CorpusRecord 55590

Grand Forks Public Schools School Board Meeting (February 10, 2025)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / GF Schools
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Grand Forks County, ND
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,276 words · about 52 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e we call to order the meeting of the Grand Fork school board for Monday February 10th first item on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance we'd ask you to stand as able and the flags you'll find in this corner of the room 1A the reading of our Schoolboard meeting Norms Mr Larson thank you the Norms are be prepared be on time value and respect each other exercise thoughtful deliberation and conversation be professional professional at the board table and when visiting with the general public speak up when the Norms are not being followed Advocate on behalf of students and keep the community in mind thank you moving on to item two uh before I seek a motion to approve the agenda just one announcement related to the agenda uh Mr Chad cka who

002was to lead the presentation on celebrating success from uh Nathan Twining uh Elementary in middle school is unavailable this evening so that item will be moved to our February 24th meeting so understanding that I would seek a motion to approve the agenda with the elimination of agenda item 3 and 3A related to celebrating success it's been moved by Dr hodak is there a second second by Mr pa uh we'll take a roll call Vote pomino Yes Anderson yes Len yes Flynn is absent Larson yes Manley yes clevin yes hodak yes and Berger yes eight yes Zer no one absent motion passes now moving into item four the public comment period and again my apologies if this is coming up in the agenda sooner than folks had uh had anticipated I do believe a a message

003went out to most of the interested parties about the fact that we would land here about 602 rather than 647 uh with that said let me introduce the public comment period uh I'll share the number of uh comment forms I have and if any others uh want to add there'll be an opportunity for that as well we're about to enter into the public comment period for our meeting although state law does not require us to hold a public comment period we have chosen to do so because we believe it is crucial for us to hear from our community members about their concerns and issues having said that please note that the board is here to listen the public comment period is not designed to be a discussion accordingly please do not expect board members to

004respond to your concerns or questions now this is because we take your concerns and questions seriously and want to have sufficient time to process and research issues if need be we will however respond to your questions and concerns at a future meeting or have proper staff get back to you at the appropriate time I also want to point out that under state and federal privacy laws we are unable to entertain any comments or questions about school district Personnel please know however that we take Personnel concerns very seriously on these matters we would ask that you would go through the appropriate administrative channels finally we recognize that right now in our nation and in our community we are polarized on a number of issues that said we want our school board meetings to serve as an

005example to our students that members of our school board and members of our Community can deal with controversial issues in a civil Manner and to demonstrate mutual respect for one another in that Spirit we will insist that all speakers and members of the audience maintain Civility and respect for any Divergent views that others possess we ask speakers to please address their comments to the board directly finally I want to remind everyone listening that you may submit written comments to the board in lie of speaking during the public comment period if you so choose the board will now entertain public comments each individual speaker is allotted up to 3 minutes the individual time limit will be enforced so that all members of the public who wish to speak may be allowed to do so at this

006time I believe I have five public comment forms if there are others uh you could bring them up now the first form I have is from Don Mor good evening I'm Don Mard and I have been an educator here in gr forks for 31 years and during that 31e time I have also served in many different capacities here in grandforks I have been a second grade teacher a third grade teacher a fourth grade teacher a fifth grade teacher a sixth grade teacher a curriculum technology partner and I have also served on the negotiations team for the grandforks Education Association since 2009 and I am here tonight to um implore you to really look at um accepting the definition of teacher that is currently in our negotiated agreement I can tell you that since 20 9

007that definition of teacher as outlined in our agreement has been discussed and agreed upon by the negotiation teams on both the board and the teachers side on more than one occasion the most recent being during our 2021 negotiations at that time we were not polarized over the definition of teacher at that time we all agreed that we were part of Team Grand Forks that we were all Educators here serving in the best interest of our students and I encourage you at this point in time to make sure that we look at that definition of teacher together as a board team and a neg and a negotiations unit and talk about that together as a group we know that everyone who works with a student in our district whether it's in the classroom or not is

008an educator so I urge you to accept the petition for GR Forks Education Association to negotiate on the behalf of of all of our educational professionals here in gr Forks thank you thank you next I have I'm sorry is it Kayla Christensen Kayla or kala my apologies president briger and members of the school board my name is Kayla Christensen and I serve as a GFA negotiator and membership chair I'm also a sth grade R teacher at Valley Middle School while my fellow classroom teachers at Valley are the best that I've ever worked with we could not do what we do without all of the Educators in our building who support us and our students our colleagues do not deserve the worry of losing contract benefits protections and collective bargaining rights that this change of wording

009presents remind you that Article 1 Section 1e of our negotiated agreement defines a teacher as certified or professional person El excluding there from the superintendent assistant superintendent principes associate principles supervisory Personnel substitutes and classified Personnel certified or professional Personnel that is what the negotiated agreement currently States unless a staff member is in one of the seven groups listed in the negotiated agreement they are part of this negotiation body also article 12 of our negotiated agreement states the provisions of each article attached here to except as otherwise specifically provided shall be effective as of July 1st 2023 to June 30th 2025 at which time it shall automatically renew itself unless written notification to the contrary is made by either party at least 60 days prior to the anniversary date of this agreement if such notification occurs

010this agreement shall be renegotiated changes may be made at any time by Mutual consent article 12 applies to article one changes to the wording of article one cannot be made by one party of the negotiated agreement without consent or agreement by the other any changes to the negotiated agreement must happen at the negotiating table thank you thank you next I have Melissa bkup president burger and and the members of the school board um many of you already know me but my name is Melissa buap I am the current uh government relations chair for GFA a negotiator and former president of GFA as well has been an educator in our school district for 20 years I here today to express my disappointment in the recommended action of rejecting the language of the letter of petition to

011negotiate of the gr Forks Education Association the language in our petition states that definition of teacher that is written in our current teacher negotiated agreement this long-standing Clause has been a key and guiding piece in our agreement for many many years the language that protects our certified staff that are not on the principal or director's negotiated agreements North Dakota Century code has not changed since our last negotiating session Additionally the North Dakota Schoolboard Association is not telling anyone that they have to remove positions from the agreement the ruling from Fargo states that the districts may consider removing these positions but it does not inherently mean you must remove them this year will be my fourth round as a negotiator for GFA historically when we come together for the first negotiation meetings one of the first

012things the lead board negotiator has said is I want this to be a collaborative conversation it is a real concern that this potential move will force this next round of negoti into a hostile and adversarial tone many of our certified staff on the negotiated agreement feel attacked and feel that the board will do everything in their power to not follow our teacher negotiated agreement if there is a language that you think needs to be changed in our agreement then you bring the proposal to the negotiation table you don't reject our petition that has already agreed upon language and try to negotiate new language outside of negotiations in in the past 7 to 8 months I unfortunately hear more and more from staff on how they are continually losing trust in the district this possible move

013to reject the language the language that has been agreed to will cause even more distrust than people already have who will want to come work and stay in a district where employees don't feel protected and don't feel like they have the Trust In Those Who oversee the district I hope that you make the decision today to gain some of that trust back I urge you to accept our petition to negotiate as is so that we may start this negotiation cycle off on the right foot thank you thank you I have Carla havin did I turn it on very good all right miss gatch Mr Burger and members of the school board my name is Carla Haven and I'm an instructional coach at South Middle school I started working for the grandforks public schools in 1999

014as a curriculum technology partner and now as an instructional coach in both of these roles I have worked hard to come alongside Educators to intentionally support and partner with them I don't think tonight is about questioning if the group of Educators behind me are hard workers who support classroom Educators and students or if this group is not an important part of our schools it's about a ruling in another city that did not really pertain to us but now we are being grouped in with that situation I know none of us want to be considered separate from our colleagues and I don't believe you are questioning that we are Educators however singling us out as a separate group is hard for me to understand we all have current educator license or Griffin would have called most

015of us and said hey your license hasn't expired while we do not have our own classrooms we are in the classroom each day just last week tan and Bill our counselors at South were in the classroom all day presenting on careers as an instructional coach I wear many hats from planning and supporting teachers to providing professional development just to name a few things meanwhile last week at Valley Middle School they celebrated their instructional coach Lisa boek as a certified staff member of the quarter I believe that's like the third instructional coach to be recognized along with other classroom Educators the past few years if the intent is not to include us with our colleagues in the classroom you are now taking away that partnership that we have work so hard to build with them as

016I read through the Supreme Court ruling it stated this court is not free to amend or defend amend or clarify the clear language of the statute and if changes are to be made in the statute we leave that matter to the legislature as is for the legislature to determine that policy not for the courts I understand we have long been grouped with Educators who are employed primarily as a classroom teacher as a collective barging bargaining group and I understand you can decide if you want to include Educators like myself um in the negotiation process in a few minutes you will go to the executive SE into executive session to hear recommendations from the school district's attorney Miss Bruner is asking you to reject our petition and negotiate because of Educators like me and like them

017who are not employed primarily as classroom teachers I am asking at this time for you to accept us to be part of the negotiated group of Educators just as we have always been for many years we need our legislature to revise his policy so we can work together for our students thank you for your time thank you next I have Julia Dost all right my name is Julia duur I'm the president of the swim club at the University of North Dakota we're grateful that the grand for public school district and the central oh sorry hi my name is Julia duur and I'm the president of the swim club at undd we are grateful that the Grand Forks public schools and the Central School District is considering opening their pool to the public this would be

018greatly appreciated by the college Club the USA swimming club and master swimming and the other uh clubs and organizations that use the pool this would be an incredible opportunity for we're an active and growing club we currently have about 35 members practice four days a week and compete with other college clubs we have swimmers of all backgrounds from swimmers who are new to the sport and swimmers that compete at Club Nationals since the Hislop is closing at the end of March we are we and the other teams and groups that use the Hislop will yeah will be out of the pool and would greatly appreciate swimming at the Central High School pool thank you thank you moving on to item five on our agenda uh these are superintendent's recommendations for discussion 5A the demographic Task

019Force update and I believe Dr glat you are taking the lead on this I am I am so Dr brener sends his um regards he apologizes for not being able to be in attendance this morning or this evening um so I'm just going to go from his memo and read from there and then entertain any questions and answer them as best I can so the memo reads as follows first and foremost it is important to know that Mr Schwarz and Dr brener discussed adjusting the timeline which presently suggests a final boundary line recommendation presented to the board on March 17 2025 given the feedback provided by all stakeholders he is recommending that we extend the timeline for this work with an updated and to be determined timeline for final recommendation to the school board in

020other words March 17 2025 is a bit ambitious given all the feedback that has already been provided below is an outline of possible next steps in the overall process that he will talk through um or I will talk through in his absence um so first of all for the plan Evolution we want to make sure that we're taking into account the in-person feedback that uh occurred during the January 15th and 16th live conversations with our community constituents want to make sure that we integrate the social pinpoint survey and just a reminder There's an opportunity for anybody in our community to go on and make suggestions and kind of manipulate the map as far as the boundary proposals go um we want to reconnect regarding the guiding principles and Boundary criteria so Mr Schwarz would actually

021like to meet with the board and kind of reconvene and look at prioritizing the principles that were put forth and from an I guess an internal perspective I think that's really a pivotal um component of our work that needs to be done because much of our debate and when we tweak the boundaries back and forth at one time it's to look at a more neighborhood School concept at the next time we're looking at Equity um as far as social economic balance goes at another time we're looking at etc etc so we really kind of need to Prior prioritize the principles to to move the work forward um some options to look at how we move into the redistricting when that time comes so do we allow um siblings to Trail in do we phase in

022um at different levels um how do we handle our Air Force based students in which school they might attend and slant the um attendance uh accordingly so basically next steps in District administration tasks um we need to make sure the functional capacity validation and the rational behind that which means the number of sections we have the class sizes the data um is understood by everybody okay there have been some discrepancies there and interpretations on the data that's put forth and we want to make sure we clarify that um we have to take a look at the realities of our high schools and how the current boundary lines might be affecting things like programmatic offerings um activities Athletics things of that nature and look at that as a rationale for potential change the data differences I

023already talked about that there's some discrepancies between the internal data that we have in um an external uh dashboard from DPI called North Dakota insights um and really we can't figure out why that discrepancy exists to be honest with you that's the honest answer um so basically the potential to extend the timeline for the process to the board to decide on February 24th um Mr Schwarz will be in attendance at this meeting to lead that discussion so in the meantime we have our next demographic task force tomorrow um that's in the evening and we will talk about all of the things that I just mentioned in this m memo so Dr Brer would consider the above as highlevel items that illustrate District administration and RSP are listening to the feedback and are working towards a

024solution that will provide the appropriate changes addressing the challenges at each grade level just an update for you any questions I can entertain thank you remember this is a agenda item for discussion tonight uh and not action any questions for Dr glatch Dr l just a comment on a question uh clearly none of the other males on the school board got the memo from Mr Anderson and I to wear the same shirt so next time you got to look at your email so we were all wear the same shirt so better at the end of this yeah I'm glad we didn't show up at prom with the same cloth on so um the question is and I didn't see it in here we don't have a new timeline uh as far as when this would

025come back to the board yet uh and and I the answer is going to be yes do do we have a time frame that that changes will be not made in the 2526 school year that we're going to run out of time and and this will be something that would start in 26 27 great question so I believe it's uh an accurate representation that we never really intended U the redistricting to occur as soon as next school year we always looking at the in ensuing school year as the possible first dates so we should have plenty of time to advertise and and inform our constituents other questions for Dr glutch Mr Palin yeah I just have a question you know every couple years we have to have public for that is do is this something

026that we could since the timeline is looking down the road to 26 you know in that year to put together a public for the first part of next year in which we could sit down with people in classrooms like we've done in the past and get all the facts out you know so we aren't you know because a lot of misinformation flies all over when rumors go from rumor to rumors so it would we could incorporate that and we're we're always looking for a subject for the public forum and this might be one of the biggest ones that ground Forex is going to face for a while sure I think we can take that into advisement I think the con of that is if we're looking at making a change you know right now the

027pushes and pulls on our building are real um so that would just prolong that timeline but to your point it would allow for a greater constituency to weigh in so we'll take that under advisement and I don't know if if May is too early to put something like that together but if you could do it before the end of the school year we could still pull that off and as long as you know that would take care of the Forum that we're supposed to have next year if we could have that at that time other questions for Dr glatch Dr hodek yes um I was very appreciative of this memorandum that came out from the administrative team I heard everything from a lot of people in the public about these various things that are in

028that plan Evolution as well as District administration tasks in fact to the board I had 21 people contact me personally um to let me know their concerns and that's why I do feel that when I read this I was very much incouraged I would like to say that um I am disappointed with some of the data and even Katherine with what you're saying about why the dashboard data doesn't Co you know with that but I know that with technology with entry of in information and everything else but I do think that that's critical that when we make an informed decision that we have the exact data that is available and that is out there I am excited about um knowing that Mr Schwarz will reconnect with us as a board so that we can ask

029about some of the things um on how the process has um been followed as well too um I think the one that continues to come up when I run into people and everything else is still the um who selected the task force the demographic task force and not necessarily who but how those um people were selected because there's concern about equal representation so we're parents put on that have children currently in school and so I think that was um uh has been raised as well too so ultimately my you know I really don't have a question I just am really appreciative of extending the timeline I completely agree with what bill has said about to having a public forum so that our public can hear from us and I do believe that that's something that

030we should be able with all the information we have currently that we could um put together and such but again I applaud the team coming up with this so thank you others Mr cevin on the uh the academic predictions like the predictions of academic performance of each of the proposed districts is the method of assessing that has that been consistent over a number of years in other words same tools to come up with out are the same tools we used prior and kather and you seem confused by the phrasing my question so I am I'll apologize I Stumble over my words but in in The Proposal well I I won't even call proposal in the first round of information shared for discussion there was predicted academic outcomes for each of the proposed schools it was

031like a number like 2.0 6 2.03 it was on a scale of 1 to three you discussing the um it's more of the demographic uh correct yes correct yeah that's not about the academic outcomes that was more about the um social economic um capacity of Any Given neighborhood region well I'll I'll be I thought there was an academic component in there but I'll I'll rephrase to be more Broad and more General those that scale is that been the same scale you in previous discussions and is that a consistent metric great question so that scale if we're talking about the same indicator is one that has been caused called into question um from the data U side so we have What's called the North Dakota insights dashboard that reports out on um social economic demographics um

032ethnicity things of that nature different student groups um uh broken down by School area etc etc and that seems to be a bit in competition with the metric that you're describing I think that's one of the things we really need to have our constituents better understand um my understanding of rsps um data is that they look at they take into other considerations besides just free and reduced lunch rates they look at the um uh for example a household income uh in that geographical area the um what a house is worth things of that nature to to get to that overall metric but there seems to be a discrepancy between that and what we see as kids in school so if we're talking about the same indicator Jay I think that's one of the components that

033we really need to make sure that our constituents understand I I don't think we are I'll come back with a better question I just I got to go back look at paperwork look at materials okay thank you other questions for Dr glutch yeah Miss Flynn I um when I was looking on the what do we have to work on still I know it's probably not an all-inclusive list but one thing that I um noticed that was missing from there was um potential effects to access through busing so as we're moving things and shifting things how are our busing routes changing are we potentially adding are we potentially taking away are we um potentially seeing an uptick in those um especially for the boundaries that might draw a little farther away from individuals home so just

034wondering if um our busing company and branded could help possibly give us some data to understand the numbers or or possible projections that way and then of course I think um that probably would have some sort of fiscal impact in understanding that a little more um that was another question that I asked is besides the cost of the consultant or or using um the consultant in the extra Capac capacity are there any fiscal impacts associated with moving boundary lines so other questions okay thank you for that we'll move on to 5B government Affairs committee report uh Miss Flynn I believe you chaired this would you want to lead off here and then perhaps I know Brandon you were there as well and Dr glch you were there but please go ahead sure we met on

035February 6th um there were no legislators present at this meeting um but we went through an extensive list of um bills that were um currently in hearings or had gone through hearings um so we talked about a variety of things that could impact um students and the way we do things in Grand Forks Public Schools um we uh heard from some of the district administrators on their presence um in bismar and testifying on certain bills um and how it might affect um things at Grand Forks Public Schools um there's a list of key legislative actions on um the back here uh what we get every week from school board the N Norco School Board Association and then the district gets from ndcel um is very EXT exensive they follow along very closely um we've gotten

036emails from GFA we've gotten emails from other individuals um on uh certain laws or legislations that are are being proposed um and then we also talked about the timeline of our uh next meetings especially during the crossover um so all of the um legislative actions that we discussed are um their for you to read I won't go over those um we also talked about um re kind of circling back with the legislators um from Grand Forks to determine if there's a better time um because it' be nice to meet with them or have some of our local legislation present um to kind of hear our thoughts about some things as well so um and then lastly um I made an Ask of Dr brener to put together sort of a cheat sheet for board members

037on um testifying if we send in a a statement how do we do it what do we do just because everyone has different levels of experience in doing that so Dr rener said that um he and administration would work on that for board member so others who were at that meeting wish to add or clarify anything okay questions for Mrs Flynn or or this committee from board members all right uh we'll move on to 6A at this time I would ask for a motion to hold an executive session pursuant to North Dakota Century code 44- 04-19 1 2 comma 5 comma 9 and North Dakota Century code 4404 4 -192 for attorney consultation to receive the attorney's advice and guidance on legal risks strengths and weaknesses of an action which if held in public would

038have an adverse fiscal effect on the school district and for negotiation strategy related to descriptions of negotiating units moved it's been moved by Dr Lun is there a second second and then second by Mr clevin we'll take a roll call vote Manley yes Len yes Larson yes palino yes hodak yes clevin yes Flynn yes Anderson yes Berger yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes so at this point uh Grant Forks Public Schools board members uh are going to convene an executive session next door uh so I don't believe the public has to leave or move um we do have in the minutes uh that we've uh given approximately 20 minutes uh for this session really don't know where we're going to land here uh but we will come back in and reconvene U

039the open portion of the meeting um so again a best guess would be 6:55 but I I really can't hold the session to to that length of time it will take as long as it takes e e e the minutes will show that the executive session was adjourned at 7:29 p.m. we we've all convened back together in the meeting room we are now back in Open Session the next item on our agenda is 6B consideration of petition for recognition of appropriate negotiating unit from the gr Forks Education Association uh I would seek a motion to either accept or reject the proposed negotiating unit described in the petition Mr cevin I'll make a motion to accept it's been moved by Mr cevin to accept the proposed negotiating unit described in the petition is there a second

040it's been second by Mr Manley any discussion Miss Flynn sorry I had to run to the bathroom um I uh have been on the negotiating team for the board for four Cycles now I think um since 2016 and we have had some really good conversations with the GFA group we've had some really tough conversations and every year we've been able to work through compromises on some things and understand a little bit more about each other's sides and I um I think that we can work with GFA um to help them understand and the board's perspective and hear them a little bit further I think it would be worth the board bringing this to the negotiating table for language but I don't know that personally I'm in favor of changing anything now so I um plan

041to vote in favor of accepting their petition but I do think that it would be very important for us to have conversations at the board table and to learn more about each side and um I strongly um would ask the board to consider that as the intent of looking at this language um looking at these other positions um you know we we want to recruit all positions and we want to do what's best for the kids and so the ability to be able to have um some flexibility in doing that I think we can figure out with the teachers so that's what I have to say thank you other thoughts questions conversation from board members Dr hodek and on my opinion here first of all I have to say that I am very disappointed in

042North Dakota unite the North Dakota educational Leadership Council and the North Dakota School boards Association as well as espb and the Department of Public Instruction for not handling this and this being dropped on our backs because I want to make sure that every person is represented to the best that they can be represented and when I know that there have been some people that have said well gfea represents us even though I didn't have a say or they don't represent or I have to get my insurance at from another National Organization or anything else that causes me a lot of concern about how they are represented this other group of people out there so um I'm not certain how I will vote until the the motion goes forward and such but I do know that

043I believe the gfea has to be engaged and involved with all of those people so that they do not feel left out and so that we can honor and recognize that yes they want to be a part of gfea because I know after 40 some years in education and having done this that there are teachers that do not believe in what GFA or the North Dakota unite does represent when they do so I know that that is out there and I'm just trying to make the best decision that is best for all and that will equally represent the best education for our students thank you others Dr Len I too I'm going to supp support this motion um and I'll put my other hat on the medical hat I'm tired of the medical hat people

044stealing our medically oriented people in the school district so we have to look at compensation for those people that can go out into Health Systems and elsewhere and get paid a lot more money we've got to Fig figure out how we take care of that group and and and I agree with Amber I I have confidence in NE go both negotiating teams being able to work through some of that others I have just one thought to add and that is um we're really talking about this board's decision for this bargaining unit for this round of negotiations I too look forward to having those conversations uh between uh the board's negotiating team and and gfa's negotiating team uh there's no telling what a board two years from now will do or would do depending on the

045composition of that board uh so it really behooves all of us to land somewhere we're comfortable with moving forward um I believe we can do the work we just have to do the work others there is a motion on the floor to accept the proposed negotiating unit described in the petition and we'll take a roll call vote Larson y Paulino yes clevin yes Len yes Manley yes Anderson yes hodak no Flynn yes Burger yes H yes one no zero absent motion passes the next item on our agenda is consideration of petition for recognition of appropriate negotiating unit gr Forks principles Association I would seek a motion to either accept or reject the proposed negotiating unit described in this petition I move to accept it's been moved by Mr clevin to accept the proposed negotiating unit

046described in the petition is there a second by Mr Manley any discussion seeing none we'll take a roll call Vote clevin Yes Manley yes hodak yes Anderson yes Flynn yes Larson yes Len yes pomino yes Burger yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes 6D consideration of petition for recognition of appropriate negotiating unit grant for director's Association I would seek a motion to either accept or reject the proposed negotiating unit described in this petition it's been moved by Mr Anderson is there a second Mr Mr cevin any discussion we'll take a roll call vote Anderson yes Flynn yes hodak yes clevin yes LaRon yes Len yes Manley yes palmano yes Burger yes nine yes Zer no zero absent motion passes item 6E is our consent agenda I would seek a motion to approve the

047consent agenda as it as it states in your packet it's been moved by Dr L as our second Mr Manley we'll take a roll call vote Anderson yes hodak yes Flynn yes Manley yes Len yes pomino yes Larson yes clevin yes Berger yes nine yes Zer no zero absent motion passes 6f consideration of 2025 2026 joint Powers agreement between gr Forks Air Force based Public School District number 140 and gr Forks Public School District number one for Educational Services uh I chaired this meeting so I'll do my best to uh give you a bit of an overview and then I would uh entertain any comments from others uh we met uh on February 5th of last week and these recommended changes uh are updating dates and some minor language changes uh I believe Brandon could

048help us uh understand some of the current practice as well as some of the things that are coming down the way we're we're in a bit of a holding pattern as it relates to some of the the funding formula pieces uh so I'll defer to you to hopefully illuminate that for the whole board please president Burger members of the board I'm happy to do so um so like again largely the the changes that were made here are are just change of terms which is traditionally what we've seen in this document it has been in the same place for it has uh for years there was just a little bit uh it hadn't been reviewed for a while so we got in front of our attorney and then when we started talking through the functionality of

049it the attorney suggested we include a couple things including on page one or article 4.1 there's an additional sentence about District 140 adopts governing policies of District 1 this has been the practice has been followed for quite some time it just needed to be reflected here in the jpa another example would be clarification on article 4.3 that really it is district one who is employing um the superintendent but then administrative services are being provided to District 140 uh so that same um uh decision it kind of gets reflected here in 4.5 in in reflecting that each board will have representation uh or District 140 will have representation on uh District one's committees that are um listed there and what was included now is the superintendent evaluation committee which certainly District 140 has had a voice

050on um further clarifications in Article Five that just points out U adds a little more detail to that District 140s responsibilities in this agreement including the construction projects of District 140 as well as the maintenance of the buildings we already account for those expenses against District 140 so it better reflects this uh operational costs that support the board um still the case and it is it already reflects a portion of the superintendent salary as well as the business manager salary and this is reflected here in wording and also adds in other administrative salaries and resources for example our our executive secretary and lastly I'll just point out 7.1 uh article 7.1 that each district will obtain carry furnished general liability policy with adequate amounts um that's currently the case we we renew our insurance at

051the same time each year and this just better reflects it so those are largely the changes here some of what president berer mentioned that this this Arrangement could be uh could change and what would bring upon that change is the new Twining um School building really could um want to bolster this agreement to make sure that when District 140 enters into a 20-year debt service agreement that this is reflected on how uh on how that relationship uh is articulated here so more more will come in some time but that project uh won't really be underway during this term of contract through uh next school year anything to add Mr Anderson from that committee any questions for this committee from board members as you can see in the memo uh this got unanimous approval at the

052committee level uh the committee and administrative recommendation is to approve the 2025 2026 joint Powers agreement between gr Forks Air Force based Public School District number 140 and gr Forks Public School District number one as presented I would seek that motion Mr cevin second by Mr Paulino any discussion the workk you any other discussion we'll take a roll call vote Len yes Flynn yes pomino yes Larson yes clevin yes hodak yes Anderson yes Manley yes Berger yes nine yes Z no zero absent motion passes now to 6G uh the first item under 6G construction of excuse me consideration I have skipped one G finance committee report will be first first uh Mr palino do you want to lead this off yeah if you look at the memo uh I'm going to talk a little bit

053about what the committee did and then I think believe Jonathan is going to come up and give you some details if there's any questions and then Brandon will jump in or somewhat in that order but we did uh we had two bids that have come in on Winship and on LS and Clark's enhancement for safety and security they both include additions to the building uh wind ships will be on the uh Northwest side of the building and then Lewis and Clark will also be on the uh Northwest side of their building on the lower end of of Lewis and Clark so it'll be on a drivein if you haven't been to Lewis and Clark lately there's a drive-in pass so that's where those two additions are and we we accepted or as a board made

054a recommendation finance committee to accept both prices and they'll be within follow the the guidelines that we're doing on tier one of the Safety and Security and that was a total of about $18 million which we passed on the bond issue the uh price for the uh me see I think it was wind chip project uh was 14 million or 1 m492 $715 and Louis and Clark was 1,2 108 784 and as a group we asked to do the uh the bit or the uh approval together but at any time if you want to pull out one we could always do that if you wanted to so I don't know Jonathan if you have more of a report on those two that You' like to give thank you Mr Paulino um is is many of

055you noticed in the board packet both of these came in slightly above where we had uh projected them to come in um that has been largely driven by electrical costs um and within that uh low low voltage electrical costs which are proprietary to our fire and communication systems uh so we just didn't properly um scope for those specific pieces which because they're proprietary we only have one option um to work with our current systems in place so uh outside of that I would and for any questions um I would clarify if needed on these two projects or the the Safety and Security project as a whole any questions for this committee or to Mr El Mr cin the uh I'll try the microphone today the uh costs are a little bit higher than estimated yes

056uh but less than 10% and it's a pretty good bid but I have a question regarding project cost that are a contingency as a percent of construction cost I I assume cm's got fees that are percent of construction and the AE firms correct uh the the CM will carry that as soon as we accept the J the GMP we will not have a design contingency anymore but we will have they will carry they will carry a percentage contingency on that looking I don't I know Chad's here I believe it's 5% but I'm not 100% sure well and the question Mor is related to basic fees for service are any of them tied as a percent of construction cost I primarily I'll just cut right to the first that's most consistent The Architects and Engineers fees

057yes the Architects and Engineers fees um we are negotiating them um project by project or as groups of projects um I don't know if Brandon wants to kind of chime in here we had I I do understand that but the point I'm trying to make is the cost of the work came in a little bit higher but it's not an extension of scope or an increase of scope and and the contract is what it is I'm not we can't change it but I think going forward trying to kind of lock in a fixed fee earlier so we're not paying extra money for just Market forces that cost the cost to go up you know it's it's just a point of comment I'm certainly going to approve any motion to accept these because this is good

058work from the construction team and the AE firm so just a point going forward for consideration I appreciate your comment um we will we will look into that and we will report back thank you other questions I just have one comment in case people haven't heard this before when we talk about tier one this isn't necessarily tier one in order of importance or even order of magnit it's just we have them out in different construction seasons is that a fair way to say it we just sometimes we we hear this language and we might think we've we've prioritized but this might just be uh there there are good reasons behind it if you just illuminate those for just a moment yes I'd be happy to do so so we did break them out into teers

059as far as what we thought the the need was based on um our architectural engineering firm as well as a special consultant who came in and made reports uh that we reported on the board to last year for those of you that were here so we broke those into into different tiers on where the need was the highest so we coupled that with um what the highest needs and then which projects were feasible and then also keeping in um in mind prices are going to go up so if we can tackle our highest cost projects first well we're going to save money in the back end so that's kind of how we prioritized which projects uh to go forward with thank you other questions Mr P I think one other point is that Lake Agy

060bids have been received and are being looked at by the uh GM and then also Shader is coming in I believe this week with their prices so that'll be so it'll be an ongoing thing of of getting as many as they can tackle this year any other questions Miss FN can Brandon remind the board and the public about where these funds are coming from like are we kind of under what we had gone to the public with type thing um president Berger um board member Flynn I'm happy to answer that question so this is a part of the May um 2023 referendum that was passed 79 million there were three components to that project or that question to the public Valley Middle School construction Central Kitchen construction and then Safety and Security upgrades across the

061district um largely I we give probably more update here but um largely those projectss are are going really well value midle school is really tracking ahead of budget um Central Kitchen just wrapped up under budget in Safety and Security you uh heard that $18 million number um that board member palino put out there that is our Target and when you look at the the third attachment associated with this part of the finance committee it kind of puts that in context because we don't want to lose um our eye on the prize of the of the budget for this one and so what you'll see there is it's tracking about 18.6 um million doar so just over that budget but it's really early really early yet so we've had just these few projects get bid um

062Red River was the first of those and it came under budget you can we just talked through Lewis and Clark and windship just a little bit over and lake ausy is already promising the bids are in and they're working through those but to be under budget in addition there's contingencies built in there and there's even some assumptions on other buildings that are conservative in nature so I'd say we're we're tracking right on budget with this as well as far as the referendum money goes other questions Dr L I don't have a question but I would moove approval of the guaranteed maximum price of for both loose and Clark and windship as outlined in the memo so there is a motion on the floor to approve both of these uh guaranteed maximum price and total project

063prices as outlined in the memo I can read them if necessary is there a second second by Dr hodek uh again just so we know the motion on the floor uh we're approving uh assuming it passes the motion is uh the GMP of 1.49 2 and a total project 1739 for Lewis and Clark and 1.208 total project of 1. 1420 million for Winship uh that's the motion on the floor and a second is there any discussion I see a microphone on from Mr palino it's off any further discussion take a roll call Vote hodak Yes Larson yes Manley yes clevin yes Anderson yes Flynn yes Pino yes Lun yes Burger yes nine yes Zer no zero absent motion passes uh 6 G2 consideration of change orders seven and 8 for Valley Middle School I think

064I'll let Jonathan you let him walk through it because he can explain thank you thank you president Burger uh in front of you have two change orders uh CPR 07 and 08 we'll just start with 07 and I'll kind of talk you through it um this was $106,000 and $3 change order um which added a comi oven to the kitchen in Valley Middle School um we made this adjustment to align it better with other middle schools in the district uh this would have been the only uh only Middle School that did not have three comi ovens so we added this one and you'll see it's just the addition of the oven which was the ma the major expense in this which was around $50,000 um and then just changing the layout and our electrical um

065costs in order to in order to uh feed that oven uh I would stand for any questions at this time any questions related to uh CPR 07 uh this would be the memo page eight of this line item in your electronic packet any questions from Mr L Mr CL so this is a owner directed change correct um while we were trying to trim down uh trim down our scope in order to meet budget this was one thing we removed and because things came in so favorably we've been adding things back in and this is one of those other questions the administrative recommendation is to approve this change order at a cost of $163 uh I would seek a motion to approve it's been moved by Mr Paulino is there a second second by Mr Manley

066any discussion take a roll call vote Flynn yes clevin yes Anderson yes hodak yes palino yes Len yes Manley yes Larson yes Berger yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes still on 6 G2 this would now be change order 8 for valy Middle School Mr elwi thank you president berer um for change order 8 this was a largely user directed change order um this was asked by both uh Administration and those who would be using these spaces we'll start out with number one layout changes in the mediate Tech area um essentially we changed the um functionality of that space from just being a a say rollup door where people brought in and took out Tech items to more an open space um so we changed the layout with that uh and as as

067well as a storage room so it allowed someone to be sitting out in a hallway to and to have supervisory capability down two hallways um it was it was a in my opinion a good change um and it will be good for our end users uh layout and insulation changes in the admin area this was just a uh a little small shift of the uh uh principal and vice principal rooms in order to better align with the window and while as making a conference room slightly smaller and then additions of uh soundproofing insulation as asked for by those administrators um change in layout in the fax classroom is similar because we had an earlier um change in an exterior framing uh we had to adjust that room to again better align with the windows and

068then insulation changes in the music area um this was asked uh largely we were going to move the day treatment room from Upstairs Downstairs next to the music Suite um we worked with the admin and the admin worked with upper admin um Dr Brer uh Dr gach to to make sure that that would work with the current schedule and this will allow the day treatment room to be more segregated um as well as adding in extra insulation to provide more soundproofing in that area and then number five is just the electrical and mechanical um changes related to all of these the subset of changes uh total cost is 8,245 and I would stand for any questions at this point questions for Mr El it's been a motion to approve change order eight at a cost

069of 8,245 is there a second a second by Mr cevin any discussion we'll take a roll call Vote pomino Yes Manley yes L yes Larson yes clevin yes hodak yes Flynn yes Anderson yes Berger yes nine yes Zer no zero absent motion carries we're now on to 6 G3 consideration of contractor to recommission Grand Fork Central Pool also Mr elne thank you again uh president Burger um so with the hlop coming offline this spring uh we've worked with Community groups and explored many options and uh we decided that our best option was to recommission the pool at Central High School so we had we put out a request for proposals um to get that pool back in working order um so we we received essentially four proposals from two firms we allowed them to submit

070uh proposals that included either replacing uh or recommissioning existing equipment so as you can see on the memo um we had two from Horizon pool and two from Associated pool builders and for Horizon pool we had a replacement with new sand filter system a replacement with a new regenerative media system and from Associated we had a replacement with cartridge or recommissioning of our current uh equipment um we worked with uh I worked with Mr bomach as well as uh Brian STM of V formerly V and Lisa R sad excuse me of Choice Fitness um and talked through these different options and we came in agreement that the best option would be the regenerative media filter um so our administrator recommendation to is is to approve Horizon Pool Supplies regenerative media proposal at a cost of

071$169,500 to the building fund I'll stand for any questions questions from Mr elne oh a comment first from Mr bomach yeah I appreciate the opportunity um president Berger members of the board I've had the opportunity with with Mr elwi and and a number of different groups I'll point out in a second and I I just wanted to kind of celebrate this conversation there's been a lot of work that's gone into this um you know when bricks are popping off the building before due to some of the the issues involved with that pool and it was initially shut down we we looked at different estimates of what it might cost and and we really saw a wide range as much as multiple millions of dollars to really fix that pool properly um other Alternatives that were

072explored was was Community Partnerships even broader than our community uh with the Air Force Base and kooken pools and we looked at okay if we don't have the pool here uh with Hislop being coming down offline where would we swim where would we dive and although those were options um they became challenging as kirton changed Direction with their own pool and even uh they certainly weren't without costs associated uh to drive to have the extra time to think about the the burden even on those students making those trips but where we continued to um explore was within our community and our Community Partnerships so we worked with the groups most affected not just the students that were swimming and Diving but our community groups who you might see represented here in the audience our waho

073our Dakota Masters Safe Kids and Beyond and so when Administration really began to consider this idea of bringing the pool back online to make sure there wasn't going to be a gap for our swimmers we realized the importance of making sure there wouldn't be a gap for the community we didn't want to let a couple of years slip by where students weren't getting the swim lessons that they needed uh and Beyond there are other partners in the community but just not enough water so um it has been a community approach from the start um and I would say that has helped even in the economical nature of this fix it's no longer millions of dollars um what we can do here with a lot less a lot fewer dollars to bring this pool online and

074operate for a short term is um significant one those Community groups will help facilitate swim lessons Etc and access to the facility and they will share in the operational costs which is a tremendous um partnership with them uh further the regenerative filter you talked about it was in key consideration of knowing what the marketability of that product would be when the pool gets turned off what do we do with that we don't want to throw good money after bad we want to make sure it's repurposed and we even see the possible partnership with the park district of seeing if that could fit at a Riverside pool which we know is coming so we've really done some due diligence to plan ahead and make this um Thrifty and really a community approach so lastly I would

075just say thanks to all those Community Partners starting with UND and what the hlap has done for the community for so many years to the city and the park district for what it will do for all the coming years with the all true sports complex and then all these key Partners uh who have come through walked the facility with us and helped us make sure there wasn't a gap in the community so thank you for letting me um underscore those points questions for Mr elwi or Mr bomach Dr l i too would want to Echo the the great Community Support that it's a great partnership that shows how it can work when you get a group of interested people together with the same goal my my one quick and Brandon kind of teased it a

076little bit but the the intent of this is to be used for two or three years and then we be decommissioned once the alt complex is up and running am I correct I'm correct yeah we see this as a stop gaps uh solution not a long-term solution um simply because of how the the humidity and the air damaged the building before we have some we have some plans to mitigate that but it's not a uh say long-term 5 10e plan um other questions yes Mr Manley uh we went on the tour of that building recently is there a way to keep the general public in a certain area or out of certain areas that that we don't want them in because we took that path in and it was pretty wide open to Yes actually

077there is the way the doors are currently set up um I did a walk through just to make sure and even without having to make any changes to the building we can segregate that pool from the rest of the building it will just have to involve um extra checks by our custodial staff to make sure doors are locked other questions Miss Flynn I have like six questions so um I didn't see a pool cover on the sheet what's the plan for covering the pool correct we will be ordering a pool cover but as that is not a um part of a project or a piece that is uh fasten to the building it's not eligible for building fund dollars okay do we know how much that will cost yes approximately uh $23,000 okay thank you

078and who's responsible for maintenance of the pool uh we will be responsible for maintenance of the pool um we are we are in talks with someone to essentially run the pool day by day um from an operational standpoint not not necessarily from a scheduling standpoint um but we will uh be responsible for upkeep so would that be an additional position that would be hired potentially uh I'd love to talk about this because it's another one of these Community Support efforts um Brian strom's name was mentioned before used to run un's Hislop facility and is now in retirement and he too has invested in seeing that there isn't a gap where this community doesn't have enough water for all of its users and so he is um willing to to monitor the pool and be involved

079on a contract basis and I can tell you it's really a lot less than we anticipated it would cost and I think that just says a lot about how invested he is in it okay um who would be responsible for supervising the pool for safety so when Community groups are using it are we potentially doing an mou where they have who covers the insurance Etc yeah and we're we're uh in ation to that contract we had our attorney draft a contract and then working with our community users are are responding to that um we're still working out the details and exactly that but we've covered these subjects and so certainly insurance coverage has been agreed to um these groups already carry their own insurance that isn't a problem there's life card responsibilities um when these

080user groups are in there there's other life- saving measures that need to be considered you think about the buoy on the wall and the aeds and such and that's where Grant Forks public schools has agreed to provide those okay um someone mentioned in the public comments that und's pool is going offline in March 2025 I thought it was the summer yeah right now we it's March um we haven't had an update on that to the to the contrary uh so there will be a small Gap so our community groups have been talking with the parks district and we have been talking with the parks District to hopefully try bridge that small Gap until we get back online Al we're trying to find if there's any Avenues to accelerate this uh project at all okay um

081and then swim meets I know that there's like the pool in the pool area are a bit smaller than like UND where they had some before are we are we looking at what we're going to do for like Meats is there going to be limited Meats how does that work I don't know if we're the very best people to answer that um certainly our activities director Mike beer would be the best and and Dr Gad if you want to jump in but you know largely they'll operate like they did prior to um we were here when the pool was operating and so I think it was really much more like duels than than meets and I'm outside of my swim Lane on this one so I it just came to me you're sinking yeah you

082got a thumbs up from Dr glatch so I think you covered it well despite my commentary my um other question is uh so we talked about ongoing costs so there's potentially going to be a contract for someone are we going to have higher utilities for water are we going to have pool chemicals that we need to buy do we have an idea of what the scope of the operational costs are going to be outside just the 169,000 um I'll also mention that I have a lot of questions about this one because I was pretty ill that night and couldn't come two I'm I am very surprised at the amount of money that it cost being so low compared to what I thought it was going to be so I very much support this but I

083want to make sure that the board is having these conversations so my last two questions are do we have a scope of what we understand the operational cost to be and then do we have an idea of what possible income revenue is going to be and how that might offset those operational costs yeah I can take the first piece and I'll add Brandon and take the second um so annual operation I've got some estimates in here I'm carrying a $43,000 line item uh for filters Energy Water Testing labor and chemical as well as a $12,500 uh line item for maintenance anything that that might come up so essentially about $55,000 a year to operate okay and as far as that agreement goes again working through the contract feel like those conversations have been very positive

084and we've really largely agreed to a split that's that's reflective of the usage so we look at the usage actually gr Forks Public School swimmers would be in the minority of this to the tune of 80% to 20 and so we've kind of taken that principle and applied it to those operating costs and we've already come to an agreement in that in spirit I mean we're just working through the final pieces but I would say um you know the Wahoo's Group which is the actual entity would be contracted with and reflective of all the other groups said we think that's reasonable uh in the first year knowing that um we may not get the pool open in time to really gather all of the revenues they could collect so they hope to do more in

085future years so we're not painting them down on that it's just feels like a real great partnership to make this work okay thank you other questions Mr palino I I think just to answer a little bit Amber on on the difference between 3 400,000 and one1 or2 million I think when we looked at it originally we were looking long-term and we were looking at taking walls down and putting up new walls with inside the pool I think people have to understand the pool will be what it was it'll look just like our tour when we walk through it it'll be like that with the lunchroom tables out of there and then filled with water but there'll be less the cover will take care of the humidity to a point but if we were going to

086do a long term then you would have had to replace walls and do that so they can absorb that humidity a long term so that's why the price went way down feel like I need to clarify the the lunch table piece so uh John John strandell was explaining that during covid they needed more tabl spread further apart uh to get everyone when they when they returned to inperson instruction and then this decommission pool became the storage for Central's excess lunch tables and then storage for the district's excess lunch tables it's not like we're planning an additional cafeteria but uh but I there must be a plan for where they're going you don't have to illuminate that now I I trust there's a plan other questions for Mr cevin just a a point of comment the

087extra 9 or so thousand for the regenerative media is totally worth the money it's that's the best choice here so in that I'm going to strongly concur with the recommendation of the billing committee any other questions Dr L there's been a motion to approve Horizon Pool Supplies regenerative media proposal at a cost of 16955 to the building fund is there a second second and second by Mr Anderson any further discussion we'll take a roll call vote Manley yes Anderson yes hodak yes clevin yes Larson yes palino Flynn Len yes Berger yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes 68 consideration of s f sfn 5234 application to Department of Public Instruction for GR Fork Central Pool recommissioning this would be Mr bomach yes president Burger members of the board um for any project that

088exceeds a threshold of $150,000 we need to let Department of Public Instruction know that we're doing that and then seek their approval on that so this is the paperwork to do just that so the administrative recommendation is to approve the sfn 52304 and then the administration can get that submitted to DP for their consideration any questions from Mr bomach so it's been moved by Mr to approve sfn 52304 and direct the administration to submit to DPI for consideration is there a second second and second by Mr Larsson any discussion we'll take a roll call vote Len yes pomino Flynn yes Anderson yes clevin yes Manley yes Larson yes hodak yes berer yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes 6 I consideration of building fund use for GR Fork Central High School pool Expansion

089Joints it's Mr elwi thank you president berer for bearing with me um so this is related to our our previous discussions about the pool um this is just the first step in recommissioning that pool which is to replace the expansion joits within and outside of the pool um this came at the recommendation of our uh of our experts that we spoke to including some including uh some that bid on this project project and they recommended that we actually pull this out of that scope and bid it separately to prevent being prevent markup costs that they would have to charge us um so we we talked to a number of firms um and we we worked with new life restoration to come to a scope and a quote on that which came out to $1,525 and

090our uh administrative recommendation is to approve $1,525 of building fund dollars for the replacement uh of pool Expansion Joints at Central High School I will stand for any questions questions for Mr elwi seeing done i' seek a motion to approve $1,525 building fund dollars for the replacement of pool Expansion Joints at Central High School it's been moved by Dr hodc second by Mr Manley any discussion take a roll call Vote hodak Yes clevin Yes Manley yes Larson yes Flynn yes L yes Anderson yes palino Berger yes nine yes Z no Z absent motion passes item 7A announcements are there any announcements from board members staff Administration anything for the good of the whole 7B board requests for future consideration any requests from board members 7c Schoolboard meeting Norms Mr Larsson how did we do your

091microphone your microphone other than me cursing at Amber inside for having six questions we did very well thank you very much we are adjourned e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.