001Good evening. Welcome to the zoning Board of Appeals meeting for February 5th 2025 ginger, can we have roll call please? Here Here Here Member Roberts here member Here All right, you all Keep the copy of our Minutes for January 8th. Can we have a motion to approve make a motion to approve? Roll call Yes Yes, member Olson, yes member Roberts. Yes member Truppiano. Yes Carries. All right. So tonight under old business we have appeal 3419 that was Held over and tabled from the last the previous meeting. Is there anyone here to speak to this appeal? All right Me and approach this stand. I'm gonna read the appeal appeal 3419 Vanessa Avalos 803 st. John's wine dot owner and appellant has appealed to the zoning Board of Appeals and adjustments for variants to obtain a building
002permit for a pergola at 803 st. John's 47 Cunningham Tobias company Goddard Park sub PC 112 in a RA zoning district where the proposed conflicts with section 190 that 290 and section 190.323 dot e of the wine dot zoning ordinance 190 dot 290 States lot coverage for an RA zoned districts shall not exceed 35% of the lot area The size of the lot is 36 by 100 or 3600 square feet The construction of the pergola will result in excess of 76 square feet of lot coverage section 190.323 dot e no attached or no detached accessory building Shall be located closer than 10 feet to any main building proposed pergola abuts the existing home Please state your name and address It's Vanessa Avalos. My address is 803 st. John Street and wine dot more 8192 Thank
003you so tell us about your appeal and What you're doing there? So I guess originally we had Asked for it. We took out a permit. Well, we wanted to get a permit We were in contact with with someone they were asking for more measurements of everything And then I think we went back like two times They were asking for more measurements and then we didn't hear back from anybody for like two months. I think it was So I guess we just kind of went ahead and started building after that an inspector came by and told us about The building and it turns out I guess the the inspector who was helping us out Doesn't work here anymore. So we weren't told anything Anymore and it kind of just our permit just stayed there with no
004answer So we were just building and then I guess yeah, they were we were told that it had to be four feet away I guess from the building from the lot line Yeah, I guess that's that's really it I guess that's that's really it They wanted to see if it were able if we were able to leave it the way that it is Okay, we're gonna open it up for for questions Not really, I guess you can answer Yeah, we it's pretty obvious that pergola is already built. Yes In In the paperwork you mentioned that there were Interferences with the garage door that yeah when I yeah when I read sorry when I read the paper It said it had to be four feet away If it was four feet away like how it's how
005it says it's allowed it would cover the entrance to the side door and the garage door So yeah, that's why you weren't able to build it that way either. So did you know? Did you know any other requirements when you started building? No, no because we were just going back and forth with the inspector We never got that letter of denial Sent to our house Okay. Yeah, so we weren't aware that of any anything that I said on that paper about the four feet away and everything We never received that when we started building so that sketch that you've made was turned in Yes, it was turned in and they replied to that asking for more measurements We did reply back, but we never heard back after that Okay, thanks Dave One thing in here
006that there was one of the neighbors was in favor there was a communication I wasn't Keith basically asked questions that I was gonna ask. We reviewed this last month and there was a considerable amount of Violations, okay. I would say that if the building department and you can pass everything Within the building code and I don't know how that can possibly be done because you already have your post in there's no post hole inspection as far as I know I'm pretty sure there is no submitted plan yet of the structure So none of these things have been completed so I don't know why you're even here until you got something that you could submit that would be a Workable a drawing or set of plans that you're going to be building from now I suppose
007that um Just like myself when I was considerably younger Permits, what are permits? What are they good for except the money getting sent to the city? Well Permits are important because all of a sudden you put something up a pool You put it over put it under a power line. You didn't know What would you know our line broke four people died? Yeah Should have got a permit Yeah, like like I said, we did do it. We did ask for a permit We did submit the plans, but we just never we were never replied to at the end So we didn't know that it wasn't gonna be accepted So yeah, I guess that's what's happened. That's what happened with that. But whatever is that we submitted? That's what we have up so far It's not
008finished yet. But yeah when the inspector went he just Suggested that we appealed so we wouldn't have to take it down without I guess everybody else's opinion Therefore you made an application, but you never got a permit a Permit something that's issued to you. Yeah, you're allowed to build Yeah, correct. That's why that's why that was our fault on that on that end because we just didn't hear back for like two months So we I guess we just went ahead with what we had and we started building it But then it yeah, it turns out that our permit was just left there and then nobody replied to our permit So that's what happened with that Not necessarily that we didn't want to get a permit just because we didn't want to Well, believe it or
009not paperwork is important. No, that's all Tony is the pergola connected to the house or the garage? Not connected to it. No the post it's from the fence Okay, since we're on a corner lot and did you guys build it or did you have a my husband built it? He works in that is framing. Yeah, he's right. He just doesn't speak English. Okay. Yeah Can you ask him how deep he did the post? 42 inches And on the house side, there's a window underneath that pergola or a door. It's next to it. It's a window It's a our bedroom window. Okay, you know and a door on the garage side it's not Touching the the doors from the the entrance of the of the backyard. It's not near the garage door. Okay I've got no
010other questions Yeah, you you imagine that you submitted drawing. Yes Where are the drawings? Oh, it's you should have a copy Yeah, I haven't seen any in the previous. There was a there were a couple of sketches There was a sketch. Mm-hmm. Yeah, it was just a sketch where it was gonna go, right? Yeah, that's all that's all That's that I am that you submitted You didn't submit a finished drawing of what it was gonna look like Yeah, well we were going back and forth with the inspector on measurements. Yeah The only drawing that you submitted was this Yes, all right, that's all I am so do you intend to enclose the roof or is it or is that would that stay? Oh, no. Yes, not finished. I got yeah, we did intend to put
011some type of roof on it Okay, yeah, so that would so that would be enclosed on three sides then or just oh just the top just yeah Just the roof all the rest of it's going to be open open. Yeah your intent. Yes Is that roof gonna be flat or sloped? Towards the backyard or towards the sidewalk is it like this? Yeah slope to the sidewalk So that would put all that watershed With a gutter Yeah, that's it really another a good important point because when stated pergola pergola typically doesn't have a Solid roof, right? It's just joists and maybe people put plants or whatever. But yeah That's that's a lot of water. That's a lot of area to collect water If if we put a solid roof But again, that would have to go
012be approved by the Well, nothing has been approved yet by the building department as far as I know They have not received any type of structure all depth Where's location anything all we have is a little square on a piece of paper and in the only thing we have right now To to actually deliberate on is the lot coverage and and the The fact that it's not attached to the house and it's not ten feet away So all these other things side yard Mm-hmm. That's not even on here Is it five four five five feet from the street Yeah side lot side lot right now right now it's right on the property line got it's on the old one It's not on the new one. Yeah So they have to be ten feet away from
013the from the house. Basically, it's gotta be ten feet away from any building Okay. Well, yeah that ten feet away would be our garage there I guess technically wouldn't be away for it to be ten feet away from the house as well Yeah, exactly the house or the garage. Mm-hmm I hate to say it the reason that is code fire Mm-hmm. Now if you submit that you want to put it closer to the house. You would have to fire proof everything between Pergola and the house. I think it's a two-hour firewall that would be required Firewall between the pergola and the house The house is brick part part brick and aluminum siding, isn't it? I think so. It'd have to be reviewed by the engineering department and garages are closer to the house Than ten
014feet. They have to have drywall on the inside of the garage You keep the fire from spreading from the garage, which most fires start going over to the house Okay. So what you're doing is you're throwing everything together and if for some reason you want to have a Barbecue on that pergola. I would have that's fire hazard Just saying and let's not forget Kelly to ask any questions as well Since she's a voting member Yes, I'm sorry, I'm sorry Kelly is there any any questions Do we have any other questions or no other questions and may I ask what our neighbor said I Heard someone say something about our neighbor. Yes, it was when I saw it in here some communication One of the neighbors said this appeal This was here to 842 842 8th
015Street. Yeah, this was from Juan and Courtney or as global and says good evening I understand there is a hearing in regards to the pergola that was built on the side of their property We do not have any issues with it We find it to be aesthetically pleasing and feel that it adds to the individuality of wind out homes We believe it enriches beauty of our neighborhood. So we have one appeal for one communication in favor Thank you So, um, we'll ask if there's anyone else here to speak to this appeal And then if there's none then we'll close the Public portion and we'll have discussion deliberation on this. Okay. So is there a motion we can address all three as as one motion What do we have? Is there three years or two? Well,
016there's there's three. There's the side yard There's the lot coverage and then there's the proximity to the existing buildings The third one didn't get carried over to the new yeah the new minutes. Yeah, let's I would say we can take them all together It's tough, I mean we just need a motion and then we can deliberate I will I'll have to make a motion to deny Oh, I'll support that. All right, so we have a motion to deny and a support do we want to Entertain any options for them If they didn't cover it Then what that would possibly open up a little bit of it being just a deck and not a full structure That would be my thought on it. The only one that I would support would be in the lot coverage
017Because we do that all the time. Sure, but the the other two are definite violations Well, but then to the one do it sit it's right next to the street right there's a wooden fence right there and Like you suggested the barbecue that you know, you have barbecue on there. You've got the fence You got the house you got the garage right there and they don't meet any of the right, you know Yeah, a lot coverage like with Mike. I would say we should keep them together Yeah, and then it's it's it's all it's all incorporated Later date they have a plan that's submitted and It's you know away from the house or whatever and they put it someplace else and there's a lot coverage area This this commission is always usually gone with lot
018coverage right new houses. Yeah exceed lot cover. Yeah, I Can't see over the fence, but I'm assuming there's a patio there concrete is it poured under the pergola in the yard Yeah, it's nothing there. It's just grass just grass underneath there right now All right, so we have a motion and support or any other discussion We'll have roll call number Flaxman Yes Number Dylan. Yes member McDonald. Yes member Olson. Yes member Roberts Member Trippiano. Yes, so I'm sorry, but your appeal is denied You'll be able to get the the information from the engineering department in three days Okay, so since it's been denied it might is that is everything that I'm gonna be everything's gonna be in like written I guess yes, okay Okay, and three days you said I'll get some oh, yeah, is
019that correct? Five days. I'm sorry. It was five days. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Our next appeal is appeal number three four two zero Rita Connagel owner and appellant has appealed the zoning board of appeals and adjustment for a certificate of occupancy To convert the garage into a living space for a second dwelling unit at 1254 2nd Street lots 15 and 16 and all of the vacated alley 80.58 feet lying northly and adjacent to said lots in the Antwine Labadees sub T3 s are one one e l3 one p11 also lot one five six and all of the vacated alley eighty point five eight feet lying southerly and Adjacent to said lot in the assessor's windup plat number eight and in our T Zoning district where the proposed conflicts with section
020one nine zero that two nine zero of the wind up zoning ordinance one nine zero that two nine zero States required front yard setback is 20 feet in an RT zoning district He is this thing the existing garage setback is eight feet Please state your name and address for the record Rita Cornelia One two five four second Street wind up Michigan four eight one nine two. All right. Thank you So you want to tell us a little bit more about what you want to do there? Yes Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to present my case today I stand before you to request a variance for non-conforming front yard setback for my property at one two five four second Street the current zoning code requires a residential dwelling to be set back 20 yards
021From the street while my property which was built in the 1940s Has an existing setback of only eight feet from the sidewalk My request is not for a new structure But rather to repurpose an existing one to accommodate a critical family need Even with its current approved use of the outbuilding garage It's still encroaching into the required front yard setback The purpose of the project is to convert the back portion of the existing 2,000 square foot outbuilding into a functional living space for my Mother who requires full-time care in 2020 I relocated my family to California But due to my mother's declining health my family made the difficult but necessary decision to return home So that I could care for her Which I purchased this property last year It was done in the sole intention
022of providing a suitable home for my mother given her condition and Recommendation from her doctor. She must live with a family member, and I'm the only person available to take her in This property as exists is an existing structure And it has already been encroaching on the required front yard setback for almost a hundred years Which is still technically required even in its current use This variance request is not self-imposed the structure in question was built decades before I acquired the property and the previous Any previous? Apartment existed in this very outbuilding Given this history. I believe this project would be viable and in line with the property's prior use Additionally the property already includes 1100 square feet home with an attached three-car garage Making the 2,000 square feet outbuilding redundant converting it into living
023livable space practical and Aligns with the character of the neighborhood which includes both single-family and multi-family residents Not commercially zoned Granting this zoning variance would not negatively impact their surrounding neighborhood Community or adjacent property owners the structure is already in place Meaning there will be no new construction affecting the area's aesthetic or function instead this variance would allow my family To use an existing building in a way that serves meaningful purpose Denying this request however would create an immense hardship for my family If the project is not approved I will have no viable way to accommodate my mother's needs as I do not have the financial resources to purchase another suitable property for her care This property was purchased with my mother's well-being in mind and without this variance It will not serve the purpose
024in which it was acquired for I was respectfully ask for your consideration and approval of this request so I made So I may provide my mother with the care and the suitability that she urgently needs Thank you for that that actually Answered a few of the questions. I'm sure and we'll see if the board has any other questions Tony I'm still gonna look through this just a minute longer Kelly you have any questions It all be on one meter yes, it's not intended to be a second dwelling. It's all one household Me yeah, okay Yeah, I had a list, but you did answer a number of the questions that I had so you mentioned that the I Don't know what you call that building to the north that big storage building whatever that is that
025Is currently being used as part of the residents did I hear that correctly? It's not correct. My name is Victoria Kami. I'm Rita's real estate broker. I help her I helped her purchase the property. No, it's I mean, it's currently Vacant she's waiting on her permits to Renovate it in hopes of being able to turn it into a residential space. Okay, but it is finished Not necessarily. No, it's okay It's enclosed. Okay Okay so When all said and done There will be two separate residences at this. Is that true? No, it would be one conjoined residents. Okay, the building is conjoined with the house Okay, there's that breezeway between the two right correct, correct, which leads into the main house. Okay Okay, so one large residence got it And the front part or the east
026part of that building is going to remain a garage, correct? Okay Let me see That's that that's almost 19 feet. Mm-hmm So is the end is the entrance to that new living space is that inside the breezeway? Is that the only entrance? There's an entrance from the backyard and then from the breezeway, okay. Oh, yeah From the backyard and then it goes into the garage. I see Okay, so that was another question again. I had it in my head this was going to be two different residences and I wondered about the backyard if that was going to be a shared space, but I Guess this is a question. I have a question for the board if this if this is just really Extending an existing residence, it's not going to be considered a two-family dwelling
027That's my question. Okay, we wait to come around a week. All right Let me just take a look cuz yeah, right, right. I had a lot of questions two addresses on the house I know that's why I asked that Because there's it's only one address. There's no there's two addresses. Yeah, the other one doesn't exist anymore It was it was enjoying well, it's above the double doors. I understand that but we don't show it on our side That was my thing is there's two addresses there's a 54 and a 44 correct There were 44 is above the double door. That's what I saw and and if that goes away Then it's all gonna in my opinion. It's all gonna be considered one resident, but basically Two residents in one exactly. Yeah. Yeah, and that's Rita's
028goal is we just she just wants one extended residence, right? Okay, that's right. And right now the Appeal is for the offset which is on the building That's setback. It's a setback. Yeah, and it's only on the building and that was brought in front of the board I'm gonna say probably ten or twelve years ago Maybe longer when that when they built that building was was here Okay, basically it's gonna be converted into Family living space And there is a list of the city's approved everything I saw all that other other and they made a whole list of stuff that they have to comply to in order for that to happen And the only thing that the city didn't was a setback. Yeah. Okay. I think I got it Thank you very much. Have you
029reapplied for The build out or are you doing the variance first? She has a list of things that need to be addressed on her plan Which she will completely comply with pull all necessary building building permits to have it done. Okay So my question was is that it's an RT and in the information that we received It said that it was going to be turned into an apartment separate from the house, which would have been a two-family They are allowed but When you change what it is Everything else changes with it. So the setback came in to effect. All right Now if you're going to just say that it's already part of the original building and you're just going to modify it and there's going to be connecting doors not You wouldn't even need a
030separate entrance, but you would need an egress That's all within the building department and what they need to Tell you what you need to do to make that a living space Sure, but as far as the setback, it's an existing non-conforming building, which I think we already approved I remember there was an appeal for this address in the past I don't remember exactly what it was, but I think it was it was to at one time it was two separate addresses possibly even with two separate owners and then and then they Brought them together. Yeah, it was as I recall I pulled them I pulled out the old C of O's because I when I talked to the realtor this afternoon and In 1980, it looks like it came here to the zoning board for
031approval, but it was for a maintenance shop That's what a maintenance shop member he had a it was a motorcycle shop. Yeah, it was completely. Yeah, it was His workshop, I think it was called Mr. Stolpa, I don't know if you remember him. Oh, yeah, that's who was that. That's who applied and appealed to here Was that Stolpa's house? Yeah. Yeah, that's a long time ago. Right exactly So I did it did get approved here before in the past, but it wasn't for residential It was for commercial correct. The only thing is is I understand that she's gonna use it for her family But if it gets approved if she goes to sell it she could sell it as a two-family dwelling if you approve it as residential That that's my so just so you
032know, I mean, it's fine. It's known that and everything So, I mean, I'm just letting you know that if you do approve it, that's well There's there's certain requirements still if she was going to sell it as a two-family would have to be there would have to be a Separation no, she would just have to meet the requirements on the inspection checklist from the engineering department Yeah, that's well, so she if you decide on yeah what they're going to do and how they're going to address the Improvements is what it will be because if you make it into a two-family believe me your taxes are gonna go up That's probably understood. Yeah, I got my tax my assessment Yeah, that's all intention is just really to make it all one one livable space We're not
033here to give advice, but that's good advice In your real estate person knows these type of things. Yes That's why she's here with me today So to summarize that you're actually You're not here to give advice, but that's good advice and you're real estate person knows these type of things. Yes Why she's hired? That's why she's here with me today So does it just summarize that your your intent is to increase the living space of your single-family Dwelling by using this space that's currently used for a garage space. That is correct. Okay So that should be in your motion. That's yes, if you guys approve that yeah Motion to approve the existing non-conforming setback as is and To address it as a single-family dwelling correct Yeah, because all these items from the building department most
034of them are for two-family Because that's how we reviewed it So once again most of those things I mean you still have to go that the insulation and the yeah And these other things have to be addressed, but there's a difference some things They may not have to do right. Yeah, as long as it's a Like I said existing single-family dwelling setback is Approved as far as it's a single-family dwelling Right. That's the motion. May I may I ask a question with? Seeing it's just a single-family versus a two-family unit and they've given her already These you know ten things she needs to do. Will they increase will she need to resubmit plans? Decrease With the fire rated doors and all of that, right? Yes Doors Resubmit it and have them review it again Which
035it'll cost you but believe me what it costs for a plan review submitted as a single-family is going to be much less than All those that you would have to address to make it into a two-family So should I revise the actual plans to reflect these? No, we submit and then we will fix that Submit the plans as a single-family dwelling with with your converting what basically converting an industrial area into a living space That would be what your plans with the description. Yes Okay, perfect. All right, and I made the motion Then You guys can have a seat if you don't have anything else right now Okay, and I'll ask if there's anyone else here to speak to this appeal on there were no communications received There any other discussion? entertain a motion motion
036to approve on a single-family dwelling setback an existing setback and I think that's all we're here for There's a setback. So we're going to approve the existing single-family setback There a support I'll support The emotion and support is there any other discussion and then can we have roll call number Flaxman Yes, member Gillen. Yes, member McDonald. Yes, member Olson. Yes, member Roberts. Yes Member Chupiano. Yes All right, six days motion carries moving on to appeal three four two one first metro wine dot LLC owner and Arthur Silver a pillent have appealed to the Zoning Board of Appeals and adjustment for a variance to a building permit to construct two residential units on the second floor at 2909 and 2911 Biddle Avenue the south 38 point four eight feet of lot one executive and excluding the
037East 60 feet of the south 35 feet corrected plat of blocks 1920 30 and 31 block 31 in a CBD zoning district where the proposed conflicts with section 190.307 T 4 of the wind up zoning ordinance section 190 307 T for Requires all residential dwellings provide off-street parking the two proposed units would require two off-street parking spaces No off-street parking is provided. Is there anyone here to speak to this appeals? Good evening. Good evening. Please take your name and address. My name is Arthur silver My address is 2669 Devonshire, Leonard, Michigan Okay, I'm here for dr. Mazum. He's a gut surgery scheduled tonight. So I'm acting on his part All right. Thank you. Who are you representing? Dr. Mazum. He's a that's his property. Okay All right, so you want to tell us a little
038bit about the appeal Well, this was previously approved and what we've had a little difficulty in getting this whole project going is Because the requirement is to install a sprinkler system That's been very difficult enough for us to do that We've been trying to figure out a workaround Because we did not want to go through the expense of bringing the water source from across the street But since then we were able to find that there is a water source behind the building that would provide us or a very Reasonable cost to put that sprinkler system in so, you know, we've got that in the plans and ready to go So now we have to move forward to get the approval for that parking spaces, you know the off-street parking again Okay. All right. We'll I
039just wanted to let you know that it did come before this board January 9th of 2019 and it was approved. Yes, and he's also appealing to the Planning Commission. So it does have to go back to Planning Commission as well Yeah, it's going and that's not gone there yet, correct So this is really an approved a re-approval of something that's exactly as it was before. Yes And that appears to be a goal assuming that we put that sprinkler system in there That's been all the requirements from the building review That's taking place Keith any questions? No, I guess Can't remember 2019 very remember yesterday very well What is in the What is in that space right now? There's two floors on the first floor There's just an open area that he plans to put a
040little deli or a little restaurant and right on the second floor It was I don't know maybe an office, you know a couple offices at one time. It looks like it They were apart my space there. Yeah, I couldn't tell Yeah, so that the there will be a bedroom there and that's on each side and that's The main reason put for putting a sprinkler system there and of course we have to improve that fire wall. Sure Okay. No, that's all I had. Thank you. Okay Colleen if you have any questions Sprinkler systems a good idea and if you would have asked me earlier I knew that water was over there behind those buildings. We've spent a quite a while trying to find that out I didn't know to ask you look at it. Isn't it
041a river the Yeah, we could have maybe done this about a year ago so Thank you, though. I got no questions Tony. No questions. All right All right, and then you don't have anything else you can have a seat and we'll okay Thank you. We'll ask if there's anyone else here to speak to this appeal Seeing none we'll entertain a motion motion to approve All right, we have a motion and support There's any any discussion and can we have roll call number Flaxman? Yes member. Yes Yes, member Olson. Yes member Roberts. Yes member. Yes All right, sexy eyes motion carries Thank you, so you have been been approved and now you can put in your sprinklers and we look forward to Seeing the business of residents go there Alright that was our last appeal There
042anything else? Come to before the board and none will Have a motion to place all communications on file. Oh should the computer support what he said all in favor All right, so our Next meeting is March 5th and we have any appeals yet. We do not we do not have any appeals So then that one may not happen. So With that we'll have a motion to adjourn so moved You