001e e e one that's okay with you now right agenda review does don't have to add anything and move things around we did add two items to nonpublic a couple hours ago one related to contract the other related to a Personnel issue so anyone else see anything none righte we're open with a brief public hearing regarding the donation before we get to the regular board maybe La you want to walk us through this off donation yes um so in in our budget process um our music department which includes our general music teacher um Miss Emma greo along with our band teacher Faith goodness and then our strings teacher um Nick sonon um had some ideas about how to peque interest in instruments that we currently don't offer to students while also expanding the current program
002that we have in general music as well as band and strings um in the process of normal budgeting um you we told people dream big think about those things be ready to defend them and then also think about potentially other funding sources um and just with that sort of one Q as the music department went over their hopes and dreams um they noticed that their hopes and dreams had a pretty large dollar side next to it so they all on their own pursued some alternate funding for uh their hopes and dreams for the music department which they articulated in the grant that you see before you um and we were just so excited and honored and pleased to hear back from Mrs burn who offered our music department $220,000 in favor of funding um many
003of the items that were requested so tonight before you you can take a look at the proposal um as well as what Mrs burn responded to our music department and we're as always just so incredibly grateful for what the foundation does for our community and also our school someone got what the viola issue it's um well taken and we appreciate the burn Foundation as always for this very generous response to our application I would just like to um re request that we get a total amount that the burn Foundation has given to us as hover and certainly also Dres because it's an extraordinary and we we always say thank you as individual donations are made but I feel really strongly that we should be doing something to celebrate darthy Burn's generosity as school dist and
004I also want to just observe that I never knew a bassoon cost over $77,000 yes and you you may recall from a previous meeting too that um that uh our band teacher also made a request to their friends andge schools too and received a donation build it's amazing to the last yes and we're all missing the Orest concert yes but it's incredible how much what they've Leed here and how it keeps going and there were like solos yesterday that were on inspiring so many much thanks to per Foundation yes any other comments from board members or our copious public members here tonight anyone online for those folks online please refer to raise your Zoom hand and we'll call on you as appropriate right in that case we will take a motion if someone would care
005to make it I moved to approve the donation with sincere gratitude from the bur foundation in the amount of $20,000 to be used for the race school music program as presented seconded by Tony all those in favor that's just us tonight okay is unanimous 5 uh for the notaker I note that Marcel is traveling and will not be with us tonight uh Kelly I believe will be calling in eventually from her offsite location but she has not joined us has of yet and we're going to close the hearing and move to the regular board meeting will take public comment at this time if you wish to speak about something not related to an item already on the agenda please raise your hand virtually or now in person now otherwise please hold until your specific topic
006comes to us anyone nothing here and nothing online all right thank you much we'll move right along to the principal's report what's going on Lauren I'll see the majority of my time to the all important presentation around the budget tonight um but just highlighting a few things that have happened uh noting that one of the weeks um was taken up by partial part of the week was taken up by Thanksgiving break so this always comes really quickly the December principal's report comes fast so quick enrollment update we're one uh one up since last month and we are anticipating two more students joining us in uh January um I had the pleasure of going to Manchester New Hampshire um with Ben and Jay for the second 22nd annual celebration of leadership and education awards ceremony and
007you can read that about that there we joined by some other guests as well and some other folks that were honored um just a gratitude to the PTO for a lovely lunch that they put on on one of our new dismissal days so we were holding conferences but also got to enjoy some delicious lunch as well as gratitudes from families and a sort of high five written on um some handprints uh we had an excellent opportunity for for our student St that you can read about through our music program um and then uh just letting everybody know that we have concluded our first um conferences of the year so next up we'll have digital progress reports coming out on January 24th um and then our next set of conferences happen in March pleased to report
008that we hired one new inclusion EA since the last time that we met but there are still many positions open anybody that is watching or interested please reach out or so looking for more great folks um our media Specialists uh along with a team of volunteers hosted our winter book fair which was a great success and in support of our birthday book program um and then we have some upcoming great activities including the dmouth basketball education day that our students will be attending um hopefully that you can enjoy the artwork on display at MoMA Bank downtown during this holiday season and then we're always supporting our community Through Haven helpers donations items listed there are items that can be donated to the school for the Haven this month happy to answer any questions thank you
009Lauren any questions from the board any questions from the public say thank you much Laur appreciate it there's definitely surreal at that uh that dinner see who who we were standing with it was very surreal and nice it was special education update welome BR Derek to the floor hi Brat J CH full screen thanks uh uh I'm Rett Derek I'm the director for student services uh and during the budget season I like to give an update an overview of special education because it is a substantial portion of the ray school budget um so I'm going to briefly go over what special education is some data specific to the ray school and then implications for the and any questions while I'm speaking please just interrupt me or raise your hand and have um so special education
010is all governed by the individuals with Disabilities Act Education Act which is federal education law and then States Implement that in accordance with the law and make a few changes depending on what state um really the the overview is that students with disabilities need to be afforded the same educational opportunities and appropriate programs as students without disabilities and so there are lots of laws paperwork procedures um foundational principles in place to ensure that happens and as a public school we're responsible for educating all children regardless of ability uh a few primary tenants uh fate is free appropriate public education that students with disabilities should be educated and will be educated with no additional cost to the parents in a way that's appropriate to their learning L is least restrictive environment which ensures that students with
011disabilities are educated in the classrooms with their general education teachers with their peers as much as possible and they're only removed when necessary because the needs related to what and then IEP is the the program and the document that's created that details child strengths where their needs are what the school is going to do about it what the services the supports the programs are and then there are goals which are measured to ensure that the child Mak hards next slide very briefly the the process is structured and regulated by the state and so there are timelines to ensure both that the school district doesn't delay an addressing needs but also allows the school district sufficient time to complete the process that we need to a referral is the first step and that can be made
012by a parent a teacher in New Hampshire it can be anybody could be a neighbor they could contact the school and when we get that information we have to meet within days to address the concerns look at school records and decide do we feel like a special education evaluation is necessary if the team says yes they would suspect a disability category which I'll show on the next slide and then we have to complete assessments evaluations gather information within 60 days meet and determine if the child's eligible to be eligible for special education in an IP there's three criteria excuse me one you have to meet the definition of one of the educational disabilities and there are 13 different ones that disability has to have an adverse effect on your learning so we have a number
013of students at the r School in across se70 that have some condition whether it's anxiety disorder ADHD my learning disability that doesn't adversely impact their learning significantly that they need an IP but they may need some accommodations or additional supps um and there colle students where there is a significant adverse impact and then they need something specifically designed for them based on their needs and that's that third criteria once that decision is made within 30 days the team meets and develops that plan that IEP and then implements it as soon as possible afterwards and then every year that whole document and plan is reviewed by the team updated looked at progress it can be updated sooner but at least once annually and then every 3 years um the child goes through a re-evaluation to look
014at do they continue to be eligible for an IP and where their needs at now and what progress has been made so we can redesign the program to make sure it's aligned with where Curr what would happen if a parent like disagreed like they come to you or some like I think they need help for X issue you investigate you say I don't think this is an issue what do they what would they do next if they disagree with you uh it depends on which part of the process so if if we have a referral meeting and the school team and the parents and anyone else that's a part of that Child's World wants to attend and the school team looks at and says no the child's making sufficient progress and the parent disagrees and
015says well I really want an evaluation um the option at that point is to either use something called alter alternative dispute resolution which is the process they can engage in with the school district or with the state to try to reach an agreement on that disagreement um if the evaluation is completed and the team goes through the assessment results and finds that the child doesn't meet the criteria but the parent disagrees that same process can be used the parent can also request an independent evaluation and that would be at public expense so in the regulations if parents disagree with our evaluation um they can have an independent evaluation done by someone that's not an employee of the school district have that completed and then the school team would me to review that inform this is
016a list of special education disability categories um they don't necessarily align with medical diagnosis uh they each have their own specific definition that's written into the idea regulations and part of what the assessment looks at is do they meet that criteria so you can be a student with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder but you may not need an IP for because it's not significantly impacting your learn um similarly with speech language impairment you can have some articul articulation issues um I did many years of speech so I'm fluent in that process um and that may not be adversely impacting your educational experience you you may still want to seek out some support but it's not something you have developmental delay is DV on the bottom that's a category that's sort of a catchall for
017our youngest students up through age nine and that really stems from the research and understand that early intervention is the best way to address needs and so when students are identified with the developmental delay it's kind of a general not as specific category of definition um disability because you want to ensure those children are getting support and services they need and then when they at their next evaluation after they turn nine the team would then reconsider are they still eligible and if so under what new category the school age next slide this is the last of the the process slides and then we'll get into the ray School data um after we develop an IP and during that process the team really looks at how do we meet that child's needs most of the students
018in the ray School are spend the majority of their time in their classroom they're in fifth grade most of their time is in the fifth grade they may be pulled out which is or push in start there which is what a a specialist so a special educator speech language pathologist occupational therapist would go into the classroom or the learning space in work with a child in that set could be in small group could be in oneon-one pull out is when that specialist take the student out of what their class is doing and work with them in a separate setting that may be with a few other students or may be oneon-one and that's utilized when the skill that you're teaching can't be done effectively in classroom so we have a number of students with specific
019learning disabilities whose reading instruction is significantly different than what they're learning in the classroom and so those professionals would work with their students on those foundational basic reading skills in a separate setting and then we work to transition those skills and generalize them into the classroom co- teing and collaboration we don't utilize any formal co- teing here um it's a model high school we have one class and Mar and cross we used it in the past where a general ed teacher and a classroom teacher go teach um a whole class or a specific subject and it's designed with those two people together proactively to ensure that all the students in the class have their learning met and then academic Behavior Support is primarily provided by our educational assistants and that's to ensure that students while
020in the classroom um are afforded to support they need to access the content whether or not they need additional prompts because they're in attentive or their reading ability is below where it needs to be independently and so that adult can support that person with ACC a few of our students have one-on-one behavioral support um or for self-care needs that's an educational system that's assigned to work specifically with that student because their needs are significant enough that they need somebody to help fa itate whether it's communication or behavior plan throughout the day so for the push in and push out St with your reading example someone needs help on reading and they're either pulled out or someone goes in to help do they do that during when the rest of the class is doing reading or
021could they theoretically be like pulled out during math which then they it further behind in math in order to get catch up on reading yeah there is that part of the schedule that's a great question and it varies um one we start with what is the student needs and if they need four times a week of 30 minutes of explicit reading instruction that's what we start with and then we look at their schedule our special education schedules our special Educators schedules and find times that work the best for everybody so there are times where students May um be removed from an Ela lesson and get some structured reading because that lines up with what they're doing in class but a different level and there may be times where the team wants that student in ela
022and in addition to wants them to get additional reading and so we may takeen out of another learning opportunity stud another part of the school now we're looking at some specific R School data uh and what this slide shows is um our highest number of students with disabilities those categories autism spectrum disord Lang emotional disturbance of Health impairments for civic Lear disability and BD and so what this shows over the past five years is we continually have similarly size cohorts of students in those categories um which is consistent across the state of New Hampshire I did look at ASD we we're seeing an increase uh and so I looked at the New Hampshire wide data and the state is also seeing um over the past 10 years there's been about a 2.2% increase in students
023identified with autism spum disorder so our trend is consistent with with what other districts you're seeing we just a smaller portion of that um and another thing when I look at the New Hampshire Statewide data that includes K through2 and here we're only looking at at K through five and so our percentage of students with developmental delay which is only for students at ag9 that would be far lower in the aggregate New Hampshire State Line this also lets us look at our educational professionals and what areas of need we have um most if not all of our special Educators have been trained in um know literacy strategies and structured language approaches because majority of our students with IPS have specific Lear disability related needs speech Lang speech language impairment we have two speech language professionals
024to address those students other health impairment is a category for students that have some health condition often times can be ADHD anxiety executive function dysfunction um that impacts your learning and so that other health impairment is a bit of a catch off for for health conditions that impact your students does that mean some students are double counted no they're not double counted so this is U by primary disability so some students do do have two or more educational disabilities this is just looking at the primary one and primary is determined by which one is most impactful on your learning like if we were to hypothetically dissect a child and say okay if you also weren't inattentive and you just had a reading disability which would be more impactful you learning that's how the team decides
025which is primary and which is secondary but the order of which doesn't dictate what services and how we address our needs slide so this looks at the percentage of students from the total enrollment at the r school that have IEPs are in special education um so New Hampshire is consistently above the ray school um we did have this fall we had well starting in July 1 through December one we had nine new IEP students so they're not all counted in here because I pulled this information in early November um so may be slightly higher but I don't know en rment also went up since then do this data also capture kids with 504 than no this is just student with IEPs and I don't include ports because they're not included students with those needs aren't
026included in the special education budget because there's some overlap right so when you talk about learning disabilities and ADHD and such a child may be diverted to a 504 rather than an i depending on the classroom performance of the US depending on the level of need and so this is looking at just the students that have IPS but there are a number um I can pull it up backwards but there are a number of students at the ray school that have a 504 plan which is a a separate law it's a civil rights law not an educational law that ensures that students aren't discriminated against and that they're provided Equitable opportunities as and is it that the costs are so much lesser for the 5504 implementation that they not included as a as a line
027item like we would look at for special education they're included in the the general race School operating budget and the costs are I would say quite small um most students at most would have maybe a consultation service a student with um hearing impairment we may need to contract with a audiologist to check their clear implants and make sure that our equipment is working um but it's rare for student with power to receive weekly services like a student on I thank you yeah Tony um on this race School versus State of New Hampshire comparison State the state includes K through 12 so is it a higher or lower percentage at P five than if you have the full I think my next so what I did here was kept that state of New Hampshire line the
028ray school is the the thicker Blue Line I also included Marin cross the middle school and high school um to look at Trends over 10 years New Hampshire Statewide data is only available up to the this year 203 um and so consistently uh except for the past few years the elementary schools tend to have higher percentage great than the middle school and high school and that trend is consistent across other districts um primarily because they're we're doing our jobs well and we're identifying students early um it should be rare that we're newly identifying students at the high school level and unless something significantly changes in their functioning um and there are a number of students every year that are discharged from special education because their needs no longer require targeted instruction and if they still
029have a condition they may move to a 504 plan where they get some accommodations and supports but don't need an the ray school is higher than Mar and cross um and what I attribute a good portion of that to is that um at the ray school and Hanover responsible for preschool students that have disabilities you don't have any enrollment numbers for other preschool students because you have a program and so at the Marin Cross School when I calculate there percentage it includes 3K all students up through sixth grade and here this includes all students K through sorry K through Shi grade but also includes PRK students just with IEPs and so when I take out I think there are 11 students in prek with IEPs and when I take those students out it drops our
030percentage down to about 12.5 yeah next slide brings us to the budget implications and portion of my presentation so at the ray school and for the Handover School District uh the special education budget for expenses includes K through five special education staff materials contract and services early childood special education which I was just speaking about is for students of preschool Age 3 through five before they enter kindergarten uh and the the learning needs that they have so that's for our staff to work with those students in whatever setting they're in contrac and services have needed materials and also preschool tuition the preschool child's team determines that they need a structured preschool environment in order to build those skills and practice prek kindergarten read skills that's something that's included in the child's IEP and our professionals
031will work with that student in that location also for expenses extended school year primarily this is over the summer months where students would be not a great place in the fall uh if they didn't Pro if they didn't receive any services for that two months in the Su and so each spring every student's team with an i AP meets looks at the progress looks the data and determines does the child need something over the summer to maintain that progress It's not a time to make up ground or to um progress ahead but it's really about what do they need to do to maintain and be ready in the fall to pick up where and then out of district schools and programs for Hanover residents so even students of Dresden age that are would be attending
032the middle school or High School if their special education needs require that they attend an out of District program those costs come back to hand of the school district so want me to share some numbers here sure look numbers so the special education proposed for 2526 in total is 4,551 th000 of that there is uh out of District tuition projected at 1.2 million to 1.25 million just to put some of that in perspective for you R when do we get involved if it all for not for students not attending Handover schools but are Handover residents or go are private schools like there a crossroad kid or a homeschooled kid that lives in Handover do we get involved with any sort of special uh so parents uh children without or with disabilities can send their child
033to any school they want so if we have parents um that live in hand over and they want to send their child to a school somewhere and they don't have an IP there's no involvement from our school sorry if if there is IP so if they have they've been identified and have a educational disability um our responsibility of school districts is to propose an IEP that meets a child needs and our primary placement for that child will be in our our school so if we as the team decide we can meet that child's needs in our program here but the parent wants to send them to program in another town um they can do that and we as a school district don't have any responsibility called the unilateral needs homeschooling uh homeschooling uh if a
034student has a educational disability and they're homeschooled again we would say we can meet your child's needs if you want to enroll them here if you don't the only requirement that we have as a school district is a very small portion of our IA Grant which is pro-rated based on the number of students in h school and so at minimum at most it may be a few weeks of service from one of our providers to a homes school student and that then we would meet our threshold C allocated amount we have can provide to that student just go back for um so the expenses are large Revenue not so great coming back um every year we get an annual IAB Grant um over the past couple years it's been around 120,000 dren also gets one
035um and so primarily we've used that over the years for Staffing um I believe three of our staff are partially um their salary is partially covered by that Grant and then any additional funds we use for unexpected costs whether it's some equipment or we need to update some evaluation or testing protocols that we have and the other revenue is special education aid used to be called catastrophic Aid U and it's a funky formula and so we spend the money and then the following year the state reimburses reimburses us a portion of it never fully reimburses us as it's supposed to um and that's based on the actual cost for each student that we submit to the state so if a student was placed out a district and their program cost $200,000 we calculate that we
036send that to the state and then they reimburse us [Music] 80% at the amount between 3.5 per pupil cost and 10 and then anything over 10 times the per pupil State average they fully reimburse and then and then when they don't have enough money they prate that um and so what I P because the education commissioner sent a letter to the state I know the news paper picked it up as well saying that there's really big shortfall in funds available for special education Aid across the state uh and so for f school year 24 so the last school year they were expenses for us and I estimated at the time of building the budget back then that we were going to spend about $574,000 worth of eligible costs at the end of the school year
037we actually spent 550,000 that was submitted State um and I expected pration rate of 80% which I thought was reasonable and I would have gotten this back 440,000 and then the rate that came back was pro rated at 66% and so we're expecting to get back this year for expenses last year 36 so I've adjusted my estimates for next year with a much lower prision rate so that we're at least closer to getting what we expect in the and the projections get adjusted because New Hampshire doesn't set tax rate until October so that we have we're notified by the state prior to setting our revenues that the original projection we had is two so we lower the projection and and then you know then we set yeah sorry I um I find that element of
038your presentation and the most deeply troubling because as a privileged School District we're going to be able knock on wood to you know navigate this shortfall but a lot of other schools in the state of New Hampshire aren't and is there an association you belong to that has any teeth to make a statement should we as a school board be making a statement should is there something that we can do on behalf of school districts that are looking at significant shortfalls and um what might we do I I appreciate your question and your desire to help uh the there's a New Hampshire Association for special education administrators uh which I'm a member of and we have public meetings and there's legislative committees and Ru making committees and so there are members of that organization that
039attend the state meetings um send communication to the Department of Education to try and get these things resolved I know there are some pending lawsuit or Court things you know the conval suit and appropriate education and the state funding which is kind of connected to this um but there has been a lot of communication from colleagues of mine in my position from across the state um to the Department of Education stating our straless with this decision and sure there are some funds that could be reallocated to support districts none of that is changed I mean that communication was happening prior to the the coming out just following off on that I I believe that this isn't the first time that this pullback has happened in this because I believe 80% we were kind of excited
040about getting even though that was kind of the average because it was lower in history just if was there any lawsuit or like was there any impetus that went when it was lower to the 80 in history or just I'm just trying used to be around 62 and that up to like 65 that probably 15 15 years ago um I don't recall that it was lawsuit that changed that dollar amount um as much as it it could have been additional funding streams that came in from the feds um like with Medicaid monies or Medica now I'm I'm just speculating it was 62 for when I first started doing I think there are now more competing sides people organizations for Educational Funding whether that's through the efas there's multiple millions of dollars M State being allocated
041to that and I don't know if that used to be part of funds that were available for special vation Aid um I also know that uh costs are just going up for educating student program and placement cost tuition continues go up so I think that the costs are rising as well and they was not able to keep up with that those are just speculations it could be the bump up up into the mid 80s was also because of s that came into the state I'm not sure about that but um there's a lot of money came into the state and and um you know that percentage kept creeping up during those times of course if the if the schools weren't running full boore right they probably weren't submitting as high of claims depending on how
042they were operating so that it left more money to distribute as well then just two more slides uh this just briefly shows how much of our H School District budget the perc of that of special education and so uh important to remember that a good chunk of that special education cost are out of District students um which in other school districts would be split between the K through 12 budget so we're pretty consistent um right around the average over 10 years was 25 these a of district schools are they generally nonprofits uh yes you ever do in New Hampshire I believe they in order to be approved as a private special education program um eligible to receive federal funding on it and have to be a nonprofit there are programs that I'm sure are for
043profit schools but we don't have any then do we ever do any sort of on-site visits or audits so what they charge us or anything like that uh so yeah so anytime a students placed out a district um even before they go I go and for and speak to the programs um because we as a district are responsible for that placement and in essence that the child's need to be met there um and then so prior to any placement I go and then while the students there there any meetings I can go and attend or visit depending on distance some of those kind of transition to zoom meetings but I've visited in all the programs we have students uh the last slide um is a graph showing the blue line is what was budgeted for
044special ucation cost and then the red line is what was actually spent uh and if people are interested I have the reasons for increase or why there's a difference from what was budgeted to actually spent I'm happy to talk more about this this year budget when you go through the rest of the presentation the increase this year from last year's budget um is about 55,000 up in professional salaries so special ucation staff um and then a large increase um 232,000 and out of District tot in cost the primary reasons for that increase and then briefly I'll just the points for 23 24 um why it was less than budgeted um we had an unfilled special education teacher position and I was so specialist salaries in total were down about 95,000 27,000 less than educational assistant
045salaries again unable to positions 175,000 less than Insurance B benefits and that year there was 275,000 less in out of District tuition from budgeted I believe because we have two students whose needs changed and or moved out of District that we're attending out of District programs and so those fluctuations can happen sometimes where our costs are less and sometimes when students needs change after the budget planning process or student moves into the district with sing needs and then we're on the other side of being so the same question so where does that excess dollars go does it go to our Reserve fund for special um if you have an article to redirect it there if you don't have an article to redirect it there then it goes back against uh we use it to offset
046assessment for taxation you know that one point yeah 1.2 1.4 last year uh this year um and then we did redirect 100,000 of it um from the end of this fiscal year into the capital reserve funds um so that's where the warrant article come into place if we think we're going to Trend with a large Surplus also retainage we retained as much as we were allowed so that we can carry it into the next year in case there's a problem that can be used okay separate question uh it is a separate question and I followup comments on the reserve fund right so I think um in Prior School Board um you know kind of thinking and a little bit maybe tripling into this one you know the the reserve fund amount was kind of the
047one and a half student in a sign significant resal out of placement kind of thinking and um so we had I don't was it last year or two years we we've been switching off between maintenance fund and special education Reserve fund as far as where we place our excess so if we have Surplus in excess of what we get promised in March you know where would that go that's what that Warren article says um you know we were trying to get back to that one and a half students um of a cost um because the had been inflation and other things if you don't add to your reserve fund amount you're falling behind right and so that was kind of the idea and that's my comment on reserve fund um so we can also think
048about that when it comes the our discussion and then my my question to Rett is um how you know are are all of our students with IEPs being fully served to what their I has said or are we meting based upon you know shortages in staff or whatever reason schedu I mean there's so many reasons right but are we kind of rationalized having to do that in some way little show assistant minutes so when we look at our students that have that academic or behavioral support in their IPs I believe because we're not fully staff with educational assistant um some of those students aren't receiving the full amount of minutes that are in their IEPs uh earlier in the school year we had the case managers communicate families for any students that were impacted by
049that um and offered a set time to talk or a meeting and also laid out like hear ways that we're supporting the child in additional ways because we don't have that person that might be increased consultation with teacher um so I believe we're still in that space where we don't have that did look into for some of our schools look into the option um happy hear we did get person since the last meeting um but besides that when somebody becomes available there are staffing agencies which offer to provide professionals behavior interventionists um at a cost that is quite a bit higher than um what we would reason to pay with Benefits um PA Professional Care so that is an option but the cost appears to be prohibitive or not really warranted any other questions for
050rep from the board anyone question from the public thank you very much thank you appreciate your time as always we're going to move on to the budgetary fund P fund and J kind to start with um transportation issues laneel Lane to thean is she's the vice president of electrification and sustainability for R st can you hear me than youin there you are and you're on the big screen here did you want to um present or would you like me to run the PowerPoint while you speak um I can present that's fine can you give me control to do so hold on one second r than a co-host you did okay okay so I think they made you co-host so you should be able to pull up your power point what do you need me to
051do Jamie pull up your power and share I have it pulled up um I don't know how do you share it from here if you can't do it I can no it's not it's not given me an option to share my to share my screen so I can just walk along with you if you've got the first slide up I okay just this is so folks following along home um are able to see it and Stacy Emerson is with us as well um I was going to just uh did you want to promote Stacy or you all set any questions and also I'm sorry Brian hway is here with us in person so Brian is here with us as well Rachel in person I think you already knew that from emails yeah Brian President of
052Operations from Northern New England for R st um I'm with you now if you want to um go ahead I will move the slides okay thank you good evening everybody thank you for giving me the opportunity to talk about electric buses to you all for a few minutes my name is Rachel Lane I'm the VP of electrification and sustainability for student transportation of America America Next slide please so just briefly I'm going to go over where we're at um at sta with our electrification progress talk about um some general benefits of electric school buses and Community engagement that we can also um take part with with with electric school buses and talk about the funding opportunity that we have um for you all with this project next slide please so SC has been doing electrification
053on school buses since 2020 we currently have 37 on the road we have another 115 that are in active Planning Development infrastructure development and we've got several hundred more that we're hoping to launch um all pending Grant approvals we've delivered buses across the United States and Canada to a variety of climates and customer bases we are the second largest bus contractor in North America we're a key account for all of the bus oems when we have an issue and we call they answer the phone for us um so we are in a good position um to deliver the best service that we can um from a bus perspective our charging solution partner in charge provides services Nationwide for Fleet delivery Transportation Industries again we're key account for them our grant writing firm that we work
054with um handles all of the grant backend processing and compliance to make sure that we follow all the EPA regulations from start to finish locally in your area we have four electric buses that are currently running in New Hampshire we have two deployed to Barry Vermont and we are delivering this week three to White River Valley Vermont um we've got the training scheduled um at Stacy's terminal um on Thursday so exciting I might want to add there too I think you all um along with Stacy had invited any of us up if you wanted to come um we were going to share some information about when they get delivered right so we'll we'll get that information out to you sorry Rachel I'll go on to the next slide thank you so some general benefits of
055electric school buses they're healthier for our students our drivers and our communities anybody that's in local proximity to an electric School Bus can take advantage of those benefits immediately they have zero tailpipe emissions um diesel exhaust is a carcinogen diesel exhaust is is linked to negative cogni developmental impacts diesel exhaust negatively impacts respiratory Health it has more of an impact to children just because their bodies are smaller and their lungs are smaller and still developing and pollution levels that are found um in a diesel bus can be several times higher than pollution levels on the outside of a diesel bus next slide please so we did an estimate on the reduced emission that would come from converting three of your diesel buses to electric buses an annual greenhouse gas emission reduction is approximately 31 metric
056tons of co2e and an annual critical air pollutant emission reduction is approximately 107 pounds that actual number is going to vary just based on on the mileage that is run um but this is for all three of those buses on an annual basis that would be the emissions reduction that the electric buses would bring there's also increased operational efficiency on an electric bus versus a diesel bus school buses are a great use case for electric vehicles because they run established regular routes you can optimize your charging schedule based on those routes they have regenerative braking which extends the range of the bus and it also reduces the brake wear and tear and they give a good Rider experience there's a lower engine noise this leads to believe it or not better behavior on the bus
057from the students because it's not so loud in there so they're not shouting over the diesel engine they're calmer they're quieter um the buses are smooth and they're a pleasant ride and the drivers that that we have um that are operating them love them so they're a good tool for driver motivation driver retention next slide please so we've done a variety of things that are other locations to partner with the local community and the local school districts um on engagement with the electric buses they're a great educational tool for the students we do provide all the training for the drivers and the maintainers and when we do training we also bring in the local First Responders in the area so that they know these buses are in their communities they get an understanding of what
058they're looking at how to identify one in public and where the disconnect points are on the high voltage system we've done different things with electric buses that can be at your service or at your liking um information sessions demoing them to neighboring districts using them in local Earth events local media events um we've we've supported a variety of activities with our buses and having electric buses will align with um your District's climate action plan and strategic plans next slide please so I'll just go over a couple common questions but of course please ask me anything else that wouldn't be covered on here how long do the batteries last and what happens to them when they need to be replaced the batteries are covered by multi-year warranties with a minimum of eight years um I can
059provide you full warranty information on on the bus if if you would like more details the batteries do degrade over time just like the batteries in your cell phone do degrade but with proper storage and minimizing High rate charging that does extend the life of the battery battery life and Battery end of life technology is still relatively new it is evolving um right now they can be used for external storage or recycled once they reach their optimal life lifespan what type of buses and and what are their ranges um most types of buses are also available in electric models your type c is is what um we're planning to bring to you the range on this bus is going to be approximately 100 100 miles for a full charge is the battery range reduced in
060hot and cold climates yes it is um we have seen that that's that is reported that's um we do see some loss in cold climates um we expect to see that um we do teach our drivers to precondition the batteries before they leave for the day so this ensures that the the cabins are comfortable for the Riders and that the batteries are at the optimal temperature to reduce um any impacts from the Colder Weather um again they also have the regenerative braking that the drivers can use to help um get energy back into that battery and and make them run more efficiently next slide please what about fires so first sorry first I want to emphasize that school bus transportation is the safest form of transportation for children Bar None School Bus fires are extremely
061rare and even more so in electric buses than in their combustion engine counterparts the buses including the batteries undergo rigorous testing and the batteries are in protective encasing that sits between the frame rails um they're equipped with automatic and Manual High Voltage disconnects like I said we provide training to their First Responders the bus manufacturers and also the um NF PA also have additional training and information on responding to battery fires another question doesn't the pollution just shift to the electric grid so the immediate dirty air that a student breathes in in and around in a diesel bus is eliminated when you make the switch to an electric bus bus charging itself does produce extra admissions on the electric grid that's absolutely true um that amount does vary based on how clean your grid is
062um sta every year does full carbon accounting both on their scope one emissions their emissions that their buses generate and also their scope two emissions that is the emissions that are generated from utility usage and um things like like bus charging so yes you do have you will have pollution that some of that will be shifted to the electric grid but it is less than what is um generated just from operating a diesel bus so this bus or these buses were funded um with support from the EPA clean School Bus program this is a fiveyear five billion program over 2.7 billion has already been awarded to over 1300 school districts at a number of almost 9,000 buses you were funded with the third round of this this funding it was a lottery based rebate round
063um and your district is categorized as non priority um based on how the EPA does their categorization so that does put you at a lower funding level than districts that are categorized as priority the bus ownership as per the terms of the grant we own the bus it is to serve the district for five years after delivery so we can't get these buses and just run them wherever we feel like they are for your District um should our contract end with you prior to the five years we have a couple different options we could move the bus to another District or you could buy or lease the bus from us or we could sell or lease the bus to who your next contract provider is so there there are options with that um far away
064the EPA clean School Bus program is the best opportunity for grant funding in the country so here's a highle breakdown of the project financials um an these electric buses were $343,000 a piece the EPA incentive was $200,000 a piece a diesel bus is approximately $125,000 so you can see the cost difference on the electric three electric versus three diesel inclusive of the EPA funding the infrastructure with the utility upgrade is approximately $150,000 we did get a small incentive from Green Mountain Power we're anticipating so the total project cost is 571 there's a direct there's a cost to the district of 375 the Capital Improvements that we're making to support this project are approximately $196,000 I showed a a breakdown of the three routes that we're anticipating um using for the three electric buses the mileage
065is there a question oh no I'm sorry just one of the one of the computers had a mind of it own okay sorry so I I showed a breakdown of the estimated mileage the estimated diesel cost the estimated charging costs and the Delta between diesel versus electric that were anticipating and then also an estimated Savings in preventative maintenance um the preventative maintenance costs are based on what we've seen so far at our other sites again this is routine preventative maintenance work and the electric charging costs are based on utility rates that are available at our terminal and what we are anticipating our charging cost based on our anticipated efficiency that we we will get from the bus I'm just GNA make a note here um before we go on Rachel one second uh when you
066look at the budget as built um the dollar amount of what we had already expected to pay for a new diesel fleet is included in our budget as built for Han um sta America is going to they're going to keep the infrastructure and because it fits with what their um National plan is with uh regards to Environmental uh we will not be reimbursing sta for that uh the Capital Improvements and the difference between the diesel buses and the electric buses so um that will not the dollar amounts that we had already had budgeted were based on a fiveyear extension with our vendor that is sta which we already have so the number that's in the budget however May if we decide to do this go down by approximately $77,000 and that would be tied to
067what we expect the savings to be in the diesel cost okay so depending on you know when we make this decision or what the decision is there may be an adjustment to is my is my point hope Rachel I'll go on to the next slide so the next steps we have quotes for both the bus and the infrastructure structure ready to execute um as soon as we get the green light from you all they will be executed the electric buses um will be on order the infrastructure design process is already begun bus delivery takes approximately a year or so but we don't take delivery of buses until the infrastructure is complete we find that the infrastructure tends to be the longer lead of the two and we can't take the buses until we have charging
068available for them so that the biggest driver of the timeline will be the timeline for Green Mountain Power to provide the upgrades to the site that we need approximately a year and a half from mortar will be what we're looking at um for a timeline and we'll have a better idea once we get a fmer commitment from Green Mountain Power which we will do when we have the official green light from you all and then we'll we'll go into the detail design on the infrastructure alternatively a diesel delivery is about nine months Tim has a question yeah so um and actually kind of um another idea but so if they if we don't get the buses into August 2026 but this is the budget for 2025 26 what do we do August 2025 we will
069and you can correct me if I'm wrong but we've had that conversation so what we will do is we will maintain we will keep on hand three of our buses I believe that we already own from the prior lease agreement um where they're you know shared between us so we'll keep three of those and then rotate them in and out um and when they buy the new diesel fleet we also when they bring in a new diesel fleet we bring in I believe it's three additional is four routs for arra trips for trips we keep them for athletic trips and you know educational trips and all of those so they'll keep the three that has to be because you have to um not damage but destroy right you have to destroy three buses when you
070take delivery of three electric buses so we'll keep those three buses that will be destroyed upon delivery of the electric buses and they'll switch them out um not my area of expertise at all but it seems like even in the past couple of years technology has changed um around electric vehicles and so if we purchase Vehicles now in a year and a half from now the technology has changed in a way that is better how can we or can we benefit from that or we locked into year and half old technology at that point Rachel did you hear that question I did so the bus oems they're not like cars in that they're coming out with a new model every year um when they do make improvements to things that can be updated with software
071um we see that continually um and so you would have the latest software availability um charger and bus interoperability firmware um those type of things are being updated all the time um and that will continue after your bus delivery but huge I don't how the right word to describe it big changes from bus platform to bus platform don't happen all the time um just because there's so much R&D and so much development that's required um the Chargers themselves they the model that we will buy will be consistent in that it's the power um the power kilowatt from the company that will stay but again as they make updates to Firmware software features those are continually refreshed um and they have roll out plans for patches to deliver across all the sites and whatnot and so
072we have this same charger model in other locations and as they make fixes patches improvements etc those fixes get delivered to everybody so I I hope I hope that answers your your your question thumbs up okay did you have a follow up I have several but um I guess it's on on your bus destroyed comment is one um who current I believe we Le right so who well who currently owns our buses now ta and right so the m as far as destroy I mean they'll do whatever they need to do to depose that asset right so um that's one thing okay and then so we will be basically um okay the the other thing was um kind of more talking about this infrastructure that's to be developed which you know is this larger investment
073that SCA is doing um you know can we hear more more about the future planning on that okay yeah so so we have in a subsequent slide what your site layout or what the terminal site layout will look like with the Chargers um if these are just some pictures of some of our training events and some of our deployments but if you go down to the next slide this is the site plan for what it will look like with the little gray boxes on the right hand side will be where the Chargers are mounted um there's a new utility Service drop that needs to be added that's that's also identified on there um I can provide you specifications of the Chargers if you're interested in in seeing those if you'd like more detail on that
074um there's Chargers that get mounted on pedestals and then the conduit and cable runs to the switch gear which is tied into the utility service connection Point um what what kind of what other details are you looking for just I mean the comment on like Proper Storage to increase longevity and every and it looks like these are going to be based on the picture right not covered not you know just kind of aside from you know parked connected to yeah so so what that means is um like if you are not running your bus for two weeks because it's Christmas vacation or you're down for a few weeks because it's summer vacation there's a procedure that you follow to shut the bust down completely um rather than having it sit there and the battery drain
075or having it stay on a charger and keep charging unnecessarily and having charge and discharge through the battery when it's it's not going to be used so so that's what I mean in that regard when we know we have a a period of downtime that's more than a weekend we'll shut the bus down completely we'll turn off um the battery system so that the bus sits completely dormant and the battery is not being exercised in any way just is so then the capacity of this plan so say we decided to you know purchase all of our whole flea you know what what would be the capacity of that or if all of the districts are currently engaged with these contracts per full leads you know would that be you know it just it would it
076would be interesting because then that would increase you know our timeline if we if there needed to be more infrastructure up yes so so that is a good point and this current cost and this current design is not future proof decide for adding one more bus we are not running additional conduit we're not putting in a larger than needed switch gear for this time we're not adding additional um you know Chargers that aren't going to be used now depending on the circumstances sometimes we future prooof sometimes we don't this cost this price is not is not a future prooof um design there was also another question um Rachel that we discussed and I would love for you to put it on the record it was a question that came from um the hover sustainability folks
077um when we had met earlier on um they had asked about whether or not a charger of this kind uh could could feed back to the grid could you talk to that a little bit Yeah so so that is vehicle to grid um it's done in various small pockets of utilities across the country this is not currently set up for that um that's a bigger investment it's a bigger charging investment it's a bigger timeline with the utility because you have to go through their interconnection process um is it technically possible yes have we done it here no um just for because of the reasons that I stated it's a much more complicated infrastructure delivery both from a a time and a coordination and um and a cost perspective is it as a followup is it
078fair to say that if in a once we get these and they're rolling if the district wants to look to make um an investment in the future Fleet perhaps and move them all to that type that we could potentially look at charging station like that at that point in oh we absolutely can we absolutely can um I I guess I would just say that for as much good press as VG gets it's really only being done at a you can probably count on one hand the number of locations um and so there's still a lot of technical comp um challenge that comes with it but absolutely it could be addressed for a future iteration if if Handover was looking for a bigger Longer term type deployment thank you Rachel um are these buses the same
079capacity in terms of number of people that can fit on the buses yes yeah and probably a question for Jamie more so than um you guys but in terms of specific routes kind surprised to see h10 on here G one of the concerns was Hills and Ice wouldn't that be one of our Hillier more distinct no actually um the there's only a couple Hills on it's and the weather's really bad they come down to the bottom um but some of our other roots that go up through L that go out Greensboro that go there're those are much hiler on a regular basis up and down and they're longer they're they're a longer distance so often times the distance um will and you know more than I do buy but um they looked at all the
080different roots and this is the three that they had what What's the total distance of these CLS um if you go to slide right here slide 10 uh bus 10 is 54 miles bus rout five is 40 and bus route four and bus route four is good just a follow up so I have an electric car and in the winner say I get maybe 55 to 60% of my you know theoretical capacity theoretical Miles because of cold weather so if you have a buster that's 54 and it's I mean it's 100 accounting you said that the 100 mile range is that accounting for cold weather or is that ideal conditions in cold WEA there could be so so 100 so a couple things first on the Hills Hills aren't necessarily bad because you can use
081the regenerative breaking going down the hill to gain some power or some um energy back into your battery really the worst thing for an electric bus is driving on a highway um because there's no stops and starts and and there's no Hills so you're not breaking um this mileage here is both AM and PM together and so you would have an opportunity to charge in the middle of the day if you needed to um for whatever reason the 100 is is an average um it could be lower on in the winter um could be better on on good condition days again it's it's going to depend um on the conditions of the route it's going to depend on the temperature it's going to depend on how good the drivers are at being efficient with their
082driving and with their regenerative braking like we've seen at other locations I identical buses identical charging infrastructure identical route conditions and two different buses get different efficiencies and that's just based on the driver and whether they're really good at using the braking or if they stop and start really um roughly and so there's a lot of things that can impact it you know we're going to see a reduced range in in the winter we know that but these these buses this bus model we have them running in Maine right now um so they'll be in an environment that is similar to what to what yours are I don't know that this has any budgetary inact I'm more curiosity so I go through tires much faster on my electric vehicle because of the regenerator breaking and
083so so it's an interesting question um we haven't seen it yet I I wouldn't be surprised if over time we potentially see some impacts in in tire wear you know there are certain tires that are specs for these buses um because they are heavier and and because of the the braking and whatnot I don't have anything conclusive to tell you that we will see more tire wear and tear but if you ask me two or three years from now you know I wouldn't be surprised if we if we did honestly although tires large large vehicles tiers are harder they're harder um right they're they're much harder and denser than what you see on regular Auto Vehicles so um they usually will last longer amount of years um and Miles right I mean what do we
084do with our with our Fleet now every three four yeah probably about four years we rotate so in the winter months we put studed tires on school buses right so we're going have a longer lifespan because you know we are rotating the tires uh you know November to say April we vot with the regular road tires backgr as of our icing on interesting question any other questions from board members any from the public well thank you guys for your time we appreciate it thank you all and everybody has your contact information so I'm going to encourage the board members um to reach out perhaps directly and CC me if they do with questions that way I can make sure everybody gets the answers answers I just want on the safety like safety I know we
085talked about fires but just like crash ratings I'm sure that's probably pretty stock and probably just something like that to make sure that absolutely did you want to speak to that quickly so so they have to go through all the same um safety certifications and uh level of testing that the diesel buses do um there's they don't get any kind of benefit or anything like that um thank you thank you for joining us Stacy and Rachel and no pressure ling you're welcome to I think I'm good all right good night everybody I think if you don't know that that his wife who's a wonderful teacher here at La school probably keeps him informed of what's going on and I will just note for the board there is two brochures attached the brochures that I've shared
086with you okay are also attached here to the board dogs um J buses buil um and then the InCharge spec sheet is also online so you can take a look at that there have any questions um if you want to if you want for us to arrange the ability to go on a um a visit to one of their other locations that has the buses um Happ to do that as well will we take a bus what take a ride they for couple years actually they were the first site in the um is Julie I asked this what she's on Julie the the best company the whatever brand model that we would be getting yes yeah the two yes the spe sheet you have online other ones that we're looking at absolutely um and there
087are I think I think they're gone now but there are three main manufacturers they have found and I believe Tony they've placed because they've done this all over the country they're a nationwide company um I believe they've used some of each different manufacturer and they feel that this is the best one um right now for the technology um I also have attached in the board Docs the fiveyear extension proposal um we were a little disjointed this year on on rolling this out because of the holiday so as they mentioned the only thing holding it up is whether we want to move forward or not we do not have a vote on this tonight so I'm going to say that we should probably be sure to place um you know place a a vote yes or
088no on the January one when we do the hearing so that we can know if we're going to move which buses will'll move forward with because if we say no and we move forward with all diesel then you know the numbers that you have are in there they work either way okay I I believe at the last meeting we were told that there was a deadline to respond to the Grant and that we had to order in January they they did the extension on the deadline okay so but I I understand SCA had an order in January is that that deadline extended as well so that if we not at this point so we would need to make we would need to make a decision I'll double check that but I think we would need
089to make a decision in January on whether to move forward or not I I I think we can ask for another extension I'm not sure of that I don't recall from reading all the L there may be another extension our next meeting is January 8th so it's pretty early long and that's that's plenty of time but if if we're not confident yet to make a decision and we want to ask if there's an ability to extend that can ask that question yeah um I know a lot of the money originates with the Environmental Protection Agency okay it's already that's already been spent correct I'm just concerned a five year it was a five year and this year we're coming up on round four I believe there's one more year one more year of round yeah
090maybe I just exact I think we if this is something we want to do we don't want to wait past certain a certain date in January to take advantage of it and I think the date of our my opinion is that the date of our hearing is fine they asked me um when we were having conversations about putting the information together um whether or not there would be a vote tonight and I said there wouldn't because you need time time to digest it look into it be comfortable with it right so the the January hearing really is a good time I think to have that updated conversation or followup conversation they're more than happy to come back for that meeting and then you'll you hopefully you know get and I'll find out whether you can
091do an extension feel there's any more specific information they need before they make a decision move ready to move on to the budget sure okay this is going to look very similar to all the ones that we've done together in the past um I think maybe all I think it sets the stage for all the next awesome hold on one I will share okay great oh and I just love seeing myself on that big screen that's just so we're starting with the attachment but everybody who wants a print out or needs a print out this is someone called um creating the ray school budget or the attachment is called Ray admin hsd so Han of Schoolboard budget presentation and I just I don't think I need to go through all of this I'm not going
092to go through all of this um but what I hope that you see when you look at this attachment is the amount of thought and iteration that went into creating the budget that you're going to hear moving forward and you know what you see and what you hear in many of the other um attachments it's the numbers and that's important but we also wanted you to know what the story was and also to take you through year two of zero based budgeting and share some of those Reflections as I promised I would um in the previous meeting that was the the smaller meeting um with the committees and the Hand finance committee uh Representatives so the first couple of slides just detail uh the process that we had internally it doesn't include all of the
093other meetings that we had with various folks but what did we do as a as a school team here um and I I wanted to highlight that because I wanted to highlight that it's inclusive so even though we have budget reps from every one of our teams um everyone is invited to all of our budget meetings and encouraged to attend um and everybody receives receives the slides from the budget meetings um so it is an inclusive process and it's supposed to be transparent both inside the school but then also outside of the school which is why we decided to put um this creating the r school budget presentation together um uh this was year two of following to the best ability that we had uh zerob based budgeting last year I called it kind of
094a light touch to zero based buding because it's hard and this was year two and it was still hard you'll see that reflection at the very end it was still hard um and I think it will continue to be challenging but budget generally is challenging this is just challenging in a different way um so as a reminder to everybody when we're doing this zero ba based budgeting we're really talking about the story that a person or an organization's budget tells um a reflection we had last year right the first time through the process is the hardest so we're breaking the mindset of but we' we've always had x amount of money to operate and instead reconsidering what functions do we need to operate and then how much do those functions really cost um another way
095to say that is that you know in year two just continue to think about think about like what we need not just what's been done before oh we've always had the X amount of money for supplies so let's just go ahead and move that over for next year we've always had x amount of money for you know books um testing protocols presentations field trips you're starting from zero every year and you might see that the things that you valued last year will get moved over but you also might see that there are other opportunities to either reduce redundancies um or try something different or move on to the next part of a strategic plan when you're starting from zero every time I'm not following these slides but Sor think when I I made them right
096I know where you are so I'm with you so um so as we set the stage for this you know we sent our our rep andent anybody else that attended out to um their teams with the task presented in front of you you know share all of this information come back with the propos proposal don't simply move forward line items you know think what do we really need and avoid reduce the tendency to stockpile resources right like oh I better buy this is not a great example but I I better buy all of the pencils this year in case we don't have pencils next year right no what do we need and then what do we budget for it um and then we also encourage folks to think about hopes and dreams um and as
097they're thinking about the hopes and dreams though to be able to articulate how that supports Mission how that supports School vision and how it supports the sau70 Strategic plan um and if they had those sort of hopes and dreams to make sure that they came prepared to tell the story or the rationale um we also when we went through this this year uh reminded folks to keep in mind that we value people over stuff and that this year we would be seeing the impact of um the increase from the collective bargaining agreement in year two for our certified staff numbers um so if as a school you know we're continuing to Value people over stuff we also need to keep in mind that people will be valued in this budget they're already valued and that's
098going to take part a part of the budget already before we even start putting other things on the table um and then we also reminded folks that we have other funding sources so if you're thinking about something big Hy and dreamy and maybe it doesn't quite fit in a clear concise connected way into Mission Vision um or the Strategic plan that explore other things too that we can um other funding sources that we can use to enrich the experience of our students while they're here with us at the race school um so folks went off and they did their thing and they created their budgets and then they came back and the task during our internal meeting number two was all right tell tell us your story um share the specifics and tell us your
099story and then as a group we thought through you know what are the themes that we notice what are the wonderings that we have about the budget that we've created all the pieces that went into it um we talk through enrollment projections any next steps and reminded folks about the budget timeline the all of the next slides and I'm not going to go through all of them but all of the next slides are what folks shared um the stories that are coming out of each of our teams and they're just really interesting because you see differences but then you also see themes and those similarities um which will bring us I encourage you to read through them because people work really hard on these stories but kind of brought us to the end so scrolly
100scrolly scrolly scroll all through all the teams um all the way down to sort of the key takeaways for year two so it's almost all the way at the end all right I'm get now scrolling quickly yes so people can get snapshots here that that Str right so yeah looks great like every single section in Department really went off and did their thing yeah and this is you know while we're getting there it's like this is um this is year two and so this is still hard and this is still new and with any kind of new process including budget um there will be you know the early kind of early doctors that are ready to go it makes sense let's do this thing and then other folks are like oh I question your sanity
101Lauren but like I'm going to go along with it and then other folks that are you know still trying to understand know why the why behind it and so in this spectrum of folks and understanding and and buying around this we have a lot of really cool stories um and and we also have you know various levels of buyin at this point but we're all moving together and that budget shows that and these stories represent that um so talking through the key takeaways I've said it a couple times now but gosh this is still challenging because even as you're starting from zero you have this little thing in the back of your head that's going but what if I forget something I'm not looking necessarily at last year's budget proposal like what if I forget
102something so we've had a lot of talks about yeah so what if we forget something or what if we didn't budget for XYZ scenario um and you know the answer to that is that we make it work and within the budget that we have we may need to make some decisions about where we've allocated some funds um to meet the needs that we didn't necessarily know that we would have as we move forward and that is budget um what I hope that you'll see is that there was intentional consideration about alternate funding sources um another takeaway that we had is that folks are starting to it's not like you know 100% yet right but we are all starting starting to think about budget earlier in the year versus being like Oh my gosh it's August
103time to create a budget again right in the course of the school year there are things that you're thinking um that are shortterm and longterm and having the Strategic plan is really helpful with that so thinking about budget earlier um we're continuing to work on articulating our alignment with Mission Vision and strategic plan um that we're continuing conversations that have been really productive around eliminating redundancies um I mentioned this the conversations about the what ifs and just a reminder to folks that we budget for what we know um we are further refining our thinking around simply moving money forward and in various parts of the budget you can see like Allin around zero based budgeting and then certain areas that are not quite there yet um and uh thinking about budget and you know multi-year
104um kind of tiers Now versus thinking okay we're creating next year's budget well we're creating next year's budget but how is that going to impact the following years what are we not doing next year that we need to be considering um through strategic planning and mission and vision in the following years if we can't do it next year what is our plan in the following years and therefore in the following budgets um and then a general feeling that just hearing each other's budget stories helps us understand each of the teams within the school and what we stand for together and it's really a way to um unite us moving forward um and so then I would encourage you in the you know the final slide to think through our our final Reflections here and um
105I would just end with saying that um each year we have a budget guideline or like a cap increase and what we talk about as a staff is think of the amazing year where nobody needs to tell us that we have a cap because they trust us the community trusts us the board trusts us to present a budget that accurately describes what we need and nothing more um so that's sort of like the dream will it ever happen who knows but in moving in that direction what we're trying to do is build that trust be transparent in our process be really thoughtful about what we're doing um focus our efforts and mission and vision and strategic planning um yeah and moving forward together and we continue to see the benefits especially here in year two
106um even though it's hard continue to see the benefits uh and we'll continue to use this process moving forward I hope that you see the stories reflected in the numbers that you're about to see thank you Lauren any questions for more specific to the Zer based budgeting process or mindset Pony um I noticed that a number of grades said were prioritizing field trip C Class experiences um and to me that was you know go seem like extras to me not the focus so I was like oh my gosh like what's the budget going to be if this is the center of their budget and and what they highlight um but it's actually half what it was last year yeah so it doesn't the slide doesn't seem to really I mean in a way seems not
107to reflect that it might be a big percentage of their classroom budget and that's why it's centered but here explain the drop I guess I'm I'm pleased because I was like oh my gosh like are we how much money are we spending on field trips like that seems like a really nice bonus thing for a well researched school but not what's the focus of a grade year yeah so okay sure so um couple of layers that I want to address even though it might feel like um a bonus the way that field trips are chosen by teams across the school really um are are a a supplement and a continuation around the learning that's happening that's aligned with standards so it's bringing that learning to life and whether it's that we go out to our
108Outdoor Classroom which we are so fortunate to have here or transport students to another place where they can really see this learning come to life rather than it being like just a fun experience or something that is not connected to the learning that's happening I would say it's not just like an added special bonus it's another way that teachers are really intentionally trying to bring learning to life um and so that being said our teachers don't want to lose the focus on experiences that are happening outside in the community Through field trips but are also cognizant of the competing priorities that we have especially in the Strategic plan around things like you know curriculum documentation the programs that we've been implementing um the resources that we need around assessment and as they're thinking about the
109field trips and still wanting to communicate to the board the importance of the field trips they are also within the but their their team budgets navigating um properly allocating funding within their budget for those other things as well so we're not going to see a huge increase in field trips because there is um an understanding that we also need to be putting our funds towards these other things that are really important in the Strategic plan because believe it or not the Strategic plan doesn't necessarily name field trips as one of the things that we're prioritizing moving forward but um having you know equity in in learning access and having um multiple Pathways for students to learn are part of that and therefore also valued when it comes to field trips did that answer part of
110the question it it answered most of it I'm just wondering about the drop by 53% and field trip budget over last year some of that was because I'm sorry I can't yeah some of that is because when they were budgeting if the if the opportunity doesn't require travel some of the folks are coming into them so it's been moved to the artist lines up regular that's right so some of the thank you Jamie I was trying to figure out why there yeah it's it's because we had um not quite allocated the money in the correct line so the GU we moved some some field trips to artists um in Residence and that includes the fifth grade field trip which is a big one um we were calling the Nature's Classroom experience a field trip um
111and it's actually because they come to us it's considered an artist or a r residency so it moved into that line so if you look at the budget if you're looking at the long line item budget you would look in the 1100 300 Street I think yeah 1100 300s and you might see increases up in those ones because they've redirected them because they don't have travel involved yeah as I went through and um as as the teams presented their budgets there wasn't a single team that was like we're not going to do as many field trips anymore field trips are still maintain but where those live in the budget may have changed a little bit you already discussion of bringing back the fifth grade overnight [Music] no I know there are folks on both sides
112of that any other questions specific to Lauren right thank you for that intro we appreciate it okay yes very nice thank you that was awesome so again uh you've seen this presentation pretty much you de before um and on the first slide we've included all the administration who somehow had a hand in helping to build different parts and Departments of the budet um we've also included all of our Schoolboard members names here and um I'll point out that Antonio Barry and uh Kim Hartman are your two Handover budget committee members who met with the um Administration and principles on two different occasions at this point maybe yeah three and the Handover Finance yes and the Handover finance committee of which there are thank um yes so we've had great discussions our last meeting was on
113November 21st um this does have changes to it and I'll Point them out um so I went searching for some newer information to share and I have a few slides here um and this is just a great picture of all of the students and there's volunteers and there's meeting members who were here here for a special function along with the um I think it was firefight firefighters not um and they were doing it in the gym on the other side of our barriers here looks like they were having a wonderful time it must have been around H because it looks like we got crost and then again some other slides of just you know what it's all about what we do here at the Rain Elementary School right and the vision that you know that
114to be one red and two Empower these young minds right to think outside the box to look to help you know make a difference in the world in a positive manner and to allow them to dream and uh be the next inventors of The Next Century for us here or the next decades the next few decades so this is a great picture of them playing all those wonderful instruments in the strange class Here In This Very Room uh and some of kiddos bringing uh food stuffs down to The Haven um another um very important part of what goes on here at the race school about giving back to the community and helping others um as Lauren mentioned in one of her slides um we meet in August that's when the Budget Building starts we do
115What's called the quick model the quick model based on assumptions we may know at that point in time and if we don't know we make projections u based on the quick model we looked at in August the board um you know they encouraged us all to look at the Strategic goals and the uh to try to put monies towards those type of Investments so we stay in line with where we want to go and then you know there's it's a very It's a larger document I just pulled out some excerpts so I would tell people to please go out and take a look at the document in total um and at the end of the day when they looked at the quick model they thought let's target the increase of 5% or less over the
116prior Year's budget um they wanted us to keep in mind about moving beyond the status quo of the model projections and they also gave us a few bullet points about Improvement considerations uh they're listed here I won't read them all off you know some of them are very important to programming like Ela expansion of uh English language arts multi-tiered systems um we did as a I will point this out we did as a whole District look at and discuss perhaps bringing on a 1.0 FTE social worker and sharing it across all four schools three districts and uh we did in the very end decide not to include that in this projected Year's budget but to perhaps look at that in the next budget out each one of the individual schools within the three districts has
117been um making Provisions within their own Staffing levels to address some of the concerns that have been raised um and I would let the principal speak to those because they can do it much better than our um buildings and grounds improvements we are working through a capital Improvement plan at the SAU level uh so we'll be probably looking into many of those different ideas in 5 through eight um early again in September we meet with the administration to take a look at enrollments uh and forecasting it forward as Lauren mentioned the enrollment right now as of your slide and you're picking up two more is two higher than what we have here as an actual um and so it looks like actual is going to be sitting at 468 is um by the end of
118maybe what next week or January who knows right so what we do in order to project forward is that we take a look at historical averages and we make adjustments as the students move up in their cohorts and so sometimes they'll gain students and sometimes they'll lose them and we've done that some of the numbers might seem a little bit lower and we pointed out that very small kindergarten class that came in at 46 in 2324 prior year um we rebounded this year with a kindergarten class of 74 uh and I looked back through and that's a really great size for us we've had approximately four other kindergarten classes above 70 and we had one that actually reached 80 um since I've been here anyway so doing all of that projecting it forward for next
119year we were looking at 468 if I thought about it and or it might be up around 470 or 472 if we were going to uh you know keep track of all students that are coming in so that's 23 above what we projected for fy2 and it will be a 28 student increase going into 26 when you compare it to the projection okay so was 463 right now and we projected 440 if you look at projection to projection it's 440 to 468 okay all right so we move on from that as an Administration still in September in that same discussion we look at Staffing District Staffing there is a wonderful exhibit that has been expanded yes exhibit eight thank you Kim thank you for yes absolutely um that I will say principal am uh designed
120and it came out very very well and it points out all the breakdowns of where these numbers are I will say that there are not a lot of changes there there are smaller changes but in light of the fact that we're picking up 28 students projection to projection we will be putting on a 27th classroom teacher there are some FTE movements so so in the end we are actually down uh aemp basically aemp in FTE U most of that pickup that offset the 1.0 classroom teacher would be from the interventionist tutor realm okay and the others are just movements between um um your educational AIDs that are dispersed throughout your school here okay so we move on from that I just wanted to take an opportunity here because we were talking about Staffing to point
121out that Hanover's Ray School won the Blue National Blue ribon School award um I think if you haven't heard about it I would encourage you to go out and take a look and read about it that doesn't happen without really great quality staff uh who put in a lot of extra hours and time into the programing here at Race schol So kudos to the ray School staff and the administration here you're doing a great job I then or we then take the budget proposal um it's it's nice to look at it by function which is like by Department it tells a story right similar to what Lauren's saying about they tell a story so you can look at this and as I mentioned we've had some changes in our budget bill from the one on
122version two which we shared on uh on the 21st actually it was built through the 18 we shared it on the 21st there were then some changes that came in um that this version is dated December 8th okay you can see there is regular educational changes there that is due in part to the fact there were seven track advancements that came in approximately $1 15,8 128 um there are associated benefits that go along with that right taxes n retirement Etc that's about $5,000 um we also had redirected on the other side half the FTE as you saw from regular Ed to special ed um for the behavioral interventionist because they're spending half of their time in differing differing orders so that will go opposite direction um the other changes were in special education we made
123some adjustments because of some retirements that were coming through on folks who are sitting at the very tippity top of the scale and so as we look at our hiring processes we normally are hiring in around Master Next Level Up middle range so we made a few adjustments to the budget down in that area um and that also had effects on health and other benefits um we had an ESL retirement that we made an adjustment with we also had a year-over-year change for election on health that was a large change there um and then in the 2400s you're going to see there's changes there as well the school board and sa Services also went up because the school board in between the meeting on the 21st and this meeting this SAU board set their budget
124and ratified it and when they did that they made one uh change to that two changes excuse me one of them was for the CIP project that we had uh 50,000 I think budgeted and we needed a little bit more than that about $10,000 more than that and then uh actually was1 18,000 we have 42,000 budgeted and then the other part of it which Ray only shares a piece of that right based on the formula uh the other change was for Market driven a compensation committee changes to some of the upper level management wage uh levels so that comes in in the school board SAU Services line that went up and then the school administration lines where your retirees uh wages as people retire and they have a retirement package those are charged in the
1252400 lines we had an additional uh retiree that um came in and we processed and that upped those dollar amounts there in the amount of about $26,000 so between Health F and the bries so that was the bulk of the changes between the two verions uh then we look at it I like to also look at it by object because that's the other side of the store it makes it very quick and easy for you to look at the budget and see where the increases are object is more like what we're paying for subjects right so all 100 lines are teachers wages or other wages all 200s are benefits or payroll taxes staff development you can see as you look down the list right so you can see that we're almost at 5% for teacher
126and specialist salaries that kind of makes sense because we did have a settled agreement there was 4% put on the Bas of the wage scale so that kind of ties there were changes in Personnel being high than leaving so there's probably some up and downs on the salary levels on the on the wage there um to go along with that would be payrolls taxes and benefits those obviously go up as salaries go up there Rel um the retiring wages I spoke to that but those have gone up um and then you can see where we've got some other different changes in uh levels the big one that will draw your interest would be the purchased property and maintenance services down 184 that's directly correlated to um some of the salary other salary lines up above
127um that would be custodia wages that we reinstated because we were Outsourcing the prior year for uh two two and a half positions and we've been able to fill some of those so we're moving that dollar amount back to the line in which it lives okay uh the other one as Rett mentioned uh is tuition out of District uh that's for the high school level and that's uh Turing up about 233,000 there um du's fees of debt that is actually debt schedule savings as we move up in our payments um okay moving on summary by category this is um another way to look at the budget so that you can see the direct operating expenses for PR prekay through five we carve out anything like the special ed tuition the capital expenditures The Debt Service
128and the transfers in and out so what we're directly spending on actual programming for the students okay without those involved and the increase there is 3.84% uh year over year um these summaries most of these summaries I have included the three warrant articles that we've been doing year over year which would be the board salaries the bridg VIN fund and the $100,000 to the reserves the the Bridgman fund and the $100,000 have offsetting revenues okay all right significant changes you probably very um familiar with some of these we've done significant changes sheet now twice we've updated it if you want really good detail go back out to the budget committee um sections they're posted there and all of the significant changes are within those writeups within the budget book which is what I'm holding here
129it's also post poed okay for today within that there is a narrative which tells you all about each one of these significant changes and it tracks it by the line and number I could bore you with all the details and read through every single one of them if you would like um but truly I think we've uh discussed most of them uh anything with salaries if it has to do with teacher lines there's 4% on base there's also track advances and their steps for other salaries we are in negotiations right now with the support staff so nothing has been added to those lines unless it was an FTE change and those were trending down for those folks um or it was nonunion non-union administrators are a 2% increase non-union um I'm going to get this
130backwards non- exemp are at 2 and a half% you have very few non-union workers here in so those numbers are pretty small um property equipment and Technology they are looking at you know turning over they have a regular uh rotation for the equipment that they use within the school and classrooms um all the parel taxes and benefits we also experiened a 12.9% increase in the health insurance rates so those are all the way through this document other than the custodial section which is also under negotiations right now because custodial and non-union are on a different plan um as somebody mentioned earlier the field trip line is down some of that was conscious about trimming some of that got moved up into the artist Lin um I'll say for the significant changes our threshold was $10,000
131um unless it was relevant to other questions okay um if anybody has any specific we spoken to most of these special ed transportation is down 65,000 that has to do with the fact of movement from um students to a different uh situation uh site and building improvements we down 105,000 that was a conscious decision due to a lot of the work that we had gotten done well due a to a lot of the work that we got have gotten done in the last two years but also B because we're looking at a capital Improvement plan which is going to help us to prioritize what some of the larger projects might be um I will also say exhibit you know what it is uh exhibit 12 has all of what we have planned for um projects
132here at the race school I won't say all but most of the big ones right um and then I as I mentioned before we have um well and we did speak earlier about the difference in cost for transportation and supplies um I still think based on what we're trending right now for diesel nobody has a crystal ball we may be able to trim that down a little bit maybe 10 grand I was taking a look at that today and Diesel pricing is down but who knows in a year and a half if it still will be right because we're a year and a half out but um anyway that's where the effect and changes in what we've projected with the fiveyear um extension on the original agreement loss okay and superintendent Services we discussed about
133the sa and the portion of Ray schools piece of De as I mentioned before I did also include uh this one does not I'm sorry this one does not include the money that we sent to the building maintenance fund or the bridg fund that's why the figures here are lower okay um revenues and net assessment the warrant articles 2 three and I'll fix that little thing right in F in and seven which is the $100,000 transfer from Surplus which you may change going into January um I have carried that here and shown it anything in salmon color or tan whatever it looks like to you uh is subject to change right they're based on projections at this point in time keeping in mind on the revenues we don't set revenues until October so we do
134have a ability and a chance to change them or adjust them accordingly when we know more right before we said tax rate so right now balance carry forward as was mentioned we offset taxation with almost $1.7 Million last year R spoke to Y the bulk of that was from having 12 open positions I think plusus um in the special ed real um so and then we had last year uh transferred 100,000 into Surplus uh Hanover Waterworks is expected to go up a little bit the interest on investments uh has been trending up we're still in the 4 and a half% range um the adequacy a right now is trending up from the state's early projection at 197,000 keeping in mind they normally cannot lower that more than 5% um Freedom account there's a phase out
135payment there it's going down from what we had catastrophic Aid Brett mentioned that we we're being very cautious on that but we will know before tax rate is set so if the if uh that goes up we'll adjust it Federal sources Medicaid is trending down uh Medicaid will Trend down if your expenditures Trend down um and there's a whole host of other information that is tied to Medicaid reimbursement a couple years ago was it they made it more difficult to file for Medicaid reimbursement requiring doctors um signatures are many of the are much of the information so after that went into effect a lot of District's Medicare or Medicaid univers went down um and then just carrying the bridan reserve fund down there um so net assessment actual when you net the revenues against the
136projected expenditures is 13,3 93 674 that's up $622,500 [Music] adjusted we have met this week uh administrators and we have some adjustments going into the budget downward so at this point in time and then we will be also bringing information to the school board for some decision making uh about that where we're going to be with that so that number as of was as of 128 um that's up just over 2% or no yeah and a little foreshadowing right for decision making it could go back up so it might go down and go back so I just wanted either all options abolutely absolutely administrators I think are bringing adjustments for you to contemplate down but there are to kins Point other strategic initiatives that have been discussed which may send that the other direction fair
137enough thank you yes um so all in all totaled is 322 million $729,000 let's say or a change of just over um $1 million at 3.18% um the tax rate production I'm going to say here for everybody in case nobody reads this does not include all warrant article for Union negotiated settlements we have two being negotiated right now um larger of the two is a support staff agreement we do have our current ta the board the Hover Board will discuss in executive later tonight then it will need to go to the Dres board for a discussion as well next Tuesday so the numbers on that won't be shared out until after next Tuesday um even though we do know what they are uh so the Handover projected tax rate here is all what we know
138now with a a a projected now and I cut that off I'll fix that increase of 10 million now is net assessed valuation for the town um and so you can see in 2425 what it is and then 2526 we're projecting $10. 32 on local tax rate then what happens is with the state school tax rates called swep the state takes all of our valuations throughout all of the State of New Hampshire they equalize our valuations by playing with the rate okay so by playing with the rate they make it fair or Equitable on a portion of what's raised locally still raised locally they don't send it to us um adequacy a is sent to us so right now based on our nav up a 10 million and the numbers we have out from the
139state because they can't adjust the sweat number they haven't yet um we're looking at a pending increase on the St ta so all in all we're looking at a 33 increase or just below 3% okay just as a recap as of this build excuse me our expenditures are looking to Trend this is direct expenditure at just over 4% or 644,000 uh that does include more Article 2 three and 7 two is uh board sens three is bridan and seven would be if transfer money from uh Surplus froms uh the revenues are up just about 74% or 21,000 22,000 that would include if we were to offset the 100,000 with Surplus money um which is noted there the Handover net assessment will be up just below 5% at 4.87 or up 2.04% or $386 371 um
140we have an estimated tax rate difference of just below 3% at 2.84% or 33 cents then doesn't include two settlements um sharing with everybody what the other that I know of right now two potential warrant articles might be one would be support staff agreement one would be service staff agreement historically support staff been three years historically service staff's been doesn't mean they will and they will out but this is the the draft of those um and then again just to share some cheerfulness at the end of our presentation this was uh I thought it was awesome it was an awesome exercise that you've done here and you know we were handed out dots and and they included all of us in the board and administration right and and we're some of us sat here like
141where are we supposed to De this dog right right and I just love the quote that you had just just make a mark and see where it takes you right because that's how a doodle starts that's how our thought starts so I love this it's a beautiful H board here uh at the race school and just look at the amazing uh thoughts that people I don't know if I completed my out remember any oh we did okay so um so that's it for our presentation our first presentation to the full School Board um and happy to entertain along with my fellow administrators any questions you might have thank you very much Jamie work you did everyone else put into it we appreciate it very much any initial questions by board members know we talked a
142lot about this before in previous meetings I'm on the budget committee but have a question um on the buses so not included and could they be a warrant article the funding just they're built in so because they're done as a lease purchase agreement through the fiveyear extension so the next step for moving to Electric over um diesel would it would require the board to uh make a statement that they support it because it's it's a grant right and it's a grant that's being awarded an offsetting amount that's being awarded so that's why it would require the board to say yes we want to move and accept that Grant to three buses for an electric portion of the fleet as opposed to just a diesel uh or reordering a diesel fleet but but Grant doesn't cover
143full cost so wouldn't it be a the contract would be can't remember how much no they're absorbing that sta is absorbing that the difference the $55,000 difference and they're absorbing it because they're going to own the infrastructure so and they're doing that for two reasons because believeing us said to them well why would you do that right like I said I'm going to ask you why would you do that you know and and um both Brian and uh Rachel said that with infrastructure projects where uh the school districts don't own them they not on our land because we couldn't come to we don't have a lot of land first of all but um it was really nowhere that was as advantageous to place them um that they will own that infrastructure it so because the
144infrastructure will be good past five years it's also that sta as a company really is embarking on the availability of moving diesel out and bringing Electric in they were also one of the companies that were at the Forefront of moving away from diesel fleets the propane fleets Unfortunately they had a very bad incident that occurred in kard where somebody was are killed from one going really bad um one of their workers and so they've moved a little bit away from that and are embarking more on the electric f um projects so I I think it's twofold that it fits within their um you know their company's direction of trying to be a good partner with environmentalist and sustainability so right now it's it's in whether we go with diesel because it's been projected at diesel
145rate which is 125,000 approximately purose another no if you do just email me okay any other questions from board members anything from the public um and sorry I'm not looking at any numbers this is just off top my head so but I believe the year-over-year increase was budgeted at a a 15% increase from our bus transportation so you know is it what we're paying currently this year no right it's but we we knew we were GNA it was going to be a contract year this upcoming year and we sorry it's okay um so I I was just saying that we're talking year over year right so you know what's in the budget for transportation is about 15% more than what we're paying this year however we also know that this budget Year we're talking about
146is a re contract year anyways which tends to increase some of our expectations on and and wages because of the adjustment in wages from us having um moderate increases on some of the one year right so I mean so to say that they're absorbing all of the least you know right you know and and if you're looking at kind of the cost and some of what they were saying is you know we need to have drivers primy the buses beforehand well that's extra time you know so you know I think there's some healthy skepticism in where these kind of rakes would go um they would have been the same because they were I mean we can stop and go out to bed no I'm just I'm yeah yeah no I understand you know it's a
147gift horse right we yeah yeah no what we do right the process and so you know it's just trying to understand the model because it's very different than what we have um but I am you know electric buses are currently used in Handover with at so you know I just it's not it's not unusual but it's new to so absolutely um sorry Transportation contract when it's a renewal year do we have um Clarity and transparency on future year pricing if it's like yes it's a fiveyear agreement and it's listed on the there's an attachment to this so I just want to make sure that my understanding is correct what you told us what I thought I heard before is that the financial outlay for this contract will be the same whether we vote Yes on
148these plus electric buses or no is that yes okay so there's no net budget impact for our because of the grants and because of the partnership and correct transparency in the multi-year pricing agreement it is what it is we could say yes and take the buses or we could decline the grants and stick with what we have and there will be to this document there will be no imount to what's in there now so if you run the number on how many roots we have just to be fully transparent there about a $3,000 so if there's a lack of clarity um just to follow there's a lack of clarity on how much this is actually going to um impact our vendor financially to implement this they are accepting all of that impact except based on
149that projection because they've given us an addendum to our Master agreement from 2016 which I'm happy to post that too but um yes they've given us an actual projection for Signature and they cannot change it so if someone needs to spend more time doing XYZ because of the implementation of the few newes it's not going to but the one thing that I did understand would be impacted that if we do take the electric buses and if our diesel consumption decreases then we will have a net positive gain of potentially $7,000 so so there's some potential small upside on an annual basis and there's no negative that I can see but if there is a negative I do want to see it well to me there's not a negative the the 8,000 savings wouldn't at the
150Kim's Point wouldn't be for this year because because of the how far out right when I initially started speaking to them in May um you know had had we the order of this was sooner it would have been within a year's time right so we could have potentially had them in by June and roll them out for September one and so every you know I just want to make sure that there no so Tim to my I mean we have used them as a vendor for eight years right um we had used some of their Administration with a different vendor prior and it was the year before I came but I heard it was horrible there were multiple problems um we've not had a problem with to me there's no downside we've not had a
151problem with securing drivers and when there were problems with drivers we've been pretty good and prompt about moving them out um you know with with the ability to continue routs we were able to expand a route in um Handover a half a route in the morning because of H2 being overloaded um you know they've been able to for the most part absorb all of our Athletics it's still challenging here and there you know because we have so many people that but what a great problem right with so many people that uh participated right it's great um of course that's not your cost that's J's cost um you know they're they're responsive they are responsive they're a big company they as Rachel mentioned when they call people answer the phone because they're big one we have
152to say y not to this January so I would say in the January meeting and you know again if there are more you know you're GNA leave here tonight it's a lot of stuff to absorb right and it would be not fair to give you all this information and say make a decision today right I get that because I wouldn't want to as a board member and so by January he's heing ing I'm hoping that we can if there are still questions or concerns or once you have a chance to digest it play with the numbers ask me questions ask them questions you know let's get everything answered right and if we need to bring them back let's bring them back this isn't a question it's just an observation I recall last spring that you
153were one of the most skeptical I cranky um you you did you miss the meteer meeting where I said I was I me I said that I said I was so skeptical about whether or not these are going to be okay or not you're not letting me finish I was going to compliment I was saying that you were in a very different place a few months ago and so I am in part reassured by your your change of heart yeah because I know you're a little bit attentive to Dollars that's all well and that was my compliment well part of it is the dollars right yeah yes I mean this decision is not yeah saving any money I even you know right right I think actually having it being an equal to our relative expectation
154of what a future contract would be is pretty surprising um but I think what what is a limitation right is like thinking about do we if we ever have the question of expansion of the you know of our Fleet it sounds like there's not going to be an infrastructure there's probably not going to be Federal grant funding you know and so and I know that that's not what on the table today but it's just something for us to consider when we think about because you can imagine if these things you know go well we want to do more you know we have to have that discussion too so and and I mean we have we had some of those discussions that was part of my earlier concern right is that a we didn't have room
155at any of our locations to to do this right um I have had some conversations with Folks at the Town level about perhaps if they were looking at moving to a fleet an electric Fleet for their larger trucks would it make sense for the school district to try to get into a partnership if we were thinking of expanding right because I think I I didn't get um I didn't get an early buying that they would have room to store a whole Fleet of buses up at their tow yard location but I mean it's a big site right so I think there's opportunity for expansion if that's the direction that both the town and the school district want to do as a joint venture the because truly sta doesn't care if there are still our provider
156they don't care where you put that or who owns it right it's a matter of doing it where it makes sense um you know but that's again like Kim saying it's it's getting late on the on the thing tonight but for future planning and strategic planning that should be a part of the discussion it's already a part of the discussion I'm sorry not to interject sorry not to interrupt you it's already discussion between myself and the maintenance director about anything that we may look to bring on you know for maintenance operations so the SDA charging yard is there electricity Supply by Green Mountain Power it is you know so I'm not a GRE power client personally but I know that a lot of the the electricity around the town actually has different thresholds of where
157they get their power from in terms of like energy or what not and if it was in Handover versus anybody re Junction we have access to Handover Community power which is substantially cheaper while giving higher quality sort of percent of renewable so in having a conversation there was a conversation and I'm going to get you an answer because I don't want to get it wrong okay but we had a conversation about that between Yolanda myself Brian I don't think Rachel was on the call Stacy might have been on the call about that and I vaguely remember I think yoland I think you're on the call too right Yolanda saying that green mount power had better initiatives than but I'll get an answer I surpris not yeah I have both I have both electric companies myself
158but um so so let's get the answers okay um any other questions about the budget for anyone anyone in the public that's [Music] what but the finance committee with my colleague on the committee we just wanted to say thank you very much for this invitation um in order to contribute to the analysis and and U considerations we look backwards and I wanted to comment on forward on the presentent and then beyond that so it was important for you to know that uh we looked at what we had commented on here last year and see if that got covered off as well as whatever comments we made on the statement uh regarding the the budget so as you know we we approved the the budget as a committee unanimously and within that statement all the provisions
159that were in the budget we we agreed with and made particular mention that we U agreed with the uh contract negotiation and um and cited the uh institution of the zerob based budget there so uh the other comment that was made in last year's meeting here had to do with um making sure that enrollment projections were keeping up with with Staffing and and so all of the things that we talked about both in the last year's meeting as well as within our our statement have been amply addressed so well done on that um the thing that we will do now is we're actually me Mee uh tomorrow as a committee and so we'll have a chance to uh with all of the members of the committee go over what we've heard tonight uh Tony's our
160representative of course we will come back with any uh questions U coming from that discussion one one point um just kind of a question in a comment regarding then forward looking would be coming from from FL your presentation so you know one of the things that we did um in the state last year was talking about you have the U the coach that new position that came on board and it looks like within the presentation that um there is a focus on quantifying results by the coach to to ensure that the value is being uh received for the money that's being spent for not only the position but what the training is and am I reading that correctly with some of these comments that you the the coaching is being delivered but you're testing to
161make sure that those outcomes are what what you're looking to achieve is that correct yes okay so one other comment is if you look at other um entries I would I would ask you to to look further maybe it's just absolutely implied or or assumed understood but I don't see educational outcomes being mentioned so much with within the comments and so for the value of the U increase in the budget is certainly the value for uh the investment in staff all of this you you want have return on the investment and so um that would be something that I would say very helpful thank you great interested in that at the meeting last month yeah that instructional coach step heral gave a a talk presentation on how she what she's doing how she's doing it
162how it's going so far very little meting to watch and was it correct on what what I thought that there's there's an emphasis on outcomes yeah that was partially what she talked about yes so I would encourage you guys to watch that from the November meeting and it's right okay [Music] great and by the way to I think it's fair to say that um at this point we have no um major criticisms or anything with what's happened and what's being presented to the budget so I don't expect you to be getting any surprises at all from the committee and so I just wanted to you know quite open we'll leave that still for discussion coming back with questions of course but um that's that's where we are today we're going to shift to the business
163requiring discussion and first up is appointing an accounts table Uber I believe it is Marcel and Tony at the right and prior to that de was it you and I so by my MTH I was just appointed a couple months ago I know aren't you the current person yeah but I doing we're shiing to [Music] bter I'm kind of giv tear some light glances right now all right okay thank you very much so we take that over we'll make sure to get Kelly next uh probably the next is probably one two weeks tonight Merry Christmas thank you folks foring out it's probably next week probably next week okay [Music] issue anyway shifting along to the reading of policies so these are all second readings that we discussed at president and in great detail and I
164believe there was some minor discussion last week I did last month I didn't miss that meeting any further discussion just the second reading on all of these things [Music] the emergency planning updates is this J or we it off right so the attachment you're seeing is a poster that um is this is this is called um standard response protocol which is a widely used um protocol for the language we use in emergency situations and so we've we've adopted this and um I would also so this is to give parents some idea of how we're responding to different um different safety issues in in the schools and we also on our district website on the main page the very first option is to pull out our districts the last item on that is safety and if
165you are interested in learning more um there's we're also posting information there we're being very careful to make sure that we're not revealing any information that's not already publicly available so um I encourage you if you are interested to take take a look at that uh we're we're looking forward to making sure that we're all using the same terminology from building to building that means that students who are training and all of this here at the ray school will go on to the middle school and high school we'll have the same same commands and the same actions that will be taken in an emergency situation okay so um I think we might have skipped an agenda item the discussion of potential warrant out of course oh Shi we didor Steed up too fast I mean
166finish up the emergency yeah yeah no I just sorry Lauren if you have anything else to add that's that's what we wanted to share tonight all right any any comments on the emergency planning updates see none we'll shift back think you came for that nice catch uh back to the warrant articles yeah so they've been uh hopefully updated apparently I have okaying needs to be thank you very glad and um also the the board membership needs to be updated I don't think Rick wants to do this anymore I'll get that we'll get that fixed wor it's right on dress I'll go back and double check I don't know why didn't on you know I'll R the whole thing all right so we know that one is pretty boiler plate two we did we did change
167it to 75 I believe last year from our previously stand 40 does anyone have any concerned with keeping it at 40 or keeping it at 75 EXC or changing it higher or lower anyone can no actually just to underscore I spoke to a member on the trustees and the trust fund and I asked is 75 still fine this is you know just one member right but they said totally fine 75 is fine so no concerns on board members all right in terms of the salaries haven't changed those any have any comments on salaries no okay the collective baring agreement for support staff we'll discuss later uh service staff I haven't heard anything much about that lately we there's not much to discuss about that trying to come off the dates we'll leave that then in
168terms of the budget we just talked about that that's number six number seven I be I see a big bolded or right so strong which one right which one um ask that I believe last [Music] year Jamie is there any strong reason to do one versus the other this year given how they're looking so far K anyone I personally would want maintenance M um but you know if you ask other administrators any disagreement from over there no okay okay then any anyone have concerns with maintenance no no but to to describe what it would could potentially help to fund right in the future so I mean if you look at the helpful buildings and grounds slide on um Lauren's presentation right so it's like the capital Improvement planning needs um the HVAC soundproofing this room
169which we can hear the rain I know they were talking War as uh you know the roof um you know kind of so these are these are just kind of you know extra top up funding for future needs and I I see additional needs um and maybe even the playground as well you know that it says potentially use Bridgman for it but funding you know for whatever that is might be additional as well so yeah mean where are we on the roof it's been it's been a little while since to talk about the roof there's been issues with it before I mean like how it's doing life cycle been um we've been doing repairs to it it it had a large overhaul before I got here which was eight years ago right nine probably right
170before the year before I got here it was already completed um you know flat roofs in New England are horrible and so we they had a horrible time today chasing stuff all over that lots of holes in them or even worse including the sa with three different locations um so short of changing it out and making it pitch which is super duper expensive you have to make sure infrastructure will support that all it should if it supports flat um you're eight years into a rehab right um we are addressing situations as they her I know milans was on site I think you're on site here yesterday yesterday yeah yeah they were on site of SE today um so you know we do repairs as issues ofur um I don't know it's part of the roofing
171plan really is going to hinge on the capital Improvement plan and our strategic plan on what we want to do moving forward with solarization right because at that point in time you know we'll really need to make sure that whatever condition they're in they're ready to accept an array right um so so I mean I don't think it's I don't think what we're dealing with here is horrible I think what we deal with here is often in the same location which is frustrating for many um you know is there have any concerns with the dollar amount on article 7 so I can show you how much money is uh the building maintenance Reserve um is going to be sitting at like 277,000 because uh remember we had brought it down to almost nothing when we
172did the tech project um and then our special education Reserve is probably going to be sitting depending on interest it may go higher I go a little bit low um about 358,000 by the end of this year and again um maintenance about 277 on wait did you get an answer to your question you said is are people okay with the amount yeah no one concerns you have concerns well I I I see this as like an overall like right with the total taxpayer layout this year and and this article seven also really gets [Music] into Surplus beyond what we are currently anticipating and I'm just kind of looking at a combination of you know kind of a CPI level increase this year and if we have additional Surplus because I'm continuing to hear that we
173have Surplus in Staffing in at the you know at the race School level and I'm also looking at a pretty larger list of and projects that we kind of know going forward and um I'm looking at our you know total you know maintenance budget some of these line items have been kind of relatively flat to actually lower than as far as our what's in our general budget for maintenance is actually lower than we would have typically done last year I'm just more inclined to kind of boost up the 100,000 to I mean even 200,000 you know just and that's always up to right so it's not you know if we don't have 200,000 then we're not going to take 200,000 and this would all be beyond the Surplus beyond the you know you know spending
174level we we had already committed to so I just I don't know I I feel like this might be a good year to um to boost that aspect in the maintenance I would agree with J on it because so what happened this year right we gave back 1.7 million almost against Taxation and we retain as much as we were able to um so you know so it would have been great had we been able to change that right now chryst the wall but CN as we're trending you know a little bit we filled a few positions but we haven't filled a lot if we were going into the next fiscal year out I don't know that I would agree right with how much Surplus we're going to come off of but coming off of this
175fiscal year with the Surplus I think and keep in mind you have a you have a safety net there right because it says it's only money that's above what you're promising back against a tax assessment so so it's it is an up to if you don't have the 200 then you whatever is left goes there happens raising it to 200 okay let's make that change and also um J the very last sentence uh probably should be January 2025 I think right oh yeah crial failure and and just add Marcel when you take fix I don't know why I did not fix an I'll actually pull it down and fix it and pop it back up everyone ready to move on Tony so I think one of the Warren articles says the board recommends approval of
176this this appropriation but I wonder if we could put the board position on all of the Articles uh we will and we will yeah and then um one of them has the effect on recommendations on um it has the the budget implication in one of them I believe but I wonder be added to you tell me where you're um article one yeah has um same ston as last year this article's effect on the tax rate is negligible but we don't have anything about the effect on the tax rate of any of the others like article seven yeah that's a note that's been I don't know why it's been carried over year after year after year we could probably so either strike it from the one or put it on all of them and they don't
177allow you to put it on all of them so we'll probably strike it from that one on surprised the state hasn't come back until start the notes on the four and five have to be there they um because of the type of article there anything thank you for that mbers let's move on down to where are business cing action I take a motion to approve the expenditure minutes and all [Music] the I moveed to approve items B through d by consent seconded by Tony uh Kelly are you there H MC joined us virtually right after I said she wasn't here things time to go right so thank you Kelly starting with k yes Nelson yes Kelly can you hear me hello you say yes hello can you hear me Mell yes you can hear me
178it is unanimous thank you all right moving on to report of the chair I'd like to thank tarot for doing an excellent job um at the meeting that Kelly and I missed I watched the today it was awesome and thank you so much you're welcome to be here easily and the next meeting will be on we're going to remember in January we have two weeks in a row one specific to the hearing of budget adoption the second will be our regular meeting so we'll see you after the holidays and I did enjoy my lots of travel time lately with Lauren and Jay it was very surreal with our new capital new friends in conquer and that's all say say about that moving on to any committee level reports we've heard a lot about budget today
179and any other updates nsba Capital Improvement committee Finance of anyone nothing really right we'll move right on to Jay's report and I will just reiterate what Lauren have already mentioned about Blue Ribbon recognition at the state level U it's it's it really is a nice event each year they recognize teacher of the year and some other Awards as well um and and uh it was it was nice for us to ask him a little bit of Pride and the great job that all of our staff do and make the school such an excellent place to learn um the other thing I want to talk about first is make a public apology to Jamie so I've gone into great detail about how we make the snow day call year after year and I've attached that as
180my written report just a reiteration through the letter I submitted last year um this this morning we done it like two or three times already this week oh my God before 5 a.m texting with our respective people and then we get we get on the phone together and we we touch base around 5 this morning and I went back and forth with the Vermont superintendent and the New Hampshire superintendent and then promptly fell asleep apparently around 5:25 five minutes before Jamie had to make the definitive call um which she did without me thankfully so I I want to just say sorry it won't happen again um I've already been relegated to the guest room on nights when I might have to be up early and will be doing so again tonight I think not so
181uh so just want to remind everybody a lot goes into it we don't make these decisions lightly uh whether we call a snow day or decide not to it's it's usually and and we're doing it more and more in concert with um other leaders in the region who are who are talking to their own road crews and making that decision is informed as possible um and that letter is attached and um again we welcome feedback but I address the whole feedback loop in the letter so um we do the best we can will the repeat of this letter be going out to the yes I will be sending it out again I I made mention of I think in the last newsletter but I'll go into greater detail and just re re submit the letter
182there there is a line that says bear in mind it's only January that it's only January it's last year's letter it's last year yeah I when I send it I'll keep it just the way it is and send has changed app all you guys no matter what hours of the day he's going he's going sleep yeah you were working late last night speaking wed it's all good all right um anything else J no that's it all right thank you very much for that let's see Robin with us then hello so I've submitted my report and I'm happy to answer any questions anyone might have okay any have any questions for Robin about this yeah about her um report or anything else I was gonna ask her about the Taylor Swift concert but um that might
183be lots of fun anything specific to I see all right thank you for the report Rob we appreciate itome see you thanks Jamie anything on top of what we already talked about today you talk a few times to not really other than to thank our road crews and Hannah R Norway have been really on the ball this year answering our calls right away prly so it's very helpful um thank you to the parents even who were emailing me in morning letting me know what their conditions are in their area because I I do forward it to them thank you for that we appreciate that as we also extend our thanks to all the parties involved um that say we do have multiple needs for non-public tonight um and the specific reasons are there was a
184Personnel issue and then the contractual issue which would be we SLI C for personal matter and see is anyone else I think we're say a and appreciated all right second invite we have to the one more time starting yes yes yes Kelly right Kell's not with us all right and my son yes let going to non public I will try F and you add my bring your computer e e e and we're back and thank you everyone um as we noted in the agenda review we did add a vote regarding a negotiation agreement may be happy to take motion right now move to approve the tenative agreement with the hover support staff ass ation as presented seconded by Tara and we did lose Kelly due to connectivity issues so we can do all those in
185favor it is unanimous 5 Z thank you all and then second opportunity for public to address the board there's no one here or online so we'll move on send me any items you have for the agenda for the next meeting remember there are two separate vanular meetings the first a specific to the public hear budget adoption on January 18 so that I'll take a motion toour I move to adjourn at 9:35 p.m. second starting with Kim yes and Keen yes thank you everyone we're adjourned we'll see you at TR next week