001I am calling to order the meeting of the S SAU 41 governing board which is comprised of the three individual District Boards of the Hollis and bookine communities including the Hollis Elementary School District the Brookline School District and Brookline Elementary School district and the Hollis Brookline Cooperative school district and I'm going to uh folks introduce themselves and uh let them know what board they're on if they are on a board here on Wednesday feary February Thursday February 13th at approximately 6:30 p.m. stting that in I'll start so uh Johanna Sheran I'm on the brook line School Board Jessica lens holl School Board Rie Zack holla School Board Rob man Co-op Tom Solon Co-op board Carol Roy holla School Board Gina bur superintendent elect do flarity uh assistant superintendent nominee Lauren de Jero director of student
002services Holly derlo Babcock Co-op School Board Kate stole Co-op School Board Amy Kelner Hollis school board for now thank you very much and in a pre pre-arranged conspiracy I'm appointing H as the uh process Observer for tonight happy to do it thank you uh goingon to start out with agenda adjustments if there are any there are none great nominations resignations and correspondence sure I would like to nominate Dorothy flarey for the role of assistant superintendent beginning July 1st 2025 with a salary of 141,000 just in general um is this a courtesy vote I no we actually have to uh accept vote to accept the nomination assistant superintendent I know the motion is there [Music] but we often bring forth nominations that the board doesn't necessarily have to uh be involved in but done think it's
003a legitimate question thank you for asking it you all right well I I move to accept the superintendent's nomination of Dorothy FL for the position of assistant superintendent at a salary of $141,000 second beginning uh oh beginning July 30th July July 1 sorry I'm thinking June 30th July 1st be late 2025 I'll second that too thank you uh any discussion I just I think um I'm excited we have someone so I'm was glad that you're here thank you for stepping in um you know I sat on the interview committee and I think Dorothy's a great is a great candidate and I'm I'm very pleased that you're here so thank you very much welcome yeah no I think this is an excellent vote we should all vote for it because it's it's needed and I think
004this will be a good thing it's great to have someone with so much experience in the in the role that'll be a nice way for us to transition yeahi prior to the meeting starting we got to have some informal conversation and obviously I wasn't on the hiring committee or the search committee so uh this is the first I've gotten a chance to meet you do and it's absolutely a pleasure we question J uh what is the period of the contract being offered a twoe two plus one okay thank you uh just for the record Allison has arrived at 6:35 he Alison um and we didn't volunteer you for process Observer thank you uh any other discussion Allison this is a u a vote to accept the nomination are you uh do you feel you want
005to participate do you have any questions in the vote I'm comfortable okay thank you um I'm gonna wing it and try to get a single vote in on this one so we have the nomination all those in favor is unanimous so it's no magic calculator necessary great congratulations than you very much welcome aboard welcome very excited and can't wait to join you guys this summer and thank you to the committee that participated in the process of finding a candidate and it sort of demonstrates that good things come to those who wait they asked wonderful questions so at this point I'm going to release her um yes from the misery of the rest meeting she can enjoy that starting July one well or you can just watch it because it's on you know so maybe next
006week just I actually did watch one of your school committee meetings as well from each God bless you and you still I still you want to watch [Laughter] deliver thank you so much thanks see you soon okay now we have approval of meeting minutes from uh December 12th and absent more more than this absent but it's okay if you weren't here in December just don't vote you can vote if you you can vote if you want Can Vote or you can abstain and the meeting the minutes are offered with the following Corrections or amendments page nine line 14 correct spelling of more m page 13 line 8 correct the spelling of enrollment uh I have a motion to accept as amended I move to approve as amended second second by Al any discussion any other
007Corrections or amendments seeing none all those in favor uh opposed extensions okay and then we have minutes from the public hearing on December 12th uh with no uh suggested amendments and move to approve as presented second uh any discussion seeing none all those in favor of the public hearing minutes opposed extensions proba you did not vote either way I did vote I put my hand up yes I remember because I had my cracker in my hand [Laughter] I can we note that in the eight plus a [Laughter] cracker then do should have stay we should have snow days more off non we have nonpublic minutes from December 12th yes we do with no uh recommended amendments I move to approve as presented call a second who was that Joe yeah thanks thank you any discussion
008seeing none all those in favor C opposed exstension got it thank you okay that gets us going there public input residents providing public providing input are asked to State their name and address for the record and make sure the input is focused on items included on the agenda uh this is not a back and forth discussion but an opportunity for the public to communicate to the board uh we keep minutes excuse me we keep public input open for 30 minutes seeing there is no members of the public present we will open it now 64 at 6:40 and close at 6 I was gonna say 670 but 710 I can do math I just can't do time um should anyone in the audience or anywhere appear during that time we will pause at an opportune moment
009and give them uh time to speak to the board moving right along for discussion f y 25 revenue and expense update I believe that is coming from it is so it is a not very exciting Revenue expense report if you recall we had proposed to use $3,233 from the fund balance but due to the superintendent line item not utilizing conference money and due to um some Savings in benefits due to to enrollment changes in nhrs and health insurance and some folks kind of switching to um to more of a part-time status which um allowed us to have some Savings in nhrs we are only now expected to utilize the $4,139 instead of the 53,000 um of the fund balance so at this point the expected ending balance for the fund balance is320 3,713 which is
01013.3% when we hope to have between 7 and 10% yeah so I see on the revenue side where that $49,000 was removed from revenue where did it come out of the expense side do you know um so originally we had our budget and then we had the one-time use of the 53 233 so that comes in as Revenue but we're utilizing the the budget money first and then not act we're only accessing fund balance money when we have to so it's not that it's coming out of a bud item that wasn't spent it's just you CH chose to pay for it out of corre existing budget money right because then we would have a surplus and it would go back to the fund balance so it would be coming out and going back in so
011it doesn't make sense makes it more direct right so our ending fund balance is going to be 13.3% correct so that's a little high higher than what we would like correct is there like any thoughts about like bringing it down do we need to bring it down or what is I mean if we're a little bit higher than we normally so if we want to spend from it we do need to have a public hearing to to spend from it but um you know usually that's a one-time expense um type item and um you know so so it wouldn't be like for salaries or human resources it would be maybe like when you got when we redid the bathroom or something like that or is that more no so that usually comes from the trust
012okay from the rental income and so at the H's public hearing we did talk about redoing the porch with that money okay um so then it would be like what would be a onetime expense like so the purchase of a copy software license we've also used it we've done that once before for um bonuses because they are not typically recurring well guaranteed recurring don't Factor it in okay what I was wondering is are you are we allowed to if someone were to qualify for any kind of uh retirement expense can those can it be used for those kind of expenses as well um Gina what's the downfall of us being over having more money than that we would like to have well I think a downfall is that looks like we're hoarding the money um
013but we don't have a mechanism to return it to the taxpayers um if we utilize it to lower the budget for something that's recurring then the next year it's an artificial Spike to the budget so we try not to do that but here we are um you know slowly but surely creeping up there um yeah so what was the porch cost again say it was 31,000 somewhere around there but that comes out of the trust that comes out the yeah so I mean we don't want to spend money to just spend money but I just was wondering if there's some one time only need that's out there that we're not chances are there will be will and there that we don't know about so we could we could effectively use this as a um a
014facilities kind of not a trust but area so whether whether it's like equipment or having to do repairs or if uh we have something crop up needed to be outsourced this could potentially be a way to find it and this current SAU budget has a has a we've increased the Merit pool right correct to some degree we have to some degree so to be as transparent with the taxpayers as possible we do have a merit pool in there that's more significant than it used to be I believe correct I don't want to speak out of turn so correct me if I'm wrong but I think it was increased by an amount of 35,000 last budget yeah I thought that was that's the number that is in my head but I don't I'm not I don't
015remember I don't want to say like it was 33 but I'm not sure yeah I think just like the concern is exactly what you're saying is like if we are if the perception is is that we're asking for money but yet we have all this money I mean I would be interested if you know later down the road like as we're wrapping up towards the end of the year like if there's something that might potentially end up being a budget item but is a one-time expense now that we could use I feel like that could be a good way to maybe lower the fund a little bit with us kind of being transparent that like we're doing this in advance in order to keep the budget years low it's a onetime expense Now versus us
016that could be an option yes and another good option is um for example Lauren's um laptop has experienced greater difficulties than typical and we also hence hence my loner and um we would need a new laptop for the new assistant superintendent um the superintendent's laptop is well over its age of replacement and I believe we had budgeted for one and so that would be a small item but something that certainly would be more of a onetime expensive okay great thank you thank you next on is that all that's it yeah next on the agenda is a review of CBI F2 evaluation of the superintendent short form and also CB1 evaluation to superintendent long form my understanding is that the uh the versions that were presented were brought forth by uh by the folks on the
017policy committee with the goal I think is with the policy committee with the goal of giving a starting point for the discussion as opposed to it specifically being an explicit recommendation I don't know who wants to speak to that I'm happy to do so but um we had discussed I believe in our October meeting that maybe the we would use February as a workshop to look at the forms themselves um the policy committee got together after the December meeting and we just started to look at it and figure try to figure out what that what that Workshop might look like and then we thought maybe we should D kind of guide the workshop to with um a sample to see if that makes better sense and when we were looking at the short form the
018long form we thought wouldn't it be great and maybe you don't agree but wouldn't it be great if the categories were the same because the categories were vastly different between the short form and the long form and we thought probably should stay within the same categories but just ask more questions and then in in looking for which categories made better sense um and then looking at the sample policies we realized that the short form that we had is really a shorter form of a longer one that exists in the um sample policy pack and so we looked at the Lo their longer version and looked at ours to figure out if we looked at this one are we missing anything are we um would we just you know miss out on budgetary or or you
019know any any category that would be important to the board and we didn't feel like we would they were potentially just in different categories um but they were still there and so we thought well why don't we just do that why don't we because nobody likes the long form and maybe it's just the format of it so why don't we sort of keep our short form and then add to the short form to make it long form and um I think there was some feedback in the committee that the way it was presented seemed more confusing than it had to be until maybe a chart form was easier to understand and translate into the Google form um and then there's also would desire based on the last discussion that um the direct reports also filled
020this out and so if you look to the final page of the short form the ending like the The District overview composite scores there's a Brookline School District Hall School District Co-op school district and then an admin category um so that their feed back wasn't just verbal and you weren't really sure where to put it in but there was actually some numerical value to it uh and then go from there and so they would fill they would fill up the form too okay so it was just a thought like I said it was um we just thought it might be easier to come up with a suggestion and then get feedback rather than trying to have a free-for-all I'm going to ask a loaded question to start with how many people actually have dug into
021this prior to coming here tonight I'm on the policy committee so I have I read through it but what do you mean by dig in just oftentimes when we ask a question I don't know how to interpret lack of input to I'm still in information collecting mode versus I've digested it and I formed an opinion mode gotcha so um would anyone like to express any comments or feedback right off the regarding the what was distributed so I I'll jump in um looking specifically at the short form since that's one we're discussing right now um I like the changes uh I also see this as being the vice chair of the governing board I am in charge of the superintendent performance evaluation committee so I've been the one to bring it forth last year and would
022have done it this year had we moved forward with with doing the evals um this will make that end result cleaner clearer and just frankly easier to get there instead of having it you know be cut and pasted by the people submitting um I think bringing up the admin feedback and bringing that forth in a in a numerical fashion as you mentioned I think that's incredibly important because when you have the folks sitting in the room talking to the direct reports the superintendent or the ad ad level building admins um it's you can interpret it maybe more severe more negative or less severe or positive so I think giving them that opportunity to to follow the same uh number scale that we do in doing ours is going to be incredibly helpful and just lead
023to a little more accuracy I think in the representation um I do have just one change uh on that first page of CBI F2 it talks about the online implementation and it does mention that the chair or their designate can access responses then in the paragraph it says once districts ratify their District level evaluation chairs enter their evaluation data into the SAU level form it's not necessarily the chair like especially for Hollis since I am already in charge of spec it was always somebody else so if we do chair or designate okay or whoever whatever language we're calling that that spec lead from each board okay anyone else I I will say I'm still kind of in the processing because I'm just still trying to figure out obviously this is my first year and we're
024not doing one this year so I like I'm still just trying to figure out what we're doing here but that's I'm I'm reading it and kind of going through it I do agree though with Carol what she's saying that like having everything be standardized I think is just going to be much easier for everybody um as we're kind of coming together as a group so I do think that's a really good change um I mean I'm still trying to figure out the difference between the short form and the long form obviously one is longer I got that but um like how we use them when we use them I think that's still just what I'm processing I think too one of the things that seemed clear is that it would be if we wanted to
025use the long form in the future that this is a more usable long form than the other long form and so I know in the past obviously this is my first year too we're not doing this right but the past we never the long form wasn't used because it's so odorous and so well and also we had a superintendent here for over a decade so there was a lot of the stuff that you you know I'll use you as the example over um right you didn't need to do it every year but with a new superintendent taking the helm a new you know it would that would be the time that you would do it maybe for the first one to two years of their tenure yeah until you didn't need something that big and
026then you could do it in more of the short form I'm kind of answering johanna's question as well I also think if we wanted to use it more than just the first few years it is more usable to use beond because because of the new structure and and quite frankly I remember a time where we needed to long form because things weren't going quite well with our uh Superintendent at that time so we needed to get more granular and more very direct and clear so it's it's a tool but we don't always have to use the tool so that's why I found that the short form so a couple things number one um I want to try to be as positive as I can I'm not a fan of like the numerical thing but I
027get it but I what I don't understand in this process is the fact that we never compare years um it's we never compare years we always just look at the numbers for the year but we never look at how how the what the growth is so that's not in the policy and I don't suggest it should be in the policy but just in terms of the process it's one of the things that has always made me crazy and it I literally the first meeting I came here I had had a horrible day and I walked in here on a February meeting it was my first year I joined in September and I remember sitting here thinking and it was Andy's second year and I was like why are we looking at numbers and not looking
028at last year's numbers I don't understand that I see I don't get that so that's one of my like concerns about this process and secondly I think as board members we need to read through this and realize that there are things that we don't have insight to but there are ways to get insight to those things by making sure that we ask the right questions in say a nonpublic so for example on the long form relationship with staff um like facilitates two-way communication interaction with staff is one of those things so you're sitting there in December in the middle of the holidays and you're trying to remember as you're giving this evaluation whether or not not you know whether this person has that has that happened so I just think it's really important that when
029you're in a room with in a nonpublic and every May when our superintendent presents us or our building principles present us with like staff information that you ask those questions or you try to find those things out because I don't think we I don't think we have insight into a lot of these things I I I share the same concern I I actually think that that whole ction should be relegated to the administration to answer because I because that for me the relationship would stop because I don't have that level of insight and now I'm going to apply a metric to it applicable pardon like a not applicable uh yeah well that you could put not applicable we had that just not answer it so there are some things like but we but but for
030new members they have to realize that if we're going to use a non applicable option that it's okay to use it and you usually use it if you feel I don't know right so use it or you can dis disposition that whole section to administration reviews and we we do we can do Financial we can do relationship with the board we can do how do you interact with the community that's in our wheelhouse but there are some things like we some of us do have access to conversations and interactions that do allow us I I would not support prohibiting or or creating a barrier for board members toine on those are so so then the the na option should be no opinion or no no opinion but it's no it's no ding either it's just
031a blank but I but I don't think that addresses what Holly would say so but like for example number one on relationship with staff this is a long form I'm looking at includes the participation of faculty and staff in establishment and implementation of districtwide goals objectives and programs we have insight into that we know that you're you know running committees and you're you know inviting staff members we have insight into that promotes programs for staff growth and development we do have insight into that we're invited in the beginning of the school year to attend uh we can actually stay and attend a professional development so we do have insight into some but then there are some things and I don't know I'd have to go through and you're right I haven't I haven't I should
032have gone through and highlighted the ones that but every time I filled it out when it was the long form or the short form I've always been like yes I need an NA or maybe I do I'm the board chair so I have more conversations with the superintendent or the assistant superintendent so I might know a little bit more than because that's you know how it works but I just want to make sure that we look at that and and and then then I also encourage board members to look at this and be like oh okay well what what could I ask about you know you can ask a question like about when you're in a nonpublic about like have there been a lot of um what's it called grievances or you can ask questions
033and you can get information specific to staff um that you can ask in public but you can so I just want to make sure people have an idea about that does that make sense the only thing is is though you're you're soliciting that information from the person we're going to evaluate I understand that so I need I need an a dis interested party to give me that information not the person CU they're going to know why I'm asking the question so you're not going to say Hey you know my relationship with three of these other administrators is terrible yeah you're not you're never going to get that so then we just need I definitely think there needs to be an NA as one of the categories and the committee did say that and I um
034forgot to include it that's okay I really like your idea about we got to use the previous metrics and understand what the trending is Right CU that's part of our um analysis right part of our job that we would add to the policy versus adding to it would be more like the the what is it not the process but what's the lower part of the policy procedure proced should be in like a procedure dock not not at the policy level but like here's how you execute the policy you know you got to look at last year's numbers um can I clarifying question really quickly did the did the policy committee add the dot so like where it says like five consistently exceeds minimum did we add to Performance C like what what that means are
035those new I can't tell the category I mean the the scoring was not new right the one through five was not new but but is what equals like a four new is that something that no those are the exact same the things that are crossed out weed right but that's why I got confused because it was crossed out oh um so it's crossed out down below because I don't know why it's written twice oh okay it it's written right above with with a description I thought that was more helpful than yes no it was I was just confused because I just when you're on that page and I think you're adding you're adding more detail to what that c that a number two what is that mean instead of just a very tur like little
036not met which I think for me just like oh before we didn't have those explanation so I thought they maybe were added and we had just they were somewhere else in the form they just weren't there on every page so it was kind of like your key and then so when I look at the short form I don't see as many of those examples of things that I wouldn't have insight into I feel like there's the short form I'm just an advocate for the short form because I feel like it asks questions that we can actually answer and um if we want that other you know long form for like Administration or something I don't know but I really feel like the short form just gives us what we need um and I I I
037understand that you know inexperienced superintendents and all that I just feel like it gives us what we need I think it's you know four or five questions on each one of these areas will give us a strong evaluation and covers us for what we need and if there's a concern I think there's ways with all the comments and I've also been here and we spend a lot of time talking about this and gathering information on this and I feel like we do a really good job with this and we've been using the short form for quite a few years and I understand he's been here for 10 years and whatever but I I feel like it's I feel like it's adequate Holly can we go back to the first thing you said where you were
038talking about we can't see the previous years I was sugges um I had a question but go ahead make your suggestion I think that when we when this gets distributed we should have the summary page of the previous year included in the handout that shows the cumulative scores and the goals at goals I agree with you my question actually speaks to that is is that something we have to put in the policy and do we make note of it is please see the attached form from last year or summary from last year put I think you can put it into the form does policy mention is I guess my my question I feel like for if you really if the board really feels like it's something that should be done it should probably be in
039the policy because if not his it'll just it'll just be like historically we've done it this way and then one year we might not okay so I do feel like that's more valuable I mean it's like when you look at kids like when you grade kids like you want to see growth and and you know see them show well they don't just send you a trimester grade you see the other we need to be very mindful that if we're going to provide that historical data that's super like extremely confidential extremely confidential that does concern me about Distributing it and having people having a copy of it it maybe you get a copy of it at a meeting and then you got to give it back well no I it's all it's it's you have to
040look at it online you you make it so it wouldn't be downloadable it just needs I we just want to be mindful that it's protected it's maintained I agree with you 100% I'm fine with it just like walking in and having it be on a hard copy that we turn in I would be fine with that but I do think some language might need to add to the policy that that's going to be part of the process I I think that it's a great input that it is necessary to have context and I don't know what the methodology will be but to to have it but people agree that that's that's the information that would be useful well can I ask about when you would give it like are we giving it when people are
041originally like when I'm scoring for this year and can I see right then SC Alison what's your issue my issue is why are we why are we looking at the previous year summary when we're evaluating a we're looking at a single year why are we giving I understand context wanting to see growth but as soon as you give that summary to somebody and they read it I agree you think it biases them I agree I don't think I don't think we should fill it out and but we should see it should be given information I think I think unless there's an an issue year to year then we can come back and look and maybe see what's going on I don't think it's personally I don't think it's fair to to cloud people's judgment in
042the way because if you're asking to evaluate on a school year you are putting thoughts in people's head by having to look at the previous year I don't think that's fair I agree with you on that I just feel like once we've done it we come to this board with a completed we do like so we we upload it we we roll it up we roll it up and then you get the final sort of where we're going to put input I feel like at that moment which is still part of the process we should then have access to or be able to see what we saw last year because we hear this a lot to be careful yeah sometimes we hear that things you know and I want to make sure that we have
043continuity and actual information not just oh we've had this issue like I I don't think anyone is suggesting at least what I'm pulling from this conversation that we get previous year scores before we score right so it would be hot you know how we do the rollup after you scored it rolls up rolls up at some point in that hierarchy you get last year's scores because then you're already committed you scored and then your scores it's for this body to look at the trend data basically would you would you an go ahead this might be a separate question than what you're about to say but just please grab me next I have a question about this okay um from what I'm hearing and and it and it all makes sense and Alis thank you very
044much for bringing that point up because you does accentuate if anything it sounds like the place for it to happen would be during the rollup at the February meeting during this meting when we're looking at it well not only this but I I think the people who are doing that final Roll Up is it the spec because some because they will be putting together the final and they should be bringing forth so yes it can be presented there but I I don't I think that someone should be able to have access to it to have them both to bring to this discussion so I disagree with that okay um thinking about when we roll it up how many people in this room have not been to to the Eternal meeting that usually happens here so
045we have just a few people right okay so how what usually happens is everybody fills in their stuff on a Google sheet it goes to your board's spec person they average it out and they push forward here's what Brookline said here's what Hollis said here's what Co-op said as an average I if I'm still in the vice chair position take all of that average those three things together to get the final average score amongst the three boards and then compile the comments and bring it forth to this body and in non-public we go through it line by line to make sure that people's comments were properly represented and things like that so if we're talking about being able to see the growth yes it's it's final it's very rare that like we're not changing numbers
046during this rollup meeting because what people put in it gets average those are final and it's really just the commentary that gets added so displaying the previous years is not going to change really any of that but it allows us to take a look at it and say are we seeing the growth that we're seeing because at the bottom of that is we give the superintendent goals for the following year so if we say it during if we see that we've asked for this last year and it didn't happen we need to ask for it again which has happened in the last six years and we're like listen you're not you're not getting this part done now we've had two years of where we're asking for the same goal so it wouldn't influence anybody's scoring
047no one would see it and I don't think any of us remember what the scores were previous to this year because you finish it and you just kind of like I think yourself well that's I was GNA say so the spec chair does the rollup but then the spec committee actually reviews that final evaluation before presented to the entire board corre and so I think at that point it might be helpful for the spec committee to see the previous scores as they're you know to Carol's point is they're talking about what potential goals might be or adding comments it might be helpful to know what the previous um years sorry forgot that step yeah that would be essential for for the goals because we spend a lot of time in that meeting talking about the
048goals right so that that that's what I see is that last year data set is going to help provoke deeper conversations around that because we always an we meeting and it also gives us hard metrics to back up what we're saying so that's that's key because that connects and and and provides consistency that I think a superintendent needs to have right because it it it legitimizes what we're saying and sometimes that mean sorry well one of my questions actually was just answer listening to all um I will say one comment though as far as looking at the numbers and the scores I would think though as far as how relevant they are to when we're evaluating if the goals are changing each year I don't I think that growth can't really be measured by just
049looking at the scores because I agree 100% what our goals for and excuse me like being brand new our goals for her and her first year in a superintendent would be very different than the goals for this the person who's been here for nine years and has all that experience and so we might be more realistic with our goals for someone who's just walking in what's accomplishable for that person versus what we're going to expect from her five years from now it's G to be hard so I I think that we have to keep that just numbers I'll be in a if if that's with paired with the goals and whether or not the goals were accomplished then that context actually matters how many years in a row were the goals not being accomplished because
050then we could also ask well were the goals set by that board that year unre right it's one document here are all your scores here are your goals so yes okay yep so so are people in generally supportive of the the idea of the spec committee when preparing the final rollup pulling in the the previous year or years if appropriate yeah I I just think the point that I want to make also though is that like you're GNA have new board members like brookly is going to have two entirely new board members in March like we we have two people who so you're going to have that like the co-op's you're going to have people who are rotating over so I see both sides that might be helpful context for them but it absolutely might
051be something that gets in the way of them that's why they're not likely to be on the spec committee yeah but they're but if okay but but what if they get designated what if the chair like that's the role of the spec committee to help guide and through well and that's and that if you're seeing it after you've already filled out your evaluation you've already done all that um you're seeing it after the the conversation in here can get quite heated and sometimes people think they remember something from last year that didn't actually show up and so it's important to have that last year's document so that you can and I'm not S I agree with you 100% Alison I didn't like the idea of it being beforehand because I think you need to go
052into this year focused on what you know from this year and when I do this evaluation I do that like I try really hard not to think about anything that occurred prior to this current year but what I'm saying is when you're giving a person a really strong a person who's been with you for a few years you want them to you want to have that evidence if you will when you're in the conversation because people will say well wait a second didn't we say last year well if you don't have any way of looking at that and and I'm fine with that and GNA say something and it's gonna land me on the spe committee out of Brooklyn we should and and I and I forgive me if we do but I can't remember
053um when that spec committee gets together and they get all the results year to year there should be a specific tracking mechanism that we have so we can see the history for each planet and it's not hard to put together and it's not hard to track because then you actually can see the whole history so you know three years from now we can look back if we want the evidence for growth or see where we're got some gaps and we and we need to see growth we can you know celebrate the winds we can work on on where we want Improvement but we would have that I just want to be sure that when we evaluate I I've been in ruls where i' I've had people under me for years and it is a skill
054to evaluate and it is very hard to your point to only look in a specific time frame which is why I wanted want to make sure that we are not bringing out bias yeah I agree with you so I think if the role of the spec committee is to assemble the data to present to this group then it should be presented in a historical way obviously year one we're not going to have that right um but in year two three and subsequent years we should have a standard templated way that we're presenting the information so that when we do come together to have those conversations we have the scoring we have the comments and it allows for some so you're saying see all the num so the spec committee should have and I actually agree
055with that be is that an appropriate task for policy committee or spec committee to create that template for the rollup form I think that should be the spec committee well except the spec committee doesn't usually meet on any kind of regular basis can well they got a year off this year okay is that um is that an acceptable Tas for to to put on spec committee to come up with um that kind of and and the fact that it's the spec committee's responsibility doesn't mean that someone who's not on the spec committee cannot participate or offer in into the process but I I like that idea a lot does every other people like it the idea that we have a standard presentation mechanism that we're getting to a point here where the the format for
056collecting is getting standardized now having an ability to bring that over and to bring it back to the the collective board in a coherent and again standardized manner where year after year they know what they're looking at I think that'd be great so if we're collecting it on Google it's really easy to automate that and push it out into either it's just more a question of making sure you know what data you want want in it well sure and I but I but I think it needs to be the anecdotal notes that people are are sharing in the in the commentary and I think it should be those the numbers for each of the board okay well that that'll need to get fleshed out you can flesh it out however you want just so I'm
057just going to speak to the uh amendments that we're considering um to the form I personally think that they're very helpful and the way that they're laid out is great just because again being aware that like there's a good chunk of us in here who have not done this I me there's a lot of in this room about this but there's also a lot of us who have not yet done it um and there's going be more people next year when we're doing it who have not yet done it so I do appreciate how clearly it is laid out and kind of like what it is that we're looking at I think that's a big positive um but I do think that this is probably if there's going to continue to be questions so I
058just think you know that's going to be something that we all just have to be aware of is that there's going to be a lot of knowledge coming into this and then there's going to be me who has no knowledge but is very M and we'll ask a lot of questions so I just want us to kind of have that balance that'll get filtered out I I don't mean to be this within your own board because that's where that's where that and that will be one where you'll have the comfort of working with people who have experienced the same input that you have yes I'm just I'm just putting that forward so one other question when you say admin is that direct reports meaning the building level administrators and also um direct reports at the
059SAU is that part of this admin like so everyone fills it out um or went back and forth and um is it just the building level don't know that we came up with yeah we went back and forth I think we felt um I think we ended up landing on people within the SAU building because we felt like principles could also maybe be captured in multiple pools and that that might be kind of confusing um I think that's where we landed so I just want to know who's filling out the form is it the principles or is it the who is it every is it everyone that in the past the spec committee has the chairs or the person on the spec committee from the specific board whether it's the co-op board would interview and
060talk to the principles and then the spec committee like Vice chair or whatever would then talk to um the assistant superintendent the director of student services and the business administrator and so and so no I'm with you and I'm uncertain so I'm trying to figure out who are you asking the the the interview to fill this out or are in the past what was done is the a series of questions were given suest suggested questions no a list of questions were given to the um administrators prior to the interview and they were used as as topics of possible discussion but there was a fixed list and it wasn't the same stuff that was going before the board members is there continue using that process or not I don't think I mean so like I said
061the policy committee um just felt like we wanted to put something out there to start the discussion but it's not like we were like this is absolutely what we should do I think that the conversations are a good part of it and I think to your point there were different questions that were being asked so in my mind and I'm not speaking for the whole committee I don't think you take away that part but I think this provides um a numerical response to better allow feedback from the direct reports into the process because um someone had mentioned in the committee it's really difficult to throw in a comment from a direct report without it being identifiable um and then how does it tie into the rest of the evaluation and where does it because the
062questions were not the same questions you know would you envision that each of the direct reports would also receive this form and directly in in my mind it was everyone sa and principles but that's just what I have in my head but you know Tom I almost like that idea better because I remember when we would be an interviewee and I would have to try to gather this information and then distill it and put it into some kind of comments I would much rather get it direct remove me from that chain and let the the people put in their and and document it right right into the you elim that's fine but the the challenge is that I'm not sure that some of the questions that folks wanted to ask the administrators are captured in
063the represented there yeah so I'm gonna throw something out there need to think on that we could try something out and then make a change for a following year because I don't think you're really going to know what makes most sense but so I feel like put out the form to the administrator so they can fill it out still do the interviews trying to make sure you ask potentially different questions and then say was that did that add value the process get feedback could we do that before the actual do it as a trial run just to say about the questions say what do you think of these questions just ask ask the direct reports to look at this Pro Form get some feedback from them can I jump in for a second I think
064the part that I'm as someone who has been interviewed um I'm trying to flush out whether it would be more valuable for us to fill it out and then the interviewees have it when they interview us or if it would be more valuable to be interviewed and then we do it because I I can see benefits to both ways because I I do agree I think sometimes it's hard to quantify from a conversation but you know there could be I'm just throwing it out there like you you can decide would you rather see the scores and then ask some follow-up questions or dig into it a little bit from what we write Prov conversation I don't know which because it'll kind of guide it would guide the interviews I think to a certain extent because
065all of us do have a little bit of a different lens everyone who's being interviewed we all have a little bit of a difference yeah because then the interviewer can say well what did you what did you really mean here I think I'm seeing it but I want to make sure I'm getting it right and then that might lead to a deeper to a more Rich discussion I have a much more generic comment or question about this when I looked at the short form versus the long form it looked to me like didn't look to me I saw basically some of the questions have just been eliminated and others have carried through intact I view the long form as being a a guide and and what that it's it's uh useful for both new superintend
066but it's also useful for new board members to understand what are the factors that potentially get considered the short form as I took it when it got generated one of the reasons it took a different form is that it was it was um generalized it was trigger points of more General discussions without going through an an itemized checklist so for the short form I would rather rather see a few questions that captured the main components of the long form um just and and I I tried I don't know how even to read this stupid thing but so the short form didn't change I just changed the format of it but the fact that the questions on the long form and the short form the short form is a an incomplete subset of the long form
067I don't I don't think that some of the things that were left off the concepts of them should have been left off I think that there are things on the long form that are important that need to be evaluated but not necessarily elucidated this the way they are so we have does they have leadership does he have manage it does how does they hire know there's how do they handle staff relationships how do they handle management you know I'd rather see the short form be a consolidation of Concepts than just cherry-picking specific questions that that's that's my opinion and I just as an exercise for myself I went through the first one on Administration I said how many questions would I want to see to capture the range of things that were asked for in
068the law form and I came up with four questions that to me generalized now someone who a new um a new board member and going through the first time might benefit from answering the short form but having the long form there with each section saying you know what are the elements that that make up this section yeah in the short rather than having to answer every individual and say oh when they're talking about um Staffing and talking about you know hiring and training and you know these are things that that go into it but uh usually on the on the by the time we got to the short form the idea was we had a general feeling over the past couple years of where the strengths were and where the opportunities for improvement were and
069we had set specific goals about perhaps supporting weaknesses um how are they doing this year just sort of sort of that I would like the short form not to just be a a cherry-picked subset of the exact same question question that's me one thing that um a little awkward but the one that's going to be evaluated what I didn't like about the long form and the short form the ones that exist now is the categories were different um and the the components that you were looking at and evaluating were completely just different and so it's like the expectations would be completely different from one year to the next without any other reason than well it's your first year versus it's your second year or whatever and so that didn't seem right so that's just my
070perspective um for I'll just let me see if I can figure this out okay so long form for administration I don't know if anyone has the the patience to open it up but there were 10 questions um and it talks about exert form so you can compare them I I have that but what I what I did is so my consolidation of the administration was section were were four questions or four statements provide strong leadership management and general oversight for SAU and District staff on operations that to me covered the leadership management aspect of the questions responds to board Direction and keeps the board and Community informed on the state of the district that was the the board and commun community relations portion Administration staff organ staffs organizes evaluates and empowers an effective and competent
071team to meet the current and forecasted needs of the district and then finally ensures that state and federal requirements are being met maintains effective relationships with organizations and persons to advocate for the district's educational needs now that was just just a a quick thing but my what I was essentially doing is does this check off all 10 boxes does this capture the without being so granular and specific just more of a general yeah so I could see why you would go that way and I'm curious I just notice that under Administration fulfills the board's goals and policies successfully it's not under Administration in the short where does that it it doesn't that's the that's the is what he's talking about I I there's no alignment from the so so for for my proposal it would
072come under the thing of response to board Direction and keeps the board in Comm Comm formed on the state of the district so that's fulfilling I don't think that is the same thing I mean I feel like the whole evaluation comes down to I mean put of the most important things because the goals that we as a board set should be aligned to each one of these strands and I would imagine pleas tell me I'm wrong there are goals that are set for administration goals that are set for instruction am I correct in this like we three goals no yeah we they're much more if we're not then that's how we're doing it then that that line that sentence needs to be somewhere in the evaluation no but the the the idea is that that
073is in the long form intended specifically about goals and policies regarding Administration not so then where would it go in the short form this idea of goals the IDE well the overall thing of goals is is captured at the end when you set specific goals so each section is supposed to articulate important things and and they usually if it if it relates to board Community communicated activity there'll be a statement like uh fulfills board direction or or followed followed board direction or communicated well with the board so there'll be there'll be a a line item question and board will be in there and that will be a question about the relationship of the superintendent to the board on that specific topic if we um again I haven't been part of this process before but if
074what we do is set three goals for the superintend is that right we generally two but sometimes three two or three would it make sense on maybe having a spot for this on both short and long forms putting in like these the goals for last year and also you know like it feels like those might fall under a lot of different categories depending Administration or instruction depending on what they they are completely not they they they could be any of the categories but we don't have one from every category we have two goals maybe three depending on what we're seeing during the evaluation process it's much more it's more organic and it's not as um subscribed they would show up in the proposed rollup that the spec committee would do to say okay here are
075the goals of people set here are the goals from last year when the when the spec committee then comes to us at this meeting next year they well no it' be two years from now because we haven't we will not have set goals um specific in that manner but they'll come in and say oh by the way you know here were the goals we set last year here are the goals we're setting this year are we setting the same goal may I correct you the spec committee does not propose goals are you telling us that you would like us to no no what I'm saying is when you in what we just talked about about the spec committee getting last year's information previous years that committee will then be able to present going forward last
076year's goals as well as goals I just wanted to make sure because you were talking about proposed goals and I wanted to just make clear that we don't propose those that's happen we collect information but they but they are proposed in the evaluation we don't we we don't wait until this yes we do they're not on the form anywhere no were in the past I'm looking at the one that I brought to the governing board review meeting in February of 24 or no that wasn't it sorry it was yes it was and it was um it did not have anything under goals because after we went through all the comments and had discussion the group proposed goals and there were anecdotal things with um you know where people could say hey we gave him this
077goal last year and it didn't go so we've actually done we've done it both we've done it both ways that out both ways we've done it both ways spe committee doesn't fill it out no no the all the respondents do correct but that comes into this room we have we did not put right but but when you give the summary I don't we have in the I have been the spec chair in the past there were two years where we actually did propose goals um at the spec committee level that we brought forward just as discussions um points and they were edited edited you know and agreed on that night so we've done it both ways I also can I just say I just want to say one thing we don't spend a lot of
078time talking about the numbers we spend a lot of time talking about the comments so which is why we can can rearrange like you said Tom but honestly we don't really talk about the numbers that much we unless there's a big Divergence somewhere then we drill down for that or if two boards say five and then one board says two or or or you know what's the problem you know why aren't we coming together okay so my I'm not worried I'm not about the numbers but is there any value and putting on the short or long form somewhere I space to say just as a framework here were the goals for last year having that at the top of the form to say oh you know I don't know however I guess that I I
079don't know about the goals for last year but I I feel like there needs to be we've had the same superintendent for what nine 10 years is that true y okay so I think that some of the our ideas of what's been done in the past we have to rethink we have a new superintendent and you know this we Andy grew into it and so we knew what was going on um and we have we have a responsibility to be guiding our new superintendent and so the goals need to be extremely clear I think that we should be aligning goals to some of these strands like does we don't have to align one to everyone but we should be choosing goals to align and I I've heard once maybe I misheard that there wouldn't be
080goals for the first year I think there absolutely should be we should be going into the year maybe we need to meet maybe at our first meeting of the year or last meeting here in may we should be setting goals and maybe we ask our new superintendent elect to set her own goals what goals do you have in your first year why how will you try to meet them now we're going to hold you accountable when we come when we come up because that's that would be the Baseline um and then when we start should be looking at what were the goals were the goals met I mean to me when I just think about my evaluation process as a teacher or evaluating teachers and I know this is an administrator but everything was goals
081based yes we had all of the criteria and the numbers and everything but a lot of it came down to did you or did you not meet your goals otherwise we're just kind of filling out forms and we're not moving forward as far as what the district actually needs from this person I hear what you're saying my comment was based on what took place a a few meetings ago when we made the decision not to do an evaluation process for Andy this year which would have been also a goal setting I don't I I don't disagree I I don't like dou I agree with you that there should be goals I think that we because it will be a a new superintendent and a new start I think we're going to have to use an
082exception process to develop those but I will tell you that have we have this through both experience anecdotal experience here as well as the general concepts if you have too many goals they almost lose their importance there's only so many things that people can focus on there may be um I'm not asking for no but when you said you when you said you you made a comment about we need to have goals tied to every section I did not say that I said we don't need to TI them to every section but we need to when we when we make goals they should be tied to a section so it could still be two or three why do they need to be tied to a section as opposed to something that might span multiple sections
083perhaps then we should say which sections it's aligned to right so this goal aligns to administrative and instruction and this is what it is I I I disagree I mean I've seen the things that the presentations that where you come in when you have the rubric and and everything and you tie it back to this addresses this principle this is I the goal the type of goals that we have set in the past have been of a nature that that they don't necessarily align with a specific subsection maybe they do and if they do that's great but I don't think that we should be constrained in our goal setting to finding out where it fits and having to tie it think it should go the other direction because if you have a goal and it
084doesn't align to a section do we create a new section so that we have just a a subsection this is this is just as as Harley said this is just an idea a way to get you thinking the real the real benefit comes in the comments you'll find that each district has their own set of values their own set of need and their own set of goals and the really really tough part about what happens here in February is getting anything approaching consensus on that I guess the feeling is what's the point in having these strands you know they they should be giving us information about a person's strengths and areas in need of growth right so we should be gleaning data from this particularly early on of where growth is needed and when we
085identify where growth is needed a goal should be formulated from that data right because that doesn't coming goal from the air the goal should be coming from the data that we're collecting so in response to that but we don't all have like my idea that's fine you can shoot it down I'm just saying I think it would help with Clarity and I think at the beginning of the year I feel we should invite our new superintendent to write some of her own goals I like that this that you're bringing to the conversation evaluation and goal setting are two separate things you can do one by itself or do the other by itself it just so happens that our process we did them in parallel because we're doing the evaluation it's a good time to do
086the goals too this year as you point out it'd be silly to do an evaluation but we would be remiss if we don't set set goals so we can do that I think it's going to be important to do that um so I think up till now at least I've always kind of connected the two and yeah I think the missing element the missing element and and what isn't stated here is every year before we kick off this Andy gives us his self- evaluation and his goals and I think that um I don't think we'll ask Gina to give her give us does he do I thought he did he does he do it during the roll up no he we've in the past asked him to do it prior to the evaluation so that
087we have that for we've had that for context last year he did not do it right could I make a suggestion um I wonder if and shoot me down but I I feel like the long form is um the the existing one is tedious in the way that it asks questions that that they don't seem to tie in if we move forward with this version whether or not all the questions make sense I mean I do think that sustains physical and mental health and appropriate energy is an awkward question but like let's just keep it um move forward with a long form for next year because by the time we hit next year you're probably G to have half the board members turned over with who's experienced it and who hasn't and at that point
088After experiencing that long form more everyone would have all these components in their mind and then can better identify what needs to be changed given the fact that I'm a new superintendent and you just experienced it and if it's not the numbers that take up the time then it doesn't really matter if you're answering 10 questions or four I don't know say that about I think it's a really good point that like we have the three of you haven't done this before right when we come to this evaluation I will be the only Hall of school board member who has ever gone through this process right so I feel like although I cannot believe I'm about to say this but I feel like we probably need to just work through the long form next year
089and just work on that and go through this process I agree with you completely Gina and and I'm really listening to what you're saying and I hear what you're saying I think we need to experience it and have you been through you've been through it right no not really no so I think it's really you have to it's it this this is a very different experience when there's no camera and we just like go into it and um and there's quite a lot of digging and chewing at it and I think I think it comes out the way it's supposed to come out I me I'm just going to say also that I would not have necessar I don't think it would be a good idea to just do the short form with so just
090because again as we've all pointed out we all know Gina will be new are all aware of that but I think just the fact that like it's a turnover I don't think a short form would be appropriate in that situation Holly when you say we should do do the long form do you mean the long form that is suggested by the policy committee or do you mean the previous long form I mean this one this one looks find to me this find me listen I am you know really this is a this is a process that's really interesting for me it's not my favorite thing obviously it's not about evaluating people I could write a paragraph or two to answer these questions I I'm not a numbers girl so um but I will do it
091and I you know and I do think it you have to be really careful if you don't feel like you have Insight in to it you should just put na or um because I feel like it's not there are some things on here that we really just don't have insight into because we don't micromanage that's not our job you not qualified yeah right we're just not we don't see some things and so I think it's important for us to say na because then we'll know which questions really don't work for us um and which questions are not really appropriate for us to answer and so I think that's a really important thing that this board walks away with and then the other thing I'm going to say is that right now from what I can
092tell we have really um engaged board members who care about this process it isn't always that way it's an elected position and so there could be outliers so I think what Allison said earlier about having the spec committee have Vision into sort of historical like looking at numbers because you could have someone come in with an extra grind and and really throw this so to be able to see that over the course of years is an important thing because we're elected we're not appointed rapael you looked like you wanted to say something a couple times that I hope you didn't just get shouted down is there anything you want to yeah I had a question um about the overall rating for the category that's at the bottom of every category is that the average of
093of the scores above um so then I wonder I think uh if we're going towards the long form my concern not really for next year but just in the general sense I wonder if it ever comes up uh maybe less so since if the numbers aren't uh looked at too closely is just if you have um a really big category with like 10 items in it and let's say you had like two item two rows in there that were just like at one and the rest were high scores like four fours and fives I feel like those ones would get kind of more washed out as opposed to the short form where if there are two ones and two fours it would be more apparent so I wonder your concern is real it does happen
094that's one of the areas where the comments really come into play because the instructions in general have been is if you're scoring less than a three you are required to put comments in so that allows people rolling it up to understand the context and the importance of those scores so that to try and generate some Valance that's not in the policy that's just kind of like right it doesn't say in the policy to score less than a three you have to put it says it on the Forum you do it says it on the Forum okay I'm sorry um I might be branching off if I me back in but we've talked about using the LA perform for next year we talked about goal setting for next year this is where I'm going to Branch
095so with Andy going out does this board an opportunity to exit interview Andy because I would be interested as he's been working so closely with G this past year in transferring um knowledge and really helping to train her up I would be interested in his thoughts on where we could help Focus goals for next year with with I certainly I I think the opportunity does exist it hasn't explicitly been defined uh when's our next meeting it's not until May and he was curious um if anyone's going to ask him for next an interview so I think he's very much um ready willing and able to do that I wonder if what would be the spec committee would get together and do an exit interview with Bandy prior to the May meeting so that you could
096have that conversation nonpublic without me and then work together develop goals or or or whatever but I just wonder if that's or or I think an opportunity exists for the board chairs because you have board chair meetings with the superintendent you could dedicate that that one instance to an exit interview because I think Andy has been in the past more comfortable working and speaking frankly to his board chairs because you he works most closely with them so I think that would be an opportunity to at least consider that that's it could be done there okay I I think the first of all I don't think you're you're exceeding appropriate branching okay that's a good question second of all I I think that it's a topic that is both important and and worthwhile um I am
097concerned about how best to accomplish it because I think that doing it with a full 17 member board would be inappropriate yet I'm also concerned about excluding anyone from the process um um does anyone have a suggestion as to how to go about resolving who and how such a exit we haven't had to deal with one we could take an action uh we could discuss it debate it and give the board chairs agency to do it or spec committee or the spec committee or Pi three numbers from the hat right so we can debate debate that well here's the thing if we're going to talk about doing goals at the May meeting the May meeting is when this board gets reorganized and so you won't know who the chair of the spec is until that
098meeting so we can't say have the spec committee do it because we didn't really establish one for this year because we weren't doing an eval right you may also want know who the chairs of each board are because we will after your May April meeting you will have a new chair that Andy hasn't worked with that that comp that what you're saying correct people think of the idea of each board choosing its own representative to participate and then members of the board send their questions to them well that that's what I was gonna say how each board chooses to do it is up to that board what I was going to say is each of the three boards could submit questions that they would like to ask in the exit interview you could have sorry
099committee could assemble those so if there's overlapping questions we reduce it down to one right and then the board chairs could sit with the and go through those those ex exit interview questions and then that data can be brought back we have a secretary in that meeting or the really good not and then present set information sorry I like and I'm not on I'm not on the spe one thing I will well you will be all my mouth tonight will suggest to you is having having worked with Andy as much as as I have and others have Andy's going to drive the interview he will Andy's G to tell you what he believes that we need to know I what you Shak your head I don't think I'm not sure we need a I'm not
100sure you need as extensive list of questions I think it's it's a conversation you'll just yeah and and basically you can have it that's fine there just may be some board members that may have specific questions that they'd like asked and what I wouldn't want to do is just say right hey the board chairs are going to go have a conversation and then you have a board member that was elected that was like hi I wanted to ask a question like I want to at least make sure that we allow everybody's voice to participate in some fashion the only way to do that is to go back to our respective boards and say we are going to go have an exit interview with Andy as the as the chairs is there anything specific that you
101would like me to bring up I think that's a really good way of do it in your individual board is should be up to that individual discretion I'm a solution so what I I would I'd like to see is just each board identify an individual to participate in the in the process and you decide with the Dynamics of what you've got on your board as to who that person is and how you want to prepare for it and then you're going to get probably three individuals in in a room with Andy and and tell you what he wants to tell you I guarantee he already has in his head of what he's planning on sharing especially if he's asking that's who he is who he's proven to be over the last decade for for this
102for these towns right and like he's just he's so detail oriented in that sense and he cares so much he's not just going to walk out the door without this is his legacy exactly so I I but I think it's important that we have enough time between now and the main meeting to make sure that one the boards are able to have a conversation about who who that person is that's going to go have sit down with Andy and the other Representatives read board right and is there anything particular want to talk about and then figuring out of those that are going to represent who's going to compile all of that information to them bring back to to the May meeting here so that then we can have a really solid conversation this we Circle
103it back around we can have a really solid conversation about um I would like to know personally from Gina what she would like to have as her goals and then I would like to compare that against what Andy's feeling and then that way as a board we can make a really important decision because going into year one Gina's new but she's not new we know her right so like I think it's but I but I but I just want to make sure what would you what would you think of the same people who participated in the exit interview sitting down with Gina to put together a a um a path going I think we could do that as a group I see to I would just like to hear right but I'd like to let
104her communicate it to um and have an opportunity to to have some have some discussion prior to it because the the hardest thing I've seen for new people coming into it is is to have their first exposure of their plan be to an overly large audience without having an opportunity to sort of test test the waters that's just my experience but that that that's something that Gina can potentially veto as well it's it's our it's our decision ultimately but I don't think we're going to try and Bully her into anything I am speaking for myself I was say you never know all right no no one would bully her but I but I agree with an that it is important for us at that like if we're the board that's going to be working with
105her I don't see why she couldn't I mean she spent the last three meetings with us it's not like she doesn't know like what you but I think it that would be important but if we've just sat down and got a list of things or a a discussion of what's needed I don't know I can't speak for for her but I can speak for myself that I would like to close the loop to see whether my perceptions are the same as the perceptions that my predecessor have given yeah well I mean I think the conversation can happen between the people who conduct the exit interview and with Gina specifically about the goals but I know that you guys are already talking about that so he's probably not going to say anything that's a surprise and
106then I think that the goal sharing by Gina would be appropriate to this entire board in a non-public or public whatever you guys want to I I think that this has to be non-public to the full full Board of us in May can be done public depends on the type of goals we're talking about we're talking about professional P you know professional her own professional goals then that would be nonp that would be nonpublic but if we're talking about goal setting for the entire District but I think we're talking about professional professional goals be nonpublic I mean think about it when we said in the eal that's in nonu I thought you were talking about different goals I think goal planning for the district is strategic plan which you know so that's something different and
107that's totally public and that's what I but this is professional go this is personel personel Human Resources personel those are going to get fired okay I volunteer that's great you volunte for tribute that's what I'm hearing over there okay so no he said which BTE are going to yeah right you go I volunteer so you're volunteering for trib so what um what have we learned we've learned that the spec committee or excuse me the policy committee is going to take another swag at a call it a long form for lack of a better better definition right now to be used for the first year at a minimum is that is that yeah yeah I think we I think we actually have to take it to vote in May on whe what form we want to
108use well but they but we we want them to come to May with that proposal of what that form might might be can I can I clarify that just to understand so Holly had said that she liked this long form we were're talking about we had talked about making changes to the short form to changing the nature of the questions to better summarize the questions on the long form what were we saying were the big changes we wanted to make to the long form well the long form I think that there see there seems to be consensus with the format when I say format the the the charting the restructuring um I think that um especially in light of some of the the topics that that Ann brought up there is a desire to have
109uh some consistent wording within each section that helps sort of identify I don't know if goals is the right word but but objectives of of that that section sort of lead lead uh in a direction of what what we trying what are you expecting to be achieved in those sections and you have to add in can I so I okay and now I remember the issue if you add that that'll skew the numerical calculation so I think by omitting it that and and we can Define um the lack of the score represents um and one word that we had used as the policy commit because it'll go in as a zero yeah we would we talked about um doesn't have to or is that just the way the spreadsheet works spre yeah no um insight
110into this category yeah I think that's fine yeah how how you do it is is fine but shouldn't go in as a as a zero or a six or it just goes in as like a no number and then that person who doesn't do the na is divided by six like how you know you divide by however many aners however many answers you actually have so you divide by five if on our board if two people give n then the whole score is divided by five instead of so can can I ask a quick question why would we need to decide in May what form we're going to use in nov I thought that was the policy I could be wrong you guys you guys have the policy but I believe it was a in
111the May meeting we vote on I thought there was a meeting where we specified you know Amy yeah yeah in the may I see you governing board meeting we determine what which form we're going to use for the evaluation and if if we decide we need to kick the can one one meeting we can but default is do it oh I'm F totally fine with that I just wasn't sure because we don't we don't do anything until October is when people start having to talk about at their meetings and getting ready to fill stuff out in December getting back on the attempt to figure out where we are so does does that give you so changing making edits to the long form to be better capturing goals or object possibly um and again if you
112publicize when you are meeting perhaps other people will want to be there I don't think we need to change what theyve proposed for the long form at all right now what I was saying is when we write goals more more the opposite instead of putting in the form about goals when we write goals we utilize the information here garnered in the section like we're seeing it's not that we need to put in instruction something about goals per se I'd rather say when we write a goal we could we could refer or I don't know if there's a way we would categorize or something but like we look we look at instruction and we see obviously instruction is not going to be weakness Gina but um this is an area of growth there's something specific we
113want from that because we're seeing that in the comments in the numbers whatever in the data that this is a place from where we need to derive a goal actually you want in the goal Su in the summary the goal section to have an ability to reference yes areas in the long form I think support the that goal it actually that's how it that's how it happens gu that's what happens the comments the lower the lower the lower scores it just leads to it like it really does happen that way like it's it happens organically but I think that that what would like to see is some some tieback to it so that people who are looking at the goals can understand understand the route if they weren't there for the conversation that above at
114the scores and the comments but they don't get to by the time you get to the roll up it isn't necessarily all there but this is it wouldn't be relevant for changing the form anyway it wouldn't be relevant for change the form I basic because I saw it on the long form fulfills the board's goals and policy successfully not on the short form when I saw that Omission it was it struck me so we're using a long form that's there I just I've already made the statement yeah I think we're good I don't think you need to change the long form very much I think we need to be cognizant of it when we're working on the evaluation and then potentially look at making changes to the policy in the future to reflect how we're
115actually doing things which is what we are always always going to be working on in this particular policy so we're not making the policy committee is not making changes to the long form it's the good news what's so I thought gen you felt there needed to be some tweaks to it to be utilized as is I'll fix the typos um so well I don't I don't care you can tell me all about my physical mental health are you involved in that g are you involved in that committee yeah we can review the questions question TW but we not making fals what you think needs to be in the evaluation I think take another cut of yeah we'll take another cut but I think this assuming that this is the proposed change to policy we can
116bring this back to for a vote um for the May meeting and maybe I don't know the are we saying do we need to change policy based on the conversation yeah because policy here right now as it stands the long form is the the one that nobody likes it maybe that nobody likes but it doesn't prevent us from using it I thought my under but help me if I'm wrong I understood the conversation to be we're going to use a long form but this version of the long new long form so we have to vote that in we have to vote this is a change this this long form is a complete change like if the way the way it's been restructured and there's retitled and all that but does the I thought part of
117the policy just re refers to was what CBI F1 Y which is voted on right but you can you can vote on the policy which reference F1 and still change F1 the policy has the form in its entirety as part of the policy it does oh I'm sorry I didn't realize that that's okay yeah this is CBI F1 first read um this was not a first read this was just a give us Direction okay but we could bring no it's CB1 that is different policy from CBI and CB and CBI F2 there's four different four with CBI come up with something else we were being asked to vote on CBI and CV yes which are totally I don't I don't think not there yet that's in deliberations yeah we're getting okay I thought I thought
118you were saying that we can't vote on those tonight oh no no no what I'm saying is okay where CBI like this I'll bring forward in May yeah F1 and potentially F2 yeah and CBI emphasizes F2 as being um I think the preferred one CBI um just says that the governing board will conduct an annual formal eval of the superintendent the governing board will determine at meeting thank you Amy whether cv1 or CV F2 will be utilized and we change from it being required that it be used for the first year to it being choose you choose in May what you use yeah so we're moving are we moving on to deliberations and talking so just so the other thing that needs I'm the process recorder so I got to know the other thing that
119needs to be um done is come up with a a while ago um each board's uh proposed participant in a u exit interview and perhaps goal setting session the elect yeah um I also want to point out in CBI it says before October 30th governing board will perform an annual review of the goals from the prior evaluation if applicable so it's already in the policy for people to review goals not other school stuff um but that would be something that if we that's when we would do that so we just have to do that at our October meeting okay so sorry so we got the information that the um policy committee wants got information for each board to take back as action items prior to May for so it's going to be up to each
120board to decide who's going to do the the exit interview is that within the jurisdiction of the boards or is that the seu governing board that needs to make a motion for that because it's the seu governing board that oversees the um superintendent so should I think that in May we'll have a motion to form a committee made up by the proposed people I because we don't have that on the agenda now to form that that group so then the EXT interview will happen after May after the sometime after the May meeting before he um the the country AFC okay yeah watch for me anything else that we need to do during this discussion period you have to close public input public is closed at 809 thanks for reminding me everyone oh okay um to
121to be clear the only two voting items are CBI and CBI are it is not the F1 and F2 correct bless you bless you thank you all right so are we moving on to deliberations then yes okay so I move to amend policy CBI superintendent evaluation in its entirety by replacing it with the copy provided with the agenda accept the third reading and adopt as amended some your second D any discussion so the changes were minor the changes were just based on the feedback in the December meeting about who is on the spec committee and who was um on the spec was on the spec sorry um and then the other item that was changed was evaluate the performance to the superintendent in the areas of we thought it would be nice if those categories
122actually matched up to the form cuz they didn't so were there was there any heartburn at the deletions did you say was there any heartburn at the deletions at the Del meaning that that inning it something got left off I think the language that was provided to us for that motion doesn't make sense because it said replaced in its entirety oh she just says that when there's an amendment to the policy that's just making sure rather she doesn't want to list all the Amendments yeah that does anybody have discussion about this I mean I I want to just say and we talked about it I think briefly I do wonder about adding the a self- review component to the um evaluation process because I know there's been years when Andy's done it formally there's been
123years that he's done it informally um and I just wonder if if belongs in policy I I look like that would that be on this one would be um so that's part of before January 31st is it in there yeah in the chart oh yeah it's there there we go there we go perfect yay well done Amy great sorry I was like I thought we no that's great good job policy committee woohoo okay any other discussion comments besides say you want to go home okay so we have the amended version we have a motion to adopt as amended all those in favor is everyone still here 11 z z y thank you and then CB I move to accept the third reading and adopt CB instructions for superintendent performance review process School District boards a
124second there are no changes do need to adopt it when it already exists because it's been a long time since we got no oh there were no changes since the second reading oh okay so we did make changes for first reading and then Amy suggested a nice chart so we added that for second reading and then we're looking for third and adult okay is it the same chart yes yes uh and I think the suggestion was for CBI but then we felt that it probably is a good idea to also have it in like the instruction page the only concern I have is duplicating some document on two places and maintenance forgetting to change it yeah understood but both of them outlin in the um policy and the the process so if you make a
125change the process you don't have to update both places anyway okay that I'm good any discussion seeing none all those in favor of the amended version of cbir is you mous thank you non we do have it on public we do super fast oh I have to take not for okay you're up girl well we have to go into before we go into nonpublic like report out by the process Observer um I think we did pretty well actually I thought that the conversation about the review of the two forms went over but actually we really didn't we were supposed to go into that at 8:15 I think and we are now at 8:15 going into on public so we had a really nice conversation and I think we hashed out a lot of good information
126and yeah I just want to add to thank you all for for participating in the conversation please don't mistake uh tone of voice with anything other than passion no I'm serious I think there's a lot of respect here and that that's part of what makes no I think that was great that you said that Tom just just struck me as a little okay uh at this point I would like a motion you go into I move the board by roll call go into non-public session pursuant to RSA 91a col 3 section 2A the dismissal promotion or compensation of any Public Employee and C to discuss a matter which if discussed in public would likely affect adversely the reputation of a person other than a member of the body or agency itself is there a second
127to the motion second we'll uh go for a roll call vote I will start I I Holly I Carol I Tom I Rob I ra i Jess I Johanna I Alison I okay we are in nonpublic 816 are we stay here when we come out of nonpublic we will be um just a basically a j are we staying in this room e e for