001e e e it's 6:31 and I'd like to call the meeting to order I'd like to call the meeting to order thank you I would ask that everybody rise and please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America God indivisible andice you may I have roll call please Mrs Christensen here Mr panta here Mrs Greenberg here Dr Lim here miss wanie here thank you next on the agenda is approval of agenda Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg governing board cabinet and guests items approved by consent will not come up for discussion during the meeting but will be approved when the agenda is adopted this is possible since members of the governing board receive the agenda along with backup materials at least 24 hours prior
002to the meeting and have time to review and consider all items prior to the agenda being adopted members of the governing board may ask that an item be removed from the consent agenda and brought to the floor for discussion at the appropriate place on the agenda any member of the audience who submitted a blue public card prior to the start of the meeting will be recognized to speak on that agenda item under items for approval I would like to offer the agenda as posted president Greenberg with just a few changes uh due to some governing board questions received regarding School repurposing uh Dr Davis our director of facilities and construction is out of town and unavailable to answer those questions therefore I recommend we remove items F12 f-13 and F22 and add them to a
003future meeting for discussion Andor approval thank you Dr Reynolds prior to the meeting we received we'll say eight uh blue public comment cards and each speaker will have three minutes to remark on a specific agenda item will be recognized to speak under items for approval um and because we received those these items will also be moved from consent um to the approval so that would be F15 F16 F18 F21 and F2 4 and that was F5 16 18 21 and 24 does any member of the governing board wish to have an item removed from the consent agenda Mrs Christensen I want to remove item f8 from the consent agenda okay so f8 will be moved to the approval agenda does any other board member have any other item they wish to move reference poent Greenberg
004if something's already been pulled by a comment card do we need to request that again no it's it's been moved anybody else and obviously members of the public asked for these um so all of those items will be moved after what is already on the approval agenda and then we'll take them in order of the numbers they were under the uh consent agenda um Mr panta may have motion to approve the meeting agenda and recommended consent agenda items president Greenberg someone out there has their hand up I don't know if you saw that I just wanted to point that out but I do move that we approve the agenda as modified thank you all those in favor please say I I all those opposed please say nay any extensions the motion passed Mage unanimously next
005on the agenda is governing board statements U Mr panta do you have anything thank you president Greenberg hello everyone I'm glad you're all here um I'm going to take a point of personal privilege here and wish my wife who's watching online happy birthday tonight honey okay yeah and make sure you save me at least a bite of that that birthday cake when I get home please so speaking of bites how many people got their Girl Scout cookies bought yet right this is a tough time of year for me you talk about the holidays no this is the time because I have to show much restraint I I do like the sweets and I have to pce myself because I don't want to buy all my cookies from one person because I have so many former
006students who now have students of their own they remember oh Mr Panter is a soft touch we always like to get you know a couple boxes from him so I got to spread the wealth wealth and get from wherever I can and speaking of bites um I to many of those things sometimes and that's why it's good to run just last Saturday we had the uh Fun Run the 5K the 15th I believe uh annual fun run which is a lot of exercise and a lot of people showed up almost 600 were there this year it's great to see people they come out with their uh you see your colleagues but you see your colleagues with their families and you maybe you see your students but you see your students with their families everybody's there
007together it's a chance to talk and and uh share with each other they even had a wellness Fair there so another opportunity for all of us to be more healthy as we we uh be in Ed our in education once again I came in first of all the board members so I got my streak going yeah thanks one guy back um it's just wonder and tomorrow I'm going to be at Eagle Ridge they have their annual dance that they do this time of year their PTSA I need a Volunteers in my old school so I went I'm going there tomorrow it's what we do here we have all these ways for us to communicate with each other and to understand each other because it makes that process of education and learning that much easier when
008we live in an atmosphere of trust uh safety we know each other I guess I like our schools like I like my coffee warm Rich inviting and Ice free so that's what I'm looking forward to very much to tomorrow and that concludes my comments thank you Mr panta Dr Lim all right I'm going to take a little Personal Privilege too here and I'm going to take a moment to highlight the teacher students and parent engagement around our dual immersion program at Whispering Winds Academy which our is our Mandarin immersion program just this past weekend our third and fourth graders um from miss van and uh Go's classroom performed at the Chinese New Year celebration at Desert Ridge it was a great opportunity for not only them to celebrate the culture of the language they are
009learning but also demonstrating those skills they've been learning speaking mandrin um while also our parents came not only to bring their students there but they also spent time engaging the community by hosting a table um spreading the importance of this program and helping the community and potentially future students of Whispering Winds Academy um know that this is available right here in pvusd um I want to send a big shout out and thank you to the student staff and parents for taking time out of your weekend to do this and if you're a little sad that you missed this showcase this past weekend please join us tomorrow um at 6 pm at PV High School where Whispering Winds and myself we'll be hosting the annual Chinese New Year celebration in collaboration with the amazing staff at
010Whispering Winds who have been working hard to put this event together so hopefully we'll see you at 6 pm tomorrow at PV high school thank you Dr L Mrs Christenson good evening everyone I just want to welcome welcome all the wonderful faculty staff parents and community members that are here today and I will save my comments for later in the meeting because we have a lot to discuss today and um I just want to welcome you and thank you for coming today thank you Mrs Christensen miss m good evening everyone um so you you all heard it from Mr panta himself so if you still have Girl Scouts that need some buyers of cookies I think we know where to send them um yeah uh so I I just want to kind of piggyback a
011little bit off of governing board member panta said and um just say what a wonderful opportunity it was to come together as a whole Community the entire District we don't get a lot of those opportunities we're a very large District um at the community fundr run um it's something I have looked forward to just as a parent in this District over and over and over again um and it always kind of makes me pause and reflect and think about how lucky we are that we have such a diverse and wonderful Community I wish we had more opportunities to kind of like all come together uh as one District um and I just want to kind of take a second and reflect on the importance of community community is why I got involved in um volunteering
012and in our schools in the first place um Community I think is where we as human beings go in times of uncertainty and Times of fear um and we might not all agree on all things all the time but I I think that that's probably something that everyone in this room has in common is that we believe in community that's why we're all here whether we're attending you know as a community member or a parent or a staff member a governing board member um and in that vein um when things are uncertain and when there's change that's a scary time and we need to be able to lean on community the thing that we're all also here for are our students um and so I will just hope and and kind of put out to
013this room and and hope it ripples sort of out there that you know our students um our students need to feel safe in order to learn our students need to feel supported um and I know and believe in this community um that we will rally around our students and make sure that we are supporting them we are doing everything that we can to make them feel safe or the adults that's our job um so just a reminder again no matter what our differences are kids deserve to be safe and they need to feel safe to learn um and so let's let's hold that tight as we sort of like navigate all the things and all the policy which I'm here for don't get me wrong right I mean that's that's what we're here that's what
014we're here to do um but at the end of the day none of this matters if our kids don't feel safe so um thank you all for for being here and for being a part of this community and I appreciate all of you thank you Miss wanie um I think everybody has said just about everything but I I also want to just uh give a shout out um in regard to the fundr run it was incredible once again I want to thank everybody um on staff who played a role in putting it together and we had a lot of great volunteers I think mostly from Horizon but um some other uh schools as well and uh it once again you know it did bring our community together and I appreciate that we have continued to
015do this over 15 years and look forward to the next 15 and thank you you all for being here so next on the agenda is Awards and recognitions Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg I would like to invite the board to join me in front of the Das good evening president Greenberg governing board members members of cabinet and attendees both inperson and virtual tonight we have three actually tonight we have several recognitions to share with you this evening we'll be inviting our honores to the front of the room for their recognition and photo so when your name is called please come to the front of the room our first honor tonight is the proud recipient of the Arizona Association of gifted and talented gifted education teacher of the year award this Honore demonstrates an exceptional
016understanding of giftedness and aligns educational experiences with the unique needs and talents of her students she positively impacts the social emotional well-being of students and families and goes above and beyond in her commitment to differentiation enrichment and Equitable practices for gifted students please help me welcome from mountaint Trail Middle School and pvhs uniquely gifted Karen h Hudson our next recognition is the recipient of the Paradise Valley education association's Rec nition of Professional Standards award for teachers the honory this evening will be introduced by Miss Heather Schmidt pvea president good evening president Greenberg Dr Reynolds governing board and cabinet my name is Heather Schmidt I'm proud to be the president of the Paradise Valley Education Association and once a month I get to do my favorite thing and recognize one of my colleagues uh and give
017them their props as in professionals recognizing other professionals success tonight I am honored to recognize Elizabeth Warner the gifted program Mentor as the recipient of the February 2025 pvea props again I've started a trend this year I have three nominations for Miss Warner um from Karen Bowden Amy Bolan boach and Dr Karen Hudson uh Miss Bowden said Elizabeth is an integral part of the gifted Department she always has time to help with an issue give advice or meet with parents no matter what else is going on you always feel like are a priority when reaching out to Elizabeth her knowledge of the gifted Community is vast and she knows how to guide teachers parents and students whenever an issue arrives or guidance is needed this is a rare quality and makes our department run more
018efficiently from Dr Hudson um I have had the pleasure and opportunity of working with Mrs Warner for the past six years as she developed a solid base of support at multiple schools for students in our gifted program including our twice exceptional or two students under her Direction toe students parents staff members and I have all greatly benefited from her knowledge and expertise to collaboratively build best practices for our students what has particularly impressed me over the years is her leadership ability to understand and identify the needs of gifted students and their staff strengths and collaboratively implement the vision of Highly Successful programs unique to PV including journey and Quest and from Miss bolbach uh Elizabeth is a true gift to the gifted Community her unwavering dedication to her staff is truly inspiring she generously shares
019her time ideas and res resources creating a supportive and collaborative environment she's always accessible making herself available to her team at all hours stop that uh demonstrating a genuine commitment to their growth and success I have to admit I've called and texted on weekends late at night and early in the morning and she always happily responds to offer support her leadership Fosters that culture of excellence and empowers individuals to reach their full potential Elizabeth encourages us the gifted teacher team to reach for more share strengths and to keep learning I've never felt as supported as I have since joining the gifted team and that is largely due to Elizabeth and from pvea and all of these gifted teachers we should all be so lucky to have an Elizabeth Warner on our team congratulations Elizabeth e
020thank you for the chance to thank my family my gifted team if they all stand they are amazing people to work with um my mom is here this evening and my husband Dave my daughter Shay who is a PB grad and my wonderful son-in-law Connor and my sweet granddaughter Joan next is the Paradise Valley education support professional of the month PVA president Miss Michelle Courtright is here to make the presentation um president Greenberg governing board Dr Reynolds and cabinet my name is Michelle Courtright and I will have the pleasure of being the president of the Paradise Valley support employees Association and um I get to once a month recognize a very very special person in our district and this month we are recognizing Becky Carson she is an administrative assistant for support student student services
021and she is one of a growing trend of administrative assistants who serve not one but two administrators and I was reminded by every single person that nominated her that the people that she talks to on the phone are not calling to let us know we are doing a wonderful job they are often heightened in some way and I am hearing that even though she has not been with us very long she has a way of managing those challenging often confrontational phone calls with a calmness and Grace she is positive she has a professional demeanor that ensures that every parent staff and Community member that calls feels heard and supported and almost all of them either on the phone or that walk through our reception area are calmer and happier when they leave which is exactly
022what we want her remarkable work ethic her patient her organizational skills consistently impress those around her making her a model of outstanding customer service in PB USD so it is with pleasure that we recognize um Becky Carson this month thank you first and foremost I want to thank everybody especially everybody that's here I see a bunch of Familiar Faces tonight um I want to thank my husband who has you know been here for everything my mom who is the second in our three generation of pvusd employees my dad my wonderful bosses who are both here tonight my friends Darlene Susie Morgan and more everybody um thank you so much I've been here for such a short amount of time and this is unbelievable thank you our final recognition this evening will be presented by principal
023Shelley strus member of the Paradise Valley principals Association Mrs stroes will be presenting the administrators celebrated for excellence and support or Aces award this quarterly recognition highlights administrators and their accomplishments I will say Becky you are quite friendly because I often call and I'm like oh stuff is hitting the fan and she's like hi and then I'm like okay it's fine like everything's gonna be fine so congrats okay it's so true um good evening president Greenberg governing board members Dr Reynolds cabinet and guests um I'm Shelley stopus filling in for our sick president Alysa tonight but it's my great honor to stand before you tonight representing an incredible group of leaders the principles and vice principls of PB schools we would like to recognize one of our leaders for the aces award administrators celebrated for
024excellence and support while many principles and assistant principles were nominated we would like to celebrate Michelle Fowler her colleague Tammy deia shared it is with the utmost admiration that I nominate Michelle for the prestigious Aces award Mrs fower is not only an exceptional leader but also an inspiring colleague who makes the challenges of this role feel more manageable through her unwavering dedication and support her creativity and commitment to her staff are evident in the countless ways she uplifts and appreciates them through Innovative initiatives and heartfelt gestures of gratitude Mrs Fowler Fosters a positive collaborative environment where her team feels valued motivated and empowered to succeed Mrs Fowler's deep care for her students shines through in everything she does she exemplifies what it means to put students first ensuring they receive the academic social and emotional
025support they need to thrive even in the face of challenges she remains approachable listening with empathy and addressing difficult situations with wisdom and Grace her staff deeply respects and admires her consistently expressing how supported they feel under her leadership Mrs fow's ability to cultivate a culture of trust positivity and Excellence enables her team to focus on what matters most helping students reach their fullest potential Michelle is an extraordinary principal whose passion kindness and Leadership leave a lasting impact on her students staff and colleagues she approaches her work with a smile and an infectious energy that inspires everyone around her making her truly deserving of this Honor on behalf of the Paradise Valley principles we honor Michelle Fowler as a true leader congrats for all right change us up falling down all right my husband is
026at home cheering me on today but I would like to thank my PVP family in the back I appreciate that and especially tamy um said very lovely things so thank you Tammy all right thank you that's it and that President Greenberg concludes this evening's Awards and recognitions e thank you all next on the agenda is superintendent's comments Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg or should I say newly Grandma Greenberg very exciting there are lots of pictures up here if you'd like to stay after she's absolutely willing to show them uh I also want to give a shout out uh to the entire district for just an amazing 5K that we held over the weekend our benefits team just did an extraordinary job and uh uh it's such a wonderful event and an opportunity for us
027to come together and celebrate as a community uh in PB schools we engage Inspire and nurture students through high quality instruction meaningful educational opportunities and dynamic learning experiences one of those opportunities is our District's partnership with westm and Paradise Valley Community College PV schools has partnered with pvcc and West Mech to offer students in grades 9 through 12 access to tuition free college programs where they can earn high school credit that count towards graduation and college credits these programs are offered during the school day and include clinical data Esports EMT and paralal TV schools wants to help prepare your child for the future career uh to learn more or how to apply please contact your school's counselor graduation this is hard to say but graduation is quickly approaching and the College and Career department is
028is here to help you and your family navigate the next steps explore postsecondary Pathways options with your senior by attending our comprehensive College and Career 101 night this event is specifically designed for students with IEPs or a 504 plan and will explore all the unique opportunities that will support your child's future this is a virtual event that will be held on Thursday February 20th from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. and will be hosted through Google meet graduation will be here before you know it and PV schools wants to encourage you to take advantage of this important night that will positively impact your child's future for more information please contact our College and Career department on Monday February 24th the College and Career department is also offering an in-person districtwide senior fa FAFSA night to support senior
029students and families seeking guidance on completing their 2025 FASA forms the event will occur at North canyan High School from 5:30 to 7:30 and registration is required as a reminder all contributors must create their FASA IDs prior to the event and parents please bring your 2023 tax documents and a laptop for more information please contact the College and Career department and Grandma Greenberg that concludes my comments I'm G to have to get used to that thank you Dr Reynolds uh next on the agenda are items for approval the first is um consideration of I'm sorry of new mou uh to the ESP bargain agreement and I will turn it over to Dr Holmes to give us some more you thank you madam president members of the board as you are aware the transportation department is
030stretched very thin with respect to Staffing as such daily attendance in the department is incredibly important and with that in mind we're asking your approval of an of an attendance incentive that's hard to say those two words together uh an attendance incentive for those in the department critical of the transportation of students uh We've outlined the details in theou attached to this agenda item and I will share that I did work with Michelle Courtright P sea president to to develop this I'm happy to answer oh and she supports that's important she supports uh and I'm happy to answer any questions you may have thank you Dr Holmes um may I please have a motion to approve the new mou to the education support professional ESP bargaining agreement with PB sea for 2024 as presented Mr
031panta so moved does any board member have any comments Mrs Christensen thank you grma g excuse me president Greenberg I do have a question um answer to both okay um so I thank you for this I I really appreciate that I do have a question regarding CDLs because it's my understanding that when somebody applies to be a bus driver then we help them with their CDL do do does the district pay for that or do the individual applying for the job pay for that is that so other companies May charge for a CDL but we have an in-house trainer so it's not like there's a a charge or a billing that would happen for it but we do maintain an in-house trainer to be able to do that usually takes somewhere from four to six
032weeks thank you uh the reason I'm asking that question is because I'm I was just trying to think of other ways for in to incentivize people to stay longer because it was it's my understanding that um I'm not sure if it's happening in our district but in other districts they will get a CDL and then they will Happ in here they will drive for Waste Management or somebody else and then they make a lot more money and so I was thinking is there a way to have in in business what we generally do is is have something where you have to be here at least six months or a year otherwise that gets revoked I don't know if that's even legal so I'm just asking the question is that another way that we can incentivize
033are wonderful bus drivers to stay longer uh yes thank you it is it is legal it's something Dr Holmes and I have briefly discussed and we'll probably be discussing further thank you does anybody else have any comments questions just just really I just so thank you for this you know program um and thank you to U Michelle court right for um you know coming to the table and and working with everyone on this I I just have one question which is um was there like conversations with um with the drivers or a way of kind of gathering ideas about what might speak to them and is that did this kind of come from that I'm just sort of curious sure I you know the primarily the conversations were between uh Brandon George uh the um
034director of the department uh myself Michelle Courtright Jill beran um and of course that's with a lot of knowledge that you know we understand that pay is incredibly important um as expressed by members of the department um on a regular basis um so this is an effort to meet that interest in the department anybody else Miss Dr limb so piggybacking off of that question are we then going to be tracking if this incentive actually is increasing the the absentee rate of our drivers or if this is if this actually does have a positive impact to keep our drivers coming to work on a regular are we going to keep track of that okay does anybody else have any thoughts comments questions uh seeing none um all those in favor please say I I I any
035opposed please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is acceptance of gifts and donations we are incredibly grateful I signed lots of letters today um would like to highlight some of the donations we received suntech concrete gave Campa belloo Elementary nearly $2,000 for classroom supplies and furniture for second grade Dorito Partners gave $1,000 to Echo Mountain intermediate for uh prizes or their caught being kind store um Angel and Jeff K Kus kudus I apologize I'm mispronouncing gave $155,000 to Echo Mountain Primary for various classrooms and staff um Azo central campus gave $5,000 each to Greenway Middle School and Paradise Valley high school as well um so thank you to all of the donors um and your incredible generosity to our students staff and schools and um Mr panta may have a
036motion to accept gifts and donations please move does any board member have any comments questions seeing none all those in favor please say I all those opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda are the items that were previously on the consent agenda so the first is what was f8 so I'm sorry I'm working off of two different agendas here to make sure I grab everything um so this is consideration approval of resolution number 571 in agreement with the Arizona Board of regions for and on behalf of Na and pvusd and um I will turn it over to miss copen to give us thank you president Greenberg governing board members our uh district has partnered with the educational technology Consortium for over 10 years uh this is a 5-year renewal agreement
037that allows our district to participate uh in a Consortium that's led by the na uh Northern Arizona University uh it provides us access to high quality uh customized data Integrity tools and auditing report services for State ADM funding uh by joining this Consortium our district benefits from exclusive tools that are not commercially available we access tools to ensure accurate reconciliation of reported data to the a ad and throughout our me through our membership and to the Consortium these tools become available to us at a modest cost and greatly improve funding accuracy and compliance uh we recommend approval of this agreement and I am happy to answer any questions and Mr Billings is also here tonight to answer any questions thank you Miss copen uh Mr panta may have a motion to approve sorry getting back
038to it um resolution number 571 in agreement with the Arizona Board of regions or on behalf of Northern Arizona University and Paradise Valley Unified School District so moved does any member have any comments or questions Miss Christensen thank you for that update um you answered a little bit of my first question but I'm going to go ahead and ask it anyway I uh my first question was what's the purpose of this agreement and what are the benefits to Paradise Valley Unified so you did mention we will be utilizing them and they we will be we will have access to tools that would un be unavailable to us presid agree Mrs Chris yes that is correct okay what other what other benefits to Paradise Valley would be um included M christon the Consortium offers um a
039variety of services we really use one service um which is what I mentioned about um the tool that helps us uh reconcile our data okay uh to create greater greater accuracy around our funding and what we're reporting to ad okay um is this solely a Personnel resource concern or is it an economic as well in addition to the tool that you mentioned so is it both that we're doing this to turn that to Mr billing that was a question I I wasn't sure um what was being asked there but I think he might help us good evening and congratulations on the grandma I'm a I'm a new Grandpa and it's phenomenal yes ma'am uh the question specifically um what happens in in Arizona is that every year there's changes to funding like there's been some
040big changes for instance in the for C Ted J CTE type funding right these are very rapid and have to be integrated in fact funding has gotten transactional almost on a daily basis right um all of that's good but the changes in the law need to be rapidly implemented uh because Miss Bergan holds me accountable for making sure the data has Integrity it's accurate and we're getting all the funding we should get so it's kind of a combination of speed skill set for the price I can't beat it you know and and they're the only ones in Arizona that do it so do we have somebody in the house that does that because it was my understanding I looked at the list there's a a large list of other districts that are going to come
041on to this Consortium but I didn't see our largest District which is Mesa and it's my understanding that they have somebody that writes grants and they do these types of things in-house so they have a full-time person that's all they do is that one of the considerations why uh we're not doing that inh house yeah or organiz Mesa as you know is much larger in enrollment um the Mesa also has uh they've got quite a culture of having quite a bit more a much larger even on a per student basis uh ratio than our it department has right we're lean and mean and agile and I don't have an issue with that uh but not the mean part I'm trying to improve but um the they've consistently over the last couple of decades have had
042a a very heavy development software development cycle they're fun they used to develop their own student information system though they no longer do that they couldn't keep up with the changes uh and they use a different student information system than we do my final question um well just a comment I wish I could be more lean and less mean as well so thank you for that um will will na be doing the rfps for all of those individuals districts because it it just seems like a big burden on na or is this not new is that what I'm understanding they're already doing this because sorry and and as required by procurement law for all these districts list on page seven you could put an RFP but nobody does it until a business steps up and
043develops it so that we can procure it through an RFP process that's where we're at and believe me I thought about it but I I just don't have the desire I like public education right now so uh rather than being an entrepreneur which I used to be thank you for answering all my questions thank you thank you does any other member of the board have any questions or comments on this item uh seeing none all those in favor please say I I I I all those opposed please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda was former F15 so that is uh consideration to approve purchase from current District contract uh 2202 PV for interactive display flat panels Miss copen president greenber governing board members uh the purchase of new line boards
044is afforded to our district through Bond funding and we are grateful that these funds allow us to invest um in things that align with voter approved bonds specified expenditures and supports the district committed to modernizing classroom technology and enhancing learning experiences for our students uh the boards were selected through the collaborative work of our information technology committee uh this purchase also includes support uh for teachers through training we are requesting approval for the new line board's purchase and again I'm happy to answer any questions and Mr Billings is available also thank you Miss copen we have one public comment card um on this Wendy merer you'll have three minutes good evening president Greenberg school board members and blinking on your positions cabinet um I'm a former parent with the child in the district and a
045current Community member and taxpayer if you could please help me understand why the district wants to spend $3 million on 496 flat panel displays with Bond and also how it came to be that this is a new classroom standard so that means each one of these roughly cost $6,450 per panel the bond was sold to the public to maintain the schools such as the AC units and not create new classroom standard of flat screens so four students can project their screens at this cost the district has just closed schools and went to the voters to pass a bond measure due to declining enrollment also while facing a 14 million budget deficit and are expecting the taxpayers to pay back this $3 million spend through our property taxes moreover tonight later on you'll be proposing to
046rebuild Indian Bend and spending 1 million on bathrooms to move a preschool to one of the closed School may I please ask why these flat panels are necessary why now and why is this a new classroom standard personally I'd also like to know is this going to raise proficiency levels that our students are currently at will this get them to at grade level how are you to planning on Distributing these 496 panels are you planning on dividing up equally between all of our schools in the district is it possible since these are on they will be on mobile carts that if you do plan on voting on this maybe you could amend it to have only one or two per School these are 7 foot panels and will these all need to be replaced within
047seven years so this will be an ongoing spend every seven years because that's when the warranty will expire and we know how technology is it changes all the time in conclusion I would please ask that you vote no or amend on these $3 million spend and be fiscally responsible to your property owners and Community thank you thank you Mr panta may I have a motion to approve uh purchase from from current District contract 222 PV for interactive display flat panels so moved does any member of the board have any comments or questions Miss wanie um I have a question so this is 496 I think is this for the purchase of 496 of them is that correct um so do we have classrooms right now that have these boards in our district Mrs wanted yes
048okay um and so is this was this sort of like a plan then to to phase in so that we can ensure that all classrooms are sort of operating in the same standard and have the same resources this that is correct this is going to be replacing like the LCD projector and screens that have become very um expensive to maintain and outdated okay and do we have a sense of the lifespan on on these look at that he might need a seat here from now on I don't know he might just need to stay up there yes uh sorry um yes ma'am uh they every technology and not just digital technology has a lifespan cars air conditioners computers uh the object is to get where we're moving into now and this also I'll I'll try
049to be quick um but um the the object is to maintain it as long as we can to get maximum value uh uh out of it uh we push the limit in PV um it's now becoming a little more dynamical with cyber security and you know we have to keep things updated Opera these are computers with a very large display and audio speakers right so we have to manage it we have to secure it and we run it as long as the operating system can stay with us these are based on Android 14 currently and um so to answer the immediate question I think was lifespan yeah like just I mean I know it's hard to you know I don't expect you to say oh five years and then we you know but just a
050we've been using them I assume other districts use them do we have just a sense of like how how long we've been able to keep them you know in use I would say any computational device today seven to 10 years is probably maxed out and that's primarily because of cyber security anymore you know it can't keep up with the security updates and the operating system and the vendors I'm sorry uh but I came from a corporate world but um it's planned obsolescence you know they're going to move you forward right one way or another so um I hope that answers your question it does thank you thank you yeah thank you and then I think my next question I just have one more um for for Mrs beran um I think uh so and and
051thank you because you did sort of talk about how this is in line with you know the the voter approved uses and so to sort of expand on that Mrs beran I know that when um you know there's when the when the district is sort of trying to decide and do their homework around you know do we need to go out do we want to go out for a bond um I know you all do your homework and there's you know committee with with stakeholders correct and as part of that committee do you discuss things like you know what's on the list what are you know what are what are we what are we looking to sort of accomplish and what would be the estimated budget for those kinds of items Mrs wani yes we
052do that and Technology was included in that okay and then this specifically has like did this come up in conversation with like as a at that time as a as a possibility two years ago yeah I presume so I know that he's had this in his plan um that all of these pieces when he provided his estimate for the bond uh were were part of his plan and what he was intending uh for the use of the proceeds of bond sales and then specifically in the voter pamphlet that was shared with or mailed to every member who lives in this community there was a line for furniture fixture technology and equipment so that was advertised to voters appropriately you've been waiting for this item for a little while planning for it and considering the cost
053of it and incorporating that into the ask that ultimately went to voters and voters approved correct yes ma' and I I can add uh Miss Bergen headed up the bond committee which has community members as well as parents as well as teachers and directors and principls and uh am I forgetting okay um the one um Miss Bergan which I've served on uh three on committees in my tenure here uh she did something that I thought was really interesting she went out to a focus group surveyed focus groups outside of the committee that was community members and what was interesting but consistent was and Miss Bergen drove that into all the committee's heads this is the community speaking right what if you were if we were to go for this how would you like to see
054this money invested notice I say invested right to me that's what education is it's an investment not a cost sorry but that's just my personal the con the top three consistently were number one school safety number two technology and number three modernized every buy I'm doing or asking you to do has to have at least two and preferably three uh of those components or why are we doing it we're not listening to the community if we're not doing that so that's not good in business when you don't listen to your customers kind right so this these boards meet all three of those criteria and I can go into that a little bit deeper if you want I mean I could do this all day but I'll give my colleagues an opportunity sorry does any other
055member of the board Dr so I'm going to take it away from you we're going to head back over here to uh Jean copen um so my question is actually around it sounds like we do have smartboards in place the these smart devices are already in place in some of our schools so my biggest concern with us rolling out something like this is one how has the staff reception been to these devices in those classrooms and is that training sufficient we know devices like this are not any use to us in the classroom if staff and those who are utilizing them aren't trained appropriately including our students so how is the roll out going with that how is the reception that kind of stuff yeah Dr Lim thank you for asking that question yes um
056training is a critical part of this roll out and we have included that in the purchasing agreement so that um we will be including that uh we did pilot these um actually the school showed great interest in them initially and um used some of their dual enrollment funding to put these in teachers classrooms before we were considered ing them um they Incorporated the training we did study that a little when teachers had um adequate training uh we saw about a 80% usage uh compared to those who did not um so it it is critical that they get the the training and that is part of the rollout plan great and extending on that what was the age group that we piloted what what grades were we piloting these in have we gone all the way
057down or is there what's the goal for these smartboards in what space I might rely on um Mr for this I know High School uh put them in initially with dual enrollment funding so we definitely had them in yeah I want I want to add to and clarify something we um smartboards is a brand name okay uh for interactive large screen devices um so we've had smartboards in this District we tried it pilot at a school number of years back we've had U some p Sonic uh and we've tried to Pilot Dell Intel as a kind of an interesting uh the uptick wasn't the up it didn't they didn't take right and what we found is that if you professionally develop you get about an 85% uptick if you don't it's about 15% if you
058say here's a board please use it doesn't work right so these are things we've learned over the years which sometimes is decades but that's another subject but uh the the schools Miss copen is absolutely correct the schools drove the initial of this is the board right this is the tool we want and I have to thank Miss Shelly in the background back there uh a principal at Horizon uh was very instrumental in in doing this so they kind of drove this and then it got into What's called the information technology committee which is a big Committee of all stakeholders do we want to do this do we not want to do this is the right board how are we going to integrate it what kind of professional development how do we secure it how you
059know all of this kind of thing and they also set the deployment plan which goes specifically to your question it was we didn't we're not going to force any down a teacher's throat doesn't work right so there's an actual four-year plan they've got four years to get used to what the community is telling us modernize use technology right and school safety on top of that so the initial deployment plan was teacher Choice first come first serve it was spread across the Spectrum okay U gifted special ed K12 you name it so does that answer the question sorry TR to I had a challenge that's the upcoming plan of how the deployment we're going to follow that same model because that was the model the ITC that that's what they reached consensus on that's their model
060which is that Community stakeholder committee I do have other questions but I can defer to any okay so um so talking on that you did mention special ed classrooms so the other concern I had about these boards is as a district have we began to think about that interactive boards aren't always best for all of our Learners sometimes they actually can marginalize some of our Learners who may not do well with technology in the classroom so are we putting measures in place and making sure they're going to be protection so that Learners who are are negatively impacted by this being in that space we're accounting for that and we're supporting these students appropriately so we don't marginalize kids in the classroom because they don't benefit from having this in the room it's actually a detriment
061to their learning uh yes ma'am we listen to the teachers we listen to the programs we adjust we adapt we're lean mean and we adapt not not not so mean but uh so we have to listen to those experts what's happening in the classro it's a continuous loop right so that's why it's a four-year plan we keep learning and learning and learning each year and adjusting there it's a multimodal sensorial it's you know those who can hear better than see those who can see better than here those who want interactive touch and then there are some if this a distraction absolutely you don't want you don't want to impact learning like I'm not a good reader I have to have that's just me that's the way I learn I'm visual I think the answer to
062your question was yes okay yes but I want I I just want to take that a little bit further and ask so what are we going to do in our schools that have say low numbers so we know some of our schools are down to you know only one or they're down to two classrooms and for example it was spring winds Academy we have the dual immersion then we have the full English Learners who are who are doing everything in English so what happens when we have Learners that are in specialized programs that are not benefiting from these in the classroom so what are we going to do in those schools where we don't really have a place to say move a student out of a space where that device is we don't want to
063force students into a special ed classroom that may not benefit to be in a special ed classroom if it's not there like what plans do we have in place that are not just pushing the student out of the space that they're comfortable in say the classroom that they're in or a program they're in because this device is present in their room that question is better answered by somebody other than me I will do what my boss and bosses tell me so you know I'll Implement from there Dr L I'll try to answer your question we we don't anticipate that that will be a large amount of students and of course for those kids we'll make those adjust ments um these boards have a very um High sensory piece to them they're the visuals are Way
064Beyond what we can do with LCD projectors and what we currently have so we anticipate that um all students will be able to see curriculum better from every seat in the classroom um they have great Audi auditory features to help kids hear like our videos that are embedded in our curriculum um their touch screen so they can um actually do activities um so they're interactive so we anticipate um specifically with students that might have some challenges that this might even benefit them um and give them more than what we're currently giving them with our technology that's providing this in their classroom and do we have data to actually back that up or is that just a gut feeling that we're hoping it's going to help these Learners like do we have actual academic data showing
065because these interactive boards are not new they they are present do we have data showing that these are benefiting those Learners not hard ing those Learners so Dr I'll I'll answer that I don't I don't have like an official study in front of me but um some of our characteristics that we're aspiring for for portrait of a graduate um do include a lot of College and Career ready skills and we know that our kids are bound for technology so the more we incorporate this in their learning experiences throughout their schooling with us uh we feel the better we are preparing them for what they're going to encounter in either postsecondary or the workforce so I think they have those benefits especially um to cite specific academic achievement I I don't have that in right in
066front of me yeah I I think I'm less concerned about them learning to use the technology I think our kids learn just fine how to use the technology it's more of this is now another bright shiny thing in the classroom that feels like it might take away from the learning process especially for students that might be neurodiverse or have high sensory issues these are high sensory devices that feels like May marginalize these students who have sensory issues and now there's a huge bright shiny object in their room that may be actually impacting their sensory issues in a negative way instead of a positive way less about them learning to use the technology and more about that small population of students not getting marginalized because this is something we've rolled out in every space in our
067schools Dr Li do you have any other questions com I think that was all of my questions Mrs Christensen did you yeah I would like to thank the board members wannie and Dr Lim for their thoughtful questions and making my job a little easier because you asked some a lot of my questions um but I still have lots of Mars so um so 496 screens that's a little over 10 per school what school specific spefic are they going in all the schools is my understanding or have we targeted certain schools it's still using the itc's recommendation it's a a first come first serve kind of a a roll out who's most in adoption is you have to have the end user you know so when they're ready if they're not ready yet if we have
068a teacher who's not ready or a classroom of students who are not ready or whatever there it's a four-year plan we're trying to in order to serve the community who you know uh school safety technology and and uh modernize right so it's a four-year implementation plan we're not going to force Any teacher on it are they you know they got four years to to see their their colleagues use it are they getting more comfortable this kind of adoption type thinking with the answer to that question I'm a little bit concerned about some of our um title schools and um so Palomino for instance I know that there's a lot of uh Latinos in Palamino that are struggling with language itself and if our Educators who are amazing at helping them Bridge the language Gap and
069also learn how are they going to manage this new technology so I fear that these Technologies are all going to go to our schools like greyhawk and Pinnacle Peak and the high schools and then the title schools may be left out if you're because it doesn't sound like you have a solid rollout plan yet it's first come for serve so four-year plan uh and I haven't found that with palominos in particular they're very embracing of Technology very much so uh so I I don't know I I don't have the numbers in the back of my head what schools took you know got got in first and what schools are in second the principles would know that better than I miss Christianson from what I'm seeing I think there's enthusiasm throughout the district we have several
070teachers kind of chomping at the bit to get uh these tools in their classroom and I do want to say that it is a tool it does not replace any of our valuable teaching um it is a tool that enhances our curriculum enhances what the teachers are doing in the classroom um but we have several teachers from all schools that are very interested one of the pieces is they will have to receive training before they get their board that's kind of the the deal is that they have to be trained on the board before we we install it or roll it into their classroom so we have a lot of teachers that are willing to take that on they're they um value this tool for their students they are embracing technology um and they know
071what it can do and how it can enhance their instruction so I'd say there's enthusiasm throughout the district not in specific places so having heard that response I'm I'm I'm a little bit worried about burdening our Educators because it seems like we get new curriculum pretty much every other year and um I know there's a lot on their plates and we really ask our Educators to do a lot and it seems like if it's a volun on a volunteer basis that the roll out may not be very smooth if we're just you know asking for volunteers but I I just I'm concerned about burdening our Educators um has not come up in any of the conversations Miss Christian we're always concerned about that balance um from the observations I've done in classrooms our LCD projectors
072and screens um are not not adequate for what they want to do a lot of people want to do they're becoming very outdated if you have 30 students in a classroom it's sometimes difficult to see um I think teachers are excited about what this is going to bring um to the classroom um as far as the the burden I think that the training is um it it's integrated into it's not like you sit in a classroom and you you know it's going to be integrated into them using it every day the more they use it um the more they'll uh learn about it I think that uh there are teachers that this is second nature to them they're looking for these tools a lot of our uh teachers that are coming out of college are
073looking for these type of tools in our classrooms because this is how they learned I realized the other day that some of our teachers were born in 2000 2001 um so even our teachers are pushing us with technology um and striving to keep up uh with what is going to be required of our students outside of of when they leave us in the 12th grade I know our district talks a lot about um Equitable practices I I prefer to talk about fairness and it doesn't seem fair that not because it doesn't sound like that's enough for everybody to go around and every teacher that may want one not on and so how are we addressing if we have so many teachers that want this but are they sharing these are they staying in one I
074was reading in the details that we may put some in hallways that gives me pause I don't know if that was just a random thing but would we put them in hallways um there's two reasons at some of our high schools um it's a digital signage it's to make sure they remember to get some sleep tonight because you got test tomorrow we got a football you know it's that kind of thing now that that is not some that school decided okay what we're trying to get to is a standard so we don't have this for this and this for that and and then come to the it department and say manage this and secure it for us right it you have to get to a standard to be able to measure and Improvement if you
075got all over the place it's hard to measure Improvement so the for instance uh that can be sent with morning announcements messaging uh you know if a school wants it the other thing once we go to the standard and I want to make sure you understand this is there's this thing called school safety okay so uh this is where these boards really shine okay I know instructionals where everybody's at you know the focus I work for the instructional uh person there uh so uh but there is uh school safety is another thing okay how do we get messages quickly fast clear uh emergency alerts the the the old days of the intercom are it it has to be faster and it has to be consistent and clear and it has to recognize that some kids
076uh don't like loud noises right or they're they have issues with that so you have to do it multi-sensorial being sensitive to who are your view I'm sorry if I'm not using the correct terminology but does does that make sense kind of what I'm saying so that was a lot to digest um with the with all due respect a $6,000 price tag per device for a signage seems very excessive to me and also the speed of sound is faster than a visual display if there's an emergency we have alarm systems in place for school safety in order to sound the alarm for everybody uh understand what that's a Works uh the boards have are there's a thing called capap Community Action protocol and a message can be triggered including the principal can trigger it on
077their phone and we can go to lockdown we can go to uh Str you know uh evacuation yes fire drill is separate it's a separate kind of thing it's manag uh managed and com we have different compliance rules okay a community action protocol is now standard these boards Now integrate communicate Community Action protocol uh natively and I want to point out that the digital signage they're about a third the cost of an interactive board okay that makes sense yes you you indicated that replacing that we're using this to replace the LCD displays with the 7 to 10 year lifespan to me again um that's not an enormous lifespan for such a a large investment in almost $3 million um and Dr Lim brought up a really good question that was on my list as well
078where are the studies or metrics done that says this is going to ra our raise our proficiency levels or is it just a new shiny object so I I did have that concern as well so thank you for asking that question uh I go back to what the uh focus groups of the bond Committee of the community said school safety technology modernized that's what they wanted the money invested in I will try to do that as delicately as I can and incorporating all three of those uh but the ball gamees changed in school safety as as you well know I'm sure uh and it has to be consistent reliable multimodal fast and clear the object is to reach every I don't want to get into the details okay um so so I I do like
079that I I do like your U top three safety and modernization and I can't not mine school safety technology modern technology and modernization I do like that however we have to balance that with fiscal responsibility and I do appreciate that this is Bond money and that the voters approved this but we still have to look at expenditures even when it's Bond money this is taxpayer dollars and would would the taxpayers be happy about a $6,000 price tag for one device um I don't I don't know so this is the question Dell you mentioned Dell and other vendors did you consider um did you consider price when you were looking at other other vendors and how did that process take place what was the process to determine once yes ma'am once the specifications are defined what
080is it you're looking for what products out there have this capability when the community send a very clear message on school safety the object every device we buy we want to get more value out of it it's not just about price it's value when I can start tapping not only the instructional practices that I'm told we need to tap multimodal and active higher resolution you know this this kind of thing and by the way students computers can be shared on the screen instantly too so you can have up you know like hey Johnny show what you're you're doing to the other students right but so the object becomes how do you integrate systems that's what we're in this is no different than about 20 years ago uh when we had to move from analog phones
081to vo we could not maintain analog systems you're getting very quickly to that point with our current analog speakers they have to go through IP to get the message out and that creates challenges with older technology it's technology I didn't create it I'm just trying to survive in this business like everybody else is thank you I and I do really appreciate answering all all our questions um having heard the discussion and some of the concerns um I moved to table this matter until our next study session so that we can have time to digest all the that was a lot of information and I don't and having it in consent agenda means that I don't think the the taxpayers and community members had a chance to really dive into this so perhaps um I so
082I move to table this item until the next I was trying get a comment in much earlier but someone seems to be dominating all the questions here um my hands been up for a while there were three of us and okay go ahead I've been through many of these roll outs with technology before okay I hear some of the questions and we've had these questions before these things have come up before it is just a tool it's not uh the program is to help us do the program we do what we always do here we use it and adjust adjust it individually for each need as as it occurs these kind of tools give us more uh technology to help us in ways we couldn't be with kids with special needs to do things more
083for them than we could ever in the past and that that's true when we had our computers coming out when we first got computers for all the students um it's it's a dynamic interactive process so if you ask for a specific plan well the plan is interactive who wants them how you going to use them and then okay show us how you them you ask about uh uh student achievement it's like asking about what kind of student achievement uh data for having a kid have a chair in the classroom it's a it's a tool we use it it's it's vital to what we need right now um I'm and so there that is my experience it's been working for our district as far as how we get our students into technology things that they need
084especially when things are work um wearing out and becoming obsolete they need not the same thing but that the thing that's the next stage forward thank you uh there is a motion on the floor to table this item is there a second this is a secondary motion so it would require a second does anybody second the motion seeing none we're back to the motion on the floor does anybody else have any comments or questions Dr Lim so I I think this one goes to jail so clarification um for the approval it may actually go to you as well president Greenberg um so if these dollars have to be spent in a certain amount of time if I understand correctly for the bond dollars so asking for a partial amount for something is not an option
085based on the limit of the bonds or just for clarity to understand like this roll out requires us to approve the entire amount for the number of boards to do the roll out or if this is a four-year plan is there any possibility to approve half of the amount with the plan to approve the other half in two years and splitting up this three million into a 1.5 and a 1.5 I'll let Mrs beran address that but to change the motion would require another motion would require separate motion yeah thank you president Greenberg um Dr Lim I'm not sure I understand your question are you wanting and and I think I actually need just's help in understanding this um is this set one year of four years or is this set to be rolled out
086over four years excuse me uh if the board approves this we'll be about 40% deployment at that point in time so there's 60% more now did that answer your question no no 40% of your total deployment or 40% of this bonds for your rollout 40% of the total deployment Okay so so this this 3 million is already only a portion of that okay so so if there were any changes to the amount it would reduce the number of schools that we can deploy out to um because we're already only able to deploy to 40% that is correct okay are there any other questions or comments Mrs Christensen yes and I and I do appre as I mentioned before I do appreciate every board member's comments on here and I am not monopolizing this conversation we
087had healthy discussion with Miss Lim and and um do I'm sorry Dr Lim and and Miss Swani and um I you know I have an IT background but that was my degree and I do understand the importance I do understand the importance of technology we have to balance that with a lot of the concerns that Dr LM mentioned with um our most vulnerable children sensory issues things of that nature and fiscal responsibility so I I'm not saying I'm against technology I think this is wonderful just my opinion but I just want to ensure that we are using our bond dollars in a way that is going to benefit our students um and that's why I asked for metrics that's why I ask for studies on how it's going to increase academic achievement because if if
088it's not if it's just a fun new toy and we're spending $3 million um then we've wasted $3 million of taxpayer money and I'd just like to jump in and and uh first of all thank uh Mr Billings for being here this evening uh and answering these questions uh Mr Billings is if not the foremost uh leader in K12 uh technology leadership um he's certainly is one of them uh I have every confidence uh that he and the team that he works with the committee that has worked hard uh both a bond committee and a technology committee uh have worked hard to to work through many of these uh issues and questions uh and uh I want to thank you for that work um I'd also just like to make a comment thank you Professor
089Billings um you and I have you know been been at this a while and I agree with everything Dr Reynolds said you are I'm going to say you are the the guru um I also want to say as as a parent of a a student who you know went through school with an IEP and certainly had sensory concerns most of the time um I just want to give a shout out to our Educators who no matter whether something was in his IEP or I know parents who have students with 504s our educators are very sensitive to the needs of our students and I know that if you know you're in a they're in a classroom and um you know realistically they're in a classroom with with a Smartboard now so maybe the graphics aren't as
090good or whatever if they're having a sensory ISS they're having an issue it will be addressed I I have every confidence um that um these will be used again as the tools that they are meant to be um they will provide greater support uh I'm excited I mean we keep talking about wanting our students to be College and Career ready and this is exactly one of those ways we help reach that goal um and uh yeah I find it interesting it's it's many of our educators are expecting this because it's how they learned and they want to be able to reach our students in even greater Ways by using this technology so I do and I appreciate that you've also referred back to the committee and the community so often in terms of ensuring that
091we're reaching the goals and and the information that that our community and the the desires that our community have in terms of how we're using these bound dollars and what we're using them for in terms of technology so I very much appreciate um everybody body's discussions and contributions Mrs Christensen president Greenberg I don't think we address Dr Lim's question about um perhaps making a for her making a motion if she wished for a lower amount I don't I don't I don't know I just want to ensure that every voice is heard on this board and I don't I'm not sure if her um question was addressed properly I think your question was addressed you want to make a motion I I don't want to make a motion thank you um for clarifying that this is
092going to hit 40% of our population and frankly I think trying to hit only 20% is actually doing a disservice to the district so the fact that we're only going to hit 40% with this roll out um means that there is still work to be done um and I appreciate the Insight that this is going to modernize our classrooms and that we have a choice of stick with the old technology and start to replace it or replace it with this new technology um so while I I still have some reservations and some concerns to make sure that if students need accommodations or updates to IEP or 504 as these roll out that we continue to do that among our special educations that would be my only thing um would be that we still consider and
093make sure that we have appropriate measures in place to make sure that our students that don't benefit from being in these spaces have those accommodations made and that we continue to make those accommodations while they're a small fraction of our students they do want to go into the workforce often in different spaces and we just make to make sure they're ready as well thank you does anybody else have any comments or questions I believe we are ready to vote all those in favor please say I I I I all those opposed please say nay any abstentions I abstain because I don't feel I have enough information at this time to make a decision the motion passes four eyes and one exstension next on the agenda is a former consent agenda item F16 is consideration to
094approve purchase from current District contract 2202 PV uh for Dell Windows computers uh Miss copen president greenber governing board this purchase will replace end of life staff computers with new windows-based devices and establish a consistent standard for our St technology the Dell Latitude 7450 computer delivers reliable performance for their daily tasks this purchase also includes 5year accidental damage warranty next business day on-site service and 247 technical support which ensures minimal downtime and sustained productivity uh the information technology committee worked collaboratively to select this device due to its strong alignment with the district's classroom endpoint standards uh we are here for questions and we do request or we do uh request approval for this item thank you Miss copen we have one comment card on this Nicole kwick you'll have three minutes hi thank you um
095president Greenberg uh Dr Reynolds board members cabinet I appreciate the time for the um the comments I have to say when I saw the agenda and I looked through it um I was frankly really sad disappointed and a little angry um not including the million dollars that got removed from the agenda tonight you have about 10 million dollar worth of spending in your consent agenda which meant it was going to pass with no one asking any questions um I know some people said they might have some addition things that they would take off but but as board members I know you're able to take them off of consent ahead of time and so a lot of you guys ran on fiscal responsibility and that you would not be a rubber Stamper and I love the
096healthy debate that you guys just had it was wonderful I would like to see a lot more of it um I think our community deserves it while we passed a 340 million Bond dollar Bond while we still had $120 million in our bond account waiting to be spent we have promised the taxpayers we wouldn't spend it if we didn't need it and what appears to be happening here is an acceleration of spending so that when it comes up on schedule in another three years that you guys can say well look at how much we've spent of course we need more like that's not fair to the taxpayer it's not fair to overspend on things that aren't necessary or pre-sp spend um in order to bump up your numbers of capital spending so I want to
097warn you for that um here's my specific question here speaking of bumping up so we are buying 15500 replacement laptops for staff okay I don't have a problem with buying replacement laptops but these do have a five fiveyear warranty so I would expect them to last at least 5 years and we have 38 00 staff so are we replacing basically half of our staff's laptop all in one year typically you would do a 20% per year so that you're not in five years later when you might not have the capital stuck replacing all of them at once so um I'd like you to consider um reducing that amount thank you so much uh Mr panta may I have a mo motion to approve purchase from current District contract 2202 PV for Dell Windows computers so
098moved uh does any member of the board have any questions or comments Mrs Christensen yeah um Dr Billings Le you're up again um I just was wondering I know that this um is the same vendor I'm not sure if it's pronounced Bloom Blum as the interactive displays that we just had a healthy discussion on um what other vendors did we consider uh thank you uh Bloom is a member of the um Cooperative Contra one GPA uh We've uh bought before through other Cooperative agreements we have other National Distributors etc etc the um uh Bloom was able to provide us the uh what what I call White Glove Service uh to make it you know uh Speedy deployment uh um a baseline uh configuration standardized we also have to install management software security software endpoint detection
099that sort of thing um Bloom the support that they provide is is phenomenal and uh plus um I appreciated the discount which is hard you know I say appreciate I have to negotiate that stuff all the bloody time done I like that are these computers an upgrade or are they considered a replacement so similar to what they had before just new models um no ma'am uh since we're talking about lifespan we have taken our technology beyond what is considered uh well unfortunately now it's consider it's not considered safe uh but as long you know we try to get as much life as we can out of the darn things uh again going back to the information technology committee um we are standardizing instead of having three platforms which creates three different ways to troubleshoot support
100train etc etc uh and that was a big decision that this consensus group had to reach uh and we're standardizing on the Windows platform we have some very old Macs that are becoming very problematic not only for the enduser but for us to securely manag and for me to help Miss baragan keep the insurance premium as low as possible uh but get as big as many we can for it so we are replacing we're Way Beyond needing to replace some of these teachers computers perfect and as um Community member CL pointed out it this is not every single te teacher in the district so when will the others need to be replaced on the replacement cycle yeah uh which with the we got a a large number of Staff now that are using Chromebooks uh
101and uh we have some that are using Windows so we will try to get as best we can a seven to eighty year use out of it but a lot of that's dependent on cyber security anymore the hardware works but I can't secure it and manage it right that answer your question so we'll we'll be back here next year probably with some more old ones we got to replace Mr panta yeah I want to agree about what you said about the different computers we have here I remember um the big debate well you can have a chrome or you can get the the Mac or you can stick with your windows platform and teachers were allowed to choose it within these scope of these three or four computers that were offered and then it got
102to be a problem well I'm I'm teaching with my Chrome I'm working with a colleague who's got a Mac and getting to them to interface with each other got to be a real real problem real hassle not to mention replacing and fix them so I'm I'm glad we're trying to get more of a standard to one machine kind of look at things well the committee that decision that's correct good mine does anybody else have any other comments or questions I just want to say I I that I very much respect and appreciate the work that these committees do and the professionalism that bring to these conversations I also have a lot of respect for the professionals that um our our our district brings in and attracts and hires and I I put a lot of
103faith and trust in your judgment um and and the and the hard work that you do and I firmly believe that you wouldn't be up here and these things would not be on our agenda unless they were needs they're not fancy wish list items um I I I believe that I think that our district does an incredible job of uh get Community feedback doing their due diligence doing their homework and so um when I see these items uh come up for approval uh I I certainly you know will will scrutinize and have my questions and ask those questions but at the end of the day you all are the professionals right um and I really appreciate the opportunity to kind of dive into some of this but I know coming in um you you've negotiated
104the best prices possible I know that these are needs they're not wants and I know that our teachers um are are constantly being you're communicating with them and there's nothing on these lists that you know that they don't also want so I just kind of want to say that's my Baseline coming into these conversations um and I believe we should be treating all of our um professionals as professionals from our teachers to the staff to our district leaders um and so thank you to all of you and thank you for answering all of our questions tonight and thank you for all of the work that I know you did before you got here so that is not lost on me and want I just felt like I needed to say that so thank you thank
105you Mrs Christensen yes and I also would like to thank you and for Mr Pantera's com comments because it is important to standardize and to have across the board as well as uh Miss Swan's comments so thank you and thank you for answering all of our questions tonight so I I do appreciate all the work you do and I I I appreciate the honor of serving you and and um th far you haven't fired me but there there may come a day when you know I I don't know what I'm saying whatever sorry good night I think we were both going for over our dead bodies here um does anybody else have any questions or comments on this agenda item seeing none we have a motion on the floor all those in favor please say
106I I any oppos please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda was former uh F18 which is consideration to approve purchase from current 1gpa Cooperative contract 225p for asphalt Renovations at Mercury Mine Elementary School Miss Baran thank you president Greenberg and governing board members if approved this project will address deterioration of the asphalt parking lots and driveways of mercury Mine Elementary School telltale signs of asphalt degradation include alligator cracking and surface cracks wider than an inch so this project will create a safer surface for the school community and we recommend approval thank you we had one blue comment card on this uh Nicole kwick you have three minutes I thank you again for um allowing me the time to speak so I did try to raise my hand to have 19
107and 20 also removed from the consent agenda because they are related items um but my my request was uh not acknowledged so although I had eye contact but it was not acknowledged so one thing I would like to um go ahead and point out is that of this $10 million of things that were in the consent agenda that were to be passed without debate or discussion none of them have a second quote I mean I'm not even talking go out for bid um I believe the question was just asked did you ask did you get an additional quote and the answer was I really and I do respect Mr Billings um but you know I know this company I trust him I think it's a good price I think the taxpayers deserve to have more
108than um more than having to rely on one person's trust and gut feel um we are you are a a governmental a pseudo governmental agency and so you have a higher standard than an entrepreneurial company which might operate that way but literally not one of these has a second bid they're either continuing contracts one GPA or job order costs which means you guys have selected and in fact in the memo it uses the words we have selected fill in the blank for the name in this particular case you guys have selected or someone actually has selected on your behalf they have not given you the ability to choose what you think is best for the district they have chosen on your behalf to spend 1.3 million not just to update the the concrete the asphalt
109but they are completely ripping out the asphalt replacing the sublayer of aggregate I don't know why and then replacing all of the asphalt on top which is an extreme situation and according to this should last 20 years based on the frequency which we are replacing these things because this is not the first time I've talked about the fact that we are completely tearing up and tearing out um parking lots instead of fixing them we are going to replace all of them well within well less than 20 years none of them give the information on when they were replaced last one says that in 2016 it was resealed when was it replaced how old are these do you have pictures did they give you pictures of how bad the condition is do you have information that
110this really needs to happen or again is this trying to frontload our Capital expenditures you should know it should be your choice thank you uh Mr panta may I have a motion to approve purchase from current 1gpa Cooperative contract 225p for Renovations at Mercury mine so move does any member of the board have any comments or questions Mrs Christensen yes thank you president Greenberg it seems this came up last year as well the process of ripping up Asphalt and then laying down fresh it seems as though it's it's ex again excessive and I am not an asphalt expertise um I'm not an expert in Asphalt so I don't know but it it does seem unusual and so perhaps Mrs beran can give us some justification on why we wouldn't just fix and mold rather than
111bring everything up and then lay it all down again thank you president Greenberg and um Mrs Christensen um some was shared with the board so I know not all board members had this because it did come up last year and I don't know if you have access to the former board updates but this information is in there if you want to refer back to a more lengthy uh piece of detailed information on asphalt replacement but we can really only resurface asphalt driveways if the foundation is in good condition if there are no deep or wide cracks if the surface is less than 20 years old or if there's less than about a quarter of the surface area that needs repair so in the cases of all three of those that are on the agenda this
112evening uh at least two of these things are true for um those surfaces Mr panta yeah it's my understanding that a lot of these have already been repaired several times already correct they already so there's repair them as much as we can this is like the next thing right at some point the repair doesn't work anymore true okay yeah and and I would just say you know thank you for explaining that um certainly I I imagine there's tremendous liability risks um involved if we don't do these things properly not only like for like the physical protection and safety of students and staff but also potentially property damage to people's cars and and things like that so it's incredibly important from from even just that perspective that we maintain these things and um and and recognize
113that you can only do so much maintenance before the whole thing has to be replaced we've got a lot of schools a lot of parking lots so it seems like we're going to have this come up probably every single year because I would imagine there is some sort of cycle that they're on we're not going to do them all at once um we're going to sort of phase them in and so I I'm just note this will probably come up next year and we'll probably have to have the same conversation and you know I you again we we do have access to that information and so thank you for that um because it does make it easier to come in here and you know have have a good sense of sort of the the history
114and how this has been done over the years so thank you for minimizing the district's liability as well thank you does anybody else have any other comments or questions um yeah I just kind of want to Echo what Miss wannie said um you know obviously uh just as with the items we passed these wouldn't be coming before us if it wasn't at the point where we can no longer patch we can no longer repair but we really do need to replace um I appreciate that uh we do have uh experts on staff because I am no expert in Asphalt either um so I appreciate that we do have experts who uh you know understand these issues better than I and um and I think all of us up here um and make the recommendations accordingly
115and yeah I I believe we're going to be looking at this every year there's no doubt in my mind president Greenberg I'd also like to mention uh and thank uh Miss beran and Dr Davis and his whole team uh for the level um the um of attention to detail of to fiscal responsibility uh I know both of them spent a lot of time uh ensuring that the work that we uh need to do uh gets done for the safety and the wellbeing of uh our entire District thank you Dr rolds does anybody else have any other comments or questions seeing none all those in favor please say I I I any opposed please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is uh consent agenda F21 consideration to approve purchase from current
116District contract 2214 PV Joc for HVAC upgrades at Desert Shadows Middle School Miss Baran thank you president Greenberg if approved this projects will project will replace an obsolete HVAC system currently in place on the A and E classroom buildings at Desert Shadows Middle School the only campus the only school campus excuse me with this system installed the manufacturer discontinued the system many years ago and no longer provides technical support to its operation so parts are extremely difficult to acquire and disruptions to the learning environment are frequent the system is being replaced by a traditional package unit system that will work seamlessly with the current District standard HVAC controls the contractor will be installing new electrical and utilizing new and existing duct work to support 59 new air conditioning units throughout the buildings this renovation will
117dramatically improve the reliability of a comfortable indoor climate at Desert Shadows Middle School and I recommend approval thank you we have one public comment card you'll have three minutes Nicole clck hello um thank you again for allowing me the um privilege of speaking I do want to point out with my last question um it wasn't answered no as far as I can tell none of you got pictures and when the answer was given no dates were given no dates of the initial installation no dates or numbers of how many times it actually was replaced you got all trust no verify that's the situation we just entered this isn't the agenda item can you please address yes of course yeah I know it's painful to listen to um so this is weblo mechanical um two almost
118$2.6 million again we should have a bid for this um I know that it's under your bylaw amount of job order costing of $3 million but the Arizona State Statute actually suggests that that number should be 1 million you guys have increased that amount to 3 million and allowed yourself allowed the administration to put these things before you that really should have um have bids there should be additional people we're talking giving quotes the fact that you guys have chosen quo mechanical who also donates to the yes for PV students which funds the bond um initiative encouraging sending out mailers spending thousands tens of thousands of dollars um convincing voters to fund the bond pass the bond it seems a little unethical to then just select them as your um as your contractor thank you
119Mr panta may have a motion to approve uh purchase from current District contract 2214 PB Joc for HB upgrades at Desert Shadows Middle School as presented so moved does any member of the board have any questions or comments I just want to say I'm big fan of good indoor air quality so thank you so much and I'm sure the Desert Shadows staff and students also thank you because we're talking not only about temperature Comfort we're talking about like our health and it's incredibly important and I'm really actually very very pleased to see this on the agenda and I am going to be very excited to vote in just a moment Dr ly so I I do have a question I know uh Dr Davis has been working really hard on making sure we maintain our
120schools and and all of that I do have a question specifically because this is Desert Shadows I know we're going to be talking later about Indian Bend and rebuilding of schools but I know in the previous um Bond there was the potential to rebuild a middle school and this is our oldest middle school so I'm not sure if Dr Davis is aware of if this is one that's slated for a rebuild and are we putting an HVAC system on a school that's actually our one of our oldest it is our oldest Middle School based on the Reconstruction dates that are available to me so are we putting a new HVAC system on a school that's slated for a rebuild very shortly um I I don't necessarily want to give away which schools are slotted for
121replacement however I can say we are being um very judicious about ensuring that we're not putting into money money into something that we're eventually going to tear down um Desert Shadows Middle School is built like a bomb shelter it will it will be here long after any of us are here just I know the middle middle schools are built vared and their high schools of really long shelf lives because of the nature of their build but again those details aren't available to me so thank you for clarifying that that that school is in solid shape other than its HVAC system does anybody else have any other questions or comments Mrs Christensen thank you and and thank you for that question Dr Lim um well I don't necessarily have a concern with upgrading the haax system
122but however the on this item it is over $2 million and um just making a pleaded District leadership and president and superintendent to put things in items for discussion this is a there was a lot in the consent agenda here and so this item was over two million and it it just seems that we owe taxpayers a discussion on these even if we're going to approve them does anybody else have any other questions or comments seeing none all those in favor please say I I I any opposed please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously uh last on the items for approval is uh what was f24 consideration to approve purchase from current Mojave Cooperative contract 23d csbs 0905 for multi-function school activity buses Miss Baran thank you president Greenberg uh it is the recommendation
123of our director of Transportation Mr Brandon George that we purchase these activity buses it is part of our budget and planned budget expenditures these will be four 14 passenger activity School activity buses and they'll be replacing buses that were purchased in 2009 we will keep those in the Fleet for um backup buses but uh we don't want to continue to use those as our primaries and I'm happy to answer any questions thank you we have one blue public common card miss kwick you have three minutes hi thank you again for the privilege to speak um so my vet just happens to be right next to um next to the bus barn that is between 32nd Street and Cave Creek Road um so I have had occasion unfortunately to be driving by that parking lot quite
124frequently lately um it is filled with buses and as you guys have all mentioned in fact it's such a dire situation that we are now um paying $100 as incentive pay per week for bus drivers to show up it it appears we have more buses than we can drive now um so why while it might be in the budget the question is is do we need it can we utilize it um and why are we keeping the rest in reserves when again we have a lot of buses um that are sitting and that's not the only Park there's another one around the corner on 32nd Street like we have these large Lots filled with buses that do not appear to be oh and there's another one off of um the 101 right so we have
125several parking lots filled with buses um I don't know why exactly we need this 14 and why we need to hold on to the others in reserve so if that could be addressed that would be great thanks Mr panta may have a motion to approve purchase from current Mojave Cooperative contract 23d csbs 0905 for multi-function School activity buses so moved does any member of the board have any questions or comments on this item miss one yeah I guess my only question really is um you know sort of what what went into uh the conversations to determine like I think it's four is it four buses that the the the four buses four buses four buses 14 passenger four buses that can hold 14 passengers so if you could just share what went into this decision
126and recommendation yeah I would say um the word the use of the word bus is probably a loose word of the use bus I would say more like a van um these are the vehicles that you will see parked at schools not in a bus barn they are white fleet vehicles not yellow buses and they are ever more important as we do not have enough bus drivers and we rely on other staff to drive students around um they can drive these they cannot drive yellow buses thank you so just to clarify you these are um vehicles that can be driven without that license that's required to drive a bus okay thank you Mr Christensen so would these types of vehicles help alleviate a problem um for instance say we have um students that want to
127go on a either a field trip or a um sporting event and they I know that the big buses can only be driven certain times I think there's a time limit I don't really understand all the rules maybe you can enlighten me I know that's um sometimes um for instance like a sporting event if if the sporting event is at 4 and that's not the time because they're taking people home they can't do that would this because a staff member can drive this would this help alleviate some of that that's exactly do you understand my question that's exactly what it would do okay thank you you're welcome does anybody else have any other questions or comments thank you seeing none all those in favor please say I I I any oppose please say nay any
128extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is call to the public so I'd ask that you turn your attention to the video monitors call to the public is about to convene this portion of today's meeting allows the public the opportunity to address the governing board although state law does not require that the governing board hold a call to the public The Paradise Valley Unified School District and its board have chosen to do so because we believe it's important to hear about concerns and issues from our community while call to the public is not designed to be a discussion the board is here to listen due to Arizona open meeting law the governing board cannot respond to discuss or take any action on items brought up during this time however staff members may be directed
129to get back to you and address individual concerns as a reminder the point of this and every board meeting is to accomplish the business at hand and to be able to do so in an open and collaborative way all in attendance are expected to observe meeting rules as well as rules of politeness and decorum so that we may serve as an example to our students that issues can be discussed in a respectful and civil [Music] manner thank you tonight we have seven people have submitted comment cards prior to the start of the meeting and each speaker will have three minutes for remarks as a reminder we ask that you please direct your comments to the board please State your first and last name when you come to the podium our first speaker is Nicole kwick
130and our next speaker will be Loretta soell hi I am here that's a beautiful color on you um again thank you for your time and your patience uh I do realize that I ask a lot of questions um I think it's really important I think that knowing what the community thinks is really important and um I I want to con um I want to give you um I guess accolades for putting out a survey so that people can tell you what they think is important about the superintendent which you are now going to be entering um an interview process for I do want to say though that um it's not helpful it's not a helpful um survey so for instance one of the things you ask is how important it is that the superintendent have
131a vision it is far far more important that we know and that the community can give feedback on what the vision should be is the vision whole Community whole child schools but he's really good at that Vision well there's a lot of people who wouldn't necessarily want that is the vision um academics first there's no place for somebody to give that information and really the wording is so vague that depending on your lens um it can be twisted in to mean literally almost anything for instance Vision there's also Innovation I mean frankly like what does that mean they're going to be Innovative does that mean that we're going to go um Back to Basics or which would be Innovative for our our district or does it mean we're going to do whole language because we
132did whole language and it failed phonics was better are we going to do direct instruction which Studies have shown are outperforming the more curiosity exploratory only kind of approach um it's everything that I went down there other than trans transparency and communication can be twisted into whatever your worldview whatever your wish list means and I'm discouraged that you guys can use that that someone can use those survey results to basically justify any decision that you make and say well the this is what the community asked for you can't know what the community is asked for based on the vagueness of that um one thing I was sad was not included was academic proficiency we have a high school with only 25% of our kids reading at or above grade level we have across the US
13354% of the Stu of the adults read at sixth grade or below which means our students may not be able to be getting help at home it is so important that the new um whoever becomes the permanent superintendent has academic proficiency and it was nowhere on your survey so I would ask that you redo your survey and actually get their opinions next is Loretta satell followed by Jacob Anderson hi my name is Loretta soell um I'm a parent of a senior in the district and um I proudly taught second grade for nine years at Palamino uh primary um shout out to Palamino um I'm incredibly concerned about the lack of attention given by the board and the superintendent specifically about the threats to our students and their families for deportation it's your obligation to protect
134and serve the students and their families and the silence on this issue is disheartening student students expect to come to a safe place at school where they can learn and it's impossible to do so while worrying whether or not their parents will be deported or whether ice officials will taret Target them on their campus is this not an important issue do our students of color both documented and undocumented not warrant reassurance that they will be protected what I see is lack of moral courage um as you know normally protected spaces are under assault in this under this Administration and immigrants have been scapegoated and Demon demonized it's imperative that we protect all of our students and that we they feel cared for in these uncertain times we must have a plan as a district to
135ensure Protocols are met directives should be given to staff and administration to stop warrantless threats to our schools our students and families should be sent information regarding their rights as well as reassurance that it this is a priority for the district parents should be urged to update contact information bus drivers should be informed of what to do if students are dropped off and family has been removed this is your job I urge you to take this more seriously and to show that you care about all of your students not just the protected ones thank you so much president Greenberg we can make contact and and uh share some of the things that we're working on with you thank you next is Jacob Anderson followed by Jake husted Houston sorry good evening I'm Jake Anderson I'm
136the proud parent of a fourth grader and first grade at Mercury mine and I appreciate the opportunity to speak um I'm speaking on behalf of Shadow Mountain Area sports home which is a community-based softball and baseball league um I'm one of many volunteer coaches that H take a lot of joy in in working with the kids of this community including my own um recently the uh Community baseball league decided to transition into a different format that would allow them to grow to raise funds in order to replace lights on our fields and and do some needed field repairs and in that process we lost um what was fixed to be a long-term contract with with our Fields the Nancy Lane fields at Roadrunner school and so with that uh has put us in limbo um
137unfortunately during that time because we transitioned from being a part of little league to um something else although still a nonprofit organization little league and and what appears to be a bad actor have come in and and sort of undermined our work again I um am up here on behalf of all the volunteer coaches the 250 plus kids that we have signed up for uh for baseball and softball that are ready to start playing and and we hope that the board um pvusd will help support us in in uh regaining those fields so that we can continue to play it's really not about baseball or softball as you guys can appreciate um when my uh now fourth grader started he couldn't throw a ball or hit a ball and now he wants to be a
138professional baseball player he has backup plans hopefully but um you know it's about the community and and I was heartened to hear about the importance of community that you all spoke to your opening remarks and it's clear that we have an incredible Community the this baseball and softball league is an extension of that incredible community and and so uh we hope we can have your support in in being able to continue and grow that community thank you so next is Jake I'm sorry Houston um followed by Russ Nelson I apologize if I mispronounced happens all the time good evening Madame President and governing board my name is Jake housted and I'm a proud parent of two sons who attend uh schools in the Paradise Valley District but more importantly they've been part of the community
139of smash or formerly known as The Shadow Mountain little league for the past several years I can't fully Express how much this program has meant to me and my family and more importantly my boys the weekly practices and games are not just events we mark on our calendars but they are the highlights of our week they've given us opportunity to build lasting Connections in the community and create a second family that we have cherished very deeply there's something incredibly special about a place where we can all gather families cheering on the sidelines watching your children grow learn and share moments of Joy this is what the community really means Nancy Lane fields and sha Middle School Fields have become that place where our family feels it of a sense of belonging but it is heartbreaking
140to think that that very community that we have come to love we could lose that space what does it say to our childrens when they don't truly have a home field let me tell you what it says it says that you have no home you have no support and perhaps most painfully all you have no sense of community today I stand before you not just as a parent but as someone who believes in the power of sports to unite the strength of our community I asking for your help to ensure the growth of our community the future of our children and to show that you're not just committed to the families here today but that you're invested in the future of our children together I want to build a foundation that will nurture our children
141Inspire them to reach their full potential and create a lasting impact on the future of this community and this program I thank you for your time next is Russ Nelson followed by Stephanie thank you good evening uh president Greenberg uh Dr Reynolds and the rest of the members of the board my name is Russ Nelson a former member of the United States Air Force and a proud parent of a kindergarten over at merury mine I'm also a coach uh for t-ball for the smash uh league and I can't stress how important it is for us to have access to the Nancy Lane Fields just like uh the other gentleman just uh just said it is a sense of community for us and um a lot of the kids on our team are they go to
142Mercury mine and for them and for their parents a lot of them are just rushing from work to be able to get them to practice at 4:30 and to be able for them to go over and have to go over to Scottdale like 15 20 minutes away it's a huge inconvenience for them I have um children that are being raised just by their grandparents I have um children that are coming from you know divorced homes and everything where their parents are just trying to make it work for them to get to these practices on time and uh it is just very important for us if we can uh get your consideration for us to get access to Nancy Lan Fields thank you very much thank you next is Stephanie tan thank you and uh last
143will be Ashley stoker thank you all for being here my name is Stephanie trian um I'm also a public servant I've worked with Mar Copa County for almost nine years in real estate doing lease license agreements and now in the Housing and Community Development I'm here today to plea and ask that Nancy Lan fields um be returned to the 250 children that um you know enjoy their time there um I'm a single mom two kids and I'm about to be a mom of three I'm adopting my son's younger sister it's been a very long process um she's coming home to us from California next Thursday on the 13th she loves to support and watch her big brother play baseball this mint right here is what um he has left of his dad's youth um I
144am also an assistant coach on Smash um I love baseball I always have um it would be a really really sad thing to see those Lanes at Nancy Lane baseball fields remain vacant untouched because of a title because of a name from Little League to smash it's about Community I would love to be a part of the paradise vality uh Valley School District um but this new league allows us welcomes us invites us we don't have a baseball league where I live and my son wouldn't be able to play based on Little League rules that's why we're expanding I hear that enrollment is down for your community it was down for little league this new Smash ball allows for more children to be able to play it's about the children it's not about the name
145Little League versus smash it's about the community Economic Development I usually go to Trader Joe's on Camelback but when I go to Nancy field Lanes I go to the one right over here in your guys's District I mean we go to Zoyo and we go have yogurt with the other kiddos it is a community some kids who go to school don't really have connections with the kids they go to school with but they have the opportunity to meet other kiddos all around we are one big community and um baseball is life for some of these kids this is he feels connected to his dad every time he plays his dad passed in June and his little sister's mom passed in January in 2024 it's uh been a rough ride but this brings us joy and
146this brings us like just really great opportunities and there's an opportunity for a major Capital improvement from the Diamondbacks on those fields that's not going to cost a constituent a penny um let's just evolve with the times and like do what's right having vacant baseball fields that's that's broken dreams I'm scrambling a single mom like I said driving all around working full-time so my son can have something to look forward to he's meeting great kids for mercury mind and he's making really great connections that can be lifelong so please uh it's pretty obvious thank you and last is Ashley stoker thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I'm Ashley Stokes um I'm the secretary and registar for Shadow Mountain Area sports home also known as smash I'm also a parent of three kids in
147pvusd uh schools I'm a scientist by training and I'm I like numbers I like to quantify things um so I think you've heard a lot about what the community uh means uh to members of our community um but I just want to highlight that we have over 200 50 participants we're up 25% from last year and part of that is because we're no longer limited by boundaries we can bring in kids that don't have other leagues to play with um and that's really a strength we have ages four to 15 co-ed baseball and softball um we talked to a mom yesterday who cried because we have an opportunity for a 15-year-old boy that is a cost that she can afford um Club is very expensive so um you know that really means a lot to
148us that we can provide this um the vast majority even though we have the open boundaries are they live in 85028 and 85032 which is prime PV territory most were previously with us in Shadow Mountain Little League um so we have the people we have our community um in terms of a business um in 2023 we paid PB schools $6,700 for fields in 2024 it was 13.5 th000 um we have taken in over $30,000 in registration fees and a lot of that is allocated to field rental um and we want to support the PV fields we want to rent these fields um I was previously on the board of Shadow Mountain Little League um as an update it has been dissolved uh per the State of Arizona the corporate commission um and we are in
149the process of closing out the nonprofit with the IRS um we are fully prepared to rent the fields today tomorrow last week we're ready um we um I've driven by the fields every day this week and they're empty and that's sad because I'm having to send my entire Community out to Scottdale only 10 minutes doesn't sound like a lot but it's all of these families that want to play right here um according to your own facility use agreement you have sold discretion over the field rentals and I hope that you will uh use that discretion um and really do what the community wants thank you thank you next on the agenda are items for discussion um we have one and that would be the potential re rebuild of Indian Bend Elementary School and I will
150turn it over to miss Baran uh thank you president Greenberg and governing board members are we ready for the final hour of tonight's board meeting I won't take that long I'll try not to take that long uh this is uh something I think very positive to bring uh to the board tonight um as mentioned earlier the uh community did approve our bond and in that there is the opportunity for uh two Elementary School rebuilds and a middle school rebuild and our first on the list is Indian Bend so I want to share with you a little bit tonight about why that is uh I do want to caveat this with uh a lot of this is facility information and as mentioned uh Dr Davis isn't able to be here tonight uh and so so I
151will do my best to uh answer any of those questions that may come up so just starting with funding sources we have the Bond as mentioned that was approved for construction Remodel and Improvement of school district facilities buildings and grounds and the 120 million total was set aside for the uh three School rebuilds the two elementaries and the one Middle School uh additionally uh with school rebuilds you generally have some adjacent ways funding associated with that for fire lanes and safe Ingress and egress uh so there will be a portion of that that will be an adjacent way budget as well a little bit about Indian Ben there are three buildings on that site building a was constructed in 1972 and that makes it the oldest Elementary School building that we have that we are
152currently using for a k6 school Building B is the kitchen and the multi-purpose room building and that was constructed in 1985 and then Building C an additional classroom building was constructed in 2001 uh on the next few slides you will see that uh there are issues listed in red those are current or existing deficiencies uh that need to be remedied and then in Black potential or likely uh deficiencies due to age and use and this will all look very familiar this was shared in a board update I believe shortly after the winter break starting with perhaps the most uh significant issues these are structural deficiencies uh with Foundation settlement cracks in the masonry and concrete being um the most severe and over time there's been settling of the foundation that's led to cracks in the
153walls the floors and the ceilings um and then additionally older brick and concrete walls and sidewalks are showing signs of cracking due to age or movement in the ground um I know there are school districts in the state of Arizona that have had to get students out and close schools with structural deficiencies such as these and I don't ever want to be in that situation additionally with with the roof structure there are some sagging uh potentials due to age wear or uh water damage and those roofs may need some reinforcement and more to the point of roofing issues there um have been leaks obviously with the roof from the 1970s and it being I think all three buildings are flat roof but for sure the main building is a flat roof uh they have worn
154out waterproofing materials after these years um those have been you know updated and and repaired at certain times but at some point they just become um beyond the repair additionally there's deterioration of the roof me membrane um so older roofs like our tar gravel roofs that we have there need replacement because they lose Integrity After Time HVAC system deficiencies uh we have aging HVAC equipment if it's from the 1970s and I I don't know that all of them are are from are from that time that are on that building the older they are they are ineff icient undersized and obviously require significant repairs additionally duct work that's been there since the 70s can become disconnected um that leads to poor air quality poor circulation costing uh more money and then also we are always concerned
155about our indoor air quality and ensuring there's good ventilation no mold or inadequate filtration Plumbing deficiencies uh these can be a little more pesky and we've heard in recent board meetings uh some of these Plumbing issues that have caused um unpleasant smells at the campus um there are aging pipes because in the 1970s they would use steel pipes galvanized steel or PVC and those become brittle over time and with age additionally cracked pipes or outdated Plumbing fixtures lead to leaks a lack of pressure in the system or even blockage in the supply of the water and then the original fixtures are also prone to leak uh leaks or corrosion moving on to electrical deficiencies with outdated wiring um which would be aluminum or the knob and tube they don't meet the modern electrical code and
156while we don't necessarily have to update them on the current building unless we're making modifications to something that would touch electrical um they obviously still can pose a concern potentially even with fire hazards um additionally they may have insu efficient power because they aren't in um modern technological demands and that may cause circuit overloads and power outages Additionally the same thing would occur with our outdated panels which include our fuse boxes and our circuit breakers they can be undersized or also outdated um and that would have safety as well as operational concerns and then additionally there's a concern for lack of grounding in some cases in the older buildings that may be insufficient and cause some sensitivity to um electrically powered equipment then there's the building envelope and insulation so that includes things like walls
157ceilings doors and windows and as those age particularly with the heat here in uh in the Phoenix area uh that poor insulation uh allows for all of our power when we're cooling a building most of the time on occasion we're heating a building and that just goes out of those cracks and walls ceilings floors and doors uh same with air infiltration as well on that and then Asbestos and lead paint concerns when uh schools and many buildings were being built in the 70s Asus was a common material used in sealing tiles floor tiles um insulation roofing materials um and while sealing tiles and floor tiles have likely been replaced the insulation that would still be there and some of the roofing materials that would uh would still be there as well uh lead based paint
158were commonly used in the 1970s again there have been um opportunities for us to repaint um but there may still be lead paint in certain areas that haven't been touched and then additionally with mold and mildew in those areas with water damage uh POS concerns as well fire safety code violations in terms of inadequate egress routes the doors and Hall hallways um have often been um changed I make a joke all the time that somebody wants a door here and then two years later somebody wants that door shut off and wants a door moved over here um unfortunately sometimes when those things happen they um cause obstructions to um our quick evacuation routes and so we want to make sure that uh those aren't posing any problems in terms of parking lot and site issues
159um we've talked about some of our parking issues there's some draining issues in particular um at Indian Ben that affect the plumbing as well as the park lot when we do have rain which hasn't been often recently um but it does cause flooding during those heavy rain heavy rains uh with interior finishes and Furnishings the outdated flooring with vinyl uh tile or carpets that have um been there for more than 10 years they're worn or cracking or um need to be maintained uh additionally there's outdated and damaged furniture and fixtures some of which are original to the school site and then a potential issue are acoustic issues with worn out materials that provide acoustical um uh protection finally uh accessibility issues with a lack of ADA compliance if you don't know uh the American with
160dis Americans with Disabilities Act didn't go into effect until 1990 so building from 1970 um doesn't necessarily have all of those accommodations that are appropriate for an ADA building and then security concern concerns some outdated security systems and that includes an outdated campus that um doesn't have the protections of how new campuses are laid out or um all of the cameras for example or alarm systems and then Energy Efficiency lighting we still have some florescent incandescent lighting uh at that site and obviously those are are not uh uh modern energy uh light sources we move to LED systems for our uh our lighting and then I said finally before this is finally other miscellaneous concerns uh these all sort of go together in terms of outdated classroom layouts campus configuration and pick up and drop
161off with the original design of that school uh things operated differently 50 years ago than they do now um for example there is hardly any parking on this campus um it was very much I'm sure a walking campus when it began in the 1970s uh but more parents tend to bring uh students to school via cars at this point in time and so it's a terrible congestion for pickup and drop off particularly being on a main road so those outlin some of the concerns some additional information I wanted to present um that I think is important Indian Bend is a 79% free reduced lunch campus um SI that's sixth out of our 27 elementary schools in terms of the highest free and reduced lunch percentage and if you don't know that's located on Thunderbird in
16236th Street just east of the 51 it is our actually our only Elementary School located on a main road which I believe makes it ideal from um an appeal perspective to potential family member uh families Future Families um there are a few things that attract new students like a shiny new building um for whatever reason that is you know something that attracts parents and students to a campus and so to have one on a main road um would be nice for our district uh students during a re uh remodel of the school or a rebuild of the school could be busted to the former JPL campus pending some changes that will come back to the board at the February 20th meeting uh that's less than a mile away and so that's um ideal from a
163transportation perspective from our transportation gets as uh as close as possible for parents as well to bring their students temporarily to a campus and that's something we've done in the past um when we rebuilt uh Palamino they were housed at air Libre when we rebuilt oh it's this thank you Road Runner they were also temporarily housed and it's nice to be able to do that because frankly this uh this site is not a site where we could keep students in an existing building and build on another part of the campus this campus is about 10 acres and it might actually even be slightly less than 10 acres a very small area um and and there are other campuses in our district that have some of these issues but Indian Ben stands out not just as
164the oldest campus but that with the highest number of deficiency and the most severe uh level of those deficiencies in terms of next step it would be the architectural design selection and so the design team or the architect will be selected from a list of firms awarded Under The 1gpa Cooperative contract a questionnaire will be sent out to those firms um as determined by the district and then the selection process may consider the firm's qualifications Experience Project scope of work availability uh workload as well as their past performance uh our facilities Department Dr Davis will collaborate with our purchasing department Mrs Eva kayaz to help finalize the selection of the architect after that we move on to the construction manager at risk procurement uh that pre-construction phase is the first part of that and uh
165construction manager at risk we refer to is semar the firm is selected through a comp competitive request for qualifications process we advertise that RFQ for at least four calendar days generally we will do at least 30 days even total um so beyond 14 the RFQ for the preconstruction and Construction Services evaluate the various items listed here including their personnel the way they approach the project their organizational strength and uh importantly too their experience we don't evaluate cost proposals as part of the RFQ um and then the selection may include interviews with prospective firms generally that is what we do so our goal here is to establish a final list of at least three but no more than five qualified vendors and we have a selection committee for that or we will have a selection committee
166it hasn't been uh selected yet uh that's required by procurement rules it needs to have at least five uh but no more than seven members that in will include someone from the purchasing department someone from um the facilities Department a construction uh company who would not be awarded uh the the work for this um and generally it includes someone who can sort of speak on behalf of the instructional and educational side of the house uh the semour collaborates with the owner in this case us as well as the design team or the architect and then provides us with cost estimates constructibility reviews and project scheduling during the design phase um you know we clearly have a budget set aside for this based off of what we asked voters for in the bond and so it
167will obviously be within that budget um just as a reminder on some uh terms you've probably heard from before guaranteed maximum price or GMP is re refer to that the semr does provide that GMP that sets the maximum cost for the project and it should include any contingencies and fees like fees to City of Phoenix that we have to pay for permits and things of that nature the construction phase is overseen by the semar the construction manager at risk they manage our subcontractors and ensure that we stay within schedule and within the GMP and then for post construction they ensure project completion with checklists and punch list items and then they just help us fa facilitate the close out which includes warranty very important and then um documenting our the Handover to us as the
168owner uh we use the semar process because it ensures collaboration it ensures cost control and a shared risk between the semar and us as the owner this is a very rough timeline it doesn't include nearly anywhere uh all of the pieces of this uh but with the selection of architect Community engagement and design happening in Spring of 2025 uh design would potentially continue through early summer of 2025 and a temporary move of Indian Bend to former JPL would also happen over the summer uh in Fall of 2025 through spring of 2026 design and construction uh will commence and then fall of 26 the school could potentially open um it is a bit of a tight timeline but Dr Davis ensures that we can make sure that that is done and I'm happy to answer any
169questions you may have thank you Miss Baran I see Mrs Christenson has her hand up first take a breath that was a lot so I'm hearing asbestos lead paint mold mildew po um insulation fire code safety violations how long have we known about these safety issues so some of these are potential issues some of these are not issues unless we disturb something like asbest asbest is known to be in buildings and unless you disturb it it doesn't bother anyone um you know potential fire safety issues that was in Black we're not specifically aware of any we have Fire Marshals walk our building every year when we're notified of any fire issue we make to to remedy that at any point in time we do everything we can to ensure that our schools are safe but
170these are um some current deficiencies and some potential deficiencies have any staff members or students complained about respiratory or headaches because not that I'm aware of seems nope like a lot and I I'm concerned about safety of the individuals that are in this building now it emphasizes the importance of having the bond so that we're able to to make price and bond dollars aside we have we have many empty and underutilized buildings why hasn't this been add if this is as urgent as we're hearing why hasn't this been addressed sooner we seems like we play a little shell game with moving people around different um different facilities different buildings that may be vacant or underutilized I I I'm just wondering why this hasn't been addressed before when we have issues we address the issues we
171remedy the issues for example the plumbing and drainage issue that uh we experienced earlier this year we address that issue as soon as we can none of these issues are um necessarily causing like an eminent danger to a staff or student we don't put our staff in student in that kind of a situation but these are all potential deficiencies or deficiencies we continue to work on uh and that's what we're attempting to do is to resolve this we want to ensure that um all of our students are in the best buildings we have um you know hence some of the changes you uh have have discussed previously so with with um about 79% getting free and reduced lunch these are some of our most vulner vable populations and as a former foster parent I know
172that a lot of um if you have two working parents and generally a lower socioeconomics sometimes they won't complain or so I just I I'm just highly concerned these are a lot of a lot of safety issues and a lot of things and and I get it we you know you're addressing them now but I I'm just worried about these vulnerable communities that may not mention it things I mean I we were at Pinnacle Peak prep and every time my son skinned a knee he would mention it so sometime I just know because growing up in New Mexico and a lot of the like my family and community members we you know pretty we didn't we didn't really talk about stuff like that we didn't address it as much as maybe people people that have
173a higher socioeconomic awareness so I'm just concerned about these vulnerable communities thank you Mr panta let go with what you said before about when things happen we we address them I remember teaching in the district this is years ago when they did move students out of Indian Indian Ben because of ASB bestus whole the whole building was sealed off people went in with hazmat suits most of that should be out of there at least the asbest stuff there but like you said there may be some lingering spots where they deter deted that there wouldn't be direct exposure but we do address these things as they come up when they're that uh prevalent like right out there in your face the you're talking about maybe these are we want to avoid it getting to that point
174where we have to do this and because there's so many Mayes in this building you're talking that's why it's been chosen is that kind of what we're going with this yes Mr pter you have that correct thank you Dr LM so I just want to clarify based on the conversation we had earlier a school like this would not be able to support these new devices that were rolling out with like these interactive displays based on the potential electrical that's in those buildings or it would take a big lift to get them to even be compatible for such devices like like a a upgrade to this school is beneficial because they'll be able to access technology that as we Implement more technology it could put the school at risk of not being able to engage with
175that technology is is that my understanding from the electrical system deficiencies I I think that I think that it could still support some of that I think there are issues in terms of uh power outages and ensuring I I have no doubt that when Mr Billings were to ensure that it was installed they would make sure that the electrical to that is appropriate but there are lots of modifications that have to happen when you're in an older building okay yeah I did yeah I'm not saying the school is going to go up I'm just raising concerns that we may not be able to put a device in every single classroom because this building may be a capacity at just a handful of devices Miss W during the um rebuild period where the students would be
176uh transported to the um you know the current JPL campus um so what would that look like would that be sort of like the students would have would get to the current campus at Indian Ben now and then from there the buses would transport them that's Mrs wnie that's correct and that's what we did with um the most recent rebuild with Palamino uh I think we had two shuttles it might have been three shuttles that would pick students up there and then get them to JPL uh if parents couldn't take them or if their bus route wasn't already picking them up thank you Mr panta yes I remember when they were taking choya and turning into Goldust and doing a whole rebuild there its first rebuild or not rebuild but they were changing it we
177all had to cuz I was teaching there then we went to Desert Cove Desert Springs some other school and that's what they did they did exactly that shuttle thing and the students would come like they didn't take us we had to still drive ourselves but um yeah it was pretty efficient and the students get used to it right away Mrs Christensen with the question that Miss swanie mentioned and the challenges that we have in transportation how can we ensure that we're going to get our students to school on time with um I know that sometimes buses can be an hour late because we're doing double duty double shifts um have we thought about those and are we going to I mean what is the the you know what how are we going to mitigate those
178risks yeah thank you Mrs Christenson we have thought about that but um we know that it's important to continue to trans transport those students um it is possible I mean we're our buses are late every day when we're down to 38 drivers out of 110 positions there's no getting around now and well he's not here but we don't do you Happ to know how many students are bused to the school now I don't off the top of my head I know the is Marcy still here do you happen to know and how many are enrolled okay so most people get there on their own so these that's a lot more kids that need to be busted right to the new location or some how many of these are from um out of the boundary area
179like a a open enrollment people can can you come to the mic so open enrollment students would still be driven however they get to school now that's the same way they're going to get to U the temporary school okay Miss wnie thanks I'll be quick um H have there been conversations yet within the community I know that there probably will be I mean after we kind of move through some of this but the community will be engaged in some of this conversation I'm assuming thank you for that question um because I I do want to frame that this is a little bit different than how we've done this with the board before in previous rebuilds there wasn't an opportunity um where there was a discussion like this put on a board agenda it didn't come
180to the board until it came for architectural services approval and GMP or semar uh selection approval and so we wanted to provide this information while ahead of time so that the board uh felt clear that they had all of the understanding about why the rebuild was necessary moving forward um that was all towards answering your question which I forgot now say it again involving the community in the conversation thank you um and so I think Dr Lindsay can tell us the timeline for Community discussions or a gen General timeline um and with staff uh I think that discussion happened yesterday is that right that's correct um knowing that this was on the board agenda is your mic on can you hear me now yeah need to speak closer um that's correct uh knowing that this
181was on the agenda um principal Christner and I met with the staff yesterday morning to let them know that this was on the agenda and depending on the outcome of this meeting then our next steps would be to communicate with the community um and then as we work through the process we would involve them in the design features and engage parents staff students and in the rebuild great and then the timeline I mean I'm not an expert but that seems fast it does does seem fast um and uh Dr Davis feels pretty good about it and then um I had actually spoken with somebody who's in the construction industry and they were sharing with me about another um it was actually a brand new school build uh and they did that in about an eight-month
182time frame and we actually have a little bit more than that within um this time frame and a rebuild doesn't necessarily take quite as long as a new build because some of that infrastructure is already there so thank you you're welcome Dr LM um so I know where um the potential move will be taking the uh students to the J uh JPL campus the James P Lee campus so um obviously I'm very familiar with the James P Lee campus and I know because it hasn't been a k6 school in a while the basketball courts are a little under maintained because are our our Littles don't play basketball um in either one of the little cubs program or the sun kids as well as the fields are disconnected from connecting to the main um playground and
183things like that so what measures are going to be Tak to kind of reintegrate this campus for a k12 and kind of what cost goes into getting that campus to be able to allow these students access to things like the fields and the basketball courts which other elementary schools have access to and they do currently have access to at their school um Dr Lim the um when we do temporarily move somebody we do make some small modifications to ensure the campus is um you know most conducive to learning to playing especially on a k6 campus obviously so we'll make some minor modifications to JPL to ensure those things and accessibility to all of the fields and things of that nature and I I just want to follow up that question so there there wasn't any
184other option other than JPL I mean I I know we have two elementary schools that have been recently closed in nor just k6 uh elementary schools what is the resistance to having those students bus to those campuses which already have they're laid out appropriately at this moment so Desert Springs is already being used for PV online so it's not available for use for an entire Elementary School uh and Sunset Canyon as we've um shared with the board in work sessions uh back in October so before your time uh Sunset Canyon is slotted to receive the students from JPL um from the special education program Mrs Christensen how many individuals educators are on with PV online and what is the capacity of Desert Springs prep I I don't know those numbers off the top of my
185head but I know that both campuses could not be there together and there are other uh I I'm not yeah I'm sorry I'm not suggesting they both be there together but if I don't know the number but I it seems I've I passed through there it seems there's 12 or so anywhere between 8 to 12 cars out there on an during the day at various times and it doesn't seem like there's a lot why can't we have underutilized campuses why can't those PV online individuals go to an underutilized campus if they're just the Educators we they're not students there and then bust to bust these kids to a a something that is not going to have to be redone because it sounds like JP Lee is already set for the the the prease so I
186don't understand the the logic on that yeah so Mrs Christensen um P PV online Desert Springs is their permanent home they've just moved there so I don't think moving them I'm not sure they would appreciate an additional move um and you know th that campus was set up and intended for them to be received there uh and so it it it from our perspective makes the most sense for for them to remain there we have additional renters there as well I think they're called everything matters or first things first I don't recall so they're taking up some of those spaces and then on occasion we do have students on that campus yeah I can't imagine it would be that large of a community and it seems as though it would be more disruptive to take
187Little's pre and disrupt them because there's a commute there there needs to be notification to parents and things of that nature so I I just don't think it sounds like this has been well thought out but um again I that's why we're having this discussion so um I I would like the numbers on PV online staff members because it doesn't seem I I don't know what is the cap capacity like 500 I I would just add additionally that I don't Springs Desert Springs isn't particularly close that's right that's I just wanted to jump in and say that we we probably wouldn't recommend that given the proximity and the uh in convenience that it would be for families uh JPL is less than a mile away from Indian band and be worth the investment uh for
188those students to have uh to bring a few of the the areas up uh so that uh they would be able to access uh what they're familiar with uh and it would be for a period of a year uh and then they would be able to uh go back into a pretty amazing fa facility uh for the remainder of their education in in their k6 school Miss W I was just going to say so when I reviewed this before I got here today I mean to me that that's what jumped out at me as a major win that there is a place to put these kids during this build that is like their still it's part of their Community I think that that is a really important consideration I think displacing those kids and bringing
189them to a completely different neighborhood and a completely different area um does a disservice and I think it's I think that this is a major strength of this plan quite frankly I understand there might need to be some modifications so that you know these kiddos get to partake in activities I think that's also really important and it also is you know then an improvement of that campus which will still be receiving students preschool students um you know are are not going to be there anymore but at some point there might be other opportunities right to to repurpose that that facility so in keeping and I recognize right like as you're making those decisions you'll be thinking about those things as well and having those conversations so I just want to say to me that it's
190a it's a tremendous win that there's an option that close by thank you so anybody else have any other question so Dr Lim I I I do have a question and it's regards to the ball field so there are baseball fields and I don't know if those are associated with the actual campus or separate from the physical campus at Indian B there are the baseball the baseball diamond right back there and if it's if it's part yeah Kurt Schilling did the rebuild there and built up that is are there plans for that particular diamond and what's going to happen back there on that Backlot if that's part of our campus so much of that will be determined by the architect right and the uh the team that is going to be uh instrumental in that
191planning process uh and what areas of that uh 10ish Acres they're going to need to to utilize the plan is that obviously the Kurt chilling field uh will remain there uh and be a vital part for of the community for many many years to come does anybody else have any other questions comments well yeah I think I do there's also another park right by there right next to it that's City Park yeah that's a city park right so okay we can't do anything with that cannot okay thank you anybody else I want to thank you Mrs beran and Dr Davis as well um I know that that uh bringing this plan forward means there's a lot of hours that went into the planning and the discussion and determining needs um uh and to me it's
192I don't want to say no-brainer I don't mean it that way but I think when we have the opportunity as we do um to provide our students with a renovated building that will better meet their needs and meet the security needs U meet the safety needs that these older buildings unfortunately um they're just getting old I mean that's that's the reality of it and we can only patch and repair so so long and so um again it's a shout out to the community for approving the bond and and allowing us this opportunity and this option um and I hope we are able to you know give these kids a new school that better meets their needs president Greenberg again I just want to Echo what you you just said I want to thank uh Mr
193beran uh Dr Davis the entire team uh for the uh enormous amount of effort and planning that went into this thinking uh they've gone over uh every scenario and uh have worked hard to to bring a plan forward our next steps then would be to as you saw in the presentation uh would then to be to go out uh and uh look for architectural support uh so that we can begin moving forward uh on this plan and and get this community a uh a wonderful learning environment as soon as we can thank you that takes us to the end of the agenda before we adjourn I'd like to remind you that the next regular board meeting will be held Thursday February 20th at 6:30 pm. Mr panta may I have a motion to adjourn so
194move all those in favor please say I I I any opposed say nay motion passes unanimously