001e e e I wasn't sure about um I'll give Dave L EXC absence I wasn't sure about his attendance but let's with a quorum president I'd like to call this uh meeting of the co-op budget committee to order at 6:31 PM this is a regular meeting of the co-op budget committee for the month of December um is this the thir this is the third Thursday yes I was going to say I think our fourth Thursday would have been um right after Christmas so we've adjusted the calendar accordingly to meet this evening uh the agenda was posted more than um 24 hours in advance of the meeting as required I'd like to introduce myself Darlene man and the members present this evening who include Tom wellan Ryan rer R Blan and Matt McGuire like to welcome
002Kelly cely our business administrator and um note the excused absences of Tom Solon Tom en and Dave L if you could all join me in the pledge allegiance to flag FL the United States of America one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay um I'll note an agenda adjustment um tonight I have the Hessa contract review listed as an agenda item and I shared some materials with regard to the h agreement um Christ wellan um it was not available to attend this um evening due to a schedule change um that was unanticipated and um we'll hold over that conversation and like thorough review of the contract and what was negotiated for our January meeting I did share the materials and if anyone does have any questions we can kind of have
003a kind of high level little discussion maybe come up with some questions specifically for Christa she has negotiated that contract several years in the past and I know her explanation will be thorough um but if we do have any questions um we can discuss them tonight you can send them to me in advance but I'm sure um any concerns or questions would be answered in January um and also I I will say the school board update is likely to be short as Tom Solon the Schoolboard representative is not um present this evening as well so we'll move on with the um information at hand um and uh uh we'll see how things unfold and tonight our U meeting Observer is Brian and we are going to get this approval of minutes correct because um Don
004our recording secretary if I don't get this right I think she'll um maybe stop giving me outlines before the so we do have outstanding minutes from our um September 26th meeting um I believe I forwarded those earlier today I was having just my own computer I was having a problem with the download I don't know why so I forwarded the email that had them previously so we have the minutes from September 26th we have notes from the meeting in October we didn't have a quum present so those are it's just um informational things we discussed no we never officially called to order um or you know made any you know decisions or passed motions so they're just there for um people to you know review just so you're aware of things that were discussed and
005then we'll have the meetings from our November the minutes from our no meeting so at this time I'll take a motion to approve the minutes of the September 26th meeting so moved from Tom wh seconded by Raul um do have them up in front of you Matt so we had Tom and Tom Sol Tom wh Dave Matt and Brian were absent um you can still vote you we're not in attendance if you've if you've reviewed the minutes for Content um so I don't think anyone is really if you're Comfort just vote whatever way you're comfortable depend whether you attended or not or need to abstain get so um seeing no comments or amendments I'll take a motion all those in favor of approving the September 26 meeting three opposed zero exensions Matt Brian and for
006the November 21st um amended minutes there was um an amended uh version sent out earlier today as Don um indicated it was really just a clean up and consolidation um correct some spacing and things like that so there were no real content ships from the original um minutes that were distributed so I'll take a motion to approve the minutes of our uh November 21st meeting so moved Tom will seconded by Raul questions concerns comments seeing none all those in favor of the minutes from November two four oppos zero exstension onean great thank you appreciate that have to date with that see no public present we'll pass over public input and move on to the fy2 budget discussion so I did did include a um updated budget Trend file from Kelly uh who was kind enough
007to update our budget for I guess the retirees oh yes yes so um while the previous version um did in fact improve on the guidance number um that we came up with in November uh this latest view had about another um 100,000 or so the salary adjustment in a line and the line for um the teachers that are retiring was updated so now the operating budget guidance Falls uh just shy of $100,000 um below our guidance so we continue to improve on that and just a reminder for the um it's not a huge complexity it's just an interesting way of how we're going to have to address the budget this year operating budget and the full value of the warrant so right now with that lower operating budget amount the budget itself $100,000 below guidance
008is an increase of 6.34% however we between that number and uh the total budget number we have a double count of at least $600,000 so we have um a PL a project uh to improve the H hbms boilers of 915,000 included in the operating budget and the cost of that repair among other things is included in the hbms boiler lease line for 600,000 so whether the bond or lease um whichever financing mechanism is put forward in the article if that passes 915,000 would be um amended and removed from the operating budget if it does not pass then that 600,000 would come off the total amount and 915 would stay in the budget um for voting uh later in the March meeting so there's a kind of a double there's there is a double count right
009now of the expenses so Kelly was kind enough to include on the superintendent's view page a little summary on the bottom that kind of you know breaks out where things are falling so if we had budget with the 915,000 but not the 600,000 in total um we would have an operating budget increase of 6.34% and a total budget increase of 6.44% if we take out the 915 but include the 600 we would have an operating budget increase of 3% and a total budget increase of 5.43% so um that's kind of of where we stand with the budget I don't think there were any other changes at this time um I did ask Kelly because there's so much um discussion around um health insurance I asked Kelly to give us um provide some documentation about where
010we are with health insurance rates and plans and plan usage and things like that so um the last Trend file that I had um dates back to fy7 and track expenses I think there must have been um something we were doing with the Hessa agreement because I had the Hessa information in there but not the haa information and so on the let's see okay so for the professional staff um looking at the there's a rate um sheet and then an analysis sheet so the rate sheet kind of gives us that overview that one two three four fiveyear overview of plan costs so you can see um the abos which is a site of service plan um for a single starts at seven um it starts at 76811 for a monthly rate um in fy22 moveed
011to 153 6 for two person and family of just 2100 and by FY 26 those rates are up to um just shy of 1100 for a single 2100 for a two person and just under 2900 per month for a family so as we move into FY 26 that's an 8.9% increase on that plan and um a 4.3% increase in the ab10 plan so that's more of a um like $10 co-pay for visits um yeah I think it is that's is right well that's pretty reason yeah so this plan is um again this this was a fiveyear view so five years ago the plan for a single was just under a thousand just under 2,000 for two person and 2666 for family is now up over a 5year period to 1320 per month for a single
012um two persons at 2640 and a family is at 3565 that's why we would be B school would be B right that is the to that's so that's our that's not the this total oh no cost yeah that's total cost and then on the analysis page um we have the district contribution levels and the number of people taking um anticipated to take the plan next year kind of using the census for what we have this year we're anticipating those would be the people that would take it next year so um on the SOS plan it's a 19090 so the co The District covers 100% of a single 90% of a two person and 90% of a family and is there a buyout for people who don't take the plan professional staff and um and administrators
013there so that's like around a thousand no for the professional staff I think it's I want to say it's 2700 okay per month no one time that's the buy out if you don't take insurance for the year yeah said want to be a professional St yeah no that was that's a good number um and it's the same 1999 for um coverage for the non-union administrators and we see the numbers shift a little bit um because I believe the support staff um under Hessa has dollar caps as opposed to a percentage so the um District contribution ratees um shift a little bit dependent upon how much that dollar cap is of the monthly amount which is is changing a little bit so um um that gives us the breakdown can you give me um we also
014have Allied health professionals yeah that's down at the bottom y so those are people who we would pay like through the idea Grant um no these are more like um OTS and um pts spe language yeah right ex are service providers all of those yes okay and so is the 90 8575 that's a flat percentage like everybody else it's not the dollar cap y okay so thanks Kelly for putting that together um it just like I said that I think that fiveyear analysis really does give you an idea of how the industry has changed I mean if you really want to go back to actually the plan that that comp that plan wasn't even available in fy7 fy17 um was probably the the first the best year to use from comparison's sake for haa yeah
015it was at um 642 so like 2third of of where it is today or anticipated be um 1,00 for uh two person and 1700 for a family so there really has been some significant changes over the last well definitely fiveyear period but going further back to um eight or n years ago so the industry has changed pretty dramatically and on Dental um so is there a way to correlate this data with the actual contracts right now so that I'm not sure I understand the question we're paying now in the existing contracts for healthare for the employees right yep so where does that where do those numbers that were the district is pay compared to those projections and those tables that well this is what we're paying right now these These are what the rates were
016okay so one so we know the 8.9% increase in the ABS SOS plan and the ab and the 4.3% in the ab10 plan because Health Trust has solidified those rate increases so we know what they are yes and there's um for the haa agreement we're currently in a s beriz contract and there's no um change to the 100% 9090 over the time term of that contract and then for the Hessa agreement um there based on the red line um view of the contract act there was an increase to the Caps um and I'm not sure like the driver of um but that's basically G you rates and costs per plan right one person two person Etc but obviously we can go to the line items and the actual budget and see what the amounts would
017be toal right yeah there's a total there's one line item for health insurance there yes yeah that incorporates everything plus there's also it also includes shared employees the rates for them and um so in case anybody El they might be nice to have maybe those charge with some sort of highlighting the key numbers that apply to the current contracts or budgeted or plan contracts so looking at you know words that may be some good backgr in case anybody ask sure I mean it adds up on the bottom and to close to what it adds up to in the budget lines the only difference is what we also include in that line which are shared employees and um the uh new employee uh Health uh what do you call them when you hire someone new they
018have to go to the the um our provider to get a employee wellness check I guess I thank you you think of such a simple word um so the increase we're looking at year-over-year is a 177% increase in health insurance and 12% in dental and some anticipated reductions the health insurance opt out so um so were we anticipating like a census shift going into 26 no because if the rates are going up by 8.9 and we're seeing a 17% increase well it probably has everything to do with this year's budget you know it could be the census is now what it is but we've probably budgeted for something something different this year's budget so okay all right um any other questions I had a question from a previous topic before we started focusing on this
019one remind me again the 600k that we have in the budget that may not come out depending on what happens with a war article in front of it so that was the um financing for the it's listed as the boiler lease but it's it's a it's a larger scale project it is yeah yeah that would be the front end the first year for for that project right okay and that that number is still an estimate I'm still waiting so it would be 915 plus is 600 no no it's 95 or 600 or 600 okay the 915 would be just the boiler yeah yeah yeah yeah I wased those discussions right I know just just reminding yeah so the 600 is the longer the larger scale project over a whatever Finance period and that number will
020likely be less than that I'm just waiting for the the final number now they n 15 drops you know which we're not including it then the net uh in percentage increase in the total budget would be what uh the 915 drop offs but we keep the other longer term financing the operating budget is 3.05% and the total budget is 5.43% in case people start asking questions um one of the things we talk talked a little bit about in October was that uh the solar lease piece um Tom gave us kind of an impromptu overview of um the the facilities projects at the November meeting and I believe the facilities committee was going to be meeting and then um bringing recommendations for the board to make a decision on at their um meeting which took place
021last week my understanding is that the decision on the solar pce of the project would not take place until January I believe that's what happened yes um but R since who else is on the committee we usually have so many members of the committee pres and Tom and so now it's you and and Kelly are on the committee of the facilities committee so as a result of the meeting that the facilities committee had that led into the um School Board school board meeting was the solar project still the same um anticipated like rooftop units not going to be a cost like there weren't there were going to be offsetting costs and it wasn't going to be a cost issue for the district that's what the goal is yes okay so is that so that so
022this that decision will be made in January and then finalize as we go so that was the plan that was going forward instead of having the separate uh system on ground yeah they were going to be rooftop units and something about I would just I'll I'll wait till January I guess because I'd still like to understand how it's not costing us anything so but it may cost but um hopefully it won't be a significant amount right so so maybe somewhere between the 600 and 19 yes and and we're still waiting for numbers on that as well right so yeah mhh okay so are there any other um questions data concerns um I just want to look at one quick thing Kelly sometimes we oh uh you had the um public hearing on the um SAU
023budget oh yes so that's the the you the governing board had their meeting and that um pass is moving forward so are there any pending action items or things we need to do between now and the public Hearing in February like putting together briefings or inv yeah the town report um information for both Town reports is due um by mid January and um pending the decision by the board in January um the the amounts for that the financing amounts and things like that will be finalized so that that can go into the public hearing information um there were also five petition warrant articles submitted to date and um those will be added in some way to the public hearing um agenda for our public hearing at the beginning February and yeah just putting together that
024you know General um information in preparation for public hearing so it is just going to be that odd explanation and how that information is presented because there is that kind of over count that makes the budget higher than it will end up being both things won't pass so you know it's the if one then the other type of thing so okay are we planning to have drew Mason come to one of our meting prior to a district meeting to talk about exactly how the meetings are going to take place or is there any any benefit to have those come didn't he meet with the school board he did meet with the school and they um agreed to some rule changes that um to think what three big ones the the the school board did spend
025um a lot of time speaking with Drew Tom andri um attended the meetings um to voice some of the concerns that were voiced earlier in May and I believe Drew um when he drafts his rules will include things like um when a question is moved people online will if that passes to move the question any people if enough time is passed debate itself those involved will sit down um instead of having instead of hearing everybody that's um still on online um there were three things like the majority not simple but the was it super majority yes oh yes it was oh it was a super majority thank you to change the order of the Articles um in the Warren um and a sh present a shift to the presentation that there's um more time given
026to hear presentations or to dis discuss items in the public hearing as opposed to limit presentation yeah for the petition warrant AR doesn't get a special exactly and so we can consolidate the public hearing into one night including everything and move forward in that way and that that will require just a little understanding um of uh who condu if it's necessary to determine who's conducting like which public hearing or if we're it's posted as jointly by both boards I'm not sure of the logistics what exactly needs by RSA to be done if it's for um like a bond versus I think the Bond is the school board's public hearing but the budget is the budget committee's public hearing I don't know so I'm going to let the business [Laughter] who's supposed to move what and
027when and or if we just jointly call everything to order I you know um there are you know rules behind all of that so we will also have um a special meeting I believe the board decided to move forward with the special meeting um for the apportionment formula which will take place at the end of January January 30th I believe it January 30th and the public hearing is I think it's the 15th of January oh okay so that's coming up I think so okay so so just as a refresher in my mind how who and how is the order of the Articles determined the school board School Board the school board determines the order right bonds go first we typically have the order that's bonds contracts and and then the budget but like for example
028the Hollis budget committee does does all of that but they always have their budget article as the last article we put it um more upfront and then the other things fall after it we usually put the petition word articles at at the end um the meeting for the for the um special meeting on the on January 30th does the budget committee meeting for that no no it's a school board meeting we we can attend as as um you know members of the public um yeah I'm not going to be there regardless but but I no I don't conflict but still I was just curious if I don't us calling to order we haven't in the past we have had uh one or two at least one special meeting um maybe it's been two yeah the
029years are just running together yes they are um but it is the board's meeting and and they um will put forward uh basically a renewal of the exist to my knowledge it's a renewal of the existing um abortion formula it's for an up or down vote it can't be amended so it it either passes or it doesn't and and the other article that is up is um to clarify the funding so we because right now it makes it sound like it uh bonds are the only thing we can use so it will clarify that you can also use leases and actually a more robust description of what we can include so yep yeah so that you we really really are addressing like you know Capital financing yes in total as opposed to being you know
030that Target in specific and I and again I think that's just a function of the fact of when the Articles were put together exactly it just wasn't you know no you just bonded things and you didn't think of the other you know typ of mechanisms that were available to to District so just to clean that language up yes so yeah that would require a public hearing as Kelly said that'll be on the 15th and um we would meet as a nor our regular committee meeting is on the 23rd of January um we'll have Lauren um discussing special education we'll have Christa discussing the Hessa agreement we'll have the portion meeting on the 30th and then the public hearing is Thursday the six are we on Monday the 3 yes the third Monday the thir great
031so the the public hearing is is Monday the third Monday the thir yeah I um I may or I probably won't be able to make that okay all right well I think we've Co we covered most of the topics um that I had planned for the evening I don't know any anyone has anything else at this point I had a question on the budget just sure something I noticed I'm not I'm just not not clear on it so the only changes I saw in the budget from round four from round three to round four were this English salary English eer salary retirement benefits and the hesa contract and those I mean those came out to you know minimal $35,000 so different between 4.0 and 3.0 um what was the the retirement benefit change I I
032wasn't clear on that I you mentioned it earlier so um the teachers have a bonus amount that they get if you will uh for retiring if they meet certain criteria I had put left in there um the previous year's number as a placeholder because last time we met we met they still had time someone still had time to to retire which in fact they did so I was able to reduce that number based on the one person that retired okay so just an update yeah it wasn't nothing changed it no nothing changed it was there was a placeholder there and I just put reality in instead thank you okay well great um any other questions is anything so the actual number a budget guidance is that going to officially change as a result of no
033I I would recommend we just hold guidance um where it was and um we'll discuss the fact that the the administration came in at a number better than the number good good credit yeah there's no need to keep you know adjusting and things like that if there continue to be improvements there might be unless there might be improvements on the operating budget side and as Kelly mentioned there'll be some changes to the addition warrant articles um that are listed that right now include the Hessa agreement uh the $125,000 contingency uh maintenance Trust of 300 nothing for the special education lease a placeholder of 600,000 on the boiler lease um the SAU budget amount and uh right now the solar lease place is the solar lease is listed but there's nothing associated with it so things
034might kind of shift a little bit those compon okay great well I appreciate um everybody's time I'm glad that we were were able to kind of um get through some some of the information more quickly and like I said I think January will have a busy month but I think um you know any of your attendance would be gratefully appreciated at the the public hearings the special meeting um special meeting is really important that'll on apportionment that solidify the um apportionment formula for five five years so um what and what we will also do I think in January is review uh just a very high level discussion on the petition articles um because I think I would just like some legal clarification on uh if they can coexist there there are three articles five articles
035um one for sb2 one to establish a charter Commission that only addresses allowing SP2 essentially as a voting mechanism tax cap on the warrant I'm sorry tax tax estimated tax impact on the Warren article um tax cap and a budget cap and so my question is more of Legally how those two can coexist because uh I don't I don't if a a budget cap if you put in a budget cap it has the PO potential to push you over on the tax cap side depending on Revenue elements that are outside of how the budget is calculated and similarly that so I don't know I don't know that how those two can coexist or you just go and I'm not sure if the one that supersedes the other is based on the order in which they
036were approved or good questions you know those types of things and maybe um jimos shauny in kind of reviewing and explaining things to the board might come up with some kind of explanation two separate warrant articles those are two separate Warr articles conly they could be separated one approved one not approved yes or both approved or both approved both rejected you're talking about yeah if they were both approved I don't again the the um the RSA doesn't seem to imply one supersedes the other it just is kind of gives some you know explanation of how it would be calculated because the calculation of a tax cap is now different um the brook line I believe when the Brookline uh School District tax cap was passed it was only on the operating budget itself now the
037tax cap um is on the full value of the warrant which is different as opposed to it being just on the operating budget because those additional articles for like um construction projects for um teacher contracts support staff contracts um those do have the potential to push you know um caps a little bit depending on the level of you know how revenue and other things affect the tax result um so again for a district like Brookline I'm not sure how that affects the tax cap that they have because the one they have in place is now not consistent with the way the law is written but that is an issue for the Brookline School District to work through and um you know it might have to come up again or something like that I don't know
038but have a question if the school board is the one that decides on the order of the Articles and the are being accepted is there any public hearing for when they come up and propose what the war and article should be and then next information on background as a wise needed and in other words as a as a as a citizen of the district I would not like to find out the details of something being offered at the last minute I would like to have some background information and it would seem to me that before War an article can be accepted by the board they should have been so you know you talking about petition War articles yeah yeah well they're submitted ahead of the meeting you you can get them ahead of the meeting
039yeah that's you saying is it discussed from the school board though yeah yeah no they don't no that's not their their purview that's the job of of the petitioner to explain it at the meeting yeah yeah it's not the perview for the first time yeah I see I see what you're saying but that's the way it works it would seem to me that if you wanted support at the meeting you want to do a little bit of lobing ahead of time and that may be having a public hearing maybe uh having in front of going in front of the budget committee or the school board and explaining what you're trying to do look in your mailbox you'll see Flyers no I don't want to see it then I want to see it no I'm saying
040but beforehand people will try to sell you on their abolutely Abol their warrants it's just not a public hearing but they're they'll be they'll be lobbying with you locally yeah but that's that's just how they do it I know it's just how they do it no that's okay all right well seeing no other um topics questions issues my email is always open if anything comes up um and uh there any uh topics or agenda items you know you want added to January it will be that you know that mid January the beginning of February will be busy um but we'll we'll meet weekly and um you know get make some good decisions so um I'll look to Brian for our process overview well we were stayed on topic and this was remarkably one of our
041shortest meetings one of our shortest meetings ever yes I agree I agree excellent okay so as I said we have now a public hearing on the 15th in January thank you for clarifying that Kelly um that's the public hearing for the special meeting we have our regular meeting on the 23rd of January we have a special meeting on on the 30th of January and the public hearing for the warrant on the uh Monday February 3rd Fe I said January 30th did I say 3D I meant January 30th for the special meeting February 3D for the public hearing on our regular warrant and the co-op School District meeting is when March 4th oh the the we have the first a good yeah I don't have that with me I have too many dates in my head
042sorry me second does it it that's what got on my calendar but that sounds right but I just it would make sense we if our if our March 4th is the co-op yeah it is than you we before the election early all right okay great okay um well at this time seeing no other items I will wish everyone a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year and take a motion to adjourn at 711 p.m. so moved from Brian seconded by Raul all those in favor 5 Z thank you Happy New Year yes