001okay we're ready to go Stacy also we're not going to say the Pledge um okay good evening everyone um thank you for joining us virtually um and I really appreciate anyone who's watching whether live or later I appreciate everyone's flexibility for letting us uh hold this meeting over Zoom for sure and I also want to um send a special get well to Kim Hurst and Leo human two of our board members who are sick um and not able to join us over Zoom tonight so adequate notice has been given for this meeting um Chris if you could please read the motion to approve the agenda I move that we approve the agenda as posted second okay all those in favor I I okay any opposed all right motion passes okay we will move on to
002recognizing our own and I believe that is Jim Brunell and John Brazil and Lisa you can go ahead and get going and Lisa too yeah go ahead Jim hey good evening um I am proud to honor two of our captain custodians that truly embodied the meaning of the word hero um one evening they noticed uh a colleague in a situation that proved to be dire they acted quickly and called both myself and 911 to help render Aid to the individual and literally saved her life in the process so uh wanted to just honor them this evening and I I think they should be on Zoom with us uh watching you know I don't know if their picture or not but uh wanted to thank them both are they here Lisa do they or do you
003want is there anything else you wanted to say well I know that they indicated that they were going to be able to um be on our Zoom tonight so I'm hopeful that they are um I just want to say that they are very um they did not even hesitate when um co worker was having a medical emercy and I truly agree with Jim without their uh heroism B right now um I really truly believe they saved her life um and they timing of this was really really close to the time that they were getting off of work and that is late in the evening around 11: um p.m. and I really think if this situation would have been five minutes later it would not have had um the happiest of all endings that it is
004now I know that um this individual has gone through a lot of medical um treatments and is getting extremely healthy right now and we're very excited about that and the captain staff have wrapped our love around her and um just know that we're just hoping that she gets um gets well soon but Jasmine and Demetrius both are individuals at our school that make such a sign ific difference every um evening and truly to be a Demetrius had really only been working I think jym about a month around the time that this happened so it was just amazing that their quick action and quick thinking just led to a um a a successful uh ending I guess you could say thankful that they're Captain um or Clayton employees and Captain staff members thank you so much
005and um Demetrius and Jasmine on behalf of the Board of Education thank you so much and we are so proud of you we are so proud to have you on our team and part of our school community and I know you know you feel your roles are are vital to our schools for many reasons but this is just an incredible example of um why we're so proud to have you as part of our community so thank you so much and um we again on behalf of the board just so proud of you and the way you handled that situation so thank you very much okay thank you Lisa and thank you Jim too for bringing them to our attention and I'm I'm just so happy we could recognize them in public so thank you okay
006we will be moving on to um public comment and uh the way we handle public comment on a virtual board meeting is that our chief Communications off officer rece Gina tart receives all of the public comments and she will read them out um it it's just easier that way than than getting everyone in on the zoom so I apologize for that but I will ask again Gina tart our chief Communications officer to read any public comments we have tonight good evening thank you we did receive one comment uh via email prior to the meeting today so I will read it to you now that's from Nicholas Vivio says hi Felicia my wife and I would be interested to know what what role the board plays in setting school cancellation policies regarding snow days the reason
007we ask is that in our opinion the district has been far too conservative this year when cancelling School obviously when we get 8 to 9 Ines a snow day or two is warranted but not four but school should never be canceled in advance of incoming flurries I.E last week's snow day or a measly in shift snow like yesterday furthermore what is the person that is making these decisions optimizing for are they optimizing for drisking litigation and being advised by an overly cautious attorney because it certainly seems that they are failing to take into account the off times and necessary disruptions to students and parents especially those of us who have young children thank you for consideration and setting a more reasonable approach to snow days one that pairs a snow boots and a $9.99 ice
008scraper can easily solve for Nick and Vivio and Kathy bennette and that was the only comment we received in advance thank you okay thank you so much Gina um moving on now Dr Patel will give a superintendent communication great thank you um so I want to go ahead and start it's actually fitting since we just had the public comment so I do want to go ahead and start with the snow day conversation so obviously you've seen the tractor tracker that we have developed which is the weather tracker and if you look at it we have used up quite a few of our days with one left so I just want to start off by thanking the community I know that there's a level of frustration out there so I appreciate the patience that everyone has
009had um because we do recognize this has been difficult and there are a few things that we absolutely consider when we're making these decisions first as as we've said in our emails and our Communications student and staff safety is always our priority I think a lot of people have to also recognize that over 90% of our staff live outside the district so we we also consider our student drivers um most of the time within Clayton Community the roads are appear clean and it seems like we absolutely can get to school but then we also get numerous reports from outside the area where roads have not been clear so students student and staff safety is always our priority and then secondly we also make our decision based on what we consider to be expert advice and
010guidance and coordination so proceeding any kind of weather um you know storm or winter storms or watches that are coming up we get reports from the National Weather Service and I actually get emails twice a day in the morning and in the evening reports which we go through and assess the situations we look at MoDOT to see what kind of guidance they're giving and the reports that they're sharing we also have superintendent calls that we have in the evening and then sometimes we also have them at 4:00 in the morning where all of St Louis County superintendents get together to discuss the situation and assess what the roads are like we also have to consider Transportation not only within our district but also for our students um with special needs so our special school district
011has transportation that they Ser provide for our students we have our voluntary interdistrict Choice Corporation who provides transportation for our students and they also are considered as we make these decisions so I I understand and recognize that school closures disrupt work schedules um child care and absolutely instructional time so I just want to assure everyone we don't make these decisions lightly a lot of thought goes into it and as always I've gotten a lot of feedback on the decisions so please know that we will continue to look at ways on how to improve when it comes to these type of decisions or the processes we have in place but again I just appreciate everyone's understanding and patience and we're hoping what um we are past this and we can put winter behind us we're hoping
012for I know it's going to be cold tomorrow so bundle up and I look forward to every everybody back in school tomorrow so that's just a little bit of update on that shifting gears what's been happening in school when we have been in school we I think it was two weeks ago I get I had the honor and privilege of watching um L Miz at Clayton High School's theater and the theater program and it was simply outstanding there were over 1,500 tickets that were sold I believe there were 93 high school students that participated three elementary students and three middle school students and this was a what I believe a full circle moment for our new um Drama teacher mallerie Duncan's first winter production interesting fact this is her first winter production and she actually
013performed this very play 21 years ago as a Clayton High School student um so I thought that was very you know just inspiring and full circle moment for her we're just very proud of our students and incredible staff so it was a privilege to watch this and great job to them and then at the middle school they actually hosted their first ever International night a couple of weeks ago as well great turnout I want to thank all of the staff that was um that worked diligently to put this event together for the first time I believe they had over 200 people in attendance um lots of different you know performances and activities that represented over 18 to 19 different countries they had um I know vibrant dances from the Philippine Art Foundation they had energetic
014a West African drumming by drum Warriors Brazilian soccer henna tattoos and so many more cultural events so lots of planning and a sense of community was absolutely evident in this so again thank you for the staff students and families that came out to support this wonderful job with that then we had another exciting event for the first time again ever at the high school we had um Steve Hudson athletic director worked D diligently to make sure that he put together a first ever combined College Signing Day on actual national Signing Day we had over 14 students who have committed to playing Collegiate Level Sports at esteemed schools Across the Nation including institutions like Stanford Emory MIT so many more and the neat thing about it was there was it was a broad mix of sports
015so you had baseball basketball rowing was represented soccer beach volleyball cross country and so many other sports but again um it was a privilege to see all the students and the entire half of the gymnasium was filled with parents who were very supportive and excited for their children as we are for our students and there'll be more student athletes that we're going to honor during the Spring's um Signing Day in April so looking forward to that as well and then celebration for one of our staff members I want to take a moment to recognize Adrian he is a special education teacher at Clayton High School um and he is being recognized as one of 10 special education teachers honored with ssd's annual keys to the classroom award which recognizes exceptional skill commitment and impact on
016student learning some of the examples that if you know Adrian you know he goes above and beyond in everything and he's extremely student centered he actually manages Clayton High School snack cart and before and after school coffee shop as initiatives to provide students with actual I would say real world opportunities to build problem solving and Vocational skills so I just want to thank Adrien who's a creative teacher leader and for his commitment to inclusion um he's truly truly deserving of this recognition so if you see him please congratulate him or even send him an email so thank you Adrian for all that you do and then last Friday when we were in school we had our professional learning day and I'm pleased to share that our district has successfully achieved the goal of training all
017of our faculty and staff to recognize um mental health signs and symptoms and really to ensure common language between all of us as you recall we introduced the Mental Health First Aid course to all of our Elementary staff and District employees at our January PD day and now with the LA with this Friday we've completed all of our training with our secondary staff so very happy about this and I know this required a lot of coordination and a lot of Planning by so many different individuals I don't think I could sit here and name them all but just know that we appreciate appreciate all of you for your dedication to learning and growing as part of our um goals for the Strategic plan as well and meeting those objectives in there so thank you for
018that and then finally tonight we have the Paragon team who's going to present the results of a long range facilities master plan if you recall it's been I would say probably 8 to n month process with so much stakeholder input um we've had a survey out there we've had Community for forums I believe we had over 110 committee members um involved in this the survey I think collected about 3 responses we had over eight Community engagement opportunities and again our goal was really to make sure that our community is aware of the process engaged and has been giving us feedback and um has been given an opportunity to be a part of this process last time we did this was in 2008 which was about 17 years ago and as we know education is ever
019evolving and it's our responsibility I believe to adapt to those needs and make sure that we continue to be a premier District not only locally in the state but nationally and our facilities have to be in par to adapt to our ever growing needs for our students so I look forward I think we all look forward to the results that are going to be presented by Paragon and I think at the same time it's very important to know that this is is just the first phase of the work our goal was for them to come in assess all of our facilities provide us with the results and now um we begin the process of what where do we go next with all of the information we had and what's the conversations that will follow with
020that so please assure the community that we will keep you posted and all the information there's going to be quite a bit share tonight will be posted on our website um and we will also share that over email with everyone in the community so thank you again for all of your engagement with that and then now I would like to hand it over to Lu our student board rep thank you um I would like to start off by sharing that at least from the student perspective the unexpected extra long break this weekend has certainly been an amazing surprise and so a bunch of students friends and including my little brother would like me to say thank you um of course I know that that's not a factor in deciding when snow days are but it's
021still nice to be able to bundle up and catch up on extra homework and of course play and have fun in the snow um I would like to update with the National Honor Society as well I remember earlier I talked about I think in a past rep update um how they were planning on doing an advertisement in GNN which is our um intercom that like we watch a video and it's the it's the announcements for the day and there was a very successful video and um they have started the tutoring process in algebra and physics and I've been hearing it's going great so this is just the beginning but um the tutoring and the mentoring and then the additional um senior project not senior projects semester projects will be going very go very well um
022I know we've also talked a lot about the wellness center in the past and I would like to share that lately I have been hearing lots of positive feedback I'm hoping to meet with the student committee for the wellness center soon and so I'd like to look forward to um sharing an update about that in one of my um one of my next updates yeah update on update but uh Junior and senior prom preparations are upcoming as well and so I am looking forward to sharing that excitement in the in a future board meeting um I'd like to give a shout out to all of the winter sports especially the girls swim team as they approach State um today they had a Wacky Wednesday I think it was swim swim practice I'm not sure if
023it was today or last Wednesday but I saw some pictures on their Instagram and it's amazing to see the winter sports hold their motivations so well especially during the cold and so a very special shout out goes that for them and I also like to mention that the winter running is in session it's led by the um fall coaches by the Fall cross country coaches and it's a great way that the spring that the upcoming spring student athletes are choosing to prep for their for their season so yeah thank you thank you Lucia happy to see you back at the board meeting too um so next we are um going to have our pres presentation from Brad Irwin and the Paragon team um before he starts I just want to reiterate I know Dr Patel
024just said some of this but um I just wanted to remind the community we hired Paragon to evaluate our facil our facilities all of our facilities um buildings athletic facilities Etc to determine um how well they're meeting our needs now and how well they will meet our needs in the future we are not as a board taking any action tonight we're not making any decisions this is just a presentation it is the culmination of kind of the study portion of this process where as I said Paragon evaluated our facilities you'll see they're going to provide some highlevel concepts for us to consider they will also um give us all the information from Community feedback Etc and um the board has also had we've had a couple of Retreats recently with Paragon where we will able
025to ask them lots of questions had very great informative discussions so this is um the culmination of paragon's work and their study and um as Dr Patel said I really just view this we view this as a starting point right so we are excited to have Brad Irwin here tonight to present to us and to the community um the entire study that he's been working on for with his team for several months so Brad thank you so much for being here we appreciate it yeah thank you um yeah tonight is a big culmination of eight to nine months of of hard work um if you remember one of our first meetings was right before school let out back in in May uh where we were able to jump into all the different facilities before all
026the students were out and you know here we are in the middle of winter uh back in Zoom land uh presenting uh tonight so um I'm going to try to recap uh 8 to nine months worth of work in under an hour uh feel free I'm going to need to at least take one or two breaths uh through here so feel free to jump in if I go over something a little bit too quickly or um need to interrupt me and to clarify something but also obviously I'm sure we'll have some pretty good dialogue um here at the end so just a quick check that you can see my screen okay they're not sharing okay not yet how about now great yes okay looks like it's coming yeah there we go great so we'll go
027ahead and jump in and um you know as we've talked a lot of times is that you know this um we filter everything through the district's strategic plan and throughout the process we had a lot of Engagement and interaction with different levels within the Clayton community and these things kept popping up of Learners feeling safe and valued um that our Learners are having Equitable and personalized individual learning experiences and then the importance of the social emotional and physical well-being so just to know that that this is something that we look at it's a filter through this master plan and popped up a lot you know tonight we wanted to kind of go back to beginning establish a foundation but also these are some of the things that popped up that are really important to have
028a good understanding as before we launch into the master plan so that understanding that our Learners today they learn differently the teaching environment is differently the curriculum is a lot different than when the buildings that they're in were built especially the ones from the 1920s and the 1930s you know school districts our peer districts around Clayton have invested a lot of money in facilities and are set up to be future ready so really in order for Clayton to be and to continue to be that Premier School District not only locally but nationally there must be that investment in the facilities to keep on that Cutting Edge of Education through the demographic study we've seen that the resident enrollment might be projected to slowly decline but overall enrollment is projected to be pretty stable over the
029next 10 to 15 years and one of the reasons for that is because the district typically an increase in the tuition pting students especially in that sixth through nth grade when they enter into the into the district when we went through the facilities we realized that all of the buildings are compliant with the American with Disabilities Act but there's some challenges within them that we might not be Ada convenient and we'll touch on that a little bit you know all spaces are learning spaces inside and outside the building so that also includes that athletic and ity spaces and right now some of those facility needs are not really being supported especially at the high school level and at gayfield so as we move through this process the city has been a good partner with the
030district in the past and that relationship with the city is going to be crucial as we move forward especially on a couple of the things we're going to talk and show tonight and then even though the district spends about $4 million annually for that Capital Improvement and maintenance plans we know some of the things that we show tonight are going to go above and beyond so just knowing that the current what that current debt Levy is and what the district can borrow is basically up to about $90 million without an increase in that debt Levy so that just kind of helps set the stage and the foundation for some of the things we're going to talk about tonight here's essentially a graph showing on the left where the district was back in 1990 with the
031enrollment and where we're at today so overall over the last 30 years we're pretty steady with the with the enrollment part of that reason is even though you see a an increase in a little bit of a dip about 10% of the K through2 enrollment is actually non-residents one of that's really unique for Clayton versus other districts in the St Louis metro area and the ones that we work with but also the district is only 3.2 miles large so there's only seven other school districts across the state that are actually smaller so that plays into a lot of the things we're talking about tonight and then we also see this across the state is that a combination of the Aging population as well as lower birth rates is actually contributing to just lower enrollments across
032the state actually our demographers is predicting in the next 10 to 15 years there literally might be a handful of districts that see an actual increase in enrollment unless there's some big shift that comes to you know to our state this was one of the graphs within our demographics that kind of shows that Resident enrollment Decline and how that looks across um the different grade levels but again as we're talked about especially because of the Clayton's um reputation and the ability attract students from outside the district in we think that the enrollment is actually going to be fairly stable we also know that there's continuous conversation at the state level related to funding and potential open enrollment and if those things occur we actually think that they're um that actually solidifies that projection even further
033building on the capacity right now the things that we're talking about any sort of um facility improvements large scale facility improvements take a little bit of time to implement and so what you see here is not only our current enrollment for each building but also a snapshot in time of five and 10 years because even though marac right now is busting at the seams and we heard that and we've seen that within the data but if we look five and 10 years out all the buildings get within that sweet spot in that yellow and green area and what that allows us to do is it allows us to invest in those specialized Innovative learning environments as well as some of those larger indoor spaces like cafeterias and gymnasiums for those schoolwide and community events and
034we don't just have to address just regular general education classrooms we can invest in those Innovative specialized learning classrooms um that also allows within that sweet spot uh in that green and yellow zone when you have those larger grade levels that kind of move through the building it allows that larger second grade class to move all the way through the elementary school without displacing art or displacing Spanish or or music for example so it really helps from a facility planning standpoint to keep the students in the right environment when you're in that in that yellow and green area and so it's really important that when we show that graph that we get a snapshot in time so this right now is we're showing for every building every floor how that building is currently utilized so
035that when we look back at this three years five years or 10 years down the road we understand how these decisions were made the rooms that we're talking about where for example at Captain the sensory room was or the SSD was because we know down the line those spaces may change so there's going to be an example within our master plan of every school and every floor plan and that's really helpful for us as we went through this assessment process so this summer we went through every room in every building so we not only assessed the floors walls and ceilings we also looked at the heating ventilation and air conditioning and what the replacement costs would be and the timing of those would be because that can be a large expense back to the district
036also looked at the outside of the building such as your building envelope like your Roofing your brick your masonry and your windows and we also looked at the playgrounds the playfields the parking lots and driveways as well as your exterior lighting and then what's not included within our scope of work but what's included within the kind of the the big picture is the Safety and Security audit that tier one did last year for the district that is a filter that runs throughout our our project as well our part of the project as well so next I'm just going to show just a couple quick examples you've seen these before but we also know tonight's a good recap so for example the parking lots and drives here's at the high school and all these are very
037similar where green is something that's in good condition that might be 10 15 or 20 years out before it needs to be replaced or renovated if something is yellow that means it's in fair condition that needs to be you know addressed maybe in that 5 to 10 year range and if you see any red that's more in that immediate need where it needs to probably be addressed within the next two to 5 years so here's a great example of the high school um condition assessment of the parking lots and drives we go over to W down Middle School where we're looking at that exterior lighting so not only what type of lighting and where it's located but where those dark spots are and is it because a fixture is out or does a light fixture
038need to be added or is it simply a tree was planted and now it's matured now it's blocking that light so it helps a facility staff identify where those spaces are that need to be addressed because that Safety and Security especially when we get into this time of year um we're you know out there in the dark a little bit more um than than other times playgrounds and play fields are important as well not only for uh phys physical education but also obviously like recess and then the community use and each one of your especially your Elementary sites are very very tight and because of that those surfaces get a lot of use a lot more use and abuse so to speak than if they were you know two or three times the size so
039the constant need for replacement and repair is is very evident and um is really needed because of the amount of use that your spaces um get we talked about the exterior so this is just an example Le here of marac where we're looking at what type of roofing surfaces they are when they need to be replaced in their current conditions so that when we look at the when the warranty runs up we have a replacement plan or a plan to address them to continue the life of of that roof and then we also looked at the exterior of the building same thing same level of grading between like yellow and red of maybe some walls or Windows um for example there at marac we jump into our heating ventilation in inventory um so right now
040what we're looking at is a couple different options at each one of those buildings for a replacement and again timing those based on that yellow red and green type schedule so this is just an example of what's going to be included within the master plan as well the costs associated for replacement each one of those locations and then I talked about the um assessments of your floors walls and ceilings and this is just a snapshot here of Glenridge where you can see some of those areas for example the ceilings on the lower level at Glen Glen Ridge where a lot of that repair is needed and then to help facility staff moving forward it's really important that we identify the preferred products that they like to use and have seen success using so whether it's
041a design team an architecture team or it's facility staff making sure that we're specifying and using the right product so we went through and looked at all the interior type um U building materials so you'll see like drinking fountains for example as well as the colors of the paint so that when you know when we talk about a Clayton white or a Clayton gray or Clayton blue we have that color identified so it's consistent throughout the district um and we have those colors called out so we talked about those assessments and here is just what we tried to do is identify for each one of those scope items on the left such as your hbac your building envelope your Roofing flooring ceilings walls and then the condition that they're in and to try to assign
042a cost to them so for example on the HVAC line across the district basically within the next 5 years we think that there's just under $19 million worth of improvements or Replacements um in that 5 to 10 year window about 4.2 million for a total you can go across the to top there for a total of about $35 million of HVAC improvements and Replacements over the next 10 15 20 years and each one of those Scopes line up and go left to right so overall when we're talking about those Capital Improvement type projects about $94 million over the next you know 15 to 20 years of costs in both those long range um deferred maintenance type things and system improvements as well as just your regular replacement of your ceiling tile refreshing the paint on
043the walls Etc we also wanted to break it down a different way and to show it per location so for example Clayton High School it's one of your largest facilities so not surprising it has a large amount of that of the overall costs So within that 94 million same $94 million the high school has about $ 36.5 million do of facility improvements over the next 15 to 20 years but you can see how that's broken down within the red which is basically within five that yellow is about 5 to 10 and that green is about 10 to 20 years so that again we can look at how to budget for these cap capit improvements not only by the different scope of work but also by each location to put a good plan in place for
044the district to go through that process and one additional level of assessment we did was called the Hawkins Lily um School appraisal and the purpose of this was to really measure these older buildings against the really the 21st Century Learning and education environments that our students require today and the curriculum today because it really helps us determine if a building needs to be refreshed renovated adapted or decommissioned and so again I T touched on this a lot and it's going to be a common theme is that our sites and the the they're they're so tight and limited just as an example y down most of the physical structure the vertical structure of Y down is almost property line to property line and so if we just increased y down sight by two acres you would
045see y down go from a green at 89 up into the below 90s automatically so things like you know even though there's the parking garage there's still really not enough parking there's really not enough spot for physical play area for physical education or just to have classroom activities outside you know at White on you've got a lot of um pickup and drop off occurring basically at the street so those things negatively impact the scores and actually you know keep Li down for being more blue per se but there's also some real big facility Improv ments that are espcially needed uh related to The Learning environments at the elementary schools and that's reflected there um there in the yellow and so Dr Patel talked about the level of Engagement and it was pretty awesome so we're
046going to dive into each one of these a little bit but we had a lot of engagement at the building level Community level obviously with you guys I think now this is maybe like the eth or ninth time we've been together um but also that Community survey to make sure that we got that input from around the district so here is just a calendar or recap of what we did and when we did it um and to talk through these just a little bit more to remind everybody that that steering committee was like our guiding voice our filter throughout the whole process because we wanted to make sure whatever we produced really reflected the district's needs and the Strategic objectives so here's just the list of all the volunteers that helped us through this process
047that we met with um four five six times and then our building level subcommittees so we set these up at each one of the buildings to get that diverse group of stakeholders from each school to make sure that we get those deep insights of what it's like to live learn and play Within These facilities on a daily basis because we really needed to identify and prioritize those needs within each building so we're able to meet with these subcommittees twice at each building plus a joint meeting at the end and again here's uh a shout out to all the people that were part of of those groups and then as we went through this process we identified just a couple of extra things that we needed to do and so we had a special subcommittee that
048was made up of the coordinators of curriculum to really focus on that section as well as Safety and Security and Athletics and activities because these needed to have like a a deeper special dive into these key areas that were more I'll say District holistic versus building specific so again great interaction and engagement um as Dr Patel mentioned we were some where between 110 125 different members of the community of these subcommittees that helped us out through this process and without their support and without their guidance we would not have been ready for the community forums so we had a building level Community Forum at each building so that helped us be a little bit more focused on each one of those buildings and then we had two CommunityWide forums in November and December and all
049that data that we did through our assessments through the walkthroughs with the principles the heavy engagement with the steering committee and the subcommittees Really provided us the information that we needed to go out to the community and have these forums and really we wanted to make sure that everything that we were talking about ensure that alignment not only with the district goals and the vision but also what we were hearing from the buildings and the communities and when we got on the backside of these basically it kind of reaffirmed that we on the right track the things that we were coming up with were on track with with uh the expectations but also what we are hearing but be um the after that First Community Forum they gave us additional information to be able to
050go out to the community uh with a survey so you can see on the right this is the qu these are some of the questions we asked we asked them to just identify themselves by that kind of that role within the community but also which building they felt that strongest connection to um and you can see the results of that we asked some just a couple of questions so we know that if we were to ask the community what their number one priority is Safety and Security is always number one so we kind of took that off off the table and we just said other than Safety and Security what two priorities would you rank the highest and you can see there the green bars on the left are basically imp the one on the
051left is improving your air quality and the conditions of the HVAC units your systems and infrastructure and then the next one is that increase the specialized learning spaces for new and innovative of curriculum so those two really stood out from the rest and again we asked a little bit more specifically questions that were related to one or multiple buildings so what we asked is select your top five School building priorities and the one on the left there was increased and and update the specialized learning spaces and environment so again that one bubbled up to the top but you can also see there in the orange where we talked about at the beginning that uh mental physical social Wellness um added space for green space for uh play at the elementary schools and then expanding there
052at the last orange bar was expanding those in indoor um spaces for school and CommunityWide events at your elementary schools so those were stood out pretty well and we know that that slide was pretty um um small so we wanted to just show this in a different way and one of the things that came up um at very at the very beginning of the process but is also filtered through each one of these is what we call the districtwide common um themes and so you'll see and we'll talk through these a little bit more in detail here in a couple minutes and then at the very end um we had what we have called as the joint joint committee meeting where we at every member of the subcommittee at each building as well as the
053steering committee get together there in January at the high school in the library because it was an important end to the project an important end to that stakeholder engagement where we presented a lot of the information tonight to make sure that we had consensus that when basically when we left the room um that we really captured made sure that we captured that holistic view of all that data gathered through the process and that when we walked out we didn't have just a list of priorities per building that we truly had what was the districtwide priorities to help us set forth on this master plan together so any quick questions on on that before I uh continue on to a couple other things okay I'll jump in so um you've seen the slide before um but
054just it's important to remember that you know as we talked about what uh the profile of a Clayton graduate looks like today you know it's a shift in that learning environment to more empowered learning those opportunities for Innovation getting that Global Experience in real world Hands-On activities and what's great is that you know you've got a lot of businesses located really close to all of your schools which a lot of districts don't have and so looking for the opportunities to enhance that and remembering that Athletics and activities and the focus on those are very essential so what that can look like in the physical environment are those spaces for CTE so Career Technical education and some of those programs that the high school is doing um you know looking at those athletic type learning spaces
055as well as learning uh Studios and areas for performing and visual arts that recognition like your library at the high school it's not just an area for for books to store books and to read books you know it's that learning Commons and that area for uh Advanced learning and Project based learning and again we talked about the wellness spaces and that opportunity to have Community uh Partnerships and and that integration uh space this was a slide Dr Patel shared in one of one of her presentations but it was really came out a lot in our building subcommittees where especially the teachers and the staff talked about you know creating spaces that that lowered anxiety and lowered the stress of the students and a couple of ways to do that is having proper Acoustics within the
056space so both from noise from outside the noise from mechanical HVAC units but also just the proper Acoustics of the space also talking about just the overall Quality Air Quality indoor air environment as well as access to Natural Light daylight and Views so those were really good that I mean Dr Patel captured well in her slide but these are things that came up repeatedly in our conversations at each building and here's here's a little bit of a deeper dive into those common themes that kept coming up related to Safety and Security maintenance and hbac the accessibility and inclusivity within those spaces and then focusing on those special spaces for curriculum and and programming and some examples of what each one of those means and how it how it basically impacts every building we're talking about
057this is districtwide this is not every building has these types of needs um throughout the district and this is small intentionally but and this is just part of the data but as we went through these exercises we wanted to make sure that we captured captured everything but we really wanted to highlight those areas that the building level subcommittees talked about as their highest priorities so we did through our interaction with them we put a lot of information uh out in front of them and then basically ask them to identify their top three priorities and here are just some of those examples and they'll be more easily read within the document but those really helped lay the foundation for what we're calling then the next step is this long range kind of future design options and
058improvements because we what we tried to do is translate all the input that we received at the building level as well as District administration level and the community input into an actionable long range facility plan for each site so we had a lot of like I mentioned a lot of Engagement so these Solutions these proposed designs are really rooted within all that feedback that that we uh received so what we did is we took two or three different options to each one of the schools walked through those design options with them so that we looked at different ways to improve those facilities based on that feedback we got some feedback and then what you're seeing tonight is you know the basis of those revisions and that feedback that really um made sure that we captured
059that the feedback from each one of the buildings and and carried that forward so what we're showing tonight at each site is basically a long range potentially multiphase Improvement um step for each for each facility so I'm going to start and go just a little bit more in detail on the Family Center because a lot of what I'm talking about on this will be applied to the other sites so what you see in red on the right or sorry on the right hand side is the site plan for the family center and what you see in red is interior Renovations inside the space if you see a blue box that is a new addition new construction outside the existing footprint if it's gray that means it's something to do with asphalt parking lots driveways and
060then if it's green it's usually a playground or play Space over on the left you'll see up at the top it says level two so there's level one improvements which are kind of most of your Capital Improvement projects and then what we're calling a level two and a level three so what we're showing here is a level two type project and those uh uh priorities in Black are all of the top priorities that the family center identified that we are addressing based on this diagram on the right so there's the uh new addition for the multi-purpose and gross motor skills there's relocating the state play and learned from the high school back over to here there's interior Renovations of the classrooms better site circulation as well as the needed playground Renovations and expansion of the
061nature zone so that's what you see on the right and then a big disclaimer because we're going to talk about some costs tonight so these are all preliminary um they're all based on the same amount of data which is 2025 construction costs of recent similar type projects in the St Louis metro area but this is an order of magnitude only it's really based on dollars per square foot and not specific designs um so it allows us to get some costs on a on a page to be able to make to have good conversations and to be able to base future decisions on but it doesn't include what we call FF which is those fixtures Furnishings equipment doesn't include any professional fees or permitting and it doesn't and you'll hear us maybe talk about property acquisition
062or swing space and it doesn't include those two things and I'll touch on the swing space here in a minute so you also see a line for contingency and based on the level of complexity or the size of the building that contingency might range from 20 to 35% so we'll talk about that too but that'll be pretty consistent through everything that we showed tonight so on the Family Center you'll see on the leand side the different types of improvements so renovation new addition parking lots and drives then you'll see there that quantity so for example I think it's about 10,700 ft of renovation at the Family Center at about $100 a square foot gets us to you know just over a million just under $1.1 Million worth of costs longterm for renovation at the family
063center you can see down at the bottom that the subtotal gets us to about $5.9 million and then you can see that 30% takes care of some of that contingency some of the gc's um General conditions and some markup to get us overall big picture of these types of improvements at the family center about 7. $ 7 million when we go over to Captain Captain the building is a p a poured in place concrete structure so it's really hard to um make major modifications to that structure based on how it is so you can see on the left the IDE the uh priorities in Black that we were able to you know make some significant improvements on but something like the accessibility I I mentioned the structure is difficult to alter so we still have
064four five level changes within this building we talked about the site circulation being really tight we're not able to you know have a new drive lane or driveway or parking lot on the site so we really weren't able to add address the site circulation so that's why it's in red and crossed off you can see some of those other improvements on the site that we've reviewed before and then the costs associated with that so to do that level two type um Improvement app Captain would be about $18.8 million now I mentioned because captain that tight sight we really don't have a level three for that a level three would be a new building so we haven't shown that yet here for Captain but when we talk about Glen Ridge and marac we'll have a level
065two and a level three so for example at Glen Ridge you can see there the amount of renovation some Demolition and new construction and really what we what we're showing here it's going to fully maximize each one of those sites but it's also going to allow for limited opportunity for future growth both inside and outside the building a little opportunity and flexibility for adaptation and most of the Interior spaces in a level two would kind of remain as they are just just being refreshed so because of that we'd really have to look at the long-term viability of this building at Glen Ridge and marac in you know about 10 or 12 years from now if this approach is taken because we're not making a it's only a level two impact and not a level three
066so when we show level two at Glen Ridge our total costs are just under $27 million for that level two at Glen Ridge when we go and show a level three you can see it's it looks a little different so this is like a complete overhaul of the interior of the building a lot more Demolition and new construction on the back side of the building Glen Ridge would still look like Glen Ridge on at least three sides of the building but that back because because we're doing such a significant addition and we're doing such a significant renovation on the inside we're able to kind of reset the life of the building a little bit more we don't have to come back to you know Glen Ridge or marac as soon to re-evaluate it um it's
067going to even though we're fully maximizing the site it's going to allow for better future growth and adaptation inside the building because of how it's constructed um and so you know it's kind of hard to show a lot of examples of this at elementary level because all of our first generation big elementary schools are about this age um but we typically would see this in higher education where the outside of the building looks really similar but when you walk in it looks like a new building that might be 5 10 years old so for example so this is a level three at Glen Ridge and so again level two was about 27 million and 11 level three it's about $44 million at glenage when we talk about marac a lot of similarities because those buildings
068are laid out pretty similarly so a lot of adding on little chunks of of building here some renovation throughout um on this level too again it's going to fully maximize the site but we'd have to come back and really evaluate the long-term viability of this of this in in about 10 years so about a level two at marac is again pretty darn close at about $27 million because they're about the same size they're requiring about the same level of renovation and new additions just maybe in a little bit different way um one of the things with each each one of of these is that if we add a gymnasium it would also be a tornado safe room so that's why when you see a gymnasium it's $700 a square foot for example um that's code
069but it also a great amenity um needed amenity for for the district so again a level two for marac would be just under 27 million we go to what a level three at marac would look like again very similar um just one thing we're showing we haven't had conversations with the city but we think there might be an opportunity to expand parking up there in the EAS along the downside of Forest Park Parkway but a lot of similarities as I mentioned with with Glenridge here at marac and then when we get to level three at marac again we're just we're you know we're 44.5 million dollars for those for those level three improvements when we jump over to Y down even though y Down's 12 years old there's still some changes from a curriculum and
070from a use of a building that need to take place so that's why you see some of those red boxes within that building you see a blue box down at the bottom that's what we're talking about is um enclosing putting um you know making the um rooftop garden on the back side of the building making that an enclosed space but the biggest Improvement is taking the um the natural uh grass that's above the parking lot and turning that into artificial turf um the amount of use that that facility gets um and its inability to you know properly drain you know in weather like this for example really limits the use of that so we think that we can get artificial turf on there not only is it more conducive for uh PE it's more conducive
071for just general classroom activities um time during lunch to be able to go out there but also a better um uh surface uh for the community on nights and weekends so um here again we kind of consider that more like a level two at y down but there's a lot of level one type impacts there and so at y down we think it's about 4.2 4.3 Million worth of improvements um that are needed there and then when we get to the high school you're seeing some new additions on both sides of the of the uh campus as well as a lot of interior Renovations so again the items in Black were those highest priorities that we were able to address and the ones in Orange were ones that we were kind of sort of to
072be addressed so there's some things there with the um uh Performing Art Center that the way it's constructed a complete renovation of that or overhaul of that really difficult um without essentially just building it new so there we're talking about more of a light renovation versus a complete uh retrofit or complete overhaul so for a level two type of improvement at the high school we're at about $29 million of all those projects um stacked up there from top to bottom now we separated Athletics and activities um from the high school campus so what you see here is level two so this is essentially we're keeping everything where it is at gayfield but we're just you know replacing the turf and the track when it needs to we're replacing the buildings that really need to be
073replaced expanding the parking lot but then we're also looking at the city-owned uh Athletic Field down there behind the admin building and potentially renovating that and improving that so girls softball can use that better and then not to leave out adzic field so adzic field there you'll see some blue boxes kind of faintly that's to construct the Press Box the restrooms and the dugouts so we're calling this a level two because things are pretty much staying where they're at um and so level two is about $23 million but we wanted to ask the question before we um invest $23 million in those facilities are those facilities located in the right spot we know that there's some disadvantages of having gay Field located away from the high school it could be Safety and Security thing it
074is it limiting access to students because of they have to travel over there walk over there drive over there themselves we also know that it kind of is a little bit more difficult maybe to get people uh over there from um The High School uh versus if it was um you know on the same campus so we asked the question before we invested that $23 million in gayfield and um the Athletic Facility behind the admin building is there potential to partner with the city on what we're calling a land Swap and is it even possible to fit the activities that are currently occurring at gayfield to put those over top of the athletic fields that the city owns behind the admin building and vice versa and so here's a diagram that shows we we think
075it can work so on the upper left you'll see the footprint of the existing multi-purpose field that the city owns and the footprint of the existing softball field if that were to be overlaid over at gay field and then vice versa if we were to take the existing uh Fields behind um the athletic fields behind the high school could the football and track field fit on top of that area and we think it can as well as the other improvements that are needed for locker rooms training rooms the Press Box the grand stands the field events for example so this would essentially be we'd locate the High School athletics then back on the High School main campus and relocate the city-owned athletic fields over to gay field in addition to all the improvements for adic
076field so we think there's some really good opportunities for both the city and the school district to continue to investigate this um and to do that it would be about $30 million we think to do all of that and so that's going to be one of our recommendations coming out of this is to to take this to the next step of development and investigation and feasibility we also look like again when we're in a tight Urban environment like Clayton is if there's a aent property to any of your buildings like is there an opportunity there for a future use and we know that Claris has been talked about in the past but when we wanted to look at it is well first of all in option number two if something didn't work with the city
077owned property could the football field and track fit over top of klaris for example and it could um but we also looked at you know is that another opportunity for expansion of Athletics activities is that an opportunity for a new Performing Art Center and again we think it could be so up there on the top you'll see if if we kept the existing Claris building and use that for swing space um for those elementary schools for example if we we don't know if wasu is going to continue to expand you know could they want white 's campus well could that be a a future Middle School is that an opportunity for expansion of the high school for different Innovative type learning environments um can we keep the garage in place and do something similar that
078we're doing at yon and put a turf field on top of it for PE or for field hockey um could a new larger Performing Arts Center be placed adjacent to the garage on the east side there over the parking lot we think it can um the other thing we wanted to show is you know there's only about one other good spot that if you ever wanted to expand um you know the athletic side what we did is we copied your existing gym just east of um of that that footprint to show you know before any other improvements were to happen on that side of the of Campus that we want to make sure that you know future expansion of Athletics and activities is taken into account so um we didn't put any cost estimates to
079this because this was just purely high level of feasibility but we wanted to be able to diagram some of the conversations that we've had and some ideas that we had through this process so similar to what I mentioned with uh gayfield and and the city-owned athletic facilities um we wanted to have a conversation related to the elementary school so as I mentioned each site each elementary site is five acres or less when really that minimum for an elementary school is really closer to 8 to 10 for the minimum we also showed that there's a high cost of renovation of those existing facilities and there's a lot of disruption that would be caused by those construction activities occurring while school is in session in session so what we talked about is like can we identify some
080swing space to be able to move faculty and students and staff out of their home school and into the swing space for one or two years well there's a challenge of finding those spaces but then also the cost of relocating students and the cost of um renovating those spaces so that they could be elementary schools so um you know there there's some challenges there also if we were to take and re build new schools or uh on those existing sites it's almost impossible without relocating students as well so what you see up there at the top is the existing size of each of the elementary schools and with the improvements and the needs that we've identified for what each Elementary School needs moving forward we think that if you were to rebuild three elementary schools
081they would each be about 880,000 Square ft at about $450 square foot with the contingency at about $43 million for that construction so it doesn't include all the things that we talked about earlier but again before we invested you know uh $27 million or less into a level two or $44 million into a level three should we look at what new construction would be and so that's the question we're kind of proposing back um and and our recommendation back to the district is we think it's worth in and taking this one step further to see what it would take to rebuild the three elementary schools on different sites and before and before we make that decision also have that conversation because of the size of the elementary population two elementary schools is technically feasible so
082again just to ask that question before we rebuild three would we look at rebuilding to obviously larger than 880,000 Square ft so again that's going to be one of our major recommendations coming out of this process is that further exploration of feasibility study needed on you know both the elementary school of of what the renovation would be at each site or property acquisition and new construction so kind of parallel paths to investigate both to be able to provide um you know the Board of Education the community with all the information that's needed to evaluate that moving forward again just a reminder as we talked through this level two and level three type improvements um the current debt from the district is just under $35 million you know fully paid off in just about four years
083from now and that if the district were to put something on the ballot next April it would support about $90 million of bond funds of capital Improvement projects without a tax increase and then just to kind of recap everything on one page if we were to look at those um elementary schools what would that cost be for new elementary school just for those construction you know vertical construction so again there's some disclaimers there of what's included again that's that order of magnitude to help us have good conversations and um make decisions um to move forward into a design process and then you see there on the right hand side those level two and level three type costs where if you were to go uh go that route we think it's anywhere from 137 to about
084$178 Million worth of those long range potential future long range projects um at each site and then to kind of wrap it all up you know I think hopefully tonight we've shown how the plan and the comments and the feedbacks are all real really aligned with the Strategic plan you know recognizing that Learners today are it's just different um than when our schools uh were originally built especially the ones in the 20s and 30s you know for Clayton to continue to be that Premier District not only locally but nationally that continue to invest in state-of-the-art facilities is needed um the demographic uh studies you know support just basically a stable um popul enrollment uh for Clayton that allows us to invest in those Innovative and specialized learning environments um a lot of the improvements within
085the assessments can be handled within that $4 million Capital Improvement budget but when we start talking especially about those level two and level three type of improvements we're going to need some participation and partnership with the community Through um bond issue elections our recommendation like I mentioned tonight the next step Dr Patel mentioned earlier this is kind of the first phase that phase two really needs to be additional exploration of renovation of the elementary schools or um and the feasibility of new elementary schools and to have that go on a parallel path with additional development and study of those um facilities uh improvements that we diagrammed at the high school middle school Family Center and then lot of good collaboration and communication with the city is going to be really important as we investigate the
086Athletics and activities between the city-owned athletic fields and gay field um but hopefully you've seen that um we've had a lot of Engagement um you know the longrange master plan through the involvement of all the building subcommittees all the different stakeholders that extensive Community engagement that we had um you know provides you the Board of Education and Dr Patel all the information needed to evaluate the next steps moving forward um but I just I can't end just there just yet um this has been a great process uh and project for for Paragon um obviously getting to work with the board um Dr Patel Mr Brazil you guys have been with us every step of the way every meeting um it's been nine months of of really really uh great work um the Board of Education
087you guys have been right there with us along the way like I said this is probably our seventh eth or nth time meeting um but really that engagement at the building level the steering committee and the Community Feed uh Community forums that was just absolutely critical um and without you know you guys really pushing us and allowing us to get that deep um within the community um we wouldn't have get been able to get the data that we had so you know thank you for allowing us to do that thank you for allowing us to be part of this journey with you um and then just yeah opening up for uh all the questions wow okay Brad you can take a deep breath um I um be before we ask questions and comments because I
088know we probably all have a lot of them um I know I do I just want to start by thanking you so much you and your team there's like many of you who are not on the screen tonight that worked with Brad at Paragon for all your hard work throughout this process not only did you in detail evalu all of our current facilities but you facilitated the community forums the surveys the de the demographic studies um everything that you've presented tonight and it's certainly providing us with all the information we now need to um to move you know to move to the next step which is making some decisions about what's best for our district so I just appreciate all you did so much it's um a lot of information but it is thorough and
089everything we need to move forward so thank you so much for that um I I do appreciate it I'm going to save my questions and comments um for the end and I think because we're on Zoom it'll be easiest if I call on board members to ask theirs um I do want to before I do that just clarify this presentation will live on our website is that correct Dr Patel that is that is corre okay I just wanted to confirm that for the community watching because a lot of these slides have a lot had a lot information um and people watching might thinking like you you went too fast and they wanted to see it again or whatever so this will be on our district website so anyone at any time can refer back to
090this and certainly reach out to us with questions about it at any time and we have multiple volumes of uh PDF documents and books that have the um everything you've seen tonight from really detailed cost estimates to the demographic study to those floor plan uh so the site plan diagrams that we showed as well as floor plan diagrams um the survey results um I don't it's it's literally for books um I really don't know how many pages okay thank you I just wanted the community to be sure that you know there is a place they can go to to walk to look at this information again you know for the future so okay um is there anyone in particular that wants to go first otherwise I will just call on people um okay Ben you
091just un muted yourself so why don't you go first with any questions or comments you have for Brad or anyone else sure sure yeah thank you um Brad for the presentation and for your team's hard work and for everyone who's contributed to this it's really been been a fascinating thing to to observe um actually I had a lot of questions and then but you answered quite a few through the through the course of that presentation so uh thank you for that um I guess one of the things is um so this is an assess I mean so your facilities assessment obviously is kind of summarized in in the presentation that you provided um in terms of the data that we'll have from you is that is that really um you describe the depth of that
092assessment I know you talked a lot about like there's lots of different factors things that are needed but how how how how would you characterize the depth of that I think they call it FCA um document so uh just as an example you'll see the amount I'll just pick on the flooring and at the high school you'll see the amount of flooring that needs to be replaced within the next two to five years what type of flooring it is and how much it costs and where it's located within the building for the two to five year frame time frame the 5 to 10 and then the you know 10 years and Beyond um so it really will help uh facility staff to be able to see what hey as of today how we to uh
093plan our future improvements um and um to be able to budget but also just to scope out that work and start to see where some of those projects you can get some economies of scale to do some good overlap so if you're going to do a lot of work over in this side of the building you know just for example uh the art room you know can we take care of the flooring and the ceiling and the paint all in one shot um is everything really needed to be done over there at one time uh so without them needing to go through and do their own assessments we've captured all of that um for every building awesome awesome very good thank you um okay I had a couple specific questions on some of the slides
094um so um I thought one one one question I had I thought maybe would' be helpful is for um what what is what do you mean by envelope when you have a a that I kind think I know what it means but I'd love for you to yeah your building envelope is typically like your Roofing we call that building uh that's part of your building envelope but we outlined uh Roofing separate so your building envelope is mostly your walls so your brick and your masonry um your windows and your do so you will see like tuck pointing of so that's your joints of your masonry your sealant around the windows maybe some window or door Replacements as a whole um so the other part of that is we captured the number of Windows and the
095square footage of windows at at those buildings so again when we look at doing a window replacement project potentially we we can see really quickly what that would be without needing to do that in the future as a as a separate step so your facility guy team for example could go out and get a quote from three different manufacturers on what this would cost to replace these the size of window these number of Windows of the same size on the West Wall of this building as an example gotcha okay perfect and we have all that pretty well detailed out as it sounds like okay yes awesome awesome and so also so the the slides 16 and 17 which are the um long range Improvement cost by scope would you consider that like the level one
096stuff that needs to get done pretty much yes so that's a lot of those things that came up during the facility assessments but also those long uh those uh like uh new Roofing new HVAC systems for example those are those larger costs that um have a big impact on the learning environment that um some people just don't realize how much it cost and and what condition they're in so we wanted to be able to capture what the replacement cost would be and about when that should be budgeted for gotcha great um I guess I want to ask your opinion you know in terms of the cost so it's 94 million dollar right and I guess that extends out a little ways right uh maybe 15 years um would you consider that like the kind of
097these are kind of some mounting needs for all of our buildings like that have kind of been adding up a bit over or is this a fairly normal schedule of cost given age of buildings things like that yeah so I think one of the things that our teams saw was that the buildings are well maintained they're well taken care of they're they're clean um some of the a lot of those big costs are just the typical replacement of replacing Roofing and HVAC units and the typical wear and tear that occurs onto a building so actually I think overall the the facilities are in good shape I think the challenge becomes is like are they really suited for the educational environment are they well designed and set up for today and then are some of those
098replacement costs over time is it also looking at um at at your elementary schools just as a great example the amount of improvements that are needed to bring that facility really up to par for 21st Century Learning environments that what does that look like compared to new and so that's why we looked at that diagram and and helped scoping that out okay excellent thank you um one one question I had maybe if you could help me cl help clarify so between the level two and level three Investments and particularly I'm looking at the the elementary schools um one of one of the statements in here is um new school within existing shell to extend the life for decades um versus a level two which I believe it says let's see here um life of building
099resets on new addition but not entire structure can you tell tell us a little more about I'm just curious get a that so as we look at the existing building that might be colored red for example in a level two we're going in and it's more of a refresh of those spaces and not getting into the to the bones of the building the bones of the infrastructure that a level three would have same thing from the amount of you know so the on a level two we're looking at demolishing the gymnasium and hollowing out that core to kind of build back within it but there's a lot of constraints with that versus the level three has a lot more demolition on the back that allows us to have more purposeful space that's truly in size
100and designed for future needs but also the construction will allow us that flexibility um as well moving forward so it's more of a gut and overhaul in a level three versus a level two is when you walk into that space it's going to smell new it's going to have new finishes so to speak but a lot of the bones and guts are still going to be the same so in a level three so there um when you say gut it's really you really would be a a structural some structural factors as part of that yeah there there will be some there will be some structural improvements you know we'd have we'd have to look at the elevator placement and you know the we talked about the accessibility piece that's built into each one of those
101um but yeah there's like more of a complete overhaul of your mechanical electrical Plumbing uh systems than retrofitting and peace mealing um approach okay gotcha um I think maybe one way to describe it is it's more of a peace meal of Renovations and additions kind of cobbled together within a level two versus a level three is more of a holistic overhaul because you've got full access to the building you can kind of go in there and make it right for the long term gotcha gotcha and so that you would maintain the old uh elements of the old school there's still value in the older structure from a kind cost perspective or is it more of an aesthetic um it's a little bit of both so we think that from the the importance of the outside
102of those buildings to the neighborhood and Community is a is a strong Factor um what we actually find is the buildings from the 20s and 30s are better structurally um than our buildings that we are retrofitting from the 50s and 60s um and so um yeah so I think and that's one of the challenges frankly when we talk about Captain is that the the way that Captain was con construct constructed is a is a challenge it's it's harder to take that poured in place concrete structure and make major modifications to it plus it's built on five different levels within that building that you can't really over you guys have done the best that you can with the lifts to make it the way it is but it's still not awesome it's still not great you
103would I mean today we would never design a facility with that many level changes for example um and there's just not a good way the way it's constructed to really improve on it other than just to kind of live with it excellent um I think I just have one last question um one of the like the summary findings has to do with uh athletic and activity facility needs uh and I think it's especially at the high school um I wonder if you just talk a little bit about that um maybe just where our facilities are in your opinion because you obviously work with lots of different schools so I'm just curious what how would you characterize where we are right now I mean re realistically everything at gayfield needs to be completely replaced from your
104vertical construction uh the Press Box is in really poor condition that impacts your the way your students can utilize that space on game days the protection of equipment so forth you know the the uh locker rooms your training areas your um spaces for your students they're just they're not set up the way that they could be and should be for multiple Sports moving forward but also if we want to look at how you compare to pier and surrounding communities a lot of the other communities have put a lot of investment in those spaces um as well and it's just not uh Clayton is not at the same level as those other communities excellent okay that's it for me Stace thank you thanks Ben you asked some of my questions as well so um okay how
105about uh Chris would you like to go next with your questions okay yes thank you um thanks to Brad again this has been um and thanks to our entire Community for their involvement between the experts um that Brad has brought in and um the input that we've gotten I I'm just extremely um impressed with where we are today versus what we knew uh a year ago it's just a a world of difference for our district and um I we have a lot of great things to look forward to because we've started this process so I just want to start out by saying how exciting it is um okay so one of my questions was surrounding the Hawkins Lily School appraisal we've talked about and you've said this catchphrase um you're measuring the older buildings against
106the 21st centur educational requirements I wonder if you could be a um a little give some examples more specific on what that 21st century educational requirements are sure so I think if you look at um just one easy one is the gymnasium space at uh Glenridge and mirac um it was designed for activities that um were quite a bit different in the 20s and 30s than they are today um there's not enough storage just that that's a great and and we we hear that a lot from districts that we work with you you guys truly don't have enough storage space and when we look at the gymnasiums that's one of those areas that it's being used for storage and it's impact negatively impacting Student Activities within that space Also the inability to be able to
107get multiple grade levels and multiple sets of parents and family members into that space I would say somewhat comfortably it that that's a big deal um but even though those those spaces kind of look look cool and they're nice and they're well taken care of they're just not set up well and the number of students that that was initially designed for is quite a bit different than what's been added to that building over time so also if we look at the classrooms you know the classrooms were not designed they were designed for chairs and desks and in rows only teacher at the front one white one Blackboard um not the project-based learning that occurs not the Collaborative Learning spaces that occurs I mean even if we just look at what are the power requirements the
108electrical requirements that are needed today versus anything that's been done so those types of things actually all play into it and then as I mentioned especially like at y down you know pick up and drop off on the street is not best practice um being able to have space to just live and breathe outside is needed um and when your buildings go basically property line to property line W down is a great example that has a negative score on that as well I mean the everything that you that that you guys are can do shows up really well within those scores it's just those barriers that exist because of the infrastructure that's there um but it's not like a a negative um outlook on anything that the the district has done or isn't doing or
109can't overcome except for like really major renovations to be able to get those learning environments up to up to par for what not just what today looks like what the next 20 to 30 years and really that's the point of this is not to solve the the problem or the challenge of today it's to recognize those challenges of today that sets us up for success for the next 20 to 30 years and that's one of the things especially at those elementary schools that we're really looking at is like yes you can make those temporary improvements on a level two at the elementary school and everybody walks in there and it'll feel good it'll be exciting but does it really set you up for Success down the road and we don't think so and that that's
110why we came up with and wanted to look deeper and came up with those level threes but then when we started looking at that cost of what that level three is and looking at like wow what what would a new school be and obviously there's new CH there's all sorts of challenges with that but just just from a construction perspective we wanted to put that out there because once you go to make 27 20 30 $40 million investment in one one of those schools you've now committed to continue to make investment in that school for a long period of time and before you do that we want to make sure that you have the data that shows if you were to do new what would that cost and then different communities have made different decisions
111based on that same data but at least you have the data to evaluate it and that that was really the goal of us going through that exercise and I think that the other part of this is if we would have came back in the beginning and said hey three new schools are what you need I don't think there would been any sort of um acceptance of that we really had to go through the process and it was all brought to us through going through this process of all the challenges that we have at these buildings at these sites that really led us to be able to have that as a recommendation to say this is something that we need to look at a little bit further that's great okay thank you for that um those
112I think doing that part of the assessment again like you said was extremely important especially because our elementary schools two of them in particular are 100 years old um and even with what like you said the the third being so constricted by the way it was built so knowing those numbers are in the 600s out of a 100 on those scores you know versus our other buildings are in the 800s High 800s even um it it helps us give us a focus um on you know ensuring that those three buildings are really um appropriately um looked at long term rather than like you said thinking about those peace meal give us 5 to 10 years here and there versus an entire new structure would give us 20 to 30 you know could give us a
113hundred years you know depending on how we build it like like um like these buildings have for us so far but it does feel to me like this is a really clear sign of you know making that once a century you know um decision to make sure that these facilities are um up topce with like you said 21st century requirements knowing especially that those requirements will change rapidly um probably more rapidly than they ever have in the past 100 years um so I really appreciate that part of our analysis and the way you've described it as really helpful um I also want to say that um this survey is so so important to me and I think to the whole board to really understand and recognize um what our uh families are looking for in
114these schools and um I love that it really um you know we're we're taking out the HVAC and the Safety and Security um really because we know that those are you know clearly the priorities and what has to be done on a regular basis but I loved the three responses one of them was space for mental Wellness another one um was increased Green Space space and another one was like you said that common space area that could fit you know multiple CL multiple PE classes at the same time or um the entire student body plus parents you know to watch a performance of some kind um and it's it does occur to me that very clearly those level three um changes at the academic or at the uh Elementary level would address all of those
115things that the at survey and that our you know stakeholders are saying they really want um in terms of um those three things I just mentioned as well as the big big draw of having Innovative and flexible spaces for um continued you know Innovation as we move forward and um in time with with our the way we do education so I'm very excited about this idea of um brand new facilities and and would feel very um given what we know and the way you've presented it would it would feel um like a much more long-term um efficient plan to go that level um and so I was glad also for you to give us this concept of doing two elementary schools instead of three um you know your outside perspective has helped me see how
116where our elementary schools are located is is so incredibly con you know restrictive and um really now it's at time like I said it's a Once in a century time to think about um what elementary schools should look like in terms of how many acres they are and how we can get all the things that our survey has you know and that our teachers have said that they really need out of their learning spaces so um I'm really glad it's not something I had considered is you know to go from three buildings to two and to make those two buildings in SE places other than where they currently exist um because I think that's you know as a as a community and um it's hard for us to imagine that we this community is we
117love our you know the way that our um elementary schools are surrounded by you know our our neighborhoods and it feels you know it's such a f you know warm environment because of that it's Unique to our school system um to be in that that's that just kind of um like you said it it feels um like they really are part of the community because of the way they're they're located but I think we have to go bold and um and and realize that you know our education facilities um even if they're moved um are are really the most important thing for our district to continue to maintain so um we got to look at moving you know some of these locations and that's going to be hard um but I think with your guidance
118it makes me much more um um excited about that rather than looking at the challenges we really want to look at that as just a gigantic opportunity that you've helped us see um so I just want to make that comment um let me look what else um yeah okay okay um I did want to point out I've said almost everything except for I'll say it again maybe if I haven't said it already but um or if I've said it already you know I might be repeating myself but it's worth repeating that this idea of us going for something that is a 5 to 10 year fix um especially at the elementary levels but at any level we really want to consider um not just doing that short-term solution as a board I would like for
119us to really make sure that we're looking at the option to do a much more holistic um long-term plan um we we have the information to tell us what is um what is what could be done in a short-term way but I don't think that short-term look is um what's best for the the district um and then to my final question is um can you help me understand if we were to move sha Park uh sorry if we were to swap gay field into Shaw Park I did not see in that slide so help me understand if any perking would be added because I know that if you know every game and all the things that happen at a gay the gay field and all the you know it's not it's not just for practice
120time obviously we want that to be a space where all you know at every game and every um event that we have as many people from the community can come and attend and a you know um in a way that is feasible so parking is not something I saw on the that slide and I wondered what your thoughts were on that so if we look so sha Park itself would stay as is okay take those just where those two athletic fields are the multi-purpose and softball field yep we actually would not be negatively impacting the existing parking lot parking lots that exist around the administration building and around the high school so all that parking would stay as is okay I don't have the counts but I'm going to guess it's double the amount of
121parking that's located close to there versus what's at gayfield without without adding more okay I hear what you're saying Brad so you're saying because I'm thinking about that parking that's right behind it's very limited parking behind that multi-purpose field where it is now you're saying that we would also have that additional parking on the other side of um you know the the center and in the high school parking lot that and that that not be benefit of the high school piece right so have kids driving from the high school to gayfield they're already parked they're walking from the locker room or from I see what you're saying and they're walking over if they're already at school they're staying for you know the Freshman or JV game or they're staying for practice whatever it is so
122your transportation between sites becomes non-existent and then you get the benefit of all those spots that are needed on a daily basis for the high school and for the center to be available then for the Athletics and activities fields which I I think it's got to be at least double of the what's over at gayfield in close proximity like I'm not talking about the stuff that's on the other side of the gym even just the things that are in really close proximity to where the new Fields would be okay so you don't foresee that parking being a problem clearly it's not going to be right at gayfield it'll be you know there'll have to be some walking done it's not like you're going to get out of your car and walk you know but you're
123saying you don't foresee that being a an issue um capacity wise no no well I think that's all I have thank you so much Brad thanks Chris um okay how about Jason any questions or comments there you go okay um I'll add my thanks as well Brad I think um you've demonstrated you and your your firm have demonstrated tremendous amount of patience with us um and guiding us through this process and and um it's it's much appreciated and uh it's all reflected in in the work product here that you demonstrated tonight I I'm just sort of curious um I want to take us in a different path uh you spoke at the beginning about all the community input that went into this and I think we all recognize and and applaud that and appreciate um
124both you guys you know willing to dig in lean in on that and the community for showing up for that and are there one maybe two places in the plan in what you presented where you just sort of reflecting back you guys sort of had to Pivot because the community told you one thing you thought oh this is different than what we were anticipating so we're going to make a little bit of a change here that's a good question um thanks let me come let me let me think about that one for a minute because it was so iterative of the whole of the the whole process and we made sure that before we drew anything that we had all that feedback back because we didn't want we int we intentionally come into this process
125without any pre-conceived Notions and to start going on a tangent and drawing so um you know so so what we were talking about some of the things that wi down and some of the improvements that wi down um you know we as we lock worked through it and got the feedback at the community Forum about really you know that feasibility of it's It's kind of not even on there anymore of building a new footprint between the parking garage and the existing building like that's literally the only footprint that's there but just that feedback that you know it's not really going to be feasible it's going to be difficult like do we really want to show that um and no it's probably just more confusing than than not um I'm trying to think you know actually
126some of the conversation that um actually we did get some good feedback um during the community forums about the Callis property um and we actually some of the feedback that we got made us look at that potential for relocating the Performing Arts Center over that and if then also the question was asked you know um well what is that build I think the kind of the question was what is that building good for um and that's really what we started looking into I was like well wait a second you know we've got the infrastructure here of the parking garage just as an example that you know one way is yeah you could clear that out and do something else but you know there's we didn't do the full investigation a full investigation into it but
127you know I think the feasibility is does that top gar part of the garage become activity space and be able to use the parking under it similar to what we're doing at y down you know how can we use that investment there at the corner so um for future use for the district so a lot of that conversation came out of some of those questions that we got I'll say formally during the community Forum but also the conversations that occur after those meetings uh with the community members that are there um help generate some of those ideas and Concepts at Claris just as an example yeah that's great thanks that was my only real question everything else has been asked so again appreciate the work thanks Jason okay that was a great question um Pam
128thank you um like everyone thank you so much I also wanted to call out our building principles and John Brazil and Dr Patel who were at every single one of these meetings and put in so much extra time so I just want to give a heartfelt thank you to all of you I don't even know if the principles are here um but um so to frame I think just really my two questions is to say that Clayton is a Comm commun that values tradition and education and I'm I know that you saw that in your work um it is our task as the board to honor Clayton's values and balance it with a great deal of fiscal responsibility in light of this that's that's going to be that will keep us on task um the
129way you presented like the last third of your presentation is you were talking about the elementary schools and proposing this idea of two elementary schools initially as a Clayton person who values that tradition that seems very scary um but I the way you laid it out was incredibly beautiful and I just it allowed me to think about it that the values from the survey from the community were to expand our indoor spaces for you know Innovative learning new kinds of learning um counseling centers and Community Gathering areas expand inside Space it was also to expand outdoor space and because as you have said our buildings don't have the ability to expand both indoor and outdoor spaces it really allowed me to see the beauty of the proposal for um new buildings or new two new
130the idea of two rather than three elementary schools um because there isn't a way to do all of what those buildings need um all of my my other questions were answered there's one thing about the Hawkins Lily on p uh 18 page 18 of their slides so I understand all these colors but I'm not sure if I understand the details inside of them so if we were just to like look at glennridge like 30 8.5% I would like to understand this so that if someone in the community asks me what this means I could explain it so 38.5% is red is that like 38.5% of the square footage needs that kind is a poor condition yes so no that's a good question so previously we had just kind of shown that chart up at the
131top right was just the overall score and actually back to Jason's comment like one of the questions that came up during some of these interactions at the Community Forum was just it was hard to understand some of the details of that building by just that top score so that's why we uh showed it this other way to show like for example like out of the what that represents what and I can't read the numbers but if it's 83% 83% of the scoring was red you know 17% of the scoring was yellow and then you can see the key to the right of it of what that looks like you know deficient borderline satisfactory or excellent because and that's what it's a challenge because I think if you just looked at the upper chart you kind
132of paints a different picture to see really how potentially I'll say deficient Glenridge and marac are compared to really how excellent marac and the high school and Family Center are right there's there's a lot of blue within those scores um and it's reflective of the quality of those spaces but they still need help they still need need um you know that additional space or different types of spaces or quality of spaces to launch forward for the next 20 or 30 years thank you for that explanation and thank you for everything we'll miss you hopefully you keep me around for a little bit longer and my team thanks Pam um so I just I have a couple obser a few observations I just wanted to point point out because we were just presenting with so much
133um information it's kind of overwhelming one thing that stood out to me with your presentation and your findings is that whatever we decide to do here it is critical and essential that we keep the lines of communication open with the city I think you've presented a lot of opportunities for land swaps or land purchases um and so I just think moving forward we need to continue to keep them informed with whatever we're thinking and and doing they we you know Clayton is is different than a lot of districts we have a little bit of Richmond Heights but all of Clayton really basically one municipality with one school district and so that partnership together is critical to our success and frankly to the city's success right if we want the school district to be the best
134it can be which it has been it helps the city and the strength of the city helps us um and just so everyone knows um David Gibson the city manager as well as a few of the aldermen were on our steering committee and some of the building level committees so they have been part of the process so far but I just know it's critical to continue to include them moving forward um the second you know kind of observation I have through all of this is that our it seems our elementary schools have both the biggest the greatest needs but also present the greatest challenges to fix and I was kind of like focused on uh one of your last slides where you said you know ideally the space needed for an elementary school is or
135recommended is 8 to 10 acres and ours are on much less than that so clearly you know like Chris and Pam touched on your suggestion of possibly you know Finding land to build to new elementary schools instead I think we just need to remind remain open-minded to what we can do if we really want to commit ourselves to improving the elementary school facilities as best we can because those spaces are so constrained um and so not only is there not a lot of room to expand or rebuild there's not even a lot of room for construction equipment to get in there like it's so I think that that being said whatever we decide to do moving forward that you know the community the board everyone needs to just remain open-minded you know be supportive of
136us thinking outside the box because we really do have a lot of constraints both on our current facility properties but also there is not much other land within our district boundaries to even acquire to do new construction so we are going to have to really be creative and think outside the box and I'm really hoping and um uh hoping that the community will support you know whatever we come up with because of we have so many constraints there too so I I think another important piece there obviously is is there property to acquire if we need it is there property to lease if we need swing space because we're using you know we're renovating the current property so it it's a lot to think about certainly um I I wanted to also point out uh
137one more thing and that is that the survey results show from the community that um in addition to Safety and Security that they their priority was increasing you know Innovative learning opportunities with real world um experiences for our students and I think when I think about that and then think about the numbers the data you gave us for capacity in our buildings you know it doesn't necessarily look like all of our buildings are over capacity or anything I think the capacity in a lot of them is fine I think we just need to all of us including the community rethink how the spaces in our buildings are used currently and how they will lend themselves to that top priority of innovative Real World Learning opportuni so although we may have capacity for all of our
138students at this point it it's very become very apparent that we don't have the right space um for the learning that is also a priority for everyone so I think um uh an one oh sorry I forgot one more thing I wanted to point out and I think you mentioned briefly is that a lot of our neighboring districts have invested in their facilities lately um Leo builts you know renovated or built Al elementary schools and a new football stadium and redid their High School uh I believe Webster Groves did a lot of construction Lindberg and so if if our priority and the community's priority is for us to remain a leading District in the region and the country our facilities have to reflect that and if we are being stifled Now by not being able
139to offer some of the programs that these other districts can now offer we really need to take that to heart and think about that for sure so um I think for me and I I probably speak for the whole board at the end of the day what I think needs to guide us is TR what is best for our students into the future that's it we have to we always make all of our decisions with students at the center of them and I think we need to continually remind ourselves of that through this process it's not even it's not our students today but it's students like Chris said generationally you know for the next several decades so what is education going to look like and what will our facilities what is best for them as
140far as our facilities go so um in closing again thank you Brad and the community probably doesn't realized this but Brad and his team travel here from Springfield Missouri every every time they meet with us which is reason why just you sorry travels from Springfield Missouri which is another reason why we're virtual tonight but so thank you for that additional effort to just get here and meet with us and I just wanted to also publicly thank um everyone who served I think you said it what it was 117 people on all of our building level and steering committees and everyone in the community who participated in the surveys um and came to the forums because this is truly a community effort and we need everyone's input so thank you so much I think we have
141obviously a lot to think about but you've given us everything we need to do so you know as a great starting point so we appreciate it Brad I'm sure we will um be in touch as we move forward but thank you for all your hard work again we appreciate it no worries we're here thank you so much okay that was great all right um okay moving along that was our only presentation of the night we are moving to the consent agenda items um Chris I will call on you to read a motion for those please I move that we approve the consent agenda items 7.1 through 7.7 second okay um it's been moved and seconded all those in favor I I any opposed okay none opposed so the consent agenda passes and I will move
142on to any board committee or Community updates does anyone have any raise your hand I don't have a list in front of me did anyone have any uh committee meetings okay I had a teaching and learning um committee meeting and this time we reviewed uh the literacy curriculum so um we started off by kind of getting an overview of recent legis that's impact literacy in in recent years like when the dyslexia screening became mandated and we talked a little bit about the ban books and now state New State approved assessments reading success plans that was like a great way to kind of ground Us in the discussion um we learned about what's changed in the K through five literacy curriculum and what hasn't changed for example um the foundational skills transfer of information in the
143scope has kind of all been revised but what has not changed is um the choice in their learning um their independent time workshops um currently the literacy curriculum for grades six through eight is being revised to more uh cohesively vertically align with grades five through nine the grades that have are coming into middle school and where they're headed out of middle school so that vertical alignment is obviously really important for those transition years um also we broke up into small groups to discuss um three different three different areas as far as literacy curriculum um the instruction assessments and intervention and student growth and it was great because um this committee as all of our committees are filled with different types of stakeholders there were teachers there were students there were parents and just to hear
144everyone's different perspectives in those areas was really great and also lastly I'll just add that we learned um all of our staff the last few years have had a lot of professional development on literacy interventions so I think it's important to note that a lot of time has been dedicated to that for our staff as well and okay if there's no other um reports from any committees we can motion to adjourn Chris I move the the Board of Education adjourn second okay it's been moved and seconded all those in favor I um any opposed