CorpusRecord 54183

2/5/25 Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Clayton
Date
2025-02-06
Location
St. Louis County, MO
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,305 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e coming from another meeting um adequate notice has been given I'd like everyone to stand and join us in saying the Pledge please pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay Chris will you read the motion to approve the agenda please I move that we approve the agenda as posted second all those in favor I I any opposed okay motion passes okay um Dr Murdoch we are going to move to recognizing our own I don't they can hear you you hear me testing there we go good evening everyone all right so I am here to recognize Glen ridge's own Corey Kent he is our custodial super supervisor um he exemplifies

002the spirit of it takes a village um he embodies the essence of a true Fred as described in one of my favorite books the Fred Factor so if you haven't read that book is a great book um nobody can prevent you from choosing to be extraordinary and that's Mr Kent Corey goes above and beyond his duties ensuring our building is spotless and supporting staff with countless handyman tasks daily he ensures that our building is clean he helps individuals load and unload their vehicles he has helped me hang up more signs than I can count all with the smile um he never seems to stress when he's getting calls to clean up all types of messes across the building he's has a smile and he's going from one mess to the next um he always shows

003school spirit by participating in school spirit days and Halloween even even if it's not his favorite he still does it uh more than that he steps into the role of a big brother for our students offering guidance conversation and activities to help them process emotions and fine stability uh his involvement in the African-American male affinity group has been very pivotal in our building he has profoundly impacted our whole entire Glen Ridge Community teachers staff and students are better because of his extraordinary care and dedication to our school [Applause] Community come up Mr Kent and then we have some staff members that are here to support Mr Kent so I would love for them to come up to and a colleague M yes come up [Applause] and we're recognizing another one of our own from Steve

004Hudson please that okay you're going need to do your like you know thank you tonight I'm here to recognize our head girls soccer coach who also is our head boys SOC ER coach that is Brenan Taylor heated there just right in front of some of his players um why this is uncomfortable sorry uh why the obvious answer might be the fact he's one of nine coaches in the history of high school soccer Missouri to win both a girl state championship and a boy state championship another obvious answer might be uh that he and his father are the only two fatherson in the history of high school soccer in Missouri to both win a state championship in boys soccer you put that up a little early that was a surprise but um we thought it would

005be an awesome idea to go to Parkway West and dig through their trophy cabinet and get that picture from the 1986 state championship so there's coach Taylor with the with the 1986 trophy so that a special moment for him and his father uh um these are obvious reasons uh why I advocated to recognize coach Taylor at this table um the more importantly uh the environment that he creates on the soccer field um Fosters a teaching environment uh that builds strong character and teaches lessons that can be taken from the field to navigate the difficult World ahead uh the curriculum that he teaches on the soccer field is woven throughout what we call the profile of a graduate myself Dr Batel Dr kisi and many others in this room got to witness this Excellence when we

006went out to lyndenwood to watch the state semi-final boys game and the state championship the way they organized the seating we as Spectators or administrators had to sit directly behind the bench to monitor our students and it was absolutely incredible to watch coach Taylor and his assistants interact with these boys that night parents often ask me what makes a successful coach and I always ask how many of their alumni come back to visit them how much did their coach mean to them I have another picture up there wherever he went boom there it is if you ever need me for technology please call uh so this is just evidence of that um here is a picture from a pickup soccer game that many of the alumni soccer players came back to play with their former

007head coach I'll end with this I was at a longterm facilities planning meeting in this room seated probably right here and at my table was one of the starting soccer players defensive back for that state championship team uh I was a few days before the semi-final final games and I said how you feeling about the games and without pausing he said we cannot be better prepared so I probably checked out of that meeting for 20 minutes and all because could he have made a better statement me refer reference back to my notes I don't want to mess this up it was clear that one of the brightest young men that Clayton High School had to offer knew that preparation equaled success and we got to witness on that cold windy evening at Lindenwood University what

008preparation looks like because the boys some of them seated back there absolutely dominated so coach Taylor from the bottom of my heart I value you as a friend I value you as a coach but more importantly everyone in this room values values you for what you do for the students at CHS so thank [Applause] you hey coach I think you're a pretty good teacher too maybe we get you on another team over here one day on students come in yes please thank you [Applause] [Music] all congratulations again to both Corey and Brendan um we're so proud and happy we can recognize you here here tonight um no pressure If Everyone anyone wants to leave the meeting now though too anyone that came for Corey or Brendan you don't need to stay congratulations um we are

009moving on to the best yeah well that's that is true um public participation we do have one public comment tonight um from ltha Marie Kaine oh wait yeah Jeff will get you set up on the microphone hi everyone my name is ltha Kane right I like to say thank you for having me this evening um I wanted to share something very quickly it's going to be very short uh my grandfather was very fond of this District uh his name was Donald Larry young um fortunately he passed away and I would like to continue what he started and so more to come but thank you guys so much for uh welcoming my grandfather while he was here he was very fond of uh claim School District so so I would like to thank you guys on

010his behalf and I hope you guys have an amazing school year thank you thank you so much for sharing that thank you okay we will move on now to 4.1 superintendent Communications from Dr Patel okay um continuing with the celebrations I wanted to first start off with by sharing an amazing experience I had last week so last week Dr gusi and I got to attend the Missouri music educators conference at oage Beach and every year I get invited to it and every year something comes up so I I'm not able to attend um but I made it a point this year to really be there and Jeff if you don't mind getting to that picture for me um the students were remarkable I I don't know if I have the exact words how to express

011what I felt when they were performing they were one of three high schools in the state that got selected to perform and apparently for the past four years you you're eligible every 3 years to go and perform and for the past 12 years the are high school's always at the conference and is selected to do that and I I really have no words for how amazing they were in fact at the end of their performance there was a photographer there who had been there all week listening to all the um different performances and she came up to Dr gusi and I and know and I couldn't believe it but she was literally crying and she said that that that music that our students performed and she'd been there all week she said and she'd seen

012so many students but this moved her so much so I just want to highlight all of those students and especially our teachers Daniel Henderson who puts in hours and hours of work in getting them to this level so thank you Dr gusi as always for being there and supporting our students as well so I I think you would agree that it was was remarkable abely one of my P yes and I learned that so I was like great but they were remarkable so I just wanted to make sure we recognize them um and then at the middle school again student highlights I want to keep giving some shoutouts we had our eighth grade Exploratorium team that went to rala Missouri to do um participate in a future cities competition um there's a lot of work

013that goes behind the scenes to get our students prepared for that and they came in second place so that was great for them and a great learning experience for them and then our student kayn who's an eighth grader at weown right now won the Healthy Living poster competition that's put together by the St Louis County Department of Public Health there were over 700 entries and she was the winner so her artwork is going to be featured on the calendar cover and inside 700 entries yeah our students continue to impress us and then lastly I wanted to share this um story so I was at miramac last week I believe and I was talking to Mr Osborne Mr Osborne if anybody knows he was at miramac fifth grade teacher for quite a few years and then

014we had the science opening and he became our science um specialist at miramac and so I'm like so how is it going how's everything you know this year you're teaching you and he actually said and I quote I feel guilty when I get my paycheck because I love what I do so much like he he is in heaven he said the students are remarkable and then he said what was amazing is he's preparing the students for the science fair that they have and it's going to be on March 8th so all the elementary schools participate in it and he shared how high school students go go to miramac to Mentor the science kids and help them presenting fine-tuning their science projects and so these are just pictures of our high school students working with elementary

015students and again volunteering to do that so amazing students everywhere that you see so I just wanted to share those highlights with our students and what they're up to um Switching gears long range facilities master plan I'm not sharing a lot tonight obviously but just know that anyone who's um in the audience are viewing right now our long range facilities master plan is nearing coming to completion they will Paragon will be here next at the next board meeting yes February 19th to give us their final results um and again just a reminder it was I think the last time we went through a process this in depth was 2008 so that was quite a while ago um we had over 110 committee members involved in the process almost 300 community members um gave input through

016a survey we had about I can't remember how many um Community forums that we had at least eight where we had opportunities for communities to come in and give us input on this so all of those results are being compiled and Paragon will present all of that at the next board meeting so looking forward to that result the results there and then ongoing conversations after that and then finally tonight we have two presentations that I'm looking forward to um hearing about the first one is cognia presentation um Mr suker is going to be here and Dr gusi is going to be at the table and they're going to talk to us about cogia which is a global organization that um Works across I think 80 countries and they come into schools and it's almost like

017a continuous improvement process so our Clayton High School has been in Partnership for over a hundred years with this and they come in and they have rubrics and they'll get into all the information but I just think it's important for our community and the board to hear what a thorough process it is and an extern external entity coming into our high school to look at all of our programming schoolwide and the amount of work they put into that a lot of Kudos and a lot of celebrations and the best part is that they they show us areas that we need to continue to improve on so that's our first presentation and then the next one is a just a legislative update from our um friend Jerry Hawkman who always has been helping us and volunteering

018I do want everybody to recognize that he's volunteering his time and helping us um with this and thank you to Leo who because of the board and Leo we have our legislative ADV ADV advisory committee for the first time this year and Leo's our board rep on that and he's been working with Jerry they they're having meetings and keeping us updated on what's happening in Jefferson City which we really need to pay close attention on for sure and thank you Leo I know you've also been attending all the PTO meetings to let them know about what's happening so you're going to steal my entire report for later in the meeting what am I talk sorry okay there you go just rewind pretend I didn't say that um so yeah that is our update for now

019and Lucia is not well so I hope she's taking care of herself so we don't have a student update today right I was going to say that as well um that no uh student rep update tonight but we look forward to Lucia feeling better and joining us next time um so at this time I'd call on Dr KUSI and Mr suker to come talk to us about Coga good evening I see uh uh coach Hudson left I thought he was just really excited about cogo when I walked in and saw I'm sitting here uh but um but no I was glad I was really glad till we got to recognize Brendan but thank you uh for having us here this evening uh Craig and I are going to talk a little bit about uh cognia

020and the history and give a little context for it and talk about uh like how we use it and and uh how we move forward using the information that we gained from from the the the cognia visit first off cognia uh is an organization that has been in existence for over a 100 years and and Clayton High School has had a relationship with this organization and it's been it's gone through a couple iterations but U as Dr Patel said for over 100 years and we've we actually have the longest continuous relationship with cognia uh in Missouri and actually one of the longest in the entire in the midwest uh like Dr pel said it goes back over a hundred years but cogni is a global organization that supports institutions a lot of educational institutions it

021also works some in healthcare and a couple of other Industries uh through the process of uh continuous Improvement uh it's gone by a couple different names uh at one point it was Advance Ed and before that for a very long time it it was North Central and um basically this organization originally developed like I said over a 100 years ago to help organizations uh focus on uh continuous Improvement and so this organization predates all you know the state accreditation systems the the state school Improvement efforts so they were kind of one of the original uh organizations that that was really well respected Nationwide in in helping organizations with this work and and and Clayton has been a part of this or been doing this work for a long long time and so as as this

022organization has has has progressed one of the things that I'll admit has happened with with some districts there used to be a lot of districts that were associated with North Central and and with with Advance Ed but with the rise of school accreditation systems and and school Improvement plans um sometime going back you know 10 or 15 year 15 or 20 years um a lot of times it seemed like kind of like parallel play you were doing one thing for the state and you were doing this other kind of accreditation system this other continuous Improvement and it kind of seemed like you were doing double work actually and and and they weren't really aligning and one of the things that happened with cognia was they really evaluated and really reached out to the the members

023and said you know how how can we be helpful one of the things that we said was this idea that that you know aligning with like the various State accreditation system um and allowing us to like kind of adapt and not be so cookie cutter and and they very much really responded so one of the things that that Coga did was they really focused on the needs of each individual organization and help let the organization kind of guide the the direction of the uh of the review and the uh focus of the continuous Improvement so going back I guess to 2010 uh we we did an engagement review at that time and and basically we our focus at the time was around aligning arrows one of the things that the the visit found was we

024had all these great initiatives and I'll call them pockets of Excellence but they weren't really um coordinated actually so the the and and so one of the the the big uh focuses of that work was aligning our arrows and making sure that you know that the old adage of work work smarter not harder and and and making sure that we uh were aligning all of our efforts and as as a result of that we developed our building PDC that functions in alignment with District PDC and and District Improvement goals also out of that work came our Equity committee and our Wellness committee which function as subcommittees of the larger group so that all of our efforts are are are aligned so fast forward another five years actually the the feedback from the 2015 Engagement review

025focused on the need for formative versus summi of assessment and how we were using assessment in in the classroom and so that that actually kicked off a lot of work focusing on uh for formative and summative assessment it got a little Sidetrack during Co in there but but ultimately that was the really kind of the the impetus uh for a lot of our work in uh our grading reforms our grading for equity and it was really found it was really important to our foundational work and and where we are today then uh our next review was in 2019 and then one one of the uh one of the things we focused on there that came out of that review was how we use use data to form or and inform our school Improvement plan and

026so the basically you know kind of analogous to a funnel the strategies were protocols and structures to access and analyze data to produce focused focused and needed goals which leads us to our our last review which was uh last year in 2024 and um and the cogn group actually uh revamped how they how some of the structures that they use as part of the review process process to make it like much more adaptable uh and uh Craig's going to talk about that now thank you Dan so uh what we're presenting here with intention uh is kind of a Continuum of uh Dan starting out with a big picture um in regard to overview history and context and what I want to move to now uh is to help you understand what the work was really

027like uh both in terms of our specific actions and the different components of the review so an important time stamp like Dan said was about one year ago almost exactly in the middle of February of 2024 uh when we hosted the review and then eight months prior to that uh we worked with a lead evaluator from uh cognia uh not completely but mostly uh on four important areas four important project areas and those involve families uh students and staff uh producing data in our making meaning out of that data and so what I'm going to try real hard to do within six minutes is to try and encapsulate um eight eight months of of pretty dense work and I I think I can get there um and just not to interrupt you but you guys

028have the clicker there if you need for the slides okay so and actually yeah this is right on time because I'm gonna address the four bullets um and not exactly in the order that they're listed there uh in favor of that I kind of want to talk about those that are kind of the easiest understand first uh and then move to the ones that uh might need a little bit more explanation um so the first important component is a student performance diagnostic uh powerfully but simply uh that's a focus on student achievement and this is a specific example of what Dan reference um while cogni requires this component uh as a part of all reviews uh they give latitude to schools to choose what data uh holds the most meaning for them so it was

029with uh uh easy and obvious um logic that we focused on uh student achievement on the SAT standardized test series and also our EOC scores because those are foundational to how we developed our school Improvement plan and how we continue to look at um assessing the effectiveness of that plan and adjustments that we need to make uh the second uh category were stakeholder surveys uh we use separate related surveys uh for staff input perceptional input put uh families uh and also students uh we did actually choose cognia uh standard surveys uh because they uh were written in a manner that both aligned uh with each other and also aligned with what I'm going to talk about next uh which are the performance standards and the review of that but before we do I kind of

030want to interject uh that already you're starting to appreciate I think uh that that what we're producing is a a rich source of deep data to make meaning out of in in impactful ways uh for us and our kids and strategically what we want to accomplish uh in any and all times is to triangulate that data right to try and find multiple data sources uh that kind of speak to the same uh point of for Focus so if we transition from the stakeholder surveys to the performance standards um there are a lot of parallel uh uh prompts and considerations for reflection in those now uh the standards uh there are 30 total standards that cognia has uh in they're in four categories engagement of learning culture of learning leadership for Learning and growth in learning

031and so we did with those 30 standards was broke them into uh groups that best aligned uh with different cohorts of folks uh both in our building and districtwide so as an example of that our full staff uh evaluated about seven or eight of the standards our curriculum coordinators looked at about four of the standards uh memory doesn't serve all the math but it would add up to 30 if I got it all right but also building Leadership Council looked at some of the standards building Administration and also our building professional learning committee uh when we did that we applied a really strict protocol that was very important for efficiency and Effectiveness and I know this is absolutely true uh for teachers and I suspect it's probably true among other professionals uh considering these standards

032in a group of teachers is an opportunity to get into the weeds very very quickly and for things to become more muddy uh compared to the atttention of clarity that's coming out of that so for every one of the 30 standards all these different groups the approach was the same uh individuals spent two minutes silently individually to read the standard to best understand the standard and to start thinking about how they would rate that standard against cogni numeric fourpoint scale uh after 2 minutes was up we had timers working we said we need a person who's really good at keeping time and this is going to be your skill set and we need you uh then we had uh three minutes uh for folks in the group then to just share thinking uh takeaways and

033connections to obviously kind of cultivate the thinking of the group and then after that there was one minute uh for individuals again silently themselves uh to record their uh rating on the fourpoint scale and to try and come up with as many examples of evidence that would kind of be used to justify uh that rating uh so when we did that for 30 different standards again you can imagine the wealth of data that came out of that both as uh numeric metrics and also uh the U kind of qualitative uh evidences examples through that uh the last component uh the acronym is the Elliott it's the effective learning environment observational Tool uh this is a fantastic tool it was developed in 2012 it's been uh continuously utilized and refined since then it has Rich uh

034basis uh in research that confirms its reliability along with that uh observers uh go through it's not an extensive certification but an important certification you know online for about two hours to go through modules uh for the important point of in Rider reliability so uh last fall a year ago last fall our observers were uh Dan Regina Moore Drew Spiegel Cameron p melena AR ganino Janet Cruz I miss Janet I know I can say that yeah you can okay can I do it's true um and myself um and that instrument uh had seven categories and each of those had about four or five different indicators within them and the categories uh are probably predictable and then helpful to hear uh to confirm your thinking uh looking for aspects of uh Equitable learning high expectations supportive

035learning Active Learning progress monitoring well-managed classrooms and then digital learning so from that effort we were able to execute together uh 40 uh classroom observations okay so uh I again I picked these because that was primarily the work of data collection that involved all of our stakeholders families students uh and staff and then there were other smaller pieces um that was like an executive summary so folks could kind understand sort of our demographics and shape um but again the bulk of the work uh toward continuous Improvement uh really came through those Endeavors and then what happened next right because what uh Dan and myself as the lead writers needed to do was to um C through that comprehensive amount of information and we we're cognized as fantastic job of training uh in this endeavor and

036the resources that support um kind of organizing the thinking and the results uh of this uh was to first to take this massive amount of data and to analyze it and then in that analysis to produce findings of which there's many and then an attempt to try and synthesize those findings to make it more definitive and then with the synthesized findings then to drill into what is the root cause of those findings and then with the root causes then we develop theories of action to do two really really important things and and the first one's one that sometimes we miss um we need theories of action to continue to sustain the things that are given us success those are as important as the next thing right and then you know what the next thing is

037uh these are also opportunities look for opportunities to growth uh for growth and and while Dan and I were the lead writers in this endeavor uh we were uh Shameless uh throughout the process to continually go back to various um uh connections within our staff as individuals and groups uh when we were looking at findings here's some data and information can you find a finding from this and so we' look to calibrate uh that and include the voices of our entire Community uh in a way that wasn't burdensome and honorous because the process can become that way uh if you allow it to and and our message to staff uh from the beginning throughout is uh we have a healthy Obsession about continuous Improvement we're doing the work you know within that we're going to

038take a pause this year during this Engagement review to get feedback from folks uh to document to call to come up with our theories of action which is uh what we're able to share with our folks in the middle of February great so feedback um the and one of the things I I want to point out too is is while that that we have these reviews every five years actually that the idea that the Improvement is is continuous we have uh annual check-ins and and ongoing uh connections with our facilitator um actually about our progress and and so that this is kind of I know I I think sha dhy brought it up the Evergreen model so that that we we adapt it as as we go but um in this past review uh the

039we were uh acknowledg for a noteworthy achievement and and a noteworthy achievement is something that they that they identify as an Exemplar for for other districts and specifically the noteworthy achievement I'm I'm going to read it to you is uh Clayton High School sustains a culture where staff and Learners well-being is at the heart of the institution's guiding principles student support such as the wellness center and learning center and administrators personal and professional support of Staff create conditions that benefit student and staff well-being um and and then what they do is they they take this rating and and then that they convert it um to an overall score and our score was 320 and I don't know Jeff can you click on that that score report for me and so it's a little hard to

040see uh but but basically I just wanted to show there that um actually that that it was obviously above 300 and the average score across all schools within cognia uh worldwide is around 253 um and so that that even the regional director of of for cognia in the midwest called me just to to say that uh 320 is is a a score rarely seen actually that that's that we should be particularly proud of of of that score so I mean we we really we really are I mean and it's certainly it certainly takes a village um so despite not despite but also with that uh with that uh score there were a couple areas of improvement that were identified and and and one of those areas of of improvement was to continue to implement collaborative

041strategies with students to enhance student voice and choice in the classroom and that was some work we we had had started to dabble in and and and and in our work with empowered learning but that was really um emphasized and it was it was also you know um you know kind of you know just affirming of of the work that we were already starting and and and where we needed to go which I think that's also particularly timely as we look at our range facilities master plan what one of the things that was mentioned was as we continue to look at all at how we Empower our students how we incorporate voice and choice uh with our students a significant part of that is the programming and the educational opportunities that we provide for kids

042and we need to make sure that our our facilities match the that programming and also like are are in a position to um amplify uh the that student choice and student voice in the opportunities that students have at at Clayton High School and then another area of improvement was to continue to evaluate methods to identify teachers for leadership roles within the institution so in other words promoting uh teacher leadership um teacher leaders like Craig uh actually and and in various areas when when we can within um within the organization whenever we have the opportunity and so that's some work we had started and we've we've continued that work in in in Earnest so that's it so we're happy to take questions yeah thank you so much wow um I'll open it up to the rest

043of the board if anyone has comments or questions first before I go anyone Kim it's okay I don't know I'm not I'm okay I'll go first um I'm probably the worst person to go first because uh I I think it's great that you guys do this but I have to be honest I don't really understand what it is so there's so much educational um and pedagogical um uh jargon are you gonna chime in here with me um Can the question differ sure can so this is a lot of information was good information and congratulations on the on the score it sounds I don't what is the max I don't know is it like 350 or I've uh 321 the scale tops out at 3 can maybe can someone just help us maybe understand how's the

044how this fits into our overall sort of you know whether it's connected to MIP or Assessment program or whatever it is like how does this fit into that entire strategy that we pursue as a school district good yeah I I think that's the coaching question and honestly what what I think is probably the most value for for everybody's understanding um our state accreditation um is is necessary is valuable the the accountability is something that I I want all schools and US too to be able to um to you know to produce um and the depth of impact that's allowed through that process uh is is pretty thin okay it's an accountability measure it's a it's a reporting measure and it's really really important um the depth of reflection that happened among our staff uh through

045the different structures that I showed um the actionable mindset uh that we are interested in continuous Improvement uh is is significant and palpable um I've been able to lead this work since 2014 prior to the last review um the ease of engaging staff this time compared to the last time didn't even compare because of where we are collectively in our mindset about continuous Improvement um and then pre previous to that participating in the previous reviews from that um just as a teacher not as a leader it it honestly looked like some kind of exhibit dog and pony show where you'd have this group in whine and dine and that's exactly what happened um so I I hope I'm giving you a tangable answer and I again I would Circle back and say it's an opportunity

046for all staff to be deeply reflective um and to to actionably focus on Improvement well and and and just a to also emphasize that I I I think like when you look at MP I mean so like was it 60% is is eoc's or or map scores and your attendance is a category and school funding is a category and uh and and like it there's a lot of check boxes and and and and not that those things aren't aren't uh important but like the this this you know process really takes into account the all of the stakeholders gets firsthand uh feedback from all of the stakeholders students parents teachers incorporates classroom observations and and and various Trends and things that are going on with with within the school so it gives you a much more

047holistic picture of I think a school's well-being actually than than say the state accreditation system does so this certainly adds color and a lot of depth to to an important process so the depth and breadth of this process Fosters a culture of self-improvement that staff throughout the day District are embracing now that it's been in place for 100 the last 15 years at least since 2010 since history that you gave okay that's very helpful and continuous Improvement now you're speaking my language so so I guess in the questions that I would have as far as areas of improvement you identified too and I think it's great you shared the I think this is just like I this is like P page 33 of the report maybe it would be helpful if we could see the

048whole report um to like understand and digest kind of all the things that we've heard which sound great um uh and then my only other question is were those were those just the two areas that you wanted to highlight or were there other areas it sounds like there were given the breath of stakeholders that you surveyed and the amount of information that you that you come back in and my guess is those go through the the structures you already have in place in the school and then as you go through these reviews every five years or so do you ever go back is it backward looking so like when you said in 2015 you did you know you looked at formative versus summative assessments and that's when you did grading reforms and Grading for Equity

049do you ever go back then and you know that's part of the see how that stuff is going and if it needs to be adjusted or changed or was that the right decision was that the wrong decision yeah that that's part of the process so so part of the process is that the the the initial part is is kind of reviewing where you where you've come and and since the process is ongoing that's kind of we're always referring back to the the the initial growth areas from the the previous review great so who is g to be uh what bench strength are you creating for a coach suit here to to do this for the next 15 years I guess would be my next question I thought you were talking about left-handed pitch this is

050I think in line with theirs I agree I would love to see the entire oh my gosh okay um I was wondering why you were waving um I agree with what they were saying to be able to have and digest this whole packet would be great you know for a wonderful Saturday night event um could you maybe just to help us understand here like give us an example and then walk us through these steps is that a possibility okay um the steps where we analyze the data findings yes you use their standard survey and then the engagement of learning and the leadership and growth and something of learning okay so let's use a an area of growth that our evaluators suggested to us um so that was touched on in response in the parent surveys

051the student surveys uh and uh the staff surveys right that was also touched on uh in a particular standard of the 30 uh that targeted uh levels of empowered learning student voice and choice that were happening uh that was also touched on within the observational tool called the Elliot right and so from that we had a triangulation that focused on uh this area that we also knew this is something that we need to get better at and we also know that this is something that is an important District goal uh for us uh as well as a building goal for us and so I I hope I hope I'm answering your question directly but that's uh an example that I try to keep brief but kind of shows how that was uh distilled into um

052an area of focus that we need um from multiple data sources yeah yeah okay um I want to say that I'm totally impressed and super excited um that we do this really glad that as a district this is important to us I'm really happy that we pointed out here that we you know the bare minimum is doing what is required MIP Etc but for you to understand that that is such a you know shallow look at what um we could do to improve and knowing that we are so um as a district so focused on Improvement is just it's what makes our district what it is and you know we see with that number that it's happening so um I just want to say I appreciate everything that you did here for this report and

053the fact that we continue to be involved I hope that we you know continue um this effort I think it's magnificent um can you tell me a little bit first of I also want to point out that I really appreciate that you um talked about how programming has to do with our facilities as well I think that's just so great that we're continuing to looking and seeing um as a district and to the public to know that these things like our facilities are so instrumental in making sure that our teachers and our students have the facilities the programming that they need to continue to you know do these amazing things that our students are doing like Nisha pointed out earlier um the only question I have is like a a very tiny one but um

054I didn't know what you meant by digital learning can you explain what that category is what is digital learning uh digital learning is uh using technology okay uh in the learning process that's what I thought so tell me how what does it look about like does it how much time is being spent digitally what is the question there what's the indicators uh I I could pull them up and I will I'll share the Elliot indicators to you and that'll be the best most comprehensive answer okay um but to the extent of access to the technology right is important and I think frequency of use was actually one of the it is one of them it was it was one of them during the class assuming during the during the class observation okay I would love

055to know more this may not be this kind of discussion but it is something that I'm curious about with our district certainly at the high school level um but I know that um I'm ass I'm going to assume that you take all this information and you help you know the not just the high school but you say to yourself oh um let's see how you know doing something different at the middle school will help this thing once they get to the high school right these things that you're indicating and even all the way down to the elementary you know level and I just am curious about digital learning um again this may not be the the convers the the right it's not on the agenda per se but you you mentioned it and so I

056will say that um as we continue to use you know digital everything um and AI ET there's so many technology things we could discuss but um I do want us as a district um to be aware of how much digital learning is happening and whether or not we think that that's a benefit or clearly it's part of our education it's part of our society but I I really want us to think about you know the difference between a a Kinder kindergarten classroom much less a high school classroom in terms of the amount of time they spend in front of a screen versus not and and I'd like to know specifically what you found out around that for our high school students yeah I I made a note of that and I'll tell you one thing

057because I just kind of looked at it as I was looking at different things um but it was curious because on that OT seven categories right uh our the way that our observers rated uh Us in the digital learning category that was the one category we're actually lower National Aver national average great I'm very happy to hear that was one of the well and and and to to your point even on the if I recall correct too like with the the the observation team we we had some we had some robust conversations around it because I I the the indicator uh I think the greater the frequency the higher the score actually the usage which uh as as a as an observational or as an observational group we necessarily agree with that we were using

058the tool but that was probably the most controversial I I think I think indicator in in in the whole uh in in in the whole instrument which I I think is is very good but there there was a level of equating frequency with a positive score and and we didn't necessarily agree with that actually but I'm really glad you said that but but it was our lowest score across the board actually that's right that's that's why we only got [Laughter] 320 yeah and uh you know I I I almost hesitated on the word because it almost sounds Sensational but but that part of it almost felt a little bit Antiquated um and I'm only speaking for myself right now but um maybe not where I feel like in almost every technology conversation uh it feels

059kind of antiquated because what's going to happen the next day right right um right that's we know that's a a worthy challenge for us to continue to try to solve right I think that's it congratulations and thank you for all your hard work um you asked you actually answered the couple of questions that I had so I will also just join and say congratulations this is like clearly a Monumental task that is obviously very worthwhile um so thank you for all the work you put into this and um I the only criticism I have is I wish that I would have been made aware of this sooner like this is really cool and we hadn't heard about it till now um so I I love that we're doing this and again and that we value

060continuous Improvement um and that we've seen um we've gotten such great feedback clearly from our score on it so congratulations I just think great job oh and I did have one question are there any other schools in the region doing this that you know of or is this so what what's in what's interesting was we used to be the we used to have the third longest tenure I think actually in in Missouri and US city and Webster Groves had been doing it I think like four years longer than us actually and then they they stopped around covid I believe or shortly before but uh uh but I'm not there are there are other schools because it's not just public schools there are a fair number of private schools that that uh that do it in

061the area because they they've been part of our cohort uh that then of of of of schools would that we get together they have a conference every year too where we kind of exchange notes and um we were invited to presentes and but it's uh uh there's a whole whole list of schools okay yeah I was just curious um well what I will say is it leans towards private now because of because of in a lot of the a lot of the public schools just focus on uh MP and and whereas the the private schools don't necessarily have a a unified uh like kind of like accreditation slash continuous Improvement like advisory body yeah and I appreciate you actually answering that about the difference with the MIP goals and these goals earlier that was helpful

062I just think um it's you know in any industry right it's great to have an outside entity give a you know 360 look on what what you're doing and get that feedback so I'm really happy that we've invested in this so thank you for all for all your hard work and congrats and just real quick and I would I would like to acknowledge Craig for all the work and his partnership and as as uh we co-chaired this work because uh he's he's an amazing teacher but he's an amazing coach and amazing teacher leader and so it it certainly would not have been possible without his his hard work thank you app that's great thank you and Chris I think Chris had one more thing to say okay I you're wonderful you know I okay um

063I want to say I don't know how this got on the agenda but I just want to sort of echo what you said which is I'm really glad that the board is hearing about this you know been watching the board you know and been on the board for so long and have never heard about this and these are the types of things that I think are really important for us not just as a board but as a community to hear about because the more we understand how um well our schools are doing um and how much work we put into continuing to make sure they're great the better it is for our community as a whole to you know recognize the the not just the work but the importance of you know our district in

064our community Etc yeah so agree thank you both again thanks thanks thank you so much okay we are moving on to 6.2 which is our legislative presentation with Jerry Hawkman and as as Dr P while while Jerry's coming up as Dr Patel said earlier um I just want everyone to understand that um Jerry's a volunteer and we're so lucky to have him volunte ER with us in Clayton um he he not only volunteers to help our legislative advisory committee but Jerry also volunteers to help school districts across the region be more informed and active when it comes to legislation he sends out newsletters to school boards across the region he um participates in monthly Zoom calls about legislation so I just want to thank Jerry for all your volunteer work not just for Clayton but

065for all of the districts around around the area on this very important topic so we appreciate your volunteer time thank you um I'm sitting back there and the first thing that came to mind was is this Heaven no it's Clayton that is High Praise coming from you I mean I mean no um um seriously um hi I'm Jerry hakman class of 1970 um and and um I'm I'm I'm listening and I have yeah and I have you know former colleagues Sons and Daughters who were here tonight I have former students who are here tonight um and I remember North Central evaluations and accreditation processes so it uh it all just kind of comes around and in addition uh side note Pam and Dr Patel and I were in the Family Center this morning and saw

066your granddaughter so it really comes full circle yeah yeah now I'm retired and um after 50 years of public education service um and doing a variety of things um but that's the number one being a grandpa so um so thank you I'll take a few moments tonight to kind of do an overview for you and then I know that uh Leo is going to pick it up from there with some with some discussion um I'd like to do a quick overview kind of put everything in context with what's happening uh with legislation this year uh talk very briefly about the process um and then get into some content specific specifically some major themes of bills that are floating already just two or three and then uh zero in on House Bill 711 which is one

067of several open enrollment bills because I know that's a topic that is uh moving along um so very quickly this year is different than previous years for a variety of reasons one of them is that we have a new governor we have a new lieutenant governor they have a new Administration there are over 60 new legislators um in Jefferson City this year 10 new Senators um and I believe it's like 50 some new representatives of which one of them is one of yours um and so that means it's different um they're still getting to know each other and they're still getting acquainted they're still saying who's going to be following certain things and so they're building a culture of what this new legislature is going to be the Republicans still have a super majority but

068even that feels a bit different um so just kind of keeping that in mind because they want to establish themselves as the new group so already we're hearing they're focusing on some things that haven't been touched on in previous years um to give you some context last year there were 32 bills this is not count budget bills 32 bills passed the entire session that's the lowest I think in like three decades um this year uh when I did this PowerPoint a couple weeks ago there were already 1700 bills filed and they're still going up because the the final de deadline is not there um very quickly the legislative process I mentioned the other day to the committee if you remember Schoolhouse Rock it's still the same thing um but it's important to remember because bills

069start in one house or the other they go to a committee which is very important to watch because that committee chair is the gatekeeper of what gets heard hearing a bill is when it starts to make its movement when a bill goes to a committee and it's heard they will discuss it there are public hearings you can come testify you can send in testimony to both the Senate and to the house um and then they that committee votes and if that committee votes the bill out and I'll make a reference later then it goes to the full house I'll start there then they debate it um and then if they pass it it goes over to the Senate starts back at the committee level it may or may not work its way through to the

070senate floor when both groups have pass the exact same bill same wording then it if they pass it it goes to the governor so it's that same process proc but there's several opportunities for you to have your voice heard uh throughout that process I'll talk more about that um I've mentioned this in some of the Friday phone calls that we've had about building relationships with legislators and as I said you have one of the new ones so I hope he's reaching out to you to say tell me a few things about how things should work and uh and what can you what can I learn from you but staying informed paying attention to what committees you know that you know that some of your legislators are on who's on the education Comm commes uh because

071you just never know when that one comment you make may go somewhere and make a difference um there are several people tracking legislation the school boards Association State School boards Association School administrators Association School business officials Association the m&a and on and on and on they all have platforms they all track legislation I borrow a lot of their stuff U some of those blurbs that you see in some of these updates um but they do track it and they are value able insight into what's moving along and I have conversations with them routinely um as I know Dr Patel tunes into uh many of those uh phone calls uh to to listen to what's going on U the most important aspect of that is getting content and then seeing what is getting traction that's the

072key um some and I I'll get more into that uh and then next slide do I have this J thank you um let's say yeah advocacy so this is a topic that I believe one of the reasons you wanted to talk is what is the school board's role in advocacy that's up to the school board that's up to you um and some usually the way to think about this in one of the meetings with Dr Patel she mentioned well it goes back to our mission and the mission statement and then here you focus on the graduate and what does that mean and that really is the number one guiding principle when trying to have a litmus test for legislation how will it affect our district um but then there are more there's also more specificity

073and some others will you take a stance on issues in a general sense and will you take a stance on a specific piece of legislation and both can be important um as I mentioned there are ways you can deliver your comments officially uh to legislators uh to the Committees when they meet and also through your representatives and your Senator um so what's happening in Jefferson City uh next bill there are some major themes one of them is school choice of which one of those is open enrollment which I will get back to in a moment school choice comes in a variety of ways in across the country and in Missouri charter schools are essentially school choice last year in the open enrollment in one of the bills there was a move to allow charter schools

074in St Louis County that was taken out of the bill along with St Charles so the only expansion this year was in Boon County that's Columbia in that area um surely that will come back around um open enrollment is another means of school choice where a parent could say I would like my child to go from our district to that district and that's what we'll talk about later um one that um was debated heavily last year was Senate Bill 7 727 which was school vouchers which essentially says that a family that qualifies with a certain home uh uh you know what their family income is if it's below a particular level if that family wanted to apply for a voucher which is exactly what it sounds like to apply to go to another school district

075that is participating in the program they could take that they could School District or private school or prio school they could take that and go to a foundation get their name into the hopper and apply to go to that school and possibly be accepted that's a big leap from the others because that's public money go going to private institutions that'll be another conversation perhaps um but so that's one big area there's a lot of movement already on open enrollment another significant area this year which has gotten a bit of attention in previous years excuse me is taxation um this week um the house committee heard very quickly bills on income tax reform changes red reducing income tax earn earning tax opportunity zones personal property taxes tax credits personal property assessments and income tax everyone trying

076to either eliminate one of those or reduce them or phase them down over time every one of those bills affects every public entity in the state it'll it will affect you um so more on that perhaps at another time uh there are some sensitive topics this year that are getting attention it's not the way it was 3 years ago two years ago and even last year uh when you were talking a lot about books and you were talking about uh diversity and what gets taught in the history curriculum etc etc you know those bills and you know those topics they're still there but there are not as many bills they keep them out in front because it gets attention whether any of them actually move remains to be seen but it's not the same Focus

077that's um you know there there are some exceptions um um that that are getting attention already this week and we'll continue to but um it's just not the same as it was on those divisive issues so let's talk about Open Enrollment um open enrollment is a concept where as I said the bottom line is is that a parent family could say I want my child to go to a different District if that District's participating they could apply to go to that district and and possibly get in um there there are two bills in the house already that have been heard in the education committee today they were voted out of the committee and so that means they will now be delivered to the Full House to debate when the Speaker of the House decides to

078put it into a discussion last year it was like a month it was not immediate who knows what'll happen this year so that's already been sent to the house floor for when they're ready to debate it if it makes it through there then it has to go back through the Senate um the Senate tomorrow is holding a committee their education committee is hearing um Senate Bill 70 and 215 which are pretty much the exact same open enrollment bills with the same content that I'm going to talk to you about couldn't have told you that two days ago because they just posted it you have to post within 24 hours and so they wait until like 24 hours and one minute to put it on the website so people can find out that there's a particular

079hearing coming up um so right off the bat there are several open enrollment bills so let me talk about what that means and then allow you to talk about that um the bill State similar to last year that the Department of Education would be required to require every school district in the state to develop a policy about Open Enrollment doesn't mean you're participating but you have to have a policy that says we've discussed it and in that policy you essentially declare if you're going to participate and all of these moments that I'm going to mention have deadlines and they've spread them out this year more than they were last year at some point a district would be given a deadline to say are you participating what does it mean to participate to participate means you

080as a school district are willing to accept students from other school districts and there are procedures as to how that would happen um the and um let me talk about the other direction and then I'll get back to the eligibility and all the difference between that participation does not mean that if you don't participate you don't lose students or potentially lose students because every student in the state is eligible to apply to one of those receiving districts and and there is a cap that they set at 3% so that no school district could lose more than 3% of their previous year's population going to other school districts the Senate version has it at 5% um and I a reminder all the time with legislation in Missouri as we're seeing on some other legislation right now

081if they can get their foot in the door then it's smooth sailing from there because two years later they'll say well let's raise raise the cap let's take the cap off and that's what's happened in several other states and you can you can you can follow that um there is an eligibility as to who can apply and Who Um can be accepted so essentially a school district that's on a receiving end has to take any student that applies and there are very few exceptions one is if they've had a disciplinary offense that falls into that type one um you know category you know board board expulsion hearing or or that whatever that layer is now um oddly there is one that if a child with disabilities applies to go to a district and that District

082does not provide those services that District does not have to take the student that will be contested heavily throughout the process because that that won't fly in St Louis County it really doesn't matter because St Special School District is the overlay so the services are provided or they would have to provide um other than than that um the you know there's you know a few pieces about Athletics uh so that school districts are not recruiting and so um you know how many you know if somebody in high school tries to transfer they have to sit out a year if they apply in seventh grade they don't and so there are some nuances to that um as I said desie would establish the process and different this year is that they would handle all of the

083paperwork if you will the school district doesn't have to accept the applications and go through them at all desie would say okay these are the students that have applied to your school district and um then they figure out on a lottery basis but that's questionable too which ones then would actually come to the superintendent superintendent would go through those and decide is there any reason why we wouldn't take any of these students then there's an appeal process for the parent um but again desie handles all of that paperwork um funding um so funding that is the primary funding question is about the funds that you receive from the state separate that out from funds you receive from the local taxpayers so a sending District would lose that students count in your enrollment count and you

084would lose whatever your state funding is is for your students which I think Leo mentioned is about you're you're held harmless at what $500 512 right John that's not what we that's money we get doll or gain a dollar no you won't gain okay so five 5005 12 was a gross overstatement the 512 is just div like we got a different number our beginning number Dollar okay un a district is so thank you um so exactly what was just stated that the child that goes to another District then the state has to provide funds for that additional student in their Ada and if it's a district that receives 70 80% of their funds from the state that's a significant number in their revenue and so they will receive those funds um the um transportation is

085an issue this year some back and forth on it as it's written now that school districts would have to provide transportation but this year unlike last and I was rereading again today there is a transportation fund and um but the eligibility for that initially is if a child has a disability or if they receive free and reduced lunch and then there was talk last year about if it's a neighboring district and you can get to a bus stop and things like that um so there's different versions on how Transportation would be handled and the funding the goes with that um we're digging into that I need to get more detail for you I don't want to you know misinform you on that but that of course would be a key part to uh to to

086look into one factor to keep in mind also with the overall program on this is that Clayton dollars go to the state of Missouri taxpayers pay into the state of Missouri so if the state of Missouri is providing funds for a program like this that may go up to 40 million or whatever it may cost the state for transportation for other reasons state taxpayers from across the state are funding this program and not getting anything back home for this program so you begin to want to calculate that as well um there are some new sticking points as last year they want Charter the prop U sponsors would like Charters to be able to accept these students um there's a question will this create re segregation and there is definite potential for that to occur um

087and then the recruiting and some of the other things I mentioned um went through that quickly there's a lot of pages in this bill but wanted you to get the main component of it um so that you can begin to have discussions and I will in of course in the updates give you progress reports as to what's happening I know Leo's going to pick it up with some discussion but if I can answer any questions about this or anything else I'd be happy to do so so thank you thank you so much um do we want so Leo you have more to like present to us you mean I'll tell you what's going on with the legislative committee now or in my report later okay and I'm happy to talk about this now um I

088think you know I guess I'd be interested in Dr hawkman's view on whether this is likely to change significantly through the Senate process or whether we're premature in talking about it and I guess I say my view is if it if we're at all premature I would confine myself to commenting on some particular aspects of this bill and try and avoid a broad philosophical discussion of open enrollment which is more difficult but just commenting I'd be happy to point out some things I saw in this bill in addition yeah go ahead um I noticed that the policy which we have to pass regardless has some language in here that um just sounded like a lot of fun to deliberate at the board table insufficient classroom space we have to Define insufficient classroom space um and

089I I I guess I had a strong reaction to that a little bit and that would it would be a challenging conversation to have for our district but either of the Dr Dr Patel Dr Hawkman I mean when you're making decisions about putting kids in classrooms is it is it really about the space in the room or is it about educational arrangements with the right number of kids in front of teachers it's not about space in the room usually is it and it also you're correct it's about the number the the needs also of the students that we're placing in the classroom we're not looking at fire codes we're not looking at we're not looking at physical space we're looking at I mean I understand we we comply with fire correct that's not what's driving

090I was like we do look at that but yes that's not what's driving that and I guess I would just say I don't particularly it doesn't Delight me for the state to be asking us to Define that category in a piece of legislation that we opt out of potentially I don't know why the state is requiring every District to Define that amount um if it's going to remain an opt out program I I just don't I just don't trust the state on that there's a bit of history there um because it's a desegregation program um that some of you may remember as having been students at the time um was an open enrollment program yeah pretty much the exact same except the funding that went to the district and to back to the city was

091significantly higher um but it was the same thing you could not not accept students and say well we don't have enough space now it wasn't defined there was no square footage piece but there were some districts that would try that and they would would be contested and they would say you have space you can fit kids in your classroom you can't tell us to 10 kids in a class so it's not necessarily a formula um but um and so it's there's some other history in some of this language it's a very least a very challenging thing for a district to Define and I think it would be a challenging thing for this District to Define given you know the value we place on um stent teacher ratio and some of these things um and you

092know and then you you get to the second question of Defending it and somebody else comes in who says I don't have the same standard for a classroom space that you do anyway um I that was the other piece of it that uh that jumped out at me that and the funding piece um and then one other thing I guess I would like um to just talk about what declin enrollment looks like for districts that go through that and what effect that has I mean the bottom line with that as I understand it is that enrollment declines but you can't decrease your costs proportionately right at least not quickly your Capital costs tend to be fixed and your personnel costs can be reduced but that can be sticky and slow um and so it's a

093very difficult situation put a district in when you put them in a dis in the position of 3% declining enrollment year over-year or if it's more it's more and um I those are my thoughts on this Bill thank you I'm I'm thinking about how you mentioned you know getting their foot in the door you said right and then things grow like like the percentage Max that can leave and I'm thinking too about that as it's written right now it's an opt-in program but how long till they're thinking it's going to be a man you know mandated like you have to participate program so I think it's all those are all things to consider as we pay attention to this and keep in the back of our heads where some of these are probably headed in

094in the future too if I could you made me think of one thing I should have mentioned in the context of this is that um rural Missouri has a very different view of this than some of their own legislators do uh the small school districts and we are a state that has over 550 school districts I mean just kind of stop and think about that yeah um that's a lot of school districts of 300 kids 400 not schools school districts of 300 kids 400 kids and they see this also as a foot in the door as lever to get School District to consolidate which is definitely an agenda of of of many of the legislators and it has been um and they're looking at it as efficiency and I I I won't go into that

095because there are other models but outstate folks are worried about that because if you're a school of 300 kids and you talk about capacity and you have you know very quickly a first grade that's got 14 kids in it and a second grade that's got nine kids in it and then you lose kids um how low do you go before you say okay we have to combine and that means we're going to lose a teacher because we don't have the revenue to pay that teacher so that's what they are desperately worried about in the small districts and also they are very worried about recruiting from the moderate sized districts that surround them um so it's not a slam dunk as they found out last year uh this bill made it through the house very quickly

096it sat in the senate for months and then because they focus so much at the very very end on the school vouchers it just went away um so we'll see what happens this year but when you mentioned um the transportation the district would have to pay for the transportation which district the sending or the receiving no the receiving district has to pay and again I want to I heard two different things this week from two reliable sources in the language in the bill is of course not clear for somebody like me um but uh um don't Bank on anything no pun intended and I will get details on you on that for you okay thanks any other general questions or comments what is the bill number the house bill number oh it's not seven uh

097this one is 711 um same sponsor as last year this sponsor has brought it forward this is his fifth year in a row and um I I I have to share this I know you have a lot on your agenda um every person that spoke against this bill in the hearing I'm talking about the legislators who were speaking against it the few Democrats in the room every one of them the first thing they did was compliment the sponsor because he has heard he's brought this forward and he's just as diplomatic as could be he's not fiery he's not trying to change the politics in Missouri for him it's I just don't understand why a child can't go to the neighboring District if their parents want to send them there and as polite as can be

098about it and um and that's his explanation he has no other agenda and that's kind of nice too very sincere um so he's add it again then you said there's a similar Senate Bill 70 and 215 uh yes 70 and 2:15 hearing at 8:30 tomorrow morning if you'd like to listen to it great um so there's two very similar Bills going through House and Senate one has passed and it's going right how do they reconcile the language um well first within either house uh because they will like there may be four bills in the house on the exact same language on the topic and eventually they have to decide which one will carry the ball and it's going to be this sponsor this bill so they have to negotiate that internally and see what happens

099um then if it goes to the other house it's it's a negotiation um sometimes it just goes through the committee or they're looking at their own bills in the Senate their language is moving forward they may pass it and then it will turn into hjr you know house joint resolution or and so they will form a separate Committee of both representatives to negotiate the language that they could possibly both live with um it's just a back and forth process until they land on something that they think will fly um and what was spoken in the what what came up often in the hearing earlier this week about the house bill was the Senate version when they know when they get when the Senate gets it that there will be much more discussion about Charter Schools

100than there is in the house it's not in the language right now but they know that will be something that they will try to push through with their version so so there are people that read the tea leaves on that and we'll see what happens um uh you had mentioned that um there is open enrollment in some other states yes have we has there been like enough time with that in place to kind of understand some of the the impacts of that of that yes okay anything you might want to share um I'll I'll broad um answer um I want to say there's over 40 states that have some version of school choice and Missouri is on that list because of the voucher program that uh empowerment scholarship program that was started two years ago

101uh I think Minnesota was the first state that did this over 20 years ago and there it's just kind of like the way we do things here um and the example I gave the other day is Clayton has always known what percent percent of students who live in Clayton will not attend Clayton schools what percentage approximately will go to private and parochial schools and there's usually a pattern and you can track that and see and so this is sort of the same thing that at some point you know the pendulum will swing and then every District who's participating that number will land and then what the flow is Will land and the procedures um I was a superintendent of three school districts in Massachusetts at the same time because they have Regional districts and collaborative

102districts and so with that there was also open enrollment and um so it's been in place there I believe since like 2003 or four and I went back and looked at all the studies that they did before they started studies that they've done since then the patterns of the funding and all of that and so um the pendulums kind of landed there as to what districts can expect I don't know if any districts folded as a result of it uh but that would have happened um so there has been a lot of there has been research on it um and the achievement question you'll find 10 different answers to whether or not this has an effect on student achievement or not U but I will say that the experience I had was um one that

103many districts County school districts we'll face which is this district is um more affluent than others let's just say this District here the question is do we want to accept students from other districts and I the the school committee where I was had that dilemma because the neighboring Town had 100 kids in that school and if they lost six kids they'd have to lose a teacher because that's that's how much the teacher made was the amount of money that they they were going to lose from state aid on that so there's this relationship piece between neighboring districts and how do you play that out um and so I was actually looking at those districts and and see and again the pattern eventually ironed itself out but yes there there is research and I can dig

104some up for you and provide that to Dr Patel if you like and what I'd like to add to that is that there's a there's less experience in states with education funding models the same as ours right that I mean it is important to understand that Missouri's education funding model is not the same that they have in the west count most in the mountain states um and there's a reason that this is the second year running that this bill has come up with financial Provisions that don't make any sense it's because it's hard to design it with financial Provisions that make sense Missouri system yeah yeah noticed today that I was looking through some charts that where Missouri ranks in terms of State funding for schools and it's 50 yeah we're dead it's 50th because

105of exactly what you just said they other states fund it completely differently can I jump in okay so first of all I do want to say I mean you said at the beginning but I mean Dr hawman I mean thank you for all this effort I mean you know you are truly a public servant uh in all that you do so I I'll just really quickly I I'm you know just to say on the record I'm in the same place I was last year you know I am open to open enrollment in certain situations and Dr hopkins's right when you say open enrollment it's not a proper noun it's you know because there's not one system right open enrollment means different things depending on how it's constructed but to me in a at a sort

106of a in the generic level if we have the opportunity and there's you know what that how we Define that would be an ongoing conversation I think Leo's right but if we you know if you if we as a community have the opportunity to um change the dynamic of where a kid what ZIP code a kid is Born Into determines his or her or their outcome educational outcome if we if we have the opportunity to provide a different pathway for that child then I'm open to the discussion you know and really what's coming down I don't know Leo maybe you're going to bring up during communication or whatever but you know there's this are we going to vote on this resolution or not right and the resolution just says that we're uh not you know

107you oppose open enrollment in all forms right and that's where you know I have a problem voting for that you know I'm open to open enrollment in certain situations um uh the 3% cap I understand the long-term I'm concerned but the 3% cap which is the cap that's in front of us tonight uh doesn't strike me as destructive to a school district when Wade when the counterweight is can you change a child's life or a small handful of children's lives right with a different educational outcome um I will say that if we are going to bring this the resolution up we should invite representative Mackey to come and address the board because he covers he represents most of the school district and he voted for it in the house committee today right and so we

108should allow him to explain why he supports it uh open enrollment is something that you know has both urban and rural support and urban and rural opposition and the same thing with you know in a bipartisan support and opposition um and the last thing I'll just sort of say on this is that the his the at least the recent history of this school board has been to not wade into political issues unless it is so black and white that you get unanimous agreement very quickly and it's really just you know we faced it with gun violence examples of racism and other forms of discrimination open enrollment doesn't strike me as getting to that level so you know I I just sort of put that out there to consider here in terms of how we think

109about this as a group and as a team that's my soapbox and open enrollment for now I want to ask about the taxation bills so last year there was a concern about um eliminating the property tax which I know is sort of a more of a political you know the guy was running for governor and it is what it is right but is there anything that that threatens the the property tax as as a taxation instrument moving through the legislature or anything that could be approaching that that we should be aware of because that's what I'm more concerned about tonight um there is one proposal to phase out property taxes as a source of funding Al together anyone wants to put a resolution slow slow slow pass right right right um yes yeah yeah there's

110U doing away with property tax the you know uh shifting some of that burden to sales tax I was reading today which is odd in The Proposal because there's also a proposal to reduce sales tax on certain Goods um you know vehicle you know and how vehicles are uh assessed and and resale of vehicles and when they can cap how much you can tax that and I I mean it gets very complicated of course so um they're going to go at it every which way and it's back to the question of which language okay which one has the best chance of passing and which one will stick yeah um so it it really it's it kicked off already this week with one hearing um and tomorrow um there are several in one committee thanks for

111that I so just I mean to put up on this in my mind the property tax question actually threatens how this district is funded right and so and in previous conversations in in past boards right and Boards change every year but in past boards the question has been you know we would wait into a political issue when we think that we cannot execute on getting our kids to reach the profile of a graduate threatening our funding is a much bigger issue to me than open enrollment which by the way we may get a program in front of us I might be against participating in that right but I'm just talking about this as a sort of generic question right so if we're going to prioritize things just from one per one of Seven's perspective the

112property tax issue is a much bigger threat to us than open enrollment I agree with you I mean's there there's no question that that is a much more concrete threat I I guess to Clayton I guess yes there's a question which is more likely to proceed um but there there's no question that when you look at our district what has a concrete effect on our district that's uh a a yeah much more direct issue I I just want to say about open and I mean I took a position on this during the campaign I don't have a categorical objection to open enrollment as Dr Hackman said the Vic program could be characterized as open enrollment if you look at it in squint um there's a set of criteria that I have in my mind about

113uh reliable funding that makes sense about um maintaining a degree of local control and thinking about the impact and controlling the impact on sending districts that's my criteria that I have in my mind one of seven and um so whe we'll talk a little more about the legislative committee I guess maybe we'll talk about it now I Envision something coming up in front of the board whether it's a partic that particular resolution I don't know yet I do Envision something coming out of that committee to the board asking us to um you know take a position as a board on some legislative matters so what do you mean that to the board like to all boards to this board that we would vote yes or no on a document stating a position on either a

114particular piece of legislation or a set of principles and both of those were discussed uh in our meeting um so I'll say to what Jason said um you know thinking about the direct threats to our district is obviously you know top priority but I want to say um you know I think for me having this committee that we've started which is so important isn't just about our district it's about us understanding how do we can support uh all all districts in in general like I said maybe two years ago now how we support public education in general so as I said then I think this a lot of open enrollment bills are kind of the antithesis to what public education should be however there are exceptions to that obviously and who knows you know what

115what will come about but um I am one you know and I I won't be on this board forever but I am one that wants us as a board to discuss these issues um not just in a bubble of our district but to look at them as a not just a Statewide even but as a a crisis of America at this point and I think maybe that's why Dr hop decides to do what he does because you know you've been a lifelong educator and you realize that um you know a as a country we have to make a decision about how how important education is to us and how we continue to fund it and how we continue to um you know help our citizens be the best citizens they can be I mean this

116is a very broad thing as well as a specific thing like you're saying so um I would be one to say that if we're going to have have a committee like this that um you know are we willing to talk about the stuff that's not the black and white big stuff or are we not and if we are willing to you know what's our what's going to be our role and our what's our purpose for doing that Etc you know here we are saying this may this bill may or may not come up but and we kind of you know we've kind of given some I don't know if we like it sort of thing but again we have to decide as a board how much we're going to go forward in terms of you

117know testifying or you know obviously we're there's going to be resolutions so we'll have a St say there but we could certainly have a say along the way on whatever bills we want to or not want to so again um let's just think about that overall um as a board and and kind of decide although boards change every year so that's rough you know in terms of but I just want us to um recognize the value of our district and our board coming to the table and saying this is what we think and historically we haven't really done that and I would be one to say that there's um you know as things continue to progress there may be uh ethical even moral reasons for us to do that if we are True Believers in

118public education I'll you know maybe playing into type here I'll give a pragmatic reason to do the same thing awesome which is I love it it doesn't work it doesn't work to only show up on these things when it's affecting your bottom line in my opinion I think Clayton is very distinctive in it's in what affects it we're really it's really narrow compared to a lot of districts and we're going to be separated from everyone else a lot if we limit ourselves we're going to be the only ones chiming in on a particular thing and then everyone's else is going to be talking and we're going to be silent and it's not an effective way to engage with that process in my opinion and there's experience with this not in the recent past but a

119little further back where we had an issue that was very important to us and we were the only ones raising it and it didn't work and so I think it's important for us to get engaged in this process in a way that that fits into a larger um framew work because um when you've got their back maybe they'll have yours that's that's it and uh and I think that's that that that would be the pragmatic reason to weigh in on things that aren't necessarily going to have a dramatic impact on us well look I don't mind the political discussion I'm not against I you know I'm appreciate this is on the agenda tonight I it sounds like it may be on the agenda in a couple meetings and you know I certainly don't mind I

120don't mind that discussion I I'm also not going to worry about it one bit if this vote if we take up a resolution and vote 61 you know we're fine you know I'm not worried about that I suspect that the majority of Jefferson C doesn't really care what the school district of Clayton has to say On Any Given issue but you know we can talk about that another time my only my only point to bring that up is that you know there there has been a trend or the the the the the recent history on this has been that we have not engaged when it's not clearcut and it's not unanimous right and if we're going to change that as a board let's just be honest that we're going to start to wait into political

121issues here you know that's where that's where this board is going to go I'm a little uncomfortable with that I don't know how I feel about that you know and I think we should talk about that in terms of what that means for the board moving forward and Board elections moving forward and what are going to be issues in Board elections moving forward if we're going to start to pick this stuff up okay so good point you know that is something we need to think about the last thing I'll I'll say is um Chris I agree with you that you know part of this is thinking about our role in terms of a community you know whether that's St Louis County Missouri whatever it is I agree with that and that's actually where I come

122from ton is thinking about the broader Community not necessarily how I would view myself as a board member voting on do I participate in this program whatever it is we don't know you know this thing is you know there's been open enrollment and efforts of various kinds going back 15 20 years plus ever since Matt blunt was elected governor I mean that's kind of the history here in the state in fact the current mayor of St Louis proposed a unified school district when she was a state representative you know so like that's how long this goes back but I would just sort of say this board has also said um we should do we need to remain focused on what's best for kids and so if we're going to be focused on what's best for

123the community it should be what's what's best for the kids of those communities and their educational path right which is more than you know more than I'm in underperforming or under served school district and I want to try to get into Clayton it's the kid who's getting bullied because he she or they is being beaten up for being trans you know what I mean I'm you know you could pick that it's the kid who can't get into the college he or she wants to go to because the AP courses aren't available due to class size you know there's a lot of things that go into this and so you know it's not a clear-cut thing to me um and so you know if you guys want to vote for it at the end of the

124day that's fine it's GNA be a 61 vote you know and so and I'll say the same thing at a couple meetings when this comes up it might not be one it'll be at least 61 you know and so um if we want to go down that path I think we need to think through we need to at least be honest with ourselves about it and no more telling people we don't that's political we don't get involved in that yeah well I think uh I think you're suggestion earlier about bringing e in here is really important I think we need to hear from yeah and I just want to kind of piggyback at what Jason said I think there's a difference between being informed of what's in the legislature and coming down the pipe that

125could affect the school district and then reacting to the legislature as it comes in as we're required to do and it becomes law and getting involved in taking one side of the other particularly when you start waiting into issues that may be partisan if a school SCH board elected officials we are supposed to be nonpartisan and representing kids from all walks of lives so that's I think you know there is a so there's a little bit of an ethical dilemma there for me in terms of how far you want to get the desire for us to be involved in issues that don't directly affect our school community so what portion of the school boards of the state do you think are taking a position on this it's most of them right 35% is it 35%

126that's the number of districts that sign that thing divided by the number of districts so is that are they are they all involved in quasi unethical conduct I mean it doesn't no they're not on ethical no I'm not I'm not I don't think I'm insinuating that anybody is involved in unethical conduct an ethical dilemma does not mean that in I mean I I think that's a bridge too far for you to say that I'm accusing other state school boards of being involved in unethical conduct I think there are um interests of educational institutions and uh interests of children that can be spoken to by this board um that have remote impacts on us that may not impact us next year but impact the state educational environment um and we see as potentially having an impact

127on us and I certainly think that a proposal like this potentially has a long-term impact on this District I think it is uh not going to impact us next year certainly not as written but um I don't think that the overall rearrangement of our educational system that is contemplated if this proceeds um I don't think we can predict where that goes but um I think we should be thoughtful as a district about whether it's a rearrangement that benefits children and families that we represent I don't think there's any disagreement I take no issue with what you said yeah well okay but what I just said is if this bill presents the first step towards a rearrangement of our educational system Statewide that's going to affect our families we should take a position on it well

128I mean we go on I mean going back to the actual issue I don't view that I don't view this necessarily as a as as as Draconian is what you laid out I mean I understand that's your perspective but like I just I just don't you know I mean you know and so and so that's sort of you know that's my P that's just my perspective on on that particular thing you know that's all you just don't view it as as first step that's yeah and I look we don't need we're not deciding anything tonight we're just like getting information from Dr Hawkman and from Leo about just inform us what's going on right so this I'm sure will be continual discussion on however we want to you know move forward so um any other

129questions for Dr hawman yeah I'm G to take us way over here um so it seems like many of us or all of us agree that the any sort of Bill to remove or minimize property tax personal property tax directly impacts our community at the very beginning of this and what you have said in the legislative advisor committee is encouraging school board members to get involved and to be aware so would you recommend that this is something that we should specifically follow and consider taking action long before it goes higher further um the taxation issues yes um I would say it's definitely time to start doing homework on what's Happening and um getting some expertise experts to explain to you what the impact of each of these could be um whether it's the fiscal note

130that goes through that the the state actually figures out what the effects are in various districts um but um it's inevitable that there are going to be tax bills that will get a lot of traction which ones surface to the top remains to be seen last year there was really just one possibly um they're flooded with bills now so I would suggest I can definitely I'm also looking for contacts uh you know Scott Kimbell who does the phone calls for the superintendent mon on Mondays uh he and and that Association have experts on this and um but I would begin doing the research on what each of these bills truly means for for you not my 10,000 F foot level and then just play out scenarios and you you you'll decide where to go from

131there Ian will have some insights for you um your Senator will have some insights for you Mr hails um is just getting his feet wet and I'm was going to mention this in board communication later but it seems appropriate to mention now on March 11th is the msba Missouri school boards Association um annual advocacy day Chris and I went last year um it was great actually we we had um hia had set up appointments with us to meet with all of our legislators and we asked Ian about Open Enrollment we we met with all of them and asked different questions and what were their positions on them and it was a great opportunity to tell them how Clayton felt about certain issues so um I haven't seen but maybe I've missed it that msba has

132sent us like registration for that day yet but we can keep an eye out for it it's a Tuesday and you go most of the day um and Felicia could register us but just keep that in the back of your heads too if that's something that we want to participate in or any one of us that's available it's a great a day that's just for Schoolboard members to Advocate on different issues so I'm going to add to that and say that one of the things that we've talked about at this table and then I know Stacy and I after we left that um that day day of advocacy talked a lot about is you're right getting um involved in a political discussion like this as a board it is it is really tricky again we're

133we're voted official you know it's but what we've talked about in the past and all remind us is that we could I don't mean to say just but what we could do this with this is to help a group of parents or concerned uh you know citizens to be the ones that actually have the ability and are supported by the board in a way that's neutral you know I'm not this is all coming off I don't remember our conversations exactly but you know it it doesn't have to be us but we could still support it um and I would I would say that that's something the advisory committee could really just start to look at because that's kind of where the advisory exactly that's how it came to be that community members could as a

134Grassroots effort or an organized effort so instead of it being the actual board on all of these issues it would be uh the board supporting the community being very you know knowledgeable and having the information they need to do the efforts that they want to do you know for our district if what however they feel about that or as the bigger you know picture of Education um Etc so and I would say that I would really like our committee and our board to encourage that because you know our profile of a graduate um we want our kids to go out and be really great citizens right and and that includes you know being well informed but it also includes allowing you know them to know how to advocate for you know whatever it is I

135just think we need to be the role models that say Hey this is something that is important to our community it's important to us that as students we want you to be able to go you know do is speak up and and know how to you know advocate for yourselves on state level whatever it is not just in the classroom right so again I just want us to continue to be involved I understand that it's a sticky situation um but involvement is is what we can exemplify as Role Models um in any way that you know makes sense for us well thank you Dr Hackman thank you for we appreciate your time tonight and your time otherwise helping us through this educating us all thanks so much okay we will move on to 7.1 which

136is a second reading of policy BDC the closed meetings records and votes so Chris if you would read that motion please I move that we approve the policy BDC second any questions or comments okay all those in favor I any opposed okay motion passes and moving on to eight the consent agenda read that motion please I move that we approve consent agenda items 8.1 through 8.3 second okay all those in favor I any opposed okay consent agenda agenda passes um okay board Communications um I know Le you have something to report out from the legislative committee so the legislative committee met we talked about many of the same things that Dr Hawkman raised here we talked about um generating a uh a set of legislative principles similar to the ones that many institutions have could

137be adopted as a basis for involvement in these issues um and we talked about uh you know the process of assembling a uh email list to get information out uh regarding um some of these topics and then uh I have also been going to a couple pto's and getting word out about that same email list that's great thank you and I would say the last few years we've you know heard randomly from parents like coming to us for information on legislation and what's going on so that so I'm appreciate that that's in the works that you're not only talking ptos but talking about an email blast with information I think that's great um any other committee meetings Pam oh Equity you had today R we had an equity committee meeting today um talked about two

138main topics one was just reviewing the walkthroughs that have happened so far at Captain and the high school um just shared a lot of the highlights that people saw for time I'm going to just leave that as that but a lot of positivity um and then the uh second part was reviewing the legislative issues that are ahead of us now um part of the I'm going to leave it at that as well okay good any other communication to ch um Pam and Dr Patel and I did a walk through at the family center this morning which I mentioned earlier it was Pam's first time I didn't know if there's anything you wanted to share but it's always um it is no offense to our other schools it is a really joyful place to be and

139it was a great place to go in the morning it's a great way to start your day really anyway they're doing some great stuff there yeah I yes it was a great way to start my day anyway okay we can motion to adjourn I move that the Board of Education adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.