001I have to give the quickest shout out about their costumes that was all part of a costuming grant that we were um received this year and so it's awesome to see them in action thank you it's 6:30 so I would like to call this meeting to order um I'm going to ask everybody to rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance but before we do that can we give our do we have any parents of our performers here first you you get your rise first thank you for sharing your very talented students with us and thank you Mrs Miss Kar for uh bringing them uh to to the meeting tonight um so I am going to ask everyone to please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance followed by a Moment of Silence to
002honor the memories of two students who we lost Jordan Williams an 11th grader at Shadow Mountain and Rees dortenzio a Shadow Mountain homebound student United States of America to The Republic which stands one nation under God indivisible withy andice thank you very much may I have roll call please Mrs Christensen here Mrs Greenberg here Dr Lim here Mr panta here miss wanie here thank you the next six items on our agenda are related to the board organizational portion of tonight's meeting next on the agenda is nomination and election of board president does anyone have a nomination for 2025 board president miss wanie yes I would like to um nominate uh an elect uh make a motion for Anne Greenberg to remain as the governing board president for 2025 thank you um does anyone else have
003a nomination for board president uh seeing none Mr panta may have a motion to approve the nomination for me uh for an Greenberg to serve as 2025 board president so moved does any board member have uh comment question seeing none all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay nay any extensions motion passes orise one day uh next on the agenda is nomination and election of president pro excuse me proem for 2025 does anyone have a nomination for president proem for 2025 I have a nomination I'd like to nominate Tony panta for the position of protemp for thank you does anyone else have a nomination for president protom for 2025 uh seeing none Mr panta may have a motion to approve the nomination for Tony panta to serve as president
004proem for 2025 to preside over any meeting during the 2025 calendar year in the absence of the governing board president so moveed does anybody board member have a comment or question seeing none all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay any extenstions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is uh establishing the order of roll call vote uh so consistent with the board's practice the order of voting is decided by lot during the organization meeting in January of each year each board member drew a number prior to the start of meeting uh Mrs chisman will call on each of us now to announce our numbers to determine the order of roll call Vote for This calendar year Mrs Christensen your number number one Mrs Greenberg three Dr Lim four
005Mr panta two Miss wani five thank you next on on the sorry uh next on the agenda is approval of authorized signatories uh may have a motion to appoint all governing board members as authorized signatories for the 2025 calendar year Mr panta yes so moved do any board members have a comment seeing none uh all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is authorization of signature stamps may I have a motion to authorize the use of exim signature stamps of governing board members for the 2025 calendar year Mr panta uh so moved any board member wishing to make a comment seeing none all those in favor please say I I any opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously and
006next on the agenda is approval of resolution number 570 may I have a motion to adopt resolution number 570 authorization to ratify vouchers which approves the signing of expense vouchers between board meetings and resolves to ratify the expenditures as reported at each regularly scheduled board meeting Mr panta so moved does any board member have a comment seeing none all those in favor please say I I I any opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda that concludes our organizational meeting and the next on the agenda is approval of agenda Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg governing board cabinet and guests items approved by consent will not come up for discussion during the meeting but will be approved when the agenda is adopted this is possible since members of the governing board
007receive the agenda along with backup materials at least 24 hours prior to the meeting and have had time to review and consider all items prior to the agenda being adopted members of the governing board may ask that an item be removed from the consent agenda and brought to the floor for discussion at the appropriate place on the agenda any member of the audience who submitted a blue public comment card prior to the start of the meeting will be recognized to speak on that agenda item under items for approval I would like to offer the agenda as posted thank you prior to the meeting we received no blue public comment cards and so there will be no member of the audience speaking um on specific agenda items um does any member of the governing board wish
008to have an item removed from the consent agenda Mrs Christensen yes I would like to have items F10 and F12 from the consent agenda and um I also had a concern um I moved that we remove item G2 from the agenda because I'm concerned that it might be a violation of procurement law we didn't last time we were doing a superintendent search we actually went out for bid and um so it's interesting that we are just going to have this as an item for approval and while it may fall under the the threshold for the dollar amount that we may not need to do that I think it would be in our best interest as a district to make it transparent and to actually do go out for bid instead of approving just one vendor
009for a superintendent search which is one of our most important decisions so I can make a motion well I think when it comes to item G2 we can take it up that you know your suggestion of of removing from the agenda we can take up then but um we will move F10 and F12 that's what you had right so um per policy those will now be moved to after G3 on items for approval thank you president Greenberg um does anybody else have anything they would like to move from the consent agenda uh Mr Pantera may have a motion to approve the meeting agenda and recommended consent agenda items yeah I move that we approve the approval of agenda minus items 10 and 12 which will be further down in the agenda okay move um all
010those in favor please say I hi any oppos say nay motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is governing board statements um Mrs Christensen would you like to go yes thank you president Greenberg um first of all I'd like to welcome everybody here this evening I always appreciate when there's community community members in attendance because we report to you all and I so I always appreciate you being informed and coming to the meetings um I do have an exciting um Proclamation or announcement that um so the The Horizon class of 2024 had three students that got accepted to the Berkeley College of Music in Boston and I just found out over the holiday break um initially there was one student that's already attending and um two more got accepted and if for those of you
011that don't know this is like the Harvard of music school and it's such an amazing accomplishment and I just and I know that I always um shout out to our wonderful Arts departments including NVA but um Horizon choir is phenomenal and I I and I wanted to thank um Mr Dro because they there is going to be something in marketing rate a picture May perhaps um but it is a big deal and so I just wanted to shout out to those three individuals and lastly I just wanted to welcome our new board members here today and congratulations thank you Mrs Christensen Mr panta thank you president Greenberg um we are at the last Arizona School Board Association um assembly and I heard this speaker we all heard the speaker that were there uh Stephen Constantino
012okay I even got the book engaging families every family I really love that idea I've always loved the ideas of making sure that we all always want our students engaged but parent engagement and it's more than just um student um teacher parent teacher conferences and things like that the two things that he mentioned right away that got my interest about uh some of his philosophies is the fact that this doesn't cost anything okay number one for for a board with free great love it and it doesn't place a lot of burdens on staff to learn a whole new curriculum a whole new uh way of doing things it's just five simple principles although they're so simple at least five of them it's a pretty thick book you know but I got a I got a
013copy I bought one I got the used one with all the notes kind of like Harry Potter and you know the Half Blood prints okay so I've got all the inside info on that any teacher staff member wants to read the book or talk about these principles I'd be glad to do so it's about doing what we do already but having even more conversations about it welcoming people letting them know that they're value no matter where they are what part of the district and so if you want to get on board with that the first cup of coffee on me all right thank you then that concludes my comments thank you Mr panta Dr Lim great thank you welcome to 2025 and I just want to take a moment to say I feel very privileged
014to be joining the board um and I've appreciated the opportunity to already connect with our communities and I just wanted to take a moment to highlight two great opportunities I got to do um I got to right before the holiday break I got to attend North Ranch uh elementary school and I got to join their readathon was a great opportunity to not only read to kindergarteners and share with them that I struggle reading out loud because I have a learning disability dyslexia and I still struggle reading out loud but also to see the community come together and see all these amazing community members showing up with their books to read to all the different classrooms at North Ranch it was a great opportunity to connect and see our community coming together and just last night
015I got to connect with my daughter's community at was spring winds Academy um they're ptso and uh we know our parent teacher organizations are invaluable parts of our community organized an event but more than anything our teachers took the time out of their evening we were at an ice cream parlor to actually serve the ice cream to the students the students were so excited to see their teacher serving their ice cream but more than anything us parents felt really uh we really like seeing our students connect with their teachers outside of the classroom and really show that their Community can come together outside of the classroom it was great being involved and I appreciate being on the board already and those opportunities to connect with our community and support them thank you Dr LM Miss
016wanie uh so yeah I'd like to just reiterate um an appreciation and of just just my sincere gratitude um I think it's a great service and honor um to be able to to sit here before you um I've been a parent volunteer in this district for many many many years on sitting with you all um on the other side of the Das and I take this role very very seriously um and I I am honored and humbled um to be in a position of service so thank you to everyone for your support um and I also had the chance to read but I didn't get kindergarteners I got sixth graders and I was really really nervous about that um but to my surprise they were the biggest loves ever um and it just filled my
017heart and it was just such a great reminder of like why we're all here um while everyone on this board is here and while you all are are all here in the audience today um and so I am super super excited to have more opportunities like that and to kind of learn that you know what I maybe had some ideas about what sixth graders were like and they just blew me away um I was super nervous that they were going to like throw things at me or think my story was boring um and they were just like the most polite wonderful engaged uh little humans so yay so everybody uh at North Ranch thank you for that and what a great job everybody is doing parents families and I really do look forward to more
018opportunities like that um and so with that I'm going to cut myself off because I don't want this meeting to go too long for everyone here uh thank you miss m um I'd also like to officially welcome Dr Lim and Miss Wy to the board um like to thank everybody for being here today and I'd like to thank the community for trusting me again to serve as a governing board member um I think this position is incredibly critical to supporting our students our teachers our staff our families I want to thank you for giving me the opportunity to continue to make a positive difference in our community in such a vital way as a public servant to be something part of something that I feel is truly Monumental and life-changing and the essence of who
019we are as Citizens in ensuring that our children receive a quality education I'd also like to thank my colleagues for trusting me to serve again as board president this year as we all work together to ensure everyone in our PV Community shares in and is well positioned along their IND individual and our Collective journey of Excellence so thank you all for being here and next on the agenda is Awards and recognitions Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg at this time I'd like to invite the governing board to join me in front of the Das good evening president Greenberg governing board members members of cabinet and attendees both inperson and virtual tonight we have several recognitions to share with you this evening we'll be inviting our honores to the front of the room for the recognition
020and photo so when your name is called please make your way to the front of the room our first honores tonight won their fourth straight 5A girls volleyball state championship after defeating number one ranked Sunrise Mountain in four sets this team lost the first set then went on to win the next three in nail-biting fashion this team is truly a force to be reckoned with and we're excited to welcome uh the 2024 AIA 5A girls volleyball state champions from Horizon High School a lot of this team no doubt is practicing this evening so we have Coach McKenna gags Varsity assistant coach Sarah kerbau and varsity manager senior Bella Heimer our next honores recently earned the prestigious AIA sportsmanship award this coveted award is an annual tradition given to one team in each conference that consistently
021displays the highest level of sportsmanship throughout the season as determined by the efficients this football organization's commitment to fair play respect for opponents and overall positive conduct on the field has earned them this well-deserved recognition please help me welcome from Horizon High School AIA football sportsmanship award recipients Horizon football with us this evening is Jackson morray Jace Ashley Jax marovich Bo cendo Mato Johnson Ethan Brennan and Coach Tyson dmore next is the Paradise Valley education support professional of the month pvca president Miss Michelle Courtright is here to make the presentation president Greenberg governing board Dr and cabinet my name is Michelle Courtright and I am the President of the ESP Association and it is with great honor that I get to recognize One ESP exceptional ESP every month and this month we are recognizing Alicia
022shapot she is the record secretary over at sonor and Crossing Elementary and she has been described as multiple things an Energizer Bunny um a jack of all trades and many people think of a record secretary are is somebody who just manages records well in our district not only do they manage records they take care of attendance they also greet every person that comes in they answer the phone calls they call parents when their child isn't there they're the first person you see and usually the last person if you're walking in and out of the office but I guess Alysa also does crosswalk which is unusual she also helps with noon Duty so she wears a lot of hats but she is descried cribed as someone who has a personality that warms has a warm smile
023she has a contagious energy and no matter what kind of mood you are in when you walk into her office you're going to walk out with a smile on your face because she is treated you with respect and dignity um it says alicious um contributions to our school Community are ear ear immeasurable whether it's lending a hand to a colleague keeping an eye on students or just supporting our families she does it with Grace positivity and a genuine commitment to make Sky crossing the best place it can be so it is with my pleasure that we recognize Alisha shop cot to be the ESP of the month for January last but certainly not least is the recipient of the Paradise Valley education association's recognition of Professional Standards award for teachers the honory will be introduced
024this evening by Miss Heather Schmidt pvea president put it in Heather mode uh good evening president Greenberg Dr Reynolds governing board and cabinet thank you for having me my name is Heather Schmidt I'm proud to serve as the president of the Paradise Valley Education Association which represents our certified employees once a month I get to stand here and talk to you about props which is professionals recognizing other professional successes and our members are nominated by each other to receive this award this evening I'm honored to recognize Jenna Galvin a reading specialist at Palamino primary as the recipient of the January 2025 pea props she was nominated by her colleagues Lisa Davis and Amy girkin who are both here this evening to celebrate her from Miss Davis Jenna is the title one raing specialist at pal
025primary she lo I love working with her because she is knowledgeable creative passionate about helping our students she is so easy to collaborate with and is always willing to help when needed she is also our Title One coordinator on our Title One leadership team and co-leads our mtss literacy Committee in addition to being an amazing colleague she also teaches seven intervention periods each day with kindergarten through third grade students to help them build their reading schools and created a third grade reading club to encourage their love of reading uh from Miss girkin Jenna is a strong leader and she has demonstrated her leadership in so many ways um again a note about the book club that meets once a week during her lunchtime and she started 100 % Club in Star reading for second and
026third graders and again mtss literacy Jenna motivates her students with her genuine caring and support for them as a colleague she is positive helpful and committed to success for all as Miss Davis and miss miss girkin both said we are fortunate to have Miss Galvin as an educator in PB schools and as a member of pvea congratulations Mrs Gavin kid and that President Greenberg concludes this evening's Awards and recognitions thank you all uh congratulations again to all of our um Wrecking knes shall we say and next on the agenda is superintendent's comments Dr Reynolds thank you president Greenberg governing board tonight I would also like to welcome our new governing board members Miss Jessa wani and Dr Amanda limb thank you for being here and choosing to uh to support PV schools in this way
027as well as Rew welcome president Greenberg uh who will obviously be serving uh another four four-year term so thank you for your service uh all three members were joined by friends family family and loved ones prior to the start of the December governing board meeting where they were officially sworn in as the newest members of The Paradise Valley Unified School District governing board uh so congratulations to you and all your family and friends I look forward to working with the board to advance our District's goals and continue providing an unparalleled educational experience for our students in PV schools we engage Inspire and nurture students through high quality education meaningful educational opportunities and dynamic learning experiences one of the opportunities is the proactive approach we take with our health and wellness Wellness initiatives every year we
028host a 5K fundr run and this year is no different so please join us for the 15th annual PV schools Community 5K fundr run and health fair this event encourages active Lifestyles among our staff families and community members and will be held on Saturday February 1st 2005 at Horizon High School to register visit runsignup.com between now and Saturday February 1st participants who register by January 17th 2005 will receive a funrun t-shirt for more information please visit the new my link page and visit our news section to find out what color this year's shirt will be uh listen to this week's episode of our district podcast PV be available on Apple podcast and Spotify we are hiring bus drivers join the PV Schools transportation team and be the driving force behind Student Success as a bus
029drial You'll Play a vital role in our community by safely transporting students to and from school and other events we offer flexible schedules competitive pay and we will provide your CDL training at no cost if you enjoy working with children and want a rewarding career with excellent benefits apply today at pvschools.net slbs PV schools is here to guide families on their journey of excellence and hopes to inspire and influence them when choosing the best school for their children with National School Choice week quickly approaching I want to thank all of our families who have chosen PB schools the district is proud to offer a variety of unique opportunities that meet the individual needs of every child with programs such as advanced placement Athletics career uh in technical education dual enrollment dual language immersion Fine Arts
030and and much much more PB schools wants to continue to encourage parents to make decisions about their child's their children's education based on the factors that matter most PV schools is a leader in choice and I can say with confidence that families have so much variety and ample choices here in Paradise visit our website of pvschools.net to see all the great opportunities we have to offer and with that my comments are concluded thank you Dr Reynolds next on the agenda is is items for approval uh the first item is consideration approval of governing board Norms uh for 2025 uh we discussed this uh at our Retreat thank you was it a study session no it was at our Retreat um and we talked about um the need to perhaps expand and add an item which
031we are recommending which came out of the uh The Retreat and in addition to the Norms that we have approved uh in the past we are adding a norm that says uh as a member of the Paradise Valley Unified School District governing board I will use social media and artificial intelligence responsibly and ethically to support the well-being of the district uh we felt it was important to uh include um further language uh specially given expansion shall we say of social media and um and AI currently so that is really the only change from the previous board Norms um Mr panta may I please have a motion to approve the governing board 2025 board Norms is presented I move that we approve the governing board 2025 board Norms does any board member have a comment in
032regard to the Norms Mrs Christensen the new item that was added uh I was not provy to the discussion that was that happened and um so I just wanted to know who who decides if we're using social media and artificial intelligence responsibly and ethically um I am not for censoring anyone and so I just would like to hear a little bit about that discussion um I was Ill that day and could not attend I mean anybody wants to jump in jump in I think it was you know just a concern um because we have something in here where we do talk about respectful being you know in person and online but it was felt that there is so many there are so many more opportunities to in terms of social media which we know is
033this big in a lot of ways amorphous you know entity um and with all the board Norms this is this is each of us saying that these are things that we will do that that we intend to do as board members um you know are we going to sit here I don't think we really had a a discussion about defining responsibly and ethnically but I think we all I would think have have similar views on what that would look like um this particular wording we kind of had a discussion and then Dr Arnolds you can jump in he took the lead with cabinet to to craft some language and we got it last week right yeah and so it was distributed last week in the the update and you received no changes I presume so
034that's where we're putting it in yeah happy Mr pant I especially like it because of it's got that artificial intelligence portion in there the ethics we're asking our students to do this all the time in their classrooms our staff I'd like to be uh you know be as us be an example of how to do that and we should take on the same thing we're asking our students and teachers to do that's why I really like this particular item being added Dr Lim go ahead and add to that um this is a especially in the AI and artificial intelligence is something that's being added to lots of norms and policies around the country and in different organizations um as we're moving into this AI technology just to make sure that we're upfront and using these
035Technologies appropriately as we move forward and we're thinking very streamlined and ethically as we move forward in this um just to be prepared as this technology further and further develops and becomes a more integrated part of our way of functioning and I'll just add and and actually it was Dr Lim that um brought up this this really important point about AI which is you know a lot of a lot of those um new platforms right they're not private so you know putting anything in there potentially is could be a violation right of like student privacy and and those kinds of things family privacy and I really appreciated that because it wasn't really something I had thought about in terms of like the context of a school district and so that was kind of another piece
036if that is all it all helpful that we really did kind of dive into a little bit does s answer your questions thank you I just was curious about the discussion and I appreciate the explanation thank you absolutely um does anybody else have any other questions or comments about the board Norms so we have a motion on the floor all those in favor please say I I I any oppos please say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on sorry I've got a lot of papers here next on the agenda is consideration and if deemed advisable retain retain the services of the Arizona School administrators Inc ASA for the purpose of conducting a superintendent search and take possible action to approve the ASA executive Search Services agreement um I would would like to ask uh
037Dr Tim ogal uh to provide a presentation um in regard to this agenda item before we discuss it president greenbird can we postpone that so that I could because I did want to make a motion to table this item and so it I don't want to hear the presentation until after the motion that I wanted to make is done I move to postpone the discussion the presentation until after the board has had a conversation about this item okay we have a motion on the floor it's a main motion so it does not require a second Mrs Christensen would you like to address it yes um so last year when we were conducting a superintendent search um president Greenberg and I were we took the lead to do to work with procurement to do a procurement
038search to um figure out what vendors we were going to use and we did our due diligence and we did do some research we I felt we did a good job of interviewing and taking time um in the in the spirit of transparency I I think it would be wise to perhaps add this to the consideration of what we've already done I do understand that it's a different superintendent search because that was prior to the board deciding to do an interim superintendent but for us to just add this for approval does it's it may be a violation of procurement law um I I did look into it a little bit and and I think it might be under the that threshold but it it definitely is not transparent nor um nor should we be approving
039this this item without looking at other vendors can you provide I mean if you're saying you think it might be against procurement law what what specifically when we when we were doing important uh procurement searches including vendors um we either have to follow U certain things like I know we do a lot of job order contracts this is a this is a different situation because we are actively asking for vendors to come and present us so that we can search for a superintendent um it's my understanding that we did not not get multiple bids or quotes and we are just going ahead with approval with just one vendor where as last year we looked at several and so I'm concerned that we are we're changing the process and that it is not transparent or fair
040to other vendors that may be able to provide similar or other types of services we need to have all options on the table um because this is a very important decision we um this is the board's most important decision is to is to pick a a good superintendent for our district and so I I think rushing this um is is a mistake and so I I would like to move to table this item until we've compared it to some of the other research that we've done Dr Reynolds so uh it might be helpful just to talk a little bit about um the conversation that the board had at The Retreat around this item regarding uh a past look uh and why uh we wanted to to bring ASA as an option uh for the board
041to review from the board's perspective do you want to talk about your introduction in to the topic sure absolutely yeah so um when at The Retreat we discussed uh a variety of options we talked about the fact that you know you had mentioned uh the review uh that I think yourself and president Greenberg went through last year um ASA uh fell outside of that uh and so the board wanted to have an opportunity to uh review the services that they provide uh there is no obligation at the end of the presentation uh for you to to vote yes or no on it we could table it uh but uh the conversation uh as I remember it that the uh the board members that were there wanted to to hear that presentation from ASA why was
042this item not included as an item for a discussion rather than approval if we just wanted to hear what they had to what they had to offer um going ahead and approving this is would be premature and um reckless in my opinion because we need to look at all options on the table so so the discussion around that was uh to make it an action actionable item so that after the presentation if this was a service that the board uh wanted to use that you would have the option to be able to do that there was a discussion around discussion action and we talked about the fact that after the presentation if the board did not want to take action uh you don't have to so is the approval of this item would be yes
043we would approve to go forward with this vendor or is approval meaning yes we would consider this in addition to others because to me the way it's worded it implies that approval would mean yes would go for with as go forward with Asa rather than being transparent and looking at all options on the table and looking at other companies as well uh no so the item on the agenda this evening would be to approve ASA um after the presentation after you've heard what what ASA um has to offer as far as a search Service uh that you have that option to then approve them as the search why were not other companies vendors invited to have this this discussion with this new board any governing board members want I believe one of the things that
044Drew us to want to have this presentation first was that this particular company the the fees involved are below a certain threshold all the every other vendor out there is Way Beyond in price compared to this one that's that's how I think it was explained to us then so well let's list listen to this one which is seems to me the cheapest version and um anything else would be a lot more expensive I remember when we put out the bids before too it was hard to get anybody to put in a bid for for um for the search you know when you you and uh president Greenberg were on those companies well we're lucky to have two bids put in I but our our general discussion on this was well let's see what they have
045to offer we we can vote up or down either way but let's see what they got and that's why we chose to maybe to have this presentation today Miss W you know when we did have this conversation and this discussion again like Dr Reynold said we did kind of have a little bit of a back and forth about oh you know do we do we have it just as an item you know for discussion again we wanted to sort of preserve the option to be able to go ahead if that's what we wanted to do um at this point I mean I think a reasonable step forward could be we could listen to the presentation and just Mo like table it for now and um at least you know get the information because mrle is
046here today and then we can have a conversation and a discussion and we don't necessarily have to vote on this today Mrs Christenson so I find it highly inappropriate to have the to have had this discussion in a mini retreat we are have a responsibility to the this District to be transparent and to do the absolute best job of finding a superintendent not just the cheapest vendor but the absolute best and we would need to look at all the options on the table and absolutely take price into consideration but is is this going to be the right thing and when you only have one choice it doesn't make sense for our district in my opinion to to just choose say yes or no on this because the timeline that we're looking at is very aggressive
047and um I'm just concerned I brought this up several months ago when are we going to do the superintendent and it was not put on an agenda so I'm a little bit um concerned that all of a sudden we're trying to rush this through with just one vendor and not provide all the choices so that this governing board this new board can best decide which vendor can support our district you have a motion yes the the motion on the floor is actually M Mrs Christensen could you repeat your motion please I move to table this discussion to consider other vendors so that we can do a complete um superintendent search so I move to table this item number G2 all right does anybody else have any other comments all those in favor of tabling item
048G2 please say I I all those opposed please say Nay Nay Nay Nay any extensions the motion fails 4 to one so we will proceed with Dr Ogle thank you for um your patience and um we look forward to your presentation thank you Madame President and members of the board thank you for having me here tonight Dr Reynolds uh thank you for your uh service here to the district and uh I am a representative of the Arizona School administrators Association uh Miss Christenson thank you for your feedback um and it's um probably a misnomer to call the Arizona School administrators um a vendor in comparison to other vendors we're a private nonprofit of which you your administrative team is a member you pay membership dues to the Arizona School administrators Association so it's a private
049nonprofit mission-driven organization in the state of Arizona that exists to support uh districts and school leadership and um so therefore that's you know why we're here so to speak um there are a number of private uh for-profit companies that do superintendent searches um and uh you know they they uh do a number of searches each year in Arizona um we tend to we the Arizona School administration uh administrators have done a majority of the superintendent searches over the last couple years for uh districts around the state um and so we uh have as contractor and contract employees some of the top school leaders um around the state um we tend to know the candidate pool very intimately because we have worked in the field um and we certainly know districts uh local cultures and uh
050we pride ourselves in in that kind of Arena because uh we've been in the seats and myself I have been involved in dozens if not more than dozens of superintendent searches um during my career both as a candidate and as a hiring person and um as a representative of school boards for uh nearly a decade so with that all being said um we're certainly At Your Service to try to provide the best kind of opportunity for this board and this community and you're correct all of you have recognized that this is the number one important function of a board to represent your community and folks voted for you and they have great trust in you to make a good decision and bring the next leader for PV schools you know forward so that's why we're
051here we're here to help you be successful um so that all being said um the presentation will go on as is this is uh the the goals of the search of course and that would be to select the highest qualified and best fit uh to lead your District into the future and all along with process ensuring transparency and um and stakeholder input because this is a community I know your District very well um and I know that there's lots of public interest in your in your schools um and so uh that's a great thing and that's an asset that we would certainly leverage uh as we move through the process the typical search runs through six phases so phase one um would be uh where we could develop a profile and um a timeline and
052work with the board to bring forward uh an advertisement and um like I said uh you know the the community engagement strategies and those kind of things and we would bring that back for the board for approval uh and that would allow the Arizona School administrators Network to publicly advertise and recruit candidates the Arizona School administrators is part of a National Organization and so um any advertisement and recruiting would include um a national perspective there are State associations Like Us in each of the 50 states and the network includes all of those folks um and in a district of this size and sophistication I would anticipate you know a national um a national marketplace where you'll have candidates from other states um who certainly have interest um in a position of this of this caliber
053so if that's phase one phase two then um once you develop your profile and your expectations and the board participates in uh the kind of person that you want to recruit um then uh we do the advertising and the posting normally we need probably around a month for phase two for us to do our work and for us to talk to candidates um in the profession phase three then would occur when um we bring the candidates to the board that typically is done in executive session because um the anonymity of the candidates is very important in order to bring in top uh candidates and people that um already have jobs so to speak um uh we would do that in executive session those names would remain confidential as we kind of go through phase three
054and you select candidates to interview and phase four we would do our interviews once again in executive session to ensure anonymity of the candidates and uh once that occurs then the board would identify uh the finalists and that's the point at where there would be a public motion to identify the candidates by name and create uh some kind of community opportunity for folks in your District to interact with those individuals at the end of that then the board would name one finalist to enter into contract negotiations with and that uh culminates with phase six um and so that's typical of the process and the steps to get from the beginning to the goal of having someone in place uh by July 1 or Yeah by July first so yes so if there's questions feel free
055to stop me along the way so okay Mr panta yes um you mentioned uh Phase 2 be like basically an estimate of a month yes the all six phases there an estimation on that how much time yes thank you for your question that's a good one and um when I work with boards I like to work backwards so to speak and so if our goal is to have someone in place under contract let's call it the first week of April then that gives you uh the month of March to have phase three four and five it gives you the month of February to have phase two completed um and that gives us um you know a couple of weeks to get phase one completed and that puts in place the ability for your attorney and
056the candidate to bring a recommendation to the board in early April so basically we're setting a a deadline and we work backward to make it happen by our deadline kind of thing well yeah that's that's that's Tim's recommendation you know you can do it different ways you could look at a may you know you could stretch it out and try to get a candidate identified by the early May and delay things by a month um knowing the marketplace so to speak um you're at the place where you need to accelerate because good candidates are beginning to interview other places and um there are several districts that are doing just what you're doing you know this in the next few weeks and so uh you know it's not urgent but yes you know we need to
057not not drag our feet to have a successful outcome others other questions good questions this particular chart has a lot of detail on it that may not matter tonight but it's uh from an education stand Point matters so this identifies each phase of the six phases and then what the board's uh actions and commitment would be and so um you can review this on your own time I don't need to read it to you but you'll see that phase one we develop the profile and the timeline we bring that to the board for approval uh then we participate in phase two where we do our recruiting and advertising um and during that time many boards will want to participate with their community in uh Anonymous survey collection so that we can develop the kinds of
058expectations your community has for the new leader and then you move into phase three four and five where the board is intimately involved in screening interviewing and uh we like to describe it like a like a funnel because you begin Broad and you end narrow during that month of phase three four and five okay the duties and responsibilities of the Arizona School administrators should we be asked to uh be your representative are identified there they include you know Consulting with the board um my recommendation is um that we would identify a liaison from the board to work with myself as the consultant uh to help facilitate some of the progress along the way of course all actions require board approval but um a boardly aison can help speed the process so that we don't have
059to keep coming back for board meetings um and communicating with the applicants um developing the template Etc um and then uh those are the kind of things that you could expect from from your consultant the duties of the PV board then would be of course uh honoring the open media law and uh referring all the communications from the applicants to the search consultant uh of course being present honoring the open meeting law um and uh maintaining strict confidentiality along the way we recommend that the board uh follow a moratorium with the media and refer all media contacts to the consultant and remembering that in order to have quality candidates uh uh the the responsibilities of the board are are observed by candidates and um their careers are in your hands so to speak particularly in
060the early phases when when uh we're working with candidates you know privately um and uh so those are our guidelines and recommendations along the way so I'm happy to have uh any kind of discussion that that the board would like to have with regards to the process timeline the role of the search consultant of the school administrators Association um we're open for discussion thank you Dr oal does anyone have any uh comments or questions for Miss wanie thank you so much for that um you answered a lot of questions that I already had like through your presentation but I do I do just have a a couple of questions um just even just about the organization itself and and thank you for the introduction where you kind of did speak a little bit about it
061so as a nonprofit um you could could you just speak maybe just generally about like the mission of your organization yeah absolutely thank you for the question the the mission of the Arizona School administrators is to develop strong leadership in school districts um that's why the association exists individual administrators pay dues uh through their district offices and um it's uh uh several thousand membership wide virtually every District across the state um is represented by our association um lots of Staff Development lots of training and conferences for your leadership teams um and um we've in the last few years been doing more of this kind of work because districts have asked us to basically and uh we know lots of board members around the state and um have worked in virtually every County and and folks
062have called and said can you help us so that's kind of how we have emerged into this into this environment okay so it sounds like your your mission is to serve this you know this population and administrators across across our state you you heard a cry for there's like a gap in Services we need this from you something affordable and you guys Rose to the occasion if I'm understand you're saying so so it's been a couple years that you've been helping facilitate these kinds of things I'm sorry I spoke too soon but uh a couple of years for the association yes myself individually I've been doing this for decades okay so you so prior to being a with Asa you you helped run these kinds of searches yes in other organizations yes um were were
063those nonprofit organizations also or were those more of the the for-profit kinds that you had experienced all all nonprofit all of my experience professionally has been with school districts or with uh nonprofit associations okay wonderful and so you've been at this a long time just just would you and I know you you know you're obviously I mean you work for the association but you've seem very trustworthy so if I ask you you know do you think you know that ASA is you know can is rising to the occasion in the same at the same level in the same way that some of these for-profit pricey um Consultants are um like could you kind of give us a sense of your thoughts around that I think we're better okay I think we're better at it because
064we know everybody we know everybody in the state we know the candidates uh we know the colleagues uh we know the culture of each of the districts um and you know not being Brazen in any way but uh we're better at it and just one more question um are you can you how many districts um like at any given time are you working with and if you could just give us a sense of how many um districts in Arizona right now that you're you know helping facilitate their superintendent search efforts um right now we have uh I got a count in my head we have a colleague of mine who tends to work more in Southern Arizona and there are three searches going along uh in that in that area um we're working with uh
065three Suburban Maricopa County districts currently um and one in northern Arizona those are all going on right now and we anticipate a few more coming along the way so yeah great questions thank you Mrs Christensen so I did find my notes from our superintendent search and ASA actually did give an RFQ for us to us last year in addition to mcferson and BR Associates and um I I don't believe that was information they were I believe you can address the two that we talked about right my my question is um how many superintendents have you placed because it was my understanding that ASA was new and that maybe one reason why ASA was not as desirable for a large District such as Paradise Valley Unified School District um specifically how many have you placed um
066as an ass ation or how many superintendents have you placed in school districts myself ASA no oh I I would I would have to count uh Miss chrisan Christensen um I would say probably in the neighborhood of 20 but I and so that was all this year because when we were looking one of the reasons why I when I was doing research on your company you had not placed one one superintendent yet when we were looking on um as of January 11 2024 so are you saying that in over the span of 12 months you've placed 20 superintendents are you sure about that number no I'm not sure about the number and I've also know that during the during the previous year we probably did a dozen during the 2324 hiring cycle so to speak
067and now we have these current ones going on um but I think it's important to understand that the search Consultants themselves each have been doing this kind of work for for Years also in other places the Arizona School administrators Association uh moved into this Arena at the request of members and so as an association it's been a couple of years um but you know our Consultants each of our Consultants are independent contractors and have been doing search work um other places and other times one of my other concerns with Asa was there was some um concerns about integrity and things there was some of the employees that were helping had some um things that were not Kosher and were actually called out for that and I believe one might have actually I won't mention details
068but one of my concerns was um integrity and um do you have the same employees that you did on January of last year 2024 not sure what you're referring to um and none of the search Consultants are employees okay um so you know I myself for example I I'm a former superintendent I'm a former School Board representative and um you know I do independent contract work for the school administrator's Association because I believe in the mission and I want to be helpful to school districts but um none of the Consultants are employees and I'm not sure what you I mean I'm happy to discuss this with you but I'm not quite sure what you were asking anybody else have um I mean I want to make a couple comments having gone through having served on
069this board for a while and having gone through other searches um one of the things I appreciate that Dr Ole has uh communicated is the fact that this is a service of Asa um and that is I don't know if refreshing is the quite the right word but that is different than working with a for-profit firm um I appreciate also that they are Arizona based um any of the firms I know that we have employed in the past and from the most part there are I don't know that there are any others National firms based here in Arizona and so we are dealing with um you know quite often uh having to deal with staff that's out of town having to deal with you know Consultants that are that are not necessarily we we would
070tend to get an Arizona based consultant um but we often would also get a number of folks who are not based in Arizona I have also been concerned in the past about the amount of time uh that our own staff has had to put in to the searches despite the fact that we are supposedly Contracting Services from National firms where we thought that's what we were getting and we were not and um again what I think is is much more um apparent uh in this search if if we were to retain these Services is that we know that our staff will be involved um and we can work out what that looks like and what that means and who that is and we'll know that much more in advance as opposed to oh the Secretary
071of such and such firm suddenly is out and suddenly that means Mrs chisman is going to jump in and do things that weren't on the schedule or weren't uh initially supposed to be under her um so I most of all I do appreciate that ASA understands what it means to be a superintendent in Arizona um not just what we and PV may want versus what the board of Glendale Union is looking for currently or or um Window Rock or um you know another District um and Dr Ole knows uh districts in this state I know my understanding of the other Consultants who I know are Consultants with Asa are uh know as well um the fact is is that because Asa is part of a National Organization this would be a national search it's not
072that it wouldn't um no matter what it is that that we end up determining as the criteria for our superintendent uh and knowing that that National search is conducted through other superintendent associations um I think would be um would provide us a much more expansive potential pool of candidates than some of what I have seen with national search firms who seem to have established a pool of candidates that they often take from opening to opening um I don't know that for sure that may not happen but just in my experience that seems to happen more than I would expect um and so I think the the network of superintend or or School administrators uh groups around the country I think provides us a much broader potential pool um those are just some thoughts uh which
073is why when when the possibility of our being able to retain ASA for this um given past experiences seem to be a very refreshing uh positive alternative Dr Lim can you clarify a little bit for us Dr uh Miss Greenberg if like these talent agencies that you guys have used in the past are focused specifically to Schoolboard searches or these talent agencies that are searching for everything from a CFO a CEO across Healthcare to you know school systems across multiple Talent spaces not just education are they the firms that that we have either used or I believe have provided um you know uh proposals have been focused in the education Arena now they may also be searching for principles they may also be searching for CFOs they may you know it it's not limited to
074superintendence but it from what I've seen tends to be within districts and education okay Mr P Mr panta sorry you are you done yeah I do like what you said about the fact that it's Arizona based but has a national reach you know they they understand uh what the needs of the state are but but they can still find people from beyond our borders to come on in here one thing appeals to me is this whole timeline issue where they make recommendations but in the end we're we're the ones that control how that time those due dates and timelines go you know where we still retain our control through the whole process that way so I find those two things appealing about this one Mrs Christenson yeah for me it's about experience and integrity and
075um we did a detailed rubric and both you and I had come to the same conclusion that we wanted somebody experience exped um the other some of the other companies that were out there have done thousands of placements in Arizona thousands and I'm looking at our rubric notes right now so I'm not going to share information that should not be out in the public but I'm I'm really concerned about not including those other items because there as I mentioned there were three and we did not include ASA we decided to look at more experience firms that have done successful placements in Arizona and at the time because I did do search you um this organization had not placed one superintendent there were other principles Etc like Dr Lim was asking um but our concern here
076is finding the best superintendent for Paradise Valley Unified and that's my concern Miss wanie um Mrs Christensen you keep you keep referring to like a lack of Integrity on the part of the organization and or people associated with it and I just there could you substantiate that in some way so that we as a board can understand what your concern is yeah I'm going to review my notes I don't I don't know if it's a it's it's appropriate because these conversations were done in private I can speak in generalities that when I did a search on this firm there were and thank you for correcting me that you don't have employees but you have people there was one individual and I won't name a name but in Arizona that actually was prosecuted for something that
077was not appropriate in terms of it something illegal so I I'm just very highly concerned and I do have names and I have details but I I don't feel that it's appropriate for me to say that out loud um Mr may I make a comment yes Dr so uh Miss Christensen if I had information like that I'd be concerned also I can assure you that no one in the organization that I'm fam familiar with has ever been prosecuted of anything and every every one of the search consultant is a former superintendent in our state and you know it was held in high esteem by the profession yeah and if I could provide a little context as well too I just wanted to make sure that as we in the retreat we um had a conversation
078around uh what the future is going to look like and I just want to make sure that the community also understands um that although it is a pleasure to have come back uh and serve in this role as interim superintendent it is interim uh I am not a candidate uh for uh for the long-term uh leadership of this District um also a longtime member of Asa um and not aware of any concerns regarding uh in Miss wanie um Dr Ole you you just a moment ago you you brought up that your the Consultants are um former superintendents could you could you give us a little bit more just just sort of background on like like how many consultants and how long they've been with you and just the scope of of work that they do
079for you thank you sure yep thank you for your thank you for your uh question um so um our Southern Arizona person so to speak is Dr Nick Clement who is a longtime Superintendent at Flowing Wells School District he is now a a a professor um in Ed leadership at Northern Arizona University um Dr jorstad is doing search Consultants is a search consultant for us he is the former executive director of the Arizona School administrators Association um former superintendent um in the West Valley and um out um in the west side just outside Maricopa County uh but was also an administrator in a number of West Side District Suburban districts um uh we also have utilized Dr Santa relli former Superintendent at Peoria he is now he is currently facilitating the search for Glendale Union
080um and myself I'm a uh uh I was a 10-year superintendent in Suburban Indiana and then I was the executive director of the Arizona school boards Association for eight years um and have been uh doing independent contract work for ASA for the last couple of years um that's basically the team that we utilize as search Consultants thank you and um at any given point in time how many uh searches would any consultant be sort of helping facilitate um occasionally there's two um right now um we have uh Dr Clement uh facilitating two in the Southern Arizona region and there's another one who that was just approved I believe last night um in Yuma County so he'll be finishing up one and then facilitating two others um Dr Santelli is currently working with Glendale Union um
081I am currently working with Avendale L um and we're in the final stages there we're in Phase probably phase uh four just about to enter into phase five in the next week so I'll be wrapping that one up here pretty soon myself um Dr jorstad is currently doing uh the search for Winslow Unified District in northern Arizona so um that's what we have going as we speak yeah Mr Christensen I would like to make a motion to move that we revisit the detailed analysis that and Greenberg president Greenberg and I did last year um I'm willing to work tomorrow to do that just be I don't want to make a mistake on this this is one of our most important decisions and there was a reason why we had bring things a certain way and
082I would really like to revisit that and um so I I moved to revisit the RF q's and the detailed I moved to table this so that we can revisit the rfqs and that an and I could revisit the detailed analysis that we've done prior I'm going to look over it uh Miss Baran just to make sure uh we wouldn't revisit the RFQ start all over we would start all over correct right so there's I mean we can't go back to the previous they expired so what given that I'm Mo to revisit other companies to table this item at this time I don't think we have enough information miss m because you guys kind of started that process last time can you just share with us so that you know those of us that were
083not privy to that what that timeline looked like um from like the time that you sort of initiated that process until you know what to whatever point you got to like procuring you know the bids and just can you can you kind of give us a sense of the timeline last time I don't have it right in front of me Mr Christenson do you um it was about two to 3 months and when we were finally doing the evalu the final evaluation it was about January 11th that's one of my biggest concerns because that's why I had brought this matter up to put on an agenda but it I was rejected on that um to talk about this sooner because we we are running against the clock here um and we were ready to go
084forward with this and we ended up deciding to go with a local search based on a a we decided to do an interim superintendent rather than going forward with the search but it was yeah we were at the end stages and we were getting ready to pick and it was January 11th but we started the process I want to say October November time frame does anybody have any comments there is a motion on the floor to table I presume the approval the potential approval president green sorry to interrupt but I do have the timeline from last time if that would be helpful thank you Mrs be yes so December 7th the request for quote was distributed to all potential biders December 21st was the closing date and three valid proposals were received from Arizona School
085administrators mcferson and Jacobson and Ray and Associates December 22nd was the evaluation that you and Mrs Christensen did and January 12th were interviews the selection committee requested to hold interviews with the top rank firms as part of the evalu valuation and the selection and award of contract didn't occur at any point after that January 12th was really the last part of the timeline does that answer your question Miss W on Mr panta do you remember uh the cost of these other uh companies would have cost the district if we' used them I want to say in the 50,000 range if you gave me a few minutes I might be able to find I have the exact numbers but I don't know if that's appropriate at this time because we would have to do a public
086information it's all that information I have it I have it on my I have the rubric okay so it would be for the two finalists their prices certainly may have changed but if the referen is for La the pricing from last time yep that's public information at this point okay I have the rubric with the detailed information but I'll have to you have it okay perfect y um while and I think or doc uh president Greenberg when you were discussing um you know sort of your thought process around oh yeah you know let's hear a little bit from ASA I think you mentioned um you know just your experience in the past that you've had with outside you know large for-profit firms and sort of like I think the potential burden that that can sometimes
087have on our staff here um so a question if I could you know poee to you because that is I think definitely a concern you know that that we def we spoke about at our Retreat which was you know we don't want to put you know we want to avoid putting a burden on you know on an in-house kind of search or you know we've we're already tapped out and as you know I don't need to tell you you're an educator in Arizona you know there's only so many resources and so could you tell us what that would look like as far as you know the utilization of our you know Department here and HR here to best facilitate this search sure U thank you Miss wanie um when you hire you know if if
088you hire me so to speak as a search consultant um it's my job to to do that work um now developing the profile which is the very beginning you know I would need assistance from you know you're probably Mr Dro to get data and you know local profiles and those kind of things uh but beyond that that's the responsibility of the search consultant and uh I don't know if I can access the slides anymore but when you have the duties uh you know of the association uh basically that's that's what you hire us to do and so um you know that that's how we do it that's you know that's when when you when you hire us to do the job we get it done and we work our tales off for you thank you
089Mrs CH president Greenberg um the exact numbers were in the bond fire Hub portal and I wonder if Miss B has access to that because that's not letting me I don't but I've texted uh Miss Eva Kai as our director of purchasing so hopefully she'll get us something short of Mr Panter do you have a question I mean if you have the numbers let's well I Oh I thought you okay thank you no I I don't have them I'm asking our director of purchasing to get them okay I don't have access to that system I got you I mean I I think Mrs beran was right they were probably in the neighborhood between 40 and $50,000 that's why I remember for services alone that doesn't include and obviously it wouldn't with with Asa either but
090it doesn't include travel it doesn't include anything like that um you know it also doesn't include the support that our staff will give no matter whether we hire um ASA as a consultant or we hire another firm there will also be um you know costs involved that way I you know again in looking at it um based on Dr Ogle's presentation based on on the information provided it feels to me like we would get at the very least um the the equivalent of the services we would be getting um from a firm such as our two finalist last time Reign Associates and and who was it mcferson yes um with the added bonus that that the um outline cost is much less um and the bonus that um we know the individuals we we work
091individual or individuals we working with are Arizona based and I do think that is a bonus in this case although some of the other vendors had had people individuals that were based out of Arizona no we will we will always get somebody based out of Arizona but I will say again based on my experience in doing this um the last time we had a search our main consultant was based in California even though we had Arizona based consultants and um I was quite honestly surprised about that because it it the person that we worked with was was excellent but they weren't based here and they did not know they didn't know Arizona the to that to the extent that that I believe Dr ogal and and the other ASA folks do right well I but
092I would argue that one of them in particular placed over a thousand superintendents in Arizona schools and according to our notes with that may be true but that's going to that is absolutely over a number of years so you're talking about a number of different Consultants right and that's what I was pushing is they had the experience they had the the individuals they had a they cast a wider net um but yes we have to consider all things including price and they were more expensive yeah and I I'm not I mean The Wider net piece is also on us um my past experience is we have options in terms of for example advertising and again that's an expense we incur and so um we can do that we can you know those are pieces that
093that can happen no matter who we would potentially hire to assist us but it was my understanding that that was part of the process and and that was the those advertisements were included in a lot of the vendors out no they're looking at they're not and if they are I mean it's built into the price right and the advertising is not that expensive but I'm so but it's not a matter of they have a wider I mean that net can be cast no matter who's doing the who's who's assisting us with the search can I just clarify up yes you know there's there's plus or minus 260 school districts in our state and so there haven't been thousands of placements even in a decade so that that math doesn't make sense maybe they mean nationally
094probably nationally I'll look must because there's only there's only 260 some districts in our state and we and some of our districts have been around for many many decades but yeah it's probably nationally yeah that would I would that would make more sense Mrs Baran if you gotten any do we it was 32,000 for Ray and Associates and 38,700 for mcferson and I believe both of those also charge expenses yes typically that's typical for the private firms the way they do their biding yeah so that was a little less than I remembered but president Greenberg is there any way we could clarify again what the cost of Asa would be we submitted a a proposal of I believe it's not to exceed $10,000 but um I have it right here okay I found it thank
095you I I believe it's on the last page of the agreement it looks like it's the district shall pay 8,000 plus expenses yeah it's a yeah 8,000 plus expenses the expenses typically because there wouldn't be a travel allow you know you don't have to pay uh folks to fly in uh it's there really wouldn't be any travel um so it's really more criminal history checks um and miscellaneous other things but it it's a not to exceed 10,000 8,000 does say 8,000 I mean there will you know if if we have candidates from out of state then we will incur travel costs that way but that's that's going to happen no matter who assists us in a search yeah we don't you know you can't pay their travel so nor can we because of the gift
096Clause right in our in our state we do have a motion on the table can we call the question and decide I'll call for the question can we vote on on this on the motion before us okay the motion before us is to table consideration of um approval of uh the ASA executive Search Services agreement is there any further just well you call the question so there's no further discussion all those in favor of tabling uh consideration of approval of the ASA executive Search Services agreement please say I I all those opposed please say Nay Nay Nay any abstentions I abstain Dr limb Dr wannie was I was an I an I oh no I'm an a an a sorry so to continue the discussion okay so the motion fails uh one I three Nays
097and an exstension so we are continuing the discussion uh to consider uh well right now we're still in discussion of the presentation uh so may I have please have a motion to retain the services of the Arizona School administrators Inc for the purpose of conducting a superintendent search and approve the ASA executive Search services agreement as presented Mr Panter so moved all right now we have the item for approval on the floor for discussion and I will open it up if there is any further discussion on this item miss miss juie so you know again just kind of thinking about the timeline here you know I I I just I do have I have concerns around um you know a two to three month delay before even starting search when we know there are all
098these other districts that are also seeking candidates um and it's not to rush the process by any means but I guess from my perspective um you don't know I don't I don't know that I've really personally heard anything that would convince me that ASA would do a lesser job than one of these National firms and so if you kind of are balancing these things um timeline quality of candidates right like knowledge of ER a providing a service which is why they can have this reduced cost for us um I mean right because every all decisions are kind of like a balancing you've got to youve got to look at it like that if we had all the time in the world and all the money in the world I mean we might actually land at
099the same exact spot and that's kind of where I'm where you know how I'm trying to think about this um to be to be frank so um you know I think I would I would be more inclined to even have a have a Contin Ed conversation if the timeline wasn't what it was because we we could indulge in that but I'm I'm not I guess again I'm just going to reiterate that I I I'm not convinced that ASA wouldn't be the Top Choice sort of no matter what all things being constant and so that's kind of where I'm at right now in this conversation Mrs Christensen Mrs Bergen corrected that it was not a three-month process it was it only took us a couple of weeks because we did we were running into Christmas break
100and so it it was during during the month of yes of December and then we came back from break and then we don't have that break this time we don't have um Christmas break that we're running into so if we do a accelerated look at this I think we have time to entertain our f use from a another vendor or two and I think it to it would be best to do our due diligence and look at more than one rather than just vote Yes and move forward or vote no today Dr Lim um president Greenberg I just W to um hopefully get some clarification on kind either whether it's from you having done this or whether from Dr Ole about if we were to delay the timeline assume it takes four weeks to even
101get those rfqs and get those conversations happening does that put us behind the ball in that we are not going to have a good pool of candidates to select from because we're selecting in May or almost June and is that going to put us at a detriment of picking a superintendent that is appropriate for an extremely large um District it won't help Dr would you agree yeah the the marketplace tends to run um from you know November December up into April and May that's sort of the cycle in the normal year um so so the short answerers yes it doesn't it it's better to get moving um but you know as your organization that you pay dues to be a member of our Council would be you should be comfortable with the process and not
102you know because it is a really important moment in time for your school district and so we're here to serve and help you know that's our job and we can do this for you um we can you know we'd love to be of service and help you and we think we would do a great job but we want everybody to be com comfortable and uh this is a time for a board to work together and unite around the strategy and so um you know if if that's the way it plays out then we're still here to support you and uh you know we're happy to get moving we'll get moving tomorrow if you ask us to anybody Mrs Christensen yes and and I appreciate those comments because I am not comfortable I'm not comfortable with
103this process on November 19th I did send an email to president case can we reconvene the superintendent search committee sooner rather than later I'm available to me after Thanksgiving come up with the plan and I was told that the superintendent position would reconvene when the new board convened so I think we've put oursel in that own precarious position and we did have plenty of times we had we've had several board meetings W with the previous board where we could have started this process and then still allowed this board to make the decisions while we can't go back in time I really think we need to do this the right way this is such an important decision and to just go with one presentation one search firm is is a mistake in my opinion anybody else
104have any comments well I would really hate to take more time time and put us at more of a disadvantage uh only to find out we're going to use ASA anyway because I so far I haven't heard anything except unsubstantiated rumors about some kind of illegality uh that put that would infringe upon my confidence in this this particular organization so I'm really against putting this off so Mrs Christian yes um taking away that comment of Mrs president Greenberg and I did do a thorough search and there were three and we just we had decided on two others for a reason and there were other reasons why it wasn't because of that comment so um I would I would just really plead with this board to take this very serious and and to I mean it
105it wouldn't hurt to entertain an RFQ from a couple of search Firs they already do search firms in other districts and um I'm sure they can pull things together rather quickly via the search Firs Mrs Baran can you maybe address how the uh procurement rubric process works so that board members who haven't been involved in that have a sense of that um in terms of the rubric you can set up a rubric as you see fit you worked with uh Mrs Ka excuse me Mrs kaaz last time to I think develop that rubric and what was important and relevant to you um what I would say is you'd be looking probably at about a three-week minimum process I've never seen an RFQ or RFP go out for less than two weeks and even that's pretty
106rare when we did it that way last time um so I would suggest doing no less than two weeks it's you know it takes a lot of work to to put all of that together um and then time for them to evaluate whoever the evaluation committee would be Miss Wy and so last year there were three correct one of which was ASA is that correct or not that's correct okay um and so at like best case scenario we're talking four four to six weeks something like that I think you could do it very tightly in three weeks but then you know when I'm when I'm hearing Mr Ole say that uh excuse me Dr Ole say um that there are a number that are further along in the process that's where the you know potential
107harm could be done understood okay I mean I want to address the um yes Mrs Christenson you sent a note asking to I don't remember how you put it but but start the process start process um but I when I got that email um I mean the and maybe that was maybe I was I was interpreting your email a little bit differently but the circumstances were such that while I understand what you're saying is that we would be at a place where we would asked for an RFQ we would have gone through the same process I think we were also I was trying to be cognizant of the fact that we did have new board members coming in I was trying to have discussions with Dr Reynolds as to um you know his his thoughts
108moving forward in terms of uh potenti po Al remaining or not as superintendent and so there were a number of pieces and balls being juggled uh so it felt the best that that it would be better to wait for the new board to be able to deal with it because there were just question marks and other pieces so that's and again it was towards the holidays as you said you weren't avail ailable until after Thanksgiving um I think you know we we were up against that again as well go ahead Mr Christensen right and um I I fully understood that the new board was going to select the new superintendent that's why I wanted to start the process sooner so that we can get rfqs and things like that and then decide who would if
109we had another committee but it it's a moot point at this point um it's it's passed and we can move forward and decide I just I just think it would be a very big mistake to just decide today to go with one firm when we haven't received rfqs from others Dr Lim um Dr o I do have a question for you just talking about um the work that you're doing have you had any unsuccessful um searches for super superintendent uh either in your time working with this organization or previously and what does that look like uh no I haven't um personally um and it's important to know that that the search consultant doesn't place superintendence the board this is a board process the search consultant is a facilitator and a consultant but the board it
110makes the decisions and calls the shots and so in my uh I have Decades of working with boards um I've not been personally involved in a failed search I know districts that that has happened to it's unfortunate uh I've not had that experience great thank you are there any other comments or questions right so we do have a motion on the floor [Music] um to retain the services of Asa for the purposes of conducting a superintendent search and approve the ASA executive Search Services agreement as presented all those in favor please say I I I I I all those opposed please say nay nay I don't see that there are any extensions the motion passes 4 to one thank you Dr Ural will continue the discussion all right thank you president Greenberg thank you members
111of the board um and just know we'll we'll do our best to make this as efficient and effective as possible and look forward to working with you thank you thank you so next on the agenda is acceptance of gifts and donations we actually have many here and I'd like to highlight a few well this is still going to be long but I'd like to highlight a few um at Echo Mountain inter Intermediate School Dorito Partners Incorporated uh donated $11,000 for prizes for the school caught being kind store at greyhawk uh the PTO um provided more than $1600 for third and second grade field trips uh at Greenway Middle School uh merich I hope I pronounced that correctly merri management company provided $5,000 for the site discretionary fund and Northstar Foundation provided $155,000 for the site
112discretionary fund at Horizon High School Morgan Stanley for shanovich gifting account provided $2,000 for the ban program and Barry and Julia Smith provided donated $3,000 for the just serve Club supplies and food at Mercury mine uh Freeport McMoRan Foundation donated $2,000 for a mineral geography Outdoor Learning stations at Mountain Trail Middle School Shutterfly donated just over $11,000 to the site discretionary fund at North Canyon the Slender Birds Foundation donated $1,000 for boys golf at Paradise Valley High School carvana donated $10,000 to the automotive program supp for the automotive program supplies and tools Justin's donated $2,000 for faculty appreciation staff development PV online our PV schools education Foundation donated just under $113,000 for intelligent insights canvas extension for PV online and the PB USD fine arts department PB schools Education Foundation donated just under $2,000 for
113clay for empty bowls and the musical instrument museum donated $1,500 for bus expenses for MIM field trips uh Shadow Mountain uh asbo International donated $2,500 for the Eagle Award scholarship and Thunder Birds Foundation donated 1,000 for the girls golf program and at Sweetwater Community School Northstar Foundation donated $12,000 for PBIS for refresh signs that promote the program incentives for students and staffs staff and funds develop a community center that promotes team building so we thank all of our donors if any of you are here thank you in person if you know anyone um on the list uh please extend our congratulations Mr panta may have a motion to accept gift and donations please I move that we accept uh the gifts and donations does any board member have a comment or question seeing none all
114in favor please say I I I I any opposed say nay uh any extensions the motion passes unanimously uh next on the agenda we have two items that were moved from the consent agenda so the first is consideration to approve purchase from current Cooperative contract adsp 161 96282 for iboss cloud security um shall I give it Dr Reynolds over to you thank you um Miss Baran would be here to answer any questions that you might have thank you Miss beran I would like to know how a Cooperative contract differs from actually we need a motion on the floor first and then then we'll open it up soon this is just for for um for yes this is for what was F10 uh for the iboss cloud security is now G G3 G4 four G4 okay
115uh moving item G4 so moved okay now does any board member have any questions or comments Mr Christenson yes um thank you Mrs Bergen how does a Cooperative contract differ from a j i um was wondering what other vendors were considered and what was the decision making process uh to come up with the final decision for this contract okay so Cooperative contracts and Joc's are somewhat related but they are not even really the same it's not even comparing apples and oranges it's not like both are fruit one is a fruit and one is a chair Cooperative contracts uh can be for any number of Commodities so Joc which is capital projects is one commodity that could be considered under a Cooperative contract um School Furnishings is another item that could be considered under a Cooperative
116Contract Office Supplies under a Cooperative contract anything that a school district buys can be done under a Cooperative contract and a Cooperative contract allows us to pull our resources and the potential spend together with other districts um and some other um public agencies to take advantage of larger buying power and for that procurement to be done by a lead agency a lead District we take a lead on many of them um so that others can take advantage of them and then we take advantage of ones that other districts have done as well so that's a Cooperative contract J is one way to procure Construction Services for a school district that expedites the process up to 3 million for our district A J can be under a Cooperative contract um but they're not they don't have
117to go together and you can have a j without a Cooperative contract thank you understood so for example when GPA would be considered a Cooperative contract or that no when GPA is an agency that helps develop Cooperative contracts okay so they're a level above so it's and then they would okay I don't know about a level above but they're the comp they're a company that that that is their so purpose is to develop Cooperative contracts in conjunction with districts okay um so what other vendors were considered it in this decision um okay so SEC um it vetted uh additional vendors and some of these included Cisco umbrella goguardian and light speed and um was the process to come up with the final decision based on price or offerings or probably a combination of both I
118hope um so in the time between we got the question and we're able to put this together uh Miss copen got sick so I have her notes on this but we also have is he still here Mr Jeff Billings is here to answer any detailed questions so iboss was selected because it's the um it Department's strongest recommendation that it's the most Superior product for K12 education um due to what it provides for malware virus protection compatibility with Chromebooks Dell and MacBooks since we have all of those um and best in class but if we have um any more detailed questions I'm sure Mr Billings can answer them for us thank you that's sufficient I I I did I was able to click on the links and look and they were very um all-encompassing and so
119I was very impressed with this fendor so I I just wanted some clarification on the process and thank you thank you Miss wannie um I was just curious um I miss I mean I I know Mr Jeff billing so I know we've got to have uh some serious security in place now so I was just curious to know what do what do we have now and like can what's the compar like is it a comparison and is this to replace something that we already have that's going to be a question for Mr Billings Professor B all I know is I have to log in every 24 hours soon to be every 12 oh and my children's passwords are like how in the world do you remember those so but they do somehow yeah that's a
120that's a whole another set of questions about uh working with younger very young and uh children who are are challenged with um everything from dyslexia to uh language Learners English language Learners right so it's getting there's some things coming down the pike but uh your question this is I don't know if you're familiar with Gartner Gartner Miss Christen is uh they're um kind of world class financial and information technology advisor globally right and iboss is in What's called the upper quadrant which is they're a leader okay uh whereas others are are Challengers uh in the K12 space so it's best of class but miss Baran and my my supervisor Miss copen uh pushed me further and we actually got a 25% discount so this is a contract renewal that is at 25% thank you thank
121you any other questions any other questions for professor or Billings seeing none are there any other questions or comments in regard to this item uh so we have a motion on the floor all those in favor of approving uh purchase from I'm not going to read the alphabet soup here uh the the current Cooperative contract for iboss cloud security please say I I I any oppose please say nay any extensions the motion passes unanimously we also moved former item F12 from the consent agenda to become G5 I believe it is consideration approval to renew existing District contract 2206 PV for public affairs and government relations Consulting Mr Pantera may have a motion to approve I move uh G5 so move thank you is there any uh disc well is there any discussion this Christensen yes
122thank you I first of all I I would like a reminder of how much these are because when we got the information we I know it's been approved and this was a multiple year contact but I didn't remember the dollar amount so that was my first question and then um the second question is what is the difference in the firms I know I remember deina they provided information provide information on um things that were coming from the legislature and they a lobbying organization um and I was not familiar with high ground so I didn't know if they were competing and both providing that or if highr was doing something maybe perhaps with bonds and overrides or something if just clarification so the sorry the two questions are how much are we paying these two firms
123and what what are the firms doing for PV okay so starting with Deena we uh are paying them $54,000 this year for the lobbying services for our district and I I just want to note that this is the renewal of an existing contract not the purchase so this is a renewal of a Cooperative contract that includes you you know that we do multiple vendors when we award um Cooperative contracts so the two vendors that are on there are demena who we do use and high ground who we don't happen to use but this is so that anybody else who's interested in Services can take advantage from either High ground or demena we use the Mena for our superintendent advisory team um to provide legislative updates you're welcome thank you Miss beran you're welcome are there
124any other questions or comments seeing none all those in favor I lost the number again all those in favor uh to approve uh the renewal of existing District contract 2206 PV for public affairs and government relations Consulting please say I I I I all those opposed please say nay any obenson passes unanimously thank you next on the agenda is call to the public so I would ask that you turn your attention to the video monitors call to the public is about to convene this portion of today's meeting allows the public the opportunity to address the governing board although state law does not require that the governing board hold a call to the public The Paradise Valley Unified School District and its board have chosen to do so because we believe it's important to hear about
125concerns and issues from our community while call to the public is not designed to be a discussion the board is here to listen due to Arizona open meeting law the governing board cannot respond to discuss or take any action on items brought up during this time however staff members may be directed to get back to you and address individual concerns as a reminder the point of this and every board meeting is to accomplish the business at hand and to be able to do so in an open and collaborative way all in attendants are expected to observe meeting rules as well as rules of politeness and decorum so that we may serve as an example to our students that issues can be discussed in a respectful and civil [Music] manner thank you tonight we have four
126people who have submitted uh comment cards prior to the start of the meeting so each speaker will have three minutes for remarks as a reminder we ask that you please direct your comments to the board and state your first and last name when you come to the podium um our first speaker will be Aaron McDonald followed by Ashley Stokes hi good evening everyone I'm Aaron McDonald um I'm a mother here at Paradise Valley School District I serve on the board of mercury mine ptg I started the PTO at uh Shay middle school and now I'm the vice president of the high school uh PTO so I love volunteering I also volunteered for the school closure committee which I don't recommend volunteering for but I am here tonight and and Mr Panera I'm so glad you
127talked about parent engagement because something that our parents are very engaged in in our community is um baseball so I am here tonight with my baseball mom shirt on I would like the board to consider leasing the fields to smash baseball we've uh our community our our boys and girls have been playing together for years and years and we would like to continue that Tradition at our home fields at Roadrunner we also uh the board at smash has an opportunity to replace the lights that were um tipped over by time and the elements um so there's a tremendous opportunity to improve school grounds um at no cost to you and just really keep communities together and keep our kids playing boys and girls we have softball and baseball uh so I just really encourage you
128to let smash have the lease for the fields at Roadrunner school uh thanks so much sorry next will be Ashley Stokes followed by Susan Winder thank you my name is Ashley Stokes um and thank you for the opportunity to speak to you today um I am a proud parent of three kids in the PB schools one at Shea Middle planning to go to Shadow Mountain next year and two at Mercury mine um for full disclosure I am on the board of smash the Shadow Mountain Area sports home um but I'm really speaking to you as a parent um a few years ago after covid I think you know my family felt pretty isolated um and and kind of cut off from the Greater Community after all of the shutdowns and my son came to me
129and said I want to play baseball and I said I think you're too old uh and and so I asked around and there was a local League um and they said sure bring them out no no skill level needed um and so he played and he lost every game and it was a rough season and I thought okay this experiment's over we're done we're good I've enjoyed it but we're okay uh and lo and behold he wanted to play again and again and again and again and we have played every season since uh and I've become more and more involved and engaged in my local community and um it's really become a place where my family goes my daughters both now play in the softball program and it's it's really become kind of our our
130home away from home um they go to school all day uh and then in the afternoons you know we go out and we play baseball and softball and it has turned into um really just a love for all of my kids um the league has now switched over to a new organization um and I have already registered my kids I'm excited to play again um I've put countless hours into those fields um Field improvements and you know I just I I love this league uh and so I am also hoping that you will um encourage whatever decision has to happen um to allow smash to continue that Community feeling at the Roadrunner field um they are named after Nancy Lane uh and we have spoken to Mark Lane uh and I I think he is
131um although a little league guy I think he is on board with our vision uh for our community and the growth that we see for um this community and so I think that's all I have to say so thank you thank you next is Susan wer followed by Julie bloomen R good evening um my name is Susan wer and I'm a taxpayer in pvusd let me congratulate the new board members um I look forward to seeing how you make decisions and upon which you base them as you are aware I ran on the conservative slate for pvusd as is obvious the liberal slate won I would like to remind the board that you represent 100% of the taxpayers in PB USD that that means even the ones that did not vote for you the split
132between conservative and liberal slates was 48% for the Liberals 42% for the conservatives not a huge win president Trump won by a much larger margin reflecting that most of the US voted conservatively now I know you are thinking but Schoolboard elections are nonpartisan we all know that's not true president Trump has stated he is going to immediately make an executive order that there can be no deel in curriculum in us we'll have to wait and see if he does that last year your language arts committee did an outstanding job of selecting new curriculum shortly after the beginning of the school year they discovered some seal and Dei in one grade they immediately went through and tore out the pages unfortunately your social studies committee did not do such a good job in the teachers manual
133from K to five or k to six what ever it is in the front of the manual has a page that tells the teachers how to include seal in teaching the curriculum I encourage you to follow what the uh language arts committee did and tear that out I'm going to change what the rest of my comment was because I have to make some comments about the superintendent search first off Mrs Christensen thank you for your bravery and your consistency I 500% agree with you I know Mrs Greenberg you've said you've done this over over within your 20 years experience so I share this with you if you want more of what you got continue to do what you do Arizona in the probably the fast past 10 years has never ranked any more than 46
134to 50% in achievement and so we're going to continue to do what we do go for it if that's what you want also it's not about money it's about what is best for the students and what superintendent will come in and make achievement and issue I'm going to run out of time but I ask you you want to keep things in Arizona like this company does I wouldn't I would look to what Florida does thank you and the last card is Julie blim R good evening president Greenberg um to all the governing board members Dr Reynolds cabinet STA and all the guests here today and online anyone watching later I'm Julie blumen R I am the 2024 2025 United parent council president and I just wanted to take a minute to congratulate the new board
135members and to all of the members of the board just wanted to wish you all a Happy New Year and the most success in the year ahead and let you know that we are looking forward to your leadership for the district and to working with each of you on behalf of all PB schools parents and families as we strive to do all we can to enhance the education experience for all students in the district so thank you and happy New Year thank you very much there are no items for discussion this evening so before we adjourn I would like to remind you that the next regular board meeting will be held on Thursday February 6 2025 at 6:30 I also would ask that all board members uh not bolt out of here because we have
136some signatures we need um so Mr panta may have a motion to adjourn so moved all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say nay motion passes unanimously we are adjourned