001thank you Bard like a motion to approve the agenda for December 18th 2024 as presented so moved second director Ponder second by director Blair all those in favor say I those oppose say no eyes have it board our agenda item for tonight is to talk about um Contracting for superintendent search firm um so just to give a little background for the public so we did reach out to search fir terms um we did get four responses back in our timeline our timeline as I said in uh kind of the announcement um Dr rus' resignation is to be aggressive and our timeline is to try to get this done by March um for a couple different reasons um one because we have CFO position the fill and the search for and the feature superent should be
002involved in that but also we have teacher hiring in March as director Blair had pointed out in one of our conversations um and we want to make sure that they have stability and understand kind of who's going to be leading leading the ship and who's going to be be kind of the the person in charge and and have that continuity um that there's continuity there and know um what they're getting into so we thought that was important as well um so I know Bard I sent out some information u based on the context that we that we got of the The Firm that were able to meet that timeline we did get four of them I will work with um Miss heler heler um to get that posted um after the meeting after we clean
003up some of the some of the some of the data as far as like contact information and that kind of thing so the public can see what those firms were um but I just wanted to put it up there I would if there's any questions I would recommend the mo a motion to approve the president of the board to enter a contract with msba Missouri school boards Association for superintendent search not to exceed 18,000 and um expenses for six up to up to 6,000 for travel potential candidate travel fees um that would be my recommendation um but open to the suggestions from the board and any commentary or thoughts discussion around that and around the around the topic at hand I think they're great I think they'll be a good great person to a group
004to have with us do we have a is that a full motion from you Adam it's it's just a recommendation recommendation P recommendation so the other firm was school exec connect is that right yeah so we had hya msba Ray Associates and school exec connect for the for four firms yeah but School exact was the only other one that could meet the timeline um they all said they all said they could meet the timeline um some had some hesitancies or and thought they may have to pull in other resources and had some hesitancies but they all said that they could could find a way so is your is your recommendation from msba versus another one just purely based on cost I think yeah I think some of it's based on cost so I don't see
005a reason why so for I guess for the Public's knowledge schools that connect um charged up to 30,000 msba is 18,000 so part of its costs right I don't know that there's a reason msba is known throughout the state they know many superintendents they're doing many superintendent searches in the past and many currently um so they have a a strong background and track record um which seemed as good or good or better than any any of the other candidates at a lower lower cost have you heard any reviews about msba for this I have tried to talk to a few people um I did talk to one of the a former board member at wizville um and they said they were happy with msba when they did their search and like just their reactiveness and
006um how that how how they operated they were they were satisfied with with them I had a conversation with the president of Kirkwood who they Kirk would use um School exec connect um they were happy with that service as well so it seems a post service is um some context where we're happy with the service I think it's a good look for us not to choose someone that's more expensive at this point yeah but there's also the you get what you pay for side of it but I I generally agree with that I would say they're experts well they I think um I'm looking at their chart here so are we are we confident that the the superintendents that msba searches are finding for districts are um the right fit meaning they don't meaning they
007have above average tenure in the position I'm looking here at school exec connect and um you know there's there's some start dates listed here I don't see anything comparable to to msba I mean msba the way I see it they have they have you know basically a um a lock on the whole state and um they're kind of always doing these superintendent search firms so what I Envision is they have some pool of the the available people or the qualified people if you will um what what frustrates me is that so many of these National searches you know we end up or districts end up finding you know the the best candidate was wouldn't you know it they were in the district uh one or two districts over from where we are right that was
008there was some conversation around that so I worked with Carol a little bit on worked with Carol on this and so we had some conversation around that and I went through and poked around um Google searching and I I put some commentary on there I think I put that in the email and a lot of the a lot of the candidates that did get hired are a large majority of them were local candidates to begin with so when we talk about National searches it's hard because state law for education is diff from state to state so it's hard for somebody to come in from from another state be difficult to search and find somebody from another state that can come in and then not only are they picking up the new school the new area
009also the new state laws yes so uh Adam The Matrix that you created for us is that public or can that be public yeah that's what I said the beginning we'll clean that up take out contact information and stuff and then we'll publicize that because I think the public would benefit from seing that because it really is clear that I think uh School exec connect and msba are both good options and when you look at all the different Apples to Apples you um you can see where one might be a little better here one might be a little better there one piece that I thought was helpful was when you identified that msba um is currently helping out uh Webster Groves and uh St Joseph correct and they helped uh Columbia and that's they found
010a local person for Columbia but schools that connect uh found Kirkwood Rockwood written hour they're just starting University City Parkway they just started um St Joseph pops up on that too I'm not sure why but uh they both have some experience reaching out to the local um area like radio just said so I am getting did we just get the live stream up Scott that is correct we've been sending out the public link for the uh Zoom as well as the live stream is now going right perfect so uh president berin you will clean up the Matrix you shared with us and that will be uploaded at some point yeah yeah yeah for the community who's just jumping in um there's nothing that I see in The Matrix that appears to be um misleading or
011prioritizing one over the other it looks like just a standard cross-section of what each of the four options were and where they are in all these different areas and uh I appreciate that is a very helpful tool to help us make this decision any other thoughts commentary questions board I think it's important here so superintendent tenure is um at least in the state of Missouri as we know is what's the average like I believe the average right now is 2.3 over two yeah so just over two years is the average so I think all of us would love to have a superintendent for a good long time but I think the reality is that we we should expect that we'll be lucky to have someone for three um in in in this um in the
012year 2024 or 2025 rather um that I think it's important here that so with school exec connect we have or that you know just setting the the district up down the road you know if this person doesn't work out out um then uh you know we have a um we have some some different guarantees here if you will um between both msba and school EXA connect you guys can are probably looking at those on your screen here but um Randy um for those who are joining us live could you identify the similarities between those two msba School EXA uh guarantee in the event superintendent leaves just so they can see the similarities yeah Scott just so I'm Crystal Clear were we not live streaming prior to just yeah there's there's a delay in getting the
013live stream up okay all right uh oh we have director Harmon we will be following up just for clarity we will be following up with the full recording okay have appr it um so we're um we are discussing which of the four firms that were reached out to uh to go with here so mba's guarantee is uh if onboarding services are utilized and the superintendent does not return for year two meaning they only make it one year um the new search cost is uh $11,000 plus staff train travel um whereas the the cost for this first year is is $188,000 so and and staff travel uh the difference here is with school exec connect um if the person leaves for whatever reason within 24 months additional searches at no additional fee uh except expenses so
014um that that's a you know that's something I think that is important to consider here well and and also as you mentioned Randy um I think an important part of that too is is the guarantee going forward that that particular firm will not try to poach that superintendent from us right they they are you know it's kind of like uh you know attorney client privilege I can't sorry I can't help you here I'm I'm out um so you're going to have to go with another search firm to find you uh a home so um I think that's an important aspect of it too considering this executive Search firm is one of the Premier ones in the in the land as well yeah yeah now the cost difference for the Public's sake um so we're looking
015at $188,000 plus travel for the msba search uh and approximately $30,000 plus costs um travel cost costs and and uh expenditures for the other strong Contender which is school exec connect um so say 12 12,000 give or take Delta here I think this is um obviously 12,000 is 12,000 um but this is arguably one of the one of the most exp important positions in the district not a place to um to cut costs at least at least at at this order of magnitude um so I'm the costs aren't that far apart as far as I'm concerned um so there's yeah I mean if you if you divide it up between you know let's let's let's let's let's give any superintendent the benefit of the doubt and say that they're going to last three years on
016average here you know we'll bump it up a little bit so $10,000 a year is what ultimately we're paying for one versus $88,000 a year was what we're paying for the other so when you split it up into that and and take the overall cost divided by the years that that they're there it's it's a nominal difference director Harmon any thoughts you've uh joined here I am just trying to gather where you guys are in the process we're uh we're looking over the The Matrix the the chart yeah we're just talking through the between mainly between msba and school exec connect and school exe that's kind of what where I thought you guys were so kind of looks like a wash between the two in my opinion as to what I looked at all right
017what did you D Haron what did you what did you did you hear our um our pros and cons to both I don't know when you jumped in I jumped in probably two minutes ago okay please heard some of the conversation and has the Matrix yeah I do have the Matrix I think one thing we're all wondering and well correct me if I'm wrong I don't want to speak for everybody but this is a um probably a pretty small candidate pool um and part of me wonders if we're going to get the same candidates no matter which firm we go through um which which then begs the question do we really need a firm um but I suppose there's some value in in having them uh you know do some of the some of the
018initial vetting um although I do think president berran is it I know we talked about this briefly but is there uh Provisions where we we are able to see every applicant yeah we we can set we can set up the process however we want we'll work so one of the next steps would be whichever firm it is the put a contract together then work with them on on exactly what that process looks like and and kind of line that out how it looks kind of a plan of action as you will I'm certainly happy to see there whichever firm we go with see their recommendations but I I would also like to see the the full candidate pool as well just as a as a as a check yeah yeah I agree with that I
019would say one of the benefits I see with msba they have some really strong relationships with the other school organizations so like the superintendant organization the administrators organization and it's all all their costs as far as posting jobs they do it's all all included in some other costs again I don't want to go back to just costs I agree with that but I think it's a beneficial that they have a lot of good strong relationships with some of those other organizations where where candidates are involved candidates are are members of um potential candidates are members of that they can leverage as well I would assume School EXA connect also has some of those relationships um so in some regards there's going to be a lot of probably a lot of overlap and capabilities between between
020both of them and so comes down to I guess where we place some of the intangible benefits maybe one question I have and and this is something that maybe both firms are the same I don't know if you if you've asked this um are we paying these companies to literally just post the job apps on these different sites and then they sit back and wait for the applications to roll in and then they read them or is somebody actively thing searching no I think they both go out and actively search and try to try to work I I would just part of my envisioning of the process and looking at other processes that both these firms have gone through is working with the board to understand the district pulling data for the district um in
021my head we share with them all the work and data around strategic planning around some of the roundtables things like that with them so they get a good picture and view of the district and working with us I'm sure they would talk with with with the board on kind of that what that superintendent profile looks like like what do we think what are our strengths what are our weaknesses of the district where do we need to need to leverage the superintendent um that kind of thing and then they they should be going out and also searching and trying to find candidates that they know of or asking around and the and the organizations that they they have Rel relationships with looking for candidates that might fit that profile the other question is you know go
022ahead Ron I was going to say again I'm late and I'm just curious because looking at at the msba I I see that they're basically covering the advertising but then they they declare a March delivery can't occur so I'm kind of thinking that would require them to be proactive and and I would think they would have a database based on their recent searches that's yeah they're gonna have yeah you know and I'm thinking I heard you guys talking about the two years versus three years and then understanding that the average superintendent is 2.3 years so I mean they're covering if you need to go for another one the new search cost is $1,000 plus staff travel if we have to if we're require another search for year two so it's pretty curious yeah that's so
023msba yeah they're basically giving their guarantee for one year whereas the other is for two now the other firm is another $122,000 so that get you more than halfway there to hire msba again um so there there's that um the other the other concern I have is if they have some dedicated staff you know how what is it Carol you may know this what I think there was something on an MS recent msba email There Was 80 or 90 superintendent openings in Missouri did anybody see that I think I read that in the paper yeah this was maybe three or four weeks ago I I think I read that um I have to assume that msba is doing the Lion Share of those um so you know you also run into the idea that do
024their do their recruiters have the Capa you know how how busy are their recruiters is really the the bottom line here well if they if they said they could do it in the timeline we wanted I'd say that they probably have enough people to handle it I no yeah I have no doubt that they will find us three candidates um that anybody could find us three candidates um in by March the question is is how far and wide are the are their recruiters able to search given their workloads especially in the months of January and February um in the state of Missouri so we're our timeline isn't the best but we have you know we are and it might not work it might not work out because um fewer in fewer people are wanting that
025job well yeah so I have a yeah want to point out a question here um Adam we use msba for some other functions correct correct yeah we're we're members of msba so are there is there any other value for us to stay with msba for this purpose because we're using them for other purposes as well like is there any is there any reason that our longer relationship with msba would be a benefit for them to lead this process as well yeah so I would say the the the only thing that pops out or or comes to mind would be if you if msba is engaged in the future for for additional training which which is part of what they include in the cost was is like an initial training they try to onboard the superintendent
026and get the superintendent and the CFO and the president be together and kind of get them kind of coalescing as a team if you will uh but if they do future any kind of future training then they'd have that background they'd already kind of be be one foot ahead and getting that set up so where I'm at the the difference between 18,000 and 30,000 is it is $12,000 difference but in the light of how big our budget is when it comes to just finding the right person really it's whoever we think finds the right person and not find the wrong person and say well we saved $12,000 we got the wrong candidate but we saved 12,000 that doesn't doesn't quite carry uh very far when I think about msba I think some of the recommendations
027you mentioned I've talked to other board members different uh cities and they said very positive things about msba um the one thing about school exec that I thought was interesting is under the notes you indicated Adam it says quote no lawsuits uh 97% success over an eight-year period with superintendent receiving a second contract uh me obviously uh it's hard to double check that right now but that sounds like they're very confident that the people they choose uh or help direct towards the the school board leads to a very positive match and potentially um a longer stay at least that's how they're presenting themselves so uh right now we're I am msba and school EXA connect both seem like very good options um I think we'll be in good hands either way uh but I just
028want to lift up those as two potential perks or pluses one for each one any additional questions or discussion or motions to be recommended or stated did Carol either way no she basically she didn't she didn't want she she didn't want to she said work together here's the information yes it's up to you guys yeah blamer nope well I'll make a motion to uh to engage uh School exec connect in the in the search of our next superintendent second we have a motion in a second discussion board any additional discussion all those in favor say I I I I all of posos say no no eyes have it all right board like a motion to adjourn wait Adam y could you share while we have people's attention what next steps would be and where they
029can find um information about the next steps yeah so right now the next step the main step would be to engage School exec connect um and then from there we will work with them to put put a kind of a more stringent timeline or action plan together on and we'll probably be making I would assume we'd make that publicly available somewhere um we have to find out exactly where somewhere potentially maybe on the website or something I'll have to work with admin to do that overall timeline is the try to is execute in March so we can meet um the needs of the district for Teacher hiring as well as hiring of feacher CFO Etc thank you before like a motion to adjourn the meeting no moved all in favor say I I all opposed
030say no eyes have it thank you everybody appreciate have a good night good night thank you everybody