001e e e everyone um it's now six o'clock I'm going to call the Hollis Brooklyn Cooperative school board meeting to order um I'm going to ask that we go around the room and do introductions and then we will be moving into and I'm going to appoint the process Observer and then we'll move into um nonpublic so Tim we'll start with you Tim yourone uh Hall Brookland high school principal Cindy vanc conut School Board member Rob man School Board member Kate sto School Board member Holly derlo BC School Board chair Andy Corey superintendent Gina burog assistant superintendent Lauren D Jero director of student services Chris whan School Board member and Linda Sherwood Director of Business operations thank you so I believe that Beth is going to be late um she is the process Observer tonight so
002I will hold off on that until after um our nonpublic if she's here then she'll be process Observer if not you guys have the entire nonpublic to think about who's going to be process Observer I'll do it with here but I don't think we need one during the nonpublic so all right so at 6:05 we're supposed to go into nonpublic can we go in a little early yes we can okay so I need a motion that the board by roll call go into non-public session pursuant to RSA 91 a colon 3 section 2 a the dismissal actually it's section 2 C to discuss a matter which have discussed in public would likely affect versely the reputation of a person other than a me member of the body or agency itself I need a motion so
003mov moved by Kate seconded by Christa um and then I'm going to need a roll call vote and I'm going to start with you Christa Christa I Holly ey guess I Rob I Cindy I so we are going to enter nonpublic at 602 and we're going to go that way e e e am I on now great thank you okay um so we've come out of nonpublic at 612 um and we are now about to begin our business meeting um we do we have any we have an agenda adjustment right yes we'd like to add a deliberative item to address uh the facilities committee's recommendation for the boilers and HVAC related equipment okay are there any other agenda adjustments not that I okay I didn't really write that down exactly but you did um and
004is there any objection to that object agenda adjustment at this point great so add that is number four um nominations resignations and corresponden I have a retirement I am writing to formally announce my retirement from my position as 8th grade English teacher at Hollis Brookline Middle School resigning effective June 30th 2025 it has been an honor to spend the past 15 years teaching in this exceptional District Hollis Brookline has been more than a workplace it has been a community where I've grown as an educator and built lifelong relationships I am profoundly grateful for the support I have received along the way working with students has been the highlight of my career watching them develop their voice and confidence through the power they discover in language I've also cherished the collaboration and camaraderie of my fellow
005educators whose dedication has been a constant inspiration as I prepare for this next chapter I also want to thank the district leadership and the parents of Hollis and Brookline for your commitment to our schools being part of this community has been an experience I will treasure in the days to come and that is from keret Porter Elliot yep kber k r p r t Okay so I need a motion to accept the letter of intent to retire received from Kerber Elliot um with an effective date of June 30th 2025 right so moved moved by Cindy second seconded by okay um all those in favor first of all any discussion we want to thank him for his years of service and all of his dedication to our students now all those in favor five zero five
006am I right is there five of us here yeah five thank you so that motion carries the other piece I have is just correspondence in the board packet uh we have received five citizens petitions uh I'm not going to R review those tonight but they're available for anybody who would like to see them in the board packet we will spend time working with them in our January meeting and they will become part of our warrant article so that in one sense at least we won't have to do separate public hearings because the information is already here they sent uh center around a wide variety of issues uh regarding tax cap sb2 uh posting tax rates um putting a cap of $27,000 per student is the maximum amount that the board could spend on a student
007and just doing a simple calculation of 27,000 times the enrollment as our budget um so there are a number of things here that are are very interesting and we'll have further feedback from our attorney for our January meeting and in the um board P packet you included not just the language of the warrant but the actual petitions correct correct uh many times I will get get citizens especially a lot of times people new to New Hampshire who don't understand our process so this way you can see the whole petition and they are as with everything we do subject to right to know anyways okay so those are all in there great hi Beth Beth is joining us at 6 um 20 and I hate to tell you this but you're the process Observer tonight so
008we've already had a a quick non-public um but we just started at 6:12 to be part of our regular meeting so all right is there anything else no that's it for nominations resignations and correspondence thank you so much uh so we went over the appointment of the process OBS server and now we'll move on to approving some minutes so I need a motion I'm going to read some amendments um so these are the amendments that were offered on page five for the minutes of November 13 2024 page five line8 correct the reference to 20125 page 5 line 35 replace is with r page 10 Line 39 student should be plural page 21 line 29 replace on within and page 23 line 34 replace eii with eii I need a motion to accept as amended so
009move moved by Beth I need a second second second by Christa okay are there any other comments on the um minutes from November 13 2024 okay all those in favor oh five oh four and opposed abstentions two 4 two um just to appoint 4 two motion carries um we did learn at the seu governing board meeting in October that you do not have to abstain if you were not present you don't you can if you want to but you don't have to you never have to okay at this point I hope we're on time to do this what time were we supposed to scheduled for public input perfect okay so at 6:22 I'm going to open the floor for public input if there's anyone here who would like to provide input um we ask that
010you state your name and address and that your input be focused on items on the agenda um and that you remain respectful the public input period will be open um for 30 minutes if someone is out there and would like to come down you have 30 minutes and that would be somebody do the math for me 622 652 we will be closing um public input um but we will move on with our meeting and if you come down and would like to speak we will will make time free to hear from you great moving on we are going to move to the principal reports and we have a principal here who's going to be covering everything tonight I um so uh Patrick is out for a couple of weeks right great thank you so moving
011on to which what Tim it's up to you just sure I'll start with P support um I'll uh highlight just a couple items that has on his report including the Turkey Trot race uh something that uh came about when Patrick joined us here in 41 uh he had the see 95% of the student body took part in the race this year where they come up to the high school looks like we being invaded by middle schoolers uh for a good 15 20 minutes um and they were all in costume uh with the theme of um the turkey day Thanksgiving holiday so uh another great tradition um pck has brought along and it looks like um it was uh combined with some competitions top finishers funniest costumes all those types of things and they also it
012sounds like they were grouped by Rock so they had a singular Mr moral Rock for getting all members to cross Finish Line first and Mr Goldstein for the overall first place finish so good job Mr West and uh the entire middle school for taking part in that event this year it looks like uh he also included his list of clubs and advisers which was something that we incorporated I think it was last year's board meeting we wanted to make sure that the board was aware of the clubs that were running the uh co-curriculars and such and those who were associated with those so he's listed those there um and they had their band and chorus Winter concert last night so um and outside of that any questions about Mr West's present um Mr West's um
013report I'm happy to attempt to answer any comments about it obviously you're welcome well congratulations to all those turkey Trotters that's great um are there any other comments or questions for Tim regarding the Middle School great I I just wanted to mention that uh game club at the middle school is not running this year that just happened okay I'm going to just check out that list is is that on the list or is that it is the last item on the list okay I I just want to take a look at that really quick the club advisers and thank you for catching that Patrick did email me and ask to that so great Co was that lack of student interest yes there was an adviser who was willing to do it it was lack of
014Interest okay great good to know well and we thank all those staff members who take the time to do this those things so um that really adds to the flavor of our buildings which is important so thank you moving on to the high school are you I'll do Brian I'll do athletics first um so congrats to our girls soccer team who um capped off their second back-to back undefeated state championship Seasons um congrats to um coach Clark as well as his entire staff and the entire program and uh specifically mcken Maguire who was named the division two girls player of the year so um quite the season quite the program congrats to all involved we have our winter season kicking off actually uh we did have a meet on Sunday a swim meet on Sunday
015a bowling meet on Saturday um and then tonight Brian's actually hosting our first wrestling match and then our basketball teams go on the road sorry our boys basketball team is on the road our girls uh is home on Friday and we have um our ice hockey team uh in our new co-op uh with marac and derfield they kick things off next week so things are underway as well as our indoor track and gymnastics teams are also up and running hbms uh middle uh the Athletics of the Middle School the winter sports are already underway they've already got their boys and girls Hoops steam have already played and and looks like off a good start as well as um their wrestling team uh looking to defend their Tri County Championship from last year so it looks
016like things are off to a good start down here in the middle school as well and as always Brian includes his participation numbers as Holly points out every year typically uh you see some evid flow between sports um but in addition to um what we usually see uh we did see an increase over participation uh I ran the numbers real quick uh after school today and it looks like that's a little above 30% of our student population takes part M Sports is our student population higher this year than it was last year 72 it's right it hovered from last year right around the same number but uh our participation numbers increased and if you look it looks like our indoor track team beefed up um 40 to 53 participants um and everything else um some
017slight increases and wrestling looks like it jumped about 12 kids too so gymnastics nearly tripled gymnastics significantly higher from six to 15 participants yeah that's a lot czy was reason for that just I don't know but as an example I've always point out so there's no winter cheer so potentially some of those students who might opt for and what is that just lack of Interest win yeah so interesting well I mean but overall the numbers are higher and um our track numbers were higher in this fall as well I think the cross country numbers yeah yeah sorry cross country numbers were higher so and uh that's like a runnner thing right and then we also uh just hired a no I just mean that they I had a runner it just means that like if
018if we if they it means that they're running that you're G to have kids running probably three seasons you know and so you'll end up with bigger numbers in all three that's what I meant it just didn't come out right and last highlight I want to make here from Brian's report was we did hire a high school girls lacrosse coach MD learnard and high school girls basketball JY coach you might recognize that name Jordan Scott our assistant athletic director he is helping Heidi out coaching girls so overall uh sports are off to a good start this winter and capped off with uh Soccer Championship to round off all season does anyone else have any comments just congratulations to the girls soccer team that's incredible were they undefeated last year as well yeah wow quite some
019I think undefeated is actually like a little bit of an understanding I don't know because I can't maybe you know Tim but I I don't think I have to take off my socks and shoes to count how many goals they allowed but they didn't allow I mean last I knew it was a few goals they allowed so not only were they undefeated they excellent they didn't allow anyone was great super impressive and it was a great and all that being said it was still a great very competitive championship game they needed everything they had to to win it all so it was it was it was great overes love that thank you so now it's your turn all right um I wanted to um bring to your attention so I think I mentioned it in
020last month um but we uh took part in what is called New Hampshire day where students across the state of New Hampshire have the opportunity to apply to any uh New Hampshire institution of higher ed for free so the um application fees are wav that day um we had more than half of our seniors take part in this opportunity our librarian hosted the event uh we had um representatives from uh what is formerly known as NE highered um um financial aid office so we had on hand to support our students in the application through the application process and we also gave away a $500 scholarship um through U through that same agency so uh it was a really exciting opportunity uh there was a really great Vibe throughout the school that day um and in
021addition uh you also saw the underclass take interest in um in what that looked like and what that was all about so really overall positive experience for for the school again um we are once again going to be taking part RPS which is slated for March 25 similar to Brian I'm sorry Patrick's report I also included my club to advis their positions which happy to talk about with any questions about that per board's requests I included our CTE enrollment numbers and in addition to those um kind of more generalized numbers there where uh we have just the raw numbers of who's attending which of our receiving schools also have a breakdown of the number of students taking part in specific programs at each of thoseo north south and mil a highlight I just wanted to
022mention I was hoping we could have a vote on our program study so we can move forward with our course selection process the agenda last was thew it's on I'm sorry okay it's item number two fantastic um and then item number two under deliberation okay I have a different agenda I must have printed later I printed up the wrong I printed out a different so it's number two hbhs program so last month we presented that um a proposal that included the na computer science principal course um going into the program of studies and the removal of a dual enrollment engineering course and uh given the feedback about um the removal of that course we are currently in the process of researching um a replacement dual enrollment course we have come across a statistics course um
023through the community college system of New Hampshire uh that we are considering uh not for this upcoming year um but for the potential incorporation into next year's program studies for the following school year so we are doing our research uh for the 26 27 program of studies to replace that uh offering for the dual enrollment um uh opportunity for uh for that profile of student and not included in this report only because it's uh somewhat hot off the press um we did have um a recent advisory leadership team meeting where we are taking into account input from our staff and uh students and we are um going to uh make a slight adjustment to our schedule uh no instructional minutes will be adjusted whatsoever um it'll just be uh merely moving our advisory block uh
024down a little later in the day to a but cab block uh it'll improve accessibility for our CTE morning students so right now we're seeing uh a handful of morning CTE students are returning back right at the end of advisory and missing out on an opportunity um so this will actually um support that so those kids will be coming into um study hall instead of advisory so it increases accessibility and then also U just improves the overall flow of the day so this came as um by request from our staff um through advisory leadership team um and without any instr any impact on instructional minutes or anything of that nature um this is um a notification that this this adjustment is going to be made the plan andly for the second semester so um early
025February after the um midterms do you have the schedule do I do have hard copies I did make it into the packet but I can pass these around just we'll pass thank you yep so now it buts C block sure so um I think it'll um I think it'll improve the flow of the overall day and um generally speaking the uh an improvement to our schedule great what else we got um 12 Angry jurors I'll highlight next month's um report but we had that last weekend we have guitar night this upcoming weekend as well as our um performing arts department Winter concert next week and I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about just a Qui question on the advisers Ron um there were a few that were blank there highl are those
026I was more are those just not running I'm assuming maybe just not a sign because the spring play is on there that's a corre big one Debate Club um did not run for a lack of Interest Herer uh same thing um spring play we are in the process of filling that role that'll obviously run uh it was just those three oh yeah figured it what I just was curious y thank you for bringing that up yeah so debate and heer are not running this year just lack of interest and then um the spring play I would say probably have that build by next awesome thank you than any other questions yeah I was curious um really excited to see the apply New Hampshire day happen um did that end up were we able to pull
027pull that off before uh early action deadlines yeah so it's right before great yeah it was the 14th I think okay so before like the November 15 yeah and I that's not our date that's apply New Hampshire's date so I think it's done with purpose that it's just prior to the right early action date well I think they they sort of allow schools to do it on different days throughout okay November even I think even we let you do it even earlier but glad it happened I'm glad to see somebody students to advantage of it a great opportunity cool anything else um I have two questions um youth RIS Behavior survey we're going to do that again in March have we do we have any followup or do you want to kind of come back
028with us to us maybe in January with some followup on like what what's been taking place since we've got the results of the youth best behavior survey in the fall yeah yeah happy to um and then just one side note um I think one of the things that we had talked about kind of at length here is the setting in which the students are surveyed um yeah and our plan will be to administer the survey in advisory ideally with some leadup um in conversation around the results from last year or two years ago I should say um and also in the environment where uh you're with that trusted adult you're with Umar it's in a different space than we been administrative and we don't do it every year we do it every other year that's
029correct outside of the covid Year where it got kicked um one year further um it isn't every other year survey um any other questions on that and then my second comment is really that I was really excited to see this the idea that you guys are pursuing or looking at a stats one class because I believe that was a conversation in this board um a couple of years ago when we had our like chat about what we'd like to see in the program studies and I think many of us feel like that's a class that is good for a liberal arts student it's good for a you know and we only we have an AP stats class which some kids can't access that so you know I just want to put a plugin for encouraging
030if that if you can find that way because you know social social like there there's all sorts of social sciences that use stats too and kids going off into college in all different areas so and also kids who aren't going off to college just understanding a little bit about data yeah we were really excited about it we just uh felt like the timing of it um uh we didn't have enough time to get into this year's program but we want to do a little bit more research on it but we agree we thought it was a great option yeah perfect great um the CTE is that higher numbers or is it pretty much the same do you remember I don't remember what last year's are I should have looked it up but you give me
031a few minutes I can certainly find that information and I'll report back in in a minute if you want and we are we are are we are continuing with Milford for kids who have already signed up for class like who are in a program like they're in culinary arts two and you'll maybe next year be in three but we are phasing out Milford right that's correct yep so these students are have already been there for a year uh we grandfathered them in and allowed them to finish their program U but the plan is um to consolidate down to alurn North and South in the coming year I had a constituent ask why I can't recall it's just simply Transportation it's transportation and uh there's redundancy in the offerings so we have an opportunity to offer
032um similar if not the same um options for students in those other three schools and and it it does support our offerings in that um you know we can provide transportation we don't have students driving out and it um it just makes things uh a little bit more simpler great any other questions on the princial okay did you have something you want to say I saw you moving okay all right moving on thank you very what time is it so okay still have a couple more minutes um okay so next is the budget I we're at discussion right yes is that where we are some you tell me we at discussion great in your board packet uh you have an Excel spreadsheet as well as uh three rounds for the new items I'd like to
033start the Excel spreadsheet that which is the very last page because I think I can kind of highlight most of the information there so the last page the very last page where we have um FY 25 26 round 3.1 and then the percentages first of all I'd like to start by thanking the bucom uh we've had another very good year uh some very positive discussions whether it be about facilities whether it be about the operating budget waren articles um and I want to thank uh Kelly for her her efforts there as well we are presently at this moment 99,354 below guidance um the reason that number fluctuated pretty big between last month and this month is we only had uh one retirement so the others money that we had put into the retirement account was
034taken out so that's why uh there's a large uh difference between our budget and guidance in the budget right now we have both items listed and what I mean by that is we have n $915,000 in there in the operating budget to do the boilers we also have as you'll see on there a warrant article for 600,000 so right now operating budget from last year to round 3.1 is a difference of 1,856 41048 which is 6.34% we put in uh what would be year one for Hesser which we'll be discussing later on tonight the contingency which has been in there the last couple years our consistent funding for maintenance trust we are not funding the special ed trust because we are at the agreed upon maximum so until we use some we will leave that
035where it is we have the 8 BMS boiler lease which is a new boiler and all the accompaning HVAC items which again we'll be discussing later tonight we will discuss a u a solar proposal uh that's why that is in yellow and just question marks because we don't know if the board will or will not move forward with that I do want to bring your attention uh down to the bottom uh right hand corner of that last page because Kelly provided us with the options regarding only one of the items is going to pass obviously if the lease for the boiler and equipment is passed at the middle school we will make a motion on the floor to remove the $915,000 or vice versa if the lease is not approved then the $915,000 will be
036in there so when you look at it first set of blocks uh Kelly has a 915 but not to 600,000 so we see the increase of 3.34% that we talked about just a minute ago and then the overall warrant only goes up to 6.44% if you go to what I think is my preferred scenario at least that the voters would approve the warrant article for the 600,000 and we would take out the 915,000 that would give you an operating budget of 3.05% from last year to this year and then the overall budget would be 5.43 um and that's simply because again using the lease or Bond whichever is decided by the voters and the board will just spread those costs out over multiple years so when you say you said the bo voters would approve
037a $600,000 warrant it's it's not a $600,000 warrant it's a warrant article it's a it's a 5 it's more than that but that's the payment that's the pay correct thank you for that $600,000 is the payment on if if if the bond if the municipal SL Bond whatever we go with is approved it'll be a $600,000 payment and that payment starts in FY 26 uh yes okay it'll be slightly different between a bond and a lease because a lease should only pay half year of interest and the full payment the following year the other thing that um the 915 is the complete cost of the boiler replacement the boiler and the piping and we just pay it and that's not the rest of the project that's just the it's the absolute like we absolutely have
038to do that or we will not be in compliance with piping and we could have no heat in the building and from a b budget standpoint we have a approximately a $600,000 bond coming off so from that overall piece this is kind of tax neutral if the voters were to approve this new lease SL Bond whichever it may be um the new items which I'm not going to go line item by line item or really go over um once again this year provide us the ability to move forward as a school district um there are you know mentoring items um more facilities uh pieces on a minor scale science tables um technology which is on our regular uh cycle you know so it's it's a very very good budget and I really want to thank
039the the budget committee for all their pieces uh one thing I will highlight because Lauren's done a masterful job of it uh we'll be adding um a bcba and an ID teacher um but those two additions will allow us to drop an out of District program that really works in our building which is called NCC which is $200,000 and by owning those employees they'll have the ability to add to their case load throughout the year should somebody new move in or something of that so again this is one of those what I call Cost avoidance pieces but I honestly believe it's much better services for our students by doing it inhouse and I'll happily take any questions on the budget uh and it'll go back to the budget committee uh later this mon yeah later
040this month and then final approvals in January Andy did we uh need to see relief from the budget committee on any elements it doesn't appear to we we did not okay we we did not um you know it was a very solid year yeah um and very fruitful discussions so you're under guidance at this point correct and there's still around four so you'll still be tweaking or you are you going to go to round four we will go to round four there might be some minor tweakings I mean if you know I think 2.99 looks better than 3.05 um and again we and that you know if I could get the whole warrant down around right around 5% uh I would do that but I also have a potential number that would be in for
041the solar lease or Bond but at least in the first couple years uh as you'll see tonight that would be cost neutral because what would be saving in our electric bills great thank you are there any questions on this thanks for all the hard work and mean and the budget committee needs to be commended for all their work as well thank you to them um the next piece is the budget committee update um Tom is that you're done right yep so Tom did send an email and um he did say um he talked a little bit about what you just said but he also said the bdcom voted to support a facility Bond lease for the msac improvements at the $5.2 million level so just so we know that they did vote for mhm um
042and it's a preliminary position contingent upon final budget and more articles so that's the budget committee update from Holly great um facilities presentation for the warrant let me just check the time not quite yet so three more minutes um so at this point uh who is is this Lance and Mike are here to present to us or they're here for questions they're here for backup okay your your presting yeah or is Rob uh I'm going to I'm going to take it but Rob is going to jump in Gina is going to jump in and Lance and Mike here for those technical items items uh so basically in your packet you have the same proposal as you saw last month uh which cont includes the following upgrade of the boilers and installed new propane tanks for
04395,000 and then the rebates are listed upgrade to LED lighting for 333,000 and the accompanying rebates are listed the upgrade to the HVAC controls for 665,000 add mechanical ventilation and dehumidification for 550,000 upgrade the 1994 unit vent area to ervs with dehumidification for $2,112 up up grade the hru units 1 and two for 727 th000 and then item 7 and 8 replace 2002 units for 850,000 and item 8 replace the MPR cafeteria ventilation 400,000 that gave us a total of 6,541 1200 with grants and rebates of 85,000 and any Energy savings of 5357 more to come on items seven and eight so that takes us to um I'm just going to highlight Lance has provided you with page one the facilities committee's recommendation it was a unanimous recommendation uh we had a a great discussion
044and we had a a number of the uh members from the Hollis energy committee who attended uh to hear the discussion and where appropriate offer input the boilers are at holl brookl Middle School it's currently two boilers they're both at the end of their use of Life approaching 25 plus years of age uh we have provided pictures in the packet for those people at home that would like to refer that it's on board dos um we also need to replace the delivery system the piping because stricter testing standards um these boilers with their age in the piping can't withstand such testing so they have to be replaced as most people recall we did this at the high school last year the proposed change would be from heating oil to prop propane and the installation of
045two new propane boilers would require the removal of the old us and installation of new propane tanks so a side benefit the underground storage tank would be removed and we wouldn't have to potentially worry about any environmental issues as that tank ages yeah it's removing a lot of risk it is District yep um we believe these changes to the boilers will make it a much better learning environment for students and better climate control for all Bill building occupants so that's where the $915,000 came in the lighting the LED lighting we are recommending that we do that project at this time because uh from our discussion with the facilities committee and information from Mike Davies our energy consultant we believe that the rebates for these projects will be going away so to do the lights at
046the middle school would be 333,000 the HVAC controls these would allow us to install new Erv units that will require the older HVAC controls to be added and upgraded so this is going to really give us a lot more technology around the efficient running of our boilers you know external controls from remote sites if all of a sudden it's it's a snow day on a Friday and and the next week is vacation we can adjust the temperatures then and get that savings and and it is significant when you're talking buildings of this size making those changes yeah I think the other thing that we want I think that we gain is the ability to for both boilers to be redundant right now they're separately piped so you lose one boiler half the building goes out
047you lose the other one the other half goes out so by putting the two boilers together and piping them together not only are they redundant but they're load sharing now so they're not carrying 100% of the load they're sharing that 100% of the load so that takes a lot of stress and strain off the boilers as well good the piece number four is to add mechanical ventilation to the gym right now we off operate off for a Louver so if it's too hot in the gym we open the Louver and the heat goes right right outside and the cold air comes rushing in you don't want to be sitting in that section of the Middle School gym when that Louver opens up uh it's an archaic system that would not meet muster uh in today's
048standards so by replacing this and adding the dehumidification uh we get a savings out of it in the long run and the budget for that is 550,000 and that really does need to be done it's probably one of our most inefficient areas of fuel consumption the number five is the upgrade the 1994 unit ventilators um overtime unit ventilators hanging from the ceilings are underneath the windows become very noisy and very inefficient and we had to look at it from both environments we looked first from the Energy Efficiency which was not good and they are starting to show their problems in Breaking T down on the educational side they're getting noisy enough that teachers would like them off during class so that students can hear the lesson so it really is one of those things that
049we will see a significant upgrade to the the um climate in our school as well as the climate in our classrooms these are a number of of units AC really kind of across the building and to replace all those is 2,11 th200 not one in every classroom like spread around just that one in every classroom in that red area right okay yep so on page six uh for those people who would be at home if you went to page six in the packet and looked at the red highlighted area those are all the areas that have the unit ventilators that need to be replaced um item six is upgrade the hru one and two the heat recovery units serve uh the seventh and eighth grade classrooms at the middle school that is the majority of
050our INR instructional space is located in these two wings so by doing this we doing the vast majority of the building's instructional spaces to replace these units is 727 th000 again on page seven of the packet Lance has provided us a couple uh pictures of the rooftop units in the red areas in the diagram highlight the instructional spaces that will be uh seeing a significant upgrade in the quality of those rooms item seven and item eight are both in the proposal because that's what the facilities committee originally um looked at both items seven and eight have been tabled so the replace existing hva units installed in 2002 for 850,000 has been delayed and the replace the cafeteria for um room ventilation for 400,000 um in reviewing these we realize these units are aging but they
051are working very efficiently and they do not really provide uh places for the instructional space so we're talking these units Supply the two music rooms the staff room the library and main office spaces and we would believe we have solutions for those if if things were to come up and needed to be replacement so we have taken those two items seven and eight as you would see on page 10 of the final page of the packet when we come up to our new proposal that was unanimously supported by the facilities committee which includes items 1 through six for a total of 5,291 1200 with $85,000 in repats and $ 53,5 70 of annual Energy savings so that will be the annual ongoing savings we are recommending a lease for this project uh we will have
052further numbers to give you the terms uh for that dollar amount but we know we're right into um you know we will be under the present Lea that is coming off and that was one of the facilities committee's goal uh to have some savings from that Bond that's coming off but at the same time uh take care of these items that are in desperate need of upgrades that ends recommendation one which is the HVAC and the units and I'll take any questions on recommendation one at this time I want to close hold on one second I just want to close public input at 659 okay the the only thing I would add to that Andy was that I'd ask you to think about this recommendation because it's been carefully curated as a as an integrated
053system so each one of these components not just a laundry list of items that you just you know do and check off each one kind of complements the other to meet the goals of we're trying to achieve which is better environment or climate control better experience for for uh students at staff where they spend the biggest bulk of their time um and you know and it also meets our performance goals which is you know be Net Zero which is co impact of the taxpayer um and and uh you know so it's really been thought out and and really needs to be looked at as a system because that's what the whole system delivers so removing a piece is just going to take a leg out of maybe a four-legged table right or a five-legged table
054and you just keep moving stuff away and now now you just got a couple of upgrades that really don't impact and deliver the level of performance so that's how we approached it there any other questions i' would like to just uh recognize Lance uh Lance fitore is our facilities uh director Lance he coordinated facilities committee he was a chair uh and he did a great job of leading a very diverse group uh to a very solid solution and also with Lance is uh Mike Davies Mike Davies is with eii for those at home eei did our high school boiler project in dehumidification and came in on time on budget and they also did a Brookline project at rmms and on time on budget so they have uh produced these results so I feel very confident
055in the recommendations they make regarding the dollar amounts and the product that we'll end up with so I just have some questions that I'm going to ask I might know the answers to but I just want the public to know the answers to them so these are prices and estimates um if we approve this do those like stay solid or what if um I don't know there's creases in tariffs or something like that um would we be subject to that um we did discuss tariffs and that is an unknown that we don't know how it will impact us but I would say these are would you agree Mike solid estimates um and um I'd say there's a high probability unless something Chang governmentally that we would see these numbers uh complete this project okay um
056and then on number seven and eight I can see what the thinking is my I'm more concerned about number seven um is that the $850,000 is that something like I know you said they're running pretty efficiently now will we be back to the taxpayers in two years asking for these or is this something that you can phase because it's more than one unit it could be phased into the budget over time like what what's the overall end game with that I think there are a number of solutions they could be uh phased into the faciliity maintenance schedule okay like we did the roofs at the high school uh we could take an approach like we did with the elevator here where we put aside money over a number of years and then when one of
057these goes we have that sitting there we also have um in the last couple years a larger unreserved fund balance that is something were to go in an emergency we'd be able to tap into that obviously with a board vote so I think that's why we're very comfortable and I think we feel that these units will last uh and again we did kind of look at it more from uh instructional spaces sure uh and the other police just like we saw at the high school we believe there'll be what I'll call a byproduct of the other work where these environments this Library will be much more um climate friendly because of the other units if their rooftop unit were to go great good that makes sense to me and then my final question is um
058two years ago we presented a a bond for replacing all of our boilers at the high school and the middle school with propane boilers I and um I got a lot of push back not just from folks who didn't want to spend money but from folks who really wanted to make sure that we were doing the most energy efficient you know will this lead us to a more like you know Green way of doing things is this after all this time are we headed in that direction now with these I'm not very Savvy on all of this so are we headed that way I would say we are with our discussion that's still to come on recommendation number two regarding solar because everything we're doing now um we can offset with our solar load and
059what will happen is as we continue to expand solar we will then be able to use these propane boilers as potentially backup units which will extend their longevity so instead of a 25 to 30 year old boiler we might be able to get 40 to 50 years out of it and another line of thinking with that was um these are brand new boilers because we needed to rethink the um the system we needed a central plant we don't have that here the high school there is a central plant and so what we did was we took older boilers and we um replaced simply the burner so that added useful life to that system but that makes the high school a little bit more primed for um future technology in terms of of energy efficiencies so
060rather than kind of putting all your eggs in one basket it allows you to try out an alternate Source in one location while having sort of a guaranteed reliable system in our other building okay and it's virtually identical to what we did in the lower schools okay the same reasons you have a the foundational boiler typical boiler system but then you have other things like heat pumps and things like that that actually do 80 to 90% of the the demand and then you have your your foilers there and so members of the Hollis energy commission is it a commission committee they've been you know paying attention and part of the not oh okay part of the conversations and and at the meetings and okay around great well because they were they were very um they
061were very vocal two years ago and you know um I just want to make sure we're not there again I don't want to be there again so Christa I just want to thank the committee for all the work you guys did it's truly amazing and I know how much work went into this you can see it just in this but this is just a snippet of all the time and energy and effort that you guys pun intended um that you put into it so thank you very much yeah I think I think the big upside is also is the committee being kind of unique that it's a standing commit MH members of the committee get to build their understanding of the buildings and what and how things were done because you need that level of
062understanding to be able to figure out what is the proper step to go forward so it's not something that you can just gain by a couple of meetings and then have it you have to really lean into it and deep dive into it so uh so it's I think it's been a great move for the board to have this um committee to do this heavy lifting so we can stay more high level yeah I think it's great and I think it's good and I mean as this project gets if this gets approved and there may not be as many projects on the Forefront or you know on the horizon but having a standing committee that can meet less often but regularly yeah and and I think maybe some of the other items that we would
063look into after let's say everything gets approved is these other items that we took off the list maybe we look lean into that and say okay what's the best way how would we go ahead and and do this over time what is a recommended funding model or strategy or something like that so thank you so much so you're going to go on and talk to us about so that is on our that we made a an agenda adjustment to vote on whether or not to move forward with that on the warrant um but then a Lee I think did I did I say lease did I say Bond I don't know what I said the recommendation is the changes to the middle school as a lease right I don't know if we can actually even
064say that at this point because we have to change the articles of agreement but we can certainly recommend to move forward with the project you know yeah we have to have the special meeting and we so technically I don't believe we can actually approve leases at this point right but we can move to put the project on right move to put the pro on the warrant and then with the funding mechanism to be or not the P whatever the word is you guys will write it all of you start working I'm writing it just say it um okay so moving on to so that we'll vote on but this next is this is the first time this board is seeing the next recommendation correct and it will be back again next month January and if
065unless we tell you not to correct and most likely looking for a potential vote if the board so chooses so the recommendation two out of the co-op facilities committee was regarding the Energy Efficiency and energy resilience we put forth many topics and ultimately solar power and solar efficiency were narrowed down and discussed at length through these discussions a Solar Ray on an open part of our property was investigated as an option and eei provided us with the map and the area in blue was originally where we were looking for that solar field and that's really kind of the area between the track and um the high school building over for those who know the the track storage shed and then going back that way so that's the area that we that we looked at uh
066this slide along with others were discussed and it seemed a ground mounted Solar Ray would be the best Choice discussion about open areas and land plots were immediately discussed as the best placement of such an array the solar array was an attractive option because it could feed both Hollis Brookline High School and Hollis Brookline middle school as well as potentially other sites in the sau41 budget numbers were put together in the cost for doing the project is shown below so the project for the solar array field mounted uh you have have the energy supervision Administration the Sol and panels the inverters the balance of the system the switch gear the ever source connection costs the site work and insulation labor and equipment so that brought us uh to 3,454 183 there was an IRS elective
067pay benefit for doing a project like this that we would receive back which would return $88,900 to the Hollis substation so if you went over to Hollis primary school and looked diagonally across the street there is your substation right there uh and there would need to be significant upgrades at that substation to the tune of approximately $1.5 million over and above the cost that I just talked about on the previous page there were also concerns about land clearing and treem removal for such a large area finally using the land and not it takes it out of any possibility for future expansion if the high school ever needed to expand because of population grade so these were all concerns raised by the committee so then we explored in depth the roof mounted solar systems like we
068did at the Hollis primary and the Hollis upper school and a roof mounted option was proposed at both the co-op middle school and the co-op High School first thing and the biggest concern was the structural integrity and whether the roofs were capable of supporting the increase in the load uh we had a structural engineering study conducted and it was deemed that both roofs were capable of supporting the solar panels in the designated areas the high school roof mounted system proposal would provide annual Savings of $84,700 a 69% electric usage offset and a payback of 10.9 years please understand that the payback was calculated without using an escalation of future energy cross so we just used this year's numbers and kept them that way and that's how we arrived I can't imagine there will won't be
069electrical increases over the years so that payback would actually come down and be less with those increases the initial system cost would be 1,290 and after tax benefit the net cost would be 9617 129 and in Lance's packet he shows those calculation the turnkey installation again for that [Music] 1,290 the federal elective payback which is about 25.5% of the cost so the net cost to us would be 9617 129 and again it's an annual Savings of 84,4 se4 the Hollis Brookline Middle School roof mounted system proposal would provide an annual savings of$ 57,7 129 a 77.6% electrical usage offset and a payback of 10.8 years again payback calculated without escalation the initial system cost would be 925,000 , 244 and the after tax benefits the next C the net cost would be [Music] 68937 the
070co-op's facility audit tool which is what we use to plan our facility budgeting has a complete roof replacement cycle included in it which would mirror the solar installation so as we did the roof we were installed a solar so in next year's budget is150 ,000 uh for roof upgrade at the middle school we would start the section that would allow us to add the most solar on that roof section so again you have the turnkey installation cost the federal payback and the net cost to us so we had a uh AR rousing debate at our December 4th meeting and the committee came to again uh consensus unanimous support uh that they would prefer the roof mounted systems this would allow us to use our space on the roof gain the Energy Efficiency and still reduce
071our energy cost significantly and not preventing us from moving forward in the future if we wanted to do a solar field at some point down the road the committee was uh created to again discuss the facilities related topics as they pertain to the co-op School District you just heard about their recommendations for the HVAC and everything included in the boilers they're also making this recommendation uh which was unanimous uh one to do the roofs at the high school for 925 5,244 and the excuse me that was the middle school I misspoke and then the high school is the 1,290 for a total project of 2,261 155 that would be the cost of the warrant article if you so choose but you would get grants and rebates totaling 565,000 Le are Bond so your net cost
072ultimately would be 1,651 36 with a payback of approximately 10 years and eight or nine months depending on the scenario I do believe though that payback will be quicker I think that has been proven in Hollis because the Hollis uh system is already paid for itself uh in about under eight years as a result of that what was the original projection on that do you remember about the same about the same yeah um and we believe between the rebates and the energy efficiencies at both buildings that this project will potentially be uh cost neutral and Kelly was working up those numbers for the January presentation and again we're not looking for an action on this item tonight but want you to get it out there for the community and for the board and again thank
073every body who served on the energy commission there are also two uh supporting documents that were provided by eii that show uh the return on on investment in the solar array and those calculations for both the middle school the high school is there a time frame to receive the grants of rebates does it happen in the first year two years uh the the rebates would be like if we did the plan would be to do the whole high school because the roof is ready okay so those rebates would probably be in in somewhere between 6 months and a year just waiting for them to arrive and take a little time um the middle school if we did as suggested a a lease on this as well uh we could do kind of a pay as
074you go so we do the first section of roof we'll do the corresponding solar the nice part about a lease is you only pay on the money you borrowed not money you used not the total amount you borrowed so let's say uh the first year we we take out 2.2 million we spend 1 million 1.2 million is in our bank account earning interest for us and then as we do the first section of roofing we do the first section of solar at the middle school so I guess my only question is like if it's going to take multiple years we have these estimates based on like what things cost now so how does that work like does eii just kind of like set those prices and I mean know that um well we have the
075significant piece already scheduled for the roof at the middle school and that would be a large piece of the solar okay then my recommendation in looking at the what would be the FY 27 budget is to uh in our maintenance trust to accelerate the roof because you'd have the money and basically be done either in a second or third year um just for people at home um we we don't have any worries with regard to snow in the Solar uh we have had to remove a whole section of Hollis primary and we do some issues with the roof there and they were all easily and inexpensively remounted and up and running in just a few days after the roof was done um so we have data that really supports doing this just want to add
076that um if you look at the pictures of the roof of the middle school and high school you can see what parts of the roof were deemed appropriate to receive the solar so the Middle School roof actually has the largest portion that is not solar capable if you will and so we would um as Andy mentioned uh coordinate the roof based on where the solar could go and then save that portion for the end um it's just a I mean I'm not in this world so just like a common question like don't prices go up how do you you know protect against that and um and then I do I did go to the um facilities committee meeting and I think Christa kind of referenced it those grants and rebates are part of the Mike
077said it it's are they're part of the inflation reduction act right and so we don't know politically where that all is going to be but we hope that we would be able to pull that out if we approve it in March hopefully it's still there right right and we do feel confident from uh comments eii has provided to us from they're looking at this from a more global point of view than New Hampshire uh to the benefits across the country of solar to um government agencies yeah did you want to say something Mike are you good I I think you cover okay are there any other questions um it certainly is something that we should definitely is everyone in the board feel like we can vote on this next month it should be come back
078it should come back there's interest in it coming back and having debate and disc discussion on that again okay I just want to make sure that there's General support for it at this point and and and Mike just a question for me just a um the the lifespan of the solar is roughly what 30 years yeah they they say 35 35 so as these things get paid off there's a whole bunch of years that they're just going to keep generating power and right pay it off after eight or 10 years it's going to be a gift that keeps on giving I actually have to say the other thing about the roof mounted system is it's a little bit more secure from Bad actors if you will like a a system out in the middle of
079the fields that are between our high school and our um I mean I know that we had a golf ball incident at Hughes right didn't we have a golfing incident so I just I I feel like it's a lot safer if it's I mean obviously that happened but it's still safer if it's up high and aesthetically you don't even if you look at the primary school you don't even know there's I didn't even know they were up there there's panels up there this would be very similar to that right so I I do actually can I can see why the roof mounted system is a good thing for us at this point I assume that the the advantage to that ground mounted system was that we would just be producing that much more energy and
080it would cover a 100% of our costs and we could actually forget sell back energy to eversource right that was why I I got the sense at the meeting that a lot of folks were really hoping we would go with that system because we' be supplying the street side of power and consuming power as we normally do and would just be a number right but that was a a significantly more expensive correct project for us correct okay sounds good to me all right moving on um we'll stay through we'll keep the keep Tim here through deliberations yeah you guys I think we're good gentlemen thank you for being here thanks guys um and then Lind does Linda need to stay no Linda can go Linda would like to go I'm I'm good you're good okay
081and Tim probably wants to stay through um the vote on the program studies right and then after yep after the program of studies Tim you can sco so have we moved to um deliberative items is that where we are correct okay so first and foremost I did um email with the uh just to move forward with the um special meeting I did send an email to Liz Brown again and she agreed to um moderate the special meeting um if anybody wants to talk about that did you want to speak to that at all Andy or should we just put a motion on the floor I I think we can put a motion on the floor if there's any discussion that can happen dur then sure okay so I need a motion to I need motion
082by member to schedule a special meeting to take place at 7 p.m on Thursday January 30th 2025 with a snow date of Friday January 31st 2025 to consider amendments to the articles of agreement that would clarify the definition of capital expenses and continue the current apportionment formula so moved I I heard Cindy so moved by Cindy second second by Rob okay um so we have in our packet the actual warrant does anybody want to talk to that yeah in your board packet uh um you have the memo that Jim had provided last month uh when he attended and we had a variety of questions and discussions our moderator had attended in those pieces and a couple things that had come out one was in his calendar we were making the adjustment from 116 2025 to
0831:15 2025 for the public hearing because that would be our meeting date so we wouldn't be adding another meeting so that would be one of the pieces and the snow date would be 1225 um if we unfortunately had not 131 or of the public hearing oh the public hearing okay and then the special meeting dates would be 1:30 2025 and 130 2025 the Friday is uh was indicated we had requested and Jim has provided which is included in your packet um the proposed warrant articles for the uh special meeting and they are there with all the different pieces that we had highlighted um so it asks article one amend Capital articles of agreement to clarify definition of capital expenses and to see if the school district will vote to clarify the definition of capital expenses
084and article four of the article of agreement of the Hollis Brookline Cooperative School District as follows Capital expenses of the holl Brookline Cooperative School District payable in each fiscal year shall be a portioned based on the average daily membership ADM and the equalized valuation EV according to the table below Capital expenses shall include the cost of requiring land and buildings for school purposes the construction Furnishing and equipping of school bu buildings and facilities and the payment of the principal and interest on any indebtedness which is occurred is incurred to pay for the same or which is assumed by The Cooperative School District including but not limited to the principal and interest of bonds and leases under RSA 33 col 7-e so that would be the first piece that we would have for the special meeting
085which would uh address the lease versus bond question and and change those if the voters should approve the second item for that night would be to continue the current method of apportionment expenses in the Articles of agreement and this is simply an up or down vote to see if the school district will vote to continue the current apportionment formula set forth in article four of the Articles of agreement of the haris brook line Cooperative school district and then the legislative body's action would dictate our next steps so Kelly would post the article Jim is would provide her all the different dates for meeting the the requirements we would hold the public hearing on the 15th and then providing there was no snow on the 30th we would take up these two uh items at a
0867 o'clock meeting at hollbrook L high school are there any questions on this comments about the language does what we needed to do right yep okay um one one question from to what extent could somebody on the floor um try to modify or change language in this more um in terms of the special meeting the language that is going to be discussed has to be advertised in the paper so changing of the wording I believe our attorney would object to because it would not have been advertised because a citizen may have decided their attendance based on what was in the official notices right and that's what Jim uh informed us of again last month so that would be considered out of order that would considered out of or these are both basically up and down
087vote items okay and um the moderator and the attorney will be meeting to go over the the requirements of that night because we'll be using uh the Hollis moderator because the co-op moderator is away uh with a family commitment okay and the public hearing date would be 115 116 correct on this we y we will change that yeah so that means it's at our meeting so we'll open with the public hearing correct okay are there any other questions on this um okay so this is this vote that we're taking right now a vote to have the special meeting and on this warrant on this language like that sets it all right okay all right so all those in favor 6 Z motion carries okay next is a motion to approve the program of studies as
088presented I need a motion guys so mov moved by Beth second by Kate move by Beth second by Kate okay are there any comments or questions further comments or discussion on the program of studies just great job as always okay all those in favor 6 Z motion carries thank you um I also need a motion by member to ratify the tentative agreement with the Hollis education support staff Association ne- NH so moved moved by Beth as Christa Christa second by Beth Beth um thank you for all your hard work on that as well any comments okay all those in favor 60 motion carries okay so we got through those really quickly now we're on policy keep moving quickly the memo no we want to do facilities first I I don't know you want do do
089the memo and just get through that because that we the facilities thing first to but I just need a motion I can give you yeah you like me to read it yeah to see what action the board will take regarding the facilities committee's recommendation to move forward the boiler and other related HVAC items to the warrant at 5, 291,000 so I need a motion to approve that correct so move to Second by Christa second by Beth um okay is there any further conversation on that I think we've had a lot of conversation all right all those in favor 60 so moving forward with the facilities recommendation you're welcome all right and do we have a memo I didn't see it have a memo okay how did I miss the memo I missed the memo my
090gosh you like myo okay so so we have a memo and the way we're going to approach this because um I think we're going to do the whole memo right I mean we've got a third reading and adopt there were no changes the second reading was no changes and then we have a first reading with substantial changes so why don't we um how do we have we've been doing this like make a motion to put the memo we can do the memo yeah make a motion for the whole memo and then we can discuss each individually right okay so I need a motion to approve the policy committee's memo completely so moved moved by Beth can I need a second second second by Kate all right so J I'm gonna let you go because I
091feel like all these except for maybe the issue okay so ebch there have been no changes you've seen it a couple times before it's a new required bylaw policy uh so there were no comments or questions so I will just assume there are none um we're moving forward with the second read with no changes to ihb Simply a bunch of regulations really no wiggle room for um discuss discussion of changes because it's very um much legal um and then here are the substantial changes we're bringing bedg minutes forward um for first read and um the the meat of the changes presented here represent changes in rsas that discuss sealed minutes and how to handle sealed minutes so now if a board does not take action on sealed minutes after 10 years they automatically become unsealed
092so um the the Board needs to either review them or um so to do that periodically so the superintendant or board chair or their designate um shall look at those minutes and then decide when it's appropriate to bring It Forward for review to see and you can continue to seal them again but just know you're on a um 10year cycle for that um and then there's also an importance of if someone at the board um objects to something being discussed at the board level and they continue to object and the the board continues to discuss it the minutes must reflect that member X um like didn't want to talk about didn't want to talk about it um so those are substantial changes but I don't really think it changes the way we operate but we
093needed to make sure the policy showed that um policy ji students rights and responsibilities we um made a couple of changes based on um well we had to make sure that the handbook was called what we actually call the handbook um and we do publish it annually but but the policy should reflect that um and we also are now required which we have been already um to make the handbook available in other languages or present it orally um so that's the change first reading we haven't look seen that since 2008 so time to look at it and then the final one is JJJ and so this is being presented for a first read as a brand new policy that's required by law and this has to do with um access to public school programs by
094non-public students and so those would be residents of Hollis or Brookline who whether it's homeschooled or private school or or whatever how do we provide access to various programs and what are the um rules and regulations that we must abide by we have similar policies and we've done the crosswalk to make sure the language here does not is not in conflict with our current policies so that's them does anyone have any questions on those three that were were like kind of well on any of them on any of them does anyone have any questions comments feedback okay that's interesting um explain very well it was great great job Gina all those in favor of approving the um policy memo as is thank you so much Z policy is done um and that means we've done
095everything on this list right all right great so now a quick report out from the process Observer sure well the process Observer missed the beginning of the meeting but com yeah I thought if I game lead I didn't have to do it um no I so I missed the very beginning of it but you know very very timely meeting um I think that the um policy memo stuff is working beautifully and it's clear to it's easy to understand it feels less chaotic um and I think for anybody that's watching you know really big good presentation discussion by the facilities so that's really the highlight of the meeting is really if you havn't been here or missed any of it check that out because there's really a lot of information coming that's can be very relevant
096in the coming months but everything everything went smooth no uh no concerns for me unless I missed something in the beginning that's where all the controversy was okay you so much so um I guess we don't have another non-public right no we do so I could take a motion to adjourn we've got a move by bet seconded by chrisa all those in favor 6 Z weed at