CorpusRecord 55674

Norwich School Board - December 4, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SAU 70 Media
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Grafton County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,602 words · about 76 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001this computer all right okay it is live you are live all right we will call our meeting to order at 605 first item on the agenda is our agenda review [Music] agenda I hope so it won't as as yourself okay so I guess I No Agenda review items all right do we have any comments from the anybody that's online you raise your you over have a me one second I and ra okay Leah I think you are able to chat now okay looking for the mute button one second I just want to okay can you try again yes can you hear me now awesome good okay great um I'm just going to give you the PTO update does that sound good great um so in November we had our fall Feast it was beautiful super

002yummy we had great participation from families and staff really appreciated all the food um we tried to give staff a heads up to not bring in lunch and bring in an empty container to take home leftovers and that worked really well um the PTO also supported an all School celebration we had four parents come in and help cover all of the doors in the school which was quite the morning that was fun um and now we're shifting our Focus to the upcoming events so Sunday December 8th we have the gift making Festival we have 10 tables of activities for kids to make homemade gifts for the special people in their lives we will also have a wrapping station so kids can rrap on site and we will also have a photo backdrop um Tuesday December

00310th we have coffee talk with Sean and Greg and then we have a few things in the works um we just had the Haven reach out so we will be colle ing something for a food drive uh more to come on that um the wish jars from the fall PTO Grant are set to be displayed before the holiday concerts next week so I think that will be a nice start and end to the evening for families um and we are also kicking off holiday gift giving this week we are following the model that we did last year where we take a whole school approach we pair Home Room teachers with support or specials or additional staff and then each class collects money to give a gift to their three or sometimes two staff members and

004it's a way for everyone in the building to be recognized and um hopefully to get a little something for the holidays families and kids can also show appreciation in a non-monetary way by making a card for their teacher at the gift making Festival we will have a special box there collecting cards um that kids can make and then also in the works Chrissy Morley reached out about a grant she received to get a soup and sandwich day off the ground and I think there's a lot of enthusiasm uh on the PTO and from parents around that so we are forming a cafeteria subcommittee group to help get her the volunteers and support she needs to make the initiative a success and that is all I have for right now any questions no that's super helpful

005thank you for calling in I've been reading your notes at the past few meetings so those have been helpful too thank you awesome thank you so much for being there move on to our presentations got the first one is our special ed one cor yes uh I'm going try to share my screen have to request Jam is like running ADV it tonight right so I think what I would suggest to board members that if you haven't if you look up to the zoom then you'll be able to see what that's why they give me administrative access so when when Jam's here I can't log in first I have to let them log in first otherwise Thea but that's why just in case right on Zoom indid this bill is Education Act correct okay um so

006um I'm assuming we can okay uh I'm right d I'm the director for student services for the school district uh each year during the budget presentation um I give an overview of what special education is and the impact on the Norwich budget um it is about 16% of the total norch budget so I think get warrants and explanation opportunities for questions um explain the rationale for why we um have these fund allocated for students with disabilities the first slide that you see uh a general overview um is federal education laws which we refer to as Ida individuals with Disabilities Act which ensures that all students regardless of ability are afforded the same opportunities and equal access to education u a few of the primary tenants um Fai which ensures that all students are provided a

007free appropriate public education public meaning we can't charge parents or students with disabilities money because their child May cost more to educated that has to be part of the public SCH system least restrictive environment L uh to ensure that all students are in the general education classroom receiving their instruction with all students to the maximum extent appropriate and then IEP is an individualized education program which is the document in the plan which describes how the student learns what their needs are what their strengths are and what the school district is going to do about meeting those students briefly the special education process is all regulated ferally and then each state implements those rules um a referral is it mer sta parent or anyone from the school team can make a referral which then triggers the

008team including parents School staff to meet and discuss are there significant concerns at warrant and evaluation team decides yes then an eval valtion will be conducted and it has to be completed within 60 days that can include anything from psychological testing academic achievement testing adaptive Behavior speech and language occupational therapy the evaluation specifically designed for that student what those concerns are within those 60 days a team completes evaluations reviews the results and then makes the determination to answer really three questions does an educational disability exist if so does it significantly adversely impact that student's learning and then three if so do they require especially denied instruction something explicitly targeted for that student as a result of their within 30 days of that meeting the team would then develop an IEP the I is reviewed annually

009and then every 3 years at a minimum um the students are reevaluate to check on progress to see if that condition still exists this slide shows the categories of educational disabilities um you'll notice they don't necessarily necessarily correlate to medical diagnosis um these are listed in the federal regulations for student disabilities um and how you meet criteria for these may be different than a diagnosis which you would receive from a pediatrition or a psychologist and now we're going to get into some specific data looking at the mar Cross School and this slide shows the percentage of students with disabilities by primary disability from the total enrollment so some students have more than one disability and this categorizes the Maring cross students over the last five years um and you'll see that there tends to be

010common trends that DD which was developmental delay tends to be the largest category over the past five years um that's for students between ages three and nine and it's really a catchall for those students when they're young the team notices something atypical about their learning and the most effective approach is early intervention and so there's a large number of younger students that ID ified and after they reached age 9 or 10 they're reevaluated and if there are still concerns those numbers in that DD category will then transition to another category one specific example if you look at SLI which is speech language impairment it looks like there's a large spike in this current year um and there's also a deine in developmental delay so last year we had four students with a developmental delay that

011were reevaluated and now they're identified under speech because that more accurately reflects the challenges that they have if there are questions do this please just interrupt or speak up these are um IMA or if you're out all the bars it means that you have about 70% of the kids with some sort of sorry so this is based on the number of students compared so we're looking at speech language impairment about 21% this year out of the students with disabilities Oh I thought this was out of the mar cross population that's the next slide okay I was like well we get 70% of the kids okay so this SL uh shows the percentage of students with disabilities from Total enrollment um and the most recent data from the state of Vermont that I was able to

012access from 2022 and I was at 18.1% but then I have the data and information from Mar cross for the past 10 years we are showing a steady decline uh over the past three four years um in the percent student with disabilities uh I was talking with principal GA earlier just trying to um and so what may be the reason for that um and we had some changes in special education rules that went Mo effect in July of 2022 we started changing the funding model there have been intervention programs that have been in place and I would say steadily increasing both in like the FTE allocated towards it and the kind of attention to those programs um so I think it's a good place to be for students where we now have a range of

013supports ranging from students who only require classroom instruction and we have intervention available where students can receive some support in reading and math a checkin and checkout program address social behavioral needs and then kind of at that tier three level we have special education and IEPs for students who have more significant this slide shows both Mar and cross that thicker red line is mar and cross and that's the same line in the previous slide but it also includes state of Theon Trend the ray School in Handover the Middle School RMS and Handover high school just to look at as a whole SAU where are we at with our students um Elementary School student elementary schools tend to have higher percentages of students with disabilities than middle school and high school um because some of those

014students needs are addressed efficiently and they no longer need that level of support as they metricate through the grades and so thinking about our specific data the budget cost which I'll get into the next couple of slides um really the majority of the special education costs are from Staffing uh and this gives a brief overview of the different Service delivery models that are available and we have or currently utiliz that Mar and cross uh push in is when you have a special educator or one of our other professionals occupational therapist te language pathologist go into the General Ed classroom with the student and work with them in that environment pull out is when a specialist would take a student out of the general education classroom to work with them either in a one-on-one setting or

015in a small group and that may be necessary the students skills are significantly behind grade level and it they can't work on that skill in the classroom C teing and collaboration uh we don't currently have any co- teing models we did three years ago we do a little bit of prek um and that's really where it's a it's a specifically designed bottle that we have to get approved through the state of Vermont where a special education teacher and a classroom teacher as the name says Cod teach a grade level or content area grades and then academic and Behavior Support uh this is provided primarily by our par professionals so they would either be working with the student in the classroom to support the work that a special educator we've been working with the student on

016to facilitate transference of skills um ensuring that that child has access to what the learning is in the classroom and some students require one-onone par professional support due to selfcare needs um significant social behavioral needs so they may have a staff member that works with them across the school day in all environments to ensure that they're getting the support of when we look at the specific expenses that are included in the budget which will go through in more detail and Jamie is going to go through the presentation later um the costs include special education for kindergarten through sixth grade so that's staff contracted Services instructional supplies materials equipment we also provide special education for students age three through five um and that includes all the same component staff and Contracting Services extended school year services

017are for students who need some instruction and service F over the summer and so there's staff cost for that as well and then out of district schools in programming for Norwich resident students for students that reside in Norwich and require a school or placement outside of the public school and that includes students K through 12 um So currently we have three students that are Norge residents of Dr and AG that attend out of District programs and those costs come back to normal for students who live in Handover and res those cost go back to the Handover and this final slide uh shows our special education budget over the past few years and then where we actually came out on expenditures and you'll see that it's rare that we are spot on with our budget projection

018and where we end up at the end of the year um a lot of fluctuations occur due to changes in students who replaced out of District you may know we may not know either students that move into the district move out their needs change halfway through the school year which do the line up will be for budgets and we build those budgets uh and so so the increase this year uh for projected RIS year 26 um is primarily due to salary and benefits of Staff um when I looked at last year this for year 24 that difference between what was budgeted and what we actually spent was there's about 200,000 Less in out of District tuition so there's a student that be budgeted for that we believed was going to require out District placement and

019those needs changed between when we approved the budget and the school year so those weren't costs that we ended up spending um and we're also down about 30,000 in educational assistant per professional salary du to un positions were there any questions about any what I went over so far I'll also be here for the rest of the presentation so if questions come up as we go through the line items I question one is have we have you been able to make a correlation between Co and special education needs no we have seen consistencies in some challenging eras for certain grade levels but we're not seeing a spike in special education I know I've been a part of some meetings where there are number of handwriting concerns that get brought up by parents or other professionals

020and it tends to be in a Grade where those students would have more targeted instruction maybe during Co um if there isn't any thing we're special education wise whether they're seeing an increase in need I think part of that is address through intervention that if not the disability that's causing that challenge those students are going to receive that intervention and that's going to be an appropriate support for them or they get back on track where they need to as opposed to a disability which is consistently going to be challenging for them um I want to go back to something you said earlier I just want to make sure that I understand it right um and that special education categories and the resulting I don't necessarily track a clinical diagnosis did I am I understanding that

021correct so so then I have a followup So based if that's true right um is there a connection between special education needs and a student's socio economic status um we don't have any data here but there is research and data that shows correlation between school districts and students who live in low socioeconomic conditions and higher rates in those areas for student would it be a fair statement to say that because of the affluent nature of Norwich that is why we might be seeing numbers lower than the state average I think that's a fair assessment I mean the state average includes all school districts and we're that one small town and norch is just an elementary dist so those State numbers include districts K through I think there are definitely challenges that other school districts have

022that we don't experience here I'm fortunate for that and that our school staff are able to address the needs as they present and not maybe masking some other need that looks like something that it's not one example is students with the categor is called emotional disturbance which is not a great name but that's the term that the regulations provide um and I think often times those students can struggle behaviorally socially with regulation some of that is caused by a legitimate um emotial disturbance mental health conditions but I think that can also present for children who don't have the basic needs now teasing out what's the cause can be difficult in service situations I think here we're fortunate to have good evaluations families that work with us and they show up um so we can really

023get a full picture of who the students are of best thank you Gary couple questions but I just out of curiosity want to follow up on that last comment to the extent you're trying to assess whether something's emotional disturbance or a child who's failing to get their basic needs met if it's the latter is there an IEP for that or some other way in which we work to support child B so if we go back to this slide so there's those three criteria the first one is there an educational disability and each of those categories of disability has its own specific definition that has to be met and so when we evaluate um for student with an emotional disturbance we're looking for do they have some um psychological condition that causes them to have impairments

024in regulation social behavioral skills um we look at kind of family history we look at economic disadvantage all those questions are part of that evaluation so we can really try to best identify what the cause of that challenge is and if we can do that then we know we the best so for students who don't meet that criteria that may have struggles not caused by disability that will go back to their school's other means of support meet those on slide four uh you noted the large increase in speech language impairment um do you think that's a blip or a trend um that's a blip expect that to go down in the next there yeah so those students um it was three students in 23 four and then it's up to eight students this current year

025and four of those were coming from that developmental delay um then thinking about not just the nor School District but the whole SAU is it the same cohort of children um receiving special education services all the way through the end of their education or here there are people cycling children in cycling in and out like how much churn if any is there in special education services yeah that's a that's a good question we don't have specific numbers I know this year alone I've been a part of two or three meetings here where we reevaluate student that had an IP and the team agre that they no longer meet criteria because they've made sufficient progress they don't need that Target instruction so they move off the we've also had meetings at the high school where students

026have never had an I but there significant concerns presenting team evaluates and they determine that there's significant anxiety disorder which is impacting their learning and they require an I level of support and service so I think my answer be both there definitely are students who start with an IP in kindergarten require that up to graduation in high school and I guess my final question if I may I apologize if the language here is not precise but just so I can try to understand the experience to the extent I can students and families utilizing special education services when you make that determination that someone no longer needs an IP is that viewed as from a family's perspective as a graduation or a reduction in Services um both we have those meetings and I think part of

027you wants to celebrate because the students made so much progress that they no longer need that support but with that also comes concern parents as students transition from this school to the middle school for Middle School to high school um and so often times it's mixed emotions in those because the evaluation results are shown as good growth no longer need for taking that student out of the class to get these Services um and are Tis of intervention that you're no longer eligible for an I but you still have a condition you may have a disability but it's just not significantly impacting the learning yeah um there's 504 which is a different federal law the civil rights law on education law but it ensures that anyone with disability has equal access and can be afforded accomodations

028so often times a student that had an IP and is no longer ible May refer to a board because they need some support they may need some accommodations in your classroom for testing and that would then be the theer of intervention that they need I appreciate that you're trying to figure out whether someone is putting their umbrella away because it's sunny out or because they sto wet point you put the umbrella away not Sports and just prot I need right yeah uh one other thing that the teams consider is when we look at that student progress and considering do they no longer need an IP we look at those mitigated measures of okay are they making this progress because the services they're getting are necessary and if we take those away would they still make

029so those are questions that the team has to ensure that we're not in appropriately discharging than yeah I apologize for being late um and if I'm missed this I apologize as well um I'm glad you mentioned the five of fours and I'm wondering because that is also under your department correct um do we know like is it a similar Trend we have fewer than the state at 504s or do we have more because we tend to recognize that they need the extra support um and sort of what what sort of impact do the 504s have on this because this isn't all you do I don't want to I don't want people to think that this is it so yeah no uh I prepar the special ucation presentations because there's that significant budget portion um five

030four needs are addressed through the general education piece and they're not nearly as significant as special education I don't have numbers of Bible for Handy but um I'd be happy to share those or I've done presentations for school STA and others where we look at like what are the differences between special education and 504 I believe here there's 14 yeah maybe cou less 12 students that have 5504 plans and some students that have a medical 504 plan individualized health plan if they may have diabetes or something that they need combinations but it may not impact their learning unless something okay so it sounds like the budget have for the F course is just absorbed in the regular budget and and you don't and you don't have concerns about that I would say at most there

031may be consultation from an occupational therapist or someone or um teacher for death and Har hearing May consult with the school team to ensure the child's thank you I just want to express appreciation for re um not only does he have high know our [Music] kids just a clarification I like to ask the Maran cross budget contains the special education costs for students not just here but also at the middle school and high school yeah and just um because the question was asked um in the 1100 which is your regular education the money set aside for 504 contracted services are year over year is actually down 6,600 so it has a it's projected decrease in any other questions anyone from the public have questions for okay all right well thank you R for all that

032you do um and for all the help even come to the budget meeting last week that I missed very helpful to be there in person um with that said why don't we move on to our budget presentation okay yeah give me one second because I'm meanning this and do you want to do the presentation I'm just I'm going to go over there and use and her computer and like I'm not in front ofen over [Music] here GNA allow and are you are you in yes just want to allowa to promote the panelist share the screen I think I can the screen sorry about this all right my extent of Zoom abilities okay okay let me um there screen here so um if you opened your um board dos early I might not have posted again

033in the haste to get us up and running on an hourl so if you refresh there is a budget presentation same one you have as a paper format okay um I'm gonna excuse me open it here so we can speak to it uh like red um it iig we'll just go for it can you see this I don't have out the rest so we're just going to go for it okay all right so the first slide is basically just telling you um everyone that work directly on building the budgets we build the budgets in a remote fashion uh Often by departments and um you know obviously the bulk of the building of the budget is done by Sean and his staff here at the Maran Cross School um and then the finance team rebuild the

034salary and benefits in conjunction with um the principal and his staff over here on based on the needs and based on looking at the enrollment um and then everybody like who oversees an Department um like Bryant Patton Tony dagel re as he mentioned they all build their portions of the budget then we bring it all together usually um last week of October is our first look at it as a whole complete document like we all see our little pieces but we don't really know what it's going to look like so it's all brought together and that's what we call our first draft the draft you're looking at tonight is actually a second draft because because as we work through the first draft that we meet together and you know we look at anywhere where we

035might have missed something okay because you have all kinds of pieces that are moving around so all of these folks were involved um and on the budget committee was Neil and Garrett right Neil and Garrett my budget committee members um and I think a few other folks might have popped their heads on occasion um and so that's where're on that work okay we always like to share the slide for I'm hoping this is updated okay sometimes I don't get the most up to date one when I pull them off of the internet anyway we like to share the mission and vision statements of the school districts and of the schools within the districts and um what they're trying to accom with their kiddos here we're prek through sixth grade um and then the children move

036on to Maran Cross School for seventh year um I'm not going to read them technical difficulties myself there we go so we also like to have a discussion about the budget guidelines um the budget guidelines were shared in the September meeting for Norwich and they were ratified then uh we ratified budget guidelines based on what we we call is a quick model the quick model can be found if you go to the nor which budget committee um pay um section in the board docks um we build a quick model where we take assumptions from the prior year push them forward so we can see what we think it might look like based on what we know in August okay we did that and in doing that the board took a look at the quick model

037is broken up in two sections and the top section shows a direct K prek through six costs and then below that it carves out other costs that really aren't discretionary to the direct education of the students here at the school meaning it carves out in the bottom the cost for the SAU the cost for transportation to and from school which no is in the Norwich budget even though they transport to middle and high uh the cost for any debt Serv the cost for any Capital Improvements uh the cost for special education at a district or special Transportation um so anything that isn't a cost in the normal direct programming for the marry and cross students here in the school is basically carved up okay and so when we looked at that on the quick model

038for prek through six it showed that we were projecting about a budget increase of 202,000 or approximately 3.10% and so the board charged us with trying to keep the direct k6 operating budget increase at 0% and so I'm happy to report that when we look at the actual and I'm sorry I didn't rebuild this for you but I can for the budget book okay um the actual for prek through6 direct is 6,517 1863 that was last year updated for this year it's 6,549 451 that is a increase of $ 31,5 188 or a half a percent so in the building of what was discretionary and direct for the school here we are up about a half a percent 48% okay or $ 31588 um so the balance of the 1.92% increase or0 and a half%

039increase is is all of those other things that are below that quick model line that are that are um non-discretionary to shaan's team okay um then we look at projected enrollment and we use what is called the cohort survival method it takes information as students have moved up in grade level over the past five years and it averages it so we first of all take the actuals for this year which we have listed in the second column on the top chart and it pushes those kids forward to the next grade it then takes the adjustments based on a fiveyear average as people transfer from one grade level to the next and it either it either adds a student number in or decreases a student number out or um minus is a student de so as

040you can see in K through one historically over the past five years we've added four students and then one to two we've lost one student two to three we we added one 3 to four we've added two four to five five and five to six we've lost three okay and there's many different reasons for that we have a bit of a transient population do in part to the folks who work at the college maybe come in for special projects folks who work at the hospital sometimes if you're losing sixth graders they might be moving on to private schools you know so there's many different reasons we really haven't tracked because the numbers aren't huge right but we use those numbers and we drive it into this chart and we draw drive it out over 5

041years so when we do that projected for 2526 interestingly enough the number is static sometimes that happens um so then we and we meet as a team with the administration um from the SAU and Sean and his folks and then we look at what might be projected as different class sizes or sections we do that for two reasons first reason we do it is because we want to make sure that having 21 teachers is enough right um and we when we do that we look at what our class siiz policies are to try to make sure that we stay within the um boundaries of that um and so we show in the second chart the first section that's what we have for this year for 2425 we said well if we kept the teachers in

042their same exact spots that they are in right now and look use the new numbers what would the class sizes look like and you can see that would be problematic for grade four because that would be really big class and so then we say okay well maybe in 25 26 there would have to be some movement between numbers of where the teachers are assigned obviously this is a what if right this is not what's going to happen as of you know for next year because Sean and his team make that decision as you get closer to opening the school usually that decision is made what August right August yeah so so that's due to change absolutely but it's just a wh if and we also look at a wh if to see if we had

043to make Cuts because as you can look back at the prior slide with what we thought we were projecting as a dollar amount of increase it may have required a significant cut and significant cuts only come from reduction in stad not only but usually you can also cut all your Na's budgets you know not do anything but that's a whole different story okay all right so that's what's going on in that slide so we look at that I'm sorry I'm going backwards we look at the budget guidelines we look at Staffing we looked at the Staffing in a different view on how many we have now you might say why do we have 21 teachers shown on the prior SL showing 28 regular regular teachers here well because we have other folks within that uh

044certified section that are not necessarily labeled classroom teachers right they do um I'll get this wrong but they do languages and they do art and they do music and they do PE and librar Library well Librarian Is listen below them she has her own line because that's not in the 1100s so really the numbers that you see here also line up with what is known as your function codes in your budget function codes can also be looked at as departmental codes right they're kind of interchangeable so when we looked at this information the marry and cross school like many of our other schools in schools in all the districts New Hampshire and Vermont have had a a terrible time trying to cover illness and other outages and so substitutes are very far and few between

045and when you have multiple certified staff out in the same day it really provides a difficulty for making sure that everything is covered and so because of that uh Sean and his team decided that they would take one of the FTE in the upper section and move take the and move that FTE down into a um a um certified substitute section uh we do not show certified substitute sections here and so oh and you know what I posted the wrong one there I'm sorry that's last year I posted last year here I need to post this year hold on one second I'm showing you last year f i was obviously probably interrupted on the phone when I posted that so let me come back to that slide and we'll look at that as we go

046forward because what occurred this year sorry about that guys if you look at um the FTE posting that's within all of the sections uh in the board docks it has the correct Staffing FTE we made one staffing change from the teachers down to the substitute section when we made one large staffing change from the regular education EA section down in the special education EA section we also added a0 2 in ESL so I will get that updated with the correct slide sorry um and data and like I said the data on the exhibit that is in the section of board dos is correct at the end of the day we ended up with a change of 0.006 F yes yeah I'm looking at exhibit 11 in the boards it's still 2224 to is it okay

047I get it posted I'm sorry that's okay I just wanted to make sure so I will get that reposted it only take a minute uh right after we finish this while we post it so you can see we have shared it before but we want to make sure you got the right information that goes along with the significant change slide it's been a crazy day in my world so apologies um it's a 0.06 that's it's less than less than 10 10 um I'll pull it up you can see so it's noted here excuse me the significant changes and what I just mentioned with the salary changes and the FTE are noted up above here and you can see that the coordinating dollar amounts are there uh there were also non FTE changes in salary lines

048in the non-union wages uh 2% for admin and 2 and a half% plus there were a couple of steps for folks who are non-exempt or considered hourly workers they're non-administrative they're non they're not high higher admin um and also to note that we are in uh negotiations with both the teachers union and the support staff Union so steps have been included in the budget at the present wage levels but no base increases have been included because we've not come to a room yet as you can see the medical insurance uh rate election changes and and the different FTE changes are resulting in a total increase of 27491 for medical um there was a medical election change that had an offset of $27,000 so that would have been higher with the 11.9% rate increase but because

049there were some election changes it actually came in lower um the other Associated benefit costs which would be like um uh 403b matches UI workers comp increases um New Hampshire retirement system increase percent all of those are coming in at 2396 uh the SAU assessment has increased you can see here at 66520 I've asked to risk that because we are in discussion at Dresden School District about cutting the budget and the Dresden school district is absorbing the bulk of the increase from the SAU budget so that number may be subject to change um that's why I've asked dle prek tuition is a slight increase really due to the rate the state of Vermont sets the rate every year um overall the supply and Equipment lines are a slight decrease of both of 88,200 and 5,800

050respectively and then changes in special ed are as follows these specialized therapies which include testing Psychological Services physical and occupational therapy all total are showing a decrease of 33850 which mentioned earlier that there are changes going on that are in a positive direction uh while the summer programs adjusted only down by about 600 and the outer District tuition is projected to decrease by about 40,000 that corresponds with the specialized transportation for out a district um at 19,000 rounded out uh the F the facilities and maintenance property and service contracts have decreases totaling 17,200 a lot of that is because we're no longer having to pump septic P okay uh transportation is budgeted with an increase for two and from school of about 26350 some are offset by field trips when you look at that as

051a rolled up line um we are carrying monies for a half of a route expansion once we can find another bus driver we would like to put on another half a root to relieve the I think norch five norch five is a huge route and it's very full and it goes over a a a large span of area so that's why we're carrying that additional monies in that one um site and building improvements which is totally discretionary um is projecting a decrease of 83,000 I think everybody can understand why we've done a lot here in the last uh two years um I should have done pictures is invol everything that we've accomplished but I did not have time to do that uh Debt Service payments on our current projects and then the heating upgrade lease

052payment is coming for its first payment this coming year for 2526 and that's the projected increase we went for and New York on that uh transfer to food service accounts down 8,000 last year or I should say yeah 2324 the program broke even which is amazing it's a great thing um because the money that they give you from everywhere and everybody really doesn't it's not designed to break even so um kudos to our food service staff they did a great job um and then again not included is the wage and benefit changes so total changes at the bottom line is an addition of 1527 764 up and down they all some of it was absorbed or 1.92% okay moving right along why want be here all night right um two different ways to look at

053the budget they both tell different stories this is a budget overview by function like I said function is basically departmental do you have questions that I could answer along the way okay I I just can hear you okay thank you um the budget over because if you do feel free to stop me okay um budget overview by function is really like by department and so you you can see like all the 1100 are your regular education uh we're down a bit there technology we're up a little bit special education is up a little bit guidance and Health Services are rolled together even though they are actually separate departments we roll them up together when we report them um the curriculum staff development media and Library are all four different separate departments but they're rolled together

054when we um report them and then the school board and superintendent services are up a bit as we mentioned School administration that's basically all of the information that is encompassed in the principal's departments that also includes retiring costs for um retirement payments you know after folks are gone it also includes an uptick in coverage for the h is it ra I think it's the H yeah the health reimbursement accounts is covered is carried in that section and we did have an increase in that um and then you can look down through the line here um building and sight improvements we discussed that one debt service and food service transfers that's the two we discussed just briefly netted against each other because again they're rolled up into the same section when we report now there's another

055way to look at the budget which tells a different story you can look at it by object object and subject they're interchange able depending on who you're talking to they may call it subject um all 100s in the object section are salaries all 200s are benefits all 300s are purchase professional Technical Services all 400s are purchased Property Services okay and so on you can read them there um the other purchase services in the 500s are usually like utilities uh travel communication um and items such as that so as you can see we're down a little bit in the teaching salaries which we would be because one FTE was redirected right to other salary lines so we're up in the other salary lines which makes sense because we have increases in the areas of custodial support

056staff for steps we have increases in our non-union section and we move that $50,000 out of the teaching line down into the um District substitute La okay so um also you can look at payroll taxes and benefits and so those are all lump together to report and those are up about almost 4% um the other significant ones purchase Property Services are down 114 um the other significant is du's fees and debt and again that's the first lease debt payment coming in at 143 so that's the other significant one that's pointed out when you look at it as overview by object or subject yes yes absolutely number yesu no actually I do know what that is off the top of my head it was a change in election benefit of $27,000 C so that's where the

057that's where that election benefit changed that made the really big difference in the uptick of cost for health insurance and sure jimy you minut thought before on discretionary so if we were to look at this you thr number kind of said it was flat if you exclud the discretionary so what numbers would you include on that not on that on the disc yeah like either function or object is it easy like how are you doing that now so is are you ex certain lines are you saying well Debt Service is off like right if it's a which ones would you say were your flat non discretionary non-discretionary would be anything contracted right that we cannot break so anything debt related you cannot break right anything Union agreements or negotiated um agreements cannot be broken so

058those are not discretionary um anything required by state or federal law are not discretionary so pretty much basically all your special education section is probably non-discretionary other than within those lines discretionary pieces would be like travel supplies equipment um so most of your probably six and 700 object codes could be discretionary and then discretionary would be maintenance um in the Capital Areas which are those lower ones because those are project related right that we decide we're going to do the floor we're going to do a a bathroom or we're going to do new doors or anything like that those are discretionary any of the contracts that we have to carry like for the alarm system or for um Insurance yeah thank you tresa and anything like that would be in the service contract section and

059so those would be non-discretionary because you you have to do it in order to report to state or federal yeah so but we could come up with that number for you for the next meeting if you wanted to know what that you had mentioned when you first sat down you your notebook and you I was wondering where you would P that oh um I went back and looked at the quick model okay and so on the quick model we had rolled up all the prek through six um direct uh Educational Services and programming and we had carved out down below the items that they didn't have control over which would be SAU out of out of District special ed um the capital projects the you know those items so I went to the quick model

060because I wanted to give you a comparison based on the budget guidelines discussion but but there are more discretionary Lines within you know the regular program here within the school because supply lines equipment lines you know those are all discretionary I have seen school districts where you know large out of District placement costs have moved in and they've Frozen budgets and stopped spending right I mean you know you you then make do with what you have right so right the word can be in different ways I was wonder where you got that yes because you clearly had a yes I was doing a math over there based on because I wanted to be able to give you a comparison on the guideline yes um I'm just wondering that the you noted that we didn't you

061didn't include the negotiated wage changes how much of an impact does that have or agreement and then when is that agement expected I don't know isn't in it's not included and so it's an important point Sorry Bas just so everyone's clear so we do not have this year we're reentering into negotiation with regular Ed and teachers and support teachers and support right Neil so these are right now because the contract so what will happened that was this what happened last year right so those of us that been on the board for a while all of a sudden you hear people like Tom other and de say like this is you have to pay attention what happens is that the next year we'll have to basically catch up those items so those things that the the

062the impact of the extra not just the steps but what actually the increases right will impact next year's budget it could depending on yeah go ahead yeah what I would say though is we we are doing everything that we can to try to wrap up negotiations and time to be able to have a number to this so uh just met with support staff earlier this evening met with teachers um just a few days before that um and we've got a schedule in place that is trying to drive us to um having negotiated settlements in time in this budget and is that just done every two years or is it done every is it just done a basis no depends on uh what both sides can agree to for a duration of contracts and um uh

063there is sufficient uh I would say there's sufficient uncertainty in Vermont's education funding formula um that uh um there's there's a hesitancy to engage in a multi-year contract the most recent year contract that was a two-year contract right but for regular Ed but it was almost two years in had been dagging on for a long time so we are already everyone was highing we just finished our negotiations but we almost entered negotiations immediately again we good news is we just agreed to a contract I will say that we're in a much better place this year than we have been in past years because we don't have multiple years that we're trying to put catch up on we are current like so for 2425 we're current in our budget you know so that's a great place

064for us now um and if we can come to an agreement prior to the budget uh you know having to go be ratified that's great what I will say is steps are included at the present um wage levels so a portion of what you negotiate is included thank you I would add just one more comment um there are many examples in Vermont's education funding system where um the state has the authority and we have the accountability and so if you're sitting there wondering gez you knew the budget was coming up but now you're in negotiation body to take care of this beforehand um part of what informs us is the tax commissioner so-call December 1 letter which gives the outlook for the education fund and that just came out M and so it is very

065hard in my opinion as a m of negotiating comme it's very hard to offer absent that letter about the state of the current education fund and so we've only have 48 hours of that letter one offer it but you know it's hard to start that process and faster than that yeah the timing I think you it's not optim um okay great questions thank you um I'm on slide nine for those of you who are following on paper um this is I just have one yes so um I read the the changes document I see money flowing from a teacher salary object code to the other salaries exactly the way that you described um in the absence of exhibit 11 where does that position come like does does do we have a hypothesis about what teacher

066what what you're moving to pick up the substitute I don't know exactly where another way the same question was is the section are going to stay the same at 19 correct we're FTE yes so I guess as most of us think about teachers you think about a regular fulltime teacher for classroom so I think that might be there's 21 seconds to belong sorry but we're staying the sections are staying the same we're not reducing a section but we're reducing carul next year right now this year we have our last position next inad carry right so it's just the redirection because it's it was it will be a vacancy it's projected to be a vacancy does that mean that one section is always going to be covered at any time by no it just so happened

067to work out that way for this year had so stated another way you're accumulating vcy savings this year and then redeploying that we would have had there not been so many outages for different maternities okay understand so basically the FTE is sitting up here but what's being done with that FTE is the exact same thing as what we're now budgeting in for that makes sense it just be like super blunt yeah people are wondering out home I mean I could have we could have left it up to when we're talking about moving from a regular Ed FTE to the substitute line you're not doing a reduction course of a person that already works here no just Mak sure everybody understands understood and like I said it could have been we talked about whether we leave

068it up top or not right um because the dollar amounts were similar um so it was just a matter of really being transparent about what we're trying to cover because it's it's an issue um you know and it's an issue in all of our schools um so we were being transparent with with yeah you know and and I don't know if you want to say God forbid or or Kudos whatever right if we gain another 30 kids in one area you know then it might shift back up right budget is a player that's right yeah at snapshot in time right okay all right good moving on okay are we projecting only two kindergarten cres next year we're not sure because that's done in August so we're graduating a small class that has them two sixth

069grade if we don't also have a two section kindergarten aren't we reducing the number of sections from what we currently have we are projecting three sections for kindergarten so I'm just so what about this fourth grade only having two when current the third grade has and am I miss what am I missing I'm sorry that I'm going backwards it's probably going to shift based on where the need is for the teacher right based on class sizes now yeah we are we not actually reducing them so you have to think about it different you're thinking about actual hit numbers this is the projected number do the formula J has to say what our survival rate is what we project kids for next year so it changes the numbers a little bit some cohorts are planing to

070gain some stud some to lose so that fluctuation CH and then when we get closer to the actual we have the number of FTE is exactly the same they w those section because we know that there's some so I wouldn't get too stuck on no overall we have the same number of Staff teach the same number students correct okay but the numbers jump right so it's like the one from so your you know your grade one was 44 this year yeah if you look at next year grade two was 43 so it means that that grade one lost a kid yeah and it's based on historical it's not a perfect science right so the 47 in grade three BEC comes to 49 in grade four so that's why Sean you know keep the same sections

071or we can talk about this but the next Slide the next column is really how we might move some around based on the class sizes right and I'm I'm looking at that and that's I think where my yeah we just don't know that's why it's not determined until August we just do a what if to be sure that we're carrying enough bodies because we were tasked with in the budget guidelines in August looking at potential cuts of you know a couple hundred thousand but so far the budget as it stands is pres we have 21 sections and we're budgeting for 21 sections even if they might get classroom section corre okay slide I don't know am that's the hardest thing listen for yeah it gets worse when you get to the high school with sections

072and fdes and oh my God it's I would not want that job okay I don't want that job of figuring out how many f eion need for every you know whatever class um all right so this is off the press as Garett mentioned somebody else oh Michael mentioned we got the December 1st uh commissioner is yeah Commissioners letter Tax Commission letter yes and thanks to Neil who sent it out for me to have thank you because the state hasn't yet and so uh we're showing this is a early Dr projection of both revenues and where the tax rate assessment very early on may may come out on nine however what you're predominantly looking at is the marry and Cross School assessment is as we've discussed the dresin assessment is early um and does not include

073support staff negotiations or service staff negotiations there will be two articles in Dres for both of those Union negotiations I don't have the numbers um I hopefully will have the numbers soon because the dresen Board needs to ratify the support staff and the service staff hasn't been agreed upon yeah but the service staff one is usually pretty small it's probably like a $20,000 item okay uh revenues we're projecting here um two tuition income those and that can be dangerous but if they don't come to fruition by next June we'll adjust that down and change the hestad liability um interest on investments it's still projected to be pretty uh stable through next year by the economists other local is um basically rent earned rent that we get from the building um then vocational Aid I'm projecting

074forward what we have now because nobody has sent out any numbers from the state yet same Transportation Aid um the census block grant is true we did get that from the state so that increase of 134,000 is legitimate the spec Ed extraordinary Aid is uh based on an early projection from the state that can change depending on circumstantial information and data uh essential early end I'm projecting forward because again I have the data from the state and the elll orical Aid will most likely not change that should be a pretty good number of 50,000 um we have no more transfers from construction fund that monies came to us I God I know 22 years ago 20 years ago was invested over 20 years was used to offset the cost that were born in Dresden for

075doing all the um updates to the buildings over there we drew our last 149,000 some dollars last year I think Tesa transfer the last amount of little interest that $48 $48 okay so that got transferred to and that account is closed um from prior year fund balance uh that's a projection anything in Salmon colored means because I don't exactly have perfect numbers um I'm pretty confident that that that is pretty close we are almost done with the Norwich audit and so we should have those numbers I'm hoping we'll have I going to hope for today but yeah they we're waiting on the actuarials in order to close the audit and we don't do the actuary things for the audit so we're waiting on them and then they can close the audit we'll have it for

076the January meeting I'm sure okay anyway let's flip to the next page because that goes with this page you then carry forward the assessments less revenues and fund balance which we just talked about is a just shy of $2 million uh so education spending comes out at 14 milon 621 622 uh or we're up $171,200 um the uh long-term weighted average daily membership is not ratified at this point we're carrying forward what we had last year 8 2889 um I don't know when that number is coming I asked today if they had an idea and I didn't get that I got that I hadn't missed anything but I don't know what the numbers um the next section that you're looking at is excess spending threshold right now we have an exemption from that because we're

077an interstate agreement we're Interstate School District um so I didn't carry any of that forward and then the per pupil figure for calculating tax rate review that we're looking at is $1 17,640 which would be up $27 or 1.18% as representative um the base amount yield is in Salmon because that comes from the commissioner's December 1 letter it is absolutely subject to change last year I think it changed I don't know four times um they didn't set it until June so um hold on and we'll figure out what happens right so you carry that forward the district spending adjustment is there equalized homestead tax less the 21 cent discount which was a 15 cent discount but because there's a ratio that adjust that in order to make us all equal in Vermont it's a complicated

078formula anyway uh that gives us a 21 cent discount again otherwise you can see what the homestead tax would be without the discount uh then we adjust that by the common level of appraisal which is also sub subject to change because we're in the middle of a reval it didn't get finalized last year right now they're projecting our CLA at 62% it's then adjusted by 72% which is the state adjustment which brings us to 86.11% and so you adjust the rate up above of a185 because we're not at 100% And then we get our estimated nominal tax rate with discount of $2 of 15 cents uh per 100 so that's right now based on this year's rate um a reduction of 17.5 cents again don't get too excited too quickly um dresden's budget's not set

079there are two warrant articles that will have a relative bearing on that the ADM is not set the base amount has not been set and the SE has not been s but early indicator is there um sensitivity percentage is 2.88% that is down as well and then the nominal n non-residential tax rate is that actually up two cents projected to be up two cents um so that is the new complicated formula subject to change at the state level so maybe we put a pin in it for a second yeah so the CLA right so last year it was it was 67% and this year it dropped to 62% this is this is not factoring in the new appraisal so obviously it's basically saying our property in nor is way under apprais compared to the average

080in Vermont just so everyone listening understands that is important because it's a Statewide education funding rate that's assuming that everyone is paying the same has the same value of property no matter where you live depending on where it that so that's why you see anyways this year though I I was actually confused because I'm like I thought the 86% was because of our reassessment or reappraisal it's not so the 86 so that means if you're fully appraised you actually get over 100% ideally if you were phrased if your house if everyone house was appraised that the proper value it should be 100% that's why every year we've been going down because we haven't done appraise on to for 10 years but and then once you drop you're supposed to get your C so this year

081they're doing this thing maybe I'll turn over Neil now because basically now the 62% is actually 86% which makes no sense because back for the past 10 years if you had a CA of 86% you're doing pretty well like you're you're a little bit below the averages but it's not critical and certainly not needing a once we get down to this below 70% that's when the bells go off and everyone's like you need to get appraised so I'm actually confused why it's not 85 because it looks like that's actually help a lot overall but of course then you're also dealing with the yield which of course dropped as well the yields lower than last year because the CLA but it was adjusted right so they they've made things slightly more complicated by introducing this concept

082of what's called a Statewide adjustment Statewide adjustment if I'm understanding it correctly looks at the agregate um change in CLA value at the state so the state's Grand list value compared to what um the those properties are value G for the entire State you can consider this figure which I think is 70 it's 72% that's this consider that to be like the state CLA is that because basically the entire state is under assessed because yeah I mean if you look if you combine like all of the properties from all of the towns all across the state aggregated all together and look at the the aggregated value of all of those properties yes the the calculation says that we are undervalued by 20% right so give you a state CLA of 72% you got to be

083really carefully you can't so they're now using that state CLA number to adjust some figures in the traditional formula so that that figure is um being used to manipulate the yield number right so it's getting divided into the yield number so 72% divided into what would have been what is a higher yield number so the real yield number if I'm doing my math right it's like 11,890 something right so a dramatic increase from last year and I would attribute that two things one is we've heard that the revenue coming into the education fund has increased because of an increase in consumption tax revenue so sales and use tax so for Moors they're buying stuff online and all kinds of good stuff they generating more sales tax revenue on the other side of things there has

084been so in order for the tax commissioner to come up with this yield number they surveyed School District all across the mon said hey where are you at with your budgeting right now what do your budgets look like what do you think you're going to be putting forward School District supplied all that information collectively it looks like board members have gotten this message School dist gotten the message let's keep spending down You' got two things going on you've got increased Revenue into the Ed fund and decreased obligation in the form of what we think school budgets are going to be right resulted in a higher yield number almost 11,000 almost $112,000 because of the change in the formula however that number that you saw in the tax commissioner letter was $855 because you take that

085larger yield number and you apply this new Statewide adjustment to it to get this smaller at the end of the day right if we took away this Statewide adjustment and we went with the calculation as it was last year you would end up with the exact same tax R so why they do because now when we get reassessed because I think what they were trying to do was alleviate these wild swings in CLA year to year they tried to smooth things out by coming up with this Statewide adjustment things so Statewide adjustment gets applied to the property yield number it gets applied to our sense discount yeah and it also gets applied to our local CLA if we were to take all that stuff out at the end of the day we'd still end up

086with the exact same tax get the calculated here and so you can't compare this new 86% CLA number with last year's CLA it didn't really go up it went down it went down to 62% or it's forecast to go down to 62% but the application of this adjustment Factor makes it look like it went so if I were I try to imagine um our good towns folks trying to follow along yeah they're watching on Zoom having their Kucha at home they thought I had it I was with it until line 14 um is it fair even very simple to think of it as the common level of appraisal is the relationship of our property values to the market the next percentage is the relationship of everybody's town every Town's relationship to the market right uh

087I think so I um let me say it can I read what the state said I'm not sure that no it might okay so so section 13 of the yield Bill defines Statewide adjustment as the ratio of the aggregate education property tax brand list of all municipalities to the aggregate value of the equalized education property tax brand list of all municipalities right so so that that saay right State adjustment that they're putting through on all three of those pieces are to try to bring about some type of Equalization through the property values that are all they skewed all over the place right now because some have been adjusted by um reevaluations and some have right but I think to answer Michael's question right the way that I interpr that 86% is that is our CLA

088in comparison to the state level CLA and so that's why you can't take last year's you know 67 compared to this year's 86 because they're they're two different calulations and they represent change to Garrett's question there are some towns that are over 100 they're 116 112 they're because if we were if we were 62 now we get reappraised the say go back to 100 then you put the 70% thing on be 125 which is what some of these are unless they put a cap in is you lots of public policy debates in decision there's the way it is and different things and so for me one of the things I just think about is hey the way it is is currently given where we're at in the budget process the change is in up of

089about 1.18% which to me see everything I see on slide N9 and 10 says that we're being very responsible so far as the school board when it comes to the budget the way it feels I can't control what state policy makers do once they come back together and month whether they make decisions that might cost nor residents money and then with the c when the grand list gets reassessed everybody's relationship to their tax bill is going to change based on the reassessment of their house and then the relationship of the value of their home to everybody else's and that's going to scramble things in ways that might make some people feel good it might make some people feel really bad and going to take our overall tax rate and drop it because the rate goes

090down as the values go up even though you still pay your money and so I just try to stay pretty focused on hey here's the increase in actual spending in the aggregate or on basis that's what we can control that's something is really far out our control as I will note the number in 15b I'm sorry I'm looking at it's Notre um and we're no longer subject to the threshold right at this point in time yeah we um Jamie inquired with the state um and the AOE had responded back that because of our status as an interstate School District we are not subject to spending I have it inting otherwise that okay so right so I think I mean um I would you know I do think there's a little there's a kind little bit

091of a good story here and and that is that we are at this moment in time looking at a reduction in the tax rates from last year I've Bo now for how many years i' never me say something positive then then allow me to follow that up bring last year's increase was 16% we can't forget um I I I think that I probably you know you know maybe I would have quit if we were looking at another increase on top of that this year like um but yeah you know uh when I do think to that point we have to also keep in mind that we are also benefiting from both lower Dresden budgets BS or even our other budgets just because we have let all of the capital spending and The Debt Service go

092away that at some point we need to come back online right I me you just retire all the debt for the middle school and the high school for those 20 year things so that's why we're kind of getting very low increases as well at some point we will be to start spending unless we just kind of everything crumbled right right and sorry but the and the other point that I want to make sure that we that voters understand right is the one of the Prime reasons why we're getting this decrease in the tax rate from last year is this Cent discount that we've been afforded because we got wallet by the team to student weights right that discount is going away so relief that we're seeing here is because of that primarily um and that

093ain't going to be with us forever I want to update that part of the SL 15b I know I'm sorry I'm looking at it here I know 15b that carry didn't carry a cost that's the difference between 260 and 239 is not 7 I mean you know to in the budget I guess I been I apologize I missed the last meeting but I think the Neil's Point here I think that what we can control Michael said too is our spending and I think given all the uncertainty the best we can do is continue to you know really try to stay to the squat budget and thank Sean for and everybody for just kind of keeping things the lid on things now and then frankly is this that the percent discount comes off over the next

094couple of years I think in order to kind of right size things without actually cutting people right is at least if we keep things which is also hard to do right because everything's going up in price right contracts going up prices are going up still so it's not I always say a flat budget is actually a down right healthare goes up all night you can't just some point people cut happen so I think this is been a pretty good budget process I just I would agree with that though one of my takeaways from this budget presentation is that the price T will go up because we have four actual negotiations right right now right so this for base those four negotiations will lead to base increases that will carry with over time and the discount

095is temporary right there's there's incom pressure on sorry headwind otherwise known as a headwind yes any other comments well and my shouldn't say final but to go along with that right one of my worries well things look better than I anticipated at this stage There's an opportunity here that we could chew up this entire decrease with a couple of negotiated settlements here some stuff on the other side of the river um and then suddenly we're not stand front of Voters saying your taxes went down saying so I just I think we've done a great good job to this point I think but the work's not done yet to the public yes I'm curious what the impact on the budget is with increases or decreases in tuition students um I was mentioned there was some like

096two students coming in and I asked that in part because word on certain streets is that there are other school systems that are talking about significant cuts to the programming that they're offering and parents are asking about tuition in to Maran cross so is is that something that is a revenue source that we can explore can we advocate for that is that a conflict of some kind of public school interest to be like hey over here you're still great come um I'm just I don't know what that that scene is and I would love to have a better understanding of what the tuition in looks like in terms of what it does to our bu and out Jamie answer I think you know the line is the tuition income is going up by 20 grand

097so but I will but then to your overall question keep me honest here everyone but I think I know Julie of the high school they actually go to a day where you're kind of selling your school at these things and yes it's a little bit of a fine line between outright just capitalism saying comes to our school versus keeping L on but I think there is at least for an Administration listening to the work that we've done over the past few years the goal is you get more tuition students to come to hand over RMS MCS like abolutely I don't think there's the more the better right because we can keep more kids here so revenue is your friend right in most instances um you know there are times when Revenue income from tuition may

098not be your friend but uh you know you don't really you don't you don't look at those directly right off but um you you can you want to be able to take as many students as you can fit without triggering having to do another section right because you know just as an average cost to put on another certified teaching section is probably at the minimum 80,000 upwards to 120 right depending on where the teacher hits on the scale level of health benefit right so so where you have capacity within your class sizes absolutely I think um Sans any you know additional special education or any other type of cost that might go along with the kid um you know that can absolutely help offset uh your rate because it lowers your assessment burden right that

099dollar amount of any Revenue that in lowers the assessment amount you have toties so so I'll tell you what at most high schools in New Hampshire anyway it is absolutely a tuition Revenue gain especially as schools over there are declining population just to add that so yeah revenue is good um the if we're focusing so there's a couple things there like there's the income that we could possibly get by having kids tuition to the high school you know nor will'll see a portion of that but we don't get all of that money we're talking specifically though about tuition and kids in the Maran cross a little bit of a different story and there's a couple of issues there that make a bit difficult for marry and cross to see I think any substantial income in

100that um number one is we are the second we have the second highest per people spending in the state which means that our tuition rate is going to be above uh except for that one other school which is just to north of us actually every other school is going to have a lower tuition rate than we are for tuition purposes the second thing is for those districts where those families might be feeling like they want to make a choice to send their kids somewhere because they're local public school has had to go into some Cuts in order to get a budget to pass those families would have to fund that tuition revenue on their own the tax dollars don't come with that kid so they'd be they'd be pulling up they'd still be paying taxes

101in their Hometown but they'd be funding that tuition completely out of their own Pockets to have that student come and so those two things I think are probably unlikely to to net us a lot but I would love to be surprised every little bit on slide four quickly I just want to the section so it looks like we'll probably go with the sections on the right far this we wouldn't know until August that's kind of the plan right now and I guess the question there is is obviously you know our policy it kind of says for K through three of 14 to 22 16 18 and 17's off all right and then so it does look like grade one is pretty small even if if you took that to two sections you'd get a 17

102to 18 17 in one section 18 are we kind of just is that just a sure yeah absolutely so yeah so it sounds like okay it's just an exercise next it's GNA present just because I know from a budget pers we get a lot of times people that talk about how small class you know you get something like 11 12 kids per class well that's why there's three different I mean there's two different um projections it probably makes sense here change okay anyway sure just the next one two SE next you want you tell me the what if scenario you'd like and all okay so grade three would still be 13 and 14 still be really small you right on the cere probably unfortunately where it's like grade three would be 21 one section of

10321 to 21 and then it comes down to you makeing make right who's in that class and what the teachers like right okay but so it sounds like we do have a little bit of like flexibility here in this and then we actually have a little bit of conservatism in the numbers with regards to we're not on the cuser of any one class blowing up too big and we're not going to be C short all of a sudden somebody's going to be way too big it sounds like you kind of move somebody we to do that was kind of where my question was it sounds like there's conservatism to this as far as the sections vers okay can I go slide 11 now just because I know I'm gonna have to get up at 5

104tomorrow morning and snow calls call now no I can't and I want to show this picture look at that beautiful picture of that amazing xylophone in all its Glory of color okay so this is just to wrap it up and you guys have had great conversation tonight I think it's been wonderful with everybody um you know the what if budget reduction scenarios we talked about we we've I think we have talked that through to the Sun um we also talked about expanded pre- opportunities we talked about that early on uh we really have spit some space constraints here in order to take a look at that and that absolutely would also add to the budget in the bottom line so we kind of pull back a little bit from that um we also went through

105the budgeting process and talked about some strategic plan initiatives the asterisk on the sau70 increase comes into play because we're looking at the uh getting a CIP done Cal Improvement plan with cost out done and it's via the sa70 assessment um that includes Mary and cross in it so some of that increase that Maran cross is seeing there is twofold uh it's because of that CIP plan from the Strategic plan in there and also because of a um a surplus carryover has dried out prior years um the other piece that was discussed at all all the tables of the schools uh budget committees in the district was a potential District social worker um in conversation with all of the different um uh budget committees we have placed that on hold for this upcoming year um

106although I will say that each one of the different principles at all of our S70 um school districts do have some ideas um and some alternative uh thoughts in place to deal anything um and then I just wanted to share some pictures of things the outdoor classrooms that they're using here on in the environmental programs and the kids you can see playing with they're learning about it looks like a black cricket and some kind of uh some kind of I don't know what is seed pods maybe and then uh I loved it today as I was putting this together because as they mentioned we just got the other information on Monday late on Monday afternoon um I asked Karen Wright to send me some of the pictures because I wasn't able to be here and

107they're amazing I I want to put some more on everything of the kids playing on the playground and there's movies and it's just they're having a blast they're having an absolute blast I love seeing that because I'll have to tell you out of all the projects yes that one gave me more gray hair than any including the so um um I'm glad it's open and in place we do have a couple other things that we're still working on for back there and the the one other project that got fully funded by Grant is um well underway with the um what she call it she has a great name for no compost Palace yes the compost Palace which we got approve Thea town and they actually board I think they prepped the base and for the

108concrete and the structure should be going up within the next week or two yeah it's exciting yeah we got more Forks today because the elf delivered them last night I don't know what time it pass we left here s okay so that is it for us today I'll get those I'm gonna take a twom minute when you move forward and I'll repost the right exhibit and repop the right uh FTE in this and post it right back up so if anybody wants to go take a 10 minute go back in and work it'll be there takes two seconds okay apologies again all right other questions I love the play all right hand it back over to you jar thank you for all the work on that it's a team effort with all of us um

109for [Music] given our discussion oh yes there I I don't know that you need to discuss them other than just take a quick look there's nothing out of the ordinary just as the point of order the select board has not yet set the day and time of the deliberative session oh okay good to know I recommended they take it up next week and I don't know if they will follow my Rec I think I did put draft on that right okay okay good Monday no I I will not I will uh double check with them and I know that um Miranda's been in uh in contact with Ryan so sorry I just had one question on the war article I thought Shar got a little bonus in salary no okay thank you I just was

110confused I wanted to make sure Garett got it if he was supposed to because it wasle okay uh onward okay so just started I think you and I we've been doing it for a while because I think not enough people were here last time to properly assign so you didn't want to Vol and I haven't done it in a while I'm happy to take my ship I can do it again I like that and I don't know what I honestly don't recall what you're approv you're approving nor obviously are you doing dress in too is it time to switch that yeah so it's norin I won't open my mouth too loud Keep voice for a while nobody wants to do okay and so that's starting now it will be uh with next week this week

111should be done okay uh reading the policies we've got the second reading of all of these policies listed and the third reading of our district ining non-resident student policy I apologize I missed our last meeting um I know that the obviously the upper policies all these are been discussed extensively at all of the other board meetings do we have any comments on these because I believe we we are going to be must we have more changes we're going to be improving all of these policies the second and third reading so why don't we start with the second reading policies does anybody have any comments or questions or things that changed on those polies District want and then um probably the most important policies our district employee student policy which is giving uh teachers the ability

112to they are out of District to have their kids come here um I know we went through a third reading and I know Jay's I don't think here tonight has been very helpful drafting that policy is there anything on there that is still outstanding or people I'm not sure if you guys discussed this discuss this at the last meeting I I so I'm not sure what changed between the previous reading and this reading but um one thing that I think we need to discuss is that in the one two three four paragraph it says non-resident student may continue to enroll in district schools until grade six and I know that we have been discussing the possibility of potentially moving grade six over to Handover at some point so we may want to consider boarding that

113just says until graduation from Mari and cross or something along those lines so maybe we can have it makes sense pretty easy modification you want to just adopt this as amended Maybe I'm still sorry yeah I'm still a little bit uncomfortable in how the superintendent would make a determination as to which children would get to join school if they had more then would be able to be absorbed in a given year right if you had four kids and you only had three possible seats I understand that the superintendent discretion but I I'm not sure that the Optics of accepting three children and rejecting a four without any real reason are great and I wonder if we can do it based on teacher seniority or something else but I feel May to be a little more

114out kind of first Ser well with all the applications are due by a certain date so I guess if you were a late hire then that's understandable but if these are all along teachers I I thought Jay was going to do a criteria similar to what we do for the pre um I mean it was my understanding that we requested that to get him out of the situation of having to make that awkward decision um and that we had requested criteria similar to what we have for prek but there is some sort of process procedure poliy improve policy understand do I mean I think it's important just going on record that we do need to be able to limit this and make call we are going above and beyond offering this and then all of

115a sudden something happens and it means like Jamie was just saying that we H that one person that would do section that's like okay I still I'm still uncomfortable with the fact that we reevaluate this every year but the children who are already in will stay until the end but also their siblings can then attend so if we let in a pre- child and that then has seven more children we're still going to be on the hook for this for the next you know 25 years right and I'm not sure that I would agree to allow siblings in automatically or I would allow siblings in if the policy has been discontinued we pull this one that was our position last time yeah my ears are it's going to get done we will get something here

116I think it's just a matter most the next school year so have time can I qualify this also by saying I realize these are nitpicky things and in reality we're never going to have a teacher that joins in PRK and then you know has eight children later and all that but these are things that I worry about when putting in this sort of blanket policy that may affect the school of bir I would say not I second last paragraph furthermore should this policy be discontinued siblings of non-residential students admitted under this policy will be considered for consent 10 District schol it feels less like aing yeah I wonder but um I mean I will admit right I I there is a there's a need for this and I think there's a benefit to Maran cross

117for this but I do share some of my colleages concerns like I I can I can foresee a future with a board that doesn't have me on it and they're going it's they're going to have a really sticky situation deal with and I'm trying not to put that on that future board and yeah and so gett I like I don't think it needs to fall all on you like I I I wonder if there ought to be just like a maybe a you know enhanced policy committee meeting but almost in the full board um just to try to talk through some of these things and see if we can figure out a path forward for some of stuff but not just one more thing sorry you need a period after the underlying fit at the

118bottom least of our concy I like I like the easy fix um just one question though for like I guess for Robin and probably the two of you when does this policy need to be in place to help with recruiting and hiring like by the January meeting by the March you know March I would say feu VES start coming up I just want to make sure that we're we're adhering to that timeline because if we're doing this to be helpful we should make sure that we're doing it to be helpful even if we do a Zo me person in today happy to zoom in and actually spend time talking about this right uh I don't have a revised Statute in my head I think the I think committees that are cly advisory to the board

119can do mostly remote I I would just add one more comment that um couple exp there is no policy that is perfect that is suceptible to difficult hypothetical um I sometimes a little scar my 20 years working in leg bodies where people use process instead of just saying I really don't want to do this to intad anybody really just doesn't want to do this let's have that conversation as opposed to try to here so I'm having work on it if there are hey I want to get to yes but I just have a couple objections I feel someone's I just don't want do this sticky us well maybe just gave I mean I think everyone wants to do this right so I don't think that I think it's more just making sure that you know

120there is some flexibility built into it um and that we're not also you know putting the superintendent bad position where like want that you have three or four people and how do you like have we not given the tools to make those decisions without having a major being in a bad position does occasionally seem to be part of the job right or future okay um so with that being said what we'll do is we will um remove let's see so we will we'll just remove the we're not sorry G is that policy is this G g g j f a so we're going to remove those two right yeah somebody would do that reming you can just okay uh all right moving on the donation from the Vermont Academy of Science and Engineering um so

121Tech $1,400 grant for engineering project that will give us some supplies next one next one is a very generous $762 for foring any questions or comments on those two donations thank you very much for those um all right moving on to action I think here we can have a motion I'm going to do it this way move to approve items b c d f and g by consent then I'll make another motion after that second on that one second it all right all those in favor already unanimous on that one do we have a another motion yes move to approve policies da a BB AA BB a d G A IG IG g a r IG g a e and i g d as presented that all those in favor that is allify for the

122folks that own that just pulled the one about nonresident student tuition fut permission to make one comment um the Vermont Community Foundation I think it's it's important to know that that's from the milk Pride fund um because we didn't talk about that and since he's a former principal and lives in town um it just feels important to recognize that Carolina and mil were behind that donation okay all right um I report the chair keep it um simple again just thank you all for all help on the budgets Mak great progress hopefully everyone has a great holiday I am Saturday report this is our first year 10 years where we will not be attending any MCS holiday concert a little different your kids there um so that's G to be a un offended on of the

123chorus it's beautiful try and find this will be our first year will not be attending that um and any I think uh we are going to be L let us know too it's okay I we will be looking for a new board member come next here as well so come March so if anyone has suggestions uh for your board member Lily understand ising on all of things have time for this as well but anyway we really thank L for all of her help over the years and advice and support and obviously important to working with you for the rest of your term here but just so everyone knows we will be looking for somebody to be running in March so has suggestions or wants to at least get the word out um applications are welcome

124and I'm happy to talk to anybody petitions are in my office petitions are in the office and when are they due January 27th and cler is a sticker so and happy to talk with anybody might be interested in put it inails and what we be um okay on that we have the principles report give you the highlights enrollment is 324 students you can see the current sections and of students there the palion should have updated picture because today to build want goell uh and then exciting for us we ranked the US News and World Report as the number one Elementary School in the second time noted that gradu to the r school schol did you as last time together information about nonresidential sta cles and I want tol tomorrow we are just delay okay good

125and not on here but I did want to note I can send board members the AOE as a result listening learning scuc one of the things we get together is series of 30 minute sessions the consultant that the state hired about best practices in St and I attended the one this week best practic in Elementary School St classroom they have a section that I'll also attend about best practices for special teachers for interventionists for coaches they all sessions but it was it was informative and I think it kind of could for one or two because it's shaping the direction that I think the AE is trying to us towards for last they had some interesting ideas of how to how to navigate Waters between sta used to teach 16 willing to take on a lar

126SI some interesting ideas so I'll continue to go to those but just those a meetings anyone I invited our staff inv thank you Sean for that I forgot to mention my report I could see that ranking which is great thank you for meeing that um all right any other questions for Sean just remind me again what rank did R School get what we get thank so calling question if you had to put this an Olympic term what medal are all right Robin um just a few things we received a $155,000 grant from bfit to improve the staff Lounge area and a lot of work was done on that this summer and we finished spending the money recently and we're we were able to put a couch and chair up there as well as just Place

127much more comfortable and invied for the staff so I think that's been a really positive change with the um School this year and we've been continuing with our curriculum work we had our last second grade release day yesterday and we're finalizing our first real unit plans long story line for our science unit so that's been exciting and um um continuing with our work with the English committee which has been great surpris we have over 22 people who volunteered their time in all almost all of our great level St VI special education chillian our library media Specialists so it's a wide variety of people I feel like we're making great progress there we're starting to look at the Knitting Gres of what our literacy loction look like what resource and materials we might need so we're

128making a lot of progress with that as well and that again has been all volunteer effort um and continuing to document curriculum and I've been sending drafts back to individual teachers regarding publishing the documents so that's been good but it's continuing to go through various itations so lot right now Jamie do you want to say anything else Jamie said um any other committee reports I can just say negotiations continue with both teachers and support I know there not really relevant to norch but kind of relevant in norch I know I've been going to a number of the Dr athletic call Middle School sports right so been being done on a weekly basis and we do think about what might be coming down the pike from slight increases in budgets um over address and that might

129be one of the things because that's going to be potentially be added as a warrant article which you give the town's people as I I kind of I think the way would roll out the ability to um for keep research but the ability to vote on it but the B Be work in such a way that Bic become a permanent ongoing thing not just a not just all a sudden have to people every year article um but it would be moving into at least having some initial programing over the middle school or Sports sorry Sports nor residence as your kids move through uh the ref will still stay the same through six for both towns and then for seven eight would be M school one again out of Theon work being done on that um

130okay executive session do we need to enter into exective session or based on what's being read here discuss ex okay why move executive you can probably sorry we discusss out here or is there probably we teer has to extend that all weeks due to return back January okay sounds good there's no voting to make a motion want to make a motion um do I do I name the teacher um I'm sorry it's sorry yes approve to yes than um I would move to approve ktie to extend her maternity leave and return on February 5th 2025 seconds all those in favor that is also unanimous okay um agendas for next meeting [Music] thank you all I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.