001e e e call to order the regular meeting of the school board for Monday January 13th one note Dr brener is joining us via telephone this evening first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance ask you to rise as you able 1A the reading of our Schoolboard meeting Norms Mr Paulino be prepared be on time value and respect each other exercise thoughtful deliberation and conversation be professional at the board table and when visiting with the general public speak up when the Norms are not being followed advocate for behalf of students and keep to community and mine thank you item two the approval of our agenda this evening I would entertain a motion to approve tonight's agenda it's been moved by Mr Paulino is there a second second second by Mr Manley we'll take
002a roll call Vote clevin Yes Manley yes hodak yes Anderson yes Flynn yes Larson yes L yes pomino yes and berer yes n yes zero no zero absent motion passes thank you item three celebrating success we have various members of Winship Elementary School with us this evening we'll lead off with Mr Travis thoron thank you very much for having us it is really a pleasure to be here and it's a pleasure to be here with this Winship team as well they'll all have a a part in tonight's presentation uh so thank you for this conversation um you know I I did tell them take a deep breath we don't have to worry about getting nervous uh we don't have to you know I first thought we'd have to hurry up to get Dr brener home
003uh so that he could watch the Bengals game but it turns out you know they're not playing so uh I don't feel any pressure at all uh to present here whatsoever uh he just told me to tell you that hurts a little bit it's the same for Mr baky he was going to stay home tonight to watch the highlights of the Packers game but there are no highlights of Packers you know I I look I looked on uh dpi's web page uh when it comes to uh be legendary you know what it meant what's the big picture and it's this you know this great alignment between school boards superintendents District leaders and school-based teams like ours and it talks about the singular focus of student achievement student outcomes and uh they use two words sharpen
004and cultivate how do we sharpen and cultivate our focus and so I really hope that the stories we tell about our children who they are and who their families are uh what kind of growth they have how are they achieving and and what we intend to do to help them succeed resonate with you and help you sharpen and cultivate your focus uh for our school I'm pretty excited about that so we'll we'll start just with mission and vision and then get into demographics and way we go hi I'm Chrissy Dy I'm the ml teacher one of the ml teachers at Winship um the vision is up here but really um meaningful experiences and bringing meaningful experiences fostering curiosity and then um taking risks not only our students but also our teachers um we really encourage
005that and our mission we just truly want to enrich the world so thank you I'm going to leave this slide up here just for a moment before I talk about demogra Graphics because these these are our children these are our colleagues and uh you'll see quite a few pictures throughout the evening um that look like the world that surrounds us there's a lot of diversity in our school you'll you'll see that throughout the evening here's what our organization looks like for tonight we'll go through those four parts uh demographics Ela math attendance pbal and then we added a section um that we're calling imp impacting growth things that we might do um or have a philosophy about um that are different because of our children and our families we're excited to share that with you
006I I would uh be neglectful if I did not add a thank you to miss Jess borer you'll probably recognize some of the structure in uh from past um schools that we're presenting and she was really instrumental and was a great guide and was a great leader for us and and really spent a ton of time so if you know Miss Jess uh sbert she's just a a wonderful asset to our our school community and she spent lots of time with us here's who we are we have 36 certified staff that includes our classroom teachers this includes our ml teachers multilingual teachers our special education teachers this includes literacy this includes our Specialists including library media Specialists our social studies uh PE uh music uh this includes counselor uh social worker it also includes a
007number of staff that we share with other schools or that are transient between buildings like is common within our District 36 of those certified staff members and then we have 22 classified staff members that includes kitchen custodial uh office staff and of course all of our wonderful uh pairs we don't have any program pairs that you maybe have heard other schools speak about all of our paas are either inclusion paas uh Library pairs or other pairs of such we have 21 students uh we're in 12 general education classrooms this year uh we had a little bubble in in our kindergarten numbers so we have one section of pure K and then a section of K1 combo other than that we have two sections of grade levels one through five you can see our low income
008uh percentages almost 70% um historically that will be uh nor of 70% for our school um our ml students make up about 37% of our population you'll hear more about that uh later that's a huge component of our school that that does set us apart from almost all other uh elementary schools in our community and then our Special Education team and our classroom teachers serve uh our students with I APS um they make up about 17.6% of our students right here for you thank you I'm Logan Casta the school social worker at windship um and really what I want to tell you as we look at the ethnicity and the student population uh these are just the numbers of the kids that we serve every day but truthfully we're telling you the story about them
009and how it creates windship so as you can see there's a lot of diversity up there um related to ethnicity and the demographics just by that population Alone um and so it brings a lot of uniqueness to Winship um I'm really sharpening my Spanish speaking skills and things they're teaching me a lot there that I think kind of shapes what we do um every day when we look at our special student populations for ML um lowincome and mckin vinto uh the Unique Piece of it there and how we found those kids I guess would be kind of something that is unique to windship in that we do home visits every year uh myself with the ml teachers and sometimes the classroom teachers as well um and many of those families had marked that they had
010permanent housing on their enrollment form but what we found when we got there was a lot different families doubled up 14 people living in one house homes that weren't maybe fit for human habitation with no heat maybe no Refrigeration things like that and those were things that we would not have known about had we not gone into the home because to a lot of those families they felt like that that was truthfully um stable housing and we know that that's probably not the case for that it also impacts what we do as a whole in that we have a lot of things that we cater to our families so that they can feel that there's equity for them so Winship has a food pantry that they families and students have access to uh we also
011ensure that our kids have their winter gear so all the schools do that but some of our families don't know how to access that any other way um other than coming to the school and working with our classroom teachers or myself um and then really when families need something um I definitely am headed to their home or texting or having them come in because a lot of our families don't know how to access the community and that's definitely something that we do is help them access the things that are out there for them through us at Winship sorry guys um this picture up above just shows um that multilingual students at Winship so we currently have 78 multilingual students as you can see they're from all over the world um many different languages and again
012some of our students speak more than two languages um and um in the past the nepales population was our largest population but in the last two years you can see Central and South America has become um the largest population um District wide with our Spanish speaking students um also um just this diversity and then you think of the families and the siblings and the parents that come it brings so much culture and diversity and richness into not just windship but into Grand Forks into our district it's truly a blessing um to have these families in our community in our schools uh you can see this is a breakdown when a ml child comes or they get um their language proficiencies are are in six levels a level one being entering with little to no English
013all the way to a level six which is reaching they use social and academic language at their highest level at Winship 15% of our ml students are um entering so they come to us with little to no English um and a third of all the level one students um in the district are at windship so um that's a big impact in our school we've come to realize um just how critical it is to collaborate to scaffold to collaborate schoolwide from classroom teachers to ml teachers um to reading specialist um to interventionist to Paras it's huge because um the goal is no matter what amount of language they have we want them in the classroom we want them with their peers learning hearing all that academic language so scaffolding is really big and the collaboration that
014we do is huge uh the second graph is language proficiency Levels by grade so you can see um we have in every classroom at least two level one students so where they came to us with little to no English all the way to level twos level threes and we have some fours and some fives um so the impact that the teachers have working together is like again I said very critical um a level five or I'm sorry a level one student in fifth grade has a larger Gap than say a kindergarten or a first grader that comes with lower language so that Gap that we need to fill um is more uh more critical or um more apparent in the older grades uh but again we've learned and we've come to learn that that collaboration
015is so key uh because they are making huge growth in the gains they make um the third graph it shows us the growth so um the English language Learners they're growing the trajectory in which they're growing the growth that they're making is um what is expected for them to exit the program so windship uh definitely is showing huge growth compared to even District or Statewide so that's the growth compared to themselves in the next few um slides When Miss bean and Mrs berer come up looking at the ELA proficiency by grade level even though our ml students are making huge growth they're not proficient at their grade level but that's just part of our story right where our children have come from how far they've come how much they're growing and where they're going to
016go is so much more to our story than just this or the next few slides um so I'm really proud of our team and yeah Cassidy and Kristen come on up is there any questions I'm sorry I should ask you if there's any questions with demographics so far before we move into Ela yeah go ahead Mr pal do you see uh more kids coming during the school year or you see the number come at the beginning and you stay with that yes so last year the last last two years there was a huge influx throughout the year um of students coming throughout the year um and then thankfully um our district noticed that and they made some adjustments so Lake aacy became an ml student U ml school um to help with that because our
017numbers grew drastically very quickly um so I'm we're very thankful for the district seeing that need um but this year it hasn't been it's been a slow at windship I should say the other ml schools they've seen um ml attendance are starting schools not just at the beginning of the year so they're still kind of coming in um throughout the year but we haven't seen it as much this year Winship yeah other questions before we move on okay thank you for the pause I appreciate that yeah all right my name is Cassidy Vina I better adjust this Cassidy beina I'm A literacy specialist at windship hello I'm Kristen berer I'm the second literacy special list at Winship so Kristen and I work together and today we'll be sharing some data um regards to our English
018language assessments and some of our data that we um we collect for literacy and our school's literacy plan so windship teachers collaborated and did some work into digging into our data and our past ndsa scores uh with the goal of an 8% growth proficiency increase so if you can see on here we have our 2022 38% growth in our students and then in 23 24 which was just last year a 34% growth and then our teachers all met and decided upon what would be a good growth goal per year for the next few years to get to 2028 which is 46% proficient so you can see the trend line there and um the progression that we would like to make for our school and these are some of the ways that we are going to
019ensure that we get there as a building um these inputs uh will help us with our Ela growth goals and supporting literacy within our classroom so a few of the things that for sure we really would like to highlight are the the top one District curriculum is taught with Fidelity in a tier one level that means all students are getting all of the same materials curriculum and access um and then the other one that is a big one in our building is the targeted small group instruction we call that tsgi and with that those are different approaches to meet all the needs of all the students at different parts of the day here are some other inputs that we would like to recognize for opportunities to support our school in the area of literacy um
020the top one being that we have two literacy Specialists which is unique to um some of the schools in our district not all schools have the two literacy specialist but we're lucky enough to do that because we do have some Dynamic needs and even though our population doesn't show it our needs definitely show that we have to support these students that are coming in in the best way possible so Kristen and I are the two literacy Specialists and the other one is the data meetings at every PLC and data digs after each assessment window our teachers really work hard um in these powerful opportunities to help our students grow in their academic needs and these are ways that we can ensure our instructional approaches and our their needs can be met and implemented um during
021these times of the day and then here we have our Ela outcomes through ndsa this is current data that reflects the percent proficient in third grade in blue red is our fourth grade and then fifth grade is in yellow and it shows a little bit of a trend from 2020 to 2024 uh um the left side graph we look at as uh as our current year and we reflect on what we can do to help those students as they move up to different grade levels and on the right side you see the trend that we follow the pattern of each grade level so we look at our third graders from 2021 and as they grow as fourth graders and fifth graders so we we try to really track um those patterns of growth and find
022areas that we can um help close the gap and this chart will show our student populations and the percentage proficient um in 22 to 23 and then 24 as well um one thing to highlight is we have the green population of students who have met our growth goal already for the end of 2025 which is 37% proficient for this year um and the other populations you see we have a gap to fill and like Mrs dwey said the these students we really we really celebrate the growth each and every day uh that number doesn't tell their story but it does give us some more um inside into what we really need to focus on in the classroom to help these students grow and be successful on these State assessments all right I'll turn it over
023to Mrs berer she's going to share a little bit more about our star data yes hello so um next I'm going to take you through our star growth data um by grade and as I think Mr thorvilson said earlier we have two sections um of each grade level so um when you're looking at our kindergarten data here if you look below where there's a one and a two that's simply um dividing into the two different sections of kindergarten that we have and then it is totaled in that third column there so what you're seeing is um on the left letter sound fluency that's our star CBM so that's our curriculum based data um blue is where we began in the fall and and then winter was our most current data um so you can see
024in kindergarten we've had incredible growth there and then on the right is our star early literacy assessment which is also through star starcat which is a computer adaptive test um and our District's goal by the end of the year is to be at 50% proficiency um and in this specific assessment um there is some literacy and math questions um within so as I take you through each grade level um you'll kind of see the same format there so this is kindergarten at windship and then here is first grade um as we mentioned before there is one combo class so you will see that third combo um in the data as well for some of those first graders that are um with the Kinders and uh once we're into first grade we're going to be um
025talking about the oral reading fluency from 1st through 5th so basically are they proficient enough to read um a grade level text uh within 1 minute so you can see the two different uh sections of first grade there and then the total showing growth and then um you may start to see the stars on the bottom and those Stars denote the Wht and wisdom classrooms um that are pilot piloting that curriculum this year so if you look at star early literacy that's similar to um well that's actually identical to what kindergarten takes as well so you can see growth and um Mrs Bea and I look at this data and help us guide um who needs help and how and I'll continue on here is a look at second grade again with the oral reading
026fluency on the left from growth from fall to winter and then on the right is a star reading test which is the first year that second graders take this um or students I should say take this specific test and both of our sections of second grade are piloting the Whitten wisdom curriculum this year uh the same here in third grade with the oral reading fluency the two sections of third grade with fall to winter growth and then again that red line showing where our end ofe hope would be for that 50th percentile and we do not have any third grade piloter this year but we do have one in fourth grade that you'll notice on the right for Star reading and again the oral reading fluency from fall to winter and finally our fifth grade
027data for the growth in oral reading from fall to winter and then also their star reading cat test uh is there anything Ela related that Cassy and I can answer before we move on to math Mr clevin the the star reading that's not the assessment goal though right that's a the B legendary the metric's a different test correct yes yep it's separate from B legendary which is the NDA plus yes so this data is just used for like historical tracking and yes yes yep of course also a predict it's a predictor for us to see you know how might they do on that ndsa sure assessment so it helps us and it guides us yeah other questions from board members yes Miss CL move my chippers out of the way um I have two questions
028my first one is um since Whitten wisdom is being piloted curious about how it's um piloted at windship with a large ml population and maybe if the program is set up as such to um maybe manage ml populations um and then my second question which may or may not be both of you is um really just looking at um the ml population in terms of uh parent teacher conferences so um when we're going through some of these things um I think like any parent especially when you're in kindergarten is like hey what are all these assessments and where's my Kida and so um just curious about um language barriers and how those conversations go too absolutely um in regard to the wit and wisdom I think just like Mrs dwey talks about a lot it's
029all about collaboration and I'm really proud of our team at Winship our teachers are very thorough about looking ahead at what's to come um there's a lot of pre-teaching that can happen um a lot of um collaboration or I guess correlation of topics um if there maybe was a unit on the heart then teachers are really good at talking to the ml teachers and saying hey let's find these vocabulary words let's pre- it let's find videos in Spanish Let's um you know see what kinds of different opportunities we can have for these kids and what's wonderful about W wisdom is it is language-based there's so much vocabulary which is good for all kids right and so I think that's really helped us serve all children as well the focus on vocabulary language um oral language
030and speaking um there I believe there is an ml component to the wit and wisdom um which we've dabbled in a little bit but again it's just really good teachers making smart decisions about what the kids need and so far so good the language that I've heard in the classrooms is quite spectacular things that I hear fourth graders talking about and how eloquently um and even feeling that safe space to be able to speak out loud has been pretty pretty great and they all are accessing the same curriculum and so they're in there for all of it that is a very sacred time that we have them in the room and we make sure that no students leave during that time so it's it's pretty powerful yes and I don't know if Mrs do he
031wants to elaborate on conferences as well or testing and things like that but we do utilize voyance uh the translation system uh quite frequently um and we are lucky enough to have one um one of our ml teachers is fluent in Spanish which is you know kind of our most prevalent language aside from English um and then what we do is we are pretty great about taking the most important parts and using a lot of visuals for those families and checking and double-checking that they understand um what it is that we are proud of um things that we're working on and just celebrating their successes that's perfect thank you other questions from board members on this section okay thank Youk you thank you all right my name is Stephanie Krueger I kind of have a
032unique position at Winship my title is a math collaboration teacher um and we'll talk a little bit more about what that is and what I do specifically um but I'm here to talk about our math goals um like Ela we collaborated as a staff to look at our goal for growth in proficiency and math through the 20 27 2028 school year uh we're looking to reach 38% proficient um B September of 2028 as measured by ND NDA plus and that's our kind of trajectory that we're looking at all right here are some ways that we're working on increasing our Proficiency in math as a school so my position is a title funded position um I'm a math collaboration teacher because I kind of get the best of both worlds I don't pull out kids to
033do interventions like our um English our reading interventionists do instead I get to do some intensive work with teachers and I collaborate with them every week to plan for the week ahead uh we have a co- teing model in grades 2 through five so I'm joining classrooms every day to support students with differentiation or um sometimes I lead the class and the classroom teacher might take a small group to do differentiation in the moment uh that looks like maybe providing manipulatives that they might need in order to complete the math um giving higher levels of support or completing things as a group um and then during our math collaboration meetings we kind of talk about how that's going how kids might shift around or what the next thing we're looking at doing is are doing
034in our math lessons uh we also use that time to analyze data so when we get those star scores in we can look at where where our kids are and where we might need to go next and we've also taken a deep dive into instructional strategies so we talk about things like what manipulatives might be helpful here what background knowledge do we need to make sure kids have before we can move on to this next step um is there any lessons that we maybe need to stretch out or condense to make sure that we're getting kids the information they need and they have enough practice we've also renewed our focus on vertical alignment between grade levels so since I get to join all the grades 2 through five I can say to the second grade
035teachers hey next year in third grade they're really going to need this concept to be solid so let's make sure we're focused closely um we also talk about using vocabulary that's the same from vertically between grades so that kids are familiar with the structure and when they hear that word again in third grade they know oh yeah we talked about that in second grade and because I join all those grade levels I have a chance to share that with teachers and kind of align that a little better um we've used title funds to shore up physical math supplies so lots of manipulatives um we use cards a lot to practice like our math facts and things and we noticed that we needed to kind of shore up those materials we've also bought some new tools
036and a digital fa fact fluency platform that are used daily and that's what we've um used our title funds for to support in math uh another thing that I've been really passionate about in my position is the correlation between social emotional learning and math um we've really renewed our focus on the connection between our thinking and feelings about math and how we do math um I say up here more than counting arithmetic and memorization math is the act of problem solving and so if our students see themselves as problem solvers who are capable of doing the math um then we have a little higher success rate and kids are more willing to take a take a risk and attack the math challenges using lots of different strategies um and then I put a little quote
037here that I think kind of speaks to this which is whether you think you can or you think you can't you're right and we want our kids to think and know that they can um similar to ELA we have some data here for math outcomes on the ndsa again the blue represents third grade fourth grading red and then yellow is fifth grade um we do have some variable data here and again we're working hard myself as a collaboration teacher and all of our classroom teach fees on how we can keep this going in an upward trajectory on the other side the green arrows are just tracking a cohort of students so the third graders when they were in fourth grade to fifth grade and of course we want to see those proficiency levels go up
038as they move through uh this is some breakdowns by our student population the green is indicating that those students have met our 2025 end of the year goal based on the star predictor we don't have um ndsa results because we haven't taken that test yet um but these we're hoping that these star scores are going to help us predict how they might perform on that NDA plus test um of course we have some more work to do but I am encouraged to see growth even from the beginning of the year just to our progress monitoring in November and these numbers are indicating the per percent of students who were proficient any questions about math any questions on this section okay thank you very much okay so I get to walk you through the next portion
039that I'm super passionate about um obviously as a social worker we're focusing on the whole child um but at Winship I'm not the only one that does that and so I think for us we really work as a team and process through that so one of the things that you're going to see throughout here are um the clear and consistent expectations and this year really we dove into that with creating some good behavior Matrix for our students that um our staff will talk a little bit more about later um so that we all are being consistent and have the same language used with our students K5 the first part is our attendance school and really what we're looking for is our kids to be in the seats so that they can learn um and what
040are we doing about that and how are we getting them here is one of the the largest portions so what are what are our inputs what are we doing to get our students here um relationships are key if you don't have a relationship with that student and you don't have a relationship with that family you're not going to get very far uh and that's something that we are doing all all of the time to help our families feel like school is a place that their children are safe that they feel safe that they are connected to um our families that feel safe with us are willing to have tough conversations are willing to tell us things that are barriers for their students to come to school and then we can work on them if we
041don't know what's going on we can't help um so we're also regularly having contact with students and families about attendance cesa message Mees phone calls conversations a pickup um and then myself I'm now at Winship 5 days a week versus three and that will be important to note just as we go a little bit further with our attendance data um so at this time last year we have made a great increase on our students that have attended um last year at this time we had 45 out of our 25ish students chronically absent um and when this data was was pulled for this year we only have 24 so the decrease of students who are chronically absent is huge at windship and we're seeing that we're feeling that even some of our chronic offenders kids that
042have been chronically absent since kindergarten might still be chronically absent but it's less less days that they're missing I really attribute that to myself being able to be there every single day I can watch that attendance data um I can see and get into homes more regular because of my time isn't being split um the home visits again I created packets to give to those ml families with resources for them um and then our ml teacher who speaks Spanish translated some of that for them just really to increase the realization that school is important with our ml families and all of our regular kids just like you have to get to school um and if we look at our outcomes here on the next page so we have had 137 of our students have attended
04395% or more days of school which is amazing we are getting our kids to school and when they're there they can learn kids can't learn if they're not in the not in their seat um but we are seeing some populations that are having a higher chronically absent rate one of those being our um Hispanic or Latino families so right now out of those 24 students that are chronic chronically absent 15 of them identify as Hispanic or Latino um and 11 out of those 15 have limited to no English so we are seeing that impacting them coming to school and I attribute a lot of that to the um barriers that they're facing being here in country if they have little to know English their parents might have little to know English school may not have
044been important to them so really educating our families that we want them here we want to be a part of your journey As you move forward um some of the other things that we do that I think are are really great are the parent engagement events that we do throughout our year each of the grade levels has one getting the parents into the building how can we make you feel like you're safe how can we make you feel like you're a part of what's going on for your children's education um because families are key in in all of this I'm going to hand it over to um Megan who's going to talk more about our PBIS and what we're doing on that front good evening my name is Megan Baker and I am the social
045studies teacher at Winship this year as well as an administrative intern working with Travis um my role tonight is to share theal and PBIS goal that we've adopted this year to help support students in their learning and their development um you'll see on this slide uh we have our goal up here um our overall PBIS goal this year is to decrease Behavior referrals by 50% um by implementing our behavior intervention flowchart with Fidelity this flowchart has been very helpful in determining which behaviors can and should be managed by our teachers in the classroom and then which behaviors should be following the referral process and reaching our Administration by following this Behavior flowchart schoolwide there has been a clear and consistent process for all staff for students to follow um as these behavior issues arise in
046addition to following the behavior flowchart our school has focused on many inputs uh this year to promote the Positive Behavior Uh few of the inputs implemented our weekly seal lessons in each class our Roar postcards to recognize and reinforce positive behavior weekly counseling lessons for all of our grade levels monthly assemblies to recognize positive student Behavior as well as visits to St an's Assisted Living Center down the street from us to build connections with senior citizens in our community in addition to the inputs that I just explained um our Behavior team has worked very closely over the last year to create a schoolwide behavior Matrix that all students have been explicitly taught um and are expected to follow each day this Matrix has been very helpful for students and for staff because expectations are exp
047explained and they change throughout our building depending on where students are um during class meetings and monthly assemblies we take time to review the expectations in the different areas of our school we also take time to teach about the different voice levels that there are when they'd be appropriate to use in different parts of our building what line Basics look like when you're lining up to go to PE what they look like when you're waiting for your teacher to pick you up from lunch um what our body Basics look like when we're on the carpet versus what they look like when we're sitting at our seat um and then reminding students to use their manners but some of our students may not know what manners look like so explicitly teaching waiting your turn requesting asking
048not just expecting the first time that you ask for something and teaching what active listening and learning look like um we've also had to really talk to some of our students about apologizing and what that looks like and how that how that uh is important to our relationships in the classroom um but by teaching this Behavior matri Matrix explicitly all students and staff really understand what's expected in every part of our school um and what we found through the conversations with staff as we were making this is like wow we really need to hold each other accountable too that you know if we see a class walking through the hallway and they're not out of volume zero like it's important for us to be a able to have that open communication so that we're reinforcing
049this K through five because this is language that we want kindergarteners to use as well as fifth graders from start to finish at windship so since our school has put a huge Focus especially this year on following the behavior Matrix and really cracking down on those expectations and following the flowchart with Fidelity to meet our goal our staff has really committed to recognizing and reinforcing the roar behaviors that students are displaying each day and at Winship um the roar behaviors that we talk about stand for respectful actions only safe behaviors always do your best and make responsible choices um and when we notice students doing this which most of the time they are um we really have been focusing on recognizing it immediately reinforcing it and getting those postcards in the kids' hands you see
050their little faces light up they love to go to that mailbox they press the BS the the awesome button they put it in there flashed their little card to Miss Lori in the office we have our celebration and then they're able to pick out a free book to take home uh to read and share with their families um and something that's been really cool as a way to kind of encourage staff members uh to write postcards because we know sometimes that's you have a million things to do as a teacher so like when am I going to do this well as a way to kind of keep accountability and just reminders I've taken it on to review data each month and send teachers just kind of like a just a little reminder of like hey
051this was your data for the month this is how many kids received a postcard more months than not we've had over half of our teachers have 100% in their class um but as a way to kind of take that responsibility just off of classroom teachers um I also send an email to all staff members uh a list of the kids that did not receive a postcard that previous month so that we can have that shared ownership as a staff hey it's not just that teacher responsibility we can all take part and it's kind of funny to see like I sent the December data out um right I think the Monday after we came back from break and said uh now that we're back in our full week you know this was our data it was
052a little low compared to where we had been at you know let's see if we can get after it Jan in January this this month and that next day it was like postcards flying you saw teachers um we tell our counselor our counselor wrote over 20 postcards that day and we had Paras writing postcards um we're just seeing a really really great uh connection within the school and a shared ownership that really I think matters and shows the kids that it's not just their classroom teacher that's expecting these behaviors it's not just Mr T it's everybody and it's it's a common message so as you see up on on the board you can see we started in September at 50% and after that first month and that first email went out it was super exciting
053cuz we're like wow 22% up like this is great um and then obviously we saw a little bit of a decline but like I said in January once that email went out I checked today and we were already up over 55% of students already receiving at least one postcard and we're only halfway through the month so um we're really excited about this model and our goal and I think that we can feel feel our students growing and learning through this model does anybody have any questions about our PBIS goal or anything we're putting in place questions Mr CLE acronyms so what does PBIS stand for yes so when we talk about PBIS it's positive behavioral interventions and supports thanks yep other questions okay thank you yep all right and I will this is Betsy McIntyre
054she's going to share Community collaborations thank you all right my name is Betsy McIntyre I'm the library media specialist at Winship um as you can hear we're all very proud about lots of things um our community collaborations is something that I think we can speak about how proud We Are we have many um Community collaborations that we have at Winship these are just a few but just to talk about a couple the therapy Partnerships we have cvic the village and Deep Roots healing coming into winchip to do sessions with students um Deep Roots healing does a session in Spanish with some of our Spanish speakers which is really unique to our school um UND lots of collaborations with UND but just at the last Red event we were able to connect through the Ground Forks
055Public Library with Spanish um students in the language program and we had like five people just show up that spoke Spanish and were able to read with kids that day whose parents didn't come which was really really fun to see lots of cultural events we have welcoming Winship was which is an event we do in May um North Dakota Museum of Art you can see in the top right corner that picture I think we've had three concerts two to three concerts this year alone so we're giving our students these experiences that they might not get um on their own and it's just been really fun we've had lots of really fun groups there uh University Park neighborhood and blue zones we do quite a few events with them we did a raking event they helped
056us with the windship sign and the planting in front of it and then Logan talked about great great ples food pantry and of course the mission who provides Friday food backpacks Friday food bags um also I think it's important that we these collaborations are enriching our students but also that our students are enriching other people in the community when we go um last year we received a grant Chrissy wrote a grant through the foundation we were able to bring every student to the Ground Forks Public Library to register for library card to get a tour to understand the services provided there and as a result this year they added many um more titles in Spanish to their collection which I think is just the way they saw us come in and to see what was
057kind of in demand I think those collaborations are just so important for our community and for our students and you can see Megan talked about the office referrals our goal was I believe a 50% decrease so you can see by the time we got to December that's something to celebrate we were at that decrease and hopefully that will continue as we head into January um we talked about some of these inputs some of the inputs are the same as our outputs just the things that we're seeing you know as much as you pour in you can see those um coming out in our students lots of data our HRS surveys are showing lots of this growth some of our small groups incl um Megan gets on the intercom every Friday to do her bucket filler
058Challenge and there are screams down the hallway um for the class that wins and then just the decrease in student um referrals so lots of these things that we've talked about have an impact on student growth and just the way that our students are growing daily both in our schools and in our communities um my job is also unique to Winship in that I'm the library media specialist which if you don't know I teach classes as a normal specialist like PE music and social studies but I'm able to be there 100% of the time which is really fabulous because I'm only teaching those classes half of the time so the other half of the time I'm able to do different things that lots of schools are not able to do one is that I get
059to go into um every classroom once a month to do a stem lesson and I just read a story book and then incorporate a stem lesson in into that story book and it's just really great for language development for all of our students um something that the kids look forward to also having an increased number of elbow participants if you don't know what elow is Elementary library book awards um super fun to be able to be there daily to have these conversations with kids um having somebody there every day gives kids access to books but also things like the red event I pull all of our Spanish books all of our Nepali books to put on the table for the red event so when families come those parents who do not um read in English
060are able to find a text that they might be able to share with their families to read and then I put access to the library and the people in it and um when I was going over this with Travis he's like but you're not really in there all the time and he's he's right like I don't just sit in the library all day right I'm all over the place so this morning I was able to in on a Wht wisdom lesson in fourth grade which was really awesome and when I came back to grab a drink of water I had a student who was like where have you been it's like you know so I just think that having me there every day is so powerful having conversations with kids about books um just it's
061just really really amazing uh last year we added so many Spanish titles to our collection able to when we draw for postcards not only are our books in English but they're in other languages as well those kinds of things are super special um and something that we're proud of at Winship all right and Macy's going to come on up good evening my name is Macy strm I'm one of our special education strategists at Winship tonight I'll be sharing about our mtss process for behaviors and how we support our most vulnerable students as they develop emotional skills to be successful in school but also in the community so our first part of mtss is our check-in checkout system the system has four main focus points is to be intentional to be consistent to make connections and
062to be goal focused the check-in checkout system helps connect School staff members with students needing additional mentoring opportunities the mentor and the student meet regularly to develop a trusting relationship talk about challenges provide guidance and review personal goals Our Hope with the check-in checkout is that the mentors become consistent adults who students can go to when needing advice managing emotions practicing skills and most importantly navigating life at school at home and in the community in addition to our check in checkout system we also have a responder system a responder system or responder schedule creates a system where staff members can reach out for additional adult support in order to effectively work with students during challenging moments all teachers and one-on-one Paras have a walkie-talkie with them or in their classrooms when a responder is called
063the responder's job is to either help the student who is needing more emotional support to deescalate so the teacher is able to problem solve with that student at a later time or the responder can switch off with the teacher um to take over the class while the teacher problem solves with that student um you can see in the picture the responder schedule it has our time and it has um staff in our school that are designated to certain times on certain days of the week um those staff members have been involved in mtss meetings at some point they have de-escalating um trainings in order to help the students um the responders in the other photo there were um the lines on there um they're in charge of documenting each call um and next to their
064name they put the student initial and then they rate um how severe the behavior was therefore um the mtss team can collect data on that student Behavior and the teachers that call the responder are also in charge of adding that into Panorama um that kind of leads us into uh our third step within the mtssb process which is team referrals and interventions team referrals and interventions are about collaborative approaches to identifying and to support students with ongoing behavioral needs when our tier one behavior supports are not enough staff members will refer to students using our mtssb form and our mtssb team will come together and meet with that teacher about that referred student after hearing about the ongoing areas to problem solve the team develops an intervention plan to specifically Target the behavior that is
065most interfering with with the learning the plan is documented within Panorama to collect data and determine effectiveness of that plan the team then has follow-up meetings with the staff member or members to discuss the plan any changes that need to be made and or even better to celebrate student Behavior achievement so our ultimate goal in the mtssb process is to support our most vulnerable students as they develop emotional skills to be successful in school and out in the community any are there any questions oh thank you there were quite a few families that I connected with when they were picking their children up from Encore today and they were going to watch so I just need to talk to them for a second because I hope this information and these stories honor the work we
066do with those families we care for them so deeply they're such an important part of our community and to the staff not only to the staff that's here but to the staff that um works with these children every day I I do think they're everything that is right and good and just about public education there some of the hardest working and smartest people I know uh I think uh the gr Fork schools are just so fortunate um to have the teachers and support PL support Personnel in place um we're awfully fortunate so I'm proud of them uh I'm proud of our kids you know it's uh not so long after uh winter vacation you just uh listen to miss strem uh talk about one way we're trying to help students that have uh specific needs
067related to emotional um supports or deescalation and uh what happened today we didn't have one responder call you know not single one our responder says I'm I'm I'm kind of bored today but I think that speaks to some of the themes all of them talked about when you give support and you provide instruction that meets their need and when you have a group of people that work together it works things get better little growth Snippets at a time and I'm so very proud of that I appreciate you listening and being a part of this conversation I want to pause once again uh before we wrap uh for any questions you might have for me or any of our team members uh that shared information with you this evening any questions yes uh first of all
068we also have to give kudos to you as the building leader I know that this great team um would say that if they had the opportunity so I'm going to say that for them so thank you for your leadership um I do have a specific question when I saw your aggregate growth data in ela and Mathematics around students and IEPs it really Flo the charts to me because that is a category of students of which we've struggled to meet the needs of um academically districtwide so I'm wondering if if all of the systems that you described tonight are what you attribute to that great growth or if there is there are additional interventions and supports that occur as well to to Target that specific population I think I'll speak about two things in particular one
069it is uh collaboration our speech language Pathologists and our two strategists um are really committed to collaborating with those class classroom teachers um they don't take days off and I think that's essential the second thing is uh there is a mentality whether it's on a poster or not that these are our kids they're not their kids or her kids or his kids they are our kids um and and I think that matters when you all pull on the Rope uh in the same direction at the same time um it it makes a difference now with that said we do have student populations like all schools that have very unique and and very challenging needs and so you have to be really thoughtful when you work together you can't just say oh let's work hard and
070it'll happen you really have to be um focused on uh some of the best uh newest uh most sought after research on instructional strategies you have to continue to push yourself and challenge yourself to figure out new ways to to reach those needs you have to be curious and open-minded um you have to have a 1940s work ethic um and and thankfully these team members do they they just do not do not give up uh and I think that speaks to you know those numbers that you were looking at other questions y Mr pal just to ask has your staff and and your parents enjoyed a new look of the outside of the building as well as a new playground yeah they have now your next question is you should give us your order of
071what you need inside what's that what you need to be done inside oh all [Applause] right you know um I appreciate that question bill but yes the the commitment from a number of people um specifically uh this guy to my left uh and the building ground director worked really hard to make that exterior and our playground uh happen in a in a in a way that it should you know if you are familiar with the playground it it uh it spun for a while and it had sat in a to-do list for a long time and so we were we were grateful um for the support of of team members at MC that really uh were invested in it and and got it done um we appreciate it that the inside um walk through it
072it is it is in really nice shape um Rosalinda and Frank our custodial team take a lot of Pride um on the inside of the building much of it was was uh done uh I hate to say number because I I think I'm going to be wrong but I'm giving going to give you a range about 16 to 18 years ago tile um sheetrock paint um but we recently had new carpet uh put in uh we are um in phase one for Safety and Security for elementary schools next year that'll be a major component we're super excited about those plans and renderings um that we're seeing and and uh finalizing um lots of walkthroughs have already happened uh we think we're going to start that work uh in May when the the kids are are
073still working and learning in our buildings uh so that it's done by the beginning of the next school year so that'll be a really great upgrade for us um there are things that we just can't you know um change uh we have 12 classrooms uh for our students um at most grade levels we have one classroom that is average to decent size classroom and we have one classroom that's too small you know so we'll have class sizes in one uh classroom that might be you know let's say 20 21 22 all the way up to 24 this year and then we might have to really limit those in the other room because of its you know size just the square footage isn't there to have 24 in that room we um and so you'll see
074that throughout our school all the way from kindergarten all the way up to fifth grade there's one big room and one small room can't change much of that unless you want to build up above the mezzanine bill there's space up there we can talk afterwards appreciate your commitment to that yes do you have one here go ahead please so my question was for the roar cards or the those things that they like send home with the kids to their parents that they can like put on their fridge and stuff like that exactly they are yeah okay so that's like a similar experience that I had in middle school but in elementary school I was used to having so do you implement like things in the classroom like um different like color coding for like level
075charts and like stickers that you can put students can like put on the board if they did good for the day or like daily things that students um get rewarded for by their behavior in specific classrooms or is it just the roar cards that are the main focus I love that question so before we might have had different expectations in different classrooms or in different hallways that's actually one of the reasons we put together that behavior Matrix is because we we knew that we we're sometimes doing the kids a disservice when maybe year to year they would have different expectations that that's why we put that in place um and so we want to celebrate accentuate when those students are are meeting those expectations or exceeding those expectations that's the sole purpose are there students
076that that might have some unique plans um because they have some unique behaviors or some unique circumstances for sure it's not a rule for all of our kids or even most of our kids but yet it it absolutely happens um for some of our children because they they need it but for the most part the way we celebrate student Behavior is with lots of love lots of hugs lots of high fives and handshakes and uh the roar cards as well uh Miss Flynn I always like to ask this question because it gives the board members insight into maybe what you still need for resources so give us your wish list item or what what would take this to the very best well it it's always about people over programs it always is um I I
077I really love this this team they they are they are committed um they are very smart very intelligent and they they do work extremely hard um it really is important when you have the Dynamics we have with the different um populations and and as you saw the different levels within all those populations a level one ml in fifth grade is not the same as a level one in first grade a level one that's new to country is not the same as a level one that might have been born in our country um there so many difference and so many so many differences and so many Dynamics and so you really need the people but the other thing that um I think uh Mr baky and Dr brener have been really cognizant of with our school
078um we don't have class sizes of of of 25 and and up um it's really essential in order for our team members like Stephanie Krueger in math or our special ed team or our literacy teachers or our ml teachers to make sure that there's um you know a smaller class size where they can meet all those Dynamic needs um you know we were just talking about a student in another Community U related to one one of us that has 30 in that classroom I think teachers can walk on water but I that's a different type type of walk to be able to do 30 in a classroom uh and so um we we are seeing um growth that is related to to class sizes which you know we we all know that um but we
079we really have changed some some of our commitments and expectations Behavior you've heard um they talked about our intervention systems um our our recommitment to uh teaching a curriculum with with Fidelity and zest um we we think that's a really big deal we're excited about wit and wisdom that we know is a very big investment um we think that will serve our ml populations and all students quite well we think that's a a major thing for that the school board has invested in and I tip my hat um to you for all those things I appreciate the question thank you other comments questions yes Mr paky yes thank you I just wanted to also note um the team members didn't know note this in their presentation but I want you to know that on Saturday
080um there will be a number of Winship students and staff that will be taking over the Ralph this weekend and so um if you are at the hockey game make sure you uh note the individuals that are participating in that game that are all coming from Winship and we're excited to watch that and participate in that and so uh thank you to the staff for putting in those extra hours of organization and time and effort to provide this opportunity for our students again another note that um just the extra time and efforts that are put in to provide opportunities for our students that go unmatched and so not only thank you to the staff but also thank you to Rea for that opportunity um and the work that they put in to make that happen
081so thank you thank you Matt it was it was really fun to to work through this um project uh with Rea jod Hudson has been completely Hands-On has made uh School visits with uh team members uh Brock schn and Britney dvor um Nicole lovsky have just been fantastic connecting families getting a sneak peek at some of the supports they need to do simple things or sometimes what we think are simple things like downloading a digital ticket into a North Kota account seems easy not always easy and that that team has been really awesome so thanks for mentioning that very good thank you so much thank you very much move on to item four on our agenda the public comment period I do not have any blue comment forms turned in are there any citizens here
082wishing to make a public comment move on to item five there are no recommendations for discussion so we'll move on to item six this is 6a the consent agenda I would seek a motion to approve the consent agenda for tonight it's been moved by Mr cevin second by Miss Flynn I'll take a roll call vote Manley yes Len yes Larson yes Hino yes Kodak yes clevin yes Flynn yes Anderson yes Berger yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes 6B notice of intent to negotiate GF Directors Association this is Dr brener yes thank you chair Berger and uh perhaps before the windship crew leaves I I didn't want to interrupt um since you're not able to tell when I'm want to speak because I can't raise my hand uh on the batom but what
083what I'd like to say is uh just commendations to our windship colleagues for everything that they do I'm glad this meeting was recorded because I believe there are Snippets that would be applicable to two and four our lawmakers as they're making decisions about one siiz fits-all assessments um and and windship windship story is the rest of the story so um thank you accommodations congratulations to principal thorvilson and uh your team for presenting this evening thank you on to 6B um you have uh the first memorandum of three coming from uh one of the negotiating groups that would be from the grant Forks directors Association what I'll do is I'll basically read this first memo but for the next two uh it's going to be a repeat so I'll just abbreviate that um as indicated in
084the mammo North Dakota Century code section 15.11 16-33 provides that either the board of the school district or the representative organization May modify or terminate the contract on its annual anniversary date by giving notice of its desire to modify or terminate the contract to the other part not less than 160 days before the annual anniversary date for GR Forks public schools that anniversary date is July 1 attached as a notice from uh the gfda the director's Association president uh Eric Ripley uh stating their desire to enter into negotiations prior to the expiration of the existing negotiated agreement petition describing the group wanting to negotiate and seeking recognition as a representative organization according to the century code uh 15.11 16-10 and 15.1 - 16-11 is expected to be filed in the immediate future as required by
085state law the petition will be forwarded to the board for consideration in February so tonight is the intent to negotiate and then when we come back under action again in February it'll be the petition to negotiate so what you have in front of you from the directors uh the administrative recommendation is to receive the notice of intent to negotiate from the grant for ex Directors Association any questions for Dr brener yes have one yes Mr clev and it might have already been stated and I missed it when does the contract officially expire June 30th 2025 thank you any other questions seeing none I would seek a motion to receive this notice of intent to negotiate from the gr Forks Directors Association so moved it's been moved by Mr clevin second by Mr Larson any discussion
086we'll take a roll call vote Larson yes pomino yes clevin yes Len yes Manley yes Anderson yes Kodak yes Flynn yes Berger yes nine yes Z no zent motion passes uh 6 C notice of intent to negotiate Grant Fork's education ass Association Dr brener okay same thing chair Berger uh I won't read through everything other than this is from the gr Forks Education Association from president Brady Olen and the administrative recommendation is to receive the no 710 to negotiate from the grant Forks Education Association you seeking a motion yes I'm sorry I had just pulled up the wrong link uh any questions for Dr brener same expiration date on the contract as the Director thank you that is correct any other questions just kind of jumping ahead maybe well no I won't do that never
087mind seeing no other questions I would seek a motion to receive the notice of intent to negotiate from the gr Forks Education Association so moved it's been moved by Mr clevin second second second by Mr lson any further discussion we'll take a roll call vote Pino yes Anderson yes Len yes Flynn yes Larson yes Manley yes clevin yes hodak yes burer yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes 6D this is the notice of intent to negotiate gr Forks principales Association One More Time Dr brener please okay and you have a letter from the president of the association Terry Bohan uh everything else applies and similarly their contracts would expire June 30th 2025 the administrative recommendation is to receive the notes of intent to negotiate from the gr Forks principal Association any questions for
088Dr brener seeing none I would seek a motion to receive the notice of intent to negotiate from the gr Forks principal's Association it's moved by Mr cevin is there a second second a second by Mr Larsson any further discussion we'll take a roll call vote Flynn yes clevin yes Anderson yes hodak yes pomino yes Len yes Manley yes Larson yes Burger yes nine yes zero zero no zero absent motion passes 6E policy review Dr L would you give a summary of the last meeting of the policy Review Committee please I well and since I'm a college football fan and not a pro football fan I'm going to read every policy before we vote on them um no if you look at your uh if you look at the section uh there are are seven uh
089first reading policies the the first three of them uh policy AAC FDD and FF have just some very minor changes to those policies and also some added legal references the the fourth one AB BB which is use of generative artificial intelligence is a new policy simply because artificial intelligence is taking over the world um and that that's a new policy um the fifth one ACF which is The Whistleblower protections policy has been updated to reflect federal and state law changes and also to provide consistency within our other policies um the sixth one is the uh ba School Board ethics and that just has one minor change on it and then the seventh one is uh policy IAD which is sale of District Real Property which is a new policy for us not for the school
090boards and just as as a reminder um prior to getting to the school board meeting uh these policies are developed and modified over time by a Cadre of Attorneys at the School Board Association who have expertise in school law uh they then go through the executive cabinet and are reviewed by the executive cabinet here uh and then there is our policy Review Committee which we review it before it gets here so so uh it was the recommendation of the policy Review Committee to uh approve the first reading of those seven policies and I I or my other colleagues on the committee can entertain questions if there are any questions about it Miss Flynn anything to add from that committee meeting from your standpoint okay uh Dr if I'm hearing you correctly those seven policies um
091would be one motion to complete the first reading and then in the cover memo there's also B- br2 will we touch base on that in a moment or that that'll be touched in a moment and and we can you can either do them individually or if you want to do them as a whole you can although if any board member has has objections we would want to pull that particular policy so whatever the group wants to do sure well how about this I would first seek a motion to complete the first reading of the seven policies listed AAC FDD FF abdb ACF ba a and I a as amended I think the motion comes from the committee correct no it's just a recommend I mean it can come from anybody by by tradition we've always
092Whoever has been presenting has made the motion yeah I just elected not to if you want me I I can make the motion I'll make the motion to going against here okay so what we have now is a motion on the floor to complete the first reading of those seven policies as amended first of all is there a second to that motion it's been seconded by Mr palino any discussion I saw Mr CL yes so after first reading we can still modify language because there are a couple things that I'd like to talk about on one of the uh policies but I don't want to get in the way of a first reading so if we can still change language or ask the committee to review some language going forward uh I'd have no problem
093with the motion nothing on these policies nothing is finalized until this it's approved by the second meeting it takes it takes to approval so thank you that's correct so I'm going to interrupt so does that mean that anything that we H have some concerns about or need further clarification on do we give that now to the committee or do we wait and give it at the second reading well I I can I can give you my opinion it would be nice to get those recommendations before the first reading or if not at the first reading rather than waiting till the very last second and then all of a sudden we have a controversy because there may be something that we could easily clear up but it's it's hard to do it off the top of
094your head right in the middle of a meeting when when we've got a stack of you know 150 pages so so it' be better to do it beforehand than than than after would be my recommendation So to that point Dr hodek is there a policy that you would like to take out of this no there's nothing that I want to take out as far as the policy but I do have it's under the of course it would be this AI that we've got coming and so it's going to be unbelievable but in the guidelin on page two of the AI I would um respectfully ask um the committee to consider the wording where it says the district also encourages staff to explore generative AI to discover lesson plan ideas create templates or assessments and to
095generate ideas for the personalization of student learning in doing so staff shall use the Nai tool rules in accordance with the applicable laws regulations and board policy and the only reason that I question that or even you know hesitate a little bit is does that mean we're giving them cart blanch that they can um use something that they find in the good old days when teachers had to turn in lesson plans and if a teacher turned in a lesson plan that was you know generated by the computer or anything else that would be considered substandard so so I just would ask that the um because again the School Board Association sends us um what is the um minimal that they're recommending and what we can do is to maximize if there's some just little tweaking
096of wording so otherwise I was very pleased with the rest of the policies can I ask one follow-up question since we're discussing this do you have something in mind to change that paragraph or would you want the policy Review Committee to bring this bring this back for a discussion what what are we hoping for from what I see with it I would just want to you know caution almost like a um light blinking for you to revisit that also when revisiting that um possibly ask teachers what that would mean to them how they would inter interpret that because if we were to ever get into an issue where um we need to um release a teacher because of substandard or and they say well you say write out that you encourage your staff to use
097this so we were I was using it as a teacher to assess this student and and so forth so no I have I'm just throwing it out as a red light consideration warning Dr GL uh thank you Dr hodek the timing of this is quite good this policy was vetted by the artificial intelligence task force which I lead and we meet this Thursday when we reviewed the language that was in this policy we were very comfortable with it the intent of that was to encourage staff to use AI in mannerisms that may help their efficiency and allow them more time to work on individualizing um lessons for students none of that though gives uh green light to Veer off of our guaranteed and viable curriculum standards and that sort of thing which is what you're
098alluding to so we'll revisit that this Thursday if that's all right and um bring that those suggestions forward to the policy committee yes I think that's very helpful and thank you for that uh Mr clevin since we're we've got these seven did you also want to lift up what it was that you had CH actually I feel kind of like silly this one's because it's tiny in comparison into the impact of that one uh but on the on the policy about discipline the reference to the all district high schools it's it's bullet point number three it's page 12 of 25 on the PDF itself there's the qualifying language accept Alternative High School programs which we I think we all acknowledge it's an exclusion because they have their own policy like they right they I talking
099to Dr L about this Alternative High School has a different set of conduct policies I would only ask that that additional qualifier be included here because just as it is like in the black and white it's kind of like they don't need a policy at all we have an exception here because we know they have a different policy more suitable to their constituency so some kind of clarifying language on that would be desirable other I mean that's but it's a quibble admittedly sure I I'll just respond to that is a reference in the meeting notes because we did talk about that um and Cindy was just going to request a response from nsba okay yeah got you so we have that that we'll talk about then for next meeting so it's already kind of flowing
100down the path already all right thank you any other comments discussion about the motion on the floor which as a reminder is to approve the first reading of the seven policies in our packet any further discussion just a comment that appreciate the committee work thank you I will'll take a roll call vote Anderson yes hodak yes Flynn yes Manley yes Len yes thomasino yes Larson yes yes clevin yes berer yes nine yes zero no zero absent motion passes uh we also in this same memorandum uh have um have a recommendation to complete one reading of B2 board member internet and social media use as amended so I would entertain a motion to complete one reading of ba- br2 as amended I'll I'll move that we approve that it's been moved by Dr Lun or second
101second by Dr hodek just just a comment that the changes were based on recent US Supreme Court rulings so I think it's pretty clearcut if the US Supreme Court has based on we've had to change it based on that so that was the reason for it so as we go through the discussion on this it is Pages 24 and 25 of your electronic packet uh related to this agenda item any further discussion questions seeing none we'll take a roll call vote Pino yes Manley yes Len yes Larson yes clevin yes hodak yes Flynn yes Anderson yes Berger yes nine yes Zer no zero absent motion passes we are on to 6f consider of a joint Powers agreement for Cooperative purchasing this is Brandon bomach yes thank you president Burger members of the board um this
102joint Powers agreement is a new one of its type coming to us and it's essentially um through conversation with some of the other larger school districts across the state of North Dakota about wanting to come together to try to leverage a little bit of our size and efficiency for different purchasing opportunities um admittedly it's new and it's kind of finding a sweet spot perhaps in some procurement um processes the state law and it's cited in the memo really articulates when you need to do it uh and and how many days something needs to be published but the specifics of the RFP you're putting out can change based on your need and so we do this alone we ask for precisely what we'd like there are other structures such as state procurement where they've already gone
103through the bidding process or even Cooperative agreements where there's an association that's together are already put out those requirements looking to some of my uh you know the more experienced business managers they feel that there's an opportunity to find sometimes the right size things for us consider up and down the valley of some of the larger school districts and leveraging and rather than bidding across the whole state and where to deliver that Child Nutrition commodity we're going to focus on just this this Valley I don't entirely know all of the application to it just yet it's it's a disagreement really just puts in place the opportunity to do that and then as the uh conversations really come up um we'll be we'll be one more sort of tool in the toolbox to use in this
104regard so this um was an idea I think really led by um bismar it's inclusive of Fargo Grand Forks Mandan Min not West Fargo and Williston um it was Fargo's attorney on staff who um pulled this together their board has acted on it but I understand most of these other boards actually have a meeting tonight where they'll be considering the same thing so the administrative recommendation here would be to approve the joint Powers agreement um for the Cooperative purchasing as presented but just as a reminder too there's no requirement to ever use it should we have better rates in any of those other structures any initial questions for Mr pach Mr clevin there was some reference in there about defaulting to bismar being in charge and I I'm paraphrasing I know that uh but how
105did that how does that Clause work and how what's the possible worst outcome like because at that point we don't kind of control our own stuff and how do we resolve that possibility yeah no I appreciate the question um really I think it that came from a statement of the kind of their leadership on the concept and their willingness to raise the hand to kind of do some of the paperwork Behind these things um you we will still satisfy all publication requirements and we're going to raise our hand if if you know essentially this tool will be a way for them to say hey we're going to we're going to go shop for something in particular you know who wants in on this one or who's going to be a part of that and then
106it's with those details that bismar can just kind of lead through that that bidding process or that RFP process and they'll articulate you know it's going to be you know Mandana bismar is going to advertise for this one and they're trying to attract a vendor in that area but with double the I mean not double but a larger capacity because the two school districts together so my point is they're going to help lead in that paperwork we're involved with every step of the way if we don't like something there's absolutely nothing that precludes us from going through our normal bidding process as an individual School District or looking at the state procurement of what they've already bid Etc so it's totally an opt-in process and we can opt out at any point along on an
107individual procurement process absolutely thank you MH other questions for Mr bomach just a comment is that if we do decide to opt out you know how many times do we opt out because then it could change that RFP um to something different so that when there's a vendor whatever saying here we come and then they're expecting all of these schools you know to participate and then all of a sudden West Fargo and gr Fork says no we're not going to that could end up changing things but it's built in here from what I've read that those people would know that that if your offer isn't good enough you know some the districts do not have to buy into it so they've got to work on their end to make it to us so and and
108I'm not envisioning that once an RFP is issued Ed any participant in that collective bargaining RFP you're in it but we could still choose not to accept the submitted bids I'm only referring to the opt out even before it's issued for public RFP so just a we're we're talking clarifying intent here and I would just underscore um communication between the districts it's been honestly one of the most fun observations I've had entering into K12 space it's not your private sector it's not if we got a good idea we're not necessarily going to share it because of perceived competition it's more like we want to share it we want to get it out there and so it's it's we're in constant communication in the first place and so when this idea was mentioned we said yeah
109let's give it a shot together and there are other Cooperative purchasing Vehicles out there how do is there a method in determining at what point like is there a priority if we pursue that existing agreement or this or this third agreement like how are we going to resolve that and does this group get an provide advice on that decision making yeah I appreciate the question so we always do the best we can to shop around so to speak and so we look at that and we're going to try to assess based on first and foremost what we're looking for I mean the details sometimes can change so greatly that that product might be available there but not quite the way we need it if I can say it that way and so we're going to
110always be looking for that very best price you know explicitly if it's already been bid and the North Dakota centry requirements are met we don't go to the board to to get that permission to do that you know we will do that when needed or if in particular we you know there's a there's something of of interest to the board we can always absolutely do that but I would say that it's up to our administrative team to do a good job of looking for the best prices where we can find them thank you other questions see none I the administrative recommendation is to approve the joint Powers agreement for Cooperative purchasing as presented so I would entertain a motion uh to approve that jpa it's been moved by Mr Larsson second by Miss Flynn is
111there any further discussion I'm a little worried we're Reinventing a new wheel uh so I'm probably going to vote against it just because I think we have lots of tools already available other discussion yes Dr Len Brandon would you like to comment about that um you know the only comment I appreciate the ask is is uh I think it's still new and and and we might find ourselves in that situation where we found that we've recreated the new wheel and and we'll learn from that uh if we find some in that we'll be sure to make sure you're aware of it too yes Mr lson I think I viewed this as like a upside only kind of agreement it really just seems it seems prudent to do it to collaborate and learn from people that
112are doing the same things a little bit differently Kudos other comments seeing none we'll take a roll call Vote hodak Yes Larson yes Manley yes clevin no Anderson yes Flynn yes Hino yes Len yes Berger yes H yes one no zero absent motion passes we are on to 7A announcements and I'll start with Dr brener because I feel like I missed him the last time he wanted an opportunity so Dr brener you're up first oh that's okay thank you president Berger uh just a reminder that Wednesday and Thursday evening of this week January 15th at 700 p.m. we'll have a public input meeting at Central High School uh regarding uh boundary line discussions demographics and then Thursday the 16th 7 PM uh we'll be at Red River the Red River session will be recorded um
113so we'll be able to play that back upload that on our website so um most of that was explained in Fray Focus so I won't comment anymore on that uh and then finally you'll at least I can see on my screen you've got some pink boxes in front of you from Whitman's and uh January is Schoolboard appreciation month and I just want to uh demonstrate my appreciation and gratitude for all of you with that small token of appreciation um the community um r large doesn't understand how much time and energy uh you put into your servant leadership so thank you very much uh from our adult board members to our student board members thank you thank you very much other announcements 7B board requests for future consideration anything you would like discussed or added for
114a future meeting 7c our Schoolboard meeting Norms Mr palino how did we do very good very good very good thank you and we are jour SL