001as you come in if you can get your ballots quickly um on the back table um is important information we have slightly revised rules from our typical meetings um these were put together along with um Drew um and we worked on these along with the um Hollis um Cooperative um budget committee and the school board and there was uh Drew Mason and I worked on these together and the these were a Cooperative effort um to bring these revised rules and procedures to this body they have to be like all rules adopted by this body as our first order of business tonight before we get started if we could say the Pledge if you could please rise pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands
002one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you at this time we have uh senior uh Emma dearo I almost called you by your mother's name um that's going to come and um sing the national anthem for us oh say can you see by the Dono the light what so proudly we ha at the Twilight last gleaming who broad stripes and bright stars through the perous fight or the ramp parts we watched were so G streaming and the rocket red glare the bombs bursting in air gave proof through the night that our flag was still there oh say does that star spangled B W or the land of the free and the home of the bra thank you thank you thank you so much for doing that it's always quite the
003joy to see the talent that our students here at Hollis Brook line High School have and thank you for sharing that with us tonight um first um up Holly could you please um introduce the members of the SCH Hollis Brooklyn Cooperative school board for us happy to welcome thank you for joining us tonight I'm Holly derlo Babcock I'm the chair of the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School Board um I don't know what order they're in but Kate stole is our vice chair Christal whan is next to Kate um Cindy vanc Conan is here Beth Beth Williams Rob man I think I have everyone and then Tom Solen won't be joining us tonight thank you typically we have the budget committee to my left they're not up tonight because these are there's the budget is not on
004as a topic for this special meeting um take a moment to uh introduce and thank the school administration um for being here tonight uh we have superintendent um Andrew Corey who is starting his last season of district meetings with us we appreciate your many years of service um assistant superintendent Gina burog uh we have director of student services Laura uh Lauren djaro business administrator Kelly cely um the principal Tim grone Yolanda flamino Tracy Lane and Amanda Zeller and I don't see them with us tonight but they are um work hard for our students um the meeting officials um I'm Elizabeth Brown I am stepping in um for Drew Mason who is not able to be here running the special meeting for you tonight I have not become the permanent um moderator um of the Co-op
005I am just standing in this evening um the meeting officials uh Jos shanesy is um here he is a district council um and the supervisors of the checklist are in the back the ballot clerks the assistant counters um we've the assistant moderator selected um counters we have two from each Town five total F four total two from two from Hollis and two from Brookline one additional counter from each town thank you melenda um we appreciate all of your help um it there's a lot of work that goes into um making sure that all the people are here and that we can take part in this very pure form of democracy um the um meeting is being being streamed on sau41 uh the uh warrant can also be found on the SAU website they've also been
006published on the uh local um Hollis Brookline uh Community um newspaper which is our only source of getting things out at this point our first order of business this evening is taking up the meeting rules and a couple times before you all sat down and we called the meeting to order I suggested folks pick up a copy of the printed rules for this um for the that's going to be for the upcoming annual meeting and for the special meeting um like I mentioned these are a little bit different um than the rules that we typically follow um I think the main difference that's going to be important for tonight's meeting is one once somebody moves the question the old rules we pretty much allowed everyone to continue to speak and now if that motion carries
007that will in debate and the line will sit down has to be the motion has to be made by somebody that's in the line that's one of there are other rules that are slightly changed but I think that's going to be the most important change that's going to be relevant for tonight because many of the other changes deal with petition warrant articles and petitioners and we don't have those tonight um so I am your moderator I propose the operating rules these have to be adopted at every meeting um once they're adopted if somebody in the meeting wants to change the rules you can do so by a motion and by a two-thirds vote of the members here tonight um we use Robert's Rules as a guide we don't follow them precisely but they the our
008rules are generally based upon Robert's Rules and we will typically follow those and the where it says it's not in the town report that's where it should be um for regular meeting we don't have the town reports published yet because the regular warrants are not yet um it's not yet due um we are get getting ready to go into um public hearings in the beginning of February so we're just around the corner um if you would like to speak at the meeting you should come to the podium which is here way to be recognized please speak into the microphone before you start speaking the first order of business is show your voter card state your name and your address um you should direct your comments to the moderator to the front of the room not
009to the voters not to other folks and speak only once in line until others have had an opportunity to speak um speaking at the meeting um speaking for will be limited to two minutes and uh we're going to try to use something new tonight we're going to try to do that electronically um so there'll be a timer that I'm going to start when somebody comes to the podium to speak um hopefully that keeps me honest and keeps everyone else honest and so everyone gets that same two minutes if you notice that I don't start the timer you can uh kind of note because uh we're all trying to this this process is a little bit new for us too and I won't proclaimed to be able to do everything perfect up here um if you
010are coming to the podium to propose a Amendment which I don't anticipate we should have amendments tonight but if we did um the person who is bringing the motion for Amendment will have five minutes to um speak in support of that motion um your two minutes is for you you can't yield it to somebody else or give it to your neighbor or your spouse um one part of the speaking at a meeting that is governed by law that we can't change is that no person shall speak at the meeting without leave of the moderator um and you should only speak when you um have the floor so when speaking is in order and I am attempting to control the meeting so please speak when I've given you leave to speak and allow me to try
011to keep order in the meeting so we can get through our business tonight as quickly as we can um if I make a mistake if you're confused if there's something that needs to be brought to my attention the proper thing is to say point of order um you can bring that to my attention along with whatever is um an error at the meeting you can appeal my ruling using that mechanism point of order is not supposed to be used for questions it's not supposed to be used for motions it's supposed to be a time where I'm not following my rules and that we need to bring the order to the meeting back in line um it's best if you can actually point to the number of the rule that I am not following so I
012can be directed to that and the other voters in the room can be directed to that rule that is the best way to bring forth a point of order ending debate we have several folks here for a special meeting um a motion to end debate may be only after waiting in line that motion is not debatable so um and um I will determine in my discretion whether or not it's it's appropriate um if I rule that it's appropriate and the room believes that it's not that would be an appropriate time to attempt to overrule the moderator um a motion to end debate requires two-thirds of the voters in the room to agree with you that it is time to end debate at that point debate ceases and the motion will be brought to the floor
013this is that important difference that I want to highlight is which is why it's underlined because this is a little different than the way um Drew Mason has ran recent meetings and is a this is kind of goes back to what I understand was the old rule it's what I remember doing probably 10 years ago um so this is going back to the old way so the line sits down if the motion to end debate is successful it should allow for meetings to go a little bit more quickly and a little less duplication um also a change in the rules is a motion to postpone inally or Passover can be made before an article is brought to the floor this type of motion requires a second it is debatable and also requires 2third of the
014members of the voters to pass motions to reconsider the purpose for a motion to reconsider is not to get a second bite at the Apple the reason for a motion to consider reconsider is to bring new information to the floor it is debatable requires a simple majority in order to pass but it can only be made by a voter on the prevailing side so if you lose the vote and you voted against something you don't have the right to bring forth a motion for reconsideration it really is intended to allow for um new information to be heard a motion to restrict reconsideration um we may have those tonight those are very important in longer meetings where we have a number of different articles on the warrant um we can have a motion to reconst reconsideration
015once that passes it doesn't completely prevent reconsideration it just requires that the later reconsideration be at least 7 days later um a motion for rec to restrict reconsideration is in order at any time the speaker has the floor and it's only in order after the results of the vote has been declared so if we end up having to have um a vote that is not declared based upon a um card count um it can it's only in order after we've counted the votes that is not a debatable motion um appeal of a moderator's ruling any interpretation of the rules can be appealed and less it's something that's required by state law um good news is I have um attorney o shanesy here with me tonight who can help me confirm what is state law um
016a appeal regarding what a moderator's ruling should be made immediately after the ruling is made um that is appropriate to do by a point of order or I'd like to challenge the ruling does require a second and it requires a majority to overrule the moderator I need a motion from the floor to shall the school district vote to adopt this rules for the special meeting as proposed by the moderator that would include what is written and that includes what I highlighted here for you today can I get a motion a motion by Darlene uh I have a question on the rules so motion to end there's a motion on the floor so a question would not be in order of a second all those in favor of the rules all put Hand cards down all
017those opposed okay the rules carry now I acknowledge I'll give you the floor what is your question so motion to end debate uh I'm trying to understand if that's a privileged motion which can be made from the floor or if someone has to get to the podium in order to make that motion it may made the the motion to in debate under the new rules as noted here may only be made after you've waited in line and got to the podium so like if there's a long line behind me someone behind me couldn't in debate until they got to the podium couldn't make that motion you need to have the floor to make the motion okay after waiting in line thank you thank you okay the first article of business tonight is article one um
018it's been moved by Holly deru Babcock and seconded by Kate stole um the article is to see if the school district will vote to clarify the definition of capital expens es in article four of the article's agreement of the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District you can see where the language here is presented for what article four would do we would strike the first Clause of the rule the expenses related to principal and interest of bonds current and future would be stricken from the articles of agreement and then it would read Capital expenses of the Hollis Brook line Cooperative School District payable in fiscal year shall be proportioned based on an average daily membership ADM and equalized value EV according to the table below Capital expenses shall include the cost of acquiring land and buildings for
019school purposes the construction furnishings and equipping of school buildings and facilities and the payment of the principle and interest of any indebtedness which is incurred to pay for the same of which or which is assumed by The Cooperative School District including but not limited to the principal and interest of bonds and leases under RSA 33 7-e if I understand attorney orany you have a presentation yeah um uh Liz Can somebody adjust the the uh so that's a a clearer picture so it could be read thank hi so the the language you see here is actually what's printed in your warrant it's just presented up here for convenience so if you have warrants in front of you this is the same language all right um so both both of the warrant articles today on the special
020meeting warrant pertain to the apportionment formula um article one specifically pertains to one part of the apportionment formula uh so before we get started talking about that um relevant law in New Hampshire is governed by RSA 19518 uh sections e and G that is the law that requires Cooperative school districts formed after a certain time post 1963 to have um uh articles of agreement and the articles of agreement must set forth the method for proportioning operating expenses and capital expenses those are the two types of expenses in a Cooperative School District right so it's really just broken down into those two categories your current articles of agreement I'm going to go back this is the the actual current version of your articles of agreement are broken down into two categories operating expenses and bonds so
021if you kind of recognize that there's a difference with part two is that the law says you have to have a method for a portioning capital expenses and your current articles of agreement have a method but it only says um principle and interests of bonds so the purpose of article one today is to amend your articles of agreement so they specifically align with the statutory language to have um Capital expenses apportioned with a description of what capital expenses is following the exact language in the statute which is which is printed here 19518 Roman numeral 3G that's the long and short of it the only part of the Articles of agreement that are being amended here is the middle part here which is the definition of capital expenses the actual table and the formula is not
022on the floor it's not being proposed for Amendment the idea being you update your your definition and down the road wherever it's appropriate you can um update your apportionment formula if that's something you want to do that's the purpose of article one I'll stay here Liz in case people have questions for a couple minutes or you can have me sit any other thank you attorney asan your F first to the floor uh Melinda Willis 40 right Road um I have a question for you it's um clarification of the language please sure so when it says uh the way it's written in the amendment Capital expenses shall include the cost of acquiring land and building for school purposes the construction Furnishing and equipping of school buildings and Facilities that sounds to me like it means when
023you do the building it includes the furnishings and the equipment that are put in at the time you are building the building or does it mean anytime that we decide oh we need new tables for the cafeteria to replace our old beat up ones that those would also then follow under this definition yeah so capital is capital right like it's it's it's your building it's your property anytime you purchase new property repair your property put a roof on the building put a new boiler in those are capital expenses and when the legislature adopted the law they uh inv IED that you would you would pay for your operating expenses and your Capital expenses using a different formula you could use the same formula but you would a portion them using potentially different methods so the
024answer is anytime moving forward you have a capital expense it would be a portion using the capital expenses formula I represent a lot of Cooperative school districts that's how everybody does it that's the language from the statute is there a subparagraph that definitively explains what Capital Equipment is like if it has to have a 5year lifespan a 10year lifespan a 20-year lifespan because that could make a big difference I don't know the answer to that question I don't know if if there's a a clear in the statute in New Hampshire our statutes are are typically pretty limited I think most folks know what what is capital and what isn't and I don't think the like lifespan or the depreciation whatever I don't think that's really applicable um well because of how our apportionment done it's
025very applicable yeah no like in terms of the the lifespan I don't I don't think the lifespan is how you define whether it is or is not capital is there a Dollar definition then not in the law no okay thank you hello thank you uh Sue hola 15 mendleson Drive uh the question I had was that am I understanding this correctly that we are now uh what you're proposing is to move leases into the calculation uh that we Ed for bonds is that correct yes okay and second if somebody could answer this for me I'm not really sure what that the math on EV looks like so if you had a million dooll expense and it is being calculated under um the 95 ADM and the 5% EV versus like we do leases Now versus
0260% 8 M and 100% EV can somebody give me an estimation of what that looks like in our million dooll expenses between two towns between Hollis and Brooklyn I think this guy is going to try to do that we have one lease that if this was passed would go from the lease operating to the bond the difference total Difference by moving it over from a taxpayers point of view is $35,000 that that would mean that Hollis would pay a penny and a half per $100,000 more and Brook line would pay three cents less okay we have that one lease it moves over the difference is $35,000 in total between the two formulas and it results again Penny and a half increase per 100,000 for Hollis 3 cents decrease for Brookline can you um thank you
027for that and can you give me can you remind me again what you said about how much that lease that you're using as an example is it would be the most recent lease which was for all the uh heating equipment here at the high school dollar amount uh 2.9 Million I believe give or take okay thank you you're welcome web scales 49 dep gold Road Brook line um I understand that we are about to enter into some lease to purchase agreements um and it's clear in my mind that those are capital expenses because they are going to result in a physical asset that we are going to own at the end of those leases and so having those leases structured as a capital expense under Article 4 makes very good sense if we have other
028leases for instance if we leas a tractor or something and at the end of three years that tractor goes back to to the company that leased it to us that strikes me as an operating expense and not a Capital One because at the end of the lease we don't have any asset and so I have a question as to whether the fact that this article deals with capital expenses how operable is that word lease if it's a lease to purchase Arrangement it's Capital regardless of whether it's lease if it's not going to result in a in an asset then even though it's a lease it's not a capital expense does it come under article four the way I look at it um first of all is if it's in the operating budget like I'll use
029um most recent purchase of a school van okay we just choose to purchase that we could lease it we have leased it in the past but that that's an operating piece based on it it's in the operating budget so when I look at these two words I think the way I separate them is the lease or the bond is a separate warrant article for a separate per purpose if it's in the operating budget it goes under the operation formula so your your your you know $20,000 tractor to me is buy outright in the operating budget it's an operating expense and then just because you asked uh on Monday night if you watch you'll see that I'm going to recommend the two leases that we're proposing actually move over to bonds because we just got the
030recent Bond rates and it's much better from a interest rate point of view at this present time to go to bonds so we're going to make it that recommendation on Monday night right but if they're bonded then we understand how they're dealt with it's the least to purchase Arrangement right I think that the big thing is when it's a separate warrant article like the ones you're talking about for Monday that was at least for x amount to do the HVAC equipment at the middle school and the other one was to do solar and all the lighting okay those are separate um items those are capital long-term capital things where we're always looking that the equipment that we're purchasing is going to have a longer useful life than the lease so just to bring this to
031a close the fact that it's a lease doesn't necessarily mean that it is or isn't Capital depends on which budget you put it in correct and pretty much we have that threshold it's going to be a significant cost to make the bond lease that we're talking about tonight thank you Brian Loveland Toddy Brook Road and I just want to come out for this amendment it's simply treating like expenses the same way and will'll give the school board the most latitude to choose on if it's a bond or lease knowing um but not that the board some board members and stuff I would be hesitant if I were a board member to choose a lease if we don't have explicit uh language clarifying how it's going to get a portion because of Any ambiguity by doing
032this we're treating about Bond and a lease which are the same would be for the same thing the same way so that um the board has the most leeway to make the right decision because as superintendent Cory mentioned he was not the worth the leases that looks like it's cheaper to do a bond but if it was cheaper to do a lease without this language change I think the board would probably and the voters would be very hesitant to vote for a lease if there's not the update to the language thank you Mike rundi 62 Allon Drive in Hollis uh question um superintendant you just mentioned u a few minutes ago about the effect of pennies um difference between the two towns I wanted to know if there was any anticipating leases coming up especially
033high dollar leases either in the next town meeting or even in subsequent years that might make numbers like that be much higher there are two proposals on this year's warrant that we'll be discussing in March that are part of the public hearing on Monday night those are for a new heating hva system HVAC system at the middle school and to install solar on our roofs those are the two proposals those are both going to be turned into Bond proposals right uh in the future what I've done since I've been here uh I look and see where the rates are because one of the things uh with the lease a lease starts out in year one and goes set payments until it's over a bond typically you pay six months of interest in year one and
034then in year two you go up to the full cost and I hate to see the tax rate doing this you know people would like it to be staed so uh the intent to me you know we have traditionally used that you know 150 to 200,000 is going to go in either the maintenance trust or the operating budget because that's typically a section of the roof uh and then the major projects which would be to me uh the solar major heat changes any additions that may occur those are a bond uh and I've always segmented leases for equipment so when I originally put these in I was talking about uh solar and boilers which are equipment in the town of Hollis where we've done lease and bonds if it's been for construction like when we
035did the whole new facade on HPS that was a bond because that was brick and water not going anywhere when we did the um unit ventilators and the heat source air pumps that was a lease because that was equipment thank you you're welcome Chris pelico holl my question is for attorney of shanesy this article references RSA 337 D E when I looked up 337 d e it's all about lease agreement of equipment and it does not look like what is underlined at all I would like you to read what 337 dashy is the other thing is since I'm under a time constraint I'd like to know how many leases we presently have for the co-op maybe you can't answer that but I'm sure somebody at the table can and do those leases turn into bonds
036if that's what's going to happen great question um the language you see here underlined is the language from RSA 195 18 Roman numeral 3 subsection I where it defines Capital expense the only difference being between this and the definition of the statute is this language specifically calls out lease purchas agreements pursuant to RSA uh e and the reason I put that in there as as the language the board asked me to put in is because I knew the B you folks would want that specifically said in the in the language that if it's amended we are going to treat those lease purchase agreements um of equipment as capital expenses specifically so the this is a reference to another statute and you are correct it's referencing the leases of equipment part of RSA 33 that is
037correct and it has has nothing to do with um the acquisition of land and um 337 d e which is what we got as a reference I don't believe it has anything to do with land the acquisition of the capital expenses will will include a a lot more categories of things than just the acquisition of land it'll include for example lease purchase agreements um all kinds of equipment so yes that is correct okay just going back to my first request was would you please read from RSA 337 d e for the audience I mean do you have it pulled up because I don't I have a copy okay I mean go ahead says the governing body it says lease agreements of equipment the governing body may enter into lease's of equipment as required by the
038municipality Appropriations to fund lease agreements with non-appropriation Clauses may be approved by a simple majority vote of the legislative body lease agreements with non-appropriate Clauses shall not be treated as debt under RSA 33 4-a for the purpose of this section lease shall include lease purchase sale and leas back installment sale or other similar agreement to AC acquire use or ownership of such equipment as is from time to time required by the municipality for the purpose of this section and RSA 382a building or facility improvements related to the installation purpose or operation of such equipment shall be deemed to constitute equipment and and costs of such improvements may be financed through lease agreements under this section all right thank you your time has expired next speaker please yeah I am uh Aon penich I'm at 133
039Dow Road in Hollis I have a question about this entire uh warrant article and that's why are you trying to change the traditional definition of a capital expense a capital expense traditionally is a one-time purchase or Improvement uh to assets that provide a lasting benefit Capital expenses are different from operating expenses which is the day-to-day expenses to run a business or an Enterprise which is what a lease would be as an example why are you trying to change the definition of a capital expense for purposes of this this situation sure um can you Liz put um put it ahead maybe to next slide NOP back one back one at the bottom of the page in in quotations is the statutory definition of capital expenses which is contained in the Cooperative School District statute so I'm
040not changing anything rather than me sit at home and you know use use the internet or some other resource to come up with a definition and there are a lot of really good definitions I think your definition is great rather than do that to play it safe right so we wouldn't have to have a debate about what definition is better and what to include or not include I put the definition from right from the statute in there the only difference being I added lease purchase agreements which would have been included but I put it in there so it would be expressly clear that under this langu they would be part of the capital expenditure formula that was that was an issue of transparency we wanted to be clear that if you passed it it would
041include lease purchase agreements so we haven't changed any definition the legislature came up with this definition probably 50 or 60 years ago that's the definition that's in the proposed amendment so you said we're not trying to change anything if that's the case why are we here because in the Articles of agreement that we're operating under we don't have the words Capital lease we just have Bond when there are two types of mechanisms Capital lease and bond so by adding Capital lease we're clarifying for the Articles agreement for 10 years in the future 20 years in the future those are the two types of long-term debt I think part of it when the co-op was founded leases were not popular and I don't know if they were a funding mechanism then I kind of look at
042it the same way when I first purchased cars you could only buy a car it sound it sounds like you're trying to fix a problem that doesn't exist no I'm trying to clarify the articles of agreement with the the constitution of the co-op so that they're clear so that anybody at home would understand them and I was trying to do that because the question has been brought to the board so we felt we had an obligation to clarify that came from citizens thank you thank you David Perry uh three West Hollis Road and Hollis um in getting the original communication on this um this article I was actually astounded that uh School expenses are a portioned in a way other than the number of students that are being sent by the towns that are involved
043and for the life of me I can't understand what the Genesis of this formula is versus using the student population I guess it's called ADM the average daily uh m stands for something I'm sure mersh membership thank you what is the Genesis of that where does that come from versus student participation that is a study committee that was initiated by the two communities that came up with a formula that was brought to the meeting and approved by the voters and that's why it's the second article tonight because you could decide to stay with that formula or you could decide that no would like you to look at something else and that comes up automatically every five years so I believe it's exactly five years ago tonight that we were in this gym discussing a portion
044but I wasn't here I I wasn't living here then but that's okay we we we discussed this an awful lot uh it's a fun and robust discussion uh and we're back again and the only positive thing that I can say is this is my last one congratulations yeah thank you is is there any who could enlighten me on what's the thought process that goes into that it just doesn't seem to make any sense to me we're GNA okay I guess I'm done Food For Thought Brian Leland t b Road motion to end debate second okay all right I have a motion to end debate so we will bring forth the um vote on article one tonight we're going to do a hand vote do I have my counters they up we have one over here
045are you voting to end debate right now first thank you all right on the motion to end debate um all those in favor of ending debate can you um can I get a all right looks pretty unanimous uh counters have you had an opportunity to count sorry all right my mistake hold on let's all right on take let's take the vote raise your hand if you would like to end debate counters have you had an opportunity to count okay it has to be has to take and we have any no put your cards down are there any nose on the motion thank you motion carries now we'll go to take a vote on the article all of those in favor of article one please raise your cards okay you can put your cards down all
046those opposed you're I'm all right apologize there I thought I was getting the signal from I apologize for creating confusion everybody put your card down we're going to start over you've got that side over there you have that side all right now that I have exactly where everybody's got all right all those in favor of the article one please raise your card good you have the table okay Erica I'm going to wait till I get a thumbs up from Melinda okay sorry it's aerobics tonight okay now you can put your cards down if you were voting in favor all those in opposition to article one please raise your cards keep them up so everybody can get counted thank you for your patience everybody will have their exercise in by the time we get done tonight
047I don't have the all clear yet so leave your cards up please until he make sure that everybody's been counted we're good okay you can put your cards down okay motion carries the votes were yays 97 NOS 85 article one passes I'm not getting on the treadmill tonight so I need some exercise somehow okay next on tonight's agenda is article two it's been uh moved by Holly derley Babcock and seconded by Kate stole um article two is the continue the current method of apportionment expenses in the article agreement the article is to see if the school district will vote to continue the current apportionment formula as set forth in article four of the Articles agreement of the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District Christa you have do I just no it's fine thank you good evening
048um I'm going to take some time to just explain what a porman is we've been talking about it and I'm sure the majority of you know but just in case people aren't familiar with it um porman is the formula used to determine the share of the cost in The Cooperative School District between Hollis and Brooklyn it's set up by a simple majority vote at either an annual Co-op School District meeting or a special district meeting we've been holding these special district meetings um every 5 years because that's when you renew the apportionment formula we've been doing them in January um because our meetings in March tend to take a long time and adding another warrant onto it um would make our meetings even longer so we've been taking it doing it usually in January once
049a change in the apportionment formula is adopted um or a vote to keep the formula it is set for 5 years that is a new rule in the past you had to change the formula in order to set it for five years but in 2021 there was a law pass that we were allowed to keep a formula as long as there was a majority of vote in the legislature to keep it this is just a slide to show you how the apportionment works with the high school and the middle school goes into the apportionment formula the state aid goes into both the Hollis Co-op tax impact and the Brookline tax impact very simple explanation of how it's a portioned um the current Formula was brought forward in 2015 and it was brought forward because of
050a committee that worked on it so 2013 a board approved a committee after a request from the public and then in March in 2014 a petition based warrant article was brought to the district meeting to change the um apportionment formula at that meeting no apportionment formula was approved and so 100% a average daily membership was stayed intact in 2014 an apportionment committee was formed it had six Brookline residents six Hollis residents B meetings were held from May to November and three public forums were held so a lot of work went into putting together this formula whoops so the committee came forward with the recommended formula 95% ADM 5% EV for non-bonded costs and 100% EV for bonded costs in October the apportioning committee supported the new formula in November on November 13th they brought it
051to the school board um in a public forum and then November 19th the school board approved the recommendation by the apportionment committee and then it was brought forward to a special meeting in 2015 so the components of the for formula are the operating costs so the variable costs the costs that are programmatic to the student population are based 100% on ADM 10% of the operating costs are fixed costs that are not related to how many students we have so we made that 50% on property evaluation and 50% on average daily membership and then the capital cost which is a question that came up earlier was changed to 100% property evaluation and that was a compromise that was brought forward and one of the reasons it was brought forward is because the schools are located both
052the middle school and the high school are located in hus and Hollis does benefit from that and one of the issues that came up a lot during these meetings were if the co-op were to break up Hollis has these buildings and so that's where the 100% EV came forward is that Hollis would pay the reason we are asking to keep these this formula is because the numbers have not changed our average daily membership has remained pretty much the same for the faps 10 years changed a couple of percentage but not much our average daily membership right now is Hollis brings in 55% of the students Brookline brings in 45% of the students and our property evaluation Hollis has about 68% of the property 32% is evaluated for Brooklyn so oh and I wanted to add
053one more thing five years ago we had to change the formula in order to set it for five more years so we added a dollar that's where that plus dollar is coming from so this is the formula that the board is asking to keep set for the next 5 years and the vote that we're asking for is an up or down vote thank you very much do we have speakers on Mr GBA Joe garuba 28 Winchester Drive so we um changed the apportionment formula in 2020 so my question is when was that meeting held in 2020 January 25th 2020 January 25th pretty sure that was the day yes it would be a 367 days at this point it was five years ago again yes okay five years plus two days right okay thank you uh
054Jonathan Fontaine 42 Ironworks laye Hollis um I understand that the percentage ratios haven't changed in the last period in in terms of student enrollment uh I also know that both Hollis and because of some of my driving Brookline is experiencing um housing growth and thereby they'll experience population growth do we have a projection or an understanding of the possible ratio changes based on the new housing happening in both towns because my rough concern would be whether those P percentages change and how that might impact over the next 5 years I don't believe we have any projection to think that the it's going to change according to NASDAQ it doesn't look like it's going to change anywhere from Seven you know from 5050 55 to 45 would you present that's a good question sorry I'm going
055to make you get up with last year uh both towns are anticipating significant growth so I I don't see it changing radically since I've been here which is 11 years the closest would have come was 5248 all right uh and a swing of a percent and this was a few years ago so the numbers might have changed a little bit but a few years back when we swung a percent you swung about $200,000 okay okay so nothing significant in the variance that's that's what we've had historically okay that's what I looking for thank you Tony steny from Hollis I have a question about the EV could you clarify what the E is estimated market value because there makes a difference on where that e is the EV is the evaluation like how would I describe
056that the property evaluation how much the property is worth in each town and so if you combine them that number Hollis has about about 68% of that and Brookline has about 32 just to uh for the record I looked up these numbers and the uh uh median house sale in Hollis right now is $615,000 and the median in Brook line is $628,000 Hollis has uh seen above a 10.2% drop in this market values in the past year while uh Brooklyn has only seen like about a 3% so you know it makes a difference whether it's a market value or or a town assessment but I think those values are getting very very close between both towns when you look at like something like a median run and average yeah I hear what you're saying and
057when we send this to the state the state does the calculation for the evaluation the property evaluation they are the ones who assign that number to US based on the calculations they have okay thank you so we provide the porit formula and then they work it out split it up for us so everyone's upset pardon me so everyone's upset yes thank you Maryanne Shanley Buttonwood driveing Hollis uh I'm curious why you're keeping the plus do why not just strip that out and make it easier just we just wanted to keep it the same that's why we kept the dollar in there just to keep it the same okay Jo GBA 28 Winchester Drive so considering the fact that the equalized value valuation results in higher taxes being paid by Hollis than Brookline on a per
058student basis I think there's two problems with the formula and these are reasons that I suggest that we don't continue this formula um firstly someone mentioned growth uh the voters of Hollis do not get to vote on zoning amendments or zoning ordinance in Brookline so that leaves us in a situation where we're paying additional taxes and in essence we have no representation on the zoning control or growth Management in Brookline um uh the second thing as mentioned uh there the schools being in Hollis it certainly is a benefit in some sense but uh in others it's a drawback uh potentially when you look at the amount of traffic that we see uh in town when schools are filling up or uh when they're leaving so I don't think it's appropriate to tax the residents of
059Hollis a greater amount uh on a per student basis so those are the reasons that I suggest voting against this thank you good evening Ryan owski for Baldwin Drive in Brook line my question is if we vote if this doesn't pass what happens to the apportionment on the operating expenses um if this doesn't pass if we don't keep it the same then we will put a committee together to re-evaluate and look at the apportionment formula to come up with a new one but it would this would remain until we get that voted in and when will that apportionment formula come forward for a vote it would depend on the committee and their work of putting it together and until that time would we keep the current abortion keep this one for yeah probably another year
060thank you maryan Chanley button would drive and holl um you gave a synopsis of how the apportionment committee went five years ago or 10 years ago and um I would like to make those who were not here at the time aware that it was EX extremely contentious people watched it like a hawk it it was you said it was a lot of work it was hours and hours and hours and hours of research and discussion and dredging through the doe website for statistics and information it was an enormous undertaking a huge amount of work I would be cautious about jumping back into that unless we have some big upheaval like Mason buys half of Brooklyn or I don't know or half a Hollis goes to Nashua I I would hope we could keep this and
061not go back into that firestorm hi sua Mendelson Drive um I I know I I've heard I've heard it mentioned that um Hollis benefits from having the school property um and I'm just asking question I'm not sure the answer to this but is it our just our fire department that's that supports the school and it and do does Hollis pay for any police or resource officers do the resource officers paid for by the district by Co-op okay both and that's an operating expense that's not okay a portioned EV okay but okay thank you sure hi Rob zerman uh nard off road and Hollis um has there been any consideration as to what the pending um impact will be of Workforce housing in both towns uh in terms of resource draw and what the tax implication
062are there we have not discussed that I mean again the apportionment formula people keep talking about the EV the EV could shift to Brookline if their property evaluation became much more than ours then that that would change I mean the formula was put together based on what we know and then we continued it based on what we know now so the workforce housing no that has sure so I if if obviously we're we're more on a single family home basis in both towns right now so if that shifted it's just something we'll have to consider 5 years from now yes okay thank you thank you Brian L Toddy Brook Road motion to end debate is there a second all those in favor of the motion to in debate ra your cards um is it close
063do you need to yeah all right so uh all those opposed let's count just to be careful don't want anybody accusing me of ending debate on this one it's important okay so I got my counters in position all those in favor of the motion to end debate please raise your cards keep them up so the counters have an opportunity to count counters are still working I'm waiting for a thumbs up from Melinda to assure me that all of the counters have had an opportunity to count you got the front table too okay um you can put your cards down if you want to all those opposed to the motion to end debate please raise your cards keep them up my counters count user [Music] error okay you can put your cards down Linda it's a
064yes okay the motion carries although so now we're going to take a vote on article two you voted in favor to ending debate Tom so now you have to all um all those voting in favor of article two please raise your cards keep them up so the counters have opportunity to count you're think we can think we've got everybody counted now all those opposed to article two please raise your cards here it looks like it passes but I'm going to wait till an official vote count comes [Applause] forward okay Article 2 passes the Y's votes were 148 and the NOS were 30 so article two passes Mr Gan Tom Gan oh Tom Gan Broad Street Hollis uh motion to dissolve the meeting is there a second second behind me from Mr Man all those in
065favor of the motion to dissolve the meeting thank you should please please raise your cards as your proposed motion carries thank you all this is the first of many meetings February starts out there's lots of hearings on the budgets for the school districts that's the time to go here ask your questions at those meetings thank you all for attending