CorpusRecord 56024

BSD School Board Meeting 12/18/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SAU41 Meetings
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Hillsborough County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,078 words · about 101 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay I'm Colleen mikovich I'm the board chair Joan Tracy Perry Alison Manion Kate Elkins finance committee Danel K also the finance committee Donna Smith SAU um the administrative um assistant ad business administrator sorry assistant the end of the semester assistant business administrator and Trisha Boule the principal at csda Richard hi there my name is Lauren D Genero I'm the director of student services Gina bcog superintendent elect and Andy Corey superintendent great all right so um let's start with any agenda adjustments that we might need we don't have any we don't we do not have any resignations um and the only correspondence will cover when we go through the draft warrant just we we received one petition warrant article uh and we'll go over that later tonight okay perfect all right so we can move on

002to approval of minutes from uh looks like the October 10th s41 governing board meeting um oh this is so do we have to approve all of these minutes um so you didn't do governing board no you should do the approval of minutes from November um November 20th okay I have the October one all right oh okay all right so for November 20th the only changes that are requested are um page two line 37 replace us with you so I'll make a motion to accept those changes as or accept the minutes as amended does somebody want a second I'll second any discussion okay all in favor I'm just going to vote no because I wasn't here okay well you you're abstaining no I'm going to vote no you can't you can't the governing board meeting that's

003a training yeah it messes up because we don't have Kelly here our quum numbers might or our numbers might be different no okay so three yes and one no all right and then we can move on to the principal's report atricia Enid conc December 11 a couple pictures down below course and it was nice at the chorus level U Mr Trembley our band teacher excuse me music teacher joined in with electric guitar um it was really a one wonderfold showing students uh their talents we had a great crowd present and I think everyone really enjoyed itce job and at RMS there's a lot of excitement in the air here um for this month grade three had a has had a really busy month they have their heritage project that's um we do that every year

004and they the kids do a wonderful job researching a country of their choice and then presenting it uh in our gymnasium so tomorrow is that is that event they also had the opportunity to go on a field trip last Friday to the uh L Mills and they had a great field trip um something that they'll do again um I gave them the challenge of finding a turbine and one group of boys found it so that was good um and we also wanted to thank the PTO they had had held the um kids holiday bazaar uh that was Saturday like two Saturdays ago I believe um and that was just really well attended and it's a nice opportunity for the students to do some shopping for family relatives friends um but we also appreciate too that

005the PTO provides um some little um Buck for I think they call them elf bucks for students that uh for financial need reasons so that's really I appreciate their thought there as well and uh yeah for the break and doing well thank you so I just want to say that I was um volunteering making Christmas ornaments um and a drill happened while I was here and I just wanted to again say how like nice it is to see how those are being run and that every is being run so well um I haven't been to CSD yet but when you want to make preschool ornament there but um it's you know it's just really nice to see that like communication is happening from the top down so you know the principes are communicating to the

006teachers the teachers are then able to empower the students and it goes so smoothly so just really thank you guys so much for all that hard work because I'm sure it's not easy to try and say okay we're going to explain to our kids that there's an you know whatever type of chill it is um but nobody was panicked everyone was was very smooth it was very quick so I just want to publicly say thank you for all of the work you guys are doing on that as well thank you our teachers do a great job and the students did a phenomenal job during the drill and we also just want to thank our safety officials because they're a big part of yeah uh the drills that we do at both buildings but throughout the

007district and it's nice that we have a district that works so well with the safety officials because that's not always the case yeah so it's it's nice we have alignment there so thank you yeah no everything everything is is going well in that department I think so it's good to see just a a quick question too um it looks like we're up three students from November so that was was that was nice to see and also for the par Educators that we need at rmms the three and then the one at csda those are currently be filled by contract yes and we we've made some growth there like I think it was five the last time we're down three and then we're going to get two more students too by the way after the break

008so we're growing as we speak always thank you and that's something we definitely need to keep track of with the work that Tracy and I are doing with the um the not the select the planning board and Michelle Deo because the growth management ordinance has been um sunsetted I don't know if you're all aware so um you know even like the numbers are I think it's from 562 so um the projections the nees DEQ projections too from my understanding are much more they're um not aligned as well as they normally are with reality so there's something we I don't know usually they're I when we did a presentation last year and I did it they're usually incredibly accurate and they're off this year so we there was I guess in some ways good there's less

009students than we anticipated but it's hard to really um plan for that growth when we don't when we were relying on numbers that now are not so reliable plus with all the building that was supposed to happen it's still somewhat happening but anyway I guess it's just more of a longer term thing so great those nezda numbers came up with the governing board say they were off right that they were off there too yeah across the whole District yep oh okay that's strange okay um thank you any other questions or thoughts okay it's actually only 608 but I'll open public input now is there anybody that has any public input there's nobody in the room okay all right so 608 will open it and then do we want to move on to budget discussion okay

010uh I handed out two pieces of information uh to Stat one is just a draft of the warrant these would be the proposed articles that would be potentially putting forth I know there'll be some further discussion on articles potentially tonight uh I just wanted to draw your attention to article six which was a petition warrant article filed by uh citizens it says shall we adopt the provisions of RSA 32 col 5-d and Implement a budget cap whereby the school board or budget committee shall not submit a recommended budget that is higher than $225,000 per pupil cost times the average daily membership in Residence of the school district as of October 1st of the year immediately preceding the proposed budget year plus an annual increase for inflation using cpi-u for the Boston Cambridge Newton mask New

011Hampshire area published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics as of January 1st and that would require a 3- fifth majority of the school district bless you thank you I wanted to highlight that first because it's it's new to the board okay that that came in between our last meeting and now I have also been contacted by another citizen that will be potentially filing a Citizens petition regarding um SP2 which is the town voting versus the annual meeting and we shall also discuss there was discussion by the board uh about potentially doing an article that would be um see if the community wanted the Brookline School District to become part of the co-op and then there was also a question that one of the board members had raised just around the tax cap the because

012when the residents of Brookline adopted the tax cap they did so under a different definition the state legisl has Chang the definition of the tax cap so now as you'll see tonight it includes all the warrant articles and not just the operating budget in Prior years it had just been the tax cap was on the operating budget and the second document I hand handed out is the tax cap calculation okay so as you'll see um the tax cap calculation is a a process that the business administrator uh Gina and I have gone through and then we sent it off to Beed by legal because it is new so right now um the our entire warrant comes out to be 6.85% so if the voters passed everything that would be proposed by the school board that

013would be a an increase of 6.85% for tax purposes for the tax cap purposes I what you do is you take the FY 25 actual and the FY 26 proposed budgets you take any articles last year we had a paraprofessional contract this year we do not you take the SAU budget which is pretty much standard each year you have the maintenance Expendable trust and then the infrastructure lease which we'll be discussing later on tonight which gives you a total of all the war then what is subtracted from that is what we actually return to the taxpayers so we sent back $338,500 to offset the current tax rates and we are budgeting for $1,000 we feel very confident that we can reach that plateau uh to again reduce taxes next year so when you do that

014calculation uh you see 6.85 Kelly um put a no to NIS there she had more time between last meeting and this meeting to work on the infrastructure lease and she's quite confident now with that number of 90,000 $565 okay so that is the tax cap we'll get that posted um probably the end of this week so it'll be out there for residents and that is the draft warrant if there's no questions I'll actually go into um a variety of pieces that are in board packet so I just have one question Andy about the infrastructure lease so the 9,565 that would be this year's payment the first Year's payment that would be the first Year's payment correct do you know how that would be impacted like in following years sure uh this year's payment because of

015rebates and Energy savings would be cost neutral okay okay next year's payment uh uh the rebates would no longer exist so you'd see a little bit over 50% % of that uh through Energy savings about $48,000 to $50,000 so the payment when you offset the budget would really come out to be uh about half of that okay but our notification has to be for the whole amount of the taxpayers okay thank you I have a couple questions sure uh this may not be readily accessible the 2025 fund balance that was returned was the estimate at the beginning of the year and then if it was substantially different than that we were actually estimating um not having enough money and having to utilize one of our trusts at the beginning there that was yeah what was

016it that led to this being different the the difference is the most volatile what we're going to talk about in a minute is the special ed component so like right now uh when you look at our numbers for today they're better than they were in August and September because we had the start the year with contracted Paris so uh that is not a number you can budget for it's almost two and a half times what we pay a par um so that's what really is creating the difficulty and in some instances in February March April uh a child could move out of district and one child moving can be a windfall from a budget sense so that's where where the unexpected differences came in all right thank youcome other question 360,000 in the trust there

017Y how was that number arrived at uh when we go through the new items we're going to it's broken down number by number uh and that's really just because we're getting to the point where at some point we're either going to have to do a large capital investment do a bond or a lease or we're going to have to increase the maintenance trust so this year we're looking at kind of a combination of both with a a potential proposed lease and a increase in mainten trust it okay um kind of to highlight that special ed piece um we wanted to just break it down a little bit and I want to thank Lauren and her department for their efforts because they provided in your packet a special education overview and right now we have about

01814% of our students of 45 total students out of 316 at RMS that receive special services we have 47 uh approximately 18% at csda we have three specialized programs in Brooklyn we have a step program for K to three we have a life skills program for grades four to six and an EBD program in grades 4 to six the outou of District cost for students as you can see uh are extensive a tuition for one of those students and we have 12 currently that are out of District uh oh excuse me out in the program accessing one of the three programs I outlined the tuition ranges out of District between 100,000 and 200,000 related Services range from 30 to 75 if they needed and transportation is between 100 and 200,000 so the 12 students that

019are currently in our program if we had to place them out of District would range between 200 and $475,000 per student per student per student per year per student per year make sure we're yes clear on that that that's per student student per year per year whereas we developed the in-house programming uh our expenses are a special ed teacher which is a shared cost with an average salary of $76,000 plus pro potential benefits for the three programs above you have individual costs for the par Educators there are 13 of them now they are $28,000 which we budgeted and that gives us 336,000 the related Services which are shared cost as needed are for speech pathologist about 25,000 an occupational therapist about 25,000 a bcba of 40,000 and other related services for 30,000 and transportation quite

020often when they're in District we can share costs and that will range between 60 and 75,000 for special transportation and that's total for all those students is not per student that 60 to 75,000 is for all for for all the specialized transportation in District right so that gives you an estimated car cost uh in District of$ because as I just read you the petition warrant article wants us to cap at $25,000 it it's from a regular Ed perspective 25,000 seems like a lot of money but from a special ed perspective you know one special ed child is eating up almost three times that cost and if they do need to go out a district they could be equivalent to 10 to 20 um the other problem we're facing is the state of New Hampshire is

021reducing their funding even though it's a federal mandate and it's required by law uh they had been picking up 80% of the cost and now they're going to pick up 63% of the 80% and the rest of that cost is allocated to the local taxpayer because it's still federally mandated so we we cannot ignore doing it right and that cap is getting high the special8 cap is getting higher and with us receiving less money back you know you're going to lose more of that differential so and and they're estimating that next year we're going to be receiving 50 something back 57% back like it's going to be even less can you just explain that to people as if they sure didn't know have any background so like the how much we pay initially for say

022a student is excluding Transportation $200,000 a year for an out a district placement how would that so our special education Aid cap for this year fy2 is $775,000 in change I don't have the exact amount um so if a student's Pro programming let's say their tuition is $200,000 that we're paying so anything above that 75,000 so 200,000 minus 75,000 we would get 80% of that back okay um on a typical year per the formula but because of the special a Aid cost in the state they're not able to pay everybody back that 80% they've now done like a pro pro pro rated differential so now School District are getting 67% of that back so we're now not getting 80% back we're getting 67% back and they're estimating that next year school districts are going to

023get even less than that back we might go down to 57 58% back um but odds are with out of District cost that's going to be much higher that we you know should have gotten back um but if we're able again to have students in District keep our costs down then we don't have to even hit that special a Aid cap and then worry about what we'd get back in Revenue after that and is this just for St students kindergarten right because I know Early Education sometimes they'll apply for Medicaid right is that separate from this this would include well this would include pre preschool through grade six but we don't have any intensive needs Pro programming at the preschool level at this point right okay so I think what I'm trying to Fig figure

024out in my head is like if we're not getting as much back from the state but it seems like early intervention is getting things back from the federal government is that kind of the difference in terms of like costs private private early intervention is different than our preschool programming so we don't have um I mean if if a preschool program did cost that special Aid cap and then we went above that we would still um be able to apply that but often times preschool costs won't go up that high like we won't hit that okay yeah no I was just because it just said K through which I get like that oh I only said that because of where our our our industri the programming is that would prevent students having to go out of

025District okay does that make sense and if we ever did have an intensive needs at the preschool level I I would add that to this sheet y if we created that at some point if we had a need to I assume when we're looking for added District placements that most of them do provide the related Services though so instead of paying extra for them on yes but often times if a student needs a power educator in that out District we pay the power educator cost it's not included within the tuition um and then there are some um added District placements where speech is contracted out or School site is contracted out so that does vary just by school um it just depends on what the related services are so I always kind of throw that

026in there if needed because that could definitely be a factor I was just going to say um but still if a student is at an out a district placement there's the tuition component and one student might have OT that's an add-on to the tuition even if they're not Contracting it's their individual and then student B over here um pays the tuition maybe they need OT and PT so those are two add-ons to the tuition so there's still the differential regardless of if they are Contracting for that or not or we are Contracting that do that make sense used to be are some schools no no no you're correct there are some schools where it is a package deal depending on what the students needs are where yes speech would be included and what have you

027but it just varies by school plac no um and then with the other related costs is that PT here like so because I see spech I see OT BCB so if like a student needs PTR or another service that's not correct so other related Services could be Vision it could be Physical Therapy it could be orientation Mobility it could be a variety of things but those costs you know again are neg are factor out to be about that for the students who receed them okay can I just talk through some math a little bit I just want to make sure I'm really thinking about this to get the full impact so if we said tuition for out of states or for out of District was 200 and the cap is 75 and we get 80%

028back so 200 minus 75 is 125 80% of 125 is 100 is that now going to be 67% of that 100 yes yes okay and I don't think you'll see 67% we all comes no I we'll be lucky to see and the other thing to keep in mind is the time it takes to submit and then actually receive the revenue months later yeah yeah so we would still be responsible for $667,000 is that well well we we PID the tuition we paid through our budget regard so it's just a matter of when we try to estimate Revenue that comes back each year we would try to factor in the revenue that we get back from Special Education Aid so what we typically try to do is that 80% the the formula that we're given right

029but because we know the state of special education Aid right right right now I've actually been kind of lowballing that Revenue when I talked to Kelly and Andy and Gina just because I I'm really don't expect to get much of that back and to Gina's point you get it a year later like 14 months L you get it so really we we have to budget for all of this and we budget for all of it and we pay it and then the revenue is just extra Revenue 14 months later yeah yeah no I just wanted to make sure I was I was understanding because that's still you're still fronting all that money corre and that's the that's the problem correct we have to budget and and pay it regardless of what happens with the state

030aid right right and we're only getting the 62 back so you're you're picking up 138 of that M from the get go so that's why it's critical that we believe we need to continue to develop our in-house programming one because we believe the programming is better for our students correct two it keeps them in their local schools with their neighborhood friends and three some of these children are on a bus for 45 minutes to an hour to get to some of these placements yes so those are our our three primary drivers of why we want to have the programming and then there's a I'll call it a benefit of cost avoidance because if you just look at the the cost comparison on the back side of that page it's the estimated total cost based on

031C current enrollment if we were placing them all out would be $3 million the current cost that we're we're impacting is $787,000 so it really developing these programs are so much more beneficial and then Lauren made a great point if in August a child moves in and we don't have any programming we have to find 200 to 475,000 because our budget's already passed we don't go go get to go back and say we need more whereas if we have the programming in house by adding another body on top of the 12 that are in our programming it would be 19,000 and Andy if I can pick you back on that and just to point out and it is on the sheet too that these programs can hold up to 20 24 students you know and

032so as of right now the way that they're structured um and of course we can always inrease and build upon that you'd have to add teachers or what have you as you go but right now this under this model of this cost that can service up to 24 students um through the through the programming um the other piece is as programs like this become more and more established some some of these are in their newer stages um and some are are more established there are districts around that do look for placements in other districts so I have people reach out to me saying I'd like to you know refer one of my students to your program do you have space we would tuition them in and so that could potentially as our programs Build and

033Grow become a source of Revenue because we could put tuition students in um if we wanted to do we have a number just roughly on how many students right now are being tuition out of District I I try not to give kind of exact numbers due to privacy just like guesstimate no I mean I know I know how many but I I know identifiable I'm just saying I guess in terms of the math cost I'm I guess I'm want maybe rather than a number less than less than a handful okay yeah thank you and the biggest thing that the board is well aware of right now that we're struggling with is the hiring of Paris because without Paris we could be forced to um have to place a child out of District so and again

034right now a contractor par is running about twice the cost of our par the biggest uh barrier to hiring paers is lack of health insurance and I say that because we have contracts coming up next year uh we have we're fully staffed at the co-op because they they provide health insurance to their uh Paris and then in the um current contract that will be going to the voters in Hollis they have stepped forward and provided benefits for their Paris as well so uh it's just something to keep on the back burner as you head into negotiations year we would be the only District without benefits that's correct in our in our any District that don't do it but everybody's starting to move to that Trend because as you know in the industry there are certain

035even part-time jobs now where you can get full benefits what what percentage cost would adding health insurance add to that repair if we were able to get away from you know Contracting to bring that yeah it diff differs um you know it all depends on negotiations but hold on um one moment would probably be about 38% so just looking at year one of a contract of a support staff contract it's going to go before the voters in hollas it's um $362,450 that being said this current year they've been paying about 600,000 for contracted Paris so it's a huge number for a support staff contract but we're paying way more than that anyway uh but this way you get the benefit of having your own employees that you can fully train and be a little bit

036more selected with so um so that's just a philosophical um thing to ponder when going into negotiations next year it's something that both Hollis and Brooklyn have struggled with for years and we're presently playing uh about 500,000 contracted pars this year now that's coming down because our principles have done an outstanding job of beating the bushes and advertising and working with HR to bring people on board that are our own employees and as soon as we do that we release the contract to par um but it's it's very difficult hiring environment across the board moving on to sorry and sorry just one more question when we say that the the 75 special ed cap is 75 and we are at 60 about 66 is that does that mean that we are fully able to be

037to be reimbursed for no so what happens is so that that's 75,000 it's actually $753 $19 is the special cap so any student that exceeds that threshold we can we can put in for special ed Aid to get back above the 75,000 anyone that hits that threshold above that we can put in for reimbursement um but if it's below that then you don't get reimbursed anything so okay that's that's the cap that they've determined school districts can afford yeah I'm just yeah no I mean I think it's I mean the 75 is not you know it's not workable but that we're at 65 offering such a robust program I think that is really says a lot about the programs that we have here in in now thank you uh next senior board packet that I'd

038like to cover is What's called the default budget the default budget is the number that is a Formula that goes on the warrant and if the operating budget proposed by the school board were to fail the default budget is the number that we get to work with um pretty much almost all of our our default budget difference because the FY 26 default budget number comes out to be $3,229 447 the budget as it sits right now with the school board is 13,825 261 the difference is that $595,000 items sheet wait so sorry so the print out says 12 million and this say he's reading the total warrant dollar amount the bottom so we're oh we're not reading just article three okay I'm not gonna look at this that's fine I'll just look at this sheet

039and I'll Focus I I I'll use that number to explain it there the default budget is 12,285 275 the proposed budget is 12,881 089 which is the $595,000 provided by the business administrator so if you look at uh its Personnel contracts it's teacher Lane changes uh Personnel contracts uh contracted service is going down significantly aition tuition Services is going up um again Personnel contracts contracted Services again so you see it's it's say it basically comes down to anything that is not a contractual obligation next year or was not already in the budget does not become part of the default budget and we'll spend more time on this uh at the public hearing but this was an opportunity to get it out to the board and then uh Kelly provided you with the complete um Excel

040spreadsheet the line by line items reductions that correspond with the default in terms of how it was calculated and again the default budget is a a legal calculation um so if you get to the end of the um information regarding the default budget you'll again see that if the default budget were passed the we would be at a 4.8% increase one one question it in the lines that are make up the 595 I'm assuming it's SAU assessment and down how would we not be able to pay the SAU assessment no the the the 595 is your new items right the SAU is totally different oh I see uh because the SAU is uh it's not called a default it's called adjusted budget so again there'll be two numbers on that and that's based on the

041equalized valuation of the property in the towns and the overall SAU budget this year is only going up $112,000 the difference is again we're seeing Revenue Cuts so last year we had $53,000 more of Revenue that we don't have this year and that's why the uh the apportionment to each of the communities is increased more than just a total of the 12,000 and that gets us to um really a kind of opportunity to go through the new items discuss them again and have the board decide if they're happy to be at the number we're at if they'd like adjustments if they'd like to look at other warrant articles to be added to the warrant just giving the SAU kind of uh some directions that will we get from now until uh the January public hearing

042we can fine-tune that so if there's no questions on the default I'll move to the the new items when we're looking at the when you're speaking to looking at the default budget this worksheet and and is that also including these reasons yes so could I just ask a clarifying question then okay so the way I'm looking at it is um account um account line number 2800 to 29999 which is all around it looks like insurances I'm not seeing it reflected on this summary page in the same way the summary page okay um encompasses more of the accounts than the reasoning page I think is what I'm not exactly sure of your question I guess on the um the summary page it has it does doesn't have 28 to 2999 it has 29 to 2999 oh

043there's just may a I think 28 because it's 8701 would you be able to I I do think it might just be a because the number is the same total it just it just jump on the on the summary it just jumps from 2799 to 2900 I think there should be 7800 okay and maybe the same it looks like with 2499 to 2600 potentially I don't know okay again we'll we'll we'll go back to Kelly and get that clarified but I know our numbers okay in terms of the total piece are accurate okay moving to new items the first thing uh we have is academics so we see the new uh programming for ELA uh the literacy programming the literacy programming training and consumables this is year two of that program we're seeing very strong

044results from uh CK um we have some student chairs I know it how do student chairs fit under academics but that's the coding that we're provided by the state uh some dry erased kidney board at grade three uh preschool table rep replacement brass instruments and Foundations decodables as you can see when we started round one we were at 7,939 and we' cut that back to 51,4 60 moving down to csda because we try to break everything down by its uh cost center we have 10,000 for the literacy program 8,000 again for the consumables and training uh student desks 100 $76 a desk The Brown Center event at csda The Brown Center is a um a a training center through UNH that comes over and does all sorts of different leadership training with our students it's

045been very well received uh we were able to do it the first couple years out of grant money and again the grants have uh dissipated and gone away uh you also see the 9500 uh sixth grad is as a culminating event go to The Brown Center um and spend a day there on the UNH campus doing a lot of what I call challenge drills and and different uh growth pieces uh and it goes very well and the teachers have been very happy with it uh a laminator some dry erase kidney tables and an AED replacement in the gym so we went from 50,400 to 454 uh reducing csda on academics are there any questions on the academics I'll try to stop each section so it won't become too uh much so I yes so just

046really quickly like with the preschool classroom I think Dan you had said that we were setting we were establishing a classroom correct for the preschool we have two we have two preschool classes yeah uh we're just looking to improve the uh Furniture needs that we have in there because those are like it's borrowed and used furniture other areas of the building right so I was actually just wondering why we could we possibly add the toy storage back in I I know it's $700 but I'm like is that something that would be helpful like is that I mean I'm just curious about that like in terms of like what is toy storage right now now like would it be beneficial for us to replace it like or is it going to be worse of like say

047something breaks next year and there like that kind of thing you're looking at adding it back in yes right now yes um I mean as many dollars as you want to give us okay I but at the same time it's it's that delicate balance of getting to what we believe is a a good number for the community I think my my question is is like okay you know if we're looking at adding it back in like is there a safety issue right because like I know there's no safety issues yeah so I will sh that when you when you um when you keep staying on the board for year after year you'll see that you see items and then we end up cutting them and we prioritize them based on safety and like immediate need

048so you'll see the prechool toy storage again next year okay and um you know the the preschool classrooms we were both fully used and and then um we we didn't fully use the other so you'll see it again and when we absolutely feel that we can't move on without it for some real reason such as safety Etc it's not going to be cut right I think my my thought though is is that it's like would it be better to pay 700 now or 1,400 later that's my question also cuz preschoolers are pretty rough on things so like you know like they they're abusive I love them but they're they're physical with toys and storage and things like that do do we have the chance to go through this one more time and for the next

049meeting is there a chance to look at this area or no well the next meeting is the public because I was if we needed to what we could do is where we have four dry race tables next year we have four third grade classes instead of five make get three because we did get one dry erase table this past year that free up that would free up enough to cover this the preschool and again I think the key is um if we could go through it and then kind of make more of a global decision because I I think we're getting into the weeds because once you pass the budget or the voters approve a budget it becomes a bottom line number okay so if all of a sudden Dan said to me after the

050bottom line number is passed he wants to reduce a kidney table and get a storage thing that's something that that's the we could do okay that's right I just I'm thinking like long term I know we've had a couple of discussions on the board about how things are not getting cheaper price is only increasing and so while I I absolutely appreciate and understand that like we're not going to let unsafe things in the classroom that's right I just also worry like are we really doing our due diligence to the taxpayer by putting something off that we could get for a significantly more costeffective cost now rather than having it double sure and then speaking of the bottom line budget just another thing to consider the moment there's a shift in the student population and let's

051say we needed one of those um out of District Place placements all of those items that we highight as needs go out the door and then we need to cover what we have to cover so so we we do our best and we evate Andy but sometimes it shifts in the opposite direction and then we're able to get something that we didn't think we would be able to yeah I just I think part of my question is too is like as we're watching enrollment numbers go up are you know I know sometimes preschools can shift right so we were using both and we were only using one now we're back to using both like if we anticipate that that's going to stay that we're going to be using both I feel like it would be

052more beneficial for us to give them the tools that they need now than it would be to say okay like we'll buit off so that's just my thought I mean I I think I hear what you're saying about the bottom line number so we don't necessarily need to add it back in but it is something that I think we should look at if there's room or extra Joan I I will say I I trust them not fully with with what they're saying they need and you will see like we'll we'll see that toy storage back I guarantee and and we're probably going to see it zeroed out again next year it'll come eventually and like I think you can build the toy St glob right like what they're saying with the the the bottom line

053number is really where Focus to because it's a number correct me if ipe but you are allowed to shift Line to Line so long as you stay within that bottom line number correct L line item has been zeroed out directly by um by a Community member at the deliberative session we're allowed to shift that money correct as we just ease your just ease your concern about I have utmost faith and trust in our sa I have no doubt that they are being very safe and very thoughtful about that I'm I'm just saying like when I'm looking at this and I'm hearing we're establishing a classroom we don't know that that like we don't think that classroom is going to be decreased in size then I'm saying why why don't we think about Staffing or getting

054it set up now when it's most cost effect that's that's all I'm saying so like I I don't think you guys are trying to like you know topple the preschoolers I'm just I'm just thinking about like what do we need to do to like be most cost effective for our district no and I I appreciate it and I made a note uh and that's exactly why we go through this um the next section is uh Personnel sorry just one one oh sure Tracy we had talked a little bit about the the partial funding from the PTO for the rock wall and I know that it's zeroed out um but and I know there's no member of the PTO here I don't think but um just wondering if we've had any conversations about if the money

055that they raised would be like held for us or if if it was just for the rock wall so for the Rockall um Andy and I did talk about this they've raised I believe it's $7,500 to $10,000 to be used for I think it was $7,500 for the rock wall area and then some additional funds to like do some painting around the area but there is there is set aside funds there and I think there's some grant money as well there was a grant that was just applied for was just applied for so so then I guess I just I'm wondering if if we do have the money then could we would we not zero it out like if it's from the PTO well didn't we mention at the last meeting didn't we say that

056somebody had there was funding for that that was coming grant funding yeah okay cuz I yeah I thought because I had asked that question I think at the last meeting and I thought we had been we had discussed that we were just checking in with insurance but it was funded y y so it was fully fed you need add it back in because it doesn't the grant money doesn't go into our bottom line the grant money is separate and gets paid separately outside of this budget which is why it's Zed on here because we were initially looking at hey we'll fund it and the PTO thank you very much we really appreciate the work RP does as man so so it's a it's a completely separate pot of money so they zero it out here

057just to show that this is something we were willing to do and hey our community stepped up yeah here we go so I think we were just waiting to hear back from insurance right on liability or like you guys were yeah looking that okay I think that's um so the next section is Personnel this is the the brunt of the clost this year and I'll try to wck people through them the first position that we are recommended is an environmental salary teacher with salary and benefits would be 93,173 is at rmms We are looking for another special uh what we mean by special art music PE as enrollment goes and you go from four sections to five class sections you need a prep time for that teacher and you need a place for those students

058we have been looking at this as a curriculum goal for a few years now we have been able to put it in in a sister District over in Hollis and it's gone very very well this will solve a scheduling issue for Dan and give us much greater flexibility the mentor program addition uh as you may know we have seen uh a wealth of turnover across RSU and across the educ ation field in general bringing new teachers in uh who have gone through programs but necessarily haven't uh learn the craft or the trade yet uh our assistant superintendent has established a wonderful Mentor program and these are the stiens we pay to the mentees to work with those individuals the chemical hygiene safety stien uh that is another mandate by law now so we have to

059to have a chemical hygiene safety person we are actually using a high school teacher who obviously teaching in the science field has a wealth of knowledge and we're broken down that cost to each building based on how much they would have to do in that building and obviously uh rmms and csda would be not be that much we don't have the amount of chemicals of that but this is required by law it's another example of passing a law that is not funded the the uh mtss facilitator stiens uh the board has spent uh quite a bit of time and effort bringing uh a multi-tiered system of services to our students it goes very well we've seen some very positive things occur this year and these are the stiens um for two people so $500 each

060to track the data on our behavioral pieces the next um piece is a school psychologist this kind of goes o on the overall piece with our in-house programming that 46553 is divided between rmms and csda because the person would be splitting time uh so we allocated it to each of the cost centers the interventionist uh would be working with students who are struggling um and again that is a uh share position at csda and rmms so jumping down to csda the only thing that is not on the rmms list is the lunch recess monitor um we are looking for more supervision outside at recess uh and uh we've had some good success in Dan's building we were able to bring one on board this year and kind of pilot it and see what the benefits

061would be and we have been very happy with that so as I said this is probably our our largest cost area uh 2997 48 some of these positions because of their nature and I'll use uh the school psychologist is dedicated to special ed we need that position so that would be uh in the default budget whereas the environmental science teacher because it is uh not associated with mandated Services would be something that would not be in the default budget that's kind of the difference on how something gets into the default or the operating based on the need so moving down uh we see special ed we are a prek coordinate program we presently have a halftime person who works in our PK and would like to make that a full-time position to meet the needs

062of those students uh for those of you who don't know prek is kind of a a r involving entry when you turn 3 years old you're eligible for admission and it's very difficult to plan for you know we usually get a phone call and uh the child is on their way uh in a couple weeks so this is a constant um evaluating of students and what we have seen is by getting students in as early as possible um greater chances of success of moving them from special ed to regular Ed or better chances of them staying within the district and then we have the power positions one is new we have a new student in FY 26 that will require a par and then we actually have two Paras that we had to add this

063year that weren't budgeted for so we're budgeting those for next year and can I just ask a quick question going back up to Personnel can you um just explain so that those who are watching the meeting are watching back a little bit about why it's so important that we add a school school psychologist as well um CU we already have one so I would just love like for us to have that knowledge out there so people are aware so right now we have a school psychologist that split between the two buildings um and we are seeing an increase in both service need uh in tier 2 need you know across the board as well as an increase in special education evaluations that are needed so really having a full-time person in each building would be

064vital to the efficiency and services of our students are we having to contract out for testing right now we have yes okay so we're also looking at additional costs for the contract acting that we could reduce if we approve this position correct we have a sheer curiosity question the chemical hygiene safety typen if we are using somebody out of the high school they're not technically in our district or is it because they're in the Su SAU that they're okay to have on board is that so we actually have lot quite a few shared positions maybe um you know let's say we have a um bcba that's owned by the hollow school district but services are split between maybe all six buildings and so they each of the buildings or each of the individual districts are

065build for the services so yes this is an individual who's a high school teacher works for the Cooperative District so the co-op bills Brookline that dollar amount yeah I was curious how that worked okay that's just for my own knowledge Bas of I just thew workings of our district um a quick question to it looks like there's a 300 about $300 difference between rmms and csda for the chemical safety stien is that just because there's differences it's form yeah it's formula based so it has to do with how many safety showers how many eyewash stations how many chemicals there are and how many locations they're located in and how many tests per month have to be completed okay thank you thanks could you describe an interventionist sure so this position um is actually we're just

066looking for a um k6 or K8 Elementary educator and the reason we looking at this is this individual will be trained to provide direct instruction in English in writing in math social emotional learning so could be um more far-reaching than if we were just focusing on let's say a reading Specialist or just a math specialist so looking at the needs of our students from our mtss data um that teacher that interventionist could provide intervention at where the based on the needs that we're seeing and do we currently have that type of position or is that a new position that is a new position um we had looked at a couple different models historically we had had um PA professionals that were regular Ed Paras and we can't find them we can't hire them and they

067don't have the same level of training so rather than um hoping to find some miracle people that we can't seem to to pay for or hire or whatever looking at one um intervention mentioned a split between two buildings that could provide better direct instruction um with the appropriate training was the the thought process okay thank you and all three of these full-time people the environmental science teacher interventionist and what was the other one scho that's full Year's budget right there that's not eight months out of the year and next year it's going to be it's a no no that is a full year so that would be for the 25 26 school year based on their annual salary and it's budgeted at Master step 7even T so that gives us the ability to go out

068and be competitive but we're not putting it at the top of the scale but we're not putting it at the bottom either so that's fully loaded at Master step seven I just want to um close public input if that's okay yeah is there any more there's no public here but I'll ask if there's any public input otherwise I will close the public input at 658m so that takes us down to new computer equipment rmms is uh asking for a access point an exterior access point for pickup Patrol pickup Patrol has been uh very successful where we're using it and this would give us um much greater capability at csda you'll see that we had interactive flat panels in round one at 13,500 those flat panels will be be purchased but they'll be moved to the

069reap Grant Brookline is eligible for a rural education grant that we receive on a yearly basis it's dedicated pretty much to technology so you'll when you see reap that just means it's going to be funded but it's going to be funded through the Federal grant that we uh receive so that moves us down to replacement of computer equipment the last couple years the board has received um presentations by our director of technology and we are on a regular replacement cycle with our computers and it goes very well so the Chromebooks for students will'll be getting 86 of them at $380 which will be the 32,670 but that has been moved to reap uh we have uh staff Chromebooks um staff laptops Windows laptops for certain individuals the iPad with cases um we have one set

070of those and I correct and those are just for the kindergarten yes right uh so that's kindergarten is the only place we use iPad it's because of the the tou touch screen and the interactive nature and then rmms has um flat panels listed there for two at 4500 uh csda we have the student Chromebooks for 247 we have staff Chromebooks staff laptops Windows laptop for staff and to replace the uh camera server which is end of life that is all our safety security cameras each building has their own server and csda is just up so that total of the new and replacement equipment is $68,400 any questions on the computer replacement equipment yeah if um a student needs an Adaptive communication device such as I is that covered under that iPad replacement no it's under

071special that comes out as special education okay so with that I know we don't have it right now but that would come under the special ed like is there a different part of the budget that it would or it come out of the trust no no no I have we have uh we have um special education account lines that that cover the the technology and the technology we would necessarily you don't need it under new new items because we keep uh running kind of section of our own iPad new and yeah I just wanted to make sure that it was like where those cuz if those were coming out of there like okay thank you for the reef Grant I'm loving that we we have it and we qualify for it and I know the

072last couple of years we've really put it to good use in terms of qualifying for it and applying for it is that based on total District student population it's a it's definitely a formula grant okay and it has to do with um our student population it's one of the grants that has less to do with um our free and reduced lunch and more to do with um our location and the fact that we're still considered rules so I apply for it every year uh in February and then we get our allocation in about May okay yeah there's just there were some grants that looked at student population and I was just curious as we think about you know what our what our population numbers are going to be if that could possibly go away uh

073yeah know so the the population um the ADM is part of it but U because it's Federal it's it's not quite so you know a shift of five to 20 is not really going to make such a difference in that and a lot of it actually has to do with whether or not every other eligible District across the country um applies for it and realizes that they're eligible because it's it's sort of a hidden one that we just happen to know about it because they're eligible over like once every seven years or so Hollis is eligible and I'm like oh look at that let's apply so all thank you any other questions as the district been in any conversation with the town about they're doing that technology revamp I guess that's a no no um

074what do you want to tell us just so we no just the town's um recently contracted with a new technology supplier they're doing looking at replacing doing kind of a you know put more F focus on I didn't know if the district had feedbacked along or had any kind of conversation about Synergy at all essentially I can I can speak to that I'm fairly knowledgeable about that basically that the town has been doing a tech study as to where their services are at and looking at upgrading their technology infrastructure in the town-owned buildings but we are a school district owned building right or how does like we we have our own technology thing so it's it's a it's separate it's not on that same it's not part of that same group of services that they're

075looking at and then the tech provider that they recently hired is for those Town own suppos municipal buildings not the school district buildings they are two actually separate entities but but we have gone through a similar study that's what made the decision on things like Chromebooks and who gets what and why only kinderart and gets iPads um so we've done an extensive study and uh have a regular replacement cycle so we don't see hopefully tax spikes so the dollar amount for Computer should stay pretty level every year by Design um moving to shed services this is an area that um we worry about every day this is your uh firewall and your security and your data and schools are getting attacked probably almost daily because again the wealth of data that we have around uh

076students their families and everything and Our IT person every time we meet scares us with the next oh my go scam we have what we call tech tech tip Tuesdays and you get the email and we keep learning about things like you run home and you make nine switches to everything you do at home that's all wrong um but we're we're really good shape but it it's something that you know we work closely with our insurance company uh because they're after you know trying to get into payroll they're trying to get into uh student identification numbers all of those things so this uh $4,280 is not a lot but again this is one of those Services that's split across all all the district all the buildings so you know again your elementaries are significantly less

077uh to do these Services than your middle school and high school based on volume and uh number of computers safety compliance issues uh we are phasing in new walkie-talkies to enhance communication uh we moved uh the LED lighting the Energy savings and the re gates to the warrant if the board decides to move forward with the warrant and then we are doing some door frame Replacements at csta which is a multi-year project and it's in year four out of five uh as you may know one of the nice things about csda they have a outside door to every classroom one of the problems with C csda is they an outside door to every CLS because in an environment with snow and salt and all the things that we do uh those doors take a real

078beating so we're working our way around the building uh facilities maintenance we've moved can I ask a question about absolutely safety so um safety compliance with the security cameras is that just more something that we're like dreaming about right now we have a a quite in-depth um section of security cameras those those are areas that um over time we'd like to increase coverage on okay um but at the same time we're all our main entrances are covered um and if you were to go into the principal's uh secretary's thing you would see we have the whole building it's one screen so all entrances are covered all day long uh there are a number of different safety items that go along with all our doors as the board knows we did um new glass in many

079areas that is basically what I'll call not bulletproof but it will uh significantly enhance the chances of that taking quite a while to get through because what we're really trying to do is buy time for the the police department to get here um and unfortunately you know 10 years ago when I started this was not a major part of the budget uh thankfully the state of New Hampshire this is one area they have done a very good job of providing safety grants and we pretty much have been eligible every year and uh pretty much been funded every year and that's what we've used a lot of our dollars for to enhance the uh the structure and the fortifications can given the given the climate currently with schools and safe surrounding safety in particular and I

080applaud everything that this group has done and continues to do to secure our buildings is there anything else if you had a choice to do something else this year to enhance the safety of either of our buildings is there something you would like to do and I know I know I know this goes up soon and I know we've done the whole budget thing but I can't help but pause and think of our schools that have seen tragedy and want to ask that question if there is something that this group feels is necessary or you would like to do to the buildings this year to increase that security for our student population I'm gonna defer to Dan Dan coach is our Safety Committee I kind of keep looking at him knowing that and I'm putting

081you on the spot a little bit so maybe it's not an answer for tonight but I if there is something I'd like us as a board to be able to support that if possible yeah know I appreciate the question um we talk about this a lot at the district safety needs we have we have four year um I I guess Tod be I mean I'm really happy with where our schools are at with what we've done over the last since I've been here like say 9 10 years I guess I'm more Curious are there things that we're missing that we're not thinking of that's what I'd be curious about I think you know what I'm saying so I mean I do have a thought so like I told you on when I was here last

082two weeks ago or whatever um that like the gate on the street that faces Milford Street like it keeps swinging open like it's very easy to open and get into and so I'm I'm wondering if it would even be worth looking at like spring loaded type so that it's shutting more consistently because every time I pull in drop my daughter off I'm like okay anybody could walk in and I understand that with these cameras but like it's very easy to get in and out of there and I Dan was explaining that you know we need that for in case we do need to leave the premises which I completely understand but I'm wondering if there's more we could do even just like things like that that would make it more secure or make it maybe

083again like Andy saying delay a little bit if someone was trying to get in that way especially given that like a lot of the gym classes are out there and that leads right in the playground so that's something that maybe I like I have noticed better I don't know if there's another what what I can share with you is that we made great progress with the security cameras we have the school guard glass like that superintendent Cory was sharing we have what's called annunci panels which are in our office that tell us when the doors open and when they're closed we have the Ballers I mean we we've pretty much checked off everything that's been recommended okay but it's something that I appreciate the question I think it's something we can look at more and

084then see what other school doing I mean I'll I'll be honest four or five years ago I wouldn't have let a lunch monitor go through for the budget and they can tell you that um I look at it differently now because it gives me another adult so it wasn't yes it's it's a a safety for students on the every day to day you know fall down skin my knee but it also gives me another be human out there another adult and um like I said I met the gentleman that took Dan's position um and he he just his presence just something else to the table so I think if you would to say that I think anything that we could add uh around them the most vulnerable areas and I would say um lunchtime is

085vulnerable you want kids to go out and have fun uh but you need a group of adults who are not only worried about the kids but are worried about the gate being open the Vigilant so um and Jo so you have point about the gate I think that's something we can look at just within our mainen lines yeah no I'm not saying we need to add it to the budget but I'm thinking if we're to Allison's point if we're thinking about like just like ways you can be more safe which is why I mentioned it to you and your answer made total sense but like I also don't think you should have to drive by on weekends and stop and close the gate you welome to we got a lot of students that like to

086use our basketball courts which which is fa like I want shut the gate right I want to keep the community accessible I also just want to be aware that during the school day you know when it's wide open and it is in a corner of the school where I don't know you know like we just want to make sure that we're yeah being mindful no I appreciate your point Andy though about if you feel our buildings are where they should be then I agree that our best defense is humans who are Vigilant in care yeah um it's okay just I wanted I just wanted to ask no I'm glad you did I think it's a important conversation for us to have as much as we don't want to necessarily share too many details around safety

087because of people outside it's nice to have the discussions in the broad sense so parents know that it's something that we talk about on a regular basis you know one of the big changes from a a legal standpoint it's now one of the items that we are allowed to use non-public to discuss because there are a lot of questions sometimes and you want that freedom to really make sure this is the right Next Step for safety sure appreciate that no no just just going to say the same thing you know since I've been here for four and a half years um changes that we've we've made um and I I think the biggest thing though is the dedication of the entire District um like Dan was saying that the meetings that we have you know

088I know Dan and I are always talking about safety um but then the the district monthly meetings um the big thing is also all the drills that we practice and the conversations that we have with the staff at staff meetings um you know the staff comes to us if they have any concerns we also quiz them as far as like when a drill is completed we have a a code name for perhaps um and you know I've gotten some phone calls like oh is the drill really over I don't remember that being the the code name so um you know I think it's it's just um not just uh making sure that we have cameras and things like that um but it's also the communication thank you guys um looking at facilities maintenance a lot

089of this is our annual ongoing upkeep so chimney and KOA repair classroom floorings and the classrooms are outlined right there at RMS uh cafeteria tables we are in a final phase of updating all those uh trim replacement in rooms one and two uh guts and playground mulch at csda we have the main office flooring a rain Basin repair uh we have the life skills renovation this is this number I'll be honest with you we may still see a tweak here um because when we're looking at our self- attain programs we're working with our facilities coordinator Lauren Gina and I and and Patricia to to kind of do this so you may see this being reduced slightly not because we won't get what we need but because uh there may be a better way or more

090cost effective way to get the same results great um uh some painting some ceiling tiles uh Landscaping needs one big thing uh is the soccer field right now we don't use that during the school day because it's not handicapped accessible this $20,000 would uh take care of that um um and we really can't use it until this occurs so we have recess on the on the back playground as I would call it uh so that's something I definitely want to see stay in the budget uh classroom counter elimination repairs uh a generator service contract uh the portable skirting around the uh Portables at csta needs to be up upgraded and playground mulch there um so I just have a question do we have where do the elevator maintenance coming because is the how long has

091the elevator been out of service here elevator has been out for about um three weeks two weeks three weeks fourth fourth yeah uh and we had seven people here today uh and you can see it's still out of service see um one of the a couple kind of interesting things it's it's about phone lines and different things that going on the smoke detectors and smoke detectives um okay but it was running and it came up for angle inspection so it's not uncommon having I don't know five or six elevators uh to go through this but Lance had seven people here today and we're we're hoping it's on the men and we had three last week yeah yeah yeah um is so does maintenance for the elevator just come out of the general like because I

092don't see a line for it I mean obviously this is new items is there a line for it in the regular y the maintenance line yeah okay it's hard for me to sometimes get the really which one and to Gina's earlier point if all of a sudden um the elevator needs to be fixed it doesn't matter whether it it's budgeted or not we have to find that money so that's one another one of those cases where we would just move money from line item to line item yeah I just want to make sure because I know that that's also an ADA thing to make sure that we are like and I know with it being cold if someone needs to access it it's really crappy to have to go right now yes um so right

093now Kate has a question I'm sorry were you moving on to the next one or go ahead question what what is life the life skills renovation I'm not familiar okay um so one of the the programs that we referred to earlier for specializ education so the life skills the program we want to make sure because it's actually going to have more enrollment next year um due to students moving up so at csda we want to make sure we have the right size classroom um and different supplies and um so it's a it is AAL classro that will be renovated okay yes thank you when I see things like ground mulch I'm just reminded of how Dan had said that you know he needed sand and then you know he called one of the local companies

094which was really great I'm wondering when it comes to certain items that we purchase do we do rfps or vendors because we we have such a a great Community here you know we we have people I'm sure donate things all of the time um you know if if a company or an individual wanted to to donate is that you know or to submit an RFP because they do security camera say you know is that um something that the community should know that they can do something like that yeah so we we put rfps out all the time based on um certain needs if they hit a certain threshold we're required to and Community folks you know can can respond to those certainly what that is absolutely one of the benefits that we've experienced since we've

095added the facilities director at the SAU because you know you're looking at playground mulch at ours but we might be looking at it at and and HPS Etc now every school has C you know different needs so um Dan uses a playground mulch that was deemed appropriate and necessary for his playground which isn't necessarily the same as as the playground at Hughes let's say um but we absolutely look at to um do items in bulk across the district and then allocate the portion of the total cost which is just for further cost savings beyond the RFP but you're right no local folks Step Up all the time to help us out and um absolutely when we go out to bed um we love to hire local we love to get a deal yeah PL in

096there community service thank you um so the the final piece is the maintenance Expendable trust uh we had allocated $36,000 for this year it's made up of the following items uh there's $50,000 which is uh year two we put away money last year here this $50,000 will give us the total cost of 95,000 to uh fully replace our indcom system our bells and our phone system here at rmms which I believe is the only school we have left for that upgrade um the create office and step program this is similar to the life skills renovation the the step program is a specific uh program that we have for special ed students it currently she has a a small piece at the back of the library and then the next room adjacent to that and this

097would make it um a more appropriate setting for those students to access their programming which school is that at Andre that is csda and then um here at rmms um we need to start renovating our bathrooms many of them are original to the building and um this will allow us in some bathrooms to uh increase the number of handicap stalls we have and to uh take care of some aging plumbing and then uh the other significant piece in its time is the Milford Street roof replacement uh which is 85,000 um Dan is kind of my Roofing expert and he assures me that he does not want to go up there and stand on that roof anymore so that tells me it's time to uh make replace it you just repaired it the other day yeah

098I know I was like were you up there spackling I was up there there because one of our it's interesting the side of the roof lifted oh oh that's and I screw it down on the rake board okay but it's still it's up the roof is on top of the building I think that's the age of right now but it's it's I think it's I think uh it's close to 30 years which if we we got our money's worth I mean you want anywhere from 20 to 25 with an Nal shingle but if the person who goes up on the roof or Tinley is now refusing to go on the roof I'm F then we will replace not going on the roof um so that takes me through the new items and now I'm going

099to just go to the very last page of the Excel spreadsheet um can I just correct something quick yep I would walk in the roof I want well here's I want to say something it's really important because I don't want to make it sound like the roof will hold because this one will have snow it will it will be fine with snow loads okay just needs good to know yes Dan will play however it is structurally fine yeah okay I mean I I go to D because in his previous life he did Roofing so he has extensive knowledge okay I didn't know that and at one point was doing a facilities for Brookline before we were able to get an SAU facilities it was greatly appreciated is that like an educator thing because I did

100a couple Summers and Roofing and shingling it's a great summer G coup on our shoulders you can respond to our RFP for roofing that I cannot any longer this back in back in the day but yeah that I did Summer Roofing G it was side gig I mean it's got to be an educator thing eat the whole basket so in the last page of the um spreadsheet of the Excel spreadsheet you can go line by line and see the increases and decreases across the board but I just wanted to focus in on at this point the percentages um the round four operating budget is at 12,881 8946 which is a a difference of 87,3 5831 uh that is a uh 6.8% increase we have a proposal as you'll see it came down slightly with Kelly

101going out and getting some quotes uh to do an infrastructure lease for 9,565 35 that would be to replace the boiler at csda um if it's approaching its end of life you know it's about a half a million dollars for that boiler and if it were to go I don't know where we'd find a half a million to be honest we' have a special meeting with the town and have to request uh funding so this will allow us to upgrade that boiler and do some of the controls uh we would convert it over to propane which would mean that we would have um seven of our buildings right uh six six out of the seven building would be on propane what is it on right now is it on oil it's on oil um which

102would increase our buying power right now we buy uh propane with town of Hollis the town of Brookline and the school district and we coordinate that purchase because we're the largest user and we we've been able to get some very good rates for our propane so by moving to that we do believe we see savings that 9,565 35 in the first year would be cost neutral because you would have rebates which account for approximately half of that and the other half is in Energy savings that are ongoing and will continue into the future the maintenance trust we already discussed uh we're not recommending funding for the special ed trust this year because it is at um fully funded and then the SAU budget is um at 493 606 which from a uh fiscal year to

103fiscal year Brook Line's increase is $20,000 as I said the total increase of the SAU was 12,000 but we did lose the revenue so the over overall warrant when you look at it from this fashion is at 8.9 but I don't want people to get confused because that's not the tax rate calculation that's just where the warrant came out that's why I hand out the separate tax Camp uh analysis um so Kelly provided us for a 20-year lease of 1,131 750 with an interest rate of 4.97 with is how we get to the $90,000 if we decide not to do that lease then we do have to add that money back into the budget because we won't be getting the Energy savings so um we we'll have further clarification and details on that so so

104when you say the the part that's in yellow yep basically we're paying 9,565 35 irregardless is what you're saying correct okay right so if you if you pass it you get the first year free years after that you get about a 50% savings on the bond because you're getting the energy reduction and I I just wanted to clarify along with the boiler where you get your most of your energy savings is converting to LED lighting so uh we had a board member ask a question in terms of um if we split them into two different bonds are two different leases you would be at approximately $28,269 th000 or is it a different number um so I'm about to I realized something didn't make it to the packet and it kind of breaks us down and

105it provides the pictures you had requested so I apologize for that but I'm about to to um upload it but I will share with you that the um LED lighting installed cost is 215,000 um annual Energy savings is 12,500 with a onetime rebate of 35,000 so 215 and then it was 48 and then um H fact controls have an installed cost of 43,500 with annual Energy savings of 5500 and potential rebates of 5,000 and then the boiler replacement 57275 with annual Energy savings of 12,000 with a potential rebate of of 8,000 so um those are the details of that so I'm going to upload that um so you can the public and everyone can um evaluate that and just um to let you know right now a lease is about 4.9% and a bond is

106about 3.75 the difference between the uh Bond and Lease since I'm been at the SAU if we were doing what I would call construction you know building rooms and things like that we've gone a bond when we do equipment in this case boilers and license that we've gone with a lease the other benefit of a lease it's kind of like your home equity line if the money is just sitting there you know you're not paying for that on it and right now uh last year and the year before we started to see the districts make that had outstand leases make money off what was sitting in the bank so uh there there is that piece so I think the lease is what I would recommend in this case but at the same time I wanted

107you to know that the bond rate is 3.75 but this way let's say we ordered the boiler tomorrow we get the lease we order the boiler and all of a sudden it's back ordered if I'm on a bond I'm paying for that boiler that's sitting someplace else if I'm on a lead I'm getting interest on that money until the boiler gets here so it's just two different ways to look at it uh that would be ultimately the board's decision but I think I would recommend the lease on the on the lease I I think I I think I need a little bit more clarification between the two yep so with the lease just round numbers we take 100 grand we have that money to draw from or that goes into our account so that we

108make interest money but then we're already but then we're paying interest on the we're paying that 4% interest I don't I don't I need I need a little bit more education on this let's use the $100,000 sure it's round number so it's easy and the in that1 $20,000 is going for Li and 80,000 is going for boiler the boiler is delayed so the $220,000 we pay lights get installed the $80,000 sits in our account making whatever the interest rate is and it is right now running where you would make money off that even though there's a difference between the 3.7 the 4.9 the interest rates are high enough you know like Hollis had um the end of a a lease and wasn't that significant about amount of money about a quarter million right M so

109and they made about $84,000 off of that so the money goes into our account correct boiler sitting here so we haven't paid for it so it's sitting in our account making money but we're already making payments on the lease right like we're already starting to pay that fact only for the lights so it's a pay as you go then how do we make money on it that seems because you the the money that in there so we took we took out a lease okay right all right and that money is sitting in our bank account so the check is delivered to us right and then we start to pay that check back that check back but when we use the funds you have five years to use the funds okay got it okay that didn't

110the five years help y okay is there if we were to do a separate lease for the boiler and a separate lease for the lights is the interest rate different uh it's usually higher it it'll go up because the amount one of the things that you'll see with a lease company they're looking at all different um amounts of the leases MH so sometimes a small lease like ours for a million dollars will get a good interest rate because they need to package it for $80 million to sell to the to the next person m and they're at 78 and they look over oh there it is that'll get us to what we need and they'll entice us and that Hasen for us uh so we will never know the lease just like the bond rate

111until it it's sold until it's sold okay and and I'm asking this because you know I support 100% keeping our buildings up to par and and I'm struggling with this because I know the boiler is in need I know the town has rejected the boiler in the past and I am concerned that if we package it with a light we're not going to get the boiler and then we're going to be in trouble if that boiler fails or if a part goes on that boiler and I had asked for a list of what are the non what are the parts of the boiler that are no longer are if it if a part were to break what's that list of parts that we can no longer get that would force our hand to get a

112new boiler um I I just have concerns knowing the overall Financial State of the town at the moment packaging a need with a nice to have because the lights turn on right I understand the cost savings and I I don't want to sound like I'm not being supportive but I'm trying to just kind of take a step back look at the big picture from the town and everything else that I know is coming down the pike and what's going on with the town I want to be mindful of boilers in need and I just don't want us to risk losing it again so I was the one boor who sent that question in because I'm concerned about packaging these two things together on the same same warrant article um I I I would feel better

113if we gave the choice at Town of either or or both and I don't know how to do that in a warrant article like this where we're packaging it together if we can give the town an option of just the boiler just the lights or both I will share another Factor like the $35,000 if we do that now we'll get that rebate if we if we wait a year we're throwing 35 ,000 away um it has we've been successful at the co-op certainly holl is a different story in terms of ease of things passing but it was successful in the co-op we're putting forward LED lights again at the middle school packaged with facilities needs with boilers and HVAC system um I absolutely hear what you're saying but it seems um like it would be

114um not very forward thinking to walk away from a $35,000 rebate when you're looking at the LED lighting paying for itself in a matter of um about 10 years less than 10 years about 10 years so and with our calculation on the payback we did not escalate the charge for electricity and it typically goes up one one and a half% every year uh so when we did the LED light in Hollis we estimated just under 11 years for the payback it actually took just over seven so I I see your point we can have it there's nothing that stops us from putting that together for you and then the board making the decision our reason for packaging them was because it made it cost neutral in that first year and then we got the ongoing

115savings to offset it in the subsequent years but I kind of agree with you that um people will look at and say the lights work and for us to have a boil the go um you know that would be a significant budget hit and it would have to be would have to take a leap of faith because if if I was the superintendent the boiler goes I'm going to buy the new boiler I have to put it in I have to have school right and then I have to have a meeting probably after that boiler's already sitting in there and ask for the money right you know so and I I don't want I don't want us to I transparently I don't want us to be in that position I I understand the cost savings

116I get it I would convert my entire house to ladies I I I understand all of that I just know when listening to previous uh Town meetings surrounding similar topics talking to people in town I just don't know if the appetite is going to be there and I am just I I am genuinely concerned we are not going to get this at all and then what do we do right um and I don't necessarily want to set us up to in that position not saying that we would I mean but I just I I just I just genuinely have concerns about this so let let us do our homework we can bring a warrant at the public hearing that gives you the options of what you choose to do as a board and as a

117finance committee on how you think it's it's best because again um I'm in Gina's Camp from just my finance background but at the same time I also have owned my own home and sometimes you just have to yes be able to do only one thing right so I get that I'm I'm curious kind of if there's other thoughts on this or if I'm a kind of stand alone sit alone worn article last year where they changed it late to be from specific here's the plan to energy Improvement no this was this boiler was on the article two years ago that passed you had a choice you could do $25 million and do the boiler at csda and all the controls and then all the work we did at RMS and the voters choose chose a

118million and a half so that boiler was never done right so I mean I think I I hear what you're saying Alis and I understand the concern because I do think it's a very valid concern I think one thing that would help me feel better knowing what to do is like okay so we say the first year is cost neutral what would we be looking at in terms of the payments in years two and three for a lease like that I think if we had those numbers because I guess I'm not seeing like those numbers firmly I wonder if that's something that would help give people a more full picture yeah and and so this is assuming we took out the full amount in one but that lease payment remains pretty steady which is a

119little different from how Bond year one you pay interest only and then you pay um the the rest so so the payments stays at that um 9,565 okay plus sh uh but then you're looking at annual Energy savings of 30 so the net would be roughly 60,000 okay and how many years would that be for it's a 20 year so we would actually have already paid for itself um prior to that okay so we're looking at a 20-year lease with yearly payments of about 9,565 but we're also looking at reduce costs in other areas of the budget of 30,000 which would then go to off I guess part of my question would be is like right but if what if those costs get eaten up by other things like well that's always going to happen

120right that's right yeah that's life right but like that's that might be something that comes up for people also is like if that that 30 yes we're saving that $30,000 is an offset but now it's going to special education it's not going to offset right but um if we didn't have the $30,000 the money would still come to special and then we would have $30,000 more in cost so so that you know they're completely independent and cost are going to come up and we try to find the savings when we can but this um you know is our our last opportunity at that $35,000 rebate um and then you get that ongoing Energy savings seems like Joanna are are you kind of saying that a different model could be that $30,000 in savings go into

121some sort of trust or another account in which the taxpayers can can see that it's I don't savings to them I mean maybe I don't know I don't know exactly like what I would say but I I guess part of me is just like when I'm looking at it and I'm saying okay you know I'm paying 90,000 but I'm getting 30,000 back which is 60,000 but like I also work with um lots of black and white thinkers who would say right but is that 60,000 only for energy when they're like well then now special so it's kind of like like we're seeing it as like it could be like an abstract yes we're saving $30,000 and Gina's got a point that like now we're short but we have an extra 30,000 so maybe it gets

122pushed somewhere else in the budget whereas a voter might be asking but isn't that for energy that's I think what I'm thinking it's it's kind of just like trying to look at like the bigger picture because I think for me when I look at like asks like this it's like I want to think about like okay but down the road is this going to cost me more is it going to cost me less like what's the most cost effective where am I going bigger picture- wise um so I think that's what I'm thinking I don't know if that answer I mean we certainly have tracked all of the savings with and we um completely redid um Halls upper and Halls primary and we were able to show that over time um but we're never not

123going to have energy costs associated with lights U and we're never not going to have a year where we don't need to use um you know the boiler um but by adding another school adding propane to another school and hopefully with the middle schol school as well if that passes the the buying power is just going to be incredible and then our propane rates are going to be far lower and another factor of this is removing the underground storage tank the oil storage tank at um um csda which would just add another layer of overall safety for the school um so that that's just another important factor but um one other note at the deliberative session if people have that concern they can amend the warn article we're going to put certain amount of money

124every year you know yeah so I think the the what I'm hearing is you would like to see it laid out so that you understood better understood all the options and could move forward from there I think that for me that would be helpful um for Alice and I don't I mean I I do think there's a little bit of it but like I don't want them paired I I'll I'll be straightforward I don't want them paired together like this I can't support it um and and I I 100 like I said I I 100% understand the benefits the cost savings with the lights everything else I understand the need for the boiler and looking at these pictures which tell just tell an amazing story um and if we have a part list that's like

125not able I'd love to see that too I I am concerned about I am just concerned that we wouldn't be able to pass it and I really want to look at immediate needs um I I would like I would like like people to have the choice to do one or the other without having to go through amending a warrant language and going through two hours of back and forth of rewarding to get it I just is there another way to present this thing I guess my question really is there another way to present this warrant article to give people the option of one the other or both without having to spend two hours with people at the microphone trying to reward it and break it down if they if they're if they're looking at it

126the way I am with the with a similar concern of it being packaged together I think that's kind of where I'm headed like so maybe I'm not being articulate quite well enough but just I'm struggling what I'm hearing you would like is a war an article at list a boiler here's the cost of the boiler Bo and controls yeah whatever whatever it takes to make the boiler function so right like the whole whole complete package and if that includes the removal of the oil tank the underground tank like the the complete package to make the boiler upgraded effective like working yeah is is there a mechanism in the warrant that you know we we want to pass this but if x fails then it's called annual meeting that we don't have cool okay get to

127know get to know not that down so I was thinking if we worded it like you know uh this is for the boiler and the LED lights but if that doesn't pass then you know then so and so passes so that it gives people like Al was saying the option but we can start Blue Sky in big picture like you know we all kind of want and and then you know people will know if they don't vote for that then they're voting for the boiler or so we we actually that is what we did when we did the renovation here article one was a bond that included everything and then article two was a bond that just did 1.5 they went with a 1.5 but it was worded such that if article one passed and

128two passed over one article one like trumped article two and then two was not in effect yeah um so we could but to my point there's a lot of more flexibility in the annual meeting format um but yes I mean I suppose we could we could look at coming up with wording like that I think for me like I I'm not necessarily opposed to them being paired I hear the concerns and I I think that those are valid I think what I'm looking for and possibly what other people in the public might be looking for is just like education so like if we do have to split them these are going to be the interest rates if we pair them this is the industry if we do have like that kind of thing I think

129that would be helpful um because I think that gives us an opportunity to say okay these are why we're pairing them these are so and then people can yeah make the choice but at least we've laid out a very clear transparent path in terms of like we looked at the interest rates we looked at the payments per year we looked at this and this is why we have paired them together first and we will also please fix the boiler take that like if that's because that's a need because your kids can't go to school if there's no boiler like that's just we know that um but also laying out that if the boiler fails we do need to like this is we don't have half a million dollars so therefore it will me a specialty

130I think it's it's that education piece is probably what I would like to see but I'm not necessarily opposed I think to a parrying and I just would like to see more of a complete we can do that we can do that we'll bring that that might be helpful in the public hearing too to help no absolutely great and that's it for the budget presentation thank you you're welcome that's a lot that was a lot that was great all right where are we here so now we're moving on to policy right do we need to discuss the warrant articles uh I mean I know we just went through the budget thing but do we need to discuss like the what what you it's just more so that you would understand the the wording I mean

131article one is the election of offices yeah article two is the the um the lease but we're going to be working on that to change that to bring that back to as kind of article two A and B uh some that type format three is the operating budget which we've discussed article four is the SAU budget okay Article Five is the maintenance trust okay and article six is the petition Warr article okay do we need to discuss the ones that the board had Poss about um I know you said that a citizen will won't be bringing one forward and that a board member had asked about a warrant article or do we need to talk about that now um You can absolutely talk about that now uh the the two that the board had least

132uh expressed interest in was did they want to do anything with the Brookline School District joining the co-op okay and uh the other one which Colleen had mentioned and again he may not want to but was mentioned just um do we want to look at the tax cap only because what was passed for the vote is isn't what's in effect now okay so when do we need to make a decision about those like when do we need to make a decision about whether or not those are articles that we're going to put forward at public well the last opportunity you have is the public hearing if you wanted those to be available at the public hearing you would tell me and I would have legal counil do the wording there's nothing that says because they're

133at the public hearing that they move forward do you have control of anyone's of the articles that the board is sponsoring at the public hearing okay the petition warrant article has to go to deliberative session yes right so if we wanted to support a warrant article to do a study to understand the benefits or drawbacks of joining the co-op in a K to 12 setting well I think it have to be pre to 12 though well what whatever it is yeah the pre the the full yes the pre full spectrum whatever that is that then I know there have been and Andy correct me from wrong I know in the past there have been studies done that the board is I believe supported or not we've had to pay for I think about leaving the

134Co-op right so if we were to propose one to look at the benefits of being part of a kada2 co-op is that does that start with us paying for a study and do you have any idea like because that's going to add then to our budget right so that this this starts to bring up other conversations so I am not going to support a Warner article that just joins the co-op I would want to see a study no well but I think the wording was that to join the C I would definitely need to see a study I would want to have a committee I would want to kind of very thoughtful about that because I would want to make sure that Brookline as a community had a chance to weigh in on that um

135so like if we worded it that way yes I would support that if we word it as in will Brookline join the co-op like I would not no that's I think Alison was talking about what is the cost we're willing to pay to do a study when the board supported a study reviewing the separation the disillusion of the co-op it came with a fee yeah um since then additional Studies have been proposed as in the form of partition warn articles that have beened so we didn't have to incur that fee okay um but the the fee was not part of the warrant article no if the vot is passed it then then the the board through the administration kind of did an RFP to see who was out there who could conduct such a stuff

136for and then uh got pricing for the study and that's how we move forward and then who we we would pay for that though right out of our school budget so we as a board would need to be in agreement that if we were to put forth a warrant article to to conduct a study or have or have an outside entity come in to conduct a study to understand the benefits or not of joining a co-op K to 12 um and if that passed then we would need to make room in the budget somewhere to pay for that correct correct and that would be one of the few times I would recommend that you look at your unreserved fund balance is that and this is this is where so that's not allocated okay whatsoever and

137it can only be done after public heing board approval and then pay for the study would would the board be interested in supporting this interested study I think as as long as it's a study and it's not like here with like six weeks before Liber Rec session make a decision I don't think that would go over I I personally as a voter would not appreciate that so I think yes a study I think would be fine if we were to like would you like us to propose a study or work on a study I think how do we word that I guess legal would do that but I I would propose it it be a yearlong study and you'd have information at next year's March meeting if you wanted to move forward okay I think

138that could be I mean my only I would support that I think it it's worth looking into my only question would be would we have any support from hollas in that regard or the co-op it doesn't mean it doesn't really just us joining The Coop I mean so I will I will Colleen I will say this um I've had conversations I don't know if I'm speaking out of turn but the the school our our partners over in Hollis or our colleagues over in Hollis if there's movement here they would be interested in movement and conversations there okay because that's really the only so I think somebody's got to start somebody's got to start the conversation is what I'm getting at because I think the study would have to say okay is it beneficial if Brookline

139is to 12 and Hollis is not if Hollis were to also be K to 12 is that beneficial so then Andy I kind of pushed back a little bit on the the warant article of or or the study I guess are we how does that how does that work like in our study I would want us to be able to look at if Hollis word also join like can they jump on board with that or would they just use our study to help launch their conversation or like are we allowed to kind of assess in our study are we allowed to assess okay if just Brook line kada2 was part of the co-op here's benefits or not if Hollis were to also like join like if we were to spons could we sponsor that like

140is that appropriate I I guess is where over here just my I think I think the easiest way to go is you as a board decide what you want to do as an Administration we can convey your thoughts because Hollis is also going to be looking at their warrants and what they want to propose and they could they may not decide that wow that might be something interesting to do as well to get a study and that would also trigger a discussion with the co-op to see if the co-op would be willing to potentially down the road accept that and it and this does not just like disillusioned if you were to leave the co-op this is not necessarily a quick and easy process yeah I know so it's it's not necessarily A Bad Thing

141to gather data because there would be some economy of scale you know there would be benefits in one teacher's contract one Paris contract because like Dan and Trisha joke a lot they do a lot of interviewing of Paris for the co-op because once the par hears that they have benefits of the co-op they go over and take that job I mean right consultant good job guys so I I I think if you're looking at at kind of getting the sense of community this is a good warrant article and again I'll just use historical perspective 11 years ago when I started we could have we would have never even considered this I think it's always good to consider things even if they are rejected because 5 years from now another 10 years from now it may

142be Revisited again yeah I think getting the data is absolutely good step and then you know from there we can ask questions I guess part of my question though with the data and maybe this is something that have to be explored in the study but it's like if we have S SP2 and no one else does like I I'm not I'm not trying to count chickens or anything here but like is that something that we have to consider well here's what happens if if if you were to do this what you're eventually doing is dissolving okay so that woulds and you would be moving into the co-op okay and abiding by their rules now somebody could propose SP2 in the co-op that's fine I just don't want to get sued because we dissolved to without

143permission or something I just want to make sure no and again this is going to be a long process and it would be one that I would I Gina will walk through with the attorneys and bring them along for the road Merry Christmas dinina yeah sorry sorry Gina not and I would be the same with the tax cap right so everything that's associated with the brook District would then be okay okay I know that that's early but I just wanted so do I do we need to make any kind of motion to ask you to put that one article together Ben CLE if you'd like me to research this and get some wording from legal counsel on that for the the public hearing for you to consider just like you'd like me to get wording

144for the two different bonds yep okay okay so that's that one and then we want to talk about the tax cap right yeah sorry it's going to be it's budget season no but we need to talk about no because it's not that much longer we have one meeting in January I'll bring coffee to the next one I'm drinking it I'm slow s in my car would also if we could explore the the tax cap more article that we discussed okay I mean yeah I I would 100% agree with exploring a tax cap article because I concerned the same page yeah I very concerned about like future years especially with contracts coming up and contract negotiations coming up and it kind of becoming I mean I hearing that Brookline School District will be the only School

145District next year that doesn't offer par benefits is concerning to me because now um Dan and Trisha are going to be interviewing for hollison and the co-op rather than Brookline so I don't don't want that Trend to so I mean that is something that I feel we're going to have to consider and I just feel like having a tax cap apply to everything I think is very handicapping so I certainly would be in support of us exploring that can you can you somebody give me paint this picture a little bit for me because I'm not just remember so probably do it better than I can well I when we passed the tax cap and I wasn't opposed to it uh there was a a warrant on the floor there was discussion of deliberative session and

146came up with 8% for the operating budget to operating budget okay okay that went to the voters that passed the difference now is next year I would think that three to five and a half% somewhere in that range is going to get eaten up just with the teachers contract and then the par contract if you were to add benefits you'd probably be at you'd be in the neighborhood of what Hall it should be about $300,000 so there goes another 3% so we've already eaten up the entire tax cap to fund the most critical element of the school district which is the Staffing so are we looking to not include contract increases in the 8% I don't know if we can that's well I guess this want to masking like I don't helping out here as

147to what we you would have to the otic would have to be about repealing the tax cap or uh or the other piece and I'll talk to Legal you could amend the tax cap article to CH potentially change the percentage CU I was not opposed to a tax cap right I'm just opposed to the percentage when the legislature introduces a new definition they change what the voters voted on but didn't give the voters a chance so just yeah even broader just for anybody that's listening because I know we've been through this is that what the Brookline voters agreed to in that warrant article was a tax cap on only the operate rating budget which what the legislature did is changed it so that the tax cap would apply to the budget and all our warrant

148articles which is not in my opinion what the voters agreed to so I just think we should explore that and and it's and part of that is just educating people about the tax cap okay so we need to make sure it's so Callen H you just explained it made far more sense to me just usually I'm tracking with you I was not tracking with you so so we really want to look at the a% only being the operating budget and then warrant articles being outside but we can't do that a state law that's that's a new state law is saying the 32.5 has been redefined we want to raise not what we voted or repeal it all together and so we would repeal it got it on the basis that we didn't vote on that

149meaning we the entire town did not vote on that they voted on the operating budget tax cap not on a tax cap on the operating budget and warrant articles which can be more wildly unpredictable because of those contract so that's why we need a little legal advice on this well we need legal advice and then we also want wording to help since this will go to ballot yes that's what that we want to make sure that it's worded in a way that people something that I understand I wanted to float to the board if people felt comfortable so last year one thing I did was I would kind of translate the war articles to like more plain English would would there be opposition from the other board members if I did so just as informational

150purposes no opinions no we recommend or at the meeting I would say I wouldn't be opposed but I'm not sure we can um I do create the district report and I welcome assistant I will I will have with that but that's what I do I mean I have the worn article and then I essentially take content from the budget presentations and this is what this means this comes from this fund I I'm happy I'm happy to assist with that because I think that's one of the biggest things that a lot of Voters have mentioned too is that it's just like you're sitting here reading this going like I'm even just looking at the petition article going how is that all one that's one sentence it's this long like okay like I have to like it's

151legally yeah it's legally right so anything that I can do to kind of because I do think for our community that is an important step is that people are looking at this and going what what does this mean what am I reading so I'm happy to do that in the districts I just don't want to like set us up are like this is our opinions it's not it's just more like this is what it is this fact yeah and this is what we're voting for and that's it like this is just literally what I mean so I mean we can certainly talk about that after budget hearing if you'd like and we can kind of make a board agreement I just don't want to do that without agreement from everybody we're we're going to do

152it and input is welcome and then we vet it through legal so that we're not election earing yeah either great and then I can just share what you do that goes through legal I will share that and correct that is good perfect and then we vote on all these in January as a board public hearing yes you we'll do the public hearing and get any input that we may receive and we could at that point decide not to put an article forward to amend it based on what people told us um or leave the warrant alone and and put it forward to deliberative session which is the fifth right and then will I know you had said that you had received word that another warrant petition warrant article will be coming does that have to

153be present at the public hearing or no no so our um the last day for petition War articles is January 7th our public hearing date is January 8th depending on what what petition one article we get and when we receive it it is likely that it would need to have its own public hearing which would have to be um um noticed okay and so what if it comes in on the 7th we wouldn't have time to notice that properly at the 8th okay so we'd have another meeting M okay can I I I need to make sure I don't miss anything January 7th is public hearing no January 8th is public hearing is public hearing at here here there was a flow chart somewhere wasn't there it's fine I just want to make sure it's

154like this yes it's yes and it was highlighted I like yeah I just life has been sideways for me is. is it at 6 so 600 p.m. on the 8th is the public hearing are we holding 6:30 no it's 6:30 cuz I think something at the bottom said say 6:30 for all meeting yes 6 okay okay so we have that one then are we still having our normal 2 school board on the 27 yes as far as I know yes that has always been decided after the public hearing after the public hearing okay and then the fifth is the deliberative session correct and the fifth has typically been the uh the meeting for that month and it is usually the last meeting for those board members who are not returning and that's at 6:30 yes

155that's at csda oh I knew that part okay I'm just adding to my calender now because sorry so for members of the budget committee you're welcome to stay but we're going to move into policy so I don't know if they have to stay though no you are most I didn't think so I thought he was saying no we can't let you leave I'm like about headlight the only I would say is thank you just jour meeting as you normally would okay so you have a motion to adjourn I'll make a motion tojn that'll pure in our minutes that's all perfect all right thank Youk very much appreciate the time appreciate the work everyone thank you thank you if you have questions or anything you can always email thank you take care all right so we're

156going to move on to uh the pro proposed policy member and I'll started by making a motion to approve the recommendations of the Brookline School Board policy committee as per the memorandum provided as part of the agenda packet do I have a second okay and then we can discuss okay so starting with lice uh jlcc so we'll present for third and adopt with minor changes the minor change is simply the removal uh based on the conversation in our last meeting the removal of that last paragraph criteria for return to school so um we we can't exclude so we can't really provide a criteria for return so we've suggested that we remove that the next is presenting for a second reading and adopt uh of bedh public participation at board meetings it was a minor tweak

157that we made for first read given that the policy committee sort of takes a recess between now and the reorganization in March we just figured we didn't want to have things dangling so we would do second and adopt the only change last month was that it's 30 minutes for public input um second reading and adopt with minor changes is ebcb fire and all Hazard drills and so we fixed the hyphenated hyphenations when needed between all and Hazard and then I think we just cleaned up the language and it really just sticks to what we actually do which is we are required to conduct six evacuation drills four all Hazard drills each year one of the all Hazard drills must test emergency response to an armed as salant so that's pretty much straight from the RSA

158and then remove the confusing sentence it says the remaining fire evacuation drills should be for each building Etc so that makes a lot more sense than you so that's that we see there and then um first reading and adopt is JL cja this is simply a change in an RSA that requires that we add um in section A I'm not sure why it goes letter and then letter but it does section a section h of that require that all School sponsored sports activities in grades 6 through 12 be super supervised by a person trained in CPR so that's a legal requirement um and then we have a first reading with some significant changes so we these will linger um onto our March and April meetings eh public access to school district records this is um

159a change in the RSA and so you can talk about it talks about the procedure for requesting those um records so that's that new paragraph um so basically they're just saying was the superintendent always the custodian of Records yes um so one thing that one thing that um has changed is the ability of the district to charge for items in addition to paper copies because what we've seen is some of our right to know requests have been quite extensive all electronic but required to have you have 35,000 emails with um redactions taking place regardless if they're being sent electronically that's a lot of work and so it's not really just the 10 cents per paper copy that is that's consuming so so um this requires us to have a procedure relative to records requests and

160that's essentially the the change there we're looking at jlf reporting child abuse or neglect significant changes to the policy which will be great that it will be um out there in the community for a few months to digest because there are significant changes but at the end of the day um we're all mandated reporters and that's essentially what it says and um that's not changing so what are the significant changes that have taken place for people to that people might need to dig for our people nothing we're mandated reporters okay this just updates our policy okay so for uh people in the public who are reading it is there significant changes that they need to be aware it really just clarifies everything so um when we used to say mandated reporters and we knew what

161that meant but many folks didn't understand fully what that means so um sometimes we can if a DCF report is made we can disclose who's filing it sometimes there disclosure of who filed it is not allowed if for safety reason um and sometimes there's an anonymous call so just that like explaining um all the rules and regulations that we follow okay and that's not but that's not for the staff like the staff here are are all aware of what that is it's more just like for like when you're getting someone who comes in and says well X Y and Z and I need to know when you're like here's the policy that says like okay exactly um and then we're presenting as a brand new SP policy ibab special education evaluations and so this policy

162comes from our director of student services um sorry for the random like gray block I don't know why that appeared but um but anyway it just talks about uh outside evaluations and procedures um and regulations around that um so you're talking about like if a parent comes in and is like I went to an independent neuros and here's the evaluation that's what this is about um sort of I mean that that can definitely apply um as far as when we review outside evaluations there are also times where parents um re request independent educational evaluations at our expense there are times that we propose and conduct evaluations and we want to list what our own standards are as well so it's really all-encompassing evaluations that's good and we're looking at for first reading it's a brand

163new policy here we are the eh- which is the um procedures relative to uh the public access to school district records okay and then and so we had procedures before but now it's required by law that we have um a regulation policy sharing those procedures I guess in a more public fashion by having it as a a board approved policy and then finally a first reading is a brand new policy kfd use and location of the aeds um so and I just noticed something that we will probably delete in second read but anyway okay so this is just saying like this is where they're at this is who's in charge of them is every I mean is everyone in the school trained on how's in A8 are all the staff trained they've gone through CPR

164training they have been otherwise we've identified you know we have the AED in the um in the gym uh so I've identified how to use it then it goes step by step yeah okay so kind of for back to one of the other policies with after school activities needing to be supervised by a CPR certified like is that a training that the staff receive or is that something that they opt into uh they opt into okay um some so we don't have Athletics if you were a coach for our district or an assistant coach we would require it but we don't have those in brookly school district which makes sense okay so we're more just saying like people who like might be supervising a club or something you're going to either ask them to opt

165in or it needs to be somebody who has already opted it well it's also we have um this policy with the AED in the in the gym yeah and it also lists so um for instance if um our gym teacher um we have a listing in that policy um I update each year who is currently CPR trained okay um so that so that there's knowledge availability um but we also for instance when we BR out the gy or say basketball um we let them know that this is where the a is um this is the policy that you know needs to be um you know followed so our policies are are then being applied to outside groups just so they're aware you know the safety precautions that should be taken okay okay thank you and

166I'm just putting it out there that um in March at our reorganization meeting uh that's when everyone gets to run to be first to be part of the policy committee um it's a really fun group you're really selling it right now um also do we need to talk about Capital Improvement projects we can we vote on this before yes sorry let's vote on it sorry I'm distracted it's okay probably all right so all in favor thank go you're welcome all right whoever came up with this memo great fabulous as my daughter would say that's a thumbs up not a thumbs down fici I appreciate it I get a lot of thumbs down these days so thank you Johna for notic saying that I skipped two and three I kind of assumed we gone through that

167whole section but Capital Improvement um project do I need to make a motion to adjust the agenda or did I just adjusted it on my own you're Char you can do whatever you want oh yeah it's on the agenda you're just out of order I like some pizza do you want a cook I okay thank you though so we'll move on to the uh number two because we did the budget but Capital Improvement project fiveyear plan yeah and I would say we did number three as well because that was about the warrants the warrants we'll take care of that okay um what what you have is the in the packet it was asked to put it again the fiveyear Improvement plan which is encompasses our goals from 26 through 2030 um in terms of the

168where they're slotted that's just where they have been slotted based on our facilities planning tool it doesn't mean they can't be moved or adjusted um and the other thing that happens is when we go through year to year sometimes um things are adjusted because maybe they haven't uh deteriorated as quickly as we would hope you know so like I'll give you two examples right by the way in 2025 which would be uh or 26 uh we already updated the adx Ada access to the uh Portables with new ramps last year because those came about um the soccer field is in this year's budget but the estimate was Far exceeded uh what the reality was because the reality was we were able to use a different uh uh train of thought on how to access the

169field and that worked out very well the um control upgrades are just will be in the uh delayed and then the phone system is in the budget so it's this is a constant piece that goes back and forth I think it was done for the um Town CIP plan and now the building mon tutorium is has has been lifted so this is something we work closely with the town and Colleen and Tracy have been putting time in on a regular basis to uh attend those pieces you'll also see it happens to have the uh co-ops pieces as well that is just more because it's going to the book line CIP so rather than create two different things we just added those uh but this is this gets done July by Kelly and Lance uh with

170input from school administrators yes I just would like to say that this these lists of projects are really really important for us to have a full and complete list of what we might think we would need to do for Capital improvement over the next five years because this is how legally our town would be able to assess impact fees so when those you know new homes are built or you know we have population growth we we can assess those those impact fees so I like to think of this more as like our wish list um and you know not and I think to Andy's Point not saying that just because something is listed in you know 2026 or 2027 or the other years that that's exactly when it has to be done um but it

171just has to be be in here um I think the other thing that Colleen and I had talked about with Michelle DDO our Our Town planner and the planning board was um you know how do we look holistically at um at at what we are proposing and and what we would like to do you know if um is there are there other ways to handle growth um and how do we want to talk about that that might that topic might not be part of this discussion um but we really need to have a plan for you know if we get X number more students or what high number more students um you know do we look to escalate one of these one of these projects because we have to um it's really about planning um

172for the future with an with a certain unknown aspect of how much growth we we're going to see um we can use NZ DEQ numbers and I think that's the those are the numbers that we've always used to kind of to track to um but the the plan would be you know what do we do next year if we get 50 students what do we do in two years if we get 300 students like I'm not probably not explaining this correctly but it's kind of like AB B CDE e f right like if we get 10 more students we can inter we can enact plan a which is like uh specials on carts if we get get 50 more students we have to think about you know Portables if we get 100 more students we

173have to think about an addition so I think that's what we really wanted to those are the two things that we really wanted to to make you aware of and that we have to really get in place um before before building starts is the individual projects but also our overall plan Colleen did I get that mostly yeah I think what I heard was more of a yeah I think that you explained it well also looking eventually at big picture so there's some discussion about looking farther out than the next couple of years so that could be part of the committee's role to do that and sort of um and there was also discussion about how it's really sometimes a nitty-gritty which we is hard to project that far out but I think there's like setting

174goal post sort of for when would we actually need a new building would be the the farthest out we could probably think of um when we work I've worked with the growth management piece for a while it's what if the town were fully built out so where would that so probably at like beginning of the year maybe like because I know we're so deep into budget now but yeah absolutely yeah I mean I think it sounds like right at reorg the the board might want to consider more of a standing facilities committee to do both short-term but also long-term strategic planning about facilities whether it's looking at boilers to new buildings you know and everything in the middle absolutely I think we need that in order to do this it can't all happen at these

175meetings there's just no way it would be interesting to if we were to end up doing a study on joining the co-op what that looks like in conjunction with this um just knowing like if we were at capacity but in a co-op if other buildings or not both of them would play into each other I was just thinking that KN yeah they really would yeah they absolutely would I would just like to say I I appreciate Tracy and Colleen's efforts because um this is probably what I would say another significant step that were recently taken to be more in line when I first started they were definitely separate entities the town and the school right um so we we continue to break down those barriers you know with the board of Selectmen coming and talking

176to us this year about keeping each other in tune so I think this this lines up to me with the long-term vision of where both the district and the town wants to go and the in-depth planning that's going to occur and to Gina's point you the co-op just did their first standing facilities committee this year so I think her point is well taken in March uh if we did that then we could go out and solicit CH people who may be a able to offer their area of expertise and help us along because not all of us are the construction people um so I think we're in really good shape and I think the work that has got us to this point is has been uh very positive and we will put that on the

177agenda to do a facilities Committee in March and then kind of hand this over and make it ongoing um and try to keep some consistency uh from the board point of view uh you know that we we we try to put two members on it but always make sure that it's not somebody who's going to be moving off the board because that's how things get put by the wayside um are there community members on the co-op community members um budget committee members okay great yeah yeah so both towns are represented um and it and it's been very good it's how we arrived at what they'll be proposing for their warrant um and it again these they each bring a different background but together it's a it's a very solid group I mean I think it's

178that definitely sounds like a good idea especially when we're presenting at meetings because well it's not just the school board saying it's exactly a wide variety of community members and um you know coming in and saying no I've looked at this and this is actually what so I think that's actually very valuable all right do we need a non-public not oh not okay I'll will make a motion to adjourn I'll second all in favor thank you wonderful holid

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.