001oops bless you before we get started how many people haven't been to one of these meetings before don't be proud raise your hand okay all right I ask you that because I don't know much explaining I should do uh so I'm going to do a minimum of explaining most of these guys know how it works and how I work so I'm not going to go over it in any great length Al righty um would you be so kind as to rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you very much for coming out on a cold night we'll see what is
002in store for us weatherwise tomorrow welcome to the annual meeting of the Brooklyn New Hampshire school district uh as I'm sure you know but I'll say it anyhow that district is responsible for the Richard mahawan Memorial School prek through third grade and the captain Douglas uh Captain Samuel Douglas Academy this building fourth grade to sixth grade my name is Peter Webb and I will be your moderator this evening uh I would like to ask uh the players members of the school board I guess we have no finance committee people uh and uh SAU employees to be so kind one at a time we we'll start here and go to the end and then we'll go on you guys I would like you to introduce yourself and tell the people not only your name but your
003role in this process and I can see you're thrilled about this hi my name is D salara and I'm the new school clerk our clerk yes Colleen hi I'm Colleen mikovich and I'm the chair of the Brooklyn School Board Tracy Perry Vice chair of the school board I'm Johanna Sher hallan I'm a member of the school board Allison Manion Secretary of the school board and on the budget committee good evening Jim o shanesy attorney for the district thank you um principles sa folks would you be so kind as to let the people see your smiling faces thank you for letting me do that appreciate it appreciate your time and your hard work um so simple process as you guys know uh the uh school district has prepared a warrant which consists of uh uh a
004handful of uh what we call articles they're numbered I assume you all have a copy of them uh from the supervisor's uh desk we'll go through them one at a time uh these are what the school says they want you to approve in order for them to continue doing business there there is also an additional warrant article uh which is is from the petition of 25 or more uh voters uh that under law is included on that warrant as well for you to address today and I think I might have said approve or disapprove already and that's wrong and I do that this is an sb2 meeting you guys are not going to approve or disapprove what you're going to do is you're going to Fashion what goes on the ballot on Election Day which
005is March 11 so the uh petitioners have done one article and the school board has done I think eight articles you folks will I'll read them out loud uh someone will make a motion under them then we'll if they're seconded proceed to talk about them and basically when the conversation is ended we're done you don't vote on them we just say Okay on to the next article and the form of the motion when you're done talking about it is what gets on the ballot what people will vote on on March 11 I hope that's clear I think most of you have seen this before you know what's going on um new people if you got a question just come up to the mic we we'll work you through it we kind of follow rudimentary uh
006parliamentary procedure stuff but it's totally unnecessary just come up to the mic tell me what you want to do we'll get you through it uh don't get intimidated by that baloney because it doesn't govern this meeting um everybody knows that our discussions are going to be civilized uh and respectful um you can ask questions about the motion you can amend the motion you can explain the motion uh that will be the job today and we'll hammer it out and then eventually we'll have it in a form where it will go on the ballot um I wanted to say as I already said that elections are March 11 Tuesday March 11 all day 7 to 7 7 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. there was a notice that went out because of my fault that at 6:30 our
007polls are always open at 7 in the morning this is Tuesday March 11 that's for uh the town's warrant excuse me that's for Town officials school officials and the uh schools warrant that you're going to Fashion tonight those are voted on on March 11 by ballot at town meeting that process is on the floor vocally uh to the extent that a secret ballot is requested we do do a paper ballot but it's in the confines of the meeting um town meeting is a day after election day March 12 it starts at 7 it'll be here uh they've scheduled a second day assuming that it will spill over beyond that first night so that's March 13 a Thursday starting again at at 7 and they've uh selected Friday and Saturday of that same week snow days
008if necessary um February 25 uh the Hollis Brook line Rotary Club tries to put together a candidates Forum it's live streamed from town hall and zoomed from town hall and we asked candidates questions so when you see that name on your ballot in the voting booth you have some idea who you're voting for or not so uh February 25 I've contacted all of the Town um uh candidates I haven't contacted all the school candidates and I'd be grateful if the school would give me a list of the school candidates with their email addresses so I can tell them they're welcome to the February 25 candidates Forum candidates Forum I I I allow the people two or three minutes to introduce themselves open up the discussion I ask them some questions back and forth and then
009they have two or three minutes to close it's just a way that you guys can see who these people are and they get a chance of exposing their ideas to you so you know what's going on um I think I've covered anything I mean everything so uh we can proceed so if you will take a look at your uh warrant your school district warrant we start at article one and that is stuff that happens on Election Day so we don't act on it today it's done by ballot uh on March 11 so we'll uh begin instead with article two so I'll read it and then someone uh can make a motion under that and if it's seconded we'll get get into discussion and uh we'll W wind up fashioning what will go on the ballot
010article two follow with me if you would to see if this school district will vote to authorize the school board to enter into a 20-year lease purchase agreement for 1,317 to finance the acquisition and installation of energy conservation equipment CD csda boilers and LED lighting and controls at both schools and related building improvements at Captain Samuel Douglas academy uh and Richard mahawan Memorial School these are why you have glasses you put them on your face and it makes it easier uh and to raise an appropriate the sum of 9,565 for payments due under the lease purchase agreement during the 2025 2026 six fiscal year the annual lease payments over the 20-year term annual lease payment payments are are estimated to be $ 9,565 per year this lease purchase agreement will contain an escape non appropri
011appropriation clause which I'm sure someone will explain to us a majority vote is required a simple majority meaning 50 more than 50% estimated tax impact is8 cents per th000 of value of your property assessed value of your property the school board recommends the uh appropriation 310 the finance committee recommends this appropriation 20 do we have a motion under article two I'll make the motion she's making the motion that's Tracy and I think she said as written as written yes yes I knew it so the motion is just as the language is there in Article 2 that is the motion as somebody want to Second them it's been seconded therefore it is open and on the floor guys for you to ask and explain yes and Gina will begin with the explanation thank you good evening
012Captain s Douglas sorry Academy was built 25 years ago while it is the newest building in the SAU we cannot ignore routine maintenance and replacement of the mechanical electrical and structural components csda has two boilers with oil fueled burners the main components of these boilers are the boiler body the oil fire fired burner and the delivery System including an underground storage tank located outside preventative maintenance has been completed annually to the boilers but they have reached end of life in November 2019 a crack in the boiler was repaired and the seals were replaced for both boilers that was a temporary fix and we need to move forward the full replacement or we risk facing a breakage midyear and an inability to find replacement parts or to fund an urgent repair by switching to a propane
013system we will gain efficiency and experience cost savings oil underground storage tanks and Associated piping have currently they now have higher standards than they did before which create additional concerns for our current existing systems switching to propane will allow us to benefit from a greater purchasing power as we can combine our efforts with our high school potentially our Middle School the Hollis School District the town of Hollis and the town of Brooklyn this article also includes upgraded controls for the HVAC systems at both rmms and csda our existing controls are Antiquated have limited functionality and are actually quite difficult to find a vendor who can navigate an Antiquated do system upgraded controls will allow us to improve climate control reduce isolated issues and allow for remote monitoring finally this article includes upgrading our existing Lighting
014in both RMS and csda to the industry standard which is LED lighting not only is this a superior lighting solution to optimize the educational experience for all students it also provides significant Energy safe savings year after year the intent behind combining these items was to create a cost neutral warrant article installing LED lighting in FY 26 allows the district to benefit from a rebate estimated to be $70,000 this rebate is likely to go away in the near future increasing the urgency of the article in addition the expected annual savings is estimated to be $31,000 year after year the total cost of the project is 1,131 750 the first year payment for a 20-year lease would be 9,565 the annual Energy savings would uh total 48,000 and the FY 26 potential rebates total $ 42,5 65
015the net impact to the budget is actually $0 thank you very much uh questions just approach your mic ask your questions and we'll do it yeah Eric power and the gentleman knows as I didn't say you're supposed to say your name and address thank you um I have a concern about using this lease with the skates Clause uh for things that you install um this is a very expensive way to finance a u any kind of project because you're paying for the flexibility of an escape Clause that you really can't exercise and uh in the budget hearing at the co-op on Monday they actually saw the wisdom of that and they changed two proposed leases to two bonds um saving on the first one $1.4 million in s in interest by going from a lease
016to a bond and on a second one it was about uh $500,000 in interest savings so I think going for a lease I'm not debating whether we need to do this but going for a lease with an escape Clause is a premium expensive mechanism for the uh for the financing of this project and um would you address an escape clause for the uneducated like me so the a lease a lease agreement with an escape Clause means each year you can decide whether you want to escape or not so you could say the legislative body which is us could say we don't want to do this anymore and you return the equipment presumably but the reason it doesn't make sense is how do you return turn the boiler you're going to have to replace it with
017something else and what do you do with the LED lighting you've already taken out the other lights so it's really not a practical thing it's only in there just so that you could actually propose it and pass it with a simple majority and it's actually a very bad mechanism and it's a very expensive mechanism and I'd like to make a motion to amend go right ahead can I see the can somebody move it back to the language um I can't is someone able to show the original language of the the article excuse me it's there okay is that what you want yes it is Okie do I'd like to amend the article to say to fin uh for a 20-year lease purchase agreement for 0 to finance the acquisition and installation of the energy conservation
018equipment then also change the 9,565 to zero in two places below and uh that would that's my motion thank you it's clear I don't need it in writing usually I'm going to need it in writing you guys but that's that's clear does the gentleman's motion have a second would anyone like to address the gentleman's motion to amend as he has suggested it can I briefly speak to that motion since it's been seconded um I I think you did so yes but I'm going to let the gentleman behind you go so um a question and this may be more for the um for the administration hi Kelly um if the co-op were we're discussing one of the reasons for the the reason for moving from a lease to a bond was the interest rates were better
019for bonds right now why why would this continue to be a lease then okay you're gonna have to speak in the mic please okay so so the oh can address this question okay just um would if you have something to offer I'd be very grateful uh you're not a Brookline resident are you H she said you can talk I can talk he's not a book grind resident either but with your permission Andrew Corey can speak to it if that's all right everybody anybody all those in favor of letting the gentleman speak to you thank you all those opposed thank you go right ahead when we went out to look at the projects that we're doing uh at that point leases and Bonds were approximately the same rates as a result of being an SP2 town
020our calendar is much quicker because tonight's deliberative session being an annual meeting Town The Cooperative board has more time so they are actually able to change theirs and schedule a bond hearing next week now couple things in comparing leases and bonds bonds will give you an artificial decrease in the first year because you're only paying six months of Interest the lease is going to be one consistent payment over the 20 years the bond has a larger upfront cost than the lease and the bond cannot be refinanced if rates were to go down and lastly ultimately the rates have to be brought to the school board and the school board has to approve the rates if they don't approve the rates and the project doesn't go forward and my second question was part of the the
021amended proposal was to change the dollar amounts to zeros for it isn't this authorizing the expenditures if we change those amounts to zero would that be preventing us from taking out the lease or is that um a valid thing to do if if you change them to zero there's no funding appropriated for the first Year's payment so obviously the board can't enter into that agreement okay but it would authorize the school to do it into future years but not this year is that the I would say it would be the vote on the ballot would decide and I would say if it lost on the ballot that is basically telling the school board no we're not doing that uh for this year and they'd have to bring it back in whatever shape or format next
022year all right so it's effectively defeating this is is that correct correct all right thank you I appreciate that thank you Mr Cy yes sir uh Rob rushon Flint metal Drive uh although the justification for this uh Amendment uh as well as nullifying the article essentially uh is that a bond would be better note that the amendment does not authorize a bond uh and the one element that uh is if it did would be that a bond would also require a higher margin for uh passage so I think uh you know effectively you might as well wipe article two off the Slate although we can't do that does a bond require a preliminary hearing you would have to have a bond hearing and we could we couldn't have it right right thank you I just
023want to bring those two points up yes uh okay one other funny thing about sb2 that I always struggle with so it's your struggle too is you're not allowed to eliminate the subject matter is zeroing out this does and and multiple cases have go gone to the Supreme Court is eight tried to struggle whether a town in the context of a meeting like this eliminated the subject matter or just modified it and where is that line um Mr moderator yes sir there's a statute directly on point um reducing the dollar amount to zero is is legal it does not constitute eliminating the subject matter thank you very much goe ahead sir right Greg darone from 65 Cleveland Hill Road understanding what a Escape Clause is is and you can't just escape from having your your
024furnace or whatever in the lights taken off but how much is the cost for the Escape Clause because it was mentioned that that was an added burden but how much is that burden and realizing that bonds and leases one is faster than the other understand so how much is that escape Clause go ahead Eric Eric thinks he knows the answer I mean I can answer that question I I we review a lot of these purchase agreements I've answered this question before in other context typically the Escape Clause means you have to um return all of the equipment at The District's expense to the um to the company um and where you're replacing uh I mean necessary equipment you'd have to then replace it um somehow you'd have to find a way to buy boilers and
025replace the equipment continue them my question so if the boilers turn out to be Duds lemons so to speak is the burden on us to give it back or is it the person that owns it which is the manufacturer I mean that's a totally different question that's really like a a warranty issue if if they turn out to be Duds they replace the boiler um the non-appropriation issue is a different issue if the voters vote not to appropriate money which is the escape Clause that's what the Escape Clause is it's a vote not to appropriate the next year's payment yeah you've got to return all the equipment um theoretically back to to the to the vendor um you may not actually be able to do that or there may be a high cost associated with
026that I don't know what that cost would be neither do I but I know it'd be a really dumb idea seriously I mean if you need the water heater to heat the building and stuff like that so I'm hoping that whoever we purchases from our board has examined you know the best one to get and so forth so this this need for an escape Clause I understand but it's going to be super hard to do that escape Clause it super hard so if we're not paying any extra for this thing it's really a mute point in my opinion so just want to make that point thank you sir yes sir web scales Jaa gold Road apologies for getting technical but um before we can enact a bond we have to have a P public bond
027hearing what's the sequence sequence of events I understand when we're in a town meeting um the town meeting occurs on a date certain my understanding with theb2 is that the bond would come before the um voters in March so it seems like if tonight we requested a bond there's plenty of time to have a bond hearing between now and when we vote on it is that not true can anybody speak to the gentleman's point he's he's checking on the dates just to give to used the co-op example because it's fresh in my head their bond hearing is February 13th for March fourth election dat Jim can check that now and see if that's something that uh has the ability to happen I think the bigger issue at hand is that I think an amendment to
028turn a lease purchase agreement into a bond would be uh a change in subject matter and wouldn't be a valid or lawful Amendment the question of whether there's sufficient time under the municipal Finance act I can look that up I don't think that's really necessary because I don't think it's lawful to change it from a lease to a bond here thank you all right um that all stated I think it would be a gross mismanagement to zero out these numbers um I think it would be a disservice to the voters who have to vote in March and so I think we should vote this amendment down thank you thank you sir yes sir Eric power again I just wanted to mention that leases do cost more because of the Escape Clause I've looked into this
029quite a bit and in the case of the co-op you're talking about an interest rate that's about 1.6% higher and on a smaller Bond it's 1.9% higher so you're you're paying for this flexibility that you really can't use that's why I think a bond is a much better approach to this and that we should vote this vote this amendment so that next year we can come back for a bond and do this at a much lower cost estimate I estimate that you'll save about $300,000 in interest by using a bond and that's more than three years payment so thank you thank you sir yes ma'am Stephanie gray Westell Road um I just wanted to first ask a question the current state is that it's been zeroed out and somebody has seconded that motion is that
030correct or has it been restored to its original good question thank you uh what you're talking about now everybody is whether you support the gentleman's motion to zero it out okay great I do not support his motion um and one of the reasons I don't support his motion is if we kick this can down the road there is no way we're saving money we're going to end up paying higher prices we all know tariffs are coming if we're not getting this stuff now we're definitely paying what 25 35 50% higher than what we've got now this isn't optional equipment our schools need this um you know your kids need heat and if we end up paying some ridiculous repairs or can't come up with the funds to replace it midy year because we didn't want
031to do it now we're doing the entire community at disservice not just our kids in this school thank you ma'am yes ma'am good evening Melanie Lake to McDaniel's Drive I rise to speak against this amendment um our school board has voted on it our finance committee our budget committee has voted on it to come up this evening with a totally different solution I think is unfair to our school board to our citizens I would vote this amendment down and move the question you can't do that oh well end all conversation after this person you no Tom Arnold my predecessor for 40 years got violent if someone got up to speak and then move to cut off conversation it's just bad I love you dear it's bad for him I'm not ex doing that you can
032get back in in line and and do it yes sir radi alligan 17 berill uh I just want to remind the voting body here tonight that this budget process starts in December if not earlier um I have personally spent many nights home alone with my daughter while these meetings were occurring so um while the idea is you know not a bad one uh I must say unfortunately uh the question of timing and coupled with the uh fact that this is an sb2 meeting uh means that the timing is not is non-existent to make this change and this is one of the negatives of2 is it reduces flexibility that the co-op board does have thanks to you know short-term changes and interest rates that have created an opportunity it's an opportunity that we simply don't have
033um it would have been great if we had known this interest rates were going to be what they are today three months ago and all this was being developed but we don't and that's just the nature of SP2 so I would strongly oppose the amendment and hope we can move the question as written so thank you yeah that was an aspirational Les it's up to somebody to get in line to shut down the discussion which you can do when they say move the question I means End discussion but you can't get up and speak your piece and then say shut it off yes sir Ed Perry for muskat anpus I'm here to do two things one I want to introduce myself to the folks right here and let you know that in a second I'm
034going to come back with a mop I'm going to actually save you folks some tax by making sure somebody doesn't have a slip and fall over here cuz there's a whole heck of a lot of water on the floor so when you see me come back with a mop that is me acting as my official Duty as a uh a select person in the town and cleaning up um but I also rise today in in an independent capacity to just call Malarkey on this amendment because here here here's what was said at the end of it let's look at this next year so usually when you listen to people long enough they'll tell you what their real intention is and the intention is to kick this boiler another year I've said this before unless you
035are talking about Arizona Iced Teas or rotisserie chickens at Costco there's nothing that remains the same price every year so we either buy the boiler for this year's prices or we get next year's prices and we don't even have to get into tariffs it's just common sense it's going to cost more so that's foolish secondarily here's the other problem I know somebody personally in Brookline right now whose boiler has failed cold today wasn't it so what happens if over the course of that year the boiler just fails well for my friend in town who doesn't have a boiler right now nobody's coming for four to five days so we would have schools closed for four to five days on some random nonsense that got brought up into a meeting from some from for something that
036does nothing this doesn't amend an article it negates it and even though it's legal it's chicanery because at the end of the day nobody's going to sell us a boiler for Z I mean come on we're all adults here in this room and we've got better things to do tonight so I do move that the person behind me once you get your point or however you want to do it Peter for Pete sake I'll get back in line too let's shut this down at some point so we don't have to spend the whole evening arguing whether or not we want to pay for a more expensive boiler in a year on the off chance it doesn't fail midwinter and put us in a real crisis thank you sir yes sir Tom Duren Meeting House Hill
037Road so I was reading this handy dandy Little Packet and uh you're talking talk about expansion for the school does this boiler include extra capacity for expansion you're looking confused here so that no page numbers awesome uh little girl looking at uh some notes and it says uh requesting new boilers we're currently beginning a discussion regarding the potential expansion of cdsa based on enrollment projections good question thank you sir yes anybody know the answer to that the boiler is somewhat larger it will have some capacity but it's not intended to uh do a new complete addition because that addition is still in um discussion format and it could look in the same form as the Portables that are out there already and those Portables come with their own Heating units so then my next question
038would be is the expansion plan for the next 20 years I don't know what your question which so you're saying you got a 20-year lease but you may be building or adding to the school is that going to happen within the 20-year lease so is it smarter to go with a shorter lease where we can then budget a larger boiler uh I think the boiler that we're looking at uh will sufficiently do what exists for csda today and slightly more when we're talking in addition we're looking at probably uh at most four class classrooms so about 4,000 ft so again if you go Portables which we are already doing in some instances um the heating unit comes with it okay I'm just curious if it's a great question yeah I mean because you got an
039option for 15 years so I'm just curious if we're just looking too far down the road with a lease understood typically with the lease is you're looking for the useful life for the new item you buy to be in excess years of what you're purchasing so we expect the boiler go you know a 30 to 40 year boiler all right that's all thanks thank you sir appreciate it remember we're on the motion to amend changing the numbers to zero Melanie would you like to speak or moop yes I do thank you Mr moderator Melanie L to McDaniel's drive thank you for correcting the procedure for me I'd like to move the question the young lady is proposing to End discussion now is there a second for her motion there is it takes a 2third majority
040to shut off the oh forgive me you guys will get to be heard the question is whether after you uh the discussion is ended so uh all those in favor of ending discussion raise your voting card thank you all those who want to keep talking raise your it's clearly 2third in favor of ending discussion except for you two guys go for it thank you for that so Bob bolio 56 Pepper Road Brooklyn New Hampshire I do support Eric's um recommended Amendment Amendment y uh the reason I support it is because he's one of the few people that I know in this town that is conservative and wants to save the taxpayers money and I know that there's a lot of people who are not conservative here obviously and that's okay but it saves all it
041saves all the families money if we save money I'm not I don't know the details of this as much as other people may do I did have a so I do support it only because of Eric's bringing up and I trust him frankly um I do have another question though somebody was mentioning there was a $40,000 rebate starting that's available this year but might go away I'm sorry sir would would you I didn't catch it I don't you're sticking on the issue about zeroing out these numbers yes but okay so I support that because Eric suggesting it and I trust him dearly so that's the only issue the floor is to make that change that's all we're talking and we'll get back to the primary stuff yeah thank you sir for understanding yes ma'am Mr
042moderator I'm sorry before we get going can I ask a question can I ask a point of order question are we owed to um is this a nonpartisan meeting I don't know what that means um you can are we allowed to are we allowed to talk politically and identify our political parties and when we're when we're making comments at the microphone I think it's empty but yes you can do that thank you yes ma'am Rebecca lebling 63 ail Road Brook line um I was wondering if uh we could repeat about the condition of the current boiler and and whether it will make it for another year do we think it's going to make it do we think it's really going to break and number two um uh I forgot sorry you got one how long
043is this thing going to last is that your question yeah how long is it do we think it's can we hear he on that please uh the ex existing boiler that we have is it its end of life in 200 end of it life in 2019 it had a substantial crack uh we were able to repair that crack and at that time which is now 6 years ago uh we were told that we should be looking to replace the boiler uh it is becoming very difficult to get parts because when a boiler gets to be that age it struggles to make the efficiency level and once it doesn't make the efficiency level companies stop making parts so that's an issue as well and I'd like to remind about is we did bring a proposal in
04420 22 to replace the boiler and uh we approved a contingency bond for 1 A5 million when the full request was for 2 A5 million and that extra million dollars was for the heating system so we've asked for this once before uh could it survive another year it may but it may go next January and I can tell you we don't have a great enough margin to fund a $700,000 boiler so we'd be here at a special meeting and would' have kids at home with their parents for a number of days while we approved that funding right and while we waited for it to be repaired and I was I remembered what I was going to say $300,000 is not nothing it's a lot so these are very good points that were raised whether you're
045conservative or liberal and uh thank you so much for that further information thank you for getting to the microphone it takes a little bit of Courage um further discussion on the motion to change these 90 ,000 numbers to zero that's the motion to amend it's on the floor seeing no further discussion we'll put changing uh we we'll put changing the $90,000 numbers to zero in the two places on article two uh all those in favor of doing so please raise your voting card all those opposed please raise your voting Ro it's clearly a a defeat for that motion to amend further discussion on the motion which reads now just as your article two reads yes ma'am Susan hait from South Main Street I have a question to the budget committee and the school board when
046you were discussing this particular article and the need to replace the boilers under the lease did you also consider the as a bond and what was the reasoning to not present to bond yeah I think we have talked we did talk about it but the rates at that point were not comparable so this is what we went with you mean the bond braids M this was what this is what we could afford and this was what was in our budget okay should article two not pass and should article three not pass what happens so I mean I think it's very similar to what Andy was just saying is that we can't guarantee that the boiler will last longer right so if if let's say the boiler goes um next October or November we're calling a
047special meeting we're having to replace the boiler school won't be running um so it's it's a pretty catastrophic failure if the boiler goes and we don't have a plan in place to replace it thank you you're welcome thank you yes sir two questions just Financial how long is a warranty every time you get up you got to do the same thing name and address oh barbert bolo brookly New Hampshire 56 Peppo Road what how long is the warranty on the boilers the on the new ones that might might be going in it's very hard to hear how long is the the warranty on the proposed new boilers warranty how long is the warranty on the new Bo how many years the new boilers if this pass have to be put out to bid and we
048have to get three bid proposals to bring to the school board and part of that information is the warranty what's the expected warranty on an average project of this size typically there's pots and labor that are usually the first five years and then uh major failures usually after that but each proposal has to come in and would be speculating in hypotheticals until the board has that that's a that's a board vote so just by passing this doesn't mean it happens because let's say the board this the proposal came in and it's much much more than we expected then we have to figure out the next solution fair enough thank you for that U my my my my thing to I want to say is we were talking about if something happens a year from now
049in January that we would have to then have the discussions pay the money Etc that would also be true s years from now or 12 years from now if it's past the warranty that's that's so there's nothing new there that's always true um my other question was and I don't know the answer to this at all actually I'm just curious there was I mention of 40,000 or some number like that rebate but that's available now but it might go away in so many years my question is yeah maybe it's I don't 42,000 rebate thank you for that um my question is if that goes away does does that stay for all 20 years guaranteed even if it quote goes away 3 years from now or do we or does it go away when it would
050have gone away anyway your Energy savings the $48,000 is the entire life and could the savings could actually go up if cost gets more expensive the rebate is a one-time rebate that's why in the first year it's cost neutral oh so that's 42,000 is it not every year just 42,000 one year okay so that's like 2,000 a year okay gentlemen forgive me for a moment finance committee member Kate is this on oh now it is you have to do the thing too oh Kate Elkins and 95 Mason Road finance committee I don't know where you live um that is where I live um wait I'm confused where you're getting the 42,000 number 42565 FY 26 potential rebates it's the second line from the bottom I see at the bottom second line from the bottom as
051as stated earlier by someone saying that was available now but might not be in the future and I'm hearing now that that's a one-time rebate not per year so the the cost for this year may be lower which is great but that's only a onetime thing I you know or or someone correct me would like to speak to that okay so um if you look at the top that's the whole project so the project is broken down into various onetime rebates and annual savings for the LED lighting there have been rebates for many many years everyone except for us has already converted to LED lights so therefore there's no incentive to continue to give rebates it still exists now it won't for much longer so it's the $70,000 that is the if we don't take
052advantage now it won't be around when you go down to the bottom the 42565 is just a portion of the 85,500 total so that is just showing demonstrating how there's zero impact to the budget if article two passes got it so it's actually 85,000 not 42,000 for I'm sorry it's actually the total is $85,500 correct that have my question thank you thank you sir yes sir Steve Brogan n Hollis Lane I just have two quick questions so one is the just want to make sure I understand this right so the lease is over 20 years it's kind of like a car lease I'm assuming where if anything breaks they come fix it correct there's a lot of Leverage uh if something were to go wrong because the lease company is also on the hook okay
053so historically when we've had an issue it's the school district and the lease company kind of going back at that vendor uh and there's a lot of power there okay um whereas with a bond it's just the school district okay and so the other question is the the I guess the longevity the security majority of the companies we using not just with the Mechanicals the the equipment but the actual lease company you know have they been around for a long time they're not somebody that's going to go bankrupt in five years or seven years or 10 years or whatever these the companies that we have leased with to the Past because we do have leases in Hollis and at the co-op um have been around for many many years okay uh they are very familiar
054with schools and the other thing I will note not knowing the prediction but it's very interesting that the latest Bond rates came down historically lease rates have also Fallen after bonds because otherwise there's no business for the leasing companies so it wouldn't shock me if I saw the lease price come down but I don't know that yet and we won't know that until after March we're out to bid okay that's positive and if I can just offer one thing I know we we we always are very reactionary with a lot of this stuff and you know like the gentleman was talking about his his neighbor that has a boilet G they're going to pay a whole bunch of money in emergency calls and trying to get somebody in their ASAP is it possible that we
055could have through our finance and school committee a fund created that like we know this boiler is going to die or be end of life at what 25 or 30 years I think you said it could explode at 21 years we don't know I would love I'd be more than happy to pay a little extra tax that went into a fund that we know the boiler is going to need replacing in 25 years here's a bunch of money so instead of being reactionary we can be a little more proactive cash is King and having having that money on hand to be like here we're going to buy a boiler now this year because we need it would be a lot better than having to put it out over bonds or put it out over leases
056which obviously are more expensive for you know many different reasons so that's just what I just yeah so I can I can let you know we do have a facilities maintenance trust which we will be talking about like article six um that is that is partially why we have that um I do not know that we would have enough in it to replace the boiler right that's because we also use that for funding um other parts like roof Replacements and windows and things like that yeah so I we can definitely get into that a little bit more at that point but it is there so yes but it's a great idea yeah to kind of prepare thank you very much yes sir hello M moderator can you hear me we can depends what you're gonna
057say well we I don't even know uh Eric Bernstein Macintosh Road um just two two questions uh first one is related to the DDC controls uh is that specific for the heating system for the lighting does it touch both and is it both buildings or just r m as it's noted here the the control systems would be across both buildings and the lighting would give us um much greater control than we have now so let's say I leave at the end of the day as a teacher and forgot to put the lights out they're going to dim it a certain number of minutes and then they're going to go off in a certain number of minutes that's what we've done around the other buildings in the SAU okay thank you so that that that $445,000
058amount is there's functionality for both the heating system and the lighting if all of this were were to pass in the control systems there is yes thank you and then my my second question is I notice there's the article three contingent article it was mentioned earlier that lease terms are determined based on the expected life of what's being leased which makes complete sense uh I noticed in article three the uh lease term was 15 years but Article 2 it's 20 and I'm just wondering uh with the primary purchase being the heating system uh why the difference between the terms the difference in terms is because if you notice in article three we're talking about 616,000 are they're not going to go 20 years financing that they just won't so you're not going to get a
05920e lease on that dollar amount okay so on if if it were to be article three we'd be leasing less than the expected life of the heating system in that case you're in either case you're leasing less than the expected life but it's just they won't fund the dollar amount appreciate it thank you thank you sir yes ma'am Jessica Hartman 51 Mountain Road just move the question thank you is there a second to ending discussion there is okay so we uh are you are about to vote on a motion which is exactly the language that is printed as article two uh all those pardon oh yeah that's right so forgive me uh I I I always forget and I go back to town meeting asking you guys to approve or not you can't approve it's
060done in the voting booth on March 11 so I fell into bad habits forgive me so um the question is is the uh is there any more discussion on that motion there's no more discussion that motion with the original language is going to go on the ballot for the voters any more discussion thank you there's no discussion so therefore that will go on the ballot in that form uh we have article three which uh how do we do this because we're not passing uh we're going to put on the ballot that uh that motion does that void article three no article 3 goes on as well excuse me you need to take up article three because it's contingent on article two so presumably one could pass and the other might not so okay let's do
061it article three reads as follows this article will be null and void if article two passes but that happens in the voting booth to see if the school district will vote to authorize the school board to enter into a 15-year lease purchase agreement for 600 $616,500 [Music] term is estimated to be $51,100 per year this lease purchase agreement will contain an escape non-appropriation Clause majority vote required estimated tax impact 4 cents on $1,000 of assessed value School Board recommends the appropriation for to zero finance committee recommends it two to zero is there a motion under article two a motion to move that's right has written yes second for the young ladies has been seconded any discussion if you'd like to discuss if they don't you feel free to Enlighten them come please okay so just
062to clarify um this is here because we absolutely need a boiler um article two includes uh the boiler the controls the LED lights LED lights and controls for both RMS and csda this article simply includes the csda boiler and the associated controls for the csda boilers as uh superintendent Cory mentioned we already asked you for the boiler in 2022 because it was um we were advised in 2019 after the crack was repaired that it wasn't going to last and we really needed to plan for it we've been trying to plan for it uh it failed in 2022 we are here now in 2025 very concerned about the boiler so this option is simply the boiler and the associated controls it's a 15-year lease for $616,500 um because we're not benefiting from additional rebates and additional
063annual Energy savings so this is $ 26,3 um um I wanted to also just address the idea of putting a little bit of money aside we do have at a capital Improvement plan we do talk about it at our meetings and this is not the only thing that we need to replace in repair in the Brookline School Districts um take a look at the the household boiler in rmms the many of them those need to be replaced with a functional boiler that can handle the size of the building it is so um we can't keep kicking it down uh keep kicking the can because we absolutely need the boiler which is why we have this contingent article thank you yes sir Rob rush and Flint metal Drive uh when you talk about Associated controls for
064just the boiler are we talking about a similar system to the DDC controls that were mentioned in the previous article uh just not covering the uh or or eliminating the LED lighting that is correct yes that's correct further discussion on the motion under article three yes ma'am Susan ha South Main Street just for clarification when we get to the voting booth we have two articles to vote that are related to the boiler how as a voter do we V vote Yes on both of them or yes no or I I would love you to vote Yes on both of them but but you also have the option of voting yes on the first one if you want to do the lights and the controls at rmms if you believe because of your tax expense that
065all is a community you can afford is the $612,000 then you would only vote on article three um but when you go in what will happen is they will tally the the results of article two if article two passed they will not worry about article three they'll count it but they will not it won't be valid if article two is counted and it fails then they'll move to article three to see if that passes okay thank you thank you anything further hearing none uh there will be in the ballot a uh article a motion you know the jargon doesn't quite work there'll be language on the ballot for you guys to vote on which will be the language of article 3 exactly as it is am I properly assuming that you're not speaking to three
066okay so we uh close on three and open on four which reads to see if the Brooklyn school department will vote to raise moderator actually wanted to take up an another article first was my motion you guys are always free to change the order of the Articles and so the gentleman is wants to do that so go ahead I'd like to take up article nine okay y second for the gentleman's desire okay article nine um okay Excuse me yes uh so the the gentleman is proposing to go out of order and uh um it's been seconded so we have discussion on that proposition would you be so kind to tell us why we should take nine out of order I think there's a lot of people here that are interested in this one and they
067wanted to vote on it early okay that's enough people want to do that so uh any further discussion on taking up article nine now hearing none we'll put it to a vote all those in favor of taking up none now raise your voting card all those opposed raise your voting card I think it's clearly uh a defeat for the motion but I'd like to count so we have the precise numbers Kate how are you with numbers uh uh Jess you going to do it too there's so few people here I think Kate can do the whole room if you don't mind my you like help okay she would use your help so we're going divide the room as we always do right down here that so the first question is everybody who wants to take
068up nine now raise your card you're fine okay you can bring them down thank you all those who don't want to take up nine now raise your voting card please yeah why you bring your numbers up okay what' you got so on yes for bringing or would you combine them that would be helpful thank you uh explain okay 21 people said let's take up uh article 9 now 47 people said let's not take up article 9 now so that motion is defeated thank you folks appreciate it so we take up four which reads to see if the Brookline School District will vote to raise an appropriate as an operating budget not including Appropriations by special warrant articles and other Appropriations voted separately the amounts set forth on the budget posted with with the warrant or
069as amended by vote of the first session this session for the purposes set forth therein totaling 12, 911, 654 should this article be defeated the default budget shall be $1,378 381 which is the same as last year with certain adjustments required by previous action of the school district or by law or the governing body May hold one special meeting in accordance with RSA 40 call and 13 ran 10 and 16 to take up the issue of a revised operating budget only majority vote required to pass simple majority estimated tax impact $763 on $1,000 of assessed value the School Board recommends this article 4 to Z the finance committee recommends this article 2 to0 is there a motion under Article 4 I'll make a motion to accept the article as written thank you very much the
070the motion is as written therefore uh we need a second we got lots of seconds Now we move into discussion uh on the motion under Article 4 please approach the mic if you'd like to you don't have to [Applause] should we should do you want me to go over this can I go over the slides that would be start okay great thanks I'm GNA do it from here but um yeah get close to that mic because can people hear me we okay great so um for the operating budget the key budget changes um we just wanted to go over include um academics the addition of year two of the primarily literacy program which will be 96,6 we're also proposing adding two regular education Personnel um with the amount of $ 26,6 42 as we continue
071to bring students back into our district in order to save the district a lot of money um we are also needing special education Personnel to work with those students so the amount as and for other special ed needs $23,170 450 we also have shared services and software of $4,280 and facilities and safety needs in the amount of $177,700 and then if we go to the next slide just sort of an overview of the major changes this year we were able to save or we're proposing Savings of $263,900 in contracted Services again that goes to the bigger picture that the district has been following of bringing our students back into the least restrictive environment it not only benefits them but it benefits the community it benefits their peers and it is a Financial benefit special ed
072Transportation costs would be going down $185,900 64 um on the other side of that in order to make these switches we have the uh special ed positions that I mentioned before the regular Ed positions and then outof District um tuition is going up $182,600 so the major changes total is $615 for the next slide for the default budget summary the um FY 25 this is if the default budget were the one we resorted to was um 12,637 31 um we have costs that are required by law or contracted increases or reductions adding up to $339,100 okay just want to make sure with the expenses $247 um leading to the default budget total of 12, 378,000 48,3 we're now saving on transportation and special ed services 381,000 323 um Insurance Health dental FICA nhrs is going
073up $ 35,2 35 regular education Transportation costs uh include 9,248 and regular education contracted services are $2,755 and various other small amounts are zero um for people just so they're aware if we had to use the default budget that would mean the following Cuts would need to happen or certain additions would not happen for me give me cing everybody understands the default budget is the uh budget we revert to if the primary budget is defeated at the polls it kicks in the default as a mandatory alternative thank you thank you for explaining that though I should have done that um academic positions that would be impacted are the prek coordinator we would have to um we would cut that to manage and the purpose of the coordinator is to manage our growing population and growing
074programs which include bringing students again keeping students in their home schools which benefits everybody um it cutting an proposed environmental science position which um would save $93,600 just to staff our students um teaching positions would be cut which would again affect class sizes and we are bound by class siiz mandates that the town has told us um that they want so that would have to change we would no longer have um interventionists to support student learning needs um and behavioral needs the reading literacy program which we already started in year one would be cut we would not be able to afford that um we most districts almost all districts use walkie-talkies to ensure safety which is even more important um year by year and those would be cut uh grade six has annually gone on
075a culminating uh experience to The Brown Center um it's something that the sixth graders look forward to that would be cut uh students would not be allowed to access the soccer field for recess at csda because in order to allow students to access that field all students have to have access and part of our proposed budget would allow all students to have access um life skills renovation um would need to not happen and again when we're talking about um bringing our students back in so that they can be with their peers it's NE we can't just bring them back into a regular classroom we have to provide for them and again for those who might just be looking at is this a cost savings to send a student out of District who has needs it
076can be anywhere from $85 $90,000 and above just for tuition never mind Transportation so just be aware you can you overall we can see some of the numbers how we're shifting and we're savings but we can't just bring kids back without providing them what they need that's not successful um we would also have to cut out replacement tables doors and flooring um these are endof life Replacements those would not be able to Happ happen and we would also not be able to do counter lamination portable skirting and painting for end of life replacements for those you can take questions and comments cor our bone 65 Cleveland Hill Road that's great slide for me to talk to and I've been here long enough to know that people move into our community get their kids through our
077school system and then they leave and they've raise the tax because it's for the children I always want someone to get up and go but what about the grandparents who've been here for ages right Peter you and I yeah all right so there's a lot of money there and I understand for instance the Ada access for soccer field totally understand I would vote for that I have no problems with that or the life skills uh renovation I understand why you know what I do have to question environmental science is that a person that is going to go from grade to grade teaching environmental science it is it would be a special so tell me why a second grade teacher can't do what that person is said give me a break ask the question all right
078so tell me why can't a second grade teacher who's been teaching all the subjects that do now can't add that to their science that they teach well you wouldn't have a second grade teacher the second grade teacher is bound by the curriculum standards which are standards across the board different grade to grade which aren't environmental science across the board so number one number two is that the this would be this is a full-time position so this person would be teaching a whole curriculum so science grade to grade I hear what you're saying I disagree so we you don't interrupt she didn't interrupt you you listen and he I'm disagree that's I didn't know if um Gina wanted to talk to the position at all or Andy to to answer or if that's sufficient the environmental
079position does a couple things one it allows us to uh get the proper number of specials for growing enrollment because right now we're starting to see rmms at some SE some class our grades have five sections some four so we're going to need an extra special uh educationally number two it actually is kind of replacing Spanish which we did away with a few years ago and the reason for eliminating Spanish was there's simply a lack of teachers um number three we live in the community of Brookline similar to Hollis who has environmental um it is probably one of the fastest growing Fields there is and we need to take advantage of all the resources we have locally we are purchasing a number of conservation Acres it would be nice to teach children why we do
080that and um and finally it will allow our teachers to get a level of experience that a generalist doesn't hold in science I hear you but I disagree I and I respect that so I just want to say every person we add adds cost there's a retirement for them there's health insurance for them so forth and so on and it's been a while since I was in second grade but my second grade teacher Mrs Clarkin could teach a whole bunch of subjects and we would go out in the woods and look at the environment there now I know today's kids are much smarter than we were back then so uh they may need a specialist to do this kind of stuff but the Boy Scouts taught me a lot my local teacher taught me a
081lot living in the woods so personally I think we can reduce the big budget without hurting too much the one that's you know if we go to the default there are some things are going to drop off that we we do need okay uh but but environmental science and teaching positions we got to look at some of that you know in interventionist how do we do it today that's a question I have how do we do it today that we have to hire this one special person and I know it's important I totally understand but how do we do it today I think what we were talking about earlier is that as we have first of all a growing population we also have special education increases we have growing needs so again again it's similar
082to what I was saying about life skills renovation you just don't bring students back with um unique needs and expect them to be able to learn in the same way as their typical peers so in some ways the interventionists can help with that interventionists are also looking at overall progress making sure that we're keeping our scores up for um making sure our kids are learning appropriately kids that might be falling behind so there's many uses for interventionists so my next question then is we have an interventionist there and we have a life skills renovation is that a person also life skills renovation no renovation is physical renovation of a room so ramps and stuff like that so wheelchairs can go where I want to double check life skills renovation to me means yeah okay I
083want to check my I want to be 100% make sure we weren't adding another person again I I just I caution us from hiring more people you know and that's every time I look at the numbers I try to compare where we are today to where the same number of students were a few years ago and how many more teachers do we have today or actually more administrators I'm a big anti-administration person I think teachers should get credit for doing a lot of great things so we need more teachers that's my personal opinion so we have a lot of Administrators that supervise the many teachers but if we eliminate every administrator except maybe the principal we probably could still run an efficient School because we're giving the teachers that ability before so I don't I
084don't want to go too far oh sorry I did interrupt you sorry I I just that's my personal opinion we got to be careful of people that we hire because of all those other costs we're not looking at that's my bottom line so thank you thank you sir appreciate it um Mr moderator yes could I just um make one comment is I just want to point out K El Kate Elkins 95 Mason Road um that these are potential cut and I wonder if uh the superintendent could speak to that word potential and how you came to these suggested Cuts before we move on sure I'd be happy to um obviously the difference between the recommended budget and the default budget is call it about $600,000 and as a result of that we went through and
085outlined some of the recommendations that we would make to the school board ultimately the school board would make the choices between the uh the budget pass by the voters and what would need to be cut uh we would recommend some of these because they would be new positions we're asking them for them now um and that's why they would be looked at and scrutinized but the board could choose to go in a different way okay thank you if I could also I do think it's relevant to the question question and I don't know that everybody has it in front of them but the process of doing this budget actually went through four rounds so in every area we have cut what the district actually wanted and felt like they needed so this has been carefully
086considered month after month um I won't go through the whole thing I it should be in the packet but for example in the round one of academics for both buildings the proposals were for 121,00 $39 and it was cut to 96,6 in Personnel the recommendation um was 320,000 approximately and it was cut to 206,000 so we've already gone through extensive cuts to meet the needs of um vote to to balance the needs of everybody we have to meet the needs of our students but we also have also take into consideration um the needs of taxpayers the one area where um costs did go up because it's mandated as special ed Personnel but again we've talked about the flip side of that is how much money we're actually saving by allowing students to remain in the
087least restrictive environment so in every area and I'm just checking as we're going through um cuts have been made already and I I will note further to the point um that Greg brought up about Personnel um regulations change and if we are are unable to hire Personnel in house we end up Contracting out which is a significant hit to the budget we're paying sometimes double to Triple the cost for hiring in house so I wanted to make that aware as well this is a conversation that we have um we invite you to the budget meetings you'll hear us have this conversation all the time um but we want to do our best by taxpayers which is also limiting the amount of people we're having to contract out and double and triple pay for by attempting
088to bring them in house so that we are in the long run meeting the needs and regulations that we are required to meet by the federal and state government while also providing you the taxpayers the best uh bing I guess for your buck that we can I don't know if that is the right way to phrase it but we're trying to be very mindful of both so um and I just I wanted to add um you know I I think there's probably a lot of people in these rooms who who spend some time in our schools who either have children there or volunteer there um and I think you know I think everyone is aware that there's an increase um of Behavioral in issues in children there are um you know increased mental health issues
089and you know and and a lot of people who also left the teaching uh profession after the pandemic and and so the stress on our our staff and our administrators is pretty and on our students is actually pretty high and so you know when I look at some of the things that you know know um we have looked at as a board you know when when Colleen is you know reviewing like things that we've cut you know we've looked at um like behavioral reports or incident reports and seen that like many of these behavioral issues happen on school buses so we were like oh great let's let's get a school bus monitor let's have some adults you know who can help monitor what's going on in the buses so the bus drivers can actually drive
090and maintain safety on the road um you know so we cut that right we we are really cognizant of the stress on everyone's pocketbooks and um you know our principles are often substituting in classes because we don't have substitutes so you know you can't just have one administrator in the building because you know there's there's literally like little fires everywhere that have to be put out and sometimes that person who's the principal in the building is you know doing lunch duty or uh substitute teaching for the day um so our administrators and our and our teachers have done really amazing work with with very few resources and um and I just want I want to point that out this is a really lean budget and we are trying to add salaried positions to number one
091keep more students in our buildings in our district um in the community and also as um Johanna was saying stop paying so many contractors right there are there are resources that we are required by law to provide to students and if we can't hire those positions we are going to pay for them at three to four times the cost that's included in this Budget on the heels of of what Kelly said just the work that we did with this budget this year um every single round that came back to the board every single time we asked um we we asked to have them go back and make it lower and every single time um our administrators and the budget committee was able to do that and this budget is a reflection of that and the
092multiple rounds to get it to a point where we as a board have asked the professional who run the schools that as much as you've cut you're do you feel confident with this for the year and they and they do and we we have cut a lot we have tried to be very mindful of um everybody and the community and costs so I just want to Echo that and the the work that went into this and our multiple rounds um and again every single time we asked them to to bring it down and bring it down and they did without hesitation right so I do just want to call that out for the room as well thank you yes sir yes Eric power West VI Road I wanted to bring up the slide that says
093BSD tax rate info please think it was in the intro we didn't actually show it there it is thank you um for those aren't aware in 2019 we passed a 8% local tax cap under RSA 325b which means the tax effort cannot go up more than 8% a year the proposed one and so this slide is the closest to that calculation the only thing that's missing on this is on the tax effort part of the law um says that you can add you you're supposed to bring forward a fund balance from the previous year which is $338,500 which means the total tax effort with that fund balance would be 8,924 1995 and if you do that with the the $9.95 one million that's a 11.5% increase that's been proposed going into the meeting where we
094have an 8% tax cap so I'd like to know why are we exceeding the tax cap the purpose of a tax cap is to limit the proposed spending going into the deliberative session yes sir thank you sir can someone address that please I'd be happy to uh we spent uh pretty much an entire board meeting working with the school board and attorney oanes on the tax cap calculation we followed what was provided to us by legal councel and uh I did pose your question to Legal uh and the response I got respectfully was that your interp ration of the law doesn't make it the correct reading of the law well the first few years we had the tax cap this was the methodology that was used and all of a sudden it's changed and I'm
095concerned about that um the if you go go to can you go to the slide that says tax cap or do you have that tax cap calculation I have a print out of it here with me it's in the public hearing which I could not unfortunately go to but um about a week ago I made an inquiry I did not hear back at least I didn't see a response um but the in the tax cap calculation that they Ed they just had operating budget the warrants and then there was nothing about revenues and either the current year or the previous year it was just adding up all the expenditure is like it's a budget cap and we do not have a budget cap we have a tax effort cap so I'm really concerned that we're
096not following the uh you know the tax cap that we passed that's what I'd like to point out and I'm very concerned about that and I'd like to make a motion to amend as a result I'd like to make a motion to amend uh the warn article on the floor to a new figure of 11,867 198 you going have to do that more slowly 11, 467,000 $198 is there a second the gentleman's motion to amend there is uh would someone like to address that Mr power I'm a little concerned about the time you've occupied that microphone there's a long line behind you while I was patient here while other people were talking I just would like to talk the reasoning where I came from this so if you go back to uh fy22 we had
097587 students we're down to 571 we've lost 16 students in the four years uh there has been inflation of about 211% so we have inflation of 21% we lost 3% that's a net of about 18% or 17.9 so this budget is accounting for the change in students and the inflation we had a lot of inflation that's where this new number came from for the FY 26 budget uh people cannot afford the taxes in this town they're going up rapidly I know we have to strike a balance but I think it's out of balance and that's why I'm making this proposal thank you thank you so we have on the floor then this motion to amend to this 11 million number that's what we're addressing Ed Perry for muskat tanus so at this point we can
098speak either in favor or against and it's we limited too you you can speak to the merits of it yes I thought a few moments ago the idea was we had to get out of here a little bit quickly so we could get to the uh items later in the night that people wanted to entertain guess that's not a concern anymore um I'm going to give you a little fast forward on how the rest of the night's going to go because I've been to a few of these because I know enough we're going to have a long line of people who are going to discuss this operating budget and at the end of it we're going to pass the operating budget and the same handful of people that disapproved of the last thing are going
099to be in the minority again and we're going to do this lather into to repeat for the next three hours and some people are going to complain about the length of it but I'd like you to know that the people who complain about the length of it are the people who are taking up the most time talking about things that don't make a heck of a lot of sense the idea that someone could stand up in a public meeting and on the back of a brown paper bag care don't make personal don't make it person speak to the merits any person I can speak to any person that's within the law I'm not speaking it's not a matter of law I'm the law here you're going to you're going to be civil and respectful is
100you do not have to Target anybody we not the merits of the issue are the only thing you guys are going to talk about I believe you misheard me the idea that any person this is a common thing that's been said at every meeting Peter and I I know you know this the idea that anyone could come up with a better number than a group of people who have struggled over this number for right you've heard this many times before it's not new I don't remember the idea that someone could come up with a better figure in a minute than people who have been looking at these numbers for months and months months and months and have been to hearings and have tossed the numbers back and forth with legal and have come up with
101ways to reduce it the idea that they don't have the Fuller picture of this considering that they know every other element of the school budget is a little bit Preposterous just saying but beyond that the other part that we heard here is that we've got to contain these budget costs you're not going to do that here tonight folks and you're to know that because you're going to look at these numbers and you're going to divide them by 265 taxable plots and that's basically all you can sa yourself some people might not know this but here is how your tax bill breaks down your property tax bill break I wish we had a slide for this one because it's a good one 71% of your tax bill does go to the schools that's absolutely true 20%
102covers your Municipal um your local stuff here the stuff that the select board passes 3% we kick over to County and then there's the state portion you see in the state of New Hampshire the Constitution says that the state has to provide adequate funding to the schools as well now we're putting in 71% you got to imagine it must be a high figure right it's five the state contributes five and here's the kicker one of the reasons why we're dealing with less is because they're going to give us less now they're going to give us Less on special education and unfortunately we are still unfortunately because these people deserve the service we still have fed Federal mandates now how that works is the federal mandates say that there's a certain amount of money that's going
103to have to be paid on special education the state is supposed to reimburse that money to us they don't reimburse all of it and they don't do it all at the same time and every year they discuss up and conquered how they can put less money into the schools I get it folks taxes are not sustainable folks are out there struggling to BU eggs but here's the thing if you really want to save money I you how to save 5% off your property Bill call conquered talk to your state representative and say come up with some other formulas for that 5% because it's kind of weird that you're taking your 5% portion out of my property taxes as well might be an idea but they don't discuss that up in concerete they got other stuff
104to do on the merits of this particular thing just changing the number isn't going to do a whole heck of a lot but it is going to cut a lot of those programs out of there and people are going to talk about those programs as if they're all extra things that we don't need but something that you've heard a lot tonight is the term end of life one more minute end of life floors end of life doors end of life boilers that's not fiscal responsibility fiscal responsibility used to not just be tax cuts it was savings it was buying things when they were cheap had we bought this boiler those boilers three years ago we would have saved a heck of a lot of money but no we kicked it down the line and we
105spent more thank you sir yes sir this question is related to the amendment here and your name would be Brian oh sorry Brian Raider 31 Mason Road and I am still happy to be sitting on this side and not on that side um the uh uh yeah this question is related to the uh Amendment for changing the dollar amount my question is um how is could you explain how the um the 12.9 million that that's proposed um satisfies the cap that is in place um what's the details that allows that to work we um at the public hearing provided a slide uh that demonstrated the calculation that legal council had approved that supported the budget that we put in front of you um and here it comes so the 12,916 54 is the budget the
106SAU warrant is 493 606 the maintenance trust is 6 360 360,000 the lease is 9,565 and the fund balance that we anticipate return returning to the tax pay is US 100,000 that gives us the tax year 20 25 of 13, 995 825 and when we look at the tax cap amount of 13, 32,36 you arrive at a 7.09 calculation to be under the 8% and that's the uh calculation that legal council we we had them come to a meeting and spent the money to make sure we're being correct so the board had that uh I did send Mr power's question to him uh and they went through and reviewed it and it they just feel it's a different way of interpreting something and they feel the way we did it was legal and correct okay
107so the um uh funds that the school returns to the town is part of that calculation if if unless I misheard that's correct okay right thank you thank you sir yes ma'am hi Don Albertson uh 21 Pigeon Hill Road and really my for me I just felt like this whole conversation was losing context um and I think it's deeply important obviously when we talk about spending we need very serious look at it and my understanding is you went through four rounds is that right of of work on this budget and I appreciate the time and energy that went into that um I think the other part of context is important is that families move here for the amazing School District it's a huge drop and it's uh a more affable option than Hollis and we
108are holding our own all ings right so school is not just a thing to be considered um I think in par with other things but fundamentally the the context I was really hoping to speak to was the idea that outside of grades one and two we actually are working well above the state average in terms of pups per classroom and if you look we are spending about 20% less than the state average per student um so whilst this might be positioned to seem like wild budget um these people are working very lean and uh thoughtfully to make sure to deliver the continued school education which brings families in which raises everyone's property values right um so this is an investment in our community that is beyond just for the children um but it's also for
109the children and those are perfectly acceptable things to say out loud because it is of course why we're here in a school um talking about how we deliver for these students and the ways in which that that feeds our community and that feeds our state um so again we are already working 20% below the state average um there's a huge Delta between the conversation around the wild inflamatory pricing uh and what's actually happening here so that's my statement thank you so I I presume you're speaking against the uh well go ahe you guys will have to figure it out go ahead Brady hallan 17 burill uh folks who have been to these meetings before know I make this statement every year if you torture numbers long enough they will confess to anything I could make
110this budget say had a net tax impact of Z I could make this budget say it had a net tax impact of 40% all depends on how you do the math as we all know the reason why attorneys have jobs is because there are discussions about the law and disput about the law and that's why we have attorneys in courts etc etc etc so debate is natural and healthy and we should not be running around accusing other people of violating the law because that's not what people do around here um and to the woman's point yes Brookline actually is 20% lower than Hollis in in our cost for the Brookline School District so we do do a pretty good job around here um and I just wanted to make sure that that point was very
111very clearly made as well as there is a meeting public meeting every single night uh these days uh the school board at least has all of them on YouTube for free every single archived one too you can look at them and review all of this information before you come tonight and know exactly what's going on how these decisions were made I would encourage people to look at that stuff this is all your public transparency out there for you I oppose the gentleman's motion because this work has already been done and this is a Bare Bones budget that's already 20% lower than the state average thank you thank you sir yes ma'am hi Stacy espito 26 peol Road um I know that this is related to the tax cap however at and I don't know if
112this is allowed but at the meeting on Monday for the co-op um a tax cap I believe it was a tax cap was presented um and within that presentation was the notion that at any point it can be um amended or shifted or changed I don't know if I can ask specifically about the tax cap um and the rules around it but it does seem as though the way at least it was presented at the co-op meeting made it sound as though it was a little bit more flexible than it seeming right now thank you so I think that's really all I want say thank you appreciate it yes sir Rob rushman Flint Meadow Drive um this if I heard the numbers correctly uh this amendment to the article puts us in a rather odd
113position again which we've seen before where if we defeat the budget we pay more and if we pass the budget we pay less so I mean if that is confusing to anybody here imagine it's going to be fairly confusing to any of the voters come uh voting day um I think that would in itself is enough to say hey wait a minute we we are making things more difficult for for the rest of us uh I think voting is complex enough that we need to uh make things as simple and as direct as possible without this amendment we've got a good choice in front of the voters a perhaps somewhat less than ideal default budget or a budget that better meets the needs of our school system so I would uh recom amend that we
114vote against this amendment thank you thank you sir yes sir Tom Duran Meeting House Hill Road so I I just want to say that uh about 15 minutes ago $365,000 in interest wasn't made a big deal and suddenly add 200k to it it is just you know maybe the whole Bond thing might have been a better idea to rethink but we can't talk about that anymore so I just want to say I'm in favor of the amendment thank you sir yes sir Bill Graham aine as a taxpayer of 40 years I support the work that you have done I think you do your best to really try to deliver a good school board and a good environment for us and the people who live here as a taxpayer I support he is proposing you know
115give us a lower tax bill I think we all want that I think as a country it's pretty damn clear we're spending more than any other country in the world and we're ranked around 40 in terms of the rest of the country rest of rest of the St nations in the world so kind of education that the at a national level that we're giving our students is inferior to what's being happening in the rest of the world so think about the system that's going on here that's giving you your job that you're doing admirable and trying to deliver on but also think about the money that we're spending and why we're at this impass you know trying to sort this problem out seems to me like the Tail's trying to Wag the Dog a lot
116and um think also about the change That's Just Happening Here in the country if the Department of Education goes away all this stuff changes have you thought about that much thank you very much sir anything further on the motion to amend our $12 million number the first one in article 4 to 11,466 1198 it's a motion to amend to make that change not to approve anything other than making that change and then you'll have to vote about the motion the changed motion if you choose to change it all those in favor of changing the number from 12,9 11,654 to $1,467 1098 please raise your voting card oppos please raise your voting it's clearly a vote defeating the motion to amend therefore you guys revert back to the original motion which is the very language of
117the article any further discussion or do we move this to the voters yes ma'am clearly in any budget the biggest piece is salaries she still Sue hate oh sorry Susan Kate South Main Street Brookline um as I was saying clearly the biggest part of any budget is salaries and benefits there's not much that can be done about benefits but in most corporations salaries become a key part and there is such a thing as a reduction in salaries I know historically for the last 50 years I've been involved in this District the the argument is we need good teachers and it's for the benefit of the students and that's the argument every single year in every single budget and I don't have a problem with that basically but at some point in time I think it
118has to be said enough's enough maybe we need to hold salaries and I know that the unions require certain things but there has to be a way around some of that and I I don't know what the answer is but I think we need to try to control the biggest part of the budget thank you thank you Madame anything further otherwise this thing goes to the ballot seeing no further discussions that's exactly what will happen the motion under article four goes on to the ballot moving on to Article Five shall the voters of the Brookline School District adopt a school administrative unit budget of 2,438 355 for the forthcoming fiscal year in which $493,000 is assigned to the school budget of this school district this year's adjusted budget of 2,389 654 with $483,000 $748 assigned
119to the school budget of this school district will be adopted if the article does not receive a majority vote I've confused myself I kind of want to I kind of want to read that all over again shall the voters adopt a gross budget for the SAU of two grand 2 million plus 490 is going to be our school district District's burden question mark that's simple this year's adjusted budget what is the adjusted budget is that default budget legally talk legally it's at an SAU it's called adjusted it's not called a default that's why okay but it's the same same same concept okay so this year's adjusted default budget of 2,389 654 with $483 783 assigned to the school budget of this district will be adopted the default thing will be adopted if the article does
120not receive a majority vote of all School District voters voting in the school administrative unit I get it now do you get it now should I do okay estimated tax impact 42 cents on $1,000 of assessed value the school board recommends this article 40 the finance committee recommends this article two Z motion under this article like to make a make a motion as written it's been moved as written does the young lady have a second she has a second discussion on the motion under Article Five Peter can we go to the next slide can I just talk through this a little bit well it would be right for the school board to uh be the proponents and therefore to address this issue you use whatever slide you want I'd like to just talk about this
121before we get into conversation is that okay just SEC this subject matter is is is it related to yeah it's the budget it's the the budget yes it's it's Article Five whatever fabulous Do It Fabulous thank you um this is you you'll see this this is a flat budget this year for all intense purposes there's a increase of $122,000 $2,510 um over last year's budget the uh the factors in this one is that we we have a savings in the superintendent salaries with Andy's departure um so we have some savings there there were some savings with the New Hampshire retirement system there are increases in this budget um primarily driver of that is a 4% of salary increases which are contractual that we need to honor um after we have gone through negotiations with the
122unions um so but it's relatively a flat budget overall and the work that the SAU did with that this year um as you can see up up on the board so I just wanted to take a moment and call that out for everybody and now we're good thank you you're welcome appreciate it very much yes sir Rob rushon Flint metal Drive uh it's my understanding that this particular article is not subject to amendment that is the number yes numbers are not subject to Amendment then I suggest we move on second look it people seem to always feel free to talk about stuff that means nothing so let's let's not start that precedent okay therefore the gentleman's right the statute says we can't tweak these numbers therefore it will go to the voters as written unless
123anybody violently objects seeing no violent objection we'll go forward to article six which reads to see if the school district will vote to raise an appropriate sum of up to $360,000 to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust fund from the June 30th unassigned fund balance otherwise known as a surplus no amount to be raised from taxation estimated tax impact foregoing a potential rate reduction 30 cents on $1,000 assessed value the school board recommends this article 40 Finance recommends this article 20 motion under article 6 motion moved as written second for the young ladies motion second we got discussion on the motion under article six please um so I'll just run through the slides really quickly to kind of explain so article six is addressing our maintenance fund um when we look
124at the current status of the fund um the FY 25 ending balance you'll see there is 33317 we're asking for 360,000 yes thank you to replenish it um the proposed usage wow that was loud proposed usage is 339,000 um with an FY 26 anticipated ending balance of 54,3 20117 um when we look at the proposed uses we are looking at again a couple of projects some that we've already started some that we are um looking ahead so uh with rmms intercom Bell's phones we are um in year two of a two-year project the first year was last year um so that's $50,000 um they are at end of life so we've already started replacing them and this year we would finish um for the csda we would be creating step program spaces so this is
125important because it is um allowing us to kind of provide programming spaces uh for students that are moving up from rmms to csda so rmms actually already has step programming csda does not so that's where that number is coming from um we are looking at bathroom Renovations for phase one um Andy can let me know if I say this wrong but I believe that they are not currently Ada compatible I believe they are grandfathered in yes Kelly's Ming yes okay so our goal here is to make them Ada compatible um that is important that all of our students are able to access the bathroom um as the mother of a preschooler it is very important that people can access the bathroom and then we have the roof replacement of Milford Street for rmms um for
12685,000 um that's because we'd like Dan to stay off the roof so we want that to be um and something that we're mindful of um and that is where we are at for the usage and I believe that's the end of my slides okay thank you very much further discussion on the motion under article six Rob Rush it again still Flint metal Drive um how does the appropriation uh to this fund this year compare with the last few years I know it's an ongoing time okay so let me let me pull up last year's um minutes really quickly yeah the maintenance trust is up significantly closer the maintenance trust is up significantly this year um and it's just the projects that are coming due the two major things is the the space for the step
127program which will allow us some cost avoidance and then the moving forward the bathroom renovations to become ADA Compliant so I think we were closer to about 180,000 last year I give a take I'm not I don't have that number in front of me okay so I looking at last year um we asked for 156,000 um we that was foregoing a potential rate reduction of 13 cents to the Thousand so it is up this year um but again we do have different needs so creating the step program here at csda is allowing for what Colleen was referencing earlier with um least restrictive environment which is very important also because students are coming up from rmms um programming is coming with them and spaces are needed for that so that's kind of a big piece of
128it this year um but that is in turn allowing us to service students in house which is important in terms of integration and life quality and also um out of state or out of District placements can be upwards of $200,000 a year so that yes per child that is not like a so if we're saying roughly you know five kids have to go out we're looking at like that's a pretty significant chunk of money versus the 100,000 that we're asking for here to help so so it is a little bit higher this year but there's reasons that we kind of um have that we've we can't really put off any longer okay yeah so my understanding more money this year but all going to necessary and appropriate purposes yes Gina has a yes I I'm
129sorry I got to get you on the microphone because people at home thank you I just want to remind everyone this only funds if there's money to fund it at the end if there's U money left over so you're foregoing a tax reduction so if we only have 200,000 then only 200,000 can fund um and at this point it looks like we're not going to have any money left over so uh might it might be a moot point that's good to know thank you yes thank you J yes sir web scales dupa gold Road um I find this all very frustrating the um facilities are critical to our operation they need to be maintained they need to be able to provide the capacity capabilities that the student students and staff require um and so seeing
130this trust fund funded and then with a full intention of depleting it again during the year suggests to me that these are important considerations that ought to be in the main operating budget as normal expenditures these are not um things that we are um let me back up when we we started doing this trust the idea was that we could save money over several years for uh large expenditures and we could even out the the flow of taxes and so I would expect to see something in here like the roof which part of it's in here but we're now doing the roof peace meal pretty much every year I would have liked to have seen something in here for the boiler um we knew this expense was coming three years ago why on Earth didn't
131we put money to board the boiler and so to to have this as just another funding mechanism so that we can claim that the operating budget is flat and then we can turn around and say but we're going to spend all this money on maintenance sounds like a shell game to me and what's worse if we actually don't have money left over from this past year and we can't fund these things now I feel like gracious that was mismanagement not that we didn't save the money but that we didn't provide the money that we need to spend so having you come to us and say please allocate money for these expenditures is very frustrating to me because if we need to spend this stuff why isn't it in the budget thank you thank you sir
132yes sir great against 17 Bell uh to the gentleman's Point uh there is a reason for that and I believe there's a proposal to address that um in article 7 um so I would like to uh propose to amend this we said there's not going to be any we don't think there's going to be any money in the trust fund um it's it's looking uh at projections right now is looking like that is a possibility yes can we go to the language of the article itself slide so I would like to change the dollar amount to 300,000 and I would like to strike through from the June 30th unassigned fund balance so that the article will read to see if the school district will vote to raise an appropriate a sum of up to $300,000
133to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust fund period period and the balance out correct so would the effect would be that actually let me change it from the June 37 Sun out Surplus comma if available well I don't know if I can do that either what I want to do is I want to say if there isn't any money in this unassigned fund balance we're going to raise it through taxation because this stuff needs to happen and if it doesn't happen we don't have any money for our day if there's no money in the unassigned fund balance to give to this account this account will have 20 grand in so where are you now I'll just leave it as I'll just leave it as original and if we have to Mor
134we have to Mor to see if the school district will raise and approprate up to $300,000 to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust fund period period okay is there a second to the gentleman's motion there is a discussion on that motion to amend Stephanie gray 24 West Hill Road um it was going to say something completely different but now that we've had that motion to amend and I've seconded it um I don't know to have anything to say except for I support the new suggestion I appreciate that thank you yes sir so if we're raising this in taxes as opposed to taking it out of the existing funds and the unassigned fund balance would that put us over the tax cap this body has that ability I'm sorry what was that
135this meeting has that ability if you as voters make that change and it's moved from here to the Del from the deliberative then that's what goes to the ballot okay great thank you so as as I've learned over time the tax cap applies to what they can propose but not what you guys can vote and can I can I just um draw people's attention again to the four rounds of the of the budget so in the first round there was $100,000 allocated in the facility's maintenance line for the bathroom Renovations there was $85,000 allocated for the Milford Street roof um you know there were $30,000 allocated for classroom floors so all of those things were in the budget we I think have heard that feedback Mr scales like many times and I think many of
136us are frustrated with that as well and so I think we really wanted to put forward a budget that did include all the things that we need to do to keep our facilities um up to date and you know safe and working properly and um and then we had to take it out and so I appreciate the amendment and I think if this legislative body is willing to uh put that forward to the voters then I think that's a great idea thank you so just to remind everybody we are on a motion to amend as you've heard several times the number changes to 300 and taking out the unassigned fund balance language yes sir I had a question does the school board given if it's amended at this deliberative session does the school board and
137the finance committee revisit their uh potentially their recommendations at a public meeting after this before it gets put on the ballot yeah so the the article has recommendations of those boards and we've just changed the article so you're wondering shouldn't those recommendations be changed well do they revisit them given the new language and the numbers does that happen and when does that happen don't know the answer anybody know the answer to that don't we as far as positions the board opens a meeting if items were changed during the evening and takes a position on any article that has changed the finance committee has that option as well okay very good um yeah I'd like to see what they vote on given this new number I'm against this because I think this is going to be
138uh against you know returning money to taxpayers it's actually going to raise the taxes by $300,000 instead of using potentially leftover money and for that reason I would oppose this amendment let me ask a question so the the school board doesn't have the option of using the Surplus and a specific authorization to use a surplus as we go through the budget which right now um just for voters to know it's in about the same place it was a year ago and then because of a couple special education changes that could take place between now and the end of the year just like last year we went from a negative projection to 330,000 return to the taxpayers that's how volatile special education is so what would happen is we continue to go through our revenue and
139expense reports if this project is funded through taxation then I don't Envision the school board utilizing a surplus but they may have a surplus and they do have that right to spend it thank you so we have a motion on the floor which is to change the motion under Article Five excuse me under article six whereby it would read as it's put on the ballot as follows to see if the school district will vote to raise an appropriate appropriate the sum of up to $300,000 do do you want up to in there of Brady was your thing up to or of no take out take out up to yeah sorry because it needs to be a su certain if you're raising it through taxation versus if you're raising it through Surplus it can be up
140to because it it's dependent on how much Surplus is available that's why that phrase is there got it thank you glad you're here that's why I'm not an attorney yes that's that's what I want that's what the gentleman wants again it'll read to see if the school district will vote to ra an appropriate the sum of $300,000 to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust fund period and the recommendations Etc are now obsolete because we've changed the thing so if you would like to make that change to $300,000 and deleting that other language please raise your voting card if you're in support of that proposition thank you if you're opposed please raise your voting card uh counter is I'm uncomfortable would you be so kind as a count it's too close for
141me all those in favor of the change please raise your voting card I think you guys got it but I I want to make sure we're good then you can put your hands down and the counters will give me a number so I know what's going on oh we didn't do the oppos post oppose raise your voting card you guys are falling off he's just waving to you uh the motion to amend is supported by a majority of 44 to 19 opposed so uh if there's more discussion or not otherwise it goes on the ballot with this new language okay pardon me repeat the language sure it uh the ballot will read unless you guys have some further to do to see if the school district will vote to raise and appropriate the sum of
142$300,000 to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust fund period any further discussion all right that's what'll be on the ballot excuse me Peter pardon me can I make a motion to restrict reconsideration of any of the previously addressed warrant articles yeah in sb2 we'll go through the motions even though I'm not sure it has any effect uh is there there is a motion to restrict reconsideration uh I it's more than my brain can handle at the moment I don't I don't think an sb2 re reconsideration can happen y yep what yeah I mean it's specifically addressed in the statute it just means that if it passes it goes right to the ballot and it can't be raised later on during the deliberative session without it someone could raise a motion to
143reconsider something that's already been passed on okay I hope you guys got that so uh there's been a motion reconsider to restrict reconsideration meaning that it can't be we can't have a do over here tonight on that issue that decision was Final is there a second for such a motion there's a second for such a motion all those in favor of restrict reconsideration raise your voting cards thank you opposed raise your voting cards thank you it's restricted thank you Kelly yes okay so we move on to article 7 as we build the ballot for the people to vote on resend tax cap shall we resend the provisions of RSA 325b known as the tax cap as adopted by the Brookline School District on March 12 2019 so that there will no longer be a limit
144on increases to the recommended budget in the amount to be raised by local taxes I me be a limit with a recommended budget in the amount to be raised by taxes three- fth majority would be required on such a vote in The Ballot Box the school board recommends the article 40 Finance recommends is tied one to one uh motion under article 7 all motion yes as moved as written yes um article 7 is moved as written and does the young lady have a second she does therefore we can discuss this Peter can I say a few words on this you it's your warrant thank you thank you um so thanks everyone for being here tonight to participate um tonight I'm going to speak about article 7 which proposes resending the tax cap that Brookline voters
145approved in 2019 this article is being presented because a recent state law change has made the tax cap more restrictive than what voters originally approved when the tax cap was first implemented under RSA 32 colon 5B it limited school budget increases to 8% a year but applied only to the operating budget not warrant articles for teacher contracts Capital Improvements or special programs however a recent change in state law now extends the cap to the entire budget including warrant articles imposing limits that brookln residents never voted for to put this into a broader context Brookline is now one of only four towns in New Hampshire with a school district tax cap other district with caps like Manchester and nashaa are large Municipal districts unlike our small town no other small towns in the state now face
146these same Financial constraints under the new law we all know that costs rise every year we are all taxpayers they rise due to inflation special education needs and necessary academic Investments without the ability to budget correctly we risk cutting essential programs expanding class size reducing teaching staff and limiting resources for all of our children resending the tax cap does not mean unlimited spending it simply restores local control over our school budget ensuring we the voters decide what's best for our schools not a state imposed restriction by voting yes on article 7 we would ensure Brookline has the same flexibility and opportunity ities as other districts the school board does recommend this article 40 the finance committee recommends this article one thank you very much Miss ha um with what you just said the reason why
147this is being put forward is there any other reason besides putting us in the same category with with every other District in the state so the new law puts additional restrictions on us so when we first adopted this in 2019 it was just on the operating budget and we've been doing that the budgets have been 8% this new law that was passed in conquer also now has us include warrant articles so when there are years that we have teachers contracts or things like that that's going to very quickly eat up that 8% so the state law changed we didn't change our tax cap it's not what we voted for it was done at a state level okay that explains it then thank you thank you thank you ma'am yes sir Ed Perry for muskat tanus
148I am rising in support of this because finally tonight we've got an opportunity to save some money let me explain there was a gentleman earlier don't worry Peter I'm going to say nice things who had a question why are certain not in the budget right we had this $300,000 worth of things why aren't they in the budget the answer is is because right now we're operating under an 8% cap so to stay under the 8% you have to kick these other things to a separate section that does not ideas like that don't save us money it puts us into a position where we buy boilers three years later at end of life when we couldn't have taken advantage of costs that would have been in place three years ago it also does a different phenomenon
149where we don't hire people but we end up with contracts and the contractors end up being a heck of a lot more expensive one thing I've always been impressed by in Brookline is our voters are incredibly smart people who come to these rooms in the deliberate recession and the town meeting craft things spectacularly and they understand the subject matter and what we understand because we budget this way at home is sometimes it makes sense to pay for something now so you don't pay more later on sometimes it makes sense to save money over the long term so you can buy a big item these are all common things but they're not necessarily possible when we put an artificial 8% cap on things now the reason why like um was just said that this is being
150changed is because the state level the good folks in concrete have decided that they now want to include all of the warrant articles as consideration for the total budget amount whether or not they pass or not has no consequence they've also limited how much they want to give us towards um special education and there are several other considerations up at the state level that is going to decrease how much money the state contributes towards education which means we all have to pick up the balance out of our property taxes in addition to that they have all manner of science experiments going on up there that are untested in other states for example the chart of school debacle that's several million dollars over budget currently and has not resulted in any of our property taxes going
151down because at the end of the day when you've got 47 students in a school instead of 50 if the boilers that end to life you still have to pay for for it it didn't change anything and if you get a classroom with 30 people in it and two go out a district to go to one of those Charter Schools you still got 28 kids the teachers raise is still going to happen and to speak to something somebody said earlier well maybe we'll just freeze wages where all is that happening who would take those jobs let's be serious let's have adult conversations here that's just something that doesn't happen anywhere we just freeze the salaries and say well let's see who we can get especially for something like training the future of our country a
152lot of people talk about changes in the country but that's one that I'd never want to see change especially not here and we always defend our schools in this town and there's a reason for that look at your town hall it's an old school it was put there because a woman strongly believed in education I believe it was the husband am I screwing this up brenon no it came from and the husband decided to dedicate it and the condition was it would always have an educational tie to it which it still does to this day we're a schools town since Inception none of that has ever changed people come here and to speak to one last things I know I'm going long somebody spoke to the idea that people come here for the schools and
153then they leave that's one of the fables that I've heard so many times about this town but when I look at the data it's not necessarily true there's some percentage of people who come here they come for the schools they stay for the period of time that they're here some costs go up as a result because people want what they came here for when they leave their property value has increased as such that there is no other investment in the US Stock Market that grows at that rate let me say that again your property values have increased year over-year at a rate that cannot be done in any fund that is traded in the stock market so this investment has been incredible if you leave if you don't leave like many people don't and you
154grow older in this community there's things we do to offset your taxes we always think about these things but if we don't consider that and we start to do things that are negative for the school like capping how much money we can spend which will lead to a depreciation in our infrastructure and quality of education and the types of people that we're able to keep what's going to happen is less people are going to move here 30 seconds and as less people move here our tax base will shrink but guess what the fire truck's still going to be a million dollars you're just going to have less people to help you pay for it thank you sir yes sir Rob br Flint metal Drive um I've got a brain teaser for all you smart people
155uh what would be the net effect if at the polls warrant article 7 were to fail but warrant article 9 the petition warrant article that also addresses tax caps were to pass so I think um that was a question that we we brought up at the public hearing um that we had in January and I think what we were told was that it would most likely be a budget cap on top of the tax cap so that would be a much stricter restriction which would really be um difficult for us to provide funding for special education mandated funding contract things of that nature we would really have our hands tied in regards to that but I do believe that it would count on top of the tax cap yes I'm getting so that's that would
156be quite a quite a combination um one of the reasons why I would have hoped that we could settle the whole issue here and now while uh both are under consideration in discussions thank you yes and thank you yes sir web scills um dup gold Road as I understand the um RSA and I admit my knowledge is a couple years old now um the tax cap um binds the board not the legislature and so you're the legislature just you know that but we we the voters in this room are the legislative body um and we are not bound by the tax cap so if we keep it or if we get rid of it it doesn't make a difference to what we can enact in this room the difference that it makes is that the
157board has to present us with a budget willy-nilly that meets the tax tax cap and so if this town gets into really Dire Straits the board has to come to us and say okay here's the budget it's woful inadequate but it meets the tax cap and by the way if one of you people would please amend it upwards to this other number which is what we actually need then we could step to this microphone here and fix the problem but that's ridiculous that means that the board has to present us with two budgets the one that meets the tax cap which is inadequate and the one that we actually need to ratify so what the tax cap really does is it makes the board do double duty so that sounds like a really bad deal
158to me because I as a voter want to be presented with the real number and the real justification and I don't want the board to have to work twice so um I believe that we should uh pass this and I'll speak again for article none thank you thank you sir yes sir great Alan 17 B um I'll be quick one uh point that hasn't been made yet is the idea of compounding interest the tax cap at 8% actually encourages the board to spend the full 8% every single year because as we all know from compounding interest you get that 8% plus 8% the year following plus the compounded 8% and that compounds very quickly over the years so you get rid of the tax cap it's entirely possible depending on what happens with the school
159district we could have a budget well below the cap because the board it doesn't have to spend that 8% in order to keep the 8% for the following year thank you smart thank you sir yes sir Eric power West View Road um I'm speaking against this article uh we passed this tax cap with a super majority vote uh back in 2019 so at least 60% wanted it um there are currently eight towns and school districts that have adopted RSA 325b I've I've looked into this so it's not four and you know a tax cap is enabling legislation that the that the uh legislature has provided us so it is really that the name of it is a local tax cap because it is local control so if voters want it they should keep it if
160they don't want it they don't keep it but you need three- fths to change away from it and for it and I'd also like to mention the legislature does a lot of work to clarify laws and you know if you look across the state with the tax caps most of those eight um six of those eight were interpreting the tax cap before the law change as in as an uh encompassing all warn articles there were two towns that were taking a different interpretation so the legislature went to clarify that so that's where we are today and I hope that people vote against it that we continue the tax cap because I think an 8% tax cap is a very generous tax cap and it is a good guard rail for Brookline taxpayers thank you thank
161you sir yes ma'am can I just make the the point that I I think the one of the things that the board is cons concerned about is that um when it was on the operating budget then things like Collective margeting agreements and um special education like expenditures that were beyond what was budgeted for you know weren't necessarily included in um the default budget or were included in the default budget because of um contractual obligations and when this legislative body voted for the tax cap in 2019 we were voting under the um offices of just voting on The operational budget and so I think as a board our position is that we want to make sure everyone is aware that they have watched the um presentation from the October 23rd 24 Brookline Schoolboard meeting um that
162is recorded on the YouTube and is um described in the minutes that we not necessarily opposed to a tax cap but we want the legislative body to be able to fully understand what they're voting for so that if the legislative body says yep that's not what we thought we were voting for in 2019 we want to repeal this tax cap by a super majority there's nothing that then prevents this legislative body from um bringing forth a warrant article next year to put in a tax cap but that tax cap vote would then be based on an understanding of the broader law that um our state representative who represents us here in Brookline did propose and bring forward um to the legislature in in coner so um I just want people to please go to that
163October 23rd 2024 Brook line school board meeting minutes and watch the Youtube um recording of the meeting because we have had a very robust conversation about the nuances of what this new legal interpretation um means for our you know future um potential budget overdrafts yeah thanks I just want to thanks Kelly I just want to make sure that everyone here pretty much understands that this warrant article would never have been on the up for vote this year if it wasn't for the state changes so we're not saying saying to Kelly's point that we want to resend the tax cap we're saying that the new changes to the law are punitive for us here in this small rural town and that we did not vote for that in 2019 thank you yes ma'am Lynn powers to
164Parker Road Brookline um first I would like to say I'm in support of resending the tax cap I am reading this and I think it may be uh Mis Ed by a voter and so I wanted to propose an amendment where after March 12 2019 so that the recommended budget May adequate adequately reflect the operational needs of the district is not amendable is that true sorry is that not amendable and then I'm no unfortunately it's not there's there's specific language in the statute um that provides the wording for a vote to resend a tax cap and and um the law says you can't amend language when it's prescribed by law so yeah okay thank you thank you yes sir Bron Den 31 Mason Road um I was here six years ago when this legislative body
165U discussed a petition warn article for a tax cap of 4% and we were able to amend it to 8% because the legislative body at the time thought that that was 4% was a punitive tax cap and that if we went to 8% we're not going to get 8% inflations at one or two% and that was so we were looking forward and we were saying things aren't going from our vision in 2019 things aren't going to change well everybody knows what happened in 202 and what happened to inflation in 2020 and on top of that we now have these changes made by the legislature as other people mentioned this tax cap that we currently have does not work for the town of Brookline I support resending the Tas thank you sir yes sir 142 oakill
166road so if this RSA changed and it's no longer just the operating budget but entire budget how does that differ for you now you get to include everything from this year's fiscal year 26 budget as your base for the next year and now you're held an 8% tax of a larger number we we run a fairly fairly flat aggressive budget to meet our needs if we add in the warrants to this 8% and we have a teacher contract or we have a special emergency need we will really really hit that 8% very quickly adding in the warrants adding in the warrants is punitive and it was done at the state level this is not what Brookline voters voted for we have run an 8% budget or something to about that effect for years now and
167it's been fine and it's been good could we but but the but adding in the warrants and all of the other uh extraneous portions that were added in by the legislature are not going to work for Brook line I do I just also want to make not sure you can actually say it that way but so as as but nonetheless the point is you're going to have a larger Base number to work with right and it's not an 8% on your your budget it's it's the impact to the taxes right that's the tax cap is it not can we get some legal help here it's the tax cap is we have to present a budget that is 8% only up to of last year's budget I think what I think what what I hear him
168saying is that it's the new base will be all the articles with a tax impact this year for next year so it's it's it's not like the base will increase that the 8% is applied to I think is what I'm hearing him say I I don't disagree with you that the base will increase I I can't hear you sure I don't disagree with you that the base will increase but next year you're going to have a teacher contract and that will quickly get you to that 8% the following year my base will increase with that teacher's contract that's no longer going to be in there and it gives you an artificial inflation for me to work with because you don't have a teachers contract every year well let's say it's a half a million dollars
169next year then my base goes up 8% on that half a million dollars that is not going to be in the following 2028 warrant so it's again we were we we agreed on one set of things 8% on the operating budget there was a change that encompasses everything and the board believed and I agree that we should send that back to the voters and if they agree that's how we operate if they resend it then that's how we operate the legislative body needs to decide that at the ballot because we're in sb2 town so at this meeting I first learned through the information here that the legislature was changed how many voters in this town know that if they don't know it like I did not know it I looked at this I read this
170and I said well hey I I don't want to change the tax cap I want it to still be there and so I would not vote in your favor and you can't change the wording on this is that correct correct word to St that's why I think listening to the meetings and coming to the meetings we throw a great meeting every month um we are on YouTube but we're YouTube stars now apparently um it's really important because we discuss these things and we want voters and and fellow Brook liners to know about these things to know about these changes and to have the resources to make educated decisions when they vote it's it's it's not pulling wool over your eyes we're we we live here too we we're taxpayers we we are neighbor to neighbor
171you know we we're working for the for the benefit of the entire town um and it's just it's difficult when we have such strong handcuffs on um sometimes that are out of our control like when the state changes the legislation so again you go back to this changing the legislation and you know I can be wrong you're the lawyer but he can be wrong too sometimes I wasn't going to say that Peter you know I've known coup I've known a couple you know Shakespeare yeah never mind I'll tell you that that one private that let's kill all the lawyers oh you said it was so was so the bad guy could take over because people were not going to hold him accountable yeah but those lawyers were the king's uh prosecutors well in any on
172this point get back to the point here right um I don't I you don't think that going forward that you could put together a budget that still meets the 8% tax Gap after you include all these things because the way I'm reading this is that your budget next time you come here to the to to present to the budget is it's going to be everything instead of just an operating budget and all these other things as web pointed out you're going to come in with one great big thing here and everything will be listed out this might not answer your question directly but I think it's very important the reason we put this as an article is because it's out of respect for your 2019 vote you did not vote for this I did not
173vote for this so for the state to decide that they're going to change something that local voters decided on we all I think we can all agree that we're here because we we think it's our right to vote on that not somebody else's to change the meaning of a tax cap and what isn't included in it is a violation of your rights as a taxpayer and so we're not here to argue about the tax cap we're here to resend it because it was not voted on it was it is inappropriate that the state changed what you voted on you weren't even aware it sounds like so at least we're making I knew about the other one but I didn't you weren't aware CH but people may not have been aware of that and it's just
174inappropriate I mean we could sit here all night and debate the the 8% whether it would work or wouldn't work it depends on the warrant articles sometimes therefore for significant expenditures that are um either unpredictable or not something that's in an operating budget that is not what you voted for in 2019 so well I will also just just to clarify okay we're not talking about 8% increase of your budget of the operating budget right that's not what a tax capap is am I correct right you talking about the tax effort right how you impact the taxes okay so what so what okay guys yeah I think we're each side has been very eloquent in expressing their position I don't want to beat a dead horse so please try to wrap it up no that's what
175I was going to say I think I mean I think we've kind of discussed to this point and we we can just tell you all that we can tell you which is none of us can see the future and we are doing what we as a board feel is best after a discussion and a very informative that is on YouTube so I really really urge everyone to watch it it's the October 8th presentation on this exact topic with the attorney um but we can't predict the future we don't know what regulations are coming down we don't know what contracts will need to be we don't know what special education students may move in so so all we can say to you is we hear what you're saying but we can't predict the future we are
176doing what we feel is best in this moment to provide for the future of both the taxpayers and the schools that's all we can do so whether you guys agree with us or not that's totally to you but that's where we're at so we agreed to disagree up boy thank you appreciate it yes sir Craig gbone Cleveland hell Road and I'll try and keep this as brief as I can number one I apologize ma'am for my Interruption earlier that was unprofessional to me so I apologize ma'am I think your explanation of this thing was excellent I did not realize and now I'm going to kind of look at the board and say please stop telling me to attend the meetings and watch on YouTube I'll Tell You Why I sat on the co-op budget committee
177for 6 years so I know how hard it is okay no no beating on you but to tell us here you should attend the meetings and watch YouTube it's not at getting the message out there's a lot better way the couple of them is Facebook there's a brook line Facebook page be great if you put something there and if I ignore it that's my fault from there the other is the Hollis Brookline rotary club yay they put out a wonderful email every week every Friday I get it and I read it religiously and it you can put stuff in there links whatever so I don't think it's helping your cause by telling us the public you should be attending meetings I don't know about your lives but mine are pretty busy the last thing is
178I'd like to ask the question if we're held to this tax cap and something catastrophic does happen that we have to go how I think I know the answer but what do we do then how do we hey we need another 200,000 because something blew up or whatever is there a special meeting method or what you know because if we leave this in place and there's a catastrophic event great now we know how to do that otherwise the cap has really no impact of what the legislature no by the way we're a constitutional republic so if the legislature and conquered past this law or this change we were there because we're a constitutional republic which means our Representatives who represent us past it so just little history lesson so my question is how do we
179un if we have a catastro event what can we do to to go over that we would have we would have a special meeting we would call a special meeting we would come together in this format and the voters would decide after the board informed them of what was the need and why and we would move forward okay so there is a method to cover it just in case we have to we should be aware we the public should be aware of that because things happen yep you went to the meetings more often I know I need more meetings in my life like everybody else okay so I do actually just want to take this time to point out I post the links and everything in the Facebook pages they are there for you I
180post them please don't ignore them because they are there I think what Mr Daron Daron is saying is that um he would prefer and is suggesting perhaps like a digested synopsis um so that people don't have to click on a link and watch a video and I think you know um or go fish through Reading minutes and I and I will absolutely um concede the point that like we have talked as a district probably at nauseum about communication strategies and ways to effectively communicate with um the community that doesn't like you know count as an unofficial meeting it doesn't have exchanges between you know more than three members at a time so I really appreciate that and I think um maybe we'll have to the next board will have to figure out a way to
181um put that into action so I think that's a great idea I I would like to interject as finance committee Kate Elkins 95 Mason Road and I I also completely agree with the previous speaker um and that is why you SE select and elect a a trustworthy School Board hopefully and a trustworthy finance committee that then goes through four rounds of budget review as we heard tonight um that is the staff the school board and the finance committee looks at this budget many times we then have this deliberative session and then we have voting so if if we cannot uh find a way to come up with a lean budget during that time then I don't think the tax cap is our issue um we we have a a good what I consider a very
182good checks and balance in place to provide you all with a budget that is fiscally responsible um so to everyone's point no I don't want to go to the meetings either I have a busy life and that is why I think you should trust the the people that you elected um in our recommendations thank you yes sir Brian Raider still of 31 Mason Road um I have three points here one is I've never been a fan of tax caps as opposed to budget caps because tax caps um taxes depend on your revenues as much as your expenses and the revenues can be highly variable they're based you know on what the state does it based on you know a lot of other factors that are out of our control so when you're talking about tax
183cap we have to make you know or you guys in this case have to make estimates of what you think that the the revenues are going to be in order to guess what the tax is going to impact if is going to be so there's one that one particular argument against tax caps the second issue is um as an example we we talked about how you can have one big expense that completely blows away your tax capit let me give an example of that there was a proposal a couple of years ago to have Brookline withdraw from from the Middle the from the Middle School um from the co-op and have our own middle school for it that proposal would have cost tens of millions of dollars to build a new school that would be
184just a Brooklyn Middle School the first Year's Bond payment of that would have blown way past the 8% tax cap that we have right now and it would force the school board to present us with a budget that is completely ridiculous in order to meet that total warrant article thing that's just an example of the sort of thing that can happen that that okay yes it's a larger number but um individual things can blow past that by themselves and impact the budget the final thing is this is a very complicated issue um and the problem that we're facing right now is that there's only a few of us in here that are discussing this right now that are we're reaching a common understanding of what the Imp implications of this are but we're not voting
185on it now it's going to be a completely different set of people who are not paying attention to this at all who only see what's in front of them that's going to be voting on this we really need to go back to a Traditional School District meeting where we can have these discussions get an understanding of the issue and then be able to vote on it based on a common understanding of what the pros and cons are Hallelujah yes sir Jesse Basset a rock Raymond Road um I just want to make two points uh one this resins the tax cap that the school budget can provide but uh we have some very enthusiastic members of the community who will correct it if it's too high and traditionally have done so so I have every faith
186that should this pass and the budget would be too high a corrected version would be immediate medely proposed the second thing is that um if the voters pass this once they can always pass it again in fact there's another tax cap on the ballot this year so um uh should this pass they can always pass it again with a higher value that's more appropriate to accommodate everything next year thank you that's all thank you sir whoops yes sir Mr skore Claire Skidmore oakill road am I correct um that the language can't be changed yeah the statute says that okay so just a comment and then I'm going to ask for you to help me pardon I'm going to ask for you to help me oh all right just comment we've had we've had wonderful discussion
187and a lot of Education out of this whole thing here but um I want to move that we just stop the discussion what's that how do you say that okay that's fair enough and clear as a bell the gentleman has moved the question as it's called so effectively stop the discussion is there a second to the gentleman's motion thank you uh all those in favor of ending discussion please raise your V thank you very much all those opposed please raise your vote thank you very much therefore discussion has ended and article 7 will go to the voters in the form in which you see it here uh therefore we move on to article eight Cooperative study committee shall the voters of the Brooklyn School District form a Cooperative study committee to study the advisability of
188fully joining the Hollis brookly Cooperative school district and to submit a report of its findings and recommendations to the Brooklin School Board uh this article to be funded from the fiscal year 26 operating budget not to exceed $110,000 there will be no tax impact school board recommends this unanimously Finance recommends this one no one I'm never quite sure one in favor one abstains or one opposed how many people say opposed one to one okay go ahead not important let's go uh do we have an a motion under article I so move been moved as written second for the young yes thank you very much okay it's on the table guys let's take it on yes so to um Mr ators um it was a very nice segue thank you Brian um about the the petition
189waren articles that we've seen in the past to take the Brooklyn School District out of sa41 um or out of the co-op for Middle School um I think one of the things you know sitting on the SAU governing board and looking at the SAU um budget which is you know a big topic of conversation at um at school district meetings um every year both here and in the co-op one of the reasons why um the the costs tend to be higher at the um at the at the SAU is because we have six different six different budgets that are managed by our business office six different collective bargaining agreements um so there's the Hollis School District the co-op District the Brookline School District and then for each of those districts there's uh professional staff and
190support staff um and so you know a lot of times we will you know be talking at a a governing board meeting and saying to Kelly and Donna well why can't we just get like some sort of great like ADP software that does the p payroll you know why why do we need all these payroll Specialists because there's literally six different payrolls um and so I think you know many of us um and I particularly am in in favor of this um you know wonder if you know economies of scale you know having one um you know having two contracts having you know one professional sport sta One Professional contract and one um support staff contract you know obviously Hollis would need to act on this on their own this is for you know Brookline
191to just study it you know do some run some numbers look at you know what what do the economy economies of scale look like would the brickline taxpayers actually save money um you know if we were able to join with um the co-op District um and not just for um 7th through 12th grade but K through 12 so um so I am in support of this and I and this does not lead to any action other than studying it creating a report making recommendations um and then you know being able to discuss that hopefully next year again as a as a legislative body to see you know is this something that might make sense for the town and the District of Brooklyn and again just want to reiterate this is a study this is not
192a we're going to go join a k to2 Co-op this is simply for us to gain a responsible understanding of different ways that it may or may not make sense uh to be fiscally responsible and provide even a stronger education for our students here in our town thank you yes sir ER Eric Power westf Road I think you know just looking at the beginnings of this and a study might be okay I'm not sure we want to do it but you know Hollis already spends a great deal more money than we do in their Elementary District so if we join them it's going to raise up our costs right now we spend uh 23,000 is for per student and in the co-op we're about 27,000 normally across the state when you go to an upper
193level School your costs go down because of an economy of scale and we have the reverse because holl is even higher than that um and I served on for people who don't know me I served on the Cooperative School Board uh for three years so I know a lot about the co-op board and you know we had four members from Hollis and three from Brookline and the um if you do this Brookline is not going to have a say just like we don't really have a say in the co-op it's it's going to be basically Hollis telling us how much we're going to be spending and I think that's a really bad idea and just want to mention if people don't know our nextto neighbor in Mason they have a contract with Milford right now
194that's for 20 years and I believe they have they're in the they're in year 16 um and I think looking at potentially having a school district with Mason makes a lot of sense to check that out as part of this so I'd like to make a motion to amend Mr moderator excuse me can I just respond to Mr power for a minute we're not looking at joining with the Hollis um School District we're looking at joining The Cooperative School District so um that I think you're extrapolating it to certainly a potential and I think that you know one of the things that we would have to look at in this study is would the apportionment of C of of of seats be different because right now it's it's you know a a 7 through 12
195District that's the co-op district and I think um I think that what Mason has with Milford is an area agreement and not a Cooperative agreement and so having lived in an area agreement uh District in New Boston with gtown for many years it's a you're com like comparing apples to oranges so I went to Milford Area Senior High School so I know what an area agreement is and it's not an area agreement anymore it Mason has a tuition agreement for their grade six to 12 so it's not uh it's not an area agreement they just tuition that's a different format um but I think you know talking to the people I know a lot of the people in Mason they're coming up to a decision point in about four years and you know looking at
196them joining us as a co-op I think makes a lot of sense so that's why I would recommend that my motion to amend would be shall the voters of the book line School District form a Cooperative study committee to study the advisability of fully joining the Hollis Brookline Cooperative District or forming a co-op district with mason or is that a different totally different changing the article well you're adding you're adding to it so now you're asking for two studies because you'd have to do a study what it looks like to join the Hollis Brooklyn Co-op as it stands today it's a whole different study um and you're creating a whole second study now okay let let me go I don't know if you can can you you may well be right the gentleman has made
197a motion to amend and that's his right and I'm wondering if someone wants to second that motion we have a second to the motion so his uh his motion is on the floor as to whether that language would be added or not now the merits are a different issue so the the title of this article the subject matter is cooperative study committee so I think it's a apprpriate to look at a Cooperative School District with Mason and a Cooperative School District with Hollis Brookline I think it's a I think it's in the same subject matter that's my that's the reason I made that and I think it's it's a worthy thing to look at okay thank you thank you now we're on that motion to amend sir yes BR Alan 17 berill um if if
198Mr power would give me the pleasure it's extremely rare that I speak in support of something he has to say um hey get a room you two come on uh but this is a case where um I actually am in support of uh what Mr P has to say I think the article is a little premature because it only binds Brooklyn um it does not bind Hollis so there would not be economies of scale in Hollis K through five or excuse me K through six joining Brookline K through six um so I would I would suggest we defeat the motion as well as defeat the article um because I think it's a little premature and I think some discussion between the boards needs to occur um including possibly looping in um Mason um in order
199to present something that's more um more actionable um and I don't think I need $10,000 right now to as an sb2 process we can't defeat it it will go forward to the Ballance yes so I'm speaking against the article as written as well the amendment I'm speaking against the amendment and against the article as written okay um but agreeing with the idea just it's too it's premature okay forgive me do you support the motion to amend I do not okay thank you may may I respond Peter oh I'm sorry thank you so when we talk about economies of scale if we look at the SAU as it stands today there are three districts there is the Brookline District which is K to 6 prek to 6 you have the Hollis District similar grades then you
200have the co-op which is 7 to 12 when we talk about wanting to run a study to see what economies of scale look like in terms of cost savings joining a co-op it means taking our SAU down from running three districts to two districts grade levels would be expanded in the co-op to serve K to 12 which means we would have one teacher contract for the co-op versus two when you talk about the co-op and Brooklyn Hollis Hollis Elementary and Hollis school district is not in this conversation because they are not currently part of the co-op we have spoken I personally have spoken with our partners over in Hollis and if we are interested in engaging in a study they would they would be willing to as well Al I'm going to be a jerk
201because what we're talking about is a motion to amend but but but they bring up some points here about this amendment and talking about how it doesn't make sense and so I want to be clear that you're just because a co-op is 7 to 12 doesn't mean it can't be extended to K through 12 and I just want to be clear about that that Our intention is to try to reduce costs by reducing the number of districts that our SAU runs so it is an unfair statement to say that Hollis spends more money when Hollis is not in this conversation the co-op is in our conversation with the study and joining to understand an economy is a scale as it pertains to benefits and salaries it's what's on the table is the motion to include
202Mason that's the only thing we're talking about right now not the merits of this overall issue of the original article we're talking about his motion to amend we we got to dispose of that and then we can get into these things okay okay so uh any more coms Mr moderator I just want to raise a question I'm not um 99 out of 100 times I'm asked the question by the moderator whether a amendment is lawful or whether it constitutes a change in the subject matter yeah um I'm I'm like I'm on the fence really with this one here because although the title is Co-op study committee that that's not the subject matter I I tend to be pretty sort of narrow in what I think and I typically think most things can be amended this
203is a a a to form a Cooperative study um to study the advisability of joining the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District that school district exists there is there is such an entity I do agree that this would then require the formation of a of a second study I I'm just not sure personally that it's the same subject matter to add that um and and the purpose of that is you really have to specifically say in the warrant what the subject matter is so the folks at home can decide whether they're going to come or not come starting to add other districts into the mix to me really pushes that limit um and I'm just giving you that legal advice because it's a it's an issue of notice to the public and we are very grateful
204yes sir raw brush didn't Flint metal Drive um I come up here because um whether or not this amendment uh passes uh I was hoping that uh the people who would volunteer for this committee would be a lot smarter than I am because because um even without this amendment uh we're talking about much much more than simply economy of scale here we're talking about structural differences a lot like getting into I gave a hard time the point being that uh let let's do the motion to amend do you want to insert Mason here your PO your position on that uh with regard to the amendment I would be against it because it further complicates the issue to be addressed and would require people with even more capability than what was originally proposed thank you sir
205I'm sorry to be pushy yes ma'am Melanie l with Daniel's Drive um as a representative I helped Mason leave the um ringe Milford school district the mic School District um they didn't have as many children as many students I still feel that Mason does not have as many students as we do um I I think introducing Mason into this kind of study lacks any synergies at all and I don't think it's appropriate so I also wonder what Mason thinks about that thank you thank you ma'am yes sir uh testing okay Max Millian buo peppol Road uh I initially had a question that was on about the original Bill itself I assume I should save that for later yes we're going to save that we're going to return if you'd get to the end of the
206line or I I do have a question of sorts about the amendment though yes sir um for uh the fine lawyer there uh what was his name again depends who's asking I think fair enough I'm listening um a legales sort of question about whether this amendment changes the subject matter would the joining of the hall Brookline District the fact that it's joining an existing District be considered to be separate or similar to the formation of a new district with Mason Andor Milford I don't know if you might be able to weigh in on that yeah I mean that's that's the the gist of my concern is joining an existing District versus um studying the formation of an entirely new entity with a district that uh with which you don't currently have a relationship just feels
207like a new a new thing entirely and that's that's my answer all right then thank you if I could just weigh in I'm coming around to it I mean the concept is that the published article tells the world what we're going to talk about and you any motion under that article's got to be about that subject matter the people are ill-informed and have no advanced notice if you move into territories which are unrelated this is a close one but I I appreciate your help the concern I have is the superintendent of Brookline and the superintendent of the co-op is aware of the discussion I think it is quite taking a leap of faith to put a community in and have something in our warrant that they know nothing about and I think it would be
208a common courtesy not to do this because how would you feel tomorrow if you were waking up reading that Mason was adding you and had never asked you there's been no conversation it may not be a bad idea but I think that could offend somebody and may lead to not being able to look at something down the road that may be beneficial to both communities thank you sir yes sir and mus catanus Road couple quick things if we add another town then we're really talking about a $5,000 study per Town um not sure that that makes a whole ton of sense additionally a little information about Mason New Hampshire for people who aren't aware there's about 1500 people who live in Mason New Hampshire we get about 6,000 people here and this is based on
209uh most recent census data so this is the oddest couple since uh those shows I missed it you guys are probably too old young for this anyway um it doesn't make sense it's an odd couple situation pairing us with Hollis makes a lot of sense pairing us with a town that has 1,400 people is specifically designed in my humble opinion the same way as our marriage to them legislatively it's to water down our voice in this town and I'll say it again when we got legislatively married to places like Greenville and Mason it was a redistricting that was meant to water down the voice of this town and when we speak about a representative government somebody spoke to that earlier they're up there representing our interests I'd really like to know how they thought that
210was in our interest because anybody that I voted for wouldn't have done such a thing and this is just a furtherance of that well let's see what we could do if we combin with Mason who's got very few school children and only has 1400 people in the whole town and hey what if all of our decisions had to be paired with them then wouldn't that be a neat way to water down the voices in this room I don't know last time I looked this was Brooklyn thank you sir yes sir this is on the motion to amend web scales 49 dupa g Road um this touches on both the article and the motion to amend um first I need a question answered if the voters in March were to turn down this article would that
211enjoin and prevent the school board from pursuing this I think it would prevent the school board from funding it yes it would how thear according to what I read in this text the TIC the operating budget already includes money for this they they could do it I wouldn't recommend it because they've heard the will of the voters and I don't ever think it's good to go against the will of the voters when it's been known to them yeah I think it's just to note also with the public hearing we included the funding was an addition in the January public hearing um at the recommendation of the finance committee which we thought was valid so that wasn't always the original language I just want to put that in there as well it it changed in January
212to come from the operating budget so the operating budget wasn't created with the study in mind it was added because we were trying to be aware of like how much a study might cost and cap it so that we didn't over spend I understand but this article is not asking the legislative body for permission to spend this money or even to raise it and I believe the board has the power to do this without the approval of this body I can I can give you a legal answer on that so RSA 3210 we we call that the no means no law it's not just an appropriation but it's a purpose so if the purpose um if if this wasn't funded you couldn't expend any funding on the study you could still do the study though
213the board has that unilateral authority to do whatever study it wants they just couldn't pay like me for example to help them with the study or um pay like someone else to put together figures for them they couldn't expend any money on the study they could still do it though so in in in trying to be transparent in in how we spend the operating budget money when we we as a board want to do this study we then sat when we had one of our budget conversations and said realistically in the past how much of these studies cost and then we asked where did that money come from and we were told the operating budget so we sat down and I think it was the last budget meeting we had and we said realistically where
214can we maneuver money around in the budget to find money to pay for this right so we're willing to give up some things in the operating budget here and there just kind of scale back on a few things to try to cover this but we didn't want to just go and do that we wanted the community to have a say of would you be interested in us even pursuing a K2 study so we didn't want to just go and do it because yes to what you're saying it's at no extra cost we there's there's wiggle room we can we can find it right to to cover it but we didn't want to do that just blindly and hit the community with that of oh hey we ran this study we got an outside entity to
215help us with it to ensure that we have good data to share with the community we wanted to be forthcoming as to what we were spending the operative budet let recognize you sir and then you can give your point of order go right ahead we are discussing the amendment understood understood I think there's a well there's a a lot going on yes we're supposed to be talking about the amendment yeah yeah it's a good conversation thank you but point of we're discussing the words and Mason okay well I I agree with Jesse that uh we should limit ourselves I mean this issue we so let me bring it home without ginormous substance and we're expending enormous cognitive energy to address it perhaps we could move this forward I believe that the board has the power
216to conduct this study whether they study Hollis Brookline or M or the formation of another Co-op I believe the board has this power without the legislator's um or the voters approval okay I appreciate that sir my my per personal opinion is that if it's a speal it's a special warrant article addressing a specific issue and the voters say no that makes it different might they have the license out of extra money to do something yes once they brought it before the the people and the people said no do not do that that Mr Cory says you know politically or fairness wise it wouldn't be right I think legally it's a problem thank you yeah okay so the motion to amend enough discussion thank you all those in favor of amending it as proposed to put
217in Mason please raise your voting card thank you all oppos please raise your thank you that takes care of that that's what I meant by substance I mean come on okay thank you very much that uh we're back to the study being in its original format anybody want to address the original format of the motion all right you two we're getting tired Melanie L to McDaniel's Drive I just wanted to uh reiterate that the idea of a Cooperative study between Hollis Brookline District that we are already in and the Brookline schools has always been a conversation I sat on the co-op board and even before that we've been talking about economies of scale why do we have three different payrolls wouldn't it be better if we had one and then you allocate you PR rate
218to each Town it only makes sense and to me it's worth spending $10,000 to possibly save $100,000 thank you we don't know the number but you'll find out so I support this article thank you very much yes sir um Clarence Skidmore 42 Gil and I'd like some clarification with respect to who forms the study it says the voters but the voters aren't going to form the study right so who forms the committee and how many people on it and who do you expect that they should be whether they be citizens or members of the board can you talk to that somebody the school board working with the administration would form the committee typically when we form committees we have members of the um finance committee the school board community members we would ask the Selectmen
219because this is a decision that would affect it we probably put out some sort of advertisement and see who has interest in it and then formulate the committee once the committee was formed would develop a committee charge for the committee and then would established some what I'll call uh delivery dates of material and then uh complete the study and release the findings okay so I wasn't able to hear all of that but I did hear that you would have some school board members finance committee type people um maybe selectman yep uh how about any citizens yes yes I said that community community members um we would we would put out a call to see who was interested I think I see a volunteer are you volunteering just just for a ballpark uh you know how
220many total people on that committee you thinking of typically we'd probably keep it you know 10 to 12 y because much bigger than that and you can kind of get sidetracked a little a little a little like tonight thank you sir yes sir so in the past we've had had questions come up about the wording of the recommendations at the end of it and we have decided that the article itself does not really include the recommendations um and the recommendations are basically you know individuals go off and and write the specific language of that the reason I'm bringing that up is that I have some heartour in here where it says the finance committee recommends this article one to one0 that means one person voted in favor of it one person voted against it I
221would like to see that language change to the finance committee does not make a recommendation on this article 1 to one to zero to clarify that they're not making recomendation Fair we can take care of that are we good with that we can take care of that the U second thing um I wanted to bring up was actually on article three uh the recommendations references the budget committee and it should say the finance committee on article three thank you more discussion on article eight yeah Robert B uh 56 pepper Rogue Brooklyn New Hampshire so I have three points I want to make hope I remember them because I didn't write them down uh the first one is we've been talking about reducing costs I believe or saving money possibly by joining this school district the
222other one that we've been talking about earlier in this meeting is local control of things to me joining holl book line School District would absolutely increase the cost to every single taxpayer in this city and the reason I I say that is the cost per pup is way higher in hollers I don't think anybody even disputes that it's not even close so we're it's going to cost more money we're not going to save $100,000 or a million do or anything it's probably going to cost us $5 million or some bigger number so there's that also losing control people mentioned local control which I like um we would lose that control again we don't have control right now in the in the Cooperative if it's a 43 or 54 whatever the number is and whatever har
223does is what it's going to be period doesn't matter what bookland says we have a SE at the table so we can listen we can try to influence them but it doesn't happen it's whatever house decides happens number three I do want to compliment the board of making this an article to be transparent I appreciate that it's a separate article article it says what it is it's clear that the board and may've even said it some of the them that they want to prob I won't speak for them it's likely that some people want to join the's School District completely regardless of whether a crossbow money or not probably probably because of crossbow money because it will spend more on each kid here because we'll be mandated to by the Hest vote of four to
224three so but I do appreciate the transparency to put it as a separate item and I recommend completely voting against this thank you thank you sir appreciate it yes ma'am Judy cook 10 Main Street Brooklyn I don't know why anyone in their right mind would ever want to join everything into the Hollis brookln Cooperative School District because as of we as we stand right now the only budget that the town of Brookline has any control over is the Brooklyn School District that contains this not this well our our own elementary schools it's always been that way we control this budget and it always comes in better than any other budget namely the co-op budget for our high school and Junior High or whatever they call them it just I just don't understand why we would
225ever even consider this I mean I'm not basically a conservative but I mean this is a no-brainer I'd like to point out we're just considering the study not joining why would we even waste our time studying it just pointing it out because we this is the only thing we have control over and and the the money that we raise in appropriate for the elementary schools has always been far less than anything Hollis I don't want to get in bed with him any further than we already are okay let's that's a remember we I just say vote against this if you want any autonomy at all this is the sb2 system this article will be on the ballot you can amend it or you can leave it alone uh we don't have the luxury of disapproving
226it yes ma'am good evening I'm Heather Ren um for e Drive Brook line and I just wanted to clarify because I think that there might be some confusion so we have not in any way shape or form said we're going to join Hollis this is a study it is a review of how we could potentially leverage bulk right I can't believe in this day and age actually that we have six different payal systems that does not sound like getting in bed with anybody it sounds like um working with scales and so I just want to confirm I've got that correct yes right thank you thank you yes sir Tom 21 million house Hill Road so I I don't know if it's possible to change this but it's confusing with the not to exceed 10 grand
227and there'll be no tax impact and then the other thing is I noticed everything else that has money attached to it has a little this cost per so much I I don't know if it's possible to add that so the way that if you see the um line the the sentence second to the end it says this article to be funded from the fiscal year 26 operating budget not to exceed 10,000 so the operating budget is in its own warrant article with its own tax imp okay so you don't need to have that on it so no you don't have to add it on because this is not an additional expense okay this this would come out of um the budget if we chose to spend up to 10,000 because there are professionals that help
228to Aid in these types studies oh I understand I just I'm just saying for the common folk that aren't here hearing all this that is going to they're going to be scratching their heads well and that's why the the last line there says there will be no tax impact I mean if you if there's a better way for us to clarify it I am open to that um we tried to do our best in saying that we would cap how much we'd be willing to spend on a study and then also saying it there's no tax impact because I there's another way to word it I there's no tax impact other than that of the operating budet maybe that's there you go of the already establish can I make a motion to amend it and
229add what he just said I don't remember what I said say again I don't remember what I said he said uh to uh I'm just kidding to the come on it's late now to the speaker's Point could we have 0.0 of ,000 same as all the of the other articles for consistency that's a good point see now I'm that guy creating more work okay so do we have a motion to amend this in some way so I would like to add the language that not the funds come from the operating budget therefore there's no tax impact in 0.0 of a th000 if that's all legal I I've got no problem I don't know what counselor feels I got no problem in library right now you you would make a motion to amend to add that
230language uh give us your language again I'm going to wait for him to we keep talking maybe we act on it before he even decided can can I just make a point of clarification so there's there's the the amendment to the language and then there's a request to have a tax impact notation that's not an amendment that's a decision of the board whether it wants a tax impact notation on there and whether it is required to put that under statute the legislative body doesn't get to dictate that I understand but if we put in the language other than that of the operating budget that is not one of these say what is that our Amendment going to be how would it be worded I just it at the end of the sentence where it says
231there will be no tax impact other than that of the operating budget okay that to me makes it more confusing but um it doesn't even it doesn't really matter it it you can make whatever Amendment you want but whether there's a tax impact notation is going to be something the board decides when it puts the ballot together well that's fine I'm actually responding to him not to the board what okay what what if it was there there will be no tax impact as this would be drawn from the operating budget sir that works for me for that legally okay is I mean like I God I feel like I'm doing with boing right now uh Alison I mean honestly what like I would strike all the stuff about the article to be funded from the
232operating budget not to exceed there will no because like that's it's it's just redundant and it creates confusion and it makes people wonder what it is and you typically don't reference another article like that you're using money from the operating budget to fund it so like I just I mean I'm a purist I would rather that just be taken out out um if you want something in there I can write something that legal opinion or a subjective opinion I the gentleman is saying he wants some clarity on the issue yeah but you're making it less clear so the legal opinion is according to you he he's I want to make it so that everyone that walks into the ballot doesn't look at that and scratch their heads for like five minutes going there's no tax
233impact but it's going to cost 10 grand tell us how to do it I think to like Mr scale's original point also like the intent of the board was to get a sense of the legislative body is there an appetite in the community Mrs cook says no um to to see whether or not this is something we should study I think at our budget hearing um last month or two months ago we this year is like whatever um you know certain people thought that we should add like asked where do the money come from to do the study and so then this language was added I agree with our attorney that really we're not looking for permission to spend the money to do the study we're looking to see whether or not the community has
234any interest in US looking at this and so it you guys have put an article out there and these people have the right to amend that article within the bound La whatever your intentions were okay so how about uh move to strike everything after school board that better yeah thank you you're welcome after after pardon me say after school board gotcha take that sentence out the next sentence next two article will be funded from FY 26 operating budget not to exceed 10 grand there will be no tax impact delete that delete that correct is there a second to the gentleman's motion to amend there is many and that and then that also gets to Mr Raiders question because if there's no Appropriations we don't have to add that the finance committee doesn't recommend it no
235kills two birds with one stop okay I'm sorry I got seconds any discussion on the gentleman's motion to amend whereby we would delete those two sentences this article would be funded from FY 26 operating budget not to exceed 10 grand there will be no tax impact so we're just taking that language out do I have your right sir yes and I've got seconds on that any discussion on there um my only discussion here is a comment about removing the finance committee recommendation the finance committee is not bound to just warrant articles that have a tax impact they decide for themselves which ones there are special circumstances where they do vote on other articles so it really I think should be up to the finance committee as to whether or not they want to remove their
236recommendation from it or not okay so councelor do you agree with me that uh that language about these committee's recommending is not part of the article it's not part of the article right okay so uh the the article that's going the things that they can modify I I lost my train of thought um so where we last were was to take out those two final sentences yes sir uh I got a second to that are you going to speak to the uh speak to either of them you speak to the wisdom of the gentleman's motion to amend or would you pass is that not what you're up for I'm just going to [Laughter] speak go ahead if it doesn't take too long we'll put up with it and it will be a whether it's a
237revised version or not I always have a little bit name and address don't get me wrong I think Peter Cook Peter Cook 10 Main Street still under Bohan and Bridge [Laughter] this is not I've got to be very careful because I might give wrong perceptions the whole concept of a TW Town C where one town has half as many again voters than the other doesn't strike me as being overly Cooperative because there are issues other than the uh um economy of scale and that and the education superb Pete I love you we got to deal with this guy's motion to amend we we've got to dispose of his Del I said I'd speak to whether it was the amended version or not the unamended version excuse me whether it's the amended version or the unamended
238version I'm just going to stand I hear you but what's on the table right now is a solitary issue of whether you guys are going to accept his motion to amend the article that'll I I I thought so okay so any more discussion on deleting those two sentences gentlemen go right ahead if you'd like to Todd Perkins as uh as Road by deleting those last two sentences does that give you a blank check to spend whatever you want on the study just because we don't cap it here right I look essentially yes but only what's already approved in the operating budget we are not going to go and spend so much that we destroy our our our school's budget for the year like I I would hope that the community would have enough confidence in
239the board that you've elected that we wouldn't be irresponsible that if we put that in there that we're going to adhere to that because that's what we felt was a appropriate so I I would ask that I I trust I get it but yes to answer your question it essentially could right would we I don't think there's anybody sitting in these seats here that that would we just spent a lot of time arguing about the budget and this is baked into a budget that is now coming out saying you could go to $50,000 I'm just saying could by by the by the word I don't agree with deleting those and we should have a cap on this I'm sorry sir say it again we should not delete those words thank you to his Amendment got
240because there should be a cap on this understood thank you very much Pete uh anybody want to speak to the motion to amend to delete the two sentences thank you yeah Eric power Westview Road um just want to mention councelor might know this but we passed um RSA 325 Roman 5B about making the tax impact statement mandatory how does that impact what we're doing here it doesn't this there's no tax impact because that's already referenced in the operating budget so even though so um because they're not appropriating any more money there's no tax impact exactly okay I I like my friend um from Meeting House Hill Road but I don't I think we want to have a a 10 $10,000 limit on it because I think people need to know it's not going to be
241zero and it's going to come out as something so I would vote this this amendment down for that purpose it might make confusing but at least people know and it does put as the previous speaker said I agree it does put a limit on what you're going to do we don't need a new school board that not even all these people here to come in and spend $50,000 on something that we don't necessarily want to do if we thought it was 10,000 anything more on the motion to amend motion to delete those two sentences therefore we'll put it to a vote how many people say make that deletion or support the motion to amend raise your voting card thank you all those opposed thank you so we will not make that deletion we're back to
242the original motion Pete your turn where was I up to um the general concept of a a two Town Co-op where there is one big town and one small town there half as many again voters there in holl and we can talk for the Ed I'm not talking about don't get me wrong no problem with the education that has received but when it comes to voting we're going to lose some of our independence because people vote believe it or not a great deal of the time by their pocketbook and more voters are going to vote for their pocketbook versus uh the smaller number of Voters voting for their pocketbook um and the other point I wanted to make is uh fully joining the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District which as I understand it does not
243operate under sb2 this may be a good way of getting out of sb2 thank you thank you okay uh again uh yes sir Brian Raider 31 Mason Road move the question thank you sir all those in favor raise your voting card I know I mean a second give me a second first thank you all those in favor of ending discussion raise your voting card thank you people who want to keep talking raise your voting card I figured you'd do that well you always do that um okay so discussion ceases uh I'm very good um and uh therefore this uh article will appear on the ballot as it was expressed originally in the article thank you guys now we move on to article nine uh a petition warn article that says shall we adopt the provisions
244of RSA 325d and Implement a budget cap whereby the school board or budget committee uh finance committee you're assuming we're going to create a budget committee if you have a budget Committee in the future any point that's statutory language okay well I'll keep going whereby the school board or budget committee shall not submit a recommended budget that is higher than $25,000 per pupil cost times the average daily membership in Residence of the School District as of October 1 of the Year immediately preceding the proposed budget year plus an annual increase for inflation using CPI for the Boston Cambridge Newton Mass New Hampshire area published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics as of January 1 requires a 3- fifths majority and then we have school board doesn't recommend Finance doesn't recommend and uh now Council
245my notes indicate to me that the the language is dictated by Statute so we have perhaps a limited ability to to tweak I mean yes there's a there are the form of the question is dictated by Statute um there are parts of it that can be amended I will move it but I'm going to change the RSA to 325e did I I motion I'm making the motion to move it except for the RSA would be 325e Echo let me find it it's the first line what line are we talking first line of the article okay first line refence instead of D it should be e 325 Echo e yes okay so the motion is fine doesn't have exactly with the article but wait a second that motion that's fine yes um this article is a
246okay thank you um this is a School District budget cap which is a uh a budget cap that goes uh by $25,000 per pupil so this is a very generous cap and we're not likely to run into it anytime soon so if you take the number of students we're expecting according to NASDAQ next year 571 and you multiply by 25,000 you get $4,275 th000 it's a very high number but it's meant and it will if this will adjust with inflation over time so if inflation goes up high the budget cap goes up high if the inflation is low then the budget cap goes up low if your enrollment goes up you get a higher budget cap if the enrollment goes down it goes down lower it adjusts slowly over time generally upward because of inflation
247and you won't hit the uh maximum probably for a while with this level of uh budget cap um it also has an override mechanism and you need to adopt it with a three-fifths vote like you do with a local tax cap thank you thank you sir yes sir web scales still 49 D gold Road um once again the tax cap is looming over the board and potentially it's going to make the board present two budgets um it's lovely that the cap is you know pretty high up so that it probably won't be a problem until it is um and then we'll have to go through the ions of getting around it when we need to um I feel like we the voters have the ultimate power to choose what the budget is we don't need
248this cap um and the cap doesn't actually constrain us the ones who approve the budget um so the other problem here is that only part of the expenses of the school are related to the number of pupils so really we need sort of a two-part cap um one that's part pupils and then the other one that's you know sort of fixed expenses and and other obligations um and then of course the school um costs don't follow the CPI so adjusting it for inflation based on that really isn't appropriate we really should have some other adjustment for it so when you come right down to it this formula doesn't match the formula that we actually need so this is a solution that doesn't fit our problem so I would I would recommend voting against it and
249be mindful again sb2 this is going on the ballot so you can amend it tonight or it goes on the ballot I agree okay but since I've got the bully pulpit and a few people are watching on uh on the cable TV I'm saying vote against this gotcha but since you bring it up this being SP2 um we have the power to pull the teeth out of this thing and I propose that we change the dollar per pupil to something more comfortable um let's pick $35,000 that ought to give us plenty of breathing room it's a there's a motion to amend to change $225,000 to $35,000 been seconded any discussion on I'm sorry Jess can't understand you wasn't Mr power's motion to change letter D to e have we voted oh no that was his
250motion under the article so we begin with his motion under the Y okay thank you yep yep uh okay so where are we changing 25,000 35,000 is there second to that proposition that you did indeed I remember now thank you all those in no no we got to disc now forgive me okay uh discussion on changing 25 to 35,000 yes ma'am Melanie Le McDaniel's Drive whether it's 25,000 or 35,000 I think that this uh tax cap idea is a bad one this is an article that is being proposed in just about every town in New Hampshire and you know it's funny our school we're at 18,000 per per pupil so we we manage ourselves very well I don't think we need a tax cap to you know tell our people how much we can spend
251we are going to go lower than that and that's why the 35 forgive me forgive me so this language is going to go to the voters yes and uh whether we like the idea or not it's going to the voters our job today is is yes to air opinions about whether it in general is a good idea but your ability to do something tonight is by amending this thing he's made a motion to amend this thing so that's what's on the floor should we change 25,000 to 35,000 so I will let the next person I'm sorry thank you I get cranky as the night goes on um okay to on on the motion to amend sir yes sir uh Brady aligan birell um as we just discussed in article 7 um we had a a
252tax cap uh which was amended on the floor to double it from 4% to 8% sorry guys it's late and then uh what six years later oh we're trying to get rid of it because it's already not working so we could amend them to $100,000 and at some point in the future it's going to stop working either something's going to change in conquered or something else is going to occur unforeseen circumstances are going to occur this is going to stop working we're going to have to change it again we have a budget cap it's these five individuals and if you don't like their decisions you could get rid of them so um I would argue against the amendment uh as well as the article then I had a question for the board oh y go
253ahead which would be um if this article were eventually breached um how would that impact special education or would it not impact special education and instead impact general education so I my understanding 's going to jump out the bit but this is my last meeting so I'm just going to take all the microphone time I can um my understanding is that unless something changes at the federal level um or the state level with how special education funding is allocated to towns and what is required to be um provided for students who have special education needs that is always required by federal law and so general education will always suffer when there's a shortage of funds so um if special education costs go up and special education costs especially if there's um added services or out
254of District placements we already talked about like one year of tuition at an outof District placement could easily be 80 to $100,000 so that's one student equal for you know general education students in this equation so um it could very well detrimentally affect the the general education of our students um and my other point I was going to say to you Brady when you came up is not even like yeah we could make it $100,000 right the the point with article 7 is that you know this this law this statute um that we're referencing was just passed in August of 2024 and signed by the governor in August and became effective October 1st for this budget season so you know there's nothing uh preventing the state legislature from changing the rules of the game once
255we pass another budget cap so this is a budget cap not a tax cap but you know we can vote on one thing and then the state legislature can retroactively change the rules of the game um and and so I'm not in favor of it for that reason um but I don't know if that answer question so my so my final Point piggy backing off of that is this is a new law and it is very common for laws to change in the first couple years as wrinkles are ironed out so I would fully expect this to change possibly as soon as next year and that is a fairly substantial risk to inst to further instability thank you Mr again this is an sb2 process this language will be on the the ballot so if
256you have concerns you're only you may Express them in case someone's listening who will wind up in the voting booth but right now your ability to do something is limited to a amendment in a way that you think improves this thing forgive me no problem Eric Bernstein Mcintosh Road just um I understand this is a petition warn article but I'm curious about the dollar amount like I'm not an attorney but when I looked at 325e it seems the calculation is based on the current average per pupil cost and I just if that's the case and if someone could help me confirm that I just I'm afraid people might be under the misconception that there's this extra fluff in there that really doesn't exist If This Were to pass as superintendent I have asked legal that
257exact question because cost per p is defined by the state the $25,000 I have no where idea where it comes from if you look at the way the statute was written that was a blank now was that blank to put any number you wanted in or was that blank to put your Town's Coster pupil in the legislature never talked about that I have no idea what average de daily membership means and the words in Residence does does that mean if I have a student who's out of District are they included in this or not because that could be some of my most expensive students so there are a lot of legal concerns and then after just experiencing supporting which I did the tax cap and have it go from the operating budget to the entire
258warrant I'm also concerned that the definitions may come after the fact so you may pass something thinking to Mr scales's points 35,000 or to what the petition has put in 25,000 and it might actually be 18 what we're at right now and that could be devastating to your school district thank you and that's just what I wanted to point out is that we may change it to 35,000 100,000 20,000 it might not matter so just be aware of that that this this dollar amount might not mean anything thank you okay so I'm getting foggy but if I'm not mistaken what's on the floor right now the amendment to change it to 35,000 thank you I'm just pointing out that that change might be inconsequential if this if this dollar amount doesn't hear you completely but
259I was just F on whether we actually what was on the floor thank you you're going to speak to change to 35,000 sir yes I am Brian ryer still a 31 bason R uh Peter question for you can I uh move um um what do you call it um I've forgotten the words here uh um just tell me what you want to do don't worry about the restrict discussion on the amendment is that only apply to the the full questions or can you restrict restrict reconsideration restrict no not reconsideration I'm talking about people getting into line to talk about things what's the what's the word for that somebody El move that I'm not sure move the question oh you yes just use common sense where it's you want to end the discussion yes on the
260amendment yeah they say move the question which is a crazy thing End discussion okay the gentleman has made a motion to End discussion on the amendment uh whereby we would change the 25 to 35,000 is there a second for the gentleman yes there is all those in favor of ending discussion thank you very much all those opposed thank you very much discussion is ended therefore you're about to decide whether we're going to change for the ballot the the number $25,000 to $35,000 pardon oh that's that's fine yes yes yes yes thank you for the reminder appreciate it we always let the guys who are already waiting to be heard get heard even though we've ended discussion please Stacy Esposito peol Road can I make an amendment to the amendment like can I add my brain
261can't handle that no I just wanted to adjust the language some more if that's possible so should I wait yeah you can make another one after we act on this one yeah yes sir real quick um I oppose the amendment because I think it's just a ludicrous thing to just throw a big number in there because that takes away from what the purpose of this is and I think the voters are smart enough to understand what's going on here and you got a three- fist majority take your chances thank you sir yeah Eric Power westf Road I'm also against this amendment I think think that the $25,000 provides more than enough Headroom and making the 35,000 just is uh not really sensical and I'm glad the school board and the finance committee haven't taken a
262position on this article because I see zeros up there so thank you okay thank you yes sir okay so there's no more discussion on whether to go 235 or keep it at 25 so let's have a vote on whether you guys want to go to 35 all those in favor of that raise your voting card thank you all oppose raise your voting card it's clear to me but would you forgive me if you can I ask you than can people just raise their things higher um raise your this is in support of changing to 35 raise it high until you break into a sweat and yeah I so do I but I just want to make sure you you you good you good Jess okay holy macaroni everybody opposed to that change I will everybody
263opposed to the change I mean it's clear as a b now but give me the numbers but it's not on there 38 yes 12 no so it's changed to 35 5,000 so Mr M can I just add the school board did take a position on this apparently it's in the packet but it is not on the slide okay um so the position of the school board was I believe not in favor 0 to four and the position of the finance committee who I believe also took one was was Zero uh zero to two yes so neither the school board nor the finance committee recommended this article that that is in the posted warrant by the way yes it it is it's in this but apparently it didn't make it to this so um it is
264there but I just wanted to clarify that thank you very much for making that clear uh again going back to the wording of the recommendations we've always put like the number of votes in favor of the article the number of votes opposed the number of abstaining so I would like to see this change to the school board does not recommend the article 040 and the finance committee does not recommend the article 020 to clarify that is I yes yes ma'am so you're going to speak to the merits of the original um language with the change that 25 is now 35,000 yes thank you okay um I'd like to propose an amendment y I say that the right way sh yes okay um I would like to add that um first of all two things um
265that it will be re-evaluated yearly so the annual increase for inflation da da da da da da da as of January 1st whatever year and will be re-evaluated annually I guess are you going on to your second one your first no that was my first one okay so where dides your first one start and with what word um after January 1st at the end there yeah period follows okay and and will be reassessed annually reassessed I guess Mr moderator um I wasn't really specific when I answered your question about what can and can't be amended yeah you got it in front of you um yeah I mean I have the statutory form of the question the things that can be amended or yeah so let's just sometimes the legislation says if this issue is address
266you have to use the following language and this is one of those yeah it says um the form of the question shall be so that's means it's required um and it's let me make it really simple the the blank part before dollars the dollar amount obviously we just amended that the other part it says um um and then it says for uh inflation using the index so you name the index published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics or American city and Country so you you've got a you can literally name one of the indices is that plural of index that's it you don't have a lot of choice here um you can't add or take away stuff because okay it's not allowed okay you the ability to amend is limited to that dollar amount
267and this Regional yeah I mean there are other indexes right yeah okay can I say and it will not be applied to costs associated with no the legislature has not allow does not allow that okay good try all right thank you yes Mr moderator Eric power West wrote I'd like to make a motion to amend I wanted to change the inflation index to uh based on something I heard tonight um I wanted to change the index to the municipal cost index MCI and then you change instead of us Bureau of Labor Statistics it's the American city and county okay walk me through it ER start with what you're taking out so where it says plus an annual increase for inflation using using CPI CPI gets deleted yes and you put in MCI MCI that's the
268municipal cost index yeah and then you delete the rest of that for Boston Cambridge Newton Hampshire area yeah for the MCI published by and it's American city and county American city and county what that's it American city and county as of January 1st as of J as of January 1 as of January 1 that's it that I think the council agree that's an okay Amendment it's an or that was a yes I guess yes that's fine I'm sorry American city and county correct okay so would you read our motion your your Mo the motion as you want it to be excuse me would you read the entire motion as you wish it to be Amendment you want me to read the whole article it should say um yeah plus an annual increase for inflation using
269MCI published by American city and county as of January 1 period okay that do we have a a second for the gentleman's motion we have a second all discussion on the change man wants to make yes the the MCI may be a better metric for a school district because it's a municipal cost index and so it more closely will model what is uh happening in a school district I think people would might might be more amendable to it that so uh that's my reason for doing it all righty anybody else want to speak to the gentleman's proposed motion to amend Eric yes please Eric sorry I know it's getting late um Ed Perry foros tanus I'd like to move the question we've been here four hours let's end this okay how many people would like
270to cease discussion on this motion to amend thank you who who wants to keep talking about this motion to amend thank you okay now we vote uh on Brian I'm assuming I should proceed okay so I'm trusting that you have a handle on the change the gentleman is proposing is there anybody who wants me to read it I'd be happy to read it okay uh everybody who wants to make that Amendment to the motion under article 9 if you're in favor of it raise your voting card thank you if you're opposed raise your voting card okay so it's defeated in any event okay all Brian Raider still 31 Mason Road um move the question okay move the question well uh let's see so uh the gentleman is asking that the discussion end all those in
271favor of ending discussion all those opposed to ending discussion thank you very much uh therefore this motion goes forward as you last left it which is if I'm not mistaken uh it varies from your article the original article by making that subsection D instead subsection e and the the $25,000 $335,000 that's the only change do you think I'm right pardon me no no fa okay so that's what's going to be on the ballot for the people try to figure out what it's all about Mr moderator Mr moderator yes ma'am I would I would like to make a motion to adjourn well we have a gentleman oh I've got I've got two issues that was one of them um but before we do that uh under transact any other business yeah I would just like to
272acknowledge here that superintendent Andy Corey will be retiring this summer and I would like to thank him personally for his many years of service and the second items I'd like to move to a turn all those in favor see you later alligator thank you oh