CorpusRecord 5581

February 20th, 2025 Governing Board Regular Meeting & Executive Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PVSchools
Date
2025-02-21
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,327 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e hey all it's 6:30 and I would like to call the meeting to order if you are not in a seat and you'd like to sit we've got some space thank you let me go through that again it is 6:30 and I am calling the meeting to order and I'd ask that you please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance Al to of United States of America to stand indivisible thank you may I have roll call please Mrs Christensen here Mr panta here Mrs Greenberg here Dr Lim here miss wanie here thank you next on the agenda is approval of agenda Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg governing board cabinet and all of our guests this evening items approved by consent will not come up for discussion during the meeting but

002will be approved when the agenda is adopted this is possible since members of the governing board receive the agenda along with backup materials at least 24 hours prior to the meeting and have had time to review and consider all items prior to the agenda being adopted members of the governing board may ask that an item be removed from the consent agenda and brought to the floor for discussion at the appropriate place on on the agenda any member of the audience who submitted a blue public comment card prior to the start of the meeting will be recognized to speak on that agenda item under items for approval I would like to offer the agenda as posted thank you prior to the meeting we received one blue public comment card and each speaker will have three minutes

003to remark on a specific agenda item will be recognized to speak under items for approval as a reminder we ask that you please direct your comments to the board does any member of the governor board wish to have an item removed from the consent agenda Mrs Christensen item F6 F6 so that will move to the end of items for approval after gifts and donations does anybody else wish to move remove anything from the consent agenda seeing none Mr panta may have motion to approve the meeting agenda and recommended consent agenda items so moved all those in favor please say I I all those opposed say nay any abstentions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is governing board statements Miss wanie do you have any uh yeah I just want to um kind of give

004a a quick shout out to Campo Bellow who so kindly um invited me to come and and hang out with them for a little bit today and had an opportunity to see those smart panels um those Smart Boards I'm probably using the wrong name um but they were on our agenda last last governing board meeting and so I was really excited to be able to kind of see them in live action in one of the structured autism classes I was very impressed it was incredible um watching the students interact um and engage and had so many different opportunities to do so so it was really nice to kind of take something that you know is you know on our on our agenda that we had some robust discussion and conversation about and then have an

005opportunity to really see how it's being used um you know every day on our campus so I just thank you so much for that invitation and I really appreciate it thank you Miss monnie Mrs Christensen do you have anything yes I just want to send um a message to the community of Indian Bend dear parents of Indian Bend Elementary we appreciate you trusting us with educating your children if any of your children are experiencing illnesses such as headaches nausea or respiratory concerns please contact the school or district offices um [Music] Lo the Indian Ben orator aicina this Laina this um um I really appreciate all the people coming today and um I just want to send that message out to those in at Indian bent Elementary uh Dr Lim all right thank you I'm gonna

006free flow a little bit because um as you will hear why um I just want to take a moment to highlight the pvusd community giving back and then getting to highlight the uh public Community giving back to PV so um as my board fellow board members know and much of the community may know my youngest daughter went in for open heart surgery just last week um it was something we knew that was coming she's had a heart condition for a very long time I really appreciated the community at our little cubs uh program at James P Lee for really helping prepare her for her upcoming surgery and getting to advocate for herself in the classroom but more than anything help helping her peers understand what was about to happen to her and why she was

007suddenly going to be gone for eight weeks from the classroom and so it was really great to see Miss Michelle and Miss Miley who leads the program over there come together around my daughter in her class and really support them as they stepped into this process which is a really big ask for three and four year olds so thank you to them and thank you for the amazing community that has supported her through that and you'll all be happy to hear she's doing really well though still at the Children's hospital she's recovering really well can't wait to get back to see her peers but then I want to highlight the community giving back because even though I've been going through all this I still had time to join the district fair for our high school

008learners and take part at PB high school and it was really amazing to walk in and see so many stem professionals giving up part of their weekend to come judge these science fair projects it takes a lot of our time to be stem professionals and often we work on the weekends as we do on the weekdays so to give up your weekend and come here these science fair projects was amazing I heard every everything from an app that would help high school basketball players uh track their um game uh points in different Fashions to a really amazing project that wanted to convert methane into energy so really Stellar projects these students were competing to go on to the state level and it was a really great opportunity to see our community come together and judge

009these students as many of them prepare to go to the state level so thank you to the PV Community both those external to the community and those within the community it's an amazing place to be and an amazing Community to be a part of so thank you Mr panta thank you hello everyone uh well I went to a dance at Eagle Ridge okay I was a chaperone if you will very interest interesting to me how they do dances at the elementary level um oh and uh yeah it's pretty interesting yeah my um my granddaughter made a play date or her mother did um and big deal but it got me to thinking of all things of the walls and ladmo show I don't anyone familiar with that show no oh good some people that was

010a a kid show that was here in the valley what since 1954 to 1986 or something like that I grew up on that stuff and one of the characters there was a character by uh called Gerald Pat McMahon right he played that Gerald well you don't know so uh but he was there all the time and he was built as the private school brat okay that that was his his character he looked down on all these public school kids and well me and my friends were all public school kids so he was not a he was like the villain of the show what does it have to do with my daughter well my granddaughter well because I used to have this kind of maybe a negative opinion about private school kids until I actually met

011somebody who went to a private school uh when I was at Saro high school we did a lot of coral things with competitions and I met some students at from broy and we're talking about schools these guys aren't brats at all okay they're nice nice people but one of the logistic things that they always talked about was like prom nights or any big thing they had to do you know you you live in East Mesa your your date lives in West Glendale and you got some buddies in North Scottsdale you had to coordinate this all the time and it made it very difficult I thought well it's like my granddaughter she you know she's going to a Sandpiper right but lives by Boulder Creek her friend lives by Shadow Mountain they had to do all

012the calling and longistics and as much as I like you know School choice I do like it but it gets really tough uh me and my buddies when we're growing up you know if it's baseball season we're all playing baseball basketball We're Playing Basketball we the logistics we had to do is ask M can we go out and play because all the kids in the neighborhood we want to hang with were there uh that's the coolest thing about public schools if you can go to the one in your neighborhood is because you meet other kids you meet other families those families have barbecues together they do things together they go to the same Boy Scout clubs and same Little League teams those kind of things the public school becomes a hub the glue that holds

013that neighborhood together keep that Community together uh I do miss that and I don't know a solution to it because we do need to have school choice it's an important thing but nowadays you got to reach out and find out how is my granddaughter going to find out who the kids in the neighborhood are well maybe I got to take her to Boulder Creeks events that the PTSA puts on which they're having a glow party uh the end of this month so so make sure be there be there be square so that's something I wanted to talk about a little bit thank you oh and I'm going to be at Indian Ben doing their uh read Across America if you want to hear the riveting story of King big good in the bathtub you just

014drop on by and I'll read to you too all right that concludes my comments thank you Mr panta um I want to welcome everybody who's here rather Full House uh thank you for for joining us um earlier this week we had a study session on a couple topics and I want to thank um all of our staff for the hard work but particularly Mrs Baran and Dr Davis for all of the information and uh conversation we're able to have and earlier today I joined in um a meeting it was actually an evaluation session for our IB program at North Canyon High School um I think I was there because we had to have a board member there I don't think I contributed a lot but but I really want to give a shout out to

015Dr Corson and miss copen and um principal uh uh Katie ler I'm sorry I've had no sleep and I just went like that um to to um all three of them for the information and the insights they provided it was I've known about the IB program a long time um before I was ever on the board and um it's just fascinating to hear behind the scenes pieces and the curricular pieces and where it all fits in in terms of the district so I just want to thank everybody for the information it was great and with that that concludes governing board statements and next on the agenda is Awards and recognitions thank you president Greenberg governing board cabinet and guests at this time I would like to invite the governing board to join me in front

016of the Das good evening president Greenberg governing board members members of cabinet and attendees both in person and virtual tonight we have two recognitions to share with you this evening we'll be inviting our honores to the front of the room for their recognition and group photo uh so when I call your name or your school please make your way to the front of the room our first honores tonight were invited to be a part of the prestigious 2025 Arizona music Education Association Elementary School and Junior High All State Orchestra and one of these recipients was invited to be part of the Allstate band the AA has been promoting excellence in music education since 1939 because we have so many recipients will ask the students come up when I call your school's name Copper Canyon Desert

017Cove desert Trails fire side greyhawk North Ranch Pinnacle Peak prep Quail Run Sky Crossing Sonoran Sky Wildfire Desert Shadows Middle School Mountain Trail Middle School and Sunrise Middle School please give a round of applause to all of these musicians for this incredible accomplishment parents are more than welcome to take photos e I think we just saw a lot of the parents stand up but if there are parents family members tonight we'd like to also honor 11 individuals who have maintained or newly achieved their national board certified teacher status nbct is considered the Pinnacle of recognition in education and represents an Educators diligence dedication and skill this incredible accomplishment is not just a personal mile stone for these teachers but also a driving force for ongoing Improvement in PV schools please put your hands together for

018from sonor and Sky Elementary School Rachel Wyatt from Desert Trails Elementary School Misty hoit from Echo Mountain intermediate Sarah Duval also from Echo Mountain intermediate Jenna selski from North Canyon High School Cara Diller from Copper Canyon Elementary School Anita Militello from Pinnacle High School P patience sharp from Desert Shadows Elementary School Brian Cunningham who's unable to be here from the from the Paradise Valley High School Margo Merc from within our information technology department Hannah carahan and from North Canyon High School Katie Hansen we of my mom hang on Mom one more thank you and that Pres pres Greenberg concludes this evening's Awards and recognitions spe thank you all there is plenty of seats if anybody in the back wants to sit so next on the agenda is superintendent comments Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg

019governing board cabinet and guests I'd like to start this evening uh celebrating a birthday we're not going to sing but there's nothing better on your birthday than attending a governing board meeting I'm blessed to be here thank you so happy birthday Mr drogie in PV schools we engage Inspire and nurture students through high quality instruction meaningful educational opportunities and dynamic learning experiences is one of those Dynamic experiences in our district steam is our district steam initiative BV schools is the Hub of creative of creativity and learning and through our steam opportunities we cultivate a passion for lifelong learning by connecting science technology engineering arts and math and engaging in meaningful ways one of the ways we engage our students and families is through the sights and sounds of stee posium night this year we are

020putting a new Twist on our two prominent District events attendees can enjoy Ensemble performances student artwork science and engineering Pro projects and awards ceremony a business and industry Expo Community Partnership booths and so much more join us at Shadow Mountain high school on March 1st to celebrate our spring steam event for more information please visit PB schools.net next week is National Public Schools week join PB schools and celebrate all the amazing things that happen each and every day around our schools and across the district this week designed to highlight the teachers staff students and parents who have chosen public education positive things happen in Public School classrooms each day because of the caring professionals committed to serving students public education prepares students to succeed in an everchanging world the district knows families have a choice

021when it comes to their child's education and we are grateful to every family who has made PB schools their first choice and education calling all PV schools community members help make prom Dreams Come True by donating your gently used formal gowns prom dresses suits tuxedos jewelry and accessories to the annual pvea prom boutique beginning in March our high school students will have several opportunities to shop from prom apparel and accessories at no cost to them but in order to make thisen happen we need your donations in addition to clothing items pbea is accepting donations through their Amazon wish list which can be found on the QR code up on the screen as well as gift cards that will be raffled off donations can be dropped off Monday through Friday at the district office and tonight

022we have a special event uh I am proud to highlight a point of pride in Paradise our Career and Technical education program bring industry into the classroom giving students a firsthand look at what highly desirable careers might look like to walk us through a more in-depth presentation I'd like to invite our Career and Technical education director Melissa molzan to the podium thank you Dr Reynolds good evening president Greenberg governing board Dr Reynolds and cabinet thank you so much for this opportunity to present tonight in celebration of CTE month um our Horizon High School students are very excited to present and share their experience in the marketing program and uh their accomplishments within Deca through those opportunities they've developed valuable um expertise in marketing uh marketing leadership and teamwork skills that are preparing them for real

023world business challenges and their post-secondary pathway through these stories we hope that it highlights the impact of CTE education and demonstrates the importance of programs like ours in shaping Future Leaders please join me in welcoming Colton wedi lmia pamic sheras Aurora Bella ra and their amazing teacher Suzanne marisola thank you once again uh so much for having us here and allowing us to speak um with me to my right is our vice or our VPS of Finance uh through Deca shus Aurora and Bella Ral and to my left is our VP of community service lamia and my name is Colton wedy I'm the VP of deca at Horizon High School and we just wanted to thank the board for their continuous support of CTE programs and deca as a whole um it provides many opportunities

024for kids like me like lamia like B and like shes to um further their business skills for Life Beyond High School such as college and the workplace um the marketing classes that are offered at our school also create an environment for us to learn all sorts of skills that are crucial crucial in life um that go beyond just the high school learning and go and serious life skills that are very important good evening um I'd like to say again my name is lamia pamic I'm the vice president of community service um we'd like to first start off that we are so proud to announce that this year we will be receiving Diamond level status for the second year in a row um we are also we have also thank you we have also received gold

025status uh for our chapter as well as well as gold status for our school store uh which is uh deca's highest honors um also um we would just like to thank you for your continued support through everything we wouldn't have been able to do this without um the CTE program and deca in general we are so proud of our accomplishments and we cannot wait to see where it's going to take us in our future endeavors and we just like you thank you again so much for having us here to talk to you guys thank you thank you congratulations on diamond status um next on the agenda are items for approval excuse me the first item is acceptance of the 2024 audit reports issued on December 11th 2024 for the 2023 24 fiscal year Mrs Baran

026thank you president Greenberg Dr Reynolds and governing board members uh this is the culmination of uh one of my favorite things to present on to the governing board we have staff that work incredibly hard throughout the fiscal year planning and preparing the fiscal year prior closing out the fiscal year after it's really ultimately more than a Year's worth of work and uh many many people who work incredibly hard on this so I need that large on my screen please it's very tiny right now I can't see it there we go okay so the objective for the presentation is to review the purpose scope and results of the annual Financial audit and we will review the requirements of our audit the process that we go through the reports that are issued as well as the final

027results of the audit this is a quick glimpse of frankly only some of the dates that we uh experience throughout our budget year um the fiscal year begins July 1st it ends June 30th but as I've mentioned there's planning before that year starts that we're even talking about um in November December of the Year prior we have an encumbrance period that goes through August 30th each year and then we're experiencing the actual audit process after that as well and then uh reports issued as mentioned previously for audit requirements reev Arizona revised Statute 15914 requires school districts with M budgets in excess of $2 million to have a completion of the usfr the uniform system of financial records compliance questionnaire and so we undergo that 170 some questions in addition to that if we have more

028than $750,000 in federal revenues we undergo a federal single audit so there's really two components in regard to that for our audit uh in as a reminder in the spring of 2021 the legislature passed that the governing boards must publicly take a roll call vote and so uh Miss chisman will take you all through a roll call vote at the end of the presentation and then finally for requirements we upload these files to the Arizona Department of Education public website as well as provide a copy of it to the county superintendent's office with the process for audit with our external Auditors We Begin by proc procuring their um uh Services through a competitive proposal process and the fiscal year 24 audit was the third year of that contract uh after the uh audit year begins

029they ask us to send the financial data and they we send them that general ledger which is a transaction and accounting of every single um financial transaction that occurs within the district the Auditors then send their fieldwork request based off of what they see in the general ledger and they ask for samples of various types of uh pieces of financial transactions within the district we prepare that documentation send that to the Auditors ahead of time and then they come here uh they used to come here for a week in the late summer and then a week again in the fall time frame but over the last few years we've gotten them to come just two to three days uh in the end of the summer time frame and then just another two to three days

030usually in the fall time frame and that's due to our staff being prepared ahead of time with all of the documentation uh to make things run more smoothly for our Auditors uh the Auditors then complete their fieldwork and then that process sort of repeats again in terms of additional fieldwork requests sent to us a little bit more documentation on some things sent to the auditor and then they come back out again in the fall time frame as mentioned the audit reports we issue there are a few of them we do a communication to governance that you've seen the annual comprehensive financial report which is the big 140 some page report that you've also seen the single audit reporting package that as a reminder is the requirement because we received more than the $750,000 limit from

031federal funds and then the uniform system of financial records compliance questionnaire that the Arizona auditor general uh prepares for us in the communication to governance letter it was identified that there were no difficulties encountered in the performance of the audit no disagreements with management that the management has provided all of the required representations and then heinfeld and Mech who as our our external Auditors complied with their independence audit requirements with the annual comprehensive financial report we have an unmodified or what is more commonly known as a clean opinion the best opinion that you can get uh in the independent Auditors report and some of the components of the annual comprehensive financial report include the Management's discussion and Analysis the government-wide financial statements the fund financial statements uh important notes to those financial statements in a

032statistical section with the single audit reporting package uh it was noted that we performed in accordance with government auditing standards and we had no significant deficiencies or material weaknesses um identified in our statements or in our internal controls and then additionally for the required um uniform guidance it was stated in there that in our opinion Paradise Valley Unified School District complied in all material respects with the compliance requirements referred to above that could have material and direct effect on each of its major federal programs for the year ended June 30th 2024 um those are important statements for us to receive to ensure with uh our community that we are following all of the required guidelines and requirements with the uniform excuse me with the uniform system of financial records compliance questionnaire that is showing our

033compliance with State statutes and the there are a number of areas reviewed but there are about 10 of them listed on here these are the primary areas that re review um I won't list all of them but they are there on the slide the next two slides obvious it's a little bit smaller print but tried to get them on the two slides here in terms of the compliance questionnaire findings that we received there are 18 sections total that are reviewed with 171 questions um for the district this year 11 items are listed is no we don't like any no items but uh there generally always are going to be some no items um and this is the second page of those findings um and just to put some things in perspective with the 11 minor

034non-compliance items that were noted uh the average number of findings for school districts in the state of Arizona continues to be about 18 to 20 which would put them at an 80 to 89% or a high B uh for us we exceed that with 94% of our us frr compliance questionnaire answered with a yes or an na uh additionally I just wanted to mention this year the Financial Risk analysis the Arizona auditor general in recent years has put together this analysis of the most current uh data available for seven risk categories listed um there's the receivership so if a school district is in receivership change in weighted student count that is read on this slide because we do have the change in weighted student count that they consider would put us into high Financial Risk

035that's that declining enrollment that we have addition budget limit in addition budget limit reserves and financial position are considered we have a red box again around Capital monies redirected to operations that's the 90% of the district additional assistance that we put into M they consider that a Financial Risk I do think that that misses some context um in our district we also have a district additional assistance override and bond that allows us to take care of our Capital needs um and allows us to free up that daa into M and it's allowable by the state in state statute for you to put up to 100% of daa into your m&o budget and then two other reasons for uh Financial Risk or small school budget limit adjustment we would never have that we're not a small

036school um and then a frozen tax rate and we are far from a frozen tax rate uh with our audit results uh those reports were issued on time in order to meet the Arizona School business official International and gfoa which is the government Finance Officers Association submission deadlines so we expect to receive those Awards again and we've been receiving those awards for 20 plus years I'm very proud of that in addition that will meet our continuing Bond disclosures deadline of February 1st um just as a reminder that is information we send out to our bond holders people who have purchased our bonds to show them that we are meeting all of our financial requirements as very very important um and all our required reports have already been issued to our oversight agencies before the deadline

037of March 31st which includes the AR Arizona auditor general the county school superintendent the federal clearing house and then as mentioned previously Arizona Department of Education access to our financial reports not just this report but other Year's reports and our budget information along with other pieces of information are available on our website and just wanted to remind people of that important part of transparency that we have uh within school districts uh as well I've listed here some additional resources if anybody needs to um reference back to any budget reports or classroom dollar reports um Bond information all of that is available as well with that it's important for me to say thank you to some very important people Kathy DeStefano our internal auditor Vanessa shapir our former Director of Finance who uh has still helped

038us out as we transition into our new director of Finance Mr Connor Hutchinson uh Eva kayaz our director of purchasing Rob deathridge who helps with our average daily membership everyone on our finance team everyone on our purchasing team technology there's uh technology components of our audit our human resources team helps and there are even components where the schools have portions of the audit that they are responsible for and I thank all of them for helping us be successful in this area and with that I'm happy to answer any questions you might have thank you Mrs be Aran uh Mr panta may have a motion to approve the fiscal year 2023 24 audit reports as presented so moved does any board member have any comments or questions Mr panta well just a you mentioned the finance

039purchasing technology Human Resources ballpark how many people is that because you can't list them all 100 yeah that's a big team well I don't even when you include this it's probably more than that more like 150 when include all of the people at the schools people understand this is this is you know these few words represent a lot a lot of people that's why they're not listed here and sure does you did a great job by the way thank you excellent does anybody else have any questions comments Mrs Christensen Mrs Baran was kind enough to answer a couple of my questions that I had but I I feel like I should ask them anyway just in the spirit of of just allowing the public to know what's going on with her finances so I appreciate

040this because I don't pretend to know this I I took what when's my college you don't want to know like five decades ago I went to college for business and it um and so I was wondering at the top of page 29 we it talks about support services and I'm talking about the big report not and um not the small audit report how it's increased um and so I was just curious why the expenses went up $1.4 million while our instruction expenditures only went up 3 million and you did give a very thorough answer but if you could just highlight some of those for us yep uh yes president Greenberg Mrs Christensen and governing board I'll actually go ahead and read what I did share with the board because I think it's an important question

041it's a unique year in what occurred um and I don't want to miss any of those points so what I shared was Support Services Administration for fiscal year 24 includes the quas mayor and I still don't know if I Say It Right lawsuit liability of $15.7 million year-over-year there was actually a decrease in Support Services Administration expenses if we exclude that liability amount to $15 million compared to fiscal year 23 support service Administration costs actually declined by almost $4.3 million bringing the total down to about 24.5 million so it's important to remember that the quasm is recorded as a liability on our financial statements as well it was on page 40 but it didn't impact our actual budget meaning we didn't have to uh find a place to move other expenses because we had this

042expense it just affects cash so this was simply a tax collection transaction meaning that it was a cash flow item that didn't affect budget capacity so uh due to gasby our governmental Accounting Standards Board requirements and the usfr coding the liability is included under expenses and our Auditors confirmed with gby that this is the correct place for the quasm liability our Auditors don't even run into anything like this often this was a a once in A- lifetime situation that occurred within the State of Arizona um and per the usfr judgments against the district are coded to object code 6820 and must use function 2310 admin so that's why you see it in Support Services admin on page 29 page 40 page 106 and 107 uh when you get further into the forur there's a note

043on page 107 that reads Support Services Support Services administration were higher than normal in fiscal year 2324 due to the claims and judgment related to the quasm versus Maricopa County class action judgment this ties to the figure on page 106 of the actur which then ties back to page 29 Additionally you will see the amount tied to liabilities claims and judgments payable under the general column on page 40 which is the balance sheet of governmental funds um and so all of that explains why appears there why the amount is 11 million more than last year um but I just want to make a note that um in anticipation of the classroom spending report that comes out from the office of the auditor general in March uh are my initial calculations and they always change a

044few things but based off of where I think they will move any expenditures our administrative costs will decrease from 7.8% of our total expenditures in fiscal year 23 to 7.3% in fiscal year 24 so that would be a 5.5% reduction in administrative spending this Christenson yeah thank you for that thorough explanation I do want to just correct because initially you said quasam meire was Statewide it was only mirac the second time you said miraco but I said I just want to add that that it was not a Statewide um it was only for the Maricopa County the lawsuit um and then the second question was on page 13 2 it's and it similar it it seems like we've added administrative buildings and square footages as compared to 2015 as our enrollment has decreased so it

045appears in the table that we're using 400% more square footage for administration while our enrollment has decreased 18.6% from 2015 and so you were kind enough to explain the reason for that but I think it's also important to share that with the other board members thank you Mrs Christensen president Greenberg and govern board uh as shared with you previously as well we've closed schools between 2015 and 2024 this doesn't actually include the three schools that we just closed last year because they didn't close until the end of the school year when a school's closed and no longer used for instructional purposes it becomes administrative space so even if a building is vacant even if a building is being used for a lease or some other purpose when within the district it's considered administrative space that

046doesn't necessarily correlate to having administrators in that space it's not the same thing thank you does anybody else have any questions just a little just a little question um you talk about the ex you talked about the external Auditors you know requesting samples now are those random samples or you guys to get to pick those how's that done we do not get to pick them I think so yeah they are random samples okay thank you Mrs Baran I have a question I apologize because I didn't ask this prior so if you don't have the answer it's okay sure you will find out um on the Financial Risk analysis where we were red booxed um on the capital Mony redirected operations what level does the state you know at what level would the state remove the

047box I think if I I will verify this so don't hold me to it but if I remember correctly on almost all of those measures anything within a 5% change or for example with enrollment decline they wouldn't care about an enrollment increase but enrollment decline of more than 5% over the prior year you get a red box around it um with the daa into M I don't know at what percentage threshold they put that you know in a Financial Risk uh position but I'll verify that and get back with you okay thank you does anybody else excuse me have any other questions or comments uh seeing none Mrs chisman may I have a roll call vote please Mrs Christensen hi Mr panta hi Mrs Greenberg I Dr Lim I miss wanie I uh thank you

048there are no Nays no abstentions so the motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is request for approval to update ctds numbers and information for compliance with ar1 15142 B Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg governing board uh as we discussed in our study session uh we are working to relocate our James P Lee programming uh to the former Sunset Canyon Elementary School uh and we will need to update the ctds numbers uh that correlate with the those programs so we're recommending I I would like to say that based on um the feedback from the governing board on Tuesday uh we have one slight change it doesn't impact the motion or it doesn't impact the the item uh but we are uh reexamining the move of uh little cubs to uh Foothills Elementary uh as

049requested in the in the study session thank you Dr Reynolds uh Mr panta may I please have a motion to approve ctds updates including a new ctds for James P Lee Early Childhood Learning Center reassignment of the current ctds to Arrowhead Elementary and retirement of Sunset Canyon and Arrowhead ctds numbers to comply with AR15 1042 b as presented so moved does any board member have any questions or comments Dr Lim I just want to clarify just so we have this so my understanding at least in how we read things was bullet point directed there miss Bean so bullet point 3 has us potentially changing the address of little cubs to Foothills but because we're reexamining that is my understanding that that will not be part of this motion or is this still something that's part

050of this motion so it's not Dr Lim uh president Greenberg board members it's not actually part of the motion as as it's listed on there it's part of the background information okay as such we have the ability to hold on on doing that until we make a final decision about where uh little cups will be located okay perfect thank you for that clarification you're welcome does anybody else have any questions or comments seeing none all those in favor please say I I any opposed say nay any exensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is request for approval to update the PB online ctds 07269 299 address for the 20242 school year and retire former Desert Springs Preparatory School ctds number Dr Reynolds didto no it's the same we've talked about this in our study

051session uh we need to uh update our ctds numbers uh to reflect the programming that's in the in the facility I'm G to go through that again Mr panta may I please have a motion for approval to update the PV online ctds 07269 299 to 6010 East Tacoma drive Scottdale Arizona 85254 former location of Desert Springs Preparatory School for the 20 2425 school year and retire former Desert Springs Preparatory School ctds number as presented I'm sorry what what did you say no so moved so moved once more with feeling any board member have any questions or comments Mrs Christensen so I do understand retiring the ctds numbers are and I just have a point of clarification do the ctds numbers um follow the the the address is that what it is so or is it

052when whenever something retires it just goes away and it goes to a different code I just want to understand that a little better because I thought I understood and and then the more I hear about it I still confused so yes Mrs Christensen president Greenberg board members it can vary depending upon the situation certainly if an address change occurs it may require a ctds change as it does in this case generally a ctd ctds number follows the school so ctds stands for County Maricopa the county 07 type it would type is 02 which indicates we are a unified district uh District which is 69 that's why you see Paradise Valley Unified School District number 69 on all our yellow buses uh and then school so School number so then we have an each unique identifying

053number for every school so generally it's going to follow the school okay does any Miss wanie is there um any within the statute requirement to do it within a certain time frame so for example if PV online's been operating you know at um a Desert Springs is is it like required you do it within a certain amount of time and or if it changes again you you know let's say at some point in you know the near future you know just in thinking about when these items would have to come up for approval again if if they needed to yeah um president wnie president Greenberg governing board did I say president wnie excuse me Mrs wanie my apologies it's been a long day um the answer to that is any time within the school year

054is considered acceptable however when some of this is cleanup from prior year closures as we've explained to the board and so there isn't necessarily a penalty or it's not like we didn't receive funding for something so um it is important to clean those things up if they aren't correct so technically we could still do that as we are in this case but um generally you want to do that within the school year that that the change has occurred and so we're well within the timeline for PV online okay thank you and then obviously wanting to make sure that once you make those changes like everybody's good and it's going to kind of stay that way for a while before you make a change like this I sure hope so does anybody else have any questions

055comments seeing none all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay any abstentions I abstain from this one motion passes uh four eyes and one exstension next on the agenda is consideration to approve purchase from current District contract 2315 PB Joc for additional restrooms at Sunset Canyon Elementary Dr Reynolds thank you governing board um Miss Baran uh thank you Dr Reynolds president Greenberg and governing board members uh this is to accommodate the move of the sunkid students to Sunset Canyon I will just add in here that if uh the does decide to move the little cubs to Sunset Canyon as well there would be an additional cost of approximately $230,000 that was shared with the governing board or maybe still needs to be shared with the governing board um uh

056that would be added to this so that would have to come back to the governing board I believe at that time um I think we could have an answer to that hopefully before the next board meeting thank you uh we have one public comment card um Nicole kwick you will have three minutes hello um my name is Nicole kwick thank you for the opportunity to speak um president Greenberg uh superintendent Reynolds school board members and cabinet very very very very quick I just think this might be a little premature if we don't know exactly who is moving to that school yet it seems like we should know um you know is this going to be just Sun kids is this just going to be little cubs is this going to be both programs um I

057I thought that I heard some some um some of those details have not been finalized if I've misunderstood um forgive me for my my Interruption and slowing down the meeting but um if those things have not been finalized it seems premature to be building new bathrooms for children who we don't know exactly who's going to be there yet so thank you Mr panta may I please have a motion to approve purchase from current District contract 2315 pvj for additional restrooms at sunson Canyon Elementary as presented so moved does any board member have uh questions or comments Miss Mr panta well it's my understanding that we're approving this but if um changes are made we don't actually have to put them in right correct and um Mr panta just to clarify we do know that we

058are moving Sun kids there this summer um it's just uh what we don't know at this point based off of the feedback we heard from board members in the study session from this Tuesday whether or not we may potentially also move little cubs to that campus which would be the additional $230,000 that I mentioned sure but again if we didn't need to we wouldn't yeah just because we passed it doesn't mean you have to actually do it if there's a change correct that's all I'm asking okay thank you thank you Dr Lyn I was just wondering I did not send this comment in ahead of time do you know how many bathrooms do currently exist on the campus between the preschool and the kindergarten rooms is and because I know we're going above and beyond

059to add additional bathrooms because these are all potty training Learners so um Doc is Dr Davis here he is here four there are four exist okay or exist Does anybody else have any questions or comments uh seeing none all those in favor oh I'm sorry Mrs Christensen so for the plan to move these indiv these um little preschoolers to sunent Canyon do we know how long they may be there or is this the new permanent home or is it a temporary move once again I I know you've probably told me 15 times I I just can't remember once I hit menopause I just like things don't stuck in stick in my brain so I apologize permanent permanent yeah okay all right are there any other questions comments seeing none all those in favor please say

060I I I I all those opposed say nay nay any abstentions motion passes Bo to one next on the agenda is acceptance of gifts and donations uh we have many I'd like to review just a few um Odyssey operations gave $11,000 to Greenway Middle School for the site discretionary fund at Pinnacle High School Thomas hazer gave $3,500 for the spirit line and Striker gave just under $10,000 for the spirit line and for sun kids preschool at JPL the PB schools Education Foundation uh provided a Mobility Rider valued at 1,25 $4 and change so thank you again to all of our donors we appreciate your generosity and Mr Pantera may I please have a motion to accept gifts and donations so moved do any board members have any comments or questions seeing none oh Mrs Christensen

061yes uh I would like to know a ballpark as we are on sorry I'm gonna blame menopause again I'm not I'm a a one ahead of you none at this point okay so you're good on this one okay all those in favor please say I I I any oppos please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously sorry next uh we are going to what was originally consent agenda item F6 um sorry we've got this up here G6 F6 to G6 F6 to right so what I said was originally F6 now G6 um and that is uh consideration approval of business operations Department administrative certified ESP uh employee travel request um any Dr Reynolds or Mrs Bergen would you no presentation Mr panta may have a motion to approve the business operations Department administrative certified ESP

062employee travel request so moved does any board member have a comment or question Mrs Christensen what's the uh estimated cost for each individual to to attend this conference uh Mrs Christensen president Greenberg governing board I believe this was shared with the board but maybe not so uh this conference uh will cost approximately $525 per attendee that includes the conference registration the hotel stay all of the meals that are included it's um actually very uh inexpensive conference yeah why why do we have so many individuals from from similar departments attending it's it seems that it's a bit redundant and while I understand that um we like to train our employees it this is Administration this isn't training for educators in the classroom so I'm just curious as to why there are so many people attending this

063conference um Mrs Christensen president Greenberg governing board um I believe that it's important to provide professional development for support staff as well there are seven different tracks offered at this conference that cover various areas and that allows staff to choose various topics that relate to their roles and it's uh it's not necessarily that they will stick to their track the entire time we have people in our uh facilities Department who may be uh interested or most receptive to something on a facilities track during one session and then may move to a purchase ing track for the next section because that's also relevant to their job um and so we provide this opportunity to all the people that it uh will support and be relevant for particularly at the inexpensive price that it it uh offers

064for them does anybody else have any questions comments seeing none all those in favor please say I I I I all those opposed say nay nay and extensions motion passes 4 to1 next on the agenda is call to the public please turn your attention to the video monitors call to the public is about to convene this portion of today's meeting allows the public the opportunity to address the governing board although state law does not require that the governing board hold a to the public The Paradise Valley Unified School District and its board have chosen to do so because we believe it's important to hear about concerns and issues from our community while call to the public is not designed to be a discussion the board is here to listen due to Arizona open meeting law

065the governing board cannot respond to discuss or take any action on items brought up during this time however staff members may be directed to get back to you and address individual concerns as a reminder the point of this and every board meeting is to accomplish the business at hand and to be able to do so in an open and collaborative way all an attendant are expected to observe meeting rules as well as rules of politeness and decorum so that we may serve as an example to our students that issues can be discussed in a respectful and civil manner thank you tonight we have eight people who have submitted comment cards prior to the start of the meeting so each speaker will have three minutes for remarks as a reminder as we just said we ask

066that you please direct your comments to the board uh please State your first and last name when you come to the podium and I think we've got a couple here you only gave us your first name so definitely State first and last when you come to the podium our first speaker is Nicole kwick and she'll be followed by Tiffany Ruiz hello um thank you again my name's Nicole kwick thank you president Greenberg School Board cabinet um superintendent Reynolds I just wanted to talk about the fact that um we just closed three schools just right just it was official just July 1 I believe so this fall was the first time these schools were closed we went through um what was supposed to be a long and very detailed and robust process to determine which schools

067should be closed and one of those determining factors was supposed to be the condition of the schools it is very very disheartening to find out that Indian Bend is in such a state of disrepair um and I don't understand it frankly like I especially don't understand how we have knob and tube wiring there when that was supposed to be done in the 1940s and this building was built in the 1970s but regardless I don't understand how we could have a facility in such disrepair and it was not considered forclosure we would we would have skipped all of this boundaries could have been done in such a way I just don't understand um and I think that the lack of public disclosure during that process the lack of open meetings during the deliberation process apparently there

068were um there were public well not public there were um meetings done to get public opinion polling which Mrs beran had conducted I don't know if any other committee meeting uh members attended those or those results just got reported back the lack of visibility um and transparency is really sad and especially with this result we have a facility that appears to be an emergency status um and I would like to ask you to correct that in this process you guys are moving a lot of kids around and this also seems to be not nearly as transparent as it could be um we haven't seen building inspection reports for Indian Bend we haven't seen them for James um p Lee I attended the study session at James P Lee where multiple Schoolboard members said that building

069needs to be torn down it is in horrible disrepair it we wouldn't want our kids there and now we're moving kids from Indian Bend which is in disrepair to another facility in disrepair the whole process just needs to be much more open um and I would like your consideration for that thank you next is Tiffany Ruiz followed by Diane Neeman it's j NE sorry my apologies you're fine um I am here today um I just want to thank you guys for allowing me the time to speak um governing board um I wanted to come back and give you guys an update on my statement made on um November 21st about Indian Bend the smells that have been ongoing um up to 10 days ago um I understand that in the previous Mee meeting that we

070had this week the community discussion or the board's discussion that it was stated that our facilities Department moves very quickly um I have been gaslit numerous times by this department um I've been told that it's my fragrance that I'm wearing that smells like sewage um I've been told that or my my other workers have been told that it's their lotion or it's other things we've complained and complained and complained finally after my November thing we had a a contractor come in on December 3rd that contractor found that there was sewer gas or sewer the the smell was being leaked into the walls um and so they ran a pipe to go out a different way so it wouldn't be sucked back into the building um within that time frame that was fixed by um on

071January 9th sorry we had a city inspector come out because we had no hot water at the school for 2 days um or in our kitchen which is I don't know how that happened but the hot water heater was not fixed until the 15th we had no hot water in our school from the 9th to the 15th um I don't think that that's fast um we also then um when the the inspector came they discovered that the kitchen sink wasn't up to code that was replaced when that was replaced on the 18th or the 19th our facilities crew then drilled a hole into the brand new pipe that the contractor put in releasing those fumes back into the kitchen I notified facilities about this facilities continued to come out I was even yelled at by

072one of our facilities members and told that our kitchen was not being replaced they've already spent millions of dollars on this kitchen um I advised them on the 21st that the smell was coming from the sink that was recently installed they come in they tell me that it's not it's not it's not um finally I believe it was on February 10th the sale was still coming and then by the 11th they fixed it now we don't have the smell because they've fixed it but what's concerning is that we paid a contractor to come fix this and then our facilities crew damaged the brand new work that was just done with that being said I would like the the board the district to review this department as I asked before on their knowledge of things I

073understand that we're not paying a lot so maybe that's why but yeah we need to reassess that next is Diane Neeman and like I said we've got some that I don't have last names followed by Laura Miss nean yes um I just wanted to point out that we' talking about funds a lot here tonight and um it might be important to say that it's based a lot of the funds are based on property taxes and I received last year's uh tax bill and I was shocked my tax bill went up 34% 34% so I called you know the mar Copa County uh Property Tax Center the treasurer's office and they said was because there's a um Schoolboard bond issue that raised your taxes 34% that's why it went up so if there are six or

074seven vacant schools I wonder why we don't sell those schools instead of making more administrative space uh so that we could offset maybe uh people that are retired like me to not get a tax increase by 34% and I'd like to U make a comment um regarding uh Tony Pantera's um public statement he said um that the public school is the Hub the glue that holds the neighborhood together um I'd just like to point out that a lot of people don't have children in school not that I don't recommend people going to schools but uh not necessarily just homeschooling but I would say that this is a this was founded on a Christian uh Christian uh country with the Ten Commandments being the basis and if we listen to the Ten Commandments do not kill

075and all those things it' be good for the kids to be um trained about that and um one of the in the Revolutionary War one of the most important uh groups was called the U black robe regiment and those were um actually uh pastors that were leading their own congregations into battle because they really felt that their freedom would me them to be able to continue to um talk about Christianity rather than uh other things that were England had in mind and also a lot of the original books used in our schools like in Pennsylvania and in Washington DC were founding books were um the curriculum was used with the Bible so I just like to say as a Christian that I really think the church should might be a very good place to have

076as your Hub of a of a community again I that would be my suggestion and um I um wonder about again selling some of these schools that are just administrative space and maybe uh not also leasing some of the schools for a dollar that's what I understand that some of the schools have been leased out to different project people for a dollar versus selling that to offset the costs of the school the schools so thank you next is Laura followed by Sher president Greenberg governing board members and superintendent Dr Reynolds my name is Laura Ross I'm here because I am deeply invested in pvusd succeeding at all levels from the board to the superintendent admin the newest group of little kids who have joined Parise Valley Unified School District as um I did as a

077kindergartener in this District over 50 years ago so I have a long history and my family has a long history with this district and I'm couldn't be more proud um which is why I chose this district for my child um my daughter proudly attends Horizon High School she's a junior um she's interested in a career in life science um and I'm very concerned that her options are being very very limited um increasingly um in science so I just want to talk about what's going on at Horizon High School um their bus to uh Paradise Valley High School to participate in um health care and all the other services that are offered there um is no longer available anatomy and physiology will not be offered at Horizon High School next year because of um students who

078have not um signed up for the the option that's available with anatomy of physiology um AP Bio is in danger of not being offered at Horizon High School next year which deeply concerns me so that you know her options are are very very limited um there uh there is a teacher who uh deeply wants to teach AP Bio next year um who's teaching it this year and um uh Jr Travis she um taught dual enrollment um when my daughter was a freshman and uh a lot of parents um have a plan for their kids to take her freshman level which my daughter did take college level she was fortunate enough to be able to take dual enrollment as a freshman and so J.R Trevis teaches AP Bio and many of us are have a plan

079for our children who want to go into life science um to uh take that that combo which really sets them up for success in the future um so I'm very concerned that this AP bio class is not going to be offered and and that an opportunity for our highest performing students would be taken away along with many other options that they have had to study science and as we know it's you know um Dr r talked about the steam opportunity which is wonderful I love to see th those opportunities for kids um and I hope that the district continues to offer those um so the uh current teacher has an 80% thank you your time is up thank you thanks uh next is Sherry followed by Christy McGrady uh my name is Sherry Boon and

080I'm actually here um with the same concerns for Life Sciences at Horizon High School um also I have a daughter that goes to Horizon she's a sophomore also took dual enrollment biology as a freshman and uh she PLS major in biomedical engineering her goal in life is to create the first fully functional internal spinal replacement um and she is currently in a track that according to her counselor she's the only kid in the Paradise Valley School District that is doing this program that it's basically in partnership with ASU where she's taking ASU classes but then still getting credit at Horizon for them as well but it's being counted as concurrent enrollment versus dual enrollment or anything like that which is fine except she has the limit of one credit per core subject so because as

081is common knowledge at Horizon chemistry teachers are questionable at Horizon right now she took chemistry through ASU this year so she has to take her next two years of science at Horizon she wanted to take AP Bio next year she's now coming home and telling me how she's hearing from the current teacher that if Travis is not the AP biot teer next year this current teacher that is slated to be in a class discussion there was a discussion about people with epilepsy my daughter has epilepsy my husband has epilepsy and it has become it was a statement made in this class this teacher told these kids that epilepsy is not a neur ological disorder but it is a curse from the gods this woman should not be teaching science at all but should not be

082in front of our students and I chose Paradise Valley School District when we still lived over on the other side of i7 I would drive my kids over here we've now moved over here because of the schools I have a kid that's in sixth grade at Desert Shadows Elementary School that will be headed to Horizon cannot wait to get there we have to have these Sciences we have to save this there is no way that you can have a journey of Excellence without actually offering the Excellence and our kids need quality science programs with quality science instructors that actually want to be there and want to be teaching The Proven science not their personal beliefs thank you next is chrisy McGrady followed by Ashley Rayborn good evening president green board governing board members and cabinet

083my name is Christine McGrady I'm a teacher at Indian Ben Elementary School I'm also a proud parent of three students in the district and a product of the district myself very grateful that I get to call this place home um I stand before you this evening to express our deepest gratitude to the incredible members of our school board and your unwavering commitment to the future of our students at Indian Bend rebuilding a school is no small feat it will take Vision leadership and an immense amount of hard work I know your mission is to provide our students with a safe inspiring and state-ofthe-art space for our students to learn we know that this journey will not be easy but we stand behind you we are very grateful that JPL is being considered for our temporary

084relocation we are very lucky that it's so close to home and we'll continue to allow our families to stay within the same community that they know and love we know there will be obstacles along the way such as packing and unpacking teachers classrooms logistical hurdles and countless hours spents in meetings and planning sessions I know that during this the school board would never lose sight of what truly matters the students the teachers and the entire community that this school serves when Indian benis finished being rebuilt it will be a space where young minds will be shaped where friendships will be formed and where the future will be built one lesson one Discovery and one achievement at a time on behalf of the teachers the parents the students and the entire Community we thank you uh

085next is Ashley Rayborn followed by Michelle Parker Rock who will be our last speaker good evening president Greenberg governing board and cabinet my name is Ashley Rayborn I am an employee and parent at Indian Bend thank you for the opportunity to stand in front of you and Express express my gratitude for considering a rebuild of Indian Bend I speak for many when I say that this was the best news we could have received at the last board meeting Miss bargan did an amazing job listing the reasons why Indian Ben is ready for a new campus as a parent and employee I cannot tell you how much it means to know that our children along with so many my own children along with so many others we'll now have the opportunity to learn and grow in

086a new and improved campus I also would like to thank you for considering the temporary location being the current James P Lee campus as many of our families have reached out to express the importance of Indians Ben's temporary location remaining remaining within the community thank you and last is Michelle Parker Rock good evening governing board superintendent members of the board and cabinet thank you for providing this opportunity for me to express myself and hopefully on behalf of others who are like-minded John Bo the author of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas a novel about the Friendship of two youth during a troubling time period in history said this about the word home a home is not a building or a street or a city or something so artificial as bricks and mortar a home is

087where one's family is Bo got me thinking about the word family and of course the traditional definition came to mind as I'm sure it does to yours yes a family is the people we live with but a family can be much more than that it can be the people we depend on and the people who depend on us it can be the people we love and the people who love us it can be the people who have our backs and the people who we have our backs for it can also be the people who support us and the people who we support and it can be the people we teach and the people who teach us in the wise words of Jane Howard an American journalist an educator and the author of The Margaret me

088a life biography she says call it a clan you can call it a network call it a tribe or call it a family whatever you or I or we call it whoever we are we need one we appreciate your understanding that Indian Bend is a family with great traditions and more to come we are a family of students parents Guardians aunties uncles grandmas grandpas and siblings many who have already attended Indian Bend themselves we are a family that works together plays together laughs together cries together learns together and of course we grow together we need each other and we need to keep our amazingly wonderful Indian Bend element School Community intact during what you have helped us see is the building of a brand new facility thank you next on the agenda excuse me is

089items for discussion um we have first read consideration proposed Community Education facility rental rate increases effective for next school year and I'll turn it over to Dr Lindsay thank you president Greenberg good evening and good evening to the members of the board at this time I'd like to invite Miss Natalie Wilcox our director of Community Education to the podium she will be presenting a first reading consideration of proposed rate increases to District facility rentals Community Education rents out District facility space to our community when our school are not utilizing the spaces it's been quite some time since we've increased rental fees and as you'll hear tonight we've experienced increase cost over that time period and feel it necessary to make these recommendations to you and before she begins I'd just like to publicly thank her

090as well as the members of her team for all the research and hard work that they put into this proposal thank you Dr Lindsay good evening president Greenberg governing board Dr Reynolds cabinet and guests thank you for this opportunity to review information about the proposal to increase facility use rates in an effort to allow Community ad to continue to be a self- sustaining as well as a contributing entity to the district tonight I will be presenting a first read of the proposed increase so we can hear your questions and take your feedback into consideration I do want to let you know there is a slight modification that um should have been updated in your packets I know uh thank you Miss chisman for helping me out with that today our governing board policy KF outlines

091the use of school facilities as well as the responsibility to charge reasonable rates that cover the costs associated with the use of the space the district facility rental rates have not increased since 2014 and with the increase in wages cost of living utilities and supplies this is an important time to review rates and to develop a protocol that allows rates to be increased uh and based on the increase of costs this proposal outlines a plan to implement annual adjustments to Community Education facility use rates the adjustment is necessary to ensure the long-term sustainability of our programs and facilities in the face of rising operational costs specifically increased in Personnel supplies and utilities within the presentation I will break down the cost associated with with each of those categories the first one I want to talk

092about is Personnel the rate analysis on this slide is specific to costs associated with custodial and Technical Support the rate for custodian includes personnel as well as supplies such as those needed for janitorial services this is the amount we charge to renters or to users and it's not an hourly wage that's paid to uh our staff the manner in which we bill for this service is comparable to the way other districts bill as you review the custodial line you will see that currently PV is at the low end of the rate comparison the role of a technician of an auditorium rental is to provide support to a renter while simultaneously protecting the assets of the district our district technicians are present when our district equipment is being used technicians assist with sound visuals backdrops and

093lights this role requires a level of expertise and training that differs from other positions once again you can see that PV bills at a lower rate than other comparable districts this next slide condenses the information from the previous one to show the range of rates between districts you can see where PV Falls in each area the minimum wage comparison shows where the minimum wage was the last time we considered rate increases the minimum wage in January of 2014 was $7.90 compared to January of 2025 with the rate being $14.70 minimum wage has increased 86% while we have had no increase in rates for personnel costs as previously noted supplies are considered in the custodial fees it's important to highlight the increased cost to supplies and materials from our records in 2015 some supplies have increased

094in price as much is 85% the cost of essential custodial supplies like toilet paper garbage bags Cleaning Solutions disinfectant gloves are all subject to inflation and supply chain vulnerabilities prices increase from suppliers as that happens those costs are passed on to us additionally increased facility usage by Community groups results in higher consumption of custodial supplies more events and programs necessitate more frequent cleaning restocking of supplies and increased costs are quickly realized we do not anticipate a decrease in these costs as such we ask that an annual increase be applied to rates to plan for continued increased costs of supplies based on the comparative data that we were able to obtain from our district rate study we recommend the following rate increase for personnel to be applied for facility rentals the custodian rate to increase to

095$35 per hour and technician $40 per hour due to continued increased costs associated with minimum wage the cost of living it is further recommended that an annual adjustment be applied based on the district's projected wage increases and Supply costs this will help to cover the rising cost of both the second category that we would like to discuss is cost associated with utilities there is a lot of information on this slide so I would like to highlight a couple of areas that might be helpful to understand it's important to us to show the comparison across districts however there are many variables to take into account for the published rate for utilities for example most rates are calculated hourly although some rates are listed as a daily rate for comparison an example would be uh Cave Creek

096they're listing a daily rate most districts calculate utilities separate from the rental of the space however you will see that Madison includes Utilities in their rates Madison has the Madison Center for the Arts and so they charge all of the fees within that rate districts including PV have different rates depending on the classification of the renter cost for utilities can vary depending on the classification of facility use for example PV has three classes one class or class one is for school use class two is for 501c3 entities and class three is for entities that are for profit if you look at our Auditorium rental there are two rates that are listed there one rate rate is for school day use which means an event that's happened either within the school day or after school has

097dismissed so the electricity has been on air conditioning has been on custodians may still be on site and the other one would be non-school de so is Saturday or Sunday at that time additional support is going to be needed in comparison if you look at Gilbert's rates they vary according to the space that is being used whether it's an elementary school a middle school or a high school and finally another variable in utility rates is the time of year we have two seasons for our rates most districts do rates are naturally higher from May to October than they are from November to April all of these factors were taken into consideration as we reviewed a reasonable rate increase for utilities over the past seven years we have experienced a rise in utility expenses of approximately

09821% these increases are projected to continue it is recommended that an annual rate adjustment be made tied to the utility cost that is directly linked to the percentage utility cost that the district is given this will ensure that our fees remain aligned with our actual operational expenses the third and final category that I would like to discuss is classroom utility rates while there is not as much demand for classroom rentals as there is for other spaces in reviewing our rates we noted an inconsistency in the manner in which classroom rates are calculated currently our classrooms are build on a daily rate classrooms use might include a group who needs space for an HOA meeting a girl scout troop a church we have had attorneys who rent rooms when they're discussing rezoning and need a space

099for the community to gather we have a group that uses space during the summer for an Institute it's not common that a room is rented for a long period of time typically it's a couple of hours at a time this is the only category that is build daily versus hourly and is incommensurate with the costs associated with classroom use in an effort to create uniformity in our billing Clarity for our rentals and a more accurate reflection of the costs we propose changing the language from daily to hourly in summary I recognize this was a lot of information so I want to just summarize uh the requests that we're presenting to you that we would increase the facility use rate for personnel from $28 to $35 for custodian fees from $28 to $40 for technicians and

100that we would then apply an annual increase in rates based on the district's projected cost increases and that would begin in July of 2026 increase utility fees by 21 31% and that would be effective July 1st 2025 and then annually apply an increase based on the dis District's projected costs for utilities beginning in July of 2026 and then this last section should say classroom utility fees classroom utility fees to be build on an hourly basis versus a daily basis to be consistent with our other facility rental spaces again effective July 1st 2025 we have given careful consideration to these recommendations our goal is to continue to support our community and allow for the use of District facilities the increases to these rates are necessary so that we can continue to operate in a manner that

101contributes to the district operational budget at this time I'm happy to answer any questions thank you Mrs Wilcox does anybody have any questions or comments Miss wanie thank you very impressive very good work um so truly thank you to you and your team for for all that information um and you gave some examples about like who some of the um you know renters would be um is it do we have any after school like programs um that like our like staff and and families use that would fall under that category that staff would use or yeah or yeah just like an a like a mass like does mascot fall into this category it does it's a class one so there are no fees associated with that okay same with enrichment programs or anything that is

102related to a school function okay so those programs are G they're going to continue correct under with the same cost that they've think that was my question Dr ly so I'll follow up that one and then I'll come to the freshest one on my mind so for this uh just to get the best understanding is these costs let's say for example so was springwinds every year uses PV High School um for their Chinese New Year celebration so are they going to now incur an increased cost to be able to use that facility because they're not using their regular facility but going offsite for that does this apply to programs that are say not enrichment but they're coming from our schools and often supported by our local parent organizations they are not they they will remain

103the same they are they remain as a class one rental okay I do have a few others all right I'll work through them um so my next one was so I know you talked about technicians do we have a shortage of technicians in this District are are we facing a shortage of technicians to help support those evening activities and things like that well it's it's sort of ebed and flowed we are in a a nice position at this moment but uh we have technicians who we have sought um technicians over the years multiple times but we have a really good team right now okay and then assuming we have in flow and we do have a shortage um I know you said that you kind of touched on that these technicians help support these activities

104and their expertise is need to engage with our our equipment are we able to use outside Professionals for this and obviously there's a fee associated with them is there then also a fee associated with us using the equipment on site for saying activity that where a technician isn't available when there has not been a technician we have worked with the technology department and Mr Billings and we have contracted out to meet the needs of a potential renter okay but does that incur a double cost in that where you using the equipment and using a professional or is that then we're just paying for the professional to use our in-house equipment we're paying for the professional I do have one more we're um and then I wanted to talk I know we're moving from a daily

105rate to an hourly rate so are these going to apply to any existing renters or just new renters so obviously we have Girl Scouts and other organizations that charge a very nominal fee to even take part and so an increase in cost to these organizations May mean we lose them all together to a different site that may be able to offer a different rate are we going to do this for all renters moving forward or we would do it for all renters moving forward beginning in July of 2025 groups like Girl Scouts use the room for about an hour okay perfect thank you does anybody else have any questions comments um this was just for discussion as a first read so thank you m wox Dr Lindsay we appreciate all the information and I'm sure

106we will be seeing it again on the next agenda uh next on the agenda is call for executive session pursuant to ARS 38 43103 A5 the governing board may vote to hold an executive session regarding negotiations with employee groups the purpose would be to meet for instruction and Direction Mr panta may I have an emotion please yes I move the governing board call for an executive session in accordance with Arizona revised statutes 38-43 13. A5 discussions or consultations with designated representatives of the public body in order to consider its position and instruct its Representatives regarding negotiations with employee organizations regarding the salaries salary schedules or compensation paid in the form of fringe benefits of employees of the public body the purpose is to meet for instruction Andor Direction all those in favor please say I

107I I all those opposed say nay any extensions the motion passes unanimously the regular meeting is recessed at 8:15 p.m. to go into executive session and we'll reconvene after we return from executive session there will be no action taken in the executive session but there may be possible action when the regular meeting reconvenes e e e hey we are reconvening our meeting at 9:13 p.m. next on the agenda is direction to Administration regarding negotiations with employee groups as discussed in executive session Mr panta may have a motion uh move the governing board provide direction to Administration regarding negotiations with employee groups pursuant to discussion in executive session all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously before we adjourn I would like to remind everybody

108who's watching us at home and here that the next regular board meeting will be held on Thursday March 6 2025 at 6:30 p.m. Mr panta may I have a motion to adjourn I move we adjourn all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay motion passes unanimously we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.