CorpusRecord 5585

December 12th, 2024 Governing Board Meeting and Public Hearing

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PVSchools
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,664 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-05-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e it is 6:30 and I would like to call this meeting to order and before we do anything else can we give those amazingly talented students another round of applause and are there any parents here of These Fine students can you stand up and we can thank you for sharing them with us right thank you so much um I should have asked you to stay standing because I would ask everybody to please rise and we will be led in the Pledge of Allegiance by our performers and that will be followed by a Moment of Silence to honor the memory of Horizon High School teacher Robert swoverland who has been an employee with our district since 2005 United States of America stand na indivisible andice for thank you very much may I have roll call please

002Mr panta here Mrs case here Mrs Greenberg here Mrs Baker here Mrs Christensen here thank you you also will notice we have two other individuals um up here and uh these are our newly elected board members who will be joining us officially uh next year but they're here shadowing I guess for the the meeting and I'd like to welcome Dr Amanda Lim and Jessica kwani so next on the agenda is approval of agenda Dr Reynolds thank you to president Greenberg governing board cabinet and guests items approved by consent will not come up for discussion during the meeting but will be approved when the agenda is adopted this is possible since members of the governing board received the agenda along with backup materials at least 24 hours prior to the meeting and have had time to

003review and consider all items prior to the agenda being adopted members of the governing board may ask that an item be removed from the consent agenda and brought to the floor for discussion at the appropriate place on the agenda any member of the audience who submitted a blue public comment card prior to the start of the meeting will be recognized to speak on the agenda item under items for approval president Greenberg I would like to offer the agenda as posted thank you very much prior to the meeting we received no blue public comment cards so no member of the audience is asked to move anything from the consent agenda does any member of the governing board wish to have an item removed from consent seeing none Mrs Baker may have a motion to approve the

004meeting agenda and recommended consent agenda items so moved all those in favor please say I I I any opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on our agenda is governing board statements um obviously as the last meeting of the year uh we we all have I think something to say but I will see Mr panta do you have thank you president Greenberg welcome everyone happy holidays um whatever you celebrate I hope it's a joyous time for you it was really great to hear the musicians um in from Mountain Trails that's in my neighborhood so it's nice to know we have that kind of talent So Close by it's very exciting to see them when I was in student in elementary school I played the old liquor stick I can't tell you how many

005reads I split so uh that gave that up um shortly thereafter today I had the pleasure of visiting the Ridge Eagle Ridge got to be there this morning for a spelling be I was one of the judges for a spelling be competition yeah know if you knew me you'd know how surprising that might be I thought it must be like an honorific you know you show up and well we've got a board member there no they put me to work there there's list you have to look at there's things you have to write down and it was um it was very interesting very rewarding uh especially the parts because you know it's they're trying to spell these words but they have to sometimes be given um parameters like it's a homonym or they can use

006a definition or use it in a sentence and there's rules about how these are done I I found it very fascinating because if they say oh spell night well which one like the one on Shining Armor or is it night time outside it's not just all phonics you know you got to know what they mean and how to use them it was it was great um and I really liked it I hope they invite me again maybe they'll let me ring the bell this time that little bell out there you I was good on a personal note I'm really excited you know how I I'm always trying to say hey get more kids in the district come on bring them out we need more more students well I'm having one come to the district seems

007out my uh granddaughter Matilda she's going to be moving here into the district soon hopefully going to Sandpiper right the Dual Spanish emerging class so I'm very excited about that it's like my big holiday gift for me uh it's a great District I've been enjoying it uh I hope we see more and more kids come I've done my part now it's all your turn to bring some in uh so that concludes my comments thank you Mr panta Mrs Christensen good evening everyone uh first off I want to congratulate our new governing board members and welcome them on the Das with us today um we're glad you're here and as um I want to piggyback off of a couple of Mr banta's comments I I was a clarinet player and I used to break some reads

008myself so I really appreciate the um all of the musicians that come to play for us before the board meetings it really warms my heart um welcome to all the family and Friends of the of the new board members as well as parents Educators and constituents who are here at this board meeting today I also had the privilege of being a judge at the Pinnacle Peak prep spelling be and I did get to ring the bell so um I'm so proud of all the students who participated and grateful that in a world of spell check AI autocorrect and texting via crazy acronyms that we still have great spellers in our district so kudos to the teachers that really um are educating our our students and I would like to thank Mrs Estrada who was my

009son's favorite Elementary School teacher that invited me to be a judge um as I was exiting I sent a picture with her and myself to my college kid and he immediately facetimed me and he wanted to say hello and so I had to walk back in and um he was able to say hello to her and some staff members and this is just a testament to the impact that our great teachers leave on our students and so you know kudos to all our Educators and you know even in college they remember you and they appreciate you so I just I thought that was really neat I finally I would just like to thank Mrs Baker and Mrs case for their service and um I've really loved getting to know both of you and um while

010we don't always agree on everything I've I feel like we've really learned a lot and I think we learn a lot when we have differ views and opinions so I really appreciate your service on the board so and congratulations on your retirement thank you Mrs Christensen Mrs Baker Mr panta I brought six kids to the district so I did my part as well um I didn't write anything out because I I just couldn't find the words um first of all welcome everyone to our final meeting of the year um I've been I missed the last two meetings I've been out of town I been traveling to um while I might not be serving Educators and students in this District I am still serving Educators and students across the state and so I was I was

011in CC and St Louis really working on things that we could bring here to help students and teachers um I am I'm grateful for the opportunity to serve I think each and every person who has reached out who answered my questions who took me on tours of the schools um who invited me places it's just been a really wonderful experience and I'm grateful for the opportunity um welcome to the new board members um and Mrs case you are incredible you have taught me so much in just my two years and um you've really left your mark so thank you our new board I'm sure will lead with our most vulnerable students in mind just as we have and I'm sure they will make the best decisions possible as we move forward into 2025 and I'm

012excited to see what they do and and I I just I'm like I said I'm I'm really grateful and I'm really sad this is my last meeting but um it it was truly an honor to serve so thank you thank you Mrs Baker Mrs case this is different I don't quite know lot of emotions going on here um first off want to speak about um last week we had PV voice and it was wonderful it's one of my favorite things that we do in our district I got to be part of the board that started PV voice and and that was a really good thing that we did um we were speaking about the AI parameters in the future and trying to put yourself in the future with some of the these things and what

013we should what parameters the district should have was really quite interesting and the ability of our students to express themselves was very evident our future will be bright with these students as our leaders secondly I want to correct any wrong impression I might have left with my previous comments about the processes with which we choose vendors and contractors we use the same processes which most of the school districts in Arizona use in fact we often procure the new vendors and contractors and Lead the Way in this process I want to say I have complete confidence in Jill bargan and in the Integrity with which she and her team select vendors and contractors we are very fortunate to have someone as capable and honest as she is over Finance we also are fortunate to have Dr

014Drew Davis over facilities and construction I have known Dr Davis for many years and he is a man of integrity and ability so I felt after the board meeting last time that I had left the wrong impression and I wanted to make sure that people understood that I was the process was not what I was it was the process it wasn't the people we have amazing people in this district and I have full faith in their h honesty and in their integrity so with that said yes I can admit when I'm wrong when I say something wrong um I have very mixed motions about ending my time on the board in some ways I'm Giddy and in other ways I'm very sad because this is a chapter in my life which has um well I

015thought I'll just read what I have in many ways I have grown up with the amazing staff in PB schools district our oldest child started kindergarten at Village Vista in the fall of 1984 that's 40 years ago our youngest graduated from PB high school May of 2017 so for 33 years I had children attending school in PB School District I was the mom who volunteered in the classroom helping children learn how to read I never xeroxed not my thing in the process of helping I learned to spell I'll never forget the time when I was 32 or 33 I called my mom and said Mom I know how to spell and she she was in shock and she couldn't believe it and um I had been helping in the the classrooms and I learned I

016am not a sight spell like my husband is I am a a logic speller and I had learned all those rules and parts of uh that so truly I have grown up in this District this the teachers in this District have become mentors and friends to myself and to my children started in 1987 we started to have a teacher appreciation dinner in our home every spring um through this tra this tradition we got to know the teachers even more and so because we have seven children it got busy and in high school you could choose two and when they were a senior they could have the principal over or in sixth grade they could have the principal over also if they wanted to and we got to choose the teacher the our our children got

017to choose who they would have from high school and then one year we even had the PE teacher that we loved from the elementary school and through this process we got to love and understand the depth of who these teachers and administrators were um and we have become friends with them and they have mentored our children and they have mentored me and um it's the teachers who have made the difference it's empty and so I um and so our children thank you have been profoundly impacted in this district and at some point for 10 years I started attending Schoolboard meetings and um I attended Schoolboard meetings for 10 years and finally Susie waldram convinced me to run for the school board and with that I thank you and with that I um I have learned

018a great deal and then 20 years ago 20 19 years 21 years ago I decided to run for the school board and what a process it has been at some point Susie waldram told Sue Skidmore she doesn't know anything you're going to have to teach her and I became a willing student and um I can't tell you the number of times I'd be driving home from a school board meeting and Sue would call me or I would call her and she'd say really could you not have prepared your remarks so you didn't repeat yourself or you did a really good job on part on this part but you forgot to say this and this and so that through through the years I have been mentored by someone who cares about children more than herself and

019I really appreciate it and when she retired from the school board it was during Co and I had many plans for her retirement which were not fulfilled so and yes I still owe you pajamas I am aware of that and so um the school board has given me an opportunity to see how public education blesses the lives of the children from all social economic things I was that child like these kids were up here who wanted if they wanted music lessons you had to get it in the public school I played the clarinet and um I would have never had that opportunity without public education we could afford private lessons and public education became something which I became an advocate for I have a friend who has six children she lived by Indian Ben she

020couldn't afford they had one car she couldn't drive her children to a charter school they had to get to school the closest one by them and then when they went to El um middle school and high school they had to take a bus they didn't have a car to get to education and her family has become successful um so there were a couple reasons I got on the school board one was to to try to get us back to having a a better phonic system there would had been a national swing in across the district and we had left phonics behind so and then it swung back but the Publishers didn't catch up for years and years and this district has worked really hard to come back to a better system and I'm very excited

021with the possibilities that are there now um also I believe our Founders who I have a great love of wanted public wanted the public to be educated and to do that they needed public education where everyone was treated equally and I believe one of the my reasons for running for the school board is I thought because I had the time and the ability I should run for public office and be on the school board because I felt like the founders taught that we need to serve in public in the public any way we can and so it's an unpaid job that actually costs you money to to be on the school board and you know signs cost a lot of money and um so Through The Years uh my oldest child um would help pick

022up the signs and say my goodness mom my you you look the second time I R man you look four years younger in these pictures and then the next selection mom you look eight years younger than these pictures be quiet I know and then you look 12 years younger in these pictures because I use the same signs over and over again so anyway so many memories so much support from my family it has been we talk about the Paradise Valley family and you truly have been a family to me I appreciate the love and concern you have shown me the grace that you have forgiven me from my mistakes your acceptance of me always talking about Spalding your um desire to seek for excellence this district is amazing I appreciate the superintendents which I have

023gotten to know and to work with the ones we have hired and and the ones we want to stay here and we just we have wonderful people who have chosen this district for a reason and I just appreciate the opportunity and the honor it has been to serve in this capacity so and I can't get away from saying my thanks to my husband if he will stand up art case he's was that and he has served me our I we had shock to me five of our seven children flew in today from none of them live in Arizona flew in today and they were here for the reception earlier very kind of them and and um so we have some pictures I want to show you this is what my family our family looked like

024when I started on the board actually it's a year and a half after when I started on the board we had two grandchildren the redheaded one and the little girl with the brown hair on the side the one in the orange shirt is our youngest daughter we have seven children who've gone through this district and so but that's the closest picture I could get to when I started on the board if you can go to the next picture this is our family now and it's not even up to date because our youngest grandchild our 32nd grandchild was born yesterday and um this was taken last spring and our our oldest granddaughter with a in the wedding dress was um couldn't get to when we took the family picture she got there five hours later and

025then the daughter the granddaughter in the uh corner with the red hair was serving a mission so this picture was all these people as our whole family up until yesterday and now there's a new grandbaby so we our 32nd grandchild was born and um my family has been wonderful and I mentioned in the meeting the other in the the room the reception that uh you know my children they thought it was kind of cool when I left for Schoolboard meetings because they didn't do their homework while I was gone they didn't practice their piano while I was gone there was just like freebie time without their mom there so it wasn't always such a sacrifice on their part they kind of liked it but um anyway I just appreciate my husband and my children for

026supporting me all these years and for all the opportunities I've had to come to know this school district so thank you for allowing me to give my thanks thank you thank you now it's my turn um uh I have some remarks I just before I get to those I I want to say thank you all for being here um happy holidays we'll say that again um I guess I'm an non the only non clarinet woodwin play I was I was trumpet so uh I could I would have been right over there uh when in that performance um also want to give a shout I don't have my glasses on so I don't know if anybody's here but um between the last board meeting and this um desert Shadow Middle School celebrated its 50-year celebration um

027and I was able to uh get over there for that and it was amazing um and probably one of the the the most incredible things about it was how many Alum alumni students and teachers came back for it um and you know got the chance to uh meet Ian Dennis's mom who used to be the PE teacher there and whose name is on the Middle School Festival sports awards um but it was just such a a a really and coming together of community over at Desert Shadows um I know the day before the night before sonor and Sky celebrated its 30 year unfortunately I couldn't make it um but from what I could tell it was an equally fantastic celebration so it's just amazing to um see how our communities grow and continue to come

028together like that um I do want to say so you know when you sit in the middle seat point of personal privilege and you get to get to finish up the remarks and so as we hit this last board meeting of the calendar year and we turn the page on this year um we are obviously saying goodbye to two of our colleagues and Carrie I want to thank you for your unwavering commitment to all of our students our teachers our staff and our families being able to bring your experience and lens as a teacher to your work on the board has been a boon for us all and not easy to step into a shorten term on any board L one to which you must be elected before you get here but you did so

029with intense preparation and dedication and determination and your leadership was instantly felt and although you are leaving your service on this board I know as you said you will still be focused on advocating for students and teachers and families in Arizona and we will all be better for it Nancy how does one impressed 20 years into any adequate thank you for all you have done for our district when you and I ran for the board back then we really didn't know each other despite you know we all previously attended board meetings we were all out there together we worked on a number of ventures in PV but we really didn't know any didn't know each other and I remember walking into our own boarding session with John creart and just being fascinated by your experiences

030and your know knowledge of so much about the district given how many years you had already spent volunteering in your kids' classrooms and all the other things you'd been involved in but it was then as it is now your absolute Devotion to this district and to wanting to make sure that every child not just learns to read but learns to love reading for their lifetime that completely kept mid in me that you would plunge into the point that you led classes in the summer and worked with students to help them on their roads to reading shows a passion that remains unparalleled now you and I have had many a conversation over the year and we both know there are several topics that we don't agree on but I think the one that has always United

031us is our support for public education and that's often been a beacon when we've had to deal with lean budgets and lack of legislative support and it has been appreciated more than you will know I honestly don't know what it's going to be like walking in here into the boardroom next year and not seeing you up here especially knowing that means you will be off traveling more than you do now um but I want to thank you for giving this District all you have and it's been an honor to serve with you my friend thank you and with that next on our agenda is Awards and recognitions Dr Reynolds good evening president case or excuse me good evening president Greenberg my apologies thank you for your service Mrs casee uh good evening president Greenberg governing

032board members members of cabinet and attendees both iners and virtual tonight we have five recognitions to share with you this evening we'll be inviting our honores to the front of the room for a photo our first Honore was selected as the recipient of the 2024 distinguished service outside of the profession outstanding administrator Award presented by the Arizona art Education Association this principal has been dedicated to the education of children for over 20 25 years with a deep commitment to the Arts she has supported a variety of learning opportunities and environments and Elementary programs currently in her eth year as an administrator she is a passionate uh she's passionate about fostering personal and professional growth among students and staff striving to create an atmosphere where creativity and achievement Thrive from Liberty Elementary School please help me

033welcome principal Jennifer penoyer for our next recipient was named the north regions Arizona thespians Teacher of the Year this award is given annually to a teacher who demonstrates exceptional courage and Devotion to the performing arts program within a school it's a pre it's a prestigious honor that recognizes the best of the best within our ranks in order to receive this award the recipient must demonstrate leadership character and promote the Arts this year's recipient could not be in attendance this evening but still we'd like to congratulate Drama teacher from Horizon High School Brenda bis our next recognition is the recipient of the Paradise Valley education association's recognition of Professional Standards award for teachers the honory this evening will be introduced by Miss Heather Schmidt pvea president good evening president Greenberg Dr Reynolds governing board cabinet uh

034thank you for having us uh my name is Heather Schmid I'm proud to serve as the president of the Paradise Valley Education Association which represents our certified employees once a month I get to recognize one of our folks for by giving them their props which stands for professionals recognizing other professionals successes this evening I am honored to recognize Leticia Chate a social worker in the connections program at Shadow Mountain High School uh she was nominated by her colleague uh Miss Joyce Walls um from Shadow Mountain before I jump into the beautiful words that uh Miss walls shared about Miss Chate I wanted to say this was one of the most fun uh Awards I've ever done not only did I get to crash a staff meeting and celebrate them uh with the adults I headed

035back the next day and joined the connection students and all of the Connection staff for fun Friday and I brought some cookies and treats and it was a lovely way to send us off into the weekend uh from Miss walls uh letia embodies the essence of dedication compassion and tireless advocacy as the connection social worker at Shadow Mountain her commitment extends Beyond just serving our students she actively engages with their families ensuring they receive the support they need whether that is securing food arranging counseling providing Crisis Intervention or acting as a neutral party letisia is a lifetime for those Lifeline for those who need it most she also serves as a critical liaison to the Community leveraging Resources to assist our most vulnerable students her involvement with the crisis team is pivotal addressing the needs

036of teens at risk of harming M themselves or others on scorching days when the temperature approaches trip approaches triple digits it's not uncommon to find letisia walking down Shay or 30 second straet looking for a student who may have eloped often wearing cute shoes unsuitable for Pursuit uh despite the discomfort leticia's commitment never wavers and she finds a way to bring our students back safely as the IDL or instructional Department leader latisia is a calm reasonable voice that supports and mediates among staff ensuring that we remain respectful collaborative and effective her influence extends beyond our department as general education structured and lfi teachers constantly seek her guidance for their most challenging cases in all of her efforts I have never known letia to fail anyone leticia's unwavering commitment to putting students first inspires the connections

037team to be our best so we can do the same for our students her impact is profound and far-reaching making her an exemplary candidate for the props award congratulations latisia sh next is the Paradise Valley education support professional of the month PVA president Miss Michelle Courtright is here to make the presentation president Greenberg excuse me governing board Dr Reynolds and cabinet my name is Michelle Courtright and I am the President of the Paradise Valley support employees Association and this is one of the highlights of what I get to do um this month we are recognizing Jana Santiago she is a campus support employee over at Boulder Creek and many people wonder what is a campus support employee well we've been called dyads crossing guards clerical office and we do all of those things as things

038have been cut we wear many hats and Jana wears quite a few of them from what I understand she is wonderful with helping manage requisitions and purchases she is very efficient she works on time she checks with people but when she's not doing that you can find her on a playground in a cafeteria before and after school anywhere that they need a little bit of extra help she is there and every single letter used the same word positive joyful and flexible and in this day and age we need people that when they show up that day and you say hey I need you to go down this hallway they do every student on that campus loves when they see her and from what I understand every adult adult is very excited when they get to

039work with Jana so it is with great honor that we present our month our monthly award to Jana Santiago [Music] one we likeu any of [Laughter] when graduated already more coming up and my Lely princip and our last recognition of the evening is the superintendent's distinguished service award for which I will turn it over to Dr Reynolds thank you very much uh one of the just absolute joys of being the superintendent is to be able to present uh this award it is one of the most prestigious awards that we have in our school district and tonight uh on behalf of all the superintendant that are uh two exiting governing board members uh have worked with I would like to present the superintendent's distinguished Service Awards to uh Miss Carrie Baker and miss Nancy case but

040before they come to pick up their Awards we have a guest speaker who came this evening who would like to say a few words Dr Sue Skidmore former governing board well greetings of the Season Mrs uh oh president Greenberg I better put my glasses on members of the board Dr rles cabinet thank you for allowing me to speak Mrs Baker thank you very much for your service but with all due respect Mrs Cas this one's for you congratulations Nancy dear you survived for 20 years through times when things were were really swell and times when things weren't going well with enrollment drops and budget Wes when Co dealt an awful blow reading and fics were your passion and you stuck on that in Nancy fashion your faith in public schools called you to serve you

041ran the course without Reserve except for the times when your knee gave out or when your foot got the gout or when you had some some to be somewhere or when you had to dye your hair yet when when ever someone deserved an honor you were the one to do the flowers now what's next for you I do not know you've 32 grandkids in to along your new retirement way I'm sure that they'll have lots to say as do I I must ask when will I get my pajama pants now one last thing before I quit and Dean signals me to sit uh folks have wondered why you're so nice and you like me the queen of spice the time is now and I shall share we forged a bond that's kind of rare we

042never wavered we never hid our priority was is it good for kids so to Mrs Cas I bid God's speed for you have earned it indeed if you know Dr Skidmore that was a risk uh like I said uh this award is uh one of the most prestigious award I you know from a superintendent perspective it is the most prestigious award that uh one of our community members can get it uh it it is given out uh rarely uh but tonight I think most appropriately to these two outstanding uh community members who have dedicated uh not just two years or 20 years but really a career of families right um to to public education and on behalf of the district we also want to say thank you to both of your families for the sacrific

043that they have made uh over the last two and 20 years uh when you choose to run for the governing board volunteer for the governing board uh your whole family right your friends choose to do that with you uh and so um again on behalf of the superintendant that you have worked with I would like to say thank you very very much we have a small token of our appreciation uh for Miss Carrie Baker and a special a special award uh for Miss Nancy case who loves flower arrangements and flowers and so uh we we bought you a I I was told it's a vase a vase for the your award so please come up and I would also like to invite the entire governing board to come up and take the picture with us

044this is and that President Greenberg is the conclusion of tonight's Awards and recognitions for so yes we actually still have a little bit of business here and next on the agenda is items for approval agenda items G1 through G5 or recommend oh I'm sorry I went all the way down here superintendent Comics Dr Reynolds prior prior to getting to the business uh thank you uh so tonight I would also like to welcome uh our governing board members elect Miss Jessica wani and Dr Amanda limb who will join the PB schools governing board in January uh also welcome back president an Greenberg uh who will also be serving another term I look forward to working with the board to advance our District's goals and continue to providing an unparalleled educational experience for our students in PV

045school schools we engage Inspire and nurture students through high quality education instruction and meaningful opportunities and dynamic learning experiences these experiences lead to some pretty amazing things one that i' like to highlight this evening is an accomplishment of one of our high schools I want to congratulate Pinnacle high school for earning the college board's AP School honor role recognition for the 2324 school year and for earning the 2024 AP access award the Pioneers earned bronze for developing an AP program that creates a colleg goinging culture and gives students opportunities to earn college credit while maximizing their college outcomes Pinnacle High School is also honored with the 2024 AP access award for ensuring AP coursework is equally available to students no matter their background tonight I'd also like to congratulate our elementary and middle schools that

046have been recognized as some of the best public schools in the nation by us new and World Report the rankings are based on student performance on standardized tests across uh four key indicators these rankings highlight the exceptional efforts of student staff teachers as well as their dedication to academic achievement so congratulations to those schools and I'd also like to remind the community the annual Sounds of the Season event is this Saturday December 14th from 9:30 to 400 p.m. at Desert Ridge Marketplace make sure to come out and support our performing Arts students it's an amazing event I encourage you all to uh to attend and finally as winter break approaches I want to extend my gratitude to our amazing students staff families and Community uh our parents for another successful year in Paradise in 2024

047we celebrated incredible achievements made by students and staff from academic Excellence to athletic victories and accolades and Fine Arts and much much more we have so much to boast about uh and I'm incredibly incredibly proud uh of our Collective e efforts and wish everyone a restful happy and healthy holiday season that concludes my comments thank you Dr Reynolds my apologies for stepping on that a little bit that's all right so now next on our agenda is items for approval agenda items G1 through G5 are recommended policy revisions and um I will turn over to Dr Reynolds to um bring them forth thank you to president Greenberg our first read was last time and so we will stand for any questions or comments based on I believe we're going to take all of those at once

048is that right President greenber we so we have all of those um and I don't think there were any nobody ask any questions after last time so Mrs Baker may I please have a motion to approve the policy revisions as a single motion for G1 through G5 as presented so moved does any board member have any comments or questions regarding any of the revised policy recommendations I can't I can't see flowers seeing none um all those in favor please say I I all those opposed say nay any extenstions motion passes unanimously thank you next on our agenda is public hearing for fiscal year 2024 2025 School District annual budget revision number one followed by consideration approval of the fiscal year 2024 2025 School District annual budget revision number one Mrs Baran thank you president Greenberg

049governing board and Dr Reynolds uh this is just a quick budget revision for thank you the first budget revision of the year which we're required to do if we have a difference of 1% or $5,000 the lesser of of those two uh so you see this with us annually we will always have a difference of of that amount uh I'm just going to quickly go over the m&o maintenance and operation and District additional assistance differences why there are differences um some changes to average daily membership and then how those impact the budget with our maintenance and operation budget which we adopted in June of 2024 compared to the December revision there is just under a $5.7 million difference a decrease and then the unrestricted capital is uh a little bit more than $45,000 decrease those

050are decreases we expected um as a reminder when we adopt the m&o budget in particular we adopt it at a higher ADM than expected so that if there for some reason was growth or high higher ADM than we expected um we wouldn't lose out on that budget capacity uh for the M override when we adopt that so we always know and we will always see that there'll be a decrease in the m&o budget in this time of year um and as a reminder or for for those of us who are new board members those of you who are new board members ADM isn't finalized until later on in the subsequent fiscal year so last year's 0 last year's average daily membership wasn't finalized until November of this year just last month so there's always continuous

051changes to ADM even after our year and our budgets are closed and have been finalized back in May of this year uh the M carry forward decreased from $19 million that was the estimate that we had when we were closing out the year down to the 17.4 million again expected um as the encumbrances close out between the July and August time time frame and just as a reminder these are really just changes to these budget forms that are required for us to do with ad we have a budget that we account for that you see when I present for example at at the uh board study session uh that's where our real budget work is done and that's what's presented to the governing board throughout the winter and spring time frame frame along with our

052our bargaining groups um but we have actual forms that have to be submitted and our May budget revision is really the final picture for the year uh for what our budget capacity looks like and then remember we do the AFR the annual financial report the reporting of all of our expenditures in October uh which we did this last October so with that I'm happy to answer any questions you might have for the December budget revision just remember we'll have another one in May our final one will be in May thank you Mrs Baran uh Mrs Baker may I please have a motion to approve the fiscal year 20242 25 School District annual budget revision number one as presented so moved does any board member have any comments or questions I just have Mrs Baker thank

053you Miss Baran I'm really gonna miss your the explanations that you do and so thank you for this one last budget update that I get you're welcome and you can always tune in and listen to them yeah I can you're yep sure Mrs case um I've listened to lots of people in our district for finance and you make the most sense of any of them and you bring it to a level that I begin to understand the finance Finance is not my thing but you make it so that it's understandable and I really really have appreciated what you do somehow I wish we could change our numbers upward in a positive way but you're not a magician you tell the facts so I appreciate the way you explain things and thank you thank you thank

054you Mrs case anybody else Mrs Christensen so um thank you Mrs beran for for always doing your magic with our numbers on the budget um I was listening to um Sue skidmore's comments and and we we are a very different District than 20 years ago and we really I would really like to see us as a district um do more to to I know a budget means living within our means and it's hard to to control decline in enrollment but I think there's a lot of things that the board can do to to help with that um I know Matt does a great job of highlighting our amazing programs and you know focusing on our different academic programs the steam programs that we have are amazing and which includes our Arts um and I know

055we're getting we're coming into to bargaining and it's always it's always hard to cut every anything from our budget but I I just feel we really need to find more creative ways to bring cost down and revenue up Revenue meaning attract kids back to our district um focusing on academic excellence and achievement um I found out recently that we have a I wrote it down because I don't want to get the name wrong A Center for Teacher development which I think is phenomenal um maybe utilizing ctd um to have more experienced teachers Mentor some of the other ones rather than going out of state for for training um I just think that at this board can really find creative ways to um curb spending and increase enrollment um you know this this trend is concerning

056I know Roosevelt just Clos five schools as well so we cannot continue to to spend and do things as as we have been or as we did 20 years ago we're going to all have to find ways to change because we all know the definition of insanity so we we have to find create new and creative way and I'm not criticizing the budget and what you've done I'm just I'm just um you know I want to see this District succeed I want to see us do well and you know this the stories that Nancy mentioned about the wonderful Educators we have we figure out how to put more dollars in the classroom money in their pockets and I know I'm preaching to the choir but um but yeah I just I I want to do

057better and so um I'm hoping that this new board next year can really help us make some creative and creative decisions and um just continue to make this District great thank you Mrs Christian does anybody else have any other comments or questions uh seeing none we have a motion on the floor all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say nay any extensions motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is acceptance of gifts and donations and we had uh several this time and we had many that were very large dollar and I'd like to acknowledge some uh Dorito partners gave $1,000 to Echo Mountain Intermediate School for prizes for the uh School caught being kind store at Horizon High School excuse me Cardinal Charities uh provided $2,000 to the football program and

058Jon's provided $2,000 um for gifts and donations which included food at North Ranch Elementary the uh parent teacher Association donated $2,320 for field trips for grades kindergarten 1 and third at Pinnacle Justins gave $2,000 for awards gifts staff shirts boo food beverage and substitutes at Shadow they did the same another $2,000 and also at Shadow Odyssey operations provided $1,000 to the choir program uh for a variety of items including food the Sor and Sky PTO gave Sor and Sky Elementary a little bit over $2,300 for a laminator for the library and the Peter R Marsh Foundation gave the school $1,550 as a music Grant with most going for supplies and some going for transportation so once again we thank all of the donors if any of you who I just mentioned are here thank you

059uh very much or if you know anybody who we just mentioned please pass it on and Mrs Baker may have a motion to accept gifts and donations please so moved uh does anybody have any comments seeing none all those in favor please say I I any oppos say nay any extensions the motion passes unanimously next on the agenda is call to the public so I'd ask that you please turn your attention to the video monitors call to the public is about to convene this portion of today's meeting allows the public the opportunity to address the governing board although state law does not require that the governing board hold a call to the public The Paradise Valley Unified School District and its board have chosen to do so because we believe it's important to hear about

060concerns and issues from our community while call to the public is not designed to be a discussion the board is here to listen due to Arizona open meeting law the governing board cannot respond to discuss or take any action on items brought up during this time however staff members may be directed to get back to you and address individual concerns as a reminder the point of this and every board meeting is to accomplish the business at hand and to be able to do so in an open and collaborative way all in attendance are expected to observe meeting rules as well as rules of politeness and decorum so that we may serve as an example to our students that issues can be discussed in a respectful and civil manner [Music] thank you tonight we have one

061person who has submitted a comment card and so uh she will get three minutes for remarks as a reminder we ask that you please direct your comments to the board and please State your first and last name when you come to the podium our speaker tonight is Christa Hall hi I'm Christa Hall and um I have contributed three kids to the district I'm here to talk about about the ongoing issue with the lack of our fourth grade Spanish teacher at Sam Piper Elementary but first I want to thank Dr Lindsay and Natalie and Terry in community ed for their assisting on the onboarding of a Spanish tutor I really am thankful that we got her onboarded and that we're able to offer this assistance to our fourth grade kids I would like to ask the

062district to pay for five weeks of tutoring for these kids at the minimum I would like the fee for renting the space at our school to be waved so we can offer the tutoring to these kids secondly I would like to know what followup we are having with the VISA candidate that has accepted this position are we checking in with her on a weekly basis when are we expecting her arrival and what can we do to support her when she gets here finally I want to ask the board to think about what can be done in the future so our school will not have to deal with a whole semester without a permanent Spanish teacher and finally I want to look uh forward to welcoming Matilda at our school thank you thank you there are

063no items for discussion uh this evening and so we have reached the end of our meeting before we journ um I'd like to remind you that the next regular board meeting will be held on Thursday January 16 2025 at 6:30 I'd also like to wish everybody an incredibly happy winter break and I hope um you have a great time with any and all holidays that you celebrate before we reconvene and with that Mrs Baker may have a motion to adjourn so moved all those in favor please say I I I I any oppos say nay motion passes unanimously we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.