001so let me know when we're good Scott we are good all right perfect i' like to call this meeting in a session with the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge alleg to the United United States of America stand one na IND with Li and jcece for all all right we're like a motion to approve the agenda for January 2nd 2025 as presented so moved second it's first by Mark second by Ron all those in favor say I I all suppos say no eyes have it board up next we have discussion um an overview from Dr Kevin Oma from school exective connect to discuss our Board of Education um district superintendent search so I will turn over to Kevin thank you for joining us Kevin thank you all and and happy New Year and Diane Robertson my
002partner and I are both thrilled to be here this evening and also be part of this important process that is going to take us uh through the early part of spring and um I have sent over to you Adam some copies of some documents that hopefully you've shared with your colleague um I also hopefully as I reminded uh that people have brought their count because we're going to make some date decisions tonight um hopefully um so what I'd like to do is share my screen kind of for your stakeholders especially and your public run through very quickly our process uh that makes us um a good firm for you to partner with so we're very appreciative of that without objection um I'd like to share my screen I hope this is right you should be
003able to share it from your and I click and it's it's I'm getting uh like um I'm not get I'm not able to share my my screen there so um oh okay so you co-hosted me so hold on a second give me just a moment I I apologize um I might be able to do it now we see it are we in business we're good yep I I am not Mr technology that you you'll be able to figure that out very very quickly so again um my name is Kevin Oma my partner on the search is Miss Diane Robertson she's a partner in the firm and has done many many searches as have I um our search plan is really a four-phase process where we open the search by making some decisions on the process
004and timeline that we will get to uh it's uh sooner rather than later in tonight's meeting um creating the candidate profile for the person that is a best fit for the Francis High School District uh developed the candidate pool through our own Recruitment and through our own uh networking and some advertising options that we'll discuss with the board later this evening and then get getting through our several stage um selection of candidates that again we'll we'll share some more details about that process when we get to it during the planning period of tonight um our process is oneof a kind we advertise locally and nationally we fully engage all your stakeholders we really aggressively recruit and attract people from across the country we have 67 Consultants that work for school exec connect across the United
005States uh we will screen and conduct interviews with with uh candidates so that we bring the best fit forward for the board to consider and that slate under number five will typically be a slate of five to seven candidates uh that we will present to the board and Inter and let you go through a workshop of interview training we will be there when you do your uh staff training and interviews and again whether you have staff participate uh in the training and the interview process we'll talk about that some more this evening we will thoroughly screen and vet your candidates and support your hire throughout this process and then we'll provide guarantees of the surge process and our our three guarantees I I know you talked about this during your Matrix discussion um if you
006do not if we do not present the candidate you wish to hire we'll continue to keep this open and vet candidates and recruit candidates until you're happy with someone that you want to to bring forward and and partner with um if the superintendent leaves or is dismissed for any reason within 24 months of the start date we'll conduct a new search for no additional fee the the board will only be um culpable for the expenses associated with that effort and we will not recruit your candidate for the first two uh contracts that the the candidate has um Diane anything there that you'd like to uh emphasize that I missed no I think you covered it excuse me um we were asked to just give a a brief overview of our search process uh for the
007public just to introduce kind of what we're going to be going through and then as we go through the actual planning document and and with your input board uh we will determine exactly how we're going to go through these different stages of the process so that it's a search that you are uh feeling comfortable with and uh we will make recommendations we've made recommendations all the way through the planning document but if you um don't agree with something that that we've got in there or you want to tweak something we can absolutely do that uh what we what I will walk through here in just a a little bit is um the process that we typically use that we think works well that we've been successful with and so we will use it as a
008guide to go deeper into each of those four stages that uh Kevin just reviewed briefly does anyone have any questions before I turn it over to Diane to talk about the the the details surrounding our process and timeline recommendations okay I'm going to do you want me to share the screen Diana or would you prefer to do that uh I can share the screen okay that's okay let me let me try it just to make sure are you all able to see okay we can see awesome so I'm the more Tech literate person of the the group that we've got here as you can see I will uh always take credit for things that I think that I can do well and kind of throw Kevin under the bus a little bit on in a
009while you'll you'll find that as we um go forward so that's a reciprocal agreement by the way yeah it works both ways um so a couple of uh things that we we need to know from you guys and if you would give me just a second to move some of your faces over a little bit that would be helpful for me okay so uh a couple of General decisions that we need to know and have you make um just this this is like cons ensus building uh or consensus decisions today we're not taking votes on things we just have to have some guidance on U where we're going to go and then at the end of this public session that we're having we would like to have a uh a short brief close session to
010further discuss some some specific candidates and some specific um Personnel issues surrounding the search that we really need to have in close session so if we could start off with some of these General sessions uh decisions we need to find out from you whether or not you would like for us to conduct a confidential search or an open search the difference between the two is in a confidential search we would not disclose any candidates name until the board has decided on their chosen candidate their top pick the open search would be where um we would disclose candidates names of the top three the top finalists that you have decided that you would like to um take a second look at as we get to the end of the process the pros and cons of each
011a confidential search will Garner you more candidates because candidates typically don't want their name out there uh letting people know that they're looking it it does destroy a relationship in a current District if they happen to be a sitting superintendent and so you will will find uh less people wanting to have put their name out in in advance of them you know getting a superintendency the open search is more transparent at the end you've got three finalists and people will be able to weigh in then on who those three finalists are in an open search typically there would be like maybe an open Forum where all three candidates would be introduced possibly uh people could ask ask questions about them or they could give statements um kind of like when you're running for school board
012and you have a candidate Forum um that kind of gives more public input however it kind of uh sometimes can pit the public against the board because the board's going to have more intimate um conversations in the interview process with the candidates so uh our preference or a recommendation to you would be to do a confidential search um but it is totally up to the board which way you want to go so we need some guidance which way do you want to go on this discussion board I'm happy to go with confidential agreed I'm good with that yeah just Personnel yeah okay all right sounds like sounds like consensus okay great um the level of stakeholder participation you will find in our planning document that we sometimes will recommend that you engage stakeholders um and
013their levels of participation we definitely recommend that we engage uh stakeholders in focus groups in forums to try to build this candidate profile to hear comments and opinions from the public from uh your District staff members uh from your administrators from your parents and some community members supporters of the District detractors of the district um and use all of that information to build the profile of who we think could be a good fit for your District that's all about um that's what we're all about is finding a good fit so that we can have a lengthy term um for the superintendent to be in your District that 97% success rate that we talk about is about a superintendent getting a second contract with a board after we place them so they they they are a
014good fit and they um have a second contract so there's some tenure there I know you guys have talked about the the average length of a superintendent uh it's less than three years usually and that's not what we're trying to find we're trying to find somebody for you long term so uh we would like to engage your some of your stakeholders in uh some focus groups to help build that profile we would like to do online survey to gather data from people in your District who are not able to make an open form or invited to a focus group and um there's a sec a third option that we can engage uh community and that would be at the final interview stage when you get to your three finalists we can also engage some of
015the people who have participated in focus groups to also participate in in doing um interviews of those final three candidates simply to give the board uh feedback in the in the form of strengths and challenges or weaknesses of each of the candidates just for the board to have some more views on the three candidates boards sometimes will decide not to do that stakeholder interview process and they will take that that um job on themselves with the board members so uh the three levels of participation one would be let's say the online survey would you guys all agree to allow us to do an online survey together yes sure okay I'm if I don't hear a no right away I'm gonna assume um consensus uh how about the focus groups and the open forums we would
016have a several focus groups probably over the course of a day or two we would Kevin and I would come into the district and meet with people we have a process for deciding who those people would be and then we would hold an open form for anyone from the public to come in an evening and anyone from the staff to come uh probably after school one day so would that be is that of interest to the board yes yes I think so as long as it sounds like we can make it in the time frame so yeah we've we've got it built into our calendar so we'll we'll talk about that okay um and then also uh how do you feel now this might be not all yeses this could be some NOS would the
017board like to do all of the interviewing themselves or would they like to engage some stakeholder participation at the finalist interview like the final three B I would like I'm fine with opening it up yeah I'd like to keep it to the board can you better U explain what each of those scenarios looks like what does it look like with just the board interviewing the final three and how many stakeholders what's the other picture look like okay so if the um if it's just the board well first of all let me back up a minute we will have a first round of interviews with the board that is just with the board and that's the five to seven candidates that we would recommend to you to look at once you interview those five to seven
018candidates you would narrow down the top three that you would like to talk to time before you narrow down to your one so it's that that stage of the process where you've identified three that you would like to talk to a second time and typically we would have an administrator committee with central office administrators maybe some building principles who would interview those three candidates and then possibly a staff uh made up of some teachers some support staff and um some community members that would also interview those people in a confidential process we would would have them sign agreements of confidentiality that they would stay confidential with those three candidates um as they are interviewing them we would train them on interviewing protocol we would remind them that they are not picking the candidate that they
019are simply giving feedback to the board versus Board just does all of the interview both the five to seven initial and the three at the End by themselves how would those be those people be selected um in any of those categories whether it be admin or teachers or general public at at the at the interview stage yes question okay typically Kevin and I kind of Select those based off of our interaction with those people in the focus groups the people who seem to be most engaged in the process um most you know willing to give opinions to us and things like that is usually how we determine those we can also do a random selection of the people who have participated in focus groups and just randomly select people and would those interviews be with
020in conjunction with the board or separate separate with so admin only no board members correct correct so you know we've got a a feedback sheet that we'll share with you tonight that would allow if you choose to go down this Road allow the committee members to give feedback to the Board of Education before they talk about any candidate with with their colleagues so the board would get the feedback what weight you give that feedback is entirely up to the board and as Diane mentioned we make it very clear if you do go the committee route that the committee members know it's the board's decision to make and what is what's typical I mean is it 5050 7030 the of any of the other that you have helped I I would say it's probably 6040 six
021of the searches I've done 60% do it 40% don't do it 40% uh just have board interviews Kevin what's your experience I think that's accurate and especially uh for a spring search like we're doing with this District because the time frame is a little tighter uh it's it's more likely 50% level that boards do those final interviews all by themselves that that's that was going to be my question is what's the how does that affect the time frame if we extend this out to admin Etc it doesn't affect the time frame it might affect the number of people who have the Ava availability because of the the scrunch time that we've got you give strict timelines and then say here's the time we have if you can join that please come correct you have move
022right yeah I'll just say I'm not in favor of that I think it kind of discourages internal candidates when they know that some of their own colleagues will be interviewing them and if that doesn't work out then there's a it's always right do you do you find that's kind of almost like a hybrid of confidentiality like you sign a agreement or a non-disclosure but do you find less candidates applying when they know like there's a certain level of like that's that's another a little bit of additional risk than just like purely confidential with the board do you find less candidates applying then in general we typically don't think it affects candidacy but there is you are correct there is always that risk that someone won't maintain that confidentiality and at that point then yes a
023candidate would have to determine whether or not they want to go through the process or not so it is definitely a risk I don't know that I don't know of candidates who have just totally backed out and said I'm not going to do this I would be in favor of having um a few stakeholders part of that top three U level conversation but I would also want the board to be present too I would hate to have anything shared at that level if the board didn't hear directly U which might give us the clarity we need to make a decision uh of one candidate over the other I'm not sure uh if that's possible but um yeah I would want to as a board member to be part of that top three conversation maybe another
024question is is this something we have to decide now could it be we we can do the five to seven as a board be like we're all in agreement like this one person is is that's the ideal person and ready to move and maybe have some followup questions but ready to move and then be stuck in this oh we've already said like is that something that we can pause on and then make that decision later maybe after abely absolutely we can decide that later as we go through the process some some some boards will wait until later and decide that for the very reason that you're talking about Adam and others will say nope it's a board decision that's why people elected us and we don't need to involve stakeholders in interviews and um so
025we just throw it out now to see kind of where you're at wanting to talk about it later we can absolutely do that I would say my pers while I see there's a lot of value in getting that additional feedback and stakeholder feedback and getting them involved I'm also very conscious of of the timeline involved as well for spring search and and I would say I'm in I'm in stephens's Camp when it comes to if we're going to do this um you know I think we have we need to have board at least board ears on it you know maybe just be observant of it um if possible because you know what what what one person hears what what questions are asked may have been asked in a different way you know there are a
026lot of aspects to interviewing that that um I I believe are uh are a little bit different from time to time and someone may answer a question that um or may ask a question of this interviewee um in one way and then we get to another round and we ask the same question in a different way and get two different answers so I think I think having some of the board on board with this and in those meetings at at all times no matter who is there how it's happening would be vital if that's possible okay um I think it's a a good look for us to hear other voices uh not just uh act like we know everything because no one on this board I don't believe is ever selected a superintendent and I
027like hearing a lot of voices because I think that's how you come up with the best conclusion and I would agree with that and just reiterate I can't imagine a scenario where I would not want to be present in the top three level and I would imagine every other board member would also benefit from being present one way or another at the top three level how do those interviews normally go is that like a a oneon-one interview a panel interview it's a one-on-one interview it's generally one-on-one what uh a a the board interviewing with one candidate a a interview committee interviewing with one candidate at a time yeah so be I've heard several different suggestions on how to do this so I think in the interest of time tonight let's sleep on this one and
028let's address it we've got plenty of time to decide this so let's let's sleep on it and and do some more thinking and more conversation about it and we can definitely decide that a little bit later does that sound all right okay all right um internal candidates we recommend that you consider all internal C Dian Diane can you talk about one C first please oh I'm sorry I'm sorry I totally uh missed that uh yes uh we need to have a board member typically it's the board president and a district liaison typically it's your board secretary or your administrative assistant to the board um to work with to do all the communicating um about the search whenever we have to communicate out to the entire board so that we are not communicating with the entire
029board the whole time uh the district Le aison we need for Logistics types things setting up places for focus groups to be held blah blah blah um getting getting documents out to you all that kind of stuff things posted on your website and uh if we have anything that needs to to have board input then we need someone from the board so who would you like to appoint as the board representative and the district representative for us to work with board commentary I'm happy to continue yes being the point person that sounds good I think that's fine I would maybe suggest we have our chief of communications uh Miss Joel's be the other Lea on because she will be doing most of the communications groups Communications but would she be the person like securing the
030rooms and um setting up all the details of our meetings with everyone copying things if we need things copied or we would definitely communicate with the communications person to get things out on your website we definitely would do that and I think J Jane I Jan Jane's honest she be wrong if she was the point person she would coordinate with or anybody El needs to coordinated with I would I would coordinate all of that so I would be happy to do that okay the these are just our our Point people we will definitely be you know communicating with the other people as necessary okay so while we're talking about the communication part we're going to be recommending that you on your website on the front page of your website you make some kind of a
031link or a portal or a section um that will be entitled superintendent search where we will be very transparent with everything that we're doing we'll put out a timeline we'll put out notices we'll put out all kinds of things on there so that people know where we're at in the search process all the way through um so that you you don't get hundreds of questions about where are you in the search process and we'll just keep that updated to keep the public informed about where we're at um in the process okay uh let's go to internal candidates now since we took care care of item C so our recommendation is that if you have any internal candidates that we would um if they chose to apply for the position that we would treat them as
032all the external candidates that they would everybody would be on the same playing field and they make it or they break it on their own Merit um that they don't get a a a free pass into the inter space simply because they're an internal candidate how do you feel about that I think that's perfect I would agree agree okay all right um one uh service that we will provide to you is we will give you a comparison of uh District compensation of superintendents around your area uh we can do your county we can do your region we can do the state we can do uh people in your conferences your athletic conferences we can do uh districts of like size um like makeup uh we just want to let you know that we're going to
033be doing that and we will give you that information at in the interview phase so that you can kind of be seeing what the going right is for um people and what they're making so that when you get ready to offer a compensation package you'll kind of be in the ball game we don't want you to necess unnecessarily lowball or pay exorbitant amounts to um get candidates we want you to be fair to candidates but we need candidates to be fair to you too um so that it is a good fit and it is a good marriage so if there is any any District any particular District that you definitely want us to compare you to we would like to know who those are and those could be things that you could just send to
034Jane or send to Adam and and we can U make sure we include those people also any questions about that well uh wouldn't you typically use salaries from a districts about the approximate size of ours we yes that's typically what we do but if there's somebody like that you're a Ral with that you want to be compared to and they're not really your size um you know we can do that too but typically typically we go about uh a thousand kids higher lower enrollment wise and and kind of look at those okay um the search time timeline then is going to be attachment a which is your second page and we've got some suggested dates in this timeline that we've plotted out the entire search process so we want to go through kind of these
035dates it's a very very tight time frame what we tried to do was get you into the interview stage at the very the final interview stage at the very first part of March so that you can make a hire um it is probably one of the shortest searches that we've done I'm just going to be upfront and honest with you the time frame is very very tight um usually we have about um average three to three and a half uh months to do a search and I think we're right at three months two and a half to three months by the time we get into getting candidates to you um one thing that we will do is we will set a calendar and it flexible if it needs to be at the end in other
036words if we set a calendar and then Kevin and I come to you and say we don't think we've got enough candidates yet we need to keep looking for candidates then we're going to come to you and ask you about extending the search I think it's important that we get you the right candidate rather than just whoever applies by a certain um point in time so if we don't have enough quality candidates we need to come to you and say we think we need to extend the search a little bit our goal is to stay within the time frame that we've been given which is to get you somebody by the by the first part of March the very first part of March okay so keep that in mind as we're looking at dates so
037hopefully you guys have kind of brought your personal calendars with you so that we can be looking at these so attachment a I'm going to scroll down here a little bit is actually the search timeline um um that we've um proposed I've got in yellow the tentative dates that we we are proposing and I'm going to kind of flip back and forth from the uh agenda up here with the different attachments and then we'll flip down into the attachments themselves so if we could look at the stakeholder engagement we want to kind of take a look at that on attachment b as I scroll down here we have a sample letter that can go on to your website introducing the search um introd opening the search really talking about the opportunities for stakeholder engagement that
038people can know that there's going to be a time where they can be a participant in helping to develop basically that candidate profile so if we're looking at this um letter that would kind of go out to the public on your website uh we would be mentioning that we are going to do an online survey and when that survey would be running we would be running that survey from the 13th to the 20th which is a week's time all of the survey data would come to Kevin and I nothing will go to the board it will come to Kevin and I so that we can have people speak freely it's an anonymous survey uh we would put a link out on your website we would announce ahead of time the Link's going to be out
039on the website on January 13th so check the website it's going to be there and uh it would close on the 20th then Kevin and I will take all of that information and we will give you a summarized report of the results of that survey then we would also announce when we're going to have the open forums we would have one for the public and one for the staff members uh community members staff members we would determine the location the date and the time um we've got suggested um dates I believe the 21st and 22nd on according to the first um page up there on that calendar um that we would come into the district we would hold both the focus groups and the open forums those two days and um then we would use
040the information that we get from those open forums and those focus groups and the survey data to develop that superintendent profile that we're looking at to describe who we think would be a good fit for the district and we would like to report that to you on Monday I realize you're not meeting on Mondays but on Monday January the 27th we could do this by Zoom it could be very quick we would like to present that profile to you and kind of get a thumbs up or a thumbs down about you think we hit the mark Or you think we're way off of who we're looking for one thing that we usually tell boards when we're talking to them about this candidate profile is to remember that we're looking for a candidate who can be
041a good candidate for the really the entire community of Francis Howell board members get elected and get off get elected and get off so the board members always change we want the superintendent to last through board member changes we want there to be um continuity and Longevity so the more information we can get from people to develop that profile the better off I think that we can have to get you a good fit so um this would be a sample letter we try to um Jane we try to give all kinds of stuff to you that you don't have to reinvent the wheel that you can just tweak and uh put out there on the website um and Jane once we have this all set Jane we we will send everything to you in word
042so you can adapt it the way you need to for for your own use perfect thank you okay um I think I did skip over something on the very first uh page was we would like to get this position advertised out on our website starting Monday we need to we need to get going and then uh Kevin's going to talk to you about other advertising opportunities a little bit later but we want to get it open Monday so that people know that this position is open more information to come and have it open through the Fe the 14 of February which is six weeks that would be the minimum we would ever advertise something would be six weeks we would never so that's just informational for you okay so if we could have um the
043next part which would be uh attachment C this would be the survey that we would actually put out to the staff or to the community through that online Link and the board can see what all the uh survey questions are here several pages long we just want you to see um what it is basically we're looking for uh people to tell us what are the uh strengths of the district and the community what are the challenges of the district in the community what are the characteristics and skills and traits that you're looking for in a new superintendent and what priorities you think uh the new superintendent needs to focus on in the first several months of or the first year of the job and so uh those questions on that survey kind of talk about
044those things in the focus groups again I have a sample focus group invite letter here and we're going to talk about how we will decide who those people are in just a second but the focus group questions are in the next um section here next attachment and it's just what I went over what are the strengths of the district why would a superintendent want to come to your District we're trying to sell this like sell this house like a real estate agent I want to tell you about all the good things about the district why would you want to come here then we want to talk about what challenges and barriers is the new superintendent going to face we don't want to bring a superintendent into your District District who is not equipped to deal
045with whatever challenges you've got that um they're going to have to deal with we want to have a good match um the focus areas in that first year we want to hear from people what those are and we're going to assume honesty and ethical Behavior Kevin and I will thoroughly vet candidates uh but we want to know what knowledge areas and skills and characteristics that uh a superintendent candidate would need to have in order to be successful at Francis how and then just kind of an open-ended is there anything else that you feel we should know to get us you the right person so these would be the questions we would ask in the focus groups and at those open forums and then the survey asks the same kinds of questions but in a force
046Choice manner so that then we can take the take the two sets of data and kind of compare them and um come up with um some response to develop that uh superintendent Prof profile again when we develop the profile we will give you a summary of what we've heard from all of the focus groups answering these questions so that you can hear what you know people are saying uh the community engage or the community engagement piece of the focus groups I'm gonna I'm sorry I'm having to scroll here I should use my sidebar a little bit I hope nobody's getting dizzy oh can I interrupt you here on this on this survey here I'm just perusing it um Can Can we modify this at all I see some you know something on here about how
047the district is handling the pandemic I don't know that that's really G throw that to you that's probably one that needs to come out is it is it present tense or was it past tense I I I don't have the survey in front of me sir I don't have it in front of me yeah it's present tense okay um let me look at the survey to make sure that that those kinds of questions are removed and um I'll make sure that that's taken care of and again that's my apology again this is a draft so I'm glad you caught that so thank you and I I actually have a question are in the survey is it uh are the uh the folks that fill it out are they is it Anonymous or are they identified
048it's Anonymous it's Anonymous and every IP address can only be used once so you know one person can't give a 100 opinions got it that's I was getting at but we would see or at least you would see a person's staff member uh parent student ethnicity U those features right we right so it's Anonymous but there are indicators that feel like reveals who they are sure and it's important for you guys to know that this survey you know we we let them know there is an open-ended question at the end is there anything else that you feel like we should know those things will come only to Kevin and I they will not come to board members so that uh people can speak freely if we give you a synopsis of all of that or
049a summary of all of that it becomes open to a Foye request and unfortunately when you have an open-ended question people will take pot shots and what we don't want is just some lamb blasting of certain people whether it be board members or staff members or people in the community uh we will get people just spouting off about their kids grades or whatever and it has nothing to do with superintendent search but we will have people that will say here's something that I didn't see that you asked about and I think this is important and so Kevin and I need to take kind of those things into consideration but we want people to you know take the survey seriously so that we can get a good feel for who could be you know a good
050fit for your district and so we take the board out of that part but Kevin and I will do a summary report so you can see kind of the mix of the people who took the survey some of the summary comments of things that were that we feel pretty relevant to our search process and give you that input so we would trust that you to have edited those responses appropriately sure okay do all board members feel comfortable with them being able to edit it or do you feel like we would like for her to share their decisions with like Jane heer or something that way there's somebody else who knows the edits they made we we don't really make edits we just we just ignore things that are real out there that don't have anything
051to do with the superintendent search I guess we're not gonna edit things yeah but we're not going to give you everybody's word for word response me you're the experts all right as part of your survey we recently had a big survey done we had results of that I forget what meeting we we reviewed the results of the last survey districtwide of community members do you guys at all consider that survey and how you pose your questions for this survey is it totally separate do we consider them together or how do we use that previous survey along with yours was that serve what was the purpose of that survey that you did previously uh to see strengths and weaknesses of the district what needs to improve what people see needs to improve um it was in
052it was in conjunction with our strategic Plan update okay I'm sorry I'm sorry do you mind if I jump in go ahead so our survey is a design psychometric uh survey that we use to create help create the profile so the shift is a little bit different with our survey compared to the one that you just described it's not strategically B uh plan-based it's more candidate profile based so I think there is some value there a lot of boards use the focus group and open form and Survey results that we'll present to you in a very thick packet um to to help design goals for the uh the the superintendent that you do eventually hire and uh rate that person throughout the school year so I think the focus is a little bit different and
053our our survey like I said is is proprietary and psychometric and it's been very useful to to all the boards that we've worked with that we would love to take a look at your results of your um strategic plan survey that you took because we maybe could glean some things ourselves about knowing the district better we would absolutely love to do that um and we would keep all of those things that we might see that pop out at us that could be relevant in our search process um keep those things in mind and possibly use some of those of knowledge that we could pick up from that that's I I just wanted to see if you would consider that since you're going to be taking addressing the covid issue why not address the surveys we've
054already done and incorporate that in yours so exactly we we would have be happy to do that what what we're really trying to do is get a you know we want to come into the district we're going to spend time in your District we got to know who you are get a good feel for who you are talk to people and we'll spend some time in your District just getting to get a flavor of who you are so that we have some ideas when we meet people do we think that this is a good a good fit you know outside of your interview process and all of that kind of stuff too okay let's get into identifying who would be in our focus groups so this is on the front page um on the agenda
055identifying the focus groups typically we would recommend that we we're definitely going to interview you guys and we've got a I would like to entertain that we interview you guys at your January 16th meeting if you could put some time in there for us to have a close session with the board to go over those four questions we need to hear from you what you feel the strengths are what you feel the challenges are um and you know what issues are going to be facing the superintendent coming in uh the focus groups that we do are considered Clos session we just want to hear what people have to say Co of course the open forms are open uh but we definitely need to have this with close session with the board because we may get
056into some things that are close session materials that we need to be aware of that uh new superintendents might be walking into through our conversation so if we could have some time and a close session for um at your January 16th meeting that would be last meeting you would have to have with us on the 20th or the 21st or whatever those two dates are I guess 21st 22nd um we would appreciate that would that be doable Adam yep that's should doable yep and we'll get tou about that you and J more about details about that so you guys have those four questions be thinking be jotting down your notes about you know um what what your suggestions might be to answer those questions for us okay who we T typically would like to talk
057to would be uh other than the board we would like to talk to administrators in the district I know you've got several buildings I know you've got central office district office and you've got building level so we would like to have some of the key players that are going to be working directly as direct reports with um the superintendent we would like to talk to them along with some central office staff who will be working directly with um like Jane we don't we want to talk to Jane um and some uh support staff there in the office we want to talk to some building level um administrators however you guys feel we can pick those or Jane you might have a good idea we'd like to talk to some high school administrators some Middle School
058administrators some Elementary administrators childhood administrators um special ed you have special ed departments we would like to talk to special ed administrators um and we would we would um need to determine how we want to decide who those people are we would want to talk to some teachers typically what we do with the teachers is we have the union leadership kind of pick who those teachers are going to be um we want a good cross representation of your teaching staff we want upper level lower level regular Ed um career Ed special ed gifted um just all walks of life in the teachers uh when we're talking about these groups we really would like to keep the groups to about 10 to 12 people is if we can uh we'd like to talk to a representative
059sampling of some non-certified staff members we're talking your support staff so your your transportation your buildings and grounds your uh nutrition um secretarial staff those those types of people uh I think I already did central office we would like to talk to some parents some business members usually for the parents we reach out to your parent groups and get some some leaders of your parent groups um to come and meet with us business members typically we would reach out to maybe the Chamber of Commerce or some kind of a a lead group that you've got and uh ask for several representatives from those groups or some key business members if you've got some uh big business business uh supporters of the district that you would like for us to include we can do that uh
060community members typically we have some board members um pick uh one person each and then we have some uh administrators pick one one Community member that's kind of engaged with the district and put a panel together there and uh booster groups if you have any booster groups that are pretty significantly involved in the district we would like to have you know a sampling of those people and we would like to have some high school students we like to get a feel for what's going on the district with high school students we learn a lot from the high school kids about what the districts really really like so um is there any other group that you feel that Francis Howell has that you think we should put into a a grouping of their own or a
061focus group for the purpose of a focus group do you ever include um churches that um have leas on with some of the schools putting them in um as as part of the focus groups we we usually include ministerial associations if you have associations or alliances or something ministerial ones we include those in the community group how many meetings with this be for you oh how many focus groups are you talking about like a focus group just for central office a parent focus group a business member focus group yes okay we'll be we pl we'll plan to be in the district two whole days and and the nights and Kevin and I can either do these together or we can do them two at a time Kevin can be doing one in one room while
062I'm doing one in another room um and it's back to back it's it's two full days of us talking to people and taking notes putting our heads together about what we heard so it could be I got one two three four five six seven eight nine it could be 10 to 20 groups do you usually work you work with like me and Jane to get these set up and like is that how it would generally work yes we can do that I don't know about anybody else but I would actually like to possibly include someone from some sort of a of an athletic background focus group that's a big focus of ours in this in this district and uh I mean I've talked to a lot of people throughout my time here that you know
063they come to me for those types of needs so if that's a possibility I don't know if anybody else agrees but that those typic those people typically are included in our booster group um group the athletic groups yeah you might have Fine Arts boosters yes you know various boosters [Applause] yeah you think we've pretty much hit people seems fairly comprehensive okay um I have a question about uh when you do the close session on the 16th with the board um is that all together as a group or individually that's all together and then and then you have the option to at the end if that we will tell you if there's anything that you didn't forgot to say didn't say didn't feel comfortable to say please reach out to us individually okay we think it's
064important that each board member hears what the the other board members are saying because you're going to be working as a team deciding who this um new person's going to be okay we will get that going then um and then we will delay the decision on the participation in the finalist interviews right okay um I have a sample on appendix uh D or attachment D on page 10 it's a uh sample letter again that can go out to the people that are invited to the focus groups um just kind of explaining what it is that we're we're asking them to do and we'll give them information about where when um and this is where we're going to really need somebody like Jane to help us schedule these where are we going to have these which
065groups are we going to have where uh at what time and um how we're going to get them invited and all that kind of stuff and that's uh coming up in a couple weeks so we have to get started on this right away okay next um on our agenda we have advertising decisions so if you would go to I'm going to turn this over to Kevin and if you would go to attachment uh like attachment many papers here in front of me G attachment G and Kevin will talk to you about advertising options thank you very very well thanks very much Diane um so the ones that we would recommend are to do the Missouri Association of school administrators which is all the you know the principles assistant principles assistant superintendants and superintendants throughout your
066State um that doesn't cost anything so it's a nice and easy one to do we will take care of those arrangements of course we post this on our own website and get our own um 67 Consultants out there networking across the United States um and then posted of course the opening on your own District website on that on that one link that we that Diane talked about at the beginning some options for costs are aasa which is the American Association of school administrators about 7500 members are in that organization and it's it's the one that we would recommend is the job Flash the second bullet it's married it's emailed to the 7,000 now superintendant in addition to the posting on the front page of their website and it cost $599 that's the one that we
067feel get you most bang for your buck we would not recommend education week um but we would recommend because we have a a partnership with nabzi the national Alliance of black school Educators and Al the association of Latin American superintendant that in total would be $400 for both those groups they would put that on their front page and get that out to their membership uh LinkedIn is really not in the education game just yet I wouldn't recommend that we've only had one candidate even apply for a position that we that we've posted on LinkedIn I don't think you get much bang for your buck so the ones that we would recommend are the A aasa J flash for $5.99 and and the nabzi and Alice one for $400 for both those both those recommend both
068those advertisements um but happy to take whatever questions you'd like questions board comments work I think um I trust your expertise in this matter yeah I'm good with those recommendations me as well thank you very much I think those are good calls and I think you'll get a lot of bank for your buck and because the time window so short advertising I think will be an important consideration for this this posting so if you would look at the next page which is page 14 this would be like an example of uh the superintendent ad that would go out it's just really brief um and it just uh kind of pequs somebody's interest and sends them to our website so that they can find out more information about you and about the process for applying uh
069we've got in here that you are a little over 177,000 students would that be correct I I found 16,000 and I found 177,000 it depends on where I look I thought we were under but just between 16 and 17 but uh so so maybe we'll put it we'll change that to 16,000 16,000 plus okay and when I was looking on your website at your entire District budget including your your bonds I came up with about 295 million for this year that's sounds about that sounds about right okay okay and we always usually adver I that we that we're looking to do a regionally competitive salary and benefits package without stating an exact amount because it's going to be negotiable based on experience and resume and all that kind of stuff and then we put here
070the applications are going to be due you know the 14th of February so that they know they got they got to get get on the ball if they're interested and then our our link to our website where they can actually go apply okay and then the next page is kind of what we would put on our website just a little bit of info about you so that people um think about possibly applying they can kind of learn a little bit about you and then of course they're going to go to your District website and learn more about you um they'll be watching your board meetings and looking at your minutes and all that kind of stuff but uh what we've got here is the district is uh in oallen are there any other cities or
071towns that really need to be mentioned there or is Ofallon what you would generally use it's a lot of municipalities yeah so should we say the Ofallon in the surrounding area or something like that or do you have like a square mileage that we should put in here or I mean it seems like St Charles County St Louis County would Encompass where it is I mean realistically we are just a suburb a western suburb of St Louis so right so the problem the problem ends up being is that there's you know I think there's almost 90 different municipalities that you could just go on a list forever and you just get St Louis right just I if I were you I would just consider the the St Louis metropolitan area Okay St Charles County being
072the Focus St Charles County yeah okay maybe St Charles County a sub of St Louis metro area okay I would indicate Missouri as well a Missouri suburb yeah I agree with uh Mark okay um and as far as qualifications go that they need to either possess or be eligible for a Missouri superintendent license and any other qualifications that you may desire if there's anything else that you desire you would need to let us know um that you would want the new superintendent to possess or have our website posting can be changed you know daily if we need to if you come up with something or think about something once we get an ad out there on aasa it's not going to be able to be changed well I mean do we want to do we
073want to say that they have previous experience as a superintendent or does that matter to you guys i' hate to Discount like an assistant superintendent or something hasn't been in May administrative experience yeah well that's right and and and look at what we got out got with Ken I mean he was an assistant superintendent moved up pretty quickly to superintendent he was fantastic so I would like like Adam said I would hate to eliminate somebody just because you know of that but I I think I think goes Adam yeah maybe the broad like you I think you just said Carly like previous administration administrative experience not necessarily superintendent experience but broad administrative experience you what what we can that's necessary to get the superintendent certification is that you have to have a couple of years
074experience and um that that's that's already built in captures that right yeah so you're okay with saying they're eligible or do you some people yeah some people are certainly eligible they just haven't yeah to get the the certification paper yet but um yeah certainly there's plenty that are going to be eligible plus just FYI if you get someone from out of state right they would be eligible for licensure they just haven't applied yet because you've got reciprocity with other states so I I the wording here is opens up the door so out right know that they would be genuinely um considered do you know how long it takes for them to receive that lure if they complete it last time we talked to um the Missouri State Board of uh uh State Board of Education
075it was eight 8 to 12 weeks typically but we had several candidates and a previous search do it much more quickly than that okay are there any states that don't provide reciprocity that you don't focus on for Missouri candidates I I have those in my notes uh buried somewhere in a filing cabinet but it's very few there's only like two or three that they don't have reciprocity with most most States they do what happens if they're unable to be licensed in Missouri for some reason or does that happen we the first for most of us yeah so um if they're unable to be licensed we will not move them forward if they're unable if we know they can't get the license by July 1st and be ready to you know by July 1 and be
076legit we won't move them forward so if we have a superintendent candidate who does not have their current Missouri superintendent lure we will do what we we've done in previous searches in Missouri is we will call the Missouri Department of Education and give the scenario the exact scenario and ask is it possible that they can be LIC Ed in time and they'll tell us yes they can no they can't okay um sometimes people question get getting an out ofate candidate I wouldn't always just ride off out ofate candidates because there could be someone who has ties to the St Louis area and they'd like to come back could be a previous resident of your district and they would like to come back they just happen to be living somewhere else right now um so uh
077it doesn't necessarily mean that you know they would have to learn totally everything um again being a superintendent is a it takes personal personality traits and some skill sets and knowledges but it's like any other type of job you're going to learn you go from one Factory to another Factory you're going to learn that Factory's way of working but you still know how to weld you come to a different Factory and you're welding you still know how to weld but you're just going to learn all differences and nuances of the new Factory do do any of you have any geographical restrictions I don't think I don't for I mean to me it just lines on a map but does anybody else have any thoughts on geographical restrictions are you talking about residency yeah okay considering
078people from other states like it when you mentioned that it was that you wouldn't move anybody forward if they couldn't get licensed or the scenario that you put put toward Missouri said that they couldn't get licensed well to me that's all we need to really no if they can be licensed or can't be licensed if they're a great candidate great um doesn't matter where they're coming from to your point if somebody lives in Colorado wants to come back to St Louis why do we care so I thought you were asking about would they need to be a resident here or not probably would need to be a resident here somewhere in the area eventually yeah but but also isn't that is that necessary well there have been some issues uh recently about that that' be
079something we discuss when we get the contracts right yeah right I think discuss each individual situation you know yeah might not be an issue so why talk about it now right right if we get there then we'll cross that bridge if we get there okay I was speaking just towards candidate considerations yeah okay um some of the highlights that we usually like to put put in here is some you know some tidbits about the district I pulled these off of your um your uh accolades that you've recently gotten for being one of the top districts in the nation and uh just threw these in here these are some from your website and some from Niche that um gave you the honor and uh I think that's that could be very attractive for candidates to see
080um what type of a district uh that you are are um some of your success in funding uh a large bond to take care of some of your infrastructure I understand there's been some troubles with the the bonding for the infrastructure but um that you are taking care of or trying to take care of your facilities um it's a good place to work uh you know your students are excelling and those are all things that are going to be very attractive to candidates just want to let you guys know I just got a text from Jane she said she lost connection okay oh Jane heer no Jane push oh yeah just to let you know she's listening in from the other link okay yeah um and then we will just put a few search calendar
081dates in here at the end basically when the applications are due when the interviews uh when we will be interviewing and and when the position you know will start and applying through this website so that's kind of what we will uh initially put out on our website I would like to go back up to the calendar finish out our calendar dates get back up to that uh the second page here so uh we will determine if we are going to be um using any any stakeholders in the interview process but I want to talk about the rest of interview process now so I'm going to pick it up here on um by February the 20th so by February 20th remember the the the applications are going to be due by February the 14th so by
082February 20th Uh Kevin and I will have met face to face with the most promising candidates that we feel have applied to um interview them and to vet them to do some reference check we will Google check we will we will do all that kind of stuff to make sure that we're bringing you quality candidates and that we don't have a bad apple in the bunch that we're bringing you we are not interested in being the headline that Kevin and Diane and school exec connect brought Francis Howell a thief or anything like we don't want that headline we know you don't want that headline so uh we're very happy to announce that we have not had that problem so we're not going to be the first um we are recommending that on February the 20th
083which I believe is a regular board meeting again for you guys that we will present our slate of candidates to you the five to seven that we would like for you to take a first look at and we will um actually give you the entire candidate file we will tell you about uh the references that we checked what they had to say about these candidates we will talk about their backgrounds we will um give you that some that salary study that we're doing and uh we will put you through an interview training none of you I heard have been through hiring a superintendent before so we will go through the dos and don'ts of interviewing and and um getting through the the rest of this process we will help you we will guide you we
084won't do your question writing but you'll have to determine and decide what kinds of questions you want to ask these candidates that'll have to be done before you interview them so it'll it'll take some time to prepare for the actual interviews so if we could have some time set aside we would like at the end of your meeting because we don't know exactly how long this will take um but we would like to have a close session at the end of your meeting on the 20th also to present the Slate candidates and do that interview Workshop then uh we're recommending that on February the 26th and 27th you conduct those actual first interviews uh this will be just with the board Kevin and I will be present but we will not participate in the interviews
085uh sometimes boards will get stuck and so we'll just kind of be a fly on the wall in the back corner um just in case you have questions along the way um about something that happened then we will we have a process that we will go through we're not going to go through that tonight we'll do it in the interview training but we have a process to help you narrow down uh your five to seven initial candidates to your top three so we're recommending that you interview those top three either in a single day or night or over a three-day period using March 1st 2 third and or fourth depending on what your calendars look like usually we like to recommend that you do these all on one day usually it's on a Saturday so
086that you don't have a lot of time between the first candidate interviewing and then the second candidate interviewing the next night and then the next night the third candidate you kind of lose what the first candidate was even all about um so we can we can determine those exact dates later again but if you can kind of keep your calendars open a little bit for these dates so that we can get this done um that would be helpful and then uh once you're done interviewing all three of those candidates on that day we have a process to kind of help you come to your conclusion of the the final candidate once you come to that conclusion then we have to spend a little time vetting thoroughly vetting that candidate we recommend that you do a
087deep dive background check with a third- party uh vendor that we use for backgrounds um it there is a cost of $800 for that but they can get into court records that we can't get into they can get into um they can do a a credit report on the person they can uh verify that uh college degrees and um uh certifications are accurate and not fake those are things that we can't do they can verify Social Security number we can't do that they can get into DMV records to verify that we don't have someone who is a a drunk um a consistent drunk uh that has lots of DUIs uh we get a social media report on their footprint their social media footprint it's just a deeper dive for the board to do their own
088vetting so that um you can deeper than what Kevin and I have permission to do legally um just to make sure that there's not something there it takes usually about seven days to get that report back um and you will need to probably spend about seven days or so negotiating a contract um so at some point in time when we get closer to the interview stage we'll recommend that you start working with your board attorney on a framework for a contract where we we just are ready to Simply fill in the the numbers um when you negotiate those with the candidate but the the language and the framework is there ready to go and once the contract has been negotiated and we're confident that uh we've got reference checks done uh that deep dive done
089we're going to ask the board members to do their own calling um of references that the candidate will supply for us just to make sure everything's clear and then you can publicly um hire the person and make your Public Announcement we can help you with a press release if if so desired and we we'll help navigate you through all of those steps at the end so what we've got here is um by no later than mid late March you would have a person hired if we stick to this tight time frame we can get that done it could be early March when you can have the person hired just depending on what day you would land on somebody uh July 1 your new superintendent would assume duties and we always put on this timeline that
090you reserve the the right to change any dates this timeline uh uh would be something that we would post our website so that people could follow where we're at in the process so questions um I was wondering about when you give us some um instruction on how to interview these candidates is that going to occur between February 20th and February 26th or do we do that when we're doing that you 26 and 27th we're recommending to do that interview workshop on the 20th same night we give you the Slate on the okay the same night okay yes on the 20th hopefully our meeting's not over at 11 or open hopefully not hopefully not it has happened short if you guys have a short regular meeting yes we can Adam I'll do my best so this
091these are um dates that will work to get us to the 1 of March first part of March um they dates that Kevin and I are available uh hopefully these are dates we tried to match up with meetings that you're already having anyway if we need to have a special meeting you know we can we can do that if we need be we just don't want you to have multiple meetings when we get to the end you're gonna have multiple meetings because it's to to do the action viewing any other questions comments anything we didn't cover that you're wondering about I think you did a great job tonight thank you Kevin anything to add that I forgot no you you did a really good job Diane I really appreciate it especially your technolog technology Wizardry
092I I think the primary thing we need to get out of the way uh sooner rather than later is to identify focus group attendees um and so that we can get those rooms set up and and people have enough advanced notice to be able to come on the 21st or 2 second um so whatever you can do to to um speed that along and I know you're not back in session yet but once once that takes place we'll work with Jane and Adam to get that going that's that's I think the number one priority at this point did you say you wanted each of us to give you one recommendation for the community yes and that's uh sometime in January you want that uh as soon as possible really like that because we would like
093those invitations to go out within the next week um probably yeah I assume that Jane would write uh would would do that on Adam's behalf uh so that she can keep a tally of how many again you know eight to 10 or so people per focus group is an ideal number so we send that to Adam I I would say yes but Adam you may disagree but Adam would be the one to communicate directly with Jane and and and Diana myself yep that'll work you can copy Jane on it too send to send it to his okay Adam and Jane just for your info while we're working on this focus group section we'll probably all of our emails will go to both of you just so that you're both in the loop so would be
094in on all of those um emails to to get the logistics bat and down so we should ask this person first correct I I would assume so I would assume that you would ask and let them know that blind volunteering that's what what we what we do around here surprise you're in a meeting how much how much time do you think we should tell them is involved about 45 minutes is how much time we use that's all just 45 minutes okay it's about that much time yeah all right thank you we can't give him a definite time yet but or date date it'll either be 21st or 22nd of January be what now 21st or 22nd of January according to our timeline that's on here thank you anything else okay so I hope that I'm
095going to unshare my screen if that's okay so uh does this give you kind of a sometimes your brain's just rolling when we we do all this talk but as we go through each step it just all starts making sense at the end it just all kind of flows I know this is a lot at the beginning but if if we can get your input right here at the beginning it really helps us plot it all out and then we start doing doing it in stages and we'll keep you informed all the way through as we go so does it give you kind of a framework for the whole entire search process or is there anybody that's just bewildered still yeah okay looks really good I really appreciate it thank you that's all that Kevin
096and I have for you for oh we we do need to go into close session for just a little bit if we can all right sounds good Bard like a motion to adjourn Open Session and inner close session so moved from second first by Randy director cook second by director Ponder all those in favor say I hi hi hi say now ni have it and I sent an email for all of you so that you can uh quickly go over to the closed session uh let me know if you have any difficulties okay thank you do we need to vote individually to go into close J well I I did have a motion to go into closed redo the roll call um let's see do we have at least four yes there's still okay so
097I have President bertran you want to make a motion sure I'll second the motion president Bertrand hi vice president cook hi director Owens hi director Ponder hi director Harmon hi okay and I don't see Mr Blair on any longer so that's good all right there Jane and uh director Blair both said I as well