001D Aon 3 section 2 a the dismissal promotion or compensation of any Public Employee so moved by Christa second by Kate um Tom I okay I CHR I Cindy I Holly I so now we are in non-public at 601 we'll be leaving and we will be back shortly e e e public pressure um moving forward with our agenda hello see what I live with see we have an agenda adjustment I'm getting we but not that much do that first yep so School Board I just need a um a moment we need to make an agenda adjustment we had a um you want to us sure I'll be making a um a motion to accept a donation uh Mr West had a donation come in today for the uh Washington DC trip it exceeds the $5,000
002amount so it has to come to the board so we'll be uh putting that forward and then as we talked about in uh non-public there'll be a motion along with the retirement uh of a particular individual so the DC thing I'll just start we need a motion to accept with gratitude the anonymous donation in the amount of $841 15 to support the families attending the trip to Washington DC I need a motion move by Kate I need a second by is there any discussion thank you yes thank you so much with gratitude all those in favor 6 Z motion carries all right I have a um a resignation tonight see dear superintendent Corey I am formally submitting my resignation from the position as school social worker with sau41 effective March 3rd 2025 this notice is
003provided in accordance with section 10 of my contract which requires a minimum of 30 days written notice for resignations I appreciate the opportunities I have had to support students and families during my time with the district I will work to ensure a smooth transition in the coming weeks and would appreciate any guidance on necessary steps to complete before my departure and that is uh sincerely from Julian Berkeley Hollis Brookline High School okay so I need a motion to accept the resignation of Jillian Berkeley as the school social worker at the Hollis brookly high school with an effective date of March 3rd so moved moved by Kate I need a second second second by Christa she's not completing her contract she's not on a contract she she's not on the teachers agreement she's fulfilling the 30
004days requirement that it's in her contract okay so she's on a contract but not the CPA are there any other questions or comments glad to see her go all right has done great work um all those in favor 60 and I have a retirement uh Dear Mr West I am writing to formally announce my retirement from the Hollis Brookline Middle School at the conclusion of the 2425 school year on June 23rd 2025 after more than 30 years of working with the staff and students of holl Brookline Community I am extremely grateful for the opportunity to have been part of such an engaging and supportive environment I have wonderful memories of working alongside by incredible colleagues I have enjoyed the various ways I have been able to contribute to our school by covering classes serving as
005a coach for track and cross country while also support while also supporting other Athletics are working with my team planning activities such as field trips winter walks medieval lunch are serving on committees and of course teaching my incredible students being part of the hb1 community has been a privilege as I plan for my retirement I am committed to ensuing ensuring a smooth transition please let me know how I can assist with this transition I will be available for consultation during my retirement should the need for support arise it has been a pleasure to be part of such a wonderful community in school district I look forward to the next chapter of my life and will cherish many memories and experiences as part of the uh motion to accept Sue's retirement uh per the CBA she
006is entitled to the retirement bio which would be 4,642 which will be paid out from the fy2 operating budget okay do you have a motion yep to see what action the board will take regarding the administrator's recommendation to provide the retirement contribution for Susan Connelly of 4,642 14 from the FY 225 operating budget as part of her accepting of her retirement can I get a motion on that so moved moved by K I need a second second by Christa are there any questions or comments we would like to thank to for her many many years of service and her dedication to our students any other comments all right all those in favor 6 Z so that motion carries and that's it for okay our business so I have a little housekeeping sorry I I hate
007to I'm not going to make this too long but um tonight is Christ whan's last meeting in this room she has a meeting in March that she'll be here at for but I just 14 years of service deserves a little bit of recognition so I wanted to take a moment to thank you from me but also I'm not supposed to speak on behalf of the board but I think it's safe to say that I'm going to thank you from the behalf of all the school board but this community The Many Many students who you've um worked for all the staff the many Hessa negotiations you've been involved with the turfield project that you were involved with the first time and the second time and the third time you explain a portion at annual meetings with
008Grace um there are so many things I I was going to make a list and I thought it would take too long um but by far the biggest thing and the most important thing is the fact that you have for many years brought the candy and so as a just to take a moment I bought you some very cliche things flowers which somebody can pass down to her and of course candy thank you very much thank you thank you okay and with that thank you you're welcome we might recognize you again in March but this might be it just we'll see what happens all right so now I need I'm not going to Appo a prce Observer because I think we're gonna move through this pretty quickly um so with that I need a motion
009to that the board go into recess until the conclusion of the public hearings so move move by Cy second by Rob all those in favor 60 so we are in recess and I'm turning it over to you thank you so with the quarum president I'd like to call this meeting of the co-op budget committee to order at 6:30 pm this is a joint meeting with the co-op school board for purposes of reviewing the FY 26 warrant and holding the public hearing on the proposed um that proposed warrant and the school board will be following up with a public hearing on the petition warrant articles I would like to introduce myself Darlene man and the budget committee uh members who are present this evening who include Matt Maguire Tom whan Raul Bon Dave blind Tom Enright
010and Tom Solon as our school board representative Brian Raider um is participating um by uh cell phone electronically and at this time I would like him to confirm that he was unable to be physically present this evening and then to um indicate if there's anyone present with him uh wherever he's located ran yes I'm not able to house okay thanks Brian um so due to Brian's um participation electronically any motions that the budget committee takes this evening will be by roll call so we'll have that little extra step does that mean we have to do roll call too or just you guys no it's just just us okay um so before we recess for the public hearing I just wanted to take a few minutes and give an overview of the warrant and share some
011relevant information so um the original warrant that we anticipated presenting this evening included seven school board and budget committee articles related to um facilities project the operating budget um the Hessa contract the SAU budget the facilities maintenance trust and the contingency um due to some um changes which the superintendant will explain shortly um the change of the total warrant as written to of 33.6 million uh will be adjusted and reordered to reflect um funding a funding change for both of the facilities articles one for the hbms energy conservation project one for the energy conservation solar project for both schools um those will now be numbered one and two because the funding change is to make those be Bond articles and um bonds are required to be uh addressed first in the warrant they are also
012required to have um an individual bond hearing because of the decision to make this funding change a bond hearing could not be noticed um with the appropriate time so while we will discuss them this evening it is not the formal bond hearing which will be held on February 13th February 13th so since we um you know had already anticipated discussing the projects and the lease ramifications we'll shift that conversation to bond um superintendent Cory will address um some of the reasons for the change and again the official public hearing in for both of those bonds will be on February 13th Tom our we going to present the financial stuff in the context of a bond release tonight Bond the bond okay um so we'll proceed then through the operating budget the Hessa contract the SAU
013budget the facilities trust and the contingency while the total of of the um warrant will now total 33 m7781 there is um an anticipated we like to say as we we discussed the um warrant itself the total as written so as written that is the total of will be the total of the warrant there is an anticipated adjustment so pending the passage of the um article one on energy conservation there will be an amendment to the operating budget which will reduce red the total amount of the warrant to 32,1 62,6 we also have five petition articles uh that are added um to the warrant itself one is to put the tax impact on the warrant establish a charter commission to adopt s SP2 to adopt the budget cap and adopt the tax cap for these
014um petitions there is a requirement that to uh a public hearing be held in each town of the co-op so tonight that public hearing will take place for Hollis and tomorrow night Wednesday night in Brookline that um public hearing is scheduled for um right before the deliberative session six o'clock okay so just a little background information um regarding enrollment in the co-op so right now we are looking at a three student projected enrollment decrease for FY 26 so we would call that um flat um enrollment these are B based on NZ DEQ projections we've heard a lot about um you know projects I probably wrote the book line and Halla School District levels about changes in enrollment due to the um additional the growth in each Community but at this time the projections that NASDAQ
015um has put forward does not really show a significant increase and we're anticipating after a five-year window that those increas is at the lower schools will will move up to the high school and middle school from a composition perspective um back in I would say the SE fy17 to fy19 window um enrollment composition in the district was pretty much you know very close to 5050 the reason why it's important to look at this is because we do have an apportionment formula between the two communities where the average daily membership which just arrived from enrollment um plays a significant role as we look at FY 26 which are the kind of bolded and outlined columns on that chart we're looking at a student distrib distribution anticipated to be about 5347 on the current year it's you
016know 5446 so it is kind of just hovering around that you know just slightly greater um swing toward Hollis between the if I didn't say this between the two schools themselves it's about a one3 two3 split in the population in general with oneir being at the middle school and about two-third of the population at the high school from a cost per pupil standpoint um this is the most recent data um from the um New Hampshire uh Department of Education um it is calculated through FY 24 based on uh a report called the doe2 which are the actuals that are submitted um by every District in the state um and they are the New Hampshire um Department of Education is responsible for articulating and calculating the cost per pupil for every District so there is um
017the cost per pupil simply not the amount we spend divided by students there are some um elements that are removed uh but they are removed consistently across every District in the state and we have consistently on an aggregate basis run below the cost per pupil average um here in the co-op so local tax effort is the amount that is raised through the local tax rate so while we would um we'll be discussing and impr and approving a budget in March the amount that actually affects your taxes is called tax effort it's an amount of the budget reduced by uh revenues and credits to The District in total and then additionally reduced by any adequacy and state aid that uh the both of the communities receive so you'll see here looking um at FY 25 which
018is the budget we are currently in right now while we are um had a budget of about $3.9 million the amount that's actually raised through tax effort and Taxation is $23.1 million so it consistently is at 20% or more below the uh approved budget so as I mentioned revenue and state aid are two of the elements that are reduced from the budget themselves to itself to um come up with the amount that we would be um attributing or estimating for each Community for tax effort as we look to FY 26 you'll see that um there is a estimated Revenue reduction of approximately $767,000 um this is due in uh due to the elimination of building Aid we are um we will no longer be receiving the building Aid payment um because we with um fy2
019we're making the last payment on the middle school bond and um we anticipate a lower unreserve fund balance so those two items you there are some other you know puts and takes along the way there are several elements to the revenue calculation but those are the largest contributing factors with regard to state aid these are um valuation and um student driven uh amounts that are specific to each community so the Grant is uh developed and derived specifically related to average daily membership so you'll see for Hollis um the estimate is anti the estimate is anticipated to go up by about $65,000 inadequacy and Brook lines is anticipated to go down by 43,000 um in brookline's case there is an additional um element to the adequacy calculation that the community of Brookline in total receives that
020is um decreasing over time due to legislation so um that is part of the contributing factor to the $43,000 reduction in adequacy for Brookline and the Statewide education property tax is developed by um based on the equalized value in each Community a rate across the state is developed and charged to every community in the state and then um that amount is collected in taxation in each Community through and calculated the impact of the taxes is calculated against assess value but the the rate itself to come up with the amounts for each Community is based on a flat rate every single community in the state of New Hampshire is um based on equalized valuation is charged the rate to come up with the dollar amount that they need to collect in taxes so for Hollis that's
021um $1.35 million which is a slight reduction of 6,244 from the current and for Brook Line That's $632,000 which is a little more than $22,000 more for next year so in total there's really a minimal maybe $330,000 um net increase in Aid so there are the contributing factors as I mentioned to tax effort that we'll be seeing this year are an increase in the budget lower Co-op revenue and the minimal state aid increases so this summary is just to show you where we're kind of starting in fy2 um the FY 26 as written is the revised uh warrant amount based on the bonded uh projects being the cost of the bonded projects being included and the FY 26 adjusted is the amount that we anticipate if everything passed as written and we made that adjustment
022to the operating budget of the $ 32.16 million 25.1 would be um assessed in taxation so the formula um we just had a meeting um last week to confirm and um make a slight adjustment to the uh definition of capital and as a result um the distribution um of the elements to the apportionment formula are as as follows so they are estimated of course um as we're looking to FY 26 we would be estimating uh the ADM estimate is based on the close of the prior year so based on the distribution of students at June 30 of the prior year so we'd be estimating 54 .7% of the students from Hollis 453 from Brookline um again equalized value is in a rear so we have an estimate in there at 68.3 for Hollis 31.7 for
023Brookline uh calculates to a net a portion Min of about 5545 and once um the each district uh receives its Aid the net tax effort distribution of the budget would be 56% polus and about 44% profile so this is to putting all those percentages into actual numbers these is as um indicated estimated and based on the adjusted budget we would start with the 32162 million um for the total reduced by Co-op revenue and at that that point the 30.5 million is where we would apply the apportionment formula which results in just under 17 million being apportion to Hollis 13.5 million a portion to Brookline each Community then has that amount reduced by state aid both adequacy and the Statewide education property tax yielding tax effort of just under 14.2 million for Hollis and about 10.9
024million for Brook line these are estimates there are several factors which will affect the net results including the valuation in the communities um final Revenue elements the final calculation of state aid but with the data that we have now these are the estimates that we're putting forward um that would result in an estimated Co-op local tax rate of $68 per thousand for Hollis $936 per thousand in Brookline um as indicated that would be a 7.4% increase in the local co-op tax rate for Hollis 88.2% in Brookline because the local co-op tax rate represents a portion of the tax bill the net change that that seven and eight% don't um aren't aren't the percentage increases in your final bottom line total tax bill um that would be um on the Hollis side uh the co-op represents
025about 32% of the total so the impact this has on the total tax bill is 2 4% and in Brookline the co-op represents about 38% of your tax bill um and that would uh equate to about a 3.1% increase in taxes do you have a slide that shows that without the based on FY 26 non-adjusted or something I guess the question is is there something that's going to come in come up that will show what happens if article one fa uh I do have a view of the operating budget both ways okay that's coming up okay so does anyone have any other questions at this point NE okay so at this time um I'll take we have the motion to go into recess as a board and yeah we already did that so I'll take
026a motion from the budget committee to um recess to conduct the public hearing moved by Dave Lyn seconded by Raul um we do have to have a roll call vote so that would be Brian yes okay um Dave yes R yes Tom Tom wh yes yes Tom en yes Matt Maguire yes I didn't have that on my chart um Tom Sol yes and Darlene votes yes so with a vote of what does that give us one two four eight to zero the budget committee stands in recess okay so at this point I will um open the public hearing at 6:46 pm and share oh yep share the um rules for um this evening's minute uh the purpose and rules for the public hearing so the purpose of the public hearing tonight is to introduce articles
027with stated Financial impact to be voted on at District meeting we'll be accepting public input per article after the public hearing of the Articles both the budget committee and school boards will uh deliberate and take positions on the Articles the amount of the budget article may be amended by the budget committee and the 10% on maximum allow maximum allowable appropriation limits the maximum appropriation which me which may be um recommended at district meeting rules for giving public input input is restricted to Hollis Brook line residents of legal voting age um we would make an exception of course for administration and others as necessary for clarification we are will be requesting inut on a per article basis we'd ask that you state your name and address for the record and direct questions to the chair there's
028a speaking time of two minutes which cannot be yielded um we do have uh a timekeeper for this evening if you do um ask a question and you're waiting for an answer your time will be stopped you'll have the answer to your question and you can continue or you can ask all your questions up front and then just um wait for your answers that seemed to work at last week's meeting when some folks did that um you may speak to an article again after all others have had an opportunity to do so and ask that you be brief if your point has been made by others do you want me to do some reading I'm good so far think no whatever you want you no you just you do you do you and then if
029you need a break you just tell me okay start I remember the year I did this withus that was I you too okay so the original I will not read this portion into the record this was the original article language that addressed using a 20-year lease purchase agreement since that is not what's moving forward I'm sharing it because it was discussed it's been part of um minutes of both the budget committee and the school board so people may recognize it from um either you know looking at uh data that's on the website it included a uh authorization for 5.29 5,291 1200 project in which the lease amount was $44,988 so what we will be um reviewing And discussing and again which will be also brought up at the public hearing on the 13th as the
030official public hearing for the bonds is the language as follows to see if the district will vote to raise and appropriate the sum of 5,291 1200 budget for the design acquisition and installation of energy conservation equipment hbms boilers controls LED lighting and other endof life rooftop units and related building improvements at Hollis Brook line Middle School um parenthetically the project to authorize 5,291 20000 of such sum to be raised through the issuance of bonds or notes in accordance with the municipal fin Finance act RSA chapter 33 to authorize the school board to issue and negotiate such bonds or notes and to determine the date maturities interest rate and other details of such bonds or notes and to authorize the school board to apply for accept and expend any federal state or private funds that may
031become available in respect of the project to reduce the amount that must be bonded or to pay debt service on such bonds or notes and to raise an appropriate the sum of 32,2 180 for the first Year's principal and interest payment on the bonds or notes issued three- fifths ballot vote required neither the board or budget committee have um made taken votes to um made recommendations at this time we'll do so later um the estimated tax impact of the uh project is written is three cents per thousand in Brookline and 5 cents per thousand in I mean three cents per thousand in Hollis and 5 cents per thousand in Brooklyn so at this point um I'll ask superintendent Corey to um give an overview or share some information about the project itself and then he'll
032um speak to the uh changes in the financing Arrangement sure the the project for the Middle School entails the upgrading of boilers and install new propane tanks so we' be converting from oil to propane which would increase our buying power uh with the town of Brookline the town of Harless the haris school district the high school and if this would have passed the middle school all being on uh propane which gives us a significant um volume to bid each year it would also be an upgrade to our LED lighting which we expect about a two-year useful life and that is uh for specific reasons around we do Envision the rebates that are eligible going away in the foreseeable future that's what uh legislative bodies are telling us Andy you said threeyear useful life said twoe
033useful I said twoyear and I meant that's a Payback back isn't it no this is the it's the two years before the rebates would go away oh but it's not that the lighting's only useful for two years no thank you yeah that clarify than Tom uh also an upgrade to the control system we would be adding uh mechanical ventilation and dehumidification which we presently don't have we installed it a few years at the high school and it has changed the educational environment in a very positive way we would also be upgrading uh 1994 unit vent area energy recovery recovery ventilators with dehumidification those are presently uh basically at their end of life we would also be upgrading two heat recovery ventilators and those items when combined give us the total of 5,291 1200 the facilities
034committee started work last July and came forward with this recommendation to both bucom and the school board they also looked at replacing our units from 2002 and doing something to our cafeteria ventilation system those two items were uh delayed and taken out of this project to bring the cost down to the 5, 291,000 we would expect grants or rebates uh to offset the initial cost of 85,000 and we project an energy savings at the middle school of $ 53,56 on an annual basis the reason for the change in financing uh periodically each quarter the New Hampshire Bond Bank comes out with rates they released new rates about mid to uh late January and all of a sudden there was a significant difference between the lease and the New Hampshire Bond Bank so by going from
035the lease to the bond that we're proposing now uh the difference in total interest was 1, 367,000 that we would be saving because of the lower interest rate so at that point in conferring with the business manager and the assistant superintendent uh we felt it was needed to make this change and move forward with this article as a bond I believe we have to make a motion to amend the article Don't We that's what I have that would be my team have to get right yes during the hearing we're not doing not doing that so at this point I'll entertain um any uh public input on article one for the Middle School energy conservation project so if anyone in the audience would like to make any comments please come to the podium state your name
036and address and we'll take your input good evening um my name is Eric power I live on West View Road in Brookline and I'm happy to see that this is now a bond versus a lease I think the leases are very expensive and I think finally somebody noticed and that's very good um I do have a concern I mean I heard about the uh the changing over to propane you know propane versus oil oil is less expensive from what I can see but maybe from the buying power of it if you have all your other facilities on propane it might make sense and I don't know that maybe the uh superintendent or someone can quantify that a little bit um and the other other request I would make of the Schoolboard Andor budget committee um
037the one thing you see when you do a bond is you don't see the seconde payment so when somebody thinks it's like in Brookline it's 5 cents per thousand the uh first year it actually goes up like three and a half X the second year so it would be in the transparency there to to let folks know it's not going to be a nickel after the first year it's going to probably go up to whatever three and a half times that is it's probably more like 20 cents per thousand in Brookline and probably something equivalent in holla so I would ask that that be put forward so people know what they're paying for um and um I think this is a much more responsible way I don't know if I'll vote for it but I
038definitely like the fact that we're going to save interest rates versus these leases I think leases are with these Escape Clauses are um are not the best idea because you're paying for a premium to have an escape Clause that you can't actually escape from so the bond is a much better deal but people do do need to know the tax impact they don't if they don't know about the second year I think it's important that we that that's presented to the public before they vote and superintendent I don't know if you can answer that question or someone someone chair who can answer the question about the the trade-off between Oil and Propane given the buying power and the cost of oil versus propane the that compris your whole two minutes Mr power the buying power
039is you're correct on that that's why we're able to get such a good deal because we're talking the entire um propane order for both towns uh the Hall of school district the high school and now the middle school so it has resulted in a very strong buying power uh and our rates have been um more than competitive can I just speak to that point I I brought up that question myself because I was looking at comparing the cost for BTU and the oil seem cheaper and then when I found out the rate that we'll be able to buy because there's so little oil being bought in in the community now by the school district the pendulum is swung completely and the costant is dramatic nothing that you or I can get at home right now
040thank you and I I'll just add to address your concern about transparency and additional information what we traditionally do um at the meeting when we um are proposing long-term financing of any kind is to show the exact impacts that you were talking about um at the March meeting so we'll have a chart that um shows the cumulative debt of the district over time as well as the tax impacts on a going forward basis you're saying you're going to show that the tax impact per thousand for the outgoing years okay thank you mron Baxter Road Hollis um you'll excuse me for what may be a naive question is it possible to obtain boilers that can be switched back and forth between fuel sources um and is that something we thought about or is it just you're
041going to have to buy a whole new boiler it's not so much the boilers as the fuel supply system that can't be switched back and forth right much of this is being driven by the need for us to remove our current um storage systems they are no longer in compliance so the question was do we replace them with new oil storage or switch um the cost advantages of the propane drove the propane y even I I don't know if the the boilers don't change what happens is the firing units for the CH would would change which is relatively small portion of the overall cost but what would be very expensive is to have both types of fuel storage systems so at some point it might be um economically viable to switch As prices of the
042Commodities change but you don't anticipate that well the forecast isn't for that and as we move forward and the idea of having a um um an electrical based system due to renewable sources and have the the um the propane become a backup um there are other mechanical reasons propane systems do better they are not being used as far as being able to restart there's other things as well but in theory the could operate fired by either propan or oil if that's your question well I was again it's a naive question I don't know enough about the different pieces to it's a it's a great question um the answer isn't black and white but the infrastructure itself is not fuel specific as far as I understand we we also gain the ability to be uh have
043uh redundant systems so those boilers would be load sharing with this new install currently we don't have that um so if one boiler goes down half the school gets freezes out the other half stays warm right okay and everyone goes to that one half right all right thank you very much seeing no other one no one else rising to any comment I'll close public input on article one and move to article two which is um again originally as brought forward would have been a 15-year lease on 2,2 2016, 155 with a payment of 22,6 39 that will be changing to the following to see if the district will vote to raise and appropriate the sum of two 2,2 2016, one55 gross budget for the design acquisition and installation of energy conservation equipment solar panels and
044related building improvements at Hollis Brook line middle school and Hollis Brook line High School parenthetically the project to authorize 2,216 155 of such sum to be raised through the issuance of bonds or notes in accordance with the municipal Finance act RSA chapter 33 to authorize authoriz the School Board to issue and negotiate Bond such bonds or notes and to determine the date maturities interest rate and other details of such bonds or notes and to authorize the school board to apply for accept and expend any federal state or private funds that may become available in respect of the project to reduce the amount that must be bonded or to pay debt service on such bonds or notes and to raise and appropriate the sum of $55,500 for the first Year's principal and interest payment on the
045bonds or notes issued three fths bot requ school board and budget committee will make recommendations later this evening the estimated tax impact of uh the FY 26 payment is a penny per thousand in Hollis and two cents per thousand in Brooklyn superintendent again the facilities committee uh investigated solar we were originally looking at a solar field to be on the property and that was the direction we were moving in until we spoke to our electric company as part of our research and realized that there would be an additional $1.5 million uh in cost related to a new substation that would have to be put in for us to gain the benefit of uh the selling of the electric back to the company at that point we moved from a ground mounted system to look at
046our roof similar to what we've done in the holl schools uh we have proposed in this warrant a roof mounted system that will provide an an annual savings at the high school of $84,700 which will save 69% in electric use and have approximately a 10.9 to 11.5 uh payback over the life of the uh system the system itself is eligible for a 25.5% cost rebate so the cost to us would be $1,290 excuse me 1,290 9111 and the federal offset would be $329,800 of our electric usage and having about 10.8 years approximately uh for a payback neither of the paybacks factor in the cost escalation for future energy costs so the initial system at the middle school would be 925,000 coming back to the districts the net cost would be $689 9,37 for a solar
047array on the Middle School roof and again going back to the interest rates the same thing occurred here a 2,21 2016, one55 bond from New Hampshire Bond Bank uh for a 15-year term came out of 3.59% that would give us the uh payment of the 54 excuse me 55,0 44 in the first year the interest difference in why we're switching from a lease to a bond is in interest savings we would have $446,500 so between the two projects going from leases to bonds if they were both to pass the in the interest difference that we would save would be $1,838 120 and I'll turn it back over to the chair I just ask clarification bond has to be for the full amount before the rebate U and what H since we can't prepay on a
048bond what happens to that money the the rebates come back in and is it credit towards correct okay thank you thank you you please state your name and address are the microphones running the microphones yes they're recording um for the live stream they go to the they're not for this room is there a way to do it so we can hear what you're saying over there don't okay um Susan hate from Brookline I have a question about this proposal do you have a Solar Company in mind we had a consultant that worked with us that has done work in Hollis and in Brooklyn eii uh but if the bond was passed we are required to go out to bid okay and what guarantee do we have that any company that we might select does not
049file Chapter 11 or chapter 7 and if the system fails what guarantee do we have that it will be replaced fixed or removed uh as part of the due diligence process um the facilities committee investigates anybody who submits a bid because it's not simply taking the lowest bid it's the most qualified bidder that can deliver the project uh we have experience because we've done this in Hollis those systems have been in place for a number of years now are running very efficiently uh we've actually even taken one of the systems off put in a new roof and put the system back on using the vending company I I don't anticipate uh a company going bankrupt but it could I mean I can't foresee that uh but I have found that the the solar companies that
050have uh expressed interest are very reputable companies and I would doubt very much that they would abandon a project because they would unlikely to get any other business in New Hampshire from a school district or a townside okay thank you you're welcome good evening Tony stanzy from how you doing uh Tony stanzy from uh hollus to a one South merac Road uh my concerns are basically looking at anything like this is an investment and with any investment you look for return on that investment and um I have a couple of questions really regarding um this whole process and with specifics to the return on investment uh the cost of each panel plus installation and also removal has to be considered in the cost I don't know if removal has but at the end of its
051life expectancy it will have to be removed the cost of removing can be anywhere between a few hundred and $500 per panel I don't know how many panels we have but it's I think important to have that added to your your return on investment calculation um in the return on calcul uh return on investment calculation it's not a fixed number it's a very flexible number and it has to do with the cost of energy at any given time if the cost of energy comes down the return on investment time period will be affected inversely by that so if you if the cost of energy dropped in half and the return on investment is 20 years given the cost of energy the return on investment could be 40 years so I want to be very careful
052and I want to have that information regarding the return on investment um there are there are a a lot of things relative to to whether you Bond whether you take a capital lease and all that sort of thing that's the the interest part the cost of the financing I'm sure you have all of those calculations in place but with the uh key to to my question is the return on investment and I'd appreciate it if anyone has any of those answers if not you should have the answers by the time the warrant meeting comes comes about because um I think the town needs to know both towns need to know what's the return on what the money that we're spending thanks Tony got your two minutes what's that's your two minutes all right thank you
053very much I appreciate the time just to uh give give you some answers uh we did not factor in the removal 25 years from now into the return on investment uh we have approximately just under 11 years for return on investment at a straight rate so no inflation of energy costs uh I haven't seen energy costs go down so I'm really looking for them to fall halfway uh I've seen them go the other way so I think our payback would actually less we had projected about 11year payback in uh the return on investment came a little under eight years yep base it on a a cost of oil per barrel because that's just kind of a fixed uh cost of energy and I can remember not too long ago it being $130 per barrel currently
054it's around 80 to 90 per barrel and it's been as low as about even in the high 20s per barrel so somewhere in between there's a likelihood that the cost of energy could go down and then adversely affect the return on investment time period so just basically a concern and I think it needs to be addressed thanks okay I have a question can I ask or do I need to go to the no question for you can ask your questions later all right I'll ask later write it down yeah really one way to go uh my name's Eric power from westf Road and Brookline and I'm against this warn article we've seen tax increases that have been very high recently this is definitely a nice to have category there are a lot of questions I
055agree with the previous speaker about return on investment we heard some verbal stuff here but we haven't really seen anything concrete obviously there's a lot of assumptions that go into that I'm an engineer so I have I like to see the numbers and I like to see the assumptions um I do think it's much wiser if this is to be done to be doing it with a lease versus uh to do it with a with a uh Bond versus a lease and another thing another tool that's out there I don't know if it was considered but it kind of reduces the risk on the uh the payback is to look at an energy performance contract you know the energy performance contracts guarantee a certain savings over time um under RSA 21i uh section 19d those
056are very powerful things that are maybe a better way to do it than actually buying it hoping that it works out and then hoping you get the savings I think there's another option there um that I don't know if it was explored or not maybe somebody could answer that when I'm done speaking um this I see this as sort of a green New Deal you think it's a good deal but I don't think that it you know it could pan out and also it's not really the good time when we have all these other large expenses if you want to pass a five or $6 million bond to help with the middle school we have Rising costs we still have declining enrollment this isn't the time to do this sort of project in my opinion
057um and you know I don't know that it's been thought through and I don't know if all the options have been explored and can somebody answer the question about energy performance Contracting um it was a great question Eric and and we raised that specifically um the decision to go this route was based on that current 25.5% rebate and that was the Tipping Point the um performance contracts right now the overall savings was not as great if if this rebate um is available and the project goes through the overall cost ended up being lower because the way those performance contracts work is it assumes you're going to get you pay at the higher rate essentially till you've paid it off and then you get the benefit back in later years um when looking at the calculations
058uh over the expected life of the the panels as well as the near-term costs that 25.5% immediate refund was clearly the advantage and and those the contracts that you've talked about while this rebate have has been in place have somewhat fallening out of favor if that rebate does disappear then the performance contract then becomes the the preferred method and would would likely be there um it's not shown in in here because this just shows what they're spending but what the facilities committee was was really looking for is that this be AAL essentially cost neutral to the taxpayer um the goal was that the expenditures versus the savings that would be achieved real time um would net out to have close to no budgetary impact it's not an exact thing because you don't know where the
059usage is going going to be but two things play into it one is the the cost factors alone the other is pairing this with the article one activities because the article one activities can leverage the use of electric power in certain areas which would be lower cost if we're in in a uh environment where we have solar offset nice thing about the solar is that in a net metering environment um we get to bank the money during the summer when we're not when our energy consumptions are very low and the yield is very high so um it it's not uh the same thing as an off-grid kind of calculation but the question that you asked about the cost of of operations you know what what's the real cost to it is it is it a
060nice to have or is it a is it a need to have yes it's a nice to have but we also believe that it's fiscally nice to have because the belief is that in the short term during the payoff period the budget impact will be uh low to non and that subsequent after payoff It all becomes direct savings um I don't know who's got the the best stuff with I think Mike at eii has the the best information for that but if we can get that how that uh how that evaluation was made I think it would it would go a long way to answer your questions yeah if there was an analis that we paid for or worked with that would be nice to put up on the website so we could take a
061look at it to see I could be convinced if I see better numbers but right now I'm kind of against it because I don't really understand that the differences so and I also think maybe with the new presidential Administration and everything Energy prices will be going down at least for next four years so that'll extend the time but that's that's a big question thank you hi I'm Ain hubard I live at 9y Moore Hill Road I'm just having a sorry in Hollis or Brookline oh in Hollis thank you um I'm just reading here through the Boston Globe that with the tariffs that are going to be coming on from the electricity that's imported from Canada uh which is estimated to be about 10% of New England's electricity uh cost of the um energy that comes
062in from Canada is going to go up by 10% at least due to these new tariffs that are coming in so um I understand that the hope is that energy would go down but I'm not certain that it will and so I think becoming more energy independent makes us more flexible and able to provide for ourselves thank you thank you seeing no one rise to the microphone I'll close public input on article two and move to article three the operating budget to see if the school district will vote to raise an appropriate a sum of 31,1 6,427 for the support of schools for the payment of salaries for the school district officials and agents and for the payment of statutory obligations of the district this appropriation does not include Appropriations voted in other waren articles
063majority vote required the school board and budget committee will take their positions later um the estimated tax impact to hollus is $62 bookline $925 per thousand so this is the impact and calculation of the article as uh it's written as I indicated earlier assuming the other articles pass the budget itself is overstated by $915,000 so if article uh one were to pass when this uh budget is brought to the floor there will be an amendment to it to reduce it by 915,000 um that was the uh I'll explain um what that $915,000 comprises shortly um in the event that the 30 million 245 427 is brought to the floor the impact would be $583 per thousand in Hollis and $8.95 C per thousand I just realized the typo there on the impact for 100,000 which
064instead of 817 should read 895 and that will be corrected when it this presentation gets posted to the website with recommen with the recommendations of each of the um committees so the uh impact for Brookline would be $895 per 100,000 not 817 um let's see so as um just to give you a little bit of overview and highlights of the operating budget um as indicated as a written the percent increase over the current budget that the school schools are operating under is a 6.3% increase again adjusted down 915,000 um the projected increase would be 3.2% um the budget committee has a process that it begins uh in the fall and establishes a guidance metric for the uh the school district and uh the operating budget that's been submitted um does fall below uh the guidance
065forward by the budget committee by about $100,000 so um if the $915,000 project were not in the oper the uh operating budget the budget committee would have revised its guidance downward and the budget would have still Fallen $100,000 below um the the guidance that it put forward uh in Broad categories there are some staff and FTE increases um two for student services for an IND District um provider in addition to uh board certified behavior analyst there are um academic uh items for classroom equipment and textbooks there are technology uh purchases for phasing of Chromebook laptop and flat panels and um some updates to the firewall security and for maintenance and safety items there are um you know ongoing phased approaches to um Paving across the district flooring duck work window replacements painting in ceiling tiles
066speed bumps and things like that so the $915,000 that I mentioned is um included in the total amount and represents uh for lack of a better word the Baseline changes that need to be um implemented in the middle school for the boiler upgrades so that is what represents the 915,000 and um would be reduced if original um article one were to pass from an increases and decreases perspective the district is um looking at an increase in benefits of almost 133% due to an increase in the ma the Guaranteed Rate for insurance um which is 8.9% an increase in Dental um Insurance of 5% and census changes which result in um additional staff taking benefits and those staff Meers members then um the amount of the buyout then decreases because those uh members of our um
067Staffing of our staff are now taking benefits in student services there are program changes that uh will net a six $66,872 th000 in athletics for um field maintenance uniforms and various um levels of equipment there are new facilities items um it we'll talk a little bit later about um a a facilities Expendable trust that basically addresses kind of the higher ticket or more expensive items the $31,500 includes expenses that are generally um I don't want to say they're lower ticket but because they're still expensive but they're the items that the project costs are just you know in more in the you know5 10 $20,000 range individually um the paving might be a little bit higher but it isn't um the scope of the some of the things that we'll be discussing later so this that
068$31,500 represents um projects AC in each school for Paving various elements of the parking lot putting in um and fixing and speed bumps um duck work phasing in window Replacements classroom painting ceiling tiles those are all elements that are kind of phasing over time so that any one budget isn't um inundated with with costs on any or all of those categories on the other new items of $384,500 um this is the continuing of a phasee in approach to replacing Chromebooks laptops and interactive flat panels it has been a year-over year replacement cycle um what we're looking for in FY 26 is a reduction of the prior Year's amount by almost $34,000 um there are Savings of $588,000 in building and grounds because of high school projects that were completed um in this year which are
069not going to carry forward into the next budget and we see uh reduction in staff retirements um of a little over $65,000 at this time I'll invite um individuals to provide their comments on the operating budget or ask their questions good evening Erica McDonald TR Road and Hollis um I was wondering if you could discuss if you could talk a little bit about the student services what program changes are being um are being suggested for $660,000 so these are um either students specific or in District program changes I can't go into too much detail there are some program placement pieces that are involved in this cost chain okay and what is the difference between the facility maintenance trust and the facility main the facilities charges that are here in the operating budget so the facilities
070maintenance trust um it's the amount of usually keep it around $300,000 and as I mentioned it it's usually paid for like larger ticket items or items we're saving for so we'll discuss this um as we get to that article those items are including like the root replacement um some items for elevator so they're a little bit more expensive and um we do try to put some money in there as a savings element in addition to funding those larger ticket items um I could just the uh if you give me one second facilities items that we're looking at for the Middle School the uh 31,500 include I mean there $20,000 in Middle School window replacements 18,000 um for new padding in the NPR $3,000 Phase 2 ceiling tile replacement $10,000 phase two duct work um Paving
071of the front Lop that one is $80,000 it's a little bit higher priced than many of the other items electric panel replacement of 15,000 a $4500 water bottle filling station and $220,000 in flooring at the middle school the high school includes $6,000 worth of Cabinetry $3,000 for pH Paving um painting phase two ceiling tile replacement for $3,000 classroom flooring phase one $20,000 uh a grounds maintenance vehicle for $155,000 restroom dividers phase two for 10,000 duck work cleaning phase one for 10,000 phase two of hand dryer replacement for 5,000 two water bottle filling stations for 9 and about $50,000 in front and rear parking of the drive of Paving of the driveway okay thank you very much Eric Power westrey Road in Brook line um I think this operating budget's a little too high I'm not
072that happy with it going up if you look at what's been happening uh over the past seven years years we've lost about 11 or 12% of the students but the budget keeps going up the other thing I'm concerned about is if you look at our proficiency scores we have um this most recent year we have 38% of our seventh graders that are not proficient in math 35 in 8th grade and 40% in 11th grade I'm very concerned with that we spend a lot of money we have 40% of our seniors or 11th graders not proficient in math we're doing better in Reading in the seventh and eighth grade however we're at 30% that are not proficient and 11% in 11th grade and in science we have 49% in eth grade that are not proficient and
07348% in eth and 11th grade so that's about half the students are not making proficiency but we're spending $30 million so I get concerned about that I and I'm not happy with the the rise and all the different stipend that are out there we need to get back to the basics we need to get back to getting Proficiency in math reading and science instead of all these extra things um spending more money on Sports is not the right thing to do maybe the booster club can help there and maybe they are helping but we can't keep paying that with the declining enrollment this budget is just getting too large too fast and I don't I don't I'm not going to support it I would like to see um lower budget when the student enrollment goes
074down and it's just not sustainable for the average taxpayer to spending this amount this amount of money and having these kinds of scores yeah they might be better than the state average but the state average isn't great so that's my concern and I hope that you can find some ways budget committee to take a look at lowering this budget a little bit before you approve it thank you seeing no one else rise to the microphone I'll close public input on the operating budget and move to the support staff contract to see if the school district will vote to approve the cost items for the first year of a three-year collective bargaining agreement reached between the Hollis Brook line Cooperative school board and the Hollis education support staff Association for the 2025 26 2026 27 and
0752027 28 school years which calls for the following increases in support staff salaries and benefits at the current Staffing levels for fiscal year 2025 26 estimated increase $133,400 419 for the first fiscal year 2025 26 school year such sum representing the additional costs attributable to the increase in support staff salaries and benefits required by the new agreement over those that would be paid at current Staffing levels majority vote required the school board and budget committee will make recommendations later this evening uh the estimated tax impact for Hollis is three cents per thousand and Brook line is 5 cents per thousand I'll just give a brief uh description of this contract and what happened during negotiations we had a great negotiation most of the changes um in the contract are language changes that um were made
076to keep up with the changes that we have in order and also to try to keep our contract conts a little bit more consistent with both the Brookline Hessa and the Hollis Hessa um we kept our insurance caps for our contract this year this contract is a three-year contract it is not standardized the increase for the $133,000 is a 2.75 increase from the previous salary table um for the onstep people and it is a 3 4% increase for the off step people and then our um caps went up also the single went up $93 the two person went up $164 and the family went up $291 thank you thanks anyone has any um input on the support staff contract please come to the microphone Drew Mason bter Road Hollis and moderator of the district um
077has the school board considered adding a contingent article in case this one fails anyway it's option available to school board it's up to you I don't think we generally have done that for the support staff contract okay but thank you for the the thought and the reminder I willion Eric Power westf Road in Brookline um I appreciate that this is not S beriz I think that's really the best way to go on all contracts and I I like that that part of it um I couldn't quite hear what the numbers were um and also if this CBA will be made on put on the website so that people rotors can read it I like to get it and look at it before the meeting is this is this already available on the website or can
078it be no it's already there it's already is it under the annual meeting area no it's under human resour yeah in a box it says I don't know I couldn't find it then if I was I was looking for it but it's with all the other Collective agreements okay I'll have to take a look um I'll I'll reiterate the um increases that M Mrs whan um identified or a 2.75% salary table increase for those on step and a 3.4% increase for those off so those that are on step when they get the Sal when they get the step increase plus the step what do they actually get on average it's about a 4% increase four to 5% increase depending on where they are in the table right but did it do they move on all
079the steps I thought some of them they they they um they move are they yearly steps yes okay how many how many steps are on this this table nine n okay you're correct did you even um there are nine steps nine step and how many categories were there five five is that oh it been that way in the Co in the co-op okay yeah maybe I'm confusing that with Brookline Brookline has eight or nine different categories okay very good thank you thank you seeing no one else rise to provide input on article four I'll close um article four and we'll move on to Article Five the sa budget sh the District vote to raise and appropriate the sum of 1,712 se8 as the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District District's portion of the sa budget of
0802,438 355 for the forthcoming fisal year this year's adjusted budget of 2,389 654 with 1,147 1885 assigned to the school budget of this school district will be adopted if the article does not receive receive a majority vote in all of in of all of school district voters voting in the school administrative unit both boards will uh take their positions later this evening the estimated tax impact is 28 cents per thousand in Hollis and 44 cents uh per thousand in Brook line um this article is um an opportunity where people get to vote twice um the the votes are combined um across holla the votes taken in holla the holl school district the line school district and the co-op um in each District's article will identify the different amount that would be approved for their District
081so for the co-op it's the 1,171 278 um percentage of the total there's an apportionment formula um applied to it and as we look toward um the uh increase which is um in total about a $3,000 change um the primary drivers this um budget really represents the um support staff of the central the staff of the central office and the administrators that work there um so it is very much uh I think 93% of the budget is salary and benefit driven and we see a $122,000 increase in salaries projected for FY 26 which includes 4% increases for staff and savings as we um we'll see um salary savings as we turn over from superintendent Corey to superintendent burgs goog moving into um uh FY 26 and from from a benefit perspective while health insurance rates
082are increasing by 8.9 and dental by 5% we see a slight decrease in benefits of $5,000 due to census changes um of the staff and how they're taking benefits hi could you provide your name again Susan hate from Brookline um just sort of an informational question for a lot of people that might be watching that don't understand how this SAU budget comes about I don't recall that we've ever had a public hearing and I don't know who establishes what this budget is but this has probably been a thorn in my side for a long time as I've seen this budget go up and up and up and up and I don't know how we can control it so um the governing board um is um overseas is is comprised of members of he all school
083board members can keep be honest of all school board members they assigned a Treasurer who's uh elect a treasur appoint a Treasurer who's in who is um involved in the budget development process and the SAU budget subcommittee includes members of um each School District each budget and each budget or finance committee in addition to um m members of the administration um it's a process that takes place during the fall there are meetings and information shared as the drafts of the budget are um developed they are shared with each of the member groups um at their public meetings so for example I was the representative for the co-op budget committee and when that draft was put forward I brought it to my board I shared the draft with the committee to provide input and comments and
084brought those comments back to the subcommittee so the same is done with the Hollis um budget committee and uh the brook line finance committee uh there is a public hearing that takes place on this it takes took place at the December governing board meeting the presentation is posted on the website and uh the meeting was probably December 12th December 12th and was the meeting was live streamed and is recorded so there anything no it's the SAU governing board meetings is what you're looking for if you're interested that's what you need to look for so each one of these boards were the Hollis Brookline Co-op board the Hollis School District board and the Brookline School District board We Gather um four times a year quarterly um well technically not quarterly because it's but we gather four
085times a year as an entire 17 member board and we always present the budget at the December meeting in a public hearing great thank you want Eric Power westv Road Brookline I wanted to know how many people work how many employees we have in the SAU right now I've heard numbers of 17 18 19 I don't know 17 17 are those FTE or or people what the FTE or people people so everyone's fulltime no so which is which is we have 19 people so 18 and a half people 18 and a half people yeah are is they is there going to be uh an assistant superintendent hired or has there been one hired uh we are in the interviewing process and we intend to hire you intend to replace that okay um I get concerned
086about the SAU budget it keeps going up and up rapidly I do know the process works the there's a vote by the SAU board and I used to be a school board member so I used to vote on that when I was on the school board back in the 2014 to 2017 um I don't like the process because it doesn't give the voters a a lot of choice um with the adjusted budget the way it works and I would hope you know every time that the SAU board spends the money on the administration that's less money that we can pay teachers and the and use in the school districts and I think you know you look at you know we have I don't know how many kids 2,000 some kids in the whole SAU between
087the three school districts and we're spending $2.4 million on this SAU office that's my last calculation it's $ 122 or $1,300 for every student K to 12 that we're paying for this SAU office are we really getting the value that we need from this um this structure and I'm I I I don't think so that's my perspective um not a lot we can do the die gets cast on this mostly in December you have a chance at an adjusted budget I get to vote twice on it Brookline and in the co-op but um I just don't like how fast this goes up this is a this is a big problem I think in in the budget Rising is this this year we don't have that because we have a superintendent who's highly paid retiring but
088it's going to it's something we need to keep an eye on in future years whoever's on the school board thank you time thank you right pretty okay seeing no other um seeing no one else rise for um public input on Art the SAU budget we'll move on to uh article six for the facilities maintenance Expendable trust to see if the school dist district will vote to raise an appropriate up to the sum of $300,000 to be added to the previously established School building and Facilities maintenance Expendable trust the sum to come from the hall Brookline Cooperative school districts June 30 2025 unassigned fund balance available on July 1st 2025 majority vote required positions will be taken later um since this item is being funded through um um unassigned fund balance you would be foregoing a
089um tax reduction of s cents per thousand in Hollis and 11 cents per thousand in Brook line um for the fund utilization on that's projected for FY 26 we have $158,000 uh currently in the Expendable trust um it's there in case there are you know emergency repairs and things like that that are needed um in addition to as you see um the first item listed for hbhs is year two for an elevator so that 158,000 includes savings from last uh the current year in addition to an anticipated $68,000 um and uh method of saving for what's expected to be a very expensive elevator replacement project so we um have money um as I said in that balance and are anticipating putting an additional $68,000 aside to be able to fund that project later we will
090be paying for Phase 10 of the hbhs roof which I believe is the last phase for the roof placement so that's for the high school so that's been 10 years that we've been or actually 11 or 12 because um during covid we shifted um and I believe didn't do one of the phases so it's been at least a decade that we've been replacing the roof um at hollbrook line high school and we'll be doing a $150,000 um roof section at the middle school and that would uh leave an ending balance of $16,692.34 this sum to come from the unassigned fund balance available on July 1st 2025 and no amount to be raised from taxation any appropriation left at the end of the school year will lapse to the general fund majority vote required both uh
091board and committee will take their positions later this would is another um area where you would be foregoing a tax rate reduction of three cents per thousand in hollus and 5 cents for book line um this contingency article has been put forward for several years um it started before we were able to um retain funds through a retain fund balance uh this is where school districts and towns differ when towns underrun a budget they are permitted to um hold anything um that they've underrun the budget by and include that in an unreserved fund balance that does not lapse school districts don't have that opportunity so between the $125,000 for this contingency which does lapse so if we don't don't use any of it it does get returned to the taxpayer on an annual basis or
092in you it moves to the unreserved fund balance and what we do is pretty much reallocate it annually um school districts also don't have an opportunity to re retain all of the um amount that they may underrun a budget by so there is specific article language and legislation that allows the district to retain a portion of its District assessment um the language is changed to allow a 5% Max maximum that is it's not related to this contingency article this District does not have maximum funding for that retained fund balance um and that part of the reason why this um contingency article is put forward in the amount of $125,000 annually seeing uh is there any input on the contingency article Eric Power westf Road Brookline um I want to know how much we get to
093retain dollar amount in the retain fund balance per the current authorization that we get each year what's the maximum so we're allowed a maximum of 2.5% of the district assessment so the amount does literally change every single year it is approximately $500,000 but that's not the amount that the board sets aside there is a um uh a motion made by the board annually to determine that amount and I think this year it's at 340 so it's signif it's it's under the maximum at this point so very good given it's up to 500,000 is it really necessary to have this other $125,000 when you already get the put in half a million dollars uh from year to year that seems to be quite a bit of money that could be returned to the taxpayers so I
094would say the board on a consistent basis underfunds the retained fund balance and this is another opportunity to help balance that yeah I'm not really I'm not really in favor of this article because I think it's a lot of money and taxpayers can use the relief that they um they can we already have the retain fund balance to be able to save half a million dollars do we need to have another 125 that could go back to the taxpayers I think that makes a lot of sense I can speak to that just really quickly I think one of the decisions we make by underfunding the reserved fund balance retained fund balance is to allow the taxpayers this choice I think we try to work very transparently and this is up to the taxpayers so it
095gives them the opportunity to make that decision instead of us so that's why we put it forth thank you I appreciate that and the voters get to Cho CH whether we want to do this or not absolutely that's why it's here but the other aspect is when it gets funded because with the Warren article you know how the funding comes out of retain fund balance this now gets gets put in because what's left over at the end of the year is sort of speculative so it's two two ways to take from the same pot this is sort of like a default becomes like a default minimum and then how we what we have used and what we have available gets brought into the conversation on what choose to then do with the authorized up to
096two and a half percent so they're taken in concert but this by being authorized becomes a a first cut at it so when there's the UN the unreserved fund balance at the end of the year if this passes at the the district meeting you would do 125,000 then it's your option to go up to another 500,000 and you choose that we have had it and it they sort of roll over on each other right thank you thank you drew Mason Baxter wrote Hollis I know that I seem to recall that the Hollis School District spend a lot of time agonizing over special ed and funding Reserve funding for it how is that handled at the co-op because it doesn't seem to be showing up here we we do have um a similar fund as Hollis
097has a special education trust fund it's fully funded at this point so we're not putting forward an article to add additional funding for it great thank you seeing no one no other um questions with regard to the article I'll close um the public input um the public hearing on um the first seven articles of the warrant at uh 7:54 p.m. and that gets handed over to us so um I'm going to open a public hearing for the petition warrant articles at what was it 75 754 7 7:54 p.m. we're following the same rules same structure that we've been following um the only difference is we won't be presenting on these petition more articles um these are our articles they came to us by petition um if there's someone who's speaking to them they're welcome to
098make a presentation tonight um so is it a presentation or just public input well it's actually a little bit longer than public input because of you know we're allowing the but who who's the petitioner that's a good question but we're going to allow the a petitioner to come up and speak to the public to the petition war in articles for however long they need five five to six minutes yeah yeah I just wonder I'm just wondering how you how you determine who's the petitioner so we've changed the rules for the annual district meeting and we're not allowing presentations from the the moderator is not allowing presentations but one of the things that the moderator asked the school board in our public meeting in October was to make sure that we gave people an opportunity to
099present information at this public hearing so we are doing that tonight I understand that but are they presenting it as petitioners or are they presenting it as members of the public who are in support of it um because that way more people can talk they won know one person one person's going to present okay so um first petition warn article article 8 shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 colon 5 5-b requiring that the annual budget and all special warrant articles having a tax impact as determined by the school board shall contain notation stating the estimated tax impact of the article the determination of the estimated tax impact shall be subject to approval by the governing body is there a person from the petition that wants to speak on this and present no yes
100try to limit to five minutes I'm but thank you uh Eric Power westf Road in Brookline and I definitely support this uh warrn article this Warren article is basically about transparency and making it more available to have the information on the tax impact for uh voters so some voters believe it or not they'll look at a um warrant and they'll they'll just make a decision just looking at the warrant do I go to the meeting or not um and by having that tax impact on the warrant in one place it makes a big difference so that people know the magnitude of what's being voted upon at the meeting um it's really I think an important thing so the idea would be able to put you know and in our case we have a co-op so
101there's the tax impact is not equal between Hollis and Brookline so you would expect to have a notation if there's a tax impact it would be so many dollars per thousand in Brook line and so many dollars and cents per thousand in hollus and that would be put on each warrant article um and it would be approved by the governing body which is the school board and in that case that lets people know very transparently how much it's going to cost and I realize that this information may be available today at this hearing there's not a lot of people here um and it may be available at the district meeting but people are busy people and having this uh ability to have the uh the tax impact on every warn article I I think goes
102a long way to having people understand what they're going to be spending on their tax bill they complain about that you know in Brooklyn the co-op is the biggest piece of the tax property taxes for us um and that a lot of people want to know how do we get there and how much is it cost what where is all this money being spent so if they have that uh on the warrant they they can see where it is and it may even motivate people to be more involved by having it um um we've had this uh waren article passed in the Brookline School District and we use it there and people are very appreciative of it uh we we passed this same warn article in our Brookline town meeting last year because people want
103to know how much they're spending um there's actually some legislation this year to make it mandatory we don't know if that's going to become law or not but um in the in any case I think it's really important that you know for transparency that people can look at the warrant and see that information it's not a whole lot of information and people complain a little bit well it could change well everything can change so having at least an estimate there it's not going to be off by a lot hopefully um it should be pretty accurate and with consultation with the budget committee I think it's a very wise thing to inform voters and get people to understand how much they're going to be spending when they're uh at the meeting and also ahead of the
104meeting and sometimes people can only go to certain parts of the meeting so they would they would be able to prioritize what they're going to be voting on so for those reasons I urge the uh school board and the budget committee to recommend this article to the uh District meeting thank you thank you is there any other comments okay seeing no one rise I'm going to close the floor for public comment on petition article number eight at 8 okay so I'd like to refer petition War an article number n to our attorney Mr oan do you need me to read it or are you good no it's fine it's it's written here um I can read it is it up yeah okay um so I was asked by the board to provide um a actually
105asked to review the warrant every year and um inheriting that request is is an analysis of the legality of the warrant articles and their writing and in particular um I usually the petition or articles to ensure that there's nothing um procedurally irregular or problematic um when I reviewed um this petition waren article I was uh it's a it's a new thing I'm it's not very common for districts to have um requests to form Charter commissions on warrants so I I looked at it and I said oh that's new and I took some time to review the statute um and look at what the requirements are for for what they call a home World Charter um under RSA 49b um after reviewing that in uh that process and reviewing the petition um I was able to
106determine that under the law the petitioners didn't actually follow the appropriate procedure under the under state law admittedly um RSA 49b and the process for uh establishing a charter commission is complicated it's a kind of an Arcane law um I have some familiarity with it because i' I've worked on Charter I've advised Charter Commissions in the past um so in a nutshell I'll just kind of go through the history a little bit and give you a quick synopsis um the law that governs the establishment of a charter commission um is really RSA 1975b and it authorizes the the school district to establish a home Rule Charter um by following the procedure set forth in RSA 49b I know it's going to sound a lot numbers and legally gobbly C but it does make sense um
107the procedures in 49b are are really the the the requirements for establishing a charter commission um the statute says that upon the written Petition of 25 or more voters the school board the municipal officers of school board must submit the question of establishment of a charter commission to the voters as provided in this section there are several requirements in the statute first the petitioners must submit a petition to the school board that contains the following prescribed language so this is the part where um unlike a normal petition Warren article when you're establishing a charter petition there has to be a specific Charter uh petition form that is supposed to say and the law says the petition shall read substantially as follows quote each of the understein voters request the municipal officers to submit to the
108voters at the next municipal election the question of establishment of a commission to a dra to draft a municipal Charter um the specific statutory provision is RSA 49 V3 Roman numeral to the petition must be submitted by December 15th of the preceding year for school districts with an annual meeting in March and finally if the board receives a petition under two using that language the board is required by law to place the question of establishment of a charter Commission on the next B using that language so there's a big step that was missed here um and so accordingly the petition Warren article submitted by 45 um signers on December 2nd was not quote in substantially the same form uh as the mandatory language in 49 b32 um they submitted a traditional petition using the language
109of the actual ballot question that the board was supposed to place on the warrant after the board received the the proper form um uh this is a uh procedural I think this is a material procedural defect so um the petition itself is not legally valid um I know this is a tough spot to be in 99 out of 100 times I get a call or I review a warrant all across New Hampshire and the the general rule is um unless there's something uh significantly illegal you don't put a petition warrant article on a warrant um this petition warrant article is legally defective because the petition wasn't submitted properly um uh the Supreme Court has held that when adoption of proposed article has no legal validity the board um is not uhu it's not improper for
110the or inappropriate for the board to refuse to insert it on the warrant um it's not it's not really I don't think just a proor issue because the specific language demonstrates that the petitioners when they signed the petition understood that they were directing the governing body to submit to the voters at the next municipal election the question of a charter commission to quote draft a municipal Charter that that intention isn't clear here so when they signed the petition they weren't signing language that said they understood that was what they were asking the board to do um the legislature mandated this language using substantially as follows language and it is a fundamental part of the process of establishing the charter commission um I want to say this isn't you know when you're looking at procedural defects
111uh there are minor procedural defects and material procedural defects this is not what I view to be a a minor I think this is substantive because the language prescribed in the statute and the language in thetion um are very different there are two key differences here I know I'm going into detail but I this is kind of a novel thing um first the petition language up there is not reference that the question will be placed on the ballot in March which is a requirement for the petitioners when they submit it to the board and second it doesn't say that the purpose of the charter commission is to draft a municipal Charter um that's not up there either so I I think material it's actually significant um so um given those differences the petition Warren article
112does not demonstrate that the that the 45 signers clearly understood what they were directing the governing body to do um so that's kind of my legal opinion on that and I'm happy to answer questions if necessary short the way this is word what I saw there is establishing official ballot voting that's language that's very similar to S SP2 language is is this another way of creating sb2 yeah I mean I could back way up and and sort of talk about charters in general um towns have a choice where they can adopt um different kinds of Charters school districts have the ability to adopt one kind of Charter um and really it's it's an option for determining um which votes will be submitted by official ballot like an SP2 District like which issues which articles versus
113which articles will be discussed um deliberated and voted on at the annual meeting so it allows a commission to kind of bifurcate itself rather than sb2 which gives you a choice of either or you can pick some that are voted on by ballot pick some that are voted on at the annual meeting and there's a lot more you can do the so if some if if a community voted to have SP2 and also voted to have a charter who wins they're different forms of government you pick you can't have both at the same time but but it sounds like by petition you can both can be requested on the same ballot well then it's just like having multiple petitions on the same subject but what if they both pass well then you have to scratch
114your head and you talk talk to the lawyer so I'm just wondering is there a hierarchy when you talk to the lawyer this is irrelevant 49 4 see if they suggest which one is is a priority article but to to my mind if these pass all that's passing right if this was a properly petition or an article and it were on the ballot and they both pass you'd have sb2 established for however long it's established then you'd have a charter commission established to potentially draft a charter to put before the voters if that Charter were to pass it would supersede se2 that's how that work re the reason I say says for the sole purpose of establishing official ballot I'm what I'm getting at is what would someone who just read that think they're voting
115on because because you're the reason for rejecting it or saying it's it's not subst no the reason for ejecting it is not um because this isn't the proper form of the question that is ultimately presented to the voters this is the statutory language of a warrant article to ask about the establishment of a charter the reason it's not valid is because the petitioners have to sign a specific kind of petition with specifically prescribed language in order to trigger the board's obligation to put this language on the ballot it's a two-step process it's not typical petition or an article I would understand how anybody would get confused by that because it's not like spelled out super clearly you have to kind of read it a couple of times to understand what is requiring but that's the
116that's the process so if we were to allow this to continue to exist puts the board at risk doesn't it for putting something forward that's inappropriate well that's all I mean ultimately in my opinion which I can share with the board um I I my position is the board is expected and required to follow procedures in law um it it you got to follow the law if the process for petitioning wasn't properly submitted it's not valid you don't put it on the warrant um I think of course if you don't follow the law someone else will come in and say why aren't you following the law the other question it always raises whenever I'm doing an annual meeting I don't like to influence the outcome of votes but when you got a question like this
117that's presented and it wasn't validly petitioned what is the legal effect of this passing I I don't know like it it creates really an open question question and open questions like this create liability and risk so so you're advising us to remove it from the from the from the warrant how do we do that do we need to vote to do that or do we just it's your warrant so I don't know what the school board votes I know let me let me answer the question the sorry the what what status is the warrant in right now we're having a public hearing and then we have have you voted to finalize the warrant and signed in vot no we did not so still it's a it's a work in progress yeah so the final version
118of the warrant would not have that article and that's the warrant you would sign test and discuss at theual meeting okay so we'll talk about it when we get into deliberations I have copies to share with theard is there any public input on this um do we know when this article was submitted yeah it said it said December okay yeah met the timeline like that's presumably why that that they were submitted so early this year I think we were all wondering oh this is early great um it was in time it just wasn't the right process let me ask this question which is evidently hypothetical well at this point we're we're done like we we were not we're we're not we're going to move on from this one yeah okay article 10 I know what
119to do petition War article 10 shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 40 colon 13 known as sb2 to allow official B ballot voting on all issues before the Hollis Brookland Cooperative School District on the 2 Tuesday of March question mark 60 60% majority vote required sorry I was that question mark through me okay at this point I'll open the floor for public comment on petition war and article 10 Tony steny 2011 South M Road and Hollis um I look at this as a political issue and not a budgetary issue and I'm not sure if the board should be voting on a political issue there's no dollars attached to this this is not a budget AR item and I would believe it's very important to not take a position on this and I may be
120incorrect but this is just kind of an observation I'm making if please comment and correct me on this if I'm if I'm wrong you generally do take a position on this you do yes we have you have but I'm asking if that's appropriate to just not take a position so the budget committee doesn't normally take a position we take a position on it because it impacts how we govern so okay fair enough thank you do I since this isn't a Schoolboard article do I make my comments now as a member of the public or do I do it during Del Liberation it's really up to you we are going to take a position so you can take a if you'd like to make a comment as a member of the public you can you can
121also make a comment as a Schoolboard member as well there you Goot twice but you only get two minutes you only get two minutes Tom at the microphone man we are actually actually start right now you have a minute and 35 seconds time has expired Tom soul on Shady Rock Road Brookline New Hampshire uh I just want to point out to people that the current uh Warren article that we have for the co-op has something that's really unique and powerful and that is we have a budget that includes an amount in it and we have a warrant article to to fund something with an extended pay period and the option of approving the first article to bond something and then going into the budget and changing the budget accordingly and pull that amount out as
122you may hear during deliberation or you've heard before we had to put the money into the budget to cover the musthave which was $915,000 to do absolutely necessary repairs to the heating system in the middle school but by incorporating that into the larger Bond we save money we dramatically drop the cost of next year's budget and the overall tax impact and we have the ability to pull that out in an SP2 environment you don't have that so what you'd have to do is have the budget with the full amount in it to cover what was there and the warrant article to fund the what I consider more fiscally appropriate way of funding the HVAC improvements for the middle school and you want both of them to pass then you've got an extra million dollars you
123got to pay for that year with a hope that it doesn't get spent someplace else SP2 does not leave you the option to have that flexibility that to me is a real graphic illustration of uh why SP2 was not great for us thank you thank you John very nice Eric power Brookline westf Road uh I did sign this petition um we've heard about SP2 SP2 before um it is uh something we use in our Brookline School District and I think it's been successful uh I think one of the major things that people don't like about traditional meeting is it really doesn't let everybody come because yeah everybody can come but people have life things that happen people have you know sometimes a parents somebody's got to stay home with the kids so only one of
124the two parents can participate the other one can't vote you have people that are disabled people that can't uh drive at night you have people that serve in the military as I did for many years and I miss meetings because of that you have uh people that travel for work you have people that um work second shift um we have we have people that you know work for fire departments we have nurses there's a lot of people that get disenfranchised by this annual meeting system that we have now so sb2 provides you get the deliberative session where you actually debate the Articles and get them ready for the ballot and then you have your all day ballot voting where people get to vote on all the warant articles on Election Day which is very powerful
125and you get a lot more people voting on the uh on on the ballot than you do at a meeting at a co-op meeting we're usually in the three maybe 5% range but in in hollison in Brookline we are usually in the 20 to 25% range where people turn out and vote so when you have more people participating there's more buying people feel like they have their say but if you can't make it to this a traditional meeting you don't have that say um also in the all day voting you have absentee voting available and that's not available with the with the annual meeting you can't if you're not there you don't have a say so that's a big problem um so you know it it this does um this is a very good system
126I think that you know every every article that you have on the warrant also gets voted upon which is another advantage and it gives you all day voting and we sometimes have done all day voting for certain warant articles but it is it is a little bit challenging but it is sometimes what we have to do but it makes you extend your meeting um in order to do that so the the idea about sb2 there might be people watching at home um trying to understand it we've talked about it a few different years and there's a lot of interest in in passing sb2 it's not a perfect system but I think it's a better system than we have today with the annual meeting because I think more people can actually participate and they're not disenfranchised
127and that's the primary thing I think it it it brings forth to the to the voters and I think it also gives people a chance to fact check um between the deliberative session you have at least 30 days to look at what is on the ballot and you have a chance to talk to others you have time to deliberate it you don't have to make a vote in In the Heat of the Moment In order to determine what you want to vote on so I think it it's it's a lot more um it's a more modern process for today's busy world than the uh annual meeting that that can and our annual meetings take a long time deliberative sessions are a lot faster uh our meetings last many hours and sometimes many days and uh
128so I think if we went to sb2 that would be a different story I think that we'd have more participation in a deliberative session and I think we'd have definitely have more people voting so for those reasons I hope the school board votes to recommend adoption of SP2 for the holl Brooklyn Cooperative School District thank you thank you there any other comments seeing none I'm going to close the public comment for um petition War article 10 at 8:21 move on to petition War article 11 shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 colon 5-d and Implement a budget cap whereby the school board or budget committee shall not submit recommended budget that is higher than $27,000 per pupil cost times the average daily membership in residents of the school district as of October 1st of
129the year immediately preceding the pro proposed budget year plus an annual increase for inflation using cpi-u for the Boston Cambridge Newton Mass New Hampshire area published by the US B Bureau of Labor Statistics as of January 1 requires a 35th majority of the school district um I will open the floor for public comment there's someone who wants to speak to this Eric Power westre Road Brook line again um this petition warn article talks about adopting a School District budget cap it's a new law that was passed last year I think it went into effect in October and it basically um in the case now that we have a budget committee this is statutory language um this the budget committee is the one that gets limited on what they can uh recommend and basically what it
130does is it puts a cap on the spending and it's per student that you have in your District based on uh average daily membership and residence and what what the way you figure out your cap is that you take that a you take that $27,000 and you multiply by your average daily membership from the the October 1 number reported to the Department of Education and that's your cap and once you have that cap then you uh hopefully stay under the cap in in what you propose but at the meeting the voters can always override the cap every tax cap and budget cap in New Hampshire has to have an override mechanism so if you want to override the budget cap that year with a three-fifths vote you can exceed the budget cap for any warrant
131article that you that needs to be over that 35th over that budget cap for that year and um then you proceed to the next year you adjust based on CPU the local CPI you adjust the $27,000 figure to account for inflation and you look at your new uh number for average daily membership you multiply those and that becomes your budget cap for the following year same process is repeated year to year so the whole idea of a School District budget cap is to provide some guidance to the budget committee and the school board uh on achieving a budget that's reasonable and inflation based for the voters and the families of Hollis and Brookline um I think it's a very reasonable uh uh piece of legislation it's enabling legislation that we should adopt $27,000 is higher
132than we're spending right now so it it does give some Headroom and I think it's a very reasonable uh metric to instead of having no limits and no guidance on the maximum that we spend I think it makes a lot of sense I think it's going to resonate with voters and I'm I'm happy that it's forward this year because I think it's it's an important um limit that you can put on on the on the budgeting process leading into it that way you're not having to take a budget that's high and have to reduce it at the annual meeting so it's um I think it's going to be a popular uh popular thing this year and I hope that folks consider it seriously and um for those reasons I hope that the the school board
133votes to and the budget committee both uh both recommend this Common Sense article to uh lead to inflation based sustainable spending instead of the spending we've been seing seeing that's been more it's averag more than double the rate of inflation and that's not good for taxpayers people are being taxed out of their homes this will be a solu ution to that it makes the changes slowly over time and I think it would be be a very positive um thing for the school district to adopt thank you very much is there anyone else seeing no other people rising we are going to close the I have a question for attorney sure Jim um a couple thoughts one is and I don't know if if the petitioner is able to answer there's a if there's a lead
134petitioner if if Eric can answer the question or not um but the $27,000 per pupil I know in the prescribed language in the statute it it leaves a blank um the statute itself um says that the tax is calculated using the current per pupil cost um times average daily membership um the legislature didn't I guess think it was uh prudent to Define per pup cost that's odd to me um because that isn't a number that everyone understands um to me that has to mean the per pupil cost calculated every year by the Department of Education um to me the blank in the statute unless I'm wrong and there's some legislative history there the number that you plug into that blank is the current perable cost that's how you get the process started I suspect it's
135less than 2017 ,000 uh but I don't but to me it's like I don't really care either way I just don't know if you put that up there and it's not $27,000 and it's the doe number deceiving it's just weird and I don't know if it's dece it may be deceiving voters may think oh 27,000 is great and the drra may say you don't get to dictate that that's the state number so that issue somehow has to get resolved before the ballot and I don't I I'm not I I didn't write the law and I'm not a court so um I don't know what the fix is for that I'm just saying this presents a problem going into the meeting and I always try to do my best to figure out how to solve those
136issues for the voters I don't know what the solution is here that's one issue I just wanted to raise that the board should be aware of there's another thing um uh I think that's really it for that one that's really the biggest so that number is not accurate the 27,000 like can't be in there very deceiving to me it's not the right number I think the right number is whatever your current per pupil cost is as determined by the Department of Education but the board can't amend a petition no the legislative body can I suspect it'll it'll come up and then someone will ask for that number and potentially try to amend it and the legislated body can amend and it can amend this article and I don't have a ton of ibility but there
137are it is amendable I'll I'll give it I'll allow it sure judge and jury over here my my understanding of this uh legislation is that it's uh any number can be selected by the school board or in this case petitioners it doesn't have to be the number that's the current number it can be any number it can be higher it can be lower it's just there's a blank for the number of dollars you put in there and there's nothing in the statute saying it has to use Doe's number um it's just the figure that that the that whoever is putting this article forward thinks is appropriate and would be something that would be acceptable to the voters that's my understanding of the legislative intent okay so I so I guess I just have a question
138uh this for the the attorney or Jim Mr oan um so reference to 325d is an inappropriate RSA reference I think 325d is the statute that enables you to adopt a cap 325e is the section that is the process for it's actually e andf okay it's e andf now all right I'm looking at the I'm looking at the U the chapter law so that reference needs to be fix so this is from gen Court yeah that's the more yeah you're right um I have that notation I'm looking at the old chapter law so when they actually cified it effective October first the I wanted I can put it I can mention something about that her finish you're right so my question to Mr oesi is when looking at F it clearly stipulates um shall we
139adopt the provisions of our this uh the wording of the question shall be shall we adopt the provisions of 325e so on and so forth um where you would not submit a recommended budget that is higher than blank dollars per pupil cost and so on and so forth and referring back to 35e 325e is the place where the notation is made in the law that says shall not exceed the current per pupil cost so that looks to me that it's reinforcing the suggestion that you made do you want to read this um I'm yeah I can also pull it up on my phone y ultimately though ultimately though it doesn't I mean we can we can debate this but the the truth of the matter is is that this will you you're not advising us
140to remove this so instead this is all information that needs to be provided to the voters so that they have Clarity at the meeting but we can't do anything a minor this is a minor technical thing that can be amended that the that the voters absolutely should amend because if they don't again it's like the wrong reference um so it's really important that you're there or one of your you know yes but more than that it's more than that yes because right from what Darlene brought up the dollar amount can't be more than something right the question I have based on what she read is and this I'm not trying to be fous is it like Capital per pupil cost or I do they does the law leave it open to defining per pupil cost
141or do you have to use the state's definition that that's the question we ask legal council because it is defined by the state of New Hampshire and every single District gets a per pupil cost right so all of a sudden anyone who just is developing a number it's like where does it come from so that $27,000 doeses not at all relate to the per call cost for the holl brook line Co-op but if we wanted it to be let's say the doe calculation is 21750 y and we said okay we want to set our cap at 27,000 using that process does the law allow it allow that well you're catching up to my original conversation which is like that's what he said like so so there's an issue when you're a lawyer right like at
142some point what you're doing is you're trying to figure out what a court is going to say if I brought this to them and and in the context of an annual meeting I'm trying to figure out if this passes as worded what is the Dr G to say um they're going to kind of be like they don't know they're going to send it to their lawyers their lawyers are going to say let's look at legislative history it's often very hard to determine the meaning of a law based on legislative intent sometimes you can sometimes you can't you're basing it on what people said in hearings with the um what the proponents of the bill said when it was in hearings um at the end of the day I'm guessing what about what a Court's going
143to do but I'm not a court and only courts decide what the law says and is and means so I'm kind of going into this like I I'd love it if it was really clear um and I can tell you there are a number of places where pure people per pupil cost is defined um it's in the charter law it defines per people cost I don't I don't have a good answer for you I will try to get a good one uh when I come to the meeting because I don't want to stand up there and say I'm a lawyer and I don't have a good answer for you but but sometimes like that has to be the way it is the other thing I was going to ask IND is like admr um average
144daily membership in residents where does that number come from it's it's kind of a rhetorical question you asked me to Define it it's defined two different places in the law those definitions aren't actually when you like when you really scrutinize those definitions even those aren't internally consistent because they use the term approved charter school and I'm not sure if that means School District approv charter school or state do we approve charter school it's it's a brand new law and it's it's not good or bad I'm not judging the law it's brand new and there are some things that need to sorted out with the law it's not perfect there there are inconsistencies and issues so it's we're stuck with it so we'll have to figure it out I think we're I think that's where we
145have to come to I think we have to come to the point where you know the school board will take a position on it it'll get presented to the voters you'll be there to say some version of what you just said so that voters understand that there's ambig ambiguity in this if this passes consequences significant uity yes Drew as the moderator I will be very clear that I will invite an amendment from the floor to fix the language so that it matches the current language in the law I think the problem is no one really knows what the language in the law actually means is that what I'm getting the sense of like we're not sure whether you can just plug in $27,000 or you have to use the Doe's number for we don't know
146what number is supposed to go in there so we'll try to get some clarity on that before the meeting but the language in the law doesn't talk about that it talks it sounds like there were places the language in the law is this is the language in the law and and the only thing it is that's in the prescribed language is see where it says $27,000 that's a blank it's a line okay so it's like well it's inviting something to be placed there as a placeholder and I don't know what the thing is because yes because for any District the cost for pupil would be different so with sign a number to it is like assigning in legislation like how they determine adequacy they assign a cost that get assigned to everybody but every district
147has a different cost per pupil so where did this number of 27,000 come from the writer from the petitioner oh pull it okay all right but you know as a as a reminder I think I mentioned before when I presented the cost per pupil chart the doe calculated cost per pupil removes certain elements of the budget so it doesn't really uh equal what our budget is for the district Chris did you have a question so I guess is the fear because it's blank is the fear that the Dr is thinking it's going to be the state number and so we adopt this and we adopt it based on the 27,000 and they come back and say well we don't know where that number came from we're going to ass sign this number so therefore your
148budget needs to be a lot lower exactly yeah than you assumed it was going to be based on is that what I'm understanding yeah so when I'm talking to voters right at the meeting like my overarching goal is to try to make sure that everyone in the room like understands the uh the effect of what they're doing and so what I can't guarantee now without much more information which I may not be able to really get U maybe there is maybe there's some some clear legislative history if it says 27,000 I'm not sure what the Dr is going to say but that creates a problem because if people are voting based on the expectation that it's 27,000 and it's actually not it's not transparent it's not it's not transparent like I they're not they don't
149know what the effect of what they're doing will be we have somebody else Dre yeah are you good your name restate your name and address for us yes ma'am Aaron hubard 90more Hill Road Hollis you um I I guess I'm curious about what happens in five years with this law if it stays on with this warrant article if it stays on the books so 20 $700 whatever the number might be that some yeah whatever number the petitioner puts in there that's static and isn't movable so in five years if there's increased costs for supplies texbooks computers we're still going to be stuck with $27,000 so it seems to me that it makes sense for it to be based on the other option that the lawyer mentioned so just I'm curious am I reading that right
150change so no it's yes so just to be clear what happens is um you when this passes it sets the initial amount then in subsequent years the the amount changes based on um that becomes the new base right and then it it it changes based on inflation and oh yeah there you go and it changes based on changes in your admr so if you go up a certain percentage over the prior year you get to that multip gets added so that number changes right now we're talking about if it passes what's the starting year amount and then it and then from then on it just keeps changing yeah but it isn't it isn't the the per that dollar figure that changes it's the admr inflation and the inflation because it's it's sujus yeah it's got
151this it's got the annual GP y okay so it's not static actually okay all right um I have a question I think we'll oh sorry I know you know what everybody else has asked questions go ahead R it's your big one the concern that I have is that we're going to get into a do Loop uh situation at the uh a district meeting and people will want to change the number back and forth maybe several times and we may end up being four five six hours or maybe multiple days trying to come up with a number so I second your concern so so my question is because as written with a faulty number there is a defect in what what I'm seeing is it possible that maybe we shouldn't even consider it at all eliminate
152from the list I don't know that we have that option so I I feel like we're really careful not to do that and we have this one exception in article nine and um I just you know my opinion and I can't speak for the whole board is that um this is a petition War an article it has an issue we've had this before where petition warant articles have legal concerns and we just address it at the meeting to the voters am I afraid of what you're afraid of yeah sure I don't want to see that happen but I don't know what else to do I mean these are this is one of the concerns with the petition warn article like people will might amend it try to amend it three times I don't know what'll
153happen so it's a it's just to keep a couple things make sure if I say something like that doesn't sound right let me know it's getting late um it's a three- fifths vote and it's secret ballot vote it it doesn't go to the official ballot because you're not an sb2 District right so in our the the kind of like the stuff that can like you're you have some control over what transpires to some degree and I know you know there's other things that can happen does it say it's a required secret ballot no it say yes it does it's by ballot it's by that the polls have to be open the every cycle could last one and a half to two hours this has to be a secret ballot oh God yeah the the the
154law just says byy ballot but not by official ballot and when they say by ballot that means secret ballot that's just what we call it so sometimes you call it yes no ballot can iest one more question this is article 11 our budget is article three if our budget passes the go ahead go ahead and ask your question this no doesn't take do you want this back so sorry so article three our budget would pass so this would not be relev for this year till next year J J have one more question what year for January 1 since this is a this is a brand new law is it January the just 25 is it 24 it doesn't specify what you good question Andy that's why he makes a big bu did you have a
155comment I mean the the issue is right so let me just present that articulate at the time you're voting on this will the Janu or you're preparing your budget like will the January 1 rate of inflation be known or do you use the preceding the prior years you go back like 12 months 12 months to get that years and and I think maybe it's an easy easy answer and we're just not um but this is New Again legislature said January 1 what do they have in mind I don't know if someone has the answer I don't have the answer okay so okay I don't either um Alyssa rasmon Brooklyn New Hampshire or one went to Ray Road sorry first time um if we were under sb2 what would happen to something like this where we
156were just vo you would debate and discuss and and potentially amend and do all that stuff and then whatever version you ended up with you could you can amend it 10 times over at deliberative whatever you ended it up with would would go to the official ballot and on the second Tuesday in March you you'd vote on whether to approve it and it would still need a three- majority to pass so you'd have to try to make sense of this only at the deliberative session and then whatever they come up with goes on the ballot yes so people are voting on what they don't necessarily understand and what we don't understand right okay ex that's the reason that I don't support sb2 and anybody thinking about it Most states or most towns that have done
157it regret it so I just wanted to bring that up just one one more question Jim based on that at Del liberative session or annual meeting that number can go up or down which number the 27,000 yeah so but but the but only if we're reading the that the cost per pupil defined by the state is not what we're using so we could we could move that to 50,000 could have listen like to to kind of take that to like a total absurd place not absurd be there till 2 in the morning amending this come up with a magic number that everybody likes 3 whatever 3 F vote it's going to take a lot and then the Dr could say that was all waste of time it's the per people cost by Statute that's what
158I'm going to try to head off before we get there in March but I I I don't know I don't know if I'll get there so I appreciate do we have anything else I appreciate all the feedback um we'll just move forward please um article 12 petition War article uh is that the one that's up there that's a different one sorry shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 colon 5-b and implemented tax cap whereby the governing body or budget committee shall not submit a recommended budget that increases the amount to be raised by local taxes this year's base that is higher than the prior fiscal Year's actual amount of local taxes raised last year's base adjusted for inflation using the inflation index cpi-u for the Boston Cambridge Newton Mass New Hampshire area published by
159the US bu Bureau of Labor Statistics and the change in attendance in accordance with the RSA 32 5-b 1B 1-b um I'm going to open the floor for public comment every one them right Eric Power westv Road Brook line um I did sign this petition as well this petition is a local tax cap that uh is RSA 325b so the actual new new law another new law that passed is that it allows the tax cap instead of adjusting by a fixed dollar amount or a fixed percentage let you do one based on um an inflation index that you choose and this case the CPI was chosen so the way the local tax cap works it's really the previous one was a budget cap which is on total Appropriations the tax cap is actually on the
160tax effort so the tax effort as we uh the budget committee had talked about that's your total Appropriations minus your estimated revenues and if you have a fund balance you bring that forward uh as an adjustment and you have to keep your proposed budget total all the Appropriations underneath the tax cap um and this one is based on the base from the previous year so whatever you had from the previous year you multiply by the inflation index and then that becomes your tax uh local tax cap for the current year um this is little it's similar but different than the School District budget cap because it is based on tax effort and the other thing that's different about this the local tax cap it it gets overridden by a simple majority so right now the
161the School District budget cap had a three- fifths to override this can be overridden by a simple majority at the annual meeting but the starting point needs to be uh below what's recommended by the budget committee and the school board has to be below um what the tax cap is for that year so what's a little bit different I think in my reading of the law is that this resets every year so if you have a big increase that becomes your base for the following year and it follows inflation so the inflation is sort of the guidance for that year I do believe um that they use the inflation index from January 1 of the year so you have to kind of estimate it before you get to the meeting and when you get to
162the meeting in March or the budget hearing now you should have the number it becomes available um this time of the year and um that that would then uh give you you know how much money you could recommend so it's might be uh this law is a little bit older than the other although it has a new uh component to it I think again this provides some guidance that keeps the the tax rate from really going up more than by inflation if you don't if you don't exceed the tax cap then essentially you're going to be not increasing the Appropriations or the tax effort more than inflation so I think for those reasons it's it's a very logical um metric and logical piece of legislation to adopt I think it would provide some stability instead
163of getting eight nine 11% increases year toe you'll follow What's Happening by inflation and if the district decides to uh override that they they certainly have the flexibility so for those reasons I think this is a good uh good thing to consider you might prefer the School District budget cap you might prefer the local tax cap um you might prefer both so it's up to the voters to decide what they want so for those reasons I hope the school board and the budget committee both recommend this article thank you thanks is there anyone else seeing no one else Rising I'm going to there's nothing else I need to talk to Jim about that one um seeing no one else Rising I'm going to close the floor for public comment on petition article petition War article
16412 at um 85 50 and I'm going to close the public hearing at 8:50 p.m. and reconvene the school board I'll reconvene the budget committee um I think the first action the School Board needs to do is amend the the first article right first and second first and second so um I need a motion by a member to amend the the article one with the proposed language identifying the funding mechanism as bonds or notes move by Rob second second by Kate okay Christa I all right is there any conversation question about that it's to amend the article article one the proposed language identifying the funding mechanism as bonds or notes motioned yeah that's right correct yes it will be the language we discussed tonight okay any conversation okay all those in favor of amending article
165one to be bonds 60 motion carries um article two hey Holly yes point of order can I leave yes I have a point of order actually we take a position on the article as well we will but I'm going to amend the first two make the two amendments first and then go back then we're going to go back because I'd like to just have those amended if that's okay um I need a motion to amend article two with a proposed language identifying the funding mechanism as bonds or notes is it was it was it article three in this current one or we already we read it um well wait a second I have to amend article three with a proposed language identifying the funding mechanism as sponsor notes identify it as article two and rename
166renumber the remaining articles accordingly move moved by Rob second by Kate any discussion is Tom in the room I can't see him no he just went out with Jim okay well all those in favor 5 em motion carries we're not waiting for him sorry Tom I think we will wait till we another Tom we'll sell you this Tom okay okay so moving on you this time now we need to take positions so hold on I have to find that just give me a second I'm sorry I know we're all really tired you're doing since you're doing meing um do you want to consider the legal issue of number nine number eight nine no that was nine N I have it as n sorry I'm trying to find article one here in my stuff so I'm
167sorry but okay here we go hold on um I think can we do that as we get to can we that when we get to article 9 yeah hold on one second I just to are we going to reread all of these okay I didn't think so okay silly rabbit I do I do need you'll be doing it to an empty audience I need Tom to come back in the room because he wants to be on record we're going to run out of candy in a minute okay yeah going Tom for coffee he needs to come and take a position no sugar no meeting I'm gonna kill him no sorry you don't wow your mic's live is he coming thank you strike that from the record it's just a it was just a figure of
168speech I don't mean it serious Tom I need you to vote okay so article one I need a motion to recommend article one as presented mooved by Rob second second by Kate all those in favor of article one 60 that's the school board okay I'll take a motion um from the budget committee to move uh article one for the HM hbms energy conservation as written from Tom Henry second seconded by Dave um roll calls required Brian yes he's awake Matt yes Tom whan yes R yes yes Tom uh Dave Blen yes Tom Enright yes Tom Solon he's my father Yes Darlene votes yes that's 8 Z the budget committee recommends article one cor of Border when the uh can we ask questions after uh before we actually take a vote we probably vote we should
169probably like have have a moment for did you have any questions on the next one I do okay we'll make sure we do that so I need a motion to recommend article two as presented move by Rob second by Christa is there any discussion on this I didn't give you a chance last time so if you want you can discuss them both I don't care is there any discussion on this any advocacy anything go for it go for it okay all those in favor 60 School Board recommends this article okay motion from the budget committee to recommend article two the solar um energy conservation project as written question I have a question I know I want to bring it to the floor first R um motion by Dave seconded by Tom enight um are there
170any questions or discussion yeah so my question is when we started this effort sometime a long time ago we're going to have leases and under the leases we're going to be going perhaps a little over the $600,000 that has being retired with the existing bond now that we're going through a much cheaper approach has anybody calculated what that that number is because I want to make sure that the voters understand that we're not going to reach the $600,000 number and therefore they maybe it's going to there's going to be some amount of dollars that will be given back to the district these these two Arles are 500,000 toal right so I want to be able to highlight originally I was going to vote no but given that we done a good job and coming up
171with a different approach I'm going to support it but I want to make sure that we highlight the fact that we're really saving saving some amount of dollars as well okay so in the amortization schedules that I shared um and which aren't final they're estimated um the the bond payments do aren't level so with leases they were level funded and it was the exact same amount every year with the bonds they're not they do decrease slightly over time so I would without um what we will include at the March meeting is the overview of changes um you know we have the the half year interest payment then we move up to a full in principal and interest payment and then and then it starts to decline over time so once you reach that point those
172additional years aren't incremental to that first full year once You' hit that first full year that's your highest amount you'd be contributing and it goes down after that right so in that first year um hold on if I add we have three years of payments listed in this um presentation so I would say the um it it we originally had 660 in Combined between the two uh the first year is around 692 second Year's around 674 the third year is around 674 and it decreases after that so as you're getting out to year um 15 one is for 15 years one's for 20 so the last five years will only be a$ 400,000 payment and the other one will because 200,000 comes off so you see where it it might be a little bit higher
173at the beginning but it especially after year 15 $200,000 drops off and it's dramatically lower I just want to make sure we highlight that y we'll show that and then we'll we'll do that longterm chart that shows that the debt had been for the district and then it it it decreases down now we've um we be finishing and expiring the middle school and then we're down to um the so the HVAC and the tur field and then these two would be layered on top of it but we'll we'll put that together in any other questions okay um so uh I'll do the roll call Brian um are you in favor or opposed to article two favor it yes thanks Brian Matt yes R yes Tom enry yes Tom whan y Tom Solon yes and uh
174Dave yes and Darlene votes yes passes um budget committee recommends 8 Z great moving forward to article three which is the operating budget I need a motion by board member to recommend article three as presented mooved by Rob second second by K so just to be clear as presented will be for the higher amount right right are there any comments we fully intend to amend on the floor depending on how the Articles go right yes Tom um I haven't yet seen any any evidence that are test results are directly correlated to our operating budget I think our keeping the schools open are directly related to the operating budget if uh if people are concerned about our test results and things like that it would be really good to have them come to board meetings when
175we're talking about curriculum and coursework that sort of thing but the budget isn't isn't the place to attack if you you have questions about those in my opinion that's great thank you um just for public record we've regularly checked in with um the administration and the budget committee and are aware that this budget will cover the needs for our students for the year and um that's why we support it and I also want to just go on record of thanking the budget committee for all of their work on this especially the chair um so all those in any other comments all those in favor 6 I'll take a motion to recommend the operating budget at 31,1 16,42 from Tom enri seconded by Dave um any questions comments I would like to take an opportunity to
176thank the administration and um the business office a lot of hard work goes into putting together the budget there are lots of questions that I send um to the business administrator especially as I'm putting these presentations together and I appreciate um the diligent effort and uh rapidity at which she uh answers my questions she's very quick and takes uh um like I said a lot of time to answer some follow-up questions so I sincerely appreciate that um and again thank the superintendent and the administrators of the building for their um their process and uh what they put into the budget we've been lucky for the past several years to um have budgets come in under guidance have all our questions answered and and deliver what I feel is an excellent educational opportunity for the students
177in the district so thank you um any other comments or questions um okay all those in favor we'll start with Brian yes Matt yes Raul yes Tom Enright yes Tom whan yes Tom Solon yes Dave yes Darlene motion passes 8 Z budget committee recommends the operating budget great moving on to the um contract with our he education support staff I need a motion to recommend article four as presented moved by Christa need a second second by Cindy are there any comments again thank you for all your hard work negotiating team and um I really hope this sets us up well to hire great staff and to keep great staff because that's the goal um all those in favor 60 I'll take a motion to uh recommend the support sta contract for $133,400 one with r
178will obstain okay moving forward to article five which is the SAU budget I need a motion to recommend Article Five as presented moved by Rob I need a second second second by Kate Kate thank you I don't recognize Kate's voice any comments again thanks to the SAU budget committee for coming up with all this and doing all that work um all those in favor 6 Z okay motion to approve on the sa budget from Article 5 for 1,171 278 as the Cooperative School District Portion by Tom enri seconded by Dave any questions was that a little lower than last year uh $1,000 well it's $3,000 higher in total um the budget's a little bit little higher but we down revenue of 50 so the total allotted over the three districts is about 62 okay any
179other questions seeing none I'll call the vote Brian yes Matt yes rul yes Tom enry yes Tom whan yes Tom Solon yes Dave yes Darlene votes yes passes and recommends uh sa budget 80 okay article six is the facility's maintenance trust which is $300,000 I need a motion to recommend article six as presented move by Rob I need a second any comments okay all those in favor 60 recommend we vote to recommend uh motion to move um article six for the facilities trust for $300,000 um as written yes from Tom enri seconded by Dave Blen questions comments seeing none I'll call the vote Brian yes Matt yes Ro yes Tom enri yes Tom whan yes Tom Solon yes Dave yes Darlene votes yes budget committee recommends the trust uh vote at a by a vote
180of8 Z in article seven I need a motion to recommend article 7 which is the um contingency fund um as presented so moved by Rob second second by Kate any comments all those in favor 60 School Board recommends that's why my number um I'll take a motion to recommend the contingency for $125,000 from Tom Enright seconded by Dave any questions see none I'll call vote Brian yes Matt yes R yes Tom Enright yes Tom whan yes Tom Solon yes Dave yes Darlene votes yes so the budget committee recommends uh the contingency by a vote of 8 Zer and you guys are done are you going to take just ask a question Raul was your abstention a conflict of interest AB yes he want noted yes okay thank you Tom um for I'll just um say
181it out loud for our uh person taking minutes for Don so back to article two for the budget committee um the vote was 701 with r abstaining um due to a conflict of interest because just say I think that was article four actually article four two but I'm sorry I metant article four for the Hessa agreement looked at article yeah my wife uh works for under the has that contract so it's a conflict of thank you for clarifying that time okay so um petition warrant article eight is to put tax impact on the warrant this is a weird way of doing this but I need a motion to recommend article 8 as presented moved by Cindy I need a second good luck I need a second second second by Kate okay so we're gonna take
182a position um and uh is there anybody who would like to comment on this or has any questions I I do have a question Darlene and it's a question to Darlene can you envision a mechanism by which your concerns and objections to this would be reduced or removed no the law is doesn't allow for the flexibility of um putting the language in context our um tax bills don't allow for um for anyone to easily identify what the co-op tax rate currently is and I don't see any either Town changing the format of their tax bills of our taxx bills I would also say that um while this information is presented here it will be posted um it'll be posted as part of the um package that gets uploaded prior to March meeting um anyone could
183send questions to the budget committee if they have questions or concerns about what the rates are we don't get any correspondence uh we don't have a planned meeting I would usually they could attend a meeting at any time during the planning period to understand things better but to your original question since it's clear that it's really just a a a succinct here's the tax impact without an up or down it's part of your you know this or that rate no I don't see my personal opinion changing so is there anyone else who has a question or comment okay so if you vote Yes you're voting to recommend article eight so all those in favor of recommending article 8 all those opposed so the school board does not recommend article 8 are you guys taking a
184vote on this one we are so I will take a motion to recommend um article eight which is to include the tax impact on the warrant from Tom enr seconded by Dave I would add um just in our point of discuss um that I'd like a sense of the budget committee um as to whether dependent on the vote um you'd like to provide input as a budget committee um or would rather reserve your comments to be made individually um as members of the community I would like it when you speak okay me too I I I do think that that's critical that you articulate the objections to it because in the absence of of that explanation it seems un unreasonable to object because we put it out there yes right right can I make a
185comment sure this comes across to me as someone who's trying to suggest that we're not being transparent and for the going on 40 years that I've been in town I don't remember ever not having a war article without the tax impact so for that reason I think we're traditionally what we've done for many many years is appropriate and correct and transparent so therefore we don't need to uh and I will I support the the article and I will add that but the March meeting is the one place where I do include um this this is true for the Hollis School District at well I can't speak to Brookline um but I serve on the holl School District budget committee so I know that what gets put into that presentation where we do present an overall
186estimated impact for each budget that gets presented so it really is there really is context it isn't just what these individual Artic articles represent what the tax impact is in total just for the co-op we really do include the estimates for each of the school district budgets and each of the towns and depending on the timing of the March meeting sometimes that includes the based on what the final budgets are that are passed and we are going first so ours will include estimates of everything going forward so I really do think that the information provided really does give the legislative body context um as opposed to just you know and on top of that we go at length to publish all these the presentations and all the material ahead of time yep and people who
187really want to know know where the information is okay so right now the vote is to recommend including tax impact on the warrant Brian yes Matt no r no Tom enry no Tom whan no Tom Solon no Dave no Darlene votes no so the budget committee who's confused by theing of this isn't not recommending by a vote of one to seven well if you say not recommending vot to not recommend I don't know how we're going to how we all that but we're not recommending it we have the vote on record and we they'll work we're gonna figure it out I have a point of order sure for article for item nine given that we've heard from um Council this evening I don't think it's appropriate that we take any kind of motion to accept
188or not to accept I think are and if you need a motion to remove that from the warrant I'm willing to do that right now that's what I think we need I think I think we need a motion to remove remove article n from the warrant I need a second who second did that Christa is there any comment or just we all right all those in favor of removing article nine on the charter Commission on the charter commission yes so that's 60 that will be removed I need a motion to renumber articles 10 11 and 12 to be articles 9 10 and 11 moved by Kate seconded by Rob um all those in favor of renumbering the Articles 60 so now article 10 is now article 9 UM and that would be the uh SP2
189article that we've seen a lot um just speaking truth um so I need a motion to recomend article nine sorry the current article 9 the new article N I guess um motion I need a motion move by Kate second second second by Cindy okay anybody want to comment on SP2 I just don't see how a delivera session would have the exact same difficulties as our regular annual meeting so I don't see how SP2 alleviates that if people have trouble getting to an annual meeting they will have equal amount of trouble getting to a deliberative session and worse they those people won't go and will be unaware of what's really Behind These articles so I think it just propagates um ignorance about the Articles and it doesn't leave the voter very informed so I have that
190is only one of a plethora problems I see with that SP2 so I think you know where I stand yeah I mean for me it's always comes down to the same thing the idea that it's just ballot voting completely negates the importance of the deliberative session and as we can see from tonight's meeting there is so much that can happen in a deliberative session and people need to be present for that and it doesn't negate it you have to go so if you have to go to one you should go to and there's no way for the uh for that legislature to table stuff that should not even go forward right uh whatever is brought forward in a petition will go to the ballot in one form or another and that's just another problem I
191have we and Tom I just want to point out that there uh was in my opinion a misstatement made in the public input where it said that Brook lines not having issues with deliberative sessions uh attendance is relatively light the last deliberative session took over four hours and of that three of the four hours were related directly to petition Warren articles um and I think what this points out to is is an underlying problem where petition warrant articles um are not are not put forth by people who have been doing the the research and have been delegated with the authority by the legislative body to protect their interests you get 25 people who are willing to put their name on a piece of paper with good intentions and uh so holding Brookline as an example
192of why sb2 is good is not gonna fly with people who are from Brookline in my opinion second thank you very much any other comments okay all those in favor of article now n to adopt all those opposed sorry just like facing out six we don't recommend that one so for the budget committee we um sorry traditionally have not taken a position on sb2 but given some of the um perspective that was shared I'll just look to the budget committee to see if um they're interested in taking the position this year I am absolutely okay so we'll move forward um so I'll take the motion to recommend article N9 for SP2 from Tom enri seconded by Dave Blen um so seeing no questions comments okay seeing none I'll call the vote for the motion to
193recommend sb2 Brian Matt no rul I don't recommend no Tom Enright no Tom whan no Tom Solon no Dave Darlene votes no so it's 08 committee does not recommend SP2 okay moving on to what is now article 10 petition article 10 I need a motion to recommend article 10 for the budget cap it's it's adopt the budget cap yes you need a motion so move by Christa I need a second second Kate um I don't even know what to say about this one I think we have a budget cap it's these people sitting right here and the voters and the voters so we we have it's two layers we have guidance from our budget committee we have a very good process in place and then we have additional vetting at the annual meeting where community
194members can come and we can debate the number and adjust the number that's our cap and by the way if we put a cap in what do we need a budget committee for they can all go home oh actually that might cause you want probably not the best argument I wrote that question an hour ago is there is there anyone else has a comment on this I mean the ambiguity is just in and of itself a reason to vote no so um all those in favor all those opposed 06 we School Board does not recommend okay um motion from the budget committee to recommend article 10 for the uh budget cap as written um by Dave seconded by Tom enr any comments or questions seeing none so I'll call the vote on the motion to
195recommend oh wait I will ask the same question before I call the vote is there interest in providing um an organized response from the budget committee for the budget cap sure yes okay I'll take that as a sense of the board great um Brian I'm calling the vote on the recommendation for a budget cap no Matt no Tom andri no Tom whan NOP Tom Solon no Dave no Darlene votes no budget committe is not recommending the budget cap by vote 08 and then we have article 11 um which is the adopted tax cap I need a motion to recommend article 11 moved by Chris by Cindy seconded by Kate um are there any comments on this one this just seems redundant to the other one so how many caps how many caps do you want
196to put on top of that caps the this cap layer C this caps the entire warrant is my understanding so it C it caps everything which is what Brook Brooklyn Elementary School District is dealing with now with the changes in the law the entire warrant has been kept their their cap was really high in a percentage and now they're butting up against it because you have to have projects and you have to have bonds and you have to have contracts we're not we don't want it's not our money we don't want to spend it it's just you have to provide the only issue I see is if you have both caps which one takes priority and it it just is a mess well it's both they would be a budget cap and then there' be
197a tax cap on the entire warrant so it would it would be a complex process and it would make budgeting even harder than it already is and just for the records too there there is just what we need more complexity there is all already you know wording if the budget committee were to not support the capital project um wording has to be adopted in in the bond language that says the budget committee is not um approving because that affects the 10% limitation and then you know things like that so there is wording and justification and things like that already in place depending on you know input from the budget committee and where they support it and as we've said we're overseeing you're overseeing and ultimately the legislative body can amend and change and add and
198subtract and ultimately approve or not approve things put in court all all of these are tools that have been created over the years to give Flex a go this process if we start adopting articles like this we're taking flexibility and tools away from what we do absolutely okay so have we not voted yet all those in favor School Board all those opposed 06 we do not recommend article 11 okay motion from the budget committee to recommend um is it article 11 yeah it's 11 tax uh some vot from Tom whing seconded by Dave um any comments seeing none I'll call the vote Brian the motion to recommend the tax cap Matt no rul no Tom enri no Tom whan no Tom Solon no Dave Darlene votes no recommend uh budget committee does not recommend the
199C the tax cap by unanimous vote Yes true um for the purposes of helping me write the script uh first does the school board intend to speak to any of the petition articles um I think if there was any we would speak to I would imagine we might speak to would we speak to SP2 is there anything you guys wanted to speak to I'd be more likely to speak at the microphone as a member of the public okay we don't usually okay okay same question as the budget committee so while I didn't ask the budget committee directly until anyone just jumps in and tells me I'm speaking out of turn I would say that the budget committee would have an organized response to article eight for the ta uh the tax impact on the warrant
200article 10 the budget cap and uh article 11 the tax cap those C for with whatever timeline you tell me I have you get two minutes great I'll do it so so so when would you entertain a a motion to table from the floor uh I'd have to go back and see what I wrote but I think the rule said it can be before it gets brought to the table have to listen to all of this motion to pass over I I I think what I said was it can be done before the mo the motion comes to the floor but it requires a two-thirds uh vote right yes and and it would have to do the motion would have to occur just before it comes up not yes first thing that's a question could
201you do it out of order basically you can't uh you know where I will before we start article three you can't say move to pass over article nine you can't okay can't do that okay that that's that's a question has to be right before the article now if you really want to waste waste time you can move the article you want to get rid of up so it's next and then do it that's but here's the other here's the other question um if someone has that intent of doing so yeah do you advise them to alert you so that you can so it doesn't become a a Jeopardy thing of who presses a button first hey Drew here's a here's a couple questions yeah can can a person get up and motion to table all
202like like 10 11 and 12 can they get up and do that I will not accept that motion could a could a post could could a person get up before article 8 and say I'd like to take a motion to dissolve the meeting and doesn't that take like no okay you by law you have to address every warrant article okay can the motion to pass over be do you have to be online as the speaker at the podium well once we've started it a motion to pass over is kind of then what you want to do is table okay so if okay so you can motion to table get an answer to my original question is can someone walk up to him and say I'm going to want to make a motion to pass over
203an tic article eight and alert him so that he is aware of it and and leaves a pause there I'm that often happens because people they look at the rules and they say I don't know how to do this and they come talk to me and say this is what I want to do how do I do it and I tell them what I want it's also the case that the moderator gets to speak who gets to choose who speaks next it is a matter of convenience and and history that people stand in line and get chosen based on their order in line but but that that's not the law the law says the moderator gets to choose okay so if someone's if someone is of the mindset that they wish to have that motion
204considered it's worth them alerting you to that it is very much worth worth them and you know that's it's kind of silly for somebody to be standing at the podium when I'm not ready to for input okay thank you yeah I think we're done here quick question are you good just real quick Drew on on what you just said about we cannot um make the motion to pass over before the article is in order no you can just before I mean Sor I mean just before we can't do it out of order right um is that your rule or is that a law that is my rule so we could ask the legislative body to change the rules absolutely okay but once but once you go through the rules and then you have a vote
205for people to vote on it those are the rules you have to do it when you you have to do at the very beginning well you can change the rules during the meeting with a two-thirds vote okay okay okay any other questions for Drew I'm going to let you ask do you need a non-debatable I really do CU I have to go I move toling I need a second in favor I have a motion to adjourn from the budget committee for the budget committee from Tom whan seconded by Matt Maguire I have to call the roll