CorpusRecord 55672

Dresden School Board 12/17/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SAU 70 Media
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Grafton County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,115 words · about 112 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e great well Welcome to our Dresden meeting I'm going to call this meeting to order on December 17th at 6:01 pm and for our first item of for business we have agenda review and actually I would like to move some things around um hopefully we will have fresher eyes for some of these things so I'd like to propose if it's a with the board um moving the um section six budget presentation which includes items a B and C up to after 4A so after the report of our high school council rep which I don't even see here so so um but we'll do that first and then um and then move the budget information and also would like to propose moving the principal reports for for B and C down with the rest

002of the reports in items eight currently um so if folks are okay with that basically it's just making the budget presentation up earlier and we have a member from the finance committee here would like to see as well yes um my only comment is that we also have people here for 5B yes we we do um this um I would welcome if they need to to move it so that they could speak if it's fine with the board during public comment however there is not going to be any action taken from the board on 5B tonight okay is that fair okay yes sorry just second can we basically do that as a public comment then is that what I'm hearing [Music] um Jamie okay I thought you said you okay you did have there is

003an action if the board so chooses so it was put on and I can explain it when we get there but I think they'd be all right with watching the budget presentation okay in the some stuff around okay they didn't want you to have to wait it but I figed you'd be okay with watching the budget yeah unfortunately not everyone can go first um so this is the challenge we're in so if if folks are okay with moving the budget presentation earlier um that was really in the warrant articles which actually sets the stage for the discussion later about the donation all right I'm seeing okay with that um so we'd like to maybe make that change then um moving on to public comment um for those um who have something to say and it

004might be about the donation um if not uh you know please refer to our bedh uh policy on that's posted and and we have three minutes to speak about anything that's not typically on our agenda for tonight and [Music] one okay closing public comments um and I don't see our high yeah for public comment well M of the public and I may yeah do you mind stand do you mind coming closer to the AIS so on the agenda so normally you would speak where the agenda I understand that but I have a process question and can you first say your name sorry sorry this is just for for you good evening owl Dina Romero Han resident former drent employee yeah um I just h i I understand the process but I have a question because

005it's hard to hear and I'm now in the category of people who wears two hearing aids um did you say there would not be action this evening so I was originally told that there wouldn't be action apparently we received legal advice today that we would be taking action it was not currently going to be taking action but I guess we're going to hear dis at least a discussion and then we will see if the board makes take okay potentially we'll see what if there's a motion okay great thank you I appreciate the clarification thank you no I appreciate it too and also I have to admit I feel like I'm underwater today too so if I say you know I'm doing my best but I also can't even tell how loud my voice is right

006now so um okay um so I don't see Ella here or anyone else but yes you want to come up speak on behalf of council's gonna try to be online so I know she's not okay okay if she comes online I'm sure we can be flexible yeah it might be a seven o' o' all right so then moving on um if we can move to the budget presentation then um that's what I have being next um Can Jamie would you like to kick it off so this is the first draft essentially pres budget presentation um that the full board is hearing and um Jamie has prepared some slides which I'm guessing is what we'd be wanting to look at right now yeah you have it in front of you so you don't have to watch

007but this is more PR for the public so if they don't have it or they just want to follow along so um first slide really just tells uh you know who we are and what this is so this is the Des in FY 26 budget proposal it's actually version three for us in administration it's probably version two for the budget committee and the finance committee because they didn't see version one um and so we're going to look at the agenda and so we'll look at the budget process and what we're doing this will be familiar to you we're try you know follow the same type of process then the summary and then look at each of the individual um budgets that make up the big Dres in budget so there are three small ones or

008not small ones but three individuals Jamie um apparently the camera is not picking you up and maybe the sound isn't either so do you think you could sure would it be better for the camera if we move no I think it's I think what Jamie's about to do is the right thing I'll just look at you like this there we go thank you Jamie no worries okay so this is our agenda it follows the same agenda we normally um make and so we're going to go through the budget process the summary look at each of the individual budgets that make up the large one and then what occurred with the net assessments this year next okay next so as you many of you know who have been on the budget committee and or on the

009board for many years um or for those of you who are new to us we start doing the budget in August that starts with what we call um a quick model the quick model takes into consideration the pieces that we know to be true like contractual uh items and then it makes assumptions based either on CPI or on some other hypothetical information that we may um have G it along the way we do that this year we did residents on August 12th and had a meeting about that in order to inform what the um budget guidelines would be the budget guidelines are then drawn up in draft and they're taken to the first board meeting in September that was on the 24th um based on the quick model uh that had a savings of 1.2

010is million in there because of debt roll off um the quick model was showing that we should have somewhat of a flat budget assuming making some assumptions that one of them which you'll see a little bit later did not come true uh So based on that the board issued guidelines it's a great letter I would um I would encourage people to read it it's very uh well written it's very uh complete on what our thoughts are where we're trying to get to um So based on that we were tasked with trying to build a 0% increase budget we had an early budget meeting on their second draft on October 29th uh with our budget committee and so that draft uh if you have a copy of the budget book in the budget book there is

011a document uh it is exhibit 6B um and it will show you the totals of the different drafts and what's changed between the drafts okay so you can refer to that and if you have any questions let me know I don't touch on it so we came out of that meeting um with an early overage of I think it was 1.2 I'm not looking at my my item um and then we made some adjustments uh to some of the expenditures we also um had some holes that we needed to fill because that was really our first overall look at it together and then on November 21st we presented the second draft um with review to the budget committee and the Handover finance committee and so on at that meeting um excuse me we were still

012a bit over and so we were asked to take a look at where we were at and what what we would need to do to bring in um a zerob based increased budget and so we'll get to that a little bit later on we were at 1.12% uh overall increase equaling $348,800 read the notes um and then in January we'll bring a final draft to the public hearing and budget adoption um that final draft can absolutely be adjusted at that hearing okay and has been in the pass um Not Unusual that's the night on January 7th that the board will hopefully ratify the budget and we can move forward with the warrant articles then we have a district meeting deliberative session on February 27th and we'll do District voting on March 4th okay and this

013is the membership of the different um um areas of folks or pockets of folks that were involved with building the budget um Kim Hartman is our budget committee and board chair an Neil Odell was also a board member on the budget Committee of course there's the administrators myself superintendent bams principal Stevenson principal Murray principal Olen Colleen Draper the ad and assistant at the high school Tim Bole principal of Richmond Middle School principal Morrison at the middle school and Janice starky who's their financial assistant that that helps with budgeting at the middle school yes ma'am and Kelly McConnell is oh and Kelly McConnell I'm Sorry Miss McConnell jeez critical fail we'll get that added and Miss McConnell on the budget committee yes that can retroactively not go to the meeting no it was a good meeting

014you had a lot input okay so and then what the different roles are right uh it it talks to our roles um and you know our role is to build it bring it together so everybody can take a look at it in in its entirety and then the board's role is to try to balance the decisions on what makes sense on what to carry forward okay now we're going to look at the budget summary as I mentioned before there's um an exhibit in here and I'm really going to speak a little bit to the highlighted items here because here's where some of the changes occurred between the different versions the second set of columns um was oh I put version three I'm sorry the second set of columns was yes it is version three so

015the first set column is the budget adopted for 2425 and then these are the second this is the version we're showing you tonight and it showed shows you side by sides I'm sorry I'll remember what I did here in a minute it shows you side by side for Richmond Middle School Hanover High School and the districtwide and then it shows you where the increases were for each one of these individual budgets and then it carries it out all the way to the end and it shows you the proposed full Budget on the end so in regular education you can see that there is a very large increase in the 1100 lines this is by function code so it's kind of like departments uh you can see that there's approximately $734,000 worth of increase in regular

016education the bulk of that comes from salaries and benefits um we have uh a teachers uh Union agreement that was ratified um two years ago we're in our second year and so that puts 4% on base we also had a multitude of um which is great track advancements this year in both both of our Realms of Richmond Middle School and Hanah High School um and many people who are newer to our Realms and so there's quite a bit of steps involved as well in addition to that the uh health insurance came in at a 12.9% increase and so that uh also adds quite a bit to the bottom line because not only are our teachers union on that health insurance um that came in with the 12.9% increase but so are our support staff workers

017okay so we have both folks that sit within the regular education realm um there are a few non-union no there are not any non-union folks a few non-union folks tutors in the regular education realm the increase on non-union folks health insurance was 10% okay so technology did not have a large increase from the prior budget to this budget build on version three special education had an increas at the high school from version two to version three and that had to do with multiple track advancements as well uh there were uh two three there were also Health adjustments that went the opposite direction in that realm um and then for ESL education that is going up from version two to version three also due to track advancements the guidance and health section for high school from

018version two to version three changed due to track advancements the school board SAU Services number from version two to version three went up by I think it was eight about $118,000 that was because of some changes were done during ratification of the SIU budget which came in after the second bill but before the third one um in school administration there was some changes to the health insurance numbers for the retirees um there were also some retire there was one other retiree that came in that was added um and then in building and sight improvements we made an adjustment for Richmond Middle School from version two to version three where we removed a project because um it was decided that we would wait until the CIP uh is done so that just shows you the different

019areas that had changed from version two to version three so in 2425 we started with a just over $31 million budget the Richmond Middle School's budget is up $538,000 the H high school budget is up about 690,000 the districtwide budget is down 96 now remember I said that had a $1.2 million cut part of the quick model that did not come in as expected was the projection at CPI for the sa7 budget it came in much much higher than initially projected so that has had a relevant bearing on the overage that we didn't expect to see from the quick mall that's in now so that ends up with a 31.4 is million doll budget next slide this kind of gives you a different look and I took liberties with some colors here yes um on

020the previous slide Jamie yes is transportation for sports at the high school is that under transportation or under Athletics it's under transportation okay yeah all Transportation costs are nested together and the increase in Transportation on our slides here for this realm is due to the fact that we restored a bus service to the Heartland tuition uh students that we had initially not budgeted in the prior year because their numbers had dropped but our initial agreement with them was if they had more than 20 uh tuition students that we would send a bus so we've restored it to this budget okay because they're up around 20 five or six right now projection looks good that it should uh it should remain um on this slide this is by object and object is really by um like

021a subject right so you can see in the pink those are all large reductions all right um the property services and equipment for Hanover High School is down 319,000 the districtwide debt which we talked about is 1.2 million and then the property services and equipment for Richmond Middle School is down 76,000 then as we mentioned before the offsets uh from the different uh salaries and benefit lines um with Hanover High School is about 920 and then this is all salaries and benefits put together okay uh and then Richmond Middle School salary and benefits are about 5.84 and then the audit SAU assessment legal and insurances are up 337 then the ones in white are much smaller um but still make a difference on the bottom line uh so we have salaries and benefits in the

022districtwide that are up 17 even though we are still under negotiations for a service contract we hired in between we hired the fourth maintenance guy in between carrying a budgeted line and then uh hiring him so he came in I think a little bit higher than initially budgeted the other thing is that there is a um compensation committee uh adjustment that is carried in that line um and the um custodial maintenance agreement is tied to a CPI number that moves in October so that that that's all part that and benefits the benefits increases like the 12.9 um RMS other is quite small I could go through the lines but you can do it you have a line item budget in front of you and then the purchase services and supplies at the high school um

023and those would be predominantly in some of the areas of special ed um for those so that's an object look if you look in your budget book that's been attached uh in the board docks there's a much more expanded line item overview of expenditures and changes by object this just really puts them all together to give you a view of a a pie chart um yes yes yeah sorry the pie chart is going changes cor yes between budgets between the budgets year to year ups and downs yeah ups and downs by object and then it's an absolute value for the well and I honestly check the numbers in the Excel spreadsheet in the back it does uh it does proof out so if it looks odd I will double check it again was your question

024on the graphics or just the con did you get your question answer okay okay very good all right T say yeah okay enrollment uh we're flipping to disc District enrollment and I'm just going to pull up my there my district enrollment which is in my budget book exhibit well it says exhibit one but it's actually further so this is an overview I love this this is I have to thank uh shair Hartman for these wonderful Graphics because she started this presentation a long time ago and I've just been rolling with it I love the gra these are little backpacks they're wonderful they represent our children and so uh at Richmond Middle School we're projecting 366 students uh versus the fy2 budget it looks like we may be down five um we're also looking at one

025tuition student although I'm going to tell you right now the tuition numbers are up and down week to week month to month so I actually think since I built this I might have there might be another one coming in so um in the Handover High School there's we're projecting 677 and versus the FY 25 budget that would be up 17 students I'm projected 131 tuition students although that is lighter than the quter year um on the total that's 1,60 students so it would be a total net gain of 12 and the uh the versus 25 actual that are cut off there for is up one tuition student from actual um um Rich Let's Take a look at Richmond Middle School and the principal are going to help help me when we get to the slides

026where they're going to talk to you about uh what's going on at their schools so this is again a different look of changes of overview by Department um they have a $538,000 total increase uh and so you can see where the increases are in the different departmental Realms again we had an offset in the building and sight improvements uh lines where we made a a conscious decision to take a project out of the um out of the freay and and the site Improvement had already come down a little bit from the prior year due to some of the things we've been doing so the total budget for RMS is approximately 2.1 million 538 th000 or 5.63% if you look here um we have What's called the significant changes it's exhibit one in the budget book

027and it goes through and it takes any changes that are $10,000 or more and it explains to you in narrative in the budget book what the changes were um apped to what occurred okay so we pull out the largest ones here and share them with you and so the contractor wage increases Bas and steps and Tas we have two or two and a half% cola on non-union base and there's a 1.3 three total FTE increase that is uh a04 for ESL and a 0.93 for regular Ed EA um slash they're using that role as a substitute for uh teacher vacancies that we haven't been able to fill um some of the other schools are doing a similar situation depends on where they're put because of their certifications um so that's two almost 280,000 and then

028the benefit health insurance rate increases and election changes are 238,000 there abouts and then there's also associated with the salaries the F and inh retirement system at 403b comes in around 60,000 special ed Professional Services that was due to changes in student need at 21,500 and then building and sight improvements are down um there are other so the total of those significant changes is 500 19 there are some other changes around 19,000 that rounds out that number we have um out of District um transportation and then some purchase Services as well um this I'm going to point out here because I don't think I have at this point although it might have been on the bottom of another slide um this does not include any dollar amounts for support staff or service uh warrant articles

029because we're in negotiations right now okay those will come out in the next uh budget version hopefully if we ratify agreements okay next all right and this is simply looking you're one behind sorry I'm heavy I didn't say next okay uh wrong way way there you go I know it's Mac we are PC people in accounting um RMS here just again to what we just mentioned uh has a 1.33 FTE increase included um and it shows you the changes there there were a point point4 in the certified staff FTE and a 0.93 in the other staff FTE so the total staff would be at 1.33 and then I'm going to ask principal come right up here next slide please yes and talk about the different educational benefits that are going on at the richond middle

030school right so we um we go through the same process every year when we look at the budget we convene the budgetary Committees at the building level to sort of try to make sure that our um philosophies are reflected in how we're spending our money that seems to be the best way to to sort of make sure that we're staying true to what we're actually trying to do um and these are main things that that we looked at in terms of what we're trying to do going forward despite any kind of budgetary um situations um to maintain the current team structure that we uh started I think we're in our fourth year now we have a number of small teams where you have um academic classes and learning Specialists who meet on a daily basis

031who share the same number of students in common and we've seen a real advantage to that in terms of student services that we can offer and and to make sure that the students feel as if um they have adults in the building we're really looking out for them um this also allows us to do things like make sure that we can individualize the learning opportunities keep all of our class sizes relatively small we really value and try to keep our classes under 20 um both within electives other than chorus Josh Hall somehow teaches 53 kids in chorus I don't how does it but um it's a pretty amazing thing to see um but to keep all of our other electives somewhat small so that students not only get to connect with the teachers but to

032get to connect with each other sort of within those classes and those classes are not cohorted the academic classes are all within the same team our electives are where we mix our students together we feel like we can get into a better bigger Community then we looked at our learning environment uh hbac upgrades um to Common spaces right now we do pretty well in our classrooms making sure that they're um hot when they need to be hot and cold when they need to be cold um but our common space is um so there some difficulty anybody who's been in the auditorium in the summer or the spring realizes that um yeah one more year and yeah that that's something we give back it's okay we don't use it that much it just would be ideal

033um we use some of the money to support the equity of experiences in terms of our field trips make sure that all the field trips that we offer are available to all our students um and we're continue to try to build some look at different ways that we can build support mechanisms um that is in line with the Strategic plan right now we have uh sort of an identified area where we could improve um to help students uh in support who are either um like the high school model coming back after an absence or don't qualify for a 504 an IEP or reading help all of our reading help is offered through special ed um but we want to make sure that they have the help that they need um in order to be successful

034so and again that's we try to maintain as many adults in front of students as possible within budget so that's really over I'm just um my question is actually on the previous slide I realize this is the last slide before um we talk about the high school so um if we go back to the um FTE and maybe Tim you can help answer this a little bit clear um can you describe here what is net new versus what is net from the budget but we as a board approved throughout the year we added a point4 esol a new point for esol position um this year this year right it's in the building right now right everything that's up there is actually in the building right now um it was a little it gets confusing because

035we have somebody who is H who is part esol part Spanish so they increased the amount of Spanish they were teaching decreased the amount of esol that they were teaching and then we added them another esol teacher so it seemed like we were adding more than we were but in terms of the FTE it was a point4 position and then the 093 is a regular ad um EA who also uh came in and worked as a sub for the entire first quarter and is now sort of our person who moves from place to place um and that's actually offset by wherea right short in one special education EA so those sort of those things um sort of work in terms it was a wash but it was an addition to what we have what we

036have had in the past and so far it's been a huge success it's actually the model that has been used at a number of other schools so we have Mr Tim is his name great name um has been in the building uh he was in the building a lot last year he's been in the building all this year so when he goes into classes all the students know him he's he knows all the students he's really connected um and is working really well with all our students to it seems to be the best model that we've found so far sorry I'm so confused so those people are were currently already paying for them in this form yes thank you so that's one of those I think we had in meetings before and I'm sometimes not

037as clear as I can can be in terms of talking about numbers but budget to budget there was an increase but in terms of people in the building currently to what we would like next year it's the same so put throughout the throughout this year the board has approved basically a 1.33 increase over the previously approved budget from March and that's just just kind of a good reminder of the timeline yeah thanks they have but the money's not we're not going over budget this year because we have the 0.93 right in the special that's open um we would be over budget a little bit in theol because that was a midyear change correct yeah so this would this would be adding right but we knew this year that there was yeah I'm sorry we should

038probably do a midyear call yeah yes um yeah thank you for that because I was going to ask why we decreasing students but increasing Ed assistance but it sounds like we are in fact it is an increase of 0.93 over last year because if we build that special ed position we are adding an additional position right even though we're decreasing students um what we did find when we ran the numbers and this was actually uh it was an interesting discussion to try to get our our Mr T into the building it actually I know that benefits play into it in terms of just daily pay last year he was like I don't want to do it because I make more money sub so he would actually like the fact that he's not in our system

039every single day as a sub which honestly he wouldn't have been um helps us out better value better value in terms of I have another question and it's a small increase it's $5,000 I think it's a almost 10% increase though over the budget line from last year and that's in field trips which I noted the field trip budget is going to be $56,000 which I noticed the high school has an 18% increase in their field trips but they have doubled the students and that only brings them to 38,000 so you have almost twice the budget and half the students for field trips at the high SCH school has and I'm wondering what that goes to that goes to that is an attempt to budget and um help offset our eighth grade field trips field tripsi

040Tri there are two immersion field trips for offered to all the students in the eth grade students in Spanish uh go to New York City students in French go to Montreal year there the last three days in May students who don't take a language get to choose which one would like to go on it's basically our a it's not the same as March intensive but that we're trying to offer some sort of an educational opportunity for our eighth graders as opposed to a field trip that before would have been a day um to somewhere else and it's certainly something that the the World Language Department um has taken the lead on it's something that we think offers a lot of value to our ath graders but that that's with that's for and we're trying to

041build that in we have done a significant amount of fundraising in the past we've tapped into the B Foundation we have a number of I think there are a number of dates you could go to mind speaking a little louder sorry you could go to room windows and uh we try to do a bunch of fundraising for that but this is something that uh so far the eth grade parents have been really um supported of so we'll see how that goes yeah there's another fundrais are potentially coming up think we have three in January and then a number of others Tony sorry I'm wondering if sometime we might add a presentation on the field trip because I think I asked about this last year but the trip to New York as an emerging Spanish experience

042how is an emerging how is an emerging when non Spanish students are going I understood and I might be wrong that there was a trip to a Harry Potter play like these seem like expensive things that don't constitute immersion and I don't know that the taxpayers need to be paying for that or this doesn't seem to further that educational goal so I don't know we need to get into it now but I would appreciate adding at some point some presentation about what they consist would that be interesting to others okay I see some heading off okay great thank you um I would point out Ben oh sorry separate issue so it looks like the ESL Edition is considered special ed not gaggin not special ed esol is regular so the that addition would go under

043the regular education increase yeah I've carved it out but when you look in the bigger budget um for continuity RMS has always carried if they had any ESO because it's been fleeting uh here and there it's always been carried in the regular Edline which it can be it is considered a regular Ed item even though it falls under a 12200 code yeah yes I know it's one of those anomalies for the state we've been having conversations about when they start doing the new updated code okay so the increase in guidance in health is pury salaries is that right in guidance okay y okay thank you yeah we have a new guidance yeah it was turnover turn yeah um the only thing I wanted to point out was that when we built the budget last year

044the projected number of students for RMS was 365 they actually came in six higher than was projected this year the actual and then we're projecting cohort survival method like we have with everybody else and so that's why the projection you know goes to 3636 obviously kids come and go um so we'll see how close we are we came in pretty good from 2324 to 2425 but we went up a little bit um so just keep in mind it is a projecting based on what we know today next slide Tesa thank you okay let's take a look at the high SCH school and principal ston here with us uh here's the projected changes overview by Department here um and I will point out I had an error it's not the high school's uh issue I had

045an error when I was carrying their fpes so when you see their FP sheet it's going to show a 0 five increase not a five decrease yeah but it's not a new the person was already in there so um I can show you on the other slide sorry it's my error I keep chasing the FD around through at the high school just there's so many FTE that go all over the place um so in regular education you can see that's their largest increase um you had a lot of track advancements this year in regular education uh which is amazing and wonderful that the folks who are working here at the high school are really um you know advancing their understanding and knowledge of the subjects that they're teaching with the students um special education also

046had some track advancements um and so the El elll here it says ell uh that was up again another .10 but had some movement in between um then we had some decreases going on in the school administration uh there's some Savings in the lines there I know that as did RMS um they went through all the different line items this year looking to make sure that they were trowing them up to what was actually happening in Prior years to make sure that the patterns are right and to make sure that they were doing the right um uh they have things on a schedule for replacement for a lot of the different items that are used uh in the school in the in the classrooms and all of that uh in building and maintenance custodial that

047is a machine that we replaced um it's a of scrubber that's in this fiscal year um and then transportation services is again just the restoration of the routs um and an increase in additional route for vocational we we were carrying I think one transport back and we've been doing two transports um different timings on them and then just the building site improvements down a little bit in The Debt Service and transfers the transfer for them for the schools here are your free and reduc L transfers it's transfer to food uh next slide oh I'm sorry let's go over it in high level um so we're at a total of$ 18.5 million it's a $690,000 increase or 3.88% over fy2 now let's look at the significant changes um again if you look at exhibit one on

048the significant changes sheet on the budget book it's much EX it's a lot more lines than this okay it's more expanded and that ties to the narrative which I'm not reading through for the sake of time um again salary increases is the theme track advancements and then benefits and health insurance rates that are tied uh to those um here you can see contracted wage increases at 4% we had steps Tas two to two and a half% on Cola non-union base and then a 0.50 total FTE increase for four just under $465,000 uh benefits 12.9% on the health insurance rate and some election changes came in at 368,000 Associated benefits that go along with uh salary increases are at 63 um equipment in regular Ed media and custodial that's where we just talked about is down

04969,000 purchases Services they have Tech online purchase services and also in the principal's office uh purchase Services um one one was 11,000 the other was 10,224 that Tech online was for software that they've decided they won't be using and then the principal's office was uh Nas I believe Nas c um and then building and custodial purchase services are down so some of what you see up in salaries will be tied to some of this adjustment here in building and custodial for purchase services um we have been Outsourcing I don't we have seven positions open here at the high school we've been Outsourcing I think five positions leaving two behind um with a discussion and subsequent agreement with our service staff Union uh we are redirecting and carrying those monies within the FTE lines instead of

050the outsourced Services lines so you're going to see that uh we will overspend one line and underspend the other and they will correlate um that is a negotiated agreement and anou that we carry in there um okay and then Transportation Athletics field trips uh at 56,000 the food service fnr we talked about and then so the significant changes all total there are 638 there are some other ones this is a big budget uh so there are multitude of lines in the high school and they go up and down all over the place to the tune of about 52.3 th000 or 690,000 overall um so that Hanover High School is netting a 0.5 uh FTE increase um and that won't show down below here because it was an error in the other staff section um so

051yeah it should it should be 12822 should be that bottom line next slide right which is missing the minus one tech there we go so it should be it should say 0 five on your next Slide Five increase right am I right on I don't I don't know what slide you're looking at I'm on the oh you're on this it's just missing the minus one and other sta well so bring it to 128. no this should be 129. two2 because in the regular Ed EAS we were carrying we were carrying 7.95 which never you a reduction of one when I went back through and looked at the numbers um it popped that it should have been 8.95 which it has been right along um and so I restored that so it's not a change from

052last year to this year because it was their last year at a 1.0 it would have shown on here as a 1.0 reduction which was incorrect on the prior um on the prior exhibit if you go to the big exhibit I can pull it up and show you the old one and the new one it would have shown a 1.0 decrease in regular Ed EAS and it's actually not they're still all there um so right now the increases are 0 2 in regular Ed teachers okay and then the point 34 in the media assistant which is offset by just a change in a few hours on the special ed assistant so this slide is correct as stated it's a02 up in the FTE and teacher and a three up in the FTE in the med

053in the library here in the library EA um so it's up overall 0.5 from last year right and then you're okay and then can I have some CL to from the last meeting of the change yeah yeah okay when I was going through all of them and I do when you take the data and then you consolidate it and you put it together yes I noted that it was yes ma'am sorry I would rather have it correct correct um okay so we're maintaining our program we haven't really changed much but what I would like to say is we are still adding courses to our program of studies as de a CPP a world religions class a dance class we're just going to do it within the budget so it's not like we're static like maintaining

054doesn't mean we're keeping everything the same it just means we're moving things around so there's some new things for the kids next year it's just with the similar Staffing um esol is staying the same helphub resources the only thing you might see in terms of academic support is we may transfer a little bit from the helphub over to um e Extended Learning opportunities elos so that's still in conversation but that won't be a budget change it's just a transfer within in terms of not keeping things static um instructional coach is going well doing still doing that curricular programs still plan to continue all of those got down on a more reasonable furniture replacement cycle we're still working on that missing science classroom and we have plans to sort that out next year with what we

055have for the budget um we're still keeping our Equity Steward and um we're still trying to keep the building clean it's big well been Prett well we have however we will let you know our how long has it been here 12 years 10 our head custodian 13 years has just reti retiring on December 31st yeah so that's a big big shoes to film if you want to come tomorrow at 2:15 we're doing a little sing off so come to the hrim if you want to join us it's been amazing and so be sorl missed we posted the position today I think it posted today so we'll be looking for a new lead custodian here at the high school um and then we have two other custodians who are actually on staff and then we Outsource

056five we have two and a half actually we have a half time um so I know the confusion I'm sorry no you know the confusion I do know the confusion because if you look at this one which is in your budget book which is [Music] 11b it should say 129. 22 on the you add A5 1287 I'm ask you about negative you never rehired that position might that let's look at them they might if we disagree we'll fix it okay um so I'm going to fix it on the budget book and request it for everybody okay let's take a look at District LA I before we can close the chapter on the high school than FTE dissect questions okay all right thank you okay this one's pretty quick um so District wide is all of

057the expenditures that don't fit uh directly into either one of the schools um we carry some salaries in districtwide that is the maintenance workers who go across all the districts and then what happens is um the other school districts pay Dresden back for their time that's spent out there at the schools also they pay back the percentage of the um uh director the maintenance director and the main maintenance a um so that's why you'll see a salaries line in here I think we spoke about that earlier uh the dresen share of the sau70 services assessment as I mentioned was up higher than what was initially contemplated um and that's been written about in depth uh we had some uh carry forward funding that had dried up and we're not carrying forward any more to offset

058uh the expenditures that were there and that increase the get uh building and grounds is where our general insurance costs are carried um that's up 12,780 most of that increase is due to um I I went out and looked because I'm like why does this keep going up uh it's actually from special ed filing um so that's where that sits um under general liability and then our debt which we spoke about that is um that's rolling off we're going to pay two of our regular scheduled payments we have two notes left one note has one year left on it the other note has multiple years left on it but I should um think that we may pay that off um in advance I don't know maybe next year that'll be a discussion for the Schoolboard

059okay uh so significant changes you add all that's 98,000 there are other changes here and there about 11,000 so total districtwide uh is down 97,000 um and that was a part of you know when we discussed trying to level fund um then let's take a look at the net assessment this takes into consideration what's going on with some of the revenues um so we have less Revenue projected at this point in time um we will try to true this up a little bit more before the next budget draft the balance carry forward based on our projection right now is conservative good word um and then the high school tuition students we are projecting uh at a lower and it shouldn't say just HHS tuition students because there are return Middle School tuition students in that

060member as well so we'll get that adjusted uh we're projecting that to be a bit less um and what's happening is that we've got students so even though bodies full FTE may still be coming when a student goes to the Vocational Center we only charge a half FTE because they pay the vocational are sending schools pay Vocational Center directly um in Vermont there's a whole thing in a formula in New Hampshire they just pay them directly they build them directly we don't pay for Lion's kids we yeah so there's no way way to contemplate how many of those might be coming in or going out to vocational right until it kind of recurse so that's why the number doesn't necessarily always line up with the exact amount of FTE or bodies that we're looking at

061projecting four um we are going to reach out to our two biggest senders though and take a look at what their class sizes are right now uh our two biggest centers are lime and Heartland um other local sources um that includes um many different items such as rent we rent the building and we uh we Garner rent on the building um it also includes um any of our earnings on any of our bank accounts um is included in there Teresa does r she but I'm Miss inreasing other local on PP yeah the pp Investments fun over there yeah uh we they manage excess funds and sweep them back and forth because pip has a very aggressive uh interest rate uh State sources for New Hampshire is down that is the tail payment basically for our

062uh New Hampshire um uh building Aid the building Aid even though we've paid off the large loan already the building Aid has a two has a two-year tail on it and so the payments are coming down yeah then for the renting component do we charge the town of Handover for voting for what for voting no we don't no okay um we have a um good conversation for a different day but we have a policy on renting and so depending on um who you are and whether you're a nonprofit entity and all those things it has different pieces that are involved in how the rates are set okay we'll get that sent out to you we had looked at um updating it I think we did update it actually in the eight years I've been here

063we updated it once but I think it may be time to look at it again um and that would take into consideration any rentals on Dresden Fields properties as well because we do rent you know like football field TR field um softball field baseball field we rent the fields um and then State sources New Hampshire also in there would be vocational reimbursement it's a one-year lag it's reimbursement for tuition and transportation and then State sources in Verma is tuition and transportation for locational as well um or actually that's Transportation reimbursement locational uh so total resources available to offset uh is 3 million almost 3. 6 million we're down about 260,000 um again the balance carried forward right now is um conservative because we are carrying a retainage so that is another area that if we

064wanted to make an adjustment we could look at uh so that's a net change of 2.14% increase on on assessment not on Revenue it's a decrease in revenue of 6 and 3/4% a 2.14% increase on the assessment um or $581,500 [Music] by 26 uh that inflation rate is as of October I think it actually didn't change from October to November I think it's being carried at 3.5% okay next slide and then what happened with assessment this year the assessment the net assessment as many people know it shared between the towns of Hanover and norch hence the marriage called jden and then it's based on student enrollment and this year has swung to noch a little bit um and you'll see the uh difference there of just under 410 of a percent swing and on the

065Handover share of the 500 the aforementioned uh increase in assessment of 581 854 Handover share is 3,949 or up 1.85% and know's share is up 2.8 % at 23,9 4 again these do not take into consideration any other warrant articles which make come up the two I know about maybe three for dresen on that could affect U bottom line would be uh service staff agreement support staff agreement and uh potentially Middle School sports uh which will be discussed uh a little later and then as mentioned last slide thank you um November 25th first uh we were requested to go out and take a look at uh where some of the areas are that we could perhaps make adjustments to bring in a zerob based budget we all looked at the different areas uh districtwide really

066doesn't car much the only thing that we could affect change uh with there would be as if the SAU level wanted to change anything there uh the portion of either postponing the CIP or adjusting the tech Outsourcing the portion that would come to Dres would be 44,000 there is a handout from Richmond Middle School that the board has um on that's expanded all of the information there on the Richmond Middle School side of the slide in version three we did remove the auditorium hbac that was projected at 51,000 and on the Hanover High School side we talked about um most of these we did remove move an adjusted health insurance um plan that was being carried that we knew was no longer pertinent and then special education services um of about 22,000 because of changes

067in student needs so those came in in between the two versions um I can let Tim speak to any questions you might have on the handout uh there they came up with three different options I should say before we go to that that we did um discuss a methodology on you know how to make how to look at cuts um and so I shared that with the board as well we did it by like a per people cost um so that we were trying to adjust things evenly or equally although programming is not equal between the two and that's dually noted um uh as was shared so um each one of the administrators has gone back through and looked at where they could make um adjustments that would be least disruptive uh to the programming

068end or the classroom and we would um be happy to um talk through those Andor we would like to have another meeting in between now and the budget hearing we could do that as well I just just want to clarify in Cas um so this was um because right the board yes voted um the budget guidelines which were to stay flat right so a 0% increase and so I'm sorry I don't have the exact number but I think it's around 350,000 over flat which is what 322 322 thank you we had some that went up and we did those cuts right so so 322 over which is what everything we just heard includes being 322 over what's included on this last slide y um so if you see the the options the ones that are

069in Black have not been processed if they do they would reduce the number closer to zero um and but the red ones from my understanding have already been so it was higher in a prior version but now we're kind of lower by you know 51,000 and it's not lower as much as that 93 because between version two and version three we had a multitude of track advancements come through which added to the bottom line right there are various ch right so I just wanted to clarify that that's what it's to reach the budget guideline it is meant for a discussion right so um so thank you any questions comments and I think maybe I heard a question for us to potentially react to right is you know how do we feel about the the need

070to adhere to the flat guidance versus the value you in um not ading to the flag guidance right so I think if anybody has any questions first about the content let's go with that but then also we're going to probably need to get to the discussion of the guideline maybe no questions about the content but maybe more well yes I always have a really hard time because I this slide because it's hard for me to know and and it sounds like a very prong conversation right now maybe it's not but it's hard for me to look at this and and understand if we could do without the 1.6 FTE at the middle school pulling one of these out of there like what what is what is the opportunity cost of that what the capital Improvement

071plan the sa level I mean it's really hard for me to look at this and weigh those options and understand would it be helpful if maybe the principles could come up and present these options in a little bit more detail with that I'm seeing a couple of yeses so um okay so um Tim as Richmond just happen to be top left on the slide um do you want to describe the options and if this is in order of priority or anything you can hold right up and may have a compliment he so um I'll ask Ina to chime in as as we go along um when we did this we were trying to come up with um ways and if you go back one of the things that I had said before is that we

072try as far as we can to sort of Safeguard adults in from students like that that becomes our that's what we're really trying to make sure the the structure of the middle school schedule and the midd School sort of educational plan as we have it going forward makes it very difficult to offer um I guess parttime reductions in FTE because it it doesn't it affects the entire schedule so if we had a situation where okay well we can just reduce you know two people to 08 from 1.0 there's really no way to do that without affecting the entire team structure um so what we're trying to do is is figure out okay what what do we have where we can actually make some changes um non-personnel cuts 75 that was the first one that's always

073the first thing that we go through and sort of see like okay what can we do without uh can we order one set of desks instead of two sets of desks um yeah we can probably do that we can reduce our technology budget um we can reduce our field trip budget and try to raise that back in terms of either putting money back on parents and families or try to raise that money um then we sort of looked at where there other things that are out there um where we might be able to affect some savings one of which might be that we have the building um who do who are in the building and offer a lot of support but one of the things that they also do is do a lot of testing

074um for our students who need educational need if we eliminated that position we could Outsource um testing not the that wouldn't give us back the full amount of the FD obviously because we'd still be paying resources that's the point 6 FTE student services um and then we could also reduce and restructure other student Support Services in a way um to see if we could save some money there we have a pending retirement um for somebody who is currently learning specialist um who works with you know have a case load of students who have IEPs um we could try to rework how we offer those services to those students um either eliminate sort of not fill that position entirely and shift people around shift the number of students around that would affect the way that we

075do things in terms of our teaming we thought that there's a possibility that we could have somebody who could work in that position part-time um that's thing number one so that's option one is a lot of what we do before we we talked about it but we sort of went through and we're like okay we know we know what we can do let's just cut all of our supply budget by 20% and that got us like $116,000 so like oh that's really not going to do very much so we really are at the point where most of the The Lion Share of what we're doing um is people in the building um and that that would have to be the reduction um that would obviously in our mind um significantly affect the education structure that

076we can do um so those are sort of the three different options that that we can look at in terms of of what we have and you know part of it is do we want to do field trips do we want to do desks do we want to do we didn't really cut textbooks that much we don't our textbook line is that huge if you look at it um it increases from year to year if something new comes out I think this year we have an increase in World Language but again it's it's not overly significant between five and $7,000 when you're looking at something like this that's not really going to make a do I don't know if there any other questions you have anything else that that's sort of where we are Tim

077can you enlighten me on what the transportation involving three to five students this so we have students who um currently take this year we have student two students who take math um at the high school so we're in Algebra 2 as eth graders so like during the school day during the school day they get on a bus they're right over here it actually works out um I think it's going to increase in the second semester because they'll have to go um year and then back this year A lot of times the class is at the end of the day so they come over here and then they actually leave and go home from the high school but the schedule is changing we're projecting next year that we may have one student in math who is

078planning on doing stuff over the summer so that he can get into eligible 2 in the eth grade um we're going to look at are there different options where that wouldn't be necessary but we also have a couple language students who are currently in seventh grade in I think Spanish three one in French one so they've sort of maxed out their their language capabilities school so that's sort of been a long time they come it goes back to when you know the middle school was there and high school was there and it was very easy to go back point a little bit more difficult just to follow up on that so are we paying $122,000 to transport to the students one yes I'm not sure if it actually I think our actual expenditure this year

079is quite that amount that's the amount that's budgeted um and I know last year it was $122,000 because schedule and the way that it had to go but this year it's more efficient right so this year we're saving because they only have to come one way for half much and they may if it's in the morning may only have to go halfway the second time as well I'm just I'm just curious what's Our obligation yeah my understanding is that the obligation was uh continued as a tradition or something when the Middle School moved to it had been that way from my historical knowledge what I Rec can you just my knowledge whatever we call and introduce yourself oh sorry in Morrison um what I recall at the time we were separating buildings when we were

080discussing whether we were out there on the athletic field where we went to Li Road where the high school wherever that settled that when we were splitting um one of the agreements that the board agreed to was to really continue to offer that opportunity for students who were celebrated in math or World Language to attend classes at Handover High School to meet to those that were moving faster than their peers so it has continued as an op option based on that board decision at that time when Middle School and High School were no longer located in the same space um the foll I see Julie also well I would just say I I'm pretty confident that nobody is on the board any longer who made that initial promise nor are there any people taking advantage

081of it who you know were were expecting that from the initial promise and I just think when you're talking about spending $122,000 on two students for something that's nice to be able to do but we are looking at also I think elsewhere tonight whether we want to start doing Athletics at the Richmond school and we can't do everything for everybody um Julie did you want to add to that sorry I just wanted to say I feel like I need to say this publicly I've said it a number of times in email not that we don't love eighth graders we don't want them to take classes at our school um we would like them to take vacs especially in math we don't want them taking math classes the school there's a whole social issue in terms

082of that and maybe way back when there was in different administrations different boards we would we would prefer that especially now that there's been remote school and Co happened and back then VX didn't exist we're happy to accept VX credit of VX whatever movement on the scale kids here who've done vac and then come back to our courses do fine um so we don't we don't want them transported here not that we I I don't want to be really unwelcoming I just don't think it's a great idea we back in the day had some issues with it and it it didn't it wasn't great so we would rather not do it especially now that they have an option okay my question was related to VX and whether there would be a cost basis for having

083those children en lo than AA course which was appropriate to their level rather than trans them to the high school yeah Jay as long as there a New Hampshire resident there would be no cops um we have absorb the Dilemma that we run into is that our our Vermont students so far are are not um they're not eligible for free tuition I've gone as far as having conversations directly with the commissioner and and have not been able to change his mind on that and we've gone direct with two vacs um and they they cite that it's specifically for rure taxpayers only so during Co we subsidized that tuition for our Norwich students who needed that for remote learning and in very special cases when there are conflict that didn't allow students to schedule we've also

084subsidized that but there is a Vermont alternative um I can't it's vclc or something like that um which is a little bit different in that it requires actual teachers from participating districts to provide instruction with teachers that have the time to do so um otherwise there's a there's a fee it's less than the VX fee but there's still a fee associated with um providing that instruction for our Vermont students and it gets it gets a little tricky so that's I guess a long answer to your short question could you give me a just because I don't notice at all being New Hampshire is what the sort of aggregate cost would be generalized range yes for our Vermont kids it's $1,000 a class that's corre sorry we paid their Vermont their in if we wanted them

085all theya we would be paying I think it's 11100 a class the Vermont classes are $900 and we have a certain number free now at the high school because you joined something yes right and so but but if we had to pay because some of them are um running at a certain time and some of them you work at your own on your own and so if you had to pay then I think you would probably just pay for the V STX which is 11100 but if you had to pay in ver mind I think it's 850 or 900 for a class thank you appreciate that question for Richmond Middle School for slide 26 yes Michael yeah just one quick comment about math um my impression in talking um to parents and teachers is um

086that math has essentially become self-based right I mean you're you're not you're working at your own pace on the materials with videos online you're not being taught in a standard classroom way and so I do think we have very much an obligation that you exceed for the few kids who exceed the normal bounds there needs to be some way for them to get instruction that's appropriate for them whether it's coming over the H high school or some sort of online course um know because I do remember the board I think the board bristled at the Valley news article that we were pushing our kids you know we weren't um as serious about sort of academic Excellence as we once were and so I'm just you know concerned about that and want to make sure that

087people have the appropriate opportunity if that's the right level of instruction for them well I I agree we should provide certainly for Ma at the very least I would say language as well but um maybe language I guess $1,000 a class free for New Hampshire residents we and even that they're doing selfcce online at the middle school there's not a big transition I would think to VX um but that seems like an easy I mean it's not a lot of money but seems a lot more cost effective yeah particularly if messages we don't this is not the best bit anyways right Ben I'm not kind of going along with what was just said I'm not overly concerned about the students being in the high school class acknowledging Julie's concern and maturity and all that sort

088of thing I think it's more it's not a special education need and it's the student kind of going be up and Beyond what the middle school provides what is Our obligation to provide the transportation then and does anyone know from a legal whatever standpoint like do we need to provide that Transportation or we say yes but the student has to provided or the family is that maybe I'm looking around I'm thinking is that maybe something we need to do more research about question I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that if it's not part of a required program by the school itself that the transport that is listed as being required for K to8 wouldn't apply I'll get further clarification but in reading that RSA multip multiple times unless they changes it

089unless it's a requirement um I don't believe that we would have to provide transportation to from we do have to provide transportation from home to school that in New Hampshire going from the high school at the end of the day or going to the high school at the beginning of the day would qualify for we would allow that because the buses are coming here anyway so like Tim said Orissa said that you know the cost is less if it's a early morning class because they just ride in and to high school right on one of the buses that comes in between same at the end of the day I think there's some kids that do club or something over here and they ride over come over on Friday tutoring yeah and so they utilize the

090buses in between the two buildings no extra charge but we're already going I hate to sound impatient but I'm wondering sort of what we want to decide tonight or if this is we pick it back give us a decision thanks Kelly actually I was I was wondering if this belongs in the same field trip question uh followup um is that is that what I'm hearing um or or something else I don't know I saw some squits yeah are we hoping to get to the field trip question followup for this budget cycle or is this a future at at the end of this I was planning on asking is this a field trip for January because this is an important enough issue that to have to decide as far as our budget or is it just

091more from like a vignette kind of perspective or you know so I appreciate all the options that were given but I also feel like having gone through the budget all of these seem like reductions that I would need more time to think about that I'm going to have in the next two weeks um and I would I think urge the board to take the budget as it is despite the fact that it's over the recommendation that we gave them with I I would say just with the copat that if in looking at this and going through this exercise there were some painless Cuts there were some things that you said well actually that is something we maybe don't have to have in the budget sure let's cut that I mean I that's part of the

092point of going through this maybe it's only $88,000 somewhere but yeah we actually can do without that next year um but yes I I agree I think it's a small enough percentage I agree I think those hold on T well and I was just going to say I I'm not sure if I heard you correctly say that it was possible to have a $75,000 savings for not ordering the additional desks and if so I would fly support that reduction um but I'm I want to make sure that that's what you said so when we originally went through the budget we took all of basically that non-personnel area and when we tried to level funded we basically we added to some we took away from others Etc so we basically that part of the budget I

093think went up $4,000 total um in terms of of of those things things that were not affective to salary so I mean is there a way that we can cut sure there always is it cuts PD it cuts field trips c a lot of the other hopefully maybe we can build some things this Summer that we won't be able to do next year um so it's possible um and the other part of it is is since it's not something that's technically in the building right now is it painless no because it's something that we were hoping to plan for but is it something that affects direct instruction of students right away no probably so is there anything stopping us from saying hey we're okay with the budget but it seems like there is a little

094bit more room and we empower the principal to make $100,000 deduction from wherever they best see fit in each of their budgets is that a possibility for us to do can I take a shot it yeah I I think um that type of approach I typically tend to appreciate um because um while it's it's nice to hear what the answer is and actually that's kind of how this list was created right it was the you know the B really the budget committee fulfilling what the board was asking for was just create a list right please prioritize it because then we can kind of go oh 100,000 is our let's just say that right is the sweet spot of a reduction and then you kind of just go down the list right um so I think

095that if that type of approach for a version two would be good I think what would be helpful um just from being a budget Committee Member it would be helpful to hear the general level now that you can kind of see the the layers right of potential budgetary pain right as you kind of go down the list um of where the threshold is perhaps everything's fine right or or further down um to a different number um I think that would be very helpful so that the budget committee um can reconvene or a version two we can hear more about certain things yes well I support your proposed plan of action I just find this option set a little confusing you know option one includes this $770,000 and further Cuts in non-personnel areas but I don't

096see that included at all in option two or option three I'm not sure I think I think they're ANS right is that a fair way to also to try to get to the the number right so I I me I understand that but if like that's your easiest cut why isn't it in each of the options and you know would you prefer to have the 1.0 FTE student support cut which is an option two and option three but not an option one like they're not don't seem to be in a like the first thing i' get rid of is the $112,000 in transportation but that's only 12,000 but then my second priority would be the 75,000 and non-personnel and my third would be this and then the board could pick and choose but in these

097groupings if I had to pick the options um like I don't understand your priorities I guess in the way these are presented because some of them when they were thinking it through just because I spoke with them at length Okay on on looking at the different some of them as they were talking through them is because if they cut an FTE in one area it may require them to restructure in another area to make sure that programming can still be covered so that they looked at it as separate options not building on on top of each other um because it would right let I say it would require restructuring perhaps if you take out the I might get this back long enough um the the 6 FTE reduction and what they do within the school

098itself they might not be able to do the non-personnel cuts because they might still have to Outsource a little bit of that task that they cover which is in testing right but it may not be as much as what that person cost to do that job so they kind of looked at it as a as a you know full set option of if we do this and we have to make other arrangements over here what would the net difference be that I hope that helps to make more sense I mean I I can see it a little bit but I would think it would be clear if you said6 reduction ft saves this much but that would require us to spend $10,000 on this service so the net would be this but there I I

099don't doesn't much seem like these options are actually packages that you know if we do any one of these things it's going to require all the other Cuts because for instance this Transportation line I'm not seeing why the relationship between that and the other things and it doesn't appear in any of the other objects okay part of it has to part of it has to deal with the number that we're trying to get to right so if we're trying to cut certain amount we have $75,000 right there that I think is is pretty Bare Bones in the transportation is included in that but that's pretty much the top of it right that's as much as we can cut out of that I mean maybe we get a little bit more I'm not sure um terms

100of reducing a lot of PD and some other things that we can't reduce because they're negotiated um but then to add to that it's like okay so we could do 75 plus you know the whole 1.0 FTE but that puts us you know significantly over what we were asked so um I mean we have sort of a number of things that that we could look at in terms of the budgetary thing and I think we have all of that information in terms of weever cutting in each line and some things do come together so if we have a learning specialist that we don't refill that position because of retirement then some work that we were going to do in the building this summer we probably don't need to do um so we could give that

101back so those are all sorts of options in there but those would me basically what we looked at is we tried to cut as much as we could out of the non-personnel cuts that got us there including field trips including Transportation including everything else once we get past that we're we're looking a significant reduction in terms of student services m yes so thank you um so just to make sure I'm on the same page we had a target of zero we're coming in at 1.04 seems like a lot of that is driven by the reduction in debt service allows us to absorb some of our ongoing expense that 1.04 though we're going to come back in January and we are likely to have negotiations that are completed to drive it up and then which we

102talk in the nonpublic sight yep and but my sense is if we do come to an agreement that will drive the price up right um and then we have our annual discussion about Middle School sports right which is like a right of you know you know it's budget season when we're talking Middle School sports and that could drive the price up as well um so life is full of trade-offs I expect us in January to talk about those tradeoffs and I guess it would be helpful in my opinion for staff to come back and say okay we've had another couple weeks to scrub it here are the options and the order in which we would do them right you know name amount impact and then you can figure out hey do do you want all

103that do you want to trade thing a for thing B um because I I do think once you add in the results of the negotiations are most SCH Sports we're probably going to get to a number that feels worse than 1.04 right do that I mean that would help me I don't know if it would help other board members right so just back of envelope just we F like right so that's a three 322,000 for 1.04 looking ahead at the middle school sport it's like 213,000 right so when you think of what that increase on top of that would be and then we'll talk in nonp public about the additional Madam CH that's exactly right I have a stack of bar chart in my head of 1.04 plus this plus that equals Brown Emoji what

104would you have to you um what are your options you may decide of the school board no no we need all these things um then you got to go face the taxpayers talk to them about it and so it just be good to be able to take what's stacked up with what our realistic options are to stack up from the $122,000 transpo issue to these products he's toart a little bit more NE um agree with that idea I will make life even more complicated for board members by um letting you you know so my latest run of the numbers so one of the reasons why we're having this discussion right not only is it because of the budget guidelines but it's also because of the um perceived pressure that's happening in Norwich um so I

105will complicate all of your laws by saying right now with the numbers that we've been provided nothing has finalized um we're actually looking at a 16% tax rate reduction in Norwich which means then over the span of two years it would end up to be that zero what yes yeah in planed can you can you just two more sentences because that was the opposite of everything including the Valley news article it is yes um so we've seen uh I I don't know that I can necessarily explain it um there was a dramatic increase in the yield number from last year that I believe this is just Neil making some guesses here right that I believe was the result of two things one was increased non-property tax revenue into the education fund so increased amount of

106sales and use tax rooms and meals purchased um property that sort of thing but also combined with that was a was an anticipated reduction in spending by school districts across the state because we've repeatedly gotten the word right spend out of control you all need to ratchet it down so I think those two things combined are what change that yield number so much the second thing that's contributing to the decrease is our change in long-term weighted ADM so in Norwich we pay our property taxes based on how much we spend per student the student as we've talked about before is a weighted student it's not just an actual body count and that number from last year has shot up dramatically I'm a little confused as to why because I don't believe a I know our

107student population didn't change that much and I would be surprised if the if the demographic makeup of the student population changed that dramatically to drive that number up so much so I will admit that there's some uh hesitancy to believe that the number is real um but using the numbers that I've been given we're looking right now at a 16% tax rate reduction with the budgets not including these potential reductions okay um yeah point of information ask a few questions is is so we talked about using Roberts rules so here I am so Neil uh agree direct all all questions need to be directed to permission to interrogate the no I'm not doing that um is isn't it true that part of our tax rate reduction however is based on temporary relief within the Vermont

108funding law that there's presently a discount for towns that are going to get whacked pretty hard and so we get that discount this year but there's no guarantee that we will get it in future years particularly since the state funding formula is likely to change and I'm sure that is correct so it's is it is temporary too good to be true Tony so I would um agree with Mike's proposed you know we had a set of options and I'm I'm not even going to try to heer our budget anymore to norwich's you projections because we you know we've tried do more in the past I mean that's the way I feel I'm not I don't mean it seriously but I mean man that's a whipsaw but the Hanover taxpayer is looking at an increase for

109the reasons night stated and we're not my understanding is that 1 million whatever reduction of the debt roll off we got this year we're not going to have next year so if we even kept a flat budget next year we're going to see major increases because that 1 million still isn't accounted is that an accurate understanding well I mean we would we would see the increases in um the union agreements uh and that kind of thing I mean it's not going to be you know that's not a double digit status quo right it's not that you're GNA lose the 1.2 million you're just going to stay at that total budget number and build on it because you'd be at zero basically our our debt expense this year is Z and so it'll be zero it's

110not zero but you know what I mean like that change you don't lose it again or you don't gain it again as Revenue basically I understand but budget over budget be a bigger increase and now is good that's yeah go ahead we're not overspending we we so I didn't I didn't hear any say over spend so I don't want good we also have a financial update later which we will understand that we are not over I I would make one last comment um a concern that maybe I share with Tony is that okay you pay off the debt that creates tax relief but now some of our base expenditures are absorbing some of that tax relief and so you're in an okay position for this year and if you spend 4% next year you'll get

111a 4% tax increase but your ability if you want to make additional Capital expenditures you have not reserved the capacity to do that that would be on top of the capex that you just converted into Bas spending this budget right right I mean that's how you get a 2% net net assessment increase when you have Union negotiations or beyond that right like that's all right so I I'm inclined to to let the high school speak to their Cuts knowing that for for fairness um knowing that I think I hear a generalized request to have this prioritized in a little bit easier of a manner to make a you know a total dollar decision is that fair is that what I'm I'm hearing yeah okay um so yeah can you so I was asked to cut

112102 or 106 the cuts you see here are 149 so I wouldn't want to necessarily cut more than 106 so I'm going to tell you the priorities that would get us to 106 or 102 one is red it's happening anyway right two is the retirement which I'm really sure we're not going to hire someone of the education and experience that we have now so I think that's going to be there anyway three would be a point two of The Counselor um which would get us the 24K there and then four would be the building adjustment um because we're having an increased enrollment next year I'm hesitant to cut anything from building adjustments in classrooms and things like that even though we value people it's not that is that part of like that room it right

113yeah okay so so I would ra like I'd rather not do that piece that piece I don't think I set forward you put there um the maintenance director forward and doesn't communicate with me good but we would rather not cut building stuff because we have more kids in the building um and so we need all the building stuff we could get so I would go one red two retirement three half of that counselor the point 2 and then that gets us to the 106 so we don't have to do the building adjustment and we don't have to do the point two of The Counselor so we'd only get make the counselor 08 instead of a great thank you Jamie anything else on budget or can we move to war thank you okay so um and

114anything from the public feel freeit well um moving to Warrant articles these are the draft articles which we will um look to approve in January um really what we've been talking about is article um five yes which is the general budget um there will be let's see I'll start kind of quickly at the beginning one is just a normal elections keep in mind that um the the window this is a draft and just taken from the prior year so the if you see people are listed as positions here you know the window to file is still open and is going to continue into January so um you know it is it's not closed it's not closed and so I don't even know if they even their names are on there exactly I know so um

115so that's a typical one um same with article two is similar from last year about um a board member compensation and then article three and four we will talk about in non-public as far as what um the agreements would be de yes I just have a a really quick question about article one and the auditor do we still have to list the auditor position on the ballot because that ends up generating wrs which then have to be counted I know get that cleared up we no it requires an article of an agreement it requires an amendment to our articles of agreement for the interstate pact how easy does that have to go to Congress let us I don't think it does no it doesn't it it just need to be a vote we need War

116we just have to have a warrant article written to remove that from our articles of agreement so we'll get the information we'll get Theo for January thank you I like a lot of yeses to that um and I think that that needs to be on other it might not just be dressed in it might no it just depends I forget what it is but we've done it before and we okay all right um so five five will be the general budget which we just discussed um and then six we'll hear later about Richmond Middle School sports so I'm just kind of moving through quickly um and then article seven um which we'll hear um to talk about the um the donation a little bit later um that might result in a waren article it might

117not um and in addition to other trust funds um that we currently have which may need to just kind of do the ey and cross the T on um and and anything else are there any other warrant articles that should be there or that we would like to clean up okay um yeah sorry just on article two can we note if that's not a change a I removed the note because of the conversation at Hanover about the note being on the one for Handover about the is that about the um not the recomend this is CH or this does not represent a change right I had the note on Handover and I was asked to take it off so I took it off of this one so I can put it back on the note

118was about impact to the tax rate the note was about impact negligible impact of tax right but it also said that it was no change year over-year okay so I took the whole note off but oh so you just wanted that part of the note off we're not increasing our salaries so I'll put the proportion of that back on sorry I miss any other comments questions from the public we will see another draft of that in addition to the budget next month okay so that being said um this is the opportunity for the um finance committee so keep in mind that we have a dresen finance committee which would consist of the Handover finance committee plus a nor Norwich finance committee members um and uh the Handover finance committee has um are currently the only

119appointed members to The Dresden finance committee so I just give that caveat um so this is where the Dresden finance committee would would talk but um Greg from um Handover if you would like to share what the finance committee has commented about the budget and any other things thank you be very brief uh first of all we uh I'm speaking for the committee I'm sure that would agree to have the further scrutiny on potential our cost savings you back but Prime back up primarily I have two comments the first is one of great appreciation for the budget process that you employ and my my compliments and the committee compliments all of those who have been involved in this all in this room and and them elsewhere and going the extra mile and providing us the

120committee the information that we need and particularly um things like Jamie came to one of our meetings and gave a preview uh earlier this fall so that we had a full heads up for uh what we could be seen coming forward so um thank you very much and and great appreciation uh the second thing is is that the comments that were made in the statement from last year uh I have reviewed and understand that all of the things that we had mentioned which included the the salary increases the collective bargaining um compensation in general uh building improvements Staffing levels Sports uh and The Debt Service those subjects have been have been covered off within the bud budget presentation that is either already um been discussed or will be discussed like like War article so appreciate

121that thank you very much thank you okay um yes can I just say as a informative point there are two members on the norch finance committee now yes so that committee has not been appointed to the Dresden Finance it's not an automatic okay appointment sorry but that's great hear they exist so yeah I believe that their mandate is for the town but it would need to have a separate I believe and I'm I'm out over my skis here it's a Norwich School Board um involvement in that process as well and so I think there there is something and I will ask NE the next I I know as being the school board leay on to the finance committee that they welcome norwich's participation in the process and write ups so thank you all right any

122other questions comments okay so I I would like to move to the um oh okay Ella I'll do Ella and then the memorial award we'll save hi uh is it is my turn or yeah okay uh first of all I'm so sorry for being late today the earlier starting time completely slle my mind promise it won't happen again um so council's been council's done two things in the last month first of all we passed a series of two motions that uh lay out some requirements for school clubs when requesting funding for Council from Council and the intent of that was to ensure that clubs are are using that funding for purposes that align with their club's Mission and not for say snacks or other things that aren't necessary to their to their Club um so

123we're um and yeah so we we laid out those guidelines and hopefully we'll be using you know taxpayer money more responsibly in the future and then currently council is discussing a motion brought by two uh sophomore representatives and it's a handbook revision So currently the handbook reads that if a student comes home from a school field trip or sports event after midnight they're Exempted from their first period class the following day and the intent of that is to give students the opportunity to have eight hours of sleep um but uh this current motion wants to amend that to to bring it back to 11: p.m instead of midnight because um so two Council reps believe that with the midnight requirement it wasn't enough time for students to get a full night of sleep so that's

124currently being debated in Council will'll be hopefully voting on that tomorrow at 11:00 a.m. in the course room so if you're interested feel free to stop by and join the conversation thank you Ella any question Kelly L with that also pertain to co-curricular and extracurricular activities like sports or music or that kind of travel Just Sports my understanding is that it applies to all School related extracurricular activities um currently athletic dismissals are better kept track of by the school than say like a model un dismissal but my understanding is that this motion applies to any school related absence where the student gets home or the student's bus gets back to the school after midnight thank you Ben hi Ella has the council done a deep dive into how often this happens like sort of the

125percentage breakdown by raid or activity you know are there like frequent flyers that this happens all the time or is it more occas mishaps yeah so there hasn't been any uh specific data collected but we have the firsthand accounts of some student athletes on Council and as one of them I know it's it's a quite a rare occurrence usually happens for bigger sporting events say state championships and I I think um one student who was on the soccer team said that it maybe happened twice the whole season so it it's quite a rare thing and it's not that students will be missing school once a week it's it's it's quite a rare thing thank you any other questions comments thank you Ella all right so moving on to the McCarthy Bean Memorial award proposal and

126donation from the burn foundation and I believe that Jamie wants to I'll start pick this address um so after we discussed it with the board last time I don't remember when it wasch March yes last year um we went back and we uh read through a lot of different information and spoke with Folks at the um different um like the New Hampshire Municipal folks and everything we got a whole bunch of information to look through and so as you can maybe remember I don't know we um we then uh rewrote uh the document and uh all of its parameters uh in draft form and that has been uh shared because after we wrote rewrote the document and that had uh most of our questions answered we asked to meet with the trustees of trust funds

127uh for the town of Handover and so we had an audience with the trustees of trust funds um and another potential question was raised um and it's about I have uh attached the attorney client a opinion in the I think Executive section of the school board's uh board docks um the other question that was raised by a member of the trustee of trust funds was about RSA 3131 trust funds for districts that have more than one town um and it was the question was raised on whether or not um the dresden's school The Dresden uh constituents which would be the residents of Hannah know it ever voted to vest The Authority um um to adopt funds and have them deposited with the Handover Trustees of trust fund um I I have not located anything we

128have all the books I'm not located anything because I haven't personally had a lot of time to go back through them in the 90s to see uh and some of these other four that Kim mentioned there are four other uh Awards SLS scholarships uh of this type that we already have in the dressing School District that are issued I think annually usually yeah on Awards night and scholarship night and Julie could tell you um so because that was raised by the trustee of trust funds that was sent off to the um Town attorney for their opinion their opinion came back and um it did not match the opinion that we got from our attorney who is a little bit more well-versed in the interstate pact um and so what we have done our attorney said

129if the school district accepts this Memorial award then in his opinion it would require um from RSA 3131 if we don't have can't find the blanket statement to have a warrant article go on to have the folks who fot who vote for Dresden vote on where to invest those funds um it would obviously not be to invest them in Norwich trusty a trust but because in the state of Vermont uh trusts are not vested with an with an outside Source they are kept within your own um um funds with the school district and then just track separately so Vermont does it differently than New Hampshire uh for any type of scholarships or reserves or anything like that uh they don't send them out to another um uh governmental arm or entity so we have asked

130our attorney to please reach out to the town attorney and also to speak with the trustees of trust funds um members as some of them have a lot of um historical knowledge on um but the first step in car caring it forward and it's a timing step right is to see if the Dresden School Board would be willing um to accept the memorial um award is written fund and so that would be our first step if you say yes we'd like to do this then the next step is for us to go and have to see if the town attorney and our attorney can come to an agreement on um the parameters of how to affect that and so that would be a warrant edical and as you know warrant articles have to be done

131and drafted by January so that's why I brought it Forward today yes um this is maybe a question for Julie actually um how does this align with other do we have Council Awards already do are they um does this align I guess yeah we have a council we have a Tom sorry we have a Tom Hamlin cup that we give at the end of the year which is BAS someone who helped as the founder of council so we have other Awards like that um on that day but this seems from your perspective seems to align with something you would guess okay yeah great for sure especially the Democratic nature of it I feel it's I agree I just wanted to hear you say that um Julie before you sorry the the annual cash award amount

132like how does that how are the current like are there cash Awards what cash awards are currently given there are cash Awards yeah of different you know they cash Awards there's an award somebody gives a $100 bill to the person who has a spirit of the class there's other ones that are you know the number 13 gets the um whatever they're going to college there some version of a water bottle and sweatshirt from that school there's different things that everybody does but there is the $100 the highest dollar no because there's a bunch of scholarships there's some that are 250 some are I think 500 I think 500's probably one of the any other questions so where are we to do so it's an or it's an order right it's an order of operations piece

133right um I can't move anything forward on behalf of the school district without approval and acceptance of the school board okay okay that's in speaking with our attorney that's a first step that's not to say that if you do that and we can't take it forward to the next step if there's a hiccup that we can't come back and either resend it or change it right but it as far as in speaking with Dean Edgar or attorney is concerned this is the first step um and I believe he has um he is actively working through contact with the other folks I've given them all of the information as you can see uh in your posting um he also said uh because I asked him about donations um he did say that we could accept donations

134into Dresden um with the caveat that if the warrant article were not to pass that the money would be refunded um we have in the past I will tell you this in my eight years anyway and I think before me uh we have in the past uh taken Memorial Gifts of a onee uh oneyear length we can hold them for one year if like something happens and somebody says I want to give $1,000 to I don't know pick a an right and they send us $1,000 we can deposit it into our uh our um bank accounts and then as long as we've we've dispersed great any other questions I don't I'm Marilyn B um I'm currently a resident of White River Junction but I was for 24 years a Handover resident and I was for

135about the same amount of time I think um on the faculty in fact I was the library media specialist so this heals in some ways like home Church um when we first came to the board in March I don't think Dena and I or the three other folks on our committee had any idea of how long and complicated this process would be and I don't imagine anyone else did either um maybe three or three or four others right the other funds especially because there is precedent yeah I speak from personal experience my mother had left $10,000 for the a with photography pies and every year the town of Hanover sends a check which I give to a Hanover High School senior so there is precedence having having said that and and if you hear some

136frustration don't be surprised it's taking a long time um but our goal is the same we want to recognize remember honor two extraordinary Educators who really initiated most of what makes Hannah High School what it is today that's Dr Bob McCarthy and Mr skip Bean um and we still want to do that um and I have to say that their families have been extraordinarily patient we update them every two or three months and um so we're really hoping that at this meeting you will give us formal approval of the fund as it's written and permission to begin fundraising as Jamie described where'd you go Jamie to hold the money interest and until we know what happens with the rest of the the complicated factors we all we really want is for you to say tonight

137yes we we we approve the fund and we give you permission to start fundraising and these are the caveats and we hope you'll do that thank you and we'll answer any questions people might have any question thank you um and Molly is correct I am rather frustrated and patient um I think it's really important that we don't lose sight of what we're trying to do and it has felt to me over these months that it's gotten lost in a lot of forgive me I don't mean to be rude but administ dvia I mean we really want to do this we want to honor these men and we want to um recognize a Hanover High School school student who has um shown that he or she or they understand the values that these two men brought

138to the school so we're asking you to help us move this forward uh it was going to be addressed in April which is what you said at your meeting in March apparently it wasn't addressed so we would really with with great respect um ask you to do what mly said to approve this award so that we can start fundraising we have received $22,000 from Mrs burn um and we would like to add to that and we would like to start ADV inviting alumni staff and in particular former council members um to contribute thank you for hearing us no other comments thank you thank you very much okay um so we have moving on then no principles will be back down with the other reports um so we're back to reading of policies then okay um

139second time I'll point out these are all second readings M thank you than um were you not going to we do action items later so we do all of our discussions first and then we do actions at the we feel the same thank you I don't know the answer to this could do it out of order and go is that like is that a thing you're making a motion asking the chair if such a motion would be entertainable or not hours not do I hear a motion I have yet to hear one sure go am I making a motion to change the agenda or just to approve it agenda went not a while ago I know that's why I just go for it okay I will move to approve establishing the McCarthy B Memorial award

140fund and accept the aditional donation from the burn Foundation of $2,000 second okay Deb seconds all those and we are all here so all those in favor that is a unanimous and just for the minute taker we have Tony Lily Deb Ben myself Tara Kelly um Michael Costa and Neil here um so thank you all for that unanimous vote thank you thank you question we'll be in touch tomorrow dotting ties and Crossing tees does that mean that we have commission to begin fundraising can we discuss that tomorrow sure I'm not the one to answer that answer thank you ask okay reading of policies now um so these are all um second readings and they are about curriculum development the template in the process and adoption and advanced coursework um early graduation comments or questions or

141yeah and and I I'm just curious just spased on a discussion about advanced math and advanced languages I I maybe might read this policy with those lends um it says High School right one of them involves um the advance hor I don't see agenda for the policy comme oh yeah great there are some there are stuff coming that pertains to middle school that's not our discussion tonight this says well in high school right those are school okay okay all right I see okay yes and just to be clear these are required by law all right boiler PL you didn't change much okay thank you discussion not much change okay seeing no discussion Perfect all right moving on um to burn Foundation donation to RMS this is for the fitness room so this is sort of

142um Missy wrot a grant the burn Foundation to match up to a certain amount of money to redo our fitness room which we basically Cobble together through things that have been donated or quite literally found on the side of the road at times um try to get back a number of elliptical all sorts of other machines that are not electric so they're not a draam don't increase our problem footprint and what we asked for was Mrs burn and said that they would match up to $30,000 and what we asked for was well could you match the half that we've raised so far so that we can go ahead and start the outl and start doing it so we don't have to do it all at once and she said yes so that's the amount of

143money and that's what we're going to use it for yeah um I'll not that the gift letter at least for me doesn't seem to be working link okay but uh secondly so with no Middle School sports at the moment um is this equipment all used through like a gem class yes okay uh they offer Fitness units throughout the year and then they actually offer elective boxes in Fitness in the second half of the year we have a number of students who are for whatever reason really interested in doing that we also use it for um in the winter for students who need to burn off little steam so but yeah it's it's offered on a a fairly regular basis is it offered like before school after school to whoever needs it or uh we have

144offered it at at times before before school but mostly out class the after school part we have to make sure we have done it in limited times in the past because we have to have somebody to supermark I think that the we would have more you we would be able to use it more because the equipment is newer and a little bit sturdier right now the equipment that we have is it has to be used in a very particular way in order for it to work any other question moving on then thank you very much Tim um and thank you very much burn foundation for the donation um we will move uh to take action on that later in the item in the agenda Financial update Jamie I I see we are in a a

145favorable position according to this last update we are it's um it's not the end of a quarter so we'll bring it back to you once the uh once December closes okay yeah there's in January so there's some ups and downs we want to look into um there's some overe expenditures that we want to vet again um specifically in vocational so yeah we want to take a look at a few of those Teresa's been at actually put all that together for us so um and has been working on all of the stuff in the background and looking at the revenues I think we did pick up a couple of I don't know if they're part-time is but I need to double check A couple more tuition students so that number might rise a little bit more

146so yeah for for uh for December 30th and we'll bring it back in January so now thank you any questions for Jamie and we get the Food Service ones updated too they're on a bit of a lag so we wer we didn't report on food service and March intensive is just ramping up now right huge um so we'll bring all of those Fs in January okay yeah perfect thank you anything no um moving forward now Middle School draft budget proposal I'm looking at Kelly yes so I um if you guys refresh this evening um there should be a PowerPoint that I put together just to try to move it through faster but um it it's just all of the documents that were previously attached in a it should be put it before meeting okay cool

147um so you guys should be following so um just a thank you to the members of the committee as you can tell um we we were slow kind of starting but then we've met um four times in the past month and we another meeting tomorrow so we've been meeting weekly to try to get this kind of pulled together for Budget um for the W articles and such to go before the voters um so we have Garrett uh Ben and myself from the board and then John Sherman and Justin perrow from HPR Brie wison from Norwich Parks Andre um and then Megan soel our athletic director and Tim Bole the principal at our M on the committee um and of course Jay The Perennial Committee Member um and we've had I will note we've had a

148lot of other um community members joining us for meetings so um I I will name them all but we have had coaches join us we've had um other staff members from RMS um we've had our um Teresa joined us one day so we've had um quite a few people come and um contribute to the conversation which has been wonderful and really appreciated um lots of buy and lots of good conversations um I will note our next meeting is actually tomorrow so we're looking forward to some board feedback for that um unfortunately we were not able to meet with the STA which is a big piece of the puzzle um and we will be meeting with them tomorrow so um there are some holes in the conversation and some holes in the budget that we just

149couldn't answer until we are able to meet with them tomorrow so um and then we will continue to meet after the budget season after we kind of finalize all this just to help um put more Logistics into place and I'll go into that in a second um so one of the first things we did was come up with a mission statement because um I think you know Garrett mentioned this when the uh dresen athletic committee was meeting um in previous years um there was a a lot of work done on whether this should go forward right and our understanding this time around was that the charge from the board was that this needed to go forward and so we really went into this um Endeavor with that in mind that our charge was to develop

150a comprehensive plan that would EST established Middle School athletics at the ridge of Middle School um we we are intending to serve not only current RMS students but also eligible students in the sau70 district acknowledging that we have some homeschooled students we have Crossroad students all of those students are eligible within um State statutes to participate so um our initial charge focuses on seventh and eighth grade sports but we also recognize very quickly the need for flexibility and the potential to expand the program in the future um and you'll see throughout language about sports co-curricular um so there's you know first steps but then also an aspiration to expand the program down the road so um guiding principles that we've been working with um I'll read these high level um number one we believe that

151learning extends beyond the classroom we believe that developing a thoughtful inclusive Middle School athletics program aligns with the student support pillar of our strategic plan um number three um essentially by hiring an athletic director or co-curricular athletic director see there's the language um and developing a responsible budget we hope to address some key priorities that have come out um and the biggest one is that HPR and NPR have said we want to be done with seventh and eighth grade Sports and so that's I that's a pretty big exigent circumstance for us to move forward with this um there's a lot of access and inclusive questions School identity School Spirits safety um developmentally appropriate educational approach to Athletics and co-curricular activities in general um and then the last bullet point I think is pretty important alignment

152with other local Middle School sports programs we really are the only middle school that's not currently offering any kind of Athletics program um when you go just my my role is track and field as you guys know um and when you when you go to the Middle School State track meet there are 200 some schools there we are the only non-school program represented at that so um these were some of the things that were kind of guiding our work um so moving on to the budget um so to start our our idea here is to ramp up in the first year so start with the winter um hire an athletic director for the fall um that would start in August um and there would would be there in time to build a lot of this

153so we're going to do some of the initial planning um but then hopefully this person would come in and have the time to really put all this into place so we will not be starting with fall Sports in the first year we would start with winter um we've intentionally left the sports blank here um again with the idea that this person who's hired would be able to have input into those Sports um you can kind of tell from the winter our thinking is basketball that seems um because we have the facility there um acknowledging that RMS was not built with sports with Middle School sports in mind there's nowhere for people to currently sit to cheer for a basketball team so there are some you know we we know there are some some issues obviously

154that need to be ironed out down the road um but this is a starting point so um one sport in the winter and then hopefully two sports in the spring two sports The Following fall um the overall program costs um down below we included 30,000 for equipment and uniforms for the first year figuring that there would be some ramp up um we we hope that's a high-end estimate honestly because um we're hoping to collaborate with HPR take some of the basketballs they're no longer going to be using and you know some some of that stuff but uniforms are going to be all new um so some of that will higher than normal cost in the first year and then there would be a yearly replacement cycle put in place um rental practice Bas is still

155a bit of a question mark As we said in the first year we hope that that won't have any cost Associated um it would depend what that Spring sport um situation is but there are a lot of facilities that we would be able to access for free so um that is sort of the where the budget's at for right now um any questions on that this pointel I guess um is this like all gross expenditures or is it net of activity fees paid by app Andes that's a good question it's gross and just a followup question I may currently Middle School families pay HPR and NPR for these sports right and at the high school do athletes and parti pay so has the committee come down with a decision on what it what it's you

156know view is on user fees for Middle School sports I think our our view we have not come to a final decision and it that revenue is not Incorporated in this budget um thank you for pointing that out um but I think the Comm committee consensus was that there should be some sort of participation fee um with financial aid built in as part of Department yes yeah I would even go as far as as to say that the discussion has said you know in our last conversation that I recall we said it should fall somewhere between the high school and the hprb yeah and then also to make sure that we get appropriate buy and not everyone says yes to everything and then no shows which we have to keep track of in terms of

157Transportation considerations yeah um and secondly in terms of budget this also does not include the offsets that you believe Han par could give to the tax pair in terms of losing programming it wouldn't be all of this and some of it would be redistributing dollars to older and younger communities than middle school but there will be some offsets from HPR and they will give us that number once they finalize that um did the committee um did did did the committee ask um because I know NPR and HPR were were in these meetings they ask how much Middle School currently how much it cost them the towns to operate goad part of this deres from the costs to them one of the things we're going to run into is we anticipate that registration and counts of

158students will go up fairly dramatically once it's brought to the schools in terms of number of people participating which would then impact pricing of costs of registration and busing and all that sort of thing so it's hard to consider but that is and me in the high school was source of as what grades did I miss that however I you know so a couple things I realized as we were discussing more In Articles when we put this on were asking Hanover sixth grade families to also fund this like there's a tax implication for All Families not just 7th a period families um you know part of our vision was to and I took out some of the extra wording on the slides but if you go into the backup documents um part of our vision

159is is to have um essentially in-house opportunities that are not travel basketball that are not travel you know that are giving intramural intramural type or open gym type opportunities that are getting all kids an opportunity to participate move um be together have that social moment um and that's something that we would really want to this program to offer as well um and that would be at basically zero cost it's just the Personnel right um which would already be built in um so that would be probably open to all grades the other thing you know we started thinking about track and cross country for example it doesn't make a lot of sense to just offer that to seventh and eth when it's pretty easy to offer that to all grades at the same time so I

160think there are things like that um that need to be ironed out down the road um so HPR is currently planning to keep this sixth grade teams where those are team sports that is the current plan so that's where the seventh eighth grade Focus came from but um for example track currently is sixth seventh eth and even some fifth graders right so it wouldn't make sense to split that out seven and keep the sixth graders by themselves right that doesn't make sense so I think there's some flexibility that needs to be built in I would just say in response to your caveat about sixth grade parents voting for something that they don't benefit from I vote for something every very true every year don't have any current sixth graders no I don't so I think

161I think the most important thing is to have a the big picture of about what's where the benefits are and where we lag behind other programs in other school districts and not single out the sixth grade and worry about that they do get single out a lot don't they in our Tri so um in terms of like the cost versus HPR H doesn't provide any transportation I think it's the huge win for it as a middle school but it's also a huge cost um I appreciate all the work your committees put into this I'm wondering how the coaching are you imagining it same model as High School coaches we have spent a lot of time talking about that um and I will say So currently HPR is offering siphons to coaches that was new I

162believe as of two years ago something like that's fairly recent um and that was in their attempt to start to kind of professionalize coaches and get coaches exactly um it they're not paying a going rate I guess for coaches so we have bumped that up to something that more closely resembles um but is still slightly less than the high school we again kind of tried to thread that needle um in terms of the model we have spoken with Megan and she envisions um a model where those coaches would get some sort of um you know they would be welcome to kickoff meetings at the start of the Season there might be some mentorship opportunities with high school coach is um so that's again as I mentioned this committee envisions continuing the work through the spring

163hopefully not at a break every single we face but um to to continue some of those conversations right I think there's a lot that can be leveraged um with the wonderful coaching staff that we have at the high school for sure did I see and one of the things that came up at these meetings was going back to the previous surveys of the last couple years to kind of do it specific what do we what do people say about sports and one of the things we found out by honing in on that is that um this is a top three issue for parents of all four schools not just RMS parents and that about 85% of our students across the SAU participate in sports and about 40% do so through the towns this is k12

164and 83% of parents believe that Sports should be at least partially subsidized by taxpayers at RMS specifically all of those are higher um especially about 2third of all RMS students do Sports through the towns currently and so a lot of that's going to go away with HPR deciding to end their program there was also a survey that was done that I think Tim mentioned um a few months ago that was done by students through the middle school that indicated strong support for this concept one was in as well as we've all gotten numerous comments to to each other directly and at board meetings and pre text comments and surveys all look at this as a big issue is there another question can move on to the um maybe one comment and one question the the

165comment would be if the committee is going to entertain um uh subsidizing the cost through activity fees I would strongly encourage you to review our Equity policy when you do that just to make sure that that's an alignment personally I think we're going in the opposite direction that we want to be going in if we're going to start charging activity fees for Middle School sports I think probably what we ought to be looking at is removing those activity fees at the high school level from an equity perspective um and then the second thing and maybe this is a little bit of a devil's attive but the question is why a warrant article why not put it in the budget y so can we move on to the warrant article in take way to answering that

166question um welcome yeah thank you for that um so so and and this is you'll see it's draft of proposed so it's a very drafty draft um but it it's a drafty draft yeah um we we fiddled with this a lot because we don't actually Envision this as a pilot program we envision it as a ramp up for a program that is a priority for our district um that said the committee had fallen on the warrant article um approach this year partly to reaffirm uh voter support for this program that was one of the concepts that we had talked about um and also because of where we are in the budget cycle I think this this might be a cleaner Approach at this point um but we struggle with it because as I said I

167think this um the the language for structuring this worn article when we we don't want it to be a one-year program you know our vision would be that it would be rolled into the budget next year um and so we we did we you know you see pilot program in there um uh Dean helped us craft this um so we wrote it as a non-aps appropriation to sort of emphasize that this is something that we want to continue um but I I I think we all agree that ultimately next year it it would become part of our regular programming and therefore would become part of the regular budg I think that's the vision okay um so I I think we can maybe keep it simpler so I think the reason for carving it out is

168because it's it's a newer program that we might want to get some support around I think if we were to include it and the budget and Dre and gets voted down would we just cut this item and or would we have feel like we'd have to cut more so I think the question if we keep it separate it's very clear what our commun I I think from the actual language I think we might be getting a little cutesy um I and I'm not Dean um but just kind of asking do you support appropriating whatever the dollar amount is for on the expenditure side for establishing a middle school sports program I don't think because next year right every budget year is always up in the air right so I just I I think to keep

169it you know yeah so maybe a little bit just just you know and you can actually see at the backup documents because our our previous document actually made it into the backup documents so what we had hoped to do was write it as a two-year showing that ramp up as we do with teacher contracts for example and we cannot write it that way that's not allowed that's a special commit so we can't we cannot write it that way so this was I think Dean's workaround for that um but your suggestion is just write a one year word I mean and then the following year could that board could decide to put it in the general warn article because then it just become maybe it's super successful and we actually want to ramp it up really

170quickly and increase it either right I don't um I saw J yes I I do I like the idea of the warn article also from the perspective that this this evening we're having a conversation about cutting almost the same amount of money out of the middle school budget and if you were to just fill that hole with Athletics instead of having as a separate item to be voted on by the public I I wouldn't feel as comfortable with it thankfully I'll go okay I I recognize what Jay said and then I worry next year if you try to roll this into the budget somebody's going to say well we else you're going to cut your 200 whatever thousand do and I don't know there's a solution to that but let next year's board look back

171on this conversation and realize it was not Tim's fault that next $1,000 J everyone else went away if it goes well though it is almost like cliche that like when it's a tough budget year it's almost like a like a red hering cut that you say oh we're gonna cut Sports and everybody comes out to say you can't cut Sports so yeah that got Cuts two ways I think you can go Ben Ben okay and and the two things one they mentioned this is a drafty draft ending I love that phrase um but also that we're going to have poopus language in the notes kind of indicating what we talked about where it's a relative drop in the bucket hbr's losing it you know all these different things so this is purely the legal language

172not the Layman's language that's going to go in on the end of all this which we're currently crafting so pardon my ignorance so let's say it's its own separate warrant article this year when does it just become part of the regular budget or when we decide what's going to be different in some subsequent year than is now that augers that you really should hang it out because it's War me the first year we're we're doing this in what has been historically budgetarily difficult times maybe maybe not the future right and so the idea is um you know keep it simple have have a status quo budget that people can decide to support or not and have a clear distinction of a new program um that is even of itself not totally new but new for

173our district to run and have that support be clear for both of those I think if you roll it into one I I think that's what should happen next year because it's there's special about the following year um but I think for this year having two FS like an easier vote person as a follow question is it a reasonable expectation when we go to vote on the budget and War next month that we will have the net an estimated net cost for this program because I I think you have to include the revenue you anticipate proposal there'll be rejections obviously based on student numbers and all that kind stuff but that that is the committee's aim is to get that level specificity I would also just say that you know I would love it if

174there were a couple hundred people zooming audience members people sitting here but the reality is that a lot of people don't pay any attention at all to what's going on they probably don't know that HPR and NPR talking I mean who knows what they do don't know but it seems just from a prudent perspective that bringing forward a change like this um it it's a win situation for us because we're saying to the public this is a a direction we're going in this is something we think is important this is part of our mission but we recognize that for some of you this is the first you're hearing about it so we want to be careful careful and mindful of how money is spent and give it to you as a standalone object I fully

175anticipate that people will vote for it once they hear this is going away and this is going away and by the way we're the only school that doesn't do this because people hate thinking that we are failing in some fashion and we'll we'll put some bit the notes that we'll get um yeah so we'll we'll add all that to the notes are we we have very specific things we going put in mind that we ready for public consumption today but also the hbr winding down 78 Sports it's not a secret but speaking for myself I would say they're not really advertising it because they're working with us somehow best to publicize that but people my age who really do come out and support the budget they are so far away from knowing about and thinking

176about the W department and what they're doing other than offering sour dough bread glasses and bouncy house and things like that they just they're they're they're detached from it right so there have been comments at the committee that we not in level detail yet but sort of public forums or public announcements and sort of walking through the need the concept what hbr is doing and not doing regarding to this that all that it's early stages but we are planning to address that just HPR NPR have been wonderful through this process and they are both not only 100% on board but but 100% on board with cooperating to roll this out in the smoothest most um child centered way possible including access and things and so I just want to express appreciation for that um it's

177been a really good process working with them great I guess my my question is um has the committee talked about why not to do this like what why why shouldn't we yes it's come up a lot um especially that's part of why we spent a good amount of time on mission statement right because I think that there was initially a lot of push back um from from some people and I think um not careful consideration careful consider no there yes yes I well a confusion I think is a is a good way to put it it's been going great for you know that's kind of what has been said been going just fine why do we need to change it right um and I think you know there is definitely this the shift in the

178community um away from hbr wanting to stop doing this is a big piece of it and so part of our thinking is I don't know that we really have a lot of option on that front right that's my understanding in this um but also I think you know we really started to think about the kids how much the kids have pushed for this how much the families have pushed for this um and so I think the main reason to not do it is that it's a lot to take on I think that's the reason you know it is it's not it's not like waver magic wand and we're going to have you know Athletics at the middle school um but and then the transportation piece which is one of the biggest things as Tony said

179that everyone wants it is still a big question mark and we're working on that um and we've just made the decision not to let that hold up the rest of of planning at this point um but those I think those logistical pieces are the big reason to not do it right I don't think it's cost so much as figuring out those logistical pieces I think the other if I could Tim I was going to say I think the other questions that came up um have to do with uh different people within the community believing that is answering different questions so some people see it as fulfilling one need some people see it as fulfilling another need and I think we're trying to get working through the committee to be like clarity as to what exactly

180are we doing are we offering for everyone so that we make sure that people have access that they don't have before or are we offering something that's going to be feater program to a very successful High School athletic program we might be able to do both but those also could be diametrically opposed to each other so we're just trying to make sure that we have Clarity going in because I think one of the things that happens when you when you talk to people about sports is it means different things for different people and those things can then come to a head um rather quickly if we don't sort of have those that that those are basically the um the concerns that I've seen in the committee is okay we're going forward this we need to

181make sure that we do it right when we get it going um because there's certain things that you know we're not going to be able to do as a middle school SP sportsin we're not going to be able to compete with Ford s we're not going to be able to feel the Middle School ice hockey team there are other things that we can do and I think do really well um and the the sports program here is really good and we don't have a high school sports program I mean a middle school sports program but our hbr they won the state championship in Cross Country so the kids from the school are still doing pretty well thank you hey Lily has can you just give a summary of what's been discussed in terms of non

182sports co-curricular at this point honestly very little nothing I I will say nothing at this point um I think it is very and I think it's very much um something that everyone wants to see happen um I I will say I think next steps for us is going to be um thinking about a job description and that's where that rubber is really going to hit the road because are we going to try to hire someone who can simultaneously plan lead and uh manage the sports program and also start a wonderful theater music program after school I don't know that that unicorn exists maybe I mean other than Ben right but maybe that maybe maybe that person does exist I don't know if that's a realistic job description but that's you know that's the kind of

183detail we're gonna have Julie you you might just want to check Le and high school job description the athletic director is their co-curricular director okay so they I mean Ben went there our Ben went there and he's trying to do both it's challenging but that's their model perfect so I will call then yeah and just terms that the co-curricular question is that was the directive that the board made for this committee was to focus on Sports at least initially we kind have to also thread that the do description that we envision become that while still speaking to seven eight Sports as the originating thing yeso Musical on soccer and to the point that Tim just made that decision on what type of program is going going to be offered when does that decision is that

184an administrative decision that happens later or go ahead so okay the numerous things that that Tim alluded to and you know we went well beyond what just Tim Tim says what is our philosophy around Cuts what is our philosophy around a team versus B team or is it 8th versus 7eventh you know things like that and the broad answer is really going to be it depends kind of on the sports and the counts we're going to get and that's one of the reasons the mission statement was developed in the first place was to account for things like that a lot of the granularities are not going to be in the mission statement but for the only thing we've discovered I think as a group that we're all 100% behind is no cuts the other things

185will be be a place for every yeah there's going to be a place for everybody and then how does that fit in with things like you know was this like Tim was mentioned a feeder school where it's going to create Champions out of every high school because of what they did in Middle School probably not but we want to give everyone an opportunity so whether it's going to be intramural stuff like weekly pickle ball versus baseball Champions and everything in between it's going to be largely up to the individual Sport and what the athletic director position is able to Envision and the counts we get yeah sorry just one having been on this board long enough I can Envision where this discussion is going to do especially if this gets approved because for years at

186the high school level we always entertained a request to add a new sport and I see that that's where this is headed if this thing gets approved and this year you're looking at $250,000 in five years you're looking at $500,000 um and what will be the board that has to deal with it at that point and so I caution you now that if you want to spend the time to develop the criteria by which a new sport would be evaluated and entertained that was one of the challenges that we had and dresen at the time is there was no set set of standards for a a sport like that we had some you had to go through it had to be self-funded for some initial period of time and then they came in front of

187the dresen board and they're like we're looking for full funding yeah and yeah and I I don't disagree um however I don't think those conversations should happen ahead of having someone in place as the Director of the program so I think what and I agree with you I think we can have some of the conversations right but I don't think we can put in black and white this is this is the criteria without that person on board um that said I think that's part of why we have developed something that ramps up with the first year acknowledging that yeah the program hopefully will grow in future years to some extent right budget permitting and that I think is is part of the question as well yeah sorry nean also walked us through like what happens

188still where we get new sport requests at the high school yeah and sort of the process that goes through there Jay I think there's some natural constraints on it because we're all already wrestling with where are these teams going to practice play um Unless somehow we acquire new land or something I just don't know that we would have the fields to be able to bring on multiple team sports and season I think there are some natural constraints that should keep things you know within reason Tony apologize for missing further discussion but I don't see any reason I think we need to approve Middle School sports um or at least a warant article for Middle School sports and I think these are a lot of details that will get worked out but the conceptually that we

189will have another school schs that we will be offering them I think needs to get approved and it needs to get approved soon so we can get into the budget if you guys have um specific considerations or thoughts please send them to me um as I mentioned our last 2024 committee meeting will be tomorrow um so if you go home tonight and you have pressing thoughts that you'd like me to share with committee tomorrow please send them my way um and then we will meet in January again can I propose like you know maybe for this board we'll get at the next time we see the next draft of the budget we'll also see another hopefully finalized right I'm just trying janary so we anticipate having including tomorrow's meeting we shouldn't be able to have

190approximately four meetings right so if there there are any questions or concerns to the chair of feel free to send them to Kelly um and uh hopefully we we can see them on a version two um seeing that I'm hoping we can kind of go through our action items before we go to non is that correct yes okay so can I hear so moving on to business requiring action that's where we are um yes a note that we've already approved one of them move to approve items B C D and F by consent do I hear a second Lily second all those in favor yes that is unanimous and we still have all the same people as here before so thank you very much um excellent um we have reports of the chair I have

191nothing to report now I was gonna say more but I have to report um we have uh anything from the Committees great um I think we got a lot of reports during our regular meeting um and then we see Robin's report and I am in to thank you Robin for being with us you're welome questions for Robin no questions Robin I'm inclined to move on um and then Jay do you have anything to I just had three quit Rings I'll be Chris bman um so first off I want to wish everybody Happy Holidays whatever holiday you celebrate uh we're right on the verge of a two week break for our schools and we're excited about that the SAU will be closed to uh to the public anyway the first week of a break but we'll

192be open again the second uh second thing I want to let in the context of all this budget discussion Jamie and I have four active investigations right now into enrollment fraud and so and there's no no sense of whether or not this is this is the tip of the iceberg or not what we always hear that this is going on we we're actually looking for help in in um in bird dogging some of these and the the commonality among all all four that we're looking at right now is that we have we have individuals that are apparently very high netw worth folks who are using that to acquire rental properties and then and then using those rental properties as sort of a a way to get their students and in some of these situations we've

193got students that are very high need and and are on IEPs for example and so this is this is we're we're looking at actually trying to use some help from an existing employee employe who has some background that we think will be helpful to us in uh in doing a better job of policing these things and and it's it's particularly like appalling to me when we have people that are unhoused and people that are can't find affordable housing when we have people taking up uh rare rental units for this purpose and so we're we're going after this and um I I think I'll conclude my report there happy holidays you're cheating the system and I think just to just to clarify that because I think that could be surprising to people who don't know the

194law to access public education it's not that you own property um that you have the right if you need to be a resident which means you have like certain number and I'm summarizing this as a very basic level you know number of nights that you sleep you know your head on the pillow needs to meet a certain threshold to be considered a resident not just because you happen to own property a CER location so I think that can be surprising for everyone they're like well I paid property taxes you know that kind of thing but that's not the law for your ability to access public education so all right um thank you and any principal reports I'm seeing a big shaking of the head and Tim do you have anything to report if you have

195any questions okay great any questions for either Tim or Julie thank you very much um all right so we do have a need for non-public um so if I hear a motion to go under nonpublic for me and also probably there's a Personnel I don't I don't have a personel okay okay just just the E just the one that's there yeah okay I'll do it I moveed to enter into non oh God I took my glasses off moveed to enter into non-public session at 8:58 p.m. under RSA 91a calling 3 Roman numeral 2 pen e pen negotiations do I hear a second second second by Michael all right um we have to go around the horn for these right so uh Tony bar yes kman yes Nelson yes Keeny yes M yes cost yes Odell

196yes all right and Hartman yes that is unanimous in public and we need to bring anything administrators e e e okay we are back in public session and we um will have a motion to entertain um seeing from Tony move to approve the the Association tenative agreement as presented as present second by Deb okay um and I also know we moved into um open session at 912m um voting sorry yeah I guess discussion I think I seeing none voting all those in favor it is unanimous and everyone who is presented four for prior votes are here now yes thank you very much we have one last public comment and I don't see anybody from the public who would like to make a comment unless it's Noah um and the agenda topics uh for the next

197meeting is is listed we'll be obviously talking about the budget and um preparations for annual meeting and Middle School sport at the second January meeting right or is it the first one um I'm also happy to make it it doesn't mean to be an agenda item if you all are happy with what we bring to you right like I can make it a report this is our agenda we have an updated budget have a word article to you we by January 7th there's a meeting on January 28th as well okay I how about I I will work with Kelly to see when the best time is for that thank you but we will talk about the war article a minimum um and do I hear a motion to a journ yes de I move to

198a journ at 9:14 p.m. second and second all right all around the horn meal yes Nelson yes yes there Harman yes uh thank you very much we are adjourned that time and next meeting is Tuesday January 7th

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.