CorpusRecord 56396

Exeter Region Cooperative School Board Deliberative Session 02/05/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Blue Hawk Media
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Rockingham County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,506 words · about 48 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e it is 6:30 and I'm calling to order the deliberative session for the exitor region Cooperative School District I'm Kate Miller the moderator and our first order of business is the Pledge of Allegiance please join me I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you to everybody who's here in attendance all the voters should have picked up a card from the supervisors of the checklist for your town um Bill gothier who is the chair of the Cooperative school board has a few words to begin Mr gothier thank you Kate appreciate that thank you everyone for attending tonight and listening to our uh school board and our budget we

002appreciate all of the input and um support that you guys have given us so I do want to start by uh there's been a lot of people that have given us input about the budget so I want to thank the budget advisory committee for all their work uh they have spent countless hours going through the budget line item by line item with the build building administrators in scrutinizing to ensure that we are putting a budget forth that looks strong and that values education and the taxpayers so their work we really appreciate all their work I also want to recognize a couple people on my team on the board who have done exceptional work uh one uh from Brentwood Scott fortunately Scott cannot be here tonight uh for family reasons but Scott has served on the

003board and served us very well he's an advocate for the kids he has kids in the school system he's done a great job we have developed a plaque for him we'll be sending that to him so hope if he's watching you'll be getting that plaque uh the other school board member is Mr Hall uh Bob you have been on this board and have given so much to the board and I I joined this board you on it and uh couple things that I remember about Bob is that he he does every year there's a couple things that he is very passionate about first is the real right scholarship that we give out each year to outstanding students and you have been an advocate we appreciate that uh SST in Great Bay uh we are here

004to talk about all the work that we do in te in the Great Bay you have been advocate for them for both those schools you show up to their meetings and we really appreciate the work you do on that because it brings us and Brit gets our knowledge up to speed and how we can serve them best and then the other thing is I remember saying in a meeting this a couple times that you were so passionate about making sure that every kid has an opportunity all the time and you are passionate about making Mak sure that kids had food to eat and you always stood up and made sure that their voice was heard so we appreciate all the work that you've done Bob and I've got a little plaque here to share with

005you and a little thank you card from all of us so Bob thank you very much for your [Applause] work yeah I'll save from here it's easy to say when you're a blue hawk you're always a blue hawk and I've been a bluehawk for many many years but um public education is a real asset it's the backbone of our nation there's people out there now that don't believe that and want to change that my goal is to keep this going as long as I can and with your help thank you for coming tonight it's going on we're in good hands up here that great staff thank you thank you Bob uh I also want to uh just kind of say uh that we are unfortunately that we have some retirees here in tonight in this

006place and uh I I'm I'm sad to say that Dr Isabelle will be leaving us at the end of this year so so I I just want to recognize all the work that you do and and knowing that you are retiring you put in 110% it is amazing I I go I meet with her in her office and she is ready to go all the time she's there early I get emails late I get texts at night which I don't love late at night but um you you are always on it so I appreciate all the work that you done you are going to be missed by all of us on the board so thank you for your work um principal Monahan we are going to miss you uh thank you for all your work

007you're uh you are steadfast in everything that you do your thoughtful and you're here for the students and we appreciate everything you do so you will be missed by the board certainly and one other person that I know is here in the building I thought I saw him Rusty are you here rusty he's up top he's up top up top Rusty yeah see that's that's what I'm talking about he's always here but uh someone that does not get a lot of recognition but does so much work for the school it is amazing the facility that you sit in when you walk into this High School the middle school all our schools Rusty you do amazing work can you please stay thank you for everything last and then I'll turn the uh the the mic back

008over to Kate so I appreciate you letting me have a little bit of time the school board members my teammates uh my friends thank you so much for all your work this year you're going to see presentations tonight you're going to hear about some of the things that we're putting in the ballot you're going to ask questions and we have answers it's because of their hard work dedication not just coming to every meeting and checking box but coming to every meeting and working hard asking the right questions and putting their heart into it and they do volunteer and they're here for the kids and for the administrators and I am so glad to be on your team so thank you so much thanks Bill thank you very much Bill all right um one thing wanted

009to just point out many people have been to this deliberative session before but just so that folks understand what we're doing here tonight is a meeting of the voters of the six towns that make up the Cooperative School District so this is a time for us to debate and discuss um the items that are on the warrant that will be up for the election in March um the folks who live in the town may speak at this meeting there's a microphone down front for folks to line up if they wish to speak on an article um only voters are allowed to speak at this meeting we do have some administrators and other folks who may be very helpful for answering questions and explaining things who don't live within the district so I'll be asking a

010little bit later um for permission to have all of those folks able to speak um if they have input to provide to us um this is an SP2 official ballot School District meaning that we have our district meeting split into two parts tonight is the deliberative session where we meet and discuss and amend as permitted by law the items that are on the warrant um and there are copies of the warrant lots of them at the back with explanations copies of the budget and the default budget at the back on the tables with the um supervisors of the checklist I use moderator rules to facilitate this meeting those have been available on the SAU website along with the warrant and the budget there are a few copies up there if anyone is curious they haven't

011changed in the last year um summarizing some of the rules we have four articles on the ballot I will recognize a member of the school board um to present each of the Articles the initial speakers may be Schoolboard members they may be members of the budget advisory committee or some of our administrators um I'm requesting that initial presentations be limited to about 10 minutes if possible it's a school night and after the initial presentations I'll open up the floor for questions or comments from other people I request that speakers who come to speak at the microphone limit their comments to 3 minutes um if you're on the stage and you wish to speak to a particular article please raise your hand so that I can see you because it's a little difficult for me to

012see everybody so let me know if you wish to speak and you can speak from the microphone at your place um if you're a member of the audience please line up sort of coming down that way to the microphone um and state your name and the town in which you live and please hold up your voter card when you come to the mic so that I know that you have checked yourself in it's important that people who want to speak to any of the Articles speak only at the mic um this uh deliberative session is being recorded and it will be cable cast out to all of our towns in the the six communities for them to be able to watch on the local Access TV channel um probably more than once so that we

013want to make sure we capture everyone's comments which is only possible if they're speaking at the mic typically I will recognize speakers who haven't spoken yet before I have um folks who've already spoken on a particular article speak again just to give everyone a chance if someone has an amendment that they'd like to propose to a warrant article that needs to be in writing and it needs to come up here to the clerk and to me so that we can make sure we have the wording exactly right um for someone to make a motion to amend an article we will need um someone to propose it and also a second before we can take it up and we will ask for the names of the person proposing um the amendment and also for the name

014of the person who is seconding that once we have that we will open up for discussion the person who makes the amendment can do a a brief presentation 3 minutes or less if possible um and let's see if we have a motion to call the question which means that would cut off debate on a particular article or an amendment to an article um that like any other motion requires a motion plus a second if it's been seconded then we will vote on the cutting off further debate I will not entertain a motion to call the question if there are people lined up who haven't spoken yet because I want to make sure that everybody who wants to has had a chance to speak on something um a motion to call the question requires a 2third

015majority and once that passes there'll be no more debate and we'll just vote on that Amendment so I'd like to introduce the people on the stage I'm not sure I'm going to have everybody's name correct we have our clerk here Susan bendroth you met Miss Mr Hall um Melissa liance was one of our school board members um down there is that correct yes and Mr gothier and Don bollins um Aaron D Garcia parez there we go um and then we have Amy Ransom and beyond that we have our believe is that our special ed director yes could you Renee Bennett yes oh thank you she's our um assistant superintendent for students Support Services um and we have our superintendent Esther asbell our attorney Barbara lman um and we have an assistant uh director for the

016finance and budget is that right um and Michelle lson and we have Molly O'Keefe who's our Director of Finance and operations um so some of these folks including superintendent asbel um Director of Finance O'Keefe attorney Barbara lman assistant superintendent Bennett are not not in the district all in favor of allowing them to speak if this is helpful kindly sorry O'Keefe is in the district oh I'm sorry Molly yeah sorry about that scratch Molly from that list um all folks who are in favor of that please raise your cards and say I all oppose raise your cards and say [Music] nay I don't see a card but I heard a t one voice did ra card okay good the eyes have it so those folks will be able to speak thank you all right after we

017are done this evening with discussing and possibly amending the article the voting day is Tuesday March 11th and you'll be voting in your individual Towns at your typical polling places um and encourage everybody to turn out to vote um for the first article um we they're printed in the handout and I'm going to read them as we go along they're not going to be printed on the slides overhead the first one is the operating budget shall the district raise and appropriate as an operating budget not including Appropriations by special warrant articles and other Appropriations voted separately the amounts set forth on the budget posted with the warrant or as amended by vote of the first session for the purposes set forth therein totaling 71,2 66,1 195 should this article be defeated the default budget shall

018be 7,768 618 which is the same as last year with certain adjustments required by previous action of the district or by law or the governing body May hold one meeting in accordance with RSA 40 colon 13 Roman 10 and Roman 16 to take up the issue of a revised operating budget only the exitor region Cooperative school board and budget advisory committee recommend 71 m266 1195 as set forth on said budget a majority vote is required um Mr gothier would you like to introduce this yes I would thank you uh so I would like to talk to the operating budget for a moment one of the jobs of the school board is to put forth a budget that is gives gives us the opportunity make sure that every kid has an opportunity to learn at their

019best meaning the facilities the teachers the people the administrators while also being able to be friends and talk to our families and walk around our neighborhoods and be respect ful of taxpayers and we come to that conclusion through a long process and that process starts in the spring of looking back at the past Year's budget and saying where can we be better what can we do that would be best for everyone and we scrutinize the budget and then we move into the fall where the planning really starts really starts in the Summer with the building administrators getting together with their staff and saying what what are our goals for this year how we going to accomplish those goals how does that fit into the budget and they put their budgets together and they bring those

020budgets and certainly give them to Molly so Molly has to take those and put them into the computer system which is tedious and and complicated but uh we worked through that and then we asked the budget advisory committee to meet every they meet every Thursday night with the building admin ministrators where the billing administrators go over their budget and they go through line by line asking questions ensuring that everything is understood it's reasonable and is accounted for and that's done over about six meetings sometimes it's a seventh meeting and once that's done they report back to us the board we review the budget we ask them questions and once we feel comfortable the budget we approve it and we bring it to the public so a couple weeks ago we brought this to the public

021and asked people to come forth ask questions and this is where we are come tonight with a budget that is thoughtful that supports our kids that also is respectful to the taxpayers so I would think that this is going to be a really good budget that's going to uh do well and and and I what I want to say is that Molly has put together this video that'll represent the budget so you get an inside look to everything and how it affects our students and our staff so I'm going to turn it over to Molly to play a video sure and before I start the video um in the back there are packets and so there are some of the slides that you'll see in the video if you'd like to follow along as well

022as in the packet is the line by line budget um and what's called the ms26 which is the Department of Revenue summary of the budget as well well as details on the default behind that so in your packet you can follow along as we go through the video hi welcome to this year's budget season as you know the exor region coptor school district is combined of all six towns and covers the schools of the Cooperative Middle School exer High School SEO School of Technology and our adult ed program in this video you'll see the major drivers and changes in our upcoming budget for this season and hopefully we can answer questions that you may have around increases and decreases as we work through this process we always try to create a budget that is fiscally

023responsible and meets the needs of all of our students my name is Kim sh and between my husband and me we have five children who've gone through the siu6 school system we have required special education services for two of our kiddos and cannot say enough about the assistance that's provided um from OT speech executive functioning skills and the services for uh emotional needs they have been wonderfully supportive uh particularly in the co-op and in the high school my oldest um child that's required Services is a junior this year and has uh expectations of going to a 4-year school not sure that would have been possible without these services so um we highly recommend that the budget supports this for other kiddos that have these types of [Music] requirements another amazing opportunity CMS provides is student

024counsil uh it gives a good leadership opportunity to students and we coordinate Spirit weeks that brings our School Community [Music] together hello my name is Hana Cass and I'm part of the student DJ committee at xer high school um I'm just here to talk about uh the recent event we did at Riverwoods so we got to go to Riverwoods and we discussed dialogue and discussion and debate um and how to have really um engaging dialogue with people especially in a time like now um I think our group really enjoyed having that multi-generational conversation and I think the group there as well had a really great time just talking with us and sharing experiences and what we think needs to be done in the [Music] world one opportunity that CMS offers is being able to audition

025for a musical and a play not a lot of other middle schools do this so it's an amazing opportunity for [Music] students hello my name is Marley Beltre I'm a senior at exer High School and in year 2 of animal plant Sciences at the SEO School Technology SST has benefited Me by challenging me with new opportunities creating a strong community and making me excited to learn every day the exitor region Cooperative School District budget contains three sections fed funds which are the adult education grants Food Service which is our meal service program in the operating budget which covers the expenses of the four schools Dr asbell prev ly noted the FED funds and Food Service are self-sustaining programs the part of the budget that impacts taxes is the operating budget each year we strive to

026build a fiscally responsible budget to show this we will take a look at how we finished last year the remaining unspent appropriation for the 2324 school year was only $976,000 fund which is 1.44% of the general fund's budget we use the same fiscally responsible approach when building the FY 26 budget for the 2526 school year the FY 26 proposed Cooperative budget is a needs-based budget that was created by building level and central office administration it was reviewed in sections with the budget advisory committee and the BAC voted unanimously to recommend the proposed budget as presented we also reviewed the budget in a budget workshop with the school board on December 3rd most of the Cooperative budget is contractual or mandatory obligations including salary and the associated FICA New Hampshire retirement professional development and health benefits

027as outlined in the collective bargaining agreements required special education services student transportation the SAU assessment which includes payroll for all staff accounts payable for all expenses of the Schools human resources for all staff and the superintendent of schools facilities and maintenance cost to support the operations of the schools the middle school bond Great Bay Charter School support and everything else is 5% % of the budget my colleagues will walk through the major changes from the prior fiscal year in the exiter region Cooperative School District we have three employee associations the exter Education Association which serves certified staff such as teachers school counselors and others requiring lure the exiter region Cooperative par professional association which serves par professionals and the exter area administrators Association all all pair of professionals and administrators salaries are being increased per

028their collective bargaining agreement this was a negotiating year for the extra Education Association so that increase will be reflected in a separate warrant article all non-affiliated staff were placed into the budget at a 3% increase we also took a look at Staffing levels and made adjustments as necessary based on enrollment and where contracted services are used annually we received the health and dental increases from our insurance providers this year the increase in health insurance rates varied per plan and the Plans offered changed due to the elimination of the point of service or POS plans from Health Trust the district's HMO plan includes a 5.2% increase the new po plan is more costeffective than the current POS plan that is being eliminated the district's dental plan includes a 5% increase regarding FICA and nhrs retirement both

029are a function of salary therefore when our salary budget goes up or down so does FICA and retirement Additionally the required nhrs employer contribution rates have decreased for those that fall under the teacher category rates are going from 19.64% to 19.23% for other employes EMP es the rates went down from 13.53% to 12.75% the needs of students in SAU 16 have evolved significantly since 2016 the percentage of students with IEPs in the middle and high schools has increased from 12% to over 20% and this trend is projected to continue into the 202 2 5 2026 school year the CDC reports that 40% of adolescents experienced persistent feelings of sadness or hopelessness in 2023 and 20% seriously considered suicide additionally one in six children aged 2 to8 have a behavioral mental or developmental disorder as the

030complexity of student needs grows there has been a corresponding rise in the demand for contracted Services outof District placements and specialized Transportation further straining School budgets to comply with IEP requirements the school district has had to contract several services including paraprofessional support due to Staffing shortages these Services may include a variety of supports necessary for students to make meaningful progress in response to the shortage of par professionals and to provide comprehensive support across all tiers the district has reallocated resources to hire additional interventionists at the middle and high school levels this adjustment has helped lower the cost of contracted services for the 2025 2026 school year the district is responsible for ensuring that students receive the special education services outlined in their IEPs even when they attend Charter Schools Charter Schools typically contract their own

031Specialists and the district often collaborates with these schools to use their resources minimizing the need for costly transportation to district schools while the district strives to provide the necessary supports within its schools some students continue to struggle despite extensive interventions out of District placements are considered only after significant time resources and interventions have been exhausted the number of outof District placements has risen due to the increasing complexity of student needs additionally inflation has driven up the cost of tuition for these placements under idea school districts must ensure that students with disabilities have access to a free and appropriate public education which sometimes necessitates placing students in specialized outof District programs when they cannot make meaningful progress in the general education environment we are seeing Rising costs for supplies and equipment due to inflation electric and

032natural gas rates are locked in until November 2026 and projections are based on prior year actuals part of the salary decrease in the lines above is resulting in a higher contracted service for custodial staff we continue to try to hire custodial staff when possible the increase in professional development is based on contractual obligations to enhance the learning of our staff a renegotiation of the first student contract and a change in homeless student need has increased transportation the co-op board has a memorandum of agreement with Great Bay Charter School to support students and we are seeing a change in the number of students that attend we have a fixed Bond schedule for the middle school and each year the payment is a little bit [Music] less all other changes are $344,450 or 1.26% of the budget

033change when the voters go to the ballot Bo boxes they will have a choice between the proposed budget we have just presented and the default budget the default is the prior year budget plus or minus any contractual or mandatory obligations required by law or onetime expenditures in the prior year budget the exitor region Cooperative budget is divided up on enrollment the tax rate for each town in SAU 16 has two lines one for the local elementary school and the other for the town's portion of the Cooperative budget this chart shows the breakdown of the Cooperative budget and the tax impact per Town hi everyone my name is Carly Sher and I am your student representative on the Cooperative board today I will focus on how the SAU 16 has impacted me at exitor high school

034the blend of academic and social programming has played a huge role in shaping who I am today in the classroom I've been challenged with difficult coursework and supportive teachers who push me to reach my goals whether I'm in an AP class or a unique elective the opportunities here have allowed me to explore my interests while preparing for the next steps in life beyond the academics the social aspect is just as important being involved in sports clubs and Leadership roles has taught me to take responsibility and build strong connections with my peers programs like stud student Senate helped me strengthen my skills in communication and understanding New Perspectives while working with my friends together these experiences have given me the tools and confidence I need to be successful inside and outside the classroom on the court

035or on the field I'll always be grateful for the community that has supported me since kindergarten and that concludes the video thank you very much are there any questions seeing none this will appear on the ballot without changes is there is it possible to amend is is the questions of course now okay yeah actually could you come down I'm sorry we we meant to use Just One mic tonight thank you oh this way huh yes good evening my name is Ted Lloyd I'm from from East Kingston and you've got your voter card there you go yay thank you um I just want to make a couple quick comments about the budget uh it's a little misleading showing us the 3.99% because there is a a uh another warrant article that's going to increase teacher salaries

036and both of those are recommended by the board and if you add those together it's actually a 5.3% increase I would point out to the board and to the audience the voters that the my little town of East Kingston the town itself was able to come up with a budget increase of 0.38% the East Kingston School District the local elementary school was able to come up with a budget that increased only by 0.9% 5.3% is excessive and taxpayers around the uh Kingston uh excuse me the exitor area cannot afford that so I would like to ask Liz to uh present her so I get to recognize the next speaker thank you are you done Mr Lloyd I'm going to be second in the the amendment okay thank you Liz FIA from brunwood Y and I

037would like to point out that of all the towns um together the registered voters in all the towns except for Ed exitor are 14784 and exor has 13,091 of those so we can almost never have an impact especially the four smaller towns um and I'm the large in thege largest of the small small towns and our everything together is $14 million so to get 71 million for just the middle in the high school is kind of absurd I would like to amend article one of the operating budget to 69 million and is there a second Ted Lloyd from E Kingston I second the motion [Applause] so so I gather that this would change the text of the warrant article to substitute the 69 million number for the 71,2 66,1 195 number is that correct okay

038so the default budget would then be higher which is 7,768 600 okay okay so now we are discussing this amendment um is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this amendment yes my name is Brian gret from exiter um I was unable to find the line item Budget on the website but I see you have it here today so it's only able to scan it briefly I do have in regards to these reductions I do have some questions um I found four different light items that have a $1 attributed um this is usually done to facilitate for a transfer of funds from other line items which is permissible by Statute based upon category um but that leads me to believe since they're at least four I had to go very quickly that there was

039an intent rather than zering out that line that there was an intent to transfer monies in and I would like to whoever budget committee Whoever has uh reviewed this how much money is is estimated Surplus in the budget you've given that will be allowed to be transferred to just these four or any others so we are on the topic of the amendment right and as justification for reducing the amount I'd like to have those questions answered before voting on that so you're asking for amounts that are considered excess in the budget well you have four line items yes so where is this money anticipated to come from that's my first question so why don't we do one question at a time okay um is there anyone that would like to address that question um yes

040M oef um there is no plan to move money around in this budget some lines might be at a dollar for example Co when we need to to get FEMA reimbursement Michelle and I had to scrub every single line of this budget to get the Cooperative as much as we could if we were to have have another Global pandemic we want to charge it to one line it will save us an extreme amount of time that's just an example I do believe all the covid lines have been zeroed out since we're kind of past Co but the past few years yes we kept a dollar in the co line so we could do such things we do not plan to move any money around in the budget this budget was built on a needs basis

041some lines might be at a dollar just in case we needed to move something from say a salary to a contract Service something along those lines but there is no plan to move it okay okay aware of what the I'm sorry um I'm sorry there's a lot going on so you're asking several questions um that one was answered this gentleman has the mic what is the point of order I agree but I'm letting us play this out a little bit because I try to be a generous moderator but thank you for that observation um so Mr grette your second question uh in regards to there was a figure that was just given approximately $976,000 was the UN the you see uh it was the unexpended appropriation from fiscal year 24 meaning in the general fund

042that is the amount of budgeted money that was unspent and how much is there in the reserve that is statutorily required that you have there is none there is no statutory required Reserve every year we build a needs-based budget buget and we budget for what we believe we need we do not pad the budget or have any extra fluff in the budget okay and can I my final question is in regards to Staffing and student population um has that gone up down I noticed in one of the explanations from the budget committee it said that their review is based on current Staffing levels which would include those uh that are presently at active and you're is that being projected and are there any projections reduction in either uh student count and Staffing is there okay

043Miss asell yes thank you thank you for the question our um enrollment has increased from last year to this current year with about 30 students we don't anticipate that will change drastically either way up or down the following year there's always fluctuation between 10 and 30 um our middle school has actually had uh 50 more students in their grade 8 and um so that's beginning to level off in regards to Staffing in this current budget based on enrollment last year we um cut five positions or did not replace five positions at exor high school and two positions at the middle school in this proposed budget we've reduced two more at the quad of Middle School positions and one more at exter high school as well as one more um that serves both schools so over

044over the past two budget Cycles this current one and the proposed we've reduced by 11 positions and okay I think that's pretty much it well so so I don't we don't do a lot of followup back and forth so thank you next speaker thank you good evening I'm Helen Joyce from exitor I have my card here thank you we seem to go through this every year at the deliberative session where a motion is made on the budget to reduce the budget by multiple millions of dollars based upon unexpended funds that had been returned to the voters the previous year hence the assumption that there's no need for the budget to be that high in early January I contacted Molly O'Keefe and I had a question with regard to this year's budget because there was a

045proposal made last year I'm not sure if it was one or2 million to cut the budget and I asked her what the situation was for our budget for this year's Budget on as of January 9th the budget was unfortunately $677,000 over budget for special education because of unanticipated students moving into the district another 20 215,000 for transportation for those students so without halfway through the year the Year hadn't even been halfway through the budget was in jeopardy with $892,000 in aers based upon those issues my fear is that if this amendment were to pass you would be dealing with the same situation next year New Hampshire has the lowest amount of State funding per student in the country the average per pupil expenditure for most States national average I should say is roughly $10,200 New

046Hampshire projects to be giving $3,700 per student and I anticipate based on what's going on in conquer that that number may go down for next year in addition any cuts that may be made at the federal level and we all know that's going on right now we could be dealing with a crisis situation if we do not get those funds for the coming school year I would urge everyone to please vote this down this could be seriously detrimental to all district okay jimber Brentwood uh the amendment was for $69 million MH um according to what I've seen so far from um SEO 16's website student population snapshot October a year and a half ago was 2298 this past October it was 2294 now if you take the $69 million and you divide it into say

047an even number 2,300 kids it comes out to $30,000 per student we are being overtaxed at the local level our local schools out of control our local towns out of control and the SAU 16 has averaged over a 3 and a half% increase every year for the past 20 years every 20 years your budget doubles and at some point the taxpayers will not be able to afford this we're asking for a reasonable increase over last year amounting to $330,000 per student I urge everyone here to vote for this amendment thank you good evening Amy FIA from exitor um as a former uh member of the budget advisory committee I have um all of the faith in the world that this budget has been uh well examined and that there has been ample opportunity to ask

048lots of questions and uh to really dive deep into this budget um and every year we end up at the deliberative session and we have an irresponsible amendment to cut an arbitrary dollar amount from the budget that does not take into account what actually would be cut with that dollar amount um so I urge the voters to vote against this amendment because it's not based in any fact or analysis it's an arbitrary number that would cut a very very small portion of as we saw in the pie chart there's really not a lot of wiggle room at all we're talking about less than 5% of even what is there is even able to be fluctuated as we understand it student need is changing we see that that's going to continue to change in New Hampshire

049our responsibility is for funding a very large portion of public educ ation that is how things are set up here that is the way things go here that hasn't changed and that's not going to change unless the folks in conquered make a change the folks in this room tonight are not going to change the structure of how public education is funded in the state of New Hampshire thank you thank you uh Rebecca Dunham Brentwood I just have a question walking in on the meeting I think what I heard is that a number of positions were eliminated um in various areas I don't remember the number but would you please tell me which positions were eliminated were they teachers or administrative staff who would be able to answer that question superintendent thank you it was a

050variety of positions uh certified staff and uncertified staff meaning support staff Etc there were no administrators that were cut in that number were teachers actual classroom teacher is eliminated correct though the population has increased you're putting more emphasis on administrative salaries than on teaching salaries we're adjusting to the needs in the building and working to provide our students with an education and with the support system that is required with a variety of situations that arise for our students staff and administrators thank you well I would have made other choices thank you Miss f yeah this for your brenwood um my Cut's not arbitrary although it's not in my purview to tell you where to cut um if it was me it would be in the administrative line some of the guidance lines but that's not

051I'm not allowed to recommend those things so I would have a question for you um I was looking at the transportation for example lines um they're on my copy it's 18 no it's 19 and 20 and I see that the transportation for regular two from I guess that's taking you to school and bringing you back is 8,4 78756 so I don't understand that um there's also transportation um late bus at CMS a shuttle job site Transportation sped transportation of 48,2 another sped transportation for 1,195 486 and 50 homeless Transportation one uh so excuse me Liz we're we're still on your amendments right so the two you know for or against the amendment yeah so I'm I'm just kind of confused by this massive Transportation line so maybe that that could be explained to me and

052maybe that's another place to cut I don't know I I was amazed that both the middle school and the and the high school is there someone who could respond to the questions about u m o'keef thank you so this is a exitor region Cooperative budget it is not necessarily a high school budget or versus a middle school budget and so when we have a cost that affects both schools we simply split it down the middle for budgetary purposes and the other lines for transportation now you will see things on there for 30 is high school 20 is Middle School you will see special education Transportation as that is a different type of Transportation as well as um homeless Transportation no I see that but why are there I guess one is the CMS and one

053is the high school so we pay a lot more in special ed Transportation than we do in regular Ed Transportation you want to speak just to Renee yes we do by the nature that it's designed specialized transportation is a smaller group of students could involve a bus monitor it could involve out of District placement the bus runs are higher it's specialized Transportation so it's not it's a small boss student specific okay and do we um so so this year in this budget that we have a greater needs we must have a lot greater needs for out of District which I thought we were trying to get away from we always work our hardest to keep all of our students in our local schools which means bringing in therapies specially design instruction everything however if an

054IP team determined that a student required an outof District placement in order to receive a fape the team has the authority to make that decision and the student is plac out a district it's an IP team decision so I realize that we're required to provide an adequate education but we're fre and appropriate appropriate free and appropriate okay but we're also required to Pro provide um the same to regular ed students and it seems like every single budget almost the regular Ed gets cut and the Special Ed gets increased I don't know if we're just not there's something in the formula that for Liz we really need to stick to your Amendment and talk about is 69 the right number or is the number that was proposed by the school board the right number and I'm

055going to really try to focus people on that one question because having broader questions about the budget is very legitimate but it's not about the amendment so we need I I do have legitimate things but it's not in my purview right I'm not allowed to say exact things so if you have things to talk about after we're finished on the amendment you can raise other questions okay 69 million is my Amendment and it's still an increase thank you PA Royal three pumpkin Circle exitor I try to come prepared with some knowledge about the school system and my town and the population and so on and so forth but I don't come with anything prepared like an amendment usually so my comments are on the Fly of what I've seen here tonight so far so far

056the uh budget advisory committee and the board has been insulted having their budget be called absurd it's also been called out of control I know a lot of these people they're not getting rich sitting up there I'll tell you that they're working because they care they care about our kids they may even care about the reputation of the schools I know my kids do that's how they get into good colleges I'm a lucky guy I say that every year my kids are healthy and smart and I appreciate that but what I also appreciate is that not all kids are like my kids and kids have special needs and they need to be met and that is not going to get better in the current climate and changes that are probably coming down the pike we

057always hear about enrollment sometimes enrollment is down sometimes enrollment is up but mandates change and we're responsible to give the kids what are mandated we can't control those outside forces so there are always increases we don't know what kind of populations are coming into town the voucher system and this is really not up for debate will probably increase the amount of kids that need special or have special needs within the schools private schools aren't taking those kids first choice we all know that and funding will be reduced you're looking at this budget of which I don't know the exact figure let's say I don't know 80 90% are basically fixed costs their buildings and grounds and bond issues and negotiated teacher salaries and legal commitments that we have made so when you cut the budget

058again and we did this last year but it's not and last year I said you know it was about the frosting the music the sports the stuff like that the important stuff that keeps kids also happy and wanting to go to school those needs need to be met this kind of budget cut will take away from that directly and it's going to get worse enrollment has a again has very little to do with the budget the kind of enrollment we're seeing as far as the cushion and I'm going to try to wrap this up Madam moderator we're talking about educating a family of kids whether you have them or not the kids are your family if if you have any kids in your family the grandkids whatever we're educating those people's peers it's all important

059they are all our kids it's the the the cushion is about 33 bucks per person that's cutting it pretty close and I got to tell you a lot of what happens here in this room has to revolve around trust I trust that the budget committee and the school board has done their level best over every single item on this budget there are probably a couple of mistakes in there but they got to be small after all this work so to come here tonight and call this budget absurd I'll let you pick the uh descriptive adjective that's about it thank you thank you hi Mike Whistler exitor I'd like to call the question to vote on the amendment so we've got some people who seem to be in line to speak so I want to make

060sure that those folks have an opportunity to speak to the amendment first yeah I'll be uh I'll be brief uh Cameron or from stratum so I was hoping that the B somebody from the budget committee could speak to the public comments that you got on this because I think it's important for everybody to understand like this is like one of the last steps of the process I'm not familiar I haven't been on that but I sat on the Strat Financial board and my concern is in that board there was a lastminute budget cut by you know folks that hadn't been involved with the weekly meetings so I'm just wondering if somebody from the budget committee could speak to like how many public comments you got during the many sessions I saw the schedule you had

061it looks like there's seven or eight sessions so if somebody could speak to that and um you know what kind of feedback folks provided prior to this meeting I appreciate it is is there someone who would be able to address that do I stay Rel I don't know if we have anyone from the budget do I see a a volunteer thank [Laughter] you um yes I'm sorry I lost my voice I can address that question the answer is and your name sorry I'm sorry Heidi Hansen from the budget advisory committee I was the chair this year thank you and I can report that we had no one attend any of our meetings um no members of the public attended the meetings that we held that were posted um during the fall when we discussed with

062each of the department heads their portion of the budget okay thank you I think I see another is there someone else just holding up the wall back there okay that's good all right so we have a a motion to call the question which would be cutting off debate on this is there a second and your name please wow did you get that [Laughter] clerk Nico and surname oh there we go Mr um chair of the select board thank you papa cenes excellent okay um so we need a 2third majority to um C cut off debate at this time all in favor of calling the question and cutting off debate raise your cards High ready all opposed raise your cards and say n I'm sorry so that requires in writing 10 people and it has to

063be before we vote and we've just voted so I need to get a request in writing signed by 10 people who are present um if there is a request for a paper ballot vote 10 voters excuse me well I'll have to defer to my legal counsel you're going to make me look it up I'll make you look it up all right so but in any case we had already voted on that calling the question had already occurred so it has to the request for paper ballot has to come before we vote um all right so with that warning we'll figure out the exact number um yes sir would you like to that was it okay is there anyone else who wishes to speak to this first article seeing none the article will appear um to

064vote can I make a motion oh we have to do a motion we have to vote on the amendment pardon me I'm jumping ahead we have to vote on the article yes we have to vote on the the amendment okay so all in favor of the amendment to change the budget number to 69 million um please raise your cards and say I I and all opposed raise your cards and say nay nay okay looks like the Nays have it is there anything further on this article one I see someone approaching the microphone oh thank you Moder Madam moderator Julie Gilman exitor I would like to close uh cons reconsideration of this article so there's a motion to restrict reconsideration of the article is there a second a second Mr Hall okay all in favor please

065raise your cards and say I I all opposed raise your cards and say nay the eyes have it this article will not be further reconsidered thank you thank you fine okay so the magic number is five for anyone who wonders thank you um I'm sorry I don't usually take questions from the floor what do we got that's correct so we don't vote on the article itself if there are no more comments and amendments it appears on the warrant without any changes we don't have to vote to make that happen so we are done with article one the next article is number two collective bargaining agreement teacher shall the school district vote to approve the cost items included in the collective bargaining agreement reached between the exitor region Cooperative school board and the exitor Educators Association

066which calls for the following increases in salaries and benefits at the current Staffing level fiscal year estimated increase for 2026 92300 $316 for 2027 1,1 186,187 5,511 and further to raise and appropriate $923,000 by the new agreement over those that would be paid at current Staffing levels the school board and budget advisory committee recommend 923,50 16 majority vote is required is there someone on the stage who would like to introduce this article all right I'll start with the introduction so myself and Don bollins uh were the representatives from the co-op board that negotiated this contract with the teachers uh this process started in August uh we met with the teachers uh a total of six different times in the evening um until we came to a conclusion um we had a lot of input uh

067from teachers Administration uh building principles um there are there is not much that changed within this teacher contract from prior years um with the exception of the the percentage increases um happy to speak to any questions that anyone has about the contract Liz FIA Brentwood that's exactly what I was going to ask what are the percentage increases so the percentage increases for fiscal year 2026 is 3.5% and the percent increase for 2027 is 3.25 and the increase for 2028 is also 3.25 thank you thank you are there any other questions on article two seeing none that will appear on the ballot without changes yes I'd like to make a motion to restrict reconsideration on article two okay that's Amy Ransom is there a second I'd like to second eron I'm sorry so this is to

068restrict reconsideration of the article so it can't be brought up again later in the evening correct yes okay all in favor of restricting reconsideration of this article raise your cards and say I I all opposed raise your cards and say nay okay the eyes have it this article will not be reconsidered this evening okay the next article is article three capital reserve fund shall the exitor region Cooperative School District vote to raise and appropriate the sum of $200,000 to be placed in the capital reserve fund previously established in 1998 for the purpose of construction reconstruction or acquisition of school buildings Andor school ground site improvements including Associated engineering and Architectural fees and further to name the school board as agents to expend the fund this sum to come from June 30 fund balance available for

069transfer on July 1 no additional amount to be raised from taxation the exitor region Cooperative School board recommends this appropriation majority vote required is there someone who would like to present this yes I would like to than so the capital reserve fund is a fund that we recommend continuing to put money toward and the purpose of this is to ensure that if something comes up you if we own homes we own if there's something that just happens that we have money to appropriate toward that so the the example we uh look to is the the actual roof of this building that we're sitting in right now uh is 5 Acres that's how large it is so if something comes up with the roof it is extremely large amount of money so if something happens let's

070say in November and we we're and then we find out what's happening then we find out a cost and we're looking for another year and a half till we can raise the money and put it in the budget to do something about that so this capital reserve gives us the right to actually make the choice and keep the buildings and tiptop shape rather than trying to continue to put it into a budget uh it makes sense we've been doing it for a while and what we we this makes exitor strong when we have a capital reserve because when something comes up we can as a community fix it on the spot and move on think about the boilers the roof any of those large expensers that uh that could come up so thank you very

071much are there any questions or comments or amendments on article three I'm sorry I so we I I can't if you wish to make a comment or question I need you to come to the microphone thank you Eric Trump Brentwood my question is you're asking to put $200,000 into a fund what I would like to know is how much money is currently into the fund is there someone who has that information yes Miss o'keef so the capital reserve fund has $629,900 and I'll answer the turf fund since that's coming up next $1,421 great thank you thanks very much any other questions or comments changes amendments okay seeing none this article will appear on the ballot without change which brings us to article for the capital reserve fund for Synthetic Turf replacement Kate Kate I'm sorry

072I'd like to make a motion to restrict reconsideration okay thank you um Aaron and seconded by Don thank you all in favor of restricting reconsideration I I all opposed raise your cards and say nay the eyes have it thank you this will not be reconsidered okay we're on to article four shall the coop region excuse me the exter region Cooper of school district vote to raise and appropriate the sum of $50,000 to be placed in the Synthetic Turf replacement capital reserve fund previously established under the provisions of RSA 35 colon 1 for replacement of the Synthetic Turf Field located at exitor high school this sum to come from June 30 fund balance available for transfer on July 1 no amount to be raised from taxation the exitor region Cooperative School Board recommends this appropriation majority

073vote required is there a board member who can address this Mr Hall yes uh good evening um I think we can all agree that exor High School in sau6 probably has the best sports facilities in the state of New Hampshire and with that comes the cost of those fields but tonight we're focusing on the turf the turf field we replaced 3 years ago the cost for that was just under $500,000 so the the life expectancy if it's a great run somewhere between 15 and 20 years so planning ahead every year we set aside $50,000 so there isn't sticker shock when we get to that year we have to do it so right now we have of the I think Molly just said over $100,000 in the account and we're asking to put another $50,000 planning

074for the future thank you thank you are there any questions or amendments yes Tony Burke exitor I am not going to vote against this I voted for it last year I just would like a reminder the roof wears out just about everything wears out aside from the fact that you don't want people to say no at the last minute what's the rationale for this one wear item uh being carved out every year okay so why is it a special fund okay uh superintendent thank you sure uh the rationale actually for both of those the capital reserve and for the athletic uh Turf is to avoid a large increase in one year on the taxpayer so in other words we're trying to do that rainy day fund if you will for the roof we know that

075that roof is only going to last so long and we don't want that cost to come as as a have to be bonded etc etc so trying to save at a pace that will keep things up to shape when they um need to be replaced so that's really the purpose of it is to try and keep that tax rate as stable as possible I think the question is why do we have a special one for the turf and not yeah yeah I understand that concept I know we're going to spend the money and I like evening it out I just don't I just never understood why this one light item isn't in that same area is it not allowed to be for some reason no M it could be in there however this was before

076I was employed at se6 but it was created but when you create a trust fund it has to be used for that purpose so that by having the separate trust fund here the board or whoever is the agents to expend cannot expend it except for that purpose so it protects it un unappropriate spending okay I guess is that okay all right good thank you yes hi lean flart exter um my question about this sort of turf is when it's replaced and I think we're all kind of much more attuned to where does this stuff go and how does it get recycled and what is our responsibility as human beings when we talk about this is the best field we ever saw in our lives unfortunately the replaced field gets hauled off in a truck where

077does it go what happens to it and what are we doing responsibly um for those plastic particles I don't know if there's anyone on the stage who has that information but oh are we pointing up into the rafters be expecting some help from manager a Celestial assistant over there I don't know if Mr lisst has any information on this thank you do you mind coming down that's what happens when you sit in the back of the class every now and then you get called on all that great yeah exactly good evening um when we replaced it uh three years ago they did the the company we used was field Turf and they took the existing uh material away I can't say for sure exactly where it went I can find that out for you but

078we will um certainly believed it was disposed of and handled properly just like we do with other hazardous materials it wasn't like we took it to the extra landfill or anything they they hauled it away if that helps thank you just another comment is that all right yes um if we're looking at something that may not need to be replaced for 10 or 15 years um I think it behooves us to get some more information about just similar to the styrofoam issue that you know sounds like a great idea um maybe we could be proactive um and if it turns out that that money is accumulating and we decide that that's not the way we want to go um I'd leave it to people who are more clever with budgets than I to to figure

079out how to do that but um the importance of a a safe field as well as a good field is uh something we'd like to continue so and one of the things that I noticed is that it's a Synthetic Turf replacement fund so it doesn't particularly dictate a particular material that has to be used and I think that's a great idea to yeah um figure out a way to have something that's maybe a little more sustainable we're going to need a really big recycling bin when the time comes okay thanks thank you any other question questions or comments on this one I see someone approaching the mic okay this is the last one we're not going to have time for anything else once we're done this just who came pardon me this is just the

080count of who came from the towns oh okay so um if if you wish to make that comment now go right ahead okay so I would like to thank she's been taking attendance every year for many many years so out of the 2011 people who came tonight I would like to thank you there are only about 28,000 that could have been here um even though I disagree with a lot of you I'm glad that there were 94 from exiter 24 from I don't know where I put my my uh 24 from stratom 13 from newfields 17 from Kensington six from East Kon and 47 for brenwood so thank you for coming yes I second that anything further on Article 4 seeing nothing this article will appear on the ballot without any changes and hello Miss

081bollin make a motion to restrict reconsideration that's restrict reconsideration seconded by m Lions thank you all in favor raise your cards and say I all opposed raise your cards and say nay the eyes have it I I am grateful for everyone who showed up Liz has already thanked you so much thank you to Mr liser for keeping the building so beautiful thank you to Mr Monahan for letting us use it is there a motion to dissolve the meeting motion to dissolve a motion to adjourn the meeting to dissolve it we'll be done Mr gothier yes seconded by Miss Ransom all in favor say I thank you please return your cards to those nice supervisors thank you everybody you do e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.