ability to be able to pick it's sort of like that Choose Your Own Adventure anytime you give people choice in their learning um it really is motivating and it really is more engaging for folks rather than a a one-size fits-all kind of approach and so it was really great I want to thank all of the teachers that that volunteered to run sessions um and host those learning

206sessions uh the the PD was we we got a lot of great feedback from our teachers that they absolutely love that um at the secondary level we had our secondary teams that started to take a look at AI so I don't want to freak anybody out I don't want to scare anybody I know it's all very scary as Mr Seer and I talked about at the last Oakland County Schoolboard dinner where we had a keynote speaker that presented on artificial intelligence so I do want uh the board to know I will be sharing an update with some information but we gave uh kind of just a cursory foundational um knowledge building understanding to secondary staff at that November 19th meeting we'll be delving back into that um I'll be be sharing with the board some

207updates and things like that from some of the committee work there is a Statewide Summit coming up in December that uh a number of people from that AI T of edte committee um will be attending with me and some members from learning services so we'll be bringing a lot of that back we know that it's something that we need to be out ahead of because that technology is moving way faster than anybody could even imagine um I know uh as Mr seagler and Dr Lance Mr scaling and I um Mr hamka was there as well um we heard the keynote speaker from Michigan virtual uh but I can tell you that uh there even in the last two to three weeks there's even newer Technologies around AI that have come out and it just blows

208your mind that that things are are moving at a light speed when it comes to some of that so um we're on top of that we're we're definitely getting um getting work put around that so that we can communicate with um with all of you uh about how that's going so so we have that um and then really uh just highlighting uh one of the things that I wanted to mention that went along with my data presentation is the coaching piece we had a fantastic grade four five session at Keith yesterday uh we had fourth and fifth grade teachers inviting uh staff developers into model writing instruction and small group instruction which is that Focus for really delving into some of that work with vocabulary and informational text on this end it was the writing

209side of it um which is reciprocal with reading so I don't want anybody to think we're not paying attention to literacy because the writing pieces is equally as important and um just a wonderful learning opportunity we had representatives from all of our elementary schools there instructional Specialists I attended at the end of the uh end of the session to really see how things were going and rave reviews from staff Rave rave reviews from our instructional team um just really great learning going on and I'm excited to see the work that's taking place so I wanted to highlight that and thank the Keith staff and uh Debbie Faber their instructional specialist and Dr augenstein for hosting thank you thank you Mr kensy and for me since last we met I our team has had the opportunity

210to do some instructional visits I am confident that that is the favorite day whenever we have an opportunity to get into schools and hang out with with our with our kids it's fantastic we have dedicated caring staff and happy kids and it's it just as a highlight well other than probably our cabinet meeting but we'll set that aside winter sports and our concert season is in full swing so I know that miss buer is put out to everyone if you have opportunities to attend any of those please feel free to do that it's fantastic to see our students outside of the classroom as much as it see them in the classroom and finally Mrs kasag Grande it is has been my honor to work with you since I've been here in Wild Lake I found

211you to be kind thoughtful caring supportive direct and and and I appreciate that I I have many more but I I'm confident some of other board members will have some accolades for you so it is it is my pleasure to present you with this small token of great appreciation from not only our school Community the board our student staff everyone thank you for your service it's it's been our privilege thank [Applause] you okay I will open while you go on well I'm gonna start this way so this is Fernandez so I think I'm inspired to share a reflection at this time not only for the die hards that are still here for the cabinet for um for Dr Lans for my fellow board members discuss there's nothing wrong with discussion at the table and to

212be honest that's precisely what inspired me to run for this position is watching over a year and a half of no discussion and seven zero votes which didn't seem to be very reflective of the fact that there's a lot going on in the community so you know I I think that's important I think it's healthy in the end we work and operate and support each other as a collective board decision and in case it's not clear to everyone out there because the majority is where we go and so we have a definitive answer and it's fine to be able to have discussion at the table it's healthy it hasn't happened for years and um and in the end in case there are any doubts from anyone in the community we do all work together and

213support the outcome of our of our votes and our decisions as a board and so um for anyone that watches this in replay or worries about the health or the safety of our working environment like this is what it's supposed to be we're supposed to have conversations and it's not a bad thing um so thank you to everyone for um sharing opinions and thoughts it's a healthy process in my opinion Mrs West um well I'm excited to be able to sit up here so thank you to the community for voting me in um I appreciate those who have led before me and um are guiding me through this new Journey um so it's going to be interesting so please bear with me as I go through this I agree with Mrs Fernandez regarding the healthy

214discussion is something that has also been important to me I'd like to I enjoyed as a um audience member prior to this um when I would see discussions and I think it's beneficial for the community to really understand where each board member's perspectives are coming from um to be able to appreciate them more as far as upcoming events I'm really looking forward to northern's collage concert next week I it's always a phenomenal event I believe it's already sold out so um I haven't checked out into Central or Western at this point um due to scheduling but um I know that they always put on phenomenal performances so I'm looking forward to that thank you Mr Smith thank you madam president uh I'm humbled again and so honored to work with fellow board members and be

215back up in this seat uh the last time I was here there was uh 12 years ago I was through a different lens I was a 29-year-old uh graduate and love love the school that provided for me and here I am now a father of two children in the district so it's a quite a quite a new lens now just to have a middle schooler and uh to have an elementary uh kid as well and with that I I want to acknowledge the many teachers some of them as I've been sitting up here I've seen them go through retirements which is it's aging me more which I'm sure they feel aging them I want to acknowledge the many teachers that I've had uh I don't know how many people can actually remember all their elementary

216teachers but I can and so I want to say a thank you to Mrs Anderson Mrs Jones Miss chap who's actually still teaching uh Mrs love uh Miss Pence Mr Meyers miss boty Mr Sudbury Mr McBride Mrs George Mr shulkin Mr Riley Mrs lontine who saw something in me Mr Lewis Mrs mourich Mr Keno Mrs Goff Mr Lindsay Mr frin Mr Donahue Mr walock Mr Chapel Mr Darton Mr Hines Mr DeLuca Mr O Mrs rexroat Mrs pringer Smith and Ted and Ethel I don't know if anyone knew who they were at at walck Central but uh they were a fun time there I they gave us some great memories and even miss Karen who was my bus driver for so many years who had the route on Union Lake Road I still would randomly see

217her at Kroger and she would remember me so it was it was amazing to kind of see this this life come full circle these are all the many names of teachers there's so many other people as well and helpers and role models that kind of made me who I am as being a alumni of this district and a a personal CHS family note I want to recognize Mrs Bond who is actually on the agenda this evening for her retire IR uh I had the opportunity actually to join her class and speak about my 20-year government public service experience uh this afternoon uh in my daughter's uh classroom uh which was always fun for her and uh really uh I think to see I it was wonderful to to hear I provided about 10 minutes of

218conversation for what they liked about the school district and what they saw as opportunities for growth and other things and uh I'll present some of those wonderful ideas as I was the the beacon to bring to Dr Lans and to the fellow but it was wonderful to hear seventh graders clearly the first one why didn't we have a snow day today I was like it's Michigan come on but uh we'll get through this we'll have plenty other opportunities uh but it was a wonderful time to see what was going on in Design Tech uh she's done an amazing uh thing I walked into there and realized that was where I had wood shop uh all those years ago and to see the same room but now moving forward with modern technology and things that we're

219utilizing which was amazing and they had such Amazing Ideas uh for things and that's what we need to focus on you know we make decisions up here they're tough but we always have to think about uh the students and they're going to get through this we have to work together we have to be open now that our next our what we're charged with is how we're not going to communicate to the population to all the families to make sure that through this implementation through all these changes that we go through that we're communicating being there being present being empathetic and making sure that we're doing our job and I also want to thank Dr Lans for uh his responses to I think I had about five pages of questions uh stemming from the facility study

220so thank you for answering those uh Peggy I want to thank you uh for your service uh this is this get a short time with you but I was back from 2010 to 2013 uh you were a great you know a role model for for my fresh eyes on this board as like I said as a young young man there and to see you stick it out for 16 years has has been amazing so so I thank you for that we got one meeting here and we were we were back then I look back at it like I said we were in that redistricting discussion and here we are with here we are 12 years later so that's irony it is it is uh but here we are and uh just to follow it's a

221question and that I hopefully I can ask it I just want to know where we are because my Dublin family wants to know where we are with the Dublin principal search that's just a love to communicate that out there and uh I'm looking forward to Junior Lion King this weekend I was trying to find where it was at I just know it's happening can't remember where it's at but my daughter wants to go and to the CHS choir concert which is going to be on December 18th I look forward to that so that is all I have thank you Mrs Levan Mr seagler first of all I want to wish everybody a happy healthy holiday season be safe be wise take care of everybody was a very interesting night and I'm glad we are through

222over that and we can move on to other things that will face us uh in the future lastly to the young lady who's sitting to my right and I had to write I had to write this this afternoon because I didn't think I would be able to do this tonight or just do anything impromptu so Excuse me while I read from my phone Mrs kasag Grande Peggy when we first met you were a young mother of of elementary school children I remember sitting at a PTA meeting thinking to myself she would make a wonderful board member and even bringing it up to you you politely laughed and I believe you said to me when the time is right I might consider running I remember thinking to myself there is a very bright articulate charismatic charismatic

223individual sitting there with a stunning mind a very class quit who is not afraid to go out and tackle anything that was laid down in front of her whenever we needed the PTA to communicate with our representatives in laning and Washington you were at the Forefront of the legislative act activities in our PTA and a beacon for the district I sit here tonight wanting to thank you for everything that you have done for the community our Administration our students our cabinets my fellow board members who are and have left the table and for me your warmth your wisdom your charm your ability to communicate effectively and help us do what we do when we need to do it is unbelievable it cannot be measured by any means from the bottom of my heart and soul

224I personally want to thank you for everything that you have done and wish you nothing but success in your free time where you can now enjoy your husband more and family and maybe you can cook him dinner so he doesn't have to cook it for you and I want to thank you thank your family who have so graciously allowed you to be with us for all of these years and thank you for everything you have done and will continue to do and I will miss you thank you I'm going to let Mrs Kasa Grande have the last word so I'll go next before I get to Mrs Casa Grande I just want to say um thank you to the community that came out to the Lakes area Taste of the Lakes it was a fantastic

225event of course Mr seagler walked away with way more baskets than most others that were in the room um so thank you for that um Lakes Area Youth assistant appreciates all of your specifically contributions and the rest of the community I want to Echo and say that wal Lake Western's play Adams Family was fantastic and phenomenal um um so thank you Wald Lake western that was fantastic we're moving on to Central's play this weekend we have all the collage concerts and now we're into the holiday season and it's really you know festive and I encourage you all as I always do go get involved go see what's going on in our community go participate um I also want to thank or congratulate excuse me the Wall Lake uh Marchant band they were state champions this

226year they went on to National and they came in 30th I believe was the number um overall in the nation which is a fantastic feat it's a fantastic feat that they won the states so congratulations you guys keep Rising for the stars and go bandn now I'm going to turn my attention to Mrs kasag Grande and I just want to say thank you so much for all your time all your dedication the community in Wild Lake the students the families um you have them Forefront and everything that you do and everything that you believe in you sit here at this table um whether it's you know Pleasant or not pleasant at times but you're doing what you think is best for Wild Lake and I appreciate you stepping up I appreciate you holding the reins

227I appreciate your guidance um for me I appreciate your mentorship you know I don't know how I'm going to get by or get through without our phone calls and you telling me we have to look at this or let's talk about this or have you thought about this um I'm going to definitely miss that um Ken she's yours sorry that you know you're not sharing her with us anymore um but thank you for the time that you allowed her to be with us and we will severely miss having your voice and your thoughts at our board table so thank you and now Mrs CA Grande you can speak so I like to give gifts this is for you oh no I'm scared you can read it if you want or you can keep it private

228it's up to you the list of people who underestimated me and how that worked out for them because usually when we talk you know the answer you know the answer and I gave you a book my husband wants to know how you're doing on it so maybe later you can tell them how you're doing on the exclamation mark book but in case you wanted to make some notes and then I figured this was appropriate for you thank you very much things I got blamed for yes I will not be taking that home no it's for it's for here it's it's for it's it's for here it's for here thank you Fernand no my first thank you is is is to my husband and my family because I would not be here doing this if it

229weren't for that my younger kids some younger boys were in elementary school when I was elected to the board um the reason I'm sitting up here today and not um Mrs Crafton is because I came in on a um you know she's got a full term I came in a partial term as well so I actually deed Mrs Lyle for like a meeting so this you know kind of happens but she'll be back up here and and and doing a great job when she comes back up I also the teacher and the staff the cabinet everybody I have learned so much here and I remember one of the first things I said to Dr Hamilton Mr Gutman it's so I understand the checks and balances in government but here we are coming in and you

230know so much more about education and you're teaching us as we also are leading you know you and leading this District um so I think I'll just leave it at that other than when I ran the last time I knew that would be my last time running um and you know the but I have absolutely enjoyed what I've done I I believe in you know advocating for public education and um you know sitting here you all have a tough job to do and sometimes it's a fun job though don't forget that I mean we get to shake hands with graduates we get to go to concerts and see all the wonderful things the students do uh we get to see you know superintendant come and bring us you know ideas and and help us through

231things um you know it's been a pleasure keep in touch um and you know if you can't remember something as you know somebody said I might remember it you know feel free to give a call um you know and I have passed off most things I don't have a whole basement or office full of things if I do find anything sensitive I'll bring it back to you um but thank you it has been my honor and privilege to serve well thank you all we are going to adjourn at 1028 and go lions and if anybody knows the score don't tell me but go lions

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.