001e e the uh January 8th Brooklyn Schoolboard public hearing we're going to be going over the operating budget and this is a joint meeting with the finance committee just to go over a couple things but before I start I'd like to uh when we we'll recess into the public hearing and then we'll come back to take positions at the end with the board when we come back from the public hearing I'd like to add an item uh that item will be related to we had an application for the school district clerk for those of you who don't know we've been advertising for quite a long time uh and our flyer that we send home the other day um yielded us a candidate which I'll discuss later on but both Kelly and I would really appreciate
002if we could take action on that tonight because there are duties coming up for for the clerk um as far as the public hearing goes in in a moment um Tracy will ask to recess the regular board meeting and we'll move into the public hearing we have a presentation that Kelly and I will do and at the end of each article will stop and allow public comment on that particular article uh we'll do that by the chair asking uh for public input if uh there is none or testimony is given once that is done we'll move on to the second article and repeat that process for all the different articles once we have done that um we will close the public hearing we'll come back to the school board meeting and we'll will go into
003um deliberations on the articles that we've just discussed and both the finance committee and the school board will take uh positions any questions about the process super and welcome to everybody in the finance committee hi thank you very much good to see everybody um and I'll turn it back over to Tracy to call us into recess thank you so at this time I'd like to have I'd like to make a motion to recess until the conclusion of the public hearing a second okay motion accepted oh sorry can I do sorry I just I I'm a bulldozzer uh all those in favor and any any opposed no okay great thank you so tonight we here for the brook line School District public hearing go ahead Kelly first of all we have the members of the school
004board and I'd like to publicly thank them for all their efforts during the uh budget season the hours that have gone into this are extensive and appreciated by the administration uh the administration is myself Gina for those of you who don't know uh we have a conflict tonight Hollis has a regular scheduling meeting so she's always doing the hollist meeting uh Lauren is with her and uh Donner is over there doing that and Kelly is with us tonight a little bit about uh student demographics the big thing here is right now we're sitting at 558 and based on the growth and development that we're seeing in the town and using a a private company called nezda that does our enrollment projections uh five years from now they're projecting us to be at about 660 people
005so that'll be a growth of about 102 students over next 5 years so some of the things we're discussing in the budget uh some of the things that we filed with the CIP and items such as that are all based on kind of preparing for some of those enrollment growth pieces now we move into the actual process of the budget in July through September we start with A needs assessment where we basically asked the principls to give us their wish list and then and from October through November uh they work with me and the business administrator and the assistant superintendent and we kind of Whittle that down into what we call our our needs versus necessarily our wants last month we had the benefit of the finance committee coming in and uh hearing the presentation
006about the budget as well as the uh default budget so that has been reviewed then we take another opportunity to look at our tax effort which we'll talk about tonight and we compare the tax effort to the tax cap and we adjust as needed and that has been done and then we have tonight which is our public hearing presentation on the screen you can see the tax cap calculation We compare operating to operating budgets from 25 to 26 and that's an increase of 7.86% and that's a little dependent on the warrant articles that we'll discuss later uh last year we had a uh a support staff warrant article this year we do not have that we have the annual SAU warrant which is the administrative functions provided by the SAU offices which is going from
007473 655 to 493 606 uh later on when you see the presentation on that you'll notice that the total amount that the budget is going up is less than the increase you see here and that's because last year there was more Revenue to offset the expenses this year that Revenue isn't there and that's why even though it's only a $112,000 increase it's a $20,000 increase to Brook line alone and we'll talk about that the overview of the warrant article one is the elections we're looking for a clerk which we'll discuss later tonight for this year's meeting a Treasurer a moderator for one year and two school board members for three years each the filing dates are 1 12325 to 13125 that information uh to get the form will be posted on the SAU website or
008you can just stop in the SAU and we will provide it to you article two is the csda boiler controls um RMS controls and LED lights at both buildings for 9,565 article three is tsda lease contingent on Article 2 so if the voters did not want to do the LED lights uh that $51,100 represents just the boiler pieces it does not represent uh the controls at rmms article four is the operating budget which is an increase of about 7% Article Five is the SAU budget which I talked a little bit about Alison has a question I don't know if you want if we're doing questions now or not but that article uh three with just the boiler that includes the controls and everything to make it that includes it the controls at csda okay yep
009that's I just wanted to clarify that great question thank you and don't hesitate to stop me because I've seen the numbers so many times I'll just get going uh article six is the maintenance trust article seven is to resend the tax cap which we'll talk about article eight is the Cooperative study committee article nine is a petition warant article which will be a a second budget cap to the already existing cap and the total fiscal year 2026 proposed would be 13,855 826 or 99.2% increase so can I just ask a clarifying question then about the tax cap so with a increase of 9.2% are we in violation of that tax cap we are not because we're going to go through a tax cap calculation okay because what the tax cap why the difference between the
010percent and the tax cap is based on Revenue okay and we'll we'll highlight that okay great and here it is right here so if you look at the operating budget uh we see a 7.86% if you notice the best of Warrant was 93 370 lot last year and zero this year the SAU warrant we've spoken about the maintenance Expendable trust is going from 156 to 360 to help us with some of our maintenance issues that have um been put on hold over the years we have what we call the cost savings leas to get lease to get that boiler and then the fund balance return to tax payers that's the critical element because the fund balance return to taxpayers in last year was 338 8650 so that comes off the tax rate so when you
011do that comparison our tax cap amount for this year's budget is s 7.09 and uh for those of you that weren't here and didn't have time to watch the meeting we brought our attorney in to do that presentation uh and he has reviewed that and that has met his standards and that is available online correct like the tax cap presentation so if people like are wanting to watch it you can find it online yep so here's the uh comparison of 25 to 26 uh article two is the support staff contract uh this year article two is the boiler controls LED lease for 9,565 article three is the contingent boiler for 5113 and that would be if article two fails article three could pass but if article two passes article 3 is not even considered the
012operating budget the same numbers as we talked about the same for the SAU budget the maintenance trust and there's your total proposals was 12, 693 385 last year 13855 826 this year uh you have your local Revenue these are some of the places uh we have tuition income from preschool at 24,000 uh we have earnings of about 15,000 food service is 165,000 special ed Aid is down uh going from 15760 to 140 and that is a direct result of the State uh what they've done is historically uh we went over this if people at home wanted to see it the state has uh asked us to take three times of per puple cost and subtract that off the cost of a special ed student and then they've given us 80% of that number now they're
013going to give us approximately 60% of the 80% so that's why that reduction is there the grants uh the same the voted fund balance is 360,000 which is a difference of 24 for 1.3 and that's basically the use of the maintenance trust items that we'll talk about later Medicaid is a reimbursement we get that for some students who um qualify for services and the fund balance to reduce taxes uh last year we had just so people know we had projected because we were having a very difficult year uh we were going to have a fund balance of about 20,000 and we ended up with 338 because in the last few months of the school year we have had a couple significant move outs and with them went uh significant tuitions so that's why there was
014a a a drastic shift uh right now we're running about the same deficit a little better than last year and again we believe uh as our special ed continues to work itself out that hopefully by the end we'll be uh in good shape if not we have the special ed trust that we would recommend going to and then the other is the 20,000 and that could be money that comes into us from uh interest on bank accounts different things like that but nothing of great significance so what you see is the revenue is going down by a so the this is the first time I'm seeing the Medicaid under Revenue can you just explain it so without obviously identifying information or anything is that just like like is are we as a district billing Medicaid
015for special ed services or like where is that we have a uh third party service okay that we work with that does the billing uh for those students who qualify to be reimbursed okay and as you can see it's not a significant amount but every dollar helps yeah no so that's just basically like if a student is qualified you put it through to this third party or they'll help you figure out who's qualified and then that's but it's very specific to programs is what I'm hearing yes okay okay thank you uh state aid estimates again uh adequacy Aid which is the amount of money we get from the state per student is going down by about 5.9% and the retain tax is going down by 11,500 excuse me 11,353 so again we have about a
0165% action in our state aid estimates so from a tax rate info uh we talked about our operating budget and our warrant articles you can see our warrant articles are up slightly that is basically the result of the maintenance trust uh local revenues are down that 50,000 that we talked about the state aid is down slightly the retained state tax is down slightly so the total tax effort last year was $ 8,586 345 this year that effort is 9,951 620 we go through the calculations of both the estimated Brookline tax rate as well as the state tax rate uh and you'll see that that number comes out to 12.4% for the for the tax rate now we're into the specific warrant articles what I will do uh is I will read the article once I've
017read the article the process of the public hearing is to see if there is public input on any article I will turn it back over to the chair she will ask for Testimony in favor and then testimony against and anybody is welcome to come up and speak you just need to provide your name and address uh so that we can have that for the minutes and we'll go through each article in that fashion so article two we article one is the election so we don't cover that is the cost savings Improvement to see if the school district will vote to authorize the school board to enter into a 20-year lease purchase agreement for 1,131 750 to finance the acquisition and installation of energy conservation equipment csda boilers and LED lighting and controls B schools and
018related building improvements at Captain Samuel Douglas Academy and Richard mahaki and Memorial School and to raise and appropriate the sum of 9,565 for payments due under the lease purchase agreement during the 2526 fiscal year the annual lease payments over the 20-year terms is estimated to be 9,565 per year this lease purchase agreement will contain an escape nonap appropriation clause and it's a majority vote required and the estimated net tax impact would be uh 8 cents per thousand to a resident in Brooklyn so here we have a little bit of a break clown we have a boiler at csda that's at the end of its life uh it may just for people at home go another year uh but at the same time it's getting more and more difficult to get parts it's the original boiler
019to the building and at this time we think it's uh necessary to make that change the cost of the boiler and the controls is 616,000 we will get an annual Energy savings of 14,500 and a potential rebate of 10,500 the controls for RMS would be a cost of 45,500 which would give us an annual Energy savings of25 500 and a potential rebate of 5,000 the LED lighting at the annual cost savings we're doing both schools if it passes would be a cost of 470,000 we would get an annual Energy savings of 31,000 and a potential rebate of 70,000 so you see the total Energy savings at 48,000 and the potential rebates of 855 so we have our first year lease payment of 9,5 5 565 minus the annual Energy savings to 48,000 minus the potential
020rebates so for year one it would be cost neutral obviously in years 2 through 20 the rebates will go away so you'll be paying approximately uh 50 co% of the cost uh through your Energy savings um that Energy savings does not take into account the escalation that'll probably happen with electricity and as a result that savings may be slightly more based on that but we we'd rather work off the facts we have than speculate and that is article two so I will turn it um over to Tracy to get testimony sure is there any testimony in favor from the public is there any testimony in opposition to this article all right I have to ask again is there any testimony in favor of this article and is there any testimony in opposition okay I have
021a question on it oh sure absolutely that 8 cents per thousand is that uh coming off the 90,000 number such that the real number even down the line because of the tax savings or the Energy savings will be maybe half that or something like that correct if if if energy costs were to go up that 8 cents per th would go down well is is is that that 8 cents per thousand does that give us 90,000 yeah okay y yep so even if energy cost stay the same because it's something like 40,000 in there correct the real numbers half that correct you're correct yep takes us article three this was uh just so the public knows asked for to put up by the board there'll be discussion when we come back to the board regarding
022if we even uh decide to move forward within article three a contingent article but um the board is in in total control of all the articles that they present petition warrant articles always have to go on the ballot but the board could de side maybe through testimony tonight or for whatever reason that they don't wish to put forward a particular article but article three is a contingent lease article this article will be null and void if article two passes to see if the school district will vote to authorize the school board to enter into a 15-year lease purchase agreement for $616,500 to finance the acquisition installation of boilers controls and related building improvements of Captain Samuel Douglas Academy and to raise and appropriate the sum of $51,100 for payments due under the lease purchase agreement
023during the 2526 fiscal year the annual lease payments over the 15-year term is estimated to be $ 51,1 per year this lease purchase agreement will contain an escape non-appropriation clause and it's a simple majority vote required and you can see that the tax fin PCT has basically been cut half at 4 cents per thousand um a little bit about the contingency article this takes care of the boiler and Associated controls only at csda the 616 250 the same Energy savings the same potential rebates so we see that we have an actual impact to the budget of $26,389 later on since last month when we met with the finance committee and the board we've actually had to change that a little bit because this $8,000 had to go back in in case and not knowing which
024article the board would support to put forward and I'll turn it back over to the chair for testimony on article three is there testimony in favor of article three from the public is there testimony in opposition for the second time is there testimony in favor of this article or is there testimony in opposition are there any questions from the finance committee or the school board okay okay article four is the operating budget to see if the Brookline School District will vote to raise it appropriate as an operating budget not not including Appropriations by special warrant articles and other Appropriations voted separately the amounts set forth on the budget posted with the warrant are as amended by vote of the first session for the purposes set forth therein totally 12, 911, 654 should this article be
025defeated the default budget shall be 12 million3 $ 78,3 181 which is which is the same as last year with certain adjustments required by previous action of the school district or by law or by the governing body May hold one special meeting in accordance with RSA 40 col 13 10 and 16 to make up the issue of a revised operating budget only and a majority vote is required to pass this is $763 per thousand the key items in the operating budget we see an increase of $847,000 which is a 7% change the first item is the academics we are moving forward with a primary literacy program which we implemented already this would be year two that's 96,00 60 we have regular Ed Personnel we are looking at um two positions we have special ed Personnel
026we have five positions that needed to be added to meet the needs of students for $23,100 four for 72,000 for 4450 we have a shared services software $4,280 this is to help reduce the chances of cyber attacks which as all of you know we um encountered one well we didn't but uh one of our vendors did um and facility safety is 177 700 for a total of $761,000 $263,900 uh we have some students who are aging into the co-op so that's one reason and we have some students that we have developed in-house programming so we're able to serve them in our own buildings now special ed transportation is pretty much directly aligned with contracted services and that will be reduced by 185,900 [Music] 81 that would be uh OT PT speech those type of services
027that a child would get at an out of District placement to meet their needs health insurance uh we have seen a number of our staff choose different plans that are uh more user friendly to both the employee and to the SAU for $ reduction we have special ed new positions for 23,100 6 we went over last month uh these positions are directly related to in-house programming presently we have about 12 students that if they were placed out of District would cost us about $3 million a year by having our programming inhouse uh that cost is $879,000 and these positions allow us to service those needs here in our buildings we have regular Ed new positions for 186,187 634 and classroom teaches their CBA component which is their increase that was negotiated um this will be
028the last year of the three-year agreement 168 646 for the major changes total um I think that's off 61577 excellent thank you Kelly so that is the right number that was yes it was yes it was I had to double take the adopted operating budget of 12, 63731 which is last year because now we're talking about the calculation for the default budget things that are required by law are contracted increases in reductions so obviously the teacher contract is contracted by law special ed services would be contracted by law so that increases 361 one time FY 25 expenses is a reduction of 24711 so that gives you a default budget if the operating budget were not to pass we would have a default budget of 12 million 378 381 the default budget details wages and benefits
0294 648,000 Health dental fer and New Hampshire retirement would go up 35 to35 regular Ed Transportation go go up 9,248 regular egg contracted services would go up 2,755 and there really are no other VAR small amounts this year just to kind of highlight the default budget potential cuts and if the B default budget was what the voters selected uh these are my recommendations that doesn't necessarily mean what the school board would do we would come back after the annual meeting we would take the money in the default budget and we would have a discussion of how the school board wanted to prioritize things but if I was going to recommend pieces I would recommend uh removing the kindergarten coordinator uh that's something we uh the SAU staff is actually covering this year and it it's
030difficult but if we had to we would environmental Sciences is a new position we're asking for that would allow uh Dan to change his master schedule and provide a much more um smoother running educational day for students uh the school psychologist we have it up there it's something that I would want to discuss with the board because those costs are not going to go away so we may decide to look elsewhere for that money but it would be 9316 an interventionist works with both our school counselors our school psychologists and our Administration to provide services in District to those students who maybe are struggling or behind their grade level uh the reading literacy program it's year two is a cost of 60,000 SAU walkie-talkies are 19,200 uh we have the sixth grade they have a
031annual uh team building experience for 13,000 they go over to The Brown Center and one of the nice parts of that is they go over there and for in a lot of ways it's one of the first times from an academic standpoint they meet their Harless counterparts so they enter the middle school already hopefully having made some friendships the soccer field right now uh we need a new access ramp so we're not in ADA compliance so we would not be able to use that during the school day life skills renovation uh this is to meet the needs of students replacement tables doors and and flooring that are in the budget we would look at that at 46,000 and comput counter lamination portable skirting and painting for 15,7 55 so would mean a total cuts of
032533 273 uh I can't say that the board in my list would be identical but we would have to come up with the 533 273 and I'll turn it back over to Tracy sure from the public is there testimony in favor of article 4 is there testimony in opposition is there testimony in favor or is there testimony and opposition okay any questions okay turning back to you oh oh oh sorry I didn't see her okay I think that there's a typo in article um so that and I I looked up the I looked up the RSA after the default budget um there should be a semicolon um after District or by law that should be a semicolon so that these are adjustments required by previous action of the school district or by law semicolon or
033the governing body can hold a special meeting okay thank you we'll get that corrected for the publication of it great catch it just didn't make sense to me the way that I was reading it and so I H up the RSA so and I'm not the uh the comma person I love the numbers so thank you all right switch back Kelly if you go to Article Five is the auu budget shall the voters of the Brookline School District adopt a school administrated administrative unit budget of 2,438 355 for the forthcoming fiscal year in which 4936609 of this school district this year's adjusted budget of 2,389 650 with 483,000 th000 and just to clarify for people at home this is the only article where the totals from Brooklyn hollus and the Cooperative on this article are
034added together and the totals have to pass for the article to pass the SAU budget fy2 was 2,434 n95 the budget proposed this year is 2,4 $47,552 1510 increase or a .5% change the adjusted budget is 2,398 184 uh the salaries and benefits of the contracted employees there are 50 uh plus 6,870 and last year the SAU board decided to use Revenue um to offset some of the expenses so this year you see just a $2,510 increase but there I believe was A40 or $50,000 40 yeah last year they used $40,000 of re revenue and it's nice for that tax break at that particular moment but the following year it comes back so even though we're going up 12,510 10 you're really going up because of no Revenue 510 that other 40,000 uh they selected
035to do this because between um my leaving retiring and the superintendent elect coming on board the salary differential allowed us to give the taxpayers a break without seeing a massive Spike this year so that's why you see the the $687 increase there oh that's a quick one the SAU budget uh supports 16 and a half people it is your payroll function your superintendent assistant superintendent director of student services and your business administrator your four key people being a multi-district SAU we have four payrolls four accounts payable four accounts receivable six Collective buying agreements that are all overseen by those people we have um two support people in the SAU the rest are all directly involved with the school districts and mainly with the finances and I want to just recognize them uh because this is
036their busy season um and they do a tremendous job and I'll turn it back over to the chair for input on the SAU okay thank you um for Article 5 is there testimony in favor is there testimony in opposition okay for a second time is there testimony in favor or is there testimony in opposition any questions yes um I just had a question is is the term adjusted budget sort of the same as default budget from a practical standpoint yes okay from a legal standpoint a district is called a default and SAU because it's multi-district is called an adjusted okay thank you article six maintenance trust to see if the school district will vote to raise it appropriate a sum of up to $360,000 to be added to the previously established school facilities maintenance trust
037fund from the July 30th unassigned fund balance typically known as a surplus it it'd be 30 cents per 1,000 presently this is an update on its uh the trust status we have $33,135 we are proposing to use $339,000 this coming summer and we anticipate an ending balance of $ 54,3 2017 what would we like to do uh we are in need uh and I say more than need it it has to happen we need to find the ability to change the phones bells and intercoms here it's a ourc phone system and when you think about it from a a security point of view and everything that we deal with nowadays that upgrade uh needs to happen this is year two of two so we started this planning so we're we're ready for its end of
038life so last year we allocated the same amount uh and this will actually allow Dan to call me and get through on occasion the csda uh this is to create uh a larger step program space for 104,000 the step program is a special ed program it's one of our uh programs where we have cost avoidance it's the example of the 12 students would cost us 3 million out of District by having the in District we pay $879,000 I I don't call it savings I just call it cost avoidance and this 104 would allow us to uh continue to create the appropriate spaces for those students and continue to uh serve those St students in a meaningful way the bathroom Renovations at rmms I'm I'm not sure but they may be original to the building oh
039those are yeah so1 1961 um we have done some floor upgrades and things of that we um could use some more handicapped accessible bathrooms in our facilities so that is Phase One of a multiphase project for 100,000 and then also um kind of mission critical the roof replacement on the Milford Street we've been doing our roofs and phases uh again I want to publicly thank Dan uh he has a former Roofing background and as a result of that he's been able to really assist us with in prioritizing where we go and what sections so this is a major section and kind of I think the final section to uh for the process that's want I correct the the bathrooms so it's the original bathroom area but we've updated stalls and St yeah yeah yeah yeah
040you mean they're not just like keying in a bucket good knows and I'll turn it back over to Tracy for Testimony thank you is there any testimony in favor of article six I ask a question yeah yeah Cindy lroy Lewis Drive can you go to the list Kelly so the create step program spaces is there reason why that's not under the special fund versus the maintenance fund because it's it's a physical space what I'll call walls so we look at that more as maintenance um it typically if we were going to do something with the special ed trust we would do that to service students and it's really designed to uh assist us if we were to not capture somebody in this year's budget so like I'll give you the example why we may go
041to the special ed maintenance trust this year getting par professionals has been very difficult we're legally required to have them for students if it's in their IEP so we are paying for some Paris twice the cost of what we would pay in our normal salary range so that to me is something that we couldn't have been anticipated from a budget point of view and it does in my humble opinion allow us to at least request going to the maintenance excuse me to the special ed trust from the board so we really look at that trust for services as opposed to physical changes okay and these spaces I assume if they're not needed for special ed two years three years four years down the line they can be repurposed for yes yeah I I would call
042um the reconfiguration temporary construction I mean and I don't mean temporary like down tomorrow but in 5 years if needs changed uh you know we can easily move a wall you know I'll give you the example uh yeah um you know wherever we could we would use the the folding walls like they have in the sixth grade at csda because that gives us flexible space and that's really what we're trying to do is create flexible space because we're going to need the space the students in the spaces may change their profiles okay thank you is there any testimon in opposition to article 6 is there any additional testimony in favor or any additional testimony and opposition or any questions oh sorry Kate oh sorry k sorry sorry um so could you the step program spaces
043for csda does that only service students at CSD it's not cross um school it's not rmms students we go ahead that is correct um and it's actually it's really a need now because we're going to be having additional students joining us next year for specifically in this program great yeah and we already have we already have a dedicated space of a step program in RS in rmms okay so it's a it's a kada six Continuum and then it actually continues at the co-op right through the high school is there a step program at the co-op up in high school as well okay so that's really a continuity issue yes thank you Kelly did you have a question yeah I was just wondering if Andy could please just repeat the numbers when you estimated what out
044of District placement cost would be for a number of students at last month's meeting there was a handout so it would be in the minutes of last month if anybody wanted to access it that was at home we have approximately 12 students in our intensive needs programming is what I'll refer to those 12 students if we were to have to place them out a district would be at a cost of approximately $3 million and those would all the expenses uh are guaranteed under the federal law so they're not going to go away by creating these in-house programmingsoftware them for $879,000 approximately so we're getting uh a significant cost avoidance and I also feel that we are giving them um better Services they're not on a bus for 45 minutes a day and I think one
045of the most important things to me personally is they are integrated with their neighborhood friends so you know I'll just use when I grew up um a lot of the students that we Serv as today we would have seen them Sunday at church and that would have been it and their parents would have had them now these students are totally integrated and they're able to play in the neighborhood and it's amazing uh to see them when all of a sudden they're 9th 10th 11th and 12th graders uh if you if you want an uplifting experience go to any any of our Unified sports programming and see our non handicapped students participating with our handicapped students it it's just amazing the connections um so I think it's the right thing to do educationally and it has
046a byproduct where we can avoid some costs and can say one thing for like the purpose of the minutes in case anybody at the deliver of ask what is this step program mean the title is s um Success Through engaging Partnerships so so one additional question again without giving exact numbers or breaking confidentiality are we anticipating that if there's a step program created at csda we would be able to meet the needs of the students in District I mean obviously we can't say for sure but are we hoping that's well an IEP team yeah decides what the student needs so I don't even have any say over it but this programming um through Lauren's uh guidance in leadership I think will allow us to educate the vast the overwhelming majority here in their home District
047so that's that's our goal is to create a space where we could potentially manage most and or all of these in thereby saving us money and out of tuition Place correct and integration correct and in these spaces a lot of times are where if if I was to student being service I might get my math or English or reading services and I'm going down to the classroom for physical education uh music more of the social engagement pieces because my curriculum might be built uh even though I'm uh in a building housing fourth to sixth graders my academic capabilities may be that of a six or seveny old and moving forward from there Kate you got a question um yeah la at our last meeting you had mentioned that um in the future there may be
048an opportunity that students from out of District May come into the Brookline School District is that would the creation of this step program space be an example of leading us to get to that point where we could invite other students to come and then get that funding correct uh that is Lawrence model obviously the spaces are limited to first of all our priority for our students but we could it's kind of I hate to say it like an alott menu the services are design based on that student and that's the tuition cost um and a I'm going to use the word um moderate out of District placement between transportation and services is going to cost around $200,000 uh a residential placement where the child is deemed cannot live at home is going to be in
049the neighborhood of about 450,000 to 500,000 a year so if you think of the child going out as a first grader they they sell them come back so now they're going out at say age six or seven and you're paying that cost plus its escalation until they're 22 years old so sorry one final question or at least for me and this might not be the right place to ask this are we anticipating that if we use the maintenance tress to build the step program are we do we have enough to meet staffing needs or is that going to be an additional budget cost no the staffing needs are are already met they're already met and it's but the ones that would be in there um in the new budget items that's those we're anticipating that
050that would okay so so basically we're just like if we build this we're not going to then be a year well I mean obviously if there's you know people move on or move in or whatever um but right now we're anticipating that it's it's staffed we have enough Staffing to cover it we literally just need the space we need the space and we're we're running it for well I'll say some select children it's just the number coming out of RMS to csda is creating a growth piece okay great thank you um and just to go back to Kate's example if a student came to us from another district and needed a Parra well that District would be build for the parah okay so when I when I send a student out a district I get
051build for the Educational Service the Paras the speech the OT uh all of those components if it's residential it's the meals it's the nighttime shifts to supervisor children uh so it's it's you have to think of that residential piece is you know a child uh is going there and they don't come home Summers okay okay they come home and visit right and things like that but they're basically entering a uh an educational environment that is best suited for them but they're there full-time and the district that places them is the Run that's responsible to pay correct okay okay I think we're at the seven Kelly okay um article 7 to resin the tax capap shall we resin the provisions of RSA 325-b known as the tax cap as adopted by the Brookline School District on
052March 12th 2019 so that there will no longer be a limit on increases increases to the recommended budget in the amount to be raised by local tax taxes this would need a 3- fifths majority of Voters to vote to approve it or a 60% threshold um the board uh suggested this article and the reasoning behind it for those at home was in 2019 when we adopted the 8% tax cap that cap was only on the operating budget so none of the other articles were impacted um and then the legislature recently uh changed the I'll say the definition around the tax cap and basically kind of made it retroactive so now the tax cap is on the entire warrant article and where that will become extremely problematic and it's it's coming quickly will be next year
053when the Brookline teachers union negotiates along with the par Union because you'll be probably 50 to 60% through the tax cap with nothing more than your teachers's contract and uh in other districts and we're the only non City School District that has a tax cap and what it can do is it will start to pit the required special ed funding that I have to meet versus teacher contracts versus operating budgets and it could result in um unfortunately maybe having larger class sizes and things of that nature which I don't think were uh the reasons I was not against the tax cap in 2019 I am not necessarily against an 8% cap on the operating budget I just think once you get into the all the warrant articles especially when you look at um you know
054this building is 1960 something and csda is now 20 years old 25 25 years old so you're starting to head into maintenance issues and those are quite expenses that we just outl we're only doing four things and going to spend $360,000 and that's only phase one of the bathrooms so I'd ask the voters just to consider this uh you know I wouldn't have a problem um if the voters down the road decided to do something else I just think it needs to be uh known that this is going to cause some issues in the coming years when you try to pass teacher contracts and I'll turn it back over to the chair sure thank you um is there testimony in favor of article 7 is there testimony in opposition again is there testim testimony in
055F again Cindy lroy three Lewis Drive um um I am in favor of this article especially due to the new language around including the warrant um I am curious if how did the tax cap this year impact the budget were there items left out of our budget this year or warrants that we passed on because we kind of had to stay within that cap so how did it impact us this year having the tax done I I think um knowing that we had the tax cap what we always do is we Pro prioritize the educational pieces first so the teachers that we're asking for the special head staff that we're asking for I'll say those are essential items to move our school district forward the the maintenance trust just so people understand that that's only
056if we have a fund balance meaning a surplus and we've always funded it that way so that's the only item that's not part of the uh the tax cap so this year when we went through it uh we went through and did our budget did our usual um discussions between the principles and the administration and then when we did the tax cap we were at 7% uh but looking at it and knowing what the contracts uh next year is going to be the first year it impacts us and I just the board wanted to ensure that the community was aware of it prior to it it hitting it hard because I mean when I talk to most people who are moving into Brookline a big reason is the schools it's not the only reason but
057it's a big reason and if all of a sudden um those schools change it's kind of like I I I get sold a different bill of goods yeah and I do as um Johanna mentioned earlier I encourage residents to watch the presentation from a couple meetings ago because it was very enlightening and one key point that the um presenter had made was when the voters voted in the tax cap it was based on the operating budget only good so now going forward is going to be oper budget and warrants and that is a completely different intent um in my opinion so that presentation was very helpful to understand that um so I agree with resending the tax cap in light of it doesn't match the intent now now as what the voters originally wanted thank
058you and is there just last one is there any testimony in opposition of this article question sure question um is there any remedy if a if the town wanted to kind of restructure and build that 8% budget tax cap is there any way to do that legally or they just that's not available anymore well if you rescinded it you would go through next year with out one but next year there's nothing that prevents the school board that working with the town uh or citizens petition from bringing up something uh to that effect as I as I said I was and still not opposed to an 8% cap on the operating budget just I'm not a fan of changing the rules Midstream uh so they could put a petition yes for just the operating budget again
059if that was um well the is that required is that a when I was listening to the um meeting that I missed last week or last whatever that was last month it sounded like um we're not able to pass a tax cap that only affects the operating budget because of the way the RSA is worded that if you have a tax cap it has to meet those guidelines that's correct but did would be nothing preventing the the town of the citizens from coming back with a tax cap with a different percentage okay okay that would take into account now was the entire warrant you know and I think the only year that it would really presents a difficulty is if you have a major bond for construction or you have teachers contracts which I think
060is why it probably in the first place was designed just to be to the budget because you don't have that correct correct and the and the other piece was that the any teachers contract or uh Bond or lease is voted on separately so you were getting what the voters want you to do um so so that's why historically they were outside the tax cap so I just have um a question as well just especially for those at home or who come back and watch this meeting later I mean the voters can override the tax cap correct like if the voters the legislative body chooses to override that however that can be very complicated to try and do but I just want to say that as well um and also just like keeping in mind that
061you know yes I think it's what you're basically saying is when you have full knowledge of what you're voting on a tax cap can be adjusted and to meet those needs versus where we're at right now which is we voted on a tax cap for one thing and now all of a sudden it's just a different thing right okay and from the attorney's presentation the the piece that I think the the citizens would really want to know is that and I've lost my train of thought it don't come back we'll move on I'll make a note you'll come back you're doing great this old age is tough It's Kind it's cold so we ready for article 8 eight yes article 8 is a Cooperative study committee shall the voters of the Brookline School District from
062a Cooperative form a Cooperative study committee to study the ADV advisability of fully joining the Hollis Brookline Cooperative school district and to submit a report of the findings and recommendations to the Brookline School Board um this is based on the economies of scale right now we run multiple cbas multiple contract discussions and would there be a benefit if we were streamlined you know I many times people have talked about you know the SAU and the overhead of those offices but when you're running four payrolls it takes more people than if you're running one payroll um so this will allow the community to to do a study to look at is there a economics of scale and a benefit if they were to decide to join now it's a lengthy process so I don't want anybody
063out there to think if you vote yes on this it happens next fall it's probably a minimum of 3 years and there are what I call um plenty of opportunities of off-ramps if it's something the community does not want to do uh it would also require next year the co-op doing a warrant article would they welcome the Brookline School District that type of thing but I think we've looked at the uh Brookline School District on a few occasions leaving the co-op um and I have to be honest for the 480 something thousand that you pay for the services I personally just from a you know accounting Finance guy think it's a bargain because I cannot imagine with the legal requirements that are are in place now for Staffing and for what is expected by the
064department of Ed that you could reduce those costs by having your own Services I might be wrong I don't think I am uh we have a recent new District uh in in uh Hamstead New Hampshire uh it's simply K to8 their SAU budget is far exceeds ours in the K to eight uh and they probably in some ways have um some more um Staffing than we do in terms of specifics so I just think it's a prudent thing to do for those at home we also just completed our strategic plan for the next five years I think it would provide the superintendent elect with some very valuable information and allow uh not only the school district but the town to kind of plan their future Direction which I commend Brookline because between the Capital Improvements
065projects and everything that's going on right now we kind of really do have a a much better focus than say 11 years ago when I started so I thank them for that and I'll turn it back over to the chair yeah other questions no say can I just say something clarifying because this this is just a study right to see so when you talk about it would take three years to do that we're not talking about turning around if if if the community agrees to the study committee it does not mean we are joining if if the study committee shows that there is are benefits to the streamlined process academically phisically and we and they would like to move forward with that then we start talking about that threeyear or more process to actually make
066uh a a a partnership happen within the co-op so this is strictly just approval to form a committee and to do the study to see what uh benefits if any correct there okay I just wanted to clarify that because it and and again to Do It ultimately it would be another warrant article and the citizens would have to vote for it so you could do the study all three years get all the information put it out there and it can be rejected so I think to Allison's point this is simply just trying to gather data thank you do we do you have a cost estimate for the study um I I don't but I can tell you we just did the uh strategic plann um utilizing vendors that we know and are familiar with our
067district and that ran us just about $110,000 so if it was approved uh my suggestion to superintendent elect was to find that money through the the operating budget uh and I think again because it is a a long process you could break it down into phases where next year could be relatively uh inexpensive in the data Gathering stage and then uh use uh like nezda who we use for enrollment does these type of studies uh and there are a number of um my colleagues out there that do these do private businesses so I was I was going to say was a couple years ago we we funded to do a study to uh disassociate ourselves from the co-op and I believe that was only a couple thousand right to do study so it's a varant
068cost I think the 10 is probably on the high end but once we get approval to do the study then I would imagine we would shop around so that we were not necessarily breaking the big but using the right people to get the correct data and just when we when we go to our um town meeting would there be opportunity to put a cap on the amount that we could spend I feel like this without a dollar amount is a little nerve-wracking um I I'm not opposed to that that's that's why we have public hearing I mean uh that's something when we come back to the session uh the board could take that input and do that uh because it's the board's article well board it's a it's a good piece of feedback could you
069consider that yes you'll still be here to hear the discussion like to do a not to exceed x amount I think so I just think this seems I mean it could be you know a study could be $100,000 a year so that's a very good point having some and and immediately when you said 10K I'm like oh that's so reasonable can I can I ask what about this type of study would take would we expect it to take three years to complete well it's it's a threeyear process so the study would probably be done by next school year but there would be components of discussing it with the Hollis Elementary District to see if they have any interest as well the discussions with the co-op and we only have the annual meetings once now it
070may be something that if the vote is or the legislative body really supports you could have a special uh meeting for this topic only and that could be very beneficial so I didn't want to give the the I usion out there that this was going to be a quick process right so the process of joining the co-op may take 3 years the study itself itself isn't expected to take three years no right and and that's why I wanted to clarify because Andy when you said earlier to take three years we're where it's a little bit of muddying of the waters here of Soup To Nuts versus just the starting steps of understanding what benefits we could have that could be six months to a full year depending on how deep of a dive into a
071study we we go should the town agree that we should look at that data if we were to get that data back and it it was very positive then what Andy is saying if we as a board wanted to proceed with the next steps in seeing if the town was interested in joining then that whole process could take upwards of three years so there two different things that we were talking about when really we should only be concentrating on the warrant here and not and not and I understand you're giving like the full scope of information but I think it just got a little confusing in mixing the two no I think the clarifying is correct and I think the suggestion of the dollar Mount is is appropriate yeah agreed and can I ask one
072more clarifying question I might skip to the part after Tracy does her uh routine of asking for feedback but I'll just ask it now since I'm on a rooll is that this is this particular one has always been a little bit hard for me to understand is there an analogy that you could give that helps me and then people at home understand the co-op SAU the Brookline District the Hollis district is there something similar you could think of well technically we four separate legal entities okay and there a lot of barriers by being separate legal entities so like if I needed a part-time teacher here in Brooklyn and a part-time teacher in Hollis finding a person for half time is much more difficult than finding one person that goes between two districts is it kind
073of like a franch like right now we're set up as a franchise and we'd be can can I take can I take a sound this yeah so so let's let's let's I'm going to um this came up with the governing board right it's like trying to kind of like really understand and grasp like how we operate as holl Brookline um the comparison was made to NASA and like the number of kids in NASA and their administrative costs are lower that's because they are one District they might have quadruple the amount of students but the tasks that the administration needs to do is one time one time to adjust policies for special ed one budget one teacher contract one everything right you come into the Hollis Brookline you have the Brookline School District you have the
074Hollis School District which mirrors Brook lines right with K to six then you have the co-op which is 7 to 12 and if I misspeak please tell me pre pre pre what pre then you have the sa so anytime anything comes down legally it doesn't matter if we have a four the number of students we have to pay our administrative staff through the SAU to edit everything four times so they are doing quadruple amount of work so that you you kind of need to think of it like um maybe like a workspace with like four different sections but we're all in one bubble together but the costs like you just have to pay for everything every time so I don't know if that helps at all um so when we talk about in the past
075like removing from the school district well then we'd have to figure out how to fund 7 to 12 right and we'd still have to pay an administrative unit to do all of the things um by looking at joining the co-op that would eliminate the Brookline School District so then instead of covering costs for four districts we're down to three and if the study shows that it's beneficial right perhaps our partners over in Hollis are interested and that gets us down to essentially one because then you no longer need a governing SAU to cover multiple districts it all gets collapsed down into one like yua is a good example um that governs everything and then if you have a part-time uh position necessary in arm and mass right and perhaps one of the elementary schools over
076in Hollis also have a part person they need instead of trying to find two part-time employees we can find one person that can travel between the schools without any kind of issue in terms of pay or contracts or anything of that nature so it just it solidifies things and makes things uh cleaner to to deal with and far less complicated for our Administration unit um one of the other things that came up and this is just kind of for information sharing right uh all of our board meetings every meeting that we have we are required by law to have somebody with a superintendent license make sure I'm getting this correct in those meetings so when you have four districts because you've got the governing board you've got the co-op you've got Brookline and you've got
077Hollis the the amount of work that that puts on our very limited staff that carries that license so that we meet legal requirements is a lot and so when we start talking about the overhead at the sa but we're paying them to do four jobs at once so if you start thinking about it like that this makes quite a bit of sense um but I think it's hard when people people often will think well we don't have as many students well that doesn't matter because the legal requirements that come down of what we need to do how we need to um fund our schools or or provide for our students not that doesn't change it doesn't matter if we've got one seat in the chair or 15 or 1,500 the the things that need to
078happen still need to happen um with us they need to happen four times so I don't know if that helps ites it no it really does thank you so much you're welcome something tells me I'm going to have to Andy be that explainer um is will lineboro a pre to 12 Co-op District or manat I'm trying to think of like they there are variety of some of them are area school districts right yeah um the one that's closest to us in structure would be um sau39 Amherst so their their their structure is just very similar to our they're they're currently they are right correct yes I understand that but I'm wondering I'm wondering if they have one School Board in their Co-op it usually means that they they have an agreement prek to 12 right
079that's usually Cooperative not an area agreement so that's what I'm wondering is I'm just wondering if there's a model for us to look at and I guess that would be part of the study but you know just for people to sort of like wrap their mind around that not at a city level like Nashua even though I think that's a great example but I'm just wondering if like mic or Wilton lenbo or we can another example that probably very similar to look at is Oyster River okay are they a 12 Coop uh they're a a co-op uh they're Lee Madbury and dorham uh but they only have the one school board um but they have the same demographics as us so we can we can look so I I agree with you once we if
080the voters approve a study we need to identify some districts that we can look at uh one thing I just want to mention uh because the boards have done a tremendous job at this and I don't want to when I'm talking about this study it's kind of looking at I'm going to say the business aspects because we made a conscious decision a number of years ago from a student aspect that we were going to have a curriculum that was designed for the student so we have a portrait of a graduate for Hollis Brookline High School and we worked all the way back to prek so I commend the boards for doing that because they looked at that through the curriculum lens and they were pretty much seamless math programs y I know ex I will
081point out the science teacher at the elementary level which is in this budget which is in this budget but would be cut if we didn't pass the oper budget so I just want to like that yes we have aligned curriculums however Brook line does not have a foreign language program Brookline does not have an environmental Sciences teacher um well the just so you know Hollis no longer has the uh foreign language okay so they went they changed foreign language for environmental okay uh excellent and we hope that the budget's passed so we get that environmental teacher but I'll turn it back over to Tracy to do sure in FA my my fun is there any favor is there any testimony in favor of article eight is there yeah yes thank you can I ask a
082question just your name and address for the uh hi Jesse Basset 8 Rock Raymond Road um so just I it probably somebody's going to ask it um it's not going to get rid of the Brookline schools right it's just correct correct correct pretty sure I knew the answer to that yeah um uh yeah I'm in favor of this with the addition of the um with the Restriction type thing yep um that's it thank you awesome thank you and is there any testimony and opposition and any testimony in favor and any in opposition and any other questions from the committee or the board okay at what point do we put at what point do we amend that when we come back to our board meeting we can do it that we're not technically in our board
083right we're we're in recess y so we have more discussion about that number then yes perfect good good thanks uh so article 9's petition warrant article shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 colon 5-d and Implement a budget cap whereas the school board or budget committee shall not submit a recommended budget that is higher than $225,000 per puple cost times the average daily membership in Residence of the school district as of October 1st of the year immediately preceding the proposed budget year plus an annual increase for inflation using cpi-u for the Boston Cambridge Newton Mass New Hampshire area published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics as of January 1st this requires a 3- fifth majority of the school district so this is we would still have a tax cap but this would be
084a budget cap at $25,000 per child the 25,000 sounds generous until you look at the costs associated with a special ed child who are legally mandated um you know that $879,000 that I've used a couple times tonight is for 12 students that number has to be funded this cap worries me because it's just now a another piece to cap the budget and then the tax cap to tax cap the warrant article which ultimately um I think could be detrimental to your school district yeah and just to clarify again for the people who are streaming or watch us later this is like a double tax cap basically because we as Brookline currently have a tax cap of 8% over our entire warrant and then we would also have this on top of it so we're really
085talking about possibly very constricting budget limitations yes and one of the questions that I have to our attorney uh is because it says the average daily membership in Residence I still am obligated to pay for an outof District student I'm trying to get a legal clarification what does in residents mean so it's possible that this could be even more complicated because we would only be allowed to count the students that were attending school here in in Residence but we would still have to budget for out of placement correct out of okay yeah so there's still clarification on this but it is a Citizens petition it goes to the deliberative session as is and then um it can be discussed and um it will definitely by law move on to the ballot and I'll turn it
086back over to the chair great thank you is there testimony in favor of article nine yeah or questions or questions yes yes Jesse vasate Rock ramond Road um traditionally the petition W articles have submitted by petition at the end are you going to put that in I just know that from the town warrant um they'll put before the recommendations in parentheses submitted by petition oh you're talking about adding the language yeah oh okay yeah yeah yes yep yes that will get that will take place okay and my my interpretation of the intent of the petition article is the membership in Residence of the school district probably means like students attending rather than uh to your point the students going out I me talk I'm not a lawyer but um that's my interpretation at least thank
087you that term in Residence that's not like a specific legal term that has I I don't think so that's why I have that question into the attorney we have a um a scheduled time on Monday because I have three or four petition War articles at the co-op um so it's it's more kind of going through them one after the other to to make sure that I can so you anticipate that we will have attorney guidance on this by deliberative yes and we'll have our attorney who will be providing me with the guidance at deliberative as well so if something comes up he'll speak to it we can just one one other question um read it sounds like it doesn't apply to the war articles just the budget it does that's what it sounds like yes
088to just the budget y okay so this would be like a mechanism that Dan was asking about earlier about yeah sort of indirect method of getting to the it doesn't you know it doesn't map one to one on that but yeah it's it comes from the same RSA I'm just trying to like figure it out 189 Jesse bate Rock Raymond Road I did find it uh 189 colon 1 hyphen D Roman numeral 4 um it is the relevant definition uh you can also find it in section 198 colon 38 definitions I haven't read it yet I just found it when we were looking your head is lots what's it say look at that great Wi-Fi it it's pupils attending schools operated by a school district uh which average daily membership in residents which may include
089publicy or out of District placements right the average daily membership in attendance uh maybe doesn't do that I don't know I would have to read it in more detail not quite so on the spot but no problem the res one is own concerned about that's what it says here right right who areal you're most welcome to send me an email with your thoughts I don't think I have any more on this okay um is there is there any testimony in opposition J I should just sit here S C Lewis Drive um I'm in opposition to this I'm definitely leery of a per pupil cost C because there are certain items whether there's 20 students in this building or 500 students in this building the building still needs to be heated right there there are still
090bills associated that get baked into the per pupil and so I think it's just it can get very dicey very quickly um and as you mentioned the yeah 25,000 there's too much too many variables that go into it I in my opinion to have a per pupil tax count thank you um any other testimony in favor or any testimony in opposition and any questions or comments no okay think that's it yeah at this time I think you can close the public hearing which means we'll return to our regular uh joint meeting with the finance committee all right so at 7:58 we will close the public hearing and return to our Brooklyn school board [Music] meeting the next point of business would be to go through the Articles and take positions on those uh did you
091want to do the clerk first that's what I was going to do thank you for reminding me but I'd like to start off um for those of you here or at home that on where we have been without a district school clerk for a while we sent a flyer home beer backpack mail the other day and um we were very happy to receive a response uh Kelly has spoken to the individual and I'd like to give you some information and recommend her for board approval for the district clerk um I am eager to offer my professional expertise in assist Brookline as a school district clerk I have experienced working in the Telecommunications industry across various regions of the United States where I have assisted the customer assisted with customer interactions as well as permitting and
092Zoning in the Midwest and Northeast regions I hold a master's degree in marketing and a bachelor's degree in communication Sciences I have been living in Brookline for 2 years and have a 7-year-old who attends RM rmms as well as a three-year-old thank you for your time and consideration I look forward to hearing from you and that's from uh Dela Lara and dcha I apologize if I said that wrong uh she lives at 14 Hillside Brook uh Drive in brookly New Hampshire and I would very much appreciate a motion and a discussion around uh moving Ure forward because we are in need of somebody for this year's meeting I will motion to move that forward is there a second second Kelly seconds great discussion I just want to say thank you for stepping up I know
093that this is um you this might not seem like an important job but it really is an important job um to keep our district running to make sure that all of our election materials and all that come together correctly so yeah just really grateful that someone has volunteered and stepped in I go your sance yeah yeah we can't really run on this town without the tremendous work that the volunteers do and so thank you um you know we we need volunteers and so the more you know they say more hands make light work so thank you just need a vote all in favor of passing this forward those opposed okay he passes thank you very much um for the deliberative uh taking the positions on the Articles we will not reread the Articles uh they
094are the same as was presented do we have to do public input um on each of the no no it just says in the agenda public input or that was we're skipping that because we we're not skipping it it was designed to be in the public correct it say public he and that right I know but see I get confed can we at least pull them up on screen or no sure tell can we go back to that one article one um and what I would suggest is that uh for the article we just so moved and then a second and then any discussion and then that would be the appropriate time if we were going to uh decide to remove an article or if you didn't want to put one forward um that would
095be the case we do not need to do anything with article one because that's the election of offices so that takes care of itself are we voting on each article as we go or do you want to do a vote at the end each article as we go uh so article two was the lease purchase agreement and Kelly's working to bring that up that was the 1,131 750 with a lease payment of 9,565 for the boiler LED lights uh and controls at both schools so I just needed do you is there a motion to recommend article two as presented so moveed I second and then we do we vote and then we discuss uh no you discuss T okay is there any discussion any discussion I just want to get things done so I I
096know that this has been a a topic of conversation we had a pretty in-depth discussion about it at our last meeting so um you know I think from my point of view it's helpful to have both this and then obviously or three the article three as well um because I do think that as I was looking at this and thinking about it it was important to me that we really do bring this to the body um you know I I've heard both sides in terms of like there's a lot of savings to be had possibly in rebates with like combining them there's a lot of concern about maybe not getting important things if we don't so I I am happy to see that we're kind of going to really leave that in the hands of
097the community because I think that's what the feedback that I've gotten that people really want is they want to have more control and kind of input on that so I appreciate that we were able to separate okay don't give me that I didn't give you any look I I wish they were completely separate but I just I don't like them packaged together but I've said that at nauseum and at length so I'm not going to beat that any more than I have but Allison sorry does does then but does does two and three not satisfy that no because you you do not even vote because I asked for them to be separate I asked for the boiler in one the lights in the other and if they both pass and if we get a cheaper
098um interest rate on both at once then great if not then it would have been the same as them being packaged together I wanted to see them separate from the jump so um but I mean but if this is the way that we're doing it this is going answer what I'm going I mean I just think it's important to consider though that like at the end of the day like we we're only five people four you know seven people right so there is a significant amount of money to be had in terms of replacing LED lighting and I really just just I don't feel like I'm qualified to make that decision in terms of separating or not so I'd rather present the question and just let them tell us know if that's what they want
099and respect that then then just be like well we five people decided Well I I I don't disagree that there is a cost savings to be had but I disagree that we package them like this because one is a need and one is a want if we're being real the lights work the lights turn on the lights turn off had we done this two years ago the savings would have been higher because the um rebates would have been higher and we didn't do it so I struggle with the push of oh we're going to leave money on the table well we've already left money on the table um and when I talk to people in town and I want to try to hear and listen to everybody I know there are people who very much
100support Energy savings and you know and but there are people who who don't who who would turn around and say the lights work it's not necessarily A need things are a little tight we need a boiler let's go get the boiler so I really wanted to see these as article two is a boiler article three is a light and if they both pass and if they and if there is a savings to be had in an interest rate then combining them that so I'm to me I'm still leaving it in the hands of people if I if we were to have presented it that way but that's not how it's being presented here so I mean would that even be possible though to present it that way and then combine it or do they have
101to be I mean is that is that even an option like like Andy if we were to say Article 2 is lights article 3 is a boiler or whatever do we have to then write another article to say we could combine them if they both pass that's what I guess I'm curious um there would be difficulty with combining them okay okay there would be difficulty in selling uh or getting a company that would take a lease for that small amount okay uh and that's that's a significant piece that uh we would be looking at probably you know just the the lights would be um a few hundred thousand you wouldn't find somebody that really was going to want to do a lease especially for that number of years okay so you know we we did
102take the information back to attorney this is the way he wrote the contingent articles uh you know because he felt this was the the best way because you know and I and maybe I didn't do the best job of presenting to him but I said the article three is what was the need um so article two is the whole piece article three is the need um and the reason we put article three is separate is because if you if you voted down two and past three we get the need you didn't fund the electric because the lights still work but if you felt as a voter that uh it was worth the investment Article 2 was the way to go okay so kind so what I'm hearing is that it sounds like in terms of
103just like the way things need to be packaged and the way things need to be managed that we couldn't really separate them and then come back to combine them later we would have to present a combination and then a separate one and that's really how it if you went much below like article three is 600 and something thousand uh that's going to be a tough lease to sell okay yeah okay as as it was um for article 3 we had to do a 15-year lease there was no way we could do 20 year lease that one so I wonder Kelly the the language in article three doesn't include the language about the lease and so it looks like in article two we're doing a 20-year lease agreement for $1 million and in article three we're
104spending $50,000 so I think that that needs to be clarified because if I was a voter I'd be like wow we're going to spend a million dollars to lease LED lighting over the course of 20 years but it's only going to cost us $50,000 to replace the boiler like I think something's wrong with the way that that's written perhaps the wording on can you go to the SL yeah the slide wording is different than than can you go this this is what will be on the article on the voters okay all right so what we're looking at in the draft that's not not the final dra this is the final I was going to say okay CU yeah cuz I thought I saw 15 years somewhere I was like no I that's that's right I
105forgot that the warrant itself that you guys are looking at is a little different okay so this is what voters would see yes okay because this what what you're looking at is what Don provided just to do the the voting T okay but we I think we'll continue to put the slide up so you did have a motion and a second uh I don't know if you're ready to vote is there any more discussion I I do have a question if we vote yay on Two And nay on like do we have to vote nay on three you don't vote if two passes three is not our recommendation sorry you can no your recommendation what you want to do okay yeah meaning so you can vote I I would like to support number two I
106would also like to support three because if two didn't pass I want three uh I don't want to support um two but I do want to support three because I I think the V is appropriate you your vote is your vote do that make sense it does I just think that will also be confusing to the voters if they're looking like I've done in the past to see well hey what is the board and the finance committee think right and that's why people should attend the deliberative session yes it is so that and if you look at a a neighboring not so closely neighboring District in New Hampshire kir had lines of cars waiting to get into the parking lot for their deliberative session so um really great participant democracy there so but I think
107that's the benefit of the deliberate assession is that we are able to explain right we're able to explain people should come you know Allison will have the opportunity someone will say like why did you why did you vote no she'll be able to explain it why did you vote Yes we'll be able to explain it um and and I think you know we voted yes on three because we knew that there was a chance that two might not pass and we wanted the the voters to have that opportunity you know since it was an opportunity for other discussion the Escape Clause what's the nature of that uh when you do a lease it's required by law to have an escape Clause so if ultimately the voters three years down the road could decide that they
108didn't want to pay it it's tied to we say we're not appropriating that anymore correct okay yep all right so we're voting on article two though just article two just article two okay and just so everyone knows the deliberative session is February 5th at csda what time is that U I believe it's 6:30 with a with a snow date of the next day for February 6 so I hope to see many many people there um all right so we are ready to take a vote all those uh first we'll do the school board all those in favor of this article please raise your hand that's three all those opposed one um for the finance committee please all those in favor to and no oppos thank you then to article oh no thank you before we
109do that is the board opposed to allowing our principles to go home no yeah I'm good I'm good stand okay you can say but Trisha you get on the road I know you got yes thank you for everything so article three uh we just need the uh the motion Tracy yes uh is there a motion to recommend article 3 as presented so moved is there a second thank you discussion so so yeah I just again want to be very clear that for the voters this is an option where we are saying we recognize the boiler is a need we are going to emphasize that the boiler is a need we like to heat our schools um we like our kids to be in school which they cannot be if the building is not heated um
110so this is an option to just take care of that need so I just want to reemphasize that that like we we are really giving the option here to the legislative body that you can tell us what to do and we're separating out a need so we can make it very clear that this is a need that we like and if we don't pass this then we are running the risk of having a much larger exped enture down the line out of a fund or a trust because the boiler has to work like we cannot have kids in a building that's not heated just be very clear about that and as Andy you know described during last month's meeting if there were a failure spiler and I think we talk about this at every deliberative
111session like schools would close until such a time that the boiler could be replaced the superintendent would have to make an emergency decision to purchase what's available and have it installed at the market rate and then hold a special meeting again at a cost to the the legislative body and the taxpayers of Brooklyn to vote to fund that expension after the fact um so it's going to be a lot more expensive cuz when you you know when you're when you plan to replace your dishwasher at home you can shop around and get a good deal when you have to replace it or maybe dishwasher is not a good example but like your refrigerator yeah something that you need um you know you're paying for emergency service boiler you're F you're paying for that emergency uh
112service which is does not come at a discount I do also want to bring up again um what happened recently with our firewalls at school is another good example I believe we had it on the worn articles to replace the firewalls that did not pass they then failed we did have to really kind of mediate that immediately because again kids not be in school without firewalls so the fire alarm annunciator panels maybe I don't know was the fire panels with like what triggers the fire alarm if there's a fire fire panels yes so not the same as the security electronic fire intern not the same as that um but like literally you know what would trigger our fire department to come if needed um that is again another reason that kids would be out of
113school so I just want to REM put that out there as well that we did end up paying I think more to have that replaced um so this is really an opportunity and a and a need for us to replace this at the most coste effective time right now versus later any other discussion no did we ever get um how much we spent in repairs on this boiler over the last decade did that because I I've asked for that I wanted to know how much we've actually spent because I I suspect that will come up the the boiler has come up and has failed I I don't think that there has been any RI car bills on that boiler it's more a matter of the parts are just not made okay and so that was
114the other thing I asked for was like a list of parts that are no longer made because I would like to be able to sit in front of our community and really not well I know that they've voted us here and they trust us there's also something to be said for bringing data to them to say hey here's a list of 15 parts that if one goes we can no longer get it and then we are in this emergency situation um versus yeah it's end the life is 25 years old you know I I I I just I would like to come armed with information because it is a and I am concerned that we're going to lose the boiler and I am concerned that then we're going to find ourselves emergency situation and really
115needing to find ways to cut cost or having to really reach out to the community to fund it and I I I just would like to go armed with information um so if we haven't had a whole lot of repairs on this boiler over the last 10 years great but if we can reach out to whoever Services it and let us know like how many parts actually are not made for this anymore help to get that information but promise that we can okay yeah I but I think that's just us doing our due diligence right it's just pointing out like we have really research this from every opportunity um let's not be like the FAA and run a bunch of computers from 1980 for the national air system that you can't reses anymore so that's
116fun no one will ever fly again sorry guys but um you know that is that is something that's a concern like and it's not just Happening Here We want to make sure that we're being ahead of the times and not finding ourselves stuck in a situation where the one guy who knew how to duct tape the together is gone and and I think another point and we'll certainly discuss this at the deliberative session as well is that if we're able to replace this boiler we will be replacing it with a propane boiler instead of an uh home heating fuel oil boiler which um all the other districts have already um made the transition to propane and so again when think of economies of scale and you know the ability to maintain these systems you know
117that will also be a cost saving for us and you had mentioned Andy correct me if I'm wrong that that would give us propane we could buy as a sa then if everyone is on propane is that correct correct we uh we actually uh currently buy for the town of Brookline as as well because the more you're looking for obviously the better dollar rate that's one of the areas where we have come together as a town school district and we buy propane um town of Hallis town of Brookline and all the schools together and we get pretty good rates okay okay right thank you so if there is no more discussion we can take a vote let's go school board first please all those in favor for n none opposed finance committee all those in
118favor two and zero thank you so before we move on to the next one can I just ask a I was me need to ask this and then I forgot um the what is the DCC at rmms that was in article to is that a control panel yes yes okay is that for the boilers here okay is so what would us replacing that fix at rmms what it does is allow us to have much greater control over okay the Heat and and better access remotely okay so so would that eliminate the Sahara Desert that's in the preschool wing of our MMS uh it would it would yeah I mean hate to say from personal experience when I was in there the other day I was like I'm lost like 10 pounds just it it gets
119it gets all of the systems on on one thing but that that I believe that's going to have to take time to tie everything in oh no no that's fine I just want to I just want to make sure because again I just personally have experienced how um vibrantly warm it is in that part of our school so right thank you so for article four we up to article four yep is there a motion to recommend article for as presented so and a second thank you discussion uh I just want to say thank you again to everybody who put their time and effort into this budget is a relatively flat budget from year to year um and I know that you start with a wish list and I know you guys Whittle it down and
120I know that we did come back to you a few times of like kind of push you and we appreciate and I personally appreciate the work that you did to um get this where it's at for this year so thank you thank you very much deeply appreciated yeah I will second that um I could not stare at these numbers all day could not do it so I appreciate the fact that you guys do that for as many months as you do um I also just want to point out that like when we looked at the list of cuts those were some pretty intensive cuts that we would have to make that really would not benefit our our students at all especially with like having to cut down on an interventionist and having to cut down
121on a school psychologist um school psychology is something we're paying for either way so we can either hire someone and have the ability to pay a rate that is more um like palatable I guess for our taxpayers I'll say or we can contract it out at triple that rate but it's that need is not going to go away like We are required by law to provide those tests and engage in that so um that is something I just want to point out as well we've done you guys have done an excellent job and I think we've all done our due diligence to try and ask questions about getting us to yeah a really good budget um but it's services that are needed and services that are not going to go way so us incorporating it
122into our budget actually allows for better Financial investment and return in our students and provides a better educational experience for our students um they can develop a relationship with these people they can you know rather than having a contractor come in and um you know I've personally seen how that can affect the kids you have someone come in for a little bit then they leave and then they come someone else comes in it takes time to build a relationship and build a rapport and I just think it would really benefit us to be mindful of that in terms of especially the Personnel that we are hoping to hire I don't want to see that get cut so I just want to put that up there so I agree it gives us much more control over
123our finances if we are able to employ a person rather than use contracted Services yeah anything anything else okay all right let's vote let's go school board first all in favor for none any opposed and finance committee all in favor and opposed okay thank you okay Article Five is the SAU budget is there a motion to recommend Article Five as presented I'll second it this time okay thank you thank you uh discussion on Article Five no I just would say again and I think this coin has been you know made um you know the the job that gets done at the SAU level to manage the complexities of you know four different budgets you know different collaborative agreements you know I I do think that we are getting you know these services at a bargain
124for the amount of work that's done and um yeah agree to somebody who said in on this process this year um um for the second year in a row again I reasonable it's levelheaded I know that it may seem like an incredible amount of money for what is perceived to be a small District but again it goes back to our earlier conversation of doing things not in triplicate but in quadruplet however you say that um you know so so I again to to all to the entire team that worked on this budget I again I also say thank you for your hard work and and your attentiveness to the finances and I'll quickly Echo that as the representative from the finance committee that sat in on those sessions is I I felt very confident that
125the team had done their due diligence and it was a very efficient budget so thank you yes I will Echo the thanks and I will also point out this was brought up at um the SAU governing board meeting whenever that was like two months ago or last I can't remember um October yes okay so that was a long time ago um but I think kind of also we're just remembering that it's important for us too to think about burnout because we are welcoming a new superintendent next year um Andy's not thrilled or anything ty not be doing the budget anymore um but you know we don't want to burn that person out and tonight's the perfect example we have two board meetings tonight so without the SAU staff we we're in a bit of a
126crunch there because um without G the ability of Gina to be at Hollis and Andy to be here or vice versa that is something that could really put a monkey wrench in terms of getting our budgets done on time getting all of our hearings done on time um and burnout is a real is a real problem and we have a very limited pool of people um who have the certifications that we need and um who are able to step into these roles so you know this 493 606 might seem like a very arbitrary number but the staff of the seu runs a very tight shift they are very thoughtful about how they spend the money they are you know very on top of it I've never and I see that when I sign the Manifest
127when I look through all that right it's very clear um but yeah we really need to be mindful too that this is also to help us staff appropriately so that we can run all these districts without burning through our staff at a very quick rate because we would like to retain the awesome people that we have working here we don't want them feeling like they don't want to be here anymore yeah okay shall we vote for school board all those in favor and any opposed okay 4 Z and for finance committee all those in favor and opposed two Z thank you okay article six school facilities maintenance trust is there a motion to recommend article 6 as presented and second okay discussion I'm just generally broadly in favor of putting money side yeah I think
128and especially reading that there's um no amount to be raised from taxation um I think that yes we might forego a potential reduction but that's not that's a possible reduction and just given you know we have talked more than once about the age of our buildings um we need we do need to be aware of that so I agree with with Daniel that putting money aside to make sure that our buildings remain in operating order is very important and especially with it not not causing more money to come of Taxation I think it's just a smart thing to do um on the the slides you get down to slide 30 it says Article Five at the top just yeah I noticed that too okay um and by passing this we're able to do those items
129on slide 30 correct yes okay so I am very much in favor of these yes versus lights I would just like Dan to just let I'd slide that in there for everybody because it's a similar here it's a similar cost right and this and and this is where I start looking at like big picture and really trying to be mindful of looking at the whole financial landscape because I feel bad like I I want to support everything that we do and I I hope you know I I feel bad not saying yes let's go do all the lights but then I look at this and I'm like well if we're picking and choose like yes like let's create a step program space let's fix the bells and the inter clubs let's fix the roof I
130I mean I don't want Dan up there shoveling I think Dan be you know like I mean the the bathroom Renovations are important I've got a kindergartener who tells me she holds it all day because she is weird about the bathrooms like she comes home and runs to the potty like I it let's do those things got it the lights work okay I will I I'm not talking about the lights but I will also point out that in terms of the maintenance trust um we're also just to remind everyone as well that we're also looking at that really potential poal cost Savings in terms of special education of being able to service our students which is very important and you know as um a person who has special education needs in their family um to
131have integration is huge to have people in their Community is really huge for quality of life and for being able to kind of allow them to dream for things Beyond School rather than just you know having to stay at home um so you know it's just a reminder too that we're actually looking at if we're looking at strictly at money and finances us putting this money in the maintenance trust putting money aside and being able to make those changes is is bringing yeah it's helping us save money in the long run and really serve our students again better which is our goal here right is to make the educational experience positive for all of our students in our community yep thank you all right should we wait for Kate to get back let keep moving
132okay come back to it okay okay so School Board shall we vote that's okay we got it we got it school board um all those in favor opposed 4 to zero and finance committee all those in favor and opposed thank you okay article 7 is resend the tax cap is there a motion to recommend article 7 as presented I so move thank you a second thank you discussion yeah I mean I just think that we can't I don't think it's fair to the district or to the taxpayers or to the legislative body to um be governed by something that we didn't vote for um and you know if we are beholden to these new rules you know as um decided by the New Hampshire legislature that we as a district are going to really pay
133the price in terms of the quality of our education in terms of our classroom size in terms of our ability to um retain quality Educators and staff um and so I think you know truth in in packaging um you know and as as Andy has said if if the will of the legislative body is that they do want to have some sort of a cap on spending or on taxes raised that um you know that should be um proposed with the current understanding of the current RSA 32 callon five this is the point in time where if we need to reward something we can right yes y okay final listen to this if I don't go to the dber of session and not show up the ballot I don't understand this and I'm wondering if
134there's somewhere in here we can enhance the wording so as adopted by the Brooklyn Brookline School Board on March 12th comma whereas the tax cap was only on the operating budget and the RSA now requires the full but something so something like a change in law just due to change in law or something just to clarify that the original intent that the school board voted on was for the operating budget and now with this new law it's all encompassing and I I don't I don't have the Polish to be able to work that but I feel like the planning board does that like when they have you know um items on the ballot I've seen like the planning board like sort of have an explanation for why they're proposing this Ordinance do that I mean
135I think we can do it can we add that like at the deliberative session can we add it now weina also produces the district report which has all the warrant articles with a brief explanation now but those don't show up at the ballot so if I if I am one of those incredibly busy community members that care enough to show up and read the ballot and vote and want to be able to see all read all the things but I just can't this is where I want the clarification I appreciate that we put it out in multiple spots but at the end of the day when they walk into their Ballot Box this is what they see and you're right the the planning board does put like an italic paragraph underneath are we allowed to
136do that or do we have to actually change the wording in this uh we would change it I would suggest moving this forward and changing it uh at the deliberative session which has happened many times um because then it's the will of the voters and not the board and you also have the benefit of the attorney there to make sure we get it right right so would I need to then go up as a citizen yep to then yes ask us to do this but then on the spot Peter if he's there is going to say okay well how would you word it and I have no idea how well I can we have a a question yes if if he's allowed the bab Madam chairwoman and may it please the board um Jesse bass
137at eight Rock Raymond Road um ju as long as you don't touch the language there that is statutory language that's up on screen right now um so RSA 32 colon 5-c gives specific language for how to resend 32 5-b so you can't modify what's up there ask a lawyer whether or not you can add an explanation or anything to the warrant article itself I'm not sure whether or not you can my my feeling is to let it go to deliberative like this because the that's the moderator's meeting and the moderator by law has quite a lot of flexibility and legal council will be there to guide the moderator so that you won't invalidate something legally I understand your I just know this because it's happened multiple years for us uh and between the moderator and
138the attorney we usually get it right but tonight us sitting here we I wouldn't take that risk as assistant moderator who's being urged by the current moderator to run for moderator I have particular skin in this game so um uh yeah I think the the last time it was you you can but we'll figure it out then right right right and I and again as knowing you're other role that's why you're always welcome to email because as as a moderator you can be connected with the attorney so that you have that clarification before that night oh correct yeah I get to look all this up exactly yeah so like I'm just concerned that if I go up and I raise editing this that they're going to ask me to edit it and I don't know
139but but at the same time if any citizen here if any citizen came tonight it's it's kind of my obligation to work with that Citizen and legal to help with that so I now know the issue I can now go back to Legal the answer may be you can't touch it okay Jesse's point but I would do that for any citizen so I would suggest voting on this the way it is if we can make adjustments I would have that language okay and move forward in that really and you'll help me as a citizen to move forward we would do that for any citizen whether we do that for petition warrant articles just because we want them to be legal that's the biggest thing yeah and I hear what you're saying is that if we
140try and change it now without the benefit of legal input we might actually make a bigger mess correct later which I do not wish to do I would recommend that if you feel like this is not explanatory enough add an explanatory slide and discuss it at the deliberative session um you can also uh I'm not going to speculate on what else you can do without consulting advice first but um at least bring this up the deliberative session you can talk about it as much as you want there um you may not be able to modify it though quick quick question and thank you Jesse and to Allison's point though that the vote that voters may not have listened or been at the deliberative session is it possible to have something if this does not pass
141the implications because I think in some of the other language we have we tried that last year and that was shot down by legal in again it's it's because it's a statutory requirement now there's nothing that would prevent us from doing part of the presentation having something about that uh nothing that prevents us from as Citizens talking to other citizens about the intent but from from the language here I would again I suggest we pass this as is I'll take Allison's concern back to Legal obviously uh Jesse is the assistant moderator uh always can get input from the SAU right and you're more than welcome to on Election Day to stand outside with sandwich boards with more explanation as needed as long as you're outside the election board or I guess I guess in just
142a legal fault you can ask legal Thea question because to Kate's point when I've gone to the ballot and the planning board has had things they have had an italic parentheses underneath with an explanation and I've never seen that for the school board so I I would like to know if we are able to do that and if we're not how can we make it so that we can um because I think it'd be helpful so can we can you follow up with that question as well follow and using the planning board an example since we've seen it in town um but perhaps it's a slightly different form of government I don't know I can't always your Hampshire is very follow even what we have going on here the Restriction here is that there's specific
143statutory language that specifies how the question must be laid out mhm um so in this in here it says the question shall be and then in quotes and you have to put what's in quotes right up there so it's a uh if the planning board is saying shall we adopt a zoning thing and there's no statutory requirement for how that's phrased they can do whatever they want as long as the question is clear um this you're a little bit more restricted on it's the same with the budget items you can't put in a talex this is what will happen if you don't pass the budget on the I'm not looking for this is what will happen I want to say the the original intent was the operating budget because nowhere in here does this speak
144to that and it's an incredibly important piece of information that is unfair to our community to not have that information perhaps the Hollis Brookline rotary online newspaper would like to do a quick little write up on that as well um I think too there's also from what we were talking about with the zoning um I I don't want to add more to to the discussion I know we're going to talk about it but I think they do like a little handout right is that am I remembering correctly last year from from voting like they they do a little like one one sheeter oh to walk in with at voting are we allowed to do that we provide an information guide where when they pick up your ballot you get a little information guide too we
145we don't do it at the ballot we we send it out um District why we put it in the libraries and that again because we can't electioneer so isn't that electioneering Tracy I I mean I'll have to on the planning board can I know where is the planning board I I can ask because I was the school board meeting but that's also town meeting too when they vote no we have town meeting for Brookline right but there are certain like ordinances and stuff that we V on on that go on on paper ballot and that's what she's referring to because I remember sitting there and reading the italics to understand what it was I was voting on I'm trying to like find the sample ballots but need like a login to get onto the I
146mean I think it's I think right now what one of the most important things we can do though is do our best to kind of disseminate that information um that this is a change this is a change that is very new and very recent and really does change the spirit of what the vote was on the tax cap I also think it's important to note that it doesn't mean there can't be a budgetary consideration or a budgetary cap it's more just we want the voters to be aware that this is now impacting everything that's and that's what we're missing so while we figure out how to say that I think one of the best things we can do is say that in meeting say that in and like present that so that we are being
147very clear that like it doesn't mean you can't have a tax cap it doesn't mean that you can't have you know budgetary constrictions what it means is we need to just be aware that those constrictions are going on more than just the operating budget though and that we initially voted only for on the operating budget that's why we as a district are may be recommending that if that's what we decide to present is because we are trying to be clear with you guys that when teacher contracts come up par contracts come up special education which is our favorite unfunded mandate right but it is a law like those those monies have to come from somewhere so we want you guys to be aware of that that those are still going to be funded and that
148may impact general education because that's where so I think that's kind of an approach maybe we can take now while we figure out like the legal side of it um is that we're not just trying to be big Party Poopers we we're really trying to be fair and educational to the community and the legislative body that you're you kind of got sold a bill of goods that now isn't no longer an option and you need to be aware of the impact that's going to have and the only way we can address it is to resend what we currently have and then put something new in place so I would suggest moving forward with your vote on this then uh we will consult legal okay if there's something we can do uh or we'll work on
149a slide that will present this in in a way that is digestible and clear for our community okay okay so let's vote for school board please all those in favor and opposed four to zero and for finance committee all those in favor and all those opposed I'm going to abstain okay so one in favor one y exstension okay so article eight is the Cooperative study guide uh study committee study guide yeah um is there a motion to recommend article 8 as presented so moved is there a second thank you discussion yep I got a question for um Andy because he's had a longstanding career and he's seen these studies come down the pike um it's kind of a two-part question with a single answer I guess uh I like the idea of putting a restrictive
150dollar amount on this what in your opinion and expertise would you recommend that to be that would also not deeply impact our budget this year no knowing that it comes out of our budget I think the dollar amount that was talked about the $10,000 is is more than uh appropriate um because I think to me this first phase is going to be about gathering information so I don't see it as being as labor intensive as if I was doing a study from scratch because I'm going to go get similar districts and things like that so you know my my point would be that if if that's something you wanted to do you could you could put that not to exceed uh in the article uh and do that now and then improve it and take
151your votes uh and then that wording would be adjusted when we put the final copy up um so if that was something you want to do that that would be my suggestion can when if we say not to exceed $110,000 is there a way or is there a wording that we should use that indicates that would come out of the already sentenced own budget like we'd find like we're not going to add to the budget we're not asking for an additional $10,000 from the community like and I know it might be a little tricky to you get where I'm going you get where I'm going with this right like I mean he had the jacket on he was so Clos so Madam chairwoman I may I please theard um the uh the language I've seen
152used before is uh sh the voters uh study committee um submitt a report to be funded out of the school's operating budget um to not exceed $10,000 okay um so the funding source is the existing operating budget not to exceed $10,000 so that there's a cap on it and then you could add there's no tax impact from this Okay resolution the same way that you do the other budget articles but I think just the to be funded out of the operating budget not to exceed $10,000 will cover you it it does okay I agree with the system moderator which which budget would it come out of it would it come out of FY 25 or FY 26 FY 26 so where would we find like what would we would we have to shift things or
153take things out of the operating budget then to no because the likelihood that we could have a staff uh turnover okay uh we could have somebody decide to change insurance I mean in the grand scheme of the budget $10,000 is is not that much okay uh you know you have a mild winter and you don't plow you know I mean so that's why I I feel comfortable then then we address Allison's point that we're not increasing the budget we don't have to go back and recalculate a tax cap or anything because nothing's changing you're basically just saying uh find $110,000 and and that $10,000 we're not hamstringing Gina anywhere uh or the superintendent next year with with finding that and so and that and that was that was like the second part of my question
154of what do you recommend like what would study like this cost but then also what amount also is not going to upset the budget that you guys have worked so hard on and if 10,000 your recommendation then I I would default to your expertise on that agree to that sitting here now I'm sorry go ahead well is that number that came back this year 339,000 or something like that yes right right so you're talking about 3% of that or something yeah and and the and I'm sure they work just as hard on that budget to get it right down to exactly the number right y oh yeah it's it's you know when we're sitting there projecting we're going to have a surplus of 20,000 but then two special ed placements change and now you're at
155330 it that's the most vola is that the child who moves in over the summer or sometimes you have a windfall because a child family gets relocated every Source changes their electri grate by one penny there's your $10,000 boom right exactly so that's I just want to make I just want to make sure that like we're saying because we've gone through four rounds of this budget as well and we're presenting to the public this is what we're planning to spend this money on so this is important and I understand I agree with the cap I don't think we want to have this be an unlimited budget I also just want to make sure that we're not saying to someone oh yes we put this in the budget we presented it to the voters it got
156passed no just kidding cuz now we're taking that 10 grand that's what I just want to make sure remember what you're really doing is giving us a bottom line number okay and then then the board chooses how to spend that bottom line number working with the administration okay okay anything else let's vote School Board Al those do we need to amend it first I I wrote the language that Jesse okay so that's we you were amended yeah so that's what you're passing and what Jesse said was excuse me to be funded out of the school's operating budget not to exceed $10,000 and there's no tax impact okay okay I just want to make sure that that's what we're voting on is that okay so we want to re we want to vote on the article
157as amended correct okay yep okay so is uh do we need another motion no no because this vote will what the amendment okay all right all those in favor opposed okay 4 Z from the school board and finance committee all those in favor well if there's no tax impact here are are you voting okay you don't historically if it hasn't been a financial impact Finance has not taken a position okay only if you want yeah what do you think I mean you're here if you want to raise your hand we're going to do it all right all of the one yes and one no for me okay one one please thank you all right and last but not least article nine um is there a motion to recommend article nine as presented so move and
158a second second thank you discussion bless you yes so yes this is not something that I am in favor of because I think that this is very I think this is very hamstringing um just in terms again of like all of like I think think that a very good point was made especially by Cindy that like bills still have to be paid things still have to be done all of these things like they don't change no matter how many and Alice I think you made this point as well that it doesn't really matter how many people are in the are in the building we also we already have a tax cap we're already looking at the budget with an eye towards keeping things in a very like level manner I just think this feels unnecessary
159and really hamstrings our ability to retain staff to provide quality education to our students and to make sure that we're meeting all the needs that we have I don't I don't want Brookline to suffer from that because we got slammed with like a double and I think it's very I think it's very misleading because in a way this this doesn't make it clear that this is an addition to the tax cap we already have that this is you know we're not the same as like the co-op or Hollis because I think this is on the co-op as well they don't have a tax cap so it's different right like Brookline is a different entity because we already have that so I'm just I'm concerned about that and I don't think this is very clear about
160that if if this passed does it get applied to 26 or do we because we've already gone through all budget and because perhaps the born article with the operating budget may have already well I guess they can vot on the same time like what is it which budget would this first it would go towards 27 which is a with no way to UND do it right and but and by that point I mean I believe we have contracts we have to negotiate next year right so we're negotiating contracts with this hanging over our head and we're not sure how it's going to impact that that's going to make negotiations a real interesting time for I've worked in school districts and with budgets for a long time and having a being hamstrung by a per pupil
161cost is scary yeah member of the public please the assistant sorry excuse me assistant moderator thank you um I just want to make a correction to this having read a bunch um there I'm not sure that you can correct a petition warrant article without contacting the petitioners I haven't looked into that yet I'm still learning I'm only an assistant um it's 32 5-e as an echo um that's the wrong RSA number this is also statutory language um that's listed here so shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 col 5-e and Implement a budget cap um all of that is uh very specific um so if it's not the right language is it even valid the intent of the petition War article is fairly clear since they got one letter wrong um but the rest
162of the statutory language does appear to be fairly correct so what I learned last year uh is that even if it is incorrect if it's a petition War an article if it is not correct of deliberative say session it still goes to ballot and then it still needs to be honored for its intent so it's really important that if this is not correct that we help communicate that so perhaps we can we can work with the petitioner to ensure that it is correct yeah we want to make sure it's correct because if we if we're putting it forward to vote on which we are it I mean we want people to understand what it is that they're voting on I just know like in the past when we've had to go in and cure things
163I don't know if that would be the case like would we have to come in and cure this if it was not correct that's my question I I think um I would agree with Jesse's interpretation and what Allison said about the intent but we have time because if legal I I I made a note I'll be touching Bas with legal if we needed to make a change on the floor we could easily do that to get it correct uh before we moved it forward to the ballot okay right it might be safer and do what legal recommends but if might be safer to leave this alone and then uh when it's brought up on the screen propose uh uh propose a different motion for article 9 you know propose it as amended with the language
164fixed correct um so cor what the lawyers say but right thank you thank you anything else on nine okay all right thank you all right let's vote School Board all those in favor of of this article all of those opposed for uh finance committee are you voting on this yes all of those in favor and all of those opposed two thank you so I think that concludes that uh I just have two things but if the finance committee wants you to make a a motion to adjourn cuz you're done sure thank you guys thank youing as always motion that wej I second all in favor favor thank you both thank you see you guys Del I just have two things I'll try to be quick we don't have a nonpublic no we don't need a
165nonpublic um there is an expense and revenue report in your packet we've made significant progress um since the one you had about 3 months ago go it's still in the negative it's not much different than it was last year um so we're still working on that changes every day I'll let you know if we need to go to the special ed trust or something like that as we get further along the is it is it because we're like is it the special education that's yes it's still those Powers okay so so that would allow us to go to the special education trust if it wasn't special education that wouldn't be that we wouldn't use a specialed trust we would use like the UN correct okay y um the other piece this is our or tra
166traditionally has been our January meeting so uh our next meeting is the February 6th deliberative session and I'll send that out um so we need to vote to cancel the one that's you don't need to vote to cancel it just gets canceled um and then after that we'll be voting day um so I just wanted to make sure I took a a half a second and won't mention any names but if there's anybody who's not looking to run again I wanted to offer my thanks um for all the efforts that have gone into improving us as a board for our community uh and know that your input and your dedication for those members who are not going to come back was valued and appreciated so thank you thank you I will um publicly state that
167I will not be seeking re-election um on the school board and um it has been my honor to serve this community and to do some really good work especially in the policy area I think that we have come a really long way in the last three years um I've learned a lot about our town and our school district um but uh my work life balance has changed to the point where I just um cannot continue um with the obligations but I really do encourage people who are interested in serving the community in this capacity to feel free to reach out to me um if you would like some information about what it's like and um I I encourage people to run thank you for everything you have done it's been a pleasure working with Youk
168and then lastly this is just informational many many steps uh to go if it even becomes a reality uh Kelly was uh approached by an energy company who would like uh the brook line School Board to consider potentially putting a solar or leasing some land to them for a solar field uh so obviously we can't do any of that without voter approval so that wouldn't even be proposed until March of 26 but I just want you to make you aware of the discussion so if you heard it through the grave find you've heard it first we heard yesterday you're hearing today um and we'll we we'll get more information probably by this spring and be able to give the board an update on kind of you know is it something you want to investigate or
169is it something that we're not interested in I mean did they propose where they wanted to put it they proposed they were looking for about four to six acres for a solar field okay so not like on a roof uh no they were looking for a field okay uh and they were looking to uh lease that from us uh for a fee uh and we have multiple questions in terms of you know what what other benefits would we potentially get for allowing them to come on our property where do we have four to six acres that our children don't use we have 110 is it csda it's not all cleared though right no but if they wanted would they have to clear it I don't that again long way to go but I just again
170things make it through the great find somebody who works for this company could live in our community and could come up to you say hey did you hear have a lot of like intriguing questions about this benefits that come yeah I know when they put one on my house they had to take down a bunch of trees which really irritated me so oh see and the cost of wood right now we can sell it pretty and then we can go okay but let's not hire some person I love what you're thinking about Revenue thinking about came in and like logged our neighborhoods some like random guy from n and he literally took out like two houses so let's not do it with that guy so Kelly if you would like to make your final motion
171to before she does our February deliberative session Y is also serving as our meeting yes yes okay I missed that last year and I was like dumb pounded there have been times when we've had like non public before after um yeah I would like to make a motion to adjourn this meeting of the Brookline School Board one second oh all those in favor gota vote got a vote thank you all have